CLOVIS CITY COUNCIL MEETING
December 16, 2024 6:00 P.M. Council Chamber
Meeting called to order by Mayor Mouanoutoua at 6:00
Flag Salute led by Councilmember Pearce
Roll Call: Present: Councilmembers Ashbeck, Basgall, Bessinger, Pearce Mayor Mouanoutoua
PUBLIC COMMENTS - 6:01
Eric Rollins, resident, discussed the possibility of Clovis exploring voter ID requirements for charter cities.
CONSENT CALENDAR - 6:04
Upon call, there was no public comment.
Councilmember Ashbeck commented on Consent Calendar item 2 acknowledging the financial statement for the CFD is showing incorrect figures and possibly considering termination.
Motion by Councilmember Ashbeck, seconded by Councilmember Bessinger, that the items on the Consent Calendar be approved. Motion carried by unanimous vote.
1. Administration - Approval - Minutes from the December 9, 2024, Council Meeting.
2. Finance - Receive and File - Status Report of Community Facilities District 2004-1 Revenues and Expenditures.
3. Finance - Approval - Res. 24-138, Approving the submittal of the 2024-2025 Transportation Funding Claim to the Fresno Council of Governments.
4. Finance - Approval of various actions related to Measure Y, a general 1.0% transactions and use tax ballot measure approved by voters at the November 5, 2024, Municipal Election; (A) Approval - Res. 24-139, A Resolution of the Clovis City Council authorizing the City Manager to execute agreements with the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA); and (B) Approval - Res. 24-140, A Resolution of the Clovis City Council authorizing designated City representatives to examine confidential tax records for Measure Y Transactions and Use Tax
5. Planning and Development Services - Approval - Res. 24-141, Annexation of Miscellaneous Properties to the Landscape Maintenance District No. 1.
6. Planning and Development Services - Approval - Bid Award for CIP 24-06, New Bus Stops: B2 to Cervantes Landscape Services, Inc., in the amount of $167,172.00; and authorize the City Manager to execute the contract on behalf of the City.
Planning and Development Services - Approval - Res. 24-115A, A Resolution of the Clovis City Council: Amending Resolution 24-115 to include an additional finding necessary to approve the adoption of the City of Clovis Sixth Cycle Housing Element, and authorizing staff to submit the Housing Element to the California Department of Housing and Community Development.
Public Utilities - Approval - Waive Formal Bidding Requirements and Authorize the Purchase of Six (6) 2025 Dodge Durango Police Department Patrol Vehicles from National Auto Fleet Group Using the Sourcewell Purchasing Contract in the Total Amount of $383,195.40; and Approval - Res. 24-142, Amending the 2024-2025 Fleet Capital Acquisition Budget to Allocate $190,000 of Funds for the Purchase of Two (2) 2025 Dodge Durango Police Department Patrol Vehicles.
9. Public Utilities - Approval - Waive Formal Bidding Requirements and Authorize the Purchase of One (1) Vactor 2112-18 Sewer Cleaning Truck from Haaker Equipment Company Using the Sourcewell Cooperative Purchasing Contract in the Amount of $702,379.53; and Approval - Res. 24-143, Amending the 2024-2025 Sewer Enterprise Budget to Allocate $210,000 of Additional Funds for the Purchase of a Sewer Cleaning Truck.
10. Public Utilities - Approval - Waive Formal Bidding Requirements and Authorize the Purchase of One (1) 2026 Autocar Frontload Refuse Truck from Affinity Truck Center Using the Sourcewell Cooperative Purchasing Contract in the Amount of $436,737.73.
PRESENTATION - 6:05
6:05 - ITEM 11 - PRESENTATION OF PROCLAMATION HONORING CITY MANAGER JOHN HOLT UPON HIS RETIREMENT AND COMMENDING HIM FOR 25 YEARS OF SERVICE TO THE CLOVIS COMMUNITY.
ADMINISTRATIVE ITEMS - 6:25
6:25 ITEM 12 - CONSIDER APPROVAL - CITY MANAGER EMPLOYMENT AGREEMENT
WITH ANDREW HAUSSLER, AND APPOINTMENT OF ANDREW HAUSSLER AS CITY MANAGER EFFECTIVE JANUARY 1, 2025.
Upon call, there was no public comment.
Motion for approval by Councilmember Pearce, seconded by Councilmember Bessinger.
Motion carried by unanimous vote.
