AGENDA
Garden Grove City Council
Tuesday, December 10, 2024
6:30 PM
Community Meeting Center
11300 Stanford Avenue
Garden Grove, California 92840
Steve Jones
Mayor
Cindy Tran
Mayor Pro Tem – District 3
George S. Brietigam
Council Member – District 1
John R. O’Neill
Council Member – District 2
Joe DoVinh
Council Member – District 4
Stephanie Klopfenstein
Council Member – District 5
Kim B. Nguyen-Penaloza
Council Member – District 6
Meeting Assistance: Any person requiring auxiliary aids and services, due to a disability, to address the City Council, should contact the City Clerk's Office 72 hours prior to the meeting to arrange for accommodations. Phone: (714) 741-5040.
Agenda Item Descriptions: Are intended to give a brief, general description of the item. The City Council may take legislative action deemed appropriate with respect to the item and is not limited to the recommended action indicated in staff reports or the agenda.
Documents/Writings: Any revised or additional documents/writings related to an item on the agenda distributed to all or a majority of the Council Members within 72 hours of a meeting, are made available for public inspection at the same time (1) in the City Clerk's Office at 11222 Acacia Parkway, Garden Grove, CA 92840, during normal business hours; (2) on the City's website as an attachment to the City Council meeting agenda; and (3) at the Council Chamber at the time of the meeting.
Public Comments: Members of the public who attend the meeting in -person and would like to address the City Council are requested to complete a pink speaker card indicating their name and address, and identifying the subject matter they wish to address. This card should be given to the City Clerk before the meeting begins. General comments are made during "Oral Communications" and should be limited to matters under consideration and/or what the City Council has jurisdiction over. Persons wishing to address the City Council regarding a Public Hear ing matter will be called to the podium at the time the matter is being considered.
Manner of Addressing the City Council: After being called by the Mayor, you may approach the podium, it is requested that you state your name for the record, and proceed to address the City Council. All remarks and questions should be addressed to the City Council as a whole and not to individual Council Members or staff members. Any person making impertinent, slanderous, or profane remarks or who becomes boisterous while addressing the City Council shall be called to order by the Mayor. If such conduct continues, the Mayor may order the person barred from addressing the City Council any further during that meeting.
Time Limitation: When any group of persons wishes to address the City Council on the same subject matter, the Mayor may request a spokesperson be chosen to represent the group, so as to avoid unnecessary repetition. At the City Council's discretion, a limit on the total amount of time for public comments during Oral Communications and/or a further limit on the time allotted to each speaker during Oral Communications may be set.
1
PLEASE SILENCE YOUR CELL PHONES DURING THE MEETING.
AGENDA
ROLL CALL: COUNCIL MEMBER BRIETIGAM, COUNCIL MEMBER O'NEILL, COUNCIL MEMBER
DOVINH, COUNCIL MEMBER KLOPFENSTEIN, COUNCIL MEMBER NGUYEN-
PENALOZA, MAYOR PRO TEM TRAN, MAYOR JONES
INVOCATION
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS FROM THE PUBLIC REGARDING CERTIFICATION OF THE
ELECTION
DECLARATION OF RESULTS OF THE GENERAL MUNICIPAL ELECTION AND
SEATING OF ELECTED MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS
1. Adoption of a Resolution reciting the fact of the General Municipal Election held on November 5, 2024, declaring the results and such other matters as provided by law. (Action Item)
[Item 370/2024]
COURTESY OF THE FLOOR EXTENDED TO OUTGOING MAYOR JONES AND
COUNCIL MEMBER O'NEILL, COUNCIL MEMBER KLOPFENSTEIN, AND COUNCIL
MEMBER NGUYEN-PENALOZA
RECESS
RECONVENE
OATH OF OFFICE ADMINISTERED TO ELECTED MAYOR KLOPFENSTEIN
OATH OF OFFICE ADMINISTERED TO ELECTED COUNCIL MEMBER NGUYEN FOR DISTRICT 2
OATH OF OFFICE ADMINISTERED TO ELECTED COUNCIL MEMBER MUÑETON FOR DISTRICT 5
OATH OF OFFICE ADMINISTERED TO ELECTED COUNCIL MEMBER ARESTEGUI FOR DISTRICT 6
CONVENE NEW CITY COUNCIL
ROLL CALL
COURTESY OF THE FLOOR EXTENDED TO MAYOR KLOPFENSTEIN, COUNCIL MEMBER NGUYEN, COUNCIL MEMBER MUÑETON, COUNCIL MEMBER ARESTEGUI 2
RECESS FOR RECEPTION
RECONVENE NEW CITY COUNCIL
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS (TO BE HELD SIMULTANEOUSLY WITH OTHER
LEGISLATIVE BODIES)
REORGANIZATION
2. Selection of Mayor Pro Tempore. (Action Item)
[Item 510/2024]
RECESS (TO OTHER LEGISLATIVE BODIES' BUSINESS)
CONDUCT OTHER LEGISLATIVE BODIES' BUSINESS
RECONVENE (FROM OTHER LEGISLATIVE BODIES' BUSINESS)
CONSENT ITEMS (CONSENT ITEMS WILL BE ACTED ON SIMULTANEOUSLY WITH
ONE MOTION UNLESS SEPARATE DISCUSSION AND/OR ACTION IS REQUESTED
BY A COUNCIL MEMBER)
3. Adoption of a Resolution for the Fiscal Year 2023-24 Renewed Measure M (M2) Annual Expenditure Report. (Action Item)
[Item 495/2024]
4. Adoption of a Resolution to appoint the City Treasurer and Deputy City Treasurer. (Action Item)
[Item 517/2024]
5. Adoption of a Resolution to approve a 180-day wait period exemption to hire a retired annuitant. (Action Item)
[Item 502/2024]
6. Acceptance of Project No. S-1328-A, Phase One Roof Replacement Project at the Garden Grove Amphitheater Campus, as complete. (Action Item)
[Item 508/2024]
7. Authorization of the issuance of a purchase order to Garden Grove Nissan for one (1) new SUV. (Cost $45,939.31)(Action Item)
[Item 504/2024]
8. Approval to increase amount of the purchase order with US Armor Corporation for Police body armor. (Cost: $25,000)(Action Item)
[Item 503/2024]
3
9. Approval of a Master Operation & Maintenance Agreement with CEG Solutions, LLC to provide operation and maintenance services for the photovoltaic system and battery energy storage system for the Civic Center Revitalization Project. (Cost:
$180,511) (Action Item)
[Item 479/2024]
10. Approval of a request from Edgemoor Infrastructure and Real Estate to modify construction hours and exemption from Noise Control Ordinance, Municipal Code Section 8.47.040 and 8.47.060, to accommodate construction activities for the Civic Center Revitalization Project. (Action Item)
[Item 516/2024]
11. Award a contract to Silverstone Property Management Company to provide comprehensive property, facilities, and project management services for the city- owned property located at 11277 Garden Grove Blvd. (Cost: $50,000) (Action Item)
[Item 509/2024]
12. Receive and file warrants. (Action Item)
[Item 519/2024]
13. Approval to waive full reading of ordinances listed. (Action Item)
[Item 511/2024]
PUBLIC HEARINGS (MOTION TO APPROVE WILL INCLUDE ADOPTION OF EACH RESOLUTION UNLESS OTHERWISE STATED.)
14. Adoption of a Resolution denying an appeal filed by Supporters Alliance for Environmental Responsibility (SAFER) and upholding the Planning Commission’s Decision to approve Site Plan No. SP-145-2024 and Lot Line Adjustement No. LLA- 033-2024. (Action Item)
[Item 497/2024]
COMMISSION/COMMITTEE MATTERS
15. Consideration of Appointments to the Audit Committee and outside Committees. (Action Item)
[Item 457/2024]
16. Adoption of a Resolution appointing a City Council Member to the Orange County Fire Authority Board of Directors. (Action Item)
[Item 458/2024]
ORDINANCES PRESENTED FOR SECOND READING AND ADOPTION
17. Second reading and Adoption of Ordinance No. 2962, entitled:
4
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF GARDEN GROVE AMENDING SECTION 10.36.030 OF CHAPTER 10.36 OF TITLE 10 OF THE GARDEN GROVE
MUNICIPAL CODE ESTABLISHING SPEED LIMITS FOR CERTAIN DESIGNATED CITY STREETS BASED UPON AN UPDATED TRAFFIC AND ENGINEERING SPEED SURVEY. (Action Item)
[Item 512/2024]
MATTERS FROM THE MAYOR, CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS, AND CITY MANAGER
ADJOURNMENT
The next Regular Meeting is scheduled for Tuesday, December 24, 2024, at 5:30 p.m. in the Community Meeting Center, 11300 Stanford Avenue, Garden Grove, California, 92840. 5 Item 370/2024
Final
City of Garden Grove
INTER-DEPARTMENT MEMORANDUM
To:
Lisa L. Kim From: Lizabeth Vasquez
Dept:
City Manager Dept: City Clerk
Date: 12/10/2024
Subject: Adoption of a Resolution reciting the fact of the General Municipal Election held on November 5, 2024, declaring the results and such other matters as provided by law. (Action Item)
OBJECTIVE
For the current seated Mayor and City Council adopt a Resolution certifying the results of the General Municipal Election held on November 5, 2024.
BACKGROUND/DISCUSSION
Attached is a Resolution recommended for adoption reciting the fact of the General Municipal Election held in consolidation with the General Election on November 5, 2024, with the Certified Statement of the Votes Cast and the Orange County Statement of Votes as provided by the Orange County Registrar of Voters as the Result of the Canvass.
FINANCIAL IMPACT
None.
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended that the City Council:
Adopt the attached Resolution reciting the fact of the General Municipal Election on November 5, 2024.
ATTACHMENT(S)
1. Resolution
6 GARDEN GROVE CITY COUNCIL
RESOLUTION NO.
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF GARDEN GROVE,
CALIFORNIA, RECITING THE FACT OF THE GENERAL MUNICIPAL ELECTION HELD ON NOVEMBER 5, 2024, DECLARING THE RESULT AND SUCH OTHER MATTERS AS
PROVIDED BY LAW
WHEREAS, a General Municipal Election was held and conducted in the city of Garden Grove, California, on Tuesday, November 5, 2024, as required by law;
WHEREAS, notice of the election was given in time, form, and manner as provided by law; that voting precincts were properly established; that election officers were appointed; and that in all respects the election was held and conducted and the votes were cast, received, and canvassed and the returns made and declared in time, form, and manner as required by the provisions of the Elections Code of the State of California for the holding of elections in General Law cities; and
WHEREAS, the Orange County Registrar of Voters canvassed the returns of the election and has certified the results to this City Council, the results are received, attached, and made a part hereof as “Exhibit A.”
NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF GARDEN GROVE, CALIFORNIA, DOES RESOLVE, DECLARE, DETERMINE, AND ORDER AS FOLLOWS:
SECTION 1. That the total number of ballots cast in the city is 63,616.
SECTION 2. That the names of persons voted for at the election for Mayor are as follows: Lan Nguyen, Musaab B. Mughal, Thomas Thai Nguyen, Phat Bui, Stephanie Klopfenstein, Diedre Thu-Ha Nguyen, and John O’Neill.
That the names of persons voted for at the election for Member of the City Council are as follows: John Ramirez and Phillip Nguyen - District 2; Sandra Thomas, Yesenia Muneton, and Mariyan Bahadarakhann - District 5; Ariana Arestegui and Tri Lam - District 6.
SECTION 3. That the number of votes given at each precinct and the number of votes given in the city to each of the persons above named for the respective offices for which the persons were candidates, are as listed in “Exhibit A” attached.
SECTION 4. The City Council of the City of Garden Grove does declare and determine that Stephanie Klopfenstein was elected as Mayor for the full term of two years; Phillip Nguyen was elected as a City Council Member-District 2 for the full term of four years; Yesenia Muneton was elected as a City Council Member-District 5 for the full term of four years, and Ariana Arestegui was elected as a City Council Member-District 6 for the full term of four years.
7 Garden Grove City Council
Resolution No. xxxx-24
SECTION 5. The City Clerk shall enter on the records of the City Council of the City of Garden Grove a statement of the result of the election, showing: (1) The whole number of ballots cast in the city; (2) The names of the persons voted for; (3) For what office each person was voted for; and (4) The total number of votes given to each person.
SECTION 6. That the City Clerk shall immediately make and deliver to each of the persons so elected a Certificate of Election signed by the City Clerk and authenticated; that the City Clerk shall also administer to each person elected the Oath of Office prescribed in the Constitution of the State of California and shall have them subscribe to it and file it in the Office of the City Clerk. Each and all of the persons so elected shall then be inducted into the respective office to which they have been elected.
SECTION 7. That the City Clerk shall certify to the passage and adoption of this Resolution, and enter it into the book of original Resolutions.
Adopted this 10th day of December 2024.
8 Garden Grove City Council
Resolution No. xxxx-24
“EXHIBIT A”
CERTIFICATE OF ORANGE COUNTY REGISTRAR OF VOTERS TO RESULT OF THE CANVASS OF THE RETURNS OF THE NOVEMBER 5, 2024, ELECTION 9 10
11 12
12/03/2024 11:41 AM Page 1154District Results Report - November 05, 2024 CITY OF GARDEN GROVE Mayor
Vote Center Totals
District
Registration
Ballots Cast
Turnout (%)
MUSAAB B. MUGHAL
PHAT BUI
STEPHANIE KLOPFENSTEIN
LAN NGUYEN
THOMAS THAI NGUYEN
DIEDRE THU-HA NGUYEN
JOHN R. O'NEILL
Orange County 93,191 15,534 16.7 483 2,382 4,220 2,020 361 2,537 1,793 Orange County 93,191 15,534 16.7 483 2,382 4,220 2,020 361 2,537 1,793 45th Congressional District 93,112 15,528 16.7 482 2,382 4,219 2,020 360 2,537 1,792 46th Congressional District 79 6 7.6 1 0 1 0 1 0 1
34th Senate District 17,701 2,567 14.5 88 395 577 361 68 492 310 36th Senate District 75,490 12,967 17.2 395 1,987 3,643 1,659 293 2,045 1,483 70th Assembly District 93,191 15,534 16.7 483 2,382 4,220 2,020 361 2,537 1,793 1st Supervisorial District 76,864 13,132 17.1 403 2,006 3,708 1,696 301 2,057 1,484 2nd Supervisorial District 16,327 2,402 14.7 80 376 512 324 60 480 309 Garden Grove 93,191 15,534 16.7 483 2,382 4,220 2,020 361 2,537 1,793 Garden Grove Council District 1 17,892 3,519 19.7 71 577 1,427 244 31 381 382 Garden Grove Council District 2 16,840 2,780 16.5 80 387 748 357 66 483 352 Garden Grove Council District 3 15,513 2,539 16.4 131 357 528 389 86 459 285 Garden Grove Council District 4 15,823 2,479 15.7 67 439 493 451 68 439 253 Garden Grove Council District 5 15,346 2,567 16.7 77 363 688 356 67 453 300 Garden Grove Council District 6 11,777 1,650 14.0 57 259 336 223 43 322 221 State Board of Equalization
(4th District)
93,191 15,534 16.7 483 2,382 4,220 2,020 361 2,537 1,793 4th District Court of Appeal 93,191 15,534 16.7 483 2,382 4,220 2,020 361 2,537 1,793 County Board of Education
Trustee Area 1
17,622 2,561 14.5 87 395 576 361 67 492 309
County Board of Education
Trustee Area 4
75,569 12,973 17.2 396 1,987 3,644 1,659 294 2,045 1,484 Coast Community College
District
48,454 8,264 17.1 270 1,324 2,254 1,078 188 1,296 900
Coast Community College
District Trustee Area 1
9,930 2,131 21.5 45 345 1,001 95 6 192 218
Coast Community College
District Trustee Area 2
38,524 6,133 15.9 225 979 1,253 983 182 1,104 682
North Orange County
Community College District
15,649 2,739 17.5 63 382 836 337 54 421 344
North Orange County
Community College District
Trustee Area 1
15,649 2,739 17.5 63 382 836 337 54 421 344
Rancho Santiago Community
College District
29,088 4,531 15.6 150 676 1,130 605 119 820 549
Rancho Santiago Community
College District Trustee Area 4
21,889 3,497 16.0 113 509 909 462 93 618 441
Rancho Santiago Community
College District Trustee Area 5
7,199 1,034 14.4 37 167 221 143 26 202 108
Westminster School District 4,714 695 14.7 8 94 124 95 24 139 105 Westminster School District
Trustee Area 3
4,714 695 14.7 8 94 124 95 24 139 105
Anaheim Elementary School
District
148 17 11.5 1 2 6 3 0 4 0
Anaheim Elementary School
District Trustee Area 3
148 17 11.5 1 2 6 3 0 4 0
Magnolia School District 79 6 7.6 1 0 1 0 1 0 1
Magnolia School District
Trustee Area 5
79 6 7.6 1 0 1 0 1 0 1
Huntington Beach Union High
School District
4,714 695 14.7 8 94 124 95 24 139 105
Huntington Beach Union High
School District Trustee Area 1
4,714 695 14.7 8 94 124 95 24 139 105
Anaheim Union High School
District
227 23 10.1 2 2 7 3 1 4 1
Anaheim Union High School
District Trustee Area 3
227 23 10.1 2 2 7 3 1 4 1
Garden Grove Unified School
District
85,070 14,340 16.9 452 2,202 3,991 1,870 326 2,304 1,633 Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 1
20,489 4,000 19.5 86 660 1,539 318 37 487 433
Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 2
31,538 5,413 17.2 165 770 1,540 728 137 899 639
13 12/03/2024 11:41 AM Page 1155District Results Report - November 05, 2024 CITY OF GARDEN GROVE Mayor
Vote Center Totals
District
Registration
Ballots Cast
Turnout (%)
MUSAAB B. MUGHAL
PHAT BUI
STEPHANIE KLOPFENSTEIN
LAN NGUYEN
THOMAS THAI NGUYEN
DIEDRE THU-HA NGUYEN
JOHN R. O'NEILL
Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 3
14,479 2,085 14.4 65 307 448 302 59 409 274
Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 4
1,143 159 13.9 3 28 25 48 3 31 9
Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 5
17,421 2,683 15.4 133 437 439 474 90 478 278
Orange Unified School District 3,180 476 15.0 21 84 98 52 10 90 54 Orange Unified School District
Trustee Area 2
3,180 476 15.0 21 84 98 52 10 90 54
Municipal Water District of
Orange County
93,191 15,534 16.7 483 2,382 4,220 2,020 361 2,537 1,793 Municipal Water District of
Orange County Division 2
55,325 8,988 16.2 274 1,338 2,281 1,238 233 1,581 1,087 Municipal Water District of
Orange County Division 3
37,866 6,546 17.3 209 1,044 1,939 782 128 956 706
Orange County Water District 93,191 15,534 16.7 483 2,382 4,220 2,020 361 2,537 1,793 Orange County Water District
Division 1
81,233 12,891 15.9 428 1,945 2,976 1,893 353 2,310 1,521 Orange County Water District
Division 4
11,958 2,643 22.1 55 437 1,244 127 8 227 272
Historical 2010 - 46th
Congressional District
22,975 3,515 15.3 104 508 892 487 84 640 428
Historical 2010 - 47th
Congressional District
58,845 10,355 17.6 272 1,591 3,110 1,205 225 1,588 1,200 Historical 2010 - 48th
Congressional District
11,371 1,664 14.6 107 283 218 328 52 309 165
Historical 2010 - 34th Senate
District
93,191 15,534 16.7 483 2,382 4,220 2,020 361 2,537 1,793 Historical 2010 - 65th
Assembly District
394 42 10.7 1 4 12 3 1 4 4
Historical 2010 - 69th
Assembly District
16,741 2,438 14.6 84 381 546 347 63 470 288
Historical 2010 - 72nd
Assembly District
76,056 13,054 17.2 398 1,997 3,662 1,670 297 2,063 1,501 Historical 2010 - State Board of
Equalization (4th District)
93,191 15,534 16.7 483 2,382 4,220 2,020 361 2,537 1,793 Historical 2010 - 1st
Supervisorial District
93,191 15,534 16.7 483 2,382 4,220 2,020 361 2,537 1,793 Historical 2010 - 3rd
Supervisorial District
0 0 0.0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Historical 2010 - County Board
of Education Trustee Area 1
80,898 12,853 15.9 428 1,940 2,964 1,890 353 2,306 1,518 Historical 2010 - County Board
of Education Trustee Area 2
12,293 2,681 21.8 55 442 1,256 130 8 231 275
Historical 2010 - County Board
of Education Trustee Area 3
0 0 0.0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Proposition 2 93,191 15,534 16.7 483 2,382 4,220 2,020 361 2,537 1,793 Proposition 3 93,191 15,534 16.7 483 2,382 4,220 2,020 361 2,537 1,793 Proposition 4 93,191 15,534 16.7 483 2,382 4,220 2,020 361 2,537 1,793 Proposition 5 93,191 15,534 16.7 483 2,382 4,220 2,020 361 2,537 1,793 Proposition 6 93,191 15,534 16.7 483 2,382 4,220 2,020 361 2,537 1,793 Proposition 32 93,191 15,534 16.7 483 2,382 4,220 2,020 361 2,537 1,793 Proposition 33 93,191 15,534 16.7 483 2,382 4,220 2,020 361 2,537 1,793 Proposition 34 93,191 15,534 16.7 483 2,382 4,220 2,020 361 2,537 1,793 Proposition 35 93,191 15,534 16.7 483 2,382 4,220 2,020 361 2,537 1,793 Proposition 36 93,191 15,534 16.7 483 2,382 4,220 2,020 361 2,537 1,793 United States Senator
Partial/Unexpired Term
93,191 15,534 16.7 483 2,382 4,220 2,020 361 2,537 1,793 United States Senator 93,191 15,534 16.7 483 2,382 4,220 2,020 361 2,537 1,793 President 93,191 15,534 16.7 483 2,382 4,220 2,020 361 2,537 1,793 Vote Center Totals 93,191 15,534 16.7 483 2,382 4,220 2,020 361 2,537 1,793
14 12/03/2024 11:41 AM Page 1156District Results Report - November 05, 2024 CITY OF GARDEN GROVE Mayor
Vote by Mail
Totals
District
Registration
Ballots Cast
Turnout (%)
MUSAAB B. MUGHAL
PHAT BUI
STEPHANIE KLOPFENSTEIN
LAN NGUYEN
THOMAS THAI NGUYEN
DIEDRE THU-HA NGUYEN
JOHN R. O'NEILL
Orange County 93,191 48,082 51.6 991 5449 11489 8159 995 11835 5667 Orange County 93,191 48,082 51.6 991 5449 11489 8159 995 11835 5667 45th Congressional District 93,112 48,041 51.6 983 5447 11482 8152 995 11830 5660 46th Congressional District 79 41 51.9 8 2 7 7 0 5 7
34th Senate District 17,701 8,756 49.5 182 1018 1788 1439 213 2396 1053 36th Senate District 75,490 39,326 52.1 809 4431 9701 6720 782 9439 4614 70th Assembly District 93,191 48,082 51.6 991 5449 11489 8159 995 11835 5667 1st Supervisorial District 76,864 40,106 52.2 832 4514 9916 6854 791 9619 4708 2nd Supervisorial District 16,327 7,976 48.9 159 935 1573 1305 204 2216 959 Garden Grove 93,191 48,082 51.6 991 5449 11489 8159 995 11835 5667 Garden Grove Council District 1 17,892 10,184 56.9 156 1111 3571 966 113 2098 1252 Garden Grove Council District 2 16,840 8,740 51.9 175 892 2101 1539 128 2099 1249 Garden Grove Council District 3 15,513 7,803 50.3 233 884 1400 1724 225 2008 793 Garden Grove Council District 4 15,823 7,953 50.3 160 1063 1364 1704 194 2083 808 Garden Grove Council District 5 15,346 7,710 50.2 146 794 1993 1290 176 1941 908 Garden Grove Council District 6 11,777 5,692 48.3 121 705 1060 936 159 1606 657 State Board of Equalization
(4th District)
93,191 48,082 51.6 991 5449 11489 8159 995 11835 5667
4th District Court of Appeal 93,191 48,082 51.6 991 5449 11489 8159 995 11835 5667 County Board of Education
Trustee Area 1
17,622 8,715 49.5 174 1016 1781 1432 213 2391 1046
County Board of Education
Trustee Area 4
75,569 39,367 52.1 817 4433 9708 6727 782 9444 4621
Coast Community College
District
48,454 25,323 52.3 542 2981 5906 4464 540 6162 2773
Coast Community College
District Trustee Area 1
9,930 6,042 60.8 86 606 2548 335 35 1118 760
Coast Community College
District Trustee Area 2
38,524 19,281 50.0 456 2375 3358 4129 505 5044 2013
North Orange County
Community College District
15,649 8,241 52.7 157 857 2188 1286 104 1866 1211
North Orange County
Community College District
Trustee Area 1
15,649 8,241 52.7 157 857 2188 1286 104 1866 1211
Rancho Santiago Community
College District
29,088 14,518 49.9 292 1611 3395 2409 351 3807 1683
Rancho Santiago Community
College District Trustee Area 4
21,889 10,860 49.6 219 1153 2659 1814 275 2877 1224
Rancho Santiago Community
College District Trustee Area 5
7,199 3,658 50.8 73 458 736 595 76 930 459
Westminster School District 4,714 2,336 49.6 38 274 355 505 75 643 263 Westminster School District
Trustee Area 3
4,714 2,336 49.6 38 274 355 505 75 643 263
Anaheim Elementary School
District
148 96 64.9 4 7 32 10 1 25 8
Anaheim Elementary School
District Trustee Area 3
148 96 64.9 4 7 32 10 1 25 8
Magnolia School District 79 41 51.9 8 2 7 7 0 5 7
Magnolia School District
Trustee Area 5
79 41 51.9 8 2 7 7 0 5 7
Huntington Beach Union High
School District
4,714 2,336 49.6 38 274 355 505 75 643 263
Huntington Beach Union High
School District Trustee Area 1
4,714 2,336 49.6 38 274 355 505 75 643 263
Anaheim Union High School
District
227 137 60.4 12 9 39 17 1 30 15
Anaheim Union High School
District Trustee Area 3
227 137 60.4 12 9 39 17 1 30 15
Garden Grove Unified School
District
85,070 44,099 51.8 907 4953 10816 7416 883 10795 5196
Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 1
20,489 11,494 56.1 190 1229 3898 1251 117 2377 1431
Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 2
31,538 16,185 51.3 325 1667 4124 2759 299 3931 2085
15 12/03/2024 11:41 AM Page 1157District Results Report - November 05, 2024 CITY OF GARDEN GROVE Mayor
Vote by Mail
Totals
District
Registration
Ballots Cast
Turnout (%)
MUSAAB B. MUGHAL
PHAT BUI
STEPHANIE KLOPFENSTEIN
LAN NGUYEN
THOMAS THAI NGUYEN
DIEDRE THU-HA NGUYEN
JOHN R. O'NEILL
Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 3
14,479 7,196 49.7 144 825 1451 1235 196 2052 826
Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 4
1,143 631 55.2 8 78 74 152 22 191 59
Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 5
17,421 8,593 49.3 240 1154 1269 2019 249 2244 795
Orange Unified School District 3,180 1,510 47.5 34 213 279 221 36 367 193 Orange Unified School District
Trustee Area 2
3,180 1,510 47.5 34 213 279 221 36 367 193
Municipal Water District of
Orange County
93,191 48,082 51.6 991 5449 11489 8159 995 11835 5667
Municipal Water District of
Orange County Division 2
55,325 27,832 50.3 555 3088 6385 4820 576 7080 3476
Municipal Water District of
Orange County Division 3
37,866 20,250 53.5 436 2361 5104 3339 419 4755 2191
Orange County Water District 93,191 48,082 51.6 991 5449 11489 8159 995 11835 5667 Orange County Water District
Division 1
81,233 40,857 50.3 890 4703 8439 7754 961 10536 4746
Orange County Water District
Division 4
11,958 7,225 60.4 101 746 3050 405 34 1299 921
Historical 2010 - 46th
Congressional District
22,975 11,556 50.3 211 1272 2613 1876 273 3048 1447
Historical 2010 - 47th
Congressional District
58,845 30,771 52.3 596 3414 8139 4839 557 7233 3746
Historical 2010 - 48th
Congressional District
11,371 5,755 50.6 184 763 737 1444 165 1554 474
Historical 2010 - 34th Senate
District
93,191 48,082 51.6 991 5449 11489 8159 995 11835 5667
Historical 2010 - 65th
Assembly District
394 225 57.1 13 24 54 21 7 58 22
Historical 2010 - 69th
Assembly District
16,741 8,306 49.6 163 968 1699 1352 202 2283 995
Historical 2010 - 72nd
Assembly District
76,056 39,551 52.0 815 4457 9736 6786 786 9494 4650
Historical 2010 - State Board of
Equalization (4th District)
93,191 48,082 51.6 991 5449 11489 8159 995 11835 5667
Historical 2010 - 1st
Supervisorial District
93,191 48,082 51.6 991 5449 11489 8159 995 11835 5667
Historical 2010 - 3rd
Supervisorial District
0 0 0.0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Historical 2010 - County Board
of Education Trustee Area 1
80,898 40,665 50.3 885 4680 8389 7740 954 10483 4730
Historical 2010 - County Board
of Education Trustee Area 2
12,293 7,417 60.3 106 769 3100 419 41 1352 937
Historical 2010 - County Board
of Education Trustee Area 3
0 0 0.0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Proposition 2 93,191 48,082 51.6 991 5449 11489 8159 995 11835 5667 Proposition 3 93,191 48,082 51.6 991 5449 11489 8159 995 11835 5667 Proposition 4 93,191 48,082 51.6 991 5449 11489 8159 995 11835 5667 Proposition 5 93,191 48,082 51.6 991 5449 11489 8159 995 11835 5667 Proposition 6 93,191 48,082 51.6 991 5449 11489 8159 995 11835 5667 Proposition 32 93,191 48,082 51.6 991 5449 11489 8159 995 11835 5667 Proposition 33 93,191 48,082 51.6 991 5449 11489 8159 995 11835 5667 Proposition 34 93,191 48,082 51.6 991 5449 11489 8159 995 11835 5667 Proposition 35 93,191 48,082 51.6 991 5449 11489 8159 995 11835 5667 Proposition 36 93,191 48,082 51.6 991 5449 11489 8159 995 11835 5667 United States Senator
Partial/Unexpired Term
93,191 48,082 51.6 991 5449 11489 8159 995 11835 5667
United States Senator 93,191 48,082 51.6 991 5449 11489 8159 995 11835 5667 President 93,191 48,082 51.6 991 5449 11489 8159 995 11835 5667 Vote by Mail Totals 93,191 48,082 51.6 991 5,449 11,489 8,159 995 11,835 5,667
16 12/03/2024 11:41 AM Page 1158District Results Report - November 05, 2024 CITY OF GARDEN GROVE Mayor
Grand Totals
District
Registration
Ballots Cast
Turnout (%)
MUSAAB B. MUGHAL
PHAT BUI
STEPHANIE KLOPFENSTEIN
LAN NGUYEN
THOMAS THAI NGUYEN
DIEDRE THU-HA NGUYEN
JOHN R. O'NEILL
Orange County 93,191 63,616 68.3 1474 7831 15709 10179 1356 14372 7460 Orange County 93,191 63,616 68.3 1474 7831 15709 10179 1356 14372 7460 45th Congressional District 93,112 63,569 68.3 1465 7829 15701 10172 1355 14367 7452 46th Congressional District 79 47 59.5 9 2 8 7 1 5 8
34th Senate District 17,701 11,323 64.0 270 1413 2365 1800 281 2888 1363 36th Senate District 75,490 52,293 69.3 1204 6418 13344 8379 1075 11484 6097 70th Assembly District 93,191 63,616 68.3 1474 7831 15709 10179 1356 14372 7460 1st Supervisorial District 76,864 53,238 69.3 1235 6520 13624 8550 1092 11676 6192 2nd Supervisorial District 16,327 10,378 63.6 239 1311 2085 1629 264 2696 1268 Garden Grove 93,191 63,616 68.3 1474 7831 15709 10179 1356 14372 7460 Garden Grove Council District 1 17,892 13,703 76.6 227 1688 4998 1210 144 2479 1634 Garden Grove Council District 2 16,840 11,520 68.4 255 1279 2849 1896 194 2582 1601 Garden Grove Council District 3 15,513 10,342 66.7 364 1241 1928 2113 311 2467 1078 Garden Grove Council District 4 15,823 10,432 65.9 227 1502 1857 2155 262 2522 1061 Garden Grove Council District 5 15,346 10,277 67.0 223 1157 2681 1646 243 2394 1208 Garden Grove Council District 6 11,777 7,342 62.3 178 964 1396 1159 202 1928 878 State Board of Equalization
(4th District)
93,191 63,616 68.3 1474 7831 15709 10179 1356 14372 7460 4th District Court of Appeal 93,191 63,616 68.3 1474 7831 15709 10179 1356 14372 7460 County Board of Education
Trustee Area 1
17,622 11,276 64.0 261 1411 2357 1793 280 2883 1355
County Board of Education
Trustee Area 4
75,569 52,340 69.3 1213 6420 13352 8386 1076 11489 6105 Coast Community College
District
48,454 33,587 69.3 812 4305 8160 5542 728 7458 3673
Coast Community College
District Trustee Area 1
9,930 8,173 82.3 131 951 3549 430 41 1310 978
Coast Community College
District Trustee Area 2
38,524 25,414 66.0 681 3354 4611 5112 687 6148 2695
North Orange County
Community College District
15,649 10,980 70.2 220 1239 3024 1623 158 2287 1555
North Orange County
Community College District
Trustee Area 1
15,649 10,980 70.2 220 1239 3024 1623 158 2287 1555
Rancho Santiago Community
College District
29,088 19,049 65.5 442 2287 4525 3014 470 4627 2232
Rancho Santiago Community
College District Trustee Area 4
21,889 14,357 65.6 332 1662 3568 2276 368 3495 1665
Rancho Santiago Community
College District Trustee Area 5
7,199 4,692 65.2 110 625 957 738 102 1132 567
Westminster School District 4,714 3,031 64.3 46 368 479 600 99 782 368 Westminster School District
Trustee Area 3
4,714 3,031 64.3 46 368 479 600 99 782 368
Anaheim Elementary School
District
148 113 76.4 5 9 38 13 1 29 8
Anaheim Elementary School
District Trustee Area 3
148 113 76.4 5 9 38 13 1 29 8
Magnolia School District 79 47 59.5 9 2 8 7 1 5 8
Magnolia School District
Trustee Area 5
79 47 59.5 9 2 8 7 1 5 8
Huntington Beach Union High
School District
4,714 3,031 64.3 46 368 479 600 99 782 368
Huntington Beach Union High
School District Trustee Area 1
4,714 3,031 64.3 46 368 479 600 99 782 368
Anaheim Union High School
District
227 160 70.5 14 11 46 20 2 34 16
Anaheim Union High School
District Trustee Area 3
227 160 70.5 14 11 46 20 2 34 16
Garden Grove Unified School
District
85,070 58,439 68.7 1359 7155 14807 9286 1209 13099 6829 Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 1
20,489 15,494 75.6 276 1889 5437 1569 154 2864 1864
Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 2
31,538 21,598 68.5 490 2437 5664 3487 436 4830 2724
17 12/03/2024 11:41 AM Page 1159District Results Report - November 05, 2024 CITY OF GARDEN GROVE Mayor
Grand Totals
District
Registration
Ballots Cast
Turnout (%)
MUSAAB B. MUGHAL
PHAT BUI
STEPHANIE KLOPFENSTEIN
LAN NGUYEN
THOMAS THAI NGUYEN
DIEDRE THU-HA NGUYEN
JOHN R. O'NEILL
Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 3
14,479 9,281 64.1 209 1132 1899 1537 255 2461 1100
Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 4
1,143 790 69.1 11 106 99 200 25 222 68
Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 5
17,421 11,276 64.7 373 1591 1708 2493 339 2722 1073
Orange Unified School District 3,180 1,986 62.5 55 297 377 273 46 457 247 Orange Unified School District
Trustee Area 2
3,180 1,986 62.5 55 297 377 273 46 457 247
Municipal Water District of
Orange County
93,191 63,616 68.3 1474 7831 15709 10179 1356 14372 7460 Municipal Water District of
Orange County Division 2
55,325 36,820 66.6 829 4426 8666 6058 809 8661 4563
Municipal Water District of
Orange County Division 3
37,866 26,796 70.8 645 3405 7043 4121 547 5711 2897
Orange County Water District 93,191 63,616 68.3 1474 7831 15709 10179 1356 14372 7460 Orange County Water District
Division 1
81,233 53,748 66.2 1318 6648 11415 9647 1314 12846 6267 Orange County Water District
Division 4
11,958 9,868 82.5 156 1183 4294 532 42 1526 1193
Historical 2010 - 46th
Congressional District
22,975 15,071 65.6 315 1780 3505 2363 357 3688 1875
Historical 2010 - 47th
Congressional District
58,845 41,126 69.9 868 5005 11249 6044 782 8821 4946
Historical 2010 - 48th
Congressional District
11,371 7,419 65.2 291 1046 955 1772 217 1863 639
Historical 2010 - 34th Senate
District
93,191 63,616 68.3 1474 7831 15709 10179 1356 14372 7460 Historical 2010 - 65th
Assembly District
394 267 67.8 14 28 66 24 8 62 26
Historical 2010 - 69th
Assembly District
16,741 10,744 64.2 247 1349 2245 1699 265 2753 1283
Historical 2010 - 72nd
Assembly District
76,056 52,605 69.2 1213 6454 13398 8456 1083 11557 6151 Historical 2010 - State Board of
Equalization (4th District)
93,191 63,616 68.3 1474 7831 15709 10179 1356 14372 7460 Historical 2010 - 1st
Supervisorial District
93,191 63,616 68.3 1474 7831 15709 10179 1356 14372 7460 Historical 2010 - 3rd
Supervisorial District
0 0 0.0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Historical 2010 - County Board
of Education Trustee Area 1
80,898 53,518 66.2 1313 6620 11353 9630 1307 12789 6248 Historical 2010 - County Board
of Education Trustee Area 2
12,293 10,098 82.1 161 1211 4356 549 49 1583 1212
Historical 2010 - County Board
of Education Trustee Area 3
0 0 0.0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Proposition 2 93,191 63,616 68.3 1474 7831 15709 10179 1356 14372 7460 Proposition 3 93,191 63,616 68.3 1474 7831 15709 10179 1356 14372 7460 Proposition 4 93,191 63,616 68.3 1474 7831 15709 10179 1356 14372 7460 Proposition 5 93,191 63,616 68.3 1474 7831 15709 10179 1356 14372 7460 Proposition 6 93,191 63,616 68.3 1474 7831 15709 10179 1356 14372 7460 Proposition 32 93,191 63,616 68.3 1474 7831 15709 10179 1356 14372 7460 Proposition 33 93,191 63,616 68.3 1474 7831 15709 10179 1356 14372 7460 Proposition 34 93,191 63,616 68.3 1474 7831 15709 10179 1356 14372 7460 Proposition 35 93,191 63,616 68.3 1474 7831 15709 10179 1356 14372 7460 Proposition 36 93,191 63,616 68.3 1474 7831 15709 10179 1356 14372 7460 United States Senator
Partial/Unexpired Term
93,191 63,616 68.3 1474 7831 15709 10179 1356 14372 7460 United States Senator 93,191 63,616 68.3 1474 7831 15709 10179 1356 14372 7460 President 93,191 63,616 68.3 1474 7831 15709 10179 1356 14372 7460 Vote Center Totals 93,191 15,534 16.7 483 2,382 4,220 2,020 361 2,537 1,793 Vote by Mail Totals 93,191 48,082 51.6 991 5,449 11,489 8,159 995 11,835 5,667 Grand Totals 93,191 63,616 68.3 1,474 7,831 15,709 10,179 1,356 14,372 7,460
18 12/03/2024 11:41 AM Page 1161District Results Report - November 05, 2024 CITY OF GARDEN GROVE Member, City Council, District 2
Vote Center Totals
District
Registration
Ballots Cast
Turnout (%)
JOHN RAMIREZ
PHILLIP NGUYEN
Orange County 16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180
Orange County 16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180
45th Congressional District 16,761 2,774 16.6 1,151 1,177 46th Congressional District 79 6 7.6 1 3
34th Senate District 79 6 7.6 1 3
36th Senate District 16,761 2,774 16.6 1,151 1,177
70th Assembly District 16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180
1st Supervisorial District 16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180 Garden Grove 16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180
Garden Grove Council District 2 16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180 State Board of Equalization
(4th District)
16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180
4th District Court of Appeal 16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180 County Board of Education
Trustee Area 4
16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180
Coast Community College
District
1,589 277 17.4 97 140
Coast Community College
District Trustee Area 2
1,589 277 17.4 97 140
North Orange County
Community College District
13,286 2,189 16.5 916 912
North Orange County
Community College District
Trustee Area 1
13,286 2,189 16.5 916 912
Rancho Santiago Community
College District
1,965 314 16.0 139 128
Rancho Santiago Community
College District Trustee Area 4
1,965 314 16.0 139 128
Anaheim Elementary School
District
148 17 11.5 7 7
Anaheim Elementary School
District Trustee Area 3
148 17 11.5 7 7
Magnolia School District 79 6 7.6 1 3
Magnolia School District
Trustee Area 5
79 6 7.6 1 3
Anaheim Union High School
District
227 23 10.1 8 10
Anaheim Union High School
District Trustee Area 3
227 23 10.1 8 10
Garden Grove Unified School
District
16,613 2,757 16.6 1,144 1,170
Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 1
3,290 546 16.6 194 262
Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 2
13,323 2,211 16.6 950 908
