Agenda packet, second session — Malibu City Council, April 8, 2024 (part 3 of 3)

73 City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of Malibu Environmental Health Administrator $ 11,869 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Thousand Oaks Environmental Programs Coordinator $ 11,323 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00% 3 City of Agoura Hills N/C4 City of Beverly Hills N/C
5 City of Calabasas N/C6 City of Camarillo N/C7 City of Culver City N/C8 City of Laguna Beach N/C9 City of Manhattan Beach N/C 10 City of Redondo Beach N/C11 City of West Hollywood N/C Top Monthly
Insuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. Data 1 Environmental Health AdministratorSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non ComparatorMedian of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 19 of 48 ends

74 City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of Culver City Environmental Programs & Operations Manager $ 14,626 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 2 City of Beverly Hills Environmental Compliance and Sustainability Programs Manager $ 13,469 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 3 City of Malibu Environmental Programs Manager $ 13,355 7/1/2023 unknown unknown4 City of Manhattan Beach Environmental Programs Administrator $ 12,283 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50% 5 City of Agoura Hills N/C6 City of Calabasas N/C7 City of Camarillo N/C8 City of Laguna Beach N/C 9 City of Redondo Beach N/C
10 City of Thousand Oaks N/C11 City of West Hollywood N/C Top Monthly
Insuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. Data 3 Environmental Programs ManagerSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non ComparatorMedian of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 20 of 48 ends

75 City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of Malibu Environmental Sustainability Analyst $ 9,765 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Culver City Management Analyst $ 9,065 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00%3 City of Beverly Hills Management Analyst $ 9,047 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50%4 City of Agoura Hills N/C5 City of Calabasas N/C6 City of Camarillo N/C7 City of Laguna Beach N/C 8 City of Manhattan Beach N/C9 City of Redondo Beach N/C 10 City of Thousand Oaks N/C11 City of West Hollywood N/C Top Monthly
Insuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. Data 2 Environmental Sustainability AnalystSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non ComparatorMedian of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 21 of 48 ends

76 City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of Beverly Hills1 [Utilities General Manager/ Assistant Director of Community Development/Building Official]
$ 21,965 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50%
2 City of Malibu Environmental Sustainability Director/Building Official $ 18,863 7/1/2023 unknown unknown3 City of Agoura Hills N/C4 City of Calabasas N/C5 City of Camarillo N/C6 City of Culver City N/C7 City of Laguna Beach N/C 8 City of Manhattan Beach N/C9 City of Redondo Beach N/C 10 City of Thousand Oaks N/C11 City of West Hollywood N/C Top Monthly
Insuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. Data 1 Environmental Sustainability Director/Building OfficialSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Functional Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties of the class are performed by more than one class at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is the same for both matches. Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 22 of 48 ends

77 City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of Camarillo Executive Assistant $ 10,005 7/1/2023 unknown unknown2 City of Malibu Executive Assistant $ 9,968 7/1/2023 unknown unknown3 City of West Hollywood Senior Administrative Specialist $ 9,803 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 4 City of Thousand Oaks Executive Assistant $ 9,107 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00%5 City of Laguna Beach Executive Assistant $ 8,446 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 6 City of Redondo Beach Executive Assistant to Mayor and Council/City Manager $ 8,216 1/13/2024 unknown unknown7 City of Manhattan Beach Executive Assistant to the City Manager $ 8,215 1/14/2023 unknown unknown8 City of Agoura Hills Executive Assistant $ 7,971 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 9 City of Beverly Hills Executive Assistant $ 7,938 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 10 City of Calabasas Executive Assistant II $ 6,893 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 11 City of Culver City Administrative Secretary $ 6,239 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% Top Monthly
$ 8,283

16.9%
$ 8,216

17.6%
$ 8,942

10.3%
10 Executive AssistantSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non ComparatorMedian of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 23 of 48 ends

78 City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of Beverly Hills Budget and Financial Analyst $ 11,373 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 2 City of Camarillo1 [Accountant II/ Financial Analyst II] $ 11,334 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 3 City of Thousand Oaks Financial Analyst $ 11,211 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00% 4 City of West Hollywood Accountant $ 11,157 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 5 City of Manhattan Beach Budget and Financial Analyst $ 10,299 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50% 6 City of Malibu Financial Analyst $ 9,765 7/1/2023 unknown unknown7 City of Laguna Beach Accountant $ 9,039 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00% 8 City of Culver City Accountant II $ 8,371 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00%9 City of Redondo Beach2 [Accountant/ Administrative Analyst] $ 7,678 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 10 City of Calabasas Senior Accounting Specialist $ 7,538 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 11 City of Agoura Hills N/C
Top Monthly
$ 9,778
‐0.1%
$ 10,299
‐5.5%
$ 11,211
‐14.8%
9 Financial AnalystSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowMedian of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Camarillo: Span of Responsibility Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties are bridged by a higher and lower-level classification at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is an average of the matches. 2 - City of Redondo Beach: Functional Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties of the class are performed by more than one class at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is the higher of the matches.

Page 24 of 48 ends

79 City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of Malibu Fire Safety Liaison $ 9,677 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Agoura Hills N/C3 City of Beverly Hills N/C
4 City of Calabasas N/C5 City of Camarillo N/C6 City of Culver City N/C7 City of Laguna Beach N/C8 City of Manhattan Beach N/C9 City of Redondo Beach N/C 10 City of Thousand Oaks N/C11 City of West Hollywood N/C Top Monthly
Insuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. Data N/A
0 Fire Safety LiaisonSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non ComparatorMedian of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 25 of 48 ends

80 City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of West Hollywood Digital Media Specialist $ 9,105 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Manhattan Beach Digital Communications and Graphics Coordinator $ 8,915 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 3 City of Beverly Hills1 [Graphic Artist/ Senior Graphic Artist] $ 7,841 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 4 City of Malibu Graphic Artist $ 6,770 7/1/2023 unknown unknown5 City of Agoura Hills N/C6 City of Calabasas N/C7 City of Camarillo N/C8 City of Culver City N/C9 City of Laguna Beach N/C 10 City of Redondo Beach N/C11 City of Thousand Oaks N/C Top Monthly
Insuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. Data N/A
3 Graphic ArtistSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Span of Responsibility Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties are bridged by a higher and lower-level classification at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is an average of the matches. Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 26 of 48 ends

81 City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of Camarillo Human Resources Analyst $ 11,031 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of West Hollywood Human Resources Specialist $ 10,951 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 3 City of Thousand Oaks Associate Human Resources Analyst $ 10,894 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00% 4 City of Redondo Beach Human Resources Analyst $ 10,155 1/13/2024 unknown unknown 5 City of Malibu Human Resources Analyst $ 9,073 7/1/2023 unknown unknown6 City of Culver City Human Resources Analyst $ 9,065 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00%7 City of Beverly Hills Human Resources Analyst $ 9,047 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 8 City of Manhattan Beach Human Resources Analyst $ 8,915 1/14/2023 unknown unknown9 City of Laguna Beach Administrative Analyst $ 8,011 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00% 10 City of Agoura Hills N/C11 City of Calabasas N/C
Top Monthly
$ 9,759
‐7.6%
$ 9,610
‐5.9%
$ 10,908
‐20.2%
8 Human Resources AnalystSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non ComparatorMedian of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 27 of 48 ends

82 City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of Camarillo Human Resources Manager $ 16,298 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Culver City Senior Human Resources and Equity Manager $ 15,146 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00%3 City of Laguna Beach1 Human Resources Director and Principal HR Analyst $ 15,068 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 4 City of Beverly Hills Human Resources Manager $ 15,027 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 5 City of Thousand Oaks Deputy HR Director/Risk Manager $ 14,979 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00% 6 City of Manhattan Beach Human Resources Manager $ 14,577 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 7 City of West Hollywood Human Resources Supervisor $ 13,126 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 8 City of Redondo Beach Human Resources Manager $ 12,444 1/13/2024 unknown unknown 9 City of Malibu Human Resources Manager $ 11,869 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 10 City of Agoura Hills Human Resources Manager $ 10,988 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 11 City of Calabasas N/C
Top Monthly
$ 14,184
‐19.5%
$ 14,979
‐26.2%
$ 15,068
‐27.0%
9 Human Resources ManagerSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Laguna Beach: Span of Responsibility Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties are bridged by a higher and lower-level classification at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is an average of the matches. Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 28 of 48 ends

83 City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of West Hollywood Systems Engineer $ 13,125 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Thousand Oaks Information Technology Analyst II $ 12,263 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00% 3 City of Laguna Beach Senior IT Analyst $ 11,767 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00% 4 City of Beverly Hills Network Integrator $ 11,373 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 5 City of Manhattan Beach Network Administrator $ 10,443 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50% 6 City of Culver City Information Systems Analyst $ 9,341 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 7 City of Malibu Information Systems Analyst $ 9,073 7/1/2023 unknown unknown8 City of Calabasas Senior Information Technology Specialist $ 8,839 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 9 City of Redondo Beach Information Technology Analyst $ 8,567 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 10 City of Agoura Hills N/C11 City of Camarillo N/C
Top Monthly
$ 10,715
‐18.1%
$ 10,908
‐20.2%
$ 11,891
‐31.1%
8 Information Systems AnalystSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non ComparatorMedian of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 29 of 48 ends

84 City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of Thousand Oaks Information Technology Manager $ 16,711 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00% 2 City of West Hollywood2 [Information Technology Manager/ Systems Engineer Supervisor]
$ 16,394 7/1/2023 unknown unknown
3 City of Laguna Beach Information Technology Manager $ 16,114 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 4 City of Camarillo Information Systems Manager $ 15,522 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 5 City of Manhattan Beach Information Systems Manager $ 15,013 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50% 6 City of Redondo Beach1 [Information Technology Director/ IT Operations Infrastructure Supervisor]
$ 14,228 1/13/2024 unknown unknown
7 City of Culver City Systems Support Manager $ 14,064 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00%8 City of Calabasas Information Systems Manager $ 13,695 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 9 City of Malibu Information Systems Manager $ 13,087 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 10 City of Agoura Hills N/C11 City of Beverly Hills N/C Top Monthly
$ 15,218
‐16.3%
$ 15,267
‐16.7%
$ 16,184
‐23.7%
8 Information Systems ManagerSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowMedian of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Redondo Beach: Span of Responsibility Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties are bridged by a higher and lower-level classification at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is an average of the matches. 2 - City of West Hollywood: Span of Responsibility Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties are bridged by a higher and lower-level classification at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is an average of the matches.

Page 30 of 48 ends

85 City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of Laguna Beach Information System Specialist $ 10,934 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00% 2 City of West Hollywood Information Technology Systems Analyst $ 9,803 7/1/2023 unknown unknown3 City of Camarillo Information Systems Technician $ 9,529 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 4 City of Manhattan Beach Information Systems Specialist $ 8,816 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50% 5 City of Thousand Oaks Information Technology Technician II $ 7,965 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 4.00% 6 City of Calabasas Information Technology Specialist $ 7,244 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 7 City of Malibu Information Systems Technician $ 6,770 7/1/2023 unknown unknown8 City of Culver City Service Desk Technician $ 6,590 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 9 City of Redondo Beach Information Technology Technician $ 5,349 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 10 City of Agoura Hills N/C11 City of Beverly Hills N/C Top Monthly
$ 8,279
‐22.3%
$ 8,391
‐23.9%
$ 9,598
‐41.8%
8 Information Systems TechnicianSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non ComparatorMedian of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 31 of 48 ends

86 City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of Malibu Management Analyst proposed
2 City of West Hollywood Management Analyst $ 12,141 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 3 City of Laguna Beach Senior Management Analyst $ 11,767 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00% 4 City of Camarillo Management Analyst $ 11,031 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 5 City of Thousand Oaks Associate Analyst $ 10,507 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00%6 City of Manhattan Beach Management Analyst $ 9,182 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50% 7 City of Culver City Management Analyst $ 9,065 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00%8 City of Beverly Hills Management Analyst $ 9,047 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 9 City of Agoura Hills Management Analyst $ 9,018 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 10 City of Calabasas Management Analyst $ 8,839 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 11 City of Redondo Beach Senior Management Analyst $ 8,206 1/14/2023 unknown unknown Top Monthly
$ 9,880$ 9,124
$ 10,900
N/A
10 Management AnalystSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non ComparatorMedian of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 32 of 48 ends

87 City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of Camarillo Community Relations Officer $ 13,408 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Culver City Communications and Public Information Manager $ 13,333 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 3 City of West Hollywood Public Information Officer $ 13,125 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 4 City of Beverly Hills Public Information Manager $ 12,689 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 5 City of Manhattan Beach2 [Communications and Civic Manager/ Marketing & Communications Coordinator]
$ 11,746 1/14/2023 unknown unknown
6 City of Laguna Beach1 [Communications Manager/ Digital Media Coordinator] $ 11,565 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00% 7 City of Agoura Hills Communications Manager $ 10,988 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 8 City of Malibu Media Information Officer $ 9,678 7/1/2023 unknown unknown9 City of Thousand Oaks Communications and Marketing Analyst $ 9,509 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00% 10 City of Calabasas N/C11 City of Redondo Beach N/C
Top Monthly
$ 12,045
‐24.5%
$ 12,217
‐26.2%
$ 13,177
‐36.2%
8 Media Information OfficerSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowMedian of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Laguna Beach: Span of Responsibility Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties are bridged by a higher and lower-level classification at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is an average of the matches. 2 - City of Manhattan Beach: Span of Responsibility Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties are bridged by a higher and lower-level classification at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is an average of the matches.

Page 33 of 48 ends

88 City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of West Hollywood Urban Forest and Landscape Maintenance Supervisor $ 12,141 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Calabasas Landscape District Maintenance Manager $ 11,914 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 3 City of Manhattan Beach Field Operations Supervisor $ 11,329 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50% 4 City of Beverly Hills1 [Parks Services Supervisor/ Parks Superintendent] $ 11,039 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 5 City of Culver City2 [Park Maintenance Supervisor/ Parks Manager] $ 10,376 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 6 City of Thousand Oaks Landscape Maintenance Supervisor $ 10,060 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00% 7 City of Laguna Beach Maintenance Supervisor $ 9,936 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00% 8 City of Malibu Parks Supervisor $ 9,544 7/1/2023 unknown unknown9 City of Camarillo Landscape Inspector $ 9,529 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 10 City of Agoura Hills N/C11 City of Redondo Beach N/C Top Monthly
$ 10,791
‐13.1%
$ 10,708
‐12.2%
$ 11,475
‐20.2%
8 Parks SupervisorSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowMedian of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Span of Responsibility Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties are bridged by a higher and lower-level classification at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is an average of the matches. 2 - City of Culver City: Span of Responsibility Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties are bridged by a higher and lower-level classification at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is an average of the matches.

Page 34 of 48 ends

89 City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of West Hollywood Permit Services Specialist $ 8,039 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Thousand Oaks Community Development Technician II $ 7,965 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 4.00%3 City of Manhattan Beach Permits Technician $ 6,998 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50%4 City of Beverly Hills Development Services Technician II $ 6,986 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 5 City of Calabasas Building Assistant $ 6,893 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 6 City of Malibu Permit Services Technician $ 6,770 7/1/2023 unknown unknown7 City of Agoura Hills Building Permit Technician $ 6,542 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 8 City of Redondo Beach Building and Engineering Technician $ 6,520 1/14/2023 unknown unknown9 City of Culver City Permit Technician II $ 6,429 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 10 City of Laguna Beach Permit Technician $ 6,421 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00%11 City of Camarillo N/C Top Monthly
$ 6,977
‐3.1%
$ 6,893
‐1.8%
$ 6,998
‐3.4%
9 Permit Services TechnicianSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non ComparatorMedian of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 35 of 48 ends

90 City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of Beverly Hills City Planner $ 21,965 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50%2 City of Malibu Planning Director $ 17,537 7/1/2023 unknown unknown3 City of Agoura Hills N/C4 City of Calabasas N/C5 City of Camarillo N/C6 City of Culver City N/C7 City of Laguna Beach N/C 8 City of Manhattan Beach N/C9 City of Redondo Beach N/C 10 City of Thousand Oaks N/C11 City of West Hollywood N/C Top Monthly
Insuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. Data 1 Planning DirectorSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non ComparatorMedian of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 36 of 48 ends

91 City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of Camarillo Planning Technician $ 7,840 7/1/2023 unknown unknown2 City of Malibu Planning Technician $ 7,839 7/1/2023 unknown unknown3 City of Culver City Planning Technician II $ 7,502 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 4 City of Beverly Hills Planning Technician $ 7,343 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 5 City of Laguna Beach Planning Technician $ 6,916 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00%6 City of Agoura Hills Planning Technician $ 6,542 7/1/2023 unknown unknown7 City of Redondo Beach Planning Technician $ 6,191 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 8 City of Calabasas N/C9 City of Manhattan Beach N/C
10 City of Thousand Oaks N/C11 City of West Hollywood N/C Top Monthly
$ 7,055

10.0%
$ 7,129

9.0%
$ 7,462

4.8%
6 Planning TechnicianSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non ComparatorMedian of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 37 of 48 ends

92 City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of West Hollywood1 [Public Safety Manager/ Specialist] $ 14,056 7/1/2023 unknown unknown2 City of Malibu Public Safety Coordinator $ 9,678 7/1/2023 unknown unknown3 City of Agoura Hills N/C4 City of Beverly Hills N/C 5 City of Calabasas N/C6 City of Camarillo N/C7 City of Culver City N/C8 City of Laguna Beach N/C9 City of Manhattan Beach N/C 10 City of Redondo Beach N/C11 City of Thousand Oaks N/C Top Monthly
Insuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. Data 1 Public Safety CoordinatorSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non Comparator1 - City of West Hollywood: Span of Responsibility Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties are bridged by a higher and lower-level classification at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is an average of the matches.Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 38 of 48 ends

93 City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of West Hollywood Director of Community Safety $ 22,623 7/1/2023 unknown unknown2 City of Malibu Public Safety Director $ 17,537 7/1/2023 unknown unknown3 City of Agoura Hills N/C4 City of Beverly Hills N/C 5 City of Calabasas N/C6 City of Camarillo N/C7 City of Culver City N/C8 City of Laguna Beach N/C9 City of Manhattan Beach N/C 10 City of Redondo Beach N/C11 City of Thousand Oaks N/C Top Monthly
Insuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. Data 1 Public Safety DirectorSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non ComparatorMedian of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 39 of 48 ends

94 City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of West Hollywood Director of Public Works $ 23,802 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Beverly Hills Assistant Director of Public Works/City Engineer $ 21,965 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50%3 City of Camarillo Director of Public Works $ 21,841 7/1/2023 unknown unknown4 City of Thousand Oaks Deputy Public Works Director/City Engineer $ 20,595 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00% 5 City of Laguna Beach Director of Public Works $ 20,494 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 6 City of Calabasas Public Works Director/City Engineer $ 19,791 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 7 City of Malibu Public Works Director/City Engineer $ 18,863 7/1/2023 unknown unknown8 City of Manhattan Beach Public Works Director $ 18,778 1/14/2023 unknown unknown9 City of Agoura Hills Director of Public Works/City Engineer $ 17,566 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 10 City of Redondo Beach Public Works Director $ 17,291 1/13/2024 unknown unknown 11 City of Culver City N/C
Top Monthly
$ 20,236
‐7.3%
$ 20,494
‐8.6%
$ 21,841
‐15.8%
9 Public Works Director/City EngineerSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non ComparatorMedian of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 40 of 48 ends

95 City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of West Hollywood Public Works Inspector $ 10,951 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Calabasas Senior Public Works Inspector $ 8,839 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 3 City of Thousand Oaks Construction Inspector II $ 8,800 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 4.00%4 City of Beverly Hills Public Works Inspector I$ 8,440 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50%5 City of Manhattan Beach Public Works Inspector $ 8,043 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50% 6 City of Malibu Public Works Inspector $ 8,034 7/1/2023 unknown unknown7 City of Culver City Public Works Inspector $ 7,539 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00%8 City of Redondo Beach Public Works Inspector $ 6,714 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 9 City of Agoura Hills N/C
10 City of Camarillo N/C11 City of Laguna Beach N/C
Top Monthly
$ 8,475
‐5.5%
$ 8,440
‐5.1%
$ 8,820
‐9.8%
7 Public Works InspectorSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non ComparatorMedian of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 41 of 48 ends

96 City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of Thousand Oaks Public Works Superintendent $ 15,434 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 4.00% 2 City of Manhattan Beach Maintenance Manager $ 14,576 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50%3 City of Camarillo Maintenance Superintendent $ 14,079 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 4 City of Malibu Public Works Superintendent $ 13,354 7/1/2023 unknown unknown5 City of Culver City Maintenance Operations Manager $ 13,305 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00%6 City of West Hollywood Facilities and Landscape Superintendent $ 13,126 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 7 City of Calabasas Public Works Superintendent $ 11,914 7/14/2023 unknown unknown8 City of Beverly Hills1 [Public Works Manager/ Maintenance Superintendent] $ 11,894 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 9 City of Redondo Beach2 [Public Works Superintendent/ Public Works Manager] $ 9,182 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 10 City of Agoura Hills N/C11 City of Laguna Beach N/C
Top Monthly
$ 12,939

3.1%
$ 13,215

1.0%
$ 14,203
‐6.4%
8 Public Works SuperintendentSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowMedian of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Span of Responsibility Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties are bridged by a higher and lower-level classification at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is an average of the matches. 2 - City of Redondo Beach: Functional Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties of the class are performed by more than one class at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is the higher of the matches.

Page 42 of 48 ends

97 City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of West Hollywood Recreation Services Manager $ 19,005 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Culver City Recreation and Community Services Manager $ 13,108 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 3 City of Beverly Hills Recreation Services Manager $ 13,073 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 4 City of Manhattan Beach Recreation Manager $ 12,283 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50%5 City of Calabasas Recreation Manager $ 11,914 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 6 City of Malibu Recreation Manager $ 11,130 7/1/2023 unknown unknown7 City of Agoura Hills Recreation Manager $ 10,988 7/1/2023 unknown unknown8 City of Redondo Beach Recreation, Youth, Senior and Family Services Manager $ 9,182 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 9 City of Camarillo N/C
10 City of Laguna Beach N/C
11 City of Thousand Oaks N/C
Top Monthly
$ 12,793
‐14.9%
$ 12,283
‐10.4%
$ 13,090
‐17.6%
7 Recreation ManagerSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non ComparatorMedian of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 43 of 48 ends

98 City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of West Hollywood Recreation Supervisor $ 12,141 7/1/2023 unknown unknown2 City of Malibu Recreation Supervisor $ 9,678 7/1/2023 unknown unknown3 City of Laguna Beach Recreation Supervisor $ 9,039 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00%4 City of Culver City Recreation and Community Services Supervisor $ 8,886 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00%5 City of Calabasas Recreation Supervisor $ 8,839 7/14/2023 unknown unknown6 City of Agoura Hills Recreation Supervisor $ 8,798 7/1/2023 unknown unknown7 City of Beverly Hills Recreation Supervisor $ 8,465 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50%8 City of Manhattan Beach Recreation Supervisor $ 7,848 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50%9 City of Redondo Beach Recreation Supervisor $ 7,430 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 10 City of Camarillo N/C11 City of Thousand Oaks N/C
Top Monthly
$ 8,931

7.7%
$ 8,819

8.9%
$ 8,924

7.8%
8 Recreation SupervisorSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non ComparatorMedian of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 44 of 48 ends

99 City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of Laguna Beach Maintenance Lead Worker $ 8,217 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00% 2 City of West Hollywood Senior Maintenance Technician $ 8,039 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 3 City of Malibu Senior Maintenance Worker $ 7,968 7/1/2023 unknown unknown4 City of Thousand Oaks Senior Building Maintenance Technician $ 7,576 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 4.00%5 City of Beverly Hills1 [Facilities Maintenance Mechanic/ Street Maintenance Technician] $ 7,198 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 6 City of Culver City2 [Facilities Maintenance Crew Leader/ Park Maintenance Crew Leader] $ 7,137 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00%7 City of Camarillo Public Works Maintenance Worker III $ 7,111 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 8 City of Manhattan Beach Lead Maintenance Worker $ 7,104 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50% 9 City of Redondo Beach Parks Maintenance Leadworker $ 6,147 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 10 City of Calabasas Maintenance Technician II $ 6,056 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 11 City of Agoura Hills N/C
Top Monthly
$ 7,176

9.9%
$ 7,137

10.4%
$ 7,576

4.9%
9 Senior Maintenance WorkerSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowMedian of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Functional Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties of the class are performed by more than one class at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is the higher of the matches. 2 - City of Culver City: Functional Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties of the class are performed by more than one class at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is the higher of the matches.

