Palm Springs City Council
May 19, 2026

HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION
Subcommittee Interview Schedule

CURRENT MEMBER(S) W/EXPIRING TERM(S):

Member Appointment Date Term Expiration Status
Beverly Greer 05/25/2023 06/30/2026 Eligible; Reapplied Michael MJ Horne 05/25/2023 06/30/2026 Eligible; Reapplied Carlotta Rinke 05/25/2023 06/30/2026 Eligible; Reapplied Bobby T. Rimas 09/26/2023 06/30/2026 Eligible; Reapplied Donald Soja 02/27/2025 06/30/2026 Eligible; Reapplied

VACANCIES TO BE FILLED:

New Term Expiration Recommendation(s):
06/30/2029
06/30/2029
06/30/2029
06/30/2029
06/30/2029
06/30/2029

APPLICANTS:

Applicant District Notes
Beverly Greer 4 Incumbent
David ‘Jax’ Kelly 4
Monzerrath Ortiz 1
Frank Cimaglia 3
Michael Horne 5 Incumbent
Sara Lilly 1
Erin Sammons 3
Michelle Anderberg 2
Rene Robles 5
Richard Babik 3
Mihai Patru 4
Donald Soja 1 Incumbent
Levi Knapp 5
Frank McAlpin 3
Daniel Borgstadt 3
Linda Futterer 5
George Nickle 3
Bobby Rimas 3 Incumbent
Carlotta Rinke 4 Incumbent

ALTERNATE CHOICE
Tad Iwan 2 *First choice is AAB
Rahul Jadhav Outside PS *First choice is AAB
Bashar Halabi 5 *First choice is Airport
Andrew Melissinos 4 *First choice is Measure J
Sara Lilly 1 *First choice is HRC
Charlie Roddy 2 *First choice is HSPB
Brian Daher 2 *First choice is Library
Andrew Johnson 2 *First choice is Library
Andrew Melissinos 4 *First choice is Measure J
David Anderson 2 *First choice is Measure J
ChadSebastian Wilder 1 *First choice is Measure J
Heidi Garza 2 *First choice is Parks and Recreation
Peter Brown 2 *First choice is Parks and Recreation
Vincent Devlin 1 *First choice is Parks and Recreation
Evan Gray 3 *First choice is Parks and Recreation
Paul DiLeo 1 *First choice is Public Arts
Michael Slocum 4 *First choice is Village Fest

HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION CURRENT ROSTER

Member Original Appointment Expires
Hugo Loyola* – 2 June 24, 2021 June 30, 2027
Beverly Greer – 5 May 25, 2023 June 30, 2026
Michael MJ Horne – 5 May 25, 2023 June 30, 2026
Carlotta Rinke – 4 May 25, 2023 June 30, 2026
Bobby T. Rimas – 3 Sept. 26, 2023 June 30, 2026
Scott Nevins – 1 Feb. 27, 2025 June 30, 2028
Donald Soja – 1 Feb. 27, 2025 June 30, 2026
Malakai Strong – 3 May 21, 2025 June 30, 2027
VACANT June 30, 2026

*Termed out – ineligible to reapply

BEVERLY GREER
(INCUMBENT)

CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
Commissions, Boards and Committees Application
Human Rights Commission
Date submitted: March 10, 2026
Profile
Please indicate whether you live, work, or go to school within Palm Springs:

Live ,Historic Site Preservation Board,Measure
First Name: Middle Initial: Last Name:

Beverly Greer
Email Address:
[email protected]
Street Address:
1332 South Camino Real
Suite or Apartment:

City: State: Postal Code:

Palm Springs CA 92264
Phone:
(760)699-3092
What other committees would you like to apply for if not selected to this committee? (List of all applicable open committees):

Interests & Experiences
Regarding the commission you are applying for, list dates of most recent meetings you have attended or watched

Have participated on HRC for my term and wish to continue Education
MBA, Phd – Gerontology
Background/Work Experience/Civic Involvement:

HRC commissioner,
CEO charitable organizations
Describe your knowledge of the functions, regulations and procedures of the commission you'd serve:

HAve participated for last term –
What issues or problems face the board/commission? Do you have any suggestions to address them?:

We have had a number of problems with HRC and are just finding our new and better mission

DAVID 'JAX' KELLY

CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
Commissions, Boards and Committees Application
Human Rights Commission
Date submitted: March 10, 2026
Profile
Please indicate whether you live, work, or go to school within Palm Springs:

Live ,Work
First Name: Middle Initial: Last Name:

David "Jax" Kelly
Email Address:

[email protected]
Street Address:
2858 Belleza Ct
Suite or Apartment:

City: State: Postal Code:

PALM SPRINGS CA 92264
Phone:
(323)314-3266
What other committees would you like to apply for if not selected to this committee? (List of all applicable open committees):

Interests & Experiences
Regarding the commission you are applying for, list dates of most recent meetings you have attended or watched

Watched March 9, 2026 meeting.

Education
Yale, BA, Economics & Political Science;
New York University, MBA, Finance;
University of Southern California, MPH, Health Services & Policy; Fordham U. School of Law, JD
In 2022, I received the Stonewall Volunteer of the Year Award from Palm Springs Pride and the Legacy Award from Brothers in the Desert.

Background/Work Experience/Civic Involvement:

I'm a resident of Palm Springs since 2014, and served a full 3-yr term as Treasurer of the Palm Springs Library Board of Trustees. I lead two nonprofits: Let’s Kick ASS Palm Springs, a group that celebrated its 10th anniversary serving people aging with HIV in the Coachella Valley, and HIV and Aging Institute, a policy organization bridging the gap between aging and HIV services. Since 2024, I have been serving on the Riverside County Advisory Council on Aging representing District 4.

Describe your knowledge of the functions, regulations and procedures of the commission you'd serve:

My experience serving on public advisory bodies has given me a strong understanding of how commissions function within local and state government. I currently serve on the Riverside County Advisory Council on Aging, which advises the County Office on Aging and the Board of Supervisors on issues affecting older adults. Through this role I participate in meetings conducted under the California Brown Act, including agenda review, public comment procedures, and the transparent deliberation of policy recommendations.

I have also served on the Palm Springs Library Board of Trustees, where I worked with fellow trustees and city staff to support the library’s mission and ensure that programs and services reflect the needs of the community. That experience further strengthened my understanding of the responsibilities of advisory bodies, including collaboration with staff, reviewing policy and program initiatives, and providing recommendations that inform decisions by elected officials.

In addition, I serve on the California Department of Aging’s Equity Advisory Committee on Aging and Disability, which advises the state on implementation of the California Master Plan for Aging. In that role I work with state officials and community leaders to identify equity gaps and provide recommendations to strengthen policies affecting older adults and people with disabilities across California.

My professional work also includes founding and leading the Aging and HIV Institute, where I focus on the intersection of aging, public health, and social services. This work regularly involves engaging with government agencies, analyzing policy proposals, submitting formal public comments, and advocating for equitable access to services for marginalized

communities.

Through these experiences I have developed a strong appreciation for the role commissions play in public governance. Effective commissions help elevate community concerns, ensure transparency in decision making, and advise local government on policies that advance fairness, dignity, and equal opportunity. If appointed to the Human Rights Commission, I would bring both my policy experience and my commitment to collaborative public service to support the Commission’s work on behalf of the Palm Springs community.

What issues or problems face the board/commission? Do you have any suggestions to address them?:

The Human Rights Commission is addressing several important issues that reflect both evolving community needs and the Commission’s role in advising the City Council on matters of equity, fairness, and inclusion. One of the most significant is the effort to update Chapter

2.45 of the Palm Springs Municipal Code. Modernizing language related to domestic partnerships and LGBTQ+ rights, and aligning the Commission’s work with the City Council’s 2045 Strategic Plan, are important steps to ensure that the Commission’s mandate reflects both current law and the lived realities of Palm Springs residents.

Another important issue involves strengthening the Community Service Awards program following past controversies. Establishing measurable criteria and transparent vetting procedures will help restore confidence in the program and ensure that it reflects the values of integrity and fairness that the Commission seeks to promote.

The Commission is also exploring ways to respond constructively to reports of discrimination and community tensions. Initiatives such as interfaith dialogue, documentary screenings, and other community conversations can help build understanding while reaffirming Palm Springs’ longstanding commitment to inclusion. Efforts to expand civic engagement through a student representative program and increased collaboration with other city boards and commissions are also promising ways to broaden participation and bring new perspectives into the Commission’s work.

