RFP24-069AS ON-CALL ENGINEERING AND PROFESSIONAL CONSULTING SERVICES EXHIBIT 1
SCORING SUMMARY
Item Discipline Consultant
Reviewer 1
Score
Reviewer 2
Score
Reviewer 3
Score
Reviewer 4
Score
Reviewer 5
Score
Overall
Score
A Architectural SVA Architects, Inc. 85 87.5 82 95 80 85.9 A Architectural TR Design Group, Inc. 85 87 82 90 84 85.6 A Architectural IDS Group, Inc. 79 86 87 90 84 85.2
A Architectural Rios, Inc. 82 81.5 84 88 88 84.7
A Architectural HMC Group dba HMC Architects 86 78 87 89 76 83.2 A Architectural Gillis & Panichapan Architects, Inc. 81 80 77 94 79 82.2 A Architectural Westgroup Designs 68 85 78 86 82 79.8
A Architectural Miller Architectural Corp 77 73 74 88 86 79.6 A Architectural 19six Architects 75 79 80 82 80 79.2
A Architectural Bureau Veritas North America, Inc. 71 79 74 82 77 76.6 A Architectural Black O'Dowd and Associates 74 76 77 79 75 76.2 A Architectural Studio One Eleven 63 75 83 81 77 75.8
A Architectural RACAIA 51 67.5 74 78 73 68.7
B Structural Engineering IDS Group, Inc. 81 84 83 92 85.0 B Structural Engineering John A. Martin & Associates 81 83 78 90 83.0 B Structural Engineering Michael Baker International, Inc. 85 86 73 87 82.8 B Structural Engineering Civiltec Engineering, Inc. 79 80 75 89 80.8 B Structural Engineering Mark Thomas and Company, Inc. 79 85 70 82 79.0 B Structural Engineering KPFF, Inc. 77 75 75 85 78.0
B Structural Engineering ISE Structural Engineers (Innovative) 74 78 74 83 77.3 B Structural Engineering Bureau Veritas North America, Inc. 72 73 74 83 75.5 B Structural Engineering FEI Associates Consulting Engineers C Landscape Architecture and Irrigation Design David Evans and Associates, Inc. 85 87 91 90 88.3 C Landscape Architecture and Irrigation Design IDS Group, Inc. 89 88 87 87 87.8 C Landscape Architecture and Irrigation Design RJM Design Group, Inc. 86 83 89 88 86.5 C Landscape Architecture and Irrigation Design Albert A. Webb Associates 88 78 87 90 85.8 C Landscape Architecture and Irrigation Design NUVIS 87 84 84 85 85.0 C Landscape Architecture and Irrigation Design Architerra, Inc. dba Architerra Design Group 79 86 83 80 82.0 C Landscape Architecture and Irrigation Design Mark Thomas and Company, Inc. 82 82 81 81 81.5 C Landscape Architecture and Irrigation Design Willdan Engineering 71 85 86 84 81.5 C Landscape Architecture and Irrigation Design Rios, Inc. 84 72 81 83 80.0 C Landscape Architecture and Irrigation Design Michael Baker International, Inc. 77 77 75 77 76.5 C Landscape Architecture and Irrigation Design Van Dyke Landscape Architects 73 77 74 81 76.3 C Landscape Architecture and Irrigation Design Interwest Consulting Group 74 77 75 78 76.0 C Landscape Architecture and Irrigation Design Studio One Eleven 69 75 74 79 74.3 D Traffic Engineering Iteris, Inc. 88 96 95 94 93.3
D Traffic Engineering Advantec Consulting Engineers, Inc. 89 93 92 93 91.8 D Traffic Engineering Kimley Horn and Associates, Inc. 89 92 87 91 89.8 D Traffic Engineering DKS Associates 85 90 89 91 88.8
D Traffic Engineering Fehr & Peers 88 92 87 88 88.8
D Traffic Engineering HR Green Pacific 87 88 92 85 88.0 PAGE 1 OF 5
RFP24-069AS ON-CALL ENGINEERING AND PROFESSIONAL CONSULTING SERVICES EXHIBIT 1
SCORING SUMMARY
Item Discipline Consultant
Reviewer 1
Score
Reviewer 2
Score
Reviewer 3
Score
Reviewer 4
Score
Reviewer 5
Score
Overall
Score
D Traffic Engineering Michael Baker International, Inc. 80 93 90 88 87.8 D Traffic Engineering Linscott, Law & Greenspan, Engineers 87 93 86 84 87.5 D Traffic Engineering Willdan Engineering 85 88 86 84 85.8 D Traffic Engineering Infrastructure Engineers (Bowman) 79 95 91 77 85.5 D Traffic Engineering Transtech Engineers 79 94 88 79 85.0 D Traffic Engineering STC Traffic, Inc. 79 89 86 82 84.0 D Traffic Engineering JMDiaz Inc. 85 77 89 84 83.8
