March 25, 2025 Public Comments — Apple Valley City Council, March 25, 2025

Dear Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to urgently request the expedited sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County. The shelter's current practices, especially regarding cats, have raised serious concerns, and transitioning control to the county would significantly improve conditions for all animals, especially cats.

Key concerns include:

Lack of Visibility and High Euthanasia Rates for Cats: Many cats are hidden from the public and euthanized without ever being posted online. In November 2024, only 31.6% of cats were saved, with 96 euthanized and 12 dying in the shelter, unseen by the public.

Disparity in Treatment Between Cats and Dogs: While most dogs are posted online, only about 30% of cats are, severely limiting their chances of adoption. Additionally, dogs are vaccinated promptly, while cats often wait weeks.

Questionable Labeling and Euthanasia Practices: Many cats are labeled as "unadaptable" without proper evaluation and are kept out of sight, leading to unnecessary euthanasia, including healthy kittens. This points to a lack of proper care and evaluation.

Lack of Transparency and Accountability: The shelter’s opaque practices raise questions about the decisions made and who is accountable for them.

Need for Reform: Immediate changes are needed, including transparency, better management, and adequate resources for cats. A TNVR and low-cost spay/neuter program would also address overpopulation.

Given these systemic issues, we respectfully urge the Apple Valley Town Council to expedite the sale of AVAS to San Bernardino County, where there are the resources and infrastructure to improve conditions and provide better care for the animals.

Thank you for your attention to this important matter. I hope we can work together for a brighter future for the animals in our community.

Best regards,
Sherry Wu
Dear Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to respectfully request the **expedited sale** of the **Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS)** to **San Bernardino County**. The current state of the shelter and its practices have raised serious concerns regarding the treatment of cats, and I believe that transitioning control of AVAS to the county will significantly improve conditions and provide a better chance at life for all animals, especially cats.

Below, I’ve summarized the key reasons why we urgently request the sale:

1. **Lack of Visibility and Minimal EƯort for Cats, Leading to High Euthanasia Rates:** At AVAS, many cats are hidden from public view, facing euthanasia without ever being posted online. This lack of visibility, coupled with delayed vaccinations and minimal eƯort to evaluate and rehome cats, has contributed to an alarmingly high euthanasia rate. * For instance, in **November 2024**, the live release rate for cats was only **31.6%**, with **96 cats euthanized** and **12 dying in the shelter**. These cats were never posted on the shelter’s website or included in any adoption eƯorts, eƯectively condemning them to a hidden death. The shelter’s failure to make these animals visible to the public is a form of systemic neglect.

1. **Disparity in Treatment Between Cats and Dogs:** While AVAS posts **the majority** of the dogs on its website, only around **30% of cats** are listed, drastically reducing their chances of being adopted or rescued. Additionally, dogs receive vaccinations within 3 days of intake, while cats often wait for weeks.

2. **Questionable Labeling and Euthanasia Practices:** AVAS has been labeling many cats as "unadaptable" without proper evaluation, and these cats are kept in the back areas of the shelter, out of sight. Since a policy change in **September 2024**, the intake of **kittens**, which are generally easy to socialize, has increased. However, AVAS has been euthanizing large numbers of these kittens without giving them a fair chance for adoption.

In November alone, **68 cats** were euthanized for being "unadoptable," and **24 others** were euthanized for "health" issues, despite the lack of an on-site veterinarian.

This suggests a serious failure in the shelter’s evaluation and care processes, and a culture of euthanasia out of convenience rather than necessity.

3. **Accountability and Transparency:** The lack of transparency in how cats are labeled and euthanized is concerning and undermines public trust in the shelter’s ability to fulfill its responsibilities.

4. **Urgent Need for Reform:** The current practices at AVAS betray the public’s trust and fail to meet the expectations of a taxpayer-funded shelter. We demand immediate reform to ensure that all animals, including cats, are given a fair chance at life. This includes:
* **Transparency:** Require AVAS to list all cats and dogs on the website, including those in holding and receiving areas, within **3 days of intake**. * **Accountability:** Replace the current management and staƯ responsible for the mismanagement of shelter practices.
* **Resources for Cats:** Allocate suƯicient resources to ensure timely vaccinations, proper evaluations, and medical care for all cats.
* **Establish TNVR and Low-Cost Spay/Neuter Services:** Implement a **TNVR program** and a **low-cost spay/neuter program** to address the root causes of overpopulation and overcrowding.

Given the lack of adequate resources, mismanagement, and failure to protect the welfare of animals, we respectfully urge the **Apple Valley Town Council** to expedite the sale of AVAS to **San Bernardino County**. The county has the resources, infrastructure, and commitment to animal welfare needed to address these issues and provide a better future for the animals of Apple Valley.

Thank you for your attention to this urgent matter. I am hopeful that, together, we can ensure a brighter future for the animals in our community.

Best regards,
Nicholas Poirier
News of your local animal shelter has traveled far and wide. The entire United States are seeing how poorly the cats are being treated. These precious animals need to be seen to be adopted. They need care. No animal should die in a tiny cage. They need a chance! We see it. Now, we're looking to see some change. Will it start with you? Carol Saylor
Tennessee
Dear Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to respectfully request the expedited sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County. The current state of the shelter and its practices have raised serious concerns regarding the treatment of cats, and I believe that transitioning control of AVAS to the county will significantly improve conditions and provide a better chance at life for all animals, especially cats.

Below, I’ve summarized the key reasons why we urgently request the sale:

1. Lack of Visibility and Minimal EƯort for Cats, Leading to High Euthanasia Rates:

At AVAS, many cats are hidden from public view, facing euthanasia without ever being posted online. This lack of visibility, coupled with delayed vaccinations and minimal eƯort to evaluate and rehome cats, has contributed to an alarmingly high euthanasia rate.
 For instance, in November 2024, the live release rate for cats was only 31.6%, with 96 cats euthanized and 12 dying in the shelter. These cats were never posted on the shelter’s website or included in any adoption eƯorts, eƯectively condemning them to a hidden death. The shelter’s failure to make these animals visible to the public is a form of systemic neglect.

2. Disparity in Treatment Between Cats and Dogs:

While AVAS posts the majority of the dogs on its website, only around 30% of cats are listed, drastically reducing their chances of being adopted or rescued.

Additionally, dogs receive vaccinations within 3 days of intake, while cats often wait for weeks.

3. Questionable Labeling and Euthanasia Practices:

AVAS has been labeling many cats as "unadaptable" without proper evaluation, and these cats are kept in the back areas of the shelter, out of sight.

Since a policy change in September 2024, the intake of kittens, which are generally easy to socialize, has increased. However, AVAS has been euthanizing large numbers of these kittens without giving them a fair chance for adoption. In November alone, 68 cats were euthanized for being "unadoptable," and 24 others were euthanized for "health" issues, despite the lack of an on-site veterinarian. This suggests a serious failure in the shelter’s evaluation and care processes, and a culture of euthanasia out of convenience rather than necessity.

4. Accountability and Transparency:

The lack of transparency in how cats are labeled and euthanized is concerning and undermines public trust in the shelter’s ability to fulfill its responsibilities.

5. Urgent Need for Reform:

The current practices at AVAS betray the public’s trust and fail to meet the expectations of a taxpayer-funded shelter. We demand immediate reform to ensure that all animals, including cats, are given a fair chance at life. This includes:
 Transparency: Require AVAS to list all cats and dogs on the website, including those in holding and receiving areas, within 3 days of intake.  Accountability: Replace the current management and staƯ responsible for the mismanagement of shelter practices.
 Resources for Cats: Allocate suƯicient resources to ensure timely vaccinations, proper evaluations, and medical care for all cats.
 Establish TNVR and Low-Cost Spay/Neuter Services: Implement a TNVR program and a low-cost spay/neuter program to address the root causes of overpopulation and overcrowding.

Given the lack of adequate resources, mismanagement, and failure to protect the welfare of animals, we respectfully urge the Apple Valley Town Council to expedite the sale of AVAS to San Bernardino County. The county has the resources, infrastructure, and commitment to animal welfare needed to address these issues and provide a better future for the animals of Apple Valley.

Thank you for your attention to this urgent matter. I am hopeful that, together, we can ensure a brighter future for the animals in our community.

Hunter Whiddon
Dear Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to respectfully request the **expedited sale** of the **Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS)** to **San Bernardino County**. The current state of the shelter and its practices have raised serious concerns regarding the treatment of cats, and I believe that transitioning control of AVAS to the county will significantly improve conditions and provide a better chance at life for all animals, especially cats.

Below, I’ve summarized the key reasons why we urgently request the sale:

In November alone, **68 cats** were euthanized for being "unadoptable," and **24 others** were euthanized for "health" issues, despite the lack of an on-site veterinarian.

This suggests a serious failure in the shelter’s evaluation and care processes, and a culture of euthanasia out of convenience rather than necessity.

Thank you for your attention to this urgent matter. I am hopeful that, together, we can ensure a brighter future for the animals in our community.

Best regards,
Jessye cohen-dan, LCSW
Dear Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to respectfully request the expedited sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County. The current state of the shelter and its practices have raised serious concerns regarding the treatment of cats, and I believe that transitioning control of AVAS to the county will significantly improve conditions and provide a better chance at life for all animals, especially cats.

