Town of Apple Valley Summer Lien 2023
Schedule of 20's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 1141 3112 283 08 0000 337497 THOMAS D III CHERRY 20594 TONAWANDA ROAD 92307 $ 222.36 1142 3112 291 13 0000 338194 EDWARDS B RAGAINS 20735 TONAWANDA ROAD 92307 $ 518.98 1143 3112 291 16 0000 338186 ELMA L MONTENEGRO 13947 HOPI ROAD 92307 $ 372.46 1144 3112 291 36 0000 338213 RAYMOND J III SCHMIDT 20635 TONAWANDA ROAD 92307 $ 346.03 1145 3112 291 38 0000 338439 JUAN SEGURA 20595 TONAWANDA ROAD 92307 $ 338.30 1146 3112 301 15 0000 338293 JEANETTE RODRIGUEZ 13775 SEMINOLE ROAD 92307 $ 442.62 1147 3112 301 22 0000 338717 JUAN MANUEL JR SANCHEZ 13780 HOPI ROAD 92307 $ 437.98 1148 3112 302 07 0000 337634 LENA GRIGGS 13751 HOPI ROAD 92307 $ 595.58 1149 3112 303 08 0000 338267 ROBERT D JR POWER 20825 TONAWANDA ROAD 92307 $ 556.38 1150 3112 303 14 0000 338208 LAUREN MULLINS 13775 IROQUOIS ROAD 92307 $ 442.62 1151 3112 311 09 0000 337969 JACK CARL BLUM 20971 THUNDERBIRD ROAD 92307 $ 391.69 1152 3112 313 06 0000 337977 ROBERT L CROSBY 15220 COMANCHE ROAD 92307 $ 235.67 1153 3112 313 21 0000 337618 OMAR/MYRA MARTINEZ-ORTEGA 15219 BLACKFOOT ROAD 92307 $ 438.55 1154 3112 321 22 0000 338427 LUIS & NOEMI BUSTAMONTE & NEYRA 15045 BLACKFOOT ROAD 92307 $ 269.90 1155 3112 331 02 0000 338514 VICTORIA CALVERT 20800 STATE HWY 18 92307 $ 254.63 1156 3112 331 03 0000 337807 ADOLFO JR GOMEZ 20786 STATE HWY 18 92307 $ - 1157 3112 332 02 0000 338272 ENRIQUE SANCHEZ 20840 PINE RIDGE AV 92307 $ 442.63 1158 3112 333 06 0000 338666 STEVEN JAMES REED 14776 DAKOTA ROAD 92307 $ 203.73 1159 3112 341 33 0000 337675 DONALD & MARLENE HANSING 20997 PINE RIDGE AVE 92307 $ 214.03 1160 3112 341 33 0000 338157 MARLENE HANSING 20997 PINE RIDGE AVE 92307 $ 442.72 1161 3112 341 36 0000 338176 GERALD ROHBACHER 21041 PINE RIDGE AVE 92307 $ 442.62 1162 3112 341 43 0000 338411 AGUSTIN MEZA 20850 STATE HWY 18 92307 $ 292.20 1163 3112 341 52 0000 337505 CLAUDINE E/MAURICE L GOMES/HAWKINS 20791 STATE HWY 18 92307 $ 498.52 1164 3112 351 02 0000 338482 ARSEN ASRYAN 21073 PINE RIDGE AVE 92307 $ 467.77 1165 3112 351 24 0000 338446 DAVID & TANYA FERGUSON 21065 STATE HWY 18 92307 $ 559.95 1166 3112 351 28 0000 338254 MIGUEL CADENA 14451 FLATHEAD ROAD 92307 $ 556.38 1167 3112 361 29 0000 337764 PATRICK MC MURPHY 20990 RANCHERIAS ROAD 92307 $ 215.88 1168 3112 372 02 0000 338485 HOLLY LIMA URIE/DARAID DAHN 14139 HOPI ROAD 92307 $ 600.18 1169 3112 373 06 0000 338748 JOSE MARTINEZ 14085 IROQUOIS ROAD 92307 $ 357.29 1170 3112 373 06 0000 338749 JOSE/NORMA MARTINEZ 14085 IROQUOIS ROAD 92307 $ 553.76 1171 3112 381 04 0000 337794 DAVID OCNOFF 20812 TONAWANDA ROAD 92307 $ 210.94 1172 3112 381 16 0000 338684 DARREN/CYNTHIA THOMPSON 14010 JICARILLA ROAD 92307 $ 347.14 1173 3112 381 17 0000 337684 PETER S LIPSCOMB 14018 JICARILLA ROAD 92307 $ 232.22 1174 3112 381 24 0000 337647 BRANDI SPEER 13969 IROQUOIS ROAD 92307 $ 250.78 1175 3112 382 01 0000 338412 PATRICK KAREEM SMITH 13891 JICARILLA ROAD 92307 $ 223.06 1176 3112 382 03 0000 338473 MANUEL LOMELIN 13905 JICARILLA ROAD 92307 $ 581.62 1177 3112 382 06 0000 338687 JERMIAH(JAKE) FALKNOR 13951 JICARILLA ROAD 92307 $ 223.66 1178 3112 391 09 0000 337981 JULIA HILLSMAN 20918 YUCCA LOMA ROAD 92307 $ 251.93
Town of Apple Valley Summer Lien 2023
Schedule of 20's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 1179 3112 391 17 0000 338499 CHERYL MARIE GOMEZ 13847 JICARILLA ROAD 92307 $ 445.79 1180 3112 392 01 0000 337968 JAMES T & JOHN T CHANNELL 13820 LAKOTA ROAD 92307 $ 304.59 1181 3112 392 07 0000 337690 LAURA G EL-ALI 13720 LAKOTA ROAD 92307 $ 228.52 1182 3112 392 09 0000 338163 BRAYAN MARTINES 21068 YUCCA LOMA ROAD 92307 $ 404.95 1183 3112 392 18 0000 338780 JOSEPH LOPEZ 13831 KIOWA ROAD 92308 $ 236.39 1184 3112 401 02 0000 338202 ELVIRA VIERNES 21291 THUNDERBIRD ROAD 92307 $ 435.92 1185 3112 401 18 0000 337502 BRIAN CHAVEZ 15170 DAKOTA ROAD 92307 $ 442.52 1186 3112 402 07 0000 337636 NINA MOORE 15200 ERIE ROAD 92307 $ 552.04 1187 3112 402 12 0000 338746 DANNY & NANCY LAREZ & LOZOYA 15165 DAKOTA ROAD 92307 $ 435.33 1188 3112 411 04 0000 337491 ALBERT III VELA 15111 CHEYENNE ROAD 92307 $ 378.16 1189 3112 411 05 0000 338791 CODY & ANGELICA HARTLEB 15095 CHEYENNE ROAD 92308 $ 450.91 1190 3112 411 07 0000 338325 JAMES FREDRICK IV BAILEY 15038 DAKOTA ROAD 92307 $ 209.37 1191 3112 412 04 0000 337692 JARROD MARTIN 15055 DAKOTA RD 92307 $ 299.87 1192 3112 412 11 0000 337801 SCOTT JOHN DEVOOGHT 15090 RAMONA AVE 92307 $ 278.88 1193 3112 422 04 0000 337628 OMAR & BERENICE RUIZ 14870 FLATHEAD ROAD 92307 $ 345.46 1194 3112 422 06 0000 338729 SEEUN PARK 21280 RAMONA AVE 92307 $ 914.62 1195 3112 431 03 0000 338814 MARK/JACQUELYN TOARMINA 14760 ERIE ROAD 92307 $ 352.27 1196 3112 431 05 0000 338806 NAAC 2022-33 LP 14732 ERIE ROAD 92307 $ 862.15 1197 3112 432 13 0000 338511 KURT/VANESSA FIGURA 14777 ERIE ROAD 92307 $ 442.55 1198 3112 433 12 0000 337594 JESUS BARRAGAN 21325 RAMONA AVE 92307 $ 223.00 1199 3112 433 15 0000 337798 GERARDO/DORA GONZALEZ 21350 RAMONA AVE 92307 $ 269.90 1200 3112 441 19 0000 337789 SHARI KIDWELL 14655 FLATHEAD ROAD 92307 $ 210.92 1201 3112 442 01 0000 338817 JOSEPH OJEDA 21435 RAMONA AVE 92307 $ 475.41 1202 3112 442 08 0000 337596 MICHAEL CASAREZ 14520 HOPI ROAD 92307 $ 453.73 1203 3112 442 13 0000 338373 SAMANTHA/EVAN TOLSON 14450 HOPI ROAD 92307 $ 556.38 1204 3112 442 15 0000 337645 MARTIN J BISHOP 21182 PINE RIDGE AVE 92307 $ 292.00 1205 3112 443 15 0000 338200 RAMIRO VASQUEZ 14523 HOPI ROAD 92307 $ 250.82 1206 3112 451 04 0000 338455 BRIAN L COLLOM 14350 IROQUOIS ROAD 92307 $ 556.38 1207 3112 452 21 0000 338629 CLAUDIA MEJIA 14375 IROQUOIS ROAD 92307 $ 269.77 1208 3112 452 22 0000 338278 JEFFREY FELT 14363 IROQUOIS ROAD 92307 $ 421.34 1209 3112 453 05 0000 337788 GERALD FORTON 21265 PINE RIDGE AVE 92307 $ 222.41 1210 3112 453 14 0000 337506 VANESSA MENDOSA 21159 PINE RIDGE AVE 92307 $ 435.72 1211 3112 461 11 0000 337777 ADRINE HOUFF 21110 RANCHERIAS ROAD 92307 $ 223.00 1212 3112 461 11 0000 338190 ADRINE HOUFF 21110 RANCHERIAS ROAD 92307 $ 556.38 1213 3112 462 03 0000 337758 RENE ESPINOZA 21311 STATE HWY 18 92307 $ 336.82 1214 3112 463 07 0000 337528 CAMSTEIN CHRISBERG LLC CAMSTEIN CHRISBERG L 21398 PINE RIDGE AVE 92307 $ 733.72 1215 3112 464 16 0000 338258 ROBERTO ANAYA 14167 KIOWA ROAD 92307 $ 437.53 1216 3112 472 17 0000 338464 KAMILLE COULTER 21234 RANCHERIAS ROAD 92307 $ 442.63
Town of Apple Valley Summer Lien 2023