D Traffic Engineering General Technologies and Solutions 80 85 84 80 82.3 D Traffic Engineering Interwest Consulting Group 84 80 86 74 81.0 D Traffic Engineering TJKM 76 93 77 74 80.0
D Traffic Engineering Albert A. Webb Associates 80 72 77 86 78.8 D Traffic Engineering System Metric Group 76 77 85 74 78.0 D Traffic Engineering EPD Solutions 68 58 64 54 61.0
E Construction Management and Inspection Falcon Engineering Services, Inc. 76 81 89 91 84.3 E Construction Management and Inspection Z&K Consultants, Inc. 86 83 84 83 84.0 E Construction Management and Inspection Albert A. Webb Associates 82 79 76 89 81.5 E Construction Management and Inspection Dudek 81 79 74 89 80.8 E Construction Management and Inspection Willdan Engineering 72 81 83 80 79.0 E Construction Management and Inspection Fountainhead Consulting Corporation 72 84 71 86 78.3 E Construction Management and Inspection Interwest Consulting Group 78 80 67 87 78.0 E Construction Management and Inspection Onward Engineering 71 84 79 77 77.8 E Construction Management and Inspection Transtech Engineers 72 83 71 83 77.3 E Construction Management and Inspection Psomas 60 78 79 89 76.5 E Construction Management and Inspection TKE Engineering 66 78 70 89 75.8 E Construction Management and Inspection Anser Advisory Management (Accenture) 71 81 64 85 75.3 E Construction Management and Inspection Michael Baker International, Inc. 73 78 61 87 74.8 E Construction Management and Inspection Berg and Associates 66 83 69 80 74.5 E Construction Management and Inspection PMCS Group 57 81 70 89 74.3 E Construction Management and Inspection LAE Associates 69 82 60 83 73.5 E Construction Management and Inspection FCG Consultants 54 75 71 85 71.3 E Construction Management and Inspection AKM Consulting Engineers 73 76 60 75 71.0 E Construction Management and Inspection Civiltec Engineering, Inc. 44 73 50 82 62.3 E Construction Management and Inspection N2W Engineering 45 65 50 78 59.5 E Construction Management and Inspection FEI Associates Consulting Engineers 0 0.0 F Civil Engineering Mark Thomas and Company, Inc. 84 82 72 84 80.5 F Civil Engineering Michael Baker International, Inc. 86 84 82 70 80.5 F Civil Engineering Hunsaker & Associates Irvine, Inc. 84 77 81 76 79.5 F Civil Engineering Albert A. Webb Associates 81 77 82 77 79.3 F Civil Engineering Psomas 80 80 75 82 79.3
F Civil Engineering Willdan Engineering 84 82 79 70 78.8 F Civil Engineering David Evans and Associates, Inc. 82 80 77 75 78.5 PAGE 2 OF 5
RFP24-069AS ON-CALL ENGINEERING AND PROFESSIONAL CONSULTING SERVICES EXHIBIT 1
SCORING SUMMARY
Item Discipline Consultant
Reviewer 1
Score
Reviewer 2
Score
Reviewer 3
Score
Reviewer 4
Score
Reviewer 5
Score
Overall
Score
F Civil Engineering TAIT & Associates, Inc. 83 79 74 78 78.5 F Civil Engineering Westland Group 82 77 77 74 77.5
F Civil Engineering Proactive Engineering Consultants, Inc. 85 80 75 68 77.0 F Civil Engineering Wood Rodgers, Inc. 85 77 71 75 77.0 F Civil Engineering BKF Engineers 82 81 73 70 76.5
F Civil Engineering IDS Group, Inc. 80 72 80 73 76.3
F Civil Engineering MNS Engineers, Inc. 84 79 65 75 75.8 F Civil Engineering JMDiaz Inc. 79 80 72 70 75.3
F Civil Engineering Rick Engineering 74 78 76 71 74.8
F Civil Engineering The K.W.C Companies, Inc. dba KWC Engineers 75 69 82 69 73.8 F Civil Engineering Onward Engineering 72 83 74 66 73.8 F Civil Engineering HR Green Pacific 73 74 69 74 72.5
F Civil Engineering KPFF, Inc. 79 78 63 65 71.3
F Civil Engineering Dudek 79 75 63 63 70.0
F Civil Engineering CWE 72 71 69 67 69.8
F Civil Engineering Exp U.S. Services 71 79 57 71 69.5
