Agenda packet — Livingston City Council, May 16, 2023 (part 3 of 3)

Page 224 ends

City of Livingston
BAD - Vinewood Estates
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
022-030-002-000 611
022-030-003-000 629
022-030-004-000 647
022-030-005-000 665
022-030-006-000 683
022-030-007-000 707
022-030-008-000 713
022-030-009-000 719
022-030-010-000 725
022-030-011-000 731
022-030-012-000 712
022-030-013-000 664
022-030-014-000 646
022-030-015-000 628
022-030-016-000 610
022-030-017-000 611
022-030-018-000 629
022-030-019-000 647
022-030-020-000 665
022-030-021-000 680
022-030-022-000 625
022-030-023-000 624
022-030-024-000 720
022-030-025-000 732
022-030-026-000 744
022-030-027-000 756
022-030-028-000 757
022-030-029-000 745
022-030-030-000 733
022-030-031-000 721
022-030-032-000 576
022-030-033-000 550
022-041-001-000 737
022-041-002-000 743
022-041-003-000 749
022-041-004-000 755
022-041-005-000 761
022-041-006-000 767
022-041-007-000 773
022-041-008-000 779
022-041-009-000 556
022-041-010-000 568
022-041-011-000 580
022-041-012-000 592
022-041-013-000 593
022-041-014-000 581
022-041-015-000 569
022-041-016-000 557
022-042-001-000 718
022-042-002-000 724
022-042-003-000 730
022-042-004-000 736
022-042-005-000 742
Willdan Financial Services

RAVENSWOOD DR

ALMONDWOOD DR

CHERRYWOOD WA)

BRIARWOOD DR

CHERRYWOOD CT

BRIARWOOD DR

RAVENSWOOD DR

ELMWOOD WAY

ELMWOOD WAY
F ST
F ST
F ST
F ST

RAVENSWOOD DR

1.0 1.0

1.0 $44.58

44.58 44.58

1.0 44.58

Page 1 of 3 ends

Page 225 ends

City of Livingston
BAD - Vi newood Estates
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
022-042-006-000 748 RAVENSWOOD DR 1.0 44.58
022-042-007-000 754 RAVENSWOOD DR 1.0 44.58
022-042-008-000 581 ELMWOOD WAY 1.0 44.58
022-042-009-000 593 ELMWOOD WAY 1.0 44.58
022-042-010-000 731 ALMONDWOOD DR 1.0 44.58
022-042-011-000 725 ALMONDWOOD DR 1.0 44.58
022-042-012-000 719 ALMONDWOOD DR 1.0 44.58
022-042-013-000 713 ALMONDWOOD DR 1.0 44.58
022-042-014-000 707 ALMONDWOOD DR 1.0 44.58
022-043-001-000 657 OAKWOOD WAY 1.0 44.58
022-043-002-000 669 OAKWOOD WAY 1.0 44.58
022-043-003-000 681 OAKWOOD WAY 1.0 44.58
022-043-004-000 675 BRIARWOOD DR 1.0 44.58
022-043-005-000 651 BRIARWOOD DR 1.0 44.58
022-044-001-000 724 ALMONDWOOD DR 1.0 44.58
022-044-002-000 750 ALMONDWOOD DR 1.0 44.58
022-044-003-000 632 OAKWOOD WAY 1.0 44.58
022-044-004-000 644 OAKWOOD WAY 1.0 44.58
022-044-005-000 656 OAKWOOD WAY 1.0 44.58
022-044-006-000 668 OAKWOOD WAY 1.0 44.58
022-044-007-000 680 OAKWOOD WAY 1.0 44.58
022-044-008-000 692 OAKWOOD WAY 1.0 44.58
022-044-009-000 693 ELMWOOD WAY 1.0 44.58
022-044-010-000 681 ELMWOOD WAY 1.0 44.58
022-044-011-000 669 ELMWOOD WAY 1.0 44.58
022-044-012-000 657 ELMWOOD WAY 1.0 44.58
022-044-013-000 645 ELMWOOD WAY 1.0 44.58
022-044-014-000 633 ELMWOOD WAY 1.0 44.58
022-044-015-000 621 ELMWOOD WAY 1.0 44.58
022-044-016-000 609 ELMWOOD WAY 1.0 44.58
022-045-001-000 608 ELMWOOD WAY 1.0 44.58
022-045-002-000 620 ELMWOOD WAY 1.0 44.58
022-045-003-000 632 ELMWOOD WAY 1.0 44.58
022-045-004-000 644 ELMWOOD WAY 1.0 44.58
022-045-005-000 656 ELMWOOD WAY 1.0 44.58
022-045-006-000 668 ELMWOOD WAY 1.0 44.58
022-045-007-000 680 ELMWOOD WAY 1.0 44.58
022-045-008-000 692 ELMWOOD WAY 1.0 44.58
022-045-009-000 693 FST 1.0 44.58
022-045-010-000 681 F ST 1.0 44.58
022-045-011-000 669 F ST 1.0 44.58
022-045-012-000 657 F ST 1.0 44.58
022-045-013-000 645 FST 1.0 44.58
022-045-014-000 633 FST 1.0 44.58
022-045-015-000 621 F ST 1.0 44.58
022-045-016-000 609 F ST 1.0 44.58
022-046-001-000 650 BRIARWOOD DR 1.0 44.58
022-046-002-000 676 BRIARWOOD DR 1.0 44.58
022-046-003-000 721 OAKWOOD CT 1.0 44.58
022-046-004-000 733 OAKWOOD CT 1.0 44.58
022-046-005-000 745 OAKWOOD CT 1.0 44.58
022-046-006-000 757 OAKWOOD CT 1.0 44.58
022-046-007-000 756 OAKWOOD CT 1.0 44.58
Willdan Financial Services Page 2 of 3

Page 226 ends

City of Livingston
BAD - Vinewood Estates
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
022-046-008-000 744 OAKWOOD CT 1.0 44.58
022-046-009-000 732 OAKWOOD CT 1.0 44.58
022-046-010-000 720 OAKWOOD CT 1.0 44.58
022-046-011-000 724 BRIARWOOD DR 1.0 44.58
022-046-012-000 750 BRIARWOOD DR 1.0 44.58
022-046-013-000 776 BRIARWOOD DR 1.0 44.58
022-046-014-000 721 ELMWOOD CT 1.0 44.58
022-046-015-000 733 ELMWOOD CT 1.0 44.58
022-046-016-000 745 ELMWOOD CT 1.0 44.58
022-046-017-000 757 ELMWOOD CT 1.0 44.58
022-046-020-000 732 ELMWOOD CT 1.0 44.58
022-046-021-000 720 ELMWOOD CT 1.0 44.58
022-046-022-000 824 BRIARWOOD DR 1.0 44.58
022-046-023-000 850 BRIARWOOD DR 1.0 44.58
022-046-024-000 876 BRIARWOOD DR 1.0 44.58
022-046-025-000 721 F ST 1.0 44.58
022-046-026-000 733 F ST 1.0 44.58
Summary Fields Value
Number of Parcels to be Levied 123
Total EDUs 123.00
Total Charges $5,483.34
Willdan Financial Services Page 3 of 3

Page 227 ends

City of Livingston
BAD - Vinewood Estates II
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
022-030-036-000
022-030-037-000
022-030-038-000
022-030-039-000
022-030-040-000
022-030-041-000
022-030-042-000
022-030-043-000
022-030-044-000
022-030-045-000
022-030-046-000
022-030-047-000
022-030-048-000
022-030-049-000
022-030-050-000
Summarv Fields
Number of Parcels to be Levied
Total EDUs
Total•
Willdan Financial Services
505
513
521
529
537
545
NO
639
629
621
308
602
601
607
609
Value
15 15.00
$1 080 30

BRIARWOOD DR

SITUS ADDRESS

CHERRYWOOD WAY

W RAVENSWOOD CT

E RAVENSWOOD CT

1.0 1.0

1.0 $72.02

72.02 72.02

Page 1 of 1 ends

Page 228 ends

City of Livingston
BAD - Kensington Park South
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
023-100-050-000
023-1 00-051-000
023-1 00-052-000
023-100-053-000
023-100-054-000
023-100-055-000
023-100-056-000
023-100-057-000
023-100-058-000
023-100-059-000
023-100-060-000
023-100-061-000
023-100-062-000
023-100-063-000
023-100-064-000
023-100-065-000
023-100-066-000
023-100-067-000
023-100-068-000
023-100-069-000
023-100-070-000
023-100-071-000
023-100-072-000
023-100-073-000
023-100-07 4-000
023-100-075-000
023-100-076-000
023-100-077-000
023-100-078-000
023-100-079-000
Summary Fields
Number of Parcels to be Levied
Total EDUs
Total-·
Willdan Financial Services
2797
2783
2769
2755
2741
2740
2754
2768
2782
2796
2775
2761
2747
2733
2719
2705
2691
2677
2663
2649
2648
2662
2676
2690
2704
2718
2732
2746
2760
2774
Value
30 30.00
$1 035.60

COLLEEN CT

CLARET CIR

1.0 1.0

1.0 1.0
$34.52

34.52 34.52

34.52

Page 1 of 1 ends

Page 229 ends

City of Livingston
BAD - Bridgeport
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
022-073-001-000
022-073-002-000
022-073-003-000
022-073-004-000
022-073-005-000
022-073-006-000
022-073-007-000
022-073-008-000
022-073-009-000
022-074-001-000
022-07 4-002-000
022-07 4-003-000
022-074-004-000
022-074-005-000
022-074-006-000
022-074-007-000
022-074-008-000
022-07 4-009-000
022-074-01 0-000
022-074-011-000
022-07 4-012-000
022-074-013-000
022-074-014-000
022-07 4-015-000
022-074-016-000
022-074-017-000
022-07 4-018-000
022-075-001-000
022-075-002-000
022-075-003-000
022-075-004-000
022-075-005-000
022-075-006-000
022-075-007-000
022-075-008-000
022-075-009-000
022-101-001-000
022-101-002-000
022-101-003-000
022-1 01-004-000
022-101-005-000
022-101-006-000
022-101-007-000
022-101-008-000
022-101-009-000
022-102-001-000
022-1 02-002-000
022-102-003-000
022-102-004-000
022-102-005-000
022-102-006-000
022-102-007-000
022-102-008-000
022-102-009-000
022-1 03-001-000
022-103-002-000
022-103-003-000
022-103-004-000
022-103-005-000
022-103-006-000
022-103-007-000
022-103-008-000
Willdan Financial Services
901
913
923
933
943
953
963
973
983
900
903
915
925
935
945
955
965
975
985
980
970
960
950
940
930
920
910
902
912
922
932
942
952
962
972
982
1033
1043
1053
1063
1073
1023
1013
1003
993
521
541
551
1015
1005
995
990
1000
1010
520
530
540
550
560
570
577
567

MISTY HARBOUR DR

BRIDGEPORT AVE

MISTY HARBOUR DR

BRIDGEPORT AVE

MISTY HARBOUR DR

SEAPORT VILLAGE DI

BRIDGEPORT AVE

MISTY HARBOUR DR

SEAPORT VILLAGE DI

MONT CLIFF WAY

1.0 1.0

1.0 1.0
$130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94

Page 1 of 2 ends

Page 230 ends

City of Livingston
BAD - Bridgeport
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
022-103-009-000
022-1 03-01 0-000
022-103-011-000
022-103-012-000
022-103-013-000
022-103-014-000
022-1 04-001-000
022-104-002-000
022-104-003-000
022-104-004-000
022-104-005-000
022-1 04-006-000
022-104-007-000
022-1 04-008-000
022-104-009-000
022-107-001-000
022-107-002-000
022-1 07 -003-000
022-107-004-000
022-107-005-000
Summarv Fields
Number of Parcels to be Levied
Total EDUs
_Total ~ .. n,
Willdan Financial Services
557
547
537
527
580
587
502
512
522
532
542
552
562
572
582
NO
1002
1012
1022
1032
Value
82 82.00
110 737.08

MONT CLIFF WAY

MONT CLIFF WAY
SEAPORT VILLAGE Df

MONT CLIFF WAY

SITUS ADDRESS

BRIDGEPORT AVE

1.0 1.0

1.0 1.0
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94

Page 2 of 2 ends

Page 231 ends

City of Livingston
BAD - Davante Villas
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
022-081-001-000
022-081-002-000
022-081-003-000
022-081-004-000
022-081-005-000
022-081-006-000
022-081-007-000
022-081-008-000
022-081-009-000
022-081-010-000
022-081-01 1-000
022-081-012-000
022-081-013-000
022-081-014-000
022-081-015-000
022-081-016-000
022-081-017-000
022-081-018-000
022-081-019-000
022-081-020-000
022-081-021-000
022-081-022-000
022-081-023-000
022-081-024-000
022-081-025-000
022-081-026-000
022-081-027-000
022-081-028-000
022-081-029-000
022-081-030-000
022-081-031-000
022-081-032-000
022-081-033-000
022-081-034-000
022-081-035-000
022-081-036-000
022-081-037-000
022-081 -038-000
022-081-039-000
022-081-040-000
022-081-041-000
022-081-042-000
022-081-043-000
022-081-044-000
022-081-045-000
022-081-046-000
022-081 -04 7-000
022-081-048-000
022-081-049-000
022-081-050-000
022-081-051-000
022-081-052-000
022-081-053-000
022-081-054-000
022-081-055-000
022-081-056-000
022-081-057-000
022-081-058-000
022-081-059-000
022-081-060-000
022-081-061-000
022-081-062-000
Willdan Financial Services
902 BRIARWOOD DR
912 BRIARWOOD DR
922 BRIARWOOD DR
938 BRIARWOOD DR
952 BRIARWOOD DR
951 DALLAS CT
935 DALLAS CT
925 DALLAS CT
915 DALLAS CT
903 DALLAS CT
902 DALLAS CT
912 DALLAS CT
922 DALLAS CT
938 DALLAS CT

NO SITUS ADDRESS
951 MONTELENA CT
935 MONTELENA CT
925 MONTELENA CT
915 MONTELENA CT
903 MONTELENA CT
902 MONTELENA CT
912 MONTELENA CT
922 MONTELENA CT
938 MONTELENA CT
952 MONTELENA CT
951 CHASTANET CT
935 CHASTANET CT
925 CHASTANET CT
915 CHASTANET CT
901 CHASTANET CT
902 CHASTANET CT
902 PATZER ST
912 PATZER ST
912 CHASTANET CT
922 CHASTANET CT
922 PATZER ST
938 PATZER ST
938 CHASTANET CT
954 PATZER ST
952 CHASTANET CT
964 PATZER ST
962 CHASTANET CT
978 PATZER ST
990 PATZER ST
888 VINE CLIFF WAY
876 VINE CLIFF WAY
864 VINE CLIFF WAY
852 VINE CLIFF WAY
840 VINE CLIFF WAY
839 CHANDON CT
851 CHANDON CT
863 CHANDON CT
875 CHANDON CT
887 CHANDON CT
893 CHANDON CT
897 CHANDON CT
898 CHANDON CT
894 CHANDON CT
888 CHANDON CT
876 CHANDON CT
864 CHANDON CT
----~-~85=2- CHANDON CT

1.0 1.0

1.0 1.0
$132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
....132.I 6

Page 1 of 3 ends

Page 232 ends

City of Livingston
BAD - Davante Villas
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
022-081-063-000
022-082-001-000
022-082-002-000
022-082-003-000
022-082-004-000
022-082-005-000
022-082-006-000
022-082-007-000
022-082-008-000
022-082-009-000
022-083-001-000
022-083-002-000
022-083-003-000
022-083-004-000
022-083-005-000
022-083-006-000
022-084-001-000
022-084-002-000
022-084-003-000
022-084-004-000
022-084-005-000
022-084-006-000
022-084-007-000
022-084-008-000
022-084-009-000
022-084-01 0-000
022-084-011-000
022-084-012-000
022-084-013-000
022-084-014-000
022-084-015-000
022-091-001-000
022-091-002-000
022-091-003-000
022-091-004-000
022-091-005-000
022-091-006-000
022-091-007-000
022-091-008-000
022-091-009-000
022-091-01 0-000
022-091-011-000
022-091-012-000
022-091-013-000
022-092-001-000
022-092-002-000
022-092-003-000
022-092-004-000
022-092-005-000
022-092-006-000
022-092-007-000
022-092-008-000
022-092-009-000
022-092-010-000
022-093-002-000
022-093-003-000
022-093-004-000
022-093-005-000
022-093-006-000
022-093-007-000
022-093-008-000
022-093-009-000
Willdan Financial Services
840 CHANDON CT
975 MONTELENA AVE

NO SITUS ADDRESS
995 MONTELENA AVE
1005 MONTELENA AVE
1015 MONTELENA AVE
1025 MONTELENA AVE
992 DALLAS DR
982 DALLAS DR
972 DALLAS DR
975 DALLAS DR
985 DALLAS DR
995 DALLAS DR
992 BRIARWOOD DR
982 BRIARWOOD DR
972 BRIARWOOD DR
656 F ST
668 F ST
903 BRIARWOOD DR
915 BRIARWOOD DR
925 BRIARWOOD DR
669 MIADORA CT
657 MIADORA CT
656 MIADORA CT
668 MIADORA CT
680 MIADORA CT
965 BRIARWOOD DR
975 BRIARWOOD DR
687 CALERO CT
669 CALERO CT
657 CALERO CT
1035 MONTELENA AVE
1045 MONTELENA AVE
1055 MONTELENA AVE
1065 MONTELENA AVE
1075 MONTELENA AVE
1072 DALLAS DR
1062 DALLAS DR
1052 DALLAS DR
1042 DALLAS DR
1032 DALLAS DR
1022 DALLAS DR
1012 DALLAS DR
1002 DALLAS DR
839 LATOUR WAY
851 LATOUR WAY
863 LATOUR WAY
875 LATOUR WAY
887 LATOUR WAY
893 LATOUR WAY
1042 AMARONE WAY
1052 AMARONE WAY
1062 AMARONE WAY
1072 AMARONE WAY

NO SITUS ADDRESS

NO SITUS ADDRESS
772 MONT CLIFF WAY
762 MONT CLIFF WAY
752 MONT CLIFF WAY
742 MONT CLIFF WAY
732 MONT CLIFF WAY
722 MONT CLIFF WAY

1.0 1.0

1.0 1.0
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76

Page 2 of 3 ends

Page 233 ends

City of Livingston
BAD - Davante Villas
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
022-093-010-000
022-094-001-000
022-094-002-000
022-094-003-000
022-094-004-000
022-094-005-000
022-094-006-000
022-094-007-000
022-095-001-000
022-095-002-000
022-095-003-000
022-095-004-000
022-095-005-000
022-095-006-000
022-095-007-000
022-095-008-000
022-095-009-000
022-095-010-000
022-095-011-000
022-095-012-000
022-095-013-000
022-095-014-000
022-095-015-000
022-095-016-000
022-096-001-000
022-096-002-000
022-096-003-000
022-096-004-000
022-096-005-000
Summarv Fields
Number of Parcels to be Levied
Total EDUs
Total,.,
Willdan Financial Services
712 MONT CLIFF WAY
656 CALERO CT
668 CALERO CT
1003 BRIARWOOD DR
1013 BRIARWOOD DR
1023 BRIARWOOD DR
669 SEAPORT VILLAGE DR
657 SEAPORT VILLAGE DR
1005 DALLAS DR
1015 DALLAS DR
1025 DALLAS DR
1035 DALLAS DR
1045 DALLAS DR
1055 DALLAS DR
1065 DALLAS DR
1075 DALLAS DR
1072 BRIARWOOD DR
1062 BRIARWOOD DR
1052 BRIARWOOD DR
1042 BRIARWOOD DR
1032 BRIARWOOD DR
1022 BRIARWOOD DR
1012 BRIARWOOD DR
1002 BRIARWOOD DR
656 SEAPORT VILLAGE DR
668 SEAPORT VILLAGE DR
1053 BRIARWOOD DR
1063 BRIARWOOD DR
1073 BRIARWOOD DR
Value
153
153.00
$20 312 28

1.0 1.0

1.0 132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76

Page 3 of 3 ends

Page 234 ends

City of Livingston
BAD-Strawberry Fields
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
022-096-006-000
022-096-007-000
022-097-001-000
022-097-002-000
022-097-003-000
022-097-004-000
Summarv Fields
Number of Parcels to be Levied
Total EDUs
Total-·
Willdan Financial Services
669
657
650
660
670
684
Value
6 6.00
$785.64

MONT CLIFF WAY

1.0 1.0

1.0 1.0
$130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94

Page 1 of 1 ends

Page 235 ends

City of Livingston
BAD - Sundance (Country Villas)
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
143-291-001-000 2881
143-291-002-000 2873
143-291-003-000 2865
143-291-004-000 2859
143-291-005-000 2849
143-291-006-000 2841
143-291-007-000 2835
143-291-008-000 2827
143-291-009-000 2825
143-291-010-000 2828
143-291-011-000 2836
143-291-012-000 2842
143-291-013-000 2850
143-291-014-000 2860
143-291-015-000 2866
143-291-016-000 2874
143-291-017-000 2882
143-291-018-000 2883
143-291-019-000 2875
143-291-020-000 2867
143-291-021-000 2861
143-291-022-000 2851
143-291-023-000 2843
143-291-024-000 2837
143-291-025-000 2829
143-291-026-000 2827
143-291-027-000 2830
143-291-028-000 2838
143-291-029-000 2844
143-291-030-000 2852
143-291-031-000 2862
143-291-032-000 2868
143-291-033-000 2876
143-291-034-000 2884
143-291-035-000 2885
143-291-036-000 2871
143-291-037-000 2861
143-291-038-000 2853
143-291-039-000 2845
143-291-040-000 2839
143-291-041-000 2831
143-291-042-000 2823
143-291-043-000 2817
143-292-001-000 549
143-293-001-000 548
143-293-002-000 551
143-294-001-000 550
143-294-002-000 549
143-295-001-000 2909
143-295-002-000 2917
143-295-003-000 2923
143-295-004-000 2931
143-295-005-000 2937
Willdan Financial Services

TULARE CT

TULARE ST

TULARE CT

TULARE ST

FRANQUETTE CT

TEHAMA DR

VINA CT

CHANDLER CT

ALDRICH AVE

TULARE ST

1.0 1.0

1.0 $129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28

Page 1 of 4 ends

Page 236 ends

City of Livingston
BAD - Sundance (Country Villas)
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
143-295-006-000 2945 TULARE ST 1.0 129.28
143-295-007-000 2953 TULARE ST 1.0 129.28
143-295-008-000 2959 TULARE ST 1.0 129.28
143-295-009-000 2965 TULARE ST 1.0 129.28
143-295-010-000 650 SERR AVE 1.0 129.28
143-295-011-000 644 SERR AVE 1.0 129.28
143-295-012-000 636 SERR AVE 1.0 129.28
143-295-013-000 630 SERR AVE 1.0 129.28
143-295-014-000 622 SERR AVE 1.0 129.28
143-295-015-000 616 SERR AVE 1.0 129.28
143-295-016-000 608 SERR AVE 1.0 129.28
143-295-017-000 602 SERR AVE 1.0 129.28
143-296-001-000 2910 TULARE ST 1.0 129.28
143-296-002-000 2911 FRANQUETTE ST 1.0 129.28
143-296-003-000 2919 FRANQUETTE ST 1.0 129.28
143-296-004-000 2925 FRANQUETTE ST 1.0 129.28
143-296-005-000 2933 FRANQUETTE ST 1.0 129.28
143-296-006-000 2941 FRANQUETTE ST 1.0 129.28
143-296-007-000 2949 FRANQUETTE ST 1.0 129.28
143-296-008-000 2955 FRANQUETTE ST 1.0 129.28
143-296-009-000 2954 TULARE ST 1.0 129.28
143-296-010-000 2946 TULARE ST 1.0 129.28
143-296-011-000 2938 TULARE ST 1.0 129.28
143-296-012-000 2932 TULARE ST 1.0 129.28
143-296-013-000 2924 TULARE ST 1.0 129.28
143-296-014-000 2918 TULARE ST 1.0 129.28
143-297-001-000 2912 FRANQUETTE ST 1.0 129.28
143-297-002-000 2913 TEHAMA DR 1.0 129.28
143-297-003-000 2921 TEHAMA DR 1.0 129.28
143-297-004-000 2927 TEHAMA DR 1.0 129.28
143-297-005-000 2935 TEHAMA DR 1.0 129.28
143-297-006-000 2943 TEHAMA DR 1.0 129.28
143-297-008-000 2957 TEHAMA DR 1.0 129.28
143-297-009-000 2956 FRANQUETTE ST 1.0 129.28
143-297-010-000 2948 FRANQUETTE ST 1.0 129.28
143-297-011-000 2940 FRANQUETTE ST 1.0 129.28
143-297-012-000 2932 FRANQUETTE ST 1.0 129.28
143-297-013-000 2922 FRANQUETTE ST 1.0 129.28
143-297-014-000 2918 FRANQUETTE ST 1.0 129.28
143-298-001-000 548 ALDRICH AVE 1.0 129.28
143-298-002-000 551 SAUBER CT 1.0 129.28
143-299-001-000 550 SAUBER CT 1.0 129.28
143-301-001-000 548 SERR CT 1.0 129.28
143-301-002-000 542 SERR CT 1.0 129.28
143-301-003-000 536 SERR CT 1.0 129.28
143-301-004-000 NO SITUS ADDRESS 1.0 129.28
143-301-005-000 524 SERR CT 1.0 129.28
143-301-006-000 NO SITUS ADDRESS 1.0 129.28
143-301-007 -000 512 SERR CT 1.0 129.28
143-301-008-000 506 SERR CT 1.0 129.28
143-301-009-000 500 SERR CT 1.0 129.28
143-301-01 0-000 501 SERR CT 1.0 129.28
143-301-011-000 507 SERR CT 1.0 129.28
Willdan Financial Services Page 2 of 4

Page 237 ends

City of Livingston
BAD - Sundance (Country Villas)
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
143-301-012-000 513
143-301-013-000 519
143-301-014-000 525
143-301-015-000 NO
143-301-016-000 537
143-301-017-000 543
143-301-018-000 549
143-301-019-000 542
143-301-020-000 536
143-301-021-000 530
143-301-022-000 524
143-301-023-000 518
143-301-024-000 512
143-301-025-000 506
143-301-026-000 500
143-301-027-000 501
143-301-028-000 507
143-301-029-000 513
143-301-030-000 519
143-301-031-000 525
143-301-032-000 531
143-301-033-000 537
143-301-034-000 543
143-301-035-000 542
143-301-036-000 536
143-301-03 7-000 530
143-301-038-000 524
143-301-039-000 518
143-301-040-000 512
143-301-041-000 506
143-301-042-000 502
143-301-043-000 500
143-302-044-000 501
143-302-045-000 503
143-302-046-000 507
143-302-04 7-000 513
143-302-048-000 519
143-302-049-000 525
143-302-050-000 531
143-302-051-000 537
143-302-052-000 543
143-302-053-000 542
143-302-054-000 536
143-302-055-000 530
143-302-056-000 524
143-302-057-000 518
143-302-058-000 NO
143-302-059-000 NO
143-302-060-000 500
143-302-061-000 NO
143-302-062-000 NO
143-302-063-000 513
143-302-064-000 NO
Willdan Financial Services

SERR CT

SITUS ADDRESS

SERR CT

SAUBER CT

ALDRICH AVE

CHANDLER CT

SITUS ADDRESS

CHANDLER CT

SITUS ADDRESS

CHANDLER CT

SITUS ADDRESS

1.0 1.0

1.0 129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28
129.28

Page 3 of 4 ends

Page 238 ends

City of Livingston
BAD - Sundance (Country Villas)
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
143-302-065-000 NO SITUS ADDRESS 1.0 129.28
143-302-066-000 531 CHANDLER CT 1.0 129.28
143-302-067-000 537 CHANDLER CT 1.0 129.28
143-302-068-000 548 CHANDLER CT 1.0 129.28
143-302-069-000 NO SITUS ADDRESS 1.0 129.28
143-302-070-000 536 VINA CT 1.0 129.28
143-302-071-000 NO SITUS ADDRESS 1.0 129.28
143-302-072-000 524 VINA CT 1.0 129.28
143-302-073-000 518 VINA CT 1.0 129.28
143-302-07 4-000 512 VINA CT 1.0 129.28
143-302-075-000 506 VINA CT 1.0 129.28
143-302-076-000 500 VINA CT 1.0 129.28
143-302-077-000 501 VINA CT 1.0 129.28
143-302-078-000 507 VINA CT 1.0 129.28
143-302-079-000 513 VINA CT 1.0 129.28
143-302-080-000 519 VINA CT 1.0 129.28
143-302-081-000 525 VINA CT 1.0 129.28
143-302-082-000 NO SITUS ADDRESS 1.0 129.28
143-302-083-000 537 VINA CT 1.0 129.28
143-302-084-000 543 VINA CT 1.0 129.28
Summary Fields Value
Number of Parcels to be Levied 179
Total EDUs 179.00
Total Charges $23,141.12
Willdan Financial Seivices Page 4 of 4

Page 239 ends

City of Livingston
BAD- Sundance IV
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
143-311-001-000
143-311-002-000
143-311-003-000
143-311-004-000
143-311-005-000
143-311-006-000
143-311-007-000
143-311-008-000
143-311-009-000
143-311-010-000
143-312-001-000
143-312-002-000
143-312-003-000
143-312-004-000
143-312-005-000
143-313-001-000
143-313-002-000
143-313-003-000
143-313-004-000
143-313-005-000
143-313-006-000
143-313-007-000
143-313-008-000
143-313-009-000
143-313-010-000
143-314-001-000
143-314-002-000
143-314-003-000
143-314-004-000
143-314-005-000
143-314-006-000
143-314-007-000
143-314-008-000
143-314-009-000
143-314-010-000
143-315-001-000
143-315-002-000
143-315-003-000
143-315-004-000
143-315-005-000
143-315-006-000
143-315-007-000
143-315-008-000
143-315-009-000
143-315-01 0-000
143-316-001-000
143-316-002-000
143-316-003-000
143-316-004-000
143-316-005-000
143-316-006-000
143-316-007-000
143-316-008-000
143-316-009-000
143-316-010-000
143-316-011-000
143-316-012-000
143-316-013-000
143-316-014-000
143-316-015-000
143-316-016-000
143-316-017-000
Willdan Financial Services
2817
2823
2831
2839
2845
2853
2861
2871
2885
2895
425
437
449
461
473
425
437
449
461
473
472
460
448
436
424
425
437
449
461
473
472
460
448
436
424
2816
2822
2830
2838
2844
2852
2860
2870
2884
2894
2913
2921
2927
2935
2943
2949
2957
2965
2973
2981
2989
2997
412
424
436
448
460

