Public Comments — Apple Valley City Council, July 22, 2025

JULY 22, 2025

TOWN COUNCIL PUBLIC COMMENTS
This is Luanne Yancy with Open Arms Rescue and I pull under several other rescues as well.

Im alarmed that you are considering closing the shelter! What will happen to the dogs and cats in your area? I understand there maybe a possibility of the shelter being taken over by another shelter system? Will the staƯ remain with Apple Valley if so? So many rescues have built a fantastic working relationship with Brandie Lee who works tirelessly for the animals ....she needs to remain on staƯ. Brandie contacts those of us in rescue constantly and brings to our attention those animals who are in danger of euthanasia....I can't count how many animals she has saved from death, wonderful...loving animals who would not be here now if it weren't for her eƯorts to get them out! The rescue needs Brandie Lee and your shelter! We need to be given the opportunity to continue to help the animals of your shelter! We will not still our voices! This shelter must remain part of the community and Brandie Lee must remain as rescue coordinator!
Sincerely,
Luanne Yancy
I hope that this doesn’t happen to the animals and to the people that live in av . We love animals our kids love them too !!!! DO NOT LET THIS HAPPEN NO SALE TO COUNTY !!!

WHAT A MISTAKE YOU CITY COUNCIL HAVE MADE GRAVE MISTAKES ALREADY WE THE PEOPLE Of APPLE VALLEY DO NOT WANT THIS SALE !!!
Dear Town Council member of Apple Valley, dear supervisors of San Bernardino County, We're writing to urge immediate oversight of Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS).  In 2023, the live release rate for cats at AVAS was just 7%  In 2024, it’s only risen to around 21%
 In April 2025, over 100 cats were euthanized — but only 5 were listed online  In May 2025, just 5 cats were labeled as friendly and moved to the adoption floor The Shelter Is in Transition — But the Animals Still Need Protection.

We’re encouraged that the County’s purchase of AVAS may be finalized in the next 60 days.

In 2023, the live release rate for cats at AVAS was just 7% In 2024, it’s only risen to around 21%
In April 2025, over 100 cats were euthanized — but only 5 were listed online In May 2025, just 5 cats were labeled as friendly and moved to the adoption floor The Shelter Is in Transition — But the Animals Still Need Protection.

We’re encouraged that the County’s purchase of AVAS may be finalized in the next month.

We believe that a County takeover of AVAS will bring greater transparency and a muchneeded improvement in animal welfare. Under the County’s current animal care system:
 All cat/dog intakes are posted online the same day
 Cats/dogs are vaccinated the same day they enter the shelter  Volunteers are allowed to take photos and videos of the animals to help network them
 Community cat TNVT program is better established even though the volume needs to be expanded
 The County animal care team is significantly more supportive and cooperative with rescue eƯorts
But the animals can’t wait for reform to start after the deal closes. We Urge Immediate Action:
 Review current shelter practices and staƯ performance  Establish and enforce clear standards for humane care and accurate animal assessments
Please take our urge into consideration when making your decision on Tuesday.

Thank you,
Sherry Wu
Resident of 1642 Stanford, Irvine, California
Dear Town Council member of Apple Valley, dear supervisors of San Bernardino County, We're writing to urge immediate oversight of Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS).

We’re encouraged that the County’s purchase of AVAS may be finalized in the next month.

Carmine Guillen
711 davidson ave 92411
To whom it may concern:

Strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

Reasons for having this position:

It is a financially smart move for the Town of Apple Valley. The town, despite its eƯorts, cannot financially aƯord the shelter. For the past 15+ years number of staƯ has increased, costs have increased, results are the same, contention among the residents and the public has increased due to lack of improvements.

AVAS has a very high euthanasia rate. Probably one of the highest in the nation. The county has more money, more financial means to implement protocols, standards and programs to work towards making improvements that will improve the statistics.

County has a 75 - 80% Live Release Rate, while AVAS has a 45 - 50% Live Release Rate for dogs and a 7% live release for cats.

County does not charge a Spay/Neuter deposit for rescues. County has a record of attracting more rescues to assist in helping animals.

County is Closed 9 days a year, while AVAS is closed 124 days a year. More days open equal increased access to rescues and adopters and more chances for animals to have a more beneficial outcome.

County has evening hours (until 7:30pm), while AVAS closes at 4pm. Increased hours accommodate the public’s schedules more.

County has more and better relationships with their rescue partners, over 400+ rescues have aƯiliated with County run shelters. While many rescues who worked with AVAS have stated unfriendly practices make AVAS too diƯicult.

County has a great relationship and open communication with Networkers, while AVAS rescue staƯ have demonstrated an unwillingness to work with non-rescue individuals. If networkers ask AVAS staƯ questions, front desk are unable to help and rescue staƯ response has been… “networkers are not aƯiliated with an individual rescue therefore no information can be given.” Versus the County realizes all individuals participating provide a benefit to the ultimate outcome at the shelter. We must all work together to improve this societal issue.

County has a licensed behaviorist, who provides extensive written feedback, notes and comments on the animals. AVAS does not have a behaviorist on staƯ, 95% of cats are labeled feral/fractious. Which is statistically impossible. Repeated requests for information about temperament of an animal have been denied. StaƯ, management and town council seem unwilling to make changes and despite AVAS being a publicly funded shelter.

Big Bear Animal Shelter has not euthanized in 8+ years, Devore statistics prior to September 2024 are as follows: (roughly) 50% of cats rescued, 20% of cats adopted, 10% of cats returned to owner.

County has 2-3 licensed veterinarians and can aƯord to pay for full time vets. AVAS and TOAV are unable and unwilling to add this crucial position onto their roster and budget. It’s the equivalent of running a hospital with no doctors. AVAS “Health techs” and Registered vet technicians are not licensed veterinarians and therefore not qualified to make complex medical decisions. Euthanizing cats for “possible ringworm exposure” is one example.

Cats/kittens at AVAS are euthanized based unprofessional assessments of health and behavior versus standardized protocols and procedures instituted at County level.

Opponents to the sale seem unwilling to look at the data supplied by AVAS. The data speaks for itself.

Opponents to the sale seem to think “volume of animals would increase dramatically.”Whether it does or doesn’t, what is the concern behind this concern? If it increases, then the County will address it as they have in the past at county run shelters.

The county will allot more money and have more resources to work towards tackling increase in intakes.

Opponents of the sale want to “keep things local.” The town council over and over has been unwilling (despite public pressure) to make policy changes/improvements/modifications.

In addition, the town council refuse to allot funds for something as impactful as subsidized spay and neuter programs, or enforced microchipping of dogs or punishing unlicensed breeders.

Opponents to the sale feel that “the shelter is trying their best.” The shelter has been operating in a robotic form… intake the animals, publicly display less than 20% of those animals coming into the shelter, hold for legal time limit then euthanize. Day in and day out.

It’s been a stalled approach. Any outspoken individual are thought to be contentious, diƯicult, unreasonable. There has been no big picture thinking. Why in the last 15+ years hasn’t the AVAS management appealed to the town council and presented an argument to help with the overpopulation. Why hasn’t the AVAS management pleaded for a TNVR program? Why hasn’t AVAS management insisted the town create programs for residents need for spay & neuter or vaccines or microchipping? The town council repeatedly stated they support AVAS staƯ. Why not leverage that relationship? It feels like it’s been status quo for 15+ years and it’s time for a complete overhaul, which is why the sale to the county will benefit all residents of the town and the county.

Opponents to the sale of the shelter seem to feel threatened that their jobs are at stake. In fact they will be transitioned and become employees of the county which is equal and/or a remarkable improvement. Their salaries remain intact and have more opportunities for career advancement, raises, 401ks, health benefits. It is a win for staƯ.

