Apple Valley City Council
February 8, 2022

APPLE VALLEY TOWN COUNCIL
AGENDA

Tuesday, February 8, 2022, 6:30 p.m.

Council Chamber

PLEASE SILENCE CELL PHONES UPON ENTERING THE CHAMBER

FOR INDIVIDUALS NOT PHYSICALLY PRESENT AND STILL WISHING TO MAKE PUBLIC COMMENTS, YOU MAY COMMENT IN ONE OF TWO WAYS: 1) COMMENTS AND CONTACT INFORMATION CAN BE EMAILED TO [email protected] TO BE INCLUDED IN THE RECORD; 2) A REQUEST TO SPEAK CAN BE EMAILED TO THE SAME

ADDRESS AS ABOVE AND AT THE TIME OF THE REQUESTED AGENDA ITEM, THE TOWN

CLERK WILL PLACE A PHONE CALL TO THE COMMENTER AND ALLOW THEM TO SPEAK TO

THE COUNCIL VIA SPEAKER PHONE DURING THE LIVE MEETING FOR UP TO THREE MINUTES.

The meeting will occur in the Council Chamber located at 14955 Dale Evans Parkway in Apple Valley, California.

This is an agenda for the scheduled meeting of the Town of Apple Valley.

This agenda contains a brief description of each item of business to be considered at today’s meeting. In accordance with the Brown Act, this meeting agenda is posted at least 72 hours prior to the regularly scheduled meeting. The agenda, its supporting documents and all writings received by the Town Council related to these items are public records and available for review during regular business hours in the Town Clerk’s office in the Town Council Chamber. The agenda and its supporting documents, along with live and archived video of the meeting, can be viewed online at http://www.applevalley.org. However, the online agenda may not include all available supporting documents or the most current version of documents.

Materials related to an item on this agenda submitted to the Council after distribution of the agenda packet are available for public inspection in the Town Clerk’s Office at 14955 Dale Evans Parkway, Apple Valley, CA during normal business hours. Such documents are also available on the Town of Apple Valley website at www.applevalley.org subject to staff’s ability to post the documents before the meeting.

Items listed on the Consent Calendar are expected to be routine and non-controversial and, unless the Town Council directs that an item be held for further discussion, the entire Consent Calendar will be acted upon as the first item of business. If the Town Council directs that an item listed on the Consent Calendar be held for further discussion, the item will be addressed immediately after approval of the Consent Calendar.

In accordance with the Rules of Procedure, members of the public may address the Town Council on any item on the agenda and on any matter that is within the Town Council’s jurisdiction. To address the Town Council regarding an item, complete and submit the yellow card entitled Request to Speak.

Please indicate on the card whether you are speaking under Public Comments or on an item that is listed on the agenda and please list the item number.

When called, approach the podium and if desired, please state your name before giving your presentation. Speakers may address the Town Council for up to three (3) minutes. Speakers are to address the Town Council as a whole through the Presiding Officer. Comments to individual Council Members and/or staff are not permitted.

Individuals, who demonstrate disruptive conduct during Town Council meetings that prevent the Town Council from conducting its meeting in an orderly manner, are guilty of a misdemeanor as stated in PC403, disrupting a public meeting and are subject to removal from the chamber or arrest.

The Town of Apple Valley recognizes its obligation to provide equal access to those individuals with disabilities. Please contact the Town Clerk’s Office at (760) 240-7000 two working days prior to the scheduled meeting for any requests for reasonable accommodations.

Pages

1. Call to Order

2. Opening Ceremonies

2.1. Invocation
Pastor Whitney - Apple Valley Church of the Nazarene

2.2. Pledge of Allegiance

2.3. Presentations

2.3.1. Sydnie Harris, Finance Director - presentation on the recent changes made to CalPERS .

3. Public Comments

4. Councilmember Committee/Commission/Community Participation 7 Councilmembers to make brief reports on their participation on committees, boards, and commissions on the Town’s behalf since the last meeting.

Councilmembers may also make brief reports on their community participation.

No formal action will be taken.

5. Town Council Announcements

5.1. Suggested items for next Agenda

5.2. Time, Date & Place for Next Town Council Regular or Special Meeting A. Regular Meeting - February 22, 2022 - Council Chambers Regular Session at 6:30p.m.

6. Town Council Consent Agenda
Recommended Motion:

To approve the Consent Calendar items numbered 6.1-6.8 as recommended.

6.1. APPROVAL OF MINUTES 9
That the Town Council approve the subject minutes as part of the consent agenda.

6.2. JANUARY 2022 COMMERCIAL WARRANTS AND WIRE TRANSFER

SCHEDULES
14 That the Town Council receive, ratify, and file the Commercial Warrants and Wire Transfer Schedules as presented.

6.3. JANUARY 2022 PAYROLL/BENEFITS WARRANTS SCHEDULE 30 That the Town Council receive, ratify and file the payroll/benefits warrants as presented.

6.4. CONSENT TO ADVERTISE 2022 ROADWAY REPAIR PROJECT 32 That the Town Council review and approve the bid documents for the Resurfacing 2021 Gap Repair Project.

A.

That the Town Council authorize staff to solicit bids for construction of said project.

B.

6.5. ALL-WAY STOP AT THE INTERSECTION OF MESQUITE AND

OTTAWA ROAD
37 Adopt Resolution 2022-02, “A Resolution of the Town Council of the Town of Apple Valley establishing the intersection of Mesquite Road and Ottawa Road as an all-way STOP intersection.

6.6. ALL-WAY STOP AT THE INTERSECTION OF JOSHUA ROAD AND

SOUTH ROAD
60 Adopt Resolution 2022-03, “A Resolution of the Town Council of the Town of Apple Valley establishing the intersection of Joshua Road and South Road as an all-way STOP intersection.”

6.7. APPROVE RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING SUBMITTAL OF A CLAIM

AND REQUEST FOR REIMBURSEMENT TO SBCTA FOR TDA
ARTICLE 3 FUNDS
81 Adopt Resolution No. 2022-04 authorizing submittal of a claim to the San Bernardino County Transportation Authority (SBCTA) for the Transportation Development Act (TDA) Article 3 funds for the Bear Valley Road Bridge Connector Project.

6.8. ACCEPTANCE OF WORK FOR MENDEL PARK RESTROOM 85
Accept the work completed by TSR Construction Inc. for the Mendel Park Restroom. Total contract amount was $223,700.00 A.

Direct the Town Clerk to file the Notice of Completion for the contract work.

B.

Direct the Finance Director to release the retained funds 30 days after the Notice of Completion has been filed, provided no claims are filed against the contractor.

C.

7. Public Hearings

7.1. RESOLUTION 2022-05, TO RECORD DELINQUENT UTILITY FEES

AND COSTS AGAINST REAL PROPERTY LOCATED IN THE TOWN

OF APPLE VALLEY AND DIRECTING THAT SAID ASSESMENTS

CONSTITUTE A LIEN UPON SAID PROPERTIES
90 A. Open Public Hearing;
Adopt Resolution No. 2022-05, confirming delinquent utility fees and costs against real property located in the Town, and directing that said assessments constitute a lien upon said properties.

B.

C. Close Public Hearing.

7.2. URGANCY ORDINANCE ADDING A NEW SECTION 9.71.170 TO THE

TOWN OF APPLE VALLEY MUNICIPAL CODE RELATING TO URBAN
LOT SPLITS, ADDING A NEW SECTION 9.29.220 TO TOWN OF

APPLE VALLEY MUNICIPAL CODE RELATING TO TWO-UNIT

PROJECTS,
144

AND DETERMINING THE ORDINANCE IS EXEMPT FROM CEQA
Adopt an Urgency Ordinance Adding a New Section 9.71.170 to the Town of Apple Valley Municipal Code Relating to Urban Lot Splits, Adding a New Section 9.29.220 to the Town Of Apple Valley Municipal Code Relating to Two-Unit Projects, and Determining the Ordinance to be Exempt from CEQA.

7.3. FIRST PUBLIC HEARING FOR REDISTRICTING AND

CONSIDERATION OF ORDINANCE TO ESTABLISH SEPARATELY

ELECTED MAYOR AND ALLOW MAPS TO BE ADOPTED BY

RESOLUTION
168
Receive a report from staff and the Town’s redistricting consultant on the redistricting process and permissible criteria to be considered to redraw district boundaries; and
A.

Conduct a public hearing to receive public input on district boundaries; and if desired by the Town Council:

B.

Introduce, read by title only, and waive further reading of ORDINANCE NO.549 – AN ORDINANCE OF THE TOWN

COUNCIL OF THE TOWN OF APPLE VALLEY AMENDING
SECTION 2.04.140 AND ADDING SECTION 2.04.150 TO
CHAPTER 2.04 OF TITLE 2 OF THE TOWN OF APPLE
VALLEY MUNICIPAL CODE TRANSITIONING TO BYDISTRICT ELECTIONS FOR FOUR COUNCILMEMBERS AND

AN AT-LARGE MAYOR AND ALLOWING MAPS TO BE

ADOPTED BY RESOLUTION
C.

8. Business of the Council

8.1. VACANCY ON THE PARK AND RECREATION COMMISSION 180
Council Member Cusack to nominate: ____________ to the Town of Apple Valley Park and Recreation Commission.

9. Reports, Requests and Communications

10. Town Manager’s Comments & Legislative Update

11. Closed Session
Recommended Motion:

To Adjourn the regular meeting to move into Closed Session at TIME to discuss the following:

11.1. Closed Session 181
Conference with Legal Counsel – Anticipated Litigation – Significant exposure to litigation pursuant to Paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 54956.9: one or more potential cases.

A.

Conference with Legal Counsel – Anticipated Litigation – Initiation of litigation pursuant to Paragraph (4) of subdivision (d) of Section 54956.9: one or more potential cases.

B.

Conference with Real Property Negotiators – Pursuant to Government Code. Section 54956.8. Property: Apple Valley Ranchos Water Company (now Liberty Utilities (Apple Valley Ranchos Water) Corp.); Authority Negotiator: Town Manager; Negotiating Parties: Liberty Utilities Co., Liberty WWH, Inc., Algonquin Power & Utilities Corp., Park Water Company,
Western Water Holdings LLC, Tony Penna, General Manager, Apple Valley Ranchos Water Company; Under Negotiation:

Price and Terms of Payment.

C.

Conference with Legal Counsel – Existing Litigation – Pursuant to Paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) of Government Code
Section 54956.9, Case No.: CIVDS1600180 – Town of Apple Valley vs. Apple Valley Ranchos Water Company Et Al.

D.

12. Adjournment
Recommended Motion:

To adjourn the meeting of the Apple Valley Town Council at TIME.

TOWN OF APPLE VALLEY

TOWN COUNCIL SERVING ON BOARDS, COMMITTEES & COMMISSIONS H:\TOWNCLK\COMMITTEE\OUTBCC.DOC
Rev [2/1/2022]

CITIZEN ADVISORY COMMITTEES

HISTORICAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE (HAC)
Council Member Cusack
Meets every 3rd Thursday of each month at 2:00 p.m.,
(location may vary)

SPECIAL ADVISORY COMMITTEES
DISASTER PREPAREDNESS*
Mayor - Chairman
Meets quarterly at 1:30 p.m., Town of Apple Valley
Conference Center - Development Services Building
14975 Dale Evans Parkway, Apple Valley.

TRAFFIC ADVISORY COMMITTEE (TAC)
Council Member Nassif
As needed.

Town Council Chambers

TOWN PERSONNEL COMMITTEE
Council Member Nassif
Mayor Pro Tem Bishop
Meets as Needed

PARK AND RECREATION ADVISORY COMMITTEE
Council Member Nassif
Council Member Emick

AD HOC COMMITTEES

APPLE VALLEY ROAD AD HOC COMMITTEE
Council Member Nassif

VILLAGE MERCHANTS AD HOC COMMITTEE
Council Member Emick

AGENCY - BOARDS/COMMITTEES &

COMMISSIONS

CALIFORNIA JOINT POWERS INSURANCE

AUTHORITY (CJPIA)
Council Member Nassif – Director
Exec. Committee meets every 4th Wednesday of each
month at 7:00 p.m., La Palma, CA.

HIGH DESERT CORRIDOR JOINT POWERS

AUTHORITY (HDCJPA)
Council Member Nassif – Director
Council Member Emick – Alternate
Meets every 2nd Thursday of each quarter at 2:00 p.m.
385 N. Arrowhead Ave, San Bernardino, CA

LEAGUE OF CALIFORNIA CITIES/DESERT

MOUNTAIN DIVISION (LOCC/DMD)
Council Member Nassif- Voting Delegate
Mayor Pro Tem Bishop – Alternate
Meets quarterly on the 4th Friday of every other month
at 10:00 a.m., rotating cities.

MOJAVE DESERT AIR QUALITY MANAGEMENT

DISTRICT (MDAQMD)
Mayor Leon-– Delegate
Council Member Emick – Alternate
Meets every 4th Monday of each month at 10:00 a.m.,
14306 Park Avenue, Victorville

MOJAVE DESERT AND MOUNTAIN RECYCLING

AUTHORITY
Council Member Cusack – Delegate
Mayor Pro Tem Bishop – Alternate
Meets quarterly on the 2nd Thursday February, May,
August and November at 10:00 a.m.
at the Materials Recovery Facility, 17000 Abbey Lane,
Victorville

SAN BERNARDINO COUNCIL OF GOVERNMENTS
(SBCOG)
Mayor Pro Tem Bishop - Board Member
Council Member Cusack – Alternate
Meets 1st Wednesday of each month at 10:00 a.m.,
1170 West 3rd St.

San Bernardino

SOLID WASTE ADVISORY TASK FORCE (SWAT)
Council Member Cusack – Committee Member
Julie Ryan - Alternate
Meets as needed on Wednesdays at 1:30 p.m.

Sam J. Racadio Library & Environmental Learning
Center Community Room 7863 Central Ave. Highland

VICTOR VALLEY ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT

AUTHORITY (VVEDA)
(George Air Force Base Reuse Task Force)
Council Member Emick – Commissioner
Mayor Pro Tem Bishop – Alternate
Meets every 2nd Wednesday of each quarter at 5:00
p.m., SCLA

VICTOR VALLEY TRANSIT AUTHORITY (VVTA)
Council Member Emick – Representative
Mayor Leon - Alternate
Meets every 3rd Monday of each month at 9:30 a.m.,
Victorville City Hall

H:\TOWNCLK\COMMITTEE\OUTBCC.DOC
Rev [2/1/2022]

VICTOR VALLEY WASTE WATER RECLAMATION

AUTHORITY (VVWRA)
Council Member Nassif – Commissioner
Mayor Pro Tem Bishop – Alternate
Meets every 3rd Thursday at 7:30 a.m.

VVWRA Offices

APPLE VALLEY CHAMBER OF

COMMERCE

GOVERNMENTAL RELATIONS COMMITTEE
Mayor Pro Tem Bishop – Representative
Council Member Cusack – Alternate
*These Boards, Committees and
Commissions require the Mayor to serve
as the representative.

Town Council Agenda Report
Date: February 8, 2022
To: Honorable Mayor and Town Council
Subject: APPROVAL OF MINUTES

From: Douglas Robertson, Town Manager
Submitted by: La Vonda M-Pearson, Town Clerk
Town Clerk
Budgeted Item: Yes No N/A

RECOMMENDED ACTION
That the Town Council approve the subject minutes as part of the consent agenda.

SUMMARY:

A. Regular Meeting January 25, 2022

1 Apple Valley Town Council

MINUTES
January 25, 2022, 6:30 p.m.

Council Chamber
Members Present: Bishop
Cusack
Emick
Leon
Nassif
_____________________________________________________________________

1. Call to Order
Mayor Leon called to order the regular session of the Apple Valley Town Council at 6:30 p.m.

2. Opening Ceremonies

2.1 Invocation
None.

2.2 Pledge of Allegiance
The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Council Member Emick.

2.3 Presentations

2.3.1 Recognition of Public Safety Personnel

3. Public Comments
La Vonda M-Pearson, Town Clerk, announced that a public comment was received via email from Ms. Jean Bracy, Apple Valley. Ms. Bracy submitted comments regarding Agenda Item 6.2 regarding power general rates for Apple Valley Choice Energy. Ms. Bracy’s comments were distributed to the Town Council and available for review on the Apple Valley Town website.

Tom Piper, Apple Valley, questioned qualified immunity with the Sheriff's Department.

2 4. Councilmember Committee/Commission/Community Participation Councilmembers to make brief reports on their participation on committees, boards, and commissions on the Town’s behalf since the last meeting.

Councilmembers may also make brief reports on their community participation.

No formal action will be taken.

Council Member Emick commented on committee meetings and events that he attended.

Council Member Cusack commented on committee meetings and events that he attended.

Council Member Nassif commented on committee meetings and events that he attended.

Mayor Pro Tem Bishop commented on committee meetings and events that he attended.

Mayor Leon commented on committee meetings and events that she attended.

5. Town Council Announcements

5.1 Suggested items for next Agenda
Mayor Pro Tem Bishop, with the consensus of the Town Council recommended that a item be presented to discuss the impact of a proposed bill requiring homes to be electric.

5.2 Time, Date & Place for Next Town Council Regular or Special Meeting A. Regular Meeting - February 8, 2022 - Council Chambers Regular Session at 6:30 p.m.

6. Town Council Consent Agenda
Motion by: Council Member Emick
Seconded by: Council Member Cusack
To approve the Consent Calendar items numbered 6.1-6.3 as recommended.

Yes (5): Council Members Cusack, Emick, Nassif, Mayor Pro Tem Bishop, Mayor Leon.

Carried (5 to 0)

3 6.1 APPROVAL OF MINUTES
That the Town Council approve the subject minutes as part of the consent agenda.

6.2 ADOPT RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING TOWN MANAGER TO MAKE

CERTAIN ADJUSTMENTS TO POWER GENERATION RATES FOR

APPLE VALLEY CHOICE ENERGY
That the Town Council Adopt Resolution No. 2022-01 granting the Town Manager the power and authority to make certain minor adjustments to Apple Valley Choice Energy (AVCE) generation rates.

6.3 PURCHASE OF PAVEMENT MANAGEMENT UPDATE AND GIS

MAPPING SERVICES
That Council authorize the purchase of the Pavement Management Program (PMP) Update & GIS Mapping Services from Omnis, Inc., in the amount not to exceed $150,000.00, and authorize the Town Manager or designee to execute appropriate agreements and documentation.

7. Public Hearings

8. Business of the Council

9. Reports, Requests and Communications

10. Town Manager’s Comments & Legislative Update
Doug Robertson, Town Manager, announced the upcoming Mayors Weight Loss Challenge, and commented on the events that would be held promoting the event.

11. Closed Session
Mayor Leon announced that there was no need for Closed Session.

4 12. Adjournment
7:03 p.m.

Motion by: Mayor Leon
Seconded by: Council Member Bishop
To adjourn the meeting of the Apple Valley Town Council at 8:03 p.m.

Carried Unaminously
Kari Leon, Mayor La Vonda M-Pearson, Town Clerk

Town Council Agenda Report
Date: February 8, 2022
To: Honorable Mayor and Town Council
Subject: JANUARY 2022 COMMERCIAL WARRANTS AND WIRE TRANSFER

SCHEDULES

From: Douglas Robertson, Town Manager
Submitted by: Sydnie Harris, Director of Finance
Finance
Budgeted Item: Yes No N/A

RECOMMENDED ACTION
That the Town Council receive, ratify, and file the Commercial Warrants and Wire Transfer Schedules as presented.

BACKGROUND
Pursuant to the Town’s Municipal Code the attached demands were presented by the departments, audited by the Finance Department and subsequent warrants/wire transfers were issued. All were found to be in conformity to Town policies and procedures and funds were budgeted or available to pay said demands. List of commercial warrants and wire transfers are now being presented to Council for approval.

SUMMARY
Commercial warrants were issued from January 1 through January 31, 2022 in the amount of $5,031,085.58 covering issued warrant #’s 150256 – 150732. Also, wire transfers were made from January 1 through January 31, 2022 in the amount of $23,717.50.

The claims and/or demands covered by the attached list of warrants and wire transfers were audited as to the accuracy and availability of funds for payment thereof and said claims and/or demands are accurate, and the funds were available for payment thereof.

FISCAL IMPACT
478 Commercial Warrants were issued in the amount of $5,031,085.58 3 Wire Transfer payment was issued in the amount of $23,717.50

ATTACHMENTS
A. January Commerical Warrants
B. January Wire Transfer Schedule

Check # Date Vendor Description Check Total
150256 1/6/2022 007796 360 FREESTYLE GYMNASTICS DECEMBER 2021 GYMNASTICS 338.10 150257 1/6/2022 008201 ABF PRINTS, INC. AVCE POST CARDS 932.88 150258 1/6/2022 007948 ADVANTAGE COLORGRAPHICS REC BROCHURE 7,711.52 150259 1/6/2022 000102 ALBERTSONS LLC SUPPLIES 30.55
150260 1/6/2022 021342 AMAZON CAPITAL SERVICES SUPPLIES 719.55 150261 1/6/2022 021091 AMERICAN BUSINESS BANK 05-515802 POWELL ESCROW ACCOUNT 43,504.42 150262 1/6/2022 000140 ANIMAL CARE HOSPITAL SPAY VOUCHER 150.00 150263 1/6/2022 000142 ANIMAL EMERGENCY CLINIC EXAM 146.00 150264 1/6/2022 000143 APPLE VALLEY ANIMAL HOSPITAL SPAY/NEUTER VOUCHER 75.00 150265 1/6/2022 007981 APPLE VALLEY SMOG TEST ONLY SMOG TEST 350.00 150266 1/6/2022 005923 ASCAP PREVIOUS BALANCE 741.50
150267 1/6/2022 022565 AV COMMUNICATIONS RENTAL REFUND 250.00 150268 1/6/2022 000150 AVCOM SERVICES INC. PHONE TRANSACTIONS 231.80 150269 1/6/2022 000193 RICHARD BATTISTA GRAFFITI REMOVAL 660.00 150270 1/6/2022 002298 BEAR VALLEY ANIMAL HOSPITAL MISC CAT/DOG 1,103.50 150271 1/6/2022 003649 BECK OIL INC. FUEL 809.32
150272 1/6/2022 000272 CAPIO SOUSA WEBINAR 20.00
150273 1/6/2022 000914 CAPITAL ONE SUPPLIES- WALMART CREDIT 1868 585.31 150274 1/6/2022 000087 COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO ANIMAL SERVICES LIENS 1,037.00 150275 1/6/2022 001216 COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO- ISD RADIOS 2,773.38 150276 1/6/2022 002842 DOKKEN ENGINEERING SR18 AV RD DESIGN 91,126.38 150277 1/6/2022 REFUND RENTAL REFUND 250.00
150278 1/6/2022 000387 EDISON COMPANY 11/20/21 TO 12/20/21 5,018.11 150279 1/6/2022 022563 DEVON ENCINAS LOCK PICKS REIMBURSEMENT 46.33 150280 1/6/2022 000406 FARMER BROTHERS COFFEE COFFEE 374.94 150281 1/6/2022 000407 FEDEX SHPPING 119.73
150282 1/6/2022 009345 FEED MY SHEEP 2ND QUARTER REIMBURSEMENT 3,895.97 150283 1/6/2022 012826 FLYERS ENERGY, LLC PD FUEL 1,311.45 150284 1/6/2022 000897 FRONTIER COMMUNICATIONS 1/1/22 TO 1/31/22 2,456.03 150285 1/6/2022 000679 G.A. OSBORNE PIPE & SUPPLY PARTS 28.26 150286 1/6/2022 001558 HAAKER EQUIPMENT CO SWEEPER 1,076.72 150287 1/6/2022 CSMFO ANNUAL CONFERENCE REIMB CSMFO ANNUAL CONFERENCE REIMB 620.00 Town of Apple Valley
Commercial Warrants
Month of January 2022

150288 1/6/2022 000480 HI DESERT TROPHY & AWARDS LLC WRONG DATE FIX 772.13 150289 1/6/2022 000488 HIGH DESERT LASER GRAPHICS BADGES AND PLATES 122.70 150290 1/6/2022 000507 HOME DEPOT PARTS 536.60
150291 1/6/2022 021301 JASON CHAIDEZ LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE CONTRACT PW2021-01
14,703.20
150292 1/6/2022 021113 LAWSON PRODUCTS, INC. PARTS 64.73 150293 1/6/2022 000168 LIBERTY UTILITIES 10/19/21 TO 12/17/21 9,607.64 150294 1/6/2022 005351 LOWE'S (LAR) PARTS 108.42
150295 1/6/2022 015206 MDG ASSOCIATES INC HOME ADMIN NOVEMBER 6,205.38 150296 1/6/2022 006760 MERIDIAN URGENT CARE EXAMS 120.00 150297 1/6/2022 001190 MISSION UNIFORM SERVICE MATS 40.27 150298 1/6/2022 006275 MOJAVE DESERT & MOUNTAIN SEPTEMBER MRF 4,361.01 150299 1/6/2022 000639 MOJAVE DESERT AQMD DISEL IC ENGINE EMERGENCY GEN 712.24 150300 1/6/2022 008501 SANDRA MONDRAGON RENTAL REFUND 250.00 150301 1/6/2022 018836 MARIA MURO DECEMBER ZUMBA 13.65
150302 1/6/2022 002368 MWI ANIMAL HEALTH GALLIPRANT 171.33 150303 1/6/2022 010385 MELANIE MYERS DECEMBER ACTING 355.95 150304 1/6/2022 007673 MYONLINEBILL.COM DECEMBER ONLINE CC TRANSACTIONS 2,404.36 150305 1/6/2022 000654 NAPA AVGC PARTS 676.43
150306 1/6/2022 011959 NIEMELA PAPPAS & ASSOCIATES JANUARY 2022 SERVICES 3,000.00 150307 1/6/2022 002599 OFFICE DEPOT SUPPLIES 202.55
150308 1/6/2022 008206 O'REILLY AUTO PARTS PARTS 175.99 150309 1/6/2022 009804 PARSONS TRANSPORTATION GROUP SR18 & AV Rd Construction Management 76,291.34 150310 1/6/2022 REFUND DANCE RECITAL REFUND 10.00
150311 1/6/2022 008771 PRUDENTIAL OVERALL SUPPLY MATS 644.77 150312 1/6/2022 000729 R&R PRODUCTS PARTS 2,286.90
150313 1/6/2022 021425 HAILEY RICHLING DECEMBER TAP & BALLET 492.15 150314 1/6/2022 022564 KARLY RODDICK SPAY/NEUTER REFUND 40.00 150315 1/6/2022 011479 ROW TRAFFIC SAFETY, INC PARTS 581.53 150316 1/6/2022 000787 SAN BERNARDINO COUNTY SHERIFF'S

DEPARTMENT
LIVESCANS JUL-NOV 206.00
150317 1/6/2022 010082 SIERRA GOLF MANAGEMENT, INC AV COM SERVICES 64,288.68 150318 1/6/2022 018717 SPECTRUM DEC 15-JAN 14 22 6,313.96 150319 1/6/2022 000845 STERICYCLE SHREDDING 135.22
150320 1/6/2022 011688 STUDIO K 2022 CALENDARS 840.00
150321 1/6/2022 016857 SUPERCO SPECIALTY PRODUCTS MAGIC CHUMS CHERRY BERRY 1,039.73 150322 1/6/2022 001475 SHARI TAYLOR DECEMBER BATON 129.60 150323 1/6/2022 002658 TRI-STATE HOME IMPROVEMENT INC PERMIT REFUND 13533 BORDEAUX 90.82 150324 1/6/2022 000876 TYPE-SET-GO WINTER BASKETBALL JERSEYS 4,197.42 150325 1/6/2022 001758 UNITED SITE SERVICES INC. WEEKLY SERVICE 1,243.86

150326 1/6/2022 000890 CHRIS URMSTON DECEMBER TAI CHI 371.04 150327 1/6/2022 000166 VALLEYWIDE NEWSPAPERS LLC NOTICE OF FUNDING 350.00 150328 1/6/2022 001769 VERIZON WIRELESS PHONES 3,449.19 150329 1/6/2022 001278 VULCAN MATERIALS COLD MIX 205.36 150330 1/6/2022 003789 WILLDAN FINANCIAL SERVICES NOVEMBER SERVICES 1,450.00 150331 1/6/2022 013692 WPONCALL WEBSITE MAINTENANCE 300.00 150332 1/6/2022 020199 ONWARD ENGINEERING STODDARD WELLS RD 9,418.00 150333 1/6/2022 020216 POWELL CONSTRUCTION INC SR18 & AV RD 826,583.91 150334 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 14513 TEMECULA RD REFUND 36.80 150335 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 14573 CHOCO RD REFUND 64.00 150336 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 13250 IVANPAH RD REFUND 51.78 150337 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 18462 SYMERON RD REFUND 63.17 150338 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 21533 PINE RIDGE AVE REFUND 25.18 150339 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 10811 LANCELET AVE REFUND 54.55 150340 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 12953 CASCO RD REFUND 27.79 150341 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 19004 RAVEN ST REFUND 91.61 150342 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 12394 MACINTOSH ST REFUND 9.59 150343 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 19220 CHOLE RD REFUND 69.14 150344 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 14320 JICARILLA RD REFUND 56.51 150345 1/10/2022 VOID VOID 0.00
150346 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 12840 MAR VISTA DR REFUND 95.54 150347 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 11193 CAMDEN ST REFUND 38.10 150348 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 13584 KURENA RD REFUND 77.77 150349 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 13190 MUGU CT REFUND 94.56 150350 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 13497 SHAWNEE RD REFUND 53.14 150351 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 14320 JICARILLA RD REFUND 5.84 150352 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 19287 WILLOW DR REFUND 76.71 150353 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 23022 ST HWY 18 REFUND 62.76 150354 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 13215 PERIGNON PL REFUND 6.91 150355 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 21230 WALADI RD REFUND 7.35 150356 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 14620 KOKOMO RD REFUND 2,011.25 150357 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 14141 CUYAMACA RD REFUND 41.33 150358 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 10486 NOBLETON RD REFUND 2.46 150359 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 19128 PINE WAY REFUND 85.45 150360 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 14295 HAVASU RD REFUND 76.27 150361 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 16767 MESQUITE RD REFUND 105.09 150362 1/10/2022 VOID VOID 0.00
150363 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 15855 WYANDOT RD REFUND 258.69 150364 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 20071 SERRANO RD REFUND 61.62 150365 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 16130 CHIPPEWA RD REFUND 29.70

150366 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 21181 TEEPEE RD REFUND 36.96 150367 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 19931 YUCCA LOMA RD REFUND 1.49 150368 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 14643 HAVASU LANE REFUND 99.41 150369 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 21808 GOSHUTE AVE REFUND 48.33 150370 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 22717 MOTNOCAB RD REFUND 71.25 150371 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 19626 CASTLE HARBOR CT REFUND 1.86 150372 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 20510 SHOLIC RD REFUND 18.52 150373 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 22712 NALATAPA RD REFUND 48.12 150374 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 16275 KASOTA RD REFUND 32.31 150375 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 15855 WYANDOT RD REFUND 218.24 150376 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 10178 DARBY RD REFUND 97.95 150377 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 16340 CROWN VALLEY DR REFUND 100.36 150378 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 19977 HAIDA RD REFUND 18.94 150379 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 16443 MENAHKA RD REFUND 12.71 150380 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 10787 TUMBLEWEED RD REFUND 12.51 150381 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 15020 CHOCO RD REFUND 1.04 150382 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 19191 COCHISE CT REFUND 35.49 150383 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 10826 PHOENIX RD REFUND 59.65 150384 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 22838 POWHATAN RD REFUND 3.87 150385 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 15502 COMANCHE RD REFUND 32.47 150386 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 21485 OKANAGAN RD REFUND 9.08 150387 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 20522 ZUNI RD REFUND 51.62 150388 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 18570 KAMANA RD REFUND 30.48 150389 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 22258 LONE EAGLE RD REFUND 10.57 150390 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 10749 BRIDGE HAVEN RD REFUND 36.44 150391 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 20130 ONEIDA RD REFUND 62.49 150392 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 13502 CUYAMACA RD REFUND 40.48 150393 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 18826 SAHALE LANE REFUND 81.67 150394 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 12819 COVEY CT REFUND 49.76 150395 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 14963 CHOCTAW RD REFUND 52.15 150396 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 15316 BIG SKY RD REFUND 74.57 150397 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 19128 CEDAR DR REFUND 85.45 150398 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 19434 LYNBROOK RD REFUND 53.86 150399 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 16367 MUNI RD REFUND 178.34 150400 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 18740 MINGO RD REFUND 76.77 150401 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 19365 GALLOPING HILL RD REFUND 86.71 150402 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 22379 LITTLE BEAVER RD REFUND 44.45 150403 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 11231 DANDELION LANE REFUND 45.04 150404 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 22665 SOUTH RD REFUND 97.42 150405 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 21808 GOSHUTE AVE REFUND 355.19

150406 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 13206 WACO RD REFUND 3.96 150407 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 21184 MERLOT LANE REFUND 11.01 150408 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 15535 BROKEN BOW RD REFUND 1,284.97 150409 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 15514 WASHOAN RD REFUND 91.21 150410 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 19104 KAIBAB RD REFUND 89.11 150411 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 10652 LANIGAN RD REFUND 13.25 150412 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 10426 NOBLETON RD REFUND 85.38 150413 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 11408 RIVER RUN ST REFUND 62.72 150414 1/10/2022 TRASH REFUND 10661 GREEN VALLEY RD REFUND 108.70 150415 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 42.25
150416 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 330.46
150417 1/12/2022 000142 ANIMAL EMERGENCY CLINIC EXAMS 191.00 150418 1/12/2022 002363 ANIMAL HEALTH & SANITARY SUP. CLEANING PRODUCTS 848.30 150419 1/12/2022 000154 APPLE VALLEY COMMUNICATION INC LABOR 738.09 150420 1/12/2022 022592 APPLE VALLEY PORTABLES ADA HANDICAP PORTABLE 250.00 150421 1/12/2022 007981 APPLE VALLEY SMOG TEST ONLY SMOG 50.00 150422 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 16.40
150423 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 233.97
150424 1/12/2022 019613 AUS WEST LOCKBOX UNIFORMS 136.80 150425 1/12/2022 000150 AVCOM SERVICES INC. QUARTERLY ALARM MONITORING 1,305.00 150426 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 37.82
150427 1/12/2022 000192 BATTERY MART BATTERIES 45.77
150428 1/12/2022 000193 RICHARD BATTISTA GRAFFITI REMOVAL 660.00 150429 1/12/2022 002298 BEAR VALLEY ANIMAL HOSPITAL SPAY 1,732.75 150430 1/12/2022 003649 BECK OIL INC. FUEL 162.61
150431 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 89.75
150432 1/12/2022 000204 BIG APPLE AUTO VEHICLE REPAIR 10,825.00 150433 1/12/2022 022570 BLUE 360 MEDIA CA PENAL CODE 75.75 150434 1/12/2022 022593 BLUE DIAMOND MATERIALS COLD MIX 488.86 150435 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 37.54
150436 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 44.13
150437 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 44.38
150438 1/12/2022 000182 BURRTEC WASTE INDUSTRIES INC AS 706,567.49 150439 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 118.81
150440 1/12/2022 015315 CALPINE ENERGY SERVICES LP DECEMBER 2021 SERVICES 66,500.00 150441 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 85.38
150442 1/12/2022 021170 HEATHER CONLEY MILAGE REIMBURSEMENT 7/1/21 TO 12/23/21 287.04 150443 1/12/2022 017697 LISA M COOL NEM CASH OUT 50.05
150444 1/12/2022 000087 COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO CE LIENS 100.00 150445 1/12/2022 000777 COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO NOVEMBER SERVICES 162,253.22

150446 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 11.42
150447 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 15.25
150448 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 5.11
150449 1/12/2022 002842 DOKKEN ENGINEERING SR18 AV RD DESIGN 5,492.00 150450 1/12/2022 022500 LATRICE DONERSON REFUND ADOPTION 85.00 150451 1/12/2022 000387 EDISON COMPANY 12/7/21 TO 1/5/22 8,261.18 150452 1/12/2022 022569 ELEMENT ELECTRIC ENTERPRISES RRLP CONSTRUCTION #3 3,022.00 150453 1/12/2022 000406 FARMER BROTHERS COFFEE COFFEE FOR PD 312.30 150454 1/12/2022 004734 FAUST MEDIA SERVICES AV COMMONS SIGN 93.49 150455 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 10.79
150456 1/12/2022 014861 FIREMAN ROCK & NURSERY INC TOP SOIL 228.38 150457 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 58.93
150458 1/12/2022 022567 CHRISTINA FOILES REFUND FOR DANCE CLASS 31.00 150459 1/12/2022 022591 CHARITY OR MARVIN FRAZIER SPAY/NEUTER REFUND 40.00 150460 1/12/2022 022568 AMBER GOMEZ REFUND FOR DANCE CLASS 64.00 150461 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 72.19
150462 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 14.00
150463 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 33.21
150464 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 17.03
150465 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 49.59
150466 1/12/2022 000507 HOME DEPOT PARTS 103.19
150467 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 75.26
150468 1/12/2022 000520 IMPERIAL SPRINKLER SUPPLY PARTS 297.70 150469 1/12/2022 000524 INLAND FAIR HOUSING & 1ST QUARTER AUGUST 1,050.15 150470 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 58.65
150471 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 4.80
150472 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 7.45
150473 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 57.07
150474 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 120.77
150475 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 194.11
150476 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 27.01
150477 1/12/2022 006565 KONICA MINOLTA BUSINESS 11/25/21 TO 12/24/21 69.02 150478 1/12/2022 021345 KONICA MINOLTA PREMIER FINANCE COPIER 916.96 150479 1/12/2022 022590 RONALD KOTLER ADOPTION REFUND 85.00 150480 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 4.97
150481 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 139.50
150482 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 215.63
150483 1/12/2022 000168 LIBERTY UTILITIES 10/27/21 TO 12/28/21 34,694.68 150484 1/12/2022 005351 LOWE'S (LAR) PARTS 585.27
150485 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 109.74

150486 1/12/2022 022594 KARA MARIANA BOOTS REIMBURSEMENT 122.33 150487 1/12/2022 015365 MARIN CLEAN ENERGY (MCE) DECEMBER 2021 RA LA BASIN 13,437.50 150488 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 28.71
150489 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 242.72
150490 1/12/2022 006760 MERIDIAN URGENT CARE EXAMS 275.00 150491 1/12/2022 002239 MERRELL-JOHNSON ENGINEERING SURVEY 3,635.75 150492 1/12/2022 001190 MISSION UNIFORM SERVICE MATS 40.27 150493 1/12/2022 002368 MWI ANIMAL HEALTH MISC. ANIMAL SUPPLIES 7,678.57 150494 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 29.47
150495 1/12/2022 011959 NIEMELA PAPPAS & ASSOCIATES NOVEMBER 2021 SERVICES 3,000.00 150496 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 42.36
150497 1/12/2022 002599 OFFICE DEPOT SUPPLIES 169.77
150498 1/12/2022 008206 O'REILLY AUTO PARTS PARTS 33.29 150499 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 64.90
150500 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 87.53
150501 1/12/2022 000710 PRECISION LOCK & SAFE LOCKS 160.16 150502 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 22.84
150503 1/12/2022 008771 PRUDENTIAL OVERALL SUPPLY MATS 504.39 150504 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 78.42
150505 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 306.13
150506 1/12/2022 000062 RSG, INC FY 21-22 SUCCESSOR AGENCY 506.25 150507 1/12/2022 000779 SAN BERNARDINO COUNTY JAN 22-MAR 22 THIRD QUARTER 21,892.07 150508 1/12/2022 017745 MELINDA SCHAFFNER NEM CASH OUT 184.49 150509 1/12/2022 012491 SCMAF DECEMBER 2021 INSURANCES 161.95 150510 1/12/2022 010082 SIERRA GOLF MANAGEMENT, INC GOLFBACK & CLUB CADIE 6,740.75 150511 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 14.92
150512 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 42.37
150513 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 28.01
150514 1/12/2022 016857 SUPERCO SPECIALTY PRODUCTS MAGIC CHUMS 585.99 150515 1/12/2022 002422 SWRCB ACCOUNTING OFFICE HWY 18 AV RD 808.00 150516 1/12/2022 000171 TOWN OF APPLE VALLEY JAN SEWER SERVICES 3,040.62 150517 1/12/2022 002855 U.S. BANK CORP. PMT SYSTEM DECEMBER 2021 CAL CARD PURCHASES 15,507.10 150518 1/12/2022 000884 UNDERGROUND SERVICE ALERT- MONTHLY TICKETS 259.15 150519 1/12/2022 001758 UNITED SITE SERVICES INC. WEEKLY SERVICE 747.32 150520 1/12/2022 000893 V.V.W.R.A. 14681 RIVERSIDE DR 13,569.10 150521 1/12/2022 000909 VOYAGER DECEMBER FUEL 12,459.16 150522 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 28.46
150523 1/12/2022 008390 ZERO WASTE USA CAN LINERS 532.59 150524 1/12/2022 NEM CASH OUT NEM CASH OUT 26.16
150525 1/18/2022 TRASH REFUND 11982 PASCO RD REFUND 63.04

150526 1/18/2022 TRASH REFUND 12424 LAKOTA RD REFUND 26.09 150527 1/18/2022 TRASH REFUND 12394 MACINTOSH ST REFUND 17.13 150528 1/19/2022 008201 ABF PRINTS, INC. TOAV INVOICES 5,037.12 150529 1/19/2022 000126 AMERICAN COMPUTER SERVICE POSTAGE 9,391.29 150530 1/19/2022 001864 APPLE VALLEY TIRE VEHICLE REPAIR 735.00 150531 1/19/2022 021350 BURRTEC WASTE IND, INC. FOOD WASTE 459.85 150532 1/19/2022 000387 EDISON COMPANY 12/7/21 TO 1/5/22 1,520.74 150533 1/19/2022 003402 EL DORADO BROADCASTERS LLC MISC. ADS 1,110.00 150534 1/19/2022 004734 FAUST MEDIA SERVICES L. WEAST BUSINESS CARDS 8,219.18 150535 1/19/2022 000407 FEDEX SHIPPING 48.02
150536 1/19/2022 001558 HAAKER EQUIPMENT CO PARTS 495.78 150537 1/19/2022 000168 LIBERTY UTILITIES 10/28/21 to 12/29/21 3,875.03 150538 1/19/2022 002187 LINCOLN AQUATICS INSTALLATION OF POOL HEATERS AT THE

AQUATIC CENTER
91,845.53
150539 1/19/2022 001190 MISSION UNIFORM SERVICE MATS 44.33 150540 1/19/2022 000635 MOJAVE BASIN AREA WATERMASTER WELL WORK 225.02 150541 1/19/2022 006275 MOJAVE DESERT & MOUNTAIN MRF NOVEMBER 16,052.42 150542 1/19/2022 002599 OFFICE DEPOT SUPPLIES 82.63
150543 1/19/2022 CSMFO HOTEL REIMBURSEMENT CSMFO HOTEL REIMBURSEMENT 249.79 150544 1/19/2022 000710 PRECISION LOCK & SAFE KEYS 107.75 150545 1/19/2022 000841 STATE OF CALIFORNIA- D.O.J. FINGERPRINTS 200.00 150546 1/19/2022 022596 DESHAUN STONE REFUND FOR DOUBLE PAYMENT ON BUS. LIC. 54.00 150547 1/19/2022 017048 XPRESS SIGNS 2022 TOWN COUNCIL NAME CHANGE 250.00 150548 1/19/2022 VOID VOID 0.00
150549 1/19/2022 017165 UNITED STATES TREASURY 4TH QUARTER TAX RETURN 64.64 150550 1/27/2022 008201 ABF PRINTS, INC. AVCE POSTCARDS 1,210.04 150551 1/27/2022 000096 ADSCOT PEST CONTROL INC. AS PEST CONTROL 6,264.00 150552 1/27/2022 010143 AMERICAN FIDELITY ASSURANCE JANUARY 2022 PREMIUMS 6,242.68 150553 1/27/2022 000158 APPLE VALLEY FIRE PROTECTION FIRE DIF JUL 21 TO SEPT 21 19,115.88 150554 1/27/2022 008806 APPLE VALLEY PRINTING #10 ENVELOPES 797.35 150555 1/27/2022 001864 APPLE VALLEY TIRE VEHCILE REPAIR 195.88 150556 1/27/2022 000199 B B & K EMPLOYEE BENEFITS 33,817.40 150557 1/27/2022 000192 BATTERY MART BATTERIES 71.12
150558 1/27/2022 000193 RICHARD BATTISTA GRAFFITI REMOVAL 1,344.60 150559 1/27/2022 022598 BURRTEC WASTE INDUSTRIES, INC 20701 ST HWY 18 1,737.52 150560 1/27/2022 001247 MICHAEL CADY RETIREE HEALTH REIMBURSEMENT 271.88 150561 1/27/2022 000914 CAPITAL ONE SUPPLIES- WALMART CREDIT 1868 139.09 150562 1/27/2022 001347 CERTIFIED CREDIT REPORTING INC CREDIT CHECK 204.00 150563 1/27/2022 000088 CHARLES ABBOTT ASSOCIATES OCTOBER B & S SERVICES 199,287.75

