SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL
MEETING
OCTOBER 10, 2023
DOCUMENTS RECEIVED AFTER
PUBLISHED AGENDA
Public Comments
Thank you,
Elisa Márquez (She/her/ella)
Supervisor, Second District
Item# 1
MIN 23-101
Memo to amend the
September 26 City
Council meeting minutes
DATE: October 10, 2023
TO: Mayor and City Council
FROM: City Clerk
SUBJECT September 26, 2023 City Council Meeting Minutes
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________
This serves to amend the September 26 City Council meeting minutes.
Page six, first paragraph, currently reads:
Council Member Andrews agreed with her colleagues on the restorative justice aspect and supported an administrative approach; agreed with addressing the issue through education at schools but noted that a lot of the activity stemmed from outside the community; wanted to learn about the outcome of the meeting between San Jose and Silicon Valley about deterring sideshows with social media companies; supported privacy and First Amendment rights, but was also interested in impacts from criminal behavior and requested year -to-year data be provided; supported the urban design approach and urged staff to be more creative in responding to requests for traffic calming and evaluating through a lens of preventing escalation of activities, and not involving law enforcement when not needed; was interested in community engagement and indicating where such activities were legal, but was reluctant in sanctioning it due to liability and insurance reasons; and added that information on the topic be a part of the education to the community.
Proposed to read:
Council Member Andrews agreed with her colleagues on the restorative justice aspect and supported an administrative approach; agreed with addressing the issue through education at schools but noted that a lot of the activity stemmed from outside the community; wanted to learn about the outcome of the meeting between San Jose and Silicon Valley about deterring sideshows with social media companies; supported privacy and First Amendment rights, but was also interested in impacts from criminal behavior and requested year -to-year data be provided; supported the urban design approach and urged staff to be more creative in responding to requests for traffic calming and evaluating through a lens of preventing escalation of activities, and not involving law enforcement when not needed; stated she did not want illegal sideshows due to the cost impact to the community; and added that there should be education on where it is allowed.
With the change noted above, I respectfully request approval of the amended minutes.
Item# 4
PH 23-038
Sidewalk Vendor Program
I sincerely hope that Council honors and respects that. --
Jesse Gunn, He/Him
Community Services Commissioner, City of Hayward
experience. Brick-and-mortar restaurants are hurting: inflation, rising minimum wages, and a slow post-pandemic recovery have all hurt the already-slim margins with which brick and mortar restaurants operate. They absolutely need help and economic stimulus to recover. But using sidewalk vendors as a scapegoat for larger economic issues will not help them: it won’t bring down the cost of butter, it won’t bring in more customers, it won’t lower the cost of living.
Instead of criminalizing sidewalk vending, we should work hard to make it accessible to vendors and safe for customers, all of which will make it beneficial for the whole City.
Thank you for your time, and I look forward to the discussion tonight.
All the best,
Collin Thormoto
Community Services Commission
Item# 5
RPT 23-100
City Council Referral:
A Bench for Every Bus Stop
DATE: October 6, 2023
TO: Mayor and City Council
FROM: Director of Public Works
THROUGH: City Manager
SUBJECT: Response to Council Referral Memorandum: A Bench for Every Stop
That the Council accepts an amendment to RPT 23-100, Attachment II Staff Analysis and also receives a copy of Attachm ent I to the Council Referral , which w as inadvertently om itted from the agenda packet.
Recommended by: Alex Ameri, Director of Public Works
Approved by:
_______________________________________
Kelly McAdoo, City Manager
Attachment: Attachment I – Hayward Bus Shelter Placement Rankings Revised Attachment II Staff Analysis
City
Existing
Shelter
At Bus
Stop?
Person-Minutes
(Percentile Rank)
% People of
Color in Block
Groups
(Percentile Rank)
% Low-Income
Population in
Block Groups
(Percentile Rank)
Social Services
within a Quarter
Mile (Percentile
Rank) Bus Stop Location
Weighted Score
