October 24, 2026
VIA EMAIL AND PUBLIC HEARING SUBMISSION
To: Honorable Mayor and Members of the San Dimas City Council City of San Dimas
245 East Bonita Avenue
San Dimas, CA 91773
RE: FORMAL WRITTEN OPPOSITION — LONE HILL PARK REGIONAL WATERSHED
MANAGEMENT PROGRAM PROJECT
Public Hearing: November 9, 2026
Project Location: 500 North Shellman Avenue, San Dimas, CA 91773 State Clearinghouse No.: 2026021076
Reference: Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration (February 2026) Dear Mayor and Members of the City Council:
I am submitting this letter to formally express my strong opposition to the Lone Hill Park Regional Watershed Management Program Project as currently proposed, particularly the construction of an additional parking lot, the potential loss of existing green space and mature trees, and the environmental and neighborhood impacts associated with the proposed improvements.
As a lifelong San Dimas resident and frequent visitor to Lone Hill Park, I am familiar with the park's existing conditions, recreational activities, and importance to the surrounding community.
I recognize the importance of responsible stormwater management, groundwater replenishment, and compliance with applicable water-quality requirements. My opposition is not directed toward those objectives. Rather, I question whether certain proposed surface improvements, particularly the additional parking lot, are necessary or appropriate given their potential impact on existing parkland, wildlife habitat, neighborhood conditions, and public resources.
Having reviewed the City's February 2026 Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration (IS/MND), I believe several aspects of the proposed design warrant further examination and explanation before the City Council proceeds with approval.
1. Proposed Additional Parking Lot and Loss of Existing Green Space My primary objection concerns the proposed construction of an additional parking lot along Juanita Avenue.
ATTACHMENT 5
Lone Hill Park is an established neighborhood recreational resource whose existing open space, mature landscape, and natural environment should be preserved to the greatest extent feasible.
While the City proposes permeable paving for the additional parking area, converting existing grass or landscaped areas to vehicle parking would nevertheless result in a loss of natural green space and its associated recreational and environmental benefits.
I am particularly concerned that the parking expansion may be intended primarily to accommodate the significant number of participants and spectators attending organized softball activities. These events regularly attract substantial attendance, particularly on weekends during softball season.
If accommodating peak athletic-event parking demand is a primary justification for the expansion, I believe the City should demonstrate why that need warrants the permanent conversion of neighborhood parkland.
I am also concerned about the proximity of Gladstone Elementary School, located directly adjacent to Lone Hill Park. Any proposed increase in parking capacity should be evaluated in relation to school-related traƯic, pedestrian safety, neighborhood circulation, and access along Juanita Avenue, Shellman Avenue, and Gladstone Street.
Section 3.17 of the City's IS/MND concludes that significant transportation impacts are not anticipated. However, the available discussion does not clearly establish the actual parking demand or provide a detailed evaluation of the proposed parking area's operational eƯects near the school.
I respectfully request that the City provide:
1. A detailed, to-scale site plan identifying the exact location, dimensions, and number of proposed additional parking spaces.
2. A comparison showing the square footage of existing grass, landscaping, and open space that would be permanently converted to parking.
3. Any parking-demand or utilization studies supporting the proposed expansion, including demand during ordinary park use, weekend softball activities, and evening practices.
4. A traƯic and pedestrian-safety assessment addressing the surrounding residential streets and Gladstone Elementary School.
5. Documentation identifying alternative designs that would eliminate the additional parking lot while preserving the project's necessary stormwater-management functions.
6. The estimated construction and ongoing maintenance costs attributable specifically to the proposed parking expansion.
I strongly request that the City reconsider and eliminate the proposed additional parking lot in favor of preserving the park's existing natural green space.
2. Environmental Review, Wildlife Habitat, and Preservation of Mature Trees I have significant concerns regarding the potential environmental impacts of the project, particularly the disturbance or removal of existing vegetation and wildlife habitat.