TRIGGERLN

TRIGGER LN

TRIGGERLN

TRIGGER LN

TRIGGERLN

EVANS LN

SUNDANCE ST

EVANS LN

ALDRICH AVE

SUNDANCE ST

AUTRY LN

AUTRYLN

AUTRY LN

AUTRYLN

AUTRY LN

AUTRYLN

AUTRY LN

TRIGGER LN

TRIGGERLN

TRIGGER LN

TRIGGERLN

ROGERS AVE

1.0 1.0

Page 1 of 2 ends

Page 240 ends

City of Livingston
BAD- Sundance IV
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
143-316-018-000 472 ROGERS AVE 1.0 130.94
143-316-019-000 480 ROGERS AVE 1.0 130.94
143-316-020-000 488 ROGERS AVE 1.0 130.94
143-316-021-000 496 ROGERS AVE 1.0 130.94
143-317-001-000 424 ALDRICH AVE 1.0 130.94
143-317-002-000 2924 TRIGGER LN 1.0 130.94
143-317-003-000 2930 TRIGGER LN 1.0 130.94
143-317-004-000 2938 TRIGGER LN 1.0 130.94
143-317 -005-000 2946 TRIGGERLN 1.0 130.94
143-317-006-000 2952 TRIGGERLN 1.0 130.94
143-317-007-000 2960 TRIGGERLN 1.0 130.94
143-317-008-000 2968 TRIGGER LN 1.0 130.94
143-317-009-000 2978 TRIGGERLN 1.0 130.94
143-317-010-000 2979 SILVER LN 1.0 130.94
143-317-011-000 2969 SILVER LN 1.0 130.94
143-317-012-000 2961 SILVER LN 1.0 130.94
143-317-013-000 2953 SILVER LN 1.0 130.94
143-317-014-000 2947 SILVER LN 1.0 130.94
143-317-015-000 2939 SILVERLN 1.0 130.94
143-317-016-000 2931 SILVER LN 1.0 130.94
143-317-017-000 2925 SILVER LN 1.0 130.94
143-317-018-000 448 ALDRICH AVE 1.0 130.94
143-317-019-000 436 ALDRICH AVE 1.0 130.94
143-318-001-000 473 WYATT EARP CT 1.0 130.94
143-318-002-000 485 WYATT EARP CT 1.0 130.94
143-318-003-000 497 WYATT EARP CT 1.0 130.94
143-318-004-000 496 WYATT EARP CT 1.0 130.94
143-318-005-000 484 WYATT EARP CT 1.0 130.94
143-318-006-000 472 WYATT EARP CT 1.0 130.94
143-318-007-000 473 CISCO CT 1.0 130.94
143-318-008-000 485 CISCO CT 1.0 130.94
143-318-009-000 497 CISCO CT 1.0 130.94
143-318-010-000 496 CISCO CT 1.0 130.94
143-318-011-000 484 CISCO CT 1.0 130.94
143-318-012-000 472 CISCO CT 1.0 130.94
Summarv Fields Value
Number of Parcels to be Levied 97
Total EDUs 97.00 Tntal CharnA"' Si12 701.18
Willdan Financial Services Page 2 of 2

Page 241 ends

City of Livingston
BAD-Parkside
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
022-062-005-000 377 TASHIMA DR 1.0 $130.94
022-062-006-000 371 TASHIMA DR 1.0 130.94
022-062-007-000 363 TASHIMA DR 1.0 130.94
022-062-008-000 355 TASHIMA DR 1.0 130.94
022-062-009-000 343 TASHIMA CT 1.0 130.94
022-062-010-000 335 TASHIMA CT 1.0 130.94
022-062-011-000 NO SITUS ADDRESS 1.0 130.94
022-062-012-000 321 TASHIMA DR 1.0 130.94
022-062-013-000 1012 PARADISE DR 1.0 130.94
022-062-014-000 322 PARADISE DR 1.0 130.94
022-062-015-000 328 PARADISE DR 1.0 130.94
022-062-016-000 334 PARADISE DR 1.0 130.94
022-067-007-000 301 PARADISE DR 1.0 130.94
022-067-008-000 307 PARADISE DR 1.0 130.94
022-067-009-000 315 PARADISE DR 1.0 130.94
022-067-010-000 951 DOSANGH CT 1.0 130.94
022-067-011-000 939 DOSANGHCT 1.0 130.94
022-067-012-000 923 DOSANGHCT 1.0 130.94
022-067-013-000 310 DOSANGHCT 1.0 130.94
022-067-014-000 308 DOSANGHCT 1.0 130.94
022-067-015-000 300 DOSANGH CT 1.0 130.94
022-067-016-000 301 DOSANGH CT 1.0 130.94
022-067-017-000 307 DOSANGH CT 1.0 130.94
022-067-018-000 315 DOSANGH CT 1.0 130.94
022-067-019-000 323 DOSANGH CT 1.0 130.94
022-067-020-000 329 DOSANGHCT 1.0 130.94
022-067-021-000 335 DOSANGH CT 1.0 130.94
022-067-022-000 912 DOSANGH CT 1.0 130.94
022-067-023-000 924 DOSANGH CT 1.0 130.94
022-067-024-000 938 DOSANGHCT 1.0 130.94
022-067-025-000 950 DOSANGHCT 1.0 130.94
022-068-004-000 1085 FERNWOOD WAY 1.0 130.94
022-068-005-000 1067 FERNWOOD WAY 1.0 130.94
022-068-006-000 1049 FERNWOOD WAY 1.0 130.94
022-068-007-000 1031 FERNWOOD WAY 1.0 130.94
022-068-008-000 1013 FERNWOOD WAY 1.0 130.94
022-069-001-000 320 TASHIMA DR 1.0 130.94
022-069-002-000 328 TASHIMA DR 1.0 130.94
022-069-003-000 336 TASHIMA DR 1.0 130.94
022-069-004-000 344 TASHIMA DR 1.0 130.94
022-069-005-000 354 TASHIMA DR 1.0 130.94
022-069-006-000 362 TASHIMA DR 1.0 130.94
022-069-007-000 368 TASHIMA DR 1.0 130.94
022-069-008-000 376 TASHIMA DR 1.0 130.94
022-105-002-000 407 TASHIMA CT 1.0 130.94
022-105-003-000 419 TASHIMA CT 1.0 130.94
022-105-004-000 429 TASHIMA CT 1.0 130.94
022-105-005-000 437 TASHIMA CT 1.0 130.94
022-105-006-000 447 TASHIMA CT 1.0 130.94
022-105-007-000 457 TASHIMA CT 1.0 130.94
022-105-008-000 469 TASHIMA CT 1.0 130.94
022-105-009-000 454 TASHIMA CT 1.0 130.94
022-105-010-000 444 TASHIMA CT 1.0 130.94
Willdan Financial Services Page 1 of 4

Page 242 ends

City of Livingston
BAD-Parkside
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
022-105-011-000 436
022-105-012-000 428
022-105-013-000 418
022-105-014-000 406
022-1 05-015-000 398
022-105-016-000 390
022-108-001-000 385
022-108-002-000 393
022-111-001-000 1103
022-111-002-000 1125
022-111-003-000 1147
022-111-004-000 1169
022-111-005-000 1191
022-111-006-000 1213
022-112-001-000 321
022-112-002-000 327
022-112-003-000 335
022-112-004-000 343
022-112-005-000 353
022-112-006-000 359
022-112-007-000 369
022-112-008-000 375
022-113-001-000 1169
022-113-002-000 1191
022-113-003-000 1213
022-113-004-000 1210
022-113-005-000 1190
022-113-006-000 1168
022-114-001-000 350
022-114-002-000 358
022-114-003-000 360
022-114-004-000 376
022-114-005-000 1201
022-114-006-000 1200
022-121-001-000 1235
022-121-002-000 1257
022-122-002-000 1301
022-122-003-000 1323
022-122-004-000 1345
022-122-005-000 1367
022-122-006-000 1389
022-122-007-000 1401
022-122-008-000 1423
022-122-009-000 308
022-122-010-000 316
022-122-011-000 324
022-122-012-000 334
022-122-013-000 340
022-122-014-000 346
022-122-015-000 354
022-123-001-000 1235
022-123-002-000 1257
022-123-003-000 1256
Willdan Financial Services

TASHIMA CT

TASHIMA DR

FERNWOOD WAY

JASMINE LN

VINEMAPLE WAY

FERNWOOD WAY

JASMINE LN

PARKSIDE WAY

VINEMAPLE WAY

FERNWOOD WAY

KENSINGTON DR

VINEMAPLE WAY

FERNWOOD WAY

1.0 1.0

1.0 130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94
130.94

Page 2 of 4 ends

Page 243 ends

City of Livingston
BAD-Parkside
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
022-123--004--000 1234 FERNWOOD WAY 1.0 130.94
022-124--001--000 353 LILAC LN 1.0 130.94
022-124--002--000 359 LILAC LN 1.0 130.94
022-124--003-000 369 LILAC LN 1.0 130.94
022-124--004--000 375 LILAC LN 1.0 130.94
022-125--001--000 321 MANDARIN CT 1.0 130.94
022-125--002--000 343 KENSINGTON DR 1.0 130.94
022-125--003-000 351 KENSINGTON DR 1.0 130.94
022-125--004-000 355 KENSINGTON DR 1.0 130.94
022-125--005--000 367 KENSINGTON DR 1.0 130.94
022-125--006--000 373 KENSINGTON DR 1.0 130.94
022-125--007--000 327 MANDARIN CT 1.0 130.94
022-125--008--000 335 MANDARIN CT 1.0 130.94
022-125--009--000 343 MANDARIN CT 1.0 130.94
022-125--010--000 351 MANDARIN CT 1.0 130.94
022-125--011--000 355 MANDARIN CT 1.0 130.94
022-125--012--000 367 MANDARIN CT 1.0 130.94
022-125--013--000 373 MANDARIN CT 1.0 130.94
022-125--014--000 374 MANDARIN CT 1.0 130.94
022-125--015--000 368 MANDARIN CT 1.0 130.94
022-125-016--000 356 MANDARIN CT 1.0 130.94
022-125--017--000 352 MANDARIN CT 1.0 130.94
022-125--018--000 344 MANDARIN CT 1.0 130.94
022-125--019--000 336 MANDARIN CT 1.0 130.94
022-125--020--000 328 MANDARIN CT 1.0 130.94
022-125--021--000 320 MANDARIN CT 1.0 130.94
022-125--022--000 321 KENSINGTON DR 1.0 130.94
022-125--023--000 327 KENSINGTON DR 1.0 130.94
022-125--024--000 335 KENSINGTON DR 1.0 130.94
022-126--001--000 1444 PINECREST DR 1.0 130.94
022-171--001-000 1697 VIEIRA ST 1.0 130.94
022-171--002--000 1675 VIEIRA ST 1.0 130.94
022-171--003--000 1653 VIEIRA ST 1.0 130.94
022-171--004--000 1629 VIEIRA ST 1.0 130.94
022-171--005--000 1607 VIEIRA ST 1.0 130.94
022-171--006--000 1597 VIEIRA ST 1.0 130.94
022-171--007--000 1587 VIEIRA ST 1.0 130.94
022-171--008--000 1575 VIEIRA ST 1.0 130.94
022-171--009-000 1543 VIEIRA ST 1.0 130.94
022-171--010--000 1515 VIEIRA ST 1.0 130.94
022-171--011--000 307 LIVE OAK WAY 1.0 130.94
022-171--012--000 315 LIVE OAK WAY 1.0 130.94
022-171--013--000 323 LIVEOAK WAY 1.0 130.94
022-171--014--000 333 LIVEOAK WAY 1.0 130.94
022-171--015--000 339 LIVEOAK WAY 1.0 130.94
022-171--016-000 345 LIVEOAK WAY 1.0 130.94
022-171--017-000 353 LIVE OAK WAY 1.0 130.94
022-172--001-000 320 LIVE OAK WAY 1.0 130.94
022-172--002--000 328 LIVE OAK WAY 1.0 130.94
022-172-003-000 336 LIVE OAK WAY 1.0 130.94
022-172-004-000 344 LIVE OAK WAY 1.0 130.94
022-172--005--000 354 LIVEOAK WAY 1.0 130.94
022-172--006--000 353 REDWOOD WAY 1.0 130.94
Willdan Financial Services Page 3 of 4

Page 244 ends

City of Livingston
BAD-Parkside
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
022-172-007-000 343 REDWOOD WAY 1.0 130.94
022-172-008-000 335 REDWOOD WAY 1.0 130.94
022-172-009-000 327 REDWOOD WAY 1.0 130.94
022-172-010-000 321 REDWOOD WAY 1.0 130.94
022-173-001-000 1466 PINECREST DR 1.0 130.94
022-173-002-000 1488 PINECREST DR 1.0 130.94
022-173-003-000 1516 PINECREST DR 1.0 130.94
022-173-004-000 1544 PINECREST DR 1.0 130.94
022-173-005-000 1576 PINECREST DR 1.0 130.94
022-173-006-000 1588 PINECREST DR 1.0 130.94
022-173-007-000 1598 PINECREST DR 1.0 130.94
022-173-008-000 368 REDWOOD WAY 1.0 130.94
022-173-009-000 360 REDWOOD WAY 1.0 130.94
022-173-010-000 352 REDWOOD WAY 1.0 130.94
022-173-011-000 331 PEACH AVE 1.0 130.94
022-173-012-000 1656 SPRUCE CT 1.0 130.94
022-173-013-000 1697 SPRUCE CT 1.0 130.94
022-173-014-000 1675 SPRUCE CT 1.0 130.94
022-173-015-000 1653 SPRUCE CT 1.0 130.94
022-173-016-000 1629 SPRUCE CT 1.0 130.94
022-173-017-000 1607 SPRUCE CT 1.0 130.94
022-173-018-000 1608 VIEIRA ST 1.0 130.94
022-173-019-000 1632 VIEIRA ST 1.0 130.94
022-173-020-000 1656 VIEIRA ST 1.0 130.94
022-173-021-000 1676 VIEIRA ST 1.0 130.94
022-173-022-000 1698 VIEIRA ST 1.0 130.94
Summary Fields Value
Number of Parcels to be Levied 185
Total EDUs 185.00
Total Charaes $24,223.90
Willdan Financial Services Page 4 of 4

Page 245 ends

City of Livingston
BAD- Country Lane I ( Liberty Square)
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
023--034--001-000 2133 ASPENGLEN WAY 1.0 $132.76
023--034--002-000 2143 ASPENGLEN WAY 1.0 132.76
023--034--003-000 2153 ASPENGLEN WAY 1.0 132.76
023-034--004-000 2163 ASPENGLEN WAY 1.0 132.76
023--034--005-000 2173 ASPENGLEN WAY 1.0 132.76
023--034--006-000 2183 ASPENGLEN WAY 1.0 132.76
023--034--007-000 2193 ASPENGLEN WAY 1.0 132.76
023--034--008--000 2203 ASPENGLEN WAY 1.0 132.76
023--034--009-000 2213 ASPENGLEN WAY 1.0 132.76
023--034--010--000 2223 ASPENGLEN WAY 1.0 132.76
023--035--001--000 2130 ASPENGLEN WAY 1.0 132.76
023--035--002-000 2140 ASPENGLEN WAY 1.0 132.76
023--035--003-000 2150 ASPENGLEN WAY 1.0 132.76
023--035--004-000 2160 ASPENGLEN WAY 1.0 132.76
023--035--005-000 2170 ASPENGLEN WAY 1.0 132.76
023--035--006--000 899 JORDONOLLA WAY 1.0 132.76
023--035--007-000 889 JORDONOLLA WAY 1.0 132.76
023--035--008-000 877 JORDONOLLA WAY 1.0 132.76
023--035--009-000 867 JORDONOLLA WAY 1.0 132.76
023-035--010-000 855 JORDONOLLA WAY 1.0 132.76
023--035--011-000 845 JORDONOLLA WAY 1.0 132.76
023--035--012-000 2193 KAPREIL WAY 1.0 132.76
023--035--013-000 2183 KAPREILWAY 1.0 132.76
023--035--014-000 2173 KAPREIL WAY 1.0 132.76
023-035--015-000 2163 KAPREIL WAY 1.0 132.76
023--035--016-000 2153 KAPREIL WAY 1.0 132.76
023--035--017-000 2143 KAPREILWAY 1.0 132.76
023--035--018-000 2133 KAPREIL WAY 1.0 132.76
023--035--019-000 2130 KARINA LAU CT 1.0 132.76
023--035--020-000 2140 KARINA LAU CT 1.0 132.76
023--035--021--000 2150 KARINA LAU CT 1.0 132.76
023--035--022--000 2160 KARINA LAU CT 1.0 132.76
023--035--023--000 2170 KARINA LAU CT 1.0 132.76
023--035--024-000 2173 KARINA LAU CT 1.0 132.76
023--035-025--000 2163 KARINA LAU CT 1.0 132.76
023--035--026-000 2153 KARINA LAU CT 1.0 132.76
023--035-027-000 2143 KARINA LAU CT 1.0 132.76
023--035--028--000 2133 KARINA LAU CT 1.0 132.76
023--036--001--000 898 JORDONOLLA WAY 1.0 132.76
023--036--002--000 888 JORDONOLLA WAY 1.0 132.76
023--036--003-000 878 JORDONOLLA WAY 1.0 132.76
023--036--004--000 868 JORDONOLLA WAY 1.0 132.76
023--036--005-000 856 JORDONOLLA WAY 1.0 132.76
023--036-006--000 846 JORDONOLLA WAY 1.0 132.76
023--036-007-000 834 JORDONOLLA WAY 1.0 132.76
023--036--008-000 824 JORDONOLLA WAY 1.0 132.76
023-043--001-000 2130 KAPREIL WAY 1.0 132.76
023-043--002-000 2140 KAPREILWAY 1.0 132.76
023--043--003--000 2150 KAPREIL WAY 1.0 132.76
023--043--004--000 2160 KAPREILWAY 1.0 132.76
023-043-005--000 2170 KAPREIL WAY 1.0 132.76
023--043--006-000 2180 KAPREIL WAY 1.0 132.76
023-043--007-000 2190 KAPREILWAY 1.0 132.76
023-043--008-000 2200 KAPREILWAY 1.0 132.76
Willdan Financial Services Page 1 of 2

Page 246 ends

City of Livingston
BAD- Country Lane I ( Liberty Square)
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
023-043-009-000
023-043-010-000
Summary Fields
Number of Parcels to be Levied
Total EDUs
Total Charges
Willdan Financial Services
2210
814
Value
56 56.00
$7,434.56

KAPREIL WAY

JORDONOLLA WAY

1.0 1.0
132.76
132.76

Page 2 of 2 ends

Page 247 ends

City of Livingston
BAD- Country Lane II (Country Lane)
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
Willdan Financial Services
023-01 1-001-000
023-011-002-000
023-011-003-000
023-01 1-004-000
023-01 1-005-000
023-01 1-006-000
023-011-007-000
023-011-008-000
023-011-009-000
023-011-01 0-000
023-011-011-000
023-011-012-000
023-011-013-000
023-011-014-000
023-011-015-000
023-011-016-000
023-012-001-000
023-012-002-000
023-012-003-000
023-012-004-000
023-012-005-000
023-012-006-000
023-012-007-000
023-012-008-000
023-012-009-000
023-012-010-000
023-012-011-000
023-012-012-000
023-012-013-000
023-012-014-000
023-013-001-000
023-013-002-000
023-013-003-000
023-013-004-000
023-013-005-000
023-013-006-000
023-013-007-000
023-014-001-000
023-014-002-000
023-014-003-000
023-014-004-000
023-014-005-000
023-014-006-000
023-014-007-000
023-014-008-000
023-014-009-000
023-015-001-000
023-015-002-000
023-015-003-000
023-015-004-000
023-015-005-000
023-015-006-000
023-015-007-000
023-015-008-000
023-015-009-000
023-015-010-000
023-015-011-000
2085
2075
2065
2055
2047
2035
2025
1157
1141
1127
11 13
1101
1085
1071
1059
1045
11 38
1137
1125
1113
1097
1079
1065
1047
1064
1064
1078
1098
1112
1126
1138
1126
1112
1098
1078
1064
1048
2123
2133
2143
2153
2163
2173
2183
2193
2201
2124
2134
2144
2154
2164
2174
2184
1137
1127
1115
2183

KISHI DR

NARADAWAY

SHOJI CT

NARADAWAY

SHOJI CT

KISHI DR

OHKI ST

KINOSHITA CT

1.0 1.0

1.0 $ 132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76 ·
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76
132.76

Page 1 of 3 ends

Page 248 ends

City of Livingston
BAD- Country Lane II (Country Lane)
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
023-015-012-000 2173 KINOSHITA CT 1.0 132.76
023-015-013-000 2163 KINOSHITA CT 1.0 132.76
023-015-014-000 2153 KINOSHITA CT 1.0 132.76
023-015-015-000 2143 KINOSHITA CT 1.0 132.76
023-015-016-000 2133 KINOSHITA CT 1.0 132.76
023-015-017-000 2123 KINOSHITA CT 1.0 132.76
023-015-019-000 2126 KINOSHITA CT 1.0 132.76
023-015-020-000 2142 KINOSHITA CT 1.0 132.76
023-015-021-000 2154 KINOSHITA CT 1.0 132.76
023-015-022-000 2164 KINOSHITA CT 1.0 132.76
023-015-023-000 2174 KINOSHITA CT 1.0 132.76
023-015-024-000 2184 KINOSHITA CT 1.0 132.76
023-015-025-000 1079 OHKI ST 1.0 132.76
023-015-026-000 1065 OHKI ST 1.0 132.76
023-015-027-000 1047 OHKI ST 1.0 132.76
023-015-028-000 2183 WAKAMI DR 1.0 132.76
023-015-029-000 2173 WAKAMIDR 1.0 132.76
023-015-030-000 2163 WAKAMI DR 1.0 132.76
023-015-031-000 2153 WAKAMI DR 1.0 132.76
023-015-032-000 2143 WAKAMIDR 1.0 132.76
023-015-033-000 2133 WAKAMI DR 1.0 132.76
023-016-002-000 1148 OHKI ST 1.0 132.76
023-016-003-000 1136 OHKI ST 1.0 132.76
023-016-004-000 1124 OHKI ST 1.0 132.76
023-016-005-000 1112 OHKI ST 1.0 132.76
023-016-006-000 1098 OHKI ST 1.0 132.76
023-016-007-000 1078 OHKI ST 1.0 132.76
023-016-008-000 1064 OHKI ST 1.0 132.76
023-016-009-000 1048 OHKI ST 1.0 132.76
023-021-001-000 1033 NARADAWAY 1.0 132.76
023-021-002-000 1019 NARADAWAY 1.0 132.76
023-021-003-000 1007 NARADAWAY 1.0 132.76
023-021-004-000 999 NARADAWAY 1.0 132.76
023-021-005-000 977 NARADAWAY 1.0 132.76
023-021-006-000 965 NARADAWAY 1.0 132.76
023-021-007-000 955 NARADAWAY 1.0 132.76
023-021-008-000 945 NARADAWAY 1.0 132.76
023-022-001-000 935 NARADAWAY 1.0 132.76
023-023-001-000 1048 NARADAWAY 1.0 132.76
023-023-002-000 1020 NARADAWAY 1.0 132.76
023-023-003-000 2035 WAKAMI DR 1.0 132.76
023-023-004-000 2047 WAKAMIDR 1.0 132.76
023-023-005-000 2055 WAKAMI DR 1.0 132.76
023-023-006-000 2065 WAKAMI DR 1.0 132.76
023-023-007-000 2089 WAKAMI DR 1.0 132.76
023-023-008-000 2109 WAKAMIDR 1.0 132.76
023-023-009-000 2123 WAKAMI DR 1.0 132.76
023-023-010-000 1028 WILLOW BROOK CT 1.0 132.76
023-023-011-000 1019 WILLOW BROOK CT 1.0 132.76
023-023-012-000 1035 WILLOW BROOK CT 1.0 132.76
023-024-001-000 2034 WAKAMI DR 1.0 132.76
023-024-002-000 1030 NARADAWAY 1.0 132.76
023-024-003-000 2054 WAKAMIDR 1.0 132.76
023-024-004-000 2064 WAKAMI DR 1.0 132.76
023-024-005-000 2086 WAKAMI DR 1.0 132.76
023-024-006-000 2100 WAKAMI DR 1.0 132.76
023-024-007-000 2114 WAKAMI DR 1.0 132.76
Willdan Financial Services Page 2 of 3

Page 249 ends

City of Livingston
BAD- Country Lane II (Country Lane)
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
023-024-008-000
023-024-009-000
023-024-010-000
023-024-011-000
023-024-012-000
023-024-013-000
023-024-014-000
023-024-015-000
023-024-016-000
023-025-001-000
023-025-002-000
023-025-003-000
023-025-004-000
023-025-005-000
023-025-006-000
023-025-007-000
023-025-008-000
023-026-001-000
023-026-002-000
023-026-003-000
023-026-004-000
023-026-005-000
023-026-006-000
023-026-007-000
023-026-008-000
023-026-009-000
023-026-010-000
023-026-011-000
023-026-012-000
023-026-013-000
023-027-001-000
023-027-002-000
023-027-003-000
023-027-004-000
023-027-005-000
023-027-006-000
023-027-007-000
023-027-008-000
023-027 -009-000
023-027-010-000
023-027-011-000
023-027-012-000
023-027-013-000
Summary Flelds
Number of Parcels to be Levied
Total EDUs
Total Charges
Willdan Financial Services
2126
2123
2111
2099
2085
2065
2055
2047
2035
2034
2046
2054
2064
2086
2100
2114
2126
1009
2184
2194
2204
2214
2224
2223
2213
2203
2193
2183
986
994
999
989
983
975
965
955
941
931
932
942
954
964
974
Value
157
157.00
$20,843.32

WAKAMIDR

GRAPEVINE DR

MORI CT

WAKAMIDR

WAKAMI DR

NATSU RD

MORI CT

1.0 132.76

Page 3 of 3 ends

Page 250 ends

City of Livingston
BAD- La Tierra
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
Willdan Financial Services
022-064-001-000
022-064-002-000
022-064-003-000
022-064-004-000
022-064-005-000
022-064-006-000
022-064-007-000
022-064-008-000
022-064-009-000
022-064-010-000
022-064-011-000
022-064-012-000
022-064-013-000
022-064-014-000
022-064-015-000
022-065-001-000
022-065-002-000
022-065-003-000
022-065-004-000
022-065-005-000
022-065-006-000
022-065-007-000
022-065-008-000
022-066-001-000
022-066-002-000
022-066-003-000
022-066-004-000
022-066-005-000
022-066-006-000
022-066-007-000
022-066-008-000
022-067-001-000
022-067-002-000
022-067-003-000
022-067-004-000
022-067-005-000
022-067-006-000
022-068-001-000
022-068-002-000
022-068-003-000
022-111-007-000
022-111-008-000
022-111-009-000
022-111-010-000
022-111-011-000
022-111-012-000
022-111-013-000
022-111-014-000
022-111-015-000
022-115-001-000
022-115-002-000
022-115-003-000
022-115-004-000
022-115-005-000
022-115-006-000
022-115-007-000
022-115-008-000
022-115-009-000
022-115-010-000
022-115-011-000
022-115-012-000
022-115-013-000
253
247
241
235
229
915
931
947
963
979
995
1013
1031
1049
1067
232
240
246
252
253
247
241
235
232
240
246
252
253
247
241
235
916
932
948
964
980
994
1020
1040
1060
1256
1234
1208
1184
1164
1144
1124
1104
1080
1085
1103
1125
1133
1147
1169
1181
1191
1192
1180
1168
1144
1130

MADRID WAY

TALARADR

MADRID WAY

PARADISE DR

MERIDA WAY

BARCELONA DR

TALARADR

TALARADR
TALARA D~R,_ __ _

1.0 1.0

Page 1 of 2 ends

Page 251 ends

City of Livingston
BAD- La Tierra
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
022-115-014-000 232 MERIDA WAY 1.0 130.94
022-115-015-000 240 MERIDA WAY 1.0 130.94
022-115-016-000 246 MERIDA WAY 1.0 130.94
022-115-017-000 252 MERIDA WAY 1.0 130.94
022-115-018-000 1139 BARCELONA DR 1.0 130.94
022-115-019-000 1159 BARCELONA DR 1.0 130.94
022-115-020-000 1179 BARCELONA DR 1.0 130.94
022-115-021-000 1199 BARCELONA DR 1.0 130.94
022-115-022-000 1215 BARCELONA DR 1.0 130.94
022-115-023-000 253 LILAC LN 1.0 130.94
022-115-024-000 247 LILAC LN 1.0 130.94
022-115-025-000 241 LILAC LN 1.0 130.94
022-115-026-000 235 LILAC LN 1.0 130.94
022-115-027-000 225 LILAC LN 1.0 130.94
022-115-028-000 215 LILAC LN 1.0 130.94
Summarv Fields Value
Number of Parcels to be Levied 77
Total EDUs 77.00 Tn•~• "M~ $10 082.38
Willdan Financial Services Page 2 of 2