150564 1/27/2022 008857 CHLIC-CHICAGO JANUARY 2022 PREMIUMS 1,480.14 150565 1/27/2022 020726 CHRIST THE SOLID ROCK 2ND QUARTER 2,000.00 150566 1/27/2022 RENTAL REFUND RENTAL REFUND 250.00
150567 1/27/2022 008693 COMMERCIAL AQUATIC SERVICES BULK C02 321.72 150568 1/27/2022 000777 COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO DECEMBER SERVICES 155,265.81 150569 1/27/2022 000330 DENNIS CRON RETIREE HEALTH REIMBURSEMENT 2,102.16 150570 1/27/2022 022495 PAMELA CUPP RETIREE HEALTH REIMBURSEMENT 961.70 150571 1/27/2022 012720 DEAN HOWARD HEAT & AIR INC. UNIT 10 MOTOR 2,415.00 150572 1/27/2022 020198 RONAK DESAI ACCOUNTING SUPPORT SERVICES 13,755.00 150573 1/27/2022 000184 DFM ASSOCIATES 2022 ELECTION CODE 64.35 150574 1/27/2022 022056 DIVERSIFIED UTILITY SERVICES OVERPAID PERMIT 45.00 150575 1/27/2022 002842 DOKKEN ENGINEERING SR18 AV RD DESIGN 101,443.88 150576 1/27/2022 000387 EDISON COMPANY 12/15/21 TO 1/13/22 38,715.81 150577 1/27/2022 008120 ENDURA STEEL PARTS 72.73
150578 1/27/2022 022280 ENVIROMINE, INC. LABOR 4,002.50 150579 1/27/2022 004734 FAUST MEDIA SERVICES UREDNA BUSINESS CARDS 832.14 150580 1/27/2022 014914 FERGUSON H&C #794 JAMES WOODY 108.10 150581 1/27/2022 011409 FIDELITY SECURITY LIFE INS / JANUARY 2022 PREMIUMS 871.20 150582 1/27/2022 014844 FISH WINDOW CLEANING PD 179.00
150583 1/27/2022 014300 PATRICK GEISEL 1/8-1/22/22 BASKETBALL GAMES 225.00 150584 1/27/2022 000822 GOLDEN STATE WATER COMPANY TUSSING RANCH RD 50.50 150585 1/27/2022 000452 GRAINGER, INC. PARTS 39.44
150586 1/27/2022 022597 GUY BURNETT STATE FARM INS. BUSINESS LICENSE LATE FEE REFUND 25.00 150587 1/27/2022 000466 HARBOR FREIGHT TOOLS PARTS 89.40 150588 1/27/2022 016944 GREGORY HARVEY 1/8-1/22/22 BASKETBALL GAMES 120.00 150589 1/27/2022 022601 MICHAEL HEREDIA 16422 KAMANA RD REFUND 6,149.00 150590 1/27/2022 000488 HIGH DESERT LASER GRAPHICS MCMILLAN BADGE 69.60 150591 1/27/2022 000501 HITT PLUMBING CO., INC. BACKFLOW LEAK 175.00 150592 1/27/2022 000524 INLAND FAIR HOUSING & NOVEMBER 2021 REIMBURSEMENT 2,449.32 150593 1/27/2022 014262 KIMBALL MIDWEST PARTS 309.63
150594 1/27/2022 007034 KONICA MINOLTA COPIERS 6,051.88 150595 1/27/2022 006565 KONICA MINOLTA BUSINESS 12/7/21 TO 1/6/22 27.27 150596 1/27/2022 022403 LORI LAMSON RETIREE HEALTH REIMBURSEMENT 915.41 150597 1/27/2022 016069 LEAD TECH ENVIRONMENTAL ASBESTOS TESTING 515.00 150598 1/27/2022 000168 LIBERTY UTILITIES 11/12/21 TO 1/12/22 13,622.46 150599 1/27/2022 002187 LINCOLN AQUATICS CREDIT 624.47
150600 1/27/2022 015061 LOS RANCHOS OFFICE SPACE RENT 776.99 150601 1/27/2022 005351 LOWE'S (LAR) PARTS 528.76
150602 1/27/2022 001708 KENNETH MARTIN RETIREE HEALTH REIMBURSEMENT 201.20 150603 1/27/2022 002622 TOM MCKEON RETIREE HEALTH REIMBURSEMENT 298.06

150604 1/27/2022 022602 GHOLWAN MECHAMMIL VALENTINAS CLEANERS 24,200.00 150605 1/27/2022 016065 MICHAEL BAKER INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL ZONE ANALYSIS 17,060.00 150606 1/27/2022 020574 CAROL MILLER RETIREE HEALTH REIMBURSEMENT 508.17 150607 1/27/2022 001499 LANCE MILLER RETIREE HEALTH REIMBURSEMENT 237.92 150608 1/27/2022 012371 MISSION COMMUNICATIONS INC ANNUAL SERVICES 4,068.27 150609 1/27/2022 001190 MISSION UNIFORM SERVICE MATS 165.14 150610 1/27/2022 006275 MOJAVE DESERT & MOUNTAIN 3RD QUARTER 16,456.00 150611 1/27/2022 018484 NEW YORK LIFE JANUARY 2022 PREMIUMS 985.40 150612 1/27/2022 002599 OFFICE DEPOT SUPPLIES 1,453.90
150613 1/27/2022 008206 O'REILLY AUTO PARTS PARTS 90.45 150614 1/27/2022 001798 PAR ELECTRICAL CONTRACTORS INC PERMIT REFUND 45.00 150615 1/27/2022 012232 AARON PARKER 1/8-1/15/22 BASKETBALL 150.00 150616 1/27/2022 009276 PARS 2021 NOVEMBER 459.47
150617 1/27/2022 000710 PRECISION LOCK & SAFE LOCKS 581.40 150618 1/27/2022 018332 PRINCIPAL JANUARY 2022 PREMIUMS 9,532.93 150619 1/27/2022 008771 PRUDENTIAL OVERALL SUPPLY MATS 1,266.79 150620 1/27/2022 005036 QUADIENT FINANCE USA, INC LATE FEE 46.02 150621 1/27/2022 011479 ROW TRAFFIC SAFETY, INC SIGNS 3,205.67 150622 1/27/2022 022600 S&T CONTRACTOR'S SERIVCES, INC JWCC WATER DAMAGES 10,000.00 150623 1/27/2022 016990 SALES & DISTRIBUTION SERVICES MATERIALS 985.60 150624 1/27/2022 000787 SAN BERNARDINO COUNTY SHERIFF'S

DEPARTMENT
JANUARY 2022 SERVICES 1,342,704.00
150625 1/27/2022 002055 SHRED-IT, C/O STERICYCLE, INC SHREDDING 135.22 150626 1/27/2022 010082 SIERRA GOLF MANAGEMENT, INC PPE 12-31-21 17,235.70 150627 1/27/2022 015313 SILVER VALLEY PROPANE PROPANE 96.60 150628 1/27/2022 022048 DAWN SIMMONS RETIREE HEALTH REIMBURSEMENT 502.94 150629 1/27/2022 000814 KEVIN SMITH RETIREE HEALTH REIMBURSEMENT 331.37 150630 44588 000825 SOUTHWEST GAS CORPORATION 12/8/21 TO 1/10/22 20,850.44 150631 44588 010275 SPARKLETTS WATER 62.04
150632 44588 004691 STAPLES SUPPLIES 132.27
150633 44588 022267 DIANNE SULZBERGER RETIREE HEALTH REIMBURSEMENT 474.28 150634 44588 002422 SWRCB ACCOUNTING OFFICE ANNUAL PERMIT FEE 26,498.00 150635 44588 022076 KAYLEB TABOR 1/8 TO 1/22/22 BASKETBALL GAMES 225.00 150636 44588 001332 TERRA NOVA PLANNING & RESEARCH NOVEMBER-DECEMBER 2021 79,473.24 150637 44588 011408 TEXAS LIFE INSURANCE CO. JANUARY 2022 PREMIUMS 1,214.75 150638 44588 022142 THE ALTUM GROUP Contract Planning Services 405.00 150639 44588 001958 THE CHURCH FOR WHOSOEVER RENTAL REFUND 250.00 150640 44588 021213 THE GREATER HIGH DESERT CARLOS MONTERREY LEADERSHIP 700.00 150641 44588 022599 TOXIC SOFTBALL RENTAL REFUND 250.00 150642 44588 009943 TSR CONSTRUCTION & INSPECTION MENDEL RESTROOM 7,315.00

150643 44588 001758 UNITED SITE SERVICES INC. WEEKLY SERVICE 548.29 150644 44588 000893 V.V.W.R.A. SEWAGE TREATMENT 309,846.57 150645 44588 000894 VALLEY SECURITY SYSTEMS INC MONITORING SYSTEM 32.00 150646 44588 000166 VALLEYWIDE NEWSPAPERS LLC CITY ORDINANCE 428.50 150647 44588 016743 RICHARD VARGAS 1/8 TO 1/22/22 BASKETBALL GAMES 135.00 150648 44588 000923 WAXIE SANITARY SUPPLY SUPPLIES 7,476.55 150649 44588 000945 JAMES WHITE RETIREE HEALTH REIMBURSEMENT 837.00 150650 44588 021348 WINSUPPLY PARTS 977.37
150651 44588 019749 WIRELESS TELEMATICS LLC PARTS 720.00 150652 44588 017048 XPRESS SIGNS PD LETTERING 225.00
150653 44588 001154 YUNEX TRAFFIC TRAFFIC SIGNAL MAINTENANCE 2,308.91 150654 44588 008788 ZURICH NORTH AMERICA JANUARY 2022 PREMIUMS 135.76 150655 44589 TRASH REFUND 13524 SEMINOLE RD REFUND 135.68 150656 44589 TRASH REFUND 16591 MONTAUK RD REFUND 389.20 150657 44589 TRASH REFUND 14652 TEMECULA RD REFUND 69.57 150658 44589 TRASH REFUND 19977 OTTAWA RD REFUND 46.42
150659 44589 TRASH REFUND 20330 TONAWANDA RD REFUND 13.50 150660 44589 TRASH REFUND 16036 TUDE RD REFUND 30.23
150661 44589 TRASH REFUND 22248 RAMONA AVE REFUND 105.53 150662 44589 TRASH REFUND 19021 ELM DR REFUND 120.98
150663 44589 TRASH REFUND 19474 VERMILLION LANE REFUND 547.88 150664 44589 TRASH REFUND 18890 WASECA RD REFUND 48.22
150665 44589 TRASH REFUND 19729 CHICORY CT REFUND 110.98 150666 44589 TRASH REFUND 12335 YORKSHIRE DR REFUND 53.56 150667 44589 TRASH REFUND 14712 TIGERTAIL RD REFUND 17.89 150668 44589 TRASH REFUND 14260 CHINOOK RD REFUND 30.14 150669 44589 TRASH REFUND 18324 WINNETKA RD REFUND 57.81 150670 44589 TRASH REFUND 20630-376 BEAR VALLEY RD REFUND 7.14 150671 44589 TRASH REFUND 16031 SAINT TIMOTHY RD REFUND 208.87 150672 44589 TRASH REFUND 20161 MAJESTIC DR REFUND 104.19 150673 44589 TRASH REFUND 16264 SAINT TIMOTHY RD REFUND 120.48 150674 44589 TRASH REFUND 19875 CHASKA RD REFUND 104.89 150675 44589 TRASH REFUND 15777 WANAQUE RD REFUND 221.59 150676 44589 TRASH REFUND 16260 MONACHE CT REFUND 124.43 150677 44589 TRASH REFUND 11030 KIOWA RD REFUND 50.24
150678 44589 TRASH REFUND 10029 REDSTONE RD REFUND 123.80 150679 44589 TRASH REFUND 22241 NISQUALLY RD REFUND 12.63 150680 44589 TRASH REFUND 19360 CARLISLE RD REFUND 215.20 150681 44589 TRASH REFUND 16343 RIDGE VIEW DR REFUND 393.65 150682 44589 TRASH REFUND 16330 OLALEE RD REFUND 120.47

150683 44589 TRASH REFUND 14148 PIONEER RD REFUND 17.68 150684 44589 TRASH REFUND 13060 ALGONQUIN RD REFUND 59.35 150685 44589 TRASH REFUND 11302 SAWGRASS BEND REFUND 109.30 150686 44589 TRASH REFUND 22241 NISQUALLY RD REFUND 54.58 150687 44589 TRASH REFUND 19782 CARLISLE RD REFUND 28.35 150688 44589 TRASH REFUND 15420 BROKEN BOW RD REFUND 132.73 150689 44589 TRASH REFUND 15006 TEMECULA RD REFUND 18.54 150690 44589 TRASH REFUND 12740 SORRELL DR REFUND 44.45 150691 44589 TRASH REFUND 22194 CHOLENA RD REFUND 84.17 150692 44589 TRASH REFUND 12360 TONOPAH CT REFUND 174.72 150693 44589 TRASH REFUND 19069 ELM DR REFUND 75.03
150694 44589 TRASH REFUND 11233 MERINO AVE REFUND 26.47 150695 44589 TRASH REFUND 14124 KIOWA RD REFUND 71.80
150696 44589 TRASH REFUND 19017 RAVEN ST REFUND 111.60
150697 44589 TRASH REFUND 19324 GALLOPING HILL RD REFUND 244.15 150698 44589 TRASH REFUND 16639 KASOTA RD REFUND 47.62
150699 44589 TRASH REFUND 13776 WAWONA RD REFUND 364.94 150700 44589 TRASH REFUND 14760 KEOTA RD REFUND 442.76
150701 44589 TRASH REFUND 13663 IVANPAH RD REFUND 113.32 150702 44589 TRASH REFUND 22027 RAMONA AVE REFUND 106.65 150703 44589 TRASH REFUND 13070 QUAPAW RD REFUND 30.36
150704 44589 TRASH REFUND 12895 QUAIL VISTA RD REFUND 45.91 150705 44589 TRASH REFUND 16409 SHENANDOAH RD REFUND 36.17 150706 44589 TRASH REFUND 16829 NEENACH RD REFUND 46.92 150707 44589 TRASH REFUND 21115 GERONIMO RD REFUND 48.58 150708 44589 TRASH REFUND 14961 TONIKAN RD REFUND 108.01 150709 44589 TRASH REFUND 19564 SAINT ANDREWS WAY REFUND 21.76 150710 44589 TRASH REFUND 15233 TUSCOLA RD REFUND 47.73 150711 44589 TRASH REFUND 19065 ELM DR REFUND 29.17
150712 44589 TRASH REFUND 13891 CRONESE RD REFUND 40.17 150713 44589 TRASH REFUND 19227 ELM DR REFUND 32.19
150714 44589 TRASH REFUND 20407 SAGO LANE REFUND 30.41
150715 44589 TRASH REFUND 15182 TEMECULA RD REFUND 37.57 150716 44589 TRASH REFUND 12557 SNAPPING TURTLE RD REFUND 26.78 150717 44589 TRASH REFUND 11145 LINDSAY LANE REFUND 69.68 150718 44589 TRASH REFUND 12719 POCOMOKE RD REFUND 24.78 150719 44589 TRASH REFUND 14350 BOCHEE RD REFUND 124.68 150720 44589 TRASH REFUND 21883 ISATIS AVE REFUND 103.51 150721 44589 TRASH REFUND 20399 HOHOKAM CT REFUND 14.50 150722 44589 TRASH REFUND 10233 DARBY RD REFUND 67.87

150723 44589 TRASH REFUND 16021 WICHITA RD REFUND 115.38 150724 44589 TRASH REFUND 15749 OLALEE RD REFUND 150.74 150725 44589 TRASH REFUND 16356 APPLE VALLEY RD REFUND 23.59 150726 44589 VOID VOID 0.00
150727 44589 TRASH REFUND 19502 CORWIN RD REFUND 206.69 150728 44589 TRASH REFUND 11306 SAWGRASS BEND REFUND 102.27 150729 44589 TRASH REFUND 14470 NAVAJO RD REFUND 127.34 150730 44589 TRASH REFUND 16576 PAWNEE RD REFUND 51.17
150731 44589 TRASH REFUND 19175 MONTEREY ST REFUND 153.41 150732 44589 TRASH REFUND 12750 BAY LANE REFUND 6.94
478 Checks Total amount of checks: 5,031,085.58

Wire Reference Date Beneficiary Name Description Wire Total 93052162 1/6/2022 US BANK 98-1 FEES $ 3,327.50
93052189 1/6/2022 US BANK 2020A FEES $ 3,250.00
23716947 01/24/20212 CA DEPT OF TAX ELECTRIC ENERGY TAX $ 17,140.00

TOWN OF APPLE VALLEY

WIRE TRANSFERS
MONTH OF JANUARY 2022

Town Council Agenda Report
Date: February 9, 2022
To: Honorable Mayor and Town Council
Subject: JANUARY 2021 PAYROLL/BENEFITS WARRANTS SCHEDULE

From: Douglas Robertson, Town Manager
Submitted by: Sydnie Harris, Director of Finance
Finance
Budgeted Item: Yes No N/A

RECOMMENDED ACTION
That the Town Council receive, ratify and file the payroll/benefits warrants as presented.

BACKGROUND
Per Section 3.16.040 through 3.18.030 were applicable: Every claim and demand for employee payments and benefits, upon approval by individual departments, was collected and audited for accuracy. Every claim was due and owing by the Town; Budgeted or otherwise appropriated funds are available to said claim; the claim contains the approval of other departments and officials as required.

SUMMARY
Pursuant to the Town’s Municipal Code, the register of demands shall be presented to the Town Council at the next regular meeting thereof after preparation. The Town Council may approve, conditionally or partially approve or reject such register of demands and in connection therewith consider the recommendations of the Town Manager and Director of Finance. Further, the State Government Code provides that Staff may process and pay prior to ratification by the Town Council, demands properly made in the ordinary course of business, the just obligations of the Town, such as routine salaries and wages, and other like expenditures for which there is an express budget appropriation, and in connection with which there is no dispute as to the obligation and amount being payable.

The Payroll / Benefits warrants issued from January 1 through January 31, 2022, in the amount of $542,778.08 net of voids, covering issued warrant #’s 67701-67752 and direct deposit advice #’s 9978073 – 9978335 are herewith submitted for approval.

FISCAL IMPACT

DATE TOTAL
01/07/2022 $284,551.71
01/21/2022 $258,226.37
TOTAL: $542,778.08
The payroll and benefit warrants issued, covering warrant #’s 67701 - 67752 and direct deposit advice #’s 9978073 – 9978335 inclusive, totaled $542,778.08. Sufficient funding is appropriated and available in such amounts necessary to cover the demands included herein.

Town Council Agenda Report
Date: February 8, 2022
To: Honorable Mayor and Town Council
Subject: CONSENT TO ADVERTISE 2022-ROADWAY REPAIR PROJECT From: Douglas Robertson, Town Manager
Submitted by: Brad Miller, Town Engineer
Engineering
Budgeted Item: Yes No N/A

RECOMMENDED ACTION
A. That the Town Council review and approve the bid documents for the Resurfacing 2021 Gap Repair Project.

B. That the Town Council authorize staff to solicit bids for construction of said project.

BACKGROUND
As part of the Town’s annual paving priorities, staff evaluated local roadways and determined priority areas in need of maintenance. To prepare for a larger future resurfacing project, staff identified segments with large gap locations that must be repaired prior to applying micro surface. The Project generally consists of providing necessary labor, equipment and materials for the removal of damaged asphalt in these areas and filling with new compacted asphalt.

ANALYSIS
Bid documents for the 2022-Roadway Repair project have been prepared and are ready for approval and advertisement of bids. Staff has reviewed the documents and is satisfied that they meet the intent of the Town Council for this project. The documents are available to the Town Council for review, approval, and authorization to proceed with advertisement of the project. Staff recommends that the Town Council review bid documents that are available in the Town Council Office, approve the documents, and direct staff to proceed with advertising for construction of the project.

FISCAL IMPACT

Funding for this project has been appropriated in the adopted FY 2021-2022 budget using Paving Priorities (2021-5210-9525-0000).

ATTACHMENTS
This is for attachments, if your report does not have attachments then delete this heading.

If you do have attachments please number them:

A. List of Segments
B. Project Area Map

List of Segments

STREET SEGMENT START SEGMENT END

SOUTH ROAD CENTRAL ROAD JOSHUA ROAD

PAUHASKA ROAD SOUTH ROAD CAHUILLA ROAD

HIGH VISTA ROAD PAUHASKA ROAD END (WEST)

HIGH VISTA ROAD PAUHASKA ROAD END (EAST)

PAUHASKA ROAD (WEST BULB) PAUHASKA ROAD END (NORTH)

PAUHASKA COURT PAUHASKA ROAD END (NORTH)

PAUHASKA PLACE PAUHASKA ROAD END (NORTH)

CUYAMA ROAD CENTRAL ROAD PAUHASKA ROAD

CUYAMA ROAD PAUHASKA ROAD TENAYA ROAD

CUYAMA WAY CUYAMA ROAD END (NORTH)

CUYAMA PLACE CUYAMA ROAD END (EAST)

LAKE SHORE COVE CUYAMA ROAD END (SOUTH)

CUYAMA ROAD (WEST BULB) CUYAMA ROAD END (NORTH)

LAKE VIEW LANE CUYAMA ROAD END (SOUTH)

CUYAMA COURT CUYAMA ROAD END (NORTH)

LAGO VISTA COURT CUYAMA ROAD END (SOUTH)

LAGO VISTA COURT CUYAMA ROAD END (NORTH)

LAGO VISTA LANE PAUHASKA ROAD END (WEST)

CAHUILLA ROAD CENTRAL ROAD OCCOTILLA ROAD

TENAYA ROAD SOUTH ROAD CAHUILLA ROAD

CUYAMA ROAD TENAYA ROAD OCCOTILLA ROAD

EL CENTRO ROAD NEENACH ROAD OCCOTILLA ROAD

OCCOTILLA ROAD SOUTH ROAD WAALEW ROAD

NAWAKWA ROAD SOUTH ROAD WAALEW ROAD

PAUHASKA ROAD EL CENTRO ROAD NAWAKWA ROAD

PAUHASKA ROAD NAWAKWA ROAD NEENACH ROAD

PAUHASKA COURT PAUHASKA ROAD END EAST

NEENACH ROAD SOUTH ROAD WAALEW ROAD

EL CENTRO ROAD CENTRAL ROAD NAWAKWA ROAD

EL CENTRO ROAD NAWAKWA ROAD NEENACH ROAD

EL CENTRO COURT EL CENTRO ROAD END SOUTH

NALATAPA ROAD NAWAKWA ROAD NEENACH ROAD

MOTNOCAB ROAD NAWAKWA ROAD PAUHASKA ROAD

WALPI ROAD CENTRAL ROAD WAALEW ROAD

OCCOTILLA ROAD CAHUILLA ROAD SOUTH ROAD

WAALEW ROAD JOSHUA ROAD (CL) CENTRAL ROAD (CL)

WAALEW ROAD CENTRAL ROAD (CL) NAVAJO ROAD (CL)

WAALEW ROAD NAVAJO ROAD CORWIN ROAD

THUNDERBIRD ROAD CENTRAL ROAD NAVAJO ROAD

THUNDERBIRD ROAD NAVAJO ROAD DALE EVANS PKWY
DALE EVANS PKWY. WAALEW ROAD CORWIN ROAD

Town of Apple Valley 2022-Roadway Repair (For Reference Only) Not to Scale

Town Council Agenda Report
Date: February 8, 2022
To: Honorable Mayor and Town Council
Subject: ALL-WAY STOP AT THE INTERSECTION OF MESQUITE ROAD AND

OTTAWA ROAD
From: Douglas Robertson, Town Manager
Submitted by: Brad Miller, Town Engineer
Engineering
Budgeted Item: Yes No N/A

RECOMMENDED ACTION
Adopt Resolution 2022-02, “A Resolution of the Town Council of the Town of Apple Valley establishing the intersection of Mesquite Road and Ottawa Road as an all-way STOP intersection.

BACKGROUND
As part of the Town Wide School Zone analysis, engineering staff requested the consultant, Michael Baker International, to evaluate the intersection of Mesquite Road and Ottawa Road to determine if it met the warrants for installation of all-way stop controls. The consultant evaluated speed limits, the collision history, traffic volumes, visibility, and other warrant chriteria at the intersection. Although traffic volumes and the collision history did not meet warrants, Michael Baker International does recommend that all-way stop controls be installed based on visibility and pedestrian generator(s).

Therefore, Engineering staff is recommending that the existing two-way stop controls at Mesquite Road and Ottawa Road be upgraded to an all-way stop.

ANALYSIS
Engineering staff supports the findings of the evaluation, and with Town Manager Robertson’s approval, are bringing the upgrade to an all-way stop at this intersection before Town Council for approval, and immediate implementation.

FISCAL IMPACT

Funding for this project is available in the Town Council approved 2021-2022 Capital Improvement Project Budget using Measure I funds (2021-5210-9203-0000). The total project cost, which includes signage, markings, and the recommended temporary flashing beacons, is $3,000.00.

ATTACHMENTS
A. Resolution 2022-02.

B. Engineering Analysis

Resolution 2022-02
RESOLUTION NO. 2022-02

A RESOLUTION OF THE TOWN COUNCIL OF THE TOWN

OF APPLE VALLEY ESTABLISHING THE INTERSECTION
OF MESQUITE ROAD AND OTTAWA ROAD AS A FOURWAY STOP INTERSECTION.

WHEREAS, a traffic engineering investigation has determined that establishing the intersection of Mesquite Road and Ottawa Road as an all-way STOP intersection is warranted in accordance with Section 52.0111 of the San Bernardino County Code as adopted by the Town of Apple Valley.

NOW THEREFORE, THE TOWN COUNCIL OF THE TOWN OF APPLE VALLEY DOES RESOLVE AND ORDER AS FOLLOWS:

Section 1: Approves and establishes the intersection of Mesquite Road and Ottawa Road as an all-way STOP intersection.

Section 2: Authorizes and directs the Town Manager to cause additional STOP signs to be placed on Mesquite Road and Ottawa Road.

APPROVED and ADOPTED by the Town Council of the Town of Apple Valley this 8 th day of February 2022.
________________________
MAYOR, Kari Leon
ATTESTED:
_________________________________
TOWN CLERK, La Vonda M-Pearson

January 24, 2022
TO: Richard Berger
Town of Apple Valley
FROM: Ryan Calad, PE, TE
Michael Baker International

MESQUITE ROAD AND OTTAWA ROAD

ALL-WAY STOP CONTROLS

RECOMMENDATIONS

1. Consider the installation of all-way stop controls at the intersection of Mesquite Road and Ottawa Road.

BACKGROUND
As requested, I reviewed the intersection of Mesquite Road and Ottawa Road with respect to the need for all-way stop controls and offer the following comments. This evaluation is done in conjunction with a school area traffic
control evaluation for Vanguard
Preparatory School.

DISCUSSION
Per the Town of Apple Valley
Circulation Element Street System
General Plan Exhibit II-6, Mesquite
Road is a Collector Road that runs
north-south, and in the area of the
school, has no posted speed limit
signs and does not meet the
requirements for 25 mph prima facie.

It is unstriped and is approximately 42 feet wide north of Ottawa Road and 32 feet wide south of the intersection. Mesquite Road has a 25 mph school speed zone in the vicinity of the school.

There are0 sidewalks only at the northeast and southeast corner of the intersection. It does not have any posted speed limit signs from south of Powhatan Road and north of Lucilla Road.

The vertical alignment in the immediate vicinity of both Mesquite Road in the area of Ottawa Road and Ottawa Road in the area of Mesquite Road is flat, and the horizontal alignment is straight. Fronting development is residential, with Vanguard Preparatory School on its south leg.

There are no traffic signals and all-way stop controls within 3,500 feet north and south of Ottawa Road. It forms a four-legged intersection with Ottawa Road and is controlled with stop signs and

“STOP” pavement markings on the north and south approaches. A yellow school ladder crosswalk is located on the north and south leg.

Mesquite Road does not have advance stop
warning signs and pavement markings north
and south of Ottawa Road.

Ottawa Road is classified as a major collector
roadway. It is unstriped and runs east-west.

There are sidewalks on the north side of the
roadway east of Mesquite Road. Fronting
development is residential, with Vanguard
Preparatory School located on the east side of
Mesquite Road, approximately 1,300 feet south
of Ottawa Road. There are yellow school ladder
crosswalks on the east leg only. The alignment
in the vicinity of the intersection is straight and
flat.

Volume and speed counts were taken at this
intersection on September 1-2, 2021 (attached).

Per the California Manual on Uniform Traffic
Control Devices (CA MUTCD) and industry
standards, all-way stop control analyses are to
be conducted using traffic volume data obtained
on a Tuesday, Wednesday or Thursday, which
are considered typical weekday volumes. Since the data obtained for either day would be acceptable, the total intersection volumes for
each day were compared and the highest total
intersection volume day (September 2, 2021)
was used for analysis. The data showed the
average of the eight highest hours on the main
street (Ottawa Road) approaches to the
intersection to be 204 vehicles per hour. The
average of the same eight highest hours on the
minor street (Mesquite Road) approaches to
the intersection was 122 vehicles per hour.

Speed data revealed an 85th percentile speed
of 47 mph.

Intersection vehicle and pedestrian volume counts were taken on September 2, 2021 during the morning school arrival period (7:00 – 9:00 am) and afternoon school dismissal period (2:00 – 4:00 pm). These counts revealed the following pedestrians crossing the three crosswalks:

South Approach – Looking East
South Approach – Looking West
North Approach – Looking West

North Crosswalk: 3 during the a.m.; 2 during the
p.m.

South Crosswalk: 3 during the a.m.; 2 during
the p.m.

East Crosswalk: 0 during the a.m.; 0 during the
p.m.

The west leg is not stop controlled and does not
have a crosswalk. During the morning arrival
period, 231 vehicles travelled through the
crosswalk, while the afternoon dismissal period
had 189 vehicles traveling through the
crosswalk.

A review of the available SWITRS data at this
intersection revealed the following reported
collisions since 2014:
• 10/13/16 – Rear End Collision, Property
Damage Only
• 11/02/16 – Broadside Collision,
Complaint of Pain
• 02/11/19 – Broadside Collision,
Complaint of Pain
• 01/14/20 – Broadside Collision,
Property Damage Only
See Appendix for the complete SWITRS data
for all collisions listed.

For the suggested speed limit of 45 mph on
Ottawa Road (based on the 85th percentile
speed of 47 mph), the stopping sight distance
per Table 201.1 of the California Highway
Design Manual is 360 feet.

Field measurements revealed that visibility for
the west approach of Ottawa Road looking
both north and south onto Mesquite Road
exceed the minimum stopping distance.

Visibility for the east approach looking north
and south onto Mesquite Road also exceeds
the minimum stopping distance. However,
visibility from the south approach of Mesquite Road looking east and west is obstructed by roadside vegetation, while on the north approach looking east and west is obstructed by a fence of a residential property. Vehicles need to creep forward into the crosswalk and the travelled way to eliminate the visibility restrictions.

North Approach – Looking East
Ottawa Road – West Approach
Ottawa Road – East Approach

The CA MUTCD provides guidance for the installation of all-way stop controls. It suggests that all-way stop controls may be considered when:
• Warrant A - Where traffic control signals are justified, the multi-way stop is an interim measure that can be installed quickly to control traffic while arrangements are being made for the installation of the traffic control signal. • Warrant B - There is a crash problem, as indicated by 5 or more reported crashes in a 12-month period that are susceptible to correction by all-way stop installation. Such crashes include right- and left-turn collisions as well as right-angle collisions. • Warrant C - Where the vehicular volume entering the intersection from the major street approaches (total of both approaches) averages at least 204 vehicles per hour for any 8 hours of an average day; and combined vehicular, pedestrian, and bicycle volume entering the intersection from the minor street approaches (total of both approaches) averages at least 122 units per hour for the same 8 hours, with an average delay to minor-street vehicular traffic of at least 30 seconds per vehicle during the highest hour.

When the 85th-percentile approach speed of the major-street traffic exceeds 40 mph, as it does at this intersection, the minimum vehicular volume warrants may be reduced to 70 percent of the above values. Therefore, the major street volume threshold is 210 vehicles per hour and the minor street threshold is 140 vehicles per hour. • Warrant D - Where none of the above Warrants are satisfied, but Warrants B and C are satisfied 80 percent. For this warrant, the 70 percent reduction for Warrant C cannot be applied.

The CA MUTCD also provides other criteria that may be considered, including:
• The need to control left-turn conflicts;
• The need to control vehicle/pedestrian conflicts near locations that generate high pedestrian volumes;
• Locations where a road user, after stopping, cannot see conflicting traffic and is not able to negotiate the intersection unless conflicting cross traffic is also required to stop; and,
• An intersection of two residential neighborhood collector (through) streets of similar design and operating characteristics where all-way stop control would improve traffic operational characteristics of the intersection.
• As indicated previously, the average 8-hour volume on Ottawa Road is 204 vehicles per hour and the average volume for the same 8 hours on Mesquite Road is 122 vehicles per hour. The major street volume is 87% satisfied in Warrant C while the minor street warrant is 28% satisfied. The main street/minor street volume split during the eight highest hours is approximately 76% vs. 24%. The reported collision history revealed a maximum of two (2) collisions within a 12-month period that could be correctable with all-way stop controls. Neither the volume nor crash thresholds are satisfied, however there is an identifiable crash pattern of westbound and eastbound vehicles hitting through vehicles on Ottawa Road.

Based on the above criteria, the collision and volume guidelines are not satisfied.

However, the following criteria listed above may be applicable to this location:

• The need to control vehicle/pedestrian conflicts near locations that generate high pedestrian volumes – Vanguard Preparatory School is located within approximately 1,300 feet of the intersection and there are marked school crosswalks on the north, south, and east legs. In addition, the school utilizes a crossing guard to assist pedestrians crossing the roadways. As indicated by the intersection vehicle and pedestrian counts, there are a substantial number of vehicles crossing the uncontrolled crosswalk on the west leg. This crossing provides access to the residential areas north and south of Ottawa Road. The above information suggests the potential for significant conflict between pedestrians and motorists. Furthermore, the speed of traffic on Ottawa Road limits the available gaps in traffic to allow pedestrians to reasonably cross the roadway.
• Locations where a road user, after stopping, cannot see conflicting traffic and is not able to negotiate the intersection unless conflicting cross traffic is also required to stop –Visibility for motorists on the east and west approach of Ottawa Road viewing traffic approaching from north and south on Mesquite Road is limited based on the 360’ stopping sight distance due to roadside vegetation. This visibility restriction can create conflict for motorists attempting to enter or cross Ottawa Road.

The conflict is increase by the need for motorists to be aware of the potential for pedestrian crossings within the marked school crosswalks.

SIGNAGE AND PAVEMENT MARKINGS
As discussed, the intersection of Mesquite Road and Ottawa Road is two-way stop controlled for the north bound and south bound Mesquite Road legs and has yellow ladder crosswalks on the north, south, and east legs. Adjacent to the crosswalks at the intersection of Mesquite Road and Ottawa Road are two Assembly B, SW24-2 signs. These are facing opposite directions and are there to alert motorists of the location of the pedestrian crossing. • Findings: Per CA MUTCD, Assembly B shall be posted at all yellow and white school crosswalks that are not controlled by a STOP (R1-1) sign, a YIELD (R1-2) sign, or a traffic signal. The “SLOW SCHOOL XING” pavement markings east and west at the intersection of Mesquite Road and Ottawa Road are in unsatisfactory condition and should be restriped. But the current visibility issues at Mesquite Road and recent circulation changes of the school with the pick-up/drop-off circulation does trigger volume warrant thresholds for an all-way stop. As such, this intersection location should be updated accordingly with the removal of Assembly B signage and “SLOW SCHOOL XING” pavement markings. As well as, the installation of “STOP” control signs (R1-1) and pavement markings for the Ottawa Road intersection east and west leg approaches. Per the CA MUTCD 2C.06, an installation of “STOP AHEAD” warning signs (W3-1) and pavement markings 175 feet from the Ottawa Road intersection east and west of the stop bar for east bound and west bound traffic is also recommended.

CONCLUSION
The traffic volumes and reported crash history at this location do not satisfy CA MUTCD warrants for the installation of all-way stop controls. However, two of the additional criteria (pedestrian volume generators and visibility) may justify all-way stop controls. In addition, there

is an identifiable pattern of Complaint of Pain and PDO collisions that would be expected to be correctable with all-way stop controls. Based on this information, it is recommended that all-way stop control installation be considered at the intersection of Mesquite Road and Ottawa Road with the removal of Assembly B signage and “SLOW SCHOOL XING” pavement markings and the installation of “STOP” control signs, “STOP AHEAD” warning signs, and their corresponding pavement markings. The concurrent Vanguard Preparatory School traffic control evaluation contains recommendations that would be affected by the outcome of this report.

JR: Mesquite Rd at Ottawa Rd All-Way Stop Control Analysis Attach.

Sincerely,

Ryan Calad, PE, TE
Project Manager

Topock
Ct
Desert Rd
e
T
a
n
y
a
R
d
Deerwood Rd
Apple Blossom Ln
Applewood Rd
OjaiRd
Patomac Rd
Joshua Rd
Franceska Rd
Setancket Rd
Pueblo Rd
Lucilla Rd
i
N
o
c
a
l
R
d
Topock Rd
ShoshoneanRd
Sitting Bull Rd
NisquallyRd
Candlewood Rd
Matawan Rd
Eyota Rd
Mesquite Rd
Ottawa Rd
SLOW
SCHOOL
XING
pavement
markings
SLOW
SCHOOL
XING
pavement
markings
Attachment A
Existing School Traffic Controls
Vanguard Preparatory School
Existing Two-Way
Stop-Control on
Mesquite Rd.

Existing One-Way
Stop-Control on
Lucilla Rd.

Existing yellow
ladder crosswalks
on north, east,
and south legs
Existing One-Way
Stop-Control on
Nisqually Rd.

Existing
yellow
crosswalks
on north
and east
legs
N
Legend
School Boundary
SLOW
SCHOOL
XING
pavement
markings
SLOW
SCHOOL
XING
pavement
markings
Speed Limit (mph)
Mesquite Road: Not Posted
Ottawa Road: Not Posted Page 46 of 181
Lucilla Road: 25 (Prima Facie - Residential)
Topock
Ct
Desert Rd
e
T
a
n
y
a
R
d
Deerwood Rd
Apple Blossom Ln
Applewood Rd
OjaiRd
Patomac Rd
Joshua Rd
Franceska Rd
Setancket Rd
Pueblo Rd
Lucilla Rd
i
N
o
c
a
l
R
d
Topock Rd
ShoshoneanRd
Sitting Bull Rd
NisquallyRd
Candlewood Rd
Matawan Rd
Eyota Rd
Mesquite Rd
Ottawa Rd
SLOW
SCHOOL
XING
pavement
markings
SLOW
SCHOOL
XING
pavement
markings
Attachment B
All-Way Stop Controls
Vanguard Preparatory School
Existing Two-Way
Stop-Control on
Mesquite Rd.

Existing One-Way
Stop-Control on
Lucilla Rd.

Existing yellow ladder
crosswalks on north,
east, and south legs
Existing One-Way
Stop-Control on
Nisqually Rd.

Existing
yellow
crosswalks
on north
and east
legs
N
Legend
School Boundary
Speed Limit (mph)
Mesquite Road: Not Posted
Ottawa Road: Not Posted
Lucilla Road: 25 (Prima Facie - Residential)
Remove existing
SLOW
SCHOOL
XING
pavement markings
Install new all-way "STOP" control with
new STOP Signs (R1-1) and markings
for Ottawa Road intersection east and
west leg approaches.

Remove
existing
SLOW
SCHOOL
XING
pavement
markings
Install new all-way "STOP"
control with new STOP
Signs (R1-1) and markings
for Ottawa Road
intersection east and west
leg approaches.

Remove existing Assembly B sign
on the south side of Ottawa Rd.,
approximately 60' from Mesquite
Rd., facing EB traffic
Remove existing Assembly
B sign on the north side of
Ottawa Rd., approximately
60' from Mesquite Rd.,
facing WB traffic
Install "STOP AHEAD" pavement markings 175'
west of the intersection of Ottawa Road and
Mesquite Road, facing EB traffic
Install W3-1 sign adjacent to the "STOP AHEAD"
pavement markings 175' west of the intersection's
new stop bar, facing EB traffic
Install "STOP AHEAD" pavement markings 175'
east of the intersection of Ottawa Road and
Mesquite Road, facing WB traffic
Install W3-1 sign adjacent to the "STOP AHEAD"
pavement markings 175' west of the intersection's
new stop bar, facing WB traffic

File Name : 02_APV_Mesquite_Ottawa AM
Site Code : 12221450
Start Date : 9/2/2021
Page No : 1
City of Apple Valley
N/S: Mesquite Road
E/W: Ottawa Road
Weather: Clear
Groups Printed- Total Volume
Mesquite Road
Southbound
Ottawa Road
Westbound
Mesquite Road
Northbound
Ottawa Road
Eastbound
Start Time Left Thru Right App. Total Left Thru Right App. Total Left Thru Right App. Total Left Thru Right App. Total Int. Total 07:00 AM 3 2 0 5 0 9 16 25 3 2 0 5 0 9 16 25 60
07:15 AM 8 6 1 15 1 4 24 29 8 6 1 15 1 4 24 29 88
07:30 AM 28 55 0 83 5 8 67 80 29 54 0 83 5 8 68 81 327
07:45 AM 38 48 3 89 1 6 54 61 38 48 3 89 1 6 54 61 300
Total 77 111 4 192 7 27 161 195 78 110 4 192 7 27 162 196 775 08:00 AM 9 6 1 16 0 7 3 10 9 6 1 16 0 7 3 10 52
08:15 AM 3 4 1 8 0 8 1 9 3 4 1 8 0 8 1 9 34
08:30 AM 5 2 0 7 2 3 2 7 5 2 0 7 2 3 2 7 28
08:45 AM 2 5 1 8 1 6 2 9 2 5 1 8 1 6 2 9 34
Total 19 17 3 39 3 24 8 35 19 17 3 39 3 24 8 35 148
Grand Total 96 128 7 231 10 51 169 230 97 127 7 231 10 51 170 231 923 Apprch % 41.6 55.4 3 4.3 22.2 73.5 42 55 3 4.3 22.1 73.6 Total % 10.4 13.9 0.8 25 1.1 5.5 18.3 24.9 10.5 13.8 0.8 25 1.1 5.5 18.4 25 Mesquite Road
Southbound
Ottawa Road
Westbound
Mesquite Road
Northbound
Ottawa Road
Eastbound
Start Time Left Thru Right App. Total Left Thru Right App. Total Left Thru Right App. Total Left Thru Right App. Total Int. Total Peak Hour Analysis From 07:00 AM to 08:45 AM - Peak 1 of 1 Peak Hour for Entire Intersection Begins at 07:00 AM
07:00 AM 3 2 0 5 0 9 16 25 3 2 0 5 0 9 16 25 60
07:15 AM 8 6 1 15 1 4 24 29 8 6 1 15 1 4 24 29 88
07:30 AM 28 55 0 83 5 8 67 80 29 54 0 83 5 8 68 81 327
07:45 AM 38 48 3 89 1 6 54 61 38 48 3 89 1 6 54 61 300
Total Volume 77 111 4 192 7 27 161 195 78 110 4 192 7 27 162 196 775 % App. Total 40.1 57.8 2.1 3.6 13.8 82.6 40.6 57.3 2.1 3.6 13.8 82.7 PHF .507 .505 .333 .539 .350 .750 .601 .609 .513 .509 .333 .539 .350 .750 .596 .605 .593 Counts Unlimited, Inc.

PO Box 1178
Corona, CA 92878
(951)268-6268

File Name : 02_APV_Mesquite_Ottawa AM
Site Code : 12221450
Start Date : 9/2/2021
Page No : 2
City of Apple Valley
N/S: Mesquite Road
E/W: Ottawa Road
Weather: Clear
Mesquite Road
Ottawa Road
Ottawa Road
Mesquite Road
Right
4 Thru
111
Left
77 Out In Total
278 192 470
Right
161
Thru
27 Left
7 Out Total In
108 195 303
Left
78 Thru
110
Right
4 Out In Total
280 192 472
Left
7 Thru
27 Right
162
Total Out In
109 196 305
Peak Hour Begins at 07:00 AM
Total Volume
Peak Hour Data
North
Peak Hour Analysis From 07:00 AM to 08:45 AM - Peak 1 of 1 Peak Hour for Each Approach Begins at:
07:15 AM 07:00 AM 07:15 AM 07:00 AM
+0 mins. 8 6 1 15 0 9 16 25 8 6 1 15 0 9 16 25
+15 mins. 28 55 0 83 1 4 24 29 29 54 0 83 1 4 24 29
+30 mins. 38 48 3 89 5 8 67 80 38 48 3 89 5 8 68 81
+45 mins. 9 6 1 16 1 6 54 61 9 6 1 16 1 6 54 61
Total Volume 83 115 5 203 7 27 161 195 84 114 5 203 7 27 162 196 % App. Total 40.9 56.7 2.5 3.6 13.8 82.6 41.4 56.2 2.5 3.6 13.8 82.7 PHF .546 .523 .417 .570 .350 .750 .601 .609 .553 .528 .417 .570 .350 .750 .596 .605 Counts Unlimited, Inc.

PO Box 1178
Corona, CA 92878
(951)268-6268

File Name : 02_APV_Mesquite_Ottawa PM
Site Code : 12221450
Start Date : 9/2/2021
Page No : 1
City of Apple Valley
N/S: Mesquite Road
E/W: Ottawa Road
Weather: Clear
Groups Printed- Total Volume
Mesquite Road
Southbound
Ottawa Road
Westbound
Mesquite Road
Northbound
Ottawa Road
Eastbound
Start Time Left Thru Right App. Total Left Thru Right App. Total Left Thru Right App. Total Left Thru Right App. Total Int. Total 12:00 PM 2 1 0 3 1 7 2 10 2 1 0 3 1 6 2 9 25
12:15 PM 6 5 0 11 1 3 3 7 6 5 0 11 1 3 3 7 36
12:30 PM 1 2 0 3 1 12 4 17 1 2 0 3 1 12 4 17 40
12:45 PM 5 2 0 7 5 9 3 17 6 2 0 8 5 9 3 17 49
Total 14 10 0 24 8 31 12 51 15 10 0 25 8 30 12 50 150
01:00 PM 2 5 0 7 0 8 0 8 2 5 0 7 0 8 0 8 30
01:15 PM 3 0 0 3 2 8 3 13 2 0 0 2 3 8 3 14 32
01:30 PM 1 2 0 3 1 2 9 12 1 2 0 3 1 2 9 12 30
01:45 PM 4 1 1 6 3 9 14 26 4 1 1 6 3 9 14 26 64
Total 10 8 1 19 6 27 26 59 9 8 1 18 7 27 26 60 156
02:00 PM 3 2 0 5 2 12 19 33 2 2 0 4 2 12 20 34 76
02:15 PM 1 2 2 5 1 14 10 25 1 3 2 6 1 14 10 25 61
02:30 PM 24 39 1 64 25 13 18 56 24 36 1 61 25 13 18 56 237 02:45 PM 23 25 0 48 2 11 3 16 23 26 0 49 2 11 3 16 129
Total 51 68 3 122 30 50 50 130 50 67 3 120 30 50 51 131 503 03:00 PM 5 17 0 22 4 6 5 15 5 17 0 22 4 6 5 15 74
03:15 PM 3 4 1 8 2 11 3 16 3 4 1 8 2 11 3 16 48
03:30 PM 6 6 1 13 3 12 2 17 6 7 1 14 3 11 2 16 60
03:45 PM 2 3 0 5 2 8 1 11 2 3 0 5 2 8 1 11 32
Total 16 30 2 48 11 37 11 59 16 31 2 49 11 36 11 58 214 04:00 PM 2 2 0 4 3 17 3 23 2 2 0 4 3 17 3 23 54
04:15 PM 3 5 1 9 3 8 5 16 3 5 1 9 3 8 5 16 50
04:30 PM 5 4 0 9 2 14 1 17 5 4 0 9 2 14 1 17 52
04:45 PM 1 2 1 4 1 11 5 17 1 2 1 4 1 11 5 17 42
Total 11 13 2 26 9 50 14 73 11 13 2 26 9 50 14 73 198
05:00 PM 2 3 0 5 5 13 0 18 2 3 0 5 5 13 0 18 46
05:15 PM 1 4 0 5 0 14 1 15 1 4 0 5 0 14 1 15 40
05:30 PM 2 2 0 4 1 7 3 11 2 2 0 4 1 6 3 10 29
05:45 PM 1 2 1 4 1 11 2 14 1 2 1 4 1 12 2 15 37
Total 6 11 1 18 7 45 6 58 6 11 1 18 7 45 6 58 152
Grand Total 108 140 9 257 71 240 119 430 107 140 9 256 72 238 120 430 1373 Apprch % 42 54.5 3.5 16.5 55.8 27.7 41.8 54.7 3.5 16.7 55.3 27.9 Total % 7.9 10.2 0.7 18.7 5.2 17.5 8.7 31.3 7.8 10.2 0.7 18.6 5.2 17.3 8.7 31.3 Counts Unlimited, Inc.

