8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
Valley Fever is endemic to the area, with 1,848 cases reported in Kern County in 2026 alone.15
The FEIR dismisses this impact as less than significant by asserting that compliance with SJVAPCD Rule 8021 (which requires a Dust Control Plan to maintain visible dust opacity below 20 percent) will adequately control Valley Fever exposure.16 This assertion is contradicted when the City simultaneously claims that active dust monitoring is ineffective because there is “no direct correlation” between fugitive dust particulate concentration levels and airborne Valley Fever fungal spores.17 The City cannot logically claim on one hand that fugitive dust suppression measures reduce Valley Fever risk, while asserting on the other that dust concentration levels do not correlate with fungal spore exposure.18 The FEIR’s conclusions are not supported by substantial evidence.
As Dr. Clark explains, Coccidioides arthroconidia spores range in size from 2 to 5 micrometers (𝜇𝜇m), falling directly within the respirable range of fine particulate matter (PM2.5 and PM10).19 Because these microscopic spores travel attached to fine airborne soil particles, fugitive dust concentration is the direct indicator of whether dust suppression measures are successfully containing spore dispersal.20 Furthermore, relying strictly on visual opacity criteria under Rule 8021 is insufficient; visual opacity measures are dominated by coarse soil particles, meaning fine respirable particles carrying fungal spores can escape off-site at dangerous, health-impairing levels without ever breaching the 20 percent visual plume threshold.21
The City also fails to account for unusually high local susceptibility and on-site soil contaminants. Under CEQA, environmental review must evaluate the sensitivity of the surrounding environment and the receptors exposed to potential project hazards.22 Here, the City failed to evaluate the project-specific factors that exacerbate the risk of Valley Fever infection and cumulative adverse health effects.
First, the FEIR contains no analysis evaluating how soil disturbance during earthmoving across the 46-acre site will impact the Green Acres Estates Senior 15 Clark Comments, p. 12.
16 FEIR, p. 2.0-44. 17 FEIR, p. 2.0-93; Clark Comments, p. 11. 18 FEIR, p. 2.0-91. 19 Clark Comments, p. 11. 20 Clark Comments, p. 11. 21 Clark Comments, p. 11; FEIR, p. 2.0-93. 22 CEQA Guidelines § 15125(a).
October 1, 2026
8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
Mobile Home Park, which is situated directly west of the site.23 Adults over the age of 60 represent a highly sensitive population facing a significantly heightened risk of severe, disseminated, and potentially fatal Valley Fever.24 The City’s continued failure to analyze and mitigate risks to this highly vulnerable adjacent demographic violates CEQA. Second, Valley Fever cases in Kern County remain extraordinarily high, with reported cases rising from 948 in 2001 to 3,873 in 2024, and continuing at elevated levels through 2025 and 2026.25 Disturbing 46 acres of dry soil in an area of extreme endemic prevalence presents a potentially significant public health impact.
The City attempts to excuse its lack of mitigation by citing California Division of Occupational Safety and Health (Cal/OSHA) requirements under Title 8 (Sections 3203, 5141, and 5144) and Labor Code Section 6709.26 But an agency cannot satisfy its obligation to analyze and mitigate off-site public environmental impacts by pointing to workplace safety laws intended solely for employee safety.
Title 8 and Labor Code regulations apply exclusively to site workers and do not prescribe fence-line exposure limits, public health protections, or off-site airborne spore containment strategies for nearby residents.27
The FEIR must mitigate the Project’s potentially significant Valley Fever impacts before the Project can be approved. The City must evaluate feasible, low-cost conditions proposed in Dr. Clark’s comments to minimize Valley Fever and particulate transport, including:
1. Mandating watering of all disturbed areas at least three to four times per day, which CalEEMod calculates achieves up to a 74 percent reduction in PM10 and PM2.5 emissions.28
2. Implementing real-time upwind and downwind perimeter PM10 and PM2.5 monitoring equipped with actionable exposure thresholds to trigger additional watering or work shutdowns.29
23 FEIR, p. 2.0-28; Clark Comments, p. 1. 24 Clark Comments, pp. 1, 13. 25 Clark Comments, p. 11. 26 FEIR, p. 2.0-44; Clark Comments, p. 13 27 Clark Comments, p. 13
28 Clark Comments, pp. 11–12. 29 Clark Comments, p. 12.
October 1, 2026
8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
3. Suspending grading and excavation activities whenever sustained wind speeds exceed 20 miles per hour.30
4. Mandatory covering of haul loads, cleaning vehicles prior to site departure, and establishing project-specific medical and respiratory protocols under the Injury and Illness Prevention Program.31
Because the City’s finding of a less-than-significant impact relies on contradictory assertions, fails to account for site-specific hazardous soil contaminants and sensitive senior receptors, and omits feasible mitigation, the Valley Fever analysis is legally inadequate under CEQA. The City must prepare a revised EIR that quantifies fine particulate transport, evaluates public health risks, and incorporates enforceable mitigation measures prior to project approval.
B. The FEIR Still Fails to Disclose and Mitigate Health Risk Impacts From Project Operations
1. The FEIR Still Fails to Analyze Health Risks from the Project’s Operational Emissions
CARE CA’s comments on the DEIR demonstrate that it fails to disclose, quantitatively analyze, and mitigate significant public health risks from exposure to TACs. The Project’s proposed fuel station, char broilers, car wash, and heavy-duty truck traffic will emit TACs, yet the DEIR relies on unsupported qualitative heuristics–rather than preparing a formal Health Risk Assessment (“HRA”)–to quantify operational health risk impacts.
The FEIR responds that the City’s operational health risk analysis is supported by substantial evidence because it relies on the California Air Resources Board (“CARB”) Air Quality and Land Use Handbook and rules established by the SJVAPCD.32 The City argues that whereas the CARB Handbook recommends against locating sensitive uses near within 500 feet of a freeway, urban roads with 100,000 vehicles/day, or rural roads with 50,000 vehicles/day, this Project would only add 5,934 daily trips to the nearby roadways.33 This argument lacks merit, as the City is essentially arguing that a Project would not result in 30 Clark Comments, p. 12. 31 Clark Comments, p. 12. 32 FEIR, p. 2.0-58. 33 DEIR, p. 4.3-31, 32.
October 1, 2026
8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
significant health risks from mobile sources unless it generates a freeway’s worth of traffic. The land use compatibility screening criteria in the CARB Handbook are intended to kickstart land use planning, not serve as a substitute for project-specific health risk evaluations or detailed environmental review under CEQA.34
The FEIR also fails to respond to CARE CA’s comment that the same CARB guidelines recommend against siting new sensitive land uses within 1,000 feet of a distribution center accommodating more than 100 trucks per day.35 This Project would result in 751 daily VMT for heavy trucks, demonstrating that the Project would present similar health risks as a warehouse project.36 The City’s failure to even acknowledge this comment violates CEQA’s requirements for good faith responses to comments received during the public comment period.37 It also illustrates that the FEIR’s discussion of the CARB Handbook is arbitrary and entirely unsupported.
The FEIR’s defects are particularly severe given the immediate proximity of the Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park, located just downwind of the proposed commercial facilities and truck loading docks.38 Elderly residents represent a sensitive demographic with heightened susceptibility to respiratory and cardiovascular toxicity from exposure to DPM and TACs.39 By relying on broad screening buffers rather than modeling actual dispersion patterns, truck idling times, traffic volume, and localized meteorology, the City improperly assumes a less-than-significant impact without evaluating the real-world exposure levels at these senior residences.40
2. The FEIR Piecemeals Analysis of Health Risk Impacts
From the Project’s Stationary Sources
Regarding health risk impacts from stationary sources such as fuel dispensing and charbroilers, the FEIR reiterates the DEIR’s assertion that these 34 Clark Comments, p. 11; FEIR, p. 2.0-58. 35 CARB, Air Quality And Land Use Handbook: A Community Health Perspective, p. 4, available at https://ww2.arb.ca.gov/sites/default/files/2023-05/Land%20Use%20Handbook_0.pdf. 36 DEIR, Appendix B, p. 119. 37 Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 14, § 15088(c).
38 FEIR, p. 2.0-28; Clark Comments, pp. 1, 11. 39 Clark Comments, p. 1. 40 Clark Comments, p. 11.
October 1, 2026
8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
sources would be controlled through the SJVAPCD permitting process.41 CARE CA previously explained that separating the Project’s emissions sources into categories and analyzing them separately constitutes piecemealing in violation of CEQA.
The FEIR “disagrees” that this legal standard precludes omitting stationary sources from its analysis of the Project’s health risks.42 The City argues that:
“[s]tationary sources were identified as distinct from the non-permitted sources to acknowledge the regulatory framework that exists for permitted sources within the SJVAPCD.”43 The City also relies on the SJVAPCD Guidance for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts (“GAMAQI”) to argue that emissions from sources permitted consistent with New Source Review requirements are per se not individually or cumulatively significant.44
These arguments lack merit because statutory compliance with local air district permitting rules cannot substitute for an EIR’s independent legal duty to evaluate total, combined health risks. CEQA mandates that an agency evaluate the total environment impact of the entire project, rather than evaluating individual emission sources in isolated silos. As previously explained, CEQA defines a “project” as “the whole of an action” that may result in either a direct physical environmental change or a reasonably foreseeable indirect change.45 CEQA mandates “that environmental considerations do not become submerged by chopping a large project into many little ones – each with a minimal potential impact on the environment – which cumulatively may have disastrous consequences.”46 When a single commercial development project introduces both stationary sources (such as fuel transfer emissions containing benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene, and xylene) and mobile sources (such as heavy-duty diesel truck trips producing Diesel Particulate Matter), those pollutants reach neighboring sensitive receptors concurrently.