6:27 ITEM 13 - CONSIDER UPDATE ON THE REQUEST FROM THE BUILDING INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION OF FRESNO/MADERA COUNTIES, INC. REGARDING THE CITY OF CLOVIS MAJOR WATER FACILITIES FEES FROM THE AUGUST 5, 2024, COUNCIL MEETING TO RETURN WITHIN 120 DAYS.
Darren Rose CEO of the Fresno Madera Building Industry Association expressed appreciation for the update and noted the ongoing efforts with City staff and hoped for a fair and productive resolution after the first of the year. 6:30 ITEM 14 - RECEIVE AND FILE - INFORMATION FROM SECOND PUBLIC HEARING IN CITY'S TRANSITION TO DISTRICT-BASED ELECTIONS.
Bill Scott, resident, congratulated City Manager Holt on his retirement and addressed concerns about the city moving away from at-large elections.
Molly, resident, expressed strong opposition to districting and raised concerns about the impact of redistricting on communities of interest while also suggesting the consideration of both Council district model options.
Kay Radiberry, resident, expressed strong opposition to districting, framing it as a form of tyranny and extortion, criticizing the California Voting Rights Act for promoting division, and urging the council to delay the process.
Eric Rollin, resident, emphasized the importance of public participation in the transition to district process and advocating for five council members to ensure broader city representation.
Steve Trevino, resident, expressed frustration over low turnout at meetings, emphasizing the significance of issues like the districting process and urged more community involvement.
Susan Patterson, resident, spoke in opposition of the districting process and suggested consulting with the Alliance Defending Freedom to potentially assist in fighting the districting process, especially given their involvement with similar issues in other areas.
Anne, resident, strongly opposes the districting process and expressed concerns with the lack of communication.
Judy Steele, resident, spoke in support of the change to district-based voting elections and expressed interest in hearing more about the five district rotating mayors or the 4+1 council structure.
Patty Cassia, resident, suggested improving public notice through various social media platforms to raise awareness about the districting process, suggested coordinating with other cities that have fought redistricting lawsuits, and consider a class action or countersuit to collectively address the issue.
Director McCollum updated the Council on the significant outreach efforts including website updates, social media posts on platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and X, a news release with media coverage.
Council discussion included whether to pursue a four-district model or a five-district model for the city expressing support for both options. Council emphasized the importance of using neutral and unifying district names and include more than one community interest.
Staff was directed to update the city's website mapping tools to include both district model options, with additional public outreach for the scheduled Community Workshop on January 9, 2025. The Council also requested further information on the potential for having two at-large councilmembers who would represent and be accountable to the entire city.
PUBLIC HEARINGS - 7:40
7:40 ITEM 15 - CONSIDER VARIOUS ITEMS ASSOCIATED WITH ‡37.92 ACRES OF LAND LOCATED AT THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF THE N. PEACH AVENUE ALIGNMENT AND BEHYMER AVENUE. DEYOUNG PROPERTIES AND GARY YAMAMOTO, OWNERS; DEYOUNG PROPERTIES, APPLICANT; JULI KUTKA, REPRESENTATIVE.
Brandon DeYoung of DeYoung Properties supported the item, emphasizing diverse home types, varying lot sizes, and affordability by excluding HOA costs to keep prices accessible.
Molly, resident, spoke in favor of adding shade structures to playgrounds.
Bill Smitcamp, resident, spoke in support of the project.
Kay Radiberry, resident, expressed concern over small lot sizes in new subdivisions, emphasizing the importance of backyards for family gatherings, children's play, and creating a safe environment close to home.
The Council expressed concerns about approving an item that could create additional traffic hazards, emphasizing the need for appropriate signage, and highlighted the importance of adding more shade structures to the parks.
ITEM 15A - CONSIDER APPROVAL - RES. 24-144, A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY
COUNCIL ADOPTING AN ENVIRONMENTAL FINDING OF A MITIGATED NEGATIVE
DECLARATION AND A MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM FOR REORGANIZATION 311, PREZONE 2024-006, VESTING TENTATIVE TRACT MAP 6482, AND PLANNED DEVELOPMENT PERMIT 2024-002.
Motion for approval by Councilmember Ashbeck, seconded by Councilmember Pearce.
Motion carried by unanimous vote.
ITEM 15B - CONSIDER INTRODUCTION - ORD. 24-19, R2024-006, AN ORDINANCE OF
THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVING A REQUEST TO PREZONE THE PROPERTIES WITHIN THE ANNEXATION AREA FROM THE FRESNO COUNTY AE-20 ZONE DISTRICT TO THE CLOVIS R-1-PRD ZONE DISTRICT.