Page 45 of 48 ends

100
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of Agoura Hills Administrative Aide $ 6,542 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Beverly Hills Office Assistant II $ 6,215 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 3 City of Malibu Senior Office Assistant $ 5,996 7/1/2023 unknown unknown4 City of Laguna Beach Senior Office Specialist $ 5,996 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00% 5 City of Manhattan Beach Office Assistant $ 5,196 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50% 6 City of Culver City Administrative Clerk $ 5,118 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 7 City of Redondo Beach Office Specialist III $ 4,612 1/14/2023 unknown unknown8 City of Calabasas N/C9 City of Camarillo N/C 10 City of Thousand Oaks N/C11 City of West Hollywood N/C Top Monthly
$ 5,613

6.4%
$ 5,596

6.7%
$ 6,160
‐2.7%
6 Senior Office AssistantSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non ComparatorMedian of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 46 of 48 ends

101
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of Beverly Hills Permit Center Supervisor $ 9,166 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 2 City of Laguna Beach Permit Supervisor $ 9,039 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00% 3 City of Malibu Supervising Permit Services Technician $ 8,416 7/1/2023 unknown unknown4 City of Calabasas Permit Center Supervisor $ 7,614 7/14/2023 unknown unknown5 City of Agoura Hills N/C6 City of Camarillo N/C7 City of Culver City N/C8 City of Manhattan Beach N/C9 City of Redondo Beach N/C 10 City of Thousand Oaks N/C11 City of West Hollywood N/C Top Monthly
Insuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. Data 3 Supervising Permit Services TechnicianSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non ComparatorMedian of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 47 of 48 ends

102
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Data (Base Salary)
March 2024
Appendix II(a)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Max Salary
Salary
Effective
Date
Next Salary
Increase
Next
Percentage
Increase
1 City of Malibu Wastewater Management Program Specialist $ 8,189 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Culver City Associate Analyst $ 7,502 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00%3 City of Agoura Hills N/C4 City of Beverly Hills N/C 5 City of Calabasas N/C6 City of Camarillo N/C7 City of Laguna Beach N/C8 City of Manhattan Beach N/C9 City of Redondo Beach N/C 10 City of Thousand Oaks N/C11 City of West Hollywood N/C Top Monthly
Insuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. DataInsuff. Data 1 Wastewater Management Program SpecialistSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/BelowNumber of MatchesN/C - Non ComparatorMedian of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 48 of 48 ends

103
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of Camarillo Finance Assistant $ 9,075 $ 5,405 $ 14,480 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of West Hollywood Accounting Technician $ 8,040 $ 4,739 $ 12,779 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 3 City of Agoura Hills Accounting Specialist II $ 7,971 $ 4,487 $ 12,458 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 4 City of Malibu Accounting Technician $ 7,465 $ 4,520 $ 11,985 7/1/2023 unknown unknown5 City of Laguna Beach Accounting Technician $ 8,011 $ 3,752 $ 11,763 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00% 6 City of Calabasas Accounting Specialist $ 6,893 $ 4,697 $ 11,589 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 7 City of Manhattan Beach Revenue Services Specialist $ 7,298 $ 3,251 $ 10,548 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50% 8 City of Beverly Hills Accounting Technician $ 6,452 $ 3,755 $ 10,206 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 9 City of Thousand Oaks Accounting Specialist $ 7,030 $ 3,064 $ 10,094 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 4.00% 10 City of Culver City Senior Account Clerk $ 5,647 $ 2,895 $ 8,542 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 11 City of Redondo Beach Accounting Technician $ 5,339 $ 3,016 $ 8,355 11/4/2023 unknown unknown Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 7,176 $ 11,082

3.9% 7.5%
$ 7,164 $ 11,069

4.0% 7.6%
$ 8,001 $ 12,284
‐7.2% ‐2.5%
Number of Matches 10 10
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowAccounting TechnicianSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 1 of 48 ends

104
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of Camarillo Administrative Specialist II $ 7,466 $ 4,944 $ 12,410 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of West Hollywood Administrative Specialist II $ 6,932 $ 4,512 $ 11,444 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 3 City of Agoura Hills Administrative Assistant II $ 7,042 $ 4,322 $ 11,364 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 4 City of Malibu Administrative Assistant $ 6,892 $ 4,394 $ 11,286 7/1/2023 unknown unknown5 City of Calabasas Executive Assistant I$ 6,558 $ 4,618 $ 11,177 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 6 City of Laguna Beach Administrative Assistant $ 7,307 $ 3,627 $ 10,934 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00%7 City of Beverly Hills Administrative Assistant $ 6,849 $ 3,877 $ 10,726 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 8 City of Thousand Oaks Administrative Secretary $ 6,688 $ 3,009 $ 9,697 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 4.00% 9 City of Manhattan Beach Administrative Assistant $ 6,372 $ 3,122 $ 9,494 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50% 10 City of Culver City Secretary $ 5,591 $ 2,886 $ 8,477 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 11 City of Redondo Beach Administrative Specialist $ 4,964 $ 2,945 $ 7,909 1/14/2023 unknown unknown Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 6,577 $ 10,363

4.6% 8.2%
$ 6,768 $ 10,830

1.8% 4.0%
$ 7,015 $ 11,317
‐1.8% ‐0.3%
Number of Matches 10 10
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowAdministrative AssistantSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 2 of 48 ends

105
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of West Hollywood Assistant City Manager $ 26,753 $ 11,139 $ 37,892 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Thousand Oaks Assistant City Manager $ 26,150 $ 9,698 $ 35,848 7/8/2023 unknown unknown 3 City of Camarillo Assistant City Manager $ 24,079 $ 11,418 $ 35,497 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 4 City of Laguna Beach Assistant City Manager $ 22,543 $ 8,003 $ 30,546 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 5 City of Redondo Beach Assistant City Manager $ 23,011 $ 7,377 $ 30,388 1/13/2024 unknown unknown 6 City of Culver City Assistant City Manager $ 21,573 $ 6,872 $ 28,445 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 7 City of Malibu Assistant City Manager $ 19,802 $ 7,894 $ 27,696 7/1/2023 unknown unknown8 City of Agoura Hills Assistant City Manager $ 19,389 $ 7,875 $ 27,264 7/1/2023 unknown unknown9 City of Beverly Hills N/C 10 City of Calabasas N/C11 City of Manhattan Beach N/C
Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 23,357 $ 32,269
‐18.0% ‐16.5%
$ 23,011 $ 30,546
‐16.2% ‐10.3%
$ 25,115 $ 35,673
‐26.8% ‐28.8%
Number of Matches 77
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowAssistant City ManagerSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 3 of 48 ends

106
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of West Hollywood Assistant Director of Community Development $ 21,285 $ 9,546 $ 30,831 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Beverly Hills Assistant Director of Community Development/Building Official $ 21,965 $ 7,968 $ 29,933 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 3 City of Camarillo Assistant Director of Community Development $ 17,968 $ 8,568 $ 26,536 7/1/2023 unknown unknown4 City of Thousand Oaks Deputy Community Development Director $ 18,460 $ 6,635 $ 25,095 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00%5 City of Laguna Beach Assistant Director of Community Development $ 16,114 $ 6,180 $ 22,294 7/1/2023 unknown unknown6 City of Agoura Hills Planning Director $ 15,147 $ 6,831 $ 21,978 7/1/2023 unknown unknown7 City of Calabasas City Planner $ 13,695 $ 6,535 $ 20,230 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 8 City of Malibu Assistant Community Development Director proposed9 City of Culver City N/C 10 City of Manhattan Beach N/C
11 City of Redondo Beach N/C
Top
Monthly
Total
Monthly
$ 17,805 $ 25,271$ 17,968 $ 25,095$ 19,873 $ 28,235

N/A N/A
Number of Matches 77
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowAssistant Community Development DirectorSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 4 of 48 ends

107
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of Camarillo Planning Manager $ 14,783 $ 7,582 $ 22,364 7/1/2023 unknown unknown2 City of Malibu Assistant Planning Director $ 15,150 $ 6,410 $ 21,560 7/1/2023 unknown unknown3 City of Thousand Oaks Planning Division Manager $ 15,279 $ 5,800 $ 21,079 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00% 4 City of Laguna Beach Planning Manager $ 14,792 $ 5,887 $ 20,679 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 5 City of Culver City2 [Current Planning Manager/ Advance Planning Manager] $ 15,146 $ 5,286 $ 20,432 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 6 City of Beverly Hills1 [Urban Designer/ Principal Planner] $ 12,689 $ 5,457 $ 18,145 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 7 City of Redondo Beach Planning Manager $ 10,141 $ 4,708 $ 14,849 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 8 City of Agoura Hills N/C
9 City of Calabasas N/C
10 City of Manhattan Beach N/C11 City of West Hollywood N/C Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 13,805 $ 19,591

8.9% 9.1%
$ 14,787 $ 20,556

2.4% 4.7%
$ 15,058 $ 20,979

0.6% 2.7%
Number of Matches 66
N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Functional Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties of the class are performed by more than one class at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is the same for both matches. 2 - City of Culver City: Functional Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties of the class are performed by more than one class at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is the higher of the matches.

Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowAssistant Planning DirectorSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 5 of 48 ends

108
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of Camarillo Associate Engineer $ 12,162 $ 6,477 $ 18,638 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Thousand Oaks Associate Engineer $ 13,217 $ 4,797 $ 18,014 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00% 3 City of West Hollywood Assistant Engineer $ 12,141 $ 5,580 $ 17,721 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 4 City of Malibu Associate Engineer $ 11,869 $ 5,490 $ 17,359 7/1/2023 unknown unknown5 City of Laguna Beach Associate Civil Engineer $ 12,432 $ 4,541 $ 16,973 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00% 6 City of Agoura Hills Associate Civil Engineer $ 10,988 $ 5,235 $ 16,223 7/1/2023 unknown unknown7 City of Calabasas Associate Civil Engineer $ 10,262 $ 5,483 $ 15,745 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 8 City of Manhattan Beach Associate Engineer $ 11,040 $ 3,770 $ 14,810 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50%9 City of Redondo Beach Associate Civil Engineer $ 9,434 $ 4,519 $ 13,953 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 10 City of Culver City Associate Engineer $ 9,911 $ 3,560 $ 13,471 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 11 City of Beverly Hills N/C
Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 11,287 $ 16,172

4.9% 6.8%
$ 11,040 $ 16,223

7.0% 6.5%
$ 12,162 $ 17,721
‐2.5% ‐2.1%
Number of Matches 99
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowAssociate EngineerSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 6 of 48 ends

109
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of West Hollywood Associate Planner $ 12,141 $ 5,860 $ 18,001 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Camarillo Associate Planner $ 10,506 $ 5,815 $ 16,321 7/1/2023 unknown unknown3 City of Thousand Oaks Associate Planner $ 11,494 $ 4,405 $ 15,899 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00%4 City of Calabasas Associate Planner $ 9,764 $ 5,367 $ 15,131 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 5 City of Agoura Hills Associate Planner $ 9,954 $ 4,840 $ 14,794 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 6 City of Malibu Associate Planner $ 9,743 $ 5,022 $ 14,764 7/1/2023 unknown unknown7 City of Beverly Hills Associate Planner $ 9,508 $ 4,741 $ 14,249 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50%8 City of Laguna Beach Associate Planner $ 9,936 $ 4,096 $ 14,032 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00% 9 City of Manhattan Beach Associate Planner $ 9,892 $ 3,611 $ 13,503 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50% 10 City of Redondo Beach Associate Planner $ 8,567 $ 4,288 $ 12,855 1/14/2023 unknown unknown11 City of Culver City Associate Planner $ 8,887 $ 3,400 $ 12,287 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 10,065 $ 14,707
‐3.3% 0.4%
$ 9,914 $ 14,521
‐1.8% 1.6%
$ 10,368 $ 15,707
‐6.4% ‐6.4%
Number of Matches 10 10
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowAssociate PlannerSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 7 of 48 ends

110
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of West Hollywood Senior Combination Building Inspector $ 11,157 $ 5,378 $ 16,535 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Beverly Hills Building Inspector II $ 9,323 $ 4,291 $ 13,614 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 3 City of Laguna Beach Building Inspector $ 9,039 $ 3,936 $ 12,975 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00% 4 City of Malibu Building Inspector $ 8,230 $ 4,688 $ 12,919 7/1/2023 unknown unknown5 City of Calabasas Building Inspector $ 7,614 $ 4,865 $ 12,479 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 6 City of Thousand Oaks Combination Building Inspector II $ 8,889 $ 3,361 $ 12,250 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 4.00% 7 City of Manhattan Beach Building Inspector $ 8,278 $ 3,387 $ 11,665 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50%8 City of Culver City Building Safety Inspector $ 7,502 $ 3,184 $ 10,686 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 9 City of Redondo Beach Building Inspector $ 6,943 $ 3,322 $ 10,265 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 10 City of Agoura Hills N/C11 City of Camarillo N/C
Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 8,593 $ 12,559
‐4.4% 2.8%
$ 8,584 $ 12,364
‐4.3% 4.3%
$ 9,110 $ 13,134
‐10.7% ‐1.7%
Number of Matches 88
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowBuilding InspectorSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 8 of 48 ends

111
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of Malibu Building Official (Deputy Director Level) proposed 2 City of West Hollywood Building and Safety Manager/Building Official $ 19,005 $ 8,302 $ 27,307 7/1/2023 unknown unknown3 City of Beverly Hills Deputy Building Official $ 15,952 $ 6,192 $ 22,143 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 4 City of Agoura Hills Building Official $ 14,417 $ 6,651 $ 21,068 7/1/2023 unknown unknown5 City of Culver City Building Official $ 15,606 $ 5,350 $ 20,956 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00%6 City of Manhattan Beach Building Official $ 15,013 $ 5,771 $ 20,784 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50%7 City of Thousand Oaks Building Official/Building Division Manager $ 14,111 $ 5,493 $ 19,604 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00% 8 City of Redondo Beach Chief Building Official $ 13,709 $ 5,311 $ 19,020 1/13/2024 unknown unknown 9 City of Calabasas Building Official $ 12,522 $ 6,361 $ 18,883 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 10 City of Laguna Beach Building Official $ 13,017 $ 5,495 $ 18,512 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 11 City of Camarillo N/C
Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 14,817 $ 20,920
$ 14,417 $ 20,784
$ 15,606 $ 21,068

N/A N/A
Number of Matches 99
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowBuilding Official (Deputy Director Level)Summary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 9 of 48 ends

112
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classificat ion Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of West Hollywood City Clerk $ 19,005 $ 8,302 $ 27,307 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Manhattan Beach City Clerk $ 18,778 $ 7,065 $ 25,843 1/14/2023 unknown unknown3 City of Beverly Hills City Clerk $ 18,333 $ 6,690 $ 25,023 4/1/2023 7/1/2024 3.00% 4 City of Camarillo City Clerk $ 16,298 $ 8,715 $ 25,013 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 5 City of Thousand Oaks City Clerk $ 17,047 $ 7,127 $ 24,174 7/8/2023 unknown unknown6 City of Culver City1 City Clerk $ 15,920 $ 5,394 $ 21,314 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 7 City of Laguna Beach City Clerk $ 14,792 $ 5,887 $ 20,679 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 8 City of Malibu City Clerk $ 13,741 $ 6,401 $ 20,142 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 9 City of Calabasas City Clerk $ 13,695 $ 6,285 $ 19,980 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 10 City of Agoura Hills City Clerk $ 12,432 $ 6,162 $ 18,594 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 11 City of Redondo Beach City Clerk $ 10,875 $ 4,627 $ 15,502 1/14/2023 4/1/2024 2.00% Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 15,718 $ 22,343
‐14.4% ‐10.9%
$ 16,109 $ 22,744
‐17.2% ‐12.9%
$ 18,012 $ 25,021
‐31.1% ‐24.2%
Number of Matches 10 10
N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Culver City: This is an elected position.

Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowCity ClerkSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 10 of 48 ends

113
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of West Hollywood1 [Neighborhood and Business Safety Manager/Code Enforcement Supervisor] $ 15,573 $ 7,361 $ 22,934 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Camarillo Code Compliance Manager $ 12,770 $ 6,758 $ 19,528 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 3 City of Malibu Code Enforcement Manager $ 13,087 $ 5,929 $ 19,015 7/1/2023 unknown unknown4 City of Thousand Oaks Code Compliance Manager $ 12,775 $ 5,142 $ 17,917 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00% 5 City of Culver City Enforcement Services Manager $ 12,163 $ 4,751 $ 16,915 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 6 City of Beverly Hills Code Enforcement Manager $ 10,714 $ 5,012 $ 15,726 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 7 City of Manhattan Beach Code Enforcement Supervisor $ 10,299 $ 4,650 $ 14,949 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50%8 City of Laguna Beach Code Enforcement Supervisor $ 9,936 $ 4,096 $ 14,032 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00% 9 City of Agoura Hills N/C
10 City of Calabasas N/C11 City of Redondo Beach N/C
Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 12,033 $ 17,429

8.1% 8.3%
$ 12,163 $ 16,915

7.1% 11.0%
$ 12,772 $ 18,723

2.4% 1.5%
Number of Matches 77
N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of West Hollywood: Span of Responsibility Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties are bridged by a higher and lower-level classification at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is an average of the matches.Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowCode Enforcement ManagerSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 11 of 48 ends

114
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of West Hollywood Code Enforcement Officer $ 9,803 $ 5,101 $ 14,904 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Camarillo Code Compliance Officer $ 8,643 $ 5,281 $ 13,924 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 3 City of Malibu Code Enforcement Officer $ 8,230 $ 4,688 $ 12,919 7/1/2023 unknown unknown4 City of Agoura Hills Code Compliance Officer $ 7,971 $ 4,487 $ 12,458 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 5 City of Calabasas Code Enforcement Officer $ 7,538 $ 4,847 $ 12,386 7/14/2023 unknown unknown6 City of Beverly Hills Code Enforcement Officer $ 8,274 $ 4,095 $ 12,369 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50%7 City of Laguna Beach Code Enforcement Officer $ 8,011 $ 3,752 $ 11,763 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00%8 City of Thousand Oaks Code Compliance Officer II $ 8,455 $ 3,292 $ 11,747 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 4.00%9 City of Manhattan Beach Code Enforcement Officer II $ 8,230 $ 3,380 $ 11,610 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50% 10 City of Culver City Code Enforcement Officer $ 6,995 $ 3,105 $ 10,101 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 11 City of Redondo Beach Code Enforcement Officer $ 6,520 $ 3,241 $ 9,761 1/14/2023 unknown unknown Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 8,044 $ 12,102

2.3% 6.3%
$ 8,120 $ 12,066

1.3% 6.6%
$ 8,410 $ 12,440
‐2.2% 3.7%
Number of Matches 10 10
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowCode Enforcement OfficerSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 12 of 48 ends

115
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of Malibu Community Development Director proposed 2 City of Beverly Hills Director of Community Development $ 26,699 $ 9,125 $ 35,824 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 3 City of West Hollywood Director of Community Development $ 23,802 $ 10,279 $ 34,081 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 4 City of Camarillo Director of Community Development $ 20,801 $ 10,279 $ 31,079 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 5 City of Thousand Oaks Community Development Director $ 21,646 $ 8,426 $ 30,072 7/8/2023 unknown unknown 6 City of Laguna Beach Director of Community Development $ 20,494 $ 7,549 $ 28,043 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 7 City of Calabasas Community Development Director $ 19,791 $ 7,958 $ 27,748 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 8 City of Manhattan Beach Community Development Director $ 18,778 $ 7,065 $ 25,843 1/14/2023 unknown unknown9 City of Redondo Beach Community Development Director $ 19,021 $ 6,661 $ 25,682 1/13/2024 unknown unknown 10 City of Agoura Hills Community Development Director $ 17,566 $ 7,426 $ 24,992 7/1/2023 unknown unknown11 City of Culver City Planning & Development Director $ 18,101 $ 6,336 $ 24,437 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 20,670 $ 28,780$ 20,142 $ 27,896
$ 21,435 $ 30,828

N/A N/A
Number of Matches 10 10
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowCommunity Development DirectorSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 13 of 48 ends

116
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of West Hollywood Director of Community Services $ 22,623 $ 9,936 $ 32,559 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Beverly Hills Assistant Director of Community Services $ 21,965 $ 7,968 $ 29,933 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 3 City of Manhattan Beach Parks and Recreation Director $ 18,778 $ 7,065 $ 25,843 1/14/2023 unknown unknown4 City of Agoura Hills Director Community Services $ 17,566 $ 7,426 $ 24,992 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 5 City of Malibu Community Services Director $ 17,537 $ 6,967 $ 24,504 7/1/2023 unknown unknown6 City of Calabasas Community Services Director $ 16,878 $ 7,278 $ 24,155 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 7 City of Redondo Beach Community Services Director $ 17,291 $ 6,351 $ 23,642 1/13/2024 unknown unknown 8 City of Culver City Parks, Recreation & Community Services Director $ 17,408 $ 6,229 $ 23,636 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00%9 City of Camarillo N/C 10 City of Laguna Beach N/C11 City of Thousand Oaks N/C Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 18,930 $ 26,394
‐7.9% ‐7.7%
$ 17,566 $ 24,992
‐0.2% ‐2.0%
$ 20,372 $ 27,888
‐16.2% ‐13.8%
Number of Matches 77
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowCommunity Services DirectorSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 14 of 48 ends

117
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of Malibu Financial Controller $ 14,780 $ 6,324 $ 21,104 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Camarillo Assistant Director of Finance $ 17,968 $ 8,568 $ 26,536 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 3 City of West Hollywood4 [Accounting Manager/ Revenue Manager] $ 19,005 $ 7,425 $ 26,430 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 4 City of Thousand Oaks Deputy Finance Director $ 18,460 $ 6,635 $ 25,095 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00% 5 City of Calabasas2 [Accounting Supervisor/ Chief Financial Officer] $ 15,852 $ 7,038 $ 22,891 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 6 City of Laguna Beach Finance Manager $ 16,114 $ 6,180 $ 22,294 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 7 City of Redondo Beach3 [Finance Director/ Payroll & Finance Manager] $ 15,545 $ 6,037 $ 21,582 1/13/2024 unknown unknown 8 City of Culver City Assistant Chief Financial Officer $ 15,920 $ 5,394 $ 21,314 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 9 City of Agoura Hills1 [Finance Manager/ Director of Finance] $ 14,555 $ 6,685 $ 21,240 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 11 City of Manhattan Beach Financial Controller $ 14,577 $ 5,667 $ 20,244 1/14/2023 unknown unknown City of Beverly Hills Assistant Director of Finance $ 21,965 $ 7,968 $ 29,933 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 16,996 $ 23,756
‐15.0% ‐12.6%
$ 16,017 $ 22,592
‐8.4% ‐7.1%
$ 18,337 $ 26,096
‐24.1% ‐23.7%
10 10
3 - City of Redondo Beach: Span of Responsibility Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties are bridged by a higher and lower-level classification at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is an average of the matches. 4 - City of West Hollywood: Functional Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties of the class are performed by more than one class at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is the higher of the matches.

Number of Matches
N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Agoura Hills: Span of Responsibility: This hybrid match represents that the duties are bridged by a higher and lower-level classification at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is an average of the matches. 2 - City of Calabasas: Span of Responsibility Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties are bridged by a higher and lower-level classification at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is an average of the matches.

Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowFinancial ControllerSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 15 of 48 ends

118
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of Thousand Oaks Deputy City Clerk $ 11,565 $ 4,825 $ 16,390 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00% 2 City of Camarillo Deputy City Clerk $ 10,005 $ 6,001 $ 16,006 7/1/2023 unknown unknown3 City of Beverly Hills City Clerk Specialist $ 9,064 $ 4,320 $ 13,383 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 4 City of Redondo Beach Chief Deputy City Clerk $ 8,965 $ 4,394 $ 13,359 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 5 City of Malibu Deputy City Clerk $ 8,230 $ 4,688 $ 12,919 7/1/2023 unknown unknown6 City of West Hollywood Deputy Clerk $ 8,040 $ 4,739 $ 12,779 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 7 City of Calabasas Assistant to the City Clerk $ 7,614 $ 4,865 $ 12,479 7/14/2023 unknown unknown8 City of Manhattan Beach Deputy City Clerk $ 7,469 $ 3,977 $ 11,446 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 9 City of Laguna Beach Deputy City Clerk $ 7,307 $ 3,627 $ 10,934 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00% 10 City of Culver City City Clerk Specialist $ 7,137 $ 3,127 $ 10,265 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 11 City of Agoura Hills N/C
Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 8,574 $ 13,005
‐4.2% ‐0.7%
$ 8,040 $ 12,779

2.3% 1.1%
$ 9,064 $ 13,383
‐10.1% ‐3.6%
Number of Matches 99
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowDeputy City ClerkSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 16 of 48 ends

119
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of West Hollywood Emergency Management Coordinator $ 12,141 $ 5,860 $ 18,001 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Manhattan Beach Emergency Preparedness Administrator $ 11,925 $ 5,036 $ 16,961 1/14/2023 1/11/2025 1.50%3 City of Beverly Hills Emergency Management Manager $ 11,602 $ 5,212 $ 16,814 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 4 City of Laguna Beach Emergency Operations Coordinator $ 11,767 $ 4,422 $ 16,189 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00% 5 City of Culver City Emergency Preparedness Coordinator $ 10,369 $ 4,389 $ 14,758 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 6 City of Malibu Emergency Services Coordinator $ 9,345 $ 4,934 $ 14,279 7/1/2023 unknown unknown7 City of Calabasas Public Safety Coordinator $ 8,839 $ 5,151 $ 13,990 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 8 City of Agoura Hills N/C9 City of Camarillo N/C
10 City of Redondo Beach N/C11 City of Thousand Oaks N/C Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 11,107 $ 16,119
‐18.9% ‐12.9%
$ 11,684 $ 16,501
‐25.0% ‐15.6%
$ 11,886 $ 16,925
‐27.2% ‐18.5%
Number of Matches 66
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowEmergency Services CoordinatorSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 17 of 48 ends

120
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of West Hollywood Environmental Programs Coordinator $ 12,141 $ 5,860 $ 18,001 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Calabasas Environmental Services Supervisor $ 11,914 $ 5,869 $ 17,783 7/14/2023 unknown unknown3 City of Manhattan Beach Water Compliance Supervisor $ 10,252 $ 4,639 $ 14,891 1/14/2023 1/11/2025 1.50% 4 City of Malibu Environmental Compliance Coordinator $ 9,765 $ 5,027 $ 14,792 7/1/2023 unknown unknown5 City of Culver City1 [Environmental Compliance Inspector/ Environmental Coordinator] $ 10,166 $ 4,348 $ 14,514 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 6 City of Laguna Beach Environmental Specialist $ 8,011 $ 3,752 $ 11,763 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00%7 City of Agoura Hills N/C8 City of Beverly Hills N/C 9 City of Camarillo N/C
10 City of Redondo Beach N/C11 City of Thousand Oaks N/C Top
Monthly
Total
Monthly
$ 10,497 $ 15,390
‐7.5% ‐4.0%
$ 10,252 $ 14,891
‐5.0% ‐0.7%
$ 11,914 $ 17,783
‐22.0% ‐20.2%
Number of Matches 55
N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Culver City: Functional Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties of the class are performed by more than one class at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is the higher of the matches.

Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowEnvironmental Compliance CoordinatorSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 18 of 48 ends

121
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of Malibu Environmental Health Administrator $ 11,869 $ 5,490 $ 17,359 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Thousand Oaks Environmental Programs Coordinator $ 11,323 $ 4,366 $ 15,689 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00% 3 City of Agoura Hills N/C4 City of Beverly Hills N/C
5 City of Calabasas N/C6 City of Camarillo N/C
7 City of Culver City N/C8 City of Laguna Beach N/C9 City of Manhattan Beach N/C 10 City of Redondo Beach N/C
11 City of West Hollywood N/C
Top Monthly Total Monthly
Insuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. Data Number of Matches 11
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowEnvironmental Health AdministratorSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 19 of 48 ends

122
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of Culver City Environmental Programs & Operations Manager $ 14,626 $ 5,213 $ 19,839 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00%2 City of Malibu Environmental Programs Manager $ 13,355 $ 5,991 $ 19,346 7/1/2023 unknown unknown3 City of Beverly Hills Environmental Compliance and Sustainability Programs Manager $ 13,469 $ 5,633 $ 19,102 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 4 City of Manhattan Beach Environmental Programs Administrator $ 12,283 $ 5,122 $ 17,404 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50%5 City of Agoura Hills N/C6 City of Calabasas N/C7 City of Camarillo N/C8 City of Laguna Beach N/C 9 City of Redondo Beach N/C
10 City of Thousand Oaks N/C
11 City of West Hollywood N/C
Top Monthly Total Monthly
Insuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. Data
Insuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. Data Number of Matches 33
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowEnvironmental Programs ManagerSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 20 of 48 ends

123
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of Malibu Environmental Sustainability Analyst $ 9,765 $ 5,027 $ 14,792 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Beverly Hills Management Analyst $ 9,047 $ 4,637 $ 13,684 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50%3 City of Culver City Management Analyst $ 9,065 $ 4,125 $ 13,190 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00%4 City of Agoura Hills N/C5 City of Calabasas N/C6 City of Camarillo N/C 7 City of Laguna Beach N/C8 City of Manhattan Beach N/C9 City of Redondo Beach N/C 10 City of Thousand Oaks N/C
11 City of West Hollywood N/C
Top Monthly Total Monthly
Insuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. Data Number of Matches 22
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowEnvironmental Sustainability AnalystSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 21 of 48 ends

124
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of Beverly Hills1 [Utilities General Manager/ Assistant Director of Community Development/Building Official] $ 21,965 $ 7,968 $ 29,933 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50%2 City of Malibu Environmental Sustainability Director/Building Official $ 18,863 $ 7,663 $ 26,527 7/1/2023 unknown unknown3 City of Agoura Hills N/C4 City of Calabasas N/C5 City of Camarillo N/C6 City of Culver City N/C 7 City of Laguna Beach N/C
8 City of Manhattan Beach N/C9 City of Redondo Beach N/C 10 City of Thousand Oaks N/C11 City of West Hollywood N/C Top Monthly Total Monthly
Insuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. Data Number of Matches 11
N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Functional Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties of the class are performed by more than one class at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is the same for both matches.

Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowEnvironmental Sustainability Director/Building OfficialSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 22 of 48 ends

125
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of Camarillo Executive Assistant $ 10,005 $ 5,672 $ 15,677 7/1/2023 unknown unknown2 City of Malibu Executive Assistant $ 9,968 $ 5,071 $ 15,039 7/1/2023 unknown unknown3 City of West Hollywood Senior Administrative Specialist $ 9,803 $ 5,101 $ 14,904 7/1/2023 unknown unknown4 City of Thousand Oaks Executive Assistant $ 9,107 $ 4,180 $ 13,287 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00% 5 City of Laguna Beach Executive Assistant $ 8,446 $ 4,483 $ 12,929 7/1/2023 unknown unknown6 City of Agoura Hills Executive Assistant $ 7,971 $ 4,640 $ 12,611 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 7 City of Manhattan Beach Executive Assistant to the City Manager $ 8,215 $ 4,155 $ 12,370 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 8 City of Redondo Beach Executive Assistant to Mayor and Council/City Manager $ 8,216 $ 3,984 $ 12,200 1/13/2024 unknown unknown 9 City of Beverly Hills Executive Assistant $ 7,938 $ 4,095 $ 12,033 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 10 City of Calabasas Executive Assistant II $ 6,893 $ 4,697 $ 11,589 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 11 City of Culver City Administrative Secretary $ 6,239 $ 2,987 $ 9,226 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 8,283 $ 12,683

16.9% 15.7%
$ 8,216 $ 12,490

17.6% 16.9%
$ 8,942 $ 13,197

10.3% 12.2%
Number of Matches 10 10
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowExecutive AssistantSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 23 of 48 ends

126
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of Camarillo1 [Accountant II/ Financial Analyst II] $ 11,334 $ 6,052 $ 17,386 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of West Hollywood Accountant $ 11,157 $ 5,636 $ 16,793 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 3 City of Beverly Hills Budget and Financial Analyst $ 11,373 $ 5,161 $ 16,534 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 4 City of Thousand Oaks Financial Analyst $ 11,211 $ 4,341 $ 15,552 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00% 5 City of Manhattan Beach Budget and Financial Analyst $ 10,299 $ 4,650 $ 14,949 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50% 6 City of Malibu Financial Analyst $ 9,765 $ 5,027 $ 14,792 7/1/2023 unknown unknown7 City of Laguna Beach Accountant $ 9,039 $ 3,936 $ 12,975 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00%8 City of Calabasas Senior Accounting Specialist $ 7,538 $ 4,847 $ 12,386 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 9 City of Redondo Beach2 [Accountant/ Administrative Analyst] $ 7,678 $ 4,050 $ 11,728 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 10 City of Culver City Accountant II $ 8,371 $ 3,320 $ 11,691 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 11 City of Agoura Hills N/C
Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 9,778 $ 14,444
‐0.1% 2.4%
$ 10,299 $ 14,949
‐5.5% ‐1.1%
$ 11,211 $ 16,534
‐14.8% ‐11.8%
Number of Matches 99
N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Camarillo: Span of Responsibility Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties are bridged by a higher and lower-level classification at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is an average of the matches. 2 - City of Redondo Beach: Functional Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties of the class are performed by more than one class at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is the higher of the matches.

Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowFinancial AnalystSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 24 of 48 ends

127
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of Malibu Fire Safety Liaison $ 9,677 $ 5,007 $ 14,685 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Agoura Hills N/C3 City of Beverly Hills N/C4 City of Calabasas N/C5 City of Camarillo N/C6 City of Culver City N/C7 City of Laguna Beach N/C 8 City of Manhattan Beach N/C9 City of Redondo Beach N/C 10 City of Thousand Oaks N/C11 City of West Hollywood N/C Top Monthly Total Monthly
Insuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. Data

N/A N/A
Number of Matches 00
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowFire Safety LiaisonSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 25 of 48 ends

128
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of West Hollywood Digital Media Specialist $ 9,105 $ 4,958 $ 14,063 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Manhattan Beach Digital Communications and Graphics Coordinator $ 8,915 $ 4,321 $ 13,236 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 3 City of Beverly Hills1 [Graphic Artist/ Senior Graphic Artist] $ 7,841 $ 4,014 $ 11,855 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 4 City of Malibu Graphic Artist $ 6,770 $ 4,367 $ 11,137 7/1/2023 unknown unknown5 City of Agoura Hills N/C6 City of Calabasas N/C7 City of Camarillo N/C8 City of Culver City N/C9 City of Laguna Beach N/C 10 City of Redondo Beach N/C
11 City of Thousand Oaks N/C
Top Monthly Total Monthly
Insuff. Data Insuff. Data
Insuff. Data Insuff. Data
Insuff. Data Insuff. Data
Insuff. Data Insuff. Data
Insuff. Data Insuff. Data

N/A N/A
Number of Matches 33
N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Span of Responsibility Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties are bridged by a higher and lower-level classification at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is an average of the matches.

Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowGraphic ArtistSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 26 of 48 ends

129
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of Camarillo Human Resources Analyst $ 11,031 $ 6,135 $ 17,166 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of West Hollywood Human Resources Specialist $ 10,951 $ 5,589 $ 16,540 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 3 City of Thousand Oaks Associate Human Resources Analyst $ 10,894 $ 4,268 $ 15,162 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00% 4 City of Redondo Beach Human Resources Analyst $ 10,155 $ 4,453 $ 14,608 1/13/2024 unknown unknown 5 City of Malibu Human Resources Analyst $ 9,073 $ 4,874 $ 13,947 7/1/2023 unknown unknown6 City of Beverly Hills Human Resources Analyst $ 9,047 $ 4,637 $ 13,684 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50%7 City of Manhattan Beach Human Resources Analyst $ 8,915 $ 4,321 $ 13,236 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 8 City of Culver City Human Resources Analyst $ 9,065 $ 4,125 $ 13,190 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 9 City of Laguna Beach Administrative Analyst $ 8,011 $ 3,752 $ 11,763 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00% 10 City of Agoura Hills N/C
11 City of Calabasas N/C
Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 9,759 $ 14,419
‐7.6% ‐3.4%
$ 9,610 $ 14,146
‐5.9% ‐1.4%
$ 10,908 $ 15,507
‐20.2% ‐11.2%
Number of Matches 88
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowHuman Resources AnalystSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 27 of 48 ends

130
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of Camarillo Human Resources Manager $ 16,298 $ 7,851 $ 24,148 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Laguna Beach1 Human Resources Director and Principal HR Analyst $ 15,068 $ 5,949 $ 21,017 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 3 City of Beverly Hills Human Resources Manager $ 15,027 $ 5,983 $ 21,010 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 4 City of Thousand Oaks Deputy HR Director/Risk Manager $ 14,979 $ 5,721 $ 20,700 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00% 5 City of Culver City Senior Human Resources and Equity Manager $ 15,146 $ 5,286 $ 20,432 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 6 City of Manhattan Beach Human Resources Manager $ 14,577 $ 5,667 $ 20,244 1/14/2023 unknown unknown7 City of West Hollywood Human Resources Supervisor $ 13,126 $ 6,085 $ 19,211 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 8 City of Malibu Human Resources Manager $ 11,869 $ 5,644 $ 17,514 7/1/2023 unknown unknown9 City of Redondo Beach Human Resources Manager $ 12,444 $ 5,006 $ 17,450 1/13/2024 unknown unknown 10 City of Agoura Hills Human Resources Manager $ 10,988 $ 5,235 $ 16,223 7/1/2023 unknown unknown11 City of Calabasas N/C Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 14,184 $ 20,048
‐19.5% ‐14.5%
$ 14,979 $ 20,432
‐26.2% ‐16.7%
$ 15,068 $ 21,010
‐27.0% ‐20.0%
Number of Matches 99
N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Laguna Beach: Span of Responsibility Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties are bridged by a higher and lower-level classification at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is an average of the matches.

Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowHuman Resources ManagerSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 28 of 48 ends

131
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of West Hollywood Systems Engineer $ 13,125 $ 6,084 $ 19,209 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Thousand Oaks Information Technology Analyst II $ 12,263 $ 4,580 $ 16,843 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00% 3 City of Beverly Hills Network Integrator $ 11,373 $ 5,161 $ 16,534 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 4 City of Laguna Beach Senior IT Analyst $ 11,767 $ 4,422 $ 16,189 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00% 5 City of Manhattan Beach Network Administrator $ 10,443 $ 3,688 $ 14,131 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50%6 City of Calabasas Senior Information Technology Specialist $ 8,839 $ 5,151 $ 13,990 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 7 City of Malibu Information Systems Analyst $ 9,073 $ 4,874 $ 13,947 7/1/2023 unknown unknown8 City of Redondo Beach Information Technology Analyst $ 8,567 $ 4,288 $ 12,855 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 9 City of Culver City Information Systems Analyst $ 9,341 $ 3,471 $ 12,812 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 10 City of Agoura Hills N/C11 City of Camarillo N/C
Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 10,715 $ 15,320
‐18.1% ‐9.8%
$ 10,908 $ 15,160
‐20.2% ‐8.7%
$ 11,891 $ 16,611
‐31.1% ‐19.1%
Number of Matches 88
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowInformation Systems AnalystSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 29 of 48 ends

132
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of West Hollywood2 [Information Technology Manager/ Systems Engineer Supervisor] $ 16,394 $ 7,586 $ 23,980 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Camarillo Information Systems Manager $ 15,522 $ 7,610 $ 23,132 7/1/2023 unknown unknown3 City of Thousand Oaks Information Technology Manager $ 16,711 $ 6,176 $ 22,887 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00% 4 City of Laguna Beach Information Technology Manager $ 16,114 $ 6,180 $ 22,294 7/1/2023 unknown unknown5 City of Manhattan Beach Information Systems Manager $ 15,013 $ 5,771 $ 20,784 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50%6 City of Redondo Beach1 [Information Technology Director/ IT Operations Infrastructure Supervisor] $ 14,228 $ 5,801 $ 20,029 1/13/2024 unknown unknown 7 City of Calabasas Information Systems Manager $ 13,695 $ 6,285 $ 19,980 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 8 City of Culver City Systems Support Manager $ 14,064 $ 5,134 $ 19,198 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 9 City of Malibu Information Systems Manager $ 13,087 $ 5,929 $ 19,015 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 10 City of Agoura Hills N/C11 City of Beverly Hills N/C Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 15,218 $ 21,535
‐16.3% ‐13.3%
$ 15,267 $ 21,539
‐16.7% ‐13.3%
$ 16,184 $ 22,948
‐23.7% ‐20.7%
Number of Matches 88
N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Redondo Beach: Span of Responsibility Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties are bridged by a higher and lower-level classification at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is an average of the matches. 2 - City of West Hollywood: Span of Responsibility Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties are bridged by a higher and lower-level classification at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is an average of the matches.Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowInformation Systems ManagerSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 30 of 48 ends

133
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of Laguna Beach Information System Specialist $ 10,934 $ 4,274 $ 15,208 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00% 2 City of Camarillo Information Systems Technician $ 9,529 $ 5,535 $ 15,064 7/1/2023 unknown unknown3 City of West Hollywood Information Technology Systems Analyst $ 9,803 $ 5,101 $ 14,904 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 4 City of Manhattan Beach Information Systems Specialist $ 8,816 $ 3,462 $ 12,278 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50%5 City of Calabasas Information Technology Specialist $ 7,244 $ 4,779 $ 12,023 7/14/2023 unknown unknown6 City of Thousand Oaks Information Technology Technician II $ 7,965 $ 3,213 $ 11,178 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 4.00% 7 City of Malibu Information Systems Technician $ 6,770 $ 4,367 $ 11,137 7/1/2023 unknown unknown8 City of Culver City Service Desk Technician $ 6,590 $ 3,042 $ 9,632 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 9 City of Redondo Beach Information Technology Technician $ 5,349 $ 3,018 $ 8,367 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 10 City of Agoura Hills N/C11 City of Beverly Hills N/C Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 8,279 $ 12,332
‐22.3% ‐10.7%
$ 8,391 $ 12,150
‐23.9% ‐9.1%
$ 9,598 $ 14,944
‐41.8% ‐34.2%
Number of Matches 88
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowInformation Systems TechnicianSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 31 of 48 ends

134
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of Malibu Management Analyst proposed
2 City of West Hollywood Management Analyst $ 12,141 $ 5,860 $ 18,001 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 3 City of Camarillo Management Analyst $ 11,031 $ 6,135 $ 17,166 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 4 City of Laguna Beach Senior Management Analyst $ 11,767 $ 4,422 $ 16,189 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00%5 City of Thousand Oaks Associate Analyst $ 10,507 $ 4,180 $ 14,687 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00% 6 City of Calabasas Management Analyst $ 8,839 $ 5,151 $ 13,990 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 7 City of Agoura Hills Management Analyst $ 9,018 $ 4,847 $ 13,865 7/1/2023 unknown unknown8 City of Beverly Hills Management Analyst $ 9,047 $ 4,637 $ 13,684 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 9 City of Manhattan Beach Management Analyst $ 9,182 $ 4,385 $ 13,567 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50% 10 City of Culver City Management Analyst $ 9,065 $ 4,125 $ 13,190 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00%11 City of Redondo Beach Senior Management Analyst $ 8,206 $ 4,191 $ 12,397 1/14/2023 unknown unknown Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 9,880 $ 14,674$ 9,124 $ 13,928
$ 10,900 $ 15,814

N/A N/A
Number of Matches 10 10
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowManagement AnalystSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 32 of 48 ends

135
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of Camarillo Community Relations Officer $ 13,408 $ 7,028 $ 20,436 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of West Hollywood Public Information Officer $ 13,125 $ 6,084 $ 19,209 7/1/2023 unknown unknown3 City of Culver City Communications and Public Information Manager $ 13,333 $ 4,988 $ 18,321 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00%4 City of Beverly Hills Public Information Manager $ 12,689 $ 5,457 $ 18,145 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 5 City of Manhattan Beach2 [Communications and Civic Manager/ Marketing & Communications Coordinator] $ 11,746 $ 4,994 $ 16,740 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 6 City of Agoura Hills Communications Manager $ 10,988 $ 5,235 $ 16,223 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 7 City of Laguna Beach1 [Communications Manager/ Digital Media Coordinator] $ 11,565 $ 4,386 $ 15,951 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00% 8 City of Malibu Media Information Officer $ 9,678 $ 5,007 $ 14,685 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 9 City of Thousand Oaks Communications and Marketing Analyst $ 9,509 $ 3,953 $ 13,462 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00% 10 City of Calabasas N/C11 City of Redondo Beach N/C
Top
Monthly
Total
Monthly
$ 12,045 $ 17,311
‐24.5% ‐17.9%
$ 12,217 $ 17,443
‐26.2% ‐18.8%
$ 13,177 $ 18,543
‐36.2% ‐26.3%
Number of Matches 88
N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Laguna Beach: Span of Responsibility Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties are bridged by a higher and lower-level classification at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is an average of the matches. 2 - City of Manhattan Beach: Span of Responsibility Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties are bridged by a higher and lower-level classification at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is an average of the matches.

Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowMedia Information OfficerSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 33 of 48 ends

136
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of Calabasas Landscape District Maintenance Manager $ 11,914 $ 6,219 $ 18,133 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of West Hollywood Urban Forest and Landscape Maintenance Supervisor $ 12,141 $ 5,860 $ 18,001 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 3 City of Manhattan Beach Field Operations Supervisor $ 11,329 $ 4,895 $ 16,224 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50% 4 City of Beverly Hills1 [Parks Services Supervisor/ Parks Superintendent] $ 11,039 $ 5,086 $ 16,125 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 5 City of Camarillo Landscape Inspector $ 9,529 $ 5,535 $ 15,064 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 6 City of Culver City2 [Park Maintenance Supervisor/ Parks Manager] $ 10,376 $ 4,390 $ 14,767 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 7 City of Malibu Parks Supervisor $ 9,544 $ 4,978 $ 14,522 7/1/2023 unknown unknown8 City of Thousand Oaks Landscape Maintenance Supervisor $ 10,060 $ 4,430 $ 14,490 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00% 9 City of Laguna Beach Maintenance Supervisor $ 9,936 $ 4,096 $ 14,032 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00% 10 City of Agoura Hills N/C11 City of Redondo Beach N/C Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 10,791 $ 15,854
‐13.1% ‐9.2%
$ 10,708 $ 15,594
‐12.2% ‐7.4%
$ 11,475 $ 16,668
‐20.2% ‐14.8%
Number of Matches 88
N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Span of Responsibility Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties are bridged by a higher and lower-level classification at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is an average of the matches. 2 - City of Culver City: Span of Responsibility Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties are bridged by a higher and lower-level classification at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is an average of the matches.

Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowParks SupervisorSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 34 of 48 ends

137
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of West Hollywood Permit Services Specialist $ 8,039 $ 4,739 $ 12,778 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Calabasas Building Assistant $ 6,893 $ 4,697 $ 11,589 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 3 City of Thousand Oaks Community Development Technician II $ 7,965 $ 3,213 $ 11,178 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 4.00% 4 City of Malibu Permit Services Technician $ 6,770 $ 4,367 $ 11,137 7/1/2023 unknown unknown5 City of Beverly Hills Development Services Technician II $ 6,986 $ 3,854 $ 10,840 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 6 City of Agoura Hills Building Permit Technician $ 6,542 $ 4,233 $ 10,775 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 7 City of Manhattan Beach Permits Technician $ 6,998 $ 3,209 $ 10,207 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50% 8 City of Laguna Beach Permit Technician $ 6,421 $ 3,469 $ 9,890 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00% 9 City of Redondo Beach Building and Engineering Technician $ 6,520 $ 3,241 $ 9,761 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 10 City of Culver City Permit Technician II $ 6,429 $ 3,017 $ 9,446 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 11 City of Camarillo N/C
Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 6,977 $ 10,718
‐3.1% 3.8%
$ 6,893 $ 10,775
‐1.8% 3.3%
$ 6,998 $ 11,178
‐3.4% ‐0.4%
Number of Matches 99
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowPermit Services TechnicianSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 35 of 48 ends

138
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of Beverly Hills City Planner $ 21,965 $ 7,968 $ 29,933 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50%2 City of Malibu Planning Director $ 17,537 $ 7,336 $ 24,873 7/1/2023 unknown unknown3 City of Agoura Hills N/C4 City of Calabasas N/C5 City of Camarillo N/C6 City of Culver City N/C7 City of Laguna Beach N/C8 City of Manhattan Beach N/C9 City of Redondo Beach N/C 10 City of Thousand Oaks N/C
11 City of West Hollywood N/C
Top Monthly Total Monthly
Insuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. Data
Insuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. Data Insuff. Data Insuff. Data
Number of Matches 11
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowPlanning DirectorSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 36 of 48 ends

139
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of Camarillo Planning Technician $ 7,840 $ 5,051 $ 12,891 7/1/2023 unknown unknown2 City of Malibu Planning Technician $ 7,839 $ 4,602 $ 12,441 7/1/2023 unknown unknown3 City of Beverly Hills Planning Technician $ 7,343 $ 3,921 $ 11,263 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 4 City of Agoura Hills Planning Technician $ 6,542 $ 4,233 $ 10,775 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 5 City of Culver City Planning Technician II $ 7,502 $ 3,184 $ 10,686 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00%6 City of Laguna Beach Planning Technician $ 6,916 $ 3,557 $ 10,473 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00% 7 City of Redondo Beach Planning Technician $ 6,191 $ 3,179 $ 9,370 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 8 City of Calabasas N/C9 City of Manhattan Beach N/C
10 City of Thousand Oaks N/C
11 City of West Hollywood N/C
Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 7,055 $ 10,910

10.0% 12.3%
$ 7,129 $ 10,730

9.0% 13.7%
$ 7,462 $ 11,141

4.8% 10.4%
Number of Matches 66
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowPlanning TechnicianSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 37 of 48 ends

140
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of West Hollywood1 [Public Safety Manager/ Specialist] $ 14,056 $ 6,945 $ 21,001 7/1/2023 unknown unknown2 City of Malibu Public Safety Coordinator $ 9,678 $ 5,007 $ 14,685 7/1/2023 unknown unknown3 City of Agoura Hills N/C4 City of Beverly Hills N/C5 City of Calabasas N/C6 City of Camarillo N/C7 City of Culver City N/C8 City of Laguna Beach N/C 9 City of Manhattan Beach N/C
10 City of Redondo Beach N/C
11 City of Thousand Oaks N/C
Top Monthly Total Monthly
Insuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. Data Number of Matches 11
N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of West Hollywood: Span of Responsibility Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties are bridged by a higher and lower-level classification at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is an average of the matches.

Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowPublic Safety CoordinatorSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 38 of 48 ends

141
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of West Hollywood Director of Community Safety $ 22,623 $ 9,936 $ 32,559 7/1/2023 unknown unknown2 City of Malibu Public Safety Director $ 17,537 $ 7,336 $ 24,873 7/1/2023 unknown unknown3 City of Agoura Hills N/C4 City of Beverly Hills N/C 5 City of Calabasas N/C6 City of Camarillo N/C7 City of Culver City N/C8 City of Laguna Beach N/C9 City of Manhattan Beach N/C 10 City of Redondo Beach N/C
11 City of Thousand Oaks N/C
Top Monthly Total Monthly
Insuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. DataInsuff. Data Insuff. Data Number of Matches 11
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowPublic Safety DirectorSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 39 of 48 ends

142
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of West Hollywood Director of Public Works $ 23,802 $ 10,279 $ 34,081 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Camarillo Director of Public Works $ 21,841 $ 10,640 $ 32,481 7/1/2023 unknown unknown3 City of Beverly Hills Assistant Director of Public Works/City Engineer $ 21,965 $ 8,368 $ 30,333 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50%4 City of Laguna Beach Director of Public Works $ 20,494 $ 7,549 $ 28,043 7/1/2023 unknown unknown5 City of Thousand Oaks Deputy Public Works Director/City Engineer $ 20,595 $ 7,195 $ 27,790 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 5.00%6 City of Calabasas Public Works Director/City Engineer $ 19,791 $ 7,958 $ 27,748 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 7 City of Malibu Public Works Director/City Engineer $ 18,863 $ 7,663 $ 26,527 7/1/2023 unknown unknown8 City of Manhattan Beach Public Works Director $ 18,778 $ 7,065 $ 25,843 1/14/2023 unknown unknown9 City of Agoura Hills Director of Public Works/City Engineer $ 17,566 $ 7,426 $ 24,992 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 10 City of Redondo Beach Public Works Director $ 17,291 $ 5,976 $ 23,267 1/13/2024 unknown unknown11 City of Culver City N/C Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 20,236 $ 28,286
‐7.3% ‐6.6%
$ 20,494 $ 27,790
‐8.6% ‐4.8%
$ 21,841 $ 30,333
‐15.8% ‐14.3%
Number of Matches 99
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowPublic Works Director/City EngineerSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 40 of 48 ends

143
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of West Hollywood Public Works Inspector $ 10,951 $ 5,336 $ 16,287 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Calabasas Senior Public Works Inspector $ 8,839 $ 5,151 $ 13,990 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 3 City of Malibu Public Works Inspector $ 8,034 $ 4,645 $ 12,679 7/1/2023 unknown unknown4 City of Beverly Hills Public Works Inspector I$ 8,440 $ 4,126 $ 12,566 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 5 City of Thousand Oaks Construction Inspector II $ 8,800 $ 3,347 $ 12,147 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 4.00% 6 City of Manhattan Beach Public Works Inspector $ 8,043 $ 3,354 $ 11,398 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50% 7 City of Culver City Public Works Inspector $ 7,539 $ 3,190 $ 10,729 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00%8 City of Redondo Beach Public Works Inspector $ 6,714 $ 3,278 $ 9,992 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 9 City of Agoura Hills N/C
10 City of Camarillo N/C11 City of Laguna Beach N/C
Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 8,475 $ 12,444
‐5.5% 1.9%
$ 8,440 $ 12,147
‐5.1% 4.2%
$ 8,820 $ 13,278
‐9.8% ‐4.7%
Number of Matches 77
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowPublic Works InspectorSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 41 of 48 ends

144
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of Thousand Oaks Public Works Superintendent $ 15,434 $ 5,840 $ 21,274 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 4.00% 2 City of Camarillo Maintenance Superintendent $ 14,079 $ 7,164 $ 21,242 7/1/2023 unknown unknown3 City of Manhattan Beach Maintenance Manager $ 14,576 $ 5,667 $ 20,243 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50% 4 City of Malibu Public Works Superintendent $ 13,354 $ 5,991 $ 19,345 7/1/2023 unknown unknown5 City of West Hollywood Facilities and Landscape Superintendent $ 13,126 $ 6,085 $ 19,211 7/1/2023 unknown unknown6 City of Culver City Maintenance Operations Manager $ 13,305 $ 4,982 $ 18,287 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00%7 City of Calabasas Public Works Superintendent $ 11,914 $ 5,869 $ 17,783 7/14/2023 unknown unknown8 City of Beverly Hills1 [Public Works Manager/ Maintenance Superintendent] $ 11,894 $ 5,278 $ 17,172 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 9 City of Redondo Beach2 [Public Works Superintendent/ Public Works Manager] $ 9,182 $ 4,452 $ 13,634 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 10 City of Agoura Hills N/C11 City of Laguna Beach N/C
Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 12,939 $ 18,606

3.1% 3.8%
$ 13,215 $ 18,749

1.0% 3.1%
$ 14,203 $ 20,493
‐6.4% ‐5.9%
Number of Matches 88
N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Span of Responsibility Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties are bridged by a higher and lower-level classification at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is an average of the matches. 2 - City of Redondo Beach: Functional Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties of the class are performed by more than one class at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is the higher of the matches.

Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowPublic Works SuperintendentSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 42 of 48 ends

145
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of West Hollywood Recreation Services Manager $ 19,005 $ 8,302 $ 27,307 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Beverly Hills Recreation Services Manager $ 13,073 $ 5,543 $ 18,616 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 3 City of Culver City Recreation and Community Services Manager $ 13,108 $ 4,942 $ 18,050 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 4 City of Calabasas Recreation Manager $ 11,914 $ 5,869 $ 17,783 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 5 City of Manhattan Beach Recreation Manager $ 12,283 $ 5,122 $ 17,404 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50% 6 City of Malibu Recreation Manager $ 11,130 $ 5,472 $ 16,602 7/1/2023 unknown unknown7 City of Agoura Hills Recreation Manager $ 10,988 $ 5,235 $ 16,223 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 8 City of Redondo Beach Recreation, Youth, Senior and Family Services Manager $ 9,182 $ 4,452 $ 13,634 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 9 City of Camarillo N/C
10 City of Laguna Beach N/C11 City of Thousand Oaks N/C Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 12,793 $ 18,431
‐14.9% ‐11.0%
$ 12,283 $ 17,783
‐10.4% ‐7.1%
$ 13,090 $ 18,333
‐17.6% ‐10.4%
Number of Matches 77
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowRecreation ManagerSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 43 of 48 ends

146
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of West Hollywood Recreation Supervisor $ 12,141 $ 5,860 $ 18,001 7/1/2023 unknown unknown2 City of Malibu Recreation Supervisor $ 9,678 $ 5,007 $ 14,685 7/1/2023 unknown unknown3 City of Calabasas Recreation Supervisor $ 8,839 $ 5,151 $ 13,990 7/14/2023 unknown unknown4 City of Agoura Hills Recreation Supervisor $ 8,798 $ 4,803 $ 13,601 7/1/2023 unknown unknown5 City of Culver City Recreation and Community Services Supervisor $ 8,886 $ 4,089 $ 12,975 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 6 City of Laguna Beach Recreation Supervisor $ 9,039 $ 3,936 $ 12,975 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00% 7 City of Beverly Hills Recreation Supervisor $ 8,465 $ 4,130 $ 12,595 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50%8 City of Redondo Beach Recreation Supervisor $ 7,430 $ 3,984 $ 11,414 1/14/2023 unknown unknown9 City of Manhattan Beach Recreation Supervisor $ 7,848 $ 3,327 $ 11,175 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50% 10 City of Camarillo N/C11 City of Thousand Oaks N/C
Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 8,931 $ 13,341

7.7% 9.2%
$ 8,819 $ 12,975

8.9% 11.6%
$ 8,924 $ 13,699

7.8% 6.7%
Number of Matches 88
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowRecreation SupervisorSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 44 of 48 ends

147
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of West Hollywood Senior Maintenance Technician $ 8,039 $ 4,739 $ 12,778 7/1/2023 unknown unknown2 City of Malibu Senior Maintenance Worker $ 7,968 $ 4,631 $ 12,598 7/1/2023 unknown unknown3 City of Laguna Beach Maintenance Lead Worker $ 8,217 $ 3,789 $ 12,006 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00% 4 City of Camarillo Public Works Maintenance Worker III $ 7,111 $ 4,842 $ 11,953 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 5 City of Beverly Hills1 [Facilities Maintenance Mechanic/ Street Maintenance Technician] $ 7,198 $ 3,894 $ 11,092 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 6 City of Thousand Oaks Senior Building Maintenance Technician $ 7,576 $ 3,151 $ 10,727 7/8/2023 7/6/2024 4.00% 7 City of Calabasas Maintenance Technician II $ 6,056 $ 4,501 $ 10,558 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 8 City of Manhattan Beach Lead Maintenance Worker $ 7,104 $ 3,224 $ 10,328 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50% 9 City of Culver City2 [Facilities Maintenance Crew Leader/ Park Maintenance Crew Leader] $ 7,137 $ 3,127 $ 10,265 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 10 City of Redondo Beach Parks Maintenance Leadworker $ 6,147 $ 3,218 $ 9,365 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 11 City of Agoura Hills N/C
Top
Monthly
Total
Monthly
$ 7,176 $ 11,008

9.9% 12.6%
$ 7,137 $ 10,727

10.4% 14.9%
$ 7,576 $ 11,953

4.9% 5.1%
Number of Matches 99
N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Functional Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties of the class are performed by more than one class at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is the higher of the matches. 2 - City of Culver City: Functional Match: This hybrid match represents that the duties of the class are performed by more than one class at the comparator agency. The salary displayed is the higher of the matches.

Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowSenior Maintenance WorkerSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 45 of 48 ends

148
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of Agoura Hills Administrative Aide $ 6,542 $ 4,233 $ 10,775 7/1/2023 unknown unknown2 City of Malibu Senior Office Assistant $ 5,996 $ 4,196 $ 10,192 7/1/2023 unknown unknown3 City of Beverly Hills Office Assistant II $ 6,215 $ 3,710 $ 9,925 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50% 4 City of Laguna Beach Senior Office Specialist $ 5,996 $ 3,393 $ 9,389 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00%5 City of Manhattan Beach Office Assistant $ 5,196 $ 2,959 $ 8,155 1/1/2024 1/11/2025 1.50%6 City of Culver City Administrative Clerk $ 5,118 $ 2,813 $ 7,930 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00%7 City of Redondo Beach Office Specialist III $ 4,612 $ 2,878 $ 7,490 1/14/2023 unknown unknown 8 City of Calabasas N/C9 City of Camarillo N/C
10 City of Thousand Oaks N/C
11 City of West Hollywood N/C
Top Monthly Total Monthly
$ 5,613 $ 8,944

6.4% 12.2%
$ 5,596 $ 8,772

6.7% 13.9%
$ 6,160 $ 9,791
‐2.7% 3.9%
Number of Matches 66
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowSenior Office AssistantSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 46 of 48 ends

149
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of Beverly Hills Permit Center Supervisor $ 9,166 $ 4,261 $ 13,428 10/7/2023 10/1/2024 4.50%2 City of Malibu Supervising Permit Services Technician $ 8,416 $ 4,729 $ 13,145 7/1/2023 unknown unknown3 City of Laguna Beach Permit Supervisor $ 9,039 $ 3,936 $ 12,975 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 4.00% 4 City of Calabasas Permit Center Supervisor $ 7,614 $ 4,865 $ 12,479 7/14/2023 unknown unknown 5 City of Agoura Hills N/C6 City of Camarillo N/C
7 City of Culver City N/C8 City of Manhattan Beach N/C9 City of Redondo Beach N/C 10 City of Thousand Oaks N/C11 City of West Hollywood N/C Top Monthly Total Monthly
Insuff. Data Insuff. Data
Insuff. Data Insuff. Data
Insuff. Data Insuff. Data
Insuff. Data Insuff. Data
Insuff. Data Insuff. Data
Insuff. Data Insuff. Data
Number of Matches 33
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowSupervising Permit Services TechnicianSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 47 of 48 ends

150
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results (sorted by Total Compensation) March 2024
Appendix II (b)
Rank Comparator Agency Classification Title Top Step Benefits Package Total Monthly Comp Salary Effective Date Next Salary Increase Next Percentage Increase 1 City of Malibu Wastewater Management Program Specialist $ 8,189 $ 4,679 $ 12,869 7/1/2023 unknown unknown 2 City of Culver City Associate Analyst $ 7,502 $ 3,184 $ 10,686 7/1/2023 7/1/2024 5.00% 3 City of Agoura Hills N/C4 City of Beverly Hills N/C
5 City of Calabasas N/C
6 City of Camarillo N/C7 City of Laguna Beach N/C
8 City of Manhattan Beach N/C9 City of Redondo Beach N/C 10 City of Thousand Oaks N/C11 City of West Hollywood N/C Top Monthly Total Monthly
Insuff. Data Insuff. Data
Insuff. Data Insuff. Data
Insuff. Data Insuff. Data
Insuff. Data Insuff. Data
Insuff. Data Insuff. Data
Insuff. Data Insuff. Data
Number of Matches 11
N/C - Non Comparator
Median of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below75th Percentile% City of Malibu Above/BelowWastewater Management Program SpecialistSummary ResultsAverage of Comparators% City of Malibu Above/Below

Page 48 of 48 ends

151
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Accounting
Technician
AccountingSpecialist II
Accounting
Technician
Accounting
Specialist
Finance
Assistant
Senior Account
Clerk
Accounting
Technician
Revenue
Services
Specialist
Accounting
Technician
Accounting
Specialist
Accounting
Technician
Top Step $ 7,465 $ 7,971 $ 6,452 $ 6,893 $ 9,075 $ 5,647 $ 8,011 $ 7,298 $ 5,339 $ 7,030 $ 8,040 Classic 2% @ 55 2%@55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@55 2%@60 2%@55 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 224 $ 239 $ 342 $ 207 $ 272 $ 73 $ 425 $ 219 $ 69 $ 211 $ 571 Employer Paid Member $ 523 $ 311 $ 482 $ 635
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐198
Single Highest Year $ 37 $ 40 $ 39 $ 45 $ 48 $ 36 $ 35 $ 56 Social Security $ 350 $ 331
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 217 $ 100 $ 138 $ 635 $ 130 $ 150 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,450 $ 2,805 $ 1,885 $ 2,000 $ 1,155 Health $ 2,581 $ 2,625 $ 2,942 $ 2,201 $ 2,183 $ 435 $ 2,942 Dental $ 158 $ 167 $ 120 $ 123 $ 55 $ 180
Vision $ 28 $ 61 $ 26 $ 19
Other Ins.1 $ 129
Vacation $ 431 $ 460 $ 372 $ 451 $ 524 $ 326 $ 525 $ 365 $ 308 $ 473 $ 541 Holidays $ 431 $ 368 $ 323 $ 331 $ 489 $ 328 $ 431 $ 393 $ 308 $ 406 $ 479Admin Leave AllowAuto
$ 4,520 $ 4,487 $ 3,755 $ 4,697 $ 5,405 $ 2,895 $ 3,752 $ 3,251 $ 3,016 $ 3,064 $ 4,739 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 1 of 48 ends

152
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Administrative
Assistant
Administrative
Assistant II
Administrative
Assistant
Executive
Assistant I
Administrative
Specialist II Secretary Administrative Assistant Administrative Assistant Administrative Specialist Administrative Secretary Administrative Specialist II Top Step $ 6,892 $ 7,042 $ 6,849 $ 6,558 $ 7,466 $ 5,591 $ 7,307 $ 6,372 $ 4,964 $ 6,688 $ 6,932 Classic 2% @ 55 2%@55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@55 2%@60 2%@55 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 207 $ 211 $ 363 $ 197 $ 224 $ 73 $ 387 $ 191 $ 65 $ 201 $ 492 Employer Paid Member $ 482 $ 275 $ 459 $ 523
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐196
Single Highest Year $ 34 $ 35 $ 41 $ 37 $ 44 $ 32 $ 33 $ 49 Social Security $ 347 $ 308
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 217 $ 60 $ 131 $ 523 $ 130 $ 150 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,450 $ 2,805 $ 1,885 $ 2,000 $ 1,155 Health $ 2,581 $ 2,625 $ 2,942 $ 2,201 $ 2,183 $ 435 $ 2,942 Dental $ 158 $ 167 $ 120 $ 123 $ 55 $ 180
Vision $ 28 $ 61 $ 26 $ 19
Other Ins.1 $ 137
Vacation $ 398 $ 406 $ 395 $ 429 $ 431 $ 323 $ 479 $ 319 $ 286 $ 450 $ 467 Holidays $ 398 $ 325 $ 342 $ 315 $ 402 $ 325 $ 393 $ 343 $ 286 $ 386 $ 413Admin Leave $ 89 AllowAuto
$ 4,394 $ 4,322 $ 3,877 $ 4,618 $ 4,944 $ 2,886 $ 3,627 $ 3,122 $ 2,945 $ 3,009 $ 4,512 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 2 of 48 ends

153
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Assistant City
Manager
Assistant City
Manager N/C N/C Assistant City Manager Assistant City Manager Assistant City Manager N/C Assistant City Manager Assistant City Manager Assistant City Manager Top Step $ 19,802 $ 19,389 $ 24,079 $ 21,573 $ 22,543 $ 23,011 $ 26,150 $ 26,753 Classic 2% @ 55 2%@55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@60 2%@55 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 594 $ 582 $ 722 $ 280 $ 1,195 $ 299 $ 785 $ 1,899 Employer Paid Member $ 1,386 $ 756 $ 1,686Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐755 Single Highest Year $ 99 $ 97 $ 120 $ 135 $ 131 $ 187
Social Security $ 871 $ 871
Deferred Compensation $ 250 $ 485 $ 2,408 $ 347 $ 451 $ 115 $ 1,569 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,805 $ 1,885 $ 2,000 $ 1,155
Health $ 2,581 $ 2,625 $ 2,476 $ 435 $ 2,942
Dental $ 158 $ 167 $ 138 $ 180
Vision $ 28 $ 61 $ 19
Other Ins. $ 63
Vacation $ 1,142 $ 1,119 $ 1,389 $ 1,245 $ 1,474 $ 1,416 $ 2,892 $ 2,264 Holidays $ 1,142 $ 895 $ 1,297 $ 1,255 $ 867 $ 1,328 $ 1,509 $ 1,595 Admin Leave $ 514 $ 839 $ 741 $ 1,307 $ 867 $ 974 $ 503 $ 1,852 AllowAuto $ 250 $ 250 $ 375 $ 400 $ 375 $ 522 $ 250
Benefit Package Total $7,894 $7,875 $0 $0 $11,418 $6,872 $8,003 $0 $7,377 $9,698 $11,139 Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 3 of 48 ends

154
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Assistant
Community
Development
Director
Planning
Director
Assistant
Director of
Community
Development/B
uilding Official
City Planner
Assistant
Director of
Community
Development
N/C
Assistant
Director of
Community
Development

N/C N/C
Deputy
Community
Development
Director
Assistant
Director of
Community
Development
Top Step proposed $ 15,147 $ 21,965 $ 13,695 $ 17,968 $ 16,114 $ 18,460 $ 21,285 Classic 2%@55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2%@55 2.5%@55 2%@55 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 454 $ 1,164 $ 411 $ 539 $ 854 $ 554 $ 1,511 Employer Paid Member $ 591 $ 959 $ 1,258
Employee Cost SharingSingle Highest Year $ 76 $ 132 $ 90 $ 97 $ 92 $ 149 Social SecurityDeferred Compensation $ 379 $ 50 $ 274 $ 1,258 $ 322 $ 738 $ 150 Other Ret.

Cafeteria $ 2,550 $ 2,805 $ 1,155
Health $ 2,625 $ 2,942 $ 2,476 $ 435 $ 2,942
Dental $ 167 $ 120 $ 138 $ 180
Vision $ 61 $ 26 $ 19
Other Ins.1 $ 439
Vacation $ 874 $ 1,267 $ 895 $ 1,037 $ 1,054 $ 2,041 $ 1,801 Holidays $ 699 $ 1,098 $ 658 $ 968 $ 620 $ 1,065 $ 1,269 Admin Leave $ 655 $ 1,267 $ 415 $ 620 $ 355 $ 1,474
AllowAuto $ 250 $ 250 $ 200 $ 250
$ 0 $ 6,831 $ 7,968 $ 6,535 $ 8,568 $ 0 $ 6,180 $ 0 $ 0 $ 6,635 $ 9,546 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 4 of 48 ends

155
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Assistant
Planning
Director
N/C
[Urban
Designer/
Principal
Planner]
N/C Planning Manager
[Current
Planning
Manager/
Advance
Planning
Manager]
Planning
Manager N/C Planning Manager Planning Division Manager N/C Top Step $ 15,150 $ 12,689 $ 14,783 $ 15,146 $ 14,792 $ 10,141 $ 15,279 Classic 2% @ 55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@60 2%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 454 $ 672 $ 443 $ 197 $ 784 $ 132 $ 458 Employer Paid Member $ 1,060 $ 1,035
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐530
Single Highest Year $ 76 $ 76 $ 74 $ 89 $ 76
Social Security $ 871 $ 629
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 50 $ 1,035 $ 347 $ 296 $ 51 $ 611 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,550 $ 2,805 $ 1,885 $ 2,000 $ 1,155 Health $ 2,581 $ 2,476 $ 435
Dental $ 158 $ 138 $ 180
Vision $ 28 $ 19
Other Ins.1 $ 254 $ 63
Vacation $ 874 $ 732 $ 853 $ 874 $ 967 $ 917 $ 1,690
Holidays $ 874 $ 634 $ 796 $ 881 $ 569 $ 585 $ 881Admin Leave $ 197 $ 488 $ 341 $ 699 $ 569 $ 395 $ 294 AllowAuto $ 200
$ 6,410 $ 0 $ 5,457 $ 0 $ 7,582 $ 5,286 $ 5,887 $ 0 $ 4,708 $ 5,800 $ 0 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 5 of 48 ends

156
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Associate
Engineer
Associate Civil
Engineer N/C Associate Civil Engineer Associate Engineer Associate Engineer Associate Civil Engineer Associate Engineer Associate Civil Engineer Associate Engineer Assistant Engineer Top Step $ 11,869 $ 10,988 $ 10,262 $ 12,162 $ 9,911 $ 12,432 $ 11,040 $ 9,434 $ 13,217 $ 12,141 Classic 2% @ 55 2%@55 2%@55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@55 2%@60 2%@55 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 356 $ 330 $ 308 $ 365 $ 129 $ 659 $ 331 $ 123 $ 397 $ 862 Employer Paid Member $ 831 $ 429 $ 718 $ 851
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐347
Single Highest Year $ 59 $ 55 $ 61 $ 75 $ 55 $ 66 $ 85
Social Security $ 614 $ 585
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 217 $ 205 $ 851 $ 130 $ 47 $ 264 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,805 $ 1,885 $ 2,000 $ 1,155
Health $ 2,581 $ 2,625 $ 2,942 $ 2,201 $ 2,183 $ 435 $ 2,942 Dental $ 158 $ 167 $ 120 $ 123 $ 55 $ 180
Vision $ 28 $ 61 $ 26 $ 19
Other Ins.Vacation $ 685 $ 634 $ 671 $ 702 $ 572 $ 814 $ 552 $ 853 $ 1,462 $ 817 Holidays $ 685 $ 507 $ 493 $ 655 $ 577 $ 669 $ 594 $ 544 $ 763 $ 724Admin Leave $ 211 $ 187 $ 367 $ 57 AllowAuto
Benefit Package Total $ 5,490 $ 5,235 $ 0 $ 5,483 $ 6,477 $ 3,560 $ 4,541 $ 3,770 $ 4,519 $ 4,797 $ 5,580 Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 6 of 48 ends