Page 252 ends

City of Livingston
BAD-Somerset
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
047-581-001-000 1702 SUN VALLEY AVE 1.0 $129.02
047-581-002-000 1714 SUN VALLEY AVE 1.0 129.02
04 7-581-003-000 1728 SUN VALLEY AVE 1.0 129.02 04 7-581-004-000 1742 SUN VALLEY AVE 1.0 129.02 04 7-581-005-000 1756 SUN VALLEY AVE 1.0 129.02
047-582-001-000 1701 SUN VALLEY AVE 1.0 129.02
047-582-002-000 1711 SUN VALLEY AVE 1.0 129.02
04 7-582-003-000 1723 SUN VALLEY AVE 1.0 129.02
047-582-004-000 1735 SUN VALLEY AVE 1.0 129.02
04 7-582-005-000 1745 SUN VALLEY AVE 1.0 129.02
04 7-582-006-000 1755 SUN VALLEY AVE 1.0 129.02
047-582-007-000 1767 SUN VALLEY AVE 1.0 129.02 04 7-582-008-000 1777 SUN VALLEY AVE 1.0 129.02 04 7-582-009-000 961 SPRING BROOK DR 1.0 129.02
047-582-010-000 951 SPRING BROOK DR 1.0 129.02 047-582-011-000 941 SPRING BROOK DR 1.0 129.02 047-582-012-000 931 SPRINGBROOK DR 1.0 129.02 047-582-013-000 921 SPRING BROOK DR 1.0 129.02 047-582-014-000 909 SPRING BROOK DR 1.0 129.02 047-582-015-000 1789 WELLS AVE 1.0 129.02
047-582-016-000 1801 WELLS AVE 1.0 129.02
047-582-017-000 1811 WELLS AVE 1.0 129.02
047-582-018-000 1821 WELLS AVE 1.0 129.02 047-582-019-000 1831 WELLS AVE 1.0 129.02 04 7-582-020-000 1841 WELLS AVE 1.0 129.02 047-582-021-000 1851 WELLS AVE 1.0 129.02 04 7-582-022-000 1861 WELLS AVE 1.0 129.02 04 7-582-023-000 1871 WELLS AVE 1.0 129.02 047-582-024-000 1883 WELLS AVE 1.0 129.02
04 7-582-026-000 1905 SUN VALLEY AVE 1.0 129.02
047-582-027-000 1915 SUN VALLEY AVE 1.0 129.02 047-582-028-000 1929 SUN VALLEY AVE 1.0 129.02 04 7-582-029-000 978 NEWCASTLE DR 1.0 129.02 04 7-582-030-000 988 NEWCASTLE DR 1.0 129.02 047-582-031-000 998 NEWCASTLE DR 1.0 129.02 047-583-001-000 1804 SUN VALLEY AVE 1.0 129.02 04 7-583-002-000 1820 SUN VALLEY AVE 1.0 129.02 04 7-583-003-000 1836 SUN VALLEY AVE 1.0 129.02 04 7-584-001-000 978 SPRINGBROOK DR 1.0 129.02 04 7-584-002-000 977 GOLDEN LEAF DR 1.0 129.02 04 7-584-003-000 967 GOLDEN LEAF DR 1.0 129.02 04 7-584-004-000 957 GOLDEN LEAF DR 1.0 129.02 04 7-584-005-000 945 GOLDEN LEAF DR 1.0 129.02 04 7-584-006-000 935 GOLDEN LEAF DR 1.0 129.02 04 7-584-007-000 923 GOLDEN LEAF DR 1.0 129.02 04 7-584-008-000 924 SPRING BROOK DR 1.0 129.02 04 7-584-009-000 936 SPRING BROOK DR 1.0 129.02 04 7-584-010-000 946 SPRINGBROOK DR 1.0 129.02 047-584-011-000 958 SPRING BROOK DR 1.0 129.02 047-584-012-000 968 SPRINGBROOK DR 1.0 129.02 04 7-585-001-000 1848 SUN VALLEY AVE 1.0 129.02 047-585-002-000 1860 SUN VALLEY AVE 1.0 129.02 04 7-585-003-000 1870 SUN VALLEY AVE 1.0 129.02 04 7-585-004-000 1884 SUN VALLEY AVE 1.0 129.02
04 7-585-005-000 1896 SUN VALLEY AVE 1.0 129.02
04 7-585-006-000 1910 SUN VALLEY AVE 1.0 129.02 047-586-001-000 978 GOLDEN LEAF DR 1.0 129.02 04 7-586-002-000 977 PARK VIEW DR 1.0 129.02
04 7-586-003-000 967 PARK VIEW DR 1.0 129.02 04 7-586-004-000 957 PARK VIEW DR 1.0 129.02 04 7-586-005-000 945 PARK VIEW DR 1.0 129.02
04 7-586-006-000 935 PARK VIEW DR 1.0 129.02
Willdan Financial Services Page 1 of 3

Page 253 ends

City of Livingston
BAD-Somerset
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
04 7-586-007-000 923 PARK VIEW DR 1.0 129.02
04 7-586-008-000 924 GOLDEN LEAF DR 1.0 129.02
04 7-586-009-000 936 GOLDEN LEAF DR 1.0 129.02
04 7-586-010-000 946 GOLDEN LEAF DR 1.0 129.02
047-586-011-000 958 GOLDEN LEAF DR 1.0 129.02
047-586-012-000 968 GOLDEN LEAF DR 1.0 129.02
047-591-001-000 1001 GOLDEN LEAF DR 1.0 129.02
047-591-002-000 1013 GOLDEN LEAF DR 1.0 129.02
04 7-591-003-000 1025 GOLDEN LEAF DR 1.0 129.02
04 7-591-004-000 1035 GOLDEN LEAF DR 1.0 129.02
04 7-591-005-000 1047 GOLDEN LEAF DR 1.0 129.02
04 7-591-006-000 1057 GOLDEN LEAF DR 1.0 129.02
04 7-591-007-000 1069 GOLDEN LEAF DR 1.0 129.02
04 7-591-008-000 1079 GOLDEN LEAF DR 1.0 129.02
04 7-591-009-000 1098 GOLDEN LEAF DR 1.0 129.02
047-591-010-000 1099 GOLDEN LEAF DR 1.0 129.02
04 7-591-011-000 1111 GOLDEN LEAF DR 1.0 129.02
047-591-012-000 1123 GOLDEN LEAF DR 1.0 129.02
047-591-013-000 1135 GOLDEN LEAF DR 1.0 129.02
047-591-014-000 1838 ST IVESAVE 1.0 129.02
047-591-015-000 1848 ST IVESAVE 1.0 129.02
047-591-016-000 1860 STIVES AVE 1.0 129.02
047-591-017-000 1872 STIVES AVE 1.0 129.02 047-591-018-000 1884 ST IVESAVE 1.0 129.02 047-591-019-000 1896 ST IVESAVE 1.0 129.02
04 7-591-020-000 1910 STIVES AVE 1.0 129.02
047-592-001-000 1847 SOUTHPORT AVE 1.0 129.02
04 7-592-002-000 1859 SOUTHPORT AVE 1.0 129.02
04 7-592-003-000 1871 SOUTHPORT AVE 1.0 129.02
04 7-592-004-000 1883 SOUTHPORT AVE 1.0 129.02
04 7-592-005-000 1895 SOUTHPORT AVE 1.0 129.02
04 7-592-006-000 1909 SOUTHPORT AVE 1.0 129.02
047-593-001-000 1848 SOUTHPORT AVE 1.0 129.02
04 7-593-002-000 1847 YORK AVE 1.0 129.02
04 7-593-003-000 1859 YORK AVE 1.0 129.02
04 7-593-004-000 1871 YORK AVE 1.0 129.02
04 7-593-005-000 1883 YORK AVE 1.0 129.02
04 7-593-006-000 1895 YORK AVE 1.0 129.02
04 7-593-007-000 1909 YORK AVE 1.0 129.02
04 7-593-008-000 1910 SOUTHPORT AVE 1.0 129.02 04 7-593-009-000 1896 SOUTHPORT AVE 1.0 129.02 047-593-010-000 1884 SOUTHPORT AVE 1.0 129.02
047-593-011-000 1870 SOUTHPORT AVE 1.0 129.02 047-593-012-000 1860 SOUTHPORT AVE 1.0 129.02 04 7-594-001-000 1848 YORK AVE 1.0 129.02
04 7-594-002-000 1847 ST IVESAVE 1.0 129.02
04 7-594-003-000 1859 ST IVESAVE 1.0 129.02
04 7-594-004-000 1871 ST IVESAVE 1.0 129.02
04 7-594-005-000 1883 ST IVESAVE 1.0 129.02
04 7-594-006-000 1895 ST IVESAVE 1.0 129.02
04 7-594-007-000 1909 ST IVESAVE 1.0 129.02
04 7-594-008-000 1910 YORK AVE 1.0 129.02
04 7-594-009-000 1896 YORK AVE 1.0 129.02
047-594-010-000 1884 YORK AVE 1.0 129.02
047-594-011-000 1870 YORK AVE 1.0 129.02
047-594-012-000 1860 YORK AVE 1.0 129.02
047-596-001-000 1008 NEWCASTLE DR 1.0 129.02
04 7-596-002-000 1014 NEWCASTLE DR 1.0 129.02
04 7-596-003-000 1024 NEWCASTLE DR 1.0 129.02
04 7-596-004-000 1034 NEWCASTLE DR 1.0 129.02
04 7-596-005-000 1042 NEWCASTLE DR 1.0 129.02
04 7-596-006-000 1055 NEWCASTLE DR 1.0 129.02
Willdan Financial Services Page 2 of 3

Page 254 ends

City of Livingston
BAD-Somerset
Fiscal Year 2022/23 Preliminary Assessment Roll

ASSESSOR'S PARCEL NUMBER SITUS ADDRESS EDU CHARGE
047-596-007-000
04 7-596-008-000
04 7-596-009-000
047-596-010-000
047-596-011-000
047-596-012-000
047-596-013-000
047-596-014-000
047-596-015-000
Summarv Fields
Number of Parcels to be Levied
Total EDUs
Total -
Willdan Financial Services
1065
1074
1082
1092
1104
1116
1122
1134
1146
Value
133
133.00
$17 159.66

NEWCASTLE DR

1.0 1.0

1.0 129.02
129.02
129.02
129.02
129.02
129.02
129.02
129.02
129.02

Page 3 of 3 ends

Page 255 ends

AGENDA ITEM:

MEETING DATE:

PREPARED BY:

REVIEWED BY:

STAFF REPORT
Resolution Approving the Annual Local Transportation Fund (LTF) Claim to be filed with the Merced County Association of Governments (MCAG) for Coronavirus Response and Relief
Supplemental Appropriations Act (CRRSAA) swap.

May 16, 2023
Happy Bains, Sr. Accountant
Christopher Lopez, Interim City Manager
RECOMMENDATION:

Staff recommends that the Council adopt Resolution No. 2023-_, approving the Annual Local Transportation Fund (L TF) claim and file claim with the Merced County Association of Governments for Coronavirus Response and Relief Supplemental Appropriations Act (CRRSAA) swap on behalf of the City of Livingston.

BACKGROUND:

The City of Livingston may claim Local Transportation Funds (L TF) from the Merced County Association of Governments (MCAG) for Coronavirus Response and Relief Supplemental Appropriations Act (CRRSAA) swap. The amount available to claim by the City of Livingston is $90,999. In order to receive the funding available to The City of Livingston staff is required to submit a claim.

DISCUSSION:

This action is necessary for the city to receive its funding. The attached claim form and authorized resolution will be submitted to MCAG to claim for the Coronavirus Response and Relief Supplemental Appropriations Act (CRRSAA) swap. These monies will be used for the 2022 Slurry Seal Project. The 2022 Slurry Seal Project will consist of the following areas:
- 5th and 5th between Park St.
- All of Park St from Main St to Hammatt Ave
- 7th St from G St to Peach Ave
- Joseph St from Park St to Peach St
- 8th St from Park St to Peach St
- 9th St from Virginia Ave to Hammatt Ave
- Peach Ave from 7th St to 8th St
- G St from 7th to 8th St
FISCAL IMPACT:

Submittal of the L TF Claim ensures compliance with MCAG guidelines to be eligible for L TF funds. This action will provide additional $90,999 for street improvement projects.

Page 256 ends

ATTACHMENTS:

1. Resolution No. 2023-

2. Claim Form

3. December 9, 2022 Meeting Adm in Report from MCAG for the CRRSAA Funds

Page 257 ends

RESOLUTION NO. 2023-

A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF LIVINGSTON APPROVING THE LOCAL

TRANSPORTATION FUND (L TF) CLAIM TO BE FILED WITH THE MERCED COUNTY

ASSOCIATION OF GOVERNMENTS (MCAG) FOR CORONAVIRUS RESPONSE AND RELIEF SUPPLEMENTAL APPROPRIATIONS ACT OF 2021 (CRRSAA} SWAP WHEREAS, under the Transportation Development Act (TOA) of 1971, Local Transportation Fund (LTF) monies are available to cities for public transportation, construction and maintenance of local streets and roads, and for pedestrian or bicycle facilities under certain circumstances; and
WHEREAS, the City Of Livingston meets all requirements to qualify for said apportionment allocated through the Merced County Association of Governments (MCAG), as the designated local transportation and planning agency; and WHEREAS, the allocations of L TF monies to each jurisdiction have been calculated by population; and
WHEREAS, the City of Livingston has L TF monies available to claim in the amount of $90,999 for Fiscal Year 2021-2022; and
WHEREAS, the city's proposed expenditures of L TF monies are in conformity with the Regional Transportation Plan as prepared by MCAG; and
WHEREAS, the City shall submit a certified fiscal audit to MCAG as required by Public Utilities Code Section 99245 within 90 or such other period as is agreed to by MCAG; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of Livingston does hereby authorize the filing of the L TF claim for CRRSAA Swap in the amount of $90,999.

BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED it is deemed in the best interest of the City of Livingston that the Interim City Manager and the Interim Finance Director be authorized to sign the L TF claim form for CRRSAA Swap, and to submit said claim to MCAG for processing.

Passed and adopted this 16th day of May 2023 by the following vote:

AYES:

NOES:

ABSENT:

ABSTAIN:

Page 1 of 2 ends

Jose A. Moran, Mayor
of the City of Livingston

Page 258 ends

ATTEST:

I hereby certify that the foregoing resolution was regularly introduced, passed and adopted at a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Livingston this 16th day of May 2023.

Page 2 of 2 ends

Monica Cisneros, Deputy City Clerk
of City of Livingston

Page 259 ends

Claimant:

Type of Claim:

STREETS & ROADS

LOCAL TRANSPORTATION FUND CLAIM

CRRSAA SWAP
Amount of Claim:
□ $90,999
□
□
□
PEDESTRIAN & BICYCLE FACILITIES $ ____ _
OTHER (indicate purpose & TDA Section number ___ _ $ ____ _ TOTAL $ ____ _
It is understood by this claimant that payment of the claim is subject to approval by MCAG, to such monies being on hand and available for distribution, and to the provision that such monies (and the interest earned on such monies subsequent to allocation) will be used only for those purposes for which the claim is approved and in accordance with the terms of the allocation instructions.

Further, the Chief Financial Officer of the claimant certifies that the financial information contained herein, is reasonable and accurate to the best of my knowledge.

Authorized Representative:

Signature
Print or type name
Title
Date
Signature of Chief Financial Officer

Page 260 ends

LTF STREETS & ROADS CLAIM
Claimant: City of Livingston
Project Title, Location and Description {may use additional paper) 2022 Slurry Seal Project
5th and 6th Between Park St
All of Park St from Main St to Hammatt Ave
7th St from G St to Peach Ave
Joseph St. from Park St to Peach Ave
8th St from Park St to Prach Ave
9th St from Virgina Ave to Hammatt Ave
Peach Ave from 7th to Hammatt Ave
Virginia from 7th St to 8th St
G St from 7th St to 8th St
Project Cost by Funding Source
LTF $90.999
General Fund -"---------------
Other $312.701
TOTAL $403.700

1. For entities with a population of more than 5,000, is the claim for streets and roads (exclusive of capital requirements for major new facilities) less than 50% of the total streets and roads expenditures?
181 Yes □ No

2. Is the project in conformity with the MCAG Regional Transportation Plan? 181 Yes □ No
Prepared by:

Signature
Type or print name

Page 261 ends

LTF PEDESTRIAN & BICYCLE FACILITIES CLAIM
Claimant:

Type of PEDESTRIAN & BICYCLE FACILITIES Claim:
□ Facilities provided for the exclusive use of pedestrians and bicycles D Projects which are provided for use by pedestrians and bicycles Project Title, location and Description (may use additional paper) Project Cost by Funding Source
LTF
General Fund ..__ ___________ _
Other
TOTAL

1. For entities with a population of more than 5,000, is the claim for pedestrian and bicycle facilities (exclusive of capital requirements for major new facilities) less than 50% of the total pedestrian and bicycle facilities expenditures?
D Yes □ No

2. Is the project in conformity with the MCAG Regional Transportation Plan? 0 Yes 0 No
Prepared by:

Signature
Type or Print Name

Page 262 ends

LTF OTHER CLAIM
Claimant:

Type of LTF "Other" Claim:

D Passenger rail service operations and capital improvements D Transportation services using vehicles for the EXCLUSIVE use of elderly or disabled persons
□ To finance the construction and maintenance of multi modal transportation terminals Project Title, Location and Description (may use additional paper) Project Cost by Funding Source
LTF
General Fund --------------
Other
TOTAL

1. Is the project in conformity with the MCAG Regional Transportation Plan? D Yes 0 No
Prepared by:

Signature
Type or Print Name

Page 263 ends

I MERCED COUNTY

ASSOCIATION OF

GOVERNMENTS
PH : 209.723.3153
FAX: 209.723.0322
www.mcagov.org
369 W. 18th Street
Merced, CA 95340
ITEM lld
DATE: December 9, 2022
TO: Governing Board
FROM: Elizabeth Forte, Director of Planning and Programming RE: Action -Approve a preferred formula for the distribution of $1,234,325 in Local Transportation Funds

SUMMARY
Staff is seeking direction on how to distribute $1,234,325 in Local Transportation Funds (LTF) to loca l agencies. These LTF funds are the result of an exchange with TJPA for Coronavirus Response and Relief Supplemental Appropriations Act of 2021 (CRRSAA) funds that were allocated to TJPA by the MCAG Governing Board in September. At that time, staff proposed that the distribution follow a populationbased formula but during board discussion, a request was made to consider alternate distribution scenarios including a formula with a base allocation to each agency before the remaining funds are distributed by population. The Governing Board approved the exchange of funds in September and asked staff to bring distribution options for the LTF back to the board for further discussion and action .

This item provides several distribution options with base amounts ranging from 5-25%.

REQUESTED ACTION
Approve a preferred formula for the distribution of $1,234,325 in Local Transportation Funds (LTF) :
a) Distribute funds based solely on population; or
b) Distribute funds with a base amount of 5%, 10%, 15% or 25% of the total, and the remaining amount by population.

BACKGROUND
The CRRSAA apportioned $911.8 million in federal funding to California, and this funding is under the authority of the California Transportation Commission (CTC). Under the Act, $182.4 million is in the form of Regional Sl:Jrface Transportation Program (RSTP) funding. The Merced Region's CRRSAA RSTP share is $1,234,325. No matching funds are required for CRRSAA RSTP.

The Governing Board allocated the CRRSAA funds to TJPA for the purchase of buses, and staff proposed that TJPA exchange the same amount of LTF from their capital fund to the local agencies. This swap concentrated the more onerous application process to one project managed by TJPA and allowed t he $1,234,325 in more flexible LTF to be distributed to the jurisdictions.

The past practice for formula funds that have been disturbed to the jurisdiction has varied. The RSTP and LTF allocation has been disbursed by population. Measure V has been allocated by base (1% of 132

Page 264 ends

total Measure V) plus road miles plus population.

PAST ACTION TAKEN
September 15, 2022: The Governing Board approved programming the CRRSAA funds to the TJPA capital project and requested that staff bring back options for how the exchanged LTF funds will be allocated.

November 17, 2022: The Governing Board voted to table the item and bring it back to the next meeting.

DISCUSSION
At the September 2022 board meeting, staff proposed the distribution of funds based solely on population as shown in the table below:

Distribution Based Solely on Population
Jurisdiction Population % of Population Total Allocation City of Atwater 31,652 11% $137,403
City of Dos Palos 5,715 2% $24,809
City of Gustine 5,981 2% $25,964
City of Livingston 14,410 5% $62,555
City of Los Banos 46,639 16% $202,462
City of Merced 89,058 31% $386,605
County of Merced 90,883 32% $394,527
Total 284,338 100% $1,234,325
The Governing Board requested alternative options to consider that would take into account a base allocation prior to a population-based distribution. Below is an example of how a "base plus population" formula could work. In the example below, 10% of the funding total is allocated equally to each jurisdiction and the remaining 90% of the funding is allocated by population. The base/population split can vary widely. Staff has provided examples of a 5% base/95% population to 25% base/75% population in the attachment.

Distribution Based on 10% Base, 90% by Population
%ofTotal
Jurisdiction County Population
Jurisdiction Base (10%} Population Population Share{90%) Total Allocation City of Atwater $17,633 31,652 11% $123,662 $141,295
City of Dos Palos $17,633 5,715 2% $22,328 $39,961
City of Gustine $17,633 5,981 2% $23,367 $41,000
City of Livingston $17,633 14,410 5% $56,299 $73,932
City of Los Banos $17,633 46,639 16% $182,215 $199,849
City of Merced $17,633 89,058 31% $347,944 $365,577
County of Merced $17,633 90,883 32% $355,074 $372,707
Total $123,432 284,338 100% $1,110,892 1,234,325
133

Page 265 ends

FISCAL IMPACT
No financial impact to MCAG.

COMMITTEE ACTIONS
Committee Name Committee Action
Citizens Advisory Committee NA
Technical Review Board No formal action was taken on t he staff recommendation presented in November,
although direction was given to staff to continue
discussions on the preferred formula for
distribution and revisit at a future meeting fo r
approval.

STAFF CONT ACT
Elizabeth Forte, Director of Planning and Programming, elizabeth [email protected] or 209-769-0055

ATTACHMENTS
Base plus Population allocation options
134

Page 266 ends

LTF DISTRIBUTION OPTIONS
OPTION A: 5% BASE TOTAL AU.OCATION: TOTAL BASE @ 5" TOTAL BY POP (95"):
$ 1,234,325.00 $ 61,n&.ZS $ 1,172,608.75
Jurisdiction Base5% Jurisdiction Population % of The County Population Population (Share @195%) Total Allocation Atwater $ 8,817 31,652 11.13% $ 130,533 $ 139,349
Dos Palos $ 8,817 5,715 2.01% $ 23,569 $ 32,385
Gustine $ 8,817 5,981 2.10% $ 24,666 $ 33,482
Livingston $ 8,817 14,410 5.07% $ 59,427 $ 68,243
Los Banos $ 8,817 46,639 16.40% $ 192,339 $ 201,156
City Of Merced $ 8,817 89,058 31.32% $ 367,275 $ 376,091 County Merced $ 8,817 90,883 31.96% $ 374,801 $ 383,618 Total $ 61,716 284,338 100.1111'¼ $ 1,172,609 $ 1,234,325 OPTION B: 10% BASE TOTALAU.OCATION: TOTAL BASE @1111% TOTAL BY POP (90%):
$ 1,234,325.00 $ 123,432.50 $ 1,110,892,50
Jurisdiction Base10% Jurisdiction Population % of The County Population Population (Share @I 911%} Total Allocation Atwater $ 17,633 31,652 11.13% $ 123,663 $ 141,296
Dos Palos $ 17,633 5,715 2.01% $ 22,328 $ 39,961
Gustine $ 17,633 5,981 2.10% $ 23,367 $ 41,001
Livingston $ 17,633 14,410 5.07% $ 56,299 $ 73,932
Las Banos $ 17,633 46,639 16.40% $ 182,216 $ 199,849
City Of Merced $ 17,633 89,058 31.32% $ 347,945 $ 365,578 County MerCl!d $ 17,633 90,883 31.96% $ 3SS,075 $ 372,708 Total $ 123,433 284,338 100.oo,i; $ 1,110,893 $ 1,234,325 OPTION C: 15% BASE TOTALAllOCATION: TOTAL BASE @115% TOTAL BY POP (BS%} $ 1,234,325.00 $ 185,148.75 $ 1,049,176.25
Jurisdiction Base15% Jurisdiction Population % of The County Population Population (Share @ 85¾) Total Allocation Atwater $ 26,450 31,652 11.13% $ 116,792 $ 143,242
Dos Palos $ 26,450 5,715 2.01% $ 21,088 $ 47,538
Gustine $ 26,450 5,981 2.10% $ 22,069 $ 48,519
Livingston $ 26,450 14,410 5.07% $ 53,171 $ 79,621
Los Banos $ 26,450 46,639 16.40% $ 172,093 $ 198,543
City Of Merced $ 26,450 89,058 31.32% $ 328,614 $ 355,064 County Merced $ 26,450 90,883 31.96% $ 335,348 $ 361,798 Total $ 185,149 284,338 100.00% $ 1,049,176 $ 1,234,325 OPTION D: 25% BASE TOTAL ALLOCATION: BASE@l25% TOTAL BY POP (75%} $ 1,234,32S.DD $ 308,581.25 $ 925,743.75
Jurisdiction Base25% Jurisdiction Population % of The County Population Population (Share @ 75%) Total Allocation Atwater $ 44,083 31,652 11.13% $ 103,052 $ 147,135
Dos Palos $ 44,083 5,715 2.01% $ 18,607 $ 62,690
Gustine $ 44,083 5,981 2.10% $ 19,473 $ 63,556
Livingston $ 44,083 14,410 5.07% $ 46,916 $ 90,999
Los Banos $ 44,083 46,639 16.40% $ 151,847 $ 195,930
City Of Merced $ 44,083 89,058 31.32% $ 289,954 $ 334,037 County Merced $ 44,083 90,883 31.96% $ 295,896 s 339,979 Total $ 308,581 284,338 lOD.00% $ 925,744 $ 1,234,325
135

Page 267 ends

AGENDA ITEM:

MEETING DATE:

PREPARED BY:

REVIEWED BY:

STAFF REPORT

A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF

LIVINGSTON TO APPROVE A CONTRACT WITH PYRO
SPECTACULARS, INC FOR PYROTECHNIC SERVICES ON JULY 4,
2023, JULY 4, 2024, AND JULY 4, 2025, AND AUTHORIZE THE CITY

MANAGER TO EXECUTE CONTRACT
May 16, 2023
Jacquelyn Benoit, Recreation Superintendent
Christopher Lopez, Interim City Manager
RECOMMENDATION:

Staff is seeking council's adopt resolution approving a contract with Pyro Spectaculars, Inc. for Pyrotechnic Services on July 4, 2023, July 4, 2024, and July 4, 2025, and Authorize the City Manager to Execute Contract.

BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION:

In March of 2023 Council approved and directed staff to plan on having a July 4th Celebration with a fireworks show on the 4th of July. The recreation department has been working on putting together this event. Staff received word form Pyro Spectaculars that they had a cancellation and would be able to provide us with a show. Pyro Spectaculars has been the sole provider of our fireworks shows for at least the last 22 years minus covid or no resources available.

Pyro has sent us a contract as they traditionally have. The contract has been circulated and RMA remarked they would prefer a city contract to them vs a contractors contract to us. They also commented that they want $5 million in coverages as listed below. $SM per occurrence for Commercial General Liability coverage, $SM in Auto Liability coverage $1 M in Employer's Liability and Statutory Worker's Compensation coverage. And then I would require the city to be added as an additional insured with coverage at least as broad as CG 20 10.

Pyre's scope of coverage is as listed, but were in agreement to make the limits RMA requested:

Commercial General Liability of 1 million combined Single Limit-Each Occurrence (Bodily injury & Property Damage}, Business Auto Liability-Owned, Non-Owned and Hired Autos of 5 million combined Single Limit-Each Occurrence (Bodily injury & Property Damage) Workers compensation Statutory, Employer Liability 1 million per occurrence.

The attached contract is for 2023, 2024 and 2025. This will insure we have a show for the next 3 years. The show will begin at approximately 9: 15pm to include 2.503 shells for a total of $25,000.00. 2024 will include the same number of shells for $25,750 and in 2025 the same number of shells at a cost of $26,500.00

Page 268 ends

The deposit of$12,500 is now due. In future years the deposit as listed in the contract is due by March 15th of the year the show is provided.

FISCAL IMPACT:

Unknown
ATTACHMENTS:

1. Resolution

2. Contract

Page 1 ends

Page 269 ends

RESOLUTION 2023-

A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LIVINGSTON TO

APPROVE A CONTRACT WITH PYRO SPECTACULARS, INC FOR PYROTECHNIC SERVICES ON JULY 4, 2023, JULY 4, 2024, AND JULY 4, 2025, AND AUTHORIZE

THE CITY MANAGER TO EXECUTE CONTRACT
WHEREAS, in March of 2023 Council approved and directed staff to plan on having a July 4th Celebration with a fireworks show on the 4th of July, and WHEREAS, Pyro Spectaculars by Souza ("Pyro") has submitted a proposal to orchestrate the July 4th Celebration fireworks show. Pyro has been the sole provider of the City's fireworks shows for at least the last 22 years, excepting COVID or during times when no resources were available, and
WHEREAS, Pyro's proposed contract has been reviewed and approved as to form by the City Attorney, the City's Risk Management Authority, and City staff, and WHEREAS, the proposed contract is for fireworks shows on the 4th of July for 2023, 2024, and 2025. The fireworks show will begin at approximately 9: 1 Spm to include 2.503 shells for a total of $25,000.00. 2024 will include the same number of shells for $25,750, and in 2025 the same number of shells at a cost of $26,500.00, and WHEREAS, if the City Council approves the proposed contract, a 50% deposit equal to $12,500 will be due to Pyre and, for the years 2024 and 2025, the deposit listed in the contract will be due by March 15th each year the show is provided.

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the City Council of the City of Livingston does hereby approve the contract between Pyro Spectaculars by Souza and the City of Livingston for 2023, 2024, and 2025 4th of July fireworks shows.

Passed and adopted this 16th day of May 2023, by the following vote:

AYES:

NOES:

ABSENT:

ABSTAIN:

Jose Moran, Mayor
of the City of Livingston
ATTEST:

I hereby certify that the foregoing resolution was regularly introduced, passed and adopted at a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Livingston this 16th day of May 2023.
{CWJ28878.J} I
Monica Cisneros, Deputy City Clerk
of the City of Livingston

Page 270 ends

Page 271 ends

April 24, 2023
City of Livingston
Christopher Lopez
1416 C Street
Livingston, CA 95334
Dear Mr. Lopez,
Pyro Spectaculars, Inc. is happy to provide our pyrotechnic proposal for your July 4, 2023, 2024 & 2025 events. The following proposal outlines your custom designed Program "A" for the amount of $25,000.00 for the year of 2023, $25,750.00 for the year of 2024, and $26,500.00 for the year of 2025.

Our full service program includes necessary preproduction services, the services of a licensed pyrotechnic operator, specialized crew, an electronic firing system, and pyrotechnic safety equipment used for support and protection. The price also includes insurance coverage, sales tax, and delivery. To help ensure public safety, we work directly with the local fire authority, and we apply for the necessary fireworks related permits. Our winning combination of products, people, and production capabilities help produce the best fireworks entertainment package for your event.

Your organization will be responsible for payment of permit fees and/or standby firemen fees, if any. The Fire Department may bill you directly for any additional standby fees for inspections. Your organization will also be responsible for providing the display location, necessary security for the display site, and other event permits.

Please review the enclosed Proposal, Product Synopsis, Production Agreement, and Scope of Work in detail. In order to reserve your program, it is imperative that you return the fully executed agreement, your initial payment, and permit fees to our office by May 1, 2023, the price firm date in your production agreement. The program, pricing, and show date may not be available beyond the price firm date.

If you wish to discuss your program or need more information, please call either me or your Customer Service Representative Luis Ruiz at (909) 355-8120 ext. 227.

Sincerely,
PYRO SPECTACULARS, INC.

Jennifer Waite
PYRO Show Producer
JW/lr
Enclosures
Pyro Spectaculars, Inc.