Splitting the sources apart allows the City to claim that mobile sources pass a high-level screening threshold while assuming stationary sources are exempt from CEQA scrutiny by virtue of future air district permits.
41 FEIR, pp. 2.0-55, 59. 42 FEIR, pp. 2.0-59.
43 Id. 44 FEIR, p. 2.0-58. 45 14 Cal. Code Regs. Sec. 15378. 46 Bozung v. LAFCO (1975) 13 Cal.3d 263, 283-84; City of Santee v. County of San Diego (1989) 214 Cal.App.3d 1438, 1452; Citizens Assn. for Sensible Development of Bishop Area v. County of Inyo (1985) 172 Cal.App.3d 151, 165.
October 1, 2026
8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
The FEIR’s piecemealed review also conflicts with SJVAPCD guidance. For development projects such as this one, “[t]he District recommends an AAQA be performed for ALL Criteria Pollutant emissions for which an ambient air quality standard exists when a development projects would result in an increase of 100 pounds per day screening level of ANY pollutant for any of the following categories:
Construction emission activities [,] Operational permitted source emission activities, or […] Operational non-permitted source emission activities.”47 SJVAPCD guidance also provides that “the assessment of operational emissions in the AAQA shall evaluate operational sources within the project boundary [such as “boilers, process heaters, etc.”] as well as project-related mobile emissions…”48 The City’s improper segmentation creates a severe analytical loophole that conceals potentially significant public health risks. Adjacent sensitive receptors, such as elderly residents located at the nearby Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park, breathe ambient air that reflects the combined toxic load of all project operations simultaneously. CEQA Guidelines Section 15064(f) requires that an agency’s significance determination be supported by substantial evidence considering the whole project. By refusing to perform a unified, site-specific HRA that models the additive TAC exposures from both the gas station and heavy-duty delivery truck traffic, the City lacks substantial evidence supporting its less-than-significant health risk finding.
Compliance with SJVAPCD Regulation II rules does not relieve the City of its lead agency duty under CEQA to analyze and mitigate total off-site health impacts before Project approval. Because the FEIR improperly relies on piecemealed source evaluations to avoid assessing aggregate TAC concentrations, the FEIR’s operational health risk analysis is legally inadequate under CEQA. The City must revise its environmental review to include a comprehensive HRA that evaluates all stationary and mobile health risk impacts combined into a single, whole-project disclosure.
3. The FEIR Still Fails to Adequately Analyze Cumulative Health Risk Impacts from Construction Activities
CARE CA’s comments on the DEIR demonstrated that the City’s analysis of cumulative health risks during construction is contrary to law. A major issue is that 47 SJVAPCD, Project Ambient Air Quality Analysis Applicability Determination Under CEQA (June 2018), p. 5, https://www.valleyair.org/media/bo3hz35n/apr-2030.pdf. 48 Id. at 4-5.
October 1, 2026
8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
the DEIR asserts that any exceedance of a project-level threshold (cancer risk of 20 in one million) also is considered to be a cumulatively considerable effect, while health risks that fall below applicable project-level thresholds are not considered cumulatively considerable.49 CARE CA demonstrated that this approach fails to consider the Project’s cumulative effects with existing and proposed development near the Project site as required by CEQA.50 It also ignores the existing environmental pollution burden, as the surrounding census tract ranks in the 99th percentile in the State for PM2.5 pollution.51
The FEIR responds that any project with health risks below the individual threshold is automatically not cumulatively considerable.52 The FEIR argues that SJVAPCD guidance provides that the 20 in one million cancer risk threshold was set at such a conservative level that no cumulative impacts could occur.53 This assertion does not appear to be supported, as AB 2588 (Air Toxics “Hot Spots”) and other air districts set a 10 in one million cancer risk threshold – twice as stringent as the SJVAPCD threshold.54 In fact, the SJVAPCD guidance was referring to a 10 in one million significance threshold, which was later revised to 20 in one million.55 This threshold also ignores the existing environmental pollution burden, as the surrounding census tract ranks in the 99th percentile in the State for PM2.5 pollution.56 Thus, even if 20 in one million were a conservative significance threshold for a different area, it is possible that health risk impacts would be cumulatively considerable in this highly pollution-burdened area. 49 DEIR, Appendix B, p. 57 (“projects that do not generate emissions that exceed the values in Table 13 would not substantially contribute to cumulative air quality hazards or exacerbate an existing environmental hazard.”).
50 Kings County Farm Bureau v. City of Hanford (1990) 221 Cal. App. 3d 692. 51 Clark Comments, p. 10. 52 FEIR, p. 2.0-60. 53 FEIR, p. 2.0-60. 54 See SCAQMD, South Coast AQMD Air Quality Significance Thresholds, https://www.aqmd.gov/docs/default-source/ceqa/handbook/south-coast-aqmd-air-quality-significance-thresholds.pdf?sfvrsn=f7601d61_25. 55 SJVAPCD, Guide for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts, pp. 100, 110, 56 Clark Comments, p. 10.
October 1, 2026
8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
4. The FEIR Still Fails to Adequately Analyze Cumulative Health Risk Impacts from Operations
The FEIR does not include an operational HRA. The FEIR claims that an operational HRA need not be prepared because one was prepared for a warehouse project in Kern County with more truck trips that did not result in significant impacts.57 But Dr. Clark explains that an HRA for a different project, at a different location, with different meteorological data, receptor distances, site layout, and truck activity, does not estimate the risk from this Project.58 That HRA also addressed truck emissions only, whereas the instant Project includes a gasoline station and charbroilers.59 Truck-related risk at a receptor depends mostly on truck activity close to that receptor (on-site travel, idling, and TRU operation), not on the daily trip count alone, so the result cannot be scaled to this Project by comparing trip totals.60 Therefore, the FEIR lacks substantial evidence to conclude that health risk impacts from operations would not be cumulatively considerable.
5. The FEIR Proposes Illusory Mitigation for Operational Health Risks
The FEIR describes a Condition of Approval (“COA”) to address health risks posed by possible under-fired charbroilers.61 The measure would require that a health risk assessment shall be required for any future charbroilers, and that mitigation be adopted to reduce health risks from the charbroilers if they exceed SJVAPCD’s 20 in one million cancer risk threshold.62 This mitigation is inadequate because it again piecemeals emissions from stationary sources from the Project’s other emissions sources. Operational health risks from the Project’s total operations may exceed the significance thresholds even if charbroilers are individually below the thresholds. Therefore, this mitigation would not adequately mitigate impacts from the whole of the Project. And by calling for an HRA for future charbroilers, the FEIR paradoxically requires more review for a single component of the Project than 57 FEIR, p. 2.0-60 (“As identified in response to the SJVAPCD Comment A2.2, an operational HRA was prepared for a warehouse project in Kern County (SCH# 2025030498) that generates substantially more heavy duty diesel truck trips per day than the commercial uses associated with the proposed Project, which supports the conclusions in the Draft EIR that the proposed Project would not generate a substantial amount of truck trips that would warrant an operational HRA.”) 58 Clark Comments, p. 18.
59 Clark Comments, p 18.
60 Id.
61 FEIR, p. 2.0-61.
62 Id.
October 1, 2026
8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
included in the FEIR for the Project as a whole. The EIR must be revised to quantify operational health risks and analyze them along with cumulative sources of emissions.
6. The FEIR Still Fails to Adequately Analyze Cumulatively Considerable Emissions of Criteria Air Pollutants
As with its analysis of cumulative health risks, the FEIR assumes that emissions of criteria air pollutants below adopted regionals significance thresholds could not be cumulatively considerable.63 The FEIR fails to analyze the Project’s emissions in combination with other existing or proposed sources of emissions in the area. The FEIR’s analysis conflicts with SJVAPCD’s guidance on cumulative emissions of criteria pollutants. SJVAPCD’s Guide for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts provides:
If a project is significant based on the thresholds of significance for criteria pollutants, then it is also cumulatively significant. This does not imply that if the project is below all such significance thresholds, it cannot be cumulatively significant. For instance, another measure of a project’s individual significance contained in the GAMAQI is the impact on criteria pollutant concentrations in the ambient air. If the concentration exceeds any of the federal health-based ambient air concentration standards or causes a worsening of areas already exceeding those standards, the project is considered to be individually significant. Lead Agencies should also consider the cumulative impact of multiple simultaneously proposed projects, located within the same area. If the combined impacts of such projects cause or worsen an exceedance of the concentration standards, the project would have a cumulatively significant impact under CEQA. For example, simultaneous proposals for two 3 ton per year NOx sources located in the same area are each below the 10 ton per year criteria pollutant significance threshold. In this hypothetical example, analysis of each project’s impact on ambient air quality shows that they do not individually cause an exceedance of any ambient air quality standard.
However, when their combined emissions are considered, air quality modeling determines that their combined impacts cause an exceedance. In 63 FEIR, p. 2.0-60.
October 1, 2026
8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
this hypothetical case, each of these projects would be considered to have a cumulatively significant impact.64
To comport with this guidance, the FEIR must be revised to analyze combined emissions with nearby proposed projects in Table 3-1 of the DEIR.65
7. The FEIR Fails to Disclose that the Project’s Operations Would Result In Exceedance of Ambient Air Quality Standards for PM2.5
SJVAPCD’s Guide for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts provides that a project would be considered to have a significant impact if it would contribute to a violation of an ambient air quality standard by exceeding any of the CAAQS, or any of the NAAQS.66 Here, the proposed Project would elevate PM2.5 concentrations above the 24-hour National AAQS and the annual National AAQS and California AAQS, but the FEIR fails to identify these exceedances as significant impacts.67 The FEIR reasons that because Project-generated PM2.5 concentrations would not exceed the SJVAPCD significant impact levels, the potential for operation of the Project to contribute to an AAQS exceedance would also be less than significant.68 This reasoning ignores the plain language of the SJVAPCD guidance stating that an exceedance of any AAQS constitutes a significant impact.69 The FEIR must be revised to disclose and mitigate this impact.
