EXHIBIT 1 – VENDOR QUOTE ANALYSIS MATRIX
Using a weighted scoring matrix, CCTS staff evaluated the three vehicle models and the associated quotes. The scoring was completed using a scale of 1 through 3, with 3 being the most competitive and 1 being the least competitive.
Vendor Quote Analysis Matrix
Vendor Model 1 Model 1 A-Z
Manufacturer Starcraft Startrans Glaval Bus
Model Allstar Senator Universal
Quote Date 1/26/2026 1/26/2026 1/27/2026
Base Price (per unit) $151,975.00 $152,501.00 $161,279.00 Options Price (per unit) $59,854.00 $58,951.00 $57,054.00 Frame Coating / Corrosion Resistance Spray-primed Aluminized Coating Aluminized Coating Altoona Test Results
3 Reliability Issues /
1 Shakedown Test
Issue
2 Reliability Issues /
1 Shakedown Test Issue
3 Reliability Issues /
1 Shakedown Test Issue
Vehicle Warranty See Warranty Details See Warranty Details See Warranty Details Proposed Delivery Date 210 Days from PO 210 Days from PO 210 Days from PO Vendor Performance See Peer Survey See Peer Survey See Peer Survey Ranking
Base Price 25% 3 2 1
Required Options Price 20% 1 2 3
Frame Coating / Corrosion Resistance 5% 2 3 3
Altoona Test Results 25% 2 3 2
Vehicle Warranty 10% 3 3 2
Proposed Delivery Date 5% 3 3 3
Vendor Performance 10% 3 3 2
Total Score 2.3 2.55 2.05
*Altoona testing results for all three vehicle options were reviewed specifically for the CNG model of the vehicle, except for the shakedown test. A shakedown test was not performed for the CNG version of the Starcraft Allstar, but it was performed on the gasoline version of the vehicle. In the absence of a result for the CNG version of Starcraft Allstar, the shakedown test result for the gasoline version of the vehicle was used instead for the purpose of this analysis. All three vehicles had similar water penetration issues identified in the shakedown test, which ultimately did not impact the overall Altoona test result score. In addition, all three vehicles are manufactured by Forest River, which has implemented improvements to address water penetration issues identified in the Altoona testing reports, such as improved weather seals and enhanced caulking procedures.