JULY 30, 2024
1 JULY 30, 2024
311
1EXECUTIVE OFFICER: SUPERVISOR SOLIS?
2 3SUP. HILDA SOLIS: AYE.
4 5EXECUTIVE OFFICER: SUPERVISOR SOLIS, AYE. SUPERVISOR MITCHELL? 6 7SUP. HOLLY J. MITCHELL: AYE.
8 9EXECUTIVE OFFICER: SUPERVISOR MITCHELL, AYE. SUPERVISOR HAHN? 10 11SUP. JANICE HAHN: AYE.
12 13EXECUTIVE OFFICER: SUPERVISOR HAHN, AYE. SUPERVISOR BARGER? 14 15SUP. KATHRYN BARGER: AYE.
16 17EXECUTIVE OFFICER: SUPERVISOR BARGER, AYE. SUPERVISOR HORVATH? 18 19SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: AYE.
20 21EXECUTIVE OFFICER: SUPERVISOR HORVATH, AYE. MOTION CARRIES 5- 220.
23 24SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: WE WILL NOW MOVE ON TO ITEM 6, 25RESOLUTION CALLING AND GIVING NOTICE OF A SPECIAL ELECTION JULY 30, 2024
312
1WHICH WAS HELD FOR DISCUSSION AND ITEM 7, COUNTY CODE CHARTER 2AMENDMENT WHICH WAS HELD BY SUPERVISOR MITCHELL. FOR MEMBERS 3OF THE PUBLIC ON THE TELEPHONE, PLEASE PRESS 1 THEN 0 NOW TO 4COMMENT ON THESE ITEMS. I'LL FIRST TURN IT TO SUPERVISOR 5MITCHELL.
6 7SUP. HOLLY J. MITCHELL: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MADAM CHAIR. YOU 8HELD 6 AND 7 TOGETHER. OKAY, SO 7, I UNDERSTAND, JUST IS 9PROCEDURE. IT IS WHAT WE HAD TO DO, WHAT YOU HAD TO DO. THANK 10YOU VERY MUCH. I JUST WANTED TO JUST MAKE A FEW ADDITIONAL 11COMMENTS. WE'VE HAD LOTS OF CONVERSATION ON THE ISSUE OF THE 12ORDINANCE, AS YOU SAID EARLIER TODAY, WE JUST HAVE TO AGREE TO 13DISAGREE ON THE CONTENTS. BUT I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT, AGAIN, 14FOR ME TO ELEVATE CONCERNS FROM COMMUNITY GROUPS. THERE WAS A, 15WHAT DO THEY CALL IT, IN SACRAMENTO WE WOULD CALL IT A NASCAR 16LETTER WHERE ALL THE DIFFERENT ORGANIZATIONS' LOGOS ARE ON THE 17LETTER, A NUMBER OF COMMUNITY GROUPS, AND THEIR CONCERNS 18CENTER ON PROCESS, THAT THERE'S NOT BEEN A CO-CREATED SOLUTION 19IN MEANINGFUL COLLABORATION WITH COMMUNITY, AND 2, THE ELECTED 20CEO, THERE'S CONCERN THAT THIS ACTUALLY CONSOLIDATES POWER AND 21DIMINISHES THE VOICES OF THE ELECTED SUPERVISORS TO SERVE 22MARGINALIZED COMMUNITIES MOST EFFECTIVELY. I JUST WANTED TO 23MAKE SURE THAT ALL THE MEMBERS GOT THIS LETTER, I THINK IT 24CAME IN RATHER LATE, AND I KNOW THERE'S BEEN LOTS OF
25CONVERSATION AND ASSUMPTIONS, AND LET ME SAY FOR THE RECORD JULY 30, 2024
313
1PUBLICLY, I DID NOT SOLICIT THESE ORGANIZATIONS. THESE ARE 2ORGANIZATIONS WHO WORK IN THIS AREA AND HAVE THE CAPACITY TO 3READ LANGUAGE AND FORM THEIR OWN OPINION, AND THEY DID SO AND 4WROTE THE LETTER DATED JULY 30TH, AND I JUST THOUGHT IT WAS 5IMPORTANT TO ELEVATE IT AND BRING THEIR CONCERNS TO EVERYONE'S 6ATTENTION. AGAIN, FROM MY PERSPECTIVE, AS I WILL RESTATE, YOU 7KNOW, IT WAS MY CONCERNS WERE FIRST ELEVATED AS QUESTIONS, AND 8IN THE ABSENT OF SOME CLEAR CONCRETE ANSWERS, MY CONCERN 9REMAINS, AND IT ALSO GOES BACK TO PROCESS. I AM CLEAR THAT 10UNLIKE THE COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT MODEL THAT THIS BOARD AND 11PREVIOUS BOARDS HAVE USED IN THE PAST TO DO MEANINGFUL POLICY 12CHANGE, THAT WAS NOT USED IN THIS CASE. AND I THINK ALMOST 13SIMILAR TO THE CONVERSATION WE HAD EARLIER TODAY ABOUT SB43 IN 14TERMS OF THE NOTE OF GOING FAST, NOT BEING REAL CLEAR, AT 15LEAST PUBLICLY IN TERMS OF RESOURCES IT WILL TAKE TO DO THIS 16REALLY COMPREHENSIVE WORK. I APPRECIATE THE FACT THAT THE 17ORDINANCE SAYS THAT THERE WILL BE NO ADDITIONAL TAXES, BUT I 18CONTINUE TO STRUGGLE WITH THIS NOTION THAT IT WON'T RESULT IN 19COSTS, EVEN INDIRECTLY, TO OUR CONSTITUENTS. IF WE'RE NOT 20RAISING NEW REVENUES TO FUND THE INCREASED BOARD FRAMEWORK AND 21INTEND TO ABSORB THE COSTS WITHIN EXISTING RESOURCES, I DON'T 22SEE HOW WE DO THAT, GIVEN THE BREADTH AND SPAN OF THE REFORMS 23PROPOSED AND NOT HAVE IT HIT OUR NET COUNTY COSTS AND PERHAPS 24SHIFT EXISTING PRIORITIES TO FUND THIS WORK. THAT IS IN AND OF 25ITSELF A COST. AND IT'S LIKELY TO REDUCE THE LEVEL OF SERVICES JULY 30, 2024
314
1WE PROVIDE SOMEWHERE ACROSS THE SPAN OF WHAT NCC ACTUALLY 2FUNDS BECAUSE WE'LL BE REDIRECTING REALLY PRECIOUS DOLLARS. I 3THINK THAT'S IMPORTANT. THE TAKEAWAY FROM THIS PROCESS, I 4THINK, AND IT'S IMPORTANT, AND I'M GOING TO LOOK TOO, I THINK 5GOING THROUGH THIS PROCESS, WE WERE ABLE TO CLARIFY BROWN ACT 6FOR ALL OF US. WHEN AND HOW STAFF CAN ENGAGE ON A STAFF TO 7STAFF LEVEL, I THINK THAT WAS IMPORTANT TO CLARIFY. I THINK 8THAT IT WAS CLARIFIED FOR SOME THAT WE CAN UNDER BROWN ACT 9HAVE A COMMITTEE STRUCTURE AND POLICY CAN BE VETTED THERE. AND 10I THINK AGAIN BASED ON OUR CONVERSATION EARLIER TODAY, THAT 11MIGHT BE SOMETHING WE WANNA CONSIDER AS A BOARD BECAUSE WE CAN 12DO THAT WITHIN OUR EXISTING AUTHORITY, BECAUSE THERE ARE SOME 13MEANINGFUL POLICY ISSUES THAT CAN'T AFFORD TO WAIT FOR IF THIS 14WERE TO PASS BASED ON NOVEMBER BY THE VOTERS. THERE ARE SOME 15ISSUES THAT WE CAN TACKLE NOW, SOME PROCESSES THAT WE CAN 16TACKLE NOW BECAUSE THEY ARE ISSUES THAT REALLY SHOULD NOT HAVE 17TO WAIT. I WANT TO ACKNOWLEDGE AND THANK ALL OF THOSE, 18PARTICULARLY THOSE ORGANIZATIONS LIKE CONTRACT CITIES WHO WERE 19HERE EARLIER, WHO ENGAGED WITH US OVER A YEAR AGO ON THIS 20ISSUE. EVEN WHEN IT WASN'T A PARTICULAR POPULAR ISSUE FOR SOME 21ON THE BOARD TO DO SO. I WANNA THANK THOSE ORGANIZATIONS THAT 22PAID ATTENTION. GOVERNANCE ISN'T A PARTICULAR SEXY ISSUE, BUT 23THERE WERE ORGANIZATIONS WHO STEPPED UP, UNDERSTOOD THE 24MEANINGFUL RAMIFICATIONS OF IMPROVING OUR PROCESSES AS A BODY, 25AND I WANNA THANK THEM. I'D LIKE TO REITERATE, WE'VE TALKED JULY 30, 2024
315
1ABOUT REPORT BACKS AND MOTIONS EARLIER TODAY, THAT I'M NOT 2BRINGING FORWARD A MOTION, BUT I AM ASKING THAT THE EXECUTIVE 3OFFICE GIVE US A COMPREHENSIVE REVIEW OF WHAT HAPPENED WITH 4REGARD TO THE CONSULTANT PROCESS. IT'S MY EXPECTATION THAT 5THAT WORK CONTINUES BECAUSE THERE ARE OTHER GOVERNANCE IDEAS 6THAT THAT RESEARCH CAN ELEVATE. BUT BECAUSE IT BECAME SUCH AN 7ISSUE IN TERMS OF THE DELAY, I THINK THE ENTIRE BOARD IS OWED 8A REAL CLEAR EXPLANATION ABOUT HOW WE GOT TO WHERE WE WERE IN 9TERMS OF NO REPORT. AND SO, WE CAN MAKE SURE THAT WE'RE NEVER 10IN THAT POSITION AGAIN. IF THERE ARE BOARD MEMBERS WHO HAVE 11EXPECTATIONS AROUND TIMING OF ACTIONS, WE WANNA MAKE SURE THAT 12WE UNDERSTAND HOW TO IMPROVE. I WOULD ALSO ASK, BECAUSE THIS 13HAS COME UP, WHEN COMMENTS WERE MADE IN THE CONTEXT OF THE 14DISCUSSION THE ORDINANCE AROUND CORRUPTION WHICH TRIGGERED FOR 15ME THE MEMORY ABOUT THE WORK BEING DONE IN RESEARCHING THE 16COUNTY'S CONTRACTING PROCESS AND SO I'M GOING TO ASK THE 17COUNTY COUNSEL COMMUNICATE TO THE BOARD AN EXPECTATION OF 18TIMING OF WHEN THAT REPORT WILL BE DUE. THAT WAS AN ISSUE THAT 19THIS BOARD MADE CLEAR WAS A PRIORITY THAT WE WERE DEEPLY 20CONCERNED ABOUT AND SO IT REMAINS CONCERNING THAT 3½ YEARS 21LATER WE STILL DON'T HAVE A FULL UNDERSTANDING OF AREAS OF 22WHERE WE CAN IMPROVE AND STREAMLINE AND CLOSE GAPS IN TERMS OF 23THE COUNTY CONTRACTING PROCESS. SO, I HOPE THE COUNTY COUNSEL 24WILL, IN SHORT ORDER, GIVE US AN IDEA ABOUT WHEN THAT REPORT 25WILL BE AVAILABLE TO THE BOARD AS A WHOLE. SO, I WANTED TO JULY 30, 2024
316
1MAKE SURE THAT I REITERATED THOSE 2 EXPECTATIONS. AGAIN, 2CONTINUE TO EXPRESS MY CONCERN FOR BOTH THE PROCESS AND AS I 3WON'T REPEAT ALL THE ISSUES I'VE RAISED IN THE PAST WITH 4REGARD TO THE CONTENT I JUST THINK IT COULD HAVE BEEN DONE 5DIFFERENTLY IT COULD HAVE BEEN A DIFFERENT APPROACH THAT COULD 6HAVE BEEN MORE INCLUSIVE BECAUSE I WOULD HAVE LIKED NOTHING 7MORE TO BE ABLE TO BE IN A POSITION TO HAVE BEEN A
8COLLABORATOR AND BE ABLE TO COME TO A YES ON TALKING ABOUT OUR 9PRIORITIES AROUND GOVERNANCE GOING FORWARD, BUT BASED ON THE 10EXPERIENCE THE LAST 3 WEEKS, I'M NOT ABLE TO DO SO. THANK YOU, 11MADAM CHAIR. SUPERVISOR HAHN.
12 13SUP. JANICE HAHN: THANK YOU, AND I APPRECIATE YOUR COMMENTS, 14SUPERVISOR MITCHELL, AND I APPRECIATE, YOU KNOW, SUPERVISOR 15BARGER, WHAT WE DID LAST TIME, SAYING THERE ARE CERTAIN THINGS 16WE CAN DO NOW, WE DON'T HAVE TO WAIT. AND AN ETHICS COMMISSION 17WAS ONE OF THOSE. BUT JUST TO REMIND EVERYBODY WHO'S MAYBE 18LISTENING, THIS IS THE THIRD TIME THAT THIS REFORM PACKAGE HAS 19BEEN IN FRONT OF OUR BOARD. AND I THINK THE DEBATE THAT WE'VE 20BEEN HAVING, YOU KNOW, IS IMPORTANT. AND I KNOW THERE'S BEEN 21SOME CONCERNS ABOUT HOW DECIDING THE FRAMEWORK OF THESE 22REFORMS DIDN'T INCLUDE A PARTICULAR PUBLIC PROCESS. WE DIDN'T 23REALLY HAVE, YOU KNOW, A TOWN HALL OR A FORUM TO GET THERE, 24BUT THERE WERE CLOSE TO ALMOST 900 RESIDENTS THAT WERE TALKED 25TO ACROSS L.A. COUNTY, AND THEY WERE ASKED WHAT THEY THOUGHT JULY 30, 2024
317
1OF L.A. COUNTY GOVERNMENT. AND AN OVERWHELMING 88% SAID THAT 2L.A. COUNTY GOVERNMENT IS IN NEED OF REFORM. AND WHEN THEY 3WERE ASKED IF THEY WANT AN INDEPENDENT ETHICS COMMISSION TO 4KEEP L.A. COUNTY OFFICIALS IN LINE AND ELECTED COUNTY
5EXECUTIVE AND EXPANDED BOARD OF SUPERVISORS OF 9 MEMBERS, 74% 6OF THEM SAID YES. SO, I THINK OUR RESIDENTS WANT SMALLER, MORE 7REPRESENTATIVE DISTRICTS. I THINK THEY WANT CHECKS AND 8BALANCES IN THEIR LOCAL GOVERNMENT. AND I THINK THEY WANT 9COMMON SENSE ETHICS REFORM THAT HOLD OFFICIALS ACCOUNTABLE. 10AND THE REFORMS IN THIS CHARTER AMENDMENT ARE WHAT I BELIEVE 11ARE IN LINE WITH WHAT THE PUBLIC WANTS. WE COULD BE WRONG. I 12KNOW THERE'S DISAGREEMENT ON THIS BOARD ABOUT THAT. BUT I 13THINK WE SHOULD LET THE VOTERS DECIDE. AND APPROVING THIS 14SECOND READING TODAY DOESN'T END THE DEBATE. IT JUST MOVES THE 15DEBATE FROM INSIDE THIS BOARD ROOM TO THE PUBLIC SQUARE. THERE 16WILL BE PLENTY OF DISCUSSION ABOUT THESE ISSUES BETWEEN NOW 17AND NOVEMBER. AND AT THE END OF THE DAY, THIS ISN'T OUR 18GOVERNMENT, THIS IS THE PEOPLE'S GOVERNMENT. AND I THINK WE 19SHOULD LET THEM DECIDE HOW THEY WANT IT TO WORK. THANK YOU, 20MADAM CHAIR.
21 22SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: SUPERVISOR SOLIS.