C. The FEIR Still Fails to Identify All Feasible GHG Mitigation The FEIR finds that emissions of GHGs would be significant and unavoidable.70 CEQA requires agencies to adopt all feasible mitigation before finding that a significant impact is unavoidable.71 The City violates this 64 SJVAPCD, Guide for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts, p. 107-108, https://www.valleyair.org/media/g4nl3p0g/gamaqi.pdf. 65 DEIR, p. 3-2. 66 SJVAPCD, Guide for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts, p. 90 67 DEIR, p. Table 4.3-13. 68 FEIR, p. 2.0-64.
69 SJVAPCD, Guide for Assessing and Mitigating Air Quality Impacts, p. 90. 70 DEIR, p. ES-17.
71 CEQA Guidelines § 15002(a)(2); PRC § 21081(a)(3), (b); CEQA Guidelines §§ 15090, 15091; Covington v. Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control Dist. (2019) 43 Cal.App.5th 867, 883.
October 1, 2026
8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
requirement by ignoring feasible mitigation proposed in SJVAPCD’s and CARE CA’s comments.72
For example, CARE CA and SJVAPCD recommended reducing the permissible idling time of diesel trucks,73 but the FEIR fails to evaluate the feasibility of reducing the permissible idling period below the five minutes already required by law.74 The FEIR, merely responds that the Project would comply with the five-minute regulatory standard.75
SJVAPCD also recommended requiring installation, as technologically feasible, of particulate matter emission control systems for new large restaurants operating under-fired charbroilers.76 The City fails to implement this measure, instead calling for mitigation for charbroiler emissions only if they would result in health risks exceeding 20 in one million.77 This measure is inadequate because the Project’s significant GHG impacts requires the City to implement all feasible mitigation; a measure that only requires mitigation if a different impact would be significant is invalid.
D. The FEIR Still Fails to Adequately Analyze and Mitigate Transportation Impacts
1. The FEIR Fails to Identify Feasible Mitigation For the Project’s Significant VMT Impact
The FEIR finds that the Project would result in significant and unavoidable VMT impacts.78 CEQA thus requires the City to adopt all feasible mitigation measures. CARE CA recommended that the Project implement CAPCOA Handbook Measure T-5, “Implement Commute Trip Reduction (Voluntary).”79 The FEIR responds that “[t]he proposed implementation of employer-provided services, infrastructure, and alternative transit incentives to reduce Project VMT is 72 DEIR, Appendix A, p. 18 et seq.
73 DEIR, Appendix A, p. 23.
74 DEIR, p. 4.3-5.
75 FEIR, p. 2.0-66 (Response No. O2.31); 2.0-86 (“Because California Code of Regulations Sections 2480 and 2485 of Title 13 are codified anti-idling regulations and are legally binding, the underlying presumption is that the Project would comply with these two rules.”) 76 FEIR, p. 2.0-17.
77 FEIR, p. 2.0-18.
78 DEIR, p. 4.16-16.
79 FEIR, p. 2.0-70.
October 1, 2026
8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
practically infeasible” because “the Project Applicant possesses no legal mechanism to compel commercial tenants to implement, manage, or enforce employer-based transit programs.”80 This statement is incorrect, as the FEIR can include a measure requiring tenant lease agreements to include certain requirements.
Under Public Resources Code Section 21061.1 and CEQA Guidelines Section 15364, “feasible” means capable of being accomplished in a successful manner within a reasonable period of time, taking into account economic, environmental, legal, social, and technological factors. When an EIR identifies significant, unmitigated impacts, the agency bears the affirmative legal burden under CEQA Guidelines Section 15091 to demonstrate, through substantial evidence, that proposed additional mitigation measures are actually infeasible.
A bare claim of infeasibility, unsupported by concrete evidence, constitutes a procedural and substantive violation of CEQA.81 In Los Angeles Unified School District v. City of Los Angeles,82 the Court of Appeal invalidated an EIR where the lead agency dismissed feasible noise mitigation measures based on vague statements of impracticality without providing supporting technical or economic data. Similarly, in Flanders Foundation v. City of Carmel-by-the-Sea,83 the court held that an agency’s infeasibility determination must be supported by actual, quantifiable evidence rather than mere assertions of difficulty or administrative preference.
The City’s response fails to meet CEQA’s standards by failing to identify actual factual, economic, legal, or technical justifications precluding implementation of Measure T-5. Factually and practically, CAPCOA Measure T-5 is fully feasible and well suited for commercial developments of this nature. As Mr. Marshall explains, CAPCOA Handbook Measure T-5 establishes a proven framework to achieve up to a 4.0% reduction in VMT by incorporating voluntary commute trip reduction elements, including employer-provided infrastructure, incentives for alternative transit modes such as ridesharing (Measure T-8), discounted transit (Measure T-9), bicycling (Measure T-10), vanpools (Measure T-11), guaranteed ride home programs, and coordinated marketing and information services (Measure T-80 FEIR, p. 2.0-71. 81 City of San Jose v. Great Oaks Water Co. (1987) 192 Cal.App.3d 1005, 1017; Sierra Club v. County of Fresno (2018) 6 Cal.5th 502, 513.
82 (1997) 58 Cal.App.4th 1019, 1029–1031. 83 (2012) 202 Cal.App.4th 603, 618–620.
October 1, 2026
8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
7).84 Given that the FEIR concedes the Project’s retail and medical office components generate significant, unmitigated VMT impacts, the City cannot legally ignore an established, standard mitigation measure published in CAPCOA guidance without providing specific facts and findings demonstrating infeasibility.
CARE CA also recommended that the City require CAPCOA Measure T-6 (“Implement Commute Trip Reduction Program (Mandatory Implementation and Monitoring”).85 These can reduce GHG emissions from employee commute VMT by up to 26%.86 The FEIR dismisses this measure without explanation. Response No.
O2.36 only includes legal boilerplate:
CEQA does not require analysis of every imaginable alternative or mitigation measure; its concern is with feasible means of reducing environmental effects. Section 21002 states in part that the intention of CEQA is ‘to assist public agencies in systematically identifying both the significant effects of proposed projects and the feasible alternatives or feasible mitigation measures which will avoid or substantially lessen such significant effects.’” (Bowman v. City of Petaluma (1986) 185 Cal.App.3d 1065, 1083.) Consequently, CEQA does not mandate implementation of mitigation measures where they would be ineffective as either inapplicable to a project element or purported impact. (Ibid.) Because the commenter has failed to present feasible mitigation that was not already considered in the Draft EIR or identify a significant new or intensified impact, recirculation of the Draft EIR is not legally required under CEQA Guidelines Section 15088.5.87 The FEIR both violates CEQA’s requirement to identify all feasible mitigation for significant impacts and CEQA’s standards for responses to public comments received on the DEIR. The EIR must be revised and recirculated. 84 Marshall Comments, p. 2.
85 CAPCOA Handbook, T-6. Implement Commute Trip Reduction Program (Mandatory Implementation and Monitoring)
https://www.caleemod.com/documents/handbook/ch_3_transportation/measure_t-6.pdf. 86 Id. 87 FEIR, p. 2.0-72.
October 1, 2026
8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
E. The FEIR Still Fails to Analyze Potentially Significant Public Utilities Impacts
CARE CA’s comments on the DEIR demonstrated that the City failed to analyze whether the Project would require offsite water infrastructure to meet the Project’s fire flow demands. Construction of improvements to existing water infrastructure may be required because the Project proposes a large new development on a vacant site. Further, the Bakersfield system has historic low-pressure areas where the minimum normal operating pressure ranges between 25 and 40 psi.88 Upgrades to offsite water mains may be required to service the Project, potentially resulting in construction activities much closer to sensitive receptors than assumed in the EIR.
The FEIR fails to provide this omitted analysis, and the FEIR’s responses do not address the specific issues raised in CARE CA’s comments. The FEIR responds that the Project’s fire flow will be determined before construction of the Project.89 This results in a failure to analyze the Project’s public utilities impacts before Project approval. And although any offsite water infrastructure upgrades may be required to meet regulatory standards, there are no measures requiring mitigation for noise, air quality, and transportation impacts that may arise from this offsite construction. The FEIR thus lacks substantial evidence to find that the Project would not require extensive offsite public utilities upgrades to provide adequate fire flow, or that such improvements would not cause significant environmental impacts.
The FEIR’s approach conflicts with CEQA’s prohibition on deferred analysis.
CEQA requires that an environmental document disclose the severity of a project’s impacts and the probability of their occurrence before a project can be approved.90 In Sundstrom v. County of Mendocino,91 the First District Court of Appeal rejected a mitigation measure that required the applicant to submit hydrological studies subject to review and approval by a planning commission and county environmental 88 California Water Service, Capital Project Justification Bakersfield District, July 2021, p. 97, https://docs.cpuc.ca.gov/PublishedDocs/SupDoc/A2107002/3862/393926055.pdf. 89 FEIR, p. 2.0-73. 90 14 CCR §§ 15143, 15162.2(a); Cal. Build. Indust. Ass’n v. BAAQMD (2015) 62 Cal.4th 369, 388-90 (“CBIA v. BAAQMD”) (disturbance of toxic soil contamination at project site is potentially significant impact requiring CEQA review and mitigation); Madera Oversight Coalition v. County of Madera (2011) 199 Cal. App. 4th 48, 82; Berkeley Keep Jets Over the Bay Com. v. Bd. of Port Comrs. (“Berkeley Jets”) (2001) 91 Cal.App.4th 1344, 1370-71; CEQA Guidelines, Appendix G. 91 (1988) 202 Cal.App.3d 296.
