Agenda — Marina City Council, May 10, 2022

AGENDA

Tuesday, May 10, 2022 6:00 P.M. Open Session

SPECIAL MEETING

CITY COUNCIL, AIRPORT COMMISSION,

MARINA ABRAMS B NON-PROFIT CORPORATION, PRESTON PARK SUSTAINABLE

COMMUNITY NON-PROFIT CORPORATION, SUCCESSOR AGENCY OF THE FORMER

MARINA REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY AND MARINA GROUNDWATER

SUSTAINABILITY AGENCY

Council Chambers
211 Hillcrest Avenue
Marina, California

Zoom Meeting URL: https://zoom.us/j/730251556
Zoom Meeting Telephone Only Participation: 1-669-900-9128 - Webinar ID: 730 251 556

In accordance with California Government Code §54953(e)(1)(A) and (C) and the Proclamation of a State of Emergency issued by Governor Newsom o n March 4, 2020, under the provisions of Government Code §8625 related to t he COVID -19 (coronavirus) pandemic, consistent with recommendations by State and local health officials regarding social distancing and in order to prevent an imminent risk to the health and safety of attendees as determine d in Resolution 2022-48, public participation in City of Marina City Council public meetings shall be electronic only and without a physical location for public participation until the earlier of April 30, 2022, or such time as the City Council may ado pt a resolution in accordance with G overnment Code §54953(e)(3). This meeting is being broadcast “live” on Access Media Productions (AMP) Community Television Cable 25 and on the City of Marina Channel and on the internet at https://accessmediaproductions.org/

PARTICIPATION
You may participate in the City Council meeting in real-time by calling Zoom Meeting via the weblink and phone number provided at the top of this a genda. Instructions on how to acce ss, vie w and participate in remote m eetings are provided by visiting the City’s home page at https://cityofmarina.org/. Attendees can make oral comments during the meeting by usi ng the “Raise Your Hand” feature in the webinar or by pressing *9 on you r telephone keypad if joining by phone only. If you are unable to participate in real-time, you may email to [email protected] with the subject line “Public Comment Item#__ ” (insert the item number relevant to your comment) or “Public Comment – Non Agenda Item.” Comments will be reviewed and distr ibuted before the meeting if received by 5:00 p.m. on the day of the meeting. All com ments received will become part of t he record. Council will have the option to modify their action on items based on comments received.

AGENDA MATERIALS
Agenda materi als, staff reports and background information related to regular agenda items are available on the City of Marina’s websit e www.cityofmarina.org. Materials r elated to an item on this agenda submitted to the Coun cil after distribution of the agenda packet will be made available on the City of Mari na website www.cityofmarina.org subject to City staff’s ability to post the documents before the meeting

Agenda for Special City Council Meeting of Tuesday, May 10, 2022 Page 2

VISION STATEMENT
Marina will grow and mature from a small tow n bedroom community to a small city which i s diversified, vibrant and through pos itive relationships with regional agencies, self-sufficient. The City will develop in a way that insulates it from the negative impacts of urban sprawl to become a desirable residential and business community in a natural setting. (Resolution No. 2006-112 - May 2, 2006)

MISSION STATEMENT
The City Council will provide the leadership in protecting Marina’s natural setting while developing the City in a way that provides a bala nce of housing, jobs and business opportuni ties that will result in a community c haracterized by a desirable quality o f life, including recreation and cultural opportunities, a safe environment and an economic viability that supports a high level of munici pal services and infrastructure. (Resolution No. 2006-112 - May 2, 2006)

1. CALL TO ORDER

2. ROLL CALL & ESTABLISHMEN T OF QUORUM: (City Council, Airport Commissioners, Marina Abrams B Non -Profit Corporation, Preston Park Sustainable Communities Nonpr ofit Corporation, Successor Agency of the Former Redevelopment Agency Members and Marina Groundwater Sustainability Agency)

Cristina Medina Dirksen, David Burnett, Lisa Berkley, Mayor Pro -Tem/Vice Chair Kathy Biala, Mayor/Chair Bruce C. Delgado

3. MOMENT OF SILENCE & PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE (Please stand)

4. STUDY SESSION:
a. City Council hold study session regarding the Dunes Development Project and have disc ussion regarding 1) compensation and mitigation for trees illegally removed; 2) changing policies and procedures to ensure compliance with tree removal regulations.

5. ADJOURNMENT:

CERTIFICATION

I, Anita Sharp, Deputy City Clerk, of the City of Marina, do hereby certify that a copy of the foregoing agenda was po sted at Cit y Hall and Council Chambers Bulletin Board at 211 Hi llcrest Avenue, Monterey County Library Marina Branch at 190 Seaside Circle, City Bulletin Board at the co rner of Reservation Road and Del Monte Boulevard on or before 6:00 p.m., Friday, May 6, 2022.

___________________________________

ANITA SHARP, DEPUTY CITY CLERK
City Council, Airport Commission and Redev elopment Agency meet ings are recorded on tape and available for public review and listening at the Office of the City Clerk and kept for a period of 90 days after the formal approval of MINUTES.

City Council meetings may be viewed live on the meeting night and at 1 2:30 p.m. and 3:00 p.m. on Cable Chan nel 2 5 on th e Sunday following th e Regular City Council meeting date. In addition, Council m eetings can be viewed at 6 :30 p.m. every Monday, Tuesday a nd W ednesday. For more information ab out viewing the Counc il Meetings on Chann el 2 5, y ou ma y contact Acc ess M onterey Peninsula directly at 831-333-1267.

Agenda for Special City Council Meeting of Tuesday, May 10, 2022 Page 3

Agenda items and staff re ports are publi c re cord a nd are available for public review on the City's website (www.ciytofmarina.org), at the Monterey C ounty Marina Li brary Branch at 190 Seaside Circle and at the Office of the City Clerk at 211 Hillcrest Avenue, Marina between the hours of 10:00 a.m. 5:00 p.m., on the Monday preceding the meeting.

Supplemental materials received after the close of the final agenda and through noon on the day of the scheduled meeting will be available for pu blic review at the City C lerk’s Office during regular office hours and in a ‘Supplemental Binder’ at the meeting.

Members of the public may receive the City Council, Airport Commission and Successor Agency of the Former Redevelopment Agency Age nda at a cos t of $55 per ye ar or by p roviding a self -addressed, stamped envelope to the C ity Clerk. The Agenda is also available at no cost via email by notifying the City Clerk at [email protected]
ALL MEETINGS A RE OP EN TO THE PUBLIC. T HE CIT Y OF M ARINA DO ES N OT DISCRIMINATE AGAINST PERS ONS WITH D ISABILITIES. Council Chambers are whee lchair accessible. meetings are broadcast on cable channel 25 and recordings of meetings can be provided upon request. to request assistive list ening devices, sign language i nterpreters, readers, large prin t agendas or other accommodations, please call (831) 884-1278 or e-mail: [email protected]. requests must be made at least 48 hours in advance of the meeting.

May 10, 2022, Item No. 4a

Honorable Mayor and Members City Council Meeting
of the Marina City Council of May 10, 2022

CITY COUNCIL HOLD STUDY SESSION REGARDING THE DUNES

DEVELOPMENT PROJECT AND HAVE A DISCUSSION REGARDI NG

COMPENSATION AND MITIGATION FOR TREES ILLEGALLY REMOVED AND

CHANGING POLICIES AND PROCEDURES TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH

TREE REMOVAL REGULATIONS

RECOMMENDATION: City Council consider

1. Review the submitted staff report and the standard operating procedures

2. Adopt the recommended penalties for the unpermitted removal of trees

SUMMARY:

On March 21, 2022 Mar ina residents informed City staff that a r ow of trees within the Dunes Development Project area were removed without the benefit of permits. After this incident , the Community Development Director received approximately thirty (30) emails about the removal of a grove of trees within Phase 3 of the project. The applicant, Marina Community Par tners (MCP), was directed by city staff to cease removal of all trees moving forward until a deeper investigation occurred and the City Council could provide direction on how to resolve this issue moving forward. On A pril 5, 2022 the City Council directed staff to organize a community meeting with concerned citizens and to have a special City Council meeting prior to May 31, 2022 to discuss this matter in more detail.

Figure 1-Dunes Phased Development Map

PROJECT TREE BACKGROUND:

On January 14, 2021 the Planning Commission reviewed the design review and tree removal permits for BMR Sites #1 and #2 within the Dunes Development.1 As shown in Figure 2 several trees within BMR site 2 were recommended for removal (1397, 1398, 1410, 1411, 1412). On March 21, 2022, the applicant’s sub-contractor removed an asbestos laden pipe that was below the surface of trees 1384-1396 without prior approval from the City of Marina.

Figure 2-Tree Removal

PENALTY

Tree Mitigation-The Development Agreement between the City of Marina and Marina Community Partners (MCP) was executed on July 8, 2005. This agreement froze certain City regulations to those in effect at the time of execution of the agreement. The provisions of the 2005 Marina Municipal Code regulate tree removal within the Specific Plan area. The removal of all trees identified as protected in the Specific Plan and determined to be in fair or good condition a re required to be replaced at 2:1 ratio, unless removed without a permit. In such cases, the recommended ratio be multiplied by a factor of 3 (6:1). 2 The University Village
Specific Plan requires the condition of Monterey cypress and pines be recorded. The condition of Eucalyptus are not required to be recorded and are therefore not required to be replaced.3

Code Enforcement-In addition to the requirement to replace 6 trees for every 1 removed without permits (6:1), the City Council does have the authority under the Municipal Code to declare this violation a public nuisance

1 January 14, 2021 Planning Commission packet: https://www.cityofmarina.org/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Agenda/_01142021- 209. Tr ee Removal Permit for the Removal of 9 Monterey Pi ne Trees, 5 Monterey Cypress Trees, 2 Mexican Fan Palms, 1 Coast Live Oak, and 1 Eucalyptus Tree for the development of 140 affordable housing units on Lot 24 – Area Q (APN 031- 251-014) and a portion of Lot 20 – Area F (APN 031-282-043)

2 12.04.060(c)-Compensation Plans. However, until such time as said public tree planting plan is adopted, such replacement trees and/or payment shall be based upon the replacement of the healthy trees to be removed on a m inimum two-for-one basis unless the compensation plan is appealed, in which case the city council may approve tree replacement at a lesser rate.

12.04.100(c)-The planting of replacement trees on site or the payment to the city to fund the purchase, planting and maintenance of off-site tree plantings should be in accordance with the tree replacement formula found in Section 12.04.060C multiplied by three for each tree removed in violation of this chapter.

3 Trees 6’’ diameter breast plate height (DBH) and greater are recorded and only cypress, oaks, pines will be recorded. The condition of eucalyptus will not be recorded. Acacia trees will not be recorded in [a] table but locations will be noted on [a] map (Chapter 5, Development Regulations, University Village Specific Plan, pg 118) and to make the appli cant appear be fore a City administrative hearing officer via a code enforcement proceeding as identified within Chapter 1.12 of the Marina Municipal Code.4

Default-Finally, pursuant to Section 11.4 of the 2005 D isposition and Development Agreement (DDA), the City Council can find the applicant in default of this agreement. Questions related to finding MCP in default with the DDA should be directed to the City Attorney on May 10, 2022.

TREE STANDARD OPERATING PROCEDURES (SOP)
In light of the unpermitted removal of trees, the Community Development Director, Guido F. Persicone, did a comprehensive review of the City’s tree removal permitting processes and has prepared a standard operating procedure for the removal and retention of trees moving forward. Please see Attachment 1 to this report for more details, but the main recommendation being pushed forward is that upon review of the City’s policies and procedures, there were many interested parties involved in this permit process, the applicant, the arborist and the assigned city planner, but a break down in the system was after approval of the tree removal permit by the Planning Commission, but prior to movement of dirt on the site the assigned project planner was not signing off on a specific tree protection sheet within the grading or building permit plans.

Moving forward, before any dirt is moved or a demolition permit issued by the Building Division, a project planner will be required to approve a Tree Protection and Removal Sheet on a set of plans. The policy has been broadly written to basically mean any permit issued by the City will require the planners to stamp a set of plans to ensure the adequate protection and removal of specific trees.

No s
ite modification permits, including but not limited to grading, building or demo permits will be issued in which protected trees are on a property unl ess an applicant submits a separate Tree Protection and Removal Sheet in their submittal package. This sheet in the building, grading, or demo permit set of plans w ill clearly label the trees on site that will be retained, and which will be removed.

No permits will be issued until the project planner has reviewed this sheet of the plans and stamped said plans either in Blue Beam or with a hard copy stamp5.

Additionally, the applicant has agreed to on site monitoring by City staff prior to work near or abutting trees in the near term to provide an additional check on implementation of this new SOP.

COUNCIL QUESTIONS
At the April 5th Council meeting several questions were submitted to city staff for additional follow up. The answers to those questions can be found in Attachment 2 to this report.

COMMUNITY
MEETING:

On May 2, 2022 a community meeting within the development occurred with concerned citizens. At this meeting the following issues/comments were discussed
• The applicant (MCP) apologized to the community for inadvertently removing t rees and pledged to work closely with the City of Marina to ensure this mistake does not happen again. • MCP reviewed their current submittal for Phase 2 West and Phase 3 and agreed to retain an additional twenty-four (24) trees within the project site. Please see Attachment 3 for the specific additional trees that will retained. The applicant agreed to share a map of retained trees with the residents in the near term.
• The applicant agreed to conduct a site visit with concerned citizens for Phase 3 and Phase 4 of the development to further identify trees that could be retained for the later parts of project.

4 Section 1.08.040-Any condition existing in violation of this code or a city ordinance is deemed to be a public nuisance. See also, Chapter 1.12 (Administrative Fines) for additional code enforcement details. 5 Excerpt from the Tree Protection and Retention Policy. See Attachment 1 for further details.

FISCAL IMPACT:

On site monitoring of all trees will by paid for by the applicant so there will be no fiscal impact to the City of Marina.

ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW:

Adoption of the Tree Retention and Removal Policy is not considered a project under CEQA.

CONCLUSION:

This request is submitted for City Council consideration and comment.

Respectfully submitted,

Guido F. Persicone, AICP
Community Development Director
City of Marina

REVIEWED/CONCUR:

_____________________________
Layne Long
City Manager
City of Marina

Draft Resolution
Attachment 1-Tree Preservation and Protection SOP
Attachment 2-Dunes Development City Council Tree Questions Attachment 3-Map of Retained Trees (to be provided by MCP)

MEMORANDUM

DATE: February 21, 2017

FROM: Guido F. Persicone, Community Development Director Brian McMinn, Public Works Director

TO: Community Development and Public Works Staff

SUBJECT: Tree Preservation and Protection Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs)

1. No site modification permits, including but not limited to grading, building or demo permits will be issued in which protected trees are on a property unless an applicant submits a separate Tree Protection and Removal Sheet in their submittal package. This sheet in the building, grading, or demo permit set of plans will clearly label the trees on site that will be retained, and which will be removed. No permits will be issued until the project planner has reviewed this sheet of the plans and stamped said plans either in Blue Beam or with a hard copy stamp, and

2. No site modification permits, including but not limited to grading, building or demo permits will be issued in which trees are on a property until the applicant has installed protection fencing around all trees that are to be retained. Protective fencing shall be installed no closer to the trunk than the dripline, and far enough from the trunk to protect the integrity of the tree. a. The fence shall be chain link and a minimum of five feet in height. Fence shall be supported by vertical posts driven 2 feet (min) into the ground. b. The existing grade level around a tree shall normally be maintained out to the dripline of the tree. No signs, wires, or any other object shall be attached to the tree. c. Trees that have been damaged by construction shall be repaired in accordance with accepted arboriculture methods
d. The applicant shall submit a picture of the fencing and submit said photos to the project planner.

3. Tree recommended for removal shall be spray painted with a red X. The applicant will take a picture of the tree with the red x and submit this to the project planner.

4. A city inspector will be on site to ensure only trees recommended for removal by the Planning Department will be removed. This will be based on the Tree Protection and Retention Sheet that will be on all plans moving forward
“Tree” means any living woody perennial plant having a single stem of six inches or more DBH or a multi-stemmed plant having an aggregate diameter of ten inches or more measured at DBH

Existing trees in good or fair condition to be removed shall be replaced on site at a ratio of two replacement trees for each tree removed (2:1).

The minimum size of tree selection is 15-gallon. Minimum 24” box trees shall be located in areas of special interest such as focal points and neighborhood entries.

Nesting Birds
For any trees proposed to be removed or relocated between January and July, surveys for active nests of birds-of-prey birds shall be undertaken by a qualified biologist. If active nests are found and the biologist determines that construction activities would remove the nest or have the potential to cause abandonment, then those activities shall be avoided until the young have fledged and are no longer dependent upon the nests for survival.

Special Status Bat Species
BR-5.1 Conduct surveys for special-status bats in the project site and implement avoidance/relocation plan if present.
a. Prior to the removal of large trees or abandoned buildings, a qualified biologist shall survey the
trees and abandoned buildings for presence of roosting bats. If special-status bat species are present, the following measures should be implemented.
b. Tree removal should not occur if maternity bat roosts are present (between April 15 and August 1) in the trees to be removed.
c. No tree removal should occur within 300 feet of the maternity roost until all young bats have fledged – as determined by a qualified biologist.
d. If special-status bats are present, but there is not an active maternity roost, a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with the CDFG should be obtained in order to remove the animals prior to tree removal. Alternate habitat may need to be provided if bats are to be excluded from maternity roosts. A roost with comparable spatial and thermal characteristics should be constructed as directed by a qualified biologist. In the event that adult bats need to be handled and relocated, a qualified biologist shall prepare and implement a relocation plan subject to approval by CDFG that includes relocating all bats found on-site to an alternate suitable habitat.

A Mitigation and Monitoring Plan that mitigates for loss of bat roosting habitat should be prepared by a qualified biologist and approved by CDFG prior to tree or building removal

Pre Construction Surveys
Pre-construction (i.e. no more than 30 days prior to construction) surveys for active nests shall be conducted within 250 feet of proposed construction activities. If active nests are found and the biologist determines that construction activities would adversely affect the nest or cause nest abandonment, then those activities should be avoided in these areas until the young have fledged, as determined by nest monitoring by a qualified biologist through the breeding season. Once the young have fledged, construction activities may resume in the vicinity and no further mitigation measures would be required.

Attachment 1-Sample Tree Protection Fencing

Attachment 2-Diameter of Tree at 4’ 5” Breast Plate Height

Attachment 3-Sample Tree Protection Sheet

Attachment 1

MEMORANDUM

DATE: April 25, 2022

FROM: Guido F. Persicone, Community Development Director

VIA: Layne Long, City Manager

TO: City Council

SUBJECT: D unes Development Tree Questions

Mayor and City Council Questions/Staff Response in Red
March 27, 2022. Mayor notes regarding next steps to address unauthorized tree cutting at The Dunes approx. March 15, 2022.
1) City or developer provide a 1-2 page summary of which Phase 2 trees (their assigned number, species, size, health and reason for removal) were recently removed with or without authorization, what steps were documented to have been taken before tree removal to ensure no nesting birds were using the trees and that required steps to protect “keeper” trees were followed or not followed, and reason why unauthorized tree removal took place.

The staff report for this special meeting will discuss in more detail the timeline of events that caused the unpermitted removal of trees 1384-1396

Phase Report
Phase IA-
IC
Phase 2
North
Special status Bat species report submitted to the City on March 4, 2020 Nesting Bird surveys were submitted on March 20, 2020. Western Bluebird was seen on site so an MOU was prepared to ensure the bird left the site prior to additional construction
April 13, 2020-tree protection fencing installed for Phase IA-1C with the orange netting
Survey
Area 3
Staging
Area
June 1, 2020-No active bird nests were documented within the survey area.

Phase 2 September 23, 2020-Nesting Bird and Special Status Bat Species report submitted to the City. No active bird nests or special status species were

East documented.

November 17, 2020-Nesting Bird and Special-Status Bat Species Roost Survey. No active bird nest of special status species roots were documented.

March 23, 2021-same report. No active bird nest of special status species roots were documented.

January 31, 2022- same report. No active bird nest of special status species roots were documented.

March 10, 2022-supplemental tree report prepared determined that Trees 571 and 580 should be retained.

Phase 2 Borrow Area-April 8, 2022-no additional trees will be impacted but tree protection measures should be put in place.

2) Phase 3 Arborist report on tree locations, sizes, species, and health be made available asap.

The Phase 3 Arborist report has been made available to the public as of April 13, 2022 from this project link: https://www.cityofmarina.org/204/The-Dunes-on-Monterey-Bay

3) Postpone April 14 PC meeting on Phase 3(?) tree removal permit until unauthorized tree removal is addressed, and compensation planned.

No tree removal permits are scheduled for this meeting.

4) Based upon the Phase 3 arborist report, the number of trees and their locations to be kept and those to be removed need to be photographed and discussed in public.

The Phase 3 Arborist report has a photo of each tree and city staff are available to answer project related questions, but in general the tree removal permit includes: 458 trees are proposed for removal in the project site (Figure 2; Appendix A-B). These include:
178 Monterey cypresses ( Hesperocyparis macrocarpa), 6" to 101" DBH, • 184 Monterey pines ( Pinus radiata), 6" to 46" DBH,
• 11 Torrey pines ( Pinus torreyana), 6" to 33" DBH,
• Fou r (4) coast live oaks (Quercus agrifolia), 10" to 13" DBH, • 69 eucalyptus trees ( Eucalyptus spp.), 7" to 88" DBH, • F ive (5) Australian cheesewoods (Pittosporum undulatum), 6" to 20" DBH, • Four (4) Chinese junipers ( Juniperus chinensis), 8" to 12" DBH, • Two (2) Mexican fan palms ( Washingtonia robusta), 17" and 20"DBH, and • One (1) Peruvian peppertree (Schinus molle), 33" DBH.

5) Following questions need to be publicly discussed:
a. Why are certain trees removed and others kept?
Recommendation for removal is based on the City’s Tree Ordinance and for the Dunes Development the criteria identified within the University Village Specific Plan. For the specific criteria, please review page 5 of the Phase 3 Tree Removal Report from Denise Duffy and Associates.
https://www.cityofmarina.org/204/The-
Dunes-on-Monterey-Bay

b. Who determines what distance of proximity to roads, planned underground infrastructure, and planned residential or other buildings would require removal of existing trees?
The determination of infrastructure is based on the primary goals of the City which are to allow the project to move forward but to do so in a manner that preserves as many trees as possible and also plants replacement trees to mitigate for the loss of mature trees.

c. How many residential units and 1000’s of sq feet of office are to be constructed in Phase 3?
255 Single Family Housing Units
Arts District – this is something the city is taking the lead on not MCP, as MCP transferred this back to the City with the Operating Agreement.

Business Park - entitlements allow nearly 400,000 square ft or more of office park Neighborhood retail-around 10,000 square feet of retail for this phase.

d. What documents have been approved giving developer the rights to build structures or roads in certain Phase 3 locations?
The Phase 3 Tentative Map is scheduled to appear before the Planning Commission on May 26
th. Per Section 16.08.070 of the Marina Municipal Code the City Council will then review the tentative map.

e. What documents have been approved giving developer the rights to remove Phase 3 trees considered by developers as necessary to remove due to planned infrastructure (utilities, roads, buildings) or massive grading?
No approvals have been granted for the Phase 3 tentative map as of April 13, 2022.

f. What rights does City have to require certain trees thought to be iconic or beneficial to community to be retained?

The City retains its authority under the Marina Municipal Code and the University Village Specific Plan to retain as many trees as possible.

g. What are the options developer and City have to compensate for the loss of large, healthy, trees by retaining existing large, healthy trees? Per State law the Dunes development is bound by the original regulations in place when the 2005 Development Agreement was signed. Per the original agreement the applicant is bound by the replacement penalty of 6 trees for every 1 tree that is removed without a permit.

6) Attempt to retain all matriarch trees in Phase 3 such as:

Table 1 is a summary of the trees the Mayor requested staff be prepared to discuss at the May 10, 2022 Special Dunes Tree meeting. However, it should be pointed out that the Planning Commission has not provided its input on this tree removal permit as of yet so it would be premature of the City Council to provide policy direction on this matter. If the Council wishes to review the matter, an appeal can be filed with the City Clerk within 10 working days of the decision (17.70.040).

Table 1-Phase 3 Trees
Tree Health Remove-
Y or No
Location Picture
920 Fair Yes

1284 No tree exist within the Phase 3 tree report
923 Fair
Health
Remove

926 Eucy.

Trees-no
condition
recorded
Remove

Staff
needs the
Council
to clearly
identify
these
trees.

Cypress trees approved for removal north and south of
6th St (along 1st Ave),

973 Fair Remove

950 No
condition
Eucalyptus-no tree condition provided per the Specific
Plan
The condition of eucalyptus will not be recorded

951 Monterey
Cypress
Fair
Remove

967 Montery
Cypress
Fair
Remove

7) We should strive for a win-win by building a quality community in part by retraining clusters of large trees and isolated matriarchs scattered throughout Phase 3.

Agreed.

8) ASAP after arborist Phase 3 report has been released for at least 1 week, plan a meeting on-site with approx. 10 engaged community members, mayor, developer representatives, and City staff to discuss process of deciding which large healthy trees will be retained.

Agreed. The Community Development Director has scheduled a meeting with interested parties on May 2, 2022. Additionall, the Phase 3 tree report is available on the City website as of April 14, 2022 at:
https://www.cityofmarina.org/204/The-Dunes-on-
Monterey-Bay

9) Return to official public meeting process for planning/approval of which trees to retain and which to remove including some deference to retaining some trees in Phase 2 (such as along 1
st Ave-see photos #2-3 below) to compensate for those removed without permit in Phase 2.

This is a policy decision of the entire City Council.

LANE 1
PHASE 4 OP

CITY PARK

OPEN SPACE OPEN SPACE

F STREET
1ST AVENUE

D STREETE STREET

DIVARTY STREET
1ST AVENUE
2ND AVENUE
2ND AVENUE

QUARTERMASTER AVENUE
3RD STREET
2ND STREET

AFFORDABLE
HOUSING SITE 2
OPEN
SPACE

OPEN SPACE

G STREET

H STREET

Q STREET

D STREET

E STREET

P STREET

S STREET

N STREET
LANE 3
6TH STREET
7TH STREET

A STREET

B STREET C STREET
PHASE 3 OP
PHASE 2 OP

OPEN SPACE
OPEN
SPACE

OPEN SPACE

BUTTERFLY
PARK
LANE 2
LANE 1
LANE 4

R STREET

O STREET
LANE 5

K STREET

L STREET

I STREET
LANE 1.1
LANE 1.2
18721872187218721872
1924 1924192419241924
1942 1942194219421942
1943 1943194319431943
1948 1948194819481948
1953 1953195319531953 1961 1961196119611961
1987 1987198719871987
1988 19881988198819881989 1989198919891989
1990 1990199019901990
615 615615615615
616 616616616616617 617617617617
618 618618618618
619 619619619619
620 620620620620
621 621621621621627 627627627627
628 628628628628
629 629629629629 631 631631631631633 633633633633 638 638638638638 641 641641641641
642 642642642642
645 645645645645
655 655655655655
text texttexttexttext
658 658658658658
text texttexttexttext
660 660660660660
661 661661661661 672 672672672672
673 673673673673
674 674674674674
696 696696696696
697 697697697697
698 698698698698
699 699699699699
700 700700700700701 701701701701 702 702702702702
703 703703703703
706 706706706706 708 708708708708
709 709709709709
712 712712712712
714 714714714714
722 722722722722
723 723723723723
726 726726726726
727 727727727727 731 731731731731
732 732732732732
733 733733733733 736 736736736736
737 737737737737739 739739739739
740 740740740740 741 741741741741
742 742742742742743 743743743743
746 746746746746748 748748748748
749 749749749749750 750750750750
752 752752752752
753 753753753753754 754754754754
755 755755755755 756 756756756756
757 757757757757 759 759759759759
761761761761761
762 762762762762
763 763763763763
766 766766766766771 771771771771
772 772772772772
773 773773773773
776 776776776776 778 778778778778
779 779779779779
780 780780780780
781 781781781781
782 782782782782
787 787787787787
text texttexttexttext
801 801801801801
802 802802802802
804 804804804804
805 805805805805 806 806806806806
809 809809809809
813 813813813813
815 815815815815
829 829829829829830 830830830830
834 834834834834
837 837837837837
838 838838838838839 839839839839
840 840840840840
1275 1275127512751275
1276 1276127612761276
1277 1277127712771277
1278 1278127812781278
1279 12791279127912791280 1280128012801280
1281 1281128112811281
1282 1282128212821282
1284 1284128412841284
1285 1285128512851285 1287 1287128712871287
1288 1288128812881288
1289 1289128912891289
1290 1290129012901290
1291 1291129112911291
1292 1292129212921292
1293 1293129312931293
1294 1294129412941294
1295 1295129512951295
1296 1296129612961296
1297 1297129712971297
1302 1302130213021302
1305 13051305130513051306 1306130613061306
1307 1307130713071307
1308 1308130813081308
1309 1309130913091309
1310 1310131013101310
1311 1311131113111311
1313 1313131313131313
1314 1314131413141314
1315 1315131513151315
1316 1316131613161316
1317 1317131713171317
1319 1319131913191319
1321 1321132113211321
1324 1324132413241324
1325 1325132513251325
1327 1327132713271327
1329 1329132913291329
1332 1332133213321332 1333 1333133313331333
1335 1335133513351335
1336 13361336133613361337 1337133713371337
1338 1338133813381338
1339 1339133913391339
1340 1340134013401340
1341 1341134113411341
1342 1342134213421342
13451345134513451345
1348 1348134813481348 1349 1349134913491349
1350 1350135013501350
1351 135113511351135113751375137513751375
1374137413741374137413731373137313731373
13721372137213721372
13571357135713571357
13561356135613561356
13551355135513551355
1704 1704170417041704
888 888888888888
889 889889889889
907 907907907907
909 909909909909
910 910910910910
911 911911911911
912 912912912912
939 939939939939
950 950950950950 952 952952952952
967 967967967967
980 980980980980981 981981981981
982 982982982982
987 987987987987
989 989989989989

CITY OF MARINA, CALIFORNIA
PHASE 3 -TREE INVENTORY EXHIBIT

THE DUNES
Sheet 1 of 3
Civil Engineering
Land Surveying
6 Harris Court
Monterey, California
831.649.5225
whitsonengineers.com4 / 2 6 / 2 0 2 2
Project No.:3140.18
PHASE 3 BOUNDARY

TREE HEALTH
GOOD
FAIR
POOR

TREE TO BE STUDIED FOR

POSSIBLE SAVE

ACACIA TREE

PROPOSED REMOVAL

EXISTING TREE DRIPLINE
LEGEND
NOTE:

TREE LOCATION AND HEALTH IS PER DENISE DUFFY &
ASSOCIATES, INC. (DD&A)
LANE 1
PHASE 4 OP

CITY PARK

OPEN SPACE OPEN SPACE

F STREET
1ST AVENUE

D STREETE STREET

DIVARTY STREET
1ST AVENUE
2ND AVENUE
2ND AVENUE

QUARTERMASTER AVENUE
3RD STREET
2ND STREET

AFFORDABLE
HOUSING SITE 2
OPEN
SPACE

OPEN SPACE

G STREET

H STREET

Q STREET

D STREET

E STREET

P STREET

S STREET

N STREET
LANE 3
6TH STREET
7TH STREET

A STREET

B STREET C STREET
PHASE 3 OP
PHASE 2 OP

OPEN SPACE
OPEN
SPACE

OPEN SPACE

BUTTERFLY
PARK
LANE 2
LANE 1
LANE 4

R STREET

O STREET
LANE 5

K STREET

L STREET

CITY OF MARINA, CALIFORNIA
PHASE 3 -TREE INVENTORY EXHIBIT WITH GRADING DESIGN

THE DUNES
Sheet 2 of 3
Civil Engineering
Land Surveying
6 Harris Court
Monterey, California
831.649.5225
whitsonengineers.com4 / 2 6 / 2 0 2 2
Project No.:3140.18
PHASE 3 BOUNDARY

TREE HEALTH
GOOD
FAIR
POOR

TREE TO BE STUDIED FOR

POSSIBLE SAVE

ACACIA TREE

PROPOSED REMOVAL

EXISTING TREE DRIPLINE
LEGEND
NOTE:

TREE LOCATION AND HEALTH IS PER DENISE DUFFY &
ASSOCIATES, INC. (DD&A)
LANE 1
PHASE 4 OP

CITY PARK

OPEN SPACE OPEN SPACE

F STREET
1ST AVENUE

D STREETE STREET

DIVARTY STREET
1ST AVENUE
2ND AVENUE

QUARTERMASTER AVENUE
3RD STREET
2ND STREET

AFFORDABLE
HOUSING SITE 2
OPEN
SPACE

OPEN SPACE

G STREET

H STREET

Q STREET

D STREET

E STREET

P STREET

S STREET

N STREET
LANE 3
6TH STREET
7TH STREET

A STREET

B STREET C STREET
PHASE 3 OP
PHASE 2 OP

OPEN SPACE
OPEN
SPACE

OPEN SPACE

BUTTERFLY
PARK
LANE 2
LANE 1
LANE 4

R STREET

O STREET
LANE 5

K STREET

L STREET

I STREET
LANE 1.1
LANE 1.2
18721872187218721872
1924 1924192419241924
1942 1942194219421942
1943 1943194319431943
1948 1948194819481948
1953 1953195319531953 1961 1961196119611961
1987 1987198719871987
1988 19881988198819881989 1989198919891989
1990 1990199019901990
615 615615615615
616 616616616616617 617617617617
618 618618618618
619 619619619619
620 620620620620
621 621621621621627 627627627627
628 628628628628
629 629629629629 631 631631631631633 633633633633 638 638638638638 641 641641641641
642 642642642642
645 645645645645
655 655655655655
text texttexttexttext
658 658658658658
text texttexttexttext
660 660660660660
661 661661661661 672 672672672672
673 673673673673
674 674674674674
696 696696696696
697 697697697697
698 698698698698
699 699699699699
700 700700700700701 701701701701 702 702702702702
703 703703703703
706 706706706706 708 708708708708
709 709709709709
712 712712712712
714 714714714714
722 722722722722
723 723723723723
726 726726726726
727 727727727727 731 731731731731
732 732732732732
733 733733733733 736 736736736736
737 737737737737739 739739739739
740 740740740740 741 741741741741
742 742742742742743 743743743743
746 746746746746748 748748748748
749 749749749749750 750750750750
752 752752752752
753 753753753753754 754754754754
755 755755755755 756 756756756756
757 757757757757 759 759759759759
761761761761761
762 762762762762
763 763763763763
766 766766766766771 771771771771
772 772772772772
773 773773773773
776 776776776776 778 778778778778
779 779779779779
780 780780780780
781 781781781781
782 782782782782
787 787787787787
text texttexttexttext
801 801801801801
802 802802802802
804 804804804804
805 805805805805 806 806806806806
809 809809809809
813 813813813813
815 815815815815
829 829829829829830 830830830830
834 834834834834
837 837837837837
838 838838838838839 839839839839
840 840840840840
1275 1275127512751275
1276 1276127612761276
1277 1277127712771277
1278 1278127812781278
1279 12791279127912791280 1280128012801280
1281 1281128112811281
1282 1282128212821282
1284 1284128412841284
1285 1285128512851285 1287 1287128712871287
1288 1288128812881288
1289 1289128912891289
1290 1290129012901290
1291 1291129112911291
1292 1292129212921292
1293 1293129312931293
1294 1294129412941294
1295 1295129512951295
1296 1296129612961296
1297 1297129712971297
1302 1302130213021302
1305 13051305130513051306 1306130613061306
1307 1307130713071307
1308 1308130813081308
1309 1309130913091309
1310 1310131013101310
1311 1311131113111311
1313 1313131313131313
1314 1314131413141314
1315 1315131513151315
1316 1316131613161316
1317 1317131713171317
1319 1319131913191319
1320 1320132013201320
1321 1321132113211321
1324 1324132413241324
1325 1325132513251325
1327 1327132713271327
1329 1329132913291329
1332 1332133213321332 1333 1333133313331333
1335 1335133513351335
1336 13361336133613361337 1337133713371337
1338 1338133813381338
1339 1339133913391339
1340 1340134013401340
1341 1341134113411341
1342 1342134213421342
13451345134513451345
1348 1348134813481348 1349 1349134913491349
1350 1350135013501350
1351 135113511351135113751375137513751375
1374137413741374137413731373137313731373
13721372137213721372
13571357135713571357
13561356135613561356
13551355135513551355
1704 1704170417041704
888 888888888888
889 889889889889
907 907907907907
909 909909909909
910 910910910910
911 911911911911
912 912912912912
939 939939939939
950 950950950950 952 952952952952
967 967967967967
980 980980980980981 981981981981
982 982982982982
987 987987987987
989 989989989989

CITY OF MARINA, CALIFORNIA
PHASE 3 -TREE INVENTORY EXHIBIT WITH EARTHWORK

THE DUNES
Sheet 3 of 3
Civil Engineering
Land Surveying
6 Harris Court
Monterey, California
831.649.5225
whitsonengineers.com4 / 2 6 / 2 0 2 2
Project No.:3140.18
PHASE 3 BOUNDARY

TREE HEALTH
GOOD
FAIR
POOR

TREE TO BE STUDIED FOR

POSSIBLE SAVE

ACACIA TREE

PROPOSED REMOVAL

EXISTING TREE DRIPLINE
LEGEND
NOTE:

TREE LOCATION AND HEALTH IS PER DENISE DUFFY &
ASSOCIATES, INC. (DD&A)

Marina City CouncilMay 10, 2022

Marina City Council
May 10, 2022