5 Hutton Centre Drive, Suite 300 • Santa Ana, CA 92707 • T: 714.751.7373
MEMORANDUM
April 17, 2025
To: From:
Luis Torrico
Director of Community Development
City of San Dimas
Bryan Hamilton
Jennifer Marks
Psomas
Subject: Substantial Evidence for Notice of Exemption for the Proposed Amendment to the City of San Dimas Chapter 18.162 Tree Ordinance, MCTA 23-05 The California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) was signed into law in 1970. The California Environmental Quality Act is a statue that requires state and local agencies to identify potential significant effects a “project” may have on the environment and any feasible mitigation that may be implemented to avoid or mitigate those impacts. A “project” is defined in Section 21065, Chapter 2.5, Division 13 of the California Public Resources Code as an activity which may cause either a direct physical change in the environment, or a reasonably foreseeable indirect physical change in the environment, and consists of any of the following: an activity directly undertaken by any public agency; an activity undertaken by a person which is supported, in whole or in part, through contracts, grants, subsidies, loans, or other forms of assistance from one or more public agencies; or, an activity that involves the issuance to a person of a lease, permit, license, certificate, or other entitlement for use by one or more public agencies. A “significant effect on the environment” is defined in Section 21068 Chapter 2.5, Division 13 of the California Public Resources Code as a substantial, or potentially substantial, adverse change in the environment. Furthermore, the government agency which has the principal responsibility for carrying out or approving a project which may have a significant effect upon the environment is defined as the “lead agency” in Section 21067, Chapter 2.5, Division 13 of the California Public Resources Code.
CEQA applies in situations where a governmental agency can use its judgment in deciding whether and how to carry out or approve a project. A project subject to such judgmental controls is called a “discretionary project.” Where the law requires a governmental agency to act on a project in a set way without allowing the agency to use its own judgment, the project is called “ministerial,” and CEQA does not apply. Once an application for a project is deemed complete, a lead agency must first determine whether an activity is subject to CEQA before conducting an initial study. An activity is not subject to CEQA if: the activity does not involve the exercise of discretionary powers by a public agency; the activity will not result in a direct or reasonably foreseeable indirect physical change in the environment; or the activity is not a project as defined in Section 15378.
Pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines, a Notice of Exemption (NOE) may be filed if the City of San Dimas, in its capacity as the Lead Agency, determines that a proposed action or project is exempt from CEQA. According to the CEQA Guidelines, a NOE must contain the following information:
• A description of the proposed action or project;
ATTACHMENT 3
Luis Torrico
April 17, 2025
Psomas
• A finding that the proposed action or project is exempt, including a citation of the State CEQA Guidelines section or statute under which the project is found to be exempt; and, • A brief statement in support of the finding.
• The Lead Agency authorized the preparation of this Notice of Exemption This report was prepared in accordance with Section 21000 (et seq) - Division 13 of the California Public Resources Code and Section 15000 (et seq), Article 1, Chapter 3, Division 6, Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations. It is important to note that CEQA is not a process that determines whether or not a project should be approved and no recommendations can be made as to whether or not a lead agency should approve or deny a project application.
SECTION 15061 – REVIEW FOR EXEMPTION
Section 15061(b)(3) – Common Sense Exemption
Section 15061(B)(3), the Common Sense Exemption, of the 2025 CEQA Guidelines applies to the proposed revision to the City of San Dimas’ Community Tree Ordinance Project (Project or proposed Project). Section 15061 outlines the process for determining whether or not a project would be exempt from CEQA. This process is detailed in Section 15061(B), provided below:
(b) A project is exempt from CEQA if:
(1) The project is exempt by statute (see, e.g. Article 18, commencing with Section 15260).
(2) The project is exempt pursuant to a categorical exemption (see Article 19, commencing with Section 15300) and the application of that categorical exemption is not barred by one of the exceptions set forth in Section 15300.2. (3) The activity is covered by the commonsense exemption that CEQA applies only to projects which have the potential for causing a significant effect on the environment. Where it can be seen with certainty that there is no possibility that the activity in question may have a significant effect on the environment, the activity is not subject to CEQA.
(4) The project will be rejected or disapproved by a public agency. (See Section 15270(b)).
(5) The project is exempt pursuant to the provisions of Article 12.5 of this Chapter.