Below, I’ve summarized the key reasons why we urgently request the sale:

1. Lack of Visibility and Minimal EƯort for Cats, Leading to High Euthanasia Rates:

2. Disparity in Treatment Between Cats and Dogs:

While AVAS posts the majority of the dogs on its website, only around 30% of cats are listed, drastically reducing their chances of being adopted or rescued.

Additionally, dogs receive vaccinations within 3 days of intake, while cats often wait for weeks.

3. Questionable Labeling and Euthanasia Practices:

AVAS has been labeling many cats as "unadaptable" without proper evaluation, and these cats are kept in the back areas of the shelter, out of sight.

4. Accountability and Transparency:

The lack of transparency in how cats are labeled and euthanized is concerning and undermines public trust in the shelter’s ability to fulfill its responsibilities.

5. Urgent Need for Reform:

Thank you for your attention to this urgent matter. I am hopeful that, together, we can ensure a brighter future for the animals in our community.

Iris Sommer
Request for Expedited Sale of AVAS to San Bernardino County Dear Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to respectfully request the expedited sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County. The current state of the shelter and its practices have raised serious concerns regarding the treatment of cats, and I believe that transitioning control of AVAS to the county will significantly improve conditions and provide a better chance at life for all animals, especially cats.

Below, I’ve summarized the key reasons why we urgently request the sale:

1. Lack of Visibility and Minimal EƯort for Cats, Leading to High Euthanasia Rates:

At AVAS, many cats are hidden from public view, facing euthanasia without ever being posted online. This lack of visibility, coupled with delayed vaccinations and minimal eƯort to evaluate and rehome cats, has contributed to an alarmingly high euthanasia rate. - For instance, in November 2024, the live release rate for cats was only 31.6%, with 96 cats euthanized and 12 dying in the shelter. These cats were never posted on the shelter’s website or included in any adoption eƯorts, eƯectively condemning them to a hidden death. The shelter’s failure to make these animals visible to the public is a form of systemic neglect.

2. Disparity in Treatment Between Cats and Dogs:

While AVAS posts majority of the dogs on its website, only around 30% of cats are listed, drastically reducing their chances of being adopted or rescued. Additionally, dogs receive vaccinations within 3 days of intake, while cats often wait for weeks.

3. Questionable Labeling and Euthanasia Practices:

AVAS has been labeling many cats as "unadaptable" without proper evaluation, and these cats are kept in the back areas of the shelter, out of sight.

The adoption area has been empty for more than one month from Feb until Mar.21, which means all cats has been labeled as "feral" or "not able to be handled" Since a policy change in September 2024, the intake of kittens, which are generally easy to socialize, has increased. However, AVAS has been euthanizing large numbers of these kittens without giving them a fair chance for adoption. In November alone, 68 cats were euthanized for being "unadoptable," and 24 others were euthanized for "health ", despite the lack of an on-site veterinarian. This suggests a serious failure in the shelter’s evaluation and care processes, and a culture of euthanasia out of convenience rather than necessity.

4. Accountability and Transparency:

The lack of transparency in how cats are labeled and euthanized is concerning and undermines public trust in the shelter’s ability to fulfill its responsibilities.

5. Urgent Need for Reform:

Transparency: Require AVAS to list all cats and dogs on the website, including those in holding and receiving areas, within 3 days of intake.

Accountability: Replace the current management and staƯ responsible for the mismanagement of shelter practices.

Resources for Cats: Allocate suƯicient resources to ensure timely vaccinations, proper evaluations, and medical care for all cats.

Establish TNVR and Low-Cost Spay/Neuter Services: Implement a TNVR program and a low-cost spay/neuter program to address the root causes of overpopulation and overcrowding.

Thank you for your attention to this urgent matter. I am hopeful that, together, we can ensure a brighter future for the animals in our community.

Best,
Heather Caulfield
Dear Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to respectfully request the expedited sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County. The current state of the shelter and its practices have raised serious concerns regarding the treatment of cats, and I believe that transitioning control of AVAS to the county will significantly improve conditions and provide a better chance at life for all animals, especially cats.

Below, I’ve summarized the key reasons why we urgently request the sale:

1. Lack of Visibility and Minimal EƯort for Cats, Leading to High Euthanasia Rates:

2. Disparity in Treatment Between Cats and Dogs:

While AVAS posts the majority of the dogs on its website, only around 30% of cats are listed, drastically reducing their chances of being adopted or rescued.

Additionally, dogs receive vaccinations within 3 days of intake, while cats often wait for weeks.

3. Questionable Labeling and Euthanasia Practices:

AVAS has been labeling many cats as "unadaptable" without proper evaluation, and these cats are kept in the back areas of the shelter, out of sight.

4. Accountability and Transparency:

The lack of transparency in how cats are labeled and euthanized is concerning and undermines public trust in the shelter’s ability to fulfill its responsibilities.

5. Urgent Need for Reform:

Thank you for your attention to this urgent matter. I am hopeful that, together, we can ensure a brighter future for the animals in our community.

Regards,
Mirabai Nagle former City Council Member for Boulder City, Colorado.

Sent from my iPhone
Dear Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to respectfully request the expedited sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County. The current state of the shelter and its practices have raised serious concerns regarding the treatment of cats, and I believe that transitioning control of AVAS to the county will significantly improve conditions and provide a better chance at life for all animals, especially cats.

Below, I’ve summarized the key reasons why we urgently request the sale:

1. Lack of Visibility and Minimal EƯort for Cats, Leading to High Euthanasia Rates:

2. Disparity in Treatment Between Cats and Dogs:

While AVAS posts the majority of the dogs on its website, only around 30% of cats are listed, drastically reducing their chances of being adopted or rescued.

Additionally, dogs receive vaccinations within 3 days of intake, while cats often wait for weeks.

3. Questionable Labeling and Euthanasia Practices:

AVAS has been labeling many cats as "unadaptable" without proper evaluation, and these cats are kept in the back areas of the shelter, out of sight.

4. Accountability and Transparency:

The lack of transparency in how cats are labeled and euthanized is concerning and undermines public trust in the shelter’s ability to fulfill its responsibilities.

5. Urgent Need for Reform:

Thank you for your attention to this urgent matter. I am hopeful that, together, we can ensure a brighter future for the animals in our community.

Regards,
Tina Nikolova
Dear Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to respectfully request the expedited sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County. The current state of the shelter and its practices have raised serious concerns regarding the treatment of cats, and I believe that transitioning control of AVAS to the county will significantly improve conditions and provide a better chance at life for all animals, especially cats.

Below, I’ve summarized the key reasons why we urgently request the sale:

1. Lack of Visibility and Minimal EƯort for Cats, Leading to High Euthanasia Rates:

2. Disparity in Treatment Between Cats and Dogs:

While AVAS posts the majority of the dogs on its website, only around 30% of cats are listed, drastically reducing their chances of being adopted or rescued.

Additionally, dogs receive vaccinations within 3 days of intake, while cats often wait for weeks.

3. Questionable Labeling and Euthanasia Practices:

AVAS has been labeling many cats as "unadaptable" without proper evaluation, and these cats are kept in the back areas of the shelter, out of sight.

4. Accountability and Transparency:

The lack of transparency in how cats are labeled and euthanized is concerning and undermines public trust in the shelter’s ability to fulfill its responsibilities.

5. Urgent Need for Reform:

Thank you for your attention to this urgent matter. I am hopeful that, together, we can ensure a brighter future for the animals in our community.

Amy Palmer
Subject: Urgent Call for Reform and Accountability at Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) Dear Apple Valley Town Council Members and San Bernardino County Supervisors, We are writing to express deep concern about the systemic issues at Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) regarding the treatment of cats. The shelter practices reveal troubling trends that demand immediate action.

In November, the live release rate for cats at AVAS was just 31.6%, according to the shelter’s monthly disposition report of Nov.

As of Jan.11, only 6 cats intake in Dec and ZERO cats intake in Jan were posted on the AVAS website.

In November alone, 96 cats were euthanized, and 12 died, but none of these cats were posted online or included in the daily urgent list
AVAS has been labeling the majority cats as "unadoptable," with many of them being kittens after policy update since Sep.1, euthanizing them without proper evaluation, and hiding them from public view.

1. Disparity in Treatment Between Cats and Dogs
Key Statistics from the November Disposition Report:

Live Release Rate:

Dogs: 87% 323 total in the report(excluding dead on arrival, Euthanized: 41, Died at shelter:
1).

Cats: 31.6% 158 total in the report (excluding dead on arrival, Euthanized: 96, Died at shelter: 12).

2.Lack of Visibility and Minimal EƯort for Cats:

In November alone, 96 cats were euthanized, and 12 died at the shelter. None of these 108 cats were posted online or included in the daily urgent list, eƯectively condemning them to a hidden death.

On average, less than 30% of cats are posted on the AVAS website, severely limiting their chances of adoption.

Majority of dogs, including those in "holding" or "receiving" areas, are posted on the AVAS website, providing them with greater adoption opportunities.

Vaccination Delays:

Dogs are vaccinated within 3 days of intake, providing timely health protection.

Cats, however, are vaccinated 3 weeks after intake, leaving them vulnerable to illness and further diminishing their chances of survival.

