PINOLE PLANNING COMMISSION
MEETING AGENDA
November 9, 2026
7:00 PM
Attend in Person: PINOLE CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS - 2131 PEAR STREET OR
Attend VIA ZOOM TELECONFERENCE – Details provided below How to Submit Public Comments:
In Person:
Attend meeting at the Pinole City Council Chambers, fill out a yellow public comment card and submit it to the City Clerk.
Via Zoom:
Members of the public may submit a live remote public comment via Zoom video conferencing. Download the Zoom mobile app from the Apple Appstore or Google Play. If you are using a desktop computer, you can test your connection to Zoom by clicking here. Zoom also allows you to join the meeting by phone.
From a PC, Mac, iPad, iPhone or Android:
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/86505375301
Webinar ID: 865 0537 5301
By phone: +1 (669) 900-6833 or +1 (253) 215-8782 or +1 (346) 248-7799 • Speakers will be asked to provide their name and city of residence, although providing this is not required for participation.
• Each speaker will be afforded up to 5 minutes to speak • Speakers will be muted until their opportunity to provide public comment.
When the Chair opens the comment period for the item you wish to speak on, please use the “raise hand” feature (or press *9 if connecting via telephone) which will alert staff that you have a comment to provide and press *6 to unmute. To comment with your video enabled, please let the City Clerk know you would like to turn your camera on once you are called to speak.
Written Comments:
Please submit public comments to Planning Staff before the meeting via email to [email protected].
Please include your full name, city of residence and agenda item you are commenting on.
Planning Commission
Agenda - November 9, 2026
OTHER WAYS TO WATCH THE MEETING
LIVE ON CHANNEL 30 and CHANNEL 1070. Meetings are broadcast again the following week on channels 30 and 1070 (previously channel 26). The Pinole Community TV program schedule is published on the City’s website at www.Pinole.gov/PCTV
VIDEO-STREAMED LIVE ON THE CITY’S WEBSITE, www.Pinole.gov/PCTV. Meeting videos remain archived on the site for five (5) years. Pinole Community TV can also be streamed live from Roku, Apple TV, or Amazon Fire.
If none of these options are available to you, or you need assistance with public comment, please contact Planning Staff at (510) 724-8912 or [email protected].
Americans With Disabilities Act: In compliance with the Americans With Disabilities Act of 1990, if you need special assistance to participate in a City Meeting or you need a copy of the agenda, or the agenda packet in an appropriate alternative format, please contact the City Clerk’s Office at (510) 724-8928. Notification at least 48 hours prior to the meeting or time when services are needed will assist the City staff in assuring that reasonable arrangements can be made to provide accessibility to the meeting or service.
Note: Staff reports are available for inspection on the City Website at www.pinole.gov. You may also contact the City Clerk via e-mail at [email protected].
CITIZEN PARTICIPATION:
Persons wishing to speak on an item listed on the Agenda may do so when the Chair asks for comments in favor of or in opposition to the item under consideration. After all of those persons wishing to speak have done so, the hearing will be closed and the matter will be discussed amongst the Commission prior to rendering a decision.
Any person may appeal an action of the Planning Commission or of the Planning Manager by filing an appeal with the City Clerk, in writing, within ten (10) days of such action. Following a Public Hearing, the City Council may act to confirm, modify or reverse the action of the Planning Commission and the Planning Commission may act to confirm, modify, or reverse the action of the Planning Manager. The cost to appeal a decision is $500 and a minimum $2,500 deposit fee.
Note: If you challenge a decision of the Commission regarding a project in court, you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing or in writing delivered to the City of Pinole at, or prior to, the public hearing.
Ralph M. Brown Act. Gov. Code § 54950. In enacting this chapter, the Legislature finds and declares that the public commissions, boards and councils and the other public agencies in this State exist to aid in the conduct of the people's business. It is the intent of the law that their actions be taken openly and that their deliberations be conducted openly. The people of this State do not yield their sovereignty to the agencies, which serve them. The people, in delegating authority, do not give their public servants the right to decide what is good for the people to know and what is not good for them to know. The people insist on remaining informed so that they may retain control over the instruments they have created.
Planning Commission
Agenda - November 9, 2026
A. CALL TO ORDER
B. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
C. LAND ACKNOWLEDGMENT
Before we begin, we would like to acknowledge the Ohlone people, who are the traditional custodians of this land. We pay our respects to the Ohlone elders, past, present, and future, who call this place, Ohlone Land, the land that Pinole sits upon, their home. We are proud to continue their tradition of coming together and growing as a community. We thank the Ohlone community for their stewardship and support, and we look forward to strengthening our ties as we continue our relationship of mutual respect and understanding.
D. ROLL CALL
E. CITIZENS TO BE HEARD
The public may address the Planning Commission on items that are within its jurisdiction and not otherwise listed on the agenda. Planning Commissioners may discuss the matter brought to their attention, but by State law (Ralph M. Brown Act), action must be deferred to a future meeting. Time allowed: four (4) minutes each.
F. MEETING MINUTES:
1. Planning Commission Meeting Minutes for August 10, 2026 G. OLD BUSINESS
H. NEW BUSINESS
1. Housing Asset Fund Policy Guidebook
I. PUBLIC HEARINGS
At the beginning of an item, the Chair will read the description of that item as stated on the Agenda. The City Staff will then give a brief presentation of the proposed project. The Commission may then ask Staff questions about the item.
For those items listed as Public Hearings, the Chair will open the public hearing and ask the applicant if they wish to make a presentation. Those persons in favor of the project will then be given an opportunity to speak followed by those who are opposed to the project. The applicant will then be given an opportunity for rebuttal.
The Public Hearing will then be closed and the Commission may discuss the item amongst themselves and ask questions of Staff. The Commission will then vote to approve, deny, approve in a modified form, or continue the matter to a later date for a decision. The Chair will announce the Commission's decision and advise the audience of the appeal procedure.
Note: No Public Hearings will begin after 11:00 p.m. Items still remaining on the agenda after 11:00 p.m. will be held over to the next meeting.
1. Public Hearing To Consider Recommendations To The City Council Regarding Amendments To Chapter 17.32 (Affordable Housing Requirements) And Adoption Of An Inclusionary Housing In-Lieu Fee Schedule
J. CITY PLANNER'S/COMMISSIONER'S REPORT
K. COMMUNICATIONS
Planning Commission
Agenda - November 9, 2026
L. CITIZENS TO BE HEARD (CONTINTINUED FROM ITEM E)
Open only to members of the public who did not speak under the first Citizens to Be Heard Agenda Item. The public may address the Planning Commission on items that are within its jurisdiction and not otherwise listed on the agenda. Planning Commissioners may discuss the matter brought to their attention, but by State law (Ralph M. Brown Act), action must be deferred to a future meeting. Time allowed: four (4) minutes each.
M. NEXT MEETING(S)
1. Planning Commission Regular Meeting on November 23, 2026 at 7:00PM N. ADJOURNMENT
I hereby certify under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing Agenda was posted on the bulletin board at the main entrance of Pinole City Hall, 2131 Pear Street Pinole, CA, and on the City’s website, not less than 72 hours prior to the meeting date set forth on this agenda. _______________________
David Hanham
Planning Manager
POSTED: _______
1 August 10, 2026
1 DRAFT
2 3 MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING
4 PINOLE PLANNING COMMISSION
5 6 August 10, 2026
7 8 THIS MEETING WAS HELD IN A HYBRID FORMAT
9 BOTH IN-PERSON AND ZOOM TELECONFERENCE
10 11
12 A. CALL TO ORDER: 7:00 p.m.
13 14 B. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
15 16 C. LAND ACKNOWLEDGEMENT: Before we begin, we would like to acknowledge the 17 Ohlone people, who are the traditional custodians of this land. We pay our respects to 18 the Ohlone elders, past, present and future, who call this place, Ohlone Land, the land 19 that Pinole sits upon, their home. We are proud to continue their tradition of coming 20 together and growing as a community. We thank the Ohlone community for their 21 stewardship and support, and we look forward to strengthening our ties as we continue 22 our relationship of mutual respect and understanding. 23 24 D. ROLL CALL
25 26 Commissioners Present: Bender, Huey, Lam-Julian*, Martinez, Menis, Vice-27 Chairperson Uch, and Chairperson Sandoval 28 *Arrived after Roll Call
29 30 Commissioners Absent: None
31 32 Staff Present: David Hanham, Planning Manager
33 Justin Shiu, Associate Planner
34 35 Commissioner Menis reported on his ex-parté communications to his email list about the 36 topics on the meeting agenda.
37 38 E. CITIZENS TO BE HEARD
39 40 There were no comments from the public.
41 42 F. MEETING MINUTES
43 44 1. Planning Commission Meeting Minutes for July 13, 2026 45 46 MOTION with a Roll Call vote to approve the Planning Commission Meeting Minutes for July 47 13, 2026, as shown.
48 49 MOTION: Sandoval SECONDED: Menis APPROVED: 6-0-
50 1
F.1.
2 August 10, 2026
1 ABSENT: Lam-Julian
2 G. PUBLIC HEARINGS
3 4 1. Pinole Shores II Entitlements Extension
5 6 Planning Manager David Hanham provided a PowerPoint presentation for the Pinole 7 Shores II Entitlements Extension. He recommended the Planning Commission conduct a 8 public hearing and adopt Resolution 26-08, approving an extension through June 10, 9 2027, for entitlements adopted via Resolution 24-02 for the Pinole Shores II development 10 project located at 850 San Pablo Avenue (APN 402-230-024). 11 12 Responding to questions from the Planning Commission, Mr. Hanham clarified the 13 following:
14 15 • The Disposition and Development Agreement (DDA) was between the City of 16 Pinole and GRP Shores, LLC. Once the entitlements were extended, the 17 applicants could close on the property and complete the DDA. Staff acknowledged 18 there had been some amendments to the DDA. Staff also clarified the DDA 19 identified GRP Shores, LLC, (legal entity responsible for the project) while 20 Resolution 26-08 identified OneCore Global, Inc. as the Applicant, the company 21 doing the entitlements. (Bender)
22 23 • The DDA identified the value of the property at $3 million plus. When the City’s 24 Redevelopment Agency closed, the City transferred all of the properties within the 25 Redevelopment Agency into the City of Pinole. (Bender) 26 27 • The applicant had the ability to appeal the decision of the Planning Commission 28 on the entitlement extension request to the City Council. The Planning 29 Commission was the only governing body to consider the request to extend the 30 entitlements. The financial aspects of the project as contained in the DDA, had 31 been previously addressed by the City Council and the applicant. The request 32 before the Planning Commission was only the extension of the entitlements 33 approved in 2024. (Martinez)
34 35 • The reference to Safeway in the Analysis of Request for Extension, as outlined in 36 the first paragraph under the same heading and as shown on Page 21 of 130 of 37 the agenda packet, had been included in error and should be stricken. Staff 38 acknowledged a request for the item to be delayed to allow staff the opportunity to 39 review the staff report and make any corrections in the analysis, and also given 40 the volume of information to be reviewed more time for the Planning Commission 41 to digest the information. (Martinez)
42 43 • Staff reiterated the Planning Commission was not being asked to make any 44 recommendations based on the financial impacts of the project but consider the 45 request to extend the entitlements based on land use and compliance with the 46 required findings. (Chairperson Sandoval)
47 48
49
3 August 10, 2026
1 2 • Acknowledged concern with the continued delays with the project, resulting in the 3 City not getting funding, suggestion the applicant should have bumped up their 4 timelines for the $3 million project and acknowledged a request to slow the project 5 down since there was a lack of clarity with the details of the DDA, such as when 6 the City would receive payment. (Martinez)
7 8 • Again, acknowledging concerns with the continued delays with the project and 9 other projects in the City, and concern that some of the community character and 10 economic development elements of the General Plan had not been satisfied, as 11 an example, there had been no discussion about a warehouse use which did not 12 fit the area, no end-user had been identified and the balance of jobs and provision 13 of basic goods and services was unknown. Acknowledged an inquiry whether the 14 City was considering strategic growth in this area of Pinole, which was the last 15 vista from the San Francisco Bay Trail and concern the City may be squandering 16 the parcel. Acknowledged inquiries whether the City considered mixed use for the 17 property for a community mixed use space and concern with the adequacy of time 18 to review the volume of information related to the project before making a decision. 19 Further acknowledged concern the General Plan policies staff outlined in the staff 20 report may not fit the subject project and concern the City may be sacrificing 21 community character at the expense of ensuring a pre-determined deal. (Lam-22 Julian) 23 24 • Reiterated the process the applicant must go through to request an extension of 25 entitlements for one-year as outlined in the August 10, 2026 staff report and the 26 PowerPoint presentation. (Huey)
27 28 • Clarified there was nothing in the application to request an extension of 29 entitlements that required an applicant to identify how they would meet the new 30 timeline. The applicant was only required to submit a written request for the 31 extension for existing entitlements, which in this case had been approved in 2024. 32 As noted in the staff report, the applicant was requesting the extension due to 33 impacts from the COVID-19 pandemic, increasing construction costs, international 34 supply chain issues and a changing retail landscape. (Huey) 35 36 • Clarified the applicant had secured a new engineer and architect who were working 37 on plans. (Huey)
38 39 • Pursuant to Attachment A, Resolution 26-08, and as noted in the fifth WHEREAS 40 clause, additional delays in the project had been caused by comments from the 41 Contra Costa County Fire Protection District (CCCFPD), also known as Con Fire, 42 as well as the replacement of the original architect and engineer for the project. If 43 the requested extension was approved by the Planning Commission, 44 acknowledged a request to include a detailed explanation for the delays to ensure 45 consistency, which could be added to the referenced WHEREAS clause. (Huey) 46 47 • Confirmed the Planning Commission had been provided a corrected DDA, 48 identified as Item G1. Supplemental Item, DDA by and between the City of Pinole 49 and GRP Shores, LLC, dated May 9, 2022. (Menis)
4 August 10, 2026
1 2 • A typographical error was identified on Page 21 of 130 of the agenda packet; the 3 last sentence of the second paragraph under Analysis of Request for Extension, 4 which should be corrected to read: These related impacts, as well as supply chain 5 disruptions and/or difficulty with financing. Clarified Con Fire had suggested some 6 architectural changes which were not before the Planning Commission, although 7 staff clarified the elevations would remain the same but types of materials to be 8 used for fire protection for the interior of the building had changed. There would 9 be no changes to the exterior of the building as part of the approved 2024 plans. 10 (Menis)
11 12 • Attachment A, Resolution 26-08, the eighth WHEREAS clause reads: WHEREAS, 13 no further environmental review is necessary for the project since the scope of the 14 project has not changed or been altered since the previous adoption of the Notice 15 of Exemption. Staff clarified Con Fire’s request for interior changes related to fire 16 proofing would not change the scope, property square footage, or result in changes 17 to parking, added pavement or size of the building, and this exemption was still 18 relevant. (Menis)
19 20 • Clarified Process and Procedures, Section 17.10.100 (C) of the Pinole Municipal 21 Code (PMC) (2), Conditions, which reads: The permit, as extended, may be 22 conditioned to comply with any development standards that may have been 23 enacted since the permit was initially approved. Pursuant to the Environmental 24 Justice Element from January 2026, Action EJ4.4.3, as shown on Page 52 of the 25 Environmental Justice Element, reads: Ensure that future improvements of a City 26 that have an impact on the impacted community will be mitigated to a less than 27 significant impact and will not disproportionately produce negative impacts such 28 as an increase in pollution exposure, net loss of affordable housing or 29 displacement of residents. Whether there would be an increase in environmental 30 or pollution impacts given there would be diesel trucks delivering to the site, staff 31 clarified such impacts had been reviewed as part of the environmental review of 32 the original project. No changes were being proposed to the original project. 33 There were no physical changes proposed to the building or increases proposed 34 in the use of the building. Pursuant to Section 17.10.100 (C), as written, the 35 Planning Commission may impose additional conditions on the permit as extended 36 that comply with any development standards that may have been enacted since 37 the permit was initially approved. (Menis)
38 39 • Clarified Pages 13 through 15 of 67, specifically Section 4.6, Developer’s Post-40 Closing Obligations, (1) and Section 4.9.1 “Hazardous Material” of the DDA, as 41 defined, with staff clarifying commercial uses developed as part of the property 42 would not nullify the restrictions in these sections, as outlined, but with staff 43 required to provide further clarification after conferring with the City Attorney. 44 (Menis)
45 46 • Page 21 of 67 of the DDA, Section 8.2 Holder Not Obligated to Construct, was 47 highlighted and clarified. (Menis)
48 49
5 August 10, 2026
1 2 • The applicant would have to clarify whether or not they were in discussions with 3 any tenant(s). Staff understood the applicant had been working with a couple of 4 end-users but was unaware of the status. (Menis)
5 6 • If the request for an extension of the entitlements was granted by the Planning 7 Commission and if the applicant did not exercise the entitlements, it was possible 8 the property could potentially revert back to the City; but staff would have to refer 9 to the City Attorney and the DDA for clarification. In the event the entitlements 10 were not exercised, the entitlements would go away in 2027, and if the applicant 11 wanted to move forward with a project, it would require the applicant to go through 12 the entire process all over again, with new environmental reviews and the like. 13 Clarified the applicant had already been granted two of three available extensions. 14 In the event the Planning Commission did not agree to the extension and the 15 applicant appealed and still nothing happened with the development the 16 entitlement would go away. The DDA would detail what would happen if the 17 entitlements were not incurred and actions not performed pursuant to the contract. 18 (Vice-Chairperson Uch)
19 20 • In terms of whether or not there had been any progress to date to meet the timeline, 21 staff was aware the applicant had hired an engineer and architect, submitted a 22 potential schedule to staff for things to be accomplished and for building permits 23 to be issued in 2027, although the applicant was present via Zoom to provide 24 clarification. (Chairperson Sandoval)
25 26 PUBLIC HEARING OPENED
27 28 Hector Vinas, Manager, Pinole Shores II, representing OneCore Global, Inc., 29 acknowledged the frustration over the timing and explained at the beginning when the 30 applicant started to work on the property with the City of Pinole they found out through 31 running the title that there was no access to the property. When the City took the title back 32 from the Panattoni Development Group, it failed to obtain access from the Phase 1 33 property now owned by an association of condominiums. That process took over three 34 years to negotiate an easement allowing the right to access the property. 35 36 At that time, OneCore Global Inc. started the entitlement process when the economy was 37 different. The company went through one set of entitlements, and as they spoke with 38 various end-users there was more interest in having one building. As a result, the 39 entitlements were revised and the applicant went back for approvals for one building. 40 OneCore Global Inc. was going to joint venture the project with the Rockefeller Group from 41 New York for the one building. An agreement was signed but they ran into the issue with 42 Con Fire and with the East Bay Municipal Utility District (EBMUD), which had conducted 43 a computer analysis that determined under the worst conditions there was insufficient fire 44 flow to meet the new requirements from Con Fire, which were twice as restrictive as the 45 City requirements under which the original plans had been designed. When the project 46 started, the City of Pinole was handling the fire requirements and somewhere in the middle 47 of the process, Con Fire took over from Pinole. At that point, it took over a year to hire a 48 Fire Engineer, who presented various mitigations to Con Fire that were sent back for 49 comments, which comments were weeks in the making, ultimately taking over a year to 50 reach a mitigation agreement with Con Fire in February 2026.
6 August 10, 2026
1 Mr. Vinas explained at that point Rockefeller Group purchased other properties in the Bay 2 Area and allocated their funds. The applicant did not have a tenant and OneCore Global 3 Inc. then decided to go ahead and do the project themselves, which they had done for 4 larger projects in the City of Richmond. A project schedule had been provided to City staff 5 and they hired an architect and engineer to work on the project. He also understood if the 6 request for extension of the entitlements was not granted by the Planning Commission, it 7 did not mean the DDA would be void since the applicant would still have the right to 8 resubmit for another approval and continue the process. 9 10 Commissioner Martinez asked whether the fees to be paid during the time of the three 11 years of delays had been paid by OneCore Global Inc. or incurred by the City of Pinole. 12 13 Mr. Vinas stated OneCore Global Inc. paid fees for professionals and invested over 14 $600,000 on the project to date.
15 16 Mr. Hanham clarified, when asked, he was unaware of the costs to the City of Pinole to 17 date for the project.
18 19 Commissioner Lam-Julian understood the challenges with the current market related to 20 wholesale distribution and building supplies. She asked what the applicant would do to fill 21 the building if the entitlements were granted for the one building warehouse, particularly 22 with existing warehouses currently sitting empty in Pinole and in neighboring communities. 23 24 Mr. Vinas commented on the differences between existing older buildings that did not meet 25 the requirements of a modern/new tenant. He explained that most of the time in the 26 warehouse business tenants were looking for something that was either available or close 27 to being immediately available. OneCore Global Inc. had looked at some end-users who 28 were interested in delivery of the space in a few months but who ultimately leased space 29 in the City of Richmond. OneCore Global Inc. had been involved in the building of a 30 250,000 square foot warehouse in the City of Richmond, which had been leased to 31 Amazon three months after completion. He noted it was not unusual to build a warehouse 32 to spec and have a tenant take it at that point.
33 34 Commissioner Huey asked Mr. Vinas what would change this time around if the 35 entitlements were extended and what approach would be taken to ensure the project met 36 the timeline.
37 38 Mr. Vinas reiterated the project had not moved forward given that the fire design for the 39 project was not defined and he highlighted the types of materials required pursuant to the 40 fire codes for Types 1, 2 and 3 buildings and various subcategories. Until the applicant 41 had received the final definition from Con Fire in February/March 2026, they could not 42 move forward until they had clarification what needed to be done. Currently, they did not 43 have that obstacle since Con Fire approved the mitigation and provided specific direction 44 on how it wanted the building to be designed from a fire perspective. 45 46 Commissioner Huey commented the staff report analysis on the delays for the project had 47 been broad when there was a narrower issue that should have been addressed in the staff 48 report.
49
7 August 10, 2026
1 Commissioner Menis referenced Attachment D, Planning Response Letter received 2 March 21, 2024, Page 107 of 130 of the agenda packet, which noted: CD-12 Page C3.02 3 - Should show the following: 1. The plan should show the proposed line size needed for 4 this project. This item was discussed and agreed that this level of detail is inappropriate 5 for Preliminary Design Plans, during our zoom meeting with Planning Manager on Feb. 6 27, 2024. Had the information been provided correctly, he asked if the issues the applicant 7 faced with Con Fire would have been dealt with before the entitlement clock started. 8 9 Mr. Vinas clarified again the issue with Con Fire started when EBMUD changed the way 10 it calculated fire flow, which requirements had been revised after the Los Angeles fires, 11 and when EBMUD decided to use an algorithmic system of a worst-case scenario taking 12 into account multiple large fires throughout the County when water demands were high, 13 making the fire flow calculation more restrictive. Along with the changes from the City 14 code to the Con Fire code, the changes were twice as restrictive. Designing the pipe size 15 would not have changed anything since the pipes were available from EBMUD. 16 17 Commissioner Menis asked why the applicant was not able to provide updated plans to 18 the Planning Commission for review to ensure there were no changed circumstances, 19 particularly with a new engineer and architect, and his understanding now there would be 20 significant interior changes made.
21 22 Mr. Vinas clarified the exterior design, the look and feel of the building would remain the 23 same and the mechanical and structural components of the building had not changed. He 24 reiterated the delays in the project were due to the Con Fire requirements which took over 25 a year. He also noted the applicant had explored putting in additional water tanks, getting 26 EBMUD to provide an additional water main extension, and there were a lot of different 27 options that could have changed the building but they had not gone much further than 28 that. The plans would remain the same with some minor exceptions. The elevations 29 would remain the same. Additional plans could be provided fairly quickly, but he was 30 unaware that revised plans needed to be provided.
31 32 Commissioner Menis asked about the likelihood the applicant could pull building permits 33 by the end of the extension since this was the last extension that could be granted if 34 approved by the Planning Commission.
35 36 Mr. Vinas stated he did not expect any additional hurdles, but there was some work that 37 remained to be done on the main road, the bus stop may need to change and was under 38 a different jurisdiction and there were things that were not 100 percent under the 39 applicant’s or the City’s control. He emphasized the City had been helpful in dealing with 40 Con Fire, and suggested they had a 75 to 80 percent chance to meet the target timeline 41 with the goal of meeting it 100 percent.
42 43 Chairperson Sandoval asked about the prospective tenants the applicant had been in 44 discussions for the building.
45 46 Mr. Vinas reiterated they had spoken with a couple of tenants but had nothing promising 47 currently. Again, two tenants had seriously looked at the property but the timing was the 48 greatest issue and one tenant involved laundry service for hospitals and the other was an 49 auto parts supplier.
50
8 August 10, 2026
1 PUBLIC HEARING CLOSED
2 3 Commissioner Bender referenced Page 32 of the DDA which was signed by the applicant 4 and a number of City officials past and present. He stated he was not concerned with the 5 legality of the document, which staff confirmed had been recorded. 6 7 Commissioner Bender sympathized with the hurdles the applicant had to go through. As 8 a retired architect, he was aware fire departments could slow a project, were oftentimes 9 non-responsive and oftentimes a Fire Protection Engineer was required as a consultant. 10 He stated he had voted against the project in the second go around and had been more 11 comfortable when it had been a two-building scenario due to the potential diesel pollution 12 and large trucks the facility was designed for (18-wheelers), which would further 13 deteriorate San Pablo Avenue. He heard nothing at this time to change his mind. He 14 added the Environmental Justice Element had identified the most impacted 15 neighborhoods as those located immediately west of the facility. As part of the prior review 16 of the project, some analysis had been provided about pollution and sources of pollution, 17 and he found it strange it had identified I-80 and not San Pablo Avenue, which was a relief 18 valve for I-80. He remained bothered by the project for those reasons and pointed out 19 construction costs were not going down but would continue to increase. Also, there was 20 a lot of warehouse distribution space in the City of Richmond sitting empty, with two 21 buildings built within the last two years, with little traffic, and other spaces had become 22 available. While the proposed building may be different than those buildings since it would 23 sit higher, he remained concerned with the impacts, particularly diesel trucks on City 24 streets.
25 26 Commissioner Martinez remained concerned with the continual delays and revenue not 27 being realized by the City. He could not in good conscience provide another extension for 28 the project. He suggested if the Project Manager for the project knew entitlements were 29 about to go away he should have had the best engineer and architect teams mandated 30 via contracts to deliver by the timelines. The applicant had requested extensions since 31 2019, without putting 50 or 75 percent down. He would like to know whether the City had 32 received any money for the project and emphasized the City of Pinole was facing a 33 significant cost to repair its roads, with San Pablo Avenue a difficult road to drive. If the 34 applicant could not bring in the revenue and stick to the deadlines, he could not approve 35 another extension. He added he had been a member of the Planning Commission in 2024 36 when the last extension was requested, and based on the financial standpoint, it made it 37 difficult for him to support an extension.
38 39 Commissioner Lam-Julian, also a member of the Planning Commission in 2024, was 40 frustrated the parcel would be a warehouse since it was one of the last pieces of land the 41 City had to do something with. While the design was beautiful and acknowledging the 42 reasons for the delay, as a community member and looking at the parcel, which was close 43 to the San Francisco Bay Trail and could be a mixed use other than a warehouse, she did 44 not want to see the City miss out on building something for the community and something 45 that brought revenue to the City.
46 47 Commissioner Lam-Julian reported she had spoken to members of the community who 48 lived near the area and who were not excited about this project. 49
9 August 10, 2026
1 Many were working members of the community who were challenged to participate and 2 provide public comment. Commissioner Lam-Julian was not comfortable with the project 3 or approving another extension and would like to see the City think outside the box and 4 consider other options.
