Cities Index.
Agenda, first session

Crescent City City Council
March 18, 2024

Document
Agenda, first session
Meeting
March 18, 2024
Body
Crescent City City Council
Original file
11.6 MB
Text extracted from the city's file for reading and search. Open the original on evogov.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com. That file is the official record.

1 | P a g e
3/18/24 COUNCIL AGENDA

CITY OF CRESCENT CITY
Mayor Blake Inscore Mayor Pro Tem Ray Altman
Council Member Jason Greenough Council Member Kelly Schellong Council Member Isaiah Wright
MONDAY MARCH 18, 2024 6:00 P.M.

This meeting will be held in person at the location listed above. The City will broadcast the meeting on YouTube, however, if there is a technological issue with YouTube, the meeting will continue in person as scheduled. The public may access and participate in the public meeting by (1) attending the meeting in person and making public comment when called for by the Mayor or (2) by submitting a written comment via [email protected] or by filing it with the City Clerk at 377 J Street, Crescent City, California, 95531. All public comments (via email or mail) must be received by the City Clerk prior to 12:00 p.m. the day of the meeting. Please identify the meeting date and agenda item to which your comment pertains in the subject line. Public comments so received will be forwarded to the City Council and posted on the website next to the agenda. Written public comments will not be read aloud during the meeting.

Notice regarding Americans with Disabilities Act: In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, if you need special assistance to participate in the meeting, please contact the City Clerk’s office at (707)464-7483, ext. 223. Notification 48 hours before the meeting will enable the City to make reasonable arrangements to ensure accessibility to this meeting [28 CFR 35.102-

35.104 ADA Title II]. For TTYDD use for speech and hearing impaired, please dial 711. A full agenda packet may be reviewed at City Hall, 377 J Street, Crescent City, CA or on our website:
www.crescentcity.org

OPEN SESSION
Call to order
Roll call
Pledge of Allegiance
CEREMONIAL ITEMS - None

REPORTS AND PRESENTATIONS
• The Raging Sea Presentation

PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD
Any member of the audience is invited to address the City Council on any matter that is within the jurisdiction of the City of Crescent City. Comments of public interest or on matters appearing on the agenda are accepted. Note, however, that the Council is not able to undertake extended discussion or act on non-agendized items. Such items can be referred to staff for appropriate AGENDA

REGULAR MEETING OF THE

CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT CITY

FLYNN CENTER BOARD CHAMBERS
981 H STREET
CRESCENT CITY, CA 95531
2 | P a g e
3/18/24 COUNCIL AGENDA
action, which may include placement on a future agenda. All comments shall be directed toward the entire Council. Any comments that are not at the microphone are out of order and will not be a part of the public record. After receiving recognition from the Mayor, please state your name and city or county residency for the record. Public comment is limited to three (3) minutes. The public is additionally allotted three minutes each in which to speak on any item on the agenda prior to any action taken by the Council.

CONSENT CALENDAR

1. Warrant Claims List
• Recommendation: Receive and file the warrant claims list for the period February 14, 2024 through March 9, 2024.

2. Council Meeting Minutes
• Recommendation: Approve and adopt the February 20, 2024 and March 4, 2024 meeting minutes of the City Council.

3. Payroll Report
• Recommendation: Receive and file the biweekly payroll reports for the period ending March 9, 2024, paid March 15, 2024.

4. 5. Declaring the Continuance of an Emergency Due to Continuous Slide Activity Along Pebble Beach Drive
• Recommendation: Declare by a 4/5 vote that there is a need to continue the emergency action for the continuous slide activity along Pebble Beach Drive between 7 th and 8th Streets per Public Contract code § 22050

PUBLIC HEARING

6. Public Hearing: General Plan Map Amendment – 1405 California Street • Recommendation: Open public hearing
• Hear staff report
• Technical questions from the Council
• Receive public comment
• Close public hearing
• Further Council discussion
• Approve and adopt Resolution No. 2024-18, A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY

COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT CITY AMENDING THE GENERAL PLAN MAP FOR APN 118-403-002-000 (1405 CALIFORNIA STREET)

7. Public Hearing: Zoning Map Amendment – 1405 California Street • Recommendation: Open public hearing
• Hear staff report
• Technical questions from the Council
• Receive public comment
• Close public hearing
• Further Council discussion
2019-2020 Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) Business Assistance Loan Program Agreement
• Recommendation: Approve and ratify the City Manager's execution on Amendment No. 2 to the Subrecipient Agreement with Arcata Economic Development Corporation 3 | P a g e
3/18/24 COUNCIL AGENDA
• Waive full reading, read by title only and adopt Ordinance No. 840, AN ORDINANCE

OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT CITY AMENDING THE ZONING DISTRICT DESIGNATION FOR 1405 CALIFORNIA STREET AND THE CITY’S OFFICIAL ZONING MAP

8. ADJOURN TO THE CRESCENT CITY HOUSING AUTHORITY
Call to order
Roll Call

CONSENT CALENDAR

9. Housing Authority Meeting Minutes
• Recommendation: Approve and adopt the December 18, 2023 meeting minutes of the Crescent City Housing Authority

PUBLIC HEARING

10. Annual Plan Submission FYB24
• Recommendation: Open public hearing
• Hear staff report
• Technical questions from the Board
• Receive public comment
• Further Board discussion
• Close public hearing
• Consider and adopt Resolution No. HA2024-01, A RESOLUTION OF THE

CRESCENT CITY HOUSING AUTHORITY APPROVING AND AUTHORIZING EXECUTION OF THE FY24 PHA ANNUAL PLAN AND CERTIFYING COMPLIANCE

OF THE PLAN AND ITS RELATED REGULATIONS TO THE DEPARTMENT OF

HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT

ADJOURNMENT

RECONVENE THE CITY COUNCIL MEETING
CONTINUING BUSINESS - None

NEW BUSINESS
Municipal Code Update: Sign Regulations (CH. 17.39)
• Recommendation: Open public hearing
• Hear staff report
• Technical questions from the Council
• Receive public comment
• Close public hearing
• Further Council discussion
• Waive full reading, read by title only and adopt Ordinance No. 839, AN ORDINANCE

OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT CITY AMENDING CHAPTER

17.39, SIGNS, OF TITLE 17, ZONING, OF THE CRESCENT CITY MUNICIPAL CODE

11. Discussion Regarding the Use of Zoom at Public Meetings • Recommendation: Hear staff report
4 | P a g e
3/18/24 COUNCIL AGENDA
• Technical questions from the Council
• Receive public comment
• Further Council discussion
• Give direction to staff regarding the use of Zoom during public meetings

CITY COUNCIL ITEMS
➢ Reports, Concerns, Referrals, Council travel and training reports – In accordance with Gov’t Code § 54954.2(a), City Council Members may make brief announcements or brief reports on their own activities. They may ask questions for clarification, make a referral to staff or take action to have staff place a matter of business on a future agenda. ➢ Legislative Matters – Consider miscellaneous legislative matters pertinent to the City of Crescent City. Authorize the Mayor to sign the appropriate letters and/or positions with respect to such matters.
➢ City Manager Report and City Council Directives – Pursuant to Crescent City Municipal Code § 2.08.200, the City Council may instruct the city manager on matters of importance to the administrative services of the City and provide direction with respect to subordinates of the City Manager. (Directives from individual Council Members that are not objected to by any member present shall be considered an order of the City Council.) • CA Jobs First Funding Update

ADJOURNMENT
Adjourn to the regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Crescent City on Monday, April 1, 2024 at 6:00 p.m. in the Flynn Center, 981 H Street, Crescent City, CA 95531.

POSTED:

March 14, 2024
/s/ Robin Altman
City Clerk/Administrative Analyst
Vision:

The City of Crescent City will continue to stand the test of time and promote quality of life and community pride for our residents, businesses and visitors through leadership, diversity, and teamwork.

Mission:

The purpose of our city is to promote a high quality of life, leadership and services to the residents, businesses, and visitors we serve. The City is dedicated to providing the most efficient, innovative and economically sound municipal services building on our diverse history, culture and unique natural resources.

Values:

Accountability
Honesty & Integrity
Excellent Customer Service
Effective & Active Communication
Teamwork
Fiscally Responsible

Accounts Payable
User:

