Exhibit I
March 18, 2024
Planning Department
City Of Fresno
2600 Fresno St., 3rd Floor
Fresno, CA 93721-3604
Re: Air Impact Assessment (AIA) Application Approval
ISR Project Number: C-20240019
Land Use Agency: City Of Fresno
Land Use Agency ID Number: P23-03606
To Whom It May Concern:
The San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District (District) has approved the Air Impact Assessment (AIA) application for the Truck Maintenance Shop project, located at 121 W North Ave. in Fresno, California. The Project consists of 3,300 square foot truck maintenance shop. The District has determined that the mitigated baseline emissions for construction and operation will be less than two tons NOx per year and two tons PM10 per year. Pursuant to District Rule 9510 Section 4.3, this project is exempt from the requirements of Section 6.0 (General Mitigation Requirements) and Section 7.0 (Off-site Emission Reduction Fee Calculations and Fee Schedules) of the rule. As such, the District has determined that this project complies with the emission reduction requirements of District Rule 9510 and is not subject to payment of off-site fees.
Pursuant to District Rule 9510, Section 8.4, the District is providing you with the following information:
A notification of AIA approval (this letter)
A statement of tentative rule compliance (this letter) An approved Monitoring and Reporting Schedule
A copy of the Air Impact Assessment Application
Certain emission mitigation measures proposed by the applicant may be subject to approval or enforcement by the City Of Fresno. No provision of District Rule 9510 requires action on the part of the City Of Fresno, however, please review the enclosed list of mitigation measures and notify the District if the proposed mitigation measures are inconsistent with your agency’s requirements for this project. The District can provide the detailed emissions analysis upon request.
If you have any questions, please contact Mr. Eric S McLaughlin by telephone at (559) 230-5808 or by email at [email protected].
Sincerely,
Tom Jordan
Director of Policy and Governmental Affairs
For: Mark Montelongo
Program Manager
Enclosures
Indirect Source ReviewSJVAPCD
CENTRAL
3/18/2024
10:45 AMComplete Project Summary Sheet &
Monitoring and Reporting Schedule
Project Name: TRUCK MAINTENANCE SHOP
Applicant Name: MANDEEP KAUSHAL
Project Location:
121 W NORTH AVE.
S ELM AVE
APN: 329-020-33
Project Description:
LAND USE:
Light Industrial - 3300 Square Feet - Other
Light Industrial - 3300 Square Feet - Other
Light Industrial - 3300 Square Feet - Other
ACREAGE: 2.22
ISR Project ID Number:C-20240019
Applicant ID Number:C-303902
Permitting Public Agency:CITY OF FRESNO
Public Agency Permit No:P23-03606
Existing Emission Reduction Measures
There are no Existing Measures for this project
Non-District Enforced Emission Reduction Measures
There are no Non-District Enforced Measures for this project District Enforced Emission Reduction Measures
Enforcing Agency Measure Specific Implementation
SJVAPCD Construction and Operation -
Exempt from Off-site Fee
For each project phase, within 30-days of issuance of the first certificate of occupancy, if applicable, submit to the District a summary report of the construction start, and end dates, and the date of issuance of the first certificate of occupancy. Otherwise, submit to the District a summary report of the construction start and end dates within 30-days of the end of each phase of construction.
SJVAPCD Construction and Operation -
Recordkeeping
For each project phase, all records shall be maintained on site during construction and for a period of ten years following either the end of construction or the issuance of the first certificate of occupancy, whichever is later. Records shall be made available for District inspection upon request.
SJVAPCD Construction and Operational
Dates
For each project phase, maintain records of (1) the construction start and end dates and (2) the date of issuance of the first certificate of occupancy, if applicable.
Number of District Enforced Measures: 3
1/1
Central Region Office: 1990 E. Gettysburg Ave. Fresno, CA 93726-0244 TEL (559) 230-6000 www.valleyair.org/ISRPage 1 of 13 Revised August 30, 2022 Indirect Source Review (ISR) - Air Impact Assessment (AIA) ApplicationA. Applicant InformationApplicant/Business Name:Mailing Address: City: State: Zip:Contact:Title:Is the Applicant a licensed state contractor? No Yes, please provide State License number: Phone:Email:B. Agent Information (if applicable)Agent/Business Name: Mailing Address: City: State: Zip: Contact: Title: Phone: Email: C. Project InformationProject Name: Project Location Street: City: Zip:Cross Streets: County: Permitting Agency: Planner: Contact Number:Permit Type and Number (if known):Subject to Project-Level Discretionary Approval? YesNoLast Project-Level Discretionary Approval Date: Last Project-Level Ministerial Approval Date: D. Project DescriptionPlease briefly describe the project (e.g.: 300 multi-family residential units apartments or 6 miles road widening):For Residential/Non-Residential/Mixed-Useplease check the box next to each applicable land use below:Commercial / RetailEducationalOfficeWarehouseResidentialGovernmentIndustrialDistribution CenterRecreational (e.g. park)MedicalManufacturingOther: For Transportation/Transitplease check the box next to each applicable land use below:New Road ConstructionExpansion to an Existing RoadBridge / OverpassInterchange or IntersectionImprovementsSelect land use setting: Urban RuralE. Notice of ViolationIs this application being submitted as a result of receiving a Notice of Violation (NOV)?No Yes, NOV #:FORDISTRICTUSE ONLYFiling FeeReceived: _________________Date Paid:_________________Applicant #: _______________Check #:_____________________ Project #:_____________________Date Stamp: FinanceDate Stamp: Permit 121 W North Ave. Fresno CA [email protected] Kaushal Deep Kaushal Owner2511 Logan St. Selma CA 93662CVEAS, INC.Brenda [email protected] Maintenance Shop121 W North Ave. Fresno 93706FresnoCity of FresnoBrittany Martin559-621-8059P23-03606Proposed 100'x33x metal building for truck maintenance.