(100 x Person-Minutes)
+
(50 x People of Color)
+
(50 x Low-Income)
+
(35 x Social Services)
HAYWARD #N/A 91.10% 85.50% 67.60% 72.50% A St & Flagg St 193 HAYWARD Hayward 91.00% 74.60% 77.40% 72.50% W Tennyson Rd & Calaroga Av (St. Rose Hospital) 192 HAYWARD #N/A 86.30% 78.70% 77.90% 72.50% W A St & Victory Dr 190 HAYWARD #N/A 96.80% 50.10% 69.70% 72.50% Mission Blvd & C St 182 HAYWARD #N/A 80.20% 86.30% 59.00% 72.50% W A St & Arbor Av 178 HAYWARD Hayward 91.20% 92.00% 27.90% 72.50% W Tennyson Rd & Calaroga Av (St. Rose Hospital) 177 HAYWARD #N/A 86.90% 50.10% 69.70% 72.50% Watkins St & C St 172 HAYWARD Hayward 85.40% 50.10% 69.70% 72.50% C St & Mission Blvd 171 HAYWARD Hayward 94.60% 74.40% 76.40% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & W Tennyson Rd 170 HAYWARD Hayward 92.10% 80.20% 75.10% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & W A St 170 HAYWARD #N/A 90.00% 80.20% 75.10% 0.00% W A St & Hesperian Blvd 168 HAYWARD Hayward 92.70% 88.90% 57.30% 0.00% W Tennyson Rd & Pompano Av 166 HAYWARD Hayward 91.40% 72.10% 76.50% 0.00% W Tennyson Rd & Huntwood Av 166 HAYWARD #N/A 93.90% 70.60% 70.80% 0.00% Tennyson Rd & Whitman St 165 HAYWARD #N/A 81.80% 49.60% 61.60% 72.50% W A St & Happyland Av 163 HAYWARD Hayward 96.50% 83.40% 47.20% 0.00% W Tennyson Rd & Hesperian Blvd (Kaiser Hospital) 162 HAYWARD #N/A 74.50% 91.40% 82.10% 0.00% Schafer Rd & Tyrrell Av 161 HAYWARD #N/A 74.50% 91.40% 82.10% 0.00% Manon Av & Shepherd Av 161 HAYWARD #N/A 83.90% 70.30% 84.20% 0.00% W Tennyson Rd & Portsmouth Av 161 HAYWARD #N/A 88.40% 44.90% 48.70% 72.50% 2nd St & Walpert St (Rear Of Hayward High School) 161 HAYWARD #N/A 79.20% 49.60% 61.60% 72.50% Santa Clara St & W A St 160 HAYWARD #N/A 83.00% 92.80% 60.00% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Industrial Pkwy 159 HAYWARD #N/A 96.30% 59.30% 66.10% 0.00% W Tennyson Rd & Hesperian Blvd 159 HAYWARD #N/A 70.90% 91.40% 82.10% 0.00% Manon Av & Schafer Rd 158 HAYWARD #N/A 79.20% 80.20% 75.10% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & Sueirro St 157 HAYWARD #N/A 81.90% 88.90% 57.30% 0.00% W Tennyson Rd & Dickens Av 155 HAYWARD #N/A 89.80% 66.70% 63.30% 0.00% W Tennyson Rd & Dickens Av 155 HAYWARD #N/A 88.90% 66.70% 63.30% 0.00% W Tennyson Rd & Pompano Av 154 HAYWARD #N/A 77.00% 84.70% 69.00% 0.00% Gading Rd & W Harder Rd 154 HAYWARD #N/A 66.00% 66.60% 58.00% 72.50% W Winton Av & Amador St 154 HAYWARD Hayward 91.30% 69.20% 55.40% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & W Winton Av 154 HAYWARD #N/A 75.70% 70.30% 84.20% 0.00% W Tennyson Rd & Portsmouth Av 153 HAYWARD Hayward 91.30% 66.20% 57.00% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & Arf Av (Mt. Eden Sr High School) 153 HAYWARD #N/A 94.20% 51.50% 64.70% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & Tennyson Rd 152 HAYWARD #N/A 78.90% 44.90% 48.70% 72.50% 2nd St & Acacia Dr 151 HAYWARD Hayward 87.30% 69.20% 55.40% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & Middle Ln 150 HAYWARD #N/A 64.30% 50.10% 69.70% 72.50% Main St & B St 150 HAYWARD #N/A 62.80% 91.40% 82.10% 0.00% Manon Av & Schafer Rd 150 HAYWARD #N/A 74.00% 72.10% 76.50% 0.00% W Tennyson Rd & Ruus Rd 148 HAYWARD #N/A 94.30% 61.40% 46.00% 0.00% Southland Dr & California Bank (Southland Mall) 148 HAYWARD #N/A 74.50% 88.90% 57.30% 0.00% Tampa Av & W Tennyson Rd 148 HAYWARD Hayward 93.80% 61.40% 46.00% 0.00% Southland Dr & California Bank (Southland Mall) 148 HAYWARD #N/A 99.10% 58.50% 37.90% 0.00% Grand St & Dean St 147 HAYWARD #N/A 83.60% 58.20% 69.10% 0.00% Schafer Rd & Gading Rd (Glassbrook School) 147 HAYWARD #N/A 81.50% 66.70% 63.30% 0.00% Schafer Rd & Gading Rd (Glassbrook School) 147 HAYWARD #N/A 79.20% 77.90% 56.70% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Sycamore Av 147 HAYWARD #N/A 80.20% 76.10% 56.20% 0.00% Manon Av & Shepherd Av 146 HAYWARD Hayward 91.90% 61.40% 46.00% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & West St 146 HAYWARD #N/A 91.70% 61.40% 46.00% 0.00% W Winton Av & Wright Dr 145 HAYWARD #N/A 96.80% 58.50% 37.90% 0.00% D St & Grand St 145 HAYWARD #N/A 52.30% 77.90% 56.70% 72.50% Mission Blvd & Jackson St 145 HAYWARD #N/A 63.60% 83.50% 26.80% 72.50% W Winton Av & Edloe Dr (County Building) 144 HAYWARD #N/A 72.80% 76.70% 64.60% 0.00% W Winton Av & D St 143 HAYWARD #N/A 66.40% 84.70% 69.00% 0.00% Gading Rd & Dumont Av 143 HAYWARD Hayward 90.50% 44.60% 9.60% 72.50% Chabot College 143 HAYWARD Hayward 90.40% 44.60% 9.60% 72.50% Chabot College 143 HAYWARD Hayward 76.10% 72.20% 60.80% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Sorenson