Dear Vanguard Preparatory School Administration, Apple Valley Unified School District, and Town of Apple Valley Officials,
I am writing to formally report an ongoing and serious safety concern occurring daily in front of Vanguard Preparatory School during morning drop-off hours.
Each day while waiting in the car line to drop off my students, I witness multiple dangerous driving behaviors that place students, families, and other drivers at risk. The most alarming issue involves vehicles driving into the oncoming traffic lane on Mesquite Road in order to bypass the drop-off line and reach the front more quickly.
On the morning of April 7, 2026, I observed a particularly dangerous incident involving a large SUV (license plate “Mrs. Shrek”) that entered the northbound oncoming lane, forcing an oncoming vehicle—who had the right of way—to move as far as possible toward the curb to avoid a collision. The SUV then cut into the front of the drop-off line, dropped off a student, and exited the area without regard for pedestrians or other vehicles.
Unfortunately, this is not an isolated issue. Similar incidents occur daily and include:
- Vehicles driving into oncoming traffic lanes to bypass the drop-off line - Drivers cutting across lanes to turn into the school without yielding - Cars speeding through crosswalk areas without slowing or checking for pedestrians - Vehicles using the dirt easement near nearby homes and the adjacent field to bypass traffic, where students are frequently walking to school Additionally, it is extremely concerning that I have personally observed individuals who appear to be school staff engaging in the same unsafe driving behaviors. This undermines safety expectations and sets a dangerous example for families and students.
These actions create a hazardous environment, especially given the presence of young students walking to campus.
It is also concerning that while passing Apple Valley High School, there is a consistent law enforcement presence monitoring traffic safety, while enforcement near Vanguard Preparatory School is extremely limited. This lack of visibility and enforcement has allowed dangerous driving habits to continue unchecked.
This situation presents a clear and ongoing risk to student safety. I respectfully request immediate action to address these concerns, including:
- Increased traffic enforcement during drop-off hours
- Coordination with law enforcement for active monitoring and citation of violations - Implementation of traffic control measures to prevent vehicles from entering oncoming lanes
- Clearly marked and actively monitored crosswalk protections - Consideration of physical barriers, cones, or staff-directed traffic flow - Reinforcement of safety expectations with all staff members Please be advised that this ongoing safety concern will also be formally reported to the San Bernardino County Sheriff’s Department – Apple Valley Station to request enforcement and documentation of these daily violations.
The safety of students and families must be a top priority. I urge all recipients to take this matter seriously and collaborate on immediate and effective solutions before a serious accident occurs.
Please confirm receipt of this email and advise what actions will be taken to address these concerns.
Sincerely,
Christina Hendricks
Good morning,
I came across this very disturbing information on tiktok. If all of the information provided in this attached post are accurate there's something very wrong going on at the shelter. There are many no-kill shelters that are extremely successful in adopting cats even if they have difficult behavior. This is not acceptable. We are the stewards of animals and they depend on us for their well-being. They are trapped in those cages and deserve to be treated much better . The funding that is going toward the shelter is clearly being misappropriated and not used properly for the animals. This needs to be looked at with true compassionate consideration. What is being done and is anyone actually paying attention to the treatment of animals within this facility?
Berkleigh Warren
Good evening Mayor and Members of the City Council,
My name is Marco Luna, and I am a resident living near the proposed 210-unit multi-family development at the northwest corner of Sandia Road and Navajo Road.
I want to begin by saying I am not opposed to growth. However, growth must be responsible,
balanced, and supported by adequate infrastructure to protect the quality of life for existing residents.
This project, as proposed, raises several important concerns.
First, traffic and safety. A development of this size will significantly increase vehicle traffic in
an area not designed to handle that volume. Without proper mitigation, this could lead to congestion, increased accidents, and unsafe conditions for pedestrians. I urge the city to require a
thorough traffic impact analysis and necessary improvements such as turn lanes, traffic controls,
and safe access points.
Second, infrastructure capacity. Existing water, sewer, and utility systems must be able to support this level of density. Any required upgrades should be completed in advance and funded
by the developer, not current residents.
Third, community impact. A project of this density can alter the character of the neighborhood.
Building height, setbacks, landscaping buffers, and adequate parking must be carefully evaluated
to prevent overcrowding, noise, and spillover into nearby streets.
Construction impacts must also be addressed, including limits on work hours, designated truck
routes, and proper dust control to reduce disruption.
Finally, I ask the Council to ensure this project provides meaningful benefits to the community—through infrastructure improvements, public safety measures, or added amenities—so the area is improved, not strained.
In closing, I respectfully request that the city require comprehensive mitigation and thoughtful
planning before moving forward. Responsible development should enhance our community, not
burden it.
Thank you for your time and consideration
To Whom It May Concern,
I was taken aback and enraged when I learned about the management of both Devore and Apple Valley shelters and how they clearly prioritize dogs over cats.
I was even informed of a kitten named Squash (#254962) that had an adopter ready and was still euthanized the day before the adopter, who drove two hours, was expected to arrive.
And these are kittens who have actually been listed. As I’m an out of state resident, I don’t have the newest numbers at my fingertips but it is clear that there is a problem of not making available cats visible or only doing so for a maximum of 24 hours before they’re set for euthanasia.
At Devore, there are 80 cat kennels and in October of 2025 there were 47 cats in the shelter with only 27 being listed. 11 of these 27 were labeled as “rescue only” but the shelter only urged eight of them to be pulled due to “critical challenges accommodating dogs”. There were 42 cats specific kennels open but they cared more about dogs? Apple Valley is worse. According to data obtained by Friends of AVAS Cats, in April 2025 only five cats were listed on their website while 100 were euthanized. Many cats that arrive at Apple Valley are given an incredibly short period of time to adapt before either being labeled “friendly” or “feral”.
This makes it clear they have untrained staff or at the very least undertrained and ignorant of the “333 Rule” which cites animals need at least three days to decompress as a loud, chaotic shelter environment is overwhelming for any living being. The next 3 would be three weeks to learn a routine and settle in. The final 3 is three months to even begin feeling at home and safe.