Central Region Office: 1990 E. Gettysburg Ave. Fresno, CA 93726-0244 TEL (559) 230-6000 www.valleyair.org/ISRPage 2 of 13 Revised August 30, 2022 F. Voluntary Emission Reduction Agreement(VERA)Is this project part of a larger project for which there is a VERA with the District?No Yes, VERA #: G.Optional SectionDo you want to receive information about the Healthy Air Living Business Partners Program? No YesH. Parcel and Land Owner InformationAPN (000-000-00 Format)Gross AcresLand Owner1.2.3. www.valleyair.org/ISR.I. Project Development and OperationWill the project require demolition of existing structures?Yes,complete JNo, complete KJ. DemolitionTotal square feet of building(s) footprint to be demolished: Number of Building Stories: Demolition Start Date (Month/Year): Number of Days for Demolition: K. TimingExpected number of work days per week during construction?5 days 6 days 7 daysFor Transportation/Transitprojects,please complete L-1For Residential/Non-Residential/Mixed-Useprojects, will it be developed in multiple phases?No, complete L-2Yes,complete L-3L-1. Transporation / Transit Development and Timing DetailsPlease note that development timelines provided within this section should reflect actual work time, and should not account for possible project delays.Start of Construction (Month/Year): End of Construction (Month/Year):Number of actual construction days:Length of road being constructed: miles Width of road being constructed: feetPredominant Soil Type (choose one): Sand GravelWeathered Rock EarthBlasted RockAmount of soil imported: cubic yards Amount of soil exported: cubic yardsAmount of asphalt imported: cubic yardsAmount of asphalt exported: cubic yardsTotal area to be disturbed: acres Maximum area disturbed per day: acresAverage truck capacity: cubic yardsWill water trucks be used?YesNoL-2. Single Phase DevelopmentStart of Construction (Month/Year): Gross Acres:End of Construction (Month/Year): Net Acres (area devoted to buildings/structures): First Date of Occupation (Month/Year): Paved Parking Area (# of Spaces):Building Square Footage:Number of Dwelling Units: L-3. Phased Site Development and Building ConstructionIn addition to the information below you can submit phase specific activity timeline found on www.valleyair.org/ISR.1Start of Construction (Month/Year): Gross Acres:End of Construction (Month/Year): Net Acres (area devoted to buildings/structures): First Date of Occupation (Month/Year): Paved Parking Area (# of Spaces):Building Square Footage: Number of Dwelling Units: 2Start of Construction (Month/Year): Gross Acres: End of Construction (Month/Year): Net Acres (area devoted to buildings/structures): First Date of Occupation (Month/Year): Paved Parking Area (# of Spaces): Building Square Footage: Number of Dwelling Units:
329-020-332.22Mandeep Kaushal
August 2024March 2025April 20253,3002.225,8941 existing3 standard/2 ADA/33 truck parking
Central Region Office: 1990 E. Gettysburg Ave. Fresno, CA 93726-0244 TEL (559) 230-6000 www.valleyair.org/ISRPage 3 of 13 Revised August 30, 2022 3Start of Construction (Month/Year): Gross Acres: End of Construction (Month/Year): Net Acres (area devoted to buildings/structures): First Date of Occupation (Month/Year): Paved Parking Area (# of Spaces): Building Square Footage: Number of Dwelling Units: 4Start of Construction (Month/Year): Gross Acres: End of Construction (Month/Year): Net Acres (area devoted to buildings/structures): First Date of Occupation (Month/Year): Paved Parking Area (# of Spaces): Building Square Footage: Number of Dwelling Units: www.valleyair.org/ISR.M. On-Site Emission Reduction Measures(Mitigation Measures)Listed below are categories of possiblein this form to identify specifics relafor not selecting the measure. Also, the applicant is encouraged to provide any mitigation measures including supporting documentation that are not listed on this application form for District consideration. For reference, see www.valleyair.org/ISRfor potential additional mitigiation measures.Clean Construction Fleet Mitgation Measure below can be selected for all development types1. Clean Construction Fleet (Note: Making a commitment to using less polluting construction equipment)Yes,please complete mitigation measure 1 belowNo, please provide justification why not selected:___________________________________________________________Operational Mitgation Measure below can be selected for all development types, except for transportation and transit projects2. Clean On-Road Trucks (e.g. Heavy Duty Trucks, Medium Duty Trucks, and Light Duty Trucks)Note: Operational fleet will use zero and/or near-zero emissions for all or part of its activities.Yes,please complete applicable mitigation measure 2a through 2c belowNo, please provide justification why not selected:___________________________________________________________3. On-Site Zero Emission Off-Road Vehicles and Equipment (e.g. electric forklifts and electric yard trucks)Yes,please complete applicable mitigation measure 3 belowNo, please provide justification why not selected:___________________________________________________________4. Solar Panels (e.g. incorporate solar panels in the project)Yes,please complete applicable mitigation measure 4 belowNo, please provide justification why not selected:___________________________________________________________5. Electric Vehicle (EV) Chargers (e.g. incorporate onsite EV charging infrastructure)Yes,please complete applicable mitigation measure 5 belowNo, please provide justification why not selected:___________________________________________________________6. Clean Lawn and Garden Equipment (e.g. eletric mowers, electric leaf blowers, electric trimmers, etc.)Yes,please complete applicable mitigation measure 6 belowNo, please provide justification why not selected:___________________________________________________________7. Land Use/Location (e.g. increased density, improve walkability design, increase transit, etc.)Yes,please complete applicable mitigation measures 7a through 7f belowNo, please provide justification why not selected:___________________________________________________________8. Neighborhood/Site Enhancements (e.g. improve pedestrial network, traffic calming measures, NEV network, etc.)Yes,please complete applicable mitigation measures 8a through 8c belowNo, please provide justification why not selected:___________________________________________________________9. Parking Policy/Pricing (e.g. parking cost, on-street market pricing, limit parking supply, etc.)Yes, please complete applicable mitigation measure 9a through 9e belowNo, please provide justification why not selected:___________________________________________________________10. Commute Trip Reduction Programs (e.g. workplace parking charge, employee vanpool/shuttle, ride sharing program, etc.)Yes,please complete applicable mitigation measures 10a through 10f belowNo, please provide justification why not selected:___________________________________________________________11. Hearth (e.g. woodstoves or fireplaces)Yes,please complete mitigation measure 11 belowNo, please provide justification why not selected:___________________________________________________________12. Exceed Title 24 (e.g. exceed California Title 24 required energy efficiency for building(s) associated with the project)Yes,please complete applicable mitigation measures 12 belowNo, please provide justification why not selected:___________________________________________________________ Construction company not determined yet. Construction company not determined yet. No equipment to be used on-site.Not proposed and not required. Only regular parking is to be provided. The project only consists of a metal building.The project only consists of a metal building. Parking is provided on-site.We will only have 4 employees.Not proposed. Small building, not exceeding Title 24.
Central Region Office: 1990 E. Gettysburg Ave. Fresno, CA 93726-0244 TEL (559) 230-6000 www.valleyair.org/ISRPage 4 of 13 Revised August 30, 2022 N. Review PeriodYou may request a five (5) day period to review a draft of the I request to revieO. Fee Deferral Schedule-site air pollution reductions (mitigation measure) insufficiently reduced air pollution as outlined in Rule 9510, an off-site fee is assessed based on the excess air pollution. The money collected from this fee will be used by the District to reduce air -- date of construction. The start of construction is any of the following, whichever occcurs first: start of grading, start of demolition, or any other site development activities not mentioned above.I request a Fee Deferral Schedule, and have enclosed the Fee Deferral Schedule Application.www.valleyair.org/ISR.P. Change of Project DeveloperThe Applicant assumes all responsibility for ISR compliance for this project. If the project developer changes, the Applicant must s a change le for ISR compliance. www.valleyair.org/ISR.Q.AttachmentsRequired: Tract Map or Project Design MapVicinity MapApplication Filing Fee $841.00 for mixed use / non-residential / transporation / transit projects OR$562.00 for residential projects onlyIf applicable:Letter from Applicant granting Agent authorizationFee Deferral Schedule ApplicationMonitoring & Reporting ScheduleSupporting documentation for selected Mitigation MeasuresR. Certification StatementI certify that I have reviewed and completed the entire application and hereby attest that the information relayed within is true and correct to the best of my knowledge. I commit to implementation of those on-site mitigation measures that I have selected above. I am responsible for notifying the District if I will be unable to implement these mitigation measures. If a committed mitigation measure is not implemented, the project may be re-assessed for air quality impacts.(An authorized Agent may sign the form in lieu of the Applicant if an authorization letter signed by the Applicant is provided).Name (printed): __________________________________Title: _____________________________________Signature: ______________________________________Date: _____________________________________OwnerMandeep Kaushal