Motion for approval by Councilmember Ashbeck, seconded by Councilmember Pearce.
Motion carried by unanimous vote.
ITEM 15C - CONSIDER APPROVAL - RES. 24-145, TM6482, A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVING A VESTING TENTATIVE TRACT MAP FOR A 266-LOT SINGLE-FAMILY PLANNED RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT.
Motion for approval by Councilmember Ashbeck, seconded by Councilmember Pearce.
Motion carried by unanimous vote.
ITEM 15D - CONSIDER APPROVAL - RES. 24-146, PDP2024-002, A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVING A PLANNED DEVELOPMENT PERMIT FOR A 266- LOT SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT.
Motion by Councilmember Ashbeck, seconded by Councilmember Pearce to approve with an additional request to work with staff on the specifics of the play areas to potentially include shade structures. Motion carried by unanimous vote.
ITEM 15E - CONSIDER APPROVAL - RES. 24-147, RO311, A RESOLUTION OF THE
CITY COUNCIL APPROVING APPLICATION FOR THE ANNEXATION OF THE
TERRITORY KNOWN AS THE PEACH-BEHYMER SOUTHEAST REORGANIZATION AREA (‡37.92 ACRES).
Motion for approval by Councilmember Ashbeck, seconded by Councilmember Pearce.
Motion carried by unanimous vote.
8:16 ITEM 16 - CONSIDER VARIOUS ITEMS ASSOCIATED WITH APPROXIMATELY 201 ACRES ON THE EAST SIDE OF N. MINNEWAWA AVENUE, BETWEEN EAST BEHYMER AND SHEPHERD AVENUES. MULTIPLE, OWNERS; LENNAR HOMES, APPLICANT; YAMABE & HORN ENGINEERING INC., REPRESENTATIVE.
Brandon Broussard with Yamabe & Horn Engineering, Inc. presented to Council Jeff Callaway with Lennar Homes, spoke in support of project and addressed concerns of council.
Council discussion included concerns about potential traffic hazards and parking enforcement related to the proposed development, specifically regarding HOA responsibilities and trash collection logistics. The practicality of residents rolling trash bins to the street, and the potential for conflicts between residents and non-residents parking near park areas.
ITEM 16A - CONSIDER APPROVAL - RES. 24-148, A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY
COUNCIL ADOPTING AN ENVIRONMENTAL FINDING OF A MITIGATED NEGATIVE
DECLARATION AND A MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM FOR REORGANIZATION 310, PREZONE 2024-005, VESTING TENTATIVE TRACT MAP 6375, AND PLANNED DEVELOPMENT PERMIT 2024-001.
Motion for approval by Councilmember Ashbeck, seconded by Councilmember Basgall.
Motion carried by unanimous vote.
ITEM 16B - CONSIDER INTRODUCTION - ORD. 24-20, R2024-005, AN ORDINANCE OF
THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVING A REQUEST TO PREZONE PROPERTY WITHIN THE ANNEXATION AREA FROM THE FRESNO COUNTY AE20 ZONE DISTRICT TO THE CLOVIS C-1, R-1-PRD, O, AND P-C-C ZONE DISTRICTS.
Motion for approval by Councilmember Ashbeck, seconded by Councilmember Basgall.
Motion carried by unanimous vote.
ITEM 16C - CONSIDER APPROVAL - RES. 24-XX, TM6375, A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVING A VESTING TENTATIVE TRACT MAP FOR A 385-LOT SINGLE-FAMILY PLANNED RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT ON APPROXIMATELY 58.9 ACRES OF LAND.
Motion to deny by Councilmember Ashbeck, seconded by Councilmember Bessinger.
Motion carried by unanimous vote.
Motion by Councilmember Ashbeck, seconded by Councilmember Bessinger to rescind the previous motion to deny. Motion carried by unanimous vote.
Motion by Councilmember Ashbeck, seconded by Councilmember Bessinger to continue to a date uncertain. Motion carried by unanimous vote.
ITEM 16D - CONSIDER APPROVAL - RES. 24-XX, PDP2024-001, A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVING A PLANNED DEVELOPMENT PERMIT FOR A 385- LOT SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT.
Motion by Councilmember Ashbeck, seconded by Councilmember Bessinger to continue to a date uncertain. Motion carried by unanimous vote.