Schedule of 20's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 1217 3112 473 03 0000 338750 LINDA HODGE 21460 OUTER HWY 18 S 92307 $ 547.74 1218 3112 473 06 0000 338512 VELMA WRIGHT 21420 STATE HWY 18 92307 $ 437.70 1219 3112 473 10 0000 338693 GUSTAVO ANGEL CRUZ 21485 PINE RIDGE AVE 92307 $ 280.86 1220 3112 483 08 0000 338530 ELIZABETH MOREALES-PEREIDA 21494 STATE HWY 18 92307 $ 337.09 1221 3112 491 05 0000 338374 KIMBERLY SNOW 15201 RAMONA AVE 92307 $ 442.62 1222 3112 491 19 0000 337774 SUSAN A MADISON-DEHOYOS 15130 FLATHEAD ROAD 92307 $ 340.35 1223 3112 491 19 0000 338174 SUSAN MADISON-DEHOYOS 15130 FLATHEAD ROAD 92307 $ 661.68 1224 3112 491 20 0000 337783 JAMES E MARTIN 15110 FLATHEAD ROAD 92307 $ 217.81 1225 3112 492 04 0000 338619 JONATHAN HENRY 15237 NAVAJO ROAD 92307 $ 362.53 1226 3112 492 08 0000 337792 BRANDY A MERRICK 21722 FLATHEAD ROAD 92307 $ 211.57 1227 3112 492 24 0000 337853 PATRICIA/MIGUEL BARBOSA, 15267 OSAGE ROAD 92307 $ 263.60 1228 3112 511 01 0000 338145 MARTIN BAUM 14730 NAVAJO ROAD 92307 $ 208.28 1229 3112 511 20 0000 338290 CARMEN MENDEZ 14760 HOPI ROAD 92307 $ 211.23 1230 3112 511 31 0000 338188 TEODOLINDA HENRIQUEZ 14791 GAYHEAD ROAD 92307 $ 442.62 1231 3112 511 42 0000 338626 JEREMY JOHNSON 14800 GAYHEAD ROAD 92307 $ 556.35 1232 3112 521 04 0000 338170 SUZANNE M GATCHELL 21482 RAMONA AVE 92307 $ 337.25 1233 3112 521 41 0000 337958 TERRY & KRISTINE NOTHSTINE 14687 NAVAJO ROAD 92307 $ 218.83 1234 3112 531 01 0000 338229 JAMES R LINDORFER 21731 RAMONA AVE 92307 $ 510.30 1235 3112 531 24 0000 338225 HECTOR QUIROZ 14394 JICARILLA ROAD 92307 $ 442.62 1236 3112 541 02 0000 337790 ALAN PETERSON 14371 JICARILLA ROAD 92307 $ 220.90 1237 3112 542 11 0000 337678 ABDOL SHARGHI 14191 KIOWA ROAD 92307 $ 232.84 1238 3112 542 22 0000 338281 WILBUR J RUYBALID 14212 LAKOTA ROAD 92307 $ 247.01 1239 3112 551 22 0000 337808 JESUS PARRA 14036 MOHAWK ROAD 92307 $ 209.37 1240 3112 551 25 0000 338462 RUSSEL J TOSSETTI 21568 PINE RIDGE AVE 92307 $ 600.18 1241 3112 551 26 0000 338707 NOREIDA/ ANGELA LIZARRAGA 14005 MOHAWK ROAD 92307 $ 281.97 1242 3112 551 43 0000 337820 ALFREDO RIOS 13985 NAVAJO ROAD 92307 $ 424.67 1243 3112 551 43 0000 338247 ALFREDO RIOS 13985 NAVAJO ROAD 92307 $ 783.39 1244 3112 561 05 0000 338792 SHON D/JULLIANNE ROBINSON 21621 PINE RIDGE AVE 92307 $ 330.97 1245 3112 561 06 0000 338280 DALE JR/ALICE BROWN 21635 PINE RIDGE AVE 92307 $ 783.39 1246 3112 562 04 0000 338793 ZABEL/IZABELL MANUKYAN 21849 CHEROKEE AVE 92307 $ 823.99 1247 3112 563 27 0000 338158 MYRA LEWIS 21875 ARAPAHOE AVE 92307 $ 1,812.35 1248 3112 563 30 0000 338826 LLC GANDHI INVESTMENTT 21831 ARAPAHOE AVE 92307 $ 574.38 1249 3112 563 37 0000 337597 LILY A. GARCIA 13848 OSAGE ROAD 92307 $ 332.57 1250 3112 563 45 0000 338369 HELEN DE FORREST 13954 OSAGE ROAD 92307 $ 247.70 1251 3112 581 21 0000 337825 PAUL MC CLAIN 15078 QUINNAULT ROAD 92307 $ 361.27 1252 3112 581 35 0000 338794 CASEY TEVAULT 15077 QUINNAULT ROAD 92307 $ 424.38 1253 3112 591 17 0000 338579 LARRY/NATALIE WHITE/ERICKSON 21755 STANDING ROCK AVE 92307 $ 486.04 1254 3112 591 21 0000 338333 JOHN NOFFSINGER 14795 NAVAJO ROAD 92307 $ 211.72
Town of Apple Valley Summer Lien 2023
Schedule of 20's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 1255 3112 592 03 0000 338323 AUSTIN WALTERS 21934 MOHICAN AVE 92307 $ 238.61 1256 3112 592 16 0000 338516 MEGAN GOSS 21993 STANDING ROCK AVE 92307 $ 456.34 1257 3112 592 18 0000 337803 OMAR RODRIGUEZ 21967 STANDING ROCK AVE 92307 $ 390.31 1258 3112 592 20 0000 338618 CLAUDIA ERICA CHAVEZ 21935 STANDING ROCK AVE 92307 $ 300.26 1259 3112 593 18 0000 337642 THOMAS SURPRENANT 21932 STANDING ROCK AVE 92307 $ 644.38 1260 3112 593 23 0000 337669 JOHNNY TAYLOR 21866 STANDING ROCK AVE 92307 $ 309.96 1261 3112 593 27 0000 337810 BOSSIER TRUST 21812 STANDING ROCK AVE 92307 $ 236.86 1262 3112 601 10 0000 337572 MATTHEW TORRES 14616 OSAGE ROAD 92307 $ 288.33 1263 3112 601 12 0000 338315 DOREEN AMELIA GONZALES 14588 OSAGE ROAD 92307 $ 325.41 1264 3112 604 14 0000 338452 KEITH/ELIZABETH TAYLOR 22008 KLICKITAT AVE 92307 $ 292.45 1265 3112 604 17 0000 337813 WEN ZHAO LI 21962 KLICKITAT AVE 92307 $ 214.57 1266 3112 611 09 0000 338483 JOHN DAVID JR CUMMINGS 21843 JELAN AVE 92307 $ 309.32 1267 3112 612 07 0000 337800 SHAWNEE RENEE TERRY-DAVIS 21827 RAMONA AVE 92307 $ 438.13 1268 3112 612 14 0000 338775 ISATIS TRUST ISATIS TRUST 21868 ISATIS AVE 92307 $ 1,136.30 1269 3112 621 02 0000 338692 JSAMJ INC 14246 OSAGE ROAD 92307 $ 431.68 1270 3112 621 13 0000 338675 JUAN RODRIGUEZ 14388 OSAGE ROAD 92307 $ 237.76 1271 3112 622 05 0000 338638 MARGARITA CABRERA 21883 ISATIS AVE 92307 $ 307.70 1272 3112 622 09 0000 338503 ELIAS S AMADOR 14360 PAWNEE ROAD 92307 $ 225.28 1273 3112 623 16 0000 337956 LAURANCE A TAYLOR 21872 GOSHUTE AVE 92307 $ 304.59 1274 3112 625 01 0000 337826 ROBERTO A BUSTOS 21937 ISATIS AVE 92307 $ 324.86 1275 3112 625 05 0000 337967 RONALD L & JAMI L HESTER 21999 ISATIS AVE 92307 $ 427.34 1276 3112 626 02 0000 338185 HOWARD A HAMMOND 22078 GOSHUTE AVE 92307 $ 277.38 1277 3112 626 16 0000 337602 REBECCA DAVIS 14345 QUINNAULT ROAD 92307 $ 423.36 1278 3112 626 16 0000 338610 REBECCA DAVIS 14345 QUINNAULT ROAD 92307 $ 783.39 1279 3112 631 05 0000 338597 GLENDA GONZALEZ 14124 OSAGE ROAD 92307 $ 783.39 1280 3112 632 03 0000 337622 ZACHARY P SPARKS 21928 FOX AVE 92307 $ 778.32 1281 3112 633 09 0000 338533 DINH TAN PHAM 21919 FOX AVE 92307 $ 332.57 1282 3112 635 18 0000 338192 RODNEY & CHRISTIE L. AIDE & DUKE 14150 QUINNAULT ROAD 92307 $ 639.00 1283 3112 636 07 0000 338460 ANA LUCANO 14149 QUINNAULT ROAD 92307 $ 625.05 1284 3112 636 10 0000 337793 ABDOL ALI SHARGHI 14191 QUINNAULT ROAD 92307 $ 325.01 1285 3112 636 12 0000 337623 FREDERICK & KRISTIN WILCUTT 14215 QUINNAULT ROAD 92307 $ 373.37 1286 3112 643 06 0000 338582 JOYCE KEMPTON 21881 DOTAME AVE 92307 $ 435.72 1287 3112 643 07 0000 337656 MARTHA A FIGUEROA 21897 DOTAME AVE 92307 $ 472.92 1288 3112 643 14 0000 338590 STEPHANIE NOTTLE 21950 CHEROKEE AVE 92307 $ 556.40 1289 3112 644 01 0000 337591 KIMBERLY BROUGHTON 13974 QUINNAULT ROAD 92307 $ 230.87 1290 3112 644 11 0000 338523 GINA ALVARADO 14085 PAWNEE ROAD 92307 $ 437.70 1291 3112 644 17 0000 338319 KENNETH & KARLEY PARSONS & HURTADO 14006 QUINNAULT ROAD 92307 $ 288.61 1292 3112 645 02 0000 338532 TONY MUNOZ 22080 CHEROKEE AVE 92307 $ 648.09
Town of Apple Valley Summer Lien 2023
Schedule of 20's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 1293 3112 645 07 0000 338639 ANTONIA VALTIERRA 14041 QUINNAULT ROAD 92307 $ 307.60 1294 3112 645 09 0000 337520 TRACY LYN SHERWOOD 14081 QUINNAULT ROAD 92307 $ 783.40 1295 3112 651 03 0000 338318 CASIE J BROOKS 22015 CHEROKEE AVE 92307 $ 754.02 1296 3112 651 12 0000 337735 GINA GRIEGO 21960 BILOXI ROAD 92307 $ 484.89 1297 3112 651 17 0000 338708 CARLOS FUENTES 13971 QUINNAULT ROAD 92307 $ 390.01 1298 3112 651 19 0000 338430 MAX E KHOV 13847 QUINNAULT ROAD 92307 $ 256.68 1299 3112 651 20 0000 337805 YUN CHEN 13933 QUINNAULT ROAD 92307 $ 295.39 1300 3112 651 22 0000 338187 RANDALL PRICE 13909 QUINNAULT ROAD 92307 $ 206.78 1301 3112 651 25 0000 338151 EBMEYER FAMILY TRUST EBMEYER 13768 PIONEER ROAD 92307 $ 1,581.52 1302 3112 652 03 0000 338641 ALI CONTRERAS 21995 BILOXI ROAD 92307 $ 921.75 1303 3112 652 05 0000 337687 JEFF AUSTIN 22019 BILOXI ROAD 92307 $ 289.67 1304 3112 652 12 0000 338607 AURORA GUTIERREZ 21994 ARAPAHOE AVE 92307 $ 754.23 1305 3112 662 03 0000 338484 PETER B MOTSHAGAN 22150 FLATHEAD ROAD 92307 $ 783.40 