23 24SUP. HILDA SOLIS: YES, THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. AND I ALSO 25WANNA THANK YOU AND SUPERVISOR HAHN FOR BRINGING THIS ITEM JULY 30, 2024
318
1BEFORE US AGAIN. I THINK IT'S VERY IMPORTANT. IF WE'RE GONNA 2REALLY LOOK AT DEMOCRATIC VALUES AND TRYING TO SET FORTH A 3ROAD AHEAD FOR THE COUNTY. I THINK THAT THIS IS SOMETHING THAT 4WE ALL HAVE BEEN THINKING ABOUT FOR THE LAST, I KNOW FOR ME AT 5LEAST A DECADE. AND BEFORE THAT I KNOW THERE HAVE BEEN SEVERAL 6ATTEMPTS TO TRY TO EXPAND THE BOARD AND REFORM THE COUNTY. SO 7I KNOW THAT THIS IS A TOUGH, TOUGH THING FOR SOME OF US, BUT I 8KNOW THAT IN THE END, IF WE DO OUR JOB AND EDUCATE THE PUBLIC 9AND MAKE CLEAR THAT WHAT WE'RE DOING IS, WE HOPE IN THE BEST 10INTEREST OF 10,000,000 PEOPLE, THAT THEY'LL HAVE A BROADER 11ACCESS TO MORE LOCAL VOICES, INCREASING THE BOARD FROM 5 TO 9, 12AND ALSO CREATING A PATH FOR STRONG ETHICS REFORM, AS WELL AS 13MAKING SURE THAT WE HAVE ACCOUNTABILITY, SOMETHING THAT HAS 14BEEN TALKED ABOUT HERE FOR A LONG TIME. I DON'T HAVE ANY 15DISAGREEMENT WITH THAT. I DO WANNA SAY THAT WE WERE ABLE TO 16OBTAIN A PETITION OF 150 SIGNATURES JUST FROM ONE
17UNINCORPORATED AREA OF MY DISTRICT. SO, PEOPLE TOOK IT UPON 18THEMSELVES TO SAY, WE SUPPORT THE EXPANSION, WE SUPPORT THIS 19ORDINANCE. SO, I WANNA PUT THAT FORWARD FOR THE RECORD AND 20JUST SAY THAT EVERY TIME WE HAVE AN INITIATIVE HERE IN THE 21COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES, WE ALWAYS COME UP AGAINST, YOU KNOW, 22FOLKS THAT ARE OPPOSED TO THINGS THAT WE WANT TO DO. AND I'LL 23NEVER FORGET WHEN I FIRST ARRIVED HERE AFTER A COUPLE YEARS, 24WE WORKED ON TRYING TO GET AN INITIATIVE PASSED TO INCREASE 25FUNDING FOR OUR PARKS. THERE ARE A LOT OF PEOPLE WHO LOVE JULY 30, 2024
319
1PARKS, BUT THERE ARE A LOT OF PEOPLE WHO DON'T LIKE PARKS AND 2DON'T LIKE BEING CHARGED A FEE. BUT NONETHELESS, IT WAS VERY 3POPULAR, WE FOUND OUT AFTER TALKING TO PEOPLE. AND ALL I HAVE 4TO SAY IS SOMETIMES A DEMOCRACY IS HARD, BUT IN THESE CASES, I 5THINK GOING TO THE VOTERS, WHETHER THEY SUPPORT IT OR NOT, LET 6THEM DECIDE. AND I THINK THAT'S THE BEST WAY TO GO. SO, THANK 7YOU, MADAM CHAIR, AND APPRECIATE THE OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK. 8 9SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: THANK YOU. SUPERVISOR BARGER. 10THANK YOU. AND I WANNA THANK YOU, SUPERVISOR MITCHELL, NOT 11ONLY FOR CONTINUING TO RAISE IMPORTANT AND PRESSING UNANSWERED 12QUESTIONS, BUT ALSO FOR HAVING THE VISION ORIGINALLY TO BRING 13THIS FORWARD. AND AS I RECALL, WHEN YOU BROUGHT IT FORWARD, 14THIS BOARD WANTED TO STUDY IT. AND SO I DON'T KNOW WHAT 15CHANGED BETWEEN WHEN YOU BROUGHT IT FORWARD AND WHEN OTHERS 16WANTED IT STUDIED TO NOW, WE DON'T NEED TO STUDY IT ANYMORE. 17WE NEED TO MAKE IT MOVE FORWARD AND OH, BY THE WAY, WE'RE 18GOING TO ADD ELECTED GOVERNMENT, ELECTED TO CEO. SO I JUST 19FEEL I JUST AM TRYING TO, I'M TRYING TO PUT THAT TOGETHER, 20SUPERVISOR HAHN, BECAUSE I THINK YOU ACTUALLY ORIGINALLY DID 21WANT IT STUDIED. AND YOU MADE COMPELLING ARGUMENTS AS TO WHY, 22WHEN IT WAS BROUGHT FORWARD BY SUPERVISOR MITCHELL, THAT IT 23SHOULD BE STUDIED. AT ANOTHER TIME, NOW IS NOT BECAUSE IT'S 24GOING TO BE VOTED ON TODAY, THE VOTES ARE THERE. BUT I JUST 25CAN'T RECONCILE WHAT CHANGED BETWEEN THEN AND NOW. I MEAN, I JULY 30, 2024
320
1KNOW THAT YOU ARE DOING THIS, AND I REMEMBER WHEN SUPERVISOR 2HAHN, YOUR FATHER, BROUGHT THIS FORWARD. AND, YOU KNOW, FOR 3ME, THE QUESTION HAS ALWAYS BEEN 7, 9, 15. I DON'T KNOW WHAT 4THE NUMBER IS. THAT WAS WHAT I THOUGHT WE WERE HOPING TO GET 5OUT OF THE STUDY. SO, YOU KNOW, I BELIEVE THAT THE
6UNINCORPORATED AREAS, IF YOU WERE TO POLL THEM AND IT WAS 7CONFIRMED, I THINK I'M GONNA GET FROM FERNANDO THE STATS, THE 8UNINCORPORATED FEEL DISENFRANCHISED FROM THIS COUNTY. THEY 9FEEL LIKE THEY ARE THE STEPCHILD OF L.A. COUNTY. AND YET WE 10ARE, THAT IS OUR ROLE AS SUPERVISORS IS TO BE THE ELECTED 11OFFICIAL OVER THE UNINCORPORATED AREAS. AND SO, I TAKE THAT TO 12HEART. AND THAT'S WHY IN MY UNINCORPORATED AREAS, THEY DO 13SUPPORT EXPANDING THE BOARD BECAUSE THEY FEEL THAT THE 14REPRESENTATION WILL GET BETTER. NOT UNDERSTANDING HOW IT'S 15GONNA BE BROKEN UP. I THINK THAT THE FUNDAMENTAL CHANGES TO 16THE COUNTY GOVERNMENT THROUGH AN ELECTED EXECUTIVE AND 17EXPANDED BOARD WILL NOT AFFECT, GO INTO EFFECT UNTIL 4 TO 8 18YEARS RESPECTIVELY. SO, I DON'T HAVE A CLEAR ANSWER AS TO WHY 19WE WOULD RUSH FORWARD THIS PROPOSAL AT THE 11TH HOUR WITHOUT 20CONDUCTING THE THOROUGH STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT THAT A REFORM 21INITIATIVE OF THIS MAGNITUDE SHOULD ENTAIL. SO, WHEN I HEAR 22900 PEOPLE WERE ENGAGED, 900 OUT OF 10,000,000, AND YOU'RE NOT 23GONNA GET ALL 10,000,000, BUT STILL, I MEAN, I HAVE TO WONDER 24HOW THAT ALL CAME TO BE. I MEAN, I THINK WHEN YOU DO A POLL, 25YOU USUALLY, UNLESS IT'S A SCIENTIFIC POLL, YOU POLL WITH JULY 30, 2024
321
1QUESTIONS BASED ON WHAT YOU HOPE TO GET OUT OF THAT POLL. AND 2SO I STILL, I'M NOT HEARING IN MY DISTRICT OVERWHELMING 3SUPPORT FOR THE ELECTED. I AM FOR THE EXPANDED BOARD. SO, I 4WILL MAKE SURE I PUSH OUT TO MY CONSTITUENCY THAT, THAT, THAT 5THIS WAS NOT SOMETHING THAT WAS ORIGINALLY ANTICIPATED WHEN 6THE MOTION THAT YOU BROUGHT FORWARD, SUPERVISOR MITCHELL, AND 7I THINK IT WAS WITH SUPERVISOR, DID YOU CO-AUTHOR A MOTION? I 8CAN'T REMEMBER WHO IT WAS WITH THE CHAIR WITH SUPERVISOR OR 9WITH CHAIR HORVATH I ALSO REMAIN CONCERNED ABOUT UTILIZING 10COST SAVINGS TO PAY FOR THE EXPANDED GOVERNMENT STRUCTURE AND 11THE FACT THAT IT WILL IMPACT VACANT POSITIONS AND LIMIT A 12DEPARTMENT'S ABILITY FOR THE FUTURE TO FULFILL VACANCIES. AND 13I KIND OF CHUCKLED LAST WEEK WHEN I ASKED FESIA ABOUT THAT AND 14THE COMMENT WAS THE BOARD WILL MAKE THAT DETERMINATION UNDER 15THE NEW CEO STRUCTURE, THE BOARD WON'T MAKE THAT
16DETERMINATION. THAT IS POWER BEING GIVEN TO THE CEO AND THE 17ELECTED. UNLESS YOU CAN GET TWO-THIRDS OF A VOTE, AS I RECALL, 18TO OVERTURN OR VETO WHATEVER THE ELECTED CEO WANTS TO DO. AND 19GIVEN THAT WE CAN'T EVEN GET 3 VOTES TO CLOSE OUR JAIL, I 20DON'T KNOW HOW YOU'RE GOING TO GET TWO-THIRDS TO AGREE ON 21SOMETHING LIKE THAT. I'M SORRY? NO, I MEAN TO READ, TO, TO, 22WELL, IT'S STILL, THE JAIL IS STILL STANDING. WELL, WE GOT THE 23VOTES TO CLOSE IT, BUT WE HAVEN'T EXECUTED WHAT CLOSURE MEANS. 24IT'S TRUE. IT'S TRUE. I DON'T, I DON'T, UNLESS I'M MISSING 25SOMETHING, THE JAIL IS STILL STANDING. AND WE JUST HAD A JULY 30, 2024
322
1DISCUSSION ABOUT THAT. SO, I'M SAYING IT'S STILL STANDING. WE 2HAVEN'T DONE ANYTHING TO TEAR IT DOWN. I DON'T SEE ANY PLAN AS 3TO WHEN IT'S GONNA BE TORN DOWN. I REALLY WANT TO EMPHASIZE 4PROCESS. I AGREE WITH SUPERVISOR MITCHELL THAT THE PROCESS AND 5HOW THIS PLAYED OUT TO ME IS ASTOUNDING. AND THE FACT THAT 6DEALS WERE CUT AND THAT PROMISES WERE MADE OR WHATEVER I'M 7HEARING IS SAD FOR ME BECAUSE THIS IS A COUNTY THAT THIS 8BOARD. IN THE PAST COULD AGREE TO DISAGREE, BUT IT WAS NEVER 9DONE IN A WAY THAT WAS SO. TO BE DISHONEST QUITE FRANKLY. 10HAVING SAID THAT, I WILL AGGRESSIVELY BE VOCAL ABOUT MY 11CONCERNS ABOUT WHY THIS IS A STEP IN THE WRONG DIRECTION. I 12THINK IT'S GONNA UNDERMINE OTHER MEASURES THAT ARE GONNA BE ON 13THE BALLOT THAT HAVE FAR MORE SIGNIFICANT IMPACT ON THIS 14COUNTY WHETHER IT BE THE HOMELESS OR WHETHER IT BE
15FIREFIGHTING AND I THINK THAT'S UNFORTUNATE BUT OBVIOUSLY IT'S 16YOU KNOW IT'S 3 TO 2 AGAIN WHICH BY THE WAY IT'S GREAT TO HAVE 172 INSTEAD OF 4 TO 1. SO, THANK YOU FOR THAT SUPERVISOR 18MITCHELL. SO HAVING SAID THAT, LET'S CALL FOR THE VOTE, I 19GUESS.
20 21SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: WE DO HAVE MORE DISCUSSION, BUT I 22WANT TO ASK, YOU RAISED THE QUESTION OF DEALS CUT AND PROMISES 23MADE. AND I JUST WANT TO KNOW WHAT YOU MEAN BY THAT.
24 25SUP. KATHRYN BARGER: JUST WHAT I HEARD, SUPERVISOR MITCHELL, I JULY 30, 2024
323
1HEARD OR SUPERVISOR HORVATH, I HEARD THAT YOU AND SUPERVISOR 2SOLIS WERE WORKING ON THIS AND THAT SUPERVISOR SOLIS DECIDED 3SHE DIDN'T WANT HER NAME ON IT. I'M JUST TELLING YOU WHAT I'VE 4HEARD AND THAT IN RETURN YOU WENT TO SUPERVISOR HAHN AND ASKED 5SUPERVISOR HAN TO CO-AUTHOR IT NOW WHETHER IT'S TRUE OR NOT 6I'M JUST I'M HONEST I'M TELLING YOU WHAT I'VE HEARD AND IF 7I'VE HEARD IT I WILL GUARANTEE YOU THAT IT'S BEEN TALKED ABOUT 8AMONGST OTHER PEOPLE, BECAUSE I'M USUALLY THE LAST ON THE FOOD 9CHAIN TO HEAR THIS KIND OF STUFF.
10 11SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: I APPRECIATE THE HONESTY. AND YOU 12KNOW THAT WHEN I FIRST CAME ONTO THE BOARD, YOU ALSO SHARED 13WITH ME THINGS THAT YOU HEARD THROUGH THE GRAPEVINE ABOUT ME 14AS A CANDIDATE AND AS A POTENTIAL COLLEAGUE THAT WERE NOT 15TRUE. SO, I JUST WANT TO ACKNOWLEDGE WHAT YOUR, I, IT'S 16SOMETHING THAT YOU HEARD AND I THINK THAT IT'S FAIR TO SHARE, 17BUT IT'S NOT HONEST. AND SO, I JUST- SO YOU'RE SAYING IT'S NOT 18TRUE THAT YOU.. IT'S NOT TRUE. IT'S NOT TRUE AT ALL. AND SO, I 19APPRECIATE RAISING QUESTIONS IF THERE ARE ACTUALLY QUESTIONS. 20BUT WHEN THERE'S AN INFERENCE THAT SOMETHING ON TOWARD IS 21HAPPENING, I WANNA MAKE SURE I ADDRESS THAT DIRECTLY, BECAUSE 22THAT'S NOT WHAT HAPPENED. SUPERVISOR MITCHELL.
23 24SUP. HOLLY J. MITCHELL: THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. I DIDN'T WANT 25TO GIVE THE ORGANIZATIONS THE IMPRESSION THAT I WAS BELITTLING JULY 30, 2024
324
1THE SIGNIFICANCE WHEN I SAID NASCAR. THAT'S JUST KIND OF A WAY 2IN WHICH WE'VE TALKED ABOUT. LETTERHEAD, I DIDN'T WANT TO, SO 3LET ME JUST ACKNOWLEDGE SINCE WE'VE TALKED ABOUT A PETITION OF 4150 AND 900 PEOPLE, THE ORGANIZATIONS REPRESENTED HERE ON THE 5LETTER TODAY REPRESENT 5,000. IT'S NOT MY IMPRESSION THAT OF 6THE 900 FOLKS WERE TAPPED IN THE SECOND DISTRICT. THAT'S JUST 7NOT MY IMPRESSION. WHILE, AGAIN, THERE'S BEEN LOTS OF
8CONVERSATION ABOUT EXPANDING THE BOARD. THE PARTICULARS IN 9THIS PROPOSAL, I DON'T KNOW, ELEVATE TO THE TOP OF THE NEEDS 10IN MY DISTRICT. WE TALKED ABOUT THE NEEDS IN MY DISTRICT 11TODAY. STREET RACING, THE UNHOUSED, CRITICAL ISSUES THAT 12PEOPLE LOOK TO THE COUNTY TO SOLVE FOR THEM. AND SO, WHILE I 13KNOW THAT GOVERNANCE WILL IMPROVE OUR ABILITY TO BE RESPONSIVE 14TO THOSE NEEDS, I CAN'T IN GOOD CONSCIENCE ACKNOWLEDGE THAT 15THIS PROCESS, THAT THE CONTENTS OF THIS ORDINANCE WILL GET US 16ANY CLOSER THERE. PEOPLE HAVE GREAT NEED IN THE SECOND 17SUPERVISORIAL DISTRICT AND I BELIEVE COUNTYWIDE. AND IT REALLY 18CAUSES ME GREAT CONCERN WHEN WE LOOK AT EMPOWERING A SINGLE 19COUNTYWIDE ELECTED WHO WILL HAVE GREATER POWER OVER 579, 20HOWEVER MANY OF US. THE CONVERSATIONS WE HAD TODAY WHERE WE 21WERE TALKING ABOUT THE UNIQUENESS OF OUR DISTRICTS, I DON'T 22KNOW HOW A SINGLE COUNTYWIDE ELECTED WILL BE ABLE TO MAKE 23PRIORITIES THAT SIT WELL WITH THE 5 OR 9 OF US IN TERMS OF 24MAKING INVESTMENT AND BUDGET PRIORITIES FOR THIS COUNTY. I 25THINK THAT WITH THE CURRENT STRUCTURE, THE WAY IT'S PROPOSED JULY 30, 2024
325
1AND THE ORDINANCE, THE SUPERVISOR'S ABILITY TO TRULY FIGHT AND 2ADVOCATE FOR THE UNIQUE NEEDS OF OUR DISTRICT WILL BE DEEPLY 3COMPROMISED AND I'M CONCERNED. THANK YOU, BUT I JUST WANTED TO 4ACKNOWLEDGE THE 5,000 PEOPLE THOSE ORGANIZATIONS REPRESENT. 5THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR.