ITEM 16E - CONSIDER APPROVAL - RES. 24-XX, RO310, A RESOLUTION OF THE
CITY COUNCIL APPROVING APPLICATION FOR THE ANNEXATION OF THE
TERRITORY KNOWN AS SHEPHERD-MINNEWAWA NORTHEAST
REORGANIZATION AREA (APPROXIMATELY 201 ACRES).
Motion by Councilmember Ashbeck, seconded by Councilmember Bessinger to continue to a date uncertain. Motion carried by unanimous vote.
9:23 ITEM 17 - CONSIDER VARIOUS ITEMS ASSOCIATED WITH ‡14.57 ACRES OF LAND LOCATED ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF E. PERRIN AVENUE, BETWEEN N. MINNEWAWA AVENUE AND WEST OF THE N. CLOVIS AVENUE ALIGNMENT. DAVID WILLIAMS,
JOHN & TRICIA ZIMMERER, MERRILL MICHAEL, MISHA KAY WIGHT MILLER, AND JON KURISU OWNERS; BONADELLE HOMES, APPLICANT; SCOTT HARBOUR, REPRESENTATIVE.
Upon call, there was no public comment.
John Bonadelle with Bonadelle Neighborhoods presented to Council.
ITEM 17A - CONSIDER APPROVAL - RES. 24-149, A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY
COUNCIL ADOPTING AN ENVIRONMENTAL FINDING OF A MITIGATED NEGATIVE
DECLARATION AND A MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM FOR VESTING TENTATIVE TRACT MAP 6467 AND PLANNED DEVELOPMENT PERMIT 2024-003.
Motion for approval by Councilmember Ashbeck, seconded by Councilmember Bessinger.
Motion carried by unanimous vote.
ITEM 17B - CONSIDER APPROVAL - RES. 24-150, TM6467, A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVING A VESTING TENTATIVE TRACT MAP FOR A 162-LOT SINGLE-FAMILY PLANNED RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT.
Motion for approval by Councilmember Ashbeck, seconded by Councilmember Bessinger.
Motion carried by unanimous vote.
ITEM 17C - CONSIDER APPROVAL - RES. 24-151, PDP2024-003, A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVING A PLANNED DEVELOPMENT PERMIT FOR A 162- LOT SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT.
Motion for approval by Councilmember Ashbeck, seconded by Councilmember Bessinger.
Motion carried by unanimous vote.
CITY MANAGER COMMENTS - 9:43
None.
COUNCIL COMMENTS - 9:45
It was the consensus of the Council to revisit the change to move the Council meeting day back to Monday and bring it back for further discussion.
CLOSED SESSION - 9:48
Upon call, there was no public comment.
City Attorney Cross identified the matter involves a letter from BIA to the City of Clovis, dated October 23, 2024, regarding a dispute over major water facilities fee.
ITEM 18 - GOVERNMENT CODE SECTION 54956.9(D)(2)_CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL
COUNSEL - ANTICIPATED LITIGATION SIGNIFICANT EXPOSURE TO LITIGATION ONE
POTENTIAL CASE
RECONVENE INTO OPEN SESSION AND REPORT FROM CLOSED SESSION No action taken.
ADJOURNMENT
Mayor Mouanoutoua adjourned the meeting of the Council to January 6, 2025.
Meeting adjourned: 10:30 p.m.
Diane Tearce Buara
Mayor Pro Tem
Briana Parra
From: City of Clovis Website <[email protected]> Sent: Tuesday, December 10, 2024 7:03 PN
To: Andrew Haussler; Rebecca Simonian; Briana Parri
Subiect: [External] Public Comment for City Council
Council Meeting Date: 2024-12-10
Item Number (put "O" if your comment is regarding an item not on the agenda): 6 Full Name: Dunn
Email: [email protected]
Comment: #stopforsandro
Supporting Files (2 Max.):
--
Date: December 10, 2024
Time: 7:02 pm
Remote IP: 68.230.13.103
Public Comment for December 16, 2024
1 Briana Parra
From: City of Clovis Website < [email protected]> Sent: Friday, December 13, 20249:15 PM
To: Andrew Haussler; Rebecca Simonian; Briana Parra
Subject: [External] Public Comment for City Council
Council Meeting Date: 2024-12-16
Item Number (put "O" if your comment is regarding an item not on the agenda): 6 Full Name: Jeanette Payan
Email: [email protected]
Comment: #stopfordandro
Supporting Files (2 Max.):
---
Date: December 13, 2024
Time: 9:15 pm
Remote IP: 68.21.165.247
Agenda Item No. 14
NDC
National Demographics Corporation
CITY OF CLOVIS
Introduction to Districting
Dr. Jeff Tilton, Senior Consultant
December 16, 2024
National Demographics Corporation
Election Systems
-
"At Large"
"From District" or "Residence" Districts
3. "By District"
The California Voting Rights Act
was written to specifically
encourage by-district elections.