PO Box 1178
Corona, CA 92878
(951)268-6268

File Name : 02_APV_Mesquite_Ottawa PM
Site Code : 12221450
Start Date : 9/2/2021
Page No : 2
City of Apple Valley
N/S: Mesquite Road
E/W: Ottawa Road
Weather: Clear
Mesquite Road
Southbound
Ottawa Road
Westbound
Mesquite Road
Northbound
Ottawa Road
Eastbound
Start Time Left Thru Right App. Total Left Thru Right App. Total Left Thru Right App. Total Left Thru Right App. Total Int. Total Peak Hour Analysis From 12:00 PM to 05:45 PM - Peak 1 of 1 Peak Hour for Entire Intersection Begins at 02:00 PM
02:00 PM 3 2 0 5 2 12 19 33 2 2 0 4 2 12 20 34 76
02:15 PM 1 2 2 5 1 14 10 25 1 3 2 6 1 14 10 25 61
02:30 PM 24 39 1 64 25 13 18 56 24 36 1 61 25 13 18 56 237 02:45 PM 23 25 0 48 2 11 3 16 23 26 0 49 2 11 3 16 129
Total Volume 51 68 3 122 30 50 50 130 50 67 3 120 30 50 51 131 503 % App. Total 41.8 55.7 2.5 23.1 38.5 38.5 41.7 55.8 2.5 22.9 38.2 38.9 PHF .531 .436 .375 .477 .300 .893 .658 .580 .521 .465 .375 .492 .300 .893 .638 .585 .531 Mesquite Road
Ottawa Road
Ottawa Road
Mesquite Road
Right
3 Thru
68 Left
51 Out In Total
147 122 269
Right
50 Thru
50 Left
30 Out Total In
104 130 234
Left
50 Thru
67 Right
3 Out In Total
149 120 269
Left
30 Thru
50 Right
51 Total Out In
103 131 234
Peak Hour Begins at 02:00 PM
Total Volume
Peak Hour Data
North
Counts Unlimited, Inc.

PO Box 1178
Corona, CA 92878
(951)268-6268

File Name : 02_APV_Mesquite_Ottawa PM
Site Code : 12221450
Start Date : 9/2/2021
Page No : 3
City of Apple Valley
N/S: Mesquite Road
E/W: Ottawa Road
Weather: Clear
Mesquite Road
Southbound
Ottawa Road
Westbound
Mesquite Road
Northbound
Ottawa Road
Eastbound
Start Time Left Thru Right App. Total Left Thru Right App. Total Left Thru Right App. Total Left Thru Right App. Total Int. Total Peak Hour Analysis From 12:00 PM to 05:45 PM - Peak 1 of 1 Peak Hour for Each Approach Begins at:
02:30 PM 01:45 PM 02:30 PM 01:45 PM
+0 mins. 24 39 1 64 3 9 14 26 24 36 1 61 3 9 14 26
+15 mins. 23 25 0 48 2 12 19 33 23 26 0 49 2 12 20 34
+30 mins. 5 17 0 22 1 14 10 25 5 17 0 22 1 14 10 25
+45 mins. 3 4 1 8 25 13 18 56 3 4 1 8 25 13 18 56
Total Volume 55 85 2 142 31 48 61 140 55 83 2 140 31 48 62 141 % App. Total 38.7 59.9 1.4 22.1 34.3 43.6 39.3 59.3 1.4 22 34 44 PHF .573 .545 .500 .555 .310 .857 .803 .625 .573 .576 .500 .574 .310 .857 .775 .629 Mesquite Road
Ottawa Road
Ottawa Road
Mesquite Road
Right
2 Thru
85 Left
55 In - Peak Hour: 02:30 PM
142
Right
61 Thru
48 Left
31 In - Peak Hour: 01:45 PM
140
Left
55 Thru
83 Right
2 In - Peak Hour: 02:30 PM
140
Left
31 Thru
48 Right
62 In - Peak Hour: 01:45 PM
141
Total Volume
Peak Hour Data
North
Counts Unlimited, Inc.

PO Box 1178
Corona, CA 92878
(951)268-6268

Location: Date: 9/2/2021
N/S: Day: Thursday
E/W:

North Leg East Leg South Leg West Leg
Mesquite Road Ottawa Road Mesquite Road Ottawa Road
Pedestrians Pedestrians Pedestrians Pedestrians
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
3030 6
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
3 0 3 06
North Leg East Leg South Leg West Leg
Mesquite Road Ottawa Road Mesquite Road Ottawa Road
Pedestrians Pedestrians Pedestrians Pedestrians
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
0101 2
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
1010 2
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
1010 2
0000 0
0000 0
2020 4
1010 2
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
5 1 5 1 12
4:45 PM
5:00 PM
5:15 PM
5:30 PM
3:30 PM
3:45 PM
4:00 PM
4:15 PM
4:30 PM
Apple Valley
Mesquite Road
Ottawa Road

PEDESTRIANS
7:00 AM
7:15 AM
7:30 AM
7:45 AM
TOTAL VOLUMES:
8:00 AM
8:15 AM
8:30 AM
8:45 AM
1:15 PM
1:30 PM
5:45 PM
TOTAL VOLUMES:
12:00 PM
12:15 PM
12:30 PM
12:45 PM
1:00 PM
1:45 PM
2:00 PM
2:15 PM
2:30 PM
2:45 PM
3:00 PM
3:15 PM
Counts Unlimited, Inc.

PO Box 1178
Corona, CA 92878 Page 53 of 181 951‐268‐6268
Location: Date: 9/2/2021
N/S: Day: Thursday
E/W:

Left Thru Right Left Thru Right Left Thru Right Left Thru Right 000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
Left Thru Right Left Thru Right Left Thru Right Left Thru Right 000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
4:00 PM
4:15 PM
4:30 PM
4:45 PM
5:00 PM
Ottawa Road
Mesquite Road
Apple Valley

BICYCLES
7:30 AM
7:00 AM
7:15 AM
Eastbound
TOTAL VOLUMES:
12:00 PM
12:15 PM
12:30 PM
12:45 PM
1:00 PM
5:15 PM
7:45 AM
8:00 AM
8:15 AM
8:30 AM
8:45 AM
Southbound Westbound Northbound
5:30 PM
5:45 PM
Mesquite Road Ottawa Road Mesquite Road
1:15 PM
1:30 PM
1:45 PM
2:00 PM
2:15 PM
2:30 PM
2:45 PM
3:00 PM
3:15 PM
3:30 PM
3:45 PM
Ottawa Road
TOTAL VOLUMES:

Mesquite Road Ottawa Road Mesquite Road Ottawa Road
Southbound Westbound Northbound Eastbound
Counts Unlimited, Inc.

PO Box 1178
Corona, CA 92878 Page 54 of 181 951‐268‐6268

Town of Apple Valley
N/S: Mesquite Road
E/W: Ottawa Road
48 Hour Entering Volume Count
APV001EW
Site Code: 122-21450
Counts Unlimited, Inc.

PO Box 1178
Corona, CA 92878
Phone: (951) 268-6268
email: [email protected]
Start 01-Sep-21 Eastbound Hour Totals Westbound Hour Totals Combined Totals Time Wed Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon 12:00 1 14 0 10
12:15 2 27 0 12
12:30 2 20 0 12
12:45 0 35 5 96 0 9 0 43 5 139
01:00 1 29 0 11
01:15 1 45 0 47
01:30 0 11 0 9
01:45 0 10 2 95 0 7 0 74 2 169
02:00 0 11 4 5
02:15 0 12 1 4
02:30 1 7 1 2
02:45 0 16 1 46 1 6 7 17 8 63
03:00 1 15 2 6
03:15 0 11 0 2
03:30 0 16 2 10
03:45 0 12 1 54 2 11 6 29 7 83
04:00 0 20 0 9
04:15 0 15 1 6
04:30 0 16 2 9
04:45 1 15 1 66 2 7 5 31 6 97
05:00 0 18 2 7
05:15 2 18 4 9
05:30 0 10 4 9
05:45 2 12 4 58 6 8 16 33 20 91
06:00 2 8 3 17
06:15 6 15 7 7
06:30 10 11 17 10
06:45 15 11 33 45 10 8 37 42 70 87
07:00 18 12 6 4
07:15 36 10 11 8
07:30 72 7 23 5
07:45 58 13 184 42 23 3 63 20 247 62
08:00 12 11 7 6
08:15 11 10 5 2
08:30 5 12 6 4
08:45 12 8 40 41 12 1 30 13 70 54
09:00 6 6 9 6
09:15 5 4 5 1
09:30 3 6 10 5
09:45 6 6 20 22 9 2 33 14 53 36
10:00 4 5 7 1
10:15 8 2 5 1
10:30 7 0 11 4
10:45 7 4 26 11 8 1 31 7 57 18
11:00 5 1 3 1
11:15 6 3 6 1
11:30 8 1 5 0
11:45 11 0 30 5 8 0 22 2 52 7
Total 347 581 347 581 250 325 250 325 597 906
Combined
Total 928 928 575 575 1503
AM Peak - 07:00 - - - 07:15 - - - - -
Vol. - 184 - - - 64 - - - - -
P.H.F. 0.639 0.696
PM Peak - - 00:30 - - - 00:30 - - - -
Vol. - - 129 - - - 79 - - - -
P.H.F. 0.717 0.420
Percentag
e

37.4% 62.6% 43.5% 56.5%

Town of Apple Valley
N/S: Mesquite Road
E/W: Ottawa Road
48 Hour Entering Volume Count
APV001EW
Site Code: 122-21450
Counts Unlimited, Inc.

PO Box 1178
Corona, CA 92878
Phone: (951) 268-6268
email: [email protected]
Start 02-Sep-21 Eastbound Hour Totals Westbound Hour Totals Combined Totals Time Thu Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon 12:00 2 9 2 10
12:15 1 7 1 7
12:30 0 17 0 17
12:45 0 17 3 50 0 17 3 51 6 101
01:00 1 8 1 8
01:15 2 14 2 13
01:30 1 12 1 12
01:45 1 26 5 60 1 26 5 59 10 119
02:00 0 34 0 33
02:15 0 25 0 25
02:30 0 56 0 56
02:45 0 16 0 131 0 16 0 130 0 261
03:00 0 15 0 15
03:15 0 16 0 16
03:30 0 16 0 17
03:45 0 11 0 58 0 11 0 59 0 117
04:00 0 23 0 23
04:15 0 16 0 16
04:30 1 17 0 17
04:45 0 17 1 73 0 17 0 73 1 146
05:00 1 18 1 18
05:15 0 15 0 15
05:30 1 10 1 11
05:45 3 15 5 58 4 14 6 58 11 116
06:00 2 9 2 9
06:15 4 8 4 8
06:30 12 15 12 15
06:45 6 8 24 40 6 8 24 40 48 80
07:00 25 6 25 6
07:15 29 7 29 7
07:30 81 13 80 13
07:45 61 8 196 34 61 8 195 34 391 68
08:00 10 12 10 12
08:15 9 11 9 11
08:30 7 9 7 9
08:45 9 2 35 34 9 2 35 34 70 68
09:00 11 4 11 4
09:15 10 8 10 7
09:30 2 5 2 5
09:45 4 6 27 23 4 6 27 22 54 45
10:00 6 3 6 3
10:15 9 1 9 1
10:30 4 2 4 2
10:45 11 6 30 12 11 5 30 11 60 23
11:00 10 2 10 2
11:15 11 0 11 0
11:30 3 0 3 0
11:45 5 0 29 2 5 0 29 2 58 4
Total 355 575 355 575 354 573 354 573 709 1148
Combined
Total 930 930 927 927 1857
AM Peak - 07:00 - - - 07:00 - - - - -
Vol. - 196 - - - 195 - - - - -
P.H.F. 0.605 0.609
PM Peak - - 01:45 - - - 01:45 - - - -
Vol. - - 141 - - - 140 - - - -
P.H.F. 0.629 0.625
Percentag
e

38.2% 61.8% 38.2% 61.8%
ADT/AADT ADT 1,680 AADT 1,680

Town of Apple Valley
N/S: Mesquite Road
E/W: Ottawa Road
48 Hour Entering Volume Count
APV001NS
Site Code: 122-21450
Counts Unlimited, Inc.

PO Box 1178
Corona, CA 92878
Phone: (951) 268-6268
email: [email protected]
Start 01-Sep-21 Northbound Hour Totals Southbound Hour Totals Combined Totals Time Wed Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon 12:00 0 2 0 3
12:15 0 6 0 7
12:30 0 7 0 17
12:45 1 7 1 22 0 22 0 49 1 71
01:00 0 8 0 21
01:15 1 74 1 4
01:30 0 14 0 3
01:45 0 10 1 106 2 3 3 31 4 137
02:00 0 3 1 5
02:15 0 4 0 2
02:30 1 6 1 5
02:45 0 13 1 26 1 2 3 14 4 40
03:00 0 19 0 8
03:15 0 9 0 6
03:30 1 7 0 0
03:45 1 9 2 44 1 2 1 16 3 60
04:00 2 5 1 6
04:15 0 8 0 3
04:30 1 6 0 2
04:45 1 5 4 24 0 3 1 14 5 38
05:00 0 4 1 5
05:15 4 6 1 9
05:30 0 3 0 2
05:45 0 4 4 17 1 5 3 21 7 38
06:00 3 1 0 5
06:15 1 2 2 0
06:30 7 5 1 3
06:45 4 3 15 11 8 2 11 10 26 21
07:00 4 0 7 3
07:15 10 5 15 4
07:30 71 5 31 3
07:45 91 0 176 10 25 8 78 18 254 28
08:00 19 4 4 2
08:15 9 4 3 6
08:30 10 0 4 3
08:45 2 1 40 9 2 2 13 13 53 22
09:00 4 1 5 0
09:15 1 1 4 1
09:30 5 1 1 1
09:45 1 1 11 4 1 1 11 3 22 7
10:00 3 0 2 1
10:15 4 1 1 1
10:30 6 0 2 1
10:45 4 0 17 1 2 0 7 3 24 4
11:00 4 2 1 1
11:15 5 0 3 0
11:30 5 0 3 0
11:45 4 0 18 2 7 0 14 1 32 3
Total 290 276 290 276 145 193 145 193 435 469
Combined
Total 566 566 338 338 904
AM Peak - 07:15 - - - 07:00 - - - - -
Vol. - 191 - - - 78 - - - - -
P.H.F. 0.525 0.629
PM Peak - - 01:00 - - - 00:15 - - - -
Vol. - - 106 - - - 67 - - - -
P.H.F. 0.358 0.761
Percentag
e

51.2% 48.8% 42.9% 57.1%

Town of Apple Valley
N/S: Mesquite Road
E/W: Ottawa Road
48 Hour Entering Volume Count
APV001NS
Site Code: 122-21450
Counts Unlimited, Inc.

PO Box 1178
Corona, CA 92878
Phone: (951) 268-6268
email: [email protected]
Start 02-Sep-21 Northbound Hour Totals Southbound Hour Totals Combined Totals Time Thu Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon 12:00 2 3 2 3
12:15 0 11 0 11
12:30 0 3 0 3
12:45 0 8 2 25 0 7 2 24 4 49
01:00 0 7 0 7
01:15 0 2 0 3
01:30 0 3 0 3
01:45 0 6 0 18 0 6 0 19 0 37
02:00 1 4 1 5
02:15 1 6 1 5
02:30 0 61 0 64
02:45 0 49 2 120 0 48 2 122 4 242
03:00 0 22 0 22
03:15 0 8 0 8
03:30 0 14 0 13
03:45 0 5 0 49 0 5 0 48 0 97
04:00 0 4 0 4
04:15 0 9 0 9
04:30 1 9 0 9
04:45 0 4 1 26 1 4 1 26 2 52
05:00 1 5 1 5
05:15 1 5 1 5
05:30 1 4 1 4
05:45 0 4 3 18 0 4 3 18 6 36
06:00 2 7 2 7
06:15 1 3 1 3
06:30 4 6 4 6
06:45 6 4 13 20 6 4 13 20 26 40
07:00 5 0 5 0
07:15 15 1 15 1
07:30 83 0 83 0
07:45 89 1 192 2 89 1 192 2 384 4
08:00 16 1 16 1
08:15 8 2 8 2
08:30 7 2 7 1
08:45 8 2 39 7 8 2 39 6 78 13
09:00 5 1 5 1
09:15 2 3 2 3
09:30 5 2 5 2
09:45 5 2 17 8 5 2 17 8 34 16
10:00 4 1 4 1
10:15 3 1 3 1
10:30 6 0 6 0
10:45 5 0 18 2 5 0 18 2 36 4
11:00 5 1 5 0
11:15 6 0 6 0
11:30 4 0 4 0
11:45 5 2 20 3 5 2 20 2 40 5
Total 307 298 307 298 307 297 307 297 614 595
Combined
Total 605 605 604 604 1209
AM Peak - 07:15 - - - 07:15 - - - - -
Vol. - 203 - - - 203 - - - - -
P.H.F. 0.570 0.570
PM Peak - - 02:30 - - - 02:30 - - - -
Vol. - - 140 - - - 142 - - - -
P.H.F. 0.574 0.555
Percentag
e

50.7% 49.3% 50.8% 49.2%
ADT/AADT ADT 1,056 AADT 1,056

CASE_ID ACCIDENT_YEAR PROC_DATEJURIS COLLISION_DATE COLLISION_TIME DAY_OF_WEEK CHP_SHIFT POPULATIONCNTY_CITY_LOC CHP_BEAT_CLASS BET_NUMBER PRIMARY_RDSECONDARY_RD DISTANCE DIRECTION INTERSECTIONWEATHER_1WEATHER_2STATE_HWY_IND TOW_AWAYCOLLISION_SEVERITY NUMBER_KILLED NUMBER_INJURED PARTY_COUNT PRIMARY_COLL_FACTOR PCF_CODE_OF_VIOL PCF_VIOL_CATEGORY PCF_VIOLATION PCF_VIOL_SUBSECTION HIT_AND_RUNTYPE_OF_COLLISION MVIW PED_ACTIONROAD_SURFACE ROAD_COND_1 ROAD_COND_2 6753293 2014 20160629 3600 20141211 1803 4 5 5 3621 0 AP2 JOSHUA RDSOUTH RD 0 Y A - N 0 0 0 2 A - 9 21802 A N D C A A H - 6833948 2015 20150806 3600 20150123 1810 5 5 5 3621 0 AP2 SOUTH RD JOSHUA RD 0 Y A - N Y 0 0 0 2 A - - N D C A A H - 8282826 2016 20170124 3600 20161213 1727 2 5 5 3621 0 AP2 SOUTH RD JOSHUA RD 0 Y A - N N 0 0 0 2 A - 9 21802 A N D C A A H - 8871207 2019 20190613 3600 20190523 1746 4 5 5 3621 0 AP2 SOUTH RD JOSHUA RD 0 Y A - N N 0 0 0 2 A - 12 22450 A N D C A A H - CASE_ID ACCIDENT_YEAR PROC_DATEJURIS COLLISION_DATE COLLISION_TIME DAY_OF_WEEK CHP_SHIFT POPULATIONCNTY_CITY_LOC CHP_BEAT_CLASS BET_NUMBER PRIMARY_RDSECONDARY_RD DISTANCE DIRECTION INTERSECTIONWEATHER_1WEATHER_2STATE_HWY_IND TOW_AWAYCOLLISION_SEVERITY NUMBER_KILLED NUMBER_INJURED PARTY_COUNT PRIMARY_COLL_FACTOR PCF_CODE_OF_VIOL PCF_VIOL_CATEGORY PCF_VIOLATION PCF_VIOL_SUBSECTION HIT_AND_RUNTYPE_OF_COLLISION MVIW PED_ACTIONROAD_SURFACE ROAD_COND_1 ROAD_COND_2 8137697 2016 20161013 3600 20160921 1128 3 5 5 3621 0 OTTAWA RDMESQUITE RD 0 Y A - N N 0 0 0 2 A - 9 21802 N C C A A H - 8156266 2016 20161102 3600 20160921 1741 3 5 5 3621 0 AP4 OTTAWA RDMESQUITE RD 1325 W N A - N Y 4 0 1 2 A - 9 21801 A N D C A A H - 9024470 2019 20200211 3600 20191224 1113 2 5 5 3621 0 AP4 OTTAWA RDMESQUITE RD 0 Y A - N Y 4 0 2 2 A - 9 21802 A N D C A A H - 9196877 2020 20210114 3600 20201117 1137 2 5 5 3621 0 AP4 OTTAWA RDMESQUITE RD 0 Y A - N Y 0 0 0 2 A - 9 21802 A N D C A A H - Joshua & South
Mesquite & Ottawa
CASE_ID ACCIDENT_YEAR PROC_DATEJURIS COLLISION_DATE COLLISION_TIME DAY_OF_WEEK CHP_SHIFT POPULATIONCNTY_CITY_LOC CHP_BEAT_CLASS BET_NUMBER PRIMARY_RDSECONDARY_RD DISTANCE DIRECTION INTERSECTIONWEATHER_1WEATHER_2STATE_HWY_IND TOW_AWAYCOLLISION_SEVERITY NUMBER_KILLED NUMBER_INJURED PARTY_COUNT PRIMARY_COLL_FACTOR PCF_CODE_OF_VIOL PCF_VIOL_CATEGORY PCF_VIOLATION PCF_VIOL_SUBSECTION HIT_AND_RUNTYPE_OF_COLLISION MVIW PED_ACTIONROAD_SURFACE ROAD_COND_1 ROAD_COND_2 8137697 2016 20161013 3600 20160921 1128 3 5 5 3621 0 OTTAWA RDMESQUITE RD 0 Y A - N N 0 0 0 2 A - 9 21802 N C C A A H - 8156266 2016 20161102 3600 20160921 1741 3 5 5 3621 0 AP4 OTTAWA RDMESQUITE RD 1325 W N A - N Y 4 0 1 2 A - 9 21801 A N D C A A H - 9024470 2019 20200211 3600 20191224 1113 2 5 5 3621 0 AP4 OTTAWA RDMESQUITE RD 0 Y A - N Y 4 0 2 2 A - 9 21802 A N D C A A H - 9196877 2020 20210114 3600 20201117 1137 2 5 5 3621 0 AP4 OTTAWA RDMESQUITE RD 0 Y A - N Y 0 0 0 2 A - 9 21802 A N D C A A H - Mesquite & Ottawa

Resolution 2022-03
Town Council Agenda Report
Date: February 8, 2022
To: Honorable Mayor and Town Council
Subject: ALL-WAY STOP AT THE INTERSECTION OF JOSHUA ROAD AND

SOUTH ROAD
From: Douglas Robertson, Town Manager
Submitted by: Brad Miller, Town Engineer
Engineering
Budgeted Item: Yes No N/A

RECOMMENDED ACTION
Adopt Resolution 2022-03, “A Resolution of the Town Council of the Town of Apple Valley establishing the intersection of Joshua Road and South Road as an all-way STOP intersection.”

BACKGROUND
As part of the Town Wide School Zone analysis, engineering staff requested the consultant, Michael Baker International, to evaluate the intersection of Joshua Road and South Road to determine if it met warrants for installation of all-way stop controls. The consultant evaluated speed limits, the collision history, traffic volumes, visibility, and other warrant chriteria at the intersection. Although traffic volumes and the collision history did not meet warrants, Michael Baker International does recommend that all-way stop controls be installed based on visibility and pedestrian generator(s). Therefore, Engineering staff is recommending that the existing two-way stop controls at Joshua Road and South Road be upgraded to an all-way stop.

ANALYSIS
Engineering staff supports the findings of the evaluation, and with Town Manager Robertson’s approval, are bringing the upgrade to an all-way stop at this intersection before Town Council for approval, and immediate appropriate implementation.

FISCAL IMPACT

Resolution 2022-03
Funding for this project is available in the Town Council approved 2021-2022 Capital Improvement Project Budget using Measure I funds (2021-5210-9203-0000). The total project cost, which includes signage, markings, and the recommended temporary flashing beacons, is $3,000.00.

ATTACHMENTS
A. Resolution 2022-03.

B. Engineering Analysis

Resolution 2022-03
RESOLUTION NO. 2022-03

A RESOLUTION OF THE TOWN COUNCIL OF THE TOWN

OF APPLE VALLEY ESTABLISHING THE INTERSECTION

OF JOSHUA ROAD AND SOUTH ROAD AS A FOUR-WAY
STOP INTERSECTION.

WHEREAS, a traffic engineering investigation has determined that establishing the intersection of Joshua Road and South Road as an all-way STOP intersection is warranted in accordance with Section 52.0111 of the San Bernardino County Code as adopted by the Town of Apple Valley.

NOW THEREFORE, THE TOWN COUNCIL OF THE TOWN OF APPLE VALLEY DOES RESOLVE AND ORDER AS FOLLOWS:

Section 1: Approves and establishes the intersection of Joshua Road and South Road as an all-way STOP intersection.

Section 2: Authorizes and directs the Town Manager to cause additional STOP signs to be placed on Joshua Road and South Road.

APPROVED and ADOPTED by the Town Council of the Town of Apple Valley this the 8th day of February 2022.
________________________
MAYOR, Kari Leon
ATTESTED:
_________________________________
TOWN CLERK, La Vonda M-Pearson

January 24, 2022
TO: Richard Berger
Town of Apple Valley
FROM: Ryan Calad, PE, TE
Michael Baker International

JOSHUA ROAD AND SOUTH ROAD

ALL-WAY STOP CONTROLS

RECOMMENDATIONS

1. Consider the installation of all-way stop controls at the intersection of Joshua Road and South Road.

BACKGROUND
As requested, I reviewed the intersection of Joshua Road and South Road with respect to the need for all-way stop controls and offer
the following comments. This
evaluation is done in conjunction with
a school area traffic control evaluation
for Sycamore Rocks Elementary
School.

DISCUSSION
Joshua Road in the subject vicinity is
classified as a minor arterial roadway
in the current functional classification map (California Road System Map 15U13) and runs northsouth. It is unstriped to the north of the intersection and striped with centerline and edge line striping to the south of the intersection. Joshua Road is approximately 64 feet wide north of South Road and 26 feet wide south of the intersection. There are sidewalks only at the northeast corner of the intersection. It does not have any posted speed limit signs from south of Waalew Road and north of Cahuilla Road. The vertical alignment in the immediate vicinity of Joshua Road is flat, and the horizontal alignment is straight. Fronting development is residential, with Sycamore Rocks Park on the northeast corner and Sycamore Rocks Elementary School located on the north side of Joshua Road, approximately 780 feet east of South Road. There are no traffic signals and all-way stop controls within 3,500 feet north and south of Joshua Road. It forms a four-legged intersection with South Road and is controlled with stop signs and

“STOP” pavement markings on the north and
south approaches. A yellow school ladder
crosswalk is located on the north and south leg.

Joshua Road has various advance stop warning
signs and pavement markings north and south
of South Road.

South Road is classified as a major collector
roadway and has one lane in each direction,
separated by double yellow and skip yellow
centerline. It runs east-west and has an 85th
percentile speed of 54 mph, with a 25 mph
school speed zone in the vicinity of the school. South Road also has various advance school warning signs east and west of Joshua Road. There are sidewalks on the north side of the roadway east of Joshua Road. Fronting
development is residential in addition to the
school. There are yellow school ladder
crosswalks on the east leg only. The alignment
in the vicinity of the intersection is straight and
flat.

Volume and speed counts were taken at this
intersection on September 1-2, 2021 (attached).

Per the California Manual on Uniform Traffic
Control Devices (CA MUTCD) and industry
standards, all-way stop control analyses are to
be conducted using traffic volume data obtained
on a Tuesday, Wednesday or Thursday, which
are considered typical weekday volumes. Since
the data obtained for either day would be
acceptable, the total intersection volumes for
each day were compared and the highest total
intersection volume day (September 2, 2021)
was used for analysis. The data showed the
average of the eight highest hours on the main
street (South Road) approaches to the
intersection to be 262 vehicles per hour. The
average of the same eight highest hours on the minor street (Joshua Road) approaches to the intersection was 85 vehicles per hour. Speed data revealed an 85th percentile speed of 56 mph.

South Approach – Looking East
South Approach – Looking West
North Approach – Looking West

Intersection vehicle and pedestrian volume
counts were taken on September 2, 2021
during the morning school arrival period (8:00 –
9:00 am) and afternoon school dismissal period
(2:00 – 3:00 pm). These counts revealed the
following pedestrians crossing the three
crosswalks:

North Crosswalk: 1 during the a.m.; 0 during the
p.m.

South Crosswalk: 0 during the a.m.; 0 during
the p.m.

East Crosswalk: 0 during the a.m.; 6 during the
p.m.

The west leg is not stop controlled and does not have a crosswalk. During the morning arrival period, 165 vehicles travelled through the crosswalk, while the afternoon dismissal period had 68 vehicles traveling through the crosswalk.

A review of the available SWITRS data at this
intersection revealed the following reported
collisions since 2014:
• 12/11/14 – Broadside Collision,
Property Damage Only
• 01/23/15 – Broadside Collision,
Property Damage Only
• 12/13/16 - Broadside Collision, Property
Damage Only
• 05/23/19 – Broadside Collision,
Property Damage Only
See Appendix for the complete SWITRS data for all collisions listed.

For the suggested speed limit of 55 mph on South Road (based on the 85th percentile speed of 54 mph), the stopping sight distance per Table
201.1 of the California Highway Design Manual
is 500 feet.

Field measurements revealed that visibility
for the west approach of South Road
looking both north and south onto Joshua
Road exceed the minimum stopping
distance. Visibility for the east approach
looking north and south onto Joshua Road also
exceeds the minimum stopping distance.

However, visibility from the north and south
approach of Joshua Road looking west is
North Approach – Looking East
South Road – West Approach
South Road – East Approach

obstructed by roadside vegetation. Vehicles need to creep forward into the crosswalk and the travelled way to eliminate the visibility restrictions.

The CA MUTCD provides guidance for the installation of all-way stop controls. It suggests that all-way stop controls may be considered when:
• Warrant A - Where traffic control signals are justified, the multi-way stop is an interim measure that can be installed quickly to control traffic while arrangements are being made for the installation of the traffic control signal. • Warrant B - There is a crash problem, as indicated by 4 or more reported crashes in a 12-month period that are susceptible to correction by all-way stop installation. Such crashes include right- and left-turn collisions as well as right-angle collisions. • Warrant C - Where the vehicular volume entering the intersection from the major street approaches (total of both approaches) averages at least 262 vehicles per hour for any 8 hours of an average day; and combined vehicular, pedestrian, and bicycle volume entering the intersection from the minor street approaches (total of both approaches) averages at least 85 units per hour for the same 8 hours, with an average delay to minor-street vehicular traffic of at least 30 seconds per vehicle during the highest hour.

When the 85th-percentile approach speed of the major-street traffic exceeds 40 mph, as it does at this intersection, the minimum vehicular volume warrants may be reduced to 70 percent of the above values. Therefore, the major street volume threshold is 210 vehicles per hour and the minor street threshold is 140 vehicles per hour. • Warrant D - Where none of the above Warrants are satisfied, but Warrants B and C are satisfied 80 percent. For this warrant, the 70 percent reduction for Warrant C cannot be applied.

The CA MUTCD also provides other criteria that may be considered, including:
• The need to control left-turn conflicts;
• The need to control vehicle/pedestrian conflicts near locations that generate high pedestrian volumes.
• Locations where a road user, after stopping, cannot see conflicting traffic and is not able to negotiate the intersection unless conflicting cross traffic is also required to stop; and,
• An intersection of two residential neighborhood collector (through) streets of similar design and operating characteristics where all-way stop control would improve traffic operational characteristics of the intersection.
• As indicated previously, the average 8-hour volume on South Road is 262 vehicles per hour and the average volume for the same 8 hours on Joshua Road is 85 vehicles per hour. The major street volume is 100% satisfied in Warrant C while the minor street warrant is 60% satisfied. The main street/minor street volume split during the eight highest hours is approximately 67% vs. 33%. The reported collision history revealed a maximum of one (1) collision within a 12-month period that could be correctable with all-way stop controls. Neither the volume nor crash thresholds are satisfied, however there is an identifiable crash pattern of westbound and eastbound vehicles hitting through vehicles on South Road.

Based on the above criteria, the collision and volume guidelines are not satisfied.

However, the following criteria listed above may be applicable to this location:
• The need to control vehicle/pedestrian conflicts near locations that generate high pedestrian volumes – Sycamore Rocks Elementary School is located within approximately 780 feet of the intersection and there are marked school crosswalks on the east, west, and south legs. In addition, the school utilizes a crossing guard to assist pedestrians crossing the roadways. As indicated by the intersection vehicle and pedestrian counts, there are a substantial number of vehicles crossing the uncontrolled crosswalk on the west leg. This crossing provides access to the residential areas north of South Road. The above information suggests the potential for significant conflict between pedestrians and motorists. Furthermore, the speed of traffic on South Road limits the available gaps in traffic to allow pedestrians to reasonably cross the roadway.
• Locations where a road user, after stopping, cannot see conflicting traffic and is not able to negotiate the intersection unless conflicting cross traffic is also required to stop – Visibility for motorists on the east and west approach of South Road viewing traffic approaching from north and south on Joshua Road is limited based on the 500’ stopping sight distance due to roadside vegetation. This visibility restriction can create conflict for motorists attempting to enter or cross South Road.

The conflict is increase by the need for motorists to be aware of the potential for pedestrian crossings within the marked school crosswalks.

SIGNAGE AND PAVEMENT MARKINGS
As discussed, the intersection of Joshua Road and South Road is two-way stop controlled for the north bound and south bound Joshua Road legs and has yellow ladder crosswalks on the north, south, and east legs. Adjacent to the east leg crosswalk are two Assembly B, SW24-2 signs facing opposite directions and are there to alert motorists of the location of the pedestrian crossing.
• The existing yellow ladder crosswalk paint appears to be in good condition, but dirty from new asphalt work completed at the school and should be power washed or cleaned via a street sweeper. Per the CA MUTCD 7C.03, this location does not provide for complete traffic control needed for the uncontrolled crossing as it is missing the “SLOW SCHOOL XING” advanced pavement markings. But the recent circulation changes of the school with the pick-up/drop-off circulation moving from South Road to the new Joshua Road entrance does trigger volume warrant thresholds for an all-way stop. As such, this intersection location should be updated accordingly with the removal of Assembly B signage, installation of “STOP” control signs (R1-1) and pavement markings for the South Road intersection east and west leg approaches. As well as, an installation of “STOP AHEAD” warning signs (W3-1) and pavement markings 250 feet from the South Road intersection east and west of the stop bar for east bound and west bound traffic per the CA MUTCD 2C.06.

CONCLUSION
The traffic volumes and reported crash history at this location do not satisfy CA MUTCD warrants for the installation of all-way stop controls. However, two of the additional criteria (pedestrian volume generators and visibility) may justify all-way stop controls. In addition, there is an identifiable pattern of PDO collisions that would be expected to be correctable with all-way stop controls. Based on this information, it is recommended that all-way stop control installation be considered at the intersection of Joshua Road and South Road with the removal of Assembly B signage and installation of “STOP” control signs, “STOP AHEAD” warning signs, and their corresponding markings. The concurrent Sycamore Rocks Elementary School traffic control evaluation contains recommendations that would be affected by the outcome of this report.

JR: Joshua Rd at South Rd All-Way Stop Control Analysis Attach.

Sincerely,

Ryan Calad, PE, TE
Project Manager

6RXWK&W
&X\DPD5G
-RVKXD5G
(O&HQWUR5G
6RXWK5G
SCHOOL pavement
marking
Existing yellow ladder
crosswalks on north,
east, and south legs
SCHOOL pavement
marking
Attachment A
Existing School Traffic Controls
Sycamore Rocks Elementary School
N
Legend
School Boundary
Speed Limit (mph)
South Road: Not Posted Page 69 of 181
Joshua Road: Not Posted
6RXWK&W
&X\DPD5G
-RVKXD5G
(O&HQWUR5G
6RXWK5G
SCHOOL pavement
marking
Existing yellow ladder
crosswalks on north,
east, and south legs
SCHOOL
pavement
marking
Attachment B
All-Way Stop Controls
Sycamore Rocks Elementary School
N
Legend
School Boundary
Speed Limit (mph)
South Road: Not Posted
Joshua Road: Not Posted
Install new all-way "STOP"
control with new STOP
Signs (R1-1) and markings
for South Road
intersection east and west
leg approaches.

Install new all-way "STOP"
control with new STOP
Signs (R1-1) and markings
for South Road
intersection east and west
leg approaches.

Remove existing
Assembly B sign on the
south side of South Rd,
facing EB traffic
Remove the existing
Assembly B sign
(SW24-2) on the north
side of South Rd
facing WB traffic
Install "STOP AHEAD"
pavement markings
250' east of the
intersection of Joshua
Road and South Road,
facing WB traffic
Install W3-1 sign
adjacent to the "STOP
AHEAD" pavement
markings 250' east of
the intersection's new
stop bar, facing WB
traffic
Install "STOP AHEAD"
pavement markings
250' west of the
intersection of Joshua
Road and South Road,
facing EB traffic
Install W3-1 sign
adjacent to the "STOP
AHEAD" pavement
markings 250' west of
the intersection's new
stop bar, facing EB
traffic

Town of Apple Valley
N/S: Joshua Road
E/W: South Road
48 Hour Entering Volume Count
APV002EW
Site Code: 122-21450
Counts Unlimited, Inc.

PO Box 1178
Corona, CA 92878
Phone: (951) 268-6268
email: [email protected]
Start 01-Sep-21 Eastbound Hour Totals Westbound Hour Totals Combined Totals Time Wed Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon 12:00 0 11 1 5
12:15 0 9 0 14
12:30 1 9 0 12
12:45 1 15 2 44 0 8 1 39 3 83
01:00 0 12 1 9
01:15 1 8 0 5
01:30 2 28 0 10
01:45 0 35 3 83 0 14 1 38 4 121
02:00 0 47 0 106
02:15 1 11 0 21
02:30 0 13 0 11
02:45 0 15 1 86 0 13 0 151 1 237
03:00 0 4 1 15
03:15 0 11 1 10
03:30 0 6 1 20
03:45 0 7 0 28 2 8 5 53 5 81
04:00 1 4 1 14
04:15 0 9 2 13
04:30 1 14 2 9
04:45 0 8 2 35 2 11 7 47 9 82
05:00 0 12 1 8
05:15 0 11 5 9
05:30 1 9 3 6
05:45 3 7 4 39 4 5 13 28 17 67
06:00 3 10 5 4
06:15 4 16 9 5
06:30 3 15 9 2
06:45 2 2 12 43 11 4 34 15 46 58
07:00 7 7 4 3
07:15 5 10 8 3
07:30 8 3 8 8
07:45 20 2 40 22 10 5 30 19 70 41
08:00 15 3 7 2
08:15 17 5 23 3
08:30 46 5 20 0
08:45 73 7 151 20 39 3 89 8 240 28
09:00 32 3 33 2
09:15 1 5 17 2
09:30 4 3 7 0
09:45 5 5 42 16 6 2 63 6 105 22
10:00 8 1 13 1
10:15 5 3 5 6
10:30 7 4 9 2
10:45 9 2 29 10 12 0 39 9 68 19
11:00 13 1 17 1
11:15 10 0 10 0
11:30 12 0 9 4
11:45 9 1 44 2 4 0 40 5 84 7
Total 330 428 330 428 322 418 322 418 652 846
Combined
Total 758 758 740 740 1498
AM Peak - 08:15 - - - 08:15 - - - - -
Vol. - 168 - - - 115 - - - - -
P.H.F. 0.575 0.737
PM Peak - - 01:30 - - - 01:45 - - - -
Vol. - - 121 - - - 152 - - - -
P.H.F. 0.644 0.358
Percentag
e

43.5% 56.5% 43.5% 56.5%

Town of Apple Valley
N/S: Joshua Road
E/W: South Road
48 Hour Entering Volume Count
APV002EW
Site Code: 122-21450
Counts Unlimited, Inc.

PO Box 1178
Corona, CA 92878
Phone: (951) 268-6268
email: [email protected]
Start 02-Sep-21 Eastbound Hour Totals Westbound Hour Totals Combined Totals Time Thu Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon 12:00 1 7 0 7
12:15 2 8 0 11
12:30 0 3 0 8
12:45 0 7 3 25 0 6 0 32 3 57
01:00 0 8 1 5
01:15 1 7 0 7
01:30 0 4 0 16
01:45 1 8 2 27 0 10 1 38 3 65
02:00 1 12 0 7
02:15 0 14 0 12
02:30 0 10 0 15
02:45 1 32 2 68 0 8 0 42 2 110
03:00 0 44 3 19
03:15 1 38 2 126
03:30 0 15 3 27
03:45 0 5 1 102 0 27 8 199 9 301
04:00 0 9 0 18
04:15 0 14 0 6
04:30 2 11 3 7
04:45 0 10 2 44 5 9 8 40 10 84
05:00 0 6 0 12
05:15 0 13 2 8
05:30 1 8 5 13
05:45 3 8 4 35 5 1 12 34 16 69
06:00 2 12 4 7
06:15 1 6 8 5
06:30 3 8 10 6
06:45 2 14 8 40 7 4 29 22 37 62
07:00 5 10 3 6
07:15 8 6 9 6
07:30 4 5 11 5
07:45 8 7 25 28 12 5 35 22 60 50
08:00 13 4 2 2
08:15 24 6 13 4
08:30 51 4 20 1
08:45 77 3 165 17 41 1 76 8 241 25
09:00 21 3 33 1
09:15 10 0 14 0
09:30 13 3 11 2
09:45 9 2 53 8 11 0 69 3 122 11
10:00 8 2 12 0
10:15 9 3 10 0
10:30 9 0 12 0
10:45 12 1 38 6 8 3 42 3 80 9
11:00 5 2 14 1
11:15 10 1 8 0
11:30 8 1 6 0
11:45 8 0 31 4 10 1 38 2 69 6
Total 334 404 334 404 318 445 318 445 652 849
Combined
Total 738 738 763 763 1501
AM Peak - 08:15 - - - 08:30 - - - - -
Vol. - 173 - - - 108 - - - - -
P.H.F. 0.562 0.659
PM Peak - - 02:45 - - - 03:00 - - - -
Vol. - - 129 - - - 199 - - - -
P.H.F. 0.733 0.395
Percentag
e

45.3% 54.7% 41.7% 58.3%
ADT/AADT ADT 1,500 AADT 1,500

Town of Apple Valley
N/S: Joshua Road
E/W: South Road
48 Hour Entering Volume Count
APV002NS
Site Code: 122-21450
Counts Unlimited, Inc.

PO Box 1178
Corona, CA 92878
Phone: (951) 268-6268
email: [email protected]
Start 01-Sep-21 Northbound Hour Totals Southbound Hour Totals Combined Totals Time Wed Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon 12:00 1 10 1 4
12:15 2 3 0 6
12:30 3 15 1 7
12:45 0 15 6 43 0 12 2 29 8 72
01:00 0 7 2 11
01:15 2 16 2 6
01:30 0 13 2 11
01:45 0 24 2 60 1 14 7 42 9 102
02:00 0 16 1 21
02:15 2 9 3 16
02:30 2 5 0 8
02:45 0 9 4 39 1 9 5 54 9 93
03:00 0 5 0 9
03:15 1 9 2 13
03:30 5 12 0 10
03:45 2 4 8 30 0 9 2 41 10 71
04:00 3 13 0 8
04:15 3 5 2 15
04:30 4 9 0 11
04:45 5 13 15 40 0 5 2 39 17 79
05:00 7 5 2 16
05:15 10 11 2 14
05:30 8 7 8 9
05:45 9 7 34 30 4 9 16 48 50 78
06:00 5 11 2 14
06:15 13 7 8 14
06:30 11 10 4 11
06:45 6 2 35 30 5 8 19 47 54 77
07:00 11 6 6 7
07:15 3 5 3 18
07:30 16 7 6 22
07:45 26 4 56 22 5 9 20 56 76 78
08:00 9 7 10 9
08:15 6 4 5 4
08:30 20 5 9 5
08:45 32 6 67 22 34 5 58 23 125 45
09:00 12 6 27 1
09:15 6 1 5 4
09:30 5 2 4 3
09:45 13 2 36 11 6 2 42 10 78 21
10:00 2 0 4 1
10:15 7 0 8 3
10:30 9 2 7 3
10:45 11 3 29 5 2 3 21 10 50 15
11:00 8 1 11 3
11:15 10 1 7 1
11:30 2 3 7 1
11:45 7 2 27 7 10 1 35 6 62 13
Total 319 339 319 339 229 405 229 405 548 744
Combined
Total 658 658 634 634 1292
AM Peak - 08:15 - - - 08:15 - - - - -
Vol. - 70 - - - 75 - - - - -
P.H.F. 0.547 0.551
PM Peak - - 01:15 - - - 01:30 - - - -
Vol. - - 69 - - - 62 - - - -
P.H.F. 0.719 0.738
Percentag
e

48.5% 51.5% 36.1% 63.9%

Town of Apple Valley
N/S: Joshua Road
E/W: South Road
48 Hour Entering Volume Count
APV002NS
Site Code: 122-21450
Counts Unlimited, Inc.