Rd 143 HAYWARD #N/A 77.00% 83.40% 47.20% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & Bolero Av 142 HAYWARD #N/A 86.90% 83.50% 26.80% 0.00% Amador St & W Jackson St 142 HAYWARD #N/A 95.80% 66.10% 25.40% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & Panama St 142 HAYWARD #N/A 86.10% 83.50% 26.80% 0.00% 24660 Amador St 141 HAYWARD Hayward 74.50% 60.50% 72.60% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Harder Rd 141 HAYWARD #N/A 80.10% 52.70% 67.90% 0.00% B St & Vermont St 140 HAYWARD Hayward 54.90% 50.10% 69.70% 72.50% B St & Mission Blvd 140 HAYWARD #N/A 46.90% 77.90% 56.70% 72.50% Mission Blvd & Pinedale Ct 140 HAYWARD #N/A 46.90% 77.90% 56.70% 72.50% Fletcher Lane & Watkins St 140 HAYWARD #N/A 66.40% 88.90% 57.30% 0.00% Folsom Av & Tampa Av 140 HAYWARD #N/A 75.40% 58.20% 69.10% 0.00% Schafer Rd & Sunvale Ct 139 HAYWARD #N/A 72.30% 76.10% 56.20% 0.00% Manon Av & Harris Rd 138 HAYWARD Hayward 57.90% 83.50% 26.80% 72.50% W Winton Av & Santa Clara St 138 HAYWARD #N/A 72.40% 80.40% 51.50% 0.00% W Tennyson Rd & Lustig Ct 138 HAYWARD #N/A 70.90% 72.20% 60.80% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Harder Rd 137
ATTACHMENT I
HAYWARD Hayward 83.60% 61.40% 46.00% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & Southland Dr 137 HAYWARD #N/A 93.20% 49.90% 38.00% 0.00% Old Hilary Rd & CSU East Bay Student Services 137 HAYWARD #N/A 72.30% 58.20% 69.10% 0.00% Gading Rd & Huntwood Way 136 HAYWARD Hayward 76.50% 59.50% 8.60% 72.50% Hesperian Blvd & Depot Rd 136 HAYWARD #N/A 80.00% 78.00% 33.20% 0.00% W Tennyson Rd & Baldwin St 136 HAYWARD Hayward 72.90% 59.30% 66.10% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & Sleepy Hollow Av 136 HAYWARD #N/A 61.10% 72.10% 76.50% 0.00% Harris Rd & Manon Av 135 HAYWARD #N/A 54.20% 49.60% 61.60% 72.50% A St & Santa Clara St 135 HAYWARD Hayward 54.10% 49.60% 61.60% 72.50% W Winton Av & Santa Clara St 135 HAYWARD #N/A 79.20% 52.50% 59.00% 0.00% Harder Rd & Soto Rd 135 HAYWARD #N/A 57.00% 80.20% 75.10% 0.00% W A St & Royal Av 135 HAYWARD Hayward 76.50% 51.50% 64.70% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & Sleepy Hollow Av 135 HAYWARD #N/A 79.20% 69.00% 40.70% 0.00% Evergreen St & Eldridge Av 134 HAYWARD #N/A 74.50% 71.00% 47.00% 0.00% Whitman St & Berry Av 134 HAYWARD #N/A 94.40% 55.60% 22.60% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & W Winton Av 134 HAYWARD Hayward 73.70% 60.70% 58.60% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & Catalpa Way 133 HAYWARD #N/A 96.90% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Sabre St & Div 6 Gate 133 HAYWARD #N/A 76.90% 78.00% 33.20% 0.00% W Tennyson Rd & Ruus Rd 133 HAYWARD #N/A 58.00% 72.10% 76.50% 0.00% W Tennyson Rd & Baldwin St 132 HAYWARD #N/A 76.10% 33.20% 78.60% 0.00% Mission Blvd:Corrine St(Gresel St) 132 HAYWARD #N/A 95.90% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Sabre St & Div 6 Gate 132 HAYWARD #N/A 64.40% 77.90% 56.70% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Torrano Av 132 HAYWARD #N/A 74.50% 78.80% 35.00% 0.00% Underwood Av & Inglewood St 131 HAYWARD #N/A 55.00% 92.80% 60.00% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Arrowhead Way 131 HAYWARD #N/A 72.30% 71.00% 47.00% 0.00% Whitman St & Berry Av 131 HAYWARD #N/A 92.20% 55.60% 22.60% 0.00% W Winton Av & Wright Dr 131 HAYWARD #N/A 53.60% 50.10% 54.50% 72.50% 2nd St & D St 131 HAYWARD #N/A 69.00% 66.20% 57.00% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & Tahoe Av 131 HAYWARD #N/A 85.70% 49.90% 38.00% 0.00% East Loop Rd & CSU East Bay Recreation & Wellness 130 HAYWARD #N/A 85.20% 49.90% 38.00% 0.00% West Loop Rd & CSU East Bay Library 129 HAYWARD Hayward 93.00% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & W A St 129 HAYWARD #N/A 69.00% 60.70% 58.60% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & Industrial Pkwy 129 HAYWARD #N/A 55.00% 77.70% 68.50% 0.00% Whitman St & Cody Rd 128 HAYWARD #N/A 77.00% 69.90% 32.20% 0.00% Underwood Av & Inglewood St 128 HAYWARD #N/A 46.90% 83.50% 26.80% 72.50% Amador St & W Winton Av 127 HAYWARD #N/A 88.30% 55.60% 22.60% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & Longwood Av 127 HAYWARD #N/A 70.90% 60.50% 52.30% 0.00% Folsom Av & Tampa Av 127 HAYWARD #N/A 64.20% 59.30% 66.10% 0.00% Tennyson Rd & Oliver Dr 127 HAYWARD #N/A 46.90% 74.70% 83.80% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Valle Vista Av 126 HAYWARD #N/A 41.60% 50.10% 54.50% 91.60% B St & 3rd St 126 HAYWARD #N/A 70.90% 69.00% 40.70% 0.00% Evergreen St & W Harder Rd 126 HAYWARD #N/A 66.40% 84.10% 30.80% 