Agenda packet — Oroville City Council, August 2, 2022 (part 2 of 2)

CITY OF OROVILLE

STAFF REPORT
TO: MAYOR REYNOLDS AND CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS
FROM: DAWN NEVERS, ASSISTANT COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR RE: ANNUAL ASSESSMENTS FOR THE CITY’S CONSOLIDATED

LANDSCAPE AND LIGHTING MAINTENANCE ASSESSMENT DISTRICT, ZONES 2-6, 8-10, 12-15, 18
DATE: AUGUST 2, 2022

SUMMARY
The Council will hold a public hearing approving the Annual Assessment Report and declaring its intention to levy and collect assessments for the Oroville Consolidated Landscape and Lighting Maintenance Assessment District for Fiscal Year 2022/23.

DISCUSSION
As a condition of approval for each subdivision identified below, the developer was required to establish or annex into a landscape and lighting maintenance assessment district. Each subdivision represents a Zone within the larger district. Each Zone is financially responsible for the maintenance of the landscaped areas dedicated to the City and for the cost of maintaining the City owned street lights within the subdivision. The particular Zones within the City’s Consolidated Landscape and Lighting Maintenance Assessment District (“CLLMAD”) are identified below:

Page 2 ends

The City Council will consider the following items for all eighteen Zones within the CLLMAD:

1. Preliminarily approve the Annual Assessment Report and the proposed levy and collection of assessments for the CLLMAD for Fiscal Year 2022/23.

2. Direct Staff to make any changes or amendments to the report as necessary.

3. Approve the Resolution of Intent which sets the date for a public hearing for the August 2, 2022 City Council Meeting. At that time, the City Council will conduct a public hearing on these matters and may confirm the Annual Levy Report and Assessments.

FISCAL IMPACT
Assessments are collected for the City of Oroville by the Butte County Tax Collector to reimburse the City for the costs of operating, maintaining and servicing the landscape and lighting improvements within the CLLMAD.

RECOMMENDATION
Adopt Resolution No. 9087 - A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL AUTHORIZING AND

DIRECTING THE MAYOR TO APPROVE THE ANNUAL ASSESSMENT REPORT, AS

SUBMITTED OR AMENDED, AND TO ORDER THE LEVY AND COLLECTION OF

ASSESSMENTS FOR THE OROVILLE CONSOLIDATED LANDSCAPE AND LIGHTING MAINTENANCE ASSESSMENT DISTRICT FOR FISCAL YEAR 2022/23; and Authorize any necessary budget adjustments to the Annual Assessment Report.

ATTACHMENTS
Resolution No. 9087
2022/23 Assessment Summary from the CLLMAD Annual Assessment Report.

NOTE: In order to reduce copying costs, only the Assessment Summary of the Annual Assessment Report is attached to this staff report. The full Annual Assessment Report for the CLLMAD is available for review in the City Clerk’s office 198
Item 13.

Page 1 of 3 ends

CITY OF OROVILLE
RESOLUTION NO. 9087

A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL AUTHORIZING AND DIRECTING THE

MAYOR TO APPROVE THE ANNUAL ASSESSMENT REPORT, AS SUBMITTED OR

AMENDED, AND TO ORDER THE LEVY AND COLLECTION OF ASSESSMENTS FOR

THE OROVILLE CONSOLIDATED LANDSCAPE AND LIGHTING MAINTENANCE ASSESSMENT DISTRICT FOR FISCAL YEAR 2022/23
WHEREAS, the Oroville City Council, pursuant to the terms of the “Landscaping and Lighting Act of 1972” (the 1972 Act”), Division 15, Part 2, Chapter 1, Article 1 of the Streets and Highways Code of the State of California (Section 22645 et seq.) did by previous Resolutions, initiate proceedings and approve the Annual Assessment Report (the “Report”), on a preliminary basis, for the special maintenance district known and designated as “The Oroville Consolidated Landscape and Lighting Maintenance Assessment District” (the “District”). The District is comprised of several Zones which are identified below:

ZONE ZONE
Zone 2 – The Buttes Zone 10 – Foothill Estates
Zone 3 – Deer Creek Estates, Phase 1 Zone 12 – Vista Del Oro Zone 4 – Calle Vista 1 Zone 13 – Calle Vista 2
Zone 5 – Cherokee Estates, Phase 1 Zone 14 – Martin Ranch Zone 6 – Sherwood Zone 15 – Jake Richter Estates
Zone 8 – Cherokee Estates, Phase 2 Zone 18 – Ruddy Creek Zone 9 – Linkside
WHEREAS, the engineer selected by the City Council has prepared and filed with the City Clerk, the Report in connection with the proposed levy and collection of assessments upon eligible parcels of land within each Zone. The Report has been prepared based on the estimated costs to operate, maintain and service the improvements located within particular Zones of the District; and,
WHEREAS, the City Council has carefully examined and reviewed the Report and is satisfied with each of the items and documents as presented therein, and finds that the assessments have been spread to the eligible parcels within each Zone in accordance with the special benefit received from said improvements; and, WHEREAS, the assessments are not based on the assessed value of the properties within the Zones but are based on the special benefit conferred upon said eligible parcels from the improvements, and the maintenance and operation thereof; and, WHEREAS, the assessments are in compliance with all laws pertaining to the levy and collection of assessments, including Proposition 218; and, NOW, THEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY RESOLVED AS FOLLOWS:
199
Item 13.

Page 2 of 3 ends

1. Following notice duly given, the City Council has held a full and fair public hearing regarding the Report and the levy and collection of assessments within the District. The City Council received and considered all written and oral statements, including any and all protests or other communications made or filed by any interested persons.

2. Based upon its review (and any applicable amendments) of the Report, a copy of which has been filed with the City Clerk, the City Council hereby finds and determines that:
a. The assessable properties within the Zones will receive special benefit from the operation, maintenance and servicing of the landscape and lighting improvements.
b. The Zones include all properties receiving such special benefit. c. The net amount to be assessed upon the properties is based on the historical and estimated costs to provide said maintenance and servicing and is apportioned by a formula that fairly distributes the net amount among all assessable parcels in proportion to the estimated special benefit received from the improvements and services.

3. The Report and assessments, as presented and which are on file with the office of the City Clerk, are hereby confirmed as filed.

4. The City Council hereby orders the maintenance and servicing of the improvements to be made in accordance with the Report and the 1972 Act.

5. The maintenance, operation and servicing of the landscape and lighting improvements shall be performed pursuant to the 1972 Act and the County Auditor of Butte County shall enter onto the County Tax Roll, opposite each assessable parcel of land, the assessment amount and such assessments shall be collected at the same time and in the same manner as the County taxes are collected. After collection of the assessments by the County, the net amount of said assessments shall be paid to the City Treasurer.

6. The City Treasurer shall deposit all money representing assessments collected by the County to the credit of a fund especially for the District. Such money shall be expended only for the maintenance, operations and servicing of the landscape and lighting improvements located within the District boundaries.

7. The adoption of this Resolution constitutes the levy of assessments within the Zones for the fiscal year beginning July 1, 2022 and ending June 30, 2023.

8. The City Clerk is hereby authorized and directed to file the levy with the County Auditor upon adoption of this Resolution.

9. A certified copy of this Resolution shall be filed in the office of the City Clerk and shall remain open for public inspection.
200
Item 13.

Page 3 of 3 ends

PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Oroville City Council at a regular meeting held on August 2, 2022, by the following vote:

AYES:

NOES:

ABSTAIN:

ABSENT:

Chuck Reynolds, Mayor
APPROVED AS TO FORM: ATTEST:

Scott Huber, City Attorney Jackie Glover, Assistant City Clerk 201
Item 13.

CITY OF OROVILLE
FINAL ENGINEER’S REPORT

CONSOLIDATED LANDSCAPE AND LIGHTING

MAINTENANCE ASSESSMENT DISTRICT
FISCAL YEAR 2022-23
July 2022

PREPARED BY
Harris & Associates
1401 Willow Pass Road, Suite 500
Concord, CA 94520
www.weareharris.com
202
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

TABLE OF CONTENTS
Statement of Assessment Engineer................................................................... 1 Part I - Overview ................................................................................................ 3 Part II - Plans and Specifications ........................................................................ 6 Part III – Method of Apportionment ................................................................. 8 Part IV – Zone Budgets .................................................................................... 12 Appendix A - Assessment Roll
Appendix B- Assessment Diagram
203
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

1 STATEMENT OF ASSESSMENT ENGINEER
AGENCY: THE CITY OF OROVILLE
PROJECT: CONSOLIDATED LANDSCAPE AND LIGHTING MAINTENANCE ASSESSMENT DISTRICT TO: THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE

CITY OF OROVILLE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA
ENGINEER’S REPORT FOR FISCAL YEAR 2022-23
The preparation of this Annual Engineer’s Report (“Report”) is in conformance with the obligation of the City Council for the annual levy of assessments within the Consolidated Landscape and Lighting Maintenance Assessment District (the “District”) of the City of Oroville to provide services upon each lot or parcel of land in the district in proportion to the estimated benefit to be received by each such lot or parcel of land for Fiscal Year 2022-23.

Pursuant to the provisions of the Landscape and Lighting Act of 1972, (Part 2 Division 15 of the Streets and Highways Code of the State of California, commencing with Section 22500) (the “Act”), Article XIIID, Section 4(a) of the State of California Constitution the City Council of the City of Oroville (the “City”), adopted a Resolution Initiating Proceedings for the Levy and Collection of Annual Assessments within the District for Fiscal Year 2022-23. Said Resolution called for the preparation and filing of an annual report (the “Report”) presenting plans and specifications describing the general nature, location and extent of the improvements and an estimate of the costs to maintain said improvements within the District.

The word “parcel”, for purposes of this Report, refers to an individual property assigned its own Assessor’s Parcel Number (“APN”) by the Butte County Assessor’s Office. The Butte County Auditor/Controller uses APN and specific fund numbers to identify properties to be assessed on the tax roll for special benefit assessments.

CONSOLIDATED LANDSCAPE AND LIGHTING MAINTENANCE ASSESSMENT DISTRICT (Hereinafter referred to as the “District”),
I, Tamorah Bryant, authorized representative of the District, the duly appointed Assessment Engineer submit the following Report which consists of the following four (4) parts and Appendices:
204
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

2 PART I
Overview: This part provides a general description of the District, Proposition 218 and a summary of the proposed assessment.

PART II
Plans and Specifications: This part provides a general description of improvements proposed to be maintained in the District. Plans and specifications for the improvements are on file with the City.

PART III
Method of Apportionment of the Assessments: This part describes the method of apportionment of assessments, based upon parcel classification of land within the District in proportion to the estimated special benefits to be received. The costs and expenses of the District have been assessed upon the parcels of land within the boundaries of District pursuant to the initial methodology established at the time of formation. For particulars as to the identification of parcels, reference is made to the District Diagram.

PART IV
Estimate of Cost: This part contains the cost estimate of the proposed maintenance including incidental costs and expenses for Fiscal Year 2022-23.

Appendices
Appendix A – Assessment Roll
Appendix B – Assessment Diagrams
In conclusion, it is my opinion that the costs and expenses of the District have been assessed to the lots and parcels within the boundaries of the District in proportion to the estimated benefits to be received by each lot or parcel from the services provided and in conformance with the assessment methodology adopted by the City Council for the levying of assessments.

DATED this 28th day of July, 2022

Tamorah Bryant, P.E., Assessment Engineer
R.C.E. No. C67205
Engineer of Work

205
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

3 PART I – OVERVIEW
The District is comprised of the eighteen (18) residential developments designated as Zones within the District. Zone number 14, Martin Ranch, was formed but never developed. It will therefore, remain unassessed until such time as development is renewed or another development takes over the project area.

Please refer to the table on the next page which details the number of parcels within each Zone as well as the distinct name and number designation. Also included in the table below are the total costs to be assessed, the Proposed Assessment Rate and the Maximum Assessment Rate allowed for Fiscal Year 2022-

23. 206
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

4 CLLMAD FISCAL YEAR 2022-23 ASSESSMENT SUMMARY
Zone Name
Total
Assessable
Parcels/Units
Maximum
Assessment Rate
per Unit
Actual
Assessment Rate
per Unit
Total
Assessment
Zone 1 – Grandview Estates 21 $186.97 $186.96 $3,732.54 Zone 2 – The Buttes 58 $122.96 $122.96 $7,131.68
Zone 3 – Deer Creek Estates, Phase 1 72 $30.12 $30.12 $2,168.64 Zone 4 – Calle Vista Estates, Phase 1 70 $76.11 $76.10 $5,327.00 Zone 5 – Cherokee Estates, Phase 1 12 $79.08 $79.08 $948.96 Zone 6 – Sherwood Estates, 1 & 2 49 $42.00 $42.00 $2,058.00 Zone 7 – Grayhawk 30 $197.63 $197.62 $5,928.60
Zone 8 – Cherokee Estates, Phase 2 20 $515.71 $190.02 $3,800.40 Zone 9 – Linkside Place, Phase 1 65 $536.62 $65.00 $4,225.00 Zone 10 – Foothill Estates 25 $794.86 $110.00 $2,750.00 Zone 11 – Mission Olive Ranch 19 $596.37 $406.10 $7,715.90 Zone 12 – Vista Del Oro 92 $234.16 $30.00 $2,760.00
Zone 13 – Calle Vista Estates, Unit 2 44 $326.02 $110.16 $4,847.04 Zone 14 – Martin Ranch 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
Zone 15 – Jake Richter 8 $348.23 $348.22 $2,785.76
Zone 16 – Feather River Bluffs 121 $59.40 $0.00 $0.00
Zone 17 – Acacia Estates 20 $112.33 $0.00 $0.00
Zone 18 – Ruddy Creek 97 $150.00 $0.00 $0.00
TOTALS: 823 $56,179.52
The Assessment Rate per Unit for the prior year is shown on the respective Budgets for each Zone, shown in Part IV of this Report.
207
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

5 The February Consumer Price Index (“CPI”) is used to determine the Maximum Assessment Rate each year. The February CPI is added to the previous years’ Maximum Assessment Rate to determine the adjusted Maximum Assessment for Zones 1, and 8 through 18 (see below) for the current year. Please refer to Part III of this Report, “Assessment Range Formula” for a complete description of the CPI tables used for this purpose.

Also stated in Part III of this Report, “Assessment Range Formula”, Zones 2 through 7 have no allowable inflationary adjustment and as a result CPI is not applied to the Maximum Assessment for those Zones.

The table below provides the historical increases in the February CPI, (February to February each year) beginning in 2006/07. CPI is shown here at 7 decimal points for purposes of accuracy and for calculating the Adjusted Maximum Assessment each year.

The calculated Maximum Assessment for each Zone is shown on the individual Zone Budget pages in Section IV of this Report.

Fiscal Year February CPI Adjustment
2006-07 2.9324056%
2007-08 3.1810719%
2008-09 2.7722661%
2009-10 1.1629601%
2010-11 1.7910031%
2011-12 1.6962568%
2012-13 2.9998130%
2013-14 2.4472307%
2014-15 2.4468738%
2015-16 2.5320274%
2016-17 3.0167510%
2017-18 3.4371668%
2018-19 3.5644600%
2019-20 3.5260284%
2020-21 2.9059806%
2021-22 1.5672862%
2022-23 5.1933887%
208
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

6 PART II – PLANS AND SPECIFICATIONS
Description of the District and Boundaries
The District was formed for the purpose of ensuring the ongoing maintenance, operation and servicing of certain landscape and lighting improvements within the boundaries of each Zone. Said improvements are detailed below under “Improvements and Services Provided”.

Each Zone was formed and annexed into the District as a condition of development. The Zones are located throughout the City of Oroville.

Improvements and Services Provided
The improvements and services within each Zone are identified below:
 Zone 1 – Grandview Estates: Maintenance of trees, shrubs, ground cover, walls, irrigation system, street trees and 6 street lights.
 Zone 2 – The Buttes: Maintenance of turf, shrubs, ground cover, irrigation system, an entry way with rock wall, signage and lighting, gated fence, landscaping along the fence, an irrigation system on Oro Garden Ranch Road, street trees, and 14 street lights.  Zone 3 – Deer Creek Estates, Phase 1: Maintenance of a gateway, a ten foot gravel sewer maintenance road with safety lighting, a twenty foot emergency access road, 13 street lights, an open space area (natural state) and street trees.
 Zone 4 – Calle Vista Estates, Unit 1: Maintenance of a wooden fence, a masonry wall, trees, shrubs, ground cover, an irrigation system, street trees and 14 street lights.  Zone 5 – Cherokee Estates, Phase 1: Maintenance of a wooden fence, 2 street lights and a landscape buffer along Cherokee Road.
 Zone 6 – Sherwood Estates, Phases 1 & 2: Maintenance of a landscape buffer along 18th and 20th Streets, wood fencing, a masonry wall, irrigation system, street trees and 4 street lights.  Zone 7 – Grayhawk: Maintenance of an island planter on Gaylor Street, landscape buffers along Grand Avenue, seventy three street trees and 5 street lights.  Zone 8 – Cherokee Estates, Phase 2: Maintenance of thirty seven street trees, 1,725 square feet of landscaping, 345 linear feet of wood fencing along Cherokee Road and 5 street lights.  Zone 9 – Linkside Place, Phase 1: Landscape and lighting improvements within this Zone may include but are not limited to: street trees, landscaping (turf shrubs & ground cover), 14 street lights and other appurtenant facilities.
 Zone 10 – Foothill Estates: Landscape and lighting improvements within this Zone may include but are not limited to: landscaping (turf shrubs & ground cover), 6 street lights and other appurtenant facilities.
209
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

7  Zone 11 – Mission Olive Ranch: Landscape and lighting improvements within this Zone may include but are not limited to: landscaping (turf shrubs & ground cover), wood fencing, masonry walls, 5 street lights and other appurtenant facilities.  Zone 12 – Vista Del Oro: Landscape and lighting improvements within this Zone may include but are not limited to: street trees, landscaping (turf shrubs & ground cover), wood fencing, masonry walls, open/natural areas, 20 street lights and other appurtenant facilities.  Zone 13 – Calle Vista Estates, Unit 2: Landscape and lighting improvements within this Zone may include but are not limited to: landscaping (turf shrubs & ground cover), 10 street lights and other appurtenant facilities.
 Zone 14 – Martin Ranch: There are currently no improvements being maintained within this Zone and none are currently planned. Development never occurred. This is a completely vacant project at this time.
 Zone 15 – Jake Richter: Landscape and lighting improvements within this Zone may include but are not limited to: landscaping (turf shrubs & ground cover), 2 street lights and other appurtenant facilities.
 Zone 16 – Feather River Bluffs: Landscape and lighting improvements within this Zone may include but are not limited to: 12 street lights and other appurtenant facilities. Currently there are no improvements being maintained.
 Zone 17 – Acacia Estates: Landscape and lighting improvements within this Zone may include but are not limited to: 3 street lights and other appurtenant facilities. Currently there are no improvements being maintained.
 Zone 18 – Ruddy Creek: Landscape and lighting improvements within this Zone may include but are not limited to: 27 street lights and other appurtenant facilities. Currently there are no improvements being maintained.

Reference is made to the plans and specifications for the improvements which are on file with the City and are incorporated herein by reference.

210
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

8 PART III – METHOD OF APPORTIONMENT
The 1972 Act allows for the establishment of assessment districts by public agencies for the purpose of providing certain public improvements as detailed in Section I of this Report. The 1972 Act also requires that the cost of these improvements and services be assessed based on benefit received rather than by assessed value of the properties being assessed. In accordance with the 1972 Act, Section 22573:
“The net amount to be assessed upon lands within an assessment district may be apportioned by any formula or method which fairly distributes the net amount among assessable lots or parcels in proportion to the estimated benefits received by each such lot or parcel from the improvements”
The method of apportionment described in this Report, and confirmed by the City Council, utilizes commonly accepted engineering practices which have been established pursuant to the 1972 Act and the California Constitution for the allocation of special benefit assessments. The calculation of assessments is based upon the parcel type and the services and improvements provided to equitably apportion the costs. The special benefit received by each lot or parcel is over and above any general benefit conferred upon said lots or parcels or to the public at large.