Finally, the Commission is considering a broader engagement with human services issues such as housing equity, homelessness resources, and immigrant services. These areas recognize that human rights are often experienced through access to basic supports and opportunities that allow residents to live with dignity.

My background may be useful in several of these areas. Through my work as founder of the Aging and HIV Institute, I focus on the intersection of aging, public health, and equity in social service systems. Palm Springs has one of the largest populations of older adults in California, including many LGBTQ+ residents and people aging with HIV. My work often involves identifying gaps between public policy and lived experience and helping institutions respond

in ways that are thoughtful, evidence-informed, and community centered.

I also bring experience serving on public advisory bodies, including the Riverside County Advisory Council on Aging and previously the Palm Springs Library Board of Trustees. Both roles operate under the California Brown Act and involve agenda setting, public comment, and collaboration with staff and elected officials. These experiences have given me a strong appreciation for the responsibilities of public service and the importance of transparency and respectful deliberation.

Locally, my work with organizations and partners across the Coachella Valley has involved building relationships among community groups, healthcare providers, and public agencies to address issues affecting older adults and marginalized communities. Those collaborations have reinforced for me how important it is for public bodies to listen carefully to community voices while also helping translate those concerns into constructive policy discussions.

If appointed, I would hope to contribute by helping the Commission connect its human rights mission with the everyday experiences of Palm Springs residents. That might include strengthening engagement with community organizations, supporting thoughtful updates to policy language, and ensuring that the Commission continues to reflect the diversity and dignity of the people who call Palm Springs home.

MONZERRATH ORTIZ

CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
Commissions, Boards and Committees Application
Human Rights Commission
Date submitted: March 11, 2026
Profile
Please indicate whether you live, work, or go to school within Palm Springs:

Live ,Work ,Administrative Appeals Board,Human Rights Commission,Library Board of Trustees,Measure ,Parks & Recreation Commission,Planning Commission,Public Arts Commission,Sustainability Commission
First Name: Middle Initial: Last Name:

Monzerrath Ortiz
Email Address:
[email protected]
Street Address:
3721 E Calle De Carlos
Suite or Apartment:

City: State: Postal Code:

Palm Springs CA 92264
Phone:
(760)844-4223
What other committees would you like to apply for if not selected to this committee? (List of all applicable open committees):

Interests & Experiences

Regarding the commission you are applying for, list dates of most recent meetings you have attended or watched
I have not attended events before I wasn't aware of the dates or times being held.

Education
Master in Social work and Master in Public Administration Background/Work Experience/Civic Involvement:

Work experience in restaurant industry, timeshare, and mental health.

Describe your knowledge of the functions, regulations and procedures of the commission you'd serve:

Have no served in a commission before.

What issues or problems face the board/commission? Do you have any suggestions to address them?:

Unaware of problems or issues commission happening but would be interested in learning about our local commission/board.

FRANK CIMAGLIA

CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
Commissions, Boards and Committees Application
Human Rights Commission
Date submitted: March 12, 2026
Profile
Please indicate whether you live, work, or go to school within Palm Springs:

Live ,Parks & Recreation Commission,Planning Commission,Sustainability Commission First Name: Middle Initial: Last Name:

Frank Cimaglia
Email Address:
[email protected]
Street Address:
1475 N Palm Canyon
Suite or Apartment:

City: State: Postal Code:

Palm Springs CA 92262
Phone:
(760)229-7521
What other committees would you like to apply for if not selected to this committee? (List of all applicable open committees):

Interests & Experiences
Regarding the commission you are applying for, list dates of most recent meetings you have attended or watched

3/3/2026
Education
Hoffman Estates High School
Background/Work Experience/Civic Involvement:

Jewel Foods, Ralph’s Foods, Jensen’s Foods, Butera Market, Dominick's Finer Foods, Impact Printers
Describe your knowledge of the functions, regulations and procedures of the commission you'd serve:

Observations
What issues or problems face the board/commission? Do you have any suggestions to address them?:

Execution and enactment

MICHAEL HORNE
(INCUMBENT)

CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
Commissions, Boards and Committees Application
Human Rights Commission
Date submitted: March 12, 2026
Profile
Please indicate whether you live, work, or go to school within Palm Springs:

Work ,Public Arts Commission
First Name: Middle Initial: Last Name:

Michael Horne
Email Address:
[email protected]
Street Address:
38755 Vista Dr
Suite or Apartment:

City: State: Postal Code:

Cathedral City CA 92234
Phone:
(323)828-9656
What other committees would you like to apply for if not selected to this committee? (List of all applicable open committees):

Interests & Experiences
Regarding the commission you are applying for, list dates of most recent meetings you have attended or watched

March 8th,2026
Education
High School and mostle College
Background/Work Experience/Civic Involvement:

Served on 2 Commissions in the City of West Hollywood, Human Services Commission, 5 yrs Chair (2yrs).1989
Public Safety Commission, 4 yrs, Chair
(2yrs)1996
Describe your knowledge of the functions, regulations and procedures of the commission you'd serve:

As Commissioners we serve at the pleasure of the Palm Springs City Council. We Review and discuss issues pertaining to Human Rights in the City of Palm Springs, working with staff to address constituents issues and recommendations we might address to City Council. Arrange presentations to educate us (the Commission) on issues which may be important to the City and it’s residents.

What issues or problems face the board/commission? Do you have any suggestions to address them?:

Insure that all Human Rights are addressed in the City, Identify issues which may become relevant in the future, become more visible at City events and festivals, facilitate and guide Community Service Awards, invite guests to participate in our meetings.

SARA LILLY

CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
Commissions, Boards and Committees Application
Human Rights Commission
Date submitted: March 12, 2026
Profile
Please indicate whether you live, work, or go to school within Palm Springs:

Live ,Work ,Historic Site Preservation Board,Human Rights Commission,Parks & Recreation Commission
First Name: Middle Initial: Last Name:

Sara Lilly
Email Address:
[email protected]
Street Address:
385 N. Juanita Drive
Suite or Apartment:

City: State: Postal Code:

Palm Springs CA 92262
Phone:
(703)474-3166
What other committees would you like to apply for if not selected to this committee? (List of all applicable open committees):

Interests & Experiences

Regarding the commission you are applying for, list dates of most recent meetings you have attended or watched
I have not attended any Human Rights Commission meetings to date. It is my understanding that they are not open to the public.

Education
University of Maryland College Park / Bachelor of Arts in Journalism / Graduated 05/1999 Background/Work Experience/Civic Involvement:

I have 20 years of civil service experience in the federal government, working specifically for civil rights and internal affairs office with authority to assess matters involving human rights violations. During the 20 years, I held various senior-level positions at the GS-14 and 15 levels, both supervisory and non-supervisory. Further, I chaired numerous internal and external agency working group meetings charged with drafting, reviewing, analyzing, interpreting, applying and evaluating human rights policy.

Describe your knowledge of the functions, regulations and procedures of the commission you'd serve:

I am unaware of the specific functions, regulations and procedures of the Palm Springs Human Rights Commission. However, I have a strong command of federal civil rights statutes and laws and international human rights treaties and agreements.

What issues or problems face the board/commission? Do you have any suggestions to address them?:

1. ICE immigration raids in Palm Springs: I recently met with Mayor Soto and provided her an action list of steps the city could take to better communicate with residents and protect life and property from the potentially illegal actions of the Trump administration.

2. Civil rights of women, people of color, people of limited English proficiency, and the LGBTIQ community.

3. Homelessness/Unhoused community.

4. Access to healthcare

5. Access to clean air, water and soil

ERIN SAMMONS

CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
Commissions, Boards and Committees Application
Human Rights Commission
Date submitted: March 14, 2026
Profile
Please indicate whether you live, work, or go to school within Palm Springs:

Live ,Work ,Historic Site Preservation Board,Parks & Recreation Commission,Public Arts Commission,VillageFest Board
First Name: Middle Initial: Last Name:

Erin Sammons
Email Address:
[email protected]
Street Address:
2388 E Tahquitz Canyon Way
Suite or Apartment:

City: State: Postal Code:

Palm Springs CA 92262
Phone:
(760)997-3954
What other committees would you like to apply for if not selected to this committee? (List of all applicable open committees):

Interests & Experiences

Regarding the commission you are applying for, list dates of most recent meetings you have attended or watched
Unfortunately, I have not attended any of the monthly Human Rights meetings in several years; however, I remain extremely interested in becoming involved again in this area and would welcome the opportunity to assist wherever and whenever needed.