0.00% Tennyson Rd & Oliver Dr 124 HAYWARD #N/A 46.90% 77.20% 76.00% 0.00% Meekland Av & A St 124 HAYWARD #N/A 58.00% 66.70% 63.30% 0.00% Tennyson Rd & Tampa Av 123 HAYWARD #N/A 75.70% 44.90% 48.70% 0.00% 2nd St & Canyon View Ct 123 HAYWARD #N/A 55.00% 77.90% 56.70% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Orchard Av 122 HAYWARD Hayward 54.20% 67.60% 17.40% 72.50% A St & Filbert St 122 HAYWARD #N/A 64.20% 84.10% 30.80% 0.00% W Tennyson Rd & Bahama Av 122 HAYWARD #N/A 55.00% 60.50% 72.60% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Torrano Av 122 HAYWARD Hayward 55.00% 72.20% 60.80% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Jefferson St 122 HAYWARD Hayward 36.80% 50.10% 54.50% 91.60% 2nd St & B St 121 HAYWARD #N/A 43.30% 50.10% 54.50% 72.50% D St & 2nd St 121 HAYWARD #N/A 57.20% 58.20% 69.10% 0.00% Gading Rd & Dumont Av 121 HAYWARD Hayward 18.70% 85.50% 67.60% 72.50% A St & Grand St 121 HAYWARD #N/A 18.70% 85.50% 67.60% 72.50% A St & Alice St 121 HAYWARD #N/A 18.50% 85.50% 67.60% 72.50% A St & Filbert St 120 HAYWARD #N/A 78.50% 34.30% 49.40% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Highland Blvd 120 HAYWARD Hayward 55.00% 66.70% 63.30% 0.00% Patrick Av & Roosevelt Av 120 HAYWARD #N/A 46.90% 77.70% 68.50% 0.00% Whitman St & Jane Av 120 HAYWARD #N/A 78.50% 57.10% 25.80% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Gresel St 120 HAYWARD #N/A 75.70% 49.90% 38.00% 0.00% West Loop Rd & Carlos Bee Blvd 120 HAYWARD Hayward 52.30% 60.50% 72.60% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Carlos Bee Blvd 119 HAYWARD #N/A 82.20% 41.60% 31.40% 0.00% B St & Pearl Av 119 HAYWARD #N/A 64.40% 49.80% 58.40% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Sunset Blvd 119 HAYWARD #N/A 33.10% 50.10% 69.70% 72.50% Watkins St & Jackson St 118 HAYWARD #N/A 36.80% 46.20% 52.80% 91.60% City Center Dr & Centennial Hall 118 HAYWARD #N/A 73.70% 18.20% 19.80% 72.50% 2nd St & Acacia Dr 118 HAYWARD #N/A 42.40% 74.40% 76.40% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & Bolero Av 118 HAYWARD Hayward 36.80% 83.50% 26.80% 72.50% Amador St & Elmhurst St 117 HAYWARD Hayward 36.80% 83.50% 26.80% 72.50% Amador St & Elmhurst St 117 HAYWARD #N/A 36.80% 83.50% 26.80% 72.50% Amador St & W Winton Av 117 HAYWARD #N/A 61.10% 33.20% 78.60% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Blanche St 117 HAYWARD #N/A 81.00% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & Industrial Blvd 117 HAYWARD #N/A 77.90% 57.90% 19.60% 0.00% Harder Rd & Mocine Av 117 HAYWARD #N/A 50.20% 72.60% 58.90% 0.00% W Tennyson Rd & Beatron Way 116 HAYWARD #N/A 66.40% 46.20% 52.80% 0.00% City Center Dr & Foothill Blvd 116 HAYWARD #N/A 80.00% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Mack St & Div 6 Yard 116 HAYWARD Hayward 73.40% 63.10% 21.60% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Sorenson Rd 116 HAYWARD Hayward 23.00% 50.10% 69.70% 91.60% B St & Foothill Blvd 115 HAYWARD #N/A 30.10% 50.10% 54.50% 91.60% Foothill Blvd & A St 114
ATTACHMENT I
HAYWARD #N/A 78.50% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Depot Rd & Clawiter Rd 114 HAYWARD #N/A 78.50% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Cabot Blvd & W Winton Av 114 HAYWARD #N/A 55.00% 71.00% 47.00% 0.00% Whitman St & Sycamore Av 114 HAYWARD #N/A 40.70% 77.70% 68.50% 0.00% Whitman St & Jane Av 114 HAYWARD #N/A 36.80% 77.20% 76.00% 0.00% Meekland Av & A St 113 HAYWARD #N/A 53.60% 60.70% 58.60% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & Eden Park Pl 113 HAYWARD #N/A 69.00% 49.90% 38.00% 0.00% Campus Dr & Hayward Blvd 113 HAYWARD #N/A 50.20% 59.30% 66.10% 0.00% W Tennyson Rd & Bahama Av 113 HAYWARD Hayward 77.00% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & Skywest Dr 113 HAYWARD Hayward 50.20% 69.20% 55.40% 0.00% W Winton Av & Saklan Rd 113 HAYWARD #N/A 62.60% 48.60% 50.90% 0.00% Foothill Blvd & Grove Way 112 HAYWARD #N/A 46.90% 66.10% 64.50% 0.00% Silva Av & Thomas Av 112 HAYWARD Hayward 46.90% 83.40% 47.20% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & Oliver Dr 112 HAYWARD #N/A 62.60% 46.20% 52.80% 0.00% City Center Dr & Foothill Blvd (N Jctn) 112 HAYWARD #N/A 9.80% 85.50% 67.60% 72.50% A St & Myrtle St 112 HAYWARD #N/A 36.80% 86.00% 62.90% 0.00% Santa Clara St & Jackson St 111 HAYWARD #N/A 36.80% 72.10% 76.50% 0.00% Huntwood Av & Harris Rd 111 HAYWARD #N/A 74.50% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & Bartlett Av 110 HAYWARD #N/A 74.00% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% 25800 Industrial Blvd 110 HAYWARD Hayward 