Printed:
[email protected]
3/14/2024 9:06 AM
Checks by Date - Summary by Check Number
Check No Vendor No Vendor Name Check Date Void Checks Check Amount ACH EDDTAX State of California EDD TAX Auto Pay 03/04/2024 0.00 4,735.99 ACH FITTAX FIT Payroll Taxes Auto Pay 03/04/2024 0.00 21,383.35 ACH PERS1 PERS Health 03/04/2024 0.00 99,996.36
ACH PERS2 Public Emp Retirement Sys 03/04/2024 0.00 35,925.84 ACH PERS2 Public Emp Retirement Sys 02/29/2024 0.00 75,000.00 444982 AEDC Arcata Economic Development Corporation 02/28/2024 0.00 52,950.00 444983 CALORE AirMedCare 03/04/2024 0.00 71.00
444984 AMFAM American Family Life 03/04/2024 0.00 1,512.66 444985 AMLIF Ameritas Life Ins. Corp. 03/04/2024 0.00 5,564.16 444986 CLEA California Law Enforcement Association 03/04/2024 0.00 384.00 444987 WAMUTU Crescent City Employees Association 03/04/2024 0.00 70.00 444988 CCPOLI Crescent City Police Officer's Association 03/04/2024 0.00 650.00 444989 DNAMBU Del Norte Ambulance Inc. 03/04/2024 0.00 60.00 444990 REDWMO Kevin J Caldwell MD Inc 03/04/2024 0.00 100.00 444991 ICMARE Mission Square 03/04/2024 0.00 4,974.01
444992 MYERSS Myers-Stevens & Toohey Co Inc 03/04/2024 0.00 136.50 444993 PARS PARS, Public Agency Retirement 03/04/2024 0.00 300.00 444994 STANDAI Standard Insurance Company 03/04/2024 0.00 2,614.10 444995 VISION Vision Service Plan 03/04/2024 0.00 1,313.55 444996 ATTClets A T & T Corp 03/07/2024 0.00 85.80
444997 AMATJoy Joyce Amatuzzo 03/07/2024 0.00 35.37
444998 AMAZON Amazon Capital Services, Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 1,577.86 444999 AXELLIAN Axelliant LLC 03/07/2024 0.00 335.32
445000 BLUEST Blue Star Gas Associates 03/07/2024 0.00 7,243.79 445001 BORGSEP Joey Borges 03/07/2024 0.00 4,240.00
445002 CURRYE Brad Coleman Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 216.50
445003 CRENNE C Renner Petroleum Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 3,407.86 445004 CAMPTO Campton Electric Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 172.00 445005 CARAHSOF Carahsoft Technology Corporation 03/07/2024 0.00 14.99 445006 CAREYK Kevin Carey 03/07/2024 0.00 328.00
445007 CCDNCH Cc-Dn Chamber Of Commerce 03/07/2024 0.00 585.00 445008 CELLEB Cellebrite Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 19,376.75
445009 CHARTEC Charter Communications 03/07/2024 0.00 123.63 445010 ROTORO Curry Transfer & Recycling Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 4,274.50 445011 DEFORGEB Ben DeForge 03/07/2024 0.00 200.00
445012 DUCKSUNL Del Cur Ducks Unlimited 03/07/2024 0.00 575.00 445013 DNSOLI County of Del Norte 03/07/2024 0.00 2,064.08 445014 DNHS Del Norte High School 03/07/2024 0.00 75.00 445015 DELLMA Dell Marketing LP 03/07/2024 0.00 2,629.54 445016 DIETRAnn Annette Dietrick 03/07/2024 0.00 293.00 445017 DISH Dish Network LLC 03/07/2024 0.00 838.38
445018 DURAJul Julie Durand 03/07/2024 0.00 106.00
445019 DURHAMD David Durham 03/07/2024 0.00 6,566.39
445020 EFFDEL Efficiency Delivery LLC 03/07/2024 0.00 30.00 445021 ENGLUN Englund Marine Supply Co. 03/07/2024 0.00 2,235.41 445022 EUREKAH Eureka Humboldt Fire Extinguisher Co Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 227.25 445023 FAIRJay Jay Fair 03/07/2024 0.00 5.72
AP Checks by Date - Summary by Check Number (3/14/2024 9:06 AM) Page 1 Check No Vendor No Vendor Name Check Date Void Checks Check Amount 445024 FASTENAL Fastenal Company 03/07/2024 0.00 321.08 445025 FIRSTBap First Baptist Church 03/07/2024 0.00 75.00 445026 VERIZO2 Frontier California Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 943.83 445027 NAPA GDMI ENT INC 03/07/2024 0.00 2,169.05
445028 GEORGE George Petty Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 86.18
445029 GRAING Grainger 03/07/2024 0.00 944.61
445030 GREENWOR GreenWorks, P.C. 03/07/2024 0.00 200,394.78 445031 HAMWSG Hambro WSG Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 10,900.78
445032 USABLUEB HD Supply, Inc. 03/07/2024 0.00 396.92
445033 HEMMIN Hemmingsen Contracting Co Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 627.85 445034 INDEPE Independent Business Forms, Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 182.83 445035 INDUSTE Industrial Electric Arcata Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 4,033.82 445036 FIREAPP Kalmikov Enterprises, Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 11,947.49 445037 KangTo Todd Kangiser 03/07/2024 0.00 47.70
445038 BICOASTA KPOD, LLC. 03/07/2024 0.00 440.00
445039 LNCURT L.N. Curtis & Sons 03/07/2024 0.00 10,277.80 445040 LESSCH Les Schwab Tire Centers of California Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 50.99 445041 LEXISNEX LexisNexis Risk Data Management Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 200.00 445042 THRIFT Malcolm Kelly Inc. 03/07/2024 0.00 657.75 445043 MEYERSPO Meyers Police K-9 Training, LLC 03/07/2024 0.00 7,323.75 445044 MINGZhan Zhang Mingyu 03/07/2024 0.00 40.00
445045 MISSIO Mission Linen Supply 03/07/2024 0.00 438.62 445046 MORJON Mor-Jon Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 4.06
445047 MYCOMM My-Comm., Inc. 03/07/2024 0.00 1,658.50
445048 NCAGLOV NCG Safety Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 251.34
445049 NCCENT NCL of Wisconsin Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 225.33 445050 NCLAB Microbac Laboratories, Inc. 03/07/2024 0.00 345.00 445051 NCRCT North Coast Rape Crisis Team 03/07/2024 0.00 21,073.02 445052 NORTHR Northridge Electric LLC 03/07/2024 0.00 10,982.80 445053 HUMPES Northwest Property Services Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 164.00 445054 OFFICEDE Office Depot 03/07/2024 0.00 97.01
445055 FRANKO Orca Heating & Refrigeration Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 240.75 445056 OREILLY O'Reilly Auto Enterprises LLC 03/07/2024 0.00 653.80 445057 OTIS E Otis Elevator Company Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 376.85 445058 OWENEQ Owen Equipment Sales 03/07/2024 0.00 92.99 445059 MENDES Pacific Packaging & Supply Co Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 1,367.84 445060 PARKWA Parkway Feed Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 40.59
445061 SUPERI Petrusha Enterprises Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 88.50 445062 PIERCYSa Sandi Piercy 03/07/2024 0.00 40.00
445063 HITECHSE Pinger Industries, Inc. 03/07/2024 0.00 359.91 445064 HASLER Quadient Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 141.19
445065 RAWLINGS Christa Rawlings 03/07/2024 0.00 376.16 445066 DNDISP Recology Del Norte 03/07/2024 0.00 1,800.46 445067 LEXISNE RELX Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 275.00
445068 CAMPSPOT Rezplot Systems, LLC 03/07/2024 0.00 689.70 445069 SPRING SBRK Finance Holdings, Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 2,451.80 445070 SHNCON SHN Consulting Engineers & Geologists Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 22,636.42 445071 SMITHMJ Kimberly D Smith 03/07/2024 0.00 1,120.00 445072 STARFISH Starfish Aquatics Institute, LLC 03/07/2024 0.00 1,859.00 445073 STATEWID Statewide Traffic Safety and Signs Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 865.16 445074 STEWPat Patti Stewart 03/07/2024 0.00 55.00
445075 DNOFFI Debra Stover 03/07/2024 0.00 47.09
445076 SUNRIDGE Sun Ridge Systems, Inc. 03/07/2024 0.00 10,039.00 445077 TALBJoc Jocelyn Talbot 03/07/2024 0.00 35.00
445078 TORRESMa Mathew Torres 03/07/2024 0.00 110.00
445079 RAYMOR UBEO West, LLC 03/07/2024 0.00 48.28
445080 UNIVAR Univar Solutions USA Inc. 03/07/2024 0.00 16,593.13 AP Checks by Date - Summary by Check Number (3/14/2024 9:06 AM) Page 2 Check No Vendor No Vendor Name Check Date Void Checks Check Amount 445081 CALCARDS US Bank Corporate Pmt Systems 03/07/2024 0.00 14,879.24 445082 VERIZO3 Verizon Wireless Services LLC 03/07/2024 0.00 4,813.16 445083 CACEHA Wiececke and Associates 03/07/2024 0.00 815.04 445084 WIERER Eric Wier 03/07/2024 0.00 295.15
445085 YEAGERD David Yeager 03/07/2024 0.00 404.34
445086 YOUNGM Michael Young 03/07/2024 0.00 1,500.00
445087 ZUMAR Zumar Industries Inc 03/07/2024 0.00 1,189.26 Report Total (111 checks): 0.00 739,206.36
AP Checks by Date - Summary by Check Number (3/14/2024 9:06 AM) Page 3 AP
2-24-24 to 3-09-24 Council
User: [email protected]
Printed: 3/14/2024 9:05:10 AM
Check Numbe Check Date Acct 1 Description Amount Selected For Void 0 3/4/2024 610-000-2187-00000 PR Batch 07111.02.2024 ER PERS Contribution 59.05 False 0 3/4/2024 610-000-2187-00000 PR Batch 07111.02.2024 EE PERS Contribution 59.59 False 0 3/4/2024 610-000-2187-00000 PR Batch 07111.02.2024 Survivor Benefit 0.93 False 0 3/4/2024 610-000-2188-00000 PR Batch 00111.02.2024 Medicare Employee Portion 5.78 False 0 3/4/2024 610-000-2188-00000 PR Batch 00111.02.2024 Medicare Employer Portion 5.78 False 0 3/4/2024 610-000-2187-00000 PR Batch 00111.02.2024 ER PERS Contribution 30.63 False 0 3/4/2024 610-000-2187-00000 PR Batch 00111.02.2024 EE PERS Contribution 30.91 False 0 2/29/2024 610-000-1510-00000 Additional Unfunded Liability Payment - Plan # 1341 54,257.00 False 0 2/29/2024 610-000-1510-00000 Additional Unfunded Liability Payment - Plan # 6984 20,743.00 False 0 3/4/2024 610-000-2185-00000 PR Batch 00001.03.2024 State Income Tax 2,650.67 False 0 3/4/2024 610-000-2185-00000 PR Batch 00011.03.2024 State Income Tax 2,085.32 False 0 3/4/2024 610-000-2188-00000 PR Batch 00001.03.2024 Medicare Employer Portion 1,550.15 False 0 3/4/2024 610-000-2188-00000 PR Batch 00011.03.2024 Medicare Employer Portion 1,246.98 False 0 3/4/2024 610-000-2188-00000 PR Batch 07111.03.2024 Medicare Employee Portion 2.49 False 0 3/4/2024 610-000-2188-00000 PR Batch 07111.03.2024 Medicare Employer Portion 2.49 False 0 3/4/2024 610-000-2189-00000 PR Batch 00001.03.2024 Federal Income Tax 9,075.30 False 0 3/4/2024 610-000-2188-00000 PR Batch 00011.03.2024 Medicare Employee Portion 1,246.98 False 0 3/4/2024 610-000-2189-00000 PR Batch 00011.03.2024 Federal Income Tax 6,697.25 False 0 3/4/2024 610-000-2188-00000 PR Batch 00001.03.2024 Medicare Employee Portion 1,550.15 False 0 3/4/2024 001-111-4125-00000 March 24 Admin Fees - Active 300.35 False 0 3/4/2024 630-111-4409-00000 March 24 Admin Fees - Retirees 36.52 False 0 3/4/2024 630-000-4125-00000 March 24 Premiums - Retirees 5,799.00 False 0 3/4/2024 610-000-2173-00000 March 24 Premiums - Active 93,860.49 False 0 3/4/2024 610-000-2187-00000 PR Batch 00001.03.2024 Service Credit Purchase 413.20 False 0 3/4/2024 610-000-2187-00000 PR Batch 00001.03.2024 ER PERS Contribution 10,292.22 False 0 3/4/2024 610-000-2187-00000 PR Batch 00011.03.2024 Survivor Benefit 23.89 False 0 3/4/2024 610-000-2187-00000 PR Batch 00001.03.2024 Survivor Benefit 34.41 False 0 3/4/2024 610-000-2187-00000 PR Batch 00001.03.2024 EE PERS Contribution 8,010.58 False 0 3/4/2024 610-000-2187-00000 PR Batch 00011.03.2024 EE PERS Contribution 7,472.70 False 0 3/4/2024 610-000-2187-00000 PR Batch 00011.03.2024 ER PERS Contribution 9,497.73 False 444982 2/28/2024 153-485-4796-20BAP Business Assistance Program - Direct Financing & Underwriting 50,000.00 False 444982 2/28/2024 153-485-4796-20BAP Business Assistance Program - Direct Financing 7/23-12/23 2,950.00 False 444983 3/4/2024 001-230-4125-00000 Pro-rated Air Med Services - Fire 71.00 False AP - 2-24-24 to 3-09-24 Council (3/14/2024) Page 1 of 20 Check Numbe Check Date Acct 1 Description Amount Selected For Void 444984 3/4/2024 610-000-2174-00000 March 24 Premiums - Acct # Q9377 1,512.66 False 444985 3/4/2024 610-000-2177-00000 March 24 Premiums - Acct # 010-21636 00001 5,564.16 False 444986 3/4/2024 610-000-2179-00000 March 24 Premiums 384.00 False 444987 3/4/2024 610-000-2184-00000 PR Batch 00001.03.2024 CCEA Monthly Dues 60.00 False 444987 3/4/2024 610-000-2184-00000 PR Batch 00011.03.2024 CCEA Monthly Dues 10.00 False 444988 3/4/2024 610-000-2181-00000 PR Batch 00011.03.2024 CCPOA Dues 650.00 False 444989 3/4/2024 610-000-2180-00000 Pro-rated Ambulance Services - PW 30.00 False 444989 3/4/2024 001-230-4125-00000 Pro-rated Ambulance Services - Fire 30.00 False 444990 3/4/2024 508-508-4407-00000 Pre-employment Health screening - PW 99.00 False 444990 3/4/2024 001-480-4407-00000 Pre-employment Health screening - PW 1.00 False 444991 3/4/2024 610-000-2186-00000 Plan # 306752 2.23 False 444991 3/4/2024 610-000-2178-00000 Plan # 300878 1,100.00 False 444991 3/4/2024 610-000-2186-00000 Plan # 306752 36.12 False 444991 3/4/2024 610-000-2178-00000 Plan # 300878 2,215.00 False 444991 3/4/2024 610-000-2186-00000 Plan # 306752 172.29 False 444991 3/4/2024 610-000-2186-00000 Plan # 306752 794.70 False 444991 3/4/2024 610-000-2178-00000 Plan # 300878 476.39 False 444991 3/4/2024 610-000-2186-00000 Plan # 306752 10.64 False 444991 3/4/2024 610-000-2186-00000 Plan # 306752 166.64 False 444992 3/4/2024 610-000-2179-00000 Feb 24 Premiums - Acct # 1010024 136.50 False 444993 3/4/2024 630-111-4409-00000 Dec 23 Fees 300.00 False 444994 3/4/2024 610-000-2179-00000 March 24 Premiums - Policy # 00 639849 0001 2,614.10 False 444995 3/4/2024 610-000-2175-00000 March 24 Premiums 1,313.55 False 444996 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 Clets Line Maintenance - 104.55 False 444996 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 Clets Line Maintenance - -18.75 False 444997 3/7/2024 001-000-3221-00000 Early Cancellation - Conf # 5261 3.22 False 444997 3/7/2024 412-000-3570-00000 Early Cancellation - Conf # 5261 32.15 False 444998 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Mower blade 64.90 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-111-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.73 False 444998 3/7/2024 412-100-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.65 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-350-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 1.60 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-470-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.40 False 444998 3/7/2024 419-371-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 2.65 False 444998 3/7/2024 413-130-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.43 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-364-4350-10023 Terminals 31.72 False 444998 3/7/2024 419-111-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.69 False 444998 3/7/2024 413-111-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.69 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-113-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 2.03 False 444998 3/7/2024 413-353-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.69 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-471-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.22 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-364-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.73 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-130-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.54 False 444998 3/7/2024 419-130-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.44 False AP - 2-24-24 to 3-09-24 Council (3/14/2024) Page 2 of 20 Check Numbe Check Date Acct 1 Description Amount Selected For Void 444998 3/7/2024 419-120-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 4.13 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-112-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.54 False 444998 3/7/2024 413-352-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.32 False 444998 3/7/2024 413-120-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 4.13 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-114-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 2.14 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-480-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.47 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-313-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 1.05 False 444998 3/7/2024 419-130-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.43 False 444998 3/7/2024 412-100-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.65 False 444998 3/7/2024 419-111-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.68 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-113-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 2.00 False 444998 3/7/2024 413-352-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.32 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-470-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.40 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-120-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 3.74 False 444998 3/7/2024 420-115-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 4.21 False 444998 3/7/2024 412-120-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.43 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-251-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.54 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-250-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.47 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-112-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.54 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-480-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.46 False 444998 3/7/2024 412-120-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.43 False 444998 3/7/2024 413-357-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 1.22 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-250-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.47 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-471-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.22 False 444998 3/7/2024 413-130-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.43 False 444998 3/7/2024 420-115-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 4.16 False 444998 3/7/2024 419-371-4390-00000 Toner 131.50 False
444998 3/7/2024 419-371-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 2.62 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-251-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.53 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-364-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.72 False 444998 3/7/2024 412-120-4310-00000 Clasp envelopes 15.65 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-313-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 1.04 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-111-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.71 False 444998 3/7/2024 419-120-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 4.09 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-120-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 3.69 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-130-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.54 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-350-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 1.58 False 444998 3/7/2024 413-353-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.68 False 444998 3/7/2024 413-357-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 1.23 False 444998 3/7/2024 413-111-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 0.68 False 444998 3/7/2024 413-120-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 4.09 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-114-4310-00000 CH Office Supplies 2.11 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-480-4390-00000 Contact paper, pom poms, misc swim camp supplies 213.55 False AP - 2-24-24 to 3-09-24 Council (3/14/2024) Page 3 of 20 Check Numbe Check Date Acct 1 Description Amount Selected For Void 444998 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Connector 46.52 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-480-4390-00000 Easter egg ornament supplies 6.47 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-480-4390-00000 Charger 15.14 False
444998 3/7/2024 001-480-4390-00000 Keyless door lock 151.54 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-480-4390-2020S Brackets 268.54 False 444998 3/7/2024 001-240-4390-00000 Nitrile gloves 331.20 False 444999 3/7/2024 420-115-4450-00000 Microsoft Office Membership - 2/13-12/28/24 167.66 False 444999 3/7/2024 420-000-1510-00000 Microsoft Office Membership - 2/13-12/28/24 167.66 False 445000 3/7/2024 001-471-4220-00000 Propane FY24 - 01/15-02/15/24 - Acct # 02-0065468 16.36 False 445000 3/7/2024 001-112-4210-00000 Propane FY24 - 01/15-02/15/24 - Acct # 02-1031563 482.24 False 445000 3/7/2024 001-480-4220-2020S Propane FY24 - 01/15-02/15/24 - Acct # 02-0065442 6,726.83 False 445000 3/7/2024 001-240-4220-00000 Propane FY24 - Finance Charge - Acct # 02-1038315 2.00 False 445000 3/7/2024 001-240-4220-00000 Propane FY24 - 01/15-02/15/24 - Acct # 02-1038315 16.36 False 445001 3/7/2024 413-356-4450-35022 Emergency lift station pumpin in Dec and Jan - Vacuum Trailer 1,350.00 False 445001 3/7/2024 413-356-4450-35022 Emergency lift station pumpin in Dec and Jan - Vacuum trailer 2,475.00 False 445001 3/7/2024 901-364-4799-PBL24 Demo and transport road/concrete 415.00 False 445002 3/7/2024 001-470-4390-00000 Chisel, archer, sharpener 69.84 False 445002 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Air filter 15.70 False 445002 3/7/2024 001-470-4390-00000 Helmet and Harness 130.96 False 445003 3/7/2024 001-240-4330-00000 Fuel for Patrol Cars - Feb 2024 - Acct # 0215111 2,875.41 False 445003 3/7/2024 001-240-4330-00000 Fuel for Patrol Cars - Feb 2024 - Acct # 0215111 532.45 False 445004 3/7/2024 413-353-4390-00000 Connector parts 172.00 False 445006 3/7/2024 001-230-4530-00000 3/13-3/17/24 - Fire Marshal 1D, Rancho Cucamonga - meals 230.40 False 445006 3/7/2024 001-230-4530-00000 2/15-2/18/24 Fire Marshal 1C Rancho Cucamonga - per diem-FINAL 97.60 False 445007 3/7/2024 001-240-4530-00000 Chamber annual dinner 65.00 False 445007 3/7/2024 001-110-4530-00000 Chamber annual dinner 195.00 False 445007 3/7/2024 001-113-4530-00000 Chamber annual dinner 65.00 False 445007 3/7/2024 001-111-4530-00000 Chamber annual dinner 21.66 False 445007 3/7/2024 001-112-4530-00000 Chamber annual dinner 65.00 False 445007 3/7/2024 413-111-4530-00000 Chamber annual dinner 21.66 False 445007 3/7/2024 001-120-4530-00000 Chamber annual dinner 65.00 False 445007 3/7/2024 001-350-4530-00000 Chamber annual dinner 65.00 False 445007 3/7/2024 419-111-4530-00000 Chamber annual dinner 21.68 False 445008 3/7/2024 001-240-4480-00000 Annual subscription renewal 02/08/24-02/05/25 19,376.75 False 445009 3/7/2024 001-230-4230-00000 Cable & Internet Service- 123.63 False 445010 3/7/2024 413-356-4450-35022 Lift Station Emergency Pumping - Jan 2024 - Acct# 2040-35742-006 4,274.50 False 445011 3/7/2024 413-353-4320-04320 Boot reimbursment FY 24 200.00 False 445012 3/7/2024 001-000-2230-00000 CC DEPOSIT REFUND: REF# 7960573 EVENT 02/21/24 - Ducks Unlimited 575.00 False 445013 3/7/2024 506-506-4225-00000 Solid waste disposal - Jan 24 1,147.29 False 445013 3/7/2024 001-364-4225-10025 Solid waste disposal - Jan 24 213.52 False 445013 3/7/2024 001-470-4225-00000 Solid waste disposal - Jan 24 703.27 False 445014 3/7/2024 001-000-2230-00000 CC DEPOSIT REFUND: REF# 7955784 EVENT 02/2-02/3/24 - DN HIGH 75.00 False 445015 3/7/2024 001-240-4470-00000 3 laptops for sexual assault training/investigations 2,629.54 False AP - 2-24-24 to 3-09-24 Council (3/14/2024) Page 4 of 20 Check Numbe Check Date Acct 1 Description Amount Selected For Void 445016 3/7/2024 412-000-3570-00000 Cancellation with 72 hours notice - Conf # 5741 266.36 False 445016 3/7/2024 001-000-3221-00000 Cancellation with 72 hours notice - Conf # 5741 26.64 False 445017 3/7/2024 412-100-4230-00000 Satelitte TV CREDIT - 09/25-10/24/23 Overpayment per Dish Netwk -110.75 False 445017 3/7/2024 412-100-4230-00000 Satelitte TV Service - 02/25-03/24 949.13 False 445018 3/7/2024 412-000-3570-00000 Cancellation with 72 hours notice - Conf # 5747 96.36 False 445018 3/7/2024 001-000-3221-00000 Cancellation with 72 hours notice - Conf # 5747 9.64 False 445019 3/7/2024 506-506-4450-00000 Installation of concrete pedistals around 4 columns at the corp 6,566.39 False 445020 3/7/2024 413-352-4470-00000 Sample delivery to North Coast Labs for WW & DW FY24 30.00 False 445021 3/7/2024 001-364-4390-10025 Bib, Jacket, Seal tube 93.74 False 445021 3/7/2024 001-470-4390-00000 Bib, Jacket, Seal tube 93.74 False 445021 3/7/2024 419-371-4390-00000 Bib, Jacket, Seal tube 93.76 False 445021 3/7/2024 419-371-4390-00000 Bib, Jacket, Boot 144.03 False 445021 3/7/2024 413-353-4390-00000 Bib, Jacket, Boot 144.03 False 445021 3/7/2024 419-371-4390-00000 Water system report 193.62 False 445021 3/7/2024 001-364-4390-10025 Bib, Jacket, Boot 144.04 False 445021 3/7/2024 419-371-4390-00000 Hoses for #46 109.64 False 445021 3/7/2024 413-353-4390-00000 Hoses for #46 109.64 False 445021 3/7/2024 413-356-4390-35022 Ball Valve & Fittings 63.22 False 445021 3/7/2024 413-356-4390-35022 Fittings 517.78 False 445021 3/7/2024 413-356-4390-35022 Fittings 517.78 False 445021 3/7/2024 413-353-4390-00000 Gasket 10.39 False
445022 3/7/2024 419-371-4450-00000 Annual Fire Extinguisher Maintenance and Certification 227.25 False 445023 3/7/2024 001-000-3221-00000 Early cancellation w/72 hours notice - Conf #5402 0.52 False 445023 3/7/2024 412-000-3570-00000 Early cancellation w/72 hours notice - Conf #5402 5.20 False 445024 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Safety/PW Supplies 53.49 False 445024 3/7/2024 001-364-4390-10025 Safety/PW Supplies 53.53 False 445024 3/7/2024 419-371-4390-00000 Safety/PW Supplies 53.52 False 445024 3/7/2024 506-506-4390-00000 Safety/PW Supplies 53.52 False 445024 3/7/2024 001-470-4390-00000 Safety/PW Supplies 53.50 False 445024 3/7/2024 413-353-4390-00000 Safety/PW Supplies 53.52 False 445025 3/7/2024 001-000-1210-00000 DEPOSIT REFUND: REF # 7958390 EVENT 2/8-2/9/24 First Baptist Chu 75.00 False 445026 3/7/2024 420-115-4230-00000 707-197-0009 monthly phone 790.00 False 445026 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 Water System Phone Bill 707-1006 - 27.88 False 445026 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 Radio to Sherriff - 28.97 False 445026 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 Water System Phone 464-2826 - 96.98 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Core - RETURN -20.57 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Brake booster 104.46 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Bushing - RETURN -18.61 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Disc pad 24.22 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Core - RETURN -23.30 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Core - RETURN -104.46 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Exit door handle 31.58 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Fluid filter 32.96 False AP - 2-24-24 to 3-09-24 Council (3/14/2024) Page 5 of 20 Check Numbe Check Date Acct 1 Description Amount Selected For Void 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Bay box 422.12 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Oil filter 2.18 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Fluid filter 29.81 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Oil filter 8.66 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Brake master cylinder 62.18 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Battery 61.77 False
445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-60001 Core -RETURN -9.74 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Vacuum bleeder 140.26 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Bushing 37.22 False
445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Fuel filter 46.95 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Air filter 31.57 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Shop tool 89.59 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Seal 54.67 False
445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Valves 6.18 False
445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Fuel filter 28.90 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Filter kit, fluid filter, transmission fluid 38.71 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Oil 184.52 False
445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-60003 Batteries 167.80 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Brake booster 104.46 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Filter kit, fluid filter, transmission fluid 66.36 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Vacuum pump 155.98 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Socket set 67.21 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Bay box 168.85 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Ignition coil, spark plug 15.25 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Wire set 34.00 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Spark plug 49.15 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Spark plug 6.41 False 445027 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Ignition coil 71.75 False 445028 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Wrench, bracket 25.61 False 445028 3/7/2024 419-371-4390-00000 Wrench, bracket 60.57 False 445029 3/7/2024 001-364-4350-10023 Photo Control 198.10 False 445029 3/7/2024 413-353-4390-00000 Respirator 169.18 False 445029 3/7/2024 419-371-4390-00000 Respirator 169.18 False 445029 3/7/2024 001-364-4350-10023 Din rail 100.99 False 445029 3/7/2024 419-372-4390-41028 Couplings 163.95 False 445029 3/7/2024 001-364-4350-10023 Mounting bracket 143.21 False 445030 3/7/2024 901-470-4799-47010 Beachfront Park Master Plan Design - Thru 1/31/24 75,036.28 False 445030 3/7/2024 901-470-4799-47010 Beachfront Park Master Plan Design - thru 11/30/23. 81,856.25 False 445030 3/7/2024 901-470-4799-47010 Beachfront Park Master Plan Design - Thru 10/31/23 43,502.25 False 445031 3/7/2024 413-000-1202-00000 Sludge processing 2,168.28 False 445031 3/7/2024 413-000-1202-00000 Sludge processing 2,215.42 False 445031 3/7/2024 413-000-1202-00000 Sludge processing 2,231.13 False 445031 3/7/2024 413-000-1202-00000 Sludge processing 2,185.75 False AP - 2-24-24 to 3-09-24 Council (3/14/2024) Page 6 of 20 Check Numbe Check Date Acct 1 Description Amount Selected For Void 445031 3/7/2024 413-000-1202-00000 Sludge processing 2,100.20 False 445032 3/7/2024 413-356-4390-35022 Float Switch 396.92 False 445033 3/7/2024 413-353-4390-00000 FY24 Annual Rock to fill excavations 83.70 False 445033 3/7/2024 001-364-4390-10025 FY24 Annual Rock to fill excavations 20.93 False 445033 3/7/2024 419-371-4390-00000 FY24 Annual Rock to fill excavations 502.28 False 445033 3/7/2024 001-364-4390-2020S FY24 Annual Rock to fill excavations 20.94 False 445035 3/7/2024 413-357-4450-00000 Shop labor to rewind 40HP 1200RPM motor for WWTP 4,033.82 False 445036 3/7/2024 001-230-4391-00000 Compartment door replacement #5111 - GSRMA claim #1201281 11,947.49 False 445037 3/7/2024 412-000-3570-00000 Cancellation with 72 hours notice - Conf # 5595 43.36 False 445037 3/7/2024 001-000-3221-00000 Cancellation with 72 hours notice - Conf # 5595 4.34 False 445038 3/7/2024 001-480-4430-00000 Radio ads - 02/13-02/24 137.00 False 445038 3/7/2024 412-100-4430-00000 Radio ads - 02/07-02/27 137.00 False 445038 3/7/2024 001-480-4430-00000 Radio ads - 02/15 9.00 False 445038 3/7/2024 001-112-4430-00000 Radio ads - 02/15 10.00 False 445038 3/7/2024 412-100-4430-00000 Radio ads - 02/15 10.00 False 445038 3/7/2024 001-112-4430-00000 Radio ads - 02/10-02/29 137.00 False 445039 3/7/2024 001-230-4395-2020S 5 sets of structural turnouts 10,277.80 False 445040 3/7/2024 001-240-4391-00000 Flat tire repair 50.99 False 445041 3/7/2024 001-240-4409-00000 Monthly service fee - 01/01-01/31/24 - Inv # 1455780-20240131 200.00 False 445042 3/7/2024 419-371-4390-00000 Water fittings 213.70 False 445042 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Wrench for #1 200.75 False 445042 3/7/2024 419-371-4390-00000 Water fittings 243.30 False 445043 3/7/2024 001-240-4530-2020S Monthly K9 Maintenance - K9 Koysta 350.00 False 445043 3/7/2024 001-240-4530-00000 Monthly K9 Maintenance - Kai 350.00 False 445043 3/7/2024 001-240-4380-00000 Purchase of Police K9 - Remaining balance after deposit 6,623.75 False 445044 3/7/2024 001-000-3221-00000 Cancellation with 72 hours notice - Conf # 5674 3.64 False 445044 3/7/2024 412-000-3570-00000 Cancellation with 72 hours notice - Conf # 5674 36.36 False 445045 3/7/2024 412-120-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.28 False 445045 3/7/2024 419-130-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.29 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-480-4450-00000 Laundry Service/Uniforms FY24 - Pool Mats 39.09 False 445045 3/7/2024 419-111-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.46 False 445045 3/7/2024 413-353-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.45 False 445045 3/7/2024 413-357-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.80 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-471-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.14 False 445045 3/7/2024 420-115-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 2.76 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-251-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.36 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-313-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.69 False 445045 3/7/2024 419-120-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 2.71 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-113-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 1.33 False 445045 3/7/2024 419-371-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 1.73 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-111-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.48 False 445045 3/7/2024 412-100-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.43 False 445045 3/7/2024 413-130-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.29 False AP - 2-24-24 to 3-09-24 Council (3/14/2024) Page 7 of 20 Check Numbe Check Date Acct 1 Description Amount Selected For Void 445045 3/7/2024 413-120-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 2.71 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-114-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 1.40 False 445045 3/7/2024 413-111-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.45 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-250-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.31 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-350-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 1.04 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-120-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 2.45 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-364-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.48 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-130-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.36 False 445045 3/7/2024 413-352-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.22 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-112-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.36 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-470-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.26 False 445045 3/7/2024 413-351-4320-00000 Laundry Service/Uniforms FY24 16.46 False 445045 3/7/2024 413-353-4320-00000 Laundry Service/Uniforms FY24 23.84 False 445045 3/7/2024 508-508-4320-00000 Laundry Service/Uniforms FY24 44.09 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-480-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.30 False 445045 3/7/2024 413-351-4320-00000 Laundry Service/Uniforms FY24 16.46 False 445045 3/7/2024 413-353-4320-00000 Laundry Service/Uniforms FY24 34.16 False 445045 3/7/2024 508-508-4320-00000 Laundry Service/Uniforms FY24 47.32 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-480-4450-00000 Laundry Service/Uniforms FY24 39.09 False 445045 3/7/2024 413-111-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.45 False 445045 3/7/2024 413-357-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.80 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-350-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 1.04 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-471-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.14 False 445045 3/7/2024 413-353-4320-00000 Laundry Service/Uniforms FY24 23.85 False 445045 3/7/2024 413-351-4320-00000 Laundry Service/Uniforms FY24 23.53 False 445045 3/7/2024 508-508-4320-00000 Laundry Service/Uniforms FY24 44.08 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-480-4450-00000 Laundry Service/Uniforms FY24 - Pool Mats 39.09 False 445045 3/7/2024 419-111-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.46 False 445045 3/7/2024 413-120-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 2.71 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-250-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.31 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-480-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.30 False 445045 3/7/2024 413-352-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.22 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-313-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.69 False 445045 3/7/2024 412-100-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.43 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-112-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.36 False 445045 3/7/2024 419-371-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 1.73 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-120-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 2.45 False 445045 3/7/2024 419-120-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 2.71 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-251-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.36 False 445045 3/7/2024 420-115-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 2.76 False 445045 3/7/2024 412-120-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.28 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-111-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.48 False 445045 3/7/2024 413-353-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.45 False AP - 2-24-24 to 3-09-24 Council (3/14/2024) Page 8 of 20 Check Numbe Check Date Acct 1 Description Amount Selected For Void 445045 3/7/2024 001-364-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.48 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-470-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.26 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-114-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 1.40 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-130-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.36 False 445045 3/7/2024 001-113-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 1.33 False 445045 3/7/2024 413-130-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.29 False 445045 3/7/2024 419-130-4370-00000 City Hall Mats 0.29 False 445046 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-60003 Air king 4.06 False
445047 3/7/2024 940-240-4930-2020S 2 - mobile radios for new patrol vehicles 1,658.50 False 445048 3/7/2024 001-364-4390-10025 Gloves 62.83 False
445048 3/7/2024 419-371-4390-00000 Gloves 62.83 False
445048 3/7/2024 001-470-4390-00000 Gloves 62.85 False
445048 3/7/2024 413-353-4390-00000 Gloves 62.83 False
445049 3/7/2024 413-351-4390-00000 ACS Chemicals, Reagents, equipment, and misc supplies FY24 120.70 False 445049 3/7/2024 413-351-4390-00000 ACS Chemicals, Reagents, equipment, and misc supplies FY24 104.63 False 445050 3/7/2024 413-352-4470-00000 External testing for WWTP FY24 285.00 False 445050 3/7/2024 413-351-4685-00000 External regulatory lab tests for CCWQL & pretreat reimb 60.00 False 445051 3/7/2024 153-485-4796-20rcp 20-CDBG-12011 Sexual Assault Services - 10/1-12/31/23 11,727.77 False 445051 3/7/2024 153-485-4796-20rcp 20-CDBG-12011 Sexual Assault Services - 01/01-02/29/24 9,345.25 False 445052 3/7/2024 001-364-4409-2020S Pedestal mount service entrance at Price & Mason Mall 10,982.80 False 445053 3/7/2024 506-506-4450-00000 Pest service 82.00 False 445053 3/7/2024 506-506-4450-00000 Pest service 82.00 False 445055 3/7/2024 506-506-4450-00000 Furnace repair headstart 240.75 False 445056 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Throttle body 319.50 False 445056 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Brake hoses 44.08 False 445056 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Coolant Hose #75 13.95 False 445056 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Air filter for #75 13.11 False 445056 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Brake fluid 34.63 False 445056 3/7/2024 001-240-4391-00000 Mini bulb - Unit #58 9.45 False 445056 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Hose clamp 7.47 False 445056 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Bracketed Caliber - RETURN -99.87 False 445056 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Bracketed caliber 186.47 False 445056 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Core - RETURN -18.94 False 445056 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Rocker switch 18.38 False 445056 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Fuel injector, gasket, manifold 111.51 False 445056 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Connector 14.06 False 445057 3/7/2024 001-471-4450-00000 FY24 Elevator Maintenance - 3/1-3/31/24 376.85 False 445058 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Draw bar 92.99 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-350-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 15.71 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-480-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 13.78 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-111-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.55 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-470-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 62.01 False 445059 3/7/2024 508-508-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 6.89 False AP - 2-24-24 to 3-09-24 Council (3/14/2024) Page 9 of 20 Check Numbe Check Date Acct 1 Description Amount Selected For Void 445059 3/7/2024 413-352-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 5.51 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-471-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 5.52 False 445059 3/7/2024 412-100-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 5.51 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-120-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 2.20 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-251-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.28 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-114-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.55 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-240-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 5.51 False 445059 3/7/2024 419-120-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.55 False 445059 3/7/2024 420-115-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.55 False 445059 3/7/2024 413-120-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.55 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-313-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.56 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-113-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.55 False 445059 3/7/2024 506-506-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 5.51 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-480-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide -31.93 False 445059 3/7/2024 419-120-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide -1.28 False 445059 3/7/2024 412-100-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide -12.77 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-471-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide -12.77 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-120-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide -5.11 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-111-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide -1.28 False 445059 3/7/2024 413-352-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide -12.77 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-251-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide -0.64 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-313-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide -1.28 False 445059 3/7/2024 413-120-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide -1.28 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-240-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide -12.77 False 445059 3/7/2024 506-506-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide -12.78 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-350-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide -36.40 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-113-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide -1.28 False 445059 3/7/2024 420-115-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide -1.28 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-114-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide -1.27 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-470-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide -143.69 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-251-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.27 False 445059 3/7/2024 420-115-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.53 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-350-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 15.14 False 445059 3/7/2024 413-120-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.53 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-113-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.53 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-111-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.53 False 445059 3/7/2024 506-506-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 5.31 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-240-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 5.31 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-120-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 2.12 False 445059 3/7/2024 508-508-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 6.64 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-313-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.54 False 445059 3/7/2024 508-508-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide -15.97 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-480-4370-00000 Janitorial supplies 910.36 False AP - 2-24-24 to 3-09-24 Council (3/14/2024) Page 10 of 20 Check Numbe Check Date Acct 1 Description Amount Selected For Void 445059 3/7/2024 001-470-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 59.76 False 445059 3/7/2024 419-120-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.53 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-114-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.53 False 445059 3/7/2024 412-100-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 5.31 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-480-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 13.28 False 445059 3/7/2024 413-352-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 5.31 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-471-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 5.32 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-480-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide - Pool 355.62 False 445059 3/7/2024 506-506-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 5.94 False 445059 3/7/2024 413-352-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 5.94 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-114-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.59 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-120-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 2.38 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-470-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 66.83 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-350-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 16.93 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-240-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 5.94 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-480-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 14.85 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-313-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.59 False 445059 3/7/2024 419-120-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.59 False 445059 3/7/2024 508-508-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 7.43 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-113-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.59 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-111-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.59 False 445059 3/7/2024 412-100-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 5.95 False 445059 3/7/2024 420-115-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.60 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-471-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 5.95 False 445059 3/7/2024 413-120-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.60 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-251-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.29 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-111-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.01 False 445059 3/7/2024 508-508-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.11 False 445059 3/7/2024 506-506-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.09 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-470-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.93 False 445059 3/7/2024 419-120-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.01 False 445059 3/7/2024 420-115-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.01 False 445059 3/7/2024 412-100-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.08 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-240-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.08 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-471-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.08 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-251-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.01 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-313-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.01 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-480-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.21 False 445059 3/7/2024 413-120-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.01 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-350-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.23 False 445059 3/7/2024 413-352-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.08 False 445059 3/7/2024 001-120-4370-00000 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.03 False 445060 3/7/2024 001-240-4380-2020S Dog Food - Kostya 40.59 False AP - 2-24-24 to 3-09-24 Council (3/14/2024) Page 11 of 20 Check Numbe Check Date Acct 1 Description Amount Selected For Void 445061 3/7/2024 001-480-4230-00000 Commercial Fire Monitoring - 03/01-05/31/24 88.50 False 445062 3/7/2024 001-000-3221-00000 Cancellation with less than 72 hours notice - Conf # 5478 3.64 False 445062 3/7/2024 412-000-3570-00000 Cancellation with less than 72 hours notice - Conf # 5478 36.36 False 445063 3/7/2024 001-240-4450-00000 Monthly Alarm Monitoring - April-June 119.97 False 445063 3/7/2024 412-100-4409-00000 Monthly Alarm Monitoring - April-June 119.97 False 445063 3/7/2024 413-351-4450-00000 Monthly Alarm Monitoring - April-June 119.97 False 445064 3/7/2024 419-120-4240-00000 Meter Rental - 11/01/23-01/31/24 35.30 False 445064 3/7/2024 413-120-4240-00000 Meter Rental - 11/01/23-01/31/24 35.30 False 445064 3/7/2024 001-120-4240-00000 Meter Rental - 11/01/23-01/31/24 70.59 False 445065 3/7/2024 419-120-4530-00000 1/29-2/4/24 - Anaheim, CA - CSMFO Conf- FINAL 92.06 False 445065 3/7/2024 001-120-4530-00000 1/29-2/4/24 - Anaheim, CA - CSMFO Conf- FINAL 92.05 False 445065 3/7/2024 413-120-4530-00000 1/29-2/4/24 - Anaheim, CA - CSMFO Conf- FINAL 92.05 False 445065 3/7/2024 001-114-4390-00000 Safety Committee Boot reimbursement 100.00 False 445066 3/7/2024 412-100-4225-00000 FY23/24 Refuse services for Lighthouse Acct# 200265009 - Feb 24 1,800.46 False 445067 3/7/2024 001-130-4550-00000 Legal support - 01/01-01/31/24 137.50 False 445067 3/7/2024 413-130-4550-00000 Legal support - 01/01-01/31/24 68.75 False 445067 3/7/2024 419-130-4550-00000 Legal support - 01/01-01/31/24 68.75 False 445068 3/7/2024 412-100-4409-00000 Campspot billing for FY23/24 - 2/1-2/29/24 689.70 False 445069 3/7/2024 419-120-4415-00000 Online & IVR UB Payment Service - Feb 2024 1,225.90 False 445069 3/7/2024 413-120-4415-00000 Online & IVR UB Payment Service - Feb 2024 1,225.90 False 445070 3/7/2024 901-240-4799-2020S Police Department GeoTech - Thru 1/31/24 22,636.42 False 445071 3/7/2024 001-114-4409-00000 Safety Training Services- Bloodborne Pathogens 100.00 False 445071 3/7/2024 001-114-4409-00000 Safety Training Services - Jan 2024 1,020.00 False 445072 3/7/2024 001-480-4409-00000 Annual membership fees 2024 1,859.00 False 445073 3/7/2024 001-364-4390-10025 Pavement Striping Paint - Order #09010675 Job #003 865.16 False 445074 3/7/2024 412-000-3570-00000 Early cancellation w/72 hours notice - Conf #5240 50.00 False 445074 3/7/2024 001-000-3221-00000 Early cancellation w/72 hours notice - Conf # 5240 5.00 False 445076 3/7/2024 001-240-4480-00000 Sun Ridge RMS, Records Management System - 2/8/23-2/9/24 10,039.00 False 445077 3/7/2024 001-480-3716-00000 Cancelled private lesson 35.00 False 445078 3/7/2024 412-000-3570-00000 Cancellation - Conf # 5429 100.00 False 445078 3/7/2024 001-000-3221-00000 Cancellation - Conf # 5429 10.00 False 445079 3/7/2024 001-240-4450-00000 Monthly copier maintenance - 03/01-03/31/24 48.28 False 445080 3/7/2024 419-371-4340-00000 FY24 Sodium Hypochlorite 2,097.98 False 445080 3/7/2024 001-480-4340-00000 FY24 Sodium Hypochlorite 190.73 False 445080 3/7/2024 413-000-1202-00000 FY24 Sodium Hypochlorite 6,103.22 False 445080 3/7/2024 419-371-4340-00000 FY24 Sodium Hypochlorite 762.90 False 445080 3/7/2024 413-000-1202-00000 FY24 Sodium Hypochlorite - Reimbursed 7,438.30 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-240-4390-00000 COPS PLUS: Evidence supplies 90.67 False 445081 3/7/2024 413-356-4390-35022 ALLIED ELECTRONICS: Surge protection device 339.09 False 445081 3/7/2024 420-115-4550-00000 APPLE: iCloud Data Transfer 0.99 False 445081 3/7/2024 420-115-4550-00000 SPAM HERO: Spam filter 10.00 False 445081 3/7/2024 413-120-4530-00000 PRCLN BST WEST:2/19-2/22/24 CalPers Training Sacramento-K. Bates 134.66 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-364-4530-10025 LGE CITIES: 3/12-3/16- Lge Cities PW Conf-Monterey- D. Yeager 241.67 False AP - 2-24-24 to 3-09-24 Council (3/14/2024) Page 12 of 20 Check Numbe Check Date Acct 1 Description Amount Selected For Void 445081 3/7/2024 413-352-4390-00000 SAFEWAY: Ice for WWTP 5.40 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-240-4390-00000 SAFEWAY: Evidence bags 52.05 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-120-4530-00000 PRCLN BST WEST:2/19-2/22/24 CalPers Training Sacramento-K. Bates 134.66 False 445081 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 PARTS GEEK: Brake 103.85 False 445081 3/7/2024 413-356-4390-35022 IEC SUPPLY: Switch amplifiers 576.29 False 445081 3/7/2024 420-000-1510-00000 APPLE: iCloud Data Transfer 0.99 False 445081 3/7/2024 420-000-1510-00000 APPLE: iCloud Data Transfer 0.99 False 445081 3/7/2024 420-000-1510-00000 APPLE: iCloud Data Transfer 0.99 False 445081 3/7/2024 413-000-2122-00000 IEC SUPPLY: Switch amplifiers - TAX -42.60 False 445081 3/7/2024 420-000-1510-00000 APPLE: iCloud Data Transfer 0.99 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-364-4530-10025 PORTOLA: 3/12-3/16 - L. of Cities PW Conf - Monterey- D. Yeager 467.62 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-230-4409-00000 FIRE PROGRAMS: Fire archives 237.00 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-230-4530-00000 HERTZ: 2/15-2/18/24 Fire Marshal 1C Rancho Cucamonga - Carey 254.82 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-240-4530-00000 FOX VALLEY4/15-4/19 - Msng Persons Conf - Las Vegas - R. Griffin 12.54 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-240-4240-00000 MAIL ROOM: DNA Sample postage 23.84 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-240-4390-00000 CRYSTAL SPRINGS: Water for station 20.00 False 445081 3/7/2024 420-000-1510-00000 APPLE: iCloud Data Transfer 0.99 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-350-4409-00000 BLUEBEAM: Computer software for pw 240.00 False 445081 3/7/2024 419-372-4390-00000 MFG EDGE PUMP: Berkeley pump 235.96 False 445081 3/7/2024 413-356-4390-35022 SANTA CLARA SYSTEMS: Relays 269.98 False 445081 3/7/2024 419-371-4530-00000 PORTOLA: 3/12-3/16 - L. of Cities PW Conf - Monterey- D. Yeager 467.61 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-240-4530-00000 7-11: 1/22-1/26 - ICAC Trng - Central Point, OR - R. Griffin 62.50 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-230-4530-00000 CONTOUR: 2/15-2/18/24 Fire Marshal 1C Rancho Cucamonga - Carey 248.00 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-240-4530-00000 FOX VALLEY4/15-4/19 - Msng Persons Conf - Las Vegas - R. Griffin 425.00 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-240-4530-00000 ROMO GAS: 1/21-1/27/24 - ICI S. Assault Training McClellan, CA 25.05 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-000-2122-00000 CEDARBROOK SAUNA: Grab bars - TAX -6.60 False 445081 3/7/2024 413-352-4240-00000 MAIL ROOM: Shipping for WWTP Tests 112.17 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-230-4395-2020S CONWAY SHIELD: 30 shields for helmets 2,315.48 False 445081 3/7/2024 419-120-4530-00000 PRCLN BST WEST:2/19-2/22/24 CalPers Training Sacramento-K. Bates 134.66 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-480-4390-2020S POOL SUPPLY: Raypak flow sensor 78.40 False 445081 3/7/2024 419-371-4530-00000 LGE CITIES: 3/12-3/16- Lge Cities PW Conf-Monterey- D. Yeager 241.66 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-240-4530-00000 CHEVRON: 1/21-1/27/24 - ICI S. Assault Training - McClellan, CA 41.96 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-240-4320-00000 LA POLICE GEAR: Jackets 314.66 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-000-2122-00000 ALASKAN COPPER: Tsunami Fountain Bronze Stock - TAX -105.52 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-240-4530-00000 HAMP INN: 1/21-1/27/24 - ICI S. Assault Training-McClellan, CA 1,069.20 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-112-4390-00000 MAIL ROOM: Flower basket shipping 413.65 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-000-2122-00000 COPS PLUS: Evidence supplies - TAX -17.04 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-240-4312-00000 DRI CRUCIAL: Upgraded RAM for forensic computer 269.51 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-240-4390-00000 COPS PLUS: Evidence supplies 230.50 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-470-4390-00000 ALASKAN COPPER: Tsunami Fountain Bronze Stock 1,475.13 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-240-4530-00000 CHEVRON: 1/21-1/27/24 - ICI S. Assault Training - McClellan, CA 48.63 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-230-4530-00000 HERTZ: 2/15-2/18/24 Fire Marshal 1C Rancho Cucamonga - Carey 2.02 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-240-4530-00000 LLRMI: Dark Web Training 175.00 False AP - 2-24-24 to 3-09-24 Council (3/14/2024) Page 13 of 20 Check Numbe Check Date Acct 1 Description Amount Selected For Void 445081 3/7/2024 413-353-4530-00000 LGE CITIES: 3/12-3/16- Lge Cities PW Conf-Monterey- D. Yeager 241.67 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-240-4530-00000 HOLIDAY INN : 1/22-1/26 - ICAC Trng - Central Point, OR- Griffin 475.40 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-230-4530-00000 SOUTHWEST: 2/15-2/18/24 Fire Marshal 1C Rancho Cucamonga - Carey 389.96 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-230-4530-00000 ARCO: 1/18-1/22/24 - Rancho Cucomonga Fire Marshal 1A Trng-Carey 19.49 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-480-4390-2020S HOME DEPOT: Post base anchors 48.68 False 445081 3/7/2024 420-000-1510-00000 APPLE: iCloud Data Transfer 0.99 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-230-4530-00000 ARCO: 2/2-2/5/24- Rancho Cuco Fire Marshal 1B Training-Care 22.25 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-000-2122-00000 CONWAY SHIELD: 30 shields for helmets - TAX -176.47 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-000-2122-00000 COPS PLUS: Evidence supplies- TAX -6.91 False 445081 3/7/2024 413-353-4530-00000 PORTOLA: 3/12-3/16 - L. of Cities PW Conf - Monterey- D. Yeager 467.61 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-230-4530-00000 SHELL: 2/15-2/18/24 Fire Marshal 1C Rancho Cucamonga - Carey 14.00 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-000-2122-00000 COPS PLUS: Evidence supplies - TAX -17.57 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-240-4530-00000 HOLIDAY INN : 1/22-1/26 - ICAC Trng - Central Point, OR- Griffin 475.40 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-230-4530-00000 BEST WEST: 2/15-2/18/24 Fire Marshal 1C Rancho Cucamonga - Carey 488.49 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-240-4390-00000 COPS PLUS: Evidence supplies 223.62 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-480-4390-2020S CEDARBROOK SAUNA: Grab bars 121.22 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-230-4530-00000 ENTERPRISE:2/2-2/5/24- Rancho Cuco Fire Marshal 1B Training-Care 117.79 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-113-4311-00000 WALMART: Frames for certificates 17.32 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-113-4240-00000 MAIL ROOM: Overnight postage for contract 55.47 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-113-4311-00000 WALMART: Frames for certificates 11.41 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-113-4450-00000 STORWELL: Physical document storage 235.00 False 445081 3/7/2024 001-113-4240-00000 MAIL ROOM: Overnight postage for deed 90.00 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-230-4230-00000 707-457-0795 (CFC) 40.01 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-364-4230-00000 707-951-4759 (Long) Service: 13.84 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-110-4230-00000 707-951-3135 (Greenough) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 707-457-0881 Dash Cam 40.01 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 707-951-0481 (Wylie) Service: 20.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 707-951-4296 (Gil-Rodgriguez) Service: 0.42 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-353-4230-00000 707-458-8283 (Hodges) Service: 2.08 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-111-4230-00000 707-951-3016 (Wier) Service: 15.51 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-353-4230-00000 707-951-0167 (WWTP Ops) Service: 28.15 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-120-4230-00000 707-951-3320 (Leaver) Service: 15.51 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-120-4230-00000 707-458-8014 (Mattix) Service: 20.77 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 707-951-5250 (Balch) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-120-4230-00000 707-458-4242 (McAndrews) Service: 8.31 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-230-4230-00000 707-951-6589 (Carey) Service: 28.15 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-120-4230-00000 707-458-4813 (Rawlings) Service: 13.84 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-251-4230-00000 707-458-5306 Rosenthal, S 16.61 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-364-4230-00000 707-951-6752 (Wylie) 5.81 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-120-4230-00000 707-458-5594 (Carpenter) Service: 9.01 False 445082 3/7/2024 508-508-4230-00000 707-951-5149 (Huffman) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-350-4230-00000 707-951-3170 (Wylie) Service: 13.84 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 707-951-4918 (McAleenan) Service: 12.04 False AP - 2-24-24 to 3-09-24 Council (3/14/2024) Page 14 of 20 Check Numbe Check Date Acct 1 Description Amount Selected For Void 445082 3/7/2024 506-506-4230-00000 707-951-0481 (Wylie) Service: 4.18 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 707-951-4116 (Amarante) Service: 25.54 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-350-4230-00000 707-951-3275 (Yeager) Service: 13.84 False 445082 3/7/2024 508-508-4230-00000 707-951-0714 (Borges, D) Service: 6.23 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-353-4230-00000 707-951-4418 (Clewell) Service: 17.02 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-120-4230-00000 707-458-5594 (Carpenter) Service: 9.30 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 707-951-4494 (Wilson) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 707-951-3170 (Wylie) Service: 13.85 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-120-4230-00000 707-458-8014 (Mattix) Service: 20.76 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-110-4230-00000 707-951-0517 (Inscore) Service: 46.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-352-4230-00000 707-951-0923 (Nova - Jacobs) Service: 38.01 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 707-458-8283 (Hodges) Service: 12.04 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 707-951-4867 (Owen) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-120-4230-00000 707-951-3320 (Leaver) Service: 15.51 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-470-4230-00000 707-458-5644 (Corcilius) : 3.30 False 445082 3/7/2024 506-506-4230-00000 707-951-0540 (Smith, K) Service: 3.80 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 707-951-4624 (Lo) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 412-100-4230-00000 707-951-4515 (Lighthouse Cove RV) Service: 46.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-353-4230-00000 707-458-8617 (Leighton) Service: 13.84 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-364-4230-00000 707-951-4116 (Amarante) Service: 3.20 False 445082 3/7/2024 506-506-4230-00000 707-951-9336 (Lovdahl) Service: 27.69 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-250-4230-00000 707-951-3447 (Minges) Service: 20.77 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-364-4230-00000 707-951-4418 (Clewell) Service: 2.08 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-480-4230-00000 707-458-8452 (Garcia) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-230-4230-00000 707-951-3406 (Duncan) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-120-4230-00000 707-951-3320 (Leaver) Service: 15.51 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 707-951-2294 (PW Callout)Service: 13.85 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 707-951-4864 (DeForge) Service: 19.52 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 707-951-0430 (Borges, D) Service: 17.87 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-230-4230-00000 707-951-3561 (Carey) Service: 38.01 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 707-457-0866 Dash Cam 40.01 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-364-4230-00000 707-951-0714 (Borges, D) Service: 9.55 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-112-4230-00000 707-458-4814 (Lacey) Service: 11.09 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-114-4230-00000 707-951-3392 (Gonzales-Valero) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-120-4230-00000 707-458-8453 (Mtr Reader SPMR1)Service: 37.50 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-480-4230-00000 707-951-0714 (Borges, D) Service: 6.23 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 707-951-5438 (PD Spare) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-353-4230-00000 707-951-4569 (Mayes) Service: 13.84 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-480-4230-00000 707-951-4364 (Young) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 707-951-4204 (Eiler) Service: 13.85 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-350-4230-00000 707-457-7454 (Leighton) Service: 13.34 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-112-4230-00000 707-458-4814 (Lacey) Service: 11.09 False 445082 3/7/2024 506-506-4230-00000 707-951-6752 (Wylie) 4.56 False AP - 2-24-24 to 3-09-24 Council (3/14/2024) Page 15 of 20 Check Numbe Check Date Acct 1 Description Amount Selected For Void 445082 3/7/2024 508-508-4230-00000 707-951-4864 (DeForge) Service: 6.23 False 445082 3/7/2024 420-115-4230-00000 707-458-8649 (Patch, T) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 508-508-4230-00000 707-951-0430 (Borges, D) Service: 5.70 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-353-4230-00000 707-951-5285 (PW Spare) Service: 13.84 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-352-4230-00000 707-951-4821 (Kuder) Service: 20.34 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-351-4230-00000 707-951-6540 (Lab-Desk) Service: 28.15 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-480-4230-00000 707-951-0430 (Borges, D) Service: 5.70 False 445082 3/7/2024 412-100-4230-00000 707-951-5029 (Lighthouse Cove RV) Service: 23.59 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 707-457-0890 Dash Cam 40.01 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 707-951-7001 (VIP Phone) Service: 1.29 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-112-4230-00000 707-458-5124 (Dudley) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 707-457-0884 Dash Cam 40.01 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-364-4230-00000 707-951-0540 (Smith, K) Service: 12.16 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 707-457-0877 Dash Cam 40.01 False 445082 3/7/2024 420-115-4230-00000 707-458-8862 (Ludemann) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-364-4230-00000 707-951-4864 (DeForge) Service: 9.55 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-353-4230-00000 707-457-7655 (PW IPad) Service: 13.34 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-350-4230-00000 707-458-8617 (Leighton) Service: 13.84 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-351-4230-00000 707-951-5017 (Lab) Service: 28.15 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-351-4230-00000 707-951-9756 (Goodgame-Thill) Service: 28.15 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 707-951-4759 (Long) Service: 13.85 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 707-951-3319 (Smith, K) Service: 13.85 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-111-4230-00000 707-951-3016 (Wier) Service: 15.51 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-364-4230-00000 707-951-4821 (Kuder) Service: 0.42 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 707-457-0867 Dash Cam 40.07 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-112-4230-00000 707-458-4814 (Lacey) Service: 19.35 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-351-4230-00000 707-951-5375 (Wood) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-351-4230-00000 707-951-6819 (Lab-Desk) Service: 28.15 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 707-951-5329 (Owen, W) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-351-4230-00000 707-951-6970 (Lab-Desk) Service: 28.15 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-352-4230-00000 707-951-5862 (LS Duty) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-353-4230-00000 707-951-0481 (Wylie) Service: 7.98 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-230-4230-00000 707-457-0714 (Buell, E) 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 707-951-5285 (PW Spare) Service: 13.85 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-120-4230-00000 707-458-5026 (Meter Reader SPMR2) Service: 37.50 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-351-4230-00000 707-951-0494 (Wood-Desk) Service: 28.15 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 707-457-0870 Dash Cam 40.01 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-364-4230-00000 707-951-0430 (Borges, D) Service: 8.74 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-352-4230-00000 707-951-0002 (WWTP Lg Conf Rm) Service: 28.15 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-130-4230-00000 707-458-8008 (Rice) Service: 10.38 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-120-4230-00000 707-458-4242 (McAndrews) Service: 16.61 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-350-4230-00000 707-457-7655 (PW IPad) Service: 13.33 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-350-4230-00000 707-951-3354 (Welton) Service: 13.84 False AP - 2-24-24 to 3-09-24 Council (3/14/2024) Page 16 of 20 Check Numbe Check Date Acct 1 Description Amount Selected For Void 445082 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 707-951-5433 (Sperling) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-120-4230-00000 707-458-5572 (Jochimsen) Service: 16.82 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 707-458-8617 (Leighton) Service: 13.85 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-480-4230-00000 707-951-4296 (Gil-Rodgriguez) Service: 4.15 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-353-4230-00000 707-951-3905 (WWTP Spare) Service: 1.29 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-351-4230-00000 707-951-3225 (Lab) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 412-100-4230-00000 707-951-9704 (Lighthouse Cove RV) Service: 28.15 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-353-4230-00000 707-951-3943 (Martinez) Service: 1.29 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-230-4230-00000 707-458-5323 - (Fire duty officers) Service: 40.01 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-470-4230-00000 707-951-4418 (Clewell) Service: 8.31 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-120-4230-00000 707-458-5572 (Jochimsen) Service: 16.82 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 707-457-0885 Dash Cam 40.01 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-353-4230-00000 707-951-3170 (Wylie) Service: 13.84 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-353-4230-00000 707-457-7454 (Leighton) Service: 13.33 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-364-4230-00000 707-951-4204 (Eiler) Service: 13.84 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-353-4230-00000 707-951-4759 (Long) Service: 13.84 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-353-4230-00000 707-951-6752 (Wylie) 8.73 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-364-4230-00000 707-951-5285 (PW Spare) Service: 13.84 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-230-4230-00000 707-457-0794 (CFC) 40.01 False 445082 3/7/2024 412-120-4230-00000 707-458-5572 (Jochimsen) Service: 2.49 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-353-4230-00000 707-951-4116 (Amarante) Service: 9.59 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-250-4230-00000 707-458-5306 Rosenthal, S 4.15 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-353-4230-00000 707-951-3319 (Smith, K) Service: 13.84 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-353-4230-00000 707-951-2294 (PW Callout)Service: 13.84 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-112-4230-00000 707-458-4131 (Taylor) Service: 11.63 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-120-4230-00000 707-458-4813 (Rawlings) Service: 13.85 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 707-951-3275 (Yeager) Service: 13.85 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-230-4230-00000 707-951-6556 (Duncan) Service: 28.15 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-110-4230-00000 707-458-5725 (Schellong) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-353-4230-00000 707-951-4918 (McAleenan) Service: 2.08 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-364-4230-00000 707-951-0481 (Wylie) Service: 5.32 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-110-4230-00000 707-951-0876 (Wright) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-364-4230-00000 707-457-0899 (Ybarra) Service: 13.84 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-230-4230-00000 707-458-5216 (Fire Dept) Service: 38.01 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-480-4230-00000 707-58-4818 (Morris) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-352-4230-00000 707-951-6831 (WWTP) Service: 22.30 False 445082 3/7/2024 412-120-4230-00000 707-458-5594 (Carpenter) Service: 1.95 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 707-951-4896 (Lopez) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-120-4230-00000 707-458-4242 (McAndrews) Service: 16.61 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 707-951-0540 (Smith, K) Service: 18.24 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-471-4230-00000 707-458-4131 (Taylor) Service: 4.65 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-470-4230-00000 707-951-4296 (Gil-Rodgriguez) Service: 14.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-352-4230-00000 707-951-4779 (WWTP Project Manager) Service: 28.15 False AP - 2-24-24 to 3-09-24 Council (3/14/2024) Page 17 of 20 Check Numbe Check Date Acct 1 Description Amount Selected For Void 445082 3/7/2024 001-470-4230-00000 707-458-8283 (Hodges) Service: 22.84 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-470-4230-00000 707-951-9336 (Lovdahl) Service: 13.84 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 707-951-4950 (Miller, E) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-470-4230-00000 707-951-4918 (McAleenan) Service: 22.84 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-352-4230-00000 707-951-0023 (WWTP Operations 2) Service: 28.15 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 707-457-0873 Dash Cam 40.01 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 707-951-4418 (Clewell) Service: 14.12 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-353-4230-00000 707-458-5644 (Corcilius) : 8.56 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-230-4230-00000 707-458-8906 (Carey) Service: 46.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 412-100-4230-00000 707-951-3285 (Cordova) Service: 46.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 508-508-4230-00000 707-458-8283 (Hodges) Service: 4.57 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 707-951-4609 (Pearson) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-353-4230-00000 707-951-0540 (Smith, K) Service: 3.81 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-364-4230-00000 707-458-5644 (Corcilius) : 3.30 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 707-951-3354 (Welton) Service: 13.85 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-364-4230-00000 707-951-2294 (PW Callout)Service: 13.84 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 707-951-4569 (Mayes) Service: 13.85 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-110-4230-00000 707-458-4323 (Altman, Ray) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 707-458-8156 (Hutchens) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 707-457-0891 Dash Cam 40.01 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 707-951-4821 (Kuder) Service: 20.77 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-353-4230-00000 707-951-4951 (PW IPAD) Service: 12.67 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-350-4230-00000 707-951-3319 (Smith, K) Service: 13.84 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 707-457-0899 (Ybarra) Service: 13.85 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-113-4230-00000 707-951-3378 (Altman, Robin) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 707-951-4485 (Griffin) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 506-506-4230-00000 707-951-4296 (Gil-Rodgriguez) Service: 19.52 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-470-4230-00000 707-458-4131 (Taylor) Service: 6.05 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 707-457-7655 (PW IPad) Service: 13.34 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-353-4230-00000 707-951-3275 (Yeager) Service: 13.84 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-352-4230-00000 707-951-6681 (WWTP) Service: 22.30 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 707-951-5088 (Valero) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-480-4230-00000 707-458-4131 (Taylor) Service: 10.24 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-130-4230-00000 707-458-8008 (Rice) Service: 20.77 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-230-4230-00000 707-457-0715 (Smith, B) 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 412-100-4230-00000 707-458-4131 (Taylor) Service: 13.96 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 707-457-7454 (Leighton) Service: 13.34 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 707-951-5035 (Sanders) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-364-4230-00000 707-951-4569 (Mayes) Service: 13.84 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-352-4230-00000 707-458-4722 (WWTP) Service: 38.01 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-470-4230-00000 707-951-4116 (Amarante) Service: 3.20 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 707-951-6752 (Wylie) 22.43 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-120-4230-00000 707-458-5572 (Jochimsen) Service: 5.40 False AP - 2-24-24 to 3-09-24 Council (3/14/2024) Page 18 of 20 Check Numbe Check Date Acct 1 Description Amount Selected For Void 445082 3/7/2024 001-364-4230-00000 707-951-4918 (McAleenan) Service: 4.57 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 707-951-4951 (PW IPAD) Service: 12.67 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-480-4230-00000 707-951-4864 (DeForge) Service: 6.23 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 707-951-0714 (Borges, D) Service: 19.52 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-120-4230-00000 707-458-4813 (Rawlings) Service: 13.84 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-353-4230-00000 707-951-3354 (Welton) Service: 13.84 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-240-4230-00000 707-458-5881 (Phillipa) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-364-4230-00000 707-951-4951 (PW IPAD) Service: 12.67 False 445082 3/7/2024 412-100-4230-00000 707-951-4296 (Gil-Rodgriguez) Service: 2.07 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-371-4230-00000 707-458-5644 (Corcilius) : 26.37 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-353-4230-00000 707-951-4204 (Eiler) Service: 13.84 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-353-4230-00000 707-457-0899 (Ybarra) Service: 13.84 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-230-4230-00000 707-464-9113 (Fire Hall) Service: 28.15 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-230-4230-00000 707-951-0671 (Borges, J) Service: 41.53 False 445082 3/7/2024 419-130-4230-00000 707-458-8008 (Rice) Service: 10.38 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-120-4230-00000 707-458-5594 (Carpenter) Service: 20.31 False 445082 3/7/2024 413-111-4230-00000 707-951-3016 (Wier) Service: 15.51 False 445082 3/7/2024 001-364-4230-00000 707-951-4296 (Gil-Rodgriguez) Service: 0.84 False 445083 3/7/2024 506-506-4390-00000 Key weiser & caps 3.29 False 445083 3/7/2024 419-371-4390-00000 Rags, fuses, key schlage 38.15 False 445083 3/7/2024 001-480-4390-00000 Rags, fuses, key schlage 64.25 False 445083 3/7/2024 001-470-4390-00000 Lumbers, deck screws, wrecking bar 170.97 False 445083 3/7/2024 001-471-4390-00000 Brass 28.24 False
445083 3/7/2024 506-506-4390-00000 Pipe insulation 43.43 False 445083 3/7/2024 419-371-4390-00000 Rags, water fittings 47.07 False 445083 3/7/2024 419-371-4390-00000 Sprayer, rubbing alcohol 27.84 False 445083 3/7/2024 508-508-4390-00000 Plumbing supplies, nozzles for #6 43.83 False 445083 3/7/2024 413-356-4390-35022 Cut rope or chain 45.14 False 445083 3/7/2024 413-356-4390-35022 Batteries 28.46 False 445083 3/7/2024 413-356-4390-35022 Pipe, elbow, adapter 9.01 False 445083 3/7/2024 413-353-4390-00000 Utility knife 24.71 False 445083 3/7/2024 506-506-4390-00000 Scraper, torch tips, blades 74.48 False 445083 3/7/2024 413-356-4390-35022 Rags, silicone, blades, knife 55.80 False 445083 3/7/2024 001-480-4390-00000 Fuse 32.12 False
445083 3/7/2024 001-470-4390-00000 Pickup tool 26.29 False 445083 3/7/2024 506-506-4390-00000 Wire, titebond 14.97 False 445083 3/7/2024 001-364-4350-10023 Caulking 26.27 False 445083 3/7/2024 506-506-4390-00000 Screws, nuts & bolts 10.72 False 445084 3/7/2024 419-111-4530-00000 02/07-02/09/24 City Manager's Conf Los Angeles, CA - FINAL 98.39 False 445084 3/7/2024 001-111-4530-00000 02/07-02/09/24 City Manager's Conf Los Angeles, CA - FINAL 98.38 False 445084 3/7/2024 413-111-4530-00000 02/07-02/09/24 City Manager's Conf Los Angeles, CA - FINAL 98.38 False 445085 3/7/2024 001-364-4530-10025 3/12-3/16/24 - League of Cities PW Conf - Monterey- gas, meals 134.78 False 445085 3/7/2024 413-353-4530-00000 3/12-3/16/24 - League of Cities PW Conf - Monterey- gas, meals 134.78 False AP - 2-24-24 to 3-09-24 Council (3/14/2024) Page 19 of 20 Check Numbe Check Date Acct 1 Description Amount Selected For Void 445085 3/7/2024 419-371-4530-00000 3/12-3/16/24 - League of Cities PW Conf - Monterey- gas, meals 134.78 False 445086 3/7/2024 001-111-4409-00000 Civil Engineering Cultural Center TO5 - April, May, June 240.00 False 445086 3/7/2024 901-364-4799-FSTGI Sewer Conflict Play and Front TO6 - April, May, June 1,260.00 False 445087 3/7/2024 901-364-4799-PBL24 Street signs for Pebble Beach Slide 1,189.26 False 738,157.28
AP - 2-24-24 to 3-09-24 Council (3/14/2024) Page 20 of 20 AP
2-24-24 to 3-09-24 Housing
User: [email protected]
Printed: 3/14/2024 9:06:00 AM
Check Date Check Number Description Amount Selected For Void 3/7/2024 445059 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide -12.77 False 3/7/2024 445059 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 0.08 False 3/7/2024 445045 City Hall Mats 0.24 False
3/7/2024 445045 City Hall Mats 0.24 False
3/7/2024 444998 CH Office Supplies 0.36 False
3/7/2024 444998 CH Office Supplies 0.36 False
3/7/2024 445082 707-458-5594 (Carpenter) Service: 0.96 False 3/7/2024 445059 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 5.31 False 3/7/2024 445059 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 5.51 False 3/7/2024 445059 Janitorial Supplies- City-Wide 5.94 False 3/7/2024 445075 Office supplies - Pocket folders 12.18 False 3/7/2024 445005 Tenant work employment verification service - 01/01-01/31/24 14.99 False 3/7/2024 445082 707-951-3447 (Minges) Service: 20.76 False 3/7/2024 445082 707-458-5306 Rosenthal, S 20.77 False
3/7/2024 445082 707-464-9216 (HA Office) Service: 22.30 False 3/7/2024 445082 707-951-0897 (Stover) Service: 28.15 False 3/7/2024 445082 707-951-0902 (Hartwick) Service: 28.15 False 3/7/2024 445082 707-951-0710 (Miller) Service: 28.15 False 3/7/2024 445082 707-951-0909 (Hurt) Service: 28.15 False 3/7/2024 445054 Office Supplies - Index w/5 month tabs 29.20 False 3/7/2024 445075 Office supplies - Fasteners 34.91 False 3/7/2024 445082 707-458-4816 (Hurt) Service: 41.53 False 3/7/2024 445082 707-458-4817 (Hartwick) Service: 41.53 False 3/7/2024 445082 707-458-5990 (Miller, M) Service: 41.53 False 3/7/2024 445082 707-485-4815 (Stover) Service: 41.53 False 3/7/2024 445081 WALMART: HAC Luncheon 45.74 False
3/7/2024 445054 Office Supplies - Paper, Binders 67.81 False 3/7/2024 445081 ITZA PIZZA: HAC Luncheon 83.61 False
3/7/2024 445034 Forms & printing - envelopes 182.83 False 3/7/2024 444998 Office Supplies- Paper towels, Smoke dector 229.03 False AP - 2-24-24 to 3-09-24 Housing (3/14/2024) Page 1 of 2 Check Date Check Number Description Amount Selected For Void 1,049.08
AP - 2-24-24 to 3-09-24 Housing (3/14/2024) Page 2 of 2 1 | P a g e
2/20/24 COUNCIL MINUTES

