City Council/Public Financing Authority
July 16, 2024

CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 4.25.23
Crossing Guard RFP
Weight Factor MT ME TT Total Scores Total Weighted Scores Rank MT ME TT Total Weighted Scores 10 Compliance with RFP Requirements
All City Management Services, Inc. 5 4 4 13 130 2 50 40 40 130 Alltech Industries, Inc. 5 4.5 3 12.5 125 3 50 45 30 125 Crossing Guard Services LLC 5 4.5 4 13.5 135 1 50 45 40 135 25 Technical Approach-Understanding of Project-Methodology All City Management Services, Inc. 5 4.7 5 14.7 367.5 1 125 117.5 125 367.5 Alltech Industries, Inc. 4 4.5 3 11.5 287.5 3 100 112.5 75 287.5 Crossing Guard Services LLC 4 4 4 12 300 2 100 100 100 300 25 Qualifications and experience of Firm, key individuals and sub-consultants All City Management Services, Inc. 5 5 5 15 375 1 125 125 125 375 Alltech Industries, Inc. 4 4 3 11 275 3 100 100 75 275
Crossing Guard Services LLC 4 4 4 12 300 2 100 100 100 300 10 Education background, work experience, and directly related experience All City Management Services, Inc. 5 5 5 15 150 1 50 50 50 150 Alltech Industries, Inc. 4 4 3 11 110 3 40 40 30 110
Crossing Guard Services LLC 4 4.5 4 12.5 125 2 40 45 40 125 25 Cost/Price
All City Management Services, Inc. 3 4 4 11 275 3 75 100 100 275 Alltech Industries, Inc. 3 4.5 4 11.5 287.5 1 75 112.5 100 287.5 Crossing Guard Services LLC 3 4.5 4 11.5 287.5 1 75 112.5 100 287.5 5 References
All City Management Services, Inc. 5 5 5 15 75 1 25 25 25 75 Alltech Industries, Inc. 4 5 4 4 20 3 20 25 20 65
Crossing Guard Services LLC 3 5 4 12 60 2 15 25 20 60
100
1 Local Vendor Preference- BONUS
All City Management Services, Inc. 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0
Alltech Industries, Inc. 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0
Crossing Guard Services LLC 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0
MT ME TT Total
Scores Total Weighted Scores Rank
All City Management Services, Inc. 450 457.5 465 83.7 1372.5 1 Alltech Industries, Inc. 385 435 330 61.5 1105 3
Crossing Guard Services LLC 380 427.5 400 73.5 1207.5 2