Staff Report
City Council
Item No. 4.B
Meeting Date: November 10, 2026
From: Andres D. Perez, Assistant Engineer
Title: Reject Bids for the East Palm Canyon Drive Widening, Master Underground Plan and Traffic Signal at Cree Road Project (C08874) RECOMMENDATION:
To reject all bids received for the construction of the East Palm Canyon Drive Widening, Master Underground Plan (MUP) and Traffic Signal at Cree Road Project (C08874).
BACKGROUND:
In 2021, engineering staff identified the need to widen East Palm Canyon Drive near the city's western limits, where the roadway narrows as eastbound traffic enters Cathedral City limits from the City of Palm Springs. The proposed widening will improve traffic flow, provide wider bicycle lanes, and increase sight distance. The project requires the relocation of existing utilities, including the undergrounding of Southern California Edison (SCE) electrical facilities in conjunction with the removal of the seven (7) power poles located within the city's right-of-way along the south side of the roadway.
On February 23, 2022, the City Council authorized a task order with Interwest Consulting Group (Interwest) in the amount of $68,425 for surveying and engineering design services associated with the proposed roadway improvements. At the same meeting, the City Council also authorized a preliminary design agreement with SCE to initiate the design and cost estimate for undergrounding the existing electrical facilities.
On December 11, 2024, the City Council authorized an additional task order with Interwest in the amount of $76,800 for the design of a new traffic signal and intersection improvements at East Palm Canyon Drive and Cree Road. The traffic signal improvements were incorporated into the roadway widening project to accommodate future development and improve traffic operations at the intersection. A vicinity map showing the project location is included as Attachment No. 1.
Throughout the design process, engineering staff and Interwest worked closely with SCE to coordinate the removal of existing overhead electrical facilities and installation of new underground infrastructure in conjunction with the proposed roadway widening and traffic signal improvements.
In June 2026, SCE completed its final design plans, allowing the city to move forward with the project and incorporate the necessary underground civil improvements (vaults, conduit, pull boxes, etc.) into the project's construction plans and specifications.
Additionally, engineering staff incorporated plans and specifications for the construction of the Mountain Cathedrals Entryway Monument into the project, following the successful completion of entryway monument at the city's eastern entrance on East Palm Canyon Drive, near the Cathedral City/Rancho Mirage city limits.
With these improvements incorporated into the project, Interwest finalized the Plans, Specifications, and Estimate (PS&E) package on September 22, 2026, concluding the design phase of the project.
DISCUSSION:
On September 24, 2026, the city advertised to bid for Bid No. B23-52E, seeking qualified contractors to perform the work described in the project plans and specifications.
The bid solicitation was available to contractors for twenty-eight (28) calendar days and was advertised in the following locations:
• The Desert Sun – published on September 24,2026 & October 1, 2026 • Planit Print Works – September 24,2026 through October 22, 2026 • City’s Website – published on September 24,2026 & October 22, 2026.
On October 22, 2026, the city received six (6) bid proposals for this project. The following table ranks each bidder by the total bid amount.
RANK CONTRACTOR AMOUNT
1 Hardy & Harper Inc. – Lake Forest, CA $3,220,000.00
2 Granite Construction Company – Indio, CA $3,329,390.00 3 Calpromax Engineering Inc. – Placentia, CA $3,440,746.00 4 Van Engineering – Wildomar, CA $3,521,059.00
5 Hillcrest Contracting – Corona, CA $3,927,763.80
6 Onyx Paving Company Inc. – Yorba Linda, CA $4,444,000.00 Staff identified mathematical errors in the bids submitted by Calpromax Engineering, Inc. (Bid Rank 3) and Van Engineering (Bid Rank 4). These errors did not affect the bid rankings as announced at the time of bid opening. The correct bid amounts are reflected in the table above and the attached bid tabulation as Attachment No. 2.
The apparent low bid was submitted by Hardy & Harper, Inc., in the amount of $3,220,000, approximately 31.37% above the engineer's estimate of $2,451,082. All six bids exceeded the engineer's estimate, with the four lowest bids within approximately 10% of the apparent low bid.
Engineering staff conducted a detailed evaluation of the submitted bids and identified significant variations in bid-item prices among bidders. For example, bids for traffic control ranged from $75,000 to $756,107, while bids for trenching and backfill associated with the entryway monument ranged from $4,000 to $106,250. These substantial differences warrant further review of the bid-item descriptions, estimated quantities, and construction cost assumptions to ensure a consistent basis for competitive bidding.
Staff also evaluated the costs associated with the Mountain Cathedrals Entryway Monument, included in Bid Schedules B and C. The city recently completed a similar monument in June 2026 at a total construction cost of $142,017.63, including fabrication, foundation construction, underground electrical improvements, lighting, and installation. The submitted prices for Bid Schedules B and C varied significantly, with some exceeding the city's recent construction costs for comparable work. This comparison further supports reevaluating the monument-related scope and cost estimates before proceeding with construction.
In addition, the bid evaluation identified a preliminary funding shortfall of approximately $306,991.98 when considering the apparent low bid and other anticipated project costs.
Additional construction engineering services, contingencies, and other construction-related expenses may further increase the total funding required to construct the project. A detailed analysis of the bid results, pricing variations, and project funding is provided in the Bid Evaluation Report (Attachment No. 3).
Based on the bid results, significant pricing variations, recent construction cost experience, and identified funding constraints, staff recommend rejecting all bids and reevaluating the project scope, bid documents, engineer's estimate, and available funding before readvertising the project.
Pursuant to Section 1110-22.0 of the project specifications, which reserves the city's right to reject all bids, staff recommends City Council reject all six bids received for the East Palm Canyon Drive Widening, Master Underground Project (MUP), and Traffic Signal at Cree Road, City Project No. 8874
Following rejection of the bids, staff will reevaluate the project scope, bid-item descriptions, estimated quantities, engineer's estimate, and available funding to determine appropriate modifications before readvertising the project for construction bids.
FISCAL IMPACT:
The recommended action does not result in an immediate fiscal impact. Construction costs will be presented to the City Council upon receipt and evaluation of new bids, and at that time the fiscal impact will be subject to the City Council’s approval.
FIVE-YEAR STRATEGIC PLAN:
GOAL B: COMMUNITY INVESTMENTS
OBJECTIVE: Cathedral City roads, gateways, public spaces, and other infrastructure are well planned, designed, constructed and maintained.
ATTACHMENTS:
1. Attachment 1 – Vicinity Map
2. Attachment 2 – Bid Tabulation
3. Attachment 3 – Bid Evaluation