This lack of visibility, delayed vaccinations, and minimal eƯort reflects systemic neglect and an apparent disregard for cats’ welfare.

The disparity in outcomes for cats compared to dogs is staggering. It is evident that the shelter has the capacity to improve.

3. Questionable Labeling and Euthanasia Standards:

The evaluation process is nominal at best, and many cats are euthanized unnecessarily AVAS has been labeling the majority cats as "unadaptable," with many of them being kittens after policy update since Sep.1, euthanizing them without proper evaluation, and hiding them from public view.

Most cats are kept out of sight in the back and often face euthanasia without ever being posted online - they were held in the backend with 0 visibility given not even posted on the AVAS website and euthanized directly.

Since the cat intake policy update in September, the majority of cat intakes have been kittens—generally easy to socialize
In nearby shelters within the same county, over 75% of cats are labeled as friendly, yet at AVAS, 68 cats were euthanized as "not adoptable" in November alone.

Additionally, 24 cats were euthanized for health reasons, despite the absence of a full-time veterinarian on-site.

Cats are largely confined to the back-end areas of the shelter, where minimal resources and eƯorts are allocated to them.

Volunteers and rescues are denied access to these areas, leaving the majority of cats unseen and ultimately euthanized without a fair chance.

It appears AVAS is euthanizing cats with little to no eƯort to evaluate, treat, or rehome them. This lack of transparency and eƯort is unacceptable for a public shelter. AVAS has been killing cats at will, out of convenience, and in secret—behavior that must not be tolerated.

4. Accountability and Transparency
The labeling process appears inconsistent and unprofessional, raising questions about the qualifications and accountability of the staƯ involved. Decisions to euthanize cats are being made with minimal eƯort to evaluate, treat, or rehome them, and it seems that AVAS is euthanizing cats out of convenience rather than necessity.

We demand accountability for the decisions leading to the mass euthanasia of cats at AVAS:

Who is making these decisions?
What qualifications do they have?
Why are so many cats being labeled as "not adoptable" or killed for minor health conditions?
We call for the immediate replacement of personnel responsible for these decisions and replacing personnel who have contributed to this mass euthanasia.

5. Lack of Essential Programs and Resources for Cats
Apple valley town fails to implement key programs essential for reducing the euthanasia rate and improving outcomes for cats:

No Trap-Neuter-Return (TNR) Program: This is critical for managing community cat populations and preventing overcrowding.

No Low-Cost Spay/Neuter Program: Expanding access to aƯordable spay/neuter services would significantly reduce shelter intake.

Without these programs, AVAS perpetuates a cycle of unnecessary euthanasia.

6. Urgent Requests for Reform
To address these issues, we respectfully request:

Transparency:

Require AVAS to list all cats and dogs on its website, including those in holding and receiving areas within 3 days of intake.

Publish intake, outcome, and euthanasia data monthly.

Accountability:

Investigate the personnel responsible for labeling and euthanizing cats and hold them accountable.

Replace staƯ engaged in systemic neglect or misuse of euthanasia practices.

Resources for Cats:

Allocate qulified resources to ensure timely vaccinations, proper evaluations, and medical care for all cats.

Establish TNR and low-cost spay/neuter programs to control the population and reduce intake.

Policy Changes:

Prohibit euthanasia of animals without documented evaluation by qualified personnel.

Prioritize medical care and adoption eƯorts over euthanasia.

Implement Trap-Neuter-Vaccinate-Return (TNVR) Program for community cats TNVR/ Free spay and neuter services for community cats is desperately needed in Apple Valley Town. We strongly urge the initiation of a TNVR program specifically for community cats.

This approach is not only cost-eƯective but also directly addresses the overpopulation issue at its root by preventing future litters and improving the health of the local cat population.

With many community members struggling to aƯord veterinary care, TNVR would be a sustainable solution to manage the growing number of stray and feral cats, ultimately reducing shelter intake and preventing overcrowding
Through the TNR program friendly cats will be taken to the shelter for adoption and others will be released back to the community where they come from.

Establish a Low-Cost Spay-Neuter Service complemented by a TNVR program for longterm sustainability With the average income in Apple Valley below $25,000 per year, many residents find it financially diƯicult to provide basic care for their pets, including spay/neuter services.

AƯordable options are crucial for ensuring responsible pet ownership and preventing unintended litters.

The practices at AVAS are a betrayal of the public trust and a failure to fulfill the responsibilities of a taxpayer-funded shelter.

The shelter's treatment of cats—hiding them from public view, delaying vaccinations, mislabeling their adaptability, and euthanizing them without eƯort to save them—is unacceptable.

We demand accountability, reform, and transparency to ensure AVAS becomes a place where all animals, including cats, are given a fair chance at life.

Thank you for your attention to this urgent matter.

3. Contextual info: intensive killing:

Rules Changed Again: Luna and Harper Were Taken Too Soon List of cats no longer listed/ On hold as of 8.22
The Heartbreaking Story of Bailey (#AV244188) ᘔᘕᘖ
R.I.P. ዋዌው In memory of the 12 cats we lost on 8.17/8.20 (AVAS closed on 8.18 and 8.19) R.I.P. ዋዌው In memory of the 20 kitties we lost on 8/15 and 8/16.

R.I.P. ዋዌው In memory of the 11 kitties we lost on 8.13

4. Previous public comments in Oct or earlier FYI:

Urgent Call for Reform and Investigation at AVAS
࿸࿹࿺ No improvement has been shown even though intake dropped significantly from 325 in August to 182 in September. The live release rate for cats in September is shockingly low at just 27%.

Concerns Regarding Apple Valley Animal Shelter’s Euthanasia Practices A protest against AVAS’s practice of placing almost all cats listed on their website on the urgent list/ euth list on Oct.18
Ongoing Crisis at AVAS - Why are major outbreaks happening at AVAS every month? Please reach out to the elected oƯicials in Apple Valley City Council , San Bernardino County and Congressman’s oƯice.

4.1 Public comment : Urgent Call for Reform and Investigation at AVAS Dear Madam/Sir,
I am writing to express grave concerns regarding the alarming rise in euthanasia rates and the ongoing systemic issues at Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS). The situation has reached a critical point, with dozens of cats losing their lives everyday without proper evaluation or consideration for alternatives like adoption or rescue.

No improvement shown even though intake dropped significantly from 325 in August to 182 in September. Live release rate for cats in Sep is as low as 13%. This lack of visibility contributes significantly to the high euthanasia rate.

As of October 15, about 20% of the cat intaken in Sep has been posted on the AVAS website v.s. 100% of the dog intake posted
In August 2024 237 cats were euthanized, out of this, 198 (83%) of the cats never showed up on the website for the public to see.

Out of 182 cats taken in during September 2024, only 34 were listed on the website, while 75 were marked as “hold” and 65 were euthanized.

AVAS has significantly neglected its eƯorts on the cat side, and the outcomes for AVAS cats in 2024 may mirror those of 2023 (only 7% cats made it out alive out of 3469 intake in 2023) Key Observations:

Even though intake dropped significantly from 325 in August to 182 in September. Live release rate for cats in Sep is as low as 13%.

No TNVR or low cost Spay and neuter program provided in Apple Valley City Urgent List Discrepancies: The urgent list provided by AVAS currently is a duplicate of cats listed on their website, with almost all of which in the adoption area.

Cats under "hold" are not included, despite being the ones most at risk of euthanasia.

Disparity Between Cats and Dogs: There’s a significant disparity in how cats and dogs are handled at AVAS. While nearly 100% of dogs are posted online for adoption, very few cats are.

As of Oct.23, only 3 cats with October intake dates have been listed.Around 20% (or less) of cats are listed on the AVAS website each month leaving most cats without any visibility Many cats remain stuck in the backend during intake or on "hold," with many euthanized without being given a chance/ ever posted online.

In August, 237 cats were euthanized, with 198 (about 83%) not listed on the AVAS website. 75 cats from September intake remain under hold as of Oct 3.

As of October 2, only 12 out of 141 cats taken in September were listed on the site.

Ongoing outbreak since July 2024, with new intakes continuing to be exposed and scheduled to be euthanized in just a few days. Adoption requests were rejected, and random rules have been added that undermine life-saving eƯorts.

Volunteers are still denied access to take videos or photos of these cats in the back end, meaning they remain invisible from the moment they enter the shelter.

Poor visibility contributes to the high euthanization rate. Only 5% to 10% of the cats are put in the adoption area and visible to the public
A recent request sent to AVAS by a rescue partner asking for a volunteer to take videos on behalf of them was rejected by AVAS
Medical Care is Nominal:

Monthly disease outbreaks result in mass euthanasia for health reasons.

New intake has been placed in the same room/ area exposed to ringworm/panleuk the SAME day positive cases left/euthanized
No vaccine was given for cats labeled as feral and almost NO cat was vaccinated during intake
AVAS euthanizes cats being exposed without even testing them Lots of cats labeled "under treatment" show no medical records beyond their vaccination, yet many are euthanized regardless.