P.O. Box 2329 • Rialto, CA 92377 • Phone: (909) 355-8120 or (888) 477-PYRO • Fax: (909) 355-9813

Page 272 ends

Product Synopsis • Pyrotechnic Proposal
City of Livingston
PROGRAM A - July 4, 2023
$25,000.00
Main Body - Aerial Shells
Description
♦ 3" Souza Designer Selections
♦ 4" Souza Designer Selections
Quantity
200
150
Total of Main Body - Aerial Shells 350
Pyrotechnic Devices
Description
♦ Sousa Platinum Line Custom Multishot Device
♦ Sousa Diamond Line Custom Multishot Device
♦ Sousa Silver Line Custom Multishot Device
♦ Sousa Emerald Line Custom Multishot Device
Quantity
300 Shots
576 Shots
341 Shots
749 Shots
Total of Pyrotechnic Devices 1,966
Grand Finale
Description
♦ 2.5" Souza Designer Bombardment Shells
♦ 3" Souza Designer Bombardment Shells
♦ 4" Souza Designer Bombardment Shells
Quantity
72 85
30 Total of Grand Finale 187
Grand Total 2,503
Product descriptions are for specification of product quality, classification, and value. Final product selections will be based on availability, suitability, and overall artistic style.

Page 273 ends

Product Synopsis • Pyrotechnic Proposal
City of Livingston
PROGRAM A - July 4, 2024
$25,750.00
Main Body - Aerial Shells
Description
♦ 3" Souza Designer Selections
♦ 4" Souza Designer Selections
Quantity
200
150
Total of Main Body - Aerial Shells 350
Pyrotechnic Devices
Description
♦ Sousa Platinum Line Custom Multishot Device
♦ Sousa Diamond Line Custom Multishot Device
♦ Sousa Silver Line Custom Multishot Device
♦ Sousa Emerald Line Custom Multishot Device
Quantity
300 Shots
576 Shots
341 Shots
749 Shots
Total of Pyrotechnic Devices 1,966
Grand Finale
Description
♦ 2.5" Souza Designer Bombardment Shells
♦ 3" Souza Designer Bombardment Shells
♦ 4" Souza Designer Bombardment Shells
Quantity
72 85
30 Total of Grand Finale 187
Grand Total 2,503
Product descriptions are for specification of product quality, classification, and value. Final product selections will be based on availability, suitability, and overall artistic style.

Page 274 ends

Product Synopsis • Pyrotechnic Proposal
City of Livingston
PROGRAM A - July 4, 2025
$21
6,500.00
Main Body - Aerial Shells
Description
♦ 3" Souza Designer Selections
♦ 4" Souza Designer Selections
Quantity
200
150
Total of Main Body - Aerial Shells 350
Pyrotechnic Devices
Description
♦ Sousa Platinum Line Custom Multishot Device
♦ Sousa Diamond Line Custom Multishot Device
♦ Sousa Silver Line Custom Multishot Device
♦ Sousa Emerald Line Custom Multishot Device
Quantity
300 Shots
576 Shots
341 Shots
749 Shots
Total of Pyrotechnic Devices 1,966
Grand Finale
Description
♦ 2.5" Souza Designer Bombardment Shells
♦ 3" Souza Designer Bombardment Shells
♦ 411 Souza Designer Bombardment Shells
Quantity
72 85
30 Total of Grand Finale 187
Grand Total 2,503
Product descriptions are for specification of product quality, classification, and value. Final product selections will be based on availability, suitability, and overall artistic style.

Page 275 ends

Pyro Spectaculars, Inc.

P.O. Box 2329
Rialto, CA 92377
Tel: 909-355-8120 :::: Fax: 909-355-9813

PRODUCTION AGREEMENT
(Special)

CITY OF LIVINGSTON
Program# A
July 4, 2023, 2024 & 2025

Page 1 ends

This agreement ("Agreement") is made this ____ day of ==-,----,--,-,2023 by and between Pyro Spectaculars, Inc., a California corporation, hereinafter referred to as ("PYRO"), and CITY OF UVINGSTON, hereinafter referred to as (''CLIENT"), PYRO and CLIENT are sometimes referred to as "Paity" or collectively as "Parties" herein. l. Engngcmcnl - CLIENT hereby engages PYRO to provide to CLIENT three (3) fireworks productions ("Production"), and PYRO accepts such engagement upon all of the promises, tem1s and conditions hereinafter set forth, The Production shall be substantially as outlined in Program "A", attached hereto and incorporated herein by this reference.

I.I P\'RO Duties- PYRO shall provide all pyrotechnic equipment, trained pyrotechnicians, shipping, pyrotechnic products, application for specific pyrotechnic permits (the cost of which, including standby fees, shall be paid by CLIENT) relating to the Production, insurance covering the Production and the other things on its part to be performed, including preproduction services, all as more specifically set forth below in this Agreement and in the Scope of Work ("Scope of Work"), attached hereto, incorporated herein by this reference, and made a part of this Agreement as though set forth fully herein.

1.2 CLJF,NT Duties CLIENT shall provide to PYRO a suitable site ("Site"} for the Production, security for the Site as set forth in Paragraph 6 hereof, access to the Site, any pennission necessary to utilize the Site for the Production, and the other things on its part to be performed as more specifica!ly set forth below in this Agreement and in the Scope of Work. All Site arrangements are subject to PYRO's reasonable approval as to pyrotechnic safety, suitability, and security. All other conditions of the Site shall be the responsibility of CLIENT, including, but not limited to, access, use, control, parking and general safety with respect to the public, CLIENT personnel and other contractors.

2. Time and Pince -The Productions shall take place on ,Juh· 4, 2023, ,Julv 4. 2024 nnd ,Jul\.· 4. 2025, at approximately 9:15 PM, at Mnx Foster Sports Con111lcx1 Open Field, Livinaston, ~ Site.

3. Fees, 1ntcrcM. nnd Exncnscs -

3.1 Fee For the ,Julv 4, 2023 Producfion, CLIENT agrees to pay PYRO a fee of$25,000.00 USD (TWENTY-FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS) ("Fee") for lhe Production. CLIENT shall pay to PYRO $12,500.00 USD (TWELVE THOUSANO FIVE HUNDRED DOLLARS) of the Fee plus estimated pern1it and standby fees, specified production costs, and other regulatory costs approximated at Sl70.00 OR an amount to be determined, for a total of $12.(i70.00, as a deposit ("Deposit") no later than May l, 2023. The balance of the Fee shall be paid no later than July 50 2023, CLIENT authorizes PYRO to receive and verify credit and financial information concerning CLIENT from any agency, person or entity including but not limited to credit reporting agencies.

The "PRICE FIRM" date, the date by which !he executed Agreement must be delivered to Pyro, is set forth in paragraph 20.

3.2 Fee- 1:01' the ,July 4, 2024 Production, CLIENT agrees to pay PYRO a fee of $25,750.00 USD (TWENTY-FIVE THOUSAND SIWEN HUNDR.EO FIFTY DOLLARS) ("Fee") for the Production. CLIENT shall pay to PYRO $12.875.110 USD ffWELVE TJIOUSANO ElGflT HUNDRED SEVENTY-1:1vE OQLLARS) of the Fee plus estimated permit and standby fees, specified production costs, and other regulatory costs approximated at $00.00 OR an amount to be determined, for a total of$12.fl75,00, as a deposit ("Deposit") no later than Mnrch 15, 2024. The balance of the Fee shall be paid ho later than .Julv 5, 2024.

3.3 Fee For the ,July 4, 2025 Production, CLIENT agrees to pay PYRO a fee of $2:6,500,00 USO (TWENTY-SIX THOUSAND FIVE HUNDRED DOLLARS) ("Fee") for the Production. CLIENT shall pay to PYRO $131250.00 USO (THIRTEEN THOUSAND TWO JIUNt>Rim FIFTY DOLLARS} of the Fee plus estimated pennit and standby fees, specified production costs, and other regulatory costs approximated at $00.110 OR an amount to be determined, for a total of$l3,2:i0.00, as a deposit ("Deposit"} no later than l\·lnrch 14,202$. The balance of the Fee shall be paid no later than July 7, 2025,

3.4 Intcrc.sl - In the event that the Fee is not paid in a timely manner, CLIENT will be responsible for the payment of l.5% interest per month or 18% annually on the unpaid balance. If litigation arises out of this Agreement, the prevailing party shall be entitled to reasonable costs incurred in connection with the litigation, including, but not limited to attorneys' fees.

3.5 Expenscs-PYRO shall pay all normal expenses directly related to the Production including freight, insurance as outlined, pyrotechnic products, pyrotechnic equipment, experienced pyrotechnic personnel to set up and discharge the pyrotechnics and those additional items as outlined as PYRO's responsibility in the Scope of Work. CLIENT shall pay all costs related to the Production not supplied by PYRO including, but not limited to, those items outlined as CLJENT's responsibility in this Agreement and Scope of Work.

4. Proprictnr,· Rights - PYRO represents and warrants that it owns all copyrights, including performance rights, to this Production, except that PYRO does not own CLIENT-owned material or third-party-owned material lhat has been included in the Production, and as to such CLIENT-owned and third-partyowned material, CLIENT assumes full responsibility therefore. CLIENT agrees that PYRO shall retain ownership of, and all copyrights and other rights to, the Production, except that PYRO shall not acquire or retain any ownership or other rights in or to CLIENT-owned material and third-party-owned material and shall not be responsible in any way for such material. If applicable, CLIENT consents to the use of CLIENT-owned material and represents that it has or will obtain any permission from appropriate third parties sufficient to authorize public exhibition of any such material in connection with this Production. PYRO reserves the ownership rights in its trade names that are used in or are a product of the Production. Any reproduction by sound, video or other duplication or recording process without the express written permission of PYRO is prohibited.

5. Safety- PYRO and CLIENT shall each comply with applicable federal, state and local laws and regulations and employ safety programs and measures consistent with recognized applicable industry standards and practices. At all times before and during the Production, it shall be within PYRO's sole discretion to determine whether or not the Production may be safely discharged or continued. It shall not constitute a breach of this Agreement by PYRO for fireworks to fail or malfunction, or for PYRO to detennine that the Production cannot be discharged or continued as a result of any conditions or circumstances affecting safety beyond the reasonable control ofPYRO.

PSl V-2021-2

Page 276 ends

Pyro Spectaculars, Inc.

P.O. Box 2329
Rialto, CA 92377
Tel: 909-355-8120 :::: Fax: 909-355-9813

CITY OF LIVINGSTON
Program #A
July 4, 2023, 2024 & 2025

Page 2 ends

6. Security -CLIENT shall provide adequate security personnel, barricades, and Police Department services as may be necessary to preclude ir:dividuals other than those authorized by PYRO from entering an area to be designated by PYRO as the area for the set-up and discharge of the Production, including a fallout area satisfactory to PYRO where the pyrotechnics may safely rise and any debris may safCly fall. PYRO shall have no responsibility for monitor mg or controlling CLIENT'S other contractors, providers or volunteers; the public; areas to which the public or contractors have access; or any other public or contractor facilities associated with the Production,
7, Cleanup - PYRO shall be responsible for the removal of all equipment provided by PYRO and clean up of any live pyrotechnic debris made necessary by PYRO. CLIENT shall be responsible for any other clean up which may be required of the Production or set-up, discharge and fallout areas including any environmental clean~up.

8. Pcrmlls ~ PYRO agrees to apply for pennits for the firing of pyrotechnics only from the LIVINGSTON FIRE DEPARTMENT, FAA, and USCG, if required, CLIENT shall be responsible for any fees associated with these pennits including standby fees, CLIENT shall be responsible for obtaining any other necessary pennits, paying associated fees, and making other appropriate nrrangements for Police Departments, other Fire Departments, road closures, event/activity or land use pennits or any pem1ission or permit required by any Local, Regional, State or Federal Government.

9. lnsunmcc - PYRO shall at all times during the performance of services herein ensure that the following insurance is maintained in connection with PYRO's performance of this Agreement: (I) commercial general liability insurance, including products, completed operations, and contractual liability under this Agreement; (2) automobile liability insurance, (3) workers' compensation insurance and employer liability insurance. Such insurance is to protect CLIENT from claims for bodily injury, including death, personal injury, and from claims of property damage, which may arise from PYRO's performance of this Agreement, only. The types and amounts of coverage shall be as set forth in the Scope of Work. Such insurance shall not include claims which arise from CLIENT's negligence or willful conduct or from failure of CLIENT to perform its obligations under this Agreement, coverage for which shall be provided by CLIENT.

The coverage of these policies shall be subject to reasonable inspection by CLIENT. Certificates oflnsurance evidencing the required general liability coverage shall be furnished to CLIENT prior to the rendering of services hereunder and shall include that the following are named as addilionally insured: CLIENT; Sponsors, Landowners, Barge Owners, if any; and Pennitting Authorities, with respect to the operations of PYRO at the Production. Pyrotechnic subcontractors or providers, if any, not covered under policies of insurance required hereby, shall secure, maintain and provide their own insurance coverage with respect to their respective operations and services.

IO. lndcmnilicntion • PYRO represents and warrants that it is capable of furnishing the necessary experience, personnel, equipment, materials, providers, and expertise to produce the Production in a safe and professional manner. Notwithstanding anything in this Agreement to the contrary, PYRO sl1all indemnify, hold harmless, and defend CLIENT and the additional insureds from and against any and all claims, nctions, damages, liabilities and expenses, including but not limited to, attorney and other professional fees and court costs, in connection with the loss oflife, personal injury, and/or damage to property, arising from or out of the Production and the presentation thereof to the extent such are occasioned by any act or omission of PYRO, their officers, agents, contractors, providers, or employees. CLIENT shall indemnify, hold harmless, and defend PYRO from and against any and all claims, actions, damages, liability and expenses, including but not limited to, attorney and other professional tees and court costs in connection with the loss of life, personal injury, and/or damage to property, arising from or out of the Production and the presentation thereof to lhe extent such are occasioned by any act or omission of CLIENT, its officers, agents, contractors, providers, or employees. In no event shall either party be liable for the consequential damages of the other party.

11. Limitation of Dnnrngcs for Ordinnry Brcnch ~ Except in the case of bodily injury and property damage as provided in the insurance and indemnification provisions of Paragraphs 9 and 10, above, in the event CLIENT claims that PYRO has breached this Agreement or was otherwise negligent in perfonning the Production provided for herein, CLIENT shall not be entitled to claim or recover monetary damages from PYRO beyond the amount CLIENT has paid to PYRO under this Agreement, and shall not be entitled to claim or recover any consequential damages from PYRO including, without limitation, damages for loss of income, business or profits.

12. Foree M11fe11re - CLIENT agrees to assume the risks of weather, strike, civil unrest, terrorism, military action, governmental action, and any other causes beyond the control of PYRO which may prevent the Production from being safely discharged on the scheduled date, which may cause the cancellation of any event for which CLIENT has purchased the Production, or which may affect or damage such portion of the exhibits as must be placed and exposed a necessary time before the Production. If, for any such reason, PYRO is not reasonably able to safely discharge the Production on the scheduled date, or at the scheduled time, or should any event for which CLIENT has purchased the Production be canceled as a result of such causes, CLIENT may (i) reschedule the Production and pay PYRO such sums as provided in Paragraph 13, or (ii) cancel the Production and pay PYRO such sums as provided in Paragraph 14, based upon when the Production is canceled.

13. Rcschcdnllng QfE,·cnl - If CLIENT elects to reschedule the Production, PYRO shall be paid the original Fee plus all additional expenses made necessary by rescheduling plus a 15% service fee on such additional expenses. Said expenses will be invoiced separately and payment will be due in full within 5 days of receipt. CLIENT and PYRO shall agree upon the rescheduled date taking into consideration availability of pennits, materials, equipment, tmnsportation and labor. The Production shall be rescheduled for a date nol more than 90 Days subsequent to the date first set for the Production. The Production shall not be rescheduled to a date, or for an event, that historically has involved a fireworks production. The Production shall not be rescheduled between June 15th and July 15th unless the original date was July 4th of that same year, or between December 15th and January 15th unless the original date was December 31st of the earlier year unless PYRO agrees that such rescheduling will not adversely affect nonnal business operations during those periods.

14. Right To CRnccl -CLIENT shall have the option to unilaterally cancel the Production prior to the scheduled date. [fCLIENT exercises this option, CLIENT agrees to pay to PYRO, as liquidated damages, the following percentages of the Fee as set forth in Paragraph 3.1. I) 50% if cancellation occurs 30 or more days prior to the scheduled date, 2) 75% if cancellation occurs 15 to 29 days prior to the scheduled date, 3) 100% thereafter. In the event CLIENT Cfillce!s the Production, it will be impractical or extremely difficult to fix actual amount of PYRO's damages. The foregoing represents a reasonable estimate of the damages PYRO will suffer if CLIENT cancels the Production.

IS. Nn ,loin I Venture - It is agreed, nothing in this Agreement or in PYRO's pcrfom1ance of the Production shall be construed as fanning a partnership or joint venture between CLIENT and PYRO. PYRO shall be and is an independent contractor with CLIENT and not an employee of CLIENT. The Parties hereto shall be severally responsible for their own separate debts and obligations and neither Party shall be held responsible for any agreements or obligations not expressly provided for herein.

PSI V-2021-2

Page 277 ends

Pyro Spectaculars, Inc.

P.O. Box 2329
Rialto, CA 92377
Tel; 909-355-8120 ;::; Fax; 909-355-9813

CITY OF LIVINGSTON
Program# A
July 4, 2023, 2024 & 2025

Page 3 of 4 ends

16. Appllcnblc Law -This Agreement and the rights and obligations of the Parties hereunder shall be construed in accordance with the laws of California.

It is further agreed that the Central Judicial District of San Bernardino County, California, shall be proper venue for any such action. In the event that the scope of the Production is reduced by authorities having jurisdiction or by either Party for safety concerns, the full dollar amounts outlined in this Agreement are enforceable.

17. ~ ~ Any Notice to the Panics permitted or rct1uircd under this Agreement may be given by mailing such Notice in the United States Mail, postage prepaid, first c\nss, addressed us follows: PYRO- Pyro Si,cctaculnrs, Inc,, P.O. Box 2329, Rialto, California, 92377, or lor overnight delivery lo 3196 N.

Locust Avenue, Rinllo, California 92377, CLIENT-Cih' of Livingston, 1416 C Street. Uvinoston, CA 95334. 18, Modification of Terms-All tem1s of the Agreement are in writing and may only be modified by written agreement of both Parties hereto. Both Parties acknowledge they have received a copy of said written Agreement and agree to be bound by said terms of written Agreement only.

19. Scvcmbilily - I ft here is more than one CLIENT, they shall be jointly and severally responsible to perfonn CLIENT's obligations under this Agreement This Agreement shnll become efiCctive oiler il is executed nnd ucccptcd by CLIENT and after il is executed and accepted by PYRO at PYRO's offices in Rialto, Colifomin. This Agrccmcnl may be cxccmcd in several coun1erparts, including faxed and emailed copies, each one of which shall be deemed an original ngoinst lhc Party executing same. This Agreement slmll be binding upon the Parties hereto nnd upou their heirs, successors, c:-:ccmors, administrnlors and assigns.

20. Price Firm -If any changes or alterations are made by CLIENT to this Agreement or if this Agreement is not executed by CLIENT and delivered to PYRO on or before the PRICE FIRM date shown below, or if the Initial Payment is nol paid on or before the due date, then the price, date, and scope of !he Production are subject to review and acceptance by PYRO for a period of 15 days following delivery to PYRO of the executed Agreement. In the event it is not accepted by PYRO, PYRO shall give CLIENT written notice, and this Agreement shall be void.

PRICE FIRM through May 1, 2023

EXECUTED AGREEMENT MUST BE DELIVERED TO PYRO BY THIS DATE, See PRICE FIRM conditions, paragraph 20, above.

EXECUTED as of the date first wril1cn above:

PYRO SPECTACULARS, INC CITY OF LIVINGSTON
By: _______________ _
Its: President Its: __ ___hC,,:ity"'-'M'-'an""a"'g"'erL ____________ _ ___ _,Ce,1,,u.,,is,,tophcr Lop,;e,.__ ___________ _
Print Name
Date: ____________ _
SHOW PRODUCER: Jennifer Waite
PSI V-2021-2

Page 278 ends

Pyro Spectaculars, Inc.

P.O. Box 2329
Rialto, CA 92377
Tel: 909-355-8120 :::: Fax: 909-355-9813

SCOPE OF WORK
PYRO SPECTACULARS, INC. ("PYRO")
and

SPONSOR
("CLIENT")
Pyro shall provide the following goods and services to CLIENT:

CITY OF LIVINGSTON
Program #A
July 4, 2023, 2024 & 2025

Page 4 ends

• Three (3) Pyro Spectaculars, Inc., Productions on July 4, 2023_ Julv 4. 2024 and July 4, 2025, at approximately 9:15 PM, at Max Foster Sports Complex. Open Field, Livingston, CA.
• All pyrotechnic equipment, trained pyrotechnicians, shipping, and pyrotechnic product. • Preproduction Services and Costs for the Production, including advance acquisition of materials and products; design, engineering, programming, handling, staging, storage, and maintenance of products, props, and systems; preparation of drawings, diagrams, listings, schedules, inventory controls, choreography, and computer code; picking, packing, labeling, staging, and loading of equipment, materials, and systems; transportation, and logistics and crew scheduling and support; explosive storage magazines with legally mandated distances, surfaces, security, housekeeping, and access controls; and necessary and appropriate vehicles, including legally mandated insurance, including MCS90 explosives transportation coverage, parking, security, and maintenance. • Application for specific pyrotechnic permits relating to the Production. • Insurance covering the preproduction and Production as set forth in the Agreement with the following limits:
/11surauce Requirements
Commercial General Liability
Business Auto LiabilityOwned, Non-Owned and Hired Autos Workers' Compensation
Employer Liability
Limits
$5,000,000.00
$5,000,000.00
Statutory
$1,000,000
CLIENT shall provide to PYRO the following goods and services:

Combined Single Limit- Each Occurrence
(Bodily Injury & Property Damage)
Combined Single Limit- Each Occurrence
(Bodily Injury & Property Damage)
Per Occurrence
• All on-site labor costs, if any, not provided or performed by PYRO personnel including, but not limited to, local union requirements, all Site security, Police and Fire Dept. standby personnel, stagehands, electricians, audio and fire control monitors, carpenters, plumbers, clean-up crew. All these additional personnel and services shall be fully insured and the sole responsibility of CLIENT.
• Coordination and any applicable non-pyrotechnic permitting with the local, state or federal government that may hold authority within the Production.
• Costs of all permits required for the presentation of the Production and the event as a whole. • Provision of a Safety Zone in accordance with applicable standards and all requirements of the authorities having jurisdiction throughout the entire time that the pyrotechnics are at the Site or the load site (if different) on the date of the Production and all setup and load-out dates, including water security to keep unauthorized people, boats, etc. from entering the Safety Zone. • General Services including, but not limited to, Site and audience security, fencing, adequate work light, dumpster accessibility, a secure office for PYRO personnel within the venue, secure parking for PYRO vehicles, access to washrooms, tents, equipment storage, hazmat storage, electrical power, fire suppression equipment, access to worksites, necessary credentialing, etc., will be required as necessary.

PSI V-2021-2

Page 279 ends

P.O. Box2329 • Rialto, CA 92377 • (909) 3.56-8120
BIU. TO
City of Livingston
Christopher Lopez
1416 C Street
Livingston, CA 95334
OE.SCAPTION
PATE
4/20/2023

SHIP TO
P.O. NO. TERMS
DUE: 5/1/2023
INITlAL PRODUCTION FEE FOR SPECIAL FIREWORKS DISPLAY PROGRAM "A" ON July 4, 2023
PERMIT FEE:

PAYMENT DUE: May 1, 2023

FINAL PAYMENT DUE WILL BE INVOICED AT A LATER DATE
Total
Invoice
INVOICE ff
301
AMOUNT
$12,500.00
$170.00
'
$12,670.00

Page 280 ends

STAFF REPORT
AGENDA ITEM: Resolution Adopting City of Livingston Master Employee Salary Schedule for the Water/Wastewater Manager and Lifeguard position MEETING DATE: May 16, 2023
PREPARED BY: Arcelia Cruz, Human Resources Coordinator
REVIEWED BY: Christopher Lopez, Interim City Manager
RECOMMENDATION:

Staff recommends that the City Council adopt Resolution No. 2023-_ , adopting City of Livingston Master Employee Salary Schedule for the Water/Wastewater Manager and Lifeguard position.

BACKGROUND:

The City Council approves all salary schedules which include classification titles and pay rates/ranges at the time a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) for each bargaining unit is approved; when updates to the Employment and Benefit Policies for Unrepresented Employees are approved; or when specific wage and classification title adjustments are needed. Also, in order to confirm that the California Publi c Employees' Retirement System (CalPERS) will appropriately consider City of Livingston employee compensation earnable when calculating retirement benefits, the City of Livingston 's Salary Schedule i. required to be formally adopted by the City Council in a public meeting.

On May 4, 2021 , the Mayor and Council approved a 5% increase in the Water/WasteWater Manager position salary. The salary was updated at that time; however, the position was not updated with the 3% COLA provided in the Water/WasteWater Manager and Confidential employee MOU. As a result, in 2021 and 2022, the position was not provided a COLA under the terms of the MOU.

The proposed action updates the Salary Schedule for the Water/Wastewater Manager position to accurately reflect the correct compensation. Being that this position was vacant then there was no need to amend the Salary Schedule. Now that the City will be providing a job offer to an individual, staff recommends updating the Salary Schedule so that it's not in conflict with the Management and Confidential Employees Association MOU.

Additionally, staff recommends the Lifeguard Step B pay rate be changed from $16.28 to $16.50. This is an urgent request so that staff can successfully operate the pool activities, and is necessary to align the hourly rate for what has been offered to candidates. In the future, it is the goal to offer part time hourly wages that coincide with the Council adopted salary schedule to provide for consistency.

DISCUSSION:

Resolution No. 2023-_, has been prepared to implement the adjustment solely for the Water/Waste Water Manager and Lifeguard position.

Page 1 ends

Page 281 ends

FISCAL IMP ACT:

The increased cost for the Water/Waste Water Manager and Lifeguard position will be absorbed in the current year's budget, and will be updated for the FY 2023/24 Budget.

ATTACHMENTS:

I. Resolution No. 2023-

2. City of Livingston Master Employee Salary Schedule REVISED EXHIBIT "A"

Page 2 of 2 ends

Page 282 ends

RESOLUTION NO. 2023-

A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LIVINGSTON

ADOPTING CITY OF LIVINGSTON MASTER EMPLOYEE SALARY

SCHEDULE FOR THE WATER/WASTEWATER MANAGER AND LIFEGUARD

POSITION
WHEREAS, the City of Livingston {"City") maintains a salary schedule for all positions employed by the City, as approved by the City Council; and WHEREAS, on December 7, 2021, the Management and Confidential Employees Association entered into a Memorandum of Understanding (the "MOU") providing for an annual three percent (3%) cost of living increase for its members during its term; and WHEREAS, the Water/Wastewater Manager position is subject to the MOU, being that this position was vacant then there was no need to amend the Salary Schedule, during such time no cost of living increase was included in the Salary Schedule; and WHEREAS, it's anticipated that as of May/2023, the Water/Wastewater Manager position will no longer be vacant and must be compensated according to the MOU; and WHEREAS, a three percent (3%) increase is required effective July 1, 2021 and a three (3%) increase effective July 1, 2022 in the Water/Wastewater Manager Salary Schedule is necessary to comply with the MOU and avoid any grievance or dispute; and WHEREAS, in order to attract and retain qualified part-time, temporary employees for the Lifeguard position, staff recommends the City Council approve an increase to the Lifeguard Step B pay rate from $16.28 to $16.50.

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED: That the City Council of the City of Livingston does hereby adopt the revised City of Livingston Employee Master Salary Schedule, EXHIBIT "A" attached hereto and made a part herein.