Municipal Water District of
Orange County
16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180
Municipal Water District of
Orange County Division 2
16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180
Orange County Water District 16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180 Orange County Water District
Division 1
16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180
Historical 2010 - 46th
Congressional District
3,281 538 16.4 238 217
Historical 2010 - 47th
Congressional District
13,559 2,242 16.5 914 963
Historical 2010 - 34th Senate
District
16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180
Historical 2010 - 65th
Assembly District
79 6 7.6 1 3
Historical 2010 - 72nd
Assembly District
16,761 2,774 16.6 1,151 1,177
Historical 2010 - State Board of
Equalization (4th District)
16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180
Historical 2010 - 1st
Supervisorial District
16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180
19 12/03/2024 11:41 AM Page 1162District Results Report - November 05, 2024 CITY OF GARDEN GROVE Member, City Council, District 2
Vote Center Totals
District
Registration
Ballots Cast
Turnout (%)
JOHN RAMIREZ
PHILLIP NGUYEN
Historical 2010 - County Board
of Education Trustee Area 1
16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180
Proposition 2 16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180
Proposition 3 16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180
Proposition 4 16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180
Proposition 5 16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180
Proposition 6 16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180
Proposition 32 16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180
Proposition 33 16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180
Proposition 34 16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180
Proposition 35 16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180
Proposition 36 16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180
United States Senator
Partial/Unexpired Term
16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180
United States Senator 16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180
President 16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180
Vote Center Totals 16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180
20 12/03/2024 11:41 AM Page 1163District Results Report - November 05, 2024 CITY OF GARDEN GROVE Member, City Council, District 2
Vote by Mail
Totals
District
Registration
Ballots Cast
Turnout (%)
JOHN RAMIREZ
PHILLIP NGUYEN
Orange County 16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521
Orange County 16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521
45th Congressional District 16,761 8,699 51.9 3267 4501 46th Congressional District 79 41 51.9 15 20
34th Senate District 79 41 51.9 15 20
36th Senate District 16,761 8,699 51.9 3267 4501
70th Assembly District 16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521
1st Supervisorial District 16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521
Garden Grove 16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521
Garden Grove Council District 2 16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521 State Board of Equalization
(4th District)
16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521
4th District Court of Appeal 16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521 County Board of Education
Trustee Area 4
16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521
Coast Community College
District
1,589 758 47.7 230 432
Coast Community College
District Trustee Area 2
1,589 758 47.7 230 432
North Orange County
Community College District
13,286 6,866 51.7 2629 3516
North Orange County
Community College District
Trustee Area 1
13,286 6,866 51.7 2629 3516
Rancho Santiago Community
College District
1,965 1,116 56.8 423 573
Rancho Santiago Community
College District Trustee Area 4
1,965 1,116 56.8 423 573
Anaheim Elementary School
District
148 96 64.9 39 39
Anaheim Elementary School
District Trustee Area 3
148 96 64.9 39 39
Magnolia School District 79 41 51.9 15 20
Magnolia School District
Trustee Area 5
79 41 51.9 15 20
Anaheim Union High School
District
227 137 60.4 54 59
Anaheim Union High School
District Trustee Area 3
227 137 60.4 54 59
Garden Grove Unified School
District
16,613 8,603 51.8 3228 4462
Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 1
3,290 1,593 48.4 525 865
Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 2
13,323 7,010 52.6 2703 3597
Municipal Water District of
Orange County
16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521
Municipal Water District of
Orange County Division 2
16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521
Orange County Water District 16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521 Orange County Water District
Division 1
16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521
Historical 2010 - 46th
Congressional District
3,281 1,751 53.4 708 889
Historical 2010 - 47th
Congressional District
13,559 6,989 51.5 2574 3632
Historical 2010 - 34th Senate
District
16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521
Historical 2010 - 65th
Assembly District
79 41 51.9 15 20
Historical 2010 - 72nd
Assembly District
16,761 8,699 51.9 3267 4501
Historical 2010 - State Board of
Equalization (4th District)
16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521
Historical 2010 - 1st
Supervisorial District
16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521
21 12/03/2024 11:41 AM Page 1164District Results Report - November 05, 2024 CITY OF GARDEN GROVE Member, City Council, District 2
Vote by Mail
Totals
District
Registration
Ballots Cast
Turnout (%)
JOHN RAMIREZ
PHILLIP NGUYEN
Historical 2010 - County Board
of Education Trustee Area 1
16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521
Proposition 2 16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521
Proposition 3 16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521
Proposition 4 16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521
Proposition 5 16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521
Proposition 6 16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521
Proposition 32 16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521
Proposition 33 16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521
Proposition 34 16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521
Proposition 35 16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521
Proposition 36 16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521
United States Senator
Partial/Unexpired Term
16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521
United States Senator 16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521
President 16,840 8,740 51.9 3282 4521
Vote by Mail Totals 16,840 8,740 51.9 3,282 4,521
22 12/03/2024 11:41 AM Page 1165District Results Report - November 05, 2024 CITY OF GARDEN GROVE Member, City Council, District 2
Grand Totals
District
Registration
Ballots Cast
Turnout (%)
JOHN RAMIREZ
PHILLIP NGUYEN
Orange County 16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701
Orange County 16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701
45th Congressional District 16,761 11,473 68.5 4418 5678 46th Congressional District 79 47 59.5 16 23
34th Senate District 79 47 59.5 16 23
36th Senate District 16,761 11,473 68.5 4418 5678
70th Assembly District 16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701
1st Supervisorial District 16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701 Garden Grove 16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701
Garden Grove Council District 2 16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701 State Board of Equalization
(4th District)
16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701
4th District Court of Appeal 16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701 County Board of Education
Trustee Area 4
16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701
Coast Community College
District
1,589 1,035 65.1 327 572
Coast Community College
District Trustee Area 2
1,589 1,035 65.1 327 572
North Orange County
Community College District
13,286 9,055 68.2 3545 4428
North Orange County
Community College District
Trustee Area 1
13,286 9,055 68.2 3545 4428
Rancho Santiago Community
College District
1,965 1,430 72.8 562 701
Rancho Santiago Community
College District Trustee Area 4
1,965 1,430 72.8 562 701
Anaheim Elementary School
District
148 113 76.4 46 46
Anaheim Elementary School
District Trustee Area 3
148 113 76.4 46 46
Magnolia School District 79 47 59.5 16 23
Magnolia School District
Trustee Area 5
79 47 59.5 16 23
Anaheim Union High School
District
227 160 70.5 62 69
Anaheim Union High School
District Trustee Area 3
227 160 70.5 62 69
Garden Grove Unified School
District
16,613 11,360 68.4 4372 5632
Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 1
3,290 2,139 65.0 719 1127
Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 2
13,323 9,221 69.2 3653 4505
Municipal Water District of
Orange County
16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701
Municipal Water District of
Orange County Division 2
16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701
Orange County Water District 16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701 Orange County Water District
Division 1
16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701
Historical 2010 - 46th
Congressional District
3,281 2,289 69.8 946 1106
Historical 2010 - 47th
Congressional District
13,559 9,231 68.1 3488 4595
Historical 2010 - 34th Senate
District
16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701
Historical 2010 - 65th
Assembly District
79 47 59.5 16 23
Historical 2010 - 72nd
Assembly District
16,761 11,473 68.5 4418 5678
Historical 2010 - State Board of
Equalization (4th District)
16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701
Historical 2010 - 1st
Supervisorial District
16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701
23 12/03/2024 11:41 AM Page 1166District Results Report - November 05, 2024 CITY OF GARDEN GROVE Member, City Council, District 2
Grand Totals
District
Registration
Ballots Cast
Turnout (%)
JOHN RAMIREZ
PHILLIP NGUYEN
Historical 2010 - County Board
of Education Trustee Area 1
16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701
Proposition 2 16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701
Proposition 3 16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701
Proposition 4 16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701
Proposition 5 16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701
Proposition 6 16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701
Proposition 32 16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701
Proposition 33 16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701
Proposition 34 16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701
Proposition 35 16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701
Proposition 36 16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701
United States Senator
Partial/Unexpired Term
16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701
United States Senator 16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701
President 16,840 11,520 68.4 4434 5701
Vote Center Totals 16,840 2,780 16.5 1,152 1,180
Vote by Mail Totals 16,840 8,740 51.9 3,282 4,521
Grand Totals 16,840 11,520 68.4 4,434 5,701
24 12/03/2024 11:41 AM Page 1168District Results Report - November 05, 2024 CITY OF GARDEN GROVE Member, City Council, District 5
Vote Center Totals
District
Registration
Ballots Cast
Turnout (%)
SANDY L. THOMAS
YESENIA MUNETON
MARIYAN BAHADARAKHANN
Orange County 15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
Orange County 15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
45th Congressional District 15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328 34th Senate District 6,406 1,002 15.6 254 454 159
36th Senate District 8,940 1,565 17.5 463 672 169
70th Assembly District 15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
1st Supervisorial District 10,185 1,747 17.2 529 736 208 2nd Supervisorial District 5,161 820 15.9 188 390 120
Garden Grove 15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
Garden Grove Council District 5 15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328 State Board of Equalization
(4th District)
15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
4th District Court of Appeal 15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328 County Board of Education
Trustee Area 1
6,406 1,002 15.6 254 454 159
County Board of Education
Trustee Area 4
8,940 1,565 17.5 463 672 169
Rancho Santiago Community
College District
15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
Rancho Santiago Community
College District Trustee Area 4
12,012 2,095 17.4 599 915 261
Rancho Santiago Community
College District Trustee Area 5
3,334 472 14.2 118 211 67
Garden Grove Unified School
District
15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 2
9,464 1,656 17.5 485 719 205
Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 3
5,882 911 15.5 232 407 123
Municipal Water District of
Orange County
15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
Municipal Water District of
Orange County Division 2
15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
Orange County Water District 15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328 Orange County Water District
Division 1
15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
Historical 2010 - 46th
Congressional District
10,010 1,629 16.3 454 715 224
Historical 2010 - 47th
Congressional District
5,336 938 17.6 263 411 104
Historical 2010 - 34th Senate
District
15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
Historical 2010 - 69th
Assembly District
6,406 1,002 15.6 254 454 159
Historical 2010 - 72nd
Assembly District
8,940 1,565 17.5 463 672 169
Historical 2010 - State Board of
Equalization (4th District)
15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
Historical 2010 - 1st
Supervisorial District
15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
Historical 2010 - County Board
of Education Trustee Area 1
15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
Proposition 2 15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
Proposition 3 15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
Proposition 4 15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
Proposition 5 15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
Proposition 6 15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
Proposition 32 15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
Proposition 33 15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
Proposition 34 15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
Proposition 35 15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
Proposition 36 15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
United States Senator
Partial/Unexpired Term
15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
25 12/03/2024 11:41 AM Page 1169District Results Report - November 05, 2024 CITY OF GARDEN GROVE Member, City Council, District 5
Vote Center Totals
District
Registration
Ballots Cast
Turnout (%)
SANDY L. THOMAS
YESENIA MUNETON
MARIYAN BAHADARAKHANN
United States Senator 15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
President 15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
Vote Center Totals 15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
26 12/03/2024 11:41 AM Page 1170District Results Report - November 05, 2024 CITY OF GARDEN GROVE Member, City Council, District 5
Vote by Mail
Totals
District
Registration
Ballots Cast
Turnout (%)
SANDY L. THOMAS
YESENIA MUNETON
MARIYAN BAHADARAKHANN
Orange County 15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830
Orange County 15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830
45th Congressional District 15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830 34th Senate District 6,406 3,259 50.9 963 1554 377
36th Senate District 8,940 4,451 49.8 1524 1983 453
70th Assembly District 15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830
1st Supervisorial District 10,185 5,123 50.3 1731 2305 527 2nd Supervisorial District 5,161 2,587 50.1 756 1232 303 Garden Grove 15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830
Garden Grove Council District 5 15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830 State Board of Equalization
(4th District)
15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830
4th District Court of Appeal 15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830 County Board of Education
Trustee Area 1
6,406 3,259 50.9 963 1554 377
County Board of Education
Trustee Area 4
8,940 4,451 49.8 1524 1983 453
Rancho Santiago Community
College District
15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830
Rancho Santiago Community
College District Trustee Area 4
12,012 5,916 49.3 1944 2703 622
Rancho Santiago Community
College District Trustee Area 5
3,334 1,794 53.8 543 834 208
Garden Grove Unified School
District
15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830
Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 2
9,464 4,696 49.6 1533 2168 484
Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 3
5,882 3,014 51.2 954 1369 346
Municipal Water District of
Orange County
15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830
Municipal Water District of
Orange County Division 2
15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830
Orange County Water District 15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830 Orange County Water District
Division 1
15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830
Historical 2010 - 46th
Congressional District
10,010 5,081 50.8 1635 2361 545
Historical 2010 - 47th
Congressional District
5,336 2,629 49.3 852 1176 285
Historical 2010 - 34th Senate
District
15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830
Historical 2010 - 69th
Assembly District
6,406 3,259 50.9 963 1554 377
Historical 2010 - 72nd
Assembly District
8,940 4,451 49.8 1524 1983 453
Historical 2010 - State Board of
Equalization (4th District)
15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830
Historical 2010 - 1st
Supervisorial District
15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830
Historical 2010 - County Board
of Education Trustee Area 1
15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830
Proposition 2 15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830
Proposition 3 15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830
Proposition 4 15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830
Proposition 5 15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830
Proposition 6 15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830
Proposition 32 15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830
Proposition 33 15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830
Proposition 34 15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830
Proposition 35 15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830
Proposition 36 15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830
United States Senator
Partial/Unexpired Term
15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830
27 12/03/2024 11:41 AM Page 1171District Results Report - November 05, 2024 CITY OF GARDEN GROVE Member, City Council, District 5
Vote by Mail
Totals
District
Registration
Ballots Cast
Turnout (%)
SANDY L. THOMAS
YESENIA MUNETON
MARIYAN BAHADARAKHANN
United States Senator 15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830
President 15,346 7,710 50.2 2487 3537 830
Vote by Mail Totals 15,346 7,710 50.2 2,487 3,537 830
28 12/03/2024 11:41 AM Page 1172District Results Report - November 05, 2024 CITY OF GARDEN GROVE Member, City Council, District 5
Grand Totals
District
Registration
Ballots Cast
Turnout (%)
SANDY L. THOMAS
YESENIA MUNETON
MARIYAN BAHADARAKHANN
Orange County 15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158
Orange County 15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158
45th Congressional District 15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158 34th Senate District 6,406 4,261 66.5 1217 2008 536
36th Senate District 8,940 6,016 67.3 1987 2655 622
70th Assembly District 15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158 1st Supervisorial District 10,185 6,870 67.5 2260 3041 735 2nd Supervisorial District 5,161 3,407 66.0 944 1622 423 Garden Grove 15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158
Garden Grove Council District 5 15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158 State Board of Equalization
(4th District)
15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158
4th District Court of Appeal 15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158 County Board of Education
Trustee Area 1
6,406 4,261 66.5 1217 2008 536
County Board of Education
Trustee Area 4
8,940 6,016 67.3 1987 2655 622
Rancho Santiago Community
College District
15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158
Rancho Santiago Community
College District Trustee Area 4
12,012 8,011 66.7 2543 3618 883
Rancho Santiago Community
College District Trustee Area 5
3,334 2,266 68.0 661 1045 275
Garden Grove Unified School
District
15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158
Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 2
9,464 6,352 67.1 2018 2887 689
Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 3
5,882 3,925 66.7 1186 1776 469
Municipal Water District of
Orange County
15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158
Municipal Water District of
Orange County Division 2
15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158
Orange County Water District 15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158 Orange County Water District
Division 1
15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158
Historical 2010 - 46th
Congressional District
10,010 6,710 67.0 2089 3076 769
Historical 2010 - 47th
Congressional District
5,336 3,567 66.8 1115 1587 389
Historical 2010 - 34th Senate
District
15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158
Historical 2010 - 69th
Assembly District
6,406 4,261 66.5 1217 2008 536
Historical 2010 - 72nd
Assembly District
8,940 6,016 67.3 1987 2655 622
Historical 2010 - State Board of
Equalization (4th District)
15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158
Historical 2010 - 1st
Supervisorial District
15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158
Historical 2010 - County Board
of Education Trustee Area 1
15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158
Proposition 2 15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158
Proposition 3 15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158
Proposition 4 15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158
Proposition 5 15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158
Proposition 6 15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158
Proposition 32 15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158
Proposition 33 15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158
Proposition 34 15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158
Proposition 35 15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158
Proposition 36 15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158
United States Senator
Partial/Unexpired Term
15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158
29 12/03/2024 11:41 AM Page 1173District Results Report - November 05, 2024 CITY OF GARDEN GROVE Member, City Council, District 5
Grand Totals
District
Registration
Ballots Cast
Turnout (%)
SANDY L. THOMAS
YESENIA MUNETON
MARIYAN BAHADARAKHANN
United States Senator 15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158 President 15,346 10,277 67.0 3204 4663 1158
Vote Center Totals 15,346 2,567 16.7 717 1,126 328
Vote by Mail Totals 15,346 7,710 50.2 2,487 3,537 830
Grand Totals 15,346 10,277 67.0 3,204 4,663 1,158
30 12/03/2024 11:41 AM Page 1175District Results Report - November 05, 2024 CITY OF GARDEN GROVE Member, City Council, District 6
Vote Center Totals
District
Registration
Ballots Cast
Turnout (%)
TRI LAM
ARIANA ARESTEGUI
Orange County 11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
Orange County 11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
45th Congressional District 11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
34th Senate District 11,216 1,559 13.9 661 668
36th Senate District 561 91 16.2 37 43
70th Assembly District 11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
1st Supervisorial District 611 68 11.1 20 34
2nd Supervisorial District 11,166 1,582 14.2 678 677
Garden Grove 11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
Garden Grove Council District 6 11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711 State Board of Equalization
(4th District)
11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
4th District Court of Appeal 11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
County Board of Education
Trustee Area 1
11,216 1,559 13.9 661 668
County Board of Education
Trustee Area 4
561 91 16.2 37 43
Rancho Santiago Community
College District
11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
Rancho Santiago Community
College District Trustee Area 4
7,912 1,088 13.8 433 508
Rancho Santiago Community
College District Trustee Area 5
3,865 562 14.5 265 203
Garden Grove Unified School
District
8,597 1,174 13.7 485 525
Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 3
8,597 1,174 13.7 485 525
Orange Unified School District 3,180 476 15.0 213 186
Orange Unified School District
Trustee Area 2
3,180 476 15.0 213 186
Municipal Water District of
Orange County
11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
Municipal Water District of
Orange County Division 2
11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
Orange County Water District 11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
Orange County Water District
Division 1
11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
Historical 2010 - 46th
Congressional District
9,684 1,348 13.9 579 572
Historical 2010 - 47th
Congressional District
2,093 302 14.4 119 139
Historical 2010 - 34th Senate
District
11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
Historical 2010 - 69th
Assembly District
10,335 1,436 13.9 619 609
Historical 2010 - 72nd
Assembly District
1,442 214 14.8 79 102
Historical 2010 - State Board of
Equalization (4th District)
11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
Historical 2010 - 1st
Supervisorial District
11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
Historical 2010 - 3rd
Supervisorial District
0 0 0.0 0 0
Historical 2010 - County Board
of Education Trustee Area 1
11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
Historical 2010 - County Board
of Education Trustee Area 3
0 0 0.0 0 0
Proposition 2 11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
Proposition 3 11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
Proposition 4 11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
Proposition 5 11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
Proposition 6 11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
Proposition 32 11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
Proposition 33 11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
31 12/03/2024 11:41 AM Page 1176District Results Report - November 05, 2024 CITY OF GARDEN GROVE Member, City Council, District 6
Vote Center Totals
District
Registration
Ballots Cast
Turnout (%)
TRI LAM
ARIANA ARESTEGUI
Proposition 34 11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
Proposition 35 11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
Proposition 36 11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
United States Senator
Partial/Unexpired Term
11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
United States Senator 11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
President 11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
Vote Center Totals 11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
32 12/03/2024 11:41 AM Page 1177District Results Report - November 05, 2024 CITY OF GARDEN GROVE Member, City Council, District 6
Vote by Mail
Totals
District
Registration
Ballots Cast
Turnout (%)
TRI LAM
ARIANA ARESTEGUI
Orange County 11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648
Orange County 11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648
45th Congressional District 11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648 34th Senate District 11,216 5,456 48.6 2312 2559
36th Senate District 561 236 42.1 120 89
70th Assembly District 11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648
1st Supervisorial District 611 303 49.6 151 131
2nd Supervisorial District 11,166 5,389 48.3 2281 2517
Garden Grove 11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648
Garden Grove Council District 6 11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648 State Board of Equalization
(4th District)
11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648
4th District Court of Appeal 11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648 County Board of Education
Trustee Area 1
11,216 5,456 48.6 2312 2559
County Board of Education
Trustee Area 4
561 236 42.1 120 89
Rancho Santiago Community
College District
11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648
Rancho Santiago Community
College District Trustee Area 4
7,912 3,828 48.4 1635 1856
Rancho Santiago Community
College District Trustee Area 5
3,865 1,864 48.2 797 792
Garden Grove Unified School
District
8,597 4,182 48.6 1796 2006
Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 3
8,597 4,182 48.6 1796 2006
Orange Unified School District 3,180 1,510 47.5 636 642 Orange Unified School District
Trustee Area 2
3,180 1,510 47.5 636 642
Municipal Water District of
Orange County
11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648
Municipal Water District of
Orange County Division 2
11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648
Orange County Water District 11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648 Orange County Water District
Division 1
11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648
Historical 2010 - 46th
Congressional District
9,684 4,724 48.8 1981 2208
Historical 2010 - 47th
Congressional District
2,093 968 46.2 451 440
Historical 2010 - 34th Senate
District
11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648
Historical 2010 - 69th
Assembly District
10,335 5,047 48.8 2125 2366
Historical 2010 - 72nd
Assembly District
1,442 645 44.7 307 282
Historical 2010 - State Board of
Equalization (4th District)
11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648
Historical 2010 - 1st
Supervisorial District
11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648
Historical 2010 - 3rd
Supervisorial District
0 0 0.0 0 0
Historical 2010 - County Board
of Education Trustee Area 1
11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648
Historical 2010 - County Board
of Education Trustee Area 3
0 0 0.0 0 0
Proposition 2 11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648
Proposition 3 11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648
Proposition 4 11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648
Proposition 5 11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648
Proposition 6 11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648
Proposition 32 11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648
Proposition 33 11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648
33 12/03/2024 11:41 AM Page 1178District Results Report - November 05, 2024 CITY OF GARDEN GROVE Member, City Council, District 6
Vote by Mail
Totals
District
Registration
Ballots Cast
Turnout (%)
TRI LAM
ARIANA ARESTEGUI
Proposition 34 11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648
Proposition 35 11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648
Proposition 36 11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648
United States Senator
Partial/Unexpired Term
11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648
United States Senator 11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648
President 11,777 5,692 48.3 2432 2648
Vote by Mail Totals 11,777 5,692 48.3 2,432 2,648
34 12/03/2024 11:41 AM Page 1179District Results Report - November 05, 2024 CITY OF GARDEN GROVE Member, City Council, District 6
Grand Totals
District
Registration
Ballots Cast
Turnout (%)
TRI LAM
ARIANA ARESTEGUI
Orange County 11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359
Orange County 11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359
45th Congressional District 11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359 34th Senate District 11,216 7,015 62.5 2973 3227
36th Senate District 561 327 58.3 157 132
70th Assembly District 11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359
1st Supervisorial District 611 371 60.7 171 165
2nd Supervisorial District 11,166 6,971 62.4 2959 3194
Garden Grove 11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359
Garden Grove Council District 6 11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359 State Board of Equalization
(4th District)
11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359
4th District Court of Appeal 11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359 County Board of Education
Trustee Area 1
11,216 7,015 62.5 2973 3227
County Board of Education
Trustee Area 4
561 327 58.3 157 132
Rancho Santiago Community
College District
11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359
Rancho Santiago Community
College District Trustee Area 4
7,912 4,916 62.1 2068 2364
Rancho Santiago Community
College District Trustee Area 5
3,865 2,426 62.8 1062 995
Garden Grove Unified School
District
8,597 5,356 62.3 2281 2531
Garden Grove Unified School
District Trustee Area 3
8,597 5,356 62.3 2281 2531
Orange Unified School District 3,180 1,986 62.5 849 828 Orange Unified School District
Trustee Area 2
3,180 1,986 62.5 849 828
Municipal Water District of
Orange County
11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359
Municipal Water District of
Orange County Division 2
11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359
Orange County Water District 11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359 Orange County Water District
Division 1
11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359
Historical 2010 - 46th
Congressional District
9,684 6,072 62.7 2560 2780
Historical 2010 - 47th
Congressional District
2,093 1,270 60.7 570 579
Historical 2010 - 34th Senate
District
11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359
Historical 2010 - 69th
Assembly District
10,335 6,483 62.7 2744 2975
Historical 2010 - 72nd
Assembly District
1,442 859 59.6 386 384
Historical 2010 - State Board of
Equalization (4th District)
11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359
Historical 2010 - 1st
Supervisorial District
11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359
Historical 2010 - 3rd
Supervisorial District
0 0 0.0 0 0
Historical 2010 - County Board
of Education Trustee Area 1
11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359
Historical 2010 - County Board
of Education Trustee Area 3
0 0 0.0 0 0
Proposition 2 11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359
Proposition 3 11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359
Proposition 4 11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359
Proposition 5 11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359
Proposition 6 11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359
Proposition 32 11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359
Proposition 33 11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359
35 12/03/2024 11:41 AM Page 1180District Results Report - November 05, 2024 CITY OF GARDEN GROVE Member, City Council, District 6
Grand Totals
District
Registration
Ballots Cast
Turnout (%)
TRI LAM
ARIANA ARESTEGUI
Proposition 34 11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359
Proposition 35 11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359
Proposition 36 11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359
United States Senator
Partial/Unexpired Term
11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359
United States Senator 11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359
President 11,777 7,342 62.3 3130 3359
Vote Center Totals 11,777 1,650 14.0 698 711
Vote by Mail Totals 11,777 5,692 48.3 2,432 2,648
Grand Totals 11,777 7,342 62.3 3,130 3,359
36 Item 495/2024
Final
City of Garden Grove
INTER-DEPARTMENT MEMORANDUM
To:
Lisa L. Kim From: William E. Murray
Dept:
City Manager Dept: Public Works
Date: 12/10/2024
Subject: Adoption of a Resolution for the Fiscal Year 2023-24 Renewed Measure M (M2) Annual Expenditure Report. (Action Item)
OBJECTIVE
For the City Council to adopt a Resolution for Fiscal Year 2023-24 Renewed Measure M (M2) Annual Expenditure Report as required by the Local Transportation Authority Ordinance No. 3.
