Cities Index.
Agenda packet

Imperial Beach City Council
April 19, 2023

Document
Agenda packet
Meeting
April 19, 2023
Body
Imperial Beach City Council
Pages
190
Original file
39.2 MB
Text extracted from the city's file for reading and search. Open the original on pub-imperialbeach.escribemeetings.com. That file is the official record.

1 A4.0
2 A4.0
2 A4.1
1 A4.1
1 A3.0
1 A3.0

COMMERCIAL
(INTERIOR)
2700 sf

EXTERIOR
PATIO
1100 sf
UNIT 1
1450 sf
ADA SPACE:

COMMERCIAL

VAN LOADING
ZONE
SPACE:

COMMERCIAL
SPACE: UNIT 8
SPACE: UNIT 7
SPACE: UNIT 6
SPACE: UNIT 5
SPACE: UNIT 4
SPACE: UNIT 3
SPACE: UNIT 1
SPACE: UNIT 1
BATH
BATH
LND.

W
D
BED

BED BED

KITCHEN DINING
LIVING
PATIO
ENTRY
ENTRY
ENTRY
UP
7'-8" PROPERTY LINE 105.09' PROPERTY LINE 104.90'
PROPERTY LINE 101.11'
PROPERTY LINE 100.97'

SHELL SPACE
ONLY
1 A4.2
2 A4.2
SPACE:

COMMERCIAL
EV
EV
EV
EV CHARGER, TYP. OF 4
EV
UP
3565 7TH AVENUE
SAN DIEGO, CA 92103
SAWAYAARCHITECTURE.COM
(619) 916 - 8145 ISSUE DESCRIPTION BY DATE

SAWAYA ARCHITECTURE

SAWAYA ARCHITECTURE
2134
PRINT TO SCALE : 24" x 36" 06-06-22 CJS FOR CDP SUBMITTAL 07-20-22 CJS REVISED PER CDP COMMENTS 11-09-22 CJS REVISED PER CDP COMMENTS 02-28-23 CJS REVISED PER DRB COMMENTS C35363
REN: 06-30-23

CHRISTOPHER
SAWAYA
757 MIXED
757 SEACOAST AVE.

IMPERIAL BEACH, CA
T C E
I T

CH D AR

E S NE CI L

S T A T E OF C A L I F OR N IA
A2.0
LEVEL 1

FLOOR PLAN
1/8"=1'-0"
LEVEL 1 FLOOR PLAN 1
N

Page 131 of 190 ends

1 A4.0
2 A4.0
2 A4.1
1 A4.1
1 A3.0
1 PROPERTY LINE 104.90'
A3.0 PROPERTY LINE 105.09'
PROPERTY LINE 101.11'
PROPERTY LINE 100.97'
UNIT 8
2400 sf
UNIT 7
2400 sf
BATH
BED

KITCHEN
DINING
BA.

KITCHEN

LIVING DINING
DECK
ENTRY
BA.

KITCHEN

LIVING DINING
ENTRY
BA.

KITCHEN

LIVING DINING
DECK
ENTRY
BA.

KITCHEN

DECK LIVING DINING
ENTRY
BA.

KITCHEN

DECK LIVING DINING
ENTRY
UP
UP
UP
UP
UP
DECK
DECK
UP
DN
LIVING
DECK
1 A4.2
2 A4.2
UNIT 6
1500 sf
UNIT 4
1500 sf
UNIT 2
1500 sf
UNIT 5
1450 sf
UNIT 3
1420 sf
CLOS.

BATH
UP
CLOS.

DECK

KITCHEN
DINING
LIVING
BED
CLOS.

CLOS.

BATH
BATH
UP
8'-5"
11'-4"
6'-0"
5'-0"
7'-3"
5'-0" 5'-0" 5'-0" 5'-0" 20'-4" 22'-7" 21'-4"
ENTRY
ENTRY 13'-0"
13'-5"
10'-5"
4'-5"
8'-11"
6'-0"
2'-0" 6'-11"
10'-5"
4'-5" 6'-0"
10'-5"
4'-5" 6'-0"
DECK
8'-11"
2'-0" 6'-11"
DN
3565 7TH AVENUE
SAN DIEGO, CA 92103
SAWAYAARCHITECTURE.COM
(619) 916 - 8145 ISSUE DESCRIPTION BY DATE

SAWAYA ARCHITECTURE

SAWAYA ARCHITECTURE
2134
PRINT TO SCALE : 24" x 36" 06-06-22 CJS FOR CDP SUBMITTAL 07-20-22 CJS REVISED PER CDP COMMENTS 11-09-22 CJS REVISED PER CDP COMMENTS 02-28-23 CJS REVISED PER DRB COMMENTS C35363
REN: 06-30-23

CHRISTOPHER
757 MIXED
757 SEACOAST AVE.

IMPERIAL BEACH, CA
T C E
I T

CH D AR

E S NE CI L

S T A T E OF C A L I F OR N IA
A2.1
LEVEL 2

FLOOR PLAN
1/8"=1'-0"
LEVEL 2 FLOOR PLAN 1
N

Page 132 of 190 ends

1 A4.0
2 A4.0
2 A4.1
1 A4.1
1 A3.0
1 PROPERTY LINE 105.09' PROPERTY LINE 104.90'
A3.0
PROPERTY LINE 101.11'
PROPERTY LINE 100.97'
W
D
1 A4.2
2 A4.2
UNIT 8
UNIT 7
BATH
DN
DN
UNIT 6
UNIT 5
DECK
BED
CLOS.

BATH
BATH
6'-5" 7'-5"
6'-0"
5'-0"
7'-3"
5'-0" 5'-0" 5'-0" 20'-4" 22'-7" 21'-4"
8'-5" 8'-5"
BATH

BED BED BED
HALL
WD

BED BED
BATH
LND.

HALL
BATH
CLOS.

W
D
BATH
DN
DN
UNIT 2
UNIT 3
BATH

BED BED BED
HALL
WD

BED BED
BATH
LND.

HALL
BATH
CLOS.

BATH
DN
BATH UNIT 4
BED

OFFICE BED
HALL
WD
BED
BED
W D
LND. HALL
DN
UP
BATH
CLOS.

BED
BED
BED
BATH
BATH
BATH
HALL
CLOS.

CLOS.

LND.

W
D
DECK
DN
UP
16'-8" 5'-0" 16'-6"
3565 7TH AVENUE
SAN DIEGO, CA 92103
SAWAYAARCHITECTURE.COM
(619) 916 - 8145 ISSUE DESCRIPTION BY DATE

SAWAYA ARCHITECTURE

SAWAYA ARCHITECTURE
2134
PRINT TO SCALE : 24" x 36" 06-06-22 CJS FOR CDP SUBMITTAL 07-20-22 CJS REVISED PER CDP COMMENTS 11-09-22 CJS REVISED PER CDP COMMENTS 02-28-23 CJS REVISED PER DRB COMMENTS C35363
REN: 06-30-23

CHRISTOPHER
SAWAYA
757 MIXED
757 SEACOAST AVE.

IMPERIAL BEACH, CA
T C E
I T

CH D AR

E S NE CI L

S T A T E OF C A L I F OR N IA
A2.2
LEVEL 3

FLOOR PLAN
1/8"=1'-0"
LEVEL 3 FLOOR PLAN 1
N

Page 133 of 190 ends

1 A4.0
2 A4.0
2 A4.1
1 A4.1
1 A3.0
1 PROPERTY LINE 105.09' PROPERTY LINE 104.90'
A3.0
PROPERTY LINE 101.11'
PROPERTY LINE 100.97'
1 A4.2
2 A4.2
UNIT 8
UNIT 7

ROOF DECK
600sf

ROOF DECK
600sf
SINK TR.REF.BBQ TR.REF.BBQ SINK
DN
ROOF
ROOF
ROOF
DN
FIRE
FIRE
SOLAR
SOLAR
ROOF
ROOF
ROOF
ROOF
ROOF

GLASS GUARDRAIL

AT ROOF DECK

GLASS GUARDRAIL

AT ROOF DECK
3565 7TH AVENUE
SAN DIEGO, CA 92103
SAWAYAARCHITECTURE.COM
(619) 916 - 8145 ISSUE DESCRIPTION BY DATE

SAWAYA ARCHITECTURE

SAWAYA ARCHITECTURE
2134
PRINT TO SCALE : 24" x 36" 06-06-22 CJS FOR CDP SUBMITTAL 07-20-22 CJS REVISED PER CDP COMMENTS 11-09-22 CJS REVISED PER CDP COMMENTS 02-28-23 CJS REVISED PER DRB COMMENTS C35363
REN: 06-30-23

CHRISTOPHER
SAWAYA
757 MIXED
757 SEACOAST AVE.