PO Box 1178
Corona, CA 92878
Phone: (951) 268-6268
email: [email protected]
Start 02-Sep-21 Northbound Hour Totals Southbound Hour Totals Combined Totals Time Thu Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon Morning Afternoon 12:00 2 9 0 7
12:15 0 8 2 7
12:30 2 4 0 6
12:45 0 5 4 26 3 1 5 21 9 47
01:00 1 3 0 6
01:15 0 11 3 11
01:30 1 8 2 9
01:45 1 4 3 26 0 11 5 37 8 63
02:00 0 7 1 7
02:15 0 13 1 9
02:30 1 16 1 13
02:45 0 19 1 55 0 14 3 43 4 98
03:00 0 16 0 11
03:15 2 22 0 20
03:30 2 11 1 33
03:45 2 6 6 55 0 12 1 76 7 131
04:00 2 10 1 10
04:15 3 9 0 12
04:30 1 16 1 9
04:45 5 5 11 40 1 5 3 36 14 76
05:00 2 11 0 14
05:15 6 6 3 6
05:30 12 7 1 3
05:45 9 8 29 32 1 12 5 35 34 67
06:00 5 8 4 11
06:15 9 8 3 6
06:30 11 3 7 11
06:45 13 8 38 27 5 7 19 35 57 62
07:00 15 5 5 18
07:15 15 2 4 10
07:30 13 9 6 8
07:45 17 6 60 22 3 5 18 41 78 63
08:00 12 8 8 10
08:15 13 5 9 4
08:30 21 3 6 4
08:45 19 3 65 19 36 0 59 18 124 37
09:00 14 3 25 3
09:15 12 9 6 1
09:30 6 3 5 2
09:45 7 1 39 16 6 6 42 12 81 28
10:00 11 2 6 4
10:15 9 3 4 3
10:30 11 3 6 1
10:45 6 1 37 9 6 3 22 11 59 20
11:00 4 3 12 0
11:15 5 0 2 0
11:30 8 1 3 4
11:45 8 1 25 5 5 2 22 6 47 11
Total 318 332 318 332 204 371 204 371 522 703
Combined
Total 650 650 575 575 1225
AM Peak - 08:15 - - - 08:15 - - - - -
Vol. - 67 - - - 76 - - - - -
P.H.F. 0.798 0.528
PM Peak - - 02:30 - - - 02:45 - - - -
Vol. - - 73 - - - 78 - - - -
P.H.F. 0.830 0.591
Percentag
e

48.9% 51.1% 35.5% 64.5%
ADT/AADT ADT 1,258 AADT 1,258

File Name : 01_APV_Joshua_South Veh
Site Code : 12221450
Start Date : 9/2/2021
Page No : 1
City of Apple Valley
N/S: Joshua Road
E/W: South Road
Weather: Clear
Groups Printed- Total Volume
Joshua Road
Southbound
South Road
Westbound
Joshua Road
Northbound
South Road
Eastbound
Start Time Left Thru Right App. Total Left Thru Right App. Total Left Thru Right App. Total Left Thru Right App. Total Int. Total 08:00 AM 4 3 1 8 1 1 0 2 0 8 4 12 3 10 0 13 35
08:15 AM 5 4 0 9 1 6 6 13 0 10 3 13 2 20 2 24 59
08:30 AM 1 2 3 6 3 15 2 20 1 13 7 21 21 30 0 51 98
08:45 AM 9 8 19 36 7 27 7 41 2 13 4 19 37 36 4 77 173
Total 19 17 23 59 12 49 15 76 3 44 18 65 63 96 6 165 365 09:00 AM 9 7 9 25 1 29 3 33 1 11 2 14 11 8 2 21 93
09:15 AM 1 5 0 6 0 8 6 14 4 6 2 12 1 6 3 10 42
09:30 AM 0 4 1 5 1 7 3 11 0 6 0 6 0 11 2 13 35
09:45 AM 3 2 1 6 0 8 3 11 1 4 2 7 1 7 1 9 33
Total 13 18 11 42 2 52 15 69 6 27 6 39 13 32 8 53 203
10:00 AM 2 4 0 6 2 9 1 12 3 6 2 11 0 7 1 8 37
10:15 AM 0 3 1 4 3 6 1 10 0 6 3 9 1 5 3 9 32
10:30 AM 1 5 0 6 2 9 1 12 1 6 4 11 0 8 1 9 38
10:45 AM 2 4 0 6 1 6 1 8 0 4 2 6 1 9 2 12 32
Total 5 16 1 22 8 30 4 42 4 22 11 37 2 29 7 38 139
11:00 AM 4 8 0 12 1 12 1 14 1 1 2 4 1 4 0 5 35
11:15 AM 0 0 2 2 0 7 1 8 2 1 2 5 1 8 1 10 25
11:30 AM 2 1 0 3 2 4 0 6 0 8 0 8 0 7 1 8 25
11:45 AM 1 3 1 5 1 6 3 10 2 6 0 8 1 5 2 8 31
Total 7 12 3 22 4 29 5 38 5 16 4 25 3 24 4 31 116
12:00 PM 2 5 0 7 0 3 4 7 0 5 4 9 0 6 1 7 30
12:15 PM 2 5 0 7 3 8 0 11 2 4 2 8 0 6 2 8 34
12:30 PM 2 4 0 6 0 5 3 8 0 3 1 4 0 2 1 3 21
12:45 PM 0 1 0 1 1 3 2 6 1 4 0 5 0 6 1 7 19
Total 6 15 0 21 4 19 9 32 3 16 7 26 0 20 5 25 104
01:00 PM 1 5 0 6 0 5 0 5 0 3 0 3 1 5 2 8 22
01:15 PM 4 5 2 11 1 4 2 7 4 5 2 11 2 4 1 7 36
01:30 PM 3 5 1 9 5 10 1 16 1 6 1 8 0 4 0 4 37
01:45 PM 2 8 1 11 1 7 2 10 1 1 2 4 4 3 1 8 33
Total 10 23 4 37 7 26 5 38 6 15 5 26 7 16 4 27 128
02:00 PM 1 6 0 7 3 4 0 7 1 4 2 7 4 2 6 12 33
02:15 PM 3 6 0 9 4 6 2 12 4 9 0 13 7 6 1 14 48
02:30 PM 3 9 1 13 1 8 6 15 1 11 4 16 4 6 0 10 54
02:45 PM 3 11 0 14 2 3 3 8 1 8 10 19 12 15 5 32 73
Total 10 32 1 43 10 21 11 42 7 32 16 55 27 29 12 68 208 03:00 PM 8 3 0 11 3 14 2 19 3 4 9 16 8 31 5 44 90
03:15 PM 5 12 3 20 17 71 38 126 6 3 13 22 1 35 2 38 206 03:30 PM 9 13 11 33 5 18 4 27 1 9 1 11 7 5 3 15 86
03:45 PM 5 7 0 12 6 18 3 27 2 4 0 6 0 4 1 5 50
Total 27 35 14 76 31 121 47 199 12 20 23 55 16 75 11 102 432 04:00 PM 2 7 1 10 4 12 2 18 1 7 2 10 0 8 1 9 47
04:15 PM 4 8 0 12 1 3 2 6 3 4 2 9 0 8 6 14 41
04:30 PM 2 6 1 9 1 4 2 7 2 9 5 16 0 9 2 11 43
04:45 PM 3 2 0 5 3 4 2 9 1 3 1 5 0 6 4 10 29
Total 11 23 2 36 9 23 8 40 7 23 10 40 0 31 13 44 160
Grand Total 108 191 59 358 87 370 119 576 53 215 100 368 131 352 70 553 1855 Apprch % 30.2 53.4 16.5 15.1 64.2 20.7 14.4 58.4 27.2 23.7 63.7 12.7 Total % 5.8 10.3 3.2 19.3 4.7 19.9 6.4 31.1 2.9 11.6 5.4 19.8 7.1 19 3.8 29.8 Counts Unlimited, Inc.

PO Box 1178
Corona, CA 92878
(951)268-6268

Joshua Road
Southbound
South Road
Westbound
Joshua Road
Northbound
South Road
Eastbound
Start Time Left Thru Right App. Total Left Thru Right App. Total Left Thru Right App. Total Left Thru Right App. Total Int. Total Peak Hour Analysis From 08:00 AM to 04:45 PM - Peak 1 of 1 Peak Hour for Entire Intersection Begins at 02:45 PM
02:45 PM 3 11 0 14 2 3 3 8 1 8 10 19 12 15 5 32 73
03:00 PM 8 3 0 11 3 14 2 19 3 4 9 16 8 31 5 44 90
03:15 PM 5 12 3 20 17 71 38 126 6 3 13 22 1 35 2 38 206 03:30 PM 9 13 11 33 5 18 4 27 1 9 1 11 7 5 3 15 86
Total Volume 25 39 14 78 27 106 47 180 11 24 33 68 28 86 15 129 455 % App. Total 32.1 50 17.9 15 58.9 26.1 16.2 35.3 48.5 21.7 66.7 11.6 PHF .694 .750 .318 .591 .397 .373 .309 .357 .458 .667 .635 .773 .583 .614 .750 .733 .552 Joshua Road
South Road
South Road
Joshua Road
Right
14 Thru
39 Left
25 Out In Total
99 78 177
Right
47 Thru
106
Left
27 Out Total In
144 180 324
Left
11 Thru
24 Right
33 Out In Total
81 68 149
Left
28 Thru
86 Right
15 Total Out In
131 129 260
Peak Hour Begins at 02:45 PM
Total Volume
Peak Hour Data
North
Counts Unlimited, Inc.

PO Box 1178
Corona, CA 92878
(951)268-6268

File Name : 01_APV_Joshua_South Veh
Site Code : 12221450
Start Date : 9/2/2021
Page No : 3
City of Apple Valley
N/S: Joshua Road
E/W: South Road
Weather: Clear
Joshua Road
Southbound
South Road
Westbound
Joshua Road
Northbound
South Road
Eastbound
Start Time Left Thru Right App. Total Left Thru Right App. Total Left Thru Right App. Total Left Thru Right App. Total Int. Total Peak Hour Analysis From 08:00 AM to 04:45 PM - Peak 1 of 1 Peak Hour for Each Approach Begins at:
02:45 PM 03:00 PM 02:30 PM 08:15 AM
+0 mins. 3 11 0 14 3 14 2 19 1 11 4 16 2 20 2 24
+15 mins. 8 3 0 11 17 71 38 126 1 8 10 19 21 30 0 51
+30 mins. 5 12 3 20 5 18 4 27 3 4 9 16 37 36 4 77
+45 mins. 9 13 11 33 6 18 3 27 6 3 13 22 11 8 2 21
Total Volume 25 39 14 78 31 121 47 199 11 26 36 73 71 94 8 173 % App. Total 32.1 50 17.9 15.6 60.8 23.6 15.1 35.6 49.3 41 54.3 4.6 PHF .694 .750 .318 .591 .456 .426 .309 .395 .458 .591 .692 .830 .480 .653 .500 .562 Joshua Road
South Road
South Road
Joshua Road
Right
14 Thru
39 Left
25 In - Peak Hour: 02:45 PM
78 Right
47 Thru
121
Left
31 In - Peak Hour: 03:00 PM
199
Left
11 Thru
26 Right
36 In - Peak Hour: 02:30 PM
73 Left
71 Thru
94 Right
8 In - Peak Hour: 08:15 AM
173
Total Volume
Peak Hour Data
North
Counts Unlimited, Inc.

PO Box 1178
Corona, CA 92878
(951)268-6268

Location: Apple Valley Date: 9/2/2021
N/S: Joshua Road Day Thursday
E/W: South Road
North Leg East Leg South Leg West Leg
Joshua Road South Road Joshua Road South Road
0001 1
0000 0
1000 1
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
1030 4
1300 4
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
0010 1
0000 0
0600 6
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
0000 0
TOTAL VOLUMES: 3 9 4 1 17
4:30 PM
4:45 PM
11:00 AM
10:15 AM
10:45 AM
9:30 AM
10:00 AM
10:30 AM
9:45 AM
3:15 PM
3:30 PM
3:45 PM
4:00 PM
2:00 PM
2:15 PM
2:30 PM
2:45 PM
3:00 PM
1:30 PM
1:45 PM
11:45 AM
12:00 PM
12:15 PM
12:30 PM
12:45 PM
1:00 PM

PEDESTRIANS
1:15 PM
Time TOTAL
9:00 AM
4:15 PM
9:15 AM
8:00 AM
8:15 AM
8:30 AM
8:45 AM
11:15 AM
11:30 AM
Counts Unlimited, Inc.

PO Box 1178
Corona, CA 92878 Page 78 of 181 951‐268‐6268
Location: Date: 9/2/2021
N/S: Day: Thursday
E/W:

Left Thru Right Left Thru Right Left Thru Right Left Thru Right 000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000010000 1
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000000000 0
000000010000 1
4:30 PM
4:45 PM
3:15 PM
3:30 PM
3:45 PM
4:00 PM
4:15 PM
2:00 PM
2:15 PM
2:30 PM
2:45 PM
3:00 PM
12:45 PM
1:00 PM
1:15 PM
1:30 PM
1:45 PM
11:45 AM
12:00 PM
12:15 PM
12:30 PM
Apple Valley
Joshua Road
South Road
8:00 AM
8:15 AM
8:30 AM
8:45 AM
10:30 AM
10:45 AM
11:00 AM
11:15 AM
11:30 AM
9:15 AM
9:30 AM
9:45 AM
10:00 AM
10:15 AM
TOTAL VOLUMES:

BICYCLES
Southbound Westbound Northbound Eastbound
Joshua Road South Road Joshua Road South Road
9:00 AM
Counts Unlimited, Inc.

PO Box 1178
Corona, CA 92878 Page 79 of 181 951‐268‐6268
CASE_ID ACCIDENT_YEAR PROC_DATEJURIS COLLISION_DATE COLLISION_TIME DAY_OF_WEEK CHP_SHIFT POPULATIONCNTY_CITY_LOC CHP_BEAT_CLASS BET_NUMBER PRIMARY_RDSECONDARY_RD DISTANCE DIRECTION INTERSECTIONWEATHER_1WEATHER_2STATE_HWY_IND TOW_AWAYCOLLISION_SEVERITY NUMBER_KILLED NUMBER_INJURED PARTY_COUNT PRIMARY_COLL_FACTOR PCF_CODE_OF_VIOL PCF_VIOL_CATEGORY PCF_VIOLATION PCF_VIOL_SUBSECTION HIT_AND_RUNTYPE_OF_COLLISION MVIW PED_ACTIONROAD_SURFACE ROAD_COND_1 ROAD_COND_2 6753293 2014 20160629 3600 20141211 1803 4 5 5 3621 0 AP2 JOSHUA RDSOUTH RD 0 Y A - N 0 0 0 2 A - 9 21802 A N D C A A H - 6833948 2015 20150806 3600 20150123 1810 5 5 5 3621 0 AP2 SOUTH RD JOSHUA RD 0 Y A - N Y 0 0 0 2 A - - N D C A A H - 8282826 2016 20170124 3600 20161213 1727 2 5 5 3621 0 AP2 SOUTH RD JOSHUA RD 0 Y A - N N 0 0 0 2 A - 9 21802 A N D C A A H - 8871207 2019 20190613 3600 20190523 1746 4 5 5 3621 0 AP2 SOUTH RD JOSHUA RD 0 Y A - N N 0 0 0 2 A - 12 22450 A N D C A A H - CASE_ID ACCIDENT_YEAR PROC_DATEJURIS COLLISION_DATE COLLISION_TIME DAY_OF_WEEK CHP_SHIFT POPULATIONCNTY_CITY_LOC CHP_BEAT_CLASS BET_NUMBER PRIMARY_RDSECONDARY_RD DISTANCE DIRECTION INTERSECTIONWEATHER_1WEATHER_2STATE_HWY_IND TOW_AWAYCOLLISION_SEVERITY NUMBER_KILLED NUMBER_INJURED PARTY_COUNT PRIMARY_COLL_FACTOR PCF_CODE_OF_VIOL PCF_VIOL_CATEGORY PCF_VIOLATION PCF_VIOL_SUBSECTION HIT_AND_RUNTYPE_OF_COLLISION MVIW PED_ACTIONROAD_SURFACE ROAD_COND_1 ROAD_COND_2 8137697 2016 20161013 3600 20160921 1128 3 5 5 3621 0 OTTAWA RDMESQUITE RD 0 Y A - N N 0 0 0 2 A - 9 21802 N C C A A H - 8156266 2016 20161102 3600 20160921 1741 3 5 5 3621 0 AP4 OTTAWA RDMESQUITE RD 1325 W N A - N Y 4 0 1 2 A - 9 21801 A N D C A A H - 9024470 2019 20200211 3600 20191224 1113 2 5 5 3621 0 AP4 OTTAWA RDMESQUITE RD 0 Y A - N Y 4 0 2 2 A - 9 21802 A N D C A A H - 9196877 2020 20210114 3600 20201117 1137 2 5 5 3621 0 AP4 OTTAWA RDMESQUITE RD 0 Y A - N Y 0 0 0 2 A - 9 21802 A N D C A A H - Joshua & South
Mesquite & Ottawa

Town Council Agenda Report
Date: February 8, 2022
To: Honorable Mayor and Town Council
Subject: APPROVE RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING SUBMITTAL OF A CLAIM

AND REQUEST FOR REIMBURSEMENT TO SBCTA FOR TDA
ARTICLE 3 FUNDS

From: Douglas Robertson, Town Manager
Submitted by: Julie Ryan, Special Projects Manager
Town Manager
Budgeted Item: Yes No N/A

RECOMMENDED ACTION
Adopt Resolution No. 2022-04 authorizing submittal of a claim to the San Bernardino County Transportation Authority (SBCTA) for the Transportation Development Act (TDA) Article 3 funds for the Bear Valley Road Bridge Connector Project.

BACKGROUND
On June 2, 2021, the SBCTA Board authorized the release of the Transportation Development Act (TDA) Article 3 Call for Bicycle and Pedestrian Facilities and Transit Stop Access Improvements. Local jurisdictions and transit agencies were notified of this opportunity through the SBCTA’s website and Transportation Technical Advisory Committee (TTAC) email list. The amount of Article 3 funds anticipated to be available for award was $3,119,595 and $779,899, respectively, for a total of $3,899,494. The closing date for the Call for Projects was August 4, 2021.

The TDA provides that two percent of the State of California Local Transportation Funds (LTF) be made available to counties and cities for facilities for the exclusive use of bicyclists and pedestrians, known as the TDA Article 3 Program. In August 1999, the SBCTA Board (Board) approved a policy that 80 percent of TDA Article 3 funds would be made available for projects that implement or improve bicycle and pedestrian facilities.

The remaining 20 percent of the TDA Article 3 program would be made available for projects that improve access to transit stops for pedestrians and persons with disabilities.

On November 3, 2021, the SBCTA Board of Directors approved funding from the TDA Article 3 Bicycle and Pedestrian Facilities Program for the Bear Valley Road Bridge

Connector Project (Project) in the amount of $232,300. This Project will provide bicyclists and pedestrians access to a concrete multi-use path that will connect the north side of the Bear Valley Road Bridge over the Mojave River to Victor Valley College and the Mojave Riverwalk on the west and the Bear Valley Road Class I Bike Path at Jess Ranch Parkway on the east. This Project is also part of the larger project to rehabilitate and widen the Bear Valley Road Bridge over the Mojave River.

As a requirement of the grant, agencies are required to adopt a resolution authorizing a claim to SBCTA and a request for reimbursement.

FISCAL IMPACT
The Town’s General Fund will be reimbursed in the amount of $232,300.

ATTACHMENTS
A. Resolution No. 2022-04

Resolution 2022-04
RESOLUTION NO.2022-04

A RESOLUTION OF THE TOWN COUNCIL OF THE TOWN

OF APPLE VALLEY, CALIFORNIA, AUTHORIZING

SUBMITTAL OF A CLAIM TO THE SAN BERNARDINO

COUNTY TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY FOR
TRANSPORTATION DEVELOPMENT ACT ARTICLE 3

FUNDS FOR THE BEAR VALLEY ROAD BRIDGE

CONNECTOR PROJECT
WHEREAS, the Mills-Alquist-Deddeh Act (SB 325) was enacted by the California Legislature to improve existing public transportation services and encourage regional transportation coordination. Known as the Transportation Development Act (TDA) of 1971, this law provides funding to be allocated to transit and non-transit related purposes that comply with regional transportation plans; and
WHEREAS, TDA provides two funding sources, the Local Transportation Fund (LTF) and State Transit Assistance fund (STA); and
WHEREAS, LTF is derived from a ¼ cent of the general sales tax collected statewide and apportioned by population to areas within the county; and WHEREAS, STA is derived from the statewide sales tax on diesel fuel, plus an additional vehicle registration fee authorized under Senate Bill 1, referred to as the State of Good Repair, and both are apportioned by the State Controller’s Office 50% by population and 50% by transit operator revenues; and
WHEREAS, the San Bernardino County Transportation Authority (SBCTA) authorizes funding for a wide variety of transportation programs in San Bernardino County, including planning and program activities, pedestrian and bicycle facilities, community transit services, public transportation, and bus and rail projects to local transportation agencies through annual apportionment and allocation processes, and approves payments periodically throughout the year; and WHEREAS, SBCTA awarded the Town of Apple Valley TDA Article 3 grant funds in the amount of $232,300 for development of the Bear Valley Road Bridge Connector Project within the Town of Apple Valley jurisdiction through a competitive “Call for Projects”; and
WHEREAS, TDA Article 3 grant funds are provided on a reimbursement basis; and WHEREAS, SBCTA requires the Town of Apple Valley to submit a claim and request(s) for reimbursement; and
WHEREAS, submittal of the claim for TDA Article 3 funds must be first authorized by the Town Council; and

Resolution 2022-04
WHEREAS, the Bear Valley Road Bridge Connector Project award is over $200,000, and is eligible for progress reimbursement, or under, and eligible for reimbursement at project completion; and
WHEREAS, SBCTA requires the designation of individuals authorized to certify Project completion; and

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE TOWN COUNCIL OF THE TOWN OF APPLE VALLEY AS FOLLOWS:

Section 1. That the Town authorizes submittal of a claim and request for reimbursement(s) for TDA Article 3 funds for the Bear Valley Road Bridge Connector Project in the amount of $232,300; and
Section 2. That the Town Manager is authorized to certify project completion; and Section 3. That the Town Clerk shall certify to the passage and adoption of this resolution and enter it into the book of original resolutions.

ADOPTED AND APPROVED by the Town Council of the Town of Apple Valley this 8
th day of February 2022.

Kari Leon
Mayor
ATTEST:

La Vonda M. Pearson
Town Clerk

Town Council Agenda Report
Date: February 8, 2022
To: Honorable Mayor and Town Council
Subject: ACCEPTANCE OF WORK FOR MENDEL PARK RESTROOM

From: Douglas Robertson, Town Manager
Submitted by: Silvia Urenda, HCD Specialist II
Housing
Budgeted Item: Yes No N/A

RECOMMENDED ACTION
A. Accept the work completed by TSR Construction Inc. for the Mendel Park Restroom. Total contract amount was $223,700.00
B. Direct the Town Clerk to file the Notice of Completion for the contract work.

C. Direct the Finance Director to release the retained funds 30 days after the Notice of Completion has been filed, provided no claims are filed against the contractor.

BACKGROUND
The Mendel Park Restroom Project provided the purchase and installation of a permanent ADA-accessible restroom with direct access. The Project generally consists of providing necessary labor, equipment, and materials to remove an existing tree and plant a new tree, install a new prefabricated pre-cast concrete dual restroom unit, a new septic tank, and leaching system, a new water line from a new water meter to new restrooms, and install a new electrical meter and run new electrical from new main panel to new restroom.

ANALYSIS
Building and Safety inspected the project area and deemed the work to be complete and acceptable.

FISCAL IMPACT
Funding for this project has been appropriated in the adopted FY 2018-2019 budget under Community Development Block Grant (CDBG).

ATTACHMENTS
A. Project Location.

B. Notice of Completion.

Project Location

Town Council Agenda Report
Date: February 8, 2022
To: Honorable Mayor and Town Council
Subject: RESOLUTION 2022-05, TO RECORD DELINQUENT UTILITY FEES

AND COSTS AGAINST REAL PROPERTY LOCATED IN THE TOWN

OF APPLE VALLEY AND DIRECTING THAT SAID ASSESSMENTS

CONSTITUTE A LIEN UPON SAID PROPERTIES

From: Douglas Robertson, Town Manager
Submitted by: Sydnie Harris, Director of Finance
Finance Department
Budgeted Item: Yes No N/A
RECOMMENDED ACTION:

That the Town Council:

A. Open Public Hearing;
B. Adopt Resolution No. 2022-05, confirming delinquent utility fees and costs against real property located in the Town, and directing that said assessments constitute a lien upon said properties.

C. Close Public Hearing.

SUMMARY:

Each year the Town initiates and records liens on real property for all delinquent utility fees as permitted in the Government Code. This report identifies all delinquent utility accounts and approves Resolution No. 2022-05 initiating and approving the winter lien process.

BACKGROUND:

The Government Code allows cities to collect delinquent rubbish collection and sewer fees by recording a lien against the real property and adding that amount to the property tax bill. The Town has identified the delinquent accounts as those listed in Exhibit A.

All the billing parties and the property owners have received sufficient notification of the delinquency and have been notified of the Public Hearing to apply the delinquency to the property tax bill. For delinquent rubbish collection accounts, please see the flow chart attached (Attachment 1) which illustrates how many times the delinquent rubbish collection billing parties and property owners have been notified. The correspondence also offers an opportunity to make corrections. A sample of one of the letters is also attached (Attachment 2).

In addition to the notices and this Public Hearing, Town Finance staff allows billing parties and property owners until Thursday, February 17th, 2022, to pay the delinquency before the lien is processed.

FISCAL IMPACT:

None.

ATTACHMENTS:

1. Resolution No. 2022-05

2. Exhibit A – Town of Apple Valley Winter Lien 2022

3. Attachment 1 – Sample Sequence of Delinquent Notification

4. Attachment 2 – Owner Delinquent Letter

Resolution 2022-05
RESOLUTION NO. 2022-05

A RESOLUTION OF THE TOWN COUNCIL OF THE TOWN

OF APPLE VALLEY, CALIFORNIA, CONFIRMING

DELINQUENT UTILITY FEES AND COSTS AGAINST

REAL PROPERTY LOCATED IN THE TOWN OF APPLE

VALLEY AND DIRECTING THAT SAID ASSESSMENTS

CONSTITUTE A LIEN UPON SAID PROPERTIES
WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 38773.5 of the Government Code and Town Ordinances enacted pursuant thereto, the Town of Apple Valley has prepared a report setting forth the costs of delinquent utility fees on certain real property within the Town, and.

WHEREAS, having received and considered said report, and having noticed the affected property owners and given them an opportunity to be heard.

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, FOUND, DETERMINED AND

ORDERED BY THE TOWN COUNCIL OF THE TOWN OF APPLE VALLEY, CALIFORNIA, AS FOLLOWS:

1. The report setting forth the costs of delinquent utility fees and a description of each property upon which an assessment is made, copies of which is attached hereto and incorporated herein by this reference, is confirmed.

2. A certified copy of the confirmed report shall be filed with the Town Clerk.

3. A certified copy of the Resolution of Confirmation shall be transmitted to the Recorder of the County of San Bernardino for recording and to the Assessor and Tax Collector of the County of San Bernardino and after recordation, shall constitute special assessments against the property to which they relate, and shall constitute liens on the property in the amount of the assessment to be added to the tax bill next levied against the property.

APPROVED and ADOPTED, by the Town Council of the Town of Apple Valley this 8 th
day of February 2022.
______________________________
MAYOR, Kari Leon
ATTEST:
______________________________
TOWN CLERK, La Vonda M-Pearson