74.00% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% W Winton Av & Corsair Blvd 110 HAYWARD #N/A 57.00% 64.60% 41.00% 0.00% Huntwood Av & Folsom Av 110 HAYWARD #N/A 25.40% 50.10% 54.50% 91.60% B St & 3rd St 110 HAYWARD #N/A 65.30% 18.20% 19.80% 72.50% 2nd St & Walpert St 110 HAYWARD #N/A 59.20% 61.20% 39.50% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Blanche St 110 HAYWARD #N/A 31.60% 50.10% 54.50% 72.50% C St & Foothill Blvd (1st St) 109 HAYWARD #N/A 17.30% 50.10% 69.70% 91.60% Foothill Blvd & A St 109 HAYWARD #N/A 50.10% 71.00% 47.00% 0.00% Whitman St & Sycamore Av 109 HAYWARD #N/A 66.40% 70.60% 14.30% 0.00% Dyer St & Whipple Rd 109 HAYWARD #N/A 66.40% 48.00% 35.80% 0.00% Stratford Rd & Pacheco Way 108 HAYWARD #N/A 72.40% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Depot Rd & Industrial Blvd 108 HAYWARD #N/A 72.40% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Mack St & W Winton Av 108 HAYWARD #N/A 72.40% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Mack St & W Winton Av 108 HAYWARD #N/A 72.40% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Cabot Blvd & Kidder St 108 HAYWARD #N/A 72.40% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% W Winton Av & Cabot Blvd 108 HAYWARD #N/A 23.30% 50.10% 54.50% 91.60% B St & 2nd St 108 HAYWARD #N/A 36.80% 76.70% 64.60% 0.00% Meek Av & Jackson St 107 HAYWARD #N/A 53.60% 61.40% 46.00% 0.00% Southland Dr & La Playa Dr 107 HAYWARD #N/A 64.40% 63.10% 21.60% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Alquire Pkwy 107 HAYWARD #N/A 70.90% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & Sueirro St 107 HAYWARD #N/A 40.70% 80.40% 51.50% 0.00% Huntwood Av & Celia St 107 HAYWARD #N/A 57.00% 46.20% 52.80% 0.00% Foothill Blvd & Grove Way 107 HAYWARD Hayward 18.90% 50.10% 69.70% 72.50% B St & Main St 104 HAYWARD #N/A 36.80% 77.90% 56.70% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Berry Av 104 HAYWARD #N/A 46.90% 78.80% 35.00% 0.00% Patrick Av & Roosevelt Av 104 HAYWARD #N/A 46.90% 78.80% 35.00% 0.00% Gomer St & Underwood Av 104 HAYWARD #N/A 40.30% 53.90% 22.10% 72.50% A St & Hathaway Av 104 HAYWARD #N/A 43.20% 52.70% 67.90% 0.00% D St & 7th St 104 HAYWARD #N/A 30.30% 77.70% 68.50% 0.00% Whitman St & Cody Rd 103 HAYWARD #N/A 25.40% 50.10% 54.50% 72.50% 2nd St & D St 103 HAYWARD #N/A 61.10% 48.00% 35.80% 0.00% Stratford Rd & Welford Ln 103 HAYWARD #N/A 46.90% 78.00% 33.20% 0.00% Huntwood Av & W Tennyson Rd 103 HAYWARD #N/A 59.90% 67.60% 17.40% 0.00% W Winton Av & Park St 102 HAYWARD Hayward 66.40% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% 25861 Industrial Blvd 102 HAYWARD #N/A 46.90% 83.50% 26.80% 0.00% 24607 Amador St 102 HAYWARD #N/A 40.30% 52.70% 67.90% 0.00% B St & 7th St 101 HAYWARD #N/A 40.30% 52.70% 67.90% 0.00% B St & Linden St 101 HAYWARD #N/A 64.20% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Depot Rd & Foley St 100 HAYWARD #N/A 42.40% 84.10% 30.80% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & Oliver Dr 100 HAYWARD #N/A 46.90% 64.60% 41.00% 0.00% Huntwood Av & Folsom Av 100 HAYWARD #N/A 40.70% 71.00% 47.00% 0.00% Silva Av & Jackson St 100 HAYWARD #N/A 33.10% 60.50% 72.60% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Central Blvd 100 HAYWARD #N/A 66.40% 52.50% 13.00% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Garin Av 99 HAYWARD #N/A 61.10% 35.30% 40.40% 0.00% Campus Dr & Highland Blvd 99 HAYWARD #N/A 17.10% 46.20% 52.80% 91.60% City Center Dr & Centennial Hall 99 HAYWARD #N/A 25.40% 88.90% 57.30% 0.00% Folsom Av & Thackeray Av 99 HAYWARD #N/A 25.40% 88.90% 57.30% 0.00% Tampa Av & Sumatra St 99 HAYWARD #N/A 25.40% 88.90% 57.30% 0.00% Tampa Av & Sumatra St 99 HAYWARD #N/A 20.40% 50.10% 54.50% 72.50% D St & Valley St 98 HAYWARD Hayward 25.40% 74.50% 70.80% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Tennyson Rd 98 HAYWARD #N/A 25.40% 74.50% 70.80% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Hancock St 98 HAYWARD #N/A 25.40% 74.50% 70.80% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Hancock St 98 HAYWARD #N/A 70.30% 44.60% 9.60% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & La Playa Dr 97 HAYWARD #N/A 11.10% 60.10% 61.20% 72.50% D St & Atherton St 97 HAYWARD #N/A 36.80% 52.70% 67.90% 0.00% B St & 6th St 97 HAYWARD #N/A 46.30% 48.60% 50.90% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Sunset Blvd 96 HAYWARD #N/A 24.30% 76.70% 64.60% 0.00% D St & Meek Av 95 HAYWARD Hayward 52.30% 63.10% 21.60% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Tennyson Rd 95 HAYWARD #N/A 9.30% 50.10% 69.70% 72.50% C St & Main St 95 HAYWARD #N/A 52.10% 48.00% 35.80% 0.00% Whipple Rd & Wiegman Rd 94 HAYWARD Hayward 61.10% 52.50% 13.00% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Fairway St 94