According to Section 15061(B)(3), a project may be exempt if the project’s implementation would not result in a significant effect on the environment. The Project consists of text updates to the City’s Municipal Code that would allow owners of single-family properties to remove trees within their property unencumbered by the City’s Tree Removal Ordinance, under most conditions, as described below in the Project Description. Therefore, as the Project would result Luis Torrico
April 17, 2025
Psomas
in text amendments to the Municipal Code and would not actually include any tree removal, it can be seen with certainty that there is no potential for a significant effect on the environment, as the Project is programmatic in nature. These Municipal Code text updates would only apply to single-family properties, thereby limiting the number of trees that could be removed in the City.
PROJECT DESCRIPTION
Background
Trees within the City of San Dimas are regulated under Chapters 13.36 and 18.162 of the San Dimas Municipal Code (SDMC), respectively. Chapter 13.36 - Community Tree Management, regulates policy and enforcement related to City-owned trees located within any park, City right-of-way, median, parkway, planting easement, or any other City-owned property, and is administered by the Parks and Recreation Department. Meanwhile, Chapter 18.162, the Tree Preservation Ordinance, regulates policy and enforcement related to privately-owned trees located on privately-owned property, regardless of the established land use, and is administered by the Community Development Department.
The City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance was adopted in 1990 with the intent of preserving and protecting private mature significant trees in the City. The Tree Preservation Ordinance defines a mature significant tree as any private tree within the City of an Oak genus which measures eight inches or more in trunk diameter, and/or any other species of trees which measure 10 inches or more in trunk diameter, and/or a multi-trunk tree(s) having a total circumference of 38 inches or more (the multi-trunk tree shall include at least one trunk with a diameter of a minimum of four inches). The Ordinance exempts fruit trees and other similar species from protection; therefore, with the exception of these trees, any tree that meets the aforementioned criteria would be protected under the Ordinance.
The Ordinance requires a permit to remove protected trees. Requests to remove up to three trees may be approved by the Director of Community Development, while the removal of four or more trees requires approval by the Development Plan Review Board (DPRB). The application fee for a Tree Removal Permit for up to three trees is $300, while the fee for the review of four or more trees is $500. Approved tree removal applications are subject to a two-for-one replacement ratio with a minimum of fifteen-gallon box tree(s), or other replacement of equivalent value and size, within the subject property. A reduced replacement ratio may be approved if the reduced replacement ratio is consistent with the purpose of the Ordinance, removal of the protected tree will have a minimal impact on the community or if the subject site has an adequate number of existing trees.
On September 21, 2023, the Planning Commission considered a City-initiated request to amend the Tree Preservation Ordinance to remove the Development Plan Review Board’s review authority, create a protected tree list, reduce the replacement ratio for tree removal violations, remove replacement requirements for removal of trees that pose an immediate danger or removal of trees required by the Fire Department, remove the arborist report submittal requirement, revise findings, move the Tree Preservation Ordinance from Title 18 Zoning to Title 13 Civic Facilities to Luis Torrico
April 17, 2025
Psomas
change the implementation responsibilities of the Ordinance to the Parks and Recreation Department, and various associated code clean-up items. The Commission voted against moving the Ordinance from Title 18 to Title 13 and for creating a tree exemption list, and voted to initiate a Municipal Code Text Amendment to Chapter 18.162 as follows:
• Remove the Development Plan Review Board’s (DPRB) review authority and allow City Staff to review and approve all tree removals, regardless of the number of trees proposed for removal.
• Change replacement requirement to 1:1 if 24-inch box tree(s) is planted or 2:1 if 15- gallon tree(s) is planted.
• Create two levels of protection:
• Oak tree, and any other tree staff proposes, will need to make findings to remove.
• All other trees with a 10-inch diameter or greater can be removed without any findings as long as they replace them. In this situation, the Director of Community Development can reduce the replacement ratio if there is not enough space to replant trees.
• Do not require replacement trees for removal of trees that pose an immediate danger, and removal of trees required by the Fire Department.
• Explore relaxing the Ordinance for backyard trees.
• Do not require arborist report for dead, diseased or dying tree, unless applicant disagrees with Director's determination.
• Revise tree removal findings to make them clear and objective. • Change the point at which trunk diameter measurements are taken from 38-inches to 54-inches to be consistent with general arboricultural standards. • Revise the penalty section of the Ordinance.
On April 23, 2024, the City Council heard a discussion about fines related to community trees.
The Council also discussed processes, fees and fines related to private trees. After much discussion, the Council directed City staff to schedule a study session to discuss private trees and provided input for discussion. Some of the items that were mentioned during the discussion, included, but were not limited to:
• Explore reducing or removing the Tree Removal Permit Application fee for single-family property applications.
• Reconsider enforcement of Ordinance for single-family front yards only. • Create an exemption list for private trees (can be removed without permits/fees):
• Exempt tree species to consider: Eucalyptus, Tree of Heaven, Queen Palm, White Ash, etc.
