San Pablo Avenue Bridge Replacement Project
S A N PA B LO AV E N U E B R I D G E R E P L A C E M E N T P R OJ E C T
S A N PA B LO AV E N U E B R I D G E R E P L A C E M E N T P R OJ E C T
San Pablo Avenue Bridge Replacement Project
Introduction
Misha Kaur, City of Pinole
Sanjay Mishra, City of Pinole
Mike Roberts, City of Hercules
Jason Jurrens, Quincy Engineering
San Pablo Avenue Bridge Replacement Project
Project Goal
San Pablo Avenue Bridge Replacement Project
Existing Bridge
• 80-Year Old Bridge
• Defined “Structurally Deficient”
by Caltrans
• Eligible for Replacement
• Existing Deficiencies
San Pablo Avenue Bridge Replacement Project
Project Location
San Pablo Avenue Bridge Replacement Project
Project Considerations & Challenges
San Pablo Avenue Bridge Replacement Project
Alternative 1- Existing Alignment
San Pablo Avenue Bridge Replacement Project
Alternative 1- Detour
San Pablo Avenue Bridge Replacement Project
Alternative 2- Parallel Alignment
San Pablo Avenue Bridge Replacement Project
Cost
Alternative Roadway Structures Right of Way
& Utility
Relocation
Design &
CM
Total
1 $4.6M $20.0M $260K $4.2M $29.1M
2 $4.5M $25.2M $2.26M $4.2M $36.2M
• $16.767M Total Programmed for Project
$14.843M Federal HBP (88.53%)
$1.923M Local Match (11.47%)
• Local Match Secured to Date
$1.6M – WCCTC Subregional Transportation Mitigation Program (STMP)
$387,000 – CCTA Measure J TLC
• Project funding gap still exists
San Pablo Avenue Bridge Replacement Project
Value Analysis
Criterion Share Comment
1 Right of Way 40% Minimize permanent R/W impacts
2 Traffic Impacts 30% Minimize traffic disruption duri ng construction 3 Utility Impacts 20% Minimize permanent impacts to ut ilities 4 Construction Duration 10% Minimize construction dura tion Right of Way, 40%
Traffic Impacts,
30%
Utility Impacts,
20%
Construction
Duration,
10%
Performance Criteria
San Pablo Avenue Bridge Replacement Project
Value Analysis
Criterion Weighting Crossing Score (1-10) Criterion Score Baseline (5) - Minimize impacts to adjacent homes Right of Way 40 Alt 1 10 400 Final bridge within existing R/W Alt 2 4 160 Edge of bridge deck moves closer to existing ho mes Criterion Weighting Crossing Score (1-10) Criterion Score Baseline (5) - Minimize traffic impacts Traffic
Impacts 30
Alt 1 3 90 2-lane section through construction
Alt 2 4 120 4-lane section through construction (reduced la ne widths) Criterion Weighting Crossing Score (1-10) Criterion Score Baseline (5) - Minimize utility impacts Utility
Impacts 20 Alt 1 4 80 Temporary Impacts from building temporary bridge & roadway over utilities Alt 2 2 40 Impacts to PG&E Natural Gas and EBMUD Water Line s Criterion Weighting Crossing Score (1-10) Criterion Score Baseline (5) - Minimize construction duration Construction
Duration 10 Alt 1 7 70 Existing bridge constructed in 1 stage- Temp brid ge option Alt 2 3 30 Staged Construction- Partial Bridge Removal
San Pablo Avenue Bridge Replacement Project
Value Analysis
Criterion Scoring Summary Right of Way
Traffic Impacts
Utility Impacts
Construction Duration
Total = Performance
Score
Weighting 40% 30% 20% 10%
Alt 1 400 90 80 70 640
Alt 2 160 120 40 30 350
San Pablo Avenue Bridge Replacement Project
Value Analysis
Note: High value index score (Performance Score / Cost) is best value Crossing Performance Score Cost (Millions) Value Index Score (P/C) Alt 1 640 $29.1 21.99
Alt 2 350 $36.2 9.67
0.00 5.00
10.00 15.00
20.00 25.00
Alt 1 Alt 2
Value Index
San Pablo Avenue Bridge Replacement Project
Key Concerns
• What can this project do to mitigate speeding?
• Will there be accommodations for bicycles and
pedestrians during construction?
• What impact will there be to current state of parking and access between John Street and Pinole Valley Road
during construction?
San Pablo Avenue Bridge Replacement Project
Next Steps
• Continue Technical Studies
• Develop Type Selection Document
• Continue Coordination with Caltrans
• Continue Coordination with BNSF
• Continue Utility Coordination
• Develop Project Report
• Complete CEQA and NEPA
• Begin Final Design and Right of Way
San Pablo Avenue Bridge Replacement Project
HBP Process
San Pablo Avenue Bridge Replacement Project
Schedule
Agency Meetings, Railroad
Coordination, Utility Coordination,
& other Outreach throughout
Jan – Jun 2021 Jan – Jun 2021
• Begin Utility
Coordination
Advertise Project- Spring 2024
Construction- Summer 2024 through Spring 2026
• Complete 30% Plans
Planning & Design Utilities & Right-of-Way
Initiate Project
• Topo Surveys
• Preliminary Geotech
• Begin Environmental Studies
• Begin Railroad Coordination
• Complete
Environmental
Anticipate
NEPA CE & CEQA
IS/MND
• Complete Final
Plans Jul – Dec 2021 Jul – Dec 2021 Jan – Jun 2022 Jan – Jun 2022 Jul – Dec 2020 Jul – Dec 2020 Jan – Jun 2023 Jan – Jun 2023 Jul – Dec 2022 Jul – Dec 2022 Jul – Dec 2023 Jul – Dec 2023 • Complete R/W Acquisition • Complete
Utility
Coordination
• Begin R/W Acquisition
• Complete
Environmental
Technical Studies
San Pablo Avenue Bridge Replacement Project
Q & A
San Pablo Avenue Bridge Replacement Project
Misha Kaur
Sr. Project Manager
2131 Pear Street
Pinole, CA 94564
Email: [email protected]
Phone: (510) 724-9839
https://www.pinolespabridge.com
Contact Information