Education
I graduated from Palm Springs High School before continuing my education at College of the Desert and later attending San Diego State University. I ultimately earned her bachelor’s degree from University of Phoenix.

Background/Work Experience/Civic Involvement:

I am a lifelong resident of Palm Springs and care deeply about the well-being and continued growth of our community. Growing up here has given me the opportunity to see both the strengths of our city and the areas where we, as residents, can work together to create a more inclusive and supportive environment for everyone.

My professional background includes many years in leadership roles within the hospitality industry, both in Palm Springs and throughout California. These experiences have strengthened my ability to listen, collaborate, and respond thoughtfully to the needs of diverse communities. I believe these skills, along with my passion for community engagement, would allow me to be a valuable and dedicated member of the Human Rights Committee.

Describe your knowledge of the functions, regulations and procedures of the commission you'd serve:

I understand that the Human Rights Commission plays an important role in helping ensure that Palm Springs remains a welcoming and inclusive community for everyone. The commission works closely with the City Council and community members to identify concerns related to discrimination, fairness, and equal opportunity, while also helping guide policies that support human rights. I’m familiar with the importance of open public meetings, community input, and thoughtful discussion when reviewing issues that affect residents and visitors alike. Having grown up in Palm Springs, I value the city’s diversity and understand how important it is that all voices are heard and respected as we continue working toward a community where everyone feels safe, represented, and supported.

What issues or problems face the board/commission? Do you have any suggestions to address them?:

Palm Springs is known for being an inclusive and welcoming community, but like many growing cities it still faces challenges that the Human Rights Commission can help address.

Some issues include ensuring equitable access to housing and services, supporting vulnerable populations such as seniors, LGBTQ+ youth, and individuals experiencing homelessness, and continuing to address discrimination or bias when it arises. As the city continues to grow and attract visitors from around the world, maintaining a balance between tourism, community needs, and respect for all residents is also important.

One way to address these challenges is through continued community outreach and education so residents know their rights and feel comfortable speaking up if issues arise.

Strengthening partnerships between the commission, local organizations, and community groups can also help identify concerns early and create solutions together. I believe creating open dialogue, listening to community members, and promoting awareness of human rights issues will continue to help Palm Springs remain a city that values diversity, respect, and opportunity for everyone.

MICHELLE ANDERBERG

CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
Commissions, Boards and Committees Application
Human Rights Commission
Date submitted: March 18, 2026
Profile
Please indicate whether you live, work, or go to school within Palm Springs:

Live
First Name: Middle Initial: Last Name:
michelle anderberg
Email Address:
[email protected]
Street Address:
360 Cabrillo Road
Suite or Apartment:

City: State: Postal Code:

Palm Springs CA 92262
Phone:
(385)347-8801
What other committees would you like to apply for if not selected to this committee? (List of all applicable open committees):

Interests & Experiences
Regarding the commission you are applying for, list dates of most recent meetings you have attended or watched

I have reviewed the recent monthly commission meetings via available recordings from January 2025 through February 2026.

Education
I hold a Master of Arts from the University of South Dakota.

Background/Work Experience/Civic Involvement:

I’ve built my career around legal support, case management, and client-focused service, with over 15 years of progressive experience in both legal and human services roles. Most recently, I’m working as a litigation paralegal with Eisenberg, Lowrance, Lundell & Lofgren, where I support a busy personal injury team through all phases of prelitigation and litigation, including legal research, drafting, and case management. Prior to that, I spent nearly a decade with Eisenberg, Cutt, Kendell & Olson, supporting multiple partners and associates in complex civil litigation. I developed strong expertise in e-discovery, trial preparation, and ensuring compliance with both state and federal requirements. I also managed litigation files and played a key role in preparing cases for trial and arbitration. In addition to my legal experience, I have a background in public service and counseling. I served as a County Director for outpatient counseling centers and worked with Montgomery County’s Drug Court program, where I collaborated with legal professionals and treatment providers to support rehabilitation efforts. Academically, I hold a master’s degree in interdisciplinary studies with a focus on administration, ethics, counseling, and legal studies, which complements my practical experience. I was also honored as UAJ Paralegal of the Year in 2025. Overall, my background has given me a strong foundation in litigation support, leadership, and ethical client service, and I’m excited to continue contributing in a role where I can support and help drive successful outcomes.”
Describe your knowledge of the functions, regulations and procedures of the commission you'd serve:

While I have not served on a commission I do sit on an Association for Justice board for paralegals. It is my understanding that the functions regulations and procedures of the Human Rights commission include: The Human Rights Commission plays an important governance and advisory role in supporting the city’s commitment to equity and inclusion. As a commission, its primary responsibility is to advise the city council on policies, programs, and emerging issues related to human rights and discrimination. It also serves as a community-facing body that helps identify concerns such as bias or inequity, and works proactively to address those issues through education, outreach, and collaboration with local organizations and stakeholders. From a board perspective, the commission is responsible for fostering open dialogue, ensuring community voices are heard, and promoting thoughtful, ethical decision-making. It also helps recognize and elevate efforts within the community that advance human rights. Overall, the commission functions as both a strategic advisor and a bridge between the public and city leadership, helping ensure that policies and initiatives reflect fairness, inclusion, and accountability.

What issues or problems face the board/commission? Do you have any suggestions to address them?:

The Palm Springs Human Rights Commission faces several ongoing challenges that require both community awareness and a structured, policy-driven approach. One key issue is ensuring that individuals who experience discrimination feel safe reporting concerns and trust that their voices will be heard. From a legal perspective, accessibility, clarity in reporting processes, and consistency in handling concerns are critical. Another challenge is moving from awareness to measurable impact. While education and outreach are important, there’s often a need for stronger data collection, tracking trends, and evaluating outcomes to ensure efforts are effective and aligned with applicable laws and standards. Additionally, as an advisory body, the commission may face limitations in enforcement authority. That makes it especially important to provide well-researched, clearly supported recommendations to the city council that are grounded in legal principles and best practices. To address these challenges, I would suggest strengthening partnerships with community organizations to improve outreach, while also implementing more structured processes for documenting and analyzing complaints or concerns. Leveraging data and legal research can help identify patterns and support more impactful policy recommendations. I also believe the commission can benefit from clear prioritization of key issues and maintaining strong, consistent communication with city leadership to ensure recommendations are actionable. With my background in litigation, compliance, and case management, I understand the importance of organization, documentation, and follow-through, and I would bring that approach to supporting the commission’s work in a meaningful and effective way.

RICHARD BABIK

CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
Commissions, Boards and Committees Application
Human Rights Commission
Date submitted: March 22, 2026
Profile
Please indicate whether you live, work, or go to school within Palm Springs:

Live ,Airport Commission,Library Board of Trustees
First Name: Middle Initial: Last Name:

Richard Babik
Email Address:
[email protected]
Street Address:
460 East Club Drive
Suite or Apartment:

City: State: Postal Code:

Palm Springs CA 92262
Phone:
(954)881-0607
What other committees would you like to apply for if not selected to this committee? (List of all applicable open committees):

Interests & Experiences
Regarding the commission you are applying for, list dates of most recent meetings you have attended or watched

I watched the Human Rights Commision meetings held on January 12, February 9, and March 10, 2026.

Education
I graduated from Carteret High School in New Jersey in 1978.

I have a bachelor’s of science degree in secondary education from Seton Hall University in New Jersey achieved in 1982.

I have a master’s degree in administration and supervision from Kean University in New Jersey achieved in 1996.

I have a doctorate degree in higher education administration from Barry University in Florida achieved in 2015.

Background/Work Experience/Civic Involvement:

I was employed by the Borough of Carteret Fire Department in New Jersey for almost 20 years, retiring in 1999 as second-in-command at the rank of Captain. I was the town’s Fire Official, Fire Inspector, Arson Investigator, and Fire Sub-Code Official.

I taught English as a Second Language at Hudson County Community College in New Jersey for 10 years in the 1990’s.

I relocated to Florida in 1999.