IMPERIAL BEACH, CA
T C E
I T

CH D AR

E S NE CI L

S T A T E OF C A L I F OR N IA
A2.3

ROOF PLAN
1/8"=1'-0"
ROOF PLAN 1
N

Page 134 of 190 ends

PATIO
1600sf

KITCHEN PROPERTY LINE PROPERTY LINE

COMMERCIAL
(INTERIOR)
2700sf 15'-0" 8'-4" 8'-4" 9'-0" 9'-4" 42" 9'-0" 9'-6"
LIVING
BATH
DECK

HALL BATH
DECK

DECK LIVING KITCHEN DECK

BED OFFICE BED

BATH BED DECK

ROOF DECK
35' HEIGHT LIMIT
GRADE/SLAB 15'-10" 9'-6"

43.83' AMSL

T/PARAPET

9.00' AMSL

24.83' AMSL
T/SECOND FLOOR 9'-6" 34'-2" HEIGHT OF BUILDING FROM 9.68' AVERAGE GRADE

34.33' AMSL

T/THIRD FLOOR
GRADE 10'-2" 10'-6"

9.50' AMSL
T/SLAB

T/ROOF DECK

43.83' AMSL

T/PARAPET

9.00' AMSL

19.66' AMSL
T/SECOND FLOOR 3'-6" 34'-2" HEIGHT OF BUILDING FROM 9.68' AVERAGE GRADE

30.16' AMSL
T/SECOND FLOOR 10'-2"

40.33' AMSL
AVERAGE GRADE 9.68' AMSL + 35'-0" = 44.68' AMSL HEIGHT LIMIT 13'-6" TO BOTTOM OF OPEN WEB TRUSS AVERAGE GRADE 9.68' AMSL
3565 7TH AVENUE
SAN DIEGO, CA 92103
SAWAYAARCHITECTURE.COM
(619) 916 - 8145 ISSUE DESCRIPTION BY DATE

SAWAYA ARCHITECTURE

SAWAYA ARCHITECTURE
2134
PRINT TO SCALE : 24" x 36" 06-06-22 CJS FOR CDP SUBMITTAL 07-20-22 CJS REVISED PER CDP COMMENTS 11-09-22 CJS REVISED PER CDP COMMENTS 02-28-23 CJS REVISED PER DRB COMMENTS C35363
REN: 06-30-23

CHRISTOPHER
SAWAYA
757 MIXED
757 SEACOAST AVE.

IMPERIAL BEACH, CA
T C E
I T

CH D AR

E S NE CI L

S T A T E OF C A L I F OR N IA
A3.0

BUILDING

SECTION
SECTION 1 1
3/16"=1'-0"

Page 135 of 190 ends

GRADE/SLAB 15'-10" 9'-6"

43.83' AMSL

T/PARAPET

9.00' AMSL

24.83' AMSL
T/SECOND FLOOR 9'-6" 34'-2" HEIGHT OF BUILDING FROM 9.68' AVERAGE GRADE34.33' AMSL

T/THIRD FLOOR
AVERAGE GRADE 9.68' AMSL + 35'-0" = 44.68' AMSL HEIGHT LIMIT

PROPOSED AND

EXISTING GRADE

GALVANIZED METAL SUN
SCREEN, STYLE TBD, TYP.

AVERAGE GRADE

9.68' AMSL

BRONZE ANODIZED ALUMINUM

BRONZE ANODIZED ALUMINUM ROLL-UP DOORS, CLEAR GLASS

STOREFRONT SYSTEM
48" DEEP ALUMINUM SUNSHADES;
BRONZE ANODIZED, TYP.

STONE VENEER, TYP.

SERVING COUNTER,
QUARTZ
48" DEEP ALUMINUM SUNSHADES;
BRONZE ANODIZED, TYP.

BLACK COMPOSITE VINYL DOORS
AND WINDOWS, TYP.

FIBER CEMENT SIDING; COLOR: JAMES PARAPET CAP
HARDIE "MOUNTAIN SAGE"
TEXTURE: SMOOTH; 12" REVEAL
STUCCO SIDING; COLOR:

LA HABRA "TUXEDO";
TEXTURE: SMOOTH
STUCCO SIDING; COLOR:

LA HABRA "CRYSTAL WHITE";
TEXTURE: SMOOTH
GLASS GUARDRAILS, TYP.

STUCCO SIDING; COLOR:

LA HABRA "TUXEDO";
TEXTURE: SMOOTH
NEW 36" TEMPERED GLASS
PATIO FENCE, TYP.

GRADE/SLAB 15'-10" 9'-6"

43.83' AMSL

T/PARAPET

9.00' AMSL

24.83' AMSL
T/SECOND FLOOR 9'-6" 34'-2" HEIGHT OF BUILDING FROM 9.68' AVERAGE GRADE34.33' AMSL

T/THIRD FLOOR
AVERAGE GRADE 9.68' AMSL + 35'-0" = 44.68' AMSL HEIGHT LIMIT

PROPOSED AND

EXISTING GRADE
AVERAGE GRADE 9.68' AMSL

BRONZE ANODIZED ALUMINUM

STOREFRONT SYSTEM
STONE VENEER, TYP.

GALVANIZED METAL SUN
SCREEN, STYLE TBD, TYP.
48" DEEP ALUMINUM SUNSHADES;
BRONZE ANODIZED, TYP.

STUCCO SIDING; COLOR:

LA HABRA "CRYSTAL WHITE";
TEXTURE: SMOOTH

PARAPET CAP BLACK COMPOSITE VINYL DOORS
AND WINDOWS, TYP.

PARAPET CAP
48" DEEP ALUMINUM SUNSHADES;
BRONZE ANODIZED, TYP.

GLASS GUARDRAILS, TYP.

FIBER CEMENT SIDING; COLOR: JAMES
HARDIE "MOUNTAIN SAGE"
TEXTURE: SMOOTH; 12" REVEAL
STUCCO SIDING; COLOR:

LA HABRA "TUXEDO";
TEXTURE: SMOOTH
STUCCO SIDING; COLOR:

LA HABRA "CRYSTAL WHITE";
TEXTURE: SMOOTH
GRADE 10'-2" 10'-6"

9.50' AMSL
T/SLAB

T/ROOF DECK

43.83' AMSL

T/PARAPET

9.00' AMSL

19.66' AMSL
T/SECOND FLOOR 3'-6" 34'-2" HEIGHT OF BUILDING FROM 9.68' AVERAGE GRADE

30.16' AMSL
T/SECOND FLOOR 10'-2"

40.33' AMSL
STUCCO SIDING; COLOR:

LA HABRA "TUXEDO";
TEXTURE: SMOOTH

GLASS GUARDRAIL
NEW 36" HIGH CEMENT
BOARD PATIO FENCE, TYP.

NEW 36" TEMPERED
GLASS PATIO FENCE, TYP.

IN-WALL ROOF

DRAIN TO GRADE

DOWNSPOUT

IN-WALL ROOF DRAIN

TO DOWNSPOUT ON

GROUND FLOOR
1880 SF TOTAL UPPER STORY FACADE SQUARE FOOTAGE

78.2% OF THIS AREA IS SETBACK 7.5' OR MORE
@ 2.75' SET
BACK
@ 7.5' TO 10.5'

SET BACK
390 SF
1470 SF

WEST ELEVATION UPPER STORY STEPBACKS
3565 7TH AVENUE
SAN DIEGO, CA 92103
SAWAYAARCHITECTURE.COM
(619) 916 - 8145 ISSUE DESCRIPTION BY DATE

SAWAYA ARCHITECTURE

SAWAYA ARCHITECTURE
2134
PRINT TO SCALE : 24" x 36" 06-06-22 CJS FOR CDP SUBMITTAL 07-20-22 CJS REVISED PER CDP COMMENTS 11-09-22 CJS REVISED PER CDP COMMENTS 02-28-23 CJS REVISED PER DRB COMMENTS C35363
REN: 06-30-23

CHRISTOPHER
SAWAYA
757 MIXED
757 SEACOAST AVE.

IMPERIAL BEACH, CA
T C E
I T

CH D AR

E S NE CI L

S T A T E OF C A L I F OR N IA
A4.0

BUILDING

ELEVATIONS
SOUTH ELEVATION 2
3/16"=1'-0"
WEST ELEVATION 1
3/16"=1'-0"

Page 136 of 190 ends

AVERAGE GRADE 9.68' AMSL + 35'-0" = 44.68' AMSL HEIGHT LIMIT

PROPOSED AND

EXISTING GRADE
AVERAGE GRADE 9.68' AMSL
GRADE 10'-2" 10'-6"

9.50' AMSL
T/SLAB

T/ROOF DECK

43.83' AMSL

T/PARAPET

9.00' AMSL

19.66' AMSL
T/SECOND FLOOR 3'-6" 34'-2" HEIGHT OF BUILDING FROM 9.68' AVERAGE GRADE

30.16' AMSL
T/SECOND FLOOR 10'-2"

40.33' AMSL
48" DEEP ALUMINUM SUNSHADES;
BRONZE ANODIZED, TYP.

STUCCO SIDING; COLOR:

LA HABRA "TUXEDO";
TEXTURE: SMOOTH

BLACK COMPOSITE VINYL DOORS
AND WINDOWS, TYP.

STUCCO SIDING; COLOR:

LA HABRA "CRYSTAL WHITE";
TEXTURE: SMOOTH

PARAPET CAP
FIBER CEMENT SIDING; COLOR: JAMES
HARDIE "MOUNTAIN SAGE"
TEXTURE: SMOOTH; 12" REVEAL
STUCCO SIDING; COLOR:

LA HABRA "CRYSTAL WHITE";
TEXTURE: SMOOTH
MASONRY WALL; RCP

BLOCK, ONYX, PRECISION

GLASS GUARDRAIL
NEW 36" HIGH CEMENT
BOARD PATIO FENCE, TYP.

