AGENDA REPORT
Meeting Date: October 3, 2023
Item Number:
To: Honorable Mayor & City Council
From: Mark Odell, Urban Designer
Subject: A RESOLUTION OF THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF BEVERLY HILLS NOMINATING THE “CHURCH OF THE GOOD SHEPHERD” AT
501-505 NORTH BEDFORD DRIVE, BEVERLY HILLS FOR
INCLUSION ON THE CITY OF BEVERLY HILLS REGISTER OF
HISTORIC PROPERTIES
Attachments: 1. City Council Draft Resolution
2. July 12, 2023 Cultural Heritage Commission Staff Report
3. Cultural Heritage Commission Resolution No. CHC 115
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends that the City Council, on the recommendation of the Cultural Heritage Commission, conduct a public hearing regarding the matter. The Council could render a decision to approve the designation of the Church of the Good Shepherd as a landmark for inclusion onto the Beverly Hills Register of Historic Properties.
INTRODUCTION
The “Church of the Good Shepherd” has been assessed for eligibility as a Local Landmark under Beverly Hills Municipal Code (BHMC) Title 10, Chapter 3, Article 32 (Historic Preservation Ordinance). A City Landmark Assessment Report prepared by Jan Ostashay of Ostashay and Associates Consulting (Attachment 3) provides background information and an historic assessment of the property and concludes that the property appears to be eligible as a local landmark. City staff peer-reviewed the submitted report, conducted a site visit of the property, and drafted findings in support of the property’s landmark eligibility under BHMC Section 10-3-3212 (Landmark Designation Criteria).
On July 12, 2023, the Cultural Heritage Commission considered the proposal to initiate landmark proceedings on the property and conducted a Preliminary Hearing (time periods outlined in BHMC §10-3-3215 were waived by the property owner’s authorized representatives) and found that the property appeared to be eligible as a landmark under the criteria in BHMC §10-3-3212. A Nomination Hearing was also subsequently conducted by the Commission on July 12, 2023, following the Preliminary Hearing; the Commission voted unanimously to nominate the Church of the Good Shepherd as a Meeting Date: October 3, 2023
landmark and adopted a resolution recommending that the City Council designate the “Church of the Good Shepherd” as a Landmark and place it onto the Beverly Hills Register of Historic Properties.
DISCUSSION
Located on the northwest corner of Santa Monica Boulevard and Bedford Drive, the subject property at 501-505 North Bedford Drive was designed in 1924 by architect James Donnellan. The stucco-covered concrete church building is commonly known as the “Church of the Good Shepherd” and was identified as a potential contributor to the potential historic district defined as the “Beverly Hills Churches-Thematic Grouping” in the City’s 1985-1986 historic survey and the 2004 historic survey. The property is individually eligible for listing in the National Register and California Register at the local level of significance.
Designed in the Mission-revival architectural style, the church rises to a height of five stories in three increments and has two golden-domed bell towers with open arches. The twin towers frame the central massing with three large doors at the ground floor set within deeply recessed arched openings that provide entry to the church. The side elevations of the edifice include buttressed bays with inset custom decorative stainedglass windows at the ground floor and within the upper attic story. The gabled shed roofs of the main church structure feature terracotta barrel tiles. A major renovation in 1959 removed the small spires on the twin towers, as well as the decorative plaster ornamentation which surrounded the central tripartite stained-glass window above the entry doors; however, the colorful decorative painted and figurative glass windows which give distinction to the inside of the structure remain. Its associated buildings, such as the rectory and the two-story convent building, are also designed in the Mission style to complement and harmonize with the church, although these structures have lost integrity or are from a later period of significance.
Pursuant to Preservation Brief 17 from the National Park Service, identifying those visual and tangible aspects of the historic building that help to convey an understanding about the significance of the resource is essential in the defining the character-defining features as they relate to the preservation of an historic site. These prominent features, such as types of construction materials, construction methods, the delineation of spaces, architectural styling, important landscape features, etc. are key features that give a building its visual character and without these elements, the essential aspects of its historic nature may be irreparably damaged. Below is a summary of the characterdefining features for the subject property.
The character-defining features associated with the Church of the Good Shepherd are those features on the exterior of the central church building that reflect and define its Mission-revival architectural style and ecclesiastical property type. Character-defining features include all primary exterior elevations, form, massing, scale, proportions, structure, architectural ornamentation, and materials identified. Such features include, but are not limited to the following:
Church Building Exterior
• One-story (double height) volume
• Rectangular building plan
• Location, massing, scale, proportions, and siting of the sanctuary church building on site
• Primary elevations defined as south, west, east, and north elevations • Red tiled gable roof with overhanging eaves and exposed wood purlins • Smooth stucco sheathing
Meeting Date: October 3, 2023
• Original (existing) setbacks from public sidewalks and streets along south (front) and east elevations
• Formal concrete stairs/steps, and landing at front (south) elevation Bell Towers
• Attached five-story, three level incrementally stepped twin towers at south end of the church building
• Smooth stucco sheathing with pronounced cornice trim at incremental levels
• Engaged stucco buttresses
• Flat and round-headed openings
• Metallic (gold) domes
South (front) Elevation
• Projecting three-bay arcade with red tiled hood
• Three wooden double doors
• Tympana (semi-circular decorative wall surfaces) over the three entrance doors
• Deeply recessed entry doors set into corresponding arched shaped openings
• Large tripartite stained-glass window with curvilinear trim • Gable end attic vent opening with curvilinear trim
East/West (side) Elevations
• Eight buttressed bays (each elevation)
• Engaged stucco pilasters at upper level
• Elongated round-headed window openings
• Round-headed window openings set in pairs at upper level • Decorative stained glass
North Elevation
• High volume round shaped apse with multi-hip red-tile roof • Round-headed window openings
• Gable end attic vent opening with curvilinear trim
• Floor to ceiling fixed windows with decorative stained glass Based on the City Landmark Assessment Report and other evidence, the subject property appears to satisfy the following Landmark Criteria (pursuant to BHMC §10-3- 3212) in support of its landmark nomination: A.1 (age), A.2 (artistic value and architectural style), A.3 (integrity), A.4 (historic value), B.5 (iconic property), and B.6 (voluntary designation).
GENERAL PLAN CONSISTENCY
Designation of the subject property as a local historic landmark is consistent with the objectives, principles, and standards of the General Plan. General Plan Policy “HP 1.3 – Promote National, State, and Local Designation of Historic Resources” encourages the establishment of programs encouraging the nomination of landmarks.
ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT
Designation of the “Church of the Good Shepherd” in Beverly Hills as a local historic landmark was assessed in accordance with the authority and criteria contained in the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), the State CEQA Guidelines, and the environmental regulations of the City. It has been determined that designation of the subject property would not have a significant environmental impact and is exempt from Meeting Date: October 3, 2023
CEQA pursuant to Sections 15061(b)(3), 15308, and 15331 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations. It can be seen with certainty that there is no possibility that the designation of the subject property may have a significant effect on the environment, as no specific development is authorized by this resolution, and any future development proposed pursuant to this resolution will require separate environmental analysis when the details of those proposals are known. Further, designating the residence is an action of the City to protect and preserve a historic resource.
PUBLIC OUTREACH AND NOTIFICATION
The property owner indicated their support of the landmark designations during the Cultural Heritage Commission application and review process. As required by the City’s Historic Preservation Ordinance, notice of the public hearing for consideration of landmark designation by City Council was provided to the property owner fifteen (15) days in advance. As of the writing of this agenda report, no public comments have been received regarding the Council agenda item.
FISCAL IMPACT
Landmark designation of a property in Beverly Hills does not create a direct fiscal impact. No further fiscal impact is anticipated to result from the landmark designation of the property.
Ryan Gohlich
Assistant City Manager
Approved By
City Council Report
Landmark Designation – Church of the Good Shepard
October 3, 2023
ATTACHMENT 1
City Council Draft Resolution
!"#$%&
'#$"(!
%)*+,#!'%) $#(!
%)#*!!-!'(.$((/0&$"$,+(%1! +0#*%'$2!/#*!$#.%0&"$(#%1!/$3&+#!(%"+((+&14+'5/+&1*$/#%'$"1$/#'$"#/+&1#%,(+"! #*%/!,'%,!'#$!/+&13!%3'+,*$"+(+'!+/%&#*!$#.%)!-!'(.$((/!3$/#!'%)$/#%'$" '%,!'#$!/
!"#$%&
&60(.
#*!0(#0'+(!'$#+3!%44$//$%&"%&/$1!'!1(+&14+'5 $&$#$+#$%&)%'#*!/078!"#,'%,!'#.+&1-%#!10&+&$4%0/(.#%$&$#$+#!(+&14+'5,'%"!!1$&3/ &60(.
#*!$'!"#%'%)%440&$#.!-!(%,4!&#)$&+($2!1+'!($4$&+'.-+(0+#$%&,0'/0+&##% !"#$%&
9'!($4$&+'.-+(0+#$%&:%)#*!!-!'(.$((/0&$"$,+(%1! )$&1$&3#*+# #*!,'%,!'#.4+.7!!($3$7(!)%'1!/$3&+#$%&+/+(+&14+'57+/!1%&+-+$(+7(!!-$1!&"!+##*!#$4!
!"#$%&
&60(.
#*!0(#0'+(!'$#+3!%44$//$%&"%&10"#!1+,'!($4$&+'. *!+'$&3'!3+'1$&3#*!,'%,!'#.+#
%'#*!1)%'1'$-!$&!-!'(.$((/ ,0'/0+&##% !"#$%&
9+&14+'5%'$/#%'$"$/#'$"#!/$3&+#$%&'%"!!1$&3/;'!($4$&+'. !+'$&3:%)#*!!-!'(.$((/0&$"$,+(%1! +&1"%&"(01!1#*+##*!*0'"*%)#*!%%1 *!,*!'1 <+''+&#!1)%'4+("%&/$1!'+#$%&7.#*!%44$//$%&)%'$&"(0/$%&%&#*!$#.%)!-!'(. $((/!3$/#!'%)$/#%'$"'%,!'#$!/ +/!1%&#*!'!($4$&+'.-+(0+#$%&$//0!17.#*!$'!"#%' =>?@ABCDEFDGHI>JHEK=LEMNOPQRPST==PRTUOVMTWXYXTOVXOVZZOR=VR
!"#$%&'
(
)
*
'
+,-.+,+&
'
)
-/0
1 '
2
.
) 3
"
4)
3
5
.2
"
4
6 -/7+.-/785
0,,
5
2
&
#
#
'
*
.
) . )
)
2 )
)
)
)
2
)
.
)
)
)
)
)
2
.
-/+/
)
)
)
.)
)
9 )
.)
))
:
).
*
; )
<=>?@ABCDECFGH=IGDJ<KDLMNOPQORS<<OQSTNULSVWXWSNUWNUYYNQ<UQ
! "# $%&'!(%!) #*(" +""%+%((%(*) ($ ) & ) ,!"$ -%)%#% %%)( (.!(/ %#($%- ) )%)")"") $/)(0,)%$ #""1 -2 3 !( # $ ' ($4%"-,"! $(%- #) (( 5 6789:8;78 <=;:78>?@7AB>9C=8DEFG8A=;@:8?>8;H=I8?@89:8;8J@?J=@7A8?>8=K7@;?@L9M;@A8:9HM9>9N;MN= !( # $ ' ($')(% !( ,!"$ -1)%,!" 5OPQ) $%*(Q )(%#)-
(#(& '('( %)%#% %((
3 !( # $ ' ($4%"-,"! $(%- #) (( P
678 J?::=::=:8R9HR8;@79:79N8?@8;=:7R=79N8C;<S=I8;ML8=TU?L9=:87R=8L9:79MN79C=8NR;@;N7=@9:79N:8?>8;M8 ;@NR97=N7S@;<8:7A<=8?@8;@NR97=N7S@;<87AJ=I8?@8;@NR97=N7S@;<8J=@9?LV8 '('( %)")(W)/'" # %% X(**)")( !()"% ") $1)%$ #$)%')(# 3*(" +""% !( %X /)(!' -4 Y%5OZ X5OZ[+%(!(*
'%%%%% - )(%) $)% *)"!
(#(& '('( /% %((
3 !( # $ ' ($4%"-,"! $(%- #) (( \
678@=7;9M:8 :SU:7;M79;<89M7=H@97A8>@?T897:8J=@9?L8?>8:9HM9>9N;MN=V '($#%- #) #( %'('( 1!"$"0" ,5OPQ& $)# (- )" %(! # ,!"$ -
)'')(% ) /) !( %(!!()
]5X
]
( $#($(*%!,%) )"" () %%(- )"&W(( )'')() ) $)"" )()(X (,! -#)!(%)( ) (#(& '('( %)%#% %((
3 !( # $ ' ($4%"-,"! $(%- #) (( Q
678R;:8 N?M79MS=L8R9:7?@9N8C;<S=87?87R=8N?TTSM97A8:SNR87R;7897:8L=:9HM;79?M8;:8;8<;MLT;@^89:8@=;:?M;U<=8 ;ML8M=N=::;@A87?8J@?T?7=8;ML8>S@7R=@87R=8JS@J?:=:8?>87R9:8;@79N<= !( # $ ' ($1)% #(%#(/)" !( ,!"$ -($ *(" +""%
)%)" -) $(
_`abcdefghfijk`ljgm_ngopqrstruv__rtvwqxovyz{zvqxzqx||qt_xt
!
"
#
$
%&'()*(+,( )-.,)-(/0./10'23(
"
!
"
4
5
"
4
"
6
4
7
"
8
"
4
"
#
$
9:;1( <+,=>+0?(=1*)@,+').,(/0.-1=A01()*(),)')+'1=B(.0(1C/01**<2(+@011=('.B(D2(';1(.E,10F*G(.H(';1( /0./10'23
4
6
4
IJ"
9 KLKML NM85O5O 8MKPLM K !PQN
M LMMLRMNP
#
$
S1-01'+02(.H(';1(&,'10).0T*(S'+,=+0=*(H.0(';1(:01+'>1,'(.H(U)*'.0)-(V0./10')1*(E)';( WA)=1<),1*(H.0(V01*10X),@B(Y1;+D)<)'+'),@B(Y1*'.0),@B(+,=(Y1-.,*'0A-'),@(U)*'.0)-(ZA)<=),@* I[\\%J ]
I
!5
J
^
_
`abcdefghigjklamkhn`ohpqrstusvw``suwxrypwz{|{wry{ry}}ru`yu
!
!
!!
! !
!
"
!
# $
%
&'(
)
*
&'+
&',
!
!!
!
&'-
! !
!
&'+
&'
&'(
)
* .
.
)
*
&'/
0 !
) *
$ &'1
!