CITY OF CRESCENT CITY
Mayor Blake Inscore Mayor Pro Tem Ray Altman
Council Member Jason Greenough Council Member Kelly Schellong Council Member Isaiah Wright
TUESDAY FEBRUARY 20, 2024 6:00 P.M.

OPEN SESSION
Call to order Mayor Inscore called the meeting to order at 6:00 p.m.

Roll call Council Members present: Council Member Jason Greenough, Council Member Kelly Schellong, Council Member Isaiah Wright, Mayor Pro Tem Ray Altman and Mayor Blake Inscore
Staff members present: City Manager Eric Wier, City Attorney Martha Rice, City Clerk/Administrative Analyst Robin Altman, Economic Development and Recreation Director Ashley Taylor, Public Works Director Dave Yeager, Grants Coordinator Bridget Lacey (via Zoom), Fire Battalion Chief Joe Gregorio, Fire Battalion Chief Darrin Short, Fire Chief Kevin Carey, and Police Chief Richard Griffin
Pledge of Allegiance led by Mayor Inscore

CEREMONIAL ITEMS
• Police Chief Commendation - AC Field
Chief Griffin gave a background for Mr. Field where he started in the Marine Corps and then starting working at the Del Norte County Sheriff’s Office and then onto the Del Norte District Attorney’s Office. He is retiring and Chief Griffin wanted to give him credit for all of the assistance he gave CCPD as an Investigator with the DAs Office. Investigator Field expressed his thanks to the community, Chief Griffin, City Council and the City Manager. He wanted to give special thanks to his wife for being there for him throughout his career of 28 years. City Manager Wier stated that Investigator Field was one of the first people he met when he came back to Crescent City and he is steadfast and strong. As City Manager, Mr. Wier has been able to have Investigator Field’s expertise on cases. Council Member Schellong thanked Investigator Field for all of his years of service.

REPORTS AND PRESENTATIONS

1. City Marketing Update - Lynnette Braillard (LuLish) & Ashley Taylor (City Economic / Recreation Director)
Economic Development and Recreation Director Taylor announced that Lynnette Braillard of LuLish will be presenting to the Council. Ms. Braillard gave a marketing update for FY23 to date

MINUTES

REGULAR MEETING OF THE

CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT CITY

FLYNN CENTER BOARD CHAMBERS
981 H STREET
CRESCENT CITY, CA 95531
2 | P a g e
2/20/24 COUNCIL MINUTES
on the Fred Endert Municipal Pool, Lighthouse Cove RV Park as well as Economic Development.

For Lighthouse Cove RV Park a new logo was discussed. For the Fred Endert Municipal Pool, a simple modernization new design was chosen. She further reported that the Pool’s website has been up and running and the schedule will be up soon. For Economic Development, City marketing and identity branding is in progress. She presented the new logo designs to the Council for them to review. She detailed the results from the Lighthouse Cove RV Park website showing where visitors are coming from. Council Member Schellong asked if previous year vs current year is really showing a decline; Ms. Braillard stated that no, it is just the current year. She further stated that Lighthouse Cove RV is featured on the Visit Del Norte website under stay and camping sections. LuLish will also do marketing for the Kamome Festival for this year and also for the Forest Moon Festival. Marketing has also been done in the 101 Things to Do in Western & Coastal Oregon publication. Council Member Greenough stated that when he was travelling out of the area, there were billboards on the wall at Rogue Valley Airport that had advertisements for other areas, but not Crescent City. Suggested those billboards be used to market Crescent City. Ms.

Braillard stated that advertising has been sought, however there have been a lot of staff changes at Rogue Valley Airport and it didn’t come to fruition. However, through the Visitors Bureau, a marketing campaign is being done for travel through Advance Airlines.

PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD
The following residents addressed the Council:

Donna Westfall: spoke about if ratepayers are paying for expansion; there has not been a rate increase since 2007. Asked if connection fees need to be increased. Went into City Hall to view how many sewer connections from 2007 and how much it cost in total. Stated if anyone is interested in Prop 47, she has the material.

Sam Strait: stated that when government reaches a certain expense, and the public can no longer afford it. He feels that Crescent City has reached that point.

Josefina Barrantes: spoke about the Tri-Agency Economic Development Agency and how the Del Norte County Board of Supervisors have removed language from the JPA regarding wind energy. Would like the Council to adopt the same action as the Crescent City Harbor Commission which does not have the wind energy exclusion.
➢ Reports, Concerns, Referrals, Council travel and training reports – None

CONSENT CALENDAR

2. Warrant Claims List
• Recommendation: Receive and file the warrant claims list for the period January 27, 2024 through February 9, 2024.

3. Council Meeting Minutes
• Recommendation: Approve and adopt the February 5, 2024 meeting minutes of the City Council.

4. Payroll Report
• Recommendation: Receive and file the biweekly payroll reports for the period ending February 10, 2024, paid February 16, 2024.
3 | P a g e
2/20/24 COUNCIL MINUTES

5. Plan Review Services Professional Services Agreement • Recommendation: Approve and authorize the City Manager to sign the Professional Services Agreement with BPR Consulting Group, LLC for Plan Review Support Services
• Approve and adopt Resolution No. 2024-11, A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY

COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT CITY AMENDING THE FISCAL YEAR 2023-24 BUDGET OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT CITY

6. Contract Amendment to Regional Early Action Planning Grant Subaward Agreement • Recommendation: Approve and authorize the City Manager to execute the Regional Early Action Planning Grant (REAP) Subaward Agreement between the City of Crescent City and the County of Del Norte for Housing Planning Services for the period August 16, 2023 through June 30, 2024

7. Position Control Amendment Adjusting the Salary Range of the Fire Chief Position • Recommendation: Approve and adopt Resolution No. 2024-12, A RESOLUTION OF

THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT CITY AMENDING THE BUDGET AND POSITION CONTROL FOR FISCAL YEAR 2023-24

8. Community Corrections Partnership Funds
• Recommendation: Approve and adopt Resolution No. 2024-13, A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT CITY AMENDING THE FY 23- 24 BUDGET OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT CITY
Council Member Schellong asked for items 2, 5, and 7 to be pulled from the consent calendar, the Council was in consensus to pull the items. She explained she would be recusing herself from item 2, but would like items 5 and 7 to be pulled for discussion.

There were no comments from the public from items 3, 4, 6, and 8 of the consent calendar.

On a motion by Council Member Schellong, seconded by Council Member Wright and carried on a 5-0 polled vote, the City Council of the City of Crescent City adopted items 3, 4, 6, and 8 of the consent calendar as presented.

There were no comments from the public on item 2 of the consent calendar.

On a motion by Council Member Greenough, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Altman, and carried on a 4-1-0 polled vote with Council Member Schellong recusing herself, the City Council of the City of Crescent City adopted item 2 of the consent calendar as presented.

Item 5 – Council Member Schellong asked about the fees from this project and how it will assist the City; City Manager Wier stated that with the backflow of projects the City has, and City staff not having the availability to do it, this will help as it will be a two-week turnaround time and being developer friendly is very important. The fees are 70% of the building permit fees. Council Member Schellong asked if this will not be covering the developer’s plans that the City will be reviewing; City Manager Wier stated this is just for the remainder of this year. It will always be cash positive for the City.

Sam Strait: asked if there was a quick turnaround to allow developments to build and shouldn’t the public have a say so in the process; Council Member Schellong stated that this plan check service is to be quicker than how City staff can do. Mayor Inscore stated that this has already went through public hearings.
4 | P a g e
2/20/24 COUNCIL MINUTES
On a motion by Council Member Schellong, seconded by Council Member Greenough and carried on a 5-0 polled vote, the City Council of the City of Crescent City adopted item 5 of the consent calendar as presented.

Item 7 – Council Member Schellong stated that she has heard from a lot of people in the community about this item and feels it shouldn’t be on consent. Mayor Inscore asked if the Council had any questions on the staff report, there were none.

Sam Strait: stated that a lot of community members are decrying paying someone $200k a year.

He understands that not all of the money comes from the City, but that someone who makes $200k in salary and benefits would need another $40k. Stated that since there are only 25 fire calls a year and most calls are health related.

Darrin Short; Battalion Chief, Crescent City Fire and Rescue: wanted to make the point that if any of the Battalion Chief’s cannot cover the Chief’s shift, the Chief will cover it. He sleeps away from his family at the beginning of the week and his days off are still filled with dealing with firefighters.

Works on his days off, he supports this increase. Modern fire departments do not only respond to fires; and your Fire Chief has to deal with it in a legal and safe manner.

