Cities Index.
City Council Staff Report

Cathedral City City Council
November 10, 2026

Document
City Council Staff Report
Meeting
November 10, 2026
Body
Cathedral City City Council
Original file
853 KB
Text extracted from the city's file for reading and search. Open the original on cathedralcity.primegov.com. That file is the official record.

Staff Report
City Council
Item No. 3.F
Meeting Date: November 10, 2026
From: Michael Contreras, Fire Chief
Title: Award of a Professional Services Agreement to Willdan Engineering for Fire Marshal, Fire Plan Review, and Fire Prevention Inspection Services RECOMMENDATION:

Staff recommends that the City Council award a Professional Services Agreement to Willdan Engineering for Fire Marshal, fire plan review, and fire prevention inspection services for an initial term of 21 months, with three optional one year extensions, in an annual amount not to exceed $169,245.34 and authorize the City Manager to execute the agreement, subject to approval from the City Attorney, and to exercise the one year extension options at his discretion.

BACKGROUND:

Cathedral City Fire & EMS is responsible for fire code enforcement, fire plan review, and fire prevention inspections for new construction, business licensing, cannabis operations, residential care facilities, and existing occupancies throughout the city. In calendar year 2025, the Department completed 1,832 fire inspections. Engine companies completed 642 of those inspections, primarily annual occupancy inspections, and the Fire Prevention Division completed the remaining 1,190, which include construction, business license, cannabis, residential care facilities, special circumstance, and re-inspections.

To provide qualified and dependable Fire Marshal leadership for the Fire Prevention Division workload, the City issued a Request for Proposals (RFP) for Fire Marshal services on May 15, 2026, and reissued the solicitation on July 22, 2026 (Solicitation No. 9144) due to the limited term contract expiration of the current Fire Marshal and the extended leave of the current inspector. The RFP requested Fire Marshal services, fire permit plan review, and fire prevention inspection services, and required each proposer to work within the City's existing systems, including Tyler EnerGov Permit and Licensing (EPL), Bluebeam and the IG Inspect application. The RFP also required that the consultant's plan review fee not exceed 75 percent of the plan review fees collected, with the city retaining at least 25 percent.

The City received eight proposals, from 4LEAF, Inc.; BPR Consulting Group; Bureau Veritas North America; Interwest Consulting Group; Shums Coda Associates; True North Compliance Services; West Coast Code Consultants, Inc.; and Willdan Engineering.

DISCUSSION:

The evaluation process included a four-member evaluation panel that reviewed and scored each proposal. That panel included the Fire Chief, Fire Marshal, Chief Building Official, and City Engineer. Each panelist independently scored the technical criteria established in the RFP, worth a combined 75 points:
• Firm experience, 25 points
• Qualifications of key personnel, 25 points
• Project approach, 20 points
• Location of firm, 5 points
Cost determined the remaining 25 points. To ensure the proposals were compared on equal terms, staff applied each of the proposed rates to the same workload, as described in the Cost Analysis section below. The lowest total annual cost received the full 25 points, and the remaining proposals received points in proportion to that lowest cost. Each proposer's final score is the average of the four technical scores plus its cost points, for a maximum possible score of 100.

Cost Analysis
Proposers quoted plan review as a percentage of fees collected and inspections as hourly rates, often with different rates for different classes of inspector. To compare those proposals directly, staff built one standard workload model and applied each firm's proposed rates to it:
• Plan review: each firm's percentage applied to the City's average fire plan check revenue over the last two fiscal years, $43,193.78 (FY 2024/25, $59,096.64; FY 2025/26, $27,290.92).
• Inspections: the 1,190 inspections the Fire Prevention Division completed in 2025, at one hour per inspection. Where a firm proposed two inspector rates, the 556 Inspector I level inspections (annual, business license, permit, and re-inspection) were priced at the lower rate and the 634 Inspector II level inspections (cannabis, construction, residential care, and special circumstance) at the higher rate. • The 642 inspections completed by engine companies remain with the engine companies and are excluded from the model.

Company Plan
Review %
Inspection
Rate(s)
Plan Review
Cost
Inspection
Cost
Total Annual
Cost
True North 75% $95 / $105 $32,395.34 $119,390.00 $151,785.34 Willdan 75% $115 $32,395.34 $136,850.00 $169,245.34
Bureau Veritas 75% $135 $32,395.34 $160,650.00 $193,045.34 West Coast Code 75% $135 $32,395.34 $160,650.00 $193,045.34 4LEAF 75% $127 / $147 $32,395.34 $163,810.00 $196,205.34 BPR Consulting 70% $145 $30,235.65 $172,550.00 $202,785.65 Interwest 75% $138 / $148 $32,395.34 $170,560.00 $202,955.34 Shums Coda 70% $190 / $215 $30,235.65 $241,950.00 $272,185.65 Final Scores
The combined technical and cost results are shown below.