6 7SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: THANK YOU VERY MUCH AND I WANT TO 8THANK MY COLLEAGUES FOR THE ONGOING DISCUSSION ABOUT
9GOVERNANCE REFORM. AND I WANT TO THANK EVERYONE WHO'S WEIGHED 10IN SO FAR ON THIS IMPORTANT GOING FORWARD PROCESS. WE ALL, WE 11NEED ALL OF OUR VOICES TO BE PART OF THIS NOW AND IN THE YEARS 12TO COME IF THE VOTERS CHOOSE TO PASS THIS IN NOVEMBER. DEBATE 13AND DISCOURSE ARE WHAT MAKE A HEALTHY DEMOCRACY AND SINCE I 14JOINED THE BOARD I HAVE HEARD A RESOUNDING CALL FOR CHANGE. 15CHANGE FOR A FUTURE WHERE LOS ANGELES COUNTY MORE URGENTLY AND 16EFFECTIVELY MEETS THE NEEDS OF OUR COMMUNITIES, ESPECIALLY OUR 17MOST VULNERABLE RESIDENTS WHO DEPEND ON COUNTY SERVICES AND 18CARE. AFTER MORE THAN 100 YEARS OF THE STATUS QUO, THIS IS A 19PROPOSAL THAT GIVES ANGELENOS THE OPPORTUNITY TO SHAPE A 20COUNTY GOVERNANCE STRUCTURE FIT FOR THE 21ST CENTURY. TODAY, 21AS WE CONSIDER WHETHER TO PLACE THE AMENDMENT ON THE COUNTY 22CHARTER TO THE COUNTY CHARTER ON THE BALLOT, I WANT TO GET 23BACK TO WHY THIS PROPOSAL SOLVES FOR THE PROBLEMS WE'RE 24FACING. WHY DO WE NEED AN ELECTED COUNTY EXECUTIVE?
25ACCOUNTABILITY. HAVING AN ELECTED EXECUTIVE ACCOUNTABLE TO THE JULY 30, 2024
326
1PEOPLE IS NOT A FOREIGN CONCEPT. THE SEPARATION OF POWERS, 2CREATING A DISTINCT EXECUTIVE BRANCH SEPARATE FROM THE 3LEGISLATIVE BRANCH BUT EQUALLY EMPOWERED, LEADS TO A SYSTEM OF 4CHECKS AND BALANCES TO ENSURE THAT NO ONE BRANCH OF GOVERNMENT 5WOULD BECOME TOO POWERFUL, AND THAT POWER DOESN'T GO
6UNCHECKED. THIS IS FOUNDATIONAL TO OUR DEMOCRATIC GOVERNMENT, 7AND BECAUSE L.A. COUNTY HAS AN IMPLEMENTATION PROBLEM, TODAY'S 8JAIL DISCUSSION COULD NOT MORE PERFECTLY EMBODY EXACTLY WHAT I 9MEAN BY THAT. WE ARE VERY GOOD AT PASSING POLICY IN THIS ROOM 10AND STUDYING A VERY CLEAR VISION OF WHAT OUR EXPECTATIONS ARE. 11BUT WHAT COMES NEXT IS OFTEN TOO SLOW AND ACCOUNTABILITY IS 12DIFFUSE. WE NEED SOMEONE WHO IS EMPOWERED TO TAKE ACTION AND 13IS ACCOUNTABLE FOR IMPLEMENTING THE LEGISLATIVE AUTHORITY OF 14THIS BOARD. ACCOUNTABILITY TO CLOSE MEN'S CENTRAL JAIL, TO 15ACTUALIZE YOUTH JUSTICE REIMAGINED, TO MOVE WITH GREATER 16URGENCY ON OUR HOMELESSNESS CRISIS AND IMPLEMENTING CARE 17COURT, SB43 AND OTHER STATE DIRECTIVES WHICH WE'VE DISCUSSED 18TODAY, AND CLARITY AND AUTHORITY FOR OUR 38 DEPARTMENTS. THIS 19IS THE CHANGE WE NEED FOR THE NATION'S LARGEST AND MOST 20COMPLEX COUNTY. CREATING AN ELECTED COUNTY EXECUTIVE
21ACCOUNTABLE TO THE PEOPLE OFFERS THE CHECKS AND BALANCES 22NECESSARY AS WE ALSO EXPAND THE BOARD FROM 5 TO 9, WHICH IS 23ABSOLUTELY ESSENTIAL TO ENSURE THIS BOARD REFLECTS THE 24DIVERSITY THAT IS LOS ANGELES COUNTY. EXPANDING REPRESENTATION 25IS LONG OVERDUE, AND IT'S THE RIGHT THING TO DO. 9 IS JULY 30, 2024
327
1MEASURED, 9 IS NOT NEW. L.A. COUNTY DESERVES THE OPPORTUNITY 2TO SEE THEMSELVES REFLECTED IN THEIR BOARD OF SUPERVISORS, 3WHETHER THAT'S GEOGRAPHY, RACE, GENDER, OR ORIENTATION. WE'VE 4SEEN LOTS OF EXCITEMENT ON THE EXPANSION PROPOSAL FROM 5COMMUNITIES WHO WOULD LIKE A SEAT AT THE TABLE, AND I DON'T 6BUY INTO A SCARCITY MINDSET. I BELIEVE THAT INSTEAD OF 7FIGHTING FOR SEATS AT THE TABLE, WE SHOULD BUILD A BIGGER 8TABLE AND PULL UP MORE SEATS. THIRDLY, WE NEED AN INDEPENDENT 9ETHICS COMMISSION BECAUSE IT'S A BASIC PRINCIPLE OF GOOD 10GOVERNANCE. IT'S ALSO OUR RESPONSIBILITY TO ENGENDER THE TRUST 11OF L.A. COUNTY RESIDENTS. THIS BODY WOULD HOLD ELECTED LEADERS 12ACCOUNTABLE AND THE COMMISSION WOULD ALSO BE A SPACE TO 13CENTRALIZE WHAT IS NOW SILOED PUBLIC INFORMATION AND EDUCATION 14ON IMPORTANT CHANGES TO LAW. THERE ARE SOME DETAILS ON THE HOW 15TO BE WORKED OUT, AND THAT IS INTENTIONAL. IT IS NOT THE 16ABSENCE OF STRATEGY OR THOUGHT. IT IS TO CREATE ROOM FOR YOUR 17INPUT, THE PUBLIC AT LARGE, WHO WE SERVE AT THE PLEASURE OF. 18OUR BOARD DISCUSSED GOVERNANCE AND UNANIMOUSLY GAVE DIRECTION 19OVER A 1½ AGO, WITH NO PATH OR TIMELINE ESTABLISHED TO DATE 20FOR THAT PROCESS. SUCH A PACE DOES NOT MEET THE MOMENT. THIS 21ORDINANCE IS A STARTING POINT, WHICH IS WHY INTENTIONAL SPACES 22FOR DIVERSE VOICES WERE CREATED IN THE HOW. TO THAT END, 23THERE'S A STAKEHOLDER PROCESS FOR IMPLEMENTATION THROUGH THE 24GOVERNANCE REFORM TASK FORCE. IF APPROVED TODAY, VOTERS WILL 25DETERMINE IF IT'S TIME FOR CHANGE. I FEEL THE URGENCY OF NOW JULY 30, 2024
328
1BECAUSE THE PUBLIC DEMANDS CHANGE AND BECAUSE I ALSO FEEL A 2DEEP RESPONSIBILITY TO THE PEOPLE THAT I LISTEN TO. YOUNG 3PEOPLE HAVE LOST THEIR FAITH IN GOVERNMENT. THIS IS AN 4INVITATION TO DELIVER A GOVERNMENT THAT IS MORE
5REPRESENTATIVE, TRANSPARENT, AND ACCOUNTABLE, A GOVERNMENT 6BETTER EQUIPPED TO DELIVER ON THE PROMISES WE'VE MADE TO THEM. 7CHANGE IS UNCOMFORTABLE. IT IS HARD, AND IT IS MESSY. BUT THIS 8IS A ONCE IN A GENERATION OPPORTUNITY TO MODERNIZE OUR CHARTER 9IN A WAY THAT HASN'T BEEN SEEN IN MORE THAN 100 YEARS. AN 10OPPORTUNITY TO SHAPE SOMETHING THAT WORKS BETTER AND DELIVERS 11RESULTS WITH MORE DIVERSE VOICES SHAPING THE CHANGE. THIS IS 12THE BEGINNING AND IT OPENS THE DOOR TO ONGOING REFLECTION AND 13RECOMMENDATIONS ON HOW WE GOVERN THROUGH THE CHARTER REVIEW 14COMMISSION. THERE ARE ALSO MANY PEOPLE WHO AREN'T ABLE TO BE 15HERE TODAY TO SHARE THEIR THOUGHTS AND OPINIONS AND THESE ARE 16PEOPLE WHO MAY NOT HAVE THE ABILITY TO TAKE OFF TIME TO 17PETITION THEIR GOVERNMENT BUT INSTEAD ARE BARELY ABLE TO 18SUBSIST. THEY'RE LIKELY RECIPIENTS OF COUNTY SERVICES AND THEY 19DESERVE BETTER. WE ALL DO. PLACING THIS MEASURE ON THE BALLOT 20GIVES THEM THE CHANCE TO MAKE THEIR VOICE HEARD, TO DECIDE 21WHETHER THEY BELIEVE THESE REFORMS SHOULD BE ENACTED. WE HAVE 22NO TIME TO WASTE. I ASK FOR YOUR SUPPORT TO PUT THE POWER BACK 23WHERE IT BELONGS WITH THE PEOPLE. SUPERVISOR SOLIS.
24 25SUP. HILDA SOLIS: THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. I JUST WANT TO ENTER JULY 30, 2024
329
1INTO THE RECORD A LIST OF 91 NAMES OF PEOPLE WHO WERE HERE OR 2WERE GOING TO CALL IN OR SUBMITTED LETTERS IN SUPPORT OF THIS 3AND THEY REPRESENT KIND OF A BROAD STROKE OF MY DISTRICT FROM 4CITIES TO CBOS TO THE AFRICAN AMERICAN MUSEUM IN POMONA TO 5LGBTQ GROUPS AS WELL AS MANY, MANY CITIES AND UNINCORPORATED 6AREAS IN THE FIRST DISTRICT. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR.
7 8SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: THANK YOU. WITH THAT, EXECUTIVE 9OFFICER, PLEASE CALL THE MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC WHO HAVE SIGNED 10UP TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM.
11 12EXECUTIVE OFFICER: WILL THE FOLLOWING INDIVIDUALS PLEASE COME 13FORWARD? ANDREA MACK, FARAH SUE, ROGER PUGLISI, RAINA SCHMITZ, 14DAPHNE BRADFORD, MARTIN HERRERA, ANTHONY AYALA, LUPITA 15MARTINEZ, AND LARRY ORTEGA. PLEASE COME FORWARD AND STAFF WILL 16ASSIST YOU. AS A FINAL REMINDER FOR PARTICIPANTS ON THE 17TELEPHONE, IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO ADDRESS ITEM NUMBER 6 RELATED 18TO ITEM 7, IF YOU HAVE NOT ALREADY DONE SO, PLEASE PRESS 1 AND 190 NOW TO BE PLACED IN THE SPEAKING QUEUE. MODERATOR, WHEN WE 20HAVE THE FIRST REMOTE SPEAKER, PLEASE.
21 22MODERATOR: OUR FIRST PARTICIPANT IS DANDY DEPAULA. PLEASE 23UNMUTE YOURSELF AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO YOUR PHONE YOU MAY 24BEGIN.
25 JULY 30, 2024
330
1SPEAKER: HELLO, MY NAME IS DANDY DEPAULA FROM THE CITY OF 2HAWAIIAN GARDENS. THANK YOU, SUPERVISOR JANICE HAHN, FOR 3BRINGING THIS MOTION FOR CHARTER REFORM EXPANDING THE
4SUPERVISORY DISTRICT FROM 5 TO 9 WILL DEFINITELY ALLOW FOR 5MORE DIVERSE REPRESENTATION, INCREASED ACCOUNTABILITY AND 6IMPROVED SERVICES FOR OUR COMMUNITY. WITH A LARGER BOARD EACH 7SUPERVISOR WOULD HAVE A SMALLER CONSTITUENCY, YOU KNOW, 8ENABLING THEM TO FOCUS ON LOCAL ISSUES AND CONCERNS AND THIS 9EXPANSION I BELIEVE WILL ALSO PROVIDE A GREATER OPPORTUNITY TO 10REBALANCE DISTRICT BOUNDARIES AND ENSURING FAIR REPRESENTATION 11FOR ALL AREAS. WE ARE BLESSED TO HAVE A FRUITFUL PARTNERSHIP 12WITH THE OFFICE OF SUPERVISOR JANICE HAHN AND WE ARE LOOKING 13FORWARD TO GREATER EFFORTS TO IMPROVE THE QUALITY OF LIFE OF 14OUR SHARED COMMUNITY. THANK YOU.
15 16EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU. NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE. 17 18MODERATOR: OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS HECTOR DEL TORRE. PLEASE 19UNMUTE YOURSELF AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO YOUR PHONE. YOU MAY 20BEGIN.
21 22SPEAKER: THANK YOU. I'M A FORMER LEGISLATOR AND CURRENT 23DIRECTOR OF THE GATEWAY CITIES COUNCIL OF GOVERNMENTS. I AM 24SPEAKING IN SUPPORT OF EXPANSION OF THE BOARD SPECIFICALLY. I 25TELL PEOPLE THAT THE GATEWAY CITIES HAS OVER 2,000,000 JULY 30, 2024
331
1RESIDENTS, WHICH IS ABOUT WHAT EACH OF YOU BOARD MEMBERS 2REPRESENT. IF WE WERE ONE CITY, WE WOULD BE THE FIFTH LARGEST 3CITY IN AMERICA. IF WE WERE ONE STATE, WE WOULD BE THE 38TH 4LARGEST STATE IN AMERICA. EACH OF YOU REPRESENTS THAT. THAT IS 5ENTIRELY TOO BIG, TOO COMPLEX FOR COMPARISON. THE COUNTY OF 6SAN FRANCISCO HAS 808,000 PEOPLE AND 11 SUPERVISORS. SO, THIS 7MOVING TO A BIGGER NUMBER SO THAT EACH OF YOU CAN REPRESENT A 8SMALLER POPULATION AND SERVE THEM BETTER IS MUCH NEEDED. THANK 9YOU.
10 11EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU. NEXT SPEAKER PLEASE. 12 13MODERATOR: OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS HELEN EGANBERG. PLEASE 14UNMUTE YOURSELF AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO YOUR PHONE. YOU MAY 15BEGIN.