1306 3112 662 20 0000 338580 MONIQUE/ FABIAN CARRENO/OCHOA 22117 BROKEN LANCE ROAD 92307 $ 223.13 1307 3112 663 18 0000 338230 TONY JR GUTIERREZ 22223 FLATHEAD ROAD 92307 $ 556.21 1308 3112 665 12 0000 337824 VANESSA BURGOS 22354 CHOLENA ROAD 92307 $ 218.53 1309 3112 671 16 0000 337786 DENNIS CARRANZA 22251 CHOLENA ROAD 92307 $ 218.05 1310 3112 671 18 0000 337791 RANDY/DONNA ROY 22225 CHOLENA ROAD 92307 $ 410.72 1311 3112 671 26 0000 337971 EPITACIO LOPEZ 22242 GAYHEAD ROAD 92307 $ 142.40 1312 3112 675 07 0000 337778 TAMMY THIBODEAUX, 15017 QUIVERO LANE 92307 $ 223.30 1313 3112 675 22 0000 338506 VICTOR MURILLO 15006 TEMECULA ROAD 92307 $ 232.57 1314 3112 676 09 0000 338491 ROBERT J III FUCHS 22460 STANDING ROCK AVE 92307 $ 556.38 1315 3112 681 04 0000 337648 JEFFREY RUSSELL JONES 14836 NANTICOKE ROAD 92307 $ 477.11 1316 3112 681 07 0000 337815 ERIC E CEJA 14788 NANTICOKE ROAD 92307 $ 225.49 1317 3112 681 09 0000 337576 VIRGINIA JENSON 14758 NANTICOKE ROAD 92307 $ 508.90 1318 3112 682 09 0000 337699 PHILLIP BRODA 22143 STANDING ROCK AVE 92307 $ 210.83 1319 3112 682 13 0000 338762 NICHOLAS WALLS 22209 STANDING ROCK AVE 92307 $ 463.25 1320 3112 682 16 0000 338466 GLORIA MAJORS 14880 TONIKAN ROAD 92307 $ 442.63 1321 3112 683 11 0000 338180 WILLIAM WEEKS 14769 NANTICOKE ROAD 92307 $ 584.43 1322 3112 684 18 0000 337770 MICHELLE MCGILL 14790 QUIVERO RD 92307 $ 443.61 1323 3112 686 23 0000 338197 SHARON & CHARLES CONES 14859 TEMECULA CT 92307 $ 442.62 1324 3112 691 10 0000 337701 STEVEN STEINWAND 22112 RAMONA AVE 92307 $ 309.93 1325 3112 692 01 0000 338785 LAKEVIEW LOAN SERVICING LLC 14690 TONIKAN ROAD 92307 $ 609.82 1326 3112 692 13 0000 338706 GLENARD E SCHMIDT 14728 NANTICOKE ROAD 92307 $ 339.78 1327 3112 692 15 0000 337746 DONNIE CHAPMAN 22149 MOHICAN AVE 92307 $ 309.93 1328 3112 693 07 0000 338584 CHRISTOPHER & PATRICIA BAILEY 14590 JELAN AVE 92307 $ 534.01 1329 3112 694 02 0000 338603 FELIX LOPEZ 22158 RAMONA AVE 92307 $ 308.66 1330 3112 694 25 0000 337526 SHAREANA MESHA ANICESA QUIGLESS 14581 JELAN AVE 92307 $ 350.64
Town of Apple Valley Summer Lien 2023
Schedule of 20's
LIEN PARCEL_NO BILLNO FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME STREET_NO_ STREET STREET_SUFFIX STREET_ZIP ACCOUNT_BALANCE 1331 3112 695 08 0000 337817 RUBEN MERCADO 14605 TONIKAN ROAD 92307 $ 288.61 1332 3112 702 03 0000 337828 RACHAEL A BOYD 22282 HURONS AVE 92307 $ 288.61 1333 3112 704 02 0000 338786 MONET INVESTMENTS LLC 22331 RAMONA AVE 92307 $ 445.76 1334 3112 705 07 0000 337677 MARGARITA DELGADO 22412 HURONS AVE 92307 $ 372.43 1335 3112 705 20 0000 338510 DEAN TSAGRIS 22361 ISATIS AVE 92307 $ 210.22 1336 3112 706 02 0000 337771 CHUCK MCCREA 22459 HURONS AVE 92307 $ 325.10 1337 3112 711 03 0000 337580 ROBERT YBARRA 22144 ESAWS AVE 92307 $ 322.98 1338 3112 711 36 0000 337829 ZACHARIAH F LEVOTCH 22110 GOSHUTE AVE 92307 $ 350.64 1339 3112 712 10 0000 338558 SHAWN D HENSON 14228 TONIKAN ROAD 92307 $ 756.08 1340 3112 712 24 0000 337732 JAVIER E WU 14177 TU SU CIR 92307 $ 347.21 1341 3112 713 71 0000 337660 CATARINO ERNESTO LUQUIN 14193 FRESIAN AVE 92307 $ 639.65 $ 547,670.45
Town of Apple Valley
Animal Services
Summer Lien 2023
APN AC - First Name Last Name Address Line 1 City St ZIP Address Line 2 Amount Due 0444035020000 AC - 2309 Juan Salvador Gudino Jr. 19089 Siesta Dr. Apple Valley CA 92307 $ 298.00 3112-682-01-0000 AC - 2312 Elvin N Viernes 22258 Tajanta Rd. Apple Valley CA 92307 $ 216.00 3112-282-06-0000 AC - 2315 Anthony Million 20510 Tonawanda Rd. Apple Valley CA 92307 $ 121.00 3087-313-22-0000 AC - 2316 Daniel Chavez 13372 Rancherias Rd. Apple Valley CA 92308 $ 166.00 0399-281-28-0000 AC - 2319 Theodore A James 19221 Elm Dr. Apple Valley CA 92308 $ 196.00 0437-341-67-0000 AC - 2320 Martin Flores 15835 Central Rd. Apple Valley CA 92307 $ 180.00 0434-232-11-0000 AC - 2321 Jose Jr. / Maria A. Vega 10886 Kiavan Rd. Apple Valley CA 92307 $ 456.00 0439-051-23-0000 AC - 2322 Abraham Flores 13322 Pauhaska Rd. Apple Valley CA 92308 $ 201.00 3112-682-06-0000 AC - 2329 Juan Carlos Tostado 22180 Tajanta Rd. Apple Valley CA 92307 $ 251.50 0437-033-11-0000 AC - 2331 Carlos Edward/ Irma Alicia Alvardo 16577 Mesquite Rd. Apple Valley CA 92307 $ 176.00 0439-471-27-0000 AC - 2333 Juan Varela 13484 Franceska Rd. Apple Valley CA 92308 $ 186.00 0399-281-26-0000 AC - 2334 Robert V / Winfred Johnson 19222 Elm Dr. Apple Valley CA 92308 $ 171.50 3112-302-03-0000 AC - 2339 Cherry K / Darold G Buffington 13845 Hopi Rd. Apple Valley CA 92308 $ 211.40 0441-032-38-0000 AC - 2340 RK / Kirtiben Patel 4965 Hercules Ct. Livermore CA 94551 16512 Arcata Rd. $ 126.00 0479-106-13-0000 AC - 2343 Brian St. John PO Box 439 Sagle ID 83860 19117 Tecumseh Rd. $ 276.50 0434-366-17-0000 AC - 2344 Thomas L / Terri L Stewart 19976 Mohawk Rd. Apple Valley CA 92308 $ 166.00 0444-761-23-0000 AC - 2345 Joseph Michael Lovan C/O Joseph & 12850 Yorkshire Dr. Apple Valley CA 92308 $ 196.00 3112-642-05-0000 AC - 2350 Bylli Estuardo Reyes 21910 Dotame Ave. Apple Valley CA 92307 $ 176.00 0440-242-07-0000 AC - 2351 Oscar Gutierrez 16623 Tenaja Rd. Apple Valley CA 92308 $ 328.05 0473-227-16-0000 AC - 2352 Waw Mowafak 19134 Kaibab Ct. Apple Valley CA 92307 $ 176.00 $ 4,274.95
Exhibit A
Town of Apple Valley
Code Enforcement
Summer Lien 20 2023
APN # Amount Name Address City State Zip Case Number
0000-000-00-0000 $ - Owner name Property Address Apple Valley CA 92307 00-0000 0441-103-11-0000 323.15 Gonzales, Moises 15799 Sago Dell Apple Valley CA 92307 18-1160 3087-062-26-0000 1007.55 Wilson, Christian 13119 Modoc Ct Apple Valley CA 92308 18-1448 3112-612-12-0000 316.22 Moller, William 14450 Pawnee Rd Apple Valley CA 92307 18-1517 3087-081-16-0000 815.06 Liberman, Steven 20192 Itasca Rd Apple Valley CA 92308 18-1555 3087-361-13-0000 314.95 SMA Family Trust 22063 Ottawa Rd Apple Valley CA 92308 18-1880 0441-142-01-0000 1232.53 Badillo, Martha 20722 Thunderbird Rd Apple Valley CA 92307 19-2271 0479-127-11-0000 1143.15 Flickinger, Norman 19002 Seneca Rd Apple Valley CA 92307 19-2371 0473-065-02-0000 1120.79 Nichols, Patrick 15500 Pohez Rd Apple Valley CA 92307 19-5147 0437-153-15-0000 780.13 Martinkus, Ron 16992 Joshua Rd Apple Valley CA 92307 19-5170 0437-043-65-0000 962.16 Jones, Tanesha 21785 Allegheny Rd Apple Valley CA 92307 20-3426 0437-081-19-0000 1277.4 Hwang, Wilson 15285 Mesquite Rd Apple Valley CA 92307 20-5332 3112-673-08-0000 2097.61 Alexander, Steven 22230 Standing Rock Rd Apple Valley CA 92307 21-1356 0434-032-25-0000 828.19 Hernandez, Jose 11726 Deep Creek Rd Apple Valley CA 92307 21-2911 3087-341-08-0000 343.35 California Interstate Tel Co 13643 Navajo Apple Valley CA 92307 21-4690 3112-314-05-0000 389.73 Holland, Wayne 15190 Cheyenne Rd Apple Valley CA 92307 21-4772 3087-342-31-0000 583.66 Espeseth, Ethel 13519 John Glen Rd Apple Valley CA 92308 22-0486 3087-562-10-0000 444.48 Delgado, Anna 22331 Tehama Rd Apple Valley CA 92307 22-0509 3087-445-20-0000 565.88 Raya, Erik 12334 Lakota Rd Apple Valley CA 92307 22-0844 0479-065-08-0000 168.16 Tatevik, Babayan 18343 Cocopah Ct Apple Valley CA 92307 22-1008 3112-645-06-0000 321.22 SMA Family Trust 14031 Quinnault Rd Apple Valley CA 92307 22-1489 3112-223-13-0000 314.14 Schardt, Debra 20357 Shoshonee Rd Apple Valley CA 92307 22-3022 0441-323-07-0000 344.92 Pourgol, Sami 20251 Serrano Rd Apple Valley CA 92307 22-4448 Total 15694.43