Rank Proposer Technical
Average (75)
Annual Cost Cost
Points (25)
Total (100)
1 Willdan Engineering 65.00 $169,245.34 22.42 87.42
2 West Coast Code
Consultants, Inc.

64.06 $193,045.34 19.66 83.72
3 Bureau Veritas North America 63.75 $193,045.34 19.66 83.41 4 True North Compliance
Services

58.00 $151,785.34 25.00 83.00
5 4LEAF, Inc. 61.44 $196,205.34 19.34 80.78
6 BPR Consulting Group 61.88 $202,785.65 18.71 80.59
7 Interwest Consulting Group 59.44 $202,955.34 18.70 78.14 8 Shums Coda Associates 58.94 $272,185.65 13.94 72.88
Willdan Engineering received the highest combined score, 87.42 of 100. Willdan received the highest average technical score from the panel (65.00 of 75) and submitted the second lowest cost ($169,245.34). No other proposer finished in the top two on both technical merit and cost. True North Compliance Services submitted the lowest cost but ranked eighth of eight on technical merit and did not name a Fire Marshal in its proposal.

Willdan's proposal offers the city the following strengths:
• Depth of experience. Willdan has served public agencies since 1964, and its Fire & Life Safety division currently serves 36 California jurisdictions, the largest California fire prevention contracting record in the field.
• A proven Fire Marshal. Willdan's proposed Fire Marshal, Randy Metz, currently serves as Fire Marshal for the County of Riverside and for the Cities of Montclair and Sierra Madre, and holds California State Fire Marshal certifications as Fire Marshal, Plans Examiner, Chief Officer, Fire Prevention Officer, and Fire Investigator. • Technical bench. Four senior plans examiners holding State Fire Marshal credentials and a registered Fire Protection and Mechanical Engineer support the Fire Marshal. • Regional presence. Willdan's business office is in Riverside; the only proposer office located within Riverside County.

Contract terms remaining to be secured. The panel identified several items in Willdan's proposal that staff will resolve in the final agreement before execution:
• An unqualified commitment to perform all work within the City's Bluebeam, EnerGov EPL, and IG Inspect systems, rather than Willdan's own permitting portal. • A defined, committed level of availability for the Fire Marshal and key staff, including on-site presence and attendance at the City's Development Services Committee meetings. The proposal commits each staff member at 20 percent. • Maximum turnaround times for each plan review category listed in the RFP, stated consistently in business days.
• Confirmation that the proposed rates are firm for at least the first year of the agreement, with any later adjustment subject to City approval.

FISCAL IMPACT:

The fully burdened staffing cost of the Fire Prevention division for FY 2025/26 was $214,526.70. This includes one full-time Fire Inspector, and one part-time Fire Marshal.

With the Fire Inspector on extended protected leave, the department needs to ensure that inspections continue.

The estimated annual cost of the agreement is $169,245.34, based on the Department's 2025 workload and Willdan's proposed rates.

Component Basis Annual
Amount
Fire plan review 75% of plan check fees collected
(two-year average $43,193.78)
$32,395.34
Fire prevention inspections 1,190 inspections at 1 hour, $115 per hour $136,850.00 Annual not to exceed $169,245.34
Initial 21-month term (adjusted to
align with fiscal year)
$296,180.00
Full term with 3, 1-year extensions $803,196.02
The plan review component is paid entirely from fire plan check fees as they are collected; the city pays Willdan 75 percent of those fees and retains the remaining 25 percent, approximately $10,798 annually at the two-year average. That portion of the agreement therefore scales with development activity and does not draw on the General Fund.

The inspection expense component is billed hourly for inspections performed and will be funded by the Fire Department's existing Fire Prevention budget. The inspection revenue component will continue to be invoiced through the current E Since the agreement is billed on actual work performed, annual cost will rise or fall with plan check and inspection volume and will not exceed the annual amount without further authorization.

Alternatives:

1. Approve the recommendation as presented.

2. Award the agreement to another proposer. This would result in a higher annual cost or a lower rated technical proposal.

3. Reject all proposals and direct staff to reissue the RFP. This would delay Fire Marshal and plan review services and is not recommended.

4. Provide other direction to staff.

FIVE-YEAR STRATEGIC PLAN:

Goal E - Safety
ATTACHMENTS:

1. Professional Services Agreement with Willdan Engineering

2. Willdan Engineering Proposal

3. Evaluation Score Summary

4. Cost Analysis, All Proposals

← All documents from this meeting