16 17SPEAKER: HI, MY NAME IS HELEN EGANBERG. I'M PART OF HANGOUT DO 18GOOD BUT I'M SPEAKING AS A PRIVATE CITIZEN. I LIVE IN DISTRICT 193. I WANT TO THANK BOTH YOU, SUPERVISOR HORVATH AND SUPERVISOR 20HAHN, FOR YOUR COURAGE AND COMMITMENT TO BRINGING A GOVERNANCE 21REFORM PACKAGE TO THE PEOPLE. I WANT TO THANK SUPERVISOR SOLIS 22FOR JOINING THEM IN THIS. I DO BELIEVE THEIR INTENTION IS TO 23MOVE OUR COUNTY TO ITS FULLEST POTENTIAL. I WANT TO THANK ALL 245 OF YOU FOR THESE REALLY HARD CONVERSATIONS. I HAVE SAT 25THROUGH ALL OF THEM. THIS IS WHAT DEMOCRACY LOOKS LIKE. IT'S JULY 30, 2024
332
1BEEN OVER A HUNDRED YEARS. IT'S LONG OVERDUE. IT'S TIME FOR 2CHANGE. A GOVERNANCE REFORM PACKAGE THAT BRINGS US INTO THE 321ST CENTURY AND MEETS THE NEEDS OF OUR ENORMOUS, DIVERSE, AND 4BEAUTIFUL COUNTY. IT'S, YOU KNOW, IT'S EASY TO SAY NO. IT'S 5EASY TO SAY IT'S TOO COMPLICATED THAT THERE'S THIS PROBLEM, OR 6WE NEED ANOTHER STUDY. IT'S HARDER AND BRAVER TO SAY YES. WHEN 7PEOPLE ARE RUNNING FOR ELECTED OFFICE, EVERYONE USUALLY IS ALL 8FOR EXPANDING, CITY COUNCIL OR THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS. CITY 9COUNCIL HAS BEEN NOTHING BUT DISAPPOINTING. WE HAVE A CHANCE 10NOW TO DO THIS. YOU ALL ARE 5 SMART, BRAVE WOMEN. I TRUST YOU 11CAN DO THIS --
12 13EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU, NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE. 14 15MODERATOR: OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS CARRIE CHEN. PLEASE UNMUTE 16YOURSELF AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO THE PHONE. YOU MAY BEGIN. 17 18SPEAKER: HELLO, GOOD AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS CARRIE CHEN. I'M 19WITH THE ROLAND HEIGHTS CHINESE ASSOCIATION, WHICH LEADS 20ASSOCIATIONS SERVING CHINESE-AMERICAN COMMUNITIES IN ROLAND 21HEIGHTS. I SUPPORT ITEM 6 AND 7 TO EXPAND THE BOARD OF 22SUPERVISORS ELECT COUNTY EXECUTIVES. LOS ANGELES COUNTY IS THE 23NATION'S LARGEST COUNTY WITH 4,084 SQUARE MILES AND NEARLY 2410,000,000 RESIDENTS. AS LOS ANGELES COUNTY'S POPULATION GROWS 25AND DIVERSIFIES, WE MUST INNOVATE AND RE-EVALUATE HOW WE CAN JULY 30, 2024
333
1BEST MEET RESIDENTS' NEEDS TO ENSURE WE DELIVER THE SUPPORT 2THEY NEED AS INCLUSIVE, TRANSPARENTLY, AND EQUITABLY AS 3POSSIBLE. AS OF THE 2020 CENSUS COUNT, THERE ARE OVER
44,800,000 LATINOS AND 1,500,000 ASIAN AMERICAN AND PACIFIC 5ISLANDERS IN LOS ANGELES COUNTY, WHICH COMBINED MAKES OVER 60% 6OF THE COUNTIES. --
7 8EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU, NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE.
9 10MODERATOR: OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS PHIL BROWN. PLEASE UNMUTE 11YOURSELF AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO THE PHONE, YOU MAY BEGIN. 12 13SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: PHIL, ARE YOU THERE?
14 15EXECUTIVE OFFICER: MR. BROWN, YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
16 17SPEAKER: HELLO, CAN YOU HEAR ME NOW?
18 19SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: YES, WE CAN. PLEASE GO AHEAD. 20 21SPEAKER: MY NAME IS PHIL BROWN. ORIGINALLY, I WAS GONNA 22QUESTION WHY WE NEED TO SPEND MONEY TO INCREASE FROM 9 WHEN 23YOU CAN JUST ADD STAFF TO THE CURRENT 5 BUT AS I'M READING 24ONLINE THIS REFORM IT SAYS THAT YOU WANT A GOVERNANCE REFORM 25TASK FORCE AND A CHARTER REVIEW COMMISSION DON'T YOU THINK JULY 30, 2024
334
1THAT THE CHARTER REVIEW COMMISSION SHOULD HAVE BEEN DONE 2BEFORE YOU HAD THIS CHANGING OF THE CHARTER? MORE PEOPLE COULD 3HAVE BEEN INVOLVED. THIS SEEMS TO ME LIKE A POWER PLAY AND NOT 4DEMOCRACY. THANK YOU, HAVE A GREAT DAY.
5 6EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU, NEXT SPEAKER PLEASE.
7 8MODERATOR: OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS ROB KWON. PLEASE UNMUTE 9YOURSELF AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO THE PHONE. YOU MAY BEGIN. 10 11SPEAKER: HI ROB KWON. I'M FROM L.A. I LIVE IN DISTRICT 1 AND 12ALL THE TALK ABOUT THE MISSING REPORT. I THINK IT'S WORTH 13EMPHASIZING THAT THEY COMPLETED POLLING ON THIS ISSUE BACK IN 14MAY. YOU KNOW WAITED UNTIL JULY TO INTRODUCE THE MOTION WE 15COULD HAVE HAD TWICE AS MUCH TIME TO TALK ABOUT THIS ALSO WANT 16TO NOTE ON REALLY IN THE CALIFORNIA CLEAN MONEY CAMPAIGN 17SUBMITTED A MEMO ON THIS ITEM YESTERDAY EVENING. WE SUGGESTED 18SOME CHANGES THAT IT WOULD ENSURE SOME BARE ESSENTIALS FOR 19INDEPENDENCE. BUT I KNOW YOU WANT TO WRAP THIS UP TODAY. SO, 20WE ASK THAT AT A MINIMUM, SUPERVISORS HORVATH, HAHN AND SOLIS 21COMMIT THEMSELVES TO RETURNING TO THE BALLOT IN 2026 TO ENSURE 22SUBSTANTIVE ETHICS REFORMS ARE PROPERLY PLACED IN OUR CHARTER. 23FAILURE TO DO SO IS GOING TO NEEDLESSLY HARM THIS ISSUE AND 24POTENTIALLY OTHERS ON THE BALLOT. IF THIS THING FAILS IN 25NOVEMBER BECAUSE OF YOUR HANDLING OF IT AND IT COULD SET THE JULY 30, 2024
335
1EXPANSION MOVE BACK IN A REALLY DEVASTATING WAY THAT COULD 2SCREW OVER WHAT WE'RE TRYING TO DO AT A CITY LEVEL. SO PLEASE, 3SHOW SOME LEADERSHIP, SHOW SOME REAL FOLLOW THROUGH. THIS IS 4ALL JUST A REALLY ANNOYING PROCESS TO SEE AT A CITY-COUNTY 5LEVEL. --
6 7EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU. YOUR TIME HAS EXPIRED. NEXT 8SPEAKER, PLEASE.
9 10MODERATOR: OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS ANTHONY ARENAS. PLEASE 11UNMUTE YOURSELF AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO THE PHONE. YOU MAY 12BEGIN.
13 14SPEAKER: HI. MY NAME IS ANTHONY ARENAS WITH THE JUSTICE OF THE 15LAKE COALITION AND MY FORMER RESIDENT OF DISTRICT 3. AND I 16WANT TO SUPPORT THAT DIFFUSION OF CENTRALIZED POWER AND MAYBE 17EXPANDING THE BOARD AND REFORM THAT ENHANCES TRANSPARENCY AND 18PUBLIC INPUT. AND THE APPROACH MATTERS SIGNIFICANTLY. AND WHAT 19OUR COMMUNITIES DESERVE, THE ENTIRE COMMUNITY, NOT JUST THE 20ONES WHO ARE POLLED, DESERVE IS A DELIBERATE CHARTER AMENDMENT 21CREATED NOT BY PERSONAL PREFERENCES, BUT BY A COMPREHENSIVE 22UNDERSTANDING OF WHAT SERVES THE PUBLIC'S GREATER GOOD. THIS 23AMENDMENT SHOULD ENSURE THAT OUR GOVERNOR, OUR GOVERNING 24STRUCTURE EVOLVES IN A WAY THAT PROMOTES OPENNESS AND 25INCLUSIVITY, REFLECTING THE DIVERSE NEEDS OF OUR POPULATION.
JULY 30, 2024
336
1THANK YOU.
2 3EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU. NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE.
4 5MODERATOR: OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS JOSE BARRERA. PLEASE UNMUTE 6YOURSELF AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO THE PHONE. YOU MAY BEGIN. 7 8SPEAKER: THANK YOU, AND THANK YOU, SUPERVISORS, FOR BRINGING 9THIS FORWARD. MY NAME IS JOSE BARRERA. I REPRESENT LULAC, THE 10NATION'S LARGEST LATINO CIVIL RIGHTS ADVOCACY ORGANIZATION. 11HERE SPEAKING IN SUPPORT OF ITEMS 6 AND 7 TO EXPAND THE BOARD. 12AS YOU ALL HAVE HEARD, L.A. COUNTY IS THE LARGEST COUNTY IN 13THE NATION WITH A VERY DIVERSE POPULATION OF LATINOS AND OTHER 14DEMOGRAPHICS. AND THIS MEASURE WOULD ENSURE THAT OUR
15POPULATION IS HAVING THE CHANCE OF BEING BETTER REPRESENTED 16AND HAVING A MORE EQUITABLE PROCESS, INCLUDING TRANSPARENCY. 17SO, I APPRECIATE AND URGE YOU TO VOTE IN FAVOR OF THIS AND 18BRING IT TO THE VOTERS. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
19 20EXECUTIVE OFFICER: NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE.
21 22MODERATOR: OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS ERIC PREVIN. PLEASE UNMUTE 23YOURSELF AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO THE PHONE. YOU MAY BEGIN. 24 25SPEAKER: THANK YOU. I DON'T WANNA USE MYSELF, BUT I JUST FEEL JULY 30, 2024
337
1LIKE, YOU KNOW, HORVATH GETS A LITTLE CREDIT FOR BEING BRAVE, 2BUT THE PROCESS HAS BEEN, HAS BEEN BAD. AND TO LOOK AT THE 3COUNTY CEO AS AN ELECTED POSITION, IT REALLY DOES NOT POP INTO 4FOCUS AS THE RESOLUTION TO LIKE SOME OF THESE PROBLEMS. WHAT? 5I MEAN, DAVENPORT IS COMPETENT. SHE CAN WRITE UP A PLAN. I 6DON'T UNDERSTAND. THE VOTERS WOULD HAVE TOLD HER THAT WHAT 7KIND OF A PLAN TO WRITE UP. NO, THE LEGISLATIVE BODY THAT THE 85 SUPERVISORS PUT. AND FRANKLY, I THINK THAT IN THE OLD DAYS, 95 SUPERVISORS WAS SMART. BUT CONSIDER THIS, THE CITY ETHICS 10COMMISSION IS ALREADY, IT DOESN'T WORK, BUT IT'S FUNCTIONAL. 11WHY NOT JUST HAVE ONE ETHICS COMMISSION FOR LOS ANGELES AND 12HAVE THEM ABSORB THE 5, OR WOULD YOU BRING IT TO 9
13SUPERVISORS? SO, THEY'RE JUST ONE PLACE TO GET THE INFORMATION 14WE NEED, LIKE WHO'S BEEN PAYING OVER $250. AND WHY DON'T WE DO 15THAT AT THE CITY, FOR THE GREAT CITY AT THE EXCUSES? WHY DON'T 16THEY ANNOUNCE WHEN THEY'RE GETTING DONATIONS OVER $250? I 17WOULD RECOMMEND TABLING THIS WHOLE THING AND GETTING OVER TO 18FRIENDS AND FINDING OUT HOW MANY ARE WRONG --
19 20EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU, NEXT SPEAKER PLEASE. 21 22MODERATOR: OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS DAVID TORRES. PLEASE UNMUTE 23YOURSELF AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO THE PHONE. YOU MAY BEGIN. 24 25SPEAKER: HI, THIS IS COUNCILMAN DAVID TORRES REPRESENTING JULY 30, 2024
338
1DISTRICT 4 IN THE CITY OF MONTEBELLO. I ENCOURAGE THE BOARD TO 2VOTE TO APPROVE THE ITEM. THERE'S LONG BEEN THE OBSERVATION 3THAT VARIOUS LEGISLATIVE BODIES FROM LOCAL TO FEDERAL
4GOVERNMENT AND EVERYTHING IN BETWEEN, HAVING GROWN TO
5ACCOMMODATE THE GROWTH IN THEIR COMMUNITIES. I FIRST WANT TO 6THANK YOU ALL FOR TAKING YOUR POSITIONS AND BEING EXAMPLES ON 7HOW TO DISAGREE WITHOUT BEING DISAGREEABLE. AND I WANT TO SAY 8THANK YOU TO SUPERVISORS HORVATH, HAHN AND SOLIS FOR
9RECOGNIZING AND ADDRESSING THIS NEED AND MOVING TO EFFECT 10CHANGE TOWARDS A MORE PERFECT LOS ANGELES COUNTY. THANK YOU. 11 12EXECUTIVE OFFICER: NEXT SPEAKER PLEASE.
13 14SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: WE'RE GONNA GO TO SPEAKERS IN 15PERSON ACTUALLY, SO WE'LL GO RIGHT AHEAD PLEASE, THANKS. 16 17SPEAKER: HELLO SUPERVISORS, MY NAME IS ANDREA MACK AND I'M 18HERE ON BEHALF OF CAHLS AND ALSO A DISTRICT 1 RESIDENT. I'M 19HERE AGAIN TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT FOR THE CHARTER REFORM THAT 20WILL EXPAND THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS SEAT. THE MERE CHANGE IN 21THE NUMBER OF SUPERVISORS WOULD DEEPLY IMPACT THE RESIDENTS IN 22L.A. COUNTY. THERE'LL BE MORE OPPORTUNITIES TO CONNECT THE 23BOARD OF SUPERVISORS, BETTER SERVICES FOR RESIDENTS, AND MORE 24OPPORTUNITIES FOR REPRESENTATION AND RESIDENTS TO MAKE THEIR 25VOICES HEARD. AS SOMEONE WHO IS YOUNG AND CARES ABOUT CIVIC JULY 30, 2024
339
1ENGAGEMENT, I'M EXCITED ABOUT THE CONVERSATIONS AROUND 2CREATING TASK FORCE AND ETHICS REFORM COMMISSIONS AND
3INCREASING TRANSPARENCY ACROSS THE BOARD. TODAY I'M HERE AS AN 4ASIAN AMERICAN, AS A YOUTH, AND AS SOMEONE WHO HAS LIVED IN 5LOS ANGELES FOR THE LAST 22 YEARS, AND I'M HERE TO SAY THAT 6I'M EXCITED AND WOULD LIKE TO BE INCLUDED IN ALL PARTS OF THE 7CONVERSATION OF THIS EXPANSION AND REFORM JOURNEY. THAT SAID, 8I AM IN SUPPORT OF THIS ITEM TO EXPAND THE BOARD OF
9SUPERVISORS' SEAT. THANK YOU.