157
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Associate
Planner
Associate
Planner
Associate
Planner
Associate
Planner
Associate
Planner
Associate
Planner
Associate
Planner
Associate
Planner
Associate
Planner
Associate
Planner
Associate
Planner
Top Step $ 9,743 $ 9,954 $ 9,508 $ 9,764 $ 10,506 $ 8,887 $ 9,936 $ 9,892 $ 8,567 $ 11,494 $ 12,141 Classic 2% @ 55 2%@55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@55 2%@60 2%@55 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 292 $ 299 $ 504 $ 293 $ 315 $ 116 $ 527 $ 297 $ 111 $ 345 $ 862 Employer Paid Member $ 682 $ 388 $ 683 $ 735
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐311
Single Highest Year $ 49 $ 50 $ 57 $ 53 $ 60 $ 49 $ 57 $ 85 Social Security $ 551 $ 531
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 217 $ 50 $ 195 $ 735 $ 130 $ 43 $ 230 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,550 $ 2,805 $ 1,885 $ 2,000 $ 1,155 Health $ 2,581 $ 2,625 $ 2,942 $ 2,201 $ 2,183 $ 435 $ 2,942 Dental $ 158 $ 167 $ 120 $ 123 $ 55 $ 180
Vision $ 28 $ 61 $ 26 $ 19
Other Ins.1 $ 190
Vacation $ 562 $ 574 $ 549 $ 638 $ 606 $ 513 $ 651 $ 495 $ 774 $ 1,271 $ 817 Holidays $ 562 $ 459 $ 475 $ 469 $ 566 $ 517 $ 535 $ 533 $ 494 $ 663 $ 724Admin Leave $ 366 $ 334 $ 50 $ 280 AllowAuto
$ 5,022 $ 4,840 $ 4,741 $ 5,367 $ 5,815 $ 3,400 $ 4,096 $ 3,611 $ 4,288 $ 4,405 $ 5,860 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 7 of 48 ends

158
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Building
Inspector N/C Building Inspector II Building Inspector N/C Building Safety Inspector Building Inspector Building Inspector Building Inspector Combination Building Inspector II Senior Combination Building Inspector Top Step $ 8,230 $ 9,323 $ 7,614 $ 7,502 $ 9,039 $ 8,278 $ 6,943 $ 8,889 $ 11,157 Classic 2% @ 55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@55 2%@60 2%@55 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 247 $ 494 $ 228 $ 98 $ 479 $ 248 $ 90 $ 267 $ 792 Employer Paid Member $ 576 $ 533
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐263
Single Highest Year $ 41 $ 56 $ 54 $ 41 $ 44 $ 78
Social Security $ 465 $ 430
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 100 $ 152 $ 130 $ 150 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,450 $ 1,885 $ 2,000 $ 1,155
Health $ 2,581 $ 2,942 $ 2,201 $ 2,183 $ 435 $ 2,942
Dental $ 158 $ 120 $ 123 $ 55 $ 180
Vision $ 28 $ 26 $ 19
Other Ins.1 $ 186
Vacation $ 475 $ 538 $ 498 $ 433 $ 592 $ 414 $ 401 $ 598 $ 751 Holidays $ 475 $ 466 $ 366 $ 436 $ 487 $ 446 $ 401 $ 513 $ 665Admin Leave AllowAuto
$ 4,688 $ 0 $ 4,291 $ 4,865 $ 0 $ 3,184 $ 3,936 $ 3,387 $ 3,322 $ 3,361 $ 5,378 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 8 of 48 ends

159
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Building
Official (Deputy
Director Level)
Building Official Deputy Building Official Building Official N/C Building Official Building Official Building Official Chief Building Official Building
Official/Building
Division
Manager
Building and
Safety
Manager/Buildin
g Official
Top Step proposed $ 14,417 $ 15,952 $ 12,522 $ 15,606 $ 13,017 $ 15,013 $ 13,709 $ 14,111 $ 19,005 Classic 2%@55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@55 2%@60 2%@55 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 433 $ 845 $ 376 $ 203 $ 690 $ 450 $ 178 $ 423 $ 1,349 Employer Paid Member $ 562 $ 877
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐546Single Highest Year $ 72 $ 96 $ 78 $ 75 $ 71 $ 133 Social Security $ 871 $ 850
Deferred Compensation $ 360 $ 50 $ 250 $ 347 $ 260 $ 676 $ 69 $ 564 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,550 $ 1,885 $ 2,000 $ 1,155
Health $ 2,625 $ 2,942 $ 2,476 $ 2,132 $ 435 $ 2,942
Dental $ 167 $ 120 $ 138 $ 70 $ 180
Vision $ 61 $ 26 $ 19
Other Ins.1 $ 319 $ 63
Vacation $ 832 $ 920 $ 819 $ 900 $ 851 $ 1,732 $ 844 $ 1,560 $ 1,608 Holidays $ 665 $ 798 $ 602 $ 908 $ 501 $ 635 $ 791 $ 814 $ 804 Admin Leave $ 624 $ 614 $ 720 $ 501 $ 580 $ 271 $ 1,316 AllowAuto $ 250 $ 350
$ 0 $ 6,651 $ 6,192 $ 6,361 $ 0 $ 5,350 $ 5,495 $ 5,771 $ 5,311 $ 5,493 $ 8,302 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 9 of 48 ends

160
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood City Clerk City Clerk City Clerk City Clerk City Clerk City Clerk City Clerk City Clerk City Clerk City Clerk City Clerk Top Step $ 13,741 $ 12,432 $ 18,333 $ 13,695 $ 16,298 $ 15,920 $ 14,792 $ 18,778 $ 10,875 $ 17,047 $ 19,005 Classic 2% @ 55 2%@55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@55 2%@60 2%@55 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 412 $ 373 $ 972 $ 411 $ 489 $ 207 $ 784 $ 563 $ 141 $ 511 $ 1,349 Employer Paid Member $ 962 $ 485 $ 959 $ 1,141
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐557Single Highest Year $ 69 $ 62 $ 110 $ 81 $ 89 $ 94 $ 85 $ 133 Social Security $ 871 $ 674
Deferred Compensation $ 250 $ 311 $ 30 $ 274 $ 1,630 $ 347 $ 296 $ 845 $ 54 $ 1,023 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,250 $ 2,805 $ 1,885 $ 2,000 $ 1,155 Health $ 2,581 $ 2,625 $ 2,942 $ 2,476 $ 2,132 $ 435 $ 2,942 Dental $ 158 $ 167 $ 120 $ 138 $ 70 $ 180
Vision $ 28 $ 61 $ 26 $ 19
Other Ins. 1 $ 367 $ 63
Vacation $ 793 $ 717 $ 1,058 $ 895 $ 940 $ 918 $ 967 $ 2,167 $ 669 $ 1,885 $ 1,608 Holidays $ 793 $ 574 $ 846 $ 658 $ 878 $ 926 $ 569 $ 794 $ 627 $ 983 $ 804Admin Leave $ 357 $ 538 $ 1,058 $ 501 $ 735 $ 569 $ 460 $ 328 $ 1,316 AllowAuto $ 250 $ 250 $ 400 $ 522
$ 6,401 $ 6,162 $ 6,690 $ 6,285 $ 8,715 $ 5,394 $ 5,887 $ 7,065 $ 4,627 $ 7,127 $ 8,302 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 10 of 48 ends

161
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Code
Enforcement
Manager
N/C
Code
Enforcement
Manager
N/C
Code
Compliance
Manager
Enforcement
Services
Manager
Code
Enforcement
Supervisor
Code
Enforcement
Supervisor
N/C
Code
Compliance
Manager
[Neighborhood
and Business
Safety
Manager/Code
Enforcement
Supervisor]
Top Step $ 13,087 $ 10,714 $ 12,770 $ 12,163 $ 9,936 $ 10,299 $ 12,775 $ 15,573 Classic 2% @ 55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@55 2%@55 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 393 $ 568 $ 383 $ 158 $ 527 $ 309 $ 383 $ 1,106 Employer Paid Member $ 916 $ 894
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐426Single Highest Year $ 65 $ 64 $ 64 $ 60 $ 51 $ 64 $ 109 Social Security $ 754
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 50 $ 894 $ 347 $ 463 $ 511 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,550 $ 2,805 $ 1,885 $ 1,155
Health $ 2,581 $ 2,201 $ 2,132 $ 435 $ 2,942
Dental $ 158 $ 123 $ 70 $ 180
Vision $ 28 $ 19
Other Ins.1 $ 214 $ 63
Vacation $ 755 $ 618 $ 737 $ 702 $ 651 $ 1,188 $ 1,413 $ 1,318Holidays $ 755 $ 536 $ 688 $ 708 $ 535 $ 436 $ 737 $ 659 Admin Leave $ 170 $ 412 $ 295 $ 561 $ 246 $ 1,078
AllowAuto
$ 5,929 $ 0 $ 5,012 $ 0 $ 6,758 $ 4,751 $ 4,096 $ 4,650 $ 0 $ 5,142 $ 7,361 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 11 of 48 ends

162
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Code
Enforcement
Officer
Code
Compliance
Officer
Code
Enforcement
Officer
Code
Enforcement
Officer
Code
Compliance
Officer
Code
Enforcement
Officer
Code
Enforcement
Officer
Code
Enforcement
Officer II
Code
Enforcement
Officer
Code
Compliance
Officer II
Code
Enforcement
Officer
Top Step $ 8,230 $ 7,971 $ 8,274 $ 7,538 $ 8,643 $ 6,995 $ 8,011 $ 8,230 $ 6,520 $ 8,455 $ 9,803 Classic 2% @ 55 2%@55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@55 2%@60 2%@55 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 247 $ 239 $ 439 $ 226 $ 259 $ 91 $ 425 $ 247 $ 85 $ 254 $ 696 Employer Paid Member $ 576 $ 311 $ 528 $ 605
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐245
Single Highest Year $ 41 $ 40 $ 50 $ 43 $ 48 $ 41 $ 42 $ 69 Social Security $ 434 $ 404
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 217 $ 100 $ 151 $ 605 $ 130 $ 150 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,450 $ 2,805 $ 1,885 $ 2,000 $ 1,155 Health $ 2,581 $ 2,625 $ 2,942 $ 2,201 $ 2,183 $ 435 $ 2,942 Dental $ 158 $ 167 $ 120 $ 123 $ 55 $ 180
Vision $ 28 $ 61 $ 26 $ 19
Other Ins.1 $ 165
Vacation $ 475 $ 460 $ 477 $ 493 $ 499 $ 404 $ 525 $ 411 $ 376 $ 569 $ 660 Holidays $ 475 $ 368 $ 414 $ 362 $ 465 $ 407 $ 431 $ 443 $ 376 $ 488 $ 584Admin Leave AllowAuto
$ 4,688 $ 4,487 $ 4,095 $ 4,847 $ 5,281 $ 3,105 $ 3,752 $ 3,380 $ 3,241 $ 3,292 $ 5,101 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 12 of 48 ends

163
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Community
Development
Director
Community
Development
Director
Director of
Community
Development
Community
Development
Director
Director of
Community
Development
Planning &
Development
Director
Director of
Community
Development
Community
Development
Director
Community
Development
Director
Community
Development
Director
Director of
Community
Development
Top Step proposed $ 17,566 $ 26,699 $ 19,791 $ 20,801 $ 18,101 $ 20,494 $ 18,778 $ 19,021 $ 21,646 $ 23,802 Classic 2%@55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@55 2%@60 2%@55 2.7%@55Enhanced Formula Cost $ 527 $ 1,415 $ 594 $ 624 $ 235 $ 1,086 $ 563 $ 247 $ 649 $ 1,690 Employer Paid Member $ 685 $ 1,385 $ 1,456
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐634
Single Highest Year $ 88 $ 160 $ 104 $ 123 $ 94 $ 108 $ 167 Social Security $ 871 $ 871
Deferred Compensation $ 439 $ 50 $ 396 $ 2,080 $ 347 $ 410 $ 845 $ 95 $ 1,299 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,550 $ 2,805 $ 1,885 $ 2,000 $ 1,155 Health $ 2,625 $ 2,942 $ 2,476 $ 2,132 $ 435 $ 2,942
Dental $ 167 $ 120 $ 138 $ 70 $ 180
Vision $ 61 $ 26 $ 19
Other Ins.1 $ 534 $ 63
Vacation $ 1,013 $ 1,540 $ 1,294 $ 1,200 $ 1,044 $ 1,340 $ 2,167 $ 1,171 $ 2,394 $ 2,014 Holidays $ 811 $ 1,335 $ 951 $ 1,120 $ 1,053 $ 788 $ 794 $ 1,097 $ 1,249 $ 1,419 Admin Leave $ 760 $ 1,540 $ 640 $ 1,096 $ 788 $ 805 $ 416 $ 1,648 AllowAuto $ 250 $ 250 $ 250 $ 375 $ 400 $ 400 $ 375 $ 522 $ 250 $ 0 $ 7,426 $ 9,125 $ 7,958 $ 10,279 $ 6,336 $ 7,549 $ 7,065 $ 6,661 $ 8,426 $ 10,279 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills
Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 13 of 48 ends

164
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Community
Services
Director
Director
Community
Services
Assistant
Director of
Community
Services
Community
Services
Director
N/C
Parks,
Recreation &
Community
Services
Director
N/C
Parks and
Recreation
Director
Community
Services
Director
N/C
Director of
Community
Services
Top Step $ 17,537 $ 17,566 $ 21,965 $ 16,878 $ 17,408 $ 18,778 $ 17,291 $ 22,623 Classic 2% @ 55 2%@55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2%@55 2%@60 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 526 $ 527 $ 1,164 $ 506 $ 226 $ 563 $ 225 $ 1,606 Employer Paid Member $ 1,228 $ 685 $ 1,181
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐609
Single Highest Year $ 88 $ 88 $ 132 $ 94 $ 158
Social Security $ 871 $ 871
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 439 $ 50 $ 338 $ 347 $ 845 $ 86 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,550 $ 1,885 $ 2,000
Health $ 2,581 $ 2,625 $ 2,942 $ 2,132 $ 2,942
Dental $ 158 $ 167 $ 120 $ 70
Vision $ 28 $ 61 $ 26
Other Ins.1 $ 439 $ 63
Vacation $ 1,012 $ 1,013 $ 1,267 $ 1,104 $ 1,004 $ 2,167 $ 1,064 $ 1,914 Holidays $ 1,012 $ 811 $ 1,098 $ 811 $ 1,013 $ 794 $ 998 $ 1,349 Admin Leave $ 228 $ 760 $ 1,267 $ 1,055 $ 732 $ 1,566
AllowAuto $ 250 $ 250 $ 375 $ 400 $ 375 $ 250
$ 6,967 $ 7,426 $ 7,968 $ 7,278 $ 0 $ 6,229 $ 0 $ 7,065 $ 6,351 $ 0 $ 9,936 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 14 of 48 ends

165
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Financial
Contoller
[Finance
Manager/
Director of
Finance]
Assistant
Director of
Finance
[Accounting
Supervisor/
Chief Financial
Officer]
Assistant
Director of
Finance
Assistant Chief
Financial Officer
Finance
Manager
Financial
Controller
[Finance
Director/ Payroll
& Finance
Manager]
Deputy Finance
Director
[Accounting
Manager/
Revenue
Manager]
Top Step $ 14,780 $ 14,555 $ 21,965 $ 15,852 $ 17,968 $ 15,920 $ 16,114 $ 14,577 $ 15,545 $ 18,460 $ 19,005 Classic 2% @ 55 2%@55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@55 2%@60 2%@55 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 443 $ 437 $ 1,164 $ 476 $ 539 $ 207 $ 854 $ 437 $ 202 $ 554 $ 1,349 Employer Paid Member $ 1,035 $ 568 $ 1,110 $ 1,258
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐557
Single Highest Year $ 74 $ 73 $ 132 $ 90 $ 97 $ 73 $ 92 $ 133 Social Security $ 871 $ 871
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 364 $ 50 $ 317 $ 1,258 $ 347 $ 322 $ 656 $ 78 $ 738 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,550 $ 2,805 $ 1,885 $ 2,000 $ 1,155 Health $ 2,581 $ 2,625 $ 2,942 $ 2,476 $ 2,132 $ 435 $ 2,942 Dental $ 158 $ 167 $ 120 $ 138 $ 70 $ 180
Vision $ 28 $ 61 $ 26 $ 19
Other Ins.1 $ 439 $ 63
Vacation $ 853 $ 840 $ 1,267 $ 1,037 $ 1,037 $ 918 $ 1,054 $ 1,682 $ 957 $ 2,041 $ 1,279 Holidays $ 853 $ 672 $ 1,098 $ 762 $ 968 $ 926 $ 620 $ 617 $ 897 $ 1,065 $ 1,133Admin Leave $ 192 $ 630 $ 1,267 $ 415 $ 735 $ 620 $ 658 $ 355 $ 439 AllowAuto $ 250 $ 250 $ 200 $ 375
$ 6,324 $ 6,685 $ 7,968 $ 7,038 $ 8,568 $ 5,394 $ 6,180 $ 5,667 $ 6,037 $ 6,635 $ 7,425 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 15 of 48 ends

166
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Deputy City
Clerk N/C City Clerk Specialist Assistant to the City Clerk Deputy City Clerk City Clerk Specialist Deputy City Clerk Deputy City Clerk Chief Deputy City Clerk Deputy City Clerk Deputy Clerk Top Step $ 8,230 $ 9,064 $ 7,614 $ 10,005 $ 7,137 $ 7,307 $ 7,469 $ 8,965 $ 11,565 $ 8,040 Classic 2% @ 55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@55 2%@60 2%@55 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 247 $ 480 $ 228 $ 300 $ 93 $ 387 $ 224 $ 117 $ 347 $ 571 Employer Paid Member $ 576 $ 533 $ 700
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐250
Single Highest Year $ 41 $ 54 $ 50 $ 44 $ 37 $ 58 $ 56
Social Security $ 443 $ 556
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 60 $ 152 $ 700 $ 130 $ 336 $ 45 $ 463 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,450 $ 2,805 $ 1,885 $ 2,000 $ 1,155 Health $ 2,581 $ 2,942 $ 2,201 $ 2,132 $ 435 $ 2,942
Dental $ 158 $ 120 $ 123 $ 70 $ 180
Vision $ 28 $ 26 $ 19
Other Ins.1 $ 181
Vacation $ 475 $ 523 $ 498 $ 577 $ 412 $ 479 $ 862 $ 810 $ 1,279 $ 541 Holidays $ 475 $ 453 $ 366 $ 539 $ 415 $ 393 $ 316 $ 517 $ 667 $ 479Admin Leave $ 118 $ 154 $ 349 $ 222 AllowAuto $ 175
$ 4,688 $ 0 $ 4,320 $ 4,865 $ 6,001 $ 3,127 $ 3,627 $ 3,977 $ 4,394 $ 4,825 $ 4,739 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 16 of 48 ends

167
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Emergency
Services
Coordinator
N/C
Emergency
Management
Manager
Public Safety
Coordinator N/C
Emergency
Preparedness
Coordinator
Emergency
Operations
Coordinator
Emergency
Preparedness
Administrator

N/C N/C
Emergency
Management
Coordinator
Top Step $ 9,345 $ 11,602 $ 8,839 $ 10,369 $ 11,767 $ 11,925 $ 12,141 Classic 2% @ 55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@55 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 280 $ 615 $ 265 $ 135 $ 624 $ 358 $ 862 Employer Paid Member $ 654 $ 619
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐363
Single Highest Year $ 47 $ 70 $ 71 $ 60 $ 85
Social Security $ 643
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 50 $ 177 $ 347 $ 537 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,550 $ 1,885
Health $ 2,581 $ 2,942 $ 2,201 $ 2,132 $ 2,942
Dental $ 158 $ 120 $ 123 $ 70
Vision $ 28 $ 26
Other Ins.1 $ 232 $ 63
Vacation $ 539 $ 669 $ 578 $ 598 $ 771 $ 1,376 $ 817Holidays $ 539 $ 580 $ 425 $ 603 $ 634 $ 505 $ 724 Admin Leave $ 446 $ 479 $ 280
AllowAuto
$ 4,934 $ 0 $ 5,212 $ 5,151 $ 0 $ 4,389 $ 4,422 $ 5,036 $ 0 $ 0 $ 5,860 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 17 of 48 ends

168
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Environmental
Compliance
Coordinator

N/C N/C
Environmental
Services
Supervisor
N/C
[Environmental
Compliance
Inspector/
Environmental
Coordinator]
Environmental
Specialist
Water
Compliance
Supervisor

N/C N/C
Environmental
Programs
Coordinator
Top Step $ 9,765 $ 11,914 $ 10,166 $ 8,011 $ 10,252 $ 12,141 Classic 2% @ 55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@55 2.7%@55
Enhanced Formula Cost $ 293 $ 357 $ 132 $ 425 $ 308 $ 862 Employer Paid Member $ 684 $ 834
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐356
Single Highest Year $ 49 $ 48 $ 51 $ 85
Social Security $ 630
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 238 $ 347 $ 461 $ 150
Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 1,885Health $ 2,581 $ 2,942 $ 2,201 $ 2,132 $ 2,942 Dental $ 158 $ 120 $ 123 $ 70
Vision $ 28 $ 26
Other Ins. $ 63
Vacation $ 563 $ 779 $ 587 $ 525 $ 1,183 $ 817
Holidays $ 563 $ 573 $ 591 $ 431 $ 434 $ 724
Admin Leave $ 469 $ 280
AllowAuto
Benefit Package Total $ 5,027 $ 0 $ 0 $ 5,869 $ 0 $ 4,348 $ 3,752 $ 4,639 $ 0 $ 0 $ 5,860 Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 18 of 48 ends

169
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Environmental
Health
Administrator

N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C
Environmental
Programs
Coordinator
N/C
Top Step $ 11,869 $ 11,323
Classic 2% @ 55 2%@55
Enhanced Formula Cost $ 356 $ 340
Employer Paid Member $ 831
Employee Cost SharingSingle Highest Year $ 59 $ 57
Social SecurityDeferred Compensation $ 108 $ 226
Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 1,155Health $ 2,581 $ 435Dental $ 158 $ 180Vision $ 28 $ 19 Other Ins.Vacation $ 685 $ 1,252Holidays $ 685 $ 653
Admin Leave $ 49
AllowAuto
Benefit Package Total $ 5,490 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 4,366 $ 0 Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 19 of 48 ends

170
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Environmental
Programs
Manager
N/C
Environmental
Compliance and
Sustainability
Programs
Manager

N/C N/C
Environmental
Programs &
Operations
Manager
N/C
Environmental
Programs
Administrator

N/C N/C N/C
Top Step $ 13,355 $ 13,469 $ 14,626 $ 12,283
Classic 2% @ 55 2.5% @ 55 2% @ 60 2%@55
Enhanced Formula Cost $ 401 $ 714 $ 190 $ 368
Employer Paid Member $ 935
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐512
Single Highest Year $ 67 $ 81 $ 61
Social Security $ 871
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 50 $ 347 $ 553
Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,550 $ 1,885
Health $ 2,581 $ 2,132
Dental $ 158 $ 70
Vision $ 28
Other Ins.1 $ 269 $ 63
Vacation $ 770 $ 777 $ 844 $ 1,417
Holidays $ 770 $ 673 $ 851 $ 520Admin Leave $ 173 $ 518 $ 675 AllowAuto
$ 5,991 $ 0 $ 5,633 $ 0 $ 0 $ 5,213 $ 0 $ 5,122 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 20 of 48 ends

171
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Environmental
Sustainability
Analyst
N/C Management Analyst N/C N/C Management Analyst N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Top Step $ 9,765 $ 9,047 $ 9,065
Classic 2% @ 55 2.5% @ 55 2% @ 60
Enhanced Formula Cost $ 293 $ 479 $ 118
Employer Paid Member $ 684
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐317
Single Highest Year $ 49 $ 54
Social Security $ 562
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 50 $ 347
Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,550 $ 1,885
Health $ 2,581
Dental $ 158Vision $ 28Other Ins.1 $ 181 $ 63
Vacation $ 563 $ 522 $ 523Holidays $ 563 $ 452 $ 527Admin Leave $ 348 $ 418 AllowAuto
$ 5,027 $ 0 $ 4,637 $ 0 $ 0 $ 4,125 $ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0
N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 21 of 48 ends

172
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Environmental
Sustainability
Director/Building
Official
N/C
[Utilities
General
Manager/
Assistant
Director of
Community
Development/B
uilding Official]

N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C
Top Step $ 18,863 $ 21,965
Classic 2% @ 55 2.5% @ 55
Enhanced Formula Cost $ 566 $ 1,164
Employer Paid Member $ 1,320
Employee Cost SharingSingle Highest Year $ 94 $ 132
Social SecurityDeferred Compensation $ 250 $ 50
Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,550Health $ 2,581
Dental $ 158Vision $ 28Other Ins.1 $ 439
Vacation $ 1,088 $ 1,267
Holidays $ 1,088 $ 1,098Admin Leave $ 490 $ 1,267
AllowAuto
$ 7,663 $ 0 $ 7,968 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0
N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 22 of 48 ends