&'
&'%
&'/
23456789:;9<=>3?=:@2A:BCDEFGEHI22EGIJDKBILMNMIDKMDKOODG2KG
!
! "
#"
"
""
$
"
%
"
&'
"
""
"
(
"
"
"" #
)
*
""
"
(
"
%
"
+
,
-./01234564789.:85;-<5=>?@AB@CD--@BDE?F=DGHIHD?FH?FJJ?B-FB
!"
#
$%
&' () *+,-,+- '-.&/'(* 0), ,'.,),* ,1,.*
2'-()+).&- *3-.4*+0 - 1'.+'- ,5.(&((++. .+.5- .* -
,&' (,./&*+0 -+,
,'.,),*,1,.*
-+-(-((- *3-.4 ('** ,&)5.(&((+0+.)+. .1.+6/-+* ,.33 *- + ,&- *3-.4++++3 1.- *&' (*(/.- + 7
#
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
Y
#$
+0 - ),
,'.,), *,1,.*
-+-(-(,+.(- *3-.4]-+-++++* -.*- ],,-',.&- * _`abcdefghfijk`ljgm_ngopqrstruv__rtvwqxovyz{zvqxzqx||qt_xt
!
"
#$
"
%"
"
&'()& *&'*(+
&'**& ,&-
.
$
"
!
"
#
"
"
/
"
" "
"
$0
"
$
" "
1
$
2
!
"
#
"
"
&(
3.4543
63 ,3
7 8
!
"
#
1
$
9
"
"
5
5
5 :;5&
*<5 3
4 8
;
.
:
"
1
&&
,
"
!
"
#
1
=
.
;
5 "
"
8 "
8"
-''3
.%
8>;
?(@&(
ABCDEFGHIJHKLMBNLIOAPIQRSTUVTWXAATVXYSZQX[\]\XSZ\SZ^^SVAZV
!
"#$%&%'"
!'' (
)))))))))))))))))))))))))))) *+'! ,
-#'./(
.0 (
/
%
1% '2
+(
(%.
33#&%.
#$#( 33#&%.
#
#,
%,
' +%,
%
4!%,% , ,
"
+,
5 #$$%"
( 6
" ,-#
'!
( 6
%7 8
' 9 9 #: 6/*
;
<
=>?@ABCDEFDGHI>JHEK=LEMNOPQRPST==PRTUOVMTWXYXTOVXOVZZOR=VR
!"!#
$%&'()*+,-+./0%1/,2$3,4567897:;$$79;<6=4;>?@?;6=?6=AA69$=9
!
"# $
" %&'%%()*+,-./.*012*3/.4-./.*0153006478
$9:;<9:=>?9@ 73+1)A-./.*0153006 7)BBCD3+12./.0)EB.D+2.EF*+B.D+ G0FDD3DH23/363)D47C0+C*F05.*3+FH.7)BB3663)D I%%7*.6J.D+2*3/.4-./.*0153006478K& $9:;<9:=LM@ FDN6+F6,F14G*3DJ3EF0 N6+F6,F1O866)J3F+.67)D6C0+3DH GN-NP%I4)DH-.FJ,478KQ& RSTUVWXYZ[Y\]^S_]Z`RaZbcdefgehiRRegijdkbilmnmidkmdkoodgRkg
!"#!$%!#%& '
%()*)% ') '++ #'#
!"##$## $
$%& '()**+ %
,$
-./01234563781399:996:4/17:;<7/11 1
-=>?@=1AB1C=D1EAAF19=DG=D?F1 & H$
I&
J$ $J$ )))#
"K** "
LM+M*NOM+M*NM
.4/7<5P-/.<4 H#)
!
##$## $
$%&
Q& %)$$
R#
#H
S"##&Q
$#&
#()
,T"UI& H$ &I$J$ )))#
&Q( $
#
$J
)(
$#H$)&Q
)#,
IQ
Q$
)
!$),R)&I H$H( QH&IH$ &&
H$%H$
QH( QHR()
,T#(RV$Q% &%$ U)&Q
$
& H $
I&
J$
H$Q&I$J$ )))# H$I&Q(#&IH$
##$## $
#&
)H$QH
%$)R()
,
#
QHJ
) $#$
QH
H$I$)
#( J$
Q
$H
H$ $Q&
$
QH$
,
,$# (Q( $WH(%#
#
%
$
H
J$ (
$ ,&
$Q&
#
$
R)$
)$
&
#H
H
J$#,
IQ
)Q& % & #$
H$ H#& Q
)
$, H$&H$
(X)
# (Q( $#&
H$%
#H, &(
#
$&KMY
&(#
$&IH$ QH( QHR()
,Z#K*M%$ &
&I#,
IQ
Q$T
$&IQ&
# (Q&
U
Q)(
$
H$ $%& #
#Q(##&
&IH$#( J$ $H&
&)&,(#$
#(
[$
$#Q %&
&IH$#(RV$Q% &%$
#H#& Q
)
$,
R $IQ&
$X(
)H#& &IH$ % &%$
$J$W&IH$)&Q
))
!Q $
Q&
#
$ $
H$$J
)(
&
% &Q$##
I&
) $J
)(
&
&IH$% &%$ I& )&Q
)H#& Q
)#,
IQ
Q$
%H&&,
%H#
%%)Q
R)$ #(%%&
,
$
)# 6:/\<5<2<E0 H$)
!
##$## $
W
#Q&
(Q$
R'
#
#H
Q%
)&I"
&
$ &
$
I
$J
)(
$H$#(RV$Q% &%$
#
%&$
))&Q
))
!
$
#J$)$J$)#( J$W
# Q&
(Q$
H$
##$## $
Q)(
$
$J$W&IH$
&
)$,#$ &I#& Q
)
Q$# T
&
)$,#$ U
#
(
)(%
$#
H$
)I&
$,#$ &I#& Q
)$#&( Q$# T
)I&
$,#$ U
H$
)I&
#& Q$#&( Q$#
J$
& TU)#
$
RH$
$IIQ$&I#& Q
$#$ J
&
T
U
H$&I$J$ )))#H#& Q $#&( Q$#
J$
& #( J$I)$#
(QH
$J$WH$)%$
&
$$
$I
$J
)(
&
#& #( J$
##$## $
#&IH$% &%$ H
R$$
% $J&(#)Q& %)$$
& H#Q( $
)
!
##$## $
I$)
#( J$W
#Q&
(Q$
$J$W&IR()
, %$ #
X
##$##& $Q&
#
&H$
QHJ
)
H#& Q%H&&,
%H#W
#%$ I& $
&
&Q( $
H$% &%$ Z#$X#
,Q&
&
###
$J
)(
,H$% &%$ I& H#& Q
) #,
IQ
Q$H$&I$J$ )))#)
!Q $
W$ $$ %)&$
&$J
)(
$H$)&Q
) #,
IQ
Q$&IH$# (Q( $
#$),R)I&
J
(
)
$#,
&
#
&I$J$ )))#
!
#(
H$I&))&W
,
#!#W$ $%$ I& $
I& H$#(
L
]^_`abcdefdghi^jhek]lemnopqrpst]]prtuovmtwxyxtovxovzzor]vr
!"##$## $
$%& '()**+ %
,$*
-
$
./$
$.&
#&0/$
&
)$,#$
)0&
$,#$
#& . $#&( .$#
1$
&
/$2#
1$
& #( 1$0)$# -&
(.$
0$)
#%$.&
%/&&,
%/$
/$#(34$.% &%$ -&
(.$
#$#%$.0. $#$
./&
/$#(34$.% &%$ ()5
,
3&
$
#(
.$6
%#
.
$.& $#
$7#%
%$
.)$#
/#& .
)%/&&,
%/#
.)(
,
$
)%/&&,
%/#
3()
,%$ # -$1$7$
)5$
&
.$#
#
($#
$,()
&
#
3())$
#
$./
.
)
$
)# $)
,&0$
$
)
#
$
)&.
)/#& .% $#$ 1
&
$#,
&
##$## $
% &.$
( $#
$)
$
% &,
# -1
)(
$
/$%&$
)/#& . $#&( .$3
#$
(%&
. $
$#
3)#/$
3/$ &0$1$ )))#
()5$
/$
#( 1$ $/&
&)&,0& .&
(.
,#( 1$
##$## $
# 89:;9:<= /$/( ./&0/$ &&
/$%/$
)&.
$
& /$
0&
1$
%%$
#&#
#0 /$2#. $
0&
1
(
)
$#,
&
#
&0$1$ )))#
!
# $>( $
$.&
++**&0/$#& .
$#$ 1
&
.$?
.$@/#% &%$
%%$
# &#
#0
))&0/$
$#&0#(3#$.&
"
7&&0/$
$#(
$ #(3#$.&
&0 /$
.$ ABCD<EFG:;H9:8FEIBJ9F: /$K/( ./&0/$ &&
/$%/$
#
#
/$
& /7$#.&
$ &0
6&
.
&()$1
& /$
0&
1$$
,&
$&0/$ #3)$./( ./$#
)&
,
6&
.
&()$1
##$
3$7$$
%& &
#&0$1$ )
$
#
!/$./( ./#$&..(%$#/ $$$
)&# ?)&#L
M@&0
.M*N7/
/$&0$1$ )))#&,$/$
/$/ $$%
.$)# $
#( $ &(,/)*0$$7
$?$
#O7$#@
*+
$$%?
& /O#&(/@/$./( ./3()
,#& $
$
7/#0 &
?%
@0
P
$0
.
,#&(/&7
#
6&
.
&()$1
/$ $.& #
4 .$
/$./( ./&/$
& /
0 &
#&
&& /$
0&
1$/$ % &1$ $
#&
/$#$
$#$
)&
,/$7$#$
% &%$ )
$
$
& $
)1#3)$0 & /$%(3). ,/#&07
/$$..)$#
#.
)% &%$ ##(
$
/$3
#$&0/$
$,/3& /&&
!
&7
# /$Q0)
#R
&/$#&(/#/$3(#
$##
$
.& &
) $0$ $
&
#/$Q.& $ .
)
,)$RK /$#(34$.% &%$ 7
#
))
$
0$
$.&
$
.&3$ SNM
#%
&0
3 &
$ #( 1$&0/$&#"
,$)$#
$
.&
(.$
3/$&#"
,$)$#
(
)#& 6(#$( /$ % &%$ 7
#0&(
&3$%&$
))$),3)$0&
1
(
))#
,
/$
&
)$,#$ &0 #& .
)
.$#?
&
)$,#$ @"#%
&0/$STSTM.#%&
#& $
/#& . $#&( .$# #( 1$/$% &%$ 7
# $
$
0$
$.&
$
#
.&
3(& &
%&$
)/$
. , &(%
,&0 $),&(#3()
,#)&.
$
7/
/$$1$ )))#.& (
"/$ $
/$
# .7
#
##,
$
Q
R
)0&
#& .
)$#&( .$
(#&
$/#
,.&
$ U VKWXYXZ[\K]^[[_K`ab^c^de[KfghXKi^j[XKVkKfledjXZKmKnZj^c[XKmopK qrstuvwxyzx{|}r~|yqy
qqq
!"##$## $
$%& '()**+ %
,$+
-
$
.
.$, &(%
,
%%$
$
&/$.#& -
))#,
0-
(
$ )&-
)- $
#
%&$
).#& -
# -$-
(#$.$
)0&
#& -
)$#&( -$#
(#&
$#1$ $ (%
$
/.$
)0&
00-$&0#& -
$#$ 2
&
3
4
*+
.$
)0&
#& -
) $#&( -$#
0&
&
#$ 3
4 &1 $0)$-#.$% &%$ 1.
567
,(
$ .$ )#
,&0.$8989:#( 2$
-
,.
$$
#&/$ $$2
)(
$
.$-.( -.% &%$ 1
# $
##$##$
#%
&0.$*;.#& - $#&( -$##( 2$(%
$.$#
-(
1
#0&(
2
(
))$),/)$0& )#
,
.$
&
)$,#$
)0&
$,#$ ##
(#
#
-&
/(& &.$%&$
))$),/)$)&-
).#& -
# -
$0
$
#.$$2$ )))#.( -.$# .$
- &(%
,1
#
)#& $-&
0 $
-$.
$
.$% &%$ .
#
&/$$
$ $2
)(
$
(
$
&.$ #( 2$$00& ##%&
#& $
/.$&0$2$ )))# <=><?=@ABC?DE=F<@F>GBHGCBE>GD@=IE@F>GBJFD@>=A CKLMNOPQORST*--(% ,.$
& .1$#-&
$ &0
U&
-
&()$2
& .$
0&
2$
.$.( -.&0.$ &&
.$%.$
1 #
$#,
$
.$U##&
$22
)#)$
/()
8*;.$#
-(
#
.,.2&)( $
&
$#& # (-( $1.
$-
,()
%)
)$ $
#&0 .$#)$
$ $0)$-$
.$# (-( $V#
##
,
# $
# %)-$
)$
,
/)$ &&0#1.&2$ .
,
,$
2$#
$W%&#$
1&&
%( )
#
-.& $
/1
/$))&1$ #
.$ #&(.$
-
%.$# &&.#(--&#.$
.$
-.( -./()
,#
,&
.$,.&002$#& $#
. $$
- $ $
#
.$&1$ #
$/( $##$
%$ -$
/0)
&(
.$
$
&%$
,#
#( &(
$
/ $
))-3,&)
4 & $#
- &##$#.$ &
( $
)&1$ #0
$
#),.) % &X$-
,. $$/
-
$1.
)$
.&&
Y. $$3
&
& ,
)4&
$)-
2$
1&&
$
&(/)$
&& #
%
3#$ - -()
$-&
2$1
))#( 0
-$#&2$ .$. $$$
-$
&& #4
$
$$%)#$
&.$-& $#%&
,
-.$
&%$
,#"/&2$.$$
.$,
/)$$
.$)
,$ %
$#
$
,)
##1
&11.-( 2)
$
1
#& ,
))$ /$))#.$
1.
&Z($&
$
&
&1$2$
.$
$
)
,1
# $ &2$
(
,
X& $
&2
&
88Y
$-&
2$%
-)$##$
.$-&
$ #&0.$. $$
- $ $
)$2$)#&0.$&1$ #1$ $
)#& $ &2$
.# $ ,./( $##$
/
#-&
,#
,)$$)&
,
$
&(
.$
$
1
&1&%$
,#
#$-&
$
-$
&& #
$0
$.$, &(
0)&& )$2$)&0.$#
$$)$2
&
#3$
#
1$#4
$/
-!0 & .$, &(
0)&& 1
))%)
$#.$(%%$ %& &
#&0.$$
#
1$#0
-
$#
$
$0
$
/$,.%)
#$ $
/
#.