10 11SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: THANK YOU. NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE. 12 13SPEAKER: GOOD EVENING AND THANK YOU SUPERVISORS. MY NAME IS 14FARAH AND I'M ALSO SPEAKING ON BEHALF OF CAUSE AND AS A 15RESIDENT OF DISTRICT 1. I'M IN SUPPORT OF ITEM 7, SPECIFICALLY 16TO EXPAND THE BOARD AND I HAVE ALSO ATTENDED ALL THE READINGS 17OF THIS ORDINANCE AND REALLY JUST REALLY APPRECIATE ALL THE 18CONVERSATIONS THAT HAVE BEEN HAD IN THESE MEETINGS. THE 19EXPANSION OF THE BOARD WOULD BE AN IMPORTANT STEP TOWARDS 20BETTER REPRESENTATION AND OFFERING ADDITIONAL OPPORTUNITIES TO 21BRING MORE DIVERSE VOICES TO THE TABLE AND SHAPE THE FUTURE OF 22L.A. COUNTY. IT HAS BEEN A PERSONALLY VERY VALUABLE LEARNING 23EXPERIENCE TO ATTEND THESE MEETINGS, SO I REALLY APPRECIATE 24THE HONEST CONVERSATION. AND I DO ASK THAT AS WE CONTINUE TO 25BUILD A GOVERNMENT THAT BETTER SERVES US, THAT ALL FUTURE JULY 30, 2024
340
1ELECTED LEADERS OF L.A. COUNTY SHOULD ACTIVELY INCLUDE 2COMMUNITY VOICES IN ALL STEPS OF THE IMPLEMENTATION PROCESS. I 3KNOW THERE WERE SOME REFLECTIONS MADE BY THE BOARD TODAY AND I 4REALLY APPRECIATE THAT. AND I ALSO WISH THAT THERE WERE MORE 5OPPORTUNITIES FOR COMMUNITY INPUT AND CONVERSATION. I DO 6BELIEVE THAT'S AN IMPORTANT PART OF CREATING A BETTER SHARED 7GOVERNMENT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU, NEXT SPEAKER.
8 9SPEAKER: GOOD AFTERNOON AND THANK YOU SUPERVISORS FOR THE 10MOTION. MY NAME IS ANTHONY AYALA AND I AM WITH THE WELLNESS 11CENTER AT L.A. GENERAL MEDICAL CENTER IN BOYLE HEIGHTS. I'M 12HERE TODAY TO EXPRESS MY SUPPORT FOR ITEM 7 TO EXPAND THE 13BOARD OF SUPERVISORS AND TO ELECT A COUNTY EXECUTIVE. WE MUST 14REEVALUATE HOW TO BEST MEET THE NEEDS OF DIVERSE L.A. COUNTY 15RESIDENTS TO ENSURE THAT SUPPORT IS DELIVERED EQUITABLY AND 16WITH AN ACUTE UNDERSTANDING OF THEIR MATERIAL NEEDS. THIS IS 17ESPECIALLY CRITICAL FOR RESIDENTS AND COMMUNITIES WHO HAVE 18BEEN HISTORICALLY EXCLUDED FROM CONVERSATIONS THAT HAVE DIRECT 19IMPACTS ON THEIR DAILY LIVES AND LONG-TERM FUTURES AS 20RESIDENTS OF LOS ANGELES COUNTY. OFTEN POLITICAL
21REPRESENTATION DOESN'T RESONATE WITH ME OR MY LIVED
22EXPERIENCES, AND THIS IS SOMETHING I KNOW TO BE TRUE FOR 23VARIOUS MARGINALIZED COMMUNITIES WITHIN L.A. COUNTY. THIS IS 24WHY EXPANDING THE BOARD IS NECESSARY TO ENSURE THAT THE 25REPRESENTATION OF OUR LOCAL GOVERNANCE IS ABLE TO SPEAK JULY 30, 2024
341
1DIRECTLY TO THE NEEDS AND PERSPECTIVES OF OUR LOCAL COMMUNITY 2MEMBERS. WE MUST EXPAND THE BOARD TO ENSURE THAT OUR VOICES 3ARE NOT ONLY HEARD, BUT HAVE THE POWER TO INFLUENCE DECISIONS 4THAT ARE MADE FOR OUR COMMUNITY BY PEOPLE FROM OUR COMMUNITY. 5THIS IS HOW WE ADVANCE EQUITY AND JUSTICE FOR LOCAL RESIDENTS 6AND REPAIR A TRUST AND GOVERNANCE IN THE PROCESS. THANK YOU. 7 8SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: THANK YOU. NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE. 9 10SPEAKER: GOOD AFTERNOON, MADAM AND BOARD MEMBERS. MY NAME IS 11REYNA SCHMITZ, AND I AM A COMMISSIONER WITH OLDER ADULTS FOR 12THE FIRST DISTRICT. I SUPPORT ITEM 6 AND 7 TO EXPAND THE BOARD 13AND SUPPORT ELECTED A COUNTY EXECUTIVE. THE LOS ANGELES COUNTY 14BEING THE LARGEST COUNTY IN THE NATION NEEDS TO ADAPT TO THE 15GROWTH AND NEEDS RESIDENTS TO BETTER SERVE THEM. THE DIVERSITY 16OF L.A. COUNTY RESIDENTS DEMANDS THE REEVALUATION NEEDS OF OUR 17DIVERSE POPULATION TO SERVE THE COMMUNITY RESIDENTS NEEDS. THE 18EXPANSION IS GOING IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION. SINCE THE CENSUS OF 192020, SHOW THAT THE LATINO, ASIAN AMERICAN, AND THE PACIFIC 20ISLANDERS COMPOSED 60%, IT IS JUST THE RIGHT THING THAT YOU, 21THE BOARD, PLEASE SUPPORT THESE ISSUES, AND THAT WAY WE WILL 22HAVE FULL REPRESENTATION. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
23 24SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: THANK YOU, NEXT SPEAKER PLEASE. 25 JULY 30, 2024
342
1SPEAKER: THANK YOU, GOOD AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS MARTINO HERRERA 2AND I'M A COUNCIL MEMBER FOR THE CITY OF EL MONTE. AND I'M 3HERE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF AGENDA ITEM 6 AND 7. IT'S A BOLD 4STEP THAT ANY TIME A GOVERNMENTAL ENTITY COMES FORTH TO 5RECONSIDER ITS GOVERNANCE STRUCTURE AND MODEL OF SERVICE 6DELIVERY. SO, I'M HERE TO URGE YOU TO TAKE THAT STEP. IN MY 7OWN CITY AS A COUNCIL MEMBER, WHEN I CAME ON, I LED AN EFFORT 8TO CHANGE OUR OWN GOVERNANCE STRUCTURE AND THAT IS TO GO FROM 9AT LARGE TO DISTRICT ELECTIONS. WE EXPANDED OUR BOARD FROM 5 10TO 7, ALL IN AN EFFORT TO CREATE BETTER REPRESENTATION THAT 11WAS EQUITABLE GEOGRAPHICALLY AND DEMOGRAPHICALLY. AND IN A 12COUNTY THAT IS THIS SIZE, IT IS IN FACT THE LARGEST OF THE 13NATION, 10,000,000 RESIDENTS, IT'S JUST, I JUST CAN'T IMAGINE 14HOW 5 REPRESENTATIVES CAN ADEQUATELY REPRESENT THE DIVERSITY 15OF THIS COUNTY. SO, I URGE YOU TO SHARE THE BURDEN OF YOUR 16DECISION TODAY WITH THE VOTERS BY PUTTING IT ON THE BALLOT ON 17NOVEMBER 5TH. THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME AND THANK YOU FOR YOUR 18EFFORTS.
19 20SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: THANK YOU VERY MUCH. NEXT 21SPEAKER, PLEASE. MY NAME IS ROGER PUGLIESE. I'M THE VICE 22PRESIDENT OF LAS VIRGINAS HORMONES FEDERATION AND THE 23PRESIDENT OF THE TOPANGA ASSOCIATION FOR A SCENIC COMMUNITY. 24OUR MOUNTAIN COMMUNITIES CONTINUE TO BE IN FULL SUPPORT OF THE 25REVISED MOTION. AND WE ALL KNOW AND HAVE ALWAYS KNOWN THIS HAS JULY 30, 2024
343
1BEEN A LONG, LONG OVERDUE. BY ADOPTING THIS MOTION AND 2ENACTING IT, IT WILL INCREASE FAIRNESS AND ACCOUNTABILITY IN 3EACH OF THE MODIFIED DISTRICTS. GIVE IT TO THE VOTERS TO 4DECIDE. WE'RE 100% SUPPORTIVE.
5 6SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: THANK YOU VERY MUCH. NEXT 7SPEAKER, PLEASE.
8 9SPEAKER: MY NAME'S LARRY ORTEGA, AND MY FAMILY'S LIVED IN 10POMONA FOR 120 YEARS. IT'S THE EAST SIDE OF L.A. COUNTY. I'M A 11NATIONALLY RECOGNIZED DIGITAL DIVIDE EXPERT AND I STRONGLY 12ENCOURAGE THE BOARD TO VOTE YES ON ITEMS NUMBER 6 AND 7. THE 13CHARTER AMENDMENTS REPRESENT A GOVERNANCE MODEL THAT IS MORE 14EFFECTIVE, REPRESENTATIVE, AND ACCOUNTABLE TO ANGELENOS 15GENERALLY, BUT SPECIFICALLY TO COMMUNITIES ON THE EDGES OF THE 16COUNTY LIKE POMONA AT NO ADDITIONAL COST. I COME TO YOU TODAY 17WITH FIRSTHAND EXPERIENCE ON HOW THE COUNTY OF L.A. WITH THE 18PROPOSED GOVERNANCE AMENDMENTS WILL BE BETTER PREPARED TO TAKE 19ADVANTAGE OF GRANTS LIKE THE $1,830,000,000 THAT CALIFORNIA 20HAD. STRONGLY ENCOURAGE THE BOARD TO VOTE YES ON SUPERVISORS 21HORVATH AND HAHN’S REFORM PACKAGE FOR THE NOVEMBER BALLOT. 22 23SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: NEXT SPEAKER PLEASE.
24 25SPEAKER: GOOD EVENING SUPERVISORS, MY NAME IS LUPITA MARTINEZ, JULY 30, 2024
344
1I AM HERE ON BEHALF OF CHIRLA COALITION FOR HUMANE IMMIGRANT 2RIGHTS. CHIRLA IS A MEMBER-LED ORGANIZATION AND OUR MISSION IS 3TO CREATE A JUST SOCIETY, FULLY INCLUSIVE OF IMMIGRANTS. AS I 4MENTIONED BEFORE, CHIRLA'S CIVIC ENGAGEMENT IS FUNDAMENTAL IN 5OUR MISSION TO ORGANIZE AND MOBILIZE COMMUNITIES TO HARNESS 6OUR IMMIGRANT POLITICAL POWER. FOR YEARS, CHIRLA AND PARTNER 7ORGANIZATIONS HAVE FOUGHT AND WORKED REALLY, REALLY HARD TO 8ENSURE IMMIGRANT COMMUNITIES AND UNDERREPRESENTED COMMUNITIES 9ARE HEARD, INCLUDED, AND REPRESENTED INTENTIONALLY COUNTY 10POLICIES, INITIATIVES, AND PROGRAMS. ALTHOUGH CHIRLA SUPPORTS 11A CHARTER REFORM, IT IS CRUCIAL THAT IMMIGRANT AND VULNERABLE 12COMMUNITIES TO BE INCLUDED IN THE DECISION-MAKING PROCESS DUE 13TO OUR INVALUABLE CONTRIBUTIONS AND LIVED EXPERIENCES HERE IN 14THE COUNTY OF L.A. WE REQUEST FOR IMMIGRANTS AND
15UNDERREPRESENTED COMMUNITIES TO PLAY A PIVOTAL ROLE IN 16INFORMING THE INTRICACIES OF EVERY STEP OF THE CHARTER REFORM 17TO ENSURE A FAIR, TRANSPARENT, AND REFLECTS THE VOICES AND 18EXPERIENCES OF OUR IMMIGRANT COMMUNITIES. THANK YOU.
19 20SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: THANK YOU, NEXT SPEAKER PLEASE. 21 22SPEAKER: GOOD EVENING. GOOD EVENING, I'M DAPHNE BRACK, A 23RESIDENT OF UNINCORPORATED LADERA HEIGHTS IN DISTRICT 2. I'M 24HERE TODAY TO SPECIFICALLY ASK SUPERVISOR HAHN FOR A MEETING 25TO DISCUSS USING ME AS A CASE STUDY FOR YOUR GOVERNANCE REFORM JULY 30, 2024
345
1MOTION. I HAVE LETTERS WITH ME TO SUPPORT THIS FROM DISTRICT 2 2RESIDENTS WHO BELIEVE THAT MORE COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT SHOULD 3HAVE HAPPENED BEFORE THIS PROCESS. BUT MOST IMPORTANTLY, AS A 4SURVIVOR OF WHAT I AND MY SUPPORTERS CONSIDER POLITICAL ABUSE 5OF THE POWER BY MARK RIDLEY THOMAS, I'M ASKING YOU TO MEET 6WITH ME AND USE MY CASE AS A CASE STUDY, MY EXPERIENCE AS A 7CASE STUDY TO MAKE SURE YOU GET IT RIGHT. IF THIS MOTION 8PASSES AND YOU HAVE AN ELECTED CEO AND WHAT THAT PROCESS IS IF 9THE CEO IS DOING A BAD JOB.
10 11SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. 12WE'LL NOW GO BACK TO SPEAKERS ON THE PHONE. MODERATOR, PLEASE 13GO AHEAD.
14 15MODERATOR: THANK YOU. OUR FIRST PARTICIPANT IS SUZETTE SHAW. 16PLEASE UNMUTE YOURSELF AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO YOUR PHONE. YOU 17MAY BEGIN.
18 19SPEAKER: RESIDENTS, I'VE BEEN ON WITH YOU ALL SINCE THIS 20MORNING, AND I'M GLAD I STAYED ON. I WILL SAY THAT I BELIEVE 21EXPANDING THE BOARD AND BRINGING MORE EQUITABLE GRASSROOTS 22REPRESENTATION IS IMPERATIVE. BLACK FOLKS ARE NOT ONE OF THE 23MAJOR POPULATIONS IN L.A. COUNTY, EXCEPT AS IT RELATES TO 24POVERTY AND HOMELESSNESS. AND I BELIEVE, I STRONGLY FEEL THAT 25THIS IS ONE OF THE ISSUES AS IT RELATES TO CITY AND COUNTY JULY 30, 2024
346
1GOVERNMENTS AND THE LACK OF EQUITY AND INCLUSION AND DIVERSITY 2AS IT RELATES TO BLACK PEOPLE. AND BLACK PEOPLE LIVING IN 3POVERTY, THE HOMELESSNESS. WHEN YOU DECIDE ON REPRESENTING OR 4EXPANDING YOUR COMMITTEE, I HOPE THAT THERE IS A VOICE AND A 5SEAT AT THE TABLE FOR SKID ROW AND I WOULD LIKE TO BE THAT 6REPRESENTATION. WE COULD NO LONGER TALK ABOUT EQUALITY AND 7EMPOWERMENT WHILE CONTINUING TO ENFORCE INEQUITY. THANK YOU. 8 9SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: THANK YOU, NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE. 10MODERATOR.
11 12MODERATOR: OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS MEL BAILEY. PLEASE UNMUTE 13YOURSELF AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO YOUR PHONE. YOU MAY BEGIN. 14 15SPEAKER: YES, THANK YOU. I KNOW WE TALK A LOT ABOUT DIVERSITY, 16AND WHILE I DO AGREE WITH THAT IN PART, I DO RECOGNIZE THAT 17OVER THE PAST 3 MEETINGS, THERE HAS BEEN A LARGE
18REPRESENTATION OF DIVERSITY THAT HAS COME OUT AND SPOKEN. I 19THINK FOR THE DEMOCRATIC PROCESS, THAT IS A GOOD THING. I 20DON'T UNDERSTAND HOW IT'S NOT A CONFLICT OF INTEREST OF 21ELECTING THIS NEW POSITION OF THE CEO. THAT'S SOMETHING THAT 22I'M STILL HAVING REALLY CAUGHT UP WITH THE RATIONALIZATION 23BEHIND IT. AND THEN MY LAST THING, WELL THE STUDY. I NEVER SAW 24THE STUDY AND THE DISTRICT TEAM MEMBER, I'M NOT SURE IF IT'S 25SKIPPED US, BUT I DIDN'T REMEMBER SEEING IT. AND THEN THE LAST JULY 30, 2024
347
1THING IS WE OFTEN SAY THAT WHEN PEOPLE TRY TO FORCE YOU IN 2SOMETHING REALLY QUICK, IT'S PROBABLY A SCAM. AND I'M NOT 3SAYING THAT YOU ALL ARE SCAMMING US, BUT I AM SAYING IF IT'S 4NOT URGENT, IF IT'S NOT AN EMERGENCY, WHY DON'T WE JUST TAKE A 5STEP BACK AND AT LEAST MAYBE YOU MIGHT BE ABLE TO CONVINCE THE 6OTHER 2 SUPERVISORS WHY IT SHOULD BE CHANGED. THANK YOU. 7 8EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU. YOUR TIME HAS EXPIRED. THANK 9YOU. NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE.