Description of the Benefit
Special Benefit
The improvements and associated costs have been allocated to the assessable properties within the District based upon the special benefit received by those properties, pursuant to the provisions of the 1972 Act. The improvements for which the properties will be assessed have been identified as necessary, were required as a part of the development plans specifically for each individual tract and are also in compliance with the development plans and General Plan of the City. As such, the improvements and continuing maintenance and servicing are strictly the obligation of the properties within the District.

Although the improvements may be visible to passersby or to the public at large, the improvements were installed as a requirement of the development of the tract and are for the sole benefit of properties within the District. It has been determined therefore, any access or use by properties or individuals outside the District is completely incidental and the costs of operating, maintaining and servicing said improvements therefore provides no measurable benefit to those outside properties or individuals. 211
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

9 Definition of Special Benefit
The method of apportionment described in this Report is based on the premise that each assessable lot or parcel receives distinct and special benefits from the improvements and services provided, including the visual desirability provided by well-maintained landscaping. In accordance with Article XIII D, Section 4 of the California Constitution:
“Special benefit means a particular and distinct benefit over and above general benefits conferred on real property located in the District or the public at large” Some of the special benefits associated with local landscaping and lighting improvements are:
 Enhanced desirability of properties due to proximity of the improvements.  Improved aesthetic appeal provided by a positive representation of the development, neighborhood and the community.
 Improved ingress and egress to property resulting in enhanced traffic flow, reduced traffic accidents and consequent reduction in possible property damage.  Improved accessibility for emergency vehicles.
 Reduced vandalism and other criminal activity.

Assessment Range Formula
It is generally recognized that most budgetary items will be impacted by inflation in future years. In accordance with the California Constitution, Section 53739 (b)(1), assessments “may be adjusted for inflation pursuant to a clearly defined formula…” A formula for an inflationary adjustment is therefore included as part of the maximum assessment within the District and was approved by the property owner(s) at the time of formation/annexation. The formula, as described below, allows for annual adjustments to the budget and the assessments.

Generally, any new or increased assessment requires certain noticing and meeting requirements by law.

The Government Code excludes certain conditions of a new or increased assessment. These conditions include, “An assessment that does not exceed an assessment formula or range of assessments previously specified in the notice given to the public…and that was previously adopted by the agency…” The initial maximum assessment for each Zone was established at the time of formation or annexation into the District. Zones 2 through 7 of this District however do not have an inflationary adjustment. These Zones were created prior to the adoption of Proposition 218 in 1996 and did not include a provision to increase the initial maximum assessment.

In Fiscal Year 2020-21, the City Council conducted a public hearing to tabulate assessment ballots regarding increased assessments and the addition of an annual inflationary adjustment for Zones 1 through 7.
212
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

10 At the conclusion of the public hearing, it was determined that only Zone 1, Grandview Estates, approved the proposed increases and/or inflationary adjustments. Zone 1 approved the inflationary adjustment, along with a reduction in the Maximum Assessment for the Zone. The Maximum Assessment for Zone 1 prior to the ballot process, was $238.10. The property owners approved a reduction of the Maximum Assessment to $175.00, and included an annual inflationary adjustment.

The maximum assessments for Zones 1, and 8 through 18 (annexed in FY 2022) are adjusted each fiscal year by the following Assessment Range Formula:
 The Maximum Assessment Rate allowed each fiscal year (the “Adjusted Maximum Assessment Rate”) shall be based on the initial maximum assessment, adjusted annually by Bureau of Labor Statistics, Consumer Price Index for the month of February, All Urban Consumers, (“CPI”) for the San Francisco/Oakland/San Jose area. Should the Bureau of Labor Statistics revise or discontinue the preparation of such index, the City reserves the right to use such revised index or a comparable system to determine fluctuations in the annual cost of living.  Each fiscal year, the February CPI amount has been applied to the Maximum Assessment Rate established the previous fiscal year to calculate the appropriate Adjusted Maximum Assessment Rate for the then current fiscal year.
 If the proposed annual assessment rate for the upcoming fiscal year is less than or equal to the Adjusted Maximum Assessment Rate established for that fiscal year then the proposed annual assessment is not considered an increased assessment.

Beginning in the second fiscal year after the annexation of a Zone, and each fiscal year since, the Maximum Assessment Rate has been recalculated and a new Maximum Assessment Rate (Adjusted Maximum Assessment Rate) has been established for each fiscal year using the Assessment Range Formula described above. The Adjusted Maximum Assessment Rate has been calculated independent of the annual budget and proposed assessment rate for the given fiscal year. As stated above, if the proposed annual assessment for any fiscal year does not exceed the Adjusted Maximum Assessment Rate for that year, it is not considered an increased assessment under the terms of Proposition 218 or the Government Code.

The CPI increase for the one year period ending in February 2022 is 5.19% (rounded). This amount will be applied to the Maximum Assessment for Zones 1, and 8 through 18 only, which will establish the Adjusted Maximum Assessment for each of those Zones for Fiscal Year 2022-23.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

11 A protest occurs when, at the public hearing, the returned assessment ballots opposed to the new or increased assessment outweigh the returned ballots in favor of the new or increased assessment, weighting those assessment ballots by the financial obligation of each parcel. As previously stated, Zone 1 agreed to a reduced Maximum Assessment and the inclusion of an annual inflationary adjustment.

The definition of new or increased assessments includes any assessment which, 1) did not previously exist or, 2) exceeds a previously approved assessment amount or assessment range formula. Any assessment range formula must have been previously adopted by the agency and approved by the property owners in the area where the assessment is imposed.

ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY
The benefit formula used to determine the financial obligation for each parcel is based on the improvements benefitting the parcels, as well as the use, or type, of each parcel as compared to other parcels that benefit from said improvements. One of the more common approaches to fairly distributing District costs to the benefitting parcels in maintenance districts such as this utilizes a methodology referred to as the Per Parcel method of apportionment. This method recognizes that each parcel within a particular Zone benefits equally from the improvements. This is typical when all parcels within the Zone are of the same type (all single family dwellings).

Each Zone is comprised of a single parcel type – residential. The residential parcels are single family residential parcels (“SFR”) or condominiums and as such are deemed to benefit equally from the improvements. The “Total Balance to Assessment”, as shown on the Budget pages, is divided equally among each assessable parcel within the Zone which determines the annual assessment rate per parcel for that Zone.

214
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

12 PART IV – COST ESTIMATE
The estimated budget for the annual maintenance and servicing of the improvements and the proportionate share of administration costs for each Zone within the District have been prepared based on the estimated and historical costs. The individual Zone budgets are shown on the following pages.

In addition to the budget tables, Zones 1, and 8 through 18 contain an additional table showing the February CPI for each year since the annexation of that zone, the calculated adjustment to the previous years’ assessment and the Adjusted Maximum Assessment for each of those zones. As stated previously, Zone 2 through 7 do not have an inflationary adjustment.

215
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

13 Zone 1 – Grandview Estates Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Utilities – Water $486.78
Utilities – Electricity $422.43
Streetlights $517.00
Irrigation Materials $120.00
Plant Materials $120.00
Personnel – Parks & Trees $519.04
Personnel – Public Works $0.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $2,185.25

INDIRECT COSTS
CLLMAD Administration Fee $211.17
Maintenance Contracts $0.00
City Personnel/Parks & Trees/New Park Tech II $3,262.50 Truck/Equipment $625.00
County Administration Fee – $0.30 per parcel $6.30
Advertising $13.68
Rounding Adjustment $0.00
Indirect Costs Sub-Total $4,118.65
SUB-TOTAL COSTS $6,303.90
Contingency Reserve – 20 % of Total Costs $1,260.78
TOTAL COSTS $7,564.68
Estimated Reserve Fund Beginning Balance (7/1/2022) $3,459.32 2022-23 Reserve Contribution/Reduction ($179.20)
Estimated Reserve Fund Ending Balance (6/30/2023) $3,280.12 2022-23 TOTAL ASSESSMENT $3,926.16
Total Number of Assessable Parcels 21
2022-23 ACTUAL ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $186.96
2022-23 MAXIMUM ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $186.97
2021-22 ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL/UNIT $177.74
216
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

14 The Annual CPI calculations for Zone 1 – Grandview Estates is shown in the table below:

The property owners in Zone 1 approved the inclusion of an annual inflationary adjustment on June 16, 2021. The property owners also agreed to a reduction in the Maximum Assessment, from $238.10 to $175.00.

Beginning in Fiscal Year 2022/23, and in each subsequent year, the February CPI will be applied to the Maximum Assessment for this Zone. The actual assessment may be less than the established Maximum Assessment but may not exceed it without property owner approval via a Proposition 218 ballot process.

Fiscal Year CPI Increase Adjusted Max
2020-2021 N/A $175.000
2021-2022 1.5672862% $177.743
2022-2023 5.1933887% $186.974
217
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

15 Zone 2 – The Buttes Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Utilities – Water $640.00
Utilities – Electricity $560.00
Streetlights $287.00
Irrigation Materials $50.00
Plant Materials $100.00
Weed Abatement $0.00
Personnel – Parks & Trees $1,164.06
Personnel – Public Works $0.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $2,801.06

INDIRECT COSTS
CLLMAD Administration Fee $367.99
Maintenance Contracts $0.00
City Personnel/Parks & Trees/New Park Tech II $3,262.50 Truck/Equipment $625.00
County Administration Fee – $0.30 per parcel $17.40
Advertising $13.68
Rounding Adjustment $0.00
Indirect Costs Sub-Total $4,286.57
SUB-TOTAL COSTS $7,087.63
Contingency Reserve – 20 % of Total Costs $0.00
TOTAL COSTS $7,087.63
Estimated Reserve Fund Beginning Balance (7/1/2022) $6,028.24 2022-23 Reserve Contribution/Reduction ($5,984.19)
Estimated Reserve Fund Ending Balance (6/30/2023) $44.05 2022-23 TOTAL ASSESSMENT $7,131.68
Total Number of Assessable Parcels 58
2022-23 ACTUAL ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $122.96
2022-23 MAXIMUM ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $122.96
2021-22 ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL/UNIT $122.96
218
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

16 Zone 3 – Deer Creek Estates Budget

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

17 Zone 4 – Calle Vista Estates, Unit 1 Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Utilities – Water $416.00
Utilities – Electricity $525.00
Streetlights $100.00
Irrigation Materials $50.00
Plant Materials $0.00
Weed Abatement $0.00
Personnel – Parks & Trees $963.10
Personnel – Public Works $0.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $2,054.10

INDIRECT COSTS
CLLMAD Administration Fee $629.02
Maintenance Contracts $0.00
City Personnel/Parks & Trees/New Park Tech II $3,262.50 Truck/Equipment $625.00
County Administration Fee – $0.30 per parcel $21.00
Advertising $13.68
Rounding Adjustment $0.00
Indirect Costs Sub-Total $4,551.20
SUB-TOTAL COSTS $6,605.30
Contingency Reserve – 20 % of Total Costs $0.00
TOTAL COSTS $6,605.30
Estimated Reserve Fund Beginning Balance (7/1/2022) $10,304.23 2022-23 Reserve Contribution/Reduction $9,025.93
Estimated Reserve Fund Ending Balance (6/30/2023) $19,330.16 2022-23 TOTAL ASSESSMENT $5,327.00
Total Number of Assessable Parcels 70
2022-23 ACTUAL ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $76.10
2022-23 MAXIMUM ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $76.11
2021-22 ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL/UNIT $76.10
220
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

18 Zone 5 – Cherokee Estates, Phase 1 Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Utilities – Water $189.00
Utilities – Electricity $200.00
Streetlights $150.00
Irrigation Materials $0.00
Plant Materials $0.00
Personnel – Parks & Trees $936.15
Personnel – Public Works $0.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $1,475.15

INDIRECT COSTS
CLLMAD Administration Fee $0.00
Maintenance Contracts $0.00
City Personnel/Parks & Trees/New Park Tech II $3,262.50 Truck/Equipment $625.00
County Administration Fee – $0.30 per parcel $3.60
Advertising $13.68
Rounding Adjustment $0.00
Indirect Costs Sub-Total $3,904.78
SUB-TOTAL COSTS $5,379.93
Contingency Reserve – 20 % of Total Costs $0.00
TOTAL COSTS $5,379.93
Estimated Reserve Fund Beginning Balance (7/1/2022) ($1,277.99) 2022-23 Reserve Contribution/Reduction ($3,152.98)
Estimated Reserve Fund Ending Balance (6/30/2023) ($4,430.97) 2022-23 TOTAL ASSESSMENT $948.96
Total Number of Assessable Parcels 12
2022-23 ACTUAL ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $79.08
2022-23 MAXIMUM ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $79.08
2021-22 ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL/UNIT $79.08
221
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

19 Zone 6 – Sherwood Estates, Units 1 & 2 Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Utilities – Water $650.00
Utilities – Electricity $105.00
Streetlights $0.00
Irrigation Materials $353.00
Plant Materials $0.00
Personnel – Parks & Trees $787.23
Personnel – Public Works $0.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $1,895.23

INDIRECT COSTS
CLLMAD Administration Fee $0.00
Maintenance Contracts $0.00
City Personnel/Parks & Trees/New Park Tech II $3,262.50 Truck/Equipment $625.00
County Administration Fee – $0.30 per parcel $14.70
Advertising $13.68
Rounding Adjustment $0.00
Indirect Costs Sub-Total $3,915.88
SUB-TOTAL COSTS $5,811.11
Contingency Reserve – 20 % of Total Costs $0.00
TOTAL COSTS $5,811.11
Estimated Reserve Fund Beginning Balance (7/1/2022) ($4,624.65) 2022-23 Reserve Contribution/Reduction ($8,377.76)
Estimated Reserve Fund Ending Balance (6/30/2023) ($13,002.41) 2022-23 TOTAL ASSESSMENT $2,058.00
Total Number of Assessable Parcels 49
2022-23 ACTUAL ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $42.00
2022-23 MAXIMUM ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $42.00
2021-22 ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL/UNIT $42.00
222
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

20 Zone 7 – Grayhawk Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Utilities – Water $550.00
Utilities – Electricity $452.00
Streetlights $400.00
Irrigation Materials $125.00
Plant Materials $125.00
Personnel – Parks & Trees $352.79
Personnel – Public Works $0.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $2,004.79

INDIRECT COSTS
CLLMAD Administration Fee $264.55
Maintenance Contracts $0.00
City Personnel/Parks & Trees/New Park Tech II $3,262.50 Truck/Equipment $625.00
County Administration Fee – $0.30 per parcel $9.00
Advertising $13.68
Rounding Adjustment $0.00
Indirect Costs Sub-Total $4,174.73
SUB-TOTAL COSTS $6,179.52
Contingency Reserve – 20 % of Total Costs $1,235.90
TOTAL COSTS $7,415.42
Estimated Reserve Fund Beginning Balance (7/1/2022) $4,333.73 2022-23 Reserve Contribution/Reduction $2,846.91
Estimated Reserve Fund Ending Balance (6/30/2023) $7,180.64 2022-23 TOTAL ASSESSMENT $5,928.60
Total Number of Assessable Parcels 30
2022-23 ACTUAL ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $197.62
2022-23 MAXIMUM ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $197.63
2021-22 ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL/UNIT $155.66
223
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

21 Zone 8 – Cherokee Estates, Phase 2 Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Utilities – Water $89.00
Utilities – Electricity $80.00
Streetlights $250.00
Irrigation Materials $67.00
Plant Materials $75.00
Personnel – Parks & Trees $358.78
Personnel – Public Works $0.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $919.78

INDIRECT COSTS
CLLMAD Administration Fee $478.56
Maintenance Contracts $0.00
City Personnel/Parks & Trees/New Park Tech II $3,262.50 Truck/Equipment $625.00
County Administration Fee – $0.30 per parcel $6.00
Advertising $13.68
Rounding Adjustment $0.00
Indirect Costs Sub-Total $4,385.74
SUB-TOTAL COSTS $5,305.52
Contingency Reserve – 20 % of Total Costs $1,061.10
TOTAL COSTS $6,366.62
Estimated Reserve Fund Beginning Balance (7/1/2022) $7,839.48 2022-23 Reserve Contribution/Reduction $5,273.26
Estimated Reserve Fund Ending Balance (6/30/2023) $13,112.74 2022-23 TOTAL ASSESSMENT $3,800.40
Total Number of Assessable Parcels 20
2022-23 ACTUAL ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $190.02
2022-23 MAXIMUM ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $515.71
2021-22 ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL/UNIT $190.02
224
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

22 The Annual CPI calculations for Zone 8 – Cherokee Estates is shown in the table below:

Fiscal Year CPI Increase Adjusted Max
2004-2005 N/A $319.200
2005-2006 1.56% $324.195
2006-2007 2.93% $333.702
2007-2008 3.18% $344.317
2008-2009 2.77% $353.862
2009-2010 1.16% $357.978
2010-2011 1.79% $364.389
2011-2012 1.70% $370.570
2012-2013 3.00% $381.687
2013-2014 2.45% $391.027
2014-2015 2.45% $400.595
2015-2016 2.53% $410.738
2016-2017 3.02% $423.129
2017-2018 3.44% $437.672
2018-2019 3.56% $453.273
2019-2020 3.53% $469.255
2020-2021 2.91% $482.892
2021-2022 1.57% $490.246
2022-2023 5.19% $515.707
*Rounded to 2 decimal points. Calculation is performed at 7 decimal points each year.

225
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

23 Zone 9 – Linkside Place, Phase 1 Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Utilities – Water $285.00
Utilities – Electricity $590.00
Streetlights $200.00
Irrigation Materials $100.00
Plant Materials $100.00
Personnel – Parks & Trees $376.01
Personnel – Public Works $0.00
Landscaping Enhancements $0.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $1,651.01

INDIRECT COSTS
CLLMAD Administration Fee $666.64
Maintenance Contracts $0.00
City Personnel/Parks & Trees/New Park Tech II $3,262.50 Truck/Equipment $625.00
County Administration Fee – $0.30 per parcel $19.50
Advertising $13.68
Rounding Adjustment $0.00
Indirect Costs Sub-Total $4,587.32
SUB-TOTAL COSTS $6,238.33
Contingency Reserve – 20 % of Total Costs $1,247.67
TOTAL COSTS $7,486.00
Estimated Reserve Fund Beginning Balance (7/1/2022) $10,920.63 2022-23 Reserve Contribution/Reduction $7,659.63
Estimated Reserve Fund Ending Balance (6/30/2023) $18,580.26 2022-23 TOTAL ASSESSMENT $4,225.00
Total Number of Assessable Parcels 65
2022-23 ACTUAL ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $65.00
2022-23 MAXIMUM ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $536.62
2021-22 ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL/UNIT $62.12
226
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

24 The Annual CPI calculations for Zone 9 – Linkside Place is shown in the table below:

Fiscal Year CPI Increase Adjusted Max
2005-2006 N/A $337.340
2006-2007 2.93% $347.232
2007-2008 3.18% $358.278
2008-2009 2.77% $368.210
2009-2010 1.16% $372.492
2010-2011 1.79% $379.164
2011-2012 1.70% $385.595
2012-2013 3.00% $397.163
2013-2014 2.45% $406.882
2014-2015 2.45% $416.838
2015-2016 2.53% $427.392
2016-2017 3.02% $440.285
2017-2018 3.44% $455.418
2018-2019 3.56% $471.651
2019-2020 3.53% $488.282
2020-2021 2.91% $502.471
2021-2022 1.57% $510.124
2022-2023 5.19% $536.617
*Rounded to 2 decimal points. Calculation is performed at 7 decimal points each year.