$%(
-(
$
/ &(
.$
$
1
&1&%$
,##$
%
#&)& 0())
$#,
$
#
$
,)
##1
&1#
$#$1.
.$-.( -./()
,1
&1 &%$
,#
)&
,
))0&( $)$2
&
#.$, &(
0)&& )$2$)&0.$#
$
,)
##0$
$#
&
$%-#!$ $),&(#0,( $#
-)(
,
"
$1.&(
,)$##$
,
)$##$
U&.$ U
1..$. #-.)
'&#$%.
"
.&
&0
(
U-.
$)&0" -.
,$)
$$
().$"%&#)$
-!
'&.
.$2
,$)#
.$
- $
$
&0'$#(#
.$ &&
.$%.$
".,.2&)( $ &(
#.
%$
%#$1.0)&& &-$)
,3
&
& ,
)40W$
1
&1# 1.
$-&
2$#
$
,)
##
().% &&0$
$#.$
& .$
&0.$#
-(
.$ 2$# && #
-.$
&.$-.( -./()
,
.$
& .1$#-&
$ &0.$# (-( $"0$1 &0.$$W$ & 1
))#&0.$2$#
$%(
-(
$
/& ,
)
$-&
2$#
$
,)
##1
&1# [ \]^_`abc_]defg]bhc]icjcekl]mnkko]phqerhcosthcg`bnr]uefqanvw]pfvbnvq`bnfv]xhccby]phqerh]fd]bhc]uff_]xhcahce_] p`bhfknr]phqerhz]{rbf|ce]}~]
!"##$## $
$%& '()**+ %
,$-
.$
,/ & 0$ $
1 & 02&/0$30( 304()
,#
&
$#& &%$
)&,,
1 3
$20
3&
$3#&0$ $3& 0$
3 $
4()
5*-
##(33&$
3 %%$
60
$
)$
,
4)$ &&/
/$
( $#
#$ $#&/
))
30$
#0
%$
&%$
,#&
0$$
#
6$##
$#0$
%
#0&)&
)$77
)#)$6&&
/
$
6&#& $3& 603 &##,
4)$ &&/6
#
)#& 4()
5*-#%
1/ &
2$)$7
&
/
3$#&
&& 0$
/&
7$
58+
0$4()
, 6
#$.$
#7$) $ &
$)$
)$ $
1$.$ &
$ & 2
&)&
,$ $/)$3##& ,
)
$#,
$
& 30
3$
$/
,/$
( $#$3
(#$&/$.$
#7$
)$
&
#
$&0$ $.$ & &/0$ $3& 4()
,&7$ 0$$
##
&%
&/0#
##$## $
0$6&#& ,
,$#$4$0
0$ $3&
0$
& 06$#3&
$ &/0$#$6
#$ $3$
0$/
))&/5*-
3)(
$
)7
,9(
$ #(%#
#0
0
:& 0$
/&
7$
$##0## (3( $6
#
%% &
30$
7
)&
,
7$&//$
/&
7$0 &(,0
3&7$ $
%& $3&30$ $0
6
#
30$
&
&0$
& 0#
$&/0$ $3& 0$,
,$# (3( $
&(4)$
#;$60
&
4()&
&##&(0#
$#$7$
)
$3
$#)
$ 7$ 0$$
# 0#
33$##& # (3( $0
#4$$
&
/$
##(30#
&%
&/0#0#& 3
##$## $
0$&
$#&
$3
,()
#0
%$
3))
4()
,4()
5-<##(
$
)&
,0$6$##
$ &/0$% &%$ #$#
&
3&
4(
,/$
( $&0$0#& 3
( $&/0$#$
#
)#&
&%
&/0#0#& 3
##$## $
=>?@ABCDAEBF?GH" $7$6&/ $)$7
#&( 3$
$
)
3
$#0
0$#$
3)(
,0$ 30( 30
$3&
,
,$60#$3&
/)&&
%
$
, &(
#0
7$(
$ ,&
$#& $
&
#
I& &
/3
&
#1$.$ &
$ & 2#
3$6
#3&
# (3$
5*-
$ # &
/)$600$&/$7$ )))#
3)(
$0$/&))&6
,J KLMNC OLPQNR=SRTUCTVCWTNXC 5*- 0( 30
Y
5*-
,$
Z(
$ #
Y
* 5+5 "
&
J6& && #
$
&/ $3&
Y
-
5-< "
&
J $3 $
&
0 ))
Y
5-[ $6%)
#$
4)$
/.( $#
$
;;&/)&&
&& #
Y*
55
$$)3&)(
#/& $
/& 3$ $
&/6&/ &
&6$ #
Y
\&0$ &
/3
&
#
$ 58 $ &
$)%
&/& #&
,$
Y
58+ ")$
&
#&,
,$
Y*
58+ ")$
&
#& $3&
Y8
5<* "
&
#&,
,$# (3( $
Y
55 &
6 ))#
Y8
55* $6 &&/1% $#( $
$3& 2
Y+
55- $ &&/130( 302
Y*
1$
09(
!$
,$ $%
2 55-
(3(
) $
/& 3
,
Y
1$
09(
!$
,$ $%
2 55
$# 36& !
Y*
1$
09(
!$
,$ $%
2 55
$# 36& !
Y
1$
09(
!$
,$ $%
2 558 $$#
,$.$ &
$
/3
&
#,
3&
$ &/
]&
3
)7
$
/&
7$
##$##
,0$% & 6& !3&
(3$
&
0$% &%$
0$30( 304()
,^#& ,
)
30$3(
)
$#,
#
%%$
#/ & 0$%(4)3 ,0#&/6
)) %&
7#4)$
_`abcdefghfijk`ljgm_ngopqrstruv__rtvwqxovyz{zvqxzqx||qt_xt
!"##$## $
$%& '()**+ %
,$
-.
-$
$/
,/$
( $# $
-
&
.$-.( -.0()
,
%%$
#& $
(-.&/#.#& -
)
$,
$ #&/
$#,
)&-
&
$
)#
1& !
#.%
#$
,
/$$)
,
##&-
&
/ & #%$ &
&/#,
/-
-$23*45 6789:;7<=>?<:@9AB9 CDEDFGH?6IGGJ.$$
)#$)$ $
$K$)&% $
&/$K$ )))#0$,
&
1. 1
#-
))$
-.&&
$&
$)
#",(
#.#)
1 #& ,
))-)
$
0L$M-
#$)$ #L
)
$N
.$ .(#0
-$
$
)
$N
&(
O**"%)
$
.$
-.&/.$
.$
, &/.$P
$ #
.$#1
%#& Q-$
$,
#R.
-.
-$ N$.$
(
))
#-
%$1$ $- $
$
0
(
&///)&1
,&(&/&)
1 $
$
$
-
&
#$,$
0)$/
,
#.$$% .$
,
0$$!$$%
,
.$
#
,&/1
)
( $$#1$ $.$%
, -()(
)
-K$# 1.
.$
-.&)
#
(
,.$)
$ .
)/&/.$
$$$
.-$
(
$K$
)
$ %#
#(0
K
,
$#
0)#.
,-& (
$#&
.$
-.)
#1$ $
$ %$
(
,.$OS#
OO#0($
$
/
)( $+
3S
.$"
),
$
)& %
$& ,
N$
#.$&
$&
P
$ & %
( &
$$
%)
$
)$
, &)$
/& ()
,.$%)
#/&
,
$
-
)&-
$
0$1$$
P.$
K$&
.$1$#
&.$
K$&
.$$
#
P)#. $&()$K
&
.$#&(.
.$ /&&.))#
0&K$
(
#$&()$K
&.$
& .4.$#
-
$. $
&
0)$
)/&
%
! %)
$
P)0( &&!
'
&%)
.$
$1-& (
&&!.
1& !$
1.)
#-
%$
-.$- $
$ -!
1) #$
% & & &K
,&
!)
3&$#
0)#..#&1
/ & % #$
&/Q$K$ )R
.$-& $ -
)
,)$0$1$$
L&
-
P)#. $ 0&()$K
#
Q$K$ )))#R
& .&/
L&
-
&()$K
.$
$1-& (
1
#&
$ &/.$$
)$#%)
$
-& (
$#
#&(.$
)/&
& %$
)
,$)0-&
-$
&K$ .$1
$
#-.&&)##$ #
$#
$
#K&$
&
-& %&
$
34
- $
$
.$
$1&/$K$ )))#.$& ,
)0&(
$#&/.$-1$ $ (-. .$#
$
#.$
$&
$M-$%/& .$
$
#&(.&/P)#. $&()$K
$M$
3
&(#
)$#
$#
$M$
3L&#&/.$1
#&%$
)
.$ $&/
-& %&
&
1.
$K$)&% $
#-
$ $
&(
&
K$
$K$ )
K$
$#-$
K$
.$
&1
&1
,)$
.$
-.$-( $&/$K$ )))#
.$$
#/&))&1
,.$T#/&(
,1
#
&
$
0 .$
/#
L##&
$KK
)
$ &
$KK
)#)$#)!$(
& $KK
)
$& ,
$
(M" #)
##-# P.$K$ )))#$#
0)#.
,#$)/
#
.
K$
/& &K$#
#
.$ 3*#
.$
-.$-(
)-.
-$ &/.$-0$,
& $
)N$
K
,
$, $$&/$M
K
,
-$
.$
$#,
&/#.&(#
,#&-!. &(,.&(.$)
$3*#
3+##&%.#-
$
%$ &
$KK
)#)$#
&
$
.$
& $#-
-.$-( $&/.$-
-)(
,&)&
)$KK
)
%
#.&)&
)$KK
)
$
-.&
(
& $KK
)
.$)!$.$
&)
$ 3+#$K$ )))#0$-
$&
$&/.$
$
#
#&(.$
)/&
&#-)&#$)-&
$-$
1. .$
$K$)&% $
&/.$&))1&&
$,$
-#)$&
&/.$ $$
,&/L&
$
$#)$$!
$## 1..$$)$,
-$&/$
)
$$$
.-$
(
-.$-(
)/& #
(#$
# %)$
%
/& # U VWXYZY[\]W^_\\`W^_`ab[_cWdY`be[cY`Wfe[ZY]WghijkghilmW^_`ab[_cWnboaYpamWqrsWjsW tWuv_wmWqqsWikhsW jWuv_wmWqrsWggsW xyz{|}~y
xxxx
!"##$## $
$%& '()**+ %
,$-
.)
!/
))#( 0
1$#&% &2$1$31)(#4
#&%5#1
&
-$4$ )))#6
& $#1
15$1( $
5$%& )
7 $
#
/5$
1& %&
&
&0$44
) $0$ $
1$#
#
$/ 5&(#
,#&1!
)#&5$
&
(1&
&01&
$ %&
)(3(
$#,
# $0)$14$&05$8
1$
( 8&
$
& 5$$
&07& )
7
$4$ )))#/
#0())
$4$)&%$
.(/
##)), &/
,
$
#
$#()
,
5$#(.
4#&
&0#& $)
,$$#
$#
5$
$ &)&
&0&)
$ .()
,#&1!0&
$/ ()0
)5&(#
,
1& $ 1
)
$4$)&% $
5$16#1& $ 1
)
# 1,
$
( .$ &0% &0$##&
)&11(%
#
$4$ )))#.$1
$)$##&0
.$
&& 1& (
& &#"
,$)$#
& $&0
$#
&
&0#$)0 9:;:<=>?@A==B?C:=ADAEFB?GHBIAIFIAEHBJK$),&(#.()
,#5
4$
1$
#0&1
)%&
#0& 5$ 1& (
#
1$5$L*#4$5#& 115( 15$#
$)&1
$
$4$ )))#
5 $$&
8&
1
&()$4
.$/$$
$
0&
&
$&
4$#
0&( 515( 15
$30&
4$
5
)$4))$&()$4
%
&15
)#15&&)
$
4$
5
)$4))$&()$4
5$ 5 $$.()
,#&
8&
1
&()$4
5 4$5#& 1
)).$$
5$ #.)$
$#$ .$/$$
%& &
#&0$4$ )
$
#
!5$#$5 $$15( 15$#
$4
&
#&
%
#5 &)&
)$44
)#)
,
##5$ &&
5$%5$
15&&)"4
&
0 & 5$5$ $#5$ 5 #
1$
1$5( 15
/515#$ %5
1
)))
##1
)
#
$#,
3$ & #&05$#$ .()
,#
$%
)1&
1 $$& #(11&
5$
%
#5#)$.()
,#5
4$1)
)$ &&0#
15&05$#
1(
$#5
4$
##& $
1))
.()
,#
1)(
, $#
$
1$#
(
#15&&)#
$)
$
1&(
#& 1)&#$ #5$5 $$
8&
1
&()$4
15( 15$#5
4$ $5$ .$$
)$ $
&#& $$3$
& #,
01
)$3%
$
5&(,55&#$&
5
)$4))$5
4$ $
$
$)
4$)
#.()
!$
)&,$5$
5$#$15( 15$#5
4$
!$
# ( $
) &)$
5$ $),&(#
#&1
)
$1&
& 1
141
1()(
)
15$1(
)5#& &01& (
MNF<ON?EP?IN:?QEER?SN:TN:<RU?VWXYVWV?ZJ?9:RPE<R?[<A;:J5$ #
1&
&0.()
,5$0 # 15( 15# (1( $
1(
))$ $1$
$4$ )))#.$)&
,#&5$&
5&)10
5\5$ 8##&
$44
)#)$5( 15&05$ &&
5$%5$
/
#.()
L*]
)&
,/55$
##&1
$
$1&
$
15$
/&#& ,
,$5$ &&
5$%5$
#5
$4$ )))#
5&/$4$
#
$
$
$
)$ 5$%
#5/
#& ,
^$
&
$1$ .$ *
L*+
/5$4$ $
815
$) '8())
#%)
1$
15 ,$
)#$ 41$#/$ $5$)
5$7
$ $ $"%
$
#
/515/
# )&1
$
]+L& 5$
0&
4$
5& )5$ $
0$
#$ 41$#/$ $5$)
0&
$
#
)) $1& &
$
4$(
)#%
1$5$ $% &4$
$_(
$
#$ 41$#/$ $5$
&4$
&5$$4$ )))#&$)
)$
,5&( #&
(
/55$%#1&%
)1&
, $,
&
$4$ $
815
$)'&5
8())
#`\LLa-b/
#
4$&0 $)
$,
(
$
0 &
(.)