173
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Executive
Assistant
Executive
Assistant
Executive
Assistant
Executive
Assistant II
Executive
Assistant
Administrative
Secretary
Executive
Assistant
Executive
Assistant to the
City Manager
Executive
Assistant to
Mayor and
Council/City
Manager
Executive
Assistant
Senior
Administrative
Specialist
Top Step $ 9,968 $ 7,971 $ 7,938 $ 6,893 $ 10,005 $ 6,239 $ 8,446 $ 8,215 $ 8,216 $ 9,107 $ 9,803 Classic 2% @ 55 2%@55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@55 2%@60 2%@55 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 299 $ 239 $ 421 $ 207 $ 300 $ 81 $ 448 $ 246 $ 107 $ 273 $ 696 Employer Paid Member $ 698 $ 311 $ 482 $ 700
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐218
Single Highest Year $ 50 $ 40 $ 48 $ 50 $ 51 $ 41 $ 46 $ 69 Social Security $ 387 $ 509
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 217 $ 60 $ 138 $ 700 $ 130 $ 169 $ 370 $ 41 $ 364 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,450 $ 2,805 $ 1,885 $ 2,000 $ 1,155 Health $ 2,581 $ 2,625 $ 2,942 $ 2,476 $ 2,132 $ 435 $ 2,942 Dental $ 158 $ 167 $ 120 $ 138 $ 70 $ 180
Vision $ 28 $ 61 $ 26 $ 19
Other Ins.1 $ 159
Vacation $ 575 $ 460 $ 458 $ 451 $ 577 $ 360 $ 552 $ 948 $ 506 $ 1,007 $ 660 Holidays $ 575 $ 368 $ 397 $ 331 $ 539 $ 363 $ 325 $ 348 $ 474 $ 525 $ 584Admin Leave $ 153 $ 103 $ 325 $ 348 $ 175 AllowAuto
$ 5,071 $ 4,640 $ 4,095 $ 4,697 $ 5,672 $ 2,987 $ 4,483 $ 4,155 $ 3,984 $ 4,180 $ 5,101 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 23 of 48 ends

174
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Financial
Analyst N/C Budget and Financial Analyst Senior Accounting Specialist [Accountant II/ Financial Analyst II] Accountant II Accountant Budget and Financial Analyst [Accountant/ Administrative Analyst] Financial Analyst Accountant Top Step $ 9,765 $ 11,373 $ 7,538 $ 11,334 $ 8,371 $ 9,039 $ 10,299 $ 7,678 $ 11,211 $ 11,157 Classic 2% @ 55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@55 2%@60 2%@55 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 293 $ 603 $ 226 $ 340 $ 109 $ 479 $ 309 $ 100 $ 336 $ 792 Employer Paid Member $ 684 $ 528 $ 793
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐293
Single Highest Year $ 49 $ 68 $ 57 $ 54 $ 51 $ 56 $ 78
Social Security $ 519 $ 476
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 50 $ 151 $ 793 $ 130 $ 463 $ 38 $ 224 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,550 $ 2,805 $ 1,885 $ 2,000 $ 1,155 Health $ 2,581 $ 2,942 $ 2,201 $ 2,132 $ 435 $ 2,942
Dental $ 158 $ 120 $ 123 $ 70 $ 180
Vision $ 28 $ 26 $ 19
Other Ins.1 $ 227
Vacation $ 563 $ 656 $ 493 $ 654 $ 483 $ 592 $ 1,188 $ 694 $ 1,240 $ 751 Holidays $ 563 $ 569 $ 362 $ 610 $ 487 $ 487 $ 436 $ 443 $ 647 $ 665Admin Leave $ 437 $ 299 $ 49 $ 257 AllowAuto
$ 5,027 $ 0 $ 5,161 $ 4,847 $ 6,052 $ 3,320 $ 3,936 $ 4,650 $ 4,050 $ 4,341 $ 5,636 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 24 of 48 ends

175
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Fire Safety
Liaison N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C
Top Step $ 9,677Classic 2% @ 55Enhanced Formula Cost $ 290Employer Paid Member $ 677Employee Cost SharingSingle Highest Year $ 48Social SecurityDeferred Compensation $ 108Other Ret.CafeteriaHealth $ 2,581Dental $ 158Vision $ 28Other Ins.Vacation $ 558Holidays $ 558Admin Leave AllowAuto
Benefit Package Total $ 5,007 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 25 of 48 ends

176
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Graphic Artist N/C
[Graphic Artist/
Senior Graphic
Artist]

N/C N/C N/C N/C
Digital
Communication
s and Graphics
Coordinator
N/C N/C Digital Media Specialist
Top Step $ 6,770 $ 7,841 $ 8,915 $ 9,105
Classic 2% @ 55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2.7%@55
Enhanced Formula Cost $ 203 $ 416 $ 267 $ 646
Employer Paid Member $ 474
Employee Cost SharingSingle Highest Year $ 34 $ 47 $ 45 $ 64 Social SecurityDeferred Compensation $ 108 $ 100 $ 401 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,450Health $ 2,581 $ 2,132 $ 2,942 Dental $ 158 $ 70
Vision $ 28
Other Ins.1 $ 157
Vacation $ 391 $ 452 $ 1,029 $ 613
Holidays $ 391 $ 392 $ 377 $ 543
Admin Leave
AllowAuto
$ 4,367 $ 0 $ 4,014 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 4,321 $ 0 $ 0 $ 4,958 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 26 of 48 ends

177
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Human
Resources
Analyst
N/C
Human
Resources
Analyst
N/C
Human
Resources
Analyst
Human
Resources
Analyst
Administrative
Analyst
Human
Resources
Analyst
Human
Resources
Analyst
Associate
Human
Resources
Analyst
Human
Resources
Specialist
Top Step $ 9,073 $ 9,047 $ 11,031 $ 9,065 $ 8,011 $ 8,915 $ 10,155 $ 10,894 $ 10,951 Classic 2% @ 55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@55 2%@60 2%@55 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 272 $ 479 $ 331 $ 118 $ 425 $ 267 $ 132 $ 327 $ 778 Employer Paid Member $ 635 $ 772
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐317Single Highest Year $ 45 $ 54 $ 55 $ 48 $ 45 $ 54 $ 77 Social Security $ 562 $ 630
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 50 $ 772 $ 347 $ 401 $ 51 $ 218 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,550 $ 2,805 $ 1,885 $ 2,000 $ 1,155 Health $ 2,581 $ 2,201 $ 2,132 $ 435 $ 2,942
Dental $ 158 $ 123 $ 70 $ 180
Vision $ 28 $ 19
Other Ins.1 $ 181 $ 63
Vacation $ 523 $ 522 $ 636 $ 523 $ 525 $ 1,029 $ 625 $ 1,205 $ 737 Holidays $ 523 $ 452 $ 594 $ 527 $ 431 $ 377 $ 586 $ 629 $ 653Admin Leave $ 348 $ 170 $ 418 $ 430 $ 47 $ 253 AllowAuto
$ 4,874 $ 0 $ 4,637 $ 0 $ 6,135 $ 4,125 $ 3,752 $ 4,321 $ 4,453 $ 4,268 $ 5,589 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 27 of 48 ends

178
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Human
Resources
Manager
Human
Resources
Manager
Human
Resources
Manager
N/C
Human
Resources
Manager
Senior Human
Resources and
Equity Manager
Human
Resources
Director and
Principal HR
Analyst
Human
Resources
Manager
Human
Resources
Manager
Deputy HR
Director/Risk
Manager
Human
Resources
Supervisor
Top Step $ 11,869 $ 10,988 $ 15,027 $ 16,298 $ 15,146 $ 15,068 $ 14,577 $ 12,444 $ 14,979 $ 13,126 Classic 2% @ 55 2%@55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@55 2%@60 2%@55 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 356 $ 330 $ 796 $ 489 $ 197 $ 799 $ 437 $ 162 $ 449 $ 932 Employer Paid Member $ 831 $ 429 $ 1,141
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐530
Single Highest Year $ 59 $ 55 $ 90 $ 81 $ 90 $ 73 $ 75 $ 92 Social Security $ 871 $ 772
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 217 $ 50 $ 1,141 $ 347 $ 301 $ 656 $ 62 $ 599 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,550 $ 2,805 $ 1,885 $ 2,000 $ 1,155 Health $ 2,581 $ 2,625 $ 2,476 $ 2,132 $ 435 $ 2,942
Dental $ 158 $ 167 $ 138 $ 70 $ 180
Vision $ 28 $ 61 $ 19
Other Ins.1 $ 301 $ 63
Vacation $ 685 $ 634 $ 867 $ 940 $ 874 $ 985 $ 1,682 $ 766 $ 1,656 $ 883 Holidays $ 685 $ 507 $ 751 $ 878 $ 881 $ 580 $ 617 $ 718 $ 864 $ 783Admin Leave $ 154 $ 211 $ 578 $ 376 $ 699 $ 580 $ 526 $ 288 $ 303 AllowAuto
$ 5,644 $ 5,235 $ 5,983 $ 0 $ 7,851 $ 5,286 $ 5,949 $ 5,667 $ 5,006 $ 5,721 $ 6,085 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 28 of 48 ends

179
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Information
Systems
Analyst
N/C Network Integrator
Senior
Information
Technology
Specialist
N/C Information Systems Analyst Senior IT Analyst Network Administrator Information Technology Analyst Information Technology Analyst II Systems Engineer Top Step $ 9,073 $ 11,373 $ 8,839 $ 9,341 $ 11,767 $ 10,443 $ 8,567 $ 12,263 $ 13,125 Classic 2% @ 55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@55 2%@60 2%@55 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 272 $ 603 $ 265 $ 121 $ 624 $ 313 $ 111 $ 368 $ 932 Employer Paid Member $ 635 $ 619
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐327
Single Highest Year $ 45 $ 68 $ 71 $ 52 $ 61 $ 92
Social Security $ 579 $ 531
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 50 $ 177 $ 130 $ 43 $ 245 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,550 $ 1,885 $ 2,000 $ 1,155
Health $ 2,581 $ 2,942 $ 2,201 $ 2,183 $ 435 $ 2,942
Dental $ 158 $ 120 $ 123 $ 55 $ 180
Vision $ 28 $ 26 $ 19
Other Ins.1 $ 227
Vacation $ 523 $ 656 $ 578 $ 539 $ 771 $ 522 $ 774 $ 1,356 $ 883 Holidays $ 523 $ 569 $ 425 $ 543 $ 634 $ 562 $ 494 $ 707 $ 782Admin Leave $ 437 $ 334 $ 53 $ 303 AllowAuto
$ 4,874 $ 0 $ 5,161 $ 5,151 $ 0 $ 3,471 $ 4,422 $ 3,688 $ 4,288 $ 4,580 $ 6,084 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 29 of 48 ends

180
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Information
Systems Manager

N/C N/C
Information
Systems
Manager
Information
Systems
Manager
Systems Support
Manager
Information
Technology
Manager
Information
Systems
Manager
[Information
Technology
Director/ IT
Operations
Infrastructure
Supervisor]
Information
Technology
Manager
[Information
Technology
Manager/
Systems
Engineer
Supervisor]
Top Step $ 13,087 $ 13,695 $ 15,522 $ 14,064 $ 16,114 $ 15,013 $ 14,228 $ 16,711 $ 16,394 Classic 2% @ 55 2%@55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@55 2%@60 2%@55 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 393 $ 411 $ 466 $ 183 $ 854 $ 450 $ 185 $ 501 $ 1,164 Employer Paid Member $ 916 $ 959 $ 1,087
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐492
Single Highest Year $ 65 $ 78 $ 97 $ 75 $ 84 $ 115
Social Security $ 871 $ 871
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 274 $ 1,087 $ 347 $ 322 $ 676 $ 71 $ 668 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,805 $ 1,885 $ 2,000 $ 1,155
Health $ 2,581 $ 2,942 $ 2,476 $ 2,132 $ 435 $ 2,942
Dental $ 158 $ 120 $ 138 $ 70 $ 180
Vision $ 28 $ 26 $ 19
Other Ins. $ 63
Vacation $ 755 $ 895 $ 895 $ 811 $ 1,054 $ 1,732 $ 876 $ 1,848 $ 1,387 Holidays $ 755 $ 658 $ 836 $ 818 $ 620 $ 635 $ 821 $ 964 $ 694Admin Leave $ 170 $ 358 $ 649 $ 620 $ 602 $ 321 $ 1,135 AllowAuto $ 375
Benefit Package Total $ 5,929 $ 0 $ 0 $ 6,285 $ 7,610 $ 5,134 $ 6,180 $ 5,771 $ 5,801 $ 6,176 $ 7,586 Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 30 of 48 ends

181
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Information
Systems
Technician

N/C N/C
Information
Technology
Specialist
Information
Systems
Technician
Service Desk
Technician
Information
System
Specialist
Information
Systems
Specialist
Information
Technology
Technician
Information
Technology
Technician II
Information
Technology
Systems Analyst
Top Step $ 6,770 $ 7,244 $ 9,529 $ 6,590 $ 10,934 $ 8,816 $ 5,349 $ 7,965 $ 9,803 Classic 2% @ 55 2%@55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@55 2%@60 2%@55 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 203 $ 217 $ 286 $ 86 $ 580 $ 264 $ 70 $ 239 $ 696 Employer Paid Member $ 474 $ 507 $ 667
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐231
Single Highest Year $ 34 $ 48 $ 66 $ 44 $ 40 $ 69
Social Security $ 409 $ 332
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 145 $ 667 $ 130 $ 150 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,805 $ 1,885 $ 2,000 $ 1,155
Health $ 2,581 $ 2,942 $ 2,201 $ 2,183 $ 435 $ 2,942
Dental $ 158 $ 120 $ 123 $ 55 $ 180
Vision $ 28 $ 26 $ 19
Other Ins.Vacation $ 391 $ 474 $ 550 $ 380 $ 716 $ 441 $ 309 $ 536 $ 660 Holidays $ 391 $ 348 $ 513 $ 383 $ 589 $ 475 $ 309 $ 460 $ 584Admin Leave AllowAuto
Benefit Package Total $ 4,367 $ 0 $ 0 $ 4,779 $ 5,535 $ 3,042 $ 4,274 $ 3,462 $ 3,018 $ 3,213 $ 5,101 Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 31 of 48 ends

182
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Management
Analyst
Management
Analyst
Management
Analyst
Management
Analyst
Management
Analyst
Management
Analyst
Senior
Management
Analyst
Management
Analyst
Senior
Management
Analyst
Associate
Analyst
Management
Analyst
Top Step proposed $ 9,018 $ 9,047 $ 8,839 $ 11,031 $ 9,065 $ 11,767 $ 9,182 $ 8,206 $ 10,507 $ 12,141 Classic 2%@55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@55 2%@60 2%@55 2.7%@55Enhanced Formula Cost $ 271 $ 479 $ 265 $ 331 $ 118 $ 624 $ 275 $ 107 $ 315 $ 862 Employer Paid Member $ 352 $ 619 $ 772
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐317
Single Highest Year $ 45 $ 54 $ 55 $ 71 $ 46 $ 53 $ 85
Social Security $ 562 $ 509
Deferred Compensation $ 217 $ 50 $ 177 $ 772 $ 347 $ 413 $ 41 $ 210 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,550 $ 2,805 $ 1,885 $ 2,000 $ 1,155 Health $ 2,625 $ 2,942 $ 2,201 $ 2,132 $ 435 $ 2,942
Dental $ 167 $ 120 $ 123 $ 70 $ 180
Vision $ 61 $ 26 $ 19
Other Ins.1 $ 181 $ 63
Vacation $ 520 $ 522 $ 578 $ 636 $ 523 $ 771 $ 1,060 $ 742 $ 1,162 $ 817 Holidays $ 416 $ 452 $ 425 $ 594 $ 527 $ 634 $ 388 $ 473 $ 606 $ 724 Admin Leave $ 173 $ 348 $ 170 $ 418 $ 320 $ 45 $ 280
AllowAuto
$ 0 $ 4,847 $ 4,637 $ 5,151 $ 6,135 $ 4,125 $ 4,422 $ 4,385 $ 4,191 $ 4,180 $ 5,860 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 32 of 48 ends

183
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Media
Information
Officer
Communication
s Manager
Public
Information
Manager
N/C Community Relations Officer
Communication
s and Public
Information
Manager
[Communication
s Manager/
Digital Media
Coordinator]
[Communication
s and Civic
Manager/
Marketing &
Communication
s Coordinator]
N/C
Communication
s and Marketing
Analyst
Public
Information
Officer
Top Step $ 9,678 $ 10,988 $ 12,689 $ 13,408 $ 13,333 $ 11,565 $ 11,746 $ 9,509 $ 13,125 Classic 2% @ 55 2%@55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@55 2%@55 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 290 $ 330 $ 672 $ 402 $ 173 $ 613 $ 352 $ 285 $ 932 Employer Paid Member $ 677 $ 429 $ 939
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐467
Single Highest Year $ 48 $ 55 $ 76 $ 67 $ 69 $ 59 $ 48 $ 92 Social Security $ 827
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 217 $ 50 $ 939 $ 347 $ 529 $ 190 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,550 $ 2,805 $ 1,885 $ 1,155
Health $ 2,581 $ 2,625 $ 2,201 $ 2,132 $ 435 $ 2,942
Dental $ 158 $ 167 $ 123 $ 70 $ 180
Vision $ 28 $ 61 $ 19
Other Ins.1 $ 254 $ 63
Vacation $ 558 $ 634 $ 732 $ 774 $ 769 $ 758 $ 1,355 $ 1,051 $ 883 Holidays $ 558 $ 507 $ 634 $ 722 $ 776 $ 623 $ 497 $ 549 $ 782 Admin Leave $ 211 $ 488 $ 206 $ 615 $ 41 $ 303
AllowAuto $ 175
$ 5,007 $ 5,235 $ 5,457 $ 0 $ 7,028 $ 4,988 $ 4,386 $ 4,994 $ 0 $ 3,953 $ 6,084 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 33 of 48 ends

184
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Parks
Supervisor N/C
[Parks Services
Supervisor/
Parks
Superintendent]
Landscape
District
Maintenance
Manager
Landscape
Inspector
[Park
Maintenance
Supervisor/
Parks Manager]
Maintenance
Supervisor
Field Operations
Supervisor N/C
Landscape
Maintenance
Supervisor
Urban Forest
and Landscape
Maintenance
Supervisor
Top Step $ 9,544 $ 11,039 $ 11,914 $ 9,529 $ 10,376 $ 9,936 $ 11,329 $ 10,060 $ 12,141 Classic 2% @ 55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@55 2%@55 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 286 $ 585 $ 357 $ 286 $ 135 $ 527 $ 340 $ 302 $ 862 Employer Paid Member $ 668 $ 834 $ 667
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐363
Single Highest Year $ 48 $ 66 $ 48 $ 60 $ 57 $ 50 $ 85
Social Security $ 643
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 50 $ 238 $ 667 $ 347 $ 510 $ 402 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,550 $ 2,805 $ 1,885 $ 1,155
Health $ 2,581 $ 2,942 $ 2,201 $ 2,132 $ 435 $ 2,942
Dental $ 158 $ 120 $ 123 $ 70 $ 180
Vision $ 28 $ 26 $ 19
Other Ins.1 $ 221 $ 63
Vacation $ 551 $ 637 $ 779 $ 550 $ 599 $ 651 $ 1,307 $ 1,112 $ 817 Holidays $ 551 $ 552 $ 573 $ 513 $ 604 $ 535 $ 479 $ 580 $ 724 Admin Leave $ 425 $ 479 $ 193 $ 280
AllowAuto $ 350
$ 4,978 $ 0 $ 5,086 $ 6,219 $ 5,535 $ 4,390 $ 4,096 $ 4,895 $ 0 $ 4,430 $ 5,860 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 34 of 48 ends

185
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Permit Services
Technician
Building Permit
Technician
Development
Services
Technician II
Building
Assistant N/C Permit Technician II Permit Technician Permits Technician Building and Engineering Technician Community Development Technician II Permit Services Specialist Top Step $ 6,770 $ 6,542 $ 6,986 $ 6,893 $ 6,429 $ 6,421 $ 6,998 $ 6,520 $ 7,965 $ 8,039 Classic 2% @ 55 2%@55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@55 2%@60 2%@55 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 203 $ 196 $ 370 $ 207 $ 84 $ 340 $ 210 $ 85 $ 239 $ 571 Employer Paid Member $ 474 $ 255 $ 482
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐225
Single Highest Year $ 34 $ 33 $ 42 $ 39 $ 35 $ 40 $ 56
Social Security $ 399 $ 404
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 217 $ 100 $ 138 $ 130 $ 150 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,450 $ 1,885 $ 2,000 $ 1,155
Health $ 2,581 $ 2,625 $ 2,942 $ 2,201 $ 2,183 $ 435 $ 2,942 Dental $ 158 $ 167 $ 120 $ 123 $ 55 $ 180
Vision $ 28 $ 61 $ 26 $ 19
Other Ins.1 $ 140
Vacation $ 391 $ 377 $ 403 $ 451 $ 371 $ 421 $ 350 $ 376 $ 536 $ 541 Holidays $ 391 $ 302 $ 349 $ 331 $ 374 $ 346 $ 377 $ 376 $ 460 $ 479Admin Leave AllowAuto
$ 4,367 $ 4,233 $ 3,854 $ 4,697 $ 0 $ 3,017 $ 3,469 $ 3,209 $ 3,241 $ 3,213 $ 4,739 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 35 of 48 ends

186
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Planning
Director N/C City Planner N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C Top Step $ 17,537 $ 21,965
Classic 2% @ 55 2.5% @ 55
Enhanced Formula Cost $ 526 $ 1,164
Employer Paid Member $ 1,228
Employee Cost SharingSingle Highest Year $ 88 $ 132
Social SecurityDeferred Compensation $ 250 $ 50
Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,550Health $ 2,581
Dental $ 158Vision $ 28Other Ins.1 $ 439
Vacation $ 1,012 $ 1,267
Holidays $ 1,012 $ 1,098Admin Leave $ 455 $ 1,267
AllowAuto
$ 7,336 $ 0 $ 7,968 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0
N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 36 of 48 ends

187
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Planning
Technician
Planning
Technician
Planning
Technician N/C Planning Technician Planning Technician II Planning Technician N/C Planning Technician N/C N/C Top Step $ 7,839 $ 6,542 $ 7,343 $ 7,840 $ 7,502 $ 6,916 $ 6,191 Classic 2% @ 55 2%@55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@60 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 235 $ 196 $ 389 $ 235 $ 98 $ 367 $ 80 Employer Paid Member $ 549 $ 255 $ 549
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐263
Single Highest Year $ 39 $ 33 $ 44 $ 39 $ 42
Social Security $ 465 $ 384
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 217 $ 100 $ 549 $ 130
Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,450 $ 2,805 $ 1,885 $ 2,000
Health $ 2,581 $ 2,625 $ 2,201
Dental $ 158 $ 167 $ 123
Vision $ 28 $ 61
Other Ins.1 $ 147
Vacation $ 452 $ 377 $ 424 $ 452 $ 433 $ 453 $ 357
Holidays $ 452 $ 302 $ 367 $ 422 $ 436 $ 372 $ 357Admin Leave AllowAuto
$ 4,602 $ 4,233 $ 3,921 $ 0 $ 5,051 $ 3,184 $ 3,557 $ 0 $ 3,179 $ 0 $ 0 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 37 of 48 ends

188
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Public Safety
Coordinator N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C
[Public Safety
Manager/
Specialist]
Top Step $ 9,678 $ 14,056
Classic 2% @ 55 2.7%@55
Enhanced Formula Cost $ 290 $ 998
Employer Paid Member $ 677
Employee Cost SharingSingle Highest Year $ 48 $ 98
Social SecurityDeferred Compensation $ 108 $ 150
Other Ret.CafeteriaHealth $ 2,581 $ 2,942Dental $ 158
Vision $ 28Other Ins.Vacation $ 558 $ 1,189
Holidays $ 558 $ 595Admin Leave $ 973
AllowAuto
Benefit Package Total $ 5,007 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 6,945 Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 38 of 48 ends

189
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Public Safety
Director N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C
Director of
Community
Safety
Top Step $ 17,537 $ 22,623
Classic 2% @ 55 2.7%@55
Enhanced Formula Cost $ 526 $ 1,606
Employer Paid Member $ 1,228
Employee Cost SharingSingle Highest Year $ 88 $ 158
Social SecurityDeferred Compensation $ 250 $ 150Other Ret.CafeteriaHealth $ 2,581 $ 2,942Dental $ 158 Vision $ 28Other Ins.Vacation $ 1,012 $ 1,914
Holidays $ 1,012 $ 1,349Admin Leave $ 455 $ 1,566
AllowAuto $ 250
Benefit Package Total $ 7,336 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 9,936 Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 39 of 48 ends