Town Council Agenda Report
Date: July 25, 2023
To: Honorable Mayor and Town Council
Subject: LIGHTING AND LANDSCAPE ASSESSMENT DISTRICT #1- PUBLIC
HEARING, CONFIRMING ASSESSMENT AND LEVYING
ASSESSMENT FOR FY 2023-2024
From: Douglas Robertson, Town Manager
Submitted by: Mike Podegracz, Town Engineer
Economic and Community Development
Budgeted Item: Yes No N/A
RECOMMENDED ACTION
It is recommended that the Town Council:
A. Conduct the Public Hearing
B. Adopt Resolution No. 2023-27 - A Resolution of the Town Council of the Town of Apple Valley confirming diagram and assessment and levying assessment for fiscal year 2023-2024
BACKGROUND
On June 13, 2023, the Town Council approved Resolution No. 2023-18, directing the filing of the Annual Report for the Apple Valley Landscaping and Lighting District, approved the Engineer’s Report and approved Resolution No. 2023-19, to declare the Town’s intention to order improvements and to levy and collect assessments for Fiscal Year 2023-2024.
The resolution also gave notice of the time and place for the public hearing to discuss the proposed assessment.
ANALYSIS
The annual assessments for each annexed territory of the Assessment District are indicated in Part B of the Engineer’s Report. For next fiscal year, there are three recommended increases in annual assessments for L-10, L-13 and L-26. The Public Works Department recently put the Landscape Maintenance contract out to bid and the new contractor’s cost for L-10, L-13, and L-26 has increased. It is recommended that the levy for L-10, which was $309 per lot last year, be increase to $365.00 per lot per year; for L-13 from $224.18 per lot per year to $240 per lot per year, and for L-26 from $369.62 per lot per year to $400.00 per lot per year.
For locations L-15, L-17, L-19, and L-20, the current levy amounts exceed the existing and projected maintenance costs. Because there are sufficient reserve funds in each of these locations to accommodate large capitol replacement costs, if needed, it is recommended to lower the annual levy. The detailed reduced levy amounts are shown on Exhibit B of the attached Engineer’s Report. The recommended procedures to increase or decrease the annual levy comply with all requirements of Proposition 218.
SUMMARY:
As indicated within the attached engineer’s report, the proposed net amounts to be assessed for each location within the assessment district are as follows:
Current year’s Proposed
Location Tract No. No. of lots assessment (FY 23/24)
• L-1 Tract 13618 137 $40.88 $40.88
• L-2 Tract 13426 26 $94.75 $94.75
• L-3 Tract 14090 182 $141.54 $141.54
• L-4 Tract 13709 18 $139.00 $139.00
• L-5 Tract 15288 65 $89.23 $89.23
• L-7 Tract 8476 236 $20.00 $20.00
• L-8 Tract 14846 143 $198.06 $198.06
• L-9 Tract 9696 58 $78.00 $78.00
• L-10 Tract 16492 258 $309.00 $365.00
• L-11 Tract 16395 58 $292.04 $292.04
• L-12 Tract 16059 173 $159.46 $159.46
• L-13 Tract 14994 18 $224.18 $240.00
• L-15 Tract 16779 84 $124.00 $110.00
• L-17 Tract 15286 61 $84.00 $50.00
• L-19 Tract 16134 35 $96.00 $56.00
• L-20 Tract 17093 134 (55 developed) $200.00 $150.00
• L-23 PM 17684 31 $Varies $Varies
• L-26 Tract 17278 15 $369.62 $400.00
• L-28 PM 15151 1 $746.67 $746.67
FISCAL IMPACT:
The attached report summarizes the revenues and expenditures of the Assessment District, the estimate of cost and the proposed cost per lot per tract. The costs are borne by the property owners within each identified tract. There is no direct budgetary impact to the Town.
ATTACHMENTS
A. Engineer’s Report
B. Resolution 2023-27
ENGINEER'S REPORT
TOWN OF APPLE VALLEY
ASSESSMENT DISTRICT NO. 1
The undersigned respectfully submits the enclosed report as directed by Town Council.
Richard Pedersen, P.E.
Engineer of Work
By____________________________
I HEREBY CERTIFY that the enclosed Engineer's Report, together with Assessment and Assessment Diagram thereto attached, was filed with me on the _____ day of __________________, 2023.
LaVonda Pearson,
Town Clerk, Town of Apple Valley,
San Bernardino County,
State of California
By____________________________
I HEREBY CERTIFY that the enclosed Engineer's Report, together with Assessment and Assessment Diagram thereto attached, was approved, and confirmed by the Town Council of the Town of Apple Valley, California, on the _____ day of __________________, 2023.
LaVonda Pearson,
Town Clerk, Town of Apple Valley,
San Bernardino County,
State of California
By____________________________
PART A
PLANS AND SPECIFICATIONS
L-1
TRACT NUMBER: 13618
LOCATION: East side Central Road at Cuyama Road
DESCRIPTION: Plans and specifications for the improvements are those prepared by EDAW Inc., Landscape Architects, by William Schultz, dated July 2, 1991. These plans and specifications have been filed separately with the Clerk of the Town of Apple Valley and are incorporated in this report by reference. In summary, the improvements consist of landscaping generally of pine trees, small junipers, other decorative bushes, decorative rock, and a perimeter wall.
Perimeter parkway landscaping is bounded by the face of curb and the face of the perimeter wall (20.00) Feet along the along the easterly side of Central Road in Tract 13618. In addition, a small portion (12.00) paralleling Cuyama Road at the intersection of Central Road. The area is basically within the parkway area along Central Road 20’ in width and along a small portion of Cuyama Road 12’ in width.
L-2
TRACT NUMBER: 13426
LOCATION: West side Central Road
DESCRIPTION: Perimeter parkway landscaping bounded by the face of curb and the face of the perimeter wall (11.00) Feet along the along the westerly side of Central Road in Tract 13426 from Cholena Road to Thunderbird Road.
Area of improved landscaping consists of small trees planted at 40- feet on center with some small decorative bushes intermittency planted between the trees. The planted area is covered with 3-inches in depth with 3/4- inch granite gravel over an area of approximately 11-feet in width and 1,208 feet in length for an area coverage of 13,290 square feet.
L-3
TRACT NUMBER: 14090
LOCATION: North side of Sitting Bull Road from west of Lompoc Road to east of Tawya Road; Ottawa Road from west of Paraiso Road to west of Choco Road.
DESCRIPTION: General Plans and specifications for the improvements are those prepared by NDNA-Don Napolitano and Associates-Landscape Architects, dated September 11, 1991. Specific Plans and specifications for the proposed phasing of improvements are those prepared by Burch Meress Associates, dated September 20, 1993.
