ITEM 5. 4
CITY MANAGER' S REPORT
November 13, 2023 CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING
ITEM: PUBLIC HEARING ( PUBLISHED NOTICE) TO
CONSIDER THE 2024 SJMSCP DEVELOPMENT FEE
ANNUAL ADJUSTMENT
RECOMMENDATION: Council to Consider the Following:
1. Hold a Public Hearing; and
2. Adopt a Resolution Approving an Annual
Adjustment to the San ) oaquin County MultiSpecies Habitat Conservation and Open Space Plan ( S) MSCP) Development Fee for 2024
SUMMARY:
On August 24, 2023, the San Joaquin Council of Governments ( SJCOG) Board approved the annual adjustment to the San Joaquin County Multi- Species Habitat Conservation and Open Space Plan ( SJMSCP) development fees, and is now requesting each participating jurisdiction to adopt the annual adjustment to become effective on January 1, 2024.
The final calculation of the 2024 S) MSCP development fees shows an approximate overall decrease of 7. 4% in the most commonly impacted categories of Agricultural and Natural habitat classifications compared to 2023. The decrease is due primarily to a reduction in the land acquisition component ( Category A) for agricultural land price values of comparable sales even though there was a rise in the reported Consumer Price Index ( CPI) for Categories B ( Assessment and Enhancement) and C Land Management and Administration). The total of these 3 categories equates to the final amount of the development fee.
The following table shows the habitat categories, the current 2023 fees, and proposed 2024 fee adjustments ( per acre).
YEAR 2020 2021 2022 2023
2024
Proposed)
Multi- purpose 6, 412 8, 682 9, 781 9, 629 8, 918
Agriculture/ Natural $ 12, 822 17, 363 19, 561 19, 255 17, 833 Vernal Pool
rasslands
52, 833 71, 544 80, 453 75, 320 69, 408
Vernal Pool
wetted
100, 788 161, 286 174, 040 176, 878 177, 724
CITY MANAGERS REPORT PAGE 2
NOVEMBER 13, 2023 CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING
2024 SJMSCP DEVELOPMENT FEES
Staff recommends adoption of the attached resolution approving an annual adjustment to the San Joaquin County Multi- Species Habitat Conservation and Open Space Plan ( SJMSCP) development fees for 2024.
BACKGROUND:
On November 6, 2001, the City Council adopted Ordinance No. 01- 194, establishing the SJMSCP. The plan established a procedure to mitigate the impacts of new development on undeveloped land within the Cities of Lathrop, Escalon, Tracy, Ripon, Manteca, Lodi, Stockton, and San Joaquin County. Each City and the County adopted the SJMSCP and the recommended fee schedule at that time. A Habitat Conservation Map ( Attachment 2) identifies those areas within the City of Lathrop that are subject to a specific habitat fee category. Since its adoption, the developer paid SJMSCP fees have been adjusted annually to be effective on January lst of each year.
The development fees were calculated using a formula which is adjusted annually Fee = Category A ( acquisition) + Category B ( assessment & enhancement) + Category C ( land management & administration)]. Each component of the formula is adjusted using a specific mechanism which relates to the individual component in the fees.
Projects which participate under the SJMSCP benefit from a pre- determined streamlined processing of the project rather than navigating a very long and cumbersome regulatory process through the state and federal permitting agencies.
By participating, the project can choose a number of ways to provide mitigation for the impacts of the project:
1. Pay a fee;
2. Redesign the project to avoid/ minimize impacts;
3. Provide land in lieu of the SJMSCP fee which the project will negotiate the easement/ fee title costs; or
4. Any combination of the above options.
Alternatively, the project proponent may choose to not participate in the SJMSCP and fulfill mitigation requirements on their own with state and federal permitting agencies.
It' s important to note that development projects in Lathrop such as River Islands, Central Lathrop, South Lathrop and Gateway have taken advantage of the benefit this program.
CITY MANAGERS REPORT PAGE 3
NOVEMBER 13, 2023 CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING
2024 S7MSCP DEVELOPMENT FEES
RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends that the City Council consider all information provided and submitted, take and consider all public testimony and, if determined to be appropriate, adopt a resolution approving the annual adjustment to the San Joaquin County Multi- Species Habitat Conservation and Open Space Plan development fees for 2024.
FISCAL IMPACT:
The fee adoption has no fiscal impact to the City. Developers may participate in the SJMSCP plan or opt out and fulfill mitigation requirements with state and federal permitting agencies.
ATTAC H M E NT:
1. Resolution to approve the 2024 San Joaquin County Multi- Species Habitat Conservation and Open Space Plan ( SJMSCP) development fee.