F Civil Engineering Infrastructure Engineers (Bowman) 64 77 68 65 68.5 F Civil Engineering Armstrong and Brooks Consulting Engineers 69 73 68 62 68.0 F Civil Engineering Engineering Resources of Southern California 72 70 64 63 67.3 F Civil Engineering The Prizm Group 63 67 74 63 66.8
F Civil Engineering J. Smith & T. Muli 67 74 62 62 66.3 F Civil Engineering Civiltec Engineering, Inc. 62 67 71 59 64.8 F Civil Engineering Interwest Consulting Group 50 68 57 62 59.3 F Civil Engineering FEI Associates Consulting Engineers 0 0.0 G Labor Compliance and DBE Advanced Avant-Garde Corporation 73 73.0 G Labor Compliance and DBE GCAP Services 74 74.0
G Labor Compliance and DBE Willdan Engineering 84 84.0
H Land Surveying BKF Engineers 83 83 91 88 85 86.0
H Land Surveying Westland Group 87 83 82 79 86 83.4
H Land Surveying David Evans and Associates, Inc. 83 84 83 77 84 82.2 H Land Surveying Calvada Surveying, Inc. 84 76 89 73 84 81.2 H Land Surveying Hunsaker & Associates Irvine, Inc. 82 82 67 89 82 80.4 H Land Surveying Willdan Engineering 70 85 85 76 84 80.0 H Land Surveying Rick Engineering 68 90 76 84 78 79.2
H Land Surveying KDM Meridian 72 83 82 76 77 78.0
H Land Surveying Michael Baker International, Inc. 62 84 81 88 75 78.0 H Land Surveying The K.W.C Companies, Inc. dba KWC Engineers 75 89 38 92 78 74.4 H Land Surveying KPFF, Inc. 56 82 80 75 75 73.6
H Land Surveying Civiltec Engineering, Inc. 56 81 75 79 75 73.2 H Land Surveying The Prizm Group 55 79 42 86 77 67.8
H Land Surveying Armstrong and Brooks Consulting Engineers 52 66 36 85 77 63.2 PAGE 3 OF 5
RFP24-069AS ON-CALL ENGINEERING AND PROFESSIONAL CONSULTING SERVICES EXHIBIT 1
SCORING SUMMARY
Item Discipline Consultant
Reviewer 1
Score
Reviewer 2
Score
Reviewer 3
Score
Reviewer 4
Score
Reviewer 5
Score
Overall
Score
H Land Surveying Transtech Engineers 0 65 48 92 0 41.0
I Hazardous Materials Testing Ninyo & Moore Geotechnical & Environmental Sciences Consultants 83 87 85 76 82.8 I Hazardous Materials Testing Terracon Consultants, Inc. 85 84 81 78 82.0 I Hazardous Materials Testing The Converse Professional Group, Inc, dba Converse Consultants 75 80 76 72 75.8 I Hazardous Materials Testing Citadel Environmental 76 67 66 78 71.8 I Hazardous Materials Testing Charles Taylor Environmental Technical Services 73 65 66 73 69.3 J Property Appraisal Services Epic Land Solutions, Inc. 85 83 83 91 85.5 J Property Appraisal Services CBRE, Inc. 81 86 80 89 84.0 J Property Appraisal Services Hendrickson Appraisal Company, Inc. 79 81 82 94 84.0 J Property Appraisal Services VPA LA Inland Empire 68 75 67 70 70.0 J Property Appraisal Services Worth Valuations 63 72 66 70 67.8 K ROW Coordination Overland, Pacific & Cutler, LLC a Transystems Company 78 82 74 72 76.5 K ROW Coordination Epic Land Solutions, Inc. 79 77 67 66 72.3 K ROW Coordination Paragon Partners Consultants 69 72 73 71 71.3 L ROW Acquisition and Relocating Services Monument ROW 73 88 83 88 70 80.4 L ROW Acquisition and Relocating Services Overland, Pacific & Cutler, LLC a Transystems Company 76 77 81 81 82 79.4 L ROW Acquisition and Relocating Services Paragon Partners Consultants 83 67 78 79 80 77.4 L ROW Acquisition and Relocating Services Epic Land Solutions, Inc. 82 66 77 72 79 75.2 L ROW Acquisition and Relocating Services Interwest Consulting Group 73 66 72 74 75 72.0 L ROW Acquisition and Relocating Services Clark Land Resources, Inc. 76 65 71 73 68 70.6 M Utility Locating
