DocuSign Envelope ID: AEE30E0A-4AF9-43AD-BDDB-4A4E48140EA4
EVALUATION OF BID
PROPOSALS
FOR: NORTH GRANVILLE AND EAST BEHYMER SAFElY IMPROVEMENTS
BIDDERS-
1. Dave Christian Const. Co., Inc.
2963 N Sunnyside Ave #108
Fresno, CA 93727
2. Granite Constructi on Company
2716 S. Granite Court
Fresno, CA 93706
3. American Paving Co.
525 W. Alluvial Ave
Fresno, CA 93711
Bid File No. 12400905
Bid Opening: 02/27/2024
TO T AL NET BID AMOUNT
$624,487.00
$774,624.00
$907,986.00
Each bidder has agreed to allow the City sixty-four (64) days from date bids are opened to accept or reject their bid proposal. Purchasing requests that you complete the following sections and return this bid evaluation to the Purchasing Division at the latest by Mo nday, March 18, 2024 5:00 P .M.
The Engineer's Estimate for this expenditure is$ 796,345.00. The contract price is 21.6% below the Engineer's Estimate. If the overage is greater than 10% or only one bid was received, give explanation:
BACKGROUND OF PROJECT (To be completed by Evaluating Department/Division.
Explain need for project/equipment):
The North Granville and East Behymer Project will enhance safetyby Constructing Chicanes and Median Islands. These safety measures will slow motorists as they approach the North Granville and East Behymer Intersection.
DEPARTMENT CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATION:
� Award a contract in the amount of $624,487.00 to Dave Christian Construction Co., Inc. as the lowest responsive and responsible bidder.
Remarks:
LJ Reject all bids. Reason:
Evaluation Form Rev. 07-2022
DocuSign Envelope ID: AEE30E0A-4AF9-43AD-BDDB-4A4E4B140EA4
EVALUATION OF BID
PROPOSALS
Page2
FOR: NORTH GRANVILLE AND EAST BEHYMER SAFETY IMPROVEMENTS Department Head Approval
Title ___ Q"'----'-',-r ..... e ...... c,,_,_✓b-=t?'---( _____ _ Date J Is / 2o2./f:
--,,7--t,---------
(XJ Approve Dept. Recommendation
LJ Disapprove
LJ See Attachment
GENERAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT
'--1""V, /n AA /J 03/07/2024
p'ufc���ge_r _ _.,__._..D .... a ..... te.....-. .......
G�tz5fflites Director Date
Evaluation Form
Bid File No. 12400905
Bid Opening: 02/27/2024
Approve GSD/ Purchasing Recommend ation
LJ Disapprove
CITY MANAGER
Date
Rev. 07-2022