5 6 Commissioner Huey shared Commissioner Bender’s concerns with the potential 7 environmental and health impacts. The project had already been entitled when she joined 8 the Planning Commission and she had a hard time understanding the factors at play for 9 the request for an extension the third time around. She suggested the Planning 10 Commission consider a progress report request or check in since the last extension was 11 approved, which should be mandated when an applicant reached a third extension 12 request. While she understood the concerns with the project and was sympathetic to the 13 reasons for delays, at this time she could go one way or another for the project. 14 15 Commissioner Menis asked whether it would be possible to place a condition on the 16 project based on Environmental Justice Actions, EJ 2.4.9, EJ 2.4.6 and EJ 4.4.3. He 17 asked if a condition could be structured to limit the number of diesel trucks or to prohibit 18 the use of diesel trucks and require the use of light or electric trucks, while also allowing 19 the project to remain financially feasible and remain within the one-year time line. 20 21 Mr. Hanham confirmed if that was something the Planning Commission wanted to do, staff 22 could craft new conditions and the application could be continued. Staff could also get 23 more information on the DDA and possibly have the City Attorney present to provide 24 clarification. The item could be continued to a date certain and since the applicant had 25 applied for the extension prior to the expiration date, it would not impact the project until 26 the Planning Commission took final action. He confirmed whether the project was 27 continued or not the deadline for the entitlements remained June 10, 2027. 28 29 Vice-Chairperson Uch recalled when he first joined the Planning Commission, he was 30 pleased to see the City was seeing some Light Industrial development, but now and over 31 time and hearing the feedback from other Commissioners, the warehouse industry was 32 challenged, jobs were not well-paying blue-collar jobs and there were concerns with 33 impacts as a result of the current federal Administration, with most warehouses/offices 34 sitting empty. Even if the use was an active use, there were pollution issues and 35 technology was not there yet for medium or heavy trucks, which raised other issues. He 36 also recognized the City’s crumbling infrastructure. Even if the entitlements were 37 extended, there was no guarantee the project would happen and there could be other 38 opportunities. He would like to see the City have a more diverse economy, not just 39 warehouse spaces, and possibly Light Industrial uses with some sort of manufacturing. 40 He had no confidence in the project given the testimony. 41 42 Chairperson Sandoval concurred that the project had been inherited and he was not happy 43 with another warehouse in the City. He also recognized Contra Costa County was 44 experiencing an empty warehouse problem. He would like to have confidence a good 45 tenant would activate the space, but was not entirely confident it would be quickly filled 46 and the project may not be able to be completed. He also shared the concerns with the 47 environmental impacts, and impacts to the City’s roads from large diesel trucks. He 48 suggested there would be few community benefits beyond a warehouse and suggested 49 the community deserved better. He would like to see something else and could not 50 support the item.
10 August 10, 2026
1 Commissioner Menis offered a motion, seconded by Commissioner Huey to continue 2 Pinole Shores II Entitlements Extension to the next meeting of the Planning Commission. 3 4 MOTION to continue Pinole Shores II Entitlements Extension to the next meeting of the 5 Planning Commission.
6 7 MOTION: Menis SECONDED: Huey FAILED: 2-5
8 NOES: Martinez, Lam-Julian, Bender, Uch, Sandoval
9 10 Chairperson Sandoval referenced Page 21 of 130 of the agenda packet, 4. Process and 11 Procedures, Section 17.10.100 of the PMC, 3. Permit Findings, which stated: The 12 extension may be granted only when the designated approving authority finds that the 13 original permit findings can be made and there are no changed circumstances or there 14 has been diligent pursuit to exercise the permit that warrants such an extension. In his 15 opinion, the finding had not been met.
16 17 Commissioner Menis also spoke to the same finding, and asked whether staff was of the 18 opinion the applicant had been in diligent pursuit to exercise the permit that warrants such 19 an extension.
20 21 Mr. Hanham noted staff had recommended approval of the entitlement extension and 22 found that the applicant had met the finding.
23 24 Chairperson Sandoval pointed out the Planning Commission as the approving body may 25 reject the staff recommendation.
26 27 Commissioner Huey asked for clarification if the Planning Commisision rejected the 28 entitlement extension and the decision of the Planning Commission was appealed to the 29 City Council. She asked if the City Council approved the request whether that would mean 30 the Planning Commission may not impose additional conditions. 31 32 Mr. Hanham confirmed if the Planning Commisision rejected the entitlement extension 33 and the decision of the Planning Commission was appealed to the City Council and the 34 City Council approved the request; the project would not come back to the Planning 35 Commission for additional consideration or conditions. 36 37 Commissioner Huey asked the Planning Commission to consider potential conditions that 38 could be forwarded to the City Council for consideration in the event the request was 39 denied and the decision was appealed to the City Council. 40 41 Commissioner Menis asked the Planning Commission to consider conditions now that 42 could be imposed on the project.
43 44 Mr. Hanham clarified the only time additional conditions would come into play was if the 45 Planning Commission voted in favor of the entitlement extension. He added that in the 46 event the Planning Commission denied the entitlement extension and the decision was 47 appealed to the City Council, the City Council would have the final say whether to add 48 conditions or not and whether to approve or deny the request. It was possible the City 49 Council may decide to send the project back to the Planning Commission to reconsider 50 the project, and in that case additional conditions could be added at that time.
11 August 10, 2026
1 Regardless, the City Council would be provided copies of the Planning Commission 2 meeting minutes, copies of the Planning Commission staff report and any documentation 3 if the decision of the Planning Commission was appealed. 4 5 Commissioner Huey asked whether the Commission wanted to consider any additional 6 conditions that could be forwarded to the City Council for consideration in the event of an 7 appeal and to provide the City Council with a record of the discussion. 8 9 Commissioner Menis stated he would have preferred a continuance to draft conditions, 10 but would recommend a new condition based on the Environmental Justice Elements, 11 previously identified, that would bar the use of diesel trucks to the property. 12 13 Mr. Hanham understood Commissioner Menis sought a condition where the project shall 14 not allow for diesel fuel trucks to be used in the process of delivery of products to and from 15 the establishment based on the Environmental Justice Elements actions previously 16 identified as Environmental Justice Actions, EJ 2.4.9, EJ 2.4.6 and EJ 4.4.3. 17 18 Commissioner Bender suggested doing that would, in effect, mirror what West County had 19 done in the City of Richmond, when Richmond citizens had an uproar over distribution 20 centers and when there was a moratorium for a time. In that case, the County drafted 21 new regulations to stipulate that any new distribution centers had to have the electrical 22 infrastructure installed, not just conduit stub ups and the like, and have the wiring in place. 23 If this project was approved, only the conduits and stub ups would be installed for future 24 electrical hookup.
25 26 Commissioner Martinez commented he had not had the opportunity to read the entire 27 documentation provided for the item and would have to do that, but needed to understand 28 how the money would flow. Since the initial approval of the project, he was unsure whether 29 the City had been paid any fees for the project. Having watched the City’s Capital 30 Improvement Program (CIP) over the years, there was not a large volume of money from 31 Pinole Shores II. He asked City staff to provide a clear understanding of the timeline of 32 payment for the project. If the City was not paid until the end and nothing happened with 33 the project, the City could get nothing other than some limited fees. He again would like 34 a better understanding of the DDA and the money.
35 36 Chairperson Sandoval suggested the Planning Commission should not be considering the 37 financial aspects of the project but the land use perspective and whether the extension 38 was warranted.
39 40 Mr. Hanham suggested if the Planning Commission wanted more information or time to 41 review all of the documents, he would recommend the item be continued to the next 42 regularly scheduled meeting. If the item were continued, the public hearing would not 43 have to be re-noticed.
44 45 Commissioner Bender otherwise commented it was not unusual to have delays in projects. 46 The biggest delays were City reversals, changes and wanting to add things, with 47 negotiations ongoing. Also, if the financing was not available the project could not 48 proceed, which impacted the commercial world in terms of securing tenants. He added 49 that a few months ago he checked the County website and learned the subject property 50 was still City property.
12 August 10, 2026
1 Mr. Hanham confirmed the property was still City property at this point. 2 3 Chairperson Sandoval respected the recommendation from staff to continue the item, but 4 respectfully disagreed and offered a motion to deny Resolution 26-08, as the Planning 5 Commission found there had not been diligent pursuit to exercise the permit and the 6 extension was not warranted.
7 8 MOTION to deny Planning Commission Resolution 26-08, a Resolution of the Planning 9 Commission of the City of Pinole Approving an Extension Until June 10, 2027 of the 10 Entitlements Adopted Via Resolution 24-02 for the Pinole Shores II Project (DR 23-12 and 11 CUP 23-05) Located at 850 San Pablo Avenue (APN 402-230-024), as the Planning 12 Commission found there had not been diligent pursuit to exercise the permit and the 13 extension was not warranted.
14 15 MOTION: Sandoval SECONDED: Martinez APPROVED: 6-
16 1
17 NOES: Menis
18 19 Chairperson Sandoval identified the 10-day appeal process of a decision of the Planning 20 Commission in writing to the City Clerk.
21 22 H. OLD BUSINESS: None
23 24 I. NEW BUSINESS: None
25 26 J. CITY PLANNER’S/COMMISSIONER’S REPORT
27 28 Mr. Hanham provided the following updates:
29 30 • The former Kmart building had been demolished with fencing to be installed. 31 32 • Staff continued to work with the developers of the Appian 80 Shopping Center. 33 34 • Staff continued to work on potential entitlements for Pinole Vista. 35 36 • Staff continued to implement Housing Element policy programs, and; 37 38 • The City website now included a Geographic Information System (GIS) Zoning Map 39 for residents to obtain information about their property zoning designations. 40 41 Mr. Hanham further reported he submitted a Letter of Resignation to the City of Pinole and 42 his last day would be September 3, 2026. He was moving on to the City of Lodi as its 43 Community Development Director. He expressed his appreciation to the current and former 44 Planning Commissions, recognized and appreciated everyone’s work on City policies and 45 procedures and highlighted some of the many projects approved by the Planning 46 Commission during his tenure with the City of Pinole. He wished everyone the best. 47 48 Commissioner Menis expressed his gratitude to Mr. Hanham for all of his work with the 49 Planning Commission and stated he would be missed.
13 August 10, 2026
1 2 Commissioner Huey expressed her appreciation to Mr. Hanham for his follow-up, ability to 3 seek questions and answers and the ability to attend Planning Academies with Planning 4 Commissioners. She was confident their paths would cross again. 5 6 Commissioner Martinez also thanked Mr. Hanham for his service to the City of Pinole under 7 whose guidance the City had been able to obtain funds for reinvestment and future 8 development. He recognized Mr. Hanham and the hard work of his team. 9 10 Commissioner Lam-Julian further thanked Mr. Hanham for making everything digestible, 11 recognized his kindness and compassion and helping her to think things through and be 12 better when reviewing projects. She also recognized his accessibility and understanding 13 about the background of projects and helping her to see the vision for the future. She too 14 recognized the importance of the Planning Academies. 15 16 Vice-Chairperson Uch thanked Mr. Hanham for all of his work for the City of Pinole, his 17 accessibility and willingness to work with him as a new Planning Commissioner and stated 18 his guidance, work commitment and service to the City was inspiring. 19 20 Commissioner Bender congratulated Mr. Hanham on his next endeavor and thanked him for 21 his tenure with the City. He also recognized that during Mr. Hanham’s tenure, the Planning 22 Commission had not seen anything as ugly as the Gateway West/East Project (Sprouts), 23 acknowledging that things had improved. As a former member of the Design Review Board 24 (DRB) and past member of the Planning Commission when the Gateway Project, which had 25 originally included Safeway, had been proposed, that project was one of the reasons he left 26 the Planning Commission at that time. While he had no regrets, that was a far better-looking 27 project than what had ultimately been built on Pinole Valley Road, which he suggested was 28 overscale. He thanked Mr. Hanham for allowing developers and architects to be able to do 29 what they were doing, and wished him the best of luck. 30 31 Chairperson Sandoval also wished Mr. Hanham well on his next endeavor, recognized his 32 service to the City, with the City having grown beautifully under his leadership with 600 new 33 units. He too recognized Mr. Hanham held developers and people to a higher standard, 34 which had benefitted the community. He also recognized Mr. Hanham had been extremely 35 gracious to the Planning Commission, allowing it to develop. He wished him the best of luck 36 in the City of Lodi.
37 38 Mr. Hanham thanked the Planning Commission for the kind comments. 39 40 Commissioner Bender referenced the installation of the flood lighting on the old bank building, 41 which had conduit sticking out of the building, and naked light bulbs, serving as the flood 42 lights and asked if the work was permitted. He understood the lighting was to be shielded 43 and discreet.
44 45 Mr. Hanham understood some lighting was required consistent with the building, but he 46 would have to check the Conditions of Approval for the project since he understood nothing 47 was to be attached to the building. If the lighting was not allowed, code enforcement may be 48 needed.
49 50 K. COMMUNICATIONS
14 August 10, 2026
1 2 Commissioner Menis reported that upcoming community events included: a general food 3 produce distribution this date at the Senior Center; Senior Food Distribution from 10:00 to 4 11:00 a.m. at the Senior Center on August 11, 2026; and backpack distribution for Pinole 5 students at the Alex Clark Room in the Public Safety Building, on August 13, 2026 from 2:00 6 to 5:00 p.m. sponsored by the Pinole Police Department (PPD). He reported on the rate of 7 COVID-19 in the community which had increased, and in the state as a whole as of August 8 1, 2026, at a moderate level and more locally locations ranged from moderate to very high. 9 While rates continued to rise, he encouraged people to wear masks indoors and if levels 10 continued to rise further wear masks outdoors.
11 12 L. CITIZENS TO BE HEARD (Continued from Item E)
13 Open only to members of the public who did not speak under the first Citizens to be Heard 14 Agenda Item. The public may address the Planning Commission on items that were within 15 its jurisdiction and not otherwise listed on the agenda. Planning Commissioners may discuss 16 the matter brought to their attention, but by State law (Ralph M. Brown Act), action must be 17 deferred to a future meeting. Time allowed: four (4) minutes each. 18 19 Anthony Vossbrink expressed his disappointment with the current City Council. He was 20 unsure who would run for election in November 2026 and hoped for new Council members. 21 He was also disappointed Mr. Hanham was leaving the City of Pinole and asked if it was 22 because of the new City Manager or the possible changing of the guard of the current City 23 Council. He asked whether assistance could be provided to residents when communicating 24 with Caltrans either via telephone or writing letters as related to the lights along San Pablo 25 Avenue, Pinole Valley Road or over the I-80 interchange, which had been out for months if 26 not years, and weed abatement. He asked why the City could not designate a staff member 27 to be in touch with Caltrans and the public to get some of those issues resolved and asked 28 for clarification of the boundary lines between the City of Pinole and Caltrans. 29 30 Mr. Vossbrink also reported on the volume of debris behind the Pinole Library and suggested 31 the City and the County should be jointly responsible for cleanup, with assistance from the 32 Pinole Garden Club and Friends of Pinole Creek Watershed. The property had been in this 33 condition for over a year, and while he understood the County was responsible, the area was 34 a potential fire hazard. He also questioned why the Pinole Library improvements only 35 included the HVAC system, new roof and Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) 36 improvements, and not re-pavement of the parking lot, which was full of potholes, or repair 37 of the narrow driveway ingress/egress.
38 39 Chairperson Sandoval reminded the speaker the Planning Commission had reduced the time 40 period for Citizens to be Heard from five to four minutes. As to the issues with Caltrans, he 41 noted that was a Public Works Department issue.
42 43 Mr. Hanham clarified that most of the boundaries were the cyclone fences, which were the 44 indicators of where the right-of-way (ROW) ended and the City limit started; everything below 45 the highway bridges was Caltrans property, with the City usually having easements to allow 46 maintenance under the bridge areas, and the fences off of Pinole Valley Road were the 47 indicators of the Caltrans and City of Pinole ROWs.
48 49 Commissioner Menis understood Mr. Hanham was moving to a new endeavor to be closer 50 to home, which would also include a reduction in his commute.
15 August 10, 2026
1 2 Mr. Hanham clarified this was an opportunity that had presented itself from a personal and 3 professional standpoint, and the commute did play into it. He enjoyed working with the City 4 of Pinole and all Community Development Department staff. He recognized there was no 5 one on the current Planning Commission who had been on the Planning Commission when 6 he first started with the City, but which was exciting and he hoped would continue, since the 7 Planning Commission as a unit did good work. He again wished everyone the best of luck. 8 9 M. NEXT MEETING
10 11 1. Planning Commission Regular Meeting on September 14, 2026 at 7:00 p.m. 12 13 N. ADJOURNMENT: 9:28 p.m.
14 15 Transcribed by:
16 17 Sherri D. Lewis
18 Transcriber
PLANNING COMMISSION
REPORT H.1.
DATE: NOVEMBER 9, 2026
TO: PLANNING COMMISSION
FROM: LILLY WHALEN, COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR
PREPARED IN CONSULTATION WITH: JARED MURTI, HOUSING FELLOW
AND ASN NDIAYE, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE NORTHERN
CALIFORNIA LAND TRUST
SUBJECT: HOUSING ASSET FUND POLICY GUIDEBOOK
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends that the Planning Commission adopt Resolution 26-09 (Attachment A) recommending City Council adoption of the Housing Successor Low- and Moderate-Income Housing Asset Fund Policy Guidebook (Attachment B)
BACKGROUND
In compliance with Program 7 of the City of Pinole's 2023-2031 Housing Element, the City has developed a Housing Successor Low- and Moderate-Income Housing Asset Fund Policy Guidebook (Attachment B) in collaboration with Northern California Land Trust through the Partnership for the Bay's Future Fellowship Program. The Guidebook establishes priorities, funding strategies, and decision-making criteria for the use of Housing Successor funds while supporting the City's broader housing, fair housing, and community development goals.
Since 1969, California has required local governments to plan for the housing needs of residents at all income levels through the Housing Element of the General Plan. As part of Pinole's certified 2023-2031 Housing Element, Program 7 directs the City to develop a Housing Successor Low-and Moderate-Income Housing Asset Fund Policy to establish priorities and goals for the use of affordable housing funds. The Guidebook fulfills that requirement by identifying funding priorities, evaluating local housing needs, establishing a framework for future Housing Asset Fund expenditures, and supporting the City's obligations to affirmatively further fair housing.
The City of Pinole serves as the Housing Successor to the former Redevelopment Agency of the City of Pinole, which was dissolved statewide in 2012. As Housing Successor, the City is responsible for administering affordable housing assets and ensuring that available resources are utilized in accordance with state law. Housing Asset Fund resources may be used for eligible administrative expenses, homeless prevention and rapid rehousing services, affordable housing development, preservation activities, and other authorized housing programs serving lower-income households.
The Partnership for the Bay's Future (PBF) Fellowship Program places housing professionals within local jurisdictions to support implementation of housing policies and Housing Element programs. In 2024, the City partnered with Northern California Land Trust and Richmond Community Foundation in a successful application to the PBF Fellowship Program. The City was selected as one of ten host agencies and received a full-time Housing Fellow beginning in February 2025. One of the Housing Fellow's primary assignments was development of the Housing Successor Low- and Moderate-Income Housing Asset Fund Policy Guidebook required by Housing Element Program 7.
REVIEW AND ANALYSIS
Program 7 of the Housing Element directed the City to develop a Housing Successor Low- and Moderate-Income Housing Asset Fund Policy Guidebook. The attached guidebook fulfills that requirement by establishing funding priorities, implementation strategies, and a framework for future Housing Asset Fund expenditures consistent with state law, Housing Element objectives, fair housing requirements, and identified local housing needs. The guidebook is intended to serve as a practical tool for evaluating future programs, allocating Housing Asset Fund resources, and advancing housing opportunities for current and future Pinole residents.
The Guidebook identifies existing Housing Successor activities, near-term program opportunities, and future policy considerations. Inclusion of a program or policy concept within the Guidebook does not constitute authorization, appropriation, or commitment of Housing Asset Fund resources. Future implementation remains subject to City Council direction, annual budget approval, funding availability, legal requirements, and staff capacity.
Community Engagement
The City of Pinole sought public input throughout development of the Guidebook to ensure that proposed policies and programs reflect community needs, priorities, and experiences. Public engagement included an online survey launched in December 2025, targeted in-person outreach conducted during spring and summer 2026, participation at community events such as the Pride and Juneteenth Celebration, and consultation with the Planning Commission and City Council. Detailed survey results are included in Addendum A of the Guidebook.
While the online survey generated the largest number of responses, the respondent profile did not fully reflect the City's overall demographic and housing characteristics. To supplement online engagement, staff conducted targeted in-person outreach designed to engage a broader cross-section of residents, including renters, lower-income households, and residents living in areas experiencing housing instability.
Across both engagement formats, respondents consistently identified housing affordability as a significant community concern. Residents expressed support for increasing housing affordability, expanding homeownership opportunities, preserving and rehabilitating existing housing, supporting rental assistance and first-time homebuyer programs, providing housing-related education and resources, and streamlining permitting and development processes.
These findings informed the policy recommendations and funding priorities contained in the Guidebook.
Program and Policy Recommendations
Northern California Land Trust (NCLT) utilized the "3-P" housing framework in developing recommendations for consideration during preparation of the Guidebook. The 3-P framework is a housing policy approach that emphasizes preservation of existing affordable housing, protection of residents from displacement and housing instability, and production of new housing opportunities.
The Guidebook establishes a framework for utilizing Housing Asset Fund resources to support affordable housing development, housing stability, homelessness prevention, fair housing objectives, and long-term stewardship of the City's affordable housing assets. The Guidebook identifies existing Housing Successor activities, near-term program opportunities, and future policy considerations. Inclusion of any program or policy concept within the Guidebook does not constitute authorization, appropriation, or commitment of Housing Asset Fund resources. Future implementation remains subject to City Council direction, annual budget approval, funding availability, legal requirements, and staff capacity.
Existing Programs and Ongoing Commitments
The Guidebook recognizes several programs and activities that are currently funded, operational, or necessary to support Housing Successor responsibilities, including:
Affordable Housing Consulting Services
The City contracts with affordable housing consultants to provide compliance monitoring, preparation of required Housing Successor reports, regulatory compliance assistance, and support for affordable ownership programs. These services help ensure continued compliance with state requirements while supporting long-term stewardship of the City's affordable housing portfolio.
Coordinated Outreach, Referral and Engagement (CORE) Program The City participates in a regional partnership supporting Contra Costa Health's CORE Program. The program conducts outreach to individuals experiencing homelessness, facilitates connections to housing resources and supportive services, and assists residents in accessing the County's coordinated entry system. Continuation of this program supports homelessness prevention and housing stabilization efforts throughout the community.
Housing Successor Property and Loan Portfolio Management The Housing Successor continues to manage real property assets and affordable housing loan portfolios transferred from the former Redevelopment Agency. Ongoing oversight of these assets preserves affordable housing opportunities and ensures compliance with Housing Successor requirements.
Near-Term Program Opportunities
Based upon community engagement findings, Housing Element priorities, and eligible Housing Asset Fund uses, the Guidebook identifies several opportunities that may warrant future City Council consideration.
Tenant Retention Assistance Program
Community engagement findings, CORE Program data, and regional housing trends suggest that some Pinole residents experience housing instability due to temporary financial emergencies or unexpected expenses. A Tenant Retention Assistance Program could provide
short-term financial assistance to eligible households facing an immediate risk of displacement.
The Guidebook identifies a potential partnership with the Contra Costa County Housing Security Fund as a model that could leverage existing County infrastructure while minimizing administrative burdens on City staff.
Affordable Housing Notice of Funding Availability (NOFA) The City may periodically issue a Notice of Funding Availability (NOFA) to solicit affordable housing development proposals and strategically deploy Housing Asset Fund resources. A NOFA process would allow the City to competitively evaluate development proposals and identify projects that best advance local housing goals while leveraging outside funding sources.
Fair Housing Education and Outreach
The Guidebook identifies fair housing education and outreach as an important component of the City's Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing responsibilities. Potential activities include educational workshops, partnerships with fair housing service providers, expanded multilingual materials, and increased public awareness of housing rights and fair housing protections Future Policy Considerations
The Guidebook also identifies several housing tools utilized by other jurisdictions that may warrant future evaluation. These concepts vary significantly in cost, staffing requirements, and legal complexity. Inclusion in the Guidebook does not constitute a recommendation for adoption but rather identifies potential options for future consideration should the City Council choose to pursue additional housing initiatives.
Administrative Capacity and Program Management
As affordable housing programs, compliance obligations, and funding opportunities continue to grow, the City may periodically evaluate whether existing staffing resources remain sufficient to administer Housing Successor programs, pursue external funding opportunities, manage housing assets, and oversee compliance activities. Any future staffing modifications would require separate review and approval by the City Council.
Homeownership Assistance Programs
Homeownership assistance programs can help income-qualified households overcome barriers to homeownership by providing down payment assistance, deferred-payment loans, shared-equity assistance, or other forms of financial support. Given the high cost of homeownership throughout the Bay Area, future evaluation of homeownership assistance opportunities may be warranted should funding and partnership opportunities become available.
Community Land Trust Partnerships
Community Land Trusts acquire and retain ownership of land while providing opportunities for permanently affordable homeownership through long-term stewardship and resale restrictions.
The Guidebook identifies potential partnerships with Community Land Trust organizations as a tool that may warrant future evaluation if acquisition, rehabilitation, preservation, or affordable homeownership opportunities arise within Pinole.
Tenant Protection Policy Review
The City currently relies primarily on tenant protections provided through California law, including the Tenant Protection Act of 2019. The Guidebook recommends continued monitoring of local housing conditions and collection of data through the City's Residential Health and
Safety Inspection Program before determining whether additional local tenant protection measures may be necessary or appropriate.
Evaluation of Additional Eviction Protections
Regional studies indicate that housing instability remains a concern throughout Contra Costa County. However, local data regarding causes of eviction, tenant displacement patterns, and housing outcomes remain limited. The Guidebook recommends continued monitoring of regional trends and evaluation of local housing data before determining whether additional local eviction protection measures warrant future consideration.
Evaluation of Tenant Legal Assistance Programs
Several jurisdictions have implemented legal assistance programs that support tenants facing eviction or housing-related legal challenges. While no recommendation is made regarding creation of a City-funded legal assistance program, the Guidebook identifies legal assistance as a strategy that may warrant future evaluation should housing instability become a greater local concern.