Council Member Schellong stated she was on the Fire 2x2 and that this is a big ask. She stated that Chief Carey is worth double, he has increased volunteers for the Department, and has taken steps to be a Fire Marshall. He is also a Paramedic which brings a lot of value to the City. She stated that there are 2,000 calls a year handled by a volunteer fire department with three Fire Captains. Council Member Wright stated that when his son had a medical emergency, the first people to show up were firefighters which is priceless. Council Member Greenough stated you can’t put a dollar figure on great leadership. He struggles with the change in the salary, but isn’t sure who can take his place. Mayor Pro Tem Altman stated he fully supports this change. Mayor Inscore stated that the legacy that was left behind by former Fire Chief Wakefield, it has given everyone the impression that Fire Chief’s have to respond to all calls. The fire department provides a great service in not just responding to fire calls. Mayor Inscore outlined the Fire Department 5-Year Master Plan in detail by explaining that it was created to make sure there was the best level of service for the community. He further stated that the $200k annual includes salary and benefits, not just the salary.

Sam Strait: stated he doesn’t disagree with this item, just the discrepancies in which the fire department operates. Such as the problem with dispatch putting calls out the way they should be pushed out – such as non-emergency calls being sent to the fire department.

Kevin Hawkins: stated that Fire Chief Wakefield living and breathing the fire department is no different from Chief Carey’s passion. There are going to be calls when they weren’t needed, but it’s better not to be needed than to not be sent when needed.

On a motion by Mayor Pro Tem Altman, seconded by Council Member Wright and carried unanimously on a 5-0 polled vote, the City Council of the City of Crescent City approved and adopted Resolution No. 2024-12, A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF

CRESCENT CITY AMENDING THE BUDGET AND POSITION CONTROL FOR FISCAL YEAR 2023-24

PUBLIC HEARING

9. Public Hearing to Close Out Grant 20-CDBG-12012
• Recommendation: Open public hearing
• Hear staff report
• Technical questions from the Council
5 | P a g e
2/20/24 COUNCIL MINUTES
• Receive public comment
• Further Council discussion
• Close public hearing
• Approve the final accomplishments under Community Development Block Grant contract #20-CDBG-12012; and
• Direct staff to submit final closeout documents to Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD)
Mayor Inscore opened the public hearing at 7:20 p.m.

City Manager Wier reported to the Council how many people in need the Pacific Food Pantry had served in Crescent City. During the Smith River Complex Fire, they served 707 houses with emergency food. Sarah Campbell, of Pacific Pantry thanked the City and said it was rewarding to work for this program.

There were no comments from the public.

Mayor Inscore closed the public hearing at 7:24 p.m.

On a motion by Council Member Schellong, seconded by Council Member Greenough, and carried unanimously on a 5-0 polled vote, the City Council of the City of Crescent City approved the final accomplishments under Community Development Block Grant contract #20-CDBG12012 and directed staff to submit final closeout documents to Department of Housing and Community Development.

10. Public Hearing: Application to HCD for Permanent Local Housing Allocation (PLHA) Program Funds and Adoption of the 2020-2023 PLHA Plan
• Recommendation: Open public hearing
• Hear staff report
• Technical questions from the Council
• Receive public comment
• Further Council discussion
• Close public hearing
• Discuss the 2020-2023 PLHA Plan and application
• Approve and adopt Resolution No. 2024-14, A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY

COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT CITY AUTHORIZING THE APPLICATION

AND ADOPTING OF THE PLHA PLAN FOR THE PERMANENT LOCAL HOUSING

ALLOCATION PROGRAM
Mayor Inscore opened the public hearing at 7:25 p.m.

City Manager Wier reported to the Council that housing is desperately needed in our community.

He further stated that these funds need to be used for housing. Local developers are oftentimes sought after for more housing, and if that were to happen, it would come back before the Council.

Council Member Schellong asked if these funds would be available for a developer to have business/residential units downtown. City Attorney Rice stated that yes, as long as there is a residential component, however these funds are geared more towards low-income residents at affordable housing. She stated further that you get more points with those types of development.

Council Member Schellong asked if there is going to be something other than low income as there are a lot of community members who do not qualify for the low-income, however cannot afford the higher rents. City Manager Wier stated that workforce housing will be sought as well.

Sam Strait: stated that California does not have low income or moderate housing, so is perplexed as to why this is being entertained.
6 | P a g e
2/20/24 COUNCIL MINUTES
Grants Coordinator Lacey stated that in regards to moderate income level, this program will serve up to 120% of the area median income. Not only low income is being served, but up to moderate income as well. It will be 60% area median income or below, but it doesn’t exclude the developers that are still wanting to provide for median or moderate-income levels. With mixed use with the amount provided, it will cover only two-family apartments. It will likely work with a bigger project if they only had two units that were low to moderate income. Mayor Inscore stated that this doesn’t have to be used for the next apartment complex but could potentially be used for ADUs. There are creative ways to use this fundings rather than a developer getting tax credits.

Mayor Inscore closed the public hearing at 7:34 p.m.

On a motion by Council Member Greenough, seconded by Council Member Wright, and carried unanimously on a 5-0 polled vote, the City Council of the City of Crescent City approved and adopted Resolution No. 2024-14, A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF

CRESCENT CITY AUTHORIZING THE APPLICATION AND ADOPTING OF THE PLHA PLAN

FOR THE PERMANENT LOCAL HOUSING ALLOCATION PROGRAM

CONTINUING BUSINESS

11. Public Comment Letter to Pacific Fisheries Management Council (PFMC) Regarding Groundfish Closure
• Recommendation: Hear staff report
• Technical questions from the Council
• Receive public comment
• Further Council discussion
• Approve and authorize the Mayor to sign a comment letter related to the groundfish closure and authorize the submittal to the Pacific Fisheries Management Council (PFMC) at the March 2024 meeting
• Consideration of sending a Council representative to the March PFMC meeting City Manager Wier stated that this is another opportunity for the City to speak to the groundfish closure. Commercial fishing had to cease here, but 20 miles to the north, fishing was open. The letter is asking them to look at the methodologies on how the data is collected. For the consideration of the Council to send a Council Member to the March PFMC meeting in Fresno, Supervisor Howard has been selected by the County. Council Member Schellong asked why we are sending the same letter that was sent before; City Manager Wier stated that the ask is now a little more refined. Mayor Inscore stated they made the decision before taking public comments, now everyone is lining up to give comments. Mayor Inscore stated he would be willing to go as long as public comment can be taken.

Sam Strait: asked if it was required to have a Council Member to attend as it makes more sense to have someone with the background and knowledge speak for the City.

On a motion by Council Member Schellong, seconded by Council Member Greenough, and carried unanimously on a 5-0 polled vote, the City Council of the City of Crescent City approved and authorized the Mayor to attend the March PFMC meeting, to have a presentation prepared ahead of time, in the not-to-exceed amount of $1,500 for travel and authorized the Mayor to sign a comment letter related to the groundfish closure and authorized the submittal to the Pacific Fisheries Management Council (PFMC) at the March 2024 meeting.

12. Declaring the Continuance of an Emergency Due to Continuous Slide Activity Along Pebble Beach Drive
• Recommendation: Hear staff report
7 | P a g e
2/20/24 COUNCIL MINUTES
• Technical questions from the Council
• Receive public comment
• Further Council discussion
• Declare by a 4/5 vote that there is a need to continue the emergency action for the continuous slide activity along Pebble Beach Drive between 7th and 8th Streets per Public Contract code § 22050
City Manager Wier stated this is an ongoing issue and the emergency needs to be declared on a monthly basis to secure funding. This is going to position us correctly for repairing the slide.

On a motion by Council Member Schellong, seconded by Council Member Wright, and carried unanimously on a 5-0 polled vote, the City Council of the City of Crescent City declared by a 4/5 vote that there is a need to continue the emergency action for the continuous slide activity along Pebble Beach Drive between 7th and 8th Streets per Public Contract code § 22050

NEW BUSINESS

13. 2023 CDBG Notice of Funding Availability (NOFA) Amendment #1 Application: $3.3 Million for Front Street Project (Play Street to L Street) • Recommendation: Hear staff report
• Technical questions from the Council
• Receive public comment
• Further Council discussion
• Approve and adopt Resolution No. 2024-15, A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY

COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT CITY APPROVING AN APPLICATION FOR

FUNDING AND THE EXECUTION OF A GRANT AGREEMENT AND ANY
AMENDMENTS THERETO FROM THE 2023 AND/OR 2024 FUNDING YEAR OF

THE STATE CDBG PROGRAM
• Approve and authorize the City Manager to sign the 2023 CDBG Application Certifications and Statement of Assurances
City Manager Wier gave a PowerPoint presentation that showed the different phases of the construction of Front Street. Funding was received from 2020 Storm Drain Improvement Project CDBG, Measure S/ARRA funding, then Community Funding/ CRRSAA funds. For Front Street, Play to L Street, there will be CDBG funding available for this section. The Clean California Grant will take care of pedestrian improvements. Council Member Greenough asked what is difficult with this part of the project; City Manager Wier stated that there was heavy flooding and the storm drain aspect is very important. CDBG has funding first come first serve if shovel ready, the City is eligible for this funding. City Manager Wier stated that bridge financing may be necessary; if we cannot find a loan, we would have to turn it down. Mayor Inscore asked for this to be a specific item for our Budget Workshop, specifically the matter of a bridge loan.

On a motion by Council Member Schellong, seconded by Council Member Wright, and carried unanimously on a 5-0 polled vote, the City Council of the City of Crescent City approved and adopted Resolution No. 2024-15, A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF

CRESCENT CITY APPROVING AN APPLICATION FOR FUNDING AND THE EXECUTION OF A GRANT AGREEMENT AND ANY AMENDMENTS THERETO FROM THE 2023 AND/OR 2024 FUNDING YEAR OF THE STATE CDBG PROGRAM and approved and authorized the City Manager to sign the 2023 CDBG Application Certifications and Statement of Assurances

14. Zoning Map Amendment – 1405 California Street
• Recommendation: Hear staff report
• Technical questions from the Council
8 | P a g e
2/20/24 COUNCIL MINUTES
• Receive public comment
• Further Council discussion
• Introduce, waive full reading, read by title only and introduce Ordinance No. 840, AN

ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT CITY AMENDING THE ZONING DISTRICT DESIGNATION FOR 1405 CALIFORNIA STREET AND THE CITY’S OFFICIAL ZONING MAP
SHN Contract Planner Ethan Lawton presented to the Council this particular item is before the Council from the Planning Commission. He stated that this rezoning request is for a development at 1405 California Street. This has gone through a public hearing at the Planning Commission level. He further reported that this will allow the City to meet it’s moderate housing requirement Amending the General Plan map seems to fit the need of the community which is more housing.

Council Member Schellong asked for clarification of the action being 40 units yet it is actually for 56; Planner Lawton stated that the 40 units would be Phase II. Phase I being what has already been completed, the zoning change would allow for Phase II to be built.

Kevin Hawkins: stated that the three-bedroom projected values in our area will fall into HUD category. The more of these projects that are encouraged, the lower rent will be in our community.

Mayor Inscore stated that one piece of housing is the struggle that school district has had to retain and recruit teachers when they can’t find housing, and hospital staff who cannot stay in our area due to lack of housing.

On a motion by Council Member Greenough, seconded by Council Member Schellong, and carried unanimously on a 5-0 polled vote, the City Council of the City of Crescent City introduced, waived full reading, read by title only and introduced Ordinance No. 840, AN ORDINANCE OF

THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT CITY AMENDING THE ZONING DISTRICT DESIGNATION FOR 1405 CALIFORNIA STREET AND THE CITY’S OFFICIAL ZONING MAP

15. Tri-Agency Economic Development Authority JPA
• Recommendation: Hear staff report
• Technical questions from the Council
• Receive public comment
• Further Council discussion
• Options:
o Approve the revised Joint Powers Agreement for the Tri-Agency Economic Development Authority as approved by the County Board of Supervisors o Approve the revised Joint Powers Agreement for the Tri-Agency Economic Development Authority as approved by the Harbor Commission o Approve the revised Joint Powers Agreement with modifications as directed by the City Council
City Attorney Rice gave a background on the Tri-Agency, it was established by the State and covers the County/Harbor/City. This was derived from the tsunami event to help with economic development. It was known as an intermediary loan program, however in 2011 Tri-Agency defaulted on the loan. Ultimately the decision was made to not forgive the debt and Tri-Agency was put into the position they would have to pay off the loan whether or not they continued to work as an Agency. In 2022, the City, County, and Harbor agreed on a plan to divvy up the debt.

In 2023, the three agencies decided on a set amount to make Tri-Agency a viable agency. It was decided to have the local Tribes be involved and for the Tri-Agency to no longer be a “lender of last resort”. City Attorney Rice stated that the Board of Supervisors approved the revised JPA that included a clause that the Tri-Agency will not support advocating for wind energy. The Harbor Commission approved the JPA, but did not include the wind energy aspect. The Agreement will not be effective until all three entities agree on one Agreement. Council Member Schellong stated 9 | P a g e
2/20/24 COUNCIL MINUTES
that the Tri-Agency was also responsible for building the Harbor. Was curious why each entity chose their own JPA; City Attorney Rice stated that the BOS had made revisions and it was approved by the Board, and the Harbor approved the revisions but not with the wind energy. The Authority shall not support or pursue the activities that support the creation of off-shore energy.

Sam Strait: stated that one of the concerns of the public was the effect on fishing from the offshore wind energy. He stated that wind energy on the Atlantic Coast has been a complete disaster.

Darrin Short: stated that he and Supervisor Borges were advocating for our local fishermen and this language is what they felt would protect them. Wind farms in Ireland have attracted crabs to their cables, they froze and it killed that industry.

Kevin Hendrick: asked the Council to approve the version the Harbor Commission approved. Said precluding the Tri-Agency from these discussions will not prevent them from happening. He said the reason why the Harbor took the language out is that they felt the fishermen needed ot have a voice at the table in regards to off-shore wind.

Council Member Wright asked about the exclusion in the JPA if it was the City Council; Mayor Inscore stated that it is only the Tri-Agency. Council Member Greenough stated he didn’t understand why the County wouldn’t want to have a discussion on wind energy. Wind energy may be a large-scale economic benefit for our community. Mayor Pro Tem Altman stated that a lot of the confusion came that when the Tri-Agency came together to continue the entity. He stated he doesn’t understand how wind energy has become such a big focus of Tri-Agency. He doesn’t believe that they will have enough money to put in all of the infrastructure for wind energy here in Del Norte County or Humboldt as well. Council Member Schellong stated she doesn’t think having a statement in the JPA saying it is not supported means anything. She is not a fan of wind energy as it will absolutely affect our fishing industry. Does not want that verbiage in the JPA. Mayor Inscore stated his focus is on the JPA, not wind energy. He stated the reason why the Tri-Agency talked about wind energy is because they couldn’t do anything else due to the debt. Two Harbor Commissioners brought the wind energy discussion forward. He further stated that each member agency has a vote in the Tri-Agency's work plan and therefore if wind energy is decided to not be in the work plan, it will not be. Does not feel the wind energy exemption needs to be in the JPA.

Darrin Short: wanted to clarify that the Tri-Agency will not be disbanded, they will be unfunded.

On a motion by Council Member Schellong, seconded by Council Member Greenough, and carried unanimously on a 5-0 polled vote, the City Council of the City of Crescent City approved the revised Joint Powers Agreement for the Tri-Agency Economic Development Authority as approved by the Harbor Commission

16. Municipal Code Update: Sign Regulations (Ch. 17.39) • Recommendation: Hear staff report
• Technical questions from the Council
• Receive public comment
• Further Council discussion
• Waive full reading, read by title only and introduce Ordinance No. 839, AN

ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT CITY AMENDING CHAPTER 17.39, SIGNS, OF TITLE 17, ZONING, OF THE CRESCENT

CITY MUNICIPAL CODE
Planner Lawton stated that City Council directed staff to bring this to the Planning Commission.

The Planning Commission held several meetings to discuss and adopted this on January 11th and recommends this version to the Council. He went over the revisions to the ordinance in detail – 10 | P a g e
2/20/24 COUNCIL MINUTES
one revision is to remove “any one commercial establishment may obtain a temporary sign permit under these regulations no more than three times in one calendar year.” Council Member Schellong asked who the City’s Community Development Director; Planner Lawton stated that has been contracted to Bob Brown of SHN Engineering. Mayor Inscore stated that he would like to see it revised to “Community Development Department” instead of “Director”. City Attorney Rice agreed with Mayor Inscore, however, the term Community Development Director is used quite a bit throughout the code. Fixing it in this one spot won’t work; should be done in definitions.

Council Member Schellong asked for clarification on revision 6, “allow wind-blowing signs with a use permit”; Planner Lawton stated that what she was referring to was being removed. She further asked about sandwich boards and asked where they could be placed; Planner Lawton stated that it is a review period cannot just be placed anywhere. Council Member Greenough left the meeting at 9:16 p.m. Council Member Schellong was in opposition to charging a large fee for a conditional use permit for a business trying to draw customers in; Planner Lawton explained what conditional use permits are in comparison to other permits. Planner Lawton further stated these revisions are recommended by the Planning Commission, however the City Council does not have to accept the revisions. Council Member Schellong stated she does not approve of someone having to have a conditional use permit for $360+ just to advertise they are selling tacos. Mayor Pro Tem Altman stated that the Planning Commission put a lot of work into this ordinance and he would like that to be taken into consideration. Mayor Inscore stated he would like to see a mechanism to modify the $360+ fee; there are several signs that are against the code within the City limits and no enforcement. Mayor Pro Tem Altman stated that a year ago the Council directed staff to make a more relaxed sign ordinance and asks if this particular ordinance is not as relaxed; Council Member Schellong stated her only issue is the expense of $360 for a sign; Mayor Inscore agreed with a concern over the cost. City Attorney Rice stated that there is a lot of staff time and expenses that come with issuing a conditional use permit. Mayor Inscore stated he would like to see the fees associated with a conditional use permit to come back to the Council; City Manager Wier stated that the fee schedule will come back before the Council. Discussion over a ministerial permit was held at length. Mayor Pro Tem Altman asked if this more relaxed ordinance, we didn’t specify back a year ago that we didn’t specify for the banner to not have a fee. Mayor Inscore stated that the conditional use permit should be a ministerial permit not to go through the Planning Commission. Council Member Schellong asked if the OTC ministerial permit be less than $360; City Manager Wier stated that would have to be brought back before the Council.

On a motion by Mayor Pro Tem Altman, seconded by Council Member Wright, and carried on a 3-1 polled vote, with Council Member Greenough being absent and Council Member Schellong voting no, the City Council of the City of Crescent City waived full reading, read by title only and introduced Ordinance No. 839, AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT CITY AMENDING CHAPTER 17.39, SIGNS, OF TITLE 17, ZONING, OF THE

CRESCENT CITY MUNICIPAL CODE

17. Comprehensive Compensation Study RFP
• Recommendation: Hear staff report
• Technical questions from the Council
• Receive public comment
• Further Council discussion
• Authorize staff to release the Comprehensive Compensation Study Request for Proposals
City Manager Wier stated that CCPOA brought forward this matter and wanted to see a compensation study done. There have been a lot of changes over the last eight years regarding wages. The Association Presidents have agreed to the RFP before the Council and they will 11 | P a g e
2/20/24 COUNCIL MINUTES
continue to be a part of the process and will help select the firm. He stated that it is his feeling that this study will show that we are low on the pay scale. Council Member Schellong asked if the job descriptions would be changed; City Manager Wier stated that job descriptions will not be changed.

Sam Strait: said he does not feel that matching entry-level jobs making $20 an hour is something the City will be able to do.

On a motion by Council Member Schellong, seconded by Council Member Wright, and carried on a 4-0 polled vote, with Council Member Greenough being absent, the City Council of the City of Crescent City authorized staff to release the Comprehensive Compensation Study Request for Proposals.

CITY COUNCIL ITEMS
➢ Legislative Matters – None
Mayor Inscore stated that Council Member Greenough asked for discussions to be had with Senator McGuire and Assembly Member Wood asking if there are any state revolving loan funds available to small cities during these difficult economic times. Mayor Inscore stated that since conversations about Pebble Beach Drive will be had with Senator McGuire, it would be a good time to bring up that question. Council Member Schellong asked for an update on the Kamome Festival, Forest Moon Festival and any economic development. ➢ City Manager Report and City Council Directives – Three wrestlers going to State for the Del Norte High School Wrestling Team.

ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business to come before the Council, Mayor Inscore adjourned the meeting at 9:57 p.m. to the regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Crescent City on Monday, March 4, 2024 at 6:00 p.m. in the Flynn Center, 981 H Street, Crescent City, CA 95531.

ATTEST:
_________________________________
Robin Altman
City Clerk/Administrative Analyst
1 | P a g e
3/4/24 COUNCIL MINUTES

CITY OF CRESCENT CITY
Mayor Blake Inscore Mayor Pro Tem Ray Altman
Council Member Jason Greenough Council Member Kelly Schellong Council Member Isaiah Wright
MONDAY MARCH 4, 2024 6:00 P.M.

CLOSED SESSION
Call to order Mayor Inscore called the closed session to order at 5:03 p.m.

Roll call Council Members present: Council Member Kelly Schellong, Council Member Isaiah Wright, Mayor Pro Tem Ray Altman, and Mayor Blake Inscore
Council Member absent at roll call: Council Member Jason Greenough Staff members present: City Manager Eric Wier, City Attorney Martha Rice, and City Clerk/Administrative Analyst Robin Altman

CLOSED SESSION PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD
There were no comments from the public on closed session items.

CLOSED SESSION
• Conference with Legal Counsel - Existing Litigation (GC 54956.9(d)(1)): Sutter v.

Tri-Agency, et al. (CVPT-23-1261); Rebecca Bohannon v. City of Crescent City (CVCV-23-1284); Crescent City v. Lounge Chair Investments, et al. (CVUJ-22-1131); Crescent City v. Vonnie Von Bargen, et al. (CVCV-24-1011) • Conference with Legal Counsel Potential Litigation – Government Claim (GC 54956.9(d)(2)): Claim of Joyce Manning, et al.
• Conference with Legal Counsel - Potential Litigation – Code Enforcement (GC 54956.9(d)(4)): Three Cases
• Public Employee Performance Evaluation (GC 54957) – City Manager and City Attorney
Council Member Greenough joined the closed session already in progress at 5:08 p.m.

OPEN SESSION
Call to order Mayor Inscore called the meeting to order at 6:01 p.m.

MINUTES

REGULAR MEETING OF THE

CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT CITY

FLYNN CENTER BOARD CHAMBERS
981 H STREET
CRESCENT CITY, CA 95531
2 | P a g e
3/4/24 COUNCIL MINUTES
Roll call Council Members present: Council Member Jason Greenough, Council Member Kelly Schellong, Council Member Isaiah Wright, Mayor Pro Tem Ray Altman, and Mayor Blake Inscore
Staff members present: City Manager Eric Wier, City Attorney Martha Rice, City Clerk/Administrative Analyst Robin Altman, Finance Director Linda Leaver, Public Works Director Dave Yeager, Housing Authority Executive Director Megan Miller, Economic Development and Recreation Director Ashley Taylor and Police Chief Richard Griffin
Pledge of Allegiance led by Mayor Inscore

REPORT OUT OF CLOSED SESSION
City Attorney Rice reported the following action was taken in closed session:

On a motion by Council Member Greenough, seconded by Council Member Schellong, and carried unanimously on a 5-0 polled vote, the City Council of the City of Crescent City rejected the claim of Joyce Manning, et. al. filed on February 7, 2024 CEREMONIAL ITEMS - None
REPORTS AND PRESENTATIONS - None

PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD
The following residents addressed the Council:

Donna Westfall: spoke about her public records request – stated that on item 15, the report was not given to her as listed in the answer. Spoke about the possibility of a rate increase and that the fire chief and captains have had increases. She further stated that the public would like to see the streets being fixed. Spoke about complaints to the Grand Jury regarding the Wastewater Treatment Facility.

Greg Bianchi: spoke about Ms. Westfall’s public records request and the expansion cost of the Wastewater Treatment Facility. Spoke about complaints issued to the Grand Jury regarding the same. Taxes are out of control and inflation is on the rise.

Sam Strait: stated that the Council says one thing and does another. Spoke about driving down A Street and that the car in front of him was zig zagging due to the potholes.

Greg Bianchi: asked if the pumping station going to be fixed soon as if the rates are going to be raised, fixes should be done. He spoke about the possibility of reusing treated water from the Plant.

Bill Shaner: spoke about the potential sewer rate increase and the needed maintenance; asked what is causing the possibility of an increase.

Jim Conley: asked for a resolution to recognize June 8th when the USS Liberty was attacked, recognizing those who were lost.

Gabe Stutman: asked for a Black History Month Proclamation and gave suggestions on what to add to it.

Chad Bastwell: spoke about the inclusion agenda.
3 | P a g e
3/4/24 COUNCIL MINUTES
Molly Cogner: spoke about it being Women’s Month and the feminist movement.

Fred Leuchter: spoke about 24 protocols that the City should look into and referenced a book that listed them.

Robert Derego: spoke about how he appreciates the option to participate in the meeting via Zoom and is hopeful the City keeps that option open.

Sunny Valero: spoke about negative comments being given and to disregard them. ➢ Reports, Concerns, Referrals, Council travel and training reports – Mayor Inscore asked to move this item to the end of the meeting since the public comment period ended up taking a great deal of time to get through; the Council was in unanimous consensus.

CONSENT CALENDAR

1. Warrant Claims List
• Recommendation: Receive and file the warrant claims list for the period February 10, 2024 through February 23, 2024.

2. Payroll Report
• Recommendation: Receive and file the biweekly payroll reports for the period ending February 24, 2024, paid March 1, 2024.

3. Budget-to-Actual Financial Reports for January 2024
• Recommendation: Receive and file budget-to-actual financial reports of the City’s major operating funds for Fiscal Year 2023-24 as of January 31, 2024

4. GSRMA Board of Directors City Representative Vote
• Recommendation: Vote for the City of Crescent City to be the city district representative on the GSRMA Board of Directors for the 2024-2026 term

5. RFP for Wastewater Sludge Collection, Hauling and Disposal from the Wastewater Treatment Plant
• Recommendation: Authorize the publication of a Request for Proposals (“RFP”) for the collection, transportation, and disposal of the wastewater sludge from the Wastewater Treatment Plant (WWTP)

6. Declaring the Continuance of an Emergency Due to Continuous Slide Activity Along Pebble Beach Drive
• Recommendation: Declare by a 4/5 vote that there is a need to continue the emergency action for the continuous slide activity along Pebble Beach Drive between 7 th and 8th Streets per Public Contract code § 22050
Council Member Schellong asked for item 1 to be pulled from the consent calendar.

No public comments were received on the consent calendar.

On a motion by Council Member Greenough, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Altman, and carried unanimously on a 5-0 polled vote, the City Council of the City of Crescent City adopted the consent calendar consisting of items 2-6 as presented.
4 | P a g e
3/4/24 COUNCIL MINUTES
On a motion by Council Member Wright, seconded by Council Member Greenough, and carried on a 4-0-1 polled vote with Council Member Schellong recusing herself, the City Council of the City of Crescent City adopted item 1 of the consent calendar as presented.

PUBLIC HEARING - None

CONTINUING BUSINESS

7. Beachfront Park 60% Design Presentation / Review
• Recommendation: Hear staff report
• Technical questions from the Council
• Receive public comment
• Further Council discussion
• Provide comments / direction to staff and/or consultant team regarding the contents of the 60% Design of Phase 1 of the Beachfront Park General Development Plan The GreenWorks team went over what portions of Beachfront Park will be developed. Mr. Abbate went over a proposed design for the entryway to Beachfront Park which involves wave forms. He further explained how the wave shapes will be found all over the Park. Anya Moucha of Greenworks went over the Kamome and Redwood Tree portion of the Park and its detail aspects, the waterfront plaza and amphitheater, the fish and canoe interpretive piece. She then detailed the pump track which anticipated construction will start this Fall. Council Member Schellong liked the hollowed-out tree aspect. Is concerned with the number of plants in the Park and what maintenance it will take for upkeep. Mr. Abbate stated that these plants will be native plants and City staff has been addressed for the viability of planting these. Council Member Schellong asked if aluminum is a good choice for the coast; Mr. Abbate stated that aluminum does not rust and long-term maintenance is best. Council Member Schellong asked if there will be tie-downs in the concrete for vendor tents; Mr. Abbate stated that yes, there will be tie-downs. Council Member Schellong asked if fishing and logging would be also represented in the Park; Mr. Abbate stated that the wave structures representative of the fishing industry and explained the native Tolowa plants. Council Member Schellong asked if the Council and public will have a say so in another design from the wave pieces; Mr. Abbate stated that they received this direction from the meetings this is the 5th or 6th design plan, and it needs to be finalized. Council Member Greenough stated he is pleased with the design and is looking forward to it coming to fruition.

Sam Strait: asked if there has been any thought on the cost of maintenance of the Park; is this for tourists or City residents as most of the focus seems to be on the side of tourists.

8. FEMA Assistance to Firefighters Grant Program Application • Recommendation: Hear staff report
• Technical questions from the Council
• Receive public comment
• Further Council discussion
• Direct staff to prepare an application under the Federal Emergency Management Agency’s (FEMA) Assistance to Firefighters Grant (AFG) Program for Self-Contained Breathing Apparatus (SCBA) personal protective equipment in the amount of $467,529.59
• Approve and authorize the City Manager to sign a Memorandum of Agreement between the City of Crescent City and the Crescent Fire Protection District to facilitate a cooperative effort to purchase self-contained breathing apparatus (SCBA) and accessories for Crescent City Fire & Rescue personnel under a FEMA Assistance to Firefighters Grant
5 | P a g e
3/4/24 COUNCIL MINUTES
City Manager Wier stated that both Fire Department Administrative Assistant Vanessa Duncan and Fire Chief Kevin Carey had put a lot of work into this MOA. This is a grant application that will acquire 46 SCBAs and is a split between the City and the District, costing the City $11k in a match. He also stated that another piece for approval for the Council is the MOA that has already been approved by the District. It has been recommended to have a joint application. Council Member Greenough was impressed by the amount of SCBAs that would be obtained for a low cost. Mayor Pro Tem Altman asked if the share with the District was 50%; City Manager answered in the affirmative.

There were no public comments.

On a motion by Council Member Greenough, seconded by Council Member Schellong, and carried unanimously on a 5-0 polled vote, the City Council of the City of Crescent City directed staff to prepare an application under the Federal Emergency Management Agency’s (FEMA) Assistance to Firefighters Grant (AFG) Program for Self-Contained Breathing Apparatus (SCBA) personal protective equipment in the amount of $467,529.59 and approved and authorized the City Manager to sign a Memorandum of Agreement between the City of Crescent City and the Crescent Fire Protection District to facilitate a cooperative effort to purchase self-contained breathing apparatus (SCBA) and accessories for Crescent City Fire & Rescue personnel under a FEMA Assistance to Firefighters Grant

NEW BUSINESS

9. Fiscal Year 2023-24 Mid-Year Budget Update
• Recommendation: Hear staff report
• Technical questions from the Council
• Receive public comment
• Further Council discussion
• Direct staff to reallocate ARPA funding
• Approve and adopt Resolution No. 2024-16, A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY

COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT CITY AMENDING THE FISCAL YEAR 2023-24 BUDGET AND POSITION CONTROL OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT CITY Finance Director Leaver gave an overview of how the FY 2023-24 Budget has come together.