Some cats and kittens scheduled to be euthanized turned out to be “overall healthy” when checked by a vet
No regular evolution /health check was given. It’s normal that kittens were not re-weighted in weeks or even months. A kitten adopted out last week was put under observation for more than 2 month
Adoption (even rescue) requests are often denied by AVAS. The reasons can vary, from claims that "the cat has been exposed to [illness]" to requiring the remote adopter to be physically present. In some cases, by the next day, they simply respond with, "The cat you requested has already been euthanized."
AVAS does not include cats in their adoption event. In contract, almost every cat rescue hosts adoption events in public places
Based on recent observations and data, it is evident that immediate reforms are necessary to ensure the welfare of animals under AVAS's care and to restore community trust.

Given AVAS's ongoing negligence and mishandling of these animals, we strongly urge the following immediate actions:

I. enact reforms including:

Grant access to authorized volunteers to take videos and photos of those 90% of cats in non-adoption areas to increase visibility and promote adoptions.

List all cats on the shelter's website within 24 hours of intake Disclose the outcome of each cat in monthly reports to ensure accountability and transparency.

Stop euthanize cats not in adoption area when they can legally be Avoid euthanasia when space is available.

Implement regular reassessment of cats and timely updates to shelter notes to accurately reflect their behavioral status.

Initiate TNVR program for the community cats in Apple Valley City Prioritize providing medical care over resorting to euthanasia as a first option:

Administer vaccines to every cat upon 72 hours from entry to the shelter, including feral ones.

Stop put new intake to exposure area
A comprehensive medical treatment plan must be provided for the cats currently sick . measures must be implemented to prevent further intensive and frequent outbreaks Refrain from immediate euthanasia for health reasons; Maintain a variety of antibiotics and medications to treat illnesses promptly.

Kittens should be paired up and kept in separate cages instead of free roaming in the same room when there’s no suƯicient medical care.

Establish a dedicated medical room and consider oƯering on-site veterinary services, potentially through partnerships with veterinary clinics.

Improve airflow and hygiene protocols within the shelter to prevent the spread of disease.

Support Adoption and Rescue EƯorts:
provide a daily urgent list of cats to rescues and the community.

Adoption and rescue request need to be respond in a timely manner Discontinue rejecting adoption or foster requests due to random reasons and cease euthanizing cats under evaluation.

Ensure cats are included in all adoption events and community fairs to maximize adoption opportunities.

Those responsible for the mishandling of disease outbreaks must be held accountable. We request for replacement of the current shelter management including shelter director and key stakeholders.

II. Launch an investigation into AVAS
It’s becoming clear that AVAS is doing the bare minimum to meet legal standards, while neglecting the actual care of these animals.

Euthanasia seems to be the easiest route for them,and it’s heartbreaking to see life-saving eƯorts pushed aside in favor of convenience.

This isn’t just neglect; it’s a system that’s failing these animals, leading to unnecessary deaths.

An immediate investigation is needed to address these failures, ensure proper evaluations, and restore transparency. The community and these animals deserve better. Those responsible for mishandling disease outbreaks must be held accountable.

Thank you for your attention to these urgent matters. I look forward to seeing positive changes that benefit both the animals and our community.

4.2 Public Comment: Concerns Regarding Apple Valley Animal Shelter’s Euthanasia Practices
Dear Sir/Madam
I am writing to formally protest the current euthanasia practices at Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS). Based on my understanding, these practices are not only unethical but may also be inconsistent with established legal standards for humane euthanasia in shelters.

Under California’s Hayden Law and general euthanasia criteria, shelters should only euthanize animals when it is medically necessary to alleviate suƯering due to injury or illness, or in cases where an animal poses a danger to public safety due to severe behavioral issues. Healthy, adoptable animals should never be euthanized, especially when there are alternatives like adoption, rescue transfers, or fostering available. However, on Oct.18, AVAS has placed all the cats currently listed on its website on the urgent list for euthanasia, even though many are healthy and friendly.

The current practices at Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) seem to deviate from these principles and goes against the very purpose of animal aid.

Please make sure the cats in AVAS are posted to your website and Facebook page so that those who want to rescue them and adopt them, may safely assist them in a humane manner.

Sincerely,
Christina Marie Friedrich
Yahoo Mail: Search, Organize, Conquer
Dear Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to respectfully request the expedited sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County. The current state of the shelter and its practices have raised serious concerns regarding the treatment of cats, and I believe that transitioning control of AVAS to the county will significantly improve conditions and provide a better chance at life for all animals, especially cats.

Below, I’ve summarized the key reasons why we urgently request the sale:

1. Lack of Visibility and Minimal EƯort for Cats, Leading to High Euthanasia Rates:

2. Disparity in Treatment Between Cats and Dogs:

While AVAS posts the majority of the dogs on its website, only around 30% of cats are listed, drastically reducing their chances of being adopted or rescued.

Additionally, dogs receive vaccinations within 3 days of intake, while cats often wait for weeks.

3. Questionable Labeling and Euthanasia Practices:

AVAS has been labeling many cats as "unadaptable" without proper evaluation, and these cats are kept in the back areas of the shelter, out of sight.

4. Accountability and Transparency:

The lack of transparency in how cats are labeled and euthanized is concerning and undermines public trust in the shelter’s ability to fulfill its responsibilities.

5. Urgent Need for Reform:

Thank you for your attention to this urgent matter. I am hopeful that, together, we can ensure a brighter future for the animals in our community.

Thank you.

Venessa DeChellis
Dear Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to respectfully request the expedited sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County. The current state of the shelter and its practices have raised serious concerns regarding the treatment of cats, and I believe that transitioning control of AVAS to the county will significantly improve conditions and provide a better chance at life for all animals, especially cats.

Below, I’ve summarized the key reasons why we urgently request the sale:

1. Lack of Visibility and Minimal EƯort for Cats, Leading to High Euthanasia Rates:

At AVAS, many cats are hidden from public view, facing euthanasia without ever being posted online. This lack of visibility, coupled with delayed vaccinations and minimal eƯort to evaluate and rehome cats, has contributed to an alarmingly high euthanasia rate. - For instance, in November 2024, the live release rate for cats was only 31.6%, with 96 cats euthanized and 12 dying in the shelter. These cats were never posted on the shelter’s website or included in any adoption eƯorts, eƯectively condemning them to a hidden death. The shelter’s failure to make these animals visible to the public is a form of systemic neglect.

2. Disparity in Treatment Between Cats and Dogs:

While AVAS posts the majority of the dogs on its website, only around 30% of cats are listed, drastically reducing their chances of being adopted or rescued. Additionally, dogs receive vaccinations within 3 days of intake, while cats often wait for weeks.

3. Questionable Labeling and Euthanasia Practices:

AVAS has been labeling many cats as "unadaptable" without proper evaluation, and these cats are kept in the back areas of the shelter, out of sight.

The adoption area has been empty for more than one month from Feb until March 21, which means all cats have been labeled as "feral" or "not able to be handled".

Since a policy change in September 2024, the intake of kittens, which are generally easy to socialize, has increased. However, AVAS has been euthanizing large numbers of these kittens without giving them a fair chance for adoption. In November alone, 68 cats were euthanized for being "unadoptable," and 24 others were euthanized for "health ", despite the lack of an on-site veterinarian. This suggests a serious failure in the shelter’s evaluation and care processes, and a culture of euthanasia out of convenience rather than necessity.

4. Accountability and Transparency:

The lack of transparency in how cats are labeled and euthanized is concerning and undermines public trust in the shelter’s ability to fulfill its responsibilities.

5. Urgent Need for Reform:

Thank you for your attention to this urgent matter. I am hopeful that, together, we can ensure a brighter future for the animals in our community.

Best,
Elena Mekhanoshina
****Urgent Call for reform and the APPLE VALLEY ANIMAL SHELTER*** This place cannot call themselves an animal shelter!! They are death trap for every poor animal in your county and it’s disgusting and disturbing. OƯering services to your community to HELP with their pets should be enforced to help with the crisis of stray animals in the streets. It’s not the animals fault they are put out and abandoned. We have a responsibility as the humans in this world to help them. Frankly, none of your are doing your jobs allowing this to go on.

I am writing to respectfully request the expedited sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County. The current state of the shelter and its practices have raised serious concerns regarding the treatment of cats, and I believe that transitioning control of AVAS to the county will significantly improve conditions and provide a better chance at life for all animals, especially cats.

Below, I’ve summarized the key reasons why we urgently request the sale:

1. Lack of Visibility and Minimal EƯort for Cats, Leading to High Euthanasia Rates:

2. Disparity in Treatment Between Cats and Dogs:

While AVAS posts the majority of the dogs on its website, only around 30% of cats are listed, drastically reducing their chances of being adopted or rescued.

Additionally, dogs receive vaccinations within 3 days of intake, while cats often wait for weeks.

3. Questionable Labeling and Euthanasia Practices:

AVAS has been labeling many cats as "unadaptable" without proper evaluation, and these cats are kept in the back areas of the shelter, out of sight.

4. Accountability and Transparency:

The lack of transparency in how cats are labeled and euthanized is concerning and undermines public trust in the shelter’s ability to fulfill its responsibilities.

5. Urgent Need for Reform:

Thank you for your attention to this urgent matter. I am hopeful that, together, we can ensure a brighter future for the animals in our community. -Bernadette Cortez
Sent from my iPhone
Dear Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to respectfully request the expedited sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County. The current state of the shelter and its practices have raised serious concerns regarding the treatment of cats, and I believe that transitioning control of AVAS to the county will significantly improve conditions and provide a better chance at life for all animals, especially cats.