October 1, 2026
8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
health department.92 The Court explained that the deferred analysis of hydrological conditions fails to meet CEQA’s requirement that an environmental impact should be assessed as early as possible in government planning:
By deferring environmental assessment to a future date, the conditions run counter to that policy of CEQA which requires environmental review at the earliest feasible stage in the planning process. (See Pub. Resources Code, § 21003.1; No Oil, Inc. v. City of Los Angeles, supra, 13 Cal. 3d 68, 84.) In Bozung v. Local Agency Formation Com., supra, 13 Cal. 3d 263, 282, the Supreme Court approved “the principle that the environmental impact should be assessed as early as possible in government planning.” Environmental problems should be considered at a point in the planning process “‘where genuine flexibility remains.’” (Mount Sutro Defense Committee v. Regents of University of California, supra, 77 Cal. App. 3d 20,
34.) A study conducted after approval of a project will inevitably have a diminished influence on decision making. Even if the study is subject to administrative approval, it is analogous to the sort of post hoc rationalization of agency actions that has been repeatedly condemned in decisions construing CEQA. (Id. at p. 35; No Oil, Inc. v. City of Los Angeles, supra, 13 Cal. 3d 68, 81; Environmental Defense Fund, Inc. v. Coastside County Water Dist. (1972) 27 Cal. App. 3d 695, 706 [104 Cal. Rptr. 197].)
Here, the FEIR provides no facts showing it would be infeasible to identify the Project’s fire flow requirements, determine whether existing infrastructure would need to be upsized, evaluate the impacts from construction of these upgrades, and include the results in the CEQA. The FEIR therefore fails as an informational document and is unsupported by substantial evidence.
III. THE EIR MUST BE RECIRCULATED
CEQA requires a lead agency to recirculate a DEIR when “significant new information” is added to the environmental review after public notice and comment, but prior to certification. Under CEQA Guidelines § 15088.5, new information is deemed “significant” if the EIR is changed in a way that deprives the public of a meaningful opportunity to comment upon a substantial adverse environmental effect or a feasible way to mitigate or avoid such an effect. Specifically, Guidelines § 15088.5(a) provides that recirculation is required under any of the following four circumstances:
92 Id. at 306.
October 1, 2026
8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
1. A new significant environmental impact would result from the project or from a new mitigation measure proposed to be implemented.
2. A substantial increase in the severity of an environmental impact would result unless mitigation measures are adopted that reduce the impact to a level of insignificance.
3. A feasible project alternative or mitigation measure considerably different from others previously analyzed would clearly lessen the environmental impacts of the project, but the project’s proponents have declined to adopt it.
4. The draft EIR was so fundamentally and basically inadequate and conclusory in nature that meaningful public review and comment were precluded.
Here, the FEIR contains significant new information requiring recirculation of the EIR.
1. The FEIR Now Discloses that the Project Would Have
Potentially Significant Impacts on Special Status Species Habitat and Identifies New Mitigation
Under Guidelines § 15088.5(a)(2), recirculation of an EIR is mandated when significant new information added to the report demonstrates that a substantial increase in the severity of an environmental impact would result unless mitigation measures are adopted that reduce the impact to a level of insignificance. In the DEIR, the City originally concluded that suitable habitat for both the Crotch bumble bee (Bombus crotchii) and the San Joaquin kit fox (Vulpes macrotis mutica, “SJKF”) was entirely absent on the Project site.93 However, in response to comments and substantial evidence submitted by the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (“CDFW”) and other public commenters establishing that the site contains suitable habitat and that SJKF historically and recently inhabit the surrounding area, the FEIR fundamentally reverses its baseline position.94 Specifically, the FEIR introduces new factual determinations, acknowledging for the first time that while the site’s disturbed condition and urban surroundings reduce habitat quality for a majority of species, these conditions “do not eliminate urban San Joaquin kit fox population and recent or historical occurrences near the Project, including use of disturbed or altered land” and admitting that “[t]he open 93 DEIR, pp. 3.4-12–3.4-14; p. 3.0-10 (“There is no suitable habitat for this species present on the project site”); p. 2.0-5 (“The DEIR concludes that suitable habitat for the San Joaquin kit fox (SJKF) is absent on the Project site based on a single general wildlife survey conducted in November 2025.”). 94 FEIR, p. 3.4-16; pp. 2-15–2-18.
October 1, 2026
8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
site may provide intermittent denning, and movement opportunities even where vegetation is sparse.”95 Furthermore, the FEIR incorporates admissions from the City’s biological consultant acknowledging “that Crotch’s bumble bee habitat cannot be conclusively determined during a non-blooming survey period and that SJKF may use disturbed urban areas for movement and denning.”96 This radical change in the EIR’s factual baseline triggers mandatory recirculation under Guidelines § 15088.5(a)(1) and (a)(2) because the FEIR identifies previously undisclosed, significant potential impacts to special-status species and their active movement/denning habitats.97 To address these newly disclosed impacts, the FEIR inserts entirely new biological mitigation measures— including mandatory pre-construction survey protocols, avoidance buffer zones, potential natal den excavation requirements for SJKF, and species-specific foraging habitat preservation protocols for the Crotch bumble bee—that were completely absent from the DEIR.98
In Response A1.5, the lead agency attempts to avoid recirculation by claiming that these FEIR revisions merely represent “clarifications” or “amplifications” of the DEIR’s existing biological analysis.99 This argument fails as a matter of law because changing an impact determination from “habitat absent” in the DEIR to acknowledging active intermittent denning, movement opportunities, and potential special-status species habitat in the FEIR is a fundamental change in factual baseline rather than a minor clarification.100 By withholding the acknowledgment of suitable SJKF and Crotch bumble bee habitat until the FEIR and adding new mitigation measures after the close of public review, the lead agency deprived the public, CDFW, and trustee agencies of their legal right under CEQA Guidelines § 15088.5(a)(4) to meaningfully evaluate and comment upon the adequacy, enforceability, and feasibility of these newly formulated biological protections.101 Because the FEIR relies on post-DEIR habitat acknowledgments and uncirculated mitigation schemes to assert that impacts to SJKF and Crotch bumble bee are reduced to a less-than-significant level, the lead agency must recirculate the revised EIR prior to project approval or certification.102
95 FEIR, Biological Resources, p. 3.4-17. 96 FEIR, pp. 3.4-19, 2-22. 97 FEIR, pp. 1-2, 3.4-20–3.4-22. 98 FEIR, pp. 3.4-23–3.4-28. 99 FEIR, p. 2-42. 100 FEIR, pp. 2-43, 3.4-17. 101 FEIR, pp. 1-3, 2-44. 102 FEIR, pp. 1-4, 3.4-30.
October 1, 2026
8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
2. The DEIR (And Now FEIR) Omitted Major Analyses That
Precluded Meaningful Public Review And Comment
Under Guidelines Section 15088.5(a)(4), recirculation of an EIR is mandatory where the DEIR was so fundamentally and basically inadequate and conclusory in nature that meaningful public review and comment were precluded. The record demonstrates that this DEIR suffered from profound analytical omissions that deprived the public and trustee agencies of a meaningful opportunity to evaluate the Project’s environmental consequences, triggering mandatory recirculation under Section 15088.5(a)(4).
As discussed above, a glaring analytical omission in the EIR is the complete failure to evaluate and disclose public health risks associated with Valley Fever exposure. Soil-disturbing construction activities across 46 acres in Kern County—a region where Valley Fever is endemic and where 1,848 cases were reported in 2026 alone—present a severe health hazard to local workers and nearby residents.103 The DEIR omitted discussion and mitigation of Valley Fever entirely.
The EIR further suffers from critical omissions regarding operational health risks from TACs. Rather than conducting a formal HRA to model exposure from heavy-duty diesel truck traffic, a proposed fuel station, charbroilers, and a car wash, the DEIR relied on broad qualitative screening heuristics from the CARB Handbook.104 By failing to perform a unified HRA that models additive TAC exposures, the lead agency omitted essential information necessary for meaningful public review.
In addition, the EIR improperly deferred the analysis of public utilities impacts in violation of CEQA’s prohibition against post-hoc environmental review.105 CARE CA demonstrated that the Project may require offsite water main upgrades to meet fire flow demands in a municipal system characterized by historic low-pressure areas.106 Rather than analyzing whether offsite construction would be required and evaluating the resulting air quality, noise, and traffic impacts on nearby receptors, the FEIR states that fire flow requirements will be determined 103 FEIR, p. 2.0-44. 104 FEIR, p. 2.0-52. 105 FEIR, p. 2.0-72. 106 FEIR, p. 2.0-72.
October 1, 2026
8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
prior to construction.107 Deferring environmental assessment to post-approval study deprives the public of the ability to comment on the true physical footprint and secondary construction impacts of the Project.108
Because the Draft EIR omitted critical disclosures regarding endemic Valley Fever, operational TAC exposures, and offsite utility construction, meaningful public review and comment were precluded. Consequently, the Planning Commission cannot recommend certification of the FEIR, and the City must revise and recirculate the EIR pursuant to Guidelines Section 15088.5(a)(4).
IV. THE CITY LACKS SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE TO MAKE THE
PROJECT’S LAND USE APPROVALS
A. The City Cannot Certify the FEIR, Adopt a Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program, and Adopt Findings of Fact Draft Resolution ENV 23-0001 is a Planning Commission resolution recommending that the City Council certify the FEIR, adopt an MMRP, and adopt findings of fact. The Resolution includes a finding that “[t]he provisions of CEQA, the State CEQA Guidelines, and the City of Bakersfield CEQA Implementation Procedures have been followed.”109 This finding is not supported by substantial evidence, as these comments demonstrate that the FEIR violates CEQA’s procedural, informational, and analytical requirements. The Project would have significant impacts concerning health risk, air quality, GHG, noise, public utilities that have not been adequately disclosed and mitigated, and the FEIR contains significant new information requiring recirculation before the Draft Resolution can be approved. In sum, the Planning Commission lacks the evidence necessary to recommend certification of the FEIR, or adoption of Findings of Fact and MMRP.