FIBER CEMENT
SIDING; COLOR:

JAMES HARDIE
"MOUNTAIN SAGE"
TEXTURE: SMOOTH;
12" REVEAL
GRADE 10'-2" 10'-6"

9.50' AMSL
T/SLAB

T/ROOF DECK

43.83' AMSL

T/PARAPET

9.00' AMSL

19.66' AMSL
T/SECOND FLOOR 3'-6" 34'-2" HEIGHT OF BUILDING FROM 9.68' AVERAGE GRADE 30.16' AMSL T/SECOND FLOOR 10'-2"

40.33' AMSL
GRADE/SLAB 15'-10" 9'-6"

43.83' AMSL

T/PARAPET

9.00' AMSL

24.83' AMSL
T/SECOND FLOOR 9'-6" 34'-2" HEIGHT OF BUILDING FROM 9.68' AVERAGE GRADE

34.33' AMSL

T/THIRD FLOOR
AVERAGE GRADE 9.68' AMSL + 35'-0" = 44.68' AMSL HEIGHT LIMIT

PROPOSED AND

EXISTING GRADE
AVERAGE GRADE 9.68' AMSL
MASONRY WALL; RCP

BLOCK, ONYX, PRECISION
GALVANIZED METAL SUN GLASS GUARDRAILS, TYP.

SCREEN, STYLE TBD, TYP.

BRONZE ANODIZED ALUMINUM

COMMERCIAL DOORS AND WINDOWS
STONE VENEER, TYP.

BLACK COMPOSITE VINYL DOORS
AND WINDOWS, TYP.

STUCCO SIDING; COLOR:

LA HABRA "CRYSTAL WHITE";
TEXTURE: SMOOTH
48" DEEP ALUMINUM SUNSHADES;
BRONZE ANODIZED, TYP.

STUCCO SIDING; COLOR:

LA HABRA "CRYSTAL WHITE";
TEXTURE: SMOOTH
FIBER CEMENT SIDING; COLOR: JAMES
HARDIE "MOUNTAIN SAGE"
TEXTURE: SMOOTH; 12" REVEAL
STUCCO SIDING; COLOR:

LA HABRA "TUXEDO";
TEXTURE: SMOOTH

PARAPET CAP
FIBER CEMENT SIDING; COLOR: JAMES
HARDIE "MOUNTAIN SAGE"
TEXTURE: SMOOTH; 12" REVEAL
STUCCO SIDING; COLOR:

LA HABRA "CRYSTAL WHITE";
TEXTURE: SMOOTH

IN-WALL ROOF DRAIN

TO DOWNSPOUT ON

GROUND FLOOR

DOWNSPOUT
3565 7TH AVENUE
SAN DIEGO, CA 92103
SAWAYAARCHITECTURE.COM
(619) 916 - 8145 ISSUE DESCRIPTION BY DATE

SAWAYA ARCHITECTURE

SAWAYA ARCHITECTURE
2134
PRINT TO SCALE : 24" x 36" 06-06-22 CJS FOR CDP SUBMITTAL 07-20-22 CJS REVISED PER CDP COMMENTS 11-09-22 CJS REVISED PER CDP COMMENTS 02-28-23 CJS REVISED PER DRB COMMENTS C35363
REN: 06-30-23

CHRISTOPHER
SAWAYA
757 MIXED
757 SEACOAST AVE.

IMPERIAL BEACH, CA
T C E
I T

CH D AR

E S NE CI L

S T A T E OF C A L I F OR N IA
A4.1

BUILDING

ELEVATIONS
NORTH ELEVATION 2
3/16"=1'-0"
EAST ELEVATION 1
3/16"=1'-0"

Page 137 of 190 ends

GRADE 10'-2" 10'-6"

9.50' AMSL
T/SLAB

T/ROOF DECK

43.83' AMSL

T/PARAPET

9.00' AMSL

19.66' AMSL
T/SECOND FLOOR 3'-6" 34'-2" HEIGHT OF BUILDING FROM 9.68' AVERAGE GRADE 30.16' AMSL T/SECOND FLOOR 10'-2"

40.33' AMSL
AVERAGE GRADE 9.68' AMSL + 35'-0" = 44.68' AMSL HEIGHT LIMIT

PROPOSED AND

EXISTING GRADE
AVERAGE GRADE 9.68' AMSL
STUCCO SIDING; COLOR:

LA HABRA "CRYSTAL WHITE";
TEXTURE: SMOOTH
FIBER CEMENT SIDING; COLOR: JAMES
HARDIE "MOUNTAIN SAGE"
TEXTURE: SMOOTH; 12" REVEAL
FIBER CEMENT SIDING; COLOR: JAMES
HARDIE "MOUNTAIN SAGE"
TEXTURE: SMOOTH; 12" REVEAL

BLACK COMPOSITE VINYL DOORS
AND WINDOWS, TYP.

STUCCO SIDING; COLOR:

LA HABRA "CRYSTAL WHITE";
TEXTURE: SMOOTH
STUCCO SIDING; COLOR:

LA HABRA "TUXEDO";
TEXTURE: SMOOTH
GLASS GUARDRAILS, TYP.

GRADE/SLAB 15'-10" 9'-6"

43.83' AMSL

T/PARAPET

9.00' AMSL

24.83' AMSL
T/SECOND FLOOR 9'-6" 34'-2" HEIGHT OF BUILDING FROM 9.68' AVERAGE GRADE34.33' AMSL

T/THIRD FLOOR
AVERAGE GRADE 9.68' AMSL + 35'-0" = 44.68' AMSL HEIGHT LIMIT

PROPOSED AND

EXISTING GRADE
AVERAGE GRADE 9.68' AMSL
48" DEEP ALUMINUM SUNSHADES;
BRONZE ANODIZED, TYP.

BLACK COMPOSITE VINYL DOORS
AND WINDOWS, TYP.

PARAPET CAP FIBER CEMENT SIDING; COLOR: JAMES
HARDIE "MOUNTAIN SAGE"
TEXTURE: SMOOTH; 12" REVEAL
STUCCO SIDING; COLOR:

LA HABRA "TUXEDO";
TEXTURE: SMOOTH
STUCCO SIDING; COLOR:

LA HABRA "CRYSTAL WHITE";
TEXTURE: SMOOTH
STUCCO SIDING; COLOR:

LA HABRA "TUXEDO";
TEXTURE: SMOOTH
GLASS GUARDRAILS, TYP.

NORTH ELEVATION TRASH ENCLOSURE WEST ELEVATION

TRASH ENCLOSURE

FLAT ROOF SYSTEM, SLOPED

TO DRAIN FORWARD

BLOCK WALLS WITH STUCCO
FINISH TO MATCH BUILDING 6'-0" 7'-2"

SOUTH ELEVATION TRASH ENCLOSURE EAST ELEVATION

TRASH ENCLOSURE

ANODIZED STEEL FRAMED GATES

WITH CEMENT FIBER SIDING INFILL

FLAT ROOF SYSTEM, SLOPED

TO DRAIN FORWARD

BLOCK WALLS WITH STUCCO

FINISH TO MATCH BUILDING
36"X36" GATE; WOOD FRAMED
WITH CEMENT FIBER SIDING INFILL 3'-0"
36" TALL WOOD FRAMED FENCE

WITH CEMENT FIBER SIDING INFILL

TYPICAL FENCE / GATE DETAIL
3565 7TH AVENUE
SAN DIEGO, CA 92103
SAWAYAARCHITECTURE.COM
(619) 916 - 8145 ISSUE DESCRIPTION BY DATE

SAWAYA ARCHITECTURE

SAWAYA ARCHITECTURE
2134
PRINT TO SCALE : 24" x 36" 06-06-22 CJS FOR CDP SUBMITTAL 07-20-22 CJS REVISED PER CDP COMMENTS 11-09-22 CJS REVISED PER CDP COMMENTS 02-28-23 CJS REVISED PER DRB COMMENTS C35363
REN: 06-30-23

CHRISTOPHER
SAWAYA
757 MIXED
757 SEACOAST AVE.

IMPERIAL BEACH, CA
T C E
I T

CH D AR

E S NE CI L

S T A T E OF C A L I F OR N IA
A4.2

BUILDING

ELEVATIONS
COURTYARD EAST ELEVATION 2
3/16"=1'-0"
COURTYARD WEST ELEVATION 1
3/16"=1'-0"

Page 138 of 190 ends
Page 139 of 190 ends
Page 140 of 190 ends
Page 141 of 190 ends

MT1

MATERIALS
BOARD
3565 7TH AVENUE
SAN DIEGO, CA 92103
SAWAYAARCHITECTURE.COM
(619) 916 - 8145 ISSUE DESCRIPTION BY DATE

SAWAYA ARCHITECTURE

SAWAYA ARCHITECTURE
2134
PRINT TO SCALE : 24" x 36" 06-06-22 CJS FOR CDP SUBMITTAL 07-20-22 CJS REVISED PER CDP COMMENTS 11-09-22 CJS REVISED PER CDP COMMENTS 02-28-23 CJS REVISED PER DRB COMMENTS C35363
REN: 06-30-23

CHRISTOPHER
SAWAYA
757 MIXED
757 SEACOAST AVE.

IMPERIAL BEACH, CA T C E I T CH D AR E S NE CI L S T A T E OF C A L I F OR N IA

Page 142 of 190 ends

MT2

MATERIALS
BOARD
3565 7TH AVENUE
SAN DIEGO, CA 92103
SAWAYAARCHITECTURE.COM
(619) 916 - 8145 ISSUE DESCRIPTION BY DATE

SAWAYA ARCHITECTURE

SAWAYA ARCHITECTURE
2134
PRINT TO SCALE : 24" x 36" 06-06-22 CJS FOR CDP SUBMITTAL 07-20-22 CJS REVISED PER CDP COMMENTS 11-09-22 CJS REVISED PER CDP COMMENTS 02-28-23 CJS REVISED PER DRB COMMENTS C35363
REN: 06-30-23

CHRISTOPHER
757 MIXED
757 SEACOAST AVE.

