PROFESSIONAL SERVICE AWARD ANALYSIS
SERVICE: On-Call Environmental Engineering
SERVICE DESCRIPTION: Environmental engineering support for City’s annual Capital Improvement Program projects using state or federal funding sources.
VENDOR: CWE
OVERALL RANKING: 1 out of 6
SUBJECT MATTER EXPERTS/RATERS:
1. Environmental Services Manager 2. Environmental Specialist 3. Environmental Specialist
I. MINIMUM QUALIFI CATIONS REVIEW
Written Proposal Score: Ave. of 85.3
CWE – Minimum Qualifications Review
Criteria
Total
Weighted
Score
Maximum
Score
Understanding of Work to be Done 21.7 25
Experience with Similar Kinds of Work 17.3 20
Staffing 12.7 15
Capability of Developing Innovative or
Advanced Techniques 71 0
Familiarity with State and Local Procedures 9.3 10
Financial Responsibility 10 10
Demonstrated Technical Ability 7.3 10
Total 85.3 100
II. DUE DILIGENCE REVIEW
Interview Ranking: N/A
CWE – Summary of Review
Great staffing experience wi th related projects / work Experience with current state and local procedures
excellent
CWE – Pricing
Low end from $87/hr (CADD Designers)
High end to $294/hr for 3-person survey crew or
$283 for Principal Engineer
PROFESSIONAL SERVICE AWARD ANALYSIS
SERVICE: On-Call Environmental Engineering
SERVICE DESCRIPTION: Environmental engineering support for City’s annual Capital Improvement Program projects using state or federal funding sources.
VENDOR: Environmental Engineering & Contracting, Inc.
OVERALL RANKING: 2 out of 6
SUBJECT MATTER EXPERTS/RATERS:
1. Environmental Services Manager 2. Environmental Specialist 3. Environmental Specialist
I. MINIMUM QUALIFI CATIONS REVIEW
Written Proposal Score: Ave. of 83.3
EEC – Minimum Qualifications Review
Criteria
Total
Weighted
Score
Maximum
Score
Understanding of Work to be Done 23.0 25
Experience with Similar Kinds of Work 18.7 20
Staffing 11.7 15
Capability of Developing Innovative or
Advanced Techniques 6.7 10
Familiarity with State and Local Procedures 10 10
Financial Responsibility 4.6 10
Demonstrated Technical Ability 8.6 10
Total 83.3 100
II. DUE DILIGENCE REVIEW
Interview Ranking: N/A
EEC – Summary of Review
Great experience with related projects / work
Experience with current state and local procedures
excellent
Great demonstrat ed technical ability
EEC – Pricing
Low end from $95/hr (Construction Tech)
H igh end $265 for Principal Engineer
PROFESSIONAL SERVICE AWARD ANALYSIS
SERVICE: On-Call Environmental Engineering
SERVICE DESCRIPTION: Environmental engineering support for City’s annual Capital Improvement Program projects using state or federal funding sources.
VENDOR: GHD, Inc.
OVERALL RANKING: 3 out of 6
SUBJECT MATTER EXPERTS/RATERS:
1. Environmental Services Manager 2. Environmental Specialist 3. Environmental Specialist
I. MINIMUM QUALIFI CATIONS REVIEW
Written Proposal Score: Ave. of 79.0
GHD – Minimum Qualifications Review
Criteria
Total
Weighted
Score
Maximum
Score
Understanding of Work to be Done 21.7 25
Experience with Similar Kinds of Work 15.7 20
Staffing 10.3 15
Capability of Developing Innovative or
Advanced Techniques 7.3 10
Familiarity with State and Local Procedures 8.0 10
Financial Responsibility 9.3 10
Demonstrated Technical Ability 6.7 10
Total 79.0 100
II. DUE DILIGENCE REVIEW
Interview Ranking: N/A
GHD – Summary of Review
Great understanding of work to be done
Good experience with similar kinds of work
Good understanding of local, state, federal
procedures.
GHD – Pricing
Low end from $75 for Admin Officer
H igh end to $280/hr for Technical Director