Cities Index.
Minutes

Napa City Council
December 5, 2023

Document
Minutes
Meeting
December 5, 2023
Body
Napa City Council
Pages
125
Original file
19.5 MB
Text extracted from the city's file for reading and search. Open the original on napacity.legistar.com. That file is the official record.

955 School Street
Napa, CA 94559
www.cityofnapa.org
3:30 PM
City Hall Council Chambers
Tuesday, December 5, 2023
3:30 PM Afternoon Session
6:30 PM Evening Session
3:30 P.M. AFTERNOON SESSION

1. CALL TO ORDER: 3:35 P.M.

1.A. Roll Call:

Councilmember Alessio, Councilmember Luros, Councilmember Narvaez, Vice Mayor Painter, and Mayor Sedgley

Present:
5 -

2. AGENDA REVIEW AND SUPPLEMENTAL REPORTS:

City Clerk Carranza announced the following supplemental documents:

Item 4.L. - Email from Town of Yountville Public Works Director John Ferons.

Items 5.A., 5.B., 5.C - PowerPoint presentations from City staff. (Copies of all supplemental documents are included in Attachment 1)

Page 1 ends

CITY OF NAPA
Printed on 12/8/2023

CITY OF NAPA

MEETING MINUTES - Final

CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NAPA

Mayor Scott Sedgley

Vice Mayor Beth Painter

Councilmember Liz Alessio

Councilmember Mary Luros
Councilmember Bernie Narvaez

Page 1 of 125 ends

December 5, 2023

CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
NAPA

3. PUBLIC COMMENT:

Jim Hinton - provided comments regarding a multi-rider pedal bike vehicle and shared various safety concerns with it.

Victoria Willey - provided comments regarding homelessness.

Anonymous - provided comments in support of the unhoused community in Napa.

Philip Trood - shared concerns regarding current encampment clean up and relocation at Kennedy Park.

Rochelle - shared concerns regarding current encampment clean up and relocation at Kennedy Park.

Resa - shared concerns regarding the living conditions at Kennedy Park.

4. CONSENT CALENDAR:

Approval of the Consent Agenda
A motion was made by Vice Mayor Painter, seconded by Councilmember Alessio, to approve the Consent Agenda. The motion carried by the following vote:

Aye:

Alessio, Luros, Narvaez, Painter, and Sedgley
5 -

4.A.
444-2023
City Council Meeting Minutes
Approve the minutes from the November 7, 2023 Regular Meeting of the City Council.

4.B.
432-2023
Fiscal Year 2022-2023 Annual Tax Report for City of Napa Community Facilities District No. 2017-1 (Gasser Soscol Gateway)
Received the City of Napa Community Facilities District No. 2017-1 (Gasser Soscol Gateway) Annual Tax Report for the fiscal year ended June 30, 2023.

4.C.
430-2023
Classification Plan for Maintenance Craftsworker in the Public Works Department
Adopted Resolution R2023-128 amending the City Classification Plan by adopting the revised classification specification for Maintenance Craftsworker in the Public Works Department.

Enactment No: R2023-128

Page 2 ends

CITY OF NAPA
Printed on 12/8/2023
MEETING MINUTES - Final

Page 2 of 125 ends

December 5, 2023

CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
NAPA

4.D.
441-2023
Security Agreement for 3380 Solano Avenue
Authorized the City Manager to execute Amendment No. 1 to Agreement No.

C2023-153 with Universal Protection Service LP, dba Allied Security Services for security services, increasing the not-to-exceed amount by $55,000 for a total of $755,000 to add security cameras and a guard shack to the non-congregate shelter located at 3380 Solano Avenue.

4.E.
422-2023
GIS Software Enterprise License Agreement
Authorized the Assistant City Manager to execute a three (3) year Enterprise License Agreement with Environmental Systems Research Institute, Inc. (ESRI) for Small Municipal and County GIS (Geographical Information System) services for an amount not-to-exceed $175,500.

4.F.
419-2023
Memorandum of Understanding for Regional Grant Applications from Multiple Government Agencies
Authorized the City Manager to execute on behalf of the City a Memorandum of Understanding with American Canyon Fire Protection District, City of Calistoga and County of Napa for Regional Grant Applications.

4.G.
396-2023
Park Playground and Amenity Improvement Project
Adopted Resolution R2023-129: (1) authorizing the Parks and Recreation Services Director to negotiate and execute an agreement with Landscape Structures, Inc., for the Park Playground and Amenity Improvement Project, which includes the replacement of playground equipment and park infrastructure for multiple park sites, including Abruzzini Park, Century Oaks Park, Lake Park, Springwood Park, Vine Hill Park, and Vineyard Park, and associated concrete work in an amount not to exceed $1,374,778; (2) determining that the exceptions for procurement via existing contracts of other public agencies and for specialty items in Napa Municipal Code Sections 2.91.060 and 2.91.050 apply to the agreement; and (3) determining that the actions authorized by this resolution are exempt from CEQA.

Enactment No: R2023-129

4.H.
414-2023
Napa Countywide Road Maintenance Act (Measure T) - Updated 5-Year Work Plan
Adopted Resolution R2023-130 approving the updated Five-year List of Projects under the Measure T Program, and determining that the actions authorized by this resolution are exempt from CEQA.

Enactment No: R2023-130

4.I.
421-2023
On-Call Geotechnical Design Engineering Services
Authorized the Public Works Director to negotiate and execute on behalf of the City agreements with three geotechnical engineering consulting firms: (1) Construction Testing Services, Inc., (2) Geocon Consultants, Inc., and (3) Ninyo & Moore for task-order based on-call geotechnical design engineering services for a term of three years, each in an amount not to exceed $500,000.

Page 3 ends

CITY OF NAPA
Printed on 12/8/2023
MEETING MINUTES - Final

Page 3 of 125 ends

December 5, 2023

CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
NAPA

4.J.
427-2023
One Bay Area Grant Program Cycle 3 Resolution of State Housing Law Compliance
Adopted Resolution R2023-131 certifying compliance with state housing laws to qualify for the $2,000,000 One Bay Area Grant Program Cycle 3 funding awarded to the City by the Metropolitan Transportation Commission for the Silverado Trail Five-Way Intersection Improvement Project located at the intersection of State Route 121 (Silverado Trail), East Avenue, Third Street, and Coombsville Road.

Enactment No: R2023-131

4.K.
438-2023
Silverado-Third-Coombsville-East (“5-Way Intersection”) Project Authorized the Public Works Director to negotiate and execute on behalf of the City a contract with GHD Inc. for professional engineering services for the Project Approval and Environmental Document (PA&ED) phase of the “5-Way Intersection” Project in an amount not to exceed $1,303,743.

4.L.
437-2023
Joint Powers Agreement Between the City of Napa, the Town of Yountville, and the California Department of Veterans Affairs for Shared Water Sampling and Testing Services
(See supplemental document in Attachment 1)
Adopted Resolution R2023-132 authorizing the City Manager to negotiate and execute a Joint Powers Agreement and future amendments thereto between the City of Napa, the Town of Yountville, and the California Department of Veterans Affairs for Shared Water Sampling and Testing Services.

Enactment No: R2023-132

4.M.
457-2023
Repair and Rehabilitation of 36-inch Water Transmission Main Crossing Redwood Creek
Adopted Resolution R2023-133: (1) Determining that the proposed contract with Spray in Place Solutions, LLC meets the requirements for a “specialty item” as set forth in Napa Municipal Code Section 2.91.050; (2) authorizing the Utilities Director to negotiate and execute a construction contract with Spray in Place Solutions, LLC in an amount not to exceed $500,000 for the repair and rehabilitation of the 36-inch water main crossing Redwood Creek; (3) authorizing the Utilities Director to negotiate and execute contracts for additional construction services, construction management, specialty inspections, and other services in a total amount not to exceed $100,000 for a total project amount not to exceed $600,000; (4) establishing CIP account 53160139-63WT24UTRR for Repairs to Transmission Main Crossing at Redwood Creek; (5) approving a transfer in the amount of $600,000 from Water CIP Reserve Account 530-35102 to the CIP Project account 53160139-63WT24UTRR, and increase the budget and expenditures in the amount of $600,000 as documented in Council Budget Amendment No.7P6; and (6) determining that the actions authorized by this resolution are exempt from CEQA.

Enactment No: R2023-133

Page 4 ends

CITY OF NAPA
Printed on 12/8/2023
MEETING MINUTES - Final

Page 4 of 125 ends

December 5, 2023

CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
NAPA

4.N.
451-2023
Staffing Plan Updates
Adopted Resolution R2023-134 amending the City Staffing Plan.

Enactment No: R2023-134

5. ADMINISTRATIVE REPORTS:

5.A.
366-2023
Surplus City-Owned Downtown Parking Parcels
(See supplemental document in Attachment 1)
Neal Harrison, Economic Development Manager, introduced the report.

Joseph Dieguez, Brian Moncrief, and Ken Hira, of Kosmont Companies, provided the report.

Mayor Sedgley called for public comment.

Natasha - asked how housing could be considered affordable if it were located in downtown.

Mayor Sedgley responded to the comment.

Discussion was turned over to Council. Mr. Harrison, Community Development Director Vin Smith, and Kosmont staff, responded to individual questions and comments.

A motion was made by Councilmember Alessio, seconded by Councilmember Narvaez, to direct Staff to prepare a Surplus Land Act disposition plan for City-owned parking parcels that are identified as high priority properties, including Lot X and Xw, 3rd Street Lot, Lot J and Lot S. The motion carried by the following vote:

Aye:

Alessio, Narvaez, Painter, and Sedgley
4 -
No:

Luros
1 -

Page 5 ends

CITY OF NAPA
Printed on 12/8/2023
MEETING MINUTES - Final

Page 5 of 125 ends

December 5, 2023

CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
NAPA

5.B.
415-2023
Quarterly Recruitment Update
Mayor Sedgley called for a brief break at 4:59 P.M. The meeting reconvened at 5:04 P.M.
(see supplemental document in Attachment 1)
Human Resources Director Heather Ruiz provided the report.

Mayor Sedgley called for public comment; there were no requests to speak.

Brief individual comments and questions ensued from Councilmembers.

5.C.
431-2023
Council Spotlight: Street Pavement and Sidewalk Repair Programs (See supplemental document in Attachment 1)
Peter Brestak, Public Works Operations Manager, and Ian Heid, Senior Civil Engineer, provided the report.

Following the presentation, brief individual comments and questions ensued from members of Council.

Mayor Sedgley called for public comment; there were no requests to speak.

6. CONSENT HEARINGS:

Approval of the Consent Agenda
A motion was made by Councilmember Luros, seconded by Councilmember Alessio, to approve the Consent Hearing Agenda. The motion carried by the following vote:

Aye:

Alessio, Luros, Narvaez, Painter, and Sedgley
5 -

Page 6 ends

CITY OF NAPA
Printed on 12/8/2023
MEETING MINUTES - Final

Page 6 of 125 ends

December 5, 2023

CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
NAPA

6.A.
364-2023
City Attorney’s Office Staffing Plan Update
Mayor Sedgley announced the consent hearing. There were no requests to speak; the hearing was opened and closed without comment. 1) Approved the first reading and introduction of an ordinance amending Napa Municipal Code Section 2.24.070 regarding the designation of appointive officers in the City Attorney’s Office; and
2) Adopted Resolution R2023-135 amending the City Classification Plan by adopting the revised classification specification and compensation and benefits for the Deputy City Attorney position; and
3) Adopted Resolution R2023-136 approving revisions to compensation and benefits for City Unrepresented Management Staff, consistent with that implemented for the Administrative, Managerial, and Professional Employees (AMP) per their Memorandum of Understanding for the term January 1, 2023 through December 31, 2024.

Enactment No: R2023-135 R2023-136

7. COMMENTS BY COUNCIL OR CITY MANAGER:

Vice Mayor Painter shared that at their Monday meeting the LAFCO Board unanimously approved the Vintage Farm Project.

Councilember Alessio reminded folks that Operation with Love from Home would be filling care packages Saturday, December 9th at 9:30 A.M. at Crosswalk Church and invited members of the public to volunteer.

CITY COUNCIL RECESS: 5:54 P.M.
6:30 P.M. EVENING SESSION

8. CALL TO ORDER: 6:30 P.M.

8.A. Roll Call:

Councilmember Alessio, Councilmember Luros, Councilmember Narvaez, Vice Mayor Painter, and Mayor Sedgley

Present:
5 -

9. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE:

Page 7 ends

CITY OF NAPA
Printed on 12/8/2023
MEETING MINUTES - Final

Page 7 of 125 ends

December 5, 2023

CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
NAPA

10. AGENDA REVIEW AND SUPPLEMENTAL REPORTS:

City Clerk Carranza announced the following supplemental items:

Item 11.A.:
- Recorded video from applicant Richard Tippitt.
- Emails from Gordon Huether and Bob Massaro.
- Resume from applicant Alexander Myers.

Item 13.A.:
- PowerPoint Presentation from City staff.
- Memo from Finance Director Raj Prasad noting correction to Attachment

2. (Copies of all supplemental documents are included in Attachment 2) Mayor Sedgley announced that due to the large attendance of school aged children in the audience for public comment, he would call for Item 12, general public comment, before proceeding with the Planning Commission interviews, Item 11.A.

Page 8 ends

CITY OF NAPA
Printed on 12/8/2023
MEETING MINUTES - Final

Page 8 of 125 ends

December 5, 2023

CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
NAPA

12. PUBLIC COMMENT:

Trevor Hall - asked Council to consider expanding expanded bicycle access in Alston Park by piloting a biking program.

Dave Schallon - provided comments supporting expanded bike access in Alston Park.

Camden A - provided comments supporting expanded bike access in Alston Park.

Quistan Potter - provided comments supporting expanded bike access in Alston Park.

Audrey Shallon - provided comments supporting expanded bike access in Alston Park.

Joe Vicencio - provided comments supporting expanded bike access in Alston Park.

Elayna Trucher - provided comments supporting expanded bike access in Alston Park.

Regina Brinker - provided comments supporting expanded bike access in Alston Park.

Greg Hamtil - provided comments supporting expanded bike access in Alston Park.

Kara Vernor, Napa County Bicycle Coalition - asked Council to consider piloting expanded bike access in Alston Park.

11. COMMISSION INTERVIEWS AND APPOINTMENTS:

Page 9 ends

CITY OF NAPA
Printed on 12/8/2023
MEETING MINUTES - Final

Page 9 of 125 ends

December 5, 2023

CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
NAPA

11.A.
450-2023
Planning Commission Membership
(See supplemental documents in Attachment 2)
Mayor Sedgley opened the item and welcomed all applicants.

Mayor Sedgley reviewed the proposed interview process.

Interviews began with each applicant providing a brief, three minute, introduction and statement, in the following order:

1. Beverly Shotwell

2. Ervin Hechavarria

3. Richard Tippitt - Applicant Tippitt was unavailable to attend the meeting in person. City Clerk staff played a video submitted by applicant Tippitt for Council consideration in his absence.

4. Paul Kelley

5. Lilea Duran

6. Alexander Myers
Council questions of individual applicants followed their opening statements.

Mayor Sedgley called for public comment; there were no requests to speak.

Each Councilmember voted, by paper ballot, to identify the three preferred candidates to be appointed to the Commission.

City Clerk Carranza announced that the greatest number of votes were received by Beverly Shotwell with 5 votes and Alexander Myers with 4 votes. Ervin Hechavarria and Paul Kelley received 3 votes each. She also announced the vote of each Councilmember for the candidates was as follows:

Mayor Sedgley: Shotwell, Hechavarria, and Myers
Vice Mayor Painter: Shotwell, Kelley, and Myers
Councilmember Alessio: Shotwell, Hechavarria, and Kelley Councilmember Luros: Shotwell, Kelley, and Myers
Councilmember Narvaez: Shotwell Hechavarria, and Myers
In order to break the tie for a third candidate, each Councilmember voted again by paper ballot to identify the preferred candidate, either applicant Hechavarria or Kelley.

Page 10 ends

CITY OF NAPA
Printed on 12/8/2023
MEETING MINUTES - Final

Page 10 of 125 ends

December 5, 2023

CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
NAPA
City Clerk Carranza announced that the greatest number of votes were received by Kelley with 3 votes. She also announced the vote of each Councilmember for the candidates was as follows:

Mayor Sedgley: Hechavarria
Vice Mayor Painter: Kelley
Councilmember Alessio: Kelley
Councilmember Luros: Kelley
Councilmember Narvaez: Hechavarria
A motion was made by Mayor Sedgley, seconded by Councilmember Luros, to re-appoint Beverly Shotwell and Paul Kelley, and appoint Alexander Myers to the Planning Commission for terms beginning January 1, 2024 and ending December 31, 2025; and designate Paul Kelly as a Design Professional. The motion carried by the following vote:

Aye:

Alessio, Luros, Narvaez, Painter, and Sedgley
5 -

13. ADMINISTRATIVE REPORTS:

13.A.
372-2023
Fiscal Year 2022/23 End of Year Report Update - Unaudited (see supplemental document in Attachment 2)
Finance Director, Raj Prasad, provided the staff report.

Mayor Sedgley called for public comment; there were no requests to speak.

City Manager Potter provided additional remarks and reviewed next steps.

Discussion was brought back to Council; individual questions and comments ensued.

14. COMMENTS BY COUNCIL OR CITY MANAGER:

Vice Mayor Painter thanked everyone who was in the audience earlier in the evening and asked if members of Council supported a request to have staff bring back an item to address a potential pilot program expanding bicycle use at Alston Park. Discussion ensued. Her request was supported and City Manager Potter confirmed an item could come before council as early as January 16, 2023. .

Page 11 ends

CITY OF NAPA
Printed on 12/8/2023
MEETING MINUTES - Final

Page 11 of 125 ends

December 5, 2023

CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
NAPA

15. ADJOURNMENT: 8:48 P.M.

Mayor Sedgley adjourned the meeting with a moment of silence in honor of Chaplain Lee Shaw who recently passed away.

The next regularly scheduled meeting for the City Council of the City of Napa is December 19, 2023.

Submitted by:
_______________________________
Tiffany Carranza, City Clerk

Page 12 ends

CITY OF NAPA
Printed on 12/8/2023
MEETING MINUTES - Final

Page 12 of 125 ends

ATTACHMENT 1

SUPPLEMENTAL REPORTS &
COMMUNICATIONS Office of the City Clerk
City Council of the City of Napa

Regular Meeting
December 5, 2023

FOR THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NAPA
AFTERNOON SESSION:

SUBMITTED PRIOR TO THE CITY COUNCI
L

MEETING

4. CONSENT CALENDAR:

4.L Joint Powers Agreement Between the City of Napa, the Town of Yountville, and the California
Department of Veterans Affairs for Shared Water Sampling and Testing Services

1) Email from
John Ferons

received
December 4
, 2023.
5 .

ADMINISTRATIVE REPORTS:
5 .

A
.

Surplus City
-
Owned Downtown Parking Parcels
•
PowerPoint Presentation from
Staff.
5 .

B
.

Quarterly Recruitment Update
•
PowerPoint Presentation from Staff.
5 .C.

Council Spotlight: Street Pavement and Sidewalk Repair Programs •
PowerPoint Presentation from Staff.

Page 1 of 74 ends
Page 13 of 125 ends

From:

Samantha Pascoe
To:

Samantha Pascoe
Subject:

FW: City of Napa; City Council Meeting 12-5-23; Consent Agenda Item 4L; Communication from Town of Yountville;
Date:

Monday, December 4, 2023 2:05:48 PM
From:

John Ferons <
jferons
Sent:

Monday, December 04, 2023 1:06 PM
To:

Tiffany Carranza <
[email protected]
>
Cc:

Steve Potter <
[email protected]
>; Phil Brun <
[email protected]
>; Brad Raulston
<
braulston
Subject:

City of Napa; City Council Meeting 12-5-23; Consent Agenda Item 4L; Communication from Town of Yountville;
[EXTERNAL]
Hi Tiffany-
I hope this email finds you well.

Happy Holidays to you and yours!

On behalf of the Town of Yountville, could you please forward the email below to your City Council?

It is for an item on their agenda tomorrow afternoon.

Thank you!
John F
Dear Mayor Sedgely and City Councilmembers-
The Town of Yountville respectfully requests your consideration of Consent Item 4L on your December 5
th
City Council Meeting Agenda.

This item to authorize a JPA between the City
of Napa, Town of Yountville and Cal-Vet is an excellent example of shared municipal services amongst local agencies that will greatly improve consistent potable water delivery to the Vet’s Home and the Town of Yountville.

The Town has our own Town Council meeting, tomorrow December 5 th
at 3:00 pm so I will
be unable to attend the Napa City Council Meeting on behalf of the item.

That said, we
have complete faith and trust in your Utility staff to handle any questions that may arise.

As
you are aware, your utility staff are an amazing crew and have been very helpful and informative every step of the way and the Town of Yountville appreciates their expertise and partnership very much.

On behalf of the Town of Yountville, thank you for your consideration of this matter, we look forward to these potential partnerships to better serve all of Napa Valley.

John Ferons
Town of Yountville
Public Works Director
6550 Yount St
Yountville, CA 94599
707.944.8851
Item 4.L.

Page 2 of 74 ends
Page 14 of 125 ends

P
repared by:

Kosmont Companies
D
owntown Parking &
Surplus Land Act (SLA) Briefing
City Council Meeting
D
ecember 5, 2023
12/5/23
City Council
Regular Meeting
Item 5.A.

From: City Staff

Page 3 of 74 ends
Page 15 of 125 ends

Surplus land
connecting various plans and strategies
2 •
Capture
value of future investment and development for ongoing revenue source for major infrastructure projects
•
Focusing on near term priority areas like City owned surplus land Enhanced Infrastructure
Financing District (EIFD)
•

GP LUCD
-
13: “Promote housing and business growth in infill development in focus areas …”
•
GP LUCD 20: “Continue to promote Downtown Napa as an active and vibrant heart of the community”. Includes pedestrian orientation, explore use of publicly
-
owned sites, and promote variety of land uses
General Plan 2040
•
“Prevalence of surface parking lots breaks the urban fabric, creating “holes” in the pedestrian environment with inconsistent street frontages” Downtown Specific Plan
•
HE H2 2.2: “Conversation of Publicly Owned Lands for Housing” with a goal to create a minimum of 22 lower and moderate income housing units by converting publicly owned land.

Housing Element
•
AB 2097 limits the City’s authority to impose or enforce minimum parking requirements on residential, commercial, or other development projects within .5 miles of major transit stop.

State
-
Imposed Changes to
Parking

Page 4 of 74 ends
Page 16 of 125 ends

Background & Purpose
3 •
The City owns several key properties in Downtown currently utilized for parking that have potential for redevelopment
•
The Surplus Land Act (SLA) requires cities to prioritize opportunities for affordable housing •
Successful navigation of the SLA process affords the City an opportunity to prioritize and utilize these properties to fulfill community goals and objectives:
a)
Facilitating blended
-
use development on certain properties, spurring job creation and tax revenue generation (and increasing EIFD funding capacity) b)
Facilitating affordable housing development on certain properties c)
Retaining certain properties for continued public use, such as parking

Page 5 of 74 ends
Page 17 of 125 ends

4 SLA Overview
Origin
In a response to the massive Statewide housing shortage, State Legislature passed
dozens
of housing bills including AB 1486 (which amended the Surplus Land Act) to address this crisis.

Most recently, the Governor signed two new bills (AB 480 and SB 747) in October 2023, which make certain modifications to the SLA that take effect in January 2024.

Purpose
The SLA gives affordable housing developers an opportunity to proposed to purchase any public agency surplus land in the State of California.

Does not necessarily prevent
agencies from
ultimately selling or leasing property for other uses or fair market value.

Mandate
Public Agencies in California (e.g., cities, counties, special districts, school districts, etc.),
with certain exceptions, must follow this mandate prior to selling or leasing
any
surplus public
agency owned real estate.

Process
The SLA requires an up to 180
-
day request for proposal/bid process to solicit affordable housing projects/proposals, which includes a 60
-
day noticing period and 90
-
day good
faith negotiation period.

Page 6 of 74 ends
Page 18 of 125 ends

5 Key SLA Questions
What are they worth?
What is the highest and best use?
What properties do you have?
Do you want housing on these properties?
Do you want to use them for other purposes?
Public Use? Commercial Use? Special Conditions?
Is there an adjacent owner who wants the property?

Page 7 of 74 ends
Page 19 of 125 ends

6 Potential SLA Exemptions
•
Valid Legal Restriction
–

s
uch as conservation easements that prevent housing, existing leases in existing prior to 1/1/2019 (e.g.,

Kohl’s parking lot)
•
Land Destined for Affordable Housing
–

at least 75% units restricted for lower income
families, or a mixed
-
use development with 300+ units and at least 25% restricted for lower income (e.g.,
Jefferson@Trower

property)
•
Land Dedicated for Other Public Uses
–
transferred to another agency or exchanged for
another property for local agency’s use
•
Land Not Suitable for Affordable Housing
–
former street, right
-
of
-
way, easement; small
sites (less than 5k SF or less than 10k SF with no recorded accesses); sold to owner of contiguous land
•
Grandfathered Agreements
–
Cities that entered into an ENA, PSA, DDA or similar
agreement with a buyer prior to September 2019 are exempt from the new SLA rules as long as the property is disposed of by Dec 31, 2022 (relevant due to recent SLA law updates)

Page 8 of 74 ends
Page 20 of 125 ends

7 SLA Law Updates
•
On October 11, 2023, the Governor signed Senate Bill 747 (
“SB 747”) and Assembly Bill 480 (“AB 480”)

into law, which
become effective on January 1, 2024, which further clarify provisions of the Surplus Land Act and are generally as follows:
•
Extends
term of leases.

Public agencies can enter into leases with a term of 15 years or less without triggering the Surplus Land Act (previously 5
-
year term).

If no demolition or development occurs, then the term of the lease can be extended beyond 15 years.
•
New categories of
exempt surplus land

(e.g.,
land less than ½ acre,
land transferred to a community land trust, land
owned by a
public airport where residential use is prohibited,
land sold for affordable housing purposes, public
transportation agencies under certain conditions, land transferred to third party intermediaries). •
Streamlines process for determining
whether land is exempt
–

public agency is not required to make a
declaration at a public meeting for “exempt surplus land”

but must identify the land in a notice that is published and available for public comment.
•
Change in methodology for assessment of penalties for non -
compliance

is now
appraised value or sales price,
whichever is greater. After receiving a notice of violation, the agency must hold an open and public meeting to review and consider the substance of the notice.
•
HCD is
in the process of updating its SLA guidelines, which are anticipated to be issued prior to the end of 2023, which would provide further clarity on HCD's interpretation on the impact of the recent amendments to the SLA.

Page 9 of 74 ends
Page 21 of 125 ends

8 SLA Required Disposition Process
Step 1
•
Direction from the City Council and communication with HCD regarding a draft declaration (request from HCD, technically not a requirement)
Step 2
•
City declares property “surplus” or "exempt surplus" land (at public hearing or published) •
If exempt, then City pursues HCD concurrence by providing written findings •
If not exempt, then City prepares Notice of Availability (NOA) Step 3
•
City sends NOA to qualified affordable housing developers & other required public entities for 60 days
Step 4
•
If "Step 2" responses received, 90
-
day good faith negotiation period commences
•
If no responses received or negotiations at impasse (e.g., FMV), agency may negotiate with other non
-
affordable housing developers
•
Process provides HCD with an opportunity to object, which can take up to 30 days for a Letter of Compliance
Step 5
•
Post HCD Approval, City may dispose of surplus land without regard to SLA •
Agency must still record 15% affordability covenant, which is triggered if 10 or more units Enforcement
: If local agency does not comply with SLA, HCD will impose fine of 30% of “applicable disposition value” for first violation, 50% for second violation (note: funds go to local housing trust fund)

Page 10 of 74 ends
Page 22 of 125 ends

Map of City Downtown Parking Sites
Description
Acreage
Lot A

0.71 Lot B

0.47 Lot I

0.14 Lot X

0.69 3
rd

St Lot

1.53 Lot J

0.27 Second St Garage

0.58 Lot Xw

1.21 Lot GE & Lot H

1.20 Lot GN

0.22 Lot F

0.53 Lot S

0. 35
Pearl St Garage

1.19 Clay St Garage

0.70 9

Page 11 of 74 ends
Page 23 of 125 ends

Map of Parking Sites by Potential SLA Prioritization
Description
Acreage
Lot X

0.69 Lot Xw

1.21 3
rd

St Lot

1.53 Lot J

0.27 Lot S

0. 35
Lot A

0.71 Lot B

0.47 Second St Garage

0.58 Lot GE & Lot H

1.20 Lot GN

0.22 Lot F

0.53 Lot I

0.14 Pearl St Garage

1.19 Clay St Garage

0.70 10
High Medium Low

Page 12 of 74 ends
Page 24 of 125 ends

Second Tier Priority Sites
Description
Acreage
Lot A

0.71 Lot B

0.47 Second St Garage

0.58 11
•
Yellow Second Tier Priority
•
Attached to other
developments:
•
2 nd

St. Garage
– County
•
Lot A and Lot B
–
Franklin Station

Page 13 of 74 ends
Page 25 of 125 ends

High Priority and
Tentative Sites
Description
Acreage
Lot X

0.69 Lot Xw

1.21 12
•
Cinedome
Site with adjacent
properties owned by
SyWest

(176 parking spaces)
•
Zoned Downtown Mixed
-
Use
•
Potential Housing and Mixed
Use
•
Identified in the Downtown
Specific Plan and Masterplan
2018
•
Need to consider:
•
Parking removal
•
Farmer’s Market
CyWest
Lot Xw
Lot X
Vacant City
-
Owned Parcels

Page 14 of 74 ends
Page 26 of 125 ends

High Priority and
Tentative Sites
Description
Acreage
3 rd

St Lot

1.53 13
•
Current surface parking lot (78
parking spaces)
•
Zoned Mixed Use
-
Gateway
•
Potential Housing
•
Further due diligence on site
constraints needed
•
Napa Sanitation
subsurface easement on
east boarder
•
Flood protection
easement north along
property line
•
Considerations:
•
Parking removal
•
Ped Bridge
• NVTA
3rd St. Lot

Page 15 of 74 ends
Page 27 of 125 ends

High Priority and
Tentative Sites
Description
Acreage
Lot J

0.27 14
•
Small surface parking lot on
the riverfront (27 spaces)
•
Zoned Downtown Core
Commercial
•
Potential Commercial and
Mixed Use
•
Considerations:
•
Shared trash enclosure
•
Parking removal
Lot J

Page 16 of 74 ends
Page 28 of 125 ends

High Priority and
Tentative Sites
Description
Acreage
Lot S

0. 35
15 Lot S
•
Surface Parking Lot
a
djacent to Clay Street
Garage (36 parking spaces)
•
Zoned Downtown Mixed
-
Use
•
Potential blended use
•
Considerations:
•
Parking

Page 17 of 74 ends
Page 29 of 125 ends

Potential SLA Site Prioritization
Description
Acreage
Prioritization
Lot X

0.69 High for potential redevelopment (
Cinedome
)
–
can incentivize adjacent owner to act
Lot Xw

1.21 High for potential redevelopment (
Cinedome
)
–
can incentivize adjacent owner to act
3 rd

St Lot

1.53 High for affordable housing
Lot J

0.27 High for potential commercial or blended use
Lot S

0. 35
High for potential blended use
Lot A

0.71 Medium Franklin St Project subject to further exploration / insight from HCD Lot B

0.47 Medium Franklin St Project subject to further exploration / insight from HCD Second St Garage

0.58 Medium subject to County’s relocation (separate SLA process from City process) Lot GE & Lot H

1.20 Low (9/11 Memorial)
Lot GN

0.22 Low (small site adjacent to Heritage Park)
Lot F

0.53 Low (irregular site abutting Napa Creek)
Lot I

0.14 Low (small site)
Pearl St Garage

1.19 Low (retain as public garage)
Clay St Garage

0.70 Low (retain as public garage)
16

Page 18 of 74 ends
Page 30 of 125 ends

17 Potential Benefits
Source of ongoing
revenue for EIFD &
GF
Additional
Affordable Housing
& Commercial
Development
Improvements to
the Downtown
connected to GP
and DTSP
One time funding
for enhancements
(parking garage,
civic center, public
spaces,
etc)

Page 19 of 74 ends
Page 31 of 125 ends

18 Next Steps re: SLA for Downtown Parking Sites

1. Property Inventory
–
Confirm complete

2. P
rioritize, Screen, and Select an Approach
–
Complete in draft format
–
seeking Council confirmation or feedback on draft staff prioritization of properties

3. Implementation (Transparency is Key):

Execute preferred SLA
disposition for high priority properties (e.g., property due diligence (incl. valuation/appraisals), declaration of surplus land, notice of availability to developers)
–
SLA declaration would require action in open Council session

Page 20 of 74 ends
Page 32 of 125 ends

19 Staff Recommendation
Direct Staff to prepare Surplus Land Act disposition plan for high priority properties and return for a future Council meeting with declaration of surplus land.

Page 21 of 74 ends
Page 33 of 125 ends

20 THANK YOU
Questions?
Kosmont Companies
1601 N. Sepulveda Blvd. #382 Manhattan Beach, CA 90266
Ph: (424) 297
-
1070 | Fax: (424) 286
-
4632
www.kosmont.com

Page 22 of 74 ends
Page 34 of 125 ends

Q
uarterly
Recruitment
Update
H
uman Resources
D
ecember 5, 2023
A
TTACHMENT 1
12/5/23 City Council Regular
Meeting
Supplemental
Item 5.B.

From: City Staff

Page 23 of 74 ends
Page 35 of 125 ends

Full
-
Time Recruitment Metrics
(FY22
-
23 Q4 and FY23
-
24 Q1)
Metric
Total
Recruitments Completed
39 Positions Filled
66 Total Current Vacancies
42 Current Active Recruitments
14 2

Page 24 of 74 ends
Page 36 of 125 ends

Part-
Time Recruitment Metrics
(FY22
-
23 Q4 and FY23
-
24 Q1)
Metric
Total
Recruitments Requested
20 Recruitments Completed
20 Positions Filled
44 Upcoming Recruitments
4 3

Page 25 of 74 ends
Page 37 of 125 ends

Employee Turnover
4 0
2 4
6 8
10 12
14 16
18 July - Sept
2022
Oct - Dec
2022
Jan - Mar
2023
Apr - June
2023
July - Sept
2023
Employees

Page 26 of 74 ends
Page 38 of 125 ends

Highlights
36 Promotions in Multiple Depts
(April
–
Present)
5

Page 27 of 74 ends
Page 39 of 125 ends

Highlights
6 Two Benefits Enrollment Periods

Open Benefits Enrollment

Benefits Fair

Special Benefits Enrollment

Paperless, interactive, informative, FUN!

Page 28 of 74 ends
Page 40 of 125 ends

Highlights
7 Employee Wellness Week
October 9
–
October 13

Page 29 of 74 ends
Page 41 of 125 ends

Highlights
Job Fairs & Hiring Events

Napa Valley College

Napa County Committee on Disabilities

CareerPoint Napa
8

Page 30 of 74 ends
Page 42 of 125 ends

Highlights
9 Employee Engagement Survey
-
Second Annual

Information Sessions

Surveyed 9/25
–
10/8

Town Hall Meetings

Increased Participation

Page 31 of 74 ends
Page 43 of 125 ends

Highlights
Ongoing Employee Trainings and
Continuous Learning Opportunities

Race Forward & GARE Workshops

Specialized DEI Training

LCW
Consortium Monthly Webinar Series

Preventing Workplace Harassment Training

DEI Training Year 3
–
Coming Soon!

Manager & Supervisor Academies
–
Coming Soon!

1:1 Employee Development Trainings
–
Coming Soon
!
10

Page 32 of 74 ends
Page 44 of 125 ends

11 Mid-
Manager’s
Quarterly Meeting &
Mid-
Manager’s Retreat

Page 33 of 74 ends
Page 45 of 125 ends

12 Mission Statement &
Core Values
Implementation
Highlights

Page 34 of 74 ends
Page 46 of 125 ends

THANK YOU!
13

Page 35 of 74 ends
Page 47 of 125 ends

P
resentation Focus
•
S
treet pavement and sidewalk repair
projects completed by City crews
–
N
apa Neighborhood Street and Sidewalk
Program
•
U
pcoming Capital Improvement Projects
–
E
ngineering staff design, contractor
construction
12/5/23 City Council
Regular Meeting
Supplemental - Item 5.C.

From: City Staff

Page 36 of 74 ends
Page 48 of 125 ends

NAPA NEIGHBORHOOD

STREETS AND SIDEWALKS

PROGRAM
Peter Brestak, Public Works Operations Manager

Page 37 of 74 ends
Page 49 of 125 ends

CONCRETE COMPLETED IN 2023
•
Waverly
•
Yards: 127
•
Equivalent to approximately
2 ,500 ft of sidewalk, curb and
gutter and ADA ramps
•
Stonehouse
•
Yards: 678
•
Equivalent to approximately
13,
500 ft of sidewalk, curb and
gutter and ADA ramps
•
Miscellaneous projects and repairs

Page 38 of 74 ends
Page 50 of 125 ends
Page 39 of 74 ends
Page 51 of 125 ends
Page 40 of 74 ends
Page 52 of 125 ends
Page 41 of 74 ends
Page 53 of 125 ends
Page 42 of 74 ends
Page 54 of 125 ends

Sidewalk Repair Overview
Sidewalk damage can be reported through the
Service Center
–
Asphalt Patch (temp)
–
Sidewalk Shaving
–
Neighborhood Schedule (City
C
rew) Replacement
–
Cost Share Program
–
CIP Projects
–
Private Development Projects

Page 43 of 74 ends
Page 55 of 125 ends

Paving Completed in 2023
•
Stonehouse/Adrian
–
45% Complete
–
Total Tonnage: 3,525
•
South Franklin
–
99% Complete
–
Total Tonnage: 6,926
•
Monarch/Paulson
–
100% Complete
–
Total Tonnage: 542
•
Waverly
–
100% Complete
–
Total Tonnage: 904

Page 44 of 74 ends
Page 56 of 125 ends
Page 45 of 74 ends
Page 57 of 125 ends
Page 46 of 74 ends
Page 58 of 125 ends
Page 47 of 74 ends
Page 59 of 125 ends
Page 48 of 74 ends
Page 60 of 125 ends

Signs and Striping Division
•
Thermal striping and
P
ainting completed with
NNSSP
•
Speed Reduction and
T
raffic Change Orders
•
Other duties for
dow
ntown graffiti,
downtown hardscapes,
garages, supporting
internal services

Page 49 of 74 ends
Page 61 of 125 ends
Page 50 of 74 ends
Page 62 of 125 ends
Page 51 of 74 ends
Page 63 of 125 ends
Page 52 of 74 ends
Page 64 of 125 ends
Page 53 of 74 ends
Page 65 of 125 ends
Page 54 of 74 ends
Page 66 of 125 ends
Page 55 of 74 ends
Page 67 of 125 ends
Page 56 of 74 ends
Page 68 of 125 ends

CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT

PROGRAM

STREETS PROJECTS
Ian Heid, Senior Civil Engineer

Page 57 of 74 ends
Page 69 of 125 ends

Capital Improvement Projects
Completed Projects
•
Jefferson Street Rehab
•
Freeway Drive
•
Vine Trail Crossings
•
Yajome

S
idewalk and
Drainage Repairs
•
Kennedy Park Pathways
•
SR
-
29 Undercrossing*
Upcoming Projects
•
Salvador Complete Streets
•
Laurel Street Phase I
•
Westwood Interior Streets
•
Browns Valley Road
•
Coombs Street
•
Lincoln Ave

Page 58 of 74 ends
Page 70 of 125 ends

Jefferson Street Rehabilitation

Page 59 of 74 ends
Page 71 of 125 ends

Freeway Drive Rehabilitation

Page 60 of 74 ends
Page 72 of 125 ends

Vine Trail Crossing Improvements

Page 61 of 74 ends
Page 73 of 125 ends

Yajome

Street Sidewalk and
Drainage Repairs

Page 62 of 74 ends
Page 74 of 125 ends

Kennedy Park Pathway Repairs

Page 63 of 74 ends
Page 75 of 125 ends

SR-
29 Undercrossing

Page 64 of 74 ends
Page 76 of 125 ends

Salvador Complete Streets
•
Byway East to Jefferson
•
Pavement resurfacing
•
Sidewalk gap closures
•
ADA improvements
•
New striping
–
Class II bike lanes
–
New crosswalks with
fl
ashing beacons
–
Traffic calming
•
Drainage upgrades

Page 65 of 74 ends
Page 77 of 125 ends

Laurel Street Phase I
•
Browns Valley Road to Griggs
•
Pavement resurfacing
•
New striping
–
Class II bike lanes
–
Two new crosswalks with flashing beacons
•
Sidewalk, drainage, and ADA improvements
•
Limited on
-
s
treet parking removal
•
Some utility relocations

Page 66 of 74 ends
Page 78 of 125 ends

Browns Valley Road
•
Westview to SR29
•
Pavement resurfacing
•
Class IV Bike Path
•
Sidewalk gap closures
•
ADA improvements
•
Updating striping and
s
ignage
•
Local Roadway Safety
P
lan High Injury
Network
•
Pedestrian flashing
beac
on installation

Page 67 of 74 ends
Page 79 of 125 ends

Westwood Interior Streets
•
Continuous sidewalk
on
one side
•
Parking on two sides
•
Two
-
w
ay travel on all
streets
•
Minimal impacts to
pr
ivate properties

Page 68 of 74 ends
Page 80 of 125 ends

Coombs Street
•
Imola

t
o 5
th

Street
•
Pavement rehabilitation
•
Sidewalk repairs
•
Bicycle Plan study
c
orridor
Lincoln Ave
•
SR
-
29 to Silverado
•
Pavement rehabilitation
•
Sidewalk repairs

Page 69 of 74 ends
Page 81 of 125 ends

Silverado 5
-
Way
•
Multi
-
m
ode improvements at 5
-
way intersection
•
Partnering with Caltrans
–
Developing cooperative agreement for design and environmental r
eview; City to lead

Page 70 of 74 ends
Page 82 of 125 ends

Service Center
The Service Center is the most effective
way to report an issue.

Page 71 of 74 ends
Page 83 of 125 ends

Service Center

Page 72 of 74 ends
Page 84 of 125 ends

Our Team

Page 73 of 74 ends
Page 85 of 125 ends

Q & A

Page 74 of 74 ends
Page 86 of 125 ends

ATTACHMENT 2

SUPPLEMENTAL REPORTS &
COMMUNICATIONS Office of the City Clerk
City Council of the City of Napa

Regular Meeting
December 5, 2023

FOR THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NAPA

EVENING

SESSION:

SUBMITTED PRIOR TO THE CITY COUNCI
L

MEETING

1 1
.

COMMISSION INTERVIEWS AND APPOINTMENTS
:
1 1
.

A
.

Planning Commission Membership
•
Link of recorded
statement from applicant Richard Tippitt

for his application to the Planning
Commission.

https://www.veed.io/view/74373dfa
-
75c1
-
4b17
-
ae95
-
65057164a348?panel=share
1)
Email from
Gordon Huether

received on
November 30
, 2023
2)
Email from
Bob Massaro

received on
December 1
, 2023
3)
Email from
Alexander Myers

received on
December 4
, 2023

13. ADMINISTRATIVE REPORTS:

13.A. Fiscal Year 2022/23 End of Year Report Update
–

Unaudited
•
PowerPoint Presentation from Staff.
•
Memo from Raj Prasad, City of Napa Finance Director, received on December 1, 2023 regarding correction.

Page 1 of 39 ends
Page 87 of 125 ends

From:

Mary Luros
To:

Clerk
Subject:

Fwd: 3 planning commissioners
Date:

Friday, December 1, 2023 3:05:37 PM
Begin forwarded message:

From:

Gordon Huether <
[email protected]
>
Subject: 3 planning commissioners
Date:

November 30, 2023 at 8:00:04 AM PST
Cc:

Mary Luros <
[email protected]
>, Liz Alessio
"
beth
" <
,
Bernie Narvaez <
[email protected]
>, Scott Sedgley
<
[email protected]
>
[EXTERNAL]
Greetings Friends,

As you know you have 3 Planning Commissioner appointments coming up next week and
I’m writing to give you a little feedback understanding that these appointments are entirely in your hands.

I would be delighted to continue to serve with Beverly Shotwell. She is always well prepared and thoughtful in her comments and decisions.

I would also be happy to continue to serve with Paul Kelley … as you know he is one of two designated design professionals as mandated by council.

Lastly, I understand that Alex Meyers is applying. The benefit of working with Alex is that he has served before and has experience. He’s very knowledgeable and professional.

Have a wonderful weekend!

Gordon

Gordon Huether

Gordon Huether Studio
1821 Monticello Road |

Napa, CA 94558
t: 707 255 5954 |

f: 707 255 5991

[email protected]
www.gordonhuether.com
art matters
Item 11.A.

Page 2 of 39 ends
Page 88 of 125 ends

From:

Mary Luros
To:

Clerk
Subject:

Fwd: PC Appointments
Date:

Friday, December 1, 2023 3:05:13 PM
Begin forwarded message:

From:

Bob Massaro
Subject: PC Appointments
Date:

December 1, 2023 at 1:42:17 PM PST
To:

Bob Massaro
[EXTERNAL]
(Bcc’d to Council Members)
Hello Members of Council.

I would like to pass along my recommendations for the 3 open seats on the Planning Commission.

1. Lilea Duran - I have known her for about 3 years. She is intelligent, engaged and a strong contributing member of our community. She communicates very well (and she is bi-lingual). I think she would be a great addition to the Commission.

2. Paul Kelley - I was pleased to see that Paul wants to extend his service on the Commission. He is insightful and brings a tremendous amount of institutional knowledge to the P.C. The fact that he is a practicing Architect is also quite beneficial.

3. Beverly Shotwell - I have served with her over the past 2 years. She is very detailed oriented, passionate about historic buildings, and is not afraid to speak her mind. Her participation has always been of value.

Thank you for considering these three recommendations.

Kind Regards
Bob
p.s. Thanks again to each of you for appointing me to the Commission. I have tried to do my best and to bring my perspective to the job. I am looking forward to another year of service.

Page 3 of 39 ends
Page 89 of 125 ends

Alexander J. Myers, Esq.

Napa, CA

WORK EXPERIENCE

Myers, Jameson & Myers, LLP; Partner (2019
-
present)

•

Co
-
founder and partner of regional business and real estate firm practicing across the North Bay
.

•

Focus on representing
small business owners,
property managers, asset managers, owners and
developers

of real property
.

•

Business and
real property
transactions practitioner, completing business sales, mergers, formations, and succession; preparation and negotiation of contracts.

Little Ivy Childcare, LLC (2018
-
present)

•

Co
-
owner and co
-
founder of Little Ivy Preschool, a child care center for children ages two through five
.

•

Located
in downtown Napa, caring for up to 52 children

with eight employees
.

•

Providing care for underserved communities by reserving 10% of enrollment for families receiving low income government aid
.

•

Two additional locations in
-
progress to open in 2024, 2025 respectively
.

Myers & Associates, LLP; Partner (2014
-
2019)

•

Partner and manager of real estate and business transactions practice in Napa County.

Prior Work Experience

•

Trigild, Inc. real property asset management and receiver, Associate General Counsel (2012 -
2014)

•

Gaw Van Male, Associate Attorney

(2010
-
2012)

•

Wermers Properties; Real Estate Acquisitions Analyst

(2009
-
2010)

•

CBRE; Commercial Brokerage Assistant

(2008)

•

Apartment Association of Greater Los Angeles; Government Relations Coordinator

(2005
-
2007)

EDUCATION

University of San Diego School of Law, Juris Doctor (2010)

University of San Diego School of Business, M.S., Real Estate

(2010)

Cornell University, Summer Law Institute

in

Suzhou, China

(2008)

University of Southern California, B.S. Political Science, Minor, Business Administration

(2007)

Licensed California Real Estate Broker

(active),
LEED G.A. (inactive)

ORGANIZATIONS

Board Member, Little Scholars Napa 501(c)(3)
, recently formed non
-
profit to provide access to child care
resources for families in need
,

including families who are survivors of domestic violence.

(current)

Napa Sunrise Rotary Club (
current member, f
mr. Board member)

Napa County Housing Commissioner (fmr.)

City of Napa Planning Commissioner
(fmr.)

Page 4 of 39 ends
Page 90 of 125 ends

City Hall: 955 School Street, Napa CA 94559

Mailing Address: P.O. Box 660, Napa CA 94559

(707) 257
-
950
3 

www.cityofnapa.org

M E M O

TO:

Mayor and City Council
M
embers

FROM:

Raj Prasad
,

Finance Director

DATE:

December

1 , 2023

SUBJECT:

Correction to Agenda Item
13 .A
-

Fiscal Year 2022
/
23 End of Year
Report

Update
-

Unaudited

Subsequent to

publishing the
agenda material for the
December

5 ,
2023,

City Council
meeting,
an edit

to
Agenda Item
13 .A
–

Fiscal Year 202
2/
23 End of
Year Report
Update
–

Unaudited was

identified.

END OF

YEAR FINAN

CIAL REPORT

(Attachment
1 )

1. The General Fund
Reserves

Table on page
7 of
1 6

has been updated as follows:

FY 2022/23
Beginning
Balance Usage Transfers In
FY 2022/23
Ending
Balance
Emergency Reserve 15.40 - 0.13 15.52 Operating Reserve 4.94 - 0.61 5.54 Contingency Reserve 0.99 - 0.12 1.11 CIP Facilities Reserve 6.75 - 0.10 6.85 CIP General Fund Projects Reserve 3.73 - - 3.73 Total Reserves 31.80 - 0.95 32.75 Reserves
(in millions)

Page 5 of 39 ends
Page 91 of 125 ends

E
nd of Year Report
FY 2022/23
12/5/23 City Council Regular Meeting
Supplemental - Item No. 13.A.

From: City Staff

Page 6 of 39 ends
Page 92 of 125 ends

PURPOSE
•
Update Council & Community on the
F
inancial Status of the City as of
June
30, 2023
2

Page 7 of 39 ends
Page 93 of 125 ends

Overview of FY 2022/23
•
City revenues recovered from the Covid
dow
nturn faster than originally projected
•
General Fund revenues ended the year
$10.
7 million over budget
–
Includes $7.8 million in unrealized gains
•
General Fund expenditures were under
budget
due to supply chain issues and
high staffing vacancies
3

Page 8 of 39 ends
Page 94 of 125 ends

Economic Outlook
•
Increase in sales tax and transient
occupancy t
ax (TOT) due to consumers
excited to get out and spend as the
pandemic appeared to wane
•
Property tax increase due to increased
hom
e sales
•
Exceptionally strong fiscal year, but do
not
expect growth to continue at this rate
•
City’s financial consultants expect
pl
ateau/ slower growth
4

Page 9 of 39 ends
Page 95 of 125 ends

FISCAL YEAR
-
END

CLOSING PROCESS
5

Page 10 of 39 ends
Page 96 of 125 ends

Year
-
End Closing Process
July
–
September
: pay invoices, accrue revenue
and expenses, book adjusting entries
October
: auditor review of draft financial
statements
November
: final closing entries posted; begin
financial report preparation
December:

finalize financial reports and
submit to GFOA
January/February
: present financial reports to
Council
6

Page 11 of 39 ends
Page 97 of 125 ends

Year
-
End Closing Process
•
All amounts presented to Council today
are
u
naudited estimates
•
Final numbers in the financial reports will
be
slightly different
7

Page 12 of 39 ends
Page 98 of 125 ends

More than Revenues &
Expenditures!
•
The financial reports include
a
ll

City
accounts
–
Revenues and Expenditures
–
Assets, Liabilities, Fund Balance
•
Closing Entries are posted to the different
account
s in accordance with GAAP
8

Page 13 of 39 ends
Page 99 of 125 ends

FY 2022/23 UNAUDITED

FINANCIAL STATUS REPORT
9

Page 14 of 39 ends
Page 100 of 125 ends

GENERAL FUND
10

Page 15 of 39 ends
Page 101 of 125 ends

FY 2022/23 General Fund
Budget
•
Original budget adopted June 2022
•
Increased revenue/expenditure budgets
a
t Mid
-
Year in April 2023 based on strong
revenue growth
•
Strong revenues and under
-
budget

expenditures resulted in projected
available fund balance of $6.6 million
11

Page 16 of 39 ends
Page 102 of 125 ends

Revenue Trends
12 35
17 17
21 8
38 19
12 19
6 41
22 29
21 2
43 23
31 28
-

5.00 10.00

15.00 20.00

25.00 30.00

35.00 40.00

45.00 50.00
Property Tax
Sales Tax
Transient
Occupancy Tax
Other Operating
Revenues
Non-Operating
Revenues
Revenues FY20
-
FY23
FY 2019/20 Actual
FY 2020/21 Actual
FY 2021/22 Actual
FY 2022/23 Actual

Page 17 of 39 ends
Page 103 of 125 ends

FY 2022/23 Revenues &
Expenditures
13 115.93
115.97
126.68
109.65

50.00 60.00

70.00 80.00

90.00 100.00
110.00
120.00
130.00
140.00
Revenue
Expenditures
Budget
Actual

Page 18 of 39 ends
Page 104 of 125 ends

FY 2022/23 General Fund
Revenue
Budget
Actual
YTD %
Property Tax

40.99 42.93

104.7%
Sales Tax

22.21 22.58

101.6%
Transient Occupancy Tax

31.03 30.88

99.5%
Business License Tax

3.73 4.62

123.9%
Charges for Services

6.15 5.69

92.6%
Licenses and Permits

2.49 3.00

120.4%
Other Operating Revenues

7.34 14.98

204.2%
Non-Operating Revenues

2.00 2.00

100.0%
Total Operating Revenue
115.93

126.68

109.3%
14

Page 19 of 39 ends
Page 105 of 125 ends

FY 2022/23 General Fund
Expenditures
Budget
Actual
YTD %
Salaries & Wages & Benefits

81. 85

79.09 96.6%
Materials & Supplies & Services

29.02 25.97

89.5%
Other Expenditures (Includes
Transfers to Reserves)

5.10 4.59

89.9%
Total Operating Expenditures
115.97

109.64

94.5%
15

Page 20 of 39 ends
Page 106 of 125 ends

FY 2022/23 Reserves
•
Operating Reserve: $5.54 million
–
Target: 5% of operating expenditures
•
Emergency Reserve: $15.52 million
–
Target: 14% of operating expenditures
•
Contingency Reserve: $1.11 million
–
Target: 1% of operating expenditures
16

Page 21 of 39 ends
Page 107 of 125 ends

CIP PROJECT FUND
17

Page 22 of 39 ends
Page 108 of 125 ends

FY 2022/23 CIP Reserves
•
CIP Facilities Reserve
–
$3.73 million ending balance for current and
f
uture projects
–
Per Fiscal Policy, will also receive end of year
av
ailable fund balance from General Fund and
Non
-
Recurring General Fund
•
CIP General Reserve
–
$6.85 million ending balance for current and
f
uture projects
18

Page 23 of 39 ends
Page 109 of 125 ends

PENSION & POST
-

EMPLOYMENT BENEFITS FUND
19

Page 24 of 39 ends
Page 110 of 125 ends

Section 115 Trust
•
Created to help mitigate increases in
f
uture pension costs
•
Balance at 6/30/23: $5.0 million
•
Planned usage in FY24 to offset UAL
P
ayment
20 $0.00
$2.00
$4.00
$6.00
$8.00
$10.00
$12.00
$14.00
$16.00
$18.00
Annual CalPERS UAL Payments, in millions
Misc
Safety

Page 25 of 39 ends
Page 111 of 125 ends

ENTERPRISE FUNDS
21

Page 26 of 39 ends
Page 112 of 125 ends

Enterprise Funds
–
Solid Waste
FY 2022/23
Amended
B
udget
(as of 6/30/2023)
FY 2022/23
Actual
(as of
6/30/2023)
% to date
(Budget to
A
ctual)
Revenues
Refuse Collection Charges

29. 15

30.13 103%
MDF Gate Fees

4.42 4.78

108%
Material Sales

9.98 9.23

92%
Other Revenues

0.23 (0.44)

-188%
Total Revenues

43.79 43.70

100%
Expenditures
Salaries and Benefits

1.61 1.48

92%
Contractor Service

31.33 30.61

98%
Transfer Station Disposal Fees

3.74 3.51

94%
MDF Facility Materials

2.80 2.46

88%
Debt Service

0.87 0.29

34%
Other Materials, Supplies & Services

4.01 4.31

107%
Administrative Support

0.66 0.66

100%
Transfer Out to Street Resurfacing

1.15 1.15

100%
Transfer Out to SWR CIP Fund

0.73 0.73

100%
Transfer Out to SWR Non-Recurring Fund

2.37 2.37

100%
Total Expenditures

49.28 47.57

97%
Fund Balance for Carryforwards

3.80 3.80

Surplus / (Deficit)
(1.70)

(0.07)

Solid Waste & Recycling Operating Fund
22

Page 27 of 39 ends
Page 113 of 125 ends

Enterprise Funds
–
Solid Waste
23 40.00

41.00 42.00

43.00 44.00

45.00 46.00

47.00 48.00

49.00 50.00
Operating Revenues
Operating Expenditures
Millions
SWR
-
Operating Fund
Budgeted
Actual

Page 28 of 39 ends
Page 114 of 125 ends

Enterprise Funds
–
Solid Waste
24 -

0.50 1.00

1.50 2.00

2.50 3.00

3.50 4.00

4.50 Non-Recurring Revenues
Non-Recurring Expenditures
Millions
SWR
- Non-
Recurring Fund
Budgeted
Actual

Page 29 of 39 ends
Page 115 of 125 ends

Enterprise Funds
–
Water
FY 2022/23
Amended
Budget
(as of
6/30/2023)
FY 2022/23
Actual
(as of
6/30/2023)
% to date
(Budget to
Actual)
Revenues
Charges for Services

35.07 34.94

100%
Other Revenues

0.73 0.75

103%
Total Revenues

35.80 35.69

100%
Expenditures
Salaries and Benefits

11.76 9.99

85%
Services, Materials and Supplies

9.33 12.02

129%
NBA Water Supply

10.59 8.69

82%
Administrative Support

1.91 1.91

100%
Water Bond Debt Service

3.33 3.33

100%
Transfer Out to Water CIP Fund

5.09 5.09

100%
Transfer Out to Water Non-Recurring Fund
-

-

n/a
Transfer Out to Fleet

0.06 0.06

100%
Total Expenditures

42.05 41.07

98%
Surplus / (Deficit)
(6.25)

(5.38)

Water Operating Fund
25

Page 30 of 39 ends
Page 116 of 125 ends

Enterprise Funds
–
Water
26 32.00

34.00 36.00

38.00 40.00

42.00 44.00
Operating Revenues
Operating Expenditures
Millions
Water
-
Operating Fund
Budgeted
Actual

Page 31 of 39 ends
Page 117 of 125 ends

Enterprise Funds
–
Water
27 -

2.00 4.00

6.00 8.00

10.00 12.00

14.00 16.00

18.00 CIP Revenues
CIP Expenditures
Millions
Water
-
Capital Improvement Project Fund
Budgeted
Actual

Page 32 of 39 ends
Page 118 of 125 ends

Enterprise Funds
–
Water
28 -

2.00 4.00

6.00 8.00

10.00 12.00

14.00 Non-Recurring Revenues
Non-Recurring Expenditures
Millions
Water
-
Non
-
Recurring Fund
Budgeted
Actual

Page 33 of 39 ends
Page 119 of 125 ends

OPERATING POSITION:

GENERAL FUND &
NON
-

RECURRING GENERAL FUND
29

Page 34 of 39 ends
Page 120 of 125 ends

FY 2022/23 General Fund
Operating Position
30 FY
2022/23
Budget
FY
2022/23
Actual
General Fund
($ in millions)
Total Revenues
115.9

126.7

-
Operating Expenditures
116.0

109.6

-
Contributions to General Fund Reserves
-

0.9 Projected Surplus/ Deficit
(0.0)

16.2 -
Mark-to-Market Adjustment
-

9.6 Available Fund Balance
(0.0)

6.6

Page 35 of 39 ends
Page 121 of 125 ends

FY 2022/23 NR General Fund
Operating Position
31 FY
2022/23
Budget
FY
2022/23
Actual
Non-Recurring General Fund
($ in millions)
Beginning Fund Balance

6.5 6.5

Revenues

10.3 6.1

Expenditures

12.5 6.0

Projected Ending Fund Balance

4.3 6.6

Page 36 of 39 ends
Page 122 of 125 ends

What We Are Looking At:
32 Property Tax
Transient
Occupancy Tax
(TOT)
Sales Tax
Investment
Market
ERAF
Vacancy
Factor

Page 37 of 39 ends
Page 123 of 125 ends

End of Year Report
FY 2022/23

Page 38 of 39 ends
Page 124 of 125 ends

City Hall: 955 School Street, Napa CA 94559

Mailing Address: P.O. Box 660, Napa CA 94559

(707) 257
-
950
3 

www.cityofnapa.org

M E M O

TO:

Mayor and City Council
M
embers

FROM:

Raj Prasad
,

Finance Director

DATE:

December

1 , 2023

SUBJECT:

Correction to Agenda Item
13 .A
-

Fiscal Year 2022
/
23 End of Year
Report

Update
-

Unaudited

Subsequent to

publishing the
agenda material for the
December

5 ,
2023,

City Council
meeting,
an edit

to
Agenda Item
13 .A
–

Fiscal Year 202
2/
23 End of
Year Report
Update
–

Unaudited was

identified.

END OF

YEAR FINAN

CIAL REPORT

(Attachment
1 )

1. The General Fund
Reserves

Table on page
7 of
1 6

has been updated as follows:

FY 2022/23
Beginning
Balance Usage Transfers In
FY 2022/23
Ending
Balance
Emergency Reserve 15.40 - 0.13 15.52 Operating Reserve 4.94 - 0.61 5.54 Contingency Reserve 0.99 - 0.12 1.11 CIP Facilities Reserve 6.75 - 0.10 6.85 CIP General Fund Projects Reserve 3.73 - - 3.73 Total Reserves 31.80 - 0.95 32.75 Reserves
(in millions)
Item 13.A.

Page 39 of 39 ends
Page 125 of 125 ends
← All documents from this meeting