Funding Priorities
Consistent with Housing Element Program 7, community engagement findings, and Housing Successor requirements, the Guidebook recommends prioritizing Housing Asset Fund expenditures in the following order:
1. Preservation and Expansion of Affordable Housing
• Affordable housing development
• Affordable homeownership opportunities
• Acquisition and rehabilitation projects
• Community Land Trust partnerships
• Preservation of affordability-restricted housing
2. Homelessness Prevention and Housing Stability
• CORE Program services
• Tenant retention assistance
• Housing stabilization and navigation services
• Other eligible homelessness prevention activities
3. Fair Housing and Community Education
• Fair housing workshops and outreach
• Language accessibility services
• Educational materials and community engagement
• Partnerships with fair housing service providers
Ongoing: Program Administration and Compliance
• Affordable housing monitoring and reporting
• Asset management
• Housing Successor compliance activities
• Administration of housing programs and services
ATTACHMENTS
A. Resolution 26-09 Recommending Approval of Guidebook to City Council B. Draft Housing Asset Fund Policy Guidebook
1 PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION 26-09
WITH EXHIBIT A GUIDEBOOK
A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF PINOLE
RECOMMENDING THAT THE CITY COUNCIL ADOPT THE HOUSING SUCCESSOR LOW-AND MODERATE-INCOME HOUSING ASSET FUND POLICY GUIDEBOOK WHEREAS, the City of Pinole adopted its 2023-2031 Housing Element to address the housing needs of current and future residents at all income levels; and WHEREAS, Housing Element Program 7 directs the City to prepare a Housing Successor Low-and Moderate-Income Housing Asset Fund Policy to establish priorities and goals for the use of Housing Asset Fund resources; and
WHEREAS, the City of Pinole serves as the Housing Successor to the former Redevelopment Agency of the City of Pinole and is responsible for administering Housing Asset Fund resources in accordance with California law; and
WHEREAS, Housing Asset Fund resources may be utilized for eligible affordable housing activities including affordable housing development, preservation, homelessness prevention and housing stabilization efforts, fair housing activities, and administration of Housing Successor responsibilities; and
WHEREAS, the City, in collaboration with Northern California Land Trust through the Partnership for the Bay's Future Fellowship Program, prepared the Housing Successor Low- and Moderate-Income Housing Asset Fund Policy Guidebook ("Guidebook"), incorporated herein as Exhibit A; and
WHEREAS, the Guidebook provides a framework for future use of Housing Asset Fund resources by identifying funding priorities, evaluating local housing needs, establishing implementation strategies, and supporting the City's obligations to affirmatively further fair housing; and
WHEREAS, development of the Guidebook included community engagement efforts consisting of online surveys, targeted in-person outreach, participation in community events, and consultation with the Planning Commission and City Council; and
WHEREAS, the Guidebook identifies existing Housing Successor programs and activities, near-term program opportunities, and future policy considerations intended to inform future decisions regarding the use of Housing Asset Fund resources; and
WHEREAS, adoption of the Guidebook does not authorize any specific expenditure of Housing Asset Fund resources nor require implementation of any specific program, and all future expenditures
ATTACHMENT A
2 and program implementation shall remain subject to City Council direction, funding availability, applicable law, and annual budget appropriations; and
WHEREAS, the Planning Commission held a duly noticed public meeting on November 9, 2026, at which time it reviewed the proposed Guidebook, received the staff report, heard public testimony, and considered all evidence presented.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Planning Commission of the City of Pinole hereby finds that:
1. The foregoing recitals are true and correct and are incorporated herein by reference.
2. The Housing Successor Low- and Moderate-Income Housing Asset Fund Policy Guidebook fulfills Housing Element Program 7 by establishing a policy framework for future use of Housing Asset Fund resources.
3. The Guidebook supports the City's affordable housing, housing stability, fair housing, and community development objectives.
4. The Guidebook provides a useful framework for evaluating future housing investments and programs while maintaining flexibility for future City Council consideration of specific funding allocations, programs, and policies.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Planning Commission recommends that the City Council adopt the Housing Successor Low- and Moderate-Income Housing Asset Fund Policy Guidebook.
PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Planning Commission of the City of Pinole on this 9th day of November, 2026, by the following vote:
AYES:
NOES:
ABSTAIN:
ABSENT:
_____________________________
Gabriel Sandoval, Chair, 2026-2027
ATTEST:
_____________________________
Lilly Whalen, Community Development Director
3 Exhibit A: Guidebook as Recommended by the Planning Commission to the City Council [Planning Commission recommended guidebook to be inserted]
[DRAFT] Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
For Planning Commission Review 11/9/26
City of Pinole
Adopted by City Council: [DATE]
Developed in Collaboration with:
ATTACHMENT B
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
2 Glossary of Terms and Acronyms ................................................................................................................4
1. Introduction:..............................................................................................................................................9
1.1 Housing Element Program 7 .......................................................................................................9
2. Housing Successor Fund........................................................................................................................11
2.1 Eligible Uses .....................................................................................................................................11
2.2 Housing Successor Compliance Requirements................................................................................12
2.2.1 Income Targeting Requirements ............................................................................................12
2.2.2 Excess Surplus Requirements................................................................................................12
2.2.3 Implications for the City of Pinole ...........................................................................................13
2.3 Prohousing Incentive Program (PIP) Funds .........................................................................................13
3. Housing Snapshot ..................................................................................................................................14
3.1 Summary of Housing Stock...............................................................................................................14
3.1.1 Existing Stock .........................................................................................................................15
3.1.2 Recent, Active, and Prospective Development.......................................................................15
3.1.3 Preservation/At-Risk Units......................................................................................................16
3.1.4 Fair Housing Requirements ....................................................................................................16
3.2 Summary of Housing Needs .............................................................................................................17
3.2.1 RHNA Progress ......................................................................................................................17
3.2.2 Income Level Targets and Housing Affordability ....................................................................17
3.2.3 Special Needs Populations.....................................................................................................18
3.2.4 Community Members Experiencing Homelessness ...............................................................18
3.2.5 Evictions and Housing Stability...............................................................................................19
4. Community Engagement........................................................................................................................22
4.1 Online Survey....................................................................................................................................22
4.2 Targeted In-Person Community Outreach........................................................................................23
4.3 Engagement Takeaways ...........................................................................................................24
5. Housing Successor Fund Priorities and Implementation Framework.....................................................25
5.1 Existing Programs and Ongoing Commitments ................................................................................25
5.1.1 Affordable Housing Consulting Services ................................................................................25
5.1.2 Coordinated Outreach, Referral and Engagement (CORE) Program.....................................25
5.1.3 Housing Successor Real Property Portfolio............................................................................26
5.1.4 Housing Successor Loan Portfolio..........................................................................................26
5.2 Near-Term Program Opportunities....................................................................................................26
5.2.1 Inclusionary Housing In-Lieu Fee Option................................................................................26
5.2.2 Tenant Retention Assistance Program ...................................................................................27
5.2.3 Affordable Housing Notice of Funding Availability (NOFA).....................................................27
5.2.4 Fair Housing Education and Outreach....................................................................................28
5.3 Future Policy Considerations ............................................................................................................29
5.3.1 Administrative Capacity and Program Management ..............................................................29
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
3 5.3.2 Homeownership Assistance Program.....................................................................................29
5.3.3 Community Land Trust Partnerships ......................................................................................30
5.3.4 Tenant Protection Policy Review ............................................................................................30
5.3.5 Evaluation of Additional Eviction Protections..........................................................................31
5.3.6 Evaluation of Tenant Legal Assistance Programs ..................................................................32
6. Housing Asset Fund Funding Framework...........................................................................................33
6.1 Funding Priorities ..............................................................................................................................33
6.2 Existing Annual Commitments ..........................................................................................................34
6.2.1 Ongoing Housing Asset Fund commitments ..........................................................................34
6.2.2 Available Resources ...............................................................................................................35
6.3 Illustrative Future Funding Considerations........................................................................................35
6.4 Leveraging External Resources ........................................................................................................35
6.5 Fiscal Stewardship............................................................................................................................36 References: ................................................................................................................................................37
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
4 Glossary of Terms and Acronyms
Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU): An independent residential dwelling unit located on the same parcel as an existing or proposed primary residence. Also known as a secondary unit, in-law unit, or granny flat.
Affordable Housing: Housing that is affordable to lower- and moderate-income households, generally requiring households to spend no more than 30 percent of their gross income on housing costs.
Affordable Housing Portfolio: The collection of affordable housing assets, deed-restricted units, loans, properties, and programs administered or monitored by the Housing Successor Agency.
Affordable Ownership Housing: Housing sold at below-market rates or subject to affordability restrictions to maintain affordability for income-qualified households over time.
Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing (AFFH): A requirement that public agencies take meaningful actions to reduce housing discrimination, address patterns of segregation, eliminate barriers to housing choice, and promote equitable access to housing opportunities.
Area Median Income (AMI): The median income for households within a geographic area. AMI is used to determine eligibility for affordable housing programs and income-restricted housing. AMI is the exact midpoint income for a specific county, meaning half of the families earn more and half earn less. It is calculated each year by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) using Census data. The number is based on a 4-person family and then scaled up or down according to actual household size. Housing programs use percentages of this baseline (such as 50% or 80% AMI) to qualify applicants for affordable housing, rental assistance, and down payment grants.
Asset Management: The ongoing administration, monitoring, maintenance, and oversight of Housing Successor properties, loans, and affordable housing investments.
Community Development Block Grant (CDBG): A federal program that provides funding for community development activities, including affordable housing, infrastructure improvements, public facilities, and public services.
Community Land Trust (CLT): A nonprofit organization that acquires and retains ownership of land while ensuring that homes located on the land remain permanently affordable through resale restrictions and long-term stewardship.
Compliance Monitoring: The ongoing process of ensuring affordable housing developments comply with affordability restrictions, occupancy requirements, regulatory agreements, and reporting obligations.
Consumer Price Index (CPI): A measure of inflation used to track changes in the cost of goods and services over time.
Coordinated Entry System: Contra Costa County's centralized process for assessing and connecting individuals and families experiencing homelessness to housing resources and supportive services.
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
5 Coordinated Outreach, Referral, and Engagement (CORE) Program: A Contra Costa Health program that provides outreach, housing navigation, service referrals, and case management to individuals experiencing or at risk of homelessness.
Deed-Restricted Affordable Housing: Housing subject to a recorded affordability covenant that limits rents or sales prices to income-qualified households for a specified period of time.
Deferred-Payment Loan: A loan that does not require regular monthly payments and is generally repaid upon sale, refinancing, transfer of ownership, or maturity.
Development and Disposition Agreement (DDA): A legally binding agreement between a public agency and a developer that establishes the terms for conveyance, development, and use of a property.
Extremely Low-Income Household: A household earning no more than 30 percent of Area Median Income.
Fair Housing: The right of all individuals to have equal access to housing opportunities without discrimination.
Fair Housing Complaint: A complaint alleging discrimination in housing based on a protected characteristic under federal, state, or local fair housing laws.
Gap Financing: Financial assistance used to bridge the difference between available project funding and the total cost of developing or preserving affordable housing.
General Fund: The City's primary operating fund used to support general municipal services and programs.
Housing Asset Fund Administrative Cost Limit: The maximum amount a Housing Successor Agency may spend annually on administrative activities, as established by state law.
Housing Element: The state-required housing component of a city's General Plan that identifies housing needs, establishes housing goals and policies, and demonstrates how the city will accommodate future housing needs.
Housing Fellow: A professional placed through the Partnership for the Bay’s Future Fellowship Program to assist local jurisdictions with housing policy, planning, program implementation, and housing-related initiatives.
Housing Security Fund: A housing stabilization fund that provides financial assistance to households experiencing housing insecurity or facing displacement due to temporary financial hardship.
Housing Stability: The ability of a household to maintain safe, secure, and affordable housing over time without experiencing displacement or homelessness.
Housing Successor Agency: The public entity responsible for managing the housing assets, obligations, and affordable housing programs formerly administered by a redevelopment agency.
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
6 HOME Investment Partnerships Program (HOME): A federal housing program that provides funding for affordable housing development, rehabilitation, rental assistance, and homeownership activities.
Homeless Prevention and Rapid Rehousing Services: Programs and services designed to prevent homelessness and quickly assist households in obtaining or maintaining permanent housing.
Income-Restricted Unit: A housing unit reserved for households meeting specified income qualifications and subject to affordability requirements.
Inclusionary Housing: A local housing policy requiring a portion of units in new residential developments to be affordable to lower-income households.
Inclusionary Housing In-Lieu Fee: A fee paid by a developer as an alternative to providing affordable units within a residential development. Funds are typically used to support affordable housing projects and programs.
Language Accessibility: Efforts to ensure residents with limited English proficiency can access public information, meetings, services, and programs through translation and interpretation services.
Loan Portfolio: The collection of outstanding loans administered by the Housing Successor Agency, including affordable housing development loans, rehabilitation loans, and homeownership assistance loans.
Low-Income Household: A household earning between 50 and 80 percent of Area Median Income.
Low- and Moderate-Income Housing Asset Fund (Housing Asset Fund): The affordable housing fund maintained by the City as Housing Successor Agency and used to support eligible housing activities, including affordable housing development, preservation, homelessness prevention, and program administration.
Moderate-Income Household: A household earning between 80 and 120 percent of Area Median Income.
Northern California Land Trust (NCLT): A nonprofit organization that promotes permanently affordable housing through community land trust ownership and stewardship models.
Opportunity Areas: Areas identified using state methodology that measures access to educational, economic, environmental, and community resources. Opportunity Areas help guide affordable housing investment and fair housing planning.
Partnership for the Bay's Future (PBF): A regional collaborative initiative focused on expanding housing affordability, preventing displacement, and advancing equitable housing opportunities throughout the Bay Area.
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
7 Partnership for the Bay's Future Fellowship Program: A two-year fellowship program that places housing professionals within local jurisdictions to advance housing programs, policies, and implementation efforts.
Point-in-Time (PIT) Count: A periodic count that estimates the number of individuals experiencing homelessness within a geographic area on a specific date.
Preservation: Activities intended to maintain the affordability and physical condition of existing affordable housing developments.
Program 7: Housing Element Program 7, which directs the City to develop a Housing Successor Low-and Moderate-Income Housing Asset Fund Policy to establish priorities, funding objectives, and affordable housing investment strategies.
Prohousing Designation: A designation awarded to jurisdictions that have implemented policies and programs that facilitate housing production and affordability.
Prohousing Incentive Program (PIP): A state grant program that provides funding to Prohousing-designated jurisdictions for housing-related planning, infrastructure, and implementation activities.
Racially or Ethnically Concentrated Area of Poverty (R/ECAP): An area with a high concentration of both lower-income households and residents from historically marginalized racial or ethnic groups.
Racially Concentrated Area of Affluence (RCAA): An area characterized by relatively high incomes and concentrations of affluent households.
Redevelopment Agency (RDA): A former local government entity authorized to use tax increment financing for economic development, infrastructure, and affordable housing. Redevelopment agencies were dissolved statewide in 2012.
Regional Housing Needs Allocation (RHNA): The number of housing units assigned to a city or county for planning purposes during a Housing Element cycle, distributed across multiple income categories.
Rent-Burdened Household: A household spending more than 30 percent of its gross income on housing costs.
Residual Receipts: Surplus revenue generated by an affordable housing development after payment of operating expenses and required debt obligations. Residual receipts may be used to repay affordable housing loans.
Residential Health and Safety Inspection Program: The City's rental housing inspection program designed to promote safe and habitable housing conditions while collecting housing-related data, including rental rates, property conditions, and occupancy characteristics.
Resale Restriction: A recorded agreement or covenant that limits the future sales price of a home to preserve long-term affordability for future buyers.
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
8 Satellite Affordable Housing Associates (SAHA): A nonprofit affordable housing developer, owner, and manager that develops and operates affordable housing communities throughout Northern California.
Shared-Equity Model: A homeownership model in which appreciation, resale proceeds, or ownership interests are shared between a homeowner and a public agency or nonprofit organization to preserve affordability for future homebuyers.
Special Needs Populations: Groups that may require targeted housing assistance due to unique housing challenges, including seniors, persons with disabilities, extremely low-income households, large families, female-headed households, veterans, and individuals experiencing homelessness.
Tax Credit Allocation Committee (TCAC): The state agency responsible for administering Low-Income Housing Tax Credits and publishing Opportunity Area maps used in affordable housing funding programs.
Tenant Retention Program: A housing stabilization program that provides short-term financial assistance or services to help renters remain housed and avoid displacement.
Three Corridors Specific Plan: The City's long-range planning framework for the San Pablo Avenue, Pinole Valley Road, and Appian Way corridors that guides future housing, economic development, transportation, and public investment.
Three Corridors Specific Plan Area: The primary mixed-use growth area identified by the City for housing, commercial investment, transportation improvements, and neighborhood revitalization.
Uncollectable Notes Allowance: An accounting adjustment recognizing that some outstanding loans may not be fully repaid and therefore may not represent recoverable assets.
Very Low-Income Household: A household earning between 30 and 50 percent of Area Median Income.
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
9 1. Introduction:
The City of Pinole is developing a Housing Successor Low- and Moderate-Income Housing Asset Fund Policy Guidebook (the “Guidebook”) in accordance with Program 7 of the City of Pinole’s certified 2023- 2031 Housing Element. The Guidebook is intended to establish priorities, funding strategies, and decision-making criteria for the use of Housing Successor funds while supporting the City's broader housing, fair housing, and community development goals. Since 1969, California has required that all local governments adequately plan to meet the housing needs of everyone in the community, at all income levels through the Housing Element of the General Plan. The Housing Element identifies housing needs, establishes policies and programs, and outlines strategies for accommodating future housing growth while promoting fair housing and housing choice.
As part of Pinole’s 2023-2031 Housing Element, Program 7 in part directs the City to develop a policy framework for its Housing Successor Low- and Moderate-Income Housing Asset Fund. This Guidebook fulfills that requirement by establishing funding priorities, evaluating housing needs, identifying strategic investment opportunities, and providing guidance for future use of Housing Successor resources.
The City of Pinole serves as the Housing Successor to the former Redevelopment Agency of the City of Pinole, which was dissolved as part of California's statewide redevelopment dissolution process in 2012.
As Housing Successor, the City is responsible for managing the former agency's affordable housing assets and ensuring that available funds are utilized in accordance with state law. Housing Asset Fund resources may be used for eligible administrative expenses, homeless prevention and rapid rehousing activities, affordable housing development, preservation efforts, and other authorized housing programs serving lower-income households.
This Guidebook has been prepared in collaboration with Northern California Land Trust (NCLT) through the Partnership for the Bay's Future (PBF) Fellowship Program. In 2024, the City partnered with NCLT and Richmond Community Foundation (RCF) in a successful application to the PBF Housing Fellowship Program. Through this program, the City was selected as one of ten host agencies and was provided a full-time Housing Fellow beginning in February 2025.
The Fellowship Program supports local jurisdictions in developing innovative housing policies and implementing Housing Element programs. Development of this Policy Guidebook is one of several housing initiatives undertaken through the partnership and is intended to provide a long-term framework for leveraging local, regional, state, and federal resources to address Pinole's housing needs.
This Guidebook is informed by state housing law, the City's Housing Element, local housing market conditions, community engagement efforts, and fair housing objectives. It is intended to serve as a practical tool for evaluating future projects, allocating Housing Asset Fund resources, and advancing housing opportunities for current and future Pinole residents.
1.1 Housing Element Program 7
Program 7 of the 2023-2031 Housing Element directs the City to prepare a Housing Successor Low- and Moderate-Income Housing Asset Fund Policy to ensure the strategic, equitable, and effective use of available affordable housing resources.
The policy is intended to:
• Establish priorities for the expenditure of Housing Asset Fund resources; • Align funding decisions with identified housing needs and RHNA obligations; • Advance the City's Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing (AFFH) objectives; • Support the development and preservation of affordable housing;
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
10 • Expand housing mobility and access to opportunity for lower-income households; • Promote homeownership opportunities for moderate- and lower-income households; and • Evaluate the creation of an inclusionary housing in-lieu fee as an alternative compliance mechanism for qualifying residential developments (an item separate from this guidebook).
Consistent with Housing Element goals, the City will seek to balance housing investments across a variety of needs, including affordable rental housing, affordable homeownership opportunities, housing stabilization programs, and preservation of existing affordable housing. Particular consideration will be given to investments that increase housing opportunities in areas with greater access to transportation, employment centers, community services, educational opportunities, and healthy environmental conditions.
The City will continue to require that a minimum of 15 percent of units in qualifying residential developments be provided as inclusionary affordable housing. Of those inclusionary units, at least 40 percent must be affordable to very low-income households. The City is also, on a parallel track, evaluating the creation of an in-lieu fee option to provide flexibility for smaller development projects while generating a dedicated source of funding for future affordable housing initiatives. The full Housing Element Program 7 language is provided below for reference:
Official Housing Element Program 7 Language:
To develop a Housing Successor’s Low and Moderate-Income Housing Asset Fund Policy. The policy will set priorities and goals for the use of affordable housing funds in the City as well as investigate the creation of an in-lieu fee as an alternative to the inclusionary housing requirement. The policy guide will ensure efficient and productive use of the resources. The policy guide will consider RHNA requirements, local housing needs and demographics, and fair housing objectives, among other factors. To encourage housing mobility and choice across Pinole, the City will prioritize use of limited affordable funding to create affordable housing developments and provide ownership of housing for moderate and lower-income households in higher opportunity areas of the City, including those with healthy environment, access to transportation and resources, and higher education scores, more common in eastern Pinole. The City is also including a waiver of park impact fees for affordable units beyond the inclusionary housing requirement (per Program 8).The City will continue to require 15 percent of the units located in new residential developments of four or more to be affordable, and of those units, 40 percent must be affordable to very Low-Income households with the construction of units off-site as an alternative. The City will pursue creation of an in-lieu fee alternative for the inclusionary housing requirement to provide flexibility for smaller projects and to create a new funding source for affordable housing projects.
Implementing Agency: Community Development Department
Supporting Agency: Finance Department
Timeline: Three years after Housing Element adoption
Funding Source: Housing Successor Low and Moderate-Income Housing Asset Fund; Contra Costa County, State and Federal funding programs as available.
Quantified Objective: Create a housing fund policy guide, create in-lieu fee alternative and funding source. For applicable development projects, maintain a minimum requirement of 15 percent inclusionary units, and of those 40 percent of units affordable to very Low-Income households.
Geographic Targeting: Target 50 percent of affordable housing funding towards development of affordable housing and facilitating ownership of housing for moderate and lower-income households in higher opportunity areas.
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
11 2. Housing Successor Fund
The City of Pinole is the housing successor to the former Redevelopment Agency of the City of Pinole, which was dissolved statewide in 2012. At the time of dissolution, a housing successor was to be selected to accept the transfer of and be responsible for the remaining assets and liabilities of a former redevelopment agency.
Upon the statewide dissolution of redevelopment in 2012, all rights, powers, committed assets, liabilities, duties, and obligations associated with the affordable housing activities of the former Agency were transferred to the Housing Successor.
A year after the dissolution of redevelopment began, the California State Legislature recognized the need to regulate and provide transparency on the use of the housing activities transferred from a former redevelopment agency. Senate Bill 341 (DeSaulnier, 2013) and subsequent legislation enacted several requirements for housing successor agencies contained in HSC Sections 34176-34176.1. In general, housing successors must comply with three major requirements pursuant to HSC Section 34176.1:
1. Housing Successor expenditures and housing production are subject to income and age targets.
2. Housing successors may not accumulate an “excess surplus,” or a high balance based on certain thresholds.
3. Properties must be developed with affordable housing or sold within five to ten years of being approved for transfer from the former redevelopment agency to the housing successor.
2.1 Eligible Uses
Pursuant to Health and Safety Code (HSC) Section 34176.1, Housing Asset Funds may be used for the following purposes:
1) Administrative Costs to operate the housing successor agency. State law allows a housing successor to expend the greater of:
● $200,000 per year adjusted for inflation, or
● 5% of the statutory value of real property owned by that housing successor and the value of loans and grants receivable from the HAT (“Portfolio”).
The California Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) annually publishes the inflation-adjusted administrative cost limit based on changes in the Consumer Price Index.
For calendar year 2025 (Fiscal Year 2024-25), the inflation-adjusted administrative cost limit is $270,700. This amount exceeds the alternative limit of $236,753, calculated as 5% of the Portfolio value. Accordingly, the applicable administrative cost limit for FY 2024-25 is $270,700. 2) Homeless Prevention and Rapid Rehousing Services up to $500,000 per year if the former redevelopment agency did not have any outstanding inclusionary housing or replacement housing production requirements as of 2012. Pinole is eligible for this expense because the former Agency did not have any outstanding inclusionary or replacement housing requirements upon dissolution.
3) Affordable Housing Development assisting households earning up to 80 percent of the Area Median Income (“AMI”), subject to specific income and age targets over a five-year period.
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
12 2.2 Housing Successor Compliance Requirements
In addition to restrictions on eligible uses, Housing Successor Agencies must comply with ongoing state requirements related to income targeting, housing production, and fund balances. These requirements are intended to ensure that affordable housing resources are directed toward households with the greatest housing needs and that Housing Asset Fund resources are actively deployed rather than accumulated indefinitely.
2.2.1 Income Targeting Requirements
Expenditures for affordable housing development are evaluated over fixed five-year reporting periods.
The current reporting period spans Fiscal Years 2025 through 2029. During each five-year period, Housing Successor Agencies must maintain the following proportional spending requirements for housing development expenditures:
• Extremely Low-Income Requirement: At least 30 percent of total housing development expenditures must be directed toward rental housing affordable to households earning no more than 30 percent of Area Median Income (AMI).
• Low-Income Limitation: No more than 20 percent of total housing development expenditures may be directed toward households earning between 60 percent and 80 percent of AMI. • Remaining Expenditures: The balance of development expenditures generally serves households earning between 30 and 60 percent of AMI, including Very Low- and Low-Income households.
These requirements are designed to ensure that Housing Asset Fund resources are primarily directed toward households facing the greatest affordability challenges.
Failure to satisfy these requirements may result in statutory spending restrictions. For example, if an agency fails to meet the Extremely Low-Income requirement, a greater proportion of future expenditures must be directed toward Extremely Low-Income rental housing until compliance is restored. Similarly, excessive expenditures on households earning between 60 and 80 percent of AMI may restrict future expenditures within that income category until proportional compliance is reestablished.
State law also establishes certain housing production requirements related to age-restricted affordable housing. In general, Housing Successor Agencies must monitor the proportion of affordable rental units that are restricted to senior households to ensure ongoing compliance with state law. The City tracks these requirements through its annual Housing Successor reporting process and evaluates future affordable housing investments accordingly.
2.2.2 Excess Surplus Requirements
State law also limits the amount of uncommitted Housing Asset Fund resources that may be accumulated over time. An Excess Surplus generally exists when the Housing Asset Fund's unencumbered balance exceeds the greater of:
• $1,000,000; or
• The cumulative amount deposited into the Housing Asset Fund during the preceding four fiscal years.
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
13 If an Excess Surplus occurs, the Housing Successor Agency must take action within three fiscal years to either:
• Encumber the funds through legally binding commitments to affordable housing activities; or • Transfer eligible funds to another qualified housing entity for affordable housing purposes.
Failure to address an Excess Surplus within the statutory timeframe may result in the transfer of excess funds to the California Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) for redistribution to affordable housing programs elsewhere in the state.
2.2.3 Implications for the City of Pinole
These statutory requirements influence how the City prioritizes Housing Asset Fund expenditures and maintains long-term reserves. Because Housing Asset Fund resources must satisfy income-targeting requirements, age-related housing production requirements, and excess surplus limitations, the City must balance investment in immediate housing needs with preservation of sufficient resources to support future affordable housing development opportunities.
2.3 Prohousing Incentive Program (PIP) Funds
In 2024, the City of Pinole was awarded $650,000 through the California Department of Housing and Community Development's (HCD) Prohousing Incentive Program (PIP). The award was obtained contingent on implementation of Housing Element Program 7 and the development of a Housing Successor Low- and Moderate-Income Housing Asset Fund Policy Guide.
Purpose of the Award
Consistent with the approved PIP work plan, the awarded funds are intended to be deposited into the City's Low- and Moderate-Income Housing Asset Fund and utilized in accordance with Health and Safety Code Section 34176.1. As a result, these funds become subject to the same eligible-use restrictions, affordability requirements, income-targeting requirements, and reporting requirements applicable to other Housing Successor resources.
Relationship to Housing Element Program 7
The PIP award directly supports implementation of Housing Element Program 7, which directs the City to develop a Housing Successor Low- and Moderate-Income Housing Asset Fund Policy. The approved PIP work plan notes that the policy guide should:
• Consider RHNA requirements, local housing needs and demographics, and fair housing objectives;
• Promote efficient and productive use of affordable housing resources; • Encourage housing mobility and housing choice;
• Support creation of affordable housing opportunities; and • Facilitate affordable homeownership opportunities for lower- and moderate-income households, particularly within higher-opportunity areas of the City.
Extremely Low-Income Housing Requirement
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
14 The approved PIP work plan specifies that funds deposited into the Housing Asset Fund must comply with Health and Safety Code Section 34176.1, including the requirement that at least 30 percent of applicable affordable housing development expenditures be directed toward housing serving Extremely Low-Income households earning no more than 30 percent of Area Median Income.
