Cities Index.
Staff Report Introduce Ordinance 1326

San Dimas City Council
November 9, 2026

Document
Staff Report Introduce Ordinance 1326
Meeting
November 9, 2026
Body
San Dimas City Council
Original file
3.2 MB
Text extracted from the city's file for reading and search. Open the original on sandimasca.primegov.com. That file is the official record.

Agenda Item Staff Report
To: Honorable Mayor and Members of City Council
For the Meeting of November 9, 2026
From: Brad McKinney, City Manager
Prepared by: Yasmin Dabbous, Assistant Planner
Subject: Introduce Ordinance 1326, a City-initiated Municipal Code Text Amendment of Title 18, Chapter 18.162 Tree Preservation Ordinance to Exempt Single-Family Zoned Properties and Single-Family Properties within Specific Plans, with the Exception of Certain Open Space, Scenic, Slope, or Conservation Easements, Homeowner Association (HOA) Common Areas, and/or HOA Maintained Areas and Associated Clean-Up Items within the Chapter Relating to the Amendments.

This project is Categorically Exempt under CEQA guidelines, Title 14, Article 5 Preliminary Review of Projects and Conduct of Initial Study, Section 15061(B)(3), Common Sense Exemption.
____________________________________________________________________________

SUMMARY
Revising the Tree Preservation Ordinance began in 2023 as initiated by the Planning Commission. Since then, several public hearings were held by the Planning Commission and City Council to further review and discuss these changes.

At the November 12, 2024, City Council study session, Staff was directed to revise the text amendment to exempt all single-family properties from the Ordinance and incorporate associated clean-up items.

At the April 17, 2025, Planning Commission meeting, the Commission recommended approval to the City Council of Resolution PC-1696 to exempt single-family zoned properties and single-family properties within a specific plan from the tree ordinance, including the recommendation of two (2) additional items. These items include (1) the preservation of front-yard areas and (2) excluding Single-Family Hillside (SF-H) zoned properties from the exemption.

At the May 27, 2025, City Council meeting, Staff was instructed to explore alternative options for the amendment (such as a preservation list and front-yard protections) and further research defensible space and Zone 0 legislation. City Council requested that the item come back after a public presentation was provided by the Los Angeles County Fire Department regarding fire prevention, which was presented by the Fire Department at the May 26, 2026, City Council meeting.

MCTA 23-05 – Tree Preservation Ordinance Page 2
For the Meeting of November 9, 2026
This proposed ordinance includes the Council’s original direction to exempt all single-family zoned properties from the Tree Ordinance, and items that were recommended by the City’s environmental consultant and City Staff, should the Council desire to approve it. Additionally, the report discusses recommendations by the Planning Commission and a protected tree list, should the Council decide to include in the proposed changes.

RECOMMENDATION
Staff and the Planning Commission recommend the City Council:

1. Read by title and introduce Ordinance 1326 (Attachment 1), approving Municipal Code Text Amendment 23-05.

2. Find that this project is Categorically Exempt under CEQA guidelines, Title 14, Article 5 Preliminary Review of Projects and Conduct of Initial Study, Section 15061(B)(3), Common Sense Exemption.

Please note that this report includes additional discussion items, including the Planning Commission’s recommendations in their motion that included considering preservation of front-yard areas, excluding Single-Family Hillside (SF-H) zoned properties from the exemption, and discussion of creating a protected tree list for consideration. In the case that the City Council decides to move forward with any of these additional items, the Council would need to direct Staff to include the added language in the Ordinance for adoption at the second reading.

GOVERNMENT CODE §84308 APPLIES:
https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov
No

FISCAL IMPACT
Application Fee revenues will be reduced with the approval of exempting single-family properties, as specified, from the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance.

BACKGROUND
Trees within the City of San Dimas are regulated under two (2) separate chapters of the San Dimas Municipal Code (SDMC) as follows:

1. Chapter 13.36, Community Tree Management, regulates policy and enforcement related to City-owned trees located within any park, City right-of-way, median, parkway, planting easement or any other City-owned property, and is administered by the Parks and Recreation Department.