NDC December 16, 2024 2
California Voting Rights Act (CVRA)
• Under the Federal Voting Rights Act (passed in 1965), a jurisdiction must fail 4 factual tests before it is in violation of the law. • The California VRA makes it significantly easier for plaintiffs to force jurisdictions into "by-district" election systems by eliminating two of the US Supreme Court Gingles tests:
•-Can the protected class constitute the majority of a district? Does the protected class vote as a bloc?
Do the voters who are not in the protected class vote in a bloc to defeat the preferred candidates of the protected class?
•- Do the "totality of circumstances" indicate race is a factor in elections? • Liability is now determined only by the presence of racially polarized voting and dilution of the protected class's ability to elect or influence the outcome of elections
NDC December 16, 2024
3 CVRA Impact
• Switched (or in the process of switching) as a result Sample settlements and fee awards:
of CVRA:
Palmdale: $4.7 million
200 cities
Santa Clara: $3.8 million
At least 328 school districts
Modesto: $3 million
• 46 Community College Districts
Highland: $1.3 million
1 County Board of Supervisors
Anaheim: $1.1 million
• 73 water and other special districts.
Whittier: $1 million
Santa Barbara: $600,000
• Palmdale, Santa Clara and Santa Monica fought "on
the merits." All lost. Tulare Hospital: $500,000
Santa Monica: CA Supreme Court sent case back Camarillo: $233,000 down. Now back in Superior Court. Compton Unified: $200,000 Palmdale spent about $1.8 million, Santa Clara Madera Unified: about $170,000 $1.37 million, and Santa Monica over $7 million, Hanford Joint Union Schools:
just on their defense.
$118,000
Santa Monica plaintiffs requested $22 million
Merced City: $42,000
So far, no jurisdiction has won a case.
An estimated $20 million in total
settlements and court awards so far.
NDC December 16, 2024 4
Districting Process
Step Description
Pre-draft map hearing •Held prior to release of draft maps November 18 Education and to solicit input on the composition of districts Pre-draft map hearing •Held prior to release of draft maps December 16 • Education and to solicit input on the composition of districts Community Workshop • Cvs Transit Center, 6 p.m.
January 9 • Learn about the process and mapping tools
Release draft maps
: Rabi must be posted at lenit by poday p hier to hearing Hearing on draft maps • Discuss and revise the draft maps January 21
Hearing on draft maps • Discuss and revise the draft maps February 11
Selection of final map • Select final map and the election sequence March 4 • First reading of the Ordinance
•Final map must be posted at least days prior to adoption Ordinance adoption • Map adopted via Ordinance
March 11
Within 21 days of Map • Issue compliance report
adoption
Districting Rules and Goals
1. Federal Laws 2. California Criteria 2. California Prohibition Equal Population "Shall not adopt election district
Mandatory in prioritized order:
Federal Voting Rights Act boundaries for the purpose of favoring
1. Geographically contiguous or discriminating against an incumbent, No Racial Gerrymandering political candidate, or political party."
2. Avoid division of
neighborhoods and
No other criterion may be prioritized
"communities of interest"
over statutory criteria.