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 1 0399 271 05 0000 329993 JESS RANCH BREA RETAIL XVI,LLC 18825 BEAR VALLEY ROAD 92308 $ 760.39 2 0399 271 05 0000 331551 JESS RANCH BREA RETAIL 18825 BEAR VALLEY ROAD 92308 $ 1,690.06 3 0399 271 15 0000 331553 JESS RANCH BREA RETAIL 19035 BEAR VALLEY ROAD 92308 $ 370.41 4 0399 271 22 0000 329996 JESS RANCH BREA RETAIL XVI,LLC 19059 BEAR VALLEY ROAD 92308 $ 566.82 5 0399 281 28 0000 331631 THEODORE ALEXANDER JAMES 19221 ELM DR 92308 $ 808.56 6 0399 282 26 0000 331713 LYDIA PHILLIS BROWN 19181 ELM DR 92308 $ 457.20 7 0399 282 46 0000 331669 RENE J WALTON 19190 PALO VERDE DR 92308 $ 130.66 8 0399 292 09 0000 330702 BROOKHOLLOW PROPERTIES LLC 19267 PALO VERDE DR 92308 $ 499.08 9 0399 293 10 0000 330677 BROOKHOLLOW II LLC 19219 PALO VERDE DR 92308 $ 345.71 10 0399 293 23 0000 331256 MICHELE LANE 19245 PALO VERDE DR 92308 $ 365.20 11 0399 293 25 0000 330709 BROOKHOLLOW PROPERTIES LLC 19249 PALO VERDE DR 92308 $ 499.08 12 0399 301 07 0000 330654 OLIVIA DAVIE 19264 PINE WAY 92308 $ 245.32 13 0399 301 11 0000 331740 CHERYL L HOOPER 11590 PEPPER LANE 92308 $ 1,630.28 14 0399 301 59 0000 330692 TODD M SANDBERG 19235 PINE WAY 92308 $ 588.18 15 0399 302 17 0000 331520 SHARON E HENRY 11543 WINIFRED DR 92308 $ 399.65 16 0399 302 46 0000 330754 TIMOTHY JUST 11563 SUNSET PL 92308 $ 607.47 17 0399 302 52 0000 331380 ANNA R MAYO 11536 SUNSET PLC 92308 $ 334.42 18 0399 302 59 0000 330776 RONALD JAMES 11530 WINIFRED DR 92308 $ 607.21 19 0399 302 69 0000 330201 ERICA THOTOS 19193 PINE WAY 92308 $ 371.77 20 0399 311 14 0000 331777 MARK KUYPER 19134 ELM DR 92308 $ 279.12 21 0399 311 17 0000 331341 MAGDALENA M SANCHEZ 19122 ELM DR 92308 $ 566.63 22 0399 311 38 0000 329957 CLEO MCLAIN 11730 OAK ST 92308 $ 408.24 23 0399 312 14 0000 330624 RICHARD HIGH 19073 ELM DR 92308 $ 605.22 24 0399 312 25 0000 331307 MANUEL FRANCO 19136 CEDAR DR 92308 $ 491.18 25 0399 312 30 0000 331765 RICHARD THURLOW 19082 CEDAR DR 92308 $ 108.15 26 0399 312 45 0000 330102 CHRISTENA HANSON 19022 CEDAR DR 92308 $ 585.12 27 0399 313 14 0000 331591 KKTL LLC 11681 CEDAR CT 92308 $ 268.46 28 0399 313 22 0000 330800 RITA J HATHEWAY 11679 CEDAR PL 92308 $ 576.95 29 0399 313 29 0000 331592 CALIFORNIA IHFC LLC 11680 ASH ST 92308 $ 634.31 30 0399 321 11 0000 330779 THEODORE EARL VICK 19088 FRANCES ST 92308 $ 527.14 31 0399 326 10 0000 330171 MARTHA A BERTHELET 19013 FRANCES ST 92308 $ 558.93 32 0399 326 19 0000 330575 DONALD LEIS 19050 PRIMROSE LN 92308 $ 573.06 33 0399 331 01 0000 330031 MELANIE MARION VARGAS 19091 OAK ST 92308 $ 527.19 34 0399 333 37 0000 331707 ROLAND ROJAS 11568 MOUNTAIN MEADOW DR 92308 $ 268.46 35 0399 334 18 0000 330200 NELSON 11542 OAK ST 92308 $ 436.28 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 36 0399 391 15 0000 330763 ROBERT G FINDLING 19213 CASTANA ST 92308 $ 568.99 37 0399 401 01 0000 331376 JOHN WONG 18938 ALPINE ST 92308 $ 594.88 38 0399 411 03 0000 331315 MARK SHANE ESPINOSA 11414 RIVER RUN ST 92308 $ 1,284.32 39 0399 411 33 0000 331378 KIMBERLY A VAN DORN 18967 ALPINE ST 92308 $ 141.59 40 0399 421 53 0000 331453 ALBERT SOSA 18868 LATIGO ST 92308 $ 665.05 41 0434 021 62 0000 331524 FORREST D REV TR ANGELOPOULOS 19311 BEAR VALLEY ROAD 92308 $ 314.82 42 0434 032 17 0000 330708 WILLIAM WALTER MC MINN 11875 COTTONTAIL LN 92308 $ 370.62 43 0434 033 06 0000 330625 OCHOA, URIEL LIVING TRUST EST OF 11624 COTTONTAIL LN 92308 $ 257.02 44 0434 033 12 0000 329984 MARISELA VALDOVINOS REV TR 9/ LEYVA 11549 COTTONTAIL LANE 92308 $ 207.44 45 0434 033 12 0000 330645 MARISELA/MARIA/ROSILINDA LEYVA/VALDOVINOS 11825 COTTONTAIL LN 92308 $ 267.34 46 0434 033 36 0000 330597 ARTURO RAMIREZ 11363 COTTONTAIL LN 92308 $ 442.42 47 0434 042 30 0000 330670 BRIAN ST JOHN 20159 WISCONSIN ST 92308 $ 325.07 48 0434 051 12 0000 330074 JACOB/LIAH ATTWOOD 20572 DEL ORO ROAD 92308 $ 269.36 49 0434 051 34 0000 330630 PIERRE ABOUJAOUDE 20606 DOMINGUEZ RD 92308 $ 252.53 50 0434 051 56 0000 330112 JOHNNY & MICHELLE DUTTO 11577 MERINO AVE 92308 $ 146.13 51 0434 063 42 0000 331232 HSIEN LIN YANG 21460 DEL ORO RD 92308 $ 260.58 52 0434 171 04 0000 331429 MICHAEL & TABITHA ALVEY 11236 DOLPHIN AVE 92308 $ 239.58 53 0434 171 08 0000 330701 JOSE M MANZO 11180 DOLPHIN AV 92308 $ 239.08 54 0434 172 02 0000 331331 ANGELINA F F MARTINEZ 20791 DEL ORO RD 92308 $ 327.39 55 0434 172 08 0000 330764 GINO CORTEZ RODRIGUEZ 20885 DEL ORO RD 92308 $ 526.65 56 0434 172 12 0000 330622 CLARA P WRIGHT 11240 KIOWA PL 92308 $ 237.73 57 0434 172 14 0000 331665 JONATHAN D MEZA 11236 KIOWA PLC 92308 $ 724.03 58 0434 172 21 0000 330192 SUSAN ALLEN 11190 CARIBOU AV 92308 $ 423.84 59 0434 173 04 0000 331480 JOHN M WILSON 11169 CARIBOU AVE 92308 $ 213.87 60 0434 173 14 0000 331228 PEDRO H GALVAN 11090 LANCELET AVE 92308 $ 588.41 61 0434 173 15 0000 331229 IO REVOCABLE LIVING TRUST 11080 LANCELET AV 92308 $ 342.70 62 0434 175 01 0000 331147 ROBERT KEVIN SCOTT 10911 CARIBOU AVE 92308 $ 588.41 63 0434 175 12 0000 330668 JOHN P & CLIFFORD L WALKER 11081 CARIBOU AV 92308 $ 283.18 64 0434 176 03 0000 331435 FLORENCIO CARRILLO 10941 LANCELET AVE 92308 $ 588.41 65 0434 176 12 0000 331360 TRINIDAD REYES 11002 MERINO AVE 92308 $ 264.43 66 0434 177 16 0000 330766 MANUEL FABELA 10989 MERINO AV 92308 $ 449.03 67 0434 181 07 0000 330697 CAROL ROBIDOUX 10717 CARIBOU AV 92308 $ 320.91 68 0434 181 18 0000 331571 MAS REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS VII L 10864 LANCELET AVE 92308 $ 212.85 69 0434 181 28 0000 330136 CASEY GREENE 10722 LANCELET AVE 92308 $ 212.69 70 0434 183 20 0000 330762 ANTHONY R OLGUIN 10711 LANCELET AV 92308 $ 441.92 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 71 0434 191 02 0000 330760 DAWN HARVELL 20131 MONTE VISTA ST 92308 $ 491.24 72 0434 191 19 0000 329938 CALEB I CHRISTENSEN 11116 MOCKINGBIRD AVE 92308 $ 384.87 73 0434 191 20 0000 330742 HESPERIA 26 ASSET HOLDINGS LLC HESPERIA 26 ASSET HL 20214 MONTE VISTA ST 92308 $ 242.18 74 0434 191 21 0000 330725 HESPERIA 26 ASSET HOLDINGS LLC 20212 MONTE VISTA ST 92308 $ 242.18 75 0434 191 51 0000 331076 WHY SONG 20225 MONTE VISTA ST 92308 $ 592.81 76 0434 191 65 0000 330689 MARK MC COMBS 11101 BRISBANE AV 92308 $ 269.36 77 0434 191 65 0000 330358 MARK MCCOMBS 11101 BRISBANE AV 92308 $ 1,198.30 78 0434 211 19 0000 331649 JUSTIN MASLEY 21116 VALENCIA ST 92308 $ 393.14 79 0434 213 04 0000 330792 MARCIA HAWKINS 20940 RAMBLING RD 92308 $ 245.39 80 0434 214 02 0000 331125 WILLIE E JOHNSON 10821 KIOWA ROAD 92308 $ 364.94 81 0434 215 16 0000 330863 KIM N LE 21230 VALENCIA ST 92308 $ 187.34 82 0434 215 19 0000 331321 ROBERT J THOMASSON 21186 VALENCIA ST 92308 $ 269.36 83 0434 215 22 0000 331393 ARMIJO/CHRISTINA LARES 21148 RAMBLING ROAD 92308 $ 588.41 84 0434 216 03 0000 331108 LEONA F SHERMAN 21101 VALENCIA ST 92308 $ 538.90 85 0434 216 20 0000 330223 JAY S GRIGSBY 21226 WISTERIA ST 92308 $ 227.16 86 0434 217 07 0000 330879 FRANCISCO JR DECASAS 21205 WISTERIA ST 92308 $ 327.39 87 0434 217 23 0000 330907 JA HALL TRUST 1986 04/23/1986 21144 VERDE DR 92308 $ 420.17 88 0434 217 23 0000 331667 JA HALL TRUST 1986 21144 VERDE DR 92308 $ 833.22 89 0434 221 07 0000 330839 KAREN DURSTON 10679 RAMBLING RD 92308 $ 256.32 90 0434 223 15 0000 330817 STEVEN JEFFRIES 21202 BALSA ST 92308 $ 324.35 91 0434 223 15 0000 329997 STEVE JEFFRIES 21202 BALSA ST 92308 $ 752.45 92 0434 224 06 0000 330577 VALERIE GOODWIN 21193 BALSA ST 92308 $ 266.73 93 0434 224 10 0000 330402 PHYLLIS BUYS 21253 BALSA ST 92308 $ 247.75 94 0434 224 14 0000 331638 CAROLINA VIRAMONTES 21228 ROSEWOOD ST 92308 $ 340.40 95 0434 224 15 0000 330837 RAYMOND & LYNDOANA WOODS 21208 ROSEWOOD ST 92308 $ 256.32 96 0434 224 20 0000 331461 REYNALDO B ROMERO 21122 ROSEWOOD ST 92308 $ 405.16 97 0434 225 06 0000 331623 MARIA YANEZ 10538 MOHAWK ROAD 92308 $ 237.17 98 0434 231 01 0000 331693 MARIE CHEEK 10721 MOHAWK ROAD 92308 $ 625.87 99 0434 231 07 0000 330854 PERCY MARTIN 10823 MOHAWK RD 92308 $ 242.43 100 0434 231 07 0000 330036 PERCY MARTIN 10823 MOHAWK ROAD 92308 $ 767.33 101 0434 231 09 0000 331206 YVETTE REBECCA CURRY 10855 MOHAWK ROAD 92308 $ 277.40 102 0434 231 10 0000 330128 STEPHANIE/FERNANDO CARDENAS 10873 MOHAWK ROAD 92308 $ 588.41 103 0434 231 21 0000 331500 EVELYN BARAKAT 10712 NANDINA ST 92308 $ 248.04 104 0434 232 12 0000 330144 JOSHUA/SONIA OLVERA 10872 KIAVAN ROAD 92308 $ 255.17 105 0434 234 04 0000 330939 ARMANDO TORRES 10791 NANDINA ST 92308 $ 261.37 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 106 0434 234 05 0000 330928 MICHAEL E NITSCHE 10827 NANDINA ST 92308 $ 215.40 107 0434 235 01 0000 329940 ZERO LANE CRABTREE 21516 TUSSING RANCH ROAD 92308 $ 460.14 108 0434 235 18 0000 331000 MAELI GIORGE 10277 KIAVAN RD 92308 $ 803.13 109 0434 236 05 0000 330524 LI LU 10686 JAMUL RD 92308 $ 221.05 110 0434 236 07 0000 330931 IGNACIO D MARTINEZ 10662 JAMUL RD 92308 $ 256.69 111 0434 236 07 0000 331204 IGNACIO MARTINEZ 10662 JAMUL RD 92308 $ 846.60 112 0434 236 26 0000 330806 LANCE E OLSON 10615 BALSA ST 92308 $ 282.39 113 0434 236 27 0000 331529 HECTOR ULISES MARTINEZ 10627 BALSA ST 92308 $ 146.99 114 0434 237 11 0000 331202 MATEO ALVAREZ RODRIGUEZ 10612 BALSA ST 92308 $ 133.87 115 0434 237 13 0000 330130 MARIA F. CALVO 10590 BALSA CT 92308 $ 241.92 116 0434 237 16 0000 331609 BRIAN CHARLES EGGER 10560 BALSA CT 92308 $ 188.42 117 0434 241 18 0000 329982 DOUGLAS C DOLAN 10750 PINOLE ROAD 92308 $ 563.75 118 0434 242 15 0000 330410 ROBERT CAMPBELL 10852 NAVAJO RD 92308 $ 278.29 119 0434 243 14 0000 329912 TONI WEIR 10717 PINOLE ROAD 92308 $ 603.80 120 0434 244 04 0000 330832 RANDY R THORNELL 10565 KIAVAN RD 92308 $ 352.03 121 0434 244 10 0000 330937 JOHN P SR ATWATER 10649 KIAVAN RD 92308 $ 231.52 122 0434 244 25 0000 330804 NATALIE CADY 10578 TECOPA RD 92308 $ 256.69 123 0434 271 14 0000 330860 RAFAEL SOTELO 21183 SANDIA RD 92308 $ 282.39 124 0434 271 17 0000 330900 MAS REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS VII L 21225 SANDIA RD 92308 $ 326.49 125 0434 271 28 0000 330887 LYDIA CASTILLO 11540 PAGOSI RD 92308 $ 290.68 126 0434 271 30 0000 330858 MARIA GUILLEN 11502 PAGOSI RD 92308 $ 264.38 127 0434 281 03 0000 331430 CYNTHYA SALAZAR 21061 SANDIA ROAD 92308 $ 256.73 128 0434 281 11 0000 330578 9 & 20 WELTE 21080 CHAMA RD 92308 $ 267.22 129 0434 283 01 0000 331280 DEBRA GARCIA 11475 CHIMAYO ROAD 92308 $ 206.35 130 0434 291 06 0000 330828 MARVIN EVERLING, PHYLLIS REEDY 11515 KIOWA RD 92308 $ 282.39 131 0434 291 28 0000 330400 JOHN CASSEL 11542 CHIMAYO RD 92308 $ 200.61 132 0434 291 29 0000 330961 ERNESTO GUERRERO 11536 CHIMAYO RD 92308 $ 256.32 133 0434 293 06 0000 331189 ALFRED LUCATERO 11585 CHIMAYO RD 92308 $ 188.80 134 0434 302 01 0000 330932 TIMOTHY ALAN BOOCK 11486 PAGOSI RD 92308 $ 282.39 135 0434 303 02 0000 331475 ANTHONY FLORES 11480 MOHAWK ROAD 92308 $ 588.39 136 0434 305 02 0000 330407 ANGEL & CYNTHIA ZARAGOZA 11434 CIBOLA RD 92308 $ 336.67 137 0434 305 12 0000 331123 MACK BLANKENSHIP 11385 CHIMAYO ROAD 92308 $ 570.24 138 0434 311 03 0000 331426 JIM ROGERS 11425 KIOWA ROAD 92308 $ 450.06 139 0434 311 04 0000 330818 LEANDREA SIMS 11441 KIOWA RD 92308 $ 282.39 140 0434 312 08 0000 330959 ERIC W SLONCIK 11484 CHIMAYO RD 92308 $ 256.69 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 141 0434 322 11 0000 330212 RANDALL L STINEBRING 11325 OTOWI RD 92308 $ 249.81 142 0434 331 11 0000 330830 PAMELA R BARTLETT 11335 PAGOSI RD 92308 $ 269.36 143 0434 331 19 0000 331087 GEORGE MAIN 11350 CHIMAYO LANE 92308 $ 1,157.21 144 0434 332 05 0000 331238 JUAN ROMERO 11369 MOHAWK ROAD 92308 $ 340.13 145 0434 341 13 0000 331270 ERIN H RODRIGUEZ 10882 SARATOGA ROAD 92308 $ 741.16 146 0434 342 09 0000 331100 JOHN L THOMPSON 21065 DEL ORO ROAD 92308 $ 588.41 147 0434 343 13 0000 331145 AUGUSTIN ESPAIN 21220 TRUCHAS ROAD 92308 $ 588.41 148 0434 343 16 0000 331743 HOCHAN & ALEXANDRA CHUNG 21176 NEOLA ROAD 92308 $ 482.66 149 0434 344 06 0000 331388 KRISTIN WINKLER 11187 MOHAWK ROAD 92308 $ 200.93 150 0434 345 04 0000 330912 CYNTHIA L MEDINA 11151 TRUCHAS RD 92308 $ 372.55 151 0434 346 17 0000 330083 HECTOR/ALVARRAN ANZESTIGA 11076 MOKI CT 92308 $ 160.68 152 0434 346 19 0000 330560 ELIZABETH ANDERSON 11070 MOKI CT 92308 $ 259.91 153 0434 348 15 0000 331095 BARBARA SHANEFIELD 21138 CARIBOU ROAD 92308 $ 588.41 154 0434 348 16 0000 330994 PATRICIA SERRET 21126 CARIBOU RD 92308 $ 209.70 155 0434 351 21 0000 330165 OLIVIA FLORES 10930 NEOLA ROAD 92308 $ 293.19 156 0434 351 29 0000 330789 JEFFERY R MEEKS 20970 WREN ST 92308 $ 326.30 157 0434 352 15 0000 329910 JERRY HINKLE 10985 NEOLA ROAD 92308 $ 229.86 158 0434 354 10 0000 330215 JOHN CASSEL 11060 TRUCHAS RD 92308 $ 271.61 159 0434 354 18 0000 331679 L BEST 21130 NEOLA ROAD 92308 $ 454.92 160 0434 355 07 0000 330584 GLORIA CAMPOS 11006 MOHAWK RD 92308 $ 256.89 161 0434 355 07 0000 331613 GLORIA CAMPOS 11006 MOHAWK ROAD 92308 $ 667.87 162 0434 355 12 0000 330409 JOHN CASSEL 11015 TRUCHAS RD 92308 $ 271.61 163 0434 357 07 0000 330028 ROSA ISELA FIGUEROA 21215 NEOLA ROAD 92308 $ 239.08 164 0434 357 19 0000 331783 ROSEMARY LIMA 21150 WREN ST 92308 $ 568.05 165 0434 362 05 0000 331386 DENA HARRIS 11975 KIOWA ROAD 92308 $ 421.44 166 0434 362 12 0000 330078 WILLIAM GOMEZ 11934 CHIMAYO ROAD 92308 $ 588.42 167 0434 364 02 0000 330949 MANUEL ENRIQUEZ 11931 PUYE RD 92308 $ 245.41 168 0434 364 14 0000 330406 ENRIQUE ARROYO 11910 PECOS RD 92308 $ 249.81 169 0434 365 02 0000 331137 RONALD FRANCIS 11975 PECOS RD 92308 $ 396.42 170 0434 365 07 0000 330847 ERIKA VASQUEZ 21145 LAGUNA CT 92308 $ 180.62 171 0434 366 13 0000 330974 MELINDA MURRAY 11995 OMAK RD 92308 $ 256.32 172 0434 366 14 0000 329970 MARLINE MOORE LIVING TRUST 11999 OMAK ROAD 92308 $ 198.88 173 0434 366 17 0000 330569 THOMAS L STEWART 11976 MOHAWK RD 92308 $ 327.39 174 0434 372 09 0000 331483 ZONIA/VINCENT GALINDO 11990 WAPATO ROAD 92308 $ 727.57 175 0434 373 08 0000 330795 GLORIA M/JORGE A ESCALANTE 11829 PASCO RD 92308 $ 221.56 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 176 0434 375 06 0000 330935 PUI-YUE TRUST 11/6/87 TSUI 11936 PASCO RD 92308 $ 325.07 177 0434 385 08 0000 331455 JUAN CARLOS MORAN BECERRA 11734 CHIMAYO ROAD 92308 $ 242.53 178 0434 385 10 0000 331451 MONICA H VELASQUEZ 11711 KIOWA ROAD 92308 $ 213.87 179 0434 385 16 0000 330382 WILLIAM GRIFFIN 11817 KIOWA RD 92308 $ 408.40 180 0434 391 04 0000 331560 CHRISTINE MONTEZ 21030 SANDIA ROAD 92308 $ 627.23 181 0434 391 08 0000 330991 JOHN M KING 21033 MALIBU RD 92308 $ 478.05 182 0434 394 06 0000 330819 PETER LITVIN 11824 PECOS RD 92308 $ 282.39 183 0434 401 03 0000 330384 BRANDON BASS 21168 SANDIA RD 92308 $ 586.17 184 0434 401 11 0000 330990 VICTORIA CROSBIE 21165 COWICHAN RD 92308 $ 282.80 185 0434 411 03 0000 331489 LEOBARDO JR PADILLA 11743 MOHAWK ROAD 92308 $ 277.91 186 0434 411 06 0000 330867 MONCADA, ANTHONEY MONCADA,HELEN 11791 MOHAWK RD 92308 $ 298.28 187 0434 413 11 0000 331521 JASON P SAMP 21174 COWICHAN ROAD 92308 $ 537.52 188 0434 441 11 0000 330968 ROSS JR HAAS 11724 JAMACHA RD 92308 $ 256.69 189 0434 442 08 0000 330849 ALBERT FRUEAN 12080 MORNING STAR RD 92308 $ 290.95 190 0434 442 09 0000 331019 MARK A DONADO 21580 LAGUNA RD 92308 $ 296.77 191 0434 443 07 0000 331007 LESLEY K LUNA 21690 LAGUNA RD 92308 $ 607.24 192 0434 443 10 0000 330846 WILLIAM M BOYD 21640 LAGUNA RD 92308 $ 256.45 193 0434 444 08 0000 331421 NATHAN A CULLUM 11900 MORNING STAR ROAD 92308 $ 588.41 194 0434 445 10 0000 331465 NORMAN MCLEOD 11870 RUNNING DEER ROAD 92308 $ 340.93 195 0434 445 22 0000 330979 PATRICIA N FRANKLIN 11925 JAMACHA RD 92308 $ 129.63 196 0434 446 09 0000 330868 JANINE 10-14 THREET 11833 MORNING STAR RD 92308 $ 52.07 197 0434 446 10 0000 331192 MICHAEL & TERRI GREENE 11845 MORNING STAR ROAD 92308 $ 588.41 198 0434 446 14 0000 331691 DOMINIQUE KELLY 11875 MORNING STAR ROAD 92308 $ 315.63 199 0434 446 15 0000 329921 NELIE QUIROZ 11885 MORNING STAR ROAD 92308 $ 86.95 200 0434 451 22 0000 331131 MANUEL GONZALEZ 21485 DEL ORO ROAD 92308 $ 360.16 201 0434 451 38 0000 330138 DANIEL/IRENE FERCH 11283 TECOPA ROAD 92308 $ 256.94 202 0434 451 41 0000 330889 DIANE CROSSLIEN 11114 NAVAJO RD 92308 $ 257.09 203 0434 451 62 0000 331670 ABEL FLORES 11275 LOVIA LANE 92308 $ 105.92 204 0434 461 48 0000 330039 ADAM AMICK 10921 MOHAWK ROAD 92308 $ 547.47 205 0434 461 52 0000 330842 DEENEICE GOODSON 10992 TECOPA RD 92308 $ 256.32 206 0434 571 16 0000 330126 REFUGIO GONZALEZ 20841 OTOWI ROAD 92308 $ 439.03 207 0434 571 17 0000 330632 NORBEL RIVAS 20827 OTOWI RD 92308 $ 257.02 208 0434 601 15 0000 330391 DONALD PRAXMARER 11684 SANDIA PL 92308 $ 275.51 209 0434 701 31 0000 330044 PAUL ALLMAN 11600 RIDGEMARK ROAD 92308 $ 362.22 210 0434 711 08 0000 330643 JEFF MOORE 11357 COUNTRY CLUB DR 92308 $ 402.11 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 211 0434 711 91 0000 330637 EARNEST WEBB 11400 COUNTRY CLUB DR 92308 $ 349.88 212 0434 721 08 0000 331678 DANIEL LAVIGNE 19627 ROLLING GREENS DR 92308 $ 262.58 213 0434 721 36 0000 331600 DAVID SANTOS 11170 COUNTRY CLUB DR 92308 $ 142.86 214 0434 721 47 0000 330025 FERNANDO VALDEZ 19619 IRONSIDE ROAD 92308 $ 1,284.32 215 0434 731 19 0000 330194 OTIS DUREN 11230 BUNKER CIR 92308 $ 54.61 216 0434 731 27 0000 330627 FREIHOFF FAMILY LIVING TRUST 11252 COUNTRY CLUB DR 92308 $ 262.58 217 0434 744 08 0000 330646 JOSE VILLAMIZAR 11045 WATERWOOD ST 92308 $ 619.16 218 0434 744 11 0000 330009 PATRICK S FRERICKS 11061 WATERWOOD ST 92308 $ 473.91 219 0434 744 49 0000 331318 SERGIO J & ELIZABETH REV T SALVADOR 11063 SEMMERING CT 92308 $ 393.63 220 0434 744 56 0000 330163 RUSSEL W PLOTT 11083 PORT ROYALE CT 92308 $ 477.14 221 0434 751 06 0000 330710 CAROL A STAPEL 11152 LINDSAY LN 92308 $ 554.49 222 0434 761 05 0000 330653 DONALD W MACKEY 11167 AVONLEA RD 92308 $ 343.74 223 0434 771 61 0000 330712 LINDA S BESERRA 19370 GALLOPING HILL RD 92308 $ 119.29 224 0434 781 07 0000 330644 MAJOR T ELLIS 10988 ROCKAWAY GLEN RD 92308 $ 122.40 225 0434 791 18 0000 330647 DOLORES A VILLACARLOS 19533 VERMILLION LN 92308 $ 461.24 226 0434 801 30 0000 330634 VU FAMILY TRUST 10827 ASTER LN 92308 $ 692.55 227 0434 811 04 0000 331281 QUIANA & VEANTEA BURNSIDE 10804 ASTER LANE 92308 $ 527.69 228 0434 811 08 0000 330038 LAWRENCE E JR TAYLOR 10793 ASTER LANE 92308 $ 279.97 229 0434 811 27 0000 330713 JOSHUA MICHAEL FUENTES 19761 CHICORY CT 92308 $ 631.86 230 0434 811 30 0000 329980 CECILIA RODRIGUEZ 19737 CHICORY CT 92308 $ 492.33 231 0434 821 05 0000 330696 ALBERTUS VAN DER HULST 11034 DANDELION LN 92308 $ 638.72 232 0434 841 04 0000 330638 BART J RATNER 11252 DANDELION LN 92308 $ 607.21 233 0434 841 15 0000 330640 MICHAEL WALLACE 11249 DATURA LN 92308 $ 692.55 234 0434 871 50 0000 331374 ANTOINETTE FULLERTON 10506 NOBLETON ROAD 92308 $ 141.59 235 0434 881 02 0000 330651 DOLORES J PILGRIM 10626 BRIDGE HAVEN RD 92308 $ 607.21 236 0434 881 12 0000 330746 BETTY D FAMILY TRUST 10-14-0 PARLET 10534 BRIDGE HAVEN RD 92308 $ 242.51 237 0434 891 36 0000 330652 RICHARD E FERRATO 10684 BRIDGE HAVEN RD 92308 $ 631.86 238 0434 931 33 0000 330750 HYO S KIM 10501 GREEN VALLEY RD 92308 $ 527.19 239 0437 021 12 0000 329880 VERONICA BECERRA 16762 CENTURY PLANT ROAD 92307 $ 333.84 240 0437 021 12 0000 329868 VERONICA BECERRA 16762 CENTURY PLANT ROAD 92307 $ 1,153.85 241 0437 031 01 0000 331203 ROSEMARIE IRREVOCABLE 10 & 14 READ 16643 OCOTILLA RD 92307 $ 223.07 242 0437 032 10 0000 330268 SHANNON SMOCK 16710 CANDLEWOOD RD 92307 $ 275.21 243 0437 032 10 0000 331176 MATHHEW & SHANNON SMOCK 16710 CANDLEWOOD ROAD 92307 $ 494.50 244 0437 034 06 0000 331121 KERI DOWNING 16616 MESQUITE ROAD 92307 $ 588.41 245 0437 062 22 0000 330279 BENJAMIN A FELIX 15088 MESQUITE RD 92307 $ 249.81 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 246 0437 062 29 0000 329884 KEITH FAIER 22788 STANDING ROCK AVE 92307 $ 733.23 247 0437 081 19 0000 331569 WILSON HUANG 15285 MESQUITE ROAD 92307 $ 275.64 248 0437 081 24 0000 330497 BENJAMIN FELIX 22983 BROKEN LANCE RD 92307 $ 275.20 249 0437 153 04 0000 330519 DAVID L DIETZ 16930 JOSHUA RD 92307 $ 249.81 250 0437 153 08 0000 330506 ABBAS SHARGHI 16983 CENTURY PLANT RD 92307 $ 240.09 251 0437 153 13 0000 330803 LINDA S STALEY 17037 CENTURY PLANT RD 92307 $ 207.46 252 0437 154 12 0000 330275 MARIE CHRISTINE JENNE 17025 JOSHUA RD 92307 $ 249.81 253 0437 162 10 0000 331768 JESSICA VORHAUER 23859 PAPAGO ROAD 92307 $ 530.84 254 0437 164 02 0000 331221 JOSHUA/STACY KOELLE 17133 CENTURY PLANT ROAD 92307 $ 284.85 255 0437 172 09 0000 330267 CYNTHIA H BURDEN 17241 JOSHUA RD 92307 $ 368.16 256 0437 192 03 0000 331288 ISSAC SAHAGUN 17525 CENTRAL ROAD 92307 $ 236.89 257 0437 193 03 0000 331075 4 & 29 FEENSTRA 22601 PAPAGO ROAD 92307 $ 1,072.52 258 0437 193 73 0000 329901 JAMES L BEITER 17010 LLANTO ROAD 92307 $ 367.98 259 0437 193 76 0000 331516 SUSIE LY HA 17029 LLANTO ROAD 92307 $ 156.52 260 0437 193 78 0000 330213 JANET BURCHAM 17090 MESQUITE RD 92307 $ 249.81 261 0437 212 08 0000 331340 JEFFEREY WOODS 21874 WAALEW ROAD 92307 $ 200.61 262 0437 212 15 0000 330024 SERINA/ALADINO LUCERO 17196 CARMEL LANE 92307 $ 210.61 263 0437 223 26 0000 330232 GALEN T JR LAMPHERE 22200 THUNDERBIRD RD 92307 $ 275.21 264 0437 261 03 0000 331240 ALBERTO MENDOZA LOPEZ 16436 TENAYA ROAD 92307 $ 222.86 265 0437 261 06 0000 331567 RAFAEL & MANUEL MARTINEZ & RAMIREZ 16362 TENAYA ROAD 92307 $ 265.59 266 0437 262 05 0000 330505 SHIRLEY GASKINS 16384 OCOTILLA RD 92307 $ 251.78 267 0437 272 25 0000 331485 RYAN S. BONATO 17075 OCOTILLA ROAD 92307 $ 254.94 268 0437 281 10 0000 330541 KENNETH J STILES 16958 OURAY RD 92307 $ 420.85 269 0437 281 19 0000 330259 GEORGE W GASKINS 17383 MESQUITE RD 92307 $ 249.81 270 0437 282 02 0000 331581 MICHAEL/CHELSEA DUNKIN/GONZALES 16923 OURAY ROAD 92307 $ 252.57 271 0437 301 03 0000 329931 FELIPE JR GARZA 16834 NAVAJO ROAD 92307 $ 318.49 272 0437 301 04 0000 330289 MAS REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS VII L 21742 SOBOBA RD 92307 $ 381.45 273 0437 302 10 0000 330351 SHERRY GASKILL 16701 OSAGE RD 92307 $ 830.34 274 0437 302 14 0000 329906 RUDOLFO FERNANDEZ 16817 NAVAJO ROAD 92307 $ 277.06 275 0437 302 14 0000 331703 KAYLA FERNANDEZ 16817 NAVAJO ROAD 92307 $ 589.59 276 0437 302 16 0000 331138 VAL SIMON 21795 WAALEW ROAD 92307 $ 778.24 277 0437 304 20 0000 330543 JORDAN E BLACKWELL 16624 QUINNAULT RD 92307 $ 311.17 278 0437 304 24 0000 331184 ROBERT D BELL 16548 QUINNAULT ROAD 92307 $ 347.51 279 0437 305 10 0000 330526 BRANDON THIBODEAU 16654 PAWNEE RD 92307 $ 249.81 280 0437 306 07 0000 330152 MICHAEL CAUDILLO 16615 NAVAJO ROAD 92307 $ 1,157.15 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 281 0437 306 12 0000 330238 RICHARD J SWANK 16693 NAVAJO RD 92307 $ 487.36 282 0437 321 09 0000 331243 VICTORIA PALOMINO 16819 WALPI ROAD 92307 $ 415.48 283 0437 323 04 0000 331563 MAYRA OREJEL 16641 CENTRAL ROAD 92307 $ 369.48 284 0437 325 09 0000 331593 LAURA & DONACIANO CEBALLOS 16687 PAUHASKA ROAD 92307 $ 238.14 285 0437 325 17 0000 330731 PEGGY L WILSON 22644 EL CENTRO RD 92307 $ 257.03 286 0437 331 22 0000 331507 BETTY J 1 & 30 BURKHART 16722 PAUHASKA ROAD 92307 $ 1,197.52 287 0437 333 16 0000 331142 ADAM LOBATO 22780 EL CENTRO ROAD 92307 $ 135.67 288 0437 334 16 0000 331588 DAVID / SAMANTHA COWELL 22712 NALATAPA ROAD 92307 $ 384.63 289 0437 335 03 0000 330542 CRYSTAL ALVAREZ 22743 NALATAPA RD 92307 $ 249.81 290 0437 335 08 0000 330244 TERRY & STACEY CAPPS 22821 NALATAPA RD 92307 $ 195.30 291 0437 335 17 0000 330255 CLARENCE S BROOKS 22826 SOUTH RD 92307 $ 220.43 292 0437 337 06 0000 330274 STEPHANIE KING 16731 NEENACH RD 92307 $ 406.73 293 0437 341 67 0000 331617 MARTIN FLORES 15835 CENTRAL ROAD 92307 $ 630.46 294 0437 341 68 0000 330181 LUIS NUNEZ 15829 CENTRAL RD 92307 $ 226.24 295 0437 471 34 0000 330002 GRACIELA OCHOA 16400 PAUHASKA ROAD 92307 $ 218.58 296 0437 471 35 0000 330303 BRUCE G MALCOLM 16406 PAUHASKA RD 92307 $ 288.84 297 0437 471 41 0000 330233 GINO D DI COCCO 16442 PAUHASKA RD 92307 $ 275.21 298 0437 472 10 0000 331506 SARA MAE ROSS 22747 SOUTH ROAD 92307 $ 304.65 299 0437 491 33 0000 331546 JAMES A LUKE 22352 SOUTH ROAD 92307 $ 371.58 300 0437 501 05 0000 330301 ARTHUR RAY SMITH III 21845 RESOTO RD 92307 $ 249.81 301 0437 503 04 0000 330310 ELDRIDGE & TERESA REV TRUST KIDD HUGH 16050 PAWNEE RD 92307 $ 418.40 302 0437 513 02 0000 330549 BRIAN K LOSEY 21929 CARLISLE RD 92307 $ 249.81 303 0437 521 04 0000 331436 ENRIQUE MORENO 16030 OSAGE ROAD 92307 $ 748.26 304 0437 522 07 0000 331755 RACHEL JONES 21888 MESALLERO ROAD 92307 $ 263.03 305 0437 531 23 0000 330388 GUY REEVES 16433 OCOTILLA RD 92307 $ 252.59 306 0437 571 12 0000 331173 JASON J MORRIS 17353 CENTURY PLANT ROAD 92307 $ 609.33 307 0437 611 01 0000 330511 MARIA E CALDERON FLORES 22523 CHIPETA RD 92307 $ 272.62 308 0437 651 10 0000 330493 MIKE SIMPSON 22570 CUYAMA RD 92307 $ 124.94 309 0437 651 22 0000 331589 CARMEN OJEDA 16278 LAGO VISTA CT 92307 $ 708.28 310 0437 651 32 0000 330167 MELISSA & GUTIERREZ,DANNY MOEN-RODRIGUEZ 16262 PAUHASKA ROAD 92307 $ 200.61 311 0438 043 28 0000 331627 KYLE HERRINGTON 22110 LUPINE ST 92308 $ 509.22 312 0438 043 50 0000 331242 PASCUAL & LEWIS MIRAMONTES & JABLONK 10176 CENTRAL ROAD 92308 $ 600.24 313 0438 181 09 0000 330845 IRA V JONES 10259 KIOWA RD 92308 $ 243.41 314 0438 331 33 0000 330648 ROBERT SANGER 10357 SILVERBERRY ST 92308 $ 506.41 315 0438 331 51 0000 330765 MARIO & JOANNA MEZA 10298 DAYLILY ST 92308 $ 450.86 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 316 0438 341 38 0000 329995 MICHELLE/NATHAN GARRICK 19767 GAZANIA ST 92308 $ 292.25 317 0438 341 43 0000 330737 T & L DEVELOPMENT LLC 10276 DAYLILY ST 92308 $ 126.61 318 0438 351 26 0000 331610 RITA F LIV TR 08/07/07 SWICK 10435 GLEN OAKS LANE 92308 $ 122.72 319 0438 353 11 0000 330656 JEROME P BOWEN 19469 DEL RAY RD 92308 $ 592.74 320 0438 353 23 0000 330665 ARNETT REVOCALBE LIVING TRU 10497 WILMINGTON LN 92308 $ 594.70 321 0438 362 33 0000 330678 VERNELL BLUE 10402 LAKESHORE DR 92308 $ 582.73 322 0438 372 28 0000 330081 NOEL KENT RESSE 19429 VERBENA ST 92308 $ 377.98 323 0438 382 20 0000 330752 MICHAEL HUDSON 19483 MAPLE CREEK ROAD 92308 $ 611.17 324 0438 401 12 0000 330711 THOMAS J KELLY 10341 DARBY RD 92308 $ 268.46 325 0439 013 09 0000 330559 ROBERT VICUNA 22910 RAMONA AV 92307 $ 527.49 326 0439 022 53 0000 330491 ALBA M MURCIA RIANO 23120 CHEROKEE AV 92307 $ 200.61 327 0439 052 05 0000 330076 JEFFREY BARNETT 22677 POWHATAN ROAD 92308 $ 242.18 328 0439 052 27 0000 330227 KARL J KLEIN 22764 ANOKA RD 92308 $ 249.81 329 0439 053 30 0000 330848 TONIA S FERNANDEZ 22710 EYOTA RD 92308 $ 282.39 330 0439 053 36 0000 331478 BRADLEY & KALLI COLBERT & TICE 22610 EYOTA ROAD 92308 $ 354.96 331 0439 053 38 0000 331815 SOPHIA AGUILERA 22645 ANOKA ROAD 92308 $ 303.98 332 0439 054 26 0000 331539 GENARO ZAPATA 22770 OTTAWA ROAD 92308 $ 494.66 333 0439 054 29 0000 330882 JOHN HERNANDEZ 22724 OTTAWA RD 92308 $ 282.39 334 0439 054 31 0000 331676 DANIEL JUSTO 22696 OTTAWA ROAD 92308 $ 841.79 335 0439 054 32 0000 330197 ROBERTA A BROXSON 22676 OTTAWA RD 92308 $ 370.98 336 0439 061 19 0000 329975 BLANCA/RENE/MARILYN MIRANDA 13166 NICOLA ROAD 92308 $ 266.84 337 0439 062 01 0000 330052 JUAN LUIS GUTIERREZ FLORES 13149 NICOLA ROAD 92308 $ 250.22 338 0439 062 08 0000 330919 HUNGLANG INVESTMENT GROUP INC 13253 NICOLA RD 92308 $ 325.07 339 0439 062 13 0000 331375 NILDO YAURI 13254 FRANCESKA ROAD 92308 $ 314.18 340 0439 062 19 0000 329885 LOUIE/CAROL GANZER 13166 FRANCESKA ROAD 92308 $ 1,511.11 341 0439 063 07 0000 330084 RICHARD VALDEZ 13193 FRANCESKA ROAD 92308 $ 269.36 342 0439 063 10 0000 330945 ERICA M LANCASTER 13149 FRANCESKA RD 92308 $ 266.71 343 0439 063 10 0000 331383 ERICA LANCASTER 13149 FRANCESKA RD 92308 $ 684.43 344 0439 064 02 0000 329951 JOSEPH ZIEPKE 22931 LUCILLA ROAD 92308 $ 91.70 345 0439 064 09 0000 331806 ROBERT K II BLOMKER 23039 LUCILLA ROAD 92308 $ 257.34 346 0439 122 06 0000 330844 PATRICIA ROMAN 22770 SITTING BULL RD 92308 $ 261.37 347 0439 123 08 0000 330908 JACOB & DYLAN EMANUELSON 22775 SITTING BULL RD 92308 $ 282.39 348 0439 123 15 0000 330214 MICKEY R SCHWARZENBACH 22858 LITTLE BEAVER RD 92308 $ 370.65 349 0439 123 19 0000 330196 DONNA VALDEZ 22774 LITTLE BEAVER RD 92308 $ 244.18 350 0439 123 23 0000 330101 JERRETT & TAMMY LYNN DRESSLER/ROQUEMORE 22684 LITTLE BEAVER ROAD 92308 $ 398.50 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 351 0439 123 25 0000 330085 ROSA MARTHA ORDONEZ REVOCABLE TR 22634 LITTLE BEAVER ROAD 92308 $ 833.22 352 0439 124 04 0000 330156 RAYMOND PALOMINO 22685 LITTLE BEAVER ROAD 92308 $ 1,157.21 353 0439 124 12 0000 330927 MATTHEW DAVID BOCANEGRA 22859 LITTLE BEAVER RD 92308 $ 282.80 354 0439 125 09 0000 330913 JOSHUA G ROE 12787 CENTRAL RD 92308 $ 256.25 355 0439 132 10 0000 330902 MARSHA ZACHARY 22652 LONE EAGLE RD 92308 $ 282.39 356 0439 132 12 0000 330877 GONZALO MONTANO 22700 LONE EAGLE RD 92308 $ 51.86 357 0439 133 13 0000 331744 JEAN-PIERRE BISHOP 22666 PAHUTE ROAD 92308 $ 475.14 358 0439 133 18 0000 330821 HAROLD 4-5-00 DUNN 22789 LONE EAGLE RD 92308 $ 241.72 359 0439 133 32 0000 330872 MARIA & ANTONIO GARCIA 22710 PAHUTE RD 92308 $ 280.73 360 0439 133 34 0000 331230 RAYMOND ROMO 22721 LONE EAGLE ROAD 92308 $ 1,157.21 361 0439 141 06 0000 330782 NOE ROMO 23080 MINNETONKA RD 92308 $ 441.92 362 0439 141 11 0000 330984 ANTONIO KUNZ 22976 MINNETONKA RD 92308 $ 282.39 363 0439 141 34 0000 330180 RONDA L 9 & II CLEMONS 22931 LITTLE BEAVER RD 92308 $ 209.10 364 0439 141 43 0000 330574 DIANA L. ROBERTS 22980 LONE EAGLE CT 92308 $ 263.52 365 0439 142 07 0000 331096 JERRY S MYERS 23037 MINNETONKA ROAD 92308 $ 220.13 366 0439 142 16 0000 330784 MARCOS ROMERO 23162 PAHUTE RD 92308 $ 267.02 367 0439 142 17 0000 330833 ILENE RIOS 23142 PAHUTE RD 92308 $ 256.32 368 0439 142 18 0000 329909 CHRISTIAN MARROQUIN 23120 PAHUTE ROAD 92308 $ 475.57 369 0439 251 04 0000 330986 AUDREY CRAWFORD 13191 CENTRAL RD 92308 $ 256.25 370 0439 251 18 0000 330589 GUILLERMO ABARCA 13126 TOPOCK RD 92308 $ 283.18 371 0439 252 01 0000 331496 JOSUE/LORENA ARRIZON 13145 TOPOCK ROAD 92308 $ 177.23 372 0439 262 02 0000 331673 VIRGINIA HOYLE 13141 SETANCKET ROAD 92308 $ 367.26 373 0439 291 23 0000 331497 ROGER HURTADO 22558 POWHATAN ROAD 92308 $ 577.54 374 0439 292 09 0000 331595 JUAN ALBERTO JR MONTENEGRO 22669 SHAWNEE ROAD 92308 $ 829.16 375 0439 301 10 0000 331209 DOUGLAS BETTENCOURT 22853 SHAWNEE ROAD 92308 $ 631.43 376 0439 302 02 0000 330916 DAVID/SHANNON WAGNER 22870 SHAWNEE RD 92308 $ 337.75 377 0439 304 07 0000 330489 RAYMOND JARDINE 22764 POWHATAN RD 92308 $ 238.15 378 0439 313 04 0000 330972 WILLIAM TRATZ 22853 ITASCA RD 92308 $ 240.75 379 0439 314 04 0000 329925 HEIDI CHOLEWIAK 22838 ITASCA ROAD 92308 $ 477.48 380 0439 392 31 0000 330922 GEORGE & MARY MEJIA 12438 MESQUITE RD 92308 $ 269.36 381 0439 461 19 0000 331816 FELIPE/ANA GALVEZ 22573 OJAI ROAD 92308 $ 342.37 382 0439 461 25 0000 330970 SHERIE E RUGGIERI 13055 TOPOCK RD 92308 $ 401.27 383 0439 471 10 0000 330940 ANDRE & REBECCA & FRANKLIN ELLIS & WHITE 13446 NICOLA RD 92308 $ 256.32 384 0439 471 10 0000 331200 FRANKILIN & REBECCA & ANDRE ELLIS & WHITE 13446 NICOLA ROAD 92308 $ 1,157.21 385 0439 471 28 0000 330834 DOROTHY A NEAL 13496 FRANCESKA RD 92308 $ 677.17 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 386 0439 471 33 0000 331163 LAURA/EVERETT MCLAIN/WALLER 13437 FRANCESKA ROAD 92308 $ 300.00 387 0439 471 38 0000 330864 HIGINIO/VIRGINIA BENAVIDES 13472 APPLEWOOD RD 92308 $ 386.41 388 0439 481 13 0000 330925 MARIA DEL CARMEN & GERARDO GUTIERREZ 13335 FRANCESKA RD 92308 $ 243.06 389 0439 481 20 0000 331308 JOHN O HOLTGREFE 22921 EYOTA ROAD 92308 $ 224.61 390 0439 481 38 0000 330063 KENNETH & KAREN LATIMER 13384 APPLEWOOD ROAD 92308 $ 221.34 391 0439 491 01 0000 331355 CHARLES STANLEY & ESTHER C PICKENS 13495 APPLEWOOD ROAD 92308 $ 299.74 392 0439 491 10 0000 331277 KEVIN & MEGAN OROURKE 13476 APPLE BLOSSOM LANE 92308 $ 241.27 393 0439 491 17 0000 330923 REMI & MAUREEN THOMAS 13475 APPLE BLOSSOM LN 92308 $ 256.73 394 0439 491 35 0000 329991 SALVADOR/ERNESTINE ARREDONDO 13397 DEERWOOD ROAD 92308 $ 928.05 395 0439 491 42 0000 330808 TYRON SMITH 13398 JOSHUA RD 92308 $ 237.33 396 0439 501 08 0000 330978 JASON GRANTHAM 13368 APPLE BLOSSOM LN 92308 $ 282.76 397 0439 501 22 0000 330775 CLAUDETTE PATRICIA SANTOO 13350 DEERWOOD RD 92308 $ 327.49 398 0439 501 31 0000 330815 SUSAN HALL 13386 JOSHUA RD 92308 $ 282.39 399 0439 511 08 0000 330805 PATRICIO CHAPARRO 14489 MIRADA PL 92307 $ 327.39 400 0440 021 11 0000 330495 EFREN SILVA 21099 SOUTH RD 92307 $ 230.43 401 0440 021 30 0000 331575 APRIL M SALMON 20954 WIGWAM ROAD 92307 $ 67.96 402 0440 022 07 0000 331550 RAYMOUND G TAPIA 21237 SOUTH ROAD 92307 $ 380.59 403 0440 023 03 0000 330240 DAVID QUICK 20953 WIGWAM RD 92307 $ 418.40 404 0440 024 09 0000 330547 YESENIA HERNANDEZ 21030 TEEPEE RD 92307 $ 249.81 405 0440 031 17 0000 331418 MOALLEN MAZIAR 16349 DALE EVANS PKWY 92307 $ 598.00 406 0440 032 08 0000 330581 PHILIP & CATHERINE KOREIS JOIN 16231 DALE EVANS PKWY 92307 $ 266.74 407 0440 041 20 0000 331602 JANELLE TRAYLING 15620 APACHE ROAD 92307 $ 1,180.58 408 0440 042 01 0000 331640 GEOVANNY ABRAHAM GARCIA 21094 ZUNI ROAD 92307 $ 550.75 409 0440 043 15 0000 331641 MARION L MCCANDLESS 15615 APACHE ROAD 92307 $ 1,022.72 410 0440 043 17 0000 330785 KENNETH PINKSTAFF 15640 BLACKFOOT RD 92307 $ 281.13 411 0440 043 27 0000 329987 AUSTIN WULSTEIN 15420 BLACKFOOT ROAD 92307 $ 228.60 412 0440 051 30 0000 330000 BRAD/KIMBERLY KEASLER 15394 COMANCHE ROAD 92307 $ 1,187.27 413 0440 052 08 0000 331313 N LANFORD, ROBYN/JUSTI 21130 ZUNI ROAD 92307 $ 67.96 414 0440 053 11 0000 330242 STEVE L RABELLO 15485 COMANCHE RD 92307 $ 430.27 415 0440 053 16 0000 330235 DICKEY REEDER 15591 COMANCHE RD 92307 $ 249.81 416 0440 061 01 0000 331165 CHOPPER HOLDING TRUST 21380 THUNDERBIRD ROAD 92307 $ 778.24 417 0440 061 10 0000 329979 LI ZHU CHEN 15465 CHEYENNE ROAD 92307 $ 251.73 418 0440 061 24 0000 330095 LES PALCSIK 15530 DAKOTA ROAD 92307 $ 238.30 419 0440 062 02 0000 330530 PABLO CHACON 21450 ZUNI RD 92307 $ 362.81 420 0440 062 02 0000 331586 PABLO CHACON 21450 ZUNI ROAD 92307 $ 560.33 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 421 0440 063 04 0000 330252 SAM B BODENBENDER 15325 DAKOTA RD 92307 $ 367.25 422 0440 063 18 0000 331492 EDGAR ALONSO RANGEL 21435 ZUNI ROAD 92307 $ 574.26 423 0440 071 02 0000 331736 SEAN M COLONY 21560 THUNDERBIRD ROAD 92307 $ 505.33 424 0440 071 17 0000 330247 EVA A BOGAL 15615 ERIE RD 92307 $ 397.27 425 0440 071 20 0000 330438 BRUCE S BRADY 15620 RAMONA AV 92307 $ 397.27 426 0440 071 20 0000 331114 BRUCE S BRADY 15620 RAMONA AVE 92307 $ 778.24 427 0440 071 25 0000 330042 KATHRYN A DEBOW 15506 RAMONA AVE 92307 $ 397.46 428 0440 071 28 0000 331213 JIM MATTHEW PERRY 15434 RAMONA AVE 92307 $ 775.73 429 0440 073 02 0000 331557 PHILLIP J WEBB 21660 THUNDERBIRD ROAD 92307 $ 1,170.76 430 0440 073 08 0000 330068 MARIO TORNERO 15415 RAMONA AVE 92307 $ 778.26 431 0440 073 14 0000 330514 TODD WAYNE HARTMAN 15545 RAMONA AV 92307 $ 236.86 432 0440 231 09 0000 330262 SANDRA MALAN 16520 MONTAUK RD 92307 $ 275.21 433 0440 241 07 0000 330510 LINDA RENNIE 16572 TENAJA RD 92307 $ 237.70 434 0440 241 07 0000 331298 LINDA RENNIE 16572 TENAJA ROAD 92307 $ 778.21 435 0440 241 20 0000 331463 GABRIELA S MC DONALD 16683 MONTAUK ROAD 92307 $ 778.24 436 0441 011 09 0000 331754 CRISTIAN HERNANDEZ 20848 OTOE ROAD 92307 $ 718.79 437 0441 032 82 0000 330376 ADOLFO B MEDRANO 16595 CHOCO RD 92307 $ 62.34 438 0441 052 04 0000 330237 JOHN VAUGHN 16469 CHIPPEWA RD 92307 $ 112.32 439 0441 052 04 0000 330070 JOHN VAUGHN 16469 CHIPPEWA ROAD 92307 $ 149.10 440 0441 052 05 0000 330397 CHERYL AVENDANO 16479 CHIPPEWA RD 92307 $ 743.12 441 0441 052 07 0000 331698 PD MC CABE INVESTMENTS LLC PD MC CABE INVEST. 16499 CHIPPEWA ROAD 92307 $ 614.82 442 0441 052 17 0000 330377 DARYL C RUGG 16490 ARCATA LN 92307 $ 81.09 443 0441 053 11 0000 330271 JANETTE REYES 19483 ARCATA RD 92307 $ 381.53 444 0441 053 11 0000 331151 JANETTE REYES 19483 ARCATA ROAD 92307 $ 778.24 445 0441 053 12 0000 330027 BAHJAT S RABADI 19499 ARCATA ROAD 92307 $ 207.54 446 0441 055 02 0000 331424 JESSE HERNANDEZ 19633 CORWIN ROAD 92307 $ 634.12 447 0441 055 03 0000 329930 IVAN ACOSTA 19667 CORWIN ROAD 92307 $ 255.68 448 0441 056 20 0000 330246 MURIEL EALY-BROWN 19456 ROANOKE RD 92307 $ 601.93 449 0441 057 03 0000 331747 CLIFFORD ALLEN BRACE JR 16270 CHIPPEWA ROAD 92307 $ 696.80 450 0441 061 05 0000 330362 RONALD A FAMILY TRUST 8/15/91 CROW 19463 ROANOKE RD 92307 $ 601.93 451 0441 061 17 0000 330341 DANIEL GARCIA 16258 SAINT TIMOTHY RD 92307 $ 375.77 452 0441 061 20 0000 330350 YAN YUN ZHENG 16238 SAINT TIMOTHY RD 92307 $ 431.20 453 0441 062 15 0000 331370 SHEILA M JOSHWAY 16333 RIMROCK ROAD 92307 $ 606.33 454 0441 062 15 0000 330073 SHEILA M JOSHWAY 16333 RIMROCK ROAD 92307 $ 819.63 455 0441 071 03 0000 330208 BERNIE & MELINDA HARRINGTON 15932 SAINT TIMOTHY RD 92307 $ 272.90 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 456 0441 072 03 0000 331304 JEREMY CHABOYA 19333 ROANOKE ROAD 92307 $ 664.24 457 0441 072 10 0000 331686 SAMIA CARRANZA 16112 SAINT TIMOTHY ROAD 92307 $ 730.04 458 0441 074 15 0000 331532 ROSEANNE/ALEJANDRO POOL 16087 MANDAN ROAD 92307 $ 267.45 459 0441 081 03 0000 331696 IGNACIO JR MELGOZA 20058 RANCHERIAS LANE 92307 $ 960.27 460 0441 081 12 0000 331166 CHRIS CARLSON 15783 KEWANEE ROAD 92307 $ 960.07 461 0441 081 32 0000 329877 ROMULO F DAMASO 15902 ATOKA ROAD 92307 $ 971.30 462 0441 081 40 0000 330415 KIM BOOKER 19831 CARLISLE RD 92307 $ 364.39 463 0441 082 02 0000 330504 CHRISTOPHER DAVID DELAHOUSE FAM TRUST 15783 CATAWBA RD 92307 $ 610.83 464 0441 091 06 0000 329904 BRETT & MARY E. SHANER 15993 RANCHERIAS ROAD 92307 $ 718.52 465 0441 094 03 0000 331642 FIRST AMERICAN EXCHANGE 20305 CARLISLE ROAD 92307 $ 5,523.00 466 0441 094 07 0000 330494 AQUILEO GUTIERREZ 15918 SERRANO RD 92307 $ 571.42 467 0441 101 14 0000 330323 DAVID K PESKETT 20448 SAGO LN 92307 $ 593.77 468 0441 101 15 0000 330269 MARIO SANCHEZ 20428 SAGO LN 92307 $ 565.11 469 0441 101 19 0000 331070 GOSAL HOUSING LLC 20415 SAGO LANE 92307 $ 1,620.02 470 0441 101 32 0000 331283 TIFFIANY L JOHNSON 16019 SERRANO ROAD 92307 $ 583.87 471 0441 102 08 0000 330300 ISSA Y & VICTORIA AZAT RENT TO OWN LLC 15855 WANAQUE RD 92307 $ 36.72 472 0441 102 17 0000 331284 CARMEN ESPINOSA 16021 SAGO ROAD 92307 $ 282.99 473 0441 103 07 0000 331796 STANLEY HUNG 15791 SAGO DELL 92307 $ 648.83 474 0441 103 20 0000 331680 CASA VERDE INVESTMENTS INC 20450 ZUNI ROAD 92307 $ 5,476.85 475 0441 104 11 0000 331347 ELMER GEOVANNI GALINDO 15838 SAGO ROAD 92307 $ 509.16 476 0441 104 13 0000 331080 BAR ASSET HOLDINGS LLC BENNY MATZRI 15810 SAGO ROAD 92307 $ 2,636.44 477 0441 104 14 0000 331079 BAR ASSET HOLDINGS LLC BENNY MATZRI 15790 SAGO RD 92307 $ 2,636.44 478 0441 111 02 0000 330272 DOROTHY ROSS 16070 WINNEBAGO RD 92307 $ 409.02 479 0441 112 17 0000 331365 MARK BRUCKER 16035 WINNEBAGO ROAD 92307 $ 240.00 480 0441 112 24 0000 330243 JEFFREY R SWEET 16018 WYANDOT RD 92307 $ 234.04 481 0441 112 33 0000 330552 NINIVE GASTELUM 15856 WYANDOT RD 92307 $ 336.67 482 0441 112 37 0000 330241 SONIA GARCIA JR. 15774 WYANDOT RD 92307 $ 426.09 483 0441 113 07 0000 330124 ARTURO & PATRICIA CASTANON & ALEMAN 15841 WYANDOT ROAD 92307 $ 663.29 484 0441 113 21 0000 331612 FIDEL GUTIERREZ MORFIN 16084 WICHITA ROAD 92307 $ 467.08 485 0441 113 28 0000 331764 ALBERT E EDU 16065 WICHITA ROAD 92307 $ 272.52 486 0441 121 03 0000 331692 JUAN L GARCIA 15755 WICHITA ROAD 92307 $ 808.69 487 0441 121 04 0000 330245 KEITHA P DENSON 15785 WICHITA RD 92307 $ 626.04 488 0441 121 05 0000 330540 GEORGE & PAULINE CHEN 15815 WICHITA RD 92307 $ 129.28 489 0441 121 22 0000 331562 GIZELLE BACHAWATI 15990 WASHOAN ROAD 92307 $ 595.42 490 0441 122 02 0000 331400 PREHER LIVING TRUST 07/31/18 15731 WASHOAN ROAD 92307 $ 778.21 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 491 0441 122 09 0000 330811 DAWN M/TOM SCHINHARL JR. 15903 WASHOAN RD 92307 $ 239.36 492 0441 122 28 0000 330058 DORA LAND INC 15865 UTE ROAD 92307 $ 249.21 493 0441 122 28 0000 329953 DORA LAND 15856 UTE ROAD 92307 $ 262.23 494 0441 122 33 0000 330239 EDYTH BYRNE TRUST EDYTH H 15746 UTE RD 92307 $ 68.11 495 0441 123 05 0000 330270 ABBAS SHARGHI 15811 UTE RD 92307 $ 397.27 496 0441 123 06 0000 330321 MARCO ANTONIO MARTINEZ MEDRANO 15833 UTE RD 92307 $ 249.06 497 0441 123 07 0000 330283 RICARDO HERNANDEZ 15847 UTE RD 92307 $ 429.12 498 0441 123 09 0000 331470 MARIA H TRUST PIERCE 15903 UTE ROAD 92307 $ 401.96 499 0441 132 09 0000 330562 CHARLES PRUITT 15471 WASHOAN RD 92307 $ 249.81 500 0441 132 12 0000 330172 ALICE SALUM 15515 WASHOAN RD 92307 $ 321.20 501 0441 132 37 0000 330210 KIMBERLY M PHILLIPS, 15486 UTE RD 92307 $ 397.27 502 0441 133 07 0000 330812 GLENDA K NIESTRADT 15471 UTE RD 92307 $ 261.75 503 0441 133 08 0000 329915 GRAFF GEERLINGS 15487 UTE ROAD 92307 $ 305.20 504 0441 133 11 0000 331352 RODRIGO DIAZ 15531 UTE ROAD 92307 $ 312.86 505 0441 133 35 0000 331801 ROY VANCE 15486 DALE EVANS PKWY 92307 $ 243.13 506 0441 133 40 0000 330556 PAUL FRANKLIN RILEY 15410 DALE EVANS PKWY 92307 $ 249.73 507 0441 134 05 0000 330174 MERLINA L BURTON 20891 THUNDERBIRD RD 92307 $ 270.60 508 0441 141 19 0000 331143 ARRIAN WILLIAMS 15619 WYANDOT ROAD 92307 $ 778.24 509 0441 141 35 0000 330287 JOHN & SANDRA REV LIV TR 5 MC MAHON 15594 WYANDOT RD 92307 $ 78.13 510 0441 141 51 0000 331368 YUAN & PENG SHEN & ZHANG 15595 TONEKAI ROAD 92307 $ 972.40 511 0441 142 01 0000 330160 MARTHA BADILLO 20722 THUNDERBIRD ROAD 92307 $ 594.72 512 0441 151 06 0000 330276 LAWRENCE C & JUNE JACKSON-HAMI HAMILTON 20446 RIMROCK RD 92307 $ 601.93 513 0441 152 11 0000 331443 AUSTIN TODD 20460 RIMROCK ROAD 92307 $ 2,458.96 514 0441 161 18 0000 330498 ZHUO WEI LIN 15583 TONEKAI RD 92307 $ 260.52 515 0441 171 16 0000 329998 JUSTIN DEAN BUTLER 15440 WANAQUE ROAD 92307 $ 255.68 516 0441 181 01 0000 330534 WILLIAM LEE ADRIAN 15415 KIAMICHI RD 92307 $ 380.86 517 0441 181 21 0000 331263 JOSE ZENDEJAS 15315 BROKEN BOW ROAD 92307 $ 255.68 518 0441 191 16 0000 329948 DANIEL JACOB TOTO 15360 BROKEN BOW ROAD 92307 $ 1,077.70 519 0441 192 12 0000 330116 JEAN/HOLLY D'ABREAU C/O SENTINEL REALTY 20411 THUNDERBIRD ROAD 92307 $ 217.55 520 0441 201 18 0000 331434 CHERI STEVENS 15358 KIAMICHI ROAD 92307 $ 273.97 521 0441 202 03 0000 331798 JUANA MURILLO 20215 THUNDERBIRD ROAD 92307 $ 121.40 522 0441 222 02 0000 331441 ARENA COLE 15475 TONEKAI ROAD 92307 $ 300.00 523 0441 263 05 0000 330204 REVERSE MORTGAGE FUNDING LLC 15837 MANDAN RD 92307 $ 933.78 524 0441 263 17 0000 331629 ROBERT K HOFFMAN 15762 RIMROCK ROAD 92307 $ 628.56 525 0441 265 03 0000 331141 TERRIE WALKER 19511 ALLEGHENY ROAD 92307 $ 849.73 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 526 0441 275 03 0000 329900 KURSTEN BURNS 16161 SAGO ROAD 92307 $ 1,147.98 527 0441 276 12 0000 331179 ALEJANDRO P PLASCENCIA 20390 OTOE ROAD 92307 $ 1,528.86 528 0441 277 13 0000 330131 ROGER GUDINO 16165 RANCHERIAS ROAD 92307 $ 590.01 529 0441 281 03 0000 330522 RONALD A FAM TR 8/15/91 CROWE 16390 SHENANDOAH RD 92307 $ 217.36 530 0442 012 02 0000 330374 TOM LEWELLEN 19546 STATE HWY 18 92307 $ 566.57 531 0442 013 09 0000 330037 ALEJANDRO PICHARDO 19493 STATE HWY 18 92307 $ 508.27 532 0442 021 02 0000 330248 RON ZIRGES 20066 RIMROCK RD 92307 $ 303.60 533 0442 022 08 0000 331710 DAVIT GEVORGYAN 19973 RIMROCK ROAD 92307 $ 375.85 534 0442 022 12 0000 330501 STEVEN JOHN RAINWATER 20061 RIMROCK RD 92307 $ 249.78 535 0442 022 12 0000 331345 STEVEN JOHN RAINWATER 20061 RIMROCK RD 92307 $ 658.74 536 0442 023 04 0000 331775 CARMEN MARICELA GUTIERREZ 20050 SERRANO ROAD 92307 $ 310.94 537 0442 023 06 0000 330257 TOMMY CHASE 20002 SERRANO RD 92307 $ 252.59 538 0442 031 03 0000 331666 MICHAEL ALLEN 19793 SERRANO ROAD 92307 $ 485.75 539 0442 031 17 0000 330417 TIMOTHY SMITH 19826 STATE HWY 18 92307 $ 278.29 540 0442 