Cities Index.
Exhibit 1: Settlement Report

Alameda City Council
September 17, 2024

Document
Exhibit 1: Settlement Report
Meeting
September 17, 2024
Body
Alameda City Council
Original file
224 KB
Text extracted from the city's file for reading and search. Open the original on legistar1.granicus.com. That file is the official record.

July 1, 2023 through June 30, 2024 - LIABILITY CLAIMS SETTLEMENTS

CLAIMANT INCIDENT DESCRIPTION DATE OF LOSS SETTLEMENT

APPROVAL DATE APPROVED BY DATE OF

PAYMENT AMOUNT PAID
Tran, Tam Sidewalk fall 10/1/2022 5/24/2023 Risk Manager 7/17/2023 $ 15,000.00 Kwong, Cindy Property damage due to City tree
roots: sidewalk, yard, walkway 6/14/2022 6/27/2023 Risk Manager 7/13/2023 $ 3,500.00 State Farm ASO Rose, Lassel City vehicle collided with claimant's vehicle 12/18/2022 5/24/2023 Risk Manager 7/18/2023 $ 11,419.77 Casadidio, Briana Vehicle tow 7/5/2023 7/18/2023 Risk Manager 8/8/2023 $ 525.00 Meneses, Marilyn Vehicle tow 5/1/2023 8/1/2023 Risk Manager 8/8/2023 $ 375.00 Farrington, Angelo Vehicle damage due to collision with City vehicle 6/20/2023 8/7/2023 Risk Manager 8/10/2023 $ 2,804.83 Progressive ASO Breunig, Lia Vehicle damage due to collision with City vehicle 12/29/2022 6/15/2023 Risk Manager 8/8/2023 $ 1,111.18 Rubio, Fe Vehicle tow 5/1/2023 8/1/2023 Risk Manager 8/17/2023 $ 375.00 Hayward, Ryon Vehicle damage due to pothole 1/19/2023 8/1/2023 Risk Manager 8/8/2023 $ 544.75 Lucero, Stephen Vehicle damage due to broken City
fence 3/21/2023 7/31/2023 Risk Manager 8/15/2023 $ 5,575.22 NorCal Pool Construction Vehicle damage due to collision with City vehicle 3/22/2023 7/24/2023 Risk Manager 9/7/2023 $ 3,055.65 Yuan, Xiao Fence in City park fell on property 3/22/2023 8/31/2023 Risk Manager 9/7/2023 $ 3,277.24 Feng, Siying Vehicle damage due to pothole 3/30/2023 8/8/2023 Risk Manager 9/19/2023 $ 634.21 Mid-Century ASO Nathan Ghera Vehicle damage due to collision with City vehicle 7/18/2022 7/31/2023 Risk Manager 9/14/2023 $ 2,533.05 Geico ASO Audrey Harker Vehicle damage due to collision with City vehicle 4/27/2023 7/25/2023 Risk Manager 10/26/2023 $ 1,125.99 Burrows, Jeffrey Vehicle damage due to collision with
City vehicle 9/27/2023 10/30/2023 Risk Manager 11/7/2023 $ 2,997.93 Miller, Ronald Trip and fall on sidewalk tree grate 2/28/2023 11/16/2023 City Attorney 11/28/2023 $ 22,500.00 Willis, Clay Property damage due to tree roots 4/25/2023 7/25/2023 Risk Manager 1/9/2024 $ 2,500.00 Fowler, Scott Vehicle damage due to collision with
City vehicle 12/13/2023 1/11/2024 Risk Manager 1/30/2024 $ 4,867.28 CSAA ASO Mohammad Alam Vehicle damage due to collision with City vehicle 11/25/2022 5/7/2024 Risk Manager 3/19/2024 $ 1,122.61 Hayes, Debra Trip and fall on sidewalk 8/29/2023 1/9/2024 Risk Manager 3/26/2024 $ 4,000.00 Roccaforte, Francesca Trip and fall at dog park 8/10/2023 1/29/2024 Risk Manager 5/2/2024 $ 8,000.00 Garcia, Patricio Escalera City vehicle collided with claimant's vehicle 3/7/2024 4/17/2024 Risk Manager 4/30/2024 $ 3,457.22 Chen Jinying City vehicle collided with claimant's
vehicle 11/7/2023 5/6/2024 Risk Manager 5/14/2024 $ 12,703.00 1 of 7
Exhibit 1
July 1, 2023 through June 30, 2024 - LIABILITY CLAIMS SETTLEMENTS