2. S) MSCP Habitat Conservation Map
3. 2024 Habitat Fee Table
CITY MANAGERS REPORT PAGE 4
NOVEMBER 13, 2023 CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING
2024 S7MSCP DEVELOPMENT FEES
APPROVALS:
lO a.9 a.
Ja s Michaels Date
Senior Planner
b z 2
Ric Caguiat Da e
C u ' ty evelopment Director
3 Cari Jam Date
Finance ' ector
o• } o• Zot3
Salvador Navarrete Date
City Attorney
Il• ! •2
Ste en J. Salvatore Date
City Manager
RESOLUTION NO. 23 -
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LATHROP APPROVING THE ANNUAL AD7USTMENT TO THE SAN JOAQUIN COUNTY
MULTI- SPECIES HABITAT CONSERVATION AND OPEN SPACE PLAN S7MSCP) DEVELOPMENT FEE FOR 2024
WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Lathrop adopted Ordinance No. 01- 194 establishing the authority for collection of a Development Fee for the San Joaquin County Multi- Species Habitat Conservation and Open Space Plan ( SJMSCP) for all new development pursuant to the SJMSCP within the City of Lathrop; and WHEREAS, a Fee Study" dated July 1, 2001 was prepared which analyzed and identifies the costs, funding, and cost- benefit of the San Joaquin County MultiSpecies Habitat Conservation and Open Space Plan; and WHEREAS, the purpose of the SJMSCP development fee is to finance the goals and objectives of the SJMSCP that include, but are not limited to preserve land acquisition, preserve enhancement, land management, and administration that compensate for such lands lost as a result of future development in the City of Lathrop and in San Joaquin County; and
WHEREAS, after considering the fee study and the testimony received at the public hearing, the Lathrop City Council approved said report; and further found that the future development in the City of Lathrop will need to compensate cumulative impacts to threatened, endangered, rare and unlisted SJMSCP covered species and other wildlife and compensation for some non- wildlife related impacts to recreation, agriculture, scenic values and other beneficial open space uses; and WHEREAS, an Updated Fee Study" was prepared in 2006, 2011, 2016 and 2020 which analyzed and identified the costs and funding of the SJMSCP; and WHEREAS, the SJMSCP development fees are divided into three categories:
Category A - Acquisition; Category B - Enhancement; and Category C - Land Management/ Administration; and
WHEREAS, the SJMSCP development fees for the different habitat types is shown on Attachment 3 of the staff report; and
WHEREAS, to ensure that the SJMSCP development fees keep pace with inflation, annual adjustments are made to the fees based on the method previously adopted by the Lathrop City Council; and
WHEREAS, the method of annual adjustments was modified in Z011, 2016, and 2020; and
Resolution No. 23-
WHEREAS, the 2020 adjustment resulted in a minor change to category A" with an adjustment to the easement to fee title percentage used in the fee model and category C" with pivoting to a more robust diversified endowment investment for higher return on investment.
NOW, THEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY RESOLVED, by the City Council of the City of Lathrop, as follows:
1. The City Council finds and declares that the purposes and uses of the development fee, and the determination of the reasonable relationship between the fees' uses and the type of development project on which the fees are imposed, are all established in Ordinance No. 01- 194, and remain valid, and the City Council therefore adopts such determinations.
2. The 2024 development fee for the three habitat types - natural land and agricultural lands, vernal pool habitat, and multi- purpose open space conversion, shall be as set forth in Attachment 3 of the staff report, incorporated by reference herein.
3. The fee provided in this resolution shall be effective on January 1, 2024 - December 31, 2024.
Resolution No. 23-
The foregoing resolution was passed and adopted this 13th day of November 2023, by the following vote of the City Council, to wit:
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
ABSTAIN:
Sonny Dhaliwal, Mayor
ATTEST: APPROVED AS TO FORM:
Teresa Vargas, City Clerk Salvador Navarrete, City Attorney Resolution No. 23-
ATTA GHMENT " `
u
t 1 D 4
O
I
i
v
n
i i `° , ` au" iAv , ,
r^ 1 i -- w/
G
Y
R
p D C _,< _.