032 21 0000 331774 BRIDGET L LIVING TRUST 9/28/ BARCUS 19664 SYMERON ROAD 92307 $ 271.76 541 0442 041 05 0000 331515 VICTOR PRESSEY 19775 SYMERON ROAD 92307 $ 276.05 542 0442 041 12 0000 330306 ABDOL ALI & ABBAS SHARGHI 19989 STATE HWY 18 92307 $ 610.91 543 0442 041 14 0000 330371 ABDOL/ABBAS SHARGHI 20025 STATE HWY 18 92307 $ 767.11 544 0442 042 11 0000 330572 ABBAS SHARGHI 19988 STATE HWY 18 92307 $ 370.52 545 0442 052 16 0000 331705 BYRON RIVAS 19702 YANAN ROAD 92307 $ 500.81 546 0442 052 16 0000 331725 SESSIONS FAMILY REVOCABLE LIV 19702 YANAN ROAD 92308 $ 660.49 547 0442 052 25 0000 330091 RAYMOND MOYA 19476 YANAN ROAD 92307 $ 1,106.98 548 0442 061 03 0000 329968 NARGIS & M. RAHMAN & ZUBAIDUR 19375 SYMERON ROAD 92307 $ 278.11 549 0442 061 09 0000 331168 MEYER FAMILY GOLF TRUST 12/21/ 15414 MANDAN ROAD 92307 $ 374.11 550 0442 061 11 0000 330219 COMPTON LIVING TRUST 19326 YANAN RD 92307 $ 249.81 551 0442 062 09 0000 330883 SHARON ZALEWSKI 19571 SYMERON RD 92307 $ 256.32 552 0442 062 10 0000 330488 ADRIAN SEBASTIAN URIBE 19594 SHASTA RD 92307 $ 371.95 553 0444 021 16 0000 331182 LYNETTE P DUNCAN 18910 SHOSHONEE RD 92307 $ 143.33 554 0444 022 21 0000 330369 STEVEN M AGUAYO 18966 SHOSHONEE RD 92307 $ 252.59 555 0444 022 21 0000 331711 STEVEN AGUAYO 18966 SHOSHONEE ROAD 92307 $ 320.01 556 0444 023 04 0000 331129 MARTIN CAMERA 14111 IVANPAH ROAD 92307 $ 778.24 557 0444 023 10 0000 330043 19055 HAIDA ROAD 92307 $ 155.82 558 0444 023 20 0000 331264 SHANNON COLEMAN 14050 CUYAMACA ROAD 92307 $ 275.21 559 0444 025 08 0000 330162 JASON II PELLETIER 14204 TEHACHAPI ROAD 92307 $ 275.20 560 0444 031 04 0000 331625 DANIELLE DENNISTON 18891 SHOSHONEE ROAD 92307 $ 348.61 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 561 0444 034 01 0000 330583 ROSE FAMILY TRUST 19066 SIESTA DR 92307 $ 386.43 562 0444 034 01 0000 329955 ROSE FAMILY TRUST ROSE FAMILY TRUST 19066 SIESTA DR 92307 $ 639.99 563 0444 034 02 0000 329922 FAITH DIAZ 13937 CUYAMACA ROAD 92307 $ 274.61 564 0444 141 11 0000 331785 WILBERT YAP 18765 SENECA ROAD 92307 $ 281.73 565 0444 141 16 0000 330047 JULIE & RONALD BYRD 14400 INKPA ROAD 92307 $ 85.19 566 0444 141 18 0000 331236 RYAN D HOFF 14350 MANDAN ROAD 92307 $ 584.95 567 0444 144 06 0000 330022 CURT/LEAH WOLKE 18995 RED FEATHER ROAD 92307 $ 337.29 568 0444 147 02 0000 330312 DORFF FAMILY LIVING TRUST 18725 MINGO RD 92307 $ 249.81 569 0444 151 10 0000 330398 DAVID & CAROL OWEN 14455 HAVASU RD 92307 $ 309.82 570 0444 153 08 0000 330359 MARIA DURANT 19160 TEHACHAPI RD 92307 $ 312.85 571 0444 154 05 0000 331440 MILES & APRIL SMILEY 19140 HAIDA RD 92307 $ 661.61 572 0444 211 16 0000 330311 BRENDA BUCKLEY 13987 COACHELLA RD 92307 $ 367.80 573 0444 211 16 0000 331214 BRENDA BUCKLEY 13987 COACHELLA RD 92307 $ 1,252.52 574 0444 215 03 0000 330182 BENNIE/JANICE TAFOYA 19217 SIESTA DR 92307 $ 226.24 575 0444 301 09 0000 331212 DEVIN MCELWAIN 18920 APPALOOSA ROAD 92308 $ 580.99 576 0444 302 04 0000 331721 FELIPE HERNANDEZ 19040 APPALOOSA ROAD 92308 $ 207.35 577 0444 342 01 0000 331628 CAROL WASHINGTON-JAME 12690 SORREL DR 92308 $ 1,198.69 578 0444 352 15 0000 329986 CHAD ESQUIVEL 19025 SHETLAND ROAD 92308 $ 333.56 579 0444 371 05 0000 330401 SHELLEY A SAN FILLIPPO 12495 REATA RD 92308 $ 249.81 580 0444 403 02 0000 331482 NEUSA DIDONATO 19230 SADDLE LANE 92308 $ 152.44 581 0444 411 05 0000 331417 JOSE/ROSALBA CASTILLO 12260 INDIAN RIVER DR 92308 $ 137.44 582 0444 433 07 0000 330749 ROBERT JESSEE 19140 BAY MEADOWS DR 92308 $ 503.71 583 0444 443 06 0000 330008 CHEVRON U S A INC 19180 BEAR VALLEY ROAD 92308 $ 740.41 584 0444 481 02 0000 331756 FRANCISCO SOTO SANCHEZ 13912 RIVERSIDE DR 92307 $ 304.98 585 0444 491 04 0000 330486 DANNY SOLIS 13906 NOWATA CT 92307 $ 601.93 586 0444 491 14 0000 330383 GARY D PARSONS 14002 SIESTA DR 92307 $ 705.78 587 0444 501 03 0000 331106 DUANE E JR BROWN 13836 RIVERSIDE DR 92307 $ 945.42 588 0444 512 18 0000 330333 DAVID L ROMERO 13801 SAHALE PL 92307 $ 685.40 589 0444 543 03 0000 331582 KARA M REEVES 19191 COCHISE CT 92307 $ 626.77 590 0444 552 02 0000 330619 TEDD & CECELIA WILLIAMS SR. 13708 HAVASU RD 92308 $ 619.88 591 0444 553 11 0000 331606 ROSEMARIE APRIL JAIMEZ 19001 SAHALE LANE 92307 $ 882.51 592 0444 553 11 0000 331268 ROSEMARIE APRIL JAIMEZ 19001 SAHALE LANE 92307 $ 978.30 593 0444 554 03 0000 331459 EDWARD CARSEY 19052 SAHALE LANE 92307 $ 299.93 594 0444 761 19 0000 331527 NICHOLAS J WILLIAMS 19129 MARITA PLC 92308 $ 279.97 595 0444 761 21 0000 330598 ARTURO RAMIREZ 12830 YORKSHIRE DR 92308 $ 560.30 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 596 0444 761 36 0000 330719 JON K BAKER 19150 SAN JACINTO WAY 92308 $ 337.18 597 0444 771 20 0000 330573 LLOYD DAUGLASH 19209 SAN JACINTO WAY 92308 $ 441.27 598 0444 771 20 0000 329913 LLOYD M DAUGLASH 19209 SAN JACINTO WAY 92308 $ 639.18 599 0444 771 27 0000 329990 JISOOK KANG 12720 MAR VISTA DR 92308 $ 622.93 600 0444 782 04 0000 330699 BYROENA D EARLEY 12651 YORKSHIRE DR 92308 $ 209.64 601 0444 782 23 0000 330175 DENNIS MCKINLEY 19198 LA QUINTA PL 92308 $ 263.09 602 0444 782 26 0000 330650 RANCHO ENTERPRISES DARCEL BLACK 19150 LA QUINTA PL 92308 $ 631.86 603 0444 931 04 0000 331265 ANDREW KRESCENT 19149 SAGUARO WAY 92308 $ 1,557.15 604 0444 931 10 0000 330679 REAH & MIGUEL INUMERABLE 12557 CABAZON CT 92308 $ 258.29 605 0444 931 16 0000 330695 STEVEN J & SHARON DENISE HUNTER 12540 YORKSHIRE DR 92308 $ 436.89 606 0444 931 17 0000 330098 HANNA CHO 12524 YORKSHIRE DR 92308 $ 247.38 607 0444 931 18 0000 331508 LORETTA VERDIN 12508 YORKSHIRE DR 92308 $ 129.96 608 0463 051 07 0000 329965 CARLOS & GUADALUPE FLORES 21012 STODDARD WELLS ROAD 92307 $ 248.46 609 0463 051 11 0000 330010 JACK VALENTIN ESTRADA 20685 DALE EVANS PKWY 92307 $ 237.87 610 0463 051 13 0000 330011 JACK VALENTIN ESTRADA 20695 DALE EVANS PKWY 92307 $ 237.87 611 0463 213 12 0000 330256 JEFFREY S FINNEY 19481 DACHSHUND AV 92307 $ 249.81 612 0463 421 02 6000 331282 PEDRO B PALACIOS 20532 NAVAJO ROAD 92307 $ 275.21 613 0463 432 11 6000 330231 VERONICA VIVIANA HERNANDEZ 21541 KIMSHEW ST 92307 $ 249.81 614 0472 431 10 0000 329974 XIUFANG WANG 19416 CHUPAROSA ROAD 92307 $ 380.72 615 0472 441 11 0000 330286 JEROME WASHINGTON 19506 ARCATA RD 92307 $ 626.04 616 0472 471 12 0000 331585 EVERGREEN HOMES 19472 CEREUS ROAD 92307 $ 295.56 617 0473 021 02 0000 331519 WESLEY S PECK 16070 KASSON ROAD 92307 $ 802.99 618 0473 021 02 0000 330378 WESLEY S PECK 16070 KASSON RD 92307 $ 1,418.50 619 0473 022 10 0000 330346 KONSTANTINO KARAGIANNIS 16034 VENANGO RD 92307 $ 601.93 620 0473 024 08 0000 329969 JOSEPH/DANA BROWN 16045 VENANGO ROAD 92307 $ 517.42 621 0473 024 18 0000 329883 ANITA RODRIGUEZ 19050 RESOTO ROAD 92307 $ 552.66 622 0473 024 18 0000 329899 ANITA RODRIGUEZ 19050 RESOTO ROAD 92307 $ 627.91 623 0473 026 04 0000 331472 JOHN/PAMELA WOOD 15916 ACOMA ROAD 92307 $ 346.04 624 0473 034 05 0000 330796 DELIA CHAVEZ 19048 ALLEGHENY RD 92307 $ 692.61 625 0473 041 12 0000 331791 BRECKENRIDGE PROEPRT 18962 SYMERON ROAD 92307 $ 1,009.65 626 0473 042 04 0000 331753 REAL ESTATE RECOVERY INC 19232 SYMERON ROAD 92307 $ 238.43 627 0473 042 05 0000 331077 GABRIEL NAVARRO 19212 SYMERON ROAD 92307 $ 777.23 628 0473 043 08 0000 331112 JON GIAIMO 19036 YANAN ROAD 92307 $ 588.41 629 0473 046 02 0000 330331 TRACIE R BALLINGER 19230 YANAN RD 92307 $ 338.33 630 0473 054 22 0000 330343 JUAN D RODRIGUEZ 19004 CHOLE RD 92307 $ 275.20 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 631 0473 054 34 0000 331502 RUBINA AGADJANIAN 15492 LENCA ROAD 92307 $ 218.03 632 0473 063 07 0000 330385 GARY CHRISTOFFELS 18561 COCQUI RD 92307 $ 241.73 633 0473 063 09 0000 331555 DWIGHT ATKINS 18550 COCQUI ROAD 92307 $ 67.96 634 0473 063 11 0000 331471 BRIAN SNYDER 18790 OTOMIAN ROAD 92307 $ 653.26 635 0473 063 15 0000 330413 JUANITA M. HUFFMEIER 18690 OTOMIAN RD 92307 $ 249.81 636 0473 065 02 0000 330482 PATRICK T NICHOLS 15500 POHEZ RD 92307 $ 249.81 637 0473 065 07 0000 331651 KEVIN LI 15380 POHEZ ROAD 92307 $ 523.12 638 0473 066 06 0000 330347 WOSJ VII LLC WOSJ VII LLC 18725 OTOMIAN RD 92307 $ 249.81 639 0473 066 10 0000 330596 TIMOTHY A MURPHREE 18530 COCQUI RD 92307 $ 247.53 640 0473 066 10 0000 331117 TIMOTHY MURPHREE 18530 COCQUI ROAD 92307 $ 573.87 641 0473 068 05 0000 331763 GOR KIRAKOSYAN 18511 COCQUI ROAD 92307 $ 249.26 642 0473 071 03 0000 331425 RODNEY THOMAS 18840 SYMERON ROAD 92307 $ 601.93 643 0473 072 10 0000 331654 NODDIE B ROBINSON 15575 POHEZ ROAD 92307 $ 360.14 644 0473 075 05 0000 329967 EDDY JR VELIZ 18596 COCQUI ROAD 92307 $ 290.90 645 0473 075 07 0000 330146 EXCEL PROPERTY MANAGEMENT 18555 SYMERON ROAD 92307 $ 249.27 646 0473 081 39 0000 331029 SIERRA CORWIN LLC SIERRA CORWIN LLC 18564 STATE HWY 18 92307 $ 1,080.12 647 0473 091 24 0000 331262 JORGE AVILA 16085 PALMERO ROAD 92307 $ 621.26 648 0473 092 28 0000 330366 AYMAN ABDELAAL 15910 MALAHAT RD 92307 $ 516.57 649 0473 092 40 0000 330003 CHRISTOPHER R ROUND 15962 MALAHAT ROAD 92307 $ 594.88 650 0473 102 04 0000 331044 N J REDDY INVESTMENTS LLC 18495 CORWIN RD 92307 $ 35.56 651 0473 114 05 0000 331342 SUNRISE BUILDING LLC 18375 STATE HWY 18 92307 $ 512.96 652 0473 115 01 0000 330449 RANDY FUNDER 15747 MONDAMON RD 92307 $ 238.27 653 0473 122 04 0000 331115 ANNE B/EFREN SAENZ 15623 MONDAMON ROAD 92307 $ 232.93 654 0473 122 05 0000 330364 LAURA ALVARADO 15643 MONDAMON RD 92307 $ 274.87 655 0473 123 02 0000 331271 SHAUN J DUTTON 18405 OWATONNA ROAD 92307 $ 642.90 656 0473 123 04 0000 330442 FUNCKES FAMILY TRUST 18447 OWATONNA RD 92307 $ 249.81 657 0473 124 14 0000 330462 SONIA COOPER 15589 KASOTA RD 92307 $ 249.78 658 0473 124 20 0000 331190 DAVID RODRIGUEZ 15655 KASOTA ROAD 92307 $ 480.13 659 0473 125 07 0000 330305 ABBAS SHARGHI 15625 APPLE VALLEY RD 92307 $ 249.81 660 0473 125 09 0000 331548 RENEE ESTELLE EPLEY 15659 APPLE VALLEY ROAD 92307 $ 865.38 661 0473 125 12 0000 331170 ANTHONY M MESA 15676 KASOTA ROAD 92307 $ 588.41 662 0473 125 13 0000 330477 MARIA VASQUEZ 15658 KASOTA RD 92307 $ 124.23 663 0473 126 13 0000 331781 GUADALUPE/RAMON BECERRA 15524 APPLE VALLEY ROAD 92307 $ 160.69 664 0473 135 03 0000 331559 RITA K NIJJAR 18328 SYMERON ROAD 92307 $ 500.84 665 0473 136 12 0000 330797 FORTUNATO S CLARITA T MATIAS 15433 IDAHO LN 92307 $ 236.75 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 666 0473 136 12 0000 331253 FORTUNATO S CLARITA T MATIAS 15433 IDAHO LANE 92307 $ 724.11 667 0473 137 01 0000 330394 GREGORY HAWKINS 15496 IDAHO RD 92307 $ 239.12 668 0473 138 02 0000 330178 LAILANI CASTANEDA 15496 APPLE VALLEY RD 92307 $ 244.93 669 0473 141 43 0000 331420 ZACHARY E. RHEAUME 15476 TUSCOLA ROAD 92307 $ 588.41 670 0473 153 23 0000 331653 JAIME ESPINOZA CASILLAS 15785 POTOMAC ROAD 92307 $ 4,554.03 671 0473 155 02 0000 331722 PETER YANG 17775 QUANTICO ROAD 92307 $ 855.18 672 0473 156 01 0000 329999 NAOSHIGE SUNADA 17935 QUANTICO ROAD 92307 $ 4,971.92 673 0473 156 03 0000 331792 AUGIE JUAREZ 17979 QUANTICO ROAD 92307 $ 2,816.23 674 0473 192 08 0000 331490 RAMON RIZO 16210 MALAHAT ROAD 92307 $ 486.65 675 0473 192 10 0000 330334 PAUL & GRACIELA RODRIQUEZ 18680 SISKIYOU RD 92307 $ 601.93 676 0473 194 05 0000 331499 EDAR/CRISTINA RODRIGUEZ/VELASQUEZ 16270 TAO ROAD 92307 $ 684.76 677 0473 194 06 0000 331561 DERREN GALVEZ 16250 TAO ROAD 92307 $ 956.91 678 0473 194 13 0000 330309 BRIAN JOSEPH SR BRAYMAN 18740 SISKIYOU RD 92307 $ 601.93 679 0473 194 20 0000 330266 TED REYES 18725 MUNSEE RD 92307 $ 601.93 680 0473 194 23 0000 331766 ALEXANDER MNATSAKANYAN 18741 MUNSEE ROAD 92307 $ 359.31 681 0473 196 03 0000 331099 LENARD & VICKIE LIV TR 1/4/ JOHNSON 18665 SISKIYOU ROAD 92307 $ 105.05 682 0473 201 08 0000 330250 HAZEL HURTE 16460 MALAHAT RD 92307 $ 377.46 683 0473 202 06 0000 330234 STEVEN & MYRA LEWIS 16596 TAO RD 92307 $ 287.87 684 0473 202 20 0000 331661 ANTONIO PATAG 16527 MALAHAT CT 92307 $ 522.50 685 0473 202 20 0000 331333 ANTONIO PATAG 16527 MALAHAT CT 92307 $ 727.75 686 0473 204 10 0000 330141 VIVIAN L WILLIAMS 18975 MUNSEE ROAD 92307 $ 588.34 687 0473 204 10 0000 330198 VIVIAN L WILLIAMS 18975 MUNSEE RD 92307 $ 604.84 688 0473 205 04 0000 331392 JEFFREY & BRIANA QUESSENBERRY 16380 TAO ROAD 92307 $ 633.06 689 0473 205 06 0000 330282 CHARLIE JR MARLOW 18775 MUNSEE RD 92307 $ 591.82 690 0473 212 16 0000 330308 KENNETH WALTER ANDERSON 16265 NOSONI RD 92307 $ 344.22 691 0473 213 13 0000 331695 ERNESTO ROJAS CASTANEDA 16205 WINTUN ROAD 92307 $ 1,191.32 692 0473 214 06 0000 330263 BETTY HAWKINS 19240 ROANOKE RD 92307 $ 626.04 693 0473 214 23 0000 331682 LUIS FULA 19225 CORWIN ROAD 92307 $ 255.68 694 0473 218 07 0000 331111 MARIE LEWIS-SPENCER 18920 CORWIN RD 92307 $ 549.61 695 0473 221 05 0000 330113 GLORIA E THOMAS 19150 MAJELA ROAD 92307 $ 287.08 696 0473 224 04 0000 329928 PAUL E. & LEAH R. HUBBARD & COLEY 16570 WINTUN ROAD 92307 $ 592.43 697 0473 224 04 0000 329920 PAUL/LEAH HUBBARD/COLEY 16570 WINTUN ROAD 92307 $ 631.39 698 0473 224 08 0000 330352 ALFRED H JR TURMAN 16470 WINTUN RD 92307 $ 250.12 699 0473 226 06 0000 330205 CHARLES INGERSOLL 19105 KAIBAB RD 92307 $ 243.45 700 0473 227 22 0000 331761 FERNANDO SANTIAGO CASTELAN LEAL 19124 KAIBAB CT 92307 $ 780.79 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 701 0473 227 27 0000 330566 ROBERT R TR CLARK 19055 MAJELA RD 92307 $ 621.12 702 0473 271 06 0000 330229 JERRY BRUMBLE 17728 TUDE LN 92307 $ 260.52 703 0473 282 10 0000 329983 JAMAL DAVIS 16433 VIHO CT 92307 $ 626.69 704 0473 311 06 0000 330404 THOMAS P. WATKIN 17754 SISKIYOU RD 92307 $ 602.77 705 0473 311 08 0000 331659 ARUTYUN BATMAZYAN 17712 SISKIYOU ROAD 92307 $ 635.04 706 0473 323 03 0000 331384 ADRIAN P JACOBO 16337 VIHO ROAD 92307 $ 244.54 707 0473 334 05 0000 330107 ROCHELLE LING 16347 KAMANA ROAD 92307 $ 249.56 708 0473 342 04 0000 331245 MEIYING LIANG 16263 CHIWI ROAD 92307 $ 377.46 709 0473 342 05 0000 330041 KEVIN JACOBO 16281 CHIWI ROAD 92307 $ 602.16 710 0473 343 06 0000 330264 MAXCINE PATRICK 16286 WATO RD 92307 $ 120.27 711 0473 344 27 0000 330368 RANDOLPH JR SANCHEZ 16228 MARICOPA LN 92307 $ 515.31 712 0473 363 05 0000 330265 DAVID CUSTER 16261 KAMANA RD 92307 $ 608.11 713 0473 372 03 0000 331133 JOHN SLAGOR 16125 CHIWI ROAD 92307 $ 532.52 714 0473 372 03 0000 330261 JOHN SLAGOR 16125 CHIWI RD 92307 $ 696.48 715 0473 374 20 0000 331300 JAMIE SHAFER 16126 MARICOPA LANE 92307 $ 435.23 716 0473 374 28 0000 329943 JONETTA BURNETTE 16115 MARICOPA LANE 92307 $ 566.46 717 0473 381 06 0000 330249 S L/DEPT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS WASHINGTON 16185 VIHO RD 92307 $ 481.62 718 0473 384 08 0000 331800 IBR PROERTIES LLC 16095 TUSCOLA ROAD 92307 $ 277.90 719 0473 431 01 0000 329902 KENNETH L ROBINSON 15984 TINTA ROAD 92307 $ 359.62 720 0473 482 04 0000 330105 RUIMING LIU 16691 KASSON ROAD 92307 $ 392.81 721 0473 482 05 0000 331697 WANLI INVESTMENTS LLC 16707 KASSON ROAD 92307 $ 1,851.04 722 0473 491 04 0000 331305 ALEX PEREZ 16732 MUNI ROAD 92307 $ 805.18 723 0473 514 12 0000 330251 THE SIR-OZ FAMILY TRUST 16501 MISANAKE RD 92307 $ 237.44 724 0473 524 01 0000 330236 JESSE L WALL 16513 IWA RD 92307 $ 342.31 725 0473 535 19 0000 331484 ROBERT ALLEN/VALERIE REV LIV TR 18428 SISKIYOU ROAD 92307 $ 329.00 726 0473 535 49 0000 331699 ISAAC/REGINA EDWARDS 16411 KASOTA ROAD 92307 $ 1,199.95 727 0473 536 14 0000 330209 JOSE CAMPOS PADILLA, 16353 MENAHKA RD 92307 $ 771.64 728 0473 536 17 0000 330067 VALLERIE JACKSON 16397 MENAHKA ROAD 92307 $ 602.04 729 0473 541 11 0000 331688 TRACEY L MARTINEZ 16418 OLALEE ROAD 92307 $ 221.12 730 0473 541 18 0000 329873 CHANGGEN LIU 16314 OLALEE ROAD 92307 $ 588.40 731 0473 542 06 0000 330190 NORMA TRUST BARRERAS 16247 OLALEE RD 92307 $ 282.06 732 0473 542 14 0000 330228 RAKESH K GROVER 18551 OLALEE WAY 92307 $ 600.02 733 0473 542 23 0000 330330 CHRISTIAN H ALBERTSEN 18572 OLALEE LN 92307 $ 601.93 734 0473 542 31 0000 330278 MOISES A CENTENO 16453 OLALEE PL 92307 $ 601.93 735 0473 581 18 0000 331371 ASHKA PATEL 16351 RIDGE VIEW DR 92307 $ 460.30 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 736 0473 591 12 0000 330373 HYUNJOO JIN 17640 SISKIYOU RD 92307 $ 392.81 737 0473 611 02 0000 330108 MONICA BUFKIN 15332 TUSCOLA ROAD 92307 $ 274.64 738 0473 611 10 0000 331181 ALBERTO A RODRIGUEZ 18049 MONDAMON ROAD 92307 $ 451.46 739 0473 611 14 0000 330339 LAKRITZ FAMILY PARTNERSHIP LP 18050 MONDAMON RD 92307 $ 272.82 740 0473 621 18 0000 331357 CARRIE HALM 15476 BIG SKY ROAD 92307 $ 960.07 741 0473 621 19 0000 330423 MARGARET DOYLE 15479 BIG SKY RD 92307 $ 713.01 742 0473 621 24 0000 330422 GREGORY KALAJIAN 15410 LOOKOUT RD 92307 $ 626.04 743 0473 631 04 0000 331439 SULLIVAN, ANDREW SULLIVAN, ANDREW 15351 BIG SKY ROAD 92307 $ 365.42 744 0473 651 34 0000 331616 SALVADOR GARCIA 19225 WILD MUSTANG CT 92307 $ 299.89 745 0473 661 23 0000 330381 JAMES V FENELON 15541 LOOKOUT RD 92307 $ 240.47 746 0479 022 02 0000 329946 ROSA HEREDIA 17871 SYMERON ROAD 92307 $ 101.13 747 0479 022 22 0000 330810 MARIE, JAMES & CHRISTEEN REYES 15221 CHAPARRAL LN 92307 $ 282.39 748 0479 022 22 0000 331153 MARIE/JAMES,CHRISTEEN(RUDY) REYES 15221 CHAPARRAL LANE 92307 $ 778.24 749 0479 031 16 0000 331252 DOMINICK GARCIA 18280 HIAWATHA ROAD 92307 $ 262.41 750 0479 032 18 0000 330336 LEO GARCIA 15188 NOKOMIS RD 92307 $ 274.67 751 0479 034 11 0000 331337 JAMIE/THOMAS ROBISON 15194 TACONY ROAD 92307 $ 1,157.21 752 0479 034 22 0000 330355 GABRIEL & TAREN CERDA 15081 TUSCOLA RD 92307 $ 319.83 753 0479 041 01 0000 329960 JEFFERY EDWARD GRETZNER 15036 RIVERSIDE DR 92307 $ 648.02 754 0479 041 03 0000 330106 FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG FEDERAL NAT'L MTG 14982 RIVERSIDE DR 92307 $ 606.54 755 0479 052 02 0000 331526 CYNTHIA LYNETTE BELCHER 15007 TUSCOLA ROAD 92307 $ 756.89 756 0479 054 02 0000 331299 CHRISTOPHER DAKIN 14949 NOKOMIS ROAD 92307 $ 745.27 757 0479 055 06 0000 330122 WILLIAM LARSEN 18244 COCOPAH ROAD 92307 $ 549.68 758 0479 061 01 0000 331201 BERFALIA ISABEL CASTELLANOS 14900 NOKOMIS RD 92307 $ 475.62 759 0479 063 03 0000 331366 TERRY LYN SPECIAL NEEDS TRUST MEZA 14577 RIVERSIDE DR 92307 $ 247.75 760 0479 064 08 0000 331762 DANIEL WAYNE STRATTON 14648 RIVERSIDE ROAD 92307 $ 226.46 761 0479 064 12 0000 330595 BRETT M BAYLESS 14608 RIVERSIDE DR 92307 $ 511.09 762 0479 065 06 0000 330433 DAN VILLARS 18317 COCOPAH RD 92307 $ 230.76 763 0479 065 25 0000 330375 TOMAS SR CABAN 14681 RIVERSIDE DR 92307 $ 336.87 764 0479 066 08 0000 330585 HORACE J. WEST 14812 NOKOMIS RD 92307 $ 327.45 765 0479 066 16 0000 331343 DANIEL J & CYNTHIA VILLARS 18302 COCOPAH ROAD 92307 $ 510.98 766 0479 072 11 0000 331689 JOHN PERRY 14807 KINAI ROAD 92307 $ 516.93 767 0479 073 06 0000 331292 MIRIUM STREETER 14806 CHAMBER LANE 92307 $ 262.49 768 0479 073 15 0000 331672 DEVON & GEOFFREY FRITSCH 14944 TUSCOLA ROAD 92307 $ 200.59 769 0479 083 09 0000 330034 CHRISTOPHER CURLESS 15102 YAQUI ROAD 92307 $ 418.40 770 0479 092 03 0000 330337 GEORGE GLEDSON 15261 OSCEOLA RD 92307 $ 249.81 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 771 0479 095 06 0000 330458 TONI MEREDITH 15177 MENDOTA RD 92307 $ 270.26 772 0479 096 09 0000 330284 LISA RUIZ 15128 MENDOTA RD 92307 $ 742.86 773 0479 097 09 0000 331751 NERSES SHANINYAN 15196 KINAI ROAD 92307 $ 209.81 774 0479 097 16 0000 331702 PHILLIP & GEORGETTE HERNANDEZ 15147 PIRINDA ROAD 92307 $ 293.29 775 0479 097 17 0000 331596 SANDRA FERNANDEZ 15177 PIRINDA ROAD 92307 $ 696.32 776 0479 098 01 0000 330430 ALBERT CALDERON 18915 TAMARAC RD 92307 $ 306.16 777 0479 101 07 0000 330435 GREGORY & GISELE WHITE 15065 WASECA LN 92307 $ 221.05 778 0479 102 05 0000 331339 LAURA GATES 15021 KINAI ROAD 92307 $ 589.12 779 0479 106 03 0000 331437 AKISHA ROSSES 14883 APPLE VALLEY ROAD 92307 $ 1,133.30 780 0479 106 08 0000 330576 MARWAN M EL-DANA 19041 TECUMSEH RD 92307 $ 237.33 781 0479 106 13 0000 331700 BRIAN ST JOHN 19117 TECUMSEH ROAD 92307 $ 536.68 782 0479 113 09 0000 331260 HANA NESSAY 14825 KOKOMO ROAD 92307 $ 231.52 783 0479 118 02 0000 331604 CAROLYN BELL 14770 KOKOMO ROAD 92307 $ 244.41 784 0479 122 17 0000 329874 JACOBO HUERTA 14645 HAVASU ROAD 92307 $ 252.38 785 0479 124 04 0000 330206 ROLFE MOSS 14650 KEOTA RD 92307 $ 371.95 786 0479 127 11 0000 330718 NORMAN FLICKINGER 19002 SENECA RD 92307 $ 257.02 787 3080 031 33 0000 329933 MARK S TOARMINA 22775 COLONY ROAD 92308 $ 264.97 788 3080 051 08 0000 331369 DOLORES BERFALIA ALVARADO 22053 BEAR VALLEY ROAD 92308 $ 325.07 789 3080 071 10 0000 330856 RICHARD NAGLE 11246 PAWNEE RD 92308 $ 282.80 790 3080 071 20 0000 330942 CECIL M 7 & 17 ZEHNER 11175 TYEE RD 92308 $ 261.37 791 3080 071 30 0000 330829 ANGELA SCOTT 21842 VIENTO RD 92308 $ 256.32 792 3080 081 23 0000 330993 CHRISTOPHER STUMPF 21992 WREN ST 92308 $ 295.28 793 3080 101 04 0000 330183 EVI BORDEN 10849 NAVAJO RD 92308 $ 216.74 794 3080 102 01 0000 330906 MICHELLE HOLLINGSWORTH 21858 PANOCHE RD 92308 $ 282.39 795 3080 102 06 0000 330807 DAVID C FRANKO 10737 MANHASSET RD 92308 $ 256.32 796 3080 102 09 0000 331498 VERONICA WALKER 10804 TOLTEC DR 92308 $ 226.47 797 3080 111 02 0000 330898 JAVIER MOLINA 10864 COCHITI RD 92308 $ 385.70 798 3080 111 10 0000 330933 BRITTNEY BENSON 10746 COCHITI RD 92308 $ 256.69 799 3080 112 08 0000 331712 CODY MEAD 10803 COCHITI ROAD 92308 $ 512.79 800 3080 112 18 0000 331579 LAURA BALTAZAR 10800 NAMBE ROAD 92308 $ 287.69 801 3080 113 10 0000 331611 AFFILIATED ASSET FUNDS INC LLC 21909 WREN ST 92308 $ 377.05 802 3080 114 02 0000 330861 DONNA PHILLIPS 10789 SAUK RD 92308 $ 213.33 803 3080 114 08 0000 330988 THEODORE E A SCHRAMM 10841 SAUK CT 92308 $ 267.22 804 3080 115 18 0000 331694 MIGUEL/MORENO/OLIVIA GONZALEZ/AGUILAR 22074 ALEUT ROAD 92308 $ 307.25 805 3080 115 19 0000 330840 ABBAS SHARGHI 22058 ALEUT RD 92308 $ 256.32 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 806 3080 116 16 0000 330816 RONALD MEAD 22021 NAMBE CT 92308 $ 327.39 807 3080 116 19 0000 331267 MELANIE ALAYON 22030 NAMBE CT 92308 $ 256.69 808 3080 117 16 0000 331335 CASTILLO FAMILY REVOCABLE LIVI 21980 TUSSING RANCH ROAD 92308 $ 421.23 809 3080 118 02 0000 331675 CECILIO ANDRES JR ZARATE 10591 COCHITI ROAD 92308 $ 743.33 810 3080 118 04 0000 331432 TANYA M CARRANZA 10623 COCHITI ROAD 92308 $ 977.18 811 3080 118 05 0000 330981 VINCENZO CAPPELLINO 10641 COCHITI RD 92308 $ 256.32 812 3080 118 17 0000 330392 LUCIEN SCHULTZE 21970 MICMAC RD 92308 $ 252.14 813 3080 119 03 0000 331006 RYAN/JOVETTE URENA 10646 COCHITI RD 92308 $ 327.39 814 3080 119 09 0000 331817 CRAIG GENTRY 10548 COCHITI ROAD 92308 $ 453.60 815 3087 031 10 0000 330161 ALBERT R WILSON 13066 LOMPOC ROAD 92308 $ 1,528.86 816 3087 031 25 0000 330793 DUNCAN JR HUGHES 12980 PARAISO RD 92308 $ 41.48 817 3087 031 72 0000 330720 ABBAS SHARGHI 13201 MUGU CT 92308 $ 495.87 818 3087 031 77 0000 330072 MICHAEL E THOMAS 19691 OTTAWA ROAD 92308 $ 1,149.14 819 3087 041 26 0000 331224 DELORES WILLIAMS 13554 DELAWARE ROAD 92308 $ 212.95 820 3087 052 14 0000 330089 COAST PROPERTY MNGMNT 19915 CRONESE CT 92308 $ 257.39 821 3087 052 24 0000 330682 ROBERTO & VERONICA MARTINEZ 13505 ITASCA CT 92308 $ 178.36 822 3087 053 08 0000 330705 RAQUEL WALLACE 20006 WACO RD 92308 $ 250.42 823 3087 053 26 0000 330681 ADAM EVENS 13311 TAWYA RD 92308 $ 327.45 824 3087 061 09 0000 330086 ASHLEY & NATHANIEL PARRY 13123 OLATHE ROAD 92308 $ 239.28 825 3087 061 16 0000 330738 LINCOLN G ORELLANA 13140 OLATHE RD 92308 $ 519.85 826 3087 061 39 0000 330756 PHAN TU 13114 CHOCO RD 92308 $ 239.08 827 3087 062 03 0000 330565 WILLIAM KLAERS 20045 OTTAWA RD 92308 $ 327.45 828 3087 062 26 0000 330604 CAMERON WILSON 13119 MODOC CT 92308 $ 921.46 829 3087 071 21 0000 330623 DAVID E GORDON 13054 OLATHE RD 92308 $ 402.32 830 3087 072 20 0000 331220 JOSEPH CLARK JR. 19889 MODOC ROAD 92308 $ 299.83 831 3087 072 27 0000 331789 SHAWNTEE R. JENKINS 13014 DOLI ROAD 92308 $ 230.55 832 3087 072 31 0000 331746 BARRON WILSON 12970 VALLEY VIEW CT 92308 $ 376.37 833 3087 081 21 0000 330615 CHERYL JOHNSON 20296 ITASCA RD 92308 $ 267.07 834 3087 081 21 0000 329896 CHERYL JOHNSON 20296 ITASCA ROAD 92308 $ 1,042.57 835 3087 081 38 0000 330688 NIKOLAOS K MARKOU 20130 EYOTA RD 92308 $ 238.17 836 3087 081 41 0000 330013 KATHLEEN GARTEN 20180 EYOTA ROAD 92308 $ 291.47 837 3087 081 42 0000 330755 MICHAEL J BARLEY 20212 EYOTA RD 92308 $ 258.27 838 3087 091 06 0000 330005 KENNETH MARTELL 20249 WACO ROAD 92308 $ 228.29 839 3087 091 10 0000 330075 MELISSA & HOLLY ALEXANDER 13420 WACO DR 92308 $ 256.75 840 3087 091 10 0000 330001 MELISSA & HOLLY ALEXANDER 13420 WACO DR 92308 $ 848.24 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 841 3087 091 20 0000 330721 JENNIFER & DANIEL CASE 13375 RINCON RD 92308 $ 327.45 842 3087 091 33 0000 330607 R V DALUVOY MD INC 20253 WADENA RD 92308 $ 237.33 843 3087 091 37 0000 331372 JEFFERY HANOUM 20276 WACO ROAD 92308 $ 570.24 844 3087 091 45 0000 330768 RUSSELL J KINER 20225 EYOTA CT 92308 $ 388.61 845 3087 091 52 0000 330602 RANDY SKAARE 20248 WADENA RD 92308 $ 266.73 846 3087 091 53 0000 330570 THADDEUS WAJS 20270 WADENA RD 92308 $ 342.42 847 3087 091 58 0000 331452 FERMIN ESTHER 13490 SHAWNEE CT 92308 $ 296.39 848 3087 091 60 0000 330748 DIAMOND V INVESTMENTS 13342 RINCON RD 92308 $ 216.79 849 3087 092 05 0000 331126 JONATHAN W SCOTT 13407 QUAPAW ROAD 92308 $ 213.87 850 3087 092 13 0000 330716 JAVIOER & ERICA VILLANUEVA 13428 QUAPAW RD 92308 $ 458.79 851 3087 092 21 0000 330684 BRIAN THOMAS STOUDT 20386 EYOTA RD 92308 $ 242.52 852 3087 092 27 0000 329919 ANA PATRICIA HERNANDEZ 20389 EYOTA ROAD 92308 $ 395.94 853 3087 092 29 0000 331683 CHARVAUGHN FAMILY TRUST 10/4/1 20385 EYOTA ROAD 92308 $ 504.51 854 3087 101 02 0000 330703 GRANT WILLIAMS 20123 WACO RD 92308 $ 327.45 855 3087 101 18 0000 330616 CHEEVER MARITAL TRUST 3/1/95 20136 OTTAWA RD 92308 $ 62.32 856 3087 101 30 0000 330740 LUIS DE LA PAZ 13298 RINCON RD 92308 $ 157.59 857 3087 102 45 0000 330054 SECRETARY OF VETERANS AFFAIRS 20157 ITUMA ROAD 92308 $ 2,664.95 858 3087 102 46 0000 331185 JUAN C DADO 20170 ITUMA ROAD 92308 $ 775.73 859 3087 102 47 0000 331468 SIMON REYES ARROYO 20216 ITUMA ROAD 92308 $ 817.87 860 3087 102 56 0000 331410 JULIE LAWYER 13188 QUAPAW ROAD 92308 $ 1,157.21 861 3087 102 60 0000 330694 GERARDO GUTIERREZ 13205 QUAPAW RD 92308 $ 283.18 862 3087 102 68 0000 330727 CYRUS BANDARY 13186 RINCON RD 92308 $ 306.67 863 3087 111 01 0000 330605 JULIO ALBERTO 12920 RINCON RD 92308 $ 419.32 864 3087 111 04 0000 330097 HELEN WANG 12994 RINCON ROAD 92308 $ 348.08 865 3087 111 05 0000 331624 ARMAN ZARGARYAN 13070 RINCON ROAD 92308 $ 554.77 866 3087 111 28 0000 331505 MARTYN J STODDARD 13053 RINCON ROAD 92308 $ 359.24 867 3087 111 38 0000 330774 VALERIA EST DOTTERRER 20239 OSSEO RD 92308 $ 251.99 868 3087 111 42 0000 330087 PEDRO RAMOS 20222 MODOC ROAD 92308 $ 286.94 869 3087 112 06 0000 330017 BROOKE BACHMANN 12987 CASCO ROAD 92308 $ 425.35 870 3087 112 21 0000 330771 GABRIEL SALAZAR 12951 NYACK RD 92308 $ 244.78 871 3087 112 23 0000 330661 JEAN BOWMAN 12915 NYACK ROAD 92308 $ 258.75 872 3087 112 24 0000 330773 SANDY MELANCON 13051 QUAPAW ROAD 92308 $ 445.64 873 3087 112 30 0000 330080 LARRY PATTON 12971 QUAPAW ROAD 92308 $ 1,258.80 874 3087 112 31 0000 330706 DAVID ANGELICA 12949 QUAPAW RD 92308 $ 266.73 875 3087 121 03 0000 330555 FREDERICO D MILTON 20683 YUCCA LOMA RD 92308 $ 336.67 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 876 3087 121 07 0000 331408 STELLA LEE 20585 YUCCA LOMA ROAD 92308 $ 265.07 877 3087 121 08 0000 331239 ESTELLA LEE-FLORES 20565 YUCCA LOMA ROAD 92308 $ 223.53 878 3087 121 22 0000 331728 BERTHENIA RENA CHAPMAN 20711 SHAWNEE ROAD 92308 $ 680.33 879 3087 121 47 0000 330046 DUSTIN PICKENS 20615 POWHATAN LANE 92308 $ 296.03 880 3087 122 04 0000 330023 RAUL RAMIREZ LOPEZ 20811 YUCCA LOMA ROAD 92308 $ 155.40 881 3087 122 06 0000 330412 GRETCHEN MARRUJO 13677 IROQUOIS RD 92307 $ 345.08 882 3087 122 24 0000 331632 CHRISTOPHER M HALL 13515 IROQUOIS ROAD 92308 $ 466.72 883 3087 122 26 0000 330735 EDWARD J TR HMURA 13488 TIOGA RD 92308 $ 370.68 884 3087 131 12 0000 330021 TROY/JOY WOODBURN 20590 EYOTA ROAD 92308 $ 279.55 885 3087 131 22 0000 331748 ANGEL PINEDA 13474 IROQUOIS ROAD 92308 $ 468.92 886 3087 131 26 0000 330664 REX G PIATT 13445 ANOKA RD 92308 $ 237.25 887 3087 131 28 0000 331474 ORLANDO ARIAS 13441 ANOKA ROAD 92308 $ 257.02 888 3087 132 21 0000 330633 WILLIAM RYAN 13429 TIOGA LN 92308 $ 283.02 889 3087 132 39 0000 331322 JOSEPH GRIGSBY 13363 JICARILLA RD 92308 $ 261.37 890 3087 132 49 0000 331415 TERRELL W HALE 20717 EYOTA ROAD 92308 $ 588.41 891 3087 141 06 0000 331134 NATASHA NAOMI LEON 13174 POCONO ROAD 92308 $ 747.01 892 3087 141 31 0000 331216 ERIC SUPAN 13134 IROQUOIS ROAD 92308 $ 588.41 893 3087 141 34 0000 330794 BERTHA TR/ROBERT L TR TUCKER 20622 SHOLIC RD 92308 $ 362.19 894 3087 141 35 0000 331503 SIFREDO LUNA 20610 SHOLIC ROAD 92308 $ 464.44 895 3087 141 54 0000 331522 DE ANDRE DAVILA 13190 WINONA ROAD 92308 $ 796.91 896 3087 141 58 0000 331156 JAMES WILLIAMS 13099 POCONO ROAD 92308 $ 714.11 897 3087 142 18 0000 330783 SAM NIAZI 13187 TOPSANNA RD 92308 $ 275.87 898 3087 142 33 0000 329881 LINDA RORIGUEZ 13210 TOPSANNA ROAD 92308 $ 148.27 899 3087 142 38 0000 330588 BETTY PEDEN 13130 TOPSANNA RD 92308 $ 609.05 900 3087 142 54 0000 331195 DOUGLAS MCCURDY 13190 SKIOMAH RD 92308 $ 347.40 901 3087 151 02 0000 331332 YVONNE M MOLLES 20621 SHOLIC ROAD 92308 $ 222.85 902 3087 152 24 0000 330770 BRIAN SENN 13031 IROQUOIS RD 92308 $ 382.58 903 3087 152 28 0000 330608 RICHARD W THEODORE 20750 TETON RD 92308 $ 264.35 904 3087 152 29 0000 330636 LATRISE WASP 20730 TETON RD 92308 $ 257.02 905 3087 152 34 0000 331344 GEORGE MANTOOTH 20715 TETON ROAD 92308 $ 778.24 906 3087 153 30 0000 330635 MARGARET M DOYLE REV LIV TR 20875 NISQUALLY RD 92308 $ 253.81 907 3087 181 03 0000 331227 HANSELE FAMILY TRUST (-3-24-19 20231 SITTING BULL RD 92308 $ 1,160.85 908 3087 181 18 0000 331406 KARL L HART 12846 QUAIL VISTA ROAD 92308 $ 136.63 909 3087 182 29 0000 330758 DAVID JR SPECIAL NEEDS TR KINNEY 20449 BRAZOS RD 92308 $ 717.19 910 3087 191 37 0000 330069 HORACE JOHNSON 12541 OVERLOOK ROAD 92308 $ 1,049.90 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 911 3087 191 57 0000 330655 TIMOTHY L SR MILTON 12562 HIGHLINE DR 92308 $ 982.57 912 3087 193 03 0000 331286 THEDA J GRIFFIN-SMITH 20454 MAJESTIC DR 92308 $ 614.54 913 3087 193 03 0000 331148 THEDA J GRIFFIN-SMITH 20454 MAJESTIC DR 92308 $ 630.46 914 3087 201 02 0000 331171 MIRNA ODILE KELLEY 20233 GERONIMO ROAD 92308 $ 2,416.17 915 3087 211 04 0000 329892 JEFF CLARK 12361 TONOPAH CT 92308 $ 84.73 916 3087 211 06 0000 329971 DARYN DUFF 12381 TONOPAH CT 92308 $ 1,633.57 917 3087 221 04 0000 331249 MEYER, KENNETH MEYER, ZOILA 20560 SITTING BULL ROAD 92308 $ 134.08 918 3087 223 17 0000 331167 ALEX O ALONSO 12845 IROQUOIS ROAD 92308 $ 588.40 919 3087 224 17 0000 330399 P TOMAS DUARTE 12790 IROQUOIS RD 92308 $ 139.92 920 3087 224 27 0000 330704 RAMON CONTRERAS 12640 IROQUOIS RD 92308 $ 283.18 921 3087 225 23 0000 330064 EDDIE J HERRON 20595 SITTING BULL ROAD 92308 $ 271.62 922 3087 225 32 0000 331570 MICHAEL & MARLENE AVALOS 12730 KEWANNA ROAD 92308 $ 409.18 923 3087 226 03 0000 330733 GUSTAVO GUTIERREZ 12820 POCONO RD 92308 $ 257.02 924 3087 226 06 0000 331092 BRYAN J FUENTES 12780 POCONO ROAD 92308 $ 118.23 925 3087 226 07 0000 330745 HUERTA FAMILY LIVING TRUST 12762 POCONO RD 92308 $ 270.47 926 3087 228 02 0000 331466 GILBERT CHAVEZ 20555 GERONIMO ROAD 92308 $ 334.69 927 3087 233 11 0000 331164 DAVID SANDERSON 12788 SNAPPING TURTLE ROAD 92308 $ 548.18 928 3087 233 15 0000 331219 BRANDI GERHARDT 20752 MATAWAN ROAD 92308 $ 129.94 929 3087 233 25 0000 330120 JESSE NEWMAN 20709 SITTING BULL ROAD 92308 $ 460.73 930 3087 235 10 0000 329966 MABEL SCIARRATTA 12628 TESUQUE ROAD 92308 $ 791.30 931 3087 237 07 0000 331416 BIANCA/MARIO RODRIGUEZ 12786 KIOWA ROAD 92308 $ 431.96 932 3087 238 02 0000 331056 VICTOR ORTEGA 12534 KIOWA RD 92308 $ 729.29 933 3087 238 16 0000 330621 CHRISTOPHER BRYANT 12555 SHOLIC RD 92308 $ 257.02 934 3087 242 03 0000 330148 KRISTOPHER BURNS 20776 PAHUTE ROAD 92308 $ 287.74 935 3087 244 18 0000 331246 OSCAR RODRIGUEZ 12333 SHOLIC ROAD 92308 $ 244.77 936 3087 245 06 0000 331737 MARY A JACKSON 12364 SHOLIC ROAD 92308 $ 753.65 937 3087 246 09 0000 330591 BETHEA LEE C LIVING TRUST 12318 TESUQUE RD 92308 $ 700.36 938 3087 246 22 0000 330614 KEITH & CHERYL NICHOLS 12277 SNAPPING TURTLE ROAD 92308 $ 283.13 939 3087 246 23 0000 330666 TIMOTHY J LANGEL 12293 SNAPPING TURTLE RD 92308 $ 296.77 940 3087 246 28 0000 330730 LAI KEVIN 12383 SNAPPING TURTLE RD 92308 $ 237.33 941 3087 247 11 0000 330690 BILL OLIN 12366 SNAPPING TURTLE RD 92308 $ 153.89 942 3087 247 12 0000 331354 JOHNNY VALENZUELA 12384 SNAPPING TURTLE ROAD 92308 $ 269.36 943 3087 247 16 0000 330669 CYNTHIA MARSEILLES 12454 SNAPPING TURTLE RD 92308 $ 224.91 944 3087 249 21 0000 330674 JOHN CASSEL 12173 SHOLIC RD 92308 $ 269.17 945 3087 249 29 0000 330707 RANJIT SINGH MAHINDAR SINGH 20741 KACHINA RD 92308 $ 263.75 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 946 3087 251 01 0000 331174 STEVEN BENYO 20682 PAHUTE ROAD 92308 $ 631.86 947 3087 251 03 0000 329958 FREDERICO MENDOZA 20683 PAHUTE ROAD 92308 $ 625.85 948 3087 251 09 0000 330629 RAYMOND MOROYOQUI 20673 BUFFALO POINT 92308 $ 319.49 949 3087 251 17 0000 331310 TRISHA D SILVA 12499 POCONO RD 92308 $ 325.65 950 3087 251 20 0000 330639 MARQUESITA REVOCABLE LIV TR GUTIERREZ 12430 POCONO PL 92308 $ 319.32 951 3087 261 02 0000 330642 BRIAN C COCHRAN 13370 KIOWA RD 92308 $ 257.02 952 3087 261 04 0000 330603 FREDERICKA KIRST 13434 KIOWA RD 92308 $ 257.02 953 3087 261 06 0000 330726 CURLEY JR GUIDRY 13464 KIOWA ROAD 92308 $ 358.12 954 3087 263 06 0000 331188 DANIEL S GRIEGO 13553 LAKOTA ROAD 92308 $ 226.46 955 3087 263 07 0000 330989 XAVIER ARIZA 21070 POWHATAN RD 92308 $ 244.79 956 3087 264 08 0000 330032 ERIC & JAUDY MAE BARRIOS 13361 LAKOTA ROAD 92308 $ 257.38 957 3087 265 10 0000 331423 MARILYN GREGER 13447 KIOWA ROAD 92308 $ 381.46 958 3087 265 11 0000 330871 ALFONSO M. & MARTHA LAZO MUNOZ 13487 POWHATAN RD 92308 $ 456.97 959 3087 271 13 0000 330093 ADIENNE & MARIO CHAVEZ 21244 BEAUJOLAIS WAY 92308 $ 415.56 960 3087 271 15 0000 330855 MICHAEL E SCOTT 21284 BEAUJOLAIS WAY 92308 $ 607.27 961 3087 271 19 0000 330857 KENNETH SPRAGUE 21267 BEAUJOLAIS WAY 92308 $ 231.89 962 3087 271 27 0000 329918 ALEJANDRO & VICKY URENA 21292 CASK CT 92308 $ 664.93 963 3087 271 56 0000 331014 JASON SANDHOEFNER 21280 GLENORA DR 92308 $ 51.07 964 3087 272 27 0000 330874 JERI/MELVIN WADE, 21189 CHIANTI LN 92308 $ 135.39 965 3087 272 39 0000 330143 SALVADOR LOPEZ 21186 CABERNET LANE 92308 $ 588.41 966 3087 272 39 0000 330870 SALVADOR LOPEZ 21186 CABERNET LN 92308 $ 607.27 967 3087 272 42 0000 331467 RICHARD MACIAS 21157 BURGUNDY WAY 92308 $ 214.54 968 3087 272 46 0000 331018 LEONARD RATKAY 21172 BURGUNDY WAY 92308 $ 606.79 969 3087 272 59 0000 331139 MICHEAL V DER 13568 BORDEAUX CT 92308 $ 957.15 970 3087 282 05 0000 330186 J Y DEVELOPMENT LLC J Y DEVELOPMENT 20973 CAYUGA RD 92308 $ 211.97 971 3087 283 08 0000 331537 JUAN F TEJADA 21011 PONCA ROAD 92308 $ 417.46 972 3087 283 17 0000 330340 ABRAM SANCHEZ 20958 TETON RD 92308 $ 279.53 973 3087 284 12 0000 331017 JM TRINITY INC 21030 QUILEUTE RD 92308 $ 238.11 974 3087 285 10 0000 329870 HUA-YANG HUANG 21045 QUILEUTE ROAD 92308 $ 812.55 975 3087 286 03 0000 331701 SEAN KOOPERMAN 20941 NISQUALLY ROAD 92308 $ 710.71 976 3087 286 03 0000 331685 SEAN KOPPERMAN 20941 NISQUALLY ROAD 92308 $ 715.46 977 3087 287 10 0000 330059 VERONICA GONZALEZ 13265 LAKOTA ROAD 92308 $ 390.46 978 3087 288 04 0000 331066 MONICA A FENTON REVOCABLE TRUST 12995 LAKOTA RD 92308 $ 721.57 979 3087 288 05 0000 331064 MONICA FENTON A REV TR 13009 LAKOTA RD 92308 $ 721.57 980 3087 292 10 0000 330109 CARRIE/EDWARD MARQUEZ 21156 PINOT CT 92308 $ 605.43 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 981 3087 292 17 0000 331336 DARRIN MICHAEL ROWE 21186 RELIANCE DR 92308 $ 324.37 982 3087 292 18 0000 330891 RONALD JOHN DURAN 21193 RELIANCE DR 92308 $ 607.27 983 3087 292 26 0000 330890 LARRY A MONTGOMERY 21195 RHONE PL 92308 $ 517.46 984 3087 292 44 0000 331690 WILLIE GOMEZ 13092 PERIGNON PLC 92308 $ 279.97 985 3087 292 46 0000 330056 AARON & JOHANNA CAUDLE 13056 PERIGNON PLC 92308 $ 295.14 986 3087 292 59 0000 330886 MARIA ELENA FLORES 21115 NISQUALLY RD 92308 $ 459.32 987 3087 301 09 0000 331802 ARMANDO & JENNIFER DURAN & PRUITT 21354 POWHATAN ROAD 92308 $ 696.73 988 3087 301 15 0000 331063 KENNETH JONES 13639 RANCHERIAS RD 92308 $ 1,844.24 989 3087 301 27 0000 331684 JENNIFER/JOSE ALVAYERO 13681 YAKIMA ROAD 92308 $ 30.58 990 3087 301 32 0000 331456 YUNG LAW 13601 YAKIMA ROAD 92308 $ 217.83 991 3087 301 35 0000 331431 WILLIAM CASDOS 13612 ALGONQUIN ROAD 92308 $ 596.66 992 3087 301 72 0000 331054 PABLO MERCADO 13508 RANCHERIAS RD 92308 $ 1,090.41 993 3087 301 78 0000 330962 SHAWN M MURRAY 13508 TUTELO RD 92308 $ 595.14 994 3087 311 03 0000 330686 ESTHER LANKFORD 13456 MOHAWK RD 92308 $ 275.12 995 3087 311 13 0000 331187 ROBIN ABEYTA 13390 MOHAWK ROAD 92308 $ 488.71 996 3087 312 15 0000 331022 WYNDTRIPS INC 13474 TUTELO RD 92308 $ 294.96 997 3087 312 18 0000 331793 ROBERT GRIFFITH 13430 TUTELO ROAD 92308 $ 113.49 998 3087 312 22 0000 330948 FARIMAN MOINFAR 13372 TUTELO RD 92308 $ 392.29 999 3087 313 04 0000 331412 YSENIA ESPINO 13359 TUTELO ROAD 92308 $ 237.33 1000 3087 313 21 0000 330066 ROSA YOLANDA/VERONICA LEVERON/SANCHEZ 13384 RANCHERIAS ROAD 92308 $ 607.31 1001 3087 313 26 0000 330996 AMELIA DIAZ 21460 OTTAWA RD 92308 $ 692.61 1002 3087 314 02 0000 331273 MICHAEL NIDES 13329 RANCHERIAS ROAD 92308 $ 442.43 1003 3087 314 02 0000 331274 MICHAEL NIDES 13329 RANCHERIAS ROAD 92308 $ 457.14 1004 3087 314 06 0000 330941 AQUILEO GUTIERREZ 13385 RANCHERIAS RD 92308 $ 596.32 1005 3087 314 06 0000 331175 AURORA GUTIERREZ 13385 RANCHERIAS ROAD 92308 $ 778.24 1006 3087 314 17 0000 331808 JUAN ESPINO 13444 YAKIMA ROAD 92308 $ 348.86 1007 3087 314 19 0000 331234 DIANE WOODS 13414 YAKIMA RD 92308 $ 1,101.90 1008 3087 314 23 0000 331476 ALEX ROJAS 13360 YAKIMA ROAD 92308 $ 606.56 1009 3087 314 26 0000 331513 GREGORIO GALVEZ CABEZAS 21534 OTTAWA ROAD 92308 $ 697.24 1010 3087 315 01 0000 330901 LABUHN TRUSH FAMILY LABUH 21576 OTTAWA RD 92308 $ 597.90 1011 3087 315 03 0000 330878 MARTHA DE LAMPERS 13341 YAKIMA RD 92308 $ 631.91 1012 3087 315 09 0000 330915 ABDOL SHARGHI 13429 YAKIMA RD 92308 $ 607.27 1013 3087 315 13 0000 331427 JUANA/FABIAN AMBRIZ 13489 YAKIMA ROAD 92308 $ 212.26 1014 3087 315 26 0000 330903 AURORA/AQUILEO GUTIERREZ 21608 OTTAWA RD 92308 $ 538.79 1015 3087 316 01 0000 330077 KATHERINE SHAVON DAVISON 21648 OTTAWA ROAD 92308 $ 166.40 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 1016 3087 316 09 0000 330926 GERARDO GUTIERREZ 13429 ALGONQUIN RD 92308 $ 594.76 1017 3087 316 11 0000 330954 RONALD T WILSON 13459 ALGONQUIN RD 92308 $ 268.46 1018 3087 321 03 0000 331060 SAENZ REV LIV TR SAENZ 13250 MOHAWK RD 92308 $ 623.79 1019 3087 323 14 0000 330157 LEO & BRENDA HOLIFIELD & NASH 13218 YAKIMA ROAD 92308 $ 159.49 1020 3087 323 20 0000 330998 YAN YUN ZHENG 13283 RANCHERIAS RD 92308 $ 607.27 1021 3087 323 24 0000 330134 MARK LEOUTSAKOS 13233 RANCHERIAS ROAD 92308 $ 319.88 1022 3087 323 30 0000 330992 TOMAS N BOJORQUEZ 13171 RANCHERIAS RD 92308 $ 582.68 1023 3087 324 22 0000 330004 THOMAS EDWARD TURCIOS 13174 ALGONQUIN ROAD 92308 $ 625.53 1024 3087 324 23 0000 331222 JOSEPH DEAN 13182 ALGONQUIN ROAD 92308 $ 458.04 1025 3087 324 28 0000 331564 ENRIQUE GALLARDO 13266 ALGONQUIN ROAD 92308 $ 398.20 1026 3087 325 07 0000 331009 BERTRAND B DIONNE, REV TR 13205 ALGONQUIN RD 92308 $ 341.21 1027 3087 325 20 0000 330813 GUTIERREZ MIGUEL A CARDONA 13162 CLALLAM RD 92308 $ 607.27 1028 3087 325 21 0000 331065 MERLIN YANCY 13176 NAVAJO RD 92308 $ 1,323.90 1029 3087 325 27 0000 330971 NATHAN XIN ZHANG 13276 NAVAJO RD 92308 $ 402.11 1030 3087 331 02 0000 331733 FAITH CRAFT 13072 MOHAWK ROAD 92308 $ 281.66 1031 3087 332 01 0000 330929 YANYAN ZHANG 13090 YAKIMA RD 92308 $ 279.97 1032 3087 332 03 0000 329964 ALFRED L JR HERRERA 13078 YAKIMA ROAD 92308 $ 330.11 1033 3087 333 23 0000 329914 CHARLES DUANE COLLETT 13044 ALGONQUIN ROAD 92308 $ 555.37 1034 3087 333 25 0000 331010 JENNIFER A CHASSE 13072 ALGONQUIN RD 92308 $ 607.25 1035 3087 333 26 0000 330179 MORTIMORE FAMILY TRUST MORTIMORE 13086 ALGONQUIN RD 92308 $ 216.53 1036 3087 334 03 0000 330393 ERIC J DUNN 13101 ALGONQUIN RD 92308 $ 390.88 1037 3087 334 22 0000 330020 FERNANDO ENRIQUEZ 13038 CLALLAM ROAD 92308 $ 351.49 1038 3087 334 25 0000 329972 JOHN MCGOWAN 13070 CLALLAM ROAD 92308 $ 847.05 1039 3087 335 20 0000 331276 NASRI AWAD 13016 OJAI ROAD 92308 $ 257.18 1040 3087 335 23 0000 331803 SHERRI QUINN 13040 OJAI ROAD 92308 $ 413.35 1041 3087 335 25 0000 331809 EDGAR IVAN HERNANDEZ 13074 NAVAJO ROAD 92308 $ 605.11 1042 3087 336 12 0000 329937 GONZALO GALVAN 13051 OJAI ROAD 92308 $ 1,629.49 1043 3087 337 02 0000 329907 ELSA MARTINEZ HARTNESS 21445 NISQUALLY ROAD 92308 $ 1,931.46 1044 3087 337 12 0000 331072 SHENOUDA'S INVESTMENT LLC 21593 NISQUALLY RD 92308 $ 1,844.24 1045 3087 337 17 0000 330958 MOISES CIFUENTES 21671 NISQUALLY RD 92308 $ 607.27 1046 3087 338 03 0000 331071 YUKI JONES 21337 NISQUALLY RD 92308 $ 267.38 1047 3087 342 32 0000 331731 OSOMAD LLC 22051 HIGHWAY 18 92307 $ 200.92 1048 3087 342 36 0000 331041 MULE FMILY TRUST MULE FAMILY TRUST 13566 QUINNAULT RD 92308 $ 239.33 1049 3087 361 12 0000 331011 CO RIVER MARKETING LLC 22043 OTTAWA RD 92308 $ 614.83 1050 3087 371 21 0000 331810 FERNANDO MARTINEZ 21761 OJAI ROAD 92308 $ 266.66 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 1051 3087 371 40 0000 330823 CINDY HINKLE 12960 CHIEF JOSEPH RD 92308 $ 280.79 1052 3087 371 51 0000 330973 FRANK C HERRERA 21858 OJAI RD 92308 $ 256.32 1053 3087 371 61 0000 330193 LLC(CWL DEVELOPMENT) PROJECT PROPERTY #5 12912 PAWNEE RD 92308 $ 225.38 1054 3087 371 68 0000 331811 ANDREW CUZZI 13020 PAWNEE ROAD 92308 $ 353.26 1055 3087 371 72 0000 330852 FALES LIV TR 4/22/05 13096 PAWNEE RD 92308 $ 246.02 1056 3087 381 01 0000 331023 U.S. POSTAL SERVICE 22099 STATE HWY 18 92308 $ 114.33 1057 3087 381 12 0000 331030 PETTITT- MEYER FAMILY TRUST PETTITT-MEYER FAMILY 22265 STATE HWY 18 92308 $ 212.66 1058 3087 381 21 0000 331052 JOSEPH SHAYFAR 22171 STATE HWY 18 92308 $ 2,317.17 1059 3087 421 01 0000 331409 CREATIVE RE SOLUTIONS LLC 20920 SITTING BULL ROAD 92308 $ 256.69 1060 3087 421 04 0000 330662 MICHAEL STRIBLING 20956 SITTING BULL RD 92308 $ 257.62 1061 3087 421 11 0000 331083 BRIAN SNYDER 21050 SITTING BULL RD 92308 $ 727.10 1062 3087 422 07 0000 331254 KEVIN MCCLAIM 21292 SITTING BULL ROAD 92308 $ 729.29 1063 3087 424 11 0000 330389 SUSAN PATTISON 12840 LAKOTA RD 92308 $ 249.81 1064 3087 424 15 0000 331714 NICHOLAS DONATELLI 12780 LAKOTA ROAD 92308 $ 521.09 1065 3087 425 05 0000 330997 FLOR ROBLES CARBAJAL 12795 LAKOTA RD 92308 $ 386.39 1066 3087 426 24 0000 330579 LESLIE A MC NENLY 12770 TAMIANI RD 92308 $ 262.41 1067 3087 429 01 0000 330224 DAVID MURPHY 12714 POCOMOKE RD 92308 $ 397.27 1068 3087 429 04 0000 330836 BUD GLOVER 21209 LITTLE BEAVER RD 92308 $ 282.39 1069 3087 429 16 0000 331058 JOHN F CASSEL TRUST 21005 LITTLE BEAVER ROAD 92308 $ 579.42 1070 3087 431 03 0000 330930 CHRISTOPHER & VALERIE LI 21090 LONE EAGLE RD 92308 $ 350.20 1071 3087 431 06 0000 330934 CHAD R GOODRO 21046 LONE EAGLE RD 92308 $ 256.69 1072 3087 433 06 0000 331742 JACQUELINE LOPEZ 21225 LONE EAGLE ROAD 92308 $ 905.08 1073 3087 433 08 0000 331193 JOHNNY ESPINOZA 12678 POCOMOKE ROAD 92308 $ 473.10 1074 3087 433 12 0000 330150 STEVEN JOHN TOMCZYK 21212 MINNETONKA ROAD 92308 $ 329.37 1075 3087 434 05 0000 329950 AARON WALTER ARNOLD 20929 LONE EAGLE ROAD 92308 $ 545.87 1076 3087 434 13 0000 330859 DIANA YANEZ 21084 MINNETONKA RD 92308 $ 316.44 1077 3087 434 16 0000 330952 KEVIN C LAI 21038 MINNETONKA RD 92308 $ 215.40 1078 3087 434 18 0000 331481 TIFFANY