We ask for you to vote yes in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Sincerely,
Laura Schencker
Sent from my iPhone
AVAS Needs Immediate Oversight — The Animals Can’t Wait Dear Town Council member of Apple Valley, dear supervisors of San Bernardino County, I’m a former resident of Apple Valley and I have done rescue from this area for over thirty years. Starting with VVAPL. I graduated in 1987 from Apple Valley High. I am heartbroken that the situation has not improved and is actually worse than 30+ years ago.

The situation has got to change now. StaƯ needs to be changed now. Systems need to be changed now.

I’m writing to urge immediate oversight of Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS).  In 2023, the live release rate for cats at AVAS was just 7%  In 2024, it’s only risen to around 21%
 In April 2025, over 100 cats were euthanized — but only 5 were listed online  In May 2025, just 5 cats were labeled as friendly and moved to the adoption floor The Shelter Is in Transition — But the Animals Still Need Protection.

We’re encouraged that the County’s purchase of AVAS may be finalized in the next 60 days.

We’re encouraged that the County’s purchase of AVAS may be finalized in the next month.

Thank you for your time,
Marce Einstein
San Bernardino County Resident
PO BOX 7263
Redlands, CA 92375
Dear Mayor and Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to strongly urge you to vote YES on the proposed sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County at the upcoming Town Council meeting.

The data speaks for itself — AVAS is failing.
 In 2023, the cat live release rate was just 7%.
 In 2024, despite the dedicated eƯorts of community members and networkers, the rate had barely risen to around 21%, still among the lowest in the country.  Most cats at AVAS are kept in the back and mislabeled as "feral," even when they are adoptable. Many are euthanized without any public exposure or rescue eƯort.  For example, in April 2025 alone, over 100 cats were euthanized, yet only 5 of them were ever listed online for public view.

Despite repeated public outcry and documented concerns from community members, transparency and accountability remain absent. There is no full-time veterinarian, no licensed behaviorist, and no low-cost spay/neuter services in a town where the average annual income is under $25,000.

Even promising eƯorts have been abandoned — such as the pilot TNVR program, launched briefly in Q2 2025 but paused on June 30 and never resumed, leaving community members and cats in limbo once again.

The County of San Bernardino oƯers hope.

Unlike AVAS, County-run shelters vaccinate all animals on intake, post all intakes online the same day, and work with over 400 rescue partners. They have multiple licensed veterinarians on staƯ, allowing volunteers to photograph animals to increase their adoption chances. Maintain a cat live release rate of over 75%, even in 2023 under an open admission policy, a stark contrast to AVAS's dismal record.

County supervisors and Animal care team actively listens to the community, and continues to improve policies. In recent months, they’ve implemented impactful programs such as the TNVR program for community cats (which is expected to keep expanding), and the foster program which would save many under aged kittens.

In contrast, AVAS continues to conceal animals from the public and operate in crisis mode.

This is not just a staƯing issue — it is a systemic failure.

Transferring AVAS to the County is not just a change of management — it’s a chance at life for thousands of animals.

Opponents of this sale claim the shelter is “trying its best.” But “trying” is not enough when lives are at stake. The truth is: for 15+ years, AVAS has operated in a broken loop — hide the cats, label them unadoptable, euthanize quietly. The Town has failed to enact basic reforms, even when publicly funded to do so. The result is one of the highest cat euthanasia rates in California, fueled by poor visibility, poor policy, and a pattern of indiƯerence.

Enough is enough.

This is your opportunity to end the cycle of secrecy and suƯering. With this vote, you can replace dysfunction with transparency, cruelty with care, and hopelessness with a future.

This sale is not about politics or pride — it is about life and death. The animals at AVAS can’t aƯord to wait any longer.

Please vote YES to finalize the transfer of AVAS to San Bernardino County. Let this be the turning point — where we choose compassion, transparency, and progress.

Thank you.

Emily Sotelo.

Dear Mayor and Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to strongly urge you to vote YES on the proposed sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County at the upcoming Town Council meeting.

The County of San Bernardino oƯers hope.

In contrast, AVAS continues to conceal animals from the public and operate in crisis mode.

This is not just a staƯing issue — it is a systemic failure.

Transferring AVAS to the County is not just a change of management — it’s a chance at life for thousands of animals.

Enough is enough.

This is your opportunity to end the cycle of secrecy and suƯering. With this vote, you can replace dysfunction with transparency, cruelty with care, and hopelessness with a future.

This sale is not about politics or pride — it is about life and death. The animals at AVAS can’t aƯord to wait any longer.

Please vote YES to finalize the transfer of AVAS to San Bernardino County. Let this be the turning point — where we choose compassion, transparency, and progress.

Thank you.

Your Name
Dear Mayor and Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to strongly urge you to vote YES on the proposed sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County at the upcoming Town Council meeting.

The data speaks for itself — AVAS is failing.
- In 2023, the cat live release rate was just 7%.
- In 2024, despite the dedicated eƯorts of community members and networkers, the rate had barely risen to around 21%, still among the lowest in the country. - Most cats at AVAS are kept in the back and mislabeled as "feral," even when they are adoptable. Many are euthanized without any public exposure or rescue eƯort.

For example, in April 2025 alone, over 100 cats were euthanized, yet only 5 of them were ever listed online for public view.

The County of San Bernardino oƯers hope.

In contrast, AVAS continues to conceal animals from the public and operate in crisis mode.

This is not just a staƯing issue — it is a systemic failure.

Transferring AVAS to the County is not just a change of management — it’s a chance at life for thousands of animals.

Enough is enough.

This is your opportunity to end the cycle of secrecy and suƯering. With this vote, you can replace dysfunction with transparency, cruelty with care, and hopelessness with a future.

This sale is not about politics or pride — it is about life and death. The animals at AVAS can’t aƯord to wait any longer.

Please vote YES to finalize the transfer of AVAS to San Bernardino County. Let this be the turning point — where we choose compassion, transparency, and progress.

With Regards,
Shirin Shamloo
I am in favor and urge San Benardino County to complete the purchase of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter as soon as possible.

This shelter seems to have a history of inhumane treatment to the animals, substandard care and horrible unjustified killing of the animals. This is NOT the road to a NO KILL status. Animal shelters need caring, compassionate, skilled personnel to complete the task.

Please be fair to the helpless animals and fix this!
Camilla G.

Dear Apple Valley, CA City Council Members, government oƯicials who oversee animal welfare, and concerned citizens / members of the community:

Here is the verbiage for a petition that was circulated in the past year to encourage the sale of the AVAS facility to San Bernardino County:
"The Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) does not have the structure in place to take in the volume from SBC. Animals are being sent to AVAS lacking proper care and exposure to potential rescuers/adopters, resulting in animals being killed prematurely and unnecessarily.

AVAS, presented a plan to improve/expand the shelter in anticipation of the contract renewal with SBC for $1+ Million Annually:
1) The new contract commenced in July 2023, and AVAS has yet to implement most of the proposed changes. Rather than expand the kennel space, they reduced their kennel space, thereby giving the animals less time to be saved. UPDATE: New Kennel Unit was finally ordered in October with the $80K in additional funds from SBC, but still not in operation 9 months into the contract.
2) AVAS proposed plan included hiring a behaviorist to socialize the dogs and provide vital behavior notes for rescues/adopters. No behaviorist on staƯ 4 months into the contract! UPDATE: Behaviorist was hired, but most of the animals don’t have behavioral notes because the animals get killed too quickly.
3) AVAS proposed plan included hiring a PR/Networker to help provide exposure to the animals. Instead, their social media sites are blocking volunteer networkers who have been critical of their operations. UPDATE: PR/Networker has been posting photos and videos on AVAS Facebook pages, but the videos/photos are taken down once the dogs are pending euthanasia—at the most critical time, when they should be seen. 4) The former Director of AVAS was pursuing her career as a Celebrity Photographer and was rarely there to oversee the shelter operations. (The new director is still struggling to handle the number of intakes or control viral outbreaks, and they still resort to mass euthanasia on a weekly basis with insuƯicient networking or community outreach.) 5) The Rescue Coordinator is not able to handle the volume, missing important emails/phone calls from rescues and providing erroneous data about the animals, resulting in more animals being killed. UPDATE: The Rescue Coordinator makes the networkers “jump through hoops” in order to obtain the status of unlisted dogs, instead of posting a public “Euth List,” letting everyone know which animals are pending euthanasia. It has taken over 24 hours to find out the status, and by then animals were already killed. The Rescue Coordinator job description includes assisting with euthanasia, and requires a euthanasia certificate.
6) Most towns in SB County do not know that county animals are being sent to AVAS.