Potential Future Applications
As part of the approved work plan, the City identified several housing strategies that may be evaluated through this Guidebook and future Housing Asset Fund implementation efforts, including:
• Issuing a Notice of Funding Availability (NOFA) to partner with affordable housing developers; • Land acquisition for future affordable housing development; • Partnerships with Community Land Trusts;
• Acquisition or extension of affordability covenants;
• Leveraging local resources with federal, state, regional, and county housing funding programs; and
• Other affordable housing development and preservation activities consistent with Health and Safety Code Section 34176.1.
These potential strategies are presented as examples considered during development of this Guidebook.
See Section 5 introduction regarding implementation and funding authorization.
Expenditure Requirement
As a condition of the approved PIP work plan, the City committed to depositing the awarded funds into the Low- and Moderate-Income Housing Asset Fund and expending those funds within three years of the applicable expenditure deadline (expenditure by June 30, 2029). This requirement reinforces the intent that the funds be actively deployed to support affordable housing objectives rather than held indefinitely.
3. Housing Snapshot
Program and policy recommendations are based on the current housing context within the City of Pinole.
As this information evolves, so must the programs and policies used to support residents.
3.1 Summary of Housing Stock
Pinole's housing stock reflects the characteristics of a small, largely built-out Bay Area community. The housing inventory is relatively mature, predominately owner-occupied, and heavily concentrated in single-family detached homes, with a more limited supply of multifamily and rental housing. While the City did not meet all of its Regional Housing Needs Allocation (RHNA) targets during the 5th Cycle planning period, the City entered the 2023–2031 planning period with a robust pipeline of entitled and proposed residential projects.
Since adoption of the current Housing Element, the City has made meaningful progress toward expanding housing opportunities across a range of income levels. Vista Woods, a 179-unit affordable senior apartment community at 600 Robles, was completed in 2025 and is currently leasing units. Valor Village, a 33-unit affordable housing development serving veterans and developed by SAHA, was completed in May 2025. Several additional projects — including the 154-unit Appian Village for-sale development— remain in various stages of entitlement, plan review, or construction.
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
15 In addition to supporting new housing production, the City continues to monitor its inventory of deed-restricted affordable housing to ensure compliance with affordability covenants. No assisted units are currently at risk of conversion to market-rate housing during the planning period.
Consistent with state law, the City is also required to affirmatively further fair housing by evaluating patterns of segregation, disparities in access to opportunity, and concentrations of housing need, and by implementing programs and policies that address identified barriers to fair housing choice.
3.1.1 Existing Stock
Pinole's housing stock consists of approximately 6,882 housing units, with single-family detached homes accounting for roughly 73% of the inventory. The stock is predominantly owner-occupied with approximately 69% of households owning their homes and 31% renting. The City's housing inventory is also relatively mature, with most units constructed prior to 1990.
Housing costs have continued to rise. The median property value in Pinole increased from $697,100 in 2023 to $718,600 in 2024. While the median household income was $120,833 in 2023, homeownership remains financially challenging for many households without substantial savings or accumulated equity.
Rental costs have also increased significantly with median gross rent reaching approximately $2,660 per month in 2024, compared to $1,997 reported in the 2023 Housing Element. These rising costs continue to place affordability pressures on lower- and moderate-income households and contribute to housing cost burdens among renters.
3.1.2 Recent, Active, and Prospective Development
There are 659 pending or entitled housing units in Pinole’s development pipeline that are anticipated to contribute toward the City’s 6th Cycle RHNA obligations. Of the five major projects identified in the Housing Element pipeline, two have been completed.
Vista Woods, a 179-unit 100% affordable senior community at 600 Robles, was completed in 2025 and is currently leasing units. Valor Village, a 33-unit affordable development serving veterans and developed by SAHA at 811 San Pablo Avenue, was completed in September 2024 and received a 2025 PCBC Golden Nugget Award of Merit for Best Affordable Housing Community.
Several additional projects remain in various stages of development. Appian Village, a 154-unit for-sale residential project at 2151 Appian Way, with 20% inclusionary housing, received unanimous Planning Commission approval of its final entitlements in April 2022 and is currently under phased construction, with units actively being marketed for sale by DeNova Homes. The BCRE Mixed-Use project at 2801 Pinole Valley Road (29 units) remains in the approved entitlements stage. The Pinole Vista development at 1500 Fitzgerald Drive (223 units) has expired and is no longer included in the active development pipeline.
Accessory dwelling units (ADUs) continue to be an important source of incremental housing production in Pinole. Between 2022 and 2025, the City permitted 33 ADUs, averaging 8.25 permits per year. This recent production trend exceeds the rate assumed in the Housing Element of 3 units per year, and supports continued progress toward RHNA compliance.
From 2021 through 2025, Pinole added 339 new housing units, representing approximately 5 percent growth over the City's 2021 housing inventory of 7,169 units. Of these new units, 262 units were affordable to very-low-, low-, or moderate-income households.
As of 2025, the City was approximately 38% through the 6th RHNA cycle and had achieved 20% of its overall RHNA allocation. By income category, the City has achieved:
• 24% of Very Low-Income RHNA allocation;
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
16 • 17% of its Low-Income allocation;
• 9% of its Moderate-Income allocation; and
• 23% of its Above- Moderate-Income allocation.
These figures do not include units currently under construction that have not yet received certificates of occupancy. Notably, Appian Village is not reflected in the completed-unit totals. Upon full buildout, the project is expected to substantially increase RHNA progress, bringing overall attainment to approximately 51 percent of the City's 6th Cycle RHNA obligation.
3.1.3 Preservation/At-Risk Units
The preservation of affordable housing in Pinole has remained relatively stable since adoption of the Housing Element. The City's inventory of monitored deed-restricted affordable housing includes Pinole Grove Senior Housing (69 units), East Bluff (144 units), Westmont of Pinole (37 restricted senior beds), Fernandez Corner (16 units), and Alvarez Court (19 special-needs units), among other properties. Since adoption of the Housing Element, the City's affordable housing inventory has expanded with the completion of Vista Woods Senior Apartments (179 units) and Valor Village (33 units), both of which are now leasing and subject to long-term affordability restrictions.
The 37 restricted senior beds at Westmont of Pinole remain the only affordability-restricted units identified in the Housing Element as approaching covenant expiration, with restrictions scheduled to expire incrementally through December 2028. No other assisted or deed-restricted units have been identified as being at risk of conversion to market-rate housing during the 6th Cycle planning period.
The City continues to monitor compliance with affordability covenants and affordability requirements and utilizes its Low- and Moderate-Income Housing Asset Fund as the primary local tool to support affordable housing preservation, compliance monitoring, and future housing assistance activities.
As a result, the City is expected to maintain the vast majority of its existing deed-restricted affordable housing inventory throughout the remainder of the 6th Cycle Housing Element planning period, while continuing to expand that inventory through newly developed affordable housing projects.
3.1.4 Fair Housing Requirements
Under Assembly Bill 686, the City is required to affirmatively further fair housing (AFFH) by evaluating barriers to fair housing choice and implementing meaningful actions to address identified issues. Pinole's AFFH analysis examines fair housing enforcement and outreach, patterns of integration and segregation, racially and ethnically concentrated areas of poverty and affluence (R/ECAPs and RCAAs), access to opportunity, disproportionate housing needs, and the relationship between RHNA site selection and fair housing outcomes.
The analysis found that Pinole has a moderate dissimilarity index of 31.86 slightly above the threshold for low segregation (30.0) and substantially below the Contra County average of 47.32. The City contains no identified R/ECAPs or RCAAs, and residents generally benefit from access to schools, transportation, employment centers, and other community resources. Fair housing counseling, education, and enforcement services are primarily provided through ECHO Housing and Bay Area Legal Aid.
The City continues to comply with all applicable federal and state fair housing requirements and has incorporated specific Housing Element programs to advance fair housing goals. These include affirmative marketing efforts for new affordable housing opportunities (Program 11), place-based investments and improvements in lower-resource areas (Program 19), and coordination with fair housing service providers to support tenant protections and fair housing education (Program 21). Through these actions, the City seeks to expand housing choice, promote equitable access to opportunity, and reduce barriers to housing for all residents.
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
17 3.2 Summary of Housing Needs
Pinole's housing needs extend beyond the production of new housing units to ensuring that current and future residents have access to safe, stable, and affordable housing opportunities. Through 2031, the City must accommodate a Regional Housing Needs Allocation (RHNA) of approximately 500 new units across all income categories. Pinole's Housing Element has been certified by the California Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) for the current 2023–2031 planning period, and the City remains one of a relatively small number of Bay Area jurisdictions with a development pipeline capable of satisfying its lower-income RHNA obligations.
At the same time, rising home prices and rental costs continue to create affordability challenges, particularly for renters, lower-income households, and first-time homebuyers. Certain populations, including seniors, persons with disabilities, large families, and individuals experiencing homelessness or housing instability, face additional barriers to obtaining and maintaining housing. Addressing these needs requires not only the continued production of housing across all income levels, but also the preservation of existing affordable housing, implementation of fair housing policies, and investment in programs that expand access to opportunity throughout the community.
Understanding where housing needs are greatest, which populations are most affected by housing cost burdens, and how access to opportunity varies across neighborhoods is critical to ensuring that future housing policies and investments effectively serve all Pinole residents.
3.2.1 RHNA Progress
Pinole's 6th Cycle Regional Housing Needs Allocation (RHNA) for the 2023-2031 planning period is 500 housing units, distributed across five income categories:
• 60 Extremely Low-Income (0-30% AMI) units;
• 61 Very Low-Income (30-50% AMI) units;
• 69 Low-Income (50-80% AMI) units;
• 87 Moderate-Income (80-120% AMI) units; and
• 223 Above Moderate-Income (over 120% AMI) units.
As of the 2025 Annual Progress Report (APR), the City has achieved approximately 20% of its overall RHNA allocation, including 24% of its Very Low-Income target, 17% of its Low-Income target, 9% of its Moderate-Income target, and 23% of its Above Moderate-Income target. Progress toward the lower-income RHNA categories has been supported by the completion of two deed-restricted affordable housing developments in 2025: Vista Woods, a 179-unit affordable senior housing community, and Valor Village, a 33-unit affordable housing development serving veterans. Pinole remains among a relatively small number of Bay Area jurisdictions with a development pipeline capable of satisfying its lower-income RHNA obligations. In addition to completed projects, the City has approximately 659 entitled or pending units in its development pipeline. Appian Village (154 units) is currently under construction, while the BCRE Mixed-Use Project (29 units) remains entitled. The previously proposed Pinole Vista project is no longer active and is not included in the City's current housing pipeline.
Accessory dwelling units (ADUs) continue to contribute meaningfully toward RHNA progress. Between 2022 and 2025, the City issued permits for 33 ADUs, averaging approximately 8.25 ADU permits per year, substantially exceeding the three ADUs per year assumed in the Housing Element.
3.2.2 Income Level Targets and Housing Affordability
The RHNA income categories remain the primary framework for evaluating housing needs and housing production. Income limits are updated annually by HCD based on AMI.
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
18 As of June 2025, the Contra Costa County AMI for a four-person household was $159,800. The corresponding affordability thresholds for a four-person household were:
• Extremely low-income households (up to 30% AMI): up to $47,950; • Very low-income households (up to 50% AMI): up to $79,900; • Low-income households (up to 80% AMI): up to $125,050; and • Moderate-income households (up to 120% AMI): up to $191,760.
These income limits have increased substantially since the Housing Element was adopted, reflecting broader wage and income growth throughout the Bay Area. However, housing costs have risen at a similar pace. The median home value in Pinole reached $718,600 in 2024, while median gross rent increased to approximately $2,660 per month, limiting housing affordability for many households despite higher incomes.
Housing cost burden remains a significant challenge. Approximately 53% of renter households are housing cost-burdened, meaning they spend more than 30% of household income on housing costs.
Affordability pressures are most pronounced among extremely low-, very low-, and low-income households, many of whom continue to face a widening gap between household income and prevailing market rents.
The table below summarizes Contra Costa County AMI levels over the past six years for a four-person household over the past six years, based on annual HCD income limit determinations. 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
$119,200 $125,600 $142,800 $147,900 $155,700 $159,800 $162,800
3.2.3 Special Needs Populations
The Housing Element identifies several special needs populations with distinct housing challenges, including seniors, persons with disabilities, large households, female-headed households, and extremely low-income households. These groups continue to represent a significant share of Pinole's unmet housing need and often face additional barriers to obtaining and maintaining stable, affordable housing.
Recent affordable housing production has expanded housing opportunities for several of these populations. Vista Woods, a 179-unit affordable senior housing community restricted to residents age 62 and older, was completed in 2025 and is now leasing. Valor Village, a 33-unit affordable housing development serving veterans, was completed in 2025 and provides permanent housing opportunities for a population that is disproportionately affected by housing instability and homelessness.
Although Pinole's median household income was $120,833 in 2023, community-wide income statistics can mask significant disparities in housing affordability. Extremely low-income households, representing approximately 8 percent of households, continue to face the greatest challenges in accessing housing due to the widening gap between incomes and prevailing housing costs.
3.2.4 Community Members Experiencing Homelessness
Homelessness indicators in Contra Costa County have improved since adoption of the Housing Element.
The 2025 Point-in-Time Count identified 2,118 individuals experiencing homelessness county-wide, representing a 26 percent decrease from 2024. During the same period, the County reported a 34 percent increase in temporary and permanent housing beds, reflecting continued investment in shelter and housing resources.
While Point-in-Time Count data is not published at the city level for Pinole, regional trends suggest improving conditions throughout West County. The completion of Valor Village, which provides 33
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
19 permanent affordable units for unhoused veterans, contributes to the regional effort to reduce housing instability among vulnerable populations.
In July 2025, the City utilized Housing Asset Fund resources under the eligible use category of Homeless Prevention and Rapid Rehousing Services to enter into an agreement with Contra Costa Health's Coordinated Outreach, Referral, and Engagement (CORE) Program. As described in Section 5.1.2, the program provides outreach, navigation, and service referrals to residents experiencing or at risk of experiencing homelessness.
During Fiscal Year 2025-26, the CORE program engaged 44 unduplicated individuals experiencing homelessness in Pinole. Among those served:
• 84 percent reported established ties to Pinole;
• 75 percent reported a disabling condition; and
• 68 percent reported experiencing homelessness for the first time.
These data provide valuable insight into local housing instability and help inform future homeless assistance and prevention efforts.
3.2.5 Evictions and Housing Stability
Pinole does not currently have a local rent stabilization or just-cause eviction ordinance. However, statewide tenant protections established under AB 1482 (the California Tenant Protection Act) continue to apply to many rental properties within the City, limiting annual rent increases to 5% plus the local Consumer Price Index (CPI) change, or a maximum of 10% total, whichever is lower, and establishing minimum tenant protections (such as just-cause for evictions and relocation assistance) for covered units.
Local eviction filing data is limited. Fair housing inquiries, landlord-tenant disputes, and formal fair housing complaints remain important indicators of housing stability. Residents continue to have access to tenant counseling, fair housing education, and legal assistance through ECHO Housing and Bay Area Legal Aid.
Available data from the Contra Costa County Sheriff's Office and the Bay Area Housing Finance Authority (BAHFA) indicate that housing instability remains an important regional issue. According to BAHFA's Eviction Study, Contra Costa County has experienced some of the highest eviction rates among the nine-county Bay Area region in recent years. While the total number of sheriff lockouts in Pinole remains relatively modest compared to larger jurisdictions, Pinole has consistently experienced eviction rates that are above the countywide average and among the higher rates in Contra Costa County. Local lockouts peaked at 33 in 2023 before declining to 32 in 2024 and 21 in 2025. These data suggest a need to continue monitoring housing stability trends and evaluating programs that support tenants and property owners in maintaining stable housing outcomes. See Tables 1-2 and Figures 1-2.
BAHFA attributes these trends in part to regional housing market dynamics. As housing costs in core Bay Area jurisdictions have increased, demand for rental housing has expanded into communities within Contra Costa and Solano Counties, where tenant protections are generally less extensive. Understanding these regional trends will be important as the City evaluates future housing policies and programs.
The BAHFA study also found that renters living in census tracts with majority renter populations of color were significantly more likely to experience a sheriff lockout than renters in majority-white renter census tracts. These findings reinforce the importance of continuing fair housing efforts, tenant education, and housing stabilization programs.
While Pinole-specific causes of eviction are not available, BAHFA identified nonpayment of rent as the most common cause of at-fault evictions throughout the region. This finding highlights the importance of
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
20 rental assistance, homelessness prevention, housing navigation services, and other programs that support both tenants and housing providers in maintaining housing stability and avoiding displacement.
Table 1: Sheriff Lockout order rate by City and County. Lockout data provided by Contra Costa Sheriff; Rental Stock data provided by PropertyRadar 05/02/2025 pull.
Table 2: Total Sheriff Lockouts by City and County. Lockout data provided by Contra Costa Sheriff
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
21 Figure 1: Sheriff Lockouts Issued by TCAC
Opportunity Areas
Figure 2: Sheriff Lockouts Issue Rate and Total
Quantity 2020-2025
3.2.6 Rental v Ownership
Housing tenure in Pinole remains predominantly owner-oriented, with approximately 69 percent of households owning their homes and 31 percent renting. Housing costs continue to present affordability challenges, as the median home value reached $718,600 in 2024 and average monthly rent was approximately $2,339, placing both ownership and rental housing out of reach for many lower-income households without subsidy or housing assistance. The City's development pipeline includes a mix of ownership and rental housing opportunities. Appian Village (154 units) will add for-sale housing, while Vista Woods (179 units), Valor Village (33 units), and the entitled BCRE Mixed-Use Project (29 units) are rental developments. Although the pipeline includes both ownership and rental housing, the majority of deed-restricted affordable units are rental units, reflecting the greater financial feasibility of subsidized multifamily housing development.
3.2.7 Production vs. Preservation
Pinole's housing strategy during the current planning cycle has been driven primarily by new housing production, particularly the development of deed-restricted affordable housing. The completion of Vista Woods (179 units) and Valor Village (33 units) added a combined 212 affordable housing units, representing a substantial expansion of the City's affordable housing inventory and exceeding the affordable housing production achieved during the previous Housing Element cycle.
While production remains the primary focus, preservation efforts continue to play an important role. The City maintains ongoing oversight of its existing deed-restricted affordable housing inventory through Compliance monitoring and affordability covenant tracking. Preservation activities also include support for lower-income homeowners and the potential use of Housing Asset Fund resources for property acquisition, rehabilitation, and affordability preservation opportunities should they arise.
3.2.8 Leveraging External Resources
Pinole continues to leverage regional, state, and federal housing resources to supplement local funding and expand housing opportunities. Through its participation in the Contra Costa Urban County Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Investment Partnerships Program, the City remains eligible for a variety of housing and community development funding sources. Pinole-based affordable housing developers and nonprofit organizations may also access funding opportunities administered by Contra Costa County, including CDBG, HOME, Measure X Housing Funds, and other housing development programs.
The City continues to support housing development through state-funded programs, including California's ADU assistance programs and multifamily housing financing resources administered through CalHFA and other state agencies.
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
22 In addition, the City was designated as a Prohousing Community, and subsequently awarded $650,000 through the Prohousing Incentive Program (PIP). The City was also selected for the Partnership for the Bay's Future Fellowship Program, providing a full-time housing policy fellow during 2025 and 2026 to support housing policy, program implementation, and housing-related capacity building efforts.
3.2.9 High Resource Areas
No changes to Pinole's TCAC/HCD Opportunity Area designations have been identified since adoption of the Housing Element. Under the current TCAC methodology, the City's census tracts continue to be classified primarily as Low- and Moderate-Resource Areas, with no areas designated as High Resource or Highest Resource.
Opportunity indicators vary across the community. Areas in eastern Pinole generally exhibit stronger economic indicators and higher rates of homeownership, while portions of southwestern Pinole score lower on educational opportunity measures. Environmental health indicators are generally lower in areas adjacent to the Interstate 80 corridor and industrial land uses due to transportation-related and environmental factors.
Consistent with the Housing Element and the Three Corridors Specific Plan, much of the City's planned housing growth is focused along the San Pablo Avenue, Pinole Valley Road, and Appian Way corridors.
Concentrating new housing and mixed-use development in these areas is intended to expand access to housing, services, transit, and community amenities, while supporting investments that improve opportunity and quality of life within lower-resource neighborhoods.
4. Community Engagement
The City of Pinole sought public input throughout the development of this Guidebook to ensure that recommended policies and programs reflect community needs, priorities, and experiences. Public engagement efforts included an online survey launched in December 2025, targeted in-person outreach conducted during spring and summer 2026, participation at community events such as the Pride and Juneteenth Celebration, and consultation with the Planning Commission and City Council.
The online survey provided broad initial feedback on housing priorities and program design, while in-person outreach was used to engage a broader cross-section of the community and capture perspectives from residents who may be underrepresented in traditional online engagement. Detailed survey instruments, response data, and comparative analyses are provided in Addendum A.
The Community Development Department also solicited feedback from the Planning Commission to ensure that proposed policies align with the City's housing goals, Housing Element objectives, and broader community development priorities.
4.1 Online Survey
The City received responses from 151 residents through the online survey. While the online survey generated the largest number of responses, the respondent profile did not fully reflect the City's overall demographic and housing characteristics. Compared to the City as a whole, online respondents were more likely to be homeowners, older adults, and White residents. As a result, the City supplemented the online survey with targeted in-person outreach efforts designed to capture a broader range of community perspectives and housing experiences.
Among online respondents, 12 percent identified as renters, compared to approximately 31 percent of households citywide. The average age of online respondents was 58.5 years, compared to the Citywide average of 43.8 years. Racial and ethnic representation also differed from Census estimates, indicating the need for additional outreach to ensure more representative community participation.
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
23 Housing Types Needed
Online respondents most frequently identified the need for:
• Senior housing
• Affordable homeownership opportunities
• Green and energy-efficient housing
Affordable rental housing, mixed-income housing, market-rate housing, and family-sized housing were more commonly identified as housing types for which the City has either the "right amount" or a lesser need.
Housing Production
Opinions regarding the pace of housing development were mixed:
• 37% believed housing growth is occurring too quickly; • 32% felt the pace is about right;
• 20% felt growth is occurring too slowly; and
• 11% expressed no opinion.
Housing Affordability
A majority of respondents (59%) agreed that housing affordability is a problem for families, seniors, and other residents of Pinole. When asked to identify Pinole's most important housing need:
• 37% indicated they did not believe the City currently faces a significant housing need; • 33% identified affordable housing;
• 27% identified senior housing; and
• 20% identified family housing.
Role of the City
When asked how the City should support housing needs, respondents most frequently selected:
• Make it easier to build housing (50%);
• Support rental assistance or first-time homebuyer programs (36%); and • Offer financial support such as incentives, fee waivers, loans, or grants (31%).
Personal Housing Experiences
The most frequently identified housing challenges included:
• Trouble making home repairs (40%);
• Housing costs that are too high or unaffordable (37%); • Difficulty renovating a home (33%); and
• Difficulty keeping a property in compliance with City regulations (28%).
Only 6 percent reported difficulty finding rental housing, and no online respondents reported experiencing an eviction or threat of eviction.
4.2 Targeted In-Person Community Outreach
To supplement online engagement, City staff conducted targeted in-person outreach through community events, pop-up engagement opportunities, and other public gatherings. These efforts were designed to engage a broader cross-section of residents and better capture the experiences of renters, lower-income households, and residents living in areas with greater concentrations of housing instability.
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
24 A significantly larger share of in-person respondents identified as renters, with 56 percent reporting that they rented their housing in Pinole. In-person respondents also included a higher proportion of residents from lower-income neighborhoods and areas experiencing higher rates of eviction and housing-related challenges.
Compared to online respondents, in-person participants expressed greater concern regarding housing affordability and the need for additional affordable housing. • 67% agreed that housing affordability is a problem for families, seniors, and other residents of Pinole, compared with 59% of online respondents.
• 71% identified affordable housing as Pinole's most important housing need, compared with 33% of online respondents.
• Only 5% indicated that Pinole does not face significant housing needs, compared with 37% of online respondents.
Differences were also apparent when respondents were asked about their personal housing experiences.
Among in-person respondents:
• 57% reported experiencing high or unaffordable housing costs; • 33% reported difficulty finding rental housing; and
• 19% reported experiencing an eviction or threat of eviction.
These responses were substantially higher than those reported through the online survey and highlight the importance of conducting outreach through multiple engagement methods.
4.3 Engagement Takeaways
While respondents expressed differing views regarding the pace of future housing development and the severity of Pinole's housing challenges, both online and in-person participants consistently identified housing affordability as a significant community concern.
Across engagement formats, residents expressed support for:
• Increasing housing affordability;
• Expanding homeownership opportunities;
• Preserving and rehabilitating existing housing;
• Providing housing-related education and resources;
• Supporting rental assistance and first-time homebuyer programs; and • Streamlining permitting and development processes to facilitate housing production.
Respondents also identified zoning updates and permit streamlining as important strategies for addressing housing needs, reinforcing ongoing City efforts to modernize development regulations and facilitate housing construction.
In-person outreach highlighted additional concerns related to housing instability. Notably, 19 percent of in-person respondents reported experiencing an eviction or threat of eviction, suggesting a need for continued evaluation of housing stabilization strategies, including rental assistance, tenant education, homelessness prevention services, and other anti-displacement measures.
The findings from both engagement efforts informed the policy recommendations contained in Section 5 of this Guidebook. Together, the results indicate strong support for programs that increase housing
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
25 affordability, expand housing choice, preserve existing affordable housing, and help residents remain stably housed within the community.
5. Housing Successor Fund Priorities and Implementation Framework
The Housing Successor Fund is one of several tools available to the City to support affordable housing, housing stability, and compliance with state housing requirements. This section identifies existing activities funded or administered by the City, as well as programs and policy concepts that may merit future consideration.
The programs, funding concepts, and policy considerations described in this section are provided for planning purposes only. Inclusion in this Guidebook does not constitute authorization, appropriation, or commitment of Housing Asset Fund resources. Implementation of any program or expenditure remains subject to City Council direction, annual budget approval, funding availability, legal requirements, and staff capacity.
5.1 Existing Programs and Ongoing Commitments
These programs are currently funded, operational, or required to support Housing Successor responsibilities.
5.1.1 Affordable Housing Consulting Services
Status: Active Annual Contract
Description: The City contracts with RSG, Inc. to provide affordable housing consulting services supporting Housing Successor compliance and program administration. Services include annual monitoring of 433 income-restricted housing units, preparation of required Housing Successor reports, regulatory compliance assistance, and support for affordable ownership programs. RSG also assists with resale and refinance review for affordable ownership units and develops public‑facing educational materials as needed.
The contract helps ensure continued compliance with state requirements while supporting long-term stewardship of the City's affordable housing portfolio.
Current Annual Funding: $64,200 Housing Asset Fund (FY 2025-26)
5.1.2 Coordinated Outreach, Referral and Engagement (CORE) Program Status: Active Annual Contract
Description: The City participates in a regional partnership supporting Contra Costa Health's CORE program. The program conducts outreach to individuals experiencing homelessness, facilitates connections to housing resources and supportive services, and assists residents in accessing the County's coordinated entry system.
Continuation of this program supports homelessness prevention and housing stabilization efforts throughout the community.
Current Annual Funding: $51,137 Housing Asset Fund (FY 2025-26)
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
26 5.1.3 Housing Successor Real Property Portfolio
Status: Ongoing Administration
Description: The Housing Successor continues to manage real property assets transferred from the former Redevelopment Agency in accordance with state law and existing legal obligations.