Below, I’ve summarized the key reasons why we urgently request the sale:

1. Lack of Visibility and Minimal EƯort for Cats, Leading to High Euthanasia Rates:

2. Disparity in Treatment Between Cats and Dogs:

While AVAS posts the majority of the dogs on its website, only around 30% of cats are listed, drastically reducing their chances of being adopted or rescued.

Additionally, dogs receive vaccinations within 3 days of intake, while cats often wait for weeks.

3. Questionable Labeling and Euthanasia Practices:

AVAS has been labeling many cats as "unadaptable" without proper evaluation, and these cats are kept in the back areas of the shelter, out of sight.

4. Accountability and Transparency:

The lack of transparency in how cats are labeled and euthanized is concerning and undermines public trust in the shelter’s ability to fulfill its responsibilities.

5. Urgent Need for Reform:

Thank you for your attention to this urgent matter. I am hopeful that, together, we can ensure a brighter future for the animals in our community.

Regards,
Elaine Tam
Dear Apple Valley Town Council Members and San Bernardino County Supervisors, I am writing to express deep concern about the systemic issues at Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) regarding the treatment of cats. The shelter practices reveal troubling trends that demand immediate action.

I recently became aware of the AVAS and the high risk of cats and dogs being euthanized at the facility. I in turn submitted an application to rescue 4-5 cats (and attached a list of others that I would be willing to take if they were on the euthanization list as I have a large property and could have taken them and fostered until homes were found). My application was approved for 4 cats in August 2024, they were to be sent the following day (over a week later) to be spayed/neutered. On the pickup day I received a call that 2 of the 4 cats I was adopting were exposed to Paneluk - why are cats that are approved for adoption still left in the same room with animals coming into the shelter, they should be separated for their health in order to be going to a new home. All 4 of the cats were still transported to Bear Valley Vet - so now in reality all of the cats I was adopting were exposed as well as any others and everyone at the vet's oƯice. I ended up taking the 2 that they claimed had not been exposed, and after 4 days of quarantining them at my house 1 passed away with no signs or symptoms of anything (eating and normal stool) - I feel that possibly mishandling during the spay procedure (as I heard of another cat passing a few days earlier with similar circumstance). I received a call a week after not taking the other 2 to see if I still wanted to adopt them, after losing the one, I didn't feel that it would be right to take them if they could possibly be exposed as they claimed - it broke my heart to put them back into the shelter, but I couldn't risk this other kitten and my current cats anymore than I already had. I still have this baby quarantined, and it is horrible that I can't even provide this baby any comfort as I have to take precautions of others being exposed. Everyday I see non stop posts of the animals in this shelter on a euthanization list and it has gotten to be so alarming and concerning for the well being of these animals that are put in this situation, there are places and rescues out there, and other ways to handle the influx of incoming animals. They need to do better by these animals and the community to provide alternatives to the situation instead of how it seems to be happening.

1.Lack of Visibility and Minimal EƯort for Cats contribute to high euth rate:

Many cats are kept in the back at AVAS, facing euthanasia without ever being posted online.

AVAS has been labeling the majority cats as "unadoptable," with many of them being kittens after policy update since Sep.1, euthanizing them without proper evaluation, and hiding them from public view.
 Live Release Rate for Cats per AVAS monthly report:
 Nov : 31.6%: In Nov, 96 cats euthanized, and 12 more died in the shelter  None of these 108 cats were posted online or included in the daily urgent list, eƯectively condemning them to a hidden death
 Dec: 31.8%: In Dec, only 26 intaken cats posted
 114 cats euthanized without being posted
 Cats ever listed on the AVAS Website as of Feb.21.2025:
 Feb Intake: 17
 Jan Intake: 25
 While AVAS posts the number of daily intakes, they aren't actually listing the cats.  Only 2 of the cats taken to AVAS after 2/13 have been posted on their website.
 If AVAS claims their website reflects real-time data, why are these cats missing from the listings? How is it that they have the daily intake numbers but choose not to post them on the AVAS website?
 There are still 15 cats with intake date DEC.2024 stuck in the backend not posted
This lack of visibility, delayed vaccinations, and minimal eƯort reflects systemic neglect and an apparent disregard for cats’ welfare.

2. Disparity in Treatment Between Cats and Dogs
There is significant room for improvement in how AVAS treats the animals . However, the disparity between how cats and dogs are handled at AVAS is particularly concerning. It is evident that the shelter has the capacity to improve.

Take November Disposition Report as an example:
 Live Release Rate:
 Dogs: 87% , live intake 323 total (excluding dead on arrival, Euthanized: 41, Died at shelter: 1).
 Cats: 31.6%, live intake 158 total (excluding dead on arrival, Euthanized: 96, Died at shelter: 12).
 On average, less than 30% of cats are posted on the AVAS website, severely limiting their chances of adoption.
 Majority of dogs, including those in "holding" or "receiving" areas, are posted on the AVAS website, providing them with greater adoption opportunities.  Vaccination Delays:
 Dogs are vaccinated within 3 days of intake, providing timely health protection.  Cats, however, are vaccinated 3 weeks after intake, leaving them vulnerable to illness and further diminishing their chances of survival.

Transparency and equal visibility are critical for all shelter animals. Cats deserve the same chance at adoption and rescue.

3. Questionable Labeling and Euthanasia Standards:

The evaluation process is nominal at best, and many cats are euthanized unnecessarily
AVAS has been labeling the majority cats as "unadaptable," these cats are kept out of sight in the back and often face euthanasia without ever being posted online - they were held in the backend with 0 visibility given not even posted on the AVAS website and euthanized directly.

Since the cat intake policy update in September, the majority of cat intakes have been kittens—generally easy to socialize
 In nearby shelters within the same county, over 75% of cats are labeled as friendly, yet at AVAS, 68 cats were euthanized as "not adoptable" in November alone.  Additionally, 24 cats were euthanized for health reasons, despite the absence of a full-time veterinarian on-site.
 Cats are largely confined to the back-end areas of the shelter, where minimal resources and eƯorts are allocated to them.
 Volunteers and rescues are denied access to these areas, leaving the majority of cats unseen and ultimately euthanized without a fair chance.

We demand accountability for the decisions leading to the mass mislabeling and euthanasia of cats at AVAS:
 Who is making these decisions?
 What qualifications do they have?
 Why are so many cats being labeled as "not adoptable" or killed for minor health conditions?
An immediate investigation is needed to address these failures. The personnel responsible for labeling and contributing to this continuous massive unnecessary euthanasia must be held accountable.

We call for the immediate replacement of personnel responsible for these decisions and replacing personnel who have contributed to this mass euthanasia.

5. Lack of Essential Programs and Resources for Cats
While the county’s TNVR program is expanding, Apple Valley City still does not have a TNVR program, and has been prioritizing eƯiciency over life saving eƯorts in shelter practice
 No Trap-Neuter-Return (TNR) Program: This is critical for managing community cat populations and preventing overcrowding.
 No Low-Cost Spay/Neuter Program: Expanding access to aƯordable spay/neuter services would significantly reduce shelter intake.

Without these programs, AVAS perpetuates a cycle of unnecessary euthanasia.

6. Urgent Requests for Reform
The practices at AVAS are a betrayal of the public trust and a failure to fulfill the responsibilities of a taxpayer-funded shelter.

The shelter's treatment of cats—hiding them from public view, delaying vaccinations, mislabeling their adaptability, and euthanizing them without eƯort to save them—is unacceptable.

We demand accountability, reform, and transparency to ensure AVAS becomes a place where all animals, including cats, are given a fair chance at life.

To address these issues, we respectfully request:

1. Transparency:
 Require AVAS to list all cats and dogs on its website, including those in holding and receiving areas within 3 days of intake.
 Grant access to authorized volunteers to take videos and photos of those cats in non-adoption areas to increase visibility and promote adoptions.

2. Accountability:
 We request for replacement of the current shelter management and key stakeholders involved in systemic neglect and misuse of euthanasia practices.

3. Resources for Cats:
 Allocate qualified resources to ensure timely vaccinations, proper evaluations, and medical care for all cats.
 Prohibit euthanasia of animals without documented evaluation by qualified personnel.
 Prioritize medical care and adoption eƯorts over euthanasia.

4. Routing cats from unincorporated areas to Devore/ Big Bear Animal Shelter until reforms are enacted in AVAS.

5. Implement Trap-Neuter-Vaccinate-Return (TNVR) Program for community cats  TNVR/ Free spay and neuter services for community cats is desperately needed in Apple Valley Town. We strongly urge the initiation of a TNVR program specifically for community cats.
 This approach is not only cost-eƯective but also directly addresses the overpopulation issue at its root by preventing future litters and improving the health of the local cat population.
 With many community members struggling to aƯord veterinary care, TNVR would be a sustainable solution to manage the growing number of stray and feral cats, ultimately reducing shelter intake and preventing overcrowding  Through the TNR program friendly cats will be taken to the shelter for adoption and others will be released back to the community where they come from.

6. Establish a Low-Cost Spay-Neuter Service complemented by a TNVR program for long-term sustainability
 With the average income in Apple Valley below $25,000 per year, many residents find it financially diƯicult to provide basic care for their pets, including spay/neuter services. AƯordable options are crucial for ensuring responsible pet ownership and preventing unintended litters.