IMPERIAL BEACH, CA T C E I T CH D AR E S NE CI L S T A T E OF C A L I F OR N IA

Page 143 of 190 ends

Attachment 3

Page 144 of 190 ends
Page 145 of 190 ends
Page 146 of 190 ends
Page 147 of 190 ends
Page 148 of 190 ends
Page 149 of 190 ends

Attachment 4

Page 150 of 190 ends
Page 151 of 190 ends
Page 152 of 190 ends
Page 153 of 190 ends

757 SEACOST DRIVE MIXED-USE
Materials Board
City of Imperial Beach Community Development Department 825 Imperial Beach Boulevard
Imperial Beach, CA 91932
Stucco Color #1: La Habra Crystal White
Attachment 5

Page 154 of 190 ends

Stucco Color #2: La Habra Tuxedo

Page 155 of 190 ends

Cement Fiber Siding #1: James Hardie Mountain Sage

Page 156 of 190 ends

Windows: Black Composite

Page 157 of 190 ends

Roll-Up Doors: Bronze Anodized Clear Glass

Page 158 of 190 ends

Fencing: White Vinyl

Page 159 of 190 ends

Sunshades: Bronze Anodized Aluminum
Bike Racks

Page 160 of 190 ends

Tree #1: Fruitless Olive Tree - Swan Hill

Page 161 of 190 ends

Tree #2: Willow Pittosporum

Page 162 of 190 ends

Shrub #1: Dwarf Bottlebrush

Page 163 of 190 ends

Shrub #4: Safari Sunshine

Page 164 of 190 ends

Groundcover: Grass & Paver Walkway

Page 165 of 190 ends

Groundcover: Permeable Pavers

Page 166 of 190 ends

Low Fence / Gate at Patios
Exterior Site Lighting

Page 167 of 190 ends

City of Imperial Beach
Project Name: 757 Seacoast Drive
Project Number: USE-22-0088
Comments from 02-16-2023 DRB Meeting

1. Incorporate additional varied stepbacks and setbacks along the southern and western elevations

2. Stagger and stepback the second story decks facing Seacoast Drive

3. Provide variations in roof form and height to provide variation in the building massing and primary facades

4. Consider additional transportation demand management strategies

5. Consider a design that would enhance the amount of parking available or maximize that parking available for the site, potentially reallocating space for parking purposes

6. All proposed/potential projections, mechanical or otherwise, where feasible must be below the maximum allowable building height and must be adequately screened

7. Incorporate enclosed clear tempered glass screening to the patio area fronting Seacoast Drive

8. Include secure bicycle rack storage and equipment storage for the residents while maintaining the proposed bicycle rack

9. Include posted bike routes with the bus routes

10. For unit 7, replace the glass material that screens the deck area with an opaque screening material to enhance privacy

11. Enhance and increase the total amount of plants provided in the planted landscaping area

12. Replace the trees that are currently proposed with shade trees that are taller

13. Assess the safety of the lighting in the parking area and enhance it as needed to increase safety

14. The overhang elements should be made flush all the way across the third floor instead of separated

15. Replace the metal railing for the decks with glass

16. Match the exterior materials of the trash enclosure with the primary building materials

17. Remove the brick wall in between/separating the parking areas and replace them with pillars or an alternative design that can be walked/seen through

18. Provide additional details on the project plans that would show the finished aesthetic of the building with the intended use of the commercial space

19. Show any proposed internal drains, scuppers, downspouts, or gutters to show how stormwater would drain from the roof top.

Responses

1. See revised plans. The revision includes staggered units and decks on level 2 at the west elevation. It also shows the design pulled forward the southeast corner of level 1 forward 12” to add more variation to the 3-story structure. There is an added pop out / window framed element around the windows on 2nd and 3rd floor of south elevation on unit 6.

2. See revised plans, level 2 decks on west elevation and building walls have been adjusted to show added variation and stepbacks and to add interest to the building.

3. On the back building we lowered the parapet wall 12” throughout, at all locations except for where it needs to be at 42” for roof deck guardwall height.

4. See A1.0, plans call for bike racks, bus routes/maps, as well as transit subsidies for commercial employees. The site is also fortunate to be within a few blocks of free public parking lots. All workers, customers, and tenants will be made aware. New private, wall hanging, covered bike racks at north side of commercial have been added.

5. There is no other parking that can be accommodated on site. We need commercial and one unit on the ground floor for building code requirements. The project also proposes to close two curb cuts which will gain four (4) new off-street parking spaces.

6. All building elements and mechanical equipment will be below the 35’ proposes height limit.

7. See A1.0 and A2.0, patio fencing revised to show as tempered glass partition. Additional vertical elements of glass are not desired and glass wall as proposed will protect and privatize the dining patio from traffic, noise, and weather per the concern.

8. New private, wall hanging, covered bike racks at north side of commercial have been added. We have also incorporated private storage space on the wall/ceiling at the front of the parking spaces.

9. See A1.0, note revised to include bike routes.

10. See exterior elevations, solid walls shown at all decks facing east on unit 7.

11. The landscape architect reviewed the plans and comment and has determined that increasing the density of any proposed planting areas is not possible. There are already so many plants that adding more will put all the landscaping at risk to not properly grow. The somewhat lighter density of plants at the southeast corner of the site is to allow access for utility meters.

12. There are already three large existing street trees on Donax. We have trees proposed on site but do not want large trees which will draw an excess amount of water for irrigation, as well as block views for neighbors. Larger trees here also can risk damage to the building when planted too close to the foundation.

13. See A1.0, we have doubled the number of lights in the parking areas.

14. This in particular does not fit the aesthetic of the building. One large overhang is also complicated to build, install and maintain.

Additionally, we’re trying to break up the elevations in plan and elevation and maximize variation much like the request for staggering the decks instead of one straight line.

15. See A4 sheets, exterior elevations, all guardrails revised to be glass. Railings shown as 18” wall + 24” glass.

16. See A4.2, trash enclosure revised to be stucco to match new building.

17. See A1.0 and A2.0, masonry wall cleared out to minimum structural walls for maximum visibility.

18. There is currently no proposed use for the commercial space. Regardless of what the future use is, they would be required to complete a TI permit and have substantial conformance with the approved CDP design/exterior look. We will leave a strip of the slab missing for future plumbing configuration.

19. See A4 sheets, all rooftop areas will drain to in-wall drains and some downspouts on ground floor, all labeled.

Attachment 6

Page 168 of 190 ends

Attachment 7
1 CITY OF IMPERIAL BEACH

DESIGN REVIEW BOARD

REGULAR MEETING MINUTES
February 16, 2023, 4:00 p.m.

Council Chambers
825 Imperial Beach Boulevard
Imperial Beach, CA 91932
Members Present: Chair Bradley, Member Grace, Member Rogers, Member Voronchihin
Members Absent: Vice Chair Beltran
Staff Present: Senior Planner Openshaw, Assistant Planner Pua, Assistant City Clerk Malone
_____________________________________________________________________

1. CALL TO ORDER
Chair Bradley called the meeting to order at 4:00 p.m.

2. ROLL CALL
Assistant City Clerk Malone took the roll.

3. PUBLIC COMMENT
Public Comment: Larry Zajonc commented on the construction noise that is currently happening on Seacoast Drive as well as the noise from City businesses.

4. BUSINESS ITEMS

4.1 APPROVAL OF MINUTES.

Motion by Chair Bradley
Seconded by Member Voronchihin
Approved the November 17, 2022 Regular Meeting minutes.

Page 169 of 190 ends

Attachment 7
2 AYES (4): Chair Bradley, Member Grace, Member Rogers, and Member Voronchihin
ABSENT (1): Vice Chair Beltran
Motion Carried (4 to 0)

4.2 BUCKEYE INVESTMENTS, INC. (APPLICANT); DESIGN REVIEW CASE (DRC-22-0024) TO CONSTRUCT A NEW MIXED-USE BUILDING WITH 2,700 SF COMMERCIAL SPACE AND EIGHT RESIDENTIAL
CONDOMINIUM UNITS AT 757 SEACOAST DRIVE (APN 625-192-04- 00) USE-22-0088.

Senior Planner Openshaw gave a PowerPoint presentation.

The Architect of the project gave a presentation.

Public Comment: Paul Palmieri spoke in support of the project.

Chair Bradley addressed the architect of the project. He referenced Attachment 4 of the staff report. He stated that it seemed the document was crafted without taking staff's recommendation into consideration. He explained that this shows a lack of effort on the part of the developer to comply with the recommendations of staff.

Member Rogers spoke on the design of the building and that it looks similar to the Brigantine building. He stated that there are many aspects of the project that he likes and that he is in support of the project in general. He stated that he liked the rooftop solar and suggested EV chargers.

In response to Chair Bradley's question, Senior Planner Openshaw stated that there are three EV chargers included in this project. Building Official Wagner spoke on the permits and building requirements for EV chargers.

He stated that some of the new laws that recently have gone into effect require EV chargers in some capacity dependent on the scale of the project and parking spaces allotted. When there are less than 20 residential units there are specific guidelines to follow for EV chargers. In addition, depending on the number of spaces there would be a certain number of high level chargers required.

In response to Member Rogers' question, Senior Planner Openshaw referenced the site plan that shows where the EV chargers are being proposed. Building Official Wagner confirmed that the proposed EV chargers in this project exceeds what is required.