4$ #
0
#5$
5$&)&,1
)1&( #$#
8
&&5&))$,$/5$ $5$/
#&
$
&
$1$ .$ \
L-
$
)La
5$/$
&
1$
#5
%)
/5$ $5$#$ 4$
5 $$$
#
/
#
##,
$
&5$" $ 1
0& 1$#/5$
5$
$
$#$
$ $
5$/
/
#
5$ 8())
#/5&&001
$
5$.(
)&05$0 #" $ 1
&001$ !))$
(
,5$/
$($
7))
^# &
#&0c
#
#$1
$&
5&)1
&1$#$&0&#"
,$)$#
L*
$ 5$
$1&
&05$,5$4$ $
#5&%'&5
'
/$))
5$ 8())
# d efghijkflmkfnokd ofpjqlrsjftuvwfrxsfyszsu{|f}i{{~fxuxs~xswqrifuvli mf}i~rvuifs~vus~fg
zs
rvu|ftvuwfrvhsufnekf firrvkf
¡¢£¡£¤¥£¦§¨§£¥§¥©©¡¥¡
!"##$## $
$%& '()**+ %
,$-
.&(
$
/$
/&)01&&
0( $"0& #2 ()
&." $ 0
1 0/3*+/#4
#/$. # &..0
)
&0$#
$0&,
&
&./$.)
(#
5
,
$
&5$ #$$
/$
)
$5$)&% $
&./$/( 0/&./$ &&
/$%/$
/$ 1())
#4
#)
$ $
##,
$
&5$ 6$ 3+7 "#/$%
#/, $4/$
$$
.&
%$
$
0/( 0/4
#
$$
$
/$
$
&.
$40/( 0/ .
0)4
#0&
#
$ $
$
)3*+4/%$ #
%)
#% &5
$
'(
$&./
$
/$ 1##&
$55
)#)$/( 0/&./$ &&
/$%/$
$#,
$
6&#"
,$)$#
0/$0'
$#'
&
$))
4 #0& %)$$
$0$ 6$ 4/#. ##$ 50$#/$)
&
/ #
#
3*8 4
#.&
))
$
0
$
&
(
$6 (
3* 9/
#
#(
$
0&
, $,
&
&
,/&#$4/&
$/$0/( 0/%&##6)$
0)(
$
#)$
#0 $$
0 $##1
10"5&:733378;4/&
&
$
/$9( )<$ %%$& ,
5 )($
=
0& $
#)$
.)
0& $
( %
:7>338;4/&
&
$
=7
.& /$ %$4#
0/)
0& '
0!$&&,
:38378;% &5
$
/$
,)
##:#
$
,)
##;4
&4#
'
0!$&&,
2#.
/$ ,
5$/ $$
)$ #
0&#&.=*
/$.,(
)
,)
##
#
$
,)
## 4
&4#
#4$))
#/$)
,$. &
%
$4
&4&./$#
0(
4$ $
$6/$#(
&# &./$
%
&
(
& %
&./0
,&
$4& !:
);/ &(,/&(/$$..& 0()
,
/$$ $0&
&./$0/( 0/
$#6$4$$
/$%
#/
/$ &&
%0( $ 0& (
$
$
# &
,/#0&
$0&
0&
($#&/$% $#$
9/
.$4$
#$?%
#&
%)
#4$ $%(6)#/$
/$@ABACDEFGHDDIFJHKHLAM
$
)
,
#0/&&)
0&
5$
$
$)
N
0$
&/$0/( 0/3&4$5$
)
$
3*7
$4#$
0/$0(
)#0/$ $.& /$#0/&&)4$ $
&(
0$
$
0
$
3+
/$$5$ )))#
/&)0
0/&&)
$
5$
/
)$5))$&()$5
4 #
$#,
$
1$
$
$
#)$61
!$ /$
$?$
$#
$
0$
8& /&?6(
5$4
#
0O( $
0&
5$ $
&
0&
5$
.& /$##$ #:)
$ 6$0
$#(%%& &..0$#.& /$0/( 0/; &
6)$%
#/&
$ #&./$ &&
/$%/$
/
5$
0)(
$
$#"
<
/
)$#&$
&#$
)&&
$
&&%$
$
$
(
$
'
(
$
$$
0/
5
6&
"). $
0/0&0!
$
$P$))
$
1
$
1
&6$4/
1 ( $$
2
())5
&#
)
(##$))
/&
#
& $
&(
,
(
&)%/
)$
&
&
,&/$ #9/)$5#
,
&(/$
).&
/$.
))&.3>
$#
$
'&/
P$
$
$
$
1 ##
/$0/( 0/&
(
&5$ 6$ 3/ /$/( 0/&./$ &&
/$%/$
/
#
)#&6$$
/$)&0
)$&.
( 6$ &.0$)$6 4$
,#
)$
.)
0 $##1
$1(
$
0$
5
1 5
/$ $
3*>:(
&)%/
)$
& 4
#/$6$#
;
1 3
$,/$$
$
&)
)<
6$/
)& 4
#
$
&&
0&)#&
:0!;)&
'
/$0/( 0/4
#
.
)$4$
,/
4&()
&6$
0/$
(
)
0$P$))
$
0$
$
1&
0&#& $#?$
#)
$
33
,$ &
$4
$
&
$)
0/$)(
$
/$ &&
/$%/$
/( 0/ $#
$#4$
,##$5$
)
&
6)$.(
$
)#$ 50$#/
5$6$$
/$)
/$0/( 0/4/&
$&./$ )
,$#6$
,/
.&
0& (
&)%/
)$
&
3*>/$0/( 0//
#/&#$
&/$ 0$)$6 .(
$
)#
0)(
,
$
1
:3;
&&%$ :3>;
9))
4)$:3>>;
&#
)
(##$)):3->;
$$
0/:3--;
'
(
$:37;
"). $
0/0&0!:37;
5
Q RFSJTUCVTFWXFKTAFYWWZF[TA\TACZ]^F@ABACDEFGHDDIFJHKHLAM]F_UDEF`a]F`RbcdFF efghijklmnlopqfrpmsetmuvwxyzx{|eexz|}w~u||w~w~wze~z
!"##$## $
$%& '()**+ %
,$-
.& /001
!
/0-21
&
3$4(
$
)#5$
$4& 3$067$ #&
&489 :;<=9>?9@A=BC
#4) $
3$ $ DEFFEGHIJKLELMNIOPQNKRISTUVFWSUXVFY3$3( 53&43$ &&
3$%3$
%
#3.()
, $
# 3$$##$
)53
5$
$4
,4$
( $#&43$Z##&
$77
)#)$3$Z##&
$77
)#)$
$C#
#%
&
4 & 3$)
$-3
$
)035$
( ##&
#&4
)4&
3$ #&(3C$#
$#5 .$
#3$4 #
,$
&(##)$&4
53$5( $
$7$)&%$
)4&
4$ .$5&
,%
&43$
$
$#
3$Z##&
$77
)#)$
$7$)&%$
&(&4
$# $&%
C33$
#$
5&)&
)
3$
5$
5 $
$
#)$3
C
#%
5()
&
)4&
5&
#&3$[($$
"
$#)$C3#$ %3
##&
$)
.&
$&
$
&
3$
53$5( $&43$ ##&
#&44$ $
& $# %)4$
.()
,% &4)$3
C
#
&&
) %5( $#\($
.(
)#& & $#($
&3$5)
$
$&43$4 #
]& .()
,#
3$Z##&
$77
)#)$C
#3$
)4&
()
,4& 3$^& )
_#&)( .
`%&#&
&4-0+
35
,&3$4& $ &#% &#$)a$ 4& 3$Z##&
$77
) &7$ $
C
#3
)$#)$53$ ( #
$
& &4b<Bc9Ad9:eB?fgBh
C3&5
%
,
$
4& 3$ $#&
&
&43$
)4&
##&
#
C353C$ $
#
$&4
7 5$
# $%
3$ $3$Z##&
$77
)#)$ .$5
$ & $C
$#% $
3$#&(3C$#
4$ .$
,
&%$
.3$
$
&(3$
545
) &
5& %
$#4& 3$
#
&
#
3&$)#" 53$5#.$,
&.& &C
%$
4 $$)#)#54$
( $#&43$
)4&
##&
#
5)(
,.
$%)
#$ /#(55&1C
))#
5( 7)
$
.$))#3
%$
%
%$#/& $#%
i
#1
5 $#/)&,,
#1
$
)$ &&4#
&4$
5& .
&
C3$)$ $
#&4&3$
53$5(
)#)$#&
%$ &
C
#3$4
7& $
#)$ 4& 575
53$5( $
&(3$
)4&
(#$
$#%$5
))4& 53
))#
#53&&)#
).
$#
$#
$
5$#
53( 53$# 3$Z##&
$77
)#)$
$#%$#
$
C
#
)$##3
)$
)
$ % $
&
&4#
$#
!$ ##&
#Z&#Z##&
$77
)
$#,
$
.()
,#
$&
$& C&#& $#
3$,3
5&7$ $
C3#(55&3
5
.$# &&3& $`( $
,$
$
)
Z##&
$77
).()
,# )
5!#( 4
5$&
$
&
C33$$`5$%&
&4
%)
#
,5&( #$3
&4$
&()
$# C
&C#
53$#%%$
&&4#C3&7$ 3
,
,$
7$#
$ & &
$
4
, 4$
( $#
5)(
$5( 7$
%
%$#/$#%
i
#1
& $ #
.$))&C$ #j%& 53$#
C3&#$ &&4#
$#(%%& $
.)
,$
#\(
$%$ #j#$ 5 5()
53&%$
,#
5 $#/)&,,
#1
C3
C3&( %&# &)
,#j
\(
$4&)
55$
C
&C#
4$
( $# 3
5$
$4
,$
( $#&43$Z##&
$77
)#)$
5)(
$k lm
$& & $#& $# lm%%$
& ,
.)$
$
)$ &&45&7$
, lm
&]$5
,7#& &&4C3 $
)$ &&45&7$
,
lm
&]$5
,$
7$#
(#(
))&%$
#(%%& $
.$`%&#$
4$ # lm
(55&$`$ & C
))# lm( 7)
$
%
%$#/$#%
i
#1
.$))&C$ #
& $ # lm&(
$
&%$
,#
4$
( $#/$C
&C#
53$#
5 $#/)&,,
#1
$51 lm %&# &)
,#
5&
(&(##
,5&( #$
&(
&%$
,# lm $
$
))
5!&4&
$
&
/# %)51 n op9qg=rh=s9t<=Aucv9w<ugdA=Bg<x?98=yfg;hy;e=<u9z=AB;gh=v9:<B;<9@<={<=<s9w89|9}h=h~=gBh9:g;fs9>Byv9ov9
!"##$## $
$%& '()**+ %
,$-
./0$
))1& 2&
)$ %1
##
##
, 34534567889::;8<5;=>?@A9>A4''
&
$))
$#,
$
1$1( B1&C1$ &&
1$%1$
#
B(
$B&
D&#& ,
,$
-*E'
$#'&#$%1
&
$))
D
#F&
&
G
HI
1B
,&
))
$ $1$D& !$
C& #$0$
)$
#
$%$
$
)
%
$ #1%D1
( F$ &C&1$
B1$B#1$(
&C1$*1B$
(
1$ $)&B
$
&
$
)$
1$
&
B#B&&%
BB$
B1$B( $$ &0$
&&#"
,$)$#F1$-**
D1$ $1$ $#
F)#1
B1$B(
)&CCB$
&D
&D
&#"
,$)$##%& C&)&&CD& !
1$
&(1)
B)(
$
1$
$#,
&C
%
$
F()
,#&C0
,#2$
#B
)$
1&#%
)
1$
1&)BB1( B1
$B& C& (
&C
& &D#
#1
F
1$ $
)
,$ $
&C1$
1&
#
1&)B1( B1
&#"
,$)$#
B&F$ *E
-*E
1$
,$ &CI+$
#
&
$))
D
#C
))
J( $
C&))&D
,
(& &F)$
BB
$
$
$
F$C& $1$ C ##$ 0B$#&C1$
$DB1( B1D$ $1$)
&
1 #
# &
,&C-*E
1$C&
)
$
B
&
&C1$#
B(
&
(
$F (
-* KLMNOPLQ5MLRSLTLQUSQV5QOSML6VPUNLOS5TPUWVXOPY5 VZ;:[;A@785Q=@A9=@;455
)2
,1$1#& B
)#,
CB
B$&C1$#(FJ$B% &%$
B $
C&
$#,
&
(
$ 1$\#)&B
))
!% &,
D
#B&
#
$ $
"
&
))
B&
#
$
&
&C1#& B
)
$,
1$
$CCB$&C#& B
$#$ 0
&
]
^#( 0$ $1&
&)&,D
#(#$
&#( 0$
##$##1$ $)
0$#,
CB
B$&C1$% &%$ Q@A_57`5a9Z9=:_5K@::b5c;8de;=f5Q=@A9=@;4551$\##& B $#$ 0
&
B$]G(
B%
) &
$)$1
%$ +" B)$+*gG++*^
(1& 2$#1$()(
)$
,$& ##&
]^& $B& $
1$
&
&
&C% &%$ $#
#)&B
))
!#&1$&(
B)1$ &(
B)
$#,
$)&B
))
!#
1#& B
# B#F1$% &B$
( $#&()
$
1$ &
B$1$
$#$ 0
&
B$
)#&$#
F)#1$#B $
1$% &B$##C& $0
)(
,
$#,
,% &%$ $#
#%&$
))&B
))
!# "
$),F)$% &%$
F$
&
$
$#,
$
#
)
!C#
#C$#1$ $h( $ $
##$C& 1F$)&Di " ")
! (##
#C
))&C1$C&))&D
, $h( $ $
#i #
)$
#E$
#]E^$
#&C
,$
& #
% &%$ &C$j
&
#,
CB
B$g * %&##$##$#1,1
#B&
$#1$B0
)($
$ F&
$#1$
#
B0$ B1
B$ #B#&C
B1$B(
)#)$&
B1$B(
)%$&
B1$B(
) %$ &
g + $
##(F#
)
$, C & #%$ &
&C#,
CB
B$g
E 1
#B&
($
1#& B0
)($&1$B& (
#(B11
#
$#,
&
#
)
!# $
#&
F)$
$B$##
&% & &$
C( 1$ 1$%( %&#$#&C 1#
B)$
&
&1$ $h( $ $
##$C& 1
,
%1"
F&0$
)
! (##
#C
)$
#&
$&C1$C&))&D
, $h( $ $
#i
klmnopqrstruvwlxvsykzs{|}~~kk~}{
}}}k
!"##$## $
$%& '()**+ %
,$
#)#$
&
-$
&
)$,#$ &.#& /
)
/$#0 * #
$1/$%&
)2& !3
#$
/-$/0
+ #
$1/$%&
)2& !-
2
#&2
$
&//(%$
3
%$ #&
&., $
%&
/$
2 #
$/)/&
$/$
&
& $
&(#$4$
-$%$ #&
5# $
$
4& #& -$-#& &.-$
&
& %( %&#$#&.-#%
,
%-
%$ #&
) $4$
##(/-
#3 -
$
-
,$
#&/
)
$
/&
-$)!$#-
))
&3$
$$ $
&3$ & $
&(#0 6 #
$1/$%&
)% &%$ -
2
#&2
$
&//(%$
3
%$ #&
&., $
)&/
)% &
$
/$0 #
/&
/% &%$ 0& 7 -$)
!
