Ample, Inc. Automotive Rentals, Inc.
Commercial Vehicle Leasing,
LP DBA D&M Leasing Doering Leasing Co. Element Fleet Corporation Enterprise Fleet Management,
Inc. eTransEnergy
Possible Points
Conformance to RFP Requirements 50 36 40 42 40 41 42 38 Pricing 400 250 319 334 271 310 307 230
Financial Viability and Marketplace
Success 75 51 55 62 59 63 64 52
Ability to Sell and Deliver Service 100 64 80 78 71 73 85 61 Marketing Plan 50 38 36 42 40 42 38 40
Value Added Attributes 75 58 63 61 56 61 61 56
Warranty 50 40 37 41 40 36 41 38
Depth and Breadth of OfferedEquipment, Products, or Services 200 126 170 167 168 171 172 108 Total Points 1,000 663 800 827 745 797 810 623
Rank Order 11 3 1 8 4 2 12
Five Star Express, LLC Highland Electric Fleets, Inc.
Merchants Automotive
Group, LLC. Mike Albert Leasing, Inc. NuGen Go, LLC Sewell Fleet Management Possible Points
Conformance to RFP Requirements 50 29 38 37 38 37 37
Pricing 400 170 259 316 293 281 315
Financial Viability and Marketplace
Success 75 39 54 55 58 51 56
Ability to Sell and Deliver Service 100 53 75 72 69 62 65 Marketing Plan 50 24 40 40 37 34 30
Value Added Attributes 75 42 60 59 56 51 48
Warranty 50 25 41 38 37 34 37
Depth and Breadth of OfferedEquipment, Products, or Services 200 95 151 172 159 148 162 Total Points 1,000 477 718 789 747 698 750
Rank Order 13 9 5 7 10 6
James Voelker, CPCM, CFCM, Procurement Lead Analyst Chris Robinson, CPSM, Procurement Manager Craig West, Procurement Analyst Beverly Hoemberg, Procurement Analyst Fleet Management Services RFP #030122
Proposal Evaluation