October 21, 2026
TO: City of San Dimas
ATTENTION: Brad McKinney
RE: Claim
Claimant
Member
Date Rec' d by Mbr
Date of Event
CW File Number
a
ATHENS
People, Powered.
Bulnes vs. San Dimas
Alison Bulnes
City of San Dimas
10/ 13/ 26
9/ 10/ 26
CJP- 3057713 LMV
Please allow this correspondence to acknowledge receipt of the captioned claim. Please take the following action:
CLAIM REJECTION: Send a standard rejection letter to the claimant.
Please include a Proof of Mailing with your rejection notice to the claimant. An exemplar copy of a Proof of Mailing is attached. Please provide us with a copy ofthe Notice ofRejection and copy ofthe Proof of Mailing. If you have any questions feel free to contact the assigned adjuster or the undersigned claims specialist.
Very Truly Yours,
ATHENS PROGRAM INS. SERVS.
Ti,4 M. Va -O-w
Timothy M. Varon
Claims Supervisor II
P. O. Box 4005 9 Concord, CA 94524 9 866. 482. 3535 9 athensadmin. com Claim Form
Submitted by: Alison Bulnes Alison Bulnes
Submitted On: 2026- 10- 09 16: 34: 09
Submission IP: 47. 150. 140. 123 ( 172. 31. 25. 155)
proxy- IP ( raw- IP)
Status: Open
Priority: Normal
Attachments
Assigned To: Debra Black
Due Date: Open
IMG 1371 ..peg= 2026- 10- 09 04:34: 13 pm
IMG 1170. pag- 2026- 10- 09 04: 34: 12 pm
IMG 1369. pag- 2026- 10- 09 04: 34: 13 pm
IMG 1368. png= 2026- 10- 09 04: 34: 13 pm
Sewer camera for 713 N. Hatfield ave. mp44 - 2026- 10- 09 04: 34: 12 pm IMG 1367. png= 2026- 10- 09 04:34: 13 pm
Print Del
RECEIVED
October 13, 2026
CITY OF SAN DIMAS
CITY CLERK
CLAIM AGAINST THE CITY OF SAN DIMAS
For damages to Persons or Personal Property) rfl
A claim must be filed with the City Clerk of the City of San Dimas within six ( 6) months after which the incident or event occurred. Be sure your claim is against the City of San Dimas, not another public entity. Where space is insufficient, please use additional paper and identify information by paragraph number. Completed claims must be mailed or delivered to the City Clerk, the City of San Dimas, 245 E. Bonita Avenue, San Dimas, CA 91773- 3002
TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR & CITY COUNCIL, THE CITY OF SAN DIMAS, CALIFORNIA The undersigned respectfully submits the following claim and information relative to damage to persona and/ or personal property:
Name of Claimant
Alison Bulnes
a. Address of Claimant
b. Telephone Number
Format: MM/ DD/ YYYY
d. Social Security No e. Driver' s License
2. Name, telephone and post office address to which claimant desires notices to be sent If other than above:
3. Occurrence or event from which the claim arises:
Two City -owned magnolia trees on my sidewalks have caused significant damage to my houses plumbing system and main lines causing flooding and backups in my house for years now. Now I have to remove and replace all my pipes from my backyard going all the way to the street' s main lines because the roots have broken the pipes. Now I have to pay for digging, construction and possibly removal of my driveway and sidewalks to be replaced.
a. Date * b. Time
09/ 10/ 2026 10 am
Format: MM/ DD/ YYYY
c. Place ( exact & specific location)
My entire main line plumbing system, front yard, driveway, and sidewalks. d. How and under what circumstances did damage or injury occur? Specify the particular occurrence, event, act or omission you claim caused the injury or damage ( Use additional paper if necessary) The city failed to approve my request for tree removals back in 2022 when I said this was going to happen and already starting doing damage to my property and the sidewalks. I attached screenshots of the emails. e. What particular action by the City, or its employees, caused the alleged damage or injury? San Dimas failed to remove the magnolia trees in my front yard when I requested this back in 2022 when I was told this was going to my happen with my home' s inspection and multiple plumbers.
4. Give a description of the injury, property damage or loss, so far as is known at the time of this claim. If there were no injuries, state no injuries".