It feels as though AVAS is putting in the bare minimum eƯort to meet legal requirements while neglecting the actual care of these animals. Killing seems to be the most convenient option for them, as they continue to prioritize expediency over life-saving eƯorts. This approach is not just neglect; it’s a system designed to fail these animals, resulting in their needless deaths. I also feel that the way they are mishandling the exposure of Paneluk is abuse to these animals, they need to sanitize and quarantine appropriately. Subjecting animals to disease is neglectful and abusive, it is already horrible that they are coming into a terrifying situation and then to die from a horrible painful disease is just abuse! AVAS needs to take immediate action to address these shortcomings, ensure proper evaluations, provide medical care, and allow for transparency by granting volunteers access to non-adoption areas. The community and these animals deserve better.

Thank you for your attention to these urgent matters. I look forward to seeing positive changes that benefit both the animals and our community.

Please do what is right and protect these voiceless animals from the abuse and harm of AVAS…they deserve better than this, and did not ask for this mistreatment.

Sincerely,
Stefany Zimmerman
Dear Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to respectfully request the expedited sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County. The current state of the shelter and its practices have raised serious concerns regarding the treatment of cats, and I believe that transitioning control of AVAS to the county will significantly improve conditions and provide a better chance at life for all animals, especially cats.

Below, I’ve summarized the key reasons why we urgently request the sale:

1. Lack of Visibility and Minimal EƯort for Cats, Leading to High Euthanasia Rates:

2. Disparity in Treatment Between Cats and Dogs:

3. Questionable Labeling and Euthanasia Practices:

AVAS has been labeling many cats as "unadaptable" without proper evaluation, and these cats are kept in the back areas of the shelter, out of sight.

4. Accountability and Transparency:

The lack of transparency in how cats are labeled and euthanized is concerning and undermines public trust in the shelter’s ability to fulfill its responsibilities.

5. Urgent Need for Reform:

Thank you for your attention to this urgent matter. I am hopeful that, together, we can ensure a brighter future for the animals in our community.

Shanshan Zhao
Please please on behalf of the animals at your shelter, overhaul this nightmare facility ASAP! It is run like a summer camp with no attention to trying to get impounded animals out alive! The majority of cats who enter are never listed online and are labeled "feral" which is of course not true in most cases, and most are sent to hidden back rooms where the public cannot see them! It is absolutely unconscionable.

Thank you,
Linda Abbott
Dear Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to respectfully request the expedited sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County. The current state of the shelter and its practices have raised serious concerns regarding the treatment of cats, and I believe that transitioning control of AVAS to the county will significantly improve conditions and provide a better chance at life for all animals, especially cats.

Below, I’ve summarized the key reasons why we urgently request the sale:

1. Lack of Visibility and Minimal EƯort for Cats, Leading to High Euthanasia Rates:

At AVAS, many cats are hidden from public view, facing euthanasia without ever being posted online. This lack of visibility, coupled with delayed vaccinations and minimal eƯort to evaluate and rehome cats, has contributed to an alarmingly high euthanasia rate. - For instance, in November 2024, the live release rate for cats was only 31.6%, with 96 cats euthanized and 12 dying in the shelter. These cats were never posted on the shelter’s website or included in any adoption eƯorts, eƯectively condemning them to a hidden death. The shelter’s failure to make these animals visible to the public is a form of systemic neglect.

2. Disparity in Treatment Between Cats and Dogs:

3. Questionable Labeling and Euthanasia Practices:

AVAS has been labeling many cats as "unadaptable" without proper evaluation, and these cats are kept in the back areas of the shelter, out of sight.

4. Accountability and Transparency:

The lack of transparency in how cats are labeled and euthanized is concerning and undermines public trust in the shelter’s ability to fulfill its responsibilities.

5. Urgent Need for Reform:

Transparency: Require AVAS to list all cats and dogs on the website, including those in holding and receiving areas, within 3 days of intake.

Accountability: Replace the current management and staƯ responsible for the mismanagement of shelter practices.

Resources for Cats: Allocate suƯicient resources to ensure timely vaccinations, proper evaluations, and medical care for all cats.

Establish TNVR and Low-Cost Spay/Neuter Services: Implement a TNVR program and a low-cost spay/neuter program to address the root causes of overpopulation and overcrowding.

Thank you for your attention to this urgent matter. I am hopeful that, together, we can ensure a brighter future for the animals in our community.

Best,
Bette Grau.

Dear Apple Valley Town Council Member,
I am writing to respectfully request the expedited sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County. The current state of the shelter and its practices have raised serious concerns regarding the treatment of cats, and I believe that transitioning control of AVAS to the county will significantly improve conditions and provide a better chance at life for all animals, especially cats.

Below, I’ve summarized the key reasons why we urgently request the sale:

1. Lack of Visibility and Minimal EƯort for Cats, Leading to High Euthanasia Rates:

At AVAS, many cats are hidden from public view, facing euthanasia without ever being posted online. This lack of visibility, coupled with delayed vaccinations and minimal eƯort to evaluate and rehome cats, has contributed to an alarmingly high euthanasia rate. - For instance, in November 2024, the live release rate for cats was only 31.6%, with 96 cats euthanized and 12 dying in the shelter. These cats were never posted on the shelter’s website or included in any adoption eƯorts, eƯectively condemning them to a hidden death. The shelter’s failure to make these animals visible to the public is a form of systemic neglect.

2. Disparity in Treatment Between Cats and Dogs:

3. Questionable Labeling and Euthanasia Practices:

AVAS has been labeling many cats as "unadaptable" without proper evaluation, and these cats are kept in the back areas of the shelter, out of sight.

4. Accountability and Transparency:

The lack of transparency in how cats are labeled and euthanized is concerning and undermines public trust in the shelter’s ability to fulfill its responsibilities.

5. Urgent Need for Reform:

Transparency: Require AVAS to list all cats and dogs on the website, including those in holding and receiving areas, within 3 days of intake.

Accountability: Replace the current management and staƯ responsible for the mismanagement of shelter practices.

Resources for Cats: Allocate suƯicient resources to ensure timely vaccinations, proper evaluations, and medical care for all cats.

Establish TNVR and Low-Cost Spay/Neuter Services: Implement a TNVR program and a low-cost spay/neuter program to address the root causes of overpopulation and overcrowding.

Thank you for your attention to this urgent matter. I am hopeful that, together, we can ensure a brighter future for the animals in our community.

Best,
Bette Grau.

Agregar reacción
Dear Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to respectfully request the expedited sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County. The current state of the shelter and its practices have raised serious concerns regarding the treatment of cats, and I believe that transitioning control of AVAS to the county will significantly improve conditions and provide a better chance at life for all animals, especially cats.

Below, I’ve summarized the key reasons why we urgently request the sale:

1. Lack of Visibility and Minimal EƯort for Cats, Leading to High Euthanasia Rates:

At AVAS, many cats are hidden from public view, facing euthanasia without ever being posted online. This lack of visibility, coupled with delayed vaccinations and minimal eƯort to evaluate and rehome cats, has contributed to an alarmingly high euthanasia rate. - For instance, in November 2024, the live release rate for cats was only 31.6%, with 96 cats euthanized and 12 dying in the shelter. These cats were never posted on the shelter’s website or included in any adoption eƯorts, eƯectively condemning them to a hidden death. The shelter’s failure to make these animals visible to the public is a form of systemic neglect.

2. Disparity in Treatment Between Cats and Dogs:

3. Questionable Labeling and Euthanasia Practices:

AVAS has been labeling many cats as "unadaptable" without proper evaluation, and these cats are kept in the back areas of the shelter, out of sight.

4. Accountability and Transparency:

The lack of transparency in how cats are labeled and euthanized is concerning and undermines public trust in the shelter’s ability to fulfill its responsibilities.

5. Urgent Need for Reform:

Transparency: Require AVAS to list all cats and dogs on the website, including those in holding and receiving areas, within 3 days of intake.

Accountability: Replace the current management and staƯ responsible for the mismanagement of shelter practices.

Resources for Cats: Allocate suƯicient resources to ensure timely vaccinations, proper evaluations, and medical care for all cats.

Establish TNVR and Low-Cost Spay/Neuter Services: Implement a TNVR program and a low-cost spay/neuter program to address the root causes of overpopulation and overcrowding.

Thank you for your attention to this urgent matter. I am hopeful that, together, we can ensure a brighter future for the animals in our community.

Sincerely,
Connie V Stinson
Dear Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to respectfully request the expedited sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County. The current state of the shelter and its practices have raised serious concerns regarding the treatment of cats, and I believe that transitioning control of AVAS to the county will significantly improve conditions and provide a better chance at life for all animals, especially cats.

Below, I’ve summarized the key reasons why we urgently request the sale:

1. Lack of Visibility and Minimal EƯort for Cats, Leading to High Euthanasia Rates:

At AVAS, many cats are hidden from public view, facing euthanasia without ever being posted online. This lack of visibility, coupled with delayed vaccinations and minimal eƯort to evaluate and rehome cats, has contributed to an alarmingly high euthanasia rate. - For instance, in November 2024, the live release rate for cats was only 31.6%, with 96 cats euthanized and 12 dying in the shelter. These cats were never posted on the shelter’s website or included in any adoption eƯorts, eƯectively condemning them to a hidden death. The shelter’s failure to make these animals visible to the public is a form of systemic neglect.