227
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

25 Zone 10 – Foothill Estates Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Utilities – Water $204.00
Utilities – Electricity $226.00
Streetlights $300.00
Irrigation Materials $100.00
Plant Materials $100.00
Personnel – Parks & Trees $26.43
Personnel – Public Works $0.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $956.43

INDIRECT COSTS
CLLMAD Administration Fee $286.56
Maintenance Contracts $0.00
City Personnel/Parks & Trees/New Park Tech II $3,262.50 Truck/Equipment $625.00
County Administration Fee – $0.30 per parcel $7.50
Advertising $13.68
Rounding Adjustment $0.00
Indirect Costs Sub-Total $4,195.24
SUB-TOTAL COSTS $5,151.67
Contingency Reserve – 20 % of Total Costs $1,030.33
TOTAL COSTS $6,182.00
Estimated Reserve Fund Beginning Balance (7/1/2022) $4,694.22 2022-23 Reserve Contribution/Reduction $1,262.22
Estimated Reserve Fund Ending Balance (6/30/2023) $5,956.44 2022-23 TOTAL ASSESSMENT $2,750.00
Total Number of Assessable Parcels 25
2022-23 ACTUAL ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $110.00
2022-23 MAXIMUM ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $794.86
2021-22 ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL/UNIT $100.00
228
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

26 The Annual CPI calculations for Zone 10 – Foothill Estates is shown in the table below:

Fiscal Year CPI Increase Adjusted Max
2005-2006 N/A $499.680
2006-2007 2.93% $514.333
2007-2008 3.18% $530.694
2008-2009 2.77% $545.406
2009-2010 1.16% $551.749
2010-2011 1.79% $561.631
2011-2012 1.70% $571.158
2012-2013 3.00% $588.291
2013-2014 2.45% $602.688
2014-2015 2.45% $617.435
2015-2016 2.53% $633.069
2016-2017 3.02% $652.166
2017-2018 3.44% $674.582
2018-2019 3.56% $698.627
2019-2020 3.53% $723.261
2020-2021 2.91% $744.279
2021-2022 1.57% $755.614
2022-2023 5.19% $794.856
*Rounded to 2 decimal points. Calculation is performed at 7 decimal points each year.

229
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

27 Zone 11 – Mission Olive Ranch Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Utilities – Water $810.00
Utilities – Electricity $590.00
Streetlights $500.00
Irrigation Materials $100.00
Plant Materials $100.00
Personnel – Parks & Trees $456.96
Personnel – Public Works $109.86
Direct Costs Sub-Total $2,666.82

INDIRECT COSTS
CLLMAD Administration Fee $0.00
Maintenance Contracts $0.00
City Personnel/Parks & Trees/New Park Tech II $3,262.50 Truck/Equipment $625.00
County Administration Fee – $0.30 per parcel $5.70
Advertising $13.68
Rounding Adjustment $0.00
Indirect Costs Sub-Total $3,906.88
SUB-TOTAL COSTS $6,573.70
Contingency Reserve – 20 % of Total Costs $1,314.74
TOTAL COSTS $7,888.44
Estimated Reserve Fund Beginning Balance (7/1/2022) $291.04 2022-23 Reserve Contribution/Reduction $118.50
Estimated Reserve Fund Ending Balance (6/30/2023) $409.54 2022-23 TOTAL ASSESSMENT $7,715.90
Total Number of Assessable Parcels 19
2022-23 ACTUAL ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $406.10
2022-23 MAXIMUM ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $596.37
2021-22 ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL/UNIT $386.76
230
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

28 The Annual CPI calculations for Zone 11 – Mission Olive Ranch is shown in the table below:

Fiscal Year CPI Increase Adjusted Max
2006-2007 N/A $385.900
2007-2008 3.18% $398.176
2008-2009 2.77% $409.214
2009-2010 1.16% $413.973
2010-2011 1.79% $421.388
2011-2012 1.70% $428.535
2012-2013 3.00% $441.391
2013-2014 2.45% $452.192
2014-2015 2.45% $463.257
2015-2016 2.53% $474.987
2016-2017 3.02% $489.315
2017-2018 3.44% $506.134
2018-2019 3.56% $524.175
2019-2020 3.53% $542.657
2020-2021 2.91% $558.427
2021-2022 1.57% $566.932
2022-2023 5.19% $596.375
*Rounded to 2 decimal points. Calculation is performed at 7 decimal points each.

231
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

29 Zone 12 – Vista Del Oro Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Utilities – Water $225.00
Utilities – Electricity $375.00
Streetlights $500.00
Irrigation Materials $300.00
Plant Materials $300.00
Weed Abatement $0.00
Personnel – Parks & Trees $271.79
Personnel – Public Works $0.00
Landscaping Enhancements $0.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $1,971.79

INDIRECT COSTS
CLLMAD Administration Fee $759.12
Maintenance Contracts $0.00
City Personnel/Parks & Trees/New Park Tech II $3,262.50 Truck/Equipment $625.00
County Administration Fee – $0.30 per parcel $27.60
Advertising $13.68
Rounding Adjustment $0.00
Indirect Costs Sub-Total $4,687.90
SUB-TOTAL COSTS $6,659.69
Contingency Reserve – 20 % of Total Costs $1,331.94
TOTAL COSTS $7,991.63
Estimated Reserve Fund Beginning Balance (7/1/2022) $12,494.55 2022-23 Reserve Contribution/Reduction $7,262.92
Estimated Reserve Fund Ending Balance (6/30/2023) $19,757.47 2022-23 TOTAL ASSESSMENT $2,760.00
Total Number of Assessable Parcels 92
2022-23 ACTUAL ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $30.00
2022-23 MAXIMUM ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $234.16
2021-22 ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL/UNIT $30.00
232
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

30 The Annual CPI calculations for Zone 12 – Vista Del Oro is shown in the table below:

Fiscal Year CPI Increase Adjusted Max
2006-2007 N/A $151.520
2007-2008 3.18% $156.340
2008-2009 2.77% $160.674
2009-2010 1.16% $162.543
2010-2011 1.79% $165.454
2011-2012 1.70% $168.260
2012-2013 3.00% $173.308
2013-2014 2.45% $177.549
2014-2015 2.45% $181.894
2015-2016 2.53% $186.499
2016-2017 3.02% $192.125
2017-2018 3.44% $198.729
2018-2019 3.56% $205.812
2019-2020 3.53% $213.069
2020-2021 2.91% $219.261
2021-2022 1.57% $222.600
2022-2023 5.19% $234.161
*Rounded to 2 decimal points. Calculation is performed at 7 decimal points each year.

233
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

31 Zone 13 – Calle Vista Estates, Unit 2 Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Utilities – Water $490.00
Utilities – Electricity $510.00
Streetlights $200.00
Irrigation Materials $100.00
Plant Materials $100.00
Personnel – Parks & Trees $431.01
Personnel – Public Works $0.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $1,831.01

INDIRECT COSTS
CLLMAD Administration Fee $580.51
Maintenance Contracts $0.00
City Personnel/Parks & Trees/New Park Tech II $3,262.50 Truck/Equipment $625.00
County Administration Fee – $0.30 per parcel $13.20
Advertising $13.68
Rounding Adjustment $0.00
Indirect Costs Sub-Total $4,494.89
SUB-TOTAL COSTS $6,325.90
Contingency Reserve – 20 % of Total Costs $1,265.18
TOTAL COSTS $7,591.08
Estimated Reserve Fund Beginning Balance (7/1/2022) $9,509.70 2022-23 Reserve Contribution/Reduction $6,765.66
Estimated Reserve Fund Ending Balance (6/30/2023) $16,275.36 2022-23 TOTAL ASSESSMENT $4,847.04
Total Number of Assessable Parcels 44
2022-23 ACTUAL ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $110.16
2022-23 MAXIMUM ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $326.02
2021-22 ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL/UNIT $110.16
234
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

32 The Annual CPI calculations for Zone 13 – Calle Vista Estates, Unit 2 is shown in the table below:

Fiscal Year CPI Increase Adjusted Max
2006-2007 N/A $210.960
2007-2008 3.18% $217.671
2008-2009 2.77% $223.705
2009-2010 1.16% $226.307
2010-2011 1.79% $230.360
2011-2012 1.70% $234.267
2012-2013 3.00% $241.295
2013-2014 2.45% $247.200
2014-2015 2.45% $253.249
2015-2016 2.53% $259.661
2016-2017 3.02% $267.494
2017-2018 3.44% $276.688
2018-2019 3.56% $286.551
2019-2020 3.53% $296.654
2020-2021 2.91% $305.275
2021-2022 1.57% $309.925
2022-2023 5.19% $326.020
*Rounded to 2 decimal points. Calculation is performed at 7 decimal points each year.

235
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

33 Zone 14 – Martin Ranch Budget
This Zone was annexed into the District but development never began. Until such time as development begins, there will be no assessment and therefore, no budget for this Zone The City may also decide to de-annex this Zone from the District in the future. Ground was never broken and the development may never be built. Zone 14 will be left “blank” until such time as this area develops or another area is developed to replace Zone 14 within the structure of the District. 236
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

34 Zone 15 – Jake Richter Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Utilities – Water $175.00
Utilities – Electricity $225.00
Streetlights $200.00
Irrigation Materials $50.00
Plant Materials $50.00
Personnel – Parks & Trees $186.72
Personnel – Public Works $0.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $886.72

INDIRECT COSTS
CLLMAD Administration Fee $39.42
Maintenance Contracts $0.00
City Personnel/Parks & Trees/New Park Tech II $3,262.50 Truck/Equipment $625.00
County Administration Fee – $0.30 per parcel $2.40
Advertising $13.68
Rounding Adjustment $0.00
Indirect Costs Sub-Total $3,943.00
SUB-TOTAL COSTS $4,829.72
Contingency Reserve – 20 % of Total Costs $965.87
TOTAL COSTS $5,795.59
Estimated Reserve Fund Beginning Balance (7/1/2022) $645.83 2022-23 Reserve Contribution/Reduction ($2,364.00)
Estimated Reserve Fund Ending Balance (6/30/2023) ($1,718.17) 2022-23 TOTAL ASSESSMENT $2,785.76
Total Number of Assessable Parcels 8
2022-23 ACTUAL ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $348.22
2022-23 MAXIMUM ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $348.23
2021-22 ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL/UNIT $203.78
237
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

35 The Annual CPI calculations for Zone 15 – Jake Richter Estates is shown in the table below:

Fiscal Year CPI Increase Adjusted Max
2007-2008 N/A $232.500
2008-2009 2.77% $238.946
2009-2010 1.16% $241.724
2010-2011 1.79% $246.054
2011-2012 1.70% $250.227
2012-2013 3.00% $257.734
2013-2014 2.45% $264.041
2014-2015 2.45% $270.502
2015-2016 2.53% $277.351
2016-2017 3.02% $285.717
2017-2018 3.44% $295.538
2018-2019 3.56% $306.072
2019-2020 3.53% $316.865
2020-2021 2.91% $326.073
2021-2022 1.57% $331.039
2022-2023 5.19% $348.231
*Rounded to 2 decimal points. Calculation is performed at 7 decimal points each year.

238
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

36 Zone 16 – Feather River Bluffs Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Utilities – Water $0.00
Utilities – Electricity $0.00
Streetlights $0.00
Irrigation Materials $0.00
Plant Materials $0.00
Personnel – Parks & Trees $0.00
Personnel – Public Works $0.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $0.00

INDIRECT COSTS
CLLMAD Administration Fee $0.00
Maintenance Contracts $0.00
City Personnel/Parks & Trees/New Park Tech II $3,262.50 Truck/Equipment $625.00
County Administration Fee – $0.30 per parcel $0.00
Advertising $0.00
Rounding Adjustment $0.00
Indirect Costs Sub-Total $3,887.50
SUB-TOTAL COSTS $3,887.50
Contingency Reserve – 20 % of Total Costs $0.00
TOTAL COSTS $3,887.50
Estimated Reserve Fund Beginning Balance (7/1/2022) ($160.11) 2022-23 Reserve Contribution/Reduction $0.00
Estimated Reserve Fund Ending Balance (6/30/2023) ($160.11) 2022-23 TOTAL ASSESSMENT $0.00
Total Number of Assessable Parcels 121
2022-23 ACTUAL ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $0.00
2022-23 MAXIMUM ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $59.40
2021-22 ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL/UNIT $0.00
239
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

37 The Annual CPI calculations for Zone 16 – Feather River Bluffs is shown in the table below:

Fiscal Year CPI Increase Adjusted Max
2008-2009 N/A $40.760
2009-2010 1.16% $41.234
2010-2011 1.79% $41.973
2011-2012 1.70% $42.684
2012-2013 3.00% $43.965
2013-2014 2.45% $45.041
2014-2015 2.45% $46.143
2015-2016 2.53% $47.311
2016-2017 3.02% $48.738
2017-2018 3.44% $50.414
2018-2019 3.56% $52.211
2019-2020 3.53% $54.052
2020-2021 2.91% $55.622
2021-2022 1.57% $56.470
2022-2023 5.19% $59.402
*Rounded to 2 decimal points. Calculation is performed at 7 decimal points each year.

240
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

38 Zone 17 – Acacia Estates Budget

INDIRECT COSTS
CLLMAD Administration Fee $0.00
Maintenance Contracts $0.00
City Personnel/Parks & Trees/New Park Tech II $3,262.50 Truck/Equipment $625.00
County Administration Fee – $0.30 per parcel $0.00
Advertising $0.00
Rounding Adjustment $0.00
Indirect Costs Sub-Total $3,887.50
SUB-TOTAL COSTS $3,887.50
Contingency Reserve – 20 % of Total Costs $0.00
TOTAL COSTS $3,887.50
Estimated Reserve Fund Beginning Balance (7/1/2022) ($227.59) 2022-23 Reserve Contribution/Reduction $0.00
Estimated Reserve Fund Ending Balance (6/30/2023) ($227.59) 2022-23 TOTAL ASSESSMENT $0.00
Total Number of Assessable Parcels 20
2022-23 ACTUAL ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $0.00
2022-23 MAXIMUM ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $112.33
2021-22 ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL/UNIT $0.00
241
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

39 The Annual CPI calculations for Zone 17 – Acacia Estates is shown in the table below:

Fiscal Year CPI Increase Adjusted Max
2008-2009 N/A $77.080
2009-2010 1.16% $77.976
2010-2011 1.79% $79.373
2011-2012 1.70% $80.719
2012-2013 3.00% $83.141
2013-2014 2.45% $85.175
2014-2015 2.45% $87.260
2015-2016 2.53% $89.469
2016-2017 3.02% $92.168
2017-2018 3.44% $95.336
2018-2019 3.56% $98.734
2019-2020 3.53% $102.215
2020-2021 2.91% $105.186
2021-2022 1.57% $106.788
2022-2023 5.19% $112.334
*Rounded to 2 decimal points. Calculation is performed at 7 decimal points each year.

242
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

40 Zone 18 – Ruddy Creek Budget

INDIRECT COSTS
CLLMAD Administration Fee $0.00
Maintenance Contracts $0.00
City Personnel/Parks & Trees/New Park Tech II $3,262.50 Truck/Equipment $625.00
County Administration Fee – $0.30 per parcel $0.00
Advertising $0.00
Rounding Adjustment $0.00
Indirect Costs Sub-Total $3,887.50
SUB-TOTAL COSTS $3,887.50
Contingency Reserve – 20 % of Total Costs $0.00
TOTAL COSTS $3,887.50
Estimated Reserve Fund Beginning Balance (7/1/2022) ($205.13) 2022-23 Reserve Contribution/Reduction $0.00
Estimated Reserve Fund Ending Balance (6/30/2023) ($205.13) 2022-23 TOTAL ASSESSMENT $0.00
Total Number of Assessable Parcels 97
2022-23 ACTUAL ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $0.00
2022-23 MAXIMUM ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $150.00
2021-22 ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL/UNIT N/A
243
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

41 The Annual CPI calculations for Zone 18 – Ruddy Creek is shown in the table below:

Fiscal Year CPI Increase Adjusted Max
2022-2023 N/A $150.000
*Rounded to 2 decimal points. Calculation is performed at 7 decimal points each year.

244
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

42 APPENDIX A – ASSESSMENT ROLL
Parcel Identification for each lot or parcel within each Zone of the District shall be based on available parcel maps and other property data from the Butte County Assessor’s office as they existed at the time this Report was prepared and adopted by the City Council.

A complete listing of parcels, by Zone, assessed within the District for Fiscal Year 2022-23, along with the corresponding assessment amounts, is included on the following pages. If any parcel submitted for collection is identified by the County Auditor/Controller to be an invalid parcel number for the current fiscal year, a corrected parcel number and/or new parcel numbers will be identified and resubmitted to the County Auditor/Controller. The assessment amount to be levied and collected for the resubmitted parcel(s) shall be based on the method of apportionment and assessment rate approved in this Report.

Therefore, if a single parcel has changed to multiple parcels, the assessment amounts applied to each of the new parcels shall be recalculated and applied according to the approved method of apportionment and assessment rate rather than a proportionate share of the original assessment.

Non-assessable lots or parcels include areas of public streets and other roadways (typically not assigned an APN by the County); dedicated public easements, open space areas and rights-of-way, including public greenbelts and parkways; utility rights-of-way; common areas; landlocked parcels; small parcels vacated by the County, bifurcated lots and any other property that cannot be developed or has specific development restrictions. These types of parcels are considered to receive little or no benefit from the improvements and are therefore, exempted from assessment. 245
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

43 ZONE 1 – GRANDVIEW ESTATES
APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
031-150-090 1 1.00 $186.97 $186.96
031-150-091 2 1.00 $186.97 $186.96
031-150-092 3 1.00 $186.97 $186.96
031-150-093 4 1.00 $186.97 $186.96
031-150-094 5 1.00 $186.97 $186.96
031-150-095 6 1.00 $186.97 $186.96
031-150-096 7 1.00 $186.97 $186.96
031-150-097 8 1.00 $186.97 $186.96
031-150-098 9 1.00 $186.97 $186.96
031-150-099 10 1.00 $186.97 $186.96
031-150-100 11 1.00 $186.97 $186.96
031-150-101 12 1.00 $186.97 $186.96
031-150-102 13 1.00 $186.97 $186.96
031-150-103 14 1.00 $186.97 $186.96
031-150-104 15 1.00 $186.97 $186.96
031-150-105 16 1.00 $186.97 $186.96
031-150-106 17 1.00 $186.97 $186.96
031-150-107 18 1.00 $186.97 $186.96
031-150-108 19 1.00 $186.97 $186.96
031-150-109 20 1.00 $186.97 $186.96
031-150-110 21 1.00 $186.97 $186.96
TOTALS: 21.00 $3,926.16
246
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

44 ZONE 2 – THE BUTTES
APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
079-040-001 1 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-002 2 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-003 3 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-061 4 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-005 5 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-006 6 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-007 7 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-008 8 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-009 9 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-010 10 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-011 11 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-012 12 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-013 13 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-014 14 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-015 15 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-016 16 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-017 17 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-018 18 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-019 19 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-020 20 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-021 21 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-022 22 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-023 23 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-024 24 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-025 25 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-026 26 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-027 27 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-028 28 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-029 29 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-030 30 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-031 31 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-032 32 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-033 33 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-034 34 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
247
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

45 APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
079-040-035 35 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-036 36 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-037 37 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-038 38 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-039 39 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-040 40 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-041 41 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-042 42 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-043 43 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-044 44 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-045 45 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-046 46 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-047 47 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-048 48 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-049 49 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-050 50 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-051 51 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-052 52 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-053 53 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-054 54 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-055 55 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-056 56 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-057 57 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-058 58 1.00 $122.96 $122.96
079-040-059 A 0.00 $122.96 $0.00
079-040-060 B 0.00 $122.96 $0.00
TOTALS: 58.00 $7,131.68