$#,
&
% &/$
( $#
$
& $1% $##)
, $$
&
3-$ &2
$ 8#9&.-$% &%$ :;<=>?;@ABCDE=FG?;=HICCJ
$, #-$
3)&.
% &%$ &/&
4$##,
./
/$K
&
& $$
,-$/ $
&.#,
./
/$
% &%$ (#-
4$
$,
$, #-$
(-$
/&.
% &%$ 5#%-#/
)
$
/)$
)
/
$
3-$ $$
&
&./-
/$ #/# -
$1#$
(
,-$% &%$ 5#%$ &
&.#,
./
/$
&%$ $#$),3)$.& )&/
))
!
$#,
&
(# $$
)$
#2&&.-$)&/
))
!
$#,
&
/ $
$
$
&(,- &.-$ -#& //-
/$ &
%%$
/$&3$ $/&,
L
3)$
#-#& /
) $#&( /$#
& /&
4$-$ $
#&
#.& -$ -#& /
)#,
./
/$ &--$
&
)$,#$ &.#& /
)
/$#
-$
).&
$,#$ &.#& /
)$#&( /$# $/&,
L$-$#$4$
#%$/#&.M(
)$#-
4 &(#/& 3
&
#
$.
$
$, & $
-#& /
$,
% &%$ #-&()
%&##$###$4$
)
(#(
)) &#
&.-$#$#$4$
#%$/# -(#
-$ $$
&
&.-$#%$/./
#%$/#&.
$, #%
&(
.&
% &%$ &/&
4$# #,
./
/$-$#$4$
M(
)$#-
$.
$
$,
$)&/
&
$#,
#$
,
$
)#
2& !
#-%
.$$)
,
##&/
&
-$#$4$
M(
)$#&
#%$/#&.-#& /
)
$,
$
$.
$
#.&))&2#N O&/
&
#-$%)
/$2-$ $-$-#& /% &%$ 2
#/&
# (/$
& -$%)
/$2-$ $ -$-#& /$4$
&//( $
O
$#,
#-$/& 3
&
&.$)$ $
#-
/ $
$-$.&
%)
#%
/$
# (/( $
#)$&.
% &%$ O
$
,#-$%-#/
)$
4 &
$
&.
-#& /% &%$ OP
$
)#
$-$%-#/
)$)$ $
#-
2$ $/& 3
$
&
$%&#$
(
,
%
/()
%$ &
&. $
%
/()
%
$
& /&
.,(
&
&.&
-#& /% &%$ OQ& !
#-%#-$%-#/
)$4
$
/$&.-$/
.#&.
%
/()
/()( $& %$&%)$
(
,
,4$
%$ &
-#& & % $-#& O$$)
,#
% &%$ 5#$1% $##&
&.-$
$#-$/& -#& /#$
#$&.
%
/()
%$ &
&. $
RSTUVWXYZ[Y\]^S_]Z`RaZbcdefgehiRRegijdkbilmnmidkmdkoodgRkg
!"##$## $
$%& '()**+ %
,$
-"##&.
&
#/$
$.)
!0$1$$
%&
/#& .$2$
& %$ #&
/#& .% &%$ 34567589:;<:=<>9?8:@9A56<?9B;9=9A5;A3< 5CCDEFGHEIJ<IK<AEHL<6GJMNGOP<Q?ERJEKEFGJFST<AOEHSOEGU<< #(
0 #$
&
.( $
$#$
./
V&
&
/$
0&2$
##$## $
&V/$/( ./&V/$ &&
/$%/$
/( ./0()
, )&.
$
& /$
V&
2$
%%$
#& $$/$
$.$##
&V$2$ )))#
!. $
WX++**YV&
$#,
&
/$% &%$ 1
#$2
)(
$
..&
,& /$#
(& . $
#V&))&1#Z 5U< 5<DGJMNGOP<N[\H<\GHE\KL<GDD<IK<H]S<KIDDI^EJR<OS_[EOSNSJH\<Q`>aA<bcdedefbfQ5TTg< hij kljmnjoljpqonljrsjtqounjvrswjtqounjxyjozq{jxujmnjoj|ux|qultjxyjq}luoxu~moutjnmzmymoqij /$/( ./&V/$ &&
/$%/$
%
#/./( ./0()
,1
#0()
*
#&2$ $
#&V
,$/$ $V& $
/$% &%$ #
#V$#/#. $ &
ij klj|xnnqnnqnjmzjoulmnlmjxujoqnlqlmj
opqjo~jqx~mqnjlqj~mnlmlm
qjouolqumnlmnj xyjojoumlqluopjnltpqjxujoumlqluopjlt|qjxujoumlqluopj|qumx~ij /$/( ./&V/$ &&
/$%/$
%
#/./( ./0()
,#
$.$))$
$
%)$&V X##&
$22
)
./$.( $/$
./( ./0()
,$ 0&
$#/$
#
.2$ ./
.$ #.#&V/$X##&
$22
)
&
.)(
, $
)$
&&V#
# &&/#(..& #/$
/
,
./$
#/
%$
1
&1
&& &%$
,#
.( 2)
$
/$
.& %&
&
&V
. $ $
))#
.!$
1
&1$ #.
%%$
1/
$.&
2$ $
)). W,&)
Y
& $#/$./( ./0()
,
)#&%&##$##$#/,/
#.
$#/$.2
)($
# (#$&V
$.&
2$#
$
,)
##/ &(,/&(#V$
$#
&
j/$ $V& $
/$% &%$
%%$
#&#
#V/#. $ &
ij kljuqlomnjnnlolmopjmlqzumltjyuxjmlnj|qumx~jxyjnmzmymoqijj /$$$ & &V/$/( ./&V/$ &&
/$%/$
%
#/./( ./0()
,/
#0$$
))
)$ $
#
.$#%$ &
&V#,
V.
.$W*Y/$0()
,
%%$
#
) &# $
.)
#
1/$
1
#
)).&
# (.$
.&
($#&$% $##/$
$V
2$
$#/$.
./$.(
)%
.%)$#/
V)($
.$
#& ,
)
$#,
/$ $V& $
%%$
#& $$ $ &
rij kljonjxlmq~jmnlxumj
opqjlxjlqjxmltjnjloljmlnj~qnmzolmxjonjojpo~ouj mnjuqonxopqjo~jqqnnoutjlxj|uxxlqjo~jyulqujlqj|u|xnqnjxyjlmnjoulmpqij /$/( ./&V/$ &&
/$%/$
0()
*
/
#/$, $
#
.&
&V0$
,/$ V #V&
)./( ./0()
,$ $.$
$2$ )))#/
#
)&
,
.//#&
/&)
#
% &
$
%)
.$
/$.#$#&/$$
$
$
(#
&
0$.
(#$&V#
#
.2$
.
./$.(
)#)$
!$
$#,
V$
( $#
##&.
$
1//$X##&
$22
)
&
$..)$#
#.% &%$ %$/$#(0$.% &%$ /
#
.&
($#&.&
2$
&
0)$/#& .2
)($&/$.& (
&2$
))j/$ $V& $
/$
¡¢£¡¤¥¡£¥¦ §¥¨©ª©¥ §© §«« £§£
!"##$## $
$%& '()**+ %
,$*
% &%$
%%$
#&#
#-.#/ $ &
0 123 453677898:539:39;<3=<>?8=<@<59A3A<93B:=9;3853C6=6D=6E;3F36G:H<I363J657@6=K3@?A93 A698ABL3693J<6A93:5<3:B39;<3B:JJ:M85D3=<>?8=<@<59A3N1OPQ3RSTUTUVRVN1WWX3 YZ0 [\0]^0_]^\`a0bc0\d`0ef\]bcf_0g`h]^\`i0bj0k]^\bi]l0m_fl`^Z0 .$#(no$/% &%$ # &)#$
&
.$
&
)$,#$ &-#& /
)
/$#.$ $-& $
.$% &%$
&$#
&#
#-.#/ $ &
pZ0 [\0]^0fc0`ql`r\]bcf_0sbit0uv0f0wf^\`i0fild]\`l\Z00 .$.( /.&-.$ &&
.$%.$
x
#
$#,
$
n&#"
,$)$#
/.$/'
$#'
&
$))
.$ $#
&
-&
&
&
/
$
&
$))
#.&()
n$/&
#
$ $
#$
/.$/
.# $
&
.$#
&
/)(
$
.$y##&-&/
)z
#$ " /.$/#.$ $-& $
.$% &%$
&$#
&
%%$
&#
#-.#/ $ &
{Z0 [\0]^0fc0`ql`r\]bcf_0sbit0\df\0sf^0bsc`a0fca0bll|r]`a0uv0f0r`i^bc0bj0hi`f\0]wrbi\fcl`}0 fca0sf^0a]i`l\_v0lbcc`l\`a0\b0f0wbw`c\b|^0`~`c\0]c0\d`0r`i^bc^0`ca`f~bi^0bi0\d`0 d]^\biv0bj0\d`0cf\]bcZ0bi0r|irb^`^0bj0\d]^0rfifhifrd}0r`i^bcf_0`~`c\^0^|ld0f^0u]i\d}0 a`f\d}0wfii]fh`}0^bl]f_0]c\`ifl\]bc}0fca0\d`0_]t`0^df__0cb\0u`0a``w`a0\b0u`0wbw`c\b|^Z0 .$ /.
) $#$
/.
$$x$
&
.$% &%$
&
/
$.
x
#&x
$
&//(%$
n
%$ #&
&-, $
%&
/$
&
.$% &%$ #
& /&
#
$ $
$/$%&
)x& !n
#$
/.$/
.$ $-& $
.#/ $ &
#
&
%%)/
n)$$
/$
.$% &%$
&$#
&#
#-.#/ $ &
Z0 [\0]^0fc0`ql`r\]bcf_0ribr`i\v0\df\0sf^0bsc`a0fca0bll|r]`a0uv0f0r`i^bc0bj0hi`f\0_blf_0 ribw]c`cl`Z0 $$x
,
/.
) $#$
/.
&
.$.#& &-.$% &%$ .$ $x
#
&
/
&
.
x
#&x
$
&//(%$
n
%$ #&
&-, $
)&/
)% &
$
/$
&
.$% &%$ #
&/&
#
$ $
$/$%&
)x& !n
#$
/.$/
.$ $-& $
.#/ $ &
#
&
%%)/
n)$$
/$
.$% &%$
&$#
&#
#-.# / $ &
&
#$($
)
.$% &%$
&$#
&#
#-.#/ $ &
Z0 [\0]^0fc0]lbc]l0ribr`i\vZ00 .$.( /.&-.$ &&
.$%.$
%
#./.( /.n()
,#
/&
/% &%$
#
$-
$
n.$
/$&/
$
% &
$
)
.$#&(.x$#/&
$ &-
z&
/
&()$
& .$
-&
$-& &$
) &#$
#
.$/.( /.#
.,.)#n)$
&
( $
)% &%$ .
#
$ /
n)
##&/
$
x.$$ )))#y
$
&
.
#n$$
x
$)%.&&,
%.$
#
/
$
n#$$
#$ % $#$
/$&
,$.&#
,x$nn
#$
%)
-& ##(/.
#)/!
&&,)$
,
$ $#
#
/)(
$
#%
&-
&(#x
)!
,
,&( #&-.$
$
.$ $-& $
.$% &%$
%%$
#&#
#-.#/ $ &
¡¢£¢ ¢ ¤¤
!"##$## $
$%& '()**+ %
,$+
-./ 012/34567489/62:;<54=;>5/?8>@26A82/;:/;5;=;4=26B/>8/2C?82::3D/4<8226/=>B/ED/=12/>F528G:H/ >I/=12/?8>?28=D./ J$)
!
$#,
&
% &K$
( $L
#$M% $##)
, $$
&NJ$&L
$ O#P&QJ$ % &%$ J(#
J$% &%$ #
#Q$# $ &
R
STUVWXTYZ[\]^V_`XTVabJ$J( KJ&QJ$ &&
J$%J$
%
#JN()
,
%%$
#& $$J$
$K$##
&Q$c$ )))#
$, K $
#
$Q
$
J$
K$J$$M$ & &QJ$ KJ( KJN()
, $
#J$$##$
)KJ
K$
$Q
,Q$
( $#&QJ$d##&
$cc
)#)$
# L$))
#
))#$c$
e(
)$#&QJ#& K
)
$, f)&K
&
$#,
#$
,
$
)#
L& !