BACKGROUND
Per M2, each local agency is required to submit approved documentation to the Orange County Transportation Authority to maintain M2 eligibility for Local Fair Share appropriations and competitive grant funding.
DISCUSSION
Per Local Transportation Authority Ordinance No. 3, local jurisdictions are required to adopt an Annual Expenditure Report to account for beginning/endi ng balances, Local Fair Share distributions, transportation facilities fees, and Maintenance of Effort expenditures. The Expenditure Report has been prepared by the Finance Department and has been signed and certified by the Finance Director.
FINANCIAL IMPACT
There is no impact to the General Fund. The attached report is necessary to receive M2 revenues and competitive grant funding.
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended that the City Council:
Adopt the attached Resolution adopting the Fiscal Year 2023 -24 Renewed Measure M (M2) Annual Expenditure Report; and
37 Item 495/2024
Authorize the Finance Director to submit the Renewed Measure M (M2) Annual Expenditure Report to the Orange County Transportation Authority.
By: Alexa Viramontes, Sr. Administrative Analyst
ATTACHMENT(S)
1. Resolution
2. Expenditure Report
38 [EXPENDITURE REPORT RESOLUTION]
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF GARDEN GROVE CONCERNING THE MEASURE M2 (M2) EXPENDITURE REPORT FOR
THE CITY OF GARDEN GROVE.
WHEREAS, local jurisdictions are required to meet eligibility requirements and submit eligibility verification packages to the Orange County Transportation Authority (OCTA) in order to remain eligible to receive M2 funds; and
WHEREAS, local jurisdictions are required to adopt an annual M2 Expenditure Report as part of one of the eligibility requirements; and
WHEREAS, local jurisdictions ar e required to account for Net Revenues, developer/traffic impact fees, and funds expended by local jurisdic tion in the M2 Expenditure Report that satisfy the Maintenance of Effort requirements; and
WHEREAS, the M2 Expenditure Report shall include all Net Revenue fund balances, interest earned and expenditures identified by type and program or project; and WHEREAS, the M2 Expenditure Report must be adopted and submitted to the OCTA each year within six months of the end of the local jurisdiction’s fiscal year to be eligible to receive Net Revenues as part of M2.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council for the City of Garden Grove does hereby inform OCTA that:
a) The M2 Expenditure Report is in conformance with the template provided in the Measure M2 Eligibility Guidelines and accounts fo r Net Revenues including interest earned, expenditures during the fiscal year, and balances at the end of fiscal year. b) The M2 Expenditure Report is hereby adopted by the City of Garden Grove. c) The City of Garden Grove Finance Director is hereby authorized to sign and submit the M2 Expenditure Report to OCTA for the fiscal year ending 2024.
PASSED, APPROVED, AND ADOPTED THIS ______ day of _______________, 2024. 39 City of Garden Grove
M2 Expenditure Report
Fiscal Year Ended June 30, 2024
Beginning and Ending Balances
Schedule 1
Line
No. Amount Interest
A-M Freeway Projects 1 - $ - $ O Regional Capacity Program (RCP) 2 (820,681) $ - $ P Regional Traffic Signal Synchronization Program (RTSSP) 3 - $ Q Local Fair Share 4 3,370,272 $ - $
R High Frequency Metrolink Service 5 - $
S Transit Extensions to Metrolink 6 - $
T Convert Metrolink Station(s) to Regional Gateways that connect Orange County with High-Speed Rail Systems 7- $ U Senior Mobility Program or Senior Non-Emergency Medical Program 8 559,667$ - $
V Community Based Transit/Circulators 9 - $
W Safe Transit Stops 10 - $
X Environmental Cleanup Program (Water Quality) 11 - $
Other* 12 1,464,544 $ - $
13 4,573,802$ - $
Monies Made Available During Fiscal Year 14 4,789,148 $ 124,316 $ 15 9,362,950$ 124,316 $
Expenditures During Fiscal Year 16 2,396,459 $ 124,316 $ A-M Freeway Projects 17 - $ - $ O Regional Capacity Program (RCP) 18 (88,823) $ - $ P Regional Traffic Signal Synchronization Program (RTSSP) 19 - $ - $ Q Local Fair Share 20 4,688,816 $ - $ R High Frequency Metrolink Service 21 - $ - $ S Transit Extensions to Metrolink 22 - $ - $ T Convert Metrolink Station(s) to Regional Gateways that connect Orange County with High-Speed Rail Systems 23 - $ - $ U Senior Mobility Program or Senior Non-Emergency Medical Program 24 626,247$ - $
V Community Based Transit/Circulators 25 - $ - $ W Safe Transit Stops 26 - $ - $ X Environmental Cleanup Program (Water Quality) 27 - $ - $ Other* 28 1,740,250 $ - $
Description
Total Monies Available (Sum Lines 13 & 14)
* In previous reports, Project U included the City's match/share so the ending balance for the program was understated by $174,057. We have made the adjustment in line 8.
* Please provide a specific description: This pertains to Traffic Mitigation Fees net of expenditures related to the street lights and traffic signal improvements.
Balances at End of Fiscal Year
Balances at Beginning of Fiscal Year
Balances at Beginning of Fiscal Year
40 City of Garden Grove M2 Expenditure Report
Fiscal Year Ended June 30, 2024
Sources and Uses
Schedule 2
Line
No. Amount Interest
A-M Freeway Projects 1 - $ - $ O Regional Capacity Program (RCP) 2 731,858 $ - $ P Regional Traffic Signal Synchronization Program (RTSSP) 3 - $ - $ Q Local Fair Share 4 3,533,554 $ 75,256 $
R High Frequency Metrolink Service 5 - $ - $ S Transit Extensions to Metrolink 6 - $ - $ T Convert Metrolink Station(s) to Regional Gateways that connect Orange County with High-Speed Rail Systems 7- $ - $ U Senior Mobility Program or Senior Non-Emergency Medical Program 8 226,421 $ 4,268 $ V Community Based Transit/Circulators 9 - $ - $ W Safe Transit Stops 10 - $ - $ X Environmental Cleanup Program (Water Quality) 11 - $ - $ Other* 12 297,314 $ 44,791 $
13 4,789,148$ 124,316 $
A-M Freeway Projects 14 - $ - $ O Regional Capacity Program (RCP) 15 - $ - $ P Regional Traffic Signal Synchronization Program (RTSSP) 16 - $ - $ Q Local Fair Share 17 2,215,010 $ 75,256 $
R High Frequency Metrolink Service 18 - $ - $ S Transit Extensions to Metrolink 19 - $ - $ T Convert Metrolink Station(s) to Regional Gateways that connect Orange County with High-Speed Rail Systems 20 - $ - $ U Senior Mobility Program or Senior Non-Emergency Medical Program 21 159,841 $ 4,268 $ V Community Based Transit/Circulators 22 - $ - $ W Safe Transit Stops 23 - $ - $ X Environmental Cleanup Program (Water Quality) 24 - $ - $ Other* 25 21,608 $ 44,791 $
26 2,396,459$ 124,316 $
27 2,392,689$ - $
* Please provide a specific description: Revenue received pertains to Traffic Mitigations Fees (Fund 211) collected.
Expenditures were related to the street lights and traffic signal improvements.
TOTAL BALANCE (Subtract line 26 from 13)
TOTAL EXPENDITURES (Sum lines 14 to 25)
Description
Revenues:
TOTAL REVENUES (Sum lines 1 to 12)
Expenditures:
41 City of Garden Grove
M2 Expenditure Report
Fiscal Year Ended June 30, 2024
Streets and Roads Detailed Use of Funds
Schedule 3
Line
No. MOE Developer /
Impact Fees+ O O
Interest P P
Interest Q Q
Interest X X
Interest
Other
M22
Other
M2
Interest
Other* TOTAL
1 2,551,477$ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ 2,551,477$ New Street Construction 2 - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ Street Reconstruction 3 11,572,961 $ - $ - $ - $ - $ 2,215,010$ 75,256 $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ 13,863,227$ Signals, Safety Devices, & Street Lights 4 - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ Pedestrian Ways & Bikepaths 5 - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ Storm Drains 6 - $ -$ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ Storm Damage 7 - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ 8 11,572,961$ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ 2,215,010$ 75,256 $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ 13,863,227$ Right of Way Acquisition 9 - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ 10 11,572,961$ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ 2,215,010$ 75,256 $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ 13,863,227$ Patching 11 - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ -$ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ Overlay & Sealing 12 - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ Street Lights & Traffic Signals 13 404,406 $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ 404,406 $ Storm Damage 14 - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ Other Street Purpose Maintenance 15 3,833,455 $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ 3,833,455$ 16 4,237,861$ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ 4,237,861$ 17 - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ 159,841$ 4,268 $ 66,400 $ 230,508 $ 18 18,362,299$ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ 2,215,010$ 75,256 $ - $ - $ 159,841$ 4,268 $ 66,400 $ 20,883,074$ 19 1 Includes direct charges for staff time Legend
2 Other M2 includes A-M, R,S,T,U,V, and W Project
+ Transportation related only A-M
* Please provide a specific description O
P
Q
R
S
T
U
V
W
X
Other
Total Maintenance1
GRAND TOTALS (Sum Lines 1, 10, 16, 17)
Type of Expenditure
Indirect and/or Overhead
Construction & Right-of-Way
Total Construction1
Total Construction & Right-of-Way
Maintenance
Environmental Cleanup Program (Water Quality)
Senior Mobility Program or Senior Non-Emergency Medical Program Community Based Transit/Circulators
Convert Metrolink Station(s) to Regional Gateways that connect Orange County with High-Speed Rail Systems
Freeway Projects
Regional Capacity Program (RCP)
Local Fair Share
Regional Traffic Signal Synchronization Program (RTSSP) Finance Director Confirmation
Any California State Constitution Article XIX streets and road eligible expenditure may be “counted” in local jurisdictions’ calculation of MOE if the activity is supported (funded) by a local jurisdictions’ discretionary funds (e.g. general fund).
The California State Controller also provides useful information on Article XIX and the Streets and Highways Code eligible expenditures in its “Guidelines Relating to Gas Tax Expenditures for Cities and Counties”. I have reviewed and am aware of these guidelines and their applicability in calculating and reporting on Maintenance of Effort expenditures.
Finance Director initial: PS
Description
Transit Extensions to Metrolink
Safe Transit Stops
High Frequency Metrolink Service
42 City of Garden Grove
M2 Expenditure Report
Fiscal Year Ended June 30, 2024
Local Fair Share Project List
Schedule 4
PROJECT NAME AMOUNT EXPENDED
CIP-22-STREET REHAB 950 $
CIP-ACACIA STREET IMPROVEMENT 1,276,731 $
CIP-CHAP REHAB SPRINDAL WESTRN 514,900 $
CIP-HAZARD REHABILITATION 199,820 $
CIP-SLURRY SEAL PROJECTS 287,865 $
CIP-CHAPMAN REHAB LANDSCP MAINT 10,000 $
2,290,266$
43 /0/1/2/3/i255/5/6/i255/7/8/9/10/11/12/i255/7/9/5/13/11/i255 /14/15/16/17/18/19/20/21/22/i255/24/18/16/22/i255 /25/26/i255/28/29/30/31/32/33/34/35/36/37/31/i255/38/31/30/39/40/35/i255 /41/42/43/44/45/46/i255/48/49/45/50/i255/51/52/53/49/53/i255/54/55/52/49/i255/56/57/58/i255/59/57/59/60/i255 /61/i255/62/11/9/11/63/3/i255/64/11/9/2/1/6/3/i255/2/62/8/2/65/i255 /66/i255/68/69/69/i255/2/62/11/i255/1/70/6/5/9/71/8/2/1/5/70/i255/8/2/2/8/64/62/11/10/i255/62/11/9/11/72/12/i255/8/12/10/i255/1/12/64/69/73/10/11/10/i255/1/12/i255/74/64/62/11/10/73/75/11/74/i255/76/i255/2/62/9/5/73/77/62/i255/78/i255/1/74/i255/2/9/73/11/i255/8/12/10/i255/8/64/64/73/9/8/2/11/i255/2/5/i255/2/62/11/i255/63/11/74/2/i255/5/6/i255 /71/3/i255/79/12/5/80/69/11/10/77/11/81/i255
/82/i255/84/62/11/i255/1/12/2/11/9/11/74/2/i255/11/8/9/12/11/10/i255/5/12/i255/85/11/2/i255/86/11/13/11/70/73/11/74/i255/8/87/69/5/64/8/2/11/10/i255/88/73/9/74/73/8/12/2/i255/2/5/i255/2/62/11/i255/89/9/10/1/12/8/12/64/11/i255/74/62/8/69/69/i255/63/11/i255/11/90/88/11/12/10/11/10/i255/5/70/69/3/i255/6/5/9/i255/2/62/5/74/11/i255 /88/73/9/88/5/74/11/74/i255/6/5/9/i255/80/62/1/64/62/i255/2/62/11/i255/85/11/2/i255/86/11/13/11/12/73/11/74/i255/80/11/9/11/i255/8/69/91/5/64/8/2/11/10/81/i255 /92/i255/84/62/11/i255/0/72/2/3/i255/5/6/i255/7/8/9/10/11/70/i255/7/9/5/13/11/i255/72/74/i255/8/80/8/9/11/i255/5/6/i255/2/62/11/i255/93/2/8/2/11/i255/0/5/12/2/9/5/69/69/11/9/94/74/i255/95/7/73/1/10/11/69/1/12/11/74/i255/86/11/96/8/2/1/12/77/i255/2/5/i255/7/8/74/i255/84/8/90/i255/97/90/88/11/12/10/1/2/73/9/11/74/i255/6/5/9/i255 /0/72/2/1/11/74/i255/8/12/10/i255/0/5/73/12/2/98/11/74/99/100/i255/80/62/98/64/62/i255/98/74/i255/8/i255/77/73/1/10/11/i255/6/5/9/i255/10/11/2/11/9/71/1/12/1/12/77/i255/101/89/97/i255/97/90/88/11/12/10/72/2/73/9/11/74/i255/6/5/9/i255/101/102/i255/97/69/98/77/72/63/1/69/98/2/3/i255/88/73/9/88/5/74/11/74/81/i255 /103/84/62/11/i255/0/1/2/3/104/74/i255/97/90/88/11/70/10/72/2/73/9/11/i255/86/11/88/5/9/2/i255/1/74/i255/72/12/i255/64/5/71/88/96/72/8/12/64/11/i255/80/98/2/62/i255/10/1/9/11/64/2/72/5/12/i255/88/9/5/13/1/10/11/10/i255/1/12/i255/2/62/11/i255/93/2/8/2/11/i255/0/5/12/2/9/5/69/69/11/9/94/74/i255/95/7/73/72/10/11/69/98/12/11/74/i255 /86/11/69/8/2/1/12/77/i255/2/5/i255/7/8/74/i255/84/8/90/i255/97/90/88/11/12/10/72/2/73/9/11/74/i255/6/5/9/i255/0/1/2/72/11/74/i255/8/12/10/i255/0/5/73/12/2/1/11/74/81/99/i255/8/70/10/i255 /105/i255/106/62/11/i255/0/1/2/3/i255/5/6/i255/7/8/9/10/11/12/i255/7/9/5/13/11/i255/62/8/74/i255/11/90/88/11/12/10/11/10/i255/1/70/i255/2/62/72/74/i255/6/1/74/64/8/69/i255/3/11/8/9/i255/8/12/i255/8/71/5/73/12/2/i255/5/6/i255/75/5/64/8/96/i255/10/1/74/64/9/11/2/1/5/70/8/9/3/i255/6/73/70/10/74/i255/6/5/9/i255/74/2/9/11/11/2/74/i255 /8/12/10/i255/9/5/8/10/74/i255/88/73/9/88/5/74/11/74/i255/8/2/i255/69/11/8/74/2/i255/11/107/73/8/69/i255/2/5/i255/5/9/i255/11/90/64/11/11/10/98/12/77/i255/2/62/11/i255/108/109/i255/102/110/102/111/112/102/78/i255/101/89/97/i255/63/11/12/64/62/71/8/113/79/i255/10/5/96/69/8/9/i255/8/71/5/73/12/2/114/114 /115/i255
/117/8/2/9/72/64/72/8/i255/93/5/12/77/i255
/118/1/9/11/64/2/5/9/i255/5/6/i255/108/72/12/8/70/64/11/i255/119/117/9/1/12/2/i255/85/8/71/11/120/i255 /118/8/2/11/i255 /121/77/70/8/2/73/9/11/i255
/122/122/123/73/113/72/124/10/72/125/126/72/5/70/124/i255/127/113/128/i255/128/70/125/5/73/9/127/129/128/10/i255/126/5/i255/124/73/63/71/98/126/i255/130/89/131/i255/128/69/98/129/72/63/96/128/i255/128/90/88/128/70/10/72/126/73/9/128/124/i255/62/98/129/62/128/113/i255/126/62/127/70/i255/126/62/128/1/113/i255/130/89/131/i255/63/128/70/125/62/71/127/113/79/132/i255/124/5/i255/126/62/127/126/i255 /124/62/5/73/96/10/i255/125/128/133/127/72/70/i255/128/90/88/128/70/124/128/124/i255/63/128/i255/113/73/69/128/10/i255/98/12/128/96/72/129/72/63/96/128/i255/10/73/134/98/70/129/i255/127/70/i255/130/89/131/i255/127/73/10/72/126/135/i255/126/62/128/i255/69/5/125/127/69/i255/136/73/113/1/124/10/72/125/126/98/5/70/i255/124/126/98/69/96/i255/62/127/124/i255/124/73/137/98/125/98/128/70/126/i255/130/89/131/i255 /128/90/88/128/70/10/72/126/73/113/128/124/i255/126/5/i255/10/128/71/5/70/124/126/113/127/126/128/i255/125/5/70/126/72/70/73/128/10/i255/127/125/62/72/128/13/128/71/128/70/126/i255/5/138/i255/126/62/128/i255/130/89/131/i255/63/128/70/125/62/71/127/9/79/139/i255 44 Item 517/2024
Final
City of Garden Grove
INTER-DEPARTMENT MEMORANDUM
To:
Lisa L. Kim From: Matthew West
Dept:
City Manager Dept: City Manager
Date: 12/10/2024
Subject: Adoption of a Resolution to appoint the City Treasurer and Deputy City Treasurer. (Action Item)
OBJECTIVE
To obtain City Council approval of a resolution appointing the City Treasurer and Deputy City Treasurer.
BACKGROUND
In September 11, 2018, the City Council adopted Resolution No. 9525 -18 appointing Laura J. Stover, Human Resources Director, and Scott C. Stiles, City Manager, as the City Treasurer and Interim Deputy City Treasurer.
DISCUSSION
Ms. Stover is retiring at the end of the month and Mr. Stiles is no longer employed by the City. It is therefore necessary to make new appointments to the positions of City Treasurer and Deputy City Treasurer. It is recommended that Matt West, Assistant City Manager be appointed City Treasurer and that Ursula Luna-Reynosa, Assistant City Manager/Economic Development and Housing Director, be appointed Deputy City Treasurer.
Many of the duties of the City Treasurer are performed under the jurisdiction of the City’s Finance Department, with the City Treasurer primarily responsible for the co-signing of checks and warrants, as well as the reconciliation of the bank statements. It is prudent that the City continue to maintain a separate treasurer function that provides a financial che cks and balance system.
FINANCIAL IMPACT
None.
45 Item 517/2024
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended that the City Council:
Adopt the attached Resolution appointing the City Treasurer and Deputy City Treasurer.
ATTACHMENT(S)
1. Resolution
46 GARDEN GROVE CITY COUNCIL
RESOLUTION NO. ____
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF GARDEN GROVE REPEALING RESOLUTION NO. 9525-18 AND APPOINTING THE CITY TREASURER
AND DEPUTY CITY TREASURER
THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF GARD EN GROVE, CALIFORNIA, DOES RESOLVE AS FOLLOWS:
1. That Resolution No. 9525-18 is hereby repealed.
2. That Matt West, Assistant City Manager, is hereby appointed to serve as City Treasurer.
3. That Ursula Luna-Reynosa, Assistant City Manager/Economic Development and Housing Director, is hereby appointed to serve as Deputy City Treasurer.
Adopted this 10
th day of December 2024.
47 Item 502/2024
Final
City of Garden Grove
INTER-DEPARTMENT MEMORANDUM
To:
Lisa L. Kim From: Chief El-Farra
Dept:
City Manager Dept: Police
Date: 12/10/2024
Subject: Adoption of a Resolution to approve a 180-day wait period exemption to hire a retired annuitant. (Action Item)
OBJECTIVE
To obtain City Council approval for a resolution exempting the 180-day wait period to hire a retired annuitant.
BACKGROUND
In 2021, the Garden Grove Police Department purchased and began building the Axon Public Safety Software Suite. It was intended to replace an older software system acquired in 2014 that did not offer full integration with all the necessary software programs u tilized by the Police Department. The implementation of the Axon software suite was anticipated to be completed by 2024. However, unforeseen delays, software limitations, and ongoing schedule adjustments by the vendor have resulted in an extended timeline for completion.
CalPERS requires a 180-day waiting period to hire a retired annuitant, except when necessary to fill a critically needed position. Since the Axon Public Safety Software Suite implementation project requires specialized expertise, CalPERS allows an exemption to the 180 -day waiting period and requires a resolution by the governing body.
DISCUSSION
Rebecca Meeks has served as the lead on this critical software implementation project from its inception, providing invaluable expertise and le adership in the transition process . The Police Department recognizes the unique and irreplaceable knowledge and experience that Ms. Meeks brings to this project, making her continued involvement essential for the successful completion of the software implementation.
Ms. Meeks retired on November 22, 2024, and the Police Department desires to retain her services on a post-retirement basis as extra help for her specialized skills. She will oversee the final stages of the Axon software implementation, coordinating with Axon, troubleshooting 48 Item 502/2024
any arising issues, and ensuring the project is completed in accordance with the approved contract.
The offer letter to Ms. Meeks for the position of Senior Program Specialist is attached. She would be hired to a position designated for a Retired Annuitant with a duration of three years from her starting date. As a retired annuitant, Ms. Meeks will rec eive an hourly wage comparable to the classification of Senior Program Specialist and will not receive any benefits beyond the hourly rate.
FINANCIAL IMPACT
Funding for this part -time position is included in the Police Department’s FY 2024 -2025 budget, utilizing cost savings from vacant un-benefitted part-time positions. There will be no impact to the General Fund.
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended that the City Council:
Adopt the attached Resolution that provides an exemption for the required 180 -day waiting period to hire a retired annuitant.
Prepared By: Lieutenant Vincente Vaicaro
ATTACHMENT(S)
1. Resolution for 180-Day Wait Period Exemption
2. Offer Letter
49 GARDEN GROVE CITY COUNCIL
RESOLUTION NO. ####
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF GARDEN GROVE APPROVING A 180-DAY WAIT PERIOD EXCEPTION PURSUANT TO GOVERNMENT CODE SECTIONS 7522.56 AND 21224
WHEREAS, in compliance with Government Code Section 7522.56 the Garden Grove City Council must provide CalPERS this Certification Resolution when hiring a retiree before 180 days have passed since his retirement date; and
WHEREAS, Rebecca Meeks retired from the City of Garden Grove in the position of Police Communications Manager, on November 22, 2024; and
WHEREAS, Section 7522.56 requires that post-retirement employment commence no earlier than 180 days after the retirement date, which is May 22, 2025, without this Certification Resolution; and
WHEREAS, Section 7522.56 provides that this exception to the 180 -day wait period shall not apply if the retiree accepts any retirement-related incentive; and
WHEREAS, the City Council, the City of Garden Grove and Rebecca Meeks certify that Rebecca Meeks has not and will not receive a Golden Handshake or any other retirement-related incentive; and
WHEREAS, the City Council hereby appoints Rebecca Meeks as an extra help retired annuitant to perform the duties of the Senior Program Specialist for the City of Garden Grove under Government Code Section 21224, effective January 6, 2025 ; and
WHEREAS, the entire employment agreement, contract or appointment document between Rebecca Meeks and the City of Garden Grove has been reviewed by this body and is attached herein; and
WHEREAS, no matters, issues, terms or conditions related to this employment and appointment have been or will be placed on a consent calendar; and
WHEREAS, the employment shall be limited t o 960 hours per fiscal year for all CalPERS employers; and
WHEREAS, the compensation paid to retirees cannot be less than the minimum nor exceed the maximum monthly base salary paid to other employees performing comparable duties, divided by 173.333 to equal the hourly rate;
WHEREAS, the maximum base salary for this position is $9,856 monthly and the hourly equivalent is $56.86, and the minimum base salary for this position is $6,671 monthly and the hourly equivalent is $38.49; and
50 Garden Grove City Council
Resolution No. 9527-18
WHEREAS, the hourly rate paid to Rebecca Meeks will be $56.86; and
WHEREAS, Rebecca Meeks has not and will not receive any other benefit, incentive, compensation in lieu of benefit or other form of compensation in addit ion to this hourly pay rate; and
WHEREAS, the City of Garden Grove Police Department purchased the Axon Public Safety Software Suite and Rebecca Meeks has served as the lead on the software implementation since its inception, which due to various unforeseen delays have yet to be completed;
THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED THAT the Garden Grove City Council hereby certifies the nature of the appointment of Rebecca Meeks as described herein and detailed in the attached appointment document and that this appointment is necessary to fill the critically needed position of Senior Program Specialist for the City of Garden Grove by January 6, 2025 , because of the irreplaceable knowledge and experience that Rebecca Meeks bring to the software implementation project, making her continued involvement essential for the successful completion of the software implementation.
51 GARDEN GROVE
CITY OF GARDEN GROVE
HUMAN RESOURCES
;'—';;
t ,-//;'',' (/p'/;
November 20, 2024
Rebecca Meeks
On File
Steve Jones
i 'il^.lll
Cindy Ngoc Tran
George S. Brietigam
John R. O'Neill
Joe DoVinh
I ! I II ] ( !i !';i^'i. i;.^ • !r 'iir i
Stephanie Klopfenstein
I -III ]] ;1 llil-i, ji -• i '!: I'i :!• I
Kim B. Nguyen-Penaloza
Dear Rebecca,
Thank you for accepting the offer as a temporary Senior Program Specialist. This letter outlines the terms of your extra help retired annuitant employment with the City of Garden Grove.
Your employment as a temporary Senior Program Specialist will start on January 6, 2025, with an anticipated end date of three years from your start date. Your wage will be Step I of Range M171 at $56.86 per hour. As a retired annuitant, you are only offered the hourly pay rate, as you are not eligible to receive any other benefit, incentive, compensation in lieu of benefits, or any other form of compensation.
Retirement contributions will not be collected or paid to you. Additionally, you may not work more than 960 hours in a fiscal year.
Please sign and return this letter to Human Resources to complete your hiring paperwork. If you should have any questions, please contact Liane Kwan in Human Resources at (714) 741-5011.
Sincerely,
JAlW H. LE
Deputy Director, Human Resources
I accept this job offer and all of the conditions listed above. '^^^-^—^ \ \ IW l/20-li{
Rebecca MeeksDate
11222 Acacia ParkwayP.O.Box 3070
ggcity.org
Garden Grove, CA 92842
52 Item 508/2024
Final
City of Garden Grove
INTER-DEPARTMENT MEMORANDUM
To:
Lisa L. Kim From: William E. Murray
Dept:
City Manager Dept: Public Works
Date: 12/10/2024
Subject: Acceptance of Project No. S-1328-A, Phase One Roof Replacement Project at the Garden Grove Amphitheater Campus, as complete. (Action Item)
OBJECTIVE
For the City Council to accept Project No. S-1328-A Phase One, Roof Replacement Project at the Garden Grove Amphitheater Campus located at 12762 Main Street as complete and authorize the City Manager to execute the Notice of Completion of Public Improvement and Work.
BACKGROUND
On June 25, 2024, City Council awarded a contract to AME Builders Inc., in the amount of $59,900 to complete the scope of work that specified replacing two (2) roofs on buildings located within the Amphitheater grounds. During the project, a third smaller roof was added to the scope of work. The cost of the additional work did not exceed the ten percent contract contingency designed to cover unforeseen conditions and work.
DISCUSSION
The contractor, AME Builders Inc., has completed phase one of the Amphitheater Roof Replacement Project in accordance with related plans, specification s and other contract documents.
FINANCIAL IMPACT
There is no financial impact to accept Project No. S -1328-A, Phase One, Roof Replacement Project at the Garden Grove Amphitheater Campus located at 12762 Main Street, as complete.
53 Item 508/2024
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended that City Council:
Accept Project No. S -1328-A, Phase One Roof Replacement Project at the Garden Grove Amphitheater Campus located at 12762 Main Street as complete; Authorize the City Manager to execute the Notice of Completion of Public Wor ks improvement and work; and
Authorize the Finance Director to release the retention payment when appropriate to do so.
By: Phillip Carter, Facilities Manager
ATTACHMENT(S)
1. Notice of Completion Project No. S-1328-A
54 RECORDING REQUESTED BY
When Recorded Mail To:
City Clerk
City of Garden Grove
P. 0. Box 3070
Garden Grove, CA 92842
NOTICE OF COMPLETION
OF PUBLIC IMPROVEMENT AND WORK
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the City of Garden Grove, Orange County, California, has caused a public improvement, to wit;
PROJECT NO. S-1328-A
PHASE ONE (1) ROOF REPLACEMENT PROJECT AT THE GARDEN
GROVE AMPHITHEATER CAMPUS
to be constructed upon the property hereinafter described. The contract for furnishing of all plant, labor, services, materials, and equipment, and all utilities and transportation, including power, fuel, and water, and performing all work necessary to construct and complete, in a good and workmanlike manner in strict accordance with the specifications, plans, and drawings therefore on file in the office of the City Clerk of the City of Garden Grove, for the construction, installation and completion of the above-described public improvement and work, was heretofore made and entered into with AME Builders Inc. on the 25th day of June 2024, and filed for record in the office of the City Clerk of the City of Garden Grove; that the work upon said public improvement has been completed, and that the Project Manager has notified the City Council that he has made and completed a final inspection of the materials furnished and installed and the work performed in the construction, installation, and completion of said public improvement hereinabove more particularly described and set forth, and has certified in writing to the City Council that all the provisions of the contract and contract documents for the furnishing of all plant, labor, services, materials, and equipment, and the performing of all work necessary for the construction, installation, and completion of said public improvement above described have been fully complied with to his satisfaction as required by the contract document; that final acceptance of the construction, installation, and completion of said public improvement above described was made on the 10th day of December, 2024 that the nature of the title to said property of said City of Garden Grove Is as follows: That is to say, it owns said public improvement in fee except the right-of-way upon which it is constructed, and that it owns an easement upon, over, and along said right-of-way for the purpose of the construction, installation, and completion of said public improvement hereinabove described and the use thereof after said completion; that the property hereinabove referred to and on which said public improvement is situated is described as follows, to wit:
PROJECT NO. S-1328-A
PHASE ONE (11 ROOF REPLACEMENT^
AT THE GARDEN GROVE AMPHITHEATER CAMPUS
55 NAME OF SURETY on
Labor and Material Bond is:NATIONWIDE MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY 534 E. BADILLO STREET
COVINA, CA 91723
TelNo.f626) 859-1000
DATED thisday of20
C1J\ OF GARDEN GROVE
By
City Manager of the City of Garden
Grove
ATTEST:
City Clerk of the City of Garden Grove
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF ORANGE
I am the Project Manager of Project No. S-1328-A.