CLAIMANT INCIDENT DESCRIPTION DATE OF LOSS SETTLEMENT

APPROVAL DATE APPROVED BY DATE OF

PAYMENT AMOUNT PAID
Chou, Austin Vehicle damage due to pothole 2/28/2024 4/18/2024 Risk Manager 5/2/2024 $ 323.89 Leber, Bonnie Property damage due to City tree
roots 3/20/2024 4/23/2024 Risk Manager 5/6/2024 $ 9,000.00 Nguyen, William City vehicle collided with claimant's
vehicle 10/8/2023 4/8/2024 Risk Manager 6/11/2024 $ 3,449.20 Tomlinson, Brian USAA and Haiati,
Zobair City vehicle collided with 2 vehicles 2/1/2024 5/14/2024 City Attorney 6/11/2024 $ 18,339.69 Levy, Alan Vehicle damage due to pothole 3/19/2024 5/14/2024 Risk Manager 6/6/2024 $ 348.26 Rodriguez, Douglas Vehicle damage due to pothole 4/29/2024 6/4/2024 Risk Manager 6/11/2024 $ 2,759.70 Nathan, Guy Sewer back up 2/16/2024 6/18/2024 Risk Manager 6/20/2024 $ 1,462.09 $ 149,687.76 CLAIMS TOTAL AMOUNT
2 of 7
July 1, 2023 through June 30, 2024 - LITIGATION SETTLEMENTS COURT CASE No. PLAINTIFF INCIDENT

DESCRIPTION

DATE OF
LOSS

SETTLEMENT

APPROVAL
DATE

APPROVED
BY

DATE OF

PAYMENT AMOUNT PAID
Alameda Superior Court 22CV012572 Kaneshiro, Dawn Sidewalk fall 12/17/2020 7/18/2023 City Council 8/3/2023 $ 92,500.00 Alameda Superior Court 23CV025580 Bloomfield, Carl Sidewalk fall 8/25/2022 8/29/2023 City Attorney 9/7/2023 $ 5,000.00 Alameda Superior Court 22CV011717 Espino, Rachel Sidewalk fall 7/6/2020 10/17/2023 City Attorney 11/30/2023 $ 10,000.00 Alameda Superior Court 22CV024994 Brennan, Grand Street Writ of mandate/Brown Act 8/1/2023 12/7/2023 City Attorney 12/7/2023 $ 22,500.00 *1 Alameda Superior Court 22CV016103 Gregory, Joan Sidewalk fall 8/12/2020 4/1/2024 City Attorney 4/11/2024 $ 25,000.00 Alameda Superior Court 23CV057563 Chen, Ernest Disputed invoices owed by ARPD 1/1/2022 5/14/2024 City Manager 5/23/2024 $ 9,483.72 Alameda Superior Court 22CV016617 Thomas #2 Sidewalk fall 10/18/2021 5/8/2024 City Attorney 6/13/2024 $ 5,000.00 Alameda Superior Court 22CV006600 Thomas #1 Sidewalk fall 3/15/2021 6/5/2024 City Attorney 6/27/2024 $ 65,000.00 Alameda Superior Court 22CV011264 Gatts, Donna Sidewalk fall 6/4/2021 4/5/2024 City Attorney 6/20/2024 $ 5,000.00 Federal District Court 21-CV-09733 Gonzalez, Estate of Mario Police Practices 5/25/2021 12/14/2023 CJPRMA Structured
Payments
over time
$11,000,000.00 *2
Federal District Court 22-CV-00718 Arenales, Edith Police Practices 5/25/2021 12/14/2023 CJPRMA 1/16/2024 $ 350,000.00 $ 11,589,483.72

1. $10,000 contributed by outside counsel

2. California Joint Powers Risk Management Authority (CJPRMA) is a Califoirnia Joint Powers Authority providing excess liability coverage for member agencies. The City of Alameda is a member agency of CJPRMA.