248
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

46 ZONE 3 – DEER CREEK ESTATES
APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
031-380-001 1 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-002 2 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-003 3 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-004 4 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-005 5 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-006 6 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-007 7 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-008 8 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-009 9 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-010 10 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-011 11 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-012 12 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-013 13 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-014 14 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-015 15 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-016 16 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-017 17 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-018 18 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-019 19 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-020 20 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-021 21 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-022 22 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-023 58 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-024 56 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-025 55 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-026 54 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-027 53 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-028 52 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-029 51 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-030 59 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-031 57B 0.00 $30.12 $0.00
031-380-032 60 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-033 61 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-034 62 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
249
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

47 APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
031-380-035 63 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-036 64 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-380-037 65 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-001 23 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-002 24 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-003 25 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-004 26 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-005 27 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-006 28 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-007 29 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-008 30 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-009 31 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-010 32 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-011 33 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-012 34 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-013 35 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-014 36 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-015 37 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-016 38 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-017 47 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-018 48 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-019 49 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-020 50 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-021 66 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-022 76 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-023 86 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-024 69 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-025 70 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-026 71 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-027 72 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-028 73 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-029 39 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-030 40 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-031 41 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-032 42 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-033 43 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
250
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

48 APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
031-390-034 44 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-035 45 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-036 46 1.00 $30.12 $30.12
031-390-037 57A 0.00 $30.12 $0.00
TOTALS: 72.00 $2,168.64
ZONE 4 – CALLE VISTA ESTATES, UNIT 1
APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
030-490-001 1 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-002 2 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-003 3 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-004 4 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-005 5 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-006 6 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-007 7 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-008 8 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-009 9 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-010 10 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-011 11 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-012 12 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-013 13 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-014 14 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-015 15 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-016 16 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-017 17 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-018 18 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-019 19 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-020 20 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-021 21 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-022 22 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-023 23 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
251
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

49 APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
030-490-024 24 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-025 25 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-026 26 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-027 27 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-028 28 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-029 29 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-030 30 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-031 31 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-032 32 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-033 33 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-034 34 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-035 35 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-036 36 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-037 37 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-038 38 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-039 39 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-040 40 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-041 41 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-044 44 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-045 45 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-046 46 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-047 47 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-048 48 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-049 49 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-050 50 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-051 51 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-052 52 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-053 53 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-054 54 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-055 55 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-056 56 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-057 57 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-058 58 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-059 59 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-060 60 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-061 61 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
252
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

50 APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
030-490-062 62 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-063 63 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-064 64 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-065 65 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-066 66 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-067 67 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-068 68 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-069 69 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-070 70 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-072 42 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
030-490-073 43 1.00 $76.11 $76.10
TOTALS: 70.00 $5,327.00
ZONE 5 – CHEROKEE ESTATES
APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
031-400-002 1 1.00 $79.08 $79.08
031-400-003 2 1.00 $79.08 $79.08
031-400-004 3 1.00 $79.08 $79.08
031-400-005 4 1.00 $79.08 $79.08
031-400-006 5 1.00 $79.08 $79.08
031-400-007 6 1.00 $79.08 $79.08
031-400-008 7 1.00 $79.08 $79.08
031-400-009 28 1.00 $79.08 $79.08
031-400-010 29 1.00 $79.08 $79.08
031-400-011 30 1.00 $79.08 $79.08
031-400-034 1 1.00 $79.08 $79.08
031-400-035 32 1.00 $79.08 $79.08
TOTALS: 12.00 $948.96
253
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

51 ZONE 6 – SHERWOOD ESTATES, UNITS 1 & 2
APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
030-550-001 1 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-002 2 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-003 3 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-004 4 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-005 5 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-006 6 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-007 7 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-008 8 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-009 9 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-010 10 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-011 11 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-012 12 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-013 13 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-014 14 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-015 15 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-016 16 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-017 17 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-018 18 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-019 19 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-020 20 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-021 21 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-022 22 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-023 23 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-024 24 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-025 25 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-026 26 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-027 27 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-028 28 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-029 29 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-030 30 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-031 31 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-032 32 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-033 33 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-034 34 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
254
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

52 APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
030-550-035 35 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-036 36 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-037 37 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-038 38 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-039 39 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-040 40 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-041 41 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-042 42 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-043 43 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-044 44 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-045 45 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-046 46 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-047 47 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-048 48 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
030-550-049 49 1.00 $42.00 $42.00
TOTALS: 49.00 $2,058.00
255
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

53 ZONE 7 – GRAYHAWK
APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
031-140-094 1 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-095 2 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-096 3 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-097 4 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-098 5 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-099 6 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-100 7 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-101 8 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-102 9 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-103 10 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-104 11 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-105 12 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-106 13 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-107 14 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-108 15 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-109 16 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-110 17 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-111 18 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-112 19 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-113 20 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-114 21 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-115 22 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-116 23 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-117 24 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-118 25 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-119 26 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-120 27 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-121 28 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-122 29 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
031-140-123 30 1.00 $197.63 $197.62
TOTALS: 30.00 $5,928.60
256
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

54 ZONE 8 – CHEROKEE ESTATES, PHASE 2
APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
031-400-014 8 1.00 $515.71 $190.02
031-400-015 9 1.00 $515.71 $190.02
031-400-016 10 1.00 $515.71 $190.02
031-400-017 11 1.00 $515.71 $190.02
031-400-018 12 1.00 $515.71 $190.02
031-400-019 13 1.00 $515.71 $190.02
031-400-020 14 1.00 $515.71 $190.02
031-400-021 15 1.00 $515.71 $190.02
031-400-022 16 1.00 $515.71 $190.02
031-400-023 17 1.00 $515.71 $190.02
031-400-024 18 1.00 $515.71 $190.02
031-400-025 19 1.00 $515.71 $190.02
031-400-026 20 1.00 $515.71 $190.02
031-400-027 21 1.00 $515.71 $190.02
031-400-028 22 1.00 $515.71 $190.02
031-400-029 23 1.00 $515.71 $190.02
031-400-030 24 1.00 $515.71 $190.02
031-400-031 25 1.00 $515.71 $190.02
031-400-032 26 1.00 $515.71 $190.02
031-400-033 27 1.00 $515.71 $190.02
TOTALS: 20.00 $3,800.40

257
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

55 ZONE 9 – LINKSIDE PLACE, PHASE 1
APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
030-570-001 1 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-002 2 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-003 3 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-004 4 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-005 5 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-006 6 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-007 7 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-008 8 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-009 9 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-010 10 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-011 11 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-012 12 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-013 13 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-014 14 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-015 15 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-016 16 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-017 17 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-018 18 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-019 19 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-020 20 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-021 21 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-022 22 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-023 23 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-024 24 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-025 25 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-026 26 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-027 27 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-028 28 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-029 29 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-030 30 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-031 31 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-032 32 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-033 33 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-034 34 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
258
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

56 APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
030-570-035 35 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-036 36 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-037 37 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-038 38 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-039 39 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-040 40 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-041 41 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-042 42 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-043 43 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-044 44 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-045 45 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-046 46 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-047 47 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-048 48 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-049 49 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-050 50 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-051 51 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-052 52 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-053 53 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-054 54 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-055 55 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-056 56 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-057 57 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-058 58 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-059 59 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-060 60 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-061 61 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-062 62 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-063 63 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-064 64 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-065 65 1.00 $536.62 $65.00
030-570-066 E 0.00 $536.62 $0.00
030-570-999 A, B, C & D 0.00 $536.62 $0.00
TOTALS: 65.00 $4,225.00
259
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

57 ZONE 10 – FOOTHILL ESTATES
APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
079-410-001 1 1.00 $794.86 $110.00
079-410-002 2 1.00 $794.86 $110.00
079-410-003 3 1.00 $794.86 $110.00
079-410-004 4 1.00 $794.86 $110.00
079-410-005 5 1.00 $794.86 $110.00
079-410-006 6 1.00 $794.86 $110.00
079-410-007 7 1.00 $794.86 $110.00
079-410-008 8 1.00 $794.86 $110.00
079-410-009 9 1.00 $794.86 $110.00
079-410-010 10 1.00 $794.86 $110.00
079-410-011 11 1.00 $794.86 $110.00
079-410-012 12 1.00 $794.86 $110.00
079-410-013 13 1.00 $794.86 $110.00
079-410-014 14 1.00 $794.86 $110.00
079-410-015 15 1.00 $794.86 $110.00
079-410-016 16 1.00 $794.86 $110.00
079-410-017 17 1.00 $794.86 $110.00
079-410-018 18 1.00 $794.86 $110.00
079-410-019 19 1.00 $794.86 $110.00
079-410-020 20 1.00 $794.86 $110.00
079-410-021 21 1.00 $794.86 $110.00
079-410-022 22 1.00 $794.86 $110.00
079-410-023 23 1.00 $794.86 $110.00
079-410-024 24 1.00 $794.86 $110.00
079-410-025 25 1.00 $794.86 $110.00
079-410-026 A 0.00 $794.86 $0.00
TOTALS: 25.00 $2,750.00
260
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

58 ZONE 11 – MISSION OLIVE RANCH
APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
033-490-006 1 1.00 $596.37 $406.10
033-490-007 2 1.00 $596.37 $406.10
033-490-008 3 1.00 $596.37 $406.10
033-490-009 4 1.00 $596.37 $406.10
033-490-010 5 1.00 $596.37 $406.10
033-490-011 6 1.00 $596.37 $406.10
033-490-012 7 1.00 $596.37 $406.10
033-490-013 8 1.00 $596.37 $406.10
033-490-014 9 1.00 $596.37 $406.10
033-490-015 10 1.00 $596.37 $406.10
033-490-016 11 1.00 $596.37 $406.10
033-490-017 12 1.00 $596.37 $406.10
033-490-018 13 1.00 $596.37 $406.10
033-490-019 14 1.00 $596.37 $406.10
033-490-020 15 1.00 $596.37 $406.10
033-490-021 16 1.00 $596.37 $406.10
033-490-022 17 1.00 $596.37 $406.10
033-490-023 18 1.00 $596.37 $406.10
033-490-024 19 1.00 $596.37 $406.10
TOTALS: 19.00 $7,715.90
261
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

59 ZONE 12 – VISTA DEL ORO
APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
030-580-001 92 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-002 91 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-003 90 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-004 89 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-005 88 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-006 87 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-007 86 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-008 85 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-009 80 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-010 81 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-011 82 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-012 83 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-013 84 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-014 74 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-015 75 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-016 76 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-017 77 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-018 78 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-019 79 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-020 68 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-021 69 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-022 70 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-023 71 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-024 72 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-025 73 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-026 61 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-027 62 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-028 63 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-029 64 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-030 65 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-031 66 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-032 67 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-033 54 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-034 55 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
262
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

60 APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
030-580-035 56 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-036 57 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-037 58 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-038 59 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-039 60 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-040 33 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-041 34 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-042 35 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-043 36 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-044 37 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-045 38 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-046 39 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-580-047 B 0.00 $234.16 $0.00
030-580-048 C 0.00 $234.16 $0.00
030-580-049 D 0.00 $234.16 $0.00
030-590-001 1 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-002 2 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-003 3 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-004 4 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-005 5 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-006 6 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-007 7 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-008 8 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-009 9 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-010 10 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-011 11 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-012 12 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-013 13 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-014 14 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-015 15 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-016 16 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-017 17 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-018 18 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-019 19 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-020 20 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-021 21 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
263
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

61 APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
030-590-022 22 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-023 23 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-024 24 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-025 25 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-026 26 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-027 27 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-028 28 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-029 29 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-030 30 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-031 31 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-032 32 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-033 33 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-034 34 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-035 35 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-036 36 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-037 37 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-038 38 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-039 39 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-040 40 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-041 41 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-042 42 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-043 43 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-044 44 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-045 45 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-046 46 1.00 $234.16 $30.00
030-590-047 A 0.00 $234.16 $0.00
030-590-048 E 0.00 $234.16 $0.00
TOTALS: 92.00 $2,760.00
264
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

62 ZONE 13 – CALLE VISTA ESTATES, UNIT 2
APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
030-490-074 1 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-075 2 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-076 3 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-077 4 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-078 5 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-079 6 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-080 7 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-081 8 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-082 9 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-083 10 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-084 11 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-085 12 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-086 13 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-087 14 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-088 15 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-089 16 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-090 17 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-091 18 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-092 19 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-093 20 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-094 21 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-095 22 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-096 23 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-097 24 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-098 25 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-099 26 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-100 27 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-101 28 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-102 29 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-103 30 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-104 31 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-105 32 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-106 33 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-107 34 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
265
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

63 APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
030-490-108 35 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-109 36 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-110 37 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-111 38 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-112 39 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-113 40 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-114 41 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-115 42 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-116 43 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
030-490-117 44 1.00 $326.02 $110.16
TOTALS: 44.00 $4,847.04
ZONE 15 – JAKE RICHTER
APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
031-086-013 A 0.00 $348.23 $0.00
031-086-014 1 1.00 $348.23 $348.22
031-086-015 2 1.00 $348.23 $348.22
031-086-016 3 1.00 $348.23 $348.22
031-086-017 4 1.00 $348.23 $348.22
031-086-018 5 1.00 $348.23 $348.22
031-086-019 6 1.00 $348.23 $348.22
031-086-020 7 1.00 $348.23 $348.22
031-086-021 8 1.00 $348.23 $348.22
TOTALS: 8.00 $2,785.76

266
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

64 ZONE 16 – FEATHER RIVER BLUFFS
APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
031-360-001 1 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-002 2 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-003 3 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-004 4 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-005 5 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-006 6 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-007 7 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-008 8 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-009 9 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-010 10 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-011 11 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-012 12 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-013 13 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-014 14 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-015 15 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-016 16 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-017 17 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-018 18 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-019 19 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-020 20 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-021 21 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-022 22 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-023 23 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-024 24 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-025 25 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-026 26 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-027 27 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-028 28 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-029 29 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-031 30 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-031 31 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-032 32 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-033 33 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-034 34 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
267
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

65 APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
031-360-035 35 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-036 36 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-037 37 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-038 38 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-039 39 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-040 40 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-041 41 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-042 42 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-043 43 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-044 44 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-045 45 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-046 46 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-047 47 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-048 48 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-049 49 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-050 50 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-051 51 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-052 52 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-053 53 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-054 54 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-055 55 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-056 56 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-057 57 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-058 58 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-059 59 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-060 60 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-061 61 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-062 62 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-063 63 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-064 64 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-065 65 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-066 66 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-067 67 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-068 68 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-069 69 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-070 70 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
268
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

66 APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
031-360-071 71 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-072 72 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-073 73 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-074 74 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-075 75 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-076 76 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-077 77 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-078 78 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-079 79 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-080 80 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-081 81 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-082 82 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-083 83 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-084 84 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-085 85 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-086 86 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-087 87 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-088 88 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-089 89 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-090 90 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-091 91 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-092 92 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-093 93 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-094 94 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-095 95 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-096 96 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-097 97 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-098 98 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-099 99 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-100 100 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-101 101 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-102 102 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-103 103 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-104 104 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-105 105 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-106 106 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
269
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated LLMAD
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

67 APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
031-360-107 107 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-108 108 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-109 109 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-110 110 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-111 111 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-112 112 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-113 113 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-114 114 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-115 115 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-116 116 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-177 117 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-118 118 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-119 119 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-120 120 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-121 121 1.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-198 D 0.00 $59.40 $0.00
031-360-199 A 0.00 $59.40 $0.00
TOTALS: 121.00 $0.00
270
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Landscape and Lighting Maintenance District City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23
68 ZONE 17 – ACACIA ESTATES
APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
033-360-067 & 068 1 1.00 $112.33 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 2 1.00 $112.33 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 3 1.00 $112.33 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 4 1.00 $112.33 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 5 1.00 $112.33 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 6 1.00 $112.33 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 7 1.00 $112.33 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 8 1.00 $112.33 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 9 1.00 $112.33 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 10 1.00 $112.33 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 11 1.00 $112.33 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 12 1.00 $112.33 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 13 1.00 $112.33 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 14 1.00 $112.33 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 15 1.00 $112.33 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 16 1.00 $112.33 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 17 1.00 $112.33 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 18 1.00 $112.33 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 19 1.00 $112.33 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 20 1.00 $112.33 $0.00
TOTALS: 20.00 $0.00

271
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Landscape and Lighting Maintenance District City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23
69 ZONE 18 –RUDDY CREEK
APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
030-360-091 & 092 1 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 2 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 3 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 4 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 5 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 6 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 7 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 8 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 9 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 10 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 11 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 12 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 13 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 14 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 15 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 16 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 17 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 18 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 19 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 20 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 21 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 22 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 23 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 24 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 25 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 26 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 27 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 28 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 29 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 30 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 31 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 32 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 33 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
272
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Landscape and Lighting Maintenance District City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23
70 APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
030-360-091 & 092 34 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 35 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 36 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 37 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 38 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 39 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 40 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 41 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 42 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 43 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 44 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 45 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 46 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 47 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 48 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 49 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 50 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 51 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 52 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 53 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 54 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 55 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 56 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 57 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 58 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 59 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 60 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 61 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 62 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 63 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 64 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 65 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 66 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 67 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 68 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
273
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Landscape and Lighting Maintenance District City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23
71 APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual
Assessment
030-360-091 & 092 69 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 70 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 71 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 72 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 73 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 74 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 75 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 76 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 77 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 78 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 79 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 80 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 81 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 82 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 83 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 84 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 85 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 86 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 87 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 88 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 89 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 90 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 91 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 92 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 93 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 94 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 95 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 96 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 97 1.00 $150.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 98 0.00 $150.00 $0.00
TOTALS: 97.00 $0.00

274
Item 13.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Landscape and Lighting Maintenance District City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23
72 APPENDIX B – ASSESSMENT DIAGRAM
The following pages show the Assessment Diagram or boundary map for each Zone within the District.

The lines and dimensions shown on maps of the Butte County Assessor, for the current year, are incorporated by reference herein and made a part of this Report. 275
Item 13.

Page 1 ends

CITY OF OROVILLE

STAFF REPORT
TO: MAYOR REYNOLDS AND CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS
FROM: DAWN NEVERS, ASSISTANT COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR RE: ANNUAL ASSESSMENTS FOR THE CITY’S CONSOLIDATED BENEFIT ASSESSMENT DISTRICT, ZONES 1, 4, 5, 9
DATE: AUGUST 2, 2022

SUMMARY
The Council will hold a public hearing approving the Annual Assessment Report and declaring its intention to levy and collect assessments for the Oroville Consolidated Benefit Assessment District for Fiscal Year 2022/23

DISCUSSION
As a condition of approval for each subdivision identified below, the developer was required to establish or annex into a Benefit Assessment District. Each subdivision represents a Zone within the larger district. Each Zone is financially responsible for the maintenance of the storm water infrastructure (manholes, drainpipes, etc.), including storm water retention facilities within the subdivision. The particular Zones within the City’s Consolidated Benefit Assessment District (“CBAD”) are identified below:

ZONE NUMBER AND NAME
Zone 1 – Linkside Place
Zone 4 – Vista Del Oro
Zone 5 – Calle Vista
Zone 9 – Ruddy Creek
Pursuant to the Benefit Assessment Act of 1982, which authorizes the formation and annual administration of such districts, an Annual Assessment Report was prepared and filed with the City Clerk prior to tonight’s meeting. The purpose of the report is to document the annual costs involved in the operation, maintenance and servicing of all improvements, adjust the annual assessments, to incorporate any surplus or deficit from the previous year and to determine the actual annual assessment for each assessable parcel within the CBAD.

The City Council will consider the following items for all nine Zones within the CBAD:

1. Preliminarily approve the Annual Assessment Report and the proposed levy and collection of assessments for the CBAD for Fiscal Year 2022/23. 276
Item 14.