ATTACHMENT I
HAYWARD Hayward 58.00% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Industrial Blvd & Depot Rd 94 HAYWARD #N/A 58.00% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% W Winton Av & Corsair Blvd 94 HAYWARD #N/A 58.00% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Depot Rd & Connecticut St 94 HAYWARD #N/A 36.80% 78.80% 35.00% 0.00% Gomer St & Patrick Av 94 HAYWARD #N/A 36.80% 78.80% 35.00% 0.00% Gomer St & Underwood Av 94 HAYWARD #N/A 36.80% 78.00% 33.20% 0.00% Folsom Av & Ruus Rd 92 HAYWARD #N/A 36.80% 78.00% 33.20% 0.00% Folsom Av & Harvey Av 92 HAYWARD #N/A 36.80% 83.50% 26.80% 0.00% 24607 Amador St 92 HAYWARD #N/A 72.80% 18.20% 19.80% 0.00% East Av & Hayward High School 92 HAYWARD #N/A 53.60% 35.30% 40.40% 0.00% Campus Dr & Highland Blvd 91 HAYWARD #N/A 54.50% 41.60% 31.40% 0.00% D St & 5th St 91 HAYWARD #N/A 25.40% 66.70% 63.30% 0.00% Gomer St & Patrick Av 90 HAYWARD #N/A 59.20% 44.60% 17.50% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Fairway St 90 HAYWARD #N/A 36.80% 64.60% 41.00% 0.00% Huntwood Av & Olympic Av 90 HAYWARD #N/A 30.30% 71.00% 47.00% 0.00% Silva Av & Leighton St 89 HAYWARD #N/A 46.90% 48.00% 35.80% 0.00% Ruus Rd & Folsom Av 89 HAYWARD #N/A 46.90% 48.00% 35.80% 0.00% Folsom Av & Harvey Av 89 HAYWARD #N/A 11.70% 84.70% 69.00% 0.00% Underwood Av & Cascade St 89 HAYWARD #N/A 46.50% 48.00% 35.80% 0.00% Huntwood Av & Zephyr Av 88 HAYWARD #N/A 36.80% 69.90% 32.20% 0.00% Evergreen St & Underwood Av 88 HAYWARD #N/A 50.20% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Depot Rd & Clawiter Rd 86 HAYWARD #N/A 50.20% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Mack St & Sabre St 86 HAYWARD #N/A 50.20% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% 21270 Cabot Blvd 86 HAYWARD #N/A 43.40% 63.10% 21.60% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Calhoun St 86 HAYWARD #N/A 43.40% 48.00% 35.80% 0.00% Whipple Rd & Industrial Pkwy Sw 85 HAYWARD #N/A 0.00% 50.10% 69.70% 72.50% Foothill Blvd & City Center Dr (South Jctn) 85 HAYWARD #N/A 24.50% 50.10% 69.70% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Grace St 84 HAYWARD #N/A 0.00% 50.10% 54.50% 91.60% Foothill Blvd & B St 84 HAYWARD #N/A 31.20% 50.10% 54.50% 0.00% B St & 4th St 84 HAYWARD #N/A 17.30% 76.10% 56.20% 0.00% Harris Rd & Huntwood Av 83 HAYWARD #N/A 40.30% 48.00% 35.80% 0.00% Huntwood Av & Sandoval Way 82 HAYWARD #N/A 25.40% 49.60% 61.60% 0.00% Santa Clara St & Redbud Ln 81 HAYWARD #N/A 25.40% 49.60% 61.60% 0.00% Santa Clara St & Redbud Ln 81 HAYWARD #N/A 21.00% 50.10% 69.70% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Grace St 81 HAYWARD #N/A 20.40% 52.70% 67.90% 0.00% 7597 D St (Near Sulpher Creek Nature Center) 81 HAYWARD #N/A 20.40% 52.70% 67.90% 0.00% D St & 6th St 81 HAYWARD #N/A 31.90% 58.50% 37.90% 0.00% D St & Meek Av 80 HAYWARD #N/A 11.70% 67.60% 17.40% 72.50% B St & Filbert St 80 HAYWARD Hayward 43.40% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Depot Rd & Viking St 79 HAYWARD #N/A 43.40% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Sabre St & Corsair Blvd 79 HAYWARD Hayward 43.40% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Depot Rd & Viking St 79 HAYWARD #N/A 43.40% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Cabot Blvd & Bernhardt St 79 HAYWARD #N/A 43.40% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% 21270 Cabot Blvd 79 HAYWARD #N/A 0.00% 44.90% 48.70% 91.60% E St & Bret Harte Middle School 79 HAYWARD #N/A 36.80% 48.00% 35.80% 0.00% Ruus Ln & Stratford Rd (Georgian Manor West Gate) 79 HAYWARD #N/A 36.80% 48.00% 35.80% 0.00% Stratford Rd & Cantebury Ln 79 HAYWARD #N/A 25.40% 64.60% 41.00% 0.00% Industrial Pkwy & Huntwood Av 78 HAYWARD #N/A 11.70% 72.20% 60.80% 0.00% 26395 Mission Blvd 78 HAYWARD #N/A 41.50% 41.60% 31.40% 0.00% B St & 7th St 78 HAYWARD Hayward 41.50% 41.60% 31.40% 0.00% B St & Madrone St 78 HAYWARD #N/A 41.50% 41.60% 31.40% 0.00% B St & 6th St 78 HAYWARD #N/A 41.10% 41.60% 31.40% 0.00% B St & Linden St 78 HAYWARD Hayward 11.70% 66.70% 63.30% 0.00% Patrick Av & W Tennyson Rd 77 HAYWARD #N/A 25.40% 18.20% 19.80% 91.60% 2nd St & E St 76 HAYWARD #N/A 25.40% 69.90% 32.20% 0.00% Evergreen St & Underwood Av 76 HAYWARD #N/A 25.40% 69.90% 32.20% 0.00% Evergreen St & Regal Av 76 HAYWARD #N/A 43.40% 52.50% 13.00% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Arrowhead Way 76 HAYWARD #N/A 33.10% 63.10% 