No injuries
5. Give the name( s) of the City employee( s) causing the damage or injury:
San Dimas
6. Name and address of any other person injured:
N/ a
7. Name and address of the owner of any damaged property:
Albert Garcia
8. Damages claims:
a. Amount claimed as of this date:
0 b. Estimated amount of future costs:
7, 325
c. Total amount claimed:
0 d. Basis for computation of amounts claimed ( attach copies of all bills, invoices, estimates, etc.) Choose File No file chosen Choose File No file chosen Choose File No file chosen Choose File No file chosen Choose File No file chosen
9. Names and addresses of all witnesses, hospitals, doctors, etc.
10. Any additional information that might be helpful in considering this claim:
Choose File No file chosen
My neighbors across the street from me had the same issue as me when the city of San Dimas kept rejecting their requests to remove these trees. They then had to pay to tear out their whole front yard and plumbing to replace it with all new driveway, plumbing, and front yard landscaping. I have attached a video I paid plumber to where you can see all the spots where the roots have protruded through the main line that need to be replaced. Also, I attached screenshots from 2022 where no one ever got back to me on my request for tree removals since it had already started doing damage to my property and sidewalks.
WARNING: IT IS A CRIMINAL OFFENSE TO FILE A FALSE CLAIM! ( Penal Code 72; Insurance Code § 556. 1)
I have read the matters and statements made in the above claim and I know the same to be true of my own knowledge, except as to those matters stated upon information or belief as to such matters I believe the same to be true. I certify under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is TRUE AND CORRECT.
Date
10/ 09/ 2026
Format: MM/ DD/ YYYY
Claimant' s signature
Alison Bulnes
cz
m
m
K
m
Iv
m
a,
O
O
O
CD
p
O
N
CD
CD
CZ3m
mz
9 m
z
7 ca '
Z
c5
m0
IS
c
z
m
m
D
N
QA
mN
CD
S
m
n
c@
8IE
Sfn6
m1
z
mp 0
U)
N
v
O
O
g
a
o
O w
mycaz
c
0 ng
Q
m
g
o
a
Sc
n^
M
9 c03
o
GfNWN
A
m
3 v
A
s
M
o
f•
on
0 d"
T'
o
m
3 D
o
m
3 rn
b
cod
o
D
i
c
74 m
g
s
s
z
o
O
v
o
m
o3
A
C>
C:
o
cn
8 m
D
m
0 c
ZD
S
Q
O
O
CD
m0
D =-
Zip
O
0-
4Or0(
A
n
m_
2 2
n
ag'
i
A
N
O
m
cm
zN
CDCD
o
S
A
3 m
z
d '
s
a
C
c
O
n
S.
g
m
a
Q
i-.
Z
i
Tait
fp
Cl
v
o
v
s '
o
m
O
O S
cr
e->
D
o
o
m
j
m
CD
m
m
m`
a
cm
m
S
S
CD
r
m
x
mamdm
IDa
mQnm`
mcmo3m
SD, -
O
O
a
m
O
D
CD
O
y
m
m m~
c 3
o'
c
m
nomo1Odndz o
aD
m
i
c°
7i
9@
o
m
C.:
i
S
N
o
m
m"
lu
a
x
m
S.
O
r
G
9 0
3 Z1
2 3°
y2m
mm0
C'
f
tD
x' •
c
7 .-:
y
fD
7 tD
J
O
D)
mDW
CL
CD
Dal
a
0 cD
CD
co
Er
D
H'
N
C
F
1. z
Q
v
m
2o3
dm
0 m
1dog
oamZiGa O
CD
z
gsmn
d
i
a
c
e
m
o
1 0 wwmmuo>
too"
n
5 m
o
0. c .
t, (
2•
o
Ow
C
o=
x
c
a
i
CO
d.,.
l<
Om
z
Pl.
m
0 d
MO
5 ae
3you3
K
m {
g3
m
O •
t
m
P-m -
C
my
Z
0 v
D
D
n •
fl
S
Ci
N=
m,
t
O
N
C7
7 N
C
n
2m
S
n
o`
a,
g_;,
m
Z
c'+ ,
c'
i
v
c
cm
m
ZO
v
o.
c
A
03 ni
o
fD
3 m
rM
p
S
v °
a
x
m
r C-rtt
n 3
cD
nCm
c
D,
o
D_
G3O
3 '
M>
Y
Z'
3 o
y
vmvC)
o
o
O
m
rrZ
N C)
O
m
p
n
y ,
Z7
4 O
fDn
i
cw
Tl =
S
m
O
A
tD
D
r^
3mv
a)
m
0 ? ^
m
Zo
k-ov
f
3 z
a?