Page 170 of 190 ends

Attachment 7
3 In response to Member Rogers' question, Senior Planer Openshaw stated that the total square footage of the lot is 10,608 sq. ft.

The architect confirmed Member Rogers' question that the plans show 1591 sq. ft. of total landscaping. He also confirmed that the part of the design for commercial use is merely a shell because they do not know what commercial use will be going into the space.

Member Rogers recommended that the City Council consider additional transport and demand management solutions specifically for Council to consider the imposition of that in lieu of fees so that the City can develop a budget to build a parking structure downtown.

In response to Member Grace's question, the architect stated that the commercial space can be split and shared for multiple use. He also replied that, should the use be for a restaurant and require equipment on the roof, that there is equipment designed as horizontal structures so that the building would not exceed the height limit.

In response to Chair Bradley's question, Senior Planner Openshaw explained that there are exceptions to the building height within the City's code, such as for mechanical structures. However, staff can include conditions of approval that are related to the design to say, "where feasible no portions of the structure would exceed the height limit," or include additional screening elements to ensure structures that exceed the height limits are not visible from the street.

In response to Member Grace's question, the architect stated that the roof is designed to host the necessary solar requirements. Member Grace asked that for all future projects the solar capabilities be displayed on the plans.

She stated that the design does resemble the Brigantine and that she approved of that look. She recommended a more enclosed space around the patio so that it can be used in the winter time, perhaps heating lamps.

She recommended secured bicycle parking for the residents separate from the bicycle rack for the retail space, adding secured equipment storage on the first floor accessible from the outside for the residence. She recommended that the first floor unit be turned into a parking garage and equipment storage. She requested that the bike routes be posted along with the bus routes. She recommended that for unit 7 instead of the glass guardrail that it be made with a screen like material for more privacy for the residents. She recommended that the landscaping be reevaluated as it seems minimal. She suggested tall trees for shade and not so much low landscaping. She recommended that the lighting in the parking area be

Page 171 of 190 ends

Attachment 7
4 evaluated to ensure that it is sufficient enough to meet safety needs, as well as reevaluate the solid wall in the garage; perhaps it can be converted to pillars so that they can be walked/seen through.

In response to Member Voronchihin's question, Senior Planner Openshaw explained that staff is recommending enhanced variation in the building.

She stated that staff has had a conversation with the applicant regarding the underlying zoning. She advised that they do meet step-back requirements, however, historically staff has received comments related to the shape of buildings, with this design being more modern and square shaped staff is recommending additional variations in the roof line as well as the set-backs and step-backs to address those concerns. She explained that staff is recommending the building be pushed back and pulled out in different areas to avoid obstruction on any views, to stagger the second story deck so that it is not a flush line, and to vary the roof line to provide variation in the building's massing.

In response to Chair Bradley's question, Senior Planner Openshaw stated that all the units are running market rates for rent.

In response to Chair Bradley's question, Building Official Wagner stated that, along with Assistant Fire Marshall Santos, they reviewed the plans to evaluate the safety and emergency evacuation routes and they suggested that another stair case or exit may be necessary. This was conveyed to the developer and they have been working on a solution.

In response to Chair Bradley, Senior Planner Openshaw stated that there are no requirements related to the number of tenet spaces, and that she would have to confirm if there are occupancy requirements. She also confirmed that staff does review the plan calculations and that the landscaping calculations for this project meet the requirements.

In response to Chair Bradley's question, the developer confirmed that there are two roll-up doors on the store front.

Chair Bradley mentioned that the Board agrees that parking is an issue, however, they cannot reject a project for this reason if it meets all the requirements. He suggested creating an ad-hoc committee to craft a statement that conveyed their recommendations about parking that they can attach to any recommendation they make. Member Rogers agrees that parking is an issue and is willing to have this discussion.

Senior Planner Openshaw stated that staff can return to a future meeting with an item to discuss parking requirements.

Page 172 of 190 ends

Attachment 7
5 In response to Chair Bradley's question, Building Official Wagner stated that every project is required to put together an energy compliance document, which will describe the overall compliance margin for that project.

Depending on what features they install that are energy efficient or compliant, they can offset that with solar. He also stated that during the framework portion of the project is when they would evaluate the proposed installation of solar and if it meets all requirements.

Chair Bradley stated that the design was monolithic and boxy, and agreed with staff's recommendations.

Senior Planner Openshaw reads back the Boards recommendations.

Member Voronchihin asked if the board can recommend affordable housing be required in this project. Senior Planner Openshaw explained that from a zoning perspective it is not required and that affordable housing is not encompassed in the design of the project.

In response to Member Grace's question, Senior Planner Openshaw explained that the project design is brought to the board in the early stages where you see about 30% completion of plans. The remaining design is reconciled to include building code requirements in the building permit process. It is staff's responsibility to ensure that any adjustments to the plans made during that process meet the design that was approved.

Member Voronchihin recommended that the type of drainage system be specified in the plans.

Dave Sweeney, from the development group, stated that he appreciates the Board's recommendation, that they have built over 20 units in town, and their goal is to do what is right for the City. He explained that they are having difficulty with the set-backs and step-backs, however, they have cut approximately 25% of total space to make the building non monolithic, staggered and set-back.

Member Rogers thanked Mr. Sweeney for his comments and commented on the parking concern. He requested that the developers in town get together and come up with a potential plan to address the parking issues.

He provided an example such as a joint agreement between the local developers to build a parking structure downtown.

Member Voronchihin and Member Grace thanked the developers for their time and efforts.

Page 173 of 190 ends

Attachment 7
6 Motion by Member Grace
Seconded by Member Voronchihin
To approve the project to construct a new mixed use development with eight (8) residential condominium units and approximately 2,700 square feet of commercial space at 757 Seacoast Drive (APN 625-192-04-00) and forward to the City Council with the following recommendations:
 Incorporate additional varied stepbacks and setbacks along the southern and western elevations
 Stagger and stepback the second story decks facing Seacoast Drive
 Provide variations in roof form and height to provide variation in the building massing and primary facades
 Consider additional transportation demand management strategies  Consider a design that would enhance the amount of parking available or maximize the parking available for the site, potentially reallocating space for parking purposes
 All proposed/potential projections, mechanical or otherwise, where feasible must be below the maximum allowable building height and must be adequately screened
 Incorporate enclosed clear tempered glass screening to the patio area fronting Seacoast Drive
 Include secure bicycle rack storage and equipment storage for the residents while maintaining the proposed bicycle rack
 Include posted bike routes with the bus routes
 For unit 7, replace the glass material that screens the deck area with an opaque screening material to enhance privacy
 Enhance and increase the total amount of plants provided in the planted landscaping area
 Replace the trees that are currently proposed with shade trees that are taller
 Assess the safety of the lighting in the parking area and enhance it as needed to increase safety

Page 174 of 190 ends

Attachment 7
7  The overhang elements should be made flush all the way across the third floor instead of separated
 Replace the metal railing for the decks with glass
 Match the exterior materials of the trash enclosure with the primary building materials
 Remove the brick wall in between/separating the parking areas and replace them with pillars or an alternative design that can be walked/seen through
 Provide additional details on the project plans that would show the finished aesthetic of the building with the intended use of the commercial space
 Show any proposed internal drains, scuppers, downspouts, or gutters to show how stormwater would drain from the roof top AYES (3): Chair Bradley, Member Grace, and Member Voronchihin NOES (1): Member Rogers
ABSENT (1): Vice Chair Beltran
Motion Carried (3 to 1)

5. INFORMATIONAL ITEMS/REPORTS
Chair Bradley stated that he would like a staff presentation on the latest parking regulations, the impacts of the latest regulations to mandate parking within Imperial Beach, what tools are available to make a recommendation for a project to provide more parking, and a discussion on the application for the CUP process.

Member Rogers agreed with Chair Bradley. He made a motion for an informational presentation from staff on Imperial Beach parking plans and regulations.

Motion by Member Rogers
Seconded by Chair Bradley
For staff to provide an informational presentation at a future meeting about parking plans and regulations in the City.

Page 175 of 190 ends

Attachment 7
8 AYES (4): Chair Bradley, Member Grace, Member Rogers, and Member Voronchihin
ABSENT (1): Vice Chair Beltran
Motion Carried (4 to 0)
Senior Planner Openshaw provided an update on the 951 Seacoast Drive project, she stated that construction on the project has started. She also reported that demolition of structures has begun for the project on 801 Seacoast Drive.

6. ADJOURNMENT
Chair Bradley adjourned the meeting at 5:44 p.m.

Audrey Malone
Assistant City Clerk
Karl Bradley
Chair

Page 176 of 190 ends

P a g e | 1
April 19, 2023
ITEM TITLE: DISCUSSION OF LOCAL CAMPAIGN REGULATIONS. (0430-95) ORIGINATING DEPARTMENT:

City Manager
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY:

At a previous City Council meeting, Councilmember McKay requested that there be a City Council discussion on local campaign contribution regulations. This item allows the City Council to discuss some sample regulations from a nearby jurisdiction and provide direction to staff about what it would like to see in an ordinance on this topic that the City Council can consider adopting at a future Council meeting.

RECOMMENDATION:

Discuss regulations and provide direction to staff.

OPTIONS:
 Discuss item and provide direction to staff to bring back an ordinance at a future Council meeting; or
 Discuss item and decide not to adopt local campaign contribution regulations.

BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS:

A local jurisdiction may enact a campaign ordinance that provides for additional or different campaign contribution requirements for candidates in its jurisdiction that is different than the State law contribution limits. Effective January 1, 2021, the State set a default campaign contribution limit that applies to city and county candidates when the city or county has not already enacted a local contribution limit. Along with the new campaign contribution limit, there are other related provisions that formerly applied only to State level candidates that will now apply to city and county candidates. Pursuant to Fair Political Practices Commission Regulation 18545(a), the State default contribution limit is $5,500 for elections occurring between 1/1/23 and 12/31/24 for city councilmembers.

Currently, the City of Imperial Beach does not have its own campaign contribution limits, so it uses the default contribution limit set by the State. If the City Council wants to adopt its own campaign contribution limits to be different than the State default contribution limits, it could do so. The draft regulations attached to this staff report are largely based on the regulations from the

Page 177 of 190 ends

P a g e | 2
City of Coronado, but the City Council can provide direction to revise them as it sees fit. There are also many other cities in San Diego County and California that have set local contribution limits that can be used as examples.

If the City Council does adopt its own campaign contribution limits, the City will then be responsible for the enforcement of those regulations. If the City does not adopt its own regulations, then the State continues to be the one to enforce the laws related to the default State contribution limits.

Another factor that the City Council may want to consider is the new law adopted by SB1439 that amended Government Code section 84308 and prohibits a councilmember from accepting a campaign donation of more than $250 from an applicant with a proceeding before the City Council.

It also requires Council members to recuse themselves from voting on an item if they received a campaign contribution of more than $250 from an applicant as defined by the law. If the City Council were to set the campaign contributions limits below the $250 threshold, then this new requirement of Government Code section 84308 would likely not apply.

There are many considerations on this issue, and staff is just presenting sample regulations to provide a starting point for the Council to consider and amend as desired before final adoption at a future meeting. If it is helpful, the Council may want to consider appointing a limited term ad hoc to work with staff on drafting a final ordinance to bring back to the City Council for consideration.

In addition to discussing campaign contribution limits, the City Council may consider whether local regulations should be implemented to reduce vandalism of campaign signs. The State of California has laws to protect against larceny, destruction, and vandalism of political signs placed on private property during campaign season. However, complaints related to unauthorized removal or destruction and vandalism of political campaign signs continue to increase each election. Considering a local regulation could aid existing State laws to facilitate prosecution in cooperation with the District Attorney’s Office.

ENVIRONMENTAL DETERMINATION:

Not a project as defined by CEQA.

FISCAL IMPACT:

There will be costs associated with hiring special counsel to assist the City with enforcement of any local campaign regulations adopted by the City Council.

ATTACHMENTS:

ATT 1 - Draft City of Imperial Beach Campaign Contribution Regulations ATT 2 - City of Coronado Campaign Regulations

Page 178 of 190 ends

ATTACHMENT 1
Chapter 2.55 Campaign Regulations and Contribution Limits Sections:

2.55.010 Purpose and Scope.

2.55.020 Definitions.

2.55.030 Campaign Statements.

2.55.040 Form of Monetary Contribution.

2.55.050 Limitation on Amount of Contributions.

2.55.060 Regulations Associated with Contributors.

2.55.070 Prohibitions.

2.55.080 Appointment of Special Counsel.

2.55.090 Enforcement

2.55.100 Penalties.

2.55.010 Purpose and Scope.

Participation in fair and inclusive elections is the cornerstone to effect local government. The purpose of this chapter is to ensure all candidates and their supporters are provided with rules and guidelines that are clear, unbiased, and objective. Additionally, contribution limits have been established to ensure that qualified candidates have an opportunity to engage in the political process even if they possess different fiscal resources. The ideal is for each candidate to be motivated by community interests without even the appearance of influence from large financial contributors.

The contents of this chapter are intended to be consistent with and supplement the requirements of California State law regarding election protocols. Specifically, the provisions of Article XI, Section 7 of the California Constitution and California Government Code Section 81013 support the finding that municipal elections are municipal affairs; the regulation of campaign contributions and expenditures in municipal elections is not preempted by general state law; and such activity is the proper subject of municipal regulation under the authority granted to cities by the State of California. Should any provision of this chapter be determined to be invalid for any reason, the remainder shall be severed therefrom and shall remain in full force and effect.

2.55.020 Definitions.

A. For the purpose of this chapter, the following words and phrases shall have the meanings respectively ascribed to them by this subsection:
“Campaign statement” means an itemized report prepared on a form provided by the City Clerk that provides the information required by this chapter.
“Candidate” means an individual listed on the ballot or qualified to receive write-in votes counted by election officials for nomination or election to the position of Mayor or member of the City Council, or who receives a financial contribution or makes an expenditure or gives his or her consent for any other person to receive a contribution or make an expenditure with the intention of bringing about his or her nomination or election to the position of Mayor or member of the City Council, whether or not the specific elective office is known at the time the contribution is received or the expenditure is made and whether

Page 179 of 190 ends

ATTACHMENT 1
or not candidacy has been declared or filed. “Candidate” also includes any Mayor or Councilmember who is the subject of a recall election.
“Closing date” means the date which any report or statement filed under this chapter is required to be complete.
“Committee,” including controlled and independent committees, means any person or combination of persons who directly or indirectly receives contributions or makes expenditures or contributions for the purpose of influencing or attempting to influence the action of voters for or against the nomination or election of one or more candidates for City elective office, or for or against the qualification or passage of a City measure.
“Contribution” shall have the meaning set forth in Government Code Section 82015, as amended from time to time.
“Controlled committee” means a committee controlled directly or indirectly by a candidate or that acts jointly with or in coordination with a candidate or another controlled committee in connection with making expenditures. A candidate controls a committee if the candidate or agent or any other committee the candidate controls has significant influence on the actions or decisions of the committee, or if the committee coordinates its expenditures with the expenditures of a candidate or committee controlled by a candidate, whether or not the candidate is personally aware of the coordination. "Elected Official" (specific to Imperial Beach) means a member of the City Council, including the Mayor. “Election” means any City general, special, initiative, referendum or recall election. “Electronic filing” means use of a system that provides for the online or electronic transfer of data using telecommunications technology that ensures the integrity of the data transmitted and that creates safeguards against efforts to tamper with or subvert the data. “Entity” means any corporation, company, association, or other organization other than an individual or a political party.
“Expenditure” shall have the meaning set forth in Government Code Section 82025, as amended from time to time.
“Fundraiser event” means any political event organized for the purpose of raising funds to be used in the support of or opposition to any candidate or measure. “Independent committee” means any committee which receives contributions or makes expenditures for the purpose of influencing or attempting to influence a City election which is neither controlled by a candidate nor coordinates its expenditures with the expenditures of a candidate or a committee controlled by a candidate.
“Individual” means a singular human being.
“Measure” for the purposes of this chapter, means any proposition submitted to a popular vote at a City election.

Page 180 of 190 ends

ATTACHMENT 1
“Person” means an individual, proprietorship, firm, partnership, joint venture, syndicate, business trust, company corporation, association, or committee (including both controlled and independent committees), labor union, and any other organization or group of persons acting in concert. “Political party” means any organization qualified to participate in any primary election in the State of California as set forth in California Elections Code Section 5100, or such law as may replace Section 5100.

B. For purposes of this chapter, a person or combination of persons becomes a “committee” subject to the regulations of this chapter when such person or combination of persons:

1. Receives, for a City election, campaign contributions totaling $200.00 or more in a calendar year.

2. Expends for a City election a total of $200.00 or more in a calendar year.

C. Unless otherwise provided herein, the definitions, special provisions, and interpretations of the Political Reform Act of 1974, as amended, are to be relied upon in administering this chapter. The requirements of this chapter are in addition to and shall not be administered or interpreted to be in conflict with, the requirements of the Political Reform Act of 1974.

2.55.030 Campaign Statements.

A. Each candidate, each treasurer of a committee supporting or opposing a candidate, and each treasurer of a committee supporting or opposing a measure shall prepare an itemized statement of campaign contributions received and campaign expenditures made. The statutory provisions of the Political Reform Act of 1974 and the Elections Code Section 11500 et seq. shall be complied with as well as the reporting of campaign contributions and expenditures indicated in the following subsections:

1. Each contribution received with a value of $5.00 or more must be itemized listing the value of the contribution with the contributor’s name, street address, occupation and the name of employer, if any, or principal place of business if self-employed.

2. Each expenditure of a value of $5.00 or more must be itemized listing the full name and address of the person to whom the expenditure is made and a brief description of the consideration or service received.

B. Campaign statement forms shall be provided by the City Clerk and campaign statements shall be filed with the City Clerk in accordance with the deadlines established by the Political Reform Act of 1974.

Successful candidates and committees who support successful candidates must file their campaign statements before the candidate takes office. No certificate of election shall be issued nor shall an elected candidate assume office unless all campaign statements are filed in the Office of the City Clerk.

C. The City Clerk shall ensure that all campaign statements, filed with the City in accordance with this chapter, are retained and available for public review at City Hall, in accordance with law. Also, the City Clerk shall ensure that copies of the campaign statements are available for public review at the City Library by the close of business on the day following the filing of the statement with the City Clerk; and shall remain there for no less than six months following the related election.

D. Any elected officer, candidate, committee, or other person required to file statements, reports or other documents (“statements”) as required by Chapter 4 of the Political Reform Act (California Government Code Section 84100 et seq.) (“filers”) will file such statements using the City Clerk’s online system according to procedures established by the City Clerk and Chapter 2.58 of this code.

