ATTACHMENT A
CONSULTANT SCORING AND RANKING
PROPOSAL EVALUATION
Proposer's
Name
Experience
/
References
20 points
Organization/
Qualifications
20 Points
Project
Approach
30 Points
FinancialStrength
5 Points
Safety
Record5 Points
Local
Pasadena
Business
5 Points
Small or
MicroBusiness
5 Points
CMAR
Price
Proposal
10 Points
Total
Score
(Max
Score =
100
Points)
PCL
ConstructionServices, Inc.
18.1 18.8 28.4 5 4.7 0 0 3.6 78.5
Charles Pankow
Builders Ltd.
15.2 15.9 25.8 5 3.4 5 0 3.1 73.4
HenselPhelps 16.3 18.2 27.2 5 5 0 0 0.2 71.9
W.E. O'Neil
Construction
16.2 13.6 20.2 5 4.4 0 0 10 69.4
BalfourBeatty
Construction,
LLC.
16.2 16.4 24.9 5 3 0 0 3.5 69.0
INTERVIEW EVALUATION
Proposer's Name Total Score (Max Score = 50 Points)
PCL Construction Services, Inc. 48.5HenselPhelps 44.0BalfourBeatty Construction, LLC. 39.5Charles Pankow Builders Ltd. 39.1W.E.O'Neit Construction 33.0
FINAL EVALUATION
Proposer's Name Proposal Evaluation (Max Score =100 Points) Interview (Max Score = 50 Points) Total Score (Max Score =150 Points) PCL Construction Services, Inc. 78.5 48.5 127HenselPhelps 71.9 44.0 115.9Charles Pankow Builders 73.4 39.1 112.5 Balfour Beatty Construction, LLC. 69.0 39.5 108.5
W.E.O'Neil Construction 69.4 33.0 102.4