Because of their expedited kill rate, dog/owners are not able to find their animals in time.

UPDATE: the Volume from SBC is greater than 60%! More than 5,000 animals have come through AVAS since the contract commenced in July 2023! 7) The Mayor and City Council of Apple Valley are in full support of AVAS and therefore refuse to listen to the public, or require the shelter to improve their operations. UPDATE: the Town Manager, Doug Robertson, who signed the contract for Apple Valley, received a raise the day the contract commenced…earning almost $25k/monthly! 8) AVAS is in BREACH of the contract, Section N, that requires them to make all animals visible to the public. Most animals (especially cats) do not even make it onto the site, so there is no record of what the animals looked like before they’re killed. Some animals are uploaded onto the site after being there almost a week, and then killed a few days later while the owners could still be searching for them.

AVAS misrepresented themselves and their ability to handle the volume from SBC, therefore the contract MUST BE CANCELLED! Those animals deserve a shelter that cares about saving their lives, instead of the $1+ Million that SBC is paying them.

SBC Board of Supervisors approved $45 Million for building a new shelter last year. The new shelter structure should be
expedited! The animals must be
redirected to shelters who can handle the volume and possess a greater desire to help save their lives! The animals of SBC need YOUR help! Please give them a chance at life with people who truly want to save them. SBC Board of Supervisors, please cancel the AVAS contract ASAP!
As well, here is the petition update as of 7/20/2025:

The contract AVAS had with San Bernardino County is coming to an end.

This is a vital action for the animals of San Bernardino County! The way to hold AVAS accountable is to end this contract.

With this contract ending, the Town of Apple Valley will not be able to aƯord the salaries of the AVAS Shelter director and high paid staƯ, and will therefore be forced to have a RIF and shelter staƯ will need to focus more on adoptions, licensing and vaccinations to keep the facility operating.

As the County is interested in purchasing the AVAS facility, in my humble opinion, that would actually be the BEST CASE scenario for the animals in San Bernardino County.

The facility of AVAS was built in 2010 with the intention of expanding the space (there is a vast amount of land around the original building) in order to be able to accommodate more animals comfortably and not be forced to euthanize for space.

However, the Town of Apple Valley chose not to utilize the space and were content with killing animals for space.

For the first 10 years of the county contract, they were paid around 500 thousand dollars annually, and then negotiated a $1 million dollar + annual payment from San Bernardino County to continue taking in the unincorporated county animals.

The contract stated that the county animals were to be accepted without exception, which forced AVAS to halt intake of AV animals…despite the fact that they had the space to take them all in. I guess they didn’t want to work as hard or keep the animals much longer than they were required to by law. I mean they were all being paid well, had ALL holidays oƯ (including 5 days over Thanksgiving and 10 days over Christmas and New Year’s), and all they had to do was continue taking in the county animals and killing them for space. Their sanitation practices have also been dismal, with numerous parvo and distemper outbreaks. I would say that 90% of the dogs who exited alive, had at minimum a kennel cough.

So, San Bernardino County has been in negotiations with the Town of Apple Valley to purchase the facility of AVAS for over a year now.

The town of Apple Valley has made attempts to stall the process, and the staƯ at AVAS has become very vocal against the sale.

Why you may ask?
The contract that was extended between SB County and AVAS in June of 2024 included an amendment requiring the employees at AVAS to shadow the staƯ at the Devore Animal Shelter, so they were able to see first hand how hard the staƯ at Devore worked, and the open lines of communication the Devore staƯ had with their rescue partners and networkers.

AVAS staƯ in contrast have built up a very poor reputation with rescues and networkers.

It appears they do not want to be held accountable by the County, and would prefer to continue euthanizing large numbers of innocent dogs and cats.

I am urging everyone to speak up now IN FAVOR of this sale, if you care about the welfare of the animals of San Bernardino County.

While the County is currently building a new shelter in Bloomington that is scheduled to open in late 2027,
the current need for the animals of the county for housing, rescue, and care is growing exponentially by the day.

If the county takes over the property/facility at AVAS, they would be able to expand it and make room for more animals. We have a horrific animal overpopulation crisis, and if we need to reach a “No-Kill” status in the county, we firstly need more space for the animals. " Thank you for reading these comments from the petition and subsequent update in favor of the sale of Apple Valley Animal Services to San Bernardino County, written by Animal Welfare Advocate Veronica Golub.

I am inclined to agree with her statements, as she is a passionate animal lover, as I am, and understands that this is a matter of stewardship over God's beloved dogs and cats, who are loving, loyal, intelligent, sentient beings deserving of our care and protection, and are part of our vulnerable populations.

Our beloved companion animals are NOT 'livestock' to be 'culled', nor are they a commodity to be bred, bought, and sold for profit, or killed for convenience or when they get sick due to lack or proper vaccinations.

To dove tail on that,
I personally feel that their city council needs to pass emergency ordinances to protect companion animals and start taking decisive action to improve the situation.

As well, awareness campaigns need to be run, and the community needs to get involved to help solve this problem.

Our beloved companion animals are God's property, and they are neither disposable nor expendable.

Dogs are not only man's best friends, but they are God's guardians that he has put in our midst to protect, support, and help us, and we need to be good stewards of them.

If other localities in California and the U.S. are experiencing the same (or similar) problems with their companion animal populations and committing mass euthanasia as well, it is still morally wrong and an aƯront to our creator with regard to his beloved creatures, and it doesn't make it any less
deplorable or reprehensible.

The excuse "other towns have been doing it too" did not cut it when the Americans liberated prisoners from concentration camps in Nazi Germany at the end of World War Il, and residents of the nearby towns were asked how they could not know what was really going on, or condone this kind of conduct in their own backyard.

On the same token, just because this town is not the only place an America experiencing these problems or guilty of this kind of heartless conduct does NOT excuse it in the eyes of God, or in the eyes of anyone with a moral compass.

1. A state of emergency needs to be declared for companion animals in the region.

2. An emergency ban on breeding and buying needs to be enacted, for an a minimum of 2 years,
or possibly ban breeding altogether in this jurisdiction.

3. Emergency spay-neuter and vaccination ordinances need to be enacted with stiƯ penalties for noncompliance, and multilingual publication so that local pet owners are aware.

4. Landlords need to be required to allow well-behaved pets, with caps on extra fees and rent.

5. A community veterinary clinic needs to be established and opened to the public with spay-neuter, vaccination,
internal and external parasite control, and basic checkups available to low income pet owners who qualify along with licensing and microchipping services, as well as on-line or phone interpreter services, applications available in multiple languages, and mobile vans deployed to reach outlying areas. (A legal resident of the United States would need to present and register as the legal owner of a dog or cat for these services on behalf of anyone who undocumented.)

6. The luxury tax or sales tax could be used to expand funding for animal welfare.

7. An empty building with the proper amenities could be loaned out to an animal Welfare/Rescue organization like Best Friends, the Humane Society, the PAW Mission or the SPCA, to create a second emergency overflow shelter in this town.