Both plans and specifications have been filed separately with the Clerk of the Town of Apple Valley and are incorporated by reference.
In summary, the improvements consist of approximately 40 acres of open space landscaping. The open space landscaping is to be maintained on an as needed basis under “extra work”.
A concrete V-channel connecting Paraiso Road to the drainage channel,
An equestrian trail located on the east side of the drainage channel from Ottawa Road south to the end of Mugu Ct,
Parkway landscaping bounded by the face of curb and the face of the perimeter wall along the along the northerly side of Sitting Bull Road within the tract boundaries from 200’ east of Lompoc Road to 200’ west of Choco Road, parkway landscaping along the south side and the north side of Ottawa Road from 200’ feet west of Paraiso Road to 200’ east of Choco Road, parkway landscaping is also located along the south side and the north side of Paraiso Road west of Capella Road adjacent to the drainage channel within the tract boundaries.
L-4
TRACT NUMBER: 13709
LOCATION: Along the north side of Geronimo Road at Bannock Ct. and Sarsi Ct. within the tract boundaries
DESCRIPTION: Plans and specifications for the improvements are those prepared by Shelly Harper, dated October 5, 1993. The landscaping consists generally of pine trees, small junipers and other decorative bushes.
The area is basically left earthen for drainage retention and percolation over three areas totaling 30’ in width by approximately 602’ in length for an area of 16,020 square feet along the north frontage of Geronimo Road.
L-5
TRACT NUMBER: 15288
LOCATION: South side of Sitting Bull Road east of Rincon Road within the tract called Quail Run Estates.
DESCRIPTION: Plans and specifications for the improvements are those prepared by Jennings Landscaping. The parkway landscaping consists generally of pine trees, small junipers and other decorative bushes. The area is covered in cobble stone and brown decorative rock over three areas varying in width by approximately 1000’ in length for an aerial coverage of 15,300 square feet along the south frontage of Sitting Bull Road. In addition to the parkway landscaping along Sitting Bull Road, a small median is located at the entrance to the tract at Quail Summit Road and a long retention basin on the westerly boundary of the tract are also included in the maintenance program.
L-7
TRACT NUMBER: 8476
LOCATION: South of Yucca Loma Road and east of Cochise Road DESCRIPTION: Improvements consist of maintaining 43 existing streetlights located with a portion of Tract 8476, generally located south of Yucca Loma Road and east of Cochise Road.
L-8
TRACT NUMBER: 14846
LOCATION: South side Sitting Bull Road at Skyline Ranch Drive DESCRIPTION: In summary, the district consists of maintaining perimeter landscaping and wall within the parkway along Sitting Bull Road, Deep Creek Road, Geronimo Road and 1.7 acres of open space landscaping and fencing within Lot A. General Plans and specifications for the proposed improvements are those by Fennel Associates, dated July 14, 2000. Both plans and specifications have been filed separately with the Clerk of the Town of Apple Valley and are incorporated by reference.
L-9
TRACT NUMBER: 9096-1
LOCATION: South side Yucca Loma Road at Delaware Road
DESCRIPTION: In summary, the district consists of maintaining an existing landscaped area basically within the parkway along Yucca Loma Road. The parkway is approximately 30’ in width from the street curb to the perimeter wall adjacent to Tract 9096-1, from approximately 400’ west of Delaware Road to 700’ east of Delaware Road.
The area is basically left earthen but includes landscaping, generally of evergreen trees and juniper bushes on Yucca Loma at the entrance of the neighborhood at Delaware Road, and trees planted at 50-feet on center along Yucca Loma Road. The landscaped area currently has a drip irrigation system installed.
L-10
TRACT NUMBER: 16492
LOCATION: South side Yucca Loma Road at Tamani Road
DESCRIPTION: The landscaped area to be maintained by the District is the landscaped parkway on the south side of, and adjacent to, Yucca Loma Road, being also the rear yards of Tract No. 16492-1 and 2
lots 2-12, Lot A, the 60’ drainage easement, the landscape strip along Tamiani Road, the landscaped parkway along Ottawa Rd. and adjacent to Ottawa Rd., being also the rear yards of lots 65-74.
With the construction of Tract No. 16492-1 and 2, the parkway 60’ drainage easement and Lot A is hydro seeded with a desert wildflower mix and maintained twice a year to control overgrowth.
The landscape strip along Tamiani Road includes a strip with gravel mulch and no other planting, and between the sidewalk and rail fence is planted with Plane trees and Desert Willows alternating in groups with shrubs in between and gravel mulch throughout. The planters along Ottawa Rd. has gravel mulch with Chitalpa trees at 40 feet on center and shrubs on bubblers in between. There is dense planting at the main entry and at Yucca Loma Road. The landscape strip along Yucca Loma Road between the bike path and parkway includes Pine Trees and Desert Willows alternating in groups spaced at 10 feet to 30 feet with shrubs in between. The Parkway is landscaped with low growing shrubs. All planters is covered with ¼” gravel.
L-11
TRACT NUMBER: 16395-1, 2
LOCATION: South side Catalina Road, west of Apple Valley Road The landscaped areas to be maintained, in summary, is the landscaped parkway and adjacent to, Apple Valley Road, south of Catalina Road to the southern boundary of the tract; and the storm water detention basin, lot A. Maintained areas also include the slopes adjacent to lots 33 though 37 and lots 40 and 41 within said tract.
L-12
TRACT NUMBER: 16059
LOCATION: North of Sitting Bull Road, east of Apple Valley Road The landscaped area to be maintained by the District is the landscaped parkway and slope area on the north side of, and adjacent to, Sitting Bull Road; and on the east side, and adjacent to, Apple Valley Road. The parkway and slope area adjacent to Sitting
Bull Road and Apple Valley Road and includes the maintenance of an irrigation systems installed as shown on the approved landscape plans.
L-13
TRACT NUMBER: 14994
LOCATION: South of Geronimo Road, at Bannock Road
The landscaped area to be maintained by the District is the landscaped parkway and slope area on the south side of, and adjacent to, Geronimo Road; in Tract 14994 as shown on the approved landscape plans. The total landscaped area to be maintained on the south side of Geronimo Road is approximately 516 linear feet in length by an average width of 33 feet for a total of about 17,128 square feet of landscaping.
L-15
TRACT NUMBER: 18343
LOCATION: North of Esaws Road, west of Central Road
The landscaped area to be maintained by the District is the landscaped parkway and slope area on the west side of, and adjacent to, Central Road (25,200 sq.ft.); the Lot “A”, the detention basin (90,000 sq.ft.), storm drain system and landscaping along the side yards of Holsteiner Lane (13,700 sq.ft.) in Tract 18343 and as shown on the approved landscape plans.
L-17
TRACT NUMBER: 15286
LOCATION: North of Wintun Road, west of Chippewa Road
The landscaped area to be maintained by the district is the detention basin located in Tract No. 15286 as shown on the assessment diagram. With the construction of Tract No.15286 the Detention Basin will be landscaped and have irrigation systems installed as shown on the landscape plans (Exhibit A). After the acceptance of
the landscaped area by the Town of Apple Valley, the funds generated by this annexation will allow the District to provide for the maintenance of the landscaped area.
L-19
TRACT NUMBER: 16134
LOCATION: North of Mana Road, west of Awia Road
The maintenance areas include a sixty (60) foot wide drainage easement to the Town of Apple Valley that is 1,760 lineal feet along the north boundary line of Tract 16134. The south twenty (20) feet contains a graded access road and just north is an eighteen (18) foot 3:1 slope containing 100-pound rip-rap protection. The remainder of the channel is an earthen bottom flowline. Behind the access road is a private six (6) foot backyard masonry wall that runs along lots 26, 27, and 29-35 of this tract. At the easterly end of the channel a 72’ reinforced concrete drainpipe has been installed under Mana Road and a driveway access to the channel access road has been installed on lot 35.
L-20
TRACT NUMBER: 17093
LOCATION: South of Bear Valley Road, east of Itoya Vista Road The maintenance areas include:
1. Landscaped slope of a variable width strip along and adjacent to the southerly right of way of Bear Valley Road between Itoya Vista Street and the easterly tract boundary of Tract 17093 with approximately 12,488 square feet. Approximately 1,270 lineal feet of eight foot (8) wide parkway bicycle trail. Two (2) foot and Six (6) foot wide strips of landscaped parkway areas both approximately 1,270 lineal feet long.
2. Landscaped slope of a variable width strip along and adjacent to the northerly right of way of Sandia Road between Itoya Vista Street and the easterly tract (Merino Avenue) with approximately 16,086 square feet. Approximately 1,170 lineal feet of nine foot (9)
wide decomposed granite parkway equestrian trail. A three (3) foot wide strip of landscaped parkway area approximately 1,170 lineal feet long.
3. Landscaped slope of a variable width strip along and adjacent to the easterly right of way of Itoya Vista Street between Bear Valley Road and Sandia Road with approximately 20,975 square feet.
Approximately 2,277 lineal feet of nine foot (9) wide decomposed granite parkway equestrian trail. A three (3) foot wide strip of landscaped parkway area approximately 2,277 lineal feet long.
L-23
PARCEL NUMBER: PM 17684
LOCATION: North SR 18, west of Dale Evans Parkway
Assessment District L-23 is established to provide landscaping and landscape maintenance within parkways and medians which primarily provide specific aesthetic benefit to the retail shopping centers that are generally located north of Highway 18, south of Thunderbird Road which front Highway 18, Dale Evans Parkway and Bass Hill Road.
L-26
TRACT NUMBER: TR 17278
LOCATION: West of Wabisi Road, South of Mana Road
Assessment District L-26 is established to provide landscaping and landscape maintenance adjacent to Tract 17278, which consists of 15, 1/2 acre lots located on the southwest corner of Mana Road and Wabisi Road. A six-foot masonry wall has been constructed on the property line of the perimeter roads and there is a 12-foot parkway with a four-foot sidewalk. Mana Road landscape surface is 410 lf x
7.5 feet and Wabisi Road is 942 lf x 8 feet for a total landscape surface of approximately 10,611 square feet.