21.60% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Valle Vista Av 75 HAYWARD #N/A 33.10% 48.00% 35.80% 0.00% Huntwood Av & Zephyr Av 75 HAYWARD #N/A 33.10% 48.00% 35.80% 0.00% Huntwood Av & San Luis Obispo Av 75 HAYWARD #N/A 0.00% 46.20% 52.80% 72.50% Foothill Blvd & City Center Dr (South Jctn) 75 HAYWARD #N/A 25.40% 50.00% 46.10% 0.00% D St & 7th St 73 HAYWARD #N/A 36.80% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Hesperian Blvd & Eden Park Pl 73 HAYWARD #N/A 36.50% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Industrial Blvd & Fwy Entrance 72 HAYWARD #N/A 36.50% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Sabre St & Corsair Blvd 72 HAYWARD #N/A 36.50% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% 20201 Mack St (Opp. Ac Transit Training Center) 72 HAYWARD #N/A 36.50% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Mack St & Sabre St 72 HAYWARD #N/A 11.70% 60.50% 52.30% 0.00% Folsom Av & Thackeray Av 68 HAYWARD #N/A 32.20% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% 20234 Mack St (AC Transit Training Center) 68 HAYWARD #N/A 32.20% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Cabot Blvd & Kidder St 68 HAYWARD #N/A 32.20% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Cabot Blvd & Davis Av 68 HAYWARD #N/A 32.20% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% 21121 Cabot Blvd (Railroad Crossing) 68 HAYWARD #N/A 32.20% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Cabot Blvd & Radley Ct 68 HAYWARD #N/A 11.70% 78.00% 33.20% 0.00% Huntwood Av & Celia St 67 HAYWARD #N/A 25.40% 48.00% 35.80% 0.00% Industrial Pkwy & Stratford Rd 67 HAYWARD #N/A 11.70% 49.60% 61.60% 0.00% Santa Clara St & Ocie Way 67 HAYWARD #N/A 11.70% 49.60% 61.60% 0.00% Santa Clara St & Ocie Way 67 HAYWARD #N/A 19.60% 44.90% 48.70% 0.00% 2nd St & Sylvan Glen Ct 66 HAYWARD #N/A 24.30% 48.00% 35.80% 0.00% Huntwood Av & Crocker Av 66 HAYWARD #N/A 24.30% 48.00% 35.80% 0.00% Huntwood Av & Industrial Pkwy 66
ATTACHMENT I
HAYWARD #N/A 0.00% 72.60% 58.90% 0.00% Tennyson Rd & Oharran Dr 66 HAYWARD #N/A 17.30% 58.50% 37.90% 0.00% Grand St & Dean St 66 HAYWARD #N/A 23.50% 48.00% 35.80% 0.00% Whipple Rd & Huntwood Av 65 HAYWARD #N/A 11.70% 64.60% 41.00% 0.00% Huntwood Av & New England Village Dr 65 HAYWARD #N/A 11.70% 64.60% 41.00% 0.00% Ruus Rd & Thiel Rd 65 HAYWARD #N/A 19.60% 18.20% 19.80% 72.50% D St & Valley St 64 HAYWARD #N/A 24.50% 57.90% 19.60% 0.00% Tennyson Rd & Leidig Ct 63 HAYWARD #N/A 11.70% 69.90% 32.20% 0.00% Underwood Av & Cascade St 63 HAYWARD #N/A 11.70% 69.90% 32.20% 0.00% Evergreen St & Regal Av 63 HAYWARD #N/A 42.40% 18.20% 19.80% 0.00% D St & 5th St 61 HAYWARD #N/A 18.50% 48.00% 35.80% 0.00% Huntwood Av & San Luis Obispo Av 60 HAYWARD #N/A 24.50% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Cabot Blvd & Radley Ct 60 HAYWARD #N/A 0.00% 71.00% 47.00% 0.00% Sycamore Av & Silva Av 59 HAYWARD #N/A 10.10% 50.00% 46.10% 0.00% D St & Kings Ct 58 HAYWARD #N/A 10.10% 44.90% 48.70% 0.00% 24535 2nd St 57 HAYWARD #N/A 0.00% 49.60% 61.60% 0.00% Santa Clara St & Santa Clara Way 56 HAYWARD #N/A 18.70% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Depot Rd & Connecticut St 55 HAYWARD #N/A 18.70% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% 1809 Sabre St 55 HAYWARD #N/A 10.10% 18.20% 19.80% 72.50% D St & 2nd St 54 HAYWARD #N/A 11.70% 48.00% 35.80% 0.00% Ruus Ln & Ruus Rd 54 HAYWARD #N/A 11.70% 48.00% 35.80% 0.00% Ruus Ln & Stratford Rd (Opp.Georgian Manor W.Gate) 54 HAYWARD #N/A 25.40% 31.30% 24.90% 0.00% 1797 D St (Next To Sulpher Creek Nature Center) 54 HAYWARD #N/A 7.50% 49.90% 38.00% 0.00% Mission Blvd & Holy Sepulchre Cemetery 51 HAYWARD #N/A 9.30% 48.00% 35.80% 0.00% Huntwood Av & Crocker Av 51 HAYWARD #N/A 11.70% 41.60% 31.40% 0.00% B St & 4th St 48 HAYWARD #N/A 11.70% 30.90% 31.80% 0.00% Whipple Rd & Amaral St 43 HAYWARD #N/A 0.00% 48.00% 35.80% 0.00% Huntwood Av & Salmon Way 42 HAYWARD #N/A 0.00% 48.00% 35.80% 0.00% Huntwood Av & Salmon Way 42 HAYWARD #N/A 0.00% 48.00% 35.80% 0.00% Industrial Pkwy & Industrial Pkwy Sw 42 HAYWARD #N/A 0.00% 48.00% 35.80% 0.00% Industrial Pkwy & Ruus Rd 42 HAYWARD #N/A 0.00% 48.00% 35.80% 0.00% 1310 Ruus Ln (Near Ruus Rd) 42 HAYWARD #N/A 0.00% 48.00% 35.80% 0.00% Ruus Rd & Thiel Rd 42 HAYWARD #N/A 19.60% 18.20% 19.80% 0.00% 24514 2nd St 39 HAYWARD #N/A 0.00% 41.60% 31.40% 0.00% B St & 5th St 37 HAYWARD #N/A 0.00% 41.60% 31.40% 0.00% B St & 5th St 37 HAYWARD #N/A 0.00% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% 20303 Mack St 36