SPEARS 21008 MINNETONKA ROAD 92308 $ 256.32 1079 3087 436 03 0000 331633 MARIO MUNOZ 21011 MINNETONKA ROAD 92308 $ 1,115.51 1080 3087 436 11 0000 330967 DORIE HODKINSON 12580 TAMIANI RD 92308 $ 257.09 1081 3087 436 21 0000 330170 JOHNNY SMELSER 20996 GERONIMO RD 92308 $ 272.64 1082 3087 436 21 0000 329963 JENNIFER GUERRERO 20996 GERONIMO ROAD 92308 $ 306.37 1083 3087 436 22 0000 330187 SALLY MURRY 12545 REDWING RD 92308 $ 120.50 1084 3087 437 02 0000 329989 KATHERINE/KEVIN PANOWICZ 21173 MINNETONKA ROAD 92308 $ 632.06 1085 3087 437 03 0000 330827 FRED DOHI 21185 MINNETONKA RD 92308 $ 256.69 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 1086 3087 437 06 0000 331724 TUSTIN NORRIS 21235 MINNETONKA ROAD 92308 $ 421.23 1087 3087 437 07 0000 331795 MARI ANN GARCIA 21255 MINNETONKA ROAD 92308 $ 310.45 1088 3087 437 09 0000 331395 MARY ELLEN WILLIAMS 21236 GERONIMO ROAD 92308 $ 249.48 1089 3087 438 08 0000 330222 R & C BOGGS 12553 POCOMOKE RD 92308 $ 247.48 1090 3087 438 08 0000 330405 RICHARD/CLAUDINE BOGGS 12553 POCOMOKE RD 92308 $ 496.07 1091 3087 439 07 0000 330820 TODD ELLIOTT 12516 POCOMOKE RD 92308 $ 217.97 1092 3087 444 04 0000 331367 STEVEN SEPULVEDA 12397 KIOWA ROAD 92308 $ 409.17 1093 3087 445 32 0000 330904 THOMAS N RHINEHART 12377 TAMIANI RD 92308 $ 313.68 1094 3087 445 47 0000 331433 ALBERTO VARGAS 21189 SIOUX ROAD 92308 $ 136.95 1095 3087 445 47 0000 331223 ALBERTO VARGAS 21189 SIOUX RD 92308 $ 459.51 1096 3087 446 10 0000 330780 ARTHUR BANUELOS 12419 SARATOGA RD 92308 $ 265.81 1097 3087 446 27 0000 330947 ELDRED S CAMERON 12363 LAKOTA RD 92308 $ 256.12 1098 3087 446 28 0000 330363 JOSHUA ALLEN SMITH 12381 LAKOTA RD 92308 $ 249.81 1099 3087 447 15 0000 330258 CAMERON BAKER 21213 PAHUTE ROAD 92308 $ 221.30 1100 3087 448 10 0000 330910 LARRY MIKKELSEN 21281 POCOMOKE CT 92308 $ 244.92 1101 3087 448 12 0000 331813 EDRAS JOEL SILVA 21270 POCOMOKE CT 92308 $ 288.33 1102 3087 451 10 0000 330944 JUAN CARLOS GONZALEZ 20961 CADDO RD 92308 $ 268.56 1103 3087 452 16 0000 330946 JOSE CAMPOS PADILLA 20990 CADDO RD 92308 $ 282.39 1104 3087 453 10 0000 330892 MARICELA HERRON 12261 LIPIAN RD 92308 $ 265.81 1105 3087 454 08 0000 330184 MICHAEL MCDADE 21145 KLAMATH RD 92308 $ 216.40 1106 3087 454 28 0000 331739 AMANI INVESTMENT INC 21044 BEAR VALLEY ROAD 92308 $ 509.31 1107 3087 454 30 0000 330835 KHOI HOANG 21008 BEAR VALLEY RD 92308 $ 221.34 1108 3087 455 08 0000 330914 HUGO AQUINO, 21169 MULTNOMAH RD 92308 $ 327.39 1109 3087 462 02 0000 330964 SHANNON D SCOTT 12838 RUNNING DEER RD 92308 $ 256.31 1110 3087 462 07 0000 331002 TERRENCE DONEL SMALL 12760 RUNNING DEER RD 92308 $ 237.42 1111 3087 462 07 0000 330071 SAMANTHA BROWN 12760 RUNNING DEER ROAD 92308 $ 1,199.07 1112 3087 463 06 0000 331447 KYLE BARKDULL 12819 RUNNING DEER ROAD 92308 $ 545.42 1113 3087 463 08 0000 330876 S & R LIMITED LLC 12857 RUNNING DEER RD 92308 $ 237.25 1114 3087 463 08 0000 329871 S & R LIMITED LLC 12857 RUNNING DEER ROAD 92308 $ 1,168.23 1115 3087 463 15 0000 330980 VINAY ABROL 12750 MORNING STAR RD 92308 $ 255.17 1116 3087 464 13 0000 331577 PLANET HOME LENDING LLC 12786 STANDING BEAR ROAD 92308 $ 287.46 1117 3087 466 08 0000 330965 JUSTIN M MALDONADO 12641 RUNNING DEER RD 92308 $ 327.39 1118 3087 466 09 0000 331155 PAUL & YESENIA ROBERTS 12659 RUNNING DEER ROAD 92308 $ 588.41 1119 3087 466 15 0000 331146 TILLY SIVERT 12640 MORNING STAR ROAD 92308 $ 408.62 1120 3087 466 16 0000 330893 JOE ROBY 12622 MORNING STAR RD 92308 $ 241.27 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 1121 3087 466 16 0000 330396 JOE ROBY 12622 MORNING STAR RD 92308 $ 747.07 1122 3087 466 17 0000 330955 REGINA WEBB 12602 MORNING STAR RD 92308 $ 325.07 1123 3087 467 03 0000 330826 RANDALL J VOJKUFKA 12551 MORNING STAR RD 92308 $ 327.59 1124 3087 467 03 0000 331244 RANDY VOJKFKA 12551 MORNING STAR ROAD 92308 $ 588.39 1125 3087 467 13 0000 331387 JOSEPH J HIBLE 12676 STANDING BEAR ROAD 92308 $ 256.69 1126 3087 467 16 0000 330957 ZHONGREN CHEN 12622 STANDING BEAR RD 92308 $ 255.17 1127 3087 468 06 0000 331549 SAM E LEE 12597 STANDING BEAR ROAD 92308 $ 716.87 1128 3087 468 28 0000 329962 JOSEPH & LORA COLLIS 12778 NAVAJO ROAD 92308 $ 201.38 1129 3087 468 33 0000 330850 ROZANNA/RICHARD MAPSTEAD 12692 NAVAJO RD 92308 $ 327.39 1130 3087 468 44 0000 331658 CARLOS JR PEREZ 21678 PAHUTE ROAD 92308 $ 717.20 1131 3087 471 01 0000 330372 CARLOS TZI 21494 SITTING BULL RD 92308 $ 839.49 1132 3087 471 34 0000 331674 DHINTEC INC 12807 CLALLAM ROAD 92308 $ 417.30 1133 3087 491 02 0000 331040 APPLE VALLEY SQUARE CENTER LLC 21560 BEAR VALLEY ROAD 92308 $ 968.73 1134 3087 501 02 0000 330866 JOSEFINA MEJIA 21933 NISQUALLY RD 92308 $ 386.36 1135 3087 502 01 0000 331330 VIRGIL PONTES 12707 NAVAJO RD 92308 $ 631.89 1136 3087 502 20 0000 330960 HILLARY/CALEB PARAMO 21825 NISQUALLY RD 92308 $ 746.11 1137 3087 502 30 0000 330938 KELLY & MICHELE 2004 TR MOFFETT 12740 CHIEF JOSEPH RD 92308 $ 293.72 1138 3087 502 40 0000 329872 MARIO DANIEL VALENCIA 12721 PAWNEE ROAD 92308 $ 213.87 1139 3087 502 77 0000 330843 GERALD SPARLING 21890 LITTLE BEAVER RD 92308 $ 344.16 1140 3087 502 79 0000 331005 DENICE M AGILAERA 21975 MAUMEE RD 92308 $ 228.17 1141 3087 502 80 0000 331015 MICHAEL JOSEPH CAPONE 21985 MAUMEE RD 92308 $ 237.09 1142 3087 502 80 0000 331535 MICHAEL JOSEPH CAPONE 21985 MAUMEE ROAD 92308 $ 1,182.06 1143 3087 521 08 0000 330387 LINDA EVANS 21824 SIOUX RD 92308 $ 559.81 1144 3087 522 08 0000 331716 SUSAN KLUNK 21992 SIOUX ROAD 92308 $ 217.05 1145 3087 522 12 0000 330885 AGUSTIN & MYRELLA ALVAREZ, JR 12386 QUINNAULT RD 92308 $ 282.39 1146 3087 522 21 0000 331004 JEREMY GARRIDO 22023 PAHUTE RD 92308 $ 256.69 1147 3087 522 33 0000 330896 DONALD E PRAXMARER 12350 QUINNAULT RD 92308 $ 280.68 1148 3087 531 09 0000 331540 WILLIAM III ROSS 21823 SIOUX ROAD 92308 $ 675.78 1149 3087 532 04 0000 330895 MARTIN VAZQUEZ 21961 SIOUX RD 92308 $ 259.29 1150 3087 532 39 0000 331491 LIZETH F SANCHEZ FLORES 12259 PAWNEE ROAD 92308 $ 615.01 1151 3087 532 40 0000 331599 AMORE SMITH 12287 PAWNEE ROAD 92308 $ 307.22 1152 3087 532 44 0000 331730 RIGO CENDEJAS RODRIGUEZ 21960 BEAR VALLEY ROAD 92308 $ 413.84 1153 3087 541 01 6033 330865 TRAILS END TRAILER PARK 22241 NISQUALLY RD 92308 $ 245.41 1154 3087 551 02 0000 331618 ALBERT VILLEGAS 22423 LITTLE BEAVER ROAD 92308 $ 590.84 1155 3087 551 13 0000 330822 VICTOR SERRANO 22273 LITTLE BEAVER RD 92308 $ 256.32 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 1156 3087 551 16 0000 330824 CLIFFORD A SMITH 12663 QUINNAULT RD 92308 $ 265.81 1157 3087 551 20 0000 330564 SCOTT LIONEL ARCHULETA 22174 LONE EAGLE RD 92308 $ 257.02 1158 3087 551 32 0000 330851 GODWIN C ALOZIE 22364 LONE EAGLE RD 92308 $ 250.64 1159 3087 552 02 0000 330936 CHERYL FARLESS 22146 NOMWAKET RD 92308 $ 382.58 1160 3087 552 05 0000 330791 EDUARDO CASTANEDA 12605 QUINNAULT RD 92308 $ 364.09 1161 3087 553 25 0000 331152 VICTOR/ADRIANA RODRIGUEZ 22305 LONE EAGLE ROAD 92308 $ 581.63 1162 3087 553 28 0000 330853 JUAN LOPEZ 22349 LONE EAGLE RD 92308 $ 282.39 1163 3087 553 29 0000 331132 STEVEN HARDY 22363 LONE EAGLE ROAD 92308 $ 778.24 1164 3087 554 01 0000 331663 JESS/ NEWMANN/KELSEY 22405 MINNETONKA ROAD 92308 $ 421.23 1165 3087 554 31 0000 331414 NICHOLE HARRISON 22243 MINNETONKA ROAD 92308 $ 201.73 1166 3087 554 33 0000 329911 BRYAN & YUNUEN DURAN 22273 MINNETONKA ROAD 92308 $ 346.72 1167 3087 555 06 0000 330976 JOHN PENSINGER 12615 TONIKAN RD 92308 $ 282.39 1168 3087 555 07 0000 330966 VALLEY, SARAI DEL 12589 TONIKAN RD 92308 $ 242.53 1169 3087 555 20 0000 330977 RONALD A FAMILY TRUST CROWE 12630 CENTRAL RD 92308 $ 256.32 1170 3087 561 24 0000 330905 DONALD & KATHY URBANEK 22260 TEHAMA RD 92308 $ 235.32 1171 3087 561 29 0000 330983 ROSALIE MONTES ALVAREZ 22185 PAHUTE RD 92308 $ 256.18 1172 3087 561 36 0000 330100 RAMON LOPEZ 22210 TEHAMA ROAD 92308 $ 413.18 1173 3087 562 10 0000 330920 ANNA/JULIANNA DELGADO 22331 TEHAMA RD 92308 $ 282.39 1174 3087 562 11 0000 331225 NASRI AWAD 22347 TEHAMA RD 92308 $ 256.97 1175 3087 562 29 0000 331008 NICOLE CABAN 22175 TEHAMA RD 92308 $ 218.44 1176 3087 562 41 0000 330924 REFUGIO GONZALEZ 22130 KAYENTA RD 92308 $ 242.36 1177 3087 563 05 0000 330951 RENE CASTELLON 22261 KAYENTA RD 92308 $ 184.86 1178 3087 563 15 0000 331231 REBECCA BLACK 22394 SIOUX ROAD 92308 $ 538.30 1179 3087 563 28 0000 330862 HATTIE M. SHEPPARD 22161 KAYENTA RD 92308 $ 386.39 1180 3087 564 23 0000 331257 JESUS D MARTINEZ 22475 PAHUTE ROAD 92308 $ 207.96 1181 3087 571 05 0000 330088 EDWARD WARREN 22391 SIOUX ROAD 92308 $ 282.46 1182 3087 571 07 0000 331149 GUADALUPE RUIZ 22425 SIOUX ROAD 92308 $ 360.65 1183 3087 571 11 0000 331074 JOHN F CASSEL TRUST 22462 MIRAMOT ROAD 92308 $ 1,139.39 1184 3087 571 13 0000 330019 DAVID TORRES 22422 MIRAMOT ROAD 92308 $ 350.97 1185 3087 571 16 0000 329879 JORGE HERNANDEZ 22370 MIRAMOT ROAD 92308 $ 405.06 1186 3087 571 18 0000 331329 CARL NIELSEN 22330 MIRAMOT RD 92308 $ 351.75 1187 3087 571 24 0000 331399 TOM/RONNIE DICKSON 22393 MIRAMOT ROAD 92308 $ 282.74 1188 3087 571 65 0000 330587 FELIX ESPINO 22303 MIRAMOT RD 92308 $ 257.02 1189 3087 581 12 0000 330831 DEBRA & HENRY WAHNISH & VELASQUEZ 12775 WAYNOKA RD 92308 $ 585.82 1190 3087 581 24 0000 330825 ROBERT & SANDRA KLODNICKI 12763 ALGONQUIN RD 92308 $ 392.73 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 1191 3087 581 27 0000 331021 DONALD D KINDT 12792 OMANI CT 92308 $ 245.65 1192 3087 581 27 0000 331639 DONALD D KINDT 12792 OMANI CT 92308 $ 1,174.56 1193 3087 581 35 0000 330841 DEMETRIO RAMOS 12729 CLALLAM RD 92308 $ 256.32 1194 3087 591 22 0000 330869 RICHARD L GIVENS 21413 LONE EAGLE RD 92308 $ 386.39 1195 3087 591 24 0000 331178 GUILLERMO MORALES RODRIGUEZ 12695 ALGONQUIN ROAD 92308 $ 778.24 1196 3087 601 17 0000 330040 MICHAEL S FLOYD 12562 ALGONQUIN ROAD 92308 $ 297.75 1197 3087 601 22 0000 331003 INLAND ASSET MNG LLC INLAND ASSET MNG LLC 12497 ALGONQUIN RD 92308 $ 256.32 1198 3087 611 15 0000 331645 LARRY & PENNY TAYLOR 21457 PAHUTE ROAD 92308 $ 348.98 1199 3087 611 30 0000 331110 IAN A ATEN 21475 MINODOKA ROAD 92308 $ 298.31 1200 3087 621 18 0000 330090 JAMES V SR ONEAL 12369 POCONO ROAD 92308 $ 319.08 1201 3087 621 32 0000 331316 JORGE ALBERTO MENDOZA 20496 HALFMOON CT 92308 $ 295.98 1202 3087 621 35 0000 330672 ERNEST HALL 20463 RED HAWK PL 92308 $ 293.33 1203 3087 621 38 0000 331312 JULIA FERNANDEZ 20403 RED HAWK PL 92308 $ 308.24 1204 3087 631 04 0000 330700 TINYUK CHEUNG 20675 MOCKINGBIRD AV 92308 $ 777.83 1205 3087 631 06 0000 331794 EVA LUCERO DE KURTZ 12195 IROQUOIS ROAD 92308 $ 272.49 1206 3087 631 33 0000 330620 YAN ZHENG 12275 POCONO RD 92308 $ 143.69 1207 3087 641 07 0000 330739 ALI KHAN 20673 IROQUOIS CT 92308 $ 607.21 1208 3087 641 22 0000 331514 STORE MASTER FUNDING XIX LLC ST 20570 BEAR VALLEY ROAD 92308 $ 2,278.30 1209 3087 651 32 0000 330119 MARIA P FLORES 21415 OKANAGAN ROAD 92308 $ 213.87 1210 3087 651 37 0000 331402 TERRI SMITH 12300 ALGONQUIN ROAD 92308 $ 221.34 1211 3087 651 41 0000 330195 ANDREW BAEZ 12325 ALGONQUIN RD 92308 $ 288.66 1212 3087 661 26 0000 331162 ROLLANDA MILLER 21430 NOWATA ROAD 92308 $ 588.41 1213 3087 661 31 0000 331814 EUN YOUNG CHO 12265 ALGONQUIN ROAD 92308 $ 297.17 1214 3087 671 23 0000 331012 CHRISTIAN ZENDEJAS 21325 KLAMATH RD 92308 $ 386.32 1215 3087 671 27 0000 331338 MICHAEL J/MELINDA ALCANTAR/GODINA 21360 KLAMATH ROAD 92308 $ 254.86 1216 3087 691 22 0000 330611 4-5-06 BLACKHURST 12238 INCA RD 92308 $ 416.27 1217 3087 691 30 0000 331647 SHELLY A TUCKER 20371 PIMA ROAD 92308 $ 363.34 1218 3087 701 01 0000 330685 SKY/MARIE JULIAN/DUCKWORTH, 13365 PAOHA RD 92308 $ 607.21 1219 3087 711 17 0000 330761 BHAMINI NARAYANASWAMY 13230 PARAISO RD 92308 $ 142.52 1220 3087 721 08 0000 330600 JOHN P FITZSIMMONS 19617 POWHATAN RD 92308 $ 268.46 1221 3087 741 05 0000 330663 ANGEL AMAYA 12978 HYPERION LN 92308 $ 716.71 1222 3087 771 08 0000 330982 MICHAEL AHERN 21279 MERLOT LN 92308 $ 268.46 1223 3087 771 13 0000 330911 CAM THACH THI LE 21214 SAUVIGNON LN 92308 $ 692.60 1224 3087 771 14 0000 330881 VICTOR SOTTO 21230 SAUVIGNON LN 92308 $ 487.10 1225 3087 771 15 0000 330880 ARNOLD P MANSAT 21246 SAUVIGNON LN 92308 $ 529.36 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 1226 3087 771 25 0000 330888 LARISSA TODD 21218 SEIBEL LN 92308 $ 751.60 1227 3087 771 31 0000 330884 STEPHEN MARK CALDWELL 21273 SEIBEL LN 92308 $ 420.06 1228 3087 781 01 0000 331477 FERNANDO CAMARENA 21226 TANNIN PLC 92308 $ 268.46 1229 3087 781 05 0000 330969 FAMILY TRUST HANCOCK 21290 TANNIN PL 92308 $ 402.11 1230 3087 781 21 0000 331124 MICHAEL A JAMES 21210 NISQUALLY ROAD 92308 $ 316.42 1231 3087 781 22 0000 331013 ERNESTO R SANCHEZ 21226 NISQUALLY RD 92308 $ 314.54 1232 3087 781 25 0000 329961 DALLAS FINZELBERG 21274 NISQUALLY ROAD 92308 $ 724.37 1233 3087 791 01 0000 331294 RAVINER SINGH 12211 BRAEBURN ROAD 92308 $ 279.97 1234 3087 801 08 0000 331285 THOMAS J CARPINO 20283 GALA ROAD 92308 $ 241.36 1235 3087 801 11 0000 329945 JANET/JUAN CISNEROS 20280 GALA ROAD 92308 $ 800.16 1236 3087 801 33 0000 330657 NOEL F WELSH 20166 GALA RD 92308 $ 631.86 1237 3088 431 25 0000 330660 JOHN H HANOUM 13592 COACHELLA RD 92308 $ 673.11 1238 3088 431 26 0000 331349 TIA/PERRY COVELLO 19112 CRONESE LANE 92308 $ 631.86 1239 3088 441 19 0000 331446 MAEN SHAAR 13576 IVANPAH ROAD 92308 $ 174.85 1240 3088 441 36 0000 330728 CHANG SOON LEE 13504 HAVASU RD 92308 $ 168.45 1241 3088 451 14 0000 330609 JEREMIAH VERMILLION 13562 COCHISE RD 92308 $ 622.62 1242 3088 451 15 0000 330050 CHASE SMITH 13576 COCHISE ROAD 92308 $ 402.11 1243 3088 451 16 0000 331210 DANIEL J WARE 13577 COACHELLA ROAD 92308 $ 329.00 1244 3088 461 08 0000 330221 ROBERT & YVONNE REYES 13490 CUYAMACA RD 92308 $ 685.40 1245 3088 461 24 0000 331158 PATRICIA A ASHFORD 13456 IVANPAH ROAD 92308 $ 928.56 1246 3088 461 29 0000 330723 JESUS JOSE HERRERA 13397 HAVASU RD 92308 $ 386.20 1247 3088 461 35 0000 330613 RICHARD A FOGARTY 13489 HAVASU RD 92308 $ 665.95 1248 3088 461 37 0000 331486 MICHAEL CAMACHO 13478 HAVASU ROAD 92308 $ 589.95 1249 3088 481 08 0000 330277 COLEEN HERBER 19051 CUYAMACA PL 92308 $ 212.26 1250 3088 481 09 0000 330751 RICKEY C JR ASHTON 19057 CUYAMACA PL 92308 $ 279.97 1251 3088 481 19 0000 330788 MAEN SHAAR 13381 IVANPAH RD 92308 $ 268.46 1252 3088 481 23 0000 330617 CARLOS MUNGUIA 13334 IVANPAH RD 92308 $ 607.70 1253 3088 491 11 0000 331377 HARVEY & NICOLE LEYDE 13315 COCHISE ROAD 92308 $ 968.41 1254 3088 501 05 0000 331587 RYAN ALEXANDER RICHARDS 19006 IVANPAH WAY 92308 $ 268.46 1255 3088 501 11 0000 330626 RICHARD G MARQUEZ 13239 IVANPAH RD 92308 $ 607.70 1256 3088 511 05 0000 330759 CHARLES & CONSTANCE NUNLEY 13260 APPLE VALLEY RD 92308 $ 257.02 1257 3088 561 15 0000 330680 TIEN LAM 19187 GLENBROOK CIR 92308 $ 595.02 1258 3088 601 02 0000 329956 A & F FAMILY TRUST 8/20/97 ANGELOPOULOS 12966 IVANPAH ROAD 92308 $ 279.97 1259 3088 601 06 0000 331479 DUSTIN D SHAFER 19163 KANBRIDGE ST 92308 $ 576.42 1260 3088 601 08 0000 330649 JAE LEE 12964 STONEBROOK RD 92308 $ 607.21 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 1261 3088 611 36 0000 330659 S & C AB LIV TR 3/11/05 HOLLANDS 19218 STRATFORD WAY 92308 $ 309.29 1262 3088 621 15 0000 331719 VPH-RWC LLC 19162 MONTEREY ST 92308 $ 279.97 1263 3112 011 25 0000 330354 LINDA WALKER 15271 MANDAN RD 92307 $ 235.33 1264 3112 021 02 0000 331089 DANIEL VILLARS 15110 MANDAN ROAD 92307 $ 350.36 1265 3112 023 08 0000 331772 JAMES H MILLER 15111 MANDAN ROAD 92307 $ 241.70 1266 3112 024 03 0000 331509 JASON P E BROWN 15056 PAMLICO ROAD 92307 $ 271.23 1267 3112 024 03 0000 331578 JASON P E BROWN 15056 PAMLICO ROAD 92307 $ 586.89 1268 3112 024 04 0000 330439 SIMONA BUGARIN 19472 KINAI RD 92307 $ 275.20 1269 3112 025 06 0000 331398 WENDY/GEORGE D'ISABELLA 14960 CHOCO ROAD 92307 $ 882.27 1270 3112 026 02 0000 330444 ALEX MORONES 15055 MIAMI RD 92307 $ 362.00 1271 3112 026 09 0000 331635 RYAN T. ZIEROLF 15184 POCAHONTAS ROAD 92307 $ 389.92 1272 3112 026 11 0000 331517 JUDY HARRIS 15150 POCAHONTAS ROAD 92307 $ 328.29 1273 3112 031 28 0000 331119 JOSEPH S HERNANDEZ 14840 PAMLICO ROAD 92307 $ 588.41 1274 3112 032 24 0000 331086 KEITH E FIELER 19587 TONKAWAN ROAD 92307 $ 778.24 1275 3112 051 10 0000 331177 RAYMOND BROWN 19455 ONEIDA ROAD 92307 $ 678.47 1276 3112 051 32 0000 331247 JOVY CADALIG 14650 PAMLICO ROAD 92307 $ 809.95 1277 3112 052 15 0000 331088 GEORGE H WOODWORTH 19629 ONEIDA ROAD 92307 $ 282.67 1278 3112 052 17 0000 331469 WAYNE P. MCKEE 19589 ONEIDA ROAD 92307 $ 262.50 1279 3112 061 08 0000 330563 SHAHIN LIVING TRUST SHAHIN 19325 SENECA RD 92307 $ 269.36 1280 3112 062 02 0000 331643 LOGAN A WEST 19435 RED FEATHER ROAD 92307 $ 355.43 1281 3112 062 07 0000 331594 LANNI G RODERICK 19438 OSHKOSH ROAD 92307 $ 540.64 1282 3112 063 02 0000 331583 GLENN JOHNSON 14342 PAMLICO ROAD 92307 $ 696.51 1283 3112 063 09 0000 330139 MARIA HERNANDEZ 14315 APPLE VALLEY ROAD 92307 $ 79.64 1284 3112 064 04 0000 330149 YAN RONG ZHENG 19609 SENECA ROAD 92307 $ 543.31 1285 3112 064 10 0000 330465 SARKIS DERDERIAN 19524 RED FEATHER RD 92307 $ 253.50 1286 3112 071 14 0000 331237 CHARLES L TAYLOR 14265 APPLE VALLEY ROAD 92307 $ 669.55 1287 3112 072 02 0000 329917 PREME LIFE TRUST 14119 MONTE VERDE ROAD 92307 $ 301.86 1288 3112 081 01 0000 330338 RAYMOND VALENCIA 14095 APPLE VALLEY RD 92307 $ 249.81 1289 3112 081 12 0000 330315 RONALD S EDSELL 14030 MONTE VERDE RD 92307 $ 249.81 1290 3112 082 02 0000 330295 KELLER REVOCABLE FAMILY TR 1-8 14075 MONTE VERDE RD 92307 $ 249.81 1291 3112 082 05 0000 330395 CHESTER & MARILYN GUFFY 13989 MONTE VERDE RD 92307 $ 361.42 1292 3112 084 17 0000 330096 JOSEPH III TROMBINO 19686 CREST DR 92307 $ 241.73 1293 3112 084 18 0000 330431 KIRK E NELSON 13982 CHOCO RD 92307 $ 200.61 1294 3112 091 19 0000 331518 CHARLES & HILLARY KNOTTS & BURRELL 13790 CHATEAU CT 92307 $ 588.61 1295 3112 101 12 0000 330062 FERMAN HERNANDEZ 19814 TOMAHAWK ROAD 92307 $ 221.05 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 1296 3112 101 18 0000 330191 CHARLES CARISTI 19963 RANCHERIAS RD 92307 $ 437.92 1297 3112 101 22 0000 330380 MICHAEL LEMONS 19960 RANCHERIAS RD 92307 $ 262.49 1298 3112 111 01 0000 330386 MOSSA LARI 19729 TOMAHAWK RD 92307 $ 243.51 1299 3112 111 06 0000 331351 DEAN MILLIGAN 14790 TIGERTAIL ROAD 92307 $ 216.20 1300 3112 111 20 0000 330356 LETICIA ROSALES 14603 TIGERTAIL RD 92307 $ 398.64 1301 3112 121 04 0000 330082 ROBERT/TIERRA LOCKWOOD 14662 TIGERTAIL ROAD 92307 $ 561.01 1302 3112 121 10 0000 331199 ERIC NACK 19766 SENECA ROAD 92307 $ 848.17 1303 3112 121 21 0000 331681 DENNIS TAN 20016 SENECA ROAD 92307 $ 353.99 1304 3112 121 22 0000 331275 ANDREW ANDRADE 20038 SENECA ROAD 92307 $ 426.21 1305 3112 121 30 0000 330353 EFREN CHAVEZ 14682 RINCON RD 92307 $ 257.81 1306 3112 121 34 0000 329932 BRIAN/SAUNDRA RING 19989 CROW ROAD 92307 $ 1,219.90 1307 3112 133 27 0000 330582 DIANE LUNDY 19848 CHASKA RD 92307 $ 497.53 1308 3112 135 12 0000 330432 MICHAEL SANCHEZ 19998 RED FEATHER RD 92307 $ 359.00 1309 3112 135 12 0000 330061 MICHAEL SANCHEZ 19998 RED FEATHER ROAD 92307 $ 565.02 1310 3112 138 16 0000 331160 SALVADOR SANDOVAL 20059 RED FEATHER ROAD 92307 $ 578.33 1311 3112 144 11 0000 330445 FABIEN M RODRIGUEZ 14146 CRONESE RD 92307 $ 249.81 1312 3112 144 11 0000 331098 FABIEN & MICHELLE RODRIGUEZ 14146 CRONESE ROAD 92307 $ 1,157.21 1313 3112 146 04 0000 330365 ILYA GEYMAN 19942 SHOSHONEE RD 92307 $ 275.21 1314 3112 147 08 0000 330461 JOHN C ROBLES 19900 TALIHINA RD 92307 $ 275.20 1315 3112 148 12 0000 330370 JIMMY PHILLIPS 14208 RINCON RD 92307 $ 412.69 1316 3112 149 03 0000 331494 JONATHAN AUGERS 14127 CROW ROAD 92307 $ 215.89 1317 3112 151 05 0000 331732 DONALD SHULTS 14025 CHOCO ROAD 92307 $ 263.81 1318 3112 151 13 0000 331391 DALE PETERSON 14072 OLATHE ROAD 92307 $ 333.75 1319 3112 151 34 0000 330207 AQUILEO GUTIERREZ 13992 TAWYA RD 92307 $ 361.42 1320 3112 151 35 0000 330483 AQUILEO GUTIERREZ 13974 TAWYA RD 92307 $ 361.42 1321 3112 153 22 0000 330469 MARTHA M/GEORGE J KAHKOSKO 13985 DELAWARE RD 92307 $ 278.29 1322 3112 153 34 0000 329944 JOSHUA B AUGERS 13930 CROW ROAD 92307 $ 270.84 1323 3112 154 09 0000 330446 HAROLD LOVE 14075 CROW RD 92307 $ 361.42 1324 3112 154 16 0000 330437 AMBER AILEEN COATS 13966 RINCON RD 92307 $ 204.17 1325 3112 161 04 0000 330335 DERRICK BLASINGAME 13881 CHOCO RD 92307 $ 249.81 1326 3112 162 15 0000 330799 JAMIE HOODY 13822 DELAWARE RD 92307 $ 312.79 1327 3112 162 15 0000 329936 DENICE & JAMIE HUTNER & HOODY 13822 DELAWARE ROAD 92307 $ 704.27 1328 3112 165 03 0000 330411 BENJAMIN A TORREZ 13917 DELAWARE RD 92307 $ 397.27 1329 3112 165 08 0000 330342 SHARON NICODEMUS 13909 CROW RD 92307 $ 274.87 1330 3112 168 07 0000 331450 YAN ZHEN CHEN 20086 YUCCA LOMA ROAD 92307 $ 249.82 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 1331 3112 191 19 0000 331319 PHILIP II COLE 19954 TINNE RD 92307 $ 397.27 1332 3112 191 20 0000 330460 JOSE J SALCEDO 19952 TINNE RD 92307 $ 214.85 1333 3112 191 21 0000 331363 MATTHEW HELMS 19950 TINNE ROAD 92307 $ 173.62 1334 3112 192 12 0000 330026 TONY WONG 20152 CHICKASAW ROAD 92307 $ 241.73 1335 3112 192 17 0000 330216 EDWARD VEGA 20245 RANCHERIAS RD 92307 $ 254.80 1336 3112 201 08 0000 331183 RITA STEWART LYNUM 20305 RANCHERIAS ROAD 92307 $ 588.41 1337 3112 201 14 0000 330741 TIM Q DANCY 20112 ONEIDA RD 92307 $ 283.18 1338 3112 201 26 0000 329878 HAROLD F III MANLEY 20280 SENECA ROAD 92307 $ 249.98 1339 3112 201 30 0000 329941 JOAN WIESE 20204 SENECA ROAD 92307 $ 268.31 1340 3112 211 09 0000 330129 WILLIAM/LAURA WALKER/PARDO 14337 RINCON ROAD 92307 $ 259.46 1341 3112 211 17 0000 331362 DAVID MALDONADO 14330 RICAREE ROAD 92307 $ 587.78 1342 3112 212 25 0000 331303 ROGER EDVIN JR BOHMAN 14399 RICAREE ROAD 92307 $ 357.82 1343 3112 212 25 0000 331576 ROGER EDVIN JR BOHMAN 14399 RICAREE ROAD 92307 $ 1,156.39 1344 3112 213 17 0000 330127 TONY WONG 20421 RANCHERIAS ROAD 92307 $ 107.85 1345 3112 223 13 0000 330419 DEBRA M. SCHARDT, 20357 SHOSHONEE RD 92307 $ 275.20 1346 3112 223 17 0000 330361 YANRONG ZHENG 20441 SHOSHONEE RD 92307 $ 231.71 1347 3112 231 04 0000 330463 PATRICK T NICHOLS 20163 OCHOA RD 92307 $ 249.81 1348 3112 231 06 0000 330447 RICK AYERS 20145 OCHOA RD 92307 $ 275.20 1349 3112 231 26 0000 330155 SEAN/JUSTINE STEWART/JOERGER 20195 MASSAI TRL 92307 $ 216.38 1350 3112 232 28 0000 331805 OTHA MCMILLAN REVOCABLE TR 13930 FALLING LEAF ROAD 92307 $ 251.36 1351 3112 232 33 0000 330586 VICTOR MURO 14030 FALLING LEAF RD 92307 $ 283.18 1352 3112 233 41 0000 330786 SHEILA A O'SULLIVAN 20154 OCHOA RD 92307 $ 200.24 1353 3112 251 21 0000 331034 COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO 14901 DALE EVANS PKWY 92307 $ 449.40 1354 3112 251 68 0000 331051 APPLE VALLEY COMMONS APPLE VALLEY COMMONS 20258 STATE HWY 18 92307 $ 381.68 1355 3112 271 23 0000 330440 SHURON TAYLOR 14293 FLATHEAD RD 92307 $ 359.00 1356 3112 271 24 0000 330006 ANA BOGINO 14285 FLATHEAD ROAD 92307 $ 365.51 1357 3112 272 06 0000 331493 ENRIQUE JR LIMON 14249 GAYHEAD ROAD 92307 $ 381.46 1358 3112 281 01 0000 330288 DONALD J WALSH 20585 TONAWANDA RD 92307 $ 275.21 1359 3112 282 06 0000 331511 ANTHONY MILLION 20510 TONAWANDA ROAD 92307 $ 1,166.70 1360 3112 291 16 0000 331102 ELMA L MONTENEGRO 13947 HOPI ROAD 92307 $ 210.44 1361 3112 291 36 0000 331144 RAYMOND J III SCHMIDT 20635 TONAWANDA ROAD 92307 $ 261.69 1362 3112 301 13 0000 330322 ROSALBA MARTINEZ 13825 SEMINOLE RD 92307 $ 195.00 1363 3112 301 13 0000 331135 ROSALBA MARTINEZ 13825 SEMINOLE RD 92307 $ 548.95 1364 3112 301 15 0000 331266 JEANETTE RODRIGUEZ 13775 SEMINOLE ROAD 92307 $ 588.41 1365 3112 301 16 0000 330220 MICHELE L MAYNE 13755 SEMINOLE RD 92307 $ 275.21 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 1366 3112 302 07 0000 330123 LEENA GRIGGS 13751 HOPI ROAD 92307 $ 421.02 1367 3112 303 08 0000 331211 ROBERT D JR POWER 20825 TONAWANDA ROAD 92307 $ 778.24 1368 3112 303 12 0000 331226 VANESSA THOMAS 13815 IROQUOIS ROAD 92307 $ 847.00 1369 3112 303 14 0000 331136 LAUREN MULLINS 13775 IROQUOIS ROAD 92307 $ 588.08 1370 3112 311 08 0000 331741 RICARDO APARICIO 15252 APACHE ROAD 92307 $ 1,225.76 1371 3112 313 01 0000 330558 YANRONG ZHENG 21195 THUNDERBIRD RD 92307 $ 254.80 1372 3112 313 06 0000 330809 ROBERT L CROSBY 15220 COMANCHE RD 92307 $ 282.39 1373 3112 314 03 0000 331050 FLORENCE GWAN 15245 COMANCHE ROAD 92307 $ 261.28 1374 3112 314 05 0000 330557 WAYNE HOLLAND 15190 CHEYENNE RD 92307 $ 249.81 1375 3112 321 19 0000 331120 EILEEN KROESE REV TRUST 15005 BLACKFOOT ROAD 92307 $ 518.16 1376 3112 321 25 0000 330125 FELIX JR GAYTON 15097 BLACKFOOT ROAD 92307 $ 514.37 1377 3112 322 14 0000 330471 JOHNSTON 14908 DAKOTA RD 92307 $ 204.17 1378 3112 323 04 0000 331150 EDWARD VALDEZ 14985 DAKOTA ROAD 92307 $ 588.41 1379 3112 332 02 0000 330329 ENRIQUE J. & ANN M. SANCHEZ 20840 PINE RIDGE AV 92307 $ 415.31 1380 3112 332 02 0000 331218 ENRIQUE SANCHEZ 20840 PINE RIDGE AV 92307 $ 491.32 1381 3112 332 07 0000 330452 KENNETH L RHODES 20875 STANDING ROCK AV 92307 $ 299.56 1382 3112 333 01 0000 330466 ELMOSTAFA ELKHIAR 14880 DAKOTA RD 92307 $ 258.04 1383 3112 333 16 0000 330425 CARLA YACOBUCCI 14835 CHEYENNE RD 92307 $ 249.81 1384 3112 333 18 0000 329916 TIMOTHY BUCKNER 14875 CHEYENNE ROAD 92307 $ 302.03 1385 3112 341 36 0000 331091 RUDOLPH HARRISON 21041 PINE RIDGE AVE 92307 $ 588.41 1386 3112 351 16 0000 331255 MAURICIO PALMA 21066 STATE HWY 18 92307 $ 205.99 1387 3112 351 16 0000 331438 MAURICIO/SANDRA PALMA 21066 STATE HWY 18 92307 $ 353.31 1388 3112 351 28 0000 331191 MIGUEL CADENA 14451 FLATHEAD ROAD 92307 $ 724.31 1389 3112 361 34 0000 330450 DTD 03-17-2005 ARDI 21019 RANCHERIAS RD 92307 $ 270.99 1390 3112 372 08 0000 329905 ROYAL FALCON INVESTMENT CO.LLC ROYAL FALCON INVEST, 14065 HOPI ROAD 92307 $ 218.58 1391 3112 373 02 0000 329886 CATHY J EVETT 14037 IROQUOIS ROAD 92307 $ 304.13 1392 3112 373 06 0000 330580 T KAZEE 14085 IROQUOIS RD 92307 $ 284.54 1393 3112 381 04 0000 330480 DAVID OCNOFF 20812 TONAWANDA RD 92307 $ 215.88 1394 3112 381 17 0000 330199 PETER S LIPSCOMB 14018 JICARILLA RD 92307 $ 244.89 1395 3112 382 01 0000 331464 PATRICK KAREEM SMITH 13891 JICARILLA ROAD 92307 $ 408.96 1396 3112 382 22 0000 330468 RHONDA B FRANK 13894 KIOWA RD 92307 $ 337.54 1397 3112 382 24 0000 331738 ROMEL DUENAS 13866 KIOWA ROAD 92307 $ 521.19 1398 3112 382 26 0000 331538 JERYN PETERS 13840 KIOWA ROAD 92307 $ 295.77 1399 3112 391 07 0000 330348 YAN RONG ZHENG 13748 KIOWA RD 92307 $ 260.02 1400 3112 391 09 0000 330814 JULIA HILLSMAN 20918 YUCCA LOMA RD 92307 $ 261.37 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 1401 3112 391 17 0000 331607 CHERYL MARIE GOMEZ 13847 JICARILLA ROAD 92307 $ 812.43 1402 3112 392 01 0000 330802 JAMES T & JOHN T CHANNELL 13820 LAKOTA RD 92307 $ 327.39 1403 3112 392 09 0000 331069 BRAYAN MARTINES 21068 YUCCA LOMA RD 92307 $ 520.43 1404 3112 392 18 0000 331094 JAMES & KAREN 12 VIEUX 13831 KIOWA ROAD 92307 $ 150.62 1405 3112 393 02 0000 330299 DAVID CORDOVA 13718 MOHAWK RD 92307 $ 625.27 1406 3112 393 09 0000 330345 GERALD & MONA BIGGERS 13789 LAKOTA RD 92307 $ 249.81 1407 3112 401 13 0000 330317 THOAMAS/WENDY RODRIGUEZ 15175 CHEYENNE RD 92307 $ 266.33 1408 3112 401 15 0000 330551 JOSE FRANCISCO DE LA TORRE 15120 DAKOTA RD 92307 $ 287.13 1409 3112 402 06 0000 331650 TORIA ALLAHAR 15220 ERIE ROAD 92307 $ 235.40 1410 3112 402 07 0000 330153 NINA MOORE 15200 ERIE ROAD 92307 $ 216.02 1411 3112 411 04 0000 329875 ALBERT III VELA 15111 CHEYENNE ROAD 92307 $ 205.28 1412 3112 412 02 0000 330324 YAN YUN ZHENG 15035 DAKOTA RD 92307 $ 242.59 1413 3112 412 11 0000 330499 SCOTT JOHN DEVOOGHT 15090 RAMONA AV 92307 $ 519.15 1414 3112 421 01 0000 329903 DIEGO E LOPEZ 21291 RAMONA AVE 92307 $ 261.87 1415 3112 421 05 0000 331403 FANG SUJIAN 14820 ERIE ROAD 92307 $ 247.75 1416 3112 421 12 0000 330479 ABBAS SHARGHI 21258 STANDING ROCK AV 92307 $ 249.81 1417 3112 422 12 0000 330454 WALTER BRADFORD 14915 RAMONA AV 92307 $ 251.68 1418 3112 431 05 0000 331084 MICHAEL WILLIS 14732 ERIE RD 92307 $ 500.35 1419 3112 431 07 0000 331350 ANTHONY RUBIN RODRIGUEZ BEZADA 14811 DAKOTA ROAD 92307 $ 573.97 1420 3112 433 12 0000 330053 JESUS BARRAGAN 21325 RAMONA AVE 92307 $ 395.90 1421 3112 433 15 0000 330492 GERARDO/DORA GONZALEZ 21350 RAMONA AV 92307 $ 209.16 1422 3112 441 19 0000 330453 SHARI KIDWELL 14655 FLATHEAD RD 92307 $ 212.44 1423 3112 442 08 0000 330055 MICHAEL CASAREZ 14520 HOPI ROAD 92307 $ 253.47 1424 3112 442 13 0000 331401 SAMANTHA/EVAN TOLSON 14450 HOPI ROAD 92307 $ 778.24 1425 3112 442 15 0000 330434 MARTIN J BISHOP 21182 PINE RIDGE AV 92307 $ 249.50 1426 3112 442 15 0000 330142 MARTIN J BISHOP 21182 PINE RIDGE AVE 92307 $ 588.41 1427 3112 443 09 0000 329976 VIRGINA HOWELL 14432 IROQUOIS ROAD 92307 $ 194.54 1428 3112 443 15 0000 331128 RAMIRO VASQUEZ 14523 HOPI ROAD 92307 $ 127.69 1429 3112 451 04 0000 331528 BRIAN L COLLOM 14350 IROQUOIS ROAD 92307 $ 637.16 1430 3112 452 01 0000 331194 JANET HAYS 14220 JICARILLA ROAD 92307 $ 253.67 1431 3112 452 05 0000 331327 SERGIO ZEPEDA 14272 JICARILLA RD 92307 $ 200.61 1432 3112 452 11 0000 331462 FREDDIE TERRY 14350 JICARILLA ROAD 92307 $ 618.44 1433 3112 461 11 0000 330420 ADRINE HOUFF 21110 RANCHERIAS RD 92307 $ 397.27 1434 3112 461 11 0000 331109 ADRINE HOUFF 21110 RANCHERIAS ROAD 92307 $ 778.24 1435 3112 463 07 0000 329947 CAMSTEIN CHRISBERG LLC CAMSTEIN CHRISBERG L 21398 PINE RIDGE AVE 92307 $ 1,139.19 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 1436 3112 463 08 0000 331530 AGUSTIN RIVERA 21370 PINE RIDGE AVE 92307 $ 259.61 1437 3112 463 10 0000 330280 ZUBENA SHAMIM KIDWAI 14245 JICARILLA RD 92307 $ 80.85 1438 3112 471 04 0000 330427 VINCENT J MAZZONE 13959 KIOWA RD 92307 $ 306.16 1439 3112 472 17 0000 331422 KAMILLE COULTER 21234 RANCHERIAS ROAD 92307 $ 275.21 1440 3112 472 17 0000 331543 KAMILLE COULTER 21234 RANCHERIAS ROAD 92307 $ 596.48 1441 3112 473 13 0000 331584 ED R JR BLASDEL 21533 PINE RIDGE AVE 92307 $ 951.30 1442 3112 481 01 0000 330367 ANGEL MURO 21287 RANCHERIAS RD 92307 $ 237.85 1443 3112 483 08 0000 331652 ELIZABETH MORALES 21494 STATE HWY 18 92307 $ 238.44 1444 3112 491 03 0000 331603 KYLE C CHAFFIN 15165 RAMONA AVE 92307 $ 902.84 1445 3112 491 05 0000 331404 KIMBERLY SNOW 15201 RAMONA AVE 92307 $ 581.05 1446 3112 491 19 0000 330416 SUSAN A MADISON-DEHOYOS 15130 FLATHEAD RD 92307 $ 612.31 1447 3112 491 19 0000 331090 SUSAN MADISON-DEHOYOS 15130 FLATHEAD ROAD 92307 $ 1,157.21 1448 3112 501 21 0000 331334 GARY W COOPER 15105 FLATHEAD RD 92307 $ 361.42 1449 3112 511 08 0000 330189 FERNANDO ORTIZ 21444 RAMONA AV 92307 $ 252.40 1450 3112 511 19 0000 331487 DOE D GASQUE 14758 HOPI ROAD 92307 $ 753.42 1451 3112 511 20 0000 331259 CARMEN MENDEZ 14760 HOPI ROAD 92307 $ 370.06 1452 3112 511 31 0000 331105 TEODOLINDA HENRIQUEZ 14791 GAYHEAD ROAD 92307 $ 527.73 1453 3112 521 01 0000 330293 RICHARD ALLEN JOHANNSEN 14681 HOPI RD 92307 $ 249.81 1454 3112 521 04 0000 331085 SUZANNE M GATCHELL 21482 RAMONA AVE 92307 $ 457.55 1455 3112 521 41 0000 330790 TERRY & KRISTINE NOTHSTINE 14687 NAVAJO RD 92307 $ 256.32 1456 3112 531 01 0000 331157 JAMES R LINDORFER 21731 RAMONA AVE 92307 $ 588.41 1457 3112 531 09 0000 330455 BETTY JEAN JONES 14352 KIOWA RD 92307 $ 212.70 1458 3112 531 14 0000 330320 KJBCO INC 14450 NAVAJO RD 92307 $ 230.09 1459 3112 531 19 0000 330314 MICHELE L ALLEN 14457 JICARILLA RD 92307 $ 230.09 1460 3112 531 24 0000 331154 HECTOR & ROSA QUIROZ & ANDRADE 14394 JICARILLA ROAD 92307 $ 588.41 1461 3112 542 08 0000 330302 ABDOL SHARGHI 14215 KIOWA RD 92307 $ 249.81 1462 3112 542 22 0000 331235 WILBUR J RUYBALID 14212 LAKOTA ROAD 92307 $ 246.50 1463 3112 551 06 0000 330744 JAMES PETER II NARANJO 14099 LAKOTA RD 92307 $ 250.22 1464 3112 551 06 0000 331473 JAMES PETER II NARANJO 14099 LAKOTA ROAD 92307 $ 778.65 1465 3112 551 23 0000 329927 VICKIE & DWAYNE JOHNSON 14020 MOHAWK ROAD 92307 $ 266.29 1466 3112 551 37 0000 331458 MARIA ELVA SOTO 14115 NAVAJO ROAD 92307 $ 626.34 1467 3112 551 43 0000 330539 ALFREDO RIOS 13985 NAVAJO RD 92307 $ 633.85 1468 3112 551 43 0000 331180 ALFREDO RIOS 13985 NAVAJO ROAD 92307 $ 1,261.63 1469 3112 561 06 0000 331233 DALE/ALICE BROWN 21635 PINE RIDGE AVE 92307 $ 1,157.21 1470 3112 561 23 0000 329908 YAHAICA/JOSE ROJAS 13926 NAVAJO ROAD 92307 $ 893.09 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 1471 3112 562 07 0000 330508 ESTANISLADO MENDOZA JR 21895 CHEROKEE AV 92307 $ 203.68 1472 3112 562 11 0000 330509 PHILLIP DESANTIAGO 13950 PAWNEE RD 92307 $ 260.21 1473 3112 562 32 0000 331323 CENTRAL APPLE VALLEY LLC 21898 ARAPAHOE AV 92307 $ 381.13 1474 3112 563 27 0000 331055 MYRA LEWIS 21875 ARAPAHOE AV 92307 $ 3,002.24 1475 3112 563 37 0000 330057 LILY A. GARCIA 13848 OSAGE ROAD 92307 $ 248.70 1476 3112 571 33 0000 330473 LISA PIERSON 15123 QUINNAULT RD 92307 $ 249.81 1477 3112 571 33 0000 331278 LISA PIERSON 15123 QUINNAULT ROAD 92307 $ 281.13 1478 3112 581 09 0000 331356 DONALD J WALKER 21960 ELKALO ROAD 92307 $ 248.17 1479 3112 581 14 0000 331295 SOKHOEUN & LEE KHEM & CHAN 14990 NANTICOKE ROAD 92307 $ 238.56 1480 3112 581 18 0000 331597 ROBERT GRESHAM 14942 NANTICOKE ROAD 92307 $ 693.51 1481 3112 581 33 0000 330535 DEREK REY MORENO 15088 NANTICOKE RD 92307 $ 309.87 1482 3112 591 03 0000 330390 CHARLES R TAFOYA 21848 MOHICAN AV 92307 $ 566.21 1483 3112 591 04 0000 330429 CHRISTINE V. DUNNE 21834 MOHICAN AV 92307 $ 602.23 1484 3112 591 17 0000 331758 LARRY/NATALIE WHITE/ERICKSON 21755 STANDING ROCK AVE 92307 $ 1,063.65 1485 3112 592 03 0000 331324 AUSTIN WALTERS 21934 MOHICAN AV 92307 $ 601.93 1486 3112 592 08 0000 330217 MONT V ELKINS 22006 MOHICAN AV 92307 $ 601.93 1487 3112 592 16 0000 331630 MEGAN GOSS 21993 STANDING ROCK AVE 92307 $ 354.51 1488 3112 592 18 0000 330502 OMAR RODRIGUEZ 21967 STANDING ROCK AV 92307 $ 528.71 1489 3112 592 22 0000 330485 RUFILO GERMAN DORADO 21907 STANDING ROCK AV 92307 $ 381.53 1490 3112 593 18 0000 330132 THOMAS SURPRENANT 21932 STANDING ROCK AVE 92307 $ 1,149.89 1491 3112 593 23 0000 330176 JOHNNY TAYLOR 21866 STANDING ROCK AV 92307 $ 605.80 1492 3112 593 27 0000 330512 BOSSIER TRUST 21812 STANDING ROCK AV 92307 $ 392.24 1493 3112 601 10 0000 330018 MATTHEW TORRES 14616 OSAGE ROAD 92307 $ 568.27 1494 3112 601 12 0000 331314 DOREEN AMELIA GONZALES 14588 OSAGE ROAD 92307 $ 761.41 1495 3112 602 03 0000 330443 YRENEO CRUZ 21868 KLICKITAT AV 92307 $ 225.23 1496 3112 602 04 0000 330164 CAROL ALLEN 21856 KLICKITAT AVE 92307 $ 993.68 1497 3112 604 06 0000 330490 JOHN 3-23 IRWIN 21985 MOHICAN AV 92307 $ 278.71 1498 3112 611 09 0000 331565 JOHN DAVID JR CUMMINGS 21843 JELAN AVE 92307 $ 621.78 1499 3112 611 11 0000 330451 JULIENNE/DONALD MCAFEE, 21867 JELAN AV 92307 $ 522.20 1500 3112 612 07 0000 330049 SHAWNEE TERRY-DAVIS 21827 RAMONA AVE 92307 $ 1,528.86 1501 3112 612 10 0000 330117 VICTOR TORRES, 21879 RAMONA AVE 92307 $ 143.02 1502 3112 613 06 0000 331626 ISRAEL HERNANDEZ 22020 RAMONA AVE 92307 $ 1,289.50 1503 3112 614 10 0000 330326 MATTHEW JAMES LADD 14482 QUINNAULT RD 92307 $ 601.93 1504 3112 622 10 0000 331449 BRYAN/ERIC ECHOLS 21900 HURONS AVE 92307 $ 249.27 1505 3112 622 15 0000 330297 ALLEN DEVAN 21828 HURONS AV 92307 $ 247.03 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 1506 3112 623 04 0000 331241 TYLER BOLDUC 21841 HURONS AVE 92307 $ 238.27 1507 3112 623 16 0000 330787 LAURANCE A TAYLOR 21872 GOSHUTE AV 92307 $ 327.39 1508 3112 625 01 0000 330553 ROBERTO A BUSTOS 21937 ISATIS AV 92307 $ 608.11 1509 3112 625 05 0000 330801 RONALD L & JAMI L HESTER 21999 ISATIS AV 92307 $ 631.90 1510 3112 626 02 0000 331101 HOWARD A HAMMOND 22078 GOSHUTE AVE 92307 $ 260.58 1511 3112 626 14 0000 331104 DON NEFF II 22051 HURONS AVE 92307 $ 960.07 1512 3112 626 16 0000 331799 REBECCA DAVIS 14345 QUINNAUILT ROAD 92307 $ 217.41 1513 3112 626 16 0000 330065 REBECCA DAVIS 14345 QUINNAULT ROAD 92307 $ 451.61 1514 3112 626 16 0000 329981 REBECCCA DAVIS 14345 QUINNAULT ROAD 92307 $ 739.26 1515 3112 626 17 0000 330474 MAS REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS LLC 14365 QUINNAULT RD 92307 $ 537.29 1516 3112 631 05 0000 331788 GLENDA GONZALEZ 14124 OSAGE ROAD 92307 $ 208.35 1517 3112 632 03 0000 330099 KRISTINA L & ZACHARY CRAIG & SPARKS 21928 FOX AVE 92307 $ 134.08 1518 3112 633 09 0000 331656 DINH TAN PHAM 21919 FOX AVE 92307 $ 241.82 1519 3112 635 03 0000 329977 ANGEL HERNANDEZ 14097 PAWNEE ROAD 92307 $ 339.34 1520 3112 635 18 0000 331113 RODNEY & CHRISTIE L. AIDE & DUKE 14150 QUINNAULT ROAD 92307 $ 960.36 1521 3112 636 02 0000 330426 SONIA POWELL 14083 QUINNAULT RD 92307 $ 292.94 1522 3112 636 10 0000 330478 ABDOL ALI SHARGHI 14191 QUINNAULT RD 92307 $ 626.04 1523 3112 642 08 0000 330294 ABBAS SHARGHI 21866 DOTAME AV 92307 $ 249.81 1524 3112 642 10 0000 330104 JINYONG & WEN JIANG & CHENG 21836 DOTAME AVE 92307 $ 249.21 1525 3112 643 02 0000 331379 ISRAEL ROBLES 21821 DOTAME AVE 92307 $ 316.50 1526 3112 643 14 0000 330290 GLENN R NOTTLE 21950 CHEROKEE AV 92307 $ 205.08 1527 3112 643 14 0000 331779 STEPHANIE NOTTLE 21950 CHEROKEE AVE 92307 $ 212.75 1528 3112 643 21 0000 331394 MATTHEW SCOTT KEMPTON 21850 CHEROKEE AV 92307 $ 275.22 1529 3112 643 22 0000 330527 KENNETH D JR ROY 21840 CHEROKEE AV 92307 $ 249.81 1530 3112 644 11 0000 331637 GINA ALVARADO 14085 PAWNEE ROAD 92307 $ 477.25 1531 3112 644 17 0000 331320 KENNETH & KARLEY PARSONS & HURTADO 14006 QUINNAULT RD 92307 $ 601.93 1532 3112 645 01 0000 331361 LYNN AUCHEY 22090 CHEROKEE AVE 92307 $ 571.42 1533 3112 645 02 0000 331655 TONY MUNOZ 22080 CHEROKEE AVE 92307 $ 933.59 1534 3112 645 09 0000 329926 TRACY LYN SHERWOOD 14081 QUINNAULT ROAD 92307 $ 1,176.33 1535 3112 651 03 0000 331317 CASIE J BROOKS 22015 CHEROKEE AVE 92307 $ 1,149.89 1536 3112 651 12 0000 330285 GINA GRIEGO 21960 BILOXI RD 92307 $ 709.52 1537 3112 651 17 0000 330798 ANNETTE VALENZUELA 13971 QUINNAULT RD 92307 $ 607.57 1538 3112 651 17 0000 329882 ANNETTE VALENZUELA 13971 QUINNAULT ROAD 92307 $ 1,220.75 1539 3112 651 18 0000 330307 FELIPE ANDRADE 13959 QUINNAULT RD 92307 $ 603.39 1540 3112 651 22 0000 331103 RANDALL PRICE 13909 QUINNAULT ROAD 92307 $ 223.70 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 1541 3112 652 12 0000 330188 AQUILEO GUTIERREZ 21994 ARAPAHOE AV 92307 $ 516.77 1542 3112 653 05 0000 331033 LAKRITZ FAMILY PARTNERSHIP LAKRITZ FAMILY PARTN 21958 STATE HWY 18 92307 $ 412.45 1543 3112 661 15 0000 330513 AMERICAN HOME MORTGAGE AMERICAN HOME 22163 THUNDERBIRD RD 92307 $ 361.42 1544 3112 661 17 0000 330418 HENRIETTA M MORENO 22133 THUNDERBIRD RD 92307 $ 241.73 1545 3112 662 03 0000 331568 PETER B MOTSHAGAN 22150 FLATHEAD ROAD 92307 $ 826.57 1546 3112 662 20 0000 331760 MONIQUE/ FABIAN CARRENO/OCHOA 22117 BROKEN LANCE ROAD 92307 $ 313.29 1547 3112 665 08 0000 330467 RAYMAN & BERTHA MARTINEZ/BECERRA 15151 TONIKAN CT 92307 $ 275.20 1548 3112 665 20 0000 330472 NATHAN ELLIOTT 22385 BROKEN LANCE RD 92307 $ 318.66 1549 3112 666 17 0000 330060 TERRY STONEMAN 22418 GOLD BAR CT 92307 $ 265.23 1550 3112 666 20 0000 330481 MARI L KILGORE 22421 BROKEN LANCE CT 92307 $ 364.72 1551 3112 666 27 0000 331159 MICHAEL JOHNSON 22438 BROKEN LANCE CT 92307 $ 518.16 1552 3112 671 18 0000 330459 RANDY/DONNA ROY 22225 CHOLENA RD 92307 $ 398.33 1553 3112 671 20 0000 330687 MARIE S DOWNEN 22193 CHOLENA RD 92307 $ 245.41 1554 3112 672 15 0000 330448 TERESA/ANTONIO A CAUBET 22197 GAYHEAD RD 92307 $ 249.81 1555 3112 673 01 0000 330470 CYNTHIA G GREENLEE 14925 NANTICOKE RD 92307 $ 249.81 1556 3112 673 01 0000 331127 CYNTHIA GREENLEE 14925 NANTICOKE ROAD 92307 $ 588.41 1557 3112 673 07 0000 330292 ADRIENNE/JASON CURD 22214 STANDING ROCK AV 92307 $ 374.81 1558 3112 673 09 0000 330515 LISA MARIE HARRIS 22244 STANDING ROCK AV 92307 $ 249.27 1559 3112 674 05 0000 330159 JASON MAESTAS 14945 TONIKAN ROAD 92307 $ 228.97 1560 3112 675 07 0000 330421 TAMMY THIBODEAUX, 15017 QUIVERO LN 92307 $ 517.05 1561 3112 675 21 0000 329992 GILBERTO MUNOZ 14992 TEMECULA ROAD 92307 $ 322.02 1562 3112 676 09 0000 331590 ROBERT J III FUCHS 22460 STANDING ROCK AVE 92307 $ 809.00 1563 3112 681 04 0000 330147 JEFFREY RUSSELL JONES 14836 NANTICOKE ROAD 92307 $ 719.00 1564 3112 681 07 0000 330520 ERIC E CEJA 14788 NANTICOKE RD 92307 $ 222.86 1565 3112 682 01 0000 330544 ELVIN N VIERNES 22258 TAJANTA RD 92307 $ 249.81 1566 3112 682 16 0000 331289 GLORIA MAJORS 14880 TONIKAN ROAD 92307 $ 262.41 1567 3112 682 16 0000 331544 GLORIA MAJORS 14880 TONIKAN ROAD 92307 $ 596.34 1568 3112 683 02 0000 330319 ISABEL SOTO 22272 MOHICAN AV 92307 $ 249.81 1569 3112 684 05 0000 331708 RENZO J BUSTAMANTE 14849 TONIKAN LANE 92307 $ 439.19 1570 3112 684 18 0000 330403 MICHELLE MCGILL 14790 QUIVERO RD 92307 $ 584.60 1571 3112 686 16 0000 331787 ROBERT WEB 14757 TEMECULA ROAD 92307 $ 253.64 1572 3112 686 23 0000 331122 SHARON & CHARLES CONES 14859 TEMECULA CT 92307 $ 588.41 1573 3112 691 02 0000 330048 SHAWN/MARCELLA GUARDADO 14638 NANTICOKE ROAD 92307 $ 597.69 1574 3112 691 02 0000 331364 SHAWN/MARCELLA GUARDADO 14638 NANTICOKE ROAD 92307 $ 602.26 1575 3112 691 10 0000 330218 STEVEN STEINWAND 22112 RAMONA AV 92307 $ 601.93 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 1576 3112 692 01 0000 331541 EDWARD & FRANCES LIV TR PINZON 14690 TONIKAN ROAD 92307 $ 255.68 1577 3112 692 01 0000 331542 DOUGLAS MANN 14690 TONIKAN ROAD 92307 $ 290.79 1578 3112 692 06 0000 330424 GREG MILLER 22202 KLICKITAT AV 92307 $ 601.93 1579 3112 692 15 0000 330328 DONNIE CHAPMAN 22149 MOHICAN AV 92307 $ 601.93 1580 3112 692 21 0000 331272 JAVIER RAMIREZ 22241 MOHICAN AVE 92307 $ 110.71 1581 3112 693 13 0000 330546 OMAR MARTINEZ 22184 HUPA RD 92307 $ 528.71 1582 3112 693 26 0000 330313 ABBAS SHARGHI 14591 NANTICOKE RD 92307 $ 601.93 1583 3112 694 25 0000 329942 SHAREANA MESHA ANICESA QUIGLESS 14581 JELAN AVE 92307 $ 802.22 1584 3112 694 33 0000 331301 SHARON PALMER 14517 JELAN AVE 92307 $ 294.29 1585 3112 695 06 0000 330484 MAS REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS VII L 14637 TONIKAN RD 92307 $ 554.48 1586 3112 695 08 0000 330533 RUBEN MERCADO 14605 TONIKAN RD 92307 $ 601.93 1587 3112 697 12 0000 330503 CONSTANCE E LANGFORD 14544 CENTRAL RD 92307 $ 238.15 1588 3112 697 12 0000 330015 CONSTANCE E LANGFORD 14544 CENTRAL ROAD 92307 $ 505.56 1589 3112 697 14 0000 330548 EMAD HAMDAN 22482 RAMONA AV 92307 $ 362.00 1590 3112 701 08 0000 330525 RAMONA ENT TRUST DEHART, JOHN 22215 RAMONA AV 92307 $ 520.82 1591 3112 701 17 0000 331784 MICHAEL J NOVOA 22127 ISATIS AVE 92307 $ 220.05 1592 3112 702 03 0000 330561 RACHAEL A BOYD 22282 HURONS AV 92307 $ 601.93 1593 3112 703 02 0000 330035 FERNANDEZ, ROSIE FERNANDEZ ANTHONY 14347 PIONEER ROAD 92307 $ 163.34 1594 3112 704 05 0000 330567 MARY E COFFELT 22377 RAMONA AV 92307 $ 315.69 1595 3112 704 06 0000 330538 SHELLY A HEMPHILL 22393 RAMONA AV 92307 $ 208.67 1596 3112 704 20 0000 330532 MANUEL M KRAPES 22378 ISATIS AV 92307 $ 249.81 1597 3112 705 03 0000 330521 DAYONG YOU 22348 HURONS AV 92307 $ 250.12 1598 3112 705 07 0000 330185 MARGARITA DELGADO 22412 HURONS AV 92307 $ 595.13 1599 3112 705 20 0000 331621 DEAN TSAGRIS 22361 ISATIS AVE 92307 $ 213.89 1600 3112 706 02 0000 330408 CHUCK MCCREA 22459 HURONS AV 92307 $ 637.85 1601 3112 711 03 0000 330030 ROBERT YBARRA 22144 ESAWS AVE 92307 $ 260.52 1602 3112 711 39 0000 330456 LEROY JONES 22164 GOSHUTE AV 92307 $ 362.95 1603 3112 712 10 0000 331720 SHAWN D HENSON 14228 TONIKAN ROAD 92307 $ 578.49 1604 3112 712 11 0000 330211 RUSSELL BACARELLA 14258 TONIKAN RD 92307 $ 377.46 1605 3112 712 19 0000 330325 RONALD A FAMILY TRUST 8/15/91 CROWE 14237 TONIKAN RD 92307 $ 250.12 1606 3112 712 24 0000 330281 JAVIER E WU 14177 TU SU CIR 92307 $ 626.04 1607 3112 712 35 0000 330523 TOMMIE BUCKNER 22298 ESAWS AV 92307 $ 377.46 1608 3112 713 71 0000 330166 CATARINO ERNESTO LUQUIN 14193 FRESIAN AVE 92307 $ 972.94 1609 3112 741 13 0000 331290 CARRIE BRATTON 14105 JICARILLA ROAD 92307 $ 365.41 1610 3112 741 18 0000 330529 STEVEN O JAMES 14171 JICARILLA RD 92307 $ 227.07 Exhibit A

