ON-CALL ARCHITECTURAL ENGINEERING AFP
FEBURARY 28, 2022 DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS
ATTACHMENT "A"
ON-CALL ARCHITECTURAL ENGINEERING RFP
CONSULTANT EVALUATION SUMMARY
PROPOSAL EVALUATION
Completeness of
[TOTAL (MAX OUT OF 100
Response Quifications and Experience Organization and Approach Scope of Services [References Local Pasadena Business
RESPONSIVE PROPOSERS (POINTS)
Gonzalez Goodale Architects
dba GGA PASS 30 22 26
Gruen Associates PASS 5 87
28 25 nies
3 85
HH Fremer Architects, Inc. PASS 26 27 81
Onyx Architects, inc. PASS 32 21 5
Dahlin Group, Inc. PASS 82
30 IDS Group, inc. 80
PASS 25 25 24
CM Peck Inc., dba Peck 78
Architecture Structural Civi PASS 20 23
5 76
Dewberry Architects Inc. PASS 19 24
Johnson Favaro, LLP PASS 80
22 28
MAX POINTS EACH CRITERIA 78
PASS/FAIL 25 30
5 100
INTERVIEW EVALUATION
Completeness of [TOTAL (MAX OUT OF 100
Response Qualifications and Experience Organization and Approach Local Pasadena Business RESPONSIVE PROPOSERS [POINTS)
Gonzalez Goodale Architects
dba GGA PASS 31
Gruen Associates 92
PASS 28
HH Fremer Architects, Inc. 86
PASS
Onyx Architects, Inc. PASS 1 85
Dahlin Group, Inc. 82
PASS
IDS Group, Inc. PASS 80
24 0 79
CM Peck Inc., dba Peck
Architecture Structural Civil PASS 23 24
Dewberry Architects Inc. 5
PASS
Johnson Favaro, UP PASS
MAX POINTS EACH CRITERIA PASS/FAIL 35
30 FINAL EVALUATION
completeness of
TOTAL (MAX OUT OF 200
Response Qualifications and Experience Organization and Approach Scope of Services References Local Pasadena Business POINTS)
RESPONSIVE PROPOSERS
Gonzalez Goodale Architects
PASS 60
i ruen Associate PASS 10
56 H Fremer Architects, in [PASS 54
Onyx Architects, Inc. PASS 64
Dahlin Group, Inc. PASS 59
IDS Group, Inc. PASS 52
CM Peck Inc., dba Peck
Architecture Structural Civil PASS 47
Dewberry Architects Inc PASS 152
48 Johnson Favaro, LLP PASS 45 990 8
MAX POINTS PER CRITERIA PASS/FAIL 70