8. Healthy adoptable Animals should be put on rescue transport out of the area to other shelters and Rescues in other locations where they can be adopted and fostered.

Thank you,
Beth Hunt, dog and cat lover, and follower of the online Networking sites for Apple Valley cats and dogs, who is tired of seeing so many of them euthanized weekly and monthly.

Caveat: This is crushing my soul. Please make it STOP.

Thank you, and God Bless those who are taking decisive action to save the lives of these innocent dogs and cats in this community.

You are standing on the side of what is good, true, and right.

Keep standing up for our innocent companion animals. Thank you for not giving up, as God is on your side, as they are ultimately HIS beloved creatures, and this is a matter of STEWARDSHIP.

Dear Town Council member of Apple Valley, dear supervisors of San Bernardino County, We're writing to urge immediate oversight of Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS).

We’re encouraged that the County’s purchase of AVAS may be finalized in the next month.

Cindy Hernandez
711 davidson ave 92411
Dear Town Council member of Apple Valley, dear supervisors of San Bernardino County, We're writing to urge immediate oversight of Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS).

We’re encouraged that the County’s purchase of AVAS may be finalized in the next month.

Max Hernandez
2667 Irvington Ave, San Bernardino, CA 92407
Dear Mayor and Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to strongly urge you to vote YES on the proposed sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County at the upcoming Town Council meeting.

The County of San Bernardino oƯers hope.

In contrast, AVAS continues to conceal animals from the public and operate in crisis mode.

This is not just a staƯing issue — it is a systemic failure.

Transferring AVAS to the County is not just a change of management — it’s a chance at life for thousands of animals.

Enough is enough.

This is your opportunity to end the cycle of secrecy and suƯering. With this vote, you can replace dysfunction with transparency, cruelty with care, and hopelessness with a future.

This sale is not about politics or pride — it is about life and death. The animals at AVAS can’t aƯord to wait any longer.

Please vote YES to finalize the transfer of AVAS to San Bernardino County. Let this be the turning point — where we choose compassion, transparency, and progress.

Thank you.

Alexandra Kallas
Sent from my iPhone
Dear Mayor and Apple Valley Town Council Members,

I am writing to strongly urge you to vote YES on the proposed sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County at the upcoming Town Council meeting.

The data speaks for itself — AVAS is failing.
 In 2023, the cat live release rate was just 7%.

 In 2024, despite the dedicated eƯorts of community members and networkers, the rate had barely risen to around 21%, still among the lowest in the country.  Most cats at AVAS are kept in the back and mislabeled as "feral," even when they are adoptable. Many are euthanized without any public exposure or rescue eƯort.  For example, in April 2025 alone, over 100 cats were euthanized, yet only 5 of them were ever listed online for public view.

The County of San Bernardino oƯers hope.

In contrast, AVAS continues to conceal animals from the public and operate in crisis mode.

This is not just a staƯing issue — it is a systemic failure.

Transferring AVAS to the County is not just a change of management — it’s a chance at life for thousands of animals.

Enough is enough.

This is your opportunity to end the cycle of secrecy and suƯering. With this vote, you can replace dysfunction with transparency, cruelty with care, and hopelessness with a future.

This sale is not about politics or pride — it is about life and death. The animals at AVAS can’t aƯord to wait any longer.

Please vote YES to finalize the transfer of AVAS to San Bernardino County. Let this be the turning point — where we choose compassion, transparency, and progress.

Thank you,

Sara CioƯi
To whom it may concern,
I hope this email finds you well. I am reaching out prior to the council meeting scheduled for 7/22 in hopes of urging the council to allow for the sale of AVAS to the county. This will allow for more animals in the area to be saved from unnecessary euthanasia. With a growing pandemic of homeless animals, let’s do right by the voiceless.

Thank you for your consideration,
Brett Gaswirth
Dear Councilmembers,
I’m writing to express my strong support for the sale of the AVAS facility to San Bernardino County.

This transfer would be a critical step toward improving conditions for animals in the community. The County has the resources and commitment to expand the facility, increase lifesaving eƯorts, and provide the care and transparency the animals deserve.

Please move forward with this sale. The animals of San Bernardino County are counting on it.

Sincerely,
Melanie Maras
Los Angeles, CA
Dear Mayor and Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to strongly urge you to vote YES on the proposed sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County at the upcoming Town Council meeting.

The County of San Bernardino oƯers hope.

In contrast, AVAS continues to conceal animals from the public and operate in crisis mode.

This is not just a staƯing issue — it is a systemic failure.

Transferring AVAS to the County is not just a change of management — it’s a chance at life for thousands of animals.

Enough is enough.

This is your opportunity to end the cycle of secrecy and suƯering. With this vote, you can replace dysfunction with transparency, cruelty with care, and hopelessness with a future.

This sale is not about politics or pride — it is about life and death. The animals at AVAS can’t aƯord to wait any longer.

Please vote YES to finalize the transfer of AVAS to San Bernardino County. Let this be the turning point — where we choose compassion, transparency, and progress.

Thank you.

Sincerely,
Mandy Gustafson
Dear Mayor and Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to strongly urge you to vote YES on the proposed sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County at the upcoming Town Council meeting.

The County of San Bernardino oƯers hope.

In contrast, AVAS continues to conceal animals from the public and operate in crisis mode.

This is not just a staƯing issue — it is a systemic failure.

Transferring AVAS to the County is not just a change of management — it’s a chance at life for thousands of animals.

Enough is enough.

This is your opportunity to end the cycle of secrecy and suƯering. With this vote, you can replace dysfunction with transparency, cruelty with care, and hopelessness with a future.

This sale is not about politics or pride — it is about life and death. The animals at AVAS can’t aƯord to wait any longer.

Please vote YES to finalize the transfer of AVAS to San Bernardino County. Let this be the turning point — where we choose compassion, transparency, and progress.

Thank you for your attention ion this matter.

Sincerely, Dana Cohen.

The County of San Bernardino oƯers hope.

In contrast, AVAS continues to conceal animals from the public and operate in crisis mode.

This is not just a staƯing issue — it is a systemic failure.

Transferring AVAS to the County is not just a change of management — it’s a chance at life for thousands of animals.

Enough is enough.

This is your opportunity to end the cycle of secrecy and suƯering. With this vote, you can replace dysfunction with transparency, cruelty with care, and hopelessness with a future.

This sale is not about politics or pride — it is about life and death. The animals at AVAS can’t aƯord to wait any longer.

Please vote YES to finalize the transfer of AVAS to San Bernardino County. Let this be the turning point — where we choose compassion, transparency, and progress.

Thank you.

Iris Sommer
To Whom it May Concern,

Hello,
This change of animal care and holding for adoption is near and dear to my heart. My experiences haven't always been positive. For a multi-million dollar beautiful building, the employees have been there a long time and have not been good for the animals involved.

I currently have two cats I acquired from AVAS, and I have had others prior. One of these cats, my mother owned, she barely was able to save, because they tried to hide her in the back. My mom refused to leave without her. That was ridiculous . I also have been attached to several more, that even though I informed them of interest, they put down before I came back to adopt.

I had other incidents of over vaccinations of dogs we acquired there, animal control taking pets out of yards, and vaccinating done multiple times, nearly killing the animals.

This has been a span of over 20 years. It needs to stop. I hope all those that currently work there that worked there for a long time, especially the man who has run it this whole time, are fired and investigated. Maybe down the road it can start over with better people, but as of now, it's been a death sentence for mostly cats. Please close that place and send to San Bernardino County shelter.