One of the major expenses of the City are wages and benefits. There was a City-wide net decrease of approximately $300k (3% of total wages and benefits budget). For the General Fund, the sales tax increased $115k, TOT increased $153k, and interest increased $53k. In the General Fund there was a decrease OF $100,497 across all departments. For the fire department there was a revenue increase of $86,061 and an increase in expenses of $60,871 from mutual aid. The police department had very little increases that were from public outreach, K9 supplies, investigation expenses, generator maintenance. Code Enforcement contract expense will increase $5,940, Streets revenues are projected to decrease $9,896 due to a decrease in projected gas tax revenue from the State. Parks expenses are recommended to increase a total of $3,202, with a decrease in wages and benefits offset by an increase in contracts for janitorial services and relocating the dog park fence. Cultural Center revenue is recommended to increase $10,000 for the Chamber of Commerce’s contribution toward the Cultural Center feasibility study.

Pool - the original budget for the pool assumed the HVAC and flooring projects would occur this fiscal year, requiring an 8-week closure. The budget reduced revenues and also staffing for parttime lifeguards. These projects are now anticipated to occur in the next fiscal year, so the midyear budget update recommends an increase in revenue of $21,500, an increase in expenses of $35,934, and an increase to the position control for additional lifeguard hours. Overall for the General Fund, the total revenue increase is $434,779 and the total expense increase was $8,407.

The current required reserve is $2.5million. At the end of the year, the General Fund will be at 6 | P a g e
3/4/24 COUNCIL MINUTES
$3.7million should all expenses/revenues be as expected. Staff’s recommendation is to not spend the $700k reserve and to not do anything with it until we know what is going to be done about Pebble Beach Drive. Council Member Schellong asked if recruitments are being done for the vacancies; City Manager Wier stated that the City has hired an HR firm that will be helping with upcoming recruitments. Council Member Schellong stated an on-staff HR member would be better for the employees and to not continue on with a consultant. Council Member Schellong asked if the moving of the dog park fence be covered by the grant; City Manager Wier stated that the requirements doing it internally would be better for us. Director Leaver went over the RV Park budget – the new fee structure will show an increase in the anticipated revenue. For the Sewer Fund, sees an increase of revenue of $50k due to connection fees. The Water Fund saw an increase in connection fees. Revenues increased $38k in interest revenue and operating expenses increased $80,551. In regard to the AMR meter project, there is a request to add $270k to the budget to keep them going. She reported on American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) which was COVID-19 relief funding.

Sam Strait: asked if the HVAC project will stay at $1.5million; City Manager Wier stated that the estimates from the engineering firms, they are huge ranges which includes the changing out of certain components. It will be bid as a dehumidification project. Mr. Strait stated that the pool is popular but is a drain on the City’s finances.

Mayor Inscore asked City Manager Wier to have the 5-Year Plan to be made easier to read for constituents. He further stated that sewer rates haven’t been raised in 10 years unlike everything else.

On a motion by Council Member Wright, seconded by Council Member Greenough, and carried on a 5-0 polled vote, the City Council of the City of Crescent City directed staff to reallocate ARPA funding and approved and adopted Resolution No. 2024-16, A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT CITY AMENDING THE FISCAL YEAR 2023-24

BUDGET AND POSITION CONTROL OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT CITY

10. Prohousing Incentive Program Application
• Recommendation: Hear staff report
• Technical questions from the Council
• Receive public comment
• Further Council discussion
• Approve and adopt Resolution No. 2024-17, A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY

COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT CITY AUTHORIZING THE APPLICATION

FOR AND RECEIPT OF PROHOUSING INCENTIVE PROGRAM FUNDS
City Manager Wier stated that this item is needed for our Prohousing Designation. The Prohousing Designation Program provides incentives to cities and counties in the form of additional points or other preference in the scoring of competitive housing, community development, and infrastructure programs.

There were no public comments.

On a motion by Council Member Schellong, seconded by Council Member Wright, and carried on a 5-0 polled vote, the City Council of the City of Crescent City approved and adopted Resolution No. 2024-17, A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT CITY

AUTHORIZING THE APPLICATION FOR AND RECEIPT OF PROHOUSING INCENTIVE

PROGRAM FUNDS

11. Council Member Travel to San Francisco
• Recommendation: Hear staff report
7 | P a g e
3/4/24 COUNCIL MINUTES
• Technical questions from the Council
• Receive public comment
• Further Council discussion
• Authorize up to $750 for the Mayor to attend a meeting in San Francisco with Consul General of Japan, California Senate Leader McGuire, Rikuzentakata, Japan Mayor Sasaki, and other State or Federal representatives on April 10, 2024 City Manager Wier stated that Mayor Inscore has been invited to this meeting. The delegation is coming here to Crescent City for the Kamome Event. They arrive on April 10th and have a dinner with the Consul General of Japan in San Francisco first. This is not an additional allocation; it is a part of the Sister City budget.

Sam Strait: its his understanding that Mayor Inscore is spending $750 to have dinner with a group that will be traveling back to Crescent City with him; he doesn’t understand the value of Mayor Inscore attending. Mayor Inscore explained that the meeting is with California officials and representatives of Rikuzentakata. Asked if Mayor Inscore would be doing international affairs that’s the job of the feds, not local government. Feels the business can be transacted here in Crescent City instead of traveling to San Francisco for a ceremonial item. Feels the money can be spent filling a pothole instead of a nice hotel and expensive dinner. What is the benefit.

Council Member Greenough stated that this meeting will strengthen the relationship between the two cities; supports the Mayor’s trip. Mayor Pro Tem Altman stated that like our City Council changes with new people, so does our Sister City. It is important to familiarize ourselves with the new regime and focus on emergency response and disaster recovery. Council Member Wright asked if anyone else from Del Norte County was invited; Mayor Inscore stated that Supervisor Howard was invited but is not able to attend. Council Member Schellong stated that if this was just to go to San Francisco for a dinner, she would vote no. Would like to know what the agenda for the meeting entails. Does not think it is for disaster preparedness and recovery. Stated that the economic development aspect is important to keep the relationship intact.

Robert Derego: said it’s not a lot of money but agrees with Mr. Strait. The City should focus closer to home. International relationships are above a local Council. Asked if Senator McGuire and Assembly Member Wood have accepted their invitations; Mayor Inscore stated he cannot speak for them and is not sure if they have accepted.

Sunny Valero: spoke in support of anything involving our Sister City. Wants the City to be good working partners with Rikuzentakata.

On a motion by Council Member Schellong, seconded by Council Member Greenough, and carried on a 5-0 polled vote, the City Council of the City of Crescent City authorized up to $750 for the Mayor to attend a meeting in San Francisco with Consul General of Japan, California Senate Leader McGuire, Rikuzentakata, Japan Mayor Sasaki, and other State or Federal representatives on April 10, 2024

CITY COUNCIL ITEMS
➢ Legislative Matters – None
➢ Reports, Concerns, Referrals, Council travel and training reports – Council Member Schellong: attended PBSP Citizens Advisory Committee for Mayor Pro Tem Altman which included the Prison Paws Graduation; congratulated the Crescent City Jaycees who hosted 56 teams. On Sunday, CCPD, DNSO, CHP, CCFR, CalFire all chipped in and lined 8 | P a g e
3/4/24 COUNCIL MINUTES
the streets with lights flashing welcoming in a young man who came home from a life-threatening condition. Thanked all agencies for helping with moment’s notice.

Mayor Inscore: the Army Corps of Engineers were in town regarding the jetty, it was a productive meeting to include a planning meeting. Communication improvement was discussed at length.

Google has designated the jetty as a “historical monument” and therefore drawing tourists to it.

Will be traveling to Fresno in the morning to attend the Pacific Fisheries Management Council meeting regarding the recent groundfish closure. There are a lot of people from our area that are going that are in the fishing industry to include Supervisors Howard and Borges. ➢ City Manager Report and City Council Directives –
Chief Griffin reported on the recent graffiti incidents in the City. There has been an arrest made and the case is being finalized. Due to the storms, the graffiti cannot be painted over until the rains subside. City Manager Wier stated that the Del Norte/Humboldt Film Commission recognized CCPD for the Film Friendly Award for the Forest Moon Event. Chief Griffin further stated that the Law Enforcement Administrators Del Norte awards ceremony will be on Thursday, March 14th at 7:00 p.m. at the Cultural Center. Chief Griffin reported that CCPD has been recognized by Lexipol for Gold Standard for the training the officers have done. He also has implemented an app for Lexipol that pushes out training bulletins. Council Member Schellong asked about the Detective position; Chief Griffin stated that Detective Miller and Officer Pearson attended a conference about child abduction. Child Abuse Response Training will be attended by Detective Miller in Klamath with Volunteer Gloria Bobertz. City Manager Wier stated that Chief Griffin is doing a great job with the Department and a lot of the gear he was explaining was funded by Measure S.
o Update on upcoming City Events: Economic Development and Recreation Director Taylor reported on the following events:
▪ Easter Egg Adventure will be March 16th for $3 a child; includes a rec swim, egg hunt in KidTown and games.
▪ Spring Swim Camp (March 25-29, 2024) - this is the second swim camp that is five days long for $75 a child. Very similar to the last Camp that was held at the pool.
▪ 60th Anniversary of the 1964 Tsunami (March 28, 2024) - Ms. Taylor stated that the Harbor planned a much larger event, therefore the City will be joining theirs at 4pm with a walking tour.
▪ Kamome Festival (April 12-13, 2024) - this year will be a two-day event, first day will be activities for school age children 4th and 5th grade with first responders doing activities for the children. DNACA is offering an event at Elk Valley Casino that will include our delegation from Rikuzentakata. The following day will be event at the Cultural Center that will have performances from local organizations. A showing of the documentary Kamome will be done that evening.
▪ Forest Moon (May 31- June 1, 2024) - will be very similar to last year’s event.

There will be the new additional of the concert in the park with DNACA as well as the movie in the park, a showing of The Return of the Jedi along with vendors.

Council Member Schellong asked what will be done to remember the lives that were lost during the tsunami; Director Taylor stated that the walking tour will have remembrance as well as a candle-lighting. The walking tour is open to the community; however, the groups will be limited in size.

City Manager Wier stated that Sgt. Murtaugh will be arriving March 18th, he is our newest K9. He further reported that the Front Street grant was submitted, and we are in good shape to receive it. Regarding Pebble Beach Drive repair, it is still on the Governor’s desk – the exact scope needs 9 | P a g e
3/4/24 COUNCIL MINUTES
to be decided. The next Measure S Oversight Committee meeting will be on March 27th. The RMAP application has been submitted. There has been a request to hear Dennis Powers, author of “The Raging Sea”, of a presentation at the next Council meeting. The Council was in unanimous consensus to have it on the next agenda. Roger Gitlin spoke about the upcoming presentation and how valuable it will be. Mayor Inscore stated that having a gathering Tuesday morning for those who may not be available for Monday night’s meeting. Mr. Gitlin stated that would be a possibility.

ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business to come before the Council, Mayor Inscore adjourned the meeting at 8:53 p.m. to the regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Crescent City on Monday, March 18, 2024 at 6:00 p.m. in the Flynn Center, 981 H Street, Crescent City, CA 95531.

ATTEST:
______________________________
Robin Altman
City Clerk/Administrative Analyst
Home Dept. Regular Pay Overtime Gross Pay Employees Notes City Council (110) 1,409.84 - 1,409.84 5
Administration (111) 15,457.32 270.64 15,727.96 4
Econ Dev / Grants (112) 7,685.25 624.08 8,309.33 3
Human Resources (114) - - - 0
Finance (120) 13,679.45 117.84 13,797.29 6
City Attorney (130) 5,128.08 - 5,128.08 1
Fire (230) 18,466.67 3,197.00 21,663.67 5
Police (240) 45,476.49 8,193.92 53,670.41 16
Planning (313) 2,719.82 - 2,719.82 2
Public Works (350) 56,815.74 3,404.76 60,220.50 22
Recreation (450) 1,724.21 - 1,724.21 1
Swimming Pool (480) 13,510.61 288.73 13,799.34 20
Housing (490) 10,984.30 - 10,984.30 4
193,057.78 16,096.97 209,154.75 89
Payroll summarized above according to employees' home departments. Actual costs of employees are charged to department / fund where work was performed.

City of Crescent City
Biweekly Payroll Report
Payroll Ending 03/09/24
Pay Date 03/15/2024
Check Numbers: 111130-111135 (Plus Direct Deposits)

CITY COUNCIL AGENDA REPORT
TO: MAYOR INSCORE AND MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL
FROM: ERIC WIER, CITY MANAGER
BY: BRIDGET LACEY, GRANTS AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT

COORDINATOR
DATE: MARCH 18, 2024
SUBJECT: 2019-2020 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT (CDBG)

BUSINESS ASSISTANCE LOAN PROGRAM AGREEMENT
______________________________________________________________________

RECOMMENDATION
• Approve and ratify the City Manager’s execution of Amendment No. 2 to the Subrecipient Agreement with Arcata Economic Development Corporation

BACKGROUND
The Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) program is a federally funded program through the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). The principal objective of CDBG is the development of viable urban communities by providing decent housing and a suitable living environment, and by expanding economic opportunities, principally for persons of low- and moderate-income.

As a non-entitlement jurisdiction (cities with population less than 50,000 and counties with populations less than 200,000), Crescent City applies for CDBG program funding through the State Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD). HCD receives funding from the federal government and releases a Notice of Funding Availability (NOFA) to invite applications from jurisdictions within California.

The City applied for and was awarded $500,000 for a Business Assistance Loan Program under the 2020 CDBG NOFA. On August 28, 2020, the City entered into a Subrecipient Agreement with Arcata Economic Development Corporation (AEDC) to perform the underwriting and loan management services for the program.

The City entered into a number of agreements to provide the various services that would be required to implement the program, including program management and technical assistance to the businesses (Claggett Wolf Associates), additoinal technical assistance to businesses (North Coast Small Business Development Center), and loan underwriting AEDC CONTRACT AMENDMENT NO. 2
MARCH 18, 2024
2 and disbursement (Arcata Economic Development Corporation). On April 17, 2023, the AEDC contract was amended to increase the compensation from $250,000 to a “not to exceed” amount of $380,000 due to the fact that the agreement did not initially include the entire amount of available direct financing available to participants in the Business Assistance Program.

The City has currently authorized four forgivable loans to businesses totaling $290,000, with one final loan moving through the process for an additional $50,000.

ITEM ANALYSIS
As the program nears an end, it has been determined that additional dollars will be required for technical assistance and underwriting to get the final loan through the process for the full loan amount. There are remaining general admin grant funds that City staff would like to transfer to the project, however, our existing contract with Claggett Wolfe Associates has been fully expended and they do not wish to increase their contract to complete the remaining work involved. Due to the fact that there is little time left to expend the funds and get the final loan through the process, the City Manager has executed a contract with Cholwell, Benz, and Hartwick to complete the remaining technical assistance and executed an amendment with AEDC to increase the contract amount by $2,500 for the remaining underwriting. Given the need to get the process started in order to complete it within the grant expenditure timeline, the City Manager executed the amendment and now requests that the City Council ratify that action.

The proposed budget breakdown for the grant is as follows:

Claggett Wolfe Associates (Program Operator): $ 87,000
Cholwell, Benz, and Hartwick (technical assistance): $ 6,985 North Coast Small Business Dev Ctr (technical assistance): $ 3,465 Arcata Economic Develpment Corporation (underwriting): $ 37,500 Arcata Economic Development Corporation (direct financing): $345,000 City (general administration): $ 20,050
Total: $500,000

FISCAL ANALYSIS
The cost of all of the above services is fully covered by the CDBG grant. CDBG funds are allocated on a reimbursement basis.

STRATEGIC PLAN ASSESSMENT
This action supports the following Strategic Plan goals:
• Goal 1: Support quality services, community safety, and health to enhance the quality of life and experience of our residents and visitors AEDC CONTRACT AMENDMENT NO. 2
MARCH 18, 2024
3 • Goal 1(A): Enhance collaboration with other agencies and the community to better aid the public
• Goal 1(E): Target economic development improvements that provide additional benefit by enhancing the quality of life for residents
• Goal 2: Promote a thriving local economy
• Goal 2(D): Collaborate with other jurisdictions and non-profits to maximize regional effectiveness and amplify funding opportunities
• Goal 2(E): Create an environment that is conducive to attracting and retaining strong, sustainable businesses that reflect community needs and culture • Goal 2(F)(1): Streamline services that support new, existing, and prospective businesses
• Goal 2(F)(9): Expand on the success of grant funding by maximizing utilization of opportunities with corresponding community needs

ATTACHMENTS

1. Professional Services Agreement with AEDC – Amendment No. 2

CITY COUNCIL AGENDA REPORT
TO: MAYOR INSCORE AND MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL
FROM: ERIC WIER, CITY MANAGER
BY: MARTHA D. RICE, CITY ATTORNEY

DAVID YEAGER, DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC WORKS
DATE: MARCH 18, 2024
SUBJECT: DECLARING THE CONTINUANCE OF AN EMERGENCY DUE TO

CONTINUOUS SLIDE ACTIVITY ALONG PEBBLE BEACH DRIVE
__________________________________________________________________________

RECOMMENDATION
• Declare by a 4/5 vote that there is a need to continue the emergency action for the continuous slide activity along Pebble Beach Drive between 7th and 8th Streets per Public Contract code § 22050

BACKGROUND
At the February 5th City Council meeting, the Council declared an emergency pursuant to Public Contract Code Section 22050. This declaration of emergency allows the City to by pass the normal competitive bidding process in order to procure services and contractors to address the emergency; in this case, the continual slide activity that has undermined a section of Pebble Beach Drive between 7th and 8th Streets.

As of the posting of this agenda there are not any additional updates or significant changes in the current emergency. City staff are maintaining communication with Coastal Commission staff regarding permitting and Caltrans / California Office of Emergency Services regarding funding as well as engaging with State Senator McGuire’s and Congressman Huffman’s Office. These meetings have been productive and all agencies are fully aware of the emergency situation as well as the funding challenges. The last conversation with the California Office of Emergency Services indicated they actively working on evaluating this project, although they could not commit to an exact timeframe when a determination will be made.

As a reminder, the City has applied for Emergency Opening (EO) funding with Federal Highways Administration (FHWA) and administered through Cal Trans. If approved, EO funding is 100% reimbursable. Once granted the EO funding has to be spent within 270 days. These funds are intended to cover only the immediate costs to stabilize the emergency, reopen the roadway, and provide for public safety. It is not yet guaranteed Pebble Beach Slide Emergency Declaration
MARCH 18, 2024
2 2
that EO will be granted. If granted, the timeline for reimbursement is also not yet known.

Staff is continuing to work on funding options for this portion of the repair work.

ANALYSIS
The Public Contract Code requires the City to revisit whether an emergency declaration allowing the City to contract without formal bids is still necessary at each regular meeting.

It is necessary to continue the emergency action as the slide has yet to be fixed. The City will only be able to complete a “temporary” fix, which itself is complicated by its coastal location. Funding, design and construction will all need to come together in a very short window of time. This window is not enough time to competitively let bids.

FISCAL ANALYSIS
Both the immediate emergency costs and the permanent repair costs are unknown as the scopes of work for both are unknown at this time.

STRATEGIC PLAN ASSESSMENT
GOAL 1: SUPPORT QUALITY SERVICES, COMMUNITY SAFETY, AND HEALTH TO

ENHANCE THE QUALITY OF LIFE AND EXPERIENCE OF OUR RESIDENTS AND

VISITORS
A. Enhance collaboration with other agencies and the community to better aid the public.

B. Empower and utilize Police, Fire, and Public Works departments to make Crescent City one of the safest cities in the United States.

C. Provide and maintain an efficient, adequate infrastructure to provide for both current and future community needs.

GOAL 2: PROMOTE A THRIVING LOCAL ECONOMY
D. Collaborate with other jurisdictions and non-profits to maximize regional effectiveness and amplify funding opportunities.

ATTACHMENTS
None.

CITY COUNCIL AGENDA REPORT
TO: MAYOR INSCORE AND MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL
FROM: ERIC WIER, CITY MANAGER
BY: ETHAN LAWTON, CONTRACT PLANNER

BOB BROWN, CONTRACT PLANNER
DATE: MARCH 18, 2024
SUBJECT: PUBLIC HEARING: GENERAL PLAN MAP AMENDMENT – 1405

CALIFORNIA STREET
______________________________________________________________________

RECOMMENDATION
• Open public hearing
o Hear staff report
o Technical questions from the Council
o Receive public comment
• Close public hearing
• Further Council discussion
• Approve and adopt Resolution No. 2024-18, A Resolution of the City Council of the City of Crescent City Amending the General Plan Map for APN 118-403-002- 000 [1405 California Street]

BACKGROUND
Sam Schauerman is the owner and developer of 1405 California Street (APN 118-403- 002-000). The parcel is designated General Commercial / Multi-Family (6-15). Schauerman is currently constructing 16 units on the lower portion of the parcel as allowed by the current zoning designation. He submitted a Rezoning Request (Application RZ23-01), Zoning Map Amendment (Application ZA23-01), and General Plan Map Amendment (Application GPA23-02) to the Planning Commission to rezone 2.34 acres of the subject parcel. The purpose of this change in zoning / GP designation is to allow for a greater density of dwelling units.

The Planning Commission held a duly noticed public hearing at its regular meeting of February 8, 2024. After considering the matter, the Planning Commission recommended approval of the rezoning request, zoning map amendment and general plan map amendment to the City Council by way of Resolution No. PC2024-04.

GENERAL PLAN MAP AMENDMENT
MARCH 18, 2024
2 The General Plan Map amendment can only be made by resolution following a public hearing.

ITEM ANALYSIS
The subject parcel is partially developed with a 7,050 SF commercial building (formerly California Auto Image) and is currently being developed with 16 residential units. By changing the parcel’s designation to General Commercial / Multi-Family (15-30) as requested by applicant and recommended by the Planning Commission, the owner will be able to construct residential units at a greater density. The owner plans on constructing 40 dwelling units in addition to the 16 currently being constructed. The total development will include 56 units comprised of 36 two-bedroom units and 20 three-bedroom units.

The proposed 40-unit residential-only development is a use consistent with the MF 15-30 GP land use designation and is relatively similar to some of the surrounding uses. Two of the sides are adjacent to GC Designations, providing a transition of CG to MF 15-30 to MF 6-15, which is appropriate for this entire block section with a mixed designation. The parcel has remained mostly vacant for many years and now is proposed for an infill project that provides much needed housing, as identified in the City’s 6th Cycle Housing Element.

In order to approve this General Plan Map change, the City Council must find that the amendment is (1) consistent with the General Plan and (2) deemed to be in the public interest. These criteria will be addressed in detail at the public hearing.

If the City Council decides to approve the General Plan map amendment, then the City Council must do so by resolution after holding a public hearing. If approved, the changes to the Zoning Map and the General Plan Map would be effective 30 days after adoption (April 17th).

FISCAL ANALYSIS
There are no costs directly associated with approving the General Plan Map amendment.

ATTACHMENTS
• Resolution No. 2024-18
• Planning Commission Staff Report February 8, 2024
• Resolution No. PC2024-04
CITY OF CRESCENT CITY RESOLUTION NO. 2024-18 Page 1
RESOLUTION NO. 2024-18

A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT CITY AMENDING THE GENERAL PLAN MAP FOR APN 118-403-002-000 [1405 CALIFORNIA STREET] WHEREAS, the City of Crescent City is a general law city incorporated under the laws of the State of California in 1854; and
WHEREAS, it is the statutory duty of the City to adopt a comprehensive, long-term general plan for the physical development of the City (Gov. Code Section 65300); and WHEREAS, the City’s General Plan was adopted May 21, 2001 and contains a General Plan Land Use Diagram (“Map”) designating parcels within the City according to defined land use designations; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission received an application to amend the General Plan Map to change APN 118-403-002-000 land use designation from General Commercial / Multi-Family (6-15) to General Commercial / Multi-Family (15-30) to allow for more dense development of townhomes on the parcel; and
WHEREAS, the Planning Commission held a duly noticed public hearing, considered the staff report, application, and public hearing testimony, and determined to recommend that the City Council amend the General Plan Map as requested to allow the development; and WHEREAS, the City Council has also held a duly noticed public hearing, considered the matter, the information presented and public hearing testimony; and WHEREAS, the City Council has determined that the General Map Amendment should be approved.

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT CITY, CALIFORNIA AS FOLLOWS:

1. FINDINGS. The City Council makes the following findings:

A. HEARING & NOTICE. A duly noticed public hearing was held March 18, 2024 to hear all positions on the proposed General Plan Map Amendment for APN 118-403-002- 000.

B. GENERAL PLAN CONSISTENCY. The proposed General Plan Amendment (redesignating APN 118-403-002-000) is consistent with the General Plan. The adjacent parcels to the northwest, north and east of the subject parcel are currently designated General Commercial. The adjacent parcels to the south and west of the subject parcel are designated low density residential. The multi-family land use designations serve as a transition between commercial and low-density residential.

Thus, changing the land use designation for the southern 2.34 acres of the subject parcel from GC / MF 6-15 to MF 15-30 provides the same type of transition between the two land use designations, but at a higher density.

C. GENERAL PLAN GOALS AND POLICIES. The proposed General Map amendment is supported by the following General Plan Policies and Goals:
• Policy 1.A.2. The City shall encourage infill development that makes efficient use of existing public infrastructure and is compatible with existing development.

CITY OF CRESCENT CITY RESOLUTION NO. 2024-18 Page 2
• Policy 1.A.3. The City shall encourage project sites to be designed to increase the convenience, safety, and comfort of people using public transportation, walking, or cycling.
• Goal 1.F. To provide adequate land in a range of residential densities to accommodate the housing needs of all income groups expected to reside in Crescent City, while ensuring a high quality of residential development. • Policy 1.F.2. The City shall ensure that Infill development (either new or rehabilitated structures) is compatible with the overall established character of residential neighborhoods.
• Policy 1.F.3. The City shall encourage higher residential densities at locations where convenient access and adequate facilities, including parks and open space are readily available.
• Policy 2.A.2 The City will continue to encourage maximization of residential development potential and limit underutilization of land through project design review.
• Policy 2.B.9. The City shall continue to monitor housing activity on an annual basis to assess whether their respective needs projections for all income levels are being met by voluntary open market (Rather than mandatory inclusion) as they have in the past.
• Goal C. To assist in the development of adequate housing to meet the needs of low/very low and moderate – income households.
• Policy 2.D.1. The City shall continue to maintain opportunities for al income groups by use of clustered development to maximize density and minimize land development and/or construction costs.

D. CEQA. The proposed General Plan Map amendment has been reviewed for compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), and the CEQA Guidelines, and the City Council finds that the General Plan Map amendment will allow for development that is subject to a Class 32 exemption for infill development.

2. GENERAL PLAN MAP AMENDMENT. The City’s General Plan Map is hereby amended to designate the southern 2.34 acres of APN 118-403-002-000 from General Commercial (GC) / Multi-Family 6-15 (MF 6-15) to Multi-Family 15-30 (MF 15-30) as follows:

CURRENT LAND USE NEW LAND USE

DESIGNATION DESIGNATION

CITY OF CRESCENT CITY RESOLUTION NO. 2024-18 Page 3

3. EFFECTIVE DATE. This resolution will be effective 30 days from its date of adoption.

PASSED AND ADOPTED by the City Council of the City of Crescent City on this 18th day of March 2024, by the following polled vote:

AYES:

NOES:

ABSTAIN:

ABSENT:
_______________________________
Blake Inscore, Mayor
ATTEST:
_____________________________
Robin Altman, City Clerk

CITY OF CRESCENT CITY PLANNING COMMISSION

AND ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE
AGENDA ITEM: #1
Incorporated April 13, 1854 web: www.crescentcity.org
February 8, 2024 Page 1 of 14 RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02

STAFF REPORT
MEETING DATE: Thursday, February 8, 2024
TO: Planning Commission
FROM: Community Development Department, Planning & Zoning Ethan Lawton, City Planner / Consultant
SUBJECT: A Public Hearing to consider a Rezoning Request (Application RZ23- 01), a Zoning Map Amendment (Application ZA23-01), and a General Plan Map Amendment (Application GPA23-02) for Sam Schauerman’s proposed Roosevelt Estates (Phase 2) requesting 40-unit residential-only development located at 1405 California Street (APN 118-403-002).

SECTION 1: EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Sam Schauerman has submitted a Rezoning
Request (Application RZ23-01), a Zoning
Map Amendment (Application ZA23-01),
and a General Plan Map Amendment
(Application GPA23-02) for a proposed
Roosevelt Estates (Phase 2) requesting 40-
unit residential-only development on a
partially developed (Phase 1 = 16-units)
parcel within the R-2/C-2 Zoning (ModerateDensity Residential District/General Commercial District) located at 1405
California Street (APN 118-403-002).

STAFF RECOMMENDS: “Motion to adopt
Resolution No. PC2024-04, read by title only,
A Resolution of the Planning Commission of
the City of Crescent City Approving a
Rezoning Request, a Zoning Map
Amendment, and a General Plan Map
Amendment for a 40-unit residential-only
development.

ATTACHMENTS:

A) RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02
Application
B) Resolution PC2024-04
FIGURE 1-1: PROJECT LOCATION MAP
Source: Housing Element (December 2022)
City of Crescent City - Regular Planning Commission Meeting Staff Report - Agenda Item: #1
RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02 Page 2 of 14 February 8, 2024
SECTION 2: BACKGROUND INFORMATION
The proposed project parcel is partially developed with a 7050 square foot (sf) commercial building and is in the process of developing Phase 1 of the project, which consists of 16 residential units.

ADDRESS:
1405 California Street
Crescent City, CA 95531
APN:
118-403-002-000
PARCEL SIZE:
±2.78 acres
±121,097 sf
PROJECT SIZE:

2.34 acres
101,930 sf
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING:

A Notice of Public Hearing was submitted to the Del Norte Triplicate newspaper (on 01/11/24) to be published (on 01/24/24) in print/online circulation. A similar Notice of Public Hearing was mailed (on 01/22/24) to the property owners within 300-ft of the project location (CCMC §17.46.050) as required (Cal. Gov. Code §65090 & §65094).

REQUIRED FINDING #1 (BY THE COMMISSION):
□ The Planning Commission has considered this proposed project on this date at a duly noticed public hearing, staff report, and public testimony.