Luis Torrico
April 17, 2025
Psomas
• If exemption list is created, consider creating protected list. • In situations where 4:1 replacement is required, it may not be an appropriate solution, as space and maintenance are a factor.
• The Tree Ordinance should be easy to follow and not burden residents. • Creation of a tree fund, funded by residents who remove trees but do not have room for required replacement, that would allow other residents to plant trees at no expense to them.
During the November 12, 2024, City Council study session, City staff was directed to revise the Municipal Code Text Amendment to exempt single-family properties from the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance and incorporate associated clean-up items. The proposed changes to the Ordinance, as specifically requested by City Council, are described in the next section.
Proposed Municipal Code Text Amendment
Following the November 12, 2024, City Council study session, City staff focused on addressing the City Council’s main objective of exempting single-family residential properties from the Tree Preservation Ordinance, while still protecting the following trees:
• Trees located within common areas, open space, scenic easements, slope easements, or areas maintained by a Homeowner’s Association (HOA); and • Trees located on a single-family property within designated open space area, scenic easement, or slope easement.
The City contains numerous hillside residential properties as well as properties governed by a homeowners association (HOA). These properties contain sensitive open space or easement areas that are part of the property in question but are restricted from development in order to be kept as natural open space. These specified areas would remain as protected under the proposed Municipal Code Text Amendment. In addition, there are certain properties/communities within the City where a portion of the owners’ parcel is landscaped and maintained by an HOA, thus viewed as a common area tree. These areas would continue to remain protected areas. Nevertheless, any other tree(s) located outside of the categories mentioned above would be allowed to be removed without the submittal of a formal Tree Removal Permit and associated fee.
REVIEW OF CITY OF SAN DIMAS GENERAL PLAN LAND USE MAP AND GUIDELINES The proposed Project would apply to trees situated within single-family properties. The City published its General Plan in 1991, one year after the passage of the Tree Preservation Ordinance. The City’s Land Use Element contains no specific goals or policies related to trees or tree preservation. In addition, the Conservation Element contains no specific goals or policies related to trees or tree preservation. Nevertheless, the Element does mention the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance (City of San Dimas 1991). As such, there would be no conflict with City Land Use policies, nor would there be any conflict with City Conservation Element policies.
Luis Torrico
April 17, 2025
Psomas
REVIEW OF 15300.2–EXCEPTIONS CRITERIA
Location: Classes 3, 4, 5, 6, and 11 are qualified by consideration of where the project is to be located – a project that is ordinarily insignificant in its impact on the environment may, in a particularly sensitive environment, be significant. Therefore, these classes are considered to apply to all instances, except where the project may impact on an environmental resource of hazardous or critical concern where designated, precisely mapped, and officially adopted pursuant to law by federal, state, or local agencies.
The Project is not considered under Classes 3, 4, 5, 6 or 11. Therefore, this exception is not applicable to Common Sense Exemptions. Nevertheless, the Project consists of Municipal Code Text Amendments made to the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance. As the Project is programmatic in nature, the Project would not result in any direct impacts. Subsequent tree removal conducted under the revised Tree Preservation Ordinance would be required to adhere to the requirements outlined in the updated Ordinance, ensuring that none of the trees identified above and in the proposed Text Amendment are removed. As a result, a significant impact would not be created based on the location of future actions under the revised Tree Preservation Ordinance; conversely, impacts would be avoided based on the locations identified as allowable areas for tree removal.
Cumulative Impacts: The Project consists of Municipal Code Text Amendments made to the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance. As the Project is programmatic in nature and does not propose any development or alteration of existing streetscapes or topography, the Project would not result in any direct impacts.
The City’s consideration of native and sensitive trees, including those within designated conservation areas, would preclude a significant impact related to loss of native and locally important species throughout single-family properties located within the City. In addition, the City has prepared a Community Forest Management Plan dated June 27, 2023 with the intention of protecting existing City trees, implementing public education programs, and expanding the City’s inventory of trees within viable, vacant sites along city streets, at city facilities and in city parks (City of San Dimas 2023). Additionally, because the trees allowed for removal under the revised Tree Preservation Ordinance would primarily consist of individual trees within private property. As a result, cumulative biological impacts are not considered to be significant. Meanwhile, cumulative air quality and greenhouse gas emissions would not be significant either. As stated above, the City’s Community Forest Management Plan calls for the planting of a diverse selection of trees within City owned property. The expansion of the City’s tree inventory would offset the small loss of carbon sequestration resulting from the removal of trees within private, single-family properties.