#J%
Q$$)
,
##&K
&
J$ $K& N()
,&J$
& J&QJ$KJ( KJ
J$
$
KJ$
,
,$LJ#$K&
Q)&&
%
$
(
J$
& JL$#K&
$ &QJ$#$L$ $
)#& N()
g*h
$#,
$
J$d##&
$cc
)#)$&L$c$
J$J
c$N&JN$$
#(N#
))
)$ $
&c$ J$$
#
&)&
,$ $Q)$KJ$ & ,
)#)#KKJ
K$
$Q
,Q$
( $#J$&J$ % &c$ $
#&
J$#$
$Q & &(#
$J$KJ( KJi#
##&K
$
%$ &
&Q#,
QK
K$ jkZXZYV_Xlm_nT^T^`\o_ZVpX_Ub\c$ J#& K% &%$ #( e($
LJ#&L
$
#&L
#
,(#J
,KJ
K$ "% &%$ i#Q&
$
)
,
$ %&
$Q
,#c#(
) J#& KKJ
K$
#,
QK
K$#
% &%$ i#
,N)$Q$
( $#& $)$ $
#J
$ N&
##,
QK
K$Q&
##&K
&
LJ#%$KQKJ#& K
)$c$
#
%&
%$ #&
,$#
&
#
Kc$
KJ$K( $
#J&#$
,N)$$)$ $
#qJ$ $Q& $
J
#J&()
N$ $
$
% $#$ c$
J
K$ $Q$ #&
))J&#$c#(
)
#%$K#
%J#K
)Q$
( $#J
K& % #$J$
%%$
K$ &Q$c$ J#& K% &%$ "KK&
,&r4=;>543/s489/t28u;@2/v8;2I/wxB/y8@1;=2@=A843/z1484@=28{/ |625=;ID;5</=12/};:A43/y:?2@=:/>I/~;:=>8;@/vA;36;5<:/4:/45/y;6/=>/s82:28u;5</012;8/z1484@=28 KJ
K$
$Q
,Q$
( $#
K)(
$J$&c$
))#J
%$&Q
% &%$ ON()
,
# (K( $
$KP
#
$
)
K
Q#
#J%
$K&
c$
$
)#
$ & #%
K$#
Q$
( $#O
#
%%)K
N)$P
#L$))
#J$c
&(#
#%$K#&Q##$
$
$$
c &
$
OQ&
K&
Q,(
&
& $
&
P J$t2@82=48D/>I/=12/|5=28;>8:/t=456486:/I>8/=12/0824=725=/>I/~;:=>8;@ &%$ $#
$Q
$#J#& K KJ
K$ NJ$Q&
$
)
,&Q
$
)#
#(KJ
#
#&
L&&
#(KK&
%)
#$
$
K&
$
)
$Kq#%$KQKQ$
( $#
#(KJ
# &&Q#
%& KJ$#
L
&L#
L
&L$)$ $
#
&)
,#
#
K
#$#
KJ
$#
c$L
#
,
,$#
)
#K
%$
J
#K
%$$)$ $
#
$Kq
# L$))
##%
) $)
&
#J%#N$L$$
N()
,#
# (K( $#
Q$
( $#q && K&
Q,(
&
#q
KJ
K# (K(
)
$KJ
K
)##$ #
$
Q
,J&#$Q$
( $#& $)$ $
#J
,c$
J#& K% &%$ c#(
)KJ
K$
LJKJ#J&()
N$
!$
&
KK&(
% $#$ c$
& J$
M ( $M$
%&##N)$# %&
&
$ Q& J$% &%$ &
#J#& K
) #,
QK
K$ J$KJ
K$
$Q
,Q$
( $#
##&K
$
LJJ$/J( KJ&QJ$ &&
J$%J$
$J&#$ Q$
( $#&
J$$M$ & &QJ$KJ( KJN()
,J
$Q)$K
$Q
$#d##&
$cc
)
!"##$## $
$%& '()**+ %
,$-
./$.(
)#)$
$..)$#
#.
)% &%$ %$0/
.$
$1
,1$
( $#
.)(
$
)) %
$2$ & $)$3
&
#
1&
##
,
#.
)$
% &%& &
#
# (.( $
./$.(
) &
$
&
$
)#
$
1$
(./1$
( $#
.)(
$
4(
$
&) $
&/$ 1&))&5
,6 /( ./()
,2$ & 78
$#& 9
&(4)$/$,/:3&)( $ 78$.
,()
4()
,%)
78&.
&
##
,
#.
)$
% &%& &
#
#
,&1/$#
.(
./( ./4()
,&
#$ 78
$)$3
&
#
$1
$
##&(/
5$#
$
#
& /$)$3
&
# 78$
)$
,
4)$ &&15/&3$ /
,
,$
3$#
$2%&#$
5&&
%( )
# 78
&&/#(..&#/$
/
, 78 ,
)9$2#
,:#$4
.!#1 & %(4).#
$5
)!#
# $$#
)&
,#&(/91 &
:
$
#9#
$:$)$3
&
# 78&
).&
. $$#
#;#$%#
)
,
1 &
9#&(/:$)$3
&
$))&5$ # 78"
./$
13$#&
/ $$)$3$)
. $ $
))#$%%$
5
&5$ #
#&(/$
&1 ./( ./4()
, 78
&&/#(..&#/$
/
,5/% &
&(
.$
.&
.$
. $ $
))$3$)# 78
,
,$
#(..&4( $##$# 78)
&(
/$
$
&%$
,# 78<$
)).9,&)
:
& $#
&(/91 &
:)$3
&
78 &=$.
,/ $$4
.
$5/ $
)$
/&&
78/ $$5&&
$
&(4)$
&& # 78 %
9#$ . .()
$.&
3$5
))#( 1
.$#:&3$ /$/ $$$
.$
&& # 78
$$%) $.$##$
$
&& ##$
&.& $#%&
,
./$
#/
%$
&%$
,# 78
,$ %
$#
$
,)
##5
&55/.( 3)
$
78
4)$$
.3$
&%$
,5/.( 3)
$
#;>$#9#
$:)$3
&
# 78,/4( $##$
4 #$
./$)$3
&
78
,
,$
#(..&%)
#$ #
(%%$ )$3$) 78)&
,
$
&(
/$
$
5
&5&%$
,# 78&(
/$
$
5
&5&%$
,##$
%
#
(%%$ )$3$) 78
$.&
3$#
$
,)
##
?@ABCDEFGHFIJK@LJGM?NGOPQRSTRUV??RTVWQXOVYZ[ZVQXZQX\\QT?XT
!"##$## $
$%& '()**+ %
,$
& -)$.
&
/0,-.&)( $ &(
#-
%$
%#$1- ()-% $
)$ &&2 /0&(
-$
$
1
&1&%$
,# /0
3)$$
4.$
&%$
,1-4( .)
$
/0)&& &4$)
,25$
1
&1#1-
$4&
.$#
$
,)
## 67869:;<78= "#
$#()&23
4!, &(
$#$
4-
#$
#%$4&
$.
)(
&
(
$ )&4
)$),3)4 $
-#& 4
)
$, 4&
#
$
&
#
-$-( 4-&2-$ &&
-$%-$
4-( 4-3()
,#
#2$# -$&2$.$ )))#>)
!4 $
##%()
$
-$
4$?@
$4&
+ +**A
%%$
#& $$-$ $B( $
$#&2#(3#$4&
"? $
"C"DA
#1$))
# $
E
FGHIJKLMNOMPQRGSQNTFUNVWXYZ[Y\]FFY[]^X_V]`aba]X_aX_ccX[F_[
!"##$## $
$%& '()**+ %
,$-
./.0/12345678 "))$
9:
;<=>?@AB=>C@A=DEF>GHBI=>J@>K@LLMN@@I$O& !P &
O
&&!#
QR
* "
9$# 9&
$
$#$
#(# $9&
#S
$
: $9&
#ST : $9&
#
U&$ $,#
&
$9&
#
)
V $,#
&
$9&
#
$O#%
%$ #
9
$9& )#
,#W&
)
$
T
#$#X
&U&
:"99$##$
'(
$*Y+
**+ "
$ #&
&T$
Z=A=DLM>KBLLF[>;<=>\BDFJ>]^^>_=`DF$O& !Paa&)
*b
#$
$
Z=A=DLM>KBLLF[>c@DJD`BJ>@d>`>\`eL=I>fBJM&#"
,$)$#P
&(,)
#g$#
(T)#:$ #
QY $
$
9
$ 9$
$
KBFJ@DM>@d>Z=A=DLM>KBLLF$U$ )))#P"
O#&
Q+b &V$U$ )))#& (
$U$)&% $
$%
$
T()
,%$ :#&
(
9%
) 9&
$
&:$ $)$U
V)$#
U#
$
$U$U$Z=A=DLM>KBLLF[>hi>jLLHFJD`J=I>KBFJ@DM& :
,$
)V&
Pg
#&
(T)9
&
#
9
QRR ))$
T$ ,$
"))
;<=>k`L=iJBi@>?MFJBlH=[>;<=>m=`J<>`iI>hdJ=DLBd=>@d>J<=>nBL=iJ>\BLo>jI@L & : &)
Pp9
)
q& %
9
(T)#:$ #
* $T:
U
&T$ g
$ hDr<BJ=rJHD=>Bi>C@F>his=L=F
)
!$
:P
$ $,
$
:&&!#
QR $T:
U
&T$ g
$ hi>hDr<BJ=rJHD`L>GHBI=e@@t>J@>C@F>his=L=F
)
!$
:P TT#
:
(T)#:$ #
*+
U$
&
)
h>nJ`D>jF>Z@Di[>;<=>?`tBis>@d>J<=>]uvw>?@AB=>`iI>jJF>]uxy>z=FJ@D`JB@i$O & !P{ &%V
** '&:
#&
$(
$#$
9:"##&9
$#Z=A=DLM>KBLLF>KBFJ@DBr>z=F@HDr=F>nHDA=M>]uxv|]ux}>\Bi`L> z=~@DJ>BirLHIBis><BFJ@DBr>r@iJ=J $%
$
V& :$&V$U$ )))#
QR- KBFJ@DBr>z=F@HDr=F>nHDA=M>]uxv|]ux}> Z=A=DLM>KBLLF>f<HDr<=F;<=o`JBr>GD@H~Bis>KBFJ@DBr>z=F@HDr=F>jiA=iJ@DM>d@Do>NBJ<> f@iJBiH`JB@i>n<==JF $%
$
V& :$&V$U$ )))#
9&T$ QR- '&
$#q
&!$#
&V$U$ )))##& 9$#&( 9$#
( U$$%&
( U$" $
P & $ 9
)
&%$ $#
$%
$
V& :$&V$U$ )))#
'(
$*-
$U"% ) *Y { !$
&)
f`LBd@DiB`EF>hDr<BJ=rJHD`L>\D@iJB=D
T
)V&
P
$ $,
$
:
9
QY+
¡¢£¢ ¢ ¤¤
!"##$## $
$%& '()**+ %
,$-
&#"
,$)$#&(
."##$##&
/&
&
01%233
%#
##$##& )
4&(
,&56 &#"
,$)$#
(7)47
)
$1#& 4
)
,$
7 #$
415$#
/)$# &"(1& 8"
5$ #$ $
#9:;<=>?@ABA<=CDA?E?@=CFGHA<<
$7 (
*I
I*J
%J &"(1& 8"
5$ #$ $
2&
# &1$ # $
$
)()
,&
4& #9KLA=KEME?@<
&# "
,$)$#
$4$ 7$ I
I*J
%+N &"(1& 8"
5$ #$ $
2O$))
#&
$
(44&
1$
&
)O$))
#&
$&9KLA=KEME?@<
&# "
,$)$#
$4$ 7$ I
I*J
%+* &"(1& 8&
&/
1$!&
$ "P&&
9QBBR<SHTSAM=UTEBV=WAX<
&#"
,$)$#
$%$ 7$ J
I*Y
%
* &"(1& 8
$
P
$
19Z;BBVX;;M=[AG;HSAH
"(,(#
I
5&)+
%J &"(1& 8
1&)4P&&
4( $"4& \# ()
9KLA=KEME?@<
&#"
,$)$#
"% )
I*
% N &"(1& 81( 41&/(
&/
& &]#9KLA=KEME?@<
&#"
,$)$#
4&7$ +
I*J
%-
I &"(1& 81( 41&/1$ &&
1$%1$
9^ADAHBV=ZEBB<=_ESE`A?
'()J
I*- &"(1& 81( 41&/1$ &&
1$%1$
$5$ )))#9KLA=KEME?@<
&#"
,$)$#
$4$ 7$ I
I*J
%++ &"(1& 81( 41&/1$ &&
1$%1$
$
4
&
9KLA=KEME?@<
&#"
,$)$#
$7 (
Y
I*
% &"(1& 81( 41
//
$4& $#9KLA=KEME?@<
&#"
,$)$#
$7 (
N
I*J
%* &"(1& 81( 41
$ 54$#2 &&
1$%1$
9Z;BBVX;;M=UTEBV=_ESE`A?
4&7$ *
I*J
% &"(1& 81( 41
&
$&7$
9:;<=>?@ABA<=UTEBV=KEaA<
$%$ 7$ *-
I*J%* &"(1& 8P##
$
!$ b$
#&
&&
9:;<=>?@ABA<=KEaA<
$%$ 7$ *J
I+J
%
%Y &"(1& 8
1$ P())
#$
#
), #9:;<=>?@ABA<=CDA?E?@=CFGHA<<
"% )I
I*
% &"(1& 8
1$ P())
#&"
$]&#P
##9Z;BBVX;;M=UTEBV=_ESE`A?
%I &"(1& 8
)&
&
&&,
9:;<=>?@ABA<=KEaA<
P
I
I+
%
%* &"(1& 8
)$#/& ''
&
$))
" $& & &]9:;<=>?@ABA<=KEaA<
4&7$ *N
I*J &"(1& 8 &&
1$%1$
#19KLA=KEME?@<
&#"
,$)$#
'
(
+
I*
%Y
cdefghijkljmnodpnkqcrkstuvwxvyzccvxz{u|sz}~~zu|~u|uxc|x
!"##$## $
$%& '()**+ %
,$-
&"(.& /0
##&
1&
.&)2) ()
&(
$ 3456789:;<;67=>?<@7A?B;6
$2$ C$ *
D*E
%
% &"(.& /0
02"F&$2& $#
$3456789:;<;67A?B;6
'(
$*G
D*D
%
%* &"(.& /02
. &.$ #
$F$ )))#3AH;7A?I?9:6
&#"
,$)$#
"% )-
D*E
%- D &"(.& /0##&
&%$
$F$ )))#&
3J<<K6LM>L;I7=>?<@7N;O6
&#"
,$)$#
0 2. +
D*P
% &"(.& /0&F$.
%)
#$F$ )))#
#.3456789:;<;67QR;9?9:7QSTM;66
$2$ C$ *
D*+ &"(.& /
#.&1.$ &&
.$%.$
3AH;7A?I?9:6
&#"
,$)$#
'
(
-
D*E
%G &"(.& /
)
0 $1& ,"%
$
3456789:;<;67A?B;6
$C (
E
D*+
% &"(.& /
)
#()$
$
2
&
1& .( 2.3456789:;<;67=>?<@7A?B;6
$2$ C$ **
D*E
%
%G &"(.& /
)
$ #$
&
)$
&37456789:;<;67A?B;6
$%$ C$
D*P
%
%G &"(.& /
()%
)
1&
&,
#3AH;7456789:;<;67U;V5MI
0 2.+
D*P
%*" &"(.& /$#%$2
&
)$
&&))W&&
3XH?LL?;M7N;O6
"(,(#*+
D*G
%+ &"(.& /
,.##$"#Y(
Z#( $
3J<<K6LM>L;I7=>?<@7N;O6
&#"
,$)$#
$%$ C$ -
D*P
%+ )F$
0
/
.)
. &%#Y
&))Z $$
[$ $##W
$
.& &(,.C $
#3456789:;<;67 A?B;6
$%$ C$
DD
%"-
)!&F2
0 !XKM<?L\;M75]7^?9V?99>L?_7AH;7N>B;7AH>L7`;>967`K6?V7L57`?<<?596. )$#&
&(.