I taught various courses for the English Department at Barry University in Florida for 15 years, where I also managed the university’s on-line writing lab, until 2015.

I relocated to Palm Springs in 2021.

I served on the Board of Directors of the PrimeTimers of the Desert for over four years, serving as the organization’s Vice-President and President. The PrimeTimers of the Desert is an active non-profit social club with almost 1,400 members and is based in Palm Springs. I am currently the Vice-President of the PrimeTimers WorldWide, with over 7,200 members around the globe.

Describe your knowledge of the functions, regulations and procedures of the commission you'd serve:

I have yet to serve on a commission.

I am interested in the Human Rights Commision because its purpose and goals align with my beliefs and practices. This commission has an ongoing positive impact on the community and strives to provide a fair, inclusive, and equitable outcome for Palm Springs residents.

What issues or problems face the board/commission? Do you have any suggestions to address them?:

I am not aware of specific issues or problems that face the Human Rights Commission in Palm Springs.

I know that promoting and protecting diversity in a community is of utmost importance and is an ongoing process that requires attention and diligence. Palm Springs in an inclusive and welcoming village; however, there are always opportunities to improve human relations even in a wonderful community such as this one.

If I am able to serve on this commission, I will strive to educate residents about any concerns that may arise, resolve any problems that may come before the commission, and continually work to raise community awareness of the necessity to always be vigilant and treat one another with respect.

MIHAI PATRU

CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
Commissions, Boards and Committees Application
Human Rights Commission
Date submitted: March 29, 2026
Profile
Please indicate whether you live, work, or go to school within Palm Springs:

Live ,Work ,Airport Commission,Library Board of Trustees,Measure ,Parks & Recreation Commission,VillageFest Board
First Name: Middle Initial: Last Name:

Mihai Patru
Email Address:
[email protected]
Street Address:
2001 E Camino Parocela,
Suite or Apartment:

City: State: Postal Code:

Palm Springs CA 92264
Phone:
(240)838-6570
What other committees would you like to apply for if not selected to this committee? (List of all applicable open committees):

Interests & Experiences

Regarding the commission you are applying for, list dates of most recent meetings you have attended or watched
I have started engaging with recent Human Rights Commission meetings by reviewing agendas and recordings from early 2026 and plan to attend regularly moving forward to stay closely connected to the Commission’s work and priorities.

Education
I am currently a doctoral student in Leadership for Educational Justice at University of Redlands, focusing on equity, access, and economic mobility. I hold a Master’s degree in International Public Policy from Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies (Washington DC), as well as a Master’s degree in International Relations from Central European University (Budapest, Hungary). I also earned a Bachelor’s degree in Arabic Language and Literature from University of Bucharest, grounding my work in cross-cultural understanding and global engagement.

Background/Work Experience/Civic Involvement:

I bring over a decade of experience at the intersection of economic development, education, and community empowerment. As Executive Director of Blue Zones Project Palm Springs, I lead initiatives that integrate well-being into everyday life—across schools, workplaces, and neighborhoods—while advancing equity and access for all residents.

As co-founder and former Executive Director of Caravanserai – Alliance for Entrepreneurs, I have worked extensively with underserved and underrepresented entrepreneurs, including immigrants, first-generation business owners, and faith-based communities. Our work focuses on reducing barriers to opportunity by providing culturally responsive business education, access to capital, and long-term support systems.

My earlier career as a diplomat in the Middle East, along with my research and academic work, has shaped a global perspective on human rights, social inclusion, and economic justice. I currently contribute to statewide efforts as a member of the California Governor’s Entrepreneurship and Economic Mobility Task Force.

I view civic engagement as essential to building inclusive communities and am committed to supporting policies and practices that uphold dignity, equity, and opportunity for all.

Describe your knowledge of the functions, regulations and procedures of the commission you'd serve:

While I have not previously served on a Human Rights Commission, I have developed a strong understanding of its core functions, including advising local government on policies that promote equity and inclusion, reviewing and addressing community concerns related to discrimination and human rights, and supporting education and outreach efforts that advance dignity and access for all residents.

I understand that commissions operate within established municipal frameworks, including adherence to public meeting laws such as the Ralph M. Brown Act, and play an important role in fostering transparent, community-informed decision-making.

Through my professional and civic work, I have collaborated with public agencies, community stakeholders, and diverse populations, which has given me practical insight into how advisory

bodies function, build trust, and translate community needs into actionable recommendations.

What issues or problems face the board/commission? Do you have any suggestions to address them?:

The Commission faces a number of interconnected challenges, many of which reflect broader dynamics in the community. These include ensuring equitable access to resources and opportunities across different populations, addressing disparities experienced by marginalized groups—including LGBTQ+ individuals, immigrant communities, seniors, and low-income residents—and strengthening trust and engagement between community members and local institutions.

Another key challenge is moving from awareness to sustained impact—ensuring that conversations around human rights translate into tangible changes in policy, practice, and everyday experiences. Like many advisory bodies, the Commission may also face limitations in visibility, capacity, and influence in shaping decision-making at the city level.

To address these challenges, I would suggest:
- Strengthening community engagement through more accessible and culturally responsive outreach (including partnerships with trusted local organizations) - Creating clearer pathways for community input to inform policy recommendations - Focusing on a few high-impact priority areas each year to drive measurable progress - Improving communication and visibility so residents better understand the Commission’s role and how to engage
- Building stronger alignment with other city departments and initiatives to ensure human rights considerations are integrated into broader decision-making

DONALD SOJA
(INCUMBENT)

CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
Commissions, Boards and Committees Application
Human Rights Commission
Date submitted: April 1, 2026
Profile
Please indicate whether you live, work, or go to school within Palm Springs:

Live ,Human Rights Commission,N/A
First Name: Middle Initial: Last Name:

Donald Soja
Email Address:
[email protected]
Street Address:
1099 PALMAS RIDGE
Suite or Apartment:

City: State: Postal Code:

Palm Springs CA 92262
Phone:
(913)642-6006
What other committees would you like to apply for if not selected to this committee? (List of all applicable open committees):

Interests & Experiences
Regarding the commission you are applying for, list dates of most recent meetings you have attended or watched

I last attended the City of Palm Springs Human Rights Commission meeting on March 9, 2026, as Vice Chair of the City of Palm Springs Human Rights Commissioner. I have attended every meeting since March of 2025.

Education
I have attended both Eastern Michigan University, and Mid America Nazarene University. I have previously completed the Dale Carniege Management Training Program. I have been through both General Motors & Saturn Motors Management Training. I completed the TWA Airlines Flight Attendant Training Program, and the TWA Management Training Program. I completed the American Airlines Flight Attendant Training Program, and the American Airlines Management Training Program. I completed the City of Palm Springs CERTS Training program. I completed the City of Palm Springs Police Departments Citizens On Patrol training program.

Background/Work Experience/Civic Involvement:

Personnel Analyst for General Motors Chevrolet Division. International Travel Director for Sperry & Hutchinson Corportation. Flight Attendant for both TWA & American Airlines, also a recruiter & Instructor/manager for both airlines. I have volunteered for the following Palm Springs organizations: 1. Helped start what is now known as ONE PS Neighborhood Organization, in 2007. 2. President of the Racquet Club West Homes Organization. 3. CERTS Qualified. 4. Volunteered at the Palm Springs Animal Shelter. 5. Volunteered at the City of Palm Springs Citizens on Patrol for 5 years. 6. Volunteer on Saturday mornings feeding the homeless at the United Methodist Church in Palm Springs. 7. Currently Vice Chair of the City of Palm Springs Human Rights Commission.