Page 181 of 190 ends

ATTACHMENT 1

2.55.040 Form of Monetary Contribution.

A. It is unlawful to make or receive a monetary campaign contribution in any amount unless the contribution is by check or credit card.

B. Every person required to file a campaign statement in accordance with this chapter shall:

1. Make a photocopy of each check or credit card receipt of each reportable contribution and obtain documentation showing the contributor’s name, address, and occupation;

2. Retain each photocopy or documentation for one year after the date of the related election; and

3. Make the photocopy or documentation available for inspection upon the reasonable request by the City’s special counsel.

2.55.050 Limitation on Amount of Contribution.

A. No individual or political party shall make one or more contributions with a total value of more than $200.00, per election, to:

1. The same candidate for Mayor;

2. The same candidate for City Council; or

3. The same controlled committee of a candidate for Mayor or City Council.

B. This section does not apply to a candidate’s contribution of personal funds to his or her own campaign contribution account or prohibit a controlled committee or political party from conveying to a candidate any monies legally received as contributions. The contribution limitation of this section is not a limitation upon expenditures and shall not limit the expenditures by any candidate, person, or committee.

C. Spouses are two separate individuals for purposes of the contribution limitations of this section.

2.55.060 Regulations Associated with Contributors.

A. No person or entity, other than an individual or political party, shall make a contribution to:

1. A candidate for Mayor or City Council; or

2. A controlled committee of a candidate for Mayor or City Council.

B. No contributor shall contribute anonymously or under an assumed name, or on behalf of another person, whether as agent, intermediary or otherwise.

C. No person who contracts with the City, either to conduct personal services or to furnish any material, supplies, or equipment to the City, or for selling any land or building to the City, shall make any contributions to a City Council candidate or a committee supporting or opposing a City Council candidate.

These prohibitions shall exist at all times between the commencement of negotiations for and during the completion of the performance under, or the termination of negotiations for such a contract or the furnishing of materials, supplies, equipment, land or building, whichever occurs later.

2.55.070 Prohibitions.

A. It is unlawful for any contributor to make, knowingly or willfully, a contribution which is prohibited by this chapter.

B. It is unlawful for any candidate, agent for a candidate, committee, or agent for a committee to solicit, knowingly or willfully, a contribution which is prohibited by this chapter.

Page 182 of 190 ends

ATTACHMENT 1
C. It shall be unlawful for any candidate, agent for a candidate, committee, or agent for a committee to accept, knowingly or willfully, a campaign contribution which is prohibited by this chapter.

D. It is unlawful for any person to aid, abet, advise or participate in, knowingly or willfully, a violation of this chapter.

E. No committee shall make any expenditures to influence or attempt to influence the voters in a City election if such committee has not complied with the contribution limitations imposed by this chapter upon such committee’s receipt of funds.

2.55.080 Appointment of Special Counsel.

A. At least 90 days prior to a City election, the City Council shall appoint a special counsel for that election and such additional special counsel as may be required, on such terms and conditions as the City Council deems appropriate.

B. The special counsel shall be the District Attorney, the Attorney General, or such other qualified and independent special counsel or combination of the foregoing as may be appointed by the City Council.

2.55.090 Enforcement.

A. The City’s review and investigation of complaints of alleged violations of this chapter shall be commenced and carried out only by an appointed special counsel. If the special counsel determines that there is a reason to believe that a violation of this chapter has occurred, special counsel shall conduct an investigation as it deems necessary for the enforcement of this chapter. The special counsel shall have such investigative powers as are necessary for the performance of duties described in this chapter and may demand and shall be furnished records of campaign contributions and expenditures of any person or committee subject to this chapter. In the event production of records is refused, the special counsel may commence civil litigation to complete the production.

B. Persons residing in the City who believe that a violation of this chapter has occurred may file a written complaint for review by the special counsel. If the complaint presents probable cause to believe that a violation has occurred, the special counsel will initiate an investigation of such violation.

C. Review, investigation, enforcement, litigation, and prosecution under this chapter shall be commenced and carried out only by an appointed special counsel. If the special counsel determines that there is good reason to believe that a violation of this chapter has occurred, special counsel may commence such administrative, civil, or criminal legal action as it deems necessary for the enforcement of this chapter.

D. Activity by special counsel in accordance with this chapter shall not be subject to review or control by the City Council or City Attorney. The City Attorney shall not review, investigate, prosecute or otherwise deal with any alleged violation of this chapter, but may defend the constitutionality and legality of this chapter in any civil proceeding in which the City or the City Council is a party.

E. Any action alleging a violation of this chapter must be commenced no later than four months after the mandatory filing date for semi-annual statements which cover the period during which the violation is alleged to have occurred, but in no case later than six months from the date of the related election.

2.55.100 Penalties.

A. Any person who knowingly or willfully violates any provision of this chapter is guilty of a misdemeanor.

Page 183 of 190 ends

ATTACHMENT 1
B. Any person who violates any provision of this chapter shall be liable in a civil action for damages in the amount of three times the amount not properly reported or unlawfully contributed, solicited, or accepted, not to exceed $1,000. Upon collection, the monies shall be deposited into the general fund of the City, earmarked to be used for the purpose of defraying the costs of municipal elections.

Page 184 of 190 ends

Chapter 1.84

CAMPAIGN REGULATIONS
Sections:

1.84.010 Scope of chapter.

1.84.020 Campaign statements.

1.84.030 Form of monetary contribution.

1.84.040 Limitation on amount of contribution.

1.84.050 Limitation on who can contribute.

1.84.060 Prohibitions.

1.84.070 Appointment of special counsel.

1.84.080 Enforcement.

1.84.090 Penalties.

1.84.010 Scope of chapter.

A. This chapter is intended to place realistic and enforceable limits on political campaigns conducted within the City, as well as to supplement the requirements of State law with regard to the reporting of campaign contributions and expenditures, for the purpose of preventing the exercise by campaign contributors of potential undue or improper influence over elected officials and to inform the public of the sources and objects of campaign contributions and expenditures. The City Council finds that municipal elections are municipal affairs; the regulation of campaign contributions and expenditures in municipal elections is not preempted by general State law; and such activity is the proper subject of municipal regulation under the authority granted to cities by Article XI, Section 7 of the California Constitution and State Government Code Section 81013. This chapter is to be interpreted in a manner consistent with constitutional requirements. Should any provision of this chapter be determined to be invalid for any reason, the remainder shall be severed therefrom and shall remain in full force and effect.

B. Definitions. For the purpose of this chapter, the following words and phrases shall have the meanings respectively ascribed to them by this subsection:
“Campaign statement” means an itemized report which is prepared on a form provided by the City Clerk and which provides the information required by this chapter.
“Candidate” means an individual who is listed on the ballot or who has qualified to have write-in votes on his or her behalf counted by election officials for nomination for or election to the position of Mayor or on the City Council, or who receives a contribution or makes an expenditure or gives his or her consent for any other person to receive a contribution or make an expenditure with the intention of bringing about his or her nomination or election to the position of Mayor or City Council, whether or not the specific elective office for which he or she will seek nomination or election is known at the time the contribution is received or the expenditure is made and whether or not he or she has announced his or her candidacy or filed a declaration of candidacy at such time. “Candidate” also includes any Mayor or Councilmember who is the subject of a recall election. “Closing date” means the date which any report or statement filed under this chapter is required to be complete. “Committee,” including controlled and independent committees, means any person who directly or indirectly receives contributions or makes expenditures or contributions for the purpose of influencing or attempting to influence the action of voters:

ATTACHMENT 2

Page 185 of 190 ends

For or against the nomination or election of one or more candidates for City elective office; or For or against the qualification or passage of a City measure. “Contribution” shall have the meaning set forth in Government Code Section 82015, as amended from time to time. “Controlled committee” means a committee which is controlled directly or indirectly by a candidate or which acts jointly with or in coordination with a candidate or another controlled committee in connection with the making of expenditures.

A candidate controls a committee if such candidate, his or her agent or any other committee such candidate controls has significant influence on the actions or decisions of the committee or if such committee coordinates its expenditures with the expenditures of a candidate or committee controlled by a candidate, whether or not such candidate is personally aware of such coordination.
“Election” means any City general, special, initiative, referendum or recall election. “Electronic filing” means use of a system that provides for the online or electronic transfer of data using telecommunications technology that ensures the integrity of the data transmitted and that creates safeguards against efforts to tamper with or subvert the data.
“Entity” means any corporation, company, association, or other organization other than an individual or a political party. “Expenditure” shall have the meaning set forth in Government Code Section 82025, as amended from time to time. “Fundraiser event” means any political event organized for the purpose of raising funds to be used in the support of or opposition to any candidate or measure.
“Independent committee” means any committee which receives contributions or makes expenditures for the purpose of influencing or attempting to influence a City election which is neither controlled by a candidate nor coordinates its expenditures with the expenditures of a candidate or a committee controlled by a candidate. “Individual” means a sole human being.
“Measure” means any proposition submitted to a popular vote, only at a City election. “Person” means an individual, proprietorship, firm, partnership, joint venture, syndicate, business trust, company corporation, association or committee (including both controlled and independent committees), labor union, and any other organization or group of persons acting in concert. “Political party” means any organization qualified to participate in any primary election in the State of California as set forth in California Elections Code Section 5100, or such law as may replace Section 5100.