Passed and adopted this 16th day of May 2023, by the following vote:

AYES:

NOES:

ABSENT:

ABSTAIN:
{CWl28886.1)
Jose A. Moran, Mayor
of the City of Livingston
Page I of2

Page 283 ends

ATTEST:

I, hereby certify, that the foregoing resolution was regularly introduced, passed and adopted at a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Livingston this 16th day of May 2023. {CW128BS6.1}
Monica Cisneros, Deputy City Clerk
of the City of Livingston

Page 2 of 2 ends

Page 284 ends

EXHIBIT"A"
Approved 9/6/22

CLASSIFICATION
Account Clerk
Accountant I
Accountant II
Accounting Technician
Administratrve Analyst
Administrative Analyst PW
Administrative Assistant
Administrative Services Manager
Assistant Planner
Building Official
Chief of Police
City Clerk
City Council
C~yManager
City Treasurer
Code Compliance Officer
Community Development Director
Communications/Records Manager
Commun~y SelVice Officer
Custodian I
Custodian II
Oiredor of Public Works
Executive Assistant to the City Manager
Executive Assistant /Deputy City Clerk
Finance Director/Assistant City Manager
Human Resources Coordinator

MASTER SALARY SCHEDULE
Effective July 1, 2022
Baraalnlna Group Tvoe A B C D E
Hourfv 17.04 17.89 18.78 19.72 20.7 1
Cle rical Monff1Jv 2,953.08 3.100.73 3.255.77 3.418.56 3.589 49 Annually 35,436.95 37,208.79 39,069.23 41 ,022.69 43,073 83 Hourly 27.42 28.79 30.23 31 .74 33.32
Mgmt,/Confidential Montt1/y 4,752.14 4,989.75 5,239.24 5,501 .20 5.776.26 Annualfy 57,025.71 59,876.99 62.870.84 66,014.39 69.31 5.11 Houtfv 31 .58 33.24 34.99 36.74 38.58
MgmtJConfidential Monlhlv 5,473.73 5,761.82 6,065.07 6,368.33 6.668.74 Annually 65,68-4.73 69,141.82 72.780.86 76,419,90 80.240,90 Hourtv 20.25 21 .26 22.32 23.44 24.61
Clerical Monthly 3,509.19 3.684.65 3.868.88 4,062.33 4,265,44 Annually 42,110.30 44,21 5.82 46,426.61 48,747.94 51 ,1 85.34 Hourly 24.06 25.26 26.53 27.85 29.24
Clerical Monlhlv 4.170.31 4,378.83 4,597.77 4.827.66 5.069 04 Annually 50,043.76 52,545.94 55,173.24 57,931 .90 60,828.50 Hourly 24.06 25.26 26.53 27.85 29.24
Clerical Monthlv 4,170.31 4,378.83 4.597.77 4,827.66 5,069.04 Annually 50,043.76 52,545.94 55.173.24 57,931 .90 60,828.50 Hourlv 20.75 21.79 22.88 24.02 25.22
Clerical MonlfllV 3,597.06 3,776.91 3,965.75 4,164.04 4,372.24 Annuaffy 43,164.67 45,322.90 47,589.05 49,968.50 52,466.92 Hourly 29.28 30.74 32.28 33.89 35.59
Mgmt/Confidential Montllly 5.075.00 5,328.75 5,595.19 5,874.95 6.168 70 Annually 60,900.01 63,945.01 67,142.26 70,499,37 74.024,34 Hourtv 23.35 24.52 25.74 27,03 28.38
Unrepresented Monthlv 4.047.33 4.249.70 4.462.19 4.68529 4.919 56 Annually 48,568.00 50,996.40 53,546.22 56,223.53 59,034.71 Hourlv 19.97 20.96 22.01 23.11 24.27
Unrepresented Monthlv 3,460.68 3,633.69 3,815.37 4,006.14 4.206.45 Annually 41 ,527.87 43,604.26 45,784.48 48,073.70 50,477 39 Hourly 62.65 65.95 69.42 73.08 76.92
Unrepresented Monthly 10.860.08 11 ,431 .67 12,033.33 12.666.87 13.333.33 Annually ··::- Hourlv
Elected Monthfv
Annually
Hourly
Elected Monthly 300.00
Annually
Hourly 72.30 76.10 80.11 8-4 .32 88.78
Unrepresented Monlhly 12,531.18 13,190.71 13.88-4.96 14.615.75 15.385.00 ■ Annualfy '"
·'""lliillilllll Hourly
Elected Monthtv 60.00
Annually
Hourly 24.18 25.47 26.79 28.13 29.54
LPOA Monthly 4,192.00 4,414.18 4,643.71 4,875.90 5.119.69 Annually 50,304.00 52,970.11 55,724.56 58,510.79 61 ,436.33 Hourfv 50.87 53.41 56.08 58.88 61 .83
MgmtJConfidential Mon/hlv 8.816.82 9,257.66 9.720.55 10,206.57 10.716 90 Annually 105,801.86 111 ,091 .95 116,646.55 122,478.88 128,602 82 Hourly 25.24 26.50 27.83 29.22 30.68
Mgmt.lConfidential Monthly 4,374.70 4,593.44 4,823.11 5.064.28 5.317.48 Annually 52,496.41 55,121 .23 57,877.29 60,771 .18 63,809,71 Hourlv 19.00 19.95 20.95 22 00 23 10
Unrepresented Monlhfy 3,294.09 3,458.80 3,631 .74 3,81 3.33 4.003.99 AnnuaJ/y 39.529.13 41 .505.59 43.580.87 45,759.91 48,047.91 Hourly 15.50 16.28 17.09 17.94 18.84
AFSCME/Public Works Monthly 2,686.67 2.821 .00 2,962.05 3,110.15 3.265 66 Annually 32,240.00 33,852.00 35,544.60 37,321.83 39.187 92 Hourly 17.73 18.66 19.65 20.83 21 .86
AFSCME/Public Works Monthly 3,073.21 3,234.96 3,405.22 3.575.48 3.754.26 Annually 38.878.53 38,819.51 40,862.64 42,905.77 45,051.06 Hourly 49.28 51 .74 54.33 57.05 59 90
Unrepresented Monlhly 8,541 .70 8,968.79 9,41723 9.868.09 10,382.49 Annually 102,500.44 107,625.47 113.006.74 118.657.08 124.589.93 Hourly 26.21 27.52 28.89 30.34 31.86
Mgmt./Confidentlal Monff1/y 4,542.77 4.769.91 5.008.41 5.258,83 5,521 77 Annually 54,513.29 57,238.95 60,100.90 63.105.94 66.261 .24 Hourly 28.11 29.52 30.99 32.54 34 17
Mgmt/Confidential Monthry 4,872.74 5,1 16.38 5,372.20 5.640.81 5,922.85 Annuatry 58,472.88 61,396.53 64.466.35 67,689,67 71 ,074,15 Hourly 55.75 58.53 61 .46 64.53 67,76
Unrepresented Mon/h/v 9.662.84 10,145.98 10.653.28 11 ,185,94 11 ,745 24 Annually 115,954.04 121 ,751 .74 127,839.32 134.231 .29 i 40.9-i2.86 Hourty 31 .01 32.56 34.19 35.89 37.89
Mgmt./Confidentlal Monthly 5.374.52 5,643.25 5,925.41 6,221.68 6.532.76 Annually 84,494.23 67,718.94 71 .104.89 74.660.14 78,393 14 F

21.74 3,768.96
,s 227.52

25.84 4 478.72
53 744.60

30.71 5 322.49
&3,869.92

30.71 5 322.49
E3 869.92

26.49 4.590.66
55 090.27

Page 285 ends

- 24.45 25.74 27.09 28.44 29.87
Lead Maintenance Worker AFSCME/Pilbllc Works Mon1111v 4.237,78 4.460.82 4.695.60 4.930.38 5.176.90 Annually 50,853,35 53,529.84 56.347.20 58.164.56 62,122.78 Holl/Iv 24.45 25.74 27.09 28.44 29.87
Lead Parksnandscape Worker AFSCMEIPUbllc Works Moott,1. 4.237.78 4.460.82 4,695.60 4,930.38 5,176.90 Annually 50.853.35 53,529.84 56,347.20 59,164.56 62,122.79 Hourly 23.44 24.61 25,84 .27.13 23.49
Maintenance Mechanic AFSCME/Publlc Worb Mon/hly 4,062.19 4,.265.3D 4,478.58 4,702.49 4,937.61 Ama,r.,1/y 4B,748,23 51,183.54 53,742.72 56,4.29.BS 59,251.35 Ho•""' 18.77 19.71 20.70 21.73 22.82
Maintenance Worker I AFSCME/Public: Worl<s Mon/hlv 3.253.78 3,416.47 3,587.29 3,786.66 3,954.99 Annually 39,045.36 40,997.63 43,047,51 45,199.89 47,459.88 Hoorty 21.62 22.76 23.96 25.16 26.42
Maintenance Worl<er II AFSCMEIPUblic Works Manll!ly 3,748.30 3,945.58 4,15324 4,360.90 4,578.95 Allnuelly 44,979.59 47,346.94 49.6311.88 52,330.82 54,947.37 H""'1v 15.50 16.28 17.09 17.94 18.84 19.78
Office Assistant I c1er.ical ManUIIY 2,886.67 2,821.00 2.962.05 3,110.15 3,.265.68 3.428.94 Annually 32,240.00 33,852.DD 35,544.60 37,321.83 39,187.92 &1.141.32:
""'""' 58.13 61.03 84.09 67.29 70.65
Police Lieutenant Superviso,y Monthlv 10.()75.37 10,579.14 11,106.09 11,663.50 12,24667 Annually 120,804.41 126,949.63 133,297.11 139,961.98 148,960.06 Hourly 35.51 37.29 39.15 41.11 43.17
Police Commander Supervisory Manthlv 6,155.65 6,463A3 6,785.61 7.125.94 7,482.23 AnnuBliy 73,867.83 77.551.22 81,439.28 85,511.24 89,786.80 Houri• 33.73 35.42 37.19 39.05 41.00
Police Corporal LPOA _,,. 5,847.07 6,139.42 6,448.40 6,768.72 7,107.15 Annually 70,164.85 73,673.09 77,356.75 81,224.58 85,285.81 Houtfv 35,44 3721 39.07 41.03 43.oa
Police Corporal w/Oegree LPOA Monlhlv 6,142.85 6.449,99 6,772.49 7,111,12 7,486.67 AnnuBlfy 73,714.2D 77,399,91 81.269.90 85.333.40 89,600.07 Hourtv 19.65 20.63 21.68 22.75 23.88
Police Olspatciler LPDA Mo•""" 3,405.81 3,576.10 3,754.90 3,942.65 4,139.78 Annually 40,969.69 42.913.17 45,058.83 47,311.77 49,677.36 Hourlv 17.55 18.43 19.35 20.32 21.34
Police Office Asslslant II LPOA MonUw 3,042.61 3,194.74 3.354AB 3,52.l-20 3,698.31 Annually 38,511,30 38,336.86 40,253.71 42,266.39 44,379.71 ""'""' 26.43 27.75 29.14 30.60 32.13
Police Officer LPDA Monlhlv 4,581.31 4,810.38 5,050.9D 5,303.44 5,568.61 Annually 54,975,73 57,724,52 60,610.74 63,641.28 66,1123.35 Hourly 27.77 29.18 30.61 32.l4 33.75
Police Officer w/Oegree LPDA Mon!hlv 4,812.93 5,053.58 5,305.28 5,571.57 5,850.15 Annually 57,755.18 60.842.94 63,675.00 66,858.84 70,201.79 Hourly 17.38 18.25 19,17 20.12 21.13
Police Public Assistant LPOA ManUllv 3,013.25 3,163.91 3,322.11 3,488.21 3,682.62 Annually 38,158.97 37,958.92 39,88527 41,858.53 43,951.46 Hourlv 15.00 15,75 16.54 17.38 18.23
Police Records Assistant LPOA Moll""" 2,600.00 2.730,00 2.886.SO 3,009.83 3,160.32 Annually 31,200.00 32,760.0D 34,398.00 36,117.80 37,923.80 Hourlv 43.35 45.52 47.60 50.19 52.69
Police Sergeant supervisory Mon/hi• 7,514.35 7J19D,07 8,284.58 8,698.80 9,133.75 Annually 90,172.26 94,680.87 99,414.91 104.385.66 109,604.94 ""'""' 45.54 47.82 50.21 52.72 55.36
Police Seryeant w/Degree Supervisory Momhlv 7,894.18 8,28ll.85 8,703.31 9,138.47 9,595.40 Amlul!fly 94,729,88 99,486.311 104,439.70 109,681.88 115,144.76 ,,,,,.,,, 19.65 20.83 21,66 22.75 23.86
Public Services Officer LPOA .... ..,., 3,405,81 3,576.10 3,754.llO 3,942.85 4.139.78 Amaunlly 40,869.69 42.913.17 45.D58.83 47,311.77 49,677.36 HolJtly 24.62 25.85 27.15 28.50 29.9:l
Pubflc Works Lead AFSCMEIPUblic Works Monthly 4,268.llO 4,481.40 4,705.47 4,940.74 5,187.78 Allnuelly 51,218.01 53,776.81 56,485.85 59288.93 62.253.311 Houtfv 27.42 28.79 30.23 31.74 33.33
Public Works Street Supervisor Mgn,t,/Confi""ntial Monthlv 4,752.83 4,990A7 5.240.llO 5.502.00 5,777.1D Annuolly 57,033,113 59,885,88 82,879.97 68,1123.97 89,325.16 Hounv 29.43 30.90 32,44 34.07 35.77
Public Works Supenntendant MgmtJConfldonllal M.,,,,,., 5,100,81 5,355.85 5,623.64 5,904,82 6,200.06 Amaually 61,209.69 84,270.17 67.483.68 70,857.85 74,400.78 Hourlv 28.71 30.14 31.65 33.23 34.89
Public Works Supe:visor Water Division MgmtJConlidantlal Monthly 4,975.62 5,224.40 5,485.62 5,759.90 6,047.9D Annually 59,7D7,45 82,892,82 85,827.47 69,118.84 72,574.78 ""'""' 15.60 18,'37 17.19 18.05 18.96 19.90
Rec.-eation Coordinator Clorli:al _,It!,. 2.703,17 2,838.33 2,98025 3,129.26 3,285.72 3450.01 Annually 32.438,08 34,059.98 35,782,98 37,551.13 39,4.28.69 41 400,12 ,.,,,,..., 17.03 17.88 18.78 19.72 20.70 21.74
Recreation Specialist Clerical MonUllv 2.952.lll 3,099.61 3,254.58 3,417.32 3,588.18 3 767.59 AnnuDHy 3S,424,09 37,195.29 39,055.06 41,007.81 43,05820 45,11.11 HoUllv 23.65 24.63 28.D7 27.37 23.74
Recreation Superintenoent MgmtJConfidentlal Monthly 4,096.50 4,303.42 4,518.59 4,744.52 4,981.75 Annlliily 49,181.94 51,641.04 54,223.09 56,934.25 59,760.96 Halllf11 19,76 2D,74 21.78 22.87 24.01 25.22
Senior Account Clerk Cterlcal Me"""" 3,424.54 3,595.77 3,775.56 3,954.34 4,162.55 4 370.88 lmnualiy 41,094.51 43.14924 45,306.70 47,572.04 49,950.64 52 448,17 Hr,,""' 43.86 46.05 48.36 50.76 53.32
Senior Ac,;ountanl MgmtJC<>nfidentlal M•nlhlv 7,803.26 7,983.42 8,382.59 8,601,72 9,241.81

Page 286 ends

91,239.10

26.56 Senior Administrative Analyst Clerical 4,604.27

55.251 .29

28.02 Senior Administrative AnalysUComm. Devlop, Clerical 4,856.08

58.272.95

15.50 Senior Offtce Assistant Clarical 2,686.67
32,240.00

33.56 Senior Planner Mgmt./Confidential 5,816.91
69,802.98

20.20 Street Sweeper Operator AFSCME/Public Works 3,500.97 42,011 .64
21 .23
Uti6ty Wor1<er t AFSCME/Public Works 3,679.20
44,150,41

23.44 Utility Worker II AFSCME/Public Works 4,062.19
48,746.23

28.49 Water/Waslewaster Operator I AFSCME/Public Works 4,936.49

59.261 .87

32.30 Water/Wastewaster Operator II AFSCME/Public Works 5,599.43 67,193,16

36.17 Water/Wastewaster Operator Ill AFSCME/Public Works 6,269.92 75,239,03

36.41 WaterPNastewalef-Manager Mgmt./Confidential
Water/Wastewater Manager
Water/Wastewataer Operator OIT (in training)
• Degree includes: AA, BA, Intermediate or Advanced Post Cer1ificates. No compounding for multiple degrees or certificates as slated in the MOU's.

Classification of Office Assistant I, Office Assistant II, Administrative Assistant, Recreation Specialist, Recreation Coordinator, Administrative Analyst and Sr. Administrative Analyst positions are not specific to one depar1ment. Their positions can be used in any of the City's various departments and/or may be used by milliple departments as determined by the City Manager.

Positions are filled on a full-time or part-time basis as determined by the City Manager.

PART-TIME MASTER SALARY SCHEDULE
STEP

CLASSIFICATION
A B C
Administrative Analvst 18.82 19.76 20.75
Administrative Assistant 16,23 17.04 17.89
Building
~
Maintenance Worker 15.50 16.28 17.09
15,50 46,;!8 17.09
Lifeouard 15,50 16.50 17.09
Maintenance Worker I 15.88 16.67 17.51
Office Assistant I 15.50 16.28 17.09
Office Assistant II 15.50 16.28 17.09
Police Disoalcher 16,55 17.38 18.25
Police Records Assistant 15,50 16.28 17.09
Recreation Leader 15.50 16.28 17.09
Recreation Soecialist 15.50 16.28 17,09
Reserve Police Officer 25.00 26.25 27.56
Sr. Administrative Analyst 20.78 21 .82 22.91
95,801.05 100,591.10 105,620.66 110,901 ,69

27.89 29.29 30.75 32 29 33.90
4,834.49 5.076.21 5.330.02 5.596.52 5 876.35

56.013.85 60,914.55 63.960,27 67,156.29 "O 516.20

29.42 30.89 32.43 34,05 35,76
5,098.88 5,353.83 5,621 .52 5,902 59 6 197.72
61 .186.59 64,245.92 67,458.22 70.831 13 :• 372.69

16.28 17.09 17.94 18 84 19.78
2,821.00 2.962.05 3,11 0.15 3,265 66 3 428.94
33,852.00 35,544.60 37,321 ,83 39. 187,92 ,1 147,32
35,24 37.00 38.85 40,79
6,107.76 6,413.15 6.733.81 7,070.50
73,293.13 76,957.78 80,805.67 84,845,95
21 .21 22.27 23.38 24.55
3,676.02 3,859.82 4,052.81 4.255,45
44,112.22 46,317.83 48,633 72 51 ,065.41

22.29 23.40 24.57 25.80
3,863.16 4.056.32 4,259.14 4,472 09
46,357,94 48.675.83 51 ,109.62 53,665 10

24.61 25.84 27.13 28,49
4,265.30 4,478.56 4.702.49 4,937 61
51 ,183.54 53,742.72 56.429.86 59,25 1 35

29.92 31 .41 32.98 34,63
5,185,41 5,444.68 5,716.92 6,002.76
62,224.97 65,336.22 68,603.03 72,033,18

33.92 35.62 37.40 39.27

5.879.40 6,173.37 6.482.04 6,8061
70,552,82 74,080.46 77,784.48 81 ,673 71

37.98 39.88 41 ,87 43.97
6,583.41 6.912.59 7,258.21 7.62113

79.000,98 82.951 .03 87,098.58 91.453 51

38.;!; 49.14 42.14 44 2i
~

6.626.+4 6,967.93 H9UB H•- 83,484 .39 - 92,QU 63

42.14 44.25 46.46
D E

21.79 22.88

18.79 19.73

17.94 18.84

17.94 18,84
17 ,94 18.84
18,38 19.30

17.94 18.84

19.16 20,12

17.94 18.84

28.94 30.39

24.06 25.26

Page 287 ends

AGENDA ITEM:

MEETING DATE:

PREPARED BY:

REVIEWED BY:

STAFF REPORT
Public Hearing - Conditional Use Permit Application No. 2022-01 and Site Plan and Design Review Application No. 2022-02 - Single family, two-story dwelling on an undersized on property located at 1547 F Street.

May 16, 2023
Miguel Galvez, Contract City Planner
Christopher Lopez, Interim City Manager
RECOMMENDATION:

Adopt City Council Resolution No. 2023-_, approving Conditional Use Permit No. 2022-01 and adopt City Council Resolution No. _, approving Site Plan and Design Review Application No. 2022-02, to develop a two-story, single family dwelling on an undersized parcel in the R-2 Zoning District on property located at 1547 F Street, Livingston, CA (APN No.: 024-173-013).

BACKGROUND ANO DISCUSSION:

The applicant and owner, Juan Maldonado, is proposing to develop a two-story 3,282 square foot residential dwelling consisting of four bedrooms, 5 bathrooms, a recreation room, a terrace/patio and an attached garage on a 4,391 square foot parcel.

The subject site is generally located on the north side of F Street, west of 5th Street at 1547 F Street. The project is located in the R-2, Medium Density Zoning District and has a General Plan designation of MD, Medium Density Residential.

An alley right-of-way is located along the western property line and F Street is located along the southern property line. Full street improvements have been installed along F Street and the adjacent alley has been graded and paved. F Street is developed with curb, gutter and sidewalk. Public water and sewer service is available to the project site.

The subject parcel is developed with a 120 square foot accessory structure, a six-foot high wood fencing along the alley right-of-way way and rear property line, a three-foot high wrought iron and brick fencing along F Street, and a curb entrance to accommodate a vehicular access onto the property. The existing accessory structure on the subject property is planned to be removed prior to development of the project.

The property contains an entrance driveway onto F Street that currently provides vehicular access to both the subject property and the adjoining property at 856 5th Street (APN 024-173-01 4), which is also owned by the applicant. This existing driveway is proposed to continue to serve both the new dwelling at 1547 F Street, as well as provide vehicular access between the dwelling at 856 5th Street and F Street.

Page 1 ends

Page 288 ends

ANALYSIS:

The subject parcel is considered a legal non-conforming lot as its size of 4,391 square feet is under the 5,500 square foot minimum size for lots in the R-2 Medium Density Residential Zoning District. Development of residential lots that are nonconforming is permitted when the development conforms to the property's zoning district's development standards.

In addition, development of a single-family dwelling in the R-2 zoning district may be permitted by the Planning Commission with the approval of a Conditional Use Permit per LMC Section 5-3-15 - Table 2 Residential Uses, Dwelling, single-family. Approval of a Site Plan and Design Review Application by the Planning Commission and City Council is also required for all new development in the R-2 zoning district.

The development project, as submitted, meets the City's Zoning Development Standards with respect to setbacks, building height, lot coverage, off-street parking, and provision of private open space. The construction style, elevations, and colors are consistent with the residential development in the neighborhood.

Staff referred this proposal to various departments and agencies for comment and possible conditions for approval. The City Engineer responded with a memo dated February 1, 2023, with a list of recommended Conditions of Approval. This memo is included in the attached Resolution and incorporated as Conditions of Approval. The majority of these comments are standard Conditions of Approval required by local and State rules and regulations.

Also required by the City, consistent with all other new development, are Conditions of Approval requiring payment of applicable development impact fees and annexation to Capital Facilities District CFO 2017-01 (Urban Services).

ISSUES
No significant development issues were identified.

Single-family dwellings surround the project site on all sides. The proposed project is consistent with both the development character in the neighborhood and with the City's General Plan and zoning classification for the neighborhood.

One minor issue, pertaining to vehicular access, was identified and addressed. Each residential parcel is required to have direct vehicular access onto a public street. For 856 5th Street, vehicular access onto a street is currently provided through the subject property at 1547 F Street.

The applicant is proposing to expand the existing driveway entrance and travel lane to serve both parcels through a reciprocal access easement, which will be prepared by a licensed land survey and recorded. City staff believes that a recorded reciprocal access easement serves to protect the existing vehicular access of the property at 856 5th Street onto F Street in the event that property ownership changes in the future. The subject property and adjoining property at 856 5th Street are presently owned by the applicant. The applicant is in agreement with this requirement.

GENERAL PLAN
The 1999 Livingston General Plan includes the following Residential Land Use Objectives.

A. Designate and allow for the development of a wide range of residential housing types in the City including housing for middle and upper income families to meet the needs of all {CWl289!4.I} Page 2 of?

Page 289 ends

Livingston residents.

Policy 1. b. Medium Density Residential contemplates a range of 7. 6 to 11. 9 units per gross acre. The subject site is proposing one unit at a density of 9. 9 units per gross acre, which is within the development range of the Medium Density Residential Designation.

B. Promote stable, high quality residential standards. The project will serve to develop a vacant lot in an area that is planned for medium density residential development densities.

Policy 2. b. Development standards for interface between multi-family and residential and single family residential.

Multi-family parking areas are required to have a landscaped setback of 10 feet when adjacent to next to R-1, single family zoned properties. As the proposed project abuts property also zoned R-2, the 10-foot landscape setback is not required for the proposed development.

Policy 4 Site development techniques should be encouraged which ensure a mix of housing types throughout the community. The neighborhood is zoned R-2 and is developed with a mixture of single family and multi-family dwellings. The proposed four-bedroom single family dwelling will be two story in a neighborhood area that is predominately developed with single story, single family dwellings. The proposed project conforms to the R-2 zoning district development standards.

The 2016 adopted Housing Element identified the following Housing goals and Policies.

C. Goal 1: Housing and Economic Diversity. Promote the development of a balanced residential environment, including a range of housing types, with access to employment opportunities, community facilities, and adequate services to meet the needs of residents and persons working in Livingston.

Policies:

1. 1) Encourage the development of a variety of housing types at various prices in order to maintain a diverse housing stock for residents of all income levels.

1.6} Maintain an adequate housing stock to accommodate increases in the work force. 1 . 7) Encourage both commercial and residential development in Livingston in order to maintain a balance between jobs and housing.

The project will result in the development of one new market rate dwelling unit that will be located near the City's downtown area.

D. Goal 3: Encourage the development of housing to meet the needs of lower- and moderateincome households, particularly those with special needs.

Policies:

3. 2) Provide technical assistance to developers of affordable housing for lower-income or special needs populations.

The proposed dwelling unit will serve to provide housing opportunities to a large household. City staff provided guidance in the design of the project to ensure compliance with development standards.
{CWl28914.I} Page3 of7

Page 290 ends

ZONING ORDINANCE
Site Plan and Design Review - The property is zoned R-2 and, as such, the Livingston Municipal Code requires all new construction to undergo Site Plan and Design Review consideration by the Planning Commission for a recommendation to the City Council for final consideration. The Site Plan and Design Review application allows the City to evaluate the development proposal to assure compatibility, harmony in appearance with the neighborhood, reduction of any negative impacts, and orderly development of the area.

The dwelling will incorporate an entrance porch, a tile roof, and stucco walls with exterior decorative wall banding. The project site will also incorporate landscaping areas in front of the dwelling unit. The rear of the dwelling will be developed with a patio/terrace and private open space. The building height of the patio/terrace will meet the setback requirements for one and two-story portions of the building.

Staff is of the opinion that the design, height, materials, and development intensity is consistent with the development in the surrounding neighborhood.

Use Permit -As discussed earlier, the City's land use matrix table in the Zoning Ordinance (LMC 5-3-15: Table 2 - Residential Uses), a single family dwelling in the R-2 zone is permitted after approval of a Conditional Use Permit.

Livingston Municipal Code Section 5-6-9 USE PERMITS, TEMPORARY AND CONDITIONAL contains the provisions for considering Use Permits.

Section 5-6-9 (F) Conditional use permits. States:
"1. Use permits that are revocable, conditional or valid for a term may be issued for any of the uses or purposes for which such permits are required or permitted by the terms of this section. Because of their unusual characteristics, conditional uses require special consideration so that they may be located and developed properly with respect to the intent and purpose of this title and to their effect on surrounding properties. Conditional use permits require a determination of findings and conditions by the Planning Commission.

2. The Planning Commission may designate such conditions in connection with conditional and revocable use permits as it deems necessary to carry out the purpose of this title, and may require tangible guarantees or evidence that such renditions are being or will be complied with. These conditions may include, but not be limited to:
(a) Dedication of right-of-way, setback, curbs, gutters and sidewalks; (b) Improvement of vehicle access to the subject property to city standards; (c) Regulation of height, number of stories;
(d) Regulation of the placement of the use or building of the subject property; (e) Regulation of the nature, hours of operation, extent of use; (f) Regulation of lighted community sports facilities for extended hours of use; (g) Regulation as to transferability of the use; and
(h) Regulation of landscaping for the protection of adjoining and nearby properties.

Section 5-6-9 (I) Criteria. In considering an application for conditional use permits, the following criteria shall be as follows.
{CW128914.I} Page 4 of7

Page 291 ends

1. A conditional use permit shall not be granted for the use unreasonably incompatible with permitted uses in the area considering damage and nuisance from light sources, noise, smoke, odor, dust or vibration, hazard resulting from unusual volume or character of traffic, or congestion of a large number of persons or vehicles.

2. A conditional use permit must be considered in relationship to its effect on the general plan for the area in which it is to be located. The conditional use applied for must be in conformance with the general plan land use map and policies.

3. Findings required for approval shall include:
(a) The site for the proposed use is adequate in size and shape to accommodate said use and all yards, spaces, walls and fences, parking, loading, landscaping and other features required by the applicable zoning district; (b) The site for the proposed use is served by streets and highways adequate to carry the quantity and kind of traffic generated by the proposed use; (c) Public facilities are currently adequate to serve the proposed use or improvements are included in an approved capital improvement plan or otherwise will be complete prior to the issuance of building permits; and ( d) The proposed development is consistent with the general plan. If granted, it should be made subject to those conditions necessary to preserve the general welfare, not the individual welfare, of any particular applicant." The proposed residential development is consistent with the surrounding residential development which is located in the R-1 and R-2 zoning districts. The proposed residential development's development density of 9.9 units per gross acre and consistent with the General Plan's Land Use designation of MD, Medium Density Residential, which contemplates a range of 7.6 to 11.9 units per gross acre.

Staff believes the Findings required for approval of the Use Permit can be met per the discussion provided below in bold print.
( a) The site for the proposed use is adequate in size and shape to accommodate said use and all yards, spaces, walls and fences, parking, loading, landscaping and other features required by the applicable zoning district;
The proposed site plan, elevations for a single family dwelling meets all development standards in the R-2 zoning district.
(b) The site for the proposed use is served by streets and highways adequate to carry the quantity and kind of traffic generated by the proposed use; The site fronts on F Street, a fully developed public street that was designed to carry the traffic of the proposed single-family dwelling. (c) Public facilities are currently adequate to serve the proposed use or improvements are included in an approved capital improvement plan or otherwise will be complete prior to the issuance of building permits; and
Public Facilities and utilities are available and adequate to serve the subject site. (d) The proposed development is consistent with the general plan. If granted, it should be {CWJ28914.J} Page 5 of?

Page 292 ends

made subject to those conditions necessary to preserve the general welfare, not the individual welfare, of any particular applicant."
The proposed site plan, elevation and conditions of approval will ensure that the development will conform to City development standards for development within the residential zoning district and preserve the general welfare of the community.

In conclusion, although the subject parcel size of 4,391 square feet does not meet the 5,500 square foot minimum size, its proposed design meets the development standards of the R-2 zoning district. Given the City's strong need for more dwelling units to meet housing goals, staff is very supportive of this request.

PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION AND RECOMMENDATION:

The Planning Commission held a Public Hearing on March 14, 2023, to consider Conditional Use Permit Application No.2022-01 and Site Plan and Design Review Application No. 2022-02, a single family dwelling at 1547 F Street. The Commissioner asked if the home would meet setbacks from the alley. Staff replied that the new dwelling will meet the setback requirements.

The Commission asked about the location of the trash cans. The trash service would consist of garbage totes which will be placed in the alley. The Commission asked if the City could prevent the creation of minimum lot sizes to prevent the creation of substandard lots. Staff replied that the lots were created under an older standard and new subdivision lots are required to meet the current lot size standards. The Commissioner did not see any problems with the proposal.

Resident Diego Castillo spoke during the public hearing and commented that there are other lots that are substandard and that the City is following a good process for considering the development of substandard lots.

The Planning Commission on a vote of 5-0, approved Planning Commission Resolution No. 2023- 03 recommending City Council approval of Conditional Use Permit Application No. 2022-01 and approved on a vote of 5-0 Planning Commission Resolution 2023-04, recommending City Council approval of the Site Plan and Design Review Application No. 2022-02 to the City Council, subject to Findings and Conditions of Approval.

ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW:

The proposed Project is eligible for a Categorical Exemption under two classifications of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines: Class 3, Section 15303{a) - New Construction or Conversion of Small Structures (single family dwelling). Class 32 - Infill development Section 15332 - In-fill Development Projects. This Exemption applies to Projects within the City Limits that are consistent with the General Plan and Zoning Ordinance, provided all utilities and City services are available, no more than 5 acres in size on land with no value as habitat for endangered, rare, or threatened species. The project site is within a developed urban location and complies with all of the above listed conditions to qualify for this categorical exemption. This development would also have no significant effects relating to traffic, noise, air, or water quality. A Notice of Exemption citing these categorical exemptions is recommended. {CWl28914.l) Page 6 of7

Page 293 ends

FISCAL IMPACT:

The Project would increase property taxes and assessments to the City. Staff costs associated with processing the Conditional Use Permit and Site Plan and Design Review applications are subject to cost reimbursement from the applicant.