2. Chapter 18.162, the Tree Preservation Ordinance, regulates policy and enforcement related to privately-owned trees, located on privately-owned property, regardless of the established land use, and is administered by the Community Development Department.

This Municipal Code Text Amendment (MCTA) solely proposes modifications to Chapter 18.162, which deals with specific provisions, authorities, and enforcement procedures relating to preservation of trees located on private property.

MCTA 23-05 – Tree Preservation Ordinance Page 3
For the Meeting of November 9, 2026
The Tree Preservation Ordinance (Chapter 18.162) was originally adopted in 1990 with the intent of preserving and protecting private mature significant trees in the City. The Tree Preservation Ordinance defines a mature significant tree as any private tree within the City of an Oak genus which measures eight (8) inches or more in trunk diameter and/or any other species of trees which measure ten (10) inches or more in trunk diameter and/or a multi-trunk tree(s) having a total circumference of thirty-eight (38) inches or more; the multi-trunk tree shall include at least one trunk with a diameter of a minimum of four (4) inches. The trunk diameter measurement must be measured at a point thirty-six (36) inches above the ground at the base of the tree. The Ordinance also exempts fruit trees and other similar species from protection; therefore, with the exception of these trees, any tree that meets the aforementioned criteria would be protected under the Ordinance.

The Ordinance requires a permit to remove protected trees. A request to remove up to three (3) trees is reviewed administratively by Planning Staff, while the removal of four (4) or more trees requires approval by the Director of Community Development. These review authorities were recently adopted in 2025 as part of the deletion of the Development Plan Review Board (DPRB); previously, the removal of up to three (3) trees required review/approval by the Director, and removal of four (4) or more trees required review/approval by the DPRB. The application fee for a Tree Permit on a single-family property for three (3) trees or less is $300 and $500 for four (4) or more trees. Approved applications are subject to a two-for-one (2:1) replacement ratio with a minimum of fifteen-gallon tree(s), or other replacement of equivalent value and size, within the subject property. A reduced replacement ratio may be approved if it is consistent with the purposes of the Ordinance.

At the November 12, 2024, City Council study session, Staff was directed to revise the text amendment to exempt all single-family properties from the Ordinance and incorporate associated clean-up items.

At the April 17, 2025, Planning Commission meeting, the Commission voted (5-0) to recommend approval of Resolution PC-1696 to the City Council to exempt single-family zoned properties and single-family properties within a specific plan from the tree ordinance. The recommendation to City Council also included two (2) additional items. These items include the preservation of front-yard areas and the non-exempting of Single-Family Hillside (SF-H) zoned properties.

Most recently at the May 27, 2025, City Council meeting, (Attachment 2) Staff was instructed to explore alternative options for the amendment and further research defensible space and Zone 0 legislation. City Council requested that the item come back after a public presentation was provided by the Los Angeles County Fire Department regarding fire prevention, which was presented at the May 26, 2026, City Council meeting. Assistant Fire Chief Steve Cabrera shared that the legislation is currently under review by the California Board of Forestry and Fire Protection as they continue to hold ongoing stakeholder meetings regarding the legislation with a draft policy.

Items they discussed included implementation, roll out periods and materials outside of vegetation (i.e. fencing, decking, etc.). The Fire Department originally expected Zone 0 implementation to begin in January 2027. That timeline is now uncertain. On August 19, 2026, the California State Board of Forestry and Fire Protection adopted Zone 0 regulations. The Board sent the regulations to the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) for approval on August 28, then withdrew them soon after to make technical edits. The regulations have not been approved, so they are not yet in effect and there is no statewide compliance deadline. Figure 1 below visualizes the fire protected zones.

MCTA 23-05 – Tree Preservation Ordinance Page 4
For the Meeting of November 9, 2026
Figure 1: Zone Zero Defensible Space
Additionally, Staff was instructed to establish additional discussion items related to a possible tree preservation list and the potential protection of front yard areas within single-family residences.