HAYWARD #N/A 0.00% 65.00% 6.70% 0.00% Cabot Blvd & Bernhardt St 36 HAYWARD #N/A 19.60% 25.90% 3.20% 0.00% Campus Dr & Oakes Dr 34 HAYWARD #N/A 10.10% 18.20% 19.80% 0.00% 2nd St & Patricia Ct 29 HAYWARD #N/A 10.10% 18.20% 19.80% 0.00% 24237 2nd St (Rear Of Hayward High School) 29 HAYWARD #N/A 10.10% 25.90% 3.20% 0.00% Campus Dr & Oakes Dr 25
ATTACHMENT I
DATE: October 3, 2023
TO: Mayor and City Council
FROM: Director of Public Works
SUBJECT: Response to Council Referral Memorandum: A Bench for Every Stop
SUMMARY
The City of Hayward has a total of 363 transit stops and only 63 stops of the total have bus shelter and seating available, leaving the remaining 300 stops without seating. To improve access and comfort for transit riders, the implementation of Simme Seats, which are small one to two-seater benches, was explored. The cost estimates for installation and maintenance are summarized below as informed by AC Transit:
Simme Seat Installation Cost
Material, Installation (including minor Concrete work): $2000 per Unit Installation cost for all 300 transit stops without shelters: $600,000
The total cost for multiple installation may be less than $2,000 per unit due to economies of scale. The total cost will be determined after the total number of units is determined.
Simme Seat Maintenance Cost
Pressure washing: $30 per Unit
Cleaning/Trash Pickup/Graffiti Removal: $25 per Unit
Based on the maintenance cost of each Simme Seat, monthly and annual maintenance costs were calculated for the high-range scenario, which assumes bi-weekly cleaning and monthly pressure washing, and the low-range scenario, which involves both cleaning and pressure washing once a month. The two cleaning frequency scenarios have been selected to give Council a sense for the cost. The actual required frequency can be determined in future discussions with AC Transit. The estimated costs of the two scenarios are shown in the table on page 2:
Bus Shelter Installations Cost Estimated Cost
Material & Installation Cost per Unit
(One-Time Fee) $2,000
Material & Installation Cost for 300
Stops (One-Time Fee) $600,000 (or less, due to economies of scale) Bus Shelter Maintenance Cost
High-Range
(Bi-Weekly
Cleaning &
Monthly Pressure
Washing)
Low-Range
(Monthly Cleaning
&
Monthly Pressure
Washing)
Monthly Maintenance Cost per Unit $84 $55
Annual Maintenance Cost per Unit $1,010 $660
Monthly Maintenance Cost for 300
Stops $25,250 $16,500
Annual Maintenance Cost for 300
Stops $303,000 $198,000
It is noted that the estimated maintenance costs assume Simme Seats are installed at all stops without seatings (300 stops). The actual cost and number of transit stops may be modified upon completion of the ongoing Accessibility Study conducted to determine stops suitable for street furniture installations.
NEXT STEPS
Below are the next steps as requested in the Council referral memorandum:
1. Collaboration with AC Transit to conduct an expedited Accessibility Study of Hayward’s bus stops to determine which stops are suitable for the installation of street furniture before the end of FY23/24. The Referral memo suggests that this collaboration may include financial support from the City not to exceed $30,000, as stated in the referral memo.
2. Pilot five (5) low-cost Simme Seat at the highest priority shelter-less bus stops according to AC Transit’s Overall Index Score for each stop to determine the cost of maintenance while AC Transit conducts the Accessibility Study from Step 1. The pilot program is needed to help determine the suitable frequencies of maintenance and potential benefits of Simme Seats such as a rise in ridership.
3. Develop a staff report and project proposal that outlines the cost of installation and maintenance of bus benches across all bus stops in Hayward that currently do not have a shelter and meet the accessibility requirements determined by the Accessibility Study from Step 1. Installation of benches should be prioritized by AC Transit’s Overall Index Score for each stop. Staff’s proposal should include a funding
strategy to complete this initiative within five (5) years, utilizing dollars from our CIP budgets, grants, Measure BB, support from local organizations to “adopt” or sponsor a bench, and/or any other relevant funding sources.
4. Present the project proposal and results of the pilot to the City Council for adoption before the end of 2024.
Prepared by: Jade Kim, Assistant Transportation Engineer Kathy Garcia, Deputy Director of Public Works
Recommended by: Alex Ameri, Director of Public Works
Approved by:
______________________________________
Kelly McAdoo, City Manager