I know this isn’t the first time Apple Valley has been cited for lack of transparency about their available animals, sub-standard operational procedures, and has unwillingness to improve oversight of processes. This shouldn’t be a negotiation. I know that Saving Devore Shelter Cats and Friends of AVAS Cats have given solutions in the past and they’ve been ignored.
I hope you continue to listen to your constituents and the volunteer groups who are advocating for these animals.
Thank you,
Carson M.
Dear Mayor and Town Council Members,
I am writing as a community member to respectfully request that the Town of Apple Valley establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR (Trap-Neuter-Vaccinate-Return) program for community cats.
In August 2025, a TNVR-style program was made available to residents, allowing up to four vouchers per person for feral/community cats. However, it appears that this program is no longer available at this time.
Currently, the only known spay/neuter assistance is the Lange Foundation Intervention Program. While this effort is appreciated and helpful, it has important limitations:
• It is privately funded, not a Town program
• It primarily serves owned or friendly cats
• It is limited in availability and currently booked out As a result, there is currently no accessible, structured TNVR program for true community cats in Apple Valley.
At the same time:
• The shelter has adopted a managed intake policy for cats • Many community members are reporting increasing numbers of kittens and unaltered cats this spring
• Residents are actively seeking help for outdoor cats but have limited options When these conditions occur together — limited intake and no TNVR infrastructure — community cats are left without a clear pathway for care.
TNVR is widely recognized as the most effective and humane method to:
• Reduce outdoor cat populations over time
• Prevent repeated litters, especially during peak kitten season • Reduce shelter intake and long-term costs
• Support both animal welfare and community concerns
Without a functioning TNVR program, the current system places increasing pressure on:
• Residents
• Rescues and volunteers
• And ultimately the shelter system itself
I respectfully request that the Town:
• Establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR program for community cats • Ensure adequate capacity to meet actual community demand • Provide clear public information on eligibility and access • Consider expanding services during peak kitten season A sustainable TNVR program is a critical component of any effective community cat strategy, especially under a managed intake model.
This comment is submitted to ensure that the need for TNVR is clearly documented as part of the public record.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Respectfully,
Rebecca K
Sent from my iPhone
Dear Mayor and Town Council Members,
I am writing as a community member to respectfully request that the Town of Apple Valley establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR (Trap-Neuter-Vaccinate-Return) program for community cats.
In August 2025, a TNVR-style program was made available to residents, allowing up to four vouchers per person for feral/community cats. However, it appears that this program is no longer available at this time.
Currently, the only known spay/neuter assistance is the Lange Foundation Intervention Program. While this effort is appreciated and helpful, it has important limitations:
• It is privately funded, not a Town program
• It primarily serves owned or friendly cats
• It is limited in availability and currently booked out As a result, there is currently no accessible, structured TNVR program for true community cats in Apple Valley.
At the same time:
• The shelter has adopted a managed intake policy for cats • Many community members are reporting increasing numbers of kittens and unaltered cats this spring
• Residents are actively seeking help for outdoor cats but have limited options When these conditions occur together — limited intake and no TNVR infrastructure — community cats are left without a clear pathway for care.
TNVR is widely recognized as the most effective and humane method to:
• Reduce outdoor cat populations over time
• Prevent repeated litters, especially during peak kitten season • Reduce shelter intake and long-term costs
• Support both animal welfare and community concerns
Without a functioning TNVR program, the current system places increasing pressure on:
• Residents
• Rescues and volunteers
• And ultimately the shelter system itself
I respectfully request that the Town:
• Establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR program for community cats • Ensure adequate capacity to meet actual community demand • Provide clear public information on eligibility and access • Consider expanding services during peak kitten season A sustainable TNVR program is a critical component of any effective community cat strategy, especially under a managed intake model.
This comment is submitted to ensure that the need for TNVR is clearly documented as part of the public record.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Respectfully,
[Your Name]
, Conquer
Dear Mayor and Town Council Members,
I am writing as a community member to respectfully request that the Town of Apple Valley establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR (Trap-Neuter-Vaccinate-Return) program for community cats.
In August 2025, a TNVR-style program was made available to residents, allowing up to four vouchers per person for feral/community cats. However, it appears that this program is no longer available at this time.
Currently, the only known spay/neuter assistance is the Lange Foundation Intervention Program. While this effort is appreciated and helpful, it has important limitations:
It is privately funded, not a Town program
• It primarily serves owned or friendly cats
• It is limited in availability and currently booked out As a result, there is currently no accessible, structured TNVR program for true community cats in Apple Valley.
At the same time:
The shelter has adopted a managed intake policy for cats • Many community members are reporting increasing numbers of kittens and unaltered cats this spring
• Residents are actively seeking help for outdoor cats but have limited options When these conditions occur together — limited intake and no TNVR infrastructure — community cats are left without a clear pathway for care.
TNVR is widely recognized as the most effective and humane method to:
Reduce outdoor cat populations over time
• Prevent repeated litters, especially during peak kitten season • Reduce shelter intake and long-term costs
• Support both animal welfare and community concerns
Without a functioning TNVR program, the current system places increasing pressure on:
Residents
• Rescues and volunteers
• And ultimately the shelter system itself
I respectfully request that the Town:
Establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR program for community cats • Ensure adequate capacity to meet actual community demand • Provide clear public information on eligibility and access • Consider expanding services during peak kitten season A sustainable TNVR program is a critical component of any effective community cat strategy, especially under a managed intake model.
This comment is submitted to ensure that the need for TNVR is clearly documented as part of the public record.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Respectfully,
Roseann Whypp
To whom it may concern:
I am writing as a friend of the area to respectfully request that the Town of Apple Valley establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR (Trap-Neuter-Vaccinate-Return) program for community cats.
In August 2025, a TNVR-style program was made available to residents, allowing up to four vouchers per person for feral/community cats. However, it appears that this program is no longer available at this time.
Currently, the only known spay/neuter assistance is the Lange Foundation Intervention Program. While this effort is appreciated and helpful, it has important limitations:
It is privately funded, not a Town program
It primarily serves owned or friendly cats
It is limited in availability and currently booked out
As a result, there is currently no accessible, structured TNVR program for true community cats in Apple Valley.