Page 2 ends

2. Direct Staff to make any changes or amendments to the Annual Assessment Report as necessary.

RECOMMENDATION
Adopt Resolution No. 9088 - A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL INITIATING

PROCEEDINGS, PRELIMINARILY APPROVING THE ANNUAL ASSESSMENT REPORT

AND DECLARING ITS INTENTION TO LEVY AND COLLECT ASSESSMENTS FOR THE

OROVILLE CONSOLIDATED BENEFIT ASSESSMENT DISTRICT FOR FISCAL YEAR 2022/23; and
Authorize any necessary budget adjustments to the Annual Assessment Report.

ATTACHMENTS
Resolution No. 9088
2022/23 Assessment Summary from the CBAD Annual Assessment Report.

Page 1 of 3 ends

CITY OF OROVILLE
RESOLUTION NO. 9088

A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL AUTHORIZING AND DIRECTING THE

MAYOR TO APPROVE THE ANNUAL ASSESSMENT REPORT, AS SUBMITTED OR

AMENDED, AND TO ORDER THE LEVY AND COLLECTION OF ASSESSMENTS FOR

THE OROVILLE CONSOLIDATED BENEFIT ASSESSMENT DISTRICT FOR FISCAL YEAR 2022/23
WHEREAS, the Oroville City Council, pursuant to the terms of the “Benefit Assessment Act of 1982” (the “1982 Act”), Title 5, Division 2, Part 1 of the California Government Code (commencing with Section 54703) did by previous Resolutions, initiate proceedings and approve the Annual Assessment Report (the “Report”), on a preliminary basis, for the special maintenance district known and designated as “The Oroville Consolidated Benefit Assessment District” (the “District”). The District is comprised of several Zones which are identified below:

ZONE NUMBER AND NAME
Zone 1 – Linkside Place
Zone 4 – Vista Del Oro
Zone 5 – Calle Vista
Zone 9 – Ruddy Creek
WHEREAS, the engineer selected by the City Council has prepared and filed with the City Clerk, the Report in connection with the proposed levy and collection of assessments upon eligible parcels of land within each Zone. The Report has been prepared based on the estimated costs to operate, maintain and service the improvements located within particular Zones of the District; and, WHEREAS, the City Council has carefully examined and reviewed the Report and is satisfied with each of the items and documents as presented therein, and finds that the assessments have been spread to the eligible parcels within each Zone in accordance with the special benefit received from said improvements; and, WHEREAS, the assessments are not based on the assessed value of the properties within the Zones but are based on the special benefit conferred upon said eligible parcels from the improvements, and the maintenance and operation thereof; and, WHEREAS, the assessments are in compliance with all laws pertaining to the levy and collection of assessments, including Proposition 218; and, NOW, THEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY RESOLVED AS FOLLOWS:

1. Following notice duly given, the City Council has held a full and fair public hearing regarding the Report and the levy and collection of assessments within 278
Item 14.

Page 2 of 3 ends

the District. The City Council received and considered all written and oral statements, including any and all protests or other communications made or filed by any interested persons.

2. Based upon its review (and any applicable amendments) of the Report, a copy of which has been filed with the City Clerk, the City Council hereby finds and determines that:
a. The assessable properties within the Zones will receive special benefit from the operation, maintenance and servicing of the drainage improvements. b. The Zones include all properties receiving such special benefit. c. The net amount to be assessed upon the properties is based on the historical and estimated costs to provide said maintenance and servicing and is apportioned by a formula that fairly distributes the net amount among all assessable parcels in proportion to the estimated special benefit received from the improvements and services.

3. The Report and assessments, as presented and which are on file with the office of the City Clerk, are hereby confirmed as filed.

4. The City Council hereby orders the maintenance and servicing of the improvements to be made in accordance with the Report and the 1982 Act.

5. The maintenance, operation and servicing of the drainage improvements shall be performed pursuant to the 1982 Act and the County Auditor of Butte County shall enter onto the County Tax Roll, opposite each assessable parcel of land, the assessment amount and such assessments shall be collected at the same time and in the same manner as the County taxes are collected. After collection of the assessments by the County, the net amount of said assessments shall be paid to the City Treasurer.

6. The City Treasurer shall deposit all money representing assessments collected by the County to the credit of a fund especially for the District. Such money shall be expended only for the maintenance, operations and servicing of the improvements located within the District boundaries.

7. The adoption of this Resolution constitutes the levy of assessments within the Zones for the fiscal year beginning July 1, 2022 and ending June 30, 2023.

8. The City Clerk is hereby authorized and directed to file the levy with the County Auditor upon adoption of this Resolution.

9. A certified copy of this Resolution shall be filed in the office of the City Clerk and shall remain open for public inspection.

PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Oroville City Council at a regular meeting held on August 2, 2022, by the following vote:

AYES:
279
Item 14.

Page 3 of 3 ends

NOES:

ABSTAIN:

ABSTENT:

Chuck Reynolds, Mayor
APPROVED AS TO FORM: ATTEST:

Scott Huber, City Attorney Jackie Glover, Assistant City Clerk 280
Item 14.

CBAD 2022/23 ASSESSMENT SUMMARY
Zone Name
Total
Assessable
Unit
Total
Assessable
Cost
Maximum
Assessment
Rate per Unit
Proposed
Assessment
Rate per Unit
Zone 1 – Linkside Place, Phase 1 65 $3,550.30 $407.39 $54.62 Zone 2 – Foothill Estates 25 $2,438.50 $473.88 $97.54
Zone 3 – Mission Olive Ranch 19 $2,599.96 $412.91 $136.84 Zone 4 – Vista Del Oro 92 $4,478.56 $332.57 $48.68
Zone 5 – Calle Vista Estates, Unit 2 44 $3,062.40 $246.08 $69.60 Zone 6 – Martin Ranch 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
Zone 7 – Jake Richter 8 $1,344.32 $352.17 $168.04
Zone 8 – Acacia Estates 20 $0.00 $245.68 $0.00
Zone 9 – Ruddy Creek 97 $0.00 $119.00 $0.00
TOTALS: 370 $17,474.04
281
Item 14.

CITY OF OROVILLE
FINAL ENGINEER’S REPORT

CONSOLIDATED BENEFIT ASSESSMENT DISTRICT
FISCAL YEAR 2022-23
July 2022

PREPARED BY
Harris & Associates
1401 Willow Pass Road, Suite 500
Concord, CA 94520
www.weareharris.com
282
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

TABLE OF CONTENTS
Statement of Assessment Engineer ............................................................................... i Part I – Overview ........................................................................................................... 1 Part II – Plans and Specifications .................................................................................. 3 Part III – Method of Apportionment ............................................................................. 4 Part IV – Zone Budgets .................................................................................................. 7 Appendix A – Assessment Roll
Appendix B – Assessment Diagram
283
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23
i

STATEMENT OF ASSESSMENT ENGINEER
AGENCY: THE CITY OF OROVILLE
PROJECT: CONSOLIDATED BENEFIT ASSESSMENT DISTRICT
TO: THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE

CITY OF OROVILLE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA
ENGINEER’S REPORT FOR FISCAL YEAR 2022-23
The preparation of this Annual Engineer’s Report (“Report”) is in conformance with the obligation of the City Council for the annual levy of assessments within the Consolidated Benefit Assessment District of the City of Oroville to provide services upon each lot or parcel of land in the district in proportion to the estimated benefit to be received by each such lot or parcel of land for Fiscal Year 2022-23.

Pursuant to the provisions of the Benefit Assessment Act of 1982, commencing with Section 54703 (the “1982 Act”), and in compliance with the substantive and procedural requirements of the California State Constitution Article XIII D (the “California Constitution”) the City Council of the City of Oroville (the “City”), adopted a Resolution Initiating Proceedings for the Levy and Collection of Annual Assessments within the Consolidated Benefit Assessment District (the “District”) for Fiscal Year 2022-23. Said Resolution called for the preparation and filing of an annual report (the “Report”) pursuant to section 54716 of the 1982 Act, presenting plans and specifications describing the general nature, location and extent of the improvements and an estimate of the costs to maintain said improvements within the District.

CONSOLIDATED BENEFIT ASSESSMENT DISTRICT
(Hereinafter referred to as the “District”),
I, Tamorah Bryant, authorized representative of the District, the duly appointed Assessment Engineer submit the following Report which consists of the following four (4) parts and Appendices:
284
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23
ii
PART I
Overview: This part provides a general description of the District, Proposition 218 and a summary of the proposed assessment.

PART IV
Estimate of Cost: This part contains the cost estimate of the proposed maintenance including incidental costs and expenses for Fiscal Year 2022-23.

DATED this 28th day of July, 2022

Tamorah Bryant, P.E., Assessment Engineer
R.C.E. No. C67205
Engineer of Work
285
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

1 PART I – OVERVIEW
The District is comprised of the nine (9) residential developments designated as Zones within the District.

Zone number 6, Martin Ranch, was formed but never developed. It will therefore, remain un-assessed until such time as development is renewed or another development takes over the project area. Please refer to the table below which details the number of parcels within each Zone as well as the distinct name and number designation. Also included in the table below are the total costs to be assessed, the Proposed Assessment Rate and the Maximum Assessment Rate allowed for Fiscal Year 2022-23.

CBAD FISCAL YEAR 2022-23 ASSESSMENT SUMMARY
Zone Name
Total
Assessable
Unit
Total
Assessable
Cost
Maximum
Assessment
Rate per Unit
Actual
Assessment
Rate per Unit
Zone 1 – Linkside Place, Phase 1 65 $3,550.30 $407.39 $54.62 Zone 2 – Foothill Estates 25 $2,438.50 $473.88 $97.54
Zone 3 – Mission Olive Ranch 19 $2,599.96 $412.91 $136.84 Zone 4 – Vista Del Oro 92 $4,478.56 $332.57 $48.68
Zone 5 – Calle Vista Estates, Unit 2 44 $3,062.40 $246.08 $69.60 Zone 6 – Martin Ranch 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
Zone 7 – Jake Richter 8 $1,344.32 $352.17 $168.04
Zone 8 – Acacia Estates 20 $0.00 $245.68 $0.00
Zone 9 – Ruddy Creek 97 $0.00 $119.00 $0.00
TOTALS: 370 $17,474.04
The February Consumer Price Index (“CPI”) is used to determine the Maximum Assessment Rate each year. The February CPI is added to the previous years’ Maximum Assessment Rate to determine the adjusted Maximum Assessment for each Zone for the current year. Please refer to Section III of this Report, “Assessment Range Formula” for a complete description of the CPI tables used for this purpose. 286
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

2 The table below provides the historical increases in the February CPI, beginning in Fiscal Year 2006-07. CPI is shown here at 7 decimal points for purposes of accuracy and for calculating the Adjusted Maximum Assessment each year.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

3 PART II – PLANS AND SPECIFICATIONS
Description of the District and Boundaries
The District was formed for the purpose of ensuring the ongoing maintenance, operation and servicing of certain drainage and storm water improvements within the boundaries of each Zone. Said improvements are detailed below under “Improvements and Services Provided”.

Each Zone was formed and annexed into the District as a condition of development. The Zones are located throughout the City of Oroville.

Improvements and Services Provided
The improvements and services for all Zones may be identified as: Drainage improvements within each Zone may include but are not limited to: flood control and storm water facilities, graffiti removal, masonry walls and other appurtenant facilities. The services provided include all necessary service, operations, administration and maintenance required to keep the above mentioned facilities in a proper working condition. The improvements within each individual Zone are:
 Zone 1 – Linkside Place, Phase 1: Detention basins, channel fencing, pump station and controller and storm drain pipes.
 Zone 2 – Foothill Estates: Detention basins, channel fencing and storm drain pipes.  Zone 3 – Mission Olive Ranch: Detention basins, wood channel fencing and storm drain pipes.  Zone 4 – Vista Del Oro: Detention basin, drainage infrastructure maintenance, storm drain pipes and fencing/gates.
 Zone 5 – Calle Vista Estates, Phase 2: Detention basin, drainage infrastructure maintenance, storm drain pipes and fencing/gate.
 Zone 6 – Martin Ranch: There are currently no improvements being maintained within this undeveloped Zone and none are currently planned.
 Zone 7 – Jake Richter: Detention basins, drainage channels, drainage infrastructure maintenance and storm drain pipes.
 Zone 8 – Acacia Estates: Detention basins, drainage channels, drainage infrastructure maintenance and storm drain pipes. This Zone is undeveloped as of July 2022.  Zone 9 – Ruddy Creek: Detention basins, drainage channels, drainage infrastructure maintenance and storm drain pipes. This Zone is undeveloped as of July 2022.

Reference is made to the plans and specifications for the improvements which are on file with the City and are incorporated herein by reference.

288
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

4 PART III – METHOD OF APPORTIONMENT
The 1982 Act allows for the establishment of assessment districts, by public agencies, for the purpose of providing certain public improvements as detailed in Section I of this Report. The 1982 Act also complies with the California Constitution which requires the cost of these improvements and services to be assessed based on benefit received rather than by assessed value of the properties being assessed. In accordance with Article XIII D, Section 4 of the California Constitution:
“An agency which proposes to levy an assessment shall identify all parcels which will have a special benefit conferred upon them and upon which an assessment will be imposed.

The proportionate special benefit derived by each identified parcel shall be determined in relationship to the entirety of the capital cost of a public improvement, the maintenance and operation expenses of the public improvement or the cost of the property related service being provided. No assessment shall be imposed on any parcel which exceeds the reasonable cost of the proportional special benefit conferred on that parcel. Only special benefits are assessable…”
The method of apportionment described in this Report for the allocation of special benefit assessments utilizes commonly accepted engineering practices which have been established pursuant to the 1982 Act and the California Constitution. The calculation of assessments is based upon the parcel type and the services and improvements provided to equitably apportion the costs based on the special benefit received by each lot or parcel. The special benefit received by each lot or parcel is over and above any general benefit conferred upon said lots or parcels or to the public at large.

Description of the Benefit
Special Benefit
The improvements and associated costs have been carefully allocated to the assessable properties within the District based on the special benefit received by those properties, pursuant to the provisions of the California Constitution. The improvements for which the properties will be assessed have been identified as necessary, were required as a part of the development plans specifically for the tract and are also in compliance with the development plans and General Plan of the City. As such, the improvements and continuing maintenance and servicing are strictly the obligation of the properties within the District.

Definition of Special Benefit
The method of apportionment described in this Report, and confirmed by the City Council, utilizes commonly accepted engineering practices which have been established pursuant to the 1982 Act and the California Constitution for the allocation of special benefit assessments. In accordance with Article XIII D, Section 4 of the California Constitution:
289
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

5 “Special benefit means a particular and distinct benefit over and above general benefits conferred on real property located in the District or the public at large” The special benefits associated with the local improvements are specifically:
 Enhanced desirability of properties due to existence of the improvements and the services provided by the District.
 Improved aesthetic appeal provided by a positive representation of the development, neighborhood and the community.
 Improved ingress and egress to property resulting in enhanced traffic flow, reduced traffic accidents and possible property damage.

Assessment Range Formula
It is generally recognized that most budgetary items will be impacted by inflation in future years. In accordance with the California Constitution, Section 53739 (b)(1), assessments “may be adjusted for inflation pursuant to a clearly defined formula…” A formula for an inflationary adjustment is therefore included as part of the maximum assessment for each Zone within this District and was approved by the property owner(s) at the time of formation. The formula, as described below, allows for annual adjustments to the budget and the assessments.

Generally, any new or increased assessment requires certain noticing and meeting requirements by law.

That initial maximum assessment was established at that time and has been adjusted each subsequent fiscal year by the following Assessment Range Formula:
 The Maximum Assessment Rate allowed each fiscal year (the “Adjusted Maximum Assessment Rate”) shall be based on the initial maximum assessment, adjusted annually by the Bureau of Labor Statistics, Consumer Price Index for the month of February, All Urban Consumers, (“CPI”) for the San Francisco/Oakland/Hayward area. Should the Bureau of Labor Statistics revise or discontinue the preparation of such index, the City reserves the right to use such revised index or a comparable system to determine fluctuations in the annual cost of living.  Each fiscal year, the February CPI amount has been applied to the Maximum Assessment Rate established the previous fiscal year to calculate the appropriate Adjusted Maximum Assessment Rate for the then current fiscal year.
 If the proposed annual assessment rate for the upcoming fiscal year is less than or equal to the Adjusted Maximum Assessment Rate established for that fiscal year then the proposed annual assessment is not considered an increased assessment.
290
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

6 Beginning in the second fiscal year after the annexation of a Zone, and each fiscal year since, the Maximum Assessment Rate has been recalculated and a new Maximum Assessment Rate (Adjusted Maximum Assessment Rate) has been established for each fiscal year using the Assessment Range Formula described above. The Adjusted Maximum Assessment Rate has been calculated independent of the annual budget and proposed assessment rate for the given fiscal year. As stated above, if the proposed annual assessment for any fiscal year does not exceed the Adjusted Maximum Assessment Rate for that year, it is not considered an increased assessment under the terms of Proposition 218 or the Government Code.

The CPI increase for the one year period ending in February 2022 was 5.19 (rounded). This amount will be applied to the Maximum Assessment for each Zone within the District, which will establish the Adjusted Maximum Assessment for each Zone for Fiscal Year 2022-23.

To impose a new assessment or increased assessment in excess of the Maximum Assessment Rate for the current fiscal year, as provided by the preceding Assessment Range Formula, the City must comply with the provisions of the California Constitution, Article XIII D, Section 4c that requires a public hearing and certain protest procedures including mailed notice of the public hearing and property owner protest balloting. Property owners must approve the proposed new or increased assessment via a property owner protest balloting process before any such new or increased assessment can be imposed. A protest occurs when, at the public hearing, the returned assessment ballots opposed to the new or increased assessment outweigh the returned ballots in favor of the new or increased assessment, weighting those assessment ballots by the financial obligation of each parcel.

ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY
The benefit formula used to determine the financial obligation for each parcel should be based on the improvements benefitting the parcels, as well as the use, or type, of each parcel as compared to other parcels that benefit from said improvements. One of the more common approaches to fairly distributing District costs to the benefitting parcels in maintenance districts such as this utilizes a methodology referred to as the Per Parcel method of apportionment. This method recognizes that each parcel within a particular Zone benefits equally from the improvements. This is typical when all parcels within the Zone are of the same type (all single family dwellings).

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

7 PART IV – COST ESTIMATE
The estimated budget for the annual maintenance and servicing of the improvements and the proportionate share of administration costs for each Zone within the District have been prepared based on the estimated and historical costs. The individual Zone budgets are shown on the following pages.

In addition to the Budget Tables, there is another table for each Zone which shows the February CPI for each year, the calculated adjustment to the previous years’ assessment and the Adjusted Maximum Assessment for each Zone.