N NPDES Compliance and Program Support Services Michael Baker International, Inc. 81 89 93 94 93 90.0 N NPDES Compliance and Program Support Services CWE 81 84 89 90 78 84.4 N NPDES Compliance and Program Support Services Infrastructure Engineers (Bowman) 66 62 61 67 42 59.6 O Electrical Engineering Civiltec Engineering, Inc. 80 90 91 89 87.5 O Electrical Engineering Michael Baker International, Inc. 82 88 88 91 87.3 O Electrical Engineering SKM Engineering, LLC 84 91 85 85 86.3 O Electrical Engineering IDS Group, Inc. 78 84 84 83 82.3 O Electrical Engineering Bureau Veritas North America, Inc. 81 77 81 80 79.8 P Grant Writing Willdan Engineering 87 81 91 86.3
P Grant Writing Mark Thomas and Company, Inc. 89 83 85 85.7 P Grant Writing MNS Engineers, Inc. 84 83 87 84.7
P Grant Writing Evan Brooks Associates, Inc. 82 82 82 82.0 P Grant Writing California Consulting, Inc. 85 80 78 81.0 P Grant Writing BKF Engineers 81 78 76 78.3
P Grant Writing Engineering Solutions Services 80 79 75 78.0 P Grant Writing Transtech Engineers 75 78 79 77.3
P Grant Writing Michael Baker International, Inc. 88 76 64 76.0 P Grant Writing HR Green Pacific 77 76 70 74.3
P Grant Writing Interwest Consulting Group 68 73 68 69.7 P Grant Writing Iteris, Inc. 66 73 68 69.0
PAGE 4 OF 5
RFP24-069AS ON-CALL ENGINEERING AND PROFESSIONAL CONSULTING SERVICES EXHIBIT 1
SCORING SUMMARY
Item Discipline Consultant
Reviewer 1
Score
Reviewer 2
Score
Reviewer 3
Score
Reviewer 4
Score
Reviewer 5
Score
Overall
Score
P Grant Writing Linscott, Law & Greenspan, Engineers 60 66 61 62.3 P Grant Writing N2W Engineering 63 60 63 62.0
Q Material Testing and Special Inspection Ninyo & Moore Geotechnical & Environmental Sciences Consultants 84 77 86 90 84 84.2 Q Material Testing and Special Inspection RMA Group, Inc. 76 72 84 91 72 79.0 Q Material Testing and Special Inspection Twining, Inc. 80 75 76 88 75 78.8 Q Material Testing and Special Inspection The Converse Professional Group, Inc, dba Converse Consultants 73 77 83 86 74 78.6 Q Material Testing and Special Inspection Willdan Engineering 79 76 81 81 76 78.6 Q Material Testing and Special Inspection Verdantas, Inc. (formerly Leighton Consulting) 80 72 84 90 66 78.4 Q Material Testing and Special Inspection GeoTek 83 71 77 87 70 77.6 Q Material Testing and Special Inspection Earth Systems Pacific 83 71 72 81 69 75.2 Q Material Testing and Special Inspection Geocon West 81 76 61 79 75 74.4 Q Material Testing and Special Inspection Fenagh Engineering & Testing 81 74 70 76 68 73.8 Q Material Testing and Special Inspection Inland Foundation Engineering 72 68 71 85 60 71.2 Q Material Testing and Special Inspection GeoMat Testing Laboratories 66 67 0 68 77 55.6 R Water and Wastewater Engineering Albert A. Webb Associates 79 81 83 85 81 81.8 R Water and Wastewater Engineering Dudek 81 83 82 85 78 81.8 R Water and Wastewater Engineering Civiltec Engineering, Inc. 70 81 81 79 85 79.2 R Water and Wastewater Engineering GHD Inc. 76 82 75 86 75 78.8 R Water and Wastewater Engineering The K.W.C Companies, Inc. dba KWC Engineers 71 81 80 82 77 78.2 R Water and Wastewater Engineering Michael Baker International, Inc. 83 81 80 66 80 78.0 R Water and Wastewater Engineering Armstrong and Brooks Consulting Engineers 67 80 78 78 68 74.2 R Water and Wastewater Engineering N2W Engineering 67 74 82 71 70 72.8 R Water and Wastewater Engineering Willdan Engineering 72 70 76 69 75 72.4 R Water and Wastewater Engineering HR Green Pacific 77 74 67 67 74 71.8 R Water and Wastewater Engineering MKN & Associates 68 72 76 68 70 70.8 R Water and Wastewater Engineering SA Associates 75 70 70 67 72 70.8 R Water and Wastewater Engineering CWE 73 73 70 70 66 70.4 R Water and Wastewater Engineering AKM Consulting Engineers 66 75 71 69 62 68.6 S Business Goodwill Appraisal Services Desmond, Marcello & Amster, LLC 76 74 74 70 76 74.0 T Furniture, Fixtures, Machine and Equipment Appraisal Services Desmond, Marcello & Amster, LLC 77 79 73 70 76 75.0 PAGE 5 OF 5