Cities Index.
FY 2025-26 Budget Work-Study Session_

Commerce City Council
May 29, 2025

Document
FY 2025-26 Budget Work-Study Session_
Meeting
May 29, 2025
Body
Commerce City Council
Original file
2.8 MB
Text extracted from the city's file for reading and search. Open the original on cityofcommerce.legistar1.com. That file is the official record.

2 • Budget Approach for FY 2025-26
• FY 2025-26 consolidated budget process – 1.5 months
• Two Council Work-Study Sessions:
• 05/29/25 – FY 2024-25 Update, FY 2025-26 Proposed Budget, & Authorized Positions
• 06/12/25 – Parks & Rec programs, Capital Improvement Program, Non-General Funds
3 1. Budget Practices
• No Budget Process
• Inadequate maintenance of the City’s financial system – unclear budget figures
• Deficient Budget Oversight & Control
• No Appropriations for large items
• No position control or position budgeting in at least five years (MOUs were being approved, PERS increases, health insurance increases; these impacts were never added to the budget)
• Lacking long-term planning
• No published budget book since FY 2022-23
4 2. Financial Practices
• Significantly delayed audited financial statements
• Inadequate maintenance of the City’s General Ledger– unclear cost centers for Depts.
• Several audit findings have not been addressed
• Outdated policies and procedures
• Deficiencies in the Accounts Payable Process
• Internal controls need improvement with an emphasis on separation of duties
5 3. Other Areas
• Transit Fund Deficit – potentially up to $15 million by the end of current fiscal year • No investment of idle cash – significant loss of investment earnings in high-interest environment
• Comingling of Successor Agency Bank Account and the General Account • Unauthorized payments to vendors:
• No existing contracts
• Expired Contracts
• Payments exceeded or will exceed the “not-to-exceed” threshold • High fees for services that offer little value to the City (continue to pay for services that are no longer needed)
• Equity adjustments
• No Master User Fee Schedule
• No Reserves Policy or other Policies required by the Govt Code 6 7
FY 2024-25 FY 2024-25
Revenue Source Amended Through April $ %
License Fees - Card Club $ 29,370,000 $ 20,260,154 $ 9,109,846 31% Sales Tax 27,350,000 16,170,922 11,179,078 41%
Other Taxes 8,213,578 5,254,056 2,959,522 36%
Licenses & Permits 5,435,160 4,958,640 476,520 9%
Use of Money 1,730,000 1,797,507 (67,507) -4%
Rev - Other Agencies 1,525,000 2,220,626 (695,626) -46% Current Charges 1,101,587 922,772 178,815 16%
Transfers-In 800,000 800,000 - 0%
Parks and Recreation 261,838 355,881 (94,043) -36%
Misc. Revenue 340,603 670,618 (330,015) -97%
Fines & Penalties 308,200 366,983 (58,783) -19%
Total $ 76,435,966 $ 53,778,158 $ 22,657,808 30%
Left to collect
8 FY 2024-25 FY 2024-25
Department Amended Through April $ %
Administrative Services 231,494 16,447 215,047 93%
City Administration 3,370,216 2,000,584 1,369,632 41%
Debt Service/Transfers-Out 2,145,000 3,862,298 (1,717,298) -80% Economic Development & Planning 1,445,303 432,238 1,013,065 70% Finance 2,362,763 1,829,778 532,985 23%
Human Resources 1,614,053 1,237,169 376,884 23%
Library Services 3,597,230 2,934,174 663,056 18%
Non-Departmental 9,068,758 4,484,032 4,584,726 51%
Parks and Recreation 9,046,151 7,360,703 1,685,448 19%
Public Safety 27,982,825 22,064,351 5,918,474 21%
Public Works 10,261,715 7,195,390 3,066,324 30%
Transportation 483,887 1,261,650 (777,763) -161%
Total 71,609,395 54,678,816 16,930,579 24%
Remaining
• No revenue or expenditure budget for most Non-General funds • Need appropriations (zero budget) for the following funds:
• 22 ( COPS Grant), 26 (Gas Tax), 29 (CDBG), 30 (AQMD), 31 (Housing), 33 (Community Assistance Fund), 50 (Water Utility)
• Need additional appropriations for the following funds:
• Fund 40 (Capital Projects):
• Wash-Tel project $1.8 million in exp and $0 budget
• Fund 41 (Measure AA) – comingling sales and use tax with grant reimbursements
9 • Baseline Budget for FY 2025-26 – “Bridge Year”
• Core expenditure growth outpacing revenue growth
• New ongoing costs were carefully evaluated
• Potential recession (even a mild one) or decreased economic activity may threaten a balanced budget
• Biennial Budget for FY 2026-28
• Some changes incorporated into FY 2025-26 budget, further changes to be considered in FY 2026-28
10 • Tariffs, tariffs, and more tariffs – overall avg. tariff rate 17.8%, which is the highest level since 1934 • Economic volatility – outlook: increased probability of a recession in the next 12 months • “Growth Recession”
• CPI – US: 2.8%, California : 3.1%, Commerce: 3.1
• Unemployment – US: 4.2%, California: 5.3%, Commerce: 3.3% • 2025 & 2026 outlook
• Market volatility – market reacting to tariff threats • SB 549: Tribal Nations Access to Justice Act
• Cannabis Operations
• Major company no longer operating since 2023.
• Budget est. for revenue since FY 2021-22: $1.3 million • Currently, on avg, generating approx. $550k annually
• Federal & State Budget
• Federal cuts across the board are highly anticipated
• State budget projected $12 billion shortfall
11 • Analyzed over 140 revenue accounts and “right-sized” each account • Low to Moderate increases across the board
• Major increases/decreases reflect adjustments due to inaccurate low or high estimates in the prior year
• Sales tax increase of 5% - staff will be monitoring sales tax closely • Casino License Fee (card club) moderate increase of 3% • Removed Gas Tax transfer-in to the General Fund; all gas tax eligible expenditures to be recorded in the Gas Tax Fund
• Assumes no recession or economic downturn
12 13
FY 2024-25 FY 2025-26
Revenue Source Amended Proposed $ %