Thank you,
Connie Stinson
Please vote yes these poor animals need help be there voice they don’t have one ! I am writing to express grave concerns regarding the alarming rise in euthanasia rates and the ongoing issues at Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS). The situation has reached a critical point, with dozens of cats losing their lives everyday without proper evaluation or consideration for alternatives like adoption or rescue.

No improvement shown even though intake dropped significantly from 325 in August to 182 in September. Live release rate for cats in Sep is as low as 13%. This lack of visibility contributes significantly to the high euthanasia rate.
 As of October 15, about 20% of the cat intaken in Sep has been posted on the AVAS website v.s. 100% of the dog intake posted
 In August 2024 237 cats were euthanized, out of this, 198 (83%) of the cats never showed up on the website for the public to see.
 Out of 182 cats taken in during September 2024, only 34 were listed on the website, while 75 were marked as “hold” and 65 were euthanized.

AVAS has significantly neglected its eƯorts on the cat side, and the outcomes for AVAS cats in 2024 may mirror those of 2023 (only 7% cats made it out alive out of 3469 intake in 2023) :
 I am deeply troubled with what I have read about this shelter! I am writing to respectfully request the expedited sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County. The current state of the shelter and its practices have raised serious concerns regarding the treatment of cats, and I believe that transitioning control of AVAS to the county will significantly improve conditions and provide a better chance at life for all animals, especially cats.

Sincerely,
Suzanne Parodi
A resounding yes. Sell. AVAS does a horrible job. StaƯ have no compassion Sent from my iPhone
Dear Council Members,
I beg of you to VOTE YES on the AVAS sale to SB County.

AVAS is failing and too many cats are losing their lives.

In 15 years it's only gotten worse. It's not working. Spay & Neuter must be taken seriously to address our crisis of more pets than homes.

PLEASE Vote YES
Sincerely, Cat Edwards
Dear Town of Apple Valley Council Members,
This communication is in support of SELLING the shelter to San Bernardino County.

I'm a lawyer by day, one-person animal rescue by night. I've battled your town attorney and his associate for a few years over practices at that shelter that I felt were illegal. I became a rescue specifically to have a better understanding of issues at your shelter, and I worked with your rescue team quite a bit, until I was suspended on June 2025 because I had too many outstanding spay and neuter certificates. This is the only shelter that enforces this policy, but this is not the only shelter I rescue dogs from. By law, as a rescue I'm bound by the same law that the shelter is regarding spay and neuter of intact animals prior to adoption, and given my exhaustion and complete mental and emotional defeat from the overwhelming pet population I do take my duty seriously. However, complying with your shelter is not as simple as declaring an animal was sterilized; it's not even as easy as just producing the evidence. Rather, the documentation needs to conform to the shelter's requirement of what must be stated on the certificate, which means lots of editing of a photo to note everything. I don't have time for that, so I have stopped trying to submit them and get reinstated. I did oƯer to provide declarations under the penalty of perjury that the oƯered certificate purports to be for the dog as represented, which would have been easier for me to do. They denied my request. Let it be known that I am in good company with all the other rescues that have been suspended from the shelter. You should ask the shelter how many rescues are active and current with them.

Worse than not being able to rescue AVAS dogs is the undeniable fact that there are many shelters I can rescue from that are easier to work with to save a dog, including San Bernardino County, so there's really no incentive for me to work with AVAS again. And I'm not the only rescue that feels this way. Rescuing animals from AVAS is also expensive compared to rescuing from the County. Ultimately, there's no real incentive to rescue your animals over those at any other shelter in the Inland Empire area. Rescues continue to rescue from your shelter because we feel really, really bad for your animals.

A big part of the AVAS problem is the policies of the shelter that have been handed down from years of leadership under the former director, and are now being carried on by the current director and staƯ. Many of us had hoped that with the retirement of Gina Whiteside it would have been a new dawn at the shelter, that staƯ would be excited to try some new policies and procedures to see if it yielded better results for your animals. Sadly, nothing has changed, and if anything it has gotten worse. If you eliminate the contract with the county, then you will reduce part of your issue which is the overpopulation problem arising from county dogs coming into your shelter. However, the staƯ will remain under the same policies and procedures that they currently operate by. And that itself is the biggest reason to complete the sale of the shelter to the county, because your staƯ are too stuck in the past and lack vision and ability to eƯect change. If they are under the thumb of the county, then presumably policies of the County would become the policies of this shelter, and you will see a much better rate of live exits than you currently do now.

Selling the shelter to the County will be in the best interest of the animals, who are currently caught in this wicked game between shelter staƯ who have their own interests at heart, and your constituents who just want to see your shelter do better by the animals.

Robin Unander
Attorney at Law /
Kennels 2 Couches
PO Box 41821
Santa Barbara, CA 93140
Tel (805) 450-1010
Dear Council Members,
I urge you to vote YES to finalize the transfer of Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County.

The data is clear: AVAS is failing. In 2023, the cat live release rate was just 7%. In 2024, even with community help, it rose only to 21%. Most cats are mislabeled as "feral," hidden from the public, and euthanized without a chance. In April alone, over 100 cats were killed — but just 5 were listed online.

There’s no full-time vet, no behaviorist, and no spay/neuter access for a town where most people earn under $25K a year. Even the pilot TNVR program was paused in June and never resumed.

In contrast, San Bernardino County shelters post every intake, vaccinate all animals on entry, and maintain a 75%+ live release rate. They’ve launched a foster program, expanded TNVR with a mobile clinic, and work with over 400 rescues.

AVAS has had 15+ years to change. It hasn’t. This is not about politics — it’s about life and death.

Please vote YES to give these animals the second chance they deserve.

Thank you for your attention to the matter,
Elena Mekhanoshina
Dear Mayor and Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to strongly urge you to vote YES on the proposed sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County at the upcoming Town Council meeting.

The County of San Bernardino oƯers hope.

In contrast, AVAS continues to conceal animals from the public and operate in crisis mode.

This is not just a staƯing issue — it is a systemic failure.

Transferring AVAS to the County is not just a change of management — it’s a chance at life for thousands of animals.

Enough is enough.

This is your opportunity to end the cycle of secrecy and suƯering. With this vote, you can replace dysfunction with transparency, cruelty with care, and hopelessness with a future.

This sale is not about politics or pride — it is about life and death. The animals at AVAS can’t aƯord to wait any longer.

Please vote YES to finalize the transfer of AVAS to San Bernardino County. Let this be the turning point — where we choose compassion, transparency, and progress.

Thank you.

Leonor Delgado
To Whom it May Concern,
I am writing to you to express that I am strongly in support of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

I ask for you to vote yea in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Sincerely,
Melissa Kachura
Dear Council Members,
I urge you to vote YES to finalize the transfer of Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County.

The data is clear: AVAS is failing. In 2023, the cat live release rate was just 7%. In 2024, even with community help, it rose only to 21%. Most cats are mislabeled as “feral,” hidden from the public, and euthanized without a chance. In April alone, over 100 cats were killed — but just 5 were listed online.

There’s no full-time vet, no behaviorist, and no spay/neuter access for a town where most people earn under $25K a year. Even the pilot TNVR program was paused in June and never resumed.

AVAS has had over 15 years to change. It hasn’t. This is not about politics — it’s about life and death.

Please vote YES to give these animals the second chance they deserve.