At the same time: The shelter has adopted a managed intake policy for cats. Many community members are reporting increasing numbers of kittens and unaltered cats this spring. Residents are actively seeking help for outdoor cats but have limited options. When these conditions occur together — limited intake and no TNVR infrastructure — community cats are left without a clear pathway for care.
TNVR is widely recognized as the most effective and humane method to:
Reduce outdoor cat populations over time
Prevent repeated litters, especially during peak kitten season Reduce shelter intake and long-term costs
Support both animal welfare and community concerns
Without a functioning TNVR program, the current system places increasing pressure on:
Residents
Rescues and volunteers
And ultimately the shelter system itself
I respectfully request that the Town:
• Establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR program for community cats • Ensure adequate capacity to meet actual community demand • Provide clear public information on eligibility and access • Consider expanding services during peak kitten season A sustainable TNVR program is a critical component of any effective community cat strategy, especially under a managed intake model.
This comment is submitted to ensure that the need for TNVR is clearly documented as part of the public record.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Respectfully,
David W James
Please set up a TNR program for stray/feral cats and give them a chance at life. There is no reason they can't live in the wild, they eat birds, mice, and lizards.
I personally feed and care for a friendly stray cat and he is thriving living outdoors. Cats are not necessarily indoor pets.
Thank you for your attention.
Brandy McGinnis
Dear Mayor and Town Council Members,
I am writing as a community member to respectfully request that the Town of Apple Valley establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR (Trap-Neuter-Vaccinate-Return) program for community cats.
In August 2025, a TNVR-style program was made available to residents, allowing up to four vouchers per person for feral/community cats. However, it appears that this program is no longer available at this time.
Currently, the only known spay/neuter assistance is the Lange Foundation Intervention Program. While this effort is appreciated and helpful, it has important limitations:
It is privately funded, not a Town program
It primarily serves owned or friendly cats
It is limited in availability and currently booked out
As a result, there is currently no accessible, structured TNVR program for true community cats in Apple Valley.
At the same time:
The shelter has adopted a managed intake policy for cats Many community members are reporting increasing numbers of kittens and unaltered cats this spring Residents are actively seeking help for outdoor cats but have limited options When these conditions occur together — limited intake and no TNVR infrastructure — community cats are left without a clear pathway for care.
TNVR is widely recognized as the most effective and humane method to:
Reduce outdoor cat populations over time
Prevent repeated litters, especially during peak kitten season Reduce shelter intake and long-term costs
Support both animal welfare and community concerns
Without a functioning TNVR program, the current system places increasing pressure on:
Residents
Rescues and volunteers
And ultimately the shelter system itself
I respectfully request that the Town:
• Establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR program for community cats • Ensure adequate capacity to meet actual community demand • Provide clear public information on eligibility and access • Consider expanding services during peak kitten season A sustainable TNVR program is a critical component of any effective community cat strategy, especially under a managed intake model.
This comment is submitted to ensure that the need for TNVR is clearly documented as part of the public record.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Respectfully,
This is in response to the proposal from BMI to develop a 210 unit complex on Apn 0434- 063-02.
I’ve resided in the area for over 20 years. I’ve enjoyed Apple Valley due to low crime rates near my parcel and surrounding areas , friendly neighbors, and spacious land.
Unfortunately a 210 multifamily development carries negative weight to communities. This will result in increased police activity, crime , and other emergency responses. It also places our Sandia elementary and highschool at risk for more frequent lockdowns.
Unfortunately , these schools have been subject to multiple lockdowns in past for various gun related crimes. Nearby resides a senior living complex as well which can leave our elderly victims to the new increased population. Apple Valley has been home to single family residences and small complexes . Let’s not lose sight of of what Apple Valley prides itself on. Our community will lose our safe space and sanctuary if we allow investment companies to to come in and protect their capital interests and not the lives of our children , the elderly, and our community. Graffiti is at an all time high in Apple Valley and the worst I’ve seen it in my community. This community is not equipped with enough support services to sustain a 210 complex where vape and liquor stores reside on every corner.
I hope that the community rallies in opposition to the 210 development as it will surely negatively impact us. If you agree, I encourage you to respond via a public comment at [email protected] before April 14.
Dear Apple Valley,
Please make a consistent publically funded TNVR program in Apple Valley, especially needed now, during kitten season.
Without intake and without TNVR, community cats have no way to get care, and many end up on the street with no help.
Thank you,
Joanne Newton
Dear Mayor and Town Council Members,
I am writing as a community member to respectfully request that the Town of Apple Valley establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR (Trap-Neuter-Vaccinate-Return) program for community cats.
In August 2025, a TNVR-style program was made available to residents, allowing up to four vouchers per person for feral/community cats. However, it appears that this program is no longer available at this time.
Currently, the only known spay/neuter assistance is the Lange Foundation Intervention Program. While this effort is appreciated and helpful, it has important limitations:
• It is privately funded, not a Town program
• It primarily serves owned or friendly cats
• It is limited in availability and currently booked out As a result, there is currently no accessible, structured TNVR program for true community cats in Apple Valley.
At the same time:
• The shelter has adopted a managed intake policy for cats • Many community members are reporting increasing numbers of kittens and unaltered cats this spring
• Residents are actively seeking help for outdoor cats but have limited options When these conditions occur together — limited intake and no TNVR infrastructure — community cats are left without a clear pathway for care.
TNVR is widely recognized as the most effective and humane method to:
• Reduce outdoor cat populations over time
• Prevent repeated litters, especially during peak kitten season • Reduce shelter intake and long-term costs
• Support both animal welfare and community concerns
Without a functioning TNVR program, the current system places increasing pressure on:
• Residents
• Rescues and volunteers
• And ultimately the shelter system itself
I respectfully request that the Town:
• Establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR program for community cats • Ensure adequate capacity to meet actual community demand • Provide clear public information on eligibility and access • Consider expanding services during peak kitten season A sustainable TNVR program is a critical component of any effective community cat strategy, especially under a managed intake model.