As a result, no significant cumulative impacts would occur.
Significant Effects (unusual circumstances): The Project would not have a significant effect on the environment due to unusual circumstances, as demonstrated by the discussion below.
Air Quality and Greenhouse Gas: The Project consists of Municipal Code Text Amendments made to the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance. As the Project is programmatic in nature, dealing with the removal of certain trees located within single-family properties, the Project would not induce any development. As a result, no air Luis Torrico
April 17, 2025
Psomas
quality or greenhouse gas emissions would occur. Nevertheless, depending on the type of equipment used, subsequent tree removal conducted under the revised Tree Preservation Ordinance would result in negligible emissions. It is important to note that these emissions would be too small to quantify and would be well below the regional and local thresholds established by the South Coast Air Quality Management District (SCAQMD). As stated above, while the ordinance may result in a small loss of carbon sequestration, the City’s Community Forest Management Plan calls for the planting of more trees within City-owned properties. Therefore, no impacts with respect to air quality and greenhouse gas emissions would occur.
Biological Resources: The following analysis focuses on trees that are native to the City of San Dimas: coast live oak (Quercus agrifolia), scrub oak (Quercus berberidifolia), canyon live oak (Quercus chrysolepis), San Gabriel oak (Quercus durata var. gabrielensis), Nuttall's scrub oak (Quercus dumosa), Engelmann oak (Quercus engelmannii), interior live oak (Quercus wislizeni); western sycamore (Platanus racemosa), southern California black walnut (Juglans californica); knobcone pine (Pinus attenuata), Coulter pine (Pinus coulteri), and Bishop pine (Pinus muricata) 1 . Of these
species, the following species are considered special status: southern California black walnut (California Rare Plant Rank [CRPR] 4.22), San Gabriel oak (CRPR 4.22), Nuttall’s scrub oak (CRPR 1B.13), and Engelmann oak (CRPR 4.22) (CDFW 2025a). Additionally, the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) considers the following woodland vegetation types to be sensitive natural communities: western sycamore woodlands (Platanus racemosa alliances), California walnut groves (Juglans californica alliances), and Coulter pine woodland and forests (Pinus coulteri alliances) (CDFW 2025b).
The Significant Ecological Area (SEA) Program was established to help conserve the genetic and physical diversity within Los Angeles County by designating biological resource areas capable of sustaining themselves into the future. SEAs are places where the County deems it important to balance between development and conservation of fragile resources such as streams, woodlands, and Threatened or Endangered species and their habitats. There are two SEAs within the City of San Dimas: the East San Gabriel Valley SEA (i.e., Walnut Creek, Bonelli Regional Park/Puddingstone Reservoir, and various open spaces referred to as the Walnut Islands) and San Dimas Canyon/San Antonio Wash SEA. Both of these SEAs include important oak and walnut woodland habitats. The protection of trees within these open space areas would not be changed by the current proposed municipal code text amendment.
There are a number of HOA-governed and designated hillside residential properties that have large lots with sensitive open space or easement areas that are part of the property but are non-developable and intended to be kept as natural areas. Many of these 1 This list of pine trees includes those that are known to occur along the southern edge of the Angeles National Forest.
2 CRPR 4.2: Species that are considered of limited distribution and are considered fairly threatened in California (20– 80% of occurrences threatened; moderate degree and immediacy of threat). 3 CRPR 1B.1: Species that are considered Rare, Threatened, or Endangered throughout their range and are considered seriously threatened in California (over 80% of occurrences threatened; high degree and immediacy of threat).
Luis Torrico
April 17, 2025
Psomas
conservation overlays include oak and walnut woodlands. The protection of trees within these open space areas would not be changed by the current proposed municipal code text amendment.
The current staff report recommends that single family residences be exempted from applying for a tree permit for the removal of trees on their lot. While single individuals of the protected tree species (as defined by the ordinance) listed above could be present on an individual lot, individuals within developed areas are more likely to have been planted as landscaping during development than to be remnant native individual trees. These individual trees, whether planted or remnant native individuals, are within small fragments of habitat (i.e., single family lots), isolated from larger areas of naturally occurring woodlands and habitat areas, and would not be expected to be naturally reproducing. The change in the municipal code text amendment would not require a tree removal permit for individual trees within single family lots, and could result in the loss of tree individuals, including species on the protected species list. However, since these individual trees are not contributing to sustaining natural woodland areas, the loss of these isolated individual trees would not affect the viability of the larger areas of native woodlands (described above within SEAs and hillside areas/conservation overlays) that provide higher quality woodland habitat. Therefore, the loss of trees resulting from the municipal code text amendment, as currently proposed (applying to only single family lots), would be considered less than significant.
