Cities Index.
ATTACHMENT 3 - BID EVALUATION C08874

Cathedral City City Council
November 10, 2026

Document
ATTACHMENT 3 - BID EVALUATION C08874
Meeting
November 10, 2026
Body
Cathedral City City Council
Original file
133 KB
Text extracted from the city's file for reading and search. Open the original on cathedralcity.primegov.com. That file is the official record.

ENGINEERING DIVISION

PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT

BID EVALUATION
Project: East Palm Canyon Drive Widening, Master Underground Project (MUP), and Traffic Signal at Cree Road
City Project No.: C08874
Bid No.: B23-52E
Bid Opening: October 22, 2026
Prepared by: Armando J. Garcia Baldizzone, PE, City Engineer

1. Project Background
The East Palm Canyon Drive Widening, Master Underground Project (MUP), and Traffic Signal at Cree Road consists of roadway widening and pavement improvements, construction of concrete sidewalks, curbs and gutters, utility relocations, installation of Southern California Edison (SCE) underground infrastructure, construction of a new traffic signal at Cree Road, pavement striping and signage, and installation of a Mountain Cathedrals Entryway Monument.

The project was advertised for construction bids on September 24, 2026, with the bid opening scheduled for October 22, 2026.

The construction bid was divided into four schedules:
• Schedule A: Roadway Widening, Civil Improvements, and Traffic Signal Improvements. • Schedule B: Mountain Cathedrals Entryway Monument – Concrete Foundation. • Schedule C: Mountain Cathedrals Entryway Monument – Fabrication and Installation. • Schedule D: Southern California Edison Underground Structures.

The Engineer's Estimate for the combined four schedules was $2,451,082.

2. Bid Results
On October 22, 2026, the City received six bids for the project. The bids were publicly opened and subsequently reviewed by Engineering staff.

The bid results are summarized below, ranked from lowest to highest:

Rank Bidder Total Base Bid Difference from Low Bid
1 Hardy & Harper $3,220,000.00 —
2 Granite Construction $3,329,390.00 3.40%

ENGINEERING DIVISION

PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT

BID EVALUATION
Project: East Palm Canyon Drive Widening, Master Underground Project (MUP), and Traffic Signal at Cree Road
3 Calpromax Engineering $3,440,746.00 6.86%
4 Van Engineering $3,521,059.00 9.35%
5 Hillcrest Contracting $3,927,763.80 21.98%
6 Onyx Paving $4,444,000.00 38.01%
Engineer's Estimate $2,451,082.00
The apparent low bid submitted by Hardy & Harper, Inc., was $3,220,000, exceeding the Engineer's Estimate by $768,918, or approximately 31.37%. All six bids exceeded the Engineer's Estimate.

The four lowest bids were within approximately 10% of the apparent low bid, indicating relatively consistent overall construction pricing among these bidders. However, staff's detailed review identified significant variations in individual bid-item prices.

3. Detailed Bid Evaluation
Staff evaluated the submitted bids by comparing the total bid amounts, individual unit prices, estimated quantities, and costs associated with each bid schedule.

The evaluation identified substantial pricing differences among bidders for several items, particularly traffic control, clearing and grubbing, and work associated with the Mountain Cathedrals Entryway Monument.

3.1. Unit Price Variation
The following table summarizes selected bid items with significant pricing differences among the four lowest bidders.

Bid item Hardy & Harper Granite Calpromax Van
2-A Traffic Control $300,000 $100,000 $75,000 $225,000
3-A Storm Water Protection Plan $20,000 $5,000 $2,400 $15,000 5-A Clearing and Grubbing $111,675 $75,000 $30,000 $65,000 5-B Trench and Backfill $106,250 $4,000 $20,000 $50,000 6-B Install 4-inch Conduit $31,250 $5,500 $7,500 $33,500 9-B Electrical Lighting Fixtures $18,600 $6,150 $3,600 $27,200 Amounts shown are extended bid-item prices, based on the estimated quantities in the bid schedule The traffic control prices among all six bidders ranged from $75,000 to $756,107. Similarly, Bid Item B-5, Trench 24 Inches Deep and Backfill, ranged from $4,000 to $106,250 for the same estimated quantity of 250 linear feet.