Key properties include:
• The Pinole Grove Senior Housing open space parcel; and • The Faria House property;
The Housing Successor has fulfilled disposition requirements for two additional sites in recent years:
the Collins House property at 612 Tennent Avenue, rehabilitated into a fourplex with one affordable unit (and currently constructing an ADU) and the 811 San Pablo Avenue parcel, which was conveyed under a Development and Disposition Agreement (DDA) and successfully developed by SAHA into 33 affordable units prioritized for unhoused veterans.
Ongoing management of these assets supports compliance with Housing Successor requirements while preserving future affordable housing opportunities where appropriate.
5.1.4 Housing Successor Loan Portfolio
Status: Ongoing Administration
Description: The Housing Successor maintains a portfolio of outstanding affordable housing and homeownership loans, including developer notes, rehabilitation loans, and historic first-time homebuyer loans. Through FY24/25 the Housing Asset Fund held $4,380,000 in developer notes, representing four loans originally issued to affordable housing developers; these loans are repaid from residual receipts when properties generate sufficient annual cash flow. An allowance for uncollectable notes is applied to three of the four loans to account for the possibility of non‑repayment, consistent with standard accounting practice. The portfolio also includes $259,552 in outstanding first‑time homebuyer and housing rehabilitation loans with maturity dates extending through 2099, offering continued affordability support for Pinole households.
These investments provide a long-term affordable housing resource and may generate repayments that can be reinvested into future housing activities.
5.2 Near-Term Program Opportunities
The following concepts are generally consistent with Housing Element policies, community feedback, and eligible Housing Asset Fund uses. See Section 5 introduction regarding implementation and funding authorization.
5.2.1 Inclusionary Housing In-Lieu Fee Option
Description: Housing Element Program 7 directs the City to evaluate an in-lieu fee alternative to the current inclusionary housing requirements.
The City completed a feasibility analysis evaluating whether residential developments could support an in-lieu fee while remaining financially viable. The analysis found that a citywide replacement of the existing inclusionary housing requirements with an in-lieu fee would not generate sufficient revenue to offset the affordable housing units that would otherwise be provided on-site. However, the analysis indicated that a more limited in-lieu fee program focused on smaller residential developments may be
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
27 feasible and could generate supplemental affordable housing funding while preserving flexibility for projects that may not be well suited to providing on-site affordable units.
At the time of preparation of this Guidebook, the City is also considering updates to its Inclusionary Housing Ordinance, including modifications to the applicability and structure of the City's affordable housing requirements and potential implementation of an in-lieu fee option for certain residential projects. These efforts are intended to support affordable housing production throughout the community while balancing housing feasibility, Housing Element commitments, and evolving state housing requirements. Any changes to the City's inclusionary housing requirements or adoption of an in-lieu fee program would require separate public review, Planning Commission consideration, and City Council approval. See Section 5 introduction regarding implementation and funding authorization.
Illustrative Annual Revenue Potential: Based on residential development activity between 2019 and 2025, an in-lieu fee program applicable to single-family residential projects could have generated approximately $25,000 to $40,000 annually, depending on development activity and housing market conditions. Actual revenues would fluctuate substantially from year to year and should not be relied upon as a guaranteed funding source.
5.2.2 Tenant Retention Assistance Program
Description: Community engagement findings, CORE program data, and regional housing trends suggest that some Pinole residents experience housing instability due to temporary financial emergencies, unexpected expenses, or other short-term barriers to maintaining housing.
Several Contra Costa County jurisdictions participate in housing stabilization or tenant retention programs that provide limited financial assistance to households facing an immediate risk of displacement. These programs are generally designed to address one-time barriers to housing stability, such as rental arrears, utilities, transportation costs, license renewal fees, medical expenses, or other circumstances that may lead to a loss of housing.
One potential model is the Contra Costa County Housing Security Fund, which includes city-specific set-aside contributions from participating jurisdictions. For example, the City of El Cerrito contributes annual funding that may be used to assist income-qualified residents experiencing housing instability.
According to County staff, the program typically supports six to eight households annually, with average assistance amounts of approximately $2,500 per household.
Should the City wish to explore a similar approach in the future, staff could evaluate establishing a Pinole-specific set-aside within an existing County-administered housing stabilization program. Under this approach, the City could leverage its existing partnership with Contra Costa Health's Coordinated Outreach, Referral, and Engagement (CORE) Program, which would administer the program, conduct eligibility screening, coordinate case management, and facilitate assistance to qualifying households.
This model could minimize administrative burden on City staff while leveraging existing County infrastructure and housing stabilization expertise.
Illustrative Funding Level: Approximately $25,000 annually, subject to Council direction and annual budget approval.
5.2.3 Affordable Housing Notice of Funding Availability (NOFA) The City may periodically elect to issue a Notice of Funding Availability (NOFA) to solicit affordable housing development proposals and strategically deploy Housing Asset Fund resources.
A NOFA process allows the City to competitively evaluate development proposals and identify projects that best advance local housing goals while leveraging outside funding sources. Depending on the
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
28 City's priorities, a NOFA may be used to support new affordable rental housing, affordable homeownership opportunities, acquisition-rehabilitation projects, permanent supportive housing, or mixed-income developments.
Based on prior consultant estimates, preparation and administration of a NOFA process, including developer solicitation, proposal evaluation, interviews, negotiations, and agreement review, could cost approximately $90,000 per funding cycle. Actual costs would vary depending on the complexity of the solicitation, number of proposals received, and extent of negotiations required.
A NOFA process may be particularly appropriate when the City seeks to:
• Encumber Housing Asset Fund balances;
• Advance affordable housing production goals;
• Address Excess Surplus concerns;
• Leverage state, federal, and private financing sources; or • Assist affordable housing developers with project feasibility gaps.
Illustrative Funding Level: Approximately $90,000 per funding cycle, in addition to any Housing Asset Fund resources awarded through the solicitation process.
5.2.4 Fair Housing Education and Outreach
Description: The Housing Element identifies fair housing education and outreach as an important component of the City's Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing (AFFH) responsibilities. Housing Element Housing Element Program 20 ("Fair Housing Resources and Services") directs the City to advertise the services of and collaborate with the County's contracted fair housing provider, currently ECHO Housing, while expanding public awareness of fair housing rights, responsibilities, and resources.
The City currently distributes fair housing information, refers fair housing complaints to qualified service providers, and supports outreach efforts intended to increase awareness of housing rights and available services. Building upon these existing efforts, the City may continue exploring partnerships with organizations such as ECHO Housing, Bay Area Legal Aid, Northern California Land Trust, and other housing service providers to expand access to housing-related information and education.
Potential activities may include:
• Hosting an annual fair housing workshop in partnership with the County's fair housing provider or another qualified fair housing organization;
• Promoting ECHO Housing's Regional Fair Housing Trainings for tenants, landlords, service providers, and local government staff;
• Providing educational materials regarding fair housing protections, housing discrimination, fair housing testing, mediation and arbitration services, reporting procedures, tenant and landlord rights and responsibilities, habitability issues, and best rental practices; • Expanding access to fair housing information through presentations, community outreach, multilingual print materials, prerecorded workshops, and online resources; • Continuing distribution of fair housing materials at City Hall, the Pinole Library, the Pinole Senior Center, and on the City's website;
• Continuing referral of fair housing complaints to ECHO Housing or other qualified fair housing service providers; and
• Supporting language accessibility through translation and interpretation services, including notices regarding the availability of language assistance and periodic review of community language needs.
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
29 These efforts support the City's Housing Element commitments, help residents better understand their housing rights and responsibilities, and promote equitable access to housing opportunities throughout the community.
Illustrative Funding Level: Approximately $1,000 annually from the Housing Asset Fund and $5,000 from other City resources, subject to future budget approval.
5.3 Future Policy Considerations
The following concepts represent housing tools used by other jurisdictions and organizations that may warrant future evaluation. These concepts vary significantly in cost, staffing requirements, and legal complexity. See Section 5 introduction regarding implementation and funding authorization.
5.3.1 Administrative Capacity and Program Management
Description: Housing Successor responsibilities have expanded as affordable housing production, compliance obligations, and housing-related funding opportunities have increased.
Historically, Housing Successor administrative resources have been used to support consultant services, program administration, and limited staff capacity. Future needs may include affordable housing compliance monitoring, grant administration, housing program implementation, real property management, and coordination with development partners.
The City may periodically evaluate whether existing staffing resources remain sufficient to administer Housing Successor programs, pursue external funding opportunities, manage housing assets, and oversee compliance activities.
Any future staffing modifications would require separate review by the City Council.
Illustrative Funding Level: State law permits Housing Successor agencies to expend up to the applicable annual administrative cost limit on eligible administrative activities. For calendar year 2025 (Fiscal Year 2024-25), the inflation-adjusted administrative cost limit is $270,700.
5.3.2 Homeownership Assistance Program
Description: Homeownership assistance programs are commonly used to support income-qualified households that are able to afford a mortgage payment but face challenges accumulating sufficient down payment or closing cost funds.
Programs may take several forms, including deferred-payment loans, shared-equity models, forgivable loans, or partnerships with nonprofit organizations and state funding programs.
Northern California Land Trust and other regional organizations currently administer homeownership assistance programs that utilize deed restrictions and affordability covenants to preserve long-term affordability. State programs such as CalHome similarly provide deferred-payment financing to eligible households.
Given Pinole's median home values and limited ownership opportunities for lower-income households, future evaluation of homeownership assistance options may be warranted should dedicated funding or partnership opportunities become available.
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
30 Illustrative Funding Level: $100,000-$250,000 annually, potentially supporting one to three income-qualified homebuyers per year depending on program design, home prices, and leveraged funding sources. Funds may be structured as deferred-payment loans or revolving assistance funds to maximize long-term affordability impacts. Any use of Housing Asset Funds for this program would require long-term affordability covenants to be placed on the property.
5.3.3 Community Land Trust Partnerships
Description: Community Land Trusts (CLTs) are nonprofit organizations that acquire and retain ownership of land while allowing homes located on that land to remain permanently affordable through long-term resale restrictions.
This structure removes the underlying land value from speculative market pressures and can provide affordability benefits to multiple generations of homeowners. Throughout California, CLTs have been used to preserve affordability, support homeownership opportunities, and facilitate community stewardship of land.
Several Bay Area organizations, including Northern California Land Trust and Richmond LAND, are actively developing and managing community land trust properties. Richmond LAND has also worked with the City of Richmond on policies supporting equitable public land disposition and community ownership models.
Future opportunities to partner with community land trusts may warrant evaluation if acquisition, rehabilitation, preservation, or affordable homeownership opportunities arise within Pinole.
Illustrative Funding Level: Potential future partnership funding to be determined based on project opportunities and available resources.
5.3.4 Tenant Protection Policy Review
Description: The City currently relies primarily on state tenant protections established through the California Tenant Protection Act of 2019 (AB 1482) and other state housing laws. AB 1482 applies to many rental units within the City and limits annual rent increases to 5 percent plus the local Consumer Price Index (CPI), or 10 percent total, whichever is lower. The law also establishes just-cause eviction requirements and relocation assistance requirements for certain no-fault evictions.
In 2026, the City launched its Residential Health and Safety Inspection Program. In addition to supporting habitability, code compliance, and resident health and safety objectives, the program is expected to provide an important source of local housing data. Through annual registration and inspection activities, the City will collect information on rental housing conditions, rental rates, occupancy characteristics, and other housing-related demographic indicators.
Because the program is newly implemented, the City may benefit from collecting and evaluating several years of local data before determining whether additional local housing policies or programs should be considered. This information will provide decision-makers with a clearer understanding of local housing market conditions, affordability trends, rent growth, housing quality, housing stability, displacement pressures, and potential gaps in existing tenant protections.
As regional housing conditions evolve, the City may periodically review tenant protection policies adopted by neighboring jurisdictions and evaluate whether any additional measures may be appropriate for local conditions. Potential areas for future study could include:
• Rental housing affordability trends;
• Tenant retention and housing stabilization programs;
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
31 • Housing quality and habitability conditions;
• Relocation assistance practices;
• Tenant education and outreach efforts;
• Eviction and displacement trends; and
• Other strategies intended to promote housing stability.
The primary objective of this effort is to develop a reliable, locally informed understanding of Pinole's rental housing market and housing stability conditions so that future policy discussions, if warranted, can be based on objective data, community needs, and demonstrated local conditions.
Illustrative Funding Level: No additional Housing Asset Fund allocation is recommended at this time.
Data collection and monitoring activities are expected to occur through the City's Residential Health and Safety Inspection Program. Any future studies, consultant analyses, or policy evaluations would be considered through the City's regular planning and budget processes.
5.3.5 Evaluation of Additional Eviction Protections
Description: California's Tenant Protection Act of 2019 (AB 1482) currently provides baseline tenant protections for many renters in Pinole. The law requires landlords of covered rental units to provide a legally recognized "just cause" for eviction after a tenant has continuously occupied a unit for at least 12 months. AB 1482 distinguishes between at-fault evictions, such as nonpayment of rent, violations of lease terms, or nuisance activity, and no-fault evictions, such as owner move-in, substantial rehabilitation, withdrawal of the property from the rental market, or compliance with government orders requiring vacancy. In many no-fault eviction situations, landlords must also provide relocation assistance equal to one month's rent.
Available data from the Contra Costa County Sheriff's Office and the Bay Area Housing Finance Authority (BAHFA) indicate that housing instability remains an important regional issue. While the total number of sheriff lockouts in Pinole remains relatively modest compared to larger jurisdictions, Pinole has experienced eviction rates that are consistently above the countywide average and among the higher rates in Contra Costa County in recent years. At the same time, local data regarding the causes of eviction, tenant displacement patterns, rent burdens, and long-term housing outcomes remains limited.
The City's Residential Health and Safety Inspection Program provides an opportunity to better understand local rental housing conditions over time. Through annual registration and inspection activities, the City expects to collect information regarding rental housing conditions, rental costs, occupancy characteristics, and other housing-related indicators. Coupled with future eviction trend analysis and community engagement efforts, this information can help create a more complete picture of housing stability conditions within Pinole.
As additional local data becomes available, the City should periodically monitor and evaluate:
• Rental housing affordability trends;
• Eviction and displacement patterns;
• Housing stability indicators;
• Tenant retention and homelessness prevention outcomes; • Housing quality and habitability conditions; and
• Policy approaches and best practices implemented by neighboring jurisdictions.
The objective of this effort is to develop a reliable, locally informed understanding of housing stability conditions in Pinole so that future policy discussions, program development, and resource allocation decisions can be based on objective data, community needs, and demonstrated local conditions.
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
32 Illustrative Funding Level: No additional Housing Asset Fund allocation is recommended at this time.
Data collection and monitoring activities are expected to occur through the City's Residential Health and Safety Inspection Program and existing housing programs. Any future studies, consultant analyses, or policy evaluations would be considered through the City's regular planning and budget processes.
5.3.6 Evaluation of Tenant Legal Assistance Programs
Description: Several jurisdictions throughout the Bay Area provide funding for legal assistance programs that support tenants navigating eviction proceedings, housing disputes, habitability issues, fair housing complaints, and other housing-related legal matters.
Legal services are commonly delivered through existing nonprofit legal service providers, such as Bay Area Legal Aid, the East Bay Community Law Center, and similar organizations. Some jurisdictions fund limited legal consultation services, tenant education clinics, or referral programs, while others have adopted more comprehensive right-to-counsel programs for tenants facing eviction. Jurisdictions can partner with a non-profit as well to provide enhanced services to the community.
Research conducted by housing advocacy and legal service organizations has found that tenants are significantly less likely than landlords to have legal representation during eviction proceedings.
Jurisdictions that have implemented tenant legal assistance programs have reported improved housing stability outcomes and, in some cases, reductions in displacement and homelessness.
In Pinole, eviction activity remains relatively limited in absolute numbers compared to larger cities.
However, community engagement findings, regional eviction trends, and data from the Bay Area Housing Finance Authority suggest that housing instability remains a concern for some residents. Legal assistance may serve as one component of a broader housing stabilization strategy by helping tenants understand their rights, access available resources, and resolve housing disputes before they result in displacement.
At this time, no recommendation is made regarding the creation of a City-funded right-to-counsel program. Should housing instability or eviction trends become a greater local concern, the City may wish to further evaluate legal assistance models, partnership opportunities, service demand, administrative requirements, and available funding sources.
Potential future approaches could include:
• Funding a limited legal assistance referral program;
• Partnering with existing nonprofit legal service providers; • Supporting periodic tenant legal clinics or workshops; • Expanding referrals through existing City housing programs; or • Evaluating a targeted legal defense program for vulnerable populations experiencing housing instability.
Illustrative Funding Level: Approximately $30,000-$35,000 annually could support a limited legal assistance partnership or pilot program serving Pinole residents. Actual costs would depend on the service model selected, number of households served, and availability of partner organizations. Any future program would require additional analysis, funding identification, and City Council direction prior to implementation.
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
33 6. Housing Asset Fund Funding Framework
The Housing Successor Low- and Moderate-Income Housing Asset Fund provides the City with a flexible resource to support affordable housing development, preservation, homelessness prevention, fair housing activities, and program administration. Consistent with state law, expenditures from the Housing Asset Fund must serve households earning up to 80 percent of Area Median Income and comply with all applicable Housing Successor requirements.
As of Fiscal Year 2024-25, the Housing Asset Fund maintains an estimated balance of approximately $3.5 million, in addition to outstanding housing-related loan assets and receivables. Given the limited availability of affordable housing resources and the significant cost of housing development in the Bay Area, the City should continue to prioritize investments that achieve the greatest long-term housing benefit while leveraging additional outside funding sources whenever possible.
This Guidebook does not authorize the expenditure of Housing Asset Fund resources. All expenditures remain subject to annual budget approval by the City Council, applicable state law, funding availability, and evaluation of competing housing priorities.
6.1 Funding Priorities
Consistent with Program 7 of the Housing Element, community engagement findings, and Housing Successor requirements, the City should generally prioritize Housing Asset Fund expenditures in the following order:
Priority 1: Preservation and Expansion of Affordable Housing Affordable housing development and preservation activities typically provide the greatest long-term community benefit and remain the primary eligible use of Housing Successor resources. Examples may include:
• Affordable rental housing development;
• Affordable homeownership opportunities;
• Acquisition and rehabilitation projects;
• Community Land Trust partnerships;
• Gap financing for affordable housing developments; and • Preservation of existing affordability-restricted housing. • Notice of Funding Availability (NOFA) processes used to identify and fund affordable housing development opportunities.
Priority 2: Homelessness Prevention and Housing Stability Housing stabilization efforts can help prevent displacement and reduce future homelessness among vulnerable households. Examples may include:
• CORE Program services;
• Tenant retention assistance;
• Homelessness prevention programs;
• Housing navigation services; and
• Other eligible rapid rehousing activities.
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
34 Priority 3: Fair Housing and Community Education
Fair housing education and outreach support the City's Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing obligations and improve access to housing opportunities. Examples may include:
• Fair housing workshops;
• Language accessibility services;
• Educational materials and outreach campaigns; and
• Partnerships with fair housing service providers.
Ongoing Priority: Program Administration and Compliance Administrative expenditures are necessary to ensure legal compliance, stewardship of Housing Successor assets, and successful implementation of affordable housing programs. Examples may include:
• Affordable housing compliance monitoring;
• Housing Successor reporting;
• Consultant services;
• Asset management; and
• Program administration.
6.2 Existing Annual Commitments
The City currently maintains several ongoing Housing Asset Fund commitments.
6.2.1 Ongoing Housing Asset Fund commitments
Housing Asset Fund Program Eligible Use Category FY 2025-26 Allocation
Affordable Housing Compliance
Monitoring Services
Administrative Costs $39,265
Housing Successor Annual Report Administrative Costs $6,725 Housing Fund Consultation / Advisory
Services
Administrative Costs $5,500
Affordable Housing Educational
Materials
Administrative Costs $5,125
Loan Coordination (Resale &
Refinance Assistance)
Administrative Costs $7,585
Legal Services Administrative Costs $8,000
Utilities/Salary Overhead Allocation Administrative Costs $61,297 Total Committed Administrative Costs $133,497
Maximum Administrative Cost Allowance $270,700
Remaining Administrative Capacity $137,203
Property Disposition Affordable Housing
Development
$20,000
Total Affordable Housing Development Commitments $20,000 CORE Program Homeless Prevention and Rapid
Rehousing Services
$51,137
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
35 Total Homeless Prevention & Rapid Rehousing Commitments $51,137 Maximum Available Homeless Prevention and
Rapid Rehousing Services Costs
$500,000
Remaining Homeless Prevention & Rapid Rehousing Capacity $448,863
6.2.2 Available Resources
As of Fiscal Year 2024-25, the Housing Asset Fund maintained an estimated balance of approximately $3.5 million, in addition to outstanding housing-related loan assets and receivables. Because affordable housing development expenditures are not subject to a fixed annual spending cap, the balance available for future affordable housing development activities is primarily determined by available fund balance, statutory income-targeting requirements, excess surplus limitations, and City Council funding priorities.
Total Existing Annual Commitments: $204,634
Estimated Housing Asset Fund Balance Available for Future Housing Opportunity Investments:
Approximately $3.3 million, subject to annual revenues, loan repayments, interest earnings, future appropriations, and legal restrictions on eligible expenditures.
6.3 Illustrative Future Funding Considerations
The following funding levels are presented for planning purposes only and do not represent adopted City policy or approved future expenditures.
Program Illustrative Funding Level
Inclusionary Housing In-Lieu Fee Program Revenue Source: Approximately $25,000-$40,000 annually
Tenant Retention Assistance Program Expenditure: Approximately $25,000 annually Fair Housing Education and Outreach Expenditure: Approximately $1,000 Housing Asset Fund contribution annually
Homeownership Assistance Program Expenditure: Approximately $100,000-$250,000 annually
Community Land Trust Partnerships Expenditure: To Be Determined Tenant Legal Assistance Program Expenditure: Approximately $30,000-$35,000 annually
Affordable Housing Notice of Funding Availability
(NOFA)
Expenditure: Approximately $90,000 per funding
cycle
Actual funding needs, program design, and implementation timing would be determined through future City Council actions and annual budget discussions.
6.4 Leveraging External Resources
Given the high cost of housing development and preservation, the City should continue seeking opportunities to leverage Housing Asset Fund resources with outside funding sources whenever possible.
Potential funding partners and programs include:
• Contra Costa County CDBG and HOME programs;
• Measure X Housing Funds;
• California Department of Housing and Community Development funding programs;
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
36 • CalHome and other homeownership assistance programs; • Affordable housing tax credit programs;
• Philanthropic and nonprofit partnerships; and
• Partnership for the Bay's Future initiatives.
Leveraging local funds with external resources can increase the impact of Housing Asset Fund investments and improve the financial feasibility of affordable housing projects.
6.5 Fiscal Stewardship
The Housing Asset Fund represents one of the City's most important long-term housing resources. While annual administrative and housing stabilization expenditures provide valuable community benefits, affordable housing development and preservation opportunities typically require substantial capital investment and may arise unpredictably.
Accordingly, the City should maintain sufficient reserves to respond to future affordable housing opportunities, leverage competitive grant funding, and support projects that provide long-term affordability benefits to Pinole residents. Funding decisions should be evaluated based on consistency with Housing Element goals, Housing Successor requirements, fair housing objectives, community needs, and the potential long-term impact of the investment.
DRAFT Housing Asset Fund
Policy Guidebook
37 References:
Baker International, Michael, and Daniel K Wery. Pinole, CA, 2023, City of Pinole Housing Element 2023- 2031, https://www.pinole.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/PinoleHEU_Compliant_Clean-1.pdf.
Accessed 2026.
Blount, Casey, et al. “Silhouette of Cityscape Redevelopment Agencies in California:” US Department of Housing and Urban Development, Jan. 2014,
www.huduser.gov/portal/publications/redevelopment_whitepaper.pdf. Accessed 30 June 2026. “CalHOME Program | California Department of Housing and Community Development.” Hcd.ca.Gov, California Department of Housing and Community Development, www.hcd.ca.gov/funding/calhome. Accessed 30 June 2026.
California Assembly Bill No. 1482, 2019-2020 Reg. Sess. (2019) https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtml?bill_id=201920200AB1482. Accessed 30 June 2026.
“Eden Council for Hope and Opportunity - Home.” Eden Council for Hope and Opportunity, www.echofairhousing.org/. Accessed 30 June 2026.
“Home Match – Front Porch.” FrontPorch, frontporch.net/live/home-match/. Accessed 30 June 2026. “Housing Security Fund.” Contra Costa Health, www.cchealth.org/services-and-programs/homeless-services/how-to-help/donate/housing-security-fund. Accessed 30 June 2026. “Housing Successor Annual Report; City of Pinole; Fiscal Year 2024-2025.” Pinole.Gov, City of Pinole, Mar. 2026, www.pinole.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/Pinole-2024-25-HSA-Annual-Report_Final.pdf. Accessed 30 June 2026. “Just Cause for Eviction Ordinance.” City of Oakland, www.oaklandca.gov/Community/Housing-Programs-Support/Evictions-and-Tenant-Rights/Managing-Evictions-For-Landlords/Read-the-Just-Cause-for-Eviction-Ordinance. Accessed 30 June 2026. “Legal Assistance for Tenants | Eviction Defense Collaborative.” Eviction Defense, evictiondefense.org/legal-assistance-services/. Accessed 30 June 2026. “No Eviction without Representation | American Civil Liberties Union.” ACLU.Org, American Civil Liberties Union, May 2022, www.aclu.org/publications/no-eviction-without-representation. Accessed 30 June 2026.
“Northern California Land Trust — About.” Nclt.Org, Northern California Land Trust, www.nclt.org/about.
Accessed 30 June 2026.
“Redevelopment Agency Dissolution .” Department of Finance, California Department of Finance, dof.ca.gov/programs/redevelopment/. Accessed 30 June 2026. “Redevelopment Agency History.” Auditor Controller - Los Angeles County, County of Los Angeles, 2017, auditor.lacounty.gov/redevelopment-agency-history/. Accessed 30 June 2026. “Richmond Land.” RichmondLand.Org, Richmond Land, www.richmondland.org/. Accessed 30 June 2026.
Robbins, Jenny, and Shelby Ferguson. “Coordinated Outreach Referral and Engagement (CORE): Fiscal Year 2025-2026 Update - Pinole City Council.” Civic Clerk Agenda Minutes, 7 Apr. 2026, pinoleca.portal.civicclerk.com/. Accessed 30 June 2026.
Saver, Daniel. “Bay Area Eviction Study | Metropolitan Transportation Commission.” Metropolitan Transit Commission, Bay Area Housing Finance Authority, July 2025, mtc.ca.gov/about-mtc/authorities/bay-area-housing-finance-authority/bahfa-programs/bay-area-eviction-study.
Accessed 30 June 2026.
Sturm, Sylvie. “Eviction Rates in SF Soar as Legal Aid Faces Deep Funding Cuts.” San Francisco Public Press, https://www.sfpublicpress.org/eviction-rates-in-sf-soar-as-legal-aid-faces-deep-funding-cuts/. Accessed 26 October 2026.
PLANNING COMMISSION
REPORT
DATE: NOVEMBER 9, 2026
TO: CHAIR AND PLANNING COMMISSION MEMBERS
FROM: LILLY WHALEN, COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR
SUBJECT: PUBLIC HEARING TO CONSIDER RECOMMENDATIONS TO THE CITY COUNCIL REGARDING AMENDMENTS TO CHAPTER 17.32 (AFFORDABLE
HOUSING REQUIREMENTS) AND ADOPTION OF AN INCLUSIONARY
HOUSING IN-LIEU FEE SCHEDULE
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends that the Planning Commission:
1. Review all policy recommendations in this report;
2. Make any modifications as appropriate; and
a) Adopt Resolution No. 26-10 (Attachment B) recommending City Council adoption of an Ordinance amending Chapter 17.32 of the Pinole Municipal Code (Affordable Housing Requirements); and
b) Adopt Resolution No. 26-11 (Attachment D) recommending City Council adoption of a Resolution establishing an Inclusionary Housing In-Lieu Fee Schedule
SUMMARY
The City's Inclusionary Housing Ordinance – Chapter 17.32 (Attachment A) currently requires residential developments containing four or more dwelling units to provide affordable housing units equal to 15% of the total units in the project (i.e., a 100-unit project requires 15 of the units to be affordable). The City Council adopted the Ordinance in 2010 and subsequently identified updates to the program through Housing Element Program 7, adopted in 2023 as a part of the City’s certified 2023-2031 Housing Element. The Program directed the City to evaluate modifications to the Ordinance, including the establishment of an affordable housing in-lieu fee as an alternative method of compliance.