DISCUSSION/ANALYSIS
Following the numerous Planning Commission and City Council meetings and recommendations, Staff has put together Table 1 below that summarizes the current Code requirement, proposed changes, and whether additional discussion is needed for each of the items. The table is broken down into three (3) categories:

1. Proposed Ordinance – This category includes the proposed changes in the Ordinance should the Council decide to approve and introduce the Ordinance, which consists of changes that were originally requested by the Council and changes recommended by Staff and the environmental consultant (Psomas).

2. Planning Commission Recommendations - This category includes recommendations by the Planning Commission, which consist of only exempting rear and side yards of single-family zones and single-family properties within specific plans and continue to protect and require tree removal permits for any tree that is fifteen (15) inches or greater in diameter in the front yard, and continue protecting and requiring tree removal permits for properties zoned Single-Family Hillside (SF-H). Should the Council decide to incorporate the Commission’s recommendations, the Council would need to direct Staff to include the language in the Ordinance for adoption at the second reading.

3. City Council Additional Discussion Item – This category consists of the tree protection list requested by the Council for discussion. Should the Council decide to incorporate a protected tree list, which would only be applicable to single-family properties, the Council would need to direct Staff to include the list in the Ordinance for adoption at the second reading.

All of these items are discussed in more detail later in the report, but the table aims to simply provide a summary of the major changes.

MCTA 23-05 – Tree Preservation Ordinance Page 5
For the Meeting of November 9, 2026
Item Current Code PC
Recommendation
CC
Direction
Proposed Ordinance
Council Direction & Staff/Environmental Consultant Recommendations Single-Family
Zone &
Single-Family
within Specific
Plans
Requires Tree Permit for
Removal
Sec. 18.162.070
Change
Protect 15” Dia. Trees in
Front Yards; Exempt
Side and Rear Yards
Change
Exempt whole
property
HOA Owned or
Managed Areas
Requires Tree Permit for
Removal
Sec. 18.162.070
No Change
Require Permit Discussed
Open Space
Areas
Requires Tree Permit for
Removal
Sec. 18.162.070
No Change
Require Permit Discussed
Scenic/Slope
Easements
Requires Tree Permit for
Removal
Sec. 18.162.070
No Change
Require Permit Discussed
Conservation
Areas
Requires Tree Permit for
Removal
Sec. 18.162.070
No Change
Require Permit Discussed
Fire Department
Requested Tree
Removal
Requires Tree Permit for
Removal
Sec. 18.162.070
Not discussed Implement
Home Insurance
Requested Tree
Removal
Requires Tree Permit for
Removal
Sec. 18.162.070A
Not discussed Implement
Zone 0 Self-Compliance
Requires Tree Permit for
Removal
Sec. 18.162.070
Not discussed Implement
Planning Commission’s Recommendations
Single Family
Front Yards
Requires Tree Permit for
Removal
Sec. 18.162.070
Change
Protect 15” Dia. Trees in
Front Yards; Exempt
Side and Rear Yards
Requesting
Direction
Single-Family
Hillside Zone
Requires Tree Permit for
Removal
Sec. 18.162.070
No Change
Require Permit
Requesting
Direction
Additional City Council Discussion Item
Protected Tree
List N/A No direction given Requesting Direction
Table 1: Summary of Discussion Items
MCTA 23-05 – Tree Preservation Ordinance Page 6
For the Meeting of November 9, 2026
Original Direction from City Council & Staff Recommendations The first set of discussion items consists of the Council’s direction to exempt all single-family zoned properties from the Ordinance, and items that were recommended by the City’s environmental consultant and City Staff.

While working on exempting these properties, several concerns arose regarding environmental review and Code consistency. Items such as easements and biologically sensitive areas were discussed with the hired environmental consultant (Psomas). Psomas determined that exempting all single-family properties and not protecting specified areas would require additional CEQA review. The consultant noted this would potentially entail a quantitative analysis, biological studies, and mapping services which would span over the duration of months to prepare, most likely taking form of a Mitigated Negative Declaration (MND). The consultant provided that the estimated cost proposal for the prospective MND would be approximately $75,000, acknowledging that this estimate is very preliminary and does not include all associated costs.

