1. Scoring Meeting
Date: April 13, 2023
FIRM'S NAME Vikkie Daniel Francisco Henry References Total Rank Alievon Pacific Aviation Consulting, LLC 67 80 71 79 0 218 3 ASM Global Route Development Consulting Svcs 65 75 78 75 0 218 3 Campbell Hill Aviation Group, LLC 62 85 83 85 0 230 1
Crawford Murphy & Tilly (CMT), Inc 60 75 74 75 0 209 4
ICF SH&E, Inc 67 65 67 60 0 199 5
InterVISTAS Consulting, LLC 68 80 77 83 0 225 2
Lufthansa Consulting 51 65 65 60 0 181 6
Totals: 440 525 515 517
2. In-Person Interviews
Date: May 9, 2023
FIRM'S NAME Melissa* Daniel Francisco Column1 Column5 Column2 Column3 ASM Global Route Development Consulting Svcs 3 2 2
Campbell Hill Aviation Group, LLC 2 1 1
InterVISTAS Consulting, LLC 1 3 3
Scoring Criteria based on:
A. Presentation
B. Expertise/Capability
C. Creativity
D. Technology
E. Client Relationships
F. Airline Contacts
3. References
FIRM'S NAME Column1 Column2 Column3 Column5References Total Column8 ASM Global Route Development Consulting Svcs 5 223
Campbell-Hill Aviation Group, LLC 15 245
InterVISTAS Consulting, LLC 15 240
Overall Rating and Ranking
FIRM'S NAME Proposal In-Person
Interview Reference Total Ranking
ASM Global Route Development Consulting Svcs 218 7 5 230 3 Campbell Hill Aviation Group, LLC 230 4 15 249 1 Firm AWARDED InterVISTAS Consulting, LLC 225 7 15 247 2
Selection Panel
*Melissa Garza-Perry included in interview process due to absence by Vikkie Cal y
Airports Department
Request for Qualifications (RFQ)
Air Service Development Consultant Services
RFQ Evaluation Scoring Sheet
RFQ PANEL