y
o
i
co
0 c "
4 11: 40
Gmail
Sewer camer ... eld ave. mp4
al 5Gcu •
u •
12 8VM/
i "
Wo
00 i- ,\ » •
m
C7 r,
Li
Cl
drive. google. com • • •
ALBERTO' S PLUMBING
Sewer Camera Inspection & Recommended Repair Report
Inspection Date: September 14, 2026 Estimated Repair: $ 6, 900. 00 Property: Residential property Inspection: Two sewer cleanouts / two camera runs Reason for Inspection
Following drain - clearing service, a sewer video inspection was performed through the property' s two cleanouts to evaluate the condition of the building sewer and identify conditions that may contribute to future stoppages.
Camera Run No. 1 — Rear of House Toward Front
The interior portion of the sewer line includes older cast- iron piping with substantial internal scale and rough buildup visible along the pipe walls. This buildup reduces the smooth interior surface of the pipe and can catch paper, waste and debris, increasing the likelihood of recurring restrictions or stoppages.
Recommendation: Perform professional cast- iron descaling to mechanically remove accumulated scale and restore a smoother interior flow path where the existing pipe condition permits. Descaling is intended to improve flow and reduce snag points; it does not make an aged or structurally damaged pipe new.
Camera Run No. 2 — Front of House Toward City Sewer
The exterior sewer inspection shows significant tree -root intrusion at multiple locations. Root penetration indicates openings at joints, cracks or other defects through which roots can enter the sewer. Root cutting may temporarily restore flow, but roots can grow back as long as the defective pipe remains in service.
Recommendation: Replace the affected sewer section from the front of the residence toward the property line, estimated at approximately 15- 20 linear feet. The preferred method is trenchless replacement, subject to field conditions and verification that the existing alignment is suitable.
Why the Recommended Repair Is Beneficial
Replacing the root -intruded section addresses the source of the recurring root problem rather than repeatedly cutting roots from inside the pipe. When site conditions allow, trenchless replacement can reduce excavation and disturbance to the property compared with a conventional open trench. A new continuous sewer section also provides a smoother flow path and removes defective joints or openings in the replaced area that are allowing root intrusion.
Proposed Scope & Estimate
Item Proposed Work
1 Prepare and access the affected exterior sewer section. 2 Replace approximately 15- 20 linear feet of sewer line from the front of the house toward the property line using 3 If trenchless installation cannot be completed because of field conditions, perform the required replacement by c 4 Reconnect the replaced sewer section and verify operation after completion.
Estimated total for exterior sewer replacement: $ 6, 900. 00 The cast- iron descaling recommendation is identified separately in this report and is not stated as included in the $6,900 exterior sewer replacement estimate unless specifically added to the written proposal.
Important Notes
Camera findings are based on conditions visible during the inspection. Exact pipe depth, underground utilities, concealed fittings, connection configuration and other site conditions may require verification before work begins. The recommended replacement is intended for the visibly affected exterior section described above; conditions outside the inspected/ replaced area are not represented as corrected by this work.
Prepared by Alberto' s Plumbing
2: 18 t. II
FW:
N Inbox
II EI
Request Update
Connie Arellano Jun 7, 2022 O ...
to James, me
Hello Jim,
Resident Allyson Bulnes, attached to the email, called to follow up on her report she submitted regarding "=-- root issues.
PW recently fixed the sidewalk but informed the resident that = roots are heavily wrapped around the pipes. She is very concerned that the roots are going to cause a expensive damage to her pipes and she wants to avoid the costs.
Please per her request contact:
Allyson Bulnes
Thank you so much.
https:// sand i masca. gov_/
httpsJ/ www. facebook. com/ cityofsandimas/
https:// twitter. com/ cityofsandimas
to Aub. A- Cap Request list
kn On Reply all r- Forward
2: 18
Thank you so much.
t 1h
https: Hsand imasca. gov/
https:// www. facebook. com/ citvofsandimas/
httns:// twitter.com/ citvofsandi mas
From: Kathleen Boneman < kboneman@sandimasca. gov>
Sent: Tuesday, June 7, 202211: 21 AM
To: Connie Arellano < carellano@sandimasca. gov>
Subject: = Request Update
Allison Bulnes
1j".......... A
The'=-- is wrapped around plumbing and lifting concrete. It wants to be - . -. before further damage.
Kathleen Boneman
Recreation Specialist
City of San Dimas
909) 394- 6236
E-) On Reply all r- Forward