B. The City Cannot Make the Requisite Findings to Approve the General Plan Amendment
Draft Resolution No. GPA 23-0001 is a Planning Commission resolution recommending that the City Council approve the Project’s General Plan Amendment. The Resolution includes a finding that “[t]he Project is compatible with the land use designations and development of surrounding properties and is 107 FEIR, p. 2.0-72. 108 FEIR, p. 2.0-73.
109 Draft Resolution ENV 23-0001, p. 2.
October 1, 2026
8343-007acp
printed on recycled paper
internally consistent with the Metropolitan Bakersfield General Plan.”110 The City lacks substantial evidence to make this finding because the Project would result in potentially significant air quality, health risk, and noise impacts to senior residents at the Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park, which is situated directly west of the site.111 The Staff Report fails to mention this land use anywhere in its discussion of the Project’s consistency with the surrounding properties. Therefore, the Planning Commission lacks substantial evidence to approve the Resolution.
Conversely, substantial evidence in the record demonstrates that the Project’s construction and operation would impact the health and general welfare of residents near the Project site. Residents would be exposed to fugitive dust disturbed during construction activities, which may expose them to Valley Fever spores. Residents would be exposed to potentially significant concentrations of TACs during operations, but the FEIR failed to analyze this risk in a quantitative HRA.
Air quality and noise impacts to residents would be much higher than disclosed in the FEIR if the Project requires offsite construction to upsize water mains. The City cannot approve the General Plan Amendment until these impacts are analyzed and mitigated in accordance with CEQA.
V. CONCLUSION
For the reasons discussed above, the FEIR for the Project remains wholly inadequate under CEQA. It must be thoroughly revised to provide legally adequate analysis of, and mitigation for, all of the Project’s potentially significant impacts.
These revisions will require that the EIR be recirculated for public review. Until the EIR has been revised and recirculated, as described herein, the City may not lawfully approve the Project. Further, the record does not support the findings necessary to make the Project approvals. CARE CA urges the Planning Commission to recommend that the City revise and recirculate the EIR before any further action is taken on the Project.
Sincerely,
Aidan P. Marshall
Attachments
APM:acp
110 Draft Resolution No. GPA 23-0001, p. 2. 111 FEIR, p. 2.0-28; Clark Comments, p. 1.
EXHIBIT A
P a g e | 1
September 23, 2026
Adams Broadwell Joseph & Cardozo
601 Gateway Boulevard, Suite 1000
South San Francisco, CA 94080
Attn: Mr. Aidan P. Marshall
Subject: Response to the City of Bakersfield's Responses to Comments in the Final Environmental Impact
Report (FEIR) for the Riverview Marketplace
Commercial Project, City of Bakersfield, Kern
County, California (State Clearinghouse No.
2025101507
Dear Mr. Marshall:
At the request of Adams Broadwell Joseph & Cardozo (ABJC), I have reviewed the City of Bakersfield (City) Final Environmental Impact Report (FEIR) for the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project (Project), dated September 2026. My review focused on the City's responses to my August 21, 2026 comment letter on the Draft EIR (DEIR), which the City reproduced as Appendix O2A and answered in Responses O2A-1 through O2A-14. I also reviewed the City's responses to the comment letter submitted by the San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District (SJVAPCD or District) (Comment Letter A2, Responses A2.1 through A2.14), the related responses to ABJC's letter that repeat or expand on the City's technical positions (Responses O2.12 through O2.28), and the revisions in the FEIR Errata (Section 3.0).
The City's responses in the FEIR do not resolve the deficiencies I identified in the DEIR nor do they address the District's comments.
Several responses introduce new figures that conflict with one another or with the DEIR. Others rely on screening tools and permit programs that were not designed to answer the questions raised.
The FEIR also confirms, for the first time, that total PM2.5 concentrations at nearby receptors would exceed the federal and state ambient air quality standards within the Project in operation.
Clark & Associates
Environmental Consulting, Inc.
OFFICE
12405 Venice Blvd
Suite 331
Los Angeles, CA 90066
PHONE
310-907-6165
EMAIL
[email protected]
P a g e | 2
My review of the materials in no way constitutes a validation of the conclusions or materials contained within the FEIR. If I do not comment on a specific item, this does not constitute acceptance of that item.
PART I. THE CITY'S RESPONSES TO CLARK'S COMMENTS
Responses O2A-1 through O2A-3: Project Description and Environmental Setting The City noted the project description and setting comments without responding to the substance of my comment. The setting information is directly relevant to the impacts discussed below and should not be set aside as background.
First, the Project site is subject to a 2019 Land Use Covenant because on-site soils contain total petroleum hydrocarbons as diesel and motor oil, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs), and Title 22 metals. Fugitive dust generated by grading and excavation across the 46-acre site can carry these contaminants off-site along with Coccidioides spores. This makes the City's reliance on visual opacity limits for dust control (Responses O2A-9 and O2A-12) a greater concern here than on an uncontaminated site.
Second, the FEIR itself identifies the nearest residential community to the west as the Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park.1 This confirms my point that the nearest receptors include older residents, who are more susceptible to the effects of fine particulate matter and toxic air contaminants (TACs) and are at higher risk of severe Valley Fever. None of the City's responses account for the sensitivity of this population.
1 FEIR, Response O1.5, pp. 2.0-27 to 2.0-28.
P a g e | 3
Figure 1: Project Site and Surrounding Land Uses (DEIR Figure 2-2, Local Vicinity Map) Figure 2: FEIR Response O1.5, p. 2.0-28 (City identifies the Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park)
Responses O2A-4 and O2A-8: Pollution Burden and CalEnviroScreen Results The City states that the CalEnviroScreen 4.0 results were provided in the CalEEMod output files in Appendix B, that the adjacent census tract scores higher primarily because it contains State Route 99, and that the adjacent tract's score has no relevance to the Project. These statements do not address my comment.
P a g e | 4
Figure 3: FEIR Response O2A-8, p. 2.0-89
First, placing percentile scores in model output files is not a full disclosure to the public regarding the potential impacts that currently exist nor does it provide the decision makers with adequate information for their review. The air quality section of the DEIR does not discuss them, and the FEIR Errata does not add them.
Second, the pollution-burden indicators I cited are for the Project's own census tract, not the adjacent tract: PM2.5 in approximately the 99th percentile statewide and ozone in approximately the 94th percentile. The City's explanation about State Route 99 and the adjacent tract's composite score does not speak to these values. The FEIR provides no indicator data for the adjacent tract to support its explanation. The Project would add approximately 14.6 tons per year of VOC and 10.3 tons per year of NOx (both ozone precursors), along with direct PM2.5, to a tract that already ranks near the top of the state for both pollutants.
P a g e | 5
Figure 4: CalEnviroScreen 4.0 Pollution Burden Indicators for the Project Census Tract (DEIR Appendix B)
Figure 5: Project Location and Adjacent SB 535 Disadvantaged Community (Tract 6029000507) Third, the City's own ambient air quality analysis (AAQA) confirms the concern. The FEIR states that, with the Project in operation, total PM2.5 concentrations would exceed the 24-hour National Ambient Air Quality Standard (NAAQS), the annual NAAQS, and the annual California Ambient P a g e | 6
Air Quality Standard (CAAQS).2 The City finds the impact less than significant only because the Project's increment falls below the District's significant impact levels (SILs). As a result, the Project would add PM2.5 at receptors where the standards are already exceeded. The FEIR does not report the size of that increment at the Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park nor does it report the size of the increase at the residences in the tract east of Coffee Road, and it does not identify any on-site measure to reduce the PM2.5 increases. Feasible measures that would lower the local PM2.5 increment include particulate controls on under-fired charbroilers and a designed vegetative barrier on the western boundary (see Part II, Responses A2.4 and A2.5).
Figure 6: FEIR Response O2A-8, p. 2.0-90 (PM2.5 standards exceeded with the Project) Finally, the City states that the District's health risk threshold measures incremental risk and does not consider existing ambient risk. I agree that the threshold is incremental. That is not a reason to withhold the existing pollution burden from decision makers, and in any case the Project's incremental operational risk was never calculated (see Response O2A-7).
I recommend that the CalEnviroScreen results for the Project tract and the adjacent SB 535 tract be presented in the air quality analysis, the Project's modeled PM2.5 increment should be reported at each sensitive receptor group, and on-site PM2.5 reduction measures should be adopted.
Response O2A-5: Reliance on the VERA and Lack of On-Site Reductions The City disagrees that operational emissions are addressed solely through the Voluntary Emission Reduction Agreement (VERA) in MM AQ-1, pointing to MM AQ-2 (low-VOC coatings) and MM GHG-1 through MM GHG-7. This response does not change the conclusion in my comment, for the following reasons.
2 FEIR, Response O2A-8, p. 2.0-89; Response O2.28, p. 2.0-64.
P a g e | 7
Figure 7: FEIR Response O2A-5, p. 2.0-81
• None of the greenhouse gas measures was quantified for VOC or NOx reductions. If those measures produced meaningful reductions, the mitigated operational emissions would reflect them. They do not. The Project still exceeds both thresholds before the VERA is applied, which is why the VERA is needed.
• The City does not dispute that the exceedances are driven by mobile sources. MM GHG-1 (all-electric buildings) specifically exempts commercial cooking, which is the largest natural gas use in a retail center of this type, so its NOx benefit is small. MM GHG-2 (carbon-free electricity) reduces emissions at off-site power plants, not local VOC or NOx.