Lone Hill Park supports a variety of wildlife, including falcons, wild parakeets, other birds, squirrels, rabbits, and additional species that I regularly observe throughout the park.
The existing trees, grass, and landscaped areas provide important shelter, nesting opportunities, and feeding habitat for these animals.
Section 3.4 of the City's IS/MND evaluates biological resources and relies in part on the park's developed, urban setting when assessing habitat suitability. However, the study also acknowledges that existing trees may provide nesting habitat and that some trees are proposed for removal.
Although Mitigation Measures BIO-1 through BIO-3 establish certain biological assessment and protection requirements, I believe greater clarification is warranted regarding actual site conditions and the implementation of these measures.
I respectfully request:
1. The biological field surveys and supporting documentation used to evaluate wildlife species and nesting habitat at Lone Hill Park.
2. A complete inventory identifying mature trees proposed for removal, trees to be preserved, and the size and species of replacement trees.
3. Specific consideration of existing birds of prey, including falcons, and the potential eƯects of construction on nesting and breeding activity.
4. An explanation of how the required biological mitigation measures will be implemented, monitored, and enforced.
5. An assessment of habitat impacts associated with the additional parking lot, new lighting, removal of vegetation, and prolonged construction.
6. Consideration of alternatives that preserve additional existing trees, grassland, and natural habitat.
The replacement of mature trees with new landscaping does not immediately restore the ecological benefits, shade, and wildlife habitat provided by established vegetation.
I therefore request that preservation of existing mature trees and natural areas receive priority in the final project design.
I also request that the City identify the supporting evidence for its conclusions regarding biological resources and determine whether additional site-specific environmental analysis is warranted before adopting the Mitigated Negative Declaration.
3. Project Budget, Financial Accountability, and Evaluation of Alternatives Given the substantial public investment contemplated for this project, I believe the City should provide greater financial transparency regarding the proposed improvements and their long-term costs.
Previously published information has identified an estimated capital cost of approximately $9.9 million, along with earlier design funding of approximately $900,000. I recognize that these figures may not represent the project's current approved budget.
Nevertheless, it is important for residents to understand how these public funds will be allocated and whether the proposed improvements are necessary to accomplish the project's primary stormwater-management objectives.
The City's project description identifies the capture, treatment, and infiltration of stormwater runoƯ from approximately 335 acres as a principal objective.
I respectfully request clarification regarding which components are necessary to achieve these environmental requirements and which represent discretionary recreational or parking improvements.
Specifically, I request:
1. The current total project budget, including amounts already expended, committed, or anticipated.
2. An itemized allocation of costs for the underground stormwater infrastructure, additional parking lot, recreational courts, playground, pathways, landscaping, and other proposed improvements.
3. Identification of all project funding sources, including applicable Measure W funding, grants, and City contributions.
4. Clarification of any restrictions on funding that would aƯect the City's ability to modify or eliminate particular improvements.
5. Estimated annual operation, maintenance, inspection, and replacement costs following project completion.
6. A comparative cost and feasibility assessment of alternative designs that would preserve existing parkland and eliminate the additional parking area.
I recognize that the project provides important stormwater-management benefits.
However, the necessity of the underground infrastructure should be evaluated separately from the proposed surface improvements wherever feasible.
Before committing substantial public funds, the City should demonstrate that the proposed design represents an appropriate balance of environmental compliance, financial responsibility, neighborhood recreational needs, and preservation of existing parkland.
4. Existing Park Maintenance and Operational Concerns
Lone Hill Park already experiences substantial recreational activity, particularly during organized softball games, tournaments, and evening practices.
I have personally documented recurring problems involving excessive litter, overflowing trash receptacles, and substantial waste left behind following sporting activities.
I have also discussed these conditions directly with the landscaping personnel responsible for maintaining the park. These employees routinely face the burden of collecting preventable litter associated with organized recreational use.