10 11MODERATOR: THANK YOU. OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS TIM LEMAURIE. 12YOU MAY UNMUTE YOURSELF AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO YOUR PHONE. 13PLEASE BEGIN.
14 15SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: KIM?
16 17MODERATOR: THAT PARTY DID DISCONNECT. I APOLOGIZE. OUR NEXT 18LINE IS XOCHITL COVARRUBIAS. PLEASE UNMUTE YOURSELF AND SPEAK 19DIRECTLY INTO YOUR PHONE. YOU MAY BEGIN.
20 21SPEAKER: GOOD AFTERNOON, BOARD OF SUPERVISORS. BUENAS TARDES. 22MY NAME IS SOCHIL COVARRUBIAS, PRESIDENT OF THE LABOR COUNCIL 23FOR LATIN AMERICAN ADVANCEMENT, AN ORGANIZATION FOR LATINO 24WORKERS AND THEIR FAMILIES. I'M SPEAKING AS A CITIZEN. I WANT 25TO THANK SUPERVISOR HILDA SOLIS FOR THE MOTION. I SUPPORT ITEM JULY 30, 2024
348
16 AND 7 TO EXPAND THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS AND ELECT A COUNTY 2EXECUTIVE. THIS IS ESPECIALLY CRITICAL FOR RESIDENTS IN 3COMMUNITIES WHO HAVE HISTORICALLY BEEN LEFT OUT OF THIS 4CONVERSATION, WHO DESERVE EQUAL REPRESENTATION AND CAN HAVE 5CONFIDENCE IN OUR COMMITMENT TO DELIVER IT AND I'M VERY 6CONFIDENT WITH THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS THEY'RE VERY
7INTELLIGENT WOMAN POWERFUL WOMAN AND I KNOW THAT THEY WILL DO 8THE RIGHT THING IN BOTH IN FAVOR OF ITEM 6 AND 7. THANK YOU. 9 10EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU. NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE. MODERATOR 11NEXT SPEAKER.
12 13MODERATOR: THANK YOU. OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS LOURDES 14CARACOVA. PLEASE UNMUTE YOURSELF AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO YOUR 15PHONE. YOU MAY BEGIN.
16 17SPEAKER: HELLO, SUPERVISORS. MY NAME IS LOURDES CARACOZA. I 18WAS BORN AND RAISED IN EAST LOS ANGELES, AND I'M BLESSED TO BE 19LEADING AN ORGANIZATION SUCH AS ALMO FAMILY SERVICES THAT 20SERVES THE DIVERSE COMMUNITIES THROUGHOUT L.A. COUNTY. AS 21SOMEONE WHO GREW UP IN THE 70S AND 80’S IN EAST L.A., I ONLY 22KNOW TOO WELL THE IMPORTANCE OF REPRESENTATION. A
23REPRESENTATION THAT LOOKS LIKE THE COMMUNITIES THEY SERVE. 24THAT IS WHY I AM IN SUPPORT OF ITEMS 6 AND 7. I HAVE NO DOUBT 25THAT THIS BOARD OF SUPERVISORS HAS OUR COMMUNITY'S BEST JULY 30, 2024
349
1INTEREST IN MIND, AND HAVE A PROVEN RECORD OF BEING INNOVATIVE 2IN YOUR APPROACH AND HOW YOU REEVALUATE HOW TO BEST MEET THE 3CHANGING NEEDS OF OUR COMMUNITIES AND OUR RESIDENTS. I AM SURE 4THIS IS NOT AN EASY DECISION OR PROCESS, BUT THE FACT THAT YOU 5ARE A BODY WILLING TO LOOK INTO THE REALITY THAT THE LATEST 62020 CENSUS DATA SHOWS US REGARDING THE GROWTH OF DIVERSE 7COMMUNITIES AMONG US GIVES ME HOPE, MEANING YOU AREN'T JUST 8LOOKING AT THESE NUMBERS, BUT YOU'RE WILLING TO TAKE ACTION TO 9ENSURE.
10 11EXECUTIVE OFFICER: NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE.
12 13MODERATOR: OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS ROBERT LANCET. YOU MAY 14UNMUTE YOURSELF AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO YOUR PHONE, PLEASE 15BEGIN.
16 17SPEAKER: I AM ROBERT LANCET, A FORMER PRESIDENT AND CURRENT 18MEMBER OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS REPRESENTING THE
19UNINCORPORATED COMMUNITY OF WEST HILLS. WE SUPPORT THE 20PROPOSED GOVERNMENT REFORM PACKAGE AS DEFINED IN ITEMS 6 AND 217, AND RECOMMEND THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS APPROVE PLACING IT 22ON THE DELIVER BALLOT FOR VOTERS TO APPROVE. WE BELIEVE THAT 23THE VOTERS WILL WELCOME AND APPROVE THIS LONG OVERDUE 24IMPROVEMENT TO COMMUNITY ACCESSIBILITY AND REPRESENTATION AS 25WELL AS BOARD EFFICIENCY, EFFECTIVENESS AND TRANSPARENCY.
JULY 30, 2024
350
1THANK YOU.
2 3EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU. NEXT SPEAKER PLEASE.
4 5MODERATOR: OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS ESTHER ADIM. PLEASE UNMUTE 6YOURSELF AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO YOUR PHONE. YOU MAY BEGIN. 7 8SPEAKER: THANK YOU. HI, THIS IS ESTHER. MAKING GOVERNMENT MORE 9EFFECTIVE AND ETHICAL IS COMMENDABLE. WHOEVER THINKS THIS PLAN 10FULLY ACHIEVES THAT IS CONFUSED. AT THE BASELINE, A PROPER 11FISCAL REVIEW WAS NOT DONE, PARTICULARLY FOR THE MOST 12VULNERABLE. ADDING MORE MEMBERS AND A NEW ELECTED POSITION 13REQUIRES THE VOTERS' APPROVAL, BUT NOTHING ELSE. ADDING THE 14ETHICS REFORM TO BOARD EXTENSION AT A TIME WHEN VOTERS ARE 15DISGUSTED WITH POLITICIANS IS A MANIPULATOR OF VOTERS' DESIRE 16FOR REAL REFORM. MANY OF THE ETHICS REFORMS THIS BODY CAN 17CREATE WITHOUT GOING TO THE BALLOT. SO, START FIXING THE 18CORRUPTION TODAY IF IT EXISTS. I ALSO WONDER WHAT DOES THIS 19MEAN FOR TERM LIMITS FOR THE CURRENT BOARD. WILL THOSE NEW 20SEATS BE FAIR GAME FOR THEM? WILL THEY BE ALLOWED TO RUN FOR 21THE NEW ELECTED EXECUTIVE POSITION? THIS SEEMS RUSHED. WHY NOT 22TAKE THE TIME TO DO THIS RIGHT IF IT'S FOR THE PEOPLE? THE 23COUNTY HAS CONSISTENTLY BEEN FISCALLY SOLVENT UNLIKE OTHER 24GOVERNMENTS WHO CURRENTLY HAVE THE SYSTEM YOU WANT TO SHIFT 25INTO. SO WHY THE CHANGE? WANT TO BE MORE TRANSPARENT, JULY 30, 2024
351
1EFFECTIVE, AND ETHICAL FOR THE PEOPLE? THEN JUST DO IT TODAY. 2STOP LOOKING FOR THE HEADLINES. THANK YOU ALL FOR YOUR EFFORTS 3AND YOUR SERVICE.
4 5EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU. NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE.
6 7MODERATOR: THANK YOU. OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT.
8 9SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: MODERATOR. MODERATOR? MODERATOR, 10NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE. MODERATOR, NEXT SPEAKER PLEASE. 11 12MODERATOR: OUR NEXT QUESTION IS FROM SCARLETT PERALTA, PLEASE 13GO AHEAD.
14SPEAKER: YES, HELLO MY NAME IS SCARLETT PERALTA I AM A 15RESIDENT AND THE MAYOR FOR THE CITY OF MONTEBELLO. I AM 16SPEAKING TO EXPRESS MY STRONG SUPPORT FOR ITEMS 6 AND 7. I 17WOULD LIKE TO THANK SUPERVISOR HORVATH AND HAHN FOR THEIR 18COURAGE TO BRING THIS MOTION FORWARD AS WELL AS SUPERVISOR 19SOLIS FOR HER SUPPORT AND ALL SUPERVISORS FOR ENGAGING IN THIS 20IMPORTANT AND VERY DIFFICULT DISCUSSION. AS WE KNOW LOS 21ANGELES COUNTY IS THE LARGEST COUNTY IN OUR NATION. AS OUR 22POPULATION CONTINUES TO GROW AND DIVERSIFY IT IS EXTREMELY 23CRUCIAL THAT WE ADAPT AND REALIGN OUR APPROACH TO A MORE 24EQUITABLE GOVERNANCE. HISTORICALLY MARGINALIZED COMMUNITIES 25DESERVE TO HAVE THEIR VOICES HEARD AND THEIR NEEDS ADDRESSED.
JULY 30, 2024
352
1THIS REFORM WILL HELP BETTER SERVE ALL RESIDENTS BY PROVIDING 2MORE EQUITABLE REPRESENTATION AND FOSTERING CONFIDENCE WITHIN 3OUR COMMUNITIES. THANK YOU.
4 5EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU. NEXT SPEAKER PLEASE.
6 7MODERATOR: THANK YOU. OUR NEXT QUESTION IS FROM JUAN CARDENAS. 8PLEASE UNMUTE YOURSELF AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO YOUR PHONE. YOU 9MAY BEGIN.
10 11SPEAKER: HELLO, MY NAME IS JUAN GARVINAS I'M IN THE THIRD 12DISTRICT IN THE CITY OF SAN FERNANDO. I'M AN ASSOCIATE 13DIRECTOR FROM NONPROFIT ORGANIZATION CALLED L.A. FOURTH 14SOCIETY AND WE ARE IN SUPPORT OF ITEM 6 AND 7 TO EXPAND THE 15BOARD OF SUPERVISORS. WE BELIEVE THAT L.A. COUNTY AND THE 16COMMUNITY SERVE MORE REPRESENTATION. THANK YOU SO MUCH. 17 18EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU. NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE. 19 20MODERATOR: OUR NEXT QUESTION AND PARTICIPANT IS FROM DEBORAH 21MENDEZ. PLEASE UNMUTE YOURSELF AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO YOUR 22PHONE. YOU MAY BEGIN.
23 24SPEAKER: HELLO. MY NAME IS DEBORAH MENDEZ AND I'M WITH POMONA 25ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY CENTER. WE ARE AN ORGANIZATION THAT JULY 30, 2024
353
1SUPPORTS IMMIGRANTS IN THE POMONA VALLEY AND THE INLAND EMPIRE 2AND I'M CALLING IN SUPPORT OF ITEMS 6 AND 7 TO EXPAND THE 3BOARD OF SUPERVISORS AND ELECTED COUNTY EXECUTIVES. IT IS 4ESPECIALLY CRITICAL FOR RESIDENTS AND COMMUNITIES WHO HAVE 5HISTORICALLY BEEN LEFT OUT OF THESE CONVERSATIONS AND WHO 6DESERVE EQUAL REPRESENTATION AND HAVE AND I HAVE CONFIDENCE IN 7THE COMMITMENT TO DELIVER IT. THIS IS ESPECIALLY CRITICAL FOR 8SUCH A LARGE AREA. WE HAVE OVER 4,800,000 LATINOS AND
91,500,000 ASIAN AMERICAN AND PACIFIC ISLANDERS IN THE COUNTY 10OF LOS ANGELES. AND COMBINED, IT MAKES UP 60% OF THE COUNTY'S 11TOTAL POPULATION. WE NEED TO HAVE EQUITY AND TRANSPARENCY AND 12INCLUSION --
13 14EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU, YOUR TIME HAS EXPIRED. NEXT 15SPEAKER PLEASE.
16 17MODERATOR: THANK YOU, OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS FROM GABRIELA 18GOMEZ. PLEASE UNMUTE YOURSELF AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO YOUR 19PHONE. YOU MAY BEGIN.
20 21SPEAKER: HELLO. GOOD AFTERNOON, BOARD. AND ESPECIALLY I WANT 22TO THANK SUPERVISORS HAHN AND HORVATH FOR LEADING THIS EFFORT. 23I APPRECIATE ALL THE ENTIRE BOARD FOR LEADING THE DISCUSSION 24AS WELL FOR PARTICIPATING IN THE DISCUSSION. I AM IN SUPPORT 25OF ITEM 6 AND 7. I AM HERE AS THE MAYOR OF THE CITY OF BELL JULY 30, 2024
354
1GARDEN AND ALSO AS A 30-YEAR EMPLOYEE WITH THE DEPARTMENT OF 2PUBLIC SOCIAL SERVICES SERVING THE ENTIRE COUNTY. WE SERVE 3ABOUT 4,000,000 PEOPLE, YOU KNOW, FULLY NEARLY HALF OF THE 4ENTIRE COUNTY POPULATION AND WE DEFINITELY NEED MORE
5REPRESENTATION. I THINK IT'S UNFAIR TO EXPECT THAT EACH 6SUPERVISOR WILL BE ABLE TO HANDLE THE LARGE NUMBERS OF PEOPLE 7THAT ARE IN YOUR DISTRICT. YOU NEED HELP AND WE NEED HELP. SO, 8I AM ON BOARD WITH THIS AND THANK YOU FOR THE TIME.
9 10SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: THANK YOU. NEXT SPEAKER PLEASE. 11 12MODERATOR: THANK YOU. OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS LAURA SANTOS. 13PLEASE UNMUTE YOUR PHONE AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO IT. PLEASE 14BEGIN.
15 16SPEAKER: HI, MY NAME IS LAURA SANTOS. I'M A COLLEGE BOARD 17MEMBER AT MOUNT SAN ANTONIO COLLEGE AND A RESIDENT OF 18UNINCORPORATED BASSETT. I SUPPORT ITEMS 6 AND 7 AND I COMMEND 19THE SUPERVISORS FOR BEING WILLING TO SHARE POWER. MANY ELECTED 20OFFICIALS WOULD NOT SUPPORT AN ITEM THAT WAS GOOD FOR THE 21RESIDENTS, GOOD FOR THE COUNTY, BUT DID NOT BENEFIT THEM 22PERSONALLY OR DIMINISHED THEIR POWER. THANK YOU.
23 24EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU, NEXT SPEAKER PLEASE. 25 JULY 30, 2024
355
1MODERATOR: THANK YOU, OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS TEOCORA REYES. 2PLEASE UNMUTE YOUR LINE AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO YOUR PHONE. 3 4SPEAKER: HI, MY NAME IS TEODORA REYES AND I'M COMMENTING IN 5BEHALF OF MY CAPACITY AS THE COMMUNICATIONS DIRECTOR WITH THE 6SAN FERNANDO VALLEY YOUNG DEMOCRATS AND I'M A LIFELONG 7RESIDENT OF DISTRICT 3 IN THE SAN FERNANDO VALLEY. AS A UNITED 8FRONT THE SAN FERNANDO VALLEY YOUNG DEMOCRATS STRONGLY SUPPORT 9THE ALLEY COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS' PREVENTANCE REFORM 10PROPOSAL AND WE URGE ALL BOARD SUPERVISORS TO VOTE YES ON 11MOTION ITEM 6 AND 7. SAN FERNANDO VALLEY IS HOME TO 2,000,000 12ANGELENOS, WHICH OVER HALF ARE LATINAS. AND MANY LATINOS HAVE 13NEVER HAD THE OPPORTUNITY TO ELECT A CANDIDATE OF CHOICE IN A 14SINGLE DISTRICT. WITH THIS REFORM, WE'D BE ABLE TO REALLY HAVE 15A REPRESENTATIVE THAT CAN SERVE THE SAN FERNANDO VALLEY. AND 16AS YOUNG DEMOCRATS, WE ALSO BELIEVE IN THE FULLEST POSSIBLE 17PARTICIPATION OF YOUNG DEMOCRATIC VOTERS. THIS REFORM GIVES 18VOTERS THE OPPORTUNITY TO REMOVE BARRIERS AND CREATE EQUITABLE 19OUTCOMES, BUILD THE PATH FOR DIVERSE YOUNG DEMOCRATIC 20CANDIDATES TO RUN FOR OFFICE, AND ADDRESS THE DESPERATE NEEDS 21FOR REPRESENTATION WITHIN THE SAN FERNANDO VALLEY AND ALLEY 22COUNTY. WE THANK YOU FOR ALL YOUR HARD EFFORTS FOR MAKING THIS 23HAPPEN AND WE HOPE TO CONTINUE SUPPORTING --
24 25EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU, YOUR TIME HAS EXPIRED. NEXT JULY 30, 2024
356
1SPEAKER, PLEASE.
