EVALUATION TABULATION
RFPN0.2026-RFP-0186
Broker Services Employee Benefits Plans
ATTACHMENT A
VENDOR SCORES BY EVALUATION CRITERIA
Vendor
Keenan &
Associates
Experience Proposed Solution References
Points Based Points Based Points Based
65 Points (65%) 15 Points (15%) 5 Points (5%)
6213.34.3
Cost Proposal Local Pasadena
Reward Low Cost Business
5 Points (5%) Pass / Fail
5 Points (5%)
2.50 Small or Micro-
Business
Pass/Fail
5 Points (5%)
0 Total Score
(Max Score 100)
82.15 Alliant57.711.33.71.85079.48
USI Insurance I 54.3
Services LLC
Marsh & I 48
McLennanAgency
LLC
10.7 8
3.3 3
3.2 5
0 0
0 0
71.51 64