&)
a#&
$##
*
$ F2$#/#& 2$#&( 2$#
( F$
a#& 2$#&( 2$#
( F$%
$
a " $
E0()
)$#
$
2$
( F$3
$%
$
1& .$&1$F$ )))#
'(
$*E
&)!Z#
$2& $#
&1$F$ )))#
&b($##& 2
)$W#%
%$ #a456789:;<;67A?B;6c--D--d $
F))
)e5<<@O55I_789I7LH;7f;6L75]7456789:;<;6
!)
& %
##" $ 2
(
$#
DDE
C&
$
#(
2$0
%#
$F$ )))#D**
DcD*Pd
D
$
$#
$%
$
&1.$
$ & N>L?59><7U;:?6L;M7fK<<;L?97ghi7je5O7L578TT<@7LH;7 N>L?59><7U;:?6L;M7^M?L;M?>7]5M7QR><K>L?59ikl #.
,&
a
&
)
!
$ F2$
$
,$
2$#&( 2$#
F#&
DDG
mnopqrstuvtwxynzxu{m|u}~mm
}m
!"##$## $
$%& '()**+ %
,$-
$
$#
$%
$
&./$
$ & 01234516789:3;29<7=>6692357?@A7BC>3D96359;7E4<7 F4GH69235:701234516789:3;29<7I4<G;JKL #/
,&
M
&
)
!
$ NO$
$
,$
O$#&( O$#
N#&
-PQ 89:3;29<7=>6692357RSA7BC>3D96359;7E4<7T4U167 V><W9X;Y77Z7=1;3;7E4<7[<9;9<W123457[615535:JKL #/
,&
M
&
)
!
$ NO$
$
,$
O$#&( O$#
N#&
-P 89:3;29<7=>6692357\]J7B^4_7247`W16>129715D7 a4U>G95278><167^3;24<3U7T15D;U1H9;JKL #/
,&
M
&
)
!
$ NO$
$
,$
O$#&( O$#
N#&
-P-
$
$#
$%
$
&./$
$ & [<9;9<W123457=<39E7?bJ7BZ<Uc329U2><167Fc1<1U29<7d7 eD9523EX35:72c97f3;>167Z;H9U2;74E7^3;24<3U7=>36D35:;71;7157Z3D7247[<9;9<W35:7gc93<7 Fc1<1U29<JK7L #/
,&
M
&
)
!
$ NO$
$
,$
O$#&( O$#
N#&
-P* $N L
!$
h
OeG1:9;74E7ZG9<3U1Y7`1<6X7=9W9<6X7^366;/
)$#&
&(/
&)
M" O
(i)#/
,
* L
!$
h
OeG1:9;74E7ZG9<3U1Y7=9W9<6X7^366;7?j\]kR]]l/
)$#&
&(/
&)
M " O
(i)#/
,
*Q
mnopqrstuvtwxynzxu{m|u}~mm
}m
!"#!$%!#%& '
%()*)% ') '++ #'#
!"##$## $
$%& '()**+ %
,$*
-../01234 &5
&
6 %
5$)6
%
7&
$
#(
5$6
%# %8$ $
)6
$
)
8&&,
%8#98#& 5
):5( $
;
4 4
<=>?@ABCDECFGH=IGDJ<KDLMNOPQORS<<OQSTNULSVWXWSNUWNUYYNQ<UQ
!"#!$%!#%& '
%()*)% ') '++ #'#
!
!"
#!$%&%!
#%
#''
#
!"#$%"&
'(
)*++,**-
+./0
123*(4
56789:;<=><?@A6B@=C5D=EFGHIJHKL55HJLMGNELOPQPLGNPGNRRGJ5NJ
!
"#$%&!'(%&$ )&$*+ !*$,-./0 1
2&#,1#3& !$
$4&5$!$%! 6 ,7/89, 87:7
;<=>?@ABCDBEFG<HFCI;JCKLMNOPNQR;;NPRSMTKRUVWVRMTVMTXXMP;TP
!"#!
$%
&'()*+),-)+-.(/&-0121-(/1(/33(+/+
!" #$%&$!'(!)*+,-.,/0,.01+2)034540+24+266+.2.
!"#$%&'&!"()** *+
,-
./
01234567894:2;6<62;62=
,-
>?@ABCDEFGEHIJ?KIFL>MFNOPQRSQTU>>QSUVPWNUXYZYUPWYPW[[PS>WS
!"
# $
% &
'
()
# *#
+
,
-./01234564789.:85;-<5=>?@AB@CD--@BDE?F=DGHIHD?FH?FJJ?B-FB
!
"
#
$%
&
'
()*+,-./01/234)5306(7089:;<=;>?((;=?@:A8?BCDC?:AC:AEE:=(A=
!"
#$
%!
&#
'#!( !")#*!$
!#)
!$
%!
&#
!
#
!'!#!$)#*!$"
+
!
#
!"!& #,
*!$ +
!
'!#!$)#*!$
-./01234564789.:85;-<5=>?@AB@CD--@BDE?F=DGHIHD?FH?FJJ?B-FB
!
"#
$
%&#'
( )
*)
+%#( !
&
)
)
#
%
&
)
%" %"' ##&
)
#
&#
,
)%
(
-./01234564789.:85;-<5=>?@AB@CD--@BDE?F=DGHIHD?FH?FJJ?B-FB
!"
#
$
#
#
%
&%
#
#
!
%%
#
'
()*+"!"%%
%!
'
()*+!#
,
%!"-
%
#
'
()*+!#
,
!"-
%
#
./01234567589:/;96<.=6>[email protected]@G>EHIJIE@GI@[email protected]
! " #$ $ "
%&'()*+,-.,/01&20-3%4-56789:8;<%%8:<=7>5<?@A@<7>@7>BB7:%>:
!!
"
#$%&%
#%
#''
!# ()*)+,() (+-./)#0)12)3!/+(24 &
5 & 678!829*0*8:!,24*)2;(3*8 &5& 5
##<=== (+8/ !/+0)>*4,"? (24*)+8, @8242*)8 #8)272/*)>*4,
2)2*,& 2A/3 %+)6**- ()*024*- B20CDEB#5&$&&F>*/272/B20DE(G#***F " 6=HI78!82 8JK2,L#%?&
& 1/3M-8J32,=84 >%8,,
?$=
" =
$?=
N
OPQR ()*)+,@8242* ?S
S
&
&
?>< K82A/3 1/3M-8J32,=84 9/*)2!/+(24 TRUVW TRX P W
!*2<=(1 ,1M-8J32,=84 (/+82)J90*2L%//+)%+)3)2/*)2 D6F (24*)+8%)2!8*1!2/ E,24>%8,,&= $=
"
=
()?S
S
&
">< Y21?S
S
&
>< (24?S
S
&
?
?"
>< U
N
OOTRXZW
WX[ 6)@7782*!/+(24 HJ*;32/3 8432/3M-8J32,=84 %,,2,)*)#2)J<**48 (/+82)J90*2L%//+)%+)3)2/*)2 D6F (24*)+8%)2>85,/)()J E,24>%8,, ?$=
" =
$?=
()?S
S
&
?
?"$>< H,)?S
S
&
$
?&
%< Y21?S
S
&
$ &&$%< (24?S
S
&
$ &
"%< U
N
OOTRXZW
WX[ 6)@7782*!/+(24 #2J@1, /1,M-8J32,=84 >2/JG<**40)%*J,) #2)J78JK2, (/+82)J90*2L%//+)%+)3)2/*)2 D6F ()?S S
&
$ &
%< U
N
OOTRXZW
WX[ 6)@7782*!/+(24 6*/JK+)5#77J 3+)/77JM-8J32,=84 (/+82)J90*2L%//+)%+)3)2/*)2 D6F U
N
OOTRXZW
WX[ 6)@7782*!/+(24 \+2*%=; .4M-8J32,=84 (/+82)J90*2L%//+)%+)3)2/*)2 D6F U
N
OOTRXZW
WX[ 6)@7782*!/+(24
!"
# $%
&
'
()
*%%"+&&+& %& "+ ,-"+. /0 102013
3
4
0/1
5 -"&677
8"%$ #+ 9:
1
3 14/;
< 4/;
9 3
;4/;
= >34/;
=
?1=1;
8"
+@"+ "+
!"
# $%
&
'
()
*%%"+&&+& %& "+ ,-"+. /0 102013
3
4
0/1
5 -"&677
8"%$ #+
++A
B"+ &
B"+
!"
# $%
&
'
()
*%%"+&&+& %& "+ ,-"+. /0 102013
3
4
0/1
5 -"&677
8"%$ #+ C
D1
;
/1
;
)+
"E$+& F)+%
E& GFHIFHJHKK(LH(MNO@ :
;
City Council Report
Landmark Designation – Church of the Good Shepard
October 3, 2023
ATTACHMENT 2
July 12, 2023
Cultural Heritage Commission Staff Report
City of Beverly Hills
Planning Division
455 N. Rexford Drive Beverly Hills, CA 90210
TEL. (310) 285-1141 FAX. (310) 858-5966
Cultural Heritage Commission
Report
Attachment(s):
1.Resolution, including City Landmark Assessment Report Report Author and Contact Information:
Minjee Hahm
Associate Planner
(310) 285-1136
[email protected]
Meeting Date: July 12, 2023
Subject: 501-505 North Bedford Drive – Church of the Good Shepherd Landmark Nomination
Landmark Nomination of the “Church of the Good Shepherd” at 501- 505 North Bedford Drive as a Landmark for inclusion onto the Beverly Hills Register of Historic Properties. Pursuant to the provisions set forth in the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), the Cultural Heritage Commission will also consider adoption of a Categorical Exemption for this project.
Property Owner/
Project Applicant: Church of the Good Shepherd
Recommendation: Adopt a resolution recommending that the City Council designate the “Church of the Good Shepherd” as a Landmark and place it onto the Beverly Hills Register of Historic Properties.
REPORT SUMMARY
The “Church of the Good Shepherd” has been assessed for eligibility as a Local Landmark under Beverly Hills Municipal Code (BHMC) Title 10, Chapter 3, Article 32 (Historic Preservation Ordinance). A Landmark Assessment Report prepared by Jan Ostashay of Ostashay and Associates Consulting (Exhibit A of Attachment 1) provides background information and an historic assessment of the property, and concludes that the property appears to be eligible as a local landmark. City staff peer-reviewed the submitted report, conducted a site visit of the property, and drafted findings in support of the property’s landmark eligibility under BHMC Section 10-3-3212 (Landmark Designation Criteria). The resolution in Attachment 1 recommends that the City Council designate the property as a Landmark and place it on the Beverly Hills Register of Historic Properties.
BACKGROUND
On July 12, 2023, the Cultural Heritage Commission considered the proposal to initiate landmark proceedings on the property and conducted a Preliminary Hearing (pursuant to the requirements in BHMC §10-3-3215), and found that the property appeared to be eligible as a landmark under the criteria in BHMC §10-3-3212. The Director’s Preliminary Evaluation was reviewed and a Preliminary Hearing was also conducted by the Commission on July 12, 2023.
Ostashay & Associates Consulting (OAC) has subsequently completed a City Landmark Assessment Report on the subject property and concludes that the property qualifies for local listing.
Cultural Heritage Commission Report
501-505 Bedford Drive
Landmark Nomination
July 12, 2023
DISCUSSION
Located on the northwest corner of Santa Monica Boulevard and Bedford Drive, the subject property at 501-505 North Bedford Drive was designed in 1924 by architect James Donnellan.
The stucco-covered concrete church building is commonly known as the “Church of the Good Shepherd” and was identified as a potential contributor to the potential historic district defined as the “Beverly Hills Churches-Thematic Grouping” in the City’s 1985-1986 historic survey and the 2004 historic survey. The property is individually eligible for listing in the National Register and California Register at the local level of significance.
Designed in the Mission-revival architectural style, the church rises to a height of five stories in three increments and has two golden-domed bell towers with open arches. The twin towers frame the central massing with three large doors at the ground floor set within deeply recessed arched openings that provide entry to the church. The side elevations of the edifice include buttressed bays with inset custom decorative stained-glass windows at the ground floor and within the upper attic story. The gabled shed roofs of the main church structure feature terracotta barrel tiles. A major renovation in 1959 removed the small spires on the twin towers, as well as the decorative plaster ornamentation which surrounded the central tripartite stainedglass window above the entry doors; however, the colorful decorative painted and figurative glass windows which give distinction to the inside of the structure still remain. Its associated buildings, such as the rectory and the two-story convent building, are also designed in the Mission style to complement and harmonize with the church, although these structures have lost integrity or are from a later period of significance.
Based on the City Landmark Assessment Report and other evidence, the subject property appears to satisfy the following Landmark Criteria (pursuant to BHMC §10-3-3212) in support of its landmark nomination: A.1 (age), A.2 (artistic value and architectural style), A.3 (integrity), A.4 (historic value), B.5 (iconic property), and B.6 (voluntary designation).
Pursuant to Preservation Brief 17 from the National Park Service, identifying those visual and tangible aspects of the historic building that help to convey an understanding about the significance of the resource is essential in the defining the character-defining features as they relate to the preservation of an historic site. These prominent features, such as types of construction materials, construction methods, the delineation of spaces, architectural styling, important landscape features, etc. are key features that give a building its visual character and without these elements, the essential aspects of its historic nature may be irreparably damaged.
Below is a summary of the character-defining features for the subject property.
The character-defining features associated with the Church of the Good Shepherd are those features on the exterior of the central church building that reflect and define its Mission-revival architectural style and ecclesiastical property type. Character-defining features include all primary exterior elevations, form, massing, scale, proportions, structure, architectural ornamentation, and materials identified. Such features include, but are not limited to the following:
Cultural Heritage Commission Report
501-505 Bedford Drive
Landmark Nomination
July 12, 2023
Church Building Exterior
• One-story (double height) volume
• Rectangular building plan
• Location, massing, scale, proportions, and siting of the sanctuary church building on site • Primary elevations defined as south, west, east, and north elevations • Red tiled gable roof with overhanging eaves and exposed wood purlins • Smooth stucco sheathing
• Original (existing) setbacks from public sidewalks and streets along south (front) and east elevations
• Formal concrete stairs/steps, and landing at front (south) elevation Bell Towers
• Attached five-story, three level incrementally stepped twin towers at south end of church building
• Smooth stucco sheathing with pronounced cornice trim at incremental levels • Engaged stucco buttresses
• Flat and round-headed openings
• Metallic (gold) domes
South (front) Elevation
• Projecting three-bay arcade with red tiled hood
• Three wooden double doors
• Tympana (semi-circular decorative wall surfaces) over the three entrance doors • Deeply recessed entry doors set into corresponding arched shaped openings • Large tripartite stained-glass window with curvilinear trim • Gable end attic vent opening with curvilinear trim
East/West (side) Elevations
• Eight buttressed bays (each elevation)
• Engaged stucco pilasters at upper level
• Elongated round-headed window openings
• Round-headed window openings set in pairs at upper level • Decorative stained glass
North Elevation
• High volume round shaped apse with multi-hip red-tile roof • Round-headed window openings
• Gable end attic vent opening with curvilinear trim
• Floor to ceiling fixed windows with decorative stained glass Cultural Heritage Commission Report
501-505 Bedford Drive
Landmark Nomination
July 12, 2023
ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT
Designation of the “Church of the Good Shepherd” in Beverly Hills as a local historic landmark was assessed in accordance with the authority and criteria contained in the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), the State CEQA Guidelines, and the environmental regulations of the City. It has been determined that designation of the subject property would not have a significant environmental impact and is exempt from CEQA pursuant to Sections 15061(b)(3), 15308, and 15331 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations. It can be seen with certainty that there is no possibility that the designation of the subject property may have a significant effect on the environment, as no specific development is authorized by this resolution, and any future development proposed pursuant to this resolution will require separate environmental analysis when the details of those proposals are known. Further, designating the residence is an action of the City to protect and preserve a historic resource.