FIGURE 2-1: PROJECT PARCEL
Source: Parcel Quest (January 2024)
City of Crescent City - Regular Planning Commission Meeting Staff Report - Agenda Item: #1
February 8, 2024 Page 3 of 14 RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02
SECTION 3: PROPOSED PROJECT DESCRIPTION
Sam Schauerman has submitted a Rezoning Request (Application RZ23-01), a Zoning Map Amendment (Application ZA23-01), and a General Plan Map Amendment (Application GPA23- 02) for a proposed Roosevelt Estates (Phase 2) requesting 40-unit residential-only development on a partially developed (Phase 1 = 16-units) parcel within the R-2/C-2 Zoning (ModerateDensity Residential District/General Commercial District) located at 1405 California Street (APN 118-403-002). These requests aim to rezone/amend approximately 2.34 acres from R-2/C2 (Moderate-Density Residential District/General Commercial District) zoning designation to a R-3 (High-Density Residential District), which would increase the density, allowing for additional housing through the proposed 40-unit residential development. The C-2 portion of the property currently has an existing 7,050 sq. ft commercial building fronting Washington Blvd, which will remain zoned C-2. The portion of the property zoned C-2 is approximately 1.24 acres while the southerly area zoned R-2 is approximately 1.54 acres. The project in total proposes 56 residential units with 36 two-bedroom units and 20 three-bedroom units, including ten buildings (seven in Phase 2 and three buildings from Phase 1).

REQUIRED FINDING #2 (BY THE COMMISSION):
□ Sam Schauerman has submitted a Rezoning Request (Application RZ23-01), a Zoning Map Amendment (Application ZA23-01), and a General Plan Map Amendment (Application GPA23- 02) for a proposed Roosevelt Estates (Phase 2) requesting 40-unit residential-only development on a partially developed (Phase 1 = 16-units) parcel within the R-2/C-2 Zoning (ModerateDensity Residential District/General Commercial District) located at 1405 California Street (APN 118-403-002).

FIGURE 3-1: PROPOSED RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT
Source: Site Plan (January 23, 2024) See Attachment A: AR23-16 Application City of Crescent City - Regular Planning Commission Meeting Staff Report - Agenda Item: #1
RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02 Page 4 of 14 February 8, 2024
SECTION 4: GENERAL PLAN CONSISTENCY
The proposed 40-unit residential-only development is currently located on a single lot with mixed-designations, the northern portion being General Commercial (GC) and the southern portion being Residential Multi-Family 15-30 (MF 15-30) General Plan (GP) land use designation (See Figure 4-1: Section of General Plan Map).

FIGURE 4-1: SECTION OF GENERAL PLAN MAP
Source: General Plan Map (May 2001)
However, the applicant has submitted a GP Map Amendment (Application GPA23-02) to amend the GP land use designation to become Multi-Family Residential 15-30 (MF 15-30). (See Figure 4-2: Before General Plan Map Amendment and Figure 4-3: After General Plan Map Amendment)
FIGURE 4-2: BEFORE GENERAL PLAN MAP AMENDMENT
The (northern half) GC land use designation may grant
“residentials uses as a secondary/mixed use at a density of 12 units per acre” with a conditional use permit as the intended uses are to “provide the Crescent City Planning Area with goods, services, and jobs.”
The (southern half) MF 6-15 land use designation principally permits “clustered multiple-unit buildings” at “residential densities range from a minimum of six to a maximum of 15 dwelling units per acre” as the intended uses are to “provide for moderate to high density residential development within the urban boundary.” GC
MF
6-15
City of Crescent City - Regular Planning Commission Meeting Staff Report - Agenda Item: #1
February 8, 2024 Page 5 of 14 RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02
FIGURE 4-3: AFTER GENERAL PLAN MAP AMENDMENT
The (northern small portion) GC land use designation principally permits “commercial activities such as small retail stores and personal service shops” as the intended uses are to “provide the Crescent City Planning Area with goods, services, and jobs.” The (southern large portion) MF 15-30 land use designation principally permits “multiple-use buildings” at “residential range from a minimum of 15 to a maximum of 30 dwelling units per acre” as the intended uses are to “provide for high density residential development within the urban boundary.”
The proposed 40-unit residential-only development is a use consistent with the MF 15-30 GP land use designation and is relatively similar to some of the surrounding uses (See Table 4-1:

Comparison of surrounding Properties). Two of the sides are adjacent to GC Designations, providing a transition of CG to MF 15-30 to MF 6-15, which is appropriate for this entire block section with a mixed designation. The parcel has remained mostly vacant for many years and now is proposed for an infill project that provides much needed housing, as identified in the City’s 6th Cycle Housing Element.

TABLE 4-1: COMPARISON OF SURROUNDING PROPERTIES
Vicinity Land Use Designation Current Use
Project Property General Commercial (G-C) &
Multi-Family Residential (MF
6-15)
California Auto Image & (Phase 1) 16-
unit Residential
North General Commercial (G-C) &
Del Norte County
Del Norte Unified School District and
King of the Grind Boxing Club
South General Commercial District
(G-C) & Residential (SF 2-6)
Single Family Residential
East General Commercial (G-C) Uncharted Shores Academy & James C.

Standring Family Dentistry
West Residential (SF 2-6) Napa Auto Parts & Single Family Residential
SUPPORTING GENERAL PLAN GOALS/POLICIES:

Regarding General Plan Amendment Request:
-Goal 1.L. - “To provide for the on-going administration and implementation of the General Plan.”
-Policy 1.L.1. - “The City shall review the General Plan annually and revise it as deemed necessary.”
GC
MF
15-30
City of Crescent City - Regular Planning Commission Meeting Staff Report - Agenda Item: #1
RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02 Page 6 of 14 February 8, 2024
-Policy 1.L.2. - “The City shall not amend the General Plan more than four times per year. Each amendment, however, may include multiple changes.”
-Policy 1.L.3. - “The City shall conduct a major review of the General Plan, including the General Plan policy document and background report, every five years and revise it as deemed necessary.”
-Policy 1.L.4. - “The City shall review and amend, as necessary, applicable ordinances and regulations to ensure consistency with the General Plan.” Regarding the Reasons for the General Plan Amendment Request:
-Policy 1.A.2. - “The City shall encourage infill development that makes efficient use of existing public infrastructure and is compatible with existing development.” -Policy 1.A.3. - “The City shall encourage project sites to be designed to increase the convenience, safety, and comfort of people using public transportation, walking, or cycling.” -Goal 1.F - “To provide adequate land in a range of residential densities to accommodate the housing needs of all income groups expected to reside in Crescent City, while ensuring a high quality of residential development.”
-Policy 1.F.2. - “The City shall ensure that infill development (either new or rehabilitated residential structures) is compatible with the overall established character of residential neighborhoods.”
-Policy 1.F.3. - “The City shall encourage higher residential densities at locations where convenient access and adequate facilities, including parks and open space, are readily available.”
-Policy 2.A.2. - “The City and County will continue to encourage maximization of residential development potential and limit underutilization of land through project design review.” -Policy 2.B.9. - “The City and County shall continue to monitor housing activity on an annual basis to assess whether their respective needs projections for all income levels are being met by voluntary open market (rather than mandatory inclusion) as they have in the past.” -Goal C. - “To assist in the development of adequate housing to meet the needs of low/very low and moderate-income households.”
-Policy 2.D.1. - “The City and County shall continue to maintain opportunities for all income groups by use of clustered development to maximize density and minimize land development and/or construction costs.”
-Policy 4.A.2. - “The City shall encourage new development to contribute its fair share to providing all public services and infrastructure necessary to serve that development.” -Policy 4.E.5. - “The City shall encourage new project designs that minimize drainage concentrations and impervious coverage and maintain, to the extent feasible, natural site drainage conditions.”
REQUIRED FINDING #3 (BY THE COMMISSION):
□ The proposed project would be consistent with this revised Crescent City General Plan’s (MF 15-30) land use designation, in that the proposed project:
a) Would be principally permitted as “multiple-use buildings” within the MF 15-30; b) “Provide[s] for high density residential development within the urban boundary” within the MF 15-30; and
c) Is supported by the General Plan goals (1.F, C, G, and 1.L) and policies (1.A.2, 1.A.3,

1.F.2, 1.F.3, 2.A.2, 2.B.9, 2.D.1, 4.A.2, 4.E.5, 1.L.1, 1.L.2, 1L.3, and 1.L.4).

City of Crescent City - Regular Planning Commission Meeting Staff Report - Agenda Item: #1
February 8, 2024 Page 7 of 14 RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02
SECTION 5: ZONING CONSISTENCY
The proposed 40-unit residential-only development is currently located on a single lot with mixed-zones, the northern portion being General Commercial District (C-2) and the southern portion being Moderate-Density Residential District (R-2) (See Figure 5-1: Section of Zoning Map). The proposed project is not located within the Coastal Zone and is not appealable to the Coastal Commission.

FIGURE 5-1: SECTION OF ZONING MAP
Source: Zoning Map
(December 2007)
However, the applicant has submitted a Rezoning Request (Application RZ23-01) and Zoning Map Amendment (Application ZA23-01) to amend the Zoning designation to become HighDensity Residential District (R-3). (See Figure 5-2: Before Zoning Map Amendment and Figure 5-3: After Zoning Map Amendment).

FIGURE 5-2: BEFORE ZONING MAP AMENDMENT
The (northern half) C-2 zone allows “residential units up to thirty units per acre density, as either a mixed-use activity which is secondary to an existing or proposed commercial use, or as a residential-only development” with a conditional use permit (CCMC §17.22.020(B)(4)) as the intended uses are to “primarily to serve as the central trading area of the city (CCMC §17.22.010).” The (southern half) R-2 zone principally permits “multiple dwellings” (CCMC §17.14.020(A)(1)) at one “Dwelling Unit [per] Three thousand square feet” (CCMC §17.14.030(B)(5)) as the intended uses are to “provide living areas within the city where the residential density is of moderately dense concentrations” (CCMC §17.14.010(A)).

C-2
R-2
City of Crescent City - Regular Planning Commission Meeting Staff Report - Agenda Item: #1
RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02 Page 8 of 14 February 8, 2024
FIGURE 5-3: AFTER ZONING MAP AMENDMENT
The (northern small portion) C-2 zone principally permits “Services located inside a building” (CCMC §17.22.020(A)(2)) as the intended uses are to “primarily to serve as the central trading area of the city (CCMC §17.22.010).”
The (southern large portion) R-3 zone principally permits “multiple dwellings” (CCMC §17.16.020(A)) at “fifteen hundred square feet per dwelling unit” (CCMC §17.16.030(B)(6)) as the intended uses are to “provide living areas within the city where development provides for high density concentrations of dwelling units” (CCMC §17.16.010(A)). This portion is the proposed project area.

ZONING: The proposed 40-unit residential-only development is a use consistent with the R-3 Zoning District and is similar to some of the surrounding uses (See Table 5-1: Comparison of surrounding Properties). Two of the sides are adjacent to C-2 Zoning, which serves to provide a transition of C-2 to R-3 to R-2, which is appropriate for this entire block section with a mixed zoning. The parcel has remained mostly vacant for many years and now is proposed for an infill project that provides much needed housing, as identified in the City’s 6th Cycle Housing Element.

TABLE 5-1: COMPARISON OF SURROUNDING PROPERTIES
Vicinity Land Use Designation Current Use
Project Property General Commercial District (C-2) &
Moderate-Density Residential District
California Auto Image &
(Phase 1) 16-unit Residential
North General Commercial District (C-2) &
Del Norte County
Del Norte Unified School
District & Commercial
South Low-Density Residential District (R-1) Single Family Residential East General Commercial District (C-2) Uncharted Shores Academy & Standring Family Dentistry
West General Commercial District (C-2) &
Low-Density Residential District (R-1)
Napa Auto Parts & Single
Family Residential
DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS & PROPOSED PROJECT:

A. Height and Area Regulations: All permitted uses within the R-3 Zoning District are subject to height and area regulations and are addressed below (See Table 5-2: Comparison of Height and Area Regulations).

C-2
R-3
City of Crescent City - Regular Planning Commission Meeting Staff Report - Agenda Item: #1
February 8, 2024 Page 9 of 14 RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02
TABLE 5-2: COMPARISON OF HEIGHT AND AREA REGULATIONS
Zoning District Code Regulation Proposed
Height (CCMC §17.16.030(A)(1)) 35-ft 27-ft
Front Yard (CCMC §17.16.030(B)(1)) 10-ft 20-ft
[Exterior] Side Yard (CCMC §17.16.030(B)(2)) 5-ft 20-ft [Interior] Side Yard (CCMC §17.16.030(B)(2)) 5-ft 10-ft Rear Yard (CCMC §17.16.030(B)(3)) 10-ft 10-ft
Lot Area (CCMC §17.16.030(B)(5)) 6,000-sf 122,403-sf
Lot Coverage (CCMC §17.16.030(B)(6)) 65% 39.2%
B. Parking, Fencing, and Signs: All permitted uses within the R-3 Zoning District are subject to the general requirements regarding Parking (CCMC §17.16.070(A)), Fencing (CCMC §17.16.070(B)), and Signs (CCMC §17.16.070(c)) and are further addressed under Section 6: Site Plan & Architectural Design Review below.

C. Site Plan: All permitted uses within the R-3 Zoning District requires a Site Plan & Architectural Design Review (CCMC §17.16.080) and is further addressed under Section 6:

Site Plan & Architectural Design Review below.

REQUIRED FINDING #4 (BY THE COMMISSION):
□ The proposed amendments are consistent with the Crescent City’s High Density Residential District (R-3) Zoning Code, in that:
a) The proposed amendments are not located within the Coastal Zone and is not appealable to the Coastal Commission;
b) The proposed uses are consistent with the “multiple dwellings” which is principally permitted within the proposed R-3 zone (CCMC §17.16.020(A)); c) The proposed uses are consistent with the intention to “provide living areas within the city where development provides for high density concentrations of dwelling units” (CCMC §17.16.010(A));
d) The proposed amendments would require all proposed projects within the R-3 Zoning District to be subject to all zoning regulations including a Site Plan & Architectural Design Review (CCMC §17.16.030) and CCMC §17.79 requirements.

City of Crescent City - Regular Planning Commission Meeting Staff Report - Agenda Item: #1
RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02 Page 10 of 14 February 8, 2024 SECTION 6: REZONING REQUEST AND ZONING AMENDMENT
The proposed Rezoning Request and Zoning Map Amendment for Sam Schauerman’s proposed Roosevelt Estates (Phase 2) requesting 40-unit residential-only development located at 1405 California Street (APN 118-403-002) requiring the scheduled public hearing for the Planning Commission to determine whether the proposed Rezoning Request (Application RZ23-01) and Zoning Map Amendment (Application ZA23-01) (See Attachment A) shall be approved or denied (CCMC §17.02.040), based on the following standards.

The zoning title is adopted to preserve, protect, and promote public health, safety, peace, comfort, convenience, prosperity, and general welfare. More specifically, the title is adopted to achieve the following objectives (CCMC §17.02.010):

A. Guide Physical Development (CCMC §17.02.010(A)):

To provide a specific plan to guide the physical development of the city in such a manner as to achieve progressively the general arrangement of land uses depicted in the general plan.

B. Encourage and Establish (CCMC §17.02.010(B)):

To encourage a wholesome, serviceable, and pleasant living environment and to establish a stability of existing land uses which conform with the objectives, policies, principles, and standards of the general plan.

C. Prevention (CCMC §17.02.010(C)):

To prevent excessive population densities and overcrowding of land with structures.

D. Promote (CCMC §17.02.010(D)):

To promote the safe, effective traffic circulation system, the provision of adequate off-street parking and truck loading facilities and the appropriate location of community facilities.

E. Preserve and Strengthen (CCMC §17.02.010(E)):

To protect and promote properly located commercial and industrial activities in order to preserve and strengthen the city’s economic base.

F. Protect and Enhance (CCMC §17.02.010(F)):

To protect and enhance real property values and the city’s natural assets.

G. Orderly Development (CCMC §17.02.010(G)):

To provide for the orderly development of new urban expansion that is logical, desirable, and in conformance with the objectives and policies of the general plan.

If, in accordance with the provisions of this title and state statutes, changes are made in the district boundaries or other matter portrayed on the official zoning map, such changes shall be made on the official zoning map promptly after the amendment has been approved by the city council (CCMC §17.08.040).

City of Crescent City - Regular Planning Commission Meeting Staff Report - Agenda Item: #1
February 8, 2024 Page 11 of 14 RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02 Upon completion of the redrafting of the map, the planning director shall, with their signature, file said map with the city council and the city clerk which will then constitute the official zoning map of the city (CCMC §17.08.040).

REQUIRED FINDING #5 (BY THE COMMISSION):
□ The proposed Rezoning Request and Zoning Amendment satisfies the objectives (CCMC §17.02.010), in that the amendments:
a) Provides a specific plan to guide the physical development of the city in such a manner as to achieve progressively the general arrangement of land uses depicted in the general plan (CCMC §17.02.010(A));
b) Encourages a wholesome, serviceable, and pleasant living environment and establishes a stability of existing land uses which conform with the objectives, policies, principles, and standards of the general plan (CCMC §17.02.010(B)); c) Prevents excessive population densities and overcrowding of land with structures (CCMC §17.02.010(C));
d) Promotes the safe, effective traffic circulation system, provision of adequate off-street parking and truck loading facilities, and the appropriate location of community facilities (CCMC §17.02.010(D));
e) Protects and promotes properly located commercial and industrial activities in order to preserve and strengthen the city’s economic base (CCMC §17.02.010(E)); f) Protects and enhances real property values and the city’s natural assets (CCMC §17.02.010(F)); and
g) Provides for the orderly development of new urban expansion that is logical, desirable, and in conformance with the objectives and policies of the general plan (CCMC §17.02.010(G)).

SECTION 7: GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT
The proposed General Plan Map Amendment for Sam Schauerman’s proposed Roosevelt Estates (Phase 2) requesting 40-unit residential-only development located at 1405 California Street (APN 118-403-002) requiring the scheduled public hearing for the Planning Commission to determine whether the proposed General Plan Amendment (Application GPA23-02) (See Attachment A) shall be approved or denied based on the following standards:

A. GP Revisions. The General Plan is a long-term document with a planning horizon of 15-25 years. To achieve its purposes, the plan must be flexible enough to respond to changing conditions and at the same time specific enough to provide predictability and consistency in guiding day-to-day land use and development decisions. Over the years, conditions and community needs change and new opportunities arise; the plan needs to keep up with these changes and new opportunities. (GP page 4)
B. GP Review. Every year, the Planning Commission should review the plan’s implementation programs to assess the City’s progress in carrying out the plan. Every five to ten years, the plan should be thoroughly reviewed and updated as necessary. (GP page 4) City of Crescent City - Regular Planning Commission Meeting Staff Report - Agenda Item: #1
RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02 Page 12 of 14 February 8, 2024 C. GP Amendments. From time to time, the City will be asked to consider proposals for specific amendments to the plan. The City will initiate some of these proposals itself but will be initiated by private property owners and developers. Most General Plan amendments involve changes in land use designations for individual parcels. (GP page 4) D. State Law. State laws limit General Plan amendments to four times per year, but each amendment can include multiple changes. Like the adoption of the General Plan itself, general amendments are subject to environmental review, public notice, and hearing requirements and must not create inconsistencies with other parts of the plan. (GP page 4) REQUIRED FINDING #6 (BY THE COMMISSION):
□ The proposed General Plan Amendment satisfies the General Plan Amendment requirements (GP page 4), in that the amendment:
a) Must be flexible enough to respond to changing conditions and at the same time specific enough to provide predictability and consistency in guiding day-to-day land use and development decisions;
b) Needs to keep up with these changing conditions, community needs, and new opportunities that arise over the years;
c) Can be reviewed by the Planning Commission with the plan’s implementation programs to assess the City’s progress in carrying out the plan and updated as necessary; d) Are often requested by private property owners and developers, to consider proposals for specific amendments to the plan;
e) Frequently involve changes in land use designations for individual parcels; f) Are subject to environmental review, public notice, and hearing requirements; and g) Must not create inconsistencies with other parts of the plan.

SECTION 8: ENVIRONMENTAL DETERMINATION SUMMARY
The proposed project is determined to be categorically exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to following sections of the CEQA Guidelines:

A. Class 32 §15332. In-Fill Development Projects, consists of the proposed project:

1. Is consistent with the applicable general plan designation, policies, and zoning designation and regulations:

The proposed project is consistent with the Crescent City General Plan’s Residential Multifamily (15-30) land use designation (incorporating the General Plan Amendment) and is consistent with the Crescent City’s High-Density Residential District (R-3) Zoning Code (with Zoning Amendment, Site Plan & Architectural Design Review);

2. Development occurs within city limits on a project site (<5 acres) substantially surrounded by urban uses:

The project site is located in the City of Crescent City, is approximately 2.78 acres, and is located adjacent to existing residential/commercial uses;

3. Site has no value, as habitat for endangered, rare, or threatened species:

City of Crescent City - Regular Planning Commission Meeting Staff Report - Agenda Item: #1
February 8, 2024 Page 13 of 14 RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02 The project will be located on a site that has had past disturbances, is partially developed and contains no habitat value for rare, threatened, or endangered species;

4. Approval would not result in any significant effects relating to traffic, noise, air quality, or water quality:

The project proposes a residential use in a developed residential/commercial area that already services residential/commercial use and has a limited potential to result in significant traffic, noise, air quality, or water quality impacts;

5. Site can be adequately served by all required utilities and public services:

The site is surrounded by and is already adequately served by utilities and public services.

REQUIRED FINDING #7 (BY THE COMMISSION):
□ The proposed project is determined to be categorically exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) under Class 32 §15332 (In-fill Development) of the CEQA Guidelines.

SECTION 9: PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION OPTIONS
A. APPROVAL. Making all the required findings.
• “I move to adopt Resolution No. PC2024-04, read by title only, A Resolution of the Planning Commission of the City of Crescent City Approving a Rezoning Request, a Zoning Map Amendment, and a General Plan Map Amendment for a for a 40- unit residential-only development.”
• Planning staff will send the applicant an approval letter, after the 10-day appeal period (CCMC §17.46.050), along with the resolution, as adopted by the Planning Commission during the public hearing. The resolution will be sent to the City Council and scheduled for consideration.

B. DENIAL. Denying one, or more, of the required findings. • “I move to deny the Rezoning Request (Application RZ23-01), Zoning Map Amendment (Application ZA23-01), and/or General Plan Map Amendment (Application GPA23-02) due to the requirements not being fully satisfied, specifically regarding ________.”
• Planning staff will send the applicant a denial letter stating why the application was denied. The applicant would not be allowed to build the residential accessory structure.

C. REQUEST ADDITIONAL INFORMATION. Requiring additional information to make the necessary findings.
• “I move to request additional information regarding __________ be brought back to the February 22, 2024 (or, time certain, Special) Planning Commission meeting for consideration.”
• Planning staff will follow up with the applicant requesting any additional information, which will continue this item on the next scheduled Planning Commission meeting agenda (CCMC §17.46.050) scheduled for Thursday, February 22, 2024 or a specific alternative Special Planning Commission meeting.

City of Crescent City - Regular Planning Commission Meeting Staff Report - Agenda Item: #1
RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02 Page 14 of 14 February 8, 2024 SECTION 10: STAFF RECOMMENDATION

1. (Chair) “Agenized Item #1: A Public Hearing to consider a Rezoning Request (Application RZ23-01), a Zoning Map Amendment (Application ZA23-01), and a General Plan Map Amendment (Application GPA23-02) for Sam Schauerman’s proposed Roosevelt Estates (Phase 2) requesting 40-unit residential-only development located at 1405 California Street (APN 118-403-002).”

2. (Chair) “I will open the Public Hearing.”

3. (Chair) “We will now receive a presentation on the Staff Report from Planner Lawton.”

4. (Chair) “Does any Commissioners have any clarifying questions for staff?” a. (Chair) “Does the Applicant wish to address the Planning Commission?”

5. (Chair) “I will open Public Comment, which we will receive at the podium.” a. “We request that (1) you state your name and residency, (2) subject to a three-minute comment be directed to the Planning Commission for consideration, and (3) please state if you are for-or-against the proposed project.”
b. (Chair) Any clarifying questions?

6. (Chair) “I will close Public Comment.”

7. (Chair) “Is there any discussion on this item from the Commissioners?”

8. (Chair) “I believe a motion would be in order.”
a. (Commissioner) “I move to adopt Resolution No. PC2024-04, read by title only, A Resolution of the Planning Commission of the City of Crescent City Approving a Rezoning Request, a Zoning Map Amendment, and a General Plan Map Amendment for a for a 40-unit residential-only development.”
b. Note: Any changes should be included in the motion.

9. (Chair) “A motion has been made by Commissioner _________. Is there a second?”

10. (Chair) “It was seconded by Commissioner __________.”

11. (Chair) “A motion was made and seconded to: Adopt Resolution No. PC2024-04, read by title only, A Resolution of the Planning Commission of the City of Crescent City Approving a Rezoning Request, a Zoning Map Amendment, and a General Plan Map Amendment for a for a 40-unit residential-only development.”
a. Note: Any changes should be included in the motion.

12. (Chair) “Is there any additional discussion from the Commissioners on the motion?”

13. (Chair) “Seeing as there is no further discussion, it is time for a vote on the motion, Specialist Welton, can you poll the vote?”

14. (Chair) “The motion passes (or fails) by a vote of ___-to-___.” (Example 5-0) --- END OF REPORT ---
Incorporated .·lpril 13. 185-1

CITY OF CRESCENT CITY

PLANNING COMMISSION AND

ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE
RESOLUTION NO. PC2024-04

A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT

CITY RECOMMENDING TO THE CITY COUNCIL A REZONING REQUEST, ZONING AMENDMENT, AND GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT FOR A 40-UNIT

RESIDENTIAL-ONLY DEVELOPMENT
WHEREAS, Sam Schauerman has submitted a Rezoning Request (Application RZ23-0l), a Zoning Amendment (Application ZA23-01), and a General Plan Amendment (Application GPA23-02) for a proposed Roosevelt Estates (Phase 2) requesting 40-unit residential-only development on a partially developed (Phase I= 16-units) parcel within the R-2/C-2 Zoning (Moderate-Density Residential District/General Commercial District) located at 1405 California Street (APN 118-403-002);
WHEREAS, the Planning Commission has considered this proposed project on this date at a duly noticed public hearing, staff report, and public testimony; WHEREAS, the Planning Commission finds that the proposed amendments are consistent with the Crescent City General Plan's (MF 15-30) land use designation, in that the proposed project:
a) will result in principally permitted "multiple-family buildings" within the MF 15- 3 0 designation;
b) "Provide[ s] for high density residential development within the urban boundary" within the MF 15-30; and
c) Is supported by the General Plan goals ( 1.F, C, G, and l .L) and policies ( 1.A.2, l.A.3, l.F.2, l.F.3, 2.A.2, 2.B.9, 2.D.1, 4.A.2, 4.E.5, l.L.1, l.L.2, IL.3, and l.L.4).

WHEREAS, the Planning Commission finds that the proposed amendments are consistent with the Crescent City's High Density Residential District (R-3) Zoning Code, in that:
a) The proposed amendments are not located within the Coastal Zone and is not appealable to the Coastal Commission;
b) The proposed uses will be consistent with the "multiple dwellings" which is principally permitted within the R-3 zone (CCMC §17.16.020(A)); c) The proposed uses are consistent with the intention to "provide living areas within the city where development provides for high density concentrations of dwelling units" (CCMC §17.16.0l0(A));
d) The proposed amendments would require all proposed projects within the R-3 Zoning District to be subject to all zoning regulations including a Site Plan & Architectural Design Review (CCMC §17.16.030) and CCMC §17.79 requirements.

WHEREAS, the Planning Commission finds that the proposed Rezoning Request and Resolution No. PC2024-04 Page 1 of 3 February 8, 2024
A Rezoning Request, Zoning Amendment, and General Plan Amendment For a (Phase 2) 40-unit Residential-Only Development
Zoning Amendment satisfies the objectives (CCMC §17.02.010), in that the amendments:
a) Provides a specific plan to guide the physical development of the city in such a manner as to achieve progressively the general arrangement of land uses depicted in the general plan (CCMC §17.02.0l0(A));
b) Encourages a wholesome, serviceable, and pleasant living environment and establishes a stability of existing land uses which conform with the objectives, policies, principles, and standards of the general plan (CCMC §17.02.0l0(B)); c) Prevents excessive population densities and overcrowding of land with structures (CCMC § 17.02.01 0(C));
d) Promotes the safe, effective traffic circulation system, provision of adequate off-street parking and truck loading facilities, and the appropriate location of community facilities (CCMC §17.02.0l0(D));
e) Protects and promotes properly located commercial and industrial activities in order to preserve and strengthen the city's economic base (CCMC §17.02.0IO(E)); f) Protects and enhances real property values and the city's natural assets (CCMC § 17.02.0IO(F)); and
g) Provides for the orderly development of new urban expansion that is logical, desirable, and in conformance with the objectives and policies of the general plan (CCMC § 17.02.01 0(G))
WHEREAS, the Planning Commission finds that the proposed General Plan Amendment satisfies the General Plan Amendment requirements (GP page 4), in that the amendment:
a) Must be flexible enough to respond to changing conditions and at the same time specific enough to provide predictability and consistency in guiding day-to-day land use and development decisions;
b) Needs to keep up with these changing conditions, community needs, and new opportunities that arise over the years;
c) Can be reviewed by the Planning Commission with the plan's implementation programs to assess the City's progress in carrying out the plan and updated as necessary;
d) Are often requested by private property owners and developers, to consider proposals for specific amendments to the plan;
e) Frequently involve changes in land use designations for individual parcels; f) Are subject to environmental review, public notice, and hearing requirements; and g) Must not create inconsistencies with other parts of the plan.

WHEREAS, the Planning Commission finds that two of the project area sides are adjacent to GC Designations, providing a transition of CG to MF 15-30 to MF 6-15 and similarly a transition of C-2 to R-3 to R-2, which is appropriate for this entire block section with a mixed designation and zoning. The parcel has remained mostly vacant for many years and now is proposed for an infill project that provides much needed housing, as identified in the City's 6th Cycle Housing Element.

WHEREAS, the Planning Commission finds that the proposed amendments proposed project is determined to be categorically exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) under Class 32 §15332 (In-fill Development) of the CEQA Guidelines.

Resolution No. PC2024-04 Page 2 o/3 February 8, 2024
Shamblin, Tinkler, Walp
None
None
Decossio, Wendt
A Rezoning Request, Zoning Amendment, and General Plan Amendment For a (Phase 2) 40-unit Residential-Only Development
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT HEREBY RESOLVED by the Planning Commission of the City of Crescent City recommends to the City Council for Consideration the Rezoning Request (Application RZ23-01), Zoning Amendment (Application ZA23-01), and General Plan Amendment (Application GPA23-02) for Sam Schauerman to construct a proposed Roosevelt Estates (Phase 2) 40-unit residential-only development located at 1405 California Street (APN 118-403-002).

PASSED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Planning Commission of the City of Crescent City held on this 8th day of February 2024, by the following polled vote.