190
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Public Works
Director/City
Engineer
Director of
Public
Works/City
Engineer
Assistant
Director of
Public
Works/City
Engineer
Public Works
Director/City
Engineer
Director of
Public Works N/C Director of Public Works Public Works Director Public Works Director Deputy Public
Works
Director/City
Engineer
Director of
Public Works
Top Step $ 18,863 $ 17,566 $ 21,965 $ 19,791 $ 21,841 $ 20,494 $ 18,778 $ 17,291 $ 20,595 $ 23,802 Classic 2% @ 55 2%@55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2%@55 2.5%@55 2%@55 2%@60 2%@55 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 566 $ 527 $ 1,164 $ 594 $ 655 $ 1,086 $ 563 $ 225 $ 618 $ 1,690 Employer Paid Member $ 1,320 $ 685 $ 1,385 $ 1,529
Employee Cost SharingSingle Highest Year $ 94 $ 88 $ 132 $ 109 $ 123 $ 94 $ 103 $ 167 Social Security $ 871Deferred Compensation $ 250 $ 439 $ 50 $ 396 $ 2,184 $ 410 $ 845 $ 86 $ 824 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,550 $ 2,805 $ 2,000 $ 1,155
Health $ 2,581 $ 2,625 $ 2,942 $ 2,476 $ 2,132 $ 435 $ 2,942 Dental $ 158 $ 167 $ 120 $ 138 $ 70 $ 180
Vision $ 28 $ 61 $ 26 $ 19
Other Ins.1 $ 439
Vacation $ 1,088 $ 1,013 $ 1,267 $ 1,294 $ 1,260 $ 1,340 $ 2,167 $ 1,064 $ 2,277 $ 2,014 Holidays $ 1,088 $ 811 $ 1,098 $ 951 $ 1,176 $ 788 $ 794 $ 998 $ 1,188 $ 1,419 Admin Leave $ 490 $ 760 $ 1,267 $ 672 $ 788 $ 732 $ 396 $ 1,648 AllowAuto $ 250 $ 250 $ 250 $ 400 $ 400 $ 250
$ 7,663 $ 7,426 $ 7,968 $ 7,958 $ 10,640 $ 0 $ 7,549 $ 7,065 $ 5,976 $ 7,195 $ 10,279 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 40 of 48 ends

191
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Public Works
Inspector N/C Public Works Inspector I Senior Public Works Inspector N/C Public Works Inspector N/C Public Works Inspector Public Works Inspector Construction Inspector II Public Works Inspector Top Step $ 8,034 $ 8,440 $ 8,839 $ 7,539 $ 8,043 $ 6,714 $ 8,800 $ 10,951 Classic 2% @ 55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2%@55 2%@60 2%@55 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 241 $ 447 $ 265 $ 98 $ 241 $ 87 $ 264 $ 778 Employer Paid Member $ 562 $ 619
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐264
Single Highest Year $ 40 $ 51 $ 40 $ 44 $ 77
Social Security $ 467 $ 416
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 100 $ 177 $ 130 $ 150 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,450 $ 1,885 $ 2,000 $ 1,155
Health $ 2,581 $ 2,942 $ 2,183 $ 435 $ 2,942
Dental $ 158 $ 120 $ 55 $ 180
Vision $ 28 $ 26 $ 19
Other Ins.1 $ 169
Vacation $ 463 $ 487 $ 578 $ 435 $ 402 $ 387 $ 592 $ 737 Holidays $ 463 $ 422 $ 425 $ 439 $ 433 $ 387 $ 508 $ 653Admin Leave AllowAuto
$ 4,645 $ 0 $ 4,126 $ 5,151 $ 0 $ 3,190 $ 0 $ 3,354 $ 3,278 $ 3,347 $ 5,336 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 41 of 48 ends

192
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Public Works
Superintendent N/C
[Public Works
Manager/
Maintenance
Superintendent]
Public Works
Superintendent
Maintenance
Superintendent
Maintenance
Operations
Manager
N/C Maintenance Manager
[Public Works
Superintendent/
Public Works
Manager]
Public Works
Superintendent
Facilities and
Landscape
Superintendent
Top Step $ 13,354 $ 11,894 $ 11,914 $ 14,079 $ 13,305 $ 14,576 $ 9,182 $ 15,434 $ 13,126 Classic 2% @ 55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2%@55 2%@60 2%@55 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 401 $ 630 $ 357 $ 422 $ 173 $ 437 $ 119 $ 463 $ 932 Employer Paid Member $ 935 $ 834 $ 986
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐466
Single Highest Year $ 67 $ 71 $ 70 $ 73 $ 77 $ 92
Social Security $ 825 $ 569
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 50 $ 238 $ 986 $ 347 $ 656 $ 46 $ 617 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,550 $ 2,805 $ 1,885 $ 2,000 $ 1,155 Health $ 2,581 $ 2,942 $ 2,132 $ 435 $ 2,942
Dental $ 158 $ 120 $ 70 $ 180
Vision $ 28 $ 26 $ 19
Other Ins.1 $ 238 $ 63
Vacation $ 770 $ 686 $ 779 $ 812 $ 768 $ 1,682 $ 830 $ 1,707 $ 883 Holidays $ 770 $ 595 $ 573 $ 758 $ 774 $ 617 $ 530 $ 890 $ 783Admin Leave $ 173 $ 457 $ 325 $ 614 $ 358 $ 297 $ 303 AllowAuto
$ 5,991 $ 0 $ 5,278 $ 5,869 $ 7,164 $ 4,982 $ 0 $ 5,667 $ 4,452 $ 5,840 $ 6,085 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 42 of 48 ends

193
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Recreation
Manager
Recreation
Manager
Recreation
Services
Manager
Recreation
Manager N/C
Recreation and
Community
Services
Manager
N/C Recreation Manager
Recreation,
Youth, Senior
and Family
Services
Manager
N/C
Recreation
Services
Manager
Top Step $ 11,130 $ 10,988 $ 13,073 $ 11,914 $ 13,108 $ 12,283 $ 9,182 $ 19,005 Classic 2% @ 55 2%@55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2%@55 2%@60 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 334 $ 330 $ 693 $ 357 $ 170 $ 368 $ 119 $ 1,349 Employer Paid Member $ 779 $ 429 $ 834
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐459
Single Highest Year $ 56 $ 55 $ 78 $ 61 $ 133
Social Security $ 813 $ 569
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 217 $ 50 $ 238 $ 347 $ 553 $ 46 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,550 $ 1,885 $ 2,000
Health $ 2,581 $ 2,625 $ 2,942 $ 2,132 $ 2,942
Dental $ 158 $ 167 $ 120 $ 70
Vision $ 28 $ 61 $ 26
Other Ins.1 $ 261 $ 63
Vacation $ 642 $ 634 $ 754 $ 779 $ 756 $ 1,417 $ 830 $ 1,608 Holidays $ 642 $ 507 $ 654 $ 573 $ 763 $ 520 $ 530 $ 804Admin Leave $ 144 $ 211 $ 503 $ 605 $ 358 $ 1,316 AllowAuto
$ 5,472 $ 5,235 $ 5,543 $ 5,869 $ 0 $ 4,942 $ 0 $ 5,122 $ 4,452 $ 0 $ 8,302 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 43 of 48 ends

194
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Recreation
Supervisor
Recreation
Supervisor
Recreation
Supervisor
Recreation
Supervisor N/C
Recreation and
Community
Services
Supervisor
Recreation
Supervisor
Recreation
Supervisor
Recreation
Supervisor N/C Recreation Supervisor
Top Step $ 9,678 $ 8,798 $ 8,465 $ 8,839 $ 8,886 $ 9,039 $ 7,848 $ 7,430 $ 12,141 Classic 2% @ 55 2%@55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@55 2%@60 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 290 $ 264 $ 449 $ 265 $ 116 $ 479 $ 235 $ 97 $ 862 Employer Paid Member $ 677 $ 343 $ 619
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐311
Single Highest Year $ 48 $ 44 $ 51 $ 54 $ 39 $ 85
Social Security $ 551 $ 461
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 217 $ 100 $ 177 $ 347 $ 37 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,450 $ 1,885 $ 2,000
Health $ 2,581 $ 2,625 $ 2,942 $ 2,201 $ 2,183 $ 2,942
Dental $ 158 $ 167 $ 120 $ 123 $ 55
Vision $ 28 $ 61 $ 26
Other Ins.1 $ 169 $ 63
Vacation $ 558 $ 508 $ 488 $ 578 $ 513 $ 592 $ 392 $ 672 $ 817 Holidays $ 558 $ 406 $ 423 $ 425 $ 517 $ 487 $ 423 $ 429 $ 724Admin Leave $ 169 $ 410 $ 289 $ 280 AllowAuto
$ 5,007 $ 4,803 $ 4,130 $ 5,151 $ 0 $ 4,089 $ 3,936 $ 3,327 $ 3,984 $ 0 $ 5,860 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 44 of 48 ends

195
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Senior
Maintenance
Worker
N/C
[Facilities
Maintenance
Mechanic/
Street
Maintenance
Technician]
Maintenance
Technician II
Public Works
Maintenance
Worker III
[Facilities
Maintenance
Crew Leader/
Park
Maintenance
Crew Leader]
Maintenance
Lead Worker
Lead
Maintenance
Worker
Parks
Maintenance
Leadworker
Senior Building
Maintenance
Technician
Senior
Maintenance
Technician
Top Step $ 7,968 $ 7,198 $ 6,056 $ 7,111 $ 7,137 $ 8,217 $ 7,104 $ 6,147 $ 7,576 $ 8,039 Classic 2% @ 55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2%@55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@55 2%@60 2%@55 2.7%@55 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 239 $ 381 $ 182 $ 213 $ 93 $ 436 $ 213 $ 80 $ 227 $ 571 Employer Paid Member $ 558 $ 424 $ 498
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐250
Single Highest Year $ 40 $ 43 $ 36 $ 49 $ 36 $ 38 $ 56
Social Security $ 443 $ 381
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 100 $ 121 $ 498 $ 130 $ 150 $ 150 Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,450 $ 2,805 $ 1,885 $ 2,000 $ 1,155 Health $ 2,581 $ 2,942 $ 2,201 $ 2,183 $ 435 $ 2,942
Dental $ 158 $ 120 $ 123 $ 55 $ 180
Vision $ 28 $ 26 $ 19
Other Ins.1 $ 144
Vacation $ 460 $ 415 $ 396 $ 410 $ 412 $ 538 $ 355 $ 402 $ 510 $ 541 Holidays $ 460 $ 360 $ 291 $ 383 $ 415 $ 442 $ 383 $ 355 $ 437 $ 479Admin Leave AllowAuto
$ 4,631 $ 0 $ 3,894 $ 4,501 $ 4,842 $ 3,127 $ 3,789 $ 3,224 $ 3,218 $ 3,151 $ 4,739 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 45 of 48 ends

196
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Senior Office
Assistant
Administrative
Aide
Office Assistant
II N/C N/C Administrative Clerk Senior Office Specialist Office Assistant Office Specialist III N/C N/C Top Step $ 5,996 $ 6,542 $ 6,215 $ 5,118 $ 5,996 $ 5,196 $ 4,612 Classic 2% @ 55 2%@55 2.5% @ 55 2% @ 60 2.5%@55 2%@55 2%@60 Enhanced Formula Cost $ 180 $ 196 $ 329 $ 67 $ 318 $ 156 $ 60 Employer Paid Member $ 420 $ 255
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐179
Single Highest Year $ 30 $ 33 $ 37 $ 36 $ 26
Social Security $ 317 $ 286
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 217 $ 100 $ 130
Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,450 $ 1,885 $ 2,000
Health $ 2,581 $ 2,625 $ 2,201 $ 2,183
Dental $ 158 $ 167 $ 123 $ 55
Vision $ 28 $ 61
Other Ins.1 $ 124
Vacation $ 346 $ 377 $ 359 $ 295 $ 393 $ 260 $ 266
Holidays $ 346 $ 302 $ 311 $ 298 $ 323 $ 280 $ 266Admin Leave AllowAuto
$ 4,196 $ 4,233 $ 3,710 $ 0 $ 0 $ 2,813 $ 3,393 $ 2,959 $ 2,878 $ 0 $ 0 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 46 of 48 ends

197
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Supervising
Permit Services
Technician
N/C Permit Center Supervisor Permit Center Supervisor N/C N/C Permit Supervisor N/C N/C N/C N/C Top Step $ 8,416 $ 9,166 $ 7,614 $ 9,039
Classic 2% @ 55 2.5% @ 55 2%@55 2.5%@55
Enhanced Formula Cost $ 252 $ 486 $ 228 $ 479
Employer Paid Member $ 589 $ 533
Employee Cost SharingSingle Highest Year $ 42 $ 55 $ 54 Social SecurityDeferred Compensation $ 108 $ 100 $ 152
Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 2,450Health $ 2,581 $ 2,942 $ 2,201 Dental $ 158 $ 120 $ 123
Vision $ 28 $ 26Other Ins.1 $ 183
Vacation $ 486 $ 529 $ 498 $ 592Holidays $ 486 $ 458 $ 366 $ 487Admin Leave AllowAuto
$ 4,729 $ 0 $ 4,261 $ 4,865 $ 0 $ 0 $ 3,936 $ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0 N/C - Non Comparator1 - City of Beverly Hills: Wellness Pay Benefit Package Total
Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 47 of 48 ends

198
City of Malibu
Market Benefit Detail
March 2024
Appendix II (c)
City of Malibu City of Agoura Hills City of Beverly Hills City of Calabasas City of Camarillo City of Culver City City of Laguna Beach City of Manhattan Beach City of Redondo Beach City of Thousand Oaks City of West Hollywood Wastewater
Management
Program
Specialist
N/C N/C N/C N/C Associate Analyst N/C N/C N/C N/C N/C
Top Step $ 8,189 $ 7,502
Classic 2% @ 55 2% @ 60
Enhanced Formula Cost $ 246 $ 98
Employer Paid Member $ 573
Employee Cost Sharing $ ‐263
Single Highest Year $ 41
Social Security $ 465
Deferred Compensation $ 108 $ 130
Other Ret.Cafeteria $ 1,885Health $ 2,581
Dental $ 158Vision $ 28Other Ins.Vacation $ 472 $ 433
Holidays $ 472 $ 436Admin Leave
AllowAuto
Benefit Package Total $ 4,679 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 0 $ 3,184 $ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0 Agency
Benchmark/ Comparator Agency Match
Retirement Insurance Leaves

Page 48 of 48 ends

199
© 2024 Arthur J. Gallagher & Co. 3
Appendix III
Proposed Salary Range Schedule
© 2024 Arthur J. Gallagher & Co
200
City of Malibu
Proposed Salary Schedule
March 2024
Appendix III
Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4 Step 5 Step 6 Step 7 Step 8 Step 9 Step 10 Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4 Step 5 Step 6 Step 7 Step 8 Step 9 Step 10 1 36,399 37,491 38,615 39,774 40,967 42,196 43,462 44,766 46,109 47,492 3,033 3,124 3,218 3,314 3,414 3,516 3,622 3,730 3,842 3,958 2 38,219 39,365 40,546 41,763 43,015 44,306 45,635 47,004 48,414 49,867 3,185 3,280 3,379 3,480 3,585 3,692 3,803 3,917 4,035 4,1563 40,130 41,333 42,573 43,851 45,166 46,521 47,917 49,354 50,835 52,360 3,344 3,444 3,548 3,654 3,764 3,877 3,993 4,113 4,236 4,3634 42,136 43,400 44,702 46,043 47,425 48,847 50,313 51,822 53,377 54,978 3,511 3,617 3,725 3,837 3,952 4,071 4,193 4,319 4,448 4,5825 44,243 45,570 46,937 48,345 49,796 51,290 52,828 54,413 56,046 57,727 3,687 3,798 3,911 4,029 4,150 4,274 4,402 4,534 4,670 4,8116 46,455 47,849 49,284 50,763 52,286 53,854 55,470 57,134 58,848 60,613 3,871 3,987 4,107 4,230 4,357 4,488 4,622 4,761 4,904 5,0517 48,778 50,241 51,748 53,301 54,900 56,547 58,243 59,990 61,790 63,644 4,065 4,187 4,312 4,442 4,575 4,712 4,854 4,999 5,149 5,3048 51,217 52,753 54,336 55,966 57,645 59,374 61,155 62,990 64,880 66,826 4,268 4,396 4,528 4,664 4,804 4,948 5,096 5,249 5,407 5,5699 53,777 55,391 57,053 58,764 60,527 62,343 64,213 66,140 68,124 70,167 4,481 4,616 4,754 4,897 5,044 5,195 5,351 5,512 5,677 5,847 10 56,466 58,160 59,905 61,702 63,553 65,460 67,424 69,446 71,530 73,676 4,706 4,847 4,992 5,142 5,296 5,455 5,619 5,787 5,961 6,14011 59,290 61,068 62,900 64,787 66,731 68,733 70,795 72,919 75,106 77,360 4,941 5,089 5,242 5,399 5,561 5,728 5,900 6,077 6,259 6,44712 62,254 64,122 66,045 68,027 70,068 72,170 74,335 76,565 78,862 81,228 5,188 5,343 5,504 5,669 5,839 6,014 6,195 6,380 6,572 6,76913 65,367 67,328 69,348 71,428 73,571 75,778 78,051 80,393 82,805 85,289 5,447 5,611 5,779 5,952 6,131 6,315 6,504 6,699 6,900 7,10714 68,635 70,694 72,815 75,000 77,250 79,567 81,954 84,413 86,945 89,553 5,720 5,891 6,068 6,250 6,437 6,631 6,830 7,034 7,245 7,46315 72,067 74,229 76,456 78,750 81,112 83,545 86,052 88,633 91,292 94,031 6,006 6,186 6,371 6,562 6,759 6,962 7,171 7,386 7,608 7,83616 75,670 77,940 80,279 82,687 85,168 87,723 90,354 93,065 95,857 98,733 6,306 6,495 6,690 6,891 7,097 7,310 7,530 7,755 7,988 8,22817 79,454 81,837 84,293 86,821 89,426 92,109 94,872 97,718 100,650 103,669 6,621 6,820 7,024 7,235 7,452 7,676 7,906 8,143 8,387 8,63918 83,427 85,929 88,507 91,162 93,897 96,714 99,616 102,604 105,682 108,853 6,952 7,161 7,376 7,597 7,825 8,060 8,301 8,550 8,807 9,07119 87,598 90,226 92,933 95,721 98,592 101,550 104,596 107,734 110,966 114,295 7,300 7,519 7,744 7,977 8,216 8,462 8,716 8,978 9,247 9,52520 91,978 94,737 97,579 100,507 103,522 106,627 109,826 113,121 116,515 120,010 7,665 7,895 8,132 8,376 8,627 8,886 9,152 9,427 9,710 10,00121 96,577 99,474 102,458 105,532 108,698 111,959 115,318 118,777 122,340 126,011 8,048 8,289 8,538 8,794 9,058 9,330 9,610 9,898 10,195 10,50122 101,405 104,448 107,581 110,808 114,133 117,557 121,083 124,716 128,457 132,311 8,450 8,704 8,965 9,234 9,511 9,796 10,090 10,393 10,705 11,02623 106,476 109,670 112,960 116,349 119,839 123,435 127,138 130,952 134,880 138,927 8,873 9,139 9,413 9,696 9,987 10,286 10,595 10,913 11,240 11,57724 111,800 115,153 118,608 122,166 125,831 129,606 133,494 137,499 141,624 145,873 9,317 9,596 9,884 10,181 10,486 10,801 11,125 11,458 11,802 12,15625 117,389 120,911 124,539 128,275 132,123 136,087 140,169 144,374 148,705 153,167 9,782 10,076 10,378 10,690 11,010 11,341 11,681 12,031 12,392 12,76426 123,259 126,957 130,765 134,688 138,729 142,891 147,178 151,593 156,141 160,825 10,272 10,580 10,897 11,224 11,561 11,908 12,265 12,633 13,012 13,40227 129,422 133,305 137,304 141,423 145,665 150,035 154,537 159,173 163,948 168,866 10,785 11,109 11,442 11,785 12,139 12,503 12,878 13,264 13,662 14,07228 135,893 139,970 144,169 148,494 152,949 157,537 162,263 167,131 172,145 177,310 11,324 11,664 12,014 12,374 12,746 13,128 13,522 13,928 14,345 14,77629 142,688 146,968 151,377 155,919 160,596 165,414 170,377 175,488 180,752 186,175 11,891 12,247 12,615 12,993 13,383 13,785 14,198 14,624 15,063 15,51530 149,822 154,317 158,946 163,715 168,626 173,685 178,895 184,262 189,790 195,484 12,485 12,860 13,246 13,643 14,052 14,474 14,908 15,355 15,816 16,29031 157,313 162,033 166,894 171,900 177,057 182,369 187,840 193,475 199,280 205,258 13,109 13,503 13,908 14,325 14,755 15,197 15,653 16,123 16,607 17,10532 165,179 170,134 175,238 180,495 185,910 191,487 197,232 203,149 209,244 215,521 13,765 14,178 14,603 15,041 15,493 15,957 16,436 16,929 17,437 17,96033 173,438 178,641 184,000 189,520 195,206 201,062 207,094 213,307 219,706 226,297 14,453 14,887 15,333 15,793 16,267 16,755 17,258 17,776 18,309 18,85834 182,110 187,573 193,200 198,996 204,966 211,115 217,448 223,972 230,691 237,612 15,176 15,631 16,100 16,583 17,080 17,593 18,121 18,664 19,224 19,80135 191,215 196,952 202,860 208,946 215,214 221,671 228,321 235,170 242,226 249,492 15,935 16,413 16,905 17,412 17,935 18,473 19,027 19,598 20,185 20,79136 200,776 206,799 213,003 219,393 225,975 232,754 239,737 246,929 254,337 261,967 16,731 17,233 17,750 18,283 18,831 19,396 19,978 20,577 21,195 21,83137 210,815 217,139 223,653 230,363 237,274 244,392 251,724 259,275 267,054 275,065 17,568 18,095 18,638 19,197 19,773 20,366 20,977 21,606 22,254 22,92238 221,355 227,996 234,836 241,881 249,137 256,612 264,310 272,239 280,406 288,819 18,446 19,000 19,570 20,157 20,761 21,384 22,026 22,687 23,367 24,06839 232,423 239,396 246,578 253,975 261,594 269,442 277,525 285,851 294,427 303,259 19,369 19,950 20,548 21,165 21,800 22,454 23,127 23,821 24,536 25,27240 244,044 251,366 258,907 266,674 274,674 282,914 291,402 300,144 309,148 318,422 20,337 20,947 21,576 22,223 22,890 23,576 24,283 25,012 25,762 26,53541 256,247 263,934 271,852 280,007 288,408 297,060 305,972 315,151 324,605 334,344 21,354 21,994 22,654 23,334 24,034 24,755 25,498 26,263 27,050 27,86242 269,059 277,131 285,445 294,008 302,828 311,913 321,270 330,908 340,836 351,061 22,422 23,094 23,787 24,501 25,236 25,993 26,773 27,576 28,403 29,25543 282,512 290,987 299,717 308,708 317,970 327,509 337,334 347,454 357,877 368,614 23,543 24,249 24,976 25,726 26,497 27,292 28,111 28,954 29,823 30,71844 296,637 305,537 314,703 324,144 333,868 343,884 354,201 364,827 375,771 387,044 24,720 25,461 26,225 27,012 27,822 28,657 29,517 30,402 31,314 32,25445 311,469 320,813 330,438 340,351 350,561 361,078 371,911 383,068 394,560 406,397 25,956 26,734 27,536 28,363 29,213 30,090 30,993 31,922 32,880 33,866 Salary
Range
Annually Monthly

Page 1 of 1 ends

201
© 2024 Arthur J. Gallagher & Co. 4
Appendix IV
Salary Range Placement Recommendations
© 2024 Arthur J. Gallagher & Co
202
City of Malibu
Proposed Salary Plan
March 2024
Appendix IV
Proposed Classification Title
Current
Maximum
Monthly
Salary
% from
Target
Market
Market
Placement
Proposed
Salary
Range
Proposed
Maximum
Monthly
Salary
Percent
Difference
Study
Benchmark Rationale
Accounting Assistant $5,894 ‐‐ 12 $6,769 14.84% Set 15% below Accounting Technician Accounting Technician $7,465 ‐5.6% $7,880 15 $7,836 4.96% x Set to marketAdministrative Assistant $6,892 ‐8.0% $7,445 14 $7,463 8.28% x Set to marketAssistant City Clerk $11,353 ‐‐ 23 $11,577 1.98% Set 25% above Deputy City Clerk Assistant City Manager $19,802 ‐27.8% $25,312 38 $24,068 21.55% x Set 10% above PW Director Assistant Engineer $10,254 ‐‐ 22 $11,026 7.53% Set 10% below Associate Engineer Assistant Planner $8,304 ‐‐ 19 $9,525 14.70% Set 15% below Associate Planner Assistant Planning Director $15,150 ‐7.4% $16,266 30 $16,290 7.53% x Set to marketAssistant Public Works Director/Asst City Engineer $15,150 ‐‐ 30 $16,290 7.53% Set equal to Assistant Planning Director Assistant to the City Manager $11,353 ‐‐ 25 $12,764 12.43% Set 10% above Senior Management Analyst Associate Engineer $11,869 ‐2.3% $12,143 24 $12,156 2.42% x Set to marketAssociate Planner $9,743 ‐11.9% $10,905 22 $11,026 13.17% x Set to marketBuilding Inspector $8,230 ‐14.7% $9,442 19 $9,525 15.73% x Set to market a Certified Plans Examiner $10,813 ‐‐ 22 $11,026 1.97% Set 15% below Plan Check Engineer City Clerk $13,741 ‐29.0% $17,720 31 $17,105 24.48% x Set to marketCode Enforcement Manager $13,087 ‐2.2% $13,380 26 $13,402 2.41% x Set to market Code Enforcement Officer $8,230 ‐8.5% $8,932 18 $9,071 10.21% x Set to marketCommunity Services Deputy Director $15,150 ‐‐ 28 $14,776 ‐2.47% Set 10% above Recreation Manager Community Services Director $17,537 ‐10.2% $19,323 34 $19,801 12.91% x Set to marketDeputy City Clerk $8,230 ‐7.5% $8,844 18 $9,071 10.21% x Set to market Deputy City Manager $19,430 ‐‐ 36 $21,831 12.36% Set 10% below Assistant City Manager Development and Operations Manager $13,087 ‐‐ 26 $13,402 2.41% Set to currentEmergency Services Coordinator $9,345 ‐37.5% $12,853 23 $11,577 23.88% x Set to market Environmental Compliance Coordinator $9,765 ‐15.5% $11,277 23 $11,577 18.56% x Set to market Environmental Health Administrator $11,869 ‐ ‐ 24 $12,156 2.42% x Set 20% below Environmental Programs Manager