PUBLIC OUTREACH AND NOTIFICATION
Notice that the Cultural Heritage Commission would conduct a Preliminary Hearing to consider the Preliminary Evaluation was provided to the property owner and the owner has also formally waived the deadlines, as required in the Municipal Code (BHMC §10-3-3215A.4).
Type of Notice Required Period Actual Period Required
Date
Actual
Date
Newspaper Notice n/a n/a n/a n/a
Mailed Notice
(Property Owner Only*)
15 Days 7 days *Time
periods
waived
7/5/23
Property Posting n/a n/a n/a n/a
Agenda Posting 24 Hours 7 Days 7/11/23 7/5/23
Website (Agenda) 24 Hours 7 Days 7/11/23 7/5/23
GENERAL PLAN CONSISTENCY
Designation of the subject property as a local historic landmark is consistent with the objectives, principles, and standards of the General Plan. General Plan Policy “HP 1.3 – Promote National, State, and Local Designation of Historic Resources” encourages the establishment of programs encouraging the nomination of landmarks.
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends that the Cultural Heritage Commission adopt the attached resolution approving the landmark nomination for the “Church of the Good Shepherd” in Beverly Hills and forward the recommendation to the City Council for approval.
NEXT STEPS
Should the Cultural Heritage Commission act to recommend landmark designation of the property, staff will forward the Commission’s recommendation to the City Council to designate the subject property as a local landmark and to place it on the Beverly Hills Register of Historic Properties.
City Council Report
Landmark Designation – Church of the Good Shepard
October 3, 2023
ATTACHMENT 3
Cultural Heritage Commission Resolution
No. CHC 115
1 RESOLUTION NO. CHC 115
A RESOLUTION OF THE CULTURAL HERITAGE
COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF BEVERLY HILLS
NOMINATING THE CHURCH OF THE GOOD
SHEPHERD AT 501-505 NORTH BEDFORD DRIVE,
BEVERLY HILLS, FOR INCLUSION ON THE CITY OF
BEVERLY HILLS REGISTER OF HISTORIC
PROPERTIES
Section 1. Article 32 of Chapter 3 of Title 10 of the Beverly Hills Municipal Code authorizes the City Council to designate local landmarks and historic districts and to place those properties and geographical areas on the City of Beverly Hills Register of Historic Properties.
Section 2. On July 12, 2023, the Cultural Heritage Commission considered landmark initiation for the subject property and voted unanimously to initiate landmark proceedings. On July 12, 2023, the Director of Community Development finalized a Preliminary Evaluation pursuant to Section 10-3-3215A.3 (Preliminary Evaluation) of the Beverly Hills Municipal Code, finding that the property may be eligible for designation as a landmark based on available evidence at the time.
Section 3. On July 12, 2023, the Cultural Heritage Commission conducted a preliminary hearing regarding the property at 501-505 North Bedford Drive in Beverly Hills, pursuant to Section 10-3-3215A.5. (Landmark or Historic District Designation Proceedings; Preliminary Hearing) of the Beverly Hills Municipal Code, and concluded that the Church of the Good Shepherd warranted formal consideration by the Commission for inclusion on the City of Beverly 2 Hills Register of Historic Properties. Based on the Preliminary Evaluation issued by the Director and other evidence, the Commission found that sufficient evidence existed to conclude that the subject property merits formal consideration for landmark designation.
Section 4. BACKGROUND. Located on the northwest corner of Santa Monica Boulevard and Bedford Drive, the subject property at 501-505 North Bedford Drive was designed in 1924 by architect James Donnellan. The stucco-covered concrete church building is commonly - 1985-1986 Historic Survey and the 2004 Historic Survey. The property is individually eligible for listing in the National Register and California Register at the local level of significance.
Designed in the Mission-revival architectural style, the church rises to a height of five stories in three increments and has two golden-domed bell towers with open arches. The twin towers frame the central gabled massing with three large doors at the ground floor within deeply recessed arched openings that provide entry to the church. The side elevations include buttressed bays with inset stained glass-stained windows at the ground floor with decorative glass windows on the upper attic story in pairs and separated by engaged pilasters. The central gable roof and shed roof elements for the side-aisles of the church feature terracotta barrel tiles. A major renovation in 1959 removed the small spires on the twin towers, as well as the decorative plaster ornamentation around in the central tripartite stained-glass window above the entry doors; however, the custom painted and figurative stained-glass windows which give distinction to the inside of the structure still remain. Its associated buildings, such as the rectory and the two-story convent building, are also designed in the Mission style to complement and harmonize with the 3 church, although they do not rise to the level of significance for potential designation due to major modifications or a later period of significance.
Section 5. FINDINGS AND DESCRIPTION OF PARTICULAR ATTRIBUTES JUSTIFYING LANDMARK DESIGNATION. The Cultural Heritage Commission finds, pursuant to the City of Beverly Hills Historic Preservation Ordinance, that the building satisfies the necessary requirements for designation as a local landmark based on the following:
The Church of the Good Shepherd is eligible under significance criterion A.1. It is at least forty-five (45) years of age, or is a property of extraordinary significance. The Church of the Good Shepherd parish church building was built in 1924 and is over 45 years of age.
Therefore, the property satisfies this criterion.
The Church of the Good Shepherd is eligible under significance criterion A.2. It possesses high artistic or aesthetic value, and embodies the distinctive characteristics of an architectural style or architectural type, or architectural period. The property is a clear example of the Mission-revival architectural style and was identified as Churches- -1986 Historic Survey. It possesses high
artistic and aesthetic value. Therefore, the property meets this criterion.
The Church of the Good Shepherd is eligible under significance criterion A.3. It retains substantial integrity from its period of significance. The period of significance for this property would likely be 1924, the date of the original construction of the building. It appears that the main church structure at 501-505 North Bedford Drive substantially retains its original, exterior appearance and all character-contributing features are intact. Therefore, the property satisfies this criterion.
The Church of the Good Shepherd is eligible under significance criterion A.4. It has 4 continued historic value to the community such that its designation as a landmark is reasonable and necessary to promote and further the purposes of this article. The Church of the Good Shepherd was the first formal church building erected in Beverly Hills. It has a long and rich history and holds a prominent place in the city The Church of the Good Shepherd has continued historic value to the community such that its designation as a landmark is reasonable and necessary to promote and further the purposes of the City of Beverly Hills Historic Preservation Ordinance. Thus, the property is considered to have continued historic value to the community and satisfies this criterion.
Church of the Good Shepherd 5. It is an
iconic property. The Church of the Good Shepherd is an iconic property, as defined by the Ordinance. The church is a highly visible, monumental property that is associated with Beverly sive
presence on image hosting web-based platforms, such as Flickr and Pinterest, and included as part of various walking tours. Therefore, the property appears to satisfy this criterion.
The Church of the Good Shepherd is eligible under significance criterion B.6. The landmark designation procedure is initiated, or expressly agreed to, by the owner(s) of the property. The landmark designation procedure was initiated by the Cultural Heritage Commission but has been expressly agreed to by the owner(s) of the properties. Therefore, the property satisfies this criterion.
Section 6. CHARACTER DEFINING FEATURES THAT SHOULD BE
PRESERVED. Use and development of the Church of the Good Shepherd shall be governed by the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties with Guidelines for Preserving, Rehabilitating, Restoring, and Reconstructing Historic Buildings 5 (1995) by Weeks and Grimmer (herein referred to as the SOI Standards). These standards and guidelines have been formulated to ensure that any significant adverse changes to the property do not compromise those qualities that justify its listing as a landmark. The key features that should be preserved are as follows.
The character-defining features associated with the Church of the Good Shepherd are those features on the exterior of the church building that reflect and define its Mission-revival architectural style and ecclesiastical property type. Character-defining features include all primary exterior elevations, form, massing, scale, proportions, structure, architectural ornamentation, and materials identified. Such features include, but are not limited to the following:
Church Building Exterior
One-story (double height) volume
Rectangular building plan
Location, massing, scale, proportions, and siting of the sanctuary church building on site Primary elevations defined as south, west, ad east, and north elevations Red tiled gable roof with overhanging eaves and exposed wood purlins Smooth stucco sheathing
Original (existing) setbacks from public sidewalks and streets along south (front) and east elevations
Formal concrete entry stairs/steps, and landing at front (south) elevation Bell Towers
Attached five-story, three level incrementally stepped twin towers at south end of church 6 building
Smooth stucco sheathing with pronounced cornice trim at incremental levels Engaged stucco buttresses
Flat and round-headed openings
Metallic (gold) domes
South (front) Elevation
Projecting three-bay arcade with red tiled hood
Three wooden double doors
Tympana (semi-circular decorative wall surfaces) over the three entrance doors Deeply recessed entry doors set into corresponding arched shaped openings Large tripartite stained-glass window with curvilinear trim Gable end attic vent opening with curvilinear trim
East/West (side) Elevations
Eight buttressed bays (each elevation)
Engaged stucco pilasters at upper level
Elongated round-headed window openings
Round-headed window openings set in pairs at upper level Decorative stained glass
North Elevation
High volume round shaped apse with multi-hip red-tile roof Round-headed window openings
7 Gable end attic vent opening with curvilinear trim
Floor to ceiling fixed windows with decorative stained glass Section 7. DESIGNATION OF THE SANCTUARY BUILDING OF THE CHURCH OF THE GOOD SHEPHERD AT 501 505 NORTH BEDFORD DRIVE AS A LANDMARK. The Cultural Heritage Commission finds that the sanctuary building of the Church of the Good Shepherd qualifies for City Landmark designation pursuant to the Beverly Hills Historic Preservation Ordinance. The sanctuary building at 501 505 North Bedford Drive is therefore recommended for landmark designation based on the recommendations in the City Landmark Assessment Report and the Cultural Heritage Commission deliberations.
Section 8. GENERAL GUIDELINES AND STANDARDS FOR FUTURE
PROPOSED CHANGES PURSUANT TO THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION ORDINANCE.
The Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties with Guidelines for Preserving, Rehabilitating, Restoring, and Reconstructing Historic Buildings (1995) by Weeks and Grimmer (herein referred to as the SOI Standards and Guidelines) are incorporated as reference. These standards and guidelines have been formulated to ensure that any significant adverse changes to the property do not compromise those qualities that justify its listing as a landmark. The guidelines and standards are an aid to public and private property owners, and others, formulating plans for new plantings, constructions, for rehabilitation or alteration of existing landscapes, associated structures, and for site development. The SOI Standards and Guidelines are also standards that City Staff and the Cultural Heritage Commission shall apply when making decisions about Certificates of Appropriateness as required by the City of Beverly Hills Historic Preservation Ordinance.
8 Section 9. ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS. Designation of the Church of the Good Shepherd as a local historic landmark was assessed in accordance with the authority and criteria contained in the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), the State CEQA Guidelines, and the environmental regulations of the City. It has been determined that designation of the Church of the Good Shepherd would not have a significant environmental impact and is exempt from CEQA pursuant to Sections 15061(b)(3), 15308, and 15331 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations. It can be said with certainty that there is no possibility that the designation of the Church of the Good Shepherd may have a significant effect on the environment, as no specific development is authorized by this resolution, and any future development proposed pursuant to this resolution will require separate environmental analysis when the details of those proposals are known. Further, designating the Church of the Good Shepherd is an action of the City to protect and preserve an historic resource.
Section 10. GENERAL PLAN CONSISTENCY. Designation of the Church of the Good Shepherd as a local historic landmark is consistent with the objectives, principles, and standards of the General Plan. General Plan Policy "HP 1.3 - Promote National, State, and Local Designation of Historic Resources" encourages the establishment of programs encouraging the nomination of landmarks.
Section 11. NOMINATION. The Cultural Heritage Commission hereby nominates, and recommends that the City Council designate, the Church of the Good Shepherd as a local landmark included on the City of Beverly Hills Register of Historic Properties.
Section 12. The record of proceedings for designation of the Church of the Good Shepherd as a local landmark is included on the City's Register of Historic Properties and 9 maintained by the City as part of the official records of the Community Development Department at 455 North Rexford Drive, Beverly Hills, California, 90210.
Section 13. The Secretary shall certify to the adoption of the Resolution and shall cause the Resolution and his certification to be entered in the Book of Resolutions of the Cultural Heritage Commission of the City of Beverly Hills.
Adopted: July 12, 2023 ____________________________________ Marc Teren Chair of the Cultural Heritage Commission
of the City of Beverly Hills
Attest: ___________________________ Mark Odell
Secretary of the Cultural Heritage Commission
Approved as to Form: Approved As To Content: ___________________________ ___________________________ David M. Snow Mark Odell, Urban Designer Assistant City Attorney Community Development Department Exhibit A Landmark Assessment Report by Ostashay & Associates Consulting, dated July 2023
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY BLANK
STATE OF CALIFORNIA )
COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES ) SS.
CITY OF BEVERLY HILLS )
I, KAREN MYRON, Recording Secretary of the Cultural Heritage Commission of the City of Beverly Hills, California, do hereby certify that the foregoing is a true and correct copy of Resolution No. CHC 115 duly passed, approved and adopted by the Cultural Heritage Commission of said City at a meeting of said Commission on July 12, 2023, and thereafter duly signed by the Secretary of the Cultural Heritage Commission, as indicated; and that the Cultural Heritage Commission of the City consists of five (5) members and said Resolution was passed by the following vote of said Commission, to wit:
AYES: Commissioners Reiss, Corman, Vice Chair Collins, Chair Teren NOES: None.
ABSTAIN: None.
ABSENT: Commissioner Flagg
________________________________
KAREN MYRON
Recording Secretary of the
Cultural Heritage Commission
City of Beverly Hills, California