AYES:

NOES:

ABSTAIN:

ABSENT:

Heather
ATTEST:
~ Welton, Community Development Specialist
Resolution No. PC2024-04 Page3 of3 February 8, 2024

CITY COUNCIL AGENDA REPORT
TO: MAYOR INSCORE AND MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL
FROM: ERIC WIER, CITY MANAGER
BY: ETHAN LAWTON, CONTRACT PLANNER

BOB BROWN, CONTRACT PLANNER
DATE: MARCH 18, 2024
SUBJECT: PUBLIC HEARING: ZONING MAP AMENDMENT – 1405 CALIFORNIA STREET
______________________________________________________________________

RECOMMENDATION
• Open public hearing
o Hear staff report
o Technical questions from the Council
o Receive public comment
• Close public hearing
• Further Council discussion
• Waive full reading, read by title only and adopt Ordinance No. 840, An Ordinance of the City Council of the City of Crescent City Amending the Zoning District Designation for 1405 California Street and the City’s Official Zoning Map

BACKGROUND
Sam Schauerman is the owner and developer of 1405 California Street (APN 118-403- 002-000). The parcel is currently split-zoned R-2/C-2. Schauerman is currently constructing 16 units on the lower portion of the parcel as allowed by the current zoning designation. He has submitted a Rezoning Request (Application RZ23-01), Zoning Map Amendment (Application ZA23-01), and General Plan Map Amendment (Application GPA23-02) to the Planning Commission to rezone 2.34 acres of the subject parcel currently zoned partially R-2 and partially C-2 to R-3. This change of zoning designation would allow Mr. Schauerman to construct 40 additional dwelling units (for a total of 56) on the parcel.

The Planning Commission held a duly noticed public hearing at its regular meeting of February 8, 2024. After considering the matter, the Planning Commission recommended approval of the rezoning request, zoning map amendment and general plan map amendment to the City Council by way of Resolution No. PC2024-04.

ZONING MAP AMENDMENT
MARCH 18, 2024
2 On February 20, 2024, the City Council introduced this ordinance as a precursor to this public hearing where the City Council will consider whether to adopt the ordinance and approve the zoning amendment.

ITEM ANALYSIS
The subject parcel is partially developed with a 7,050 SF commercial building (formerly California Auto Image) and is currently being developed with 16 residential units. By changing the zoning designation from R-2/C-2 to R-3 for the majority of the parcel (save the commercial building) would increase the allowable residential density. The project as presented includes 40 dwelling units in addition to the 16 currently being constructed. The total development will include 56 units comprised of 36 two-bedroom units and 20 threebedroom units.

In order to approve this zoning map change, the City Council must find that the zoning amendment is (1) consistent with the public health, safety and welfare (CCMC 17.58.010); (2) satisfies the purposes and objectives set forth in the Zoning Code (CCMC 17.02.010); and (3) consistent with the City’s R-3 (High-Density Residential District). These criteria will be addressed in detail at the public hearing.

If the City Council decides to approve the zoning map change, then the City Council must do so by adopting Ordinance No. 840. At this same meeting a public hearing will also be held on an amendment to the General Plan map, which is also required in order to accomplish this zoning designation change. The changes to the Zoning Map and the General Plan Map would be effective 30 days after adoption (April 17th).

FISCAL ANALYSIS
The only costs directly associated with adopting this ordinance is the publication of the ordinance summary in the newspaper post adoption.

ATTACHMENTS
• Ordinance No. 840 as introduced
• Planning Commission Staff Report February 8, 2024
• Resolution No. PC2024-04

ORDINANCE NO. 840

AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT CITY AMENDING THE ZONING DISTRICT DESIGNATION FOR 1405 CALIFORNIA STREET AND THE CITY’S OFFICIAL ZONING MAP
WHEREAS, the City of Crescent City is a general law city with the constitutional authority (“police power”) to make laws and regulations to protect the public health, safety and welfare; and
WHEREAS, the City establishes zoning districts by way of a Zoning Map which is adopted by ordinance; and
WHEREAS, the Planning Commission received an application to change the zoning district for a portion of APN 118-403-002-000 (1405 California Street) from the owner/developer; and
WHEREAS, the requested change was for 2.34 acres currently split zoned R-2 and C-2 to be rezoned to R-3 to allow for greater residential density; and WHEREAS, Planning Commission held a duly noticed public hearing, considered the request, and has made a formal recommendation with findings to the City Council by way of Resolution No. PC2024-04 to amend the zoning map; and WHEREAS, the City Council also held a duly noticed public hearing and considered the recommendation of the Planning Commission; and
WHEREAS, the City Council has determined the Zoning Map amendment is appropriate per the findings made herein; and
WHEREAS, it is necessary to adopt zoning changes by ordinance.

NOW, THEREFORE, the City Council of the City of Crescent City ordains as follows:

SECTION 1. RECITALS. The City Council finds the above recitals to be true and correct and are incorporated herein as if set forth in full.

SECTION 2. UNCODIFIED ORDINANCE AMENDMENT. This Ordinance is an uncodified ordinance of the City of Crescent City.

SECTION 3. FINDINGS. The City Council makes the following findings:

3.01 Public Health, Safety & Welfare. The public health, safety and general welfare warrant that the zoning change be approved. (CCMC § 17.58.010.)

3.02 Zoning Purposes & Objectives. The proposed Rezoning Request and Zoning Amendment satisfies the purposes and objectives set forth in the Zoning Code at CCMC § 17.02.010 in that the amendment:

Crescent City Ordinance No. 840 Page 2 of 4
A. Provides a specific plan to guide the physical development of the city in such a manner as to achieve progressively the general arrangement of land uses depicted in the general plan (CCMC § 17.02.010(A)); B. Encourages a wholesome, serviceable, and pleasant living environment and establishes a stability of existing land uses which conform with the objectives, policies, principles, and standards of the general plan (CCMC §

17.02.010(B));
C. Prevents excessive population densities and overcrowding of land with structures (CCMC § 17.02.010(C));
D. Promotes the safe, effective traffic circulation system, provision of adequate off-street parking and truck loading facilities, and the appropriate location of community facilities (CCMC § 17.02.010(D));
E. Protects and promotes properly located commercial and industrial activities in order to preserve and strengthen the city’s economic base (CCMC §

17.02.010(E));
F. Protects and enhances real property values and the city’s natural assets (CCMC § 17.02.010(F)); and
G. Provides for the orderly development of new urban expansion that is logical, desirable, and in conformance with the objectives and policies of the general plan (CCMC § 17.02.010(G)).

3.03 Zoning District Consistency. The proposed zoning amendment is consistent with the City’s High Density Residential District (R-3) Zoning Code, in that:

A. The proposed amendments are not located within the Coastal Zone and is not appealable to the Coastal Commission; and
B. The proposed uses will be consistent with the “multiple dwellings” which is principally permitted within the R-3 zone (CCMC § 17.16.020(A)); and C. The proposed uses are consistent with the intention to “provide living areas within the city where development provides for high density concentrations of dwelling units” (CCMC § 17.16.010(A)); and
D. The proposed amendments would require all proposed projects within the R-3 Zoning District to be subject to all zoning regulations including a Site Plan & Architectural Design Review (CCMC § 17.16.030) and CCMC §

17.79 requirements.

Crescent City Ordinance No. 840 Page 3 of 4
SECTION 4. ZONING MAP AMENDMENT. The Official Zoning Map of the City of Crescent City is hereby amended to rezone the southern 2.34 acres of APN 118-403- 002-000 (1405 California Street) currently split-zoned Moderate Density Residential (R2) / General Commercial (C-2) to High Density Residential (R-3) as follows:

Current Zoning (R-2/C-2) New Zoning (R-3)

SECTION 5. SEVERABILITY. If any part of this Ordinance is held to be invalid or inapplicable to any situation by a court of competent jurisdiction, such decision will not affect the validity of the remaining portions of this Ordinance or the applicability of this Ordinance to other situations.

SECTION 6. CEQA FINDINGS. This Ordinance has been reviewed for compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), and the CEQA Guidelines, and the City Council finds that the Planning Commission has already determined the change will allow development that is subject to a Class 32 exemption for infill development.

SECTION 7. EFFECTIVE DATE & PUBLICATION. This Ordinance will become effective 30 days after the date of its adoption. The City Clerk shall cause this ordinance to be published in a newspaper of general circulation in Del Norte County once within 15 days of its adoption in accordance with the requirements of Government Code Section 36933. [signature page to follow]
Crescent City Ordinance No. 840 Page 4 of 4
INTRODUCED at a meeting of the City Council of the City of Crescent City held on February 20, 2024.

PASSED AND ADOPTED by the City Council of the City of Crescent City at a regular meeting of the City Council held this 18th day of March 2024 by the following polled vote:

AYES:

NOES:

ABSENT:

ABSTAIN:

Blake Inscore, Mayor
ATTEST:

Robin Altman, City Clerk
APPROVED AS TO FORM:

Martha D. Rice, City Attorney

CITY OF CRESCENT CITY PLANNING COMMISSION

AND ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE
AGENDA ITEM: #1
Incorporated April 13, 1854 web: www.crescentcity.org
February 8, 2024 Page 1 of 14 RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02

STAFF REPORT
MEETING DATE: Thursday, February 8, 2024
TO: Planning Commission
FROM: Community Development Department, Planning & Zoning Ethan Lawton, City Planner / Consultant
SUBJECT: A Public Hearing to consider a Rezoning Request (Application RZ23- 01), a Zoning Map Amendment (Application ZA23-01), and a General Plan Map Amendment (Application GPA23-02) for Sam Schauerman’s proposed Roosevelt Estates (Phase 2) requesting 40-unit residential-only development located at 1405 California Street (APN 118-403-002).

SECTION 1: EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Sam Schauerman has submitted a Rezoning
Request (Application RZ23-01), a Zoning
Map Amendment (Application ZA23-01),
and a General Plan Map Amendment
(Application GPA23-02) for a proposed
Roosevelt Estates (Phase 2) requesting 40-
unit residential-only development on a
partially developed (Phase 1 = 16-units)
parcel within the R-2/C-2 Zoning (ModerateDensity Residential District/General Commercial District) located at 1405
California Street (APN 118-403-002).

STAFF RECOMMENDS: “Motion to adopt
Resolution No. PC2024-04, read by title only,
A Resolution of the Planning Commission of
the City of Crescent City Approving a
Rezoning Request, a Zoning Map
Amendment, and a General Plan Map
Amendment for a 40-unit residential-only
development.

ATTACHMENTS:

A) RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02
Application
B) Resolution PC2024-04
FIGURE 1-1: PROJECT LOCATION MAP
Source: Housing Element (December 2022)
City of Crescent City - Regular Planning Commission Meeting Staff Report - Agenda Item: #1
RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02 Page 2 of 14 February 8, 2024
SECTION 2: BACKGROUND INFORMATION
The proposed project parcel is partially developed with a 7050 square foot (sf) commercial building and is in the process of developing Phase 1 of the project, which consists of 16 residential units.

ADDRESS:
1405 California Street
Crescent City, CA 95531
APN:
118-403-002-000
PARCEL SIZE:
±2.78 acres
±121,097 sf
PROJECT SIZE:

2.34 acres
101,930 sf
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING:

A Notice of Public Hearing was submitted to the Del Norte Triplicate newspaper (on 01/11/24) to be published (on 01/24/24) in print/online circulation. A similar Notice of Public Hearing was mailed (on 01/22/24) to the property owners within 300-ft of the project location (CCMC §17.46.050) as required (Cal. Gov. Code §65090 & §65094).

REQUIRED FINDING #1 (BY THE COMMISSION):
□ The Planning Commission has considered this proposed project on this date at a duly noticed public hearing, staff report, and public testimony.

FIGURE 2-1: PROJECT PARCEL
Source: Parcel Quest (January 2024)
City of Crescent City - Regular Planning Commission Meeting Staff Report - Agenda Item: #1
February 8, 2024 Page 3 of 14 RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02
SECTION 3: PROPOSED PROJECT DESCRIPTION
Sam Schauerman has submitted a Rezoning Request (Application RZ23-01), a Zoning Map Amendment (Application ZA23-01), and a General Plan Map Amendment (Application GPA23- 02) for a proposed Roosevelt Estates (Phase 2) requesting 40-unit residential-only development on a partially developed (Phase 1 = 16-units) parcel within the R-2/C-2 Zoning (ModerateDensity Residential District/General Commercial District) located at 1405 California Street (APN 118-403-002). These requests aim to rezone/amend approximately 2.34 acres from R-2/C2 (Moderate-Density Residential District/General Commercial District) zoning designation to a R-3 (High-Density Residential District), which would increase the density, allowing for additional housing through the proposed 40-unit residential development. The C-2 portion of the property currently has an existing 7,050 sq. ft commercial building fronting Washington Blvd, which will remain zoned C-2. The portion of the property zoned C-2 is approximately 1.24 acres while the southerly area zoned R-2 is approximately 1.54 acres. The project in total proposes 56 residential units with 36 two-bedroom units and 20 three-bedroom units, including ten buildings (seven in Phase 2 and three buildings from Phase 1).

REQUIRED FINDING #2 (BY THE COMMISSION):
□ Sam Schauerman has submitted a Rezoning Request (Application RZ23-01), a Zoning Map Amendment (Application ZA23-01), and a General Plan Map Amendment (Application GPA23- 02) for a proposed Roosevelt Estates (Phase 2) requesting 40-unit residential-only development on a partially developed (Phase 1 = 16-units) parcel within the R-2/C-2 Zoning (ModerateDensity Residential District/General Commercial District) located at 1405 California Street (APN 118-403-002).

FIGURE 3-1: PROPOSED RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT
Source: Site Plan (January 23, 2024) See Attachment A: AR23-16 Application City of Crescent City - Regular Planning Commission Meeting Staff Report - Agenda Item: #1
RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02 Page 4 of 14 February 8, 2024
SECTION 4: GENERAL PLAN CONSISTENCY
The proposed 40-unit residential-only development is currently located on a single lot with mixed-designations, the northern portion being General Commercial (GC) and the southern portion being Residential Multi-Family 15-30 (MF 15-30) General Plan (GP) land use designation (See Figure 4-1: Section of General Plan Map).

FIGURE 4-1: SECTION OF GENERAL PLAN MAP
Source: General Plan Map (May 2001)
However, the applicant has submitted a GP Map Amendment (Application GPA23-02) to amend the GP land use designation to become Multi-Family Residential 15-30 (MF 15-30). (See Figure 4-2: Before General Plan Map Amendment and Figure 4-3: After General Plan Map Amendment)
FIGURE 4-2: BEFORE GENERAL PLAN MAP AMENDMENT
The (northern half) GC land use designation may grant
“residentials uses as a secondary/mixed use at a density of 12 units per acre” with a conditional use permit as the intended uses are to “provide the Crescent City Planning Area with goods, services, and jobs.”
The (southern half) MF 6-15 land use designation principally permits “clustered multiple-unit buildings” at “residential densities range from a minimum of six to a maximum of 15 dwelling units per acre” as the intended uses are to “provide for moderate to high density residential development within the urban boundary.” GC
MF
6-15
City of Crescent City - Regular Planning Commission Meeting Staff Report - Agenda Item: #1
February 8, 2024 Page 5 of 14 RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02
FIGURE 4-3: AFTER GENERAL PLAN MAP AMENDMENT
The (northern small portion) GC land use designation principally permits “commercial activities such as small retail stores and personal service shops” as the intended uses are to “provide the Crescent City Planning Area with goods, services, and jobs.” The (southern large portion) MF 15-30 land use designation principally permits “multiple-use buildings” at “residential range from a minimum of 15 to a maximum of 30 dwelling units per acre” as the intended uses are to “provide for high density residential development within the urban boundary.”
The proposed 40-unit residential-only development is a use consistent with the MF 15-30 GP land use designation and is relatively similar to some of the surrounding uses (See Table 4-1:

Comparison of surrounding Properties). Two of the sides are adjacent to GC Designations, providing a transition of CG to MF 15-30 to MF 6-15, which is appropriate for this entire block section with a mixed designation. The parcel has remained mostly vacant for many years and now is proposed for an infill project that provides much needed housing, as identified in the City’s 6th Cycle Housing Element.

TABLE 4-1: COMPARISON OF SURROUNDING PROPERTIES
Vicinity Land Use Designation Current Use
Project Property General Commercial (G-C) &
Multi-Family Residential (MF
6-15)
California Auto Image & (Phase 1) 16-
unit Residential
North General Commercial (G-C) &
Del Norte County
Del Norte Unified School District and
King of the Grind Boxing Club
South General Commercial District
(G-C) & Residential (SF 2-6)
Single Family Residential
East General Commercial (G-C) Uncharted Shores Academy & James C.

Standring Family Dentistry
West Residential (SF 2-6) Napa Auto Parts & Single Family Residential
SUPPORTING GENERAL PLAN GOALS/POLICIES:

Regarding General Plan Amendment Request:
-Goal 1.L. - “To provide for the on-going administration and implementation of the General Plan.”
-Policy 1.L.1. - “The City shall review the General Plan annually and revise it as deemed necessary.”
GC
MF
15-30
City of Crescent City - Regular Planning Commission Meeting Staff Report - Agenda Item: #1
RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02 Page 6 of 14 February 8, 2024
-Policy 1.L.2. - “The City shall not amend the General Plan more than four times per year. Each amendment, however, may include multiple changes.”
-Policy 1.L.3. - “The City shall conduct a major review of the General Plan, including the General Plan policy document and background report, every five years and revise it as deemed necessary.”
-Policy 1.L.4. - “The City shall review and amend, as necessary, applicable ordinances and regulations to ensure consistency with the General Plan.” Regarding the Reasons for the General Plan Amendment Request:
-Policy 1.A.2. - “The City shall encourage infill development that makes efficient use of existing public infrastructure and is compatible with existing development.” -Policy 1.A.3. - “The City shall encourage project sites to be designed to increase the convenience, safety, and comfort of people using public transportation, walking, or cycling.” -Goal 1.F - “To provide adequate land in a range of residential densities to accommodate the housing needs of all income groups expected to reside in Crescent City, while ensuring a high quality of residential development.”
-Policy 1.F.2. - “The City shall ensure that infill development (either new or rehabilitated residential structures) is compatible with the overall established character of residential neighborhoods.”
-Policy 1.F.3. - “The City shall encourage higher residential densities at locations where convenient access and adequate facilities, including parks and open space, are readily available.”
-Policy 2.A.2. - “The City and County will continue to encourage maximization of residential development potential and limit underutilization of land through project design review.” -Policy 2.B.9. - “The City and County shall continue to monitor housing activity on an annual basis to assess whether their respective needs projections for all income levels are being met by voluntary open market (rather than mandatory inclusion) as they have in the past.” -Goal C. - “To assist in the development of adequate housing to meet the needs of low/very low and moderate-income households.”
-Policy 2.D.1. - “The City and County shall continue to maintain opportunities for all income groups by use of clustered development to maximize density and minimize land development and/or construction costs.”
-Policy 4.A.2. - “The City shall encourage new development to contribute its fair share to providing all public services and infrastructure necessary to serve that development.” -Policy 4.E.5. - “The City shall encourage new project designs that minimize drainage concentrations and impervious coverage and maintain, to the extent feasible, natural site drainage conditions.”
REQUIRED FINDING #3 (BY THE COMMISSION):
□ The proposed project would be consistent with this revised Crescent City General Plan’s (MF 15-30) land use designation, in that the proposed project:
a) Would be principally permitted as “multiple-use buildings” within the MF 15-30; b) “Provide[s] for high density residential development within the urban boundary” within the MF 15-30; and
c) Is supported by the General Plan goals (1.F, C, G, and 1.L) and policies (1.A.2, 1.A.3,

1.F.2, 1.F.3, 2.A.2, 2.B.9, 2.D.1, 4.A.2, 4.E.5, 1.L.1, 1.L.2, 1L.3, and 1.L.4).

City of Crescent City - Regular Planning Commission Meeting Staff Report - Agenda Item: #1
February 8, 2024 Page 7 of 14 RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02
SECTION 5: ZONING CONSISTENCY
The proposed 40-unit residential-only development is currently located on a single lot with mixed-zones, the northern portion being General Commercial District (C-2) and the southern portion being Moderate-Density Residential District (R-2) (See Figure 5-1: Section of Zoning Map). The proposed project is not located within the Coastal Zone and is not appealable to the Coastal Commission.

FIGURE 5-1: SECTION OF ZONING MAP
Source: Zoning Map
(December 2007)
However, the applicant has submitted a Rezoning Request (Application RZ23-01) and Zoning Map Amendment (Application ZA23-01) to amend the Zoning designation to become HighDensity Residential District (R-3). (See Figure 5-2: Before Zoning Map Amendment and Figure 5-3: After Zoning Map Amendment).

FIGURE 5-2: BEFORE ZONING MAP AMENDMENT
The (northern half) C-2 zone allows “residential units up to thirty units per acre density, as either a mixed-use activity which is secondary to an existing or proposed commercial use, or as a residential-only development” with a conditional use permit (CCMC §17.22.020(B)(4)) as the intended uses are to “primarily to serve as the central trading area of the city (CCMC §17.22.010).” The (southern half) R-2 zone principally permits “multiple dwellings” (CCMC §17.14.020(A)(1)) at one “Dwelling Unit [per] Three thousand square feet” (CCMC §17.14.030(B)(5)) as the intended uses are to “provide living areas within the city where the residential density is of moderately dense concentrations” (CCMC §17.14.010(A)).

C-2
R-2
City of Crescent City - Regular Planning Commission Meeting Staff Report - Agenda Item: #1
RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02 Page 8 of 14 February 8, 2024
FIGURE 5-3: AFTER ZONING MAP AMENDMENT
The (northern small portion) C-2 zone principally permits “Services located inside a building” (CCMC §17.22.020(A)(2)) as the intended uses are to “primarily to serve as the central trading area of the city (CCMC §17.22.010).”
The (southern large portion) R-3 zone principally permits “multiple dwellings” (CCMC §17.16.020(A)) at “fifteen hundred square feet per dwelling unit” (CCMC §17.16.030(B)(6)) as the intended uses are to “provide living areas within the city where development provides for high density concentrations of dwelling units” (CCMC §17.16.010(A)). This portion is the proposed project area.

ZONING: The proposed 40-unit residential-only development is a use consistent with the R-3 Zoning District and is similar to some of the surrounding uses (See Table 5-1: Comparison of surrounding Properties). Two of the sides are adjacent to C-2 Zoning, which serves to provide a transition of C-2 to R-3 to R-2, which is appropriate for this entire block section with a mixed zoning. The parcel has remained mostly vacant for many years and now is proposed for an infill project that provides much needed housing, as identified in the City’s 6th Cycle Housing Element.

TABLE 5-1: COMPARISON OF SURROUNDING PROPERTIES
Vicinity Land Use Designation Current Use
Project Property General Commercial District (C-2) &
Moderate-Density Residential District
California Auto Image &
(Phase 1) 16-unit Residential
North General Commercial District (C-2) &
Del Norte County
Del Norte Unified School
District & Commercial
South Low-Density Residential District (R-1) Single Family Residential East General Commercial District (C-2) Uncharted Shores Academy & Standring Family Dentistry
West General Commercial District (C-2) &
Low-Density Residential District (R-1)
Napa Auto Parts & Single
Family Residential
DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS & PROPOSED PROJECT:

A. Height and Area Regulations: All permitted uses within the R-3 Zoning District are subject to height and area regulations and are addressed below (See Table 5-2: Comparison of Height and Area Regulations).

C-2
R-3
City of Crescent City - Regular Planning Commission Meeting Staff Report - Agenda Item: #1
February 8, 2024 Page 9 of 14 RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02
TABLE 5-2: COMPARISON OF HEIGHT AND AREA REGULATIONS
Zoning District Code Regulation Proposed
Height (CCMC §17.16.030(A)(1)) 35-ft 27-ft
Front Yard (CCMC §17.16.030(B)(1)) 10-ft 20-ft
[Exterior] Side Yard (CCMC §17.16.030(B)(2)) 5-ft 20-ft [Interior] Side Yard (CCMC §17.16.030(B)(2)) 5-ft 10-ft Rear Yard (CCMC §17.16.030(B)(3)) 10-ft 10-ft
Lot Area (CCMC §17.16.030(B)(5)) 6,000-sf 122,403-sf
Lot Coverage (CCMC §17.16.030(B)(6)) 65% 39.2%
B. Parking, Fencing, and Signs: All permitted uses within the R-3 Zoning District are subject to the general requirements regarding Parking (CCMC §17.16.070(A)), Fencing (CCMC §17.16.070(B)), and Signs (CCMC §17.16.070(c)) and are further addressed under Section 6: Site Plan & Architectural Design Review below.

C. Site Plan: All permitted uses within the R-3 Zoning District requires a Site Plan & Architectural Design Review (CCMC §17.16.080) and is further addressed under Section 6:

Site Plan & Architectural Design Review below.

REQUIRED FINDING #4 (BY THE COMMISSION):
□ The proposed amendments are consistent with the Crescent City’s High Density Residential District (R-3) Zoning Code, in that:
a) The proposed amendments are not located within the Coastal Zone and is not appealable to the Coastal Commission;
b) The proposed uses are consistent with the “multiple dwellings” which is principally permitted within the proposed R-3 zone (CCMC §17.16.020(A)); c) The proposed uses are consistent with the intention to “provide living areas within the city where development provides for high density concentrations of dwelling units” (CCMC §17.16.010(A));
d) The proposed amendments would require all proposed projects within the R-3 Zoning District to be subject to all zoning regulations including a Site Plan & Architectural Design Review (CCMC §17.16.030) and CCMC §17.79 requirements.

City of Crescent City - Regular Planning Commission Meeting Staff Report - Agenda Item: #1
RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02 Page 10 of 14 February 8, 2024 SECTION 6: REZONING REQUEST AND ZONING AMENDMENT
The proposed Rezoning Request and Zoning Map Amendment for Sam Schauerman’s proposed Roosevelt Estates (Phase 2) requesting 40-unit residential-only development located at 1405 California Street (APN 118-403-002) requiring the scheduled public hearing for the Planning Commission to determine whether the proposed Rezoning Request (Application RZ23-01) and Zoning Map Amendment (Application ZA23-01) (See Attachment A) shall be approved or denied (CCMC §17.02.040), based on the following standards.

The zoning title is adopted to preserve, protect, and promote public health, safety, peace, comfort, convenience, prosperity, and general welfare. More specifically, the title is adopted to achieve the following objectives (CCMC §17.02.010):

A. Guide Physical Development (CCMC §17.02.010(A)):

To provide a specific plan to guide the physical development of the city in such a manner as to achieve progressively the general arrangement of land uses depicted in the general plan.

B. Encourage and Establish (CCMC §17.02.010(B)):

To encourage a wholesome, serviceable, and pleasant living environment and to establish a stability of existing land uses which conform with the objectives, policies, principles, and standards of the general plan.

C. Prevention (CCMC §17.02.010(C)):

To prevent excessive population densities and overcrowding of land with structures.

D. Promote (CCMC §17.02.010(D)):

To promote the safe, effective traffic circulation system, the provision of adequate off-street parking and truck loading facilities and the appropriate location of community facilities.

E. Preserve and Strengthen (CCMC §17.02.010(E)):

To protect and promote properly located commercial and industrial activities in order to preserve and strengthen the city’s economic base.

F. Protect and Enhance (CCMC §17.02.010(F)):

To protect and enhance real property values and the city’s natural assets.

G. Orderly Development (CCMC §17.02.010(G)):

To provide for the orderly development of new urban expansion that is logical, desirable, and in conformance with the objectives and policies of the general plan.

If, in accordance with the provisions of this title and state statutes, changes are made in the district boundaries or other matter portrayed on the official zoning map, such changes shall be made on the official zoning map promptly after the amendment has been approved by the city council (CCMC §17.08.040).

City of Crescent City - Regular Planning Commission Meeting Staff Report - Agenda Item: #1
February 8, 2024 Page 11 of 14 RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02 Upon completion of the redrafting of the map, the planning director shall, with their signature, file said map with the city council and the city clerk which will then constitute the official zoning map of the city (CCMC §17.08.040).

REQUIRED FINDING #5 (BY THE COMMISSION):
□ The proposed Rezoning Request and Zoning Amendment satisfies the objectives (CCMC §17.02.010), in that the amendments:
a) Provides a specific plan to guide the physical development of the city in such a manner as to achieve progressively the general arrangement of land uses depicted in the general plan (CCMC §17.02.010(A));
b) Encourages a wholesome, serviceable, and pleasant living environment and establishes a stability of existing land uses which conform with the objectives, policies, principles, and standards of the general plan (CCMC §17.02.010(B)); c) Prevents excessive population densities and overcrowding of land with structures (CCMC §17.02.010(C));
d) Promotes the safe, effective traffic circulation system, provision of adequate off-street parking and truck loading facilities, and the appropriate location of community facilities (CCMC §17.02.010(D));
e) Protects and promotes properly located commercial and industrial activities in order to preserve and strengthen the city’s economic base (CCMC §17.02.010(E)); f) Protects and enhances real property values and the city’s natural assets (CCMC §17.02.010(F)); and
g) Provides for the orderly development of new urban expansion that is logical, desirable, and in conformance with the objectives and policies of the general plan (CCMC §17.02.010(G)).

SECTION 7: GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT
The proposed General Plan Map Amendment for Sam Schauerman’s proposed Roosevelt Estates (Phase 2) requesting 40-unit residential-only development located at 1405 California Street (APN 118-403-002) requiring the scheduled public hearing for the Planning Commission to determine whether the proposed General Plan Amendment (Application GPA23-02) (See Attachment A) shall be approved or denied based on the following standards:

A. GP Revisions. The General Plan is a long-term document with a planning horizon of 15-25 years. To achieve its purposes, the plan must be flexible enough to respond to changing conditions and at the same time specific enough to provide predictability and consistency in guiding day-to-day land use and development decisions. Over the years, conditions and community needs change and new opportunities arise; the plan needs to keep up with these changes and new opportunities. (GP page 4)
B. GP Review. Every year, the Planning Commission should review the plan’s implementation programs to assess the City’s progress in carrying out the plan. Every five to ten years, the plan should be thoroughly reviewed and updated as necessary. (GP page 4) City of Crescent City - Regular Planning Commission Meeting Staff Report - Agenda Item: #1
RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02 Page 12 of 14 February 8, 2024 C. GP Amendments. From time to time, the City will be asked to consider proposals for specific amendments to the plan. The City will initiate some of these proposals itself but will be initiated by private property owners and developers. Most General Plan amendments involve changes in land use designations for individual parcels. (GP page 4) D. State Law. State laws limit General Plan amendments to four times per year, but each amendment can include multiple changes. Like the adoption of the General Plan itself, general amendments are subject to environmental review, public notice, and hearing requirements and must not create inconsistencies with other parts of the plan. (GP page 4) REQUIRED FINDING #6 (BY THE COMMISSION):
□ The proposed General Plan Amendment satisfies the General Plan Amendment requirements (GP page 4), in that the amendment:
a) Must be flexible enough to respond to changing conditions and at the same time specific enough to provide predictability and consistency in guiding day-to-day land use and development decisions;
b) Needs to keep up with these changing conditions, community needs, and new opportunities that arise over the years;
c) Can be reviewed by the Planning Commission with the plan’s implementation programs to assess the City’s progress in carrying out the plan and updated as necessary; d) Are often requested by private property owners and developers, to consider proposals for specific amendments to the plan;
e) Frequently involve changes in land use designations for individual parcels; f) Are subject to environmental review, public notice, and hearing requirements; and g) Must not create inconsistencies with other parts of the plan.

