PROPOSAL EVALUATION
ATTACHMENT A
CONSULTANT SCORING AND RANKING
Proposer's
Name
Experience/
References
20 points
Organization/
Qualifications
20 Points
Proposed
Approach
30 Points
Financial
Strength
5 Points
Safety
Record
5 Points
Local
Pasadena
Business
5 Points
Smaller
Micro-
Business
5 Points
CMAR
Price
Proposal
10 Points
Total
Score
(Max Score
=100
Points)
PCL
Construction
Services, Inc.
19.418.829.455009.987.5
dark
Construction
Group-CA,
LP
19.219.628.654009.986.3
Charles
Pankow
Builders
16.41724.253501080.6
Swinerton
Builders
16.616.421.255001074.2
INTERVIEW EVALUATION
Proposer's NameTotal Score
(Max Score = 50 Points)
PCL Construction Services, Inc.49.2
dark Construction Group - CA, LP44.2
Charles Pankow Builders31.8
Swinerton Builders35.4
FINAL EVALUATION
Proposer's NameProposal Evaluation
(Max Score = 100 Points)
Interview
(Max Score = 50 Points)
Total Score
(Max Score =150 Points)
PCL Construction Services,
Inc.
87.549.2136.7
dark Construction Group -
CA,LP
86.344.2130.5
Charles Pankow Builders80.631.8112.4
Swinerton Builders74.235.4109.6