I have read the foregoing Notice of Completion of Public Improvement and Work, and know the contents thereof; and I certify that the same is true of my own knowledge, except as to those matters, which are therein stated upon my information or belief, and as to those matters I believe to be true.
I certify (or declare), under penalty of perjury, that the foregoing is true and correct.
Executed on December 10, 2024
(Date)
at _ Garden Grove , California
(Place)
Phil Carter
Facilities Manager
56 Item 504/2024
Final
City of Garden Grove
INTER-DEPARTMENT MEMORANDUM
To:
Lisa L. Kim From: William E. Murray
Dept:
City Manager Dept: Public Works
Date: 12/10/2024
Subject: Authorization of the issuance of a purchase order to Garden Grove Nissan for one (1) new SUV. (Cost $45,939.31)(Action Item)
OBJECTIVE
To secure City Council authorization to purchase one (1) new SUV from Garden Grove Nissan in the amount of $45,939.31.
BACKGROUND
Public Works is responsible for providing safe and reliable vehicles for all City departments.
The Police Department currently has one (1) vehicle that meets the City’s guidelines for replacement. This vehicle is a 2007 Chevy Silverado pick -up with 98,500 miles, VIN#1GCEC19J27Z515487.
DISCUSSION
Specifications were prepared and sent to bidders in the Southern California area. No bids were received for this vehicle. Per Section 5.5 of the Purchasing Manual: If no bids or proposals are received through the formal or informal bidding procedure, the goods or services may be secured by negotiated contract. The City has a local Nissan dealer, Garden Grove Nissan. Staff has completed due diligence and negotiated a contract with the results being:
Garden Grove Nissan $45,939.31**
(Police Department SUV)
*This price includes all tax and destination charges.
**This price may also be lower due to rebates, discounts and dealer incentives.
FINANCIAL IMPACT
Total cost of the vehicle purchase is $45,939.31. The cost will be paid from the Fleet Management Fund. No additional appropriation is necessary as the replacement is scheduled and included in the adopted budget. There is no impact to the General Fund. The vehicle 57 Item 504/2024
being replaced will be sold at public auction , proceeds will be accounted for in the Fleet Management fund.
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended that the City Council:
Authorize the Finance Director to issue a purchase order in the amount of $45,939.31 to Garden Grove Nissan for the purchase of one (1) new SUV.
By: Steve Sudduth, Equipment Maintenance Supervisor
ATTACHMENT(S)
Garden Grove Nissan Quote Bid
58 59
60 61
62 63
Item 503/2024
Final
City of Garden Grove
INTER-DEPARTMENT MEMORANDUM
To:
Lisa L. Kim From: Chief El-Farra
Dept:
City Manager Dept: Police
Date: 12/10/2024
Subject: Approval of an increase to the purchase order with US Armor Corporation for Police Body Armor. (Action Item)
OBJECTIVE
To obtain City Council approval to increase the amount of the purchase order with US Armor Corporation for the purchase of police body armor for the Police Department.
BACKGROUND
Ballistic armor is custom-fitted for each individual officer, which results in several months for a vest to arrive after it has been ordered. In order for the vests to be properly fitted, the officer must travel to the vendor’s location for measurements both before and after the vest is made. US Armor Corporation is the only local vendor that can supply this equipment and necessary fittings, which is essential for officer safety.
DISCUSSION
The Police Department currently has an open purchase order (PO) with US Armor Corporation for $50,000 for the purchase of body armor. The PO has run out of funds, but it does not expire until February of 2025. The Department has had to purchase a high number of bulletproof vests due to a combination of vests reaching their five -year expiration date and an influx of new hires.
US Armor Corporation has an existing Sourcewell contract #011221-URM and has agreed to honor the prices and conditions in that contract for purchases made by the City.
FINANCIAL IMPACT
Funding of the $25,000 PO increase is included in the FY24-25 Police Department’s operating budget. No additional appropriation is needed.
64 Item 503/2024
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended that the City Council:
Authorize the Finance Director to increase the purchase order for US Armor Corporation to a total of $75,000 to purchase police body armor.
65 Item 479/2024
Final
City of Garden Grove
INTER-DEPARTMENT MEMORANDUM
To:
Lisa L. Kim From: Chief El-Farra
Dept:
City Manager Dept: Police
Date: 12/10/2024
Subject: Approval of a Master Operation & Maintenance Agreement with CEG Solutions, LLC to provide operation and maintenance services for the photovoltaic system and battery energy storage system for the Civic Center Revitalization Project. (Cost: $180,511) (Action Item)
OBJECTIVE
To secure City Council approval for a Master Operation & Maintenance Agreement with Construction Engineering Group Solutions, LLC (CEG) to provide operation and maintenance services for the photovoltaic system and battery energy storage system for the Civic Center Revitalization Project (Project).
BACKGROUND
On March 26, 2024, City Council approved the Civic Center Revitalization Project for the development of a new public safety facility, parking garage and re -imagined Civic Center Park. The new facilities are now fully designed and under construction. The primary structure consists of a 104,000 sf, three story building, with an integrated four level parking garage that includes public parking. It is anticipated Phase I (public safety building and garage) will be completed September 2026. Phase II of the Project includes the demolition of the existing police station and construction of a new 3.7 acre Civic Center Park. Phase II completion is anticipated in October 2027.
DISCUSSION
An important Project goal is implementing cost -effective building systems with long -term reliable operability. To ensure the design aligns with this goal, Verdical Group was hired to work closely with the designers. Verdigal Group’s role concentrates on providing input that support energy efficiency and low maintenance costs. They also provided recommendations on industry best practices, as developed by the U.S. Green Building Council, for achieving Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED) certifi cation standards . In a preliminary review of the building design under the LEED rating system, the project is currently meeting “Silver” standards with a total of 59 points. It is only one point away from 66 Item 479/2024
meeting “Gold” standards, so the team is working with the Verdical Group to identify the best opportunities to add elements to the project that will raise it to Gold level.
One category of the P roject’s energy efficiency outputs is renewable energy. Clark Construction is working with CEG on preli minary plans for the installation of a photovoltaic (PV) system on top of the new parking garage. The PV panels would be set on top of steel beams in a carport style (Exhibit A – Image). The design shows capacity for a 320kW system, providing enough gree n energy to support about 72 percent of estimated building power usage. The carport style also provides shade for the upper parking level, thus lowering the heat gain effect.
A Battery Energy Storage System (BESS) with a 500kWh capacity is included as part of the design. The BESS will store excess energy generated by the PV system and will discharge it during peak hours when the electricity rates are the highest. The collective system strengthens the Projects’ LEED point calculation adding six points to the current total.
To maximize energy production from the PV and BESS, operational oversight and routine maintenance is key. City staff do not have the equipment or expertise necessary to monitor and maintain the system once installed, so staff is seeking to contract with CEG for this service. The proposed contract is attached (Exhibit B - Agreement) and includes these major elements:
Installation and active review of a generation database software monitoring system. Provide annual reports on energy generation and whether it aligns with performance standards.
Cleaning of the PV array twice a year.
Emergency response to address any system outage alerts. Additional Service as needed for replacement of individual panels or other system components not properly working.
The initial term of the agreement is planned for five-years, with annual cost of living increases as specified in Table 1A below. At the City’s option, the agreement can be renewed for up to three additional 5-year terms for a total term not to exceed 20-years.
FINANCIAL IMPACT
The Master Operation & Maintenance Agreement would be paid annually once the renewable energy system is fully operational, which is currently estimated as September 2026. The initial fee is $34,000 and includes an annual cost of living increase of 3% for a total amount of $180,511 over the five-year term. Table 1A on the following page provides the payment schedule.
67 Item 479/2024
Table 1A
Year Service Fee
1 $34,000
2 $35,020
3 $36,071
4 $37,153
5 $38,267
$180,511
The cost will be programed in future year’s General Fund operating budget.
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended that the City Council:
Approve the Master Operation & Maintenance Agreement; and Authorize the City Manager to execute the Master Operation & Maintenance Agreement by and between the City of Garden Grove and CEG Solutions LLC, in an amount not to exceed $180,511, and to make minor modifications as appropriate thereto, on behalf of the City.
By: Craig Beck, Project Executive and Grace Kim, Project Manager
ATTACHMENT(S)
1. Exhibit A - Image
2. Exhibit B - Agreement
68 69
MASTER OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT
This MASTER OPERATION & MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT (this “Agreement”) is entered into as of ________________________ for reference purposes between CEG Solutions LLC, a Maryland limited liability company having its principal office at 4040 N. Fairfax Dr., Ste. 700, Arlington, VA 22203 (“Contractor”) and The City of Garden Grove, a California Municipality having its principal office at 11222 Acacia Pkwy., Garden Grove, CA 92840 (“ City”). Contractor and City are referred to herein individually as a “Party” and jointly as the “Parties”.
RECITALS
WHEREAS, Contractor will install certain solar electric generation systems generally consisting of Electricity grid-connected roof-mounted and parking canopy-mounted photovoltaic system with a total rated approximate capacity of 320 kW -DC-STC and Battery Energy Storage rated with approximate capacity of 415 kWh and power of 84kW (the “Systems”) as a subcontractor pursuant to a separate contract between The City of Garden Grove and Clark Construction Group – California LP.
WHEREAS, City now desires to engage Contractor to provide operation and maintenance services for the Systems.
WHEREAS, Contractor agrees to provide operation and maintenance services for the Systems subject to the terms and conditions of this Agreement, and C ity agrees to pay for such services and to fulfill the other requirements contained in this Agreement.
NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual promises set forth below, and for other good and valuable consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of which is hereby acknowledged, the Parties agree as follows:
AGREEMENT
1. DEFINITIONS
Unless otherwise required by the context in which any term appears: (a) capitalized terms used in this Agreement have the meanings listed in this Section 1; (b) the singular includes the plural and vice versa; (c) the word “including” indicates examples an d does not limit general terms, (d) references to “Sections”, and “Exhibits” are to sections, schedules and exhibits hereof; (e) the words “herein”, “hereof” and “hereunder” refer to the Agreement as a whole and not to any particular section or subsection hereof; and (f) references to the Agreement include all schedules and exhibits as they may be amended, modified, supplemented or replaced from time to time in accordance with the Agreement.
“Additional Services” shall have the meaning as described in Section 2.3.
“Annual Production Credit” shall have the meaning set forth in each Services Work Order.
“Applicable Law ” means any constitutional provision, law, statute, rule, regulation, ordinance, order, decree, judgment, decision, certificate, injunction, registration, license, permit, authorization, guideline, governmental approval, consent or requirement of a Governmental Authority with 70 jurisdiction over a Party, the Site or this Agreement, as construed from time to time by any Governmental Authority, as well as applicable industrial or engineering codes, standards or guidelines, insurance requirements and the other applicable requirements of the Local Electric Utility.
“Commercial Operation Date ” or “ COD” shall be the date the Local Electric Utility issu es permission to operate the System or the date the System is substantially complete and able to operate, whichever is later. The parties shall memorialize the COD in writing prior to the start of the Services.
“Confidential Information” shall have the meaning set forth in Section 5.3. “Contract Price” shall have the meaning set forth in Section 3.1. “Disclosing Party” shall have the meaning set forth in Section 5.3. “Dispute” has the meaning set forth in Section 5.8(a).
“Force Majeure Event” means any act or event (to the extent not caused by such Party or its agents or employees) that is unforeseeable or, if foreseeable, unavoidable and outside the control of the Party that invokes it, and which renders a Party unable to comply totally or partially wit h its obligations under the Agreement. Examples of a Force Majeure Event include: war (whether or not formally declared), hostilities, revolution, terrorism, insurrection against any Governmental Authority, riot or other civil disturbance; pandemic, widespread epidemic or similar public health emergency; acts of nature such as floods, lightning, earthquakes, hailstorms, ice storms, tornados, hurricanes, landslides, volcanic eruptions, fires, objects striking the earth from space; sabotage or destruction by a third party (other than one retained by a Party) of facilities and equipment relating to the performance by the affected Party of its obligations under this Agreement; regional or national strikes, walkouts, lockouts or other labor actions or dispu tes; widespread electrical grid outages; acts of any Governmental Authority that materially restrict or limit Contractor’s access to the Site or performance of the Services; compliance with any order or request of any Governmental Authority; inability to o btain equipment, materials or qualified labor sufficient to perform the Services.
“Governmental Authority” means any national, regional, province, town, city, state or municipal government, whether domestic or foreign, or other administrative, regulatory or judicial body having jurisdiction over the Site or a Party.
“Hazardous Waste” means a solid waste which is specifically listed as a known hazardous waste or meets the characteristics of a hazardous waste. Listed wastes are wastes from common manufacturing and industrial processes, specific industries and can be generated from discarded commercial products. Characteristic wastes are wastes that exhibit any one or more of the following characteristic properties: ignitability, corrosivity, reacti vity or toxicity; or, any waste defined as a hazardous waste by the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act, 42 U.S.C. Section 6901 et seq., the Comprehensive Environmental Response Compensation and Liability Act, 42 U.S.C. Section 9601 et seq., or any similar state statute.
“Indemnified Party” shall have the meaning as described in Section 4.4(c).
“Indemnifying Party” shall have the meaning as described in Section 4.4(c).
“Local Electric Utility” means the utility or any other party owning or controlling the electric 71 utility transmission or distribution system to which the Site or the System will be interconnected.
“Operating Year” means the twelve (12) month period after the Commercial Operation Date, and each subsequent year beginning 365 days after the prior Operating Year.
“Party” means, individually, each of the Parties first listed above.
“Person” means, as the context requires, any individual, corporation, partnership, company, joint venture, association, trust, unincorporated organization or Governmental Authority.
“Production Shortfall” shall have the meaning set forth in each Services Work Order.
“Receiving Party” shall have the meaning set forth in Section 5.3.
“Services Work Order” shall have the meaning set forth in Section 2.1.
“Services” shall have the meaning set forth in Section 2.2 and each Services Work Order.
“System” shall have the meaning as described in Section 2.1
“Site” shall have the meaning as described in Section 2.1 . “ Term” shall have the meaning as described in Section 4.1(a).
2. SYSTEM AND SERVICES
2.1 System and Site.
(a) The Parties shall enter into a Services Work Order, substantially in the form attached hereto as Exhibit A, for each separate Site or System, under which Contractor shall provide the Services (hereinafter defined) for such system (the “Services Work Order ”). Each system identified in an executed Services Work Order is hereinafter referred to in this Agreement as a “ System” and the location of such system is hereinafter referred to in this Agreement as the “Site”.
(b) In the event a Services Work Order is mutually agreed upon and executed by both Parties, the terms of each Services Work Order are hereby incorporated into this Agreement and in the event of conflict between this Agreement and Services Work Order, the terms of the Services Work Order shall prevail in terms of such System.
2.2 Services. City hereby engages Contractor to perform certain work and services described in each Services Work Order (the “Services”).
2.3 Additional Services. In the event City gives Contractor written notice of any maintenance, corrective maintenance, repair or other services that City wants performed on the System that is not listed in a Services Work Order (“Additional Services”), Contractor shall provide a quote to complete the work as requested.
2.4 Emergency Service. In the event of an emergency, City shall take necessary steps to secure the safety of its personnel and minimize damage to the System. As soon as practicable, C ity shall 72 notify Contractor of the emergency. City and Contractor shall jointly formulate a response, including Contractor’s performance of work to enable the continued operation of the System, if necessary.
City shall have policies and procedures in place (including notification procedures) to address emergencies at the Site that affect the System. Emergency services shall be invoiced as Additional Services.
2.5 Standard of Performance. Unless otherwise stated in th e Services Work Order, Contractor shall, and shall cause any subcontractors to, perform the Services in accordance with the terms of this Agreement and applicable operation and maintenance manuals, in a good and workmanlike manner, and in accordance with practices, methods, techniques and standards that (i) are generally accepted in the solar photovoltaic power industry in the United States for use in connection with the operation and maintenance of solar power generating projects of similar size and type as the System all in a manner consistent with Governmental Authority, reliability and good workmanship; and (ii) operate the System in accordance with (a) any manufacturer design, engineering, construction, testing, operation and maintenance guidelines appl icable to the equipment in question and (b) any applicable annual project operating plans of City. The foregoing practices are not intended to mean the optimum practice, method, specification or standard but rather refers to commonly used and reasonable practices and methods.
2.6 Subcontractors. Contractor may utilize subcontractors to perform any portion of the Services or Additional Services. Contractor shall be solely responsible for the work of its subcontractors.
2.7 Warranty.
(a) Contractor warrants that the Services performed will be free from defects in workmanship for a period of ninety (90) days from the date of performance of any such Services, provided City shall give Contractor written notice of any defect within such ninety (90) day period.
(b) Equipment Warranties. Contractor’s warranty obligations under this Agreement exclude any obligation to repair or replace equipment manufactured by third parties, and C ity agrees to solely look to the manufacturer of such equipment for any remedy under any applicable manufacturer’s warranty. In the event the City desires to pursue remedies under a manufacturer’s warranty, City shall give Contractor written notice and Contractor shall use reasonable efforts to facilitate City’s warranty claim. Any removal, replacement, freight, and investigation costs not covered under the manufacturer warranty will be at the cost of the City.
(c) THE WARRANTIES CONTAINED HEREIN ARE IN LIEU OF ALL OTHER
WARRANTIES, INCLUDING ANY WARRANTIES OF MER CHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR USE OR PURPOSE. ANY IMPLIED WARRANTIES ARE WAIVED TO THE FULLEST EXTENT PERMISSIBLE UNDER STATE AND FEDERAL LAW. THE
WARRANTIES CONTAINED HEREIN EXCLUDE CONSEQUENTIAL AND INCIDENTAL
DAMAGES AND ARE LIMITED IN DURATION TO THE FULLEST EXTENT PERMISSIBLE UNDER STATE AND FEDERAL LAW.
2.8 City Obligations.
(a) Access. City shall provide access to the System and Site sufficient for Contractor to perform the Services, as well as utilities and other services that Contractor identifies as necessary for support 73 of its work. Upon notification of Data Acquisition System ( DAS) alarms that require Additional Services, City will grant Contractor prompt access to the Site to respond to the alarms. City shall accommodate any special access requirements such as badging, facility contact, and gate codes that are listed in each Services Work Order.
(b) Operation of System. City is responsible for and retains full care, custody and control of the System, is responsible for maintaining a safe operating environment at the Site and for the System and is responsible for the day -to-day operations of the System. City is responsible for meeting all operating requirements of utility, local, state and federal regulatory bodies and for all reporting requirements of utility, local, state and federal regulatory bodies relating to the ownership, operation and maintenance of the System.
(c) Government Authority. City shall obtain, maintain and comply with all any Government Authority requirements for the operation of the System. Contractor will provide reasonable assistance to City with respect to government requ irements upon City’s written request as an Additional Service.
(d) Interconnection. City shall be party to or ensure that there are separate legal agreements with parties for, all contracts for sale and transmission of System energy and responsible for all utility, interconnection and transmission costs of the System and of its operation.
2.9 Party Representatives.
(a) City Representative. City shall designate in writing a representative as their City Representative for all matters relating to City’s obligations u nder this Agreement. City Representative shall have the authority to bind City and the actions taken by City Representative shall be deemed the acts of City and shall be fully binding upon City.
(b) Contractor Representative . Contractor shall designate in wri ting a Contractor Representative. Contractor Representative shall have the authority to bind Contractor and the actions taken by Contractor Representative shall be deemed the acts of Contractor and shall be fully binding upon Contractor.
2.10 Title. Title to all materials and equipment incorporated into the System by Contractor when performing under this Agreement shall transfer to City upon payment by City to Contractor for such material and equipment.
2.11 Liens. Provided City has made all payments currently due, Contractor shall not directly or indirectly cause, create, incur, assume, or suffer to exist any liens, claims, charges, security interests, and encumbrances whatsoever on the Site or any System, or any part of, or interest in, any of the foregoing, and upon receipt of payment in full for the Work hereunder, Contractor shall promptly pay or discharge of record or bond any such liens, claims, charges, security interests, and encumbrances.
2.12 Contractor’s Insurance . Contractor shall throughout the Term maintain the following insurance:
(a) Workers compensation insurance, as required by Applicable Law, and Employer’s Liability insurance with a $1,000,000 limit.
74 (b) Automobile liability insurance covering all automobiles, w hether owned or leased, in an amount not less than $1,000,000 combined single limit.
(c) Commercial general liability insurance with limits of not less than $1,000,000 per occurrence. Such insurance shall include coverage for premises/operations, explosion, c ollapse, underground hazards, contractual liability, independent contractors, sudden and accidental pollution, products/completed operations, cross liability, property damage and personal injury liability.
2.13 Reserved.
2.14 Insurance – Form and Content. Each policy shall waive any rights of claims and subrogation and shall name the City as an additional insured on its liability policies. Contractor shall furnish the City with certificates and endorsements evidencing that the required insurance is in effect.
3. FEES AND PAYMENT TERMS
3.1 Payments for Services . As compensation for the Services, City shall pay Contractor the amount specified in each Services Work Order (“Contract Price”). Contractor shall invoice City upon completion of each milestone listed in each Services Work Order and City shall work to pay each invoice within forty-five (45) days of receipt.
3.2 Payments for Additional Services . Contractor shall invoice City upon completion of any Additional Services. City shall work to pay each invoice within forty-five (45) days of receipt.
3.3 Taxes. City shall be responsible for the cost of all sales, use, property, excise, and other taxes (federal, state, local or otherwise), including any interest and tax penalties associated therewith, but excluding any taxes ba sed on Contractor’s net income, which are levied or imposed by reason of Contractor’s performance of the Services. City shall be responsible for costs associated with Audits originating from Taxing authorities (Federal, state, local or otherwise) and will be responsible for any agreed upon assessments. Notwithstanding any other provisions contained herein, each Party (and each of its respective employees, representatives or other agents) may disclose to any and all Persons, without limitations of any kind, the tax treatment and any facts that may be relevant to the tax structure of the transactions contemplated by this Agreement; provided, however, that no Party (and no employee, representative, or other agent thereof) shall disclose any other information th at is not relevant to understanding the tax treatment and tax structure of the transaction (including the identity of any Party and any information that could lead another to determine the identity of any party), or any other information to the extent that such disclosure would result in a violation of any federal or state securities law.
4. TERM AND TERMINATION; INDEMNITIES; LIMITATION OF LIABILITY
4.1 Term.
(a) The term of each Services Work Order for the Services (the “Term”) shall commence on the Commercial Operation Date and expire on the Expiration Date, as such dates are listed in each Services Work Order. City may terminate this Agreement and any Services Work Order upon 180 days’ notice to Contractor.
75 (b) If this Agreement is terminated for any reason other than a termination for cause, Contractor shall be entitled to payment for services completed through the date of termination. The Term may be extended upon mutual agreement of the Parties in writing, provi ded City shall deliver a written request to extend the Term to Contractor no later than sixty (60) days prior to the end of the Term.
4.2 Termination by City. Contractor agrees that City shall be entitled to terminate this Agreement pursuant to written notice upon the occurrence of any of the following circumstances:
(a) Contractor violates in any material respect any of the provisions of this Agreement, which violation remains uncured for t hirty (30) days following Contractor’s receipt of written notice thereof from City; provided however, that if the nature of the breach requires more than thirty (30) days to cure, and Contractor is using reasonable commercial efforts to cure, then such time period shall be extended accordingly.
(b) Contractor voluntarily commences bankruptcy, insolvency or similar debtor-relief proceedings, or becomes insolvent or generally does not pay its debts as they become due, or admits in writing its inability to pay its debts, or makes an assignment for the benefit of creditors;
(c) Insolvency, receivership, reorganization, bankruptcy or a similar proceeding is commenced against Contractor and such proceeding is not dismissed or stayed within a period of ninety (90) days thereafter.
Upon termination for the foregoing reasons, Contractor shall discontinue the Services and shall use reasonable commercial efforts to reduce or otherwise mitigate any expense or damage to City. City shall pay Contractor for any Services and Ad ditional Services performed up to the date of termination.
4.3 Termination by Contractor. City agrees that Contractor shall be entitled to suspend work and terminate this Agreement pursuant to written notice upon the occurrence of any of the following circumstances:
(a) Any representation or warranty made by City in this Agreement proves to have been false or misleading in any material respect as of the time made, confirmed or furnished (but, if such breach is capable of being cured, only to the extent such breach continues for thirty (30) days following receipt of a notice in writing of such breach from Contractor);
(b) City violates in any material respect any of the provisions of this Agreement, which violation remains uncured for ten (10) days following City’s receipt of written notice thereof from Contractor; provided however, that if the nature of the breach requires more than ten (10) days to cure, and City is using reasonable commercial efforts to cure, then such time period shall be extended accordingly;
(c) City voluntarily commences bankruptcy, insolvency or similar debtor -relief proceedings, or becomes insolvent or generally does not pay its debts as they become due, or admits in writing its inability to pay its debts, or makes an assignment for the benefit of creditors;
(d) Insolvency, receivership, reorganization, bankruptcy or a similar proceeding is commenced against City and such proceeding is not dismissed or stayed within a period of ninety (90) days 76 thereafter.
Upon the occurrence of any of the foregoing, in addition to all rights and remedies that may be available under Applicable Law, City shall, within thirty (30) days of the termination date, pay Contractor for (1) all completed Services and Additional Services and any materials ordered through the effective date of such termination, (2) demobilization costs, plus a combined markup of 15% for overhead and profit on such materials and demobilization costs, and (3) other verifiable out -of- pocket costs, including reasonable and verifiable termination fees of vendors and contractors, together with any other liabilities to which Contra ctor is subject pursuant to any agreements with vendors concerning the Services or Additional Services and that are executed by Contractor on or before the termination date.
4.4 Indemnification.
(a) Contractor shall, to the fullest extent permitted by law, full y indemnify, save harmless and defend City and its affiliates, directors, officers, shareholders, members, employees, agents and representatives from and against any and all costs, claims, and expenses incurred by City in connection with or arising from any claim by a third party for physical damage to property, or death of or bodily injury to any person, but only to the extent caused by or arising out of or related to Contractor’s negligence or willful misconduct or that of its subcontractors.
(b) City shall, to the fullest extent permitted by law, fully indemnify, save harmless and defend Contractor and its affiliates, directors, officers, shareholders, employees, agents and representatives from and against any and all costs, claims, and expenses incurred by Contractor in connection with or arising from any claim by a third party for physical damage to property, or death of or bodily injury to any person, but only to the extent caused by or arising out of or related to (i) City’s negligence or willful misconduct or that of its agents or employees or others under City’s control; (ii) City’s breach of its obligations hereunder; or (iii) any Hazardous Waste existing at the Site.
(c) If any claim is brought against a Party (the “ Indemnified Party ”), then the other Party (the “Indemnifying Party ”) shall be entitled to participate in, and, unless in the opinion of counsel for the Indemnifying Party a conflict of interest between the Parties may exist with respect to such claim, assume the defense of such claim, with counsel reasonably acceptable to the Indemnified Party. If the Indemnifying Party does not assume the defense of the Indemnified Party, or if a conflict precludes the Indemnified Party from assuming the defense, then the Indemnifying Party shall reimburse the Indemnified Party on a monthly basis for the Indemnified Party’s defense through separate counsel of the Indemnified Party’s choice. Even if the Indemnifying Party assumes the defense of the Indemnified Party with acceptable counsel, the Indemnified Party, at its sole option, may participate in the defense, at its own expense, with counsel of its own choice without relieving the Indemnifying Party of any of its obligations hereunder.
4.5 WAIVER OF CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES . UNLESS SPECIFICALLY ALLOWED
HEREIN, THE PARTIES AGREE THAT TO THE FULLEST EXTENT ALLOWED BY LAW, IN
NO EVENT SHALL EITHER PARTY BE RESPONSIBLE OR LIABLE, WHETHER IN
CONTRACT, TORT, WARRANTY, OR UNDER ANY STATUTE OR ON ANY OTHER BASIS,
FOR SPECIAL, INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, MULTIPLE, PUNITIVE OR CONSEQUENTIAL
DAMAGES, OR DAMAGES FOR LOST PROFITS OR LOSS OR INTERRUPTION OF
BUSINESS, ARISING OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE SERVICES OR THIS AGREEMENT.
77 4.6 RESERVED.
4.7 Force Majeure. Except for the obligation to make payments when due, which cannot be excused by a Force Majeure Event, neither Party shall be considered in breach of this Agreement or its obligations under the applicable Services Work Order nor be liable for any delay or failure to comply with this Agreement or the applicable Services Work Order if and to the extent that such delay or failure is attributable to the existence of a Force Majeure Event. Contractor shall promptly notify City in writing within twenty (20) business day s of becoming aware of the nature of a Force Majeure Event that will delay Contractor’s performance of the Services, and the anticipated length of the delay. Any Force Majeure Event that prevents performance, or is reasonably expected to prevent performance, for more than ninety (90) days shall entitle Contractor or City to terminate this Agreement. In the event the Agreement is so terminated, City shall pay Contractor for any Services performed up to the date of termination.
5. ADDITIONAL TERMS
5.1 Governing Law. This Agreement and the rights and obligations of the Parties shall be governed by and construed in accordance with the substantive laws of the State of California without regard to conflict of law principles.
5.2 Amendments. No amendment to this Agreemen t shall be binding on the Parties unless set out in writing, expressed to vary this Agreement, and signed by authorized representatives of each of the Parties.
5.3 Confidentiality. Each Party (the “Receiving Party”) shall not use for any purpose other than performing its obligations under this Agreement or divulge, disclose, produce, publish, or permit access to, without the prior written consent of the other Party (the “ Disclosing Party ”), any Confidential Information of the Disclosing Party. “ Confidential Information” includes this Agreement, all information or materials, whether in writing, oral, digital or otherwise, prepared in connection with the Services, designs, drawings, specifications, techniques, models, data, documentation, source code, object code, diagrams, flow charts, processes, procedures, know-how, and any other trade secrets. Confidential Information does not include (i) information known to the Receiving Party prior to obtaining the same from the Disclosing Party; (ii) information in the public domain at the time of disclosure by the Receiving Party; or (iii) information obtained by the Receiving Party from a third party who did not receive same, directly or indirectly, from the Disclosing Party. The Receiving Party shall use the higher of the standard of care that the Receiving Party uses to preserve its own confidential information or a reasonable standard of care to prevent unauthorized use or disclosure of such Confidential Information. However, the Receiving Party has the right to disclose Confidential Information without the prior written consent of the Disclosing Party: (i) as required by any an administrative, regulatory or judicial body having jurisdiction over the Site or Party, or by any securities exchange on which the shares of a Party are listed, (ii) as otherwise required by law, (iii) as advisable or required in connection with any government or regulatory filings, including filings with any regulating authorities covering relevant financial markets, (iv) to its attorneys, accountants, financial advisors or other agents, in each case bound by confidentiality obligations, (v) to banks, investors and other financing sources and their advisors, in each case bound by confidentiality obligations; or (vi) in connection with an act ual or prospective merger or acquisition or similar transaction where the party receiving the Confidential Information 78 is bound by confidentiality obligations. If a Receiving Party believes that it will be compelled by an administrative, regulatory or judi cial body having jurisdiction over the Site or Party to disclose Confidential Information of the Disclosing Party, to the extent reasonably possible, it shall give the Disclosing Party prompt written notice so that the Disclosing Party may determine whethe r to take steps to oppose such disclosure at Disclosing Party’s discretion and sole cost.
5.4 Representations and Warranties of the Parties. Each Party to this Agreement represents and warrants to each other that:
(a) Each is duly formed and validly existing un der the laws of the State identified in the first paragraph of this Agreement and has full legal capacity and standing to pursue its corporate purposes (including the capacity to dispose of and encumber all of its assets), full and unrestricted authority to enter into this Agreement, and full power to engage in the business it presently conducts and contemplates conducting, and is and will be duly licensed or qualified and in good standing under the laws of each jurisdiction where the nature of the business transacted by it requires such licensing or qualification and where the failure to be licensed or qualified would have a material adverse effect on its ability to perform its obligations hereunder.