MM GHG-3 (electric landscaping equipment) addresses a minor source. • The transportation measures (improvements at up to two bus stops, one end-of-trip shower facility, and CALGreen Tier 2 electric vehicle parking) would have a negligible effect on a project generating between 18,921 and 28,479 daily trips. None of these measures addresses delivery trucks which can be a significant source of criteria and toxic air contaminant pollutants.
• MM AQ-2 reduces VOC from architectural coatings, but the FEIR does not state how much. The VOC exceedance (14.6 tons per year against a 10 ton per year threshold) is driven by vehicle trips.
P a g e | 8
Figure 8: Unmitigated Operational VOC and NOx Emissions Compared to SJVAPCD Thresholds (DEIR Section 4.3)
The timing of the VERA is also a concern. As revised in the Errata at the District's request, MM AQ-1 now requires only execution of the VERA before building permits are issued.3 The District explained that the time required to achieve the reductions "may vary" and that verification "may occur after issuance of building permits." The revised measure contains no deadline for the reductions to be achieved and no requirement that they be in place before the Project begins operating. As written, the Project could operate for an undefined period with its VOC and NOx exceedances unmitigated.
Figure 9: SJVAPCD Comment A2.3, FEIR p. 2.0-17 (timing of VERA emission reductions) 3 FEIR, Response A2.3, p. 2.0-17; Errata, p. 3.0-4.
P a g e | 9
Figure 10: FEIR Errata, p. 3.0-4 (MM AQ-1 revised from "completion" to "execution") In addition, VERA reductions are achieved wherever the District funds emission reduction projects across the eight-county air basin. They do not necessarily reduce exposure in the Project's neighborhood. On-site measures do, which is why they should be applied first and the VERA used for the remainder.
The City's reference to the charbroiler Condition of Approval (CoA) in this response is not relevant to this comment. The CoA addresses health risk from individual tenants. It does not reduce VOC or NOx emissions.
Response O2A-6: The SJV Air Pollution Control District's Analysis Recommendations Item 1: Separate analysis of stationary sources
The City states that the District's NOP comment asked only that mobile and stationary sources be analyzed separately and did not require stationary sources to be quantified. A separate discussion that never estimates the emissions from the gasoline dispensing facility or the charbroilers is not an analysis of those emissions. The District's comment letter on the DEIR removes any question about what it intended: the District specifically asked for an operational health risk assessment (HRA) of the gasoline station, the fast food charbroilers, and heavy-duty truck travel, combined with the construction HRA (Comment A2.2). The City's use of the CARB Air Quality and Land Use Handbook as a substitute is addressed under Response O2A-7.
P a g e | 10
Figure 11: SJVAPCD Comment A2.2, FEIR p. 2.0-14 (District request for an operational HRA) Item 2: Heavy-duty truck trip length
The City states that the DEIR did not use the CalEEMod default truck trip length and instead calculated heavy-duty truck vehicle miles traveled (VMT) with the Kern Council of Governments (KernCOG) regional travel demand model. Accepting that correction, the truck figures presented in the FEIR are internally inconsistent, and the inconsistency affects both the NOx estimate and the AAQA.
Figure 12: FEIR Response O2A-6, Item 2, p. 2.0-84
The DEIR reports heavy-duty truck VMT of approximately 751 miles per day.4 The FEIR then presents three different daily truck counts:
• 23 truck trips per day (0.15 percent of 14,904 trips from the KernCOG fleet mix) (Responses O2A-6 and O2.16);
• 29 to 44 truck trips per day (the same percentage applied to total weekday and weekend trips) (Responses O2A-6 and O2.16); and
• approximately 191 truck trips per day (751 miles divided by the overall average trip length of 3.94 miles) (Response A2.2).
Dividing 751 miles by each count gives an average heavy-duty truck trip length of approximately 33 miles (23 trips), 17 miles (44 trips), or 3.9 miles (191 trips). The City describes the 191-trip figure as "overly conservative" because trucks delivering to the Project "would be traveling longer 4 DEIR, Appendix B, p. 119, as cited in FEIR Response A2.2, p. 2.0-15.
P a g e | 11
distances on average" than customers. If trucks travel farther than 3.94 miles, then either the truck count is far lower than 191 or the truck VMT is understated.
Figure 13: FEIR Response A2.2, pp. 2.0-15 to 2.0-16 (truck VMT and truck trip estimates) Figure 14: Implied Heavy-Duty Truck Trip Length for Each Truck Count Presented in the FEIR A regional travel demand model counts only the miles traveled inside the model boundary.
Deliveries originating at regional distribution centers outside Kern County are truncated at the county line. The FEIR does not present truck trip generation based on the Project's actual land uses, including the market (which will receive refrigerated deliveries), the restaurants, the retail anchors, and fuel tanker deliveries to a 40-position gasoline station.
P a g e | 12
I recommend that the truck trips should be estimated by land use, with trip lengths based on the likely origin of deliveries, and the operational NOx estimate, the AAQA, and the truck component of an operational HRA should be updated using those values.
Item 3: Operational health risk
See Response O2A-7 below.
Item 4: Ambient air quality analysis
The AAQA relies on the same truck inputs discussed under Item 2. It also shows that total PM2.5 concentrations with the Project would exceed the 24-hour NAAQS and the annual NAAQS and CAAQS (see Responses O2A-4 and O2A-8 above). Where the standards are already exceeded at nearby receptors, on-site PM2.5 reductions should be required.
Item 5: VERA feasibility
See Response O2A-5 above.
Response O2A-6: The District's Mitigation Recommendations Item 1: Cleanest available off-road construction equipment The City declined this measure because construction emissions are below the District's thresholds.
Being below a threshold does not mean construction emissions are negligible. The District recommended this measure for this Project, the air basin is classified as extreme nonattainment for the federal 8-hour ozone standard, and construction will occur on contaminated soils within several hundred feet of a senior mobile home park. Tier 4 Final engines emit substantially less diesel particulate matter (DPM) and NOx than Tier 2 and Tier 3 engines and are widely available in the construction fleet. The measure is feasible and low in cost and should be adopted.
Item 2: Heavy-duty truck routing
The City relies on the CARB Handbook screening criterion of 100,000 vehicles per day for busy roadways. That criterion was developed for siting new sensitive land uses next to existing high-volume roadways. It was not developed to evaluate the effect of a new project's trucks on existing residents. The same Handbook recommends a 1,000-foot separation between sensitive receptors and distribution centers with more than 100 trucks per day, and the City's own estimate in Response A2.2 is 191 truck trips per day. Roadway screening also does not address truck activity on the Project site itself, including travel on internal drive aisles, idling at loading docks, and operation of transport refrigeration units (TRUs), which are the activities closest to receptors.
A routing measure costs little to implement: direct truck access to the Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road driveways, prohibit truck use of the El Toro Viejo Road driveways, locate loading P a g e | 13
docks on the eastern portions of the site away from the mobile home park and residences, and post truck route signage.
Item 3: Cleanest available heavy-duty trucks
The City rejected a zero-emission truck requirement as infeasible because tenants will not own their own truck fleets. The District recommended the cleanest available trucks, not a zero-emission-only requirement. The following measures are within the control of the developer and tenants and are feasible:
Figure 15: FEIR Response O2A-6, Mitigation Item 3, p. 2.0-85 • lease provisions requiring tenants to request zero-emission or near-zero-emission delivery vehicles from carriers where available;
• zero-emission vehicles for all landlord-controlled service vehicles (maintenance, sweeping, and security);
• electrical hookups at the market and restaurant loading docks so TRUs can operate on grid power rather than diesel while parked; and
• electrical conduit and panel capacity at loading docks to support future medium- and heavy-duty truck charging.
Item 4: Anti-idling regulations
The City states that compliance with the state anti-idling regulations can be presumed because they are legally binding. The state regulations are enforced by field inspection, which is infrequent at any single location. Site-level measures make the limit visible and verifiable at the Project: posted no-idling signs at every loading dock and truck entrance, a 3-minute idling limit (stricter than the 5-minute state limit), tenant notification to carriers, a posted contact for complaints, and a limit on diesel TRU operation while parked. These are common conditions for commercial and industrial projects in the San Joaquin Valley and cost little.
Figure 16: FEIR Response O2A-6, Mitigation Item 4, p. 2.0-86 P a g e | 14
Item 5: Under-fired charbroilers
The City states that the presence of charbroilers is speculative because tenants have not been identified, and relies on a CoA that requires an HRA before a tenant with an under-fired charbroiler receives a tenant improvement permit. I disagree for three reasons.
Figure 17: FEIR Response O2A-6, Mitigation Item 5, p. 2.0-86 First, the Project description identifies drive-thru, fast casual, and sit-down restaurants on the outer pads,5 and the DEIR modeled restaurant land uses in CalEEMod for trip generation and energy use. The information needed to estimate a reasonable worst-case charbroiler emission rate using District emission factors is already in the DEIR. Estimating emissions from a known restaurant floor area is standard practice for a project at this stage.
Second, the CoA is applied one tenant at a time. Each HRA would compare a single tenant's charbroiler emissions to the 20 in one million threshold. The combined risk from several charbroiler restaurants, the gasoline station, and truck activity at the same receptor would never be calculated. A center with several such restaurants could produce a combined risk above the threshold even if every individual HRA shows a risk below it.
Third, the CoA sets no control requirement unless an individual HRA exceeds the threshold. The District recommended assessment and installation of particulate matter controls for new large restaurants with under-fired charbroilers, and is offering incentive funding that covers the full cost of purchase, installation, and maintenance for two years of operation (Comment A2.4). A control 5 FEIR, Comment O2.1 (summarizing the DEIR Project Description), p. 2.0-43.
P a g e | 15
requirement is therefore feasible at little or no cost to tenants and would also reduce the PM2.5 increment discussed above.
