ADMINISTRATIVE REPORT
MEETING DATE: November 18, 2026 AGENDA CATEGORY: Hearings TO: Honorable Mayor and City Council
FROM: Zachary Meyer, Public Works Director
DATE: October 19, 2026
SUBJECT: Public Hearing to present Findings and Consider Adoption of Energy Savings Performance Contract with Willdan Energy Solutions for Public Works Fleet Electrical Charging Infrastructure:
1. Resolution making findings and authorizing an Energy Savings Performance Contract for fleet electrification and electric vehicle infrastructure improvements.
2. Agreement with Willdan Energy Solutions for an amount not to exceed $19,922,436 to implement energy efficiency measures, operating cost-saving measures and equipment, and energy generation measures supporting the City’s transition to an electric fleet.
3. Appropriate $4,662,996 from the Equipment Fund, $8,263,243 from the Solid Waste Fund, $4,346,005 from the Wastewater Fund, and $1,650,192 from the Domestic Water Fund, for a total appropriation of $18,922,436 into the Public Works Capital Improvement Program Budget.
RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends opening the public hearing, taking public testimony, adoption of the resolution, approval of the contract, and appropriation of funds.
BACKGROUND:
For the last two to three years, the California Air Resources Board (CARB) has begun to implement new fleet equipment requirements as part of its Advanced Clean Fleet (ACF) program. These requirements mandate that equipment, used by public agencies, must transition to Zero Emission Vehicles (ZEV). CARB placed milestones that public agencies must adhere to as shown below:
Percentage of vehicles that must be ZEVs 10% 25% 50% 75% 100% Group 1: Box trucks, vans, buses with two axles, yard
tractors, light-duty package delivery vehicles
2025 2028 2031 2033 2035 and
beyond
Group 2: Work trucks, day cab tractors, pickup trucks,
buses with three axles
2027 2030 2033 2036 2039 and
beyond
Group 3: Sleeper cab tractors and specialty vehicles 2030 2033 2036 2039 2042 and beyond
Additionally, CARB has adopted rules that allow it to penalize agencies up to $10,000 per day for non-compliance and allow the DMV to withhold new vehicle registration for non-compliance. This means if the City ignores these CARB mandates, the City could face excessive penalties and lose the ability to place new equipment into service as the DMV would withhold registrations.
To comply with these requirements, electric charging stations would need to be installed at City facilities to provide fuel for its new zero-emission fleet. With regards for this project (to install charging infrastructure), City staff determined that a traditional planning – design – bid – build project process would not be the best solution for project delivery. The planning phase for the project is critical and time consuming due to: studying the current electrical infrastructure at all City sites that have equipment; analyze City’s equipment and replacement cycle; analyze equipment fuel usage; and investigate incentives and grant opportunities, which are time-sensitive. If staff were to solicit a contractor to focus solely on the planning phase, most qualified professionals would not submit a proposal as they would wait for the construction phase. A contractor who completed the planning phase would be ineligible to bid for the construction phase and the construction phase would yield the most profits for contractors. Staff determined the best project delivery process would be to have one consultant/contractor perform the planning, design, and construction. To accomplish this, staff would procure an energy contractor, complete an investment grade audit (IGA) for electric charging infrastructure, and award a construction contract via public hearing utilizing California Government Code section 4217.10 et seq., which authorizes an alternative method for public agencies to enter into certain “energy service contracts.” On July 31, 2024, the Public Works Department issued a Request for Qualifications (RFQ) seeking qualified Energy Services Companies (ESCOs) to conduct IGAs, identify and develop energy efficiency improvements, and potentially implement capital improvement projects at City facilities using a design-build delivery method. Eight proposals were received. A selection committee evaluated the proposals using the criteria established in the RFQ, including approach, experience, references, qualifications, and overall proposal quality. Three firms: ENGIE Services U.S. Inc., Noresco LLC, and Willdan, were shortlisted and participated in oral appraisal interviews on October 24, 2024. Willdan received the highest score of (91.25) and was selected. Willdan began working on a preliminary evaluation of City facilities, and then City Council awarded a contract (Agreement 2025-106) on June 25, 2025, to complete an IGA of City facilities for the installation of electric vehicle charging stations.
Willdan evaluated 21 City-owned sites to design and build the electrical equipment charging infrastructure. Initially, the goal was to future-proof every site to eventually install enough chargers to allow the City to obtain 100% ACF compliance through all the milestone dates going to year 2042. Due to the excessive costs and the need to finance the project with this approach, Willdan reduced the overall scope of the project and targeted enterprise-funded sites, the corporation yard, and one facility in the downtown area. Electric chargers are being proposed to be installed at the following sites (percentage of fund allocated to each site is also shown):
1530 Eye Street (City Hall South Annex parking area; 100% General Fund) 4101 Truxtun Avenue (Corporation Yard)
o Parcel A (53% General Fund / 47% Refuse Fund)
o Parcel C (7% General Fund / 93% Refuse Fund)
6901 McCutchen Road (Wastewater Treatment Plant No. 3; 100% Sewer Enterprise) 1700 East Planz Road (Wastewater Treatment Plant No. 2; 100% Sewer Enterprise) 2601 Mt. Vernon Avenue (Greenwaste Site; 100% Refuse Enterprise) 2260 South Union Avenue (Materials Recovery Facility; 100% Refuse Enterprise) 1000 Beuna Vista Road (Water Department; 100% Domestic Water Enterprise) Collectively, there will be 133 charging ports installed across these sites, and 136 make-ready ports to allow for future growth. With this approach, the City will gain ACF compliance through 2033 for Group 1 and Group 2 equipment, and compliance through 2036 for Group 3 equipment.