The remaining species recommended as protected trees in the current staff report, camphor and California redwood, are not native to the City of San Dimas. There are also several species of pine trees that have been planted as ornamentals in southern California. These species are not considered special status, as individuals or as woodlands. Therefore, the loss of individuals of these tree species would not be considered a significant impact.
All trees, including native and non-native trees, could provide habitat for nesting birds and raptors; however, compliance with standard protective measures to avoid impacts on nesting birds/raptors would be required.
Geology: The Project would not result in the development of housing or other habitable structures that would expose people to risks associated with seismic shaking, ground failure, landslides, or other geotechnical issues present in Southern California. The Project consists of text amendments made to the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance.
Water Quality: The Project consists of Municipal Code Text Amendments made to the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance. As the Project is programmatic in nature and does not propose any development or alteration of existing streetscapes or topography, the Project would not result in any impacts to water quality, as the Project specifically deals with the removal of certain trees within single-family properties. In addition, the Project’s implementation would not alter drainage patterns within hillside areas, as the removal of trees from these areas would be precluded under the revised Tree Preservation Ordinance.
Luis Torrico
April 17, 2025
Psomas
Noise: The Project consists of Municipal Code Text Amendments made to the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance. The Project would not induce any development as the Project is programmatic in nature. Nevertheless, depending on the type of equipment used, subsequent tree removal conducted under the revised Tree Preservation Ordinance would result in the generation of temporary noise associated with the use of chainsaws. It is important to note that this noise would be temporary and tree removal would be required to adhere to all applicable City noise regulations.
Utilities and Public Services: The Project consists of Municipal Code Text Amendments and is programmatic in nature. The Project does not propose any development or alteration of existing streetscapes or topography that would result in impacts on any public services or utilities. Nevertheless, green waste generated during the subsequent removal of trees must be removed and properly disposed of pursuant to all applicable local and State requirements.
Scenic Highways: The Project would not result in damage to scenic resources. The Project consists of Municipal Code Text Amendments made to the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance.
As the Project is programmatic in nature and does not propose any development or alteration of existing streetscapes or topography, the Project would not result in any impacts on scenic highways or scenic resources, as the Project specifically deals with the removal of certain trees within single-family properties. In addition, according to the California Department of Transportation (Caltrans), there are no officially designated State scenic highway in the City (Caltrans 2025). As a result, no impacts would occur.
Hazardous Waste Site: The Project consists of Municipal Code Text Amendments made to the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance. As the Project is programmatic in nature, dealing with the removal of certain trees located within single-family properties (parcels that are typically not associated with hazardous waste sites), the Project would not induce any development, especially development on properties that are included on a list of hazardous materials sites. As a result, no impacts would occur.
Historical Resources: The Project consists of Municipal Code Text Amendments made to the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance. As the Project is programmatic in nature and does not propose any development or alteration of existing streetscapes or topography, the Project would not result in any impacts to historic resources, including neighborhoods, as the Project specifically deals with the removal of certain trees within single-family properties. As a result, no impacts would occur.
Luis Torrico
April 17, 2025
Psomas
REFERENCES
California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) 2025a (January). Special Vascular Plants, Bryophytes, and Lichens List. Sacramento, CA: CDFW, Natural Heritage Division. https://nrm.dfg.ca.gov/FileHandler.ashx?DocumentID=109383&inline. ———. 2025b (February 27). California Natural Communities List. Natural Communities List Arranged Alphabetically by Life Form (PDF). Sacramento, CA: CDFW Biogeographic Data Branch. https://nrm.dfg.ca.gov/FileHandler.ashx?DocumentID=153398&inline.
California Department of Transportation (Caltrans). 2025 (April 8, last accessed). State Scenic Highway Map. Sacramento, CA: Caltrans.
https://caltrans.maps.arcgis.com/apps/webappviewer/index.html?id=465dfd3d807c46cc8 e8057116f1aacaa.
City of San Dimas. 2023 (June 27, last revised). Community Forest Management Plan. San Dimas, CA: the City.
https://files.sandimasca.gov/Document_Center/Department/Parks%20&%20Recreation/ Community%20Forest%20Management%20Plan%20%20Amended%206.27.2023.pdf ——. 1991 (April 8, last accessed). City of San Dimas General Plan. San Dimas, CA: the City. https://sandimasca.gov/departments/community_development/planning_division/general _plan/general_plan_sections.php.