Describe your knowledge of the functions, regulations and procedures of the commission you'd serve:

I am currently Vice Chair of the City of Palm Springs Human Rights Commission. I started this Commissioners position in March of 2025. I have never missed a meeting in the past 12 months. As a Commissioner on the Human Rights Commission, I understand the need for this Commission... We fall under the jurisdiction of the Palm Springs City Council. Everything the Human Rights Commission does, is done with the knowledge of the City of Palm Springs policies. The Human Rights Commission is made up of nine Commissioners. We, as a Commission, listen to Citizens & Community concerns, and make suggestions to the City Council on those concerns. We encourage the public to attend our monthly meetings. We only deal with concerns that are within the Palm Springs city limits. I am very Proud to have served this past year, as Vice Chair of the Human Rights Commission. I would be honored to serve another term. Thank You... Don Soja
What issues or problems face the board/commission? Do you have any suggestions to address them?:

As a current Commissioner for the City of Palm Springs Human Rights Commission, I am proud to serve with the other Commissioners, as a Team Member. I believe we have a great current commission. I would like to see every member attended every meeting, if possible. I

believe the Commissioners attendance, to the monthly meetings, is very important. It is important for every Commissioner to be aware of all issues presented to the Commission. I look forward to continuing as a Human Rights Commissioner... Thank You

LEVI KNAPP

CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
Commissions, Boards and Committees Application
Human Rights Commission
Date submitted: April 15, 2026
Profile
Please indicate whether you live, work, or go to school within Palm Springs:

Live ,Work ,Parks & Recreation Commission,Planning Commission,Public Arts Commission First Name: Middle Initial: Last Name:

Levi Knapp
Email Address:
[email protected]
Street Address:
689 E Camino Parocela
Suite or Apartment:

City: State: Postal Code:

Palm Springs CA 92264
Phone:
(760)285-5556
What other committees would you like to apply for if not selected to this committee? (List of all applicable open committees):

Interests & Experiences
Regarding the commission you are applying for, list dates of most recent meetings you have attended or watched

I have not been attending any meetings of the Human Rights Commission, however I have reviewed meeting minutes to see if this commission and I would be a good fit. My history of advocacy work for marginalized communities on national/state/ and local levels and belief that Palm Springs is only strengthened through diversity led me to taking a closer look at the the Human Rights Commission. Although I have been a property owner in Palm Springs for a decade I am pleased that we have decided to be full time members of the community, which led me to get involved on a neighborhood level, and now I’d like to be involved on the municipal level as well.

Education
Undergrad:

George Washington Univerity, Political Communications, (no degree) Los Angeles City College Theatre Academy- AA

Background/Work Experience/Civic Involvement:

I am currently a full time real estate agent with Desert Sotheby’s here in Palm Springs. I will copy and paste my resume below as the passion of my life had been raising money and managing candidate campaigns and issue based, state-level referendum campaigns around Marriage Equality. Working with organizations like Human Rights Campaign and National Gay and Lesbian Task Force on the ground in states like Mass, ME, NJ, NY was the most exciting, rewarding, heartbreaking work. I miss it tremendously, but i do not miss working 100 hour a week and traveling nonstop for several years. It’s nice to have my roots planted now in Palm Springs and I would like to bring my same passion for diversity. equity, and inclusion that fueled that chapter in my life and marry it with my current chapter.

Realtor
Desert Sotheby’s, Palm Springs, CA
2021- Current
Built a full-service business from the ground up—managing marketing, negotiations, and operations with the focus of a startup founder.

Created consistent inbound lead flow through SEO, paid campaigns, and referrals while maintaining a strong, luxury desert brand.

Served as a trusted advisor to buyers and sellers, simplifying complex decisions with empathy and data-driven insight.

Produced lifestyle-forward marketing that helped listings stand out in competitive markets.

Negotiated and closed complex transactions (including sight-unseen purchases) with composure and integrity.

Leveraged tech systems (BoldTrail, RealScout, Zapier) to automate operations while preserving high-touch service.

Executive Recruiter
The Winters Group
2015-2020

Partnered directly with boards and investors to identify leadership gaps and design organizational structures for growth-stage biotech companies.

Executed confidential C-suite and VP-level searches under strict discretion during funding rounds and stealth operations.

Assessed executives for both scientific rigor and business acumen to ensure alignment with investor and regulatory expectations.

Built entire leadership teams positioned for IPO readiness and global commercialization.

Acted as an embedded advisor, bridging science, strategy, and storytelling to attract top talent.

Congressional, Statewide, and National Advocacy Campaigns incl. Freedom to Marry 2007-2015
Built campaigns from concept to statewide operations—expanding from one staffer to hundreds of employees and volunteers.

Managed full P&L responsibility for multi-million-dollar budgets, ensuring compliance with FEC and state campaign finance laws.

Raised and strategically deployed millions for advertising, field programs, and digital outreach.

Crafted messaging frameworks that turned polling data into stories that moved public opinion and inspired donors.

Coordinated paid, earned, and digital media under intense scrutiny and shifting political climates.

Led teams with empathy and precision, maintaining morale under pressure while delivering measurable wins.

Describe your knowledge of the functions, regulations and procedures of the commission you'd serve:

My understanding is that the Human Rights Commission is an advisory body focused on promoting inclusion, improving human relations, and helping the City stay connected to what residents are experiencing. It’s not there to enforce or adjudicate, but to surface issues, create space for dialogue, and make thoughtful recommendations.

From a structure standpoint, it operates under the City’s municipal code and follows the Brown Act, so meetings are public, agendas are posted in advance, and there’s an emphasis on transparency and public participation. That piece feels important, because trust in the process is just as important as the outcome.

In terms of how it functions day to day, the Commission meets regularly, hears from the public, and can review concerns related to discrimination or human relations. When appropriate, it can help guide conversations or point people to the right agency if something falls outside its scope. It also plays a role in identifying trends and advising the City on policies or programs that support a more inclusive community.

At a practical level, I think the effectiveness of the Commission comes down to clarity. Clarity around what it does, how it operates, and what people can expect when they come forward.

When that’s in place, it’s much easier for the Commission to do what it’s meant to do, which is be a steady, credible resource for the community.

What issues or problems face the board/commission? Do you have any suggestions to address them?:

At its core, the Commission serves as an advisory and human relations body not an enforcement arm of the City. Its role is to educate, offer recommendations, facilitate dialogue when appropriate, document concerns, and connect residents with the right resources when issues fall outside its jurisdiction.

Based on recent materials and public discussion, it seems the Commission has been in a period of evaluation: particularly around its scope, processes, and how its governing ordinance aligns with the City’s current needs. Whether those updates are ongoing or largely addressed, it highlights a broader and ongoing challenge: ensuring the Commission’s role is clearly defined, well understood, and consistently executed in a way that builds public trust.

To me, that presents an opportunity. Clear communication around what the Commission does (and doesn’t do), continued attention to transparency and process, and alignment between its ordinance and day-to-day function all strengthen its effectiveness. Just as importantly, the Commission can continue to lean into its role as a connector making sure residents feel heard and are guided to the right place for resolution when needed.

Ultimately, the goal is less about any single update and more about maintaining clarity, relevance, and trust over time.

FRANK McALPIN

CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
Commissions, Boards and Committees Application
Human Rights Commission
Date submitted: April 19, 2026
Profile
Please indicate whether you live, work, or go to school within Palm Springs:

Live ,Human Rights Commission,Measure ,Parks & Recreation Commission First Name: Middle Initial: Last Name:

Frank McAlpin
Email Address:
[email protected]
Street Address:
280 S. Avenida Caballeros
Suite or Apartment:

City: State: Postal Code:

Palm Springs CA 92262
Phone:
(630)926-9231
What other committees would you like to apply for if not selected to this committee? (List of all applicable open committees):

Interests & Experiences
Regarding the commission you are applying for, list dates of most recent meetings you have attended or watched

Feb 9, 2026, Mar 10, 2026, April 13, 2026
Education
Bachelor’s of Arts- History/Education , Marquette University Master of Social Work, Fordham University
Doctor of Social Work, University of Pennsylvania
Background/Work Experience/Civic Involvement:

California State University San
Bernardino
San Bernardino, CA
Full-time Lecturer/Professor, School of Social
Work Jan
2024-Present
· Responsible for teaching social work courses including: Macro Practice, Social Welfare Policy, Introduction to Social Work, Social with LGBTQ
· Coordinated BASW and MSW program at CSUSB-Palm Desert Campus University of
Utah
Salt Lake City, UT
Assistant Professor/Lecturer, College of Social
Work Jan. 2021-
May 2022
· Responsible for teaching undergraduate and graduate social work courses including:

Diversity, Social Justice, Ethics & Reflexive Social Work Practice 1 & 2, Generalist Social Work Practice 1 & 2, Developmental Impact of Child Abuse
· Chaired search committee for director of field education Simmons
University
Boston, MA
Adjunct Professor, School of Social
Work
Jan. 2022-Present
· Responsible for teaching doctoral courses including: Ethics and Social Justice Seminar, Decolonized Clinical Supervision and Management, Working with Diverse and Complex Populations
California State University San
Bernardino
San Bernardino, CA