2 3MODERATOR: THANK YOU. OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS BYRON JOSE. 4PLEASE UNMUTE YOURSELF AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO YOUR PHONE. YOU 5MAY BEGIN.
6 7SPEAKER: GOOD AFTERNOON BOARD. THIS IS BYRON JOSE SPEAKING AS 8AN SB2 CONSTITUENT AND COUNTY RESIDENT FOR THE LAST 25 YEARS. 9IN KEEPING UP THE DIFFERENT BUDGET HEARINGS ON THIS MATTER, 10SOME OF MY CONCERNS AND STUFF THAT HAVE BEEN RAISED BY OTHER 11BOARD OFFICES. BUT ONE THING THAT HAS BEEN CLEAR IS THAT 12CERTAIN OFFICES ARE BEING ENGAGED AND SOME COMMUNITY MEMBERS 13MAINLY ELECTED. NOT ONLY WAS THIS ITEM BURIED INTO THE DAY, SO 149 HOURS LATER, ALL THE YOUNG PEOPLE, ALL THE COMMUNITY MEMBERS 15WERE PUSHED OUT. WE COULD NOT STICK AROUND THAT LONG. SO 16AGAIN, HOW DO WE CONTINUE TO UPLIFT THOSE COMMUNITIES AND ALSO 17CENTERING THE WAY THAT THE COUNTY THROUGH REDLINING, THROUGH 18OTHER INITIATIVES, THE WAY THAT THEY HAVE ACTIVELY DISPLACED 19THE BLACK COMMUNITIES AND OTHER TRADITIONAL MARGINALIZED 20COMMUNITIES, HOW WE CENTER THEM IN THIS PROCESS. THANK YOU. 21 22EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU. NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE. 23 24MODERATOR: THANK YOU. OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS FROM ANNE, NO 25LAST NAME GIVEN. PLEASE UNMUTE YOUR PHONE AND SPEAK DIRECTLY JULY 30, 2024
357
1INTO IT. YOU MAY BEGIN.
2 3SPEAKER: I WOULD LIKE TO THANK THE SUPERVISOR THAT MADE THE 4COMMENT OF ACKNOWLEDGING COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT. COMMUNITY 5ENGAGEMENT IS IMPORTANT IN THIS AND ANY PROCESS. COMMUNITY 6ENGAGEMENT NEEDS TO BE PART OF ANY PROCESS EARLY BECAUSE ONCE 7A PLAN HAS BEEN PREPARED AND FINALIZED TO VOTE, COMMUNITY 8ENGAGEMENT IS NO LONGER ABLE TO BE INCORPORATED OR
9RECOMMENDATIONS THAT ARE MADE TO BE INCORPORATED IN THE PLAN. 10SO AGAIN, THANK YOU FOR ACKNOWLEDGING COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT. 11NOW DO IT. GOOD LUCK. THANK YOU.
12 13EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU. NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE. 14 15MODERATOR: THANK YOU. OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS MICHELLE FRITCH. 16PLEASE UNMUTE YOUR PHONE AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO IT. YOU MAY 17NOW BEGIN.
18 19SPEAKER: THANK YOU, DIRECTOR, WITH THE ASIAN YOUTH CENTER. 20WE'RE A NONPROFIT ORGANIZATION SERVING ALMOST HALF OF L.A. 21COUNTY, BUT PREDOMINANTLY SERVING THE SAN GABRIEL VALLEY AREA. 22AND I WANT TO EXPRESS MY SUPPORT FOR ITEMS 6 AND 7 TO EXPAND 23THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS AND ELECTED COUNTY EXECUTIVE. THE 24LOW-INCOME IMMIGRANTS AND AT-RISK YOUTH AND FAMILIES THAT WE 25SERVE ARE PREDOMINANTLY ASIAN-AMERICAN AND LATINO AND WE THINK JULY 30, 2024
358
1THAT THIS THIS PLAN WILL GIVE THEM MORE ACCESS IT WILL GIVE 2THEM MORE VOICE IT WILL ALLOW THEIR NEEDS TO BE BETTER MET AND 3THE REPRESENTATION THEY DESERVE IN DECISIONS TO HELP DIRECT 4RESOURCES THAT WILL POSITIVELY IMPACT OUR RESIDENTS. SO, THANK 5YOU, THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
6 7EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU, NEXT SPEAKER PLEASE.
8 9MODERATOR: OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS ALVIA TORRES. PLEASE UNMUTE 10YOURSELF AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO YOUR PHONE. YOU MAY BEGIN. 11 12SPEAKER: MY NAME IS ALVIA TORRES. I'M THE CEO FOR SPIRIT 13FAMILY SERVICES, WHICH SERVES CHILDREN, YOUTH, AND FAMILIES IN 14SUPERVISORY DISTRICT 1, 4, AND 5. SPIRIT’S MISSION IS TO 15EMPOWER FAMILIES, IMPROVE HEALTH AND WELL-BEING, AND
16STRENGTHEN COMMUNITIES. OUR CONTINUUM OF FAMILY-CENTERED 17PROGRAMS OFFER COMPREHENSIVE PREVENTION, EARLY INTERVENTION, 18TREATMENT, AND RECOVERY SERVICES TO OVER 13,000 INDIVIDUALS 19ANNUALLY IN THE SOCIAL SECTORS OF CHILD WELFARE, PUBLIC 20HEALTH, MENTAL HEALTH. BEARD HAS 3 FAMILY CENTERS LOCATED IN 21THE CITY OF BELL GARDENS, SOUTH EL MONTE, AND WHITTIER. EACH 22FAMILY CENTER IS DIFFERENT AS IT REFLECTS THE UNIQUE NEEDS AND 23CHARACTERISTICS OF THE COMMUNITIES IT SERVES. NOT ALL 24COMMUNITY NEEDS ARE THE SAME. WE NEED MORE EQUITABLE
25REPRESENTATION. I SUPPORT ITEM 6 AND 7 TO EXPAND THE BOARD OF JULY 30, 2024
359
1SUPERVISORS AND ELECT A COUNTY EXECUTIVE. WE NEED TO MAKE SURE 2THAT DIVERSE VOICES ARE NOT ONLY GIVEN A WIDER PLATFORM BUT 3BETTER AMPLIFIED SO THAT THEY CAN GIVE REPRESENTATION THEY 4DESERVE IN THE DECISION WE MAKE TO ENSURE WE DIRECT RESOURCES. 5THANK YOU.
6 7EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU, YOUR TIME HAS EXPIRED. NEXT 8SPEAKER PLEASE.
9 10MODERATOR: THANK YOU. OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS GABRIEL 11QUINONES. PLEASE UNMUTE YOURSELF AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO YOUR 12PHONE. YOU MAY BEGIN.
13 14SPEAKER: GOOD AFTERNOON SUPERVISORS AND STAFF. THIS IS GABRIEL 15QUINONES, THE MAYOR OF THE CITY OF L.A. PUENTE HERE. WE 16APPRECIATE THE SUPPORT FROM OUR COUNTY SUPERVISORS AND 17ESPECIALLY SUPERVISOR SOLIS BUT I WANT TO SHARE IN THE 18SURROUNDING AREAS AROUND THE CITY OF L.A. PUENTE THERE'S A LOT 19OF UNINCORPORATED AREAS AND THE SUPERVISORS’ REGIONS ARE SO 20VAST THEY DON'T ALWAYS HAVE THE ABILITY TO GIVE ENOUGH 21ATTENTION. SO OF COURSE, WE'RE GONNA CHIP IN WHEN WE CAN FOR 22OUR SURROUNDING AREAS. BUT I'M HERE TO SHARE SUPPORT FOR THIS 23CONSIDERATION OF EXPANDING THE NUMBER OF L.A. COUNTY BOARD 24SUPERVISORS. IT WOULD BE NICE TO HAVE MORE REPRESENTATION FOR 25OUR COMMUNITIES. THANK YOU AND GOOD NIGHT
JULY 30, 2024
360
1 2EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU. NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE.
3 4MODERATOR: OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS MIKE FEINSTEIN, PLEASE 5UNMUTE YOUR PHONE AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO IT. YOU MAY NOW 6BEGIN.
7 8SPEAKER: HI, MIKE FEINSTEIN, FORMER SENATE, SANTA MONICA 9MAYOR, SPEAKING FOR THE GREEN PARTY. THERE'S MUCH HOPE FOR 10BROADER AND DEEPER REPRESENTATION WITH AN INCREASE IN BOARD 11MEMBERS, BUT YOUR OUTDATED CONTINGENT TWO-ROUND RUNOFF SYSTEM 12CAN WORK AGAINST THIS COMPARED TO SINGLE-RANKED-CHOICE VOTING 13GENERAL ELECTIONS, WHICH WOULD ALLOW ALL VIEWS AND CANDIDATES 14TO BE HEARD BY THE MOST VOTERS, AND VOTERS WOULD HAVE THE 15GREATEST ABILITY TO EXPRESS THEIR PREFERENCES OVER THE ENTIRE 16FIELD. YOUR CURRENT SYSTEM PUTS IMPORTANT CHOICES BEFORE A 17LOWER TURNOUT AND LESS DIVERSE PRIMARY ELECTION ELECTORATE. 18VOTE SPLITTING AMONG MULTIPLE STRONG PRIMARY CANDIDATES CAN 19LEAD TO RANDOM RESULTS OF WHO MAKES IT TO A RUN-UP WITH A 20SMALL PERCENTAGE OF THE VOTE. THIS CREATES PRESSURE FOR SOME 21NOT TO RUN WHICH SHORTCHANGES PUBLIC DEBATE. IT ALSO COSTS 22MORE MONEY TO RUN IN 2 ELECTIONS INSTEAD OF ONE WHICH CAN ALSO 23LIMIT WHO CAN RUN AND THEREFORE PUBLIC DEBATE. FOR THESE 24REASONS, PLEASE GIVE PLEASE GIVE DIRECTION TO THE COUNTY 25REGISTRAR OR VOTERS TO RETURN WITH RANK CHOICE VOTING JULY 30, 2024
361
1IMPLEMENTATION OPTIONS TO INFORM THE NEXT STEP IN THE CHARTER 2REFORM PROCESS. THANK YOU.
3 4EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU. NEXT SPEAKER PLEASE.
5 6MODERATOR: OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS ANIKO GOLD. PLEASE UNMUTE 7YOUR PHONE AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO IT. YOU MAY NOW BEGIN. 8 9SPEAKER: HI, MY NAME IS ANIKO GOLD, MAYOR OF HIDDEN HILLS. 10THANK YOU FOR THANK YOU SUPERVISORS HAHN AND HORVATH FOR THE 11COURAGE TO BRING THIS REFORM PACKAGE FORWARD. AS AN ELECTED 12OFFICIAL, AS AN IMMIGRANT, AND AS A VOTER, I STRONGLY SUPPORT 13YES ON NUMBER 6 AND NUMBER 7. THANK YOU.
14 15EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU. NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE. 16 17MODERATOR: OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS LORRAINE QUINONES. PLEASE 18UNMUTE YOUR PHONE AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO IT. YOU MAY NOW 19BEGIN.
20 21SPEAKER: HI, ON OCTOBER 18TH, 2022, A MOTION WAS PASSED TO 22DEVELOP A 90-DAY PLAN THAT WOULD BEGIN A PROCESS THAT WOULD 23HONOR THE CULTURE OF CRUISING ON WHITTIER BOULEVARD IN EAST 24L.A. BY SUPERVISOR SOLIS. UNFORTUNATELY, THAT PLAN HAS BECOME 25SILENT WHILE FAILING TO COMPLETE THE GOALS AND HONOR THE JULY 30, 2024
362
1TIMELINE. SUPERVISOR SOLIS, YOUR SILENCE SEEKS VOLUME IN 2RESPECT TO THE PLAN REACHING ITS OBLIGATION AND IN RESPECT TO 3THE STATEWIDE SUCCESS OF REPEALING THE BAN ON CRUISING IN AN 4AREA THAT YOU REPRESENT THAT IS ICONIC AND HISTORIC TO 5CRUISING IN CHICANO HISTORY AND THE HEART OF EAST L.A. I'M 6DISAPPOINTED TO SAY THE LEAST THAT YOUR NEGLIGENCE AND 7PUBLICLY RECOGNIZING THE HISTORIC WIN BY SOME OF YOUR VERY OWN 8CONSTITUENTS SUCH AS MYSELF AND MANY OTHERS WHO FOUGHT FOR 98436 AND DID OUR PART FOR CIVIC ENGAGEMENT. WHITTIER BOULEVARD 10DESERVES BETTER. THE 90-DAY PLAN IS LONG OVERDUE, SUPERVISOR 11SOLIS. SO ARE YOU WHEN IT COMES TO CELEBRATING THE LOWRIDER 12CULTURE OF DISTRICT 1. RECOGNIZE AND HONOR THE WING. EQUAL 13REPRESENTATION MATTERS. WE ARE UNDERREPRESENTED. WE BETTER THE 14ART AND CULTURE OF LOW-RIDING MATTERS LOW RIDERS MATTERS 15CRUISING IS NOT A CRIME.
16 17EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU. YOUR TIME HAS EXPIRED. NEXT 18SPEAKER PLEASE.
19 20MODERATOR: OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS ADELLE ANDRADE STADLER. 21PLEASE UNMUTE YOUR PHONE AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO IT. YOU MAY 22NOW BEGIN.
23 24SPEAKER: GOOD AFTERNOON OR GOOD EVENING ALREADY CHAIR HORVATH, 25HONORABLE SUPERVISORS. MY NAME IS ADELE ANDRADE, STADLER JULY 30, 2024
363
1COUNCILWOMAN FOR THE DIVERSE CITY OF ALHAMBRA, WELL
2REPRESENTED BY SUPERVISOR SOLIS. I WHOLEHEARTEDLY SUPPORT ITEM 36 AND 7 WITH THE EXPANSION OF THE BOARD, HERE WE ARE AGAIN, 4AND ACTUAL GOVERNMENT REFORM. WE NEED THIS IN TERMS OF 510,000,000 RESIDENTS. AND IF THAT DOESN'T SPEAK VOLUMES, I 6DON'T KNOW WHAT DOES. AND IN TERMS OF ENGAGEMENT, WHAT GREATER 7ENGAGEMENT THAN TAKING IT TO THE VOTERS? THANK YOU VERY MUCH 8AND HAVE A GREAT EVENING.
9 10EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU. NEXT SPEAKER PLEASE.
11 12MODERATOR: THANK YOU. OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS RENE JIMENEZ. 13PLEASE UNMUTE YOUR PHONE AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO IT. YOU MAY 14NOW BEGIN.
15 16SPEAKER: GOOD EVENING. MY NAME IS RENE JIMENEZ AND I AM WITH 17THE SAN GABRIEL VALLEY CONSERVATION CORPS. SGVCC IS DEDICATED 18TO YOUTH DEVELOPMENT, ENVIRONMENTAL RESTORATION, AND COMMUNITY 19BEAUTIFICATION. I AM CALLING IN TODAY TO SUPPORT ITEMS 6 AND 7 20ON THE AGENDA. AS WE ALL KNOW L.A. COUNTY'S POPULATION OF 21NEARLY 10,000,000 PEOPLE GROWS AND IT DIVERSIFIES. WE HAVE TO 22INNOVATE AND REEVALUATE HOW WE CAN BEST MEET THE RESIDENTS 23NEEDS. WE NEED TO MAKE SURE THEIR DIVERSE VOICES ARE NOT ONLY 24HEARD BUT RATHER AMPLIFIED SO THEY ARE GIVEN THE
25REPRESENTATION THEY DESERVE. WE STRONGLY SUPPORT ITEM 6 AND 7.