(Socio-economic geographic areas
that should be kept together)
3. Other Traditional
3. Easily identifiable
boundaries Redistricting Principles
4. Compact Future population growth
(Do not bypass one group of
people to get to a more distant
group of people
NDC December 16, 2024 6
Category Field Total Category Field Total
2020 Census Total Population 120,461 age0-19 31%
Demographic Hispanic/Latino 31% Age age20-60 51%
NH White 48% age60plus 18%
Total Pop. NH Black 3% immigrants 12%
Summary NH Asian/Pac.Isl. Immigration
15% naturalized 62%
NH Native Amer. 2% english 76%
Total 79,591 Language spoken at spanish 13%
Hisp 28% home asian-lang 7%
NH White 56% other lang 4%
Citizen Voting Age
Each of the five districts Pop NH Black 4% Speaks Eng. "Less Language Fluency 7%
than Very Well"
must contain about Asian/Pac.Isl. 12%
hs-grad 56%
Native Amer. Education (among
24,092 people. 0% bachelor 22%
those age 25+)
Total 72,655 graduatedegree 13%
Latino est. 26% Child in Household child-under 18 40%
Spanish-Surnamed 23% Pct of Pop. Age 16+ employed 62%
Voter Registration
With an At Large Mayor, Asian-Surnamed 6% income 0-25k 9% (Nov 2022)
Filipino-Surnamed 1% income 25-50k 15%
each of the four districts
NH White est. 63% Household Income income 50-75k 14%
must contain about NH Black 4% income 75-200k 46%
30,115 people. Total 38,468 income 200k-plus 15%
Latino est. 20% single family 80%
Spanish-Surnamed 18% multi-family 20%
Voter Turnout Housing Stats
Asian-Surnamed 4% rented 34%
(Nov 2022)
Filipino-Surnamed 1% owned 66%
NH White est. 70%
NH Black 4%
Total 59,718 Total population data from California's adjusted 2020 Census Latino est. 22% data. Citizen Voting Age Population, Age, Immigration, and Spanish-Surnamed 21% other demographics from the 2018-2022 American Community Voter Turnout Survey and Special Tabulation 5-ycar data. Turnout and Asian-Surnamed 5%
(Nov 2020) Registration data from California Statewide Database. "Latino" Filipino-Surnamed 1% figures calculated by NDC using Census Bureau's Latino NH White est. 70% undercunt by surname estimate.
NH Black est. 3%
NDC December 16, 2024 7
0% to 25%
E International Ave
25% to 35%
Latino CVAP 35% to 50%
E Behymer Ave 50% to 65%
65% to 75%
75% to 100%
E Shepherd Ave
Latino eligible voters are
somewhat concentrated in
Nees Ave
the center and southwest
portions of the city. E Alluvial Ave
W Herndon Ave
W Sierra Ave Tollhouse Rd
E Bullard Ave
W Barstow Ave Sunnyside Ave
W Shaw Ave
W Gettysburg Ave
N Peach Ave Minnewawa Ave Clovis Ave Bernadine Dr N Fowler Ave Armstrong Ave E Ashlan Ave
Temperance Ave N Locan Ave N De Wolf Ave N Leonard Ave: N Highland Ave NDC December 16, 2024
8 Asian-American E International Ave 0% to 25%
25% to 35%
35% to 50%
E Behymer Ave
CVAP 50% to 65%
65% to 75%
75% to 100%
E Shepherd Ave
Asian-American eligible voters
are somewhat concentrated in
Nees Ave
the northeast, north-central and
southwest portions of the city. E Alluvial Ave
W Herndon Ave
w Sierra Ave Tollhouse Rd
E Bullard Ave
W Barstow Ave Sunnyside Ave
W Shaw Ave
W Gettysburg Ave z
Peach Fo
Minnewawa Ave Clovis Ave Bernadine Dr Armstrong Ave
E Ashlan Ave y Temperance Ave N De Wolf Ave
Ave N Leonard Ave N Highland Ave
rash
NDC December 16, 2024 9
African- 0% to 25%
E International Ave
25% to 35%
35% to 50%
E Behymer Ave 50% to 65%
American
65% to 75%
75% to 100%
CVAP
E Shepherd Ave
African-American eligible
voters are not concentrated
Nees Ave
in any one part of the city.
E Alluvial Ave
W Herndon Ave
W Sierra Ave Tollhouse Rd
E Bullard Ave
W Barstow Ave Sunnyside Ave
W Shaw Ave
W Gettysburg Ave
N Peach
Minnewawa Ave clovis Ave Bernadine Dr N Fowler Ave Armstrong Ave E Ashlan Ave >
ve Temperance/Ave N De Wolf Ave
N Locan Ave N Leonard Ave N Highland Ave
NDC December 16, 2024 10
Defining Neighborhoods
1st Question: How do you describe or name the area where you live? 2nd Question: What are its geographic boundaries?
3rd Question: What other neighborhoods are there?
Examples of physical features defining a neighborhood boundary:
• Natural neighborhood dividing lines, such as highway or major roads, rivers, canals and/or hills
Areas around parks or schools
• Other neighborhood landmarks
NDC December 16, 2024 11
Possible Neighborhoods
School Board High School
Trustee Areas Attendance Areas
Clovis North
Buchanan
Zoning
Types
ZONE_BASE
C-1 (15)
NDC 12
Defining Communities of Interest
California Elections Code Section 21130(c)(2):
A "community of interest" is a population that shares common social or economic interests that should be included within a single district for purposes of its effective and fair representation.