(b) The execution, delivery and performance by Contractor of this Agreement will not (i) violate or conflict with any covenant, agreement or understanding to which it is a party or by which it or any of its properties or assets is bound or affected, or its organizational documents or (ii) subject the System or any component part thereof to any lien other than as contemplated or permitted by this Agreement.
(c) There are no actions, suits, proceedings, patent or license infringements or investigations pending or, to each Party’s knowledge, threatened against it before any court or arbitrator that individually or in the aggregate could result in any materially adverse effect on the business, properties or assets or the condition, financial or otherwise, of Contractor or in any impairment of its ability to perform its obligations under this Agreement.
(d) Each of the individuals executing and delivering this Agreement on behalf of each Party is duly authorized to do so on behalf of the Party and this Agreement is binding upon each Party in accordance with its terms.
5.5 Additional Representations and Warranties of City. City represents and warrants to Contractor that:
(a) City has, and will have, available all the funds that are necessary from time to time to pay Contractor the Contract Price.
(b) Title to the Site is held by City.
(c) The execution, delivery and performance by City of this Agreement will not (i) violate any Governmental Requirements applicable to City, or (ii) result in any breach of, or constitute any default under, and contractual obligation of City.
(d) There is no Hazardous Waste located at the Site.
79 5.6 Independent Contractors. The Parties acknowledge that, save as expressly set out in this Agreement to the contrary, each Party is entering into this Agreement as an independent contractor and nothing in this Agreement shall be interpreted or applied so as to make the relationship of the Parties that of partners or anything other than independent contractors.
5.7 Notices. Any notice, request, demand or other communication required or permitted under this Agreement, shall be deemed to be properly given by the sender and received by the addressee (a) immediately if made in writing and personally delivered or emailed or (b) three days after deposit in the mail if mailed by certified or registered air mail, po stage prepaid, with a return receipt requested. Notices shall be addressed as follows:
City: Contractor:
City of Garden Grove CEG Solutions LLC
11222 Acacia Prkwy. 4040 N. Fairfax Dr. Ste. 700
Garden Grove, CA 92840 Arlington, VA 22203
Attn: Attn:
Email: Email:
5.8 Dispute Resolution. In the event that any question, dispute, difference or claim arises out of or in connection with this Agreement, including any question regarding its existence, validity, performance or termination (a “Dispute”), and within thirty (30) days of one Party notifying the other Party in writing of the existence of such Dispute that such Dispute is not resolved through good faith negotiations, including the determination of the scope or applicability of this Agreement to arbitrate, such Dispute shall be exclusively and finally determined by arbitration in Los Angeles, CA, before one arbitrator. The Parties agree that the decision from the arbitration shall be final and binding. The arbitration shall be administered by AAA pursuant to its Construction Industry Arbitration Rules. Judgment on the award may be entered in any court having jurisdiction over a Party.
5.9 Construction.
(a) Survival. Any rights and obligations of the Parties th at arise prior to termination of this Agreement shall survive termination of this Agreement and continue to be governed by its provisions.
(b) Successors and Assigns. This Agreement shall be binding on the Parties and their respective permitted successors, heirs and assigns.
(c) Amendment and Modification. This Agreement may only be amended, modified or supplemented by an agreement in writing signed by each Party hereto.
(d) Headings. The headings in this Agreement are for reference only and shall not affect t he interpretation of this Agreement.
(e) Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in counterparts, which shall together constitute one and the same agreement. Facsimile or portable document format (“PDF”) signatures shall have the same effect as original signatures. Each Party consents to the admission in evidence of a facsimile, photocopy or PDF of this Agreement in any Dispute proceedings between the Parties. 80 (f) Entire Agreement . This Agreement, together with the Services Work Order s and the Exhibits, constitutes the sole and entire agreement of the Parties to this Agreement with respect to the subject matter contained herein, and supersedes all prior and contemporaneous understandings, agreements, representations and warranties, both written and oral, with respect to such subject matter.
(g) No Agency. This Agreement is not intended to create any association, joint venture, agency relationship or partnership between the Parties or to impose any such obligation or liability upon either Party. Neither Party shall have any right, power or authority to enter into any agreement or undertaking for, or act as or be an agent or representative of, or otherwise bind, the other Party except as expressly allowed by this Agreement.
(h) Assignment. Neither Party shall have the right to assign any of its rights, duties, or obligations under this Agreement without the prior written consent of the other Party, which consent may not be unreasonably withheld or delayed. Any purported assignment or delegation in violation of this Section shall be null and void. No assignment or delegation shall relieve the assigning or delegating Party of any of its obligations hereunder.
(i) No Waiver. No waiver by any Party of any of the provisions hereof shall be effective unless explicitly set forth in writing and signed by the Party so waiving. No waiver by any Party shall operate or be construed as a waiver in respect of any failure, breach or default not expressly identified by such written waiver, whether of a similar or different character, and whether occurring before or after that waiver. No failure to exercise, or delay in exercising, any right, remedy, power or privilege arising from this Agreement shall operate or be construed as a waiver thereof; nor shall any single or partial exercise of any right, remedy, power or privilege hereunder preclude any other or further exercise thereof or the exercise of any other right, remedy, power or privilege.
(j) Further Assurances. Each of the Parties shall use commercially reasonable efforts to their commercially reasonable efforts to, from time to time at the request of the other Party, without any additional consideration, furnish the other Party such further information or assurances, execute and deliver such additional documents, instruments and co nveyances, and take such other actions and do such other things, as may be necessary or desirable in the opinion of counsel to the requesting Party to carry out the provisions of this Agreement and each Services Work Order and give effect to the transactions contemplated hereby and thereby.
[SIGNATURE PAGE FOLLOWS]
81 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Parties have executed this Operation and Maintenance Agreement as of the date first above below.
CITY OF GARDEN GROVE CEG SOLUTIONS LLC
CA License No.: 1022675
By: By:
Name: Lisa L. Kim Name:
Title: City Manager Title:
Date: Date:
Attest:
City Clerk
Approved as to form:
City Attorney
82 EXHIBIT A
SCHEDULE 1 - SERVICES
WORK ORDER
Location of Site: 11201 Acacia Pkwy, Garden Grove, CA 92840 Description of System: Electricity grid-connected roof-mounted and parking canopy-mounted photovoltaic system with a total rated approximate capacity of 320 kW-DC-STC.. The Battery Energy Storage System will be rated with approximate capacity of 415 kWh and power of 84kW.
Scope of Work:
1. System Monitoring & Response: Contractor shall provide all maintenance and services work as follows:
a. System Alarms / Notification: Contractor shall respond to alarms from the Data Acquisition System (“DAS”), notifications sent by City, or field personnel (“Alarms”) as follows:
Table 1
Response
Level
General
Description
Remote
Response
(Business
Days)
Field Response
(Business
Days)
1 Emergency (Immediate Life Safety issues)
½ Day
1 Day
2 Critical System Production Issues (Inverter Loss or
Weather Adjusted Performance <80%)
1 Day
3 Days
3 Communications or DAS Issue (not classified as Tier 1 or 2)
3 Day
3 Days
4 Non-Critical Low Production: (80% < Weather Adjusted
Performance <90%)
3 Day
10 Days
5 General Issue, not falling into the categories above
3 Days
As needed
b. Pre-Authorized Work Limits: In the event that Additional Services are not covered under a warranty, City authorizes Contractor to perform, at its discretion, up to $1,500 of Additional 83 Services as may be required to respond to Alarms as described in Table 2 above.
c. Annual System Production Report : Each year, within thirty (30) days following the anniversary of the Commercial Operation Date, Contractor shall provide, via the DAS, City with an annual energy production report showing the actual System performance.
2. Preventative Maintenance: Contractor shall provide service as follows:
Table 2
Preventative Maintenance Service Description
Service
Frequency
General Inspections:
· Visual inspection for signs of damage, overall wear and tear, module breakage, loose conduit, broken straps, etc.
· Sample check torque marks and tighten loose connections
1 per year
Electrical Inspections and Maintenance:
· Perform manufacturer’s preventative maintenance on electrical equipment
· Check integrity of weather resistance (seals, hubs and weather stripping)
· Check electrical equipment housing for signs of corrosion
· Perform infrared scans, as needed
1 per year
Inverter Inspections and Maintenance:
· Perform manufacturer’s preventative maintenance
· Check integrity of weather resistance (seals, hubs and weather stripping)
· Check inverter housing for signs of corrosion
· Clean inverter air vents and heat sinks clean filters
· Perform infrared scans, as needed
1 per year
84 Monitoring Equipment Inspection:
· Clean pyranometer(s)
· Check integrity of cell temperature sensor · Check other weather station components
· Check that the System meter is reading
1 per year
Array Washing:
· Includes normally expected soiling conditions. Heavy cleaning, such as excessive soiling, debris removal, bird droppings and soot, not to exceed 10% of total array.
2 per year
3. PREVENTATIVE MAINTENANCE REPORTING : Within two (2) weeks following each visit, Contractor shall provide City with a completed maintenance checklist, list of issues discovered, resolution, and accompanying photos as appropriate.
4. MODULE REPLACEMENT: Contractor shall replace damaged PV modules with attic stock as needed (20).
5. MONITORING: Contractor shall maintain an active DAS subscription for the entire term of this agreement.
85 SCHEDULE 2 – SCHEDULE & PAYMENT
Commencement Date: Owner will notify contractor of their acceptance of substantial completion of the system and will designate the commencement of the service period.
Expiration Date: The term of the service contract is 5 years, with three 5-year renewal options, for a total potential contract period of 20 years. The parties agree there will be an annual cost adjustment of 3 percent year-over-year. At each renewal (years 6, 11, 16) the parties will update “Schedule 2” to reflect current hourly pricing for additional work.
Annual Service Price: The annual price for all services included in this contract shall be $34,000 in year 1 and escalate at 3% each year as referenced in the table below:
YEAR PAYMENT
1 $34,000
2 $35,020
3 $36,071
4 $37,153
5 $38,268
Additional Service Rates: Any additional services beyond the terms of this agreement can be included upon written direction from the owner. The rates will be tracked on a T&M Basis according to the following rate schedule for year 1 of the agreement (the rate schedule shall escalate at 3 percent annually):
Labor rate for out-of-scope maintenance and repair $228 Weekdays overtime, weekend labor rate for out-of-scope
maintenance and repair
Bill Rate x 1.5
Double-time for holidays labor rate for out-of-scope
maintenance and repair
Bill Rate x 2
Engineering / Asset Manager $264
Project Manager / PV Operator / Site Manager $240
Site Specialist $180
Assistant Electrician / Laborer $168
EVP $330
SVP $318
86 VP – Asset Management $318
VP – O&M $318
Controller / Treasurer $228
NERC Compliance - Corporate $222
Environmental - Corporate $210
Health and Safety - Corporate $210
Human Resource Specialist $180
Assoc Asset Manager $156
Accounting /Admin $138
Treasurer / AP Clerk $114
IT Network Engineer $210
IT Helpdesk $180
IT Technology Executive $270
Mobilization (per event, per person), more than 3 hour
roundtrip
$1250
Excludes any ticketed travel (such as airfare)
or rental vehicles.
Mobilization, less than 3 hour roundtrip
- Drive time
- Mileage
- Per diem
$150/hr.
IRS rate / mile
$75 / day
Subcontractor Cost + 15%
Material and Shipping Cost + 15%
Rental Equipment Cost + 15%
Lodging, Airfare, and car rental Cost + 15%
Non-Standard Wage Rate (Prevailing wage, Service Act,
IRA, etc.)
To be determined on a case-by-case basis.
OVERTIME AND HOLIDAY WORK WILL BE PERFORMED ONLY BY MUTUAL AGREEMENT BETWEEN OPERATOR AND OWNER. A
MINIMUM OF TWO HOURS WILL BE CHARGED
1. ASSUMPTIONS
A. CITY WILL PROVIDE SITE ACCESS AND A SAFE WORKING ENVIRONMENT.
C. CITY WILL PROVIDE FACILITY CONTACT TO PROVIDE REAL TIME INFORMATION ABOUT SITE CONDITIONS (POWER OUTAGE , ACTIVE CONSTRUCTION , ETC.).
D. CITY IS RESPONSIBLE FOR CLOSING THE PARKING AREA FOR THE WASHING AND MAINTENANCE
ACTIVITIES IF APPLICABLE
G. ELEVATED SYSTEMS HAVE OSHA COMPLIANT FALL PROTECTION AND/OR FALL ARREST 87 SYSTEMS INSTALLED.
I. ARC FLASH STICKERS ARE PRESENT ON ALL APPLICABLE EQUIPMENT AS REQUIRED.
J. FIELD WORK WILL BE PERFORMED DURING LOCAL BUSINESS HOURS.
K. SYSTEM SAFETY ISSUES ARE CO RRECTED AS ADVISED BY INSPECTION RESULTS.
2. EXCLUSIONS
A. HARDWARE UPGRADES BEYOND THE BASE SYSTEM OR REFURBISHMENTS.
B. INSTALLATION REFURBISHMENTS TO BRING EQUIPMENT IN COMPLIANCE WITH NEW CODE OR REVISED MANUFACTURER REQUIREMENTS.
C. COSMETIC CORROSION REPAIR.
D. ADDITIONAL WASHING DUE TO HEAVY SOILING, SUCH AS REMOVAL OF ENDEMIC BIRD DROPPINGS , TARS, PAINTS, HEAVY SOOT, OR WILDFIRE ASH.
88 Item 516/2024
Final
City of Garden Grove
INTER-DEPARTMENT MEMORANDUM
To:
Lisa L. Kim From: Craig Beck
Dept:
City Manager Dept: Economic Development and
Housing
Date: 12/10/2024
Subject: Approval of a request from Edgemoor Infrastructure and Real Estate to modify construction hours and exemption from Noise Control Ordinance, Municipal Code Section 8.47.040 and 8.47.060, to accommodate construction activities for the Civic Center Revitalization Project. (Action Item)
OBJECTIVE
To transmit a written request on behalf of Edgemoor Infrastructure and Real Estate (Edgemoor), requesting approval to be exempt from Noise Control Ordinance, Municipal Code Section 8.47.040 and 8.47.060 to accommodate construction activities for the Civic Center Revitalization Project.
BACKGROUND
In May 2024, the City initiated the Civic Center Revitalization Project, which is divided into two phases. Phase I involves constructing a new public safety facility and parking structure.
Phase II includes demolishing the existing Garden Grove Police Department to make way for a new 3.7-acre park. Completion of Phase I is estimated to be Fall 2026 and Phase II completion is estimated to be Fall 2027.
DISCUSSION
On Tuesday, December 3, 2024, the City received a written request from Edgemoor to extend construction operating hours and move the starting work hours from 7 a.m. to 4 a.m. and to deviate from ambient noise levels outlined in Section 8.47.040 of the Municipal Code during the extended construction operating hours. This request is to allow noise generating activities to begin at 4:00 a.m. instead of 7:00 a.m. for a limited number of days each year to accommodate essential construction activities, ensuring crew members have adequate time to complete their tasks. The project team will provide a 48-hour notice to the City before the requested early start days. Please refer to Table 1 on the following page for the exact number of days requested per year.
89 Item 516/2024
Table 1
Year Exemption Days
2024 2
2025 30
2026 15
2027 15
To minimize the impact to the residential neighborhood in the Civic Center Revitalization Project vicinity, the project team will utilize white noise backup alarms on all equipment and trucks to reduce noise activity. Additionally, the project team will continue to research opportunities to reduce the need for early start days, if feasible. This request requires an exemption from Municipal Code Sections 8.47.040 and 8.47.060. Granting this exemption will enable the Civic Center Revitalization Project to proceed more efficiently by meeting critical milestones and stay on schedule.
FINANCIAL IMPACT
Approval of this request will not have a financial impact on the City.
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended that the City Council:
Approve a written request from Edgemoor, to extend construction hours and exceed ambient noise levels for a certain amount of days per year, exempting the Civic Center Revitalization Project from Noise Control Ordinance, Municipal Code Section 8.47.040 and 8.47.060 to accommodate construction activities.
ATTACHMENT(S)
1. Request from Edgemoor Infrastructure and Real Estate
90 7900 Westpark Drive | McLean, VA 22102
p: 301.272.2910 | edgemoor.com
Tuesday, December 3, 2025
Lisa Kim, City Manager
City of Garden Grove
11222 Acacia Parkway
Garden Grove, CA 92840
Subject: Sound Curfew Variance Request
Dear Lisa,
In support of the Garden Grove Civic Center Revitalization Project, I am writing to request a variance to the sound curfew described in Chapter 8.47 of the Code of Ordinances to accommodate construction activities. As part of the project, we anticipate several significant monolithic concrete pours, which are long duration construction activities that often require at least 12 and up to 14-hour days. As a result, earlier start times are essential to allow crews adequate time to complete these activities.
Our request to the sound curfew is as follows:
Current starting time and amplified sound curfew: 7:00 am Proposed starting time and amplified sound curfew: 4:00 am Requested number of days in 2024: 2 days
Requested number of days in 2025: 30 days
Requested number of days in 2026: 15 days
Requested number of days in 2027: 15 days
To support this request, please find attached a noise study that indicates concrete construction activities do not contribute to elevated noise levels during the early morning. In fact, the study attributes the rising noise levels throughout the morning primarily to traffic on Euclid Street, which is closer and has more direct impact on the neighboring residential buildings.
To minimize impact to our neighbors to the greatest extent possible, the project team will utilize white noise backup alarms on all equipment and trucks to reduce activity noise. Additionally, as we continue to work, the project team will seek opportunities to reduce the needed number of variance days, if feasible.
We believe that the proposed earlier start times will enable construction operations to proceed more efficiently and will go a long way in supporting the delivery of this project to the City of Garden Grove.
Thank you for your consideration of this request. Please let me know if you have any questions or need further information.
Sincerely,
Brian Dugan
Project Executive and Managing Director
Docusign Envelope ID: 0D97BED4-502D-4965-823E-760BA741BDBE 91 PROJECT
NUMBER
PROJECT
SUBJECT
REFERENCE
DRAWN BY
SKETCH NUMBER
SUBMITTAL
RFI# SK#
Tier
RFI#
SK#
TIER
SECTION
TIER
ACACIA PARK
CONDOS
GG CITY
HALL
FIRST
BAPTIST
CHURCH
OCFA FIRE
STATION 81
GGCC
PROJECT SITE
Reading Locations
Garden Grove Civic Center - 23109B1
Decibel Reading Exhibit
AR
Docusign Envelope ID: 0D97BED4-502D-4965-823E-760BA741BDBE 92 PROJECT
NUMBER
PROJECT
SUBJECT
REFERENCE
DRAWN BY
SKETCH NUMBER
SUBMITTAL
RFI# SK#
Tier
RFI#
SK#
TIER
SECTION
TIER
Garden Grove Civic Center - 23109B1
Decibel Reading Exhibit
12/03/2024
AR
Docusign Envelope ID: 0D97BED4-502D-4965-823E-760BA741BDBE 93 Item 509/2024
Final
City of Garden Grove
INTER-DEPARTMENT MEMORANDUM
To:
Lisa L. Kim From: Ursula Luna-Reynosa
Dept:
City Manager Dept: Economic Development and
Housing
Date: 12/10/2024
Subject: Award a contract to Silverstone Property Management Company to provide comprehensive property, facilities, and project management services for the city-owned property located at 11277 Garden Grove Blvd. (Cost: $50,000) (Action Item)
OBJECTIVE
To award a contract to Silverstone Property Management Company (SSPM) for the provision of comprehensive property, facilities, and project management services for the city -owned Purcell Building located at 11277 Garden Grove Boulevard (“Property”).
BACKGROUND
On July 12, 2022, the City Council approved the purchase of the Property, a two-story office building with approximately 16,000 square feet per floor. The Property provides office space for City tenants, including:
Garden Grove Housing Authority
Garden Grove Police Department
Garden Grove Emergency Operations Center
Garden Grove Channel 3 TV
Additionally, the Property includes leased tenants, such as Be Well OC, OC Wellness Center, and Clark Construction.
To ensure proper oversight of the property, including day-to-day management, maintenance, and future improvements, a commercial property management firm is necessary to address the City’s operational and ownership objectives.
DISCUSSION
The City issued a formal Request for Proposals (R FP-GPM-NO.2401) via PlanetBids to solicit comprehensive real estate services for the Property. The scope included, but was not limited 94 Item 509/2024
to, operational oversight, financial reporting, procurement, maintenance, repair, and project management services. Three firms submitted proposals, which were evaluated by a selection panel consisting of representatives from the Economic Development and Finance Departments. The evaluation criteria included:
Relevant experience and qualifications
Ability to perform the required scope of services
Financial reporting capability
Maintenance and repair management expertise
References and oral interviews
Silverstone Property Management Company (SSPM) demonstrated qualifications to meet the City’s criteria. Reference checks confirmed their expertise in managing similar properties.
Under the proposed agreement, SSPM Scope of Services will provide:
1. Property Management Services: Day -to-day operational management, budget preparation, monthly statements, routine inspections, and security oversight.
2. Facilities Management Services: Maintenance and repair of building systems (HVAC, plumbing, electrical, and mechanical), janitorial services, grounds keeping, waste disposal, and emergency response planning.
3. Project Management Services: Oversight of tenant improvement projects, including building code compliance, zoning, planning, and environmental due diligence. Notably, this includes the procurement and installation of a new HVAC system planned for spring 2025.
FINANCIAL IMPACT
Funds are available and will be expended from the Real Property Account (212 -715-1000- NC1348000) in the FY 24 -25 Economic Development and Housing Department operational budget. No additional appropriations are needed at this time.
The annual property management cost is $15,000. Additional project management and on - call repair costs, up to $35,000, may be incurred. The total contract amount is not-to-exceed (NTE) $50,000 per year.
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended that the City Council:
Award a contract to Silverstone Property Management Company (SSPM) in the amount of $50,000.00, to provide property management and project management services for the city-owned Purcell Building located at 11277 Garden Grove Boulevard; and
95 Item 509/2024
Authorize the City Manager or designee to execute the agreement, additional option years, amendments, and make minor modifications as necessary, on behalf of the City.
By: Greg Blodgett, Deputy Director
Alana Cheng, Administrative Officer
ATTACHMENT(S)
1. Silverstone PM Proposal - 11277 Garden Grove Blvd
2. Silverstone Property Management Agreement. 12.10.24
96 Prepared by:
Cloe Learn : Director
[email protected]
Silverstone Property Management Co.
Office Address: 388 East Valley Blvd Suite 105
Alhambra, CA, 91801
Proposal for Facility Management Services
Prepared for:
Greg Blodgett
City of Garden Grove- The Purcell Building
Property Address: 11277 Garden Grove Blvd,
Garden Grove, CA 92840
Location: 11277 Garden Grove Blvd, Garden Grove, CA 92840 97 388 East Valley Blvd., Suite #105, Alhambra, CA 91801 . Bus. 626−458−6262 Text. (601) 202−1072 www. SilverstonePM.com
Cover Letter
Dear Greg Blodgett,
I would like to express my sincere appreciation for granting Silverstone Property Management ("SSPM") the opportunity to present our comprehensive services to your esteemed property.
At SSPM, we pride ourselves on delivering a wide range of services covering all aspects of real estate, including Property Management, Lease Administration, Facility Management Services, Business Development, Leasing, and Market Analysis.
Our expertise extends to managing various commercial properties such as Shopping Centers, Offices, Medical Centers, Apartments, and Hotels. With over two decades of experience, SSPM has been entrusted with the management of your building for the past 20 years. This extensive tenure has endowed us with an intimate familiarity with both the building itself and its tenants.
Allow us to outline the services we offer:
Property Management Service: Our management services encompass overseeing the day-to-day operations of your property, preparing income forecasts and expense budgets, providing computerized monthly statements and reports, and ensuring timely collection of rent and payment of property expenses. Additionally, we conduct routine property inspections, supervise on-site staff, and handle lease documentation and renewals.
Facilities Management Services: Our facilities management services encompass a range of activities designed to ensure the smooth operation of buildings, from maintenance and repair to energy management and waste disposal. These services can include janitorial and cleaning services, groundskeeping, HVAC and plumbing maintenance, electrical and mechanical repairs, and emergency response planning, as well as more specialized services like pest control and elevator maintenance. Effective facilities management can help reduce downtime, improve worker productivity, and enhance overall occupant satisfaction.
Project Management: Our project management services cover building code resolutions, site zoning documentation and planning, environmental and due diligence coordination, and negotiation of development agreements.
This letter provides only a brief introduction to our services. We would welcome the opportunity to meet with you to discuss your specific requirements in more detail. Enclosed, is our company brochure for your review. Should you have any questions or require further information, please do not hesitate to contact us.
Thank you for considering SSPM for your property management needs. We look forward to the possibility of collaborating with you.
Sincerely,
Cloe Learn, CPM®
Director | Broker
388 E. Valley Blvd. Suite 105, Alhambra, CA 91801
1470 Valley Vista Dr., Suite 101, Diamond Bar, CA 91765 (626)458-6262 Office (601)202-1072 Text
[email protected]
98 388 East Valley Blvd., Suite #105, Alhambra, CA 91801 . Bus. 626−458−6262 Text. (601) 202−1072 www. SilverstonePM.com
Proposal for Facility Management Services 1
Cloe Learn, CPM® 2
1. Executive Summary 4
2. Approach to Services 5
3. Relevant Experience 6
4. References 11
5. Vendors 13
Professionals and Licensed Vendors proposed for 11277 Garden Grove Blvd, Garden Gr… 13 Seacliff Mechanical Services (SMS) (Plumbing) 13
6. Yardi Breeze Management Software & Service Ticket Entry 14
7.Repair, Maintenance/Operations Program 16
8. Insurance 18
9. Acknowledgement Of Terms Of Agreement & Fees 19
Statement of Compliance 20
99 388 East Valley Blvd., Suite #105, Alhambra, CA 91801 . Bus. 626−458−6262 Text. (601) 202−1072 www. SilverstonePM.com
1. Executive Summary
Silverstone Property Management Co. comprehensive property management services ensure the seamless operation of your real estate assets round-the-clock. We excel in overseeing day-to-day operations. • On-site staff supervision and training
• Development of energy conservation plans
• Planning and supervision of tenant improvements, renovations, and rehabilitation projects • Obtain bids, selecting contracts/vendors, negotiating terms, reviewing contracts, and coordinating services
• Conduct routine physical property inspections
• Analyze, monitor, and enforce policies
100
388 East Valley Blvd., Suite #105, Alhambra, CA 91801 . Bus. 626−458−6262 Text. (601) 202−1072 www. SilverstonePM.com
2. Approach to Services
• Staff, Personnel and Vendors
-SSPM will not employ any onsite personnel at the location - 11277 Garden Grove Blvd CA, 92840. SSPM will send out suitable vendors for each service request and department. SSPM will conduct monthly property inspections regularly to ensure that necessary preventative maintenance is carried out. • Conduct Routine Physical Property Inspection
-Field technicians in our service department will coordinate routine physical property inspections on a monthly calendar basis to provide accurate information regarding, but not limited to the common areas, elevators, parking lots, electrical/mechanical rooms, roof and any other areas pertaining to the building.
These inspections will be followed through with a report and live pictures, allowing viewers to gain a proper understanding of the daily building operations and necessities. • Obtain Bids, Contract/Vendor Selections, Negotiating, Contract Review and Coordination -Service Department will properly collect and review any related work and information regarding the buildings service operations with vendors, bids, building projects, and service repairs. Among these items, our service department will attentively review and make recommendations when obtaining bids. Properly analyzing each bid will ensure the accurate scope of work is being met and completed. • HVAC
• Plumbing
• Locksmith
• Pest Control
• Fire Sprinklers
• Fire Extinguishers
• Fire Alarm Monitoring
• Backflow
• Roof Services
• Graffiti Removal
• Landscape Maintenance
• Parking Lot Sweeping
• Electrical Repair Services & Maintenance
• Elevator Maintenance
• Window Cleaning
101
388 East Valley Blvd., Suite #105, Alhambra, CA 91801 . Bus. 626−458−6262 Text. (601) 202−1072 www. SilverstonePM.com
3. Relevant Experience
1. Signal Hill Town Center West
Property Address: 1600 E Willow St Signal Hill CA 90755- 1920 E Willow St Signal Hill CA 90755 SSPM manages Signal Hill Town Center, a shopping center in Signal Hill, encompassing approximately 350,000 sqft.
Some of the key tenants include:-Food 4 Less-Starbucks-Chevron-McDonalds-Black Bear Dinner- The Breakfast Nook alongside other small independent businesses.
SSPM is responsible for the daily management of Signal Hill Town Center West, including property marketing, lease renewals, service operations, building renovations, city compliances, and project amenities.
One of the notable additions brought to this shopping center by SSPM is the installation of 28 Supercharger stations, powered and operated by TESLA, providing an exciting new amenity for visitors and showcasing trusted partnerships with leading companies.
102
388 East Valley Blvd., Suite #105, Alhambra, CA 91801 . Bus. 626−458−6262 Text. (601) 202−1072 www. SilverstonePM.com
2. Valley Vista Office Condo
Property Address: 1470 Valley Vista Dr. Diamond Bar, CA 91765 SSPM manages and oversees the internal operations for this office condo. Valley Vista Office Condo is the first office condominium development in the city of Diamond Bar, right on Corporate Center.
With the expertise from SSPM, the existing office building of approximately 50,000 sqft was transformed and subdivided into 22 modern, high demand office condos.
SSPM has actively participated in the renovation of Diamond Bar's Corporate Center, granting Silverstone the opportunity to introduce a completely new office environment for investors and owners. Leveraging our expertise and knowledge, Valley Vista Office Condos has been established as the benchmark for other projects.
This two-story office building, is surrounded with natural light and scenic landscape. 103
388 East Valley Blvd., Suite #105, Alhambra, CA 91801 . Bus. 626−458−6262 Text. (601) 202−1072 www. SilverstonePM.com
3. Empire Financial Center- Alhambra
Property Address: 388 East Valley Blvd Alhambra CA 91801 Empire Financial Center in Alhambra is home to one of the HQ offices SSPM resides in. This professional business center provides convenient above & ground parking and security guard service. Suites range in size from 1,200 to 3,000 square feet to meet a wide variety of business needs.
Current tenants at this property include, Keller Williams Executive Real Estate Office, ICBC USA (International Bank), Bank of East Asia and Fortune Securities.
At Empire Financial Center, SSPM is in charge of administering, managing, and overseeing all day-to-day operations. SSPM handles all marketing, lease renewals, new tenant acquisitions, move-ins and move-outs involving new or existing tenants.
Under SSPM's supervision is an Onsite Security Guard who is available Monday through Friday along with a Janitorial Team who is responsible for maintaining the upkeep and presentation of the building. 104
388 East Valley Blvd., Suite #105, Alhambra, CA 91801 . Bus. 626−458−6262 Text. (601) 202−1072 www. SilverstonePM.com
4. Villa Grande Business Condo
Property Address: 17100 Norwalk Blvd Cerritos, CA 90703 Villa Grande Business Condo is the first business condominium project in the city of Cerritos, recognized for its modern, functional, and attractive commercial condominium building.
The 2.52 acre property, with over 38,000 square feet, has been renovated and upgraded by SSPM, resulting in a value increase to approximately 16 million dollars.
The Silverstone team successfully presented the Villa Grande project to our investor clients, providing them with precise consulting and project management services from inception to completion.
The primary objective was to maximize return on investment, which required meticulous attention to detail throughout the entire process, encompassing design, subdivision processes, permitting, contractor hiring, renovations, supervision, marketing, and sales.
105
388 East Valley Blvd., Suite #105, Alhambra, CA 91801 . Bus. 626−458−6262 Text. (601) 202−1072 www. SilverstonePM.com
5. Greenleaf Shopping Village, Whittier
Property Address: 7201/7203/7205 Greenleaf Ave, Whittier CA 90602 The Greenleaf Shopping Village is host to several esteemed businesses, including The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf, Greenleaf Cafe, Supercuts, Prime Boudoir, H&R Block, and more.
Spanning approximately, 60,000 square feet, this shopping center is located in the Uptown Whittier neighborhood.
At Greenleaf Shopping Village, SSPM is responsible for overseeing all day-to-day operations, which encompass marketing, lease renewals, building compliances, renovations, inspections, and building development.
The presence of a Day Porter allows SSPM to swiftly address any issues with an expedited response time. The Day Porter is available on site from 10am-2pm every day of the week. 106
388 East Valley Blvd., Suite #105, Alhambra, CA 91801 . Bus. 626−458−6262 Text. (601) 202−1072 www. SilverstonePM.com
4. References
1. Property Name: Empire Plaza- Financial Service Center Address: 388 East Valley Blvd Alhambra, CA 91801
Approx. 55,011 square footage
Owner: Amay Family Partnership
Contact: Derek Tsai [email protected]
Phone Number: (323) 583- 3502
Managing and overseeing a three-story commercial office building.
2. Property Name: Class A, Office Building
Address: 1470 Valley Vista Dr, Diamond Bar CA 91765
Approx. 52,153 square footage
Owner: Valley Vista Office Condo Association
Contact: Susie Tsai [email protected]
Phone Number: (323) 809-1930
Manage and Oversee 2 story commercial building for owner.