To evaluate potential Ordinance amendments and an in-lieu fee program, the City retained RSG, Inc. to prepare an Inclusionary Housing In-Lieu Fee Analysis (Attachment E). The study evaluated affordable housing funding gaps, development feasibility, affordable housing best practices, and alternative compliance mechanisms. The study concluded that an in-lieu fee of $11 per square foot for ownership housing and $9 per square foot for rental housing would maintain development feasibility while generating funding to support affordable housing production and preservation activities within the City.
The proposed Ordinance (Attachment C) would:
I.1.
• Apply inclusionary housing requirements to all residential developments regardless of project size;
• Allow payment of an in-lieu fee as an alternative method of compliance; • Establish procedures governing use of the fee option; • Create an Inclusionary Housing Fund; and
• Maintain a preference for on-site affordable housing production (as opposed to off-site or fee payment in lieu of affordable housing production) while providing flexibility for smaller projects.
The purpose of this hearing is to obtain a recommendation from the Planning Commission to the City Council regarding the proposed Ordinance amendments and fee schedule.
BACKGROUND
Existing Inclusionary Housing Ordinance
Chapter 17.32 of the Pinole Municipal Code currently requires residential developments containing four or more dwelling units to provide affordable housing units equal to 15 percent of the total project units. For rental projects, affordable units are required to be affordable to very-low and low-income households. Ownership projects are required to provide moderate-income affordable units. An alternative compliance option currently exists for off-site construction of affordable housing units. The City currently does not permit payment of an in-lieu fee as an alternative compliance method.
Example Application of Existing Inclusionary Requirements:
Project
Size
(units)
Fractional
Affordable
Units
Required
Affordable
Units
Required
After
Rounding
Up*
Required Affordable Units:
Rental Housing Projects
Required
Affordable
Units:
Ownership
Housing
Very Low
Income Units
Low Income
Units
Moderate
Income Units
1 to 3 None; Not Applicable
4 0.6 1 0 1 1
5 0.75 1 0 1 1
6 0.9 1 0 1 1
7 1.05 2 1 1 2
8 1.2 2 1 1 2
9 1.35 2 1 1 2
10 1.5 2 1 1 2
11 1.65 2 1 1 2
12 1.8 2 1 1 2
13 1.95 2 1 1 2
14 2.1 3 1 2 3
15 2.25 3 1 2 3
Project
Size
(units)
Fractional
Affordable
Units
Required
Affordable
Units
Required
After
Rounding
Up*
Required Affordable Units:
Rental Housing Projects
Required
Affordable
Units:
Ownership
Housing
Very Low
Income Units
Low Income
Units
Moderate
Income Units
20 3 3 1 2 3
50 7.5 8 3 5 8
80 12 12 5 7 12
100 15 15 6 9 15
130 19.5 20 8 12 20
150 22.5 23 9 14 23
180 27 27 11 16 27
200 30 30 12 18 30
*Per PMC Section 17.32.020.D, “Rounding. In determining the number of affordable housing units required by this chapter, any decimal fraction shall be rounded up to the nearest whole number.”
Housing Element Program 7
The City's 2023-2031 Housing Element includes Program 7, which directs the City to evaluate modifications to the Inclusionary Housing Ordinance and consider establishing an affordable housing in-lieu fee option. The objective of the program is to provide flexibility to residential developers while creating a local funding source that can be leveraged to produce affordable housing within the community.
Planning Commission Review
On April 27, 2026, the Planning Commission reviewed preliminary concepts related to implementation of Housing Element Program 7 and affordable housing funding strategies.
During the discussion, Commissioners expressed interest in affordable housing preservation and production strategies, reviewed examples from other jurisdictions, and discussed the potential use of in-lieu fees as a tool for supporting affordable housing goals. Commissioners also discussed the challenge of requiring affordable units within small residential projects and the importance of maintaining development feasibility while expanding affordable housing opportunities.
City Council Review
On July 7, 2026, the City Council reviewed preliminary affordable housing policy concepts and discussed establishment of an Inclusionary Housing Fund that could be leveraged with state, federal, and nonprofit affordable housing funding opportunities. Council members expressed support for creating a dedicated affordable housing funding source and emphasized the importance of implementing policies that balance affordable housing goals with long-term financial sustainability. Council directed staff to return with draft Ordinance language, a proposed fee schedule, and implementation recommendations.
REVIEW AND ANALYSIS
Proposed Ordinance and Fee Summary
The proposed Ordinance (Attachment C) would amend Chapter 17.32 (Affordable Housing Requirements) of the Pinole Municipal Code and establish an affordable housing in-lieu fee as an additional alternative method of compliance with the City's inclusionary housing requirements. The proposed amendments are intended to implement Housing Element Program 7, provide flexibility for residential development projects, and create a dedicated funding source for affordable housing activities within the City.
Proposed Ordinance Amendments
The proposed Ordinance includes the following key changes:
• Applicability to All Residential Development. The current Ordinance applies to residential developments containing four or more dwelling units. The proposed Ordinance would apply inclusionary housing requirements to all residential development projects regardless of project size.
• Maintenance of Existing Inclusionary Housing Requirement. The Ordinance would retain the existing requirement that affordable housing units equal fifteen percent (15%) of total project units. Additionally, these policy requirements would remain:
o For rental housing developments: Forty percent (40%) of the required affordable units must be affordable to very-low-income households and sixty percent (60%) of the required affordable units must be affordable to low-income households.
o For ownership housing developments: One hundred percent (100%) of affordable units must be affordable to moderate-income households. • Addition of an In-Lieu Fee Alternative. The Ordinance would establish payment of an affordable housing in-lieu fee as an alternative method of compliance. The fee amount would be established separately by City Council resolution and may be updated periodically as market conditions change.
• Different Standards Based on Project Size.
o For projects containing 10 dwelling units or fewer, applicants may satisfy all or part of the inclusionary housing requirement through payment of the in-lieu fee.
o For projects containing 11 or more dwelling units, applicants may satisfy all or part of the inclusionary housing requirement through payment of the in-lieu fee only upon demonstration that on-site affordable housing production is financially infeasible, subject to review and approval by the Planning Commission (or City Council on appeal).
• Public Impact Statement Requirement. Applicants proposing to satisfy affordable housing obligations through payment of an in-lieu fee would be required to submit a written public impact statement explaining why on-site affordable housing units are not being provided.
• Establishment of Inclusionary Housing Fund. All in-lieu fee revenues would be deposited into a dedicated Inclusionary Housing Fund. The fund may be used to support affordable housing production, preservation, rehabilitation, site
acquisition, first-time homebuyer assistance programs, homelessness prevention programs, and affordable housing program administration.
Proposed In-Lieu Fee
Based on the findings of the 2026 In-Lieu Fee Study, staff is recommending the following fee schedule:
Housing Type Proposed In-Lieu Fee
Ownership Housing $11 per square foot
Rental Housing $9 per square foot
The total fee would be calculated by multiplying the square footage of all market-rate residential units by the applicable fee rate. Payment of the fee would be required prior to issuance of a building permit.
RSG concluded that these fee levels maintain development feasibility across a range of residential project types while generating funding that can be used to support affordable housing activities within the City. The study further concluded that local fee revenues may be leveraged with state, federal, and nonprofit funding sources to increase affordable housing production opportunities.
Policy Discussion and Planning Commission Considerations The proposed Ordinance and fee schedule present several policy considerations for Planning Commission review and recommendation, as summarized in the graphic below, and further detailed in policy questions 1-7 following the graphic.
1. Policy Question: Should Inclusionary Housing Requirements Apply to All Residential Development?
The proposed Ordinance would amend Chapter 17.32 to apply inclusionary housing requirements to all residential development regardless of project size. This represents a significant policy change from the existing Ordinance, which applies only to developments containing four or more units.
Should
inclusionary
housing apply to
all projects?
Is the fee
amount
appropriate?
Where should
the threshold
be?
What happens
below the
threshold?
What happens
above the
threshold?
Should there be
a minimum
onsite
requirement?
How should
infeasibility be
evaluated?
Policy Consideration
The Commission may wish to consider whether all residential development should contribute toward affordable housing goals regardless of project size.
Potential benefits include:
• Consistent application of affordable housing requirements; • Expanded affordable housing contributions from smaller projects; • Increased participation in affordable housing funding efforts; and • Alignment with Housing Element implementation objectives.
Potential concerns include:
• Additional requirements on very small projects;
• Administrative complexity for small-scale applicants; and • Potential impacts on infill housing development.
Staff Analysis
Staff supports expansion of applicability to all residential development because it aligns with Housing Element goals and ensures all new housing contributes toward affordable housing objectives. The availability of the in-lieu fee option for smaller projects recognizes that very small developments face different economic considerations than larger multifamily projects. Taken together, the Ordinance seeks to broaden participation in affordable housing production while maintaining flexibility for projects where onsite unit construction may be impractical.
2. Policy Question: Does the Commission Support the Proposed In-Lieu Fee Amount?
RSG evaluated six residential development prototypes and determined that the following fee levels represent the maximum fee amounts that maintain development feasibility across the broadest range of housing types:
Housing Type Proposed In-Lieu Fee
Ownership Housing $11 per square foot
Rental Housing $9 per square foot
The fee study prepared by RSG evaluated multiple residential development prototypes representative of housing likely to be developed in Pinole and concluded that these fee levels represent an appropriate balance between affordable housing goals and development feasibility. The study found that higher fees could better approximate the full funding gap associated with affordable unit production, but may discourage residential development. Conversely, lower fees may encourage additional development but generate fewer resources to support affordable housing programs.
Policy Consideration
A key policy decision is whether the in-lieu fee should primarily:
• Maximize affordable housing revenues;
• Maximize residential development feasibility; or
• Balance both objectives.
The proposed fees are intended to function as a feasible alternative to onsite affordable housing production rather than fully replicate the cost of constructing affordable units.
RSG concluded that these fee amounts would allow a wider range of projects to remain financially viable while still contributing toward affordable housing goals.
Staff Analysis
Coupled with the proposed limitation on the number of units eligible to utilize the in-lieu fee option, staff believes the consultant's recommended fee structure appropriately balances the City's objectives of facilitating housing production while ensuring that residential development contributes toward affordable housing goals. The proposed fees establish a dedicated funding source for affordable housing activities without imposing costs that could disproportionately affect the feasibility of smaller-scale residential projects.
3. Policy Question: Is Ten Units the Appropriate Threshold? The proposed Ordinance would allow residential developments containing ten units or fewer to satisfy their inclusionary housing obligation through payment of an in-lieu fee.
Projects containing eleven or more units would generally be expected to provide affordable housing units onsite unless the applicant demonstrates that onsite affordable housing production is financially infeasible.
The ten-unit threshold was identified by RSG as an appropriate transition point between small-scale residential development, where inclusionary housing requirements may disproportionately affect project economics, and larger residential developments that are generally better positioned to integrate affordable housing units into the project design. The threshold is intended to provide flexibility for smaller developments while preserving the City's preference for onsite affordable housing production in larger projects.
Policy Consideration
The Planning Commission may wish to consider whether ten units represents the appropriate balance point between affordable housing production and development feasibility.
Potential considerations include:
Threshold Benefits Considerations
Lower (e.g.,
4-6 units)
• Encourages more onsite
affordable housing
production.
• Increases the number of
mixed-income
developments.
• Reduces reliance on future
expenditure of in-lieu fee
revenues.
• May disproportionately
affect small infill and
"missing middle" housing
projects.
• Could discourage
construction of duplexes,
triplexes, fourplexes, and
similar housing types.
Proposed
Threshold
(10 Units)
• Provides flexibility for
projects where affordable
unit production may
significantly affect
feasibility.
• Supports smaller-scale
housing production while
ensuring participation in
affordable housing efforts.
• Consistent with the
recommendations
evaluated in the RSG
analysis.
• Some affordable units that
could otherwise be
produced onsite may
instead be satisfied
through payment of the in-lieu fee.
Higher
Threshold
(e.g., 15
Units or
Greater)
• Maximizes flexibility for
small and mid-sized
projects.
• Further reduces potential
development constraints.
• May significantly reduce
onsite affordable housing
production.
• Increases reliance on fee
revenues rather than direct
affordable housing unit
construction.
Staff Analysis
Staff believes the proposed ten-unit threshold appropriately balances affordable housing goals with housing production objectives. The threshold recognizes that smaller developments often face unique economic constraints and may have limited ability to absorb the cost of onsite affordable housing units. At the same time, projects containing more than ten units generally have greater flexibility in site planning, financing, and unit mix, making integration of affordable housing units more achievable.
The proposed threshold also complements the Ordinance's broader application to all residential development. By allowing smaller projects access to the in-lieu fee option while maintaining a preference for onsite affordable housing production in larger developments, the Ordinance seeks to broaden participation in affordable housing efforts without disproportionately burdening small-scale infill and missing-middle housing projects. Staff therefore supports retaining the proposed ten-unit threshold.
4. Policy Question: Should Projects Containing Ten Units or Fewer Be Eligible to Satisfy Their Inclusionary Obligation Through Payment of the In-Lieu Fee? The Ordinance proposes allowing projects of ten units or fewer to satisfy their inclusionary housing obligation through payment of the in-lieu fee rather than construction of affordable housing units onsite.
The RSG analysis identified smaller residential developments as presenting unique implementation challenges under inclusionary housing requirements. While the City's inclusionary housing requirement is intended to require affordable units equal to fifteen percent (15%) of project units, application of the City's rounding requirements often results in a single affordable unit representing a substantially larger percentage of a small development. For example, a duplex, triplex, or fourplex would each be required
to provide one affordable housing unit, resulting in an effective affordability requirement ranging from 25% to 50% of the project.
In very small projects, the requirement to provide a single affordable housing unit may have a disproportionate impact on project feasibility because the loss of revenue associated with one income-restricted unit cannot be spread across a larger number of market-rate units. By contrast, larger projects are generally able to distribute the cost of affordable housing across a greater number of units and may be better positioned to absorb inclusionary housing requirements.
Example Application:
Project Size
(units)
Fractional Affordable
Units Required
Affordable Units
Required After
Rounding Up*
Effective
Affordable Unit
Percentage
1 0.15 1 100%
2 0.30 1 50%
3 0.45 1 33%
4 0.60 1 25%
5 0.75 1 20%
6 0.90 1 17%
7 1.05 2 29%
8 1.2 2 25%
9 1.35 2 22%
10 1.5 2 20%
*Per PMC Section 17.32.020.D, “Rounding. In determining the number of affordable housing units required by this chapter, any decimal fraction shall be rounded up to the nearest whole number.”
Under the proposed Ordinance, projects within this size range could instead contribute to affordable housing through payment of the in-lieu fee.
Policy Consideration
The Planning Commission may wish to consider:
• Whether ten units is the appropriate threshold at which projects should be eligible to utilize the in-lieu fee option;
• Whether construction of one or two affordable units within a small project advances affordable housing objectives more effectively than payment of a fee; • Whether the threshold should be increased or reduced; • Whether requiring onsite affordable units in very small projects could discourage infill housing production; and
• Whether application of inclusionary housing requirements to all residential development is best paired with a flexible compliance option for smaller projects.
Staff Analysis
The proposed ten-unit threshold is intended to balance the City's affordable housing objectives with the practical realities of small-scale residential development. While the City's inclusionary housing requirement is fifteen percent of project units, application of
that requirement to very small developments may result in one affordable unit representing a substantially larger portion of the project than intended. For a duplex, triplex, or fourplex, requiring one affordable unit onsite may significantly affect project economics and could discourage the development of smaller infill housing opportunities.
Allowing projects containing ten units or fewer to satisfy their obligation through payment of an in-lieu fee ensures that smaller developments continue to contribute toward affordable housing goals while recognizing the disproportionate impact that onsite inclusionary requirements may have on small projects. The proposed approach provides flexibility for infill and "missing middle" housing projects while creating a dedicated funding source that can be leveraged to support affordable housing initiatives elsewhere in the community.
5. Policy Question: Under What Circumstances Should Projects Containing More Than Ten Units Be Permitted to Utilize the In-Lieu Fee Option? The proposed Ordinance establishes onsite affordable housing production as the preferred method of compliance for larger residential developments. Projects containing eleven or more units would only be eligible to utilize the in-lieu fee option if the applicant demonstrates that onsite affordable housing production is financially infeasible and obtains approval from the Planning Commission or City Council on appeal.
The Ordinance therefore places the burden on the applicant to demonstrate that onsite unit production would make a project infeasible.
Policy Consideration
The Commission may wish to consider whether the proposed approach appropriately balances:
• Production of affordable housing units within private development projects; • Flexibility needed to facilitate housing production;
• Use of locally generated housing revenues; and
• Creation of mixed-income neighborhoods.
The Commission may also consider whether larger projects should generally be expected to integrate affordable housing units onsite because they are better positioned to absorb inclusionary housing requirements than smaller developments.
Staff Analysis
Staff believes larger residential developments should continue to prioritize onsite affordable housing production whenever feasible. Onsite affordable units promote mixed-income neighborhoods, distribute affordable housing opportunities throughout the community, and ensure that affordable housing is constructed concurrently with market-rate development. The proposed Ordinance therefore limits the use of the in-lieu fee for projects containing eleven or more units to situations where the applicant demonstrates that onsite affordable housing production is financially infeasible. This approach seeks to preserve the City's preference for unit production while providing flexibility in circumstances where strict application of the requirement may hinder housing development.
6. Policy Question: Should Larger Projects Be Required to Provide a Minimum Number of Affordable Units Onsite?
The draft Ordinance allows larger projects to request approval for use of the in-lieu fee option if onsite affordable housing production is demonstrated to be financially infeasible. However, the Ordinance does not establish a minimum number or percentage of affordable units that must remain onsite once such a determination is made.
Project Size
(units)
Fractional Affordable
Units Required
Affordable Units
Required After
Rounding Up*
Effective
Affordable Unit
Percentage
15 2.25 3 20%
25 3.75 4 16%
50 7.50 8 16%
75 11.25 12 16%
100 15.00 15 15%
150 22.50 23 15%
200 30.00 30 15%
Under the current draft Ordinance, the Planning Commission could approve use of an in-lieu fee in lieu of some or all onsite affordable housing units if supported by the required findings.
Policy Considerations
The Commission may wish to consider for projects over ten units, whether:
• At least one affordable housing unit should always be provided onsite; • A percentage of the required affordable housing obligation should always remain onsite;
• Larger developments should always be required to provide affordable units onsite unless extraordinary circumstances exist; or
• The proposed case-by-case review process provides adequate discretion without establishing a minimum.
Staff Analysis
This policy question involves balancing two complementary housing objectives.
Requiring some minimum level of onsite affordable housing would further the City's goal of encouraging mixed-income developments and ensuring affordable housing opportunities are integrated throughout the community. Conversely, allowing greater flexibility through use of the in-lieu fee could improve project feasibility in certain circumstances and generate funding that may be leveraged with regional, state, federal, and nonprofit resources to support affordable housing production elsewhere in the City.
Staff is seeking Planning Commission feedback regarding whether preservation of some minimum level of onsite affordable housing should remain a priority when larger projects request alternative compliance.
7. Policy Question: Is the Proposed Financial Infeasibility Review Process Appropriate?
Projects containing eleven or more units that seek approval to utilize the in-lieu fee option would be required to submit an economic analysis demonstrating financial infeasibility. Applicants would also be required to reimburse the City for any consultant costs associated with reviewing the analysis. The Planning Commission would act as the decision-making body, with appeals heard by the City Council.
Policy Consideration
A key consideration is whether the proposed review process establishes sufficient safeguards to ensure the fee option is reserved for circumstances where onsite affordable housing production is genuinely infeasible.
The Commission may wish to consider:
• Whether the burden of proof should remain with the applicant; • Whether independent consultant review should always be required; • Whether Planning Commission review is appropriate; and • Whether additional findings should be established.
Staff Analysis
Staff believes the proposed review process appropriately balances flexibility for applicants with accountability to the City's affordable housing objectives. By requiring a detailed economic analysis, reimbursement of City review costs, and Planning Commission approval, the Ordinance establishes a transparent process that allows consideration of project-specific circumstances while maintaining a high standard for approval. The proposed framework is intended to ensure that requests to utilize the in-lieu fee for larger projects are evaluated based on objective evidence rather than preference alone.
Conclusion
The proposed Ordinance amendments and inclusionary housing in-lieu fee program are intended to expand the City's affordable housing toolkit while balancing housing production, project feasibility, and long-term affordable housing objectives. The proposed framework would extend inclusionary housing requirements to all residential development, establish a new in-lieu fee option, create a dedicated Inclusionary Housing Fund, and provide a mechanism for evaluating alternative compliance requests.
Staff believes the proposed Ordinance and fee schedule provide a balanced approach that encourages continued housing development while ensuring that new residential projects contribute toward the City's affordable housing goals. The proposed structure recognizes the unique challenges associated with small-scale residential development, maintains a preference for onsite affordable housing production in larger developments, and creates a local funding source that may be leveraged to support future affordable housing opportunities.
As part of its recommendation to the City Council, staff requests Planning Commission feedback regarding the following policy considerations:
• Whether inclusionary housing requirements should apply to all residential development regardless of project size;
• Whether the recommended in-lieu fee amounts of $11 per square foot for ownership housing and $9 per square foot for rental housing are appropriate; • Whether ten units represents the appropriate threshold for automatic eligibility to utilize the in-lieu fee option;
• Whether projects containing ten units or fewer should be permitted to satisfy their affordable housing obligation through payment of the in-lieu fee; • Under what circumstances projects containing more than ten units should be permitted to utilize the in-lieu fee option;
• Whether larger developments should be required to provide a minimum number or percentage of affordable units onsite; and
• Whether the proposed financial infeasibility review process provides an appropriate balance between flexibility and accountability.
Following Planning Commission review and recommendation, staff will incorporate the Commission's feedback and present the proposed Ordinance and fee resolution to the City Council for consideration.
ATTACHMENTS
A. Existing PMC Chapter 17.32
B. Resolution No. 26-10 recommending City Council adoption of an Ordinance amending Chapter 17.32 of the Pinole Municipal Code (Affordable Housing Requirements) (note:
Exhibit A is Attachment C, and will be appended to the Resolution after Planning Commission’s review)
C. Draft Ordinance Amending Chapter 17.32
D. Resolution No. 26-11 recommending City Council adoption of a Resolution Establishing an Inclusionary Housing In-Lieu Fee Schedule
E. In-Lieu Fee Study, May 2026
CHAPTER 17.32
AFFORDABLE HOUSING REQUIREMENTS
Sections:
17.32.010 Purpose.
17.32.020 General requirements for affordable housing.
17.32.030 Exemptions.
17.32.040 Incentives for on-site housing.
17.32.050 Affordable housing development requirements.
17.32.060 Alternative methods of compliance.
17.32.070 Affordable housing plan processing.
17.32.080 Eligibility.
17.32.090 Adjustments.
17.32.100 Severability.
17.32.010 PURPOSE.
This chapter establishes policies, incentives, design standards, and alternative methods of compliance for meeting the city's affordable housing needs. The purpose of this chapter is to promote achievement of the city's general plan housing element goals for affordable housing. The policies outlined in this chapter regulate the method of determining the minimum requirements. Further, this chapter identifies the administrative procedures related to affordable housing requests. (Ord. 2010-02 § 1 (part), 2010)
17.32.020 GENERAL REQUIREMENTS FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
Consistent with the City of Pinole general plan housing element, the city requires the designation of land for affordable housing to meet the city's future housing needs. The requirements of this chapter shall be governed by the requirements of the Community Redevelopment Law (California Health & Safety Code Section 33000 et.seq.), as that statute is amended from time-to-time. Where conflict occurs between the requirements of this chapter and state law, state law shall govern.
General requirements are listed below:
A. General Requirement. For all rental or ownership residential developments of four (4) or more primary dwelling units located in the City, at least fifteen percent (15%) of the total units must be constructed and offered for sale or rent as an affordable housing unit. For projects proposing rental units, a minimum of forty percent (40%) of the fifteen percent (15%) of total units (i.e., at least six percent (6%) of total units excluding density bonus units) must be affordable to households at or below the very low income level. The remaining affordable rental units of the fifteen percent (15%) must be affordable to households at or below the low income level. For projects proposing ownership units, one hundred percent (100%) of the affordable units (i.e., fifteen percent (15%) of total units) must be affordable to households at or below the moderate income level. For example, a proposed rental residential development for twenty (20) single-family homes must provide three (3) affordable housing units, two (2) of which are affordable to very low income households and one (1) of which is affordable to low income households. Existing units that are to be retained shall be included in the number of units in the residential development for purpose of calculating the number of affordable housing units required by this chapter.
B. Residential Parcel Maps and Subdivisions. For all residential subdivisions except for SB 9 lot split projects under Chapter 17.71 (SB 9 Urban Lot Split and Unit Development) where the lots to be approved would permit the eventual development of four (4) or more dwelling units, the applicant shall either agree to future development of affordable units under an affordable housing plan, or shall propose an alternative method of compliance to meet the affordable housing requirements pursuant to the requirements as established in Section 17.32.060 (Alternative Methods of Compliance).
C. Density Bonus Units. Any additional units approved as a density bonus under Chapter 17.38 (Density Bonus) will not be counted in determining the required number of affordable housing units. For example, a proposed project with twenty (20) units that receives a twenty-five percent (25%) density bonus of five (5) units will calculate the affordable housing requirements based on twenty (20) units and must provide three (3) affordable housing units, two (2) of which are affordable to very low income households.
D. Rounding. In determining the number of affordable housing units required by this chapter, any decimal fraction shall be rounded up to the nearest whole number.
E. Moderate income, low-income. and very-low income shall have the meanings set forth in California Health and Safety Code Section 50050 et seq. A unit shall be "affordable" if it is rented at an "affordable rent" or sold at an "affordable housing
ATTACHMENT A
cost" as defined in California Health and Safety Code Section 50050 et seq.
F. Price Limits for Affordable Housing Units. Affordable housing units must be restricted for sale or rental at affordable prices as identified in Table 17.32.020-1 below:
TABLE 17.32.020-1
PRICE LIMITS FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING UNITS
Affordability
Proportion
Affordability Level to Determine
Housing Costs
Income Used to
Determine
Affordable Housing
Costs (%)
Rental Developments
Very Low Income Units
40% of
affordable
units1
Very low income level based on
state income limits (approximately
50% of area median income)
30%
Low Income Units
60% of
affordable
units1
Low income level based on state
income limits (approximately 80%
of area median income)
30%
Ownership Developments
Moderate Income Units
100% of
affordable
units1
Moderate income level based on
state income limits (approximately
120% or area median income)
30%
1 Affordable units are at least 15% of total units, excluding density bonus units, as described in Section17.32.020(A). (Ord. 2025-01 § 2 (part), 2025; Ord. 2010-02 § 1 (part), 2010)
17.32.030 EXEMPTIONS.
The requirements of this chapter shall not apply to the following types of development projects:
A. Manufactured Homes.
B. Pending Complete Applications. A project which has submitted an application for approval, which application was deemed complete by the Community Development Director prior to the effective date of this title.