JULY 30, 2024
364
1IT'S NOT JUST BETTER REPRESENTATION. IT'S EQUITABLE
2REPRESENTATION. THANK YOU ALL. HAVE A GOOD NIGHT.
3 4EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU. NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE.
5 6MODERATOR: OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS THOMAS WONG. PLEASE UNMUTE 7YOUR PHONE AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO IT. YOU MAY NOW BEGIN. 8 9SPEAKER: THANK YOU. MY NAME IS THOMAS WONG. I'M THE MAYOR OF 10THE CITY OF MONTEREY PARK. HERE CALLING IN SUPPORT OF ITEMS 6 11AND 7 FOR GOVERNANCE REFORM. I REALLY WANT TO APPRECIATE CHAIR 12HORVATH AND SUPERVISOR HAHN FOR CHAMPIONING THIS. THIS HAS 13BEEN A DISCUSSION IN THE COMMUNITY AND AMONG MANY COMMUNITIES 14IN L.A. COUNTY FOR MANY, MANY DECADES. I APPRECIATE THE EFFORT 15OF THOSE SUPERVISORS IN PUSHING THIS CONVERSATION AND MAKE 16SURE WE ACTUALLY TAKE ACTION ON THIS FINALLY. I LOOK FORWARD 17TO HAVING THIS ON THE BALLOT AND ASK AND URGE THE 4
18SUPERVISORS TO PLACE THEM ON THE BALLOT SO THE COMMUNITY CAN 19CONTINUE TO HAVE THIS CONVERSATION AND HAVE A VOTE ON THIS 20AMENDMENT. THANK YOU.
21 22EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU. NEXT SPEAKER PLEASE. 23 24MODERATOR: OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS JOSE SANCHEZ. PLEASE UNMUTE 25YOUR PHONE AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO IT. YOU MAY NOW BEGIN.
JULY 30, 2024
365
1 2SPEAKER: GOOD EVENING. MY NAME IS JOSE SANCHEZ AND I'M A 3CIVICS TEACHER AND A COUNCIL MEMBER FROM THE CITY OF MONTEREY 4PARK AND I WANT TO THANK THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS FOR HAVING 5THE COURAGE TO BRING THIS MEASURE FORWARD. FINALLY, I'M HERE 6TO ENCOURAGE YOU TO VOTE FAVORABLY ON ITEM 6 AND 7. IF THERE'S 7EVER BEEN A TIME TO INCREASE REPRESENTATION AND
8ACCOUNTABILITY, IT IS NOW. OUR COUNTY IS FACING SOME SERIOUS 9ISSUES THAT INCLUDE CLIMATE CHANGE, HOMELESSNESS, MENTAL 10HEALTH, AND GUN VIOLENCE, JUST TO NAME A FEW. HAVING MORE 11REPRESENTATION IN L.A. COUNTY WILL ONLY ENSURE THAT OUR 12SUPERVISORS CAN ADDRESS THE NEEDS OF OUR COUNTY. L.A. COUNTY 13IS ALSO ONE OF THE MOST DIVERSE COUNTIES IN THE COUNTRY, BUT 14IT ALSO HAS DIVERSE NEEDS. I'M A GOVERNMENT AND CIVICS TEACHER 15AND I KNOW THAT ANY GOVERNMENT THAT INCREASES REPRESENTATIONS 16LIKE YOU'RE TRYING TO DO HERE TODAY HELPS FOSTER MORE 17UNDERSTANDING, IT HELPS ENSURE MORE VOICES ARE HEARD AND THE 18GOVERNMENT IS MORE EMPATHETIC TO THE NEEDS OF ITS RESIDENTS. I 19HOPE THAT MY COMMUNITY IN MONTEREY PARK AND MY STUDENTS WILL 20HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO VOTE ON THIS MEASURE ON THE NOVEMBER 21BALLOT AND THAT WE CONTINUE TO WORK TOWARDS ACCOUNTABILITY AND 22INCREASED REPRESENTATION --
23 24EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU. YOUR TIME HAS EXPIRED. 25 JULY 30, 2024
366
1SPEAKER: THANK YOU AGAIN FOR KEEPING YOUR CONSTITUENTS IN 2MIND.
3 4EXECUTIVE OFFICER: NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE.
5 6MODERATOR: OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS ESTHER ADIM. YOUR LINE IS 7OPEN. PLEASE SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO YOUR PHONE, AND YOU MAY NOW 8BEGIN.
9 10SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: SHE'S ALREADY SPOKEN ON THIS 11ITEM. WE'LL GO TO THE NEXT SPEAKER.
12 13MODERATOR: THANK YOU. OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS BARRY STEELE. 14YOUR LINE IS OPEN. PLEASE SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO YOUR PHONE. 15 16SPEAKER: HOW CAN YOU HAVE FOLKS FINDING ON TO SOMETHING 17KNOWING THEY DIDN'T REACH THE FINAL PLAN? YOU KNOW THEY DON'T 18KNOW HOW WE GOT TO 9 SEATS. YOU ALSO KNOW THAT THERE ARE 13 19ELEMENTS TO THIS CHARTER, NOT JUST 2, BUT YOU HAVE PEOPLE 20BELIEVING THAT THIS IS JUST A THING ABOUT EXPANDED SEATS. 21LOOK, WE ARE ALL ABOUT THE EXPANSION OF THE NUMBER OF 22SUPERVISOR DISTRICTS, INCREASED TRANSPARENCY, LESS POLITICAL 23BUDGETING PROCESSES. THOSE ARE ALL APPEALING, BUT THESE ARE 24RHETORICAL ADVANCES BUILT ON EMPTY PROMISES AND WHIMSICAL 25ESTIMATES THAT ARE NOT BACKED BY EMPIRICAL DATA, ARE NOT BASED JULY 30, 2024
367
1ON A PROMISE THAT OUR COMMUNITIES WILL BE ABLE TO REWARD IT 2EVEN THEIR SUPPORT TODAY. I'LL SAY THIS, LOOK, WE NEED TO HAVE 3CHANGE, YES, BUT THIS IS NOT THE WAY TO DO IT. WE SHOULD BE 4INCLUDED FROM THE VERY BEGINNING. AND SO, I'M ASKING THAT WE 5SAY NO TO THIS. YOU KNOW, WE FULLY AGREE THAT THERE NEEDS TO 6BE GOVERNMENT'S REFORM, BUT WE CAN DO BETTER THAN THIS 7TOGETHER. LET'S TRY AGAIN. LET'S DO IT RIGHT.
8 9EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU. YOUR TIME HAS EXPIRED. NEXT 10SPEAKER, PLEASE.
11 12MODERATOR: OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS MICHAEL FLOWERS. PLEASE 13UNMUTE YOURSELF AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO YOUR PHONE. YOU MAY 14BEGIN.
15 16SPEAKER: HI, MY NAME IS MICHAEL FLOWERS. I'M A COMMISSIONER 17FOR CHILDREN AND FAMILY SERVICES AND I AM TOTALLY IN FAVOR OF 18ITEM 6 AND 7. I DON'T SEE HOW 5 SUPERVISORS CAN COVER OVER 194,000 SQUARE MILES OF TERRITORY. THIS WOULD BE SO GREAT FOR 20THE CITIZENS OF EACH COMMUNITY. THEY PUT ON EVENTS. THE 21SUPERVISORS CANNOT GO TO ALL THESE EVENTS BECAUSE THEY'RE 22SPREADING THEMSELVES THIN. I AM TOTALLY IN FAVOR OF ITEM 6 AND 237 AND I'D LIKE TO THANK THE SUPERVISOR SOLIS FOR BRINGING THIS 24MOTION FORWARD. SO, LET'S GET IT, LET'S GO. THANK YOU SO MUCH. 25 JULY 30, 2024
368
1EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU. NEXT SPEAKER PLEASE.
2 3MODERATOR: OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS JANETTE ROBINSON-FLINT. 4PLEASE UNMUTE YOURSELF AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO YOUR PHONE. YOU 5MAY BEGIN.
6 7SPEAKER: HELLO, MY NAME IS JANETTE ROBINSON-FLINT AND I AM A 8MEMBER OF BLACK WOMEN FOR WELLNESS AND LIVE IN LOS ANGELES. I 9ABSOLUTELY AGREE THAT WE NEED TO EXPAND THE BOARD OF
10SUPERVISORS. WE NEED TO FIGURE OUT SOMETHING DIFFERENT TO DO 11TO BE INCLUSIVE. I DO NOT THINK THIS IS THE WAY TO DO IT. I AM 12NOT IN FAVOR OF ITEM 6 OR 7. I THINK WE NEED TO PAUSE. I THINK 13WE NEED TO BE MORE TRANSPARENT. I THINK WE NEED TO BE MORE 14INCLUSIVE, AND WE ABSOLUTELY NEED TO REMEMBER A CONVERSATION 15THAT WAS ON TAPE WITH KEVIN DELEON ON AND OTHERS ABOUT ERASING 16BLACK POWER AND ERASING BLACK PARTICIPATION IN GOVERNMENT AND 17MAKE SURE THAT THIS IS SO TRANSPARENT THAT WE DO NOT HAVE TO 18REMEMBER THAT AND THINK ABOUT THAT. WE ALSO KNOW THAT THE COST 19OF UNDOING AND REPAIR AND THEN FIXING IS MORE EXPENSIVE THAN 20THE COST OF DOING IT RIGHT THE FIRST TIME AND WE HAD NO IDEA 21HOW MUCH THIS WOULD COST.
22 23EXECUTIVE OFFICER: THANK YOU, YOUR TIME HAS EXPIRED. NEXT 24SPEAKER PLEASE.
25 JULY 30, 2024
369
1MODERATOR: OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS LILY TRANCH. PLEASE UNMUTE 2AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO YOUR PHONE. YOU MAY BEGIN.
3 4SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: LILY, ARE YOU THERE? LILY? LILY, 5ARE YOU THERE? OKAY, NEXT SPEAKER PLEASE.
6 7MODERATOR: OUR NEXT PARTICIPANT IS KIM LAMAURIE. PLEASE UNMUTE 8YOURSELF AND SPEAK DIRECTLY INTO THE PHONE. YOU MAY BEGIN. 9 10SPEAKER: HONORABLE SUPERVISORS, KIM LAMAURIE, PRESIDENT, LAS 11VIRGENAS HOMEOWNERS FEDERATION, WITH MORE THAN 10,000 12STAKEHOLDERS IN THE SANTA MONICA MOUNTAINS AND ENVIRONS, WE 13OVERWHELMINGLY SUPPORT THESE BOLD CHARTER AMENDMENTS. SWEEPING 14CHANGES THAT INCREASE THE FAIRNESS, EFFECTIVENESS,
15RESPONSIVENESS, ACCOUNTABILITY AND TRANSPARENCY OF LOCAL 16GOVERNMENT AS LONG-TIME ADVOCATES, THESE ARE PAST DUE BENEFITS 17TO THE PUBLIC. IT EXEMPLIFIES WHAT GOVERNMENT CAN AND SHOULD 18BE. IT IS A REAL REFORM PACKAGE, REFINED, CAREFUL, EQUITABLE, 19AND FINANCIALLY PRUDENT THAT WILL POSITION THE BOARD TO TAKE 20ON THE COMPLEX CHALLENGES OF THE FUTURE FOR ALL OF L.A. COUNTY 21RESIDENTS. THE TIME IS NOW, THE OPPORTUNITY IS NOW, NOT 22TOMORROW, NOT NEVER, NOW. IT'S HISTORIC, EXCITING, POWERFUL 23BETTERMENT FOR THE PEOPLE. CREDIT TO OUR CHANGE-MAKING 24SUPERVISOR. COUNT US IN, SUPPORT THE CHARTER AMENDMENT FOR 25POSITIVE CHANGE FOR THE PEOPLE. THANK YOU.
JULY 30, 2024
370
1 2SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: THANK YOU. THAT WAS OUR LAST 3SPEAKER. WITH THAT, ITEM 7 IS BEFORE US. MOVED BY SUPERVISOR 4HAHN, SECONDED BY SUPERVISOR SOLIS TO APPROVE THE ITEM. 5EXECUTIVE OFFICER, PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
6 7EXECUTIVE OFFICER: SUPERVISOR SOLIS?
8 9SUP. HILDA SOLIS: AYE.
10 11EXECUTIVE OFFICER: SUPERVISOR SOLIS, AYE. SUPERVISOR MITCHELL? 12 13SUP. HOLLY J. MITCHELL: NO.
14 15EXECUTIVE OFFICER: SUPERVISOR MITCHELL, NO. SUPERVISOR HAHN? 16 17SUP. JANICE HAHN: YES.
18 19EXECUTIVE OFFICER: SUPERVISOR HAHN, YES. SUPERVISOR BARGER? 20 21SUP. KATHRYN BARGER: NO.
22 23EXECUTIVE OFFICER: SUPERVISOR BARGER, NO. SUPERVISOR HORVATH? 24 25SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: AYE.
JULY 30, 2024
371
1 2EXECUTIVE OFFICER: SUPERVISOR HORVATH, AYE. MOTION CARRIES 3 3TO 2.
4 5SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: ITEM 6 IS BEFORE US. MOVED BY 6SUPERVISOR SOLIS, SECONDED BY SUPERVISOR HAHN TO APPROVE THE 7ITEM. EXECUTIVE OFFICER, PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
8 9EXECUTIVE OFFICER: SUPERVISOR SOLIS?
10 11SUP. HILDA SOLIS: AYE.
12 13EXECUTIVE OFFICER: SUPERVISOR SOLIS, AYE. SUPERVISOR MITCHELL? 14 15SUP. HOLLY J. MITCHELL: NO.
16 17EXECUTIVE OFFICER: SUPERVISOR MITCHELL, NO. SUPERVISOR HAHN? 18 19SUP. JANICE HAHN: YES.
20 21EXECUTIVE OFFICER: SUPERVISOR HAHN, YES. SUPERVISOR BARGER? 22 23SUP. KATHRYN BARGER: NO.
24 25EXECUTIVE OFFICER: SUPERVISOR BARGER, NO. SUPERVISOR HORVATH? JULY 30, 2024
372
1 2SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: AYE.
3 4EXECUTIVE OFFICER: SUPERVISOR HORVATH, AYE. MOTION CARRIES 3-
52. 6
7SUP. LINDSEY HORVATH, CHAIR: WE'LL NOW HEAR FROM MEMBERS OF 8THE PUBLIC WISHING TO ADDRESS THE BOARD ON GENERAL PUBLIC 9COMMENT. FOR MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC ON THE TELEPHONE, PLEASE 10PRESS 1 AND 0 NOW TO COMMENT ON THIS ITEM. EXECUTIVE OFFICER, 11PLEASE READ THE CALL-IN INFORMATION AND CALL THE MEMBERS OF 12THE PUBLIC WHO HAVE SIGNED UP TO SPEAK.
13 14EXECUTIVE OFFICER: MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC, YOU WILL HAVE 1 15MINUTE TO ADDRESS THE BOARD ON GENERAL PUBLIC COMMENT. PLEASE 16STATE YOUR NAME. YOU MAY ONLY ADDRESS THE BOARD ON THIS ITEM. 17WE WILL NOW CALL IN-PERSON SPEAKERS AND WHILE THEY ARE COMING 18FORWARD, WE WILL TAKE TELEPHONIC SPEAKERS.
19 20EXECUTIVE OFFICER: WILL THE FOLLOWING INDIVIDUALS PLEASE COME 21FORWARD? DAPHNE BRADFORD, NICK COLIV, AND ARTHUR MUNOZ, PLEASE 22COME FORWARD AND STAFF WILL ASSIST YOU. MODERATOR, WE MAY HAVE 23THE FIRST REMOTE SPEAKER PLEASE.
24 25MODERATOR: OUR FIRST PARTICIPANT IS ERIC PREVIN. PLEASE UNMUTE