Adjunct Professor, School of Social
Work
Aug. 2022-Dec 2023
· Responsible for teaching graduate social work courses including: Advanced Macro Practice II, Social Welfare Policy
California State University Los
Angeles
Los Angeles, CA
Adjunct Professor, Child and Family Studies
Department Jan. 2019- May 2021; Aug. 2022-Present
· Responsible for teaching undergraduate courses including: Health Disparities in Urban Communities, Urban Families and Resilience, Effects of Transitions on Children and Families University of Southern California, California State University Los Angeles, University of Utah Los Angeles, CA & Salt Lake City, UT Field Instructor for MSW/BSW
students
2014-2022

PRACTICE EXPERIENCE
Mizell Senior
Center
Palm Springs, CA
Director of Case
Management
Apr. 2023-present
· Responsible for the development and supervision of case management services for older adults including the supervision of program staff, contract compliance and clinical consultation
· Provided intensive clinical case management services to older adults including: resource connection and navigation, crisis management, care coordination and client advocacy Homeless Health Care Los
Angeles
Los Angeles, CA
Training
Specialist
Apr. 2022-Mar 2023
· Responsible for the development and facilitation of in-person and virtual trainings for homeless service providers throughout LA County
· Developed and facilitated curriculum on a range of topics relevant to homeless service

providers including: trauma-informed care, housing first, harm reduction, behavioral health, cultural humility, case management, non-violent communication and supervision · Engaged training participants in interactive learning activities including role-plays and on- the-spot coaching
Los Angeles LGBT
Center
Los Angeles, CA
Senior Housing Manager, Youth Services (May 2020-Feb.
2021) Mar. 2018-Feb. 2021
· Responsible for the leadership, development, management and supervision of a 90-bed residential program for young adults
· Managed several funding streams, including federal and county grants and contracts · Ensured that the program was in compliance with contract and grant deliverables · Oversaw the hiring, training, supervision and evaluation for 60+ residential staff · Provided clinical guidance and support, including crisis response and management to housing program, drop-in space and outreach teams
· Developed and implemented program-wide training, coaching and support on harm reduction, trauma-informed care and housing first
· Served as an agency representative at local, state and national meetings and working groups · Served as the department lead in responding to COVID-19, coordinating staff and client COVID prevention, testing and care
Program Manager, Youth Services (Mar. 2018-May 2020)
· Provided leadership, management, and program development for youth experiencing homelessness programs
· Managed the daily operations and services for a 40-bed youth shelter · Developed, implemented and supervised case management services for youth in residential and drop-in programs
· Conducted crisis intervention and mental health support for clients; Coordinated services and referrals
· Provided direct supervision to program staff, including supervisors, case managers, mental health clinicians, youth advocates and interns
Test Positive Aware
Network
Chicago, IL
HOTTER Program
Manager
Jan. 2018-Mar. 2018
· Provided leadership and management for a SAMHSA substance use/HIV grant for youth and young adults
· Facilitated a series of psycho-educational groups on substance use, trauma, HIV, sexual health and oppression

· Completed program intakes and bio-psycho assessments for clients enrolled in the program · Engaged in community-based outreach, targeting historically disconnected populations The
Door
New York, NY
Substitute Outreach Worker (part-time relief
worker) Jan. 2017-Oct. 2018
· Conducted late-night outreach to youth experiencing homelessness at various locations in lower Manhattan
· Provided crisis counseling, case management and referrals to youth experiencing homelessness
· Connected youth to various services within the drop-in space; facilitated enrichment activities within the drop-in space
Fordham
University
New York, NY
Resident Director for First Year
Students
Mar. 2016-Sept. 2017
· Responsible for the daily operation and supervision of a residential hall of 475 undergraduate students
· Provided leadership and supervision to 12 staff directly and 24 staff in-directly · Conducted crisis management and mental health support and served as a campus-wide emergency responder
Youth Emerging Stronger (formerly -Los Angeles Youth
Network) Los Angeles, CA Director of Case Management (Sept. 2015-
Mar.2016) Mar. 2013- Mar. 2016
· Served as part of the executive leadership team, assisting in overall program and service development
· Developed, implemented and managed agency-wide case management services for homeless and foster youth
· Supervised MSW case managers, BSW case managers and MSW/BSW interns · Facilitated weekly case conferences and team meetings (with both staff and families) using a trauma-informed approach
· Developed and implemented a system of services and care grounded in trauma-informed and anti-oppressive practice
· Developed and implemented agency-wide trainings on trauma-informed care, harm reduction and youth engagement practices

Transitional Living Program Manager (Mar. 2013-Sept.
2015)
· Responsible for the daily operation, management and leadership of a 17-bed transitional living program (TLP) for homeless youth
· Developed and implemented program expectations, policies, structure and care that was strengths-based and trauma-informed
· Provided clinical case management, 1:1 counseling, psycho-educational groups and crisis intervention to youth in the program
Loyola Marymount
University
Los Angeles, CA
Resident
Director
Jan. 2012-Mar. 2013
· Responsible for the daily operation and management of 2 residential apartments of 350 students
· Provided leadership development and supervision to 12 student staff · Conducted crisis intervention and management and served as a campus-wide emergency responder
Center on
Halsted
Chicago, IL
Youth Program
Coordinator
Jul. 2010-Dec. 2010
· Responsible for the daily operation and management of a drop-in space for LGBTQ homeless youth
· Managed youth program intakes and coordinated therapeutic programming and services within the drop-in space
· Provided crisis intervention, clinical case management and trauma-informed interventions to youth in the space
· Advised the Youth Leadership Council (YLC) and coordinated their restorative justice initiatives
United States Peace
Corps
Washington, DC
Community Health Volunteer,
Mozambique
Sept. 2010-May 2011

· Coordinated and supported youth programming around HIV/AIDS and gender equality · Provided counseling and psycho-education to people living with HIV/AIDS · Developed and implemented culturally competent trainings and resources on HIV/AIDS, sexual health and sexual violence
· Enhanced the capacity of local community-based agencies through providing technical support and training
Describe your knowledge of the functions, regulations and procedures of the commission you'd serve:

I have not previously served on this commission or other commissions. In reviewing the human rights commission meetings, it appears the commission follows a standard committee/commission meeting protocol and procedure. I have been part of committee meetings that follow an agenda and similar protocols and procedures. If chosen to serve on this commission I can quickly become aware of all knowledge, regulations and procedures relevant to the work of the commission. In the meetings I have viewed I appreciate the collaborative nature and open dialogue between the commissioners. In addition, I have come to know the human rights commissioners to be thoughtful, intentional and committed to furthering human rights within the community.

What issues or problems face the board/commission? Do you have any suggestions to address them?:

Homelessness, housing insecurity and affordable housing: developing a strong awareness of how these issues look/are experienced within the community, expand knowledge on current resources and supports, speak out/take action in support of community members experiencing homelessness and housing instability, center accessibility and equity in all infinitives, link housing to human rights
Immigration Enforcement: advocate for residents directly impacted by immigration enforcement, organize and/or participate in mutual aid efforts to protect/support residents impacted by immigration enforcement, frame dignity and safety for city residents regardless of immigration status as a human rights issue
LGBTQ+ rights and safety: ensure that Palm Springs continues to be a safe and inclusive community for all residents, support policies that that enhance inclusion and safety, center the lived experiences of LGBTQ+ residents in developing policies and/or advocating for the community
Racial justice: engage in ongoing discussions and support of local racial justice concerns, integrate an anti-racist framework within decisions and programming, ensure that inclusion and equity are centered in city policies and procedures, expose and/or address racial

inequities within the city
Older Adults: be sensitive and responsive to the unique needs of older adults within the city, increase access to programs and services for older adults, center the inclusion and participation of older adults within decision making
Food insecurity: increase community knowledge around the scope and impact of food insecurity in the city and frame it as a human rights concern, promote short term (emergency food distribution) and long-term solutions to food insecurity in our community Civic engagement: create opportunities for residents to engage in activities that support and/or protect human rights within the city, encourage residents to take part in human rights related initiatives /campaigns
Human rights education promotion: engage in city-wide public knowledge campaigns about the commission and its work and/or important local human rights concerns, promote human rights related issues within school system, at community events, senior centers, etc.