292
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

8 Zone 1 – Linkside Place, Phase 1 Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Detention Pond Maintenance $1,000.00
Fencing 250.00
Pump Station Electricity 886.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $2,136.00

INDIRECT COSTS
Maintenance Repairs & Contingency $500.00
City Personnel/Overhead 120.00
City Personnel/New Park Tech II 513.39
Truck/Equipment 513.39
CBAD Administration Fee 265.55
Professional Fees 0.00
County Administration Fee – $0.30 per assessed parcel 19.50 Rounding Adjustment 0.28
Indirect Costs Sub-Total $1,932.11
SUB-TOTAL COSTS $4,068.11
Contingency Reserve – 20 % of Total Costs $813.62
TOTAL COSTS $4,881.73
7/1/2022 Beginning Fund Balance $1,331.43
2022-23 TOTAL ASSESSMENT $3,550.30
Total Number of Assessable Parcels 65
2022-23 ACTUAL ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $54.62
2022-23 MAXIMUM ASSESSMENT $407.39
2021-22 ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $5.02
293
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

9 Annual CPI Calculations for Zone 1 – Linkside Place, Phase 1 are shown in the table below:

Fiscal Year CPI Increase
Adjusted
Max
2005-2006 N/A $255.980
2006-2007 2.93% $263.486
2007-2008 3.18% $271.868
2008-2009 2.77% $279.405
2009-2010 1.16% $282.654
2010-2011 1.79% $287.717
2011-2012 1.70% $292.597
2012-2013 3.00% $301.374
2013-2014 2.45% $308.750
2014-2015 2.45% $316.305
2015-2016 2.53% $324.313
2016-2017 3.02% $334.097
2017-2018 3.44% $345.580
2018-2019 3.56% $357.898
2019-2020 3.53% $370.532
2020-2021 2.91% $381.299
2021-2022 1.57% $387.276
2022-2023 5.19% $407.388
*Rounded to 2 decimal points. Calculation is performed at 7 decimal points each year. 294
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

10 Zone 2 – Foothill Estates Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Detention Pond Maintenance $450.00
Fencing 500.00
Drainage Pipes 0.00
Pump Station Electricity 275.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $1,225.00

INDIRECT COSTS
Maintenance Repairs & Contingency $500.00
City Personnel/Overhead 120.00
City Personnel/New Park Tech II 504.10
Truck/Equipment 504.10
CBAD Administration Fee 260.74
Professional Fees 0.00
County Administration Fee – $0.30 per assessed parcel 7.50 Rounding Adjustment 0.08
Indirect Costs Sub-Total $1,896.52
SUB-TOTAL COSTS $3,121.52
Contingency Reserve – 20 % of Total Costs $624.30
TOTAL COSTS $3,745.82
7/1/2022 Beginning Fund Balance $1,307.32
2022-23 TOTAL ASSESSMENT $2,438.50
Total Number of Assessable Parcels 25
2022-23 ACTUAL ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $97.54
2022-23 MAXIMUM ASSESSMENT $473.88
2021-22 ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $37.48
295
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

11 Annual CPI Calculations for Zone 2 – Foothill Estates are shown in the table below:

Fiscal Year CPI Increase Adjusted Max
2005-2006 N/A $297.760
2006-2007 2.93% $306.492
2007-2008 3.18% $316.241
2008-2009 2.77% $325.008
2009-2010 1.16% $328.788
2010-2011 1.79% $334.677
2011-2012 1.70% $340.354
2012-2013 3.00% $350.564
2013-2014 2.45% $359.143
2014-2015 2.45% $367.930
2015-2016 2.53% $377.247
2016-2017 3.02% $388.626
2017-2018 3.44% $401.984
2018-2019 3.56% $416.313
2019-2020 3.53% $431.009
2020-2021 2.91% $443.534
2021-2022 1.57% $450.485
2022-2023 5.19% $473.880
*Rounded to 2 decimal points. Calculation is performed at 7 decimal points each year. 296
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

12 Zone 3 – Mission Olive Ranch Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Detention Pond Maintenance $500.00
Fencing 500.00
Pump Station Electricity 140.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $1,140.00

INDIRECT COSTS
Maintenance Repairs & Contingency $500.00
City Personnel/Overhead 0.00
City Personnel/New Park Tech II 1,519.37
Truck/Equipment 1,519.37
CBAD Administration Fee 765.80
Professional Fees 0.00
County Administration Fee – $0.30 per assessed parcel 5.70 Rounding Adjustment 0.00
Indirect Costs Sub-Total $4,310.24
SUB-TOTAL COSTS $5,450.24
Contingency Reserve – 20 % of Total Costs $1,090.05
TOTAL COSTS $6,540.29
7/1/2022 Beginning Fund Balance $3,940.33
2022-23 TOTAL ASSESSMENT $2,599.96
Total Number of Assessable Parcels 19
2022-23 ACTUAL ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $136.84
2022-23 MAXIMUM ASSESSMENT $412.91
2021-22 ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $0.00
297
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

13 Annual CPI Calculations for Zone 3 – Mission Olive Ranch are shown in the table below:

Fiscal Year CPI Increase Adjusted Max
2006-2007 N/A $267.060
2007-2008 3.18% $275.555
2008-2009 2.77% $283.194
2009-2010 1.16% $286.488
2010-2011 1.79% $291.619
2011-2012 1.70% $296.566
2012-2013 3.00% $305.462
2013-2014 2.45% $312.937
2014-2015 2.45% $320.595
2015-2016 2.53% $328.712
2016-2017 3.02% $338.628
2017-2018 3.44% $350.267
2018-2019 3.56% $362.752
2019-2020 3.53% $375.557
2020-2021 2.91% $386.471
2021-2022 1.57% $392.528
2022-2023 5.19% $412.914
*Rounded to 2 decimal points. Calculation is performed at 7 decimal points each year. 298
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

14 Zone 4 – Vista Del Oro Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Detention Pond Maintenance $500.00
Fencing 500.00
Drainage Pipes 0.00
Pump Station Electricity 702.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $1,702.00

INDIRECT COSTS
Maintenance Repairs & Contingency $500.00
City Personnel/Overhead 1,000.00
City Personnel/New Park Tech II 1,410.91
Truck/Equipment 1,410.91
CBAD Administration Fee 729.78
Professional Fees 0.00
County Administration Fee – $0.30 per assessed parcel 27.60 Rounding Adjustment 0.16
Indirect Costs Sub-Total $5,079.36
SUB-TOTAL COSTS $6,781.36
Contingency Reserve – 20 % of Total Costs $1,356.27
TOTAL COSTS $8,137.63
7/1/2022 Beginning Fund Balance $3,659.07
2022-23 TOTAL ASSESSMENT $4,478.56
Total Number of Assessable Parcels 92
2022-23 ACTUAL ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $48.68
2022-23 MAXIMUM ASSESSMENT $332.57
2021-22 ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $0.00
299
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

15 Annual CPI Calculations for Zone 4 – Vista Del Oro are shown in the table below:

Fiscal Year CPI Increase Adjusted Max
2006-2007 N/A $215.100
2007-2008 3.18% $221.942
2008-2009 2.77% $228.095
2009-2010 1.16% $230.748
2010-2011 1.79% $234.881
2011-2012 1.70% $238.865
2012-2013 3.00% $246.030
2013-2014 2.45% $252.051
2014-2015 2.45% $258.219
2015-2016 2.53% $264.757
2016-2017 3.02% $272.743
2017-2018 3.44% $282.118
2018-2019 3.56% $292.174
2019-2020 3.53% $302.488
2020-2021 2.91% $311.278
2021-2022 1.57% $316.157
2022-2023 5.19% $332.576
*Rounded to 2 decimal points. Calculation is performed at 7 decimal points each year. 300
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

16 Zone 5 – Calle Vista Estates, Unit 2 Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Detention Basin Maintenance $500.00
Fencing 500.00
Drainage Pipes 0.00
Pump Station Electricity 349.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $1,349.00

INDIRECT COSTS
Maintenance Repairs & Contingency $500.00
City Personnel/Overhead 120.00
City Personnel/New Park Tech II 1,600.33
Truck/Equipment 1,600.33
CBAD Administration Fee 827.91
Professional Fees 0.00
County Administration Fee – $0.30 per assessed parcel 13.20 Rounding Adjustment 0.46
Indirect Costs Sub-Total $4,662.23
SUB-TOTAL COSTS $6,011.23
Contingency Reserve – 20 % of Total Costs $1,202.25
TOTAL COSTS $7,213.47
7/1/2022 Beginning Fund Balance $4,151.07
2022-23 TOTAL ASSESSMENT $3,062.40
Total Number of Assessable Parcels 44
2022-23 ACTUAL ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $69.60
2022-23 MAXIMUM ASSESSMENT $246.08
2021-22 ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $0.00
301
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

17 Annual CPI Calculations for Zone 5 – Calle Vista Estates, Unit 2 are shown in the table below:

Fiscal Year CPI Increase Adjusted Max
2006-2007 N/A $159.160
2007-2008 3.18% $164.223
2008-2009 2.77% $168.776
2009-2010 1.16% $170.738
2010-2011 1.79% $173.796
2011-2012 1.70% $176.744
2012-2013 3.00% $182.046
2013-2014 2.45% $186.502
2014-2015 2.45% $191.065
2015-2016 2.53% $195.903
2016-2017 3.02% $201.812
2017-2018 3.44% $208.749
2018-2019 3.56% $216.190
2019-2020 3.53% $223.821
2020-2021 2.91% $230.325
2021-2022 1.57% $233.935
2022-2023 5.19% $246.085
*Rounded to 2 decimal points. Calculation is performed at 7 decimal points each year. 302
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

18 Zone 6 – Martin Ranch Budget
This Zone was annexed into the District but development never began. Until such time as development begins, there will be no assessment and therefore, no budget for this Zone The City may also decide to de-annex this Zone from the District in the future. Ground was never broken and the development may never be built. Zone 6 will be left “blank” until such time as this area develops or another area is developed to “replace” Zone 6 within the structure of the District.

303
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

19 Zone 7 – Jake Richter Estates Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Detention Basin Maintenance $250.00
Fencing 250.00
Drainage Pipes 0.00
Pump Station Electricity 0.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $500.00

INDIRECT COSTS
Maintenance Repairs & Contingency $500.00
City Personnel/Overhead 0.00
City Personnel/New Park Tech II 330.89
Truck/Equipment 330.89
CBAD Administration Fee 171.15
Professional Fees 0.00
County Administration Fee – $0.30 per assessed parcel 2.40 Rounding Adjustment 0.05
Indirect Costs Sub-Total $1,335.38
SUB-TOTAL COSTS $1,835.38
Contingency Reserve – 20 % of Total Costs $367.08
TOTAL COSTS $2,202.46
7/1/2022 Beginning Fund Balance $858.14
2022-23 TOTAL ASSESSMENT $1,344.32
Total Number of Assessable Parcels 8
2022-23 ACTUAL ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $168.04
2022-23 MAXIMUM ASSESSMENT $352.17
2021-22 ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $9.94
304
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

20 Annual CPI Calculations for Zone 7 – Jake Richter Estates are shown in the table below:

Fiscal Year CPI Increase
Adjusted
Max
2007-2008 N/A $235.020
2008-2009 2.77% $241.535
2009-2010 1.16% $244.344
2010-2011 1.79% $248.721
2011-2012 1.70% $252.939
2012-2013 3.00% $260.527
2013-2014 2.45% $266.903
2014-2015 2.45% $273.434
2015-2016 2.53% $280.357
2016-2017 3.02% $288.814
2017-2018 3.44% $298.741
2018-2019 3.56% $309.390
2019-2020 3.53% $320.311
2020-2021 2.91% $329.619
2021-2022 1.57% $334.786
2022-2023 5.19% $352.172
*Rounded to 2 decimal points. Calculation is performed at 7 decimal points each year. 305
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

21 Zone 8 – Acacia Estates Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Detention Pond Maintenance $0.00
Fencing 0.00
Drainage Pipes 0.00
Pump Station Electricity 0.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $0.00

INDIRECT COSTS
Maintenance Repairs & Contingency $0.00
City Personnel/Overhead 0.00
CBAD Administration Fee 0.00
Professional Fees 0.00
County Administration Fee – $0.30 per assessed parcel 0.00 Rounding Adjustment 0.00
Indirect Costs Sub-Total $0.00
SUB-TOTAL COSTS $0.00
Contingency Reserve – 20 % of Total Costs $0.00
TOTAL COSTS $0.00
7/1/2022 Beginning Fund Balance $0.00
2022-23 TOTAL ASSESSMENT $0.00
Total Number of Assessable Parcels 20
2022-23 ACTUAL ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $0.00
2022-23 MAXIMUM ASSESSMENT $245.68
2021-22 ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $0.00
306
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

22 Annual CPI Calculations for Zone 8 – Acacia Estates are shown in the table below:

Fiscal Year CPI Increase Adjusted Max
2008-2009 N/A $168.500
2009-2010 1.16% $170.460
2010-2011 1.79% $173.513
2011-2012 1.70% $176.456
2012-2013 3.00% $181.749
2013-2014 2.45% $186.197
2014-2015 2.45% $190.753
2015-2016 2.53% $195.583
2016-2017 3.02% $201.483
2017-2018 3.44% $208.408
2018-2019 3.56% $215.837
2019-2020 3.53% $223.456
2020-2021 2.91% $229.949
2021-2022 1.57% $233.553
2022-2023 5.19% $245.683
*Rounded to 2 decimal points. Calculation is performed at 7 decimal points each year. 307
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

23 Zone 9 – Ruddy Creek Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Detention Pond Maintenance $0.00
Fencing 0.00
Drainage Pipes 0.00
Pump Station Electricity 0.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $0.00

INDIRECT COSTS
Maintenance Repairs & Contingency $0.00
City Personnel/Overhead 0.00
CBAD Administration Fee 0.00
Professional Fees 0.00
County Administration Fee – $0.30 per assessed parcel 0.00 Rounding Adjustment 0.00
Indirect Costs Sub-Total $0.00
SUB-TOTAL COSTS $0.00
Contingency Reserve – 20 % of Total Costs $0.00
TOTAL COSTS $0.00
7/1/2022 Beginning Fund Balance $0.00
2022-23 TOTAL ASSESSMENT $0.00
Total Number of Assessable Parcels 97
2022-23 ACTUAL ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $0.00
2022-23 MAXIMUM ASSESSMENT $119.00
2021-22 ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL N/A
308
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

24 Annual CPI Calculations for Zone 9 – Ruddy Creek are shown in the table below:

Fiscal Year CPI Increase Adjusted Max
2022-2023 N/A $119.000
*Rounded to 2 decimal points. Calculation is performed at 7 decimal points each year.

309
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

25 APPENDIX A – ASSESSMENT ROLL
Parcel Identification for each lot or parcel within each Zone of the District shall be based on available parcel maps and other property data from the Butte County Assessor’s office as they existed at the time this Report was prepared and adopted by the City Council.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23
26 ZONE 1 – LINKSIDE PLACE, PHASE 1
APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual Assessment
030-570-001 1 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-002 2 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-003 3 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-004 4 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-005 5 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-006 6 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-007 7 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-008 8 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-009 9 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-010 10 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-011 11 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-012 12 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-013 13 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-014 14 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-015 15 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-016 16 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-017 17 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-018 18 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-019 19 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-020 20 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-021 21 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-022 22 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-023 23 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-024 24 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-025 25 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-026 26 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-027 27 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-028 28 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-029 29 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-030 30 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-031 31 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-032 32 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
311
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23
27 APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual Assessment
030-570-033 33 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-034 34 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-035 35 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-036 36 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-037 37 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-038 38 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-039 39 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-040 40 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-041 41 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-042 42 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-043 43 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-044 44 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-045 45 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-046 46 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-047 47 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-048 48 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-049 49 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-050 50 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-051 51 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-052 52 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-053 53 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-054 54 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-055 55 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-056 56 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-057 57 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-058 58 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-059 59 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-060 60 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-061 61 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-062 62 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
312
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23
28 APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual Assessment
030-570-063 63 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-064 64 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-065 65 1.00 $407.39 $54.62
030-570-066 E 0.00 $407.39 $0.00
030-570-999 A, B, C & D 0.00 $407.39 $0.00
TOTALS: 65.00 $3,550.30

313
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23
29 ZONE 2 – FOOTHILL ESTATES
APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual Assessment
079-410-001 1 1.00 $473.88 $97.54
079-410-002 2 1.00 $473.88 $97.54
079-410-003 3 1.00 $473.88 $97.54
079-410-004 4 1.00 $473.88 $97.54
079-410-005 5 1.00 $473.88 $97.54
079-410-006 6 1.00 $473.88 $97.54
079-410-007 7 1.00 $473.88 $97.54
079-410-008 8 1.00 $473.88 $97.54
079-410-009 9 1.00 $473.88 $97.54
079-410-010 10 1.00 $473.88 $97.54
079-410-011 11 1.00 $473.88 $97.54
079-410-012 12 1.00 $473.88 $97.54
079-410-013 13 1.00 $473.88 $97.54
079-410-014 14 1.00 $473.88 $97.54
079-410-015 15 1.00 $473.88 $97.54
079-410-016 16 1.00 $473.88 $97.54
079-410-017 17 1.00 $473.88 $97.54
079-410-018 18 1.00 $473.88 $97.54
079-410-019 19 1.00 $473.88 $97.54
079-410-020 20 1.00 $473.88 $97.54
079-410-021 21 1.00 $473.88 $97.54
079-410-022 22 1.00 $473.88 $97.54
079-410-023 23 1.00 $473.88 $97.54
079-410-024 24 1.00 $473.88 $97.54
079-410-025 25 1.00 $473.88 $97.54
079-410-026 A 0.00 $473.88 $0.00
TOTALS: 25.00 $2,438.50

314
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23
30 ZONE 3 – MISSION OLIVE RANCH
APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual Assessment
033-490-006 1 1.00 $412.91 $136.84
033-490-007 2 1.00 $412.91 $136.84
033-490-008 3 1.00 $412.91 $136.84
033-490-009 4 1.00 $412.91 $136.84
033-490-010 5 1.00 $412.91 $136.84
033-490-011 6 1.00 $412.91 $136.84
033-490-012 7 1.00 $412.91 $136.84
033-490-013 8 1.00 $412.91 $136.84
033-490-014 9 1.00 $412.91 $136.84
033-490-015 10 1.00 $412.91 $136.84
033-490-016 11 1.00 $412.91 $136.84
033-490-017 12 1.00 $412.91 $136.84
033-490-018 13 1.00 $412.91 $136.84
033-490-019 14 1.00 $412.91 $136.84
033-490-020 15 1.00 $412.91 $136.84
033-490-021 16 1.00 $412.91 $136.84
033-490-022 17 1.00 $412.91 $136.84
033-490-023 18 1.00 $412.91 $136.84
033-490-024 19 1.00 $412.91 $136.84
TOTALS: 19.00 $2,599.96

315
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23
31 ZONE 4 – VISTA DEL ORO
APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual Assessment
030-580-001 92 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-002 91 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-003 90 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-004 89 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-005 88 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-006 87 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-007 86 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-008 85 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-009 80 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-010 81 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-011 82 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-012 83 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-013 84 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-014 74 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-015 75 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-016 76 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-017 77 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-018 78 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-019 79 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-020 68 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-021 69 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-022 70 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-023 71 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-024 72 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-025 73 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-026 61 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-027 62 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-028 63 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-029 64 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-030 65 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-031 66 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-032 67 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
316
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23
32 APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual Assessment
030-580-033 54 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-034 55 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-035 56 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-036 57 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-037 58 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-038 59 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-039 60 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-040 33 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-041 34 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-042 35 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-043 36 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-044 37 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-045 38 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-046 39 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-580-047 B 0.00 $332.57 $0.00
030-580-048 C 0.00 $332.57 $0.00
030-580-049 D 0.00 $332.57 $0.00
030-590-001 1 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-002 2 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-003 3 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-004 4 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-005 5 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-006 6 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-007 7 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-008 8 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-009 9 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-010 10 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-011 11 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-012 12 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-013 13 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-014 14 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-015 15 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-016 16 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
317
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23
33 APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual Assessment
030-590-017 17 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-018 18 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-019 19 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-020 20 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-021 21 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-022 22 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-023 23 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-024 24 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-025 25 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-026 26 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-027 27 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-028 28 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-029 29 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-030 30 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-031 31 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-032 32 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-033 33 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-034 34 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-035 35 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-036 36 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-037 37 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-038 38 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-039 39 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-040 40 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-041 41 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-042 42 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-043 43 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-044 44 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-045 45 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-046 46 1.00 $332.57 $48.68
030-590-047 A 0.00 $332.57 $0.00
030-590-048 E 0.00 $332.57 $0.00
TOTALS: 92.00 $4,478.56
318
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23
34 ZONE 5 – CALLE VISTA ESTATES, UNIT 2
APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual Assessment
030-490-074 1 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-075 2 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-076 3 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-077 4 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-078 5 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-079 6 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-080 7 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-081 8 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-082 9 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-083 10 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-084 11 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-085 12 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-086 13 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-087 14 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-088 15 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-089 16 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-090 17 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-091 18 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-092 19 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-093 20 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-094 21 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-095 22 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-096 23 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-097 24 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-098 25 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-099 26 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-100 27 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-101 28 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
319
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23
35 APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual Assessment
030-490-102 29 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-103 30 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-104 31 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-105 32 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-106 33 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-107 34 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-108 35 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-109 36 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-110 37 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-111 38 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-112 39 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-113 40 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-114 41 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-115 42 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-116 43 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
030-490-117 44 1.00 $246.08 $69.60
TOTALS: 44.00 $3,062.40