Town Of Apple Valley
Winter Lien
Schedule of 17's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 1611 3112 741 21 0000 330537 RICHARD TAFOYA 14149 JICARILLA RD 92307 $ 217.51 $ 739,049.52
Exhibit A

Town of Apple Valley
14955 Dale Evans Parkway
Apple Valley, CA 92307
Parcel: xxxx-xxx-xx-0000
Account: XX xxxxx
AMOUNT PAST DUE: $ XXX.XX
November 29, 2021 Service Address: xxxxxxx
Apple Valley, CA 9230x

OWNER DELINQUENCY NOTIFICATION LETTER
John Doe
17231 Highway 18
Apple Valley, CA 92394
Dear Customer:

The trash and (or) sewer bill for the above service address is currently delinquent and is subject to lien. The County Assessor has verified that you are listed as the current owner. If there is an error in the public records and you are not the current owner, it is imperative that our office be contacted immediately.

The Town of Apple Valley Code requires weekly trash removal. Ordinance #34 Section 6.20.090 stipulates that all fees for trash service will be billed and collected in accordance with Town rules and regulations. If delinquent amounts are not paid, a lien may be placed against the property where the unpaid debt was accrued in compliance with Section 6.20.100 of the municipal code.

Regarding residential and commercial properties, the property owner of record shall be responsible for paying the trash and (or) sewer service fees. Trash and sewer service rates are reviewed and approved by Town Council resolution in a public meeting.

A public hearing will be held for action to file a real property lien and authorization to add that lien to the extended property tax rolls. The lien amount will include past due charges plus an administrative fee of $100.00.

Questions regarding your account should be directed to the Customer Service staff of AVCO Disposal, Inc. Monday through Friday from 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. at (760) 245-8607.

Please note that all payments should be made directly to the Town of Apple Valley at 14955 Dale Evans Parkway.

Thank you for your prompt attention to this matter.

TOWN OF APPLE VALLEY
Attachment 2
Owner
Mailing
Address

PLEASE COMPLETE THIS INFORMATION
RECORDING REQUESTED BY:

Town of Apple Valley, Finance Department
AND WHEN RECORDED MAIL TO:

Town of Apple Valley
14955 Dale Evans Parkway
Apple Valley, CA 92307
Document recording fee is exempt per GC27383

NOTICE OF UTILITY LIENS
Title of Document
I, the undersigned, on behalf of the Town of Apple Valley, pursuant to the terms and provisions of the Apple Valley Municipal Code, Section 3.10.010, DO HEREBY CERTIFY that the following is a list of delinquent charges for rubbish collection (utility fees) together with the owner and description of the real property upon which such unpaid charges are a lien in favor of the Town and against said property.

The Town Council of the Town of Apple Valley did, on the 8 th day of February 2022, by Resolution No.
2022- , claim a lien upon said real properties.

The real properties herein before mentioned and upon which a lien is claimed are those certain parcels of land in the town of Apple Valley, County of San Bernardino, State of California, as described in attached “Exhibit A”.

I hereby certify the foregoing to be true and correct.

Sydnie Harris, M.S.A.

Director of Finance
By: _________________________________
Town of Apple Valley
(Rev. 1/2022)

August Bill for August August Bill for August
and September Payment is due upon receipt.

Payment is due upon receipt.

If not paid
If not paid
Sept. Bill for August and
October Bill for August, Sept. with message:

Sept., Oct., Nov. Your account is past due.
with message: Avoid lien action - Please
Your account is past due. pay immediately.

Avoid lien action - Please
pay immediately. If not paid
If not paid Oct. Bill for Aug., Sept., Oct. with
message: Payment must be
December Bill for August, Sept., Oct., made immediately! Continued Nov., Dec. and Jan. with delinquency will result in your message: Continued account being submitted to the
delinquency may result in your Town of Apple Valley Council account being recommended for Lien Action.
for lien action to the Town
Council of the Town of Apple If not paid
Valley.

Nov. Bill for Aug.,Sept., Oct., Nov.

If not paid with message: Continued
delinquency may result in
Nov. 29 Mail Delinquent Owner your account being
Notification Letter recommended for lien action
to the Town Council of the
Dec. 23 Pre-Lien Letter sent to Town of Apple Valley.
property owner
If not paid
If not paid
Nov. 29 Mail Delinquent Owner
Feb. 22 Lien property & mail Lien Notification Letter
Notification Letter to property
owner. Dec. 23 Pre-Lien Letter sent to
property owner
If not paid
Feb. 22 Lien property & mail Lien
Notification Letter to property
owner.

ATTACHMENT 1
H:Sanitation Delinquency Sequence
Sample Sequence of Notification for Sanitation Delinquencies Residential Commercial

NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING

TOWN OF APPLE VALLEY
Tuesday, February 8th, 2022
Beginning at 6:30 PM
Town of Apple Valley
14955 Dale Evans Parkway
Apple Valley, CA 92307
A Public Hearing has been scheduled before the Town Council of the Town of Apple Valley to consider the following:

Proposal: A RESOLUTION OF THE TOWN OF APPLE VALLEY

ESTABLISHING DELINQUENT UTILITY FEES AS DEBTS TO THE

TOWN AND DIRECTING THAT THEY BE RECORDED AS LIENS

AGAINST THE REAL PROPERTY
Location: Town-wide
This is a Resolution to record delinquent rubbish and sewer collection accounts as a lien against the property.

Any person affected by the proposal may appear and be heard in support or opposition to the proposal at the time of the Public Hearing.

The Town, in their deliberation, could approve the proposal, deny the proposal, or approve the proposal in an alternative form.

If you challenge the proposal in court, you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the Public Hearing described in this notice or in written correspondence delivered prior to the Public Hearing to the Town Clerk, 14955 Dale Evans Parkway, Apple Valley, California, 92307
Publish Dates: January 28th, 2022 and February 4th, 2022

Town Council Agenda Report
Date: February 8, 2022
To: Honorable Mayor and Town Council
Subject: Urgency Ordinance Adding a New Section 9.71.170 to the Town of Apple Valley Municipal Code Relating to Urban Lot Splits, Adding a New Section 9.29.220 to the Town Of Apple Valley Municipal Code Relating to Two-Unit Projects, and Determining the Ordinance is exempt from CEQA
From: Douglas Robertson, Town Manager
Submitted by: Daniel Alcayaga, AICP, Planning Manager
Planning
Budgeted Item: Yes No N/A
RECOMMENDED ACTION:

Adopt an Urgency Ordinance Adding a New Section 9.71.170 to the Town of Apple Valley Municipal Code Relating to Urban Lot Splits, Adding a New Section 9.29.220 to the Town Of Apple Valley Municipal Code Relating to Two-Unit Projects, and Determining the Ordinance to be Exempt from CEQA.

BACKGROUND:

The California legislature recently passed, and Governor Newsom signed into law, Senate Bill 9 (“SB 9”). SB 9 went into effect on January 1, 2022 and requires the Town to both: (1) allow any lot in a single-family residential zone to be split, roughly into halves, with resulting lots as small as 1,200 sf and (2) allow any lot in a single-family residential zone to be developed with up to two single-family primary dwellings. SB 9 requires the Town to approve eligible lot splits and two-unit projects ministerially (i.e., without discretionary review, conditions, or a hearing). Property owners can also utilize both of SB 9’s provisions, meaning that an SB 9 lot split may be followed with an SB 9 two-unit project on each of the two new lots, resulting in four total dwellings on what was formerly one single-family residential lot — all with only ministerial approval.