Thank you,
Andrea Andrade
To whom it may concern,
I am strongly in favor of you selling the shelter to the county for the following reasons:
 Current staƯ is incompetent in several ways
o Exorbitantly high euthanasia rates
o Neglect of animals - nearly all young kittens die in the shelter, many many cats pass due to treatable conditions, there are CONSTANT DEADLY outbreaks, such a panleuk and parvo
o Severe lack of communication skills with anybody trying to help animals - rescuers, networkers, potential adopters, etc
 Current staƯ is downright malicious in several ways
o Not letting people look for their lost pets inside the shelter (the main argument made by those who think the shelter shouldn't be sold, completely in contradiction to reality)
o Failing to scan nearly all animals there
 We've had several cases where a rescue ends up reuniting lost pets with their owners all because staƯ couldn't be bothered to scan for a chip
 Some cats have ended up at avas multiple times, under diƯerent names, because they don't bother to scan for a chip
 One owner was missing their cat for several months, despite them working DOWN THE STREET FROM THE SHELTER, because they didn't bother to scan for a chip
o Not a single cat has been present at their big adoption days, while staƯ back at the shelter are busy mass euthanizing them instead of mass adopting them out
I've been monitoring the website as well as publicly available data (such as the intake/disposition reports) over the last few months and here's some of the significant takeaways I've found of the awful behavior present at this shelter:
 Among the 1,678 cats that entered the shelter since October 2024, only 438 were listed on the site (26%)
 Although rescue was the most likely outcome for these cats (19.4%), the bulk of these (50%+) were lethal categories (Dead on arrival, euthanized-not adoptable, euthanized-health, died-newborn-8wks, died-medical)
Lastly, I want to highlight a personal story of a cat named Luke. I, along with many others on social media, pledged money to get Luke rescued, as he was euth listed last year. Someone stepped up, called the shelter and told them they were driving there to adopt him and to NOT KILL HIM. I believe the potential adopter drove at least 3, if not more, hours in the middle of the week, to save this cat. But by the time they got there, they had KILLED HIM.

Why??? Because they got cats mixed up. But I think you know the real reason. And the kind of punishment these awful people should face. All should lose their jobs immediately and be banned from working in any and all animal-related positions forever.

This starts by SELLING THE SHELTER. Without a doubt. Please do this. For the stake of the animals.

Thank you for the consideration
Michael Matuszak
To Whom it May Concern,
I plead you to please follow through with sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

We ask for you to vote yes and a smooth and quick transition to the County as it will save thousands of lives in doing so.

Sincerely,
Kristen F.

To Whom it May Concern,
Strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

We ask for you to vote yea in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Sincerely,
Sarah Goodman
To Whom it May Concern,
Strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

I ask for you to vote yea in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Sincerely,
Maria
To Whom it May Concern,
Strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

We ask for you to vote yes in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Sincerely,
Reann brownfield
To Whom it May Concern,
I am strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

We ask for you to vote yes in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Sincerely,
Sandra F
To Whom it May Concern,
Strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

We ask for you to vote yes in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County. Thank you.

Sincerely,
Kim Waybourn
To Whom it May Concern,
Strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

We ask for you to vote yes in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Sincerely,
Sara Sharp
Submitting public comments for the July 22nd Apple Valley Town Council meeting To whom it may concern:

Strongly IN FAVOR OF THE SALE of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

Reasons for having this position:

1. It is a financially smart move for the Town of Apple Valley. The town, despite its eƯorts, cannot financially aƯord the shelter. For the past 15+ years number of staƯ has increased, costs have increased, results are the same, contention among the residents and the public has increased due to lack of improvements.

2. AVAS has a very high euthanasia rate. Probably one of the highest in the nation. The county has more money, more financial means to implement protocols, standards and programs to work towards making improvements that will improve the statistics.

3. County has a 75 - 80% Live Release Rate, while AVAS has a 45 - 50% Live Release Rate for dogs and a 7% live release for cats.

4. County does not charge a Spay/Neuter deposit for rescues. County has a record of attracting more rescues to assist in helping animals.

5. County is Closed 9 days a year, while AVAS is closed 124 days a year. More days open equal increased access to rescues and adopters and more chances for animals to have a more beneficial outcome.

6. County has evening hours (until 7:30pm), while AVAS closes at 4pm. Increased hours accommodate the public’s schedules more.

7. County has more and better relationships with their rescue partners, over 400+ rescues have aƯiliated with County run shelters. While many rescues who worked with AVAS have stated unfriendly practices make AVAS too diƯicult.

8. County has a great relationship and open communication with Networkers, while AVAS rescue staƯ have demonstrated an unwillingness to work with non-rescue individuals. If networkers ask AVAS staƯ questions, front desk are unable to help and rescue staƯ response has been… “networkers are not aƯiliated with an individual rescue therefore no information can be given.” Versus the County realizes all individuals participating provide a benefit to the ultimate outcome at the shelter.

We must all work together to improve this societal issue.

9. County has a licensed behaviorist, who provides extensive written feedback, notes and comments on the animals. AVAS does not have a behaviorist on staƯ, 95% of cats are labeled feral/fractious. Which is statistically impossible. Repeated requests for information about temperament of an animal have been denied. StaƯ, management and town council seem unwilling to make changes and despite AVAS being a publicly funded shelter.

10. Big Bear Animal Shelter has not euthanized in 8+ years, Devore statistics prior to September 2024 are as follows: (roughly) 50% of cats rescued, 20% of cats adopted, 10% of cats returned to owner.

11.County has 2-3 licensed veterinarians and can aƯord to pay for full time vets. AVAS and TOAV are unable and unwilling to add this crucial position onto their roster and budget. It’s the equivalent of running a hospital with no doctors. AVAS “Health techs” and Registered vet technicians are not licensed veterinarians and therefore not qualified to make complex medical decisions. Euthanizing cats for “possible ringworm exposure” is one example.

12.Cats/kittens at AVAS are euthanized based unprofessional assessments of health and behavior versus standardized protocols and procedures instituted at County level.

13. Opponents to the sale seem unwilling to look at the data supplied by AVAS. The data speaks for itself.

14. Opponents to the sale seem to think “volume of animals would increase dramatically.”Whether it does or doesn’t, what is the concern behind this concern? If it increases, then the County will address it as they have in the past at county run shelters. The county will allot more money and have more resources to work towards tackling increase in intakes.

15. Opponents of the sale want to “keep things local.” The town council over and over has been unwilling (despite public pressure) to make policy changes/ improvements/ modifications. In addition, the town council refuse to allot funds for something as impactful as subsidized spay and neuter programs, or enforced microchipping of dogs or punishing unlicensed breeders.

16. Opponents to the sale feel that “the shelter is trying their best.” The shelter has been operating in a robotic form… intake the animals, publicly display less than 20% of those animals coming into the shelter, hold for legal time limit then euthanize. Day in and day out. It’s been a stalled approach. Any outspoken individual are thought to be contentious, diƯicult, unreasonable. There has been no big picture thinking. Why in the last 15+ years hasn’t the AVAS management appealed to the town council and presented an argument to help with the overpopulation. Why hasn’t the AVAS management pleaded for a TNVR program? Why hasn’t AVAS management insisted the town create programs for residents need for spay & neuter or vaccines or microchipping? The town council repeatedly stated they support AVAS staƯ. Why not leverage that relationship? It feels like it’s been status quo for 15+ years and it’s time for a complete overhaul, which is why the sale to the county will benefit all residents of the town and the county.

17. Opponents to the sale of the shelter seem to feel threatened that their jobs are at stake. In fact they will be transitioned and become employees of the county.

We ask for you to vote YES in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Sincerely,
Margaret Cashion
Dear Council Members,
I urge you to vote YES to finalize the transfer of Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County.

There's no full-time vet, no behaviorist, and no spay/neuter access for a town where most people earn under $25K a year.

Even the pilot TVR program was paused in June and never resumed.

In contrast, San Bernardino County shelters post every intake, vaccinate all animals on entry, and maintain a 75%+ live release rate. They've launched a foster program, expanded TNVR with a mobile clinic, and work with over 400 rescues.

AVAS has had 15+ years to change. It hasn't. This is not about politics - it's about life and death.

Please vote YES to give these animals the second chance they deserve.