Page 1 of 4 ends

203
City of Malibu
Proposed Salary Plan
March 2024
Appendix IV
Proposed Classification Title
Current
Maximum
Monthly
Salary
% from
Target
Market
Market
Placement
Proposed
Salary
Range
Proposed
Maximum
Monthly
Salary
Percent
Difference
Study
Benchmark Rationale
Environmental Programs Manager $13,355 ‐ ‐ 28 $14,776 10.64% x Set 10% below Assistant Planning Director Environmental Programs Specialist $8,189 ‐‐ 19 $9,525 16.31% Set 20% below Environmental Compliance Coordinator Environmental Sustainability Analyst $9,765 ‐ 21 $10,501 7.54% x Set equal to Management Analyst Environmental Sustainability
Director/Building Official $18,863 ‐‐ 36 $21,831 15.73% x Set equal to Public Works Director Environmental Sustainability Manager/Dep
Building Official $15,150 ‐ 30 $16,290 7.53% Set equal to Assistant Public Works Director Executive Assistant $9,968 9.3% $9,037 20 $10,001 0.33% x Set to currentFinancial Analyst $9,765 ‐16.0% $11,329 22 $11,026 12.91% x Set to market Financial Controller $14,780 ‐19.2% $17,619 32 $17,960 21.52% x Set to marketFire Safety Liaison $9,678 ‐ 21 $10,501 8.51% x Set equal to Public Safety Coordinator Grants Analyst $9,073 ‐‐ 21 $10,501 15.74% Set equal to Management Analyst Graphic Artist $6,770 ‐‐ 16 $8,228 21.52% x Set 5% below Management Assistant Human Resources Analyst $9,073 ‐16.5% $10,571 21 $10,501 15.74% x Set to market Human Resources Manager $11,869 ‐38.8% $16,477 30 $16,290 37.25% x Set to market Human Resources Technician $7,410 ‐‐ 17 $8,639 16.58% Set 20% below HR Analyst Information Systems Administrator $11,869 ‐‐ 26 $13,402 12.92% Set 10% above IT Analyst Information Systems Analyst $9,073 ‐32.3% $11,999 23 $11,577 27.60% x Set to market Information Systems Manager $13,087 ‐28.3% $16,794 30 $16,290 24.48% x Set to market Information Systems Technician $6,770 ‐36.3% $9,230 18 $9,071 33.98% x Set to marketMaintenance Technician $6,892 ‐‐ 14 $7,463 8.28% Set 10% below Sr Maintenance Technician Management Analyst $9,073 ‐10.9% $10,063 21 $10,501 15.74% x Set to market Management Specialist proposed ‐‐ 17 $8,639 ‐ Set 20% below Management Analyst Media Analyst $9,073 ‐‐ 21 $10,501 15.74% Set equal to Management Analyst Media Information Officer $9,678 ‐‐ 24 $12,156 25.61% Set 10% below Public Information Officer Media Production Technician $6,770 ‐‐ 16 $8,228 21.52% Set 10% below Information Technician Office Assistant $5,178 ‐‐ 8 $5,569 7.54% Set 10% below Sr Office Assistant

Page 2 of 4 ends

204
City of Malibu
Proposed Salary Plan
March 2024
Appendix IV
Proposed Classification Title
Current
Maximum
Monthly
Salary
% from
Target
Market
Market
Placement
Proposed
Salary
Range
Proposed
Maximum
Monthly
Salary
Percent
Difference
Study
Benchmark Rationale
Parks Supervisor $9,544 ‐23.4% $11,779 23 $11,577 21.30% x Set to marketPermit Services Technician $6,770 ‐12.0% $7,582 14 $7,463 10.23% x Set to market Plan Check Engineer proposed ‐‐ 25 $12,764 ‐ Set 5% above Associate EngineerPlanning Director $17,537 ‐‐ 34 $19,801 12.91% x Set equal to Community Services Director Planning Technician $7,839 0.0% $7,582 17 $8,639 10.21% x Set 10% below Assistant Planner Pool Manager $4,582 ‐‐ 11 $6,447 40.71% Set 20% below Recreation Coordinator Principal Planner $11,869 ‐‐ 26 $13,402 12.92% Set 10% above Senior Planner Public Information Officer proposed ‐ $13,439 26 $13,402 ‐ x Set to market Public Safety Coordinator $9,678 ‐‐ 21 $10,501 8.51% x Set equal to Management Analyst Public Safety Director $17,537 ‐‐ 34 $19,801 12.91% x Set equal to Community Services Director Public Safety Manager $13,354 ‐ ‐ 28 $14,776 10.65% Set 30% below Public Safety Director Public Safety Specialist $6,471 ‐‐ 17 $8,639 33.51% Set equal to Management Assistant Public Works Director/City Engineer $18,863 ‐19.5% $22,543 36 $21,831 15.73% x Set to market Public Works Inspector $8,034 ‐15.6% $9,284 19 $9,525 18.56% x Set to marketPublic Works Superintendent $13,354 ‐8.9% $14,537 28 $14,776 10.65% x Set to market Records Management Specialist $6,471 ‐‐ 14 $7,463 15.33% Set equal to Administrative Assistant Recreation Coordinator $7,651 ‐‐ 15 $7,836 2.42% Set 10% below Senior Recreation Coordinator Recreation Manager $11,130 ‐21.4% $13,511 26 $13,402 20.41% x Set to market Recreation Supervisor $9,678 ‐0.2% $9,701 20 $10,001 3.34% x Set to marketSenior Accounting Technician $8,585 ‐‐ 17 $8,639 0.63% Set 10% above Accounting Technician Senior Administrative Assistant $7,839 ‐‐ 16 $8,228 4.97% Set 10% above Administrative Assistant Senior Building Inspector $9,527 ‐‐ 21 $10,501 10.22% Set 10% above Building InspectorSenior Civil Engineer $13,741 ‐‐ 27 $14,072 2.41% Set 15% above Associate Engineer Senior Code Enforcement Officer $9,527 ‐‐ 20 $10,001 4.98% Set 10% above Code Enforcement Officer Senior Maintenance Technician $7,968 1.5% $7,851 16 $8,228 3.26% x Set to market

Page 3 of 4 ends

205
City of Malibu
Proposed Salary Plan
March 2024
Appendix IV
Proposed Classification Title
Current
Maximum
Monthly
Salary
% from
Target
Market
Market
Placement
Proposed
Salary
Range
Proposed
Maximum
Monthly
Salary
Percent
Difference
Study
Benchmark Rationale
Senior Management Analyst $10,503 ‐‐ 23 $11,577 10.23% Set 10% above Management Analyst Senior Office Assistant $5,996 ‐2.7% $6,156 10 $6,140 2.40% x Set to marketSenior Permit Services Technician $7,839 ‐‐ 16 $8,228 4.97% Set 10% above Permit Services Technician Senior Plan Check Engineer proposed ‐‐ 27 $14,072 ‐ Set 10% above Plan Check Engineer Senior Planner $11,353 ‐‐ 24 $12,156 7.07% Set 10% above Associate Planner Senior Public Works Inspector $9,515 ‐‐ 21 $10,501 10.36% Set 10% above Public Works Inspector Senior Recreation Coordinator $8,416 ‐‐ 17 $8,639 2.65% Set 15% below Recreation Supervisor Supervising Building Inspector $10,503 ‐‐ 24 $12,156 15.74% Set 15% above Senior Building Inspector Supervising Permit Services Technician $8,416 ‐‐ 18 $9,071 7.79% x Set 10% above Senior Permit Services Technician Wastewater Management Program
Specialist $8,189 ‐ 18 $9,071 10.77% x Set 10% below Management Analyst

Page 4 of 4 ends

206
© 2024 Arthur J. Gallagher & Co. 5
Appendix V
Additional Benefits
© 2024 Arthur J. Gallagher & Co
207
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results
Supplemental Benefits
March 2024
Appendix V
Agoura Hills
Bargaining Unit Benefit
Exempt Management and Mid-Mgmt $125
General employees $85
Beverly Hills
Bargaining Unit Benefit
MEA, Confidential, City Clerk Not offered.

Executive Management, Assistant
Directors, Management & Professional,
Supervisors Assoc
Reimbursement up to maximum 90% of average monthly plan cost and $500/year toward equipment purchase and or accessories
Calabasas
Bargaining Unit Benefit
All units None
Camarillo
All units Depending on department need and approval of the department head - $45/month.

Culver City
Bargaining Unit Benefit
CCEA Not offered.

CCMG and Executive $60/pay period
Laguna Beach
Bargaining Unit Benefit
MEA Not offered.

Unrep Management $80 cellular phone allowance.

Manhattan Beach
Bargaining Unit Benefit
All units None
Redondo Beach
Bargaining Unit Benefit
Teamsters None
City Employee Assoc. RBCEA None
Professional & Supervisory Association Cell phone allowance $35-$55 month if approved by department head.

MGMT Confidential Cell phone allowance $35-$55 month if approved by department head.

Thousand Oaks
Bargaining Unit Benefit
All groups None
West Hollywood
Bargaining Unit Benefit
WEHOME
All employees required to use their personal technology and equipment in the normal course of their duties shall receive $75/month stipend for costs related to internet, printer, phone, scanner.

Technology Allowance
208
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results
Supplemental Benefits
March 2024
Appendix V
Agoura Hills
Bargaining Unit Benefit
Beverly Hills
Bargaining Unit Benefit
All Units
Hybrid, temporary, and emergency arrangements available. No fully remote plans, based on supervisor approval and employee performance. Maximum 3 days per week.

Calabasas
Bargaining Unit Benefit
Camarillo
All units Depending on approval of the department head - available to all employees with the ability to perform their job remotely.

Culver City
Bargaining Unit Benefit
All units Case by case basis - available to employees deemed appropriate by supervisor - can be occasional or recurring basis.

Laguna Beach
Bargaining Unit Benefit
MEA Up to 40 hours each pay period. Certain conditions apply.

Unrep-mgmt Up to 40 hours each pay period. Certain conditions apply.

Manhattan Beach
Bargaining Unit Benefit
Unconfirmed/data pending
Redondo Beach
Bargaining Unit Benefit
Teamsters None
City Employee Assoc. RBCEA None
Professional & Supervisory
Assoc None
MGMT Confidential None
Thousand Oaks
Bargaining Unit Benefit
Unconfirmed/data pending
West Hollywood
Bargaining Unit Benefit
WEHOME Voluntary telework program
Remote Work/Hybrid Policy
Not offered.

Not offered.
209
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results
Supplemental Benefits
March 2024
Appendix V
Agoura Hills
Bargaining Unit Benefit
Beverly Hills
Bargaining Unit Benefit
All Units Maximum $2500
Calabasas
Bargaining Unit Benefit
All Units Each employee shall be eligible for reimbursement for each class for up to the cost of tuition at the California State University System for a comparable class.

Camarillo
All units Reimbursement up to 75% of expenses up to a maximum of $1800.

Culver City
Bargaining Unit Benefit
All Units
The City agrees to reimburse unit employees up to two hundred fifty dollars ($250) per applicable accredited college unit, plus the actual costs of books, registration fees and parking permit fees, pursuant to Administrative Policy 11-08, as amended.

Laguna Beach
Bargaining Unit Benefit
MEA It is $1,000 FY or upon City Manager approval (beyond $1,000) up to 75% actual cost.

Unrep - Management Max $1000, + 75% of actual cost with City Manager Approval.

Manhattan Beach
Bargaining Unit Benefit
MBMEA, Unrep Mgmt/Conf, Exec $3,000 annually
Teamsters $2,500 annually
Redondo Beach
Bargaining Unit Benefit
All Unites $15,000 total for all employees covered by MOU. Up to $1500 year. $500 of $1500 yearly for fitness/health.

Thousand Oaks
Bargaining Unit Benefit
All groups $1,000/fiscal year towards an AA; $5,000/fiscal year towards a BA; $5,000/fiscal year towards MA
West Hollywood
Bargaining Unit Benefit
WEHOME
Tuition will be reimbursed at 100% of the applicable yearly tuition for the University of CA system (UC Tuition resident fee) per fiscal year and required text books will be reimbursed to a max of $2500 per fiscal year for job related courses. Discretionary continuing education and certificates may qualify for tuition reimbursement if they are directly related to the employees current job and per Dept Director approval. Tuition is reimbursed upon completion of the course and a grade "C" or higher.

Tuition Reimbursement
Not offered
210
City of Malibu
Market Compensation Results
Supplemental Benefits
March 2024
Appendix V
Agoura Hills
Bargaining Unit Benefit
Exempt Management and
Exempt Mid-Management Eligible for a 5% of annual salary performance bonus.

Beverly Hills
Bargaining Unit Benefit
Management & Professional
A Department Head may make a recommendation to the City Manager, as submitted through the Department of Human Resources, that an employee receive a lump sum bonus of 1-10% of their base salary.

Calabasas
Bargaining Unit Benefit
Camarillo
Culver City
Bargaining Unit Benefit
Laguna Beach
Bargaining Unit Benefit
Municipal Employee Association Up to 5% gross annual.

Management
In addition to the salary received as a result of application of the foregoing salary plan, management employees shall be eligible for Exceptional Performance Pay of 2.5% or 5%. An additional 5% shall be available for one year or longer at the discretion of the City Manager.

Manhattan Beach
Bargaining Unit Benefit
Redondo Beach
Bargaining Unit Benefit
Teamsters $5,000 sign on bonus. $5,000 retention bonus. Provision effective 1/1/2021 expires 12/31/2023
City Employees RBCEA $500 sign on bonus.

Professional & Supervisory
Association $500 sign on bonus.

Management Confidential None
Thousand Oaks
Bargaining Unit Benefit
TOCEA
Exceptional service recognition: lump sum payment equivalent to 5-10% of the employee's base rate for periods of 1-12 months. Dept Head must demonstrate to CM exceptional perf. is being performed by the employee; CM approves eligibility and amount

TOEM, TOSMA, TOMA
Exceptional service recognition: lump sum payment of $1,000 after taxes. Dept Head must demonstrate to CM exceptional perf. is being performed by the employee; CM approves eligibility and amount
West Hollywood
Bargaining Unit Benefit
Unconfirmed/pending
Lump Sum/Bonus Pays
Not offered.

Not offered.

Not offered.
211
www.ajg.com/ps-class-comp
©2024 Arthur J. Gallagher & Co. All rights reserved.
212
AMENDMENT NO. 1 TO AGREEMENT
THIS AMENDMENT NO. 1 TO AGREEMENT is made and entered in the City of Malibu on April 8, 2024, by and between the CITY OF MALIBU, hereinafter referred to as City, and Gallagher Benefit Services, Inc. hereinafter referred to as Consultant.

The City and the Consultant agree as follows:

R E C I T A L S
A. On February 27, 2023, the City entered into an Agreement with Consultant for certain projects relating to classification and compensation studies, (the “Agreement”).

B. The City desires to amend the Agreement to extend the term three months.

NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of their mutual promises, obligations and covenants hereinafter contained, the parties hereto agree as follows:

1. Section 2.0 – Term of Agreement, of the Agreement, is hereby extended to May 31, 2024.

2. The Parties agree that this Amendment will be considered signed when the signature of a party is delivered physically or by facsimile transmission or scanned and delivered via electronic mail. Such facsimile or electronic mail copies will be treated in all respects as having the same effect as an original signature.

3. All terms and conditions of the Agreement not amended by this Amendment No. 1 remain in full force and effect.

This Agreement is executed on ______________________, at Malibu, California, and effective as of February 28, 2024.

CITY OF MALIBU:
____________________________________
STEVE UHRING, Mayor
ATTEST:
____________________________________
KELSEY PETTIJOHN, City Clerk
(seal)
APPROVED AS TO FORM: CONSULTANT:
_____________________________________ ____________________________________ TREVOR RUSIN, Interim City Attorney Georg S. Krammer
Managing Director
ATTACHMENT 3
213

Page 1 of 3 ends

Agenda Item # 6.B.

Council Agenda Report
To: Mayor Uhring and the Honorable Members of the City Council Prepared by: Richard Mollica, Planning Director
Approved by: Steve McClary, City Manager
Date prepared: March 20, 2024 Meeting date: April 8, 2024 Subject: City Comment Letter for Draft Environmental Impact Report for the Topanga Lagoon Restoration Project
RECOMMENDED ACTION: Review and provide comments on a draft comment letter on the Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR) for the Topanga Lagoon Restoration Project.

FISCAL IMPACT: There is no fiscal impact from the recommended action. Funding for the consultant coordinating the review of the DEIR is included in the Adopted Budget for FY 2023-24 in Account No. 101-2001-5100 (Planning – Professional Services).

STRATEGIC PRIORITY: This item is part of the day-to-day operations identified in the Adopted FY 2023-24 Strategic Priority Project List.

DISCUSSION: The California Department of Parks and Recreation (State Parks) is the lead agency under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and has prepared the Topanga Lagoon Restoration Project DEIR in coordination with County of Los Angeles and the California Department of Transportation. The DEIR assesses the potential effects of implementing the Topanga Lagoon Restoration Project. The DEIR is currently being circulated for public comments. The comment period is an opportunity for the City to address concerns related to the analysis of environmental impacts, including impacts to aesthetics, air quality, noise, traffic, biological resources, water quality, and historic, cultural, and tribal cultural resources.

The Topanga Lagoon Restoration Project involves the expansion of the Topanga Creek and lagoon ecosystem, replacement of the existing Pacific Coast Highway (PCH) bridge with a longer bridge to accommodate the lagoon expansion, development of visitor services in lower Topanga State Park, and the relocation of County of Los Angeles City Council Meeting
04-08-24
Item

6.B.
1

Page 2 of 3 ends

Agenda Item # 6.B.

Department of Beaches and Harbors (DBH) facilities on Topanga Beach that are threatened by sea level rise. The proposed project includes construction of new visitor services at the northwest corner of the intersection of PCH and Topanga Canyon Boulevard, referred to as the “Gateway Corner.” The proposed project also evaluates beneficial reuse options for excavated sediment and options for on and off-site wastewater disposal. Further information about the project can be found at https://www.topangalagoonrestoration.org/project-overview.

The DEIR considers four project alternatives including one “no project” alternative (Alternative 1), and three “build” alternatives. The three build alternatives are Alternative 2 – Maximize Lagoon Habitat, Alternative 3 - Limited Lagoon Habitat Expansion- Maximize Historic Resources and Alternative 4 - Maximum Managed Retreat-Maximum Sea Level Rise Resilience. These alternatives are described in detail in the DEIR. State Parks and its partners may choose a hybrid or blend of these alternatives after hearing from the public. The preferred project alternative would then be included in the Final EIR.

Under each of the build alternatives, project mitigation requires the project to maintain four lanes, two lanes in each direction, on PCH within the bridge area, at least one lane in each direction on all other public roadways during construction of the project other than the sewer extension option.

Improvements to any visitor-serving uses will require upgrading the wastewater management system to meet current standards. Redevelopment of the site would require either onsite wastewater treatment system (OWTS) via subsurface drip irrigation, seepage pits or a sewer connection. If the extension of the current sewer line in PCH is selected it is anticipated to be limited to paved areas along Caltrans right-of-way along the PCH and it is anticipated that one lane along PCH would be closed intermittently during construction of the sewer alignment.

As noted in the DEIR, connection to the public sewer system would involve constructing an extension of the Los Angeles County Sanitation Districts (LACSD) public sewer from existing facilities just south of the intersection of Coastline Drive/PCH, within the Will Rogers State Beach parking lot, to facilities associated with Topanga Beach and the Topanga Ranch Motel/Gateway Corner. The DEIR indicates that while the gas station on the corner of Topanga Canyon Boulevard and PCH and Mastro’s restaurant on PCH could investigate tying into the system, there is insufficient capacity to expand the sewer west into the City of Malibu.

The public review period to provide comments on the DEIR is February 12, 2024 - April 12, 2024. City staff has prepared a draft comment letter (Attachment 1) for Council’s consideration. The comments include input from each City Department. 2

Page 3 of 3 ends

Agenda Item # 6.B.

NEXT STEP: Once the Council provides staff with direction on the comment letter, staff will revise and finalize the letter and submit it to State Parks within the comment period.

The purpose of the public comment period is to receive input on the adequacy and completeness of the EIR. Upon completion of the EIR, the City can submit additional comments regarding the preferred project alternative.

ATTACHMENTS: Draft Environmental Impact Report Comment Letter 3 City of Malibu
23825 Stuart Ranch Road ꞏ Malibu, California ꞏ 90265-4861 Phone (310) 456-2489 ꞏ Fax (310) 456-3356 ꞏ www.malibucity.org Sent via email to [email protected]
April 9, 2024
California Department of Parks and Recreation
Attn: John Ota, Environmental Scientist
1925 Las Virgenes Road
Calabasas, CA 91302
Re: Comments on Draft EIR– Topanga Lagoon Restoration Project Dear Mr. Ota:

Thank you for the opportunity to provide comments on the Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR) for the proposed Topanga Lagoon Restoration Project.

The City provides the following comments on the Draft EIR:

1. Section 3.9-2 - The project must comply with the City of Malibu's Municipal Code Chapter

14.04 (Storm Water Management and Discharge Control) and Chapter15.20m Floodplain Management). This project will need to comply with the City's MS4 Permit requirements. The project will also need to be reviewed for impacts in a mapped FEMA Flood Zone.

2. Section 3.9-11- The project will be required to comply with the area's MS4 Watershed Management Plan. The reference to "SUSMP" is not applicable to the new requirements in the latest version of the NPDES permit provisions. The applicant should look into each jurisdiction's requirements.

3. Section 3.9-22 - The applicant shall verify the specific local MS4 Permit requirements as stated in the Watershed Management Plans. It appears that this project would be required to meet the water quality discharge requirements as stated in the North Santa Monica Bay Watershed Management Plan (City of Malibu, County of Los Angeles, and Flood Control). The applicant shall verify the specific requirements in the adjacent jurisdiction.

4. Section 4-12 -This project needs to be evaluated by the City of Malibu since it is within a FEMA mapped Flood Zone that is administered by the City. Any development within a mapped flood zone shall meet the requirements of the City's Municipal Code Chapter 15.20 and other FEMA Floodplain regulation.
4 California Department of Parks and Recreation
Topanga Lagoon Restoration DEIR Comments
2 5. Due to the potential impacts to water and water quality, the California Department of Parks and Recreation may consider sharing the DEIR to and requesting comments from the North Santa Monica Bay Watershed Area Steering Committee, consisting of members of numerous jurisdictions, water districts, and Wishtoyo Chumash.

6. The soils report and geotechnical investigation could consider the impact that substantial winter rains may have on the proposed subsurface drip irrigation.

7. The maps show the location of the proposed subsurface drip irrigation (option 1). Consider updating the maps to show the proposed location of the septic tank(s) and seepage pits (option 2).

8. Section 2.2.3 includes an erroneous question mark: “This upgraded an earlier coastal? road built in the early 1920s”

9. Section 2.6.2, Option 2 discusses trucking material from Pacific Coast Highway to Malibu Canyon Road. If this option is chosen, discuss the requirements of trucking material with the City of Environmental Sustainability Department.

10. Section 3.1.1 Regulatory Setting describes local regulations from County of Los Angeles, Topanga State Park 2012 General Plan, and Santa Monica Mountains Local Coastal Program.

This section should include the applicable Malibu regulations (Local Coastal Program Local Implementation Plan) since portions of the project are within the City of Malibu jurisdiction.

11. Do the results of the Los Angeles County Beaches and Harbor’s Coastal Resiliency study impact the sea level rise evaluated for this study?

12. A coastal development permit (CDP) pursuant to the California Coastal Act from the California Coastal Commission (CCC) is required. The Draft EIR indicates State Parks would obtain a consolidated CDP and implement the permit conditions. The DEIR should acknowledge that a CDP may be required from the City of Malibu for any work that takes place within City boundaries or the City may authorize the work to be implemented under the consolidated CDP. The City understands this information will not be available until after the project alternative is selected.

Sincerely,
Richard Mollica
Planning Director
5 California Department of Parks and Recreation
Topanga Lagoon Restoration DEIR Comments
3 cc: Honorable Members of the Malibu City Council
Steve McClary, City Manager
6

Malibu City CouncilApril 8, 2024

Malibu City Council
April 8, 2024