SECTION 8: ENVIRONMENTAL DETERMINATION SUMMARY
The proposed project is determined to be categorically exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to following sections of the CEQA Guidelines:

A. Class 32 §15332. In-Fill Development Projects, consists of the proposed project:

1. Is consistent with the applicable general plan designation, policies, and zoning designation and regulations:

The proposed project is consistent with the Crescent City General Plan’s Residential Multifamily (15-30) land use designation (incorporating the General Plan Amendment) and is consistent with the Crescent City’s High-Density Residential District (R-3) Zoning Code (with Zoning Amendment, Site Plan & Architectural Design Review);

2. Development occurs within city limits on a project site (<5 acres) substantially surrounded by urban uses:

The project site is located in the City of Crescent City, is approximately 2.78 acres, and is located adjacent to existing residential/commercial uses;

3. Site has no value, as habitat for endangered, rare, or threatened species:

City of Crescent City - Regular Planning Commission Meeting Staff Report - Agenda Item: #1
February 8, 2024 Page 13 of 14 RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02 The project will be located on a site that has had past disturbances, is partially developed and contains no habitat value for rare, threatened, or endangered species;

4. Approval would not result in any significant effects relating to traffic, noise, air quality, or water quality:

The project proposes a residential use in a developed residential/commercial area that already services residential/commercial use and has a limited potential to result in significant traffic, noise, air quality, or water quality impacts;

5. Site can be adequately served by all required utilities and public services:

The site is surrounded by and is already adequately served by utilities and public services.

REQUIRED FINDING #7 (BY THE COMMISSION):
□ The proposed project is determined to be categorically exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) under Class 32 §15332 (In-fill Development) of the CEQA Guidelines.

SECTION 9: PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION OPTIONS
A. APPROVAL. Making all the required findings.
• “I move to adopt Resolution No. PC2024-04, read by title only, A Resolution of the Planning Commission of the City of Crescent City Approving a Rezoning Request, a Zoning Map Amendment, and a General Plan Map Amendment for a for a 40- unit residential-only development.”
• Planning staff will send the applicant an approval letter, after the 10-day appeal period (CCMC §17.46.050), along with the resolution, as adopted by the Planning Commission during the public hearing. The resolution will be sent to the City Council and scheduled for consideration.

B. DENIAL. Denying one, or more, of the required findings. • “I move to deny the Rezoning Request (Application RZ23-01), Zoning Map Amendment (Application ZA23-01), and/or General Plan Map Amendment (Application GPA23-02) due to the requirements not being fully satisfied, specifically regarding ________.”
• Planning staff will send the applicant a denial letter stating why the application was denied. The applicant would not be allowed to build the residential accessory structure.

C. REQUEST ADDITIONAL INFORMATION. Requiring additional information to make the necessary findings.
• “I move to request additional information regarding __________ be brought back to the February 22, 2024 (or, time certain, Special) Planning Commission meeting for consideration.”
• Planning staff will follow up with the applicant requesting any additional information, which will continue this item on the next scheduled Planning Commission meeting agenda (CCMC §17.46.050) scheduled for Thursday, February 22, 2024 or a specific alternative Special Planning Commission meeting.

City of Crescent City - Regular Planning Commission Meeting Staff Report - Agenda Item: #1
RZ23-01/ZA23-01/GPA23-02 Page 14 of 14 February 8, 2024 SECTION 10: STAFF RECOMMENDATION

1. (Chair) “Agenized Item #1: A Public Hearing to consider a Rezoning Request (Application RZ23-01), a Zoning Map Amendment (Application ZA23-01), and a General Plan Map Amendment (Application GPA23-02) for Sam Schauerman’s proposed Roosevelt Estates (Phase 2) requesting 40-unit residential-only development located at 1405 California Street (APN 118-403-002).”

2. (Chair) “I will open the Public Hearing.”

3. (Chair) “We will now receive a presentation on the Staff Report from Planner Lawton.”

4. (Chair) “Does any Commissioners have any clarifying questions for staff?” a. (Chair) “Does the Applicant wish to address the Planning Commission?”

5. (Chair) “I will open Public Comment, which we will receive at the podium.” a. “We request that (1) you state your name and residency, (2) subject to a three-minute comment be directed to the Planning Commission for consideration, and (3) please state if you are for-or-against the proposed project.”
b. (Chair) Any clarifying questions?

6. (Chair) “I will close Public Comment.”

7. (Chair) “Is there any discussion on this item from the Commissioners?”

8. (Chair) “I believe a motion would be in order.”
a. (Commissioner) “I move to adopt Resolution No. PC2024-04, read by title only, A Resolution of the Planning Commission of the City of Crescent City Approving a Rezoning Request, a Zoning Map Amendment, and a General Plan Map Amendment for a for a 40-unit residential-only development.”
b. Note: Any changes should be included in the motion.

9. (Chair) “A motion has been made by Commissioner _________. Is there a second?”

10. (Chair) “It was seconded by Commissioner __________.”

11. (Chair) “A motion was made and seconded to: Adopt Resolution No. PC2024-04, read by title only, A Resolution of the Planning Commission of the City of Crescent City Approving a Rezoning Request, a Zoning Map Amendment, and a General Plan Map Amendment for a for a 40-unit residential-only development.”
a. Note: Any changes should be included in the motion.

12. (Chair) “Is there any additional discussion from the Commissioners on the motion?”

13. (Chair) “Seeing as there is no further discussion, it is time for a vote on the motion, Specialist Welton, can you poll the vote?”

14. (Chair) “The motion passes (or fails) by a vote of ___-to-___.” (Example 5-0) --- END OF REPORT ---
Incorporated .·lpril 13. 185-1

CITY OF CRESCENT CITY

PLANNING COMMISSION AND

ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE
RESOLUTION NO. PC2024-04

A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT

CITY RECOMMENDING TO THE CITY COUNCIL A REZONING REQUEST, ZONING AMENDMENT, AND GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT FOR A 40-UNIT

RESIDENTIAL-ONLY DEVELOPMENT
WHEREAS, Sam Schauerman has submitted a Rezoning Request (Application RZ23-0l), a Zoning Amendment (Application ZA23-01), and a General Plan Amendment (Application GPA23-02) for a proposed Roosevelt Estates (Phase 2) requesting 40-unit residential-only development on a partially developed (Phase I= 16-units) parcel within the R-2/C-2 Zoning (Moderate-Density Residential District/General Commercial District) located at 1405 California Street (APN 118-403-002);
WHEREAS, the Planning Commission has considered this proposed project on this date at a duly noticed public hearing, staff report, and public testimony; WHEREAS, the Planning Commission finds that the proposed amendments are consistent with the Crescent City General Plan's (MF 15-30) land use designation, in that the proposed project:
a) will result in principally permitted "multiple-family buildings" within the MF 15- 3 0 designation;
b) "Provide[ s] for high density residential development within the urban boundary" within the MF 15-30; and
c) Is supported by the General Plan goals ( 1.F, C, G, and l .L) and policies ( 1.A.2, l.A.3, l.F.2, l.F.3, 2.A.2, 2.B.9, 2.D.1, 4.A.2, 4.E.5, l.L.1, l.L.2, IL.3, and l.L.4).

WHEREAS, the Planning Commission finds that the proposed amendments are consistent with the Crescent City's High Density Residential District (R-3) Zoning Code, in that:
a) The proposed amendments are not located within the Coastal Zone and is not appealable to the Coastal Commission;
b) The proposed uses will be consistent with the "multiple dwellings" which is principally permitted within the R-3 zone (CCMC §17.16.020(A)); c) The proposed uses are consistent with the intention to "provide living areas within the city where development provides for high density concentrations of dwelling units" (CCMC §17.16.0l0(A));
d) The proposed amendments would require all proposed projects within the R-3 Zoning District to be subject to all zoning regulations including a Site Plan & Architectural Design Review (CCMC §17.16.030) and CCMC §17.79 requirements.

WHEREAS, the Planning Commission finds that the proposed Rezoning Request and Resolution No. PC2024-04 Page 1 of 3 February 8, 2024
A Rezoning Request, Zoning Amendment, and General Plan Amendment For a (Phase 2) 40-unit Residential-Only Development
Zoning Amendment satisfies the objectives (CCMC §17.02.010), in that the amendments:
a) Provides a specific plan to guide the physical development of the city in such a manner as to achieve progressively the general arrangement of land uses depicted in the general plan (CCMC §17.02.0l0(A));
b) Encourages a wholesome, serviceable, and pleasant living environment and establishes a stability of existing land uses which conform with the objectives, policies, principles, and standards of the general plan (CCMC §17.02.0l0(B)); c) Prevents excessive population densities and overcrowding of land with structures (CCMC § 17.02.01 0(C));
d) Promotes the safe, effective traffic circulation system, provision of adequate off-street parking and truck loading facilities, and the appropriate location of community facilities (CCMC §17.02.0l0(D));
e) Protects and promotes properly located commercial and industrial activities in order to preserve and strengthen the city's economic base (CCMC §17.02.0IO(E)); f) Protects and enhances real property values and the city's natural assets (CCMC § 17.02.0IO(F)); and
g) Provides for the orderly development of new urban expansion that is logical, desirable, and in conformance with the objectives and policies of the general plan (CCMC § 17.02.01 0(G))
WHEREAS, the Planning Commission finds that the proposed General Plan Amendment satisfies the General Plan Amendment requirements (GP page 4), in that the amendment:
a) Must be flexible enough to respond to changing conditions and at the same time specific enough to provide predictability and consistency in guiding day-to-day land use and development decisions;
b) Needs to keep up with these changing conditions, community needs, and new opportunities that arise over the years;
c) Can be reviewed by the Planning Commission with the plan's implementation programs to assess the City's progress in carrying out the plan and updated as necessary;
d) Are often requested by private property owners and developers, to consider proposals for specific amendments to the plan;
e) Frequently involve changes in land use designations for individual parcels; f) Are subject to environmental review, public notice, and hearing requirements; and g) Must not create inconsistencies with other parts of the plan.

WHEREAS, the Planning Commission finds that two of the project area sides are adjacent to GC Designations, providing a transition of CG to MF 15-30 to MF 6-15 and similarly a transition of C-2 to R-3 to R-2, which is appropriate for this entire block section with a mixed designation and zoning. The parcel has remained mostly vacant for many years and now is proposed for an infill project that provides much needed housing, as identified in the City's 6th Cycle Housing Element.

WHEREAS, the Planning Commission finds that the proposed amendments proposed project is determined to be categorically exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) under Class 32 §15332 (In-fill Development) of the CEQA Guidelines.

Resolution No. PC2024-04 Page 2 o/3 February 8, 2024
Shamblin, Tinkler, Walp
None
None
Decossio, Wendt
A Rezoning Request, Zoning Amendment, and General Plan Amendment For a (Phase 2) 40-unit Residential-Only Development
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT HEREBY RESOLVED by the Planning Commission of the City of Crescent City recommends to the City Council for Consideration the Rezoning Request (Application RZ23-01), Zoning Amendment (Application ZA23-01), and General Plan Amendment (Application GPA23-02) for Sam Schauerman to construct a proposed Roosevelt Estates (Phase 2) 40-unit residential-only development located at 1405 California Street (APN 118-403-002).

PASSED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Planning Commission of the City of Crescent City held on this 8th day of February 2024, by the following polled vote.

AYES:

NOES:

ABSTAIN:

ABSENT:

Heather
ATTEST:
~ Welton, Community Development Specialist
Resolution No. PC2024-04 Page3 of3 February 8, 2024

CITY COUNCIL AGENDA REPORT
TO: MAYOR INSCORE AND MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL
FROM: ERIC WIER, CITY MANAGER
BY: ETHAN LAWTON, CONTRACT PLANNER
MARTHA D. RICE, CITY ATTORNEY
DATE: MARCH 18, 2024
SUBJECT: MUNICIPAL CODE UPDATE: SIGN REGULATIONS (CH. 17.39) ______________________________________________________________________

RECOMMENDATION
• Open public hearing
o Hear staff report
o Technical questions from Council
o Receive public comment
• Close public hearing
• Further Council discussion
• Waive full reading, read by title only and adopt Ordinance No. 839, An Ordinance of the City Council of the City of Crescent City Amending Chapter 17.39, Signs, of Title 17, Zoning, of the Crescent City Municipal Code

BACKGROUND
At the February 20, 2024 City Council meeting, the City Council introduced Ordinance No. 839, Amending Chapter 17.39, Signs, of Title 17 of municipal code. The ordinance included Planning Commission recommendations on modifications to the City’s sign regulations.

ITEM ANALYSIS
The ordinance as introduced contained seven revisions to Chapter 17.39, as follows:

Additions in bold underline
Deletions in bold italic strikethrough
Revision #1: Add Not Otherwise Specified sign type for the Community Development Director to determine the applicable criteria based on similarity to other defined signage:
§ 17.39.040 Types—Generally.

SIGNS ORDINANCE ADOPTION
MARCH 18, 2024
2 The types of signs set forth in this section will be permitted for the various uses allowed in Sections 17.39.110 through 17.39.140 and must be limited to the restrictions set forth in Section 17.39.020, in addition to those required in Sections

17.39.050 through 17.39.080. Additional special use signs are also listed in this section.
--
“I. Not Otherwise Specified. Any sign that is not otherwise defined above, may be reviewed by the Community Development Director for a determination as to which approval criteria shall apply based upon the similarity of characteristics of the undefined sign as compared to those sign types that are defined.”
Revision #2: Remove the cap on temporary sign permits allowed by any one commercial establishment in a calendar year:
§ 17.39.070 Temporary permit required when.

The following types of signs and advertising devices are permitted with the issuance of a temporary permit from the community development department. The permit may impose conditions on the size, placement, structure, color, copy, conditions of removal or any other aspect of the display at the discretion of the community development director. Balloons may also be subject to approval by the building inspector, at his or her recommendation. A fee may be charged by the building department if an inspection of the balloon attachment is required. Any one commercial establishment may obtain a temporary sign permit under these regulations no more than three times in one calendar year. --
Revision #3: Increase the timeframe for grand opening signs from 30 days to 90 days:
§ 17.39.070 Temporary permit required when.
--
A. Grand Opening Signs, Banners or Balloons. Pennants, signs, banners and/or balloons for the promotion of the grand opening of a new business for a period of not more than the first thirty ninety business days of a new business. A use permit must be granted by the planning commission in order to display such devices for any longer than thirty ninety days;
--
Revision #4: Increase the timeframe for promotional signs from 5 days to 30 days:
§ 17.39.070 Temporary permit required when.
--

SIGNS ORDINANCE ADOPTION
MARCH 18, 2024
3 B. Promotional Signs, Banners or Balloons. Signs, banners, balloons, pennants or other advertising devices for the promotion of special sales or other business events lasting for a period of up to five thirty days not more than three times in one calendar year.

Revision #5: Broaden temporary or seasonal sales booth types to include more uses:
§ 17.39.170 Exempt signs.

Except for the regulation relating to construction, maintenance, public nuisance and safety the following types of nonilluminated signs shall be allowed without a sign permit and shall not be included in the determination of the type, number or area of signs allowed per business or parcel, or by zoning district:
--
Q. Temporary or Seasonal Sales Booths. Signs including, but not limited to fireworks stands, pumpkin sales, Christmas tree lots, community crafts fairs, and temporary certified farmer’s markets, and similar signs; --
Revision #6: Allow wind-blown signs with a use permit:
§ 17.39.080 Prohibited signs.

In addition to any sign or advertising display device not specifically allowed by these provisions, the following signs are prohibited.
--
B. Moving signs having one or a combination of the following characteristics:
--

2. Wind-blown devices such as streamers, balloons, flares, pennants, propellers and similar attention-getting displays or devices with the exception of the following:
--
e. Wind-blown signs obtained through a use permit.
--
Revision #7: Expand permitted portable or temporary sign use beyond grand openings or special promotions:
§ 17.39.080 Prohibited signs.

In addition to any sign or advertising display device not specifically allowed by these provisions, the following signs are prohibited.
--
C. Portable or temporary signs, including sandwich boards, except as permitted only for grand openings or special promotions;
--

SIGNS ORDINANCE ADOPTION
MARCH 18, 2024
4 If the ordinance is adopted this evening, then it will take effect April 17, 2024. Staff has also received direction to (1) consider implement of an administrative CUP process to decrease the time and cost required to get a sign CUP, and (2) establish a corresponding fee for the administrative sign CUP (less than standard CUP fee).

FISCAL ANALYSIS
The direct costs associated with adopting this ordinance is the publication of the notice of public hearing in the newspaper prior to adoption.

STRATEGIC PLAN ASSESSMENT
The revisions to the sign ordinance are consistent with the following strategic plan goals:
• Goal 2: Promote a Thriving Local Economy - Evaluating and updating the City’s Municipal Code to assure maximized efficiencies, clarity, and effectiveness.

ATTACHMENTS
• Ordinance No. 839
ORDINANCE NO. 839

AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CRESCENT CITY AMENDING CHAPTER 17.39, SIGNS, OF TITLE 17, ZONING,

OF THE CRESCENT CITY MUNICIPAL CODE
WHEREAS, the City of Crescent City is a general law city with the constitutional authority (“police power”) to make laws and regulations to protect the public health, safety and welfare; and
WHEREAS, Title 17 of the Crescent City Municipal Code sets for the zoning regulations of the City; and
WHEREAS, Chapter 17.39 pertains to the regulation of signs; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission has reviewed Chapter 17.39 and formally made recommendations for revisions to the City Council; and
WHEREAS, the City Council has considered those recommendations and held a public hearing thereon.

NOW, THEREFORE, the City Council of the City of Crescent City ordains as follows:

SECTION 1. RECITALS. The City Council finds the above recitals to be true and correct and are incorporated herein as if set forth in full.

SECTION 2. CODE AMENDMENT.

2.01 Section 17.39.040 Amendment. Section 17.39.040, Types-Generally, of Chapter 17.39, Signs, of Title 17, Zoning, of the Crescent City Municipal Code is hereby amended by adding subsection “I” to read as follows:

I. Not Otherwise Specified. Any sign that is not otherwise defined above, may be reviewed by the Community Development Director for a determination as to which approval criteria shall apply based upon the similarity of characteristics of the undefined sign as compared to those sign types that are defined.

2.02 Section 17.39.070 Amendment. Section 17.39.070, Temporary Permit Required When, of Chapter 17.39, Signs, of Title 17 Zoning, Crescent City Municipal Code, is hereby amended to read as follows:
§ 17.39.070 Temporary permit required when.

The following types of signs and advertising devices are permitted with the issuance of a temporary permit from the community development department. The permit may impose conditions on the size, placement, structure, color, copy, conditions of removal or any other aspect of the display at the discretion of the community development director. Balloons may also be subject to approval by the building inspector, at his or her Crescent City Ordinance No. 839 Page 2 of 3
recommendation. A fee may be charged by the building department if an inspection of the balloon attachment is required.

A. Grand Opening Signs, Banners or Balloons. Pennants, signs, banners and/or balloons for the promotion of the grand opening of a new business for a period of not more than the first ninety business days of a new business. A use permit must be granted by the planning commission in order to display such devices for any longer than ninety days; B. Promotional Signs, Banners or Balloons. Signs, banners, balloons, pennants or other advertising devices for the promotion of special sales or other business events lasting for a period of up to thirty days.

2.03 Section 17.39.080 Amendments. Section 17.39.080, Prohibited Signs, of Chapter 17.39, Signs, of Title 17 Zoning, of the Crescent City Municipal Code is hereby amended as follows:

2.03.1 Subsection C is amended to read as follows:

C. Portable or temporary signs, including sandwich boards, except as permitted;

2.03.2 Subparagraph “e” is added to paragraph 2 of subsection B to read as follows:
e. Wind-blown signs obtained through a use permit.

2.04 Section 17.39.170 Amendment. Section 17.39.170, Exempt Signs, of the Crescent City Municipal Code is hereby amended by revising subsection Q to read as follows:

Q. Temporary or Seasonal Sales Booths. Signs including, but not limited to fireworks stands, pumpkin sales, Christmas tree lots, community crafts fairs, temporary certified farmer’s markets, and similar signs; ***END TEXT AMENDMENT***
SECTION 3. SEVERABILITY. If any part of this Ordinance is held to be invalid or inapplicable to any situation by a court of competent jurisdiction, such decision will not affect the validity of the remaining portions of this Ordinance or the applicability of this Ordinance to other situations.

SECTION 4. CEQA FINDINGS. This Ordinance has been reviewed for compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), and the CEQA Guidelines, and has been found to be exempt from CEQA under Section 15061(b)(3) as this ordinance does not have the potential for causing a significant effect on the environment.

SECTION 5. EFFECTIVE DATE & PUBLICATION. This Ordinance will become effective 30 days after the date of its adoption. The City Clerk shall cause this ordinance to be Crescent City Ordinance No. 839 Page 3 of 3
published in a newspaper of general circulation in Del Norte County once within 15 days of its adoption in accordance with the requirements of Government Code Section 36933.

INTRODUCED at a meeting of the City Council of the City of Crescent City held on February 20, 2024.

PASSED AND ADOPTED by the City Council of the City of Crescent City at a regular meeting of the City Council held this 18th day of March 2024 by the following polled vote:

AYES:

NOES:

ABSENT:

ABSTAIN:

Blake Inscore, Mayor
ATTEST:

Robin Altman, City Clerk
APPROVED AS TO FORM:

Martha D. Rice, City Attorney

MINUTES
Crescent City Housing Authority

REGULAR MEETING
December 18, 2023 AT 6:00 P.M.

FLYNN CENTER, 981 H STREET, CRESCENT CITY, CA 95531
CALL TO ORDER Chairman Inscore called the meeting to order at 7:06 pm ROLL CALL Directors present: Director Jason Greenough, Director Kelly Schellong, Director Isaiah Wright, Vice-Chair Ray Altman, and Chairman Blake Inscore
Staff members present: Board Secretary Robin Altman, City Attorney Martha Rice, and Housing Authority Executive Director Megan Miller

CONSENT

14. Consent to Assignment of Section 8 HAP Contract for Valhalla Townhomes • Recommendation: Ratify the Housing Director’s execution of the Assignment, Assumption and Amendment Agreement – Section 8 Housing Assistance Payments Contract
On a motion by Director Greenough, seconded by Director Wright, and carried unanimously on a 5-0 polled vote, the Crescent City Housing Authority Board of Directors adopted the consent calendar as presented.

Dorothy Riley: asked how this type of housing or services can be given to someone who has been forced into homelessness from the police with psych-ops by Cointelpro. Spoke of psyche warfare and being a targeted individual.

ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business to come before the Housing Authority Board of Directors, Chairman Inscore adjourned the meeting at 7:09 p.m. to the next meeting of the Crescent City Housing Authority scheduled for Monday, January 15, 2024 at 6:00 p.m. at the Flynn Center, 981 H Street, Crescent City, CA 95531
ATTEST:
_______________________
Robin Altman
City Clerk/Administrative Analyst

HOUSING AUTHORITY AGENDA REPORT
TO: CHAIR INSCORE AND BOARD DIRECTORS
FROM: ERIC WIER, CITY MANAGER
BY: MEGAN MILLER, HOUSING DIRECTOR
DATE: MARCH 18, 2024
SUBJECT: ANNUAL PLAN SUBMISSION FYB24
______________________________________________________________________

RECOMMENDATION
• Open public hearing
• Hear staff report
• Technical questions from the Board
• Receive public comment
• Close public hearing
• Further Board discussion
• Consider and adopt Resolution No. HA2024-01, a resolution of Crescent City Housing Authority approving and authorizing execution of the FY24 PHA Annual Plan and certifying compliance of the Plan and its related regulations to the Department of Housing and Urban Development.

BACKGROUND
The PHA Plan is a comprehensive guide to public housing agency (PHA) policies, programs, operations, and strategies for meeting local housing needs and goals. There are two parts to the PHA Plan: the 5-Year Plan, which the PHA develops once every 5th fiscal year (our last 5-Year Plan was completed in 2020) and the Annual Plan, which is prepared by the PHA every year. The Annual Plan is designed to keep the public, the Board, and HUD updated on the PHA’s progress in meeting the goals that were established in the 5-Year Plan, and to identify changes in administrative policies, agency priorities, or new activities where they may have occurred since the time of the last Plan submission.

The Annual Plan is submitted to HUD on a streamlined template which includes specific Plan elements and information on where certain Plan elements that are not required to be reviewed by HUD can be obtained locally. The entire PHA Plan, including all required elements, is made available locally at the Crescent City Housing Authority office and on the City website.

The Plan consists of several components, including the disclosure of financial resources, policy changes, and certification of compliance. A progress statement on the goals outlined in the most recent 5-Year Plan is also included.

FISCAL IMPACT
NONE

ATTACHMENTS
• HUD Form 50075-HP Streamlined Annual PHA Plan Template • Statement of Housing Needs and Strategy for Addressing Housing Needs • Deconcentration Policy
• Statement of Financial Resources for FY24
• Significant Amendment Definition
• Resolution No. HA2024-01: PHA Certification of Compliance with PHA Plans and Related Regulations including Required Civil Rights Certifications (HUD-Form 50077-HCV-HP) to be signed by Chair Inscore
• Certification by State or Local Official of PHA Plans Consistency with the Consolidated Plan or State Consolidated Plan (HUD-Form 50077-SL) to be signed by Chair Inscore
• Resident Advisory Board and Housing Advisory Commission letter of recommendation to Board for approval of proposed PHA Plan

CITY COUNCIL AGENDA REPORT
TO: MAYOR INSCORE AND MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL
FROM: ERIC WIER, CITY MANAGER
BY: MARTHA D. RICE, CITY ATTORNEY
DATE: MARCH 18, 2024
SUBJECT: DISCUSSION REGARDING THE USE OF ZOOM AT PUBLIC MEETINGS ______________________________________________________________________

RECOMMENDATION
• Hear staff report
• Technical questions from Council
• Receive public comment
• Further Council discussion
• Give direction to staff regarding the use of Zoom during public meetings

BACKGROUND
As a result of the COVID-19 pandemic and the resultant restrictions regarding public gatherings and physical distancing requirements, public agencies had to change the way that they did business in order to continue to function safely. Governor Newsom issued Executive Orders allowing for flexibility in the way that local governments were allowed to conduct public meetings. Like many cities, Crescent City began utilizing the Zoom platform to conduct both non-public and public meetings. This virtual meeting space not only assisted City staff in performing the day-to-day business of the City, it also allowed the City Council, the Planning Commission, and the Measure S Oversight Committee to conduct public meetings with participation from the public, all from the safety of their own homes or work spaces.

During the pandemic, the City experienced an increase in public engagement during City Council meetings. This was, generally speaking, a positive result of the new virtual meeting platform. Public meetings were now even more accessible to the public than ever before. And for this reason, the City Council has continued to offer participation through Zoom despite the fact that the City Council has been meeting in-person since March 7, 2022.

Unfortunately, the City has now been the subject of two orchestrated verbal attacks during public comment whereby persons have taken advantage of the online platform and joined the meeting from locations across the nation. Their comments have been filled with hateful, racist, misogynistic, and anti-Semitic rhetoric, racial slurs, vulgar language and

ZOOM DISCUSSION
MARCH 18, 2024
2 conspiracy theories that perpetuate hate. The individuals that spoke during public comment were not members of our local community.

ITEM ANALYSIS
The discussion for the City Council this evening is to decide if they would like to continue to offer the general public the opportunity to participate in public meetings (and provide public comments) via Zoom. The City is under no obligation to do so and has seen a dramatic decrease in the number of persons participating virtually. The City will continue to broadcast meetings live on YouTube, and public comment will continue to be taken at the in person meeting. The public can also provide written public comments prior to each meeting.

Many people have asked why the City Council cannot just silence speakers when the begin saying things that are offensive, vulgar or hateful. The City Attorney has given the following explanation.

Per the Brown Act, at every regular meeting, members of the public have the right to directly address the body on any item of public interest if that item is under the subject matter jurisdiction of the body. (These particular groups have learned this rule and have become adept at tying their comments to City business, e.g., Black History Month proclamation, Women’s History Month proclamation, etc.) For individual agenda items, the public must be given an opportunity to comment before or during the body’s consideration of the item. The public’s comments must be directed at the agenda item or action being discussed.

Citizens have an enormous First Amendment interest in directing speech about public issues to those who govern their city. A city council meeting is a governmental process with a governmental purpose. The council has an agenda to be addressed and dealt with. As a result, the city council has a legitimate interest in conducting efficient, orderly meetings.

Although the City Council can impose reasonable regulations (such as a time limit or when on the agenda or consideration of an item to hear public comment), the City Council cannot treat public commenters differently (discriminate) based upon the content of their speech. Unpopular speech and viewpoints are protected by the First Amendment. A member of the public may not be ordered removed from the meeting or be silenced merely for speaking profane or inflammatory speech (or "hate speech").

Persons can, however, be silenced or removed for disrupting a meeting. Courts have explained that disruption means an actual disruption, e.g. the individual impedes or renders infeasible the orderly conduct of the meeting. For example, speaking over one’s allotted time, speaking out of turn, shouting over others so that they cannot be heard, etc. Additionally, speech that threatens violence or encourages others to be

ZOOM DISCUSSION
MARCH 18, 2024
3 violent (“incitement”) is considered disruptive and is not afforded the same First Amendment protections.

In applying rules prohibiting disruptions at meetings, the requirement of viewpoint neutrality is critically important. So long as members of the public are relating their comments to City business, are speaking during their turn, and are not threatening violence, they must be allowed to make their comment no matter how offensive or unpopular their ideas. That is a right guaranteed by our First Amendment.

Thus, given the requirements of the Brown Act and the dictates of the First Amendment, so long as there is the ability to join a City Council meeting via Zoom from anywhere and to participate as a member of the public, the City will continue to be vulnerable to these types of non-local, targeted efforts of persons looking to make a name for themselves by causing a stir or to create legal grounds for a lawsuit.

FISCAL ANALYSIS
The decision of the Council regarding utilizing Zoom for public meetings will not have a direct fiscal impact to the City.

STRATEGIC PLAN ASSESSMENT
The Council’s actions concerning public meeting decorum are consistent with the following strategic plan goals:
• GOAL 3: OBTAIN THE HIGHEST LEVELS OF ORGANIZATIONAL

EXCELLENCE

ATTACHMENTS
• None.

← All documents from this meeting