C. Casualty Reconstruction Projects. The reconstruction of any residential units or structures which have been destroyed by fire, flood, earthquake, or other act of nature, which are being reconstructed in a manner consistent with the requirements of Chapter 17.14 (Nonconforming Uses and Structures). (Ord. 2010-02 § 1 (part), 2010)
17.32.040 INCENTIVES FOR ON-SITE HOUSING.
A. In the Affordable Housing Plan that is prepared and approved in accordance with Section17.32.070 (Affordable Housing Plan Processing), the applicant shall identify the incentives or modifications requested and describe the exceptional circumstances that necessitate assistance from the city, as well as provide documentation of how such incentives increase the feasibility of providing affordable housing. Incentives will be offered only to the extent resources for this purpose are available and approved for such use by the City Council, as defined below, and to the extent that the project, with the use of incentives, assists in achieving the city's housing goals. Nothing in this chapter establishes, directly or through implication, a right of an applicant to receive any incentive from the city.
B. The following incentives may be approved for applicants who construct affordable housing units on-site:
1. Density Bonus. Consistent with California Government Code Sections 65915 through 65918, qualifying projects can receive a density bonus by right. Density bonus requirements are outlined in Chapter 17.38 (Density Bonus) of this code.
2. Fee Subsidy or Deferral. The City Council, by resolution, may subsidize or defer payment of city development impact fees and/or building permit fees applicable to the affordable housing units or the project of which they are a part. The affordability control covenant shall include the terms of the fee subsidy or deferral.
3. Design Modifications. The granting of design modifications relative to affordable housing requirements shall be the approving authority of the project. Projects qualifying for a density bonus shall be consistent with the applicable provisions under Chapter 17.38 Density Bonus and Government Code Sections 65915 through 65918, and may include, but are not limited to, the following:
a. Reduced minimum setbacks;
b. Reduced minimum building separation requirements;
c. Reduced square footage requirements;
d. Reduced parking requirements;
e. Reduced minimum lot sizes and/or dimensions;
f. Reduced street standards (e.g., reduced minimum street widths); g. Reduced on-site open space requirements;
h. Increased height limitations;
i. Increased maximum lot coverage;
j. Increased floor area ratio;
k. Allowance for live-work units within multi-family residential zoning districts; l. In lieu of reduced setbacks, allowance for attached dwelling units, if shown to be necessary to make the project feasible; or
m. Other regulatory incentives or concessions proposed by the developer or the city that result in identifiable, financially sufficient, and actual cost reductions.
n. Priority Processing. After receiving the required discretionary approvals, the residential development that provides affordable housing units may be entitled to priority processing of building and engineering approvals, subject to the approval of the City Manager.
4. Park Fee Waivers for Additional Affordable Units. Additional deed-restricted affordable units beyond the minimum fifteen percent (15%) inclusionary unit requirement, as described under Section 17.32.020, are eligible for waiver of park impact fees.
(Ord. 2025-01 § 2 (part), 2025; Ord. 2010-02 § 1 (part), 2010)
17.32.050 AFFORDABLE HOUSING DEVELOPMENT REQUIREMENTS.
Affordable housing units constructed pursuant to this chapter must conform to the following requirements:
A. Affordable units shall have the same exterior appearance and quality of construction as the market-rate units.
Appliances and finishes in the affordable units shall be the same as in the market rate units with the same number of bedrooms.
B. Size. The size of affordable units shall be the same size as the market rate units in the development. For the purposes of this section, ''same size" shall mean that the affordable units shall satisfy all of the following requirements:
1. The number of bedrooms in an affordable units shall be the same as the number of bedrooms in the market rate units. If the market rate units have varied numbers of bedrooms, the distribution of the number of bedrooms in the affordable units shall be the same percentages as in the market rate units.
2. The square footage of an affordable unit shall be no less than ninety percent (90%) of the median square footage of the market rate units with the same number of bedrooms. The square footage of the bedrooms in an affordable unit shall be no less than ninety percent (90%) of the median square footage of the bedrooms in the market rate units.
3. If the affordable unit is alienable separate from the title to any other dwelling unit, the parcel on which the affordable unit is located shall be no less than ninety percent (90%) of the median square footage of the parcels on which market rate units with the same number of bedrooms are located.
C. Distribution. In a mixed-income development, affordable units shall be dispersed throughout the development Without limiting the foregoing, in no event shall an affordable unit be adjacent to more than one other affordable unit (unless the adjacent affordable unit is located on a different floor in a multi-floor building). Residents of affordable units shall be entitled to use all of the same amenities and facilities of the residential development as residents of market rate units within the residential development.
D. Availability. All affordable housing units shall be constructed concurrently with and be made available for qualified occupants at the same time as, or prior to, the market-rate units within the same project unless the city and developer agree in the Affordable Housing Agreement to an alternative schedule for development.
E. Affordable Housing Agreement. An Affordable Housing Agreement shall be made a condition of the discretionary planning entitlements for all qualifying projects granted a density bonus, fee subsidy, fee deferral, or design modifications.
The Affordable Housing Agreement shall include an affordable housing plan and shall be reviewed and approved by the City Manager.
F. Duration of Affordability Requirement. Affordable housing units produced under this chapter must be legally restricted to occupancy by households of the income levels for which the units were designated pursuant to and in conformance with the requirements of this title, any other applicable city regulation, and state law.
(Ord. 2025-01 § 2 (part), 2025; Ord. 2010-02 § 1 (part), 2010)
17.32.060 ALTERNATIVE METHODS OF COMPLIANCE.
A. Applicant Proposals. If it is not practical to construct on-site affordable housing units, the city will consider alternatives of equal value. Accordingly, the applicant may propose an alternative means of compliance with this chapter by submitting to the city an affordable housing plan. One (1) alternative the applicant may consider is the construction of affordable housing units, subject to the requirements listed below:
1. Off-site construction. All or some of the required affordable housing units may be constructed off-site if the Planning Commission (or City Council on appeal) finds that the combination of location, unit size, unit type, pricing, and timing of availability of the proposed off-site affordable housing units would provide equivalent or greater benefit than would result from providing those affordable housing units on-site as might otherwise be required by this chapter. Prior to the recordation of the final subdivision map for the proposed residential development, the applicant shall post a bond, bank letter of credit, or other security acceptable to the Community Development Director, in the amount equivalent to the cost of land and improvements for the affordable housing units, as determined by the Community Development Director, to be used by the city to meet the goals of providing affordable housing in the city in the event that the off-site affordable housing units are not completed (as evidenced by the issuance of a certificate of occupancy for such units) according to the schedule stated in the affordable housing plan submitted by the applicant.
B. Discretion and Required Finding. The approving authority for the project may approve, conditionally approve, or reject any alternative proposed by an applicant as part of an affordable housing plan. Any approval or conditional approval must be based on a finding that the purpose of this chapter would be better served by implementation of the proposed alternative, in which the approving authority for the project should consider the extent to which other factors affect the feasibility of prompt construction of the affordable housing units, such as site design, zoning, infrastructure, clear title, grading, and environmental review.
(Ord. 2025-01 § 2 (part), 2025; Ord. 2010-02 § 1 (part), 2010)
17.32.070 AFFORDABLE HOUSING PLAN PROCESSING.
A. General. The submittal of an affordable housing plan and recordation of an approved city affordable control covenant shall be a precondition on the city approval of any Final Subdivision Map, and no building permit shall be issued for any development to which this chapter applies without full compliance with the requirement of this section. This section shall not apply to exempt projects.
B. Affordable Housing Plan. Every residential development to which this chapter applies shall include an affordable housing plan as part of the application submittal for either development plan approval or subdivision approval. No application for a tentative map, subdivision map, or building permit for a development to which this chapter applies may be deemed completed until an affordable housing plan is submitted to and approved by the Community Development Director as being complete. At any time during the formal development review process, the Community Development Director may require from the applicant additional information reasonably necessary to clarify and supplement the application or determine the consistency of the project's proposed affordable housing plan with the requirements of this chapter.
C. Required Plan Elements. An affordable housing plan must include the following elements or submittal requirements:
1. The number, location, structure (attached, semi-attached, or detached), and size (bedrooms, bathrooms, and square footage) of the proposed market-rate and affordable housing units and the basis for calculating the number of affordable housing units.
2. A floor or site plan depicting the location of the affordable housing units and the market-rate units.
3. The income levels to which each affordable housing unit will be made affordable.
4. The term of affordability for the affordable housing units.
5. The methods to be used to advertise the availability of the affordable housing units and the procedures for qualifying and selecting the eligible purchasers and/or tenants, including preference to be given, if any, to applicants who live or work in the city.
6. A schedule for completion and occupancy of the affordable housing units. For phased development, a phasing plan that provides for the timely development of the number of affordable housing units proportionate to each proposed phase of development.
7. A description of any incentives or modifications as listed in Section17.32.040 (Incentives for On-Site Housing) including a description of exceptional circumstances that necessitate assistance from the city, as well as documentation of how such incentives increase the feasibility of providing affordable housing.
8. Any alternative means, as designated in Section17.32.060.A, proposed for the development along with information necessary to support the findings required by Section 17.32.060.B for approval of such alternatives.
9. Except when prohibited by state or federal law, the plan shall require that preference shall be given to households that live or work in Pinole when selling or leasing affordable units within a development.
10. Any other information reasonably requested by the Community Development Director to assist with evaluation of the affordable housing plan under the requirements of this chapter.
D. Affordability Control Covenants. Prior to issuance of a grading permit or building permit, whichever is requested first, a standard City affordability control covenant must be approved and executed by the Community Development Director, executed by the applicant/owners, and recorded against the title of each affordable housing unit. If subdivision into individual property parcels has not been finalized at the time of issuance of a grading permit or building permit, an overall interim affordability control covenant shall be recorded against the residential development and shall be replaced by separate recorded affordability control covenants for each unit prior to issuance of a certificate of occupancy by the city for such units.
The affordability control covenants must identify any incentives, modifications, or terms of any fee waiver, as permitted pursuant to Chapter 17.38 (Density Bonus), approved by the city. (Ord. 2025-01 § 2 (part), 2025; Ord. 2010-02 § 1 (part), 2010)
17.32.080 ELIGIBILITY.
A. General Eligibility for Affordable Housing Units. No household may purchase, rent, or occupy an affordable housing unit unless the city has approved the household's eligibility, and the household and city have executed and recorded an affordability control covenant in the chain of title of the affordable housing unit. Such affordability control covenant is in addition to the covenant required in Section 17.32.070.D.
B. Owner Occupancy. A household which purchases an affordable housing unit must occupy that unit as a principal residence, as that term is defined for federal tax purposes by the United States Internal Revenue Code. (Ord. 2010-02 § 1 (part), 2010)
17.32.090 ADJUSTMENTS.
A. Adjustments. The requirements of this chapter may be adjusted to propose an alternative method of compliance with the chapter in accordance with Section 17.32.060 (Alternative Methods of Compliance) by the city if the applicant demonstrates to the approving authority of the project that applying the requirement of this chapter would be contrary to the requirements of the laws or the constitutions of the United States or California.
B. Timing of Waiver Request. To receive an adjustment or waiver, the applicant must make an initial request of the approving authority of the project for such an adjustment or waiver and provide an appropriate demonstration of the appropriateness of the adjustment or waiver required for the proposed development plan or subdivision.
C. Waiver and Adjustment Considerations. In making a determination on an application to adjust or waive the requirements of this chapter, the approving authority of the project may assume each of the following when applicable:
1. That the applicant is subject to the affordable housing requirements ofChapter 17.32 (Affordable Housing Requirements);
2. The extent to which the applicant will benefit from affordable housing incentives under Section17.32.040 (Incentives for On-Site Housing); and
3. That the applicant will be obligated to provide the most economical affordable housing units feasible in terms of construction, design, location, and tenure, and subject to the requirements of Chapter 17.32 (Affordable Housing Requirements). (Ord. 2025-01 § 2 (part), 2025; Ord. 2010-02 § 1 (part), 2010)
17.32.100 SEVERABILITY.
If any provision of this section or its application to any property is held to be invalid by any court of competent jurisdiction, invalidity shall not affect other provisions in this section that may be implemented without the invalid sections. To this end, the provisions and clauses of this section are declared severable. (Ord. 2010-02 § 1 (part), 2010)
1 PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION 26-10
WITH EXHIBIT A: ORDINANCE
RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF PINOLE PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDING THAT THE CITY COUNCIL ADOPT AN ORDINANCE AMENDING CHAPTER 17.32 “AFFORDABLE HOUSING REQUIREMENTS” OF THE PINOLE MUNICIPAL CODE.
WHEREAS, Chapter 17.32 “Affordable Housing Requirements” of the Pinole Municipal Code (the “Municipal Code”) establishes policies, incentives, design standards, and alternative methods of compliance for meeting the City's affordable housing needs. The purpose of the chapter is to promote achievement of the City's General Plan Housing Element goals for affordable housing. The policies outlined in the chapter regulate the method of determining the minimum requirements. Further, the chapter identifies the administrative procedures related to affordable housing requests; and WHEREAS, Chapter 17.32.020 “General Requirements for Affordable Housing” requires for all rental or ownership residential developments of four (4) or more dwelling units located in the City, at least fifteen percent (15%) of the total units must be constructed and offered for sale or rent as an affordable housing unit. For projects proposing rental units , a minimum of forty percent (40%) of the affordable units must be affordable to very low-income households and the remaining affordable units must be affordable to low-income households (the “Affordable Housing Units”). For projects proposing ownership units, one hundred percent (100%) of the affordable units (i.e., fifteen percent (15%) of total units) must be affordable to households at or below the moderate income level (the “Affordable Housing Units”); and
WHEREAS, Chapter 17.32.030 “Exemptions” exempts manufactured homes, pending complete applications, and casualty reconstruction projects from the inclusionary housing requirement; and WHEREAS, the City desires to amend the inclusionary housing requirement to apply to all rental or ownership residential developments, regardless of number of dwelling units; and WHEREAS, Chapter 17.32.060 “Alternative Methods of Compliance” establishes alternatives if it is not practical to construct on-site affordable housing units. The applicant may propose an alternative means of compliance of equal value by submitting an affordable housing plan to the City. One such alternative is off-site construction; and
WHEREAS, the City desires to establish another alternative method of compliance by permitting the payment of an affordable housing in-lieu fee in an amount that shall be calculated using the fee schedule established by resolution of the City Council. The fee shall be deposited into an Inclusionary Housing Fund for use in producing, protecting, and preserving affordable housing, including site acquisition, development, rehabilitation, or preservation of affordable housing; and
ATTACHMENT B
2 WHEREAS, the City desires to allow the payment of an in-lieu fee as an alternative to constructing on-site affordable housing units to satisfy inclusionary housing requirements for 10 or fewer residential dwelling units; and
WHEREAS, the City desires to allow the payment of an in-lieu fee as an alternative to constructing on-site affordable housing units to satisfy inclusionary housing requirements for the 11th or greater residential dwelling units only if the applicant provides compelling evidence proving that on-site unit production is financially infeasible, subject to approval by the Planning Commission (or City Council on appeal); and
WHEREAS, the City desires to require applicants who opt to pay the in-lieu fee for development for 11 or more units to present a public impact statement explaining why they chose to pay the fee over providing affordable units on-site; and
WHEREAS, proposed modifications to Chapter 17.32, as set forth in Exhibit A, require review and approval of amendments to Title 17 of the Pinole Municipal Code (Zoning Code); and WHEREAS, Planning Commission serves as the review body recommending Zoning Code amendments to the City Council for approval consideration; and WHEREAS, this resolution was reviewed and considered by the Planning Commission in accordance with the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act (“CEQA”), as amended, and the CEQA Guidelines promulgated thereunder. This resolution has been determined to be exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to Section 15378(b)(4) of the CEQA Guidelines, since it includes the amendment to government funding mechanisms and fiscal activities that do not involve any commitment to a specific project that may result in a potentially significant physical impact on the environment. Moreover, additional CEQA review would be required on a case-by-case basis prior to issuance of any approvals to construct units with the funds generated by the in-lieu fees; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission held a duly-noticed public hearing related to the proposed zoning code amendments on November 9, 2026; and WHEREAS, after the close of the public hearing, the Planning Commission considered all public comments received both before and during the public hearing, the presentation by city staff, the staff report, and all other pertinent documents regarding the proposed zoning code text amendments; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission has determined that the proposed zoning code text amendments would be consistent with the general plan goals, policies, and implementation programs.
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the above recitals are true and correct and made part of this Resolution.
3 BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Planning Commission of the City of Pinole hereby recommends that the City Council adopt an ordinance amending Chapter 17.32 “Affordable Housing Requirements” of the Pinole Municipal Code, as set forth in Exhibit A, attached hereto and incorporated herein.
PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Planning Commission of the City of Pinole on this 9th day of November, 2026, by the following vote:
AYES:
NOES:
ABSTAIN:
ABSENT:
_____________________________
Gabriel Sandoval, Chair, 2026-2027
ATTEST:
_____________________________
Lilly Whalen, Community Development Director
1 ORDINANCE NO. __-__
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING CHAPTER 17.32 “AFFORDABLE
HOUSING REQUIREMENTS” OF THE PINOLE MUNICIPAL CODE
WHEREAS, Chapter 17.32 “Affordable Housing Requirements” of the Pinole Municipal Code establishes policies, incentives, design standards, and alternative methods of compliance for meeting the city's affordable housing needs. The purpose of the chapter is to promote achievement of the city's general plan housing element goals for affordable housing. The policies outlined in the chapter regulate the method of determining the minimum requirements. Further, the chapter identifies the administrative procedures related to affordable housing requests; and WHEREAS, Chapter 17.32.020 “General Requirements for Affordable Housing” requires for all rental or ownership residential developments of four (4) or more dwelling units located in the City, at least fifteen percent (15%) of the total units must be constructed and offered for sale or rent as an affordable housing unit. For projects proposing rental units , a minimum of forty percent (40%) of the affordable units must be affordable to very low-income households and the remaining affordable units must be affordable to low-income households (the “Affordable Housing Units”). For projects proposing ownership units, one hundred percent (100%) of the affordable units (i.e., fifteen percent (15%) of total units) must be affordable to households at or below the moderate income level (the “Affordable Housing Units”); and WHEREAS, Chapter 17.32.030 “Exemptions” exempts manufactured homes, pending complete applications, and casualty reconstruction projects from the inclusionary housing requirement; and
WHEREAS, the City desires to amend the inclusionary housing requirement to apply to all rental or ownership residential developments, regardless of number of dwelling units; and WHEREAS, Chapter 17.32.060 “Alternative Methods of Compliance” establishes alternatives if it is not practical to construct on-site affordable housing units. The applicant may propose an alternative means of compliance of equal value by submitting an affordable housing plan to the City. One such alternative is off-site construction; and WHEREAS, the City desires to establish another alternative method of compliance by permitting the payment of an affordable housing in-lieu fee in an amount that shall be calculated using the fee schedule established by resolution of the City Council. The fee shall be deposited into an Inclusionary Housing Fund for use in producing, protecting, and preserving affordable housing, including site acquisition, development, rehabilitation, or preservation of affordable housing; and
WHEREAS, the City desires to allow the payment of an in-lieu fee as an alternative to constructing on-site affordable housing units to satisfy inclusionary housing requirements for 10 or less residential dwelling units; and
ATTACHMENT C
ORDINANCE NO. ________
2 WHEREAS, the City desires to allow the payment of an in-lieu fee as an alternative to constructing on-site affordable housing units to satisfy inclusionary housing requirements for the 11th or greater residential dwelling units only if the applicant provides compelling evidence proving that on-site unit production is financially infeasible, subject to approval by the Planning Commission (or City Council on appeal); and
WHEREAS, the City desires to require applicants who opt to pay the in-lieu fee for development for 11 or more units to present a public impact statement explaining why they chose to pay the fee over providing affordable units on-site.
NOW THEREFORE, the City Council of the City of Pinole does ordain as follows:
SECTION 1. Findings
The City Council finds that the foregoing recitals are true and correct and are incorporated into the Ordinance by reference.
SECTION 2. Amending Chapter 17.32.020 “General Requirements for Affordable Housing” of the Pinole Municipal Code”
The City Council hereby amends Chapter 17.32.020 “General Requirements for Affordable Housing” of the Pinole Municipal Code to read as follows:
Consistent with the City of Pinole General Plan Housing Element, the City requires the designation of land for affordable housing to meet the City's future housing needs. The requirements of this chapter shall be governed by the requirements of the Community Redevelopment Law (California Health & Safety Code Section 33000 et.seq.), as that statute is amended from time-to-time. Where conflict occurs between the requirements of this chapter and state law, state law shall govern.
General requirements are listed below:
A. General Requirement. For all rental or ownership residential developments of four (4) or more primary dwelling units located in the City, at least fifteen percent (15%) of the total units must be constructed and offered for sale or rent as an affordable housing unit. For projects proposing rental units, a minimum of forty percent (40%) of the fifteen percent (15%) of total units (i.e., at least six percent (6%) of total units excluding density bonus units) must be affordable to households at or below the very low income level. The remaining affordable rental units of the fifteen percent (15%) must be affordable to households at or below the low income level. For projects proposing ownership units, one hundred percent (100%) of the affordable units (i.e., fifteen percent (15%) of total units) must be affordable to households at or below the moderate income level. For example, a proposed rental residential development for twenty (20) single-family homes must provide three (3) affordable housing units, two (2) of which are affordable to very low income households and one (1) of which is affordable to low income households. Existing units that are to be retained shall be included in the number of units in the residential development for purpose of calculating the number of affordable housing units required
ORDINANCE NO. ________
3 by this chapter.
B. Residential Parcel Maps and Subdivisions. For all residential subdivisions except for SB 9 lot split projects under Chapter 17.71 (SB 9 Urban Lot Split and Unit Development) where the lots to be approved would permit the eventual development of four (4) or more residential dwelling units, the applicant shall either agree to future development of affordable units under an affordable housing plan, or shall propose an alternative method of compliance to meet the affordable housing requirements pursuant to the requirements as established in Section 17.32.060 (Alternative Methods of Compliance).
C. Density Bonus Units. Any additional units approved as a density bonus under Chapter
17.38 (Density Bonus) will not be counted in determining the required number of affordable housing units. For example, a proposed project with twenty (20) units that receives a twenty-five percent (25%) density bonus of five (5) units will calculate the affordable housing requirements based on twenty (20) units and must provide three (3) affordable housing units, two (2) of which are affordable to very low income households.
D. Rounding. In determining the number of affordable housing units required by this chapter, any decimal fraction shall be rounded up to the nearest whole number.
E. Moderate income, low-income. and very-low income shall have the meanings set forth in California Health and Safety Code Section 50050 et seq. A unit shall be "affordable" if it is rented at an "affordable rent" or sold at an "affordable housing cost" as defined in California Health and Safety Code Section 50050 et seq.
F. Price Limits for Affordable Housing Units. Affordable housing units must be restricted for sale or rental at affordable prices as identified in Table 17.32.020-1 below:
TABLE 17.32.020-1
PRICE LIMITS FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING UNITS
Affordability
Proportion
Affordability Level to
Determine Housing
Costs
Income Used to
Determine
Affordable Housing
Costs (%)
Rental Developments
Very Low Income
Units
40% of affordable
units1
Very low income
level based on state
income limits
(approximately 50%
of area median
income)
30%
Low Income Units 60% of affordable
units1
Low income level
based on state income
limits (approximately
30%
ORDINANCE NO. ________
4 80% of area median
income)
Ownership Developments
Moderate Income
Units
100% of affordable
units1
Moderate income
level based on state
income limits
(approximately 120%
or area median
income)
30%
1 Affordable units are at least 15% of total units, excluding density bonus units, as described in Section 17.32.020(A).
SECTION 3. Amending Chapter 17.32.060 “Alternative Methods of Compliance” A. Applicant Proposals. If it is not practical to construct on-site affordable housing units, the city will consider alternatives of equal value. Accordingly, the applicant may propose an alternative means of compliance with this chapter by submitting to the city an affordable housing plan.
B. One (1) Alternatives the applicant may consider is the construction of affordable housing units, subject to the requirements are listed below:
1. Off-site construction. All or some of the required affordable housing units may be constructed off-site if the Planning Commission (or City Council on appeal) finds that the combination of location, unit size, unit type, pricing, and timing of availability of the proposed off-site affordable housing units would provide equivalent or greater benefit than would result from providing those affordable housing units on-site as might otherwise be required by this chapter. Prior to the recordation of the final subdivision map for the proposed residential development, the applicant shall post a bond, bank letter of credit, or other security acceptable to the Community Development Director, in the amount equivalent to the cost of land and improvements for the affordable housing units, as determined by the Community Development Director, to be used by the city to meet the goals of providing affordable housing in the city in the event that the off-site affordable housing units are not completed (as evidenced by the issuance of a certificate of occupancy for such units) according to the schedule stated in the affordable housing plan submitted by the applicant.
2. Payment of an in-lieu fee for 10 residential dwelling units or less. All or some of the required affordable housing units may be satisfied with the payment of an affordable housing in-lieu fee as described in Chapter 17.32.061 of the Pinole Municipal Code.
a. If paying the in-lieu fee, the applicant must submit a written public impact
ORDINANCE NO. ________
5 statement explaining why they opt to pay the in-lieu fee rather than providing affordable units on-site
3. Payment of an in-lieu fee for 11 or more residential dwelling units. All or some of the required affordable housing units may be satisfied with the payment of an affordable housing in-lieu fee as described in Chapter 17.32.061 of the Pinole Municipal Code for the 11th or greater residential dwelling units only if found to be financially infeasible pursuant to this section.
a. The applicant shall bear the burden of presenting substantial evidence to support a finding of infeasibility. Any request under this section shall be submitted to the Community Development Director together with an economic analysis or other supporting documentation requested by the Community Development Director, and shall be acted upon by the Planning Commission (or City Council on appeal). The applicant shall reimburse the City for staff and consultant costs incurred to evaluate any claim of financial infeasibility. b. If paying the in-lieu fee, the applicant must submit a written public impact statement explaining why they opt to pay the in-lieu fee rather than providing affordable units on-site
C. Discretion and Required Finding. The approving authority for the project may approve, conditionally approve, or reject any alternative proposed by an applicant as part of an affordable housing plan. Any approval or conditional approval must be based on a finding that the purpose of this chapter would be better served by implementation of the proposed alternative, in which the approving authority for the project should consider the extent to which other factors affect the feasibility of prompt construction of the affordable housing units, such as site design, zoning, infrastructure, clear title, grading, and environmental review.
SECTION 4. Adding Chapter 17.32.061 “Affordable Housing In-Lieu Fees” to the Pinole Municipal Code
The City Council hereby adds Chapter 17.32.061 “Affordable Housing In-Lieu Fees” to the Pinole Municipal Code to read as follows:
Section 17.32.061 AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN-LIEU FEES
A. Developing all of the required Affordable Housing Units within the development, as required under Section 17.32.020, is preferred. However, as an alternative to those requirements, the requirement may be satisfied as follows:
1. The applicant may propose to satisfy the on-site Affordable Housing Unit requirements of Section 17.32.020 through payment of an affordable housing in-lieu fee subject to the requirements of Section 17.32.060. The in-lieu fee amount that shall be calculated using the fee schedule established by resolution of the City
ORDINANCE NO. ________
6 Council, as may be amended by resolution at least once during each Housing Element cycle.
2. In accordance with this paragraph, the applicant may propose to satisfy the Affordable Housing Unit requirements of Section 17.32.020 by providing some of the required Affordable Housing Units on-site and paying an in-lieu fee for any required Affordable Housing Units that are not included in the project. The amount of the in-lieu fee shall be calculated by using the fee schedule established by resolution of the City Council.
3. The full in-lieu fee shall be paid to the City prior to the issuance of the first building permit for the development project.