L-28
PARCEL NUMBER: PM 15151, Parcel 3
LOCATION: North SR 18, west of Dale Evans Parkway
Assessment District L-28 is established to provide maintenance to a drywell installed in a retention basin on Assessor Parcel Number 3112-251-56, owned by Apple Valley Commons I, LLC. Drainage easements in favor of the Town of Apple Valley will allow the runoff from the America’s Tire Parcel to drain into the existing retention basin. The retention basin and the corresponding drainage easements are described in parcel map 16984 on record in the County of San Bernardino.
The drywell and existing retention basin provide offsite drainage benefits for the development of the America’s Tire on the southwest corner of Thunderbird Road and Outer Highway 18 North, Parcel 3 of Parcel Map No. 15151.
PART B
ESTIMATE OF COST FY 2023-2024
• L-1 • L-2 • L-3 • L-4 • L-5 • L-7
ITEM DESCRIPTION
Tract
13618 Tract 13426 Tract 14090 Tract 13709 Tract 15288 Tract 8476
1. Maintenance $8,705 $2,043 $112,386 $2,458 $2,197 $0
2. Water consumption $2,689 $597 $6,380 $1,346 $1,421 $0
3. Electrical Service $81 $0 $230 $0 $549 $6,552
Total cost for FY 2022/2023 $11,475 $2,640 $118,997 $3,804 $4,166 $6,552 Assessed budget for FY2022/2023 $5,600 $2,463 $25,477 $2,502 $5,800 $4,760 Surplus or Deficit ($5,875) ($177) ($93,519) ($1,302) $1,634 ($1,792) Last Year's Reserve Fund ($27,601) ($2,153) $137,465 ($6,816) $4,543 ($19,538) Current Reserve Fund ($33,476) ($2,330) $43,946 ($8,118) $6,177 ($21,330) Estimate for FY 2023-2024 $5,600 $2,463 $25,760 $2,502 $5,800 $4,760 Number of lots: 137 26 182 18 65 236
Proposed Cost per lot per year
(FY2023/2024) $41 $95 $142 $139 $89 $20
Last year's assessment per lot per
year $41 $95 $142 $139 $89 $20
• L-8 • L-9 • L-10 • L-11 • L-12 • L-13
ITEM DESCRIPTION
Tract
14846 Tract 9696 Tract 16492 Tract 16395 Tract 16059 Tract 14994
1. Maintenance $43,665 $4,608 $88,637 $17,878 $4,608 $2,611
2. Water consumption $8,952 $1,395 $7,337 $279 $4,875 $1,887
3. Electrical Service $271 $0 $225 $85 $13 $0
Total cost for FY 2022/2023 $52,889 $6,004 $96,199 $18,243 $9,496 $4,499 Assessed budget for FY2022/2023 $28,323 $4,524 $79,768 $16,939 $7,335 $4,035 Surplus or Deficit ($24,567) ($1,480) ($16,431) ($1,304) ($2,160) ($464) Last Year's Reserve Fund $119,730 $479 ($21,890) $68,513 $103,407 $5,530 Current Reserve Fund $95,163 ($1,001) ($38,321) $67,209 $101,247 $5,066 Estimate for FY 2023-2024 $28,323 $4,524 $94,170 $16,936 $7,314 $4,320 Number of lots: 143 58 258 58 46 18
Proposed Cost per lot per year
(FY2023/2024) $198 $78 $365 $292 $159 $240
Last year's assessment per lot per
year $198 $78 $309 $292 $159 $224
PART B (Continued)
ESTIMATE OF COST FY 2023-2024
• L-15 • L-17 • L-19 • L-20 • L-23 • L-26
ITEM DESCRIPTION
Tract
18343 Tract 15286 Tract 16134 Tract 17093 PM 17684 TM 17278
1. Maintenance $4,608 $0 $0 $3,137 $24,321 $6,622
2. Water consumption $2,215 $0 $0 $0 $31,467 $0
3. Electrical Service $72 $0 $0 $0 $78 $0
Total cost for FY 2022/2023 $6,896 $0 $0 $3,137 $55,866 $6,622 Assessed budget for FY2022/2023 $9,240 $10,221 $3,360 $11,000 $29,565 $5,544 Surplus or Deficit $2,344 $10,221 $3,360 $7,863 ($26,301) ($1,078) Last Year's Reserve Fund $93,054 $131,976 $93,181 $160,279 $437,387 $21,450 Current Reserve Fund $95,398 $142,197 $96,541 $168,142 $411,086 $20,372 Estimate for FY 2023-2024 $9,240 $3,050 $1,960 $8,250 $29,565 $6,000 Number of lots: 84 61 35 55 31 15
Proposed Cost per lot per year
(FY2023/2024) $110 $50 $56 $150 varies $400
Last year's assessment per lot per
year $124 $84 $96 $200 varies $370
• L-28
ITEM DESCRIPTION PM 15151
1. Maintenance $0
2. Water consumption $0
3. Electrical Service $0
Total cost for FY 2022/2023 $0
Assessed budget for FY2022/2023 $747
Surplus or Deficit $747
Last Year's Reserve Fund $1,857
Current Reserve Fund $2,604
Estimate for FY 2023-2024 $747
Number of lots: 1
Proposed Cost per lot per year
(FY2023/2024) $747
Last year's assessment per lot per
year $747
PART C
ASSESSMENT DIAGRAM
See Attachments Entitled Assessment Diagrams For:
Annexation No. Tract No.
L-1 Tract 13618
L-2 Tract 13426
L-3 Tract 14090
L-4 Tract 13709
L-5 Tract 15288
L-7 Tract 8476
L-8 Tract 14846
L-9 Tract 9696
L-10 Tract 16492
L-11 Tract 16395
L-12 Tract 16059
L-13 Tract 14994
L-15 Tract 18343
L-17 Tract 15286
L-19 Tract 16134
L-20 Tract 17093
L-23 PM 17684, L.L.A. 2007-002
L-26 Tract 17278
L-28 PM 15151, Parcel 3
PART D
ASSESSMENT ROLL
Reference
Number Tract No. Assessor’s Parcel Numbers Assessment per lot per year L-1 Tract 13618 437-471-(parcels 6-51) $40.88
437-471-(parcels 11-46) $40.88
437-651-(parcels 1-55) $40.88
L-2 Tract 13426 426-661-(parcels 7-32) $94.75
L-3 Tract 14090 3087-031-(parcels 1-77) $141.54
3087-071-(parcels 1-18) $141.54
3087-072-(parcels 1-6,9-20) $141.54
3087-771-(parcels 1-24) $141.54
3087-701-(parcels 1-20) $141.54
3087-721-(parcels 1-27) $141.54
L-4 Tract 13709 444-821-(parcels 1-18) $139.00
L-5 Tract 15288 3087-181-(parcels 5-69) $89.23
L-7 Tract 8476 3088-421-(parcels 1-34) $20.00
3088-431-(parcels 7-28) $20.00
3088-441-(parcels1-36) $20.00
3088-451-(parcels 4-27) $20.00
3088-461-(parcels 1-40) $20.00
3088-471-(parcels 4-26) $20.00
3088-481-(parcels 1-26,28-34) $20.00
3088-491-(parcels 7-13) $20.00
3088-501-(parcels 1-23) $20.00
L-8 14846 3807-181- (Parcels 2-34) $198.06
3807-191- (Parcels 8-48, 50-59) $198.06
3807-192- (Parcels 1-40) $198.06
3807-193- (Parcels 1-19) $198.06
L-9 9696 444-681-(Parcels 3-15) $78.00
444-691-(Parcels 1-13) $78.00
444-701-(Parcels 1-31) $78.00
L-10 16492 3087-271-(Parcels 5-73) $365.00
3087-272-(Parcels 1-60) $365.00
3087-292-(Parcels 1-63) $365.00
3087-771-(Parcels 1-34) $365.00
3087-781-(Parcels 1-32) $365.00
Reference
Number Tract No. Assessor’s Parcel Numbers Assessment per lot per year L-11 16395 3087-731-(Parcels 1-14) $292.04
3087-741-(Parcels 1-9, 11-32, 34) $292.04
3087-021-(Parcels 9) $292.04
L-12 16059 444-782-(Parcels 1-34) $159.46
444-931-(Parcels 1-24) $159.46
L-13 14994 3087-761-(Parcels 1-18) $240.00
L-15 18343 3112-706-(Parcels 15-26)
3112-702-(Parcels 2-73) $110.00
L-17 15286 473-641-(Parcels 2-20) $50.00
473-651-(Parcels 1-42) $50.00
L-19 16134 433-661-(Parcels 1-35) $56.00
L-20 17093 434-051-90,91 $150.00
434-941-(Parcels 1-30) $150.00
434-951-(Parcels 1-23) $150.00
L-23 PM 17684,
LLA07-02 31 Assessor Numbers (see Exhibit “D”) Per Exhibit “D” L-26 17278 473-661-(Parcels 1-15) $400.00
L-28 PM 15151 441-301-03 $746.67
Exhibit D
Assessment Roll
Annexation L-23 to L.M.D. No. 1
Town of Apple Valley Parcel Map 17684, and L.L.A. 2007-002 Assessment Roll
Area In Maximum Annual
Square Assessment Levy
Parcel A.P.N. Site Address Property Owner Feet Amount Amount L.L.A. 2007-
002
Parcel "A" of
L.L.A.
APPLE VALLEY
2007-002 3112-251-60 Vacant Land COMMONS I LLC 219,143 $6,375.52 $1,751.42 Parcel "B" of
L.L.A.
APPLE VALLEY
2007-002 3112-251-61 Vacant Land COMMONS II LLC 306,647 $8,921.27 $2,450.76 Parcel "C" of
L.L.A.