320
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23
36 ZONE 7 – JAKE RICHTER
APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual Assessment
031-086-013 A 0.00 $352.17 $0.00
031-086-014 1 1.00 $352.17 $168.04
031-086-015 2 1.00 $352.17 $168.04
031-086-016 3 1.00 $352.17 $168.04
031-086-017 4 1.00 $352.17 $168.04
031-086-018 5 1.00 $352.17 $168.04
031-086-019 6 1.00 $352.17 $168.04
031-086-020 7 1.00 $352.17 $168.04
031-086-021 8 1.00 $352.17 $168.04
TOTALS: 8.00 $1,344.32

321
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23
37 ZONE 8 – ACACIA ESTATES
APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual Assessment
033-360-067 & 068 1 1.00 $245.68 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 2 1.00 $245.68 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 3 1.00 $245.68 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 4 1.00 $245.68 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 5 1.00 $245.68 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 6 1.00 $245.68 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 7 1.00 $245.68 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 8 1.00 $245.68 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 9 1.00 $245.68 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 10 1.00 $245.68 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 11 1.00 $245.68 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 12 1.00 $245.68 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 13 1.00 $245.68 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 14 1.00 $245.68 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 15 1.00 $245.68 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 16 1.00 $245.68 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 17 1.00 $245.68 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 18 1.00 $245.68 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 19 1.00 $245.68 $0.00
033-360-067 & 068 20 1.00 $245.68 $0.00
TOTALS: 20.00 $0.00

322
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23
38 ZONE 9 – RUDDY CREEK
APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual Assessment
030-360-091 & 092 1 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 2 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 3 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 4 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 5 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 6 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 7 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 8 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 9 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 10 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 11 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 12 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 13 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 14 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 15 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 16 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 17 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 18 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 19 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 20 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 21 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 22 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 23 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 24 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 25 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 26 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 27 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 28 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 29 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 30 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 31 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 32 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
323
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23
39 APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual Assessment
030-360-091 & 092 33 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 34 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 35 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 36 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 37 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 38 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 39 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 40 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 41 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 42 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 43 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 44 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 45 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 46 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 47 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 48 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 49 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 50 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 51 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 52 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 53 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 54 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 55 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 56 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 57 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 58 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 59 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 60 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 61 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 62 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 63 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 64 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 65 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
324
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23
40 APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual Assessment
030-360-091 & 092 66 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 67 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 68 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 69 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 70 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 71 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 72 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 73 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 74 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 75 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 76 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 77 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 78 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 79 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 80 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 81 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 82 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 83 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 84 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 85 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 86 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 87 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 88 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 89 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 90 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 91 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 92 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 93 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 94 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 95 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 96 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 97 1.00 $119.00 $0.00
030-360-091 & 092 98 0.00 $119.00 $0.00
325
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23
41 APN
Unit/Lot
Number
Assessable
Units
2022-23
Maximum
Assessment Rate
2022-23
Actual Assessment
TOTALS: 97.00 $0.00

326
Item 14.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23
42 APPENDIX B – ASSESSMENT DIAGRAM
The following pages show the Assessment Diagram or boundary map for each Zone within the District.

The lines and dimensions shown on maps of the Butte County Assessor for the current year are incorporated by reference herein and made part of this Report. 327
Item 14.

Page 1 ends

CITY OF OROVILLE

SUMMARY
The Council will hold a public hearing approving the Annual Assessment Report and declaring its intention to levy and collect assessments for the Oroville Consolidated Benefit Assessment District for Fiscal Year 2022/23

ZONE NUMBER AND NAME
Zone 2 – Foothill Estates
Zone 3 – Mission Olive Ranch
Zone 6 – Martin Ranch
Zone 7 – Jake Richter Estates
Zone 8 – Acacia Estates
Pursuant to the Benefit Assessment Act of 1982, which authorizes the formation and annual administration of such districts, an Annual Assessment Report was prepared and filed with the City Clerk prior to tonight’s meeting. The purpose of the report is to document the annual costs involved in the operation, maintenance and servicing of all improvements, adjust the annual assessments, to incorporate any surplus or deficit from the previous year and to determine the actual annual assessment for each assessable parcel within the CBAD. 328
Item 15.

Page 2 ends

The City Council will consider the following items for all nine Zones within the CBAD:

1. Preliminarily approve the Annual Assessment Report and the proposed levy and collection of assessments for the CBAD for Fiscal Year 2022/23.

2. Direct Staff to make any changes or amendments to the Annual Assessment Report as necessary.

RECOMMENDATION
Adopt Resolution No. 9089 - A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL AUTHORIZING AND

DIRECTING THE MAYOR TO APPROVE THE ANNUAL ASSESSMENT REPORT, AS

SUBMITTED OR AMENDED, AND TO ORDER THE LEVY AND COLLECTION OF

ASSESSMENTS FOR THE OROVILLE CONSOLIDATED BENEFIT ASSESSMENT DISTRICT FOR FISCAL YEAR 2022/23; and
Authorize any necessary budget adjustments to the Annual Assessment Report.

ATTACHMENTS
Resolution No. 9089
2022/23 Assessment Summary from the CBAD Annual Assessment Report.

Page 1 of 3 ends

CITY OF OROVILLE
RESOLUTION NO. 9089

A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL AUTHORIZING AND DIRECTING THE

MAYOR TO APPROVE THE ANNUAL ASSESSMENT REPORT, AS SUBMITTED OR

AMENDED, AND TO ORDER THE LEVY AND COLLECTION OF ASSESSMENTS FOR

ZONE NUMBER AND NAME
Zone 2 – Foothill Estates
Zone 3 – Mission Olive Ranch
Zone 6 – Martin Ranch
Zone 7 – Jake Richter Estates
Zone 8 – Acacia Estates
WHEREAS, the engineer selected by the City Council has prepared and filed with the City Clerk, the Report in connection with the proposed levy and collection of assessments upon eligible parcels of land within each Zone. The Report has been prepared based on the estimated costs to operate, maintain and service the improvements located within particular Zones of the District; and, WHEREAS, the City Council has carefully examined and reviewed the Report and is satisfied with each of the items and documents as presented therein, and finds that the assessments have been spread to the eligible parcels within each Zone in accordance with the special benefit received from said improvements; and, WHEREAS, the assessments are not based on the assessed value of the properties within the Zones but are based on the special benefit conferred upon said eligible parcels from the improvements, and the maintenance and operation thereof; and, WHEREAS, the assessments are in compliance with all laws pertaining to the levy and collection of assessments, including Proposition 218; and, NOW, THEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY RESOLVED AS FOLLOWS:
330
Item 15.

Page 2 of 3 ends

2. Based upon its review (and any applicable amendments) of the Report, a copy of which has been filed with the City Clerk, the City Council hereby finds and determines that:
a. The assessable properties within the Zones will receive special benefit from the operation, maintenance and servicing of the drainage improvements. b. The Zones include all properties receiving such special benefit. c. The net amount to be assessed upon the properties is based on the historical and estimated costs to provide said maintenance and servicing and is apportioned by a formula that fairly distributes the net amount among all assessable parcels in proportion to the estimated special benefit received from the improvements and services.

3. The Report and assessments, as presented and which are on file with the office of the City Clerk, are hereby confirmed as filed.

4. The City Council hereby orders the maintenance and servicing of the improvements to be made in accordance with the Report and the 1982 Act.

6. The City Treasurer shall deposit all money representing assessments collected by the County to the credit of a fund especially for the District. Such money shall be expended only for the maintenance, operations and servicing of the improvements located within the District boundaries.

7. The adoption of this Resolution constitutes the levy of assessments within the Zones for the fiscal year beginning July 1, 2022 and ending June 30, 2023.

8. The City Clerk is hereby authorized and directed to file the levy with the County Auditor upon adoption of this Resolution.

9. A certified copy of this Resolution shall be filed in the office of the City Clerk and shall remain open for public inspection.

PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Oroville City Council at a regular meeting held on August 2, 2022, by the following vote:
331
Item 15.

Page 3 of 3 ends

AYES:

NOES:

ABSTAIN:

ABSTENT:

Chuck Reynolds, Mayor
APPROVED AS TO FORM: ATTEST:

Scott Huber, City Attorney Jackie Glover, Assistant City Clerk 332
Item 15.

CITY OF OROVILLE
FINAL ENGINEER’S REPORT

CONSOLIDATED BENEFIT ASSESSMENT DISTRICT
FISCAL YEAR 2022-23
July 2022

PREPARED BY
Harris & Associates
1401 Willow Pass Road, Suite 500
Concord, CA 94520
www.weareharris.com
334
Item 15.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23
i

STATEMENT OF ASSESSMENT ENGINEER
AGENCY: THE CITY OF OROVILLE
PROJECT: CONSOLIDATED BENEFIT ASSESSMENT DISTRICT
TO: THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE

CITY OF OROVILLE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA
ENGINEER’S REPORT FOR FISCAL YEAR 2022-23
The preparation of this Annual Engineer’s Report (“Report”) is in conformance with the obligation of the City Council for the annual levy of assessments within the Consolidated Benefit Assessment District of the City of Oroville to provide services upon each lot or parcel of land in the district in proportion to the estimated benefit to be received by each such lot or parcel of land for Fiscal Year 2022-23.

PART IV
Estimate of Cost: This part contains the cost estimate of the proposed maintenance including incidental costs and expenses for Fiscal Year 2022-23.

DATED this 28th day of July, 2022

Tamorah Bryant, P.E., Assessment Engineer
R.C.E. No. C67205
Engineer of Work
337
Item 15.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

1 PART I – OVERVIEW
The District is comprised of the nine (9) residential developments designated as Zones within the District.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

Each Zone was formed and annexed into the District as a condition of development. The Zones are located throughout the City of Oroville.

Reference is made to the plans and specifications for the improvements which are on file with the City and are incorporated herein by reference.

340
Item 15.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

Assessment Range Formula
It is generally recognized that most budgetary items will be impacted by inflation in future years. In accordance with the California Constitution, Section 53739 (b)(1), assessments “may be adjusted for inflation pursuant to a clearly defined formula…” A formula for an inflationary adjustment is therefore included as part of the maximum assessment for each Zone within this District and was approved by the property owner(s) at the time of formation. The formula, as described below, allows for annual adjustments to the budget and the assessments.

Generally, any new or increased assessment requires certain noticing and meeting requirements by law.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

344
Item 15.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

8 Zone 1 – Linkside Place, Phase 1 Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Detention Pond Maintenance $1,000.00
Fencing 250.00
Pump Station Electricity 886.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $2,136.00

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

9 Annual CPI Calculations for Zone 1 – Linkside Place, Phase 1 are shown in the table below:

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

10 Zone 2 – Foothill Estates Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Detention Pond Maintenance $450.00
Fencing 500.00
Drainage Pipes 0.00
Pump Station Electricity 275.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $1,225.00

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

11 Annual CPI Calculations for Zone 2 – Foothill Estates are shown in the table below:

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

12 Zone 3 – Mission Olive Ranch Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Detention Pond Maintenance $500.00
Fencing 500.00
Pump Station Electricity 140.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $1,140.00

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

13 Annual CPI Calculations for Zone 3 – Mission Olive Ranch are shown in the table below:

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

14 Zone 4 – Vista Del Oro Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Detention Pond Maintenance $500.00
Fencing 500.00
Drainage Pipes 0.00
Pump Station Electricity 702.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $1,702.00

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

15 Annual CPI Calculations for Zone 4 – Vista Del Oro are shown in the table below:

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

16 Zone 5 – Calle Vista Estates, Unit 2 Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Detention Basin Maintenance $500.00
Fencing 500.00
Drainage Pipes 0.00
Pump Station Electricity 349.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $1,349.00

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

17 Annual CPI Calculations for Zone 5 – Calle Vista Estates, Unit 2 are shown in the table below:

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

355
Item 15.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

19 Zone 7 – Jake Richter Estates Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Detention Basin Maintenance $250.00
Fencing 250.00
Drainage Pipes 0.00
Pump Station Electricity 0.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $500.00

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

20 Annual CPI Calculations for Zone 7 – Jake Richter Estates are shown in the table below:

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

21 Zone 8 – Acacia Estates Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Detention Pond Maintenance $0.00
Fencing 0.00
Drainage Pipes 0.00
Pump Station Electricity 0.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $0.00

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

22 Annual CPI Calculations for Zone 8 – Acacia Estates are shown in the table below:

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

23 Zone 9 – Ruddy Creek Budget

DIRECT COSTS
Detention Pond Maintenance $0.00
Fencing 0.00
Drainage Pipes 0.00
Pump Station Electricity 0.00
Direct Costs Sub-Total $0.00

INDIRECT COSTS
Maintenance Repairs & Contingency $0.00
City Personnel/Overhead 0.00
CBAD Administration Fee 0.00
Professional Fees 0.00
County Administration Fee – $0.30 per assessed parcel 0.00 Rounding Adjustment 0.00
Indirect Costs Sub-Total $0.00
SUB-TOTAL COSTS $0.00
Contingency Reserve – 20 % of Total Costs $0.00
TOTAL COSTS $0.00
7/1/2022 Beginning Fund Balance $0.00
2022-23 TOTAL ASSESSMENT $0.00
Total Number of Assessable Parcels 97
2022-23 ACTUAL ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL $0.00
2022-23 MAXIMUM ASSESSMENT $119.00
2021-22 ASSESSMENT PER PARCEL N/A
360
Item 15.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

24 Annual CPI Calculations for Zone 9 – Ruddy Creek are shown in the table below:

Fiscal Year CPI Increase Adjusted Max
2022-2023 N/A $119.000
*Rounded to 2 decimal points. Calculation is performed at 7 decimal points each year.

361
Item 15.

Engineer’s Report
Consolidated Benefit Assessment District
City of Oroville
Fiscal Year 2022-23

365
Item 15.

366
Item 15.

367
Item 15.

372
Item 15.

373
Item 15.

374
Item 15.

378
Item 15.

The lines and dimensions shown on maps of the Butte County Assessor for the current year are incorporated by reference herein and made part of this Report. 379
Item 15.

OROVILLE CITY COUNCIL

STAFF REPORT
TO: MAYOR AND COUNCIL MEMBERS
FROM: RUTH WRIGHT, DIRECTOR OF FINANCE
RE: ANNUAL SPECIAL TAX FOR THE CITY’S COMMUNITY FACILITIES DISTRICT NO. 2006-1 (WESTSIDE PUBLIC SAFETY FACILITIES) AND DISTRICT NO. 2006-2 (PUBLIC SAFETY SERVICES) FOR FISCAL YEAR 2021/22 DATE: AUGUST 2, 2022

SUMMARY
The City Council will consider the annual special tax relating to the City’s Community Facilities Districts (“CFD’s”).

DISCUSSION
In October 2006, the City completed the formation of two CFD’s designed to establish a special tax for subdivision projects in the Thermalito area. CFD No. 2006-1 was formed to fund the design and construction of a fire and police facility to be located at the Oroville Airport. CFD No. 2006-2 was formed to provide ongoing funding to maintain and staff these facilities in perpetuity. Both CFD’s are funded through the collection of a special tax attached to the property tax bill issued by the Butte County Tax Collector’s Office. Currently, four subdivisions are included in these CFD’s.

The rate and method of apportionment provides for the collection of certain tax amounts for both final mapped property without building permits issued (final mapped property) and final mapped property that have had a building permit issued (developed property).

Per Senate Bill 165, an annual Report for each CFD must be filed with the City Council. The annual report shall contain all of the following:
 The amount of funds collected and expended.
 The status of any project required or authorized to be funded as identified in subdivision (a) of Section 50075.1 or Section 53410.

The attached Reports fulfill these minimum requirements. No other action is required by the City Council.
380
Item 16.

The City Council will consider the following items for the CFD’s that will:

1. Establish the annual special tax for Fiscal Year 2022/23 for the two CFD’s.

2. Direct the Butte County Auditor-Controller’s Office to attach the special tax to the property tax bill of those final mapped and developed parcels within the two CFD’s.

FISCAL IMPACT
Funds are collected on the Butte County tax roll and placed into a “Special Fund” account for specified expenses within the two CFD’s.

RECOMMENDATION(S)

1. Adopt Resolution No. 9090 - A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL ESTABLISHING THE ANNUAL SPECIAL TAX FOR COMMUNITY FACILITIES DISTRICT NO. 2006-1, WESTSIDE PUBLIC SAFETY FACILITIES, FOR FISCAL YEAR 2022/23

2. Adopt Resolution No. 9091 - A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL ESTABLISHING THE ANNUAL SPECIAL TAX FOR COMMUNITY FACILITIES DISTRICT NO. 2006-2, PUBLIC SAFETY SERVICES, FOR FISCAL YEAR 2022/23

ATTACHMENT(S)
Resolution No. 9090
Resolution No. 9091
CFD 2006-1 Annual Report
CFD 2006-2 Annual Report
381
Item 16.

Page 1 of 3 ends

CITY OF OROVILLE
RESOLUTION NO. 9090

A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL ESTABLISHING THE ANNUAL SPECIAL TAX FOR COMMUNITY FACILITIES DISTRICT NO. 2006-1, WESTSIDE PUBLIC SAFETY FACILITIES, FOR FISCAL YEAR 2022/23
WHEREAS, the Oroville City Council (hereafter referred to as the “legislative body”), has initiated proceedings, held a public hearing, conducted an election and received a favorable vote from the qualified electors relating to the levy of a special tax in a special tax district, all as authorized pursuant to the terms and provisions of the “Mello Roos Community Facilities Act of 1982”, being Chapter 2.5, Part 1, Division 2, Title 5 of the California Government Code. Said special tax district is known and designated as Community Facilities District No. 2006-1, Westside Public Safety Facilities (hereafter referred to as “CFD No. 2006-1”) and,
WHEREAS, the legislative body, by ordinance and as authorized by Section 53340 of the California Government Code, has authorized the levy of a special tax to pay the costs and expenses related to CFD No. 2006-1 and this legislative body desires to establish the specific special tax rate to be collected for the upcoming fiscal year.

NOW, THEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY RESOLVED BY THE LEGISLATIVE BODY AS FOLLOWS:

Section 1 That the above recitals are true and correct.

Section 2 The specific special tax rate to be collected for CFD No. 2006-1 for the upcoming fiscal year (2022/23) is hereby determined and established in the table below.

A listing of individual parcels, showing the corresponding special tax rate, is attached hereto as “Exhibit A”.

TYPE RATE
Developed Property $600.00 per Developed Property
Final Mapped Property $300.00 per Final Mapped Property Section 3 That the special tax rate as set forth above does not exceed the amount as previously authorized by ordinance of this legislative body and is not in excess of that as previously approved by the qualified electors of CFD No. 2006-1, and is in compliance with Proposition 218, Section XIII D of the Constitution of the State of California.

Section 4 That the proceeds of the special tax shall be used to pay, in whole or in part, the costs of the following:
382
Item 16.

Page 2 of 3 ends

A. Preliminary and Incidental Expense and Appurtenant Work and Improvements – the authorized facilities shall be deemed to include the costs and expenses of mobilization, clearing, grubbing, protective fencing and erosion control, excavation, dewatering, lime treatment, drainage ditches, rock outfalls, curb, gutter and sidewalks, base and finishing pavement, striping, traffic signals, street lights, landscaping, irrigation, soundwalls, retaining walls, barricades and related appurtenant work and facilities, together with the costs and expenses of engineering design, environmental analysis, utility relocation, permits for work in jurisdictional waters, right-of-way acquisition, plan review, project management, construction related surety bonds or like security instruments, construction staking and management, inspection and any like fees and costs incidental to such acquisition, construction and installation.