The shared interests may include (but are not limited to):
• Shared public policy concerns such as education, public safety, public health, environment, housing, transportation, and access to social services. cultural districts;
Shared socioeconomic characteristics;
Similar voter registration rates and participation rates; and /or Shared histories.
Definitions of Communities of Interest may not include relationships with political parties, incumbents, or political candidates.
NDC December 16, 2024 13
Socio-Economic Demographics
€ internettenal Ave
E International Ave
College Graduates Renters
E Behymer Ave
e Behymer Ave
0% to 25%
25% to 35%
E Shepherd. Ave e Shepherd Are
35% to 50%
50% to 65%
65% to 75% sere Are
Nees Are
75% to 100%
* Alledal Are.
W Herndon Axe.
w Sietta Ave w sie
emeralen Household Income
E Hahymer Ave
over $75,000/year
E Shopherd Are
E Allurial Are.
w Herndon Are
w sierte Ave
W Barstow Are
we Shee Are
NDC December 16, 2024 14
Socio-Economic Demographics
ermalan Child under 18 at home # Interma
Spanish spoken at home
E lehymer Ave
0% to 25%
E Shepherd Are 25% to 35% E shepherd Ars
35 to 50%
50% to 65%
Need Are. Here Are
65% to 75%
CAlluvialAve * Alinecial A
75% to 100%
W Heindon Ave
W Herndon Are
w sierra, Are
" Multi-Family Housing W Cattyabu
e dehymer Ave
(Apartment or Condo)
Shepherd Ava
does Ave
w steere Are
e Bullard Ave
NDC December 16, 2024
15 Simple Map Drawing Tool
Paper "Public Participation Kit"
For those without internet access or who prefer paper (in English or Spanish) Total Population Counts only - no demographic numbers
E Interne alonal Ave
Clovis 2024-25 Districting An onime version of this map that allows you to zoom in and out for more detail is availble as
* fahrmer Public Participation Kit a link from the City website: cityofclovis.com Fach number indicates the total population of that
"population unit" area. Each district must have
essentialls equal population. The population of
each of the five districts must be close to 24,092
with no more than a 2,409 difference between
the largest and smallest.
Please use a thick dark-colored pen to draw your
map, then submit it at City Hall or by email to
[email protected].
You can hand-deliver, mail, fax, scan and email, or
634 photograph and email your map.
H4S7
163S
1519 BIe
1733
1151 1600 1691 147 1001
Name
1645 1500 17 1770
Phone and/or email:
1H4S5
ожеслік
ali Coenaina Oral 21, 202
NDC December 16, 2024 16
Online Map Drawing Tool
Simple "paintbrush & eraser" tool. A 4-minute "how-to" video is on the website. • Full demographic data available
• Create, collaborate and share your map
• Remember: you must email your finished map's hyperlink to the City mapping contact: [email protected]
DRA 2020 C City of Clovis 2024-2025 Districting
Clovis - County City
é. X Tools -
24,075 Precinct Block
Precinct Details
District Population Deviation
120.374 Total Pop (Adj) 2020
24,075
White
Hispanic
-24075
24.075 2,910
Native
24,075
1537฿ Pacific
District Details Citizen VAP 2022
1,114
Pop
Total
White
763 1.519
Hispanie
769 Elach
Asian
1,514 1,600 1,651 Native
2,185 1,645 Pacifi:
2628 2.986
D
Map saved to server.
Colors
•)mapben
Overlays
Custom Overlays $ 2024 Social Good Fund for Dave's R bbax • OpenStreetMap Improve this map NDC December 16, 2024 17
davesredistricting.org
Interactive Review Map
Interactive Map to view the data and draft maps
Works much like Google Maps
For viewing data only - it does not have a "draw a map" capability Clovis 2024-2025 Districting with ArcGIS Web AppBuilder Find address or place Layer List A X
Layers
# • City_Border
• PopUnits
• • School_Trustee_Election_Areas
> • High School Attendance Areas
• CA Counties
• • CA Census Places
• 0
• Percent Asian CVAP 2018-2022
• • Percent who speak Spanish at Home 2018-2022 ...
Percent who speak Other Lanquages at Home
2018-2022
Fresno
Percent with High School Diploma or Higher
2018.2022
19.672 36.877 Degre County Dept. PWP, Bureau o
NDC December 16, 2024 18
Interactive review map
• •
Your Turn
What area do you consider your neighborhood?
What are your "communities of interest"?