2007-002 3112-251-62 15000 Dale Evans
Pkwy LOWES HIW INC 546,570 $15,901.35 $4,368.25
Parcel "D" of
L.L.A. 2007-
002 3112-251-63 Vacant Land
APPLE VALLEY
COMMONS II LLC
690,358 $20,084.57 $5,517.42
Parcel Map 17684,
P.M.B. 216/33-43
APPLE VALLEY
Parcel 1 3112-251-28 14900 Bass Hill Rd. COMMONS I LLC 68,221 $1,978.41 $540.31
APPLE VALLEY
Parcel 5 3112-251-32 20254 Highway 18 COMMONS I LLC 35,229 $1,021.64 $279.01
APPLE VALLEY
Parcel 6 3112-251-33 20280 Highway 18 COMMONS I LLC 52,115 $1,511.34 $412.75
APPLE VALLEY
Parcel 7 3112-251-34 20290 Highway 18 COMMONS I LLC 28,629 $830.24 $226.74
APPLE VALLEY
Parcel 8 3112-251-35 20302 Highway 18 COMMONS I LLC 29,706 $861.47 $235.27
APPLE VALLEY
Parcel 9 3112-251-36 20306 Highway 18 COMMONS I LLC 27,670 $802.43 $219.15
APPLE VALLEY
Parcel 10 3112-251-37 20296 Highway 18 COMMONS I LLC 50,745 $1,471.61 $401.90
APPLE VALLEY
Parcel 11 3112-251-38 20284 Highway 18 COMMONS I LLC 31,889 $924.78 $252.56
APPLE VALLEY
Parcel 12 3112-251-39 20258 Highway 18 COMMONS I LLC 50,042 $1,451.22 $396.33
APPLE VALLEY
Parcel 13 3112-251-40 20262 Highway 18 COMMONS I LLC 35,902 $1,041.16 $284.34
APPLE VALLEY
Parcel 14 3112-251-41 20266 Highway 18 COMMONS I LLC 25,232 $731.73 $199.84
APPLE VALLEY
Parcel 15 3112-251-42 20310 Highway 18 COMMONS I LLC 50,610 $1,467.69 $400.83
APPLE VALLEY
Parcel 16 3112-251-43 20418 Highway 18 COMMONS I LLC 34,511 $1,000.82 $273.33
APPLE VALLEY
Parcel 17 3112-251-44 20432 Highway 18 COMMONS I LLC 25,392 $736.37 $201.10
APPLE VALLEY
Parcel 18 3112-251-45 20442 Highway 18 COMMONS I LLC 61,748 $1,790.69 $489.04 Parcel 19
3112-251-46 14898 Dale Evans
Pkwy
APPLE VALLEY
COMMONS I LLC 77,130 $2,236.77 $610.87
Parcel 20 3112-251-47
14940 Dale Evans
Pkwy
APPLE VALLEY
COMMONS I LLC 50,423 $1,462.27 $399.35
Parcel 21 3112-251-48
14992 Dale Evans
Pkwy
APPLE VALLEY
COMMONS I LLC 49,105 $1,424.05 $388.91
Parcel 22 3112-251-49 20450 Highway 18
APPLE VALLEY
COMMONS I LLC 105,627 $3,063.18 $836.57
Parcel 23 3112-251-50 20426 Highway 18
APPLE VALLEY
COMMONS I LLC 79,493 $2,305.30 $629.58
Parcel 24 3112-251-51 20352 Highway 18
APPLE VALLEY
COMMONS I LLC 102,873 $2,983.32 $814.75
Parcel 25 3112-251-52 20346 Highway 18
APPLE VALLEY
COMMONS I LLC 114,218 $3,312.32 $904.61
Parcel 26 3112-251-53 20288 Highway 18 TARGET CORP 572,122 $16,591.54 $4,531.21 Parcel 27 3112-251-54 20276 Highway 18
APPLE VALLEY
COMMONS I LLC 57,046 $1,654.33 $451.80
Parcel 28 3112-251-55 20270 Highway 18
APPLE VALLEY
COMMONS I LLC 26,942 $781.32 $213.38
Misc. Parcels along Highway 18
Walgreens -
Parcel 1 of
P.M. 16195,
P.M.B. 200/21-
22 3112-171-20 20250 Highway 18
KETCHUM APPLE
VALLEY LLC 61,724 $1,795.73 $493.31
Starbucks 3112-251-05 14880 Dale Evans
Parkway
Starbucks 48,892 $1,422.41 $390.75
TOTAL ASSESSMENT $107,936.83 $29,565.45
L-1, Tract 13618
L-2, Tract 13426
L-3, Tract 14090
L-4, Tract 13709
L-5, Tract 15288
L-7, Tract 8476
L-8, Tract 14846
L-9, Tract 9696
L-10, Tract 16492-1,2
L-10, Tract 16492-3,4
L-11, Tract 16395
L-12, Tract 16059
L-13, Tract 14994
L-15, Tract 18343
L-17, Tract 15286
L-19, Tract 16134
L-20, Tract 17093
L-23, PM 17684 and L.L.A. 2007-002
L-26, TM 17278
L-28, PM 15151, Parcel 3
RESOLUTION NO. 2023-27
A RESOLUTION OF THE TOWN COUNCIL OF THE TOWN
OF APPLE VALLEY CONFIRMING DIAGRAM AND
ASSESSMENT AND LEVYING ASSESSMENT FOR
FISCAL YEAR 2023-2024
ASSESSMENT DISTRICT NO. 1
(Pursuant to the Landscaping and Lighting Act of 1972)
The Town Council of the Town of Apple Valley hereby resolves as follows:
Section 1: Pursuant to Chapter 3 of the Landscaping and Lighting Act of 1972, the Town Council directed the Town Engineer, Engineer of Work for Assessment District No. 1, to prepare and file an annual report for fiscal year 2023-2024.
Section 2: The Engineer of Work filed his annual report with the Town Clerk, and the Town Council adopted its resolution of intention to levy and collect assessments within the assessment district for fiscal year 2023-2024 and set a public hearing to be held on July 25, 2023, at the Council Chamber of the Town Council located at 14955 Dale Evans Parkway, Town of Apple Valley, California. Notice of the hearing was given in the time and manner required by law.
Section 3: At the public hearing, the Town Council afforded to every interested person an opportunity to make a protest to the annual report either in writing or orally, and the Town Council has considered each protest.
Section 4: The Town Council hereby confirms the diagram and assessment as set forth in the annual report of the Engineer of Work and hereby levies the assessment set forth therein for fiscal year 2023-2024.
APPROVED and ADOPTED by the Town Council of the Town of Apple Valley this 25th day of July 2023.
_________________________________
Scott Nassif, Mayor
ATTEST:
____________________________
La Vonda M-Pearson, Town Clerk
Town Council Agenda Report
Date: July 25, 2023
To: Honorable Mayor and Town Council
Subject: UPDATE OF THE DESIGN CRITERIA CHECKLIST FOR NEW IN-FILL
SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL
From: Douglas Robertson, Town Manager
Submitted by: Daniel Alcayaga, AICP, Planning Manager
Planning
Budgeted Item: Yes No N/A
RECOMMENDED ACTION
Receive and file staff report on the update of the Design Criteria Checklist for New InFill Single-Family Residential
BACKGROUND
On June 8, 2021, the Town Council created an Ad-Hoc Committee to review the Design Criteria Checklist for Single-Family Residential in-fill areas. The point system checklist was originally adopted in February 2016 by Planning Commission Resolution. The point system was created to provide some measure of quality control and reduce the amount of subjectiveness in plan review. It also has built in flexibility so that the standards are not rigid and can be worked out between staff and the developer/builder. Ultimately, if the developer/builder is not satisfied with the results, the decision can be appealed to the Planning Commission for consideration.
The newly formed Ad-Hoc Committee consisted of two Council members: Art Bishop and Kari Leon, as well as two Planning Commissioners: Bob Tinsley and Jared Lanyon. The Committee held a total of three meetings to discuss possible modifications, and even considered repealing the checklist altogether. Committee meetings were held on June 28, 2021, February 9, 2022, and January 26, 2023. On August 26, 2021, a workshop was held in which multiple builders attended and commented on the checklist.
On January 1, 2022, Senate Bill SB-9 became effective which allows a simple lot split, as well as the construction of two dwelling units to be constructed on each lot, by right, in all residential areas. The law only allows local jurisdictions to adopt objective development standards. The Ad-Hoc Committee requested time to allow the bill to unfold. In consultation with the Town Attorney, it was determined that the design criteria checklist
could apply to SB-9 lots splits and associated dwelling units because the checklist is based on an objective criterion. By a separate Ordinance, already adopted, the checklist applies to all dwelling units constructed under SB 9.
On June 21, 2023, the Planning Commission adopted Resolution No. 2023-001 updating the Design Criteria Checklist for New In-Fill Single-Family Residential.
ANALYSIS
At the workshop held on August 26, 2021 by the Ad-Hoc Committee, builders generally expressed the desire for additionally flexibility and offered a host of features that could be added to the checklist. Comments included:
1. That the weight of features qualifying as major and minor points should reflect the cost. That costly item, such as concrete tile roofs, should have a greater weight than one minor point. That certain features, such as decorative pilasters/columns/piers, should not be worth one major point.
2. That “beauty over time” improvements such as a paint job that is intended to last longer in time should be included in the checklist;
3. That relocating penetrations to the rear of the house should be included in the checklist;
4. That landscaping of an entire front yard should be included in the checklist.
Ad-Hoc Recommendations:
The Committee recommended keeping the existing point-system in place but making targeted improvements based on public input received during the community workshop.
These recommendations included:
1. That garages should continue to be counted towards the house size but should be limited to a maximum size of 400 square feet. It was believed that builders get penalized for constructing oversized garages.
2. The Committee recommends the introduction of a “3 minor point category”. The Committee agreed that certain features, such as concrete tile roof, are worth more than one minor point. While features such as decorative pilasters/columns/piers should not be worth one major point and should fall under the “3 minor point category”. Solar was removed from the list because it is now required by the California Building Code.