4. Except as otherwise provided in this Chapter 17.32, all affordable housing in-lieu fees paid under this Chapter shall be paid to the City and deposited into the Inclusionary Housing Fund maintained by the City for use in producing, protecting, and preserving affordable housing, including site acquisition, development, rehabilitation, or preservation of affordable housing, homelessness prevention programs, first time homebuyer programs, or other affordable housing programs, and for affordable housing program administration, either directly by the City or in partnership with other government agencies or third-party affordable housing developers.
SECTION 5. Severability
If any section, subsection, sentence, clause, or phrase of this Ordinance is for any reason held to be invalid or unconstitutional by a decision of any court of competent jurisdiction, such decision shall not affect the validity of the remaining portions of this Ordinance. The City Council hereby declares that it would have passed the Ordinance, and each and every section, subsection, sentence, clause, or phrase not declared invalid or unconstitutional without regard to whether any portion of this Ordinance would be subsequently declared invalid or unconstitutional.
SECTION 6. Publication and Effective Date
This Ordinance shall become effective thirty (30) days after its adoption. The City Clerk shall have this Ordinance published in a newspaper of general circulation within fifteen (15) days after its adoption or have a summary of the Ordinance published twice in a newspaper of general circulation, once five days before its adoption and again fifteen days after its adoption.
The foregoing Ordinance was PASSED AND ADOPTED by the City Council of the City of Pinole, at a regular meeting of said Council on ________ by the following vote:
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
ABSTAIN:
ORDINANCE NO. ________
7 ATTEST:
_________________________________
Cameron Sasai, Mayor
ATTEST:
____________________________________
Heather Bell-Spears, City Clerk
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
____________________________________
Eric S. Casher, City Attorney
1 PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION 26-11
RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF PINOLE PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDING THAT THE CITY COUNCIL ADOPT A RESOLUTION ESTABLISHING THE CITY’S FEE SCHEDULE PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 17.32 (AFFORDABLE HOUSING) OF THE CITY OF PINOLE
MUNICIPAL CODE
WHEREAS, Chapter 17.32 “Affordable Housing Requirements” of the Pinole Municipal Code (the “Municipal Code”) establishes policies, incentives, design standards, and alternative methods of compliance for meeting the City's affordable housing needs. The purpose of the chapter is to promote achievement of the City's General Plan Housing Element goals for affordable housing. The policies outlined in the chapter regulate the method of determining the minimum requirements. Further, the chapter identifies the administrative procedures related to affordable housing requests; and WHEREAS, Chapter 17.32.020 “General Requirements for Affordable Housing” requires for all rental or ownership residential developments of four (4) or more dwelling units located in the City, at least fifteen percent (15%) of the total units must be constructed and offered for sale or rent as an affordable housing unit. For projects proposing rental units , a minimum of forty percent (40%) of the affordable units must be affordable to very low-income households and the remaining affordable units must be affordable to low-income households (the “Affordable Housing Units”). For projects proposing ownership units, one hundred percent (100%) of the affordable units (i.e., fifteen percent (15%) of total units) must be affordable to households at or below the moderate income level (the “Affordable Housing Units”); and
WHEREAS, on November 9, 2026, the Planning Commission held a public hearing to make a recommendation to the City Council regarding a draft Ordinance amending Chapter 17.32 “Affordable Housing Requirements” of the Municipal Code (the “draft Ordinance”); and WHEREAS, the draft Ordinance proposes amending the inclusionary housing requirement to apply to all rental or ownership residential developments, regardless of the number of dwelling units; and
WHEREAS, the draft Ordinance proposes amending Chapter 17.32.060 of the Municipal Code to provide that the City’s Affordable Housing Unit requirements may be satisfied for 10 units or less by payment of an affordable housing in-lieu fee as an alternative to building the Affordable Housing Units; and
WHEREAS, the draft Ordinance proposes amending Chapter 17.32.060 of the Municipal Code to provide that the City’s Affordable Housing Unit requirements may be satisfied for the 11th or greater residential dwelling units by payment of an affordable housing in-lieu fee as an alternative to building the Affordable Housing Units only if the applicant provides compelling evidence proving that on-site
ATTACHMENT D
2 unit production is financially infeasible, subject to approval by the Planning Commission (or City Council on appeal); and
WHEREAS, draft Ordinance proposes adding Chapter 17.32.061 of the Municipal Code to provide that the City’s Affordable Housing Unit requirements may be satisfied by payment of an affordable housing in-lieu fee subject to the requirements of Chapter 17.32.060 as an alternative to building the Affordable Housing Units; and
WHEREAS, Chapter 17.32.061 of the Municipal Code as proposed provides that the City Council shall establish a fee schedule to calculate the amount of the affordable housing in-lieu fee by resolution, which should be amended at least once during the Housing Element cycle; and WHEREAS, RSG, Inc., a consulting firm commissioned by the City, prepared a study dated May, 2026 entitled “Inclusionary Housing In-Lieu Fee Analysis” (“Fee Study”) addressing the gap between market rate sales prices and rents for housing units in the City and sales prices and rents affordable to Very Low-, Low-, and Moderate-income households. The Fee Study contained detailed analysis for the estimated development funding gap related to constructing the affordable units on site and a calculation of in-lieu fee estimates based on the development funding gap; and WHEREAS, Chapter 17.32.061 provides that all monies collected by the City in-lieu of constructing Affordable Housing Units on-site shall be deposited into a new Inclusionary Housing Fund maintained by the City for use in producing, protecting, and preserving affordable housing, including site acquisition, development, rehabilitation, or preservation of affordable housing, homelessness prevention programs, first time homebuyer programs, or other affordable housing programs, and for affordable housing program administration, either directly by the City or in partnership with other government agencies or third-party affordable housing developers; and WHEREAS, this resolution was reviewed and considered by the Planning Commission in accordance with the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act (“CEQA”), as amended, and the CEQA Guidelines promulgated thereunder. This resolution has been determined to be exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to Section 15378(b)(4) of the CEQA Guidelines, since it includes the amendment to government funding mechanisms and fiscal activities that do not involve any commitment to a specific project that may result in a potentially significant physical impact on the environment. Moreover, additional CEQA review would be required on a case-by-case basis prior to issuance of any approvals to construct units with the funds generated by the in-lieu fees.
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the above recitals are true and correct and made part of this Resolution.
3 BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Planning Commission of the City of Pinole hereby recommends that the City Council adopt a resolution containing the following findings and provisions:
1. Review and Approval of Nexus Study. The City Council shall review and approve the study prepared by RSG, Inc., and find that the analysis therein supports the inclusionary housing in-lieu fees established by the resolution.
2. Adoption of Inclusionary Housing In-Lieu Fee. The City Council shall adopt the inclusionary housing in-lieu fee amount set forth in the resolution. To satisfy the inclusionary housing requirements of Chapter 17.32.061 of the Pinole Municipal Code, the total amount of the in-lieu fee for a residential development project shall be calculated by multiplying the total square footage of all market-rate units in the development project by the applicable per-square-foot fee.
For residential development offered for sale, the in-lieu fee shall be $11.00 per square foot. For residential development offered as rental housing, the in-lieu fee shall be $9.00 per square foot.
3. Imposition of In-Lieu Fee. The City Council shall provide that the in-lieu fee established by the resolution is due and payable prior to issuance of a building permit for the residential development project.
4. Appeal of Fee Imposition. The City Council shall provide that any applicant subject to payment of the in-lieu fee may file an appeal in accordance with Section 17.10.070 of the Pinole Municipal Code, as such provisions may be amended from time to time.
5. Severability. The City Council shall provide that if any section, subsection, subdivision, paragraph, sentence, clause, phrase, or portion of the resolution is held invalid or unconstitutional by a court of competent jurisdiction, such decision shall not affect the validity of the remaining portions of the resolution. The City Council shall further declare that it would have adopted the resolution and each portion thereof irrespective of the invalidity of any individual provision.
6. Effective Date. The City Council shall provide that the fees established by the resolution shall become effective 30 days from adoption of the resolution. Any housing development project that has not been approved by the City on or before the effective date shall be subject to the fees established by the resolution.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Planning Commission finds the proposed in-lieu fees to be consistent with the City's housing goals and inclusionary housing requirements and recommends that the City Council adopt the proposed resolution establishing such fees.
PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Planning Commission of the City of Pinole on this 9th day of November, 2026, by the following vote:
4 AYES:
NOES:
ABSTAIN:
ABSENT:
_____________________________
Gabriel Sandoval, Chair, 2026-2027
ATTEST:
_____________________________
Lilly Whalen, Community Development Director
RSG, INC.
Inclusionary Housing
In-Lieu Fee Analysis
CITY OF PINOLE
May 22, 2026
ATTACHMENT E
[This page left intentionally blank.]
INCLUSIONARY HOUSING IN-LIEU FEE ANALYSIS
City of Pinole
i
TABLE OF CONTENTS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY..............................................................................................................................1 SECTION 1: BACKGROUND ......................................................................................................................4 SECTION 2: PINOLE HOUSING MARKET AND PRODUCT TYPES.........................................................8 SECTION 3: AFFORDABLE HOUSING COSTS.......................................................................................10 SECTION 4: POLICY DESIGN OPTIONS AND BEST PRACTICES........................................................15 SECTION 5: ANALYSIS OF INCLUSIONARY HOUSING IN-LIEU FEE FOR THE CITY OF PINOLE....20 SECTION 6: CONCLUSIONS AND POLICY CONSIDERATIONS ...........................................................25
1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
RSG, Inc. (“RSG”) prepared this Inclusionary Housing In-Lieu Fee Analysis (“Analysis”) for the City of Pinole (“City”) to support the implementation of Program 7 in the City’s 2023-2031 Housing Element (“Housing Element”). The Analysis reviews potential modifications to the City’s Inclusionary Housing Ordinance (“Ordinance”), which the City Council adopted in 2010 to promote achievement of the City’s General Plan Housing Element goals for affordable housing.
In broad terms, the existing Ordinance, which added Chapter 17.32 to the City’s Municipal Code, requires developers to restrict at least 15% of total housing units to be affordable to low income households in residential developments of four or more dwelling units. For rental housing, developers must restrict at least 40% of the affordable units to Very Low-income households, and the remainder must be affordable to Low-income households1. For ownership housing, developers must restrict 100% of the affordable units to Moderate-income households.
Developers can fulfill the requirements of the Ordinance by providing affordable units on- or off-site. The City does not currently offer any other options to satisfy to requirements.
The City’s 2023-2031 Housing Element Program 7 specifies a Quantified Objective to create an in-lieu fee alternative to on-site or off-site unit production. The City seeks to offer an in-lieu fee to provide flexibility to housing developers and to create a new funding source for affordable housing projects. The City would deposit in-lieu fees to the City’s Inclusionary Housing Fund. The fund would be utilized to produce affordable housing projects on an ongoing basis by offering grants or loans to developers who can leverage other regional, state, and federal funding sources to produce a greater number of affordable housing units.
To evaluate the feasibility of an in-lieu fee, RSG conducted a financial analysis of six different prototypical residential developments in Pinole. RSG considered the financial impact of inclusionary requirements under the Ordinance, as expressed by an in-lieu fee amount that is generally equivalent a developer’s cost of providing affordable units on-site.
Key considerations for the City are below:
• In-Lieu Fee: RSG’s analysis finds that fees of $11 per square foot for ownership housing, and $9 per square foot for rental housing, may be feasible based on an analysis of development costs and return on investment from providing market-rate and affordable housing. The City should reevaluate the in-lieu fee amounts on a periodic basis in response to changing market conditions to ensure they correlate to the actual projected cost of on-site affordable unit production and do not make development infeasible. • In-Lieu Fee Applicability: The City may consider allowing developments with 10 units or less to satisfy inclusionary housing requirements through the payment of an in-lieu fee. 1 The California Department of Housing and Community Development defines household income levels for affordable housing as “Very Low-”, “Low-”, and “Moderate-income” for households that earn less than 50%, 80%, or 120% of the area median income for the County, respectively.
2 The City may assess the fee based on the residential square footage of proposed new developments.
The City may consider allowing developments with more than 10 units to satisfy inclusionary housing requirements through a combination of on-site unit production and the in-lieu fee payment. The payment of an in-lieu fee may be utilized to fulfill the inclusionary requirement for the first ten units, or if the developer can demonstrate that on-site affordable unit production is infeasible by submitting an economic analysis to the Community Development Director and Planning Commission (or City Council on appeal) for approval.
• Public Impact Statement: The City may consider requiring developers who opt to pay the in-lieu fee to submit a written public impact statement explaining why they are not providing inclusionary units on-site.
• Ordinance and Resolution: The City may add payment of an in-lieu fee as an alternative method of compliance via Ordinance. The in-lieu fee itself may be set by resolution as it changes over time.
RSG completed this Analysis during the second quarter of 2025 and it is reflective of then-existing market conditions. At that time, interest rates varied within a range similar to what was observed since mid-2023. While market consensus expected interest rates to slowly decline into the future, there were continued supply chain impacts on building material costs due to uncertainty related to tariffs. RSG does not expect this volatility to subside in the next 12-24 months. RSG designed the recommendations in this Analysis for general Ordinance feasibility over the long-term.
However, because market conditions will fluctuate, RSG recommends revisiting the Ordinance and in-lieu fee amount on a periodic basis, such as every five years or with each Housing Element update.
3 Report Organization
This Report contains six sections, as follows:
• Section 1 – Background: This section includes a summary of the current Ordinance, Pinole’s housing needs, and the use of inclusionary housing programs to create affordable housing in California.
• Section 2 – Pinole Housing Market and Product Types: This section provides an overview of the residential market in and around Pinole, including prototypical types and sizes of housing units, rental rates and sale prices, development costs, and projected investment returns to developers.
• Section 3 – Affordable Housing Costs: This section examines the net cost to produce affordable housing units in the City. This is determined by the “affordable funding gap”, which is the difference between the development cost for different unit types and sizes and the amount which households of varying sizes and income levels can reasonably afford to purchase or rent.
• Section 4 – Program Design Options and Best Practices: This section answers common questions about inclusionary housing programs and describes the range of program design options.
• Section 5 – Analysis of Affordable Unit Production Options and In-Lieu Fee Levels: This section details the calculations involved in determining a feasible inclusionary housing production requirement, as well as appropriate in-lieu amounts. • Section 6 – Conclusion: This section summarizes RSG’s findings, alternative options, and recommendations for a revised Ordinance and in-lieu fee.
4 SECTION 1: BACKGROUND
City of Pinole Affordable Housing Requirements, Municipal Code Chapter 17.32 The City’s inclusionary housing Ordinance is encoded in Municipal Code Chapter 17.32. The Municipal Code establishes policies, incentives, design standards, and alternative methods of compliance for developers to meet the City’s affordable housing needs. The following summarizes the requirements of the existing Ordinance:
On-Site Affordable Unit Production
Requirement
15% of all units must be restricted as
affordable.
Affordability Mix Rental Housing: At least 40% of the
affordable units shall be designated for Very
Low-income households. The remainder
should be affordable to Low-income
households. For example, if a development
includes 20 units, 3 must be affordable, and
2 of the affordable units must be designated
for Very Low-income households.
Ownership Housing: 100% of the affordable
units shall be designated for Moderate-income households.
Affordability Term For-rent units must be restricted for 55 years.
For-sale units must be restricted for 45 years.
Development Subject to Ordinance All residential development of 4 dwelling units or more.
This includes residential development that is
rehabilitated to increase the number of
dwelling units, such as converting a property
from a two-unit duplex to a four-unit fourplex.
Exclusions Development projects with less than 4
residential dwelling units.
Alternatives Off-Site Construction: Off-site unit
production may include construction of all or
some of the required new affordable units at
a different site, as long as the location, unit
size, unit type, pricing and timing of
availability of the proposed off-site
affordable housing units would provide
5 equivalent or greater benefit as on-site
production.
Meeting Pinole’s Regional Housing Needs Allocation (“RHNA”) The City’s affordable housing needs are largely demonstrated by the RHNA allocation as determined by the California Department of Housing and Community Development ("HCD") and the Association of Bay Area Governments (“ABAG”). RHNA determines the total number of new homes that need to be built in a region to support housing demand by income category. The Housing Element identifies sites where new housing can be built to support the City’s RHNA targets.
HCD defines household income levels for affordable housing as “Acutely-Low“, Extremely Low-”, “Very Low-”, “Low-”, and “Moderate-income” for households that earn less than 15, 30, 50, 80, or 120% of the area median income (“AMI”) for Contra Costa County (“County”), respectively. A corresponding “affordable housing cost” limit is set based on these qualifying income limits, and generally may not exceed 30% of household income. For renters, housing cost includes rent plus utilities. For homeowners, housing cost includes mortgage principal and interest, plus taxes, insurance, and HOA fees, if applicable.
The City’s RHNA for the 6th Housing Element Cycle period of 2023 through 2031 reflects a target of 500 new residential housing units, of which 12% are for Extremely Low-income households, 12% are for Very Low-income households, 14% are for Low-Income households, 17% are for Moderate-Income households, and 45% are for Above Moderate-income households. Table 1 shows this breakdown both exclusive and inclusive of Above Moderate-income housing, which is not considered affordable housing.
Table 1: City's RHNA Allocation and Unit Production (2023-2031) Absent land use regulations, incentives, and subsidies, the real estate development market will seldom provide affordable housing on its own. Either market rate developers must be required to provide it, or affordable developers must be subsidized by local, regional, state, or federal programs, or a combination of all of the above. Because cities have limited means to incentivize or subsidize production of affordable housing, they are increasingly looking to multi-pronged and integrated strategies to encourage the production of housing at all income levels. The City’s
6 existing Ordinance causes the production of affordable units within a project or off-site to support a wider range of housing opportunities in the City.
Inclusionary Housing Programs in California
Cities and counties typically enact inclusionary housing programs by an ordinance that requires residential development applications, as a condition of approval, to set aside a portion of the units constructed in a project for purchase or rent by lower income households. Inclusionary policies attempt to capture some of the surplus value generated by new residential development to provide a community benefit, using local land use controls to ensure that much-needed affordable housing is produced along with market rate units. It is a flexible tool that can be tailored to local circumstances and market conditions. There is no one model policy, but rather several best practices to consider when updating an inclusionary program or setting an in-lieu fee. An inclusionary housing ordinance is only one part of an affordable housing strategy and should not be viewed as the sole means to address the need for affordable housing, which may still require public subsidies and other policies, programs, and tools.
Affordable housing units are typically restricted by covenants recorded on the property to ensure that the units remain affordable for a long duration, usually 55 years for rentals and 45 years for ownership housing. During the covenant term, it is not uncommon for units to be rehabilitated or refinanced and the covenants to be extended, often requiring additional public subsidies. In some cases, such as when a land trust or other public entity retains ownership of the land or units, the units can remain affordable in perpetuity.
Over 170 communities in California have enacted inclusionary housing ordinances or policies.
Pinole is one of 14 cities in the County that have adopted inclusionary housing policies. The County of Contra Costa also has its own inclusionary housing policy for unincorporated areas of the County.
Legal Authority for Establishing Inclusionary Requirements and Affordable Housing Fees In California, cities can regulate the use of buildings, structures, and land pursuant to Government Code Section 65850. This includes the type of land uses, building heights, parking requirements, and other improvements to property. In some cases, this can also include inclusionary housing requirements on residential and mixed-use projects.
Inclusionary housing policies have been in place throughout California since the 1970s. In 2009, cities temporarily lost their ability to apply inclusionary policies to rental housing when an appellate court determined that inclusionary housing requirements on new rental housing were in violation of the Costa Hawkins Act, a state law that limits local rent control implementation. In 2017, Assembly Bill (“AB”) 1505 (Bloom) reinstated cities’ ability to adopt and enforce inclusionary housing ordinances that apply to both for-rent and for-sale housing projects, thereby restoring a tool for cities to facilitate affordable housing development in their communities. Under Government Code Section 65850.01(a), HCD has the authority to review inclusionary housing ordinances adopted after September 2017 that require more than 15% of the units to be affordable. The purpose of this review is to ascertain whether a jurisdiction is impairing the
7 production of market rate housing by requiring an excessive number of inclusionary units and rendering new construction infeasible.
In 2015, the California Supreme Court ruled that inclusionary housing requirements are not an “exaction” that needs to be justified by the impact of a project, like traffic and other development impact fees. Inclusionary policies may be based on the existing and projected housing needs of the region and other factors related to the regional welfare and not based on a demonstrated additional need for housing generated by new residential development. This means that a “nexus study” is not required under Government Code Section 66000, commonly known as the Mitigation Fee Act.
Regardless of the threshold of inclusionary housing required, Government Code Section 65850(g) requires that inclusionary housing ordinances contain alternative means for compliance, which may include the payment of in-lieu fees, off-site unit production, land dedication, and preservation of existing units. Most ordinances provide several alternatives.
Inclusionary Housing Dashboard
The Governor approved Assembly Bill 2663 in September 2024. Beginning January 1, 2026, local agencies collecting inclusionary housing in-lieu fees are required by AB 2663 to post annual updates detailing the amount of in-lieu fees collected in the previous year and identifying how the agency will use the fees for a project, if any. AB 2663 is chaptered as Government Code Section 65906.6.
8 SECTION 2: PINOLE HOUSING MARKET AND PRODUCT TYPES
RSG reviewed historical development, the Pinole zoning code, Three Corridors Specific Plan, and the upcoming development pipeline to determine the most common residential development patterns in the City and surrounding market area. This includes a review of single-family residences, condo and townhomes, and multifamily rental apartments at several different densities. The analysis considers development with and without a mixed-use commercial component. Accordingly, the product types used in this analysis include single-family residential development, condo or townhome development, and multifamily rental apartment developments of varying sizes and densities. RSG believes that these product types provide an accurate cross section of the potential residential developments affected by the City’s existing Ordinance based on the data reviewed, discussions with City staff, and RSG’s knowledge of the residential market.
RSG analyzed new single-family residential homes and condo and townhomes built in the region between 2020 and 2024 to develop assumptions about for-sale residential product types within the City. RSG used ParcelQuest to obtain a database of all residential properties built in the region during this time. RSG included homes and condos built in Antioch, Bethel Island, Brentwood, Byron Bay, Discovery Bay, El Sobrante, Martinez, Oakley, Pittsburgh, Richmond, and San Pablo.
ParcelQuest utilizes County Assessor data to provide property information, including sales information, such as sale date and price, and property characteristics, such as lot size, building area, garage square footage, number of bedrooms and bathrooms, stories.
For multifamily rental residential, RSG used market analytics to develop assumptions. RSG relied on Costar market and submarket analytics reports, which summarize market rental rates by number of bedrooms, as well as the City’s current development pipeline. Pinole is located in Costar’s Richmond-Martinez multifamily submarket, which includes El Cerrito, Richmond, San Pablo, El Sobrante, Tara Hills, Pinole, Hercules, Rodeo, Tormey, Crockett, Martinez, and Vine Hill. Costar’s development data includes unit sizes, distribution of bedrooms, lease rates, parking types, amenities, and other information about multifamily properties.
RSG used the development program information to estimate residential development costs using CoreLogic’s Marshall Valuation Service, which is a comprehensive cost-estimating tool and methodology that is updated monthly and serves the appraisal, development, and insurance industries.
The six market rate residential prototypes that RSG identified are summarized in Table 2, including the typical development density, unit size, and development costs. The assumptions in Table 2 represent averages for prototypical development types seen in the Pinole market area.
9 Table 2: Summary of Development Prototypes
10 SECTION 3: AFFORDABLE HOUSING COSTS
RSG determined monthly rents and sale prices for affordable housing units in California in accordance with the California Health & Safety Code (“HSC”). RSG’s calculations for rental housing are made pursuant to HSC Section 50053(b), and calculations for owner-occupied housing are made pursuant to HSC Section 50052.5(b). Affordable housing costs are a function of the AMI, adjusted for family size appropriate to the unit, which is assumed to be one person in a studio unit, two persons in a one-bedroom unit, three persons in a two-bedroom unit, four persons in a three-bedroom unit, five persons in a four-bedroom unit, and so on.
The qualifying income limits for Extremely Low-, Very Low-, Low-, and Moderate-income households adjusted for household size are established annually by HCD for each California county in accordance with data provided by the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development (“HUD”). The County 2025 median income for a household of four is $159,800.
Table 3 shows the range of 2025 County AMI by household size and the qualifying income limits by category.
Table 3: Contra Costa County Income Limits
This Analysis incorporates the data in Table 3 to calculate affordable housing cost, rents, and prices based on the income category of the household, adjusted for family size.
Affordable Rents and Rental Unit Values
RSG calculated the maximum affordable rental costs per HSC Section 50053(b) to reflect the affordable housing cost by income category, adjusted for household size, net of a deduction for utility allowance. The calculation of annual affordable rental housing cost may not exceed the following:
• For Extremely Low-income households, the product of 30% times 30% of AMI adjusted for family size appropriate for the unit.
• For Very Low-income households, the product of 30% times 50% of the AMI adjusted for family size appropriate for the unit.
• For Low-income households, the product of 30% times 60% of the AMI adjusted for family size appropriate for the unit.
Income Category AMI 1 2 3 4 5
Extremely Low 30% $33,555 $38,355 $43,140 $47,940 $51,780 Very Low 50% 55,925 63,925 71,900 79,900 86,300
Low 60% 67,110 76,710 86,280 95,880 103,560
Median 100% 111,850 127,850 143,800 159,800 172,600
Moderate 110% 123,035 140,635 158,180 175,780 189,860
Sources: California Department of Housing and Community Development, RSG Income Limit by Household Size (Persons)
11 • For Moderate-income households, the product of 30% times 110% of the AMI, adjusted for family size appropriate for the unit.
The County 2025 maximum affordable monthly rents for each income category by unit size is summarized in Table 4. Note that the amounts shown in Table 4 are prior to deducting a utility allowance.
Table 4: Contra Costa County Affordable Rent Limits
The value of an affordable rental unit is a function of the net operating income (“NOI”) it provides the property owner. This is determined by calculating the annual gross income generated by the unit, reduced by a vacancy factor, operating expenses, reserves, and property taxes. Lenders’ underwriting standards generally incorporate a 5% vacancy factor. Comparable annual operating expenses (excluding real estate taxes) for affordable rental units are about $6,000 per unit per year plus $250 per unit for annual reserve fund deposits. RSG assumed that the real estate tax rate would be 1.25% of unit value. Although non-profit affordable housing developers construct most affordable apartments, which are exempt from property taxes, for the purpose of this Analysis we have included real estate taxes because the inclusionary units would be within a market rate development subject to real estate taxes. The NOI for the affordable unit represents the affordable rent by income category less vacancy, operating expenses, reserves, and real estate taxes.
To establish the value of affordable rental units, RSG followed industry practice of applying a “yield on cost” to the projected NOI per unit. For stabilized multifamily properties, prospective investors will use a capitalization rate, or “cap rate” to evaluate potential acquisitions.
Alternatively, for new developments, investors often rely on a yield on cost to evaluate potential project returns. Both rates are reflective of the relative risk of an asset based on asset type, location, age and condition of the property, and tenant quality. Cap rates and yield on cost are related in that cap rates are generally lower than yield on cost because stabilized assets with known gross rents, operating expenses, and vacancy rates are generally less risky than new development. Developers refer to the separation between market cap rates and yield on cost as the development yield – which is the spread associated with the additional risk of new development.
RSG referred to current market reports and Costar to determine market cap rates to understand current development yields and required yield on cost. In the second quarter of 2025, cap rates for multifamily housing in the market area ranged from 4.5 to 6.7%. Development yields were Income Category AMI 0 1 2 3 4
Extremely Low 30% $839 $959 $1,079 $1,199 $1,295
Very Low 50% 1,398 1,598 1,798 1,998 2,158
Low 60% 1,678 1,918 2,157 2,397 2,589
Moderate 110% 3,076 3,516 3,955 4,395 4,747
Rent Limit by Number of Bedrooms
Sources: California Department of Housing and Community Development, RSG