418 Kenoak Place
Appeal of MINCOA 18644-2022
Applicant: Gail Titus
City Council Meeting – September 19, 2022
Agenda Item
Attachment No 8
Executive Summary
• This request is an appeal of Minor Certificate of
Appropriateness (MAJCOA 18644-2022).
• June 29, 2022 - Staff denied MINOCA.
• August 3, 2022 - HPC denied the applicant’s appeal request. • August 23, 2022 - Applicant filed for an appeal.
• A denial of the appeal would uphold the Commission’s
decision.
Location
White Ave
Applicable Code Sections
• Historic Preservation Section .5809 -13.G – Appeal procedures for decisions made HPC.
• 1999 Historic Design Guidelines – Guidelines for Fence / Wall Alterations and Installations on Historic Properties
• 2021 Historic Design Guidelines – Guidelines for Craftsman Architecture
• Section .503-I Fences, Hedges and Walls of the Pomona Zoning Ordinance – Historic Properties
1999 Historic Guidelines
2021 Historic Guidelines
Pomona Zoning Code
Photos
Conflict with1991 Design Guidelines
Vinyl in Historic Districts
• Staff and Commission have consistently denied vinyl as an appropriate material in Historic Districts.
• Commission raised concerns with setting a precedence if this were to be approved.
• The Commission determined the vinyl fencing is not
historically appropriate and denied the appeal, upholding the denial by staff with a 4-2 vote.
• The Commission gave the applicant one year to replace the vinyl fence with a wood fence.
Recommendation
• The Historic Preservation Commission recommends that the City Council adopt Resolution 2022-166, denying Minor
Certificate of Appropriateness (MINCOA 18644 -2022) to
legalize an unpermitted six-foot high vinyl fence on a
property located at 418 Kenoak Place.