I have photographs documenting these conditions, which have not previously been submitted to the City and are available for inclusion in the public record.
Additionally, I have observed what appears to be alcohol consumption by participants, spectators, and individuals appearing to serve as coaches during softball games and practices.
I request clarification of the City's applicable park regulations, whether organized sporting groups are subject to specific permit conditions, and how those requirements are enforced.
I have also observed recurring overnight vehicle occupancy and individuals sleeping or sheltering in landscaped areas within and around the park. I have contacted the SheriƯ's Department regarding these conditions.
I recognize the importance of treating individuals experiencing homelessness with dignity while also maintaining safe, sanitary, and accessible public facilities.
These issues raise legitimate questions regarding existing maintenance resources, enforcement responsibilities, and the potential operating impacts of additional parking.
Before expanding vehicle capacity or introducing facilities that may increase usage, I request that the City evaluate:
1. Existing trash collection capacity, weekend maintenance schedules, and cleanup responsibilities of organized athletic groups.
2. Whether additional trash receptacles, event cleanup requirements, or enforceable permit conditions are necessary.
3. Applicable alcohol regulations and current enforcement procedures.
4. Existing overnight parking and camping policies, including coordination with appropriate outreach services.
5. Whether the proposed parking expansion could increase maintenance or overnight management challenges.
6. The additional staƯing, maintenance, and enforcement costs associated with the proposed improvements.
These concerns are relevant to the long-term operation and stewardship of Lone Hill Park and should be considered when evaluating the necessity and appropriateness of additional facilities.
5. Community Input and Neighborhood Recreational Priorities When this project was initially introduced, I attended the informational meeting held at Lone Hill Park and provided my contact information, expressing my interest in reviewing future plans and oƯering suggestions.
Although I did not receive subsequent project updates, I recognize that the City has undertaken a formal public review process.
Given the scope of the proposed improvements, I respectfully request access to the current detailed engineering and landscape plans and an additional opportunity for interested neighborhood residents to review the design before final approval.
This request is consistent with Section 2 of the City's IS/MND, which identifies incorporating community-based input among the project's objectives.
During the initial meeting, residents also suggested incorporating a modest, designated dog-friendly area within the park.
I would appreciate clarification regarding whether that suggestion was evaluated and whether an appropriately designed dog area could be considered without unnecessarily reducing existing green space or disturbing sensitive wildlife habitat.
More broadly, I request that the City explain how recreational improvements were prioritized, including whether neighborhood needs assessments, resident surveys, or other documented community input informed the current design.
Section 3.16 of the IS/MND concludes that the proposed recreational improvements will benefit the community. I believe that conclusion would be better supported by a transparent explanation of how existing recreational space, proposed amenities, and resident preferences were evaluated.
6. Construction Impacts and Protection of Surrounding Residents The City's published project information has contemplated approximately 16 months of construction, subject to funding and scheduling.
Given the park's proximity to Gladstone Elementary School and surrounding residences, I request that the City provide detailed information regarding construction impacts and the measures intended to protect nearby properties, pedestrians, schoolchildren, park users, and wildlife.
Sections 3.3 and 3.13 of the IS/MND address air quality, noise, and vibration, including mitigation measures intended to reduce construction-related impacts.
I respectfully request:
1. A detailed construction schedule identifying anticipated phases, temporary closures, and the duration of disruptions.
2. Proposed construction vehicle routes, equipment staging locations, and traƯic-control measures.
3. Specific protections for school-related pedestrian and vehicle circulation.
4. Procedures for controlling and monitoring construction noise, dust, and vibration.
5. Measures to protect nearby residential properties, existing mature trees, and wildlife habitat.
6. Identification of the responsible City representative for construction-related complaints and mitigation compliance.
Residents should receive advance notice of significant construction activities and have access to a clear process for reporting and resolving concerns throughout the project.