Thank you.

Alexander Kinder
To Whom it May Concern,
Strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

We ask for you to vote yea in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Sincerely,
Jamie Turnock
To Whom it May Concern,
Strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

We ask for you to vote yea in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Best,
Isobel
To Whom it May Concern,
Strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

We ask for you to vote yes in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Sincerely,
Mirana Nagle
To Whom it May Concern,
I am strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

We ask for you to vote yea in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Sincerely,
Jim Stuteville
To Whom it May Concern,
I am strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

We ask for you to vote yea in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Sincerely,
Kathryn Davidson
To Whom it May Concern,
I am strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

We ask for you to vote yea in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Sincerely,
Jessica Klein
Dear Mayor and Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to strongly urge you to vote YES on the proposed sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San
Bernardino County at the upcoming Town Council meeting.

The data speaks for itself — AVAS is failing.

In 2023, the cat live release rate was just 7%.

In 2024, despite the dedicated eƯorts of community members and networkers, the rate had barely risen to
around 21%, still among the lowest in the country.

Most cats at AVAS are kept in the back and mislabeled as "feral," even when they are adoptable. Many are
euthanized without any public exposure or rescue eƯort. example, in April 2025 alone, over 100 cats were euthanized, yet only 5 of them were ever listed online for public view.

Despite repeated public outcry and documented concerns from community members, transparency and
accountability remain absent. There is no full-time veterinarian, no licensed behaviorist, and no low-costspay/neuter services in a town where the average annual income is under $25,000.

Even promising eƯorts have been abandoned — such as the pilot TNVR program, launched briefly in Q2 2025
but paused on June 30 and never resumed, leaving community members and cats in limbo once again.

The County of San Bernardino oƯers hope.

Unlike AVAS, County-run shelters vaccinate all animals on intake, post all intakes online the same day, and work with
over 400 rescue partners. They have multiple licensed veterinarians on staƯ, allowing volunteers to photograph
animals to increase their adoption chances. Maintain a cat live release rate of over 75%, even in 2023 under an open
admission policy, a stark contrast to AVAS's dismal record.

County supervisors and Animal care team actively listens to the community, and continues to improve policies. In
recent months, they’ve implemented impactful programs such as the TNVR program for community cats (which is
expected to keep expanding), and the foster program which would save many under aged kittens.

In contrast, AVAS continues to conceal animals from the public and operate in crisis mode.

This is not just a staƯing
issue — it is a systemic failure.

Transferring AVAS to the County is not just a change of management — it’s a chance at life for thousands of
animals.

The Town has failed to enact basic reforms, even when publicly funded to do so. The result is one of the highest cat
euthanasia rates in California, fueled by poor visibility, poor policy, and a pattern of indiƯerence.

Enough is enough.

This is your opportunity to end the cycle of secrecy and suƯering. With this vote, you can replace dysfunction with
transparency, cruelty with care, and hopelessness with a future.

This sale is not about politics or pride — it is about life and death. The animals at AVAS can’t aƯord to wait any longer.

Please vote YES to finalize the transfer of AVAS to San Bernardino County. Let this be the turning point — where we
choose compassion, transparency, and progress.

Please help those who cannot speak for themselves.

Thank you
Rosalind Conner
To Whom it May Concern,
Strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

We ask for you to vote yea in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Sincerely,
Olivier Lord
Dear Mayor and Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to strongly urge you to vote YES on the proposed sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County at the upcoming Town Council meeting.

The County of San Bernardino oƯers hope.

In contrast, AVAS continues to conceal animals from the public and operate in crisis mode.

This is not just a staƯing issue — it is a systemic failure.

Transferring AVAS to the County is not just a change of management — it’s a chance at life for thousands of animals.

Enough is enough.

This is your opportunity to end the cycle of secrecy and suƯering. With this vote, you can replace dysfunction with transparency, cruelty with care, and hopelessness with a future.

This sale is not about politics or pride — it is about life and death. The animals at AVAS can’t aƯord to wait any longer.

Please vote YES to finalize the transfer of AVAS to San Bernardino County. Let this be the turning point — where we choose compassion, transparency, and progress.

Thank you.

Randi Litwak
To Whom it May Concern,
Strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

We ask for you to vote yes in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Sincerely,
Best,
Natasha
Natasha Ouslis, PhD
Hello,
I support the sale of AVAS to San Bernardino County
Thank you,
Danielle Meierotto
To Whom it May Concern,
Strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

We ask for you to vote yea in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Sincerely,
Hayley Ward
To whom it may concern Transfer/sell AVAS to San Bernardino County as soon as possible.

James Hurley
To Whom it May Concern,
I am strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

We ask for you to vote yes in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Sincerely,
Diana Persinger
San Bernardino County Resident and Networker
To Whom it May Concern,
Strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

We ask for you to vote yes in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Sincerely,
M. Shaw
To Whom it May Concern,
Strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

We ask for you to vote yes in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Sincerely,
Debe Waisman
Dear Mayor and Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to strongly urge you to vote YES on the proposed sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County at the upcoming Town Council meeting.

The County of San Bernardino oƯers hope.

In contrast, AVAS continues to conceal animals from the public and operate in crisis mode.

This is not just a staƯing issue — it is a systemic failure.

Transferring AVAS to the County is not just a change of management — it’s a chance at life for thousands of animals.

Enough is enough.

This is your opportunity to end the cycle of secrecy and suƯering. With this vote, you can replace dysfunction with transparency, cruelty with care, and hopelessness with a future.

This sale is not about politics or pride — it is about life and death. The animals at AVAS can’t aƯord to wait any longer.

Please vote YES to finalize the transfer of AVAS to San Bernardino County. Let this be the turning point — where we choose compassion, transparency, and progress.

Thank you,
Lemesis Reyes
To Whom it May Concern,
I am strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

We ask for you to vote yes in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Sincerely,
Shannon Moore
To Whom it May Concern,
Strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

We ask for you to vote yes in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Sincerely,
Irma Maciel
To Whom it May Concern,
I am srongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

We ask for you to please vote yes in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County. The animals of Apple Valley need your help and support.

Sincerely,
Jyll Little
To Whom it May Concern,
I am strongly in favor of the transfer of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

Please vote yes in favor of the transfer of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Sincerely,
Susan Ellis
To Whom it May Concern,
Strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

We ask for you to vote yes in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Please find humanity to being part of the solution to reconstruct the handling and care of our helpless animals. It take ALL of us to cooperate and pitch in! Sincerely,
Sandy Johnston
To Whom it May Concern,
Strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

We ask for you to vote yes in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Thank you so much,
Sincerely,
Jennie Gong.

The County of San Bernardino oƯers hope.

In contrast, AVAS continues to conceal animals from the public and operate in crisis mode.

This is not just a staƯing issue — it is a systemic failure.

Transferring AVAS to the County is not just a change of management — it’s a chance at life for thousands of animals.

Enough is enough.

This is your opportunity to end the cycle of secrecy and suƯering. With this vote, you can replace dysfunction with transparency, cruelty with care, and hopelessness with a future.

This sale is not about politics or pride — it is about life and death. The animals at AVAS can’t aƯord to wait any longer.

Please vote YES to finalize the transfer of AVAS to San Bernardino County. Let this be the turning point — where we choose compassion, transparency, and progress.

Thank you.

To Whom it May Concern,
Strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

We ask for you to vote yes in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

BR,
Jessie.

To Whom it May Concern,
Strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

We ask for you to vote yes in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Sincerely,
Ivonne Garcia
Sent from my iPhone To Whom it May Concern,
Strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

We ask for you to vote yes in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Sincerely,
Barb Capozzoli
Dear Mayor and Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to strongly urge you to vote YES on the proposed sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County at the upcoming Town Council meeting.

