Cities Index.
Proposal Evaluation

Fresno City Council
February 1, 2024

Document
Proposal Evaluation
Meeting
February 1, 2024
Body
Fresno City Council
Original file
154 KB
Text extracted from the city's file for reading and search. Open the original on legistar2.granicus.com. That file is the official record.

ACPCreativIT Autoclear LLC CEIA USALTD CompuNet, Inc.

ConvergintTechnologies
LLC
DayAutomationSystems,
Inc. Faith Technologies FoxEnergy SystemsInc.

HomelandSafetySystems,
Inc
Possible Points
ConformancetoRFP
Requirements 50 35 34 37 35 38 35 38 25 37 Pricing 400 282 284 313 282 331 313 337 233 286 FinancialViabilityand
MarketplaceSuccess 75 56 54 56 59 65 57 59 47 53 AbilitytoSellandDeliver
Service 100 61 69 71 67 82 53 69 57 59 MarketingPlan 50 36 33 41 33 43 31 37 31 35 ValueAddedAttributes 75 58 56 55 48 62 49 53 51 57 Warranty 50 34 40 42 33 41 38 36 35 38 DepthandBreadthofOffered
Equipment,Products,or
Services 200 145 128 123 144 172 117 165 141 148 Total Points 1,000 707 697 738 700 832 691 795 618 713 Rank Order 18 21 11 20 3 22 8 25 17
Honeywell
Johnson Controls Fire
Protection LP
Konica Minolta Business
Solutions U.S.A., Inc. LONG Building Technologies
Marcomm Integrated
Business Solutions
Minuteman Security
Technologies, Inc. Paladin Technologies Parallel Technologies PC Specialists, Inc.

Possible Points
ConformancetoRFP
Requirements 50 40 42 42 31 36 31 36 35 40
Pricing 400 306 338 297 257 279 279 321 292 302
FinancialViabilityand
MarketplaceSuccess 75 67 66 63 56 58 50 58 55 60
AbilitytoSellandDeliver
Service 100 81 83 83 55 70 60 74 60 67
MarketingPlan 50 38 37 44 29 33 27 36 37 38
ValueAddedAttributes 75 65 65 65 45 53 41 57 49 62
Warranty 50 42 42 42 36 40 34 39 38 39
DepthandBreadthofOffered
Equipment,Products,or
Services 200 170 166 163 141 154 155 164 153 126
Total Points 1,000 809 837 799 649 721 675 784 719 733 Rank Order 6 2 72 41 42 3 91 51 2
R3 Security, Inc. Rhombus Systems, Inc.

Securitas Electronic Security
(Canada) Inc. Siemens Industry, Inc.

Stanley Convergent Security
Solutions
Tyco Integrated Fire &
Security Canada Inc. Verkada, Inc. Wireless Guardian Inc.

Possible Points
ConformancetoRFP
Requirements 50 39 37 31 41 43 42 39 35
Pricing 400 315 290 186 328 314 336 298 268
FinancialViabilityand
MarketplaceSuccess 75 54 51 49 64 67 65 53 50
AbilitytoSellandDeliver
Service 100 66 70 71 85 86 82 72 72
MarketingPlan 50 39 34 17 40 39 37 37 42
ValueAddedAttributes 75 52 53 52 60 63 64 50 51
Warranty 50 38 42 39 40 41 42 42 38
DepthandBreadthofOffered
Equipment,Products,or
Services 200 150 138 133 167 179 175 142 150
Total Points 1,000 751 714 577 825 830 842 732 705 Rank Order 10 16 26 5 4 1 13 19
________________________________________________ ________________________________________________ _______________________________ _________________ _______________________________________________ Chris Robinson, CPSM, Procurement Manager Brandon Town, CPSM, CPSD, Procurement Analyst Stephanie Haataja, CPIM, Procurement Anal yst Craig West, Procurement Analyst Proposal Evaluation
Facility Security Systems, Equipment, and Software with Related Services RFP #030421 




 







← All documents from this meeting