This comment is submitted to ensure that the need for TNVR is clearly documented as part of the public record.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Respectfully,
Cody Macioce
The previous TNVR-style program (Aug 2025) is no longer available and we need support with the increase need for services for community cats.
No current public, town-supported TNVR program for community cats Managed intake limits the ability for residents to bring cats into the shelter A privately funded spay/neuter program is appreciated, but focused on friendly cats and unable to meet demand
Community members are reporting increasing numbers of kittens this spring Many friendly and community cats are left on the street without access to help Without TNVR, outdoor cats continue to reproduce
Kitten season increases suffering and intake pressure
Residents and rescues are left trying to fill the gap without resources Without intake AND without TNVR, community cats have no pathway to care.
Dear Mayor and Town Council Members,
I am writing as a community member to respectfully request that the Town of Apple Valley establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR (Trap-Neuter-Vaccinate-Return) program for community cats.
In August 2025, a TNVR-style program was made available to residents, allowing up to four vouchers per person for feral/community cats. However, it appears that this program is no longer available at this time.
Currently, the only known spay/neuter assistance is the Lange Foundation Intervention Program. While this effort is appreciated and helpful, it has important limitations:
It is privately funded, not a Town program
It primarily serves owned or friendly cats
It is limited in availability and currently booked out
As a result, there is currently no accessible, structured TNVR program for true community cats in Apple Valley.
At the same time:
The shelter has adopted a managed intake policy for cats Many community members are reporting increasing numbers of kittens and unaltered cats this spring
Residents are actively seeking help for outdoor cats but have limited options When these conditions occur together — limited intake and no TNVR infrastructure — community cats are left without a clear pathway for care.
TNVR is widely recognized as the most effective and humane method to:
Reduce outdoor cat populations over time
Prevent repeated litters, especially during peak kitten season Reduce shelter intake and long-term costs
Support both animal welfare and community concerns
Without a functioning TNVR program, the current system places increasing pressure on:
Residents
Rescues and volunteers
And ultimately the shelter system itself
I respectfully request that the Town:
• Establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR program for community cats • Ensure adequate capacity to meet actual community demand • Provide clear public information on eligibility and access • Consider expanding services during peak kitten season A sustainable TNVR program is a critical component of any effective community cat strategy, especially under a managed intake model.
This comment is submitted to ensure that the need for TNVR is clearly documented as part of the public record.
Thank you,
Randi Evans
Currently, there is
no intake + no TNVR =
which means:
no pathway for community cats!
THIS IS COMPLETELY UNACCEPTABLE
OUR tax dollars do NOT pay for this type of mismanagement & DEATH Unnecessary death!
The previous TNVR-style program (Aug 2025) is no longer available • There is NO current public, town-supported TNVR program for community cats • Managed intake limits the ability for residents to bring cats into the shelter - where are they supposed to go?!
• A privately funded spay/neuter program is appreciated, but focused on friendly cats and unable to meet demand
• Community members are reporting increasing numbers of kittens this spring • Many friendly and community cats are left on the street without access to help This is inexcusable!
• Without TNVR, outdoor cats continue to reproduce
This is making the problem WORSE
MORE unnecessary deaths!
• Kitten season increases suffering and intake pressure • Residents and rescues are left trying to fill the gap without resources Without intake AND without TNVR, community cats have no pathway to care
WE ARE REQUESTING IMMEDIATE ACTION
• Immediately establish a consistent, publicly funded TNVR program • Immediately provide sufficient capacity to meet actual community needs • Expand services during peak kitten season
• Ensure clear and equitable access for community cats
LISTEN to the Constituents
LISTEN to your heart
STOP DESTROYING cats & dogs because of irresponsible humans Find some solutions to get them out of here
NO MORE EUTHANASIA
You guys are killing me
Dear Mayor and Town Councilmembers,
I am writing as a community member to respectfully request that the Town of Apple Valley establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR (Trap-Neuter-Vaccinate-Return) program for community cats.
In August 2025, a TNVR-style program was made available to residents, allowing up to four vouchers per person for feral/community cats. However, it appears that this program is no longer available at this time.
Currently, the only known spay/neuter assistance is the Lange Foundation Intervention Program. While this effort is appreciated and helpful, it has important limitations:
• It is privately funded, not a Town program
• It primarily serves owned or friendly cats
• It is limited in availability and currently booked out As a result, there is currently no accessible, structured TNVR program for true community cats in Apple Valley.
At the same time:
• The shelter has adopted a managed intake policy for cats • Many community members are reporting increasing numbers of kittens and unaltered cats this spring
• Residents are actively seeking help for outdoor cats but have limited options When these conditions occur together — limited intake and no TNVR infrastructure — community cats are left without a clear pathway for care.
TNVR is widely recognized as the most effective and humane method to:
• Reduce outdoor cat populations over time
• Prevent repeated litters, especially during peak kitten season • Reduce shelter intake and long-term costs
• Support both animal welfare and community concerns
Without a functioning TNVR program, the current system places increasing pressure on:
• Residents
• Rescues and volunteers
• And ultimately the shelter system itself
I respectfully request that the Town:
• Establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR program for community cats • Ensure adequate capacity to meet actual community demand • Provide clear public information on eligibility and access • Consider expanding services during peak kitten season A sustainable TNVR program is a critical component of any effective community cat strategy, especially under a managed intake model.
This comment is submitted to ensure that the need for TNVR is clearly documented as part of the public record
Currently, there is
no intake + no TNVR =
which means:
no pathway for community cats!
THIS IS COMPLETELY UNACCEPTABLE
OUR tax dollars do NOT pay for this type of mismanagement & DEATH Unnecessary death!
The previous TNVR-style program (Aug 2025) is no longer available • There is NO current public, town-supported TNVR program for community cats • Managed intake limits the ability for residents to bring cats into the shelter - where are they supposed to go?!
• A privately funded spay/neuter program is appreciated, but focused on friendly cats and unable to meet demand
• Community members are reporting increasing numbers of kittens this spring • Many friendly and community cats are left on the street without access to help This is inexcusable!
• Without TNVR, outdoor cats continue to reproduce
This is making the problem WORSE
MORE unnecessary deaths!