These variations indicate that contractors may have applied substantially different cost assumptions, construction methods, or allocations of project costs when preparing their bids.

ENGINEERING DIVISION

PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT

BID EVALUATION
Project: East Palm Canyon Drive Widening, Master Underground Project (MUP), and Traffic Signal at Cree Road
Variations in individual bid items do not necessarily establish that a bid is materially unbalanced, they warrant further review of the bid-item descriptions, estimated quantities, project requirements, and construction cost assumptions to ensure that the bid documents provide a clear and consistent basis for competitive bidding.

3.2. Mountain Cathedrals Entryway Monument – Schedules B and C Staff also evaluated the bid prices associated with the Mountain Cathedrals Entryway Monument, consisting of Schedule B (Concrete Foundation) and Schedule C (Fabrication and Installation).

The combined bid amounts for Schedules B and C are summarized below:

Contractor Schedule B Schedule C Combined Total
Hardy & Harper $250,000 $60,000 $310,000
Granite Construction $43,840 $86,500 $130,340
Calpromax Engineering $71,100 $36,000 $107,100
Van Engineering $164,500 $95,000 $259,500
Hillcrest Contracting $94,845 $90,600 $185,445
Onyx Paving $90,018 $72,200 $162,218
Engineer's Estimate $34,450 $67,000 $101,450
The combined monument-related bids ranged from $107,100 to $310,000, representing a difference of $202,900 between the lowest and highest amounts.

In June 2026, the City completed a similar Mountain Cathedrals Entryway Monument at East Palm Canyon Drive (East), at a final construction cost of $142,017.63. The completed project included fabrication and installation of the monument, construction of the reinforced concrete foundation, underground electrical conduits, lighting fixtures, and electrical installation.

The actual construction costs were:

Work component Final cost
Monument fabrication and installation $69,903.15
Concrete foundation $30,018.85
Underground electrical conduits $32,182.19
Electrical installation $7,317.26
Lighting fixtures $2,596.18
Total Construction Cost $142,017.63
The completed monument provides the city with recent actual construction-cost information for similar work. Although the two projects may differ in underground utility conditions, and minor

ENGINEERING DIVISION

PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT

BID EVALUATION
Project: East Palm Canyon Drive Widening, Master Underground Project (MUP), and Traffic Signal at Cree Road
installation details, the significant variations among the submitted bids support further review of the monument-related scope and cost estimates.

The apparent low bidder combined total monument bid of $310,000 was $167,982.37 higher than the City's recent completed monument cost.

This comparison identifies a substantial difference that warrants further evaluation before proceeding with a construction contract.

3.3. Evaluation of Bid Schedule D – SCE Underground Structures Staff reviewed the bids submitted for Schedule D, which includes construction of underground electrical structures and conduits associated with the Southern California Edison improvements.

Contractor Schedule D
Hardy & Harper $650,000
Granite Construction $850,490
Calpromax Engineering $678,119
Van Engineering $764,455
Hillcrest Contracting $1,358,942
Onyx Paving $1,297,145
Engineer's Estimate $615,588
Schedule D bids ranged from $650,000 to $1,358,942. The substantial variation in these prices further supports reviewing the underground utility scope, estimated quantities, and construction requirements before readvertising the project.

The apparent low bid for Schedule D was approximately 5.59% above the Engineer's Estimate.

However, the overall spread among bidders was considerably greater, particularly for underground conduit installation.

3.4. Evaluation of Bid Schedule A – Roadway and Traffic Improvements Schedule A represents the largest portion of the construction contract and includes roadway widening, pavement improvements, concrete improvements, traffic signal installation, traffic control, and related civil work.