2. Disparity in Treatment Between Cats and Dogs:

3. Questionable Labeling and Euthanasia Practices:

AVAS has been labeling many cats as "unadaptable" without proper evaluation, and these cats are kept in the back areas of the shelter, out of sight.

4. Accountability and Transparency:

The lack of transparency in how cats are labeled and euthanized is concerning and undermines public trust in the shelter’s ability to fulfill its responsibilities.

5. Urgent Need for Reform:

Transparency: Require AVAS to list all cats and dogs on the website, including those in holding and receiving areas, within 3 days of intake.

Accountability: Replace the current management and staƯ responsible for the mismanagement of shelter practices.

Resources for Cats: Allocate suƯicient resources to ensure timely vaccinations, proper evaluations, and medical care for all cats.

Establish TNVR and Low-Cost Spay/Neuter Services: Implement a TNVR program and a low-cost spay/neuter program to address the root causes of overpopulation and overcrowding.

Thank you for your attention to this urgent matter. I am hopeful that, together, we can ensure a brighter future for the animals in our community.

Best,
Allyanne rigoli Redd
Submitting public comments for the March 25th Apple Valley Town Council meeting.

To the Apple Valley Town Council Members, Mayor, Town Manager… You probably are tired of seeing people comment about the Apple Valley shelter and its practices.

You don’t feel there are any issues.

You feel the shelter is well run and nothing needs to change.

You feel the complaints are unfounded.

You feel the criticism is harsh, unnecessary and personally oƯensive.

Would it be unreasonable to say, it seems that a large majority of residents feel diƯerently than you do about the shelter?
If it’s okay to share, it doesn’t feel like the public will stop feeling as strongly as they do about the issues surrounding the shelter.

The public will not stop feeling as strongly as they do over shelter management, shelter practices and shelter protocols.

Public pressure and sentiment will force change.

What’s the reason the town council is so resistant to implementing any spay and neuter programs for residents? What’s the reason the town council doesn’t want to make any changes to how the shelter is run? What is so important that the shelter’s practices, protocols remain exactly the same as they always have? Change is inevitable.

You have probably heard of the sunk cost fallacy. The phenomenon whereby a person is reluctant to abandon a strategy or course of action because they have invested heavily in it, even when it is clear that abandonment would be more beneficial.

It feels like this is a perfect analogy for the shelter. The town is running at a deficit and the shelter is a financial drain on the town and a burden.

Selling it seems to be the town’s best solution.

I encourage the town council to sell and transition ownership to the county as soon as possible.

To a swift and quick transition of ownership of AVAS to San Bernardino County, Margaret Cashion
Good morning,I want to share my experience recently too the shelter ..in search of my missing kitty upon my arrival I addressed the reason for my visit and gave a description of my cat being their are NO cats in the adoption area ..I seen from the awful picture taken of a cat looking similar to mine ..the receptionist had no knowledge of the black cat listed on there site ..she then asks me where do I reside I mentioned too her my residing town ..she assumed since the cat was picked up ..in apple valley ..that the cat could not be mine ..which is not true bc past existence..my older cat was ..dumped in apple valley ...by a passer bye ..who was in town for the hamners in Johnson valley so do to that ..Its a possibility..that anyone ..could ..she never attempted to go look at the cat ..the second day I visited..a picture was taken from my phone by another employee which 40 min later ..decided it wasn't my cat while I sat n patiently waited .they had 1 black cat listed how hard was it to identify? I asked to take a look I was told only if they felt my pic was a match that they would bring the cat out for me too see ! Idk n will never know .bc of their lack of interest ..how inhuman is that .? He' was later unlisted ..n no one knows .what happened too him ..thank you for your time ..filled with sadness n no hope ..bc of uncaring human beings ..

Business buildings are being built in the Jess Ranch area while business building are abandoned on the North side of Apple Valley. What’s going on here??? Why isn’t the north side of Apple Valley utilized and its buildings occupied when Jess Ranch area has buildings being built at empty lots?!
The north side is becoming a ghost town!
Sent from my iPhone
Dear Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to respectfully request the expedited sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County. The current state of the shelter and its practices have raised serious concerns regarding the treatment of cats, and I believe that transitioning control of AVAS to the county will significantly improve conditions and provide a better chance at life for all animals, especially cats.

Below, I’ve summarized the key reasons why we urgently request the sale:

1. Lack of Visibility and Minimal EƯort for Cats, Leading to High Euthanasia Rates:

At AVAS, many cats are hidden from public view, facing euthanasia without ever being posted online. This lack of visibility, coupled with delayed vaccinations and minimal eƯort to evaluate and rehome cats, has contributed to an alarmingly high euthanasia rate. - For instance, in November 2024, the live release rate for cats was only 31.6%, with 96 cats euthanized and 12 dying in the shelter. These cats were never posted on the shelter’s website or included in any adoption eƯorts, eƯectively condemning them to a hidden death. The shelter’s failure to make these animals visible to the public is a form of systemic neglect.

2. Disparity in Treatment Between Cats and Dogs:

3. Questionable Labeling and Euthanasia Practices:

AVAS has been labeling many cats as "unadaptable" without proper evaluation, and these cats are kept in the back areas of the shelter, out of sight.

The adoption area has been empty for more than one month from Feb until Mar.21, which means all cats has been labeled as "feral" or "not able to be handled".

Since a policy change in September 2024, the intake of kittens, which are generally easy to socialize, has increased. However, AVAS has been euthanizing large numbers of these kittens without giving them a fair chance for adoption. In November alone, 68 cats were euthanized for being "unadoptable," and 24 others were euthanized for "health ", despite the lack of an on-site veterinarian. This suggests a serious failure in the shelter’s evaluation and care processes, and a culture of euthanasia out of convenience rather than necessity.

4. Accountability and Transparency:

The lack of transparency in how cats are labeled and euthanized is concerning and undermines public trust in the shelter’s ability to fulfill its responsibilities.

5. Urgent Need for Reform:

Transparency: Require AVAS to list all cats and dogs on the website, including those in holding and receiving areas, within 3 days of intake.

Accountability: Replace the current management and staƯ responsible for the mismanagement of shelter practices.

Resources for Cats: Allocate suƯicient resources to ensure timely vaccinations, proper evaluations, and medical care for all cats.

Establish TNVR and Low-Cost Spay/Neuter Services: Implement a TNVR program and a low-cost spay/neuter program to address the root causes of overpopulation and overcrowding.

Thank you for your attention to this urgent matter. I am hopeful that, together, we can ensure a brighter future for the animals in our community.

With Regards,
Shirin Shamloo
Dear Apple Valley Town Council Members,

Something incredibly disturbing has been brought to my attention.

I am writing to respectfully request the expedited sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County. The current state of the shelter and its practices have raised serious concerns regarding the treatment of cats, and I believe that transitioning control of AVAS to San Bernardino County will significantly improve conditions and provide a better chance at life for all animals, especially cats.

Below, I’ve summarized the key reasons why I urgently request the sale:

1. Lack of Visibility and Minimal EƯort for Cats, leading to High Euthanasia Rates- At AVAS, many cats are hidden from public view, facing euthanasia without ever being posted online.

This lack of visibility, coupled with delayed vaccinations and minimal eƯort to evaluate and rehome cats, has contributed to an alarmingly high euthanasia rate. * For instance, in November 2024, the live release rate for cats was only 31.6%, with 96 cats euthanized and 12 dying in the shelter. These cats were never posted on the shelter’s website or included in any adoption eƯorts, eƯectively condemning them to a hidden death. The shelter’s failure to make these animals visible to the public is a form of systemic neglect.

2. Disparity in Treatment Between Cats and Dogs- While AVAS posts the majority of the dogs on its website, only around 30% of cats are listed, drastically reducing their chances of being adopted or rescued. Additionally, dogs receive vaccinations within 3 days of intake, while cats often wait for weeks.

3. Questionable Labeling and Euthanasia Practices- AVAS has been labeling many cats as "unadoptable" without proper evaluation, and these cats are kept in the back areas of the shelter, out of sight. Since a policy change in September 2024, the intake of kittens, which are generally easy to socialize, has increased. However, AVAS has been euthanizing large numbers of these kittens without giving them a fair chance for adoption. In November alone, 68 cats were euthanized for being "unadoptable," and 24 others were euthanized for "health" issues, despite the lack of an on-site veterinarian. This suggests a serious failure in the shelter’s evaluation and care processes, and a culture of euthanasia out of convenience rather than necessity.

4. Accountability and Transparency- The lack of transparency in how cats are labeled and euthanized is concerning and undermines public trust in the shelter’s ability to fulfill its responsibilities.

5. Urgent Need for Reform- The current practices at AVAS betray the public’s trust and fail to meet the expectations of a taxpayer-funded shelter. I demand immediate reform to ensure that all animals, including cats, are given a fair chance at life. This includes:

A)Transparency- Require AVAS to list all cats and dogs on the website, including those in holding and receiving areas, within 3 days of intake.

B)Accountability- Replace the current management and staƯ responsible for the mismanagement of shelter practices.