RECOMMENDATION:

The subject existing property is small, but the proposed design meets the development standards of the R-2 zoning district. Given the City's strong need for more rental units, staff is very supportive of this request and recommends Council approval.

Staff and the Planning Commission recommend the City Council adopt Resolution 2023-_, approving Conditional Use Permit Application No. 2022-01, and also adopt Resolution 2023- _, approving Site Plan and Design Review Application No. 2022-02, subject to Conditions of Approval and based on the Findings included in the staff report and the attached resolutions.

ATTACHMENTS:

1. City Council Resolution No. 2023-_., approving Conditional Use Permit 2022-01 Exhibit "A", Conditions of Approval
Exhibit "B", 02/01/23 Memo from City Engineer Mario Gouveia.

2. City Council Resolution No. 2023 -_.approving Site Plan and Design Review Exhibit "A", Conditions of Approval
Exhibit "B", 02/01/23 Memo from City Engineer Mario Gouveia.

3. Aerial Vicinity Map, General Plan, Zoning Map and Assessor's Plat Map

4. Site Plan, Floor Plan, and Elevations

5. Draft Notice of Exemption

6. Planning Commission Resolution No. 2023-03

7. Planning Commission Resolution No. 2023-04
(CWl28914.l) Page 7 of?

Page 294 ends

ATTACHMENT 1
RESOLUTION 2023-

RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LIVINGSTON APPROVING CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT APPLICATION NO. 2022-01 TO DEVELOP A TWO STORY, 3,282 SQUARE FOOT, SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING ON AN UNDERSIZED PARCEL IN THE R-2 ZONING DISTRICT ON PROPERTY LOCATED AT 1547 F STREET, LIVINGSTON, CA, (APN: 024-173-013)
WHEREAS, the project site is zoned R-2 (Medium Density Residential}, and has a General Plan designation of Medium Density Residential according to the official Zoning Map of the City of Livingston and the 1999 Livingston General Plan; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to Livingston Municipal Code ("LMC") Section 5-3-15 - Table 2 Residential Uses, Dwelling, single-family. Development of a single-family dwelling in the R-2 zoning district may be permitted by the Planning Commission with the approval of a Conditional Use Permit and Site Plan and Design Review Application; and
WHEREAS, LMC Section 5-6-9 requires a Conditional Use Permit for "certain land uses that generally have a distinct impact on the area in which they are located, and/or are capable of creating special problems for bordering properties unless given special attention"; and the proposed construction of a single family dwelling on an undersized parcel in the R-2 Zoned lot is deemed such a land use; and
WHEREAS, Juan Maldonado, owner and applicant, has applied for a Conditional Use Permit to construct a single family dwelling on an undersized property in the R-2 Zoning District on property located on the north side of F Street, west of 5th Street at 1547 F Street, Livingston, CA (Assessor Parcel Number 024-173-013); and
WHEREAS, staff has reviewed the project with reference to the 1999 General Plan and the Zoning Ordinance (specifically Sections 5-6-7 "C" thru "E"); and finds that, based on the evidence documented within the associated staff report and proceedings of the public hearing, the proposed use, its site plan and design, is generally consistent with the General Plan, is permitted and complies with the Zoning Ordinance in that the site plan and design meets the standards and requirements; and
WHEREAS, the following findings listed in LMC Section 5-6-9 (I) for approving the Use Permit can be made as follows:
(a) The site for the proposed use is adequate in size and shape to accommodate said use and all yards, spaces, walls and fences, parking, loading, landscaping and other featums required by the applicable zoning district;
The proposed site plan, elevations for the single family dwelling meets all development standards in the R-2 zoning district.
(b) The site for the proposed use is served by streets and highways adequate to carry /lie quantity and kind of traffic generated by the proposed use; The project site fronts on F Street, a fully developed public street that was designed to carry the traffic of the proposed single-family dwelling.

Page I of 4

Page 295 ends

(c) Public facilities are currently adequate to serve the proposed use or improvements are included in an approved capital improvement plan or otherwise will be complete prior to the issuance of building permits; and
Public Facilities and utilities are available and adequate to serve the subject site. (d) The proposed development is consistent with the general plan. If granted, it should he made subject to those conditions necessary to preserve the general welfare, not t/Je individual welfare, of any particular applicant."
The proposed site plan, elevation and conditions of approval will ensure that the development will conform to City development standards for development within the residential zoning district and preserve the general welfare of the community.

WHEREAS, a public hearing for the proposed project has been properly noticed by posting, a newspaper ad, and a mailing to adjacent properties within 300 feet of the site; and WHEREAS, the proposed project is categorically exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act ("CEQA") under Section 15303 (b) New Construction of no more than four dwellings per site and under Section 15332 In-Fill Development Projects and a Notice of Exemption will be filed with the Merced County Clerk within five (5) days of project approval; and WHEREAS, staff has reviewed the project with reference to the 1999 General Plan and the Zoning Ordinance (specifically Sections 5-6-7 "C" thru "E"); and finds that, based on the evidence documented within the associated staff report and proceedings of the public hearing, the proposed use, its site plan and design, is generally consistent with the General Plan, is permitted and complies with the Zoning Ordinance in that the site plan and design meets the zoning standard and requirements (including those specifically referenced above).

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Livingston City Council hereby adopts Resolution 2023-_, approving the Conditional Use Application No. 2022-01 -A Single Family Dwelling at 1547 F Street, including the submitted site plan, floor plan, and elevations.

BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Conditions of Approval within City Council Resolution 2023-_, Exhibit A and B, are hereby approved.

Page 2 of 4 ends

Page 296 ends

Passed and adopted this 16th day of May, 2023 by the following vote:

AYES:

NOES:

ABSENT:

ABSTAIN:

ATTEST:

Jose A. Moran, Mayor
Of the City of Livingston
I hereby certify that the foregoing resolution was regularly introduced, passed, and adopted at a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Livingston this 16th day of May, 2023.

Monica Cisneros, Deputy City Clerk
Of the City of Livingston
Page3 of 4

Page 297 ends

Exhibit A
Conditions of Approval
Conditional Use Permit Application No. CUP No. 2022-01 - A Single Family Dwelling at 1547 F Street

EXHIBIT A

1. The Developer shall comply with all federal, state and local laws, policies, standards and requirements applicable to such a use and obtain a building permit and all other permit applicable to such a use and shall pay all fees and exactions applicable to such a use; and

2. The Developer shall include residential sprinklers in the development consistent with the requirements of the Merced County Fire Department and shall comply with other Fire Department requirements and standards; and

3. The Developer shall comply with the 17 Conditions of the City Engineer as listed in the Memo dated February 1, 2023, attached hereto and made a part of this Resolution; and

4. The Developer shall indemnify, defend and hold harmless the City and its officials, officers, employees, agents, and consultants from any and al/ legal or administrative actions or other proceedings challenging this approval or any subsequent approval associated with this project; and

5. The Developer of this site shall be consistent with approved plans, elevations, and colors. Minor variations from approved plans, elevations, and colors may be allowed at the review and approval of City staff; and

6. The Developer shall submit final landscape plans for City staff review and approval specifying plant selections, size and irrigation consistent with the preliminary landscape concept submitted as part of the application and described in the associated staff report and shall pay the landscape inspection fee to insure installation was done according to plan; and

7. Any exterior lighting shall be submitted for City staff review and approval. Such lighting shall be directed to areas on the subject property itself and shall avoid shinning toward adjacent properties; and

8. The Developer shall comply with all requirements of PG&E as it relates to the construction of the project; and

9. The Developer and/or Operator shall keep the site free from trash and debris and shall maintain the premises in a clean and orderly manner.

10. The Developer shall annex this Project site into the Community Facilities District (CFD) No. 2017-01 prior to the issuance of the Certificate of Occupancy, including payment of administrative costs associated with the annexation proceedings.

Page4 of4

Page 298 ends

GOUVEIA ENGINEERING

MEMORANDUM
TO:

FROM:

Miguel Galvez, Contract City Plan1\ (
Mario B. Gouveia, City Engineer f\)6t
Exh i b it B
SUBJECT: Engineering Response to Project Referral for Juan Maldonado CUP 2022-01 and SPDR 2022- 02 for 1547 F Street, Livingston CA - REVISED
DATE: February 1, 2023
CC: Jennifer Riedeman, Finance Director/ Acting City Manager The following are Engineering's comments and/or Conditions of Approval for Conditional Use Permit 2022-01 and Site Plan Design Review 2022-02 for 1547 F Street in the City of Livingston.

CUP 2022-01 and SPDR 2022-02

1. The developer/applicant shall prepare improvement plans (separate from the building plans) for all applicable site development including, but not limited to, demolition, site grading and drainage, utilities, landscape, on-site and off-site (street and alley frontage) improvements.

2. Public improvements shall conform to the latest edition of the City Improvement Standards and Specifications and any modifications thereto approved by the City Engineer in place at the time of construction. Improvements shall conform to other City adopted documents including the General Plan, Water Master Plan, Sewer Master Plan and Storm Water Master Plan. The work shall comply with all applicable State, Federal, and local laws and regulations.

3. All existing and proposed property lines shall be shown on the improvement plans.

4. Applicant shall prepare an Erosion Sediment Control Plan (ESCP) pursuant to the City of Livingston's MS4 Phase II Permit requirements for construction activities.

5. Unless exempt, prepare and provide volumetric sizing calculations, low development impact (LID) measures, operation and maintenance plan (O&M), and statement of responsibility agreement for storm water management in accordance with the City of Livingston's Post-construction Standards Plan and pursuant to the City's Phase II MS4 Permit requirements.

6. Unless exempt, prepare a Dust Control Plan (DCP) and file the Plan with the San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District for construction activities pursuant to Regulation VIII (Rules 8011-8081 ).

7. A soils report prepared by a California registered geotechnical engineer with recommendations for the structural sections for slabs, excavation, compaction, clearing and grubbing requirements, etc.

8. Prepare any applicable grading and encroachment permits for the project. Applicant shall pay the permit fee, plan check and inspection fees, and furnish improvement securities pursuant to the City's improvement standards, municipal code, and ordinances.
456 SIXTH STREET• GUSTINE, CALIFORNIA 95322 • TELEPHONE (209) 854-3300 • FAX (209) 854-3600

Page 299 ends

Memorandum
Page2

9. Applicant shall pay all applicable development impact fees for Municipal Facilities, Police, Fire Protection, Streets and Bridges, Water, Domestic Wastewater, Storm Drainage, and Parks.

10. Construct all proposed connections for dry utilities underground and within required easements by the respective utilities.

11. Developer shall replace/repair existing sidewalk, driveway approach, curb and gutter not meeting ADA and/or City standards along F Street extending the length of the property line.

12. The proposed common use driveway with the adjacent 856 51h Street residence is not allowed by the Standard Specification Section 3.06(A).4 of the City of Livingston 2010 Improvement Standards. The City standards require a separate driveway for each lot but the Applicant could construct a common use driveway for the 856 5th Street and 1547 F Street parcels as approved by City Planning and subject to a reciprocal access easement prepared by a California licensed surveyor. Applicant shall provide the easement plat and legal and all other required documents as determined by the City Surveyor for review and approval of the easement and recording thereof. The easement shall be prepared and recorded prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy for this project.

13. Storm runoff from on8 site development shall be conveyed through new curb drains into the existing gutter to gravity drain to the nearest catch basin.

14. Connect to the existing 8-inch water main in the alleyway along the west side of the property or as approved by the City Engineer, for all proposed domestic, irrigation, and fire flows. Developer shall incorporate water recirculation for residential sprinkler system at the water service or onsite plumbing. Water connections shall include shutoff valves, corporation stops, and water meters.

15. Connect to the existing 8-inch sewer main in the alleyway along the west side of the property or as approved by the City Engineer, for sanitary service.

16. Applicant shall relocate any existing public facilities to the street or alley side to clear any new fence lines constructed as part of the project.

17. Repairs to any damaged City Facilities such as road/alley pavement, valley gutter, sidewalk, curb and gutter caused by construction and construction-related activities shall be completed as required by the City of Livingston and at developer's sole cost.
456 SIXTH STREET• GUSTINE, CALIFORNIA 95322 • TELEPHONE (209) 854c3300 • FAX (209) 854-3600

Page 300 ends

ATTACHMENT 2
RESOLUTION 2023-

RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LIVINGSTON APPROVING SITE PLAN AND DESIGN REVIEW APPLICATION NO. 2022-02 TO DEVELOP A TWO STORY, 3,282 SQUARE FOOT, SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING ON AN UNDERSIZED PARCEL IN THE R-2 ZONING DISTRICT ON PROPERTY LOCATED AT 1547 F STREET, LIVINGSTON, CA, (APN: 024-173-013)
WHEREAS, the project site is zoned R-2 (Medium Density Residential), and has a General Plan designation of Medium Density Residential according to the official Zoning Map of the City of Livingston and the 1999 Livingston General Plan; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to Livingston Municipal Code ("LMC") Section 5-3-15 - Table 2 Residential Uses, Dwelling, single-family. Development of a single-family dwelling in the R-2 zoning distnct may be permitted by the Planning Commission and City Council with the approval of a Conditional Use Permit and a Site Plan and Design Review Application; and WHEREAS, LMC Section 5-6-7 requires the approval of a Site Plan and Design Review application for new structures within the R-2 zoning district to assure compatibility, harmony in appearance in neighborhoods, reduction of negative impacts of nonaesthetic development, and orderly development of the community; and
WHEREAS, Juan Maldonado, owner and applicant, has applied for a Site Plan and Design Review application to construct a single family dwelling on property in the R-2 Zoning District on property located on the north side of F Street, west of 5th Street at 1547 F Street, Livingston, CA (Assessor Parcel Number 024-173-013); and
WHEREAS, staff has reviewed the project with reference to the 1999 General Plan and the Zoning Ordinance (specifically Sections 5-6-7 "C" thru "E"); and finds that, based on the evidence documented within the associated staff report and proceedings of the public hearing, the proposed use, its site plan and design, is generally consistent with the General Plan, is permitted and complies with the Zoning Ordinance in that the site plan and design meets the standards and requirements; and
WHEREAS, a public hearing for the proposed project has been properly noticed by posting, a newspaper ad, and a mailing to adjacent properties within 300 feet of the site; and WHEREAS, the proposed project is categorically exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act ("CEQA"} under Section 15303 (b) New Construction of no more than four dwellings per site and under Section 15332 ln"Fill Development Projects and a Notice of Exemption will be filed with the Merced County Clerk within five {5) days of project approval; and WHEREAS, staff has reviewed the project with reference to the 1999 General Plan and the Zoning Ordinance (specifically Sections 5-6"7 "C" thru "E"); and finds that, based on the evidence documented within the associated staff report and proceedings of the public hearing, the proposed use, its site plan and design, is generally consistent with the General Plan, is permitted and complies with the Zoning Ordinance in that the site plan and design meets the zoning standard and requirements.

Page 1 ends

Page 301 ends

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Livingston City Council hereby adopts Resolution 2023"_, approving the Site Plan and Design Review Application No. 2022"02 - A Single Family Dwelling at 1547 F Street, including the submitted site plan, floor plan, and elevations.

BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Conditions of Approval within City Council Resolution 2023"_, Exhibit A and B, are hereby approved.

Passed and adopted this 16th day of May, 2023 by the following vote:

AYES:

NOES:

ABSENT:

ABSTAIN:

ATTEST:

Monica Cisneros, Deputy City Clerk
Of the City of Livingston
Page2 of3

Page 302 ends

Exhibit A
Site Plan and Design Review
Application No. SPDR No. 2022-02 -
A Single Family Dwelling at 1547 F Street

EXHIBIT A

3. The Developer shall comply with the 17 Conditions of the City Engineer as listed in the Memo dated February 1, 2023, attached hereto and made a part of this Resolution; and

4. The Developer shall indemnify, defend and hold harmless the City and its officials, officers, employees, agents, and consultants from any and all legal or administrative actions or other proceedings challenging this approval or any subsequent approval associated with this project; and

8. The Developer shall comply with all requirements of PG&E as it relates to the construction of the project; and

9. The Developer and/or Operator shall keep the site free from trash and debris and shall maintain the premises in a clean and orderly manner.

10. The Developer shall annex this Project site into the Community Facilities District (CFO) No. 2017-01 prior to the issuance of the Certificate of Occupancy, including payment of administrative costs associated with the annexation proceedings.

Page 3 ends

Page 303 ends

GOUVEIA ENGINEERING

MEMORANDUM
TO:

FROM:

Miguel Galvez, Contract City Planl\
Mario B. Gouveia, City Engineer Not f
Exhib it B
SUBJECT: Engineering Response to Project Referral for Juan Maldonado CUP 2022-01 and SPDR 2022- 02 for 1547 F Street, Livingston CA- REVISED
DATE: February 1, 2023
CC: Jennifer Riedeman, Finance Director/Acting City Manager The following are Engineering's comments and/or Conditions of Approval for Conditional Use Permit 2022-01 and Site Plan Design Review 2022-02 for 1547 F Street in the City of Livingston.

CUP 2022-01 and SPDR 2022-02

3. All existing and proposed property lines shall be shown on the improvement plans.

4. Applicant shall prepare an Erosion Sediment Control Plan (ESCP) pursuant to the City of Livingston's MS4 Phase II Permit requirements for construction activities.

Page 304 ends

Memorandum
Page2

9. Applicant shall pay all applicable development impact fees for Municipal Facilities, Police, Fire Protection, Streets and Bridges, Water, Domestic Wastewater. Storm Drainage, and Parks.

10. Construct all proposed connections for dry utilities underground and within required easements by the respective utilities.

11. Developer shall replace/repair existing sidewalk, driveway approach, curb and gutter not meeting ADA and/or City standards along F Street extending the length of the property line.

12. The proposed common use driveway with the adjacent 856 5th Street residence is not allowed by the Standard Specification Section 3.06(A).4 of the City of Livingston 2010 Improvement Standards. The City standards require a separate driveway for each lot but the Applicant could construct a common use driveway for the 856 5th Street and 1547 F Street parcels as approved by City Planning and subject to a reciprocal access easement prepared by a California licensed surveyor. Applicant shall provide the easement plat and legal and all other required documents as determined by the City Surveyor for review and approval of the easement and recording thereof. The easement shall be prepared and recorded prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy for this project.

13. Storm runoff from on-site development shall be conveyed through new curb drains into the existing gutter to gravity drain to the nearest catch basin.

I 5. Connect to the existing 8-inch sewer main in the alleyway along the west side of the property or as approved by the City Engineer, for sanitary service.

16. Applicant shall relocate any existing public facilities to the street or alley side to clear any new fence lines constructed as part of the project.

17. Repairs to any damaged City Facilities such as road/alley pavement, valley gutter, sidewalk, curb and gutter caused by construction and construction-related activities shall be completed as required by the City of Livingston and at developer's sole cost,
456 SIXTH STREET• GUSTINE, CALIFORNIA 95322 • TELEPHONE (209) 854-3300 • FAX (209) 854-3600

Page 305 ends

Google Map Aerial 2022 -1547 F Street, Livingston CA
Vicinity Map
ATTACHMENT 3

Page 306 ends

Cl)
fz
w
~
I
0 <{
~
Google Map Aerial 2022 - 1547 F Street, Livingston CA
Property Aerial

Page 307 ends

Tl
t;; . : ;J j;
"'
1'32
S 1
"5
1, '.
• Y
CUP 2022-01 and SPDR 2022-02 - Maldonado
Single Family Dwelling in the R-2 Zoning District
1547 F Street (APN 024-173-013)
Location Map
CST
OST
7i l
· ,_ 1 t·: 1 : ) 1 ,,: 1 - ~1 <.: 1 , ; I
EST
.:: 1
t:i, a:, ec 1
;· 1 :,1 ·21 -: 21

PROJECT SITE
1' . l '2'
ATTACHMENT 3
:1~ Z:.!
~h:l'i , !S
:~; ,~,
-~r
.....
1'

Page 308 ends

5S, R.1/E. M.0.8.8 M.
®
_J L !
.. ~r + :Ii :Ii
"'"' ;, , ..... ..,. ~ I
)..: ~ i?
= Cl) .•.
~ ..,~.
! \ . @. t
~
~--~--'-.B --~ : lO :

J ~ t " II .. .: : : !!~ Q)--::
~ . ,, ~ ·-· ~-JJ
I •.. J
, .... ~ .. -,,-.
10 ... • .,._ ..... ........... -
0 It ~ •
/(J :
a
, •.
® 15
@ 14 ,. ..
..
..
)..:

I.I)
.,,,
::t:
....
~
~
I
Tox Rote Area
,.rr
3-01
3-07
3-17
ATTACHMENT 3
24-17
1-,;
I.I)
L
---·-7 I ·---·--, @'
NOTE-A,,.,..,,., alod Numbo" S~~" ;., £1liJ>l'O•
,..,..,,..,,, J><,,<41 Nv .... She-Ir, Cir<I"'
Assessor's Map 8k.24'Pg. l7
Covnty of Merced, Calif.
1955

Page 309 ends

-·1 ~~ :s
• 4"'\ ,;-
-.. _.,
.,
CUP 2022-01 and SPDR 2022-02 - Maldonado
Single Family Dwelling in the MD General Plan Designation area 1547 F Street (APN 024-173-013)
DC
i=
City of Livingston
2022 General Plan Map
• - • 1 . t.-
PF
ATTACHMENT 3
i:

Page 310 ends

s ~
~
.,
•;.1_7
CUP 2022-01 and SPDR 2022-02 - Maldonado
Single Family Dwelling in the R-2 Zoning District
1547 F Street (APN 024-173-013)
.. ;;: ....
·"
. • J
-::-25
.,_ ~ .. '
. . . l)w,,"}
a·~ J - 7
R-1
City of Livingston
2022 Zoning Map
7' 1
OTC
..;;_.., ... .4 •
,., t.!
.;
t--. 1" r R-2
"' . ·;
. ' . -':>
i- .;4
_, .... , ..,
ATTACHMENT 3
; 1
R-3

Page 311 ends

( SCOPE OF WORK
<.Pl •I
li,;~~
~ •e,.Ullo l'IOC l ~'-ll-•U&
D SINGLE F , .,.,,. , ............. ,, ... .... , ..
1547 F .,,, ,,, .. , ,.,,,,,,,,,, , ,, .. , ..
( BUILDING AND MODEL CODES )
ATTACHMENT 4

CJ DRAWING INDEX

RECEIVED
DEC 1 S 2022

PLANNING

Page 312 ends

FST FST
ATTACHMENT 4
,. ~"O'i..VWML~MOOff!,:it.";."' P.i!t>.!...l'i-.f::15'".A!.. .. E'-z:: dt..,~.lff~ At It.,?" r.',rfl-''.$1".4"~ Cl" rr:':;'r-lOCt!".;).:"t.r.-.frY'. i"~,::(.:t!' ::;:l'\IJ-..:,;,;,.:f.•~~Tt?.-.~••':i"'1A!l:IJ.~:l'r.t..~.:.\.-J.~""-:~,o!to fl-'J!'~TJ:
,rt;io_,-y,J~ W.l U"..f. Of 11. D>-'-:.~~:f~'. ~'\.i\fi\~ Ci.Vll11P.. /o~fA...'"'ll'OD,
'~U:.~~~l'f.$'tf.t.ll110 l."'l•i:.\.!-;'f"J'~ :.<.'.A-r.'.Y.~11-\ ~!\I ,~;i.'!l;:>,\'r...;"\l!MU:'l.tll!~~r.lU,l'~C.,\,!.... •~•.,'ft;; t!..:=n:E-W-ll!:Ji: •~ii'!~; it;t;.,"';r ,~.

F5T
._ ___ --------L.L________.ll__.__l_______J~

RECEIVED
DEC 13 2022

PLANNING

Page 313 ends

.w;~., = El
.,,., .. ,,.,~ ....
35 ATTACHMENT 4
..... ~ . . .... !It .. "Ort',l'l)O,,._:,o;.••'-'1r.,(l-•• ~~f.:Ct\= !,,,,.,V..O--..-!..r,~:.)IT,.)O"A~, .. ,'"t".A<. ~.N'
$ '°''~"'-"'""»i,~•~•~n- ~ ~1•~·,;,_:,i~.;:,~·Z;t.?.,.~~,.,_-:-a . .-.:

CJ
, rti:".a..~•r::.n:: ~ ~.,.. .. ,:v,.,,:
,;1;:_,;::n,n ;c, ~u,~.c-Y1'0tl»'
-' .,..,~~•l~~,'fl f.:O:.llt\U . ... ll"" :cll"r.l' ..... 1~• .. ~;:: ·~"'

RECEIVED
DEC 1 3 2022

PLANNING
A1

Page 314 ends

""
ATTACHMENT 4
. ,,.,~ ... ~,:u,:r.,111r,
ix,:,r,,, ...... ~.~·~, .. ~ '""·~··•'""1,1'•~~ ..... : ,,,.~n~""''" I ~-,,1~.-~~fn•.•~lO'J.• , M!•~/,",\•lt..,,-•~=l.:'Dtot'.l'l'\.::,l ,-,r,,,v,.,,,, ~•0!•NJ.:j;<;..~~,a:r:c1,~• 1 ,_,.,.- ,.-,.•~~ ..... , _.,.,}'f.,.,,," ' ,..,,,l
, -....:tior.'.~:l!o-W\ •--,,.._l'V: " t ' \\!"I
\!~ics.1 , ~o!:<.euu;u.-·rr , .......... ,...etr.,::•-•I" .... , •• ,,,,_r-~••:_,,,. .... _...,.,..,.....,..t ,~i.:r,, .... •r~-~: .. •••• .. •~~,,-...- ,,_.,,..,."'.J>,.<.fl. . ,... ur,c,:;:,....-,. u,e~r..~"•"" ~f'Qlt,>l(,U. tf: ~U .. Nl!'t'II~•:
:'. :-;~"':.;'.ii-;' ~~~~.;.-..;:-z;t

RECEIVED
DEC 1 3 2022

PLANNING
J" OU1(;H C0. DRAFTING All'D DlSJi:;'N
WWW.)A--OUt<:tN.O,COM
10:,0MUICI.VSl
NIWKA.NCA,5J60 209-241•2.SU
n l .,.,~
CJ

Page 315 ends

8- 8 rm .rm
ATTACHMENT 4
- -

RECEIVED
DEC 13 2022

PLANNING
CJ

Page 316 ends

C SCOPE Of' WORK
r··-~SC,l,J'tAIIIO'lltR!CimON
( ADDITIONAL NOTES
wi: ,:,;
APNe024-l7J.•CIIJ,-ODO
""""--""" "'"'"'""""""' !!,8 5i1Hl!IJ u,-SKllilb~
PHONE:: [~) :US,...~"5
-
"'.»0 i::DtT
::t1U2~FJ
210.l!OSOtT
no.:uscan
"(IT~ CTY Of" I.MNCll'JDI CA
= NE¥f l'IIIVA,lt r~Yl!MENCt
J
)

ABBREVIATIONS
..,,,
..... """' ..... """""' .. ..,..,, ... ·- -- .,.,, CONWIIJCU:il ... °"""" ..... ...... , .... OOL ,.,.a, ,., ,.....,,_,..
.. .. .,.. ..... "' ......... ""' FOUNDAllr.N .... ....,.., "' ........ , .. fAci::-DF:!IIUD ... ..... ON - ,..., r...c:torCOWUN
..... ........ EA EACH rr., r.a:Cf'J1M$11
! """"""' II.IC Cl(<:TIOC<L "' """'"""' WI ...... '°' .,...,,... .. ..... .... '°""" '" m:ita,:-.f'UJ\lot .... i!UII.VANn'n!,
- ......
. ""' .._ IN:UA'tl)H """"""""'
. '" .. '""""' ........
... lli,1U'ACfUlttR
~-- ........
"1~ NGJDilC(IH'nt,t.m
N.1.$, NOt 'ro sa.u:
=· -~
( MWELO COMPLIANCE )
~:~•••l~\tt~~fl CF 1H£
~ffi.'C COU'UENC£ CJl"'ITO.l 'fa, M: loffllQ.O.

C. MWELO COMPLIANCE
I .mt! AS PAO-GT AC!N'f AHIJ &it51'-IINIX,
TO COM"LT '111111-1 M Rt:il:WWUIIS 'ntl[
~ESCRP'RVt t.OU'tDIC£ oP:noN" 10 lH!.
)
{_ DRAWING INDEX J
jADIESJ'GNCO.

DRAFTING AN-D DE:SJGN
WWW.JA•DES"JG"NCO.C:OM
.1tl:SCI- MHCl!D ST.

N'EWMA.N -CA 95360
:l(l9-Z47--25&3
.Appra111a~~
D
<t
I"}
"l
"'
lL U
5 ,-.... z ai~
1'"' tn
.. ,:: _, t.
iii~
C
., .. :"..:O..."':"..... ""'"'
I . I CONTACT -: I I -_~_".¥_""_· __ ===== :::c s:: m
z
--l
ll,,.

Page 317 ends

2 GARAGE

CONCRETE

DRIVEWAY
\U
!i
ii:
~ \U
z
:::;
•-Otl....:,_.....i.-.,,•~IC'I......_
, -=«nuu.,..,,_,.,_ .. r, •,V.-;t:5<D!'!~
·;~~~~-
'!!~~=-~~!:=~-
& !r~~:!.i~:Se.--:.r.:W)
GOlDfH sv.l0ftD '11JCCA.SHRIJ6
GOLDCII SWORD YUCCA. SHRU&
J.A OutGNCIO,
Dlllt"1NG AND OUlGH
WWW.JA-Of.SIGNCO,C0/111
1030 MEACID ST NMMAN CA UU:O

2.M-247•250
A rovnlt1
D
~
~ I ii ....
i l/l
u.. 6 ...
... 2
"' § ! ~
~ G',........ LS 1 i C!:' ..... , .....
·~'----------------------------- ----------- - ---------------------------------~~-~~ =-~

Page 318 ends

D
ATTACHMENT 5
Notice of Exemption Appendix E
To: Office of Planning and Research
P .0. Box 3044, Room 113
Sacramento, CA 95812-3044
From: (Public Agency): __________ _
City of Livingston
County Clerk
1416 "C" Street, Livingston, CA 95334
County of: _M_e_rce_d ____ _ (Address)
2222 M Street
Merced, CA 95340
Project Title: CUP No. 2022-01 and SPDR No. 2022-02 - Single Family Dwelling on R-2 zoned lot.

Project Applicant: _J_ua_n_M_a_ld_o_n_a_do ______________________ _ Project Location - Specific:
1547 F Street, Livingston, CA 95334
Project Location - City: _L_iv_in_g_s_t_o_n ____ _ Project Location - County: _M_e_r_c_e_d ____ _ Description of Nature, Purpose and Beneficiaries of Project:

Proposal to develop a 3,270 square foot single-family dwelling on an undersized lot in the R-2, Medium Density Zoning District.