LITIGATION TOTAL AMOUNT
July 1, 2023 through June 30, 2024 - WORKERS' COMPENSATION SETTLEMENTS Claim Number Loss Date Injury Type Approved By Department Settlement Date Settlement Amount 1995500034 4/3/2019 Physical Injury City Attorney Police 7/21/2023 25,000.00$ 595500102 12/5/2005 Physical Injury City Attorney Police 7/21/2023 10,000.00$ 495500060 8/3/2004 Physical Injury City Attorney Police 7/21/2023 20,000.00$
95500030 3/12/2000 Physical Injury City Attorney Police 7/21/2023 20,000.00$
2095500007 01/25/2020 Physical Injury City Council Fire 08/25/2023 10,000.00$
2295500154 9/13/2022 Physical Injury City Council Fire 8/25/2023 60,000.00$
1695500080 10/8/2016 Physical Injury City Council Fire 8/25/2023 2,000.00$
1695500022 3/18/2016 Physical Injury City Council Fire 8/25/2023 8,920.00$
2095500145 12/5/2020 Physical Injury City Attorney Police 9/12/2023 14,560.00$
2095500046 4/4/2020 Physical Injury City Attorney Police 9/12/2023 8,770.00$
2295500013 5/5/2021 Physical Injury City Attorney Fire 9/18/2023 40,000.00$
2195500105 8/31/2021 Physical Injury City Attorney Fire 9/18/2023 17,999.50$
1995500055 6/19/2019 Physical Injury City Attorney Fire 9/18/2023 1,000.00$
4 OF 7
July 1, 2023 through June 30, 2024 - WORKERS' COMPENSATION SETTLEMENTS Claim Number Loss Date Injury Type Approved By Department Settlement Date Settlement Amount 1595500125 12/10/2015 Physical Injury City Attorney Fire 9/18/2023 15,000.00$
1295500057 8/31/2012 Physical Injury City Attorney Fire 9/18/2023 1,000.00$
2195500065 4/26/2021 Physical Injury City Attorney Police 9/20/2023 34,680.00$
2295500059 1/14/2022 Physical Injury City Attorney Fire 10/30/2023 23,955.00$
2195500046 3/15/2021 Physical Injury City Attorney Fire 10/30/2023 8,500.00$
2295500034 5/27/2021 Physical Injury City Attorney Fire 1/25/2024 25,480.19$
2195500048 3/17/2021 Physical Injury City Attorney Fire 1/25/2024 15,000.00$
1495500042 5/27/2014 Physical Injury City Attorney Fire 1/25/2024 5,000.00$
2095500147 12/15/2020 Physical Injury City Attorney Fire 2/26/2024 33,722.00$
1195500009 2/20/2011 Physical Injury City Attorney Fire 2/26/2024 6,905.00$
895500058 8/28/2008 Physical Injury City Attorney Fire 2/26/2024 500.00$
895500019 3/7/2008 Physical Injury City Attorney Fire 2/26/2024 500.00$
795500086 12/19/2007 Physical Injury City Attorney Fire 2/26/2024 1,000.00$
5 OF 7
July 1, 2023 through June 30, 2024 - WORKERS' COMPENSATION SETTLEMENTS Claim Number Loss Date Injury Type Approved By Department Settlement Date Settlement Amount 1595500007 2/1/2015 Physical Injury City Attorney Police 4/3/2024 7,000.00$
895500079 12/3/2008 Physical Injury City Attorney Police 4/3/2024 5,000.00$
9895500101 10/1/1998 Physical Injury City Attorney Police 4/3/2024 3,000.00$
2295500071 5/6/2022 Physical Injury Risk Manager Police 4/22/2024 1,740.00$
2295500074 4/13/2009 Physical Injury City Attorney Fire 5/21/2024 12,247.50$
2195500094 7/25/2021 Physical Injury City Attorney Fire 5/30/2024 35,000.00$
2095500028 3/3/2020 Physical Injury City Attorney Fire 5/30/2024 5,000.00$
2195500077 5/24/2021 Physical Injury Risk Manager Fire 6/21/2024 10,000.00$
1795500032 4/15/2017 Physical Injury Risk Manager Fire 6/21/2024 1,000.00$
1195500008 2/14/2011 Physical Injury Risk Manager Police 6/28/2024 5,000.00$
1095500055 9/3/2010 Physical Injury Risk Manager Police 6/28/2024 10,000.00$
WORKERS' COMPENSATION TOTAL AMOUNT 504,479.19$
6 OF 7
July 1, 2023 through June 30, 2024 - PERSONNEL SETTLEMENTS

DEPARTMENT DESCRIPTION PAYMENT DATE APPROVED BY TOTAL VALUE IT Department Employment Practices Settlement 5/16/2024 City Manager 50,000.00$ Public Works Department Employment Practices Settlement 6/27/2024 City Manager 10,000.00$ 60,000.00$ PERSONNEL MATTERS TOTAL AMOUNT

← All documents from this meeting