This estimate would likely increase given the magnitude of the project scope.

Following much discussion and reviewing alternative options, language was included to preserve and protect sensitive biological areas to avoid ongoing environmental review, while completing the main objective as requested by the Council. In protecting these noted areas (open space, scenic, slope, or conservation easements as designated in this Code, homeowner association common areas, and/or homeowner association maintained areas) there is substantial evidence to support a Notice of Exemption (NOE) for the text amendment and would not require additional mitigation measures. The findings are further discussed in the Notice of Exemption Memorandum, as provided by the consultant in Attachment 3.

In this case, most single-family zoned properties will be exempt from the Ordinance with limitations on properties located within the noted areas. Single-family properties within specified areas, as listed, would be permitted to remove trees within the developable areas of the lot; however, trees in areas of the lot within given specified limitations will require a permit for removal.

In addition, the language proposed in the Ordinance ensures that the Tree Preservation Ordinance is consistent with protected areas listed in various Specific Plans that call out open space scenic easements. For example, open space areas are addressed in Specific Plan No. 7 (SP-7), where the Code specifically outlines focusing on the physical characteristics and the integration of surrounding urban and open space uses. If the preservation of these areas is not included in the code amendment, the Tree Ordinance would then be in conflict with SP-7 and other Specific Plans that include protection of sensitive areas.

The new exemption language in the Ordinance reads as follows:
• “Trees located on single-family zoned properties or single-family properties within specific plans, and are not within open space, scenic, slope, or conservation easements as designated in this Code, homeowner association common areas, and/or homeowner association maintained area;”
Staff would like to note that in the future, if an individual or group would like to request a code amendment to remove or revise the listed conservation areas, an MCTA application can be submitted for consideration and the applicant would incur all related costs pertaining to CEQA review.

MCTA 23-05 – Tree Preservation Ordinance Page 7
For the Meeting of November 9, 2026
Lastly, the proposed Ordinance addresses trees that are required to be removed by the Los Angeles County Fire Department or property insurance provider, and self-compliance with new Zone 0 legislation. As a result of the most recent discussion, Staff added the following language to Section 18.162.080 to address Fire Department and/or property insurer removal direction, and fire protection legislation:
• “Trees determined by Los Angeles County Fire Department or the insurer of the subject property to be a fire/failure concern and are required to be removed as documented by either entity; and”
• “Trees in accordance with California Public Resources Code § 4291(a)(1)(A), Zone 0 (the area extending zero to five feet from a structure) for the purpose of complying with applicable California defensible-space and wildfire-safety provisions and requirements.” It is important to clarify that these two new exemptions listed above would be applicable to any property in the City and are not specific to single-family zoned properties. In addition, while Zone 0 has yet to be implemented, with no set dates for implementation, Staff believes that including the exemption in the proposed ordinance would be of benefit to the residents to address fire safety concerns.

Planning Commission Recommendations
The second set of discussion items were recommended by the Planning Commission. At the April 17, 2025, Planning Commission meeting, the Commission voted (5-0) to recommend approval of Resolution PC-1696 to exempt single-family zoned properties and single-family properties within a specific plan from the tree ordinance, with a recommendation of the two (2) additional items outlined below:

1. The Commission determined that residential front-yards impact the visual appearance of the neighborhood and should be maintained with mature trees. This recommendation would be applicable to any tree that is fifteen (15) inches or greater in diameter (measured at 54-inches above the ground at the base of the tree) and located within a front-yard area, regardless of tree species. The Commission believes the removal of healthy trees in these areas can impact the overall character of single-family residential zones; therefore, trees in the front yards should be protected.

2. The Commission recommended that Single-Family Hillside (SF-H) zoned properties not be exempt from the Tree Ordinance in any way (developable areas or conservation areas).

This was determined on the basis that these areas were designated to ensure development blends with the natural setting of the terrain when viewed from neighboring areas and other parts of the City. It encourages development of safe, comfortable residential areas where residents can enjoy views and a natural setting. A total of 100 properties would be impacted by this recommendation, as depicted in Figures 2-4 below and mapped in Attachment 5.