Name of Public Agency Approving Project: _C_ity_o_f_L_i_v_in_g_s_to_n _____________ _ Name of Person or Agency Carrying Out Project: _J_u_an_M_a_ld_o_n_a_d_o ____________ _ Exempt Status: (check one):
□ Ministerial (Sec. 21080(b)(1 ); 15268);
D Declared Emergency (Sec. 21080(b)(3); 15269(a));
D Emergency Project (Sec. 21080(b)(4); 15269(b)(c));
Iii Categorical Exemption. State type and section number: 15303 (b) and 15332 D Statutory Exemptions. State code number: ------------------ Re as on s why project is exempt:

The project consist of developing one single family dwelling and the project site is located within the City Limits where utilities and services are available and the subject project site is under 5 acres in size.
' Lead Agency . Contact Person: Miguel Galvez Area Codeffelephone/Extension: 209-394-8041 If filed by applicant:

1. Attach certified document of exemption finding.

2. Has a Notice of Exemption been tiled by the public agency approving the project? ■ Yes No Signature: ___________ Date: ______ Title:
■ Signed by Lead Agency Signed by Applicant
Authority cited: Sections 21083 and 21110, Public Resources Code.

Reference: Sections 211 OB, 21152, and 21152.1, Public Resources Code.

Date Received for filing at OPR: ____ _
Revised 2011

Page 319 ends

ATTACHMENT 6
RESOLUTION 2023-03

RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF LIVINGSTON

RECOMMENDING TO THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVAL OF CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT APPLICATION NO. CUP 2022-01 TO DEVELOP A TWO-STORY 3,282 SQUARE FOOT DWELLING ON AN UNDERSIZED PARCEL IN THE R-2 ZONING DISTRICT ON PROPERTY LOCATED AT 1547 F STREET, LIVINGSTON, CA, (APN: 024-173-013)
WHEREAS, pursuant to Livingston Municipal Code ("LMC") Section 5-6-9, Juan Maldonado, owner and applicant, submitted Conditional Use Permit Application No. 2022-01 for the development of a new single family dwelling unit on property located on the north side of F Street at 1547 F Street, Livingston, CA (Assessor Parcel Number 024-173-013); and WHEREAS, the project site is zoned R-2 (Medium Density Residential), and has a General Plan designation of Medium Density Residential according to the official Zoning Map of the City of Livingston and the 1999 Livingston General Plan; and
WHEREAS, LMC Section 5-3-15 - Table 2 Residential Uses, Dwelling, single-family.

Development of a single-family dwelling in the R-2 zoning district may be permitted by the Planning Commission with the approval of a Conditional Use Permit.

WHEREAS, LMC Section 5-6-7 requires the approval of a Site Plan and Design Review application for new structures within the R-2 zoning district to assure compatibility, harmony in appearance in neighborhoods, reduction of negative impacts of nonesthetic development, and orderly development of the community; and
.WHEREAS, a public hearing for the proposed project has been properly noticed by posting, a newspaper ad, and a mailing to adjacent properties within 300 feet of the site; and WHEREAS, the proposed project is categorically exemptfrom the California Environmental Quality Act ('CEQA") under Section 15303 (b) New Construction of no more than four dwellings per site and under Section 15332 In Fill Development Projects and a Notice of Exemption will be filed with the Merced County Clerk within five (5) days of project approval; and WHEREAS, staff has reviewed the project Ylilh reference to the 1999 General Plan and the Zoning Ordinance (specifically Sections 5-6-7 "C" thru "E'1; and finds that, based on the evidence documented within the associated staff report and proceedings of the public hearing, the proposed use, its site plan and design, is generally consistent with the General Plan, is permitted and complies with the Zoning Ordinance in that the site plan and design meets the standards and requirements (including those specifically referenced above.)
WHEREAS, the following findings listed in LMC Section 5-6-9 (I) for approving the Use Permit can be made as follows:
(a) The site for the proposed use is adequate in size and shepe to accommodate said use and all yards, spaces, walls and fences, parking, loading, landscaping and other features required by the applicable zoning district;
The proposed site plan, elevations for single family dwelling meets all development standards in the R-2 zoning district
1

Page 320 ends

(b) The site for the proposed use is served by streets and highways adequate to carry the quantity and kind of traff,c generated by the proposed use; The side fronts on F Street, a fully developed public street that was designed to carry the traffic of the proposed single-family dwelling. (c) Public facilities are currently adequate to serve the proposed use or improvements are included in an approved capital improvement plan or otherwise will be complete prior to the issuance of building permits; and
Public Facilities and utilities are available and adequate to serve the subject site. (d) The proposed development is consistent with the general plan. If granted, it should be made subject to those conditions necessary to preserve the general welfare, not the individual welfare, of any particular applicant."
The proposed site plan, elevation and conditions of approval will ensure that the development will confonn to City development standards for development within the residential zoning district and preserve the general welfare of the community.

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Livingston Planning Commission hereby adopts Resolution 2023-03, recommending City Council approval of Conditional Use Pennit application No.

CUP 2022-01 -Single family dwelling at 1547 F Street, including submitted site plan, floor plan, and elevations.

BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Conditions of Approval within Planning Commission Resolution 2023--03, Exhibit A, are hereby recommended for approval.

The foregoing resolution was introduced and moved for adoption on March 14, 2023, by Commissioner Mendonca, and being duly seconded by Commissioner Fuentes, was passed by the following Vote:

AYES:

NOES:

ABSENT:

ABSTAIN:

ATTEST:

Chair Bob Wallis, Vice-Chair Steve Bassi, Commissioner Renee Mendonca, Commissioner Andres Fuentes and Commissioner Harpreet Bains None
None
None
2

Page 321 ends

Exhibit A
Conditions of Approval
CUP No. 2022 -A Single Family Dwelling at 1547 F Street

3. The Developer shall comply with the 17 Conditions of the City Engineer as listed in the Memo dated February 1, 2023, attached hereto and made a part of this Resolution; and

8. The Developer shall comply with all requirements of PG&E as it relates to the construction of the project; and

9. The Developer and/or Operator shall keep the site free from trash and debris and shall maintain the premises in a clean and orderly manner.

Page 322 ends

GOUVEIA ENGINEERING

MEMORANDUM
TO:

FROM:

Miguel Galvez, Contract City Plan1\ l \J / I
Mario B. Gouveia, City Engineer N•t M,,r-tw~
SUBJECT: Engineering Response to Project Referral for Juan Maldonado CUP 2022-01 and SPDR 2022- 02 for 154 7 F Street, Livingston CA - REVISED
DATE: February 1, 2023
CC: Jennifer Riedeman, Finance Director/Acting City Manager The following are Engineering• s comments and/or Conditions of Approval for Conditional Use Pennit 2022-0 l and Site Plan Design Review 2022-02 for 1547 F Street in the City of Livingston.

CUP 2022-01 and SPDR 2012-01

2. Public improvements shall conform to the latest edition of the City Improvement Standards and Specifications and any modifications thereto approved by the City Engineer in place at the time of construction. Improvements shall confonn to other City adopted documents including the General Plan, Water Master Plan, Sewer Master Plan and Storm Water Master Plan. The work shall comply with all applicable State, Federal, and local laws and regulations.

3. All existing and proposed property lines shall be shown on the improvement plans.

4. Applicant shall prepare an Erosion Sediment Control Plan (ESCP) pursuant to the City of Livingston's MS4 Phase II Permit requirements for construction activities.

5. Unless exempt, prepare and provide volumetric sizing calculations, low development impact {LID) measures, operation and maintenance plan (O&M), and statement of responsibility agreement for storm water management in accordance with the City of Livingston's Post-construction Standards Plan and pursuant to the City's Phase II MS4 Pem1it requirements.

8. Prepare any applicable grading and encroachment permits for the project. Applicant shall pay the permit fee, plan check and inspection fees, and furnish improvement securities pursuant to the City's improvement standards, municipal code, and ordinances.
456 SIXTH STREET• GUSTINE, CALlFORNIA 95322 • TELEPHONE (209) 8S4-3300 • FAX (209) 854--3600

Page 323 ends

Memorandum·
Page2

9. Applicant shall pay all applicable development impact fees for Municipal Facilities, :Police, Fire Protection, Streets and Bridges, Water, Domestic Wastewater, Storm Drainage, and Parks. 1 o; Construct all proposed connections for dry utilities underground and within required easements by the respective utilities.

11. Developer sbaH replace/repair existing sidewalk, driveway approach, curb and gutter not meeting ADA and/or· City standards along F Street extending the length of the property line.

12. Th~ proposed common use driveway with the adjacent 856 5th Street residence is not allowed by the Standard Specification Section 3.06(A).4 of the City of Livingston 2010 Improvement Standards. The City · standards require a separate driveway for each lot but the Applicant couJd construct a common use driveway for the 856 5ch Street and 1547 F Street parcels as approved by City Planning and subject to a reciprocal access easement prepared by a California Jicensed surveyor. Applicant shall provide the easement plat and legal and all other required documents as determined by the City Surveyor for review and approval of the easement and recording thereof. The easement shall be prepared and recorded prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy for this project.

13. Stonn runoff from on-site development shall be conveyed through new curb drains into the existing gutter to gravity drain to the nearest catch basin.

14. Connect to the existing 8•inch water main in the alleyway along the west side of the property or as approved by the City Engineer, for all proposed domestic, irrigation, and fire flows. Developer shall incoq,orate water . recirculation for residential sprinkler system at the water service or onsite plumbing. Water connections shall include shutoff valves, corporation stops, and water meters. ·1 S. Connect to the existing s:..inch sewer main in the alleyway along the west side of the property or as approved by the City Engineer, for sanitary service.

I 6. Applicant shall relocate any existing public facilities to the street or alley side to clear any new fence lines constructed as part of the project.

17. ·Repairs to any damaged City Facilities such as road/alley pavement, valley gutter, sidewalk. curb and gutter . caused by construction and construction-related activities shall be completed as requjred by the City of Livingston and at developer's sole cost
d ·n·
4S6 SIXTH STREET• GUSTINE, CALIFORNIA 95322 • TELEPHONE (209) 854-3300 • FAX (209) 854-3600

Page 324 ends

ATTACHMENT 7
RESOLUTION 2023-04

RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF LIVINGSTON

RECOMMENDING TO THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVAL OF SITE PLAN AND DESIGN REVIEW NO. SPDR 2022-02 TO DEVELOP A TWO-STORY 3,282 SQUARE FOOT DWELLING ON AN UNDERSIZED PARCEL IN THE R-2 ZONING DISTRICT ON PROPERTY LOCATED AT 1547 F STREET, LIVINGSTON, CA (APN: 024-173-013) WHEREAS, pursuant to Livingston Municipal Code ("LMC") Section 5-6-7, Juan Maldonado, owner and applicant, submitted Site Plan and Design Review Application No. · SPDR 2022-02 for the development of a new single family dwelling unit on property located on the north side of F Street, west of 5th Street at 154 7 F Street, Livingston, CA {Assessor Parcel Number 024-173-013);
and
WHEREAS, the project site is zoned R-2 {Medium Density Residential), and has a General Plan designation of Medium Density Residential according to the official Zoning Map of the City of Livingston and the 1999 Livingston General Plan; and WHEREAS, LMC Section 5-3-15 - Table Residential Uses, Dwelling, single-family, Development of a single-family dwelling in the R-2 zoning district may be permitted by the Planning Commission with the approval of a Conditional Use Permit Approval of Use Permit application No. CUP 2022-01 was considered and approved by the Planning Commission on March 14, 2023.

WHEREAS, LMC Section 5-6-7 requires the approval of a Site Plan and Design Review application for new structures within the R-2 zoning district to assure compatibility, harmony in appearance in neighborhoods, reduction of negative impacts of nonaesthetic development, and orderly development of the community; and WHEREAS, a public hearing for the proposed project has been properly noticed by posting, a newspaper ad, and a mailing to adjacent properties within 300 feet of the site; and
WHEREAS, the proposed project is categorically exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act ("CEQA") under Section 15303 (b) New Construction of no more than four dwellings per site and under Section 15332 In-Fill Development Projects and a Notice of Exemption will be filed with the Merced County Clerk within five (5) days of project approval; and
WHEREAS, staff has reviewed the project with reference to the 1999 General Plan and the Zoning Ordinance {specifically Sections 5-6-7 "C" thru "E"); and finds that, based on the evidence documented within the associated staff report and proceedings of the public hearing, the proposed use, its site plan and design, is generally consistent with the General Plan, is permitted and complies with the Zoning Ordinance in that the site plan and design meets the zoning standards and requirements (including those specifically referenced above).

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Livingston Planning Commission hereby adopts Resolution 2023-04, recommending City Council approval of the Site Plan and Design Review Application No. 2022-02 - Single family dwelling at 1547 F Street, including submitted site plan, floor plan and elevations.

Page 325 ends

BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Conditcons of Approval within Planning Commission Resolution 2023-04, Exhibit A, are hereby recommended for approval.

The foregoing resolution was introduced and moved for adoption on March 14, 2023, by Commissioner Bassi, and being duly seconded by Commissioner Mendonca, was passed by the following vote:

AYES:

NOES:

ABSENT:

ABSTAIN:

ATTEST:

Chair Bob Wallis, Vice-Chair Steve Bassi, Commissioner Renee Mendonca, Commissioner Andres Fuentes, Commissioner Harpreet Bains None
None
None
Chair BOB WALLIS f the anning Co . ission,
Ml ALVEZ
2

Page 326 ends

Exhibit A
Conditions of Approval
SPDR No. 2022.02 -A Single Family Dwelling at 1547 F Street

1. The Developer shall comply with all federal, state and local laws, policies, standards and requirements applicable to such a use and obtain a building permits and all other permits applicable to such a use and shall pay all fees and exactions applicable to such a use; and

3. The Developer shall comply with the 17 Conditions of the City Engineer as listed in the Memo dated February 1, 2023, attached hereto and made a part of this Resolution; and

5. The development of the site shall be consistent with approved plans, elevations, and colors.

Minor variations from approved plans, elevations, and colors may be allowed at the review and approval of City staff; and

6. The developer shall submit final landscape plans for City staff review and approval specifying plant selection, size and irrigation consistent with the preliminary landscape concept submitted as part of the application and described in the associated staff report and shall pay the landscape inspection fee to insure installation was done according to plan; and

8. The Developer shall comply with all requirements of PG&E as it relates to the construction of the project; and

9. The Developer and/or Operator shall keep the site free from trash and debris and shall maintain the premises in a clean and orderly manner.

Page 327 ends

GOUVEIA ENGINEERING

MEMORANDUM
TO:

FROM:

Miguel Galvez, Contract City P1am{'\ l J / f p. V. -h
Mario B. Gouveia, City Engineer Not' M,r--tW1, . ·1 1)( SUBJECT: Engineering Response to Project Referral for Juan Maldonado CUP 2022-01 and SPDR 2022- 02 for 154 7 F Street, Livingston CA - REVISED
DATE: February 1, 2023
CC: Jennifer Riedeman, Finance Director/ Acting City Manager The following are Engineerint s comments and/or Conditions of Approval for Conditional Use Pennit 2022-0 l and Site Plan Design Review 2022-02 for 1547 F Street in the City of Livingston.

CUP 2022-01 and SPDR 2022-02
l. The developer/applicant shall prepare improvement plans (separate from the building plans) for all applicable site development including, but not limited to, demolition, site grading and drainage, utilities, landscape, on-site and off-site (street and alley frontage) improvements.

2. Public improvements shall conform to the latest edition of the City Improvement Standards and Specifications and any modifications thereto approved by the City Engineer in place at the time of construction. Improvements shall confonn to other City adopted documents including the General Plan, Water Master Plan, Sewer Master Plan and Stonn Water Master Plan. The work shall comply with all applicable State, Federal, and local laws and regulations.

3. All existing and proposed property lines shaU be shown on the improvement plans.

4. Applicant shall prepare an Erosion Sediment Contro] Plan (ESCP) pursuant to the City of Livingston's MS4 Phase II Permit requirements for construction activities.

5. Unless exempt, prepare and provide volumetric sizing calculations. low development impact (LID) measures, operation and maintenance plan (O&M), and statement of responsibility agreement for storm water management in accordance with the City of Livingston's Post-construction Standards Plan and pursuant to the City's Phase II MS4 Permit requirements.

6. Unless ex.empt, prepare a Dust Control Plan (DCP) and file the Plan with the San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District for construction activities pursuant to Regulation VIII (Rules 8011-8081).

8. Prepare any applicable grading and encroachment permits for the project. Applicant shaU pay the permit fee, plan check and inspection fees, and furnish improvement securities pursuant to the City,s improvement standards, municipal code, and ordinances.
456 SIXTH STREET• GUSTINE. CALIFORNIA 9S322 • TELEPHONE (209) 8S4-3300 • FAX (209) 854-3600

Page 328 ends

Memorandum
Page2 .··. . . . . .· . ·. .· . . . . . . . . . .

9. Applicant shall pay all appl1cable development impact fees for Municipal Facilities, Police, fire Protection; Streets and Bridges, Water, Domestic Wastewater, Storm Drainage, and Parks. l 0. Construct an proposed connections for dry utilities underground and within required easements by the respective utilities.

11. Developer shall replace/repair existing sidewalk, driveway approach, curb and gutter not meeting ADA arid/or .

City standards along F Street extending the length of the property line.

12. The proposed common use driveway with the adjacent 856 Sill Street residence is not allowed by the Standard Specification Section 3.06(A).4 of the City of Livingston 2010 Improvement Standards. The City standards require a separate driveway for each lot but the Applicant could construct a common use driveway for the 856 5ih Street and 1547 F Street parcels as approved by City Planning and subject to a reciprocal access easement prepared by a California licensed surveyor. Applicant shall provide the easement plat and · legal and all other required documents as detennined by the City Surveyor for review and approval of the easement and recording thereof. The easement shall be prepared and recorded prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy for this project.

13. Storm runoff from on-site development shallbe conveyed through new curb drains into the existing gutter to gravity dtain to the nearest catch basin.

14. Connect to the existing 8~inch water main in the alleyway along the west side of the property or as approved by the City Engineer, for all proposed domestic, irrigation, and fire flows. Developer shall inCOl])Orate water recirculation for residential sprinkler system at the water service or onsite plumbing. Water connections shall include shutoff valves, corporation stops, and water meters.

15. Connect to the existing 8-inch sewer main in the alleyway along the west side of the property or as approved by the City Engineer, for sanitary service.
16, Applicant shall relocate any existing public facilities to the street or alley side to clear any new fence lines constructed as part of the project.

17. Repairs to any damaged City Facilities such as road/alley pavement, valley gutter, sidewalk, curb and gutter .. caused by construction and consttuction~related activities shall be completed as required by the City of Livingston and at developer's sole cost
456 SIXTH STREET• GUSTINE. CALIFORNIA 95322 • TELEPHONE (209) 8S4-3300 • FAX (209) 854-3600

Page 329 ends

AGENDA ITEM:

MEETING DATE:

PREPARED BY:

REVIEWED BY:

STAFF REPORT
Waive the Second Reading and Adopt Ordinance of the City Council of the City of Livingston Amending Livingston Municipal Code, Section 1.4.3, General Criminal Penalties, of Chapter 4, General Penalties, of Title 1, Administrative; and Section 7 .4.16, Administrative Penalties, of Chapter 7.4, Fireworks, of Title 7, Fire Regulations and Department of Public Safety to Establish Administrative Penalties For the Use of Illegal A.erial Fireworks May 16, 2023
Chuck Hale, Chief of Police
Christopher Lopez, Interim City Manager
RECOMMENDATION:

Waive the Second Reading and Adopt Ordinance of the City Council of the City of Livingston Amending Livingston Municipal Code, Section 1.4.3, General Criminal Penalties, of Chapter 4, General Penalties, of Title 1, Administrative; and Section 7.4.16, Administrative Penalties, of Chapter 7.4, Fireworks, of Title 7, Fire Regulations and Department of Public Safety to Establish Administrative Penalties For the Use of Illegal Aerial Fireworks.

BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION:

The City of Livingston, in recent years, has experienced a proliferation in the use of illegal fireworks. The Livingston Police Department experiences a high volume of incoming calls related to illegal aerial fireworks throughout the year and particularly in the days leading up to the Fourth of July holiday. An average of 19,000 fires were reported across the country on the Fourth of July in recent years and all were attributed to fireworks. Fires have the potential to cause personal injury, as well as damage to homes, vehicles, and other property. In 2021, Cal Fire reported that there were 916 firework related fires in the State, which caused $3,293,844 •in property loss, $1,319,804 in content loss, 2 firefighters injured, and 472 acres burned. The City of Livingston is surrounded by vegetation and many older structures that are constructed of wood materials, which are at high risk of catching fire.

Illegal aerial fireworks are a threat to the public safety of the residents of Livingston and establishing administrative penalties will assist in deterring the use of illegal fireworks. The proposed Ordinance makes any person who possesses, uses, stores, sells, or displays dangerous illegal fireworks, guilty of an infraction. For the first violation, the individual is subject to a fine of one hundred thirty dollars ($130.00). For the second violation in a twelve-month period, the individual is subject to a fine of seven hundred dollars ($700.00). For the third and each subsequent violation in a twelve-month period, the individual is subject to a fine of one thousand three hundred dollars ($1,300.00). Additionally, for commercial properties improved with a building at the time of the violation, two thousand, five hundred dollars ($2,500.00) for each subsequent violation within a two-year period.

Page 1 of 2 ends

Page 330 ends

The proposed ordinance also establishes administrative penalties associated with individuals who allow the use of illegal fireworks on their property. A host is defined as either a person who is in charge of private property or a person who organizes, supervises, officiates, conducts, controls, or is otherwise in charge of the activity associated with the use of fireworks on the property. Under the proposed ordinance, a host would be strictly liable for the use or display of aerial fireworks on their property or at their gathering and guilty of a misdemeanor with penalties of up to two thousand, five hundred dollars ($2,500). Host liability under the proposed ordinance would not extend to (1) the owner of a multi-tenant residential property unless that owner accepts responsibility for the gathering where a violation occurs, (2) an event permitted under state or federal law, (3) an individual who contacts law enforcement to assist in terminating any firework activity on their property that is made before other complaints are received for that property, and (4) where the activity occurs on public property adjacent to private property and the owner of the private property does not aid, facilitate, promote, encourage, or instigate the use of the illegal fireworks.

The proposed penalties are above those currently provided for in Chapter 4 of the Livingston Municipal Code, which only address general administrative penalties. Government Code section 36900 allows for higher fines to be assessed for violations of local building and safety codes determined to be infractions. Therefore, in order to conform the proposed aerial fireworks penalties to the statutory maximum, staff recommends the City Council also amend Chapter 4 of the Livingston Municipal Code.

FISCAL IMPACT:

The proposed ordinance may increase City policing costs for enforcement. Enforcement of the proposed ordinance may offset some of any costs that arise.

OPTIONS:

1. Waive second reading and adopt Ordinance;

2. Reject the proposed Ordinance entirely.

ATTACHMENTS:

1. Ordinance

Page 2 of 2 ends

Page 331 ends

ORDINANCE NO. __ _

AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LIVINGSTON AMENDING LIVINGSTON MUNICIPAL CODE, SECTION 1.4.3, GENERAL CRIMINAL PENALTIES, OF CHAPTER 4, GENERAL PENALTIES, OF TITLE 1, ADMINISTRATIVE; AND SECTION

7.4.16, ADMINISTRATIVE PENALTIES, OF CHAPTER 7.4, FIREWORKS, OF TITLE 7, FIRE

REGULATIONS AND DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY TO ESTABLISH

ADMINISTRATIVE PENAL TIES FOR THE USE OF ILLEGAL AERIAL FIREWORKS WHEREAS, there has been a proliferation of the use of illegal fireworks in the City of Livingston; and
WHEREAS, the City of Livingston is surrounded by vegetation and many older structures that are constructed of wood materials, which are at high risk of catching fire easily; and WHEREAS, illegal fireworks pose a significant risk to the public health and safety of the residents of Livingston; and
WHEREAS, penalties specific to the use of illegal dangerous fireworks have not been established in the Livingston Municipal Code; and
WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Livingston desires to establish administrative penalties up to the maximum allowable under State law to deter individuals from using illegal fireworks.

NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LIVINGSTON DOES ORDAIN AS FOLLOWS:

SECTION 1. Livingston Municipal Code, Title 1, Administrative, Chapter 4, General Penalties, Section 1-4-3 is amended to read as follows:
1-4-3 GENERAL CRIMINAL PENALTIES
(A) Any person who shall violate or fail to comply with any provision or requirement of this code or any other city ordinance, or a condition of any permit issued pursuant to this code or any other city ordinance, shall be guilty of a misdemeanor, unless:

1. Such a violation or failure is designated as an infraction or is subsequently prosecuted as an infraction, in which case such person is guilty of an infraction; or

2. Such a violation or failure is prosecuted through an administrative citation. Any person who fails to pay an administrative fine or to comply with an administrative order is guilty of a misdemeanor as provided in this chapter.
(B) Any violation of any provision of this code or any other city ordinance, or a condition of any permit issued pursuant to this code or any other city ordinance, may be prosecuted as a misdemeanor or as an infraction, in the discretion of the City Attorney or his or her designee. (C) Unless otherwise specifically provided in this code or by the City Council, any person guilty of a misdemeanor under a provision of this code shall be punished by a fine of not more than $1,000, or by imprisonment for a period of not more than six months, or by both such fine and imprisonment.

Page 332 ends

(D) Unless otherwise provided by City Council, as prescribed by state law, any person who has committed an infraction shall be punished for a first violation by a fine not exceeding $100, and for committing the same offense a second time within one year by a fine not exceeding $200, and for committing the same offense a third or any subsequent time within one year, by a fine not exceeding $500.
(E) Unless otherwise specifically provided in this code or by the City Council, any violation of any building or safety provision of this code determined to be an infraction that poses a threat to public health or safety is punishable by the following:

1. A fine not exceeding one hundred thirty dollars ($130) for a first violation.

2. A fine not exceeding seven hundred dollars ($700) for a second violation of the same ordinance within one year.

3. A fine not exceeding:
(a) One thousand three hundred dollars ($1,300) for each additional violation of the same ordinance within one year of the first violation. (b) A fine not exceeding two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500) for each additional violation of the same ordinance within two years of the first violation if the property is a commercial property that has an existing building at the time of the violation and the violation is due to failure by the owner to remove visible refuse or failure to prohibit unauthorized use of the property.
(F) A person cited under this code may seek a hardship waiver to reduce the amount of the fine upon a showing by the responsible party that the responsible party has made a bona fide effort to comply after the first violation and that payment of the full amount of the fine would impose an undue financial burden on the responsible party. A request for a hardship waiver must be filed with the City Manager within 10 calendar days from the date of the citation. The request will be decided by the City Manager within five business days from the date the request is received, and the City Manager's decision is final. The responsible party will be notified in writing of the decision on the request. A request for hardship waiver does not extend the time to appeal the citation.

SECTION 2. Livingston Municipal Code, Title 7, Fire Regulations and Department of Public Safety, Chapter 4, Fireworks, Section 16, Administrative Penalties, is amended to read:
7-4-16 ADMINISTRATIVE PENALTIES
(A) Administrative penalties may be imposed against any person for violating any of the requirements set forth in this chapter in the amounts and pursuant to the procedures set forth in this code.
(B) In addition to any other remedy available at law, any person or entity who possesses, uses, stores, sells or displays dangerous fireworks, or any person or entity who possesses, uses, sells or displays dangerous fireworks, is guilty of an infraction and subject to the penalties set forth in Livingston Municipal Code Title 1, Chapter 4, subsection (E). (C) Host Responsibility for Dangerous Fireworks.

Page 333 ends

who:

1. For the purposes of this section, the term "host" section shall mean a person (a) Is in charge of private property, including but not limited to, an owner, tenant, landlord, or property manager of the property; or (b) Organizes, supervises, officiates, conducts, controls, or is otherwise in charge of the activity on the property.

2. For the purposes of this section, the term "strictly liable" in this section shall mean liability for a wrongful act regardless of a person's intent, knowledge, negligence, or lack thereof in committing the wrongful act.

3. Any host shall be strictly liable for any unlawful ignition, explosion, discharge, use, or display of any dangerous fireworks in violation of this section on their property or at their gathering, except that no person who has the right to use, possess, or occupy a unit in a multifamily residential property under a lease, rental agreement, or contract shall be liable for a violation of this section occurring in the common area of the property unless the person hosts, organizes, supervises, officiates, conducts, or accepts responsibility for a gathering at which the violation occurs.

4. Any person having the care, custody, or control of a minor shall be strictly liable for any unlawful ignition, explosion, discharge, use, or display of dangerous fireworks by the minor in violation of this section.

5. Except as provided in subsection (6) of this section, no host shall permit or allow another person on private property or at a gathering on public property, where the host knows or reasonably should know that the person is engaged in a violation of this Chapter.

6. The provisions of this Chapter shall not apply to:
(a) Conduct involving display, use, or discharge of fireworks as permitted under federal or state law;
(b) A host who initiates contact with law enforcement or fire officials to assist in removing any person from the property or terminating the activity in order to comply with this Chapter, if the request for assistance is made before any other person contacts law enforcement or fire officials to complain about the violation of this Chapter; (c) No host shall aid or abet another person's violation of a provision of this Chapter in a public right-of-way adjacent to the host's private property. A host aids and abets another person's violation of a provision of this Chapter if he or she knows of the other person's unlawful purpose and the host specifically intends to, and does, in fact, aid, facilitate, promote, encourage, or instigate the other person's commission of that violation.

7. A violation of this section shall be charged as an infraction punishable by a fine not exceeding $2,500, pursuant to Livingston Municipal Code Title 1, Chapter 4, subsection (E).

In addition to any other remedy allowed by law, any host who violates this section is subject to all remedies available pursuant to the Livingston Municipal Code. Violations of this Chapter are

Page 334 ends

declared to be a public nuisance. Any host who violates this section is liable for all the response costs relating to the violation. Any fines pursuant to this section, if delinquent, may be recoverable by property lien or special assessment.

SECTION 3. If any section, subsection, sentence, clause or phrase of this Chapter that is for any reason held to be invalid or unconstitutional by the decision of any court of competent jurisdiction, such decision shall not affect the remaining portions of this chapter. The City Council hereby declares that it would have passed this Chapter and each section, subsection, sentence, clause, or phrase thereof, irrespective of the fact that any one or more sections, subsections, sentences, clauses, or phrases be declared invalid or unconstitutional.

SECTION 4. This Ordinance shall be published by one insertion in the Merced Sun Star, a newspaper of general circulation, printed and published in the City, within fifteen (15) days after its final passage and shall take effect, and be in force, thirty (30) days after its final passage.

