The City of Murrieta intends to comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Persons with special needs should call the City Clerk Department at (951) 461-6031 or email at [email protected] at least 72 hours in advance. Any writings or documents provided to a majority of the City Council regarding any item on this agenda will be made available for public inspection at the public counter at City Hall located at 1 Town Square, Murrieta, CA during normal business hours.
Any presentation requiring the use of the City of Murrieta’s equipment must be submitted to the City Clerk ’s department 24 hours prior to the scheduled City Council meeting at City Hall located at 1 Town Square, Murrieta, CA; via email at [email protected] or call (951) 461-6031. Any writings or documents provided to a majority of the City Council regarding any item on this agenda will be made available for public inspection at the public counter at City Hall located at 1 Town Square, Murrieta, CA during normal business hours.
Lori Stone
Mayor
Cindy Warren Lisa DeForest Mayor Pro Tem Council Member Jon Levell Ron Holliday Council Member Council Member Kim Summers, City Manager
Tiffany Israel, City Attorney
Cristal McDonald, City Clerk
MURRIETA CITY COUNCIL (CC)
MURRIETA COMMUNITY SERVICES DISTRICT (CSD)
MURRIETA FIRE DISTRICT (FD)
MURRIETA LIBRARY BOARD (LB)
MURRIETA REDEVELOPMENT SUCCESSOR AGENCY (RSA)
MURRIETA HOUSING AUTHORITY (HA)
MURRIETA FINANCING AUTHORITY (FA)
YOU MAY VIEW THE MEETING LIVESTREAMED VIA THE CITY’S WEBSITE AT https://murrieta.legistar.com/Calendar.aspx
CITY OF MURRIETA
Council Chambers
1 Town Square
Murrieta 92562
Tuesday, April 16, 2024
3:45 PM CLOSED SESSION
6:00 PM REGULAR MEETING
1 City Council Meeting Agenda April 16, 2024
3:45 PM CLOSED SESSION
CALL TO ORDER
ROLL CALL
PUBLIC COMMENTS - CLOSED SESSION ITEMS ONLY
ANNOUNCEMENT OF CLOSED SESSION ITEMS
CLOSED SESSION
CS1. Conference with Labor Negotiators
The City Council will conduct a closed session, pursuant to Government Code Section 54957.6, with the City Manager, the City Attorney, and the City's negotiators, regarding labor negotiations with ( 1) the Murrieta General Employees’ Association; and ( 2) the Murrieta Supervisors’ Association.
CS2. Conference with Legal Counsel - Existing Litigation The City Council will conduct a closed session, pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.9(d)(1), to confer with the City Manager, Administrative Services Director, Public Works Director, City Engineer, and legal counsel regarding 1 litigation case to which the City is a party. The title of such litigation is as follows: Procko v Murrieta; Case Number 5:22-cv-00005-JGB-SP; District Court of the Southern District of California.
CS3. Conference with Legal Counsel - Anticipated Litigation The City Council will conduct a closed session with the City Manager and legal counsel, pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.9 (d)(2), because there is significant exposure to litigation in two cases.
CS4. Conference with Legal Counsel - Existing Litigation The City Council will conduct a closed session with the City Manager, Administrative Services Director, and legal counsel, pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.95 (b), to consider the following worker’s compensation claims:
(1) Joseph Pudelwitts v. City of Murrieta. Workers Compensation Appeals Board No .
ADJ13146766, ADJ15792188, ADJ16868418, ADJ14418308; and ( 2) Sean Lawlor v .
City of Murrieta. Workers Compensation Appeals Board No. ADJ 15722126, ADJ8296622, ADJ14238781, ADJ10760142, ADJ10263049
RECESS TO CLOSED SESSION
6:00 PM REGULAR MEETING
CALL TO ORDER
ANNOUNCEMENT OF CLOSED SESSION ACTION
2 City Council Meeting Agenda April 16, 2024
ROLL CALL
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
INVOCATION
PRESENTATIONS
Presentation - Eastern Municipal Water District Project Update Presentation - Citizens City Hall Academy
Proclamation - National Crime Victims Rights Week
Proclamation - DMV Donate Life
Received After Agenda Printed - Presentations
APPROVAL OF AGENDA
CITY MANAGER - ADMINISTRATIVE UPDATE
City Manager Administrative Updates is the opportunity for the City Manager to provide community updates, as well as Department or Commission announcements on current or upcoming projects.
• City Manager: Introduction of New Assistant City Manager Justin Clifton • Economic Development Department: Update, Economic Development Director Scott Agajanian
• Police Department: Annual Report, Police Captain Matthew Henry • Public Information Officer: Community Report, Public Information Officer Cristina Davies Received After Agenda Printed - City Manager Admin Updates
GOVERNING BODY COMMISSION/COMMITTEE/BOARD (CCB) REPORTS Governing Body CCB Reports is the opportunity for the City Council to provide a brief report on conferences, seminars, and Commission, Committees, and /or Boards meeting attendance.
Reports shall not exceed three minutes. The City Clerk will use the computerized timer.
Received After Agenda Printed - GBR
3 City Council Meeting Agenda April 16, 2024
PUBLIC COMMENTS (NON-AGENDA)
At this time any person may address the governing bodies on any subject pertaining to City business, which does not relate to any item listed on the printed agenda. Normally no action may be considered or taken by the governing bodies on any matter not listed on the agenda .
Each speaker will be limited to three minutes.
Received After Agenda Printed - Public Comment (Non-Agenda) CONSENT CALENDAR - APPROVAL OF ITEMS 1 – 6
All matters listed on the Consent Calendar are to be considered routine by the governing bodies, and will be enacted by one motion in the form listed. There will be no discussion of these items unless, before the governing body votes on the motion to adopt, specific items are removed from the Consent Calendar for separate motions.
1. Waive Reading of All Ordinance Adoptions on the Agenda and Read by Title Only Recommended Action:
Waive reading, by title only, of all Ordinances and Resolutions. Said Ordinances and Resolutions which appear on the public agenda shall be determined to have been read by title and further reading waived.
2. Minutes
Recommended Action:
Approve the minutes of the April 2, 2024 City Council Regular Meeting.
3. New Contract Services Agreements for Building and Safety Recommended Action:
Award on-call consultant services agreements to BPR Consulting, Interwest, and True North Compliance Services for building inspection, plan check, and other miscellaneous services for the Building and Safety Division;
Approve the agreements in not -to-exceed amounts of $650,000 combined in total per fiscal year or the available budget; and
Authorize the City Manager to execute the agreements.
4. Professional Services Agreement - Market Research and Analysis Recommended Action:
Authorize the City Manager to enter into a two -year agreement for market research and analysis services with up to three one -year optional extensions with The Retail Coach, LLC, in a form acceptable to the City Attorney. The total contract sum shall not exceed $137,500.00 over the entire contract term.
4 City Council Meeting Agenda April 16, 2024
5. First Amendment to MGEA MOU 2022-24 Addressing Market Nights Event Pay and Schedule Issues
Recommended Action:
Adopt Resolution No. 24-4732 entitled: A Resolution of the City Council of the City of Murrieta, California, Accepting, Approving, and Adopting the First Amendment to the Memorandum of Understanding between the City of Murrieta and the Murrieta General Employee’s Association for the period July 1, 2022, through June 30, 2024.
6. Delayed Approval to Purchase and Upfitting of Police Vehicles from FY 2022/23 Budget
Recommended Action:
Ratify the purchase of three police vehicles from Phil Long Dealerships, Inc.; and Approve an additional appropriation of $15,641.67 from the Supplemental Law Enforcement Fund (Fund 411) for this purchase in the Fiscal Year 2023/24 Operating Budget.
PUBLIC HEARINGS
7. Adoption of Development Impact Fees and Nexus Study
Recommended Action:
Conduct a Public Hearing related to updating the City’s Development Impact Fees; Adopt Resolution No. 24-4733 entitled: A Resolution of the City Council of the City of Murrieta, California, Approving an Update of the Public Facilities Development Impact Fee Schedule and Amending the City’s Fee Schedule; and
Adopt Resolution No. 24-4734 entitled: A Resolution of the City Council of the City of Murrieta, California, Adopting a Development Impact Fee Nexus Study, which Includes the Five-Year Fee Report (AB1600) for the Fiscal Year 2022/23 and Making Findings Required by the Mitigation Fee Act.
GOVERNING BODY ANNOUNCEMENTS
Governing Body Announcements is the opportunity for the City Council to provide miscellaneous reports and announcements. Announcements shall not exceed two minutes .
The City Clerk will use the computerized timer.
Received After Agenda Printed - GBA
COUNCIL MEMBER REQUESTS TO ADD OR WITHDRAW ITEMS TO FUTURE AGENDAS
ADJOURNMENT
Received After Agenda Printed - Adjournment Slide
5 CITY OF MURRIETA
City Council Meeting Agenda
Report
5/7/2024
Agenda Item No. CS2.
Subject:
Conference with Labor Negotiators
The City Council will conduct a closed session, pursuant to Government Code Section 54957.6, with the City Manager, the City Attorney, and the City's negotiators, regarding labor negotiations with (1) the Murrieta General Employees’ Association; and (2) the Murrieta Supervisors’ Association.
CITY OF MURRIETA Printed on 5/2/2024Page 1 of 1
powered by Legistar™
6 CITY OF MURRIETA
City Council Meeting Agenda
Report
4/16/2024
Agenda Item No. CS2.
Subject:
Conference with Legal Counsel - Existing Litigation
The City Council will conduct a closed session, pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.9(d)(1), to confer with the City Manager, Administrative Services Director, Public Works Director, City Engineer, and legal counsel regarding 1 litigation case to which the City is a party. The title of such litigation is as follows: Procko v Murrieta; Case Number 5:22-cv-00005-JGB-SP; District Court of the Southern District of California.
CITY OF MURRIETA Printed on 4/11/2024Page 1 of 1
powered by Legistar™
7 CITY OF MURRIETA
City Council Meeting Agenda
Report
4/16/2024
Agenda Item No. CS3.
Subject:
Conference with Legal Counsel - Anticipated Litigation
The City Council will conduct a closed session with the City Manager and legal counsel, pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.9 (d)(2), because there is significant exposure to litigation in two cases.
CITY OF MURRIETA Printed on 4/11/2024Page 1 of 1
powered by Legistar™
8 CITY OF MURRIETA
City Council Meeting Agenda
Report
4/16/2024
Agenda Item No. CS4.
Subject:
Conference with Legal Counsel - Existing Litigation
The City Council will conduct a closed session with the City Manager, Administrative Services Director, and legal counsel, pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.95 (b), to consider the following worker’s compensation claims:
(1) Joseph Pudelwitts v. City of Murrieta. Workers Compensation Appeals Board No. ADJ13146766, ADJ15792188, ADJ16868418, ADJ14418308; and (2) Sean Lawlor v. City of Murrieta. Workers Compensation Appeals Board No. ADJ15722126, ADJ8296622, ADJ14238781, ADJ10760142, ADJ10263049
CITY OF MURRIETA Printed on 4/11/2024Page 1 of 1
powered by Legistar™
9 CITY OF MURRIETA
City Council Meeting Agenda
Report
4/16/2024
Agenda Item No.
Subject:
Received After Agenda Printed - Presentations
CITY OF MURRIETA Printed on 4/23/2024Page 1 of 1
powered by Legistar™
10 Los Alamos Hills Water
Facilities Project
Nick Kanetis, P .E.
April 16, 2024
Received After Agenda Printed
04/16/2024 - Regular Meeting
Staff Presentation
11 2
Project Background
• In early 2022 the City of Murrieta approached
EMWD seeking municipal water service for the Los
Alamos Hills community:
– Rural residential community
– Reliant on private water wells for their water
supply and fire prevention
– Report of failing wells
– Area not annexed into the Metropolitan Water
District of Southern California (MWD) or
EMWD’s service areas
– Approximately $3 million of ARPA funding
available
• Objective
– Provide safe and reliable water supply to the
Los Alamos Hills community
– Further the strong partnership and
collaboration between EMWD and the City of
Murrieta
12 3
Extensive Public Outreach
• Extensive outreach to inform the community
of the opportunity for a safe and reliable water
service.
– Letters, emails, town halls, a Los Alamos
neighborhood event, and notary meetings
• Explained the construction scope, the
annexation process and the costs involved.
• Provided an overview of the dual annexation
process required to expand MWD and EMWD’s
service area to accommodate residents
interested in connecting to the new water
system.
• Property owners were informed of their
responsibility to pay for required annexation
and connection fees.
13 4
Planning and Design Process
• In response to the City’s request, EMWD
prepared initial and final water system
designs and cost estimates.
• EMWD prepared financial assessments for
annexation and connections.
• EMWD and City staff worked with property
owners to gauge interest in connecting to
the new water system and navigate the
annexation process.
• EMWD led the Local Agency Formation
(LAFCO) process on behalf of the residents.
• Approximately 50 properties were
approached for annexation potential;
ultimately 36 opted to proceed.
Los Alamos Road
14 5
Project Costs
• A comprehensive project cost
estimate was developed including:
– Engineering & design
– CEQA
– Contract administration
– Construction
– Water services including fire
hydrants, and other related
appurtenances
– Paving rehabilitation
• Total estimated cost for the project
approximately $4.8 million.
• City provided ARPA funding
approximately $3.3 million.
15 6
Financing Program
• EMWD developed a specialized financing
program for each property to assist
property owners that committed to
connect to the new water system.
– Financing program will cover the
annexation cost and connection fees
– 30-year term @ 4% paid twice annually
with property tax
• Intent is to ease the financial burden
associated with annexation and connection
costs.
Mason Avenue
16 7
Project Details
• A looped water system from an existing
pressure zone available to serve the entire
Los Alamos Hills community.
• Pipelines to be installed along Los Alamos
Road, Mason Avenue, Mary Place, Celia
Road and Ruth Ellen Way.
• Project includes installation of:
– Approximately 2.2 miles of new pipeline
(8- and 12-inch diameter)
– Water services, fire hydrants, and related
appurtenances
17 8
Participating Property Owner Responsibilities
• EMWD will construct water services up to
the property line where the water meter
will be placed.
• Property owners are solely responsible for
their own onsite plumbing from the meter
to their house, and disconnection of any
well water to the residence.
• Property owners may continue use of their
wells for any outdoor use and landscape
watering.
• EMWD is working with property owners for
preferred meter locations, with ongoing
coordination efforts in place to ensure
community satisfaction.
18 9
Construction Contract Award
• The project was bid in September 2023
(five bids were received).
• SEMA Construction, Inc., based in San
Diego, California, was the lowest
responsive and responsible bidder, with a
bid of $3,498,562.
– Contract Start: December 2023
– Contract Duration: 365 calendar days
19 10
Construction Progress
• Initial construction activities included
potholing, contractor mobilization and
procurement operations.
• Water pipeline installation is now
underway on Celia Road and will turn the
corner onto Mary Place the week of April
15 th.
• Traffic control and any required road
closures will be carefully coordinated with
the City.
– Full closure of Los Alamos Road during
recent spring break with advance
noticing to the City, Rail Ranch School
and others in the community.
• Project is off to a good start and is
expected to be completed on schedule.
20 11
Construction Progress
Los Alamos Road
Celia Road
Celia Road
21 12
Construction Progress – Celia Road
22 13
Communication and Coordination
• Staff sends construction and schedule
updates to the community.
• Ongoing communication to address
inquiries from neighboring property
owners regarding potential future
connections beyond the project's current
scope.
• Staff is actively realigning the pipeline as
necessary as field conditions permit, to
avoid a road closure and to minimize
traffic disruptions, particularly along Los
Alamos Road.
• Continuous community interaction and
feedback on preferred meter location (via
stake placement) and appurtenance
locations to accommodate requests and
ensure customer satisfaction.
23 14
Project Completion
• Ongoing communication and
coordination with the City and
Community will ensure timely
delivery.
• Project completion anticipated by
December 2024.
At the City’s request, the pavement restoration on
Mason Avenue will repair the trench using a 4-inch
layer of asphalt concrete pavement laid over a 4-
inch aggregate base material. A 2-inch overlay of
asphalt will be applied over top across the entire
width of the existing pavement.
Mason Avenue
24 15
Questions?
25 Contact Information
Joe Mouawad, P .E.
General Manager
(951) 928-3777
[email protected]
Nick Kanetis, P .E.
Deputy General Manager
Operations and Maintenance Branch
Planning, Engineering and Construction Branch
(951) 928-3777 Ext. 6161
[email protected]
Roxanne Rountree
Public Affairs Manager
Public & Governmental Affairs
(951) 928-3777 Ext. 4391
Cell: (951) 203-2813
[email protected] 26
Current Waitlist 3/24
103,233
vs.
106,000 - 4/2023
106,000- 4/2022
2023
Another Record Year of Lives
Saved by Organ Donors!
46,630 Transplants
Vs.
42,800 – 2022
42.394- 2021
California
5,290 Transplants
Vs
4866- 2022
4693- 2021
* 239 (Children)
California
21,010 Waiting
vs.
24,441- 2023
*472 (Children)
Received After Agenda Printed
04/16/2024 - Regular Meeting
Staff Presentation 27
CITY OF MURRIETA
City Council Meeting Agenda
Report
4/16/2024
Agenda Item No.
Subject:
Received After Agenda Printed - City Manager Admin Updates CITY OF MURRIETA Printed on 4/23/2024Page 1 of 1
powered by Legistar™
28 Economic Development
Department Update
Scott Agajanian
Economic Development Director
04/02/2024
Received After Agenda Printed
04/16/2024 - Regular Meeting
City Manager - Administrative Update
29 2
6 MEDICAL
RESTAURANTS1
AUTO DEALERS2
RETAIL CENTERS3
TRIANGLE4
HOTELS5
30 3
Business Updates 31
4 1. RESTAURANTS
32 5
DINING COMING SOON
33 6
2. Auto Dealers
34 7
35 8
3. Retail Centers
36 9
REDEVELOPING
EXISTING CENTERS:
The Orchard
The Vineyard
Murrieta Town Center
Village Walk
Walmart
37 10
4. Triangle
38 11
5. Hotels
39 12
HOMEWOOD SUITES
MURRIETA
ANTELOPE ROAD AND
MAKENA AVENUE
MURRIETA, CA 92562
40 13
6. Medical
41 14
THANK YOU!
42 Received After Agenda Printed
04/16/2024 - Regular Meeting
City Manager - Administrative Update Police Department
43 44
45 46
47 48
49 50
51 52
53 54
55 56
57 58
59 60
61 62
63 64
What’s going on in
Murrieta?
Cristina Davies, Public Information Officer
April 16, 2024
Received After Agenda Printed
04/16/2024 - Regular Meeting
City Manager - Administrative Update
65 2
Events
Jazz and Blues Festival
• April 20 and 21
• Murrieta Amphitheater
• Tickets MurrietaAmphitheater.com
66 67
68 69
6 Stay Connected
https://www.murrietaca.gov/Jobs
https://www.murrietaca.gov/Connect
70 CITY OF MURRIETA
City Council Meeting Agenda
Report
4/16/2024
Agenda Item No.
Subject:
Received After Agenda Printed - GBR
CITY OF MURRIETA Printed on 4/23/2024Page 1 of 1
powered by Legistar™
71 MURRIETA CITY COUNCIL
Governing Body Reports:
Mayor Pro Tem Warren
April 16, 2024
Received After Agenda Printed
04/16/2024 - Regular Meeting
Presentation (GBR)
72 Governing Body Reports:
Mayor Pro Tem Warren
[email protected]
April 10, 2024 Attended the Riverside County Transportation Commission meeting in Riverside.
The Commission passed/voted on the following Items:
• Updated the Draft 2024 Traffic Relief Plan Public Outreach and Engagement Summary.
• Adopted the 2024 Traffic Relief Plan.
• Directed Staff to Draft an ACA-1 Compliant Ordinance and Expenditure Plan to Fund Eligible Projects in the 2024 Traffic Relief Plan. 73 Governing Body Reports:
Mayor Pro Tem Warren
[email protected]
74 MURRIETA CITY COUNCIL
Governing Body Reports:
Council Member Holliday
April 16, 2024
Received After Agenda Printed
04/16/2024 - Regular Meeting
Presentation (GBR)
75 Governing Body Reports:
Council Member Holliday
[email protected]
April 10, 2024 Traveled to Riverside for Local Agency Formation Commission’s City Selection meeting that was canceled due to a power outage. 76 CITY OF MURRIETA
City Council Meeting Agenda
Report
4/16/2024
Agenda Item No.
Subject:
Received After Agenda Printed - Public Comment (Non-Agenda) CITY OF MURRIETA Printed on 4/23/2024Page 1 of 1
powered by Legistar™
77 78
79 CITY OF MURRIETA
City Council Meeting Agenda
Report
6/4/2024
Agenda Item No. 1.
TO: HONORABLE MAYOR AND MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL
FROM: Cristal McDonald, City Clerk
PREPARED BY: Kimberly Ramirez, Deputy City Clerk
SUBJECT:
Waive Reading of All Ordinance Adoptions on the Agenda and Read by Title Only
RECOMMENDATION
Waive reading, by title only, of all Ordinances and Resolutions. Said Ordinances and Resolutions which appear on the public agenda shall be determined to have been read by title and further reading waived.
CITY OF MURRIETA Printed on 5/30/2024Page 1 of 1
powered by Legistar™
80 CITY OF MURRIETA
City Council Meeting Agenda
Report
4/16/2024
Agenda Item No. 2.
TO: HONORABLE MAYOR AND MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL
FROM: Cristal McDonald, City Clerk
PREPARED BY: Kimberly Ramirez, Deputy City Clerk
SUBJECT:
Minutes
RECOMMENDATION
Approve the minutes of the April 2, 2024 City Council Regular Meeting.
ATTACHMENTS
1. April 2, 2024 Minutes
CITY OF MURRIETA Printed on 4/11/2024Page 1 of 1
powered by Legistar™
81 CITY OF MURRIETA Tuesday, April 2, 2024
Council Chambers 4:00 PM CLOSED SESSION
1 Town Square 6:00 PM REGULAR MEETING
Murrieta 92562 MINUTES
The City of Murrieta intends to comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Persons with special needs should call the City Clerk Department at (951) 461-6031 or email at [email protected] at least 72 hours in advance. Any writings or documents provided to a majority of the City Council regarding any item on this agenda will be made available for public inspection at the public counter at City Hall located at 1 Town Square, Murrieta, CA during normal business hours.
Any presentation requiring the use of the City of Murrieta’s equipment must be submitted to the City Clerk’s department 24 hours prior to the scheduled City Council meeting at City Hall located at 1 Town Square, Murrieta, CA; via email at [email protected] or call (951) 461-6031. Any writings or documents provided to a majority of the City Council regarding any item on this agenda will be made available for public inspection at the public counter at City Hall located at 1 Town Square, Murrieta, CA during normal business hours.
Lori Stone
Mayor
Cindy Warren Lisa DeForest Mayor Pro Tem Council Member Jon Levell Ron Holliday Council Member Council Member Kim Summers, City Manager
Tiffany Israel, City Attorney
Cristal McDonald, City Clerk
MURRIETA CITY COUNCIL (CC)
MURRIETA COMMUNITY SERVICES DISTRICT (CSD)
MURRIETA FIRE DISTRICT (FD)
MURRIETA LIBRARY BOARD (LB)
MURRIETA REDEVELOPMENT SUCCESSOR AGENCY (RSA)
MURRIETA HOUSING AUTHORITY (HA)
MURRIETA FINANCING AUTHORITY (FA)
YOU MAY VIEW THE MEETING LIVESTREAMED VIA THE CITY’S WEBSITE AT https://murrieta.legistar.com/Calendar.aspx
4:00 PM CLOSED SESSION
CALL TO ORDER 4:00 p.m.
ROLL CALL
Present: Council Member Jon Levell
Council Member Ron Holliday
Mayor Pro Tem Cindy Warren
Mayor Lori Stone
Absent: Council Member Lisa DeForest (Arrived late)
82 City Council April 2, 2024
PUBLIC COMMENTS - CLOSED SESSION ITEMS ONLY None
ANNOUNCEMENT OF CLOSED SESSION ITEMS
City Clerk Cristal McDonald announced the following Closed Session items:
CLOSED SESSION
CS1. Conference with Labor Negotiators
The City Council will conduct a closed session, pursuant to Government Code section 54957.6, with the city manager, the city attorney, and the City's negotiators, regarding labor negotiations with (1) the Murrieta General Employees’ Association; and (2) the Murrieta Supervisors’ Association.
CS2. Conference with Legal Counsel - Anticipated Litigation The City Council will conduct a closed session, pursuant to Government Code sections 54956.9(d)(2), because there is a significant exposure to litigation in three cases.
RECESS TO CLOSED SESSION 4:02 p.m.
6:00 PM REGULAR MEETING
CALL TO ORDER 6:08 p.m.
ANNOUNCEMENT OF CLOSED SESSION ACTION
City Attorney Tiffany Israel: No reportable action on Closed Session Item Nos. CS1-CS2.
ROLL CALL
Present: Council Member Lisa DeForest
Council Member Jon Levell
Council Member Ron Holliday
Mayor Pro Tem Cindy Warren
Mayor Lori Stone
City Clerk Cristal McDonald later confirmed that Council Member DeForest was present for all of Closed Session.
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Carol Holler
INVOCATION Pastor Salvador Rangel, Calvary Baptist Church
PRESENTATIONS
Proclamation - Innovation Month
Proclamation - Retirement, Ivan Holler, Assistant City Manager 83 City Council April 2, 2024
APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Action: It was moved by Mayor Pro Tem Warren, seconded by Council Member DeForest to approve the Agenda for April 2, 2024.
The motion carried by the following vote:
Ayes: DeForest, Levell, Holliday, Warren, Stone
Noes: None
CITY MANAGER - ADMINISTRATIVE UPDATE
City Manager Kim Summers introduced the following department updates/announcements:
• Public Information: Community Report, Public Information Officer Cristina Davies
GOVERNING BODY COMMISSION/COMMITTEE/BOARD (CCB) REPORTS Council Member Holliday: Provided attendance/reported the following:
Local Agency Formation Commission
Riverside Conservation Authority
Mayor Pro Tem Warren: Provided attendance/reported the following:
Southwest Elected Leaders’ Collaborative
Riverside Transit Agency Commission
Mayor Stone: Provided attendance/reported the following:
Southwest Elected Leaders’ Collaborative
PUBLIC COMMENTS (NON-AGENDA)
Maricela Veldhuizen: Spoke on public safety concerns and accountability.
Aimee Edgeworth: Spoke about a train project.
CONSENT CALENDAR - APPROVAL OF ITEMS 1 – 13
Action: It was moved by Council Member Holliday, seconded by Council Member DeForest to approve Consent Calendar Item Nos. 1-13, with the exception of Item No. 11 that was pulled for discussion.
The motion carried by the following vote:
Ayes: DeForest, Levell, Holliday, Warren, Stone
Noes: None
84 City Council April 2, 2024
1. Waive Reading of All Ordinance Adoptions on the Agenda and Read by Title Only Recommended Action:
Waive reading, by title only, of all Ordinances and Resolutions. Said Ordinances and Resolutions which appear on the public agenda shall be determined to have been read by title and further reading waived.
2. Minutes
Recommended Action:
Approve the minutes of the March 19, 2024 City Council Regular Meeting.
3. Check Register February 2024
Recommended Action:
Adopt Resolution No. 24-4728 entitled: A Resolution of the City Council of the City of Murrieta, California, Ratifying the Check Register for the Month of February 2024 in the amount of $3,050,764.82 (Check Numbers 158232-158720).
4. Monthly Investment Transaction Report for February 2024 Recommended Action:
Receive and file the Monthly Investment Transaction Report for February 2024.
5. Agreement with Blue Violet Networks for Telephone Support Services Recommended Action:
Approve a three-year agreement with Blue Violet Networks for Managed Services Support of the City’s Mitel Telephone Systems in the amount of $56,278.80; and Authorize the City Manager to execute the agreement and related documents.
6. Agreement Renewal with Brightly Software, Inc. for Computerized Maintenance Management Software
Recommended Action:
Authorize an agreement renewal with Brightly Software, Inc. (formerly Dude Solutions, Inc.) for Computerized Maintenance Management Software in the amount of $44,491.56 for Fiscal Year 2024/25;
Authorize the City Manager to execute all necessary documents for services for an additional two fiscal years, 2025/26 and 2026/27; and
Authorize using the Sourcewell Cooperative Contract 090320-SDI to procure the services from Brightly Software, Inc.
7. Housing Element and General Plan Annual Progress Reports 2023 Recommended Action:
Receive and accept public testimony regarding the Murrieta Housing Element Annual Progress Report and General Plan Annual Progress Report for calendar year 2023; and 85 City Council April 2, 2024
Authorize the documents to be submitted to the State Department of Housing and Community Development and the Governor’s Office of Planning and Research.
8. American Rescue Plan Act Project Update
Recommended Action:
Approve the reallocation of $2,000,000 in American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funding originally allocated to the California Oaks Sports Park Pool Project (CIP 22025) to the Amphitheater Parking Lot Project (CIP 10041);
Amend the Fiscal Year 2023/24 Capital Improvement Budget to remove ARPA funding from the California Oaks Sports Park Pool Project (22025) and reallocate it to the Town Square Park Amphitheater Parking Project (10041);
Approve the reallocation of the remaining ARPA funding of $134,932 budgeted for the COVID-19 PPE Expenses program (50115) and allocate this funding to the construction of several Pickleball courts in existing public parks; and Approve the transfer of ARPA interest earnings to the City’s local funds.
9. Agreement with GovInvest, Inc.
Recommended Action:
Authorize a three-year software licensing agreement with GovInvest, Inc.; Authorize the City Manager to execute all necessary documents for a period of three years;
Authorize the City Council to waive the bidding requirements; and Appropriate additional funding in the Fiscal Years 2023/24 and 2024/25 Operating Budget.
10. Image Trend Consultant Account Services
Recommended Action:
Approve an agreement with Image Trend, LLC for system account advisement services; and
Authorize the City Manager to execute the Work Order Agreement.
12. Acceptance of CalRecycle Rubberized Pavement Grant, Amend CIP Budget, and Appropriation of Funds
Recommended Action:
Authorize the City Manager to accept the CalRecycle Grant No. TRP16-23-0020 award in the amount of $145,720 from the State of California Environmental Protection Agency;
86 City Council April 2, 2024
Ratify execution of the grant agreement;
Amend the Fiscal Year 2023/24 Capital Improvement Plan Budget to appropriate an expenditure budget in CIP Project No. 13047; and
Amend the Fiscal Year 2023/24 Operating Budget to appropriate a grant revenue budget.
13. Parcel Charge for National Pollution Discharge Elimination System Program Recommended Action:
Adopt Resolution No. 24-4729 entitled: A Resolution of the City Council of Murrieta, California, Requesting that the County of Riverside Levy the Fiscal Year 2024/25 Community Service Area 152 Parcel Charge and Requesting Continued Participation in Community Service Area 152 ;
Direct the City Clerk to certify approval of the Resolution and submit a certified copy to the County of Riverside; and
Amend the Fiscal Year 2024/25 Operating Budget to match the estimated levy amount.
PULLED CONSENT CALENDAR ITEMS
11. Delayed Purchase and Upfitting of Police Vehicles from FY 2022/23 Budget Police Chief Anthony Conrad and City Manager Kim Summers responded to Council Member Levell’s questions; and answered additional questions from the City Council.
Public Comments:
Terry Gilmore: Spoke to and requested the City look into purchasing vehicles from local dealerships.
Action: After discussion, it was moved by Council Member Levell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Warren, to postpone the purchase of the vehicles to the next City Council in order to provide an opportunity to local dealerships.
Ayes:
Noes:
Absent:
The motion carried by the following vote:
Warren, Levell, Holliday, Stone, Deforest
None
None
87 City Council April 2, 2024
DISCUSSION
14. Amending to the Comprehensive Salary Schedule for Fiscal Year 2023/24 Staff report and PowerPoint presentation provided by Human Resources Analyst Michelle Tamez. Administrative Services Director Diego Chavez was available to answer questions from the City Council.
Public Comments:
None
Action: After review and discussion, it was moved by Council Member Holliday, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Warren to adopt Resolution No. 24-4730, entitled: A Resolution of the City Council of the City of Murrieta, California, Amending the Comprehensive Salary Schedule for Fiscal Year 2023/24.
Ayes:
Noes:
Absent:
The motion carried by the following vote:
Warren, Levell, Holliday, Stone, Deforest
None
None
15. Conduct a Discussion and Adopt Resolution No. 24-4731 to Confirm the Statements of Costs and Approve Special Assessments to be Levied on the Property Tax Bill for Nuisance Abatements on Three Properties
Staff report and PowerPoint presentation provided by Code Enforcement Supervisor Nolan Berentis. Development Services Director David Chantarangsu was available to answer questions from the City Council.
Public Comments:
None
Action: After review and discussion, it was moved by Council Member DeForest, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Warren to:
Adopt Resolution No. 24-4731 entitled: A Resolution of the City Council of the City of Murrieta, California Confirming Statements of Costs and Authorizing a Special Assessment on Properties for Recovery of Nuisance Abatement Costs on the following properties:
A. 25490 Blackthorne Drive
B. 29500 Via Princesa
C.24189 Saradella Court; and
Establish a revenue budget of $21,305.87 in the Fiscal Year 2024/25 Operating Budget.
88 City Council April 2, 2024
Ayes:
Noes:
Absent:
The motion carried by the following vote:
Warren, Levell, Holliday, Stone, Deforest
None
None
16. Presentation and Review of the City of Murrieta’s Fiscal Year 2022/23 Annual Comprehensive Financial Report and Single Audit Report
Staff report and PowerPoint presentation provided by Finance Manager Jennifer Terry and Brianna Schultz from Rogers, Anderson, Malody & Scott, LLP. Finance Director Javier Carcamo was available to answer questions from the City Council.
Public Comments:
None
Action: After review and discussion, it was moved by Council Member Holliday, seconded by Council Member DeForest to receive and file the Fiscal Year 2022/23 Annual Comprehensive Financial and Single Audit Reports.
Ayes:
Noes:
Absent:
The motion carried by the following vote:
Warren, Levell, Holliday, Stone, Deforest
None
None
17. Code Enforcement Policy Subcommittee and Southwest Elected Leaders Collaborative Appointment Review
Staff report and PowerPoint presentation provided by City Clerk Cristal McDonald.
Public Comments:
None
Action: After review and discussion, it was moved by Council Member Holliday, seconded by Council Member DeForest to:
Establish by minute order:
A Code Enforcement Policy Ad Hoc Subcommittee, with the sunset of the subcommittee upon a final recommendation to the City Council; and Appoint Council Member Holliday and Mayor Stone to serve on the Code Enforcement Policy Ad Hoc Subcommittee.
Review appointments to the Southwest Riverside County Elected Leaders Collaborative; Council Member Holliday withdrew his membership. Mayor Pro Tem Warren was nominated and appointed as a delegate. 89 City Council April 2, 2024
Ayes:
Noes:
Absent:
The motion carried by the following vote:
Warren, Levell, Holliday, Stone, Deforest
None
None
GOVERNING BODY ANNOUNCEMENTS
Council Member DeForest provided verbal Governing Body Announcements, and Council Member Holliday, Mayor Pro Tem Warren, and Mayor Stone provided their Governing Body Announcements to be made part of the City’s record.
COUNCIL MEMBER WITHDRAWS AND REQUESTS TO ADD ITEMS TO FUTURE
AGENDAS
Council Member DeForest: None
Council Member Levell: None
Council Member Holliday: None
Mayor Pro Tem Warren: None
Mayor Stone: None
ADJOURNMENT 8:25 p.m.
Mayor Stone adjourned the meeting quoting Laura Bush in honor of Library Week. “Libraries offer, for free, the wisdom of the ages—and sages—and, simply put, there’s something for everyone inside.”
Cristal McDonald, City Clerk
90 CITY OF MURRIETA
City Council Meeting Agenda
Report
4/16/2024
Agenda Item No. 3.
TO: HONORABLE MAYOR AND MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL
FROM: David Chantarangsu, AICP - Development Services Director PREPARED BY: Andy Krogh, Building Official
SUBJECT:
On-Call Consultant Services Agreements for Building and Safety Services
RECOMMENDATION
Award on-call consultant services agreements to BPR Consulting, Interwest, and True North Compliance Services for building inspection, plan check, and other miscellaneous services for the Building and Safety Division;
Approve the agreements in not-to-exceed amounts of $650,000 combined in total per fiscal year or the available budget; and
Authorize the City Manager to execute the agreements.
PRIOR ACTION/VOTE
None.
CITY COUNCIL GOAL
Maintain a high performing organization that values fiscal sustainability, transparency, accountability and organizational efficiency.
BACKGROUND
The Development Services Department Building and Safety Division issued a Request for Proposals (RFP) for consulting services to retain qualified consultants to assist with building inspection and plan check services, Certified Access Specialist (CAS) services, miscellaneous services, such as general training, and code updates and adoption support on an on-call, as-needed basis.
The City of Murrieta (City) provided an average of 38,015 inspections and issued 3,144 permits for the two years covering 2022 through 2023. From time to time, consultant building services are needed to maintain adequate inspection coverage and plan checking. The current on-call service providers reviewed 145 plan checks with a total of 366 plan reviews performed, including over 600 specialized reviews such as mechanical, electrical, and plumbing systems. On-call consultants also provide over 1,500 hours of inspection and permit CITY OF MURRIETA Printed on 4/11/2024Page 1 of 2
powered by Legistar™
91 4/16/2024
Agenda Item No. 3.
technician services.
On October 12, 2023, the City’sRFP was posted on the PlanetBids website. Proposals were due to the City on December 12, 2023. Building and Safety received 16 proposals from the following firms:
- 4leaf Inc.
- ABS Consulting
- Bureau Veritas
- True North Compliance Services
- CSG
- HR Green Pacific
- JAS
- BPR Consulting
- NV5
- Transtech Engineer
- TRB and Associates
- Universal Engineering Sciences
- VCA - The Code Group
- West Coast Code Consultants
- Willdan
- Interwest
The proposals were reviewed and evaluated by the Building Official for responsiveness to the City’sRFP, as well as for consultant qualifications and the cost of services. The top five proposers (BPR Consulting, Interwest, True North Compliance Services, CSG, and TRB and Associates) were interviewed by staff. Only the top three consultants (Attachments 1-3) are recommended by staff to receive a contract. They are BPR Consulting, Interwest, and True North Compliance Services (Consultants). Contract material from each recommended consultant is attached (Attachments 4-6) for the City Council’s reference.
FISCAL IMPACT
Historically, staff has used building consulting firms for large plan checks where staff expertise may not be sufficient to provide an adequate review. In addition, on-call building inspection services are used when staffing availability is not sufficient to cover inspection demands. In previous fiscal years, the Building Division has expended $258,131.59 for plan checking and $149,091.27 for inspection services. These costs were recovered through plan check and permit fees as well as salary savings from vacant positions. Although the requested contracts total $650,000 for all Consultants, there is no guarantee that any one Consultant will be tasked to provide any services to the City. Funds typically become available for these contract services as plan check and permit fees and/or salary savings allow.
Total compensation for all services provided by Consultant(s) combined shall not exceed $650,000 per year or the available budgeted amount. General Ledger Account 1104600-60480 will be used for this expense.
ATTACHMENTS
1. BPR Consulting Proposal
2. Interwest Proposal
3. True North Compliance Services Proposal
4. BPR Consulting Contract
5. Interwest Contract
6. True North Compliance Services Contract
CITY OF MURRIETA Printed on 4/11/2024Page 2 of 2
powered by Legistar™
92 December 12, 2023
C
ity of Murrieta
Building Division
1 Town Square
Murrieta, CA 92562
RE
: Compensation Schedule | On-Call, As-Needed Building Division Services Attached you will find BPR Consulting Group’s proposed Compensation Schedule as requested in the City’s RFP for On-Call, As Needed Building Division Services. Our proposal to provide Building Division Services in response to the RFP has been submitted electronically in a separate file.
Please feel free to contact me directly if you have any questions or would like any additional information.
Sincerely,
BPR CONSULTING GROUP
R
on Beehler, SE, CBO
Principal / Director of Client Services
916.204.3178
[email protected]
Exhibit C1
93 COMPENSATION SCHEDULE
PLAN REVIEW SERVICES: For complete plan review services for building projects reviewed in electronic format, we propose a fee equal to 65% of the plan review fees based on the City‘s adopted fee schedule. Plan review services will include an initial first review and two back check reviews of the plans. Any additional plan review services required beyond the third review will be billed at our hourly rates listed within the Schedule of Hourly Billing Rates shown below. Expedited plan checks will be billed at 150% of the standard rate.
For review of projects for which a fixed fee basis is not identified within the City’s Fee Schedule, for revisions to approved plans, review of deferred submittal items and similar reviews, we propose to provide these services on an hourly basis using the rates listed in our Schedule of Hourly Billing Rates shown below. There is no charge for shipping, supply, or material costs.
Plan r eviews that are provided on an hourly basis will include minimal fees for our in-office Plan Coordinator/Technician services.
INSPECTION AND PERMIT TECHNICIAN SERVICES: Inspection and Permit Technician services will be provided at the hourly rates listed in our Schedule of Hourly Billing Rates.
SUPPORT SERVICES: For Building Official and other Community Development Department support services, we propose utilizing the hourly billing rates included in the Schedule of Hourly Billing Rates below for the specific labor classification utilized.
SCHEDULE OF HOURLY BILLING RATES
The rates displayed in the schedule below reflect BPR’s current hourly billing rates.
CLASSIFICATION HOURLY BILLING RATE
Licensed Plan Review Engineer (structural, civil, electrical, mechanical) ..................................... $145 Building Official ................................................................................................................................ $150 ICC Certified Plans Examiner ........................................................................................................... $125 CASp Plans Examiner or Inspector .................................................................................................. $130 ICC Certified Inspector* ........................................................................................................ $95 to $115 Permit Technician/Plan Coordinator ................................................................................................ $75 Permit Technician Trainee/ Building Department Support Staff ..................................................... $55 * Billing rate varies based on experience and qualifications Notes
Shipping: There is no charge for courier or shipping services for plan reviews conducted off site. Overtime: Inspection services and other hourly services provided in excess of eight hours per day, nights, weekends and holidays will be charged at 150% of the regular billing rate. Mileage: Vehicle mileage utilized in the performance of inspection services is included in our proposed hourly rates for building inspection services.
Expedited Plan Review: Expedited reviews can be provided upon request. Fees for expedited plan review services will be 150% of the above noted hourly rates.
Exhibit C2
94 Minimum Daily Charge: There will be a minimum 8 -hour daily charge for all on -call inspection, permit technician and support services provided within City offices
TURNAROUND TIMES
Standard Plan Review Completion Timeframes
We complete all plan reviews within the timeframes shown below for both commercial and residential projects as our standard business practice. We will accommodate any turnaround schedule agreed to with our clients.
We can provide expedited plan review services when requested.
Project Type
Maximum Turn Around Time
(Working Days)
Initial Submittal Backcheck Reviews
Expedited Review,
Initial and
Backcheck Reviews
Residential (Single Family)
New Construction 10 5 5
Addition 10 5 5
Remodel 10 5 5
Non-Residential
New Construction 10 5 5
Addition 10 5 5
Remodel, Tenant Improvement 10 5 5
Exhibit C3
95 Proposal to Provide
On-Call, As-Needed Building Division Services
Prepared by:
BPR Consulting Group
6856 Sundance Trail
Riverside, CA 92506
December 12, 2023
Prepared for:
City of Murrieta
Building Division
1 Town Square
Murrieta, CA 92562
Exhibit D1
96 SECTION A
COVER LETTER
December 12, 2023
City of Murrieta
Building Division
1 Town Square
Murrieta, CA 92562
RE: Proposal | On-Call, As-Needed Building Division Services Thank you for the opportunity to present this proposal in response to the City of M urrieta’s RFP for Building Division Consulting Services. We understand that the City of Murrieta is seeking to partner with highly qualified and experienced firms to assist the City with building inspection and plan check services, Certified Access Specialist (CASP) services, and miscellaneous services such as general training, code update and adoption support as needed and/or upon request. Our proposal provides a detailed description of the services and capabilities of BPR Consulting Group (BPR) . We believe BPR has the skilled staff and experience required to provide the City with the desired services in a competent, professional, and customer-focused manner.
As our proposal will demonstrate, our talented staff of plans examiners, building inspectors, permit technicians, building officials, California licensed engineers, and CASp experts have extensive experience providing building division services similar to those requested by the City of M urrieta. Unlike the large national firms, BPR’s services are focused on supporting California communities in the delivery of high -quality building department services, tailored to your community’s specific needs.
The team proposed to serve the City of Murrieta are all appropriately licensed in the State of California or ICC certified and are experienced and well -versed in providing the requested services in support of California Building Departments. Ron Beehler , SE, CBO, will be BPR’s designated representative and, as a principal of BPR Consulting Group, is authorized to bind the firm to all commitments made in our proposal . Mark Berg, CBO, MCP will serve as Project Manager and coordinate and direct all services provided to the City in a professional, timely, and customer focused manner. We have reviewed and understand all elements of the RFP and the services being requested and confirm that the following proposal and fee schedule (submitted separately) are valid and binding for 120 days from the date of this letter. Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions concerning our qualifications or the services we provide. I can be reached at rbeehler@bpr- grp.com or 916.204.3178. Thank you for taking the time to review our qualifications. We look forward to the opportunity to work with the City of Murrieta.
Sincerely,
BPR CONSULTING GROUP
Ron
Beehler, SE, CBO
Director of Client Services | [email protected] | 916.204.3178 6856 Sundance Trail, Riverside, CA 92506
Exhibit D2
97 SECTION B
TABLE OF CONTENTS
SECTION A | Cover Letter / Letter of Transmittal ....................................................... 1 SECTION B | Table of Contents .................................................................................... 2 SECTION C | Summary ................................................................................................. 3 Exceptions ............................................................................................... 3 SEC
TION D | Statement of Understanding ................................................................. 4 Scope of Services .................................................................................... 5 SEC
TION E | Background and Experience ................................................................... 7 Firm Description ..................................................................................... 7 Firm Expertise ......................................................................................... 9 SEC
TION F | Approach to Building Services .............................................................. 17 Plan Check ............................................................................................. 17 Building Inspection ............................................................................... 18 Permit Technician ................................................................................. 18 SEC
TION G | Experience ............................................................................................ 20 Staffing .................................................................................................. 26 Qualifications of Personnel .................................................................. 27 SEC
TION H | References ............................................................................................ 36 SEC
TION I | Compensation ............................ (Submitted separately via PlanetBids) SECTION J | Additional Information ......................................................................... 39 APPE
NDIX
Key Personnel Resumes
Exhibit D3
98 SECTION C
SUMMARY
Our proposal provides a detailed introduction to our firm and an overview of the services provided by BPR Consulting Group (BPR).
BPR fully understands the scope of work as outlined in the RFP and is well-equipped to provide the City with the requested services in a professional and customer-focused manner.
As our proposal will demonstrate, our talented staff of ICC certified plans examiners and b uilding inspectors, licensed engineers, architects, CASp experts , and p ermit technicians have extensive experience providing plan review and building inspection services to Southern California communities similar to those being requested by the City of Murrieta . BPR’s staff members have previous experience providing the requested building department services for numerous public agencies throughout the State of California, including a significant number of Southern California communities.
BPR’s staff of experienced building safety personnel provide high quality, thorough plan review and inspection services for our clients and their permit applicants. Our qualified professionals and expertise allow us to assist you and your department in mai ntaining timely plan review service levels and next day building inspection services during periods of increased workload and staffing fluctuations. BPR’s services are focused on supporting California communities in the delivery of high -quality, building p lan review and building inspection services, tailored to your community’s specific needs, with the goal of exceeding our clients’ expectations by:
• Providing all services in a cost-effective manner.
• Providing qualified and experienced personnel who have the ability to thoroughly plan review and inspect all aspects of projects and effectively identify, communicate and explain relevant code requirements to designers, contractors, and owner builders. • Providing a high level of customer service for internal and external customers. • Balancing the need to ensure conformance to standards and regulations with the need for predictability, uniformity, and efficiency.
• Providing services in a timely manner.
The team proposed to serve the City of Murrieta are all appropriately licensed in the State of California or ICC certified and are experienced and well -versed in providing the requested plan review and building inspection services in support of California building departments. Serving as the City’s primary points of contact with BPR will be Project Manager Mark Berg, CBO, CFM, MCP who can be reached at [email protected] | 951.522.6982 (mobile) | 424.222.9994 (office), as well as Ron Beehler, SE, CBO who can be reached at rbeehler@bpr-grp .com (mobile) | 916.204.3178. We will not be utilizing any subconsultants to provide the requested services.
BPR takes no exceptions to the requirements of the RFP or the Sampl e Agreement provided.
Exhibit D4
99 SECTION D
STATEMENT OF UNDERSTANDING
We understand t he City of Murrieta is a General Law
City functioning under the city council/city manager
form of government. With a population of 115,172,
Murrieta is the fourth largest City in Riverside County.
Murrieta is a full-service City with eight departments, including Fire and Police Departments.
We understand the City of Murrieta is seeking to
partner with one or more qualified firms to provide
building inspection and plan check services as
requested by the City on an on -call, as -needed basis. We also understand the City may request on-call, as- needed building permit technician(s) and/or office clerk(s) to perform permit technician work and/or general office related duties, as well as certified access specialist (CASP) services and miscellaneous general training, code update and adoption resource and support as needed and/or upon request.
We understand the services BPR may be requested to provide include enforcement of the City’s building laws and codes (such as local amendments) and all applicable State statutes and regulations; review of construction drawings to ensure compliance with City and State adopted laws and codes; oversight of the Buildi ng and Safety Division operations; interfacing with permit applicants and City staff; and conducting inspections.
We understand that specific projects may include residential and/or non-residential projects any of which may require one or more subsequent reviews of submitted plans. Type s of proposed plan check work may include but not be limited to new construction, remodels, additions, green building, disabled access compliance, flood zone construction; enforcement of National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) general permit for storm water discharges; and public nuisance abatement.
We understand t he City provides plan check and inspection services using modern technology . BPR staff are highly proficient in the use of specialized software for building permit ting and plan checking including Bluebeam Revu and Energov, among others. We provide our staff with the necessary hardware, software, and training to perform plan review, building inspection and permit technician services effectively and efficiently using the latest electronic systems and software.
It is our understanding that the City will utilize on-call consultant services as needed to maintain service levels for all building department activities and responsibilities. BPR Consulting Group was founded to serve the building safety industry with the sole focus of providing thorough and efficient plan review, inspection, permit technician, and other building department services on behalf of California communities. We thoroughly understand our place within your organization , that these services are integral to your Building Division, and how to deliver these services dependably and professionally on an on-call, as-needed basis.
Exhibit D5
100
SCOPE OF SERVICES
From the RFP we understand the scope of services to include, but not be limited to the following:
PLAN CHECK SERVICES
• BPR will provide assistance and examine building plans for compliance with the adopted version of the California Building Code, California Residential Code, California Green Building Code, California Mechanical Code, California Plumbing Code, California Electrical Code, Title 24, Am ericans with Disabilities Act, and all other State mandated ordinances and codes, including any local amendments, on an on-call, as-needed basis.
• BPR will, in addition to State and City code requirements, review application packages for other applicable requirements such as approvals required from other agencies and districts. • BPR will, f or purpos es of working off -site, provide robust capability for electronic intake and distribution of plans and use Bluebeam Revu and Bluebeam sessions for plan reviews. • BPR plans examiners are expert users of Bluebeam Revu and BPR maintains multiple Bluebeam Revu software licenses.
• BPR will only utilize plans examiners who are ICC certified plans examiners, registered civil engineers, structural engineers and architects, as needed for specific plan review assignments. • Plan check services will include a review of any or all of the following design elements as determined by the City:
o Architectural
o Green Building Standards (Interior & Exterior)
o Structural
o Energy Conservation Regulations (Title-24)
o Solar
o Project Site Accessibility (Within Project Scope)
o Mechanical
o Project Site MEPs (Within Project Scope)
o Electrical
o Disabled Access Regulations
o Plumbing
o City’s Procedural Requirements & Guidelines
o Local Agency Requirements…DEH/Health Dept., AQMD, Water/Sewer Districts, Etc. o Special/Local Requirements… High Fire, Seismic, Flood, Mt. Palomar Ltg, Etc.
BUILDING INSPECTIONS
• BPR will provide ICC certified building inspector(s) to perform all building and safety inspections on an on-call, as-needed basis.
• BPR Inspectors will be fully qualified to perform residential, commercial and industrial inspections for compliance with approved plans and related documents.
• BPR inspectors will perform inspections in accordance with the City’s adopted version of the California Building Code, California Residential Code, California Green Building Code, California Mechanical Code, Exhibit D6
101
California Plumbing Code, California Electrical Code, Title 24, and all other State mandated ordinances and codes as applicable.
• BPR inspectors will provide their own vehicle(s), with no additional vehicle-related charges to the City. • BPR inspectors will review permit packages to verify that onsite conditions are consistent with the appropriate records for square footage, setbacks, heights, and other requirements that may be applicable. Inspections will be provided on the day they are assigned. Inspections will include issuance Certificates of Occupancies as requested by the City.
GENERAL OFFICE SUPPORT
• BPR will provide qualified, experienced on -call, as-needed building permit technician(s) and/or office clerk(s) to perform permit technician work and/or general office related duties. • BPR will provide building permit technicians and/or office clerks who are qualified to perform general office duties, process and issue building permits, process building plans and related documents.
ADDITIONAL SERVICES
• BPR will provide Certified Access Specialist (CAS p) services and miscellaneous general training, code update and adoption resource s and support as needed and/or upon request. Please see Section J of this proposal for additional information concerning BPR’s capabilities.
Exhibit D7
102
SECTION E
BACKGROUND AND EXPERIENCE
BPR Consulting Group was founded by a group of
experienced veterans of the building safety industry
with the sole focus of providing thorough and
efficient plan review , inspection, permit technician,
and other building department services on behalf of
California communities. Our leadership team has
worked together for nearly 20 years consecutively,
supporting building departments throughout California , and collectively possesses more than 100 years of experience providing building safety services to C ities, Counties, State Agencies and other Municipal Agencies throughout California and the W estern United States. O ur focus is to support California building departments in a professional manner by providing efficient, timely and professional building safety services for the communities we serve. We have extensive experience providing all aspects of building safety services and presently provide on -site building department permit technician, building inspection, building official, and plan check services similar to those bein g requested to multiple Southern California Building Departments. BPR presently provides plan check services similar to those being requested for numerous public agencies throughout the State of California including the Cities of Ontario, Fontana, Rancho Cucamonga, Eastvale, Santa Ana, Laguna Beach, Chino Hills, Gardena, Maywood, Imperial, La Mesa, and Mammoth Lakes, and the Counties of San Diego, Madera, San Luis Obispo, Sacramento, Placer, El Dorado, Yuba, Butte, Shasta, and Siskiyou, to name a few. We are also experienced in providing plan review and inspection services for high profile and unique projects. We have worked with numerous public agencies throughout California to provide these same services in a professional, timely, and customer focused manner.
Our Building Safety team of over 70 professionals consists of the following: California licensed structural, civil, mechanical, electrical and fire protection engineers; Certified Access Specialist (CASp) professionals; ICC - certified building officials, plans examiners, inspectors, permit technicians, an d highly experienced administrative personnel.
Building department services we provide to municipalities and agencies include:
Building safety plan review services
Building inspection services
CASp plan review and inspection services
Building Department management services
Permit technician and support services
Building Official services
Fire prevention plan review and inspection services
Civil plan review and inspection services
OFFICIAL FIRM NAME:
BPR Consulting Group, LLC
LOCAL OFFICE SERVING
THE CITY OF MURRIETA:
6856 Sundance Trail
Riverside, CA 92506
HEADQUARTERS /
MAILING ADDRESS:
2201 Francisco Drive, #140-658
El Dorado Hills, CA 95762
Exhibit D8
103
BPR has a proven track record of providing efficient and predictable building department services in support of California communities. Our key objectives in providing these services in support of the City of Murrieta are as follows:
To share our wealth of building Department experience. Our staff have been intimately involved in the management of multiple California Building Departments and we will use this experience to the benefit of the City of Murrieta’s Building Department.
To provide timely and responsive plan review services. Our well qualified and professionally licensed team of plans examiners will provide you with efficient and timely building department plan review services including clear communication of plan review results. We will work with you to tailor our services to align with your unique and specific community needs.
To provide customer focused permit technician services. Our well qualified, bilingual, and ICC certified permit technicians will work with department customers and City staff to provide efficient building department services.
To be responsive to your specific staffing needs. As construction and development activity fluctuates within your community, we will adjust our service levels to maintain seamless service to your customers. To provide staff who have the appropriate experience, certifications, and knowledge. We w ill utilize appropriately experienced and qualified staff to perform all identified services.
Over the past nearly twenty years, BPR s taff have provided building department services similar to those being requested by the City of Murrieta under agreement with nearly 50 California communities. Current clients within the past seven to ten years include:
City of American Canyon
City of Arroyo Grande
City of Arcata
California Construction Authority
City of Chico
City of Chino Hills
City of Clearlake
City of Eastvale
City of Fresno
City of Gardena
City of Imperial
City of La Mesa
City of Lincoln
City of Maywood
City of Ontario
City of Oroville
City of Rancho Cordova
City of Rancho Cucamonga
City of Rio Dell
City of Roseville
City of Sacramento
City of South Lake Tahoe
City of Stockton
City of Trinidad
City of Tulare
City of West Sacramento
Town of Mammoth Lakes
Town of Yountville
County of Butte
County of Colusa
County of Madera
County of Mono
County of Napa
County of Placer
County of San Diego
County of San Luis Obispo
County of Shasta
County of Tulare
Exhibit D9
104
FIRM EXPERTISE
Recognized areas of expertise offered by BPR include Plan Review, Building Inspection and Permit Technician services as described below.
PLAN REVIEW SERVICES
BPR’s staff possesses significant technical capabilities in all areas of plans examination competency gained from years of experience providing these same services. All plans examiners are California l icensed engineers or ICC certified plans examiners with multiple years of experience providing building and fire plan review services. Our staff will conduct accelerated or project -specific phased plan reviews on an as -needed basis as requested by clients.
Plans examiners will provide comprehensive building plan review services to the City, in -house and/or remote, and review submitted project documents for compliance with all applicable Federal, State and local codes and ordinances. Disciplines may include, and are not limited to Building, Fire, Plumbing, Electrical, Mechanical, Green Building, Energy Conservation, Geotechnical , Structural, Flood Zone Construction, and NPDES requirements.
Our plans examiners have a thorough understanding of code requirements, are able to read, understand and interpret construction documents, energy calculations, geotechnical reports, structural calculations, electrical load calculations, commissioning reports, hydraulic calculations and other associated design documents. Our plans examination staff have the ability to prepare well-written plan review letters, communicate effectively orally and in writing and work effectively with jurisdiction staff, project desi gn teams, contractors and permit applicants. Our plans examiners possess knowledge of the most current state adopted building standards.
Architectural
BPR’s non-structural plans examiners have provided plan review services for a vast array of projects within California including large residential, commercial, institutional, industrial, retail, and OSHPD 2, 3 and 5 medical office buildings. Many of our pl ans examiners are CASp certified. Completed plan review projects range from single-story residential projects to complex high -rise commercial buildings and numerous building additions and remodels. We are experienced and familiar with the use and application of the most current editions of the following model codes:
California Building Standards Code
(Title 24) Parts 1 through 6 and 9
International Building Code (IBC)
Americans with Disabilities Act
Standards for Accessible Design
ANSI Standards
NFPA Codes & Standards
California Code of Regulations (CCR) Titles 19 and
25 Jurisdiction-Adopted Amendments or Ordinances
California Existing Building Code
California Historical Building Code
Exhibit D10
105
Structural
Our structural engineers have experience designing and reviewing building projects subjected to wind loads and the significant seismic loads necessitated by the geographic location of the City of Murrieta. Our structural engineers have reviewed all types of projects including residential, multi- family, commercial and multi -story projects including mid -rise and high -rise projects, institutional projects, industrial projects, retail buildings, schools, medical office buildings and court facilities.
Our structural engineers have experience designing and reviewing projects constructed with all building materials including the following:
Wood
Reinforced Masonry
Heavy Timber / Timber Frame / CLT
Reinforced and Prestressed Concrete
Stressed Skin Panels
Structural Steel
Light Gauge Steel Framing
Straw Bale
Rammed Earth
Insulated Concrete Forms, (ICF)
Our engineers have designed or reviewed a wide array of structural lateral force resisting systems including:
Structural steel moment frames
Buckling-restrained braced frames
Eccentric braced frames
Concentric braced frames
Concrete moment frames
Wood shear wall systems
Masonry shear wall systems
Concrete shear wall systems
Cantilevered column systems
Pre-stressed and post-Tensioned Concrete
Various proprietary lateral force resisting
systems
Our structural engineers and inspectors are experienced with the provisions of most model codes including current versions of:
CCR Title 24, Part 2, Volumes 2 & 2.5
International Building Code (IBC)
AISC 341, 358 and 360
ASCE 7
ASCE 41
AISI Standards for Cold Formed Steel
ANSI / AF&PA NDS for wood framing
ACI 318
ACI 530 / TMS 402/602
California Historic Building Codes
California Existing Building Codes
NEHRP
Mechanical, Plumbing & Electrical
BPR’s Mechanical and Electrical Engineers are well versed in the California Mechanical, Plumbing and Electrical codes. We will review submitted design documents to ensure compliance to the current edition of the following codes:
California Building Code
California Residential Code
California Plumbing Code
California Mechanical Code
California Electrical Code
Jurisdiction-adopted amendments
Exhibit D11
106
Specialty plan review services may be provided utilizing the most current editions of national standards including the following:
NFPA Standards 13 (automatic fire
sprinkler systems)
NFPA Standards 14 (stand pipes)
NFPA Standards 20 (fire pumps)
NFPA Standards 72 (fire alarms)
NFPA Standards 99 (medical gases)
NFPA 101 Life Safety Code
NEHRP Requirements for Existing Building
Energy Compliance
Our engineers and plans examiners are up to date on all California Energy Code requirements as they relate to both new and remodel construction for all project types. Our staff have experience verifying CA Energy Code requirements for projects located within all climate zones for all types of buildings. The Energy Efficiency Standards for Residential and Non-Residential Buildings were established in 1978 in response to a legislative mandate to reduce California's energy consumption. These standards have been updated since that time to address a multitude of building components, systems and equipment with the goal of having new and updated buildings be more energy efficient, comfortable for building occupants, and less reliant of fossil fuels.
Green Building Standards
BPR’s staff has a working knowledge of the proper incorporation of CALGreen building criteria into project designs and the resulting potential impact of these standards related to building code compliance and the environment. Our plans examiners will review project documents to verify compliance with adopted Green Building Code Standards as required by state law and local amendments and ordinances.
LEED
Developed by the US Green Building Council (USGBC), LEED provides building owners and operators a framework for identifying and implementing measurable green building design methodologies, construction, operations, and building maintenance. LEED certificat ion consists of a variety of rating systems applicable to multiple building types including commercial as well as residential. Ratings reflect a measure of how well a building performs across many sustainability metrics including: energy savings, water efficiency, CO2 emissions reduction, indoor environmental quality, energy usage and the projects impact on the local environment.
Access Compliance & CASp Review
All BPR CASp-certified professionals are knowledgeable of state and federal accessibility laws and regulations and possess the expertise necessary to promote access to facilities for persons with disabilities. Our staff are experts in the industry, maintaining appropriate certifications demonstrating their expertise, and are experienced providing services for building departments in a seamless manner balanced and in coordination with our client’s expectations and needs. We work collaboratively with our clients to address accessibility plan review and inspection related issues as efficiently as possible.
Exhibit D12
107
BPR plans examiners are fully trained and familiar with California Building Code Accessibility requirements and ADA compliance requirements and are available for plan review and/or inspection services. We offer support to municipalities for compliance enforcement and/or developing transition plans. We can assist our clie nts in researching and providing interpretations of various specific issues related to access compliance including access compliance obligation, transition plan development, construction cos ts and phasing, and regulation interpretations.
Flood Zones
BPR’s staff of engineers and plans examiners have experience in providing plan reviews for projects located in FEMA designated flood zones and areas prone to flooding. BPR Consulting Group’s staff has provided numerous plan reviews for projects located in flood zones using FEMA’s Technical Bulletins as well as locally adopted ordinances. Additionally, members of our team have participated in state -sponsored committees to establish guideline and building code requirements for projects planned in areas designated as flood zones.
OSHPD 2, 3 & 5
BPR Consulting Group’s staff of plans examiners and building inspectors have extensive experience providing plan review and inspection services for OSHPD 2, 3 and 5 projects. Our staff is well versed with the OSHPD 2, 3 and 5 requirements included in the California Building Code. Our inspection staff has recent experience providing inspection services for hemodialysis, outpatient surgery, hyperbolic chamber, medical clinics and acute psychiatric facilities.
NPDES
Our civil plans examiners are experienced reviewing grading and civil plans for compliance with National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System requirements and general permits for storm water discharge.
On-Site Consultant Services & Meeting Attendance
Our plan review staff is available for pre -construction or pre -design meetings, field visits, contacts with the design team, and support for field inspection personnel as needed. We understand, fully grasp, and utilize the efficiency afforded by the many e lectronic meeting platforms that have become available in recent years. We find electronic meeting platforms such as Microsoft Teams, Zoom, and others allow for efficient and constructive communication between parties located throughout the United States and are an efficient tool for resolution of challenging issues both during plan review and field inspections. Our staff is available to meet with the City, project applicants and their design teams either in person or via electronic platform to resolve plan review issues efficiently and collaboratively.
Exhibit D13
108
Customer Service | Responsiveness
BPR’s staff is always available and willing to discuss plan review issues for projects that we have reviewed with Building Department staff, applicants, designers and contractors via in -person or electronic meetings, telephone, or e-mail as required to resolve plan review related issues. We maintain Microsoft Teams, Zoom and GoToMeeting accounts to foster efficient communication with project proponents regardless of their physical location. Voice mails and e-mails will be responded to the same day they are received, if possible, always within 24 hours.
Electronic Plan Review Services
BPR’s staff are thoroughly experienced providing electronic plan review and will perform electronic plan reviews as requested by the City using a format that is acceptable to the City. BPR will comply with the City’s established policies and procedures for electronic plan reviews. BPR maintains an efficient cloud -based, electronic-document, submittal system for receiving and sending large electronic document files. Our electronic document portal utilizes a SharePoint system to allow permit applicants and client staff the ability to upload construction documents for our plan review services. BPR Consulting Group has provided electronic plan review services, serving building departments and other public agencies with efficient electronic plan review services. We are prepared to provide electronic plan check services for your community utilizing our Bluebeam Revu electronic plan review system and will quickly adapt to the Bluebeam protocalls presently used by your department.
We have had the opportunity to work with many different electronic plan review systems and our preferred system is Bluebeam R evu, an industry -leading software used by many jurisdictions, design teams and contractors to review and annotate construction documents. We have worked with multiple clients to purchase and deploy Bluebeam Revu software, develop jurisdiction -specific stamps, develop tools to increase efficiencies for electronic plan reviews, and participate and provide ongoing training on the use of the software.
Transporting Plans
For paper submittal documents, we will arrange for all pick-up and delivery of the plan review documents from your office at no additional cost. We utilize specific methods for project document pick-up and delivery with the goal of providing same-day service.
Quality Control
BPR monitors all plan review activities daily. Project managers work directly with our plan review team to ensure thorough and comprehensive plan reviews for our clients. A key performance measure is our ability to meet client turn-around times for plan reviews we perform. We monitor our turn-around times on a daily basis to ensure we meet our commitments to our clients. A second performance measure is responding to client and applicant inquiries in a timely manner. All project -related communications are re sponded to on the same business day when possible and always within 24 hours of the inquiry. Additional performance metrics utilized by our firm include triage of completed reviews by our project managers to ensure completeness and accuracy of our plan reviews.
Exhibit D14
109
BUILDING INSPECTION SERVICES
BPR maintains the staffing and ability to provide
experienced and qualified building inspectors who are
appropriately ICC -certified to provide on -call inspection services. If needed, BPR can provide experienced and
certified building inspector(s) to perform all building inspections within 24 hours of notification.
Our inspection staff will perform inspection services to verify that the work of construction is in conformance with the approved project construction documents as well as
identifying issues of non -compliance with applicable
building codes. Our field inspection services will include inspection of all portions of projects including project sites as applicable. Our building inspectors will write legible and understandable correction notices and field reports, and will be available to answer in -person, emailed, or telephone inquiries. All inspection personnel assigned will be ICC and/or CASp certified as required.
We understand that many municipalities have amended code sections, policies and ordinances that impact the work that is inspected and shown on approved project plans. Our inspection staff will familiarize themselves with local requirements to ensure that the projects we are inspecting are compliant with local and current code requirements. Specifically, our inspectors will ensure compliance with the applicable provisions of the Title 24 California Building Standards Code, Parts 1 through 12, covering structural, fire prevention, life safety, disabled access, energy conservation, green building, plumbing, mechanical and electrical installations in residential, commercial, industrial, existing, and historical buildings.
BPR’s ICC/CASp certified inspectors have performed building inspection services on a wide variety of construction projects including master planned developments, single -family production, custom homes, commercial, manufacturing, institutional, assembly, es sential service, industrial projects, and historically designated buildings. When necessary for large or fast -paced projects, multiple inspectors can be made available. BPR’s inspectors will inspect projects to verify conformance with approved project drawings and specifications which will include review of the permit documents to verify that onsite conditions are consistent with the approved documents for size, setbacks, heights, and other applicable requirements. At the completion of inspections, BPR’s inspectors will update database information and complete necessary forms and documents as required to provide seamless service.
Inspector Qualifications & Certifications: BPR will work with the C ity to select appropriately qualified inspectors with applicable experience and specific code knowledge based on the types of projects assigned for inspection. All BPR inspectors are ICC -certified, with many maintaining CASp certification. In addition, BPR employs OSHPD certified inspectors available for inspection of OSHPD designated facilities. Qualified inspectors having experience with inspection of new, existing and historical buildings/sites, building code enforcement, will be assigned as appropriate.
Inspection personnel will have the ability to read, understand and interpret construction plans, truss drawings and calculations, prepare and maintain accurate records and reports, communicate effectively orally and in Exhibit D15
110
writing and to work effectively with contractors, permit applicants, homeowners and agency staff. Inspectors will possess knowledge of approved and modern methods, materials, tools and safety used in building inspection and the most current building and fi re standards. Our inspectors are familiar with most of the common scheduling and tracking systems utilized by building divisions and can quickly adapt to your systems and requirements.
PERMIT TECHNICIAN SERVICES
Knowledgeable and personable permit technicians are the first impression the public gets of your Building Division, and they play a critical role as to how your department’s services are perceived. Permit technician and office support services are crucial to the success of the entire building safety workflow within building departments. The ability to convey proper information to permit applicants, properly calculate permit fees, properly route plans to various departments for review, tracking approvals, database management and permit issuance are all critical to the success of your building division. We understand that the ability to deliver excellent customer service, maintain a smooth flow of permit documents throughout departments, and maintaining accurate and up- to-date records, are all key elements to furnishing first -rate, efficient success of your Building Division.
Our permit technicians and office support staff will work closely with customers via telephone or email, answering questions and providing accurate information. Our permit technicians will provide information about plan review status, will be organized and have the ability to maintain filing systems necessary for tracking plan checks in progress, approved project documents and any other records or information important to the efficient operation of your department. BPR’s permit technicians are experienced a nd skilled at providing a variety of permitting services remotely for many California municipal clients.
Exhibit D16
111
ADDITIONAL SERVICES AVAILABLE THROUGH BPR
BUILDING OFFIC IAL SERVICES
BPR Building Officials have extensive experience implementing and maintaining the procedures and processes critical to ensuring a Building Department runs smoothly. Our staff has worked with numerous public agencies throughout California and possess the skills required to work effectively with all parties involved.
Our building officials are ICC Certified with years of experience directing and managing the full spectrum of building department services and have held a variety of building division positions, including working as a building official, inspectors, plans examiners, and supervisor s of building department services. Our building officials understand the importance of communication with the City, staff, and other departments and are comfortable representing the Building Division at City Council meetings.
FIRE CODE PLAN REVIEW
We have an experienced and licensed professional f ire protection engineer and certified fire plans examiners on staff to address your fire and life safety needs. If requested, o ur fire safety plan review and inspection staff can quickly and accurately check plans for compliance with applicable fire codes and standards. Our fire protection staff routinely review and inspect projects for compliance with fire and life safety regulations.
Our fire plans examiners and inspectors have extensive experience in the use and application of the following model codes, standards, and regulations:
o California Fire Code (CFC) and California Building Code (CBC), with local amendments and regulations.
o Adopted National Fire Protection Standards
o California Health and Safety Code
o Appropriate listings (CSFM, U.L., etc.) for common systems and materials o Fire Department Standards
o Municipal, State or Federal regulations enforced by local Fire Agencies o NFPA Standards 13 (automatic fire sprinkler systems
o NFPA Standards 14 (standpipes)
o NFPA Standards 20 (fire pumps)
o NFPA Standards 72 (fire alarms)
o NFPA Standards 96 (smoke control)
o NFPA 101 Life Safety Code
BPR’s staff is active with California Fire Prevention Officer’s Association, as well as local chapters of International Code Council Building Officials Organizations throughout the State of California.
Exhibit D17
112
SECTION F
APPROACH TO BUILDING SERVICES
PLAN REVIEW SERVICES
All of BPR Consulting Group’s plan review services are closely managed from the moment a project is assigned to completion of our services. Once a project is assigned it is entered into our custom designed plan review database. The project documents are then triaged for completeness and to identify if any documents necessary for plan review have not been provided. Upon completion of the triage process, City approved plans examiners will be assigned as warranted by the scope of the proposed work associated with the specific project. All projects are closely monitored to ensure assigned staff have the time necessary in their schedules to comprehensively review assigned projects to maintain completion schedules.
We assign a dedicated team of plans examiners to serve specific clients so your BPR plan review team will remain consistent throughout the term of the agreement. We believe assigning a dedicated team of plans examiners best serves the needs of our clients, with our firm you will not have randomly assigned plans examiners assigned to each project. All plan review services are closely monitored by our plan review supervisors and managers for consistency, thoroughness, and quality. We utilize a discipline approach to our plan review services, assigning a life safety reviewer, structural reviewer, electrical reviewer, mechanical/plumbing reviewer, grading/utility reviewer and fire reviewer as appropriate to each assigned project based on the proposed scope of work. Each plans examiner includes their email address and desk phone number with their plan review comments to facilitate direct and efficient communication between project designers and our professional plans examination staff. Our Plan Review Manager revi ews each project for thoroughness and accuracy prior to plan review comments being issued or prior to recommendation of approval for permit purposes.
Upon award of a contract, our proposed Project Manager will schedule a meeting with the City’s representative to familiarize the team with the C ity’s plan review process, methods and style. BPR’s staff of engineers are experienced in working with multiple jurisdictions and adjusting our service approach to align with your processes so that we compliment and become an extension of your staff. We uti lize a comprehensive “New Client Checklist” that documents specific requirements of each community we serve. Upon selection and before commencement of services, we schedule a meeting with our new clients to review specific plan review requirements and systems used by our clients so our services can be integrated in a seamless manner.
Should issues arise with the plan review services we have provided, our Plan Review Manager will contact designated City staff to make sure we fully understand the specific issue, review the plan review comment or other items in question, review the concern with our staff member, contact the project applicant if necessary to address the specific issue, reissue the plan review comment letter if needed, discuss the specific issue with our assigned team of plans examiners to make sure the error in question is not repeated on future projects, and follow up with City staff to explain how the issue in question was resolved. Our Plan Review Manager will take any additional steps necessary to ensure that we continue to provide services that meet or exceed your expectations.
Exhibit D18
113
BUILDING INSPECTION SERVICES
BPR will work with the C ity to select appropriately
qualified inspectors with applicable experience and
specific code knowledge based on the types of projects
assigned for inspection. All BPR inspectors are ICC -
certified, with many maintaining CASp certification. In addition, BPR employs OSHPD certified inspectors
available for inspection of OSHPD designated facilities.
Qualified inspectors with experience inspecting new,
existing and historical buildings/sites and building code enforcement, will be assigned as appropriate.
Assigned staff will perform continuous or periodic
construction inspections to verify that the work of construction is in conformance with the approved project plans as well as identifying issues of non-compliance with applicable building codes. When necessary for large or fast- track projects, multiple inspectors are available.
Projects under construction by permit from the City will be inspected for compliance with the State of California Building, Mechanical, Plumbing, Electrical, Energy, Green, and Fire Codes. Projects will also be inspected for conformance with the accessibility, noise and energy conservation requirements as mandated by the State of California’s Title 24 and all applicable ordinances. Inspectors are accessible and available to meet with the project design team and/or the client’s representatives to work out pr oblems and help resolve issues quickly and efficiently. As necessary, inspectors will perform follow-up inspections to verify correction notices. Our inspection staff easily integrate into client organizations, consistently implementing policies and procedures and remaining transparent to the jurisdiction’s applicants and customers.
We understand that personality and customer service is crucial to on-the-job success, therefore, we will select inspectors who are well versed in customer service and skilled in dealing with people both at the public counter and in the field. All inspection personnel assigned will be ICC certified as required and have the knowledge and ability to update the City’s Energov permit database on a daily basis with inspection results.
PERMIT TECHNICIAN SERVICES
We understand that personality along with a customer service mindset is critical to providing top-notch permit technician services. Upon request we will assign qualified and experienced permit technicians with Energov experience to serve the City. Select candidates will be scheduled for an interview with City staff if requested. Upon approval, the designated permit technicians and/or support staff will be assigned to work at the City or remotely as appropriate to support the City’s permitting operations.
Exhibit D19
114
QUALITY CONTROL / SCHEDULE CONTROL
Upon award of a contract, our proposed Project Manager will schedule a meeting with the City’s representative to
familiarize the team with the City’s plan review process, methods and style. BPR’s staff of engineers and plans
examiners are experienced in wo rking with multiple
jurisdictions and adjusting so that they become an extension of your staff. We utilize a comprehensive “New Client
Checklist” that documents specific requirements of each community we serve. Upon selection and before
commencement of services, we schedule a meeting with our new clients to review specific plan review requirements and systems used by our clients so our services can be integrated in a seamless manner.
Should issues arise with the plan review services we have provided, our Plan Review Manager will contact City staff to make sure we fully understand the specific issue, review the plan review comment or other item in question, review the concern with our staff member, contact the project applicant if necessary to address the specific issue, reissue the plan review comment letter if needed, discuss the specific issue with our assigned team of plans examiners to make sure the error in question is not repeated on future projects, and follow up with City staff to explain how the issue in question was resolved. Our Plan Review Manager will take any additional steps necessary to ensure that we continue to provide services that meet or exceed your expectations and are free of errors and omissions.
As noted above, all projects are logged in to our database and assigned due dates. Our staff and managers all have access to the database and the due dates are carefully tracked and managed to ensure projects are completed in a timely manner. If for an unf oreseen reason a plan review is not completed within the stipulated plan review timeframe, we will reduce the subsequent plan review timeframe by the same number of days in order to not delay the project.
Exhibit D20
115
SECTION G
EXPERIENCE
Seamlessly integrating municipal service professionals in support of public agencies is BPR Consulting Group’s sole purpose and the basis on which we were founded. BPR’s staff have extensive experience providing the same services as being requested by the City of Murrieta to communities of comparable size throughout California. Our focus is to support California building departments in a professional manner, allowing our clients the ability to provide efficient, timely and professional building safety services for their communities.
We have extensive experience providing all aspects of building safety services in support of building departments, including plan check, building inspection and permit technician services.
Below you will find a small sampling of projects for
which BPR’s proposed staff have provided BUILDING PLAN
REVIEW SERVICES.
CITY OF GARDENA
Crenshaw 5-Story Apartment Complex
BPR’s staff provided complete building department plan review services for this new 5-story, 203,055 s.f. apartment complex which sits atop a 3-story podium. The mixed-use podium structure is Type I-A Construction and fully fire sprinklered and the apartment units above the podium are Type III-A Construction and is also fully fire- sprinklered. This is the first use of podium style construction within the City of Gardena.
Industrial Warehouse with MEPS
BPR’s staff provided building department plan review services for The OMP Gardena Industrial Center project consisting of a new 190,860 s.f., one story office warehouse building and warehouse, along with associated site improvements. The proposed building is Type IIIB Constructions with Occupancy Groups S-1 and B and is fully fire-sprinklered. Site improvements include landscaping, parking lots with accessible parking and paths of travel, signage, retaining walls, concrete ramps, exterior stairs, accessible curb ramps, trash enclosures, screen walls and detention pond.
Exhibit D21
116
Senior and Aquatics Center
BPR’s provided complete plan review services for the City of Gardena’s new Senior and Aquatics Center Building which consists of a two- story building for the senior center, a single - story pool equipment building, and new outdoor pools. This is a high-profile project for the community, and it was important that our plan review services were comprehensive and timely.
The proposed buildings will be of Type VB Construction with Occupancy Groups A-3, B and S-1 and is fully fire sprinklered. Site improvements include landscaping, parking lots with accessible parking and paths of travel, signage, BBQ and picnic area, trash enclosure and perimeter fencing.
CITY OF ONTARIO
New Fire Station Building
BPR Consulting Group provided complete building department plan review services for a new Fire Station Building in the City of Ontario.
This mixed occupancy building included Occupancy Groups B (4,432 s.f.), S-2 (14,112 s.f.), and R -2 (9,291 s.f.) for a total area of 27,835 square feet. This two -story, sprinklered building utilized Type V -B Construction and includes staff living quarters, office functions and apparatus bays.
Raising Cane Restaurant
BPR Consulting Group provided complete building department plan review services for this new fast service restaurant located in the City of Ontario. This fully fire sprinklered 3,449 s.f. building is Occupancy Group A -2 with Type V -B Construction. This fu lly accessible building included exterior site improvements, a dining area, sales counter, restrooms, storage areas, and commercial kitchen with grease hood, fire suppression system, and make up air units.
New Multi Family Complex
BPR Consulting Group provided complete building department plan review services for this new 48-unit multi-family apartment complex located in the City of Ontario. This project consists of four two-story, sprinklered buildings with stucco exteriors and concrete tile roofing.
The buildings structural systems utilized platform framing with prefabricated roof and floor trusses, panelized horizontal floor and roof diaphragms, with wood shear walls. The buildings are Occupancy Group R2 and utilize Type V -B Construction with a total area of 12,690 s.f. per building.
Exhibit D22
117
Emporia Place
BPR Consulting Group provided complete building department plan review services for phase one of this new multi- phased residential complex. Phase one included the construction of two, three-level, residential buildings of Occupancy Group R -2 and one community building of Occupancy Group A- 3. The new three -level residential buildings utilize Type V-A Construction and are fully fire sprinklered with a total building area of 58,698 s.f. The 1,921 s.f.
Community Building utilizes Type V-B Construction. The building’s structural systems utilized platform framing with prefabricated roof and floor trusses, panelized horizontal floor and roof diaphragms, with wood shear walls. All buildings included stucco exteriors with lap siding accents and concrete tile roofing.
CITY OF EASTVALE
BPR provides plan review services for all types of projects including Solar PV, residential remodels and accessory dwelling units, along with commercial and industrial projects including Tenant Improvement reviews of the Hotworx Fitness project, Bafang Dumpling Restaurant and the New Taco Bell Drive Thru. Through BPR’s services, the City has been able to maintain efficient and timely plan reviews for all ongoing construction projects.
Hotworx Fitness
BPR staff provided plan review services for this tenant improvement project which included the addition of new saunas and exercise equipment. This 2,490 s.f. space houses an innovative, 24-hour virtually instructed infrared sauna and gym. BPR performed life safety, structural and MEP reviews.
CITY OF MONTEREY PARK
Costco Warehouse & Fuel Station
BPR’s staff provided building department plan review services on behalf of the City of Monterey Park for the new Costco Warehouse and Fuel Station project. Plan review services included plan review of the non -structural, structural, mechanical, electrical, plumbing, green and energy efficiency improvements associated with the project. The 154,974 s.f. tilt-up warehouse building utilizes Type V-B Construction. The fueling station is Type ll -B Construction. The building is classified as a Group M Occupancy.
Exhibit D23
118
Pacific Plaza Mixed-Use Hotel and Condominium
BPR’s staff members provided complete building plan review services for the Pacific Plaza Monterey Park project which was designed as a mixed -use project to include Hotel,
Condominium and Restaurant uses. The project includes
398,792 SF within five levels above two levels of underground parking. The project utilizes Construction Type I -A at the two lower parking levels and Construction Type III-A above the 2nd level. The building includes Occupancy Groups A -2, A-3, M, B and S-
2. CITY OF COSTA MESA
Orange County Museum of Arts
BPR’s staff members provided plan review services for this two - level state -of-the-art museum, housed within an ultra -modern 52,000 SF building which emulates the art treasures the building was designed to showcase. The building boasts over 25,000 s.f. dedicated to exhibitions of modern art with the remainder of the building area dedicated to art displays and supporting function uses. A 10,000 s.f. portion of the interior space is designed to accommodate multipurpose; education and performance uses.
The project’s design includes a rooftop terrace to accommodate up to 1,000 people for special events and outdoor displays.
JUDICIAL COUNCIL OF CALIFORNIA
BPR principals have been responsible for contracting for and providing plan review services to the Judicial Council of California on numerous new Courthouse Projects and Court Facility
Modification projects throughout California since 2008. Below are just two of many completed projects:
Indio Courthouse
BPR principals provided civil, structural, MEP, energy compliance, CTCFS, and CALGreen compliance plan review on this new 3-story, 53,000 s.f. building. This building will provide five new courtrooms.
El Centro Courthouse
BPR principals provided civil, structural, MEP, energy compliance, CTCFS, and CALGreen compliance plan review on this new 3-story, 47,000 s.f. building. This building will provide four new courtrooms.
Exhibit D24
119
Below you will find a small sampling of clients for which BPR’s staff have provided building inspection, permit technician and buidling department support services.
CITY OF ONTARIO
BPR staff provides on -call plan review, building inspection and permit technician services to the City . BPR provides services for the community utilizing appropriately qualified and certified plan review, permit technician and inspection staff. BPR presently provides multiple highly qualified and CASp certified inspection staff to support the city’s inspec tion needs and multiple ICC certified permit technicians to support the city’s permitting services. BPR provides plan review services for all types of projects including residential, multi- family, commercial and industrial projects including plan review of associated grading. Through BPR’s services, the City is able to maintain efficient and timely plan review, inspection, and permit technician services for all ongoing construction projects.
CITY OF GARDENA
BPR provides building official, plan review, building inspection, building department management and permit technician services for the City of Gardena. BPR implemented building inspection services to eliminate a three-week inspection backlog. We added inspection staff to eliminate the inspection backlog then reduced staff to a level necessary to meet daily inspection service requirements. We provide all plan review services to support the building department. We also provide on-site and remote permit technician services.
CITY OF POMONA
BPR provides on-call building inspection, permit technician and permit technician training services to the City. BPR provides services for the community utilizing appropriately qualified and certified senior building inspection and permit technician staff. Through BPR’s services, the City is able to maintain efficient services for all ongoing permit center needs.
CITY OF CHINO HILLS
BPR recently worked with the city to provide experienced and qualified Inspection staff to support the City’s building department inspection needs.
CITY OF MAYWOOD
BPR provides full-service building department services to the City of Maywood including building official, plan review, building inspection , and permit technician services. BPR provides services for the community utilizing appropriately qualified and certified building safety staff. Through BPR’s services, the City maintains efficient plan review and inspection services for the benefit of the community for all ongo ing construction projects and permit center needs.
CALIFORNIA CONSTRUCTION AUTHORITY
The California Construction Authority serves as the building department for fairgrounds throughout California.
BPR’s Staff provides on-call plan review and building Inspection services on behalf of the California Construction Authority for fairgrounds throughout Southern CA insuring safe buildings and facilities. Projects include multiple assembly occupancies, entertainment venues, agricultural facilities, tenant improvements Exhibit D25
120
with extensive electrical and accessibility upgrades, and remodel projects for many existing facilities located throughout Southern California and the Inland Empire.
CITY OF SACRAMENTO
BPR’s staff provides in-house plan review, out-sourced plan review , building inspection and permit technician services. In addition, BPR staff provided in -house plan review training for the City of Sacramento plan review staff. Types of projects reviewed and inspected include residential, multi- family, commercial, and multi-story story projects including mid -rise and high-rise projects, institutional projects, industrial projects, retail buildings and medical office buildings.
ADDITIONAL CALIFORNIA COMMUNITIES
BPR staff have provided and managed building plan review and building inspection services on an as needed, on-call basis for multiple California building departments including the cities of Costa Mesa, Rancho Palos Verdes, Eastvale, Inglewood, Compton, Newport Beach, Corona, Yorba Linda, Fairfield, Davis, Atherton, Placerville, Folsom, Rancho Cordova, South Lake Tahoe, and the Counties of Riverside, San Bernardino, Fresno, Marin, Napa, Butte, Nevada, Placer, El Dorado, Alpine, and Siskiyou.
Exhibit D26
121
STAFFING
ORGANIZATION CHART
The Organization Chart below provides an overview of the staff available to serve the City of Murrieta. BPR Consulting Group maintains a staff of highly qualified Engineers, Plans Examiners, Building Inspectors, Building Officials, CASp professionals and Permit Technicians. All our staff maintain appropriate certifications or professional licenses for the servic es they provide. We continually encourage our staff to pursue additional certifications and support ongoing training and education for our staff.
Exhibit D27
122
QUALIFICATIONS OF PERSONNEL
The founders of BPR share the values of providing quality services and a very high level of customer service to our clients. Our focus is to support California building departments in a professional manner allowing our clients to provide efficient, timely and professional building safety services for the communities they serve. We have extensive experience in all aspects of building safety, including the plan check , inspection, and permit technician services that the City is requesting.
KEY PERSONNEL
Ron Beehler, SE, CBO PRINCIPAL-IN-CHARGE
Ron is licensed as a Civil and Structural Engineer in California and Nevada, certified by the International Code Council as a Building Official, Plans Examiner and Building Inspector. He utilizes experience gained through more than 35 years of hands -on experience performing life safety, accessibility and structural plan reviews to successfully manage building department plan review services, including building department plan review services for high-profile projects on behalf of public agencies throughout California. Ron’s experience includes establishing and coordinating on - site building department services for large multi- building projects and unique fast paced development projects. His background includes the position of Chief Building Official with the City of Sacramento directing a staff of 120 engineers, plan reviewers and building inspectors, Chief of Engineering Design and Construction for the California National Guard and Senior Structural Engineer with the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development (OSHPD). Ron presently serves as Chairman of CALBO’s Structural Committee. Ron will manage all contract and billing issues and will be the individual authorized to negotiate and execute the Consultant Services Agreement with the City. Years of Experience: 35
Mark Berg, CBO, CFM, MCP PROJECT MANAGER
Mark is an ICC Certified Building Official, Fire Code Official, Plans Examiner, Building Inspector, and Master Code Professional with experience performing life- safety, architectural, mechanical, plumbing, electrical, and fire reviews in residential, multi-family and commercial projects. Mark has successfully guided department staff with inspection and plan review of all phases of complex construction projects. He is experienced utilizing building department permit tracking software and managing and performing all common building department responsibilities, including plan review, multi-discipline inspections, plan review and inspection scheduling, field supervision, regulatory compliance, code interpretation, and project acceptance. Mark also possesses exceptional skills in complaint resolution, problem solving, damage assessment and team building. Years of Experience: 31
Exhibit D28
123
Roger Peterson, SE PLAN REVIEW MANAGER | STRUCTURAL PLAN REVIEW Roger is a California licensed civil and Structural Engineer, and an experienced building safety professional with 35 years of experience in structural design and building plan review. Roger has provided plan review services for single and multi- story steel, and concrete-framed buildings, as well as structures utilizing timber, and masonry framing systems. Roger’s experience includes plan review of numerous high -profile and fast paced multi -story building projects for multiple public agency clients includin g management of inspection programs for these same types of projects. Roger utilizes his detailed code knowledge, extensive design experience and on-site construction project experience to ensure accurate, thorough, and timely plan review and inspection services on behalf of municipal client agencies. Roger will serve as Plan Review Manager and the back -up contact for the City. Years of Experience: 35
BRIEF BIOGRAPHIES (KEY STAFF)
All of our staff maintain appropriate certifications or professional licenses for the services they provide. We encourage our staff to continually obtain additional certifications and support ongoing training and education for our staff. Our focus is to maintain the highest and best qualified building department staff in the industry.
BPR’s staff has a proven track record of providing high quality and timely services on behalf of the public agencies we serve. BPR has the necessary resources available to provide all the proposed services to the City of Murrieta. Complete resumes for key personnel have been provided in the Appendix of this proposal.
Bill Rodgers, SE STRUCTURAL PLAN REVIEW
Bill is a California licensed civil and structural engineer with over 30 years of experience in the field of structural engineering, including over 20 years of experience as a plan review engineer. Bill has worked closely with Building Departments across the State of California , including many years serving Southern California communities, and has assisted government agencies with numerous projects of varying size and type . His wealth of experience includes managing plan review services for all building typ es throughout California and Nevada on behalf of public agency clients and performing structural plan review for commercial, industrial, and residential projects. Years of Experience: 30
Elena Hartsough, SE STRUCTURAL PLAN REVIEW
Elena is a dedicated structural engineer with over 22 years of experience designing structures, from small home renovations to large warehouse spaces and custom homes. Elena’s strengths include experience with multiple building materials including wood, light -gage, masonry, steel and concrete; knowledge of t he California Building Code and proficiency in relevant software programs including Enercalc, SAP2000, L-Pile and AutoCAD.
Years of Experience: 22
Exhibit D29
124
Joseph Leonard, SE STRUCTURAL PLAN REVIEW
Joseph is an accomplished engineering plans examiner and has 20 years of experience as a consulting structural engineer for light framed construction, including single family dwellings, commercial buildings, and public schools, throughout California. He also has 10 years of working as a consulting structural engineer on heavy, low to mid-rise building structures, for public and military use. Clients included NAVFAC, NASA, the Navy, and the Army Corp of Engineers, and various public -school districts in California. Joseph’s experience includes examin ation of construction documents for compliance with the California Building Code and other adopted codes for California Building Departments. Years of Experience: 20
Charles Nganga, SE STRUCTURAL ENGINEER
Charles is a California Licensed Structural engineer with a Master of Science degree in Civil Engineering from California Polytechnic State University in San Luis Obispo. He is also a certified ICC plans examiner with nearly 10 years of experience. His work experience, excellent education and solid commitment to the industry has enabled Charles to develop a solid track record of consistently providing clients with exceptional service. Charles shares his skill and knowledge with other building safety professionals by developing and teaching building code related classes. Years of Experience: 10
Chandra Desai, PE STRUCTURAL PLAN REVIEW
Chandra is a California Licensed Civil Engineer with over 35 years of experience in structural engineering, which includes the design of structures for residential, commercial and industrial facilities. He has over 16 years of experience providing plan review, permit processing and field issue resolution for all types of buildings. Years of Experience: 35
Denise Reese, CBO, ICC PLAN REVIEW
Denise is an ICC Certified Chief Building Official and Life Safety Plans Examiner. She has experience performing life-safety, architectural, mechanical, plumbing, electrical, and minimal structural reviews in residential, multifamily and commercial project s, including OSHPD -3 licensed facilities. This valuable experience is also evident in that Denise specializes in working with applicants, designers and jurisdictions, having successfully served multiple California communities. Years of Experience: 15 David Castillo, ME, FPE PLAN REVIEW
David brings more than 35 years of breadth, depth, and knowledge of mechanical engineering, design, and plan review to any project. A California licensed professional Mechanical Engineer and Fire Protection Engineer, his expertise encompasses HVAC, Plumbing, Medical Gases, and Fir e Sprinklers. David’s background includes mechanical engineering, design, and plan review on Central Treatment Centers, Substance Abuse Treatment Facilities, Inpatient Mental Health Clinics, and Inmate Housing Units for the Department of Corrections. He has engineered and designed Acute Care Hospitals, Skilled Nursing Facilities, Surgery Clinics, Psychiatric Hospitals, Pharmaceutical Plants, Industrial Plants, Educational Facilities , and Hi -Rise Commercial Buildings. Years of Experience: 36
Exhibit D30
125
Thomas Trimberger, ME, CBO, ICC PLAN REVIEW
Thomas has more than 30 years of experience working within building departments both successfully providing and supervising virtually all building department functions. Thomas is a CA Registered Mechanical Engineer, ICC Certified Building Official, Plans Examiner and Building Inspector. His extensive experience and knowledge enable him to provide excellent services to our clients. Thomas is skilled at developing relationships with developers, designers and the community to ensure plan reviews, inspections and development review functions are performed in an effective and efficient manner. He continuously assists clients by providing guidance and education on the construction and inspection process. Always helpful, personable, professional and successful in delivering a high level of customer service. Years of Experience: 30
Jerry Schreiber, EE, ICC PLAN REVIEW
Jerry has more than 40 years of electrical industry experience. He is a licensed electrical engineer in California and Hawaii and is certified by the International Association of Electrical Inspectors as an Electrical Plans Examiner and Electrical Inspector. Jerry’s experience is wide and varied, having provided engineering services to the military, public utilities, private organizations and municipal agencies.
Years of Experience: 40
Jingpei Zhang, EE, ICC PLAN REVIEW
Jingpei is a licensed electrical engineer in California and has over 30 years of experience. He holds a master’s degree of Electrical and Electronic Engineering. His extensive experience in designing a variety of facilities and systems enables him to provide excellent plan review services. His experience includes the design of electrical distribution systems for healthcare centers, data centers, commercial and industrial buildings, and educational facilities. Years of Experience: 30
Kevin Brenton, CBO, CASp, ICC PLAN REVIEW
Kevin is a California Certified Building Official, a CASp professional and Commercial Combination Building Inspector with over 24 years in the construction and inspection industry combined. He is an active local chapter member of the International Association of Plumbing and Mechanical Officials and an active member of the local chapter of the International Code Council. Years of Experience: 24 Andrew Burke, CASp, ICC PLAN REVIEW
Andrew is a Certified Access Specialist and ICC certified Plans Examiner with more than 17 years of industry experience in plan review, inspection, administration and estimating. Andrew has extensive plan check experience in multi-story mixed use projects and provides in-depth review of accessibility issues to ensure compliance with all California Building Codes. His CASp certification provides him with the ability to ensure all aspects of accessibility have been achieved. His formal training in ICC codes, as well as on-the-job experience, helps him to provide thorough and accurate commercial and residential plan reviews and inspections. Andrew is an excellent asset to any building department both in the office and out in the field. Years of Experience: 10
Exhibit D31
126
Don Ctibor, PE, QSD CIVIL PLAN REVIEW
Don is a highly experienced Licensed California Professional Engineer with extensive project experience and management experience. Specific skills include budget strategy, preparation and oversight and implementation of best practices across multiple departments. Knowledgeable in enforcing compliance and minimum standards to safeguard life, limb, health property and public welfare. Don has successfully provided project management expertise for many California clients. Years of Experience: 16 Gabriel Argueta, CASp, ICC INSPECTION
Gabriel has 45 years of experience in the construction industry. He is an ICC certified inspector with experience providing building, mechanical, electrical and plumbing inspections on residential and commercial projects. Gabriel is also a certified CASp expert and has provided CASp inspections as well as provided CASp design as a consultant.
He provides Building Department inspection services to ensure projects are built in accordance with approved plans, specifications and specified codes. Gabriel brings considerable experience from working for several California based construction companies. Years of Experience: 45
Samantha Barker, ICC PERMIT TECHNICIAN
Samantha is an ICC Certified Permit Technician with experience providing Permit Technician services in support for municipal building departments. Samantha’s experience includes updating databases, data input, permit tracking system management, and report generation. In addition to her technical abilities, Samantha utilizes her excellent customer service skills to assist department customers, applicants, and City staff. Samantha is efficient, detail oriented and possesses the ability to multi-task.
Alicia Ventura, ICC PERMIT TECHNICIAN
Alicia is an ICC Certified Permit Technician with over 13 years of experience providing services to multiple California municipal clients. Alicia is well versed in her role as a Permit Technician and has worked with several municipal tracking systems including Trakit. In addition to her technical abilities, Alicia has excellent customer service skills that help her to work well with applicants and City staff. In addition, Alicia is fluent in Spanish, proficient with Microsoft Office software including Word, Excel and PowerPoint, is detail oriented and is able to multi-task.
Exhibit D32
127
LICENSES & CERTIFICATIONS
Below you will find the extensive licenses and certifications that our proposed key staff hold.
Name Current Licenses and Certifications License/Cert.
Number(s)
Expiration
Date
Ron Beehler, SE, CBO, ICC
Principal-in-Charge
CA Registered Professional Civil Engineer
CA Registered Professional Structural Engineer
NV Registered Professional Civil Engineer
NV Registered Professional Structural Engineer
CABO Certified Building Official
ICC Certified Building Official
ICC Building Code Specialist
ICC Building Plans Examiner
ICC Building Inspector
39404
3632
019992
019992
1492
801789
801789
801789
801789
12/31/2025
12/31/2025
12/31/2024
12/31/2024
---
05/11/2024
05/11/2024
05/11/2024
05/11/2024
Mark Berg, ICC, MCP , CBO
Plans Examiner
Building Official
ICC Accessibility Inspector/Plans Examiner
ICC Building Code Official
ICC Building Code Specialist
ICC Building Inspector
ICC Building Plans Examiner
ICC Certified Building Official
ICC Certified Fire Code Official
ICC Certified Fire Marshal
ICC Combo Dwelling Inspector - Uniform Codes
ICC Combination Inspector - Legacy
ICC Electrical Inspector
ICC Fire Code Specialist
ICC Fire Inspector I
ICC Fire Inspector II
ICC Fire Plans Examiner
ICC Master Code Professional
ICC Mechanical Inspector UMC
ICC Permit Specialist
ICC Permit Technician
ICC Plumbing Inspector UPC
ICC Residential Combination Inspector
ICC Residential Energy Inspector/Plans Examiner
ICC Residential Plans Examiner
859362
859362
859362
859362
859362
859362
859362
859362
859362
859362
859362
859362
859362
859362
859362
859362
859362
859362
859362
859362
859362
859362
859362
12/11/2025
07/14/2024
07/14/2024
07/14/2024
07/14/2024
07/14/2024
07/14/2024
10/28/2024
07/14/2024
07/14/2024
07/14/2024
07/14/2024
07/14/2024
07/14/2024
07/14/2024
10/05/2024
07/14/2024
10/03/2024
10/02/2024
07/14/2024
07/14/2024
12/11/2025
04/08/2024
Roger Peterson, SE
Principal
Project Manager
CA Registered Professional Civil Engineer
CA Registered Professional Structural Engineer
ID Registered Professional Civil Engineer
ID Registered Professional Structural Engineer
46096
3846
P-8225
P-8225
12/31/2024
12/31/2024
06/30/2024
06/30/2024
Bill Rodgers, SE
Principal
Plan Review Manager
CA Registered Professional Structural Engineer
CA Registered Professional Civil Engineer
NV Registered Professional Civil Engineer
NV Registered Professional Structural Engineer
4198
50673
18427
09/30/2025
09/30/2025
12/31/2023
Exhibit D33
128
Name Current Licenses and Certifications License/Cert.
Number(s)
Expiration
Date
18427 12/31/2023
Elena Hartsough, SE
Structural Engineer
CA Registered Professional Civil Engineer
CA Registered Professional Structural Engineer
67675
5538
6/30/2025
6/30/2025
Joseph Leonard, SE
Structural Engineer
CA Registered Structural Engineer
CA Registered Civil Engineer
5880
73026
12/31/2024
12/31/2024
Charles Nganga, SE
Structural Engineer
CA Registered Professional Civil Engineer
CA Registered Structural Engineer
ICC Residential Plans Examiner
85710
6913
8325618
09/30/2024
09/30/2024
01/07/2025
Chandra Desai, PE, ICC
Plan Review Engineer
CA Registered Professional Civil Engineer 47213
12/31/2023
Denise Reese, CBO, ICC
Plans Examiner
ICC CALGreen Inspector
ICC California Building Plans Examiner
ICC Permit Technician
ICC Certified Building Official
ICC Permit Specialist
8096275
8096275
8096275
8096275
8096275
04/23/2025
04/23/2025
04/23/2025
04/23/2025
04/23/2025
David Castillo, ME/FPE
Mechanical Engineer
Fire Protection Engineer
CA Registered Professional Mechanical Engineer
CA Registered Fire Protection Engineer
31455
2013
12/31/2024
03/31/2025
Thomas Trimberger, ME,
ICC, CBO
Mechanical Engineer
Building Official
CA Registered Mechanical Engineer
ICC Mechanical Inspector UMC
ICC Building Plans Examiner
ICC Plumbing Plans Examiner
ICC Plumbing Inspector UPC
ICC Mechanical Plans Examiner
ICC Plumbing Inspector
ICC Mechanical Inspector
ICC Mechanical Code Official
ICC Certified Building Official
ICC Plumbing Code Official
ICC Plumbing Code Specialist
ICC Mechanical Code Specialist
26359
866408
866408
866408
866408
866408
866408
866408
866408
866408
866408
866408
866408
06/30/2025
05/16/2025
05/16/2025
05/16/2025
05/16/2025
05/16/2025
05/16/2025
05/16/2025
05/16/2025
12/20/2025
05/16/2025
05/16/2025
05/16/2025
Jerry Schreiber, EE
Electrical Engineer
CA Registered Professional Electrical Engineer
HI Registered Professional Electrical Engineer
ICC CA Commercial Building Inspector
ICC CA Commercial Mechanical Inspector
ICC CA Commercial Plumbing Inspector
ICC CA Residential Mechanical Inspector
ICC CA Residential Plumbing Inspector
ICC Commercial Building Inspector
ICC Mechanical Inspector
12290
13259
879275
879275
879275
879275
879275
879275
879275
09/30/2024
n/a
07/27/2024
07/27/2024
07/27/2024
07/27/2024
07/27/2024
07/27/2024
07/27/2024
Exhibit D34
129
Name Current Licenses and Certifications License/Cert.
Number(s)
Expiration
Date
ICC Plumbing Inspector
ICC Plumbing Inspector UPC
879275
879275
07/27/2024
07/27/2024
Jingpei Zhang, EE
Electrical Engineer
CA Registered Professional Electrical Engineer
ICC Commercial Electrical Inspector
NCCER HVAC Level IV Certification
NCCER Plumbing Level IV Certification
NCCER Building Maintenance Level III Cert.
NCCER Carpentry Level IV Certification
NCCER Solar Photovoltaic Level I Certification
NCCER Wind Power Level I Certification
NCCER Green Technology Level I Certification
NCCER Weatherization Technician Level I Cert.
16243
8901215
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
12/31/2024
01/28/2024
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
Kevin Brenton, ICC, CASp
Plans Examiner
Building Inspector
ICC Commercial Plumbing Inspector
ICC Residential Plumbing Inspector
ICC Commercial Building Inspector
ICC Residential Building Inspector
ICC Commercial Electrical Inspector
ICC Residential Electrical Inspector
ICC Commercial Mechanical Inspector
ICC Building Inspector
ICC Electrical Inspector
ICC Plumbing Inspector
ICC Commercial Combination Inspector
ICC Building Plans Examiner
ICC Certified Building Official
ICC Building Code Specialist
Certified Access Specialist (CASp)
Licensed General Contractor
Journeyman Electrician, 2002
8259529
8259529
8259529
8259529
8259529
8259529
8259529
8259529
8259529
8259529
8259529
8259529
8259529
8259529
CASp-964
B-88891
12/23/2024
12/23/2024
12/23/2024
12/23/2024
12/23/2024
12/23/2024
12/23/2024
12/23/2024
12/23/2024
12/23/2024
12/23/2024
12/23/2024
04/11/2025
04/11/2025
08/04/2024
Andrew Burke, CASp, ICC
Certified Access Specialist
Plans Examiner
Certified Access Specialist
ICC Building Plans Examiner
ICC Residential Plans Examiner
ICC Commercial Building Inspector
ICC Residential Combination Inspector
ICC Permit Technician
CASp-710
8250398
8250398
8250398
8250398
8250398
08/12/2025
01/07/2025
01/07/2025
01/07/2025
01/07/2025
01/07/2025
Don Ctibor, PE, QSD
Civil Engineer
CA Registered Professional Civil Engineer
CA Qualified SWPPP Developer (QSD)
ERA RRP Certification (NAT-F115845 & R139176)
General Engineering Contractor
General Building Contractor
DSA Engineer of Record
76392
24244
744754
744754
12/31/2024
Exhibit D35
130
Name Current Licenses and Certifications License/Cert.
Number(s)
Expiration
Date
Gabriel Argueta, ICC, CASp
Building Inspector
ICC Commercial Building Inspector
ICC Plumbing Inspector
ICC Building Plans Examiner
Certified Access Specialist
Licensed Building Contractor
5039994
5039994
5039994
CASp-126
430345
05/22/2025
05/22/2025
03/29/2026
Samantha Barker, ICC
Permit Technician
ICC Permit Technician 10138242 11/08/2024
Alicia Ventura, ICC
Permit Technician
Plans Examiner
ICC Permit Technician
ICC Residential Plans Examiner
9560759
9560759
09/12/2024
03/25/2026
Exhibit D36
131
SECTION H
REFERENCES
Over the past 18 years, BPR’s Principals have worked diligently to develop a reputation within California for providing top quality, timely, and efficient building safety services in a professional, courteous manner, always working in our clients’ best interests by honoring our commitment to provide timely, superior services. We believe our best advertisements are references from current and previous clients and we encourage you to contact our client references. As requested in the RFP, below are client references from California agencies where we have provided similar services to those requested by the City of Murrieta:
City of Ontario
James Caro, Building Official
303 E. B Street, Ontario, CA 91764
Ph: 909.395.2172
Email: [email protected]
Services Provided:
• BPR Consulting Group provides building department services for the C ity of Ontario under contract including plan review, building inspection and permit technician services . Types of projects reviewed and inspected include residential, commercial and retail projects.
City of Gardena
Greg Tsujiuchi, Community Development Director
1700 West 162nd Street, Gardena, CA 90247
Ph: 310.217.9526
Email: [email protected]
Services Provided:
• BPR Consulting Group provides all building department services for the City under contract including building official, out-sourced plan review, building inspection and permit technician services. Types of projects reviewed and inspected include residential, commercial and retail projects.
City of Sacramento
Anna Tekautz, Supervising Engineer
300 Richards Boulevard, 3rd Floor, Sacramento, CA 95811 Ph: 916.808.7877
Email: [email protected]
Services Provided:
• In-house plan review, out-sourced plan review, inspection and permit technician services. In addition, BPR staff provided in-house plan review training for the City of Sacramento plan review staff. Types of projects reviewed and inspected include residential, multi-family, commercial, and multi-story story Exhibit D37
132
projects including mid-rise and high-rise projects, institutional projects, industrial projects, retail buildings and medical office buildings.
City of Maywood | St eve Fowler, Director of Building and Planning 4319 Slauson Ave. Maywood, CA 90270
Ph: 323.562.5721
Email: [email protected]
Services Provided:
• BPR Consulting Group provides Building Official, Building Inspection, Permit Technician, plan review services for a multitude of project types including residential, commercial, multi-story, industrial and retail, and Building Department Management services.
City of Eastvale
Richard Hicks, Building Official
12363 Limonite Avenue, #910, Eastvale, CA 91752
951.703.4458 | [email protected]
Services Provided:
• BPR Consulting Group provides out-sourced plan review for a multitude of project types including residential, commercial, multi-story, industrial and retail.
POTENTIAL CONFLICTS OF INTEREST
Public clients for whom BPR currently provides Building Division services are listed in Section E, per the RFP.
We do not see any potential conflicts of interest in providing the same services to the City of Murrieta.
LITIGATION
BPR Consulting Group does not have, nor has had in the past five years, any performance -related civil or criminal litigation or investigations that will hinder BPR’s ability to provide the requested services. No judgements have been entered against BPR.
Exhibit D38
133
SECTION I
COMPENSATION SCHEDULE
As requested in the RFP, BPR’s compensation schedule has been submitted separately via PlanetBids utilizing the general attachment link.
Exhibit D39
134
SECTION J
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION AND CAPABILITIES
ADDED EFFICIENCIES AND BENEFITS OF BPR
• We maintain a convenient drag -and-drop project upload system for utilization by our clients and their applicants for uploading initial reviews and back-check reviews to our plan review system. • We work with several communities providing plan review of small solar projects in electronic format. Transporting and reviewing multiple small solar projects in electronic format allows for efficiencies and timeliness in the plan review process allowing BPR to negotiate reduced in plan review fees with our clients for these small and sometimes time-consuming projects. • Having a California licensed civil or structural engineer review all projects with primary structure elements ensures that these projects are designed in substantial compliance with the structural provisions of California Building Codes and regulations. • BPR maintains active Zoom, Microsoft Teams and other electronic meeting platform accounts. We believe virtual meetings allow for efficient communication with permit applicants and the City and fosters expeditious plan review approval and resolution of field inspection items. • With a qualified and appropriately licensed staff of plans examiners and permit technicians that possess hands on experience providing remote plan review and permitting processing, BPR has the ability to assign the most qualified staff for each project based on project specifics. Providing these services remotely creates added time efficiencies and potential cost savings.
ABILITY TO DRAW ON MULTI-DISCIPLINARY STAFF
As a full-service building department consulting company, BPR Consulting Group maintains full-time staff with the experience, aptitude and qualifications to perform all aspects of the building department services the City is requesting. Our significant depth of staff resources allows BPR the ability to address our clients’ needs quickly and seamlessly providing one or multiple professionals as needed to meet the staffing requirements. At BPR, our primary focus is to provide high quality building services in support of public agency building departments.
Our plan review staff work in a collaborative manner to share information and experience to provide thorough and consistent plan reviews. W e understand our rol e in the development process and take our work and commitment to our clients seriously.
Exhibit D40
135
STAFF DEVELOPMENT AND TRAINING
All of our staff maintain appropriate certifications or professional licenses for the services they provide. We ensure our staff is properly trained and require ongoing training for our staff equal or greater that that required by California Health and Safety Code Section 18949.29. We continually encourage our staff to obtain additional certifications and support ongoing training and education for our staff.
Many opportunities for continuing education for building safety professionals are offered by multiple providers throughout the state and hosted by a variety of providers including California Building Officials, local ICC Chapters, AIA, County Building Officials Association of California, and others. In addition to participating in these opportunities, BPR’s staff members have developed and presented training classes on behalf of many of these professional organizations on building code related topics including:
• Means of Egress in the 2022 CBC
• CBC Requirements for Wood Framed Building Design
• CBC Requirements for Horizontal Diaphragm and Shear-Wall Design • Structural and Non-Structural CRC Requirements
• Overview of Wind Load Changes to the CBC
• CRC Wall Bracing Requirements
• Load Path Systems for Building Structures
• Structural Welding and Bolting
• Overview of CPC and CMC Requirements for Building Systems • Anchorage of Nonstructural Building Components Per ASCE-7 • Simplified Structural Design
• Plan Check 1 and 2
Additionally, many of our staff members are active members of local professional organizations including local ICC Chapters and have served as officers and in other leadership capacities. Our Principal in Charge, Ron Beehler S.E., CBO, presently serves as the Chairman of CALBO’s Structural Committee. Our proposed Project Manager, Mark Berg, is an ICC Certified Master Code Professional and has recently served as an instructor for CALBO Ed Weeks providing instruction focused on CBC Chapter 10, exiting requirements for building structures.
CODE QUIZ
BPR’s proposed Principal-in-Charge, Ron Beehler, has authored the well -received monthly Code Quiz for over eight years for multiple ICC Chapters. The Code Quiz has become an education component of monthly ICC Chapter meetings throughout California. BPR is now the sponsor of the Code Quiz and uses the quiz as an internal training element for our staff. Current year Code Quiz’s may be found on our website, www.BPR- GRP.com
Exhibit D41
136
APPENDIX
KEY PERSONNEL RESUMES
Exhibit D42
137
RON BEEHLER, SE, CBO
PRINCIPAL-IN-CHARGE
Ron utilizes experience gained through more than 35 years of hands -on experience performing life safety, accessibility, and structural plan reviews to successfully manage building departments, building department services and high-profile building projects on behalf of public agencies throughout California. His experience includes establishing and coordinating on -site building department services for large, multi- building projects and unique, fast-paced development projects. Ron has served as Chief Building Official for multiple California public agencies including interim assignments. He has also provided building department assessments on behalf of municipal clients to identify inefficiencies and implement best practice improvements.
Licensed as a Civil and Structural Engineer in California and Nevada, certified by the International Code Council as a Building Official, Code Specialist, Plans Examiner and Building Inspector, Ron is uniquely qualified to evaluate and manage all building department services. His background includes the position of Chief Building Official with the City of Sacramento directing a staff of 120 engineers, plan reviewers and building inspectors, Chief of Engineering Design and Construction for the California National Guard and Senior Structural Engineer with the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development (OSHPD).
Ron is dedicated to maintaining his knowledge of California building codes, laws and regulations related to building department operations.
He frequently lectures and presents classes on technical topics on behalf of professional organizations including CALBO and multiple International Code Council Chapters throughout California and other western states.
He presently serves as Chairman for the CALBO Structural Committee.
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY
Principal | Director of Operations | BPR Consulting Group | 2021 - Present
Ron manages client plan review and inspection services on behalf of BPR Consulting Group providing efficient services on behalf of multiple municipal clients.
Director, Building Safety Services | Consulting Firm | 2006 – 2021 Ron provided direct oversight of all Building Safety Services including coordination of all plan review and building inspection services, ensuring timely and responsive services. He worked with building officials for full - service clients to ensure timely and efficient services. Ron also managed and provided direct oversight of plan review and inspection services for large, complicated and fast -paced projects on behalf of public agency clients.
Exhibit D43
138
Chief Building Official | City of Sacramento | 2003 – 2006 Ron planned, directed, and managed activities for a 120 -person building department with oversight responsibilities for construction inspections and plan review of 18,000 permitted projects annually. He planned, organized, administered, and evaluated staff work. Other duties included report writing and presentations to community groups, city council and professional organizations, and planning and administering a budget of $13.6 million.
Supervising Engineer | Building Inspection Division | City of Sacramento | 2002 – 2003 Ron supervised plan review, managed plan intake and public counter functions for two regional permit centers, trained and mentored staff, met with architects and engineers to resolve building code related issues, coordinated plan review for high profile projects, and worked with field inspection supervisors and inspectors.
Regional Compliance Officer, Senior Structural Engineer | CA State Office of Statewide Health Planning & Development | 1998 – 2002
Ron supervised regional hospital inspection program coordinating field inspection staff and approval of special inspection issues. He resolved complicated code related inspection issues, and reviewed plans, specifications, and structural calculations for h ealthcare facilities. Ron consulted with architects and engineers to resolve complex code interpretation issues. He researched and investigated structural adequacy of building materials and manufactured products, and verified proper loads, forces, and mate rials for the design of buildings and equipment anchorage.
Chief of Facilities Engineering | California National Guard | 1991 – 1998 Ron supervised and planned work for engineering design and project inspection staff, developed scope and budgets for projects, directed preparation of plans from preliminary design through working drawings, coordinated and approved project specifications and cost estimates, negotiated and approved project changes, coordinated inspection activities, resolved inspection disputes, represented National Guard/Military Department at public meetings, conducted plan review for projects designed by consultants, and presented design concepts and final designs.
Associate Structural Engineer | CA State Office of Statewide Health Planning & Development | 1987 – 1991
Ron reviewed construction plans and specifications for new hospitals and skilled nursing facilities for California Building Code and UBC requirements, met with architects and engineers to resolve plan review issues, reviewed field changes, investigated, and resolved construction conflicts and other administrative duties.
Associate Engineer Architect | Sacramento County Building Department | 1983 – 1987 Ron reviewed construction plans and specifications, and structural calculations for building code compliance, reviewed plans for residential, multi-residential, commercial, and industrial structures, and met with designers to resolve code issues related to commercial and residential structures.
Exhibit D44
139
MARK BERG, CBO, MCP, ICC
PROJECT MANAGER | MASTER CODE PROFESSIONAL
Mark is an ICC Certified Building Official, Plans Examiner, Building Inspector, and Master Code Professional with over 32 years of experience performing life-safety, architectural, mechanical, plumbing, electrical, and structural reviews in residential, multi- family and commercial projects. Mark has successfully guided department staff with inspection and plan review of all phases of complex construction projects. He is experienced utilizing building department permit tracking software and managing all common building department responsibilities, including plan review, multi- discipline inspections, plan review and inspection scheduling, field supervision, regulatory compliance, code interpretation, and project acceptance. Mark also possesses exceptional skills in complaint resolution, problem solving, damage assessment and team building.
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY
Building Official, Life Safety Plans Examiner | BPR
Consulting Group | 2021-Present
Performing comprehensive plan review and inspection services for client agencies. Reviews residential and non-residential plans for compliance with California Building, Life Safety, Fire, Plumbing, Mechanical, Electrical Codes, Energy and Green Standards, local building codes, policies, amendments, and ordinances.
Building Official, Life Safety Plans Examiner | Consulting Firm | 2017-2021
Performed comprehensive plan review and inspection services for residential and commercial projects for client agencies. Projects included residential, multi-family residential, commercial, and industrial projects consisting of tenant improvements and new buildings.
Building Official | City of Redlands | 2015-2017
Supervised staff coordination with cities, agencies and the public on various Technical or legal aspects of programs. Performed the most complex and difficult plan checks for both building and fire life safety. Reviewed the new and existing codes and regulations and recommended revision to current ordinances, policies, and inspection methods to meet new requirements.
Building Inspection Supervisor | City of Rancho Cucamonga | 2010-2015
Supervised and trained building inspection staff, developed inspection related policies and guidelines for the department, conflict resolution and code interpretations.
Building Official | City of Norco | 2006-2011
Supervised staff coordination with cities, agencies and the public on various technical or legal aspects of programs.
Performed the most complex and difficult plan checks for both building and fire life safety. Reviewed the new and Exhibit D45
140
existing codes and regulations and recommended revision to current ordinances, policies, and inspection methods to meet new requirements. Investigated violations of building construction codes and determined necessity for issuance of legal complaints.
Building Division Manager | County of Riverside | 2001-2006 Handled difficult public relations problems, directs investigations of complaint or problems, and recommends resolutions. Assisted in arranging and conducting classroom and on-the-job training sessions for the technical personnel and counter staff. Supervised the plan examination process, inspections, documentation activities and the development process.
Plans Examiner- Sr. Building Inspector | City of Temecula | 1991-2001 Oversee the plan examination process, inspections, documentation activities and the development review process.
Provided code interpretations and developed technical documents. Performed the most complex building code compliance plan reviews.
PROFESSIONAL AFFILIATIONS
CALBO – Damage Assessment Committee, State Building Codes Committee CACEO – California Association of Code Enforcement Officers CEC – California Energy Commission
ICC – Administrative Committee
ICC Foothill Chapter, Board Member, 2023-2024
NFPA – National Fire Prevention Association, Building Systems Committee IAPMO – Code Interpretation Committees for UPC, UMC
JAEI – Journal of Ancient Egyptian Interconnections
City of Riverside Parks, Recreation, and Community Services Commission
Exhibit D46
141
ROGER PETERSON, SE
PLAN REVIEW MANAGER | STRUCTURAL ENGINEER
With more than 35 years of experience in structural design and plan review, Roger brings considerable depth and knowledge to any project. Roger is a California Registered Structural and Civil Engineer who has designed and provided plan review services for multi- story steel and concrete-framed buildings, as well as one-story structures utilizing steel, concrete, timber, and masonry framing systems. His design experience includes schools, commercial and industrial projects, micro-chip production facilities, power plant installations and multi-family residential projects. Roger's expertise contributes to the success and safety of all projects.
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY
Principal | Structural Engineer | BPR Consulting Group | 2021 - Present
Roger directs client plan review on behalf of BPR Consulting Group providing efficient services on behalf of multiple municipal clients.
Senior Structural Engineer | Project Manager | Consulting Firm | 2006 – 2021
Roger provided management for several of this firm’s offices and special projects as well as performed structural plan review for commercial and residential construction for municipalities for various state and local agencies throughout California. In addition to providing structural plan review services, Roger was responsible for the production and performance of company offices, including maintaining client relationships. His duties also included performing structural plan reviews for industrial, commercial, and residential projects.
Senior Structural Engineer | Plans Examiner | Branch Manager LP2A | Bureau Veritas | CA | 1999 - 2006
Roger served as branch manager and lead structural plan reviewer for the Sacramento Area branch office. He was responsible for the production and performance of office including maintaining client relationships. His duties included performing structural plan reviews for industrial, commercial and residential projects.
Project Engineer | Power Engineers, Inc. | 1999 - 1999
Roger was a project design engineer for commercial and industrial-type projects. He provided structural design and construction administration services.
Project Engineer | Office Manager | R2H Engineering, Inc . | 1998 - 1999 Roger was the office manager and project design engineer responsible for the structural design of commercial projects.
Project Engineer | Rutherford & Chekene | 1995 - 1998
Roger was responsible for providing design and detailing for commercial and industrial type projects, including numerous projects in the micro-chip industry.
Exhibit D47
142
Design Engineer | Project Engineer | DES Engineers & Architects | 1995 - 1 997 Roger provided engineering design and detailing for commercial, institutional, corporate and residential building projects using wood, steel, concrete and masonry building materials.
PROJECT EXPERIENCE
Project Manager | Structural Engineer | Hollywood Park | Inglewood, CA | 2018 – 2021 Roger provided plan review services for this new, mixed-use development which included retail and office space with associated parking encompassing 28.5 acres.
Project Manager | Structural Engineer | Nasa Ames Research Center | Moffett Field, CA | 2018 Roger provided structural plan review and project management of this 1.2 million square- foot development comprised of office, research, and development space.
Project Manager | Structural Engineer | Monterey Park Hotel & Residence | Monterey Park, CA | 2017 – 2021
Roger provided plan review services and project management for this new, mixed-use hotel, condominium, and restaurant podium type building.
Project Manager |Structural Engineer | Hatchet Ridge Wind Farm | Shasta County , CA | 2009 - 2010
Roger provided project management , structural plan review and field inspections for this 101.2 MW power generating facility that consists of 44 – 2.3 MW wind turbines constructed along 9 miles of the ridge line on Hatchet Ridge near Burney, CA.
Exhibit D48
143
BILL RODGERS, SE
STRUCTURAL ENGINEER
Bill has more than 30 years of experience in the field of structural engineering, including more than 20 years of experience as a plan review engineer. His wealth of experience includes a varied and vast list of projects throughout California and Nevada. Bill is in demand for hands - on work within jurisdictions due to his great success in blending excellent engineering skills with responsive customer service.
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY
Principal Structural Engineer | BPR Consulting Group | 2021 - Present
Bill directs client plan review on behalf of BPR Consulting Group providing efficient services on behalf of multiple municipal clients.
Senior Structural Engineer |Plans Examiner | Consulting Firm | 2006 – 2021
Bill performed structural plan review for commercial and residential construction for municipalities for various state and local agencies throughout California and Nevada. In addition to providing structural plan review services, he was responsible for the production and performance of company offices, including maintaining client relationships. Bill’s duties also included performing structural plan reviews for industrial, commercial, and residential projects.
Senior Structural Engineer | Consulting Firm | 2001 - 2006 Bill performed structural plan review for commercial and residential construction for municipalities for various state and local agencies throughout California and Nevada Structural Engineer| Associate | DES Architects + Engineers | 1995 – 2001 Bill was responsible for the structural design of many projects throughout the Bay Area, including Pacific Shores Center in Redwood City, Moffett Corners in Sunnyvale, Carlmont High School in Belmont, and many other projects. Additionally, Bill oversaw the structural department of this architecture and engineering firm, and was responsible for staff development and work quality.
PROJECT EXPERIENCE
Project Manager/Structural Engineer | Judicial Council of California | State of California | 2010 – 2021
Bill provided project management and structural plan review services for new court buildings and court building upgrades throughout California. Most recently he provided services for the new Sonora courthouse, the new courthouse in Modesto, and the new eighteen-story high-rise Sacramento Criminal Courthouse.
Project Manager/Structural Engineer | Division of State Architect | State of California | 2016 – 2021
Exhibit D49
144
Bill provided project management and structural plan review services for new school buildings and school upgrades throughout California. Recent projects include Westmore Oaks Elementary School, Santa Maria High School and El Camino College District, New Behavioral Health and Social Science Building.
Project Manager/Structural Engineer | University of California, Merced | 2020 Campus Expansion | 2017 – 2021
Bill ensured all plan reviews were completed within the agreed upon timeframes by leading weekly conference calls with the plan review and onsite team and regularly visiting the project site. Additionally, Bill provided structural plan review services for this expansive project.
Project Manager/Structural Engineer | City of Berkeley | Berkeley, CA | 2008 – 2021 Bill ensured all plan review services for the City of Berkeley were accurate and completed in a timely manner.
Project Manager/Structural Engineer | Downtown Commons Tower | Sacramento, CA | 2016 – 2019
Bill served as the project manager for the plan review of this new 634,357 gross SF, 16- story, mixed-use tower located adjacent to the new Sacramento Kings Arena. The tower included office space for the team and area management, a 250-room hotel, 44-residential units and below grade parking.
Exhibit D50
145
ELENA HARTSOUGH, SE
STRUCTURAL ENGINEER
Elena is a dedicated structural engineer with over 22 years of experience which includes the design and structural review of structures ranging from small home renovations to large warehouse spaces and custom homes.
Elena’s strengths include experience with multiple building materials including wood, light-gage, masonry, steel and concrete; knowledge of the California Building Code and proficiency in relevant software programs including Enercalc, SAP2000, L-Pile and AutoCAD.
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY
Structural Engineer / Plans Examiner | BPR Consulting Group | 2022 - Present
Elena provides structural and non-structural plan review for residential , industrial and commercial projects including residential master plans, custom residential projects, commercial tenant improvement and remodel projects.
Structural Engineer / Plans Examiner | Consulting Firm | 2014-2022 Elena reviewed residential and non-residential plans for compliance with California Building, and International building standards; state and local building codes, policies, amendments, and ordinances.
Senior Engineer | Department of Water Resources | 2009 – 2014 Elena managed a staff of five, providing resource management and project coordination within the Division of Engineering. She prepared and reviewed preliminary engineering reports, technical memos, and project plans, details, and specifications. She also designed warehouse structure with light-gage wall framing and steel truss roof framing.
Project Engineer / Project Manager | Harris & Sloan Consulting Group | 2003 - 2009 Elena took projects from the schematic design phase through the construction document phase and was point of contact during construction administration. She designed wood -framed residential and commercial structures, researched structural insulated panel (SIP) construction and utilized them in design of structures.
Project Designer | Jon Brody Consulting Group | 2001 - 2003 Elena designed and detailed gravity and lateral systems for new and re-modeled structures utilizing wood, steel, light-gage, and concrete.
Exhibit D51
146
JOSEPH LEONARD, SE
SENIOR STRUCTURAL ENGINEER / PLANS EXAMINER
Joseph has 19 years consultant structural engineering of light framed construction, including single family dwellings, commercial buildings, and public schools, throughout California. He also has 10 years of working as a consultant structural engineering on heavy, low to mid -rise building structures, for public and military use. These clients included NAVFAC, NASA, the Navy, and the Army Corp of Engineers, and various public-school districts in the Southern California area. Joseph also has 2 years examining construction documents for compliance with Parts 1-10, of Title 24 of the California Code of Regulations, for and as adopted by, various local Building Departments.
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY
Senior Structural Engineer & Plans Examiner | BPR Consulting Group | 2023 - Present
Joseph provides structural engineering services and plan review for BPR Consulting Group. This includes review for residential, industrial and commercial projects including residential master plans, custom residential projects, commercial tenant improvement and remodel projects.
Principal Structural Engineer | Joseph Leonard Structural Engineering (JLSE) | 2017 - 2023 Joseph founded Joseph Leonard’s, Structural Engineering (JLSE), specializing in Architectural Engineering and Plan Review for primarily single-family residential structures.
Plan Review Engineer | Coastland Civil Engineering (CCE) | 2015 – 2017 Joseph provided p lan reviews of all types of projects, including all aspects of building design, and client management. Reviewed construction documents for compliance with all of Title 24, including all aspects of building design. More specifically, review included occupancy, allowable building heights/area/stories, construction type, egress and exit paths, access (Chapters 11A and 11B), site access, fire and smoke-rated construction requirements, Wildland-Urban Interface, mechanical, electrical, plumbing, green, and energy, as well as structural (Building Plan Check, Title 24 Parts 1 – 10)).
He also provided review of residential and commercial construction documents for AHJ’s in the North Bay Area and the local area, including everything from single family dwellings to villages. More specifically, the projects included SFD’s, hotels, apartments, townhomes, villages, and senior living facilities.
A partial list of these projects:
Managed the contract and plan review/inspection team for the County of Amador and the City of Ione, to provide building department services. CCE provided both plan review, and inspection services to both authorities. Acquired and managed a contract with the Division of the State Architect (DSA) to provide Structural Plan Review services for public school projects, throughout California. Earned Continuing Education units, by attending numerous seminars through SVABO, with topics ranging from Electrical to Access (11A and 11B).
Exhibit D52
147
Senior Structural Engineer | Stedman and Dyson Structural Engineers | 2008 – 2015 Consultant for structural engineering design services for all types of low to mid-rise structures, structural plan review for the Division of the State Architect (DSA), structural peer review for various UC projects, and Seismic Evaluations of existing buildings and bridges (utilizing ASCE 31 and 41). Joseph also worked on structural design including several schools, a shoot-house, rifle range, church and monastery, planetarium, and parking lot. These clients included NAVFAC, NASA, the Navy, and the Army Co rp of Engineers, and various public -school districts in the Southern California area.
Design Engineer | SMR-ISD | 2008 – 2008
Joseph consulted structural engineering design, of ‘heavy’ structures (steel, concrete, and masonry), and forensics engineering.
Structural Designer | Various Design Firms | 2004 – 2008 Joseph consulted structural engineering of light framed structures, ranging from room additions to new large commercial retail structures, including custom and tract SFDs.
Exhibit D53
148
CHARLES NGANGA, SE, ICC
SENIOR STRUCTURAL ENGINEER | ICC CERTIFIED PLANS EXAMINER
Charles is a California Licensed Structural engineer with a Master of Science degree in Civil Engineering from California Polytechnic State University in San Luis Obispo. He is also a certified ICC plans examiner with nearly 10 years of experience. His work experience, excellent education and solid commitment to the industry has enabled Charles to develop a solid track record of consistently providing clients with exceptional service.
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY
Senior Structural Engineer | BPR Consulting Group | 2023 – Present
Structural Plan review of multiple buildings and facilities including residential, commercial, mixed use, power generation plan ts, communication towers, solar installations etc.
Supervising Structural Engineer | Consulting Firm | 2014 – 2023 Charles performed residential and non -residential plan reviews to ensure compliance with California and International Building and Residential Codes and local building codes to include policies, amendments and ordinances.
Charles also taught classes to multiple ICC Chapters on the 2016 CRC Braded Wall Provisions. The projects completed included the following.
Hollywood Park – City of Inglewood
Structural review of Hollywood Park which is a Mixed-use development which will include retail and office space with associated parking. Structural Steel construction with special moment frames and braced frames. TI included IMAX Theater (Theater seating stands, Screen Support, technical equipment support).
Garden Grove Hotel – City of Garden Grove.
Structural review of the G arden Grove Hotel. The project consisted of Two Reinforced Concrete Hotel Towers - 200 feet tall - 18 stories. The campus also included a Retail Building.
Project Channel – San Joaquin County
Structural review of a Tilt up building in San Joaquin County with a footprint in excess of 1.3 million square feet and a mezzanine level that is over 400, 000 square feet. The project’s lateral force resisting system consisted of special concrete shear walls and structural steel moment frames.
New Terminal (Merced - Yosemite Regional Airport) – City of Merced Structural review for Risk Category III, New Terminal at the Merced Yosemite Regional Airport. The lateral system consisted of steel concentrically braced frames and cold formed steel shear walls.
Exhibit D54
149
Multiple Construction Phase New Courthouse – Judicial Council of California Project Manager and Structural review of the construction phase (Deferred Submittals, RFIs) of the following Courthouses:
1. New Redding Courthouse
2. New Modesto Courthouse
3. New Santa Rosa Courthouse
4. New Sacramento Courthouse.
5. Indio Courthouse
Trainer: 2016 CRC Braced Wall Provisions
Charles provided training on the 2016 CRC Braced Wall Provisions to the following ICC Chapters:
1. ICC, San Joaquin Chapter, 6/14/2017, Hanford CA
2. ICC Sacramento Valley (SVABO) Minstitute, 5/3/2017, Citrus Heights CA.
3. ICC Redwood Empire Chapter, 4/18/2017, Santa Rosa CA
4. ICC Napa/Solano Chapter, 3/14/2017, Fairfield CA
5. ICC Shasta Cascade Chapter, 1/19/2017, Redding, CA
6. ICC Yosemite Chapter, 11/15/2016, Merced CA.
7. ICC Napa/Solano Chapter, 11/18/2020, Via Zoom (2019 CRC)
Exhibit D55
150
CHANDRA DESAI, PE
PLAN REVIEW ENGINEER
Chandra is a California Licensed Civil Engineer with over 40 years of experience in structural engineering, which includes the design of structures for residential, commercial and industrial facilities. He has over 16 years of experience providing plan review, permit processing and field issue resolution for all types of buildings.
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY
Structural Plans Examiner / Plan Review Engineer | BPR
Consulting Group | 2022 - Present
Chandra provides structural and non-structural plan review for residential, industrial and commercial projects including residential master plans, custom residential projects, commercial tenant improvement and remodel projects.
Plan Check Engineer | Consulting Firm | 2015 – 2022
Responsibilities included plan review for residential, industrial, commercial and miscellaneous structures for structural code compliance. Chandra worked with multiple city and county clients along with outside engineers, architects and Building Departments to coordinate and resolve plan review related issues, expedite permit processing and address field related challenges.
Plan Check Engineer | County of Riverside | 1999 – 2015 Responsibilities included plan review for residential, industrial, commercial and miscellaneous structures for both engineering and non-engineering items. Chandra worked with outside engineers, architects and other consultants to coordinate and resolve plan review related issues in order to expedite permit processing and field problem resolution. Chandra assisted Junior Engineers, Inspectors and front counter staff to resolve any code related issues.
Principal Engineer | Parsons Corp. | 1980-1983 / 1987-1999 Responsibilities included design of steel and concrete structures for Petro-Chemical Plants, Gas Plants and industrial facilities. Prepared and checked structural design calculations, cost estimates and construction drawings. Extensive use of in-house computer programs and other structural programs in preparing calculations and drawings. Chandra supervised 4-6 Junior Engineers and CAD O perators in producing construction documents. He prepared cost estimates and man-hour estimates for future and ongoing projects.
Senior Engineer | Sargent and Lundy | 1983 - 1987
Work included the design of steel and concrete structures for nuclear power plant buildings. Chandra prepared structural calculations for reinforced concrete and steel structures for reactor buildings and auxiliary buildings per NRC requirements. Chandra worked on the job site for two years to resolve construction problems and coordinate field activities.
Exhibit D56
151
DENISE REESE, CBO, ICC
PLANS EXAMINER
Denise is an ICC Certified Chief Building Official and Life Safety Plans Examiner.
She has over 10 years of experience performing life- safety, architectural, mechanical, plumbing, electrical, and minimal structural reviews in residential, multifamily and commercial projects, including OSHPD-3 licensed facilities.
This valuable experience is also evident in that Denise specializes in working with applicants, designers and jurisdictions, and successfully serving multiple client jurisdictions.
Denise approaches plan review with her unique knowledge balancing the delivery of timely and accurate reviews while remaining responsive and approachable. Denise is extremely skilled in all disciplines required to successfully bring projects to approval.
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY
Life Safety Plans Examiner | BPR Consulting Group | 2022 - Present
Denise provides comprehensive plan review and inspection services for California client agencies. She performs detailed reviews of residential and non-residential plans for compliance with California Building, CalGreen, Plumbing, Mechanical, Electrical Codes, Energy Standards, state and local building codes, policies, amendments, and ordinances. Denise supervises life safety plans examiners and the permit intake team. She also provides training to new plans examiners.
Building Official & Supervising Life Safety Plans Examiner | Consulting Firm | 2014-2022 Denise performed comprehensive plan review and inspection services for client agencies. Reviewed residential and non-residential plans for compliance with California Building, CalGreen, Plumbing, Mechanical, Electrical Codes, Energy Standards, state and local building codes, policies, amendments, and ordinances. Supervised life safety plans examiners and permit intake team. Provided training to new plan reviewers.
Building Permit Technician II | City of Rancho Cordova | 2010 – 2014 Denise Interpreted and explained policies and regulations accurately and tactfully to the public assisting with the completion of building permit applications. She performed preliminary plan review for completeness and accuracy and to determine appropriate fees.
Customer Service Specialist | City of Rancho Cordova | 2007 - 2010 Denise p rovided customer and administrative support to the Building & Safety Division as well as other departments throughout City Hall.
Administrative Secretary | City of Rancho Cordova | 2006 - 2007 Provided administrative support to the City Manager’s office, his Executive Assistant and the City Council.
Exhibit D57
152
DAVID CASTILLO, ME, FPE
MECHANICAL ENGINEER / FIRE PROTECTION ENGINEER
David brings more than 37 years of breadth, depth, and knowledge of mechanical engineering, design, and plan review to any project. A California licensed professional Mechanical Engineer and Fire Protection Engineer, his expertise encompasses HVAC, Plumbing, Medical Gases, and Fire Sprinklers.
David’s background includes mechanical engineering, design, and plan review on Central Treatment Centers, Substance Abuse Treatment Facilities, Inpatient Mental Health Clinics, and Inmate Housing Units for the Department of Corrections. He has engineered and designed Acute Care Hospitals, Skilled Nursing Facilities, Surgery Clinics, Psychiatric Hospitals, Pharmaceutical Plants, Industrial Plants, Educational Facilities, and Hi-Rise Commercial Buildings.
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY
Senior Plan Review Engineer | BPR Consulting Group |
2021 – Present
David performs mechanical engineering and fire protection engineering plan review services for BRP’s California clients.
Senior Plan Review Engineer | Consulting Firm |
2012 - 2021
David performed mechanical engineering and fire protection engineering plan review services for California clients.
Senior Mechanical Engineer | State of California, OSHPD Group | 2001 - 2012
David performed plan checking of mechanical systems for hospitals, skilled nursing facilities, and surgery centers to ensure code compliance with the CBC, CMC, CPC and NFPA.
Vice President | Technical Engineering Group, Inc. | 2000 - 2001 David responsibilities included acquiring new clients, maintaining existing clients and preparing proposals. He performed heating and cooling load calculations, laid out mechanical designs for central plant systems, chilled water systems, heating hot water systems and variable air volume systems for hospitals, prisons, and educational facilities. David performed in-house plan check of all projects, and served as the Engineer of Record for all projects. He is knowledgeable of CMC, CPC, CBC, NFPA and OSHPD.
Project Manager / Lead Mechanical Engineer | Mazzetti & Associates | 1999 - 2000 David provided project management for all aspects of mechanical design on prisons, hospitals, pharmaceutical facilities, and office buildings. He was familiar with cGMP and all classes of clean rooms related to manufacturing facilities.
Exhibit D58
153
Project Manager / Lead Mechanical Engineer | Interface Engineering, Inc. / 1997 - 1999 David was the lead engineer for the Mechanical Division of a Mechanical/Electrical engineering firm. He initiated and implemented the writing of a Project Management Procedures Manual for companywide use. David performed heating and cooling load calculations, layout of mechanical designs for central plant systems, chilled water systems, heating hot water systems, variable air volume systems, and write specifications.
Mechanical Designer | Edward Rios & Associates | 1994 - 1997 David was responsible for all aspects of HVAC, process piping and plumbing design and drafting for a mechanical engineering firm. He performed heating and cooling load calculations using Trane Trace analysis software.
Mechanical Designer | The Spink Corporation | 1991 - 1994 David was responsible for all plumbing and process piping design and drafting for the Mechanical Division of a 115- person multidisciplinary engineering firm. Drafting was done using AutoCAD Release 11. David’s primary responsibilities included running HVAC loads using Trane “Load 600” analysis program, Title 24 compliance, and field work for remodel/rehabilitation projects.
Mechanical Designer / Estimator | Mark III Engineering Contractors | 1986 - 1991 David performed material takeoffs for plumbing and HVAC. He designed HVAC and plumbing for commercial projects. David priced out projects and submitted bids to general contractor. He also served as a project manager for field staff.
Exhibit D59
154
PETER SIMONSEN, PE
PLAN REVIEW ENGINEER
Peter is a California Licensed Civil Engineer with relevant experience providing plan review services to California public agencies to ensure compliance with all relevant and applicable building codes, ordinances and requirements. Peter brings careful attention to detail and a clear focus on customer service. Peter focuses primarily on structural review as he works towards becoming a licensed structural engineer.
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY
Plan Review Engineer | BPR Consulting Group | 2023 – Present Peter provides engineering plan review for residential and commercial projects including residential master plans, custom residential projects, commercial tenant improvement and remodel projects.
Plan Review Engineer | Consulting Firm | 2018 - 2022
Peter supported California public agency clients by performing Structural plan review for code compliance with the California Building Codes and city ordinances, for commercial and residential structures. Projects ranged from small non -habitable structures to intricate custom designed residences and multi -story apartment complexes. Additional responsibilities include assisting jurisdictions with plan review via in-house reviews and code interpretation as well as training new plan reviewers.
Exhibit D60
155
THOMAS TRIMBERGER, ME, CBO, ICC
MECHANICAL ENGINEER | ICC CERTIFIED PLANS EXAMINER
Thomas has more than 30 years of experience working within building departments both successfully providing and supervising virtually all building department functions. Thomas is a CA Registered Mechanical Engineer, ICC Certified Building Official, Plans E xaminer and Building Inspector. His extensive experience and knowledge enables him to provide excellent services to our clients. Thomas is skilled at developing relationships with developers, designers and the community to ensure plan reviews, inspections and development review functions are performed in an effective and efficient manner. He continuously assists clients by providing guidance and education on the construction and inspection process. Always helpful, personable, professional and successful in delivering a high level of customer service.
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY
Senior Mechanical Engineer/Building Official | BPR Consulting Group | 2023 - Present
Thomas provides plans examination and building official services to municipal clients throughout California.
Building Official/Mechanical Engineer/Plans Examiner | Consulting Firm | 2017 – 2023
Thomas has served as the Chief Building Official for the City of Modesto for and the City of Woodland. He is responsible for both Building Safety and Code Enforcement. Additionally, Thomas works for the City of Vallejo coordinating and performing plan review. Thomas also provides comprehensive building and safety services to a variety of clients throughout the Northern California region.
Chief Building Official/Senior Mechanical Engineer/Plans Examiner | Consulting Firm | 2016 - 2017
Thomas provided Fire and Life Safety, Accessibility, Mechanical, Plumbing, Energy, Green Building Code review standards for both Private and Public- sector clientele.
Mechanical Engineer | California Energy Commission | 2015-2016 Thomas worked in the Existing Buildings (AB758) Program. His responsibilities included, collaborations with local governments and real estate industry personnel regarding energy use in existing buildings.
Senior Mechanical Engineer | Consulting Firm | 2010 - 2015 Thomas provided plan review services for power plants plan. Plan reviews were completed per CA Code standards for mechanical, plumbing, energy, fire and life safety as well as applicable industry standards.
Exhibit D61
156
Reviews were also completed for both private and public buildings and properties. Additional projects included Commercial Property Assessments.
Special Project Manager | City of Rancho Cordova | 2001 - 2010 Thomas managed special projects for the City Manager and Public Works Director, including an Energy Efficiency and Conservations Block Grant, Cemetery expansion and Police Station remodel.
Chief Building Official | County of Sacramento/City of Rancho Cordova | 2003 - 2009 Thomas was responsible for the Building Department operational management and budget. He was responsible for the establishment of the new building and safety department, overseeing all aspects of Building and Safety plan review, permit issuance, field insp ections, complaints and violations, business license inspections, staffing and budgeting.
Senior Mechanical Engineer | County of Sacramento | 1999 - 2005 Thomas duties included; managing 26 inspectors including all aspects of commercial inspections, managing all plan review activities including residential, commercial and all specialists, helped institute a new automated permit system for permit issuance and tracking as well as c oordinated special issues for residential staff for energy compliance and alternate means and materials.
Associate Engineer | County of Sacramento | 1987 - 1999 Thomas was responsible for determining acceptability of proposed mechanical and plumbing systems; advising building owners and designers about the design and code compliance of public potable water, sewer, and gas systems, fire resistive building protection, ventilation, and commercial kitchen exhaust and markup air systems. He supervised the mechanical plan review staff, writing technical correspondence and various other tasks.
HVAC Design Engineer | Airway Heating and Air | 1985 - 1987 Thomas was responsible for the design, estimation of HVAC systems, and technical assistance to jobsite superintendents, preparation of bids, bills of materials, major equipment purchased, issuing and managing subcontracts. Other duties included life -cycle-cost analysis, energy budget analysis, Title 24 Energy Certification and development program.
Design Engineer | Comeau Engineering | 1983 - 1985
Thomas worked in the design of industrial, commercial and residential HVAC, piping and plumbing systems. He performed site surveys concept development and design, drafting, and coordination with contractors and facility staff. Thomas also performed load ca lculations, residential and non -residential Title 24 energy compliance certifications.
Exhibit D62
157
JEROME SCHREIBER, EE
ELECTRICAL ENGINEER
Jerome has more than 4 5 years of electrical industry experience. He is a licensed electrical engineer in California and Hawaii, and is certified by the International Association of Electrical Inspectors as an Electrical Plans Examiner and Electrical inspector. Jerome’s experience is wide and varied, having provided engineering services to the military, public utilities, private organizations and municipal agencies.
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY
Building Inspector | City of Glendale | 2013 -Present
Jerome has served as a Building Inspector for the City of Glendale since August 2013. His duties have included Building, Plumbing, Mechanical, & Electrical Inspections and Plans Examination.
Instructor | Long Beach City College | 2013 -Present
Since 2013, Jerome has served as an instructor in National Electrical Code for Industrial & Commercial Applications at Long Beach City College.
Senior Electrical Inspector | City of Vernon | 1987 -2013 Jerome was responsible for electrical plans examination and performing Building, Plumbing, Mechanical, & Electrical inspections and all electrical installation in the City and for the City municipal facilities.
Electrical Consultant | BSK Engineering | 1986 -1987
Jerome served as an Electrical Consultant for a private firm that provided design for factories, restaurants, computer rooms, car lots, and other such installations.
Distribution Engineer | Southern California Edison | 1983 -1986 Jerome provided service planning and customer coordination for this Southern California utility.
Interior Electrician | Air National Guard | 1978 -1980
Jerome provided electrician services for various installations as a member of the Air National Guard.
Automatic Flight Control Systems Specialist, Sergeant | US Air Force | 1973 -1977
As a Sergeant in the US Air Force, Jerome served as Shift Supervisor and was responsible for repair crew to facilitate maintenance on transient aircraft.
Exhibit D63
158
JINGPEI ZHANG, EE
CA PROFESSIONAL ELECTRICAL ENGINEER
Jingpei is a licensed electrical engineer in California and has over 27 years of experience. He holds a master’s degree in Electrical and Electronic Engineering. His extensive experience in designing a variety of facilities and systems lends to his ability to provide excellent plan review services. His experience includes the design of electrical distribution systems for healthcare centers, data centers, commercial and industrial building and educational facilities.
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY
Plans Examiner | BPR Consulting Group | 2023 – Present
Jingpei provided plan review services for BPR’s California clients to included residential and commercial projects. Project types include residential master plans, custom residential projects, commercial tenant improvement and remodel projects.
Plans Examiner | Consulting Firm | 2011 – 2023
Jingpei provided plan review services for public agencies throughout California.
Plans Examiner | Consulting Firm | 2009 – 2017
Jingpei designed health care facilities, commercial and industry buildings, and schools. Representative Projects included:
• Farm Credit West (bank), Yuba City
• Almadon Ranch Commercial Office Building O6/P5
• El Dorado Surgery Center, Folsom Surgery Center
• Kaiser Folsom HVAC upgrade
• San Francisco Honda Service Center in Folsom and Bayshore • University Village Shopping Center
• Folsom Broderick Restaurant
• Folsom Natural Result Surgery Center
• Sunnyvale Building T warm shell
• Twin River School District schools HVAC system Replacement Senior Electrical Engineer/Project Integration Engineer | Worley Parsons | Folsom/Sacramento, CA | 2007 – 2009
In this position, Jingpei designed and reviewed plans for power plants, including the Ivanpah Solar thermal power plant in Mojave Desert, Ca.; the Geothermal power plant grid transmission upgrade and retrofit in Imperial County; and the PG&E Gas-fired power plant planning phase, Colusa, Ca.
Senior Electrical Engineer | Mazzetti & Associates Inc. | Sacramento, CA | 2000 – 2007 Jingpei designed health care facilities, commercial and industry buildings, including:
• St. Joseph Hospital main office building (MOB), Eureka, CA. • North bay Medical Center:
Exhibit D64
159
• Medical Center Emergency Department, Vacaville, CA.
• Cardio-vascular surgery center, Fairfield, CA.
• Lakeside Hospital, Tele-medical surgery suites, Lakeport, CA. • UC Davis Briggs Hall Chemical Laboratory Building
• Franchise Tax Board Administration building, Rancho Cordova, CA. • Kaiser Hospitals, San Francisco, Vacaville, Roseville, Elk Grove. • Veteran’s Hospital Radiology Department, Mather, CA.
• Woodland Memorial Hospital, mental health department renovation, Woodland, CA. • Microsoft Data center, Redmond, Seattle, WA.
• Lockheed Martin Power distribution system upgrade, Santa Clara, CA. • CDCR Prison Housing units, Delano; Salinas; Vacaville, CA. • Elk Grove Middle school, Elk Grove, CA.
• Santa Clara Elementary School, Santa Clara, CA.
• San Jose Elementary School, San Jose, CA.
Assistant Electrical Engineer | Carlson Corporation | San Francisco, CA | 1997 – 2000 Jingpei designed and built data centers, including:
• AT&T Web hosting data center, Seattle, WA.
• Level 3 Data center, Portland, Or.
• Equinix data centers, New York, city, Chicago, IL.
• GTE call center, various sites.
• Safeco Call Center, Seattle, WA.
• Bank of America Branch offices, various sites.
• Wells Fargo Bank Branch offices, various sites.
Electrical Designer/Draftsman | Peters Engineering | Sacramento, CA | 1996 – 1997 Jingpei designed commercial/industry, residential and schools. AutoCAD drafting and design. Also, Jingpei designed power lighting fire alarm systems for various commercial, industrial, schools and office buildings.
Exhibit D65
160
KEVIN BRENTON, CBO, CASp, ICC
PLANS EXAMINER / INSPECTOR
Kevin is a Certified Building Official, CASp professional, and commercial combination building inspector with over 24 years in the construction and inspection industry combined. He is an active Local Chapter member of the International Association of Plumbing and Mechanical Officials and active member in the local chapter of International Code Coun cil. Kevin has a strong understanding and knowledge of the implementation of local, state and federal building codes.
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY
Senior Plan s Examiner / Building Inspector | BPR Consulting Group | 2022 - Present
Kevin provides plan review and inspection s ervices for residential and commercial projects including residential master plans, custom residential projects, commercial tenant improvement and remodel projects.
Senior Plans Examiner / Inspector | Stanford University | 2019 - 2022
Kevin provided combination field inspections of new and existing building construction including, large complex commercial Structural, Accessibility, Plumbing, Mechanical, Electrical and Fire installations. He performed plan review and specifications for completeness, accuracy and implementation.
Kevin provided the campus with onsite CASp review and Inspection; served as the subject matter expert for building codes and accessibility ; and provided a high level of customer service to all stakeholders though out the duration of projects.
Building Inspector | Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory | 2019 - 2019
Kevin provided combination field inspections of new and existing building construction including large complex commercial Structural, Accessibility, Plumbing, Mechanical, Electrical and Fire installations. Kevin utilized his understanding and implementation of local, state and federal building codes to perform plan review and specifications for completeness, accuracy and implementation. He possessed and practiced his e xperience with DOE procedures and provided expert code evaluations of onsite construction projects.
Structural Building Inspector | Santa Clara County Planning & Development | 2017 - 2018 Kevin provided combination field inspections of new and existing buildings for both commercial and residential projects. He served as the c ommercial combination building inspector for Stanford University, was the lead Inspector for Stanford University Escondido Village (1.5 million sqft. Pre -cast facility) and served as Building Inspector for Santa Clara County correctional facilities.
Senior Building Inspector | Consulting Firm | 2012 - 2021 Kevin provided combination field inspections of new and existing building construction including but not limited to large complex c ommercial Structural, Accessibility, Plumbing, Mechanical, Electrical and Fire installations. He Exhibit D66
161
served as Senior Combination Inspector for the APPLE AC2 campus for the entire duration of project and was the Combination Building Inspector at Sandia National Laboratory. Kevin supervised up to six employees at the AC2 project for daily assignments.
Journeyman Electrician and Pipe Fitter | KRB Construction | 1999 - 2012 Kevin worked on electrical systems in an industrial and commercial environment. He Installed and modified old and new work including but not limited to lighting, outlets electrical fixtures, electrical equipment transformers, switch gear and distribution equipment. Kevin tested and maintained repairs of emergency systems, backup generators, switch gear, fans and motors. Project types included class 1 division 1 electrical systems, f ire alarm systems, emergency power systems, solar arrays, and underground storage tank electrical.
Exhibit D67
162
ANDREW BURKE, CASp, ICC
CERTIFIED ACCESS SPECIALIST | PLANS EXAMINER
Andrew is a Certified Access Specialist and ICC certified Plans Examiner with more than 1 1 years of industry experience in plan review, inspection, administration and estimating. Andrew has extensive plan check experience in multi -story mixed use projects and provides in -depth review of accessibility issues to ensure compliance with all California building codes.
His CASp certification provides him the ability to ensure all aspects of accessibility have been achieved. His formal training in ICC codes, as well as on-the-job experience, helps him to provide thorough and accurate commercial and residential plan reviews and inspections. Andrew is an excellent asset to any building department both in the office and out in the field.
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY
Plans Examiner | Certified Access Specialist (CASp) | BPR Consulting Group | 2021 – Present
Provides life safety and accessibility plan review for residential and commercial projects including residential master plans, custom residential projects, commercial tenant improvement and remodel projects.
Plans Examiner | Certified Access Specialist (CASp) |
Consulting Firm | 2013 – 2021
Provided life safety and accessibility plan reviews for residential and commercial projects including residential master plans, custom residential projects, commercial tenant improvement and remodel projects.
Building Department Intern | Town of Los Gatos | 2012
Andrew worked as an intern in various areas of a building department. Performed field inspections and worked behind the counter as a permit technician.
PROJECT EXPERIENCE
2020 Project Expansion | University of California, Merced | 2016 - 2021 Life Safety and Accessibility Plans Examiner | Andrew reviewed plans for the campus expansion for compliance California Building, Plumbing, Mechanical, Electrical Codes, Energy Standards, Fire Codes, Green Building Standards Code, and California Accessibility Standards; state and local building codes, policies, amendments, and ordinances.
Sac Republic Soccer Stadium | City of Sacramento | 2019 Accessibility Plans Examiner | Andrew provided plan review for this new 409,664 SF stadium to ensure compliance with applicable accessibility codes and standards.
North 40 | Town of Las Gatos | 2018 - 2019
Accessibility Plans Examiner | Andrew provided accessibility reviews for the new 211,773 SF mixed use building in the North 40 development consisting of residential, parking garage, community room and commercial.
InnovAge California PACE | City of Sacramento | 2019
Accessibility Plans Examiner | Andrew provided accessibility plan review services for this new 66,030 SF OSHPD all- inclusive elder care facility valued at $6,250,000.
Exhibit D68
163
DON R. CTIBOR, PE
CIVIL PLAN REVIEW
Don is a highly experienced Licensed California Professional Engineer with extensive project experience and management experience. Specific skills include budget strategy, preparation and oversight and implementation of best practices across multiple departments. Knowledgeable in enforcing compliance and minimum standards to safeguard life, limb, health property and public welfare. Don has successfully provided project management expertise for many California clients.
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY
Plan Review Engineer | BPR Consulting Group | 2022 - Present Don is a licensed professional engineer and provides civil plan review for BPR Consulting Group. Don is well versed in all aspects of land development, civil infrastructure, and grading related to major building projects. Don utilizes his many years' experience to ensure the projects he reviews are well coordinated and clearly identify the information required for a successful project with a minimum of requests for additional information which can often result in project delays.
Professional Engineer | Consulting Firm | Fresno, CA | 2017 – 2022
Don provided project management services for the UC Merced 2020 Project.
This was a $1.3 Billion Campus Expansion Project.
Regional Project Engineer | Moore Twinning Associates, Inc.| 2015 – 2017
Don was the project manager for the Fresno Corporate Office and Monterey Office for Construction Inspection and Material Divisions. He managed 40+ construction material testing and special inspection projects concurrently including the Phase 1 of High-Speed Rail, group up Soledad Middle School, bridge projects, road projects, City water and sewer main/expansion projects. Responsibilities included preparing engineering estimates, expense budgets, proposals, contract development and contract management, report writing, correspondence, presentations to carious clients both public and private sectors. Don provided oversight of Federal, State and Local Laws, Codes and Regulations regarding material testing, special inspections and building codes.
Project Manager & Executive Director | Chukchansi Indian Housing Authority, CA | 2012 – 2014 Don managed all phases of development for 88-unit, low-income development, 6-unit leg up development, master planning and site developments for numerous other projects. He established and maintained long-term working relationships with other Tribes nationally, local contractors, developers along with Federal and local governments.
Additionally, Don oversaw design of all site development and housing related engineering projects for Trib e Exhibit D69
164
throughout Madera, Fresno and Mariposa Counties, to ensure legal and regulatory compliance at all times with all operations.
Air Quality Engineer | San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District, CA | 2009 – 2012 Don reviewed and evaluated permit applications, including calculating emission rates and permit fees, determining compliance or non-compliance with air quality regulations, determining and recommending best available control technology, defining permit conditions, and issuing authority to construct permits. He operated a variety of software and programs used to make engineering calculations, enter and retrieve data, and monitor and correct data entry; investigates and corrects errors in the designs.
Assistant Engineer | Madera County Engineer | 2007 – 2009 Don worked with building department reviewing various structural designs, construction, and inspection of grading, retaining walls, private roads, bridges, drainage, and water and sewer systems; work independently on assigned projects; FEMA prepare, check, review, and evaluate structural computations, prepare plans and specifications for County engineering projects; Reviewed elevation certificates and work closely with FEMA in all flood plain matters; attend and assist the Planning Commission, and other public meetings; act as liaison with other government agencies and the general public.
Exhibit D70
165
BPR
PROFESSIONAL LICENSES AND
CERTIFICATIONS
Certified Access Specialist, CASp-126
Building Plans Examiner
Commercial Building Inspector
Commercial Plumbing Inspector
Licensed Building Contractor No.
430345
GABRIEL ARGUETA, CASp
BUILDING INSPECTOR
Gabriel has 47 years of experience in the construction industry. He is an ICC certified inspector with experience providing building, mechanical, electrical and plumbing inspections on residential and commercial projects for Cities in the Los Angeles area. Gabriel is also a certified CASp expert and has provided CASp inspections as well as provided CASp design as a consultant.
He provides Building Department inspection services to ensure projects were built in accordance with approved plans, specifications and specified codes. Gabriel brings considerable experience from working for several construction companies in the Los Angeles Region.
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY
Building Inspector | BPR Consulting Group | 2021 - Present Gabriel provides building inspection services for municipalities in the Los Angeles area. He provides inspections for CASp, Building Code compliance and compliance with the approved construction documents for residential and commercial projects.
Self Employed | Consultant | 2019 to 2021
Gabriel provided ADA consulting services to commercial property owners and business owners. In addition He provided inspection services for various Cities and provided construction consultation to property owners for residential construction projects.
Sr. Building Inspector | City of Hawthorn CA - Building Division | 2001 - 2019 Senior for residential and commercial projects. Provided general building inspection and public safety inspections. Inspected all aspects of the construction process including building, plumbing, mechanical and electrical phases of residential and commercial projects. Also provide CASp inspections and CASp plan reviews.
Project Manager | Pace Setter Company | 1999-2021
Responsible for managing and coordinating projects and supervising construction crews for the installation of modular buildings and school bungalow classrooms.
Construction Sub-Contractor | William Scotsman Construction Trailers & Modular Buildings | 1995 - 1999
Provided services as a sub-consultant for various projects including numerous projects for the Los Angeles School District.
Self Employed Building Contractor | 1982 - 1995
General contractor in the construction industry for commercial and residential projects.
Union Carpenter | 1980 - 1982
Worked as a carpenter on high rise buildings in the Los Angeles area.
Carpenter and Supervisor | ELCCO Builders | 1976 - 1980 Worked as a carpenter and supervisor for residential construction projects.
Exhibit D71
166
BPR
EDUCATION
DeAnza College, 2017, AA in Liberal
Arts
PROFESSIONAL LICENSES AND
CERTIFICATIONS
ICC Certified Permit Technician,
10138242
SAMANTHA BARKER
PERMIT TECHNICIAN / ADMINISTRATIVE SUPPORT
Samantha is an ICC Certified Permit Technician with experience providing Permit Technician services in support for municipal building departments.
Samantha’s experience includes updating data bases, data input, permit tracking system management, and report generation. In addition to her technical abilities, Samantha utilizes her excellent customer service skills to assist department customers, applicants, and City staff. Samantha is efficient, detail oriented and possesses the ability to multi-task.
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY
Permit Technician | BPR Consulting Group | 2021 – Present Primary responsibilities include providing permit technician services to California municipal clients and customer assistance for building department services. Processes documents and reports and directs them to the appropriate department/person. Samantha facilitates a positive productive working environment and maintains clear communication with permit applicants and coworkers.
Customer Service Associate | Michael’s | 2015 - 2020
As a Customer Service Associate, Samantha’s responsibilities consisted of providing outstanding customer service which included handling transactions, providing knowledge of products and supplies, knowledge of the construction of projects, instructing customers on the appropriate application of products, teaching in-house classes for customers and maintaining front end cleanliness and organization.
Customer Service Associate | L’Occitane | 2013 – 2014
Samantha’s primary duties included assisting customers, managing transactions, and providing outstanding customer services. She was also responsible for opening and closing out registers, bank drops, maintaining storefront organization, receiving and processing shipments, report of damaged items and inventory maintenance.
Customer Service Associate | Northern California Renaissance Faire | 2010 – Present (Seasonal)
Samantha’s primary responsibilities included providing customer relations and inventory management to maintain product organization. She was responsible for sales activities as well as the merchandise displays. Samantha facilitates a positive productive working environment and maintained clear communication with staff and customers.
Exhibit D72
167
BPR
EDUCATION
California State Los Angeles, BS in
Criminal Justice
PROFESSIONAL LICENSES AND
CERTIFICATIONS
International Code Council - 9560759
Residential Plans Examiner
Permit Technician
ALICIA VENTURA, ICC
SENIOR PERMIT TECHNICIAN / PLANS EXAMINER
Alicia is an ICC Certified Permit Technician with over 13 years of experience providing services to multiple California municipal clients. Alicia is well versed in her role as a Permit Technician and has worked with several municipal tracking systems including Trakit. In addition to her technical abilities, Alicia has excellent customer service skills that help her to work well with applicants and City staff. In addition, Alicia is fluent in Spanish, proficient with Microsoft Office software including Word, Excel and PowerPoint, is detail oriented and is able to multi-task.
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY
Sr. Permit Technician | BPR Consulting Group | 2021 –
Present
Primary responsibilities include providing permit technician services to California municipal clients and customer assistance to the general public.
Processes documents and reports and directs them to the appropriate department/person. Alicia facilitates a positive productive working environment and maintains clear communication within the office.
Permit Technician I and II | Consultant | 2018 – 2021
Alicia provided Permit Technician services to several southern California municipalities. She coordinated the permit process for special projects which were typically large, complex projects. Her duties coordinating the intake, review process and the issuance of permits. In addition to all standard permit technician functions, Alicia also performed data entry into the permit tracking system and collected statistical data to prepare monthly reports for both the public and city staffs. She assisted the public in the completion of forms and documents and developed and maintained procedural manuals and worksheets. Alicia also provided over the counter plan reviews for minor submittals. She provided excellent customer services to both external and internal clients to maintain efficient Building Department operations.
Detention Services Officer | L.A. County Probation Department | 2017-2018 Alicia supervised detained probation youth in their activities within the unit, on work assignments, during recreation periods, medical appointments, or awaiting court appearances. Maintained order and control of the unit. Took appropriate action in connection with rules and regulations of the department. Supervised the movement of youth within and outside the facility. Observed and recorded the behavior of youth. Provided situational counseling as needed.
Permit Technician | City of Gardena | 2010-2017
Duties included entering daily inspections for City Inspectors and performing daily office support services. Alicia greeted customers efficiently and effectively. She reviewed and routed plans for plan check, checked for basic code compliance, calculated fees, verified parcel ownership. She reviewed address files and checked for code enforcement violations. She issued electrical, mechanical, residential, commercial, and yard-sale permits. Alicia created monthly reports for record keeping purposes and created monthly notices for residents regarding permit status. She assisted all Community Development staff and worked alongside Code Enforcement Officers as needed.
Exhibit D73
168
CITY OF
MURRIETA
Proposal for Building Services
MAIN PROPOSAL CONTACT:
Shelby Sieracki
Account Manager
626 224-2055
[email protected]
December 12, 2023 | 4:00 P.M.
FEE PROPOSAL
www.interwestgrp.com
Exhibit C1
169
1 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
Section III - Fee Proposal
Interwest will provide Plan Check Services on a percentage of fee basis for the initial plan review and two successive reviews. After the third review, charges will be on an hourly basis. Separate fees for various levels and specific Plan Checkers and for Certified Building Inspectors has been included. We provide the additional adminsitrative support of our in-office Plan Coordinators at no additional charge for the back-office support they provide out of the Irvine project office.
Personnel Hourly Rates Additional Fees or Other Charges Chief Building Official $160 150% for approved over-time Deputy Building Official $125 150% for approved over-time Permit Technician $75 150% for approved over-time
Licensed Plan Review Engineer (structural,
civil, electrical, mechanical) / Architect
$155 150% for approved over-time
Senior Plans Examiner $140 150% for approved over-time
ICC-Certified Plans Examiner $120 150% for approved over-time Building Inspector $90 - $110 150% for approved over-time Certified Access Specialist (CASp) $125 150% for approved over-time Administrative $75 150% for approved over-time
Expedited Plan Check is charged at 1.5x fixed % of fee, or 1.5x standard hourly rates.
Plan Check at 65% up to 3rd review, anything after is performed at an hourly rate per the rates above.
Additional Services
CLASSIFICATION HOURLY BILLING RA TE
Building Safety Services
Supervising Structural Engineer
................................................................................................... $185 Senior Structural Engineer ............................................................................................................ $175 Fire Protection Engineer ............................................................................................................... $155 Senior Fire Plans Examiner ........................................................................................................... $130 Fire Plans Examiner / Fire Inspector ............................................................................................. $120 Senior Code Enforcement Officer ................................................................................................ $135 Code Enforcement Officer ........................................................................................................... $125 Trainee ........................................................................................................................................... $75 Beginning on the 1st anniversary of the Effective Date of the Agreement and annually thereafter, the hourly rates listed below shall be automatically increased based upon the annual increase in the Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics or successor thereof, Consumer Price Index (United States City Average, All Items (CPI-U), Not Seasonally adjusted, All Urban Consumers, referred to herein as the “CPI”), unless a mutually agreed upon rate increase is established. Such increase shall not exceed 5% per annum. The increase will become effective upon publication of the applicable CPI data. If the index decreases, the rates listed shall remain unchanged.
Exhibit C2
170
CITY OF
MURRIETA
Proposal for Building Services
MAIN PROPOSAL CONTACT:
Shelby Sieracki
Account Manager
626 224-2055
[email protected]
December 12, 2023 | 4:00 P.M.
www.interwestgrp.com
Exhibit D1
171
Tab A
Letter of Transmittal
Exhibit D2
172
1 1 Jenner, Suite 160
Irvine, CA 92618
949.299.5300
December 12, 2023
Tiffany Vance, Administrative Assistant
Electronic Submittal: via PlanetBids @ [email protected] RE: RFP for On-Call Building Services
Dear Ms. Vance,
Interwest Consulting Group, Inc. (Interwest) has carefully reviewed all elements of the City of Murrieta’s (City) RFP and is pleased to present our proposal in response to your RFP to provide on-call, as-needed Building Services, including Plan Check, Building Inspection Services, Permit Technician Services, CASp Services, and miscellaneous services such as general training, code update and adoption support as needed and/or upon request. For this effort, we will provide highly qualified and appropriately licensed staff who are International Code Council (ICC) Certified Plan Reviewers, Building Inspectors, and qualified Permit Technicians. The team members identified within our proposal were carefully selected based on their experience, qualifications, and wealth of relevant knowledge. They have significant experience providing related services for a multitude of California cities and counties, as both private consultants and municipal staff. In fact, our Plan Reviewers. Inspectors, and Permit Technicians have been assisting the City since 2013, therefore they are very familiar with local concerns and ordinances.
Interwest maintains the largest staff of building safety professionals in California. With a deep bench of more than 400 professionals dedicated to providing building safety services to our clients, our team of well-qualified staff is available to assist the City as needed to meet workload demands.
Interwest’s core values of Integrity, Teamwork, Continued Improvement, Service, and Respect, create a positive work environment and strongly contribute to our best-in-class client satisfaction results and employee retention.
We continuously strive to provide experts in the industry who seamlessly perform our services by creating customized solutions tailored to our customers needs. We work collaboratively with our partners to resolve issues as efficiently as possible to expedite processes with our focus on successful delivery of services.
As President of Interwest, I am authorized to sign any agreements that may result from this proposal and will provide contract support to the proposed Interwest team. The proposed pricing will be valid for 120 days.
Interwest does not take any exceptions to the RFP , however, we have requested contract modifications on pages 19-20.
We are excited about this opportunity to continue partnering with the City of Murrieta and work together to create a better future for the community while we strengthen our partnership! Sincerely,
Paul Meschino, President of Interwest
Primary Contact:
Shelby Sieracki
Account Manager
626.224.2055
[email protected]
Project Office:
1 Jenner, Suite 160
Irvine, CA 92618
949.299.5300
A. | Letter of Transmittal
Exhibit D3
173
Tab B
Table of Contents
Exhibit D4
174
2 2
A. | Letter of Transmittal ...........................1 B. | Table of Contents ...............................2 C. | Summary ..............................................3 Management Personnel and Primary Contacts ...........3 The Interwest Advantage ...................................................4 D. | Statement of Understanding .............5
E. | Background and Experience ..............6
Current and Previous Municipal Clients .........................8 Project Office .......................................................................8 Expertise in Service Delivery .............................................9 Support Staff Services .......................................................16 F. | Approach to Building Services .........17
1. Cover Letter/Letter of Introduction .......................... 17
2. Table of Contents .........................................................18
3. Exceptions ......................................................................19 G. | Proposal Content ..............................21
Section I - Experience ......................................................21 Section II - References .....................................................27 Section III - Fee Proposal ............................................... 28 Section IV - Turnaround Times ..................................... 28 H. | References and Potential
Conflicts of Interest ........................ 29
References ..........................................................................29 Potential Conflicts of Interest .........................................33 Current Building Services Public Clients ......................33 Ongoing Litigation ............................................................35 I. | Compensation & Reimbursement ... 36
J. | Additional Information .....................37
Quality Control/ Quality Assurance ..............................37 Appendix A - Key Personnel Résumés
FEE PROPOSAL - Separate Document
B. | Table of Contents
Exhibit D5
175
Tab C
Summary
Exhibit D6
176
3 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
C. | Summary
Interwest has been working with the City of Murrieta, delivering Building Department Services for 10 years, since 2013. We have delivered successful Building Services, including plan reviews and building inspections to the City; a total of 344 plan reviews for the City so far this year. We have had the privilege of working on projects such as the Monamos Apartments and TI improvements for the Aldi Grocery Store. Our past and current performance with the City demonstrates our successful project delivery and exceptional customer service. We are very familiar with your permit software, Bluebeam®, along with your local codes, City ordinances, and expectations for successful plan reviews and building inspections. We always strive to provide the most efficient, effective, and harmonious approach to all aspects of partnering with your City.
As the nation’s leading provider, 60% of our services are commercial with 40% as residential. Interwest has extensive experience and a proven track record of successfully providing on-call consultant services to public agencies. Our services are specifically tailored to fit the needs of our clients. We furnish both technical excellence and a thorough understanding of the regulatory process to assist our clients through the sometimes-daunting complexities associated with the delivery of projects, implementation of important public programs, and adoption of significant public policy.
Interwest staff has held senior and executive management positions within numerous California cities and public agencies, including the titles of City Engineer, Public Works Director, Construction Manager, Building Official, City Planner, and other management personnel. This depth of experience brings a high level of knowledge and sensitivity towards community and special interest group issues. We value the importance of a focus that represents the interests of our public agency clients and reflects positively on the citizens they serve.
Management Personnel and Primary Contacts
Interwest believes that maintaining frequent and consistent check-ins between the account management and operations teams and our clients is key to the early identification of performance risks and contributes to contract success. Your account manager will continue to meet with City staff on a regular basis to ensure client satisfaction.
These meetings will continue to provide both parties the opportunity to manage the resources tactfully and develop the best Contractor-Client Relationship. Further, we can also estimate and evaluate possible future and current needs to ensure the City has a dedicated team as workflow ebs and flows.
Shelby Sieracki.
Account Manager
626.224.2055
[email protected]
Bil Hayes, CBO, ICC
State Operations Manager
909.568.9749
[email protected]
Adrienne Peterson
Irvine Plan Review Manager
951.322.4272
[email protected]
Project Office: 1 Jenner, Suite 160, Irvine, CA 92618 | 949.299.5300 Exhibit D7
177
4 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
Shelby Sieracki, Proposal Main Contact, Account Manager Shelby is your dedicated Account Manager, she works in tandem with our team to provide support and ensure client satisfaction. Shelby will continue to schedule regular check-in meetings to discuss your needs, and ensures proper follow through.
Adrienne Peterson, Irvine Plan Review Manager
Adrienne is an ICC-certified California Building Plans Examiner and Permit Technician with more than 20 years of direct municipal Building Safety Department experience. Adrienne began her building services career as a permit technician, serving cities and the general public at the counter. This experience has given her insight into the importance of exemplary customer service and strict adherence to turnaround deadlines.
William “Bill” Hayes, CBO, ICC, State Operations Manager William is an experienced Building Official, Project Manager, and Public Works Director performing operations oversight and collaborating with City Managers and City Commissioners in strategic planning for City budgets.
He has performed intergovernmental relations collaborating with agencies such as DOT, Water and Sewer, State representatives, FEMA and others. He has experience in Labor Relations, and has been responsible for contract negotiations, grievance resolution and contract implementation.
The Interwest Advantage
As proven throughout our partnership with the City of Murrieta, we have remained dedicated to open communication, proactive problem-solving, and prioritizing the City’s satisfaction. We are committed to a “no surprises” approach built upon presenting ideas, asking questions, and identifying and addressing issues early in the process. We will propose options, seek direction, and implement solutions in close coordination with the City. Our team will provide the following fundamental elements and advantages to the City:
• No “getting to know you” phase . Interwest has practical knowledge and understanding of established business practices which will ensure a streamlined and positive experience for internal and external customers without service disruptions.
• Local Understanding. Having provided plan review services to the City since 2013 and many other jurisdictions surrounding Murrieta, our team is very familiar with your local codes and ordinances. • Industry Expertise. We are skilled in assisting municipalities in Building Safety Departments. Our body of experience encompasses successful solutions for transitioning, personnel augmentation at all levels, and development of services, policies and procedures throughout all aspects of municipal government. Our Building Safety Division is the largest in California. In addition to Murrieta, we currently furnish plan review services to many California cities, including Temecula, Wildomar, Menifee, and San Jacinto to name a few. • Staff Experience. Our staff has held senior and executive management positions within numerous California cities and public agencies, including the titles of Community Development Director, Building Official, Building Plans Examiner, Building Inspector, and Permit Technician, and other management personnel. This depth of experience brings a high level of knowledge and sensitivity towards community and special interest group issues. Our staff holds a wealth of code knowledge and building industry experience with some involved in the development of the California codes. We share this unique knowledge by providing code- related training and instruction at California Building Officials conferences and training seminars, at various ICC Chapters.
Exhibit D8
178
Tab D
Statement of Understanding
Exhibit D9
179
5 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
D. | Statement of Understanding
We understand that the City is seeking a consultant to provide Building Services, including Plan Check, Building Inspector Services, Permit Technician Services, CASp Services, and miscellaneous services such as general training, code update and adoption support as needed and/or upon request to assist the City as-needed on an on-call basis. We have well-qualified personnel to provide plan reviews, including CASp-certified plan reviewers. Our Building Inspectors are knowledgeable and experienced and ensure that the construction is being performed in conformance with the approved project plans as well as identifying issues of noncompliance. Our Permit Technicians/Office Clerks deliver excellent customer service, maintaining a smooth flow of documents and plans throughout departments. Contact with the public at this initial point sets the tone for any additional interaction throughout the life of a project.
As previously mentioned, Interwest has been providing staffing to municipalities for over 21 years. Providing building and life safety department services is at the core of our business and we understand that municipalities can experience peaks that can backlog their departments. Being able to seek qualified professional assistance on an as-needed/on-call basis is a major tool for City leadership to rely on for specialty projects where the City may require specific expertise, periods of planned or unplanned staff absences, peak periods, or in the event of a disaster. Our staff is adept at assisting municipalities for short or long engagements, or specific projects; we can provide qualified personnel tailored to the City’s changing needs.
Exhibit D10
180
Tab E
Background and Experience
Exhibit D11
181
6 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
E. | Background and Experience
Interwest has 21 years of extensive experience and a proven track record of successfully providing complete building department services to public agencies in California. We currently serve more than 330 public agencies, providing plan review, inspection services, and community development technician services.
Interwest was founded by individuals with a passion for serving municipalities. Our company of more than 400 employees spans a multitude of disciplines, roles, and job placements to municipalities within building safety and public works departments throughout California.
Providing building department services is at the core of our business. We have highly qualified staff and extensive resources throughout the state.
Interwest is comprised of licensed Civil and Structural Engineers, Electrical Engineers, Fire Protection Engineers, and Mechanical Engineers registered in the State of California, ICC-Certified and highly qualified Plans Examiners and Inspectors, Certified Access Specialists (CASp), licensed Architects, and other professionals specializing in providing complete building safety services to local government agencies.
In April 2018, Interwest acquired Tri Lake Consultants, a municipal engineering firm, and in May 2019, acquired CPSI Real Estate Services.
In January 2020, Interwest was acquired by SAFEbuilt LLC and in that transaction became the Managing Partner for EsGil, Kutzmann and Associates, and BroadSpec, all of which are providers of Building Department Services.
SAFEbuilt, LLC, our parent company, began providing exceptional community development services to local governments in 1992. Today, they are a national leader performing value-added professional, technical, and consulting services to more than 1,700 clients in 37 states and the District of Columbia. With a nationwide workforce of experienced professionals working across our family of subsidiary companies, we can support your community with the people, scale, and services you need.
INTERWEST PROFILE
YEAR FOUNDED &
BUSINESS STRUCTURE:
2002, (21 Years)
Corporation
9300 W. Stockton Blvd.,
Suite 105
Elk Grove, CA 95758
FIRM CAPACITY:
More than 400
Employees
(and 700+ Plan Reviews
completed weekly)
PROJECT OFFICE:
1 Jenner, Suite 160
Irvine, CA 92618
949.299.5300
SERVICES INTERWEST
PROVIDES:
Building Department Services
Public Works & Municipal
Engineering
City Planning & Urban Design
City Engineering
Construction Management
Traffic Engineering &
Transportation Planning
Real Estate & Right-of-Way
Acquisition
Grant Writing & Administration
Capital Project Delivery
Private Development Services
With a staff of more than
200 professionals in our
Building and Safety Division,
Interwest maintains the
largest building and safety
services staff in California.
Exhibit D12
182
7 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
We fully realize the benefits of being part of a national brand and share those benefits with our clients, including enhanced technology, more scalable systems, and processes designed to improve quality and efficiency.
Municipalities demand practical, cost-effective, and innovative solutions. We utilize our proprietary technology, partner solutions, operational best practices, and national and local certified experts to deliver meaningful results and higher service levels. Interwest brings a comprehensive set of innovative, technology solutions: Community Core (our proprietary building services software), digital plan review and workflow management, geographic information systems, field management technology, custom application development, IT support, software integration, and analytical solutions. We also integrate with a full range of local government software systems.
Interwest Consulting Group is a Colorado Corporation and is a wholly owned subsidiary of SAFEbuilt, Inc. Interwest is also a managing partner of the following subsidiary firms in California: EsGil Corporation, BroadSpec Company, and Kutzmann and Associates. Interwest combined with our California subsidiaries employs nearly 500 professional staff, supported by SAFEbuilt’s larger resources of about 1,400 national employees. Above is an organizational chart for the firm leadership of Interwest Consulting Group.
Exhibit D13
183
8 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
Current and Previous Municipal Clients
On the following page, we list a sampling of California clients for whom we currently provide, or have recently provided services. We do not have any foreseeable or potential conflicts of interest from such respresentation involving our clients. A more complete list of clients can be found on pages 33-35.
Client Scope of Work Client
Since
Population
City of Anaheim Plan Review, Inspection, Permit Technician 2015 351,043 City of Chino Hills Building & Accessibility Plan Review & Inspection 2015 80,374 City of Corona Building & Fire Plan Check & Inspection 2016 167,836 City of Costa Mesa Interim Building Official, Plan Review & Inspection 2007 113,825 City of Eastvale Building Official, Plan Review, Inspection, Permit Technician 2010 63,211 City of El Monte Plan Review, Inspection, Permit Technician 2018 115,586 City of Garden Grove Plan Review, Inspection 2017 172,646 City of Inglewood Plan Review & Inspection through Tri-Party Agreements 2018 109,419 City of Lake Elsinore Building Official, Plan Review, Inspection, Permit Technician 2016 68,183 City of Lake Forest Building Official, Plan Review, Inspection, Permit Technician 2009 84,294 City of Long Beach Plan Review, Inspection 2009 470,130 City of Murrieta Plan Review, Inspection 2013 113,326
City of Palmdale Plan Review, Inspection 2018 156,667
City of Pomona Building Official, Building and Grading Plan Review, Inspection, Permit Technician
2009 152,939
City of Santa Clarita Plan Review, Inspection 2014 210,888 City of Tustin Plan Review, Inspection 2007 80,498
City of Upland Building Official, Building & Fire Plan Review, Inspection, Permit Technician
2013 76,999
City of Vernon Plan Review, Inspection 2011 114
City of Wildomar Building Official, Plan Review, Inspection, Permit Technician 2008 36,932 City of Yorba Linda Plan Review, Inspection 2010 68,229 County of Los Angeles Building Inspection, Permit Technician 2010 10.16 Million
County of Riverside Plan Review, Inspection, Permit Technician 2015 2.423 Million
Project Office
Most services will be delivered remotely or on-site, however, the project office will be our Irvine office located at 1 Jenner, Suite 160, Irvine, CA 92618.
Exhibit D14
184
9 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
Expertise in Service Delivery
Plan Review Services
Our Plan Review Services program is the largest in California, with hundreds of civil, traffic, structural, electrical, fire protection, and mechanical engineers licensed in their respective state of practice, ICCertified Plans Examiners, CASp, licensed architects, professional land surveyors, and other professionals specializing in multidisciplinary plan review to local government agencies.
Our depth of experience brings a high level of knowledge and sensitivity towards community development issues. We value the importance of a focus that represents the interests of our public agency clients and reflects positively on the citizens they serve.
Interwest has the collective, diverse team and experience to perform a full range of plan review services, and all staff assigned are well-qualified, knowledgeable, and will be available to perform the necessary work. We view our role as facilitating the efficient delivery of high-quality plan reviews by:
• Taking a partnering versus regulatory approach.
• Balancing the need to ensure conformance to standards and regulations with the need for predictability, uniformity, and efficiency.
• Provide a seamless plan review process to prevent unintentional “games of gotcha” for project applicants. • Evaluation of all plan reviews for quality control, the level and quality of comments from the review, consistency with similar reviews, and the avoidance of late hits or “gotcha” comments. • Multi-disciplinary reviews are typically performed electronically, remotely or in our offices, but we are available for on-site work when required. We understand both the City and the project applicant are looking for quality reviews within a defined time frame. Our staff will meet or exceed the city’s turnaround time outlined in the RFP . Our staff is experienced with providing electronic plan review and will continue to provide this service.
Exhibit D15
185
10 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
Technical Capabilities In Plan Check Areas
Interwest staff possesses significant technical capabilities in all areas of plans examination competence. Plans examiners are licensed engineers and/or ICC-Certified or otherwise qualified Plans Examiners with extensive experience providing plan review services. Plans examination activities will be performed under the direction of a California-licensed professional engineer and/or licensed architect. Our staff will conduct an accelerated plan review on an as-needed basis as requested by the Building Official.
NON-STRUCTURAL LIFE SAFETY
Interwest’s non-structural plans examiners furnish plan review services for a vast array of projects including large residential, commercial, institutional, industrial, retail, and OSHPD 3 medical office buildings. Many of our plans examiners are CASp-certified. Completed plan review projects range from single-story residential projects to complex high-rise buildings and numerous building additions and remodels.
We are experienced and familiar with the use and application of the most current editions of the following codes:
• California Building Standards Code
• Americans with Disabilities Act Standards for
Accessible Design
• ANSI Standards
• NFPA Codes & Standards
• CA Code of Regulations (CCR) Titles 19 and 25
• Jurisdiction-adopted amendments or ordinances
STRUCTURAL
Our California-licensed Structural Engineers have experience designing and reviewing projects utilizing virtually all building materials:
• Steel Moment Frames
• Buckling Restrained Braced Frames
• Eccentric Braced Frames
• Concentric Braced Frames
• Concrete Moment Frames
• Wood Shearwall Systems
• Masonry Shearwall Systems
• Concrete Shearwall Systems
• Cantilevered Column Systems
• Various Proprietary Lateral Force Resisting
Systems
Our engineers have designed or reviewed a wide array of lateral force-resisting systems, including:
Our structural engineers are experienced with the provisions of most model codes including, but not limited to, current versions of:
• CCR Title 24, Part 2, Volume 2
• AISC 341, 358 and 360
• ASCE 7
• ASCE 41
• AISI Standards for Cold For med Steel
• ANSI / AF&PA NDS for wood framing
• ACI 318
• ACI 530 / TMS 402/602
• CA Historic Building Codes
• CA Existing Building Codes
• NEHRP Requirements for Existing Building
• Wood
• Masonry
• Heavy Timber / T imber Frame
• Concrete
• Structural Steel
• Cold-Formed Steel Framing
• Straw Bale
• Rammed Earth
• Aluminum
Exhibit D16
186
11 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
MECHANICAL, PLUMBING & ELECTRICAL
Interwest’s California-licensed Mechanical and Electrical Engineers are well-versed in the application of California Mechanical, Plumbing, Electrical, Energy, and Green Building Standards Codes:
• California Building Code
• California Residential Code
• California Plumbing Code
• California Mechanical Code
• California Electrical Code
• Jurisdiction-adopted ordinance
ENERGY COMPLIANCE
Our engineers and plan reviewers are up-to-date on all California Energy requirements as they relate to both new and remodel construction on large residential and commercial projects. The Energy Efficiency Standards for Residential and Nonresidential Buildings were established in 1978 in response to a legislative mandate to reduce California’s energy consumption. These standards are updated periodically to allow consideration and possible incorporation of new energy efficiency technologies and methods.
GREEN BUILDING STANDARDS
Our staff is familiar with the incorporation of CALGreen building criteria into project designs and the resulting potential impact as related to the building codes. In addition, staff members have participated in the development of various “green” standards for super adobe, rammed earth, and straw bale construction, to name a few.
LEED
Developed by the U.S. Green Building Council (USGBC), LEED provides building owners and operators a framework for identifying and implementing measurable green building design, construction, operations, and solutions.
LEED certification consists of a number of different rating systems that apply to many building types—commercial as well as residential and measures how well a building performs across many sustainability metrics including energy savings, water efficiency, CO2 emissions reduction, improved indoor environmental quality, and stewardship of resources and sensitivity to their impacts.
ACCESS COMPLIANCE – CASP REVIEW
All of Interwest’s CASp-Certified professionals are knowledgeable of state and federal accessibility laws and regulations and possess the expertise necessary to promote access to facilities for persons with disabilities. Our goal is to provide experts in the industry who can perform services for building departments by customizing our services to correspond with our client’s expectations and needs. We work collaboratively with our clients to resolve plan review and inspection-related issues as efficiently as possible, ultimately resulting in an expedited process and successful project.
Our architects and plans examiners are fully trained and familiar with CA Building Code Accessibility requirements and ADA compliance regulations and they are available for plan review and/or evaluations and consultation.
We offer support to municipalities for compliance enforcement and/or developing a transition plan towards compliance and successfully partner with the disabled community to address the needs and requirements of both entities. We can assist our clients in interpreting various issues relating to access compliance, such as access compliance obligations, transition planning, construction costs, construction phasing, code ‘interpretation,’ hardship, and code changes.
Exhibit D17
187
12 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
FLOOD ZONES
Interwest’s staff of engineers and plans examiners have experience in providing plan reviews for projects located in flood zones, as several of our clients have developments that occur in areas prone to flooding. Interwest’s staff has provided numerous plan reviews for projects located in flood zones using FEMA’s Technical Bulletins as well as the local jurisdiction’s ordinances. In addition, members of Interwest’s staff have participated in state- sponsored committees to establish guidelines and regulations for construction in areas designated as flood zones.
OSHPD 3
Our staff of plans examiners has extensive experience in providing plan reviews for OSHPD 3 projects. Our staff is well versed with the OSHPD 3 requirements contained in the California Building Code. We also have OSHPD- Certified Inspectors available on an as-needed basis.
FIRE CODE PLAN REVIEW
We have a complete staff of experienced and licensed professional fire protection plans examiners and inspectors for your fire life safety needs. Our staff can check plans for compliance with all applicable fire code and standard requirements, including but not limited to the following: ICC Fire Code, Uniform Fire Code, California Fire Code, Life Safety Code, NFPA standards, and your local/regional amendments.
Our Fire Plans Examiners and Inspectors are well-versed in the use and application of the following model codes, standards, and regulations:
•
California Fire Code (CFC)
• California Building Code (CBC)
• Local amendments and policies r elated to the CFC and CBC • Adopted National Fir e Protection Standards
• California Health and Safety Code
• Appropriate listings (CSFM, UL, etc.) for common systems and materials
• Fire Department Standards
• National Fire Protection Referenced Standards pursuant to the above Codes
• Municipal, State, or Federal regulat ions enforced by Fire Departments and Fire Districts
HIGH FIRE HAZARD AND CODE COMPLIANCE
We understand that municipal codes may be frequently updated, so we will ensure that the projects we are inspecting are compliant with current code requirements. This includes the newly released State Fire Marshal Map requirements for high-fire hazard areas based on Chapter 7A of the CBC. More specifically, we will ensure compliance with Title 24 California Building Standards Codes covering structural, life safety, disabled access, energy conservation, green building, plumbing, mechanical and electrical installations in residential, commercial, industrial, existing, and historical buildings.
Exhibit D18
188
13 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
Interwest’s Engineers and Plans Examiners have experience in providing plan reviews for projects located in high fire hazard zones, as several of our clients have developments that occur in areas prone to wildfires. Interwest’s staff has provided plan reviews for projects located in high fire hazard zones using FEMA’s Technical Bulletins as well as the Title 24 California Building Standards Code.
CODE INTERPRETATIONS
Code interpretations are subject to final review and approval by the Chief Building Official, or City designated staff. Interwest’s Engineers and Plans Examiners will provide unbiased recommendations and background information to help the Building Official or Fire Marshal make an informed decision. All plan review comments are subject to review and approval by the City Building Department.
SPECIAL PROJECTS AND ACCELERATED SERVICES
Interwest can accommodate special project plan review needs such as multi-phased or accelerated plan reviews.
We establish project-specific turnaround goals and procedures with City staff for these types of projects based on the complexity of the projects as well as the construction schedule. Our staff of engineers and plans examiners will work with the City to resolve all plan review issues. Our staff will deal directly with applicants and their designers during the plan review process to resolve all issues collaboratively to resolve plan review issues as quickly as possible.
COMMUNICATING PLAN REVIEW RESULTS
Plan reviews, when not immediately approved, will result in lists of comments referring to specific details and drawings, and referencing applicable code sections. Interwest will provide the City with a clear, concise, and thorough document from which clients, designers, contractors, and owners can work. At the completion of each plan review cycle, Interwest will return an electronic and hard copy of the plan review comment list to the designated applicant and City representative. Upon completion of the plan review, after all plan review issues have been resolved, Interwest will provide two complete sets of all final documents annotated as “reviewed” to the City for final approval.
ON-SITE CONSULTANT SERVICES & MEETING ATTENDANCE
Our staff is available for pre-construction or pre-design meetings, field visits, contacts with the design team, and support for field inspection personnel as needed. With some reasonable limitations, pre-construction and pre- design meetings associated with projects that we perform plan reviews are considered part of the plan review service. Interwest’s Engineers and Plans Examiners will be available to meet with City staff, the design team, applicants, and/or contractors, at the City’s request, to discuss and resolve plan review and code-related issues.
We will be available within one (1) business day to respond to questions from the City that may be generated during field inspections for each authorized plan check that is subsequently issued a permit for construction.
Voicemails, e-mails, and faxes will be responded to as quickly as possible, always within 24 hours.
ELECTRONIC PLAN CHECK SERVICES
Interwest currently provides electronic plan review services to the City, maintaining its own software license for Bluebeam®. Electronic plan check services deliver many benefits to municipalities, including substantially improved turnaround times; instantaneous comments to the developer, applicant, or architect; secured accessibility to documents; and reduced paper storage. Our staff is experienced in providing electronic plan Exhibit D19
189
14 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
reviews and will continue to utilize Bluebeam® to efficiently process City plan review services. Our goal is always to collaborate with and support the building department by providing thorough, accurate, and timely plan reviews.
PLAN REVIEW TRACKING METHOD & BILLING PROCESS
Our staff has experience working with most project-tracking databases utilized by building departments. Our staff will update electronic records and make project-related database entries as directed by the City. We will create and maintain a Jurisdiction File containing our research on any unique amendments or specifications required by your jurisdiction, billing arrangements, contact information, and any special requests you would like us to keep in mind.
Interwest uses a custom-designed database to maintain and track all plans throughout the review process from the moment you request a pick-up and/or shipment to delivery of the final, approved documents. Information such as project name, City’s project number, assigned plan reviewer(s), date documents were received, plan review cycle and completion date for the current review can be provided. In addition to standard phone communication, custom reports can be emailed.
Additionally we currently provide online tracking for the City with a custom-designed web template geared to provide any reporting and information needs required. Our staff is available during standard business hours to answer questions via phone or email regarding the actual plan review in progress. We maintain active email accounts and our staff will be responsive to any City or applicant needs. If we cannot speak directly to a caller, we will return calls no later than 24 hours.
Inspection Services
Mike Austin, ICC and other a ssigned staff will continue to perform inspection services, as needed, to verify that the work of construction is in conformance with the approved project plans as well as identifying issues of non- compliance with applicable building and fire codes. Our field inspection services will include site inspections and writing legible and understandable correction and violation notices and field reports. In addition, we will be available to answer in-person or telephone inquiries.
Mike Austin, ICC and other assigned inspectors have been providing inspections on an on-call basis since 2017 and are knowledgeable about local regulations and concerns.
We understand that municipal codes may be frequently updated, so we will ensure that the projects we are inspecting are compliant with current code requirements. More specifically, we will ensure compliance with Title 24 California Building Standards Codes covering structural, life safety, disabled access, energy conservation, green building, plumbing, mechanical and electrical installations in residential, commercial, industrial, existing, and historical buildings.
Interwest’s ICC-/CASp-Certified Inspectors have performed building inspection services on a wide variety of construction projects including new residential developments, large custom homes, and commercial, institutional, assembly, essential service buildings and industrial projects. When necessary for large or fast-track projects, multiple inspectors are available.
Interwest’s Inspectors will provide field inspections including site inspections of projects to verify conformance with approved drawings and specifications, which will include review of the permit documents to verify that onsite conditions are consistent with the approved documents for square footage, setbacks, heights, and any other applicable conditions. At the completion of inspections, Interwest’s Inspectors will complete all necessary City forms and documents as required to provide seamless service.
Exhibit D20
190
15 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
INSPECTOR QUALIFICATIONS & CERTIFICATIONS
Interwest retains inspectors who are motivated to achieve the highest level of experience and certification. We work hard to match your jurisdiction’s level of safety and code compliance.
All Interwest Inspectors are ICC-Certified. Inspection personnel assigned will be able to read, understand and interpret construction plans, truss drawings and calculations, prepare and maintain accurate records and reports, communicate effectively orally and in writing and to work effectively with contractors, the public and general staff. Inspectors will possess knowledge of approved and modern methods, materials, tools, and safety used in building inspection and the most current building standards.
INSPECTION SCHEDULE
Interwest will work with your organization to provide inspection staff in a timely manner. Our inspectors are familiar with a multitude of jurisdictional scheduling and tracking systems and can quickly adapt to jurisdiction requirements. Emergency inspections (usually requests that pertain to a serious or urgent life/safety issue) can be provided as they are needed; nights, holidays, or weekends.
VIRTUAL INSPECTIONS
Our staff has begun providing Remote Video Inspections (RVI), which allows for the inspection of a building or building systems using already available video technology. RVI is intended to be a complete and thorough inspection that meets the minimum requirements of the California Codes and local ordinances.
Permit Technician/Office Clerk Services
Interwest proposes to continue to provide Permit Technician/Office Clerk Services. Sheri Barkley, ICC, a qualified and experienced individual currently performing these duties will continue in this position. She can perform Permit Technician services such as the Zoning, Inspections, and Permitting. Highlighted responsibilities include, but are not limited to the following:
• Facilitate the permitting process from initial permit intake to final issuance of permit. • Perform data for building and development permitting processes. • Scanning and filing permits.
• Provide front counter customer service, answering questions at the counter or over the phone as needed. • Determine and collect fees, if so desired by the City. • Ensure that submittal documents are complete.
• Work with the City to facilitate Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests. • Provide permit application processing and inspection scheduling and tracking to ensure code compliance • Provide input, tracking and reporting.
Approach to Customer Service
We understand that building department processes and procedures can be confusing and frustrating to property owners, developers, contractors, and others, no matter if it is their first or 100th time building in your community.
For this reason, our staff takes a proactive and personalized approach to our service delivery, whereby we educate each client that engages with your building department.
Exhibit D21
191
16 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
This means each client receives:
• A step-by-step explanation of the process
• Transparent communication
• Identification of timelines and costs
• Checklists and forms needed for approvals
• Advice and consultation to streamline approvals
Our staff’s experience and training, combined with our proven business practices and a core commitment to customer satisfaction, ensure each client receives the highest levels of contract performance, professionalism, and responsiveness in the industry.
Support Staff Services
The Interwest Plan Reviewers are managed by Adrienne Peterson, who delegates work assignments and ensures that all plan reviewers workloads are distributed in the most effective manner. Kathleen Salter and Julie Moss, Administrative Coordinators in our Irvine office provide daily administrative support. They provide assistance with entering data into Bluebeam®, communicating results, and answering questions. Bill Hayes manages our team of Building Inspectors and ensures they are provided with the technology and equipment (ipads, laptops, cell phones) they need to be successful. Training is offered to all positions.
Being a multi-disciplinary firm with a variety of in-house expertise, we can also offer assistance in other areas that may cross-over this scope of work and be required in the future. We offer these additional services:
• Building Department Services
• Public Works & Municipal Engineering
• City Planning & Urban Design
• City Engineering
• Construction Management
• Traffic Engineering & Transportation Planning
• Real Estate & Right-of-Way Acquisition
• Grant Writing & Administration
• Capital Project Delivery
• Private Development Services
Exhibit D22
192
Tab F
Approach to Building Services
Exhibit D23
193
17 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
F. | Approach to Building Services
1. Cover Letter/Letter of Introduction
Interwest Consulting Group, Inc. (Interwest) has carefully reviewed and understnads all elements of the RFP and is pleased to present our proposal in response to your RFP to provide on-call, as-needed Building Services, including Plan Check, Building Inspection Services, Permit Technician Services, CASp Services, and miscellaneous services such as general training, code update and adoption support as needed and/or upon request. Accurate and timely Building Department Services are critical to helping support the City of Murrieta’s (City) development. The City can rely on Interwest to provide you with quality and efficient solutions that deliver consistent customer satisfaction for the most reasonable cost.
Interwest has focused on staff augmentation for municipal clients for over 21 years and has a deep understanding of the challenges and constraints that Cities face. We understand the need to create great customer service experiences for all stakeholders as we represent the City in the execution of our work.
In order to provide your community with quality services, it is essential to choose a company with demonstrated abilities capable of fully managing the Building Department Services you need and when you need them. With a deep bench of more than 400 professionals dedicated to providing municipal services to our clients, our team of well-qualified staff brings the following advantages to the City:
• Team Capacity and Capabilities: Interwest has the largest building services team in California. Few, if any, of our competitors can match our depth of qualified, available staff. Our Irvine office will continue to serve the City on this contract and provide a longstanding team of experts that wll successfully deliver Building Department Services, including plan review services, building inspection, and permit technician services. • Proven Experience: Our long-term experience serving the City of Murrieta and many similar California communities in OrangeOrange and San Bernardino County including the City and County of San Bernardino, Anaheim, Costa Mesa, Lake Forest, Upland, Rancho Cucamonga, Menifee, Temecula, Wildomar and Riverside County. The work we perform in these communities provides Interwest with a thorough working knowledge of the requirements and expectations of the City. Our previous work highlights our technical expertise to perform these services quickly, accurately, and resourcefully. Client satisfaction remains our underlying work performance theme and is the most important part of any statement on past performance. • Your Local Partner: Interwest is your local partner with the capacity and availability to customize services to meet your needs. As industry experts and project leaders, Interwest’s assembled team has a wealth of experience working with municipalities in communities such as your own. Our team commits to delivering the services your community needs in a manner that elected officials, City staff, stakeholders, and citizens desire and deserve.
Interwest’s exceptionally talented and experienced consultant staff is excited about the opportunity to continue to work with the City of Murrieta. Interwest has requested minor modifications to the City of Murrieta Consultant Agreement (See #3 Exceptions). As President of Interwest Consulting Group, I am authorized to sign any agreements that may result from this proposal and will provide contract support to the proposed Interwest team. We appreciate the opportunity to present our qualifications to the City and look forward to serving your community.
Sincerely,
Paul Meschino, President of Interwest
Primary Contact:
Shelby Sieracki
Account Manager
626.224.2055
[email protected]
Project Office:
1 Jenner, Suite 160
Irvine, CA 92618
949.299.5300
Exhibit D24
194
THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
18 Table of Contents
F. | Appro Ach to Building Service S ............................................... 17
1. Cover Letter/Letter of Introduction (1-page) .................................................... 17
2. Table of Contents .............................................................................................. 18
3. Exceptions.......................................................................................................... 19 g. | propo SAl content ................................................................ 21 Section I - Experience (5 pages) ............................................................................ 21 Section II - References (1-2 pages) ........................................................................ 26 Section III - Fee Proposal (Separate Document) ................................................... 27 Section IV - Turnaround Times ............................................................................... 27 Exhibit D25
195
19 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
3. Exceptions
Interwest does not have any exceptions to the RFP , but asks that the City consider minor contract modifications as listed below.
4.4 Independent Contractor. ... In the event that Consultant or any officer, employee, agent, or subcontractor of Consultant providing services under this Agreement claims or is determined by a federal or state agency, a court of competent jurisdiction, or the California Public Employees’ Retirement System, to be classified as other than an independent contractor for City, then except to the extent arising from requirements imposed by City, Consultant shall indemnify, defend, and hold harmless City for the payment of any and all assessed fines, penalties, judgments, employee and/or employer contributions, and any other damages and costs assessed to City as a consequence of, or in any way attributable to, the assertion that Consultant, or any officer, employee, agent, or subcontractor Consultant used to provide services under this Agreement, is/are employees of City.
4.5 Subcontracting or Assignment. ...Therefore, without express written approval of City, Consultant shall not contract with any other City to perform in whole or in part services required hereunder without express written approval of City, which shall not be unreasonably delayed or withheld and neither this Agreement nor any interest herein may be transferred or assigned. ...
5.2 Indemnification. (a) General Obligations. Consultant agrees, to the full extent permitted by law, to indemnify, defend and hold harmless City and its elected and appointed officers, employees and agents (each an “Indemnitee” and collectively, “Indemnitees”) against, and will hold and save them and each of them harmless from, whether actual or threatened, any and all third party actions, either judicial, administrative, arbitration or regulatory claims, damages to persons or property, losses, costs, penalties, obligations, errors, omissions or liabilities (herein “Claims or Liabilities”) that may be asserted or claimed by any person, firm or City to the extent arising out of or in connection with the negligent performance of the work, operations or activities provided herein of Consultant, its officers, employees, agents, subcontractors, or invitees, or any individual or City for which Consultant is legally liable (each an “Indemnitor” and collectively, “Indemnitors”), or to the extent arising from Indemnitors’ reckless or willful misconduct, or to the extent arising from Indemnitors’ negligent performance of or failure to perform any term, provision, covenant or condition of this Agreement, and in connection therewith: 1) Consultant will defend any action or actions filed or threatened in connection with any such Claims or Liabilities, or at option of Indemnitee(s) and selected from Consultant’s insurance carrier’s panel counsel will reimburse and pay for all costs and expenses, including legal costs and attorneys’ fees, incurred by Indemnitee(s) in connection therewith; and, 2) Consultant will promptly pay any judgment rendered against Indemnitee(s) for any such Claims or Liabilities, and will save and hold Indemnitee(s) harmless therefrom. Consultant’s obligations under this Agreement are contingent upon timely receipt of notice of the claim for which indemnification is sought, such that defense of the claim is not prejudiced, and the reasonable assistance of the Indemnitee in connection with the defense of the claim.
(b) Further Provisions. ...The indemnification provisions herein do not apply to claims or liabilities occurring as a result of City’s sole negligence or willful misconduct, but, to the fullest extent permitted by law, shall apply to claims and liabilities resulting in part from City’s sole or active negligence, except that design professionals’ indemnity hereunder shall be limited to third party claims and liabilities arising out of the passive negligence, recklessness or willful misconduct of the design professional. The indemnification provided herein includes Claims or Liabilities to the extent arising from any negligent or wrongful act, error or omission, or reckless or willful misconduct of Indemnitors in the performance of professional services hereunder. Payment of invoices by City is not a condition precedent to enforcement of the indemnity obligation herein. In the event of any dispute between Consultant and City, as to whether liability arises from the sole
negligence or willful misconduct of City, Consultant will be obligated to pay for City’s defense until such time as agreed by parties or a final judgment has been entered adjudicating City as solely or actively negligent or responsible Exhibit D26
196
20 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
for willful misconduct. Consultant will not be entitled in the absence of such a determination to any reimbursement of defense costs including but not limited to attorney’s fees, expert fees and costs of litigation. (c) Pursuant to the full language of California Civil Code §2782, Design Professionals agrees to indemnify, including the cost to defend, City and its officers, officials, employees, and volunteers from and against any and all third party claims, demands, costs, or liability that to the extent arise out of, or pertain to, or relate to the negligence, recklessness, or willful misconduct of Design Professional and its employees or agents in the performance of services under this contract, but this indemnity does not apply to liability for damages to the extent arising from the sole negligence, or active
negligence, or willful acts of the City; and does not apply to any passive negligence of the City unless caused at least in part by the Design Professional. ...
5.3 Professional Liability. When the law establishes a professional standard of care for Consultant’s services, to the fullest extent permitted by law, Consultant shall indemnify, defend and hold harmless Indemnitees against, and will hold and save them and each of them harmless from, whether actual or threatened, any and all third party Claims and Liabilities, consistent with all obligations provided for in this Section 5.3, to the extent same are caused in whole or in part
by any negligent or wrongful act, error or omission, or reckless or willful misconduct of Indemnitors in the performance of professional services under this Agreement.
6.2 Ownership of Documents. All drawings, specifications, maps, designs, photographs, studies, surveys, data, notes, computer files, reports, records, documents and other materials (“documents and materials”) prepared by Consultant, its officers, employees, agents and subcontractors in the performance of this Agreement shall be the property of City and shall be delivered to City upon request of City and/or upon the termination of this Agreement, and Consultant shall have no claim for further employment or additional compensation as a result of the exercise by City of its full rights of ownership, use, reuse, or assignment of the documents and materials hereunder. For the avoidance of doubt, nothing in this Agreement shall be understood to grant City rights to pre-existing intellectual property of Consultant, including Consultant software and licensed software, or to any improvements thereto. ... Moreover, with respect to any Consultant documents and materials that may qualify as “works made for hire” as defined in 17 U.S.C. § 101, such documents and materials are hereby deemed “works made for hire” for City. Consultant shall have no liability arising from the use of any documents and materials for any purpose or on any project other than that for which it was produced.
7.5 Retention of Funds. Consultant hereby authorizes City to deduct from any amount payable to Consultant (whether or not arising out of this Agreement) (i) any amounts the payment of which may be in dispute hereunder or which are necessary to compensate City for any losses, costs, liabilities, or damages suffered by City, and (ii) all amounts for which City may be liable to third parties, by reason of Consultant’s negligent acts or omissions in performing or failing to perform Consultant’s obligation under this Agreement. ...
7. Aviation Liability Insurance: On an “occurrence” basis, including products and completed operations, property damage, bodily injury with limits no less than $1,000,000 per occurrence, and $2,000,000 in the aggregate. This coverage may also be provided by endorsement to a Commercial General Liability policy.
If the Consultant maintains broader coverage and/or higher limits than the minimums shown above, the City requires and shall be entitled to the broader coverage and/or the higher limits maintained by the consultant. Any available insurance proceeds in excess of the specified minimum limits of insurance and coverage shall be available to the City.
Primary Coverage
Except with respect to Workers’ Compensation coverage, for any claims related to this contract, the Consultant’s insurance coverage shall be primary and non-contributory and at least as broad as ISO CG 20 01 04 13 as respects the City, its officers, officials, employees, and volunteers. Any insurance or self-insurance maintained by the City, its officers, officials, employees, or volunteers shall be excess of the Consultant’s insurance and shall not contribute with it. This requirement shall also apply to any Excess or Umbrella liability policies.
Exhibit D27
197
Tab G
Proposal Content
Exhibit D28
198
21 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
G. | Proposal Content
Section I - Experience
Responses To Minimum Qualifications
Interwest is well-qualified and able to deliver the services requested in this RFP , mainly Plan Review, Inspection, and Permit Technician services. We have been providing similar services to Murrieta and neighboring cities in California for over 21 years. Interwest meets all of the requirements of the RFP and has provided verification throughout this proposal.
Interwest currently possesses a City of Murrieta business license and will maintain the license for the duration of the contact, including all renewals. The requested projects similar in scope have been included on pages 29-32 to further illustrate our experience. A table of qualifications and key personnel résumés is provided for the City with the requested education, training, experience, professional registration, certification and licensing of the principal and of staff members who will be involved in the project.
A. AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVES
Interwest offers an exceptional team ready to help the City with your Building & Safety Division services. They have been introduced initially in Section C. Summary on (page 3) and full résumés can be found in Appendix A.
Shelby Sieracki, Proposal Main Contact, Account Manager William “Bill” Hayes, Project Manager
Adrienne Peterson, Irvine Plan Review Manager
Project Office:
1 Jenner, Suite 160, Irvine, CA 92618
B. RELEVANT CALIFORNIA EXPERIENCE
Interwest has been providing building department services in California for over 21 years. We have provided building services to the City of Murrieta since 2013. Additionally, we provide similar services to many of your neighboring cities, such as those listed below.
• Judicial Counsel of California
• California Construction
Authority
• City of Anaheim
• City of Capitola
• City of Chico Hills
• City of Corona
• City of Costa Mesa
• City of Eastvale
• City of El Monte
• City of Fairfield
• City of Inglewood
• City of Lake Elsinore
• City of Lake Forest
• City of Long Beach
• Town of Lodi
• City of Manteca
• City of Murrieta
• Town of Napa
• City of Palmdale
• City of Pomona
• City of Rancho Cordova
• City of Rancho
Cucamonga
• City of Rancho Palos Ver des
• City of Rio Vista
• City of Rocklin
• City of Rosemead
• City of Roseville
• City of Santa Clara
• City of Sonora
• Town of St. Helena
• Town of Tracy
• Town of Turlock
• City of Tustin
• City of Upland
• City of Ver non
• City of Yorba Linda
• Town of Woodland
• County of Fresno
• County of Los Angeles
• County of Napa
• County of Riverside
• County of Yuba
• Town of Atherton
Exhibit D29
199
22 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
C. KEY PERSONNEL QUALIFICATIONS AND EXPERIENCE
Qualifications of Staff
We have carefully selected a team of qualified personnel with decades of experience to deliver the services required. We approach our work with pride and professionalism, getting the job done the right way, day in and day out. An organizational chart showing the proposed staff and their roles follows. Qualifications of personnel have been summarized on the table that follows and full résumés can be found in Appendix A.
STAFF MEMBER & ROLE YEARS OF
EXPERIENCE
LICENSES/CERTIFICATIONS
William “Bill” Hayes, CBO, ICC
State Operations Manager, Building
Department Services
20+ International Code Council #8230972
ICC-Certified Building Official
ICC Residential Plumbing Inspector
ICC Residential Mechanical Inspector
ICC Residential Building Inspector
ICC Commercial Building Inspector
ICC/AACE Property Maintenance and Housing Inspector
ICC Building Inspector
BUILDING PLAN REVIEWERS
Adrienne Peterson, ICC
Irvine Plan Review Manager
25 ICC CA Building Plans Examiner | #5053110
ICC Permit Technician | #5053110
Jim Northcutt, ICC
Building Plan Reviewer
40 ICC Building Plans Examiner | # 879908
ICC Building Inspector | # 879908
Bill Tewfik, PE, CBO, CASp, ICC
Building Plan Reviewer
40 CA Professional Civil Engineer | C50505
Certified Access Specialist | (CASp) 367
ICC Building Inspector | #863979
ICC Building Plans Examiner | #863979
ICC-Certified Building Official | #863979
ICC Building Code Specialist | #863979
Exhibit D30
200
23 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
STAFF MEMBER & ROLE YEARS OF
EXPERIENCE
LICENSES/CERTIFICATIONS
Hossein Afouzeh, PE, MEP
MEP Plan Reviewer
40+ CA Registered Mechanical Engineer, 27117
CA Registered Electrical Engineer, 11588
Mark Seven, EE
MEP Plan Reviewer
17+ Education: BS, Electrical Engineering
ICC-Certified Electrical Plans Examiner; #10275760
Mark Hankinson, CBO, CPE, ICC
Building Plan Reviewer
37 International Code Council #5111273
ICC Accessibility Inspector/Plans Examiner
ICC/AACE Property Maintenance & Housing Inspector
ICC Residential Building Inspector
ICC Commercial Building Inspector
ICC Building Plans Examiner
ICC Building Inspector
ICC Residential Mechanical Inspector
ICC Residential Plumbing Inspector
ICC Commercial Plumbing Inspector
ICC Plumbing Inspector
Ho Jun Kong, PE, CASp, ICC
Building Plan Reviewer
16 CA Registered Civil Engineer | C79527
Certified Access Specialist (CASp-863)
ICC Building Plans Examiner | #8255163
Sal Kaddorah, PE, ICC
Senior Engineer
37 ICC Building Plans Examiner | # 861125
CA Professional Civil Engineer | #43757
NV Professional Civil Engineer | #20795
Martha Diaz, PE, ICC
Building Plan Reviewer
15 CA Registered Civil Engineer | #081154
ICC-Certified Residential Plans Examiner | #8723293
Ali Hijazi
Building Plan Reviewer
7 Education: Bachelor of Science in Electrical Engineering, California State University, Los Angeles
Associate of Science in Physics, Cerritos College
Karla Luther, ICC
Building Plan Reviewer
22 ICC Building Plans Examiner | # 5102152
ICC Fire Plans Examiner | # 5102152
Steve Kim, PE, CASp, ICC
Building Plan Reviewer
11 CA Registered Engineer | #C88484
Certified Access Specialist (CASp) | CASp-982
Building Plans Examiner, B3 Certificate # 8887591
STRUCTURAL ENGINEERS
Hossein Sanikhatam, SE
Plan Reviewer
25 CA Registered Structural Engineer S5514
CA Registered Civil Engineer C67573
MS & BS Civil Engineering San Jose State Univ.,
AISC Member
SEAONC Member
Ali Sadre, MS, PE, SE, CE, CASp, ICC
Plan Reviewer
37 ICC Plans Examiner
ICC Building Inspector
ICC Combination Inspector
Licensed Civil Engineer in AZ, 68573
President of the Structural Engineers Association of CA (SEAOC) in 2020-2021
State Certified Access Specialist (CASp-861)
CA Structural Engineer, S3715
CA Civil Engineer, C42877
Exhibit D31
201
24 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
STAFF MEMBER & ROLE YEARS OF
EXPERIENCE
LICENSES/CERTIFICATIONS
FIRE PLAN REVIEW
Augie Cerdan, FPE
Fire Plan Reviewer
28 CA Registered Fire Protection Engineer
FP1579
BS, Mechanical Engineering
Andrew Hyatt, ICC
Fire Plan Reviewer
20 International Code Council, 8415675
ICC Fire Plans Examiner
ICC Fire Inspector I
ICC Fire Inspection II AS Fire Technology, Cabrillo College, Honorable Mention
Frank Martinez
Fire Plan Reviewer
21 California State Fire Marshal
Fire Prevention Officer
Fire PrAialist
Plans Examiner 3A and 3B
Fire Investigation 1A & 1B
PC 832
BUILDING INSPECTOR SERVICES
Mike Austin, ICC
Building Inspector
25+ Post-Disaster Certified by Governor’s Office of Emerg. Svs.
International Code Council, 1066459
ICC Building Inspector
ICC Combination Dwelling Inspector - Uniform Codes
ICC Plumbing Inspector UPC
Gary Williams, ICC
Building Inspector
31 Reinforced Concrete 47C and 47P
Masonry 84C and 84P
ACI Field Grade
General Contractors License
ICC CA Commercial Plumbing Inspector
ICC Commercial Plumbing Inspector
ICC Commercial Electrical Inspector
ICC Commercial Building Inspector
ICC Commercial Mechanical Inspector
ICC Building Inspector
ICC Residential Building Inspector
ICC Structural Masonry Special Inspector
ICC Reinforced Concrete Special Inspector Associate
ICC Commercial Plumbing Inspector
ICC Commercial Combination Inspector
ICC Residential Plumbing Inspector
ICC Plumbing Inspector
ICC Residential Mechanical Inspector
ICC Mechanical Inspector
ICC Residential Electrical Inspector
ICC Electrical Inspector
ICC Residential Combination Inspector
ICC Combination Inspector
Exhibit D32
202
25 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
STAFF MEMBER & ROLE YEARS OF
EXPERIENCE
LICENSES/CERTIFICATIONS
Guy Bowen, ICC
Building Inspector
40 International Code Council 8256307
ICC CA Commercial Building Inspector
ICC Residential Plumbing Inspector
ICC Residential Mechanical Inspector
LA Department of Building and Safety Deputy Building
Inspector | P033571
CA State Contractors License Classification B #499262
Mark Carlson, ICC
Building Inspector
22+ Disaster Service Worker – State of CA Safety Assessor International Code Council, 5034897
ICC Mechanical Inspector UMC
ICC Plumbing Inspector UPC
ICC Plumbing Inspector
ICC Electrical Inspector
ICC Combination Inspector – Legacy
ICC Mechanical Inspector
ICC Building Inspector
ICC Combination Inspector
ICC Commercial Combination Inspector
SEMS City of Orange and Riverside Fire Department
IS-00700 National Emergency Management;
IS-00200 ICS – Initial Action Incidents
IS-00100 PW – FEMA Incident Command System
Emergency Response to Terrorism
PERMIT TECHNICIAN/OFFICE CLERK SERVICES
Sheri Barkley, ICC
Permit Technician
8 ICC-Certified Permit Technician, 8295728
Basic Life Support, American Heart Association, 2011
D. PERFORMING THE SCOPE OF WORK
Interwest will continue to provide building plan check, inspection, and permit technican services as requested by the City on an on-call, as-needed basis. Such services shall include enforcement of the City’s building laws and codes (such as local amendments) and all applicable State statutes and regulations; review of construction drawings to ensure compliance with City and State adopted laws and codes; oversight of the Building and Safety Division operations; interfacing with permit applicants and City staff; and conducting inspections.
Interwest understands that specific projects may include residential and/or non-residential projects and that any single job may require one or more subsequent reviews of submitted plans. Interwest can perform all of the types of proposed plan checks referenced in the RFP; construction, remodels, additions, green building, disabled access compliance, flood zone construction; enforcement of National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) general permit for stormwater discharges; and public nuisance abatement.
Interwest has been performing plan review services for over 10 years; since 2013. Interwest has the licensed software to work efficiently with the City. Our team are proficient with Bluebeam® and Enterprise Permitting & Licensing (Energov®) and are issued iPads, laptops, and other accessories required for their respective position.
Exhibit D33
203
26 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
Plan Check Services
Interwest will assist and examine building plans for compliance with the adopted version of the California Building Code, California Residential Code, California Green Building Code, California Mechanical Code, California Plumbing Code, California Electrical Code, Title 24, Americans with Disabilities Act, and all other State mandated ordinances and codes, including any local amendments, on an on-call, as-needed basis. In addition to City code requirements, Interwest will review application packages for other applicable requirements such as approvals required from other agencies and districts. Interwest, having performed plan check services for the City since 2013, is fully capable of electronic intake and distribution of plans using Bluebeam REVU® and Bluebeam® sessions for plan reviews. Interwest Plan Examiners are proficient in using Bluebeam® and we maintain our own software licenses. All of our proposed plans examiners are ICC-Certified Plans Examiners, registered Civil Engineers, Structural Engineers, and Architects. Our team is qualified to perform plan check review of all of the design elements listed in the RFP:
Building Inspections
Interwest will provide ICC-Certified Building Inspector(s) to perform all building and safety inspections on an on- call, as-needed basis. Inspectors are fully qualified to perform residential, commercial, and industrial inspections for compliance with approved plans and related documents. The inspections will be performed in accordance with the City’s adopted version of the California Building Code, California Residential Code, California Green Building Code, California Mechanical Code, California Plumbing Code, California Electrical Code, Title 24, and all other State-mandated ordinances and codes as applicable. Interwest’s Building Inspectors are provided vehicles or compensated for utilizing their own vehicles.
Inspectors will review permit packages to verify that onsite conditions are consistent with the appropriate records for square footage, setbacks, heights, and other requirements that may be applicable. Inspections will generally be provided on a same-day or next-day basis. Inspections will include Certificates of Occupancies. Mike Austin, ICC is currently assigned to the City and will remain on the service team.
General Office Support
Interwest will provide on-call, as-needed Building Permit Technician(s) and/or Office Clerk(s) to perform permit technician work and/or general office-related duties. Building Permit Technicians, and/or Office Clerks will be qualified to perform general office duties, process and issue building permits, and process building plans, and related documents. Sheri Barkley, ICC is currently assigned to the City and will remain on the service team.
Additional Services
Interwest will provide CASp Services and miscellaneous general training, code update, and adoption resources and support as needed and/or upon request.
E. PAST PERFORMANCE
As mentiond previously, Interwest has been providing plan reviews to California municipalities for over 21 years and the City for over 10 years. Interwest has a strong track record of providing personalized services to clients, managing tight budgets, and coordinating closely with staff. Interwest utilizes sophisticated project management tools to maintain up-to-date schedules, coordinate staff time, and track the project budget. Interwest will confirm communication protocols at the project kick-off meeting. We hold weekly internal staff meetings to determine project priorities, deliverables, and staffing needs to ensure that our projects are completed within budget. We utilize specific reporting methods for this procedure, such as a custom database to compile all client and project information as it relates to any services we perform. We also develop and maintain a jurisdiction file containing all pertinent client, project and billing information accessible to project managers and assigned staff. Our highly iterative process and coordination ensure that product deliverables and budget management meet and exceed expectations.
Exhibit D34
204
27 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
Section II - References
At Interwest, we believe that client satisfaction and repeat business with these California clients is the ultimate indicator of our success as a firm. We encourage you to contact the references below to provide testimony of our capability to perform your requested services, adhere to schedules and budgets, and exceed expectations on a reoccurring/on-call basis.
City of Murrieta Client Contact: Andy Krogh, City Manager Phone/Email: 951.461.6126 | [email protected]
Dates of Service: 2013 - Ongoing
Services Provided: Plan Review, Inspection, and Permit Technician Services City of Wildomar Client Contact: Dan York, City Manager Phone/Email: 951.677.7751, ext. 209 | [email protected] Dates of Service: 2008 - Ongoing
Services Provided: Plan Review, Inspection and Permit Technician Services City of Temecula Client Contact: Brian Clements, Building Official Phone/Email: 951-506-5176 | [email protected] Dates of Service: 2013 - Ongoing
Services Provided: Building and Safety Services, including Plan Review Services, Inspection, and Permit Technician Services
City of Menifee Client Contact: Craig Carlson, Building Official Phone/Email: 951.723.3729 | [email protected]
Dates of Service: 2016 - Ongoing
Services Provided: Plan Check, Building Inspection, Permit Services City of Lake Elsinore Client Contact: Bill Belvin, Chief Building Official Phone/Email: 951.674.3124, ext, 286 | [email protected] Dates of Service: 2016 - Ongoing
Services Provided: Full Building And Safety Services
Riverside County Client Contact: Joe Feliciano, Agency Program Administrator Phone/Email: 951.955.3896 | [email protected]
Dates of Service: 2015 - Ongoing
Services Provided: Inspection Services
City of Lake Forest Client Contact: Gayle Ackerman, Director, Development Services Phone/Email: 949.461.3460 | [email protected]
Dates of Service: 2009 Ongoing
Services Provided: Full Building Services
Exhibit D35
205
28 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
Section III - Fee Proposal
This section has been submitted as a separate document as required by the City’s RFP .
Section IV - Turnaround Times
We consistently complete 99% of our customers’ plan review times on schedule for both commercial and residential projects as our standard business practice. We work hard to accommodate any turnaround schedule desired by the City. Multidisciplinary reviews are typically performed in our offices, but we are available for onsite work when required, upon the City’s request.
Table 1. Maximum Turnaround Times
MAXIMUM TURNAROUND TIME
Type of Job 1st Review 2nd Review Expedited Review
Residential
New Construction 10 Business Days 5 Business Days 5 Business Days Addition 10 Business Days 5 Business Days 5 Business Days Remodel 10 Business Days 5 Business Days 5 Business Days Non-Residential
New Commercial/Industrial 10 Business Days 5 Business Days 5 Business Days Addition 10 Business Days 5 Business Days 5 Business Days Tenant Improvement/Remodel 10 Business Days 5 Business Days 5 Business Days Large Complex Commercial Projects Turnaround Time Negotiated on a Project-by-Project Basis Interwest is also able to accommodate special project plan review needs, such as, Solar/PV and fast-track or expedited reviews. We establish specific turnaround goals and procedures with jurisdiction staff for these types of projects.
Exhibit D36
206
Tab H
References and Potential
Conflicts of Interest
Exhibit D37
207
29 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
PLAN REVIEW, INSPECTION AND PERMIT TECHNICIAN SERVICES // CITY OF MURRIETA, CA Interwest was selected by the City of Murrieta in 2013 to provide as-needed plan review and inspection services. In addition, Interwest provided a part-time building official to assist in the implementation of the City’s new permitting and inspection software system, code interpretations, and the upcoming code adoption cycle. We currently provide Building Official Services, Building and Safety Plan Review, and Building and Safety Inspection Services. Throughout our contract with the City, we have performed several concurrent tasks/projects and have successfully completed each task/project.
Team Members Involved: All team members listed have worked on various projects for the City.
Client Reference Contact: Andy Krogh, Building Official 951.461.6126 | [email protected]
1 Town Square, Murrieta, CA 92562
Service Dates: 2013 - Ongoing
PLAN CHECK, BUILDING INSPECTION, PERMIT SERVICES // CITY OF MENIFEE, CA Interwest has been providing the City of Menifee as-needed building plan check services since 2016.
The new Menifee Justice Center will replace an existing five courtroom courthouse and provide pace for four new judicial officers Court services in the new building will support family, traffic, and civil case calendars. The new building will include family law mediation, self-help and jury services; very minimal in-custody detention will be provided. This three-story court building, approximately 85,010 building gross square feet will be built in the City of Menifee, Riverside County. The site is within a new “town-center development,” the building will have a cement plaster and glass exterior with on0site surface parking lots.
Team Members Involved: All team members listed have worked on various projects for the City.
Client Reference Contact: Craig Carlson, Building Official 951.723.3729 | [email protected]
29844 Haun Road, Menifee, CA 92586
Service Dates:
2016 - Ongoing
H. | References and Potential Conflicts of Interest
References
At Interwest, we believe that client satisfaction and repeat business with these clients is the ultimate indicator of our success as a firm. We encourage you to contact the references below to provide testimony of our capability to perform your requested services, adhere to schedules and budgets, and exceed expectations on a reoccurring/on-call basis.
Exhibit D38
208
30 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
PLAN CHECK, BUILDING INSPECTION, PERMIT SERVICES // CITY OF TEMECULA Interwest provides the City of Temecula with as-needed building inspection services during peak times of development. Our partnership with the City has expanded to include as-needed building plan review services.
Team Members Involved : All team members listed have worked on various projects for the City.
Client Reference Contact: Brian Clements, Building Official 951-506-5176 | [email protected]
41000 Main Street, Temecula, CA 92590
Service Dates:
2013 - Ongoing
PLAN REVIEW AND INSPECTION SERVICES // CITY OF LAKE ELSINORE, CA Interwest has provided on-call building inspection services to the City of Lake Elsinore since December 2016.
We have provided Building Official, Plan Review, Inspection, and Permit Technician services.
Team Members Involved: All team members listed have worked on various projects for the City.
Client Reference Contact: Bill Belvin, Chief Building Official 951.674.3124, ext, 286 | [email protected]
130 S Main St, Lake Elsinore, CA 92530
Service Dates: 2016 - Ongoing
Prior to incorporation on July 1, 2008, Interwest worked on initiatives to gather essential information and data which served as the basis for confirming service area responsibilities for the City of Wildomar [population 35,400]. We prepared fiscally prudent and conservative operating budgets and identified cost-effective and innovative processes for providing public works, planning and building safety activities and services transitioned from the County of Riverside. Since incorporation of the City of Wildomar, Interwest has provided the following services:
Client Reference Contact: Dan York, City Manager
951.677.7751, ext. 209 | [email protected]
23873 Clinton Keith Road, Suite 110, Wildomar, CA 92595 Service Dates:
2008 - Ongoing
PLAN REVIEW, INSPECTION & PERMIT TECHNICIAN SERVICES // CITY OF WILDOMAR, CA • City Engineering
• Development Engineering and Entitlements
Transportation Planning
• Public Works Inspection
• Traffic Engineering
• Code Enforcement
• Drainage Engineering
• Building Department Administration
• Building and Safety Code Compliance
• Building Plan Review and Inspections
Exhibit D39
209
31 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
PLAN REVIEW AND INSPECTION SERVICES // CITY OF COSTA MESA, CA Interwest has assisted the City of Costa Mesa since 2007. Our staff provides thorough and timely plan review and building inspection services Interwest continues to perform a variety of inspections on the City’s expansive South Coast Plaza Shopping Mall. The majority of these projects have been single-story tenant improvements for individual stores at a time, working quickly and thoroughly so as to minimize inconvenience to both business- owners and the public. One of our most recent tenant improvement projects was performed for the mall’s Chanel boutique.
Orange County Museum of Modern Arts - This project is a 2-story mixed-use museum that totals 52,000 square feet with 25,000 square feet dedicated to exhibitions. There is 10,000 square feet of multipurpose, education and performance space and 10,000 square feet of additional space for exhibitions in a possible expansion and the rooftop terrace can accommodate up to 1,000 people. Interwest is providing complete plan review services for this project on behalf of the City of Costa Mesa.
Team Members Involved: All team members listed have worked on various projects for the City.
Client Reference Contact: Charles Chamoun, Chief Plans Examiner 714.754.5614 | [email protected]
77 Fair Drive, Costa Mesa, CA 92626
Service Dates: 2007 - Ongoing
In 2022, Interwest partnered with Rancho Cucamonga in the current review of the new Harvest at Terra Vista Apartments. This building is approximately 300,000 square feet, including a pool house, club house, and parking structure.
Team Members Involved: All team members listed have worked on various projects for the City.
Client Reference Contact: Zach Neighbors, Chief Building Official 909.774.4214 | [email protected]
1 Civic Center Plz, Irvine, CA 92606
Service Dates: 2016 - Ongoing
PLAN REVIEW AND INSPECTION SERVICES // CITY OF RANCHO CUCAMONGA, CA
PLAN REVIEW AND INSPECTION SERVICES // RIVERSIDE COUNTY, CA Since 2015, Interwest has successfully provided the County with a high level of accurate and timely on-call plan review services, as-needed building inspectors and permit technicians.
Client Reference Contact: Joe Feliciano, Agency Program Administrator 951.955.3896 | [email protected]
4080 Lemon Street, Riverside, CA 92501
Service Dates: 2015 - Ongoing
Exhibit D40
210
32 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
FULL BUILDING AND SAFETY SERVICES // LAKE FOREST, CA
In April 2009, Interwest began providing turn-key building safety services to the City of Lake Forest [population 83,000].
Recognizing the value and cost benefits attributable to employing a contract services model, the City has contracted for building safety services since its incorporation in 1991.
Interwest provides a team of onsite professionals that provide all building safety services—blending seamlessly with existing city staff. We provide a full-time building official, building plan reviewers, building inspectors, and a building permit counter technician.
During our tenure, Interwest staff has developed the City’s first single, combination building permit, which allowed for the same permit number to address all of a structure’s elements (electrical, mechanical, plumbing, and structural) requiring approval, greatly reducing hours and paperwork. We also introduced several key documents that have allowed staff to efficiently communicate, including a workflow tracking sheet to document approvals, a standardized monthly report using the City’s EnerGov software, and several of the City’s Building Safety handouts, reflecting current codes and standards.
Civic Center Campus: In April 2018, Interwest began providing complete turnkey Building and Safety services to the City of Lake Forest, particularly the Civic Center Campus. This 12.5-acre facility is the heart and social center of the Lake Forest community. The Civic Center Campus is comprised of the City Hall Building, Community Center, Council Chambers, Senior Center, and Parking Structure. The estimated cost of construction was approximately $60 million.
Although there was no formal RFP process, Interwest was selected to provide all plan check and inspection services. Our team at Interwest consisted of on-site professionals who delivered complete plan checks, engineering services, inspections, and electrical services. Fred Marzara, who serves as CBO for Lake Forest, was directly involved in the plan review of the parking structure and four other buildings.
One challenge our team faced during implementation was ensuring the secure placement of the building’s solar panels. Upon inspection, it was discovered that high winds caused the solar panels to continuously be pulled upward and out of place. Our Interwest team quickly reviewed the issue with the building’s architectural designers and after collaborating, found a solution of adding extra pinpoint connectors in addition to the four pinpoints the solar panels already had, securing them in place on all sides. The City of Lake Forest was awarded CALBO’s 2018-2019 Building Department of the Year Award, setting itself apart with excellent and responsive customer service. The City of Lake Forest Building Department has serviced over 9,000 walk-in customers, has performed over 24,000 inspections, and has issued almost 3,000 permits.
Client Reference Contact: Gayle Ackerman, Director, Development Services 949.461.3460 | [email protected]
100 Civic Center Dr. Lake Forest, CA 92630
Service Dates: 2009 - Ongoing
Exhibit D41
211
33 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
Admin Office of the Courts
Judicial Council (JCC)
City of Alhambra, CA
County of Alpine, CA
City of American Canyon, CA
City of Anaheim, CA
City of Angels Camp, CA
City of Antioch, CA
Town of Apple Valley, CA
City of Arcata, CA
City of Atascadero, CA
Town of Atherton, CA
City of Atwater, CA
City of Auburn, CA
City of Avalon, CA
City of Bakersfield, CA
City of Barstow, CA
City of Beaumont, CA
City of Benicia, CA
City of Big Bear Lake, CA
City of Brea, CA
City of Brentwood, CA
City of Buena Park, CA
County of Butte, CA
Cabazon Band of Mission Indians
City of Calexico, CA
City of Campbell, CA
Campo Kumeyaay Nation (Campo
Band of Mission Indians)
City of Canyon Lake, CA
City of Carlsbad, CA
City of Cathedral City, CA
City of Ceres, CA
City of Ceres, CA
City of Chico, CA
City of Chino Hills, CA
City of Chula Vista, CA
City of Claremont, CA
City of Coachella, CA
City of Compton, CA
City of Corcoran, CA
City of Corona, CA
City of Coronado, CA
City of Costa Mesa, CA
City of Covina, CA
City of Culver City, CA
City of Danville, CA
County of Del Norte, CA
City of Delano, CA
City of Desert Hot Springs, CA
City of Dinuba, CA
City of Dixon, CA
City of Downey, CA
City of Dublin, CA
City of Eastvale, CA
City of El Cajon, CA
City of El Cerrito, CA
City of El Monte, CA
City of Elk Grove, CA
City of Encinitas, CA
City of Escondido, CA
City of Fairfield, CA
City of Folsom, CA
City of Fontana, CA
City of Fountain Valley, CA
City of Fremont, CA
City of Fresno, CA
City of Galt, CA
City of Garden Grove, CA
City of Grand Terrace, CA
City of Half Moon Bay, CA
City of Hanford, CA
City of Hawthorne, CA
City of Healdsburg, CA
City of Hemet, CA
City of Hermosa Beach, CA
City of Huntington Beach, CA
City of Imperial Beach, CA
City of Imperial, CA
City of Indian Wells, CA
City of Indio, CA
City of Inglewood, CA
City of Irvine, CA
City of Irvine, CA
City of Irwindale, CA
City of Isleton, CA
City of Kingsburg, CA
La Jolla Band of Luiseño Indians
City of La Mesa, CA
City of La Quinta, CA
City of Laguna Beach, CA
City of Lake Elsinore, CA
City of Lake Forest, CA
City of Lancaster, CA
City of Lathrop, CA
City of Lawndale, CA
City of Lemon Grove, CA
City of Lemoore, CA
City of Lincoln, CA
City of Livermore, CA
City of Lodi, CA
City of Long Beach, CA
Los Angeles County
Development Authority
City of Los Angeles, CA
County of Los Angeles, CA
County of Los Angeles, CA
City of Los Gatos, CA
Potential Conflicts of Interest
Interwest currently provides Building Services to the California public clients in the list below. There are no foreseen potential conflicts of interest. Interwest only serves public agency clients. This exclusive commitment to public agency clients is crucial to avoid any real or perceived conflict of interest.
Current Building Services Public Clients
Interwest currently provides Building Services to the California public clients listed below. Our team of professionals proposed for this assignment has extensive career expertise in their respective industries. Our local knowledge in combination with our depth of experience translates into better, more consistent decision- making.
Exhibit D42
212
34 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
County of Madera, CA
County of Madera, CA
Town of Mammoth Lakes, CA
Marine Corps Base Camp
Pendleton
County of Mariposa, CA
City of Maywood, CA
Mechoopda Indian Rive of Chico
Rancheria
County of Mendocino, CA
City of Menifee, CA
City of Menlo Park, CA
City of Merced, CA
City of Milpitas, CA
City of Modesto, CA
City of Monterey Park, CA
City of Moorpark, CA
City of Moorpark, CA
City of Moreno Valley, CA
Morongo Band of Mission
Indians
Mountain House Community
Services District
City of Murrieta, CA
City of Napa, CA
City of National City, CA
City of Newport Beach, CA
City of Oakland, CA
City of Oceanside, CA
City of Ontario, CA
Orange County Council of
Governments (OC COG)
County of Orange, CA
City of Orinda, CA
City of Oroville, CA
City of Oxnard, CA
City of Palm Desert, CA
City of Palm Springs, CA
City of Palmdale, CA
City of Palo Alto, CA
Town of Paradise, CA
City of Pasadena, CA
City of Paso de Robles, CA
Pechanga Tribal Council-Luiseno
Indians
City of Perris, CA
City of Pico Rivera, CA
City of Pismo Beach, CA
County of Placer, CA
County of Plumas, CA
City of Pomona, CA
Port of San Diego, CA
Town of Portola Valley, CA
City of Poway, CA
City of Rancho Cordova, CA
City of Rancho Cucamonga, CA
City of Rancho Mirage, CA
City of Rancho Palos Verdes, CA
City of Redondo Beach, CA
City of Redwood City, CA
City of Reedley, CA
City of Richmond, CA
City of Rio Dell, CA
City of Rio Vista, CA
City of Riverbank, CA
Riverside - San Bernardino
County Indian Health, Inc.
County of Riverside, CA
City of Rocklin, CA
City of Roseville, CA
Town of Ross, CA
Sacramento Area Flood Control
Agency
Sacramento Metropolitan Fire
District
Sacramento Municipal Utility
District (SMUD)
City of Sacramento, CA
County of San Benito, CA
City of San Bernardino, CA
City of San Clemente, CA
City of San Diego, CA
County of San Diego, CA
City of San Dimas, CA
City of San Fernando, CA
City of San Jacinto, CA
San Joaquin Council of
Governments (SJCOG)
San Joaquin County Office of
Education
County of San Joaquin, CA
City of San Jose, CA
City of San Juan Capistrano, CA
City of San Leandro, CA
City of San Luis Obispo, CA
City of San Marino, CA
City of San Mateo, CA
City of San Pablo, CA
City of San Ramon, CA
City of Santa Ana, CA
City of Santa Barbara, CA
Santa Clara VTA
City of Santa Clara, CA
City of Santa Clarita, CA
City of Santa Maria, CA
Santa Rosa Rancheria Tachi-
Yokut Tribe
City of Santee, CA
City of Scotts Valley, CA
City of Seal Beach, CA
City of Signal Hill, CA
City of Solana Beach, CA
County of Solano, CA
City of Solvang, CA
City of South Gate, CA
City of South Lake Tahoe, CA
City of South Pasadena, CA
South Placer Fire District
South San Joaquin County Fire
Authority
City of St. Helena, CA
County of Stanislaus, CA
City of Stanton, CA
State of CA - CalRecycle
State of CA-Dept of Gen.
Services-Div of the State
Archit.
City of Stockton, CA
City of Sunnyvale, CA
Sycuan Band of the Kumeyaay
Nation
County of Tehama, CA
City of Temecula, CA
The Tuolumne Band of Me-Wuk
Indians
City of Thousand Oaks, CA
City of Tracy, CA
County of Tulare, CA
City of Tustin, CA
Twenty-Nine Palms Band of
Mission Indians
Exhibit D43
213
35 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
City of Ukiah, CA
City of Upland, CA
City of Vacaville, CA
City of Vallejo, CA
City of Ventura, CA
City of Vernon, CA
City of Victorville, CA
City of Visalia, CA
City of Walnut Creek, CA
City of West Hollywood, CA
City of West Sacramento, CA
City of Westminster, CA
City of Wildomar, CA
Wilton Rancheria Tribal Nation -
Boyd Gaming (GC)
Town of Windsor, CA
City of Woodland, CA
Yocha Dehe Fire Department
City of Yorba Linda, CA
Ongoing Litigation
Date Filed Case Name Status Comments
12/20/19, 3rd
Amended 5/20/22
Chan v. City of
Atherton
Open IW is not in the case and Mike Kashiwagi &
Mary Grace Houhlihan have been served. Third
amended complaint has been filed. The judge
seemed skeptical of much of the complaint. We
have spoken with plaintiff’s counsel and, given
the situation, he has agreed to let us put off
filing an answer. Most recently, plaintiff’s current
counsel has filed to withdraw from the action.
Chan depo demonstrated that the business was
failing prior to the road closure.
8/5/2021 Evans v. San Jacinto
(Tri-Lake)
Open Answer filed. It appears we did some traffic
work on this roadway. Our expert believes that
the roadway was safe and records indicate only
one head-on collision in 10 years. The City has
tendered its defense to us and we are waiting
for the carrier to respond. Plaintiff has added
the decedant’s children. We have retained an
accident recreation exert. We are attempting to
schedule mediation for 11/8/23. Trial has been
continued to 8/5/24.
Amended complain to
be filed 6/22
SAFEbuilt v. BPR Open Discovery is ongoing.
Notice of Claim 5-9-23 Frontier v. Elk Grove Open City has tendered the claim to IW.
CLOSED
1/31/21 De La Paz (NC&KD
(minors)) v. TriLake,
et.al.
Closed Plaintiff was killed in an auto accident while
turning into a commercial development. The
suit is on behalf of his children. We are not yet
in this action.
Exhibit D44
214
Tab I
Compensation and Reimbursement
Exhibit D45
215
36 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
I. | Compensation and Reimbursement
Interwest currently provides plan check services to the City on a percentage of fee basis for all reviews through the third review. Additional reviews are charged on an hourly basis according to the fee schedule provided in Section III - Fee Proposal; a separate document as required by the RFP . An hourly rate schedule has been included in the Fee Proposal. Mileage will be charged at the current federal per diem rate for travel by Inspectors to reach the job site.
Interwest is a full-service multidisciplinary firm and has many in-house experts that can be utilized when necessary.
Extra Services available to the City have been explained in more detail in the next Section (J. Additional Information) and the associated hourly rates have been provided in the Fee Proposal.
Exhibit D46
216
Tab J
Additional Information
Exhibit D47
217
37 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
J. | Additional Information
In addition to our extensive experience providing Building Department services, Interwest has a wide range of municipal service offerings including Public Works Services, Planning and Urban Design, Grant Writing & Administration, Traffic Engineering, Private Development, Real Estate, and more.
Our services are specifically tailored to fit the needs of our clients. We can proivide the City with:
• Public Works & Municipal Engineering
• City Planning & Urban Design
• City Engineering
• Construction Management
• Traffic Engineering & Transportation Planning
• Real Estate & Right-of-Way Acquisition
• Grant Writing & Administration
• Capital Project Delivery
• Private Development Services
Quality Control/Q uality Assurance
Interwest prides
itself in meeting clients’ needs while maintaining a high level of quality control. Our approach is proactive—we prevent quality issues to the greatest extent possible and prepare for other situations in advance by mitigating risk. To ensure qualit y, Interwest has implemented a Quality Assurance/Quality Control (QA/QC) program where our Project Manager performs random quality evaluations of our staff throughout the yea r.
Interwest’s QA/QC activities include:
• Standardized processes for intake, completion of returned work, email correspondence, review comment letters, and other items to ensure consistency and client satisfaction (e.g.., Logging review data into each municipality’s system).
• Our Project Manager conducts periodic reviews to ensure completeness, accuracy, and consistency of work performed.
• Periodic peer review of plan reviews.
• Staff feedback as necessary for any discrepancies or improvements needed. • Staff are paid to attend both internal and external training to grow professionally and improve skill sets. • The Account Manager conducts periodic check-ins with clients for feedback on satisfaction with work performed and services provided.
• Sending periodic customer satisfaction surveys for feedback on work performed and services provided. • Interwest uses both check-ins and surveys to find possible opportunities to improve client satisfaction, work performed, and services provided, as necessary.
• Given interwest’s comprehensive approach to management and plan review, the probability of risk is low.
As part of our QA/QC process, we ensure that Interwest standards are met. We involve the City in the entire process to maintain transparency.
Exhibit D48
218
Appendix A
Key Personnel Résumés
Exhibit D49
219
39 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
William ‘Bill’ Hayes, CBO, ICC
STATE OPERATIONS MANAGER, BUILDING DEPARTMENT SERVICES
Bill brings 20+ years of building official, plan review and building inspection experience along with 17 years of municipal experience. His progressive and extensive knowledge of the building industry and municipal organization translates to efficient and effective services for our clients. Bill works with clients, Building Officials and Community Development Directors to assure client needs are met and all services provided on behalf of Interwest are delivered professionally, timely and in a customer service manner. Bill also meets with architects, engineers, designers, and homeowners as necessary to coordinate the successful delivery of plan review and inspection services.
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY
State Operations Manager, Building Department Services / Interwest Consulting Group / 2021 - Present
Bill serves clients in the capacity of State Operations Manager and Building Official, coordinating plan review, inspection and department oversight for multiple jurisdictions throughout Southern California.
West Coast Building and Code Group Leader / HR Green / 2019-2021 Coordinated project scheduling, tasks, and budgets to ensure completion within the appropriate time frame. Prepared the scope of services, detailed project, and contracts. Worked with leaders to determine the composition of the project team and assign any duties, schedules, and budget to members. Assisted and delivered proposals to client and managed contracts to determine if amendments are needed, communicated changes to clients and coordinated timely invoices and fees. Identified project opportunities and make decisions under the Practice Leader supervision.
Attended leadership meetings, reported on group performance, strategic planning, and marketing efforts. Provided input into the creation of marketing plans and maintained regular and accurate record of marketing activities with clients. Assisted Human Resources with onboarding new employees, coordinate with IT to ensure office space and equipment are set up properly. Engaged in development-focused discussions with staff to assist in identifying and pursuing activities/projects that aligns with their development objectives.
Building and Operations Manager / City of Industry / 2016-2018 Supervised the daily operations of the Building & Development Services Departments by overseeing the daily operations of the counter customer service, issuing permits, performing plan checks, performing field inspections, gathering data, and executing proposal reports and city projects for the City Manager and City Council. Created training materials and implemented updated procedures for building inspection and counter staff. Evaluated staff responsibilities and productivity to ensure that departments are performing efficiently.
Maintained 24-hours of communications with Los Angeles County Public Works relating to installations and maintenance of sewer laterals, sidewalks, driveway approaches, and public right-of-way. Assigned and monitored work for contractors and consultants, ensuring that the services provided are within the parameters of the City Council’s approved contract. Reviewed all engineer specifications to ensure that they are appropriate for all formal bids under $10,000 and writing specifications and obtaining informal bids for all work under $10,000. Match bids to consultant invoices to ensure that amounts are correct for the work performed.
YEARS OF EXPERIENCE: 20+
YEARS W/ INTERWEST: 2+
REGISTRATIONS/
CERTIFICATIONS
International Code Council,
8230972
Certified Building Official
ICC Residential Plumbing
Inspector
ICC Residential Mechanical
Inspector
ICC Residential Building
Inspector
ICC Commercial Building
Inspector
ICC/AACE Property
Maintenance and Housing
Inspector
ICC Building Inspector
Exhibit D50
220
40 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
William (Bill) Hayes | State Operations Manager, Building Departmnet Services | Page 2 Oversaw an operational budget of over $50 million, the ADA improvements to public owned properties, and the maintenance of over $2 million worth of city vehicles and equipment, as well as city properties by repairing and improving 31 homes and 244 parcels; making sure that they comply with local, state, and federal laws, while maintaining 8,000 acres outside the city limits.
Maintained 24-hours of communications with Los Angeles County Public Works relating to installations and maintenance of sewer laterals, sidewalks, driveway approaches, and public right-of-way. Assigned and monitored work for contractors and consultants, ensuring that the services provided are within the parameters of the City Council’s approved contract. Reviewed all engineer specifications to ensure that they are appropriate for all formal bids under $10,000 and writing specifications and obtaining informal bids for all work under $10,000. Match bids to consultant invoices to ensure that amounts are correct for the work performed.
Oversaw an operational budget of over $50 million, the ADA improvements to public owned properties, and the maintenance of over $2 million worth of city vehicles and equipment, as well as city properties by repairing and improving 31 homes and 244 parcels; making sure that they comply with local, state, and federal laws, while maintaining 8,000 acres outside the city limits.
JAS Pacific / Contract Building Official-City of Pico Rivera / 2015-2016 & 2018-2019 Supervised the daily operations of the building, code enforcement, and housing departments for the City of Pico Rivera.
Tracked customer service, issued permits, performed plan checks and field inspections, gathered data, and fully executed required reports. Created training materials, and trained code enforcement, building inspectors, and counter staffs on updated procedures for building inspections and policies.
Building Official/Acting Public Works Manager / 2013-2015 Established an innovated Rental Housing Program by using a state-of-the-art GIS based inspection technology to efficiently inspect and publicly record blighted and deteriorated properties and was awarded the Helen Putnum Award for Excellence in the Internal Administration category. Created and implemented an Electronic Document Management System (EDMS) internal plan check process of 97% for efficient productivity of staffs and businesses, allowing the city to retain over $600,000 of funds in a 2-year period. Organized and managed the Industrial Waste program and successfully raised the compliance from 80% to nearly 100% from businesses within the city. Established a strong relationship with all departments in the city, therefore becoming a resource and asset to all.
Building Commissioner / City of Palos Heights, Illinois / 2008-2013 Responsible for the City of Palos Heights building departments overall operation and its annual budget of $750,000, as well as coordinated all approved outside vendors and services, and streamlined general office management duties to ensure efficiency of the department’s day-to-day operation. Provided oversight for all disciplines of residential and commercial plan reviews, zoning, enforcement, property maintenance enforcement, and all construction inspections from footing to certificate of occupancy. Inspected various construction projects, ranging from single family homes, commercial buildings, Public Works projects, and new constructions/remodeling for a private college, as well as an eight story, 500,000 plus square feet hospital surgical wing.
Senior/Lead Building Inspector / City of Countryside, Illinois / 2007-2008 End Year Supervised all sign and property maintenance inspections, enforcement programs, as well as inspections for buildings, electrical, and mechanical on residential and commercial projects, as well as zooning plan reviews and enforcement.
Coordinated as the department liaison for the local adjunction court by advising the Building Commissioner regarding building codes and city ordinance updates to stay in compliance with all Federal, State, and local laws. Lead the project in developing an electronic plan review/permit submittal program and an extensive electronic filing system for all permit and property files.
Exhibit D51
221
41 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
Adrienne Peterson, ICC
Irvine Plan Review Manager
Adrienne is an ICC-Certified California Building Plans Examiner and Permit Technician with more than 20 years of direct municipal Building Safety Department experience. For much of her career, Adrienne worked as a permit technician, serving cities and the general public at the counter. This experience has given her insight into the importance of exemplary customer service and strict adherence to turnaround deadlines. With years of experience reviewing plans for compliance at the counter, Adrienne went on to become a certified plans examiner reviewing residential and commercial plans for the City of Yorba Linda, and now for our various clients throughout Southern California.
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY
Building Plans Examiner / Interwest Consulting Group / 2018 - Present Adrienne performs comprehensive plan review services for residential and non-residential plans for compliance with California Building, Plumbing, Mechanical, Electrical Codes, state and local building codes, policies, amendments, and ordinances.
Permit Technician / City of Yorba Linda / 2011 - 2018
Adrienne provided lead and direct supervision to front counter Permit Technicians. She worked directly on the implementation and maintenance of the City’s Accela Automation 8.0 permit software and customized policies and procedures for plans submittals and permit issuance accordingly. Adrienne reviewed residential and commercial plans for submittal and plan check accuracy. She also issued all construction permits for commercial and residential projects and provided ADHOC reporting for outside agencies and internal requests.
Building Permit Technician / Consultant / 2009 - 2011
With a third-party consultant, Adrienne provided contract Building Permit Technician services to the City of Yorba Linda and the City of Upland.
Senior Permit Technician / City of Ontario / 2005 - 2009 In this position, Adrienne provided lead and direct supervision to the City’s front counter Permit Technicians. She reported all construction activity to outside state and county agencies and issued all construction permits for commercial and residential projects. Adrienne also reviewed residential construction plans for code compliance and permit issuance and provided technology support for the City’s Acella Permit Plus permit software.
Building Permit Technician / City of Claremont / 1998 - 2005 Adrienne provided building counter customer service and support. She reviewed all construction documentation for submittal and issued all construction permits for the City. Adrienne reported all construction activities to outside agencies and provided lead direction for the implementation of computerized permit software (HdL).
YEARS OF EXPERIENCE: 25
YEARS W/ INTERWEST: 5
EDUCATION
Received Diploma in
Computerized Accounting,
M.T.I. College, 1995
REGISTRATIONS/
CERTIFICATIONS:
International Code Council,
5053110
ICC Permit Technician
ICC CA Building Plans
Examiner
Exhibit D52
222
42 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
YEARS OF EXPERIENCE: 40
YEARS WITH INTERWEST: 8
EDUCATION:
AA, Civil Engineering,
Saddleback Community
College, 1981
REGISTRATIONS/
CERTIFICATIONS
International Code Council,
879908
ICC Building Plans Examiner
ICC Building Inspector
Jim Northcutt, ICC
ICC BUILDING PLANS EXAMINER // ICC BUILDING INSPECTOR
With 40 years of experience, Jim has an extensive record of successfully reviewing all phases of highly-complex construction projects. Jim has served various positions with the City of Irvine throughout his career. Accomplished in all duties, including plan review and approval, regulatory compliance, code interpretation, code enforcement, and project acceptance.
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
Plans Examiner / Interwest Consulting Group / 2015 - Present Jim provides plans examination reviews for various Central Valley and Southern California jurisdictions.
Plans Examiner / City of Irvine, CA / 1994 - 2014
Jim provided information to architects, engineers, contractors, homeowners and developers regarding Building Codes, Local Codes and State Codes including Title 24 handicap and energy requirements. He plan checked and approved room additions, patio covers, solar installations, spa installations, and all tenant improvements plans including high rises in compliance with City building codes and standard plans, State Codes, and California Building Codes.
Street Lighting Specialist / City of Irvine, CA / 1988 - 1994 Jim supervised and maintained the City’s street lighting and landscape maintenance districts; develop and administer the districts budgets; Updates annual assessment land use codes and parcel information; prepare and present engineer’s reports and related staff reports to City Council and Finance Commission.
Plan Check Technician / City of Irvine, CA / 1986 - 1988 Jim provided plan check and approval statuses to room additions, spa installations, and patio covers in compliance with City Building Codes, State Codes and Uniform Building Codes.
Engineering Technician / City of Irvine, CA / 1985 - 1986 Jim performed routine review of tract maps, parcel maps, grading plans, landscape plans; check improvements plans for general conformance with City Standards. He assisted in the development and review of design policies and standards.
Engineering Aide III / County of Orange, CA / 1981 – 1985 Jim was a draft man for grading, bike trails, street improvement plans, storm drains, and other County projects using Intergraph CAD system; design, draft and write construction specifications for minor County funded projects.
Exhibit D53
223
43 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
YEARS OF EXPERIENCE: 40
YEARS WITH INTERWEST: 7
EDUCATION:
BS, Civil Engineering,
Alexandria University, Egypt,
1979
LICENSES /
CERTIFICATIONS:
CA Professional Civil Engineer |
C50505
Certified Access Specialist |
(CASp) 367
ICC Building Inspector |
#863979
ICC Building Plans Examiner |
#863979
ICC Certified Building Official |
#863979
ICC Building Code Specialist |
#863979
Bill Tewfik, PE, CASp, CBO
CA REGISTERED PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER // CERTIFIED ACCESS
SPECIALIST // CERTIFIED BUILDING OFFICIAL
Bill is a registered engineer and CASp professional with more than 40 years of industry experience, including 23 years serving the City of Garden Grove’s Building Division.
Bill has extensive experience serving municipalities and providing engineering plan review services.
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY
Plan Check Engineer | Certified Access Specialist / Interwest Consulting Group / 2016 - Present
Bill performs architectural and structural review of commercial, industrial, and residential buildings for compliance with State regulations and City ordinances pertaining to model codes, interacting with engineers, architects, contractors, developers, and property owners to provide interpretation and assistance on building code related issues and assisting counter personnel with permit issuance.
Building Official / City of Garden Grove / 2012 - 2016
Bill was responsible for the planning and managing of the daily operations of the City’s Building Division, including the plan check section, permit counter and inspection activities. Bill also provided technical support to various City Departments regarding building related issues. He performed a variety of complex technical work to ensure compliance with applicable codes, and educated employees on different code topics.
Plan Check Engineer / City of Garden Grove / 1993 - 2012 In this role, Bill performed architectural and structural review of commercial, industrial, and residential buildings for compliance with State regulations and City ordinances pertaining to model codes, interacting with engineers, architects, contractors, developers, and property owners to provide interpretation and assistance on building code related issues and assisting counter personnel with permit issuance.
Contract Engineer / Freelance / 1991 - 1993
During this time, Bill prepared plans and performed structural engineering consulting services for private clients.
Project Engineer / McLean and Schultz / 1990 - 1991
In the role of Project Engineer, Bill participated in various office projects including the design of steel structures and reinforced concrete foundations for industrial facilities. Other duties included checking the stability of existing structures to meet the minimum seismic force requirement and structural design work for renovating existing structures (wood, masonry, concrete) to accommodate the revised architectural design.
Project Engineer / Battaglia Associates / 1987 – 1990
Bill’s responsibilities included the design of steel and reinforced concrete structures for the ”Lotte World” indoor and outdoor theme park in South Korea. He also reviewed engineering consultant plans to ensure compliance with the architectural design intent and coordinated with contractors in the
in the field, solving problems
that arise during the construction phase.
Exhibit D54
224
44 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
YEARS OF EXPERIENCE: 40+
YEARS WITH INTERWEST: 8
EDUCATION:
MS, Engineering Science
and Management, California
Polytechnic State University
Pomona, 1981
BS, Electrical Engineering,
Tehran Poly Technique/ Amir
Kabir University, 1971
REGISTRATIONS /
CERTIFICATIONS:
CA Registered Mechanical
Engineer | 27117
CA Registered Electrical
Engineer | 11588
Hossein Afrouzeh, ME, EE
PLAN REVIEW ENGINEER
Hossein is a licensed electrical and mechanical engineer with a rich background in the industry, including over 10 years of construction experience and over 40 years of design, construction management support experience, and plan review engineering.
He is a well-rounded project leader with strong interpersonal and communication skills with ability to lead a design team of Electrical, Mechanical, and Plumbing engineers to adhere to the client and code requirements. He is familiar with the preparation of contract documents for mid-rise multi-residential, commercial, industrial, and educational buildings, and he has been responsible for the electrical system design for many projects from inception to completion including construction administration and commissioning of medium voltage power distribution systems, substations, lighting and power, fire alarm, and security systems.
Hossein is organized and proactive, ensuring that projects are always moving forward.
He is able to multitask and manage several projects at varying levels of development, and has the intuitive problem solving skills to identify project issues and bring them to resolution quickly and effectively. Hossein has the interpersonal and communication skills to keep the client and design community apprised of a project’s status, and he is able to work in a complex technical environment, understanding and interpreting the impact of changes. His wealth of experience and breadth of expertise make him a true asset to any City.
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
Senior Mechanical, Electrical and Plumbing Plan Review Engineer / Interwest Consulting Group / 2015 - Present
Plan reviewing for Mechanical, Electrical, Plumbing, and Energy Engineering for some of the state of California cities such as Long Beach, Pomona, Tustin, Corona, Rossville, Lake Forest, Monterey Park, Irvine, Fresno, county of Napa, and city of Sanger.
Projects include midrise Residential and Hotels with subterrain parking garages, manufacturing facilities, wineries, industrial facilities including hazardous areas, shopping centers, private medical facilities, private schools, Port of Long Beach Pier and Terminal facilities including medium voltage distribution system, pump station projects and administration buildings, midrise office buildings, oil and gas facilities, regular shell and TI for various facilities, restaurant and fast food entities, retails and grocery stores.
Lead Senior Electrical Peer Review Engineer / FTRNV. International | SBG Jeddah / 2013 - 2015
In this position, Hossein was in charge of reviewing and commenting on documents and specifications prepared by design consultants, as well as final construction documents and shop drawings prepared by contractors. He provided technical comments for implementation within the package before submitting them for construction. He was additionally responsible for the review and verification of electrical loads of manufacturer material submittals for HVAC and plumbing systems; review of medium and low voltage distribution systems single line diagrams for normal and emergency networks; review and verification of medium voltage switching stations, substations, and transformer rooms for physical layout and code compliance; review of project cable tray systems for low and medium voltage distributions; review of overall lighting and power distribution systems; prepared technical report for project surge protection device and lighting requirements to implement; prepared method statement for construction procedures and sequence of events for medium voltage switchgears and transformers for site construction crew to follow; preparation of systems voltage drop, short circuit and coordination system with Schneider Eco dial and ETAP software; review of overall system for constructability and provided with required refinements; periodic construction site visits for genera; QAQC and coordination.
Exhibit D55
225
45 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
Hossein Afrouzeh, ME, EE | Page 2
Principal and Director of Operations / Procedure Engineers, Inc. / 1987 - 2013 He was responsible for the preparation of proposals for MEP engineering fee per architectural design development package and required scope of work; preparation of contract and negotiation with client; attending kick-off meeting with client and project team to refine scope of work and overall project time line; review required electrical system design and set up procedure and general guide line for assigned engineer to follow; review and plan check of prepared electrical drawings for code compliance, project requirements and specification; quality control and quality assurance of all MEP drawings or general conformity and coordination with all disciplines; attending progress meetings with client and other project team for coordination and scheduling; supervising of preparation of final project construction documents and bid package and helping client during bid; periodic site meeting for conformity of construction with contract documents; preparation of in-house procedure and guide lines for QC and QA; general over view of company personnel requirements including hiring and lay-offs; projects cost control and monitoring based on man-hour used on a bi-weekly basis; project scheduling, project management and day-to-day operation of team of engineers and designers; preparation computer software for basic electrical calculations.
Electrical Department Manager / Malcom Lewis Associates / 1984 - 1987 In this position, he was responsible for providing man-hour estimates for electrical system design for all potential projects; attending project start-up meeting; preparation of design guide and general design development sketches for electrical designer to proceed with design; day to day supervising of electrical design team and coordinating design progress with other disciplines; attending client progress meeting and coordination with other design team; plan check electrical design package for code conformity and against other disciplines drawings for electrical requirements; prepare and update department design guide lines and procedures; review design drawings and construction documents for construction codes compliance and governmental regulations; project scheduling and project management.
Electrical Engineer and Department Deputy / Elliot Group / 1981 - 1987 For this architectural and engineering company, Hossein was in charge of the preparation of preliminary, conceptual, design development and working drawings for mostly commercial and industrial buildings. He also reviewed and commented on electrical designer’s drawings for code conformity and scope of work. He was the electrical project manager for governmental projects and performed site investigation for existing electrical system for new renovations. He met with clients to discuss project progress in different design stages for their review comments and preparation of required answers. He also assisted the Department Manager with day to day issues and providing with required solutions, and trained electrical designers with new code requirements and electrical calculations.
Technical Director and Construction Site Liaison / Modern Osloob / 1973 – 1979 While he was with this construction company, he was responsible for the review of MEP construction documents for major equipment for project construction cost estimates; the preparation of bid submittal for presenting to board of directors for approval and submit to government agencies; attending Bid opening meetings and processes; attending to contract award ceremony for getting to know all construction team players and client representative; the preparation of equipment and material submittals and submit to consultant for approval; ordering approved equipment with opening letter of credit with manufacturers which were mostly Europe and USA; the approval of requested purchase order from construction site per drawings and spec and material tracking; attending weekly construction progress meeting with all team players and client; construction site visit and verification of work in progress per design drawings and spec; preparation of monthly pay request per work done and review with client representative for approval; the preparation of required RFI’s and process through proper channels and follow up for final direction; the preparation of punch list for closing of the project and check for required corrections; finalizing of the project and hand over to user groups of client.
Exhibit D56
226
46 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
YEARS OF EXPERIENCE: 17+
EDUCATION:
Bachelor Degree in Electrical
Engineering, Aswan University,
Egypt
LICENSES /
CERTIFICATIONS:
International Code Council,
5102152
ICC Electrical Plans Examiner
Mark Seven, EE, ICC
PLANS EXAMINER
Mark has over 17 years of experience in buildings (commercial and residential), malls, health care, and airports with extensive experience with Electrical, Mechanical, And Plumbing (MEP). He has broad experience in strategic planning, entire project management cycle, defining project constraints, risk assessment, and performance measures. In addition, Mark has an in-depth understanding of project budget management, costs verification techniques, MEP work progress, and developing technical Request For Information (RFI). He managed complex and multi-million dollar construction projects for domestic and international firms.
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
MEP Project Manager / Arco Interiors / 2017 - 2021
Management of all MEP project team members (project engineers, superintendents, and field office coordinator).
Developed and maintained relationships with consultants, subcontractors, suppliers, and inspectors.
Established a positive working relationship with owner’s representatives and clients to ensure alignment with their goals and expectations from initiation to completion of the project.
MEP Project Manager / Kele / 2014 - 2017
Managed / coordinated all activities related to MEP work in the site. Oversaw daily activities of MEP engineers, MEP Superintendents, and subcontractors.
Followed up with Client, Consultant and client representatives for any site instructions.
MEP Project Coordinator / BESIX / 2010 - 2014
Oversaw the overall MEP performance and quality control on the work site which included monitoring the scope of work: Mechanical, Plumbing, Medical, Air, Vac, Gas, Ductwork, Building Controls, Electrical, Fire Alarm, Security, Site Utilities, and Fire Protection.
Managed and led MEP subcontractors and ensured that project specifications and ADDC regulations were followed from contract award through close out. Reviewed drawings and ensured compliance and completeness.
Electrical Site Engineer / Al Shafar United / 2006 - 2010 Managed the implementation and monitoring of on-site electrical work. Estimated, prepared, and assigned project resources such as staffing, materials, consumables, equipment, tools, etc. required for electrical work before execution. Planed and analyzed possible construction methodologies and recommended top options to the Project Manager for approval before execution.
Electrical Engineer / Ministry of Housing As In New Urban Comunities’ Authority / 2005 - 2006
Electrical client engineer for medical center in New Sohag city. Electrical client engineer for playground in New Sohag city. Electrical client engineer for nursery in New Sohag city.
Exhibit D57
227
47 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
YEARS OF EXPERIENCE: 37
YEARS WITH INTERWEST: 3
EDUCATION:
Southwest Leadership
Program in Management and
Organizations, Eller College
of Management, University of
Arizona
BS in Architecture, University of
Minnesota
BS of Environmental Design,
University of Minnesota
LICENSES/CERTIFICATIONS:
International Code Council |
5111273
ICC Accessibility Inspector/
Plans Examiner
ICC/AACE Property
Maintenance & Housing
Inspector
ICC Residential Building
Inspector
ICC Commercial Building
Inspector
ICC Building Plans Examiner
ICC Building Inspector
ICC Residential Mechanical
Inspector
ICC Residential Plumbing
Inspector
ICC Commercial Plumbing
Inspector
ICC Plumbing Inspector
Mark Hankinson, ICC
PLANS EXAMINER
Mark spent 15 years as a Senior Plans Examiner for Pima County, reviewing commercial and residential plans, and ensuring building plan review work is in compliance with State and local building regulations. Mark worked with building inspectors to resolve field-related code issues, provided customer support for zoning and building questions, performed structural calculations for beam loads on residential projects, and reviewed structural calculations submitted.
Mark also had 19 years of experience as an Architect, working on many building types: hospitals, warehouses, banks, tenant improvements, hotels, churches, and residential. He is an effective team member and leader, supervising office staff or supervising individual teams, and has the proven ability to communicate effectively with all other internal and external disciplines.
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
Plans Examiner / Interwest Consulting Group / 2017 – Present Mark provides building plan review services to the cities of El Monte, Rosemead, and Maywood for residential and commercial projects to ensure compliance with all applicable building codes.
Senior Plans Examiner / Pima County, AZ / 2001 – 2017
Mark reviewed plans primarily for zoning and building, plumbing, electrical and mechanical requirements on a five-day review schedule. He also reviewed and issued permits for assisted living homes and group homes, Wastewater Sewer Connections permits, and Building and Zoning permits, in addition to reviewing solar permits. He is familiar with online submittals using Project Doxs and the County’s Adobe system to review all permit submittals that have plans.
Architect / Various / 1982 – 2001
Mark worked at various-sized architectural firms with up to 200 employees. He learned a great deal of knowledge about architectural plans and the process of reviewing plans. Mark ensured plans were complete and complied with the building codes and requirements of various states and jurisdictions.
Exhibit D58
228
48 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
YEARS OF EXPERIENCE: 16
EDUCATION:
Master’s Degree in Civil and
Environmental Engineering
(Structural Engineering),
University of Illinois at Urbana-
Champaign
Bachelor’s Degree in
Architectural Engineering,
Sungkyunkwan University
LICENSES /
CERTIFICATIONS:
Certified Access Specialist
(CASp-863)
Building Plans Examiner
Certificate by International
Code Council (#8255163)
Registered Civil Professional
Engineering License (P .E.) by
California State (C79527)
Registered Fundamentals of
Engineering License (E.I.T.) by
California State (EIT130553)
Ho Jun Kong, P.E., CASp, ICC
STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING ASSOCIATE
Ho Jun is a structural engineering associate who is knowledgeable in architectural, fire / life / safety, accessibility, structural analysis and design codes. He is ICC certified, well-educated, and experienced in many projects pertaining to his career field.
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
Structural Engineering Associate / Structural Engineering Assistant / City of San Diego / 2013 - Present
Review building plans for compliance with building code regulations, ordinances and the Municipal Code for compliance with architectural, fire / life / safety, accessibility, and for structural design provisions.
Review the building plans of buildings and structures (e.g., apartment buildings, commercial buildings, single-family dwellings, duplexes, interior modifications of buildings, and minor structures) with basic to moderate degree of complexities. Provide technical information on the application of regulations to professional architects, engineers, contractors and to other non-professional applicants.
Senior Plans Examiner (Part Time) / Bureau Veritas / 2021 - 2022 Review plans and specifications for commercial, industrial, and residential projects to ensure compliance with city, state, and federal laws and regulations.
Structural Project Engineer / Lee & Lee Structural Engineering Inc. / 2007 - 2013
Attained proficiency of structural analysis and design by participating in over 70 design projects of various types of structures.
PROJECTS
Commercial and Schools
1099 Grand Office in LA- Developed structural modeling and performed seismic analysis and design using ETABS & SAFE, ASCE/SEI 7-05, LABC 2011 & ACI 318-05 (20-story building, total floor area: 175,000 sq.ft.).
Emhurst Hotel in LA- Developed structural modeling for Preliminary seismic analysis and foundation design using ETABS & SAFE, ASCE/SEI 7-05, LABC 2008 & ACI 318-05 (20-story building with six story parking lot, total floor area: 158,000 sq.ft.). La Crescenta Plaza in La Crescenta- Performed lateral analysis and design, Shoring Design, ASCE/SEI 7-05, CBC 2010 & ACI 318-05 (two story commercial with two story subterranean garage, total floor area: 22,800 sq.ft.). Avalon Charter School in LA- Performed Seismic analysis, design and retrofit for 3 story floor remodeling, ASCE/SEI 7-05, CBC 2010 & ACI 318-05 (three story school, total floor area: 20,000 sq.ft.).
Western Plaza in Los Angeles- Performed lateral analysis and design, ASCE/SEI 7-05, CBC 2007 & ACI 318-05 (two story commercial with one story subterranean garage, total floor area: 13,900 sq.ft.).
Ocean Breeze Plaza in Huntington Beach- Performed lateral analysis and design, ASCE/SEI 7-05, CBC 2007 & ACI 318-05 (two story commercial, total floor area:
13,900 sq.ft.)
Apartments and Condos
Brynhurst Apt. in LA- Performed lateral analysis and design using RISA, ASCE/ SEI 7-05 & LABC 2011 (three story apt. with one story parking lot, total floor area:
23,500 sq.ft.).
Exhibit D59
229
49 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
Ho Jun Kong | Structural Engineering Associate | Page 2 Sunset Condo in LA- Developed modeling to Dynamic analysis and seismic design using ETABS, ASCE/SEI 7-05 & LABC 2011 (seven story condo with two story subterranean garages, total floor area: 56,680 sq.ft.). Havard Senior Apt. in LA- Performed lateral analysis and design, ASCE/SEI 7-05 & LABC 2011 (four story apt. with two story subterranean garage, total floor area: 60,000 sq.ft.).• Montana 6unit Apt. in Santa Monica- Performed lateral analysis and design, Shoring design, ASCE/SEI 7-05, CBC 2010 & ACI 318-05 (two story apt. with one story subterranean garage, total floor area: 11,500 sq.ft.)
Garvey Villas in LA- Performed Lateral analysis and design, ASCE/SEI 7-05 & LABC 2011 (four story villas with two story parking lot, total floor area: 51,600 sq.ft.).
19th Street Apt. in Santa Monica- Performed Lateral analysis and design, ASCE/SEI 7-05, CBC 2007 & ACI 318-05 (two story condo with one story subterranean garage, total area: 14,100 sq.ft.).
Residential
Arman Residence in Bel Air- Performed Lateral analysis and design, ASCE/SEI 7-05 & CBC 2010 (two story house with one story subterranean garage, total floor area: 14,200 sq.ft.). Sunset Hillside Residence in Beverly Hills- Performed Lateral analysis and design, ASCE/SEI 7-05 & CBC 2010 (three story hillside house, total floor area: 12,100 sq.ft.).
Khorram Residence in Santa Monica- Performed Lateral analysis and design, ASCE/SEI 7-05 & CBC 2010 (two story house, total floor area: 9,500 sq.ft.).
Infrastructure Project
Pedestrian Bridges Design at Lakewood Golf Club- Bridge design to replace existing rusty bridge to new bridge, developed structural modeling and performed seismic analysis and design using RISA 3D & 2D, ASCE/SEI 7-05 & CBC 2010.
Concrete Retaining Wall and Pile Design for Somera Hillside Residence- Seismic analysis and design using RISA, LABC by Hillside design provision.
Shoring Design for two story subterranean garages using RISA.
Exhibit D60
230
50 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
YEARS OF EXPERIENCE: 30+
YEARS WITH INTERWEST: 6
EDUCATION:
MS, Civil Engineering with
Specialization in Structural
Engineering Design, California
State University, Sacramento,
1988
BS, Civil Engineering, California
State University, Sacramento,
1985
LICENSES /
CERTIFICATIONS:
CA Professional Civil Engineer,
43757
NV Professional Civil Engineer,
20795
International Code Council,
861125
ICC Building Plans Examiner
Sal Kaddorah, PE, ICC
PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER / SENIOR PLAN REVIEW ENGINEER
Sal is a registered engineer with over 30 years of industry and municipal experience, serving major metropolitan governmental agencies throughout Southern California.
He spent 18 years of his career serving the Southern California City of Manhattan Beach, beginning as a Senior Plan Check Engineer and progressing to become the City’s Building Official and filling in as the Director of Community Development as-needed. This has given him a valuable perspective on and respect for working in a municipality at multiple levels. This insight allows him to problem solve and work effectively within this environment to the satisfaction of existing City staff, the development community, and the public. Over his career, Sal has cultivated expertise and a proven track record of providing City clientele with thorough and accurate reviews on a multitude of project scopes and scales. Sal continues to stay current and well-informed about the latest techniques and technologies to ensure client satisfaction and effective communication.
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
Senior Plan Review Engineer / Interwest Consulting Group / 2015-Present Sal serves a variety of clients on a contract basis providing comprehensive plan review services. Sal also, fills in as a building official, as needed.
Building Official / City of Manhattan Beach / 2011-2015 In this position, Sal supervised and managed the Building and Safety Division, including Plan Check, Inspections, Permit Processing and Code Enforcement. He ensured that construction or alteration work was being done according to approved plans and in accordance with the Provisions of Building Codes. Sal also supervised staff and provided training and guidance to perform required job duties and tasks.
He prepared reports and conducted presentations for the City Council, City Manager, City Departments, Boards and Commissions, other Public Agencies, and Private Design and Development Sectors. He also performed complex plan checks for large commercial and residential projects, and worked with the design team to ensure proper code compliance for the final design. On occasion, Sal filled in for the Director of Community Development Department, which involved running the Department operations and managing the Department personnel.
Principal Plan Check Engineer / City of Manhattan Beach / 2000-2011 He oversaw all plan check, and inspection activities within private property of the City. The work included all construction activities, i.e., Commercial, Industrial and Residential buildings within the City limits. Sal was also responsible for building code development and other code interpretation issues. He managed and supervised permit processing staff and plan check Engineers; provided technical training for staff pertaining to construction codes; and provided technical Code interpretations for the design and construction community.
Senior Plan Check Engineer / City of Manhattan Beach / 1997-2000 Sal performed plan checks for commercial and residential projects to ensure full compliance with California State codes and City amendments. He provided the Building Official with all technical engineering and life-safety interpretations and decisions on issues related to architectural, structural, disabled access, and energy standards.
Exhibit D61
231
51 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
Sal Kaddorah | Professional Engineer, Senior Plan Review | Page 2 Associate Plan Check Engineer/ City of Sacramento/ 1990 - 1997 Sal performed commercial, residential, and industrial plan checks for the City, as well as complex construction inspections, including plan checks and inspections of high-rise buildings and large arenas. He provided code training to plan check engineers and inspection staff, as well as members of the design and construction community.
Design Engineer / William Merkel Associates / 1985– 1990 In this role, Sal performed structural design for hospitals, schools, commercial, industrial and residential structures. He was in charge of design and construction projects from the initial design phase to completion, including construction costs, budgeting, and all related construction issues.
Graduate Assistant / California State University, Sacramento / 1985– 1988 Sal assisted a professor in the Engineering and Science Department with engineering lectures. He also tutored graduate engineering students and graded homework assignments, tests, and engineering reports.
Exhibit D62
232
52 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
YEARS OF EXPERIENCE: 15
YEARS W/ INTERWEST: 1
Education
� BS, Civil Engineering,
CSU-Long Beach, California
Registrations/Certifications
� Registered Civil Engineer, CA
# 081154
� International Code Council
8723293
� ICC Certified Residential Plans
Examiner
Martha Diaz, PE, ICC
PLANS EXAMINER
Martha Diaz is a bilingual plans examiner who also has extensive engineering experience. She is fluent in MS Word, Excel, PowerPoint, and BlueBeam Revu.
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY
Plans Examiner / Interwest Consulting Group / 2022- Present Martha performs a full range of residential and commercial (IRC and IBC governed) Plan Reviews. She identifies and addresses areas of plan non-compliance and suggests/recommends procedures and processes to improve operations. Martha is available, responsive, knowledgeable, and cordial to customer and client requests for information and answers code related questions from builders and the general public.
Engineer | City Of Santa Clarita, Building & Safety Division | 2017-2021 Martha reviews structural and architectural plans, calculations, and soils reports for building code compliance for projects ranging from single-family dwellings to commercial tenant improvements. She assists home-owners, contractors, architects, designers, and engineers in completing their construction projects and provides code updates for local building amendments. Martha collaborates with the planning division and helps develop plan review comments for accessory dwelling units.
Forensic Engineer I | Donan Engineering, Inc. | 2015-2016 Martha performs forensic investigations on buildings and structures to determine cause of failure and/or damage. She interviews home-owners as part of the investigation process and discusses projects and reports with clients, engineers, and home-owners. She uses the scientific method and serves as the engineer of record on reports submitted to clients.
Structural Engineering Associate II – Green Building Division | City of Los Angeles, Department of Building & Safety | 2011-2015
Martha reviews architectural plans, commissioning documents, landscape plans and calculations, and testing data for Los Angeles Green Building Code compliance. She also assists in creating documents required for plan review to meet state requirements.
Structural Engineering Associate II – Structural Plan Check Division | City of Los Angeles, Department of Building & Safety | 2007-2011 Martha reviews structural and architectural plans, calculations, and soil reports for building and zoning code compliance for jobs ranging from single-family dwellings to commercial tenant improvements. She refers customers to different agencies to obtain applicable sign-offs, and she issues building permits upon code compliance.
Exhibit D63
233
53 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
YEARS OF EXPERIENCE: 7
YEARS WITH INTERWEST: 3
EDUCATION:
Bachelor of Science in Electrical
Engineering, California State
University, Los Angeles
Associate of Science in Physics,
Cerritos College
Ali Hijazi
ELECTRICAL PLANS EXAMINER
Ali is bilingual in English and Arabic. He was part of the senior design team in the Micro Mouse (IEEE) project and worked on the IR sensors and navigation-programming of the autonomous robot.
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
Electrical Engineer / Interwest / 2020 - Present
Provide electrical plan review as an engineering consultant by applying the California Building Standards Code.
Plan reviews include residential and commercial structures for new construction and tenant improvements.
Retail Seller / Global Games / 2017 - 2020
Purchased video game consoles from retail and wholesale sellers for resale.
Systems Engineer in Training / DTE Energy / 2016 - 2017 Learned about nuclear generation and the various electrical systems associated with it.
Was part of the Integrated Processing Computer System (IPCS): a software that runs on the main computer in the control room and acts as an interface to the operators in the whole plant.
IPCS consists of all the sensors (pressure, flow, temp, distance,etc.) throughout the plant that connects to the data acquisition devices which connect to the main computer.
Exhibit D64
234
54 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
YEARS OF EXPERIENCE: 22
YEARS WITH INTERWEST: 1
EDUCATION:
Doctor of Theology, PCIE
Associates of Applied Science,
West Virginia State College
LICENSES /
CERTIFICATIONS:
International Code Council,
5102152
Fire Plans Examiner
Building Plans Examiner
Karla Luther, ICC
PLANS REVIEWER
Karla completes residential and commercial reviews for several jurisdictions and multiple disciplines.
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
Plans Reviewer / Interwest / 2022 - Present
Work with building inspectors to resolve field-related code issues and coordinate activities with other City departments as directed.
Responsible for preparing written correction letters and maintaining and updating records and database information.
Recommend necessary changes to design documents as required to obtain compliance with applicable codes and regulations.
Senior Plan Checker / City of Victorville / 2006 - 2021 Provided plan review of :residential projects of all types, including tracts. Completed commercial projects, including tenant improvements, tilt-ups, and hotels.
Worked closely with the planning division for review of site and façade City planning requirements for both residential tracts and new commercial building.
Plans Examiner / City of San Bernardino / 2001 - 2006
Produced plan reviews of residential additions and commercial tenant improvements.
Worked the permit counter.
SKILLS
Customer service oriented.
Knowledge of multiple building code disciplines.
Attention to detail.
Ability to minimize construction complications.
Exhibit D65
235
55 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
YEARS OF EXPERIENCE: 11
YEARS W/ INTERWEST: >1
EDUCATION:
Masters of Science Degree in
Civil Engineering (Structural
Emphasis), University of
Southern California
Bachelor of Science Degree
in Civil Engineering, California
State Polytechnic University,
Pomona
LICENSES /
CERTIFICATIONS:
Professional Engineer, P .E.
State of California, License No.
C88484
Certified Access Specialist
(CASp) Certificate No. CASp-
982
Building Plans Examiner, B3
Certificate No. 8887591
Steve Kim, P.E., CASp
SENIOR PLAN CHECK ENGINEER
Steve is a Senior Plan Check Engineer with over a decade of experience in his career field. He holds many licenses and certificates, as well as education, making him well- versed and experienced in his career path.
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
Senior Plan Check Engineer / Interwest Consulting Group / 2023 - Present Reviews commercial and residential structures for compliance to the California Code of Regulations, Title 24.
Provides review for ASMEP , CalGreen and the California Energy Code.
Senior Plan Check Engineer / City of Riverside Building and Safety / 2020 - 2023
Review commercial and residential structures for compliance to the California Code of Regulations, Title 24.
Provide review for ASMEP , CalGreen and the California Energy Code.
Safety Plans Examiner III / County of Riverside Building and Safety / 2019 - 2020
Provided guidance to younger engineers.
Assisted other engineers when complications develop.
Structural Engineer / KPFF Consulting Engineers / 2017 - 2019 Provided structural analysis and designed commercial and institutional buildings. Tasked as primary design engineer and project manager under direct supervision of the principal. These projects included: Yorba Linda Library and Arts Center, Roosevelt Elementary School and major tenant improvements at the Century Plaza Tower.
Project Manager / Gouvis Engineering Consulting Group, Inc. / 2015 - 2017 Provided structural analysis and design of high density apartments, mixed-use, commercial and tract home developments.
Interfaced with architects and engineers of varying disciplines to prepare construction documents and provide continued technical support through the permitting and construction process.
Engineering Technician II / Orange County Public Works, Development Services / 2015
Administered preliminary review of plans, engineering and permit documents at the public counter to qualify submittals for plan check.
Project Manager / Full Stack Developer / Toda World, Inc. / 2012 - 2015 Worked as primary web server system administrator.
Web application development of customer reward mobile application. Web application development of back-end dashboard, and custom integration of micro-services for development of QR coupon generator, email and SMS marketing, gift card and order processing, and more.
Exhibit D66
236
56 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
YEARS OF EXPERIENCE: 25
YEARS W/ INTERWEST: 2
EDUCATION
• MS, Civil Engineering, San Jose
• State University, San Jose, CABS,
• Civil Engineering, San Jose State
University, San Jose, CA
REGISTRATIONS/
CERTIFICATIONS
• CA Registered Structural Engineer,
S5514
• CA Registered Civil Engineer,
C67573
PROFESSIONAL AFFILIATIONS
Member, American Institute of Steel
Construction (AISC)
Member, Structural Engineers
Association of Northern California
(SEAONC)
Hossein Sanikhatam, SE
SENIOR STRUCTURAL ENGINEER
Hossein is a licensed California Structural Engineer and Civil Engineer with Master’s and Bachelor’s degrees in Civil Engineering from San Jose State University. He has nearly 25 years of experience in civil and structural engineering. His extensive experience includes providing structural plan check for residential and commercial buildings, multi-story office buildings, retail shops, malls, parking structures, apartment complexes, underground parking, single family dwellings, and condominiums.
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY
Vice President | Structural Engineer / Kutzman & Associates / 2006- 2020 | Interwest Consulting Group / 2020 - Present
Hossein provides structural plan check of steel, wood and concrete residential and commercial buildings including clinics and medical office buildings, multi-story office buildings, retail shops, malls, parking structures, apartment complexes over underground parking garage including PT slab podium, parking garage structures, single family dwellings and condominiums. The structural systems of his projects include SMF , STMF , OMF , SCBF , OCBF , BRBF , Special Reinforced Concrete Shear Wall, Tilt-Up Walls, Special Reinforced Masonry Shear Wall, and Structural Wood Panel Shear Wall (Wood and Light Gage Steel).
Civil Engineer | Structural Designer / Consulting Firm / 1997 - 2006 Hossein provided design of steel, wood and concrete commercial, school, facility buildings and other structures such as retaining walls, signs, bleachers, flag poles, etc. He also provided plan check (structural, fire/life safety and accessibility) of steel, wood and concrete commercial buildings including multistory office buildings, retail shops, malls, parking structures, apartment complexes over underground parking garage including PT slab podium and parking structures.
Exhibit D67
237
57 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
YEARS OF EXPERIENCE: 37
YEARS WITH INTERWEST: 37
EDUCATION:
BS, CE, MSCE, Georgia Institute
of Technology, Atlanta, GA, 1980
LICENSES / CERTIFICATIONS:
ICC Plans Examiner
ICC Building Inspector
ICC Combination Inspector
Licensed Civil Engineer in AZ,
68573
President of the Structural
Engineers Association of CA
(SEAOC) in 2020-2021
State Certified Access Specialist
(CASp-861)
CA Structural Engineer, S3715
CA Civil Engineer, C42877
ME Civil Engineer, 15622
WA Civil Engineer, 56625
WA DC Structural Engineer,
S9020118
WA DC Civil Engineer, S920878
Ali Sadre, MS, PE, SE, CE, CASp, ICC
STRUCTURAL PLANS EXAMINER
Ali reviews projects for compliance with the IBC and CBC, Title 24 for life-safety and structural design. The projects have included high-rise, multi-residential, commercial, schools, hospitals, hotels, casinos, sports arenas, essential facilities, hazardous occupancies, UC, or CSU projects, Port District, Federal, State, DOD, Navy & Department of Correction projects, tunnels, bridges & lifeline structures. His reviews demand thorough familiarity with structural and seismic provisions of the CBC, SEAOC Blue Book, State Historic & Existing Building Codes, ASCE-41, Tall Building Initiative and other design guidelines and standards for new buildings, as well as seismic strengthening of existing buildings.
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
Interwest / Senior Lead Structural Engineer / 1986-Present Ali reviews and analyzes many projects, including airports, casinos, California State University (CSU) and University of California (UC) campuses, detention facilities, high- rises, metro stations, port district wharves, stadiums, etc.
Government Consultant | Contractor
Ali has served over 165 municipalities and state agencies in the United States.
PROFESSIONAL AFFILIATIONS
Elected as a fellow of the Structural Engineers Association of California (SEAOC) in 2017
Seismic Safety Commissioner, 2007-2011
President of SEAOSD, 2010-2011
SEAOC Board of Directors Member, 2010-2012
City of San Diego Board of Appeals Chairman, 2008 - 2014 OSHPD Seismic Safety Board Member, 2008-2012
Strong Motion Instrumentation Program Member, 2007-2011 Seismology Committee of SEAOC ‘96-’97, Chairman
Seismology Committee of SEAOSD ‘94-’95, Chairman
Steel Sub-committee of SEAOSD ‘92-’94, Chairman
Current, or former Member - ASCE, EERI and SEAOC
ACCOMPLISHMENTS
Authored Commentary in the 1998 SEAOC Blue Book on the Seismic Zone Coefficient and Near Source Factors due for publication in late 1998. Authored Commentary to the 1996 SEAOC Blue Book Provisions on EBF , SCBF and High Strength Reinforcing Steel in Concrete for High Seismic Zones. Authored a periodical called” Seismic Reconnaissance” circulated by SEAOSD 1994 - 1996
Co-authored SAC Advisory # 3 published in 1995.
Exhibit D68
238
58 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
Augie Cerdan, FPE
FIRE PROTECTION ENGINEER
Augie brings over 28 years of experience in construction and fire plan review and inspection, with a proven performance in analysis and regulatory compliance as a Fire Protection Engineer. Augie’s extensive experiences as a Fire Protection Engineer have provided him a skill set to examine and correct construction documents, establish and maintain effective working relationships, determine adherence to code requirements, and provide rapid, uniform, and accurate customer service.
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY
Fire Protection Engineer | Fire Plans Examiner | Fire Inspector / Interwest Consulting Group / 2018 - Present
Augie reviews residential and non-residential plans for compliance with California Building, Plumbing, Mechanical, Energy Standards, Fire Codes and California Green Building Standards; state and local building codes, policies, amendments, and ordinances.
Fire Protection Engineer / City of Folsom / 1999 - 2017 Augie serviced the City of Folsom for 18 years as their Fire Protection Engineer ,his role included; examining and noting deficiencies of plans, calculations, and specifications associated with the review of site and building plans, fire suppression and alarm systems, tentative parcel maps, industrial processes, hazardous materials, and specifications for new buildings and building modifications to ensure compliance with Federal, State and local fire and life safety ordinances, laws and codes. Additional duties included; conducting functional tests and field inspections of construction sites; suppression, detection and alarm systems; means of egress; fire barriers and smoke management systems.
Augie also interpreted, analyzed and made recommendations and provided technical advice to staff, developers, architects, contractors and the public related to codes, ordinances and standards. He played a key role in providing construction permitting services as the Fire Department’s representative for Community Development that resulted in a one-stop permit counter at City Hall. Additionally, he spearheaded the over-the-counter plan checking and permitting services for building permit and fire protection system applications at the public counter of the Community Development Department.
Fire Protection Engineer / City of Sunnyvale / 1990 - 1999 Augie serviced the City of Sunnyvale for nine years as their Fire Protection Engineer his role included; examining and noting deficiencies of plans, calculations, and specifications associated with the review of site and building plans, fire suppression and alarm systems, tentative parcel maps, industrial processes, hazardous materials, and specifications for new buildings and building modifications to ensure compliance with Federal, State and local fire and life safety ordinances, laws and codes. Additional duties included; conducting functional tests and field inspections of construction sites; suppression, detection and alarm systems; means of egress; fire barriers and smoke management systems.
YEARS OF EXPERIENCE: 28
YEARS W/ INTERWEST: 4
EDUCATION:
BS, Mechanical Engineering,
University of California, Davis
REGISTRATIONS/
CERTIFICATIONS:
CA Registered Professional
Fire Protection Engineer |
FP1579
Exhibit D69
239
59 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
YEARS OF EXPERIENCE: 20
YEARS WITH INTERWEST: 1
EDUCATION:
A.S. Degree in Fire Technology,
Cabrillo College, Honorable
Mention
Bachelor’s Degree in
Cardiovascular Science, The
Ohio State University, Dean’s
List
A.A. Degree, The Ohio State
University, Dean’s List
LICENSES /
CERTIFICATIONS:
ICC, 8415675
ICC Fire Plans Examiner
ICC Fire Inspector I
ICC Fire Inspection II
Andrew D. Hyatt, ICC
FIRE PLANS EXAMINER
Andrew is a dedicated, highly self-motivated professional and natural leader with experience in; fi re code, plan review, inspections, and proper handling of hazardous materials. He is qualifi ed with over 20 years of extensive experience in fi re prevention, with specialized knowledge of current fi re safety laws, codes, and ordinances.
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
Fire Plans Examiner / Interwest Consulting Group / 2022 – Present Andrew is responsible for ensuring that all plan reviews and fi eld inspections are completed as committed to the customer, and that documentation is accurately maintained. He is responsible for ensuring that plan reviews and inspections are performed in accordance with the standards, ordinances, codes, and regulations adopted/established by the municipality.
Fire Prevention Specialist II / City of Santa Clara Fire Department / 2009 - 2022
Andrew provided plan reviews and inspections in the following areas: architectural, automatic sprinklers, fi re alarms, water supply, access, alternative automatic fi re extinguishing systems, hazardous materials, and additional areas.
Volunteer / Fire Prevention Division / 2007 - 2009
Andrew assisted with fi re inspections and acceptance testing of fi re extinguishing systems, fi re alarm systems, and additional areas. This included over 180 hours of plan review volunteer time. Andrew also assisted in all aspects of plan review, as well as construction and operational permit inspections.
Associate Consultant / Hazardous Materials Division / 2008 - 2009 Andrew provided consulting for applicants regarding Hazardous Materials Business Plans. He promoted a helpful and friendly relationship between contractors as well as business owners.
Computer Systems Operator / United States Air Force – OH & CA Air National Guard / 2002 - 2008
Andrew specialized in communications, including prioritizing tasks to provide support for air rescue operations. He maintained Top Secret Security Clearance.
Exhibit D70
240
60 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
YEARS OF EXPERIENCE: 21
EDUCATION:
Bachelors of Science in
Management, University of
Redlands
LICENSES /
CERTIFICATIONS:
California State Fire Marshal
ICC Fire Prevention Officer
ICC Fire Protection Specialist
ICC Plans Examiner 3A and 3B
Fire Investigation 1A & 1B
EMT
PC 832
Frank Martinez
FIRE SAFETY SPECIALIST
Frank is a Fire Safety Specialist who is fluent in English and Spanish. He has a host of licenses and certificates and 21 years of experience in his career field.
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
Fire Safety Specialist / Riverside, CA / 2015 – Present Perform advanced-level plan reviews as it relates to fire life safety in new building construction, such as building code review, private fire service mains, fire sprinkler, fire alarm, automatic fire suppression systems, and high pile storage commodity classification reports.
Conduct Planning Case reviews for proposed projects.
Provide guidance and training to multiple fire systems inspectors in both new construction inspections and annual inspections.
Fire Systems Inspector / Riverside County Fire Department / 2015 Conducted general new construction inspections including fire alarm, fire sprinkler, private fire service mains, and other suppression systems. Conducted Title 19 regulated inspections.
Provided inspection support to other inspectors conducting Hazard Mitigation (weed abatement), apartment inspections and new business inspections and general annual inspections.
Fire Inspector II / City of Moreno Valley / 2006 - 2015 Under the direction of the Fire Marshal, Frank developed the department’s R2 annual inspection program for which he served as the lead and field training officer to four Fire Technicians.
Conducted annual inspections to all commercial businesses of all occupancy types including A, E, and I occupancies and issued pertinent 105 permits. Conducted general new construction inspections including fire alarm, fire sprinkler, private fire service mains, and other suppression systems.
Fire Permit Technician / City of Moreno Valley / 2004 - 2006 Provided the customers a point of contact for the Fire Prevention Bureau. Responsible for the submittal and return of plans from and to customers. Maintained an accurate log of any incoming / outgoing plans for multiple projects.
Emergency Medical Technician / American Medical Response / 2002 - 2004 Responded to and supported the Fire Department with medical emergencies. Communicated effectively with agencies / personnel during high stress situations. Rendered basic life support and transported the sick and injured to various region hospital emergency rooms.
Exhibit D71
241
61 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
YEARS OF EXPERIENCE: 25+
YEARS WITH INTERWEST: 6
EDUCATION:
Pacesetter’s Career Institute,
Intensive coursework on
Building Codes
REGISTRATIONS /
CERTIFICATIONS:
Post-Disaster Certified by the
Governor’s Office of Emergency
Services
International Code Council,
1066459
ICC Building Inspector
ICC Combination Dwelling
Inspector - Uniform Codes
ICC Plumbing Inspector UPC
Michael Austin, ICC
BUILDING INSPECTOR
Michael has more than 25 years of experience providing building inspection services in both the private and public sector. He also has over 8 years of experience as a journeyman carpenter in commercial construction. This background gives him a thorough understanding of the construction process which, combined with his several certifications, make him a qualified addition to any team. Michael truly enjoys providing building inspection and sharing his knowledge with others. He likes to work collaboratively with contractors and the design community, and has often been responsible for interfacing with homeowners and the general public, helping them to understand the process of achieving code compliance.
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
Sr. Building Inspector / Interwest Consulting Group / 2016 - Present Michael performs inspections of commercial projects, tenant improvement, tract homes, as well as swimming pools, patio covers and room additions.
Sr. Building Inspector / RKA Consulting Group / 2011 - 2015 Michael inspected commercial projects, tenant improvement, tract homes, as well as swimming pools, patio covers, and room additions. He provided Code Enforcement and performed over-the-counter plan checks on projects such as swimming pools, patio covers, walls, and photovoltaic systems.
Building Inspector II / City of Fontana, CA / 2005 - 2011 Michael inspected commercial projects, tenant improvement, and tract homes.
He also has experience working at the front counter bringing in permits for plan check and issuing permits, and also providing simple over-the-counter plan checks such as swimming pools, patio covers, walls, and photovoltaic systems.
Building Inspector II / City of Temecula, CA / 1999 - 2005 Michael’s duties included inspection of commercial projects, tenant improvement, multi-dwelling units, custom homes, and tract homes, as well as swimming pools, patio covers, and room additions.
Building Inspector II / P&D Consultants / 1996 - 1999
Michael performed inspection of tract homes, multi-family dwellings, swimming pools, patio covers, and room additions for the City of Chino Hills.
Building Inspector / City of North Las Vegas, NV / 1995 - 1996 Michael was independently contracted to the City of North Las Vegas where he provided tract home inspections.
Journeyman Carpenter / E.F. Brady / 1983 - 1991
As a journeyman carpenter, Michael acted as a metal stud framer and drywall hanger, and has experience with composite wall systems, t-bar and lathing.
Exhibit D72
242
62 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
YEARS OF EXPERIENCE: 33
YEARS WITH INTERWEST: 3
LICENSES /
CERTIFICATIONS:
Reinforced Concrete 47C and
47P
Masonry 84C and 84P
ACI Field Grade I
General Contractors License
ICC CA Commercial Plumbing
Inspector
ICC Commercial Plumbing
Inspector
ICC Commercial Electrical
Inspector
ICC Commercial Building
Inspector
ICC Commercial Mechanical
Inspector
ICC Building Inspector
ICC Residential Building
Inspector
ICC Structural Masonry Special
Inspector
ICC Reinforced Concrete
Special Inspector Associate
ICC Commercial Plumbing
Inspector
ICC Commercial Combination
Inspector
ICC Residential Plumbing
Inspector
ICC Plumbing Inspector
ICC Residential Mechanical
Inspector
ICC Mechanical Inspector
ICC Residential Electrical
Inspector
ICC Electrical Inspector
ICC Residential Combination
Inspector
ICC Combination Inspector
Gary Williams, ICC
BUILDING INSPECTOR
Gary is an experienced Building Inspector with more than 31 years of professional experience in commercial and residential building construction, and he has obtained 19 ICC Certifications, ranging from commercial, residential and special inspections.
He has a deep understanding of all relevant codes and industry methods and best practices and has a proven ability to work independently or as part of a team.
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
Building Inspector / Interwest Consulting / 2020 - Present Gary provides building inspection services to our clients throughout Southern California, ensuring compliance with all applicable local and state codes. He has industry knowledge and the ability to adapt and learn in each project he works on.
Gary is very attentive and detail oriented.
Contractor / Weatherbee Construction / 2018 - 2020
Gary handled improvement projects from start to finish. He met and responded to building inspectors on each phase of the jobs at hand. Gary obtained the ability to read and interpret blueprints and drawings and gained experience of concrete layout and finish. He has a great knowledge and adherence of applicable building codes, safety codes and regulations.
Contractor / LMZ’s, Inc. / 2005 - 2018
Gary prepared layout, cut, drill, assemble and join moldings, wood materials, drywall and plastic materials for various jobs he was assigned. He acquired a good knowledge on measuring and cutting materials to the required lengths and dimensions in order to plan projects from initial layout to completion. Gary was lead foreman from start to finish and had the ability to effectively finish every phase of commercial and residential remodels according to the blueprint specifications.
Some examples of projects that Gary worked on were Knotts Berry Farm, Costco Warehouse, Dentist Offices, and houses from the counties of Los Angeles, Orange, and San Diego.
Carpenter and Foreman / Campbell Construction / 1990 – 2005 Gary prepared layout, cut, drill, assemble and join moldings, wood materials, drywall and plastic materials for various jobs he was assigned. He acquired a good knowledge on measuring and cutting materials to the required lengths and dimensions in order to plan projects from initial layout to completion. Gary was lead foreman from start to finish and had the ability to effectively finish every phase of commercial and residential remodel according to the blueprint specifications.
Exhibit D73
243
63 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
Years of Experience: 22
Years w/ Interwest: 8
Education
Business Management, Rancho
Santiago Community College
Registrations/Certifications
Disaster Service Worker – State
of CA Safety Assessor
International Code Council,
5034897
ICC Mechanical Inspector
UMC
ICC Plumbing Inspector UPC
ICC Plumbing Inspector
ICC Electrical Inspector
ICC Combination Inspector –
Legacy
ICC Mechanical Inspector
ICC Building Inspector
ICC Combination Inspector
ICC Commercial Combination
Inspector
SEMS City of Orange and
Riverside Fire Department
IS-00700 National Emergency
Management;
IS-00200 ICS – Initial Action
Incidents
IS-00100 PW – FEMA Incident
Command System
Emergency Response to
T errorism
Mark A. Carlson, ICC
SENIOR BUILDING INSPECTOR
Mark is an ICC Certified Combination Building Inspector with more than 20 years of professional hands-on experience. He brings a highly-trained, customer service focused perspective with an in-depth understanding of both commercial and residential building inspection.
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY
Building Inspector / Interwest Consulting Group / 2014 - Present Mark performs residential and commercial inspection services for various Southern California clients, including several large, fast-paced multi-and single-family units in conjunction with Avalon Bay and Toll Brothers & Shea Homes.
Combination Building Inspector / City of Orange / 2005 - 2013 Mark inspected all stages of new commercial and residential developments including remodels and repairs on existing developments. He enforced city, state and federal building codes while providing a high level of customer service and maintaining accurate computer-generated records.
Building Inspector II / City of Moreno Valley / 2001 - 2005 Mark read and understood blueprints and effectively enforced city, state and federal building codes. He inspected new commercial and residential developments. Mark was recognized for exceptional communication skills with business associates, homeowners and job site personnel.
Building Inspector / Consulting Firm / 2000 - 2001
Mark was contracted to the City of Temecula to provide building inspection services as required at commercial and residential locations.
Exhibit D74
244
64 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
YEARS OF EXPERIENCE: 40
YEARS WITH INTERWEST: 6
LICENSES /
CERTIFICATIONS:
International Code Council
8256307
ICC CA Commercial Building
Inspector
ICC Residential Plumbing
Inspector
ICC Residential Mechanical
Inspector
LA Department of Building
and Safety Deputy Building
Inspector | P033571
California State Contractors
License Classification B #499262
Guy Bowen, ICC
BUILDING INSPECTOR
Guy is an ICC certified building inspector with over 30 years of relevant industry experience. He is experienced in providing a wide rage of inspection types as well as working with applicants, designers and jurisdictions. Guys experience allows him to provide clients with timely and accurate inspection services. Guy has provided his services to Interwest since 2016.
PROJECT EXPERIENCE
Over his career, Guy has performed a variety of inspection types, including:
• Rough grade
• Elec. Power Final / meter
Release
• Footings/ ufer ground
• Temp Power Final
• Slab
• Soil pipe - Underground
• Structural floor
• Shower pan
• Pre-inspect roof
• Water pipe underground
• Roof sheathing
• Underground gas
• Building height
• Rough plumbing
• T-bar ceiling structural
• Rough mechanical
• Shear panel
• Rough fireplace
• Frame & flashing
• Gas pipe rough
• Lathing
• Gas pipe test final
• Siding
• Storm drains
• Insulation
• Final Re-roof
• Drywall nailing
• Final Block / retaining wall
• Plaster brown coat
• Final demolition
• Pre-grout
• Final mechanical
• Ufer ground
• Final plumbing
• Elec. Conduit -
underground
• Final electrical
• Rough Elec wiring
residential
• Final building / occupancy
• Subpanels
• Multi-family rough and final
including live work
• Rough Elec. Conduit
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY
Combination Building Inspector / Interwest Consulting Group / 2016 – Present
Guy provides combination building inspection services for Cities in Southern California, including most recently the City of Pomona.
Combination Building Inspector / City of Costa Mesa / 2015 – 2016 Guy performed all phases of residential construction inspection from the site ground up, siting, underground ufer and utilities, foundations, structural framing, HVAC, plumbing, electrical, drywall, stucco, etc., and some non-residential tenant improvements.
Exhibit D75
245
65 THOUGHTFUL SOLUTIONS. THRIVING COMMUNITIES.
City of Murrieta | Proposal for Building Services
YEARS OF EXPERIENCE: 8
YEARS WITH INTERWEST: 5
EDUCATION:
AA, Paralegal Services,
Southern California
International College, 2000
911 Public Safety Dispatcher
Certified, Golden West College,
2007
Real Estate Loan Underwriting
with Online “DU” Training,
Coastline Community College,
2005
REGISTRATIONS /
CERTIFICATIONS:
ICC Certified Permit Technician,
8295728
Basic Life Support, American
Heart Association, 2011
Sheri Barkley, ICC
PERMIT TECHNICIAN
Sheri has eight years of experience processing residential and commercial permits.
Often the first point of contact for the public, she explains the process to others in detail, reviews permit applications and supporting documents for conformance with state, federal and local codes, and distributes building plans for plan checking.
She professionally and clearly provides general and semi-technical information to developers, property owners, outside agencies and the general public.
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
Senior | Lead Development Services Permit Technician / Interwest Consulting Group / 2015 - Present
Sheri sets up project accounts and monitors project balances and close out projects.
She calculates development impact fees and coordinates plan checks. Sheri has more than 5 years of experience issuing permits and certification of occupancies while processing improvements and the post-inspection schedules. Sheri calculates development impact fees and is the central cashier for receipt mitigation and building permit fees. She is very organized and has the ability to ensure that monthly, quarterly and fiscal year reporting is completed in a timely manner.
Project Coordinator / City of Anaheim, CA / 2013 - 2015 Sheri processed residential and commercial permits as well as improvements. She provided general and semi-technical information to developers, property owners, general public and outside agencies. She coordinated plan checks and calculated development impact fees. She managed the monthly and annual reporting and prepared and distributed the inspection schedule and coordinated final inspection clearance.
EKG Technician (Per Diem) / Medical Companies / 2011 - 2013 Sheri performed administrative duties such as working on EKG’s, TMST’s, Holsters and test equipment. She also managed charging, filing and inventory.
Senior Office Assistant | Project Coordinator / City of Santa Ana Public Works Agency / 2007 - 2010
Sheri coordinated purchases of cooperative agreements, lease agreements, rent checks and right-of-entry. She prepared and submitted requests for Council action, otherwise known as RFCA’s. She submitted semi-annual combined fund transportation project updates to the Orange County Transportation Authority. Sheri prepared agendas and created Google maps for each Engineer’s region. She scheduled utility coordination meetings and coordinated CIP budget requests for inspection, and resolved resident complaints. Administratively, Sheri maintained requests and ordered supplies.
Executive Assistant | Project Coordinator / City of Santa Ana, CA / 2006 - 2007 Sheri prepared and submitted resolutions, amendments and addendums to the Clerk of the Board. She scheduled meetings and prepared minutes for the Treasury Oversight Committee. Sheri served as the liaison between management and Clerk of the Board while preparing and submitting agenda staff reports and executive secretary procedure manuals. She was project support for the Treasurer-Tax collector and Business Manager.
Indirect Lending Loan Processor / City of Santa Ana, CA / 2005 - 2006 Sheri maintained the Credit Union Direct Lending pipeline and documented retail consumer auto loans. She reviewed credit reports and requisitions and provided service to Consumers, Loan Officers, Dealer Personnel and Title Companies. She obtained and calculated proof of income and insurance.
Exhibit D76
246
8369 Vickers St, # 207 San Diego, CA 92111 TNCServices.com Fee Proposal for Building Services
City of Murrieta
Building Safety Division
Your Trusted Partner for
Comprehensive
Municipal Services
ISAM HASENIN, MSCE, PE, CBO
EMAIL: [email protected]
Phone: 858-260-0495
PRIMARY CONTACT:
Exhibit C 1
247
Section VI- Fee Proposal
True North Compliance Services is pleased to propose the following competitive fees for the services listed. Additional services not listed below may be negotiated.
Our pricing reflects our commitment to delivering the highest quality responsive and timely service to the City of Murrieta. These include:
Reduced plan review turnaround times.
Ability to expedite plan review at the request of the City Building Official.
Implementation of established electronic plan review processes.
Highly qualified staff compensated commensurate with their duties and responsibilities.
PLAN REVIEW SERVICES
• We propose to charge 65% of the City’s total plan check fees for our review. • Our fee includes initial review and all subsequent rechecks. • Our fee includes shipping and delivery of plans to/from City Hall. • Expedited Plan Services: 1.4 x the plan check fees.
• Revisions/Deferred Submittals/RFI: use Hourly Rate Table below.
Additional Services: The following hourly rate table applies to additional services included in our Scope of Services that may be required by the City of Murrieta.
Hourly Rates for Additional Services
Position Hourly Rate
Interim Certified Building Official $150.00
Plan Review Engineer $125.00
Senior Plan Review Engineer $140.00
Certified Plans Examiner I $105.00
Certified Plans Examiner II $115.00
Building/Housing Inspector I $95.00
Building/Housing Inspector II $105.00
Exhibit C 2
248
Senior Building/Housing Inspector $115.00
Code Enforcement Officer $100.00
CASp Plan Reviewer/Inspector $125.00
Fire Plan Reviewer/Inspector I $120.00
Fire Plan Reviewer/Inspector II $135.00
Grading/Public Improvements Plan Review Engineer I $140.00 Grading/Public Improvements Plan Review Engineer
II
$155.00
Planner $145.00
Senior Planner $160.00
Permit Technician I $70.00
Permit Technician II $85.00
Administrative Assistant $65.00
- On-Site services (plan review, permit technician, inspections) will be provided in eight (8) hour segments.
- Overtime for on-site staffing will be charged at 140% of the rates above. - Mileage for tasks related to requested scope such as inspections or site visits will be charged at the current IRS mileage rate measured from City Hall. - Inspections outside of the City’s business hours will be charged at 140% of rates above with a 3-hour minimum.
- Incidental expenses will be charged at cost.
Exhibit C 3
249
1 8369 Vickers St, # 207 San Diego, CA 92111
Proposal for Building Services
TNCServices.com
City of Murrieta
Building Safety Division
Your Trusted Partner for
Comprehensive
Municipal Services
ISAM HASENIN, MSCE, PE, CBO
EMAIL: [email protected]
Phone: 858-260-0495
PRIMARY CONTACT:
Exhibit D1
250
2 Cover Letter
December 11, 2023
1 Town Square
Murrieta, CA 92562
Dear Sir/Madam,
True North Compliance Services Inc is pleased to present our Proposal for Building Services.
Our philosophy and guiding principles are centered around the commitment to providing public agencies with the highest quality of professional consulting services in a timely and cost- effective manner. We take pride in our ability to provide exemplary services and deep technical expertise to our clients. Isam Hasenin is President and CEO of True North and the main contact for the firm. He is authorized to represent, sign and bind True North Compliance Services, Inc. in a contractual agreement with the City of Murrieta. His email address is [email protected], phone number 858-260-0495. The proposal and fee schedule are valid and binding for one hundred and twenty (120) days.
The founder and president of True North Compliance Services, Inc., Isam Hasenin, has developed an impeccable reputation, over his 30 -year career, as a forward -thinking customer services-centric public agency administrator, licensed Civil Engineer and techn ical manager providing high quality responsive service to public agencies and their citizens.
We understand the City’s needs for Building and Safety services to augment its staff due to the high level of permit activities and the need to provide high quality, responsive and timely service. Our depth and breadth of resources will allow us to meet the demands and requests of the City in a timely and effective manner. We are able to quickly respond to requests to review building plans and perform inspection services on an as-needed basis. We can respond to fluctuations in workload, as well as requests for expedited project reviews. Our project manager will keep an open line of communications with the Building Official and Building & Safety managers and respond to requests within 24 hours of requests. We will serve the City of Murrieta from our San Diego office.
We intent to perform all the services mentioned in the RFP. I am confident True North Compliance Services, Inc. will meet and exceed the City’s expectations and provide unparalleled high-quality and timely services to the City.
We agree to the terms and conditions prescribed by the City of Murrieta Consultant Agreement.
Sincerely,
Isam Hasenin, MSCE, P.E., CBO, President
Exhibit D2
251
3 Table of Contents
I- BACKGROUND AND EXPERIENCE.....………………….…………………………….....…4 II- ORGANIZATION AND TEAM ................................ ................................ ........................... 8 III- APPROACH/WORK PLAN ................................ ................................ .............................. 14 IV- TURN AROUND TIMES ................................ ................................ ................................ .. 24 V- REFERENCES ................................ ................................ ................................ ................. 25 VI- FEE PROPOSAL- IN A SEPARATE FILE ................................ ................................ ...... -- VII- OUR COMMITMENT ................................ ................................ ................................ ... 28 APPENDIX- RESUMES ................................ ................................ ................................ .......... 29
Exhibit D3
252
4 Section I-Background and Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc. is a full-service comprehensive provider of Building, Fire, Engineering and other related services. With four offices in California to serve the City and a staff of over 50 professionals, we are confident we have the depth and breadth of resources to meet the needs of the City of Murrieta.
True North Compliance Services, Inc. was founded and incorporated in California in 2020 as an extension of Hasenin Consulting Engineers founded in 1998. True North Compliance has been in business for 4 years, and it is a full-service comprehensive provider of Building, Fire, Planning and Engineering Services including plan review, building inspection, permit technician, building department administration, code enforcement, planning and fire services and other related services
True North Compliance Services’ philosophy, guiding principles and commitment to the City of Murrieta are centered on creating a long-term successful partnership with the City and provide the highest quality of service that is timely and responsive to client needs. Our motto is personal attentive service and excellence in the delivery of municipal services. We take the time to listen to our client’s needs and challenges and then come up with creative cost-effective solutions. We keep an open and on-going line of communications with City staff and managers as well as the public and clients. We fully understand and appreciate the fact that time is money for construction projects and every day of delay means added costs of construction and potential loss of tax revenues for the City. We will partner with the Building Official and city staff to achieve creative solutions to challenging development/construction problems that are safe yet reasonable and practical.
Isam’s experience as an active participant in the code development & administration process both on the state and national levels, serving on many technical committees and boards and serving as the Vice Chair of the California Building Standards Commission for 8 years gives him a unique perspective and intimate knowledge of the intent behind any Code provision, thus allowing him to come up with alternative solutions and methods of compliance for unique complex code compliance challenges that don’t fit squarely in the prescriptive provisions of the Code. We pride ourselves on the fact that we can create win-win solutions for code compliance challenges and streamlining of the review and inspection process to expedite the occupancy of facilities.
While our firm is relatively young, we are pleased to share with you that we already signed contracts with over 40 local municipalities throughout the state. This is a testament to the impeccable reputation of our president and team members and ability to deliver the level and quality of service expected by our public agency partners. Please see a sampling of projects and client references in this proposal.
Exhibit D4
253
5 Isam Hasenin is President and CEO of True North and the main contact for the firm. He is authorized to represent, sign and bind True North Compliance Services, Inc. in a contractual agreement with the City of Murrieta. His email address is [email protected], phone number 858-260-0495. We will serve the City of Murrieta from our San Diego office at 8369 Vickers St, San Diego, CA 92111.
Our team members have performed reviews and/or inspections of thousands of projects over their long careers including hundreds of projects of variety of sizes and occupancies during their tenure with True North Compliance Services. True North has been a trusted partner for many of our clients to review the most complex high profile or sensitive projects including highly complex custom homes in Malibu and Dana Point to a large, enclosed IC-Hockey Arena for Riverside County, 30-story high rise mixed-use building in San Jose, multiple 5 or 6 story over concrete podiums mixed-use buildings in Pasadena, La Habra, Dana Point and Redwood City. In addition, we just started the preliminary review of a large $2-Billion complex of life sciences buildings in Burlingame which will include multiple high-rise buildings, many hazardous occupancy labs and other uses. We also reviewed multiple hotels, educational buildings for universities and OSHPD-3 clinics. Below is a listing of a few recent projects our team reviewed.
We can provide many more if requested by the City.
1. Coachella Valley Sports Arena - Riverside County, CA: The arena serves as a multi-use facility for sporting events, concerts, and various exhibition-type events. The arena consists of two assembly seating areas, a primary seating bowl and practice ice arena. True North Compliance Services provided the Building, MEP, and Fire Protection plan review for the arena.
Occupancy: A-4, A-3, A-2, B, M and S-2, Type of Construction: I-B Fully Sprinklered, Floor Area: 560,000 square feet, Number of Stories: 4, Valuation: $250 Million.
2. The Wave Hotel- Dana Point: This project consists of 3 stories below grade, 3 stories above grade high end hotel with conference facilities, restaurants and retail. True North Compliance Services provided the Building, MEP, and Fire Protection plan review for project. Occupancy: R- 1, A-2, A-3, M, B, Type of Construction: I-A, V-A, Floor Area: 114,872 square feet, Number of Stories: 3 stories below grade, 3 stories above grade, Valuation: $25M.
3. Top Golf- Burlingame: This project consists of a new three-story golf entertainment venue with restaurants, meeting spaces and associated improvements. Occupancy: A-2, A-3, M and B, Type of Construction: II-B Spkld, Floor Area: 70,663 square feet, No. of Stories: 3, Valuation:
$25.5 Million.
4. Green Mills Place – Pasadena: This project consists of a new 4-story mixed use building and renovation of an existing historic building on the same site in Old Town Pasadena. True North Compliance Services provided the Building, MEP, Fire, grading and MWELO plan review for this project. Occupancy: R-2, A-3, M and S-2, Type of Construction: III-A Fully Sprinklered, Floor Area: 26,607 square feet, Number of Stories: 4, Valuation: $17 Million.
5. Best Western Plus Hotel- Adelanto: True North Compliance Services provided the Building and MEP plan review for the new 4-story hotel and associated site development. The hotel consisted of 54,000 square feet, 90 guest rooms, meeting rooms, a gymnasium, swimming pool, bar and restaurant. Occupancy: R-1, A-2, A-3 and B, Type of Co: III-B, Valuation: $5.6M.
Exhibit D5
254
6 6. Impossible Foods – Redwood City, CA: This project consists of a 4-story tenant improvement for the Impossible Foods Research Facility. Scope of work included demo of existing walls, ceiling and MEP systems, creating new rooms, relocating of walls, ceilings, Electrical lighting and data systems, new AC/heating units, mechanical equipment, flooring, new bathrooms, etc. True North Compliance Services provided Building and MEP plan review for the project. Occupancy: A-3, B and S-1, Type of Construction: II-A Fully Sprinklered, Floor Area:
150,622 square feet, Number of Stories: 4, Valuation: $12 Million.
7. Divine Arts of Yoga Center – La Habra, CA: This project consists of a new religious institution and yoga center. The building contains classrooms, assembly halls, a dining hall and onsite living accommodation. True North Compliance Services provided the Building and MEP plan review for this project. Occupancy: A-3, A-2 and R-3, Type of Construction: V-A Fully Sprinklered, Floor Area: 18,000 square feet, Number of Stories: 1, Valuation: $3,250,000.
8. Wilson Avenue Warehouse Project – Perris, CA: This project consists of a new concrete tilt-up warehouse building. True North Compliance Services provided the Building and MEP plan review for this project. Occupancy: S-1, F-1 and B, Type of Construction: III-B Fully Sprinklered, Floor Area: 153,735 square feet, Number of Stories: 1, Valuation: $4,509,212.
9. Strand Beach, Dana Point: True North Compliance Services provided the Building plan review for the new custom home located at “The Strand” in Dana Point. The dwelling consisted of 6,015 square feet of living space above grade, a 2,455 square foot basement below grade basement and a 2,246 square foot subterranean garage that is accessed through a car lift. Valuation: 2.5 million.
10. California Institute of Technology- Professor Hsieh Laboratory Renovation, 1200 E.
California Blvd, Building # 47, Pasadena. This project consisted of a renovation to an existing science laboratory in an existing R&D and classroom building. Scope of work included demo of existing walls, and MEP systems, relocating of walls, new AC/heating units, mechanical equipment, lab equipment, hazardous materials quantities determination, chemicals, fire alarms renovation, new bathrooms, etc. True North Compliance Services provided Building and MEP plan review for the project. Occupancy: B, A-3, I-3, S, Type of Construction: I-A Fully Sprinklered, Floor Area: 2,600 square feet, Number of Stories: 6, Valuation: $195,000.
Scope of Services
We offer the full range of development review & inspection services including Building & Safety services ranging from plan review to inspection and permit technician services and other related services. We have the depth and breadth of resources to perform any and all of the following services:
a. Building Plan Review Services: True North Compliance will provide plan review in compliance with the City of Murrieta Municipal Code, all applicable federal and state laws and regulations and the City’s Building Safety Division plan review standards and policies.
Our plan review covers the following: California Building Code, California Residential Code, Structural Engineering Plan Review will be performed by licensed or graduate Civil or Structural Engineers, Title 24 Energy, Americans with Disabilities Act, Exhibit D6
255
7 California Mechanical Code, California Plumbing Code, California Electrical Code, Disabled Access- CASp plan review and/or site surveys, inspections and reports, Green Building and Energy Conservation, OSHPD-3 reviews and certification, California Fire Code, California Title 25, Preliminary review of discretionary applications (Conditional-Use Permits and conditions of Approval) for significant code compliance issues that may impact the overall design and planning approval of the project, Review of Floodplain provisions where required, Review of soils conditions and other geotechnical hazards such as fault zones, liquefactions, etc, Civil Engineering (grading, drainage, National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES), MWELO, and Low Impact Development (Hydromodification); Sustainable Use Standard Mitigation Program (SUSMP), permit requirements related to the Management Stormwater System (MS4 permit), Review/recommendations for Alternate Materials and Methods Requests (AMMR), Code adoption, Local Amendments and Ordinances. We have the capabilities to review any design elements as determined by the City.
b. Inspection Services: True North Compliance has the capabilities to provide inspection and reinspection for compliance with all applicable codes, standards and regulations including: California Building Code; California Residential Code; California Plumbing Code; California Mechanical Code; California Electrical Code; California Fire Code; California Energy Code; California Green Building Standards Code; California Disabled Access Regulations; California Title 25, Mobile Home Parks, as locally adopted and am ended. Our inspection staff is certified by the International Code Council or other appropriate entities in accordance with AB717 and possess many years of building code inspection experience with a municipality or a private municipal consultant. Our inspectors have extensive construction and trade experience in addition to their Code knowledge, allowing for a practical approach to applying Code provisions during the inspection process.
c. General Office Support Services: True North Compliance has the capabilities to provide on-call, as -needed Building Permit Technician(s) and Office Clerk(s) to perform permit technician work and general office related duties. Our Building Permit Technicians and Office Clerks are qualified to perform general office duties, process and issue building permits, process building plans and related documents.
d. Additional Services: True North Compliance has the capabilities to Provide Certified Access Specialist (CASP) Services and miscellaneous general training, code update and adoption resource and support as needed and/or upon request.
Exhibit D7
256
8 Section II- Organization and Team
Principal/Project Leader
For this contract, Isam Hasenin, P.E., C.B.O., will
serve as Principal/Team Lead and will serve as the
main point of contact of True North Compliance
Services, Inc. staff and the City of Murrieta. Isam will ensure that services are delivered in accordance with
the Scope of Services established by the City and the
Consultant Services Agreement.
Isam will maintain an open line of communications
with City of Murrieta Building Official and other
managers as well as project applicants and design
teams. He will provide oversight and management of
all True North’s staff assigned to City projects.
Isam will be available for meetings at the City office.
He will be available to discuss complex code
compliance/interpretation questions or process/procedural issues with the Building Official and design team members as the needs arise. He will provide technical or administrative training and participate in any special assignments or meetings at City managers direction.
Isam has 30 years of experience in code enforcement and building department administration and technical review and inspections. Mr. Hasenin has the perfect mix of public sector experience and private sector experience managing both small and large operations. He has deep understanding and appreciation for the challenges and demands of local municipalities in meeting the needs and expectations of their citizens and applicants for building permits.
Project Manager/Director of Operations
Amar Hasenin, Director of Operations for True North will serve as the day-to-day operational and technical manager for the City of Murrieta projects. He will assign and monitor the workload of staff, quality of reviews and timeliness of the review process. He will be available to discuss code compliance/interpretation questions or process/procedural issues with the Building Official and his staff as the needs arise. He will provide technical and administrative training and participate in any special assignments or meetings at City managers direction. Amar has over 10 years of experience as a design engineer, plan check engineer, and regional manager in Southern California. He has served as a Regional Manager for a third-party building department services provider prior to joining True North. He is a highly competent plan review engineer and technical expert in the application of the California Codes and a certified Plans Examiner and Inspector by ICC.
Exhibit D8
257
9 Amar is an effective manager of building operations and managing the needs of our public agency partners and delivering high quality, responsive and timely service.
Lead Building Plan Check Engineer
Bachar Koujah, PE, CASp will serve as the Lead Building Plan Review Engineer. He is an experienced, licensed Civil Engineer. Bachar has over 20 years of experience as a plan check engineer for multiple jurisdictions where he reviewed the entire range of projects from residential remodels to complex new homes, tenant improvements and new commercial, office and multi-family projects. Bachar is a multi-discipline reviewer and can review building, MEP and grading disciplines. He provides high quality reviews and excellent customer service and always ready to offer solutions and ideas on how to comply with code provisions.
Lead Structural Plan Check Engineer
Alex Wu, SE, PhD, will serve as the Lead Structural Plan Check Engineer. He is an experienced, licensed structural engineer. He is currently the Senior Structural Plan Review Engineer for True North Compliance. Henry has a PhD degree in structural engineering and many years of experience designing and reviewing the entire range of buildings and unique structures such as high rise, mixed-use, concrete parking structures, complex public buildings, heavy industrial, refineries, nuclear power plants, etc. He will work closely with City staff to ensure high quality and timely reviews and answer questions and handle complex issues.
Project Team
Our team is comprised of over 50 highly qualified and experienced Plan Check Engineers, Plans Examiners, Building Inspectors and Permit Technicians able to handle reviews, inspections and permit processing for all aspects of the Building Services. Our team members have many years of experience working for public agencies in California. Our staff is licensed and/or certified in all disciplines including Licensed Structural Engineers, Licensed Civil, MEP Engineers, ICC Certified Building Plan Reviewers, Licensed Fire Protection Engineers, Certified HazMat Specialists, ICC Certified Plans Examiners, ICC Certified Fire Plan Reviewers, ICC Certified Building Officials and ICC Certified Permit Technicians. Our team is capable of reviewing and inspecting the entire spectrum of projects submitted to the City from single-family homes to highly complex high-rise hotels and large office buildings, mixed-use projects, R&D lab facilities, biotech buildings, data centers, distribution centers, large scale solar farms, complex tenant improvements and public buildings. Below is a table of key staff who will be assigned to work on City of Murrieta projects. Resumes are included in the appendix.
Exhibit D9
258
10 Organization Chart
Our staff is licensed and/or certified in all di sciplines including: Licensed Structural Engineers, Licensed Ci vil, MEP Engineer, Licen sed Fire Prote ction Engineers, ICC Ce rtified Plans Examiners, ICC Certified Inspectors, ICC Certified Permit Technicians, and more.
City of Murrieta
Isam Hasenin, PE, CBO
President & Principal
Amar Hasenin
Director of Operations &
Project Manager
Alexandra Perkins
Document Control
Manager
Building Plan Review
Bachar Koujah, PE,
CASp
Robert Chun, PE
Scot Weise, PE
Kylie Gonsalves, PE
Mohammad Elassad, PE
Alaa Atassi
Richard Moreno
Ali Almurshid
Areli Sanchez
Bryan Montes
Ryan DeCastro
Mehmet Emirogl
Tim Shell, PE
Ahmad Erikat, EIT
Jed Rizk, PE
MEP Plan Review
Henry Pio, PE
Ali Soheili, PE
Amir Amiri, PE
Steve Suhendra, PE
Hassan Itani, PE
Jerome Schreiber,
PE
Kevin Ybarra
Structural Engineers
Alex Wu, SE, PhD.
Gary Ho, SE
Daniel Lee, SE
Edward Alexanians, SE
Henry Hadidi, SE
Hamid Irannejad. SE
Allen Lang, SE
Mohammad Hariri, SE
Permit Technicians
Alexandra Perkins
Dana Duong
Paul Choi
Roy Kim
Derrick Thompson
Jesica Miner
Gianni Haley
Cassandra Cruz
Cierra Smith
Cynthia Villalta
Julie Hartman
Inspection/Code Enforcement
George Lockfort
Inspections Supervisor
William Barannon
Tom Graham
Steve Stingl
Rene Avela
Joe Harris
Marco Stutts
Brenda Sylvester
Charles Valaer
Randy Kilburn
Albert Leong
Fire Protection/Fire, Life-Safety
Doug Evans, FPE
Scot Deal, FPE
Eric Schmidt, PE
Gabriel Reza
Bob Scott
Girard Page
Ron Carter
Bill Cochran
Sergio Perriera
Exhibit D10
259
11 Name & Role Experience & Credentials
Isam Hasenin, PE, CBO, MSCE
President & Building Official
30+ years experience
CA Licensed Professional Engineer Certified: Building
Official, Building Plans Examiner
Amar Hasenin
Project Manager/
Director of Operations
10+ years experience
Certified: Commercial Building Plans Examiner, Building Inspector, Plumbing Plans Examiner, Plumbing Inspector, Accessibility Plans Examiner, Accessibility Inspector
Bachar Koujah, PE, CASp
Lead Building Plan Review
Engineer
20+ years experience
CA Licensed Professional Engineer
Certified Accessibility Specialist; Certified Plans Examiner Alex Wu, PhD, SE, PE
Lead Structural Review Engr.
20+ years experience
CA Licensed Professional & structural Engineer
Allen Lang, SE, PE
Structural Review Engr.
20+ years experience
CA Licensed Professional & Structural Engineer
Gary Ho, SE, PE
Structural Review Engr.
30+ years experience
CA Licensed Professional & Structural Engineer
Daniel Lee, SE, PE
Structural Review Engr.
20+ years experience
CA Licensed Professional & Structural Engineer
Edward Alexanian, SE, PE
Structural Review Engr.
30+ years experience
CA Licensed Professional & Structural Engineer
Henry Hadidi, SE, PE
Lead Structural Review Engr.
30+ years experience
CA Licensed Professional & structural Engineer
Robert Chun, PE
Building Plan Review Engr.
30 years experience
CA Licensed Professional Engineer
Scot Weise, PE
Building Plan Review Engr.
15+ years experience
CA Licensed Professional Engineer, ICC Certified Plans Examiner Mohammed Elassad, PE
Building Plan Review Engr.
20+ years experience
CA Licensed Professional Engineer, ICC Certified Plans
Examiner
Alaa Atassi
Building Plan Review Engr.
5+ years experience
ICC Certified Plans Examiner
Areli Sanchez
Building Plan Review Engr.
5+ years experience
ICC Certified Plans Examiner
Bryan Montes
Building Plan Review Engr.
5+ years experience
ICC Certified Plans Examiner
Richard Moreno
Senior Plans Examiner
10+ years experience
ICC Certified Plans Examiner
Exhibit D11
260
12 Ryan DeCastro
Building Plan Review Engr.
5+ years experience
BS in Civil Engineering
Ali Almurshid
Building Plan Review Engr.
4+ years experience
BS in Civil Engineering
Mehmet Amiroglu
Building Plan Review Engr.
3+ years experience
BS in Civil Engineering
Tim Shell, PE
Civil Plan Review Engr.
30 years experience
CA Licensed Professional Engineer
Jed Rizk, PE
Civil Plan Review Engr.
30 years experience
CA Licensed Professional Engineer
Jamal Naji, PE
Civil Plan Review Engr.
25 years experience
CA Licensed Professional Engineer
Ahmad Erikat, EIT
Civil Plan Review Engr.
15 years experience
EIT Certificate
Henry Pio, PE
MEP Plan Review Engineer
20+ years experience
CA Licensed Professional Engineer
Certified: Mechanical, Electrical, Plumbing Plans Examiner Ali Soheili, PE
MP Plan Review Engineer
20+ years experience
CA Licensed Engineer; ICC Certified Plans Examiner
Hassan Itani, PE
MP Plan Review Engineer
10+ years experience
CA Licensed Engineer; ICC Certified Plans Examiner
Amir Amiri, PE
Electrical Plan Review
Engineer
20+ years experience
CA Licensed Professional Engineer; ICC Certified Plans
Examiner
Jerome Schreiber, PE
Electrical Plan Review
Engineer
20+ years experience
CA Licensed Professional Engineer; ICC Certified Plans
Examiner
Kevin Ybarra
Electrical Plans Examiner
20+ years experience
ICC Certified Plans Examiner
Dan Larsen, CASp
CASp Plan Reviewer/Insp.
20+ years experience Certified Accessibility
Specialist
Gabriel Reza
Lead Fire Plan Reviewer
10+ years experience
Certified Fire Plans Examiner
Doug Evans, FPE
Fire Protection Engineer
20+ years experience
CA Licensed Fire Protection Engineer
Exhibit D12
261
13 Bob Scott
Fire Plans Examiner
25+ years experience
Fire Plan Review and Former Fire Marshal; Fire Inspector II, Building Inspector, Building Plans Examiner
William Barranon
Manager, Inspection Services
30+ years experience
George Lockfort
Manager, Inspection Services
Combination Inspector
30+ years experience Over 15 ICC Certifications
Tom Graham
Combination Inspector
25+ years experience
ICC Certified Building Inspector, ICC Certified Residential Inspector
Steve Stingl
Combination Inspector
30+ years experience ICC Certified Building Inspector
Charles Valaer
Combination Inspector
20+ years experience
ICC Certified: Building Inspector, Combination Inspector Joe Harris
Combination Inspector
20+ years experience
Rene Avela
Senior Combination
Inspector/Plans Examiner
30+ years experience
ICC Certified: Building Inspector, Combination Inspector Randy Kilburn
Senior Combination Inspector
30+ years experience
ICC Certified: Building Inspector, Combination Inspector Marco Stutts
Combination Inspector
5+ years experience
Brenda Sylvester
Combination Inspector
25+ years experience
Alexandra Perkins
Lead Permit Technician
5+ years experience
Gianni Haley
Permit Technician
3+ years experience
Exhibit D13
262
14 Section III- Approach/Work Plan
Our established internal procedures and policies will ensure that we provide the City of Murrieta the highest quality, accurate, timely, and responsive service. We maintain our own software licenses. Our goal is to provide consistent and uniform service, eliminate errors and confusion and ensure compliance with the City’s standards, policies, interpretations, and procedures. To that end, we have the following established procedures for each of the services we offer:
Plan Review Procedures
The following approach and procedures will apply to Plan Review Services. It may be adjusted to better accommodate the specific needs of the City of Murrieta:
1. All document/plan reviews shall be based on the City of Murrieta Municipal Code, applicable federal and state laws and regulations, Title 24 California Code of Regulations, and the City’s Building & Safety Division plan review standards and policies. Plan review shall cover structural, fire and life safety, architectural, accessibility, OSHPD -3, energy conservation, green building, grading, plumbing, mechanical and electrical installations.
2. We will pick-up plans at the City of Murrieta Permit Center within 24 hours of notification or upload immediately into our cloud-based database for electronic submittals.
3. Review all plan check applications for accuracy and make all necessary revisions to such items as description, square footage, type of construction, occupancy and uses.
4. Format plan review comment lists to compliment the style and requirements of the City of Murrieta.
5. Prepare a standard template specific to the City of Murrieta to identify specific requirements and items of interest and focus to the City Building & Safety Division.
6. Our plan review philosophy is to perform a thorough review during the first submittal of plans in order to avoid new comments on any subsequent submittals.
7. Open lines of communication with the Building Official and other City managers and staff to ensure accuracy in enforcing City policies, procedures and regulations.
8. Conduct plan reviews within the agreed upon turn-around times established by the City of Murrieta.
9. Our team is available to review projects on an expedited basis within the designated turn - around times.
10. Review deferred submittals and revisions within assigned due dates.
11. Email plan check comments to designated Building staff and provide pertinent building/project data and information required on permit application. Building/project data Exhibit D14
263
15 such as description of work, type of construction, uses, occupancy classification, floor area, number of stories, etc. will be provided on the transmittal letter.
12. Supply hard copy or electronic plan review comment, approval letters, and project invoices as required by the City of Murrieta.
13. When final review is approved, we will deliver two final sets of approved plans with approval stamps and signatures to the City within 24 (twenty -four) hours of final review and approval.
14. Be available, during regular business hours, to discuss and clarify plan check issues with applicants, designers, owners and consultants. Resolution of code issues may be performed by telephone, or meetings, prior to resubmitting corrected plans and documents.
15. Any plan check issues not resolved between the reviewer and the architect/engineer of record after the second review cycle will be quickly elevated to our QC Manager who will in turn discuss with the Building Official and come up with resolution to the outstanding issues.
16. Communicate and/or meet with the applicant, architect, engineer, other City departments or agencies, as necessary to assist with plan review responses.
17. Participate in pre-submittal meetings during preliminary design or working drawing stages to provide high level code review and discussion to ensure a smooth and timely plan review process.
18. Our President, Isam Hasenin will be available to provide technical support and advice to the Building Official, and city staff and managers related to code application and rev iew of Requests for Alternate materials and Methods, administrative aspects of the department, permit fee analysis, preparing local amendments and ordinances and similar services.
19. We will utilize the City’s Permit Tracking System to enter and monitor plan -checking information into the portal.
20. We have a fully automated web-based project tracking system to enter and track all projects assigned by the City. City staff and managers can access the system anytime to check the backlog, status and due dates of any project. They can also review copies of comment lists prepared by our staff. If the City agrees, we can provide access to applicants so they can check status of their projects online without having to call the City or come to the Building & Safety counter. Here is a screen shot of the plan log screen:
Exhibit D15
264
16 Electronic Plan Review
True North Compliance Services is able to receive, process, plan review, markup and approval stamp plans electronically and return the electronic plans back to the City. In fact, over 75% of our reviews currently are performed electronically using the Bluebeam platform.
More specifically:
1. We will adhere to the City’s Electronic Plan Review guidelines and policies.
2. We are able to receive and route submittal documents utilizing cloud storage (Box, SharePoint, Drop Box, etc.) links or any other preferred method of the City.
3. Our staff will use Blue Beam to perform the review or other City-required platform.
4. We will provide redline mark ups on the plans with Blue Beam. Then transferring a marked-up image of the plans onto the plan review comments. This process will simplify the comments for the applicant resulting in less plan review iterations.
5. When the plan check and recheck processes are complete and the plans and corresponding documentation are deemed in full code compliance, we will sign and stamp the electronic plan set and corresponding documents.
6. Our entire team is equipped with latest technology (highspeed computers, multiple large monitors, latest version of Blue Beam, access to cloud storage, etc.) to easily perform plan reviews electronically.
Exhibit D16
265
17 Building Inspection Services
True North Compliance Services, Inc. is pleased to offer excellent on-call Building Inspection Services to the City of Murrieta. Our inspectors have extensive construction and trade experience in addition to their Code knowledge, allowing for a practical approach to applying Code provisions during the inspection process. Similar to our Plan Review process, our inspectors employ the following procedures to maximize project success. These procedures may be adjusted to better accommodate your jurisdiction.
1. Become familiar with the inspection style and requirements of the City of Murrieta.
2. Provide inspection services and assure that construction complies with plans and is in compliances with the most recently adopted codes, policies, and procedures.
3. Perform inspections on construction projects to verify compliance with City of Murrieta Municipal Code and State codes and regulations: California Building Code, Residential Code, Plumbing Code, Mechanical Code, Electrical Code, Fire Code, Energy Code, Green Building Standards Code, Disabled Access Regulations, and Title 25; Mobile Home Parks regulations; State Water Resource Control Board regulations related to storm water pollution prevention; Sound Transmission Control regulations; and, locally adopted building ordinances and amendments thereof.
4. Inspect for compliance with applicable conditions of approval set forth by the City's Community Development Department, Planning Commission, and/or City Council.
5. Inspectors will possess and maintain necessary certifications required to perform inspections.
6. Be equipped with all necessary tools needed to perform inspections, including a complete set of current code books.
7. Assist in the coordination of job site conferences with technical consultants, engineers, architects, representatives of the owner, equipment manufacturers, and subcontractors to review project requirements, and clarify or resolving any questions or proble ms prior to commencing work.
8. Prepare inspection notices of noncompliance on incorrect construction methods or material found during inspection; confer with contractor or representative regarding construction methods and procedures as they relate to compliance with plans and specifications.
9. Maintain a record of non -complying items and follow up to achieve resolution of such items. Record all significant construction -related activities and events such as work completed to provide a chronological and factual history of inspection on assigned construction projects.
10. Engage with Building & Safety Division staff to understand the City’s permitting process, forms, policies, and clients.
Exhibit D17
266
18 11. Adapt to the City’s needs to allow for easy integration into the day -to-day inspection operations.
12. Communicate daily with the City’s Principal Building Inspector for assignments and to identify potential issues.
13. Coordinate with various City and County agencies and departments and other governmental agencies providing services, and/or having jurisdiction over any aspect of a development project.
14. Maintain contact while in the field to answer questions, reschedule inspections, and support City staff.
15. Serve as a resource and provide information on City regulations to property owners, residents, businesses, the general public and other City departments.
16. Build a rapport with frequent contractors and teams on continuing projects.
17. Update the City’s permit tracking software as necessary, including transferring all applicable field notes.
18. Perform and/or attend on-site and in-office preconstruction meetings as required.
19. Communicate and/or meet with applicants, contractors, engineers, architects, etc., as necessary to assist with corrections and general project questions.
Permit Processing Services
True North Compliance Services, Inc. believes that the permit technician position is one of the toughest positions in the Building & Safety Division. Being at the counter all day long handling customer contacts, questions and issues is challenging, especially as we experience the high volume of work and high customer traffic at the public counter. That’s why we believe it takes a certain type of personality to be successful at the position. It’s someone who is pleasant, calm, patient, excellent interpersonal skills and ability to use automation systems. We are pleased to offer staff who meet these criteria and qualifications. More specifically, the permit technician will:
1. Enter permit data into the automated database.
2. Research, compile and prepare various limited reports and presentation graphics.
3. Assist the general public at the front counter or by phone regarding building, planning and engineering permit requirements, plan check fees, plan check filing procedures and processing, and permit status.
4. Research information for public.
5. Accept permit applications and collect permit fees.
Exhibit D18
267
19 6. Review and evaluate plans for completeness and for conformance with ordinances and department standards, policies and guidelines.
7. Review plans for conditions of prior approval.
8. Route plans to other city departments for review.
9. Approve minor permits.
10. Research and respond to public inquiries.
11. Build and maintain positive working relationships with co-workers, City employees and the public using principles of good customer service.
12. Perform related duties as assigned.
13. Utilize City electronic and paper files to research previous and/or related permits.
14. Review permit application for completeness, perform fee calculations, route plans, verify approvals and conditions and issue permits.
15. Provide excellent service to all customers from a homeowner to large developers and designers.
16. Have excellent interpersonal skills, calm demeanor, patient and be a good listener
Quality Control Program
True North Compliance’s core values in delivering municipal services are: Ethics, Transparency, Collaboration, Empathy, Customer-Centric service, Communications, and Fiscal Prudence. High quality service, professionalism and excellence in the delivery of municipal services are at the core of what True North Compliance stands for. We share the City’s commitment to delivering responsive and timely service without compromising the quality of the service. To that end, we developed and implemented a rigorous internal quality control and assurance program for all of our services. Here are the major components of our quality control program:
Plan Review and Counter Services
Our established internal intake, plan review, quality control and customer contact procedures ensure that submittals are properly coordinated, tracked and managed. Our plan tracking procedures are designed to track each submittal throughout the review process and maintain accurate and comprehensive records for each submittal. To accomplish this goal, we f ollow this procedure:
1. We monitor our staff’s performance and interaction with customers at the counter by having customer surveys available for the applicants to complete. We will also randomly call applicants who received our service to check on their satisfaction with the ser vices Exhibit D19
268
20 received from our staff. We will monitor phone calls and produce period reports of customer satisfaction. We will train and provide feedback to our staff related to their customer service skills.
2. Once we receive a project for review from the City, our document control staff screens and logs the project into our internal project tracking s ystem with all appropriate information such as description, scope, review disciplines, Building Department staff, design team contact person and due dates.
3. Our QC Manager will perform an initial cursory review of the project to determine if there are any major code compliance issues that may require immediate discussion with the Building & Safety Division staff and/or design team, then depending on the complexity of the project, assigns to appropriate True North plan review engineers/plans examiners.
4. Plans are assigned to engineers or plans examiners for each of the required disciplines with notes from the QC manager
5. Once the plan review is complete, True North QC Manager will perform quality control of the project by reviewing the project and comments prepared by the assigned plan review engineer/plans examiner.
6. Following the QC phase, final comments will be generated and sent to the Building & Safety Division staff and designated design team member.
Inspection Services
Similar to our plan check quality control program, we have a rigorous internal quality control and assurance program for our inspection services. Main elements of our program include:
1. Rigorous hiring program to ensure that we only hire highly competent professional and friendly inspectors who believe in True North’s core values and guiding principles.
2. Thorough on-boarding and training program for our team.
3. On-going technical training on latest codes, interpretations, technology and construction methods and techniques.
4. Regular staff meetings to communicate policies, procedures and provide directions.
5. Regular feedback loop on staff performance.
6. Announced and un-announced audits of inspectors by our Chief of Inspections.
7. Regular feedback meetings with City’s Building Official and staff to obtain feedback and input on our staff’s performance.
8. Periodic calls to contractors to seek feedback on performance of our inspection staff.
9. Regular meetings with our inspectors to evaluate performance, offer critique and corrective actions if necessary.
Exhibit D20
269
21 Customer Service Commitment
Our singular focus on our motto “personal attentive service and excellence in the delivery of our services” allowed us to become the go-to provider for most of our clients. The common denominator for our success serving our clients is the absolute focus on delivering high quality, responsive and timely services. We will partner with city staff, applicants and designer to come up with practical common-sense solutions to difficult code compliance challenges. Our team is available to handle questions and issues raised by City staff and/or the applicants throughout the day. Our managers are available around the clock to handle whatever needs our clients might have. We keep an open line of communications with staff and applicants to streamline and expedite the review and approval of projects being reviewed. Our customer service commitment includes the following elements:
1. Application of the code in a reasonable practical yet safe manner, and understanding and applying the spirit and intent of the code whenever needed.
2. Our plan review philosophy is to perform a thorough and accurate plan review during the first submittal in order to avoid new comments and delays during subsequent review cycles and frustrating the applicants and designers.
3. Open lines of communication with the Building Official and other city managers and staff to ensure efficient and high level of customer service.
4. When an applicant disputes plan check comments, our plan check staff is trained and instructed to quickly elevate the issues to our QC manager to work toward quick and effective resolution of the issues.
5. Implementation of our “Express Recheck By Appointment” system to enhance customer service and expedite approval of projects.
6. Office hours: our staff is available Monday through Friday from 8:00 am- 5:00 pm to respond to phone calls and email inquiries.
7. We respond to phone calls and emails no later than the next business day and in most cases on the same business day.
8. Our plan check staff is available, during regular business hours, to discuss and clarify plan check issues with applicants, designers, owners and consultants. Resolution of code issues may be performed by telephone, or meetings, prior to resubmitting corrected plans and documents.
Exhibit D21
270
22 Philosophy/Ethical Standards
A primary reason for early success and rapid growth is our strong ethics and professional standards. Our Philosophy & Guiding Principles are: To provide highest quality, timely, cost- effective service and build strong successful long-term partnerships with municipal clients.
Our core values in delivering building services are: Ethics, Transparency, Collaboration, Communications, Excellent Customer Service, Empathy, Fiscal Prudence.
We apply our philosophy & Guiding Principles along with our core values to everything we do in the day-to-day operations and in the delivery of all of our services. To that end, we will:
✓ Partner and collaborate with City’s Building Official, Fire Marshal and their staff to deliver a streamlined and expeditious process for plan reviews. ✓ We deliver on every promise we make to our clients.
✓ Deliver timely, high-quality service.
✓ Thorough and complete plan review with clear concise comments during the first review to minimize delays and frustrations.
✓ Reasonable, practical yet safe approach to code compliance. ✓ Availability of our staff and managers to City staff and applicants. ✓ Free early global code review during discretionary process. ✓ Our motto is personal attentive service and excellence in the delivery of municipal services.
We avoid any real or perception of conflict of interest and hold ourselves to the highest ethical standards in the delivery of our services. To that end, we have the following policies and procedures in place:
1. We only work for public agencies in the assessment and verification services. We do not perform any design services to private or public agencies.
2. We do not work for any private developers, designers or engineers.
3. Our staff is not permitted to perform any design or consulting work on their own in any client cities.
4. Our staff and managers are required to disclose any personal financial interest in any city client.
5. Our staff is not permitted to be involved in any way in project reviews, inspections or approval of their personal projects, or their family members or friends.
6. Or staff and managers are not permitted to accept gifts of any monetary value from clients or project applicants and contractors.
7. Or staff and managers are not permitted to develop personal relationships or friendships with project applicants or builders of projects they are working on.
Exhibit D22
271
23 Transition and Implementation Plan
Our managers and staff are highly experienced in transitioning services from other consultants.
We have successfully and effectively transitioned services from other consultants for our current clients such as City of the Del Mar, Carlsbad, Dana Point, Malibu , Redwood City, San Bruno and others. We are prepared to immediately engage with the City of Murrieta’s Building Official and other City staff to initiate the transition process. Elements of our implementation plan would include the following steps:
2. Our President and Director of Operations will hold an initial implementation meeting in person or via video-conference with the Chief Building Official and his staff as soon as the contract is signed to gain an insight on current key issues, challenges and needs of the Building & Safety Division.
3. Tour the City’s Building Services operation and meet and greet with manager/staff of City departments that are involved in the development review and permitting process.
4. Meet with Planning Division managers to review current applications for discretionary review to gain insight of upcoming construction projects and key project conditions.
5. We would collect all policies and procedures of the Building & Safety Division’s plan review and inspection process.
6. We would provide internal training to our staff on City of Murrieta process, technical policies and other applicable local ordinances and regulations.
7. We would establish internal policy manual for City of Murrieta plan review and inspection process to ensure our staff follows established procedures and local ordinances and regulations.
8. Set up the process and procedures for plan pick-up, delivery and return of plans.
9. Train our staff on the City’s permitting software system.
10. We would develop standardized plan review checklists specific for the City of Murrieta.
11. Process and deliver projects during the last week of transition to test the system and tweak as necessary.
12. Our President, Isam Hasenin will set up regular meetings with the Chief Building Official and other City managers to discuss process, procedures, technical issues and receive feedback on the performance of True North staff.
Exhibit D23
272
24 Section IV- Turn Around Times
We commit to meeting the City’s turn -around times on all projects reviewed by our team. Our web -based project tracking system allows both our reviewers and permit technicians to stay on top of project due dates.
Below are our standard review times.
* “Express Rechecks By Appointment”
We are pleased and excited to offer the City of Murrieta our new and innovative solution to expedite and streamline the recheck process. The program, “Express Recheck By Appointment” is a revolutionary approach to expedite the recheck process, minimize the number of review cycles, reduce frustrations and miscommunications between applicants and plan checkers and reduce the workload of City staff in intaking, routing and tracking of the many cycles of plan check and rechecks on submitted projects. The program will be offered at no additional cost to the applicant or City. The service applies to the vast majority of projects reviewed by our staff.
Once the applicant is ready for the recheck, he/she will contact True North Office to schedule the “Express Recheck By Appointment”. The appointment will be scheduled within 48 hours of the request. Our plan reviewer will perform the recheck over video-conferencing meeting and sign off items completed.
TYPE OF
JOB
EXPECTED
TURNAROUND
TIME
---------------
FIRST CHECK
(Working days)
EXPECTED
TURNAROUND
TIME
--------------
RECHECK
(Working days)
EXPEDITED
TURNAROUND
TIME
------------------
EXPEDITED
REQUEST
(Working
days)
Residential:
New Construction 10 5 5
Addition 7 5 5
Remodel 7 5 5
Commercial:
New construction 15 10 10
Addition 15 10 10
Tenant Improvement/
Remodel
10 5
5 Exhibit D24
273
25 Section V- References
Client Dates Services Provided
City of Del Mar
Karen Brindley, Director of Planning Dept.
1050 Camino Del Mar, Del Mar, CA 92014
(858) 442-2512, [email protected]
2020-
Current
Building Official, Plan Review,
Inspection and Permit processing
services
City of San Marcos
David Yorba, Chief Building Official
1 Civic Center Dr., San Marcos, CA 92069
(760) 744-1050 x3243, [email protected]
2022-
Current
Building Official, Plan Review,
Inspection and Permit processing
services
City of Chula Vista
Shayne Wagner, Chief Building Official
276 Fourth Ave, Chula Vista, CA 91910
(619)409-1960, [email protected]
2022-
Current
Building Official, Plan Review,
Inspection and Permit processing
services
County of San Diego
Michael Casady, PE, Senior Civil Engineer
5510 Overland Ave, San Diego, CA 92123
(858)694-3063, [email protected]
2022-
Current
Plan Review, Inspection and Permit
processing services
City of Carlsbad
Mike Strong, Assistant Director Community
Development Department
1635 Faraday Ave, Carlsbad, CA 92008
(442) 339-2721, [email protected]
2022-
Current
Plan Review, Inspection and Permit
processing services
City of Malibu
Yolanda Bundy, PE, Chief Building Official
23825 Stuart Ranch Rd, Malibu, CA 90265
(310) 804-6648, [email protected]
2021-
Current
Plan review & Inspection services
City of Huntington Beach
Jasmine Daley, Chief Building Official
2000 Main St, Huntington Beach, CA 92648
(714) 375-5147, [email protected]
2021-
Current
Plan review & Inspection services
City of Pasadena
Ron Takiguchi , Chief Building Official,
175 Garfield Ave, Pasadena, CA 91101
(626) 744-7063, [email protected]
2020-
Current
Plan review & Inspection services
Exhibit D25
274
26 City of La Habra
Rodney Sipma, Building Official
110 E La Habra Blvd, La Habra, CA 90631
(562) 383-4119, [email protected]
2020-
Current
Plan review & Inspection services
City of Glendale
Ara Sargsyan, Building Official
633 E. Broadway, Glendale, CA 91206
(818) 937-8104, [email protected]
2023-
Current
Plan review & Inspection services
City of Dana Point
Joe Romero, Building Official
33282 Golden Lantern, Dana Point, CA 92629
(949) 248-3545, [email protected]
2021-
Current
Plan review & Inspection services
City of San Jose
Lisa Joiner, Chief Building Official
200 E. Santa Clara St, San Jose, CA 95113
(408) 535-7757, [email protected]
2023-
Current
Plan review & Inspection services
City of Redwood City
Christina McTaggart, Building Official
1017 Middlefield Rd, Redwood City, CA 94063
(650) 780-7228, [email protected]
2020-
Current
Plan review & Inspection services
City of San Bruno
Darcy Axiaq, Building Official
567 El Camino Real, San Bruno, CA 94066
(650) 616-7020, [email protected]
2021-
Current
Plan review & Inspection services
City of Tracy
Christopher Morgan, Building Official
333 Civic Center Plaza, Tracy, CA 95376 (209)
831-6415, [email protected]
2020-
Current
Plan review & Inspection services
City of Burlingame
Rick Caro, Building Official
501 Primrose Rd, Burlingame, CA 94010
(650) 558-7260, [email protected]
2021-
Current
Plan review & Inspection services
Exhibit D26
275
27 Acknowledgements
True North Compliance Services, Inc proposes no exceptions or deviations from the City’s requirements and accepts the City of Murrieta Standard Professional Services Agreement without exceptions.
True North Compliance Services, Inc. certifies that it is able to provide the insurance coverage required by the City of Murrieta.
Conflict of Interest
We attest that none of True North Compliance Services’ managers or staff have any real or perceived conflict of interest with the City of Murrieta related to this RFP.
Exhibit D27
276
28 Section VI- Fee Proposal- In a Separate File
Section VII- Our Commitment
Our commitment to the City of Murrieta is to provide the highest quality Building and Safety services to you and your clients. More specifically, we commit to the following:
1. Unparalleled Building & Safety expertise of team members, and highest quality of plan review and inspection services.
2. Our Director of Operations will serve as the single point of contact for all communication with the City.
3. We will provide the necessary plan review staffing levels to meet the volume of work and level of permit activities.
4. Open line of communications with City staff and managers and permit applicants.
5. Implementation of a rigorous quality assurance program for all services we provide to the City.
6. Availability to work directly with designer and developers to provide high quality responsive plan review services and address plan check comments.
7. Create a balance of consistency, conformance, and efficiency in all plan reviews.
8. Daily pick up of plans at City offices (for paper plans).
9. Professionally prepared comment lists with clear reference to applicable code sections.
10. Commitment to reviewing plans within the agreed upon turn-around times.
11. Ability to provide expedited plan review services upon request.
12. Ability to provide plan review staff to work at the City of Murrieta Permit Center.
13. Availability to meet virtually and in -person with applicants during pre -application and discretionary phase to provide high level code review.
14. Ability to provide technical support to the Building Official and staff such as training, code adoption, developing technical policies, procedures and review/recommendations for Alternate Materials and Methods Requests (AMMR).
15. Our President, Isam Hasenin will set up regular meetings with the Building Official to discuss process, procedures, technical issues and receive feedback on performance of True North staff.
16. Providing services exclusively to municipal clients, thus avoiding any real or perceived conflict of interest.
Exhibit D28
277
APPENDIX: RESUMES
Exhibit D29
278
26 38
Exhibit D30
279
27 39
Exhibit D31
280
28 40
Exhibit D32
281
29 41
Exhibit D33
282
Alex Wu, Ph.D., S.E., P.E.
Senior Structural Plan Review Engineer
Education
Ph.D. Degree -Structural
Engineering
Purdue University
M.S Degree - Structural
Engineering
National Taiwan University
Licenses and
Certifications
• Licensed Professional
Engineer in the State of
California
• Licensed Structural
Engineer in the State of
California
Awards/Honors
• Member of the Phi Tau
Phi Honor Scholastic
Honors Society at
National Taiwan
University
Background
Gene
Alex is a highly respected structural engineer. He has over 2 0 years in structural plan check and structural design field. With a Ph.D. degree is structural Engineering a nd many years of experience designing and peer-reviewing the full range of structures including complex building and structures. Alex has peer-reviewed highly complex buildings and structures for agencies like OSHPD, DSA, LA Unified School District, UCSD and many others.
Select Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Senior Structural Plan Review Engineer
Provide structural plan review for various projects. Review projects including single family/duplex residential construction, multifamily residential construction, commercial construction, and non-building structures. Review and evaluate architectural and
structural construction documents submitted for permit approval from various municipalities utilizing applicable codes/standards/guidelines/laws, code interpretation, appropriate municipal ordinances and construction and engineering standards; interact and communicate with design professionals and city staff on technical requirements and plan review comments; provide technical assistance to city staff; perform structural inspections in the field as needed; provide assistance and information to contractors, architects, engineers and the public in the solution of complex building problems and the interpretation of building codes, structural standards and ordinances.
K
PFF, Inc.
Senior Project Engineer
Provided structural analysis and design for variety of buildings and structures.
Examples of projects designed or peer-reviewed include: design and construction administration of hospital equipment seismic/gravity support/ bracing/anchorage design
and construction for Kaiser Hospital; Design of a new 200-foot long pedestrian bridge based on Caltrans specification for California State University, San Marcos; Peer review of the design of several new multi-story (Up to 13 stories above and 3 levels below grade) RC shear wall buildings with underground garages for University of California San Diego, North Torrey Pines Living & Learning Neighborhood; Peer review of renovation/addition design of multi-story RC shear wall buildings for University of California San Diego and many others.
TMAD, Taylor & Gaines
Structural Project Engineer
Provided structural analysis and design for variety of buildings and structures.
Examples of projects designed include: Seven masonry shear wall buildings with steel gravity frames and pile foundations for Long Beach Unified School District; Design of
new two-story steel special concentrically braced frame building for San Diego High School; Seismic retrofit design of existing three-story reinforced concrete shear wall building for Long Beach City Library; Design of new six-story steel frame building and surrounding structures for Scripps Memorial Hospital.
Exhibit D34
283
Gary Ho, SE, PE
Senior Structural Review Engineer
Education
B.S. Degree - Civil
Engineering
University of California-
Davis
M.S. Degree - Civil
Engineering
Utah State University
Licenses and
Certifications
• Licensed Structural
Engineer in the State of
California
• Licensed Civil Engineer in
the State of California
• ICC Certified Plans
Examiner
• ICC Certified Building
Inspector
• ICC Certified Accessibility
Plans Examiner
Background
Highly accomplished Professional Engineer who is effective at reviewing the entire range of residential and commercial plans for compliance with applicable building codes. Detail-oriented and analytical professional with an efficient and thorough approach. Proficient licensed plans check engineer who is knowledgeable about current codes and their effective interpretation.
Select Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Senior Structural Engineer
Perform plan review of the entire range of residential, commercial and industrial projects; examine and check structural engineering designs, calculations and plans for conformance with adopted Building Codes and local ordinance and regulations.
Provide interpretations of building codes, State laws and local ordinances to city staff and the public; evaluate alternate methods of construction/materials and provides recommendations; provide technical assistance to city staff; determine valuation and building fees; check calculations and test reports; provide assistance and information to contractors, architects, engineers and the public in the solution of routine building problems and the interpretation of building codes and ordinances; check plans for compliance with California Title 24, Energy and Disabled Access Requirements; maintain liaison with city staff related to project reviews and code compliance.
City of San Francisco -Department of Building Inspections Plan Review Engineer
Joined the department in December 1994 as an Associate Civil Engineer, promoted to Civil Engineer in July 1997, to Structural Engineer in October 2001 and Senior Engineer in July 2017. Managed permit processing and reviewing for all building permit applications in the City. Structural, Architectural and Accessibilities plan review for compliance of applicable codes. Plan review buildings for all types of construction and occupancy classifications; projects include alternation, addition and retrofitting of existing buildings, and new constructions ranging from single story to multi-stories tall buildings.
AGS
Senior Structural Design Engineer
Provided structural evaluation and reports of existing buildings. Prepared structural calculations, specifications and plans for retrofitting of commercial and residential buildings. Reviewed plans for structural compliance. Prepared proposals and presentations of projects to clients. Set up design criteria, budgets and schedules of projects. Supervised staff engineers and designers in preparing calculations, specification and plans for projects. Provided co-ordinations of projects between clients, architects, engineers and contractors. Provided construction support and field inspection.
Exhibit D35
284
Henry Hadidi, Ph.D., S.E.
Senior Structural Plan Review Engineer
Education
Ph.D. Degree -Structural
Engineering
Stanford University
M.S Degree - Structural
Engineering
Stanford University
Licenses and
Certifications
• Licensed Professional
Engineer in the State of
California
• Licensed Structural
Engineer in the State of
California
• ICC certified Plans
Examiner
Background
Gene
Mr. Hadidi is a highly respected structural engineer. He has over 30 years in structural plan check and structural design field. With a Ph.D. degree is structural Engineering from Stanford University and many years of experience designing the full range of structures including complex building and structures. He also has years of experience in structural review of variety of buildings and structures.
Select Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Senior Structural Plan Review Engineer
Provide structural plan review for various projects. Review projects including single family/duplex residential construction, multifamily residential construction, commercial construction, and non-building structures. Review and evaluate architectural and
structural construction documents submitted for permit approval from various municipalities utilizing applicable codes/standards/guidelines/laws, code interpretation, appropriate municipal ordinances and construction and engineering standards; interact and communicate with design professionals and city staff on technical requirements and plan review comments; provide technical assistance to city staff; perform structural inspections in the field as needed; determine valuation and building fees; check calculations and test reports; provide assistance and information to contractors, architects, engineers and the public in the solution of complex building problems and the interpretation of building codes, structural standards and ordinances.
Henry is the go-to Structural Plan Review Engineer for complex structures and challenging issues.
Various Public Agencies
Structural Plan Review Engineer
Provided structural plan review for many state agencies such as DSA, DGS, LAUSD throughout California. Projects reviewed included
the seismic retrofit of two reinforced
concrete building at Atascadero State Hospital in Atascadero, of numerous hospital buildings as part of plan check review for OSHPD, Westinghouse AP 1000 nuclear power plants, the design of a segment of the Los Angeles Metropolitan Purple Line underground metro tunnel in Los Angeles, California, as part of LA Metro internal review, seismic retrofit of the Caltrans Headquarters buildings located at Sacramento, California.
Owen Group
Structural Engineer
Provided structural analysis and design for variety of buildings and structures, ranging from single family residential to multi-story apartment, commercial buildings.
Exhibit D36
285
32 Allen Lang, PE, SE
Structural Plan Review Engineer
Education
M.S. Degree – Structural
Engineering
University of Virginia
B.S. Degree - Civil
Engineering
Taiwan Municipal College
Licenses and
Certifications
• Licensed Structural
Engineer in the State of
California
• Licensed Engineer in the
State of California
• ICC Certified Plan
Examiner
Background
Allen is a seasoned engineer and building official with extensive experience in all aspects of building department functions. Highly technical expertise in structural engineering of complex buildings. Building Official for many local cities in the Bay Area. Provides technical support and training to staff and clients.
Select Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Structural Review Engineer
Provide structural plan review for various projects. Review projects including single family/duplex residential construction, multifamily residential construction, commercial construction, and non-building structures. Review and evaluate architectural and structural construction documents submitted for permit approval from various municipalities utilizing applicable codes/standards/guidelines/laws, code interpretation, appropriate municipal ordinances and construction and engineering standards; interact and communicate with design professionals and city staff on technical requirements and plan review comments; provide technical assistance to city staff; perform structural inspections in the field as needed; determine valuation and building fees; check calculations and test reports; provide assistance and information to contractors, architects, engineers and the public in the solution of complex building problems and the interpretation of building codes, structural standards and ordinances.
City of Santa Clara
Interim Building Official
Plan, organize and maintain the daily operation of the Building Department. Managed 36 people in the Permit Center, plan check, inspections, and code enforcement.
Participated in preliminary, plan review and preconstruction for high profile projects.
City of Fremont
Special Program Manager Community Development Department
Managing Plan Check division in Plans and Permit and developing special programs and processes improvements for the City.
County of Alameda
Building Official
Managing the Building Department including permit center, plan check, inspection, and code enforcement with an annual budget of over $3M and a staff of 17. Serve as technical advisor to the County Board of Supervisors. Led many initiatives to improve and streamline service and automate the permitting process.
City of San Jose
Department of Building & Planning Program Manager
Managed a special program to assist applicants for over the counter projects to improve service and expedite review and permitting. Prior to that, managed plan review team, assigned work and evaluated performance of staff. Conducted plan review of complex projects and interacted with designers and applicants.
Exhibit D37
286
Daniel H. Lee, S.E.
Senior Structural Plan Review Engineer
Education
B.S. Degree – Civil
Engineering
University of California
Berkeley
Licenses and
Certifications
• Structural Engineer in
California & Hawaii
• Civil Engineer in
California & Hawaii
• ICC Certified Building
Official
• ICC Building Plans
Examiner
Background
30 years of expertise as a technical expert. Planned, assigned, and directed the work of plan check engineers. Consulted with contractors, architects, and building owners regarding application of building codes and other state and local ordinances.
Performed structural damage assessments and feasibility studies. Researched and determined acceptability of new materials and methods of construction. Seismic design in structural engineering consulting firms. Structural plan review in California and Hawaii building departments. Responsible for plan review of complex and challenging building.
Select Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Structural Plan Review Engineer
Provide structural plan review for various projects. Review projects including single family/duplex residential construction, multifamily residential construction, commercial construction, and non-building structures. Review and evaluate architectural and structural construction documents submitted for permit approval from various municipalities utilizing applicable codes/standards/guidelines/laws, code interpretation, appropriate municipal ordinances and construction and engineering standards; interact and communicate with design professionals and city staff on technical requirements and plan review comments; provide technical assistance to city staff; perform structural inspections in the field as needed; determine valuation and building fees; check calculations and test reports; provide assistance and information to contractors, architects, engineers and the public in the solution of complex building problems and the interpretation of building codes, structural standards and ordinances.
County of Hawaii -Department of Public Work
Structural Engineer
Responsible for the structural plan review and approval of all complex residential and commercial buildings on the Island of Hawaii. Provide code interpretations and engineered solutions/technical responses to architects, engineers, drafting personnel, contractors, and owners. Conduct in-house and public (island-wide) training seminars on local building codes and other engineering/field-inspection related topics as needed.
Perform the structural design of minor County-funded buildings and structures. Work closely with County building inspectors to ensure buildings are constructed in conformance with the plans & create County standard designs for the public.
Bureau Veritas North America Inc.
Consultant
Senior Structural Engineer and plan review specialist. Responsible for the structural plan review of high-rise, commercial, and residential buildings (See Major USA Plan Review Projects on page 1 for some recent projects) - Third party plan reviewer for the
City and County of Honolulu.
City of Dana Point
Senior Structural Engineer
Served as a division head within Building and Safety. Reviewed designs and checked calculations for complex custom-built residential homes, commercial buildings, and earth-retaining structures. Directed and supervised inspection staff in resolving difficult field problems. Coordinated and expedited plan check activities with other departments and outside agencies. Prepared technical guidelines/manuals and provided training to the staff and public. Created city standard designs as needed.
Exhibit D38 287
City of Huntington Beach
Senior Plan Check Engineer
Reviewed architectural and structural designs (plans and specifications) from a life safety and engineering standpoint to ensure compliance with all applicable codes and regulations for fire and life safety, structural integrity, disabled access, energy and utilities requirements. Worked effectively and sensitively in teams and with government counterparts. Provided information and solutions to developers, architects, engineers, contractors, and owners regarding matters such as design, engineering, and regulations governing building plans and construction. Supervised the Permit and Plan Check Services Division in the absence of the Division Head/ Manager.
City of Long Beach
Civil Plan Check Engineer
Performed building, structural, and life safety design reviews of commercial, industrial, and residential buildings per uniform codes, state of California regulations, and local ordinances. Presented departmental reports at monthly community development program meetings. Enforced city environmental codes of practice.
Evaluated the performance of consultant engineers. Conducted training seminar to the inspection/engineering staff.
Exhibit D39
288
Hamid Irannejad, S.E., P.E.
Senior Structural Plan Review Engineer
Education
M.S. Degree & B.S Degree–
Structural/Civil Engineering
University of Akron
Licenses and
Certifications
• Licensed Structural
Engineer in the State of
California
Background
Gene
Hamid has a Master of Science degree in Civil/Structural Engineering and a Bachelor of Science degree in Civil Engineering. Hamid has over 25 years of plan check experience as the Lead Senior Structural Engineer/ managing the day-to-day operations of the Structural Plan Check Discipline, Senior/supervising Structural Engineer and Associate/plan check Engineer with the City of San Diego Development Services Department. In San Diego, Hamid oversaw review of major projects such as mid-rise and high-rise residential and commercial buildings as well as many other types of complex structures and occupancies. Hamid has over 14 years of structural design experience of residential and commercial buildings and other structures including 8 years of structural design of steel and concrete-framed high- rise buildings with CBM Engineers, Inc. in Houston, Texas. Hamid provides structural plan check on major buildings. He is a licensed Structural and Civil Engineer in the State of California.
Select Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Structural Plan Review Engineer
Provide structural plan review for various projects. Review projects including single family/duplex residential construction, multifamily residential construction, commercial construction, and non-building structures. Review and evaluate architectural and
structural construction documents submitted for permit approval from various municipalities utilizing applicable codes/standards/guidelines/laws, code interpretation, appropriate municipal ordinances and construction and engineering standards; interact and communicate with design professionals and city staff on technical requirements and plan review comments; provide technical assistance to city staff; perform structural inspections in the field as needed; determine valuation and building fees; check calculations and test reports; provide assistance and information to contractors, architects, engineers and the public in the solution of complex building problems and the interpretation of building codes, structural standards and ordinances.
City of San Diego
Senior Structural Engineer
As a Senior Structural Engineer with City of San Diego, Development Services Department, Mr. Zamani is responsible to supervise team of up to six Associates and Assistants Structural Engineers to review architectural, structural plans, structural calculations and construction specifications to verify their conformance and compliance with current California Building Codes (CBC) and local amendments for Life Safety, Structural, and Disabled Access requirements. He is also responsible to provide preliminary reviews and code interpretations for large and complex projects prior to their full submittal for plan check.
City of San Diego
Structural Engineer Associate
As a Structural Engineer Associate with City of San Diego Development Services Department, He was responsible to review architectural, structural, plans, structural calculations and specifications to verify their conformance and compliance with current CBC and local amendments for Life Safety, Structural, and Disabled Access requirements.
Exhibit D40 289
CBM Engineers
Structural Design Engineer
Provided structural analysis and design for all type’s buildings and structures, ranging from single family residential to multi-story apartment, commercial buildings. Hamid has over 14 years of structural design experience of residential and commercial buildings and other structures including 8 years of structural design of steel and concrete-framed high-rise buildings with CBM Engineers, Inc. in Houston, Texas.
Exhibit D41
290
36 Edward Alexanians, P.E., S.E.
Senior Structural Plan Review Engineer
Education
M.S Degree -Structural
Engineering
UCLA
M.S Degree -Structural
Engineering
Tehran University
Licenses and
Certifications
• Licensed Professional
Engineer in the State of
California
• Licensed Structural
Engineer in the State of
California
Background
Ge ne
Ed is an accomplished and highly respected structural engineer. He has over 30 years in structural plan check and structural design field. He has designed or reviewed thousands of projects over his career including high rise buildings, hotels, mixed-use buildings with subterranean garage, concrete parking structures, university projects and man y others.
He specializes in complex and unique structural projects. S amples of complex projects reviewed by Ed included : The Burbank Studios high-rise concrete office buildings, four high-rise buildings with parking structure in the City of Burbank, Waldorf Astoria, a thirteen-story concrete hotel in Beverly Hills, nine-story office and dorm and a five-story hotel in El Segundo, nine and seven-story office buildings in Burbank, three-story hotel conversion into condominiums in Hancock Park, multi-unit apartment buildings with subterranean garage, Chase Bank building and a multi-s tory mixed used occupancy building, five-story post tension concrete open parking structure in the City of Alhambra, two high-rise buildings in Beverly Hills, several Cal State university facilities
Select Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Senior Structural Plan Review Engineer
Provide structural plan review for various projects. Review projects including single family/duplex residential construction, multifamily residential construction, commercial construction, and non-building structures. Review and evaluate architectural and
structural construction documents submitted for permit approval from various municipalities utilizing applicable codes/standards/guidelines/laws, code interpretation, appropriate municipal ordinances and construction and engineering standards; interact and communicate with design professionals and city staff on technical requirements and plan review comments; provide technical assistance to city staff; perform structural inspections in the field as needed; determine valuation and building fees; check calculations and test reports; provide assistance and information to contractors, architects, engineers and the public in the solution of complex building problems and the interpretation of building codes, structural standards and ordinances.
County of Los Angeles
Office Manager
Supervision of plan checking, permitting and inspection services for the South Whittier District Office and two contract cities of La Mirada and Santa Fe Springs. Supervision of the plan check engineers, permit technicians and inspectors. Interpretation of the Building Code requirements and conflict resolution between the public and office staff.
Responding to the Board of Supervisors' inquiries about the area’s issues.
County of Los Angeles
Supervising Civil Engineer
Senior plan check engineer, responsible for review of co mplex structures, high-rise and mid-rise buildings, amusement rides at the Universal and Six-Flags Magic Mountain and earthquake damaged buildings for the Los Angeles County Building Code compliance. A team member for damage assessment of several buildings after the Los Angeles riots and the 1994 Northridge Earthquake.
Frank Lucas & Assoc.
Design Structural Engineer
Design of a variety of structures and buildings throughout the region.
Exhibit D42
291
Scot Weisse, P.E.
Senior Plan Review Engineer
Education
B.S. Degree- Architectural
Engineering- California
Polytechnical University, San
Luis Obispo
Licenses and
Certifications
• Licensed Engineer in the
State of California
• CA Commercial Building
Plans Examiner
Background
California Licensed Civil Engineer with nineteen years of experience in structural engineering, construction, and plan review of the entire range of construction projects.
Areas of expertise include structural engineering and plan checking complex commercial and residential projects. Detail-oriented and analytical professional with an efficient and thorough approach. Proficient licensed plans check engineer who is knowledgeable about current codes and their effective interpretation.
Select Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Plan Review Engineer
Perform plan review of the entire range of residential, commercial and industrial projects; examine and check structural engineering designs, calculations and plans for conformance with adopted Building Codes and local ordinance and regulations; perform plan review of electrical, mechanical and plumbing projects for conformance with the Mechanical Code, Plumbing Code and National Electrical Code and local ordinances and regulations; provide interpretations of building codes, State laws and local ordinances to city staff and the public; evaluate alternate methods of construction/materials and provides recommendations; provide technical assistance to city staff; check plans for compliance with California Title 24, Energy and Disabled Access Requirements; maintain liaison with city staff related to project reviews and code compliance.
City of Ventura
Supervising Plan Check Engineer
Manage the plan check and permit counter operations for the city. Plan check architectural & structural plans for large, medium, & small sized residential & commercial projects. Enforce all applicable building codes including fire, life safety, and accessibility requirements. Coordinate a smooth process between clients and the City to ensure great customer service in meeting code requirements per the Building Code. Advised and interpreted codes to homeowners, business owners, laymen, contractors, architects, and the public; and coordinated inspection activities and the construction progress with other City departments and outside agencies as needed.
Mentored and supervise colleagues to improve their skills and education by providing technical knowledge; served as acting building official in the absence of the building official
Li & Associates
Senior Design Engineer
Served as lead engineer / project manager for multiple projects; met with clients, architects, contractors and building officials; designed simple to large residential and commercial projects including complex lateral and gravity systems; developed plans and details for construction; construction administration; managed project budgets and time schedules; delegating work to draftsmen and other engineers.
Exhibit D43
292
Robert Chun, P.E.
Senior Plan Review Engineer
Education
B.S. Degree - Civil
Engineering
University of California-
Berkeley
M.S. Degree - Civil
Engineering
San Jose State University
Licenses and
Certifications
• Licensed Engineer in the
State of California
Background
Highly accomplished Professional Engineer who is effective at reviewing the entire range of residential and commercial plans for compliance with applicable building codes. Detail-oriented and analytical professional with an efficient and thorough approach. Proficient licensed plans check engineer who is knowledgeable about current codes and their effective interpretation.
Select Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Plan Review Engineer
Perform plan review of the entire range of residential, commercial and industrial projects; examine and check structural engineering designs, calculations and plans for conformance with adopted Building Codes and local ordinance and regulations; perform plan review of electrical, mechanical and plumbing projects for conformance with the Mechanical Code, Plumbing Code and National Electrical Code and local ordinances and regulations; provide interpretations of building codes, State laws and local ordinances to city staff and the public; evaluate alternate methods of construction/materials and provides recommendations; provide technical assistance to city staff; perform structural inspections in the field as needed; determine valuation and building fees; check calculations and test reports; provide assistance and information to contractors, architects, engineers and the public in the solution of routine building problems and the interpretation of building codes and ordinances; check plans for compliance with California Title 24, Energy and Disabled Access Requirements; maintain liaison with city staff related to project reviews and code compliance.
City and County of San Francisco- Department of Building Inspection Senior Plan Check Engineer
Plan check architectural & structural plans for large, medium, & small sized residential & commercial projects. Enforce all applicable building codes including fire, life safety, and accessibility requirements. Coordinate a smooth process between clients and the City to ensure great customer service in meeting code requirements per the Building Code. Advised and interpreted codes to homeowners, business owners, laymen, contractors, architects, and the public; and coordinated inspection activities and the construction progress with other City departments and outside agencies as needed. Mentored and supervise colleagues to improve their skills and education by providing technical knowledge. Managed the City’s Soft Story Program.
Exhibit D44
293
Bachar Koujah, P.E., CASp
Senior Plan Review Engineer
Education
B.S. Degree -Civil
Engineering
M.S. Degree - Structural
Engineering
Licenses and
Certifications
• Licensed Engineer in the
State of California
• CASp
• Building Inspector
Background
Over 25 years experience as a plan check engineer. Highly accomplished Professional Engineer and CASp who is effective at reviewing the entire range of residential and commercial plans for compliance with applicable building codes. Detail-oriented and analytical professional with an efficient and thorough approach. Proficient licensed plans check engineer who is knowledgeable about current codes and their effective interpretation.
Select Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Plan Review Engineer
Perform plan review of the entire range of residential, commercial and industrial projects; examine and check structural engineering designs, calculations and plans for conformance with adopted Building Codes and local ordinance and regulations; perform plan review of electrical, mechanical and plumbing projects for conformance with the Mechanical Code, Plumbing Code and National Electrical Code and local ordinances and regulations; provide interpretations of building codes, State laws and local ordinances to city staff and the public; evaluate alternate methods of construction/materials and provides recommendations; provide technical assistance to city staff; perform CASp plan reviews and inspections and prepare CASp reports as needed; check plans for compliance with California Title 24, Energy and Disabled Access Requirements; maintain liaison with city staff related to project reviews and code compliance.
Bureau Veritas
Plan Review Engineer
Combination plan review engineer for the full range of construction projects for conformance with adopted Building Codes and local ordinance and regulations; performed plan review of electrical, mechanical and plumbing projects for conformance with the Mechanical Code, Plumbing Code and National Electrical Code and local ordinances and regulations; served as in-house plan check engineer at the City of Corona; provided technical assistance to city staff; performed CASp plan reviews and inspections.
City of Irvine
Senior Plan Check Engineer
Plan review of architectural & structural plans for large, medium, & small sized residential & commercial projects. Enforce all applicable building codes including fire, life safety, and accessibility requirements. Coordinate a smooth process between clients and the City to ensure great customer service in meeting code requirements per the Building Code. Advised and interpreted codes to homeowners, business owners, laymen, contractors, architects, and the public; and coordinated inspection activities and the construction progress with other City departments and outside agencies as needed. Mentored and supervise colleagues to improve their skills and education by providing technical knowledge.
City of Riverside
Plan Review Engineer
Plan review of architectural & structural plans for large, medium, & small sized residential & commercial projects. Enforced all applicable building codes including fire, life safety, and accessibility requirements. Coordinated a smooth process between clients and the City to ensure great customer service in meeting code requirements per the Building Code.
Exhibit D45 294
39 47
Exhibit D46
295
Kylie Gonsalves, PE
Plan Review Engineer
Education
B.S. Degree - Civil
Engineering
California Polytechnical
University- Pomona
Licenses and
Certifications
• Licensed Engineer in the
State of California
Accomplishments
· Chi Epsilon; Civil
Engineering Honor Society
· Cum Laude
Background
Highly accomplished Professional Engineer with over 8 years of experience as a plan check engineer. Highly competent at reviewing residential and commercial plans for compliance with applicable building codes. Detail -oriented and analytical professional with an efficient and thorough approach. Proficient licensed plans examiner who is k nowledgeable about current codes and their effective interpretation.
Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Plan Review Engineer
Perform plan review of the entire range of residential, commercial and industrial projects; examine and check structural engineering designs, calculations and plans for conformance with adopted Building Codes and local ordinance and regulations; perform plan review of electrical, mechanical and plumbing projects for conformance with the Mechanical Code, Plumbing Code and National Electrical Code and local ordinances and regulations; provide interpretations of building codes, State laws and local ordinances to city staff and the public; provide technical assistance to city staff; check plans for compliance with California Title 24, Energy and Disabled Access Requirements; maintain liaison with city staff related to project reviews and code compliance.
CSG
Plan Review Engineer
Reviewed Architectural, Structural, Mechanical, Electrical and Plumbing drawings for code compliance and structural integrity on behalf of various jurisdictions/agencies; provided in-house and over-the-counter review services for the Cities of Redlands and Huntington Beach.
Exhibit D47
296
40 Alaa Atassi
Senior Plans Examiner
Education
M.S. Degree – Structural
Engineering
San Francisco State University
B.S. Degree - Civil
Engineering
San Francisco State University
Certifications
• ICC Certified Commercial
Plan Examiner
• ICC Certified Commercial
Inspector
Background
Experienced Plans Examiner and Engineer who is effective at reviewing residential and commercial plans for compliance with applicable building codes. Detail-oriented and analytical professional with an efficient and thorough approach. Proficient certified plans examiner who is knowledgeable about current codes and their effective interpretation.
Select Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Senior Plans Examiner
Perform plan review of the entire range of residential, commercial and industrial projects; examine and check structural engineering designs, calculations and plans for conformance with adopted Building Codes and local ordinance and regulations; perform plan review of electrical, mechanical and plumbing projects for conformance with the Mechanical Code, Plumbing Code and National Electrical Code and local ordinances and regulations; provide interpretations of building codes, State laws and local ordinances to city staff and the public; provide technical assistance to city staff; perform structural inspections in the field as needed; determine valuation and building fees; check calculations and test reports; provide assistance and information to contractors, architects, engineers and the public in the solution of routine building problems and the interpretation of building codes and ordinances; check plans for compliance with California Title 24, Energy and Disabled Access Requirements; assist contractors, architects, engineers and others in the solution of complex code issues; maintain liaison with city staff related to project reviews and code compliance.
WC3
Plans Examiner
Performed plan review of architectural & structural plans for large, medium, & small sized residential & commercial projects; Enforced all applicable building codes including fire, life safety, and accessibility requirements; Assisted contractors, architects, engineers and others in the solution of complex structural, mechanical, electrical and related problems with interpretation of the building codes and ordinances; Maintained cooperation with other departments concerned with building and related code compliance; Performed structural inspections in the field as required.
Engineering Intern
City of South San Francisco Public Works,
Engineering Division
Supported city engineers on daily tasks, related to transportation, construction, public works and city streets for the City of South San Francisco.
Exhibit D48
297
41 Bryan Montes, EIT
Plan Review Engineer
Education
B.S. Degree – Civil
Engineering
UC- Irvine University
Licenses and
Certifications
• Engineer-in-Training (EIT)
• ICC-Certified Residential
Plans Examiner
Skills & Awards
• UCI Dean’s Structural
Engineering Senior Design
Choice Award
• Computer Literate: MS
Word, Excel, PowerPoint,
Pages, Keynote;
MATLAB, AutoCAD,
Bluebeam, Sketch-up,
Stella, EPANet
Background
Over 3 years of experience in the plan review of a wide range of structures and building from residential and commercial projects and tenant improvements. Pleasant and customer service oriented professional with a helpful can-do attitude. Team player with an enthusiastic attitude. Versed in multiple permitting software and computer systems.
Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Plan Review Engineer
Provide plan review for various projects. Review projects including single family/duplex residential construction, multifamily residential construction, commercial construction, and non-building structures. Review and evaluate architectural and structural construction documents submitted for permit approval from various municipalities utilizing applicable codes/standards/guidelines/laws, code interpretation, appropriate municipal ordinances and construction and engineering standards; interact and communicate with design professionals and city staff on technical requirements and plan review comments; provide technical assistance to city staff; perform structural inspections in the field as needed; determine valuation and building fees; check calculations and test reports; provide assistance and information to contractors, architects, engineers and the public in the solution of complex building problems and the interpretation of building codes, structural standards and ordinances.
Currently, Bryan provides in-house plan review services to the Cities of Dana Point and Santa Monica. He performs over-the-counter plan reviews, assists applicants with code compliance questions, and reviews rechecks, field changes and revisions.
Interwest Consulting Group
Engineering Plans Examiner
Perform comprehensive and complete reviews of reside ntial projects, including for Building & Life Safety, M/E/P, CalGREEN, and Energy Conservation Requirements; Review calculations, specifications, and technical reports to determine compliance with the applicable building codes and standards for different jurisdictions; Conduct structural plan reviews for residential and commercial p rojects including single family dwellings, tract homes, high-pile storage racks, temporary stages, etc.; Serve the City of El Monte as its only in-house plan check engineer performing the aforementioned duties as well as answering and assisting any inquiries from the public over-the-counter.
City of Eastville, City of Bell
City Engineer Intern
Served as the principal assistant responsible for collecting, transferring, and organizing necessary data on to the newly implemented Survey 123 for ArcGIS, a form-centric data gathering system; Worked with city engineers, public works, and building & safety on various projects that would positively impact the city; Under direction, carried out site inspections and conducted field assessments.
Exhibit D49
298
42 Areli Sanchez
Plan Review Engineer
Education
B.S. Degree – Civil
Engineering
San Francisco State University
Certifications
• ICC-Certified Building
Plans Examiner
Skills & Awards
• Computer Literate: MS
Word, Excel, PowerPoint,
Pages, Viewpoint,
Plangrid, MATLAB,
AutoCAD, Bluebeam
Background
Over 3 years of experience in the plan review of a wide range of structures and building from residential and commercial projects and tenant improvements. Pleasant and customer service oriented professional with a helpful can-do attitude. Team player with an enthusiastic attitude. Versed in multiple permitting software and computer systems.
Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Plan Review Engineer
Areli provides plan review for various projects. Review projects including single family/duplex residential construction, multifamily residential construction, commercial construction, and non-building structures. Review and evaluate architectural and structural construction documents submitted for permit approval from various municipalities utilizing applicable codes/standards/guidelines/laws, code interpretation, appropriate municipal ordinances and construction and engineering standards; interact and communicate with design professionals and city staff on technical requirements and plan review comments; provide technical assistance to city staff; perform structural inspections in the field as needed; determine valuation and building fees; check calculations and test reports; provide assistance and information to contractors, architects, engineers and the public in the solution of complex building problems and the interpretation of building codes, structural standards and ordinances.
West Coast Code Consultants
Engineering Plans Examiner
Perform comprehensive and complete reviews of reside ntial projects, including for Building & Life Safety, M/E/P, CalGREEN, and Energy Conservation Requirements; Review calculations, specifications, and technical reports to determine compliance with the applicable building codes and standards for different jurisdictions; Conduct structural plan reviews for residential and commercial p rojects including single family dwellings, tract homes, high-pile storage racks, temporary stages, etc.; Serve the City of El Monte as its only in-house plan check engineer performing the aforementioned duties as well as answering and assisting any inquiries from the public over-the-counter.
Cahill Contractors
Project Engineering Intern
Handled RFIs and field changes; meeting coordination, quality control on construction projects; safety inspections; under direction, carried out site inspections and conducted field assessments.
Exhibit D50
299
Richard Moreno
Plan Review Engineer
Education
B.S. Degree – Civil
Engineering
San Diego State University
Certifications
• ICC-Certified
Building Plans
Examiner
Skills & Awards
• ICC San Diego Chapter
Evaluation Chairman
• ICC San Digo Energy
and CalGreen
Committee Secretary
• Computer Literate:
MS Word, Excel,
PowerPoint,
AutoCAD, Bluebeam
Background
Over 7 years of experience in the plan review of a wide range of structures and building from residential and commercial projects and tenant improvements. Pleasant and customer service oriented professional with a helpful can-do attitude. Team player with an enthusiastic attitude. Versed in multiple permitting software and computer systems.
Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Plan Review Engineer
Richard provides plan review for various projects. Review projects including single family/duplex residential construction, multifamily residential construction, commercial construction, and non-building structures. Review and evaluate architectural and structural construction documents submitted for permit approval from various municipalities utilizing applicable codes/standards/guidelines/laws, code interpretation, appropriate municipal ordinances and construction and engineering standards; interact and communicate with design professionals and city staff on technical requirements and plan review comments; provide technical assistance to city staff; perform structural inspections in the field as needed; determine valuation and building fees; check calculations and test reports; provide assistance and information to contractors, architects, engineers and the public in the solution of complex building problems and the interpretation of building codes, structural standards and ordinances.
EsGil/Interwest
Senior Plans Examiner
Perform comprehensive and complete reviews of residential projects, including for Building & Life Safety, M/E/P, CalGREEN, and Energy Conservation Requirements ; Review calculations, specifications, and technical reports to determine compliance with the applicable building codes and standards for different jurisdictions ; Conduct structural plan reviews for residential and commercial projects including single family dwellings, tract homes, etc.; Served multiple cities in the San Diego region.
Exhibit D51 300
45 Timothy M. Shell, PE
Senior Civil Engineer
Education
B.S. Degree - Civil
Engineering
MBA- Government
Management
Licenses and
Certifications
• Licensed Civil Engineer in
the State of California
Background
Tim has 25+ years of broad experience in funding, planning, designing, permitting, and constructing municipal public works improvements, including coordination with Caltrans, San Diego Association of Governments, County of San Diego, North County Transit District, franchise utility companies, and other local municipal agencies and special districts. 1 0 years with the City of Vista, 9 years with the San Diego Water Authority and many years as a design civil engineer with design firms in Southern California. Tim also served as staff augmentation in the City of Lake Elsinore in the 90s.
Select Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Senior Civil Engineer
Review engineering cost estimates; storm water projects; Compliance with Current NPDES Permits; Water Quality Management Plans; transportation projects, grading plans and other assignments as necessary. Tim prepares, implements, and manages capital improvement plans and prepares plans, specifications and cost estimates for variety of municipal projects. He also serves as project manager or construction manager for municipal projects.
City of Vista
Principal Engineer
Manages consultant and construction con
tracts for the city’s Capital Improvement
Program, serving the Streets Section of the Public Works Department, the Parks and Recreation Department, and the Sanitation and Stormwater Sections of the Public Works Department. Prepares plans, specifications, and estimates for variety of municipal public works projects, for transportation, drainage, parks, and facilities.
San Diego County Water Authority
Senior Civil Engineer
Managed consultant and construction contracts for large waterworks facilities providing wholesale water supplies to member agencies in San Diego County.
Provided studies, reports, and designs for System Operation upgrades and modifications.
BSI Consultants, Inc. San Diego, CA
Associate Civil Engineer
Prepared plans, specifications, and estimates for variety of municipal clients, for transportation, waterworks, drainage, and sanitation facilities. Served as design team leader. Prepared Engineer’s Reports and provided cost analysis for Assessment District
s. Provided staff augmentation managing capital projects at cities of Santee and Lake Elsinore, and single-family private developments at cities of Lake Elsinore and Canyon Lake.
Exhibit D52
301
47 Jamal Naji, PE
Senior Civil Engineer
Education
B.S. Degree - Civil
Engineering
SDSU
Licenses and
Certifications
• Licensed Civil Engineer in
the State of California
Background
Over 30 years extensive experience in the Civil Engineering discipline that includes Wastewater and Land Development. Considerable experience in designing and inspecting construction of pipelines, wastewater facilities, grading, and flood control channels. Reviewed subdivision, grading and street improvement plans in accordance with the State of California Subdivision Map Act, and the City of Chula Vista and County of San Diego ordinances and policies. Taught workshop on reading grading and topographic maps to various departments in the County of San Diego. Performed field review and prepared conditions for Tentative Parcel Map Resolution
Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Civil Engineer
Jamal leads major reviews for the team; he provides quality control and technical support to our team; he performs complex plan review of improvement plans, documents, and technical studies including: Rough and Precise Grading Plans; Wet Utility Plans (e.g. Sewer, Water, Recycled Water, Storm Drain); Street Improvement Plans; Hydrology Studies and Hydraulic Calculations; Water Quality Management Plans (WQMPs); Water Quality reports; Erosion Control Plans and Engineering Cost Estimates; Reviews studies and inspects wastewater facilities, sewer lines, flood control channels and building projects and performs feasibility studies for wastewater treatment plants and pump stations.
City of Chula Vista – Department of Public Works
Associate Civil Engineer
Wastewater Management
Project Manager for capital improvement projects that included pipe rehabilitation projects using micro-tunneling, pipe bursting, pipe lining and slip-lining technologies; Managed and coordinated Industrial Waste Program with the City of San Diego Wastewater Pretreatment Program; Prepared Requests for Proposal and executed contracts for designing Salt Creek Sewer Trunk project (over $20 million project); coordinated and managed sewer capacity agreements between the City of Chula Vista and the County of San Diego. Coordinated wastewater projects with Field Operations and Engineering Design Divisions; Designed and inspected grading, wastewater facilities, sewer lines, flood control channels and building projects; Prepared project specifications and plans using AutoCAD and WordPerfect software for wastewater facilities; Prepared operation & maintenance manuals, and feasibility studies for wastewater treatment plants and pump stations.
Land Development
Reviewed subdivision, grading and street improvement plans in accordance with the State of California Subdivision Map Act, and the City of Chula Vista and County of San Diego ordinances and policies; Taught workshop on reading grading and topographic maps to various departments in the County of San Diego; Performed field review and prepared conditions for Tentative Parcel Map Resolution; Established an inspection program on borrow pit operations in the County of San Diego.
Geotechnical Engineering
Performed soil tests in accordance with the American Standard for Testing Materials Specifications.
Exhibit D53
302
49 49
Exhibit D54
303
Hassan Itani, PE
M/P Plan Review Engineer
Education
B.S. Degree – Mechanical
Engineering
California State Polytechnic
University, Pomona
Licenses and
Certifications
• Licensed Engineer,
Mechanical
• ICC -Certified Mechanical
Plans Examiner
Background
Hassan is a highly qualified plan review engineer and design engineer with over 8 years of experience in the review and design of heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC), plumbing systems for compliance with local and state codes and energy standards. He has knowledge and experience in large scale alternative energy generation plants. Hassan has a strong background in project management and evaluation of existing HVAC/MEP systems.
Select Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Mechanical/Plumbing Plan Review Engineer
Provide plan review and field investigations for compliances with mechanical and plumbing codes and standards and review of energy compliance documents (Title 24) for wide range of construction projects ranging from residential additions to new high- rise buildings, hotels, malls, large public facilities, hazardous occupancies, R&D, and Biotech Facilities.
City of Los Angeles
Mechanical Engineering Associate II
Review of plumbing, mechanical, heating, ventilation, and air-conditioning (HVAC), as well as electrical building plans of commercial, multi-family and industrial for compliances with mechanical, plumbing, and electrical codes, and standards. Review of energy compliance documents. Provide information on codes and regulations to engineers, architects, and contractors. Resolve issues between the field inspectors and contractors. Perform calculations for ventilation, mechanical equipment, piping, wiring, and load verifications.
Boeing
Fleet System Engineer
Monitor multiple airplane fleets and provide targeted maintenance recommendations for critical faults, enabling real-time situational awareness of in-flight Boeing airplanes; work directly with airlines to help improve reliability metrics by implementing prognostic alerting systems.
Applied Medical
Mechanical Engineering Intern
Assisted in developing and testing Kii Dissecting Balloon, promoting its reliability in the field to expedite product release; collaborated with senior engineers in product development to revise manufacturing process and equipment maintenance schedules to increase efficiency; sole generator of maintenance manuals, installation, operational, and performance qualification reports to document product progress; meeting FDA requirements in case of audit.
Exhibit D55
304
50 Amir Amiri, P.E.
Electrical Plan Review Engineer
Education
B.S. Degree – Electrical
Engineering
CAL State University,
Northridge
Licenses and
Certifications
• Licensed Engineer in the
State of California
Background
Amir has over 20 years of diverse experience in the electrical engineering construction design and plan review for a variety of construction projects ranging from TIs to complex occupancies, high rise buildings, high voltage systems and sub-stations. He reviews complex building plans for conformance to applicable electrical regulations and calculates electrical adequacy; prepares reports and written recommendations and coordinates construction activities with other agencies and citizen groups.
Select Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Electrical Plan Review Engineer
Provide plan review and field investigations for compliances with the National Electrical Code (NEC) and standards and review of energy compliance documents (Title 24) for wide range of construction projects ranging from residential additions to new high-rise buildings, hotels, malls, large public facilities, hazardous occupancies, R&D, and Biotech Facilities. Amir is also our internal expert for high voltage systems and sub-stations and large-scale solar farms.
120 Degreez, Inc.
Senior Electrical Engineer
Performs engineering designs and calculations, prepares plans, estimates, and specifications. Consults with department representatives and other agencies on electrical engineering problems, and checks plans, and specifications developed by consultants. Inspects major electrical or electronic contract work; checks material lists to ensure conformance with specifications; makes field investigations and surveys.
Prepares calculations for photometric, power, and energy studies and load characteristics. Supervise and check the work of subordinate engineers and drafting personnel, drafted and designed power distribution and electrical site plans, panel schedules, and lighting plans per NEC and local codes under engineering supervision.
Performed all aspects of project, including Title 24, load calculation, and single line diagrams.
City of San Diego -Building & Safety
Associate Electrical Engineer
As an electrical plan review engineer, performed plan review of the Electrical Code for
multifamily buildings, hotels, and all type of commercial buildings, including San Diego Convention Center, airport projects, office buildings, city facilities, fire stations, retail buildings, laboratories, restaurants, OSHPD 3 facilities, and industrial buildings.
In addition, assist city inspector with technical questions and day to day field issues for compliance with the National Electrical Code.
Exhibit D56
305
Jerome Schreiber, P.E.
Senior Electrical Plan Review Engineer
Education
B.S. Degree – Electrical
Engineering
CAL Polytechnical University
Licenses and
Certifications
• Licensed Electrical
Engineer in the State of
California
• ICC Certified Building
Inspector
• ICC Certified Mechanical
Inspector
• ICC Certified Plumbing
Inspector
• IAEI Certified Electrical
Inspector
• IAEI Certified Electrical
Plans Examiner
Background
Jerome has over 30 years of diverse experience in the electrical engineering design and plan review for a variety of construction projects ranging from TIs to complex occupancies, high rise buildings, high voltage systems and sub-stations. He reviews complex building plans for conformance to applicable electrical regulations and calculates electrical adequacy; prepares reports and written recommendations and coordinates construction activities with other agencies and citizen groups.
Select Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Electrical Plan Review Engineer
Provides plan review and field investigations for compliances with the National Electrical Code (NEC) and standards and review of energy compliance documents (Title 24) for wide range of construction projects ranging from residential additions to new high-rise buildings, hotels, malls, large public facilities, hazardous occupancies, R&D, and Biotech Facilities. Amir is also our internal expert for high voltage systems and sub-stations and small or large-scale solar farms.
Jerome will provide plan reviews of solar projects submitted to the VPP Program.
City of Glendale
Building Inspector
Performed building, electrical, mechanical and plumbing inspections; performed electrical plan reviews.
City of Vernon
Senior Electrical Inspector
Responsible for City of Vernon Electrical Plans Examination and Building, Plumbing, Mechanical, & Electrical inspections and all electrical installations in the City and for the City municipal facilities.
Southern California Edison
Distribution Engineer
Service Planning and Customer Coordination.
Exhibit D57
306
51 51
Exhibit D58
307
53 Douglas Evans, FPE
Fire Protection Engineer
Education
B.S. Degree – Civil
Engineering
CSULA
Licenses and
Certifications
• Licensed Fire Protection
Engineer -CA, NV
• Member, ICC Fire Code
Interpretation Committee
• Fellow of Society of Fire
Protection Engineers
(SFPE)
• Member of NFPA
Technical Committee on
Smoke Management
Background
Technical expert on all fire protection aspects for the mega-resorts on the Las Vegas Strip. These facilities are essentially “cities under one roof”. His duties included review, comment and approval of fire protection plans on a wide range of issues and occupancy types, for new as well as existing facilities. He has been responsible for malls, atria, theaters, arenas, and mega -resorts, as well as numerous high -rise residential and office towers. He was also responsible for developing fire protection- related policy statements and guidelines for internal and external use.
His experience includes suppression and detection/alarm systems, fire-resistive construction, exiting, elevators, secondary power supplies, fire testing, fire modeling, hazardous materials
and the codes/standards requirements that apply to the specific fire protection aspects. Some of his areas of specialization include: alternates/equivalences (performance-based designs) to prescriptive code requirements, smoke management systems, plastics/ foam plastics as building materials, interior finishes, unique interior features, combustible exterior facades, grease duct enclosures and product listings/applications for use on and within structures.
Mr. Evans has published several articles in trade journals and has given a number of professionally related presentations.
Select Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Fire-Life Safety Plan Review Technical Lead
Performs complex fire safety plan review services for a variety of occupancies, including but not limited to high rise buildings, malls, atria, theaters, arenas, and mega -
resort. Reviews complex fire modeling and alternates/equivalences (performance- based designs) to prescriptive code requirements, smoke management systems, plastics/ foam plastics as building materials, interior finishes, unique interior features, combustible exterior facades, grease duct enclosures and product listings/applications for use on and within structures.
Clark County
Senior Fire Protection Engineer
Performed complex plan review and conducted field construction inspections for new and existing buildings. Conduct field inspections and testing of new and existing fire protection systems. Reviewed blueprints for construction projects, including but not limited to grading plans, fire lane and fire apparatus access roads, fire alarm and detection systems, fire sprinkler and standpipe systems and general fire safety. Overse e
special construction projects and represent the city fire and building department to ensure timely completion of plan review and onsite construction inspections to ensure project completion.
Fire Protection Engineer
Design Engineer
Performed design of complex fire safety systems; examining existing structures to determine if the fire protection aspects were compliant with applicable codes and standards; designing exit systems, specifying fire-resistive aspects of building components; specifying when fire suppression and alarm systems were required; reviewing code requirements and negotiating levels of protection with stakeholders.
Exhibit D59
308
Scot Deal, FPE
Fire Protection Engineer
Education
M.S. Degree – Fire
Protection Engineering
Worcester Polytechnic
Institute
B.S. Degree - Chemical
Engineering
Oregon State University
Licenses and
Certifications
• Licensed Fire Protection
Engineer- CA, TX
• Chartered Engineer in
European Schengen
• Contributor to International
Building Code Council
Interpretations Committee
• Bilingual (English and
Spanish)
Background
Technical expert on all fire protection aspects for complex project. His experience includes suppression and detection/alarm systems, fire-resistive construction, exiting, elevators, secondary power supplies, fire testing, fire modeling, hazardous materials and the codes/standards requirements that apply to the specific fire protection aspects.
Some of his areas of specialization include: alternates/equivalences (performance- based designs) to prescriptive code requirements, smoke management systems, plastics/ foam plastics as building materials, interior finishes, unique interior features, combustible exterior facades, grease duct enclosures and product listings/applications for use on and within structures.
Select Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Senior Fire Protection Engineer
Performs complex fire safety plan review services for a variety of occupancies, including but not limited to high rise buildings, malls, atria, theaters, arenas and mega- resort. Reviews complex fire modeling and alternates/equivalences (performance- based designs) to prescriptive code requirements, smoke management systems, plastics/ foam plastics as building materials, interior finishes, unique interior features, combustible exterior facades, grease duct enclosures and product listings/applications for use on and within structures.
$24 Billion Metro Project
Riyadh Metro Project, Saudi Arabi
Suggest FEED strategies, templates for Alternative Methods approach, Risk evaluation of combustible materials, Hazard likelihoods and local tolerance level, Identify deviations from Employer’s Requirements and prescriptive codes, Value engineering.
Exhibit D60
309
Gabriel Reza
Fire, Life-Safety Plan Reviewer
Education
B.S. Degree – Urban
Planning
Certifications
• Certified Fire
Inspector, NCSA
#CFC040513
• Certified Fire Safety
Officer, Office of the
State Fire Marshal
• Hazardous Waste
Operations and
Emergency Response
Certified
Affiliations
• International Code
Council Los Angeles
Basin Chapter- Fire
Life Safety Chairman
• International Code
Council –
Appreciation Award
• California Building
Officials – 2020
Educator of the Year
• California Fire Chiefs
Association,
Executive Board
Member, SoCal FPO,
President
Background
Extensive experience of over 15 years conducting Title 19/24 fire and life safety inspections. Concise knowledge and experience with California State Fire Codes, local regulations, federal codes, laws and NFPA guidelines. Ability to properly research, interpret and properly apply these related codes.
Comprehensive knowledge of fire detection, sprinkler fire protection and other life safety systems, including NFPA requirements for inspection, installation, testing and evaluation of systems.
Select Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Fire-Life Safety Plan Reviewer
Performs complex fire safety plan review services for a variety of occupancies, including but not limited to public college campuses, mid and high rise buildings, storage buildings, hazardous and high pile storage, multi-family residential use and solar/PV in both new and existing buildings. Reviews blueprints for construction projects, including but not limited to grading plans, fire apparatus access roads, fire alarm and detection systems, fire sprinkler and standpipe systems, and general fire safety. Conducts inspection and testing of fire detection systems including fire sprinklers, fire alarm, standpipe, and wet chemical systems.
City of Glendale
Senior Fire Safety Specialist
Conduct advanced and complex project and blueprint plan review for new construction projects, tenant improvements, fire apparatus access, hazardous material storage and fire detection and fire protection systems; Interpret, apply, and enforce all applicable codes and standards including: Title’s 8, 19/24, CA. Fire, Building and Mechanical Codes, CA. Health and Safety Code and NFPA codes; Sampled and tested hazardous and industrial waste; Performed new construction inspections abiding by standardized methods; Conducted fire prevention training activities for fire department operations; Prepared and maintained precise reports following record-keeping procedures.
City of Glendale
Planning Assistant
Reviewed commercial and single/multi-family projects for zoning code compliance; Processed planning entitlements and housing projects, CEQA review and analysis; Processed and presented applications to the City's Design Review Board, Planning Commission, and City Council.
Exhibit D61
310
Sergio Perreira
Senior Fire-Life Safety Plans Examiner/ Inspector
Education
Fire Prevention Officer –
California State Fire Marshal
Fire Science Degree –
Miramar College
Licenses and
Certifications
• Automatic Fire Alarm -
Association Fire Alarm
Testing & Inspection
• California State Fire
Academy Hydraulics for
Fire Sprinklers
• National Fire Academy -
Management of Fire
Prevention Programs
• National Fire Academy -
Evaluating Performance
Based Designs
• National Fire Sprinkler-
Association Sprinkler
Design Residential to
High-Rise
• National Fire Sprinkler
Association Pumps for Fire
Protection
Background
Sergio has over 30 years of experience in all operations of a fire rescue department, starting in firefighting, then moving to performing plan review and inspections of all types of occupancies and construction projects and Supervising the Plan Check and Inspections for New Construction/Fire Protection Systems.
Extensive knowledge and experience conducting Title 19/24 fire and life safety plan review and inspections of numerous complex projects in the City of San Diego including convention facilities, high rise hotels, biotech research & development companies, research labs and high-tech manufacturing facilities.
Sergio has been a Fire Science Instructor at Miramar and Southwest Community Colleges in San Diego for over 10 years.
Expert in preparing Emergency Preparedness Plans.
Select Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Fire-Life Safety Plan Reviewer/Inspector
Performing complex fire safety plan review & inspection services for a variety of occupancies, including but not limited to public college campus, mid and high rise buildings, storage buildings, hazardous and high pile storage, multi-family residential use and solar/PV in both new and existing buildings. Review fire apparatus access roads, fire alarm and detection systems, fire sprinkler and standpipe systems. Consult on Fire Department management and Emergency management plans.
City of San Diego
Supervisor Plan Check & Inspection for New Construction/Fire Protection Systems
Supervise and train inspectors in plan check of building plans and fire protections system, including fire alarm systems, smoke control, fire pumps, sprinklers, kitchen suppression system, spray paint booths, clean agent systems, fixed and semi-fixed suppression systems for tank farms, standpipe systems including high-rise standpipes.
Develop and update sprinkler policies and many other Fire Prevention polices.
Provided applicability of fire, building and alternate means and methods of fire protection. Conducted new hire interviews. Investigated and made recommendations for disciplinary action. Responsible for supervising inspection teams and approving occupancy of all high-rise construction in previous 15 years and other major projects including the San Diego Convention Center expansion, Petco Park, San Diego County Jail, and airport expansion. Provided solutions for complex problem such as: City Administration Building, Sun Road high-rise, Petco Park, Grant Hyatt, and Hilton explosion.
City of San Diego
Fire Plans Examiner
Plan review for Fire Access and Water Supply for the City of San Diego. Consultant for Project Managers, Architects, Engineers. And Homeowners for Fire Access, Brush Management Mitigation and Fire Code information. Provided training for Electrical and Plumbing inspectors for fire alarm and sprinkler inspections.
Exhibit D62 311
Ron Carter
Fire-Life Plans Examiner/Inspector
Licenses and
Certifications
• Fire Academy -City of San
Diego
• Certified as a Paramedic
through Palomar College
• EMT Certified
• State Fire Marshal,
Certificates in
Fire/Sprinkler and Alarm
plan check
Background
Over 25 years of experience in all operations of a fire rescue department, starting in firefighting/paramedic, then moving to performing plan review and inspection of all types of occupancies and construction projects.
Extensive experience conducting Title 19/24 fire and safety plan review and inspections of numerous complex projects in the City of San Diego including convention facilities, high rise hotel s, biotech research & development companies, research labs and high-tech manufacturing facilities.
Knowledge and experience with California Fire Codes, local regulations, and NFPA guidelines.
Comprehensive knowledge of fire detection, sprinkler fire protec tion and other life safety systems, including NFPA requirements for inspection, installation, testing, and evaluation of systems.
Select Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Fire-Life Safety Plan Reviewer
Performing fire safety plan review services for a variety of occupancies, including but not limited to public college campus, mid and high rise buildings, storage buildings, hazardous and high pile storage, multi-family residential use and solar/PV in both new and existing buildings. Review fire apparatus access roads, fire alarm and detection systems, fire sprinkler and standpipe systems.
City of San Diego
Fire Plans Examiner
Plan review for Fire Access and Water Supply for the City of San Diego. Consultant for Project Managers, Architects, Engineers, and Homeowners for Fire Access, Brush Management Mitigation and Fire Code information. Provided training for Electrical and Plumbing inspectors for fire alarm and sprinkler inspections and performed fire inspections as needed.
City of San Diego
Acting Fire Inspection Supervisor
In addition to Fire Plans Officer and Fire Inspector duties; supervised five Fire Inspectors tasked with all fire plan check and inspections in the City of San Diego.
Section provided plan review and inspections and over the counter schedule for the section. Responsible for Fire Inspector training, performance evaluations and attended Fire management meetings.
City of San Diego
Fire Inspector
Inspection and plan review for all phases of sprinkler/suppression and alarm systems for single use family homes, commercial/high-rise buildings; underground/rough & final. Rotated duties from inspections, plan check and counter plan review.
Responsible for hydrant flow testing and training for new inspectors.
Exhibit D63
312
56 53
Exhibit D64 313
59 54
Exhibit D65 314
Tom Graham
Senior Building Inspector
Certifications
• Building Inspector
• Residential Combination
Inspector
• Mechanical Inspector
UMC
• Plumbing Inspector UPC
Background
Tom is a seasoned and experienced combination building inspector. He is a dedicated professional with strong inter-personal skills and great customer service. He is capable, dependable, detail-oriented, conscientious, courteous, helpful and will look for ways to help customers find solutions during his inspections. He works very well under pressure and in a fast-paced environment. He builds and maintains positive working relationship with peers, management, and customers. He has excellent organizational skills, computer savvy and p roven ability to adhere to the established procedures of the jurisdiction.
Select Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Senior Building Inspector
Tom serves as a True North Compliance Services senior building inspector. He conducts field inspections of variety of construction projects for compliance with the latest edition of the CRC, CBC and other standards and adopted jurisdiction ordinances. He interprets and enforces adopted City codes & ordinance; reviews plans, calculations & specifications; coordinates & schedules daily inspection assignments.
Tom provides technical support to staff/contractors/ clients, trouble-shoots & investigates complaints of code violations.
Contract Inspector
Tom’s duties included performing inspections and providing general support to Building Departments in Southern California. In addition, Tom acted as a liaison with the jurisdictions served. He ensures compliance with the adopted building codes and local regulations and installation of plumbing and HVAC systems in new construction and alterations.
C
ity of Huntington Beach
Inspections Supervisor
As the Inspection Supervisor for the City of Huntington Beach, Tom planed, scheduled, and coordinated the field operations of the building division. He conducted the most complex field inspections of industrial, commercial, and residential buildings during various stages of construction and remodeling. He performed field review of plans and specifications; maintained records and prepared appropriate paperwork, correspondence, records, and reports. He successfully resolved disputes between building division staff and developers, contractors, architects, engineers, and the public. He coordinated final inspections with other departments and agencies and trained inspectors and responded to inspector’s questions and inquires on codes and city regulations and policies.
City of Long Beach
Building Inspector
Tom provided combination inspections on a variety of construction projects ranging from residential remodels to new multi-story office and hotel buildings to verify compliance with adopted codes and standards including Building, MEP, Energy, Accessibility and local ordinances and regulations
Exhibit D66
315
Gerald Vredenburg
Senior Building Inspector
Certifications
• Certified Building
Inspector
• Certified Combination
Dwelling Inspector
Background
Jerry is a seasoned and experienced combination building inspector. He is a dedicated professional with strong inter-personal skills and great customer service. He is capable, dependable, detail-oriented, conscientious, courteous, helpful and wil l look for ways to help customers find solutions during his inspections. He works very well under pressure and in a fast-paced environment. He builds and maintains positive working relationship with peers, management, and customers. He has excellent organizational skills, computer savvy and proven ability to adhere to the established procedures of the jurisdiction.
Select Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Senior Building Inspector
Jerry serves as a True North Compliance Services senior building inspector. He conducts field inspections of variety of construction projects ranging from minor residential to complex new homes and commercial projects for compliance with the latest edition of the CRC, CBC and other standards and adopted jurisdiction ordinances. He interprets and enforces adopted City codes & ordinance; reviews plans, calculations & specifications; coordinates & schedules daily inspection assignments. Jerry provides technical support to staff/contractors/ clients, trouble- shoots & investigates complaints of code violations.
Contract Building Inspector
City of San Bernardino
Jerry’s duties included performing inspections and providing general support to Building Departments in the City of San Bernardino. In addition, Jerry acted as a liaison with the jurisdictions served. He ensures compliance with the adopted building codes and local regulations and
installation of plumbing and HVAC systems
in new construction and alterations.
C
ontract Building Inspector
City of Orange
Jerry provided combination inspections on a variety of construction projects ranging from residential remodels to new multi-story office and hotel buildings to verify compliance with adopted codes and standards including Building, MEP, Energy, Accessibility and local ordinances and regulations.
City of Redlands
Building Inspector
Jerry provided building inspections on a variety of construction projects ranging from residential remodels to new homes and commercial buildings to verify compliance with adopted codes and standards including Building, MEP, Energy, Accessibility and local ordinances and regulations.
Exhibit D67
316
Jerome Schreiber
Senior Building Inspector
Education
• Bachelor of Science in
Electrical Engineering
• Professional Electrical
Engineer
Certifications
• Certified Building
Inspector
• Certified Mechanical
Inspector
• Certified Plumbing
Inspector
• Certified Electrical
Inspector
• Certified Electrical
Plans Examiner
Background
Jerome is a seasoned and experienced combination building inspector with strong background in electrical codes. He is a dedicated professional with strong inter- personal skills and great customer service. He is capable, dependable, detail-oriented, conscientious, courteous, helpful and will look for ways to help customers find solutions during his inspections. He works very well under pressure and in a fast-paced environment. He builds and maintains positive working relationship with peers, management, and customers. He has excellent organ izational skills, computer savvy and proven ability to adhere to the established procedures of the jurisdiction.
Select Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Senior Building Inspector
Jerome serves as a True North Compliance Services senior building inspector. He conducts field inspections of variety of construction projects ranging from minor residential to complex new homes and commercial projects for compliance with the latest edition of the CRC, CBC and other standards and adopted jurisdiction ordinances. He interprets and enforces adopted City codes & ordinance; reviews plans, calculations & specifications; coordinates & schedules daily inspection assignments. Jerome provides technical support to staff/contractors/ clients, trouble- shoots & investigates complaints of code violations.
Building Inspector
City of Glendale
Jerome’s duties included performing inspections and providing general support to building permit applicants and contractors. In addition, he performed plan checking on minor projects. He ensures compliance with the adopted building, mechanical, plumbing and electrical codes and local regulations in new construction and alterations.
S
enior Electrical Inspector
City of Vernon
Jerome provided electrical code inspections and plans check on a variety of construction projects ranging from residential remodels to new multi-story office and hotel buildings to verify compliance with adopted codes and standards.
Instructor
Long Beach City College
Jerome provides instructions and teaches classes on the National Electrical Code at the Long Beach Community College.
Exhibit D68
317
Alexandra Perkins
Senior Permit Technician/Document Control
Education
• Bachelor’s degree in
Marketing
Background
Alex is an experienced permit technician and document control with many years of experience serving in multiple jurisdictions. She provides counter services to property owners, business owners, and developers for permitting and processing of discretionary and administrative permits, subdivisions, approvals, and property development entitlements, as well as neighborhood code compliance and zoning violation matters.
Select Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Supervising Permit Technician
Performs document control and intake of submitted projects. Communicates with clients and project applicants related to status of projects. Process projects and calculate fees and other building data. Review permit application for completeness, perform preliminary review for completeness and accuracy, perform fee calculations, route plans, verify approvals and conditions and issue permits. Use the City’s permitting system to file permit applications, calculate fees, research zoning and planning requirements, enter approvals and route plans to appropriate divisions and departments.
Use of different types of computer programs to determine building permit requirements, plan check fees, water & sewer fees, and building permit fees. Perform residential and TI plan reviews and communicates effectively with clients and applicants.
Contract Permit Technician
Multiple Jurisdictions in CA
Provided counter services to property owners, business owners, and developers for permitting and processing of building and other permits; Interprets and explains policies and regulations accurately and tactfully to the public with the completion of buildi ng permit applications; Issues multiple permits, including building, plumbing, electrical and mechanical; Calculates and processes permit and fees and provides fee estimates as requested; Records and reconciles the daily permit-related monetary transactions.
Graphics Designer
Defining requirements, visualizing and creating graphics including illustrations, logos, layouts and photos for websites, books, magazines, product packaging, and exhibitions.
Exhibit D69
318
Jesica Miner
Permit Technician/Document Control
Education
• Associate Degree in
Marketing
Background
Jesica is an experienced permit technician and document control with many years of experience serving in multiple jurisdictions. She provides counter services to property owners, business owners, and developers for permitting and processing of discretionary and administrative permits , subdivisions, approvals, and property development entitlements, as well as neighborhood code compliance and zoning violation matters.
Select Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Permit Technician
Performs document control and intake of submitted projects. Communicates with clients and project applicants related to status of projects. Process projects and calculate fees and other building data. Review permit application for completeness, perform preliminary review for completeness and accuracy, perform fee calculations, route plans, verify approvals and conditions and issue permits. Use the City’s permitting system to file permit applications, calculate fees, research zoning and planning requirements, enter approvals and route plans to appropriate divisions and departments.
Use of different types of computer programs to determine building permit requirements, plan check fees, water & sewer fees, and building permit fees. Perform residential and TI plan reviews and communicates effectively with clients and applicants.
Office Manager
Sugar Loaf, Long Beach, CA
Provide excellent customer service; Train new employees on services and products ;
Perform services on clients; Booking clients and maintain schedule; Manage supplies and inventory; Maintain daily/monthly sales goals; Assist with monthly reports and overlook hours related to payroll; Conduct weekly team meetings & team bonding activities.
Exhibit D70
319
Roy Kim
Permit Technician/Document Control
Education
• College of San Mateo Art-
Enrolled
Background
Roy is an experienced permit technician and document control . He provides excellent customer service. He provides counter services to property owners, business owners, and developers for permitting and processing of discretionary and administrative permits, subdivisions, approvals, and property development entitlements, as well as neighborhood code compliance and zoning violation matters.
Select Work Experience
True North Compliance Services, Inc.
Permit Technician
Performs document control and intake of submitted projects. Communicates with clients and project applicants related to status of projects. Process projects and calculate fees and other building data. Review permit application for completeness, perform preliminary review for completeness and accuracy, perform fee calculations, route plans, verify approvals and conditions and issue permits. Use the City’s permitting system to file permit applications, calculate fees, research zoning and planning requirements, enter approvals and route plans to appropriate divisions and departments.
Use of different types of computer programs to determine building permit requirements, plan check fees, water & sewer fees, and building permit fees. Perform residential and TI plan reviews and communicates effectively with clients and applicants.
Personal Arts Project Works
Designer
Progressed through personal art projects and assets for Live2D Avatars and streaming setups. Self-trained use of Live2D Cubism, and assortment of illustration programs.
Game Stop
Operate registers to assist customers in locating and exchange desired products; Advise
customers on products and payment plans; Organize incoming and outgoing inventory; Inspect and verify customer trade-in items are in a respectable state prior to placing it into inventory.
Exhibit D71
320
AGREEMENT FOR PROFESSIONAL SERVICES WITH THE CITY
OF MURRIETA (“CITY”)
Project Name/Description (“Project”): Building and Safety Contract Services Contract Number:
Consultant Name (“Consultant”): BPR Consulting Group
Consultant Address: 6856 Sundance Trail, Riverside, CA 92506 Consultant Representative Name and Title (“Consultant Representative”): Mark Berg, CBO, CFM, MCP & Ron Beehler, SE, CBO, Director of Client Services Consultant Representative Work Phone and Email: 951-522-6982 [email protected] & 916- 204-3178 [email protected]
Effective Date: 6/1/24
Termination Date: 6/30/26
Total Not-To-Exceed Contract Amount (“Contract Sum”): Total compensation for all services provided by Consultant(s) combined shall not exceed $650,000 per year or available budgeted amount.
City Department Contact (“Department Contact”): Andrew Krogh & Tiffany Liljestrom Department Contact Work Phone and Email: 951-461-6126 [email protected] & 951-461- 6052 [email protected]
Is Federal Funding Being Used to Fund Any Part of The Project (Yes/No): No
RECITALS
A. The City desires to contract with a Consultant to provide professional services as more further set forth herein.
B. The City circulated a Request for Proposals for the above -described professional services.
C. Consultant submitted a proposal to City to provide the above -described professional services.
D. City Staff has reviewed all the proposals and after considering the demonstrated competence of Consultant, the professional qualifications of Consultant, and the fairness and reasonableness of Consultant’s proposed cost, staff has determined that an agreement to provide the required services should be awarded to Consultant. 321
THIS AGREEMENT FOR SERVICES (“Agreement”) is made and entered into as of the Effective Date set forth above by and between CITY OF MURRIETA, a California municipal corporation (“City”) and (“Consultant”). City and Consultant may be referred to individually as “Party” or collectively as “Parties.” In consideration of the mutual promises and covenants made by the Parties and contained herein and other consideration, the value and adequacy of which are hereby acknowledged, the Parties agree as follows:
ARTICLE 1. SERVICES OF CONSULTANT
1.1 Scope of Services. In compliance with all terms and conditions of this Agreement, Consultant shall provide those services specified in the “ Scope of Services ” attached hereto as Exhibit A and incorporated herein by this reference, which may be referred to herein as the “ services” or “ work” hereunder. As a material inducement to City entering into this Agreement, Consultant represents and warrants: a) it has the qualifications, experience, and facilities necessary to properly perform the Services required under this Agreement b) all services set forth in the Scope of Services will be performed in a competent and satisfactory manner; c) all materials used for services will be both of good quality as well as fit for the purpose intended; and, d) Consultant shall follow the highest professional standards and practices in performing the services required hereunder.
1.2 Consultant’s Proposal. The Scope of Services shall include the scope of services or work included in Consultant’s proposal or bid, which shall be incorporated herein by this reference as though fully set forth herein. In the event of any inconsistency between the terms of such proposal or bid, and this Agreement, the terms of this Agreement shall govern. No other terms and conditions from Consultant’s proposal or bid, other than description of scope of services or work, shall apply to this Agreement, unless specifically agreed to by City in writing.
1.3 Compliance with Law. All services rendered hereunder shall be provided in accordance with all ordinances, resolutions, statutes, rules and regulations of City and any federal, State or local governmental agency having jurisdiction in effect at the time services are rendered. City, and its officers, employees and agents, shall not be liable at law or in equity for failure of Consultant to comply with this Section.
1.4 Licenses, Permits, Fees and Assessments. Consultant shall obtain at its sole cost and expense such licenses, permits and approvals as may be required by law for the performance of the services required by this Agreement. Consultant shall have the sole obligation to pay for any fees, assessments and taxes, plus applicable penalties and interest, which may be imposed by law and arise from or are necessary for Consultant’s performance of the services required by this Agreement, and shall indemnify, defend and hold harmless City against any such fees, assessments, taxes, penalties or interest levied, assessed or imposed against City hereunder.
1.5 Familiarity with Work. By executing this Agreement, Consultant represents and warrants Consultant: a) has thoroughly investigated and considered services to be 322
performed, b) has carefully considered how services should be performed, and c) fully understands the facilities, difficulties and restrictions attending performance of services under this Agreement.
1.6 Software and Computer Services. If the Scope of Services includes the provision and/or installation of any software, computer system, or other computer technology, Consultant represents and warrants that it is familiar with and/or has inspected City’s current infrastructure, equipment, computer system and software and that the software, computer system, or other computer technology provided and/or installed by Consultant under this Agreement is compatible, and shall be fully functional, with such infrastructure, equipment, computer system and software of City. Consultant acknowledges that City is relying on this representation by Consultant as a material consideration in entering into this Agreement.
1.7 Prevailing Wages. If services include any “public work” or “maintenance work,” as those terms are defined in California Labor Code section 1720 et seq. and California Code of Regulations, Title 8, section 16000 et seq. , and if the total compensation is $1,000 or more, Consultant shall pay prevailing wages for such work and comply with the requirements in California Labor Code section 1770 et seq. and 1810 et seq., and all other applicable laws.
1.8 Special Requirements. Additional terms and conditions of this Agreement, if any, which are made a part hereof are set forth in the “Special Requirements” attached hereto as Exhibit B and incorporated herein by this reference. In the event of a conflict between the provisions of Exhibit B and any other provisions of this Agreement, the provisions of Exhibit B shall govern.
ARTICLE 2. COMPENSATION AND METHOD OF PAYMENT
2.1 Contract Sum. Subject to any limitations set forth in this Agreement, City agrees to pay Consultant the rates specified in the “Schedule of Compensation” attached hereto as Exhibit C and incorporated herein by this reference. The total compensation for all work, including reimbursement for actual expenses, shall not exceed the Contract Sum set forth above. Compensation may include reimbursement, for actual and necessary expenditures, if both are specified in the Schedule of Compensation, as well as approved by City in advance.
2.2 Invoices. Unless some other method of payment is specified in Exhibit C, Schedule of Compensation, in any month in which Consultant wishes to receive payment, no later than the first business day of such month, Consultant shall submit to City, in a form approved by City’s Finance Director, an invoice for services rendered prior to the date of the invoice. By submitting an invoice for payment under this Agreement, Consultant is certifying compliance with all provisions of this Agreement. Except as provided in Sections 7.3, 7.4 and 7.5, City shall pay Consultant for all expenses stated thereon which are approved by City pursuant to this Agreement generally within thirty (30) days, and City will use its best efforts to make payment no later than forty-five (45) days, from the submission of an 323
invoice in an approved form. In the event any charges or expenses are disputed by City, the original invoice shall be returned by City to Consultant for correction and resubmission. Review and payment by City for any invoice provided by Consultant shall not constitute a waiver of any rights or remedies provided herein or any applicable law. Each invoice is to include (unless otherwise specified by City): 1) line items for all personnel describing the work performed, the number of hours worked, and the hourly rate; 2) line items for all materials and equipment properly charged to the Services; 3) line items for all other approved reimbursable expenses claimed, with supporting documentation; and 4) line items for all approved subcontractor labor, supplies, equipment, materials, and travel properly charged to the Services.
ARTICLE 3. PERFORMANCE SCHEDULE
3.0 Time of Essence. Time is of the essence in the performance of this Agreement.
3.1 Term. The Agreement shall commence upon the Effective Date set forth above and will continue until the Termination Date. This Agreement may be extended for up to two, additional one -year periods upon the mutual agreement in writing of both parties.
Unless earlier terminated in accordance with Article 7 of this Agreement, this Agreement shall continue in full force and effect until completion of any ongoing services, which shall be no later than the Termination Date set forth above.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, the Indemnification and Insurance provisions set forth in Article 5 shall survive the termination of this Agreement.
3.2 Schedule of Performance. Consultant shall commence the services pursuant to this Agreement upon receipt of a written notice to proceed from City and shall perform all services within the time period(s) established in the “Schedule of Performance” attached hereto as Exhibit D and incorporated herein by this reference.
3.3 Force Majeure. The time period(s) specified in the Schedule of Performance for performance of the services rendered pursuant to this Agreement shall be extended because of any delays due to unforeseeable causes beyond the control and without the fault or negligence of Consultant, including, but not restricted to, acts of God or of the public enemy, unusually severe weather, fires, earthquakes, floods, epidemics, quarantine restrictions, riots, strikes, freight embargoes, wars, litigation, and/or acts of any governmental agency, including City, if Consultant shall within ten (10) days of the commencement of such delay notify City in writing of the causes of the delay. City shall ascertain the facts and the extent of delay, and extend the time for performing the services for the period of the enforced delay when and if in the judgment of City such delay is justified. City’s determination shall be final and conclusive upon the Parties to this Agreement. In no event shall Consultant be entitled to recover damages against City for any delay in the performance of this 324
Agreement, however caused, Consultant’s sole remedy being extension of this Agreement pursuant to this Section.
ARTICLE 4. COORDINATION OF WORK
4.1 Representative of Consultant. The Consultant Representative is authorized to act on Consultant’s behalf with respect to the work or services specified herein and to make all decisions in connection therewith. It is expressly understood that the experience, knowledge, capability and reputation of the representative was a substantial inducement for City to enter into this Agreement. Therefore, the representative shall be responsible during the term of this Agreement for directing all activities of Consultant and devoting sufficient time to personally supervise the services hereunder. For purposes of this Agreement, the representative may not be replaced nor may their responsibilities be substantially reduced by Consultant without the express written approval of City.
4.2 Department Contact for City. The Department Contact (or other person designated by the City Manager) shall be the primary person on behalf of City responsible for the administration of the Agreement. It shall be Consultant’s responsibility to assure that the Department Contact is kept informed of both the progress of the performance of the services as well as any decisions which must be made by City.
4.3 Approvals from City. City approvals or actions, pursuant to the authority of this Agreement, are to be made (unless otherwise specified) either by the Contract Manager, City Manager or by their delegate as provided for in writing.
4.4 Independent Contractor. Neither City, nor any of its officers, employees or agents, shall have any control over the manner or means by which Consultant, or its officers, employees, agents or subcontractors, perform the services required herein, except as otherwise set forth herein. Consultant shall perform all services required herein as an independent contractor of City and shall remain under only such obligations as are consistent with that role. Consultant shall not at any time or in any manner represent that it, or any of its officers, employees, agents or subcontractors, are officers, employees or agents of City. City shall not in any way or for any purpose become or be deemed to be a partner of Consultant in its business or otherwise or a joint venturer or a member of any joint enterprise with Consultant.
Consultant shall not incur or have the power to incur any debt, obligation or liability whatever against City, or bind City in any manner. Consultant represents and warrants that the personnel used to provide services to City pursuant to this Agreement shall at all times be under Consultant’s exclusive control and direction.
No City employee benefits shall be available to Consultant, its officers, employees, agents or subcontractors, in connection with the performance of this Agreement.
City shall not be liable for compensation or indemnification to Consultant, its officers, employees, agents or subcontractors, for injury or sickness arising out of performing services hereunder. In the event that Consultant or any officer, employee, agent, or subcontractor of Consultant providing services under this Agreement claims or is determined by a federal or state agency, a court of 325
competent jurisdiction, or the California Public Employees’ Retirement System, to be classified as other than an independent contractor for City, then Consultant shall indemnify, defend, and hold harmless City for the payment of any and all assessed fines, penalties, judgments, employee and/or employer contributions, and any other damages and costs assessed to City as a consequence of, or in any way attributable to, the assertion that Consultant, or any officer, employee, agent, or subcontractor Consultant used to provide services under this Agreement, is/are employees of City.
4.5 Subcontracting or Assignment. The experience, knowledge, capability and reputation of Consultant, its principals and employees were a substantial inducement for City to enter into this Agreement. Therefore, without express written approval of City, Consultant shall not contract with any other City to perform in whole or in part services required hereunder without express written approval of City, and neither this Agreement nor any interest herein may be transferred or assigned. No approved transfer shall release Consultant, or any surety or insured of Consultant, of any liability hereunder without express written consent of City.
ARTICLE 5. INSURANCE AND INDEMNIFICATION
5.1 Insurance Coverages. Prior to commencement of any services under this Agreement, and without limiting Consultant’s indemnification obligation to City, Consultant shall procure and maintain, at its sole cost and expense, in a form and content satisfactory to City, for the duration of the Agreement, primary policies of insurance of the type and amounts set forth in the “Insurance Requirements” attached hereto as Exhibit E and incorporated herein by this reference.
5.2 Indemnification.
(a) General Obligations. Consultant agrees, to the full extent permitted by law, to indemnify, defend and hold harmless City and its elected and appointed officers, employees and agents (each an “ Indemnitee” and collectively, “ Indemnitees”) against, and will hold and save them and each of them harmless from, whether actual or threatened, any and all actions, either judicial, administrative, arbitration or regulatory claims, damages to persons or property, losses, costs, penalties, obligations, errors, omissions or liabilities (herein “ Claims or Liabilities”) that may be asserted or claimed by any person, firm or City arising out of or in connection with the negligent performance of the work, operations or activities provided herein of Consultant, its officers, employees, agents, subcontractors, or invitees, or any individual or City for which Consultant is legally liable (each an “ Indemnitor” and collectively, “ Indemnitors”), or arising from Indemnitors’ reckless or willful misconduct, or arising from Indemnitors’ negligent performance of or failure to perform any term, provision, covenant or condition of this Agreement, and in connection therewith: 1) Consultant will defend any action or actions filed or threatened in connection with any such Claims or Liabilities, or at option of Indemnitee(s) will reimburse and pay for all costs and expenses, including legal costs and attorneys’ fees, incurred by Indemnitee(s) in connection therewith; and, 2) Consultant will promptly pay any judgment rendered against Indemnitee(s) for any such Claims or Liabilities, and will save and hold Indemnitee(s) harmless therefrom.
326
(b) Further Provisions. The indemnity obligation herein shall be binding on successors, assigns and heirs of Consultant and shall survive termination of this Agreement.
Consultant shall incorporate similar indemnity agreements as provided herein with its subcontractors, and if Consultant fails to do so Consultant shall be fully responsible to indemnify City hereunder therefor. Failure of City and/or City Parties (collectively “City” for solely this Section 5.3(b)) to monitor compliance with any of the indemnification provisions herein shall not be a waiver hereof. The indemnification provisions herein do not apply to claims or liabilities occurring as a result of City’s sole negligence or willful misconduct, but, to the fullest extent permitted by law, shall apply to claims and liabilities resulting in part from City’s negligence, except that design professionals’ indemnity hereunder shall be limited to claims and liabilities arising out of the negligence, recklessness or willful misconduct of the design professional. The indemnification provided herein includes Claims or Liabilities arising from any negligent or wrongful act, error or omission, or reckless or willful misconduct of Indemnitors in the performance of professional services hereunder. Payment of invoices by City is not a condition precedent to enforcement of the indemnity obligation herein. In the event of any dispute between Consultant and City, as to whether liability arises from the sole negligence or willful misconduct of City, Consultant will be obligated to pay for City’s defense until such time as a final judgment has been entered adjudicating City as solely negligent or responsible for willful misconduct.
Consultant will not be entitled in the absence of such a determination to any reimbursement of defense costs including but not limited to attorney’s fees, expert fees and costs of litigation. (c) Pursuant to the full language of California Civil Code §2782, Design Professionals agrees to indemnify, including the cost to defend, City and its officers, officials, employees, and volunteers from and against any and all claims, demands, costs, or liability that arise out of, or pertain to, or relate to the negligence, recklessness, or willful misconduct of Design Professional and its employees or agents in the performance of services under this contract, but this indemnity does not apply to liability for damages arising from the sole negligence, active negligence, or willful acts of the City; and does not apply to any passive negligence of the City unless caused at least in part by the Design Professional. The City agrees that in no event shall the cost to defend charged to the Design Professional exceed that professional’s proportionate percentage of fault. This duty to indemnify shall not be waived or modified by contractual agreement or acts of the parties.
5.3 Professional Liability. When the law establishes a professional standard of care for Consultant’s services, to the fullest extent permitted by law, Consultant shall indemnify, defend and hold harmless Indemnitees against, and will hold and save them and each of them harmless from, whether actual or threatened, any and all Claims and Liabilities, consistent with all obligations provided for in this Section
5.3, to the extent same are caused in whole or in part by any negligent or wrongful act, error or omission, or reckless or willful misconduct of Indemnitors in the performance of professional services under this Agreement.
ARTICLE 6. RECORDS, REPORTS AND RELEASE OF INFORMATION
Records. Consultant shall keep, and require subcontractors to keep, such ledgers, books of accounts, invoices, vouchers, canceled checks, reports, studies or other documents relating to the disbursements charged to City and services performed hereunder (“books and records”) as shall be necessary to perform the services 327
required by this Agreement and enable City to evaluate the performance of such services. Any and all such books and records shall be maintained in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles, shall be complete and detailed, and shall be readily accessible. City shall have full and free access to such books and records at all times during normal business hours of City, including the right to inspect, copy, audit and make records and transcripts. Such books and records shall be maintained for a period of three (3) years following completion of the services hereunder. City shall have access to such books and records in the event any audit is required. Consultant shall fully cooperate with City in providing access to any and all Consultant records and documents if a public records request is made and disclosure is required by law including but not limited to the California Public Records Act.
Ownership of Documents. All drawings, specifications, maps, designs, photographs, studies, surveys, data, notes, computer files, reports, records, documents and other materials (“ documents and materials ”) prepared by Consultant, its officers, employees, agents and subcontractors in the performance of this Agreement shall be the property of City and shall be delivered to City upon request of City and/or upon the termination of this Agreement, and Consultant shall have no claim for further employment or additional compensation as a result of the exercise by City of its full rights of ownership, use, reuse, or assignment of the documents and materials hereunder. Consultant may retain copies of such documents and materials for its own use. Consultant shall have the right to use the concepts embodied therein. All subcontractors shall provide for assignment to City of any documents and materials prepared by them, and in the event Consultant fails to secure such assignment, Consultant shall indemnify City for all damages resulting therefrom. Moreover, with respect to any Consultant documents and materials that may qualify as “works made for hire” as defined in 17 U.S.C. § 101, such documents and materials are hereby deemed “works made for hire” for City.
Confidentiality and Release of Information. All information gained or work product produced by Consultant in its performance of this Agreement shall be considered confidential, unless such information is in the public domain or already known to Consultant. Consultant shall not release or disclose any such information or work product to persons or entities other than City without prior written authorization from City. Consultant, its officers, employees, agents or subcontractors, shall not, without prior written authorization from City or unless requested by the City Attorney, voluntarily provide documents, declarations, letters of support, testimony at depositions, response to interrogatories or other information concerning the work performed under this Agreement. Response to a subpoena or court order shall not be considered “voluntary” provided Consultant immediately gives City notice of such court order or subpoena. If Consultant, or any officer, employee, agent or subcontractor of Consultant, provides any information or work product in violation of this Agreement, then City shall have the right to reimbursement and indemnity from Consultant for any damages, costs and fees, including attorney’s fees, caused by or incurred as a result of Consultant’s conduct. As concerning, regarding or related to, in any way, this Agreement and the work performed thereunder: a) Consultant shall immediately notify City should 328
Consultant, its officers, employees, agents or subcontractors be served with any summons, complaint, subpoena, notice of deposition, request for documents, interrogatories, request for admissions or other discovery request, court order or subpoena from any party; b) City retains the right, but has no obligation, to represent Consultant or be present at any deposition, hearing or similar proceeding; and, c) Consultant agrees to cooperate fully with City and to provide City with the opportunity to review any response to discovery requests provided by Consultant, however, this right to review any such response does not imply or mean the right by City to control, direct, or rewrite said response.
ARTICLE 7. ENFORCEMENT OF AGREEMENT AND TERMINATION
7.1 California Law. This Agreement shall be interpreted, construed and governed both as to validity and to performance of the Parties in accordance with the laws of the State of California. Legal actions concerning any dispute, claim or matter arising out of or in relation to this Agreement shall be instituted in the Superior Court of the County of Riverside, State of California, or any other appropriate court in such county, and Consultant agrees to submit to the personal jurisdiction of such court in the event of such action. In the event of litigation in a U.S. District Court, venue shall lie exclusively in the Central District of California, in the County of Riverside, State of California.
7.2 Suspension, or Termination, Prior to Expiration of Term. This Section shall govern any termination of this Agreement except as specifically provided in Section
7.4 for termination for cause. City reserves the right to terminate or suspend this Agreement, or any portion hereof, at any time, for any reason, with or without cause, upon ten (10) days’ notice to Consultant, except that where termination or suspension is due to the fault of Consultant, the period of notice may be such shorter time as determined by City. Upon receipt of any notice of termination or suspension, Consultant shall immediately cease all services hereunder, unless the notice provides otherwise, or except such as specifically approved by City. Upon submittal of an invoice consistent with Section 2.2, Consultant shall be entitled to compensation for all services rendered prior to the effective date of the notice of termination or suspension and for any services authorized by City thereafter in accordance with the Schedule of Compensation, or such as may be approved by City, except as provided in Section 7.5. In event of termination, or suspension, without cause pursuant to this Section, there is no need to provide opportunity to cure pursuant to Section 7.3.
7.3 Default of Consultant and Opportunity to Cure. In the event that Consultant is in default under the terms of this Agreement, City shall not have any obligation or duty to continue compensating Consultant for any work performed after the date of default. Instead, City may give notice to Consultant of the default and the reasons for the default. The notice shall include the timeframe in which Consultant may cure the default. This timeframe is presumptively ten (10) days, but may be extended, or reduced, if circumstances warrant, as determined by City. During the period of time that Consultant is in default, City shall hold all invoices and shall, when the default is cured, proceed with payment on the invoices, without liability 329
for interest. In the alternative, City may, in its sole discretion, elect to pay some or all of the outstanding invoices during the period of default. If Consultant does not cure the default by conclusion of noticed timeframe, City may immediately both terminate this Agreement with notice to Consultant as well as pursue the remedy in Section 7.4, without prejudice to any other remedy to which City may be entitled at law, in equity or under this Agreement. Any failure on the part of City to give notice of Consultant’s default shall not be deemed to result in a waiver of City’s legal rights or any rights arising out of any provision of this Agreement.
7.4 Termination for Default of Consultant. If termination is due to the failure of Consultant to fulfill its obligations under this Agreement, City may, after compliance with the provisions of Section 7.3, take over the work and prosecute the same to completion by contract or otherwise, and Consultant shall be liable to the extent that the total cost for completion of the services required hereunder exceeds the compensation herein stipulated (provided that City shall use reasonable efforts to mitigate such damages), and City may withhold any payments to Consultant for the purpose of set-off or partial payment of the amounts owed City therefor.
7.5 Retention of Funds. Consultant hereby authorizes City to deduct from any amount payable to Consultant (whether or not arising out of this Agreement) (i) any amounts the payment of which may be in dispute hereunder or which are necessary to compensate City for any losses, costs, liabilities, or damages suffered by City, and (ii) all amounts for which City may be liable to third parties, by reason of Consultant’s acts or omissions in performing or failing to perform Consultant’s obligation under this Agreement. In the event that any claim is made by a third party, the amount or validity of which is disputed by Consultant, or any indebtedness shall exist which shall appear to be the basis for a claim of lien, City may withhold from any payment due, without liability for interest because of such withholding, an amount sufficient to cover such claim. The failure of City to exercise such right to deduct or to withhold shall not, however, affect the obligations of Consultant to insure, indemnify, and protect City as elsewhere provided herein.