MCTA 23-05 – Tree Preservation Ordinance Page 8
For the Meeting of November 9, 2026
Figure 2: SF-H Properties along Oakengate Drive
Figure 3: SF-H Properties along S. Walnut Avenue
Figure 4: SF-H Properties along Terrebonne Avenue
Additional Discussion Item Requested by the Council
At the May 27, 2025 City Council meeting, the Council directed Staff to explore a potential protected tree list. Psomas provided a comprehensive tree species list identified as native to the MCTA 23-05 – Tree Preservation Ordinance Page 9
For the Meeting of November 9, 2026
City of San Dimas and the overall local area as a potential protected tree list. This list was the following:
• Coast live oak (Quercus agrifolia);
• Scrub oak (Quercus berberidifolia);
• Canyon live oak (Quercus chrysolepis);
• San Gabriel oak (Quercus durata var. gabrielensis);
• Nuttall's scrub oak (Quercus dumosa);
• Engelmann oak (Quercus engelmannii);
• Interior live oak (Quercus wislizeni);
• Western sycamore (Platanus racemosa);
• Southern California black walnut (Juglans californica); • Knobcone pine (Pinus attenuata);
• Coulter pine (Pinus coulteri); and
• Bishop pine (Pinus muricata).

The lists above can be generalized to improve clarity, simplify classification, and support protecting more trees. Staff has generalized the list to the following:
• Oak (any genus);
• Western Sycamore;
• Southern California black walnut; and
• Pine (any genus).

Staff is requesting direction from the City Council regarding the protected tree list. Staff would like to note that the protected tree list would only be applicable to single-family zoned properties and single-family properties within a specific plan, to be consistent with Psomas’ recommendation.

Associated Code Clean-up Items
As part of this text amendment, Staff has identified several other areas of the Ordinance that are in need of associated clean ups and are as follows:
• Revise all titles from “Development Services” to “Community Development.” • Update all areas to correctly call out approved review authority change. • Ensure language for submittal requirements matches throughout the Chapter. • Clarify prolonged maintenance of replacement trees for property types. • Exempt palm trees to be consistent with current City practice and policy. • Trunk diameter shall now be measured from fifty-four (54) inches above ground level instead of thirty-six (36) inches to be consistent with general arboricultural standards.

The above-mentioned items are included in the proposed Ordinance, should the Council decide to approve it.

ALTERNATIVES
There are no alternatives proposed for this request; however, the City Council can choose to not approve the ordinance or provide Staff direction to revise the Ordinance to incorporate additional changes.

MCTA 23-05 – Tree Preservation Ordinance Page 10
For the Meeting of November 9, 2026

ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
As previously mentioned, the City hired Psomas to review the proposed code text amendment and provide additional CEQA services. As provided in the Notice of Exemption Memorandum and Notice of Exemption (Attachments 3 and 4), Psomas found that according to Section 15061(B)(3), a project may be exempt if the project’s implementation would not result in a significant effect on the environment. They found that the project consists of text updates to the City’s Municipal Code that would allow property owners of single-family zoned properties to remove trees within their property unencumbered by the City’s Tree Preservation Ordinance. Therefore, as the Project would result in text amendments to the Municipal Code and would not actually include any tree removal, it can be seen with certainty that there is no potential for a significant effect on the environment, as the amendments are programmatic in nature. Furthermore, any subsequent tree removals initiated by private property owners would be done according to the updated requirements, thereby limiting any potential impacts. These municipal code text updates would only apply to single-family properties, thereby limiting the number of trees that could be removed in the City. This founded substantial evidence to support a Notice of Exemption (Attachment 4) for the provided code amendment.

Respectfully submitted,
Yasmin Dabbous
Assistant Planner
Attachments:

1. Ordinance 1326

2. May 27, 2025, City Council Staff Report and Action Minutes

3. Psomas Notice of Exemption Memorandum

4. Psomas CEQA Notice of Exemption

5. Map of Single-Family Hillside (SF-H) Zoned Properties

6. PowerPoint Presentation

← All documents from this meeting