Introduced: April 18, 2023
Passed and Adopted:

ATTEST:

State of California)
County of Merced)
City of Livingston)
Jose A Moran, Mayor
of City of Livingston
I hereby certify that the foregoing Ordinance was duly introduced at a Regular Meeting of the City Council of the City of Livingston on the 18th day of April 2023, and was passed and adopted at a Regular Meeting of the City Council of the City of Livingston this __ day of _____ 2023, by the following vote:

AYES:

NOES:

ABSENT:

ABSTAIN:

Monica Cisneros, Deputy City Clerk
of the City of Livingston

Page 335 ends

AGENDA ITEM:

MEETING DATE:

PREPARED BY:

REVIEWED BY:

STAFF REPORT
Restated Joint Powers Agreement of Merced County Association of Governments (MCAG)
May 16, 2023
Christopher Lopez, Interim City Manager
Christopher Lopez, Interim City Manager
RECOMMENDATION:

Adopt a Resolution adopting and authorizing the City of Livingston Mayor to sign the Restated Joint Powers Agreement of the Merced County Association of Governments.

BACKGROUND:

Merced County Association of Governments (MCAG) is an association of city and county governments, with members who meet to solve regional problems such as transportation, solid waste, and air quality.

This Association of Governments allows for cities and the county come together to solve problems that can only be accomplished by working together.

MCAG was formed through a Joint Powers Authority (JPA) signed by member jurisdictions in November 1967. As a regional collaborative agency, MCAG serves in a number of transportation planning roles in Merced County based on local, state and federal designations. These designations provide funding for MCAG activities, primarily in transportation planning throughout Merced County.

The current JPA Agreement expires on July 18, 2023. The Governing Board of MCAG, composed of representatives of the jurisdictions, began reviewing the current Agreement in November 2021 for necessary amendments and updates.

In February 2022, an amended (draft) JPA was released to each of the member agencies for review and comment. The deadline to submit comments was July 6, 2022. At the July 15, 2022, MCAG meeting, the Cities requested additional time to review and submit comments. In light of this request, the MCAG Board unanimously approved a motion granting 60 additional days for comment, at the expiration of such time period, if no comments were received, the draft circulated in February 2022 would be submitted to each jurisdiction for ratification.

During the October 20, 2022, MCAG meeting, additional time was requested for each jurisdiction's Counsel to review and negotiate discrete portions of the JPA. Counsels met over the course of several months between November 2022 to January 2023 negotiating changes to the draft JPA with a comment period deadline of January 6, 2023. The JPA agreement was then submitted to the MCAG Board on January 19, 2023 for final review. At the January 19, 2023 meeting, the MCAG Board voted unanimously to submit such draft to their respective jurisdictions for ratification.

Subsequent to the January 19, 2023 MCAG Board meeting, additional revisions and corrections were requested. The substantive revisions were to require unanimous consent of the jurisdictions to amend the term of the agreement, board composition and withdrawal. These changes have been incorporated into the agreement.

Page 1 ends

Page 336 ends

FISCAL IMPACT:

Dues will be included in future year budgets.

ATTACHMENTS:

Attachment A - Resolution
Attachment B - Third Amended and Restated Joint Powers Agreement

Page 2 of 2 ends

Page 337 ends

Attachment A
RESOLUTION NO. 2023-

A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LIVINGSTON

APPROVING THE RESTATED JOINT POWERS AGREEMENT OF THE MERCEND COUNTY

ASSOCIATION OF GOVERNMENTS AND AUTHORIZING THE CITY OF LIVINGSTON

MAYOR TO SIGN THE AGREEMENT
WHEREAS, Government Code section 6500 et seq. authorizes two or more public agencies, by a joint powers agreement entered into respectively by them and authorized by their legislative or governing bodies, to jointly exercise any power common to them; and WHEREAS, the Cities of Livingston, Merced, Los Banos, Atwater, Dos Palos, Gustine, and the County of Merced, possess in common the authority to study, discuss, and develop solutions to area-wide problems of direct concern to the performance of their constitutional and statutory functions; to do all acts necessary to participate in federal programs and receive federal funds for transportation, housing, and other community improvement activities, including contracting and cooperating with other agencies; and to establish an area planning organization and expend public funds for these purposes; and
WHEREAS, the City of Livingston City Council and the residents of the City of Livingston have an interest in the orderly development of the Livingston community, as well as surrounding communities; and
WHEREAS, the continued growth and extensive development within he incorporated and unincorporated areas of Merced County have evidenced the need to create a wholly independent regional agency capable of dealing with area-wide concerns; and WHEREAS, on November 28, 1967, the foregoing needs led to the creation and establishment of Merced County Association of Governments ("MCAG"), of which City of Livingston is a member, pursuant to the Cooperative Agreement/Joint Powers Agreement (the "JPA Agreement"); and
WHEREAS, MCAG was designated by the County of Merced as the Local Transportation Authority for Merced County in 1990 and has operated as such from that date to the present; and WHEREAS, the establishment of MCAG has, among other things, provided a forum to study and develop solutions to area-wide concerns, provided efficiency and economy in governmental operations through the cooperation of MCAG's member agencies and the pooling of common resources, facilitated cooperation among and agreement between MCAG's member agencies for specific purposes, interrelated development actions, and for the adoption of common policies with respect to concerns which are common amongst the member agencies, and allowed for the imposition of a Regional Transportation Impact Fee with MCAG acting as the planning, administrative, and implementation entity; and
{CW127603.1} Page 1 of 2

Page 338 ends

Attachment A
WHEREAS, the JPA Agreement is set to expire, by its own terms, on July 18, 2023; and WHEREAS, the MCAG member agencies, by and through their designated attorneys and representatives, have negotiated the terms of a Restated Joint Powers Agreement, to be effective on July 19, 2023, for a term of thirty (30) years.

NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LIVINGSTON HEREBY RESOLVES:

1. The City Council approves the Restated Joint Powers Agreement of the Merced County Association of Governments.

2. The City Council designates the Mayor to sign the Restated Joint Powers Agreement of the Merced County Association of Governments.

The foregoing resolution was adopted at a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Livingston the 16th day of May 2023, and passed at said meeting by the following vote:

AYES:

NOES:

ABSENT:

ABSTAIN:

The foregoing resolution is hereby approved.

ATTEST:

Jose Moran, Mayor
of City of Livingston
I, Monica Cisneros, Deputy City Clerk of the City of Livingston, do hereby certify that the foregoing resolution was duly adopted and passed by the City Council at a regular meeting of said City Council, held at the Livingston Council Chambers on May 16, 2023. {CW127603.1} Page 2 of 2
Monica Cisneros, Deputy City Clerk
of City of Livingston

Page 339 ends

Attachment B

RESTATED JOINT POWERS AGREEMENT OF THE
MERCED COUNTY ASSOCIATION OF GOVERNMENTS [MCAG]
Effective Date July 19, 2023
This Restated Joint Powers Agreement is entered into by and among those undersigned of the Cities of Atwater, Dos Palos, Gustine, Livingston, Los Banos, and Merced, all municipal corporations and the County of Merced, a political subdivision of the State of California.

RECITALS

1. Common Power. Chapter 5 of Division 7 of Title 1 (commencing with Section 6500) of the California Government Code authorizes two or more public agencies, by a joint powers agreement entered into respectively by them and authorized by their legislative or governing bodies, to jointly exercise any power common to them.

2. Common Authority. The City of Merced, by virtue of its charter, and the Cities of Los Banos, Atwater, Livingston, Dos Palos and Gustine, and the County of Merced, by virtue of California Government Code Section 6500 - 6539.9, inclusive, possess in common the authority:
a) To study, discuss, and develop solutions to area-wide problems of direct concern to the performance of their constitutional and statutory functions and to establish an area planning organization and expend public funds for these purposes; and b) To do all acts necessary to participate in federal programs and receive federal funds for transportation, housing, and other community improvement activities, including contracting and cooperating with other agencies.

3. Orderly Development. The people residing within the incorporated and unincorporated areas of Merced County have an interest in the orderly development of their communities.

4. Independent Agency. The continued growth and extensive development within the incorporated and unincorporated areas of Merced County have evidenced the 1

Page 340 ends

need to create a wholly independent regional agency capable of dealing with area-wide issues and problems.

5. Merced County Association of Governments. On November 28, 1967, the foregoing needs led to the creation and establishment of Merced County Association of Governments, (hereinafter referred to as "MCAG").

6. Transportation Authority. MCAG was designated by the County of Merced as the Local Transportation Authority for Merced County in 1990 and has operated as such from that date to the present.

7. Effects. The establishment of MCAG has:
a) Provided a forum to study and develop solutions to area-wide problems of mutual concern to the Agencies.
b) Provided efficiency and economy in governmental operations through the cooperation of the Agencies and the pooling of common resources. c) Provided for the establishment of a Joint Powers Authority responsible for identifying, planning, and developing solutions to regional problems requiring multijurisdictional cooperation. d) Provided for the establishment of a Joint Powers Authority capable of developing regional plans and policies and performing area-wide planning duties. e) Facilitated cooperation among and agreement between the Agencies for specific purposes, interrelated developmental actions, and for the adoption of common policies with respect to issues and problems which are common to the Agencies. f) Allowed for imposition of a Regional Transportation Impact Fee with the Authority as the planning, administrative and implementation entity.

8. Amendment. The undersigned Agencies and Members desire to amend and restate the "Cooperative Agreement"/Joint Powers Agreement dated November 28, 1967, as amended (the "Original Agreement"), in order to establish the duties and powers of the MERCED COUNTY ASSOCIATION OF GOVERNMENTS. This Restated Joint Powers 2

Page 341 ends

Agreement and the terms and conditions set forth herein supersede all prior amendments and restatements of the Original Agreement.

NOW, THEREFORE, IT IS MUTUALLY AGREED AS FOLLOWS:

ARTICLE 1. DEFINITIONS

1.1 Unless the context otherwise requires, capitalized terms used in this Agreement will have the meanings specified in Exhibit A, which is attached and incorporated by this reference.

ARTICLE 2. PURPOSE

2.1 This Agreement is made pursuant to the Act to provide for the joint exercise of certain powers common to the Members and the additional powers granted under the Act. To the extent currently applicable, those powers and/or functions are set forth in Article 6 below.

ARTICLE 3. CONTINUATION OF AUTHORITY

3.1 Continuation. Upon the effective date of this Agreement, the Parties hereto hereby continue the MERCED COUNTY ASSOCIATION OF GOVERNMENTS, as a public entity separate and distinct from its member entities, as the agent to exercise the common powers provided for in this Agreement and to administer or otherwise execute the terms of this Agreement.

3.2 Assets, Rights and Liabilities. The assets, rights, debts, liabilities, and obligations of MCAG shall be those of MCAG and shall not constitute assets, rights, debts, liabilities, or obligations of any of the Members. However, nothing in this Agreement shall prevent any Member from separately contracting for, or assuming responsibility for, specific debts, liabilities, or obligations of MCAG, provided that both the Board and that Member approve such contract or assumption. The provisions of Government Code 3

Page 342 ends

section 6504, specifically including the right of Members to advance funds and make loans, are made a part of this Agreement.

ARTICLE 4. TERM

4.1 Effective Date. This Agreement shall become effective on July 19, 2023.

4.2 Term. This Agreement shall continue for a period of thirty years from the effective date unless terminated in accordance with Article 1 O of this Agreement. The term may only be modified by the unanimous consent of all Members.

ARTICLE 5. BOUNDARIES

5.1 Boundary. MCAG's jurisdictional boundary shall not exceed the jurisdictional boundary of the County of Merced, as the County boundary may be expanded or changed during the Term of this Agreement. This provision shall not prevent MCAG from acquiring services or property outside of its boundaries for the benefit of MCAG Agencies.

ARTICLE 6. FUNCTIONS/POWERS

6.1 Authority Functions. MCAG will function or continue to function as:
a. The Local Transportation Authority as designated by the County of Merced in 1990.
b. The Metropolitan Planning Organization as designated by the United States Department of Transportation pursuant to Title 23 of United States Code Section 134 and Title 49 of the United States Code §5303(b)(2). c. The Regional Transportation Planning Agency as designated by the Secretary of Business and Transportation of the State of California pursuant to California Government Code Sections 65080, et seq.
d. The regional transportation planning representative as designated by the parties hereto for the purpose of acting upon any appropriate proposals which may be presented to the Board for consideration or which the Board may elect to take up and for transmission of proposed recommendations to federal, state and local agencies, including, but not limited to, the member entities of MCAG.
4

Page 343 ends

e. The designated E.O. 12372 Intergovernmental Review of Federal Programs Clearing House and as such review all applications for federal funds by any participating entity wherein such review is a requirement of the particular federal aid program involved.
f. The State Census Affiliate Data Center for Merced County. g. The Service Authority for Freeway Emergencies (SAFE) as created by the Members in 1996.
h. The agency to administer, coordinate, plan and implement/effectuate a Regional Transportation Impact Fee Program if adopted by the Agencies. i. MCAG shall perform any functions directed by the Board in furtherance of the foregoing or other programs as determined by the Board.

6.2 Powers. MCAG is authorized, but is in no way required, to act in its own name on any or all of the following matters, as each Member could act separately, and as it deems in the best interest of its Members, to the extent permitted by any and all applicable laws, codes, ordinances, resolutions and regulations, subject only to such restrictions upon the manner and exercise of such power as are imposed upon the County of Merced in the exercise of similar powers:
a. Make and enter into contracts.
b. Acquire, improve, hold, lease, and dispose of real and personal property of all types.
c. Accept gifts, donations, advances and contributions and act as regional lead jurisdiction/applicant and grant administrator for grants in the name of Members/regional participants.
d. Hire agents and employees
e. Sue and be sued in its own name.
f. Incur and discharge debts, liabilities and obligations. g. Issue bonds or notes and incur other forms of indebtedness, and 5

Page 344 ends

make associated covenants, for designated purposes, subject to the provisions and limitations of the California Constitution and the Government Code. h. Adopt, as authorized by California law, ordinances and resolutions necessary to carry out the purposes of this Agreement.
i. Any additional power granted to Joint Powers Authorities under the Act.
j. All powers necessary to the exercise of the enumerated powers.

ARTICLE 7. ORGANIZATION

7.1 Governing Board.

MCAG shall be governed by a Governing Board (hereinafter "Board"), which shall exercise or oversee the exercise of all powers and authority on its behalf. The Board shall meet in accordance with the MCAG bylaws. Under this Agreement, the Board is expressly charged with carrying out the foregoing provisions through its actions, through contracts, or through staff hired by MCAG.

7.2 Directors.
(a) The Board shall consist of each of the five Merced County Supervisors and one elected legislative official from each of the other Members. No Person shall be eligible for appointment to the Board unless he or she is serving in an elective position.

Each of the city Members may appoint one elective Person as an alternate to serve in the absence of an appointed director. Directors and alternate directors who have been duly appointed and are serving at the time of the adoption of this Agreement may continue to serve in that capacity without any further action of the Member. (b) Each Director, so long as a public official, shall hold office from the first meeting of the Board after appointment by the Member until his or her successor is selected by such Member.
(c) This Section 7.2 may only be modified by the unanimous consent of the Members.
6

Page 345 ends

7.3 Principal Place of Business. The principal place of business of MCAG shall be located within the Boundary of MCAG.

7.4 Officers.
(a) The Board shall select a Chair and a Vice Chair from among the Directors who shall hold office for a period of one year commencing July 1st. The Chair and Vice Chair shall alternate between a Member of the Merced County Board of Supervisors and a city Member representative. The positions shall rotate and there shall be no consecutive terms. These specifications are met with the adherence to the Chair Rotation Schedule adopted by the MCAG Board of Directors on June 15, 2017. The Rotation Schedule may be amended at the discretion of the Board from time to time but shall generally not result in consecutive terms or break the alternation between the County Board of Supervisors Members and the city Member.
(b) Executive Director. The Board shall utilize an Executive Director who shall be the chief executive officer of MCAG.
(c) Deputy Executive Director. The Executive Director may appoint a Deputy Executive Director who shall be a full-time employee of MCAG and who shall serve as Executive Director in the absence of the Executive Director. (d) Finance Director. The Executive Director shall appoint a Finance Director who shall be a full-time employee of MCAG and who shall function under the guidance of the Executive Director.
(e) Secretary. The Board shall utilize the services of a Secretary who shall be an employee of MCAG.
(f) General Counsel. MCAG shall contract with an attorney licensed to practice in the State of California who shall serve as General Counsel to MCAG.

7.5 Designation of Law. As required by section 6509 of the Act, and in the absence of conflicting procedural rules, ordinances and resolutions adopted by the Board, 7

Page 346 ends

the procedural rules, ordinances and resolutions of the County of Merced are the governing law for MCAG.

ARTICLE 8. FINANCIAL MATTERS

8.1 Financial Matters.
(a) Budget. MCAG shall prepare and submit to the Board a budget and work plan for adoption prior to July 1 of each year for the ensuing Fiscal Year. (b) Treasurer. The Finance Director of MCAG shall be the Treasurer pursuant to Government Code section 6505.6.
(c) Auditor. The Finance Director of MCAG shall be the Auditor pursuant to Government Code section 6505.6.
(d) Duties of Treasurer and Auditor. The Treasurer and/or Auditor, as appropriate, shall do all of the following:
(1) Receive and receipt for all money of MCAG and place ii in the treasury of the Treasurer so designated to the credit of MCAG. (2) Be responsible, upon his or her official bond, for the safekeeping and disbursement of all MCAG money so held by him or her. (3) Pay, when due, all sums payable with respect to outstanding indebtedness of MCAG.
(4) Pay any other sums due from MCAG only upon warrants of the public officer performing the functions of auditor or controller who has been designated by this Agreement.
(5) Make or contract to make an annual audit of the accounts and records of MCAG. The minimum standards of the audit shall be those prescribed for special districts under Section 26909 of the Government Code and shall conform to generally accepted auditing practices. A report of the audit shall be filed as public record with each of the Agencies within 12 months of the end of the Fiscal Year under examination. Any costs in making an audit in accordance with this Agreement shall be 8

Page 347 ends

borne by MCAG and shall be a charge against any unencumbered funds of MCAG available for the purpose.
(6) Draw warrants to pay demands against MCAG when the
demands have been approved by any Person authorized to so approve in this Agreement. (7) File an official bond or proof of insurance in an agreed amount pursuant to section 6505.1 of the Act.
(8) Perform any and all other functions necessary to effectuate this Agreement.
(e) Investment Policy. The investment policy of MCAG shall be the investment policy adopted by the Board.
(f) Revenue Bonds. MCAG may issue revenue bonds, but the revenue bonds shall not constitute a debt, liability, or obligation of an individual Member. (g) lnsu ranee/Indemnification.

MCAG shall maintain general liability insurance relating to its enumerated functions and shall indemnify, protect, defend and hold harmless all of the Members and their elected and appointed officers, employees, and agents from and against any and all liability, including but not limited to demands, claims, actions, fees, costs, and expenses (including attorney and expert witness fees), arising from or connected with the MCAG's acts and/or omissions arising from and/or relating to this Agreement or any act and/or omission performed by a Member on behalf of MCAG or at the request of MCAG. This indemnity shall include Environmental Laws as herein defined.

ARTICLE 9. WITHDRAWAL FROM MCAG

9.1 Withdrawal Conditions. A Member may not withdraw from MCAG unless and until that Member:
(a) Liquidates in full its proportion of any and all existing debts, obligations and liabilities incurred, earned, or expected to be earned by the date of withdrawal, 9

Page 348 ends

including, but not limited to, certificates of participation, notes, revenue bonds and other indebtedness, if any, as determined by the Board. The liabilities of a withdrawing Member shall specifically include those resulting from acts or omissions when the withdrawing Member was a participating Member of MCAG.
(b) Has provided written notice of intent to withdraw, via a resolution of the governing body of the Member, at least one (1) year prior to the end of the Fiscal Year in which it intends to withdraw. Withdrawal shall be effective at the end of the fiscal year. (c) This Section 9.1 may only be modified by the unanimous consent of the Members.

9.2 Costs of Withdrawal. A withdrawing Member shall be responsible for all costs associated with its withdrawal from MCAG. Such costs may include, but may not be limited to, MCAG staff lime associated with ensuring the proper and complete withdrawal of the Member and costs of continuing contracts attributable to that Member. In determining the costs associated with the withdrawal of a Member, the withdrawing Member shall have the option of allowing MCAG to determine such costs or of hiring, at its own cost, an independent auditor approved by the Board to determine the costs associated with its withdrawal.

ARTICLE 10. TERMINATION

10.1 Termination Requirements. This Agreement may only be terminated by consent of all Members, and upon full and complete liquidation of all liabilities, including, but not limited to, certificates of participation, notes, revenue bonds and other indebtedness, if any, and the winding up of all MCAG business. Upon the date of termination ("Termination Date"), payment of any and all obligations and division of any and all assets of MCAG shall be conducted subject to the then applicable requirements of the law (currently Section 6511, et seq., of the Act) as follows:
(a) In the event of termination of MCAG where there is a successor public entity that will conduct all of the activities and assume all of its obligations, any and all MCAG assets and liabilities remaining upon termination shall be transferred to the 10

Page 349 ends

successor public agency.
(b) If there is no successor public agency that would conduct MCAG's activities, all assets and liabilities, including surplus money, shall be apportioned to each Member in proportion to population.
(c) If there is a successor public agency that would conduct some of MCAG's activities, then the Board shall allocate MCAG assets and liabilities, including surplus money, between the successor public agency and the Members. In such case the Member's portion of the allocation shall be based on subparagraph (b) above. (d) By unanimous agreement of the Members, assets and liabilities may be disposed of, divided or distributed on a basis different from that established in this Article 10.

ARTICLE 11. BYLAWS

11.1 Bylaws. Bylaws may be adopted by the Board pursuant to which meetings of the Board shall be called. The Bylaws shall contain appropriate provisions for the transaction of business and describe the duties and powers of the Chair and Vice Chair and such other officers as may be appointed. To the extent the Bylaws conflict with this Agreement, the terms of this Agreement shall control. The Bylaws may be amended from time to time by majority vote of the Board after notice in accordance with the Bylaws.

ARTICLE 12. AMENDMENTS

12.1 With the exception of Article 10, Article 9, Section 7.2 and Section 4.2, this Agreement may be amended at any time by agreement of five Members, one of which must be the County of Merced. The County of Merced's agreement shall be evidenced by a resolution of the County Board of Supervisors. Agreement of a city Member shall be evidenced by a resolution of their respective City Council. However, no amendment may reduce the representation rights of a Member, or add to the duties or obligations of a Member without the agreement of such Member.

ARTICLE 13. MISCELLANEOUS

13.1 Filing with the Secretary of State. All notices required by Government Code 11

Page 350 ends

Sections 6503.5 and 53051 shall be filed by MCAG with the California Secretary of State.

13.2 Immunity. All of the privileges and immunities from liability, exemptions from laws, ordinances and rules, all pension, relief, disability, worker's compensation, and other benefits which would apply to the activity of officers, agents, or employees of any such Member, when performing their respective functions within the territorial limits of the respective Members, shall apply to them to the same degree and extent while engaged in the performance of any of their functions and duties under this agreement outside the territorial limits of their Agencies.

13.2 Successors and Assigns. This Agreement shall be binding upon and shall inure to the benefit of the successors and assigns of each Member. Notwithstanding the foregoing, no Member may assign any right or obligation hereunder without the written consent of all other Members.

13.3 Severability. If any provision of this Agreement or its application to any Person or circumstances is held invalid or illegal by a final judgment of a court of law in the State of California, the remainder of this Agreement and the application of the provision to other Persons or circumstances shall not be affected.

13.4 Headings. All section headings contained in this Agreement are for convenience and reference only. They are not intended to define or limit the scope of any provision of this Agreement.

13.5 Conflict of Interest Code. MCAG has adopted a conflict of interest code.

13.6 Disputes. Prior to filing a lawsuit, the parties shall attempt to resolve, in good faith, any and all disputes, claims or controversies arising out of or relating to this Agreement, including decisions and official actions of the Board, by participating in mediation, conducted by a mediator selected by the parties to the dispute. This provision may be invoked by any Member with written notice ("Notice of Mediation") to MCAG, or to the other Agency to the dispute, accompanied by a resolution of the invoking Agency's council or board invoking this provision. MCAG may also invoke this provision through a majority vote of the MCAG Board.
12

Page 351 ends

Once Mediation Notice is received by an Agency, the parties to the dispute, or their respective representative, shall select a mediator with appropriate expertise and experience with dispute resolution. If the parties are not able to stipulate to a mediator, then, within 1 O business days of receiving the Mediation Notice, the parties shall simultaneously exchange a list of three mediators. Each party shall propose their list of mediators independently and without sharing their list with any other party. Within five business days of the exchange, the parties shall, independently and without comparing, rank all of the mediators exchanged in numerical order and exchange such rankings. The highest-ranking person shall be designated as the mediator. In the event of a tie, the earliest available person shall be designated as the mediator. If such mediator is not available to serve, or is otherwise conflicted, the parties shall proceed to contact the mediator who was next highest in ranking until they are able to select a mediator. The parties shall have 30 days from receipt of the Notice of Mediation to select a mediator.

The selected mediator, in consultation with the parties, shall establish the time and place of mediation, rules regarding the prompt exchange of information, and the exchange and preparation of written summaries (if necessary). The parties shall attempt in good faith to complete mediation of the dispute within 120 days of selection. The parties may, by unanimous agreement, establish a different timeframe for mediation. Such alternative timeframe must be in writing and agreed to within 90 days from receipt of the Mediation Notice. Such agreement may be executed by the parties' representatives. The parties agree to attend a minimum of two full-day mediation sessions if the matter cannot be resolved sooner. During the course of the mediation, no party can assert the failure to fully comply with the timelines established herein as a reason not to proceed or to delay the mediation.

The service of the Notice of Mediation shall stay the running of any applicable statute of limitations regarding the dispute until 15 days after conclusion of mediation.

Conclusion of the mediation shall occur at the earliest of 1) execution of a settlement 13

Page 352 ends

agreement by all parties to the mediation, 2) declaration of the mediator that mediation is terminated, or 3) at the expiration of 120 days from the selection of the mediator ( or alternative agreed upon timeframe for mediation) and the parties have attended two fullday mediation sessions. Each side shall bear an equal share of the mediation costs unless the parties agree otherwise.

The mediation process shall be confidential based on terms acceptable to the mediator and/or mediation service provider.

13. 7 Execution in Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed on behalf of the respective Members in one or more counterparts, all of which shall collectively constitute one agreement.

13.8 Authority to Bind. Each person signing below represents and warrants that he or she is authorized, by resolution or similar action, of their respective city council or board of supervisors to bind the Agency on whose behalf he or she executes this Agreement.

IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Parties hereto have executed this Agreement on the dates shown in the respective signature blocks.

MERCED COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
By: ------------------ Dated: _________ _
Ch airman
ATTEST:

By: _______________ _
Clerk of County Board of Supervisors
Approved as to Legal Form:

By: _________________ _
County Counsel
14

Page 353 ends

CITY OF ATWATER
By: ________________ Dated: ________ _
Mayor
ATTEST:

By: _______________ _
City Clerk
Approved as to Legal Form:

By: _______________ _
City Attorney

CITY OF DOS PALOS
By: ________________ Dated: _________ _
Mayor
ATTEST:

By: --::--,-,,----------------
City Clerk
Approved as to Legal Form:

By:. _______________ _
City Attorney
15

Page 354 ends

CITY OF GUSTINE
By: ________________ Dated: ________ _
Mayor
ATTEST:

By: ______________ _
City Clerk
Approved as to Legal Form:

By: ______________ _
City Attorney

CITY OF LIVINGSTON
By: _______________ Dated: ________ _
Mayor
ATTEST:

By: -::-:---:-------------- City Clerk
Approved as to Legal Form:

By: ______________ _
City Attorney
16

Page 355 ends

CITY OF LOS BANOS
By: ________________ .Dated: _________ _
Mayor
ATTEST:

By: _______________ _
City Clerk
Approved as to Legal Form:

By: _______________ _
City Attorney

CITY OF MERCED
By: ________________ .Dated: ________ _
Mayor
ATTEST:

By: _______________ _
City Clerk
Approved as to Legal Form:

By: _______________ _
City Attorney
17

Page 356 ends

EXHIBIT A

DEFINITIONS
Unless the context otherwise requires, capitalized terms used in this Agreement will have the meanings specified below.

Act
"Act" means the California Joint Exercise of Powers Law (California Government Code Section 6500 et seq.)
Agency/Agencies
"Agency/Agencies" means the County of Merced, City of Atwater, City of Dos Palos, City of Gustine, City of Livingston, City of Los Banos, and City of Merced.

Agreement
"Agreement" means this Restated Joint Exercise of Powers Agreement, as it may be amended from time to time.

Auditor
Board
Chair
"Auditor'' means the Finance Director of MCAG.
"Board" means the governing Board of Directors of MCAG, consisting of representatives from each of the Members as more fully described in Article 7 of th is Agreement.
"Chair" means the Chair of the MCAG Board, as described in Article 7 of this Agreement and the Bylaws.

Director
"Director'' means the Member representatives appointed to serve on the governing Board of Directors.

Environmental Laws
"Environmental Laws" means all federal and state statutes and all county, local, and Agency ordinances concerning public health, safety, and the environment including, by way of example and not limitations, the Comprehensive Environmental 18

Page 357 ends

Response, Compensation, and Liability Act of 1980, 42 USC §9601, et seq.; the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act, 42 USC §6902, et seq.; the Federal Clean Water Act, 33 USC §1251, et seq.; the Toxic Substances Control Act, 15 USC §1601, et seq.; the Occupational Safety and Health Act, 29 USC §651, et seq.; the California Hazardous Waste Control Act, California Health and Safety Code §25100, et seq.; the California Toxic Substances Control Act, California Health and Safety Code §25300, et seq.; the Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act, California Water Code §13000, et seq.; the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act, California Health and Safety Code §25249.5, et seq.; the California Integrated Waste Management Act, California Public Resources Code §40000, et seq., as currently in force or as hereafter amended, and all rules and regulations promulgated thereunder.

Fiscal Year
"Fiscal Year'' means the period commencing on each July 1 and ending on the following June 30.

Legislation
MCAG
"Legislation" means any code, ordinance, resolution, or any other forms or enactment of the Agencies or any Member which now exists or which may hereafter be adopted which constitutes law or regulation.
"MCAG" means Merced County Association of Governments or "Authority".

Member
"Member'' means any Agency (as defined above) which signs onto this Agreement.

Person
Term
"Person" means any individual, firm, association, organization, partnership, corporation, business trust, joint venture, special purpose district, town, city, county, state, or the United States.
"Term" means the period of time specified in Article 4 of this Agreement.

Treasurer
"Treasurer" means the Finance Director of MCAG.
19

Livingston City CouncilMay 16, 2023

Livingston City Council
May 16, 2023