Response O2A-7: Operational Health Risk
The City states that SJVAPCD Regulation II is mandatory, that compliance may be presumed, and that reliance on it is therefore not a postponement of the analysis. Whether the gasoline station obtains a permit is not the issue raised. No analysis in the DEIR, the FEIR, or the permit process estimates the total operational health risk from the Project at the nearest homes.
Figure 18: FEIR Response O2A-7, p. 2.0-88
• Regulation II permits evaluate individual permit units at the time an application is filed.
They do not combine the risk from all Project sources at a common receptor. • Delivery trucks, on-site truck idling, TRUs, and under-fired charbroilers are not evaluated through the Regulation II permit risk review. The City added a separate CoA for charbroilers because permitting does not cover them.
• The District asked that operational risk from the gasoline station, charbroilers, and trucks be combined with construction risk and compared to the thresholds (Comment A2.2). That calculation has not been done.
The GAMAQI statement quoted in the FEIR, that emission impacts from sources permitted consistent with New Source Review requirements "are not individually significant and are not cumulatively significant,"6 concerns criteria pollutant emissions that are controlled through Best Available Control Technology and offsets under Rule 2201. It does not address the combined health risk from permitted and unpermitted sources at the same receptor. 6 FEIR, Responses O2.16 and O2.22, pp. 2.0-55 and 2.0-59.
P a g e | 16
Figure 19: FEIR Response O2.22, p. 2.0-59
The FEIR misstates the CARB Handbook recommendation for gasoline stations The FEIR states that the CARB Handbook recommends a 500-foot separation between sensitive land uses and gasoline dispensing facilities, and that the nearest receptors are about 650 feet from the station.7 The Handbook does not recommend 500 feet for gasoline stations. It recommends avoiding new sensitive land uses within 300 feet of a large gasoline station (3.6 million gallons per year or more) and within 50 feet of a typical station. More importantly, the Handbook is a siting guide for placing new homes and schools near existing sources. It is not a method for estimating the risk that a new source will impose on existing residents, and it does not substitute for an HRA.
Figure 20: FEIR Response A2.2, p. 2.0-15 (City's statement of a 500-foot CARB buffer) Several additional problems with the City's reliance on the Handbook should be noted:
• The FEIR never states the station's expected annual throughput. A station with 20 dual-sided dispensers (40 fueling positions) is comparable in size to the high-volume stations at wholesale and discount centers, which the City itself describes as having average throughput of about 9 million gallons per year and a risk of 25 in one million at 50 feet.8 The permitted throughput for a station of this size could be higher still. 7 FEIR, Response A2.2, p. 2.0-15; Response O2.16, p. 2.0-54. 8 FEIR, Response O2.16, p. 2.0-54, citing CARB 2005.
P a g e | 17
Figure 21: FEIR Response O2.16, p. 2.0-54 (CARB Handbook gas station risk values) • The Handbook risk values were developed in 2005 using methods that predate OEHHA's 2015 Risk Assessment Guidelines. The 2015 Guidelines incorporate age sensitivity factors and higher breathing rates for young children, which increase estimated residential cancer risk, commonly by a factor of about three. Risk values taken from the Handbook therefore understate risk as it would be calculated today.
• The DEIR's construction HRA treated two buildings approximately 200 to 450 feet west of the site, across El Toro Viejo Road, as residential receptors. The FEIR does not explain whether the 650-foot distance was measured to those receptors or to the mobile home park, and it provides no figure showing the station's location relative to the receptors.
Figure 22: Conceptual Site Plan Showing the Fueling Station on the Western Portion of the Site, Nearest El Toro Viejo Road
P a g e | 18
As an illustration only, a high-volume station contributing about 5 in one million at 300 feet under the older Handbook methods could contribute on the order of 15 in one million under the 2015 methods. Adding construction risk (1.5 in one million), truck and TRU activity, and one or more charbroiler restaurants could bring the Project's combined risk close to or above the 20 in one million threshold. The District requested a quantified operational HRA for this reason. The FEIR does not include one.
Figure 23: Gasoline Station Cancer Risk by Distance from CARB Handbook Values Cited in the FEIR, with Illustrative Adjustment for OEHHA 2015 Methods
The Airport Commerce Center comparison is not an analysis of this Project In Responses A2.2 and O2.24, the City relies on an HRA prepared for a warehouse project elsewhere in Kern County, which reported a cancer risk of 8.88 in one million from 824 daily truck trips. An HRA for a different project, at a different location, with different meteorological data, receptor distances, site layout, and truck activity, does not estimate the risk from this Project. That HRA also addressed truck emissions only. It did not include a gasoline station, charbroilers, or construction. Truck-related risk at a receptor depends mostly on truck activity close to that receptor (on-site travel, idling, and TRU operation), not on the daily trip count alone, so the result cannot be scaled to this Project by comparing trip totals.
P a g e | 19
Figure 24: FEIR Response A2.2, p. 2.0-15 (Airport Commerce Center comparison) Responses O2A-9 through O2A-13: Valley Fever
The City acknowledges that ground disturbance can aerosolize Coccidioides spores and that risk is elevated in dry, windy conditions and in years following drought. It relies on the Rule 8021 Dust Control Plan, general Cal/OSHA requirements, and Labor Code Section 6709 training, and it rejects active particulate monitoring because dust monitors "cannot detect the presence of biological agents" and because there is "no direct correlation" between dust concentrations and spore levels.9
Figure 25: Valley Fever Cases Reported in Kern County (CDPH) 9 FEIR, Responses O2A-9 and O2A-12, pp. 2.0-91 and 2.0-93.
P a g e | 20
Figure 26: FEIR Response O2A-9, p. 2.0-91
The City's position on dust and spores is contradictory In Response O2A-9 the City states that "fugitive dust suppression measures generally reduce impacts from Valley Fever." In Response O2A-12 it states there is no direct correlation between dust concentrations and airborne spores. If dust suppression reduces spore exposure, as the City relies on, then airborne dust concentration is the relevant indicator of whether suppression is working. Coccidioides arthroconidia are approximately 2 to 5 micrometers in size and are released and carried with disturbed soil. My comment did not propose that monitors identify spores. The purpose of real-time perimeter monitoring of PM10 and PM2.5 is to provide an objective trigger for added watering or a work stoppage when fine dust leaves the site. On this site, the same monitoring would also track off-site transport of the PCBs, PAHs, and metals identified in the Land Use Covenant.
Figure 27: FEIR Response O2A-12, p. 2.0-93
P a g e | 21
Figure 28: Size of Coccidioides Arthroconidia Compared to PM2.5, PM10, and Coarse Soil Dust Visual opacity does not detect fine particles
The City notes that Rule 8021 requires dust controls before, during, and after dust-generating activity, and that the 20 percent opacity limit is a ceiling rather than a trigger. That is correct, but compliance is still judged by visual observation. Visible opacity is dominated by larger particles.
Fine particles in the respirable size range, which is where the spores fall, can be present at levels of health concern without a visible plume. The rule's requirement to control dust "before, during, and after" activities does not specify a watering frequency or any way to confirm that the controls are effective at the fence line.
The specific measures in my comments were not addressed Response O2A-13 refers back to Responses O2A-9 and O2A-12 and does not respond to any of the specific measures I proposed. The DEIR's CalEEMod runs for Phase 1 and Phase 2 construction credit no dust mitigation. As noted in my comments, CalEEMod estimates that watering exposed areas twice per day reduces PM10 and PM2.5 by 61 percent, and three times per day by 74 percent. Converting these practices into Project conditions is feasible and inexpensive.
The following should be adopted as enforceable conditions:
Figure 29: FEIR Response O2A-13, p. 2.0-95 (entire response to the proposed Valley Fever measures) P a g e | 22
Figure 30: Fugitive Dust Reductions from Watering Calculated by CalEEMod • watering of all disturbed areas at least three times per day, increased to four times per day when visible wind-driven dust is present;
• suspension of grading and excavation when sustained winds exceed 20 miles per hour; • covered haul loads with at least six inches of freeboard, and cleaning of equipment and vehicles before they leave the site;
• a Valley Fever section in each contractor's Injury and Illness Prevention Program, with NIOSH-approved respirators for workers near earth-moving equipment, clean eating and hand-washing areas, and separation of work and street clothing; and • a written protocol with a local medical provider for evaluating workers who develop symptoms consistent with Valley Fever.
General worker safety requirements do not protect nearby residents Title 8 Sections 3203, 5141, and 5144 are general requirements. None of them prescribes Valley Fever-specific engineering controls, respirator use, or medical protocols for this Project, and Labor Code Section 6709 requires training only. More importantly, these requirements apply only to workers. The City's responses do not address off-site residents at all, including the Green Acres Estates Senior Mobile Home Park. Adults over 60 are among the groups at higher risk of severe and disseminated Valley Fever. Perimeter monitoring and wind shutdown requirements would reduce their exposure.
P a g e | 23
PART II. THE CITY'S RESPONSES TO THE SJVAPCD COMMENTS
The District is the agency that oversees air quality issues in the San Joaquin Valley and has the expertise to determine if the impacts from a Project’s construction and operational phases are impactful. Several of the City's responses to the District decline the recommendations or substitute a different approach. The City also states elsewhere in the FEIR that the District's comments "did not raise any objections or concerns" regarding the cumulative air quality analysis, and that the District did not request that the Project's modeled risk be added to background risk.10 These statements are not consistent with the District's letter. The District told the City that only a construction HRA had been performed, that an operational HRA should be performed and combined with it, and that these modifications "have the potential to cause the Project to exceed District health risk thresholds." The District recommended that the HRA be revised. The City did not revise it.
