Proposal Graders Average 1 2 3
1 Facilities Manager Urban Habitat 79.21 78.2 91.2 68.22 2 2 Engineering Inspector Universal Green 72.12 68.48 72.4 75.48 5 3 PW Manager PS Tree 86.79 82.49 92.4 85.49 1
Orozco 63.05 57.07 66 66.07 6
Mariposa 74.33 60 85 78 4
Kirkpatrick 74.84 69.86 79.8 74.86 3
Points Price 1 2 3 Average
18.22 10,618.00 59.98 72.98 50.00 60.98 2
15.48 12,500.00 53.00 56.92 60.00 56.64 4
17.49 11,062.00 65.00 74.91 68.00 69.30 1
14.07 13,750.00 43.00 51.93 52.00 48.97 6
20.00 9,675.00 40.00 65.00 58.00 54.33 5
15.86 12,200.00 54.00 63.94 59.00 58.98 3
No reference to trash service & Overseeding not included.
Landscape approach confusing
Only onsite 2 days a week for trash in townsquare & 1 day a week at fire stations Additional charge for seed + no details how to address irrigation issues between service days Unclear method of work - No reference to fire stations - Unclear how many people to perform work & how often No other work in the valley and tree trimming not local Negative previous experience: Non-responsive, change orders to offset low cost, low quality of work Only mowing once a week - does not mention irrigation - only 2x weekly for trash No rates for heavy equipment
Staffing is unclear
Mowing only once a week & service only Tuesday & Thursday No mention of irrigation
On site everyday & local vendor
service details were stated clearly & addresses any extra work that may be needed Total Average Score
Mariposa
Technical Scores
Orozco
Urban Habitat
Universal Green
PS Tree
Orozco
Vendors
Urban Habitat
PS Tree
Comments
Landscape Maintenance & Support Services Proposal Grading Mariposa
Orozco
Kirkpatrick
Universal Green
Kirkpatrick
Urban Habitat
Landscape Services
Cost Scores
Kirkpatrick
Mariposa
PS Tree
Universal Green