License Fees - Card Club $ 29,370,000 $ 30,320,000 $ 950,000 3% Sales Tax 27,350,000 28,793,200 1,443,200 5%
Other Taxes 8,213,578 9,632,700 1,419,122 17%
Licenses & Permits 5,435,160 5,744,800 309,640 6%
Use of Money 1,730,000 2,241,200 511,200 30%
Rev - Other Agencies 1,525,000 1,694,200 169,200 11%
Current Charges 1,101,587 1,402,000 300,413 27%
Transfers-In 800,000 755,000 (45,000) -6%
Parks and Recreation 261,838 368,100 106,262 41%
Misc. Revenue 340,603 441,500 100,897 30%
Fines & Penalties 308,200 323,000 14,800 5%
Total $ 76,435,966 $ 81,715,700 $ 5,279,734 7%
Difference
14 • Developed position budgeting model for 470 (178 FT & 292 PT) citywide positions • GF Labor = $28.2 million, $5.1 million increase (22%) due to inaccurate/lack of labor budget from previous year
• MOU-driven increases incorporated into the FY 2025-26 Budget:
• 4% Cost of Living Adjustment (COLA)
• 9% Health Insurance increase
• Step Increases
• Deferred Compensation contributions
• CalPERS:
• 10.93% Normal Cost (approx. $2.8 million for FY 25-26) • Unfunded Actuarial Liability (UAL) - approx. $700k for FY 25-26 15 16
FY 2024-25 FY 2025-26
Department Amended Proposed $ %
Administrative Services 231,494 652,600 421,106 182%
City Administration 3,370,216 3,367,600 (2,616) 0%
Debt Service/Transfers-Out 2,145,000 2,915,500 770,500 36% Economic Development & Planning 1,445,303 1,638,800 193,497 13% Finance 2,362,763 3,067,600 704,837 30%
Human Resources 1,614,053 2,131,300 517,247 32%
Library Services 3,597,230 5,006,600 1,409,370 39%
Non-Departmental 9,068,758 9,540,700 471,942 5%
Parks and Recreation 9,046,151 10,765,000 1,718,849 19% Public Safety 27,982,825 28,901,200 918,375 3%
Public Works 10,261,715 11,256,600 994,885 10%
Transportation 483,887 2,472,200 1,988,313 411%
Total 71,609,395 81,715,700 10,106,305 14%
Difference
17 City Administration/Admin Services:
• $4.1 Million budget:
• 11 FT & 3 PT - $2.7 million
• Legal Services - $1.0 million
• Contracts, supplies, travel - $0.4 million
• New for FY 2025-26:
• Supplies for City calendar & Commerce
Connect - $18,500
Economic Development & Planning:
• $1.6 million budget:
• 9 FT & 1 PT - $1.5 million
• Contracts, supplies, other - $0.1 million
• New for FY 2025-26:
• Rearranging EDPD office space and
cubicles & furniture - $50,000
18 Finance:
• $3.1 Million budget:
• 12 FT & 4 PT - $2.2 million
• IT Contracts/Subscriptions - $0.5 million
• Contracts, supplies, travel - $0.4 million
• New for FY 2025-26:
• Deletion of Assistant Finance Director
• Addition of IT Technician
• Reclassification of IT Specialist to IT Supervisor
• Reclassification of Purchasing Manager to Finance Manager • Equity Adj for Accounting Supervisor, Account Technician & Payroll Specialist classifications 19 Net impact:
savings of
$62,300
Human Resources:
• $2.1 million budget:
• 8 FT - $1.4 million
• Yes Program - $0.2 million
• Recruitment, Medical Exams, supplies - $0.2
million
• Other -$0.3 million (see below)
• New for FY 2025-26:
• Job classification & Analysis - $50,000
• Investigation Services - $70,000
• Tuition Reimbursement for FT ($120,000) & PT
($84,000) employees - $204,000
20 Library:
• $5.0 Million budget:
• 21 FT & 25 PT - $4.4 million
• Library Collection - $0.1 million
• Contracts, equipment, supplies,
travel - $0.5 million
• New for FY 2025-26:
• Summer reading program, additional
library collection, 10 laptops & 20
computers - $112,500
Non-Dept.:
• $12.4 million budget:
• General Services - $5.8 million
• Liability Insurance premium - $1.5 million
• UP Sales Tax Sharing Agreement - $1.5 million
• Utilities – Electricity - $1.3 million
• Active and Retiree Benefits - $3.7 million
• Medical Insurance Retirees - $1.4 million
• CalPERS UAL - $0.7 million
• Workers Comp Premium - $0.6 million
• Debt Service Payments - $2.9 million
• 2021 POBs - $2.1 million
• 2014 Lease Rev Bonds (Aquatorium) - $0.8 million
21 Parks & Recreation:
• $10.8 Million budget:
• 24 FT & 221 PT - $8.8 million
• Special Events - $0.7 million
• Parks & Rec Activity – 0.3 million
• Aquatics Center - $0.3 million
• Park Operations - $0.2 million
• Camp Commerce - $0.2 million
• Other (Admin, Pre-School, Kids Club, Day Camps, Rec operations, Sports program, Admin) - $0.2 million
• Senior Center & Teens Center - $0.1 million
22 Public Safety:
• $28.9 million budget:
• 3 FT & 15 PT - $1.1 million
• L.A. County Fire contract - $16.1 million
• L.A. Sheriff Contract - $11.1 million
• Animal Control/Crossing Guards/Community Safety Spec./Emergency Preparedness/Probation - $0.6 million
• New for FY 2025-26:
• Rearranging office space for Public Safety and cubicles & furniture -$50k • National Night Out Budget - $30k
23 Public Works:
• $11.3 Million budget:
• 37 FT & 10 PT - $4.9million
• PW Contracts - $2.9 million
• PW Engineering & Building- $2.2 million
• Facilities Operations & Environmental -$0.8 million
• Street & Tree Maintenance - $0.3 million
• Park Maintenance - $0.2 million
• New for FY 2025-26:
• Additional funding for Engineering & Building - $900k • Freeway on/off ramp maintenance - $150k
• Project Management contract - $140k
• Addition of Maintenance & Operations Manager
• Reclassifications - 1 supervisor and 1 lead in each of the following operations: park maintenance, street & trees, & facilities 24 Transportation:
• Partially funded by the General Fund
• $2.5 million budget:
• Leases, fuel, vehicle maintenance & replacements - $1.0 million • Proposition A Exchange program- $1.0 million
• Partial Labor of certain positions - $0.5 million
25 26
• Fund Balance – Accumulation of operating surpluses during years in which revenues exceed expenditures. “Cash-on-hand” available in each of the city’s 18 funds (one-time funding).
• Five different categories of fund balance:

1. Nonspendable – not available to spend due to legal or contractually constrains – ex: inventory, notes and loans, prepaid items

2. Restricted – external restrictions imposed by grantors, contributors, or laws or regulations – ex: federal and state grants for a specific purpose or restricted donations or contributions

3. Committed – amounts committed by the City Council – ex:
capital projects or contractual obligations

4. Assigned – amounts the City intends to use for specific purposes – ex: Economic Contingency Reserve, Equipment
Replacement Fund, Rainy Day Fund, Project Management
Fund, etc.

5. Unassigned – one-time amounts available for any
governmental purpose
As of June 30, 2024 (latest audited figures):

FUND

UNASSIGNED

FUND BALANCE
10 - General Fund $ 106,359,316
22 - COPS Grant 206,348
26 - State Gas Tax 301,695
29 - CDBG -
30 - AQMD AB 2766 Rideshare Grant 42,059
31 - Housing 2,089,952
32 - Art in Public Places 1,939,924
33 - Community Assistance Fund 511,119
34 - Storm Water Management 1,459,861
40 - Capital Improvement 8,247,968
41 - Measure AA 26,739,477
42 - Community Center Debt Service 2,727
50 - Water Utility 2,476,584
57 - Transit (10,698,819)
58 - CNG/LNG Station 3,693,131
70 - Trust Fund (Donations) 366,813
81 - Successor Agency Admin Fund 1,923,333
92 - Successory Agency Projects/Bonds $ 17,596,500
Reserve Policy for Unassigned fund balance:
• Government Finance Officers Association (GFOA) recommends at least two months of operating expenditures (16.7%)
• Due to the City’s revenue base and its susceptibility to a recession or economic downturn, the goal should be 100%
• As a practice, the recommendation will be a minimum of six months of operations (50%)
• Excess of 100% = Project Management Assigned Fund Balance • One-time funding for:
• Economic uncertainty; Pension stability; OPEB stability; IT server replacements/other major IT replacements; facility improvements; equipment replacements; risk management stability, etc. 27 • Position Control = a system that ensures all positions are budgeted properly, authorized by the City Council, and accounted for
• Each position is clearly defined, including title, salary grade, and responsibilities and ensures that the number of authorized positions is not exceeded
• Official list of positions approved by the City Council (hard copy provided) is the basis of the position control system
• AB 2561 compliance
28 •June 12th – Second work-study session
•June 24th – Budget Adoption by the City Council
29 30

← All documents from this meeting