B. Fire station and related firefighting and suppression equipment, furniture and furnishings.

C. Police substation and related furniture, furnishings and equipment.

The proceeds of the special tax shall be used as set forth above and shall not be used for any other purpose.

Section 5 The special tax shall be collected in the same manner as ordinary ad valorem property taxes are collected and shall be subject to the same penalties and same procedure and sale in cases of delinquency for ad valorem taxes, and the Tax Collector is hereby authorized to deduct reasonable administrative costs incurred in collecting said special taxes.

Section 6 All monies collected shall be paid into a fund for CFD No. 2006-1, including any reserve fund amounts.

Section 7 The County Auditor is hereby directed to enter in the next County assessment roll on which taxes will become due, opposite each lot or parcel of land effected in a space marked “public services” or “special tax” or by any other suitable designation, the installment of the special tax and the exact rate of the special tax as stated above.

Section 8 The County Auditor shall then, at the close of the tax collection period, promptly render to the City of Oroville, a detailed report showing the amount(s) of such special tax installments, interest, penalties and percentages so collected and from what property collected, and also provide a statement of any percentages retained for the expense of making such collection.
383
Item 16.

Page 3 of 3 ends

PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Oroville City Council at a regular meeting held on August 2, 2022, by the following vote:

AYES:

NOES:

ABSTAIN:

ABSTENT:

Chuck Reynolds, Mayor
APPROVED AS TO FORM: ATTEST:

Scott Huber, City Attorney Jackie Glover, Assistant City Clerk 384
Item 16.

ANNUAL REPORT FOR COMMUNITY FACILITIES DISTRICT 2006-1

WESTSIDE PUBLIC SAFTEY FACILITIES
Senate Bill 165, filed with the Secretary of State on September 19, 2000, enacted the Local Agency Special Tax and Bond Accountability Act (the “Act”). This Act requires that any local special tax/local bond measure subject to voter approval contain a statement indicating the specific purposes of the special tax, require that the proceeds of the special tax be applied to those purposes, require the creation of an account into which the proceeds shall be deposited and require an annual report containing specific information concerning the use of the proceeds. The Act only applies to any local special tax measure or local bond measure adopted on or after January 1, 2001, in accordance with Section 50075.1 of the California Government Code (the “Code”).

Some of the requirements of the Act are handled at the formation of the special tax district and others are handled through annual reports. This report intends to comply with Section 50075.3 or Section 53411 of the Code that states:
“The chief financial officer of the issuing local agency shall file a report with the governing body no later than January 1, 2002 and at least once a year thereafter”.

The annual report shall contain all of the following:
 The amount of funds collected and expended.
 The status of any project required or authorized to be funded as identified in subdivision (a) of Section 50075.1 or Section 53410.

The requirements of the Act apply to the Improvement Fund for Community Facilities District No. 2006-1 (the “CFD”). The appropriate information is displayed in the table below:

CFD 2006-1

WESTSIDE PUBLIC SAFETY FACILITIES

CONSTRUCTION OF FIRE AND POLICE FACILITY
Formation
Date
2021/22
Annual Levy
7/1/2022
Balance
Amount
Expended to
Date
Project Status
9/19/2006 $81,600.00 $853,560 $0.00
No activity due
to insufficient
revenue to
begin project
385
Item 16.

Page 1 of 3 ends

CITY OF OROVILLE
RESOLUTION NO. 9091

A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL ESTABLISHING THE ANNUAL SPECIAL TAX FOR COMMUNITY FACILITIES DISTRICT NO. 2006-2, PUBLIC SAFETY SERVICES, FOR FISCAL YEAR 2022/23
WHEREAS, the Oroville City Council (hereafter referred to as the “legislative body”), has initiated proceedings, held a public hearing, conducted an election and received a favorable vote from the qualified electors relating to the levy of a special tax in a special tax district, all as authorized pursuant to the terms and provisions of the “Mello Roos Community Facilities Act of 1982”, being Chapter 2.5, Part 1, Division 2, Title 5 of the California Government Code. Said special tax district is known and designated as Community Facilities District No. 2006-2, Public Safety Services (hereafter referred to as “CFD No. 2006-2”) and,
WHEREAS, the legislative body, by ordinance and as authorized by Section 53340 of the California Government Code, has authorized the levy of a special tax to pay the costs and expenses related to CFD No. 2006-2 and this legislative body desires to establish the specific special tax rate to be collected for the upcoming fiscal year.

NOW, THEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY RESOLVED BY THE LEGISLATIVE BODY AS FOLLOWS:

Section 1 That the above recitals are true and correct.

Section 2 The specific special tax rate to be collected for CFD No. 2006-2 for the upcoming fiscal year (2022/23) is hereby determined and established in the table below.

A listing of individual parcels, showing the corresponding special tax rate, is attached hereto as “Exhibit A”.

TYPE RATE
Developed Property $600.00 per Developed Property
Final Mapped Property $300.00 per Final Mapped Property Section 3 That the special tax rate as set forth above does not exceed the amount as previously authorized by ordinance of this legislative body and is not in excess of that as previously approved by the qualified electors of CFD No. 2006-2, and is in compliance with Proposition 218, Section XIII D of the Constitution of the State of California.

Section 4 That the proceeds of the special tax shall be used to pay, in whole or in part, the costs of the following:
386
Item 16.

Page 2 of 3 ends

A. Fire protection and suppression.

B. Police protection.

The proceeds of the special tax shall be used as set forth above and shall not be used for any other purpose.

Section 6 All monies collected shall be paid into a fund for CFD No. 2006-2, including any reserve fund amounts.

Page 3 of 3 ends

PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Oroville City Council at a regular meeting held on August 2, 2022, by the following vote:

AYES:

NOES:

ABSTAIN:

ABSTENT:

Chuck Reynolds, Mayor
APPROVED AS TO FORM: ATTEST:

Scott Huber, City Attorney Jackie Glover, Assistant City Clerk 388
Item 16.

ANNUAL REPORT FOR COMMUNITY FACILITIES DISTRICT 2006-2

PUBLIC SAFTEY SERVICES
Senate Bill 165, filed with the Secretary of State on September 19, 2000, enacted the Local Agency Special Tax and Bond Accountability Act (the “Act”). This Act requires that any local special tax/local bond measure subject to voter approval contain a statement indicating the specific purposes of the special tax, require that the proceeds of the special tax be applied to those purposes, require the creation of an account into which the proceeds shall be deposited and require an annual report containing specific information concerning the use of the proceeds. The Act only applies to any local special tax measure or local bond measure adopted on or after January 1, 2001, in accordance with Section 50075.1 of the California Government Code (the “Code”).

The requirements of the Act apply to the Improvement Fund for Community Facilities District No. 2006-2 (the “CFD”). The appropriate information is displayed in the table below:

CFD 2006-2

PUBLIC SAFETY SERVICES

STAFFING OF FIRE AND POLICE FACILITY
Formation
Date
2021/22
Annual Levy
7/1/2022
Balance
Amount
Expended to
Date
Project Status
9/19/2006 $81,600.00 $893,285 $0.00
No activity due
to insufficient
revenue to
begin project
389
Item 16.

OROVILLE CITY COUNCIL

STAFF REPORT
TO: MAYOR AND COUNCIL MEMBERS
FROM: RUTH DUNCAN, DIRECTOR OF FINANCE
DAWN NEVERS, ASST. COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR
RE: A RESOLUTION CERTIFYING TO THE COUNTY OF BUTTE THE VALIDITY OF

THE LEGAL PROCESS USED TO PLACE DIRECT CHARGES ON THE
SECURED TAX ROLL FOR FISCAL YEAR 2022/23
DATE: AUGUST 2, 2022

SUMMARY
The City Council will approve a resolution certifying to the County of Butte the validity of the legal process used to place direct charges on the secured tax toll for fiscal year 2022/23.

DISCUSSION
Proposition 218, passed by California voters on November 5, 1996, requires assessment charges to be approved by a majority vote of the affected property owners within an adopted assessment district.

The notices and hearing for special taxes and assessments to be included on the regular County property tax bill for property owners of the City of Oroville was completed on August 2, 2022. The City of Oroville (City) is placing the special taxes and assessments on the Butte County secured property tax roll for collection. The City has complied with all laws pertaining to the levy of the special taxes, including Proposition 218, to be collected per Streets and Highway Code section 22501, et seq; and the special taxes and assessments are being levied without regard to property valuation of the properties involved.

Prop 218 requires the City agree that it shall be solely liable and responsible, and will defend and hold the County of Butte harmless from any liability as a result of claims or claims for refunds and related interest due filed by taxpayers against any special taxes, assessment, fees or charges placed on the roll for the City by the County.

The Oroville City Council submitted lists with parcel numbers and amounts which are certified as being correct, the Council will authorize the Mayor to sign any documents required and directed to give the list to the Butte County Auditor on behalf of the City for placement on the secured tax roll for collection:

1. Prop 218 or Compliance Certification and Hold Harmless Statement

2. Property Tax Data Bill Form

3. Authority to Approve Direct Assessment Charges for LLMAD and CBAD for FY 2022/23

4. Parcel Listings
390
Item 17.

FISCAL IMPACT
Funds are collected on the Butte County tax roll and placed into a “Special Fund” account for specified expenses within the Landscape and Lighting Maintenance Assessment District (LLMAD) and Consolidated Benefit Assessment District (CBAD).

RECOMMENDATION(S)

1. Adopt Resolution No 9092 A RESOLUTION OF THE OROVILLE CITY COUNCIL

CERTIFYING TO THE COUNTY OF BUTTE THE VALIDITY OF THE LEGAL PROCESS

USED TO PLACE DIRECT CHARGES ON THE SECURED TAX ROLL AND AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR TO EXECUTE THE PROPOSITION 218 CERTIFICATION

OF TAX BILL LEVY

2. Authorize the Mayor to sign the Proposition 218 Certificates for inclusion on the 2022/23 Butte County Tax Roll.

ATTACHMENT(S)
Resolution No. 9092
Proposition 218 Certification of Special Tax Levy
391
Item 17.
1 2
3 4
5 6
7 8
9 10
11 12
13 14
15 16
17 18
19 20
21 22
23 24
25 26
27 28
29 CITY OF OROVILLE
RESOLUTION NO. 9092

A RESOLUTION OF THE OROVILLE CITY COUNCIL CERTIFYING TO THE COUNTY

OF BUTTE THE VALIDITY OF THE LEGAL PROCESS USED TO PLACE DIRECT

CHARGES ON THE SECURED TAX ROLL AND AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR TO EXECUTE THE PROPOSITION 218 CERTIFICATION OF TAX BILL LEVY WHEREAS, the notices and hearing for special taxes and assessments to be included on the regular County property tax bill for property owners of the City of Oroville was completed on August 2, 2022; and
WHEREAS, the City of Oroville (City) is placing the special taxes and assessments on the Butte County secured property tax roll for collection; and WHEREAS, the City has complied with all laws pertaining to the levy of the special taxes, including Proposition 218, to be collected per Streets and Highway Code section 22501, et seq; and
WHEREAS, the special taxes and assessments are being levied without regard to property valuation of the properties involved; and
WHEREAS, the City agrees that it shall be solely liable and responsible, and will defend and hold the County of Butte harmless from any liability as a result of claims or claims for refunds and related interest due filed by taxpayers against any special taxes, assessment, fees or charges placed on the roll for the City by the County; and NOW THERFORE BE IT RESOLVED by the Oroville City Council that the list submitted with parcel numbers and amounts are certified as being correct, the Mayor is hereby authorized to sign any documents required and directed to give the list to the Butte County Auditor on behalf of the City for placement on the secured tax roll for collection:

1. Prop 218 or Compliance Certification and Hold Harmless Statement

2. Property Tax Data Bill Form

3. Authority to Approve Direct Assessment Charges

4. Parcel Listing
PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Oroville City Council at a regular meeting held on 392
Item 17.
1 2
3 4
5 6
7 8
9 10
11 12
13 14
15 16
17 18
19 20
21 22
23 24
25 26
27 28
29 August 2, 2022, by the following vote:

AYES:

NOES:

ABSTAIN:

ABSENT:

Chuck Reynolds, Mayor
APPROVED AS TO FORM: ATTEST:

Scott Huber, City Attorney Jackie Glover, Assistant City Clerk 393
Item 17.

FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION
Office of Energy Projects
Division of Dam Safety and Inspections - San Francisco Regional Office 100 First Street, Suite 2300
San Francisco, CA 94105-3084
(415) 369-3300 Office - (415) 369-3322 Facsimile
July 14,2022
In reply refer to:

Project No. 2100-CA
Mr. Jeremiah McNeil, Acting Manager
Hydropower License Planning and Compliance Office
California Department of Water Resources
P.O. Box 942836
Sacramento, California 94236-0001
Re: Oroville Dam - Probable Maximum Flood Study — Responses to Comments Dear Mr. McNeil:

This is in response to your letter dated March 22, 2021, that submitted responses, including a technical memorandum, to the Commission's previous comments on the Probable Maximum Flood (PMF) study for Oroville Dam, part of the Feather River Project, FERC No. 2100. We have completed our review of the submittal and have the following comments:

1. Comment No. 4: Regarding the capacity of the emergency spillway, the previously-accepted plan and schedule for resolving this comment was tied to the Comprehensive Needs Assessment (CNA), which was submitted to FERC by letter dated August 28,2020. We note that the CNA did not definitively resolve this topic nor did it provide a firm schedule going forward. Although the response in the subject letter provided some insight into this comment, the letter provided insufficient documentation of the emergency spillway's ability to safely convey the PMF. The risk informed decision-making processes, to-date, have not been at a sufficient level of detail for issue-specific decision making. Additionally, the concept of 'flow of unlimited duration' was not substantiated by a reference to a past study or report. The letter notes that no emergency spillway-focused studies were identified by the 10^ Part 12D Independent Consultants. TTiis is because, at DWR's request, the consultants were not required to assess that structure as it was under construction at the time of the Part 12D inspection. 394
Item i.

N
Although the spillways recovery project significantly improved the emergency spillway, DWR's proposal for risk reduction measures to 'be considered for future implementation', or studied 'after completion of the studies and investigations identified by the CNA' is not acceptable. It is imperative that DWR develop and submit a detailed plan and schedule for determining the safe capacity of the emergency spillway and the spillway adequacy of Oroville Dam. We are available to meet to discuss this topic.

2. Comment No. 5: Your response regarding the wind wave analysis is acceptable.

3. Comment No. 6: While we continue to hold to our previous comment regarding the classification of the emergency spillway, we have no objection to DWR continuing to use the current name for continuity, as proposed.

Within 60 days from the date of this letter, submit a plan and schedule for addressing the comments. File your submittal using the Commission's ePiling system at https://www.ferc.gov/ferc-online/overview. For all Dam Safety and Public Safety Documents, select Hydro: Regional Office and San Francisco Regional Office from the eFiling menu. The cover page of the filing must indicate that the material was eFiled.

For assistance with eFiling, contact FERC Online Support at [email protected]> (866) 208-3676 (toll free), or (202) 502-8659 (TTY).

We appreciate your cooperation in this aspect of the Commission's dam safety program. If you have any questions, please contact Mr. Wes Cooley at (415) 369-3340.

Sincerely,
Frank L. Blackett, P.E.

Regional Engineer
cc:

Ms. Sharon Tapia, Division Manager
Division of Safety of Dams
California Department of Water Resources
P.O. Box 942836
Sacramento, CA 94236-0001
395
Item i.

Project No. 2100-CA
Ms. Gwen Knittweis, Chief
Hydropower License Planning and Compliance Office
California Department of Water Resources
P.O. Box 942836
Sacramento, California 94236-0001
Re: Core Block Piezometers Drill Program Plan Supplement - Oroville Dam Dear Ms. Knittweis:

This is in response to a letter dated May 17,2022, from Mr. Jeremiah McNeil that submitted a Drilling Program Plan (DPP) supplement with additional resumes for seven (7) geologists for the core block piezometer installation at Oroville Dam, part of the Feather River Project, FERC No. 2100. We have reviewed the submittal and we have the following comments listed in the Enclosure.

Within 60 days of the date of this letter, please address our comments or provide a plan and schedule to address our comments. File your submittal using the Connnission's eFiling system at https://www.ferc.gov/ferc-online/overview. For all Dam Safety and Public Safety Documents, select Hydro: Regional Office and San Francisco Regional Office from the eFiling menu. The cover page of the filing must indicate that the material was eFiled. For assistance with eFiling, contact FERC Online Support at [email protected], (866) 208-3676 (toll free), or (202) 502-8659 (TTY). 396
Item i.

We appreciate your continued efforts in this aspect of the Commission's dam safety program. If you have any questions, please contact Mr. Chris Wang at (415) 369-3366.

Sincerely,
Frank L. Blackett, P.E.

Regional Engineer
Enclosure
cc:

Ms. Sharon Tapia, Division Manager
CA Dept. of Water Resources
Division of Safety of Dams
P.O. Box 942836
Sacramento, CA 94236-0001
397
Item i.

Enclosure: DPP Supplement Comments
Core Block Piezometers Drill Program Plan Supplement - Oroville Dam

1. Mr. Matthew Zimmeran and Mr. Mark Pagenkopp are accepted as field geologists for the execution of this DPP.

2. To avoid possible confusion resulting fi:om the various resumes submitted and the time lapsed since the original DPP, provide a personnel roster of the FBRCaccepted drillers and geologists participating in the drilling activities after the predrilling workshop, if conducted (See FERC April 30,2021 letter), or at least 2 weeks prior to the start of drilling. Please file the roster using the more stringent timeframe.

3. Provide additional drilling-specific experience at or near dams for Mr. Joseph Mason, Ms. Alodie Bubeck, Ms. Elizabeth White, Mr. Mark Szymaski, and Ms.

Leah Feigelson. Revise their resumes to include additional projects that clearly detail their experience, or clarify their roles that indicate this experience for the listed projects, as appropriate. The focus of these details should be on similar drilling conditions/methods to the scope of this DPP. Due to the large number of potential field geologist candidates for a limited number of holes, please discuss how they will be incorporated into the drilling schedule, if foimd to be acceptable.

4. The resumes of Mark Pagenkopp and Leah Feiglson indicate they were both the Project Manager of work on the Castiac Dam Spillway Exploration at the same dates. Please clarify the apparent discrepancy of both geologists serving the same role at the same time.

5. Revise the DPP to replace Mr. John Onderdonk's contact, who has since retired, with Mr. Wes Cooley's contact at (408) 480-5024.

6. An updated start date (month and year) was provided in the letter. Please provide a schedule (specific date) by which the DPP activities will be completed. 1 ofl
398
Item i.

Pioneer Union Elementary School District
Berry Creek Elementary School Bangor Hwy.

Bangor, California 95914
Telephone: (530)589-1633
Facsimile: (530)589-5021
Re: Thirty-Day Notice of Proposal to Implement Developer Fees To Whom It May Concem:

A public hearing will be held by the Governing Board of the Pioneer Union Elementary School District at its regular meeting of Wednesday, August 10, 2022, in which the Board will consider a resolution implementing school facilities fees in accordance with Education Code Section 17620. The meeting will be held at 5:00 p.m. in the Library of the District Offices, located at 7549 Oro Bangor Hwy, Bangor, Califomia.

Further information on the costs of school services and facilities and on other available revenue, including the general fund, will be available at the District office and on our District website at www.puesd.org as of July 13, 2022.

If you have any questions regarding the above, please feel free to contact me.

Nicole Cardwell
Executive Assistant

CITY OF OROVILLE
JUL 2 7 2022
CITY CLERK DEPT.
399
Item ii.

CiiA CreHK DEbi'
'H- \
CIIA Ob ObOAHTE
^ ■ .. V
400
Item ii.

Oroville City CouncilAugust 2, 2022

Oroville City Council
August 2, 2022