ATTACHMENT A
Preparation of Environmental Document and Professional Design Services for the Central Library Seismic Retrofit and Renovations Project
CONSULTANT SCORING AND RANKING
PROPOSAL EVALUATION
RESPONSIVE PROPOSERS
PROPOSAL EVALUATION SCORE
(100 POINTS MAXIMUM)
Gruen Associates87.3
Architectural Resources Group84.0
KFA Architecture LLP82.3
Pfeiffer - Perkins Eastman81.0
Skidmore, Owings & Merrill LLP76.3
Dewberry Architects Inc.73.8
ONYX Architects, Inc.71.7
Richard Yen & Associates62.3
INTERVIEW EVALUATION
SHORTLISTED PROPOSERS
INTERVIEW EVALUATION SCORE
(100 POINTS MAXIMUM)
Gruen Associates93.3
KFA Architecture LLP83.8
Architectural Resources Group82.2
Pfeiffer - Perkins Eastman78.7
FINAL EVALUATION
SHORTLISTED PROPOSERS
WRITTEN PROPSAL + INTERVIEW FINAL SCORE
(200 POINTS MAXIMUM)
Gruen Associates180.6
Architectural Resources Group166.2
KFA Architecture LLP166.1
Pfeiffer - Perkins Eastman159.7