3. There were numerous suggestions made at the workshop, as well as by committee members. However, to list additional features would require the checklist to be expanded into multiple pages. The Committee believed it is not possible to list every possibility in the checklist but did support flexibility. Therefore, the committee recommends adding an “Other ___” option under each category clarifying that suggestions can be considered by the Director if such feature is not specifically identified on the checklist.
Conclusion:
On August 26, 2021, the Ad-Hoc Committee heard from several builders at a workshop and deliberated on modifications to the checklist, including repealing the checklist. The Committee recommended keeping the existing checklist, but making targeted improvements to provide additional flexibility that builders requested. It is believed that the new “3 minor point” category will normalize the weight of features, as well as adding “the Other ___” option under each category will provide additional flexibility to builders.
The Ad-Hoc Committee believed the checklist continues to provide some measure of quality control and reduces the amount of subjectiveness in plan review. On June 21, 2023, the Planning Commission adopted Resolution No. 2023-003 updating the Design Criteria Checklist for New In-Fill Single-Family Residential.
FISCAL IMPACT
None
ATTACHMENTS
A. Planning Commission Resolution No. 2023-003
B. Exhibit A – Design Criteria Checklist
C. Exhibit B - Examples
PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION NO. 2023-003
A RESOLUTION BY THE TOWN OF APPLE VALLEY, CALIFORNIA
PLANNING COMMISSION UPDATING A POLICY FORMULATING A
POINT BASED, DESIGN CRITERIA CHECKLIST FOR SINGLE FAMILY, INFILL DEVELOPMENT.
WHEREAS, The General Plan of the Town of Apple Valley was adopted by the Town Council on August 11, 2009; and
WHEREAS, Title 9 “Development Code” of the Municipal Code of the Town of Apple Valley was adopted by the Town Council on April 27, 2010; and WHEREAS, Town Council Ordinance 481, adopted February 9, 2016, requires the single family infill development to be consistent with the Planning Commission Design Criteria Policy; and
WHEREAS, the Town Council and Planning Commission recognizes the need to have clear interpretation and consistency in applying the standards and requirements established within the Development Code; and
WHEREAS, the Planning Commission works to preserve and protect the Town’s identity and aesthetic integrity, while preserving the aesthetics of the open, desert environment; and WHEREAS, this modified Policy Statement, formulating a point based, design criteria checklist has been prepared in compliance with the Title 9 “Development Code” of the Municipal Code of the Town of Apple Valley on the recommendation of the Planning Commission; and WHEREAS, this modified Policy Statement shall promote the health, safety and general welfare of the citizens of the Town of Apple Valley.
WHEREAS, this modified Policy Statement shall serve as a guideline to encourage quality development, preserve community pride and providing aesthetic appeal, while affording an individual property owner and developer a fair and equitable opportunity to build using creative and innovative designs; and
WHEREAS, Pursuant to Section 15061(b)(3) of the State Guidelines to Implement the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), it can be determined that the activity is covered by the general rule that CEQA applies only to projects that have the potential for causing a significant effect on the environment. Where it can be seen with certainty that there is no possibility that the activity in question may have a significant effect on the environment, the activity is EXEMPT from further CEQA review; and
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that in consideration to the evidence presented at the public meeting, and for the reasons discussed by the Commissioners at said meeting, the Planning Commission of the Town of Apple Valley, California, does hereby resolve, order and determines as follows:
Section 1. Find that the modified Policy establishing a Point Based Design Criteria Checklist is consistent with the Goals and Policies of the Town of Apple Valley adopted General Plan and Development Code.
Section 2. Pursuant to Section 15061(b)(3) of the State Guidelines to Implement the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), it can be determined that the Code amendment is covered by the general rule that CEQA applies only to projects that have the potential for causing a significant effect on the environment. Where it can be seen with certainty, as with the proposed Code Amendment, that there is no possibility that the Policy will have a significant effect on the environment and; therefore, the Amendment is EXEMPT from further environmental review.
Section 3. Pursuant to the Town Council's commitment to protecting and preserving the community's aesthetic integrity, and preventing arbitrary interpretations of the Development Code, the Planning Commission of the Town of Apple Valley hereby establishes this modified policy that consists of a point based, design criteria checklist with which to address the aesthetic appearance of new single-family residential home development within the Town of Apple Valley that are subject to review by the Planning Division.
Section 4. To achieve the intent of the Municipal Code, while encouraging creativity in design, it is essential to consistently apply the standards, criteria and requirements established within Title 9 "Development Code" of the Town of Apple Valley Municipal Code and by adopting this policy, the Commission establishes the Point Based Design Criteria Checklist, attached hereto and incorporated herein as Attachment A, to provide the community with a consistent application of essential criteria needed to assure the quality of development required by the residents of the Town of Apple Valley.
Section 5. Pursuant to the goals of the Municipal Code to preserve the desert environment, community pride and the community's aesthetic appeal, while affording an individual property owner and developer a fair and equitable opportunity to build using creative and innovative designs within the Town of Apple Valley, the criteria listed below shall be considered during each review of all new, single family homes, and thus, will further community's aesthetic goals.
Section 6. The Planning Commission may modify this policy as deemed appropriate. It is the intent of the policy to be in concert with applicable guidelines required for single-family development per Title 9, of the Development Code of the Town of Apple Valley Municipal Code.
Section 7. The Director shall have the authority to interpret and/or allow features not specifically identified.
Section 8. The Point Based Design Criteria Check list (Attachment A) and associated Pictorial Definitions (Attachment B), both of which are attached hereto and incorporated herein by reference, are hereby adopted.
Approved and Adopted by the Planning Commission of the Town of Apple Valley this 21st day of June 2023.
Jared Lanyon, Chairman
ATTEST:
Nicole Montano, Planning Secretary
PC Resolution 2023-001 Exhibit "A"
Design Criteria Checklist
Additions are in red bold text; deletions are shown as strikeouts A minimum of one point from each list must be achieved in the design of an infill single-family residence. Five items from the Minor list equals one point. One item from the Major list equals one point. The number of required points is determined by the square footage breakdown shown below. For pictorial examples of the terms referenced in this list, see the attached definitions. The Director or designee shall have the authority to interpret and/or allow features not specifically identified.
Minor Features (5 checks equals one point)
Decorative features shall be required on the front and
street side yard for corner lots.
contrasting colors
decorative pilasters/columns/piers
decorative window/door reveals (i.e. arched
reveals, window or door reveals)
architectural moldings/ornamental details:
roundel
finials
medallions
quartrefoils
dentils
quiones
eyebrows
cornice moldings
band course/belly band
other
door and window details (i.e. keystones, dentils
or pediments over doors and windows)
decorative iron work
decorative/architectural niche
smooth stucco finish
decorative/stylized roof vents
second story reveal
different shaped windows on the same floor
which can include:
transom windows
arched windows
french doors
other
decorative windows with muntins and mullions
and/or arches and may include lead, colored
glass or divided lites
shutters and/or window boxes
window surrounds, decorative sills or lentils
decorative front door may include side lites,
transom windows, decorative custom design
garage door with windows or decorative style
(i.e. carriage style, barn door style)
quality decorative carriage lighting on each
side of garage door and at front entry
boxed eaves, large overhangs at least 18", or exposed
rafter tails, kickers or brackets
decorative chimney tops
rain gutters and down spouts
solar panels on roof
decorative pavers or stamped concrete walkways
on corner lots, placing the house at a minimum of 30
degree angle.
Other ___________
Moderate Features (1 check equals 3 minor points)
Roof material other than composition (i.e.
concrete tile, clay tile, simulated wood
shake/shingle)
Decorative pilasters/columns/piers
portico or decorative pronounced entryway
stucco eaves and fascia
Other ___________
Major Features (1 check equals one point)
2 types of materials (i.e. wainscot)
covered front porch or arbor
front balcony
tower feature in front or street side yard
front courtyard niches
garage doors not facing street
three (3)-car garage or greater
traditional architectural style (see definitions - i.e.
Spanish revival, pueblo, craftsman, ranch)
front or street side bay window, overhang jetty
front or side yard porte cochere
multiple roof lines and roof heights (i.e. shed roof,
dormers)
multiple off-sets on elevations
front planter walls or front privacy walls that match the residence, preferably stucco, stone or brick with a
decorative cap.
Other ___________
Point Requirement For House Size, including garage up to 400 square feet but excluding patios and porches.
1,200 sq. ft. - 1,499 sq. ft. 3 pts.
1,500 sq. ft. - 1,799 sq. ft. 4 pts.
1,800 sq. ft. - 2,199 sq. ft. 5 pts.
2,200 sq. ft. - 2,799 sq. ft. 6 pts.
2,800 sq. ft. and above 7 pts.
5-7
Minor Features (5 checks equals one point)
Contrasting Colors
Decorative Garage with Windows
Niche and Niche courtyard with Decorative Garage
Casement Style Windows
Pediments and/or Transom over Door
Pilaster Use of Quatrefoil
Windows with Mullions Sash Transom, Muttons and Architrave Finials on Pitch of Roof
Lentil over Window
Different Sizes and Styles of Windows
on Street Facing Elevation
Reveal Lines Molding with
"Reveal Lines"
Corbels under Window Sills (decorative) Eave/Box
Belly Band
Decorative Vents)
Decorative Iron Work Residence with Medallion/Feature
Quoins Cornice with Dentil
Quoins Smooth Stucco Finish
Copula Feature Use of Precast Concrete
Trim along with Keystone
Arches and Sills
Decorative Chimney Tops
Wainscot/Contrasting Carriage Lights Front Door and Garage Materials
Decorative Pavers/Stamped Concrete Driveways
Major Features (1 checks equals one point)
Balconies
Tower Feature/Prominent Entryway
Planter Walls in Front of Residence Porch along Front Elevation of House Decorative Porch with
Stylized Columns
Portico Entryway
Traditional Single-Family Architectural Styles
Craftsman/Bungalow
Spanish Electric
Prairie
Monterey
Rancho/California Ranch
Pueblo
Mediterranean and Tuscan/Californian Influence
Southwestern Influence
.
Northern Italian/Californian Influence
Contemporary
Spanish Revival