7. Requests Regarding the Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration Based on my review of the February 2026 IS/MND, I respectfully request that the City Council consider the following matters before adopting the environmental document or approving the project.
Biological Resources — Section 3.4: Provide the supporting evidence for the biological conclusions, including applicable field surveys, proposed tree removals, and the implementation and monitoring requirements associated with Mitigation Measures BIO-1 through BIO-3.
Hydrology and Water Quality — Section 3.10: Clarify whether the proposed parking lot is necessary to achieve the stormwater project's regulatory objectives and whether a design preserving existing green space would remain technically feasible.
Recreation — Section 3.16: Explain how the City evaluated the loss or modification of existing recreational open space, the selection of proposed amenities, and alternative designs responsive to neighborhood needs.
Transportation — Section 3.17: Provide supporting documentation addressing parking demand, operational circulation, and pedestrian safety in relation to the adjacent elementary school and surrounding neighborhood.
Construction Noise and Vibration — Section 3.13: Identify how mitigation requirements will be monitored and enforced and how nearby residents and school representatives will be notified of and protected from significant construction activity.
I further request access to the project's current Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program, underlying technical studies, and any public or agency comments and responses prepared in connection with the environmental review.
I am not asserting that the City has necessarily violated applicable environmental requirements. Rather, I respectfully request that the Council carefully consider whether the available analysis adequately addresses the site-specific concerns identified in this correspondence and whether additional environmental review or project modifications are warranted.
FORMAL REQUESTS FOR CITY COUNCIL ACTION
For the reasons outlined above, I respectfully request that the City Council:
1. Continue the November 9, 2026 public hearing and defer adoption of the Mitigated Negative Declaration and approval of the project in its currently proposed form until the identified issues have been adequately addressed.
2. Direct staƯ to evaluate eliminating the proposed additional parking lot along Juanita Avenue and preserving the aƯected existing green space.
3. Provide complete current engineering drawings, landscape plans, environmental supporting studies, parking analyses, and detailed project cost information.
4. Evaluate and publicly present feasible alternatives that accomplish the project's required stormwater-management objectives while minimizing impacts on existing parkland and wildlife habitat.
5. Consult with Gladstone Elementary School and the responsible school district regarding traƯic, pedestrian safety, and construction impacts.
6. Evaluate existing park maintenance, sanitation, enforcement, and overnight management concerns in connection with any proposed increase in parking or recreational capacity.
7. Explain how resident suggestions and neighborhood recreational priorities, including the proposed dog area, have been considered.
8. Conduct an additional public meeting and provide a reasonable opportunity for residents to review the current detailed design.
9. Provide written responses to the substantive questions and requests identified in this letter.
10. Include this correspondence and any supplemental photographic evidence in the oƯicial public hearing and administrative record.
Conclusion
I support responsible stormwater management and environmental improvements that provide meaningful benefits to San Dimas.
However, those goals should be pursued in a manner that preserves existing neighborhood parkland to the greatest extent feasible, protects mature trees and wildlife habitat, and ensures that proposed improvements are supported by demonstrated need and appropriate financial and environmental analysis.
Lone Hill Park is an established community resource whose natural landscape, open space, recreational functions, and proximity to Gladstone Elementary School deserve careful consideration before permanent changes are approved.
I respectfully urge the City Council to reconsider the proposed parking expansion, evaluate less disruptive alternatives, and provide greater transparency and meaningful public participation before proceeding.
Please distribute this correspondence to all City Council members, include it in the oƯicial hearing and administrative record, and acknowledge receipt in writing.
I also request written responses to the substantive matters raised and inclusion in all future project notices, updates, and public review opportunities.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Sincerely,
Kourtney Preston
San Dimas Resident
626-475-6767
Supporting Materials: Photographs documenting excessive litter and apparent alcohol consumption associated with organized park activities are included below.
Photos from 3/16/26
Photos from 2/2/26
Photo from 9/8/25
Photo from 12/16/24
Photo from 9/12/24