C)Resources for Cats- Allocate suƯicient resources to ensure timely vaccinations, proper evaluations, and medical care for all cats.

D)Establish TNVR (trap, neuter, vaccinate, return) and Low-Cost Spay/Neuter Services to address the root causes of overpopulation and overcrowding.

E)Use funds that were allocated to the shelter for certain programs (ie: TNVR), for those programs.

If serious reform does not happen immediately, I respectfully urge the Apple Valley Town Council to expedite the sale of AVAS to San Bernardino County. This county has the resources, infrastructure, and commitment to animal welfare needed to address these issues and provide a better future for the animals of Apple Valley.

Thank you for your attention to this urgent matter. I am hopeful that, together, we can ensure a brighter future for the animals in our community.

Best regards,
Julie Letzer
The description of the Technical Writers' position is good, but I think it could be more inclusive. We can look at the words and phrases used in the description and say that they are technically being inclusive. Like the word “staƯ” “users” “consumers” can technically be labeled as inclusive because these terms can include anyone really. However, by not addressing the specific terms writers can inadvertently mis-represent or exclude people with disabilities.

I would add specific language to the content provided,
Technical writers, .... to communicate complex technical information in an accessible way.

Assess the needs... to ensure accessibility and clarity.

Collect user feedback....to improve content and ensure it meets the needs of all audiences.

I would also make sure to add acronyms like FAQ after frequently asked questions.

The last sentence in particular should also be more of a focus. In a world where most information in provided in an online format its not as simple as creating documents in an accessible way to present online. What does it mean to make online contect accessible? So instead of
Increasingly, technical information is delivered online and through social media. Technical writers use the interactive technologies of the Web and social media to blend text, graphics, multidimensional images, sound, and video.

I would rewrite to make it more clear what is being addressed to make it more inclusive and accessible to everyone.

As digital and social media platforms become more important technical writers must adapt by utilizing interactive technologies to create inclusive content. By blending text, graphics, images, sound, and video writers engage diverse audiences, making sure that the information is accessible to everyone, regardless of ability or background.

When writing we must remember that we can sometimes be the first line change for people. We can help create a more inclusive world through our writing and can encourage change in other industries.

Subject: Request for Expedited Sale of AVAS to San Bernardino County Dear Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to respectfully request the expedited sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County. The current state of the shelter and its practices have raised serious concerns regarding the treatment of cats, and I believe that transitioning control of AVAS to the county will significantly improve conditions and provide a better chance at life for all animals, especially cats.

Below, I’ve summarized the key reasons why we urgently request the sale:

1. Lack of Visibility and Minimal EƯort for Cats, Leading to High Euthanasia Rates:

2. Disparity in Treatment Between Cats and Dogs:

3. Questionable Labeling and Euthanasia Practices:

AVAS has been labeling many cats as "unadaptable" without proper evaluation, and these cats are kept in the back areas of the shelter, out of sight.

4. Accountability and Transparency:

The lack of transparency in how cats are labeled and euthanized is concerning and undermines public trust in the shelter’s ability to fulfill its responsibilities.

5. Urgent Need for Reform:

Thank you for your attention to this urgent matter. I am hopeful that, together, we can ensure a brighter future for the animals in our community.

Sincerely,
Beth Hunt,
concerned citizen
P.S. Both of the cats I have had over the last few years have been Rescue cats, and they required some degree of socialization, but they have adjusted and turned out to be good pets. Our current indoor/outdoor cat's mother was most likely a barn cat, as we rescued him oƯ of the road when he was a kitten. Many 'feral' cats make great barn cats or ranch cats, as long as they have shelter in the winter.

As well, with love and patience, many cats will grow in their trust for kind humans and can be adopted.

I personally feel that unless a cat is sick with an illness that is highly contagious or very diƯicult to treat, has a severe medical condition or injury, is elderly with serious health issues, or is unusually aggressive and poses a danger to other animals or humans in the community, the cat should NOT be killed. There is no logical reason to kill healthy animals.

Banning breeding and buying, enforcing spay/neuter, and opening more shelters while working with Rescues and the community or regional/national organizations, to transport healthy cats to other locations where they can be adopted or cared for is the answer.

I would also like to inquire what the city of Apple Valley is doing with the bodies of the many younger, healthy cats they euthanize, and if they are being sold to a third party brokers for profit, as the cadavers can be used for dissection in biological/life sciences courses at colleges and universities (medical/veterinary schools) and in biomedical research laboratories. If this is the case, it is unethical.

Thankyou for reading my additional comments,
Beth Hunt
Dear Apple Valley Town Council Members,
For the past year, I have been following and donating to rescuers as they desperately work to rescue cats from the Apple Valley Animal Shelter, cats that are never made visible to the public, yet prove to be friendly, adoptable cats once in foster care. I have also been a part of that community that has had their heart broken over cases that are objectively those of neglect to the point of cruelty. Case in point, a young kitten was surrendered recently after her owner was found deceased. This baby had apparently gone without food or water for days, yet was never provided fluid therapy or the special nutritional care that is standard protocol for such cases. She too, died, alone, surely suƯering, while rescuers and those who support them, anxiously prayed she could somehow hang on until her release date.

This level of neglect is animal cruelty in my opinion, and I'm sure I'm not alone. It is also, sadly, not an isolated case at this shelter.

For these reasons, I am writing to respectfully request the expedited sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County. AVAS is apparently unable or unwilling to properly care for the vast majority of cats that come through its doors and is therefore violating the public trust and possibly the shelter laws of the state. The County has significantly more resources to materially improve conditions, especially for cats and can provide a far greater chance at life for all animals in need.

I agree with the following key reasons why we urgently request the sale:

1. Lack of Visibility and Minimal EƯort for Cats, Leading to High Euthanasia Rates: At AVAS, many cats are hidden from public view, facing euthanasia without ever being posted online. This lack of visibility, coupled with delayed vaccinations and minimal eƯort to evaluate and rehome cats, has contributed to an alarmingly high euthanasia rate.
 For instance, in November 2024, the live release rate for cats was only 31.6%, with 96 cats euthanized and 12 dying in the shelter. These cats were never posted on the shelter’s website or included in any adoption eƯorts, eƯectively condemning them to a hidden death. The shelter’s failure to make these animals visible to the public is a form of systemic neglect.

1. Disparity in Treatment Between Cats and Dogs: While AVAS posts the majority of the dogs on its website, only around 30% of cats are listed, drastically reducing their chances of being adopted or rescued. Additionally, dogs receive vaccinations within 3 days of intake, while cats often wait for weeks.

2. Questionable Labeling and Euthanasia Practices: AVAS has been labeling many cats as "unadaptable" without proper evaluation, and these cats are kept in the back areas of the shelter, out of sight. Since a policy change in September 2024, the intake of kittens, which are generally easy to socialize, has increased. However, AVAS has been euthanizing large numbers of these kittens without giving them a fair chance for adoption. In November alone, 68 cats were euthanized for being "unadoptable," and 24 others were euthanized for "health" issues, despite the lack of an on-site veterinarian. This suggests a serious failure in the shelter’s evaluation and care processes, and a culture of euthanasia out of convenience rather than necessity.

3. Accountability and Transparency: The lack of transparency in how cats are labeled and euthanized is concerning and undermines public trust in the shelter’s ability to fulfill its responsibilities.

4. Urgent Need for Reform: The current practices at AVAS betray the public’s trust and fail to meet the expectations of a taxpayer-funded shelter. We demand immediate reform to ensure that all animals, including cats, are given a fair chance at life. This includes:
 Transparency: Require AVAS to list all cats and dogs on the website, including those in holding and receiving areas, within 3 days of intake.  Accountability: Replace the current management and staƯ responsible for the mismanagement of shelter practices.
 Resources for Cats: Allocate suƯicient resources to ensure timely vaccinations, proper evaluations, and medical care for all cats.
 Establish TNVR and Low-Cost Spay/Neuter Services: Implement a TNVR program and a low-cost spay/neuter program to address the root causes of overpopulation and overcrowding.

Thank you for your attention to this urgent matter. I am hopeful that, together, we can ensure a brighter future for the animals in our community.

Best regards,
Liz Cook
Dear Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to respectfully request the sale of Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County as soon as possible.

Over the past year, I have become aware of the shelter's alarmingly high euthanasia rates for cats. Many cats are hidden from public view, denied timely veterinary care (due to lack of on-site veterinarian), and labeled as "unadoptable" without proper evaluation. It is incomprehensible that so many cats and kittens require euthanasia for health and behavioral issues, especially kittens who are much easier to socialize than adult cats.

Unlike dogs, who are posted online and vaccinated promptly, most cats remain invisible and vulnerable. While the majority of dogs that come into the shelter are listed on the website, this only happens for about 30 percent of the shelter's cats, greatly reducing their chances of finding a loving home.

I respectfully urge the Apple Valley Town Council to expedite the sale of AVAS to San Bernardino County, which has the resources and infrastructure to implement necessary reforms, including transparent listings, timely medical care, and programs such as TNVR or low-cost spay/neuter clinics to address overpopulation. Immediate action is essential to protect the welfare of the animals in this community.

Thank you for your attention to this urgent matter.

Warm Regards,
Elizabeth Henson

Apple Valley City CouncilMarch 25, 2025

Apple Valley City Council
March 25, 2025