Contractor Schedule A
Hardy & Harper $2,260,000.00
Granite Construction $2,348,560.00
Calpromax Engineering $2,655,527.00
Van Engineering $2,497,104.00

ENGINEERING DIVISION

PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT

BID EVALUATION
Project: East Palm Canyon Drive Widening, Master Underground Project (MUP), and Traffic Signal at Cree Road
Hillcrest Contracting $2,383,376.80
Onyx Paving $2,984,537.00
Engineer's Estimate $1,734,044.00
The apparent low bid for Schedule A exceeded the Engineer's Estimate by $525,956, or approximately 30.3%.

The evaluation identified significant differences in several individual bid items, including traffic control, clearing and grubbing, and construction survey. These differences indicate that additional review of the construction requirements and cost assumptions is warranted.

4. Project Funding Evaluation
In addition to reviewing the construction bids, staff evaluated the available project funding against the apparent low bid and identified utility-related costs.

The preliminary funding analysis is summarized below:

Funding category Programmed
funding
Anticipated
cost Balance
SCE Underground Improvements – MUP Fund $2,600,000.00 $2,385,000.00 $215,000.00 Traffic Improvements – Transportation Funds $900,000.00 $614,204.98 $285,795.02 Civil Improvements – SB 1 $1,133,598.00 $1,756,385.00 ($622,787.00) Entryway Monument – General Fund $125,000.00 $310,000.00 ($185,000.00) Total $4,758,598.00 $5,065,589.98 ($306,991.98)
Based on the preliminary funding analysis, the apparent low bid, together with identified utility-related costs, exceeds the total programmed funding by approximately $306,991.98.

The civil improvements and entryway monument components have funding deficits of approximately $622,787 and $185,000, respectively. Although other project components have remaining funding balances, these funds are restricted to their designated purposes and cannot be used to offset funding shortfalls in other project components.

The preliminary funding analysis does not include all anticipated construction engineering services, construction contingencies, and other potential construction-related expenditures.

Therefore, the total funding requirements may exceed the amounts currently identified.

The funding shortfall, together with the construction bids exceeding the Engineer's Estimate, indicates that the project requires further evaluation of its scope, construction costs, and funding availability before proceeding with a contract award.

ENGINEERING DIVISION

PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT

BID EVALUATION
Project: East Palm Canyon Drive Widening, Master Underground Project (MUP), and Traffic Signal at Cree Road

5. Basis for Rejection of All Bids
Section 1110-22.0, Rejection of Bids, of the project specifications expressly reserves the City's right to reject all bids.

Staff's evaluation identified the following factors supporting the rejection of all bids:
• Bids exceeding the Engineer's Estimate. All six bids exceeded the Engineer's Estimate of $2,451,082.00, with the apparent low bid approximately 31.37% above the estimate. • Significant variations in individual bid-item prices. The evaluation identified substantial differences among bidders for several items, including traffic control, clearing and grubbing, underground conduits, and monument construction. These variations warrant further evaluation of the bid documents and construction cost assumptions. • Recent construction-cost experience. The City recently completed a similar Mountain Cathedrals Entryway Monument for $142,017.63. The significant variations in the submitted monument-related bids indicate that further review of the monument scope and construction cost estimate is appropriate.
• Insufficient programmed funding. The preliminary funding analysis identified a shortfall of approximately $306,991.98, excluding certain additional construction-related expenses.

Proceeding with a construction contract would require further evaluation and identification of sufficient funding.

Collectively, these findings support rejecting all bids and reevaluating the project before readvertising for construction.

6. Recommendation
Based on the bid evaluation, staff determined that the construction bids substantially exceed the Engineer's Estimate, individual bid-item prices vary significantly among bidders, and the apparent low bid, combined with other anticipated project costs, exceeds the currently programmed funding.

The city also has recent construction-cost experience that supports reevaluating certain project components, particularly the Mountain Cathedrals Entryway Monument.

Staff recommend to reject all six bids received on October 22, 2026, for the East Palm Canyon Drive Widening, Master Underground Project (MUP), and Traffic Signal at Cree Road, City Project No. 8874, pursuant to Section 1110-22.0 of the project specifications.

Following rejection of the bids, staff will reevaluate the project scope, bid-item descriptions, estimated quantities, Engineer's Estimate, and available funding to determine appropriate modifications before readvertising the project for construction bids.

← All documents from this meeting