Localized human rights concerns: be aware and responsive to specific human rights issues/concerns as they come up in the city, be a body that centers and advocates for a human rights framework when city policies are developing/being debated or considered, help residents problem solve around human rights concerns,

DANIEL BORGSTADT

CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
Commissions, Boards and Committees Application
Human Rights Commission
Date submitted: April 21, 2026
Profile
Please indicate whether you live, work, or go to school within Palm Springs:

Live ,N/A
First Name: Middle Initial: Last Name:

Daniel Borgstadt
Email Address:
[email protected]
Street Address:
200 Vista Terrace
Suite or Apartment:

City: State: Postal Code:

Palm Springs CA 92262
Phone:
(310)383-7496
What other committees would you like to apply for if not selected to this committee? (List of all applicable open committees):

Interests & Experiences
Regarding the commission you are applying for, list dates of most recent meetings you have attended or watched

Attended in person February 10, 2025; Watched video January 13, March 10, April 14, June 9, September 8, 2025
Education
MS - Human Resources; MBA - Management; Graduate Certificate - Human Resources; BSBA - Marketing and Management
Background/Work Experience/Civic Involvement:

Former Board Member for the Palm Springs Personnel Board; appointed by the Palm Springs Mayor and City Council to a 3 year term. Equality, Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (EDEI) programs, training and administration as Director, Human Resources for The RAND Corporation and Kinecta Federal Credit Union. Affirmative Action administration and tracking for RAND. Volunteer during Thanksgiving and Christmas for community dinner and gift programs.

Describe your knowledge of the functions, regulations and procedures of the commission you'd serve:

The Human Rights Commission works to advance equality, inclusion and recognition of the multiple diverse communities in Palm Springs. This includes exposure and education on missions; educating and advocating for the organization through the Commission and the City Council as appropriate; outreach to organizations to expand inclusivity and recognize organizations or individuals that Lead by Example the mission of the HRC.

What issues or problems face the board/commission? Do you have any suggestions to address them?:

The current political environment has taken on an "us versus them" atmosphere that instills fear and suspicion. Reaching out to community organizations and individuals to make sure they are heard and understood without fear of retribution or reprisal is critical to the overall feeling of safety to the community. The Commission has had some operational issues in the past and proactively working to show that those issues have been addressed and over is critical the the Commission success

LINDA FUTTERER

CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
Commissions, Boards and Committees Application
Human Rights Commission
Date submitted: April 21, 2026
Profile
Please indicate whether you live, work, or go to school within Palm Springs:

Live ,N/A
First Name: Middle Initial: Last Name:

Linda Futterer
Email Address:
[email protected]
Street Address:
1647 South Calle Rolph
Suite or Apartment:

City: State: Postal Code:

Palm Springs CA 92264
Phone:
(760)327-5591
What other committees would you like to apply for if not selected to this committee? (List of all applicable open committees):

Interests & Experiences
Regarding the commission you are applying for, list dates of most recent meetings you have attended or watched

Nov-25
Education
Masters
Background/Work Experience/Civic Involvement:

Library Board of Trustees member and President, Noise Sub commission, Measure J commission
Describe your knowledge of the functions, regulations and procedures of the commission you'd serve:

As a member and President of the Library Trustees I was responsible for setting the agenda, review and voting on Budget, restoring the Well Wood Memorial Library, guiding all actions of the Library, meeting with Library Director once a month. Measure J commission responsibilities reviewing the Community Projects. In this capacity I visited projects to fuller understand their asks, voting on projects and reviewing the budget What issues or problems face the board/commission? Do you have any suggestions to address them?:

Having attended a meeting I feel there should be more representation from persons with handicaps, young students and young citizens, religious rights, sexual rights, ethnic rights safety rights, All citizens need to be included in the functions of the city, they should have a voice and the commission can develop policy if there is something missing in these rights.

RENE ROBLES

CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
Commissions, Boards and Committees Application
Human Rights Commission
Date submitted: April 21, 2026
Profile
Please indicate whether you live, work, or go to school within Palm Springs:

Live ,N/A
First Name: Middle Initial: Last Name:

Rene Robles
Email Address:
[email protected]
Street Address:
900 E. Saturnino Road
Suite or Apartment:

City: State: Postal Code:

Palm Springs CA 92264
Phone:
(760)219-5243
What other committees would you like to apply for if not selected to this committee? (List of all applicable open committees):

Interests & Experiences
Regarding the commission you are applying for, list dates of most recent meetings you have attended or watched

No formal meetings other than NO KINGS.

Education
Bachelor's in Criminal Justice and Paralegal Studies; 36 units in Education.

Background/Work Experience/Civic Involvement:

Current Crisis Responder with the County of Riverside - Mobile Crisis Management Team (3+ years); Former Paralegal in many areas of law, including but not limited to Civil Rights (18 years); Former Dual Immersion Sub Teacher with Corona/Norco USD.

Describe your knowledge of the functions, regulations and procedures of the commission you'd serve:

The knowledge of being person-centered, treating human fairly, with dignity and respect.

Understanding that listening more than speaking is imperative when working with each other in order to find resolve to challenges, which is an essential principle.

What issues or problems face the board/commission? Do you have any suggestions to address them?:

None at this time.

GEORGE NICKLE

CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
Commissions, Boards and Committees Application
Human Rights Commission
Date submitted: April 29, 2026
Profile
Please indicate whether you live, work, or go to school within Palm Springs:

Live ,Measure ,Planning Commission,Public Arts Commission First Name: Middle Initial: Last Name:

George Nickle
Email Address:
[email protected]
Street Address:
204 Camino Norte
Suite or Apartment:

City: State: Postal Code:

Palm Springs CA 92262
Phone:
(323)547-5613
What other committees would you like to apply for if not selected to this committee? (List of all applicable open committees):

Interests & Experiences
Regarding the commission you are applying for, list dates of most recent meetings you have attended or watched

4/13/2026, 3/9/2026, 2/9/2026, 1/12/2026
Education
University of North Carolina School of the Arts School of Filmmaking BFA, Filmmaking Background/Work Experience/Civic Involvement:

I am originally from a small town in rural Pennsylvania (near Gettysburg). I’ve lived in California for 28 years. Although my husband and I only moved to Palm Springs full-time in December, we have been visiting here since 2001.

I have a BFA in Filmmaking from the University of North Carolina School of the Arts, the first public arts conservatory in America. I trained as a talent agent, worked as a manager for actors and Japanese visual artists, in home video distribution, and am now the Business Development Manager – Western USA for Groupe Berkem.

We moved here from West Hollywood where we lived for 21 years. I started a Neighborhood Watch Group there in 2018 which is now part of the WeHo East Neighborhood Watch Group, in which I served as a Co-Captain and helped organize our very successful National Night Out block party each year. I served as a Commissioner on the West Hollywood Public Safety Commission from 2023 until we moved late last year and was the Commission’s liaison to the Disability Advisory Board. I also served on the Los Angeles County District Attorney’s LGBTQ+ Advisory Board in 2025.

I completed the American Red Cross Adult and Pediatric First Aid/CPR/AED certification, Los Angeles County Fire Department CERT Training, and the West Hollywood Sheriff’s Community Academy.

Describe your knowledge of the functions, regulations and procedures of the commission you'd serve:

Promoting Human Rights. Advising the City Council on matters involving Human Rights.

Bringing people together where tensions and misunderstanding exist because of past discriminatory practices, to address current, and prevent future ones. To educate the public on human rights issues. To act as a liaison between residents, visitors, workers, and their government.

What issues or problems face the board/commission? Do you have any suggestions to address them?:

As with any part of municipal government, I think that awareness is always a major issue.

Most residents never attend a City Council, Commission, or Board meeting and few are aware of the resources available to them, until, of course, they really need them. With the

Community Service Awards this Commission has the ability to not only recognize good works done in our community, and inspire good works in others, but also draw attention to the fact that the Commission exists, and can serve as a place for concerns to be brought and discussed and progress to be made. I liked the Commission’s presence at the ONE-PS Community Picnic & Expo and would encourage more visibility like this.

I think that this Commission has more to deal with than ever, and with our current federal government, the work the Commission will need to do will only grow as rights are stripped away. Work has already been done, like maintaining domestic partnerships in the city code.

We need to be prepared to move fast to counter federal actions against vulnerable communities by building even more connections with advocacy groups and other Boards and Commissions.