Safety equipment, such as emergency equipment used by the Police and Fire Department, is currently exempt from the ACF mandates.
Additionally, Willdan assisted the City with enrolling in PG&E’s Fleet Electric Vehicle Program. This program allows PG&E to upgrade their infrastructure to-the-meter at no cost to the City (similar to the PG&E Rule 20 Program) and comes with rebates, in the amount of $1.572 Million Dollars, for installing the chargers. In order for the City to stay enrolled in the PG&E EV Program, a contract must be awarded prior to December of this year. Consequentially, the City would lose the rebate money if a contract is not awarded prior to December of this year. This is because PG&E wants to ensure the construction can be completed by the end of 2028, and PG&E would enroll another agency into the program if it believes the City cannot meet these construction deadline goals.
Item 1 – Adopting Resolution showing there are energy savings To comply with California Government Code section 4217.12, Willdan must show that by completing this project, there will be energy savings. Willdan has successfully shown this through their IGA and delivered to the City its Summary of Findings. These fundings identify maintenance savings, clean air credits, PG&E rebates, and energy savings from using less unleaded/diesel fuels. The summary of findings is attached to the resolution as Exhibit A.
The Summary of Findings shows overall savings to the City in the amount of just over $26,000,000 over a 20-year period with a return-on-investment (ROI) by year 2039. When the cost to replace the City’s vehicles and equipment is factored in over a 20-year period, the 20-year savings is reduced by 8.8 Million Dollars; but there is still positive cash flow. Other factors included in the 20-year cash flow model:
assumed maintenance savings, forecasting electrical costs and fuel savings, Low Carbon Fuel Standard credits, vehicle/equipment replacement incentives, PG&E rebates, and charger maintenance. The 20-year cashflow model for all eight sites is attached as a support document.
A 20-year period was used in the model as the ACF milestones run through the next 15 years, and the life of the chargers are assumed to be 10 years. The replacement costs of the chargers, after ten years, is factored in the cash flow models. By showing a 20-year window for this program, the capital costs for the new chargers and replacement chargers can realize their useful life and show their entire benefit to the City in reducing fuel costs.
The summary of findings also shows a negative cash flow over the same 20-year period for the Water and Sewer funded sites. This is because there is not as much equipment at these sites, and the fuel usage isn’t as excessive as the equipment that is housed at the corporation yard. The higher the fuel usage, the greater the savings that can be realized. These sites still need chargers to comply with the ACF mandates, and having chargers at these site will geographically benefit other Departments who need to charge their equipment near these sites. Since all sites collectively show a positive cash flow and energy sites, this project does comply with California Code 4217.
In accordance with California Government Code Sections 4217.10–4217.18, the findings of the Investment Grade Audit demonstrate that the anticipated cost to the City to implement the proposed energy-related improvements will be less than the anticipated marginal cost to the City for electrical or other energy that would have been consumed in the absence of the improvements.
Item 2 – Approving agreement with Willdan
This agreement with Willdan will install electric chargers at eight City locations. Willdan expects to have its construction completed prior to the end of calendar year 2027, which will allow PG& E sufficient time to complete their to-the-meter improves prior to the end of calendar year 2028. This contract is for a not-to-exceed amount of $19,922, 436. This contract includes contingencies and this not-to-exceed amount is written as the Guaranteed Maximum Price (GMAX); meaning the total project costs cannot exceed this amount absent a City-authorized increase. Unless the City desires Willdan to complete additional duties outside of the defined scope of work, there will be no future change-orders. This contract also covers the maintenance and networking fees of the electric chargers for 5 years.
The agreement will also include provisions for Measurement and Verification (M&V) to document and verify the energy and energy-related cost savings achieved by the project. During the applicable guarantee period, Willdan and its contractor will be responsible for tracking and monitoring system performance and preparing savings reports in accordance with the contract requirements. This process will allow City staff to compare actual savings against the projected savings and evaluate whether the project is meeting the performance guarantees established in the agreement. Willdan is guaranteeing $331,000 in energy savings to City for year 1 of this program. If the City does not realize these savings, Willdan will compensate the City the shortfall amount, and be required to continue monitoring the system for energy savings.
FISCAL IMPACT:
Item 3 – Appropriation of funds
The project has a capital cost of $19,922,436. Approximately $1,000,000 from the Equipment Fund is currently budgeted in the Public Works Capital Improvement Program in Project 26PWFL01; a project for electric vehicle chargers. An additional appropriation of funds is necessary to award the contract, in the amount of $18,922,436, from multiple funding sources as follows:
1. $4,662,996 from the Equipment Enterprise Fund
2. $8,263,243 from the Refuse Enterprise Fund
3. $4,346,005 from the Sewer Enterprise Fund
4. $1,650,192 from the Domestic Water Enterprise Fund
The costs associated with each funding source is based on the construction costs and quantity of chargers that are being installed for equipment that is funded within each enterprise. For General Fund chargers, the Equipment Fund will purchase those chargers, and the using Departments will pay back the equipment over the life of the charger (approximately 10 years) for the capital costs.
COUNCIL GOAL:
Innovative and Efficient City Government
Reliable Infrastructure
ATTACHMENTS:
1. Resolution (with Exhibit A – Summary of Findings)
2. Agreement
3. 20-Year Cash Flow Model