Figure 32: FEIR Response O1.9, p. 2.0-30
Response A2.2: Operational Health Risk Assessment
The District asked for an operational HRA covering the gasoline station, charbroilers, and heavy-duty truck travel, combined with the construction HRA. The City did not prepare one. It instead relied on the CARB Handbook separation distance, the Airport Commerce Center HRA, a set of truck counts, and a qualitative acute hazard argument. As explained under Response O2A-7, the Handbook distance is misstated, the Airport Commerce Center HRA does not model this Project, the truck counts conflict with each other, and the acute hazard argument relies on a pollutant (DPM) that has no acute reference exposure level. The City's statement that the Project "with 191 estimated truck trips per day would not result in exceeding the SJVAPCD's significance thresholds" is not supported by any calculation in the FEIR.
The District also recommended, as a mitigation approach, that TAC sources be located an adequate distance from residences. The FEIR does not show the location of the gasoline station, drive-thru 10FEIR, Response O1.9, p. 2.0-30; Response O2.24, p. 2.0-60.
P a g e | 24
lanes, loading docks, or likely charbroiler restaurants relative to the receptors, so it is not possible to confirm that this recommendation has been followed.
Response A2.3: VERA Timing
The City revised MM AQ-1 to require execution rather than completion of the VERA before building permits are issued. The District's explanation for this change confirms that the emission reductions may be achieved after construction begins and possibly after operations begin. MM AQ-1 should be further revised to (1) require that the VERA specify a schedule under which the reductions are achieved no later than the end of the Project's first full year of operation, (2) require the District's verification to be provided to the City, and (3) require the developer to fund any shortfall if the scheduled reductions are not achieved. On-site measures should be applied first, as discussed under Response O2A-5.
Response A2.4: Under-Fired Charbroilers
The District recommended "a measure requiring the assessment and potential installation, as technologically feasible, of particulate matter emission control systems for new large restaurants operating under-fired charbroilers." The District's stated purpose was both to protect nearby neighborhoods during stagnant conditions and to help the Valley attain the federal PM2.5 standards.
The City's CoA addresses only the first purpose, and only when a single tenant exceeds the cancer risk threshold. Given that the Project tract ranks in the 99th percentile for PM2.5, that the AAQA shows PM2.5 standards would be exceeded at nearby receptors, and that District incentive funding covers the full cost of control systems for two years, the District's measure should be adopted as written.
Figure 33: SJVAPCD Comment A2.4, FEIR p. 2.0-17
Figure 34: SJVAPCD Comment A2.4, FEIR p. 2.0-18 (District incentive funding) Response A2.5: Vegetative Barriers and Urban Greening
The City states that the Project's ornamental trees, shrubs, and groundcover would assist in reducing pollutant concentrations. Ornamental landscaping is not a vegetative barrier. The District P a g e | 25
described a barrier that is tall, thick, and has full coverage. U.S. EPA's guidance on vegetative barriers for near-road air quality (2016) likewise calls for dense, continuous vegetation from ground level to the top of the canopy, of sufficient height and depth, with no gaps. Scattered ornamental plantings can channel pollutants through gaps and provide little reduction.
Figure 35: FEIR Response A2.5, p. 2.0-19
Recommendation: A continuous evergreen vegetative barrier should be installed along the western boundary facing El Toro Viejo Road and the mobile home park, and adjacent to the gasoline station and drive-thru queuing lanes. Species should be drought tolerant, low in biogenic VOC emissions, and suited to the Bakersfield climate, and the barrier should be subject to a maintenance requirement.
Response A2.6: Electric Vehicle Infrastructure
The City relies on the CALGreen requirements and the Tier 2 voluntary standards in MM GHG-7. Tier 2 is largely met through EV-capable spaces rather than installed chargers. The District recommended that chargers be installed, including Level 3 (DC fast) chargers, and offers incentive funding for them through its Charge Up! program. For a regional retail center with a 40-position fuel station, a firm commitment to a specific number of installed DC fast chargers is feasible and would reduce emissions from customer trips.
Responses A2.7 through A2.13: District Rules and Regulations The City responded to each of these comments by stating that they are not comments on the physical environmental impacts of the Project. Two of these rules bear directly on the adequacy of the air quality analysis.
Rule 9510 (Indirect Source Review) requires reductions in construction and operational NOx and PM10 emissions through on-site design features or fees. The District stated that, as of its August 28, 2026 letter, it had not received the required Air Impact Assessment application for the Project.11 The FEIR does not explain how Rule 9510 reductions relate to the reductions credited to the VERA under MM AQ-1. The two programs should be accounted for separately so that the same reductions are not counted twice.
11FEIR, Comment A2.9, p. 2.0-21.
P a g e | 26
Figure 36: SJVAPCD Comment A2.9, FEIR p. 2.0-21
Rule 8021 (Regulation VIII) is the City's primary basis for concluding that Valley Fever and fugitive dust impacts would be less than significant. The City's statement in Response A2.12 is inconsistent with its reliance on this rule in Response O2A-9.
CONCLUSIONS
The facts identified above and referenced in this letter lead me to reasonably conclude that the City's responses do not resolve the issues raised in my comments nor in the District's comments, and that the Project could result in significant air quality and public health impacts that are not disclosed or mitigated in the FEIR. An operational health risk assessment, a corrected truck trip analysis, and the mitigation measures identified above should be completed before the Project is considered for approval and a subsequent FEIR should be prepared.
Sincerely,
James J.J. Clark, Ph.D.
Clark & Associates Environmental Consulting, Inc.
EXHIBIT B
1 1295 Hartford Avenue #8
White River Junction, VT 05001
Norman Marshall, President
(802) 356-2969
[email protected]
September 25, 2026
Aidan P. Marshall
Adams Broadwell Joseph & Cardozo
520 Capitol Mall, Suite 350
Sacramento, CA 95814
Subject: Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project
Dear Mr. Marshall,
In August 2026, I reviewed vehicle miles traveled (VMT) and trip generation impacts of the proposed Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project in the City of Bakersfield Draft Environmental Impact Report (“DEIR”) dated July 2026 and made the following findings:
1) Both the retail and medical office components of the project would have significant VMT impacts that would not be fully mitigated by the measures listed in the DEIR. 2) CAPCOA Handbook Measure T-5, Implement Commute Trip Reduction (Voluntary) would provide additional VMT mitigation.
3) The DEIR mispresents the pass-by trip reduction for the gasoline service station component of the project.
4) Trip generation and the pass-by percentage for the gasoline service station are highly uncertain because the proposed project with 40 fueling stations is significantly different than the sites in the database.
5) The gasoline service station’s unique characteristics could result in more additional traffic and VMT than other smaller gasoline service stations.
Now I also have reviewed the responses to these comments in the Riverview Marketplace Commercial Project in the City of Bakersfield Final Environmental Impact Report (“FEIR”) dated September 2026. As discussed below, the FEIR fails to adequately address my comments. 2 Significant VMT and VMT Mitigation (Comment Areas #1 and #2) I commented that the DEIR did not include all feasible VMT mitigation. In particular, I cited CAPCOA Handbook Measure T-5, Implement Commute Trip Reduction (Voluntary) be included. This measure would achieve an up to 4.0% reduction in VMT. The Handbook states:
Voluntary CTR programs must include the following elements to apply the VMT reductions reported in literature.
• Employer-provided services, infrastructure, and incentives for alternative modes such as ridesharing (Measure T-8), discounted transit (Measure T-9), bicycling (Measure T-10), vanpool (Measure T-11), and guaranteed ride home. • Information, coordination, and marketing for said services, infrastructure, and incentives (Measure T-7).
The FEIR response is simply that: “the proposed additional mitigation measures are practically infeasible as supported by substantial evidence in the Draft EIR.” (FEIR, p. 2.0-69) The DEIR does not include this “substantial evidence.” Instead it just asserts that feasible mitigation is included. The DEIR states:
Per the VMT analysis prepared, the Project has been designed to incorporate feasible VMT reducing strategies. (DIEIR, p. 4.8-23)
The VMT analysis (DEIR Appendix H) similarly states:
The project has been designed to incorporate feasible VMT reducing strategies consistent with State guidance and best practices (DEIR Appendix H, p. 6) No evidence is presented in the DEIR, DEIR Appendix H, or in the FEIR that other mitigation is infeasible.
In particular, no evidence is given that incorporating CAPCOA Measure T-5 is infeasible.
Trip Generation and VMT (Comment Areas #3, #4 and #5)
My August 2026 comments identified a discrepancy in the DEIR regarding pass-by trips and diverted trips:
DEIR Table 4.16-2 (p. 4.16-10) shows that the gasoline service stations would generate 10,196 daily trips including 816 internal capture trips and 7,316 pass-by trips.
The Traffic Study, DEIR Appendix H, states that there would be only 3,254 daily pass-by trips plus 4,062 diverted trips, for a total of 7,316 pass-by + diverted trips. (DEIR, Appendix H, PDF p. 361 of 984)
In the first excerpt, the DEIR incorrectly lumps pass-by and diverted trips together. This is important because diverted trips generate VMT and pass-by trips do not.
The FEIR acknowledges: “pass-by and diverted trips are distinct types of trips.” (FEIR p. 2.0-67) The split between the two categories given in the second excerpt is based on Costco data, which the DEIR and FEIR argue is the best basis for estimating trip generation for the proposed facility because of the unique aspects of Costco facilities. Nevertheless, rather than correcting the deficiency identified in 3 my August 2026 comments, the FEIR introduces high pass-by trip percentages for gas stations given in ITE Trip Generation. (FEIR, p. 2.0-67) It is likely that most Costco customers are Costco members that are more likely to divert to a Costco gas station as compared to the general population that would more likely stop at the most convenient gas station across all brands. Therefore, the ITE pass-by rates are not applicable to the proposed facility.
The discrepancy should be corrected.
Sincerely,
Norman L. Marshall