• Kitten season increases suffering and intake pressure • Residents and rescues are left trying to fill the gap without resources Without intake AND without TNVR, community cats have no pathway to care
WE ARE REQUESTING IMMEDIATE ACTION
• Immediately establish a consistent, publicly funded TNVR program • Immediately provide sufficient capacity to meet actual community needs • Expand services during peak kitten season
• Ensure clear and equitable access for community cats
LISTEN to the Constituents
LISTEN to your heart
STOP DESTROYING cats & dogs because of irresponsible humans Find some solutions to get them out of here
NO MORE EUTHANASIA
You guys are killing me
Thank you for your time and consideration
Please bring program back as I have done 25 (six tks to you) but I have more friggin cats in the neighborhood now ������
Thanks
Grant Mealey
Dear Mayor and Town Council Members,
I am writing as a community member to respectfully request that the Town of Apple Valley establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR (Trap-Neuter-Vaccinate-Return) program for community cats.
In August 2025, a TNVR-style program was made available to residents, allowing up to four vouchers per person for feral/community cats. However, it appears that this program is no longer available at this time.
Currently, the only known spay/neuter assistance is the Lange Foundation Intervention Program. While this effort is appreciated and helpful, it has important limitations:
• It is privately funded, not a Town program
• It primarily serves owned or friendly cats
• It is limited in availability and currently booked out As a result, there is currently no accessible, structured TNVR program for true community cats in Apple Valley.
At the same time:
• The shelter has adopted a managed intake policy for cats • Many community members are reporting increasing numbers of kittens and unaltered cats this spring
• Residents are actively seeking help for outdoor cats but have limited options When these conditions occur together — limited intake and no TNVR infrastructure — community cats are left without a clear pathway for care.
TNVR is widely recognized as the most effective and humane method to:
• Reduce outdoor cat populations over time
• Prevent repeated litters, especially during peak kitten season • Reduce shelter intake and long-term costs
• Support both animal welfare and community concerns
Without a functioning TNVR program, the current system places increasing pressure on:
• Residents
• Rescues and volunteers
• And ultimately the shelter system itself
I respectfully request that the Town:
• Establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR program for community cats • Ensure adequate capacity to meet actual community demand • Provide clear public information on eligibility and access • Consider expanding services during peak kitten season A sustainable TNVR program is a critical component of any effective community cat strategy, especially under a managed intake model.
This comment is submitted to ensure that the need for TNVR is clearly documented as part of the public record.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Respectfully,
Robin C. Knaier
Dear Mayor and Town Council Members,
I am writing as a community member to respectfully request that the Town of Apple Valley establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR (Trap-Neuter-Vaccinate-Return) program for community cats.
In August 2025, a TNVR-style program was made available to residents, allowing up to four vouchers per person for feral/community cats. However, it appears that this program is no longer available at this time.
Currently, the only known spay/neuter assistance is the Lange Foundation Intervention Program. While this effort is appreciated and helpful, it has important limitations:
It is privately funded, not a Town program
It primarily serves owned or friendly cats
It is limited in availability and currently booked out
As a result, there is currently no accessible, structured TNVR program for true community cats in Apple Valley.
At the same time:
The shelter has adopted a managed intake policy for cats Many community members are reporting increasing numbers of kittens and unaltered cats this spring
Residents are actively seeking help for outdoor cats but have limited options When these conditions occur together — limited intake and no TNVR infrastructure — community cats are left without a clear pathway for care.
TNVR is widely recognized as the most effective and humane method to:
Reduce outdoor cat populations over time
Prevent repeated litters, especially during peak kitten season Reduce shelter intake and long-term costs
Support both animal welfare and community concerns
Without a functioning TNVR program, the current system places increasing pressure on:
Residents
Rescues and volunteers
And ultimately the shelter system itself
I respectfully request that the Town:
• Establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR program for community cats • Ensure adequate capacity to meet actual community demand • Provide clear public information on eligibility and access • Consider expanding services during peak kitten season A sustainable TNVR program is a critical component of any effective community cat strategy, especially under a managed intake model.
This comment is submitted to ensure that the need for TNVR is clearly documented as part of the public record.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Respectfully,
Catt Co Cat Nippers
Sent from my iPhone we have a need for a TVR program for the cats for the community cats please consider it as a matter of importance
Dear Mayor and Town Council Members,
I am writing as a community member to respectfully request that the Town of Apple Valley establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR (Trap-Neuter-Vaccinate-Return) program for community cats.
In August 2025, a TNVR-style program was made available to residents, allowing up to four vouchers per person for feral/community cats. However, it appears that this program is no longer available at this time.
Currently, the only known spay/neuter assistance is the Lange Foundation Intervention Program. While this effort is appreciated and helpful, it has important limitations:
• It is privately funded, not a Town program
• It primarily serves owned or friendly cats
• It is limited in availability and currently booked out As a result, there is currently no accessible, structured TNVR program for true community cats in Apple Valley.
At the same time:
• The shelter has adopted a managed intake policy for cats • Many community members are reporting increasing numbers of kittens and unaltered cats this spring
• Residents are actively seeking help for outdoor cats but have limited options When these conditions occur together — limited intake and no TNVR infrastructure — community cats are left without a clear pathway for care.
TNVR is widely recognized as the most effective and humane method to:
• Reduce outdoor cat populations over time
• Prevent repeated litters, especially during peak kitten season • Reduce shelter intake and long-term costs
• Support both animal welfare and community concerns
Without a functioning TNVR program, the current system places increasing pressure on:
• Residents
• Rescues and volunteers
• And ultimately the shelter system itself
I respectfully request that the Town:
• Establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR program for community cats • Ensure adequate capacity to meet actual community demand • Provide clear public information on eligibility and access • Consider expanding services during peak kitten season A sustainable TNVR program is a critical component of any effective community cat strategy, especially under a managed intake model.
This comment is submitted to ensure that the need for TNVR is clearly documented as part of the public record.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Jewel Burns
Public Comment: Request for Clarification and Correction of Apple Valley Animal Control Guidance Advising Residents to Stop Feeding Stray Cats Dear Apple Valley Town Council,
I am writing as a community member concerned about the current approach to community cats in Apple Valley.
Residents at an Apple Valley apartment property recently received a notice from their property manager stating that Apple Valley Animal Control advised that if they receive a report of feeding or sheltering stray cats, they will issue a violation and fine, and residents were asked not to feed the animals.
It is currently unclear what municipal code authorizes such enforcement related to feeding community cats.
Community members are also observing that ear-tipped cats (already sterilized community cats) are still entering the Apple Valley Animal Shelter.
These developments raise several policy concerns regarding how community cats are currently managed in Apple Valley:
• Apple Valley does not currently operate a well-established, publicly funded TNVR program (Trap-Neuter-Vaccinate-Return)
• The shelter has adopted managed intake, limiting the ability for residents to bring in cats needing help
• Many cats are labeled “feral” and kept in back rooms, reducing visibility and adoption opportunities
• Residents are being discouraged from feeding community cats, even when those cats remain outdoors without support
When these factors occur together, cats living in the community may receive little or no assistance.
If the notice stating that residents could receive a violation or fine for feeding stray cats was issued without a clear legal basis, I respectfully request that the Town ask Animal Services to withdraw or correct the notice so that residents are not misinformed.
I also respectfully ask the Town to clarify the legal basis for this guidance and to consider establishing a transparent and humane strategy for managing community cats in Apple Valley.
Thank you for your time and consideration. Gigi
Dear Mayor and Town Council Members,
I am writing as a community member to respectfully request that the Town of Apple Valley establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR (Trap-Neuter-Vaccinate-Return) program for community cats.
In August 2025, a TNVR-style program was made available to residents, allowing up to four vouchers per person for feral/community cats. However, it appears that this program is no longer available at this time.
Currently, the only known spay/neuter assistance is the Lange Foundation Intervention Program. While this effort is appreciated and helpful, it has important limitations:
• It is privately funded, not a Town program
• It primarily serves owned or friendly cats
• It is limited in availability and currently booked out As a result, there is currently no accessible, structured TNVR program for true community cats in Apple Valley.
At the same time:
• The shelter has adopted a managed intake policy for cats • Many community members are reporting increasing numbers of kittens and unaltered cats this spring
• Residents are actively seeking help for outdoor cats but have limited options When these conditions occur together — limited intake and no TNVR infrastructure — community cats are left without a clear pathway for care.
TNVR is widely recognized as the most effective and humane method to:
• Reduce outdoor cat populations over time
• Prevent repeated litters, especially during peak kitten season • Reduce shelter intake and long-term costs
• Support both animal welfare and community concerns
Without a functioning TNVR program, the current system places increasing pressure on:
• Residents
• Rescues and volunteers
• And ultimately the shelter system itself
I respectfully request that the Town:
• Establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR program for community cats • Ensure adequate capacity to meet actual community demand • Provide clear public information on eligibility and access • Consider expanding services during peak kitten season A sustainable TNVR program is a critical component of any effective community cat strategy, especially under a managed intake model.
This comment is submitted to ensure that the need for TNVR is clearly documented as part of the public record.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Respectfully,
Shanshan Zhao
Hi Apple Valley,
Please reimplement the TVNR program at AVAS. The amount of friendly cats and innocent baby kittens that are Euthanized everyday at AVAS is shocking, avoidable and absolutely heartbreaking. AVAS needs to be forced to work with local rescues. The workers at AVAS are as difficult as possible and often impossible to work with local non profit animal rescues to get the cats on the euthanasia list out of the shelter and adopted into loving homes. It’s a never ending cycle of death for these poor cats trapped and brought into AVAS. Your shelter would rather Euthanize rather than neuter and adopt. This needs to stop. TVNR helps to break this death cycle that is happening at AVAS on a daily basis. These community cats need help from the local shelter, not a euthanasia death sentence. Please do better Apple Valley. You have one of the highest intake kill rates in Southern California. Please do better for your community and these innocent cats.
Thank you,
Matt Torian
Dear Mayor and Town Council Members,
I am writing as a community member to respectfully request that the Town of Apple Valley establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR (Trap-Neuter-Vaccinate-Return) program for community cats.
In August 2025, a TNVR-style program was made available to residents, allowing up to four vouchers per person for feral/community cats. However, it appears that this program is no longer available at this time.
Currently, the only known spay/neuter assistance is the Lange Foundation Intervention Program. While this effort is appreciated and helpful, it has important limitations:
It is privately funded, not a Town program
It primarily serves owned or friendly cats
It is limited in availability and currently booked out
As a result, there is currently no accessible, structured TNVR program for true community cats in Apple Valley.
At the same time:
The shelter has adopted a managed intake policy for cats Many community members are reporting increasing numbers of kittens and unaltered cats this spring
Residents are actively seeking help for outdoor cats but have limited options When these conditions occur together — limited intake and no TNVR infrastructure — community cats are left without a clear pathway for care.
TNVR is widely recognized as the most effective and humane method to:
Reduce outdoor cat populations over time
Prevent repeated litters, especially during peak kitten season Reduce shelter intake and long-term costs
Support both animal welfare and community concerns
Without a functioning TNVR program, the current system places increasing pressure on:
Residents
Rescues and volunteers
And ultimately the shelter system itself
I respectfully request that the Town:
• Establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR program for community cats • Ensure adequate capacity to meet actual community demand • Provide clear public information on eligibility and access • Consider expanding services during peak kitten season A sustainable TNVR program is a critical component of any effective community cat strategy, especially under a managed intake model.
This comment is submitted to ensure that the need for TNVR is clearly documented as part of the public record.
Thank you for your time and consideration
Marina Zinchenko
Dear Mayor and Town Council Members,
I am writing as a community member to respectfully request that the Town of Apple Valley establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR (Trap-Neuter-Vaccinate-Return) program for community cats.
In August 2025, a TNVR-style program was made available to residents, allowing up to four vouchers per person for feral/community cats. However, it appears that this program is no longer available at this time.
Currently, the only known spay/neuter assistance is the Lange Foundation Intervention Program. While this effort is appreciated and helpful, it has important limitations:
• It is privately funded, not a Town program
• It primarily serves owned or friendly cats
• It is limited in availability and currently booked out As a result, there is currently no accessible, structured TNVR program for true community cats in Apple Valley.
At the same time:
• The shelter has adopted a managed intake policy for cats • Many community members are reporting increasing numbers of kittens and unaltered cats this spring
• Residents are actively seeking help for outdoor cats but have limited options When these conditions occur together — limited intake and no TNVR infrastructure — community cats are left without a clear pathway for care.
TNVR is widely recognized as the most effective and humane method to:
• Reduce outdoor cat populations over time
• Prevent repeated litters, especially during peak kitten season • Reduce shelter intake and long-term costs
• Support both animal welfare and community concerns
Without a functioning TNVR program, the current system places increasing pressure on:
• Residents
• Rescues and volunteers
• And ultimately the shelter system itself
I respectfully request that the Town:
• Establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR program for community cats • Ensure adequate capacity to meet actual community demand • Provide clear public information on eligibility and access • Consider expanding services during peak kitten season A sustainable TNVR program is a critical component of any effective community cat strategy, especially under a managed intake model.
This comment is submitted to ensure that the need for TNVR is clearly documented as part of the public record.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Respectfully,
Tammie Roberts
Dear Mayor and Town Council Members,
I am writing as a community member to respectfully request that the Town of Apple Valley establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR (Trap-Neuter-Vaccinate-Return) program for community cats.
In August 2025, a TNVR-style program was made available to residents, allowing up to four vouchers per person for feral/community cats. However, it appears that this program is no longer available at this time.
Currently, the only known spay/neuter assistance is the Lange Foundation Intervention Program. While this effort is appreciated and helpful, it has important limitations:
• It is privately funded, not a Town program
• It primarily serves owned or friendly cats
• It is limited in availability and currently booked out As a result, there is currently no accessible, structured TNVR program for true community cats in Apple Valley.
At the same time:
• The shelter has adopted a managed intake policy for cats • Many community members are reporting increasing numbers of kittens and unaltered cats this spring
• Residents are actively seeking help for outdoor cats but have limited options When these conditions occur together — limited intake and no TNVR infrastructure — community cats are left without a clear pathway for care.
TNVR is widely recognized as the most effective and humane method to:
• Reduce outdoor cat populations over time
• Prevent repeated litters, especially during peak kitten season • Reduce shelter intake and long-term costs
• Support both animal welfare and community concerns
Without a functioning TNVR program, the current system places increasing pressure on:
• Residents
• Rescues and volunteers
• And ultimately the shelter system itself
I respectfully request that the Town:
• Establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR program for community cats • Ensure adequate capacity to meet actual community demand • Provide clear public information on eligibility and access • Consider expanding services during peak kitten season A sustainable TNVR program is a critical component of any effective community cat strategy, especially under a managed intake model.
This comment is submitted to ensure that the need for TNVR is clearly documented as part of the public record.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Respectfully,
Brittany Barry
Subject: Public Comment – Request to Establish a Sustainable TNVR Program for Community Cats
Dear Mayor and Town Council Members,
I am writing as a community member to respectfully request that the Town of Apple Valley establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR (Trap-Neuter-Vaccinate-Return) program for community cats.
In August 2025, a TNVR-style program was made available to residents, allowing up to four vouchers per person for feral/community cats. However, it appears that this program is no longer available at this time.
Currently, the only known spay/neuter assistance is the Lange Foundation Intervention Program. While this effort is appreciated and helpful, it has important limitations:
• It is privately funded, not a Town program
• It primarily serves owned or friendly cats
• It is limited in availability and currently booked out As a result, there is currently no accessible, structured TNVR program for true community cats in Apple Valley.
At the same time:
• The shelter has adopted a managed intake policy for cats • Many community members are reporting increasing numbers of kittens and unaltered cats this spring
• Residents are actively seeking help for outdoor cats but have limited options When these conditions occur together — limited intake and no TNVR infrastructure — community cats are left without a clear pathway for care.
TNVR is widely recognized as the most effective and humane method to:
• Reduce outdoor cat populations over time
• Prevent repeated litters, especially during peak kitten season • Reduce shelter intake and long-term costs
• Support both animal welfare and community concerns
Without a functioning TNVR program, the current system places increasing pressure on:
• Residents
• Rescues and volunteers
• And ultimately the shelter system itself
I respectfully request that the Town:
• Establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR program for community cats • Ensure adequate capacity to meet actual community demand • Provide clear public information on eligibility and access • Consider expanding services during peak kitten season A sustainable TNVR program is a critical component of any effective community cat strategy, especially under a managed intake model.
This comment is submitted to ensure that the need for TNVR is clearly documented as part of the public record.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Respectfully,
Simone L Kelham
(Adopter this year of a cat scheduled to die at AVAS due to inaccurate labelling as feral) Subject: Public Comment – Request to Establish a Sustainable TNVR Program for Community Cat.
Dear Mayor and Town Council Members,
I am writing as a community member to respectfully request that the Town of Apple Valley establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR (Trap-Neuter-Vaccinate-Return) program for community cats.
In August 2025, a TNVR-style program was made available to residents, allowing up to four vouchers per person for feral/community cats. However, it appears that this program is no longer available at this time.
Currently, the only known spay/neuter assistance is the Lange Foundation Intervention Program. While this effort is appreciated and helpful, it has important limitations:
• It is privately funded, not a Town program
• It primarily serves owned or friendly cats
• It is limited in availability and currently booked out As a result, there is currently no accessible, structured TNVR program for true community cats in Apple Valley.
At the same time:
• The shelter has adopted a managed intake policy for cats • Many community members are reporting increasing numbers of kittens and unaltered cats this spring
• Residents are actively seeking help for outdoor cats but have limited options When these conditions occur together — limited intake and no TNVR infrastructure — community cats are left without a clear pathway for care.
TNVR is widely recognized as the most effective and humane method to:
• Reduce outdoor cat populations over time
• Prevent repeated litters, especially during peak kitten season • Reduce shelter intake and long-term costs
• Support both animal welfare and community concerns
Without a functioning TNVR program, the current system places increasing pressure on:
• Residents
• Rescues and volunteers
• And ultimately the shelter system itself
I respectfully request that the Town:
• Establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR program for community cats • Ensure adequate capacity to meet actual community demand • Provide clear public information on eligibility and access • Consider expanding services during peak kitten season A sustainable TNVR program is a critical component of any effective community cat strategy, especially under a managed intake model.
This comment is submitted to ensure that the need for TNVR is clearly documented as part of the public record.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Anonymous.
Dear Mayor and Town Council Members,
I am writing as a community member to respectfully request that the Town of Apple Valley establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR (Trap-Neuter-Vaccinate-Return) program for community cats.
In August 2025, a TNVR-style program was made available to residents, allowing up to four vouchers per person for feral/community cats. However, it appears that this program is no longer available at this time.
Currently, the only known spay/neuter assistance is the Lange Foundation Intervention Program. While this effort is appreciated and helpful, it has important limitations:
• It is privately funded, not a Town program
• It primarily serves owned or friendly cats
• It is limited in availability and currently booked out As a result, there is currently no accessible, structured TNVR program for true community cats in Apple Valley.
At the same time:
• The shelter has adopted a managed intake policy for cats • Many community members are reporting increasing numbers of kittens and unaltered cats this spring
• Residents are actively seeking help for outdoor cats but have limited options When these conditions occur together — limited intake and no TNVR infrastructure — community cats are left without a clear pathway for care.
TNVR is widely recognized as the most effective and humane method to:
• Reduce outdoor cat populations over time
• Prevent repeated litters, especially during peak kitten season • Reduce shelter intake and long-term costs
• Support both animal welfare and community concerns
Without a functioning TNVR program, the current system places increasing pressure on:
• Residents
• Rescues and volunteers
• And ultimately the shelter system itself
I respectfully request that the Town:
• Establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR program for community cats • Ensure adequate capacity to meet actual community demand • Provide clear public information on eligibility and access • Consider expanding services during peak kitten season A sustainable TNVR program is a critical component of any effective community cat strategy, especially under a managed intake model.
This comment is submitted to ensure that the need for TNVR is clearly documented as part of the public record.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Respectfully,
Julianna Arrant
Dear Mayor and Town Council Members,
I am writing as a community member to respectfully request that the Town of Apple Valley establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR (Trap-Neuter-Vaccinate-Return) program for community cats.
In August 2025, a TNVR-style program was made available to residents, allowing up to four vouchers per person for feral/community cats. However, it appears that this program is no longer available at this time.
Currently, the only known spay/neuter assistance is the Lange Foundation Intervention Program. While this effort is appreciated and helpful, it has important limitations:
• It is privately funded, not a Town program
• It primarily serves owned or friendly cats
• It is limited in availability and currently booked out As a result, there is currently no accessible, structured TNVR program for true community cats in Apple Valley.
At the same time:
• The shelter has adopted a managed intake policy for cats • Many community members are reporting increasing numbers of kittens and unaltered cats this spring
• Residents are actively seeking help for outdoor cats but have limited options When these conditions occur together — limited intake and no TNVR infrastructure — community cats are left without a clear pathway for care.
TNVR is widely recognized as the most effective and humane method to:
• Reduce outdoor cat populations over time
• Prevent repeated litters, especially during peak kitten season • Reduce shelter intake and long-term costs
• Support both animal welfare and community concerns
Without a functioning TNVR program, the current system places increasing pressure on:
• Residents
• Rescues and volunteers
• And ultimately the shelter system itself
I respectfully request that the Town:
• Establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR program for community cats • Ensure adequate capacity to meet actual community demand • Provide clear public information on eligibility and access • Consider expanding services during peak kitten season A sustainable TNVR program is a critical component of any effective community cat strategy, especially under a managed intake model.
This comment is submitted to ensure that the need for TNVR is clearly documented as part of the public record.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Respectfully,
Julia Chimento
Please keep the TNVR program going!
It reduces the number of cats living out on our streets, which also benefits local wildlife and lowers the number of euthanizations at the AV Shelter.
Hello,
I am a cat trapper in San Diego that helps at a local rescue and I know how important TNR is for community cats in San Diego. I hope that you will consider to fund a program for TNR in your neighborhood up there. Thank you, Trapper Jonas, RN Please implement a TNVR program in Apple Valley. It is needed desperately, and improvements are definitely needed in the running of the 'shelter'. Thank you.
Dear Mayor and Town Council Members,
I am writing as a very concerned person who has followed this issue closely as an animal rights activist to respectfully request that the Town of Apple Valley establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR (Trap-Neuter-Vaccinate-Return) program for community cats.
In August 2025, a TNVR-style program was made available to residents, allowing up to four vouchers per person for feral/community cats. However, it appears that this program is no longer available at this time.
Currently, the only known spay/neuter assistance is the Lange Foundation Intervention Program. While this effort is appreciated and helpful, it has important limitations:
It is privately funded, not a Town program
It primarily serves owned or friendly cats
It is limited in availability and currently booked out
As a result, there is currently no accessible, structured TNVR program for true community cats in Apple Valley.
At the same time:
The shelter has adopted a managed intake policy for cats Many community members are reporting increasing numbers of kittens and unaltered cats this spring
Residents are actively seeking help for outdoor cats but have limited options When these conditions occur together — limited intake and no TNVR infrastructure — community cats are left without a clear pathway for care.
TNVR is widely recognized as the most effective and humane method to:
Reduce outdoor cat populations over time
Prevent repeated litters, especially during peak kitten season Reduce shelter intake and long-term costs
Support both animal welfare and community concerns
Without a functioning TNVR program, the current system places increasing pressure on:
Residents
Rescues and volunteers
And ultimately the shelter system itself
I respectfully request that the Town:
• Establish a consistent, publicly supported TNVR program for community cats • Ensure adequate capacity to meet actual community demand • Provide clear public information on eligibility and access • Consider expanding services during peak kitten season A sustainable TNVR program is a critical component of any effective community cat strategy, especially under a managed intake model.
This comment is submitted to ensure that the need for TNVR is clearly documented as part of the public record.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Respectfully,
Brooke