For each answer, please provide:
• Geographic boundaries
• The history or defining shared characteristic of the area In the absence of public testimony, planning records and other similar documents may provide definition.
Any other questions about the process, criteria, maps, or any other part of this process?
NDC December 16, 2024 19
Share Your Thoughts
Website
cityofclovis.com
Phone
559.324.2060
Email
[email protected]
ras
NDC December 16, 2024 20
•
Briana Parra
From: City of Clovis Website <[email protected]> Sent: Monday, December 16, 2024 11:44 AM
To: Andrew Haussler, Rebecca Simonian; Briana Parra
Subject: [External] Public Comment for City Council
Council Meeting Date: 2024-12-16
Item Number (put "O" if your comment is regarding an item not on the agenda): 14 Full Name: Rachel Youdelman
Email: [email protected]
Comment: l'd like to reiterate my support for the transition to district-based city-council elections.
Current at-large council members have each talked about enjoying the flexibility to serve the entire city, but residents don't necessarily see it that way. In a city of this size, we residents need to know, not guess, whom to call when there is an issue of concern. We need to know that our particular neighborhood has an advocate. Currently, a resident has a better chance of being ignored by all five than of receiving a response from one. When each council member is responsible for a particular district, we residents will be better positioned to engage with our council representative and act as co-advocates for our neighborhoods ourselves.
| look forward to participating in the mapping process.
Supporting Files (2 Max.):
---
Date: December 16, 2024
Time: 11:43 am
Remote IP: 67.181.166.166
1 Agenda Item No. 14
Public Comment Dec. 16, 2024
Hi, I'm Judi Steele, a Clovis resident.
I'm in support of the change to district-based voting in compliance with the CA Voting Rights Act (CVRA) and want to thank the City Council members and staff for all the work that was put in with the Demographer's assistance to set up the dates for pre draft hearings, the commumity workshop, draft map hearings, and adoption. I want to hear the input on whether to have 5 districts and rotating mayors or 4+ 1 because i'm not sure which I prefer. Maybe drawing up both maps before a decision is made might be best at this point.
I'm also very impressed with the draft map tools that were provided on the website and for all skill levels and I would like to echo Council member Ashbeck's comments at a previous mtg that more PR is needed to get our residents involved in this process, ie social media. Thank you.
Agenda Item No. 17
BONADELLE
NEIGHBORHOODS
TM 6467
City Council Presentation
December 16th, 2024
• Tract 6467 Community Layout
• Affordability
Overview
• 6467 Proposed Amenities
• Proposed Community Amenities
• Renderings & Floor Plan Overview
BONA DELLE
NEIGHBORHOODS
Adjacent Land
„8 l
BONADELLE
EIGHBORHOODS
• HOA Maintained
Community
Highlights • Enhanced Sense of Arrival
• Approx. Total Open Space 21,997 SF
• 37' Wide Streets and Parking
BONA DELLE
NEIGHBORHOODS
APN: 556-030-03 APN: 558-030-03
EX. USE: SFR EX. USE: SFR
EX. ZONING: AE-20 EX. ZONING: AE-20
Home Site RIVATE
100 :
AVATI
Layout .oriE
STREET
ORMATE
."„".2."."
• Total DU Allowed: 233
• Total Units: 162; 11.61 D.U./AC
BONA DELLE
LOODS
• Offering options for first-time buyers and
growing families
• Anticipating to be below Clovis Avg. of $510,312
Affordability • Mortgage payments are comparable to average rents in the area
• Proven first time home buyer product
BONADELLE
EIGHBORHOOD.
Proposed Pool
and Amenity
Center
*These renderings are in the plans proposal stage and do not
BONADELLE
represent the final
NEIGHBORHOODS
RI
*These renderings are in the plans proposal stage and do not BoNADELLE represent the final
Proposed
Pickleball Court
• Total Open Space: 21,997 SF
*These renderings are in the plans proposal stage and do not BONADELLE represent the final
NEIGHBORHOOD:
Proposed Entry
Design
NUOVO TERRACES
URBAN LIVINE WITH
*These renderings are in the proposal stage and do not BONADELLE represent the final plans NEIGHBORHOODS
Palmina Floor
Plan Elevations
BoNADELLE
NEIGHBORHOODS
Generation Floor
Plan Elevations
BONADELLE
EIGHBORHOOD
Tradition Floor
Plan Elevations
BONADELLE
EIG HBORHOODS
Lineage Floor
Plan Elevations
BONADELLE
EIGHBORHOODS
BoNADELLE
NEIGHBORHOODS