The data speaks for itself — AVAS is failing.
 In 2023, the cat live release rate was just 7%.
 In 2024, even with the dedicated eƯorts of community members and networkers — who only began assisting in 2024 — the rate barely rose to around 21%, still among the lowest in the country.
 Most cats at AVAS are kept in the back and mislabeled as “feral,” even when they are adoptable.
 Many are euthanized without any public exposure or rescue eƯort.

For example, in April 2025 alone, over 100 cats were euthanized, yet only 5 were ever listed online for public view.

Despite repeated public outcry and thoroughly documented concerns, transparency and accountability remain absent. There is no full-time veterinarian, no licensed behaviorist, and no low-cost spay/neuter services — in a town where the average annual income is under $25,000.

Even promising eƯorts have been abandoned. The pilot TNVR (Trap-Neuter-VaccinateReturn) program — briefly launched in Q2 2025 — was paused on June 30 and has yet to resume, leaving community members and local cats in limbo once again.

San Bernardino County oƯers real hope.

In stark contrast to AVAS, county-run shelters:
 Vaccinate all animals on intake
 Post all intakes online the same day
 Welcome volunteers to take photos and network animals  Partner with over 400 rescue organizations
 Maintain a cat live release rate over 75%, even under an open-admission policy in 2023
The County’s Animal Care team actively listens to the community, and continues to improve policies. In recent months, they’ve implemented impactful programs such as:
 A rapidly expanding TNVR program supported by a dedicated mobile clinic  A newly launched foster program that we believe will be a game-changer for at-risk animals
Meanwhile, AVAS continues to operate in crisis mode, shielding animals from view and avoiding reform. This is not just a staƯing issue — it is systemic failure.

Transferring AVAS to the County is not just a change in management — it’s a chance at life for thousands of animals.

Enough is enough.

Opponents of this sale say the shelter is “trying its best.” But trying is not enough when lives are at stake.

For more than 15 years, AVAS has followed a broken pattern: hide the cats, label them unadoptable, euthanize quietly. The Town has consistently failed to enact meaningful reform, even when publicly funded to do so.

The result? One of the highest cat euthanasia rates in California, driven by poor visibility, poor policies, and a pattern of inaction.

This vote is your opportunity to end the cycle of secrecy and suƯering. You can replace dysfunction with transparency, cruelty with care, and hopelessness with progress.

This is not about politics or pride — it is about life and death. The animals at AVAS can’t aƯord to wait any longer.

Please vote YES to finalize the transfer of AVAS to San Bernardino County. Let this be the turning point where Apple Valley chooses compassion, transparency, and a better future.

Thank you.

Shanshan Zhao
To Whom it May Concern,
I wish to add my voice as fully supporting the sale and transfer of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County. This move would greatly benefit all animals by providing them (and the many rescue services they serve) with established guidelines for consistent care and community service.

I request that you vote ‘yes’ in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Sincerely,
Mark Jones
Public Comment: Vote YES for the Sale of AVAS to San Bernardino County Dear Mayor and Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to strongly urge you to vote YES on the proposed sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County at the upcoming Town Council meeting.

The County of San Bernardino oƯers hope.

In contrast, AVAS continues to conceal animals from the public and operate in crisis mode.

This is not just a staƯing issue — it is a systemic failure.

Transferring AVAS to the County is not just a change of management — it’s a chance at life for thousands of animals.

Enough is enough.

This is your opportunity to end the cycle of secrecy and suƯering. With this vote, you can replace dysfunction with transparency, cruelty with care, and hopelessness with a future.

This sale is not about politics or pride — it is about life and death. The animals at AVAS can’t aƯord to wait any longer.

Please vote YES to finalize the transfer of AVAS to San Bernardino County. Let this be the turning point — where we choose compassion, transparency, and progress.

Thank you.

Chris Rosinko
Dear Mayor and Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to strongly urge you to vote YES on the proposed sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County at the upcoming Town Council meeting.

The County of San Bernardino oƯers hope.

In contrast, AVAS continues to conceal animals from the public and operate in crisis mode.

This is not just a staƯing issue — it is a systemic failure.

Transferring AVAS to the County is not just a change of management — it’s a chance at life for thousands of animals.

Enough is enough.

This is your opportunity to end the cycle of secrecy and suƯering. With this vote, you can replace dysfunction with transparency, cruelty with care, and hopelessness with a future.

This sale is not about politics or pride — it is about life and death. The animals at AVAS can’t aƯord to wait any longer.

Please vote YES to finalize the transfer of AVAS to San Bernardino County. Let this be the turning point — where we choose compassion, transparency, and progress.

Thank you.

Jordan Devito
To Whom it May Concern,
Strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

We ask for you to vote yea in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Sincerely,
Andrea Rubischko
To Whom it May Concern,
I am strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

We ask for you to vote yes in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Sincerely,
Rubin
Dear Mayor and Apple Valley Town Council Members,
I am writing to strongly urge you to vote YES on the proposed sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS) to San Bernardino County at the upcoming Town Council meeting.

The County of San Bernardino oƯers hope.

In contrast, AVAS continues to conceal animals from the public and operate in crisis mode.

This is not just a staƯing issue — it is a systemic failure.

Transferring AVAS to the County is not just a change of management — it’s a chance at life for thousands of animals.

Enough is enough.

This is your opportunity to end the cycle of secrecy and suƯering. With this vote, you can replace dysfunction with transparency, cruelty with care, and hopelessness with a future.

This sale is not about politics or pride — it is about life and death. The animals at AVAS can’t aƯord to wait any longer.

Please vote YES to finalize the transfer of AVAS to San Bernardino County. Let this be the turning point — where we choose compassion, transparency, and progress.

Thank you.

Suzanne Corbett
Please vote YES to the sale of AVAS to the county, to give thousands of animals the chance they deserve. Thank you, Marian Pochet Rupp
To Whom it May Concern,
Strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County! We ask for you to vote yes in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County. The cats and dogs need a better and safe condition. Please support helping as many fur animals.

Sincerely,
Marisol Rubio
To Whom it May Concern,
Strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County! We ask for you to vote yes in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County. The cats and dogs need a better and safe condition. Please support helping as many fur animals.

Sincerely,
Joel Rubio
Dear Town Council member of Apple Valley, dear supervisors of San Bernardino County, We're writing to urge immediate oversight of Apple Valley Animal Shelter (AVAS).

In 2023, the live release rate for cats at AVAS was just 7%. In 2024, it’s only risen to around 21%. In April 2025, over 100 cats were euthanized — but only 5 were listed online. In May 2025, just 5 cats were labeled as friendly and moved to the adoption floor. The Shelter Is in Transition — But the Animals Still Need Protection.

We’re encouraged that the County’s purchase of AVAS may be finalized in the next 60 days.

Best, Miranda Feck
Dear Sir or Madam,
Please vote YES to the sale of AVAS.

THE ANIMALS NEED THIS.

Yours sincerely
Joanne Newton
Please support the transfer/sale to San Bernardino of Apple Valley shelter. With so many people at odds politically, this one subject that everyone can agree on. You will be saving countless lives of innocent, healthy , adoptable pets.

Michele SheƯler
17943 Cabela Dr
San Diego Ca
Dear Mayor Nassif, Director Whiteside, and San Bernardino County Board of Supervisors, Attached please find my comment letter, requesting that the AVAS contract be allowed to run out with no renewal, and that responsibilities for the shelter be transferred to San Bernardino County.

Thank you for taking the time to review.

Sincerely,
Susy Boyd
To Whom it May Concern,
I am strongly in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter to San Bernardino County.

I ask for you to vote yea in favor of the sale of the Apple Valley Animal Shelter and a smooth and quick transition to the County.

Sincerely,
Lori Sekhr
To whom it may concern: