View Attachment C — Rules & Legislation Committee, July 10, 2025

Citywide Security Services RFP
Proposal Review
Detailed Contractor Information and Scores

ATTACHMENT C
Total # of Proposals: 11
Total # of Companies/Firms Attended Mandatory Pre-Proposal Meeting: 10 Total # Companies/Firms Compliant w/ Oakland L/SLBE Requirements: 5 List of Companies / Firms to be invited:

A-1 Protective Services
ABC Security Services, Inc.

Allied Universal Security Services
Inter-Con Security
Marina Securities Services, Inc.

A-1 Protective
Services
Mandatory
Meeting
Attendance (Y or
N)
L/SLBE Compliant
(Y or N)
Unarmed
Hourly Billing
Rate
Patrol Hourly
Billing Rate
Armed
Hourly Billing
Rate Annual Estimated Cost
3-Year Estimated
Total Contract
Amount Proposed
5-Year Estimated
Total Contract
Amount Proposed
Relevant
Experience
(30 Points)
Project
Approach
(15 Points)
Project
Organization
(15 Points)
Qualifications (20
Points)
Estimated
Proposal Costs
(15 Points)
Other Factors
(5 Points)
L/SLBE Bonus
(Up to 12.5
Points)
Total
Rater #1 27 12 11 18 15 1 2 86
Rater #2 28 11 10 17 14 2 2 84
Rater #3 28 11 11 18 14 3 2 87
Rater #4 26 10 11 18 14 2 2 83
Total
Average 85.0
ABC Security
Services, Inc.

Mandatory
Meeting
Attendance (Y or
N)
L/SLBE Compliance
(Y or N)
Unarmed
Hourly Wage
Patrol Hourly
Wage
Armed
Hourly Wage Annual Estimated Cost
3-Year Estimated
Total Contract
Amount Proposed
5-Year Estimated
Total Contract
Amount Proposed
Relevant
Experience
(30 Points)
Project
Approach
(15 Points)
Project
Organization
(15 Points)
Qualifications (20
Points)
Estimated
Proposal Costs
(15 Points)
Other Factors
(5 Points)
L/SLBE Bonus
(Up to 12.5
Points)
Total
Rater #1 20 10 8 16 10 3 0 67
Rater #2 22 9 9 16 10 3 0 69
Rater #3 18 7 7 14 10 1 0 57
Rater #4 18 7 8 13 10 2 0 58
Total
Average 62.8
Allied Universal
Security Services
Mandatory
Meeting
Attendance (Y or
N)
L/SLBE Compliance
(Y or N)
Unarmed
Hourly Wage
Patrol Hourly
Wage
Armed
Hourly Wage Annual Estimated Cost
3-Year Estimated
Total Contract
Amount Proposed
5-Year Estimated
Total Contract
Amount Proposed
Relevant
Experience
(30 Points)
Project
Approach
(15 Points)
Project
Organization
(15 Points)
Qualifications (20
Points)
Estimated
Proposal Costs
(15 Points)
Other Factors
(5 Points)
L/SLBE Bonus
(Up to 12.5
Points)
Total
Rater #1 29 14 14 19 9 4 5.5 94.5
Rater #2 30 13 14 20 9 5 5.5 96.5
Rater #3 30 14 15 20 9 5 5.5 98.5
Rater #4 29 14 14 19 9 4 5.5 94.5
Total
Average 96.0
$ 14,849,566.68
$ 19,214,988.00
$ 24,983,797.54 $ 41.72 $ 49.31 $ 63.25 $ 7,997,218.06 $ 43,398,520.88 YES YES $ 31.88 $ 36.02 $ 44.50 $ 6,404,996.00 $ 32,024,980.00 $ 31.82 $ 35.82 $ 49.00 $ 4,949,855.56 $ 24,749,277.80 YES
Not Fully
Compliant -100%
of Project Work to
be performed by
ABC (LBE only
certified)
YES YES - 50% to
SLBE
Citywide Security Services RFP
Proposal Review
Detailed Contractor Information and Scores

ATTACHMENT C
Inter-Con Security
Mandatory
Meeting
Attendance (Y or
N)
L/SLBE Compliance
(Y or N)
Unarmed
Hourly Wage
Patrol Hourly
Wage
Armed
Hourly Wage Annual Estimated Cost
3-Year Estimated
Total Contract
Amount Proposed
5-Year Estimated
Total Contract
Amount Proposed
Relevant
Experience
(30 Points)
Project
Approach
(15 Points)
Project
Organization
(15 Points)
Qualifications (20
Points)
Estimated
Proposal Costs
(15 Points)
Other Factors
(5 Points)
L/SLBE Bonus
(Up to 12.5
Points)
Total
Rater #1 24 12 12 15 8 2 5 78
Rater #2 20 12 12 14 9 3 5 75
Rater #3 23 12 13 18 9 3 5 83
Rater #4 22 12 12 16 9 3 5 79
Total
Average 78.8
Marina Securities
Services, Inc.

Rules & Legislation CommitteeJuly 10, 2025

Rules & Legislation Committee
July 10, 2025