FI FF
O
i
COM PAINE AV
I I i , \
i
I i
I
i
M. i
i
l.
t/ NG
i
o.. F i i , , _ m F,q p ,
ys , . P
r , SE . 1, i N3lJ MOIIII A
4S .' .';''' fj. C
i
y
o'
N
a ._
a
o
D Tp
f v° ` ' - 1 1
9 ALDER z
I 4
r- o
9 AV: a ` o
i z
I I
I --
Ci ', A y7
r- I
l
9L
O
9L
x i n
bRd
s
v ^, " Y ,.
p , z
ROBERTS RD
rO i
i p
c7 , z
a=
I o
UNDINE RD
y
i
e 1 m 1
I
O ' a
A
T1 t r
i
m,
4a 6 r " ._
02f S3WlOH i
4 i I ..
g m g v
y ,
r s
i
I O
pv
m
m 1
m ' ,:
r D , Q x i
r' f
T
2 I z
N
fi
V,
t_ r o v
i
t7 o _ p
o
5 y! O t m a D o . .
s
s;
o
A
I 7
I 8^: 6C S4 e O,_ < - Y p
V
I E ,
s85' d m STRAtFORDAV ___
n'1qNTNEY R , o
A ;
S t 3^
y O o A
AVON AV OPAL ST "--__ If ,' 3 J
i' s : y g
o 1
I .
9°
se i '
O -, a. Z
O cn lgil3dSdf AH/
Ee a
O N fl . tr HOWLAtVD i _ Y
S R.
n p
D y RD iS MCKINLEY A
i : 9 g 4IA , m 1S HiN3 S
g
a
k la v _. m__ _
AdJ. 3lNIN W
O
N
m
I a. o
e ' 1 r A LS312
a:. _
ges, _. p Z
I
s[
3° 1qTHR0 n
s ', :&&
P
i
i
9. — ,.,. . i' kANTECa r
e; P o: 4: al a 9 Q
f_
aa g
50 V' '
IRPOk VJ1Y `
i'
D
4. . S, i
r
a 1
r' i
I O 9Tj, ' i
T _;,
I
r : 3 i , z O -+ u,%
L , m'
v
dti tl8HSf3 o Z = y ,
4NDER AV f
y y Q
x %. z
Q .
try D
o zt m
b
i
I
n c ai o c< o o ao voo 0
s z gn ama ' ana a
y
atis oma
p m I D
pm < A- 1 ( H- <' < Zti
San Joaquin County Multi- S pecies Habitat m
N = m = p g = mp Opp ; o !,
m mv ~ A
m
e o
m< 8< < y< ,
o < .
Conservation and Open Space Plan
m ms m '
z
3T
gx 3i n
D .
z
T . z ~ ' m 2'
s " p
y
c z
I
w m
H I
I
Attachment 3
SJCOG, Inc.
555 East t1' eber venue 5tockton, CA 95202 ( 209) 235- 0574 • Email: bo d@sjcog. org San joaquin County Multi-Speeies Habitat Conservation £t Open Spaee Plan (SJMSCP)
n" t"'" x' 2024 U dated Habitat Fees*
CHAIR
UlQ11Q. C QI'Lf
E HA, R
Habitat Type Fee Per cre
Drane, u,
Multi-Pur ose O en S ace 8, 918
EXECU? IVE DIRECTOR
u,,, e,. AK„, E. S Natural 17, 83 3
CITIES OF Agriculture 17, 83 3
ESCA LON,
LATHROP, Vernal POO1 - U lands 69, 408
LODI,
MANTECA, Vern'd POO - Well. e 1
RIPON,
STOCKTON, Effective January 1, 2024- December 3l, 2024
TRACY,
AND
THECOUNTYOF
SAN JOAQUIN 2p24 Endowment Fees with In-lieu Land**
Enhancement
Land TOTAL PER
Type of Preserve Cosi/ acre
Management ACRE
Cost/ acre ENDOWMENT
Agricultural Nabitat Lands 6, 038. 00 792. 15 6, 830. 15 Natural Lands 6, 038. 00 792. 15 6, 830. 15
Vernal Pool Habitat
Vernal Pool Grasslands 14, 906. 00 1, 956. 53 16, 862. 53 Vernal Pool Wetted 123, 058. 00 1, 918. 14 $ 124, 976. 14 Effective January 1, 2024— December 31, 2024 in lieu of fees to be used as the endowment for the dedicated land preserves( Category B+ C) based on impacted acres.
VELB Mitigation
A special fee category shall apply when removal ofthe Valley Elderberry Long-horned Beatle( VELB) habitat of elderberry shrubs occurs. The fee shall be paid to SJCOG, Inc. or a VELB mitigation bank approved by the Permitting Agencies. The current fee, as established in the VELB Conservation Fund Account managed by the Center for Natural Lands Management, and approved by the USFWS, is 1, 800 per VELB Unit( one unit= one stem over 1" in diameter at ground level which is removed). Fees shall be established by the JPA during preconstruction surveys( i. e., counts of stems to be removed with and without e t holes shall be completed during preconstruction surveys) and shall be paid to the JPA prior to ground disturbance or stem removal, whichever comes first.