C. For purposes of this chapter, a person or combination of persons becomes a “committee” subject to the regulations of this chapter when such person or combination of persons:

1. Receives, for a City election, campaign contributions totaling $200.00 or more in a calendar year; or

2. Expends for a City election a total of $200.00 or more in a calendar year.

D. Unless otherwise provided herein, the provisions, definitions and interpretations of the Political Reform Act of 1974, as amended, are to be relied upon in administering this chapter. (Gov. Code § 8100 et seq.) E. The requirements of this chapter are in addition to, and shall not be administered or interpreted to be in conflict with, the requirements of the Political Reform Act of 1974. (Ord. 2073 § 2, 2018; Ord. 2066 § 2, 2017; Ord. 1828)

1.84.020 Campaign statements.

A. Each candidate, each treasurer of a committee supporting or opposing a candidate, and each treasurer of a committee supporting or opposing a measure shall prepare an itemized statement of campaign contributions received and campaign expenditures made. The statutory provisions of the Political Reform Act of 1974 (Proposition 9) and the

Page 186 of 190 ends

Elections Code Section 11500 et seq. shall be complied with as well as the reporting of campaign contributions and expenditures indicated in the following subsections:

1. Each contribution received with a value of $5.00 or more must be itemized listing the value of the contribution with the contributor’s name, street address, occupation and the name of employer, if any, or principal place of business if self-employed;

2. Each expenditure of a value of $5.00 or more must be itemized listing the full name and address of the person to whom the expenditure is made and a brief description of the consideration or service received; and

3. Successful candidates and committees who support successful candidates must file their campaign statements before the candidate takes office. No certificate of election shall be issued nor shall an elected candidate assume office unless all campaign statements are filed in the Office of the City Clerk.

B. Campaign statement forms shall be provided by the City Clerk and campaign statements shall be filed with the City Clerk in accordance with the deadlines established by the Political Reform Act of 1974.

C. The City Clerk shall ensure that all campaign statements, filed with the City in accordance with this chapter, are retained and available for public review at City Hall, in accordance with law. Also, the City Clerk shall ensure that copies of the campaign statements are available for public review at the City Library by the close of business on the day following the filing of the statement with the City Clerk; and shall remain there for no less than six months following the related election.

D. 1. Any elected officer, candidate, committee, or other person required to file statements, reports or other documents (“statements”) as required by Chapter 4 of the Political Reform Act (California Government Code Section 84100 et seq.) (“filers”) may file such statements using the City Clerk’s online system according to procedures established by the City Clerk (the “procedures”). This online filing requirement shall become mandatory beginning April 1, 2018.

2. The City Clerk shall have the authority to establish and amend the procedures, as necessary, to accomplish the following:
a. Ensure that the online system complies with the requirements set forth in Section 84615 of the California Government Code, as may be amended from time to time;
b. Meet the purpose and intent of this section and comply with other applicable law; and c. Ensure the integrity of the data transmitted and include safeguards against efforts to tamper with, manipulate, alter, or subvert the data.

3. Online filings made under this chapter will only be accepted if made in the standardized format that is developed by the California Secretary of State pursuant to Section 84602(a)(2) of the California Government Code, as may be amended from time to time, and that is compatible with the Secretary of State’s system for receiving an online or electronic filing. (Ord. 2073 § 3, 2018)

1.84.030 Form of monetary contribution.

A. It is unlawful to make or receive a monetary campaign contribution in any amount unless the contribution is by check or credit card.

B. Every person required to file a campaign statement in accordance with this chapter shall:

1. Make a photocopy of each check or credit card receipt by which a reportable contribution is made and obtain documentation showing the contributor’s name, address, and occupation;

2. Retain each such photocopy or documentation for one year after the date of the related election; and

3. Make the photocopy or documentation available for inspection upon the reasonable request by the City’s special counsel. (Ord. 2066 § 3, 2017)

Page 187 of 190 ends

1.84.040 Limitation on amount of contribution.

A. No individual or entity shall make one or more contributions, with a total value of more than $200.00, per election, to:

1. The same candidate for City Council;

2. The same candidate for Mayor; or

3. The same controlled committee of a candidate for City Council or Mayor.

B. This section does not:

1. Apply to a candidate’s contribution of his or her personal funds to his or her own campaign contribution account.

2. Prohibit a controlled committee or political party from conveying to a candidate any moneys legally received as contributions.

C. Spouses are two separate individuals for purposes of the contribution limitations of this section.

D. The contribution limitation of this section is not a limitation upon expenditures and shall not limit the expenditures by any candidate, person or committee.

E. Joint Funding.

1. Joint funding of campaign expenditures by two or more committees shall not be deemed to be a contribution by any such committee to any candidate; provided, that each such committee contributes equal amounts to each such expenditure.

2. Any such joint expenditure shall cause any theretofore independent committee participating therein to be deemed a controlled committee of any and all candidates for whose benefit such joint expenditure is made.

3. Any independent committee, which becomes a controlled committee by reason of subsection (E)(2) of this section, shall be deemed a controlled committee for purposes of the contribution limitation of this section to the committee, effective retroactive to the date upon which the first contribution to such committee was received by such committee.

F. Subject to subsections (E)(2) and (3) of this section, the contribution limitation of this section shall not apply to any independent committee:

1. Composed solely of one individual;

2. Organized principally for a purpose other than participating in or influencing an election or elections;

3. Organized for the purpose of supporting or opposing the qualification for the ballot or the adoption of one or more City measures; or

4. Which receives contributions to be expended in the elections of more than one city. (Ord. 2066 § 4, 2017)

1.84.050 Limitation on who can contribute.

A. No person or entity, other than an individual or political party, shall make a contribution to:

1. A candidate for City Council or Mayor;

2. A controlled committee of a candidate for City Council or Mayor.

B. No Contributions by City Contractors. Page 188 of 190

1. No person who contracts with the City, either for the rendition of personal services or for the furnishing of any material, supplies, or equipment to the City, or for selling any land or building to the City, shall make any contributions to a City Council candidate or a committee supporting or opposing a City Council candidate.

2. The prohibition of subsection (B)(1) of this section shall exist at all times between the commencement of negotiations for and during the completion of the performance under, or the termination of negotiations for such a contract or the furnishing of materials, supplies, equipment, land or building, whichever occurs later.

C. No contributor shall make a contribution anonymously or under an assumed name, or on behalf of another person, whether as agent, intermediary or otherwise. (Ord. 2066 § 5, 2017)

1.84.060 Prohibitions.

A. It is unlawful for any contributor to make, knowingly or willfully, a contribution which is prohibited by this chapter.

B. It is unlawful for any candidate, agent for a candidate, committee, or agent for a committee to solicit, knowingly or willfully, a contribution which is prohibited by this chapter.

C. It shall be unlawful for any candidate, agent for a candidate, committee, or agent for a committee to accept, knowingly or willfully, a campaign contribution which is prohibited by this chapter.

D. It is unlawful for any person to aid, abet, advise or participate in, knowingly or willfully, a violation of this chapter.

E. No committee shall make any expenditures to influence or attempt to influence the voters in a City election if such committee has not complied with the contribution limitations imposed by this chapter upon such committee’s receipt of funds.

1.84.070 Appointment of special counsel.

A. At least 90 days prior to a City election, the City Council shall appoint a special counsel for that election and such additional special counsel as may be required, on such terms and conditions as the City Council deems appropriate.

B. The special counsel shall be the District Attorney, the Attorney General, or such other qualified and independent special counsel or combination of the foregoing as may be appointed by the City Council.

1.84.080 Enforcement.

A. Review and Investigation of Complaints.

1. The City’s review and investigation of complaints of alleged violations of this chapter shall be commenced and carried out only by an appointed special counsel.

2. If the special counsel determines that there is a reason to believe that a violation of this chapter has occurred, special counsel shall conduct an investigation as it deems necessary for the enforcement of this chapter.

3. The special counsel shall have such investigative powers as are necessary for the performance of duties described in this chapter and may demand and shall be furnished records of campaign contributions and expenditures of any person or committee subject to this chapter. In the event that production of such records is refused, the special counsel may commence civil litigation to complete such production.

B. Persons residing in the City who believe that a violation of this chapter has occurred may file a written complaint for review by the special counsel. If the complaint presents probable cause to believe that a violation has occurred, the special counsel will initiate an investigation of such violation.

C. Action to Enforce. If the special counsel determines that there is good reason to believe that a violation of this chapter has occurred, special counsel may commence such administrative, civil, or criminal legal action as it deems necessary for the enforcement of this chapter.

D. Review, investigation, enforcement, litigation, and prosecution under this chapter shall be commenced and carried out only by an appointed special counsel.

Page 189 of 190 ends

E. Activity by special counsel in accordance with this chapter shall not be subject to review or control by the City Council or City Attorney.

F. The City Attorney shall not review, investigate, prosecute or otherwise deal with any alleged violation of this chapter, but shall defend the constitutionality and legality of this chapter in any civil proceeding in which the City or the City Council is a party.

G. Any action alleging a violation of this chapter must be commenced no later than four months after the mandatory filing date for semi-annual statements which cover the period during which the violation is alleged to have occurred, but in no case later than six months from the date of the related election.

1.84.090 Penalties.

A. Any person who knowingly or willfully violates any provision of this chapter is guilty of a misdemeanor.

B. Any person who violates a provision of this chapter shall be liable in a civil action for damages in the amount of three times the amount not properly reported or unlawfully contributed, solicited, or accepted, not to exceed $1,000. Upon collection, said sum shall be deposited into the general fund of the City, earmarked to be used for the purpose of defraying the costs of municipal elections.

Mobile Version

Page 190 of 190 ends
← All documents from this meeting