The rights of the disabled certainly falls under Human Rights and I’m pleased to have heard these issues discussed by Commissioners. I would like to hear more from this community about issues the Commission could address. For example, in West Hollywood electric scooters have become a serious problem by blocking access when left and ridden on sidewalks.

My basic approach would be to do all possible to raise awareness of the Commission, encourage engagement, continue to build ties with resources within and outside of municipal government, and ensure that people know that the Human Right Commission is there to hear their problems and find solutions.

BOBBY T. RIMAS
(INCUMBENT)

CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
Commissions, Boards and Committees Application
Human Rights Commission
Date submitted: April 30, 2026
Profile
Please indicate whether you live, work, or go to school within Palm Springs:

Live ,N/A
First Name: Middle Initial: Last Name:

Bobby Rimas
Email Address:

[email protected]
Street Address:
321 South Sunrise Way
Suite or Apartment:

City: State: Postal Code:

Palm Springs CA 92262
Phone:
(213)952-9914
What other committees would you like to apply for if not selected to this committee? (List of all applicable open committees):

Interests & Experiences
Regarding the commission you are applying for, list dates of most recent meetings you have attended or watched

As Commissioner of the Palm Springs Human Rights Commission (HRC), I attended the April 13, 2026, February 9, 2026, and January 12, 2026 HRC meetings.

Education

THE UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS AT EL PASO
Master of Arts in Education degree with a Diversity, Equity and Social Justice in Education Concentration awarded in May 2024.

Cumulative Grade Point Average: 3.77
UNIVERSITY OF ARIZONA JAMES E. ROGERS COLLEGE OF LAW
Master of Legal Studies degree with a Compliance and Legal Risk Management Concentration awarded in December 2021.

Cumulative Grade Point Average: 3.60
Degree Honors: Cum Laude

UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, LOS ANGELES
Extension, Attorney Assistant Training Program. This Program is offered in cooperation with the UCLA School of Law and approved by the American Bar Association.

Certificate in Litigation/Corporations awarded in March of 1996.

UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, LOS ANGELES
Bachelor of Arts degree in History awarded in June of 1994.

Cumulative Grade Point Average: 3.096
Major Grade Point Average: 3.430
Background/Work Experience/Civic Involvement:
– Los Angeles, California – ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR – June 2014 to present – Subjects taught include Civil Litigation, Intellectual Property Law, Immigration Law, Entertainment Law, Administrative Law, Legal Technology, and American Legal Systems.

UNIVERSITY OF LA VERNE, Department of Legal Studies
– La Verne, California – LEGAL STUDIES ADJUNCT FACULTY MEMBER – January 2022 to present – Taught the American Legal Studies and Senior Project courses.

Larson LLP Law Firm – Los Angeles, California – LITIGATION AND TRIAL PARALEGAL – May 2022 to June 2025 – Supported and contributed to the litigation and trial teams by utilizing analytical skills for various complex civil litigation and white-collar defense matters. Researched applicable local rules, managed intake of client documents, prepared exhibits and exhibit binders, witness binders, cross-examination binders, arbitration hearing binders and researched and prepared subpoenas for records and depositions, cite checked pleadings, proofread briefs, researched experts’ backgrounds, including their affiliated cases, experience, articles, media, etc. Responsible for managing database of case filings and analyzing discovery documents as well as productions. Prepared presentations and

demonstratives, productions in various formats, researched civil and federal court room procedures and judge preferences, prepared and maintained trial war rooms, researched backgrounds of prospective jurors, compiled and created exhibits for witness outlines, lodged deposition transcripts with the courts, and assisted attorneys with all aspects of trial preparation. Worked closely with eDiscovery vendors to set-up and manage client eDiscovery databases.

Stonewall Democratic Club Vice President of Diversity, Equity & Inclusion – May 2024 to present
Responsible for centering the Stonewall Democratic Club in all its activities and functions on diversity, equity and inclusion in the membership, leadership and through advocacy. Presented several webinars regarding diversity, equity and inclusion topics. The Stonewall Democratic Club is considered one of the largest Democratic Clubs in California. UCLA alumnus elected to Stonewall leadership position - Beverly Press & Park Labrea NewsBeverly Press & Park Labrea News
UCLA Lambda LGBTQ+ Alumni Association President – August 2018 to present As President and member of the UCLA Lambda Alumni Association Board of Directors, assist with the day-to-day affairs of the association which includes providing networking opportunities for alumni and students, raising scholarship funds, and putting on various events. Spearheaded the April 2019 UCLA Lambda LGBTQ+ Alumni Association (Lambda) Gala Brunch for over 100 attendees that recognized Lambda’s accomplishments, raised scholarship funds, and recognized alumni who have gone on to become prominent community leaders.

Describe your knowledge of the functions, regulations and procedures of the commission you'd serve:

As a Commissioner, I have a strong working knowledge of the functions, regulations, and procedures of the Palm Springs Human Rights Commission. In particular, I am well versed in the current “Rules and Procedures of the Palm Springs Human Rights Commission.” I am also deeply familiar with and committed to the Commission’s mission: to promote equality, fairness, and inclusion for all residents of Palm Springs, and to serve as an advisory body to the City Council on issues related to discrimination, civil rights, and community cohesion.

What issues or problems face the board/commission? Do you have any suggestions to address them?:

Overall, I believe the Palm Springs Human Rights Commission does excellent work. I suggest there may be opportunities to further strengthen its impact on the communities it serves.

CARLOTTA RINKE
(INCUMBENT)

CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
Commissions, Boards and Committees Application
Human Rights Commission
Date submitted: April 30, 2026
Profile
Please indicate whether you live, work, or go to school within Palm Springs:

Live ,Human Rights Commission,Measure
First Name: Middle Initial: Last Name:

Carlotta Rinke
Email Address:
[email protected]
Street Address:
1400 Sonora Ct.

Suite or Apartment:

City: State: Postal Code:

Palm Springs CA 92264
Phone:
(847)354-1154
What other committees would you like to apply for if not selected to this committee? (List of all applicable open committees):

Interests & Experiences
Regarding the commission you are applying for, list dates of most recent meetings you have attended or watched

I am an active member of the Human Rights Commission and I have attended every scheduled meeting in 2026, except March, where I had an excused absesnce. During 2025 I attended all scheduled meetings except for 1 or 2 excused absences. These dates were the first Monday of the months with the exeption of a religious/ethnic holiday.

Education
I am a retired physician with an active medical license in IL. I attended St. Louis U. Medical School and an internal medicine residency at the Medical College of VA (now VCU). I certified in the boards of Internal Medicine and Geriatrics. I later attended a full-time MBA program at Northwestern Univeristy Kellogg School of Managment. Currently I am active in the Palm Springs Wrtiers Guild as board Treasurer, and on the board of the Northwestern University Alumni Association of Coachella Valley.

Background/Work Experience/Civic Involvement:

I have served on the Human Rights Commission for 2 years and worked on editing the Municipal Code as it applies to the HRC. And I developed a standardized process to assesss entries to the Community Service Award. I have participated in One-PS HRC booth in 2025, and in 2024 I accompanied the police as they checked on the homeless encampments. I participated in being present during the Friday lunches provided by Well in the Desert, and hung out with the Street Medicine residents from UCR. I have been active at the No Kings Day protests.

Describe your knowledge of the functions, regulations and procedures of the commission you'd serve:

Since I already serve on it, under Hugo Loyola for the past 2+ years, I understand the potential activities and advocacy in which we can paritipcate. I also am interested in collaborating with other commissions, seeing how we can work together on projects where we overlap. We worked on creating an active liaison with the Council and now Grace Garner is a our go-to person for our needs. Jeremy Hammond’s leadership has been instrumental as the HRC builds community relevance.

What issues or problems face the board/commission? Do you have any suggestions to address them?:

The HRC’s ongoing issues pivot around the boundaries of what we can and cannot do, which is limited to only educate and advocate. However, we are at work in devleoping strategies that make us more effective and visible to the community. These not only include a presence at parades and celebrations, but also recommending actions the HRC identifies to the city council. I personally see human rights exctending beyond LGBT rights, to include immigrant and healthcare rights. Collaborating with groups who support timmigrants is a potent area of advocacy, where we can act through recommendations to the city council, with the input of Grace Ganer.