3. Property Name: Optum Medical Building
Address: 8311 E. Florence Ave, Downey CA 90240
Approx. 25,579 square footage
Owner: Golden Bull Investment LLC
Contact: Anna [email protected]
Phone Number: (626) 512-8138
Manager Medical Building for Owner, Property being Leased to Medical Business. 107
388 East Valley Blvd., Suite #105, Alhambra, CA 91801 . Bus. 626−458−6262 Text. (601) 202−1072 www. SilverstonePM.com
4. Property Name: Towne Center
Address: 1600/1800 E. Willow St Signal Hill CA 90755
Approx. 83,433 square footage
Owner: Towne Center West LLC
Contact: Arthur [email protected]
Phone Number: (626) 512-0899
Manage and oversee commercial shopping center for owner.
5. Name: Dr. Christopher Yi- Three Office Locations (LA County) Facility Management and Leasing
Website: vvmd.com
Phone Number: (949) 229-2003
6. Property Name: Olive Residential Property
Address: 121 Olive St Glendale CA 91206
Approx. 17,100 square footage with 18 units
Owner: Louis Tseng and Tina Tseng
Contact: Louis [email protected]
Phone Number: (626) 833-6783
Manage and Oversee 2 story residential apartment complex with 18 units.
Print Name: Cloe Learn Date: 11/27/2024 Signature :
108
388 East Valley Blvd., Suite #105, Alhambra, CA 91801 . Bus. 626−458−6262 Text. (601) 202−1072 www. SilverstonePM.com
5. Vendors
Professionals and Licensed Vendors proposed for 11277 Garden Grove Blvd, Garden Grove, CA, 92840 • Seacliff Mechanical Services (SMS) (Plumbing)
• Top Notch Top Notch Plumbing (Plumbing)
• Anderson Commercial Plumbing (Plumbing)
• Elder & Young Plumbing (Plumbing)
• Seacliff Mechanical Services (SMS) (HVAC)
• Triton Air (HVAC)
• Evolution Mechanical (HVAC)
• Eddie Sieus's Perfect Lock & Security (Locksmith)
• Zac Key's (Locksmith)
• Hill's Bros. Lock & Safe (Locksmith)
• Dewey Pest Control (Pest)
• Hydrex Pest Control (Pest)
• C2C Pest Control (Pest)
• Rumble Fish (Pest)
• Blackbird Fire Protection (Fire Sprinklers)
• Kelly's Fire Protection (Fire Sprinklers)
• Fortis Fire & Safety (Fire Sprinklers)
• J&F Fire Extinguishers (Fire Extinguisher)
• Blackbird Fire Protection (Fire Extinguisher)
• Certified Fire Extinguisher (Fire Extinguisher)
• ERS Security (Fire Alarm)
• United Security Systems Inc. (Fire Alarm)
• Cintas Fire Protection (Fire Alarm)
• Aqua Tech Backflow (Backflow)
• Basic Backflow (Backflow)
• Cintas Fire Protection (Backflow)
• Goliath Roofing (Electrical)
• Horizon Lighting (Electrical)
• Amelec Co. (Electrical)
• Goliath Roofing (Roof)
• Atlas Roofing (Roof)
• Highland Roofing (Highland Roofing)
• Graffiti Pros LA (Graffiti Removal)
• Orange County Graffiti Removal
• Max Elevators (Elevator)
• Excelsior Elevator (Elevator)
• New Way Landscape (Landscape)
• Rancho Landscape (Landscape)
• Southern California Tree & Landscape ( Landscape)
109
388 East Valley Blvd., Suite #105, Alhambra, CA 91801 . Bus. 626−458−6262 Text. (601) 202−1072 www. SilverstonePM.com
6. Yardi Breeze Management Software & Service Ticket Entry How to Submit and Track Service Maintenance Request - Live 24/7 Clients will have access to our 24/7 Remote Management System software, allowing them to submit, monitor, and follow up on service requests—whether current, past, or future. After gaining access, you can log in to view real-time information regarding the property we manage on your behalf.
To submit a maintenance request, please follow these steps:
1. Open your Property Portfolio.
2. Navigate to the Maintenance Tab.
3. Click on Maintenance Requests and select "Add New."
4. On this page, you will encounter a series of fields that require your input.
You will need to specify the "Property" for which you are submitting a request; in this instance, it will be listed as "The Purcell Building."
No information is required for the following fields: Unit, Tenant, Tech Notes, Access Notes, Due Date, and Vendor, as these will be completed by Property Management.
Once your ticket is submitted, Property Management will be immediately notified, allowing them to assign a technician or contractor to address the service request. 110
388 East Valley Blvd., Suite #105, Alhambra, CA 91801 . Bus. 626−458−6262 Text. (601) 202−1072 www. SilverstonePM.com
Instructions on Submitting A Service Request Ticket
Example of a Blank Maintenance Request Form
Example of a Submitted Maintenance Request Form
111
388 East Valley Blvd., Suite #105, Alhambra, CA 91801 . Bus. 626−458−6262 Text. (601) 202−1072 www. SilverstonePM.com
7.Repair, Maintenance/Operations Program
a. Maintenance Personnel:
- All maintenance for the property located at 11277 Garden Grove Blvd, Garden Grove, CA, 92840 will be handled by contract work or on-call services from our shared Vendor List. Scheduled work will take place during Local Business Hours to prevent overtime or weekend work. The Proposer will consult with the City for approval if overtime or weekend work is necessary.
b. Reactive Service Calls:
- The Proposer will have an approval budget of $1,000.00 for any reactive or emergency service call required to be completed on site. For service calls above the approval limit, the Proposer will follow up with the City for approval and may reach out to nearby vendors or utilize the building's vendor list for a second estimate. c. After-Hours Service Calls and Emergency Responses:
- Any after-hour service call or emergency response will be directed to the building service supervisor, who will analyze the situation and address the issue accordingly. The building service supervisor will either contact a vendor for service repair or the required building vendor for assistance. Our allocated Vendors work 24/7 and will be available for any after hours call or emergencies, as needed. d. Property Inspections:
- The proposer will schedule property inspections twice a month with the building's service supervisor.
Inspections will consist of a full perimeter walkthrough of the interior and exterior of the property, including live pictures and a detailed report suggesting any necessary repairs, such as HVAC, Roof, Fire Alarm, Sprinklers, Plumbing, Electrical, Mechanical and others. e. How the Proposer will ensure the Property is adequately maintained:
- The proposer will hold all designated vendors, contractors, and assigned personnel accountable for maintaining the building 24/7. With onsite personnel and monthly property visits by the building service supervisor, all areas will be overseen daily to ensure the right preventative maintenance services are implemented, minimizing any reactive service calls to the building. 112
388 East Valley Blvd., Suite #105, Alhambra, CA 91801 . Bus. 626−458−6262 Text. (601) 202−1072 www. SilverstonePM.com
f. A description of the process for emergency service and project specialized work:
In the case of emergency service and project specialized work, the building service supervisor will communicate and coordinate important information such as times, dates, and notes with onsite personnel and representatives of 11277 Garden Grove Blvd, Garden Grove, CA 92840. They will then collaborate with allocated Vendors to determine who will be onsite to effectively address the issue. If the emergency occurs during business hours, the building service supervisor may arrange for designated rooms or compartments to be accessible for vendors and technicians to use as needed. However, if the event takes place afterhours or on weekends, the building service supervisor may be present onsite to assist with the necessary arrangements for repairs or projects. Building service supervisor, Fidel Moreno, will handle the dispatch of the recommended vendor to address the issue appropriately.
g. Describe the outside vendor services the Proposer typically employs; - The proposer utilizes vendors recommended for the property or those with a history of servicing the building.
Ideally, the vendor list would include vendors servicing the building on a yearly schedule for Plumbing, HVAC, Fire Sprinklers, Fire Extinguishers, Pest Control, Roof, Backflow, and others. The proposer may also seek competitive bids/estimates for certain service repairs to ensure the cost recommendations are being taken. h. Describe how vendors are initially vetted. Describe how vendors' performance are monitored; - Upon reviewing any new vendor inquiry, the proposer ensures that required documents (e.g., Certificate of Insurance, Licenses, Permits, Garden Grove Business License Good Standing) are collected before assigning any service work. Work is assigned to the vendor on an as-needed basis or contract once the process is completed and confirmed. The building service supervisor reviews and confirms all work before invoice payment is processed. Any vendors failing to meet obligations or standards are removed from the list. i. How will the Proposer assist the City identify and correct potential safety risks or hazard. - Using Property inspections, reports, and live pictures, the proposer immediately presents any presented or potential safety risk/hazard to the City. Once the information is gathered, appropriate solutions are implemented to address the issue.
j. A description of the process for routine maintenance. Provide a sample scheduled/preventative maintenance plan (quarterly and annually)
- Routine Maintenance for 11277 Garden Grove Blvd, Garden Grove, CA, 92840, will be categorized into its own department service such as;
- Elevator - Roof - Fire Alarm Panel - Fire Extinguishers - Plumbing - HVAC - Fire Sprinklers- Backflows & Common Area Routine Maintenance- Electrical 113
388 East Valley Blvd., Suite #105, Alhambra, CA 91801 . Bus. 626−458−6262 Text. (601) 202−1072 www. SilverstonePM.com
8. Insurance
114
388 East Valley Blvd., Suite #105, Alhambra, CA 91801 . Bus. 626−458−6262 Text. (601) 202−1072 www. SilverstonePM.com
9. Acknowledgement Of Terms Of Agreement & Fees
Acknowledgement of Terms
We hereby acknowledge and agree to the terms and conditions outlined in the Property Management Proposal. a. Facilities Management Fee - $2,500.00 Monthly
Signature: Date: 11/27/2024 115
388 East Valley Blvd., Suite #105, Alhambra, CA 91801 . Bus. 626−458−6262 Text. (601) 202−1072 www. SilverstonePM.com
Statement of Compliance
The undersigned Proposer declares that the Proposal submitted to furnish Facilities Management Services for Property: 11277 Garden Grove Blvd, Garden Grove, CA, 92840 per the RFP specifications as described in, and in response to the City of Garden Grove RFP GPM-NO. 2301 was prepared in strict compliance with the instructions, conditions, and terms listed in the Request for Proposal, Scope of Services, and Draft Agreement, with exceptions listed below, if applicable. At least one box for each item must be checked.
RFP Instructions an Terms and Conditions (Check One)
No exceptions Taken Exceptions Taken Scope of Services (Check One)
No exceptions Taken Exceptions Taken Draft Agreement/Insurance Requirements (Check One)
No exceptions Taken Exceptions Taken If any exceptions are taken, this Statement of Compliance shall include a narrative that identifies each item to which the Proposer is taking exception or is recommending change, including the suggested rewording of the contractual obligations or suggested change in the Request for Proposal, and identifies the reasons for submitting the proposed exception or change. When available, please reference specific line item as provided in the Request for Proposal. The City reserves the right to rule as non-responsive and reject any Proposals that are not accompanied with the required documentation as described above.
Proposer's Name: Silverstone Property Management Co.
Signature:
Print Name: Cloe Learn Date: 11/27/2024 Print Title: Director
116
1 PROFESSIONAL SERVICES AGREEMENT
THIS “PROFESSIONAL SERVICES AGREEMENT” (this “Agreement”) is made this day of , 2024 by the CITY OF GARDEN GROVE, a municipal corporation, (“CITY”), and SILVERSTONE PROPERTY MANAGEMENT COMPANY, herein after referred to as ‘‘CONSULTANT”.
RECITALS
The following recitals are a substantive part of this Agreement:
1. This Agreement is entered into pursuant to Garden Grove Council Resolution No. 9212-14 (January 28, 2014).
2. CITY desires to utilize the services of CONSULTANT to provide comprehensive property, facilities, and project management services including by not limited to, vendor procurement, day -to-day opera tions management, maintenance, future tenant improvements, and 24/7 availability and response to incidental repairs and emergencies on an “as-needed” basis for the city-owned property located at 11277 Garden Grove Blvd, known as Purcell Building.
3. CITY does not have the personnel to accomplish said services.
4. CONSULTANT is qualified by virtue of experience, training, education and expertise to accomplish the required services.
AGREEMENT
THE PARTIES MUTUALLY AGREE AS FOLLOWS:
1. Term of Agreement. The term of the agreement shall be for a period of six (6) months from the date of full execution through June 30, 2025 , with options to extend said agreement for four (4) additional one-year periods corresponding the City’s July 1 through June 30 fiscal year. Option years shall be exercised at the end of the set agreement date, at the sole option of the CITY. This agreement may be terminated by the City without cause. In such event, the CITY will compensate CONSULTANT for work performed to date in accordance with Scope of Services Proposal attached as Exhibit “A” and Section 3 of this Agreement. CONSULTANT is required to present evidence to support work performed.
2. Services to be Provided. The services to be performed by CONSULTANT shall consist of the Scope of Services listed in Exhibit “A” and is incorporated herein by reference. Exhibit “A” and this Agreement do not guarantee any specific amount of work. CONSULTANT warrants that all services will be performed in a competent, professional and satisfactory manner in accordance with customary and usual practices in CONSULTANT’S profession and the standards prevalent in the industry for such services. By executing this Agreement, CONSULTANT warrants that it has 117
2 carefully considered how the work should be performed and fully understands the facilities, difficulties, and restrictions attending perf ormance of the work under this Agreement.
3. Compensation. CONSULTANT shall be compensated as follows:
3.1 Amount. CONSULTANT shall be compensated for the services provided under this Agreement pursuant to the fee structure described in Exhibit “A” and made a part hereof by reference. Total compensation payable by CITY to CONSULTANT under this Agreement shall not exce ed the total amount of Fifty Thousand Dollars and 00/100 cents ($50,000.00) for the term of six (6) months. The cost breakdown is detailed as follows:
a) CONSULTANT will establish a trust account which the CONSULTANT will use for reimbursable costs and thir d party contractor expenses associated with property maintenance and emergency repairs. The CITY will deposit into the account Seventeen Thousand Five Hundred Dollars and 00/100 cents ($17,500.00) every t hree (3) months, totaling ($35,000.00) for the first six (6) month period, unless the CITY determines that sufficient reserves remain in the account from the initial deposit. CONSULTANT shall provide updates on the reserve balance at the end of each month and shall notify CITY if the reserve balance falls below $5,000.00.
b) b) Property and Facility Man agement fee shall be a flat $2,500.00 per month , totaling Fifteen Thousand Dollars and 00/1 00 cents ($15,000.00) for the first six (6) month period.
c) c) Unless otherwise mutually agreed by the parties in writi ng, CONSULTANT shall not be compensated for any services rendered in connection with its performance of this Agreement, which are in addition to those set forth herein.
3.2 Payment. For property management services under this Agreement, payment shall be made per invoice submitted by CONSULTANT due and payable within 45 days. Payment shall be made in accordance with the Proposal in Exhibit “A”.
3.3 Records of Expenses . CONSULTANT shall keep complete and accurate records of costs and incidental expenses subject to the fees or reimbursement payable hereunder. These records will be made available at the end of each month and at reasonable times to CITY.
3.4 Termination. CITY and CONSULTANT shall each have the right to terminate this Agreement, without cause, by giving thirty (30) days written notice of termination to the other party. If the Agreement is terminated by CITY, then the provisions of this Section 3 shall apply to that portion of the work completed. In such event, CITY will compensate 118
3 CONSULTANT for work performed to date in accordance with the Proposal.
CONSULTANT is required to present evidence to support performed work.
4. Insurance Requirements
4.1 Commencement of Work. CONSULTANT shall not commence work under this Agreement until all certificates and required endorsements have been received and approved by the CITY. CONSULTANT shall notify the CITY of any material change, cancellation, or termination at least thirty (30) days in advance.
4.2 Workers Compensation Insurance . For the duration of this Agreement, CONSULTANT shall maintain Workers Compensation Insurance in the amount and type required by law, if applicable. The insurer shall waive its rights of subrogation against the CITY, its officers, officials, agents, employees, and volunteers.
4.3 Insurance Amounts. CONSULTANT shall maintain the following insurance for the duration of this Agreement:
a) Commercial general liability in an amount of $1,000,000 per occurrence; (claims made and modified occurrence policies are not acceptable); Insurance companies must be reasonably acceptable to CITY, admitted and licensed in California , and have a Best’s Guide Rating of A-, Class VIII or better;
b) Automobile liability in an amount of $1,000,000 per occurrence; (claims made and modi fied occurrence policies are not acceptable) Insurance companies must be reasonably acceptable to CITY, admitted and licensed in California, and have a Best’s Guide Rating of A-, Class VIII or better.
c) Professional liability in an amount of $1,000,000 per occurrence; Insurance companies must be reasonably acceptable to CITY and have an AM Best’s Guide Rating of A-, Class VIII or better. If the policy is written on a “claims made” basis, the policy shall be continued in full force and effect at all times during the term of the Agreement, and for a period of three (3) years from the date of the completion of services provided. In the event of termination, cancellation, or material change in the policy, CONSULTANT shall obtain continuing insurance coverage for the prior acts or omissions of CONSULTANT during the course of performing services under the term of the agreement. The coverage shall be evidenced by either a new policy evidencing no gap in coverage, or by obtaining separate extended “tail” coverage w ith the present or new carrier.
The policy under section 4.3 (a) shall include CITY, its officers, officials, employees, agents, and volunteers as additional insureds for liability 119
4 arising out of work or operations performed by the CONSULTANT to the extent of losses attributable to CONSULTANT’S negligence. CONSULTANT shall provide to CITY proof of insurance and relevant endorsement forms that conform to CITY’s requirements, as approved by the CITY.
The policy under section 4.3 (b) shall include CITY, its officers, officials, employees, agents, and volunteers as additional insureds to the extent of losses attributable to CONSULTANT’S negligence for automobiles owned, leased, hired, or borrowed by CONSULTANT. CONSULTANT shall provide to CITY proof of insurance and relevant endorsement forms that conform to CITY’s requirements, as approved by the CITY.
CONSULTANT’s insurance coverage shall be primary insurance as respects to CITY, its officers, officials, employees, agents, and volunteers to the extent of losses attributable to CONSULTANT’S negligence. Any insurance or self-insurance maintained by the CITY, its officers, officials, employees, agents, or volunteers shall be excess of the CONSULTANT’s insurance and shall not contribute with it.
5. Non-Liability of Officials and Employees of the CITY . No official or employee of CITY shall be personally liable to CONSULTANT in the event of any default or breach by CITY, or for any amount, which may become due to CONSULTANT.
6. Non-Discrimination. CONSULTANT covenants there shall be no discrimination against any person or group due to race, color, creed, religion, sex, marital status, age, handicap, national origin or ancestry, in any activity pursuant to this Agreement.
7. Independent Contractor. It is agreed to that CONSULTANT shall act and be an independent contractor and not an agent or employee of CITY, and shall obtain no rights to any benefits which accrue to CITY’s employees.
8. Compliance With Law . CONSULTANT shall comply with all applica ble laws, ordinances, codes and regulations of the federal, state and local government.
CONSULTANT shall comply with, and shall be responsible for causing all contractors and subcontractors performing any of the work pursuant to this Agreement to comply w ith, all applicable federal and state labor standards, including, to the extent applicable, the prevailing wage requirements promulgated by the Director of Industrial Relations of the State of California Department of Labor. The CITY makes no warranty or representation concerning whether any of the work performed pursuant to this Agreement constitutes public works subject to the prevailing wage requirements.
9. Disclosure of Documents. All documents or other information developed or received by CONSULTANT are confidential and shall not be disclosed without authorization by CITY, unless disclosure is required by law.
120
5 10. Ownership of Work Product . All documents or other information developed or received by CONSULTANT shall be the property of CITY. CONSULTANT shall provide CITY with copies of these items upon demand or upon termination of this Agreement.
11. Conflict of Interest and Reporting . CONSULTANT shall at all times avoid conflict of interest or appearance of conflict of interest in performance of t his Agreement.
12. Notices. All notices shall be personally delivered or mailed to the below listed addresses, or to such other addresses as may be designated by written notice.
These addresses shall be used for delivery of service of process.
(a) Address of CONSULTANT is as follows:
Silverstone Property Management Company
388 E Valley Blvd Ste 105
Alhambra, CA 91801
Attn: Cloe Learn, CPM
[email protected]
(626) 458-6262
(b) Address of CITY is as follows (with a copy to):
Eric Hong/Alana Cheng City Attorney
Economic Development & Housing Dept. City of Garden Grove City of Garden Grove P.O. Box 3070
P.O. Box 3070 Garden Grove, CA 92840
Garden Grove, CA 92840
[email protected]
(714) 741-5337
13. CONSULTANT’S Proposal . This Agreement shall include CONSULTANT’ s proposal dated November 15, 2024 , on file with the City Clerk , which is incorporated herein by reference. In the event of any inconsistency between the terms of the Proposal and this Agreement, this Agreement shall govern.
14. Licenses, Permits and Fees. At its sole expense, CONSULTANT shall obtain a Garden Grove Business License, all permits and licenses as may be required by this Agreement.
15. Familiarity With Work. By executing this Agreement, CONSULTANT warrants that: (1) it has investigated the work to be performed; (2) it has investigated the site of the work and is aware of all conditions there; and (3) it understands the facilities, difficulties and restrictions of the work under this Agreement.
Should CONSULTANT discover any latent or unknown conditions materially differing from those inherent in the work or as represented by CITY, it shall 121
6 immediately inform CITY of this and shall not proceed, except at CONSULTANT’S risk, until written instructions are received from CITY.
16. Time of Essence. Time is of the essence in the performance of this Agreement.
17. Limitations Upon Subcontracting and Assignment.
a. The experience, knowledge, capability and reputation of CONSULTANT, its principals and employees were a substantial inducement for CITY to enter into this Agreement. CONSULTANT shall not contract with any other entity to perform the services required without written approval of the CITY. This Agreement may not be assigned voluntarily or by operation of law, without the prior written approval of CITY. If CONSULTANT is permitted to subcontract any part of this Agreement, CONSULTANT shall be responsible to CITY for the acts and omissions of its subcontractor as it is for persons directly employed. Nothing contained in this Agreement shall create any contractual relationship between any subcontractor and CITY. All persons engaged in the work w ill be considered contractors or agents of CONSULTANT. CITY will deal directly with and will make all payments to CONSULTANT.
b. It is intended in this Agreement that CONSULTANT shall negotiate contracts on behalf of CITY with third party vendors ("Vendors") for minor repairs, maintenance and servicing of the Property, consistent with industry standards. Such service contracts shall be entered into with Vendors by CONSULTANT as agent for and in the name of CITY and terminable with respect to the Property on 30 days' notice or less, unless otherwise approved by CITY. CONSULTANT shall require Vendors to provide insurance and indemnify the CITY to the same extent as required of CONSULTANT pursuant to this Agreement.
18. Authority to Execute. The persons executing this Agreement on behalf of the parties warrant that they are duly authorized to execute this Agreement and that by executing this Agreement, the parties are formally bound.
19. Indemnification. To the fullest extent permitted by law, CONSULTANT agrees to protect, defend, and hold harmless CITY and its elective or appointive boards, officers, agents, and employees from any and all claims, liabilities, expenses, or damages of any nature, including attorneys' fees, for injury or death of any person, or damages of any nature, including interference with use of property, to the extent attributed to the negligence, recklessness and/or intentional wrongful conduct of CONSULTANT, CONSULTANT'S agents, officers, employees, subcontractors, or independent contractors hired by CONSULTANT in the performance of the Agreement. The only exception to CONSULTANT'S responsibility to protect, defend, and hold harmless CITY, is due to the negligence, recklessness and/or wrongful conduct of CITY, or any of its elective or appointive boards, officers, agents, or employees.
122
7 This hold harmless agreement shall apply to all liability regardless of whether any insurance policies are applicable. The policy limits do not act as a limitation upon the amount of indemnification to be provided by CONSULTANT.
20. Consequential Damages. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in this Agreement, neither CITY nor CONSULTANT shall be liable for any lost or prospective profi ts or any other indirect, consequential, special, incidental, punitive or other exemplary losses or damages, whether in tort, contract or otherwise, regardless of the foreseeability or the cause thereof, that would not otherwise be covered under the standa rd liability or property insurance forms required of the Parties hereunder.
21. Environmental Assessments . Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained herein, CITY acknowledges and understands that CONSULTANT is not qualified to ( a) evaluate the presence or absence of hazardous or toxic substances, mold, waste, materials, electromagnetic field, radon, radioactive materials, or other environmental concerns under applicable law, upon, within, above, or beneath the Property (collectively, "Hazardous Materials"); ( b) maintain or evaluate compliance with environmental, Hazardous Materials or waste laws, rules and regulations; or ( c) conduct or ensure clean -up or remediation of Hazardous Material spills or contamination. CITY agrees that, with respect to any abatement, clean-up or remedial action that CITY desires to implement, CITY shall directly enter into a contract with a qualified and licensed environmental clean-up company to undertake such responsibilities. In no event will CONSULTANT make an inde pendent determination as to the presence or absence of Hazardous Materials, or whether CITY, the Property or any particular tenant is in violation or compliance with any laws relating to Hazardous Materials ("Hazardous Materials Laws"). CONSULTANT will, however, notify CITY in the event it has actual knowledge of any Hazardous Materials in or on the Property or violation of Hazardous Materials Laws at the Property.
22. Modification. This Agreement constitutes the entire agreement between the parties and s upersedes any previous agreements, oral or written. This Agreement may be modified only by subsequent mutual written agreement executed by CITY and CONSULTANT.
23 Waiver. All waivers of the provisions of this Agreement must be in writing by the appropriate authorities of the CITY and CONSULTANT.
24. California Law. This Agreement shall be construed in accordance with the laws of the State of California. Any action commenced about this Agreement shall be filed in the central branch of the Orange County Superior Court.
25. Interpretation. This Agreement shall be interpreted as though prepared by both parties
123
8 26. Preservation of Agreement. Should any provision of this Agreement be found invalid or unenforceable, the decision shall affect only the provision interpreted, and all remaining provisions shall remain enforceable.
\ \ \ \
(Agreement Signature Block on Next Page)
124
9 IN WITNESS THEREOF, these parties have executed this Agreement on the day and year shown below.
Date: _______________
ATTESTED:
City Clerk
Date:
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
Garden Grove City Attorney
“CITY”
CITY OF GARDEN GROVE
By:
City Manager
“CONSULTANT”
SILVERSTONE PROPERTY
MANAGEMENT COMPANY
By:
Name:
Title:
Date:
Tax ID:
Broker License:
Expiration Date:
If CONSULTANT/CONTRACTOR is a
corporation, a Corporate Resolution
and/or Corporate Seal is required. If a
partnership, Statement of Partnership
must be submitted to CITY.
125
EXHIBIT “A”
126
Item 519/2024
Final
City of Garden Grove
INTER-DEPARTMENT MEMORANDUM
To:
Lisa L. Kim From: Patricia Song
Dept:
City Manager Dept: Finance
Date: 12/10/2024
Subject: Receive and file warrants. (Action Item)
OBJECTIVE
For the City Council to receive and file the warrants.
BACKGROUND/DISCUSSION
Attached are the warrants recommended to be received and filed.
FINANCIAL IMPACT
Items listed in the warrants are budgeted.
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended that the City Council:
Receive and file the warrants.
ATTACHMENT(S)
1. 11222024PR
127
City of Garden GroveCertificate of WarrantsRegister Date:Nov 27, 2024This is to certify the demands covered by EFT numbers 00048709 through 00049368 and check numbers 00185979 through 00185990 inclusive as listedon this register and have been verified by the Finance Division as properlyissued and bear all proper signatures.Note: Finance DirectorPatricia Song 128
CITY OF GARDEN GROVEGGFEFM002 Warrant Register PayrollCheck Dates Nov 27, 2024Report Generated on Nov 26, 2024 5:35:16 PM Page 2PY - PayrollCheck Type: CHKCheck Vendor # Vendor Name Issue Date Check Amount00185979 E05264 LAWRENZ, CHRISTIAN M 11/27/2024 $480.7400185980 E05035 NGUYEN, TAN V 11/27/2024 $49.2700185981 E00977 BELAIR, DIANE 11/27/2024 $2,260.5400185982 E05262 FLORES, JAVIER 11/27/2024 $2,338.9700185983 E05120 NGUYEN, VICKY 11/27/2024 $87.4500185984 E04444 JULIENNE, PATRICK R 11/27/2024 $3,921.3900185985 E05287 ROCHOW, BRITTANY A 11/27/2024 $925.1100185986 E05279 CASTILLO, JOSEPH A 11/27/2024 $1,071.7900185987 E05292 JIMENEZ, ROBERT G 11/27/2024 $503.0900185988 E05273 MARTINEZ, ANDRES 11/27/2024 $806.3800185989 E05288 PADILLA, JOE L 11/27/2024 $531.1100185990 E03529 ROCHA, MICHAEL F 11/27/2024 $2,798.84CHK - Total $15,774.68Check Type: EFTCheck Vendor # Vendor Name Issue Date Check Amount00048709 E03973 AVILA, VERONICA 11/27/2024 $869.3500048710 E03982 BECKLES, CAROL E 11/27/2024 $49.2700048711 E04755 BRIETIGAM III, GEORGE S 11/27/2024 $580.9800048712 E02788 DAVIS, JEFFREY P 11/27/2024 $3,126.1800048713 E05080 DOVINH, JOSEPH T 11/27/2024 $646.9700048714 E04994 GREENUP, BREANNA C 11/27/2024 $1,034.5000048715 E00803 GRIMM, PAMELA M 11/27/2024 $2,258.5800048716 E04131 HERREN, NOELLE N 11/27/2024 $2,871.6900048717 E03612 JONES, STEVEN R 11/27/2024 $239.2200048718 E05268 KIM, JUDY M 11/27/2024 $842.3400048719 E04442 KIM, LISA L 11/27/2024 $7,504.0100048720 E04536 KLOPFENSTEIN, STEPHANIE L 11/27/2024 $510.6000048721 E05072 LOPEZ, CARLOS 11/27/2024 $1,334.8500048722 E05263 LYNN, JEANNETTE F 11/27/2024 $884.6800048723 E02787 MORAN, MARIE L 11/27/2024 $3,144.0500048724 E04537 NGUYEN, KIM B 11/27/2024 $637.4800048725 E04534 ONEILL, JOHN R 11/27/2024 $688.64Server Name: cognos.ggcity.org User Name: victoriac 129
CITY OF GARDEN GROVEGGFEFM002 Warrant Register PayrollCheck Dates Nov 27, 2024Report Generated on Nov 26, 2024 5:35:16 PM Page 3Check Vendor # Vendor Name Issue Date Check Amount00048726 E04528 PARK, SHAWN S 11/27/2024 $2,778.0900048727 E01964 PULIDO, ANA E 11/27/2024 $5,072.3500048728 E05057 SATO, MICHI L 11/27/2024 $2,891.0800048729 E05259 SERRATO RODRIGUEZ, DIANA 11/27/2024 $1,874.8300048730 E03715 THAI, KRISTY H 11/27/2024 $0.0000048731 E05079 TRAN, CINDY NGOC 11/27/2024 $688.7800048732 E03983 VASQUEZ, LIZABETH C 11/27/2024 $3,064.9800048733 E04971 VITAL, ANDREA 11/27/2024 $2,019.5900048734 E05192 WEST, MATTHEW S 11/27/2024 $7,331.1700048735 E04944 ANDERSON CAMBA, ASHLEIGH R 11/27/2024 $2,722.7700048736 E04764 BRADLEY, JANNA K 11/27/2024 $3,492.5200048737 E03766 CERDA, MARY C 11/27/2024 $1,460.5300048738 E04673 HART, BRANDI M 11/27/2024 $1,637.1400048739 E04363 KWAN, LIANE Y 11/27/2024 $5,044.9300048740 E01985 LEE, JANY H 11/27/2024 $4,759.7600048741 E05078 SANCHEZ, GIOVANNI P 11/27/2024 $2,481.9300048742 E04417 STEPHENSON, CAITLYN M 11/27/2024 $2,689.7800048743 E02115 STOVER, LAURA J 11/27/2024 $5,619.4700048744 E05286 TRAN BELLEVILLE, LYDIA M 11/27/2024 $2,507.1100048745 E04390 AMBRIZ, STEPHANIE 11/27/2024 $1,532.0100048746 E04445 BROWN, KAREN J 11/27/2024 $1,003.2800048747 E05183 CANTU, JANICE 11/27/2024 $1,902.8300048748 E05068 CASTELLON, ALVARO A 11/27/2024 $4,971.2700048749 E04961 CHAO, VICTORIA 11/27/2024 $1,809.1200048750 E03686 CHAVEZ, JAIME F 11/27/2024 $1,702.4100048751 E03760 CHUNG, JANET J 11/27/2024 $3,264.0500048752 E05094 CORTEZ, ELIZABETH M. 11/27/2024 $2,325.0200048753 E04957 CURTSEIT, MARIA 11/27/2024 $3,419.2700048754 E04960 FUKAZAWA, KEISUKE 11/27/2024 $1,780.6100048755 E05055 GAMINO, LINDA M 11/27/2024 $0.0000048756 E03877 GOMEZ, STEVEN E 11/27/2024 $1,970.9100048757 E03016 HERNANDEZ, GARY F 11/27/2024 $1,745.5200048758 E04569 HOFFMAN, CORINNE L 11/27/2024 $2,574.7500048759 E05167 LOFFLER, SARAH N 11/27/2024 $1,722.9500048760 E00057 MANALANSAN, NEAL M 11/27/2024 $2,395.78Server Name: cognos.ggcity.org User Name: victoriac 130
CITY OF GARDEN GROVEGGFEFM002 Warrant Register PayrollCheck Dates Nov 27, 2024Report Generated on Nov 26, 2024 5:35:16 PM Page 4Check Vendor # Vendor Name Issue Date Check Amount00048761 E01668 MAY, ROBERT W 11/27/2024 $1,733.7300048762 E01393 MENDEZ, ANGELA M 11/27/2024 $2,263.5500048763 E03628 MENDOZA, CHRISTI C 11/27/2024 $2,367.3300048764 E05261 MENDOZA, MARELLA L F 11/27/2024 $1,938.9700048765 E04958 NGO, TINA 11/27/2024 $2,570.7000048766 E02429 PHAM, ANH 11/27/2024 $1,931.9100048767 E03610 RAMIREZ, EVA 11/27/2024 $2,303.9000048768 E04973 RAMOS, NANCY 11/27/2024 $3,891.9000048769 E05097 RODRIGUEZ, SEBASTIAN 11/27/2024 $2,285.5000048770 E03539 SEGAWA, SANDRA E 11/27/2024 $4,682.5400048771 E04780 SONG, YUAN 11/27/2024 $5,721.7200048772 E03085 VICTORIA, PAUL E 11/27/2024 $1,623.9000048773 E04859 VO, MY TRA 11/27/2024 $3,628.7200048774 E05270 VO, NICOLE C 11/27/2024 $1,698.8600048775 E03433 WESTON, RETA J 11/27/2024 $1,341.4100048776 E04674 WHITTAKER DEGEN, HELEN E 11/27/2024 $660.6900048777 E04527 YOO, MEENA 11/27/2024 $2,731.0600048778 E04493 ANDREWS, STEVEN F 11/27/2024 $6,544.4100048779 E00845 CHANG, TERENCE S 11/27/2024 $3,452.3900048780 E05091 ENCISO, MARIA VERONICA M 11/27/2024 $2,441.8200048781 E03498 ESPINOZA, VERNA L 11/27/2024 $2,562.2100048782 E04523 GALLO, CESAR 11/27/2024 $4,105.6700048783 E04415 GOLD, ANNA L 11/27/2024 $2,373.7100048784 E04713 HINGCO, ERNIE E 11/27/2024 $2,302.0600048785 E02617 KLOESS, GEOFFREY A 11/27/2024 $7,036.8300048786 E05238 LE, JEFFREY D 11/27/2024 $864.4500048787 E03571 MORAGRAAN, RACHOT 11/27/2024 $4,278.4500048788 E05071 OCHOA, NICOLAS E 11/27/2024 $2,672.4700048789 E01277 PROFFITT, NOEL J 11/27/2024 $3,858.1400048790 E01901 RAO, ANAND V 11/27/2024 $5,913.1700048791 E05073 SEYMOUR, DAVID M 11/27/2024 $1,846.4900048792 E04395 SWANSON, MATTHEW T 11/27/2024 $1,965.1900048793 E01674 VALENZUELA, ANTHONY 11/27/2024 $1,759.6400048794 E00809 VICTORIA, ROD T 11/27/2024 $2,578.7000048795 E03725 ABU HAMDIYYAH, AMEENAH 11/27/2024 $2,233.13Server Name: cognos.ggcity.org User Name: victoriac 131
CITY OF GARDEN GROVEGGFEFM002 Warrant Register PayrollCheck Dates Nov 27, 2024Report Generated on Nov 26, 2024 5:35:16 PM Page 5Check Vendor # Vendor Name Issue Date Check Amount00048796 E05215 ANDUJO, ADRIAN S 11/27/2024 $2,176.0800048797 E02996 ASHLEIGH, JULIE A 11/27/2024 $2,400.5000048798 E05194 AVILA, RAFAEL B 11/27/2024 $2,591.9300048799 E05208 BROWN, ANDRE P 11/27/2024 $2,449.4500048800 E05199 BROWN, MIKAELA B 11/27/2024 $722.0000048801 E03601 CHUNG, CHRISTOPHER 11/27/2024 $7,154.9100048802 E00128 CRAMER, RITA M 11/27/2024 $2,712.0000048803 E04394 DAHLHEIMER, BRYSON T 11/27/2024 $0.0000048804 E04879 DAKE, RYAN J 11/27/2024 $3,015.9500048805 E04578 DENT, DAVID A 11/27/2024 $4,764.1900048806 E05216 HERNANDEZ, ZACHARY L 11/27/2024 $2,431.3200048807 E03410 HODSON, AARON J 11/27/2024 $2,393.6900048808 E04716 KASKLA, PRIIT J 11/27/2024 $2,582.7500048809 E04959 LE, KENNETH H 11/27/2024 $1,910.6700048810 E04490 LY, HUONG Q 11/27/2024 $2,587.9900048811 E04194 MARTINEZ, MARIA L 11/27/2024 $3,320.1900048812 E05188 MERCADO RODRIGUEZ, MONICA 11/27/2024 $3,696.0200048813 E04635 NGUYEN, PHU T 11/27/2024 $4,414.2900048814 E02842 PARRA, MARIA C 11/27/2024 $4,249.5500048815 E05249 PLASCENCIA, AMANDA C 11/27/2024 $2,204.5700048816 E05172 QUENTAL, RYAN 11/27/2024 $2,331.3500048817 E04992 ROBLES, ALFONSO 11/27/2024 $2,783.1700048818 E04862 TRAN, JAKE P 11/27/2024 $2,293.6600048819 E05209 TRAN, KAREN 11/27/2024 $802.1100048820 E05048 TUONG, NGHIA T 11/27/2024 $2,352.6000048821 E05053 VU, VINNY X 11/27/2024 $2,805.3100048822 E05150 WETZEL, NIKI 11/27/2024 $4,137.3200048823 E03643 ALVARADO, YOLANDA A 11/27/2024 $2,133.9700048824 E05269 APODACA, ANGELA M 11/27/2024 $938.9200048825 E04771 BAILOR, REBECCA J 11/27/2024 $845.3400048826 E04988 BAUTISTA, BRENDA 11/27/2024 $2,301.2800048827 E05125 BUI, RUBY 11/27/2024 $31.8600048828 E02658 CAMARENA, RACHEL M 11/27/2024 $2,398.7400048829 E01588 CAMARENA, RENE 11/27/2024 $2,567.0600048830 E01902 CASILLAS, VICTORIA M 11/27/2024 $2,203.13Server Name: cognos.ggcity.org User Name: victoriac 132
CITY OF GARDEN GROVEGGFEFM002 Warrant Register PayrollCheck Dates Nov 27, 2024Report Generated on Nov 26, 2024 5:35:16 PM Page 6Check Vendor # Vendor Name Issue Date Check Amount00048831 E05101 CASTANEDA, LILIANA 11/27/2024 $702.0100048832 E05058 CATAQUIZ, CHARLIZE N 11/27/2024 $380.5900048833 E03304 CHUMACERO, DEANNA M 11/27/2024 $1,927.6800048834 E05278 COLIN, ANGELICA 11/27/2024 $495.3100048835 E04611 CROSS, AMANDA D 11/27/2024 $2,217.1600048836 E05013 DINH, TIFFANY 11/27/2024 $825.4800048837 E05222 DO, LOC T 11/27/2024 $526.2700048838 E05228 DUONG, KYLA T 11/27/2024 $398.5700048839 E05281 ENGLEBERT, BRIDGET L 11/27/2024 $372.5100048840 E05090 ESCARENO, MELISSA 11/27/2024 $254.9400048841 E05158 FABIAN, SHARON J 11/27/2024 $607.2800048842 E05015 FALETOI, TERRY U 11/27/2024 $310.5400048843 E05127 FLORES, ERIKA 11/27/2024 $366.4700048844 E02120 FRAUSTO, LUIZ F 11/27/2024 $93.7200048845 E04679 FREEMAN, MARK C 11/27/2024 $4,365.2300048846 E04481 GARCIA, JARED D 11/27/2024 $559.2800048847 E05185 GARCIA, KATY 11/27/2024 $727.1200048848 E05069 GARCIA, VERONICA 11/27/2024 $200.7600048849 E03337 GODDARD, JENNIFER DANIELLE 11/27/2024 $2,971.2300048850 E05225 GONZALEZ, ETHAN Z 11/27/2024 $357.3200048851 E00940 GRANT, JACOB R 11/27/2024 $2,224.0100048852 E05276 GUIDRY, TARIQ A 11/27/2024 $464.3500048853 E05248 HERNANDEZ, CESAR 11/27/2024 $315.6000048854 E05152 HERNANDEZ, CLARISSA 11/27/2024 $175.2700048855 E05221 HUANG, WENDY Y 11/27/2024 $255.3900048856 E05147 LE, WILSON D 11/27/2024 $541.7400048857 E05032 LEE, JASON J 11/27/2024 $501.6800048858 E03603 MA AE, ELAINE M 11/27/2024 $3,263.4800048859 E05014 MARIN, AMANDA T 11/27/2024 $31.8600048860 E05148 MAZARIEGOS, ALEXA X 11/27/2024 $762.7500048861 E01552 MEDINA, JESUS 11/27/2024 $1,806.2800048862 E00455 MEDINA, JUAN 11/27/2024 $2,558.9200048863 E05186 MELVIN, ALEXIS 11/27/2024 $688.8900048864 E02808 MONTANCHEZ, JOHN A 11/27/2024 $6,476.8700048865 E04947 NGUYEN, ALEXANDER H 11/27/2024 $714.64Server Name: cognos.ggcity.org User Name: victoriac 133
CITY OF GARDEN GROVEGGFEFM002 Warrant Register PayrollCheck Dates Nov 27, 2024Report Generated on Nov 26, 2024 5:35:16 PM Page 7Check Vendor # Vendor Name Issue Date Check Amount00048866 E05220 NGUYEN, JASON H 11/27/2024 $305.7000048867 E04391 NICHOLAS, NOEL N 11/27/2024 $1,525.8600048868 E04931 NODAL, NATALIE 11/27/2024 $366.4700048869 E00785 OCADIZ HERNANDEZ, GABRIELA 11/27/2024 $3,160.6900048870 E04965 ORDUNO, SAMANTHA 11/27/2024 $506.8100048871 E03881 PANGAN, CHRISTIAN 11/27/2024 $134.3700048872 E05164 PARCELL, SAMANTHA M 11/27/2024 $608.5600048873 E03361 PELAYO, JANET E 11/27/2024 $4,572.2600048874 E04777 PHAN, EDOUARD T 11/27/2024 $396.0900048875 E05116 PRADO, ALEXA 11/27/2024 $682.6700048876 E05224 RAMIREZ, JOCELYN 11/27/2024 $340.5300048877 E02754 REYNOSO, SUGEIRY 11/27/2024 $2,778.6900048878 E05103 RODRIGUEZ, MATTHEW S 11/27/2024 $358.5100048879 E03362 ROMERO, MARINA Y 11/27/2024 $2,215.8700048880 E04684 ROSALES, MARIA D 11/27/2024 $43.2500048881 E04614 ROSAS, TANYA 11/27/2024 $693.8000048882 E01893 SAUCEDO, DANA MARIE 11/27/2024 $2,640.0500048883 E00925 SCHLUMPBERGER, EMERON J 11/27/2024 $5,813.9100048884 E04926 SERNA, SAMANTHA M 11/27/2024 $371.6400048885 E04795 SIEVE, MYCHAELLA J 11/27/2024 $423.8900048886 E05151 SORIANO, KIMBERLY A 11/27/2024 $1,018.3600048887 E05250 TEJEDA, ANDREA 11/27/2024 $340.5300048888 E05030 TRIGGS, MARY SHANNON 11/27/2024 $37.8400048889 E01396 VALDIVIA, CLAUDIA 11/27/2024 $2,443.6700048890 E00015 VAN SICKLE, JEFFREY 11/27/2024 $2,767.3400048891 E04687 VARGAS, SAMANTHA B 11/27/2024 $175.2700048892 E05149 VAZQUEZ, ELOISA E 11/27/2024 $350.5400048893 E05227 VILLEGAS, JOSEPH A 11/27/2024 $503.0500048894 E05231 VOGEL, KATIE L 11/27/2024 $764.3200048895 E04274 WILMES, DAVID M 11/27/2024 $730.9500048896 E05070 XOOL VARGAS, RUDY G 11/27/2024 $175.2700048897 E05076 XU, CHARLIE 11/27/2024 $607.2800048898 E05226 ZUNIGA, MIA 11/27/2024 $270.8800048899 E05175 AGUILAR, JENNIFER 11/27/2024 $573.6100048900 E03819 ALAMILLO, MARCOS R 11/27/2024 $4,999.35Server Name: cognos.ggcity.org User Name: victoriac 134
CITY OF GARDEN GROVEGGFEFM002 Warrant Register PayrollCheck Dates Nov 27, 2024Report Generated on Nov 26, 2024 5:35:16 PM Page 8Check Vendor # Vendor Name Issue Date Check Amount00048901 E03712 ALARCON, CLAUDIA 11/27/2024 $4,272.9400048902 E03616 ALCARAZ, MARIA A 11/27/2024 $2,972.7000048903 E04431 ALMEIDA, NICHOLAS 11/27/2024 $4,363.4000048904 E04873 ALVARADO, MADELINE M 11/27/2024 $2,686.1300048905 E04080 ALVAREZ BROWN, RICHARD A 11/27/2024 $3,566.1800048906 E05028 AMAYA, JOSE J 11/27/2024 $4,355.4900048907 E03011 ANDERSON, BOBBY B 11/27/2024 $4,070.6300048908 E05206 ANGSAVOTAI-LIGAYA, AMY O 11/27/2024 $2,545.1700048909 E05040 ARCHULETA, ANDREW M 11/27/2024 $2,468.3900048910 E05251 ARELLANO JR, JORGE 11/27/2024 $2,684.3200048911 E01234 ARELLANO, PEDRO R 11/27/2024 $4,430.7200048912 E04875 ARROYO, SANDRA M 11/27/2024 $2,937.6900048913 E04497 ASHBAUGH, TIMOTHY R 11/27/2024 $4,956.4200048914 E03397 ASHBY, PAUL W 11/27/2024 $4,794.2600048915 E04719 ATWOOD, MARIA S 11/27/2024 $2,489.8100048916 E04613 AVALOS JR, FRANCISCO 11/27/2024 $3,314.4100048917 E04033 AVALOS, KATHERINE MARIE 11/27/2024 $3,428.4400048918 E04550 BAEK, SHARON S 11/27/2024 $3,368.2600048919 E05062 BAEZ, JASMIN 11/27/2024 $1,995.8500048920 E04209 BAINTO, JUDY A 11/27/2024 $441.9100048921 E04778 BAKER, COLLIN E 11/27/2024 $4,008.7200048922 E03005 BANKSON, JOHN F 11/27/2024 $4,588.9200048923 E04645 BARRAZA, RENE 11/27/2024 $4,544.0900048924 E05041 BARRIOS-ROA, JAYDE D. 11/27/2024 $2,743.9900048925 E05253 BEDARD, CHRISTIE L 11/27/2024 $2,237.6800048926 E04432 BEHZAD, JOSHUA K 11/27/2024 $3,064.1700048927 E04951 BELLO, ANGELICA 11/27/2024 $2,093.9900048928 E03006 BELTHIUS, LISA A 11/27/2024 $576.8900048929 E04976 BELTHIUS, TYLER E 11/27/2024 $735.1200048930 E04753 BERENGER, BEAU A 11/27/2024 $4,948.3800048931 E03296 BERESFORD, EVAN S 11/27/2024 $28,323.6000048932 E01604 BERLETH, RYAN S 11/27/2024 $2,428.6500048933 E03443 BLUM, JAMES A 11/27/2024 $3,982.1500048934 E03363 BOWEN, GENA M 11/27/2024 $2,591.5500048935 E04767 BOWMAN, TROY F 11/27/2024 $3,329.08Server Name: cognos.ggcity.org User Name: victoriac 135
CITY OF GARDEN GROVEGGFEFM002 Warrant Register PayrollCheck Dates Nov 27, 2024Report Generated on Nov 26, 2024 5:35:16 PM Page 9Check Vendor # Vendor Name Issue Date Check Amount00048936 E04963 BOYENS III, ROBERT 11/27/2024 $3,669.9200048937 E00946 BRAME, KAREN D 11/27/2024 $2,242.8800048938 E04803 BRANTNER, BRITTANEE N 11/27/2024 $2,359.8200048939 E05083 BRITTON, CODY W 11/27/2024 $2,712.4100048940 E03380 BROWN, JEFFREY A 11/27/2024 $5,299.0400048941 E03968 BRUNICK, CARISSA L 11/27/2024 $3,039.5900048942 E05074 BUJANONDA, CHANON 11/27/2024 $3,145.8500048943 E02031 BURILLO, RICHARD O 11/27/2024 $6,301.3500048944 E03972 BUSTILLOS, RYAN V 11/27/2024 $3,945.6600048945 E05077 CAGLE, RONALD L 11/27/2024 $1,611.4400048946 E05284 CAIZA NUNEZ, MERWIN D 11/27/2024 $3,364.0000048947 E03964 CAMARA, DANIEL A 11/27/2024 $10,349.5800048948 E04074 CAMPOS, JESENIA 11/27/2024 $2,975.2700048949 E03739 CAPPS, THOMAS A 11/27/2024 $5,866.6100048950 E05002 CARBALLO, MILTON A 11/27/2024 $2,636.6800048951 E05266 CENDEJAS, MELISSA 11/27/2024 $1,906.4900048952 E02372 CENTENO, JUAN C 11/27/2024 $4,872.4100048953 E05252 CHACON JR, JOSE A 11/27/2024 $2,691.6000048954 E03607 CHANG, DAVID Y H 11/27/2024 $3,997.0000048955 E03481 CHAURAN HAIRGROVE, TAMMY L 11/27/2024 $2,881.5900048956 E04498 CHEATHAM, JEROME L 11/27/2024 $3,862.3900048957 E03423 CHOWDHURY, JACINTA F 11/27/2024 $2,291.6700048958 E04414 CHUNG, RANDY G 11/27/2024 $250.1500048959 E04666 CORTEZ, JULIO C 11/27/2024 $4,094.7600048960 E01796 COULTER, GARY L 11/27/2024 $4,249.6300048961 E04555 CRUZ, REYNA 11/27/2024 $2,355.4200048962 E01364 DALTON, BRIAN D 11/27/2024 $4,709.1300048963 E04874 DANG, JOHN 11/27/2024 $3,972.2400048964 E00126 DANIELEY III, CHARLIE H 11/27/2024 $1,889.4900048965 E05213 DAO, NHU T 11/27/2024 $1,700.7500048966 E04503 DAVILA, ISAAC 11/27/2024 $5,149.1300048967 E04731 DE PADUA, TANNER C 11/27/2024 $4,198.8600048968 E03691 DELGADO JR, JUAN L 11/27/2024 $4,448.1800048969 E03395 DIX, JENNIFER A 11/27/2024 $4,768.1500048970 E05088 DOAN, THOMMY 11/27/2024 $2,745.20Server Name: cognos.ggcity.org User Name: victoriac 136
CITY OF GARDEN GROVEGGFEFM002 Warrant Register PayrollCheck Dates Nov 27, 2024Report Generated on Nov 26, 2024 5:35:16 PM Page 10Check Vendor # Vendor Name Issue Date Check Amount00048971 E02313 DOSCHER, RONALD A 11/27/2024 $4,036.2600048972 E04281 DRISCOLL, RUSSELL B 11/27/2024 $2,912.9900048973 E04844 DUARTE, TAYLOR M 11/27/2024 $2,919.9800048974 E04720 DUDLEY, BROC D 11/27/2024 $3,394.2900048975 E03625 EARLE, CHRISTOPHER M 11/27/2024 $4,047.0700048976 E03740 EL FARRA, AMIR A 11/27/2024 $6,741.3700048977 E03927 ELHAMI, MICHAEL K 11/27/2024 $4,363.6600048978 E03933 ELIZONDO, BENJAMIN M 11/27/2024 $3,915.5800048979 E04016 ELIZONDO, FLOR DE LIS 11/27/2024 $2,471.8800048980 E01598 ELSOUSOU, HELENA 11/27/2024 $4,009.8500048981 E02708 ENRIQUEZ, JOHN G 11/27/2024 $1,202.2000048982 E05174 ESCOBAR, MARIANA 11/27/2024 $374.4500048983 E04334 ESCOBEDO, JOSHUA N 11/27/2024 $4,721.7500048984 E02724 ESTLOW, STEPHEN C 11/27/2024 $3,223.8800048985 E04358 ESTRADA MONSANTO, MICHELLE N 11/27/2024 $4,366.9300048986 E04748 FAJARDO, JESUS 11/27/2024 $3,459.9200048987 E04303 FERREIRA JR, HECTOR 11/27/2024 $3,311.5500048988 E01663 FERRIN, KORY C 11/27/2024 $5,928.0300048989 E03976 FIGUEREDO, GEORGE R 11/27/2024 $4,642.5700048990 E04774 FLINN, PATRICIA C 11/27/2024 $3,156.3600048991 E02887 FOSTER, VICTORIA M 11/27/2024 $1,515.6100048992 E04747 FRESENIUS, ROBERT D 11/27/2024 $3,757.6700048993 E00903 FRUTOS, VERONICA 11/27/2024 $2,708.4400048994 E05205 GAMINO, ANGEL 11/27/2024 $711.7800048995 E04729 GARCIA, JOSEPH A 11/27/2024 $2,827.3000048996 E03086 GARCIA, PETE 11/27/2024 $4,860.8300048997 E03659 GARNER, AMANDA B 11/27/2024 $2,168.0700048998 E04351 GERDIN, MICHAEL E 11/27/2024 $3,961.1600048999 E04542 GIFFORD, ROBERT J 11/27/2024 $5,080.3400049000 E04658 GIRGENTI, BRIAN C 11/27/2024 $7,993.8500049001 E04401 GLEASON, SEAN M 11/27/2024 $3,532.1800049002 E04917 GOMEZ, JESUS 11/27/2024 $3,126.2100049003 E04863 GONZALEZ JR, GONZALO 11/27/2024 $3,916.7000049004 E05003 HA, DANNY 11/27/2024 $3,855.3500049005 E04732 HADDEN, TRAVIS J 11/27/2024 $3,338.74Server Name: cognos.ggcity.org User Name: victoriac 137
CITY OF GARDEN GROVEGGFEFM002 Warrant Register PayrollCheck Dates Nov 27, 2024Report Generated on Nov 26, 2024 5:35:16 PM Page 11Check Vendor # Vendor Name Issue Date Check Amount00049006 E04787 HALEY, KYLE N 11/27/2024 $4,727.7300049007 E03527 HALLER, TROY 11/27/2024 $5,511.8100049008 E03402 HEINE, STEVEN H 11/27/2024 $5,105.6100049009 E05157 HERNANDEZ CALLEROS, SAIRA 11/27/2024 $2,793.1000049010 E04872 HERNANDEZ, KRISTINA L 11/27/2024 $2,608.7800049011 E02469 HERRERA, JOSE D 11/27/2024 $6,001.5500049012 E05265 HERRERA, MATTHEW P 11/27/2024 $526.2700049013 E04244 HINGCO, PINKY C 11/27/2024 $3,063.8400049014 E03713 HOLLOWAY, WILLIAM T 11/27/2024 $4,935.1700049015 E04739 HOWARD, JASON A 11/27/2024 $4,136.0000049016 E04654 HURLEY, KIRK P 11/27/2024 $4,359.0400049017 E04089 HUTCHINS, DONALD J 11/27/2024 $4,364.9300049018 E03815 HUYNH, AI KELLY 11/27/2024 $2,984.2300049019 E03559 HUYNH, THI A 11/27/2024 $4,068.2900049020 E04915 ITURRALDE, JENNIFER L 11/27/2024 $2,992.3700049021 E04583 JENSEN, MICHAEL J 11/27/2024 $5,434.4700049022 E02935 JENSEN, NICKOLAS K 11/27/2024 $4,700.7200049023 E04587 JIMENEZ JR, EFRAIN A 11/27/2024 $5,114.3600049024 E04781 JIMENEZ TAVAREZ, SERGIO J 11/27/2024 $2,638.5400049025 E04655 JOHNSON, CODY M 11/27/2024 $3,239.2900049026 E03368 JOHNSON, JASON L 11/27/2024 $4,536.1600049027 E03831 JORDAN, GERALD F 11/27/2024 $10,400.6900049028 E04610 JORDAN, VICTORIA A 11/27/2024 $9,679.6300049029 E04559 KELLEY, KRISTOFER D 11/27/2024 $3,501.8600049030 E04353 KEUILIAN, SHELBY 11/27/2024 $2,621.3600049031 E04663 KIM, CHAD B 11/27/2024 $4,208.7000049032 E04641 KIM, EDWARD K 11/27/2024 $86.6800049033 E05257 KIM, HANBI 11/27/2024 $2,677.4700049034 E04538 KIMBERLY, ALLYSON L 11/27/2024 $1,232.6300049035 E05254 KIMMEY, ELIZABETH J 11/27/2024 $1,867.0700049036 E03932 KIVLER, ROBERT J 11/27/2024 $2,693.3700049037 E03389 KOLANO, JOSEPH L 11/27/2024 $4,497.7000049038 E03294 KOVACS, LEA K 11/27/2024 $4,116.4500049039 E05000 KOVACS, TIMOTHY M 11/27/2024 $4,308.4400049040 E04669 KOVACS, TIMOTHY P 11/27/2024 $5,421.05Server Name: cognos.ggcity.org User Name: victoriac 138
CITY OF GARDEN GROVEGGFEFM002 Warrant Register PayrollCheck Dates Nov 27, 2024Report Generated on Nov 26, 2024 5:35:16 PM Page 12Check Vendor # Vendor Name Issue Date Check Amount00049041 E03484 KUNKEL, PETER M 11/27/2024 $4,447.4100049042 E04857 LANG, MICHAEL J 11/27/2024 $5,057.2200049043 E03511 LAZENBY, NICHOLAS A 11/27/2024 $4,618.5200049044 E04877 LE, BAO TINH THI 11/27/2024 $2,128.9000049045 E04021 LEE, RAPHAEL M 11/27/2024 $5,040.7300049046 E03488 LEYVA, ERICK 11/27/2024 $5,853.6100049047 E04541 LINK, DEREK M 11/27/2024 $4,939.9000049048 E00030 LOERA JR, RAFAEL 11/27/2024 $5,303.1100049049 E05033 LOFFLER, CHARLES H 11/27/2024 $5,449.8700049050 E02645 LOPEZ, DAVID 11/27/2024 $794.5800049051 E05214 LOPEZ, KORINA Y 11/27/2024 $1,579.0000049052 E05256 LOPEZ, VICTORIA A 11/27/2024 $1,681.8100049053 E05066 LORD, MARK A 11/27/2024 $5,314.3200049054 E04581 LOWEN, BRADLEY A 11/27/2024 $3,290.2800049055 E04761 LUCATERO, JESSE A 11/27/2024 $3,546.3400049056 E00027 LUKAS, STEVEN W 11/27/2024 $2,498.7800049057 E04048 LUX, ROBERT D 11/27/2024 $3,236.4700049058 E03663 LUX, RYAN M 11/27/2024 $7,187.7400049059 E04772 LY, LINDALINH THU 11/27/2024 $2,483.2100049060 E04661 MACHUCA, ROBERTO 11/27/2024 $4,699.4800049061 E04532 MANIACI, GIANLUCA F 11/27/2024 $4,175.5200049062 E04435 MARCHAND, MATTHEW P 11/27/2024 $6,836.6700049063 E05282 MARRUFO PUENTES, ANDRES 11/27/2024 $2,592.1900049064 E01359 MARTINEZ JR, MARIO 11/27/2024 $6,204.5700049065 E05140 MARTINEZ, ERICK 11/27/2024 $783.1100049066 E04974 MARTINEZ, JUANITA PATRICIA 11/27/2024 $3,100.4700049067 E02792 MATA, RAQUEL D 11/27/2024 $969.1200049068 E04656 MAZON, JORGE L 11/27/2024 $3,905.3200049069 E02796 MCFARLANE, MARIA C 11/27/2024 $2,757.6200049070 E06761 MEEKS, REBECCA S 11/27/2024 $31,343.5600049071 E03826 MEERS, BRYAN J 11/27/2024 $5,472.1600049072 E02655 MENDOZA CAMPOS, MELISSA 11/27/2024 $3,338.6000049073 E03965 MIHALIK, DANNY J 11/27/2024 $4,216.2500049074 E04804 MONTECINOS, LAUREN MARIE 11/27/2024 $2,850.6800049075 E04865 MORIN, LINDA M 11/27/2024 $3,393.70Server Name: cognos.ggcity.org User Name: victoriac 139
CITY OF GARDEN GROVEGGFEFM002 Warrant Register PayrollCheck Dates Nov 27, 2024Report Generated on Nov 26, 2024 5:35:16 PM Page 13Check Vendor # Vendor Name Issue Date Check Amount00049076 E04352 MORSE, JEREMY N 11/27/2024 $5,224.3500049077 E01940 MORTON, NATHAN D 11/27/2024 $3,911.3600049078 E04454 MOSER, MICHAEL A 11/27/2024 $2,402.2100049079 E03929 MURILLO JR, RAUL 11/27/2024 $5,710.6500049080 E04626 MURO, JASON M 11/27/2024 $3,939.6200049081 E04577 MUSCHETTO, PATRICK J 11/27/2024 $2,731.2900049082 E03422 NADOLSKI, THOMAS R 11/27/2024 $3,107.5500049083 E05084 NAKANO HITZKE, SARAH V 11/27/2024 $3,456.1600049084 E04111 NEELY, JACOB J 11/27/2024 $2,745.8300049085 E05191 NGO, ALLISON B 11/27/2024 $1,714.4700049086 E02813 NGUYEN, TRINA T 11/27/2024 $2,822.9700049087 E04540 NIKOLIC, ADAM C 11/27/2024 $4,780.0400049088 E05146 NIZ, IXA N 11/27/2024 $3,246.6600049089 E05054 NUNEZ, BREANNE S 11/27/2024 $2,932.1900049090 E03350 OLIVO, JOSHUA T 11/27/2024 $5,042.8800049091 E04035 ORTIZ, STEVEN TRUJILLO 11/27/2024 $3,138.2800049092 E03427 PANELLA, JOSEPH N 11/27/2024 $4,077.3800049093 E04910 PAQUA, BRANDON J 11/27/2024 $3,406.4300049094 E01948 PARK, BRANDY J 11/27/2024 $4,108.3300049095 E02995 PAYAN, CRISTINA V 11/27/2024 $4,152.3800049096 E00824 PAYAN, LUIS A 11/27/2024 $29,013.1700049097 E05200 PAZ, JUAN 11/27/2024 $4,676.4400049098 E04843 PEREZ, EMMANUEL 11/27/2024 $3,687.3400049099 E00145 PERKINS, JASON S 11/27/2024 $5,240.4800049100 E04429 PHAM, PHILLIP H 11/27/2024 $3,701.3700049101 E05195 PINEDA, MARGO S 11/27/2024 $2,545.9000049102 E06938 PLUARD, DOUGLAS A 11/27/2024 $6,574.6500049103 E03299 POLOPEK, COREY T 11/27/2024 $3,173.2700049104 E05173 PONCE, GALILEA 11/27/2024 $601.3500049105 E05050 QUANG, DENNIS 11/27/2024 $4,146.9000049106 E04788 QUIROZ, LUIS A 11/27/2024 $5,853.2400049107 E05100 RAABE, MATTHEW A 11/27/2024 $3,569.8900049108 E03967 RAMIREZ OROZCO, SINDY 11/27/2024 $3,888.4300049109 E04955 RAMIREZ, KAYLYN C 11/27/2024 $2,814.8500049110 E03390 RAMIREZ, LUIS F 11/27/2024 $4,467.93Server Name: cognos.ggcity.org User Name: victoriac 140
CITY OF GARDEN GROVEGGFEFM002 Warrant Register PayrollCheck Dates Nov 27, 2024Report Generated on Nov 26, 2024 5:35:16 PM Page 14Check Vendor # Vendor Name Issue Date Check Amount00049111 E05021 RAMIREZ, TERRA M 11/27/2024 $4,017.8200049112 E04914 RAMOS, RODOLFO B 11/27/2024 $2,048.1300049113 E03217 RANEY, JOHN E 11/27/2024 $4,245.6500049114 E04941 RASMUSSEN, TRENTON L 11/27/2024 $2,930.6000049115 E04659 REED, THOMAS S 11/27/2024 $4,928.7900049116 E03486 REYES, RON A 11/27/2024 $4,763.5100049117 E04911 RICHARDS, BRYANT D 11/27/2024 $2,834.5900049118 E04437 RICHMOND, RYAN R 11/27/2024 $3,897.6600049119 E05229 ROBINSON, IVANA M 11/27/2024 $2,889.5400049120 E04860 ROCHA, RUDY A 11/27/2024 $3,291.4900049121 E04738 RODRIGUEZ, DANIEL 11/27/2024 $3,902.7200049122 E04082 RODRIGUEZ, JENNIFER M 11/27/2024 $4,128.0900049123 E05001 RODRIGUEZ, RYAN ELIJAH 11/27/2024 $4,105.6300049124 E04438 ROGERS, CHRISTIN E 11/27/2024 $3,635.9700049125 E04385 ROJAS, ASHLEY C 11/27/2024 $2,594.6700049126 E04507 ROMBOUGH, JENNIFER V 11/27/2024 $2,597.2300049127 E04552 RUZIECKI, ERIC T 11/27/2024 $4,109.1800049128 E02845 SALAZAR, SEAN M 11/27/2024 $3,797.4500049129 E04845 SALGADO JR., ALFREDO 11/27/2024 $2,869.7300049130 E03297 SAMOFF, TANYA L 11/27/2024 $2,810.5200049131 E02646 SANTANA, LINO G 11/27/2024 $8,976.0500049132 E05086 SEELY, BRITTANY L 11/27/2024 $1,230.5000049133 E03035 SEYMOUR, SUSAN A I 11/27/2024 $3,705.4700049134 E04282 SHELGREN, CHRISTOPHER M 11/27/2024 $4,816.8100049135 E04616 SHIPLEY, AARON T 11/27/2024 $3,073.7300049136 E02937 SHORROW, NICOLE D 11/27/2024 $4,261.0900049137 E04864 SILVA, LEVI JOENIEL 11/27/2024 $3,113.0800049138 E04576 SIMONS, SHAYLEN L 11/27/2024 $3,755.1900049139 E05203 SMITH, JAVON 11/27/2024 $6,190.4000049140 E02587 SOSEBEE, DANNY J 11/27/2024 $2,820.9700049141 E03563 SPELLMAN, MARSHA D 11/27/2024 $3,484.4700049142 E04500 STAAL, GAREY D 11/27/2024 $4,025.2400049143 E03218 STARNES, CHARLES W 11/27/2024 $7,657.7700049144 E03761 STEPHENSON III, ROBERT M 11/27/2024 $5,397.5600049145 E04584 STROUD, BRIAN T 11/27/2024 $6,147.14Server Name: cognos.ggcity.org User Name: victoriac 141
CITY OF GARDEN GROVEGGFEFM002 Warrant Register PayrollCheck Dates Nov 27, 2024Report Generated on Nov 26, 2024 5:35:16 PM Page 15Check Vendor # Vendor Name Issue Date Check Amount00049146 E02979 TESSIER, PAUL M 11/27/2024 $3,795.8000049147 E04449 TRAN, SPENCER T 11/27/2024 $2,473.4900049148 E05145 VACCARO, CHRISTIAN L 11/27/2024 $696.0400049149 E02982 VAICARO, VINCENTE J 11/27/2024 $5,922.5900049150 E03053 VALENCIA, EDGAR 11/27/2024 $5,340.3900049151 E04667 VAUGHN, CALEB I 11/27/2024 $2,547.4100049152 E04434 VELLANOWETH, KIMBRA S 11/27/2024 $2,807.7700049153 E04903 VIGIL, DANIEL C 11/27/2024 $3,027.5200049154 E03022 VU, TUONG-VAN NGUYEN 11/27/2024 $3,030.2400049155 E04730 VU, TYLER D 11/27/2024 $2,686.3400049156 E01905 WAINWRIGHT, JONATHAN B 11/27/2024 $5,501.9700049157 E03220 WARDLE, DENNIS 11/27/2024 $5,347.1400049158 E03213 WARDLE, SANTA 11/27/2024 $2,736.0000049159 E04758 WEYKER, CHRYSTAL L 11/27/2024 $1,900.0600049160 E04006 WILLIAMS, RICHARD L 11/27/2024 $693.8800049161 E03305 WIMMER, ROYCE C 11/27/2024 $5,209.5900049162 E04762 WREN, DANIELLE E 11/27/2024 $3,591.9800049163 E04856 XU, DUO 11/27/2024 $2,220.9800049164 E03543 YELENSKY, SHANNON M 11/27/2024 $2,101.1100049165 E04156 YERGLER, JOHN J 11/27/2024 $4,957.1500049166 E04722 YNIGUEZ, COLE A 11/27/2024 $5,247.9500049167 E09942 YOUNG, DAVID C 11/27/2024 $810.1400049168 E01978 ZMIJA, ADAM D 11/27/2024 $31,023.1800049169 E05271 AGUILAR, KEVIN A 11/27/2024 $1,349.8100049170 E04517 AGUIRRE, ALFRED J 11/27/2024 $3,620.5400049171 E01626 AGUIRRE, ANSELMO 11/27/2024 $2,171.8700049172 E05207 AN, TONY W 11/27/2024 $3,473.2100049173 E04631 ANDREI, IOAN 11/27/2024 $1,289.6000049174 E04678 BABINSKI IV, SYLVESTER A 11/27/2024 $10,920.2400049175 E04336 BECERRA, RODOLPHO M 11/27/2024 $2,571.0600049176 E04972 BECERRA-SAMANIEGO JR, GABRIEL 11/27/2024 $1,762.9400049177 E05210 BERNAL, JASON 11/27/2024 $798.9300049178 E01255 BOS, MICHAEL C 11/27/2024 $2,372.0700049179 E05162 CAISEROS, CHRISTIAN 11/27/2024 $980.9500049180 E01584 CANDELARIA, DANIEL J 11/27/2024 $4,627.98Server Name: cognos.ggcity.org User Name: victoriac 142
CITY OF GARDEN GROVEGGFEFM002 Warrant Register PayrollCheck Dates Nov 27, 2024Report Generated on Nov 26, 2024 5:35:16 PM Page 16Check Vendor # Vendor Name Issue Date Check Amount00049181 E04300 CANO, EDGAR A 11/27/2024 $2,599.6000049182 E05280 CANTARERO, LESLY P 11/27/2024 $1,962.3900049183 E03828 CANTRELL, JEFFREY G 11/27/2024 $2,343.7300049184 E05217 CARRILLO HERNANDEZ, ERWIN R 11/27/2024 $102.6700049185 E03811 CARRISOZA, ALBERT J 11/27/2024 $2,214.5100049186 E00916 CARTER, PHILLIP J 11/27/2024 $3,677.7800049187 E04869 CHAVEZ, DAMIAN JESUS 11/27/2024 $881.7300049188 E04551 CONTRERAS, GABRIELA R 11/27/2024 $3,268.8000049189 E03518 COTTON, JULIE T 11/27/2024 $1,975.0200049190 E03807 DE LA ROSA, VINCENT L 11/27/2024 $3,433.6300049191 E05170 DELGADO REYES, JORGE A 11/27/2024 $1,708.2400049192 E03736 DIBAJ, KAMYAR 11/27/2024 $3,604.2300049193 E05122 DORADO, ANTHONY 11/27/2024 $1,980.3800049194 E02515 DUVALL, RICK L 11/27/2024 $2,737.2100049195 E04514 ESPINOZA, ERIC M 11/27/2024 $2,231.1400049196 E03733 ESPINOZA, JULIA 11/27/2024 $1,416.5200049197 E03405 FERNANDEZ, CECELIA A 11/27/2024 $1,378.9300049198 E04990 FLORES, MITCHELL C 11/27/2024 $1,542.1300049199 E05064 FOX, LUCAS 11/27/2024 $197.7100049200 E05037 GAINES, JEFFREY S 11/27/2024 $996.4700049201 E05010 GALVAN, EDGAR 11/27/2024 $1,107.9600049202 E04754 GARCIA, ALICIA R 11/27/2024 $1,707.7500049203 E04677 GIROUARD, CASEY G 11/27/2024 $273.1200049204 E05156 GOMEZ HERNANDEZ, RICARDO 11/27/2024 $1,322.7800049205 E04629 GOMEZ, DIANA 11/27/2024 $1,005.4700049206 E03341 GONZALEZ, JORGE 11/27/2024 $1,403.2100049207 E03400 GREENE, MICHAEL R 11/27/2024 $511.9600049208 E03685 GUZMAN, JESSE 11/27/2024 $2,341.1000049209 E04299 HANSEN, AARON R 11/27/2024 $2,173.8000049210 E03523 HARO, GLORIA A 11/27/2024 $1,466.0100049211 E03759 HERNANDEZ, HERMILO 11/27/2024 $3,327.2800049212 E04622 HOFER, ALICIA M 11/27/2024 $2,274.3500049213 E04347 HSIEH, NICOLAS C 11/27/2024 $3,712.9800049214 E03588 HUYNH, HUY HOA 11/27/2024 $2,559.7800049215 E04831 ILFELD, MATTHEW D 11/27/2024 $2,196.60Server Name: cognos.ggcity.org User Name: victoriac 143
CITY OF GARDEN GROVEGGFEFM002 Warrant Register PayrollCheck Dates Nov 27, 2024Report Generated on Nov 26, 2024 5:35:16 PM Page 17Check Vendor # Vendor Name Issue Date Check Amount00049216 E01907 JACOT, ROSEMARIE 11/27/2024 $2,363.3600049217 E04296 JOHNSON, ERIC W 11/27/2024 $2,172.8700049218 E04979 JURADO, MICHAEL 11/27/2024 $3,210.4600049219 E04470 KAYLOR, BRENT 11/27/2024 $2,731.8400049220 E04728 KHALIL, MARK M 11/27/2024 $2,439.5300049221 E03534 KIM, SAMUEL K 11/27/2024 $4,780.1500049222 E04382 KWIATKOWSKI, BRYAN D 11/27/2024 $2,040.7800049223 E04769 LAMAS, LEONEL A 11/27/2024 $1,919.9200049224 E03813 LEWIS, SHAN L 11/27/2024 $3,362.8700049225 E03301 LEYVA, RAUL 11/27/2024 $4,749.7900049226 E05065 LOMELI, JONATHAN 11/27/2024 $2,019.8300049227 E05202 LONDONO, MARTIN A 11/27/2024 $2,829.0400049228 E05155 LOPEZ, MOISES 11/27/2024 $1,185.9700049229 E05198 MALDONADO, RICARDO 11/27/2024 $1,993.8400049230 E05006 MARQUEZ, STEVEN ADAM 11/27/2024 $1,854.3400049231 E04665 MEJIA, DIEGO A 11/27/2024 $2,238.5300049232 E03493 MENDEZ, RIGOBERTO 11/27/2024 $2,251.5500049233 E04998 MENDOZA, LAURA 11/27/2024 $1,162.0700049234 E04724 MOORE, DOUGLAS A 11/27/2024 $2,599.1000049235 E04827 MORELAND, ANDREW J 11/27/2024 $1,794.4400049236 E04222 MOSS, DANIEL C 11/27/2024 $0.0000049237 E01243 MURRAY JR, WILLIAM E 11/27/2024 $7,218.1600049238 E04634 NAVARRO, JUAN C 11/27/2024 $3,500.9700049239 E04969 ORNELLAS, MICHAEL 11/27/2024 $4,543.7400049240 E05272 ORTIZ, JESSE 11/27/2024 $947.2600049241 E03378 ORTIZ, STEVEN T 11/27/2024 $2,499.3800049242 E04999 ORTUNO, ANIBAL 11/27/2024 $2,296.2100049243 E03754 PINKSTON, RICHARD L 11/27/2024 $2,644.9900049244 E05112 POE, HEIDI L 11/27/2024 $3,295.4200049245 E04567 POWELL, AUSTIN H 11/27/2024 $3,097.6100049246 E03799 QUIROZ, ROLANDO 11/27/2024 $3,694.2600049247 E05201 RAMIREZ, DANIEL A 11/27/2024 $1,377.8500049248 E05258 RAMIREZ, GREGORY A 11/27/2024 $2,683.9700049249 E04572 REED, MELVIN P 11/27/2024 $2,199.0500049250 E02058 REYES, DELFRADO C 11/27/2024 $1,402.34Server Name: cognos.ggcity.org User Name: victoriac 144
CITY OF GARDEN GROVEGGFEFM002 Warrant Register PayrollCheck Dates Nov 27, 2024Report Generated on Nov 26, 2024 5:35:16 PM Page 18Check Vendor # Vendor Name Issue Date Check Amount00049251 E04295 ROBLES, RAFAEL 11/27/2024 $2,401.5000049252 E04563 RODRIGUEZ, ADRIANNA M 11/27/2024 $1,511.2700049253 E05285 RODRIGUEZ, RUDY R 11/27/2024 $1,310.8500049254 E05004 RUELAS, SERGIO 11/27/2024 $2,362.6700049255 E04289 SALDIVAR, RICARDO 11/27/2024 $2,010.8500049256 E05067 SANCHEZ, MARTIN 11/27/2024 $651.8200049257 E05166 SEVELU, FAASEGA J 11/27/2024 $851.9800049258 E04836 SOTO, WILLIAM A 11/27/2024 $2,213.9600049259 E05089 STAIR, DEAN T 11/27/2024 $568.7400049260 E03091 SUDDUTH, STEPHEN D 11/27/2024 $3,434.0300049261 E01625 TAPIA, LUIS A 11/27/2024 $3,250.5500049262 E04756 TARIN, ALEXIS P 11/27/2024 $2,274.3000049263 E03239 TAUANU U, STEVE J 11/27/2024 $586.6700049264 E05154 TELLO, ALEJANDRO 11/27/2024 $803.2900049265 E04773 THURMAN JR, EDWIN O 11/27/2024 $1,239.4500049266 E08679 THURMAN, RODERICK 11/27/2024 $2,028.0400049267 E04825 TRUJILLO, JOSEPH E 11/27/2024 $1,761.7100049268 E02482 UPHUS, MARK P 11/27/2024 $5,413.0000049269 E03681 VASQUEZ, JOSE A 11/27/2024 $3,362.9300049270 E05136 VASQUEZ, PEDRO 11/27/2024 $2,019.8300049271 E05134 VEGA, ERIC J 11/27/2024 $1,974.4300049272 E03727 VERGARA NEAL, ANA G 11/27/2024 $3,362.7900049273 E05093 VIRAMONTES, ALEXANDRA 11/27/2024 $2,678.8400049274 E01580 VU, DAI C 11/27/2024 $4,145.0300049275 E04362 VU, KHANG L 11/27/2024 $3,569.6600049276 E05275 XITAMUL, JASON A 11/27/2024 $1,636.0800049277 E05023 YNIGUEZ, KARISSA N 11/27/2024 $2,601.3400049278 E03436 ZIEGLER, RICK S 11/27/2024 $576.4200049279 E03917 ALLEN, CHRISTOPHER L 11/27/2024 $0.0000049280 E04163 AMBRIZ GARCIA, EDWARD D 11/27/2024 $2,158.4200049281 E05098 BARNESE, VINCENZO A 11/27/2024 $2,759.8200049282 E04063 BERGER, JAN 11/27/2024 $4,091.8600049283 E00651 BERMUDEZ, ROBERT P 11/27/2024 $3,756.6600049284 E03495 BLAS, VICTOR T 11/27/2024 $2,926.9100049285 E00070 CANNON, TIM P 11/27/2024 $5,180.60Server Name: cognos.ggcity.org User Name: victoriac 145
CITY OF GARDEN GROVEGGFEFM002 Warrant Register PayrollCheck Dates Nov 27, 2024Report Generated on Nov 26, 2024 5:35:16 PM Page 19Check Vendor # Vendor Name Issue Date Check Amount00049286 E04365 DAN, CARINA M 11/27/2024 $2,799.9500049287 E04440 DAVIS, RYAN H 11/27/2024 $1,944.4100049288 E03145 DE LA ROSA, FRANK X 11/27/2024 $4,273.5600049289 E03051 DIEMERT, RONALD W 11/27/2024 $2,431.7600049290 E02718 ESCOBAR, CHRIS N 11/27/2024 $3,129.1000049291 E03688 GLENN, JEREMY J 11/27/2024 $2,053.7300049292 E01618 GOMEZ, JOSE 11/27/2024 $2,682.6000049293 E02701 GONZALEZ, ALEJANDRO 11/27/2024 $3,582.1400049294 E03763 GRIFFIN, LARRY 11/27/2024 $1,528.4600049295 E04828 GUERRERO, MICHAEL V 11/27/2024 $2,939.2800049296 E04018 HAENDIGES, ROBERT A 11/27/2024 $4,505.6500049297 E03575 HART, RYAN S 11/27/2024 $1,910.9400049298 E03399 HOWENSTEIN, FRANK D 11/27/2024 $2,742.5600049299 E03406 HUY, EDWARD A 11/27/2024 $2,479.7800049300 E03446 JIMENEZ, VIDAL 11/27/2024 $1,826.7700049301 E04782 JIN, LIYAN 11/27/2024 $3,234.8900049302 E03254 KIRZHNER, ALLEN G 11/27/2024 $3,554.9800049303 E05115 KOUTSOYANOPULOS, ALDOCHRIS V 11/27/2024 $1,509.7000049304 E02852 LADNEY, MARK W 11/27/2024 $3,664.5200049305 E03988 LI, REBECCA PIK KWAN 11/27/2024 $4,340.6800049306 E02063 MA AE, DAVID 11/27/2024 $2,337.6300049307 E05168 MACIAS, DANIEL 11/27/2024 $1,721.8000049308 E03249 MANSON, RAQUEL K 11/27/2024 $3,120.7900049309 E04837 MARTINEZ, ALFREDO 11/27/2024 $2,057.8900049310 E02124 MEISLAHN, TYLER 11/27/2024 $1,975.9700049311 E04403 MONTGOMERY, JESSE K 11/27/2024 $2,429.4200049312 E03590 MOYA JR, STEVEN J 11/27/2024 $2,573.9400049313 E03519 MURAD, BASIL G 11/27/2024 $3,023.3200049314 E03144 NATLAND, KIRK L 11/27/2024 $1,341.3500049315 E04291 NGUYEN, DUC TRUNG 11/27/2024 $2,360.0200049316 E04904 NGUYEN, LISA 11/27/2024 $2,128.2200049317 E03221 NICOLAE, CORNELIU 11/27/2024 $3,755.0300049318 E04210 NUNES, BRANDON S 11/27/2024 $2,181.1700049319 E03923 ORNELAS, ANDREW I 11/27/2024 $4,242.0500049320 E03582 ORTEGA, DAVID A 11/27/2024 $3,259.43Server Name: cognos.ggcity.org User Name: victoriac 146
CITY OF GARDEN GROVEGGFEFM002 Warrant Register PayrollCheck Dates Nov 27, 2024Report Generated on Nov 26, 2024 5:35:16 PM Page 20Check Vendor # Vendor Name Issue Date Check Amount00049321 E03578 PASILLAS, CELESTINO J 11/27/2024 $6,161.9700049322 E03170 PEARSON, WILLIAM F 11/27/2024 $2,709.1800049323 E04805 POLIDORI, JESSICA J 11/27/2024 $3,901.7300049324 E02500 PORRAS, STEPHEN 11/27/2024 $4,453.0900049325 E05031 RAMIREZ, AACIN 11/27/2024 $1,989.4900049326 E07590 RUITENSCHILD, LES A 11/27/2024 $3,225.3700049327 E03926 RUIZ, JONATHAN 11/27/2024 $2,968.4900049328 E05165 SANCHEZ, ALLEN J 11/27/2024 $1,052.9600049329 E07690 SANTOS, ALEXIS 11/27/2024 $2,217.5100049330 E07692 SARMIENTO, ADRIAN M 11/27/2024 $2,825.6800049331 E04956 SON, TOMMY T 11/27/2024 $2,308.7900049332 E04301 TALAMANTES JR, ALBERT 11/27/2024 $4,663.5400049333 E04121 TRAN, MINH K 11/27/2024 $4,587.8500049334 E08881 VALENZUELA, ALEJANDRO N 11/27/2024 $3,547.1400049335 E01882 VIRAMONTES, JESSE 11/27/2024 $2,515.9400049336 E04195 WOLLAND, RONALD J 11/27/2024 $2,062.3900049337 E09940 YERGENSEN, VICTOR K 11/27/2024 $5,704.9300049338 E05169 ZAMORA, JOEL D 11/27/2024 $1,624.2100049339 E09954 ZAVALA, JOHN 11/27/2024 $3,300.4900049340 E05212 AREGUINI, SARA 11/27/2024 $808.2100049341 E05099 BECK, CRAIG A 11/27/2024 $2,714.0900049342 E00740 BLODGETT, GREG 11/27/2024 $4,873.5700049343 E01338 CARRENO, SHAUNA J 11/27/2024 $2,122.1100049344 E03808 CHENG, ALANA R 11/27/2024 $4,135.8600049345 E03353 COVARRUBIAS, MONICA 11/27/2024 $3,919.3700049346 E04750 HO, VY D 11/27/2024 $2,179.9800049347 E04968 HONG, SEUNGBUM 11/27/2024 $2,504.1900049348 E02612 KLOESS, VILMA C 11/27/2024 $3,286.4500049349 E01949 LE, IVY 11/27/2024 $2,518.0800049350 E05092 LE, LINH D 11/27/2024 $2,448.2100049351 E01280 LE, TAMMY 11/27/2024 $1,709.4500049352 E03617 LEE, GRACE E 11/27/2024 $3,334.8900049353 E05159 LUNA-REYNOSA, URSULA 11/27/2024 $7,088.4200049354 E05180 MEDINA, MELANIE 11/27/2024 $1,884.4700049355 E02895 MOURE, SVETLANA 11/27/2024 $2,653.06Server Name: cognos.ggcity.org User Name: victoriac 147
CITY OF GARDEN GROVEGGFEFM002 Warrant Register PayrollCheck Dates Nov 27, 2024Report Generated on Nov 26, 2024 5:35:16 PM Page 21Check Vendor # Vendor Name Issue Date Check Amount00049356 E05181 NGUYEN, DAVID 11/27/2024 $2,122.0600049357 E03255 NGUYEN, PHUONG VIEN T 11/27/2024 $2,307.3200049358 E02560 NGUYEN, QUANG 11/27/2024 $2,810.3900049359 E01286 NGUYEN, TINA T 11/27/2024 $2,116.0400049360 E03541 PHI, THYANA T 11/27/2024 $3,162.6100049361 E05106 ROMERO, ALEX 11/27/2024 $2,107.6700049362 E05211 SURJONO, FRUMENTIUS C 11/27/2024 $802.1200049363 E04408 THRONE, TIMOTHY E 11/27/2024 $2,490.4600049364 E02543 TO, TANYA L 11/27/2024 $1,746.3600049365 E01971 TRAN, CUONG K 11/27/2024 $2,510.0400049366 E02056 TRUONG, ELAINE 11/27/2024 $1,882.3400049367 E02562 VO, THANH-NGUYEN 11/27/2024 $2,136.3500049368 E05104 YANG, DANA DAEUN 11/27/2024 $2,407.61EFT - Total $1,994,913.05Overall - Total $2,010,687.73 Server Name: cognos.ggcity.org User Name: victoriac
148
Item 497/2024
Final
City of Garden Grove
INTER-DEPARTMENT MEMORANDUM
To:
Lisa L. Kim From: Niki Wetzel
Dept:
City Manager Dept: Community Development
Date: 12/10/2024
Subject: Adoption of a Resolution denying an appeal filed by Supporters Alliance for Environmental Responsibility (SAFER) and upholding the Planning Commission’s Decision to approve Site Plan No. SP-145-2024 and Lot Line Adjustement No. LLA-033-2024. (Action Item)
OBJECTIVE
To conduct a public hearing to consider an appeal filed by Supporters Alliance for Environmental Responsibility (“SAFER”) requesting that the City Council consider modifying the Garden Grove Planning Commission’s decision to approve Site Plan No. SP-145-2024 and Lot Line Adjustment No. LLA-033-2024.
BACKGROUND
William D. Jager (“Applicant”) has filed a land use application for City approval of Site Plan No.
SP-145-2024 and Lot Line Adjustment No. LLA -033-2024, for property located on the north side of Garden Grove Boulevard, between Galway Street and Brookhurst Way, at 9891, 9897, and 9901 Garden Grove Boulevard . Site Plan No. SP -145-2024 would authorize the construction of a seven -story, 98-unit multiple-family residential apartment co mplex with associated site improvements on the 1.35-acre (gross) project site. Lot Line Adjustment No.
LLA-033-2024 would authorize removal of an existing lot line for the purpose of consolidating two (2) adjoining parcels into one (1) parcel to accommoda te the proposed residential development.
The Applicant contends that the proposed project is categorically exempt from review under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to Section 15332 of the State CEQA Guidelines (In-Fill Development Projects). In support of this contention, the Applicant provided an Environmental Information Form as part of its application (Attachment 7) and a Class 32 Exemption Justification Memorandum, along with supporting technical studies (Attachment 6).
City Staff concurred that the Class 32 CEQA exemption applies and recommended that the Planning Commission approve the proposed project, subject to specified Conditions of Approval.
149
Item 497/2024
The Garden Grove Planning Commission held a duly noticed public hearing r egarding the proposed project on October 3, 2024. No members of the public submitted letters or spoke in opposition to the proposed project at the public hearing. After closing the public hearing, the Planning Commission voted 5-0 (with 2 commissioners absent) to adopt Resolution No. 6097- 24 determining that the proposed Project was categorically exempt from CEQA pursuant to the Class 32 exemption, making certain findings, and approving the requested land use entitlements, subject to specified Conditions of Approval. Resolution No. 6097-24 is included as Attachment 2.
On October 24, 2024, within the designated 21-day appeal period, the City Clerk received an appeal of the Planning Commission’s decision from Supporters Alliance for Environmental Responsibility (“SAFER”) . According to its appeal, SAFER objects to the Planning Commission’s determination that the project is categorically exempt from CEQA review based on the Class 32 Categorical Exemption, asserts that the Class 32 exemption does not apply, and requests that the City require an Initial Study be conducted and a CEQA document prepared to analyze and mitigate the Project’s environmental impacts. A copy of the Appeal form filed by SAFER is included as Attachment 5. No additional supporting information or justification for the appeal or its request was provided by SAFER at the time of filing of the appeal.
DISCUSSION
Project Summary:
The 1.35-acre project site is located on the north side of Garden Grove Boulevard, between Galway Street and Brookhurst Way. The site is currently improved with a vacant auto brake and alignment shop, built in 1939, which was last operated by Vodie’s Alignment and Brakes from 1985 to 2021. The auto shop vacated the project site in 2021 and was subsequently sold to the current owner, Lowden Real Estate Investments, LLC. The subject site has a General Plan Land Use designation of Residential/Commercial Mixed Use 3 (RC3) and is zoned GGMU-3 (Garden Grove Boulevard Mixed Use 3). The project site abuts GGMU -3 zoned properties to the north currently improved with multiple-family units, to the east and west currently improved with auto commercial uses, and to the south , across Garden Grove Boulevard, currently improved with a commercial shopping center.
The Applicant proposes to demolish the improvements on-site formerly occupied by the auto shop to construct a five-story residential apartment complex over two (2) levels of parking garage, for seven (7) stories total. The development would consist of ten (10) deed restricted “very low-income” units and eighty -eight (88) market rate units. The Project incorporates two (2) concessions/incentives and six (6) waivers/reductions of development standards pursuant to the Density Bonus Law (DBL) to facilitate the proposed developm ent. These concessions/incentives and waivers/reductions of development standards are more fully described in the attached Planning Commission Staff Report dated October 3, 2024 (Attachment 3).
In order to facilitate the construction of the proposed development, approval of a Lot Line Adjustment is needed in order to eliminate an existing interior lot line to consolidate the two (2) parcels into one (1) parcel. Currently, Parcel 1, located on the east side of the project 150
Item 497/2024
site, has a net lot size of 17,500 square feet, while Parcel 2, located on the west side of the project site, has a net lot size of 35,000 square feet (41,253 gross square feet) for a total of
1.35 gross acres or 58,753 square feet.
SITE PLAN:
Specific elements of the proposed Sit e Plan and development are discussed below – and in more detail in the attached Planning Commission Staff Report dated O ctober 3, 2024 (Attachment 3).
Access to the site is proposed along a shared drive aisle located along Garden Grove Boulevard on the we sterly side of the project site, leading to the entry of the gated garage ground level. The garage ramp is centrally located within the building footprint to access the second garage level. The shared drive aisle also provides the required fire truck access and turnaround to the rear of the site, as well as guest surface parking spaces. A pedestrian walkway will be provided along the east side of the site leading to the active recreation area located at the rear, along the north side of the site. The proposed building provides an entry along the front of the ground floor, which leads to the leasing office, elevator lobby, a community conference room, and the parking garage.
The apartment units will be located on stories three (3) through seven (7) and will be accessed by interior corridors. The third story, the podium level, also offers outdoor and indoor common recreation areas.
Per the DBL, the project is required to provide 115 parking spaces minimum, but will provide 120 parking spaces total, resulting in a surplus of five (5) parking spaces that will be designated as guest parking.
The proposed project will consist of four (4) unit types. The units will range between one (1) and three (3) bedrooms, one (1) to two (2) bathrooms, and floor areas between 656 and 1,132 square feet. Each unit will also consist of a kitchen/dining area, a living room, a washer/dryer closet, and a private deck accessed off of the living room.
The proposed development is required to provide 29,400 square feet of open space (300 square feet per unit) minimum. As designed, the project would provide approximately 9,260 square feet of private open space, and approximately 20,566 square feet of common open space, for 29,826 square feet total, exceeding the minimum requirement.
The private open spaces are provided as decks for each unit accessible from the living rooms. The decks range from ninety (90) to ninety -five (95) square feet in size. All decks are designed to meet the minimum sixty (60) square -foot area, the minimum six-foot (6’-0”) dimension, and minimum eight-foot (8’-0”) vertical clearance.
The outdoor active open space area on -grade at the rear of the project site will be improved with two (2) half basketball courts, bench seating, and landscaping. Two (2) open space areas located on the third story podium level will be improved with a variety 151
Item 497/2024
of amenities, such as barbeques with table seating, a community garden, an outdoor yoga area, in-ground spas, fire pit tables, lounge seating, raised platers, artificial turf areas, and landscaping. There are two (2) indoor open spaces also proposed on the third story adjacent to the outdoor open spaces that will be improved with a variety of amenities, such as workstations, an indoor yoga room, a clubhouse with a kitchen. The project also proposes a community conference room, community storage space, a multi-purpose room, a media room, a flex room, and common restrooms. Additionally, a passive open space will be located on -grade along the easterly side yard improved with pathways, bench seating, raised landscape beds, and pet waste stations.
The project has been designed with a pedestrian oriented area within the first five feet (5’-0”) of the minimum required fifteen -foot (15’-0”) front yard setback. The project proposes enhanced paving, and will include bench and lounge seating. The project proposes a variety of trees and landscaping within the front setback area and the public right-of-way, as required for properties located in the GGMU-3 zone that front Garden Grove Boulevard.
The project proposes landscaping along the side and rear setbacks, except on are as designated for walkways, parking spaces, and the drive aisle, using a variety of plant materials. All of the landscaped areas will be fitted with automatic irrigation systems that comply with the City’s Water Efficiency Guidelines.
The apartment complex will incorporate a contemporary architectural style in a white and brown color scheme. The building design includes stucco, brick veneer, metal cladding and synthetic board exteriors, vinyl windows, awnings, canopies, and window and door storefronts along Garden Grove Boulevard. The deck areas of each unit will be accentuated with metal guardrails. Along the front elevation, stories three (3) through seven (7) are step ped-back approximately twenty feet (20’ -0”) to provide a human-scaled quality along Garden Grove Boulevard. The elevations of the buildings propose varied architectural articulation of the facades, such as interrupted breaks in façade planes, projections and recesses, along with changes in materials, differentiation in color, and changes in detailing.
Applicable Law Governing Appeals of Planning Commission Decisions:
Pursuant to Garden Grove Municipal Code (GGMC) Section 9.32.030 (B), all decisions of the Planning Commission are appealable to the City Council. Appeals are governed by GGMC Sections 9.32.110 through 9.32.150.
GGMC Section 9.32.110 (Appeals – Purpose) provides that t he purpose of an appeal of a hearing body decision is to allow an applicant or an interested party of a land use action who feels aggrieved by the decision to seek review of the case by another imported hearing body.
SAFER did not articulate how or why it is an “interested party” vis-à-vis this particular project when it filed its appeal.
Pursuant to GGMC Section 9.32.120 (Time for Appeal), a decision of a hearing body on a land use action may be appealed by the applicant, or an individual, within 21 